001good evening members of the public Dr kak Dr alvic and members of the Monro Township Board of Education Monro Township Board of Education organization meeting is now called to order in accordance with the provisions of the New Jersey open public meetings law the Monro Township Board of Education has caused notice of this meeting to be published by having the date time and place thereof posted December 30th 2016 at all schools the home News Tribune the cranberry press and filed with the clerk of the municipality this is a unique meeting uh where it begins without a board president as chair and as board secretary it's my role to chair the meeting until such time as a successful nomination for president occurs should we not succeed uh then hopefully we'll have a successful nomination for vice president
002and they would chair the meeting until a president is chosen uh that would happen only in the event of a tie so would you please join me in the Pledge of [Music] Allegiance flag flag of the United States of America to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible withy and justice for all moving right along with the agenda item number four is the election results the results have been sent to All board members and copies are available on the front desk for members of the public the election results have been confirmed and certified by the county it is now my duty to administer the oath of office to the following individuals who are hereby requested to join me at the table up front Mrs Michelle armeno Mr Ken Chella Mrs Patty
003Lang and Mr Paul retsky that's the wrong table [Music] does everybody have their oath please raise your right hand and repeat after I R do solemnly swear or affirm that I will support the Constitution of the United States and the contitution of the state New Jersey and that I will bear true faith and aliance to the same and to the governments established in the United States and this state under the authority of the people swe iations prescribed by law for the office of the member of Board of Education and I will faithfully and justly perform all duties of that office according to the best of my ability God declare that I not disqualified as a voter pursuant to R not disqualified to hold this office due conviction of a crime or listed in NJ 18
004so help me God so help me God please sign your names it's not it's not yeah something tells me they won't be calling us in for the uh for the [Music] concert sorry that's your first [Music] mistake was good congratulations welcome thank you thank [Applause] you thank you thanks congratulations and on behalf of the Board of Education we would like to wel welcome you to the board and appreciate your service I will now proceed with a roll [Music] call Mrs armeno here Mr Braverman here Mr Chella here Mrs Deo here Mrs K Pano here Mrs Lang here Mrs Kino here Mr Rybeck here Mr Russo here and Mr rutsky here let it be known that we have a quarum present this evening we will now move to number seven on the agenda election of a
005board president would any members of the Board of Education like to nominate a member for president Mr Braverman seeing your hand first I'd like to nominate Kathy Kip Pano for president of uh the board thank you sir is there a second I second are there any other nominations for president of the Monroe Township Board of Education Mr Russo I would like to nominate uh cany Chella I'll second at that and I don't know if I have a minute to make a statement as to why I'm nominating or should I is it open for discussion uh let's let's establish who the the the candidates are for first are there any other nominations for president seeing none then we'll close the nomination process for president and um we can engage in in some discussion if you wish
006Mr Russo um use your microphone please my reason for nominating Ken is due to the fact that he has number of years already on the board and being a newly elected board member he will be on the board for the next three years and I think one of the things that this board suffers from is lack of continuity in terms of the leadership so if we go back a little we've had Doug po was I think board president for one year then wasn't reelected then we had Steve Ryback was President for one year and and now he's not reelected um Kathy is nominated tonight to be board president uh but she also has one year left and then she'll be up for a reelection uh with you know a public election next fall with Ken
007we would beur of having a three-year period where we could possibly have a a board president that take us through these difficult times we're going to be going through some very challenging times and I think it's good to have someone there who will be uh will be there for the three years now he's also a graduate from ruus he has many years experience I think that he got most votes uh from the public in the history of Monroe Township uh for Schoolboard for 2016 um he will he would be one of the board board president if elected to um to have something that a board member a board president hasn't had in quite a quite a long time kids in the school so this is might be a big plus and uh yeah the main
008thing is in in the continuity so I think it would be an excellent choice for the board to consider uh Ken for president thank you any other comments Mr bravman sure I I really agree with you Frank it's uh it's very important uh this year that's coming up we're going to have a building program and um a lot of things are happening and that's why experience is very important Ken has been here before he knows what's going on but Kathy has actually been involved in building schools having referendums and hir Ing superintendence and I think that's very important so so as much as I like Ken on a personal note and probably a professional note I think Kathy is is uh much better suited to be president at this time Mrs armeno yes um I
009I have some um experience Mr bman talked about experience but I had some experiences that I thought were not um not up to what a leader uh should be and one of the things uh that struck me in my this is my second this will be my first term of my second my first year of my second term however the first year of my first term uh when Kathy was the president we had a negotiation year and this year will be a negotiation year also and to my disappointment the members of the board were kept at Bay during the negotiation process uh only the three negotiating uh members of the team were were kept apprised of the actual negotiations we kept um being told and when we asked what was going on what would be
010the update we were told that uh it was confidential and that they couldn't discuss it with me the rest of the members of the board and then the uh be the night of the memorandum of agreement the board members who were not involved really in the negotiations at all and not brought up to date on a regular basis we're given the memorandum in close session we were told we had to make a decision at that time in a very short period of time uh I thought it was not appropriate for board members to be held um in ignorance essentially uh and since then since my three years I have had extensive training with the New Jersey Schoolboard Association that the good citizens of Monroe have paid for um I think the training has been exceptional
011and what has happened is uh I have learned that indeed the board members are supposed to be on a regular basis informed about the process of the negotiation and indeed that the board the the full board is supposed to be contri the full board that is not conflicted is supposed to be contributing to the um the outcome of the negotiations and being apprised of it so that was disappointing to learn and as a as I was a freshman board member um even though I spoke up um it was we were not encouraged to be um informed so I think that a leader a president has to keep the full board informed and we are all in this together the president is not a unilateral decision maker um this is going to be a very extensive
012and hard uh fought referendum if we have to go out for it and I think we should all be respected we are all in in intellectually capable of understanding and we certainly have um a confidentiality uh uh pledge that we keep so I think we are that is very essential another disappointing um experience I had was that during um this konowitz is um year that she ran for reelection she used her position as um as a board member to go to um events and and took another non-board member but who was running and in my opinion used uh her power to get reelected on school property so again unless M Pon would like to tell me that that those things won't occur again and that they were just accidental um I have some concerns about
013uh the leadership thank you any other comments otherwise you know let's not get into um a debate on any uh past events but yeah this is rather weird and strange because uh and I and I and I I'm honored and I do appreciate uh you nominating me uh Mr Russo and you seconding it m Miss armeno but I I I'm not running for president and the reason for that is that uh I feel that it might actually be detrimental to the to the students and the school system for me to uh become president at this point only because I've been off the board for two years I feel that I that I'm I may be a little rusty myself I haven't been uh as involved you know in the everyday Affairs the way all of
014you have you know you you you get the confidentials and the emails and and you're aware of things and you know things that I don't know cuz I've been out of the loop for two years so although I do appreciate it and I'm very grateful and thankful for it um I I would I would just rather at this point be able to be a good board member and get up to speed you know as to what's going on and and what I need to do to be a good board member without um having the added burden of trying to lead and and and Lead almost in in darkness because I'm I'm not aware of some of the things that are happening thank you sir okay um we'll then engage a roll call and can can
