001I'm trying I keep on saying start it keeps on throwing me out um I don't know why let say all right well you guys start and I'll continue to play with this how's that can you see me now I did before we saw you your picture did come up before don't worry about me well I'll figure it out okay welcome everybody you so in ter of the order Miss Bora or Miss Alvarez um yes if we could start with uh Mr Barona and the athletic update and then he can run back we have a game going on right now and I just want to make sure he can uh get over there you know without uh absolutely absolutely how are you feeling Mr brandic are you feeling better now better I I endured the the
002F last week I was down and out for two days unfortunately Mr Dr Layman has shared that there's a flu going around yeah but I'm back so that's good okay good news um so yeah so I I wanted to talk real quick about um ice hockey in particular uh we're in a situation right now where based off the numbers in the last couple of years we have had some decline in the um in in the amount of athletes that we've had in the program uh right now for next year uh I am exploring the possibility of us uh entering into what we call a co-op uh which which is where we would essentially join another school in order to be able to have a program as the numbers that we expect for next year will
003not allow us to have um or to be able to run our own program so we have about 11 student athletes that we expect to come back next year one of the problems that we have is that four of about four of them are going are goalies by position so really kind of puts us in a situation where we again based off the the amount of goalies that we have and the amount of players that we have it it would it wouldn't be um realistic for us to be able to run a program so I have done my a little bit of research reached out um to to you know to see what options we have um Hillsboro is a is a school that matches up pretty well with us uh they're also a group
004four school um and essentially they need what we have a lot of which is again goalies and and again and based off the type of athletes that we have uh we have been a very competitive program so I would want to match this up with a school that is also obviously competitive um as our student athletes are are used to you know used to good competition last year we were GMC Champions uh tomorrow we play for the GMC championship in ice hockey again um so I know that you know our our our team would want to find obviously a good program to kind of match up with so I have had some preliminary conversations with Hillsboro um what we would essentially need is we would need the conferences to approve um a change as the
005Hillsboro team is part of what we call a skying conference and we're part of the GMC conference uh the skying conference is more competitive so we if we did uh search to do this uh it would mean we would essentially be joining basically their team um the way that it would work is I would have conversations with the athletic director to set up somewhat of an agreement of what would happen with coaches uh you know fees like uh ice you know ice fees would be shared between both programs um you know again depending on how we kind of um you know work that agreement uh based off the way that kind of things look right now uh we would request most likely to keep two coaches um and transer ation being funded through our through
006our through our district um and then we would be able to split things like the the ice rink which is the most expensive piece of um of ice hockey um they they usually uh played out of proskate which is actually in South Brunswick which is nice for us because it would mean that our team would have to go to an closer ice rank than when we actually go right now right now we play at of JSA um a Jersey Shore Arena um so again it is a little further away so the switch would be nice for us as our student athletes and families would be able to travel to a closer ice rink um right now the only really uh the only thing that that I'm asking is just again I wanted to kind of
007put it out to to to the board so that you guys can you know can can think about it um the process uh that that I need to follow is I need to submit an application State siaa uh by April so uh I'm going to sit down with the other school to kind of hash up more of the more of the details uh to then come uh to the board and march with a formal you know somewhat of an agreement for you for the board hopefully to to um to consider approving for us but I'll take any questions as to you know kind of how the process works and you know all those types of things I have one question on that Mr BR so I know done your research is there any possibility that
008we could gets coming into the freshman year like is there a way to backtrack this say we you know we make all the arrangements with pilboro but then next year we have a team or the year after we have a team so what happens if we do have a team yeah so so again I I our coach uh Mr Feliz is pretty pretty uh pretty in tune with you know what the numbers look like you know um you know for the next couple of years uh typically when you enter a co-op um the state does approve the co-op for a two-year period um after that two-year period we would have to renew those contracts so basically let's just say if we enter into a co-op and the state were to approve it we would be
009essentially locked in for two years I don't think our numbers would change drastically um between next year and the year after that especially with some of the you know some of the upper classman that would again graduate next year so I don't think that as of right now we foresee that changing after the two-year period we would absolutely reevaluate it and again with how early we were you know we're always looking into into the budget um I would do my due diligence to make sure that I'm looking in for seeing you know to see kind of where we may fall to see before why would even apply for a for you know for a second um Co-op if again if if there's no need for it then we would absolutely rather fund our own program
010I don't have any other questions anybody else please go ahead thank you Mr brand yeah I have one yes just in terms of cost is is this would this be costing the district more money the same or no so we would be we would be saving um we would be saving uh definitely um again let's just say for the ice for example our current contract right now for ice I believe is around 36,000 is what we pay alone just for the ice um in this case we would let's just say we keep 16 student athletes in the program we would divide the cost and have like a per pupil uh cost and then like let's just say if I have 10 student athletes um and we say it's you know $2,000 per student athletes we
011would only pay you know the other school for that so we would be saving significantly on the amount of ice time that that we um that we pay as we would be essentially splitting that cost how many students are there currently on the team uh right now we have I want to say about 16ish 16 17 okay and what's the maximum number uh there is no specific maximum number some schools carry you know enough athletes to be able to run a varsity and a JV program last year I did have we were able to have a varsity and a JV program but our numbers again uh came down a lot from last year to this year so this year we only ran a varsity program and now unfortunately the next year we're running into a
012situation where we can't we won't be able to run a VAR City program okay thank you so this is best the world we continue to keep the program but our costs will come down correct our costs would come down the only thing that I have uh had a conversation with Dr Layman about is are the current contract that we have with the ice rink um does have one more year in it however that they are also the same owners of prate which is where we would be essentially requesting to go um so in the interim between now and when I whenever I submit a formal proposal to you know to the board I would also have that conversation with the with the um with the ice uh with the ice company just to make sure
013you know um you know what what would happen with that with the last year of the contract but again we would be essentially getting into a new contract with the same company uh so but I will have those conversations in order again to to present everything to the board um all at once anybody else any questions thank you so much Mr Brandy awesome thank you Dr L who sure why don't we do the uh curriculum document so miss Gasco has one curriculum document Miss Gasco all yours we have to unmute yourself Miss Gasco now I'm good right okay I'm out of practice since Co days um I have two outstanding curriculum documents one is going to be for tonight um what happened is that I've had a teacher that was out on maternity leave so
014she wasn't able to finish it and when she came back she finished it up for us and it is the Dynamics of Algebra 2 um the standards changed to 2023 so we had to update our documents but once you got to the algebra 1es and the algebra 2os there weren't too many changes just a couple manyi tweaks to it um they deemphasize some of the probability and statistics which is good for a class like dynamics of Algebra 2 because that was difficult for them and another one of the major changes which um it would look something tiny in the document to you guys is that when you're graphing exponential and logarithmic fun functions um they want it where you're showing intercepts and end behavior and in the past in the 2016 standards there was an
015expectation that there would also be trigonometric functions showing period midline and amplitude and that was very complicated so I think they realized that um Algebra 2 is a very very jam-pack curriculum so they kind of tweaked it a little bit some of the changes that we made to the Dynamics Now understand this is a course for students that struggle and they need this course for graduation um we have added in a unit that we were doing anyway but was not actually officially in the document and it is to start out with factoring while it is technically an algebra 1 topic um it needs a review and it is something they absolutely need to have mastered in order to be able to go further with the course so that unit was created from scratch just so
