CorpusRecord 132977

Monroe Township Board of Education 04.26.17 Regular Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Monroe Township School District
Date
2025-02-13
Location
Middlesex County, NJ
Material
Transcript
Extent
23,365 words · about 130 min
Collected
2026-06-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001I just need your sign second one i50 good evening she's very nice she didn't interview the Monroe Township Board of Education will come to order please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance pledge allegiance to the flag flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all Mr Gorski may we please have a roll call certainly Mrs armeno Mr Braverman here Mr cherella here Mrs Deo here Mrs Lang here Mrs Ino Mr Rybeck here Mr Russo here Mr rutsky here Mrs kapano here Madame board president you have a quarum present this evening well before we move on to the the rest of the agenda I have to do that one quick thing before we do that in accordance with the

002provisions of the New Jersey open public meeting meetings of law the Monroe Township Board of Education has caused notice of this meeting to be published by having the date time and place thereof posted April 20th 2017 at all schools the home News Tribune cranberry press and filed with the clerk of the municipality thank you so before we move to the rest of the agenda you might notice some new attire on our board members and this is because we want our community to know that we are behind them in our Quest for fair funding from the state and that we will not be giving up this fight until we get everything that we deserve in Montreal so moment um Mr rety would you like to introduce your colleague from Jamesburg so absolutely so in the audience

003tonight so for those of you who don't know I'm the Jamesburg the Jamesburg Board of Ed representative to the Monroe board and so in the audience tonight is our president from the Jamesburg Board of Ed who came to uh meet everybody and and see how a Monroe meeting went Elliot where'd you go there he is [Applause] Elliot thank you for coming tonight so at this time we'll go to number five on the agenda the approval of minutes for the public Board of Education meeting of February 15 2017 move second Mr Ryback U Mr tiella and Mr Ryback are there any additions or corrections to the minutes okay seeing none all in favor I I opposed abstentions or recusals Mr Mr Braverman and Mr Russo both abstaining and the approval of the minutes for the closed

004session meeting of February 15 2017 second Mr Ryback Mr Chella again any additions or corrections to the minutes okay all in favor I opposed abstentions Mr Braverman Mr Russo are you abstaining I was there oh you were there for the closed session oh no not the Clos session I was I thought you said the 15th of uh February the Clos section of the 15th were you there were you there for the meeting on the 15th so you didn't but I don't know if I had to recused myself from that meeting well part of it no no so you were at the 15th and you're recusing from the closed session okay thank you so we're going to we're going to move around the agenda a little bit and we're going to be presenting our students with

005some certificates and Awards this evening so I will turn this over to Dr KAC would you like to come up to the front the should have been March something good evening everyone it gives me well first of all I'm Dr Michael kak to superintendent just so you know who I am uh it gives me great pleasure to have this many people out at a at one of our board meetings and for a very special reason and that reason is that we chose tonight to continue our recognition that we began last year of outstanding student achievement now you have to understand with 6600 students we could probably have invited every single student in this District to be recognized because all of our students perform well academically of course behaviorally and socially and they're all outstanding in

006their own right however we don't have room for everybody here so we did limitate and we did set some criteria and that criteria is recognition at the county state or national level or an achievement that the committee felt was appropriate to be recognized so with that we're going to have some individual students and some students who are part of a larger group they're separated by their if they're in a group they're separated by the group and just as a matter of um protocol of how we're going to do this we will be calling the students up individually we have a certificate for each of the students if a student's in a larger group we will ask the students to stand over to the side until all those students from that group are brought up and

007at that point we're going to take a quick five seconds to take a a picture so we'll let you know when you come up if you're part of a group we'll just ask you to stand over to the side if it's an individual student that's being recognized for his or her individual achievement then when we call the student up we'll hand them the certificate and we'll ask them to um join us in a picture okay and at the end we will have all the students I will ask all the students to come up and we're going toy try to fit all 6,000 no I'm only kidding all 80 students uh into a picture and uh we may have to get chairs some of these kids get pretty tall but uh we'll bring them all up

008at the very end so if you could uh after you get up if you're one of the first students called up if I could uh respectfully ask that you wait until the end so that we can get a group picture that would be great okay uh our first group of students are Elementary stud students and with that I know Miss moli is here our principal of mil Lake school and I think she's working her way through the crowd she likes to make an entrance please give Miss mcdy a round of [Applause] applause and uh Miss MCD would you like to tell the audience just uh briefly um what this why these students are being recognized yes absolutely first and foremost congratulations to all of our students we're a very lucky District to have such a

009robust group of students who have so many for in quality so congratulations to every student that's here tonight as far as mil Lake goes we had third grade tag students who participated in the New Jersey law association Mock Trial Competition they scored first place and I just want you to know what it entailed for them to do this they had presented a case under the guidance of dong Graziano and they had to give a case to real jurors a real judge and they scored first place boys and girls I couldn't be more happy to be your principal so with that being said we're going to call our students up first we have Tyler [Applause] bacon Christina latash [Applause] Delila [Applause] updale sayona [Applause] Patel and Alicia chowder [Applause] a big round of applause for our

010third grade tag students at M Lake School I also just before we take the picture uh I would like to also say that joining me up here of course is our board president miss Kathy kapovich and our assistant superintendent of schools Dr Dory Alik [Applause] ince youill [Applause] okay next we have students from our middle school and the students that we're going to be calling up are our stem and uh do we have any kids do want to uh tell us what stem stands for just yell out the four four things that stem stands for aren't they great yeah so yes all right and uh the the the students that were calling up were in a tag or talented and gifted program or math competition and we have students that scored first place second place

011and third place um in this and then we also well we'll just start with that and then we have a math counts competition so we'll start with the four students here and I'm going to apologize in advance I'm doing my very best to pronounce everyone's name correctly so if I do not pronounce it entirely correct uh please I offer me offer you my apologies to to start with so the first student if uh I'm going to call the students name out even if they may not be here we have uh swag niik uh Roy CH chy okay we have dreo ready took second place please come up to the front we have also second place par Adia I don't believe he's here but Patrick Ryan [Applause] and divid and [Applause] Bell congratulations I know you're

012GNA have to stand and we have more we more I'm going bring that up back [Applause] okay next we have also from the Middle School the tri count math counts competition and the team that competed uh in that competition so we will start with AI thanawala [Applause] next we have ret [Applause] [Music] hedi Kevin Lou [Applause] [Music] and I'm going to announce three students who I don't believe are here tonight uh they didn't respond but I do want to include them uh in the presentation so we also had uh par a we had oh okay it's not high on my apologies that's [Applause] right we have AA cha [Music] and Drew fr [Applause] next we have students that are part of the technology Student Association competition and we have uh students I'm going to say

013what they won the awards for and then we'll call the students up because they they have different Awards the first is um for third place stem animation the first two students our next two students were second place for for for for forensic I'm sorry technology and we have a three students for the the took second place for leadership strategies so our first student sear [Applause] Vara I ches Hardy angelene [Applause] Thomas Rebecca [Applause] Phillip Daniel veres [Applause] conratulations shth [Applause] gugala okay that's good did someing great and Akil [Applause] manam got to be a quick [Applause] okay Mr maroto would you like to there you are the next group we have are students that um were named to the all Eastern music education conference good evening everyone uh my name is Zach morala I'm the

014district supervisor for the Department of Applied arts and careers technology which encompasses everything from business to fine performing practical Arts Engineering and everything in between and thanks to the wonderful support of our Administration and our Board of Education we're able to offer our students tremendous opportunities throughout the state and the nation in a competitive format and tonight we're going to be recognized many of those students that uh have achieved the highest level at the state level including uh um the TSA students that were just recognized and before I speak more specifically to the all Eastern music conference I just want to thank Miss Sarah Cummings and Miss Donna Montgomery who are the co-advisors of the TSA organization at the mono Township Middle School I would also just like to recognize Miss Terry Weiss Miss Debbie

015stepensky Miss Diana Dale who are our business teachers that have realized a lot of the successes that you'll be hearing about tonight and of course I'd like to recognize our music teachers um some of of which are here tonight Mr Yale Snider who's in the back who directed um our percussion Ensemble Mr uh Martin Griffin who's our high school band director and U Miss Ariel Klein who is our High School Coral director and and if I have left anyone out which I don't think that I did I apologize so um specifically regarding the all Eastern Conference which took place a couple weeks ago in Atlantic City it's a Regional Conference that really features the elite and the best of the best in Performing Arts throughout uh the northeastern portion of the United States and we

016were uh very fortunate and very proud to feature many of our musicians from the high school and a lot of musicians from the Middle School at this conference in which we received uh numerous compliments specifically with the organization professionalism and how proficient these uh young students were on their instruments so um many of them are here tonight and we are very excited to present them to you and if you wanted to see the performance that took place at the all Eastern Conference in Atlantic City this uh a few weeks ago we will be having a Repeat Performance at our May 16th percussion Ensemble and jazz concert at mon Township middle school and we hope and expect to see you all there so thank you very much he coming up we ask Mr Snider to introduce

017the [Applause] students right there okay put me on the spot I knew you could handle it prianka [Applause] rth Jaden [Applause] Lou Sean [Applause] seagull Elizabeth [Applause] TOA Katherine Taylor Ria Sharma C sadri Logan Taylor Veronica [Applause] vogelman Rebecca [Applause] Phillip Drew varia Nick Santos Josh [Applause] fabricant Veron ragav Samar charma nille tangella Jack yatco Sean Fitzgerald Jacob fabricant Ganesh Shilla and our resident fifth grader in the Middle School percussion Ensemble Michael [Applause] poer that's my daugh this is our percussion Ensemble who was one of only four Middle School groups of any genre of music in the entire East Coast that was selected to perform in Atlantic City a couple weeks ago at the all Eastern Conference the r reviews okay so uh here [Laughter] all right okay think a to question Miss I got

018stuck onup cupcak is huge very important [Music] up one of these right great job guys G coming up I got a little bit staying on the music theme uh just for a short period we have a student who was named at a 2017 all Eastern music education conference the nme and that student is we had Michael prer already right yes Michael prer again [Applause] from the high school that's Monique from the high school Eastern Conference take picture take picture take picture my son-in-law now the [Applause] ego okay at this point we now have our high school students and we have a new recognition uh it's actually from the state and it's called the Seal of biliteracy and to talk about this program and to introduce our students we have Dr Kelly Roselle good evening my

019name is Dr Kelly Roselle I supervise language arts World Language and media literacy the Seal of biliteracy this is the first year from this for this program uh New Jersey signed it into law last January other states have been doing it for several years in order to earn the Seal of biliteracy students must demonstrate Proficiency in language arts through the park assessment sat or other graduation requirement they also take a second assessment in a language of their choice if they earn a passing score the state certifies that they are biliterate students can use this seal of biliteracy when applying to colleges um other jobs or other Awards so we are incredibly proud of 15 of our high school seniors who have earned um the Seal of biliteracy it is a real distinction um our first

020student who has earned the seal in two languages um both Italian and Spanish is Katherine [Applause] Bernal okay earning the seal in Spanish Miranda Crowley again in Spanish Erica Delgado [Applause] Natalia dik and Natalia earned in Spanish as well earning the seal in Italian is Lauren Esposito Sara Fernandez earned the seal in Spanish Cameron Fuller rishab heray Abby [Applause] hoppy Alexander [Applause] Kim Diego pizaro Andre Sedro Ashley Vargas and finally Jason Weissman congratulations to all of you who I miss no I said Abby happy is she here is Abby happy here oh she is okay we're good all right sure like that's my boyfriend all right stay put a picture can you squeeze in squee a can [Applause] next we have a group of students for both the fall and the spring life smart challenge

021we have students that came in first in actually every one of the students I believe came in first in this uh these challenges which is wonderful our first student pav [Applause] ready and Rana [Applause] ret [Applause] Gupta congratulations Nathan Ress [Applause] cult R guys out there cult R oh yeah not there na [Music] G said never did never did just grand stand all right all right we're going to take a picture of this group I just realized I don't I'm just double checking but are you looking for this they give me a they give me next we have a student who has um uh fought through some rather CH some some challenges and through determination and hard work traits that we we hope that all of our students will espouse but determination and hard work

022this student has been Ed to Purdue University we yes that student is Alexander [Applause] wildner around thate in high school school [Applause] we're sting here now we're break they're rich we're still they're in Bly Hills Mr marado if You' like to back come back up we have a number of students in our business department that'll be recognized oh just like recogniz he okay so we'll skip FCC I didn't hear anything else there was nothing else I don't think so yes hello again a lot of students that are committed to um we're now going to recognize some of our students that have had outstanding accomplishments in some of our business competitions at the Monro Township High School several of which we uh just head up here from the life smarts competition which is an off of

023our future Business Leaders of America ctso here at mono Township High School which we were very excited uh features over 200 students here at the high school and very very competitive um we'll also be recognizing students from our our brand new personal finance and economics team which in just it's a pilot program right now but we're already experiencing incredible success at the state level and of course we'll be representing um our Deca program uh which is another business ctso however most of our students that will be calling are not here because they are currently in California competing on the national level due to their success at the state level so um our business education program uh we're very proud of and uh we're very excited about welcoming all these students up momentarily okay you want

024to call them up sure okay so we'll start with uh the nation uh the personal finance and economics team which is directed by Miss Terry Weiss um our first uh uh student that we'd like to recognize is Nishan nalia [Applause] not sure if he's here but sahil [Applause] perik wahed [Applause] Zafar that's our uh finish number one in New Jersey as a wild card uh comp competition so congratulations guys number one in New Jersey next we'll move on to Deca which features categories ranging from marketing to finance to fashion and Merchandising we'll start with the team that was number one in New Jersey and financial team decision-making that's Naomi Doshi and Natasha ready believe they're in California at the moment we also have uh par Pandy who was wrote the number one business growth plan

025in the state of New [Applause] Jersey uh we have the team of Rihanna Yi and sria mamali who was number one in New Jersey for a fashion merchandising promotion plan and I'm sorry we also have retique Patel for financial team decision-making number one in New [Applause] Jersey amazing pretty and that's it for Deca and if we're going to take a photo can we have the life smart students come back up from bla sure so we can have one big happy business family so if you were recognized as a life smart uh if you're still here um why don't you come back up so we can take a big picture and we can share it with your business teachers it's not I'll forget forget forget talk about a nice check right there right can't winter storm

026later please can we not jump ahead on thank you [Applause] guys so I've referenced uh New Jersey Department and of Education CTS so that stands for a Career Tech technical student organization it is a state sponsored organization that is in alignment with industry and career standards and we feature many of those here at monor Township High School and the next group we're going to recognize is the FCCLA which uh centers on family consumer science consumer Behavior culinary arts Early Child education fashion and design and uh what's interesting about this group that um we compete with is that a lot of times as a public school we compete against Technical and vocational schools which in these types of classes however all that being said our Public School here in monor Township High School goes toe-to-toe with