015I point of order is is Mr Chella declining the nomination or are we going to vote on his nomination any there there's a nomination on the floor it's been seconded so we will vote on it and a vote for the candidate is a vote for that candidate for president of the Board of Education thank you simple majority of the members of the quarum will prevail um so we will begin with the first nomination being Kathy kapano and we'll have a roll call yes is a a vote for Kathy kabano as president Mrs armeno no Mr Braverman yes Mr Chella yes Mrs Deo yes Mrs K panowich yes Mrs Lang yes Mrs Kino no Mr Rybeck no and Mr Russo no that's five yay the Jamesburg member is not eligible to vote on the officer position
016next candidate number two is Mr Chella again a yes vote is for the president of the Board of Education Mrs armeno yes Mr Braverman no Mr Chella no Mrs Deo no Mrs col panowich no Mrs Lang no Mrs Kino yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr Russo yes that's four yays for Mr Chella and five yays for Mrs Kap panowich Mrs Cola Pano has just been resolved to be the next president of the Monroe Township Board of Education congratulations as such Mrs kapano will now chair the rest of the meeting and next on the agenda will be the nomination of board vice president thank you comination process I want to say something well for those of you who supported my nomination I appreciate the support for those of you who didn't I respect your decision but I've
017never seen a board president election like today and I hope to never see one again like this um we are supposed to be a board that's United for students and staff and today we've shown that we're not United and that some of us are really here for the wrong reasons and to bash other people I don't think that was appropriate and I hope it doesn't happen again to the next board president and then I would like to just tell you that no matter what has happened in the past I have always been ethical I've always been moral I've always been honest I've always followed the protocol I've followed the the decisions that that have been made so for those people in the public who think I didn't I did so um I just like to
018thank Mr Ryback for his past year on the board I know that it takes up a lot of your time and it's not an easy position to be in and then I'd like to congratulate Michelle on her re-election to the board it's great to have you back Mr Chella you're bringing back experience and dedication and we're welcoming you back to the board you're going to be a big help and Mrs Lang it's You've Won your first Board election and we welcome you to the board of education so we have an awful lot to accomplish this year we have a referendum that we need to get out we also have a um negotiations and um we're not going to be able to accomplish anything unless we work together so at this time we will go to
019number eight on the agenda I will open up the floor for the nominations for Vice President are there any Miss Miss Deo um I nominate Marvin Braverman is there a second I'll second second by Mr Chella are there any other nominations Mr Russo Steve ryack Mr Ryback is there a second oh I'll second that is there any other nominations for vice president of Board of Education okay seeing none um I need a motion in a second to close nominations a motion to close the nomination process second all in favor opposed abstentions okay at this time we'll have a roll call for vice president the Board of Education yes ma'am first nominee is Marvin Braverman for board vice president again a yes vote would be for the person to be vice president of the Board of
020Education Mrs armeno no Mr Braverman yes Mr Chella yes Mrs Deo yes Mrs K Pano yes Mrs Lang yes Mrs Kino no Mr Rybeck no and Mr Russo no that's five y second candidate is Steve Rybeck Mrs armeno yes Mr Braverman no Mr Chella no Mrs Deo no Mrs Cole panowich no Mrs Lang no Mrs Keno yes Mr Rybeck yes and Mr Russo yes that would be four yays for Mr Ryback five yays for Mr Braverman Mr Braverman has been elected board Vice President congratulations sir [Applause] congratulations Mr Braverman would you like to say something or would you like to just thank you you're welcome okay so we move on to the code of ethics and everybody received with their packet a code of ethics um I think it was like nine sheets of paper
021packet excuse me when did we get a packet in the beginning December 20th or something so there is an acknowledgement page that everybody needs to acknowledge that they received it they've read it and then we need to return it back to the um either Mr Gorski or Nancy anybody else I I have Steve needs one I I have copies I have extra copies need a few m yeah I mine is okay sorry I just I know I spent okay so we'll be giving out a copy of the um acknowledged form to everybody we could sign it and then give it back to Mike or Nancy this evening so while Mr Gorski is doing that we'll go to number 10 on the agenda the suspension of policy by law it is recommended that the Board of
022Education suspend the operation of policy bylaw 0164 to permit the board to conduct only one public forum at this evening's public meeting we need a motion and a second who was first can't second until somebody first motion yeah because I didn't think I did Mr rety and Mr Ryback this this we don't need Bigg pardon was that number 10 it was yes and who was Mr retsky Mr Ryback thank you we don't need a roll call on this do we um just um all in favor all in favor I opposed extensions then for this meeting only we're going to have one public forum and anything goes on this one I got that written down and we will be able to come up to the mic and talk about anything either on the agenda off the
023the agenda School related um and I just wanted to to say that public forum is supposed to be the opportunity for members of the public to make comment on any school related issue that you feel is important or a concern to the community it it has been in the past more of a question and answer session and that's not the way it's supposed to be you're supposed to come up and you're supposed to give the board your opinions on certain subjects so I I've been to a lot of training a lot of um uh board workshops and we're probably the only School District maybe in New Jersey that does this so um I'm going to request that we send the policy back to the policy committee and review it just so that we make sure
024that we're going to be fair to the whole public so for night for tonight I'm just going to ask you to come up to the microphone if you have comments make your comments if you have any questions after your comments we'll try to answer them as best we can so anyone wishing to speak about anything please come to the microphone state your name and address for the record all comments will be made to the chair and we will adhere to our thre minute allotted time good evening and happy New Year to everybody I thought somebody needs to come up and say something before the other people come up so I thought I would lead the way uh but most importantly uh I'm extremely I'm sorry name and address for the record please oh my name
025and address the guy who ran for school board and lost that would be Andy poori 16 St James Street but it very refreshing to see Kathy that you be elected as the president and we wish you on behalf of some of the community that supported me when I ran for the election that you're sitting up there and we're here to help in any which way possible to get better education to the township so thank you very much for volunteering to take the position and I also thank Mr Bayman I I have seen him in action at the the facilities meeting and he's a man of a few words but a deep thinker and I really hope that he continues on the board and brings that kind of thoughtfulness to make sure that we put into
026action not just words so thank you very much for that Ken welcome to the to the board looking forward to working with you and same thing with Patty congratulations to both of you and I'm ready and willing to do anything that you go guys want us to do moving forward so I want to offer my my expertise and my services thank you very much and good luck to everybody thank you Mr poori courting Masters I'm Michaela Court um I just want to congratulate Kathy and Marv for this evening and um couple of things one is you guys really need to kind of get your act together and work together as a group there is a lot going on in this District so you need to work as a grp group it's it's kind of sad
027what has gone on here this evening so it's as a parent it's kind of disappointing um secondly I think my question is more for um Dr alage so uh my son in the Middle School just his Spanish teacher officially started this week his second one from a sub that he's had I'd like to know if they're going to be getting actual grades for this cycle or just pass fail again as First Market grade because he hasn't had a grade in his grade book since September 30th Miss Alber Dr Alber when you hired me I was Miss Al um I I don't know the answer to that so I will have to get back to you but I will check with Dr Roselle who's the um supervisor okay for World Language and I will get back