016if a teacher were to start teaching this they would have that as a guideline as to where to go and where to start um the following units 2 through seven the standards were updated um the cross-curricular all had to be updated so it includes 2020 career Readiness and life literacy and key skills um there are in the cross-curricular the New Jersey TW uh 2023 language art standards those were updated along with the math um there's some critical thinking and problem solving into the the computer science area um the New Jersey science and engineering practices were included and then um the English language development also had there um some of the few things that got added were um having the L learning plan was actually much more detailed so again so somebody new to the course
017would have more ideas of what to do um one of the things that we had to add in in terms of the standards was explicit examples of climate change um they did in the new standards give us examples to use so those were embedded into it um the te technology was double checked and updated to make sure that they were examples that could be used one of the big ones is Desmos that we have that we have been using when it's appropriate it doesn't always have to get used but they have some great lesson plans and activities that can be embedded and then tier one two and three um in terms of um uh vocabulary we added in so again there's not major changes that were to it it was basically tweaked so that it
018actually works for the students the way it should be um and then all of the standards have been changed Going through so um and again the technology we're really trying to infuse potential technology that can be used especially with the inclusion of iPads that we have does anybody have any questions I may have a very um BL blaming dumb question so this is different from Algebra 2 so the standards for algebra number two um are the same in terms of what has to get covered but the way it is taught and the level of rigor and the level of abstractness is changed so this is the lower level of the courses so this is meant for students that really really struggle so you're not going to have as complicated of problems you're not going to
019have the detail go into as much abstractness it's a difficult course for students and it's needed for graduation so the three different levels it's not a matter of just having harder problems and more home homework it's really the depth of the way the understanding goes into it and the amount of detail that goes into um the abstractness so this is more the basic level basic problems um you wouldn't teach this level to all students because it wouldn't prepare them for the higher level classes to the same degree but the students that take this class are identified be before they start Algebra 2 so they they're only taking dynamics of Algebra 2 and not Algebra 2 am I understanding that right so so they would the the more typical track right and students move up and
020down a little bit might have been they might have struggled an eighth grade Algebra 1 which is pre-algebra um and the program of studies has guidelines as to what to go through then they might go into algebra 1ab which we've talked to before and which them algebra one every day so that they can try to get the foundation if they're still having difficulty learning math and it's something that's difficult for them they would most likely go into dynamics of geometry than dynamics of Algebra 2 so it is the most discreet most um basic level of the concepts I'm I'm I explain that right you would and then like if it's not it's College Prep still but it would be college prep for students that really struggle with math so it's it's to get them so
021that they understand the concepts and they can learn it but they might not be able to go through and do the hardest of the types of problems understood I wasn't even aware that we had that sort of uh a class there but yeah you started off by saying you have two curriculum documents but you there's only one attachment yes so I I have two outstanding for the year and the next one is literally done I have to review it and that one's done by a different teacher who is about to go out on maternity leave um so hers is is going to be in for review and should be up for the next time around okay I don't have any more questions anybody else please go ahead yeah I you know I I looked at
022the curriculum and you know I'm always um as I mentioned before I I think it's a great document but the document itself is dealing with um higher level it's still moving the taxonomy of learning is still moving from the very very low um level all the ways up to I guess analysis and synthesis correct um I mean at least that's what I'm they have to be able so they have to be able to transfer the concepts to different equations right but they're not going to be the the hardest of the problems so the state requires that we cover all the standards so all the standards have to be covered it is the degree of difficulty of the problems that they're going to practice and it's going to be the way it's going to be taught
023too um there might not go there's not going to necessarily go into the proof of every type of problem that they have in why it's going to be an explanation of why maybe a visual of it and then they're going to go through there so um you know Algebra 2 you can cover the same type of material let's just say exponential growth with any different types of level of problems the question is going to be how abstract and how difficult are you going to make the problems yeah because you know when I looked at the curriculum um and again uh when I just look at it my initial response and I I I came away from it understanding that it was a a program for kids who are having difficulty with math but yet some
024of the the ways things were stated in the curriculum itself I it just was I'm not sure they can reach those levels even though I know what you're I know I understand what the attempt is believe me I do understand what you're trying to do I understand how certain kids just have major issues with math and so you're trying to to get them to understand it from a different perspective I have to assume that so to yeah get ahead please so it might be that some of the problems that you would expect students to do independently and regular Algebra 2 or especially in an honors Algebra 2 um you might work with them and guide them and give them guided help in terms of how to see how it's applied so they're still going to
025see some of that in terms of the more difficult ones but in terms of getting them for what they retain you're going to make sure that you're going to give a level of problem that they can understand we have to still cover all of the standards we can't cut out some of those so I'm not sure if the question is you think some of the content is too difficult um some of the content is ated by the state we have to cover it it's just a matter of how much guidance we give them in terms of trying to get them through the problems it might be a problem that takes less steps to do than a more complicated one for another level class no no I I I I do understand exactly what the attempt
026is and I commend you for trying that and for trying to get kids to in fact take an algebra to class um so if you can move kids who have some reluctancy I I think that's great so I I can tell you the teacher that wrote it she actually currently teaches it and has taught the course in the past so she has firsthand experience of putting in examples that she knows has worked in her class and things that she's done so this isn't really done in theory this is actually in practice what's being done thank you very much Gala oh okay my my mute button was stuck um anybody else any questions all right we thank you so much uh Miss Gasco I think we can move on to the next item um Dr Layman
027what would you like to take up uh let's do the summer programming update so that's Mr morala and Miss Gasco as well excellent all Dr Layman can you hear me okay uh good evening everyone um we are uh happy to present our our beginning of our course catalog for the upcoming summer uh programs that we're excited to continue with this year I know it sounds crazy given the fact that it's not even halfway through February yet um and that it's about snow but um we are ahead of schedule and for very purposeful reasons because we have made some adjustments to our program that we think um our community will be excited to to get their head hands around uh as they begin to start thinking about what they're going to be doing with their children
028over the summer um we uh historically our summer program has been limited to Enrichment Services and Remediation Services um and we feel like those programs have been delivered uh with Fidelity and uh every year we've added programs and the students um and these programs have aligned directly with our curriculum and our co-curricular activities throughout the district in a variety of content areas and every year in our after action review uh one of the areas and opportunities for growth in our SWAT analysis uh always tended to gravitate back towards the possibilities um for our high school students and uh this year we're excited because we've taken a giant step in that direction um it's something that we've been looking at for a couple years now and um Mrs Gasco and Dr Higgins at the high school
029um along with Dr Layman's office uh we we've finally been able to put together a plan where we can offer uh advancement credit for our students here in town at the high school uh historically our students have had to leave uh the district to go uh obtain credit um uh at a variety of locations that are approved by our district but now they will look need to look no further than our very own high school um the program we will be offering this year will be geometry and honors geometry and it'll be open to students that have completed uh their freshman year so this is in accordance of what we've been offering uh in our district um but now we will be offering it here at home delivered by our teachers um aligned with our
030curriculum and uh we will continue to deliver our assessments to obtain credit uh these courses will be 120 hours uh which is our requirement to obtain five credits and for advancement purposes and uh we are excited to be able to do this we think it's going to provide significant utility to the students and the high school as a whole particularly now that students will have the opportunity to uh to partake in our math sequence which we're very proud of and now we will no longer have to uh Farm out our students to other locations and the district will reap all of the benefits um of this programmatic Evolution uh our curriculum will be uh obviously modified uh and compacted but this will be something that we will do uh through the math department in the