027all of these schools and this year we had two students finished number one overall in New Jersey um well one of which is here this evening but we'll start with the with a young lady that's not here tonight Caroline Kini who was number one in New Jersey in art of G oh I'm G to mess this one up art of guard Manar in uh New Jersey which is a culinary practice so Caroline Kini wow [Applause] and our second student uh that I would like to recognize tonight was number one in evening wear in the fashion runway competition and if uh my memory SE me correct she also had a perfect score on the written exam uh and that is Ria hondao [Applause] and I should also mention that our DEA program is advised by Miss

028Debbie stepensky and FCCLA is co-advised by Miss Amanda dockerty and miss panvel here at the high school so thank you to those teachers almost done uh so finally we're going to go back to Performing Arts we have a couple uh of outstanding uh musicians here at the high school that won some pretty impressive recognition um not only uh at the state level but beyond and we'll start with Monique legaspi who was uh not only first chair All State I believe for the second year in a row but was also named to the all Eastern band on in percussion so Monique legaspi Mo'Nique is trained by Mr Martin Griffin and Mr Yale Snider also uh in the instrumental music side of things we had a student that was named also to All State and all Eastern

029jazz band um and that is Graham kak no relation Graham is instructed by Mr Martin Griffin and also Mr Alfred hattinger we have Coral students y okay and finally we have some students from our Coral program which is directed by Miss Ariel Klein um being recognized to All State and all Eastern course is Mr Peter Toto [Applause] conratulations not here this evening but also earning All State honors is Taylor Viana who was named All State mixed chorus and Gabriella gimnez who was named All State Women's Chorus and all of these recognitions are unprecedented success from our uh performing arts program which continues to grow and we are very thankful to uh the administration and the board for their support thank you [Applause] and then we did the Jersey cake you Jersey cake in Jersy Jersey

030cake yeah in fifth grade I don't think so what the kids used to do yes she came and took a picture of my son's Jers and last certainly not least the student is the recipient of the Summers Governor's School of Engineering and Technology at Rucker University and that is Monique legaspi congratulations [Applause] all right so I know this has been long for everyone but we would if you could be just patient a little bit longer we would like to invite all of the our students who are recognized tonight uh if you could please come up and in um some organized fashion come up chronological by height by no I'm only kidding just come on up to the front our elementary students will be in the front and uh all of our students who received an

031award tonight please come on up so we can take one group picture picture we'll do that sear I know contagious I can't look back everybody up put on the desk Henry we didn't do the Henry r one we do a little head next no we do the hry r we doing that before him hibs up on the screen no I think we need to do this first the kids are usually read yes they read it they read it what we have to read find my son that's your son with the hoodie on number 15 I think it was Mike Mike go tell him he's in trouble Hey where's hoodie to a lot of pressure very shy kids like sort of up with swag definitely like you see different Comfort levels that's right I want to

032see a sports Cod I told them like a collared shirt like Club tire he was having none of it imagine imagine how about I just wear jeans and a t-shirt and my sweat I'm like whatever I give up up they used to use pH practice boom boom boom un I see that I see that there's a couple kids out there that are uh very impressive group yes that's it up are you ready be perfect time by time when you're ready to step aside he'll be ready to step right in my great uncle stamp he died in he died in 2000 but um he had the stamp on his arm and I I would ask him what what happened one day to go to the driving you're supposed to wear real to driving I just want

033to hit a bucket ball he was Italian there's and that needs to be maintained you don't use the golf M you don't do any of the special fun don't wine the wine I want it's always like the last one was just bad timing for better or worse would it's still not fix hopefully tomorrow they're going to get going up yeah going up to the gym takeing shower there getting my money's wor there you go you don't even have to that's fantastic I feel like I'm now winning I'm winning you might you might be more kind than I oh no Mr Gorski it's the Henry brickless presentation into and yeah the Seal of by literacy which should have been included in that student rec I'm very confused lot of those bells and whistles that you might

034yes I'm sure do glasses to match your shirt no I've had the new I've had I have glasses to match everything because I buy them for $3 at the flea market well done we like to give our outstanding students another round of applause because we're very proud of their accomplishments brings a nice element to the board meeting to have the students because we're all about kids right a good reminder so at this time we're going to move to the Henry rickless Holocaust Memorial committee award presentation Dr kosac Bonnie Bonnie yes thank you manam president would you like to go up and speak absolutely you want to do it from the podium right from the podium wherever you'd like be sure this seems to be Awards night yes yes all right I will thank you different

035kind of awards first of all um I want to thank uh Dr kak and the Board of Ed members for inviting me here um I'm Dave Rothman I work with the Henry rickus Holocaust Memorial committee and I run their essay contest just to give you an idea of what that's about each year and we've been doing this for a number of years and we're very pleased to uh we first start off by getting a a freshman Auditorium put together Bonnie caletto and Matty philippus just make it seamless for us so thank you uh we then invite survivors Holocaust Survivors these are the eyewitnesses of history and they each have their own life stories people like sa Lori people like Paul way uh are able to come and share with the Freshman audience exactly what happened

036and answer questions this goes on the auditorium is about an hour we then challenge the students their choice if they'd like to answer a number of questions write an essay about it two pages and they are questions like why is it important to learn about the Holocaust um what would you say if you ran into a holocaust denier how would you handle it and Holocaust it happened could it happen again could it happened here in the United States and we give them that challenge it's all voluntary and so forth uh we got back last year from last year's Freshman Class 272 essays phenomenal turnout you think about it's the end of the year they're thinking about summer jobs uh finals Etc and they get it all done well I get a committee together um some

037of my committee members are here as well eight or nine members we call down the 272 down to 33 and then we call it down further to 10 10 essays perfect scores absolutely perfect scores uh with your permission I would like to ask one or two of the uh essay uh winners if they may speak if that's yes that works for you thank you well I'll start ladies first and I'll also borrow a note from Dr kak if I butcher your names I apologize I think you said it differently but it was that idea so let me ask uh Sonia linetti if you'd like to come up and share your essay with the [Applause] board uh so my question was what would you do or say if you came in contact with the Holocaust denier

038and this is my essay 60 years ago the Holocaust was the time of dread sorrow anger and shock for those who experienced it today the Holocaust is a time of mourning loss and tragedy for those who know loved ones with terrifying experiences of it or for those families that have themselves lost precious brothers sisters grandparents parents uncles aunts and cousins in the dark times in the future it will be a time of remembrance a time to recall the wrongs we have done as humans and the wrongs that can be prevented most importantly the wrongs that we must be able to overcome however there are people that oppose the validity of the Holocaust people that refuse to believe that something as horrible as this can be done by the evil of Their Own Kind perhaps out

039of denial or contempt to these people I say look around to these people I say look at the letters the journals the Diaries the existing concentration camps and gas Chambers the wishes of survival and the wishes to end all imans of it the internal conflict of Hope and defeat sorrow and hatred secretly written in fear of punishment for the feelings that cannot be controlled to these people I say look at this speakers that visit from school to school and cry over the faded memories of a lost world to these people I say look at the way he hides his tears shed for his lost grandfather the one who raised him because he had already lost his parents to the darkness the parents he never even knew and to these people I say look at the

040way her hand shakes as she grips it tightly on the microphone in fear that if she stops talking she'll never stop crying look at these people These Broken Dreams these lost hopes now look at the people who aren't even here to share their Stories the ghosts that didn't even survive long enough to learn the word joy and tell me tell the world that the Holocaust did not occur something some Force evil or grief or hatred or intimidation caused the Nazis to follow Hitler in his dreams of a world without the valuable Jew Jews Christians homosexuals or egyps a dream without many of the loyal citizens of beautiful countries like Poland Hungary Ukraine Russia Holland or France a dream to end the innoc Souls that will grow up and Inspire to become doctors lawyers writers Arters

041artists Builders and inventors a dream to end the hopes of love a dream that became a nightmare and a nightmare that morphed into reality denying this the tragedy that so many people live to tell the story of is unimaginable there are people that volunteer their time to relive the stories of the past lives that they wish to forget and there are people that showcase their disabilities when they are in the worst of pains there are people willing to express their heartbreaking emotions just so that that they can spread awareness they do they do these things so that someone one brave soul will remember down the road that people can be horrible they do these things so that one day someone will stop another Holocaust from occurring they tell their stories loud so that the kid

042in the back of the room texting on his phone will hear and he may be the one to stop someone from becoming a numbered body thrown on top of a pile of an unnamed skeleton whose hair would be shaved crafted and sold in the form of a coat to a little boy these memories these emotions and these artifacts left over from the remains of the bodies are all real they are sitting in the hands and the minds of those who have lived to experience the Calamity of the Holocaust why would anyone craft a story about the death of their own loved ones as unfortunate as it is there is Hardcore evidence and proof that the Holocaust happened even though we all wish it hadn't and as unbelievable as it may sound people can be both

043incredibly kind and Incredibly evil it is up to us to learn from the mistakes of the past it is up to us to know how to express our feelings of the present before they turn into unending hate and disaster most of all it is up to us to warn the future Generations that mistakes will happen and that it is up to the people to defeat hatred with the power of love and unity to tie bonds and embrace those who are different despite hearing this there will be those who still deny the existence of the Holocaust they may say that anyone could have made these journals and letters and they may say that the whole Holocaust is just one big lie used as propaganda against Hitler and Nazi Germany maybe these people died because of a

044catastrophe within their own countries which have used Nazi Germany as a scapegoat this although not likely might be possible however to those that deny the Holocaust ever happened I ask you to soak in the reality of the deaths that have occurred the mourners the lives lost that sorrow that grief the these are all things that we can accept are real more than 11 million people were killed during the Holocaust Millions more have experienced it and millions more have had their families break apart because of it we must all whether in agreement or disagreement about the Holocaust itself have respect for the lives that have been lost and for the lives that still lie suffering in remembrance of this devastating event thank you [Applause] thank you Sonia by the way we um we not only say

045thank you we also give a $50 gift certificate to all our winners just so you [Applause] know I I'd like to beg your patience for moment longer uh Nigel would you come up here just want to share another essay thank you hello hi so I answered the question why is it important for students to learn about the Holocaust and how do you carry these those lessons into today's world it's not just important for students to learn about the Holocaust it's necessary students need to understand what went on at that time and why it was so horrific and what it means and why it means so much the Holocaust means so much to so many people because it affected so many people it was a mass genocide and a violent discrimination against Those whom the Nazi

046Nazis named undesirables Jews Gypsies blacks homosexuals and even disabled people were impacted directly by the events of the Holocaust they weren't the only ones affected sometimes those who felt that what the Nazis were doing was wrong tried to help those who needed help they might hide the Jews or even try to get them out of the country these people weren't just doing the Jews a favor they were risking their lives to do the right thing students need to grasp that what went on wasn't just 15 pages in a textbook it actually happened people had to live through it through all the horrors the pain the death the sadness the loneliness the fear the torture and not knowing what might happen to them they've had to live with that even after the Holocaust ended even after

047they found out if their friends parents siblings or relatives were still alive even after they had all their scars and bruises patched up even after they had been cured of their sicknesses they still had to live with all of it nothing you can read can show you what they experienced and how it impacted them how they can't do anything that change what happened how they can't take back what the Holocaust stole from them we have to learn that the Holocaust and anything like it can't happen again that idea needs to be passed down onto our children and onto their children when the world commits genocide it's killing itself pulling Humanity farther apart through violence and tragedy that's not the world our children deserve that's not the world we need so when kids hear about these

048crimes against humanity hope that it doesn't go in one ear and out the other the Holocaust is an example of the world at its worst so when we hear about it we must strive to make a world at its best like Holocaust Survivor Ellie weasel puts it even in darkness it is possible to create light at a time like the Holocaust it was hard to find hope in humanity but when we understand the past we can learn from our mistakes and hope to prevent anything like the Holocaust ever happening again a great place to start is by educating the Next [Applause] Generation fabulous all right let me announce the uh the other of the 10 winners we can't we can't have all of them give their essays to tonight um Nikita shenas thank you excellent

049job Lola [Applause] SEO thank you okay Justine nagoski thank you great uh kit [Applause] cedy okay now this one I apologize ahead of time vachi andar V [Applause] and Cindy [Applause] sing thank you great job okay uh Zoe fure okay and sahii dant toori [Applause] I close thank you very much great that's our presentation sure sure sure go front like a dwarf [Applause] I can recognize that right this is awesome uh building BRS oh my noes [Applause] this is I want to congratulate all of our award winners tonight from the the Holocaust essays and um we this is really truly a a night where we're honoring all of our students and outstanding students and we as a board um that's why we're here for students us and the administration so congratulations again to our award

050winners and now we're going to go back on the agenda to a presentation on harassment intimidation and bullying do you want to introduce okay my name is Lori McConnell I'm the supervisor of Grants testing and special projects one of the things that I um and in am in charge of is harassment intimidation and bullying within our district um we are required by the state of New Jersey to give a biannual Report with um facts and figures regarding bullying and harassment incidents within our school district why is that not working is it working Yes mine didn't [Music] go okay so this reporting period that I'm reporting for is July 1st through December 31st 206 um you can see here the definition of bullying which comes from the state again Hib harassment intimidation and bullying means any

051gesture written verbal physical act or any electronic communication whether it be a single incident or a series of an incident that is reasonably perceived as being motivated by either an actual or perceived characteristic characteristic such as race color religion ancestry national origin gender sexual Ori orentation gender identity and expression or mental physical or sensory disability or by any other distinguishing characteristic it does take place on school property or any school sponsored function or on a school bus or off school grounds it must substantially disrupt or interfere with the order operation of the school a reasonable person should know under the circumstances that it will have the effect of physically and emotionally harming a student or damaging the student's property or placing a student in reasonable fear of physical and em or emotional harm to his

052or her person it has the effect of insulting or demeaning any student or group of students or it creates a hostile educational environment for the student by interfering with the students's education or by severely or pervasively causing physical or emotional harm to the student at each of our schools we do have Hib Specialists they are listed as you can see they um receive training every year we meet on a regular basis to discuss different procedures for investigation um and incidents that are occurring maybe patterns of behavior things like that um so from as I said this I'm I'm sorry I'm one ahead um from the period of I always like to say September but it's actually July 1 because we really don't really have anything that happens in this summer so from September from July

0531st 2016 through December 31st within our entire District we had seven reports of harassment intimidation and bullying there were only three incidents that were founded which is pretty significant if you look at the next slide you can see I'm missing a slide oh here we go um this is not set up with my laptop so I'm trying to do dual Duty here it's a little tricky um you can see when we look at the different nature of the characteristics this first slide you can see there were no incidents at any school um based on these um protected categories the next slide is where you see where the incidents occurred we had one based on this ability and we had two based on other um other can include oh my gosh any multiple number of things

