CorpusRecord 132985

Monroe Township Board of Education 03.29.17 Special Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Monroe Township School District
Date
2025-02-13
Location
Middlesex County, NJ
Material
Transcript
Extent
12,637 words · about 71 min
Collected
2026-06-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001the special meeting of the Monroe Township Board of Education will come to order please stand for the Pledge of [Music] Allegiance Pledge Ali to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all oh may we have a roll call Mr Gorski certainly Mrs armino yes Mr Braverman Mr cherella here Mrs Deo here Mrs Lang here Mrs Kino here Mr Rybeck here Mr Russo Mr rutsky here Mrs kapano here Madam board president you have a quarum present this evening in accordance with the provisions of the New Jersey open public meetings law the Monro Township Board of Education has caused notice of this meeting to be published by having the date time time and place thereof posted March 27th

0022017 at all schools the home News Tribune the Asbury Park Press and filed with the clerk of the municipality thank you so before we go to the public forum I would like to introduce Senator Linda Greenstein and she's with us this this evening and she's going to have the opportunity to answer any of the questions that any of the board members or members of the public might have in regard to our school funding and um the legislative initiatives that we will be discussing so at this time we'll go to the public forum anyone wishing to speak to the agenda please come from the to the microphone state your name and address for the record and we are going to adhere to our 3 minute time limit thank you good evening Tom notein 15 Nathaniel Street

003you can tell it's an election year because once again we get to hear our Senator tell us that she will be fighting for Monroe to get more State funding after I yawn all I can ask is where have you been for the last eight years last week I attended the recent ad hoc committee for fair funding after being told that this was not open to the public and asked to leave by the chairman of that committee Mr Ken chiarella I reminded him that the website said it was open so I would not leave nor did I leave I did receive an email apology for the mixup from our board president who thought it was closed it was supposed to be a closed meeting I understand mixups occur but the real issue is why would anyone

004think that a committee meeting that is discussing ways to involve the public would be closed to the public at this meeting the committee members which are made up of citizens of Monroe Boe members union members and administration discussed the general lack of help being given by our elected representatives in Trenton and how best to make sure we get more funding Senator Greenstein showed up with her letter and she insisted on reading it word for word because she felt the members may just skim it and not notice the impact potential after her reading the committee gave a rousing round of applause gone was the frustration that was evident in the committee's discussion prior to the Senator's arrival the committee appeared all in after m m merely hearing her recitation this is the letter we are called

005tonight at a special Boe meeting so that the board can sign and approve after reading this letter myself I realized this is not doing anything new and what our representative should have been doing all along we all know that the state has no no additional money so where is this money for Monroe to come from if it is taken from other districts it's fairly safe to say that elected officials from those districts will not support it other school districts are having similar issues such as Robinsville which is in this uh legislative district 14 and we'll also be requesting the same attention that Monroe wants if this letter offered Solutions it would have some credibility we elect people to come up with Solutions not just campaign rhetoric during a campaign season which is all this letter

006is at its core I fear that this whole committee's idea is nothing more than a sham to say that at least we did something letter writing and wearing purple t-shirts to Trenton will accomplish nothing unless we have elected representatives that can change the current funding and come up with a bold plan to ensure Fair funding our governor proposed such a plan and yet we heard nothing from our Senator about making it work or modifying the current funding form which is really what the answer is I urge this board to not get fooled again like we did last year with the legislation proposal during the previous election cycle we need to keep pushing for the money that Monroe deserves and making a bold statement that this time it's for real thank you very much for your

007time and your service thank you good afternoon Andy poori 16 St James Street tough fact to follow uh however about the ad hoc committee that was put together I must say that I'm a little disappointed that after I came here several times to express my interest to be on the committee I think you probably found somebody better than me to represent on the committee and I kind of surprised that after all that I have done uh that my name was ignored simply and haven't been approached having said that it's still we're all in this together and I think that's the the rhetoric that I want to bring in is that we're all in this together we still need to fight together what happened in the past is on water under the bridge finding fault with

