001this meeting of the Monro Township Board of Education is now call to order uh I'd like everyone to please rise and join us in the pledge and be uh led by our uh student board members I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all thank you Mr Gorski roll call please Mrs armenio here Mr Braverman here Mrs Deo here Mr calman here Mrs Co Pano here Mr noin here Mrs Keno here Mr Rybeck here Mr Russo here and Mr rutsky board president you have a quarum present this evening in accordance with the provisions of the New Jersey open public meetings law the Monroe Township Board of Education has caused notice of this meeting
002to be published by having the date time and place thereof posted December 9th 2016 at all schools the home News Tribune cranberry press and and filed with the clerk of the municipality thank you very much and now we have our student board members report okay so the first thing I also mentioned at the last meeting is about the high school marching band I mentioned that they were going to go to Hawaii for their trip to play at the Pearl Harbor anniversary and they just came back a few days ago and from everything I've heard it went really well and all the kids had a lot of fun while they were there uh also next week on Thursday after school the High School's Science National Honor Society is going to be holding an alumni uh stem
003panel event where they're going to have people who've graduated from the high school in the past couple years come back and kind of just talk about their experiences in college and where they're going and what uh they're doing in terms of the stem field right now thank you the fpla will be holding a family karaoke night this Friday in the high school and the drama Club Cabaret night will be on Monday December 19th in the high school Commons thank you very much uh moving right along we now have a presentation of the 20145 comprehensive annual financial report it's my pleasure to introduce Mr ger stankowitz of the firm of Samuel Klein and Company Jerry Thank you Mr President members of the board do he need a mic to the public um oh I'm sorry y
004as we do every year I'm here to present to the full board the uh comprehensive annual financial report for the year ended June 30th 2016 the financial report is the thicker of the two documents that you have with you or have been presented with and it contains financial information regarding the district uh but also inside of it is our audit opinion uh which take which is really what we are hired to do by the board as our position is answerable to the board um the annual audit is done on the financial records of the district it's done in accordance with the statutes uh it's an opportunity to annually measure the operation of the district and in addition to that to report to the board of any findings relative to any procedural deficiencies that were incurred
005by the board I'm Sorry by the business office uh and just to get to the the bottom line with it the the independent Auditor's opinion that's contained inside this document contains uh an unmodified opinion which means means that the records presented were presented properly and fairly present the financial condition of the district for the fiscal year ended the other document which is the thinner of the two is actually my representation to the board relative to the operation of the business office now just as a way of a quick review um the audit process and again an audit is a sample so we will upon receiving the records from the business office we will select samples of transactions that we like to test and we test them for various what we call attributes that there's certain
006things certain items that have to be in place and we test each one of those transactions for that we run a random s sample of let's say for example the expenditures for the period July 1st of uh 15 through June 30th of 16 based on the check register it's very simple based on the check register prepared by the district business office uh for all the payment of the bills that are incurred by the district we'll select samples from those records we'll test those records we do the same with the payroll we'll get the first payroll check of the year and the last payroll check of the year and we'll run a random sample in between that Auditors sample and we use random number generators to prepare and select which transactions we want to test and
007again we test the payroll items for various items that are supposed to be in place prior to the execution of that particular transaction I'll try I will try and review that real quickly but prior to that we do sit down with the business office and we will review the procedures we'll review the Personnel we'll see if there's any new Personnel um new personel matter because if they're in a key spot within the district for example like a new payroll Clerk or payroll uh accountant um that we're not familiar with that kind of raises the risk of the audit you know we're like we don't know the person we don't know their capabilities we don't have that case here uh but in in a district that's what we do in advance we review the procedures we
008review the policies we review the people we will then my office make a determination how we're going to test what we're going to test and how much we're going to test same goes for expenditures those are the two big areas within the district that have the most activity there's a lot of little transactions and there's a lot of big transactions within those but we we have to run initially a random sample we also test other items within for example the expenditures we will look at big dollar items Big Ticket items we'll also test for health benefits making sure that everybody who is on the health benefits bill is also an employee of the district we'll test for maintenance expenses making sure that the district is investing properly in the maintenance that the state wants you
009to invest because you received several years ago a very large Grant towards the high school well part of that deal is you have to invest in the facilities to keep it maintained they have an investment they want you to invest as well we'll look at travel expenses on a sample basis every month you pass a resolution authorizing people to go to various seminars and travel we'll check to see that those are properly authorized we'll also check to see uh that you're in compliance with the local public school contracts law okay that is uh what we'll do is we will get a list of all the vendors we'll schedule them out we will look at all the uh vendors who are greater than $40,000 and determine whether if they were required to be bid that that
010they were properly bid okay and just for the record we had no bid violations we had no Public School contract violations um I I'll get to that in the end um just to to sum it up we also will look at Transportation bills we'll look at contracts to make sure they're properly executed we'll look at tuition bills the district spends like most districts a lot of money on special education we make sure that there's contracts in place with each of the private schools um and that there are at least good records that we get on a monthly basis from those schools uh Capital expenditures we look at those we make sure that they make it to the fixed asset list we make sure that they are proper Capital expenditures we also make sure those Capital
011expenditures were properly bid um we'll test your your to your um your transfers you you you approve resolutions for monthly transfers we'll check to see that if a transfer made it to the books that it was also approved by the board there was no exceptions in that case so when comes to expenditures the key things to look for are and I would advise any board this and I try to keep it concise as possible we we do test various components of each transaction but the key doc the key items are that each transaction is properly documented that there's proper approval to purchase the item which is most important that it's properly coded in terms of Which accounting line item it gets charged to which budgetary line item it gets charged to and that the bills
012are cut off properly with respect to the fiscal year so we're not paying in September of 16 we're not paying May of 16's electric bill and charging it the next year budget we we have not had any problems at least as long as I've been here in that area with with cutting off the bills so there's various things that we test for we're all in agreement here at least my staff and I in formulating our opinion as to the operation that there were no violations of any of the items that we look for that's a good thing and I think that's a tribute to having proper Personnel in those positions within the business office um we have Aura Allen who's a a former public accountant who monitors the general ledger and the cash balances daily
013we have a Jerry tag who knows the public school contracts law quite well um and has his thumb on a lot of the expenditures that are made here and we spent a lot of time with Jerry he knows the law okay we have pretty good uh setup right there we have good people in the payroll department down they work down in the basement in the Next Room for us so um they did a really good job this year there was a little you know problem with the payroll vendor that was uh quite uh nerve-wracking for everyone and they recover from that quite nicely I mean I we we did some extra work in that area that they worked out very nicely we want to make sure that everything was was correct in spite of the
014the breakdown of the software so with regards to expenses everything worked out nicely and again we test we don't check every item okay and again we test from the runs uh computer runs and the computer reports that are provided from the business office okay the other aspect we check for which is big is payroll we we'll review the payroll we will ascertain that each payroll transaction not everyone but each one that we select the sample um that a the most important that the gross payroll is proper that there's proper withholdings most especially in the area of health benefits contributions we'll make sure that the proper document ation is on file for example w4s I9 a lot of it's compliance testing just making sure there's something there but the biggest part of it is that we
015test the salaries we found them on a test basis to be all proper for the base pays for extra pays we also on each transaction we'll if there's extra pay on a particular transaction we'll check to see that that documentation is proper we'll also run a test on uh a couple payrolls for part-time and overtime a lot of lot of times when you you work in a school district everybody focuses on the base pay well there's also a lot of extra pay going on too for class coverage for athletic coverage for uh overtime for custodians or maintenance men so we check a couple payrolls to make sure that at a that the hours are recorded properly and that the rate is proper okay so we got we have good results from that we also check
016to see that the uh payroll taxes are paid timely and properly um that's a big area that you know one little slip up and all of a sudden sudden you have a fine from the IRS and a lot of times they're very forgiving sometimes they're not we have not had a problem in that area so with regards to the expenditures and the payroll we were very happy with those results we also spent time looking at uh the cafeteria fund the Food Service fund uh we we have access to I believe there Mets Mets culinary uh the company that does our food service we'll look at their pay they are very generous to us we look at their payroll records we don't question really you know how much they're paying their people but we if they're
017claiming certain number of hours that they're charging to this District we'll go through a sample of of payroll certain payrolls and check to see that the hours are properly recorded uh we'll we'll flip through uh and look through uh the food bills which are probably one of the biggest components of what we get build for just to make sure that there's nothing that looks like that it should not be charge to us um pretty much is pretty cut and dry but I believe again we have our own in-house Food Service director and I think she goes through the those items with a very fine tooth comb prior to presenting the bills to the business office for payment so we got good results out of that your food service operation is Big we we verify the
018meal counts the daily meal counts which flow to to the monthly meal counts which float through to the federal claims that we make to get reimbursed we found that to be very good and accurate so those tests are are are in the areas that are the biggest areas that we look at okay um we do spend time looking through the Student Activity funds uh it's a very tiny component of the operation we rely that it's being audited internally prior to us getting here because it's it while it is a lot of money within that fund it's not a lot of money in the overall world of the district but the business office does audit that internally prior to us getting here we would prefer that they catch an era before we catch an era so