054um I can't think of one right now I should have come up with one but I can't think of one um so um basically we had one incident at um mil Lake School um that was unconfirmed and we at the high school I mean I'm sorry at the middle school we had three incidents so that's the makeup of how it went down we didn't have anything believe it or not from September to December at the high school that was a founded incident so to me that's terrific news it's significantly lower than that we had in the past um the middle school had one based on disability two based on other and just so that you know discipline is determined based on the code of conduct so a lot of times it goes hand in hand

055we may impose discipline based on our code School codes School codes of conduct um prior to whether we find or don't find that is a confirmed case of bullying all right um we do provide remediation and the I will have to say my um antibullying coordinators at the schools are doing a tremendous job of being proactive and it's made a huge difference for our students um some of the hi programs that you'll see well let me go ahead I can't do two things at once um are listed here there are a number of others um that occur on a regular basic basis um our PTO I will say also are very helpful in providing um programs and helping out with the costs for some of these programs because this is not state funded we do

056not get any funds from the state of New Jersey for any types of programs that we Implement for this and our Target populations these are all the people that need to be trained in some way shape or form it's basically everybody um so we do take care of that as we we actually do a very very good job of it um and we've gotten much better especially with our substitute staff our bus driver um and people that are just coming into the classrooms so that's it any questions do any member of the Board of Education have any questions for Miss McConnell no so you must be doing a great job thank you very [Applause] much okay in a minute we will be going to the to the budget hearing and final adoption of the 201728

057school budget we'll be doing this any minute but while we're talking we're waiting um we are not going to have any student board members this evening because we don't have a student board member here so I just wanted to let everyone know that Mr Jamal who is our senior board AED rep was chosen as one of the winners of the 37th annual middlex County secondary principales Association outstanding student and he is attending a banquet this evening with the um High School principal Mr Goodall the criteria for a selection to this award would be the student should demonstrate academic success by ranking in the top 40% of the graduating class and should significantly contribute to the secondary school Community by participating in a variety of school activities and some of the activities that Mr Jamal is

058a part of he's a student board rep he's a class vice president he's the Monroe Muslim Students Association uh member and a member of the science National Honors Society above among other things that he does so we congratulate him on this ACC compliment [Applause] accomplishment and we and we continue with the outstanding students this evening Mr armo yeah while we're waiting um since this is a public budget hearing and final adoption is there going to be a public session uh specifically for the okay there will be after we hear the the presentation then I will open it up to the board members to have a Motion in a second and then we will open it up to the public for comment specifically for the budget and before we vote Yes okay great thank you I

059don't see it on here so um I'm looking no do we know where here he's coming you like to make an entrance Mr Gorski obviously yes you're up all right than trying to draw it out here can't be out of stretch yeah Mrs McConnell never went through a presentation that quickly before good evening welcome to the final budget hearing um about a month ago we were very pleased to roll out the tenative budget to the community and since that time we've had a finance committee meeting chaired by Mr Paul rutsky where you have an opportunity from the preliminary budget to the final adoption tonight to make any uh changes and we must have uh gotten everything right the first time because the committee recommended no changes to the budget and is very proud of our

060accomplishment this year um with all of the student focused activities this evening and because there aren't any subs of changes we'll get through everything rather quickly with me is Dr kak and Dr alvic both who were instrumental in the develop of the budget as were the principles and supervisors and all the way down to the teacher bus driver par professional level uh this is a um a zero based budget that begins from scratch and is developed organically every year our members of our board board of education are Mrs Kathy Co Pano board president Mr Marvin Braverman board vice president personnel and policy chair Mrs Michelle armeno Mr Ken Chella building grounds Transportation chair Mrs Jill Deo curriculum committee chair Mrs Patty Lang Mrs Dawn Corino Mr Steven Rybeck Mr Frank Russo and again Mr Paul

061rzky Jamesburg representative and finance committee chair it's important to recognize all of the chairs in this process because all of them contribute greatly at their various committee levels to the construction of the budget finance committee has more handson uh than others and that's chaired Again by Mr Paul rutsky Mr Frank Russo Mrs Michelle armino Mrs Jill Deo Mrs Don Kino and Mrs Kathy colano our board president is ex officio and and sits at all the committee meetings board vision statement and mission statement we're all familiar with um the district goals and the board goals are all posted on our website and it's important to note that every expenditure of funds is scrutinized during our defense rounds to make sure that they comply with board and District goals our executive summary this year we were uh

062test with preparing a very comprehensive budget meeting the needs of over 504 projected new students addressing aging facilities without the expectation of additional Aid it's a good thing we didn't count on any more Aid because with the additional assessment for Charter Schools we actually are at a deficit position of of about $100,000 compared to last year and by suppressing taxes by minimizing by maximizing budget savings through Surplus we are very pleased that we are leaving $600,000 of banked cap which would been statutorily available for this year's Budget on the table and we were able to do that because Dr alvik Dr kak and I implemented budget saving strategies including a budget freeze in January for all non-essential spending that saved over a million dollars our access Surplus grew by $1.2 million for the general fund

063all of that suppresses taxes he budget considerations again 504 new students that's a small Elementary School of new students that we're expecting next year alone aging facilities we have over $2 million of expenditures within the budget within the cap to do roving projects Asphalt Paving and the procurement of of buses um um Dr Alvi could speak a little bit about the Core Curriculum content area that it was expanded this year on the budget we are trying desperately to keep student teacher ratios down we have 30 new staff members in the budget most of them instructional and that's uh to keep the ratios down and we are all most concerned about the tax impact on the community as you could see all of us are engaged in this fight for fair funding we recognize that about

06488% of the revenues required to fund the school district's operation are raised from the local tax levy which is unprecedented and we'll get into some of the reasons for that later but we want to milk all of the educational performance out of every dollar and we think we're doing a fine job at that budget creation timeline once again it starts with the budget philosophy over the summer we look at historical enrollment patterns we review staffing needs we develop the budget and again that's zerob based it starts at the lowest School level and makes its way up it's presented to Dr alvik Dr kak Laur Allen and myself along with the supervisors where they have to defend everything in the budget and show how it's in Alliance with board and District goals that it's efficient and

065that we have established parity with other similar schools then we go wait for the Governor's budget address state aid award comes two days later the board unanimously adopted the tenative budget and then tonight we have the final public hearing Dr Ali would you like to talk about the programs in the budget sure so I'm not going to go through each um line item specifically I think I went into a lot more detail in April on the budget and what's what's incorporated into our budget but we are aligned with the New Jersey School uh student learning standards um so we all of our curriculum we look at it on a five-year rotation and make sure that we're meeting the needs of our students um our budget includes uh Provisions for special education gifted and talented AP

066honors all of those courses for our students um technology is very important it's something that our students use all the time they some of them were born with it in their hands I think so um we make sure that we're incorporating that effectively in our classroom not just using technology for technology sake but making sure that there's a purpose for using that in our classrooms um we incorporate our adult education program we're making sure that we have character education programs within our schools and all of our assemblies and some of our assemblies many of our assemblies are are thank uh a thank you to the ptas and PTO in our district for providing those for our students um we have many Athletics and co-curricular programs that we offer our students and AP uh courses how's

067that very good here's some pictures these slides are all available on our website um we have many fine programs here this is what we consider a comprehensive budget there's something here to inspire every student also included in this budget are new bus vehicles to bring our busing uh operations back in house uh we had a terrible opening a few years ago where uh Reliance on contracted buses caused widespread problems um the instability of the driver on the bus uh replacement staff member every day not having directions familiarity with the area there is no service better performed than our in-house staff and that's across the board we are also replacing the Barkley Brook roof and we are doing it responsibly that is a beautiful um historical building and instead of just overlaying it we are actually

068uh replacing the woodwork in its original form and uh we're very proud of that school and we're going to maintain it accordingly and we have deteriorating asphalt throughout the district it's easy to ignore these items here especially when you have cap considerations but um you know a responsible uh board of education does not just kick these items down the road we've been addressing these every single year to the tune of$ 1.5 to2 million or more and we do that within the budget within the cap with a growing district and with no help from the state what programs are in the budget 454 passenger buses 2 25 passenger vans three additional contracted drivers with Benefits 6 $66,000 for transportation costs Capital budgets partial roof replacement at Barkley Brook School uh replaced deteriorating asphalt um prek and

069kindergarten playground surfacing we applied for a Eric North Safety Grant which contributed $ 31,37 toward the playground restoration we are painting and restoring the steel structural columns at the Monro Township Middle School which white in front of the building we're replacing a 1998 maintenance truck and a 2002 dump truck which are nearly rotted away from Salt spreading uh we are purchasing a new Woodland sign and um instructional equipment at the high school middle school wrestling mats replace two Transportation gas pumps which are beyond their useful life and again that will be all through the regulated permit process and HVAC equipment replaced at Barkley Brook School so with all of the accomplishments that we heard about this evening for our students which is wonderful um we also have these accomplishments that we've done our our graduation

070rate is above the state average it's very high um I can't see the numbers from where I am I think it's 97% 97.3% is our graduation rate um we have 86% of our students are going to college after graduation um we have many AP courses that we offer our students and students are taking those courses and earning uh college credit before they even leave our high school and we are also still we me we heard tonight about the uh seal of New Jersey seal of biliteracy so we have 15 students who earn that this year and um we're still a member of the innovate New Jersey which shows uh some of our Innovative practices like our um World Language Blended learning model at our grades 3 to five and the uh one:1 iPad integration at

071the high school thank you this pie chart again is available on our website it demonstrates where the money comes from and on fortunately the the maze colored large portion at the bottom represents the local tax levy it varies every year depending on the revenue sources 87.2% of of all revenues required comes on the backs of the local taxpayers this is um a fight that all of us are aggressively in uh for over a decade now and um we're beginning to get optimistic that we may have some some good news key facts on State Aid I won't bore you with the details but there's two types Equalization Aid and categorical Aid Equalization Aid is uh the Lion Share of state aid it's designed to support a District's adequacy budget we receive zero we have always received

072zero in the 18 years I've been here because they the state doesn't fund the formula it has been underfunded by8 billion over Governor Christy's tenure and uh they ration what is left to distribute to schools Monroe is deemed by the state to be affluent and wealthy and because of that we received no Equalization Aid the state of New Jersey says you could provide a thorough and efficient Budget on your own we're happy to allow you to do so categorical Aid on the other hand is another type of state aid that is um eligible based upon different categories special education spending Transportation Aid um pleased to say that our transportation department is the most efficient rated in the county among the highest in the state where eligible for over $2 million of categorical Transportation aid but

073with the state phasing it out we only get about $500,000 special education Aid is the largest type that's about $1.9 million state aid is only approximately 3% of our total revenues to support the school budget and the federal government is about 1% the federal government just on historical standards has always given the burden of funding schools to the states we've handed out uh dollars and cents um information here with sources of revenue again show you where it comes from on a comparative basis and the state aid history is a sad story going back uh a few years in that demonstration budget appropriation considerations this is the other side of the coin the first one's revenues the second one's Appropriations they have to balance and budget Appropriations are driven by student enrollment we've picked up 1,600

074students over the past eight years and this slide shows how the state aid has corresponded with that enrollment growth you would think that the state would be responsible and contribute uh a proportionate amount however as you could see from the diplomas increasing uh we've picked up, 16600 new students 30% increase over the last eight years while we've recognized a 2.1 million decrease in state aid of about 40% of our total so why while we pick up 30% more students we lose 40% state aid where does the money go this pie chart demonstrates that when you put in an allocation of benefits from staff and transportation charges which are directly required and related to to um to students we spend about 62% of of all expenditures directly on instruction the money does not go to administrative

075costs the purple shows the rising County limit that you're able to spend on a per pupil basis and the Orange shows Monroe's administrative cost per puple you see a slight uptick in this year's budget and that's because of the pent up demand for administrators particularly at the school levels um to maintain safety and um the instructional process appropriation detail there's a detailed handout of all of our appropriation again that's on our website and this is something that we're very proud of cost savings from shared services we have an interlocal service agreement for Food Services where we we earn $40,000 by providing lunches to the academy Learning Center we have technology Services we apply for erate funding and we we have a shared service agreement with the township for 911 and motor Roa radios um um

076we have uh TV hosting services with the township professional development we're proud to share with our receiving District of Jamesburg it saves both districts money and improves the quality of professional development and uh this year we are very proud that we developed our own in-house proprietary fund for before and after school care it's called Falcon care and early childhood enrich is another segment in that program's inaugural year we had a net income exceeding a half a million dollar the board directed that money to to develop into some retain earnings to keep some Roots but in the future the board can direct that money for any purpose to reduce taxes uh to meet uh growing instructional needs to expand the program whatever they see fit solar energy renew renewable credits we make about $30,000 a year

077at Oak Tree on solar panels we sell electricity back um that was over $100,000 years ago but the federal subsidies have dried up and use a building fees pay about $117,000 a year from following the board policy cost savings from shared services um we have shared service agreements again with the Township recycling transportation services anybody who we could share a Transportation Route with meaning another school district we call them up on the phone and we asked if we could share the route if your child's going the same place Place ours is let's split the cost um and one thing that we're very proud of again is health benefits uh after receiving a health benefit proposal from Horizon exceeding 133% we solicited competitive quotes and uh we got a teaser rate from a particular company that

078we took back to Horizon and we negotiated from 13 a 2.5% increase in health benefits this is over a $20 million line item in the budget so this is very material with the with the um contractual um collections of chapter 78 monies from staff up to 35% of our benefit cost that many of us are paying we saved um and our health benefit account is increasing 0% for next year you will not find another school district or business anywhere that can uh demonstrate that kind of Effectiveness in saving money through health insurance insurance so how does it all pan out in the tax money and my pocketbook couple years ago we had a 4 and a. half cent increase $138 44 to the average taxpayer in Monroe last year we made an improvement of 1

079cent dropping it to 3.5 C increase or $18.66 on an average of test home this year we're very pleased that we're offering a very comprehensive budget we're spending to cap without the use of Bank cap we were using Surplus where we generated it ourselves during the year as the state aid has actually decrease from the prior year and uh because of those efforts and also because of the 2% rable growth in town this year's budget is a very attractive 1.2 Cent increase or $37.40 perom on an average assessed home that's incredible our average over the last 15 years is about a 7c increase so you could see the great strides that this board of education has made in trying to be responsible about minimizing the tax burden considering the growth and the lack of State

080contribution while never compromising on the educational product that we offer Dr so as Mr Gorski has stated and Dr ALC has stated we are very happy with the budget to present to you the public and of course to our board of education for we're recommending for approval we think that we have we're still financing uh our quality programs we have not made any Cuts in the instructional areas but we have reduced cost in every single non-instruction area that we can we are are also planning for the future we know that we have new students coming in actually monthly and we have made uh plans to uh be prepared for that so we're looking for that we're trying to be fiscally responsible we know that we're going to be going out to the community and asking