028to you okay and do we know okay and can also when you find out I also need know like because now at this point he they missed October November December it's three months of Spanish they're going to expect him to take Spanish to next year he's going to be three months behind every other seventh grader taking Spanish again who didn't have this teacher so I wonder what the protocol is going to be to try to get those kids you know to catch up because it's not fair for him to try to now do a quarter of the work you know in less time so okay agreed thanks okay anyone else from the public wishing to speak hello everyone happy New Year uh RAM ragut 6 oen Strife again congratulations to all the new members and
029the new president president and the vice president just uh I guess comments um I I was not surprised and I appreciate what Miss Jill DeMayo uh did Armenia Armenia Sorry Miss okay apologize uh Miss Michelle Armen did and raising that I think that's how democracy is supposed to work people should be sharing opinions prior experiences and uh uh so I actually applaud what she did uh so I'm not disappointed with how this went off I think I think that shows that this is a forum that will have healthy debates and dialogues that's how you get to the best outcomes um with Mr Ken Chella one of the ones people who voted for him uh in these elections I was a little bit disappointed because sometimes you know you have to take it a leadership role
030when you're given I've done that in my career sometimes you don't have all the time to prepare for it but give your past experience and given that you've been given you should have actually that up so I'm a little bit disappointed um but again but congratulations and I hope for uh good set of outcomes and last Point uh from the president that I heard maybe I mistakenly heard this that the public forum is just meant for opinions not for Q&A uh maybe I misheard it no that that that is what a public forum is supposed to be and going through board training and everything we are the only District that I know of that does a Q&A okay thank you I appreciate if that is a privilege that we are getting I hope we can
031retain that privilege thank you you're welcome anyone else from the public at least I get to say uh congratulations Madam president my name is John Elison 8 Belmont Court in Monroe Township New Jersey so congratulations to those that were elected to the board uh and to you Madame President for your position and to Mr Braverman for his position I also want to Echo that um descent can be constructive uh and I applaud Miss armeno on her efforts to uh bring forth um an approach that I think is is transparent it's refreshing it's meant to hopefully be in the spirit of how this board operates for the remainder of this uh very critical year uh for me my question and just really my mandate to the board is transparency around uh this upcoming referendum that will
032affect many of us in the community uh understanding that road map for this calendar year I think is of the utmost importance for many of us uh however it uh shapes out uh there already is some language in today's agenda that speaks to a continuation of the building uh process uh so all I ask at this meeting uh for this newly seated board uh is to uh hopefully live up to the Mandate of transparency to the community uh to give us a road map of things to come and not just on a peace meal month-by-month basis just before the board is to meet uh but to give us a trajectory so that we can react to the changes so that we can potentially assist with those changes uh I think that's essentially what many of
033us are looking for uh so again I appreciate everyone's time tonight thank you thank you anyone else from the public wishing to speak Doug excuse me Doug PO for tamarak Road have to excuse my voice there's something going on with it uh uh I do congratulate uh the newly elected president and vice president as well as the new board members Kathy Lang uh Patty Lang and Ken Chella and I do wish uh all the success that this board can find during this coming year you do have some tremendous challenges facing you uh but more specifically uh I was a little uh puzzled and you are dealing with this under the pre-referendum planning uh a little puzzled but when the second paragraph even though I know this has been mentioned in Prior board meetings uh where
034uh we're going to be seeking appraisals of properties uh that are located in municipalities uh other than uh Monroe Township uh and that's in terms of uh building referendum sites uh my comment is uh I seriously doubt that the uh the residents of Monroe Township would support building a school for our children which is not within the township itself itself so uh that's my comment and if someone cares to shed some light on why we would be looking at properties outside of the township for the Public's understanding of that uh then I think it would be appreciated thank you thank you Mr Po I'll let Mr borski answer that good evening Mr poy uh rest assured at the current time the board of education is not looking at any properties outside of Monroe Township that
035resolution is consistent with the statute with which authorizes such but there but there are no immediate um Parcels outside of the township that are being U pursued um as an update the there there is a piece of land in town that we uh talked about vaguely at the last building grounds Transportation committee meeting where uh there has been an expressed interest of sale by the owner and um the the parcel has a lot of facets meeting the board's needs so we are looking at that and we are still following the resolution that's in place which is um exploring the 65 acre piece of property as well we're also engaged with a land broker who is seeking properties uh in addition to Dr kak Dr alvic Mr T and I who have been driving around town
036and knocking on Farmers doors and exploring any parcel of land that would be suitable for the construction of a school and I can tell you with uh with a great sense of optimism that we believe we found one that seems very attractive at this time and we're aggressively pursuing it okay thank you is there anyone else from the public wishing to speak okay then at this time we will close public forum and we will go to number 12 on the agenda some organizational items a meeting dates be it resolved that the regular meetings of the Board of Education of the township of Monroe shall be held as per the previously submitted schedule at which time formal action may be taken we need a motion in a second motion Mr Ryback Mr arino is this in
037all in favor we could do do and all in favor okay um can I can I make a comment yes on 12 uh 12d the newspapers um it says be it resolved that the Board of Education designates the cranberry press or the home News Tribune um however I I did notice that when we do publicize it we do in both is that correct mam yes yes that's a good pickup Mrs armeno um the law requires that you um have a multitude of different announcements that have to go in the registered official newspaper board of education has always had to in the event that there's some kind of transmission error or printing error and it doesn't get printed we're still able to proceed with business okay so essentially the law only requires one but we're going
038with two MA which I would um highly recommend and I I know the governor is trying to get the um or pass well failed legislation I think in the house um in the assembly that uh was trying to prevent or uh the newspapers from being uh the official carriers or one of the official carriers of Public Notices I for one believe that there are still people who read the newspapers and I I would hope that we would be consistent with that and still uh publicize and both again um very often people see something in a newspaper that they wouldn't go online necessarily to see so I would I would ask that we all still um agree to that thank you you want to take uh we could do it all as a one consent roll
039call a through D oh okay so a meeting dates B policy be it resolved by the Board of Education of the township of Monroe that all policies of the previous board are hereby adopted until such time as the board decides to revise or otherwise alter policies C designation of banks or depositories be it resolved that the Board of Education designates the following Banks or depositories for school district funds the depository Trust Company state of New Jersey Cash management fund Provident Bank which provides most of the banking services and US Bank be it further resolved that the business administrator is authorized to establish accounts and wire transfer funds among the accounts as needed and approve the payments of bills between board meetings and D newspapers for legal advertisements be it resolved that the Board of Education
040designates the cranberry press and and or their home News Tribune both of which circulate in the school district as official newspapers for the legal advertisement and I think we already have a um Mr Ryback and miss armeno so are there any comments or questions other than Miss armeno seeing none we'll have a roll call Mrs armeno yes Mr Braverman yes Mr Chella yes Mrs Deo yes Mrs P Pano yes Mrs Lang yes Mrs Corino yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr Russo yes and Mr rutsky yes Adam board president motion passes thank you and we'll go to our student board members report okay so um just a few days before winter break started the science National Honor Society had its first uh stem alumni panel where they had uh students who have graduated from the high school
041in the uh past few years come back and talk about their experiences after graduation and uh just what it's been like to pursue stem careers in college and past college for some of them I think uh it was a really good experience and I hope they do continue it again cuz I think everybody Walked Away Learning something new and then for two things that are coming up later this week uh tomorrow the school's Deca chapter is going on their trip I think it's to Keen University but I'm not completely sure and then this Friday uh through Sunday is the model un conference so our school is sending I think 60 students to that trip and they've been preparing for it for a few weeks now and basically what they're going to do is simulate a