019they they do monitor those and I know a lot of money runs through those funds probably in excess of a in total each one of the schools has their own bank account and I know every time a new person starts I know they get instruction as to what the proper thing to do and what is not to do the big thing there is that that that the whoever is the controller of that fund within that school is buying items that relate to Student Activities and not to items that could otherwise run through the budget so uh we're good in that regard we also check your uh you receive quite frankly not a lot of state aid compared to other places so we the biggest area we have to check for is your biggest area of
020state aid which is the special education categorical Aid um the administration of your tuition contracts which tie into going funds going to the special schools is we find that to be proper I mentioned that previous um same with between that and the Ida funds which is federal money we have to do a little bit of extra work in that area because of the dollar threshold that you receive um you receive more than $750,000 on a grant we have to spend a little time looking into it over and above what we normally do again we found that all to be proper another big area that we look at is your enrollment count which takes place on October 15th that that particular process worked very nicely as well um it's important that the proper Personnel be empowered
021to oversee the final filing of those products and I think that the board has done a good job in allowing people to do that which is why we end up with not a lot of audit uh problems in this District in fact we audit with with none so I mean we that all worked out very nicely so what happens is we do our testing but we also get presented with General ledgers revenue reports receivable reports expenditure reports payroll reports so we start to assemble those into a report format which results in this large document here okay the way it audit works is is that management which is the two gentlemen whose names first names are Mike to my left okay and they're they're the head of those departments they present us with um these Financial
022records so an audit is based on Management's representations and presentation of the records so we get that information we we go through it we start looking at it we question it we analyze it we tie the numbers in to make sure that they're proper um and we convert that into a report format okay our role in the audit is to give an opinion okay and if you would like I just want to reference you to page 10 if you have your books if you don't um I know we everyone got their book I assume the big book yes page 10 kind of breaks out everything that I'm saying for example we're engaged to report on the financial statements management obligation is to present us with the records our responsibility is to the board is to
023give an opinion and our opinion is based on all the testing and all the questioning and the time we spend here is that the records present fairly in all material respects the respective financial position of the governmental funds business funds and each major fund of the district okay so we're happy with the result and here's one more most important thing the general ledgers as presented for audit agree on a monthly basis to the bank reconciliations that is first and foremost okay and what that means really is your general Ledger is reliable um quite frankly in in our world if every other number could be wrong which in your case is not but as long as the bank ties to the general ledger we have a good starting point okay so but we actually like it
024to be where every balance sheet account is proper and in your case the records as present that every balance sheet account was proper we did not have we hear Auditors and accountants make journal entries we didn't have any audit related journal entries order related journal entries are as a result of either an oversight or a boooo that we say hey we want to add this to your financials as presented we don't have that situation here um so in the end we have the independent Auditor's opinion indicates that the records present fairly in all respects the rest of the document contains um management discussion and Analysis which if you are familiar with any corporate uh that would start on page 13 management discussion analysis is actually the board's Management's representation not to us but to the
025board that converts this financial report uh into to more uh English in terms of more understandable it talks about the highlights of the district for the year which actually start on the bottom of 13 those are not our representations those are the boards that's keeping the board primarily and the public informed as to various uh items that happened in the district during the year um it was a result of actually the Enron situation that every audit has to have a management discussion and Analysis now included in their report and we've complied with that it's a rather lengthy document some of it is just a lot of words that are required to be there by the Lords of the profession but in your case you have key financial highlights uh up front in on page 13
026and 14 and 15 which maybe Michael can elaborate on a little later but it it it talks about some of the significant events that happened in the district this year has nothing to do with the audit but it has to do with the district tooting its horn about positive things and sometimes it they TOS about negative things okay but that's not normally the case so that that's the mdna which is the management discussion analysis which tries to make it a little easier for board members and the public to read the audit and actually this year we added a thing where we have some side-by-side comparisons uh which are on page 21 which talk about you know charges for services and property taxes and tuition federal and state Aids on a side-by-side basis and then the
027various expense categories it also has a pie chart that shows you the breakdown of the expenses and it's got expanded information on Capital assets of the district as well as as debt of the district now that information is also contained in the financial statements as well but it's it's broken out to be a little more understandable for for board members and the public inside the the financial statement itself the the cfra is actually three different types of accounting and it actually very confusing to anyone even myself there's for example there's the the districtwide financials which converts your basic financial information into a more corporate model it adds in depreciation it adds in accounting for sick pay and it somebody somewhere decided 10 years ago this is what we want to see we have to comply
028with it um it's a little misleading I think but it it does also include this uh recently enacted uh pension liability that need to be booked in here as well it's a the pension is a theoretical calculation as to what the district owes for its pension for PS employees only and it's based on interest rates it's based on discount rates it's based on um mortality rates it's based on certain pay raises for people and that part is only for the portion that the district is on the hook for which is the public employees retirement people the tpaf teachers pension annuity fund people that is an obligation of the state and therefore it is a legal and moral obligation of the state it's not on our books we we disclose a number that it is which
029is our allocated share but it it actually appears on the state's cafra as to what their legal obligation is towards the tpaf doesn't make it to our financials um we have also and I'll get to it if you turn to page 36 our food service operation um there's a 2 and a half million obligation I'm sorry operation and uh it had about $130,000 of of profit um I look that as Break Even because you know in another year you could lose a few bucks um you're not you don't need to make money on the food service but you just can't lose a lot of money okay and we don't have the case where we're losing okay we always have a nice cushion there in case the board opts to want to do some improvements or
030maybe change things within the cafeteria but the it's so regulated um it's it's very difficult to do too much and you know you have to follow the regulations of the government in that and also any excess revenues in that fund have to stay within that fund the other two funds which is child care and Falcon care though which is on the same exhib had a very nice year um made a nice recovery and eliminated some of the cash advances that were uh paid out a few years ago to the fund so th those two particular funds did very well okay so um and I think in another year the child care will be out of the red forever and then the Falcon care which makes you know is a nice operation and a nice service
031is another good item and that that just has to be monitored make sure that it doesn't lose nor gain too much the rest of the document has notes to financial statements which are an explanation of the accounting requirements that we're supposed to follow and and we do follow okay it's all pretty much stand wording if you hold school districts side by side across the country they probably have verbatim uh word for word is the same thing sometimes we add different things in there because you got to tailor the report a little bit to the district you know there may be a situation going on that needs to be disclosed we don't really have any of that but and it talks about the not of financial talk about debt it talks about the pension um it
032talks about your risk management interf funds and it talks about things like uh your excess Surplus and it has a lot of standard disclosures in it for example economic dependency sure we get state aid we get Federal Aid We're dependent on them if they go away we have a problem but you know it it it just has to be disclosed the rest of the document and actually just want to point out the allocation of our um of our fund balance it's got ious components our main operating funds um have encumbrances of 30,000 excess surplus of 6 mil capital reserve of 975,000 excess Surplus that's locked away for the 16117 budget is 5 million and our 2% unassigned amount which is what we can keep maximum of our own money used to be known as the
033free balance is 1.9 million so we have Surplus but each component is basically spoken for with the exception of our 2% money which is ours if we need it to use it and we can dip into it if we have to other pieces of the document are just the details of what's summarized in the front end and they just contain required disclosures for example they talk it talks about our capital projects it talks about our fiduciary funds which is a student activity in the payroll funds it also talks about it has in it the repayment schedules for our debt uh for the various schools that were built and it has lease payment information in it but one other section that that contains a lot of information about Monroe is in the back section it's called
034the statistical data section and again most of the stuff is a joint venture between ourselves and the district and most of the data is provided by the district we kind of just put it together in report format readable format but there's a lot of information in the back section that talks about Monroe itself income population rateable based allocation of the rateable base excuse me so in this thicker of the two documents the only real excuse me piece of information that belongs to us is our independent Auditor's opinion we actually have three opinions one on the financial statements which is unmodified excuse me and one on your internal controls which is reveals no deficiencies yes and um one I got I got I'm good thank you and one on your management of your federal estate grants
035which again is unmodified and shows no deficiencies so this document here is a joint venture between us and the business office in terms that we put it together we put it into readable format accounting format we put all the notes in there we do want to thank the people in the business office specifically the payroll department the accounts payable people Laura Allen um everybody in that room was in the business room we call it was very cooperative and you know receptive to anything that we request it and we're able to provide um and again like I said I gave kudos to Jerry tag we have minimal and we have no vid violations probably because of his oversight um and you know a lot of money goes through these books and it in my mind it's
036pretty well it's pretty well monitored the other document thinner of the two is my representation to the board everything I talked about where I talk about how positive all the results were is it's kind of summarized in this thinner of the two documents and inside this document is contained information about um our calculation of our surpluses it has meal counts for items that we claimed it has our net cash resources for our food service department and it contains an item signed by me that indicates that there's no audit recommendations the business office has been aggressive in the last several years in monitoring and keeping up to date with all the trends in the industry in terms of documentation and all the various accounting and auditing requirements it helps when you have a couple CPAs on