081the community to help us fund new schools to help us deal with our growing student enrollment and of course that'll that building of those new schools will be over the next fiveyear period so we're doing everything we can to our Monroe Township taxpayers to say we're trying to be physically responsible now and we're asking for your support as we move forward and prepare for our new students coming in so with that we will be asking the Board of Education to approve this budget tonight it has already been approved by the County Board of educa or the uh County Office of Education and and has gone through the finance committee as well as all the other committees are aware of it and the rest of the the board so thank you as always for your continued

082support thank you Mrs kapano members of the Monro Township Board of Education it is recommended that the members of the mon Township Board of Education approve the following amounts and resolution for the final budget be it resolved by the Monro Township Board of Education that the 201728 general fund budget be adopted in the amount of $2,375 1839 and the general fund local tax levy in the amount of 8,472 one and a special Revenue Fund in the amount of 1,112 and a Debt Service budget in the amount of 11,1 158,000 3 $66 and a Debt Service local tax levy in the amount of 10,267 265 whereby the 201718 budget total is m635 413 and whereas the monre Township Board of Education has has been notified of state aid amounts and whereas such state aid amounts are

083for the 1718 categorical special education Aid is $1,976 1819 and for the 1718 the categorical security Aid is $13,700 and for the 1718 categorical Transportation Aid is $57,600 The Debt Service Aid is $635,500 the other state AIDS consisting of Park Readiness Aid of $58,900 and per pupil growth Aid of $58,900 and professional earning Community Aid of $625 15 and host District support Aid of $596 whereas the mon Township Board of Education has estimated a state aid amount pursuant to application for the 1718 the estimated extraordinary Aid amount is $214,400 and whereas policy 6471 and njac 6A 23A d7.3 provides that the Board of Education shall establish in the annual school budget a maximum expenditure amount that may be allocated for such travel and expense reimbursement for the 171 18 school year now therefore be it

084resolved that the mon Township Board of Education hereby establishes the school district travel maximum for the 171 18 school year at the tenative sum of 8,422 and be a further resolve that the school business administrator shall track and record these costs to ensure that the maximum amount is not exceeded and whereas as a result of the extraordinary budget efficiencies created by the administrative stewardship of the 1516 budget which led to an increase in excess surplus of 1,124 311 as compared to the prior year as an alternative Revenue source to taxes the board has not exceeded the maximum spending Authority and furthermore has not used the $600,000 of a bank cap created in 16177 not withstanding the continuing inequity in state aid funding as well as the significant student growth and widespread facility needs in the

085district and now therefore let it be resolved that the superintendent of schools and the business administrator board secretary file all the required documents with the executive County Superintendent soov M arm second that you can second that Mr rutsky any comments or questions from members of the Board of Education Mr Russo I was just going to ask if it was part of the board strategy to um administrative strategy to uh coincide the uh events um of the students with with the budget I was going to say it was it's a good thing oh because yeah well in that case yes we planned it all along that way absolutely because you get to see the product yes and very high Achievers I think we've been trying to do that at every meeting where we have honored our

086students for some activity or another I know um we honored the band for their band trip and to go to um Hawaii and I we did something last time too but yeah last year when we started it and we did it we had the student recognition in June but we just found there was so many things going on in June uh we have retirees coming back there's a lot of different things that we decided to move it up but uh since you stated that sure we'll take credit for that yes we planned it for the budget meeting today okay no very very good plan so thank you and good sales pitch anyone else Mr Ryback I just really want to compliment not only the board members but the the central administrators I know how hard

087you all work to um run an outstanding school system caring so much about the kids and the taxpayers it's very hard to create a balance with those two and we're coming out on top every year because of your hard work so thank all of thank you anyone else Miss armino I just have some technical questions um the 30 uh 37 uh $37.40 increase in the tax levy is that per th000 or 100 assess value of the properties please M for an average assessed home in Monroe Township and this figures provided by the municipal government for 2017 the average assessed home in this Township is $312,900 on that valuation for the year or per month for the year okay so at but all right so what is the increase per th or per 100 of it's

088a it's that that refers to um what we we call sents yeah and we have a 1.2 Cent increase last year the rate was 1. 14355 this year the projected rate is 1.42 35 it's a 1.2 C increase it is the lowest natural tax increase that we've had in 18 years and that's amazing since we're getting a large enrollment as we speak so yeah kudos to you I the um I think it is extraordinary that we have been able to Stave off enormous increases which I'm afraid might be coming down the road uh because of the the amount of enrolled students that we have to accommodate every year so um to the staff at the at the zero level when when they're starting to do their budgets I appreciate the teachers and the staff members

089in each in each school um and everyone in each category for doing that um and the rate I another technical question the ratable increase per household is it a per household increase because we had a re-evaluation or are we getting new ratables or is it a little bit of both Madam yes the um the re-evaluation of ratables occurred a few years ago right um the ratable base this year is growing 2.3% through this community right and and you may not know this but I was just curious does it have to do with the rable increase that occurred a few years ago or is it because we have new ratables coming in or like I said it might be both a very good question it's the ladder it's the new ratables coming on it has nothing

090to do with the reeval that's why I reference natural tax increase this year we actually had a tax decrease occur in 2014 with the re-evaluation um well not to everybody not overall not overall but but um when when you've put it all in the when you put it in right yes okay and the curriculum we had I think I remember over $100,000 for curriculum or instructions in our budget philosophy has that been that's been maintained yes every everything in the budget philosophy has been accomplished with one exception um we had presented the need for of uh funds for the development of the transportation Depot which we expect the township to donate indeed to the board of ed very soon within a matter of days that's the lot on Buckaloo Avenue adjacent to the existing School

091lot for us I believe I believe it was on the agenda the um agenda on Monday to be voted on on the 1 of May yes I believe that is on the agenda that's a very generous contribution because as we've informed the board our transportation lot is full and is presenting problems we're having a difficult time adding buses adding staff we're parking them at the schools buses need a particular uh electrical um block heater um that's expensive to have to put in and this amount of money in its location serves the district very well we'll have two Road access over there and uh it will be able to expand our Fleet and I think I have two more uh items one is um the child care we're go have when do you anticipate us paying

092that loan off the um the mecca loan which we inherited um back when that program was um extinguished has been fully paid off the board passed a resolution about a year ago and that has been fully satisfied there was not any taxpayer use of money in that initiative well that's extraordinary and I thank I thank you you for developing that and working that out I know that that um business plan actually worked and the other thing just I'd like to say um as a just a member of the community um deferred maintenance on facilities is really never a good idea so I think it's very important that things like the asphalt and things that we really can't see that are not very glamorous um are to be addressed on a regular basis because the cost

093of deferring that kind of Maintenance and those kinds of repairs really absolutely um doubles and triples in the long run so um that's wonderful that we're doing that I hope people understand that it may not be um flashy to pave to pave over a a parking lot but it's really important it's also good for safety that we're repairing our our facilities so thank you anyone [Music] else okay at this time I'm going to open it up to the public to make your comments on the just on the budget not on funding or anything on the agenda but if anybody has anything they would like to say in regard to the budget please come to the microphone state your name and address and uh we will adhere to our three minute time limit okay just congratulations

094help I'm Krishna deal from L Jake Place U I have a question we're talking about 500 new students coming in so that would typically mean around 200 to 300 new houses have you considered that the new houses would also be paying taxes do you want to take that yes sir that that correlation is not exactly right uh the Board of Education um uh utilizes a demographer who's an expert in the field and he works closely with the township on on determining the birth ratios within the town and a lot of specific historical information and then and uses um uh scientific methods to project the number of students and um uh we have 504 projected new students next year another important fact on that is we have currently 1,000 unhoused students in the district and an

095unhoused student means students beyond the the aggregate capacities of the schools um and we have a projected 2500 I'm sorry 1500 new students in the next five years so that over in the next five years we project we will have 2500 unhoused students again students beyond the technical capacities of their schools in the aggregate 2500 is approximately the full size of this building so if you want to visualize it that way so we we've been studying for a long time now um through the student growth advisory committee the need to expand our schools and uh with the collaborative efforts of the community and the Democratic process that led to it which Dr kek would like to speak to um we are now in the framework of a bond referendum that we're going to present to

096the community shortly M if I if I just want to make sure that I understood your question I believe you also asked about ratables from new housing yes yes so M gz you want to speak yeah the the new um the new residents and the new ratables absolutely is um calculated in this tax presentation that we gave before and the tax rate Township um does a fantastic job coming up with the rable figures and um they report that to us as early as January and then I receive a certified valuation of ratables and then I present the tax information to the board as part of the budget process so every contribution of new rable um is included in the um tax calculation and the ratea bulls has a suppressing effect on taxes I said at

097the preliminary budget adoption it's like if we rented a movie uh for $5 and we had five people watching it everybody would contribute a dollar that would be the rate but if we invite 10 people it cuts everybody's rate by half that's how the expanding rateable base in this town shares um the tax levy and everybody's individual rate decreases so that's one of the benefits of the growth in the community thank you sir good evening Elliot stroll 110 moker Drive Jamesburg New Jersey president of the Board of Education of Jamesburg and I would just like to commend you for a brilliant presentation of this budget knowing what the challenges are that we all face in every school district in this state right now um it is just absolutely amazing that you've kept your increase to

098such a minimal level and hopefully people appreciate it because it's a miracle nice work thank you very [Applause] much good evening um my name is iron Nelson I live at 87 Crescent Way um my question regards this whole issue of state aid and fair funding um what is the game plan to try to get more state aid and more more funding for this District uh we've been ask to sign some petitions in the community that I live in but sort of as we used to say where I live that in a token I guess it's a metro metro car today would get you on a subway um is there a game plan is there a strategic plan to do something about this because yeah this was a great budget but we all know what's coming

099and that's that's really the the the looming issue that I think we all face and I think we all know it what is is the going forward is there is there a what is the plan is there a plan we do we do have a plan um back in January I created the ad hoc Committee of forare funding and if you wait a few more minutes Mr cherella who is chair of that committee will give you an update on what that committee is doing and what we plan on doing in the future he's going to be doing that right after the um the budget adopt option under committee reports isn't there something that you could tell us about this on the agenda which no okay I don't want to steal Mr cherella Thunder because he's

100he's done an extraordinary job with the committee a lot of hard work and a lot of community effort a lot of folks have rolled up their sleeves and have really put some good ideas into place but it's a two-prong approach um as defined by the letter from Senator Greenstein um assemblyman Ben and D'Angelo the first approach is the immediate um uh possibility of addressing the current funding formula by number one eliminating the hold harmless stabilization concept okay back before the school funding School sfra 2008 the current funding formula was put into place adjustment Aid was a type of state aid to help phase in um those getting a lot of monies in the urban centers to the new formula uh they've been receiving that the state uh has then Frozen the budgets they're continuing to

101receive it although it was supposed to be phased out so stabilization is hurting growing districts like Monroe It's Over subsidizing Districts in the large urban areas who are fighting to keep it and that's the first approach to get rid of stabilization adjustment Aid you and you could find out a lot of good information about this on our website also the growth limitations on the budget have to be uh lifted districts have to be the formula has to be run and we have to get credit for the growth that we have here and and stop the limitation on categorical Aid and the longer term approach which is the most important is to come up with a new funding formula because Monro will never be satisfied under school funding Reform Act 2008 even if it's fully funded

102even if it's it's if it's run which it hasn't been because of that um adequacy budget equal as ation Aid issue that I brought up before um all of the state mandates that are we're required to keep up with all are calculated in the adequacy budget the state needs to responsibly contribute money toward that it's grossly unfair that Monroe received Zer doar on that while our neighbors in South Brunswick get $30 million a year that's an incredible disparity if we had $30 million a year in that type of aid form or even half that it would result in a tax decrease in this community that would make your head spin so that those are the approaches and uh and I'm sure we'll hear more about that are you confident on those approaches um I think

103the assemblymen have been at this for a while our state senator has been at this for a while and um I think somebody once said the definition of insanity is to do the same thing again and again and expect a different results how optimistic are you really we're optimistic Statewide there's a lot of school districts getting behind this there's a lot of no news about suing the state I have I have a suspicion we're going to hear something about that soon and um and then and also um the the Monroe's message has been proliferated through all of the Senate and assembly uh houses they know Monroe when we show up there it's here's Monroe again so and and we have 40,000 residents in this community approximately 5,000 or more signed the petition um that's got

104some influence with the legislators so we we are optimistic hopefully you're right uh two uh two suggestions um has anyone ever thought of a lobbyist perhaps um in this in this vein number one and two I think ultimately it will be settled in the courts there would have to be some sort of legal action taken maybe with other districts that are in the same situation that we are maybe not not as bad as us but uh undergoing uh dealing with the same kinds of circumstances that we are the accountability regulations will not allow the district to um hire a lobbyist in that regard so you're looking at the the administrative lobbyists at the at the table here we've taken on that fight I think Mr and and of course the board members too we've also

105spoken to the assembly we've also spoken to the Senate um recently this past Monday and I know I'm taking a little bit from Mr cherella um we attended the the assembly budget hearing um where the the acting Commissioner of Education spoke to the um assembly committee and um she had some very tough questions that she had to answer but it was standing room only with other districts just like we are wearing different color shirts to make make ourselves heard and though we were not allowed to speak they did hear us they acknowledged us and they know that Monroe and other districts like us are in a very um it's very sad situation here we were looking at I one District who was um upset because they only get 43% of their budget covered and we

106were sitting there going we only get 3% so that that the inequities are enormous agreed okay thank you anyone else wishing to speak prakash pup 33 Dana Drive first of all um just sticking to the budget I congratulate everyone of you and Mr grai for that but please keep in mind that uh we are here as a community if anything is lacking with the quality of Education don't hesitate it is saving few dollars versus losing long-term education for our students so please don't hesitate any issues are there bring it at a board meeting and uh we can take it to the council whatever we can do we can take it to the legislatures okay and I think the you know most important is we are not communicating well we should have the gentleman ask the

107same questions we have been asking for several months so I think we should communicate we we should think of how we can communicate we had last few days we have been doing great job so I think the public has to know about that okay so thank you very much good idea anyone else then I will close the public forum and before we vote I just wanted to say a couple things the budget process is a yearr round process every time a committee does their job and brings something to the board of education and we vote on it that's a budget item so we're making we're making uh contributions to the budget all year long and then I I just like to thank the community because they have always been very supportive of what we do

108here and and knowing that you have to pay 88% of our budget that's a big chunk of money to come out of our residents and if we if we if we are successful in getting our fair share we would be able to lower the increases so there is no tax some Monroe and and that's what our object objective is as a board and lastly I'd like to thank the administration for this phenomenal budget because doesn't get much better than this and I said last time Mr Gorski has magic numbers I don't know where he gets them from but to be able to accomplish what we're accomplishing in this budget for $ 3743 a year in a tax increase to me is phenomenal so so if there's no more questions by the board we'll have a