042un session about different uh topics depending on what committees committees they've been placed into and they'll be returning on Sunday from that that concludes my report thank you is there any questions for our student board member okay then we will go to the business administrator's report Mr bsky thank you madam board president and members of the mon Township Board of Education it is recommended that board action items a be approved by consent roll call and I I apologize for the revised agenda um Administration Dr kak Dr alvic and I um instituted a purchase order freeze this week where we projected that we are going to free up uh approximately a million dollars in this year's budget from non-essential spending um which the philosophy has always been if it hasn't been spent and and ordered now
043in the school uh calendar process that it's probably not essential um this is not pertaining to any contractual obligations but um we wish to transfer that million dollars into capital reserve where we have a balance of $975,000 currently that would give the board approximately $2 million to use to uh negotiate the procurement of land um or to use it as an installment on the bond referendum process so essentially that that that amount of monies would be used from savings from the budget in lie of borrowing from the sale of municipal bonds over a 30-year period at a much higher expense to the taxpayers it was not permitted and authorized by the county office yet it the window for that will open up during the month of June even though we have had permission in the
044past other than the month of June and this certainly uh had a a good need and a reason rationale for that but in any event it was denied we are seeking other alternative financing means and the Board of Education will be apprised of that um um as this comes more into view so right now we only have one agenda item and it is for appraisals on the property that I referred to before and any other properties that may come uh to our attention so that we could ex expeditiously um on any prospects it also authorizes the use of Environmental Services and the board's architect of record and um an environmental uh group I'm sorry the Engineering Group to determine the feasibility of these prospective sites for the hosting of a school building um the cost
045for such services will be aggressively monitored by the business office and the administration so that they're reasonable and consistent with the purpose and we will report everything to the board for full um transparency and done disclosure so um before you is board action items a it needs a motion in a second second Ryback and Mrs Deo any comments or questions Mr cherella I have a a few comments and and maybe some questions also this seems to me to be kind of open-ended with the i' I I'm not used to seeing an agreement like this where it's so open-ended where you have someone being hired in um in this case uh you know one of which is a uh an engineer to do site work or plans or make plans and look at things and it
046kind of can go on forever it seems to me you know as long as we want wanted it to go on it would be open-ended and I think that an agreement that we' have would have to be more would would would have to be in my I would like to see it be more limiting anyway the other thing is I think that the one thing that's missing that I would like to see here is that we have an engineer uh draw up plans to use the property that we currently own so we have we have a number of parcels that we own we have H we have schools that we could add on to we have a lot of way ways that we could save money for the taxpayers while still alleviating the crowding and
047doing the things that we need to do to get space for our kids and this I think is giving us more of an opportunity just to buy more land and and and and look at land and do things like that when I think we really do have the ability to build on what we have but we're not even drawing out plans to look at that which would really be where the cost savings are um I don't you know we go out and we look for land we buy land or we spend 20 or $30,000 more than we've already spent you know to look at this other land now and go through uh the process and then decide that that might not be right or the price might be too high and then finally I think
048what we're going to end up doing is getting around to either saying okay we're going to accept the original deal with Toll Brothers or we're going to say all right let's see if we could build on the land that we already have and and what at what cost are the taxpayers so that's number one the other thing is that I think we also have to look at what we're going to do in the short term so I know that that's not part of what a is tonight but we have to look at what we're going to do in the short term to alleviate the overcrowding and I think that as much as we don't want to talk about it or look at it trailers are going to be a necessity and they're going to be
049a necessity rather soon so uh the the other the other the last thing that I have with regards to this is that I know we don't need an RFP for this but I think at this point it might be nice to have because an open-ended contract uh with rates and things like that that can kind of go on forever if we limit it more maybe we could get uh bids and we can we could uh find companies who would be willing to do this and it might be this company but who might be willing to do this at a cost for us that is uh less than what this is that's just my you know my opinion Madam sure thank you Mr chair I appreciate those comments i' just like to address a few of
050them as they come into the the business function um all of the professionals here without the authority of the appraisal on the property have been previously approved as um Professionals of record architect of record engineer of record with the same rate schedule there was some concern about whether the board or Administration can use those professionals beyond the broker of record to go into areas such as evaluating a uh parcel of land to see if it's feasible for school um construction so out of an effort to be uh more transparent than maybe need be we put it on the agenda again so it's just fully disclosed to the board members and the public um how we are using these professionals and what we are paying for them as I mentioned um you know this will be
051aggressively monitored by management here and uh this is money well spent in my opinion because you know God forbid a mistake is made in a property is misevaluated in the early stages it could waste time and expense and this will clearly give us a professional's opinion as to whether we should proceed or not and I mentioned the word professional with emphasis because these folks architect of record um engineer of record have licenses issued by the state and they're exempt from the bidding process um under the professional appointment exemption we still do our due diligence in the business office and um and do uh competitive quoting and um at Roundtable meetings in the county we collect information on attorney rates and engineer rates to make sure that anything we recommend to the board is consistent with
052the best practices and uh Mr T Dr alvic Dr kak and I believe that these um all for you on this resolution tonight are um we are also simultaneously and I failed to mention this before working with the architect aggressively for additions to existing facilities as well as the exploration of existing land that is in the district's portfolio unfortunately a lot of the land that's in our portfolio is either wet or or um not large enough to host a school um and we've looked we've looked aggressively at that first that would be the prudent thing to do before going out and seeking uh other land trailers um before we began the budget philosophy process this year Dr kov Dr kak Dr alvic and I met with all of the principles to to address um enrollment
053in their schools we provided them with projections of enrollment for next year we went over the number of class um uh settings in each school um class sessions and um all of the principles have felt and expressed to us as the leaders of their buildings individually that there was no need for trailers in the 1718 budget however there is a strong anticipation that that will not last into 1819 and we are planning for that already because the trailer leas payments must be included within the cap and and being that we are close to cap or will be at cap if you add a couple hundred, of trailer payments that's going to be in lie of programs and services already offered so something's going to have to be eliminated to add these trailer costs and lease
054payments and um I can also say with knowledge that the architect of record the engineer of record all were previously engaged and and retained through an RFP process um bringing Hof Environmental Services um Mr T and I recently did an RFP for that and Edwards engineering uh was a recent RFP when we did oak tree school and we have a very favorable history and rating with that vendor thank you Dr kak would like to add to that yeah I would Mr Gorski you mentioned a lot of valuable points there you didn't leave me many uh other things to mention but uh St Al good points um there there's been a lot of things that we've been involved in as Mr Gorski has stated and one of the things that Mr Gorski did not mention is