037the inside because they know pretty much as what we go through and what the requirements are and that just serves to strengthen the controls but we do want to thank uh Laura Allen because she was really the goete uh for us in terms of any accounting information that we needed so in the end we have no recommendations and we have an unmodified opinion and if there's any questions I'm happy to answer any of the questions now before we have questions I would like to thank you on behalf of the board for certainly giving this report tonight and for all the effort you and um people in in in um your employee do I also like to thank Mr Gorski and his staff for all the work they do keeping us on track uh so that
038we do not have any recommendations so thank you both you know it's incumbent upon the board to make sure that there's proper Staffing and I think that's been the case thank you any questions from board members um what percentage of total transactions were sampled oh gosh um I would say probably in the neighborhood of 5% maybe a little higher but we also looked at dollars too you know I mean we probably looked at a good 10 or 20 million dollars worth of expenses is that like 5% is that the industry standard that's probably above the industry standard a lot of firms come in and I don't know if you're in accounting or whatever but a lot of come and we'll do they'll do the bare minimum right let's do sample and get out because it
039meets the stand standards of the industry um okay we haven't done that I don't do that at any job we kind of just you know do a little bit more to make sure I need to get a real good Comfort level sometimes the statistical sampling is a wonderful thing okay but I I just like to look at different things myself like one like for example with payroll this year we went and looked at a bunch of other uh people over and above what we were required to do and by all means we do check the salary of the superintendent if it doesn't come up in the sample superintendent the business administrator and everybody in the payroll department we check their salaries over and above the sample then this year we decided to check I think
040we checked the nurses and we checked a bunch of other just I selected some people that I had my people check just double check these make sure that there's nothing on line and we also had to do we did a little bit of extra work too on that March 23rd payroll which was the last one with the old payroll service so we put a little extra time in that only because I I I personally needed to get a comfort level so yeah some of the I I don't know I don't like to toot my horn or brag but I I I think probably uh looking at a good representative s of the transactions and some might people might say that hey that's a little high you know 5% is a little high but you know
041if I add it all up it's probably in that range because we don't only look at what we sample but we have to look at Travel bills maintenance bills tuition bills it all adds up right so thank you yes thank you any other board member re question Russo Sir Mr Russo you did say you did say that we get very little state aid yeah right now that's that's just a common that's not an audit issue but I just looking at it we we we don't and it's more of a management setup I just happen to notice that considering the district size it just seemed it's low and I know we we know it's low everybody I think here knows it's low and I know Mr Gorski is a a student of the the amount he
042knows significant amount of of more than I do about why and everything looks good um anything that we can be doing better everything looks good yeah anything we can do we had all good results from every single one of the tests and even of our expanded tests uh everything is presented properly and like I said the main thing is Cash is tying out monthly to the penny and as a prior ba said cash is King yeah no I have no doubt of that the uh is any is there anything that we could do better uh I think if you just keep making sure that the business off I have to be partial to the business office I know you have to spend on education but I think making sure that the business office is properly
043St is the most important thing you can do any other board members on I I just have a question on in the smaller book page three um just an a sort of a an explanation between the payroll account and payroll agency account in the first paragraph payroll account is the there's two bank accounts the payroll net pay goes into One bank account and the withholdings which goes into the agency account the benefit that's what it's called yeah you we have to keep a separate account for the withholding in in there is everything that's withheld and when it's withheld it goes in it doesn't stay long okay because the way we do payroll we have to pay for example federal government has to be paid within three days and the state has to be paid so
044the money goes in and it goes right out it it but it has to be segregated between withholdings and net pay and our pension our Pur contribution is up to date and in good standing right oh yeah we our pension bill is paid on April 1st of every year and trust me if if you don't pay it they come after you with a Vengeance okay well we would want that we would want to just make sure it's taken care of anyway oh wor I I'm sure there somewhere behind the scenes if we don't pay the pension they'll they'll deduct our monthly uh state aid which again is is not significant but no that's all paid up to date and timely the withholdings are paid timely as well that's important most especially federal and state other
045places they won't penalize you a government agency will uh other payments go to the 401K 403 and to all the different the unions and all that stuff they don't penalize you if you're late but you don't want to be late but we're not late no good one more question uh the um Debt Service um 10 million per year I believe that's I believe that's what they number roughly 10 is it high percentage wise compared to the budget um the only thing I can say about that is that you are within your debt uh you're within your allowable borrowing capacity as to whether it's high or not that's not an audit opinion um but it's a number you know and like I said you're with the only thing I know is that we're within our borrowing
046capacity and when you ask that question where anyone asked that question you have to evaluate the district and actually evaluate what was built with it and um it sure it could be High I mean I have other districts that have you know they have no debt but they have old schools okay and their debt is low as compared to the overall percentage so uh I to say it's high or not I can't really say that I do know we are within the borrowing capacity as as certified as of June 30th some and our and that's Debt Service that's interest and some amortization right that's not our total debt that's just the cost of paying off our debt to meet that obligation for that fiscal year right it's a predetermined schedule once the board sells the
047bonds you're a lot into a permanent schedule and you can't be late and by the way we're not late um and it gets wired in on the required day so yeah it's a it's a predetermined schedule um that is actually bid and negotiat is actually bid and locked in we we dictate the days we're going to pay and then someone comes and bids for those bonds and sure we we pay them timely may may I um I I I I was happy um in the one of the committee meetings that I had asked Mr I every year I think I ask him what our total debt payment is and I found out that I think we're what about 20 million less than F yeah so I was pleased that we're actually bring our debt down
048we had we had I mean I remember back when when we were about $150 million dollar in debt and I think we're now at 132 132 132 million so we are paying our our obligations down thank you any other board member Mr n um yeah first off I'd like to thank uh Mr stankowitz um it's been a it's been a pleasure to work with him and this is my third uh cafer and uh uh it really is impressive to see the amount of uh diligence that goes into this and I always think if only only you work for Enron we'd be so much ahead of the game at this point um and also as chair of the finance committee I have the the uh the privilege of every month as part of uh the chair's
049responsibility I need to go in and I need to do what a super super mini audit of uh of the financials on on a monthly basis and uh it really gave me a whole different insight into what goes on in the administration um uh Miss Laura Allen is just phenomenal on what she does the level of detail that she provides uh for me is it blows me away I mean because part of the process is there's invoicing I I see the invoice I see the billing I see the time sheets if it's a public contract cont with service but most importantly the very last page there's our agenda highlighted where we approved it I mean it just doesn't get any better than that and I think that's a credit to uh to Mr Gorski and
050the whole administrative staff um that this level of detail uh is very uh it speaks highly of them and the fact that we got another uh unmodified uh you know cafer is is phenomenal and so I'd like I like to thank everybody for that um one one question and this maybe go to Mr Gorski um and uh would this be possible to put this on the web on our site as a PDF yes uh I have this in PDF format and I was going to mention that during my brief comments next both the comprehensive annual financial report and the auditor's management report are both the audits of of your um financial statements uh for your District activity for the year they they belong to you they're uh accessible to you if uh if Mr notin
051wishes I could post it on the website or like previous years if anybody wants to send me an email I could send it to you but I'm happy to do either one thank you very much you could also find it on the doe website they now have them all uploaded by December 5th they should be on there well I know they're on there but if you want if you can't find it on the local website it's it is on the State website Mr I have one quick last question this might be more for Mr Gorski are how are we rated in terms of our credit worthiness the Monro Township Board of Education has the very highest Bond rating of any school district in the state and U the the state of New Jersey just got
052a downgrade which affects all public school districts and when we go out for another referendum soon we will be evaluated by standard and pores once again and this um audit and the fact that we have no audit recommendations again uh does positively affect the bond rating for sure if we were to accumulate audit recommendations which is not uncommon in other districts especially if they're not resolved through a corrective action plan into the next year uh it it does downgrade the bond rating because investors feel that they're they're putting up a lot of capital to buy bonds and the uh internal controls are the financial in the district are not up to par that is not the case here as as Mr Stanwood said we have the very highest Bond rating attainable thank you any other
053board member with a question Mr G I think you want yes if I may um two minutes and not a second more because we have a lot of business to go through tonight but the comprehensive annual financial report and the auditor management report I will post on the district website I encourage everybody to go through here because it's not just a boring financial statement there's a plethora of other statistical and demographic information that's very important to this District contained in this report it's an encyclopedia of of very good information this really is the the responsibility of the district's management um Dr kak um Laura Allen and and me uh the only part of this report that is the auditor's responsibility is a very important piece where the auditor gives an opinion on the financial statements
054and once again it's determined that there in compliance with generally accepted auditing standards and through his testing which goes was above the requirements of the American Institute of CPAs um and I could tell you certain area other areas like all the IEPs were tested at 100% all the administrative payroll was tied out 100% from gross to net that all the chapter 78 deductions that we pay into Health Care contributions were 100% collected which unfortunately you may have read in the paper is not always the case some districts did not do that and they were they were written up for that um also contained in the report is um on page 36 information on Falcon care and early childhood initiative this was the inaugural year for Falcon care and Falcon care turned in a very handsome