109roll call please thank you madam Mrs armenio yes Mr Braverman yes Mr Chella yes Mrs Deo yes Mrs Lang yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr Russo yes Mr rutsky yes and Mrs kapano yes Madam board president I'm pleased to report the adoption of the budget has unanimously passed thank you very much to the board and the community for your support thank you very much okay we'll move on to the agenda with committee reports if there's any uh committee that needs to report this evening Mr Chella yeah have a s first I have a I have a couple reports and I beat you Joe um we had a buildings grounds and transportation committee meeting on April 19th and uh we have some important things some of this was covered in the budget information but we have uh

110we had five Roofing bids for the uh recovering of the roof in Barkley Brook is that too close and uh for mill work which is paint removal there's some lead on the uh uh kopa how you say that kopa K yeah I knew how to say it I was testing you guys um so uh Safeway received the uh received the work for their bid so we were budgeted at 7 13,960 and they came in at $585,000 so we were we're going to be under budget on that by $128,000 so that's a good thing the Barkley book uh School Paving so the P the uh the the uh contractor that got that bid uh came in at 381,000 the budget was 377 so we're $4,300 over budget on that bid on that project uh but now

111so now I have to now I'm going to cancel that out with some good news here so that check by our flag for 30 $ 37,8 37 is from a FEMA grant for a storm that happened back in uh January of 2016 uh winter storm Jonas I don't even remember that that storm but um apparently uh the administration uh found out that that we could go out for a grant uh through FEMA they did that and they were able to uh get us almost $338,000 back on that for snow removal because it was uh I guess deemed a a super storm um I don't know I don't I don't remember the exact process Mr Gori I don't know if you want to go into that quickly thank you very quickly um we were the only

112School District in the state to go to that FEMA meeting and and request that grant money um Mr T fought very hard for that um it was it was really his initiative um we supported him in that role and um he fought for it and he came home with it $3 37,8 which is a a reimbursement to the school district for snow plowing clearing and so on which will um uh replace and supplant the the monies budgeted for in that category and that goes into the general fund correct yes sir which is good um the the last things that we have I have as far as the from our meeting from the buildings grounds meeting CU we also looked at the uh slight change in the plan for bus parking on Schoolhouse Road across from

113the board office uh it's just a slight shift in uh how we're going to pave the the lot for the buses and then we looked at the plans for the high school edition uh for the middle school and then for the elementary school so we we we were able to look at the uh just the overall projections of how those buildings would look and how they would fit in and um how they would how the uh how the interior would work with the overall you know educating of the kids and and uh where the science labs were and things like that so that was pretty interesting and uh that's what I have for buildings and grounds now uh we also had an ad hoc committee meeting uh little over a week ago and then we

114had uh a trip to Trenton so we went on the 24th as we talked about a little while ago to Trenton to attend the assembly budget Committee hearing and that was very interesting and we we went with our representing Monroe with our purple shirts there were a number of other districts there and all of those districts are underfunded districts that are looking for you know looking for uh funding and looking for particularly for the for the state to fund the funding formula and uh so it was very important that we were there uh in the interim between our ad hoc committee meeting and that meeting our committee the made up of uh Dem Democrats Republicans and independents made up of a lot of people are here in this room today uh just citizens and a

115couple board members who are who who are volunteering their time to work hard for for funding and uh they're putting in a lot of time and a lot of effort well they went out uh and and uh went and got signatures for a petition and we we were we ended up with about 5,000 signatures that will be delivered on May 2nd to the Senate hearing the Senate budget hearing so anyone who would like to go to that hearing um is welcome to join us we're going to have two buses that will transport our residents from here to uh to Trenton and that's on May 2nd at 8:30 and we're going to meet at the soccer fields Pro and and the buses will leave properly at 8:30 we'll have shirts for everyone uh if you do

116decide to come please make sure you bring uh Refreshments uh drinks you know something to drink something to snack on if you need that um and anything else that you could uh think of that you might need in the interim because it probably will be crowded they do have you know bathrooms and things like that but uh but you could be standing for aong period of time you could be uh waiting and things like that what I would like to say is uh you know with regards to that is that um this committee uh has like I said has been working very hard they're putting a lot of effort into this a lot of uh nights a lot of weekends and things like that what I want to come to the board with today is

117that I want to get a vote of confidence from all of you what I don't want our committee to do is to continue to work and continue to fight for funding and to continue to go through all these gyration and then turn around and have a full board later on say well you know this isn't a direction that we want to go in or this isn't something that we're going to condone so what I'd like to do is ask for a a vote of approval on on uh some of our what we we see committee as some of our next steps they alluded Mr Gorski alluded to it and our board president alluded to it a little while ago what I would like to do is ask for us I'd like to make a motion

118and I am making a motion to ask for us to pursue the exploration of a lawsuit against the state of New Jersey for fair funding so I want to see us go through now and wait to see if our legislature uh takes up the government's F the governor's ch challeng to come up with a you know a way to fund education in the right way in 100 days but I don't want to wait 100 days and then have us sit here and go wow they you know they didn't come up with what they said they were going to come up with or they really didn't come up with a solution maybe they came up with a solution to get reelected but they didn't come up with a solution that's going to fund us I want

119to make sure that we're protected by that and Mr Gorski brought up an analogy earlier about a f a $10 movie ticket you d double the amount of people that are going and now the $10 movie ticket only costs $5 for that group of people but that analy only works if you don't have to build a bigger movie theater to fit all of those viewers in and that's where we're at we need to build bigger movie theaters to house all the people that are coming to watch that movie and that's going to cost a lot more than the entry price that we talked about earlier it's not fair that our residents have to fund that and it's not fair that while there are a number of districts that are overfunded uh and don't need it

120and there are districts like South Brunswick that get $30 million that we're funded we send out 39 million and we get back 3 million that's not fair to our residents so what I'd like to do is protect us and make sure that that we're ready and we're for uh for anything that could happen including them coming back and saying that they're only going going to give us you know $400,000 or a million dollar or something like that now I know the argument against the lawsuit is that we have a referendum on the horizon we have a lot of things going on that a lawsuit then could detract from my my feeling though is that if we're if we're right and I believe we are and if we do what I'm asking us to do which

121is to explore a lawsuit by partnering with other districts to defay the cost to uh help us build an argument and to help us Make Some Noise one District like Monroe screaming about funding isn't going to get us anywhere but maybe five or 10 or 20 or 40 or 200 some districts that are not funded properly standing up and joining us in a lawsuit will scare the politicians into doing something and doing the right thing so I think that that then could help us with our with our funding issues you know with with the need for a referendum that we could then make enough noise that will be properly funded so what I'm asking is to uh for for the board to vote on a motion for us to to explore not to file a

122lawsuit today but to explore a lawsuit to allow us to reach out to other districts Freehold Township just filed the lawsuit against the state Kingsway has a lawsuit currently pending I talked to Chesterfield those looking at a lawsuit that we start to do the same thing and I think that it'll come to a head you know at some point where other districts will do the same thing and then we'll be a force you know force to be reckoned with and that's when we're going to be able to get our way so you're making a motion for the Monroe Township School District to explore the to do an exploration of a lawsuit yes okay is there a second to that motion okay second by Patty comments or questions or discussions by the board on the motion

123I think it may be clear and not just to explore a lawsuit but to explore a lawsuit to bring uh charges to the state to improve our state funding I think we have to explain what the the exploration of the lawsuit is about yes I agree with that yeah to bring about Fair funding to our district yeah okay comments or questions by board members Mr Russo it's um at the last meeting I said we need I I thought that we needed more time to develop a strategy and I think that's more or less what I was getting at um the way I envisioned it the committee being set up is that we would discuss amongst ourselves the options that we could take but one option was already taken which was the letter that was signed

124but that then we would set up working groups within the committee that would work on the different options so for example you would have a group that would work on the lawsuit even if it's just gathering information you would have another group that because we even talked about registering as a charter school even if it was to scare somebody to do it or look into the um the procedure to do it uh another one was the letter uh whether it's through Greenstein or through citizens and the board so that's what we needed to do from the beginning and we could have worked on all of those um projects in Tandem and that would that would have been the strategy so one of the things I would suggest is that we need I think we need

125to do some training in terms of what funding actually means because when we had that meeting I mentioned the two items that were U two variables that are included for the adequacy budget which was the uh Monro wealth uh property wealth and Monroe's income wealth and I was sh WR it down by some people on the committee you said no no you're wrong and then even uh the consultant Mr Goldstein said no that's that's uh he suggested that may even be unconstitutional so the board has to understand what we're really fighting for and know what all the mechanisms uh are included all the variables that that are included in the funding so we know what we're fighting for and then we can you know take it from there and I think that was part of

126the strategy we would knew everybody I I mean I didn't know anybody on the on the committee except for you and maybe one or two other people so I think that um right now it's not maybe not too late to to go back to that but I would suggest setting up groups assigning people to do certain tasks and um lawsuit the charter school letter writing campaign uh you had a you had a group which U was set up to do uh talking points and Communications mhm right so that's the way it should be broken up I've done a lot of these strategy type things at the UN in the 35 years I've been there managing projects and anyway here's here here's my thought process on you know on the whole thing is that I'm looking

127for I don't want this committee made up like I said of volunteers to expend all this time and all this effort and come back to a board that says H you know maybe a lawsuit's not what we want to do maybe we want to go and just do a letter writing campaign or an email campaign or a or we just want to sit here and yell at the cameras all day um what what what I what I'm asking us to do is to is to say yeah we're we want to we we want to move forward so I I agree with you that we need to break up into those groups but at the last committee meeting we in tandem Mr bra but the but the one thing that I want to just Express is

128that it is April if we if we don't make noise and a lot of noise fast November will be here and we're going to not have the strength that we need by I think U having that joint effort with other districts and doing that broad Outreach in order to bring people in or join their effort or whatever has to be done in order to get that done and I don't think I think we're going to miss a great opportunity here to hold these elected officials and future elected officials accountable and I think that that's what this will do Mr bra I I I I go along with what you're saying however just having these committee meetings and makes everybody feel really good but I think you're right we should have do something in a legal

129way and if you're going to do that let's allocate X number of dollars hire a team of lawyers that have worked in this at atmosphere and see where they would recommend we go to have a bunch of citizens that have never done this thing before just sitting around and feeling good about themselves doesn't get us any place I I I respect what everybody is doing but sometimes you're just blowing in the wind and that's what this is so that's why I'm saying I would like to see you higher some attorneys that have this kind of experience put a put a dollar amount in there cuz we never do that you everybody wants to do something for nothing if you want to make money you spend money that's an old addage I I I I don't

130disagree with you but I what all I'm asking for right now is for us to have the okay and I'm saying it's not enough no I understand I understand that but I'm not but what I'd like to do is see if we can get other districts to join us and defay the cost so that we're not saying let's out let's put out money right now in order to do that because you can do that simultaneously Kingsway had put out a while back uh um Freehold has a lawsuit going on right but King Kingsway had put out an offer that that other districts could join them proone or free of charge and um so you know I what I want to look at is what what the what our options are what what legal teams they

131have what their legal strategy is what lawsuit basis is and so that we could explore all those all you know those Avenues do that Outreach and then come back to the board and say now we have a concrete plan and this is what we're going to join or this is what we'd like to join and this is where we'd like you to and if history tells us anything it'll be November before you do that anybody else from the board have any comments or questions Miss armino yeah I I understand again and and I'm I'm with Mr Braverman on this um acknowledging that it's important but we don't have an outline like who's going to do that work I mean we we're our committe the committee's going to do it okay so do we have research

132people there do we I mean what does how much has it cost freeold so far what have they done do we have a they just filed we just got yesterday but one of the things that we could do is find out about how much it's cost them who is doing the work for them I mean are they filing through the administration which I think is in our case is very burdened right now because of the expansion and the amount of students I think freeold is actually losing students I mean so we're freeold Township Freehold Township bar burrow yeah bur no T is suing bur oh burel bar yeah that's the smaller one yeah yes free and Freehold burrow is you know they're getting probably most of their funding from from the state um given what

133I understand about the real estate you know in in Freehold but my point is who are we talking talking about who would we pay who would we be seeking to pay and you know how much I'm just concerned about how much we may be taking away from our budget for educational purposes and like Mr Braverman said I mean after 17 years of frustration and again I'm I'm I'm not opposed to change or progress or doing something different what I am opposed to like I think a lot of people have said when we were talking about looking get the land and spending money on whether we thought the land was any good why should we throw the money into that um if we're really not sure so I I I would I know you're just asking

134for approval but I I don't I don't want to sub the board to saying well yes if we approve it now we are approving a spending situation we don't have a plan for spending and we don't know who will spend a for and just some just some citizen experience of mine um when we get governments involved and sometimes government lawyers and I apologize upfront but they prolong issues for a very long time and gets very very costly so to politicians well that yeah so listen here's the here's here's here's the challenge that I'm going to put out to the board that we could either vote for this and be serious and and take the fight to the next level or we could just back off but I'm not going to waste my time I'm not

135have the committee waste their time if we're not going to in the end support the committee and support a fight for that funding because what we're saying is hey we want everybody to feel good but if you're going to really fight we want to maybe back off on the fight because it might cost us some money or it might get us bloody or it might get us into something that we don't want to get into all I'm asking for is if we're going to commit and my committee is going to fight I want us to fight hard and be able to have something at the end of that where we're going to have where we're going to have a victory not just Mr trell can can I respond to that because you're just asking us

136to explore you're not asking us to start a law in official in an official capacity where our district then could go we we I can reach out to other districts and say we're exploring a lawsuit and not have the the uh and not well who's exploring a lawsuit and is the board behind it is the administration behind it and I have to say well no but I'm the committee of fair funding and I think it would be a good idea yeah because um we cannot expend any money unless it goes to committee so if we explore and we decide as a board to do that we would go through the committee like we normally did we what four or five years ago did uh we did explore um going for a lawsuit and we had

137somebody from the state come in we had our attorneys come in and at that time we felt that it was not the right time or the right thing to do was going to cost us too much money but we we have I don't have an issue with exploring it again not costing us any money and meanwhile the committee the ad hoc could explore on this end seeing if there's anybody that would like to join us and and we're working together or maybe we can join them and that's the point Mr Ryback thank you um I just want to just follow up on what you said because it was it was right on this is just for an explanation uh exploration um maybe an explanation later on but little um you know we're not voting for

138a lawsuit no we have to find out and and I agree with you know Mr armino Mr braveman but you need to know that my impression of the people on this ATA committee is that there're a bunch of workers and these people will get out there and and and dig out this information and you could tell Ken's passion in this and and um we'll have answers for this board I'm confident that we'll have answers for this board and then we can decide what we want to do right now he's asking us uh for really basically for direction for for the uh for the for the committee and and some support in that area we don't know whether we want to approve a law law suit we don't know if we can afford it we don't