055the 65 acres that the township uh has offered to us and I know it has to go through Toll Brothers and all that even if that land doesn't prove to be suitable at this time our demographer uh our report from the demographer on a 20 to 25 year basis shows that the growth will continue in this Township we can't go out for a referendum on a prediction Beyond five or even 10 years but we did mention that we've we've brought it up to the board at different times that the projection is that there will be continued growth so that land if not usable at this time it would be very valuable for us for the school district to be able to hold on to that land for future use it seems that a lot of
056the growth is in the southern part of town and some of the future developments that aren't even haven't even begun yet are down in that area so that was part of the thought that it wouldn't be money wasted that we would look at it and see if that land was viable and if so what could we do to hold on to that um the other piece of land that Mr Gorski referred to um you know we're looking at that and as Mr Gorski also said the our existing buildings uh I think appor is the is the probably you know the the the notable building uh We've looked at that several different ways uh for what we could do including if we had to do something in the at if we built behind it would be
057one situation we might not have enough room to do that so if we had to uh level that building we would have to move the students and then that would look you know we'd have to look at trailers to how students in the meantime so they're all things that are under consideration as I think you're you're very well aware we started with the student growth advisory committee you know a year ago and we've explored so many different options and we're continually looking until we we we feel like we're close to having some finality at least for this coming year to what we need to do we we really feel that we're very close um but until we're there you know we want to make sure that we explore everything and we want to look at
058both shortterm and long term CL thank you Mr Mino uh yes um well first of all I I just like like to sort of point out that customarily and traditionally on a reorganization meeting uh substantive resolutions like this are really not brought forward and I understand the urgency of things and I was hoping that perhaps we could have gotten a special meeting to discuss this in particular before uh the January 25th meeting so within the next week or so and I know that the public has clamored for specific meeting just to discuss these kinds of things so I was wondering if the board president would consider um and I'm not I'm asking you to table this and call for a special meeting to discuss this resolution and I know there's a sense of urgency I
059think if we postpone it for just one week and then put this all on the table and invite the public specifically for this so they understand what's going on um that would be my thought and again because uh people might not come out for reorganization meetings because they're generally housekeeping and just customarily not substantive about that Mr Gorski thank you Mrs armeno you know at the last building grounds Transportation committee meeting uh there was a clear message sent to Administration that there is an immediate sense of urgency with this building project uh with emphasis and um as such and as I mentioned before we we've identified um one very attractive piece of property in town that we would like to move on uh we have U uh an acknowledgement from the owner that they would
060like to sell and enter into negotiations we had an invitation to do an appraisal on the property and an invitation to use our professionals to evaluate the property for its suitability for a school uh these are all very time times sensitive issues and being that we don't have a committee in place yet because they've all been disbanded um and because I I think I gave the proper due diligence to this uh with communication ation to the board members to make an informed vote on the matter we really need the latitude to move ahead with the exploration of this and perhaps other pieces of land and other opportunities that may become available a special board meeting at this time um in my opinion and as as I mentioned in the email to you earlier would not
061necessarily be warranted because it would just be asking the board in a public session can Administration have permission to go ahead and do an appraisal on the property and use professionals at a reasonable amount of funds to determine if it's suitable to to explore for a school building process it is not at all entering to negotiations for the price of it it is not at all committing funds for the purchase of it it is simply part of the initial exploration process okay you you also mentioned that it was the board president's decision so I'm asking board president any any board member can make a motion to do anything if you want to make a motion to table it you can table it you C you can do that okay um I I yes I would
062like to T make a motion to table this and call for a uh well we'll table this call for a special meeting within the next week or so is there a second I'll second second by Mr cherel is there any um comments Mr tiella okay Mr tiella any uh comments questions discussion um Madam as it's a priority motion there there's no discussion on that it just goes right to a roll call to table oh Mrs armeno yes Mr Braverman no Mr cherella yes Mrs Deo no Mrs K Pano no Mrs Lang no Mrs Keno yes Mr Rybeck no Mr Russo no Mr rutsky no motion to table has not passed the business administrators board action item a is back on the floor can I make another comment yes you can okay since it's not uh
063passing I would like to just comment on the first paragraph that the recommendation uh to authorize uh Appraisal Services obtained will my objection to this is that Appraisal Services don't really give us any indication unless they're different here uh generally do not give any indication of whether the land is suitable for engineering issues or anything uh an engine most Appraisal Services say that they don't do any hazardous um they don't do any impact studies they don't do uh they don't know if there's any hazardous uh things on the land uh so the appraisal is just going to give you evaluation but to me without uh we we don't seem to have an option to purchase any of these things just to do an appraisal seems to me to um not be necessary I think the
064other parts of the I would agree to the other parts of the resolution but to just to go out and do appraisals on properties I really don't see the value of that so I'd like that explained as to why that that is a necessity I mean after we have an intent to purchase or an option to buy if we move forward after we do engineering studies that's one thing but to just have an appraisal on a property is just giving the homeowner uh without any agreement from them or any any responsibility on their part to us um to me I I don't see that as in the best interest of the district to spend that money in particular um I I requested some quotes for appraisals and the fees came in in the 4,000 to
065uh believe the $5,500 range well under the quote threshold where the board has considered that material or not to take to committee that's been the precedent uh with that kind of spending latitude in the past so if I was to follow that I wouldn't even need that as part of the resolution I could just engage in an appraisal service because of the immaterial cost I I I beg to diff disagree with you uh with the appreciation of the value assessment at this time because I think when you're contemplating different pieces of property as we are a value is an essential part of the deliberation and I believe that the the public and the board certainly would be interested in in knowing how much is that piece of land going to cost before we engage um
066professionals to commit funds to determine its feasibility and explore it further if it's out of our price range it's best to know that UPF front well first of all I don't think the public the open public meetings act does say that negotiations for land would be done in close session so the public wouldn't know about that unless we were negotiating specifically for a piece of land and I don't think it's prudent again to do an appraisal on a property uh because that's all you're going to get is a land evaluation if the if the property is very well suited to a school I think that's we're going to move ahead ba on that basis because we do have a future need and we do have to put more land into our portfolio so like I
067said doing an evaluation based on the environmental aspects on the engineering aspects that makes sense to me but to I I I think just because the business administration or the administration is able to spend the money I don't think it's necessarily prudent if if there's no if there's nothing we gain by that until the land is UN determined suitable for building just just a point of clarification this is not entering into a negotiation this is simply appraising the value of the property so that we have the general parameters of how much it costs because that will be an integral part of of this as it progresses if it should progress and for the cost associated with it it's going to have to be determined at some time um and it's good information and money well
068spent to the board in my opinion Mr am I right to that in my understanding oh sorry well she has it am I right in my understanding Jill could you give her the microphone sorry Jill thanks am I right in my understanding that the two piece the property that you're um that you knocked on doors and located it's not for sale so there is no they don't have a price for that or the the homeowners they don't have a value for the Le so we need to have the information am I right in understanding that we need to have that information so that we can make educated become educated consumers into participating in that the the purchase of the property Madam uh that is absolutely correct um Mr T and I identified this property initially