031spring and then ongoing throughout the summer as our teachers uh work uh throughout the months our um program will run from July 7th through August 8th and um we will uh operate from 8 to one um throughout the day and again this is direct line and a direct alignment with what students throughout the state have been doing uh in this particular type of programming uh we know that this is these types of decisions will uh parents have to make pretty quickly uh as they start to think about how they want to approach summer learning uh and uh we're excited to be able to turn this on and and we're going to be releasing uh registration uh protocols and procedures to the public hopefully by the end of the month maybe sooner and uh we're looking
032forward to seeing how this goes and we're very optimistic about what it's going to do as far as supporting our students as they continue to advance in their ability to consume mathematics instruction um uh I that's that's pretty much description of the program um all the information available to the public will be publicized uh direct via direct email to uh eligible students also publicly um on our various publication Outlets um um students if if the first stop for students and we'll talk all about this in our public Communications but obviously has to take place through our guidance office and this is exactly how we would oper we have operated such procedures in the past because guidance can then uh work with the math department and verify eligibility and then once we realize the student is
033eligible they'll be able to enroll in our programs and all of these procedures will be made public um once we're ready to turn this on uh like I said which will be very shortly um before I uh continue obviously I'd want to I'll pause here and see if anyone has any questions about this particular uh program that we're excited to offer I have one question but before that I want to congratulate um everybody this is beyond exciting I I have been a strong proponent of it for years now back when I was on that side of the public forum and has been a dream ever since I've been on the curum committee so thank you I'm so happy to hear that this is going to finally happen the only question I had was um the
034eligibility criteria that you just mentioned so they The Freshman going into sophomore year would be able to take this over the summer are our criteria similar to what our neighboring districts are going to you know or already have are we going to allow the students that can be taken by Petty or South BR or any other school district to take the program with us or our our criteria is going to be more stricter or more rigid so you're talking about Monroe students correct yes Monroe students taking a course in Monroe yes so one one of the things Dr Higgins and I talked about was making it so that there was equity for everybody so what has been allowed in the past for other districts or for other places and students can still go to other
035ones if they want to but we're going to be able to offer it in house and um to be quite honest with you I've had some of my own teachers be the teachers at Petty and so we know what we need and what we want to so it's not that I'm going to decline somebody from taking a level they want to I will have conversations with are you sure you want to take let's just say an honors level where the recommendation might not be because I can give statistics like when I had last year I had um 19 students take regular geometry outside um most at Petty but not all at Petty 75% of those students were able to move on they were in level that they were comfortable with they learned the material they
036got an ad or hire in their course they got an ad or higher on our final um with the honor geometry the statistics were not as good but they were stretching themselves so some did make it I had about 30% that made it um in that case I had I have the numbers right here 13 students take it um but so to give you an idea I had 32 students taking g a level of geometry to be fair I'm going to let them choose the level that they want to but they're only going to take one final so it's going to be the same identical criteria they will need to get an 80 or higher in the course and that will include a summit of assess but they're also going to come back and take
037our final on the last day that's going to be one of the things as well and get an 80 or higher on that so that way if you were taking it at an outside place or you're taking here it's the same thing but understand that this you know the research shows that with retention if you're learning something in a four or five week time period you're going to have retained most of it so get that's why getting an 80 is not something that's out of the range I had 75% of the students last year actually go through and be successful and even that three of them did finish the course so they I don't know how serious they were about it um so those are counted and the ones that didn't make it um it'll
038be the same exact idea but you should be able to learn something in five weeks and be able to retain it the retention curves usually or as time goes on that's where you lose more and more of it so taking a whole course over 10 months is harder to have remembered everything all the way through um I think it's going to be very very successful I really do um we've worked it out so I was working with u Mr moralde and we figured out the time time period that worked it matches right up to when I can give the final literally a few days later so they'll have time to review and go over it and they should be able to take it and go from there um it is going to be though the
039type of program where there's going to be attendance required so to make meet the state requirements they will only be able to be absent twice and that is along the lines of what's happened with other programs in the past um when schools do that as well um Petty offers it over six weeks we're offering it over five weeks I think we have five hours a day they might have four and a half so it's a very similar type of a setup going through um so I I just like the idea that the level of rigor will be of the rer that we know of what we expect for our students and I think the success rate is going to be very good it's not going to be a guarantee that everybody makes it through they're
040still going to have to do the work and put the work into it but I do think it's going to be very successful and I agree with you I think it's going to be very successful uh if you're going to you know allow the kids that to do what they were doing outside of the district in the district yes is actually going to be double successful because we're also going to make that money as a school district that other school districts were making off of us so uh congratulations again I don't have any more questions but anybody else on the committee has any questions please go ahead and I think offering one course of each right now I think is sufficient because if you look at the numbers from last year I had 19 of
041regular geometry and 13 Going to honors geometry so that gives us some leeway to go through that so I I think it's a very fair start and I think that we'll you know I mean we might get more people wanting to take them can there is going to be a limit but I do do believe it's going to be wor to to give you an idea with the setup in terms of the approval the approval process is so that I just make sure that somebody is signing up for a course um in the past has been that it's the appropriate number of hours I know that's going to be the case for us but also that it's an appropriate course meaning that they're coming from algebra one to take geometry so if somebody wants and
042asked to take Algebra 2 they would have had to have taken geometry first because that's the progression going through um I don't want to approve somebody going off to pre-cal that didn't have the algebra 2 so it's really just kind of a check and balance just to make sure you're taking the right next sequential course um and go from there so great start good luck to everybody that's involved in this I'm so excited because this is something that I and I think we're starting it out the right way so that we can really set it up with success yes good luck anybody else any questions um Mr make a general comment uh as as anything we do in the summer um we have a potential price structure again we have to finalize that in a
043payment method um but we would not run something that we wouldn't minimally break even so I don't want anybody to think that we're going to run something that we're going to have to put a tremendous amount of money out um we you know the break even figures here are pretty low in terms of student enrollment so based on historical students that are interested in taking geometry we have confidence that we would M our definitely meet our minimum numbers um but those are the things we'll finalize in the next uh week or two in terms of the format of payment as well as uh you know minimum numbers to run the sections and things I I mostly agree with you Dr Layman but I do know that um you know this is an additional it's an
044Al alternate way Revenue generation idea as well for the district so I'm sure you guys will come up with the right price point uh that our you know our students and their parents will not feel bad because they're putting it back into our own District money that they were willing to pay to another school district so um I'm glad that we're having this conversation uh even though you might be making that announcement a month or so down the lane Mr morala it's a public meeting and I'm hoping that the word gets out and people you know know that this option exists this year so when they when they put in for the approval I have it's a Google form and that is going to go on the site as soon as we get everything finalized
045as Mr moral just said we're going to do it as soon as possible um with the potential snow coming tomorrow probably not tomorrow but we're hoping let's say by next week at some time um I have told parents that have asked me about it that um the approval form has not been put on the site yet because I have been waiting for this to be quite honest with you because I didn't want to tell somebody to sign up for a program and them then find out oh by the way we're offering it um out of the choices there will be an mths at our school for geometry and honors geometry and then there will be other schools listed and then there's an option other that they can show me another course that I can prove