055profit uh $412,000 and early childhood enrichment was $ 114,000 that's over a half a million dollars of profit in two proprietary funds where the where the retained earnings from those are unrestricted and could be used for program enhanc ments or at the board's directive to reduce taxes or whatever you should want to do with it we are making the most of of seeking all of the external resources possible to help subsidize the resources in this District because 89% of them fall on the backs of the taxpayers through an inequity and state aid funding excess Surplus grew by a million dollars over last year that's evidence of the effective management of the budget throughout the year by Dr Co Oak Dr alvic and myself uh Dr kak initiated a purchase order free midye for not all
056non-essential spending all of that is being returned to the taxpayers through excess Surplus uh the outstanding debt as Mrs armino uh reference is $134,000 that's down $5 million from the previous year that's $134 million of outstanding debt down five from the preceding year and that's been going down as you would expect anybody who has a mortgage knows you pay off principal every year and your principal balance goes down the borrowing capacity in this District remains um to be $158 million so in consideration of a new referendum which is desperately needed at this time the board has $158 million available as of June 30 this figure changes every year with the amount of debt that gets paid off and other variables but that's enough money um to take care of any project that I I would
057anticipate we would need the unemployment in Monroe dropped to 5.3% the cost per pupil has been flat for about the last eight years and this year the cost per pupil only increased 0.4% and like I said there is a great deal of information I don't want to waste too much time on it tonight I'll be happy to post it and you could pull it down at your leisure but in conclusion the continuance of perfect audits with no audit recommendations is the result of this board and administration's commitment to the students taxpayers and staff that every precious dollar 89% of which comes from the local tax levy is accounted for properly spent in accordance with the budget and and laws and is safeguarded through exceptional internal controls I would like to thank the board of education
058for committing all the resources necessary to ensure an effective business office and again especially Laur Allen who does an excep job and uh and the taxpayers for supporting the [Music] schools thank you Mr Gorski and thank you Mr stanitz very much thank you now have a resolution to be read by uh the chair of the finance committee Mr Malin thank you Mr board president it is recommended that the members of the Monroe Township Board of Education accept and approve the comprehensive annual financial report and the auditors management report on administrative findings Financial compliance and performance and hereby approve and authorize the submission of the required corrective action plan to the county office indicating that there are no recommendations for fiscal year ending June 30th 2016 some second any discussion uh we could vote Mrs armeno
059yes Mr Braverman yes Mrs Deo yes Mr calman yes Mrs kapano Mr noin yes Mrs greo yes Mr Ryback yes Mr Russo yes for president motion passes unanimously thank you thank you very much thank you again Mr have a nice holid everyone and thank you and Tom are leaving the board thank you for your support and good luck and hope I don't not see you again well you provided a perfect segue for me uh into the next item which is actually one of the more pleasurable tasks that I have board president and I'd like to ask the administrators uh to please join me in the front over here [Applause] [Music] Mr Calin Lou you know we all talk about giving back you've been giving and giving and giving 15 years worth and what can we
060say but thank you I know you not only served for 15 years you were president of the board for one year and I believe vice president for four and um always making contributions your questioning shows so much thought depth and knowledge and uh we all have so much respect for you as a board member and as a person um all we could say as I said is thank you very much and we'd like to present you with this plaque at reads presented to Luke halman in sincere appreciation for dedicated service to the students and schools of Monroe Township while serving as a board member for the Monroe Township Board of Education from 2001 to 2016 I thank you on behalf of this board of education and all the citizens thank you [Applause] L and now
061I can ask Mr nin the vice president of the board Tom it's been a pleasure and an honor to work with you you know I don't know if everybody knows this but we have a little thing between us because I call him our VIP VP because you are very important vice president his knowledge base is incredible there isn't anyone here that doesn't respect Tom's knowledge his business Acumen uh that he brings his insight and again also similar to Lou the questions the depth of of thought uh and and what he gives to this community is uh invaluable uh I'd like to present you also with this plaque presented to Tom noston in sincere appreciation for dedicated service to the students in schools of Monro Township while serving as a board member of the Monroe Township
062Board of Education from 2014 2016 my friend [Applause] congratulations okay thank you gentlemen thank you board members and public we're going to go back [Music] we collect the pension now right I put in for doubling our pension C nothing okay moving along now we have our committee reports any committee chair uh wanted to report Mr calman find my little notes here so we had a curriculum committee meeting this evening and we reviewed the following things we went over the algebra 1 A and B a new course proposal for AP Computer Science uh and also a new course proposal for rhythmic dance uh elective and I think we agreed that uh Greg berer will do a rhythmic dance at the next curriculum committee meeting um that was a requirement so make sure that carries over okay
063um we also had a presentation on performance matters uh which is a program that we bought to run analytics against uh student data to see where we're doing well and where we can uh make improvements and we also had another a follow-up presentation on the IEC Club SL course um we're moving forward uh with getting more details about this particular program the committee asked that we uh just firm up a couple of more pieces of information but I think overall it's it's a new Innovative approach on on on looking at how we can deliver high quality education and and also utilize some of the wealth and experience of our uh residents so it's just really we're in a kind of a new territory here for education so we want to make sure that we do
064it well that it's properly vetted and that we dot all the eyes and cross all the tees so um I'm sure whoever picks this up will bring this forward and we'll see where we go from here thank you any questions from Mr Cal any other committee chair wanting to report um we had actually two finance committee meetings uh we had one last week it was a residency uh hearing for three students which we will be discussing uh amongst the board this evening in close session and coming out of close session with a resolution on those three students um and of course the second part of the the second meeting was for the uh comprehensive annual financial review and we're not going to go into that anymore that's it question for Mr nin I have a
065question you have did was that a question no I was going to ask him something about the financial review but I think I'll wait any other committee chair we had a Personnel meeting and what was said in Personnel is confidential so I can't really okay reveal any of what we confidential report that was a confidential report but we had a meeting Mr bran did you want to say anything about billing oh there's no change okay okay if you don't mind in that case I I want to provide just a bit of an update uh on the referendum planning which was discussed yesterday and have just have a report I'd like to read to update everybody Brinkerhoff Environmental soci iates have completed the first phase of wetlands mapping of the 65 acre parcel at Church Road
066the information has been transmitted to the project architect and civil engineer for evaluation on the feasibility of locating buildings at this site concurrently the threatened and endangered species species habitat assessment is ongoing the preliminary report indicates that as many as two schools can be located on this site however the land has not been officially transferred to the township which could further delay the process and Road widening traffic lights and water and sewer connections are additional considerations therefore following a directive from the board to explore alternate sites Administration has been actively engaged in looking for alternate sites we've engaged local Realtors pursuing both listed and non-listed properties based upon direction from board legal council we've expanded our search to areas outside of mono Township that might be viable for building the architect has completed an inventory
067analysis of all district schools confirmed all capacity generating Spaces by current NJ doe standards and generated functional capacity worksheets for each School building this determines current functional capacity of the of the facility which in turn allows us to determine onh house student counts earlier today the architect and administration met with rep representative of NJ dooe Department of school facilities and finance to review our long range facilities plan submission and our referendum planning and and potential for State funding the state representative acknowledged the work to date and indicated that they would be able to process our application for a school building referendum provided the land continues to clear standard mandated regulatory reviews example Wetlands Ross habber and Associates have also been working with Administration and the township planning department to update the demographic report as well
068as explore options for alternate grade configurations Dr alvic and mon monach High School administrators have been working with the architect on schematic design options for the proposed addition okay any other committee any question for this yes there many yes we had a um By Request of the some board members from last uh last meeting we had a request for a additional discussion on the nepotism policy was a bylaw 144 uh and Mr Luke Hoffman's uh question about extending the time frame for some of the additional employees um to 18 months uh we had originally had just the board members and the administ and uh the superintendent having uh been involved in the nepotism policy for and after 18 months but we now have extended that uh By Request of some of the board members we
069had that discussion so we have put that into the nepotism policy the substantive change uh now makes the reading for this evening a first reading uh it was a first reading in October it was due to be a second reading in November it was tabled uh so it is because of the substantive change it is now a first reading so it will be voted on this evening and then also again in January so it is on the board thank you any question for Miss Armenia okay I guess that ends the uh committee reports um we now have our first uh public forum let me say that members of the public that want to address the board you have three minutes in total to do so uh you can make a statement ask all your questions
070if you don't need the three minutes and you've finished with your statement or questions your time will be up and then if we can we will respond and if we we need more time we will get back to you uh if you just provide your information and you come up please uh state your name and address any uh member of the public interested in addressing the board concerning the agenda good evening uh Chrissy scurby 21 prnis um I was at the buildings and grounds and transportation meeting last night um and there were a bunch of options um being played around um one being bringing back the sixth grade to all of the elementary schools uh Dr kak can you elaborate on how that will work and have you research the curriculum impact on doing so
071as well as well as the staff needs for each of the schools okay all this is as you as you mentioned and you heard last night it is one of the options so until we determine if that is going to be a definitive plan to bring this to keep to sixth grade really at the elementary schools no we haven't done that yet because that is only one of the options and really as you and I discussed that would not be my first option to keep the sixth grade at the elementary uh but a lot of it depends on what sites are available what buildings are available um or what sites to put buildings and what kind of configuration uh we end up doing all right and you keep saying we don't need trailers next year
072at the elementary schools what about the middle school and the high school what is the plan for next year there where the class sizes are reaching 36 no I just want to know could you if there's more questions could you ask those questions now rather than go back and forth well I I think the questions deter the answers determin my next question I have three minutes to ask questions what we're doing though M scurby uh all due respect is to have people to give people their full time is to make the statement or ask their questions upfront we started doing that last month I'd like to continue that this month okay well that was a follow-up question to his answer I'm sorry would would you just State the question one more time please I said