069from Google Maps and we looked at pieces of land throughout this entire Township and um this was one that was in a very good location and we uh we approached the owner and um asked them if they would be interested in exploring a a sale with the Board of Ed um uh performing an appraisal at our expense and um at at our expense also using our Engineers determine if it's suitable for our needs uh the the the person was interested so to your point we had no basis no estimate of value at all um into this property and um you know whether I buy a piece of equipment here at the district like a snow plow truck um I I certainly want to know the value of it um before I would ever do a
070purchase order Mr Ryback and by the way I could never do a purchase order for a piece of land I just want to be clear on that that would require a board resolution gu I have a question from Mr Gorski um certainly I'm not a realtor but Mr amino's um questioning brought a question to my mind if we are going to go and have an appraisal done on a piece of property um implicit in that appraisal isn't it build whether it's U suitable for building or not I mean if it's a very low appr appraisal I think maybe there's something wrong if it's very high it might say that uh well it's very pristine or something I mean I would think that there's some kind of uh implied um meaning in there as to the
071buildability of a piece of property in an appraisal madam um and I I'm wrong I I don't I don't mean to you know be fous but if I was putting up a colonial on on a on a one acre lot certainly I might be able to to come to that conclusion but when you're talking about a uh a school facility the size of potentially a middle school and you're dealing with the complexities of the Department of Education with testing of land and and soil samples and and uh plethora of tests on the land before it's ever determined suitable for a school the Wetland study um the feasibility study that also involves the demographer to make sure that the square footage of the proposed facility can house the projected number of unhoused students that we have
072it be go it it truly goes beyond the sophistication of administration at that point when we would need the professionals and it would go beyond just an appraisal value of the property certainly aware of that I just meant as a just as a to get a feeling for the the worth of the property for future building would the appraisal give us some indication on of that uh the certainly not an exact one of course not the appraisal would give you uh the approximate appraised value of the property and that would be a starting point for negotiations at some point but before that it would be a tool uh for the Board of Education to determine if this fits into your proposed project size and cost because we have discussed at at the committee level level
073and an administrative level the cost parameters of what we feel we can engage into for a successful referendum land is certainly a component of that and the more information we have as a board on on everything that we have on every piece of property the better decision we're going to be able to make for the the public so I think it's important to to have all this information Miss D um so the so the process you've bought land before right um since I've been the business administrator um I have not procured land because oak tree was not procured it was a u um a transfer donation whatever you want to call it okay and the high school was a non-procurement is there a statute that requires what must be done first when you are buying
074land we talked today with our bond counsel our board attorney about the procurement of land about all um available statutory means to procure land financially and we also have done research into Department of Education approval process for land as part of a referendum and um certainly the Environmental um the engineer would be required I do not believe that an appraisal of the property would be uh required by the Department of Education um they could because they're authorizing borrowing on that so they may want to know that along the way I don't have specific knowledge about that but again it's it's an essential tool in my opinion to the board of aded as part of the deliberate process of choosing should we pursue this land are there better options on the table if yeah if I
075could Mr May uh like Mr gorsy we we were looking at a lot of different uh with Mary Smith and looking at statutes and and the law when we reached out to the county office and the state and various other offices and um I can't say with certainty so I would have to check but I I'm pretty sure that an appraisal was indicated in statute that that would would have to occur now the timeline of it I to be honest with you I really can't answer that but I'm I'm almost positive were looking at 6A and looking at all the different things that we had that appra an appraisal was mentioned in there thank you madam to that point we did the board of education did procure an appraisal on Oak Tree and that uh
076land was not purchased it was transferred or donated so I believe Dr kak is correct there there is probably a requirement that you get an appraisal at some point in the process Mr Min yeah I'm not objecting to the appraisal per se I'm objecting to the timing of the appraisal if we don't don't have any concession or uh option or agreement from a land owner go to me just getting the appraisal is a waste of the money before we do uh a a construction or an engineering thing if we have permission from the uh owner to to either take to have an option or a first right to purchase the property if all of our other contingencies are met I don't have a problem with that but to just go out to different land parcels
077say we're going to do appraisals 5,000 here 2500 here it's not a lot of money and you certainly can do it without our permission apparently but I don't think it's prudent to do it um unless we have some kind of agreement not even a guarantee some kind of an agreement with the landowner that if we choose to proceed after the appraisal that we have an option to do so if we get an appraisal and land owner goes holy mackerel that's twice as much as I thought I was going to get so may maybe I'll just put it on the open market or maybe you know I I'll just use this as a base and I'll try to get other buyers I want to protect the district and and try to do it again I have
078no objection to the appraisal I have no objection to the engineering I I have an objection to the timing of why the appraisal is necessary if we don't have any kind of agreement or understanding or intent from a land owner that's it's just tweaking the language would satisfy and I guess conversely it could be that the land owner feels that the property is worth much more than what the appraisal would tell us right too so but neither is important unless it works for us until the land is feasible for building and construction and it is clean of any hazardous substances or toxins or anything like that to me the the value of it is is really not quite material yet but that I I will I will be satisfied with whatever the vote is any
079other comments or questions I do Mr Gorski did you say that there there was already a study done on the existing land and we could not build on the existing land for whatever reason wet land things like that I be your pardon because there was wet land wet lands designations and things like that is that yes we've worked uh we've worked extensively with our architect on exploring the portfolio of land that the district owns uh we have different pieces all over we have a piece in back of mil Lake we have a piece in back of oak tree there's a piece associated with the Applegarth property uh there's a piece associated with the middle school that one in particular is very wet that's been brought up here and talked about before um there was a
080previous exploration of that property and it was abandoned because of the wetlands there either the pieces are too small or they're wet but all of our inventory that we've discussed with our um architect has been not suitable um to recommend to explore for uh Construction of a school yeah with that being said though I mean Applegarth is still U there's areas there there are areas that are I believe there are some areas back there that are wet but that land would still be usable and um Brookside I believe uh we could add on to Brookside I think we've mentioned that before but mil Lake and um uh well we didn't really look Woodland's kind of closed in uh we don't really have the growth there but was definitely mil Lake and I think I I
081believe the EPA was involved as well some of the information came from them of uh some of the existing information that they take from satellite shots that show uh which areas are wet Madam yes uh whereas that's true what we're looking for here is um we are going to be very underserved with an addition to a building when we're looking at up to 2500 onh housee students in the next 5 years we have a th000 now we're projected to have another 15 we need something of the magnitude of a new Middle School Andor a new Elementary School Andor in addition to the high school in order to satisfy our responsibility to house the the number of students and and and in addition to Applegarth without a complete tear down of the building it appears uh