046um if they meet the state criteria I allow it I just have experience with some programs being more successful with students than others with ours um so I do kind of like to have that but this way it's all on a Google form the parents um give me their emails we have their phone numbers we have all the information we need and that way they'll get the approval they'll then get the approval for the geometry or honors geometry and then we will send it off to Mr Moralo so he'll have it set up for the similar way that he has the payment plan for his summer enrichment program um and they'll be able to set it up that way so I'll just make sure they're in the right course and we'll go first come firster
047with that just curious uh Dr lemman would this need vot approval so we're running this under our summer programming umbrella so we this is just an additional course we're going to offer um we already have a curriculum document right so we just have to the same Concepts will be taught over the five weeks um we'll just have to uh address the pacing right unit timing and things like that so there's no specific uh you know new document to be approved or anything like that we're just uh you know keeping you in the loop and again in terms terms of fiscal responsibility and things like that this is not something that um isn't going to cost us you know it's not going to cost us anything um that we won't cover with the uh Revenue that
048we'll bring in enr sounds good all right Mr morala you can take it over again thank you and that yeah that was uh I'm glad Dr Layman uh brought that up because I had um failed to mention that this would be a tuition-based program obviously and uh we will uh our catalog and I'll continue with our with the presentation our catalog which is is going to look similar to what you received in your executive content this afternoon just a little bit more tailored to students and parents um we'll have all of that outlined including cost or fees and things like that uh so just moving along away from the high school uh we are going to reboot the enrichment programs that we have uh been historically running throughout the district which range everywhere from uh
049computer science to the culinary arts and fine artarts uh with a few uh additions and and programmatic devolutions so a lot of the feedback we've received from parents Bally of our younger students was that uh the time and availability of the programs was just too brief and and and the kids were left wanting a little bit more uh that also we received some feedback from our early childhood education program that the parents were looking for some sort of Summer enrichment for uh students approaching in kindergarten so what we're going to introduce this year will be an early childhood enrichment uh preschool program which is going to be an extension of our already existing Falcons Nest Preschool at the monor tanp high school it'll be governed by both our our in fact our two teachers and
050we will continue to leverage our student teachers into the summer so what we'll do is we'll run a uh a 5H hour preschool throughout the month of July and we will lace the existing enrichment programs through that preschool so culinary art and stem going down all the way into the preschool level and it'll be all the same inst structures and the same hallway as everybody so it's just a an expansion of our existing program into the preschool so our youngest Learners throughout the district will have an opportunity to learn alongside our teachers and our facilities throughout the summer uh and this will be a longer program than we've ever run before so it'll give the parents an opportunity to you know fulfill whatever uh needs they have as far as getting their child access to
051to legitimate programs standards align programming um and it'll do something it'll be a nice little expansion for the siblings that we have to tell they have to wait a few years before they can come to our programs so we're excited about that we've also revamped our um and that's going to be called the Falcons Nest Summer Academy uh We've also revamped our K to2 program which had been historically limited to two hour sessions what we're doing this year and and mainly because the two instructors that ran it are two varsity coaches in the district we're calling it um summer of stem MMA mind and motion Academy no it's not mixed martial arts although we've talked about it the uh it's uh basically what we're going to be doing is blending stem education with Athletics leadership
052and team building and it's going to be a kind of a hybrid program where in the morning they'll do some athletic Fitness and uh some team building they're also going to learn some team sports um and but and then in the second session after a half hour break we'll get into some structured stem modules so again longer learning experience for the parents for our youngest Learners um but again it'll be uh laced with curricularly aligned and programmatically aligned learning experiences all under the leadership of our certified instructors so we're excited about what we've done to our early childhood education program you know we've been talking a lot about preek through K learning over the last couple really years now and you know we don't have to necessarily wait around for for for everything else to
053fall into place so we're going to continue to address uh learning at that age um throughout the summer and uh in a meaningful way so we're excited to offer that to the Monroe and Jamesburg Community but also uh members of the of the region that may be interested in looking for that sort of thing it's been brought to our attention that there's very limited opportunities for curricularly driven Early Childhood enrichment over the summer so uh we're hoping to fulfill that need for some of our our community members uh the only other addition that we're excited to bring to the summer will be our first of there and and I say our first very casual um uh exploration into the world of premedical and biotechnology um learning and so what uh Miss drust and I have
054been looking at uh this school year are are ways that we could start to take a look at um premedical programs uh biotechnological programs that fit naturally into our existing curriculum but also extend beyond it and we have some opportunities we've been having some nice conversations with the staff um many of our staff are currently being trained in some of these content areas um we know that the nature of content and and nuanced uh science especially in the older levels is heading in that direction and a lot of our students here in Monroe are are looking for that type of learning we've been surveying the community over the last uh couple months gauging interest in in this area and uh shocker it's like asking people if they want their taxes to be lower um you
055know the response has been very favorable uh to look at these types of programming and again for all types of Learners and so we're going to all start it this summer um we're GNA we're not doing this in Li of something we're doing this alongside of everything we already have and the again the beauty of these summer programs is that we can bring in our teachers them test out this content meaningfully with their own students and then as we've been doing with computer science and Robotics over the last couple years we are naturally patiently and authentically embedding it into the daily learning of the school day which is a nice way to um not Bur our teachers and overwhelm them but also get them excited about uh this 21st century content that continues to be
056you know our expectations are these students need to get this content right now at early age but we can't do it uh by replacing what's already there so we have to find ways to embed it naturally and and the supervisors have been awesome in in helping us use the summer program leverage the summer program and some of these enrichment programs to to to get this done and you've seen it and some of the the new curricular programs that have just kind of popped up over the last couple years so we're happy to to continue to expand into the summer and uh we're way ahead a schedule this year which we're excited about and I know you know we've been saying soon but we we know we I can say with confidence that everything will be
057in place by the end of the month as far as a course catalog and accessibility um for parents to begin thinking about what they want to do with their summer um we're we don't anticipate on raising any prices for our programs this year um again you know these programs we want to be accessible for our program uh for our students and Community but we also have to make sure um at a financial responsibility that that we don't incur any costs to the district so that's and that's something that we're very proud of that we've been able to do successfully so uh every year we've added more this year we fulfilled our our goal of of doing something for the high school and we're going to continue to go this is this is going to get
058bigger every year and we're excited about the opportunity so um the executive content has everything I just described but we will be um you know producing information for the public very shortly that's this is all incredible you you've covered the entire spectrum of student ages and there's so much exciting stuff there quick question for for the preschool through through second grade is where we are doing the longer five hour sessions that's correct and everything else is the way we've done in the previous Summers the enrichment passes that's correct what we've done we we mentioned last year also or last uh fall in the SWAT analysis that one of the opportunities that we had was more strategic scheduling so to so what we do like for example if we run a three to five art program
059in the am we'll do a three to five stem program in the PM so so being very purposeful in our scheduling so if a parent wanted to take advantage of the full program that that becomes much more convenient and plausible so I'm super excited about the new addition on the premedical and medical track um um they you guys just seem to be out doing yourself every year so I'm very excited congratulations looks great the luck on the uh on you know the publicizing part of it um anybody else on the board has any questions or committee members no comments no questions well Mr morala thank you so much um Good Luck to everybody on your team uh it's going to be a great summer very exciting summer Dr Layman I think we only have the