073you keep saying we don't need trailers at the elementary schools for next year what about the middle school and the high school what's the plan for next year where the class sizes are reaching over 36 and we have new developments that are going to be sending an influx of students into those schools next year at the middle and the high school right now although yes some of the class sizes are large to Middle School we're very aware of that not all the class sizes are that large and right now we do not have plans based on the information that we have received from our District administration and what we've looked at to put trailers in place for next year the following year certainly we may be looking at that but not for September of 2017
074and what are we going to do with the class SI well how what are we going to do if the class sizes reach 40 42 at the middle school that's going to be acceptable well if I don't know if they're going to reach we're dealing with their radicals I don't know if they're going to reach 42 it's not a radicals we have huge developments going up that's why we have a demographer working on that and plotting it out we're working with the demographer on an ongoing basis to make sure that we keep our uh that we plan properly and what's the estimate for the end of the school year what does he have an estimate for what we're going to be looking at in June when these developments are opened and people are moving in
075uh we do not have the full report back with us yet you also mentioned last night that you don't want to expand the middle school on the current land that we own there because it would create a campus with a high number of students in one area however you're discussing having two schools in one area on Old Church what would the difference be why would you consider why wouldn't you consider expanding the middle school on the property you own instead of building two new schools I I just want to interrupt something I know you know we started and letting the go on but uh I'm going to ask you to just State all your questions we have this one do you have another follow-up question so that I'd like to put this back in a
076uniform kind of a situation is there another question you're going to ask after this I don't know it depends on the answer I need you to ask we we're asking that you ask the questions up front I I have three minutes to come up at public for you have three minutes to make your statement ask all your questions uh and then we will respond oh okay and he's responding it's not back and forth I mean you're you're asking a question our coac was responding we're asking you to ask your questions up front that's what we started last month okay well that's a question that's your last question no have you spoken to anybody on the Town Council yet I know as of last month you have not and I'm wondering if we've spoken to possibly
077the president of the Town Council to get an understanding for if the town is actually going to transfer over the land to us cuz I know as of last meeting nobody has spoken to anybody on Town Council it's not been on a Town Council agenda or a meeting or or discussed my other question is the IEC program that Dr kak is pushing in curriculum part of the goals that the board has given to them I'm as confused as the board member sitting in that meeting if it's a course that we're looking at doing why would we be asking for money to pay teachers additional on top of their salary with this fall into the realm of a regular course and if it's a club the first year the staff are volunteers and after that they
078become become to stien that's the protocol in Monroe for clubs so why are we asking for I think it was $116,000 for the IEC last question can we accept a donation for a course it was my understanding that donations are not accepted for things that are in the budget okay thank you okay so the three questions I have regarding Town Council my conversations have been with the mayor and they I do have ongoing conversations with the mayor uh regarding the land transfer and other areas as well and that's of course of course that is something that the township uh works on we have no control over that but it is something that they are in the process of working on according to the mayor the program that you heard tonight The Innovation experiential um Center
079is uh was being proposed as a pilot it was not being approved uh yes there was cost associated with that regarding uh salaries and uh possible possibilities for field trips uh I think it is a would be a beneficial program for our students uh as far as it being a course that would have to be something down the line much further along if a curriculum was written or um the board decided that they wanted to support that as a course but at this point it was not it was just looked at as a pilot program and the last thing is donations for a course uh I would refer that to Mr to Mr Gorski as far as how donations are handled um you know in there are certain principles and considering that you know he
080received a u no recommendations once again I I trust him to handle the finances in an appropriate manner so we would do whatever is legally uh allowed as far as accepting donations okay and is the program part of the goals Mr scarby I that that he didn't answer my question my question was is the IEC program that's being pushed part of the goals that the board has set okay I'm not sure what goals you're referring to did I set that as a goal that is part of what I said the board gave you goals that is part of what I set as a goal yes but that is not the reason why I'm pushing that I'm pushing pushing that because I'm not even pushing it I'm proposing that because I think it's what's good for
081kids and based on visits to other schools and based on information that I have I think something like that would be an excellent vehicle for our students to have that opportunity that is the reason behind me proposing that all right thank you very much how much time do I have left I can make a statement as well right well no you had you well you had time to make a statement and ask your questions um a statement you have um two minutes oh perfect well sit sitting in that curriculum meeting I just want to say that I was like I said I was very confused as was many of the other board members of what exactly was being proposed um I think before you move forward you really need to figure out Dr kak exactly
082what you're looking at proposing for the high school whether it's a course or a club you came this evening asking for money to be supported by the board and there was a lack of information a lack of planning a lack of a lack of understanding for what it even was it was very very alarming and very disappointing yes I think it's a wonderful opportunity for students to be given an Innovative program however what was being proposed tonight was going to be for a very small amount of people you mentioned that it would only be allowed people would have to um students would have to to apply for it there may be a fee with it there were so many things up in the air it was it was unbelievable that it was brought up at
083a curriculum meeting at that time when there's not even a plan put in place for it you had no you couldn't even answer the questions is it a course or is it a club it was absolutely disappointing thank you any other member of the public let me just State we're asking uh that you please make your statement ask all your questions up front you'll have 3 minutes if if you don't use the three minutes your time will be up and then we'll be responding stepen manfrey 12 Belmont Court uh I'll make my statements up front two of them uh first and foremost happy holidays to the board uh to you and your families uh the second statement I I have to urge the board president to uh reconsider his position to make members of the
084public ask all their questions up front the type of dialogue Rich dialogue that is created from this back and forth um is extremely important so uh in so far as you want to keep folks to three minutes I think that's entirely fair but to restrict them to not be able to ask questions in rebuttal based on some of the statements made by board members is um it's patently unfair so I would urge you to reconsider that position my questions uh Dr kak you have referenced uh some conversations that you've had with the mayor regarding um the parcel on England Road uh have you all discussed any other Parcels that the township is potentially willing to uh give to the board of education and support of our our children is that the only question uh that's
085one uh I'm just holding a pause for effect uh the second is um we heard that the preliminary Wetlands eval evaluation says that there could be two schools on that parcel uh I'm curious to understand what makes it just preliminary at this point are there additional steps that need to be taken or um has all that research been done uh the third question the wood turtle study is ongoing when will the wood wood turtle study be completed um and that's it three questions Mike want that sure yeah so the parcels of land uh now we're exploring whatever Parcels of land either publicly owned or privately owned that we can uh you know we obviously need to house more students we need uh a new school or schools and so we're exploring whatever parcels and we've
086had conversations with the township over other sites uh than just that one the preliminary study um you know from the very beginning we've tried to be as transparent as possible and and that means providing whatever information we have even if it's not finalized so rather than wait until the report is finalized we doal want to come out and say based on what we have right now uh the information it appears that there's enough room for two schools whether two schools would go in the property or not we did look at that originally for two schools and we we looked at other townships with similar size uh acreage and they also had two schools located on that property so it is an option um and the turtle study uh that has yet to be completed but
087to my knowledge the turtle study um the environmental impact of that would only extend the the the area is determined to be Wetland so it would extend it by so many feet or so many yards beyond that and no that's not done we have to wait for that to come back and any idea when that is going to come back uh off the top of my head no I I would imagine um another couple months okay thank you very much thank you anyone else good evening Andy poori 16 St James Street the statement is the retiring two board members we really appreciate your service to the township thank you very much um comments are essentially uh regarding the new schools one of the questions that I have is I believe the Edwards Engineering Group has
088been hired to conduct the Wetland study and from what I heard today the study is complete is a study going to be available to the public to review so that we can assess based on some of our knowledge again my questions are going to be based on the fact that how can we assist the Board of Education to move along to get the new schools into the system so this is not a confrontational discussion so I just want to disclose that up front so can we have the opportunity to review that and see what land is going to be available to do that uh and I believe you engaged a Brinkerhoff Associates to do the uh broad Turtle uh investigation and I think I just heard uh the superintendent say that we don't know the
089time schedule uh my comment is that you know in this world you don't work without a scope schedule and a budget so I'm assuming that when you award the contract to Brinkerhoff you set certain parameters in place it would be good to know when Brinkerhoff is going to be completing their study um and also I heard from the statement from the the the chair that the radius of search for a new school site has been expanded Beyond Monroe uh would be curious to know how far are we looking at this uh in terms of uh the distance that the kids may have to travel and and needs to be bust uh overall uh the parent Community students are interested to know the solutions I know that yesterday in the committee we talked about having a
090plan I really would like to see and if I can assist again whether it's a prim Vera or Microsoft to put down the various activities when they're going to be done the time frame what if scenarios to make sure that we have a plan moving forward that we can accomplish in a given time frame and not keep it as an open uh agenda moving forward uh I think we have gone through this for three years and I think we reaching a point where we need to start making some concrete decisions that's it thank you Mr PL good good points uh let me just state that as far as the brinkerhoff's uh study we haven't received the official document yet but um putting it up on the website is absolutely a good idea we have nothing