139know if we're going to anybody I don't know but am I willing I'm willing to find out sure and I know the people on this committee on the Ken leadership will do this very rapidly it won't take months I'm sure we'll have an answer within a month we'll be speaking with attorneys and other other uh districts Mr Russo I don't know maybe I'm speaking a different language I was saying that from the beginning we needed a strategy and the strategy would have included breaking us up into groups where we can go out and get all the information that we need to for approach a approach B approach C that's what we needed to do from the beginning what it looks like we're doing now and that's what worries me is we're trying the letter writing

140campaign through Greenstein and we think maybe it may not work and now we're going to look for a lawsuit and if we keep jumping around like that it's going to make the committee look very bad hold on hold on it's it's we're not jumping around and we're not and it's not going make the committee look bad like I said from the beginning we're we're that the letter the uh the the petition and going to Trenton was one part of a bigger picture of us doing a lot of things so a lot of people jumped on Facebook and a lot of people and some people came here and said it's a sham it's to get Senator Greenstein reelected and this and that and everything else those people are detractors those people don't want anything to succeed

141because if it succeeds then their agenda doesn't succeed my agenda is to get us funding my agenda is to is to is to get a tax break for our residents that's right and the only way to do that is to explore many different Avenues at one time because we don't have a lot of time so one of those Avenues would be exploring a lawsuit the other one is going to Trenton so just because you if uh if the if the board votes to say yes go ahead we could we could start looking into it it does not going to say hey May 2nd now we don't have to do that guys we could just take it out no and it does not mean we will file a lawsuit because again we would have to bring

142the information to the board the board would have to go through committee and the committee would decide whether to bring it to the full the feasibility of all of those options should have been done at the very beginning that's when this that's when the structure should have been set up that's what I'm saying that was my idea of joining such a committee okay months into I I just I just got on the board in January it's April so we've all we're already making noise and we're doing things this is the next step that's all listen if the board says no Then I know where we're at and and like Mr Braverman said maybe on May 2nd we'll go I'll wear aay I'll uh we'll have uh we'll have cookies and cream and slap everybody on

143the back and we'll go home and I'll be able to sleep and get rest I don't have to have any more meetings and I don't have to fight for funding and I don't have to spend weekends getting signatures I don't have to do any of that stuff Mrs Lang Ken so basically I because I I iic um totally support what you're saying so what you're asking is our permission to act as our representative and do the explorations talk to people and that's what you're asking for because as without the permission of the board you can't even say Monroe would like to talk to Kings Way about doing this am I correct great all right second your motion it's a collabor it's already been second great it's a collaboration between the ad hoc committee which is

144a board of education committee so we are responsible for what the ad hoc is doing in a way and there's no reason that the administration can't be doing some exploring on its own and working together with the ad hoc committee which is what the intent from the very beginning so and and they have so I I just want to say that also you know that that uh our administrators have been reaching out Dr kak has been reaching out to other districts but it's it's not and he's he's at all of our committee meetings so it's not that it's not that it's not being done it's that I want to be able to to be able to do it in an official capacity where we're saying can we go to that Next Level if somebody says

145to us are you interested in joining us to a la in a lawsuit that we could say yes we are interested we're exploring it and we well we could take it back to our board if there's anything if there's nothing new for the conversation maybe we can have a roll call okay so just can I just I'll just I'm just sitting here quietly we didn't know you were here I just have one one question so is what you're saying Ken and I love your passion it's great and uh it's infectious um is what you're saying as it stands now if you're presented with that question by Freehold for instance you don't feel you have the the jurisdiction to say yes we are interested in talking yes I don't I don't think we do I don't

146think I do and and I and I don't and again I don't want the committee to be to be tased with with um uh looking up information and spending all their time only to have the board later on say well we didn't even want to go in the direction of the lawsuit so why' you why'd you guys even go there and that's and that's really what I want to get ahead of you know if if the if the board is only happy with us doing this and getting petitions and sending letters then that's great and that's fine uh but if they want to do more if their heart is really in the fight Then I then I want to be able to take that fight to the next level and so this time we will

147have a roll call on if I haven't written down would you like me to repeat the motion just have one question would you like some kind of dollar amount that you can fall back on or not not at this time you don't need anything not at this time this is just another program where we're going to not well I I would imagine eventually we're going to have to whatever works for you we don't know this a feasibility money but not we don't need to spend money I don't think right now we need contact okay Madame board president motion on the floor moved by Mr cherella and seconded by Mr Lang is for the board to explore a lawsuit against the state for fair funding for Monroe yes of a roll call Mrs armeno I'm going

148to vote Yes but I would also like uh that the board does not disparage dissenting opinions and that and and and uh creates uh their P perception of somebody else's motivation as to why they speak up so uh yes I will support this but I think that everybody who has different opinions should be respected and not disparaged in the uh in the process thank you Mr Braverman yes Mr Chella yes Mrs Deo yes Mrs Lang yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr Russo yes it's uh long over two Mr rutsky yes and Mrs kapano yes mam board president motion passes unanimously I I think we're still on committees all okay um is there any other miss m Deo we had a curriculum committee tonight um we reviewed several documents a new Algebra 2 document that is uh

149better aligned with the Common Core um we also reviewed two um a functional math document and a functional language arts document these are for Falon life students from grades 9 to 21 years um and it teaches these um students uh life skills like giving change taking orders and how to navigate the world we also reviewed the summer reading um there was a lot of summer reading lists there was a lot of work put into this there was three months put into this a lot of collaboration between teachers administrators Library um personnel and um we reviewed um my notes are all over the place and they solicited the opinion of students so some of these books were recommended by students this will the the the summer reading list will be released May 11th to parents we

150also approved um a new club called the history Honor Society and um which the basis is it's you know a history basis is history we also talked about the tag program we are moving the tag program not all at once into cluster grades and what this is what this means is we are going to take tag students gifted and talented students and we're going to incorporate them into classrooms and that's like going to be four to eight students in a class and the rest of the class is going to be U mixed ability levels and um currently we're still keeping the after school program but over the next couple years we're going to start phasing out the after school program once we fully integrate the um cluster the cluster um program and that's it thank

151you anyone else hi mate Mr rutsky Finance finance committee we met last Monday the 17th happy to say this is nice and short um we spent a lot of time once again going over the budget obviously the presentation tonight went very well um so Kudos is there um that there was nothing for us to change or nothing for us to do um the one thing that we did discuss um that is on tonight's agenda is the Pupil Transportation Services proposal because we have a vacancy at the uh director of Transportation so we're bringing in um Pupil Transportation Services LLC to provide the transportation management services to the Board of Education during this vacancy period um starting now through let me see let me try it again has been found oh the new P this is

152from now till July 16th when the new Personnel uh the new director of transp ation comes on board thank you sorry uh this current Consulting transportation services will provide uh as needed Transportation Management Services during that period and um we thought the recommendation uh was good and agreed to put it forth on tonight's budget uh tonight's agenda that concludes my finance notes Mr Chella yeah I just I just want to uh thank you for that and that that that um that business is run by ingr Rano who was our for former uh director of of Transportation she's excellent so we're our our children our buses our transportation department will be in good hands yes excellent anyone else for a committee report does he have a committee report I know but he wasn't asked last time

153want to make sure he asked I'm sorry have a committee report sure Mr Braverman would you like to give your report no okay at least asked um we met the other day and all of these uh policies that you see in front of you on the agenda are all mandated policies uh Student Records the opio anecdote that uh going to be available in each school special education unsafe school choice option the one I don't remember is the independent study program why was that abolished yeah that was abolished because it's included in another program I mean another policy okay uh the public participation and board meetings this uh was passed and I don't know if Michelle you want to uh give us a Minority Report but feel free to do that uh went over it I

154I did ask where you were uh because I knew you had feelings about this um so do your thing just one other thing um the board I thought we were going to withdraw the uh wellness policy we are and I the reason why I left it on the agenda on the notes I put it's being sent back to committee and the only reason I left it on the agenda is technically if anybody from the public wanted to get up during a public spe uh session yeah okay they can only speak to items on the agenda but yes it's being sent back to the committee uh we've received comments from several parents I think there are some board members that have reservations about uh the you know the wellness committee was a committee of parents and

155administrators and they came up with a recommendation but the board I believe would like it to go back to committee to be reviewed okay so miss armeno can speak to that when Dr kak does his report oh okay I'll speak to it during the vote yes thank you okay so if there's no more the committee reports we're going to go to the public forum so anyone wishing to speak to anything on the agenda please come to the microphone and state your name and address for the record and we will adhere to our 3 minute time limit thank you my name is Heather Corona and I live at 225 Old Forge Road good evening Dr kak Dr alvic board administrators parents and guests my name is Heather Corona I'm a former teacher and a parent of

156two CH children in the Monro Township School District my 8-year-old daughter suffers from life-threatening food allergies and today it exploded on Facebook about the district wellness policy which I am a member of that committee I'm here to tell you that I'm for this new policy prohibiting treats sent in for whole classroom celebrations to be consumed by all of the children in the classroom ladies and gentlemen I'm here to tell you that it is every child's right to be safe and healthy in school we as parents can choose to pack our child's lunch and their snack appropriate for their children appropriate for our children whether they're dealing with obesity food allergies or other physician directed food restrictions such as diabetes ADHD or seizures we as parents should not be feeding other people's children during the school

157day birthday cupcakes can be enjoyed at home or at your child's birthday party a child in school should not have to wonder if a snack being served at a party is safe a teacher should not have that responsibility nor a nurse as a member of fair the food allergy research and education group I know firsthand about improper labeling of products and the constant recalls of such foods and labels even store-bought snacks are not safe 20 to 35% of children's daily calories are consumed during classroom celebrations which can include 20 to 25 birthday celebrations holiday parties and other things that the teacher would like to have in her classroom with the number of food allergy cases tripling it continues to be a threat to these students we are aware of safe snack boxes for students with

158food allergies but these children are being excluded 30 or more times per year lives are in danger children each day should only be exposed to Foods his or her parents have packed for them or agree that they purchase through the cafeteria or snack sale this new policy will not affect before or after school activities and events that we as parents decide to send our children to and pay for the nurses in our district have made it a position statement and they are in support of this policy for our schools for their parties celebrations and curricular program programs this alone should speak volumes we as parents and adults have the power to change the mindset that food is not necessary in school celebrations our kids will adjust we as adults need to grasp that a celebration

159is such because we're surrounded by our friends children will still get their birthday birthday certificate or pencil can still share their poster or have a special guest come and read holiday celebrations will still will take place they'll still have games crafts and activities and have a great time teachers are creative if I may finish my last thought yes please they will teach the phases of the moon without Oreos and they can do graphing without using Cheerios let's not back down to those that aren't research based or experience-based as we spent years developing this policy the only thing changing is that food will not and should not be served freely during the day to keep our students our children healthy and safe this is something we can all agree we want for our children all children

160matter and this policy is the best interest of all of our children who come to school to learn so Bard I urge you to vote Yes when the time comes because your child's birthday cupcake is not worth any child's life thank you thank you anyone else from the public I'm uh prash for up 33 drive I'm going to speak about Fair funding because the topic was the resolution passed I want to talk about that exploration of the lawsuit is what as is one of the item I support that with other districts but I went to the you know assembly presentation where the commissioner of Education was there and she was grilled by all the members there I saw that some assembly men who get for their schools about $400 million still acting like they don't

161get money and I saw that Commissioner of Education it was such a disappointing she could not answer much of the budget questions I feel that these politicians are going to kick their cans and nothing is going to happen till November so I agree with the adop Committee in adhoc committee we have discussed and we are going to explore because the plans and strategy changes with what is happening we can the plans will change to win we should change and accommodate to win and the Democrats and Republicans assembly men senators are discussing the new formula or how we can fund the current Formula we have to to make sure that our voice is there on those committees also so that we can cow what we need and I tell you I personally thinking that we have

162to be out of the box and think of the new formula ourself as a citizens in Canada the good education there of they don't need 12 billion to be spent 30% of of our state budget goes for school funding which is $13 billion 4.5 billion goes to pay the pensions and $9.5 million billion doll remaining goes to fund 30 districts we have 580 districts this is not fair and I tell you we are going New Jersey has become a welfare state we want to spend money and help the poor but we have to see how they come out and help the society again so I tell you our strategy I'm the member of ad committee I'll be working with the team our strategy is going to change with the time and we are going to

163work very hard and exploring the lawsuit is one of the strategy I want to work with our president Ken and everyone of you to make sure that we are successful November is not fast and we have to have also communication and take our community help okay thank you very much thank you anyone else from the public good evening my name is Lena San um my daughter is a kindergarten at Road um 24 Orchard Grove right in Monroe Township obviously um it's nice to put a face to some of the email addresses that I discovered earlier today um I'm speaking to the non-food school uh celebration section of uh the policy um and as I kind of mentioned earlier I I believe that uh well I believe this is drafted with a pure sense of wanting

164to help with allergies and and help things with childhood obesity I really think that this provision is drafted is too restrictive and it's taking the joy out of classroom celebrations and not just classroom celebrations like birthdays and things like that but additional things the Thanksgiving feast for instance that teaches history um cookie decorating parties joyful events that bring students together and in a community way food brings everyone together and I think you're losing a lot of valuable teaching moments when it comes to healthy food healthy living teaching moderation about treats and snacks and things like that um as someone who has recently published a baby food cookbook I've spent the last five years studying childhood nutrition from all around the world that includes school lunches around the world snacks around the world preschools daycares um

165schools that have Farm to school excuse me programs where we're teaching our children how to eat better and eat well and eat healthy um I think as I mentioned in some in my notes to some of you I think our energy should be directed at creating just a better nutrition program in general and that includes things like the school menu and lunch menus and things like that um and I do think it's important I think food is an important way to bring people together and something like a class celebration um which I know my my kindergartener has gotten a big kick out of it's taught her a lot about eating together and wellness and you know principles about when you can have treats and when you shouldn't have them and and moderation and I think

166that just eliminating everything kind of takes the joy out of such an innocent learning experience and while I appreciate that there are clearly safety all safety and Allergy issues I think there's got to be a way to kind of find a happy medium something that can just something that's drafted less restrictively um than this particular provision thank you hi my name is Christine Lester I live at 261 Cranberry haiger Road um um I'm a parent of three children all currently enrolled in the district um I have children with and without food allergies and I also have a child with um severe food restriction who was born without an esophagus um so I'm actually in favor of keeping the food policy as it is obviously being mindful of children with allergies um and everything like that