060policy documents left now right I don't see Dr Higgins here you want are you going to be covering both of them yeah I can definitely go over the acceptable use of generative Ai and then we can uh we can go through the other one and I can okay I can show you we took some feedback uh both about the elementary middle and high school in terms of the structure of the policy as well I think it reads a little clearer that other one um it was convoluted because it would talk about one thing in other sections and was a little messy so I think we cleaned it up um makes a lot more sense to read through yeah I did read through there's still some issues but let's tackle the AI policy first and then
061we can jump into the discussion for 544 Z yep so uh since our last meeting uh Mr Weiss and I worked through the policy and and cleaned up some of the I would call it some ambiguity that we came through some uh there's some repetitive Concepts but the general the structure Remains the Same uh like the first page page and a half is is uh board related right it's an overview kind of a a top down kind of a snapshot of basically AIS around we we as a district acknowledge it's going to be around we'd love to leverage it we support leveraging it but we also want to make sure um we do it responsibly so that's really the the first section and then there's a a student section and a staff section embedded in
062those two sections again are very similar similar thread it's h it's about um verifying sources using it responsibly there's a very clear uh element to this policy about um student privacy and staff privacy using data not copy and pasting any potential uh unique identifiers everything from you know an obvious student name or social security number or credit card number like all the the obvious pieces but we put them in here for clarity and and uh know safety sake about just the use of use and safety related to AI and there's also an element here about AC academic Integrity um in terms of verifying your Source citing your sources um AI is not a primary source docu primary resource at all it's uh it needs to be verified needs to be uh you know identified and
063cited if used and that's the expectation for both staff and students um so I think I think it hits from a board level and from a district level it hits the hits the hotpots uh where we're going to move from here is uh we have uh pockets of staff and students uh that are working on let's call it a boots on the ground guidance document that has a scale of you know when a teacher assigns an assignment This Is How They Define the potential use or the expectations of use for students um that way when an assignment gets turned in there's an expectation about whether it was used at the beginning of the assignment for the revising and editing part of the assignment for the whole assignment um and then uh you know it's clearly
064outlined in here the expectations of if there is a potential academic Integrity issue um that we definitely engage in a a responsible process to have conversations figure it out um you know verify sources and then move on um if necessary and that way you know we can take a conservative but a responsible Approach at you know identifying any potential issues um and that's I would say probably a pretty pretty broad overview of the elements of this policy umly in the policy meeting we stress s May has updated the plagiarism policy to call it academic Integrity so everything is starting to line up as we move through policies and they get updated um so any questions related to the acceptable use of J of AI I I had a um a and maybe because I'm the
065only non-educational staff on this committee when I look at the two um two sections the student and the teacher it's very understandable that the teachers are going to be checking the students work to make sure they're compliant but when the same thing is applied to a teacher's lesson plan or um and I could read from the policy the the first point in in the staff section right that they're prohibited from taking it as is um my my question is whose check is that is that the supervisor check who's who's keeping an eye on that on what the teachers are doing because you know everybody is using so much of Aid they just makes life easier so yep and and and and that's a that's a collective responsibility so part of the teachers's uh responsibility is
066to submit lesson plans and submit plans uh whether the unit plans and sometimes it's a supervisor everybody's assigned a role and a responsibility but sometimes it's a supervisor and that's particular at the high school level and then it filters into the middle school at the elementary level the building principles are screening lesson plans um so that's where the initial kind of conversation would happen and then you know as we move through and get AI specific um we can further Define you know it may may need to be addressed more than a monthly because it a non- tener teacher submits lesson plans twice a month a tenure teacher submits them once a month um something that with AI may need to be occurring more frequently so um having a pathway defined for a teacher to uh
067you know and it's obvious they can come to any of us but um we could clear we will clearly Define you know if you come up with something tonight and you want to use it in the next couple days who do you go to who's your go-to person um again it's probably the supervisor at the high school Andor a VP or or the principal at the elementary level it's going to be the Principal um because they're probably the one that's in the building every day uh but but we do have our supervisors that are filtering through but we'll Define find that um you know clearly as we as we roll out the the documents and I guess um the reason I asked this question is because you know from the very Advent of AI the
068teachers have been on the guard and they've been doing all you know whatever is in the first part of the policy the teachers have been on top of it and now we're kind of putting it in policies to the teachers but um I don't believe or maybe it has been done but I don't believe the supervisors and you know curriculum writers and they've been so closely involved in checking teachers work but now that we' put a policy in place and it's really mirroring everything that the student is supposed to do the staff is also supposed to abide by the same guidelines so I think we might be looking at putting those processes in place as soon as there's policies out there yep and and some of the things that are in there are expectations regardless
069we would not want a staff member or a student to pass things off on their own not their own so so there so whether it's you know 20 years ago photocopying an encyclopedia and trying to pass it off on your own or now it's AI again we've talked about this a little bit as as AI moves through this is the new topic right now it's going to be part of what we do right we probably eventually wouldn't need an AI policy because it's going to be embedded in everything else we do just like um you know plagiarism and copyrighting and those expectation so we're we're highlighting it now but as we it's going to be a part it's going to be a resource it's going to be a tool um and like I said a
070lot of these expectations are they're already out there for other things that exist like like we said you know um we have expectations that resources um if they're going to be taken from somewhere they're cited whether you're a teacher or a student and the same expectation applies now if it's an AI resource just cite it as a cite it as you you're using this and it's AI generated um but make sure you verify it make sure it's a vetted vetted tool and a vetted source that does make sense the other comment I had Dr Layman was uh this is definitely a much more concise and Tighter po uh policy document than the original draft that we saw last month one of the things that I really liked in that draft the old draft was the
071rubric a mention of the rubric and I'm I know it doesn't need to be in the policy and probably just a process but that idea was really nice of the teachers incorporating that into their rubrics I don't know if that has been completely um you know taken off from the table or it's just been taken off the policy but it's probably going to be procedural it's a procedural piece um everything from a rubric of expectations and guidance for how a student may use AI um from nothing to Allin or anything in between um all the way through uh you know like you mentioned maybe AI use is embedded in a rubric that's a scoring rubric for the assignment um but that's again it's a procedural thing it's a class subject dependent uh piece anybody else
072any questions I don't have any more on the head policy well see none um Dr lman I think this is good to go on to the policy committee kman this will come to you I guess um we can move on to the next policy you want me to go over the structural changes of this because we we did mention sure why don't you go over it and I I did read over it and I had some concerns but why don't you start DR Layman and then I'll bring my concerns up yep so uh we had mentioned the last time we got together that um the elementary middle and high school uh made needed to make sure we we were aligned with practice um this clearly hadn't been updated since a while ago um but in
073doing so we had at the time it was written uh grades five and six were still a part of the middle the elementary school so uh what we did is we restructured this a little bit to be more in line with what the uh the practicality of our kind of grade level alignments are so there's a grade five section A Grade 68 section and then a Grade 9 through 12 section um the elementary Upper Elementary principles um put into practice and clarified what's actually happening at in fifth grade uh the Middle School principal defined the sixth through eth grade piece and then uh you know we have uh clear expectations about what the practice was from the high school so um you know as we move through you can actually see the progression uh in