091to hide from this and the um the initial contract with them I believe gave them six months if I'm uh not mistaken and we had requested to do this as expeditiously as possible uh but they still have to do what they have to do and so this is as we stated was just preliminary yes Mr in terms of the Wetland study while while the people we've hire to have done the research we still have to have a submission to the uh Department of Environmental Protection is that correct or the in the state and they have to actually review our documents and give a permit so that hasn't happened yet is that correct I don't believe that we submitted suspect I would suspect Michelle that is correct at the end of the day once the study
092is completed you need to do what's called as an Loi right uh well the LOI has to come from the state Loi has to be done by us and submitted to the D for approval I don't think that's done again the time frame we're looking at is 6 months one year from now to looking at the site but the I just want to conclude so that the public knows that in so far everything appears to be that the site that you're looking at the 65 acres seem reasonable to move forward is it a fair assessment or not necessarily evening Mr plur um first of all as Mr Ryback said the Wetland study from Brinkerhoff is not complete yet however they have communicated The District administration that the initial Wetlands maps that we had before this
093process began um the Integrity of those Maps seems to be intact that the wetlands have not exceeded those initial um Maps which was very good news because we had some suspicions and we had heard some some comments from folks that it had but according to Brinkerhoff it has not we do not have the report yet that will be an open public record as soon as we it and the board accepts it uh the timetable for that should be uh relatively shortly because we're waiting for that information um we had our architect then do some schematic drawings with the wetlands that exist on that property and very interestingly he he presented to us and this is how rough we are at this point that we could actually pick up the footprint for the Monroe Township middle
094school with all of the fields and also oak tree school with all of the related fields and fit it on the area that's not Wetland on the new uh land now it's not our anticipation that we would need that much space so that was very good information to receive preliminarily from Brinkerhoff and as far as U looking for land outside of the township we had our attorney do some research on it I'm I'm going for memory now but I think she said that we could purch just up to 25 acres of land outside of the township uh we have not identified anything outside of the township there are incredible Transportation challenges once you go outside of the township even staying within the township this 40 square mile uh Township is is difficult to get from
095one area uh to the other side so um that's where we are with that we've identified some private pieces of land as as Mr Rybeck said that appear very promising but as the board has resolved previously Administration is directed with exploring the 65 acre parel of land till its Fidelity and the initial news that we received so far from bringing Hof as I'm repeating was favorable and more information will be provided as soon as we get it and the board accepts it the last point was the time frame for various scenarios scenario one scenario two what if and then have a time frame for implementation is that something that's going to be done and available to the public to review it's something that will be done be uh in front of the public at committee
096level certainly and those the building grounds transportation is always open to the public so uh that will be open it'll I'm sure it'll be discussed during committee reports publicly the board meeting and we'll be transparent through the whole process right thank you very much and a happy holidays to everyone thank you I see someone else waiting good evening uh prakash parab 33 daa Drive the our vision should be that we should give the best education to our students and I heard uh there is a curriculum committee here so my question is how is our curriculum compared to the top schools we have in New Jersey and um which are which have good acceptance rate in uh the students have good acceptance in good universities and I can acknowledge so can I just I'm sorry to
097interrupt but the question this portion is for the agenda yes this is for the agenda curriculum I heard about the curriculum discussions today so the question is on the curriculum am I clear yeah yeah here okay so how is our curriculum compared to should I repeat the question you want to know how our curriculum compares to do you want me to repeat the question I think I I know the question yeah you want to address that thank you for the question uh I think our curriculum compares to the best schools the when I look at what some of what are considered by many to be the best high schools in the country uh I see Innovative type programs that afford students an opportunity to have some experience kind of beyond the curriculum such as possible
098internships or apprenticeships at uh corporations maybe some work with colleges or universities or professors uh either there's different types of programs there's shadowing programs there's visitations uh similar to shadowing uh there's University PR uh professors that might work with the high school teachers or indor students and there's opportunities for students to visit programs in the high school or in the uh colleges or universities so I think that's an area that Although our students do well based on the standards of standardized testing let's say uh and our College acceptance rate we get students into good schools last year we had a student accepted into MIT we had a student accepted into I think Colombia and Cornell uh they're excellent schools I would like to see more of our students accepted into those schools I would like
099to see more of our students to have that those opportunities to work walk into those universities with the skills beyond the curriculum that that we offer we have an excellent curriculum we have excellent teachers um excellent administrators and of course with the support of an excellent board but we always want to strive to be better thank you thank you any other member of the public yes sir good evening my name is Ravi malali 16 Louise Lane Monroe I I just wanted to Echo my support a strong support for the IEC program I mean you see this in the corporate world right we bring in summer interns from colleges to get the feel for what the corporate industry does it doesn't have to be corporate the regular companies what they do I think we should start
100them much younger when they're in school yes absolutely true you have to take the school to the next level we cannot be striving for we're good enough so let's go into the next mode and and try to get them into the higher schools better schools the top five or six you know IBD schools and and to to conclude my uh statement my question is I heard you say that you need some more details my request is can you guys look at the IC program the pilot that you're planning to and sort of accelerate that so the current students can benefit from that program earlier than later thank you is it a question is a question well that that's a that's a question that we're going to continue to look at that but it's a question
101uh for the board uh you know I will present to the board and I'll continue in in my efforts uh you know they brought up excellent points tonight and I need to go back and uh look at that and uh I I don't think it's a dead issue uh with the support of the curriculum committee I would like to continue that do you think it's something that'll be done in the next couple of weeks or months or well the board meets once a month so I would have to wait till our January meeting which I believe will be later in January okay thank you happy all of here thank you any other member of the public not seeing anyone we can move on to the uh superintendent's report and recommendations Dr coai thank you thank
102you Mr President you're welcome our uh esteemed student representatives to the board uh made mention thank you very much of our high school marching band that uh you know they were outstanding they were invited to the 75th anniversary of Pearl Harbor I've seen some of the videos they performed well I think it's a um it's uh a recognition well deserved based on their performance at various festivals my understanding is that people heard the band perform at some of these competitions or festivals and invited the um marching band to to go out to Pearl Harbor and I think it's something that we can all be proud of the students uh certainly doing a great job the parents of course for helping the students getting them to their lessons to band The rehearsals the board for supporting
103them uh and we would like to uh Mr Rybeck and I have talked about it if we haven't presented this to the board yet but we would like to formally recognize the marching ban at a future date possibly the January meeting uh the board would approve that again we're just talking about this now uh so we'll make plans and we'll certainly notify people for that the um this past Monday uh Dr alick myself uh Mr goodle Mr MIP po a number of Supervisors we did go to visit high technology high school in linro uh linro New Jersey and that uh STEM Academy it's a it's a portion of a larger school district is recognized or has been recognize six or seven years in a row is the number one stem High School in the country
104and the principal there was very gracious and in giving us about two or three hours to walk through the school to talk to teachers to talk to kids and we came back with I think a lot of very good ideas that we might be able to implement in the Monroe Township School District um I I think our kids are just as smart and uh we certainly want to share and uh you know look at our best practices whether it be at linkof uh whether it be at other high schools just as other districts have visited our high school and our school district to pick up ideas I think it's always good to share uh to look at Best Practices so we we'll continue to do that I would like to make a special mention it
105was in the home News Tribune for Matt michler being the all area boys soccer player of the year it's a very nice honor for one of our students U I'm proud to say that our students are continually recognized for their academic achievements and their artistic achievements as well as their athletic achievements uh for the board members going to the Personnel section of the agenda I would like to just note a couple items that were new since Friday and I just wanted to make sure that everyone's aware um they were printed in color or in red but I think have copies in black and white because we're always looking at the budget and saving money we didn't want to make color copies so uh but item U is a a new item on there and it's
106a return to work for one of our security guards item Y is the recommended candidate for the director of human resources that we discussed during uh the Personnel committee uh within item z z is one of the tables with all the numbers in there Mike you me just slow up slow down you okay I just said bless you she oh sorry sorry oh you're good I saw you flipping paper so I just okay uh within item z uh number 10 is a resignation replacement uh reason the only reason I'm mentioning these they weren't on the agenda that was sent out Friday these were new things that came in under item Z number TW Numbers 22 to 25 are leave Replacements I know I like that uh number 15 under Z also is a retirement replacement
107and letter Double B there are two additional substitutes that were added so nothing really out of the ordinary but things that um weren't in place uh on Friday under board action uh o is the uh nepotism policy that Miss armenio referred to the first reading we had our policy meeting um um Monday was Monday Monday night Monday night right and item p is the long-term substitute teacher pay rate change that we uh discussed in personnel and um Mr Mayo is it right for me to elaborate on that to the for the board as long as it's appropriate yeah it's generic go ahead generic yeah it's generic yeah it it's the uh the pay rate that we're proposing that I'm we're asking for board approval for substitute teachers for long term to align what our pay
108policy is along with the state law as far as being in the classroom for a certain number of days um 20 days or 40 days with a certificate with not without a certificate so we would tiar the pay basically so that um The Substitute would be paid either $85 or $95 a day if they're uh depending on their certification up to the first 20 days if it's a long-term leave replacement uh I believe with that looking at the I think it was $120 a day or $150 a day and after day 40 um doing this from memories I know it's right here it's um $200 and some dollars a day which is uh equivalent to first year salary and that's basically what we're following with the uh the law for that so I just wanted