167as a room parent I've been fully able to accommodate children with an assortment of allergies and dietary and food restrictions um our biggest goal is inclusion in ensuring that every child is able to celebrate safely with their peers and has been able to accomplish this um even with the class of room of 30 when my child was on liquid feeds um I know that personally I've been able to send in a safe snack I've also given teachers um different like a Hershey's kiss that my child can have when he couldn't eat solid foods when that would cause him to have emergency surgery or he could choke and die um I know this this policy would also affect things in the classroom like we have Community Gardens in our schools and often the children will try

168new foods purely because they've planted it they've grown it um I don't want to see us like discourage that because we're implementing this food policy and then what do we do with all this food that we grow um I have a child that volunteers with cooking with friends she's concerned that this may affect that uh would the children be able to eat the stuff that they make would they be able to sell it I think that there are bigger ramifications of this policy most notably the that facts and um the fact that clubs and sports wouldn't be able to sell food to fund raise so they can't sell whole wheat pretzel but my child could go and get a Snickers bar from a vending machine and I don't think if we're looking at this policy

169for obesity and things of that nature it's kind of you have to kind of weigh it um if you're worried about allergies trust that our staff is beyond resourceful uh teachers improvise every day they will show you 50 ways to complete one math problem do you think that they can't find a substitute for a food um I can assure you that they can because they've been beyond accommodating for my circumstances and I've seen other children with circumstances um if your real concern is obesity then implementing this policy makes the district look extremely hypocritical you and in essence would be taking away a Class party where children are served items like a bagel with cream cheese fruit salad or yogurt um our lunch program the children are rushed through a lunch line um basically served appetizers

170if if you've been in our schools uh and as the last child goes through the line the lunch ladies will yell snack they take their full tray of food they T jump in the G um into the trash and they go in the line and they purchase ice cream they do funnel cakes now it's chips it's cookies with a child with an allergy that's usually where he's being associated with something that he shouldn't actually be having um I think if can I proceed are if it's very short I have like one more paragraph Okay um I I think that if we look at those type of activities where we have the vending machines and we have what we're pushing for the snacks like this might actually be something bigger to look at because I know

171second graders that will have an ice cream cone every day for lunch and they don't have you know they don't have they don't eat their lunch that's affecting them more than having apple slices when a teacher is doing an instructional thing about Johnny apple seed um in closing I would like to add that if we're really concerned about the OB Obesity part of this this um provision that we really need to look at other things um one of my suggestion is to not Institute a homework policy and I know that this seems like completely out there but my child and my children do homework till bedtime they want to ride their bikes they want to play sports uh the amount of homework that we give really impacts that so if we got children out moving

172and you know playing basketball riding their bike they would burn off that cupcake that they're having three times a year um again room parents have been exceptionally wonderful at providing uh snacks and everything keeping everyone safe that's one of the first things we discuss and generally parents that have food allergies are more than willing to help you accommodate do a classroom party do a different activity I've had my son War he couldn't eat anything slice a piece of pizza and slice the whole bottom off that he could participate that was one of the only times he could actually hang out with his peers and have food so that is my suggestion thank you so much thank you very much hi hello um my name is Jessica ISO I'm at 21 Oliver Street um I'm not

173really prepared to talk this was just a spur of the- moment thing and I want to speak in support of everything that Heather said um however my children I only have one child in the school I know she's a kindergartener um she doesn't have food allergies but I I feed her healthy foods and the problem is in school she's not she's being fed um junk garbage for example this week they had munchkins on Monday today they had cupcakes Friday is star student day and there's at least 20 kids in her class that's five months of Fridays uh Cupcakes Cookies something maybe somebody will bring in something healthier but um with my experience that's that's not the case so there have been several strings of weeks where she's just been fed garbage several times a week

174and I have no control over that I'm not going to single her out and tell her to not accept it she eats healthful foods but of course if you put a cupcake in front of her she's five she's going to she's going to take it and there's nothing I can do about that um I don't I I don't know how how to change this other than you know maybe put a cap on how many celebrations they could have it's it's excessive and it's affecting her negatively at home it makes her want more sweet treats celebrations aren't special anymore the celebration food is all the time cupcakes aren't special anymore um it it it's affecting our our outside lives I mean on the weekends you have birthday parties and you just think well all week she

175was eating cupcakes and cookies and stuff and and now on the weekend it's more it it lessens it it just lessens the joy that she has and we have in feeding her a special treat cuz it's not special anymore I I don't know how I can stress that anymore I it's excessive and I don't have any experience in the district to know that this isn't going to happen next year it's it's just getting worse the the sugar for the most part it's it's becoming part of our culture and we need to nip it in the bud because then she's gonna be and when my son gets into the school it's going to be expected and I think we're headed down a a really slippery slope thank you thank you hi cor Masters and I'm Michaela

176Court as a parent member on the school andless committee I was stunned along with four Educators in that building on the committee when we had our first meeting last month and found out that our board would be voting to make our district a no food District food is not only a necessity but part of our culture imagine a cultural Affair where there is no food for the children to learn about tasting and seeing it this may be their only opportunity they have to see and learn about this policy 8505 will allow for a provision for children with IEPs to continue to use food as needed for motivation rewards Health considerations and the like this is even more of a blinking light over that child now instead of a class reward only those with IEPs will

177receive it segregating those children further every holiday in our country has some food Association the kindergarten Thanksgiving feast will not see will not exist without food this wonderful celebration that has the am and the PM kindergarteners come together for the first time will be just another half day that they pass each other in the hallway the making gingerbread houses when a class studies Germany will be lost as well I understand that the principal or food Design's permission making a gingerbread house may still be allowed but telling the children that they can't eat it or take it home is disheartening my kindergarten is currently studying the five senses he brought home this culmination sheet on activity he did in class on Monday where he tasted a pretzel a lemon and a chocolate chip he then had

178to draw and write a sentence about how each one tasted this activity alone is covering art science and language arts in one lesson however with a no food policy in place this lesson will not be allowed when my older children were in first grade they did a mini unit on apples in for Johnny apples seed part of the lessons included tasting different types of apples sweetness tartness bitterness the class then had to vote on their favorite type from there they turned the results into a bar graph again covering many subject areas across the first grade curriculum this activity would no longer be allowed under such a policy if you ask a fourth grader what their favorite lesson is at Applegarth I can assure you that many will mention the New Jersey cake it's amazing to

179walk around that day and see how all the class cakes look similar and different children who have allergies always still participate in completing the cake and either eat a piece not containing the allergy food or they are offered something else both oak tree and Applegarth have amazing Gardens that the children work so hard on it will be sad when the food grows and they won't be allowed to eat the Bounty they they've become so vested in no one wants to have pick fruits and vegetables and tell them that they can't take them home or be eaten and they must be thrown away I attended the Avid meeting last night the adults as well as the children in the program talk about having a family atmosphere they even made a joke that the currency of avid

180was pizza they spoke about solving problems together while breaking bread this would no longer be allowed under the policy changes when I taught us history I divided the into decades Each decade I spent talking about music industrial achievements and inventions food was always included so when I spoke about 1900 to 1910 the class learned about the history of the ice cream cone being invented while having one this type of concrete claring is is definitely needed anytime I teach an Ela lesson I always do the how to make a peanut butter and jelly sandwich if students are allergic we went with a sunflower butter and jelly the students love it as they are perform their groups instructions literally never do students get a correct the first time but they eagerly edit their work to see if

181they can complete the task and snack on their accomplishments I have three sentences left I have former students that still remember some of these performances when completing these directions and these children are in their 30s now teachers and room parents are always able to find ways to work around any allergy parties may be healthier by offering fruit salad or Bagels these celebrations and types of teaching lessons should be allowed please do not stifle our teachers creativities because it only trickles down to our children thank you thank you good evening Chrissy scurby 21 pness drive I'm very happy to hear that this policy going back to the committee um to take a look at uh I'd just like to share my experience um last year after being redistricted to uh Brookside school um I was the

182room parent there and I got to witness the policy there at the school um before any party a menu was submitted to the nurse and the nurse went through I had to take pictures of the food labels and submit those as well the nurse went through she knew what students could have what foods in there and she approved or made changes to our menu a lot of parents a lot of room parents do try to incorporate a lot of healthy foods into uh the school parties um I I would I would really hope that this board takes a good look at that policy I know there's a lot of caveats in there and I think you need to really take a look at what you want to get rid of or or eliminate um for

183instance I know here at the high school there's cooking classes the children cook the food and then they eat it they consume it they make pies they make cookies they make muffins that's going to be a caveat that those children could eat that I don't have a say what my son's making in class what if I didn't want him to have a muffin but because it's going to be a caveat of the policy he'll be allowed to have it however my daughter in the elementary school won't be allowed to celebrate her birthday with a cupcake I I really think you need to take a good hard look at this policy and all the caveats I understand that there there will be certain treats that will be a allowed and for for certain things and and

184that's not right either you need to it's either all you're you're allowing food in for certain things or you're not but don't have a policy that's so open-ended that you have all these different caveats and it's not going to be clear have a clear policy I know Dr kak with the district education Council we talked about the this food policy round and round and round one of the things that I had recommended with other parents on the district education Council was not allowing home baked goods that is a a severe to me that's a severe issue that goes on you don't know what somebody's baking in their home you don't know what they're mixing a cake batter with that may be peanut free they could have made peanut butter cookies the night before with it

185that's something that I would like to see I would like to see you know home baked items taken out of the district you can have there are many many many peanut free and different allergy-free options with things like cookies and cupcakes so I'm I'm happy that you did move this back to policy and I hope the policy committee will really take a good hard look at that thank you thank you is there anybody left from the public who wants to speak okay seeing no one we will close the public forum and we will skip the superintendent report because it's getting too late well I do have person on board I'm only kidding okay all right be fast fast yes thank you yeah all right should I proceed then no yes please okay thank you madam

186president okay I'll be I'll be quick and still uh give all the value that it needs uh I before I um announce the Personnel I would just like to say we have a number of retirements on there and we normally recognize our retirees at the uh the June meeting the June board meeting uh and I would just like to publicly say uh thank you uh at this point for the the people who are listed on this agenda as well as anybody who maybe has been listed on uh prior agendas for their service to the children and the community in this District uh there's varying levels of of time that these people have put in but uh I think I can speak that each and every one of these people have really um worked hard to

187improve the lives of children so thank you for to those uh teachers and and staff members with that I recommend to the board uh for under Personnel items a through a uh J second Mr cherella and Mr Mayo comments or questions for the superintendent seeing none we'll go to the roll call Mrs armeno uh yes Mr Braverman yes Mr Chella yes Mrs Deo yes Mrs Lang yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr Russo yes Mr rusy yes and Mrs kapano yes mad board president personal items a through J has passed thank you okay action okay uh thank you Manor president and for uh the board action items a through o with the note that the policy um I want to give it the correct title uh the wellness policy nutrient standards for meals and other foods that

188uh in that is in letter N is being yes it I'm sorry yes thank you Mr Aro 8505 is being sent back to committee is there a motion Mr tiella second second by Mr Mayo any comments or questions by the board M armino on item J do we have a total um of the Avid implementation agreement of what it costs per year and and I apologize if I haven't seen it as a line item in the budget I mean I know you enumerated all these which is I'm grateful for but is this let me ask the question do you have a total I don't I do not have the total um but if you add up all of those that that is the total and it is the same same cost as last year okay

189it did not increase okay thank you um and then I'll go to m I have a question uh well I'll make my statement about public participation at board meetings I think that uh first question I have on here is to make sure that we are retaining the three public portions on the agenda yes that's not being changed that is not being changed okay uh my comment is on um the rules the public participation shall be CED by the following rules especially on number item two it says that the statement made by a participant shall be limited to 4 minutes duration or less but that four minutes includes any response by a representative of the boards to part uh to the participants's question and it says the clock will run continuously during any such question and

190answer exchange at the end of the four minutes the participants time shall be over I have always objected to any curtailment of public involvement and public participation in this uh meet at meetings um you dissent and protest is the Bedrock of our democracy sometimes we don't like what we hear from um our citizens at the podium however I think it is our responsibility as elected officials who represent those very citizens to hear uh what they have to say uh people are passionate even on the board and sometimes the language is is is uh somewhat um harsh sounding or costic um and yet we listen I think there should be no um curtailment of uh the participation by the public and they should if you want to give them three minutes fine if you want to

191give them four minutes but they should not be interrupted um I have witnessed as a citizen participant in Monroe for many years um in other uh Council meetings and things like that that sometimes the uh Representatives or the officials take up all the time and then they ask you to leave every person has something to say it's important whether we agree with it or not I would ask my colleagues who have many of them on this board who have used the podium as um you before they were elected to talk about transparency to to get their voices heard I would ask them to protect the public who we honor we should be honoring and we should be supporting and allow them to speak uh for three minutes um otherwise I I would also like to

192ask what the goal of these changes to the policy actually is why why do we feel the ne necessity to change it someone can answer that I'd appreciate it well I'll answer that um we're giving people more time to speak but there have been a lot of complaints about people who get up and ask a lot of questions and every time they ask a question we turn off the time and we answer the question questions and some people have gotten 10 to 15 minutes of conversation um and some people who just make a statement only get three minutes then we stop the clock statement is over um I was going to hold this off to my my board report but um recently Patty and I attended a New Jersey school board school public relations Forum

193Workshop where we received a nice book about the fundamentals of school board membership and I believe everybody on the board should have this because it's it's really good but they say in here and this is just New Jersey school boards that it is important for board members and the public to to understand that no response is required during the public comment segments this is not a time for individual board members or administrators to be put on the spot this is the part of the meeting in which we we the board can hear your input it is not meant to be a dialogue nor would it be appropriate for us to necessarily respond to any questions I've done research I know other board members have done research in what happens in other districts so far we

194are the only District that I know of that does a Q&A I do not want to stop the Q&A I think it's important to continue having the Q&A I think we just need to limit everybody who needs to speak if if there's a lot of questions from people in the in the public or the audience and they come up they have the opportunity to submit questions and I know that's what a lot of other districts do they submit questions beforehand so that the answers are there um I know that we have a member of the public who does that but it's to it's to ctail what we do here is this is the board's working meeting and we are here to listen to the input from our public like we did this evening with the

195um wellness policy and that's what we're supposed to do I even went to my HOA in Florida and they do not allow Q&A during that when they have their public so that's what we're trying to do is make this fair to everybody make it fair to our administrators so that nobody's put on the spot and that's why um change in the policy okay I'd like to respond to that um I appreciate uh that other people don't do it that doesn't mean we can't rise to a better level I mean we have over adequacy uh in our education we are proud that we go well beyond uh what is expected of us as a as a educational District I can't see why we can't have a better uh to me it's service to the community uh

196if it is an inconvenience and I apologize I know the administrators put in long days but this is an opportunity for the community to ask questions and get answers I also think that when I was sitting in the audience many years when someone asked a question and I heard an answer it might not have been something I would have thought to ask but I was happy to have the information it is all about public participation we asked this community to support our budgets to support the taxes and yet we asked them to sit down after 3 minutes or we don't let them finish their statements I find it um that we can go above and beyond what is you know what is uh ordinary and I've I and a lot of municipalities and a lot