082would be unsatisfactory in that regard so yes we certainly went through our inventory first um but we did not find anything satisfactory to that magnitude Mr Russo so yeah regarding the land I think it was two meetings ago I suggested put posting something on the website that the district was interested in land and I guess that didn't wasn't done but now I see that you hired um professional land um company search company is that right Madam yes we've uh We've utilized the services of Realtors with land uh expertise and as I mentioned at the last meeting there is no expense to the board for those Services as the commission comes from the seller okay but you also now have a number of Administrators yourself included looking for land so you guys are working doing the
083job that they would be doing or should be doing very aggressively it's it's all hands on deck right now to try to solve our and how many administrators do you have looking for land playing playing realtor um I would say uh certainly Mr T has been the front runner of that Dr alvic Dr kak and myself okay so it's keeping you guys quite busy then who would be doing what you guys are supposed to be doing well we we're not out running around all all the time I mean if there was something of interest there was maybe twice that I got in a car and drove out to get a visual because it helps you know I looked at Google Maps I looked at visuals but it's not every single day I mean there's plent
084plenty of other things that are keeping us busy uh with that okay the the land search company when they find land do they do an appraisal is like like we want to do no not automatically no they don't so why would we do the appraisal because we have one very attractive parcel of land that's going to be number one on the agenda of bg& as soon as that committee reconvenes uh it suits all of our needs uh it has many facets are very attractive to the board of ed unlike other properties that we've explored um it's in a a reasonable price range for the referendum scope project that we were talking about and and we would like to know that information because absent that I'm certain that would come up at committee I am certain
085that would come up at the board meeting and for a four to $5,000 expense it's money well spent that would be part of this requirement anyway well it seems like the professional company is not coming through with anything and you guys are being more proactive and really trying to do the job that you hired Bas not hired through payment but hired to do you know I I I bought a house to a realtor in the past and they certainly did not do an appraisal on the property um I had to as the buyer and I had to do so for the mortgage company uh we would have to do so for the Department of Education it would not be the obligation of the realtor land broker to do uh an appraisal and would it be
086possible to look at uh any of the inventory in the town's open space since taxpayers already owned that land it's fully paid for has it been done before um has it been done before with open space yeah this was open space the answer the answer to that is yes but that is a very difficult process that the board has not um exp indicated they want to go into in fact I've heard to the contrary very time consuming okay well we did it here so we know that we know the pathway there was several years of litigation that followed it was a very difficult Road and uh what about looking at and this just another current space we have in the school uh have there been any professional companies that look at the way work is
087done and how can be utilized more efficiently Madam yes that has been also looked at um not only are we looking for the main pieces of the puzzle which would be a parcel of land enough for middle school elementary school as I mentioned before but we're looking at additions to our existing facilities um we're also looking at more efficient use of space I shouldn't say more efficient because like let's take this Media Center for example uh I believe this this space is being used efficiently and certainly Mr Goodall would testify to that but in emergency situation where you have unhoused students uh you would consider perhaps using a media center and converting it to classrooms on a tempor every basis so yes we have explored every option we have really two summers ago the middle
088school we converted uh several spaces within the Middle School to extra classroom space this year in this building the room back there has been converted so we've looked at every um available space that we have we we've worked the the um redist rting that occurred a couple years ago really helped with the elementary schools with the class sizes we're keeping a very close watch on the Elementary class sizes we are looking at we're exploring things to do with the Middle School to um help with the class sizes there and the high school every possible space that we can uh this room is certainly utilized a lot uh both during and and after school uh but we're also looking at any available space uh in this building as well how about um hasn't been considered to
089convert some of the administrative offices into um common areas of work because today you know the way people work is much different than years ago although we still have the office we still have the desk phone we still have the computer many can work from laptops so in the organization I worked for um we we were forced to utilize the space more efficiently and we redesigned all the off space to open space so you share resources secretaries are pulled together administrators are pulled together in an open space and offices are used for other things like classrooms I there are building codes that that the the where the administrative offices are right now um as much as I would love to give up the leaking uh areas or or other things in that uh there would
090be a lot that would have to be done to that building to bring it up to code to bring any students into that building in addition then you add on the transportation cost I mean even here like in high school if you needed extra space uh and I'll just throw this out there like you have offices where principal sit I think we're getting off the topic of this resolution it's consideration of space yeah I think that's a different resolution but so if there's any comments on this resolution um any other comments questions then we need to take a roll call thank you one more how many appraisals are we looking at on this are we looking at an appraisal for one specific property or two specific or you just looking for a broad uh ability
091to just do many appraisals Madam once again uh this this resolution authorizes Administration to have the FL flexibility to explore these properties pursuant to the board's goal of having a referendum and exploring all viable options for such um the appraisals the use of professionals involved with this in this case are intended for this one particular uh parcel of land however the the resolution as I mentioned in the email before was um intended by Dr kak to be broad enough so that if another opportunity uh showed itself in the near future we wouldn't have to wait for a board meeting or call a special board meeting in order to have the authority to explore uh the feasibility of the land for presentation to the board's committee um for building project so the intent is for one
092parcel of land one consideration with this but um this this does give the uh Administration the authority to move on something else should it show itself uh we are in charge of $120 million budget every year and um the the type of EXP expenditures that you're talking about here are immaterial to this total project cost which could be anywhere in the range of 100 to $150 million and again the intelligence gained from having these Services performed is money well spent and will serve this board very well in determining and making a smart decision into which which direction to go okay at this time we'll have a roll call Mrs armeno um again with my objection to the appraisals however if we do it prudently and we are apprised of the appraisals as they go on
093uh for expedience sake I'll vote Yes Mr Braverman yes Mr Chella no Mrs Deo yes Mrs Co Pono yes Mrs Lang yes Mrs Keno yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr Russo yes Mr bretzky is ineligible Madame board president motion passes and um I I would like to thank the board for the authority to allow Administration to move freely into the exploration of these properties uh we promis to do such with um um the concern about limited board resources in mind and uh the efficiency of of what we're doing the the the perfect audit that you saw last time hopefully demonstrates uh that we've earned that respect and uh we will show that in these engagements thank you okay at this time we'll go to the board president's report and I'm going to try to keep this
094very short um one the committee preference sheets for the committee lists and what you would like to be what committees you'd like to sit on will be handed out on Friday with the confidential really shouldn't take you more than 10 minutes of your time to look through it and decide what you'd like to um sit on which committees and if I can get them by Monday day then I could start to put the Committees together and I know B&T is one is that's very important that we start moving so hopefully we can have some committees formed by next week and then get those moving um I I I know that we have in the past talked about having hard copies versus copies of the agenda on the computer so I think we should take a