109the board to understand uh what that was and what you're voting on uh because we had the Personnel committee uh last night so that's a new item on the uh on the agenda but it was discussed as Personnel last night and with that Mr President um I would like to conclude that portion of the report of the superintendent report and I would like to recommend approval of personnel items a through doubleb moved second any discussion no discussion you can vote yes rman just a minute please till Double B that what he said personnel items a through Double B yes on everything except X null on X noted thank you Mayo once again this is Personnel items a through Double B only can I ask the stem planning committee what is that for this is to
110finish the planning last year I stopped the planning for the stem Summer Academy because we didn't have the enrollment okay and I know that I was directed again this year to look at it again for moving forward so this is picking up where we left left off to finish the planning for the Academy to go out for the stem Summer Academy again so this is the camp yes this is the camp this is the summer camp and who directed you to go forward with it again I did and and I think we had some informal discussions about this at the end of last year that one of some of the problems were maybe the timing of it and uh was my impression that we wanted this to be looked at again for uh beginning this
111year okay yes thank you Mr cman yes Mrs K Pano yes Mr noin yes Mrs poo yes Mr Ryback yes Mr Russo yes I just had a question on why uh about the Director of Human Resources and was the job description changed on that one right yes um no Mr Russo the job description for human resource director was not changed I think you may be confusing that with staff accountant to accounting clerk changed but this person didn't actually hold a resource position previously yes sir person held the human resource position previously yes did yes I thought it was secretary title was secretary but according to their superintendent she had responsibilities equal to uh an assistant superintendent of personnel very high qualifications for the position meets the qualifications as we express to Personnel so she's moving
112from one school another curette to this school yes sir um difference in Pay between CET and here negligible okay so we do have some some people some staff who leave other schools and come here yes we do I just wanted to bring that up because every time somebody leaves we always hear the opposite it's usually the opp opposite uh Monroe is a great training ground and we breed a lot of Administrators here but um well she she'll be working in your office she will be working in the central office yes central office okay well she'll be around a very good uh staff so thank you she made a good choice thank you thank you sir okay so yes thank you so noted um Mr Bo president Personnel items a through BB has passed okay thank
113you would like to recommend to the board um a under board action a through P think I second any discussion we can vote Mrs armenio yes Mr Braverman no on M and O yes on the rest it's a yes on everything and a no on M as in Michael O as an Oscar yes thank you Mrs Deo no on o yes on everything else thank you Mr calman uh yes on everything Rees on O So noted Mrs K Pano no on o and yes to everything else Mr noin yes Mrs Kino yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr Russo just a question on P the change from uh was it daily rate what was the previous and what is the new yeah do you mean to answer that yeah okay so the way we have it that's
114structured right now if the long-term substit comes into the district and it's longer than 30 days we put them on step one of the salary guide at the beginning right at the very beginning and we looked at other districts um that do more of a sliding scale so you would come in on either uh it's listed here 95 or up to $150 a day if they have the proper certification for the first um 20 days actually up to the 40 days before they would go to $246 a day which is equivalent to a first year uh salary and then beyond that it's uh salary and benefits and I think that's it um yeah after the 40 days and before it was step one which was equal to what I'm sorry said when the substitute entered
115before they would started step one yes so in other words if if a substitute was coming in for days we would start the substitute at the 240 uh six hours a day right from day one this will be a little bit of a cost savings and they'll they'll start at let's say $150 a day beyond that so we're saving money yes so I vote Yes okay um and Mr is absent I have y's on o please correct me if I'm wrong from Mrs armeno Mr noin Mrs Corino Mr Rybeck and Mr Russo that's five y motion passes board action items a through P everything has passed Mr board president and members of the Monro Township Board of Education it is recommended that board action items A K A through K be approved by consent roll
116call moved second second any discussion Mrs armeno yes Mr Braverman Mrs Deo yes Mr calman yes Mrs K Pano Mr nusstein yes Mrs Kino yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr Russo yes Bo president motion passes that concludes my report thank you moving to the uh president's report I just like to take a moment and Echo Dr kosak uh comments about the um marching band uh it's a incredible honor that our band our marching band was chosen to represent the state of New Jersey um and they did it in a a wonderful way they were wonderful examples for their fellow students the younger students and the community in general way back when I was a marching band parent in New York but I know we have a few other marching band parents here M quarino Mr nin
117Mr the calman I don't know if I missed anybody else well night Mr May what Mar par no no not yet not yet not yet it's coming he's only in eth grade and right right we know the the amount of dedication that that that takes it's a lot of work I remember loading the truck unloading the truck helping that it's uh it's a tremendous amount of dedication but you know look at the results and and and these kids uh this is something they will always remember and certainly we have to thank the dedication of the uh teaching staff as well as the parents because without them this wouldn't this wouldn't have happened so we are planning something special for them and it's and it's well deserved uh the next item I I just want to
118mention is on a personal note you know we will be reorganizing next month and it's been a year that I've been serving as president uh certainly been an experience a real a good one uh you know there's always ups and downs but I really want to thank all the members of the board here because you know we've gelled to be a a board of education we work together we don't always agree but we work well together and I thank all of you uh because uh you you certainly helped to make this a positive experience uh for me so I owe this to all of you and thank you all very much um that concludes my report any other Board of Education business Mr K palich well L knows he's not going to get away easy
119but I would like to thank Tom for the service use your mic oh the mic mik everybody so I'd like to thank Tom for his past three years of service to our school district and you did a wonderful job as the finance chair and I'm sure that all of us appreciate all the time that put into that because I know just how much time that takes up then Lou I remember the first day I met you he walked into Brookside school and we were terrified of you and you come yelling at us about um technology and we're like who is this guy and what's his problem and the next thing you know you're running for the board and you won so it's been um between Marv and me and you um we've put in a
120lot of time and we've gone through a lot of stuff together and I am proud that not only were we colleagues but we became friends and you have added so much to this District in just the the buildings that we put up and the the accomplishments that we have done together and um the the sense of humor which I think is important to bring to a board and um I for one am going to miss you very much and I know that you don't plan to come back but you're going to watch us on the TV when you get a chance so thank you for everything and um I will miss you thank you thank you any anyone Mr Russo yeah I'd like to Echo the thanks too to both Tom and Lou uh Tom
121I've known a little longer Lou I think what 12 days because it's one year I get to see him once per month but um not only do I will I miss the knowledge that they have and and that they shared but U the sense of humor both of you um comedy team um anyway you'll be greatly missed both you yeah thank so many Lou thank you for your years of service and um you're right there's there's been a lot of things that have gone on over the years um but I'd also like to thank Tom nodin who brought dignity and respect and fairness and decency to the board he did a lot of work and um self-sacrificing and always had the best interest of the children in the district in mind um even when it
122was to his own detriment uh I am honored to know him personally and um have had him as a board member and truly this district is losing an extraordinary man and I for one thank you very much and I know you'll be here as a member of the public because for the last 15 years you've been a diligent uh member of the public and very concerned about our community and I thank you very much on the questions to the superintendent okay anyone else l so it's time yeah it wouldn't be right if I didn't say anything right um there nobody here I know for those of you who are still here a couple of things um the new program that we're looking at it's very exciting we want to make sure we do it right
123because the last thing we want to do is let it out of the barn have to do a lot of regrouping a lot of redoing a lot of re-engineering so we want to do it right the first time and get it right so I feel confident that this Administration will do the right thing do the right fting do the right Ence and get it right going out the door but on a closing note seriously um I would like to thank two groups of people first my family for putting up with the enormous amount of time that this stuff does take and especially when I first got on the board we had a lot of things going on at that time as Kathy remembers and Marv remembers so I would like to thank uh my family
124and and the board members that we have now and the past board members it was truly a learning experience but most of all I'd like to thank the the community members I think I want to thank them for keeping me here because it's been a long time um there have been a few years where it was kind of up in the air about me running or what have you but um du due to significant peer pressure I was encouraged to keep on and again thanks to all the community members for for keeping me here this long because I like to think that I represented them fairly and well and um it's as some of you board members know it's not easy to run for board you know sometimes you click with the community and sometimes
125you don't to stay on for this amount of time I don't know I guess again thank you to the community and um Good Luck for all you guys in the future it's going to be an exciting few years anyone else Mr not well I would like to Echo Mr cowman's uh sentiment and I'd also personally like to thank Mr Mr calman uh when I first started going to board meetings was around 2001 and uh I got to to witness his um his quality of leadership for way back then so it's it's been an honor to uh to be able to serve on my short period of time with him obviously he's going to get a much bigger pension than me um but that that's how it works sometimes um I would also uh like to
126say I really appreciated my time my short time on the board it was uh really an eye- openening uh experience for me I learned so much I learned how uh you know how the uh sausage is made I guess is the best way to describe it and um not always pretty but it does get made and I'd like to think that it gets made in uh with the best interest of the community and the students in mind with that being said I have to I'd be remiss if I didn't thank the administration because I really got to see the hard work that is involved in running a school district uh from from that side of the fence uh from from the you know Dr kak all the way down to uh all the District staff
127that's you know and I know it takes the teachers to but I really didn't have much uh contact with the teachers I did see firsthand uh the effort that is goes into running this district and it is absolutely an unbelievable undertaking and quite frankly I don't know how they do it so efficiently and so effectively um I'd also like to thank my fellow board members it's been an honor and a privilege to serve with you uh I need to especially thank I think Miss armenio because um if it wasn't for her I would never have been even involved in any type of community um Advocate um because uh it does take a lot of work and if it wasn't for her inspiration and her daily um uh inspiration to me personally it's um I would