074terms of accelerated courses at the elementary level have a window of a grade level you can get it's a 10% window then it's a 5% window at the middle school level and then that uh Fades away at the high school level so there's actually a progression moving through and that's uh that was the actual practice in place um but this reflects all the uh all the actual things that are happening in terms of principal's list and honor role um at some point we probably will revisit the National Honor Society piece uh the high school um wants to revisit that we are this this reflects the practice but uh we may have a conversation in the future about um what that looks like moving forward so um I'll start with the with one think that in
075the honors role for grade 6 to8 yep uh no sorry in in the High School uh the honor role in the high school I feel like there there's a redundancy here if you look at the second sentence if a pupil receives a grade less than 75% or if more than one grade is in 75 to oh sorry I misunderstood no no questions there yep so you can you can get one grade between 75 and 79 but nothing below 75 okay that's for the honor R own yep and if there are two grades between 75 and 79 then that automatically takes them off if there's two grades between 75 or 79 or any grade you can just one below 70 below 75 um year off as well yep the other thing in the academic Awards um
076where it mentions the validator the salador um the it doesn't mention here for rank ing purposes it doesn't mention um the weighted GPS that's typically how we are taking it right so the weighted GPA yes yep and how is the honor the Honor Society is not weight of GPA it is also it says weighted cumulated average of 90 so I feel like there should be a mention in the validator and salutatorian also of the way that GP uh I can I'll bring that back to Dr Higgins uh and I agree with you the the more explicit right the more explicit we can be the the less ambiguity there is in in the uh in this policy and and the thing that I disagree with Dr Layman and I brought to you a few times and
077I'm going to say it again tonight because I still so the old policy which was modified did say that a higher rigor of classes it just said honors it didn't said honors in AP but it said in high school 8 and above should make the principal less I see that in this modified policy that has been taken up I don't agree with that so if we are going to um and I know you just said 10 and then five 10 in fifth grade and then 5% less in six to eth grade but I don't see the logic behind when we're giving the National Honor Society is weighted when we giving the you know class ranks is weighted why are we not doing the same and I understand that weighted averages are not calculated for every
078subject in every marking period but that's an additional step to you know to honoring more students for their achievement um we are disc you know we're sort of discouraging these students because what is the principal list it's basically you know you're trying to say that all right these kids have worked hard and gotten good grade if you are not you know equating the playing field for regular rigor and higher rigor courses for the principal list then meeting a principal list is harder than making on National Honor Society in my opinion uh I I feel like it's it's just you know you've had these kids in honors in AP classes that whose parents have come to us in the last year where they may have missed in one subject and had 87 in maybe an AP
079bio class and did not make the principle hard they tell you in back to school night that don't expect 90s in this class teachers say that so I and I understand you know I have kids who've taken higher R courses it's hard to me they the kids only talk in weighted averages they don't even talk about these higher riger classes they'll tell you they got an 80 but then the very next second they'll tell you what the waited you know GPA for that classes so why are we excluding and I understand and I had heard the last committee meeting uh policy committee meeting where Dr Higgin said no schools nearby do that but that shouldn't stop us from doing it it's a internal policy it's what we choose to do as a school and I
080don't feel that it is right that we are allowing for it in fifth grade we are allowing it in sixth to eth grade and we were allowing it as per policy in high school but we were just not procedurally following that was the that's been the policy in the document written policy forever but we were not following it and so now we're taking it out I think we the order is opposite we should fix our processes not stop honoring the students who and and you know back when this policy was written there were very few students compared to the number of students today taking those AP and honor classes so what that means in my mind is we're honoring fewer students and principles list than we actually can and the whole purpose is encouragement for
081their hard work so we're saying you take a higher riger class so you don't deserve that encouragement you don't deserve to be in the principal's list because you're taking a higher level of the CL and then that student becomes a valid torian that student becomes a salutatorian so what was the principles list worth so that's my opinion I do not think we should be changing that part of the policy at all and I welcome comments from anybody else on this committee not just board members but even supervisors please feel free to share your thoughts on this but I strongly feel that we should give principal flist to kids with higher rigor classes um can I just ask what the logic is with not keeping it consistent whether it is to make um all the same
082where we count the 85s and above or remove them from the lower level as well like I just want to understand the what the logic is terms of the difference between example why are we why you know for uh sixth to e8th grade and fifth grade we're allowing you know a grade of 85 to 89 but not at the high school like we either allow it across all the grades or don't allow it across all the grades yeah I I think you know you could look at it as as students for the for a similar reason that we're not having an honor Ro or principal list at in fourth grade right that's the first year they're getting grades as opposed to the standard based report card C so as they move through the grades grades
083meaning fifth through e8th grade uh progressively the standard is when you're getting tracked into a course a more rigorous course uh those are the courses that either you're stretching yourself to take and or your your Baseline right your you should be in those classes so for you to achieve say the 90 would be consistent to a student in a Dynamics class achieving a 90 in their class right so it it's it's an School playing field as opposed to changing the bar um for a higher riger course if we had that same thought we would have to maybe change the bar for the Dynamics classes because make it easier for them to get you know so it's it's a common the principal list is the common standard of 90 um and that and that seems to
084be the conversation that's been kind of going around I know Dr Chanley and I have had that we uh you heard Dr Higgins speak about it Dr Kelli at one of the previous meetings um so that's kind of maybe the the thought process behind it um gazal I wanted to address uh the Honor Society piece and again that's I mentioned the high school is looking to potentially revisit that um and that is something we we're g to we're going to look at moving forward um and they had they've been their advisers and you know the teacher advisers and things we' they've been looking at the structure of the Honor Society and and uh the the student profile and the student body that's engaged in that so um stay tuned for that discussion discussion I think
085we may bring some thoughts to potentially align things continue to align things as well um so you might see you might see that come up in the next uh couple months um any other comments yeah I have an something I just noticed it's just in the language under where it says honor roles grade n to 12 uh letter B it says the honoral will will include all pupils who have a grade of 80 or better in all subjects weighted or unweighted excluding those pupils name to the high honor role we don't have high honor role correct that should be principal list yep so that we have to correct yep you're right it should say principal list because that's what even middle school has right okay no I'm make a note for policy so but anybody
086else feels I I I just have um yeah go ahead I'm just I'm just trying to digest everything I'm hearing plus what I read and unfortunately I don't have that in front of me so U please bear with me um the thinking when you look at fifth grade the honors piece um you have 70 to 70 n% any kid that scores within that range would then be a candidate for the uh honors uh program am I correct so far on a yes on 75 to yeah 75 right right and then as they start to move up the grade levels the expectation becomes greater and that it becomes more difficult for them to achieve uh and be part of the honors role correct yes yes you're right and and I think that's the way to go
087personally I think that's appropriate um why do I think that way because my experience has been that whenever I identified kids for inclusion into let's say A Gifted math program that was taught by a a very very good math teacher who really had experience with gifted kids and they were really it was both an accelerated and an enrichment program we found that kids at the lower level I'm talking three or fourth grade um you didn't get a lot of kids into that program but as a mature as their mathematics becomes they become more more more mature and for some reason it could be you know there could be a multitude of rationale behind it they uh somehow develop uh the mass skills they become more Adept in doing better in math at some part some
088time they just do better and then when a kid in high school I think the high school is Right On Target I think at high school once you know at a particular grade sometimes you'll take a course and you might miss it by one percent on well you you the standards are the standards I mean that's the way I look at it I see the standards is if those are the standards then that's it I mean it's unfortunate but that's part of life I mean I I know it's I know but you gotta have some standards and you have to you got to you got hang within those standards from my perspective at least agre Charlie so here's my argument to that so when we give the validator or the salad torian for the year