095a survey as to how many of the board members want a hard copy of the agenda versus how many are going to be using the laptops because I don't see laptops being utilized anymore so does everybody still want a hard copy of Mr rutsky doesn't I don't know is her Min I would I would like it for the uh Friday before the board meeting with all of the paperwork yes because I do make notes on that uh other than that the so you want to copy backup material too yeah the confidentials I don't have a a problem with reading online okay Miss Gino of the agenda or everything everything Mr Russo uh same yeah hard Mr everything for you Mr Chella I can do mine online you could do yours online Mr Ryback um I
096got used to doing it online I find that um it's it's a fast update because sometimes things change and you have it on a Friday might Tuesday could be or Monday could be right could be changed I'm always looking online any okay Mr Mayo of everything or just the agenda of everything are you writing this down yes I'm and Mrs Lang hard copies please hard copies and I just need the agenda okay okay um I know that we talked about there was people from the public who talked and Miss armeno talked about a a special board meeting just on the referendum that is something that I think that we need to do um we'll be looking at once we get more information and we'll be able to give more to the public we can have
097a a Q&A on just what's happening with the referendum with the land what where we stand and things like that so I hope to do that in the future so um that concludes the board president's report and we'll go to Other Board business is there any member of the board who has Mr Chella thank you well congratulations so I just want to officially congratulate you but um I'm going to ask you to please if you could uh when you form the Committees to look at forming a committee that will be tasked with getting us more state aid and I'm not talking about a letterwriting campaign or some feel-good thing that will make everybody feel good and and then we walk away and nothing happens or you know we sit we sit around with our uh
098legislators and they tell us how how they're going to help us out and then when push comes to sh of they get reelected we don't hear from them again what we need is a committee that's going to be tasked with getting us that getting us more money um reaching out to uh local politicians we we're in a really good position this year because we have a a race we're going to have a new governor and we're going to have new state legislators there's a lot of people that are up for reelection this coming November and I think it's it's it puts us in a good place to be able to ask them what they're going to do with uh with funding and with things like funding the funding formula if we could just get a
099new governor uh or the one of the candidates or both of the candidates or however many candidates will be sign on to just funding the funding formula that would mean $10 million for our district that's nearly 10% of our budget and that would be relief you know to our taxpayers um I I think we owe it to our taxpayers but we have to take this fight on and um you know if if we can't do it as a board through with the committee process then then we're going to have to do it outside of the board as as uh citizens of the township because I believe it it has to be done um I think there's an opportunity to contact other districts get those districts to sign on uh to getting to a petition to
100get a funding form get the funding formula funded and make that step one and I think there are 200 districts we're number 25 of the least funded districts in the State uh we're number 25 but there are 200 other districts that are in in similar situations that we are and if we look at those other Factor groups and we align with those group those uh those districts I think that we have an opportunity to do something that's never been done before and put pressure on politicians and make them see the light because if 200 districts stand up and sign off and say we want to be funded then they're going to have to find funding or they're going to lose their jobs and that's what we have to tell these people is that the the
101only thing that they understand that politicians understand is losing you know that if they think they're going to lose an election then they're going to act if they're if their uh money comes from developers and if their money comes from special interests then that's who they're going to cater to but if the voters stand up and the voters speak up and the voters demand what what what they what they're owed I think they'll take note if they if there's enough fear put you know put into the put into them by having a a mass movement so with all that being said I think uh I'm asking you to to think about that committee the other thing that I I think we need to do is as a town Democrats Republicans Independents is that we all
102need to come together for this fight because this is not a fight an ideological fight this is a fight between us to get what we need for our taxpayers to be able to survive here and and to maintain our quality of life or just having this whole thing Blow Away uh our our uh our district keeps growing there's no resolve to stop that growth and we're putting we're being put in a position where we have to fund that and fund you know fund those students either way they need to they have a right to be educated we need to educate them but I think we also have a right to fight and to ask our elected officials to do the right thing so thank okay I will look into that anyone else Mr Deo um
103I know transparency is a big transparency is a big issue with this board and we try to be as transparent as possible so I went to the state Bo of Ed meeting today and it was a very crowded meeting and it's in a very small room we were not allowed in the room the only people allowed in the room were the presenters and we were put in another room with a video screen and it wasn't even a live video screen it was an audio with whoever was presenting their slides and the audio was awful and we didn't even know which state board members were attending end ing that meeting and I have to say it was the most untransparent meeting I've ever been to going to the State Board of Ed and it was really
104a disgrace um I was completely disappointed you you could barely understand what half of the presenters were saying and not even to have a live video screen was just awful and they don't even put their meetings up afterwards it was it was really bad I was hugely disappointed and ironically they had a resolution in honor of school board members and school board members could not attend the state's board ofed meeting so we are we try hard and I think we are doing well with that thank you Mr Rybeck Dr kosak I hope I'm not going to be stealing some Thunder From You by doing this but I'd like to make mention of the meeting that you and I both attended just a few weeks ago actually uh in Franklin Township and it was concerning Charter
105schools and I know that's that was a concern for this board of education uh just a few months ago also um what we learned really was that um in this state uh they look one way for public schools and another way for Charter Schools meaning that the charter schools are supposed to serve just a certain geographical area but they don't they draw from outside that geographical area even though they're not supposed to do so and the uh State Board of Ed State education Department looks the other way they also have different requirements for hiring both teachers and administrators our teachers have to meet certain certifications theirs don't our administrators have to meet certain certification theirs don't um as far as uh requirements for students I think that's different also they seem to take um the
106top tier students and uh that leads to segregation and um that's that's uh something that's unacceptable to everyone uh just some things we have to think about because this is also Mr cherella spoke very eloquently about a very serious problem um Mr Mayo talked about I guess a lack of transparency but I also look at it as a lack of respect uh toward toward board members here but we also have another serious issue we have an issue where there is in my opinion and I'm speaking just for myself now uh um a move to do to do away with public education and we need to look at this it's a a long-term fight and um we have to come up on top because uh public education is really a a foundation in this in this
107country thank you thank you anyone else no no okay moving on we have a Clos session session resolution be it resolved that the Board of Education of the township of Monroe here moves to go into closed session in accordance with the Sunshine Law chapter 231 of the public laws of 1975 njsa 10 colum 4-6 through 10 colum 4-21 to discuss the following subjects one receive attorney advice regarding the code of ethics for school board members to an Hib incident following Clos session action action may be taken the discussion conducted in closed session can be discussed disclosed to the public at such time as a need for confidentiality no longer exists I need a motion in a second Miss AR Mr retsky all in favor opposed and do we have an idea how long this is
108going to take 15 to 20 minutes okay about 20 minutes we'll be in close session and when we come out there will be no other further U public forum is from a friend it was the cheapest Corvette we probably ever get at this time the board will move back into public session and our next spe we um we eliminated this second and third public session public forum so our next scheduled Board of Education meeting will be Wednesday January 25th 2017 at 5:00 at the mon tanip high school and at 5:00 the board will have training on data management system and I'm assuming that we will have a regular meeting starting at 7:00 so motion to journ second Ryback Miss Armenia all in favor I opposed thank you meeting is adjourned