128not have been here and maybe some people would say that's good but that's okay too um and uh so with that being said it's been an honor and privilege and I'd like to thank the community uh for their support and uh I was an honor to serve them thank you thank you any other board member well not seeing any uh of the board member hand com up we can move along to the uh public forum uh this is not limited to the agenda I ask that you state your name your address and again once again please if you're making a statement uh you have up to three minutes if you U finish before 3 minutes your time will be up if you have questions the same the same thing applies and then we will will
129be responding minutes get there that's okay good evening Patty Lang 74 McFarland Circle um first of all I wanted to say thank you for the presentation on the budget that is just an incredible amount of work that's gone into that audit and to understand and to see where the numbers go and how well you as our Board of Ed have put and our Administration put yourselves together and can present it and explain to to us what's going on is Paramount and it's so important and I think it's really that's part of what I want to talk about for a second is that we really need to do as a board I think just a little bit better of a job of explaining what's going on to people so that they understand that we really do
130have some great plans in action but if the public doesn't see that you have these plans in action or they can't see it on paper it doesn't make sense to them it doesn't it seems like there's inactivity going on if we don't understand why a pro project is happening then it doesn't make sense to us and as the public sitting on the outside and in a few weeks I'll be sitting on the same side as the the room as you guys it is a really different perception so I just wanted to say that and I know that in the buildings and grounds meeting one of the big things that came up was the lead testing that's being required by the state which the demands that the state has put on our district which are un
131it's unfunded unfunded mandate to do this lead testing which is important cuz I used to um train teachers in the dangers of lead poisoning and children the the reality is lead poisoning is irreversible to brain damage and it is happening every day in communities all over New Jersey and I think it's important that parents understand what we're going to be doing with the lead testing what the in the unattainable goal of it by the state of New Jersey is to to want to know whether or not pipes that have been fixed over 30 years ago have S LED soer on them and just how we're going to be addressing it so my only thing would be is hopefully going forward forward as a group and when I get to work with you guys and I'm
132very very excited to be doing so and I thank those of you who are leaving the board for opening the door and giving me this opportunity to come in but I just hope that we can do a really good job of educating the public and letting them know what's going on even though they don't get every little bit they just need a better understanding so that we can have a nicer Rapport between ourselves and the board of so guys thank you thank you Tom thank you Lou I hope you left your questions with Jill like I asked for the EIC and um I look forward to working with you all have a wonderful holiday thank you anyone else from the public hi good evening Timothy verasa 7 Collins Avenue I am the parent of a
133special education child I am currently very concerned for his safety I'm concerned with the violence occurring in his classroom I'm concerned with the lack of any transparency from the school I'm concerned the Administration has put one child Above the Rest of the children in that classroom this past week my son witnessed his teacher being punched in the head I was not called I was not notified nothing was said to me I had to deal with my son trying to to explain to me what happened being a 7-year-old who's autistic it's not very easy for him I cannot understand what's going on and why we are being treated like this why I'm not the only parent in this situation right now I the one Speaking there's not much I can say about this but to implore
134you to look into this and why these actions are going with little to no response why they tell us much can be done but we can't talk about it every day my child's safety is in in question and there's nothing they've done about that I'll let you I'll leave you with the words my son gave to me on Monday I'll stop him dad he won't hurt the kids he's seven no seven-year-old should have to ever say that to his dad that's all I have thank you let me respond by you know thank you for sharing those concerns with us uh they will not go unheard thank you prakash parab 33 Dana Drive uh again like to acknowledge our marching band uh we are very proud I tell you my son is not in the marching
135brand but we were so happy uh to hear the news and it was on the Facebook uh we are proud I watch our school kids we are proud of the new school high school we are proud of it okay uh to I have two questions okay to summarize the year okay so I'm not asking in a bad way I want our school to be the best okay so don't misunderstand me I'd like to understand what is the ranking of our high school and middle school this year compared to last year and what are the opportunity is we have to improve and sustain the academic performance of our Middle School and High School those are the two points yeah thank you for your questions the rankings are a little hard because there's so many different people
136that rank there are the you journals uh or um news magazines like us news and World Report uh Newsweek and there's certain criteria they look at then there's uh something called Niche that ranks schools um and they so sometimes they change what they rank the schools on so it's it's hard to get a fair comparison sometimes uh if you look at the different ways the schools are ranked but I will say academically if we look at a uh some of the indicators such as how do our students perform on the SAT test how do ouro uh students perform on the state part Park exams uh I think our students do well we uh Dr Alber gave a full report on that uh no not that long ago we have that up on our website the
137question is can we do better and I think we can uh I think you know I've mentioned this before to many people and I keep it the a sign in my office that it constantly reminds me every single day and the sign is basically that the road to success is almost always under construction ction and the reason why that's important to me is you never I never want to get to the point where we say we're good enough it's never good enough we can always do better we can always bring in something else we can individualize our instruction we can help each student move further along we can help students get into better universities we can give them better skills that'll make them happy in life and also flexible enough with the the proper skills
138that have abits of mind the dispositions to enable them to be flexible enough to move with the economy because it's it's changing from uh self-driving cars to Uber to lift to Airbnb to uh SpaceX to I mean I can go on and on and on you know but we want to provide these opportunities for our students so I think we need to continually look and say what are other people doing and can we do better even if we rank in some areas we rank we rank well in one area maybe it's another area that we need to look at maybe it's the Arts maybe it's communication maybe it's our business our law um so we're going to continue looking at all those areas uh I think it's it's very important I I think it's very
139important that we not rest on our Laurels if you will and and that we constantly look at what other schools are doing as as a I I belong on social media on Twitter uh in particular more so than Facebook because I find that on Twitter I can follow Educators from around the world I can follow the Harvard Business Report I can follow MIT I can follow the London Business Journal I can follow all the types of things and the conversations that go back and forth the links uh I think is invaluable so a lot of the Educators in the district are are using social media for that purpose and we're going to continue to always look for ways to improve uh in those areas and Dr Al you're very involved with our district you know
140anything as far as how we Rank and and the middle school that you said you know you we can't wait to high school until High School to start saying how do we get our kids into better schools we we you really we really need to look at middle school and we do a lot with data analysis and we try to disaggregate that data that data and look down at every single point can we get better in this area or that area we have an avid program for students who maybe never considered college and we try to provide them with the skills that they need that that'll be help them be successful and college across the country that may be only 34% of Americans that attend a four-year University so we have to look at those
141students who maybe aren't considering college but maybe want to go into a skilled uh job you know another type of job so we want to provide those students with those skills that they could go to a a good trade school or in a technical field that maybe a college degree isn't required for of course we want our students to experience college but we recognize that for some students maybe that's not the path but it's U it's an ongoing process and I you you getting me some you're asking me something I feel uh uh very passionate about so excuse my long answer for that but um I hope that answered your Dr kak I'm very happy uh it will be very nice you have thoughts process going on thinking going on you summarize it if you
142analyze and uh provide the information I know that it will be improving as your thoughts improve so your analysis what you're doing if you could put it in a summary it will be very nice okay thank you thank you very much anyone else from the public not seeing anyone else we can move to the Clos session resolution be it resolved that the Board of Education of the town Monroe hereby moves to go into Clos session in accordance with the Sunshine Law chapter 231 of the public laws of 1975 njsa 10 colon 4-6 through 10 uh colon 4-21 to discuss the following subjects Personnel matter student residency matters harassment intimidation and bullying following close session action may be taken the discussion conducted in closed session can be uh disclosed to the public at such time as
143need for confidentiality no longer exists moved I have a second second all in favor I I I abstain obain about how many how much time you think half hour half hour yeah say 15 minutes to a half hour is all we take uh for those that aren't staying have a happy holiday we'll see you okay we could resume um I have a resolution it is recommended that the Board of Education approve the suspension with pay of employee number 6553 retroactive to December 5th 2016 pending further action by the board the superintendent and the business administrator board secretary are hereby authorized and directed to take all necessary steps to implement this action of the board of education so moved I have a second second any discussion good vote all in favor hi any opposed yeah I
144think we need oh need a roll call I'm sorry do a roll call um Mrs armeno yes Mr is absent Mrs Deo yes Mr cman okay Mrs K Pano yes Mr noin yes Mrs Kino okay Mr Rybeck yes Mr Russo well I'm here but you have to abstain myself recuse recuse yes okay motion passes Mr board president I have a a resolution to read yes sir whereas the Administration has applied to the Monro Township Board of Education for a determination that student number 8647807404 pursuant to njac 6A Call 22-4 do3e to determine the students eligibility for a free education in the Monroe Township Public Schools and whereas on that date the father of the students attended the hearing and presented evidence on the students behalf and whereas the finance committee after having heard and considered
145all the documentary and testimonial evidence presented recommended to the full board that it order the removal of the students from the Monroe Township School District pursuant to njac 6A 22 4.3 because the students do not reside in Monroe Township now therefore be it resolved that pursuant to njac 6A col 2243 the Monro Township Board of Ed accepts the recommendation of the finance committee and find that student number 8647807404 the district schools and be it further resolved that the board hereby orders the removal of student 8647807404 Russo yes word president motion passes thank you and we can move on to the um public forum I don't see anyone sitting in the public I don't suppose you want to ask a question in that case we can finally get to the next scheduled board uh of Ed
146uh Education meeting notice which is Wednesday January 4th 2017 at 700 p.m. right here in the high school and yes a motion to aour can you identif ify what that meeting is going to be for that's not that yes I'm sorry that meeting is a reorganization meeting thank you yes thank you Miss arm for reminding me that now we I have a motion to adjourn second move any discussion all in favor I that's unanimous this meeting is now adjourned thank you all