089it's their it's their weighted GPA that's ranking them right now the the reason I even brought this discussion up is I personally know of these students whose parents have come and complained in the last year the student had five AP classes and of the five AP classes you know if there was it's found to be you know these are really hard challenging classes and these supervisors will agree some of these classes it's hard to get over 90 these students are not making the principal's list but these students are the top 1% of our high school in terms of class rankings so they miss because they miss in one marking period they they probably have a weighted 90 but they have 80 you know 82 85 right these students are are are smart students these are
090students that eventually are getting a Sprite outside of our high school they're going to Great colleges they're you know top one% but we're not putting them on the principal FL so that's the whole argument here why are we not putting them on the principal list when they are our pride and trust me I'm not talking about my kids don't that standard I am talking about these kids whose parents have come and complained in the last year and it's just and you know I honestly thought our policy was 90 and above till I read the policy document last summer and realized our policy says 85 and over should be in the principles list and we were not following the policy so and that's why I don't want to go back on that I feel like that
091policy was right and we should follow that policy but Dr Chanley did you have any comments on that sorry go that's okay so I I agree with you and Carmen I also understand what Charlie is saying also but I I come I believe that principal list should be 90 or above that's my stance but I ALS and I have mixed feelings on the 7975 um aspect for you know for honorable but I do feel like there needs to be uniformity across the policy I feel like we we we set a standard and then we change the standard so this is where I I understand what Charlie is saying like as we go through as the kids get older we want to try to you know make them challenge them a little bit more to you
092know do better um but we've also set the precedent that this was okay before and now it's not now it's not enough um so yeah I I I have very mixed feelings about this I I agree with if you're not going to give it to high schoolers stop stop giving them this from fifth grade onwards let's just make a standard policy but my honestly my pet peeve right now is you know they're taking really high rigor classes and they're eventually the kids that are our top 1% of the high school you know why are we not giving them the principal F what is what does the principles list mean if it's not going to you know honor the best stent so that that's my my pick on that um I may be wrong in the
0931% they may be the top 10% of the high school but even top 10% is you know students that are going to grade colleges and when they write their you know college application they take pride in writing that was in the principal list four years of high school no they can't write that what do the supervisors think what have you guys I would be but I can let the supervisor speak first I was going to share that I think um we have to think about the culture that we want to create around grades and learning um as well and when we're pursuing accolades at the sacrifice of potentially academic Integrity our own mental our our children's mental health um their ability to participate in extracurricular activity successfully to to have work or things like that
094so I for me it's almost it's a little bit bigger than than just this um but the other thing is and and having worked in in high school my entire um career in education putting principal list putting honor rooll and things like that on a college application it doesn't mean anything um so you can put it on your college application but at the end of the day it's going to be GPA it's going to be test scores it's going to be those things that students that also separate those students from their peers um are they earning the Seal of biliteracy Little Seal of biliteracy plug there um are they um interning at different places is there volunteer work or Community work um so I I think when we hyperfocus on some of these things um
095is there a sacrifice to to the culture of of learning that we want to create that's that's my only input I can give a little bit of insight too having gone through three sets of college applications and running around from college to college um as Kelly said the colleges don't ask and I and they honestly don't know or care if you're on principal's list or on a rooll list or not they don't even care how we wait them because they take the waiting and they take your transcript and they isolate it and they do it their own way and that's because there would be inequity within the schools we may add 10 points to um an AP class another school might offer five they look at the course and they look at the rigor of
096what you're taking and then they look at your grade um having been in Monroe since we were a farm School moving up the one thing that I did love about our system when we were really trying to get students to try to want to achieve better but there were standards that they had but if somebody had a 79 but they had an 85 first marking period we weren't focused so much on each marking period but say hey look when you're averaging the two you're in that 80s still and you keep it up marking period three and four and it's the end result we're looking at and I think we need to get the kids to be like okay I tried my hardest I did maybe I didn't do so great on one test and pulled
097me down but life goes on I can pick up the pieces I can learn what I didn't know and I can move on and I've had so many parent conversations over the last four or five years where a student has struggled but they belong in the course but they've struggled on a particular unit or a particular chapter and the parents are more the ones that are feeling like life is over it's horrible how can they have that one grade on their report card that's not even going to show up in the end for the colleges and I worry about what expectations we're giving them when they go off to college and then they do take a test and they do poorly on that test and the piece that I taught my kids was if they
098didn't do as well as as they wanted to in one thing and I said okay life goes on what are we going to do next what's the worst that could happen the very worst that could happen is that you fail a class which didn't happen with my kids thank God but that's the worst you pick up the pieces and you move on um in life we have some things that are failures some things that are good and I think we have to kind of look at that if everybody if we're giving 75 80 90% of the kids in elementary school honor roll and above what does it mean I'm not sure if it's meaning anything at that point um you know I know that I know that 85 for the advance classes from middle school
099I didn't even know we had at the elementary I'm going to be honest with you but but the 85 for the middle school was because with the algebra 1 when we had that initially or the accelerated math they are in harder classes and there is a lot more rig so they don't really wait the grades they were just saying one grade could be lower than the other so it was kind of an unofficial weight I guess you know Dr tley you you were there with that that was and that I thought that was a good reason high school they're actually waiting the grades so it kind of offsets it already um but they not waiting the grades that's my that's my point Miss Gasco for the principal's list they're not waiting the Gat uh the
100grades so the principal's list is on the great what level are you talking about the high school or the middle school the high school the high school if you got 80 in um Al you know in um AP Cal AB it stays an 80 it's not sorry 85 it stays in 85 so you won't make the principles left that's the point here and while I agree with Dr Roselle on the cultural piece we don't want to not challenge our students but you know to the point that you just said and what Dr Layman said earlier playing this you know we're giving them an even playing field so I understand you know these students have to write the brag list not everybody is in not so they have to put 10 things on their brag list
101you know on their common app they've got to put like 10 on accomplishments and achievements I've gone through two college applications too so I know there are students I didn't have to face that in my health but I know there are students that are looking for that last bullet and that last bullet could be made principal list four years in a row it may not mean something to everybody but it does mean something to somebody and I'm just saying this because we are giving them benefit of weighted GPA for our class ranks for the National Honor Society we're just not doing it for the principles list so to Katie's Point make it an even playing field like middle Elementary to high school everything the same why are we giving them undue Advent and the same
102thing with National Honor Society and you know validator salidor and the principles is why is principles list harder to get into then becoming a validator right I said why are we using different standards for the two things is my question here either we just do away with the principles list we say there's no principles list or if you're going to have a principles list then just do it the way we do it for everything else with honors and AP classes consider the weighted GP and I I'm all with you on you know parents sometimes stressing more than the students but I have you know noticed and more so in the last four or five years the Monro student demographic has changed and and they are really stressing over these grades and these report cards and
103you know it's just it's the way it is it's become so competitive everybody wants to go to you know really good colleges and they're they're look and they're pushing themselves it's not like the principal list is going to make them push themselves I'm just talking about honoring a student that has already put in the hard work I'm not talking about giving them an easy way out or you know awarding them for something that they've not done I'm saying they're already doing it you know they're already meeting our Benchmark sorry Dr Chanley you were gonna say something I that's fine it was good to hear everybody's thoughts so um I think what we're talking about two different things here I think on the one hand I agree that the academic rigor if if a child is