008the senator assembly person assembly men is not the intent of this meeting I hope I hope this is a meeting moving forward in a progressive way to find a solution for school funding and we're all here to support that and one of the comments that I would like to make in the letter is I think the letter is excellent uh I would have probably done the same thing if I'm sitting on the ad hoc uh uh funding committee as well is that put a little bit more statistics or meat to this in in terms of how much we're spending and how much money we're sending to Trenton and what we're getting back from the Trenton as a part of it uh there is money to be allocated to Monroe it's just a matter of we

009identifying that and showing it to the to the governor and to the legislators to make sure it happened the fight has just began and we're not going to give it up until we get more funding from under Township thank you thank you [Applause] prakash pup 33 Dina Drive uh I read the petition which is uh provided by Senator and our assembly men and most of the content I agree with that but also we if you want to march to Trenton and if you want to get signatures from all the citizens of Monroe Township it should be in inclusive package What U I see missing is challenging the current Formula we we are talking about implement the current formula and get money but challenging the current Formula also should be included there is a good testimony

010provided by the mayor and the mayor said New Jersey for school formula is broken and more funding and equitable distribution is needed to meet constitutional and codee mandate for thorough efficient education okay and disparity in state funding Oldbridge receives $45 million and we receive three we are growing they are stagnant and they're getting more funding so we have to address that and also there are several points in Mayors which we have to abstract them put the statistics and talk more also Board of Education School District District they have said because of hold harmless this is on the web I read today and Monroe Township School District is cutting quality education I as a parent I cannot withstand that okay we cannot cut quality education that is on the web Monro taxpayers including senior citizens pay

011fund 88% of the revenue requ required for our schools we are taxing our senior citizens and other citizens twice so this has to be included we have 1,000 unhoused students that has to be addressed and another 1, 500 on house students are coming so so my request is I can go on it should be a good package inclusive package nonpartisan we are all here for our children okay so thank you i' just like to make a comment on that and Dr kak and Dr Alvi can maybe support this um we have not cut any programs from our district that I know of so our our quality programs are still there we have not cut any quality programs um it is on the web and it is on the your web because of the enrollment so

012I can give you the copy okay it is on the District web okay on the dist District website okay we will look into that anyone else from the public wishing to speak no let me see if there's anybody else from the public and then we'll have you go as soon as they're finished uh good afternoon Doug PO for tamarak Road um I looked at the the resolution that I think will be read tonight yes uh and I also looked at the letter and they do correspond uh considerably uh however and I don't really realize the logistics of of how you make this happen or even if it can happen uh I think there is a better chance of getting some positive reaction to this if the letter and if the uh the resolution were a

013bit broader in the sense of uh including districts that are very similar to Monroe in the sense that they too have experienced increased enrollments but a decline in state aid uh there are uh going through the department of education's website uh and looking at their statistics there are about 20 districts in the state having more than 3500 students in which those districts budgets are supported by the the local taxpayer uh at a level of 80% or higher which puts them in the same category as Monroe when you look at those districts closely you can identify 8 to 10 other District eight to 10 of those districts which have had reduced enrollment I mean I'm sorry reduced funding and yet an increased enrollment so I would think that politically it would be to our advantage to

014appeal to those additional districts and to the legislators of those districts uh to have a better chance of either getting more funding or to get the hold harmless removed or to get full funding so I would simply ask that that be taken into consideration uh as you consider the resolution of this evening as well as the letter uh I I do see that this letter is supportive of Monroe there are people that may be cynical as to why it's appearing now now uh I don't think the job of this board of education uh and I don't think it should be the position here in this room that uh people appear and speak uh for political purposes uh we our purposes should be to do whatever we can of a positive nature to increase the funding