197of government officials don't want the public to participate and to me this is this is showing that that is exactly what we're trying to do we're trying to limit public participation I would ask my colleagues to remove that language and not and have either have the public be respected enough to to have their questions answered thank you anyone else Mr rutsky can I rebut that you can respond to that I'm pretty sure what I just heard Kathy say was we are going to continue to do un allow Q&A and we're extending it from three to four minutes we just don't want it to be extensive for everybody I think within four minutes questions can be asked sometimes answers can be given but in no way shape or form did did I hear anybody say we're

198not allowing the public to ask questions and expect answers back Kathy just said we're going to continue the practice if if I understood correctly of answering whenever possible I do not want to stop the Q&A I think we've done that I think it's important I think it makes our district stand out from other districts I just think that there needs to be a limit in how much every person can stand up and talk agreed and I'll actually say as Jamesburg so we follow that lead and and and because of what we've seen you do here over the last few years we similarly extend the Q&A as best we can until it gets to a point where we have to ask people respectfully will'll get back to you so I think and again I've been to

199other board meetings too and I agree with you a lot of board meetings it's strictly State your question or concern thank you very much next so I think we are going above ordinary with all due respect I absolutely ordinary doesn't even come into the equation when it comes to this Board of Ed and and what what everybody does so that's just my rebuttal Cathy Mrs SL I I'd like to say as as a new board member and somebody who's spoken in front of the board uh often to have four minutes to get my thoughts together to give my opinion and to express my concern is so much nicer than 3 minutes because I I know that I always tried to work within that three minute cycle and tell you and I know that you were

200listening and I know that people were hearing and I think that's what the real part of what the public forum is is for us to hear and I know I heard the parents speaking tonight both sides about their concerns over the wellness policy and even there are districts around this state that actually make you submit questions in writing prior to a board meeting I think that's very restrictive I think we have our state board of education who doesn't even allow you to make com public comments in front of the whole board you go to a separate meeting and there might be two people one who is usually playing on his cell phone who is listening to your comments so I think that in at of respect of all of those well most of you people

201work and I don't but out of the respect of the hours that we put in and the the hours that are going on there has to be a fairness and I did find at times for myself when there were people who stood that microphone and with the clock stopping and starting and clock stopping and starting getting 10 to 15 minutes of time when I stuck to my 3 minutes it was frustrating so I thank you for this policy and I support it and and if you look at today's agenda we have four public Forums on our agenda so I don't think we're not giving the public the opportunity to speak I I just think that when you when you take the Public's time as when you say the response the four minute shell include any

202response if you remove that language I would be happy with the four minutes for sure I think when you take the Public's time to respond that is a distraction one uh from their concerns and to uh again you know what are they what are they paying 87% of our budget I think we should hear them 100% thank you any any anyone else comments or questions yeah I I would just like to say it I don't think it matters whether you have four minutes or 10 minutes or 20 minutes the chairperson has the flexibility to pretty much wrap the gavel when they would like so at this time we'll have a roll call Mr Gorski Madame board president for clarification item n on board action items a through o is being tabled we're not voting on

203N it's going back to committee correct no we're we're voting on policy 0155 policy 8505 is going back to the committee so 8505 is the only part of n that's tabled yes yes understood and is isn't and I think p167 is this is a is a revision so it's really not as it's not here for a first reading it's not an introduction we've always had a participation in board meetings policy I I checked with the attorney today and she said that that policy also needed two readings she said that yes she did and I probably have some I wish I had a law degree because then you might listen to me Mrs armeno uh yes on everything except uh on M policy 165 and on N policy 0155 which is board committees uh I think

204that a president uh is part of the whole board and should not be um unilaterally making decisions about uh committees and and shrinking the Committees in our district where we're growing very large and if we put committees together that eliminates um that eliminates board members from participating and we're also um I think giving uh presidents any president unilateral decision making uh and excluding uh a board members so I I object to 0155 board committees also so Mrs armeno in my understanding that that's a no on M 165 and N 0155 that is correct thank you you is it 167 I'm sorry 167 on M as in Mary and on N is in Nancy policy 0155 so noted thank you Mr Braverman yes Mr Chella yes Mrs Deo yes Mrs Lang yes Mr Rybeck Yes except

205for n policy 0155 I'll vote no so noted Mr Russo yes and no on 0155 well thank you Mr rutsky I'm going to abstain on all of them because all be it a few have asterisks I believe the asteris are incorrect on some not on others so I'm just going to abstain from the whole thing so noted Mrs kapano yes motion passes thank so does that conclude your report yes that concludes my report Madam president thank you okay so we will go to the business administrator report Mr Madam board president president and members of the Monro Township Board of Education it is recommended that board action items a through R be approved by consent roll call so move Mr Chella second by Mr Ryback comments of questions for Mr Gorski seeing none we'll have a

206roll call Mrs armeno yes Mr Braverman Mr Braverman yes thank you sir Mr Chella yes Mrs Deo yes Mrs Lang yes and recuse on n on M I think I had a recuse on N I travel I recuse on N thank you Miss Lang let the minutes reflect Mrs Deo recuses on n as well as Mrs Lang Mr Rybeck yes Mr Russo yes Mr rutsky I'm going to vote on this one because I think these are correct so this is a long list so pay attention yes sir I abstain with the exception of items A1 A3 c e f g i k l and m where I vote Yes l and l and m m Mary Mary so noted thank you very much excellent thank you Mrs Cole Pano yes madame board president motion passes

207that concludes my report thank you okay so uh board president's report and I'm going to be quick um I wanted to speak about that policy and I did um then I I um will say again Patty Lang and I attended a New Jersey school board school public relations Forum Workshop where we received a lot of valuable information on communication working with the media getting our message out to the public and I think this was very helpful and going to be very useful with our both our Fair funding fight and our upcoming referendum um for those of you in the public the the fair funding the ad hoc committee now has a Facebook page and I think it's fair school funding for Monro Township Fair school funding for Monroe Township so we will be doing a

208lot of input on that and getting um any updates and funding information regarding that um and then second I'd like to thank the ptas for the um paying for the cost of the buses to our trip next uh last Monday um and for everybody who supported our petition Drive I think we were over about 8,000 signatures which I think was phenomenal considering that we had an 8 day um Hiatus from school for spring break and um I I I think in that two and a half weeks that we collected signatures I'm I'm very happy with the the support that we got from the um community and everywhere that I went people were aware of the funding fight and the petition and I think that was really really good so I thank the public for that

209so at this time we'll go to Other Board business anybody from the board Miss Miss D I have two things um the first one is I was reading an article in Asbury Park Press and it seems that there is a special education school that we send a student to that has been audited and it has been found that they have been over billing districts and I don't know if that affects us in any way but um I think we need to find out okay so I'm just I'm making a motion that we just ask our Administration to research this we we don't have to we don't have to do a motion I'm we don't have to do a motion we don't do we I can just we can but uh we we hereby test that

210we will research this we have one student there right uh we have been discussing this with board attorney she is all over this as we to and um you know the safe guarding of students is Paramount in all cases as well as the financial um interest of paying for their private education out a district education so you know we're on top of it to the extent we can okay it's regulated by the Department of Education as you know right um but you know we we'll do a weend okay and I have another thing okay so funding is a big issue that we've been talking about and in February the governor gives his budget address and then the legislators have a listening session in February and March and what this is is the assembly budget committee

211and the Senate budget approach Creations committee both have two sessions usually one in North Jersey and one in South Jersey where anybody can go and speak about anything and usually people most people or groups talk about funding issues I signed to I signed to speak up to both committees unfortunately because of the snowstorm and delayed School opening I was unable to speak at the assembly budget committee meeting but I still submitted my testimony that all the legislators received I did make the Senate budget and Appropriations Committee meeting in New York last month and I want to read my testimony um I also called the mayor's office and asked him to submit his testimony to the Senate budget and Appropriations Committee because I felt the more you know squeaky wheel so I'm just going to read

212it for you thank you chairman sarlo and the entire Senate budget and Appropriations Committee for giving me the opportunity to speak today my name is Jill Deo and I'm a parent of two boys in the Monroe Township School District of middlex County and a member of the Monroe Board of Education I'm here today as a parent and My Views don't represent that of the board and I'm not authorized to speak on the board's behalf I am I'm here to talk about how flat funding of state aid to school districts have impacted my district Monroe is a rural District but we are growing quickly over the past nine years we have seen approximately 1,700 new students and we are estimated to get another 1,500 new students in the next 5 years next year excuse me next

213year alone we are estimated to get 427 new students despite all this growth we've had Flat state aid for the past seven years during this time time we've built a new elementary school and a new high school but we still have over 1,000 unhoused students in addition to the growing student population as a result of this growth we need another new Elementary School a middle school and addition onto the high school in next year's budget alone we need 30 new staff four buses two Vans three additional drivers with benefits and $1.8 million in facility upgrades such as in roof replacement we are seeing class sizes of 30 or more kids and at 201819 we will have to invest in trailers until we can build new schools trailers will cost between $1 and $2 million this

214money is an expenditure and not an investment it doesn't create Equity it will have to supplement programs and services that we may need and it will use almost all of our state aid I can't emphasize enough how little we get in state aid our current state aid for the 20167 school year is approximately $3 million for 5700 students that's about $500 per student here's a list of what our neighbors get Oldbridge with 7,000 students get 45 gets $45 million which accounts for approximately 5,800 per student South Brunswick with 7700 students gets $24 million that's approximately 3,000 per student East Brunswick with 7,400 students gets million which is about 2400 per student East Windsor with 4,500 students gets 188 million that's about 3,900 per student cranberry with 428 students gets $476,000 in state aid that's about

2151,00 per student we are not wealthier than any of these other districts furthermore based on the last federal census onethird of our population is older than 65 years of age and on fixed incomes 87% our school B school budget is funded through local property taxes that's approximately $109 million funded by 30% of retirees because of the growth they have been burdened with yearly tax increases to cover the cost of the expanding needs of the school district the hold harmless provision of the school funding Reform Act of 2008 is hurting District like ours with growing student populations while benefiting those who have shrinking populations I'm asking you to work towards fully funding the formula and get rid of the hold harmless provision and add a provision to increase funding for districts with growing student populations such

216as Monroe my testimony um was very well received um chairman sarlo had said we've heard of Monroe we keep hearing about Monroe um of the 26 people speaking during the session I was one of six who spoke about school funding which was a lot um I've been going to the state house since 2010 when Monroe's budget was cut to $200,000 I've spoken at many of these um meetings the first meeting I ever spoke at was the Senate B budget and Appropriations Committee meeting and when I talked about fully funding the formula one of the Senators got kind of nasty with me and told me we will never fund that formula this same fun Senator the same Senator this year is now speak speaking a different tune and wanting more money for this senator's district and

217that I feel like I saw the tide turn and I feel like the Senators are really and legislators are really listening to us and they they are they are taking notice I mean things have changed a lot so that's it thanks well thank you for your continued support and Trenton of us that's much appreciated um any other board business Mr Rybeck I just want to add to what Mr Mayo said and thank you for all the work you've been doing all all these years um one of the things that our petition is saying and that we've been saying to all all the legislators is that we want to see action before November there's no clear and I think that's something that we sort of left out in all the things that we've been saying that

218we have to underscore that we're telling them we want to see action by before election day in November so um clearly they get the message that their jobs are on the line based on what on um results that we get I think we kind of saw that on on Monday that they they know anyone else Miss Armenia yes um I am grateful for all of the action um taken on the state level but um I'd like to remind our um citizens that on the local level it's equally as important because 100% of the planning in Monroe is done by our local officials and 100% of all the residential construction is reviewed and approved by the township Council and the planning board and just on that note um it's also as an aside it's ironic that

219Mr sarlo uh Senator sarlo is on that committee because he is responsible solely for an act called the sarlo act that changed Monro that allowed a change in Monroe's development uh for instance one one property had 29 uh it was originally zoned for 29 houses and It ultimately because of the sarlo Act was allowed to have 130 on the same parcel of land there are two Parcels in Monroe that the sarlo ACT contributed to an intense development uh residential development that has complicated our enrollment issues um but I'd like the the public to know that on Thursday the planning board will be reviewing uh Monroe 33 developers LLC and they're going to put 150 residential units in or they're asking for in the application 90 tow houses 60 apartments and that's all also uh a

220subdividable parcel um and that is residential on what was previously commercial zoned uh the next one on uh this Thursday at the planning board is US homes and they're going to put create and I'm reading this directly from the agenda create units 457 detached units and 130 duplex units so what goes our enrollment is 100% um conditioned on what goes on at the local these local meetings so I encourage our citizens not only to look towards the state uh officials but look towards our local officials for Relief thank you thank you any anyone else okay so then we can go to the public forum again another public forum anyone wishing to speak about anything please come to the microphone and state your name and address for the record we will adhere to our three minute

221policy prakash parab 33 daa drive if we are talking to the lawyer is advising you all on the policy please tell the lawyer that when you revive is the policy I want to know what the revision is because today I read the public participation policy what are the changes I don't know when I read this I don't know what was the previous policy and what changes are made so I object to this I think this is the first Hearing in the second hearing please I would like you all to I object this is my objection to the lawyer that any policy changes I would like to see we as a Citizens like to see what are the changes because here when I read I don't know what was the previous and what is the change

222and I object to that completely and I think the chair has any time chair is responsible I respect the chair anyone is going over time asking many questions you can cut them short but please sometime the discussions are more the questions are more so all public to participate thank you thank you anyone else from the public okay seeing no one we will close the public forum and go to close session be it resolved that the Board of Education of the township of Monroe hereby moves to go into Clos session in accordance with the Sunshine Law chapter 231 of the public laws of 1975 njsa 10 colum 4-6 through 10 colum 4-21 to discuss the following subjects harassment and intimidation and bullying negotiations following closed session action may be taken the discussion conducted in closed session

223can be disclosed to the public at such time as the need for confidentiality no longer exists second is that a motion motion Mr cherella Mr Ryback all faor have I have a question what are the negotiations that we will be discussing with the mtea so these are mtea I would ask um that that would be stated and stipulated on uh the next resolutions the specific negotiations I mean I was not aware of what for myself I wasn't even aware of what negotiations we'd be discussing I think it's it's part of the open public meetings act that says it should be clear what we're discussing not just by title thank you all in favor I opposed then we will move into close s you're opposed I won't attend I have to refuse myself okay yes from

224negotiations if Michelle okay at this time we will move back into public session and seeing no one in the audience we will go to the next schedule Board of Education meeting which is May Wednesday May 10th 2017 7:00 p.m. at the high school we'll we will be honoring our teachers of the Year motion to adjourn motion second Mrs Lang all in favor I opposed extensions and meeting is adjourned

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.