104capable of being in an AP or Honor's class they should be held to a higher standard than a child who is not capable and therefore in that vein I would say it should not be added um waited for principal list however however you said something very telling isala if our Elites and our best who are suuma come loud Magnum come loud getting into the elite schools having the highest rank highest GPA are being excluded from principal's list because of the way we do a calculation that is something that does not align so from a philosophical educational point of view I agree 100% you're smarter you should be held to a higher standard that's what differentiation is what we do for one child we don't always do for the same for their other child because every
105child in a class can't walk you know something as simplistic as well why did I have different work than Joey you had different work from Joey because you worry about your own work and Joey worries about his work and that is absolutely true so if we go from that mindset then I would say that there should not be any additional weight however we wait everything we give additional weight for everything so if we're going to give additional weight for everything you have to hearing the way you said it that means that our Elite child who's now going to the elite College who now like Dr Roselle said maybe it doesn't make a difference you don't need it on your resume doesn't make a difference it may not make a difference but that should be an
106automatic why are they not getting principal's list when they getting everything else so I think that if we're going to keep principles list and we don't have to if we're going to keep it it should be calculated exactly like everything else I have to be quite Frank with you when I originally sat down with Dr Higgins and Dr Layman I was an agreement with them 100% but after listening to what was brought out here and listening to what you said gazala it's not about making it easier for the child to achieve it it's about the playing field either we say nothing should be weighted you're smarter than you're you're smarter than your your colleague than your peer so you take a harder class so the expectation you should get a a higher grade I agree
107but if we're going to wait it then for every other Accolade why are we not waiting it for this so that's how I would sum it up so I listening to this I did change my because I think it's absurd that perhaps number one in all class is not principal's list it makes no sense and honestly I haven't met a single high schooler that doesn't talk about their grades in weighted Aver they don't anybody taking a higher rigor of course will only tell you their so just listening to everybody's Insight which I think I think it just proves that this committee does make sense is and I I respectfully did have a conversation with Dr Higgins and uh Dr Catelli and Dr Layman and based upon the original conversation is I do think it should
108be 90 but now that I'm listening we wait everything else how do we not wait that and and it's erroneous how was it in the policy before why was it in the policy before that I don't know that was way way before for a reason I feel it was there for a reason and and it only mentioned honors it didn't mention anything which was an error which was an error because they should have both right and but we've been offering more and more AP classes in the last decade then Mr morala can test you know give me a number for that but I'm sure 10 years ago our number of AP offerings were less than the number and number of students taking it were also less 10 years ago than there are today so it's
109a bigger subset of students that are not going to meet that 90 but they are smart students they are putting in a lot of hard work and they are getting into the National Honor Society they are getting the top 10% rank they're not making principles list they're not making principes list so then I think we should either either we wait everything which we do or We Wait nothing and in in all fairness I understand because I also asked around our our neighboring schools are all doing the same thing it's 90 and above everybody's doing the same thing I don't think everybody doing this the same thing is is the right thing sometimes you've got to be the first one to make a change and change is always hard but our policy was like that we
110I don't want to backtrack a right policy I felt like our policy when it came to high school was right but I also agree with Carman and Katie that whatever we do it needs to be so if we change High School one then we can keep the one right now for ele for fifth grade and six through eight but if we end up keeping the high school at 90 everybody should be 90 but I I honestly would would like us to keep it the way it was the high school 85 and above should get principles list for honors and AP classes I think we're over time well over time um so Dr Chanley we have until seven Dr Chanley we should bring we'll bring this back to Dr Higgins and yes I and I and
111I think I think the conversation is it's not about the grade this is this is about the fact that we wait not wait as it wait but we wait wi we wait everything else so it doesn't there's no consist we have to be consistent if we're going to wait National honest soci and we wait the rank and we wait everything else then we need to wait this too because I the one thing I can't live with is how are mostly children academically are not principal list that makes no sense Dr Tammy I think the logistical challenge is this that every marketing period does not the report cards don't have have weighted averages so for every marking period they just have their you know they have whatever they got but their final report card has the
112weighted average that's the that's how the school does it right while every student is calculating his her own they know how to do it the kids to do it better than the adults yeah not doing it and I think that's a challenge that we would have to face if we decide to follow the policy as it was before this change movement all right so maybe there's a way around that but let's have a conversation um with Dr Higgins but um I think it's like I said it's twofold here personally I think academically you don't have who says we have to wait anything if you if you are have the ability to do this class then you should have this class and if you have an 85 you have an 85 but we do wait it
113so if we do wait it everything should be wait conversation so so this will go back to Dr Higgins it won't move to policy yes I it should should okay but also our policy currently is 85 and over but we just finished markeing period I don't know what happened this time also but we we're not following the policy and I'm Dr Chanley that is been going on for over a year since this was made you know this was made public by a parent we've been doing yeah we've been doing something that's not on our policy are are you are you saying that we are not that what we have on paper in essence is not being followed yes so um Charlie what's going on what our current policy says in high school 85 of or
114over in Hors classes should get the principal list and that has been our policy for policy document for a long time uh apparent and I brought this but that's that's on the current policies that we you're saying yes it's on the current policy but the high school is not been following it the high school has only been giving to principal list to students 90 and above and the parents have uh brought up a complaint there's a written complaint in email that me and have been talking about for since last summer so it's been a long time so the 0 I'm sorry so the 90 and above is what is currently on what we're recommending what's being recommended now yes right yes is the draft today is saying 19 about what trying I'm trying to recall
115I don't have it in front of me so no that's all right I want to make understand it the live policy on our board dos says 85 and over and the recommend ation from the administration is to change that to 90 and over and I'm resisting that recommendation um I don't think that is fair but ultimately and I know gazal you'll agree with this whatever our policy currently is is what we should be following following so right now we are following oury yes as as per and the parent has already complained about it we following the policy yeah we are in violation no we're violating no we're not following the policy we're in we're not following the policy right now and that's why this was needed that we tackle this right away but I don't
116think we've come to a conclusion yet and so I don't know how we can um you know direct the high school I I tell you gonna go back for discussion right with Dr Higgin I understand okay I understand I just think we're making a bigger deal out of this than we should number one number two I'm in agreement with the with the supervisors I think they're right on target I have to be right very honest with you um I just I just think I think what what colleges are looking at and and I agree with them they're looking at they're not looking at that stuff they're looking at other things so I'm not going to repeat them because it it's just not necessary but I I just have very mixed feelings about the whole thing
117I'll be quite honest with you uh but I I think I think I think the supervisor hit it right on the right on the right on target I really do as far as I'm concerned so I don't I don't disagree with you Charlie either but since the policy is how it is currently and there hasn't been a revision to it um we need we need to make sure that our current policy is followed until the policy changes are put into place so right now we have to make sure that current policy is followed but this is why we're having the discussion now to change the policy in some form or fashion um and then make sure that it's followed going forward okay to summarize this discussion Dr Layman we are also going to revisit uh
118one the the little change high honor role needs to be called principal list for Middle School we're going to revisit um high school and based on that discussion we either standardize uh if High School does not budge from 90 then everything becomes you know the same we shouldn't have separate you know standards for middle school and Elementary School and if High School changes then we could keep what we have right now for fifth grade and sixth grade also right is that a good yeah that's a summary that's a feedback we'll take to the principles okay and we'll we'll bring us back yep okay wonderful I think we covered everything yes thank you everybody stay warm okay bye bye bye bye everybody bye gazala enjoy your trip thank you out of here we