015that Monroe Township gets and I think there are other districts that we could reach out to uh bring them into the fold and have a better chance of seeing that this succeeds thank you thank you thank [Applause] you Anthony proso a aan way I am here as both a former School Board member and a private citizen we and Monroe have been confronting the Dilemma of overcrowding schools in an adequate State support for 8 to 10 years now despite seeking relief through our state representatives and begging for their assistance because that's what you do in aiding our overburden taxpayers and in particular the seniors in the town nothing has changed but they are here tonight promising us a change what is the difference it's an election year that's the difference what I hear is nothing but

016rhetoric and pro pro promises we have heard that our Senator and two assembly men have written letters to our governor and in the past introduced a legislation with which would bring the need of relief we seek yes they had introduced the bills but what have they done besides that where has the leadership been in gathering support from their colleagues on both sides of the aisle despite their claims of holding leadership positions why haven't they had the clout to move the legislation forward in anything they do and what is the legislation they now claim will do the job form a committee to study school funding reform with the study to take place after the next few years it's just what we need another kick of the can down the down the road our representative hesitate to

017challenge their Democratic colleagues who represent the majority of the Abbott districts where is their leadership so while yes meaningful action is very overdue I'm not convinced that once we pass the the November election our three Representatives if they survive the election will do anything more than introduce bills that go nowhere thank you anyone else from the public Krishna deal L Jake place I have a a comment on this letter um this letter has been drafted there are a couple of things that we could actually more um highlight in this letter one um according to the projections that we have seen at the last board meeting we are looking at 500 students coming in for the next uh Academic Year this is more number of students than many school districts have we need to highlight that

018fact and the second thing reading at the letter um again this is more um what do you call a legal ease format we need to clearly identify what our immediate reliefs should be what we are looking for U from this legislation and what we are looking down the road what kind of funding do we need those two items I do not see in this SL letter thank you thank you is there anyone else from the public wishing to speak to the agenda okay at this time I will close the public forum and Senator would you like to make a comment right now good evening everybody um I was really hoping to answer so many of the things that were said and I'm just not going to remember all of them I'm sure but um one

019of the things that I want to start with not to start on a negative note but we don't see our work as political any any time of the year during any year when we're out helping one of our communities we do not see our work as political um we also see almost every year of Our Lives as election years because we have so many elections here in New Jersey so none of that has anything to do with why we're doing what we're doing or what we're doing so I do want to start on that note um we have worked for many years and we gave out an interesting piece that I was just thinking I wish I had brought with me tonight we spoke at Stonebridge about two weeks ago and we had a hand

020out there that listed many of our activities between between 2012 and now legislative and otherwise just a lot of the work that we've been doing to try to help m row and I don't know if you have it here or if you have multiple copies but it's something that I think people should at least take a look at um we have been working very hard we're trying a new approach right now and I'm going to tell you why there's a Confluence of factors that may actually make this possible now we never said that we've guaranteed that this is going to work we are going to try to make it work we're going to do our best um here are the factors that are new right now first of all the governor has stated in his

021recent budget speech that he's looking for a new way of doing things he pretty much pulled back on the flat tax approach that he was talking about or the flat funding approach and it's sort of acknowledged and I say sort of because he didn't come out directly and say it but you could tell by what he said he's pretty much acknowledging that doesn't seem to be going anywhere the courts are against it and he doesn't feel that uh he has the support he needs so he said he wanted to work closely with the other party to make something happen he also did one of his challenges that worked on the opiate thing which was he gave it a 100 days and whether it will work in a 100 days I don't know but it's kind

022of good to do that because it lights a fire under everybody and he said he'd like to see everybody try to come to some agreement on this in addition even before he made that speech the leaders of both of the houses the speaker and the Senate President president both taking different approaches have been out there working on the issue Senator Sweeney the Senate President has been going all over the state talking about his approach um the speaker has taken another approach but there have been hearings in both houses and a lot of serious discussion on a bipartisan basis about what we might do here in our particular case in this letter we are talking we are you talk about begging well people may have begged us but we're constantly begging we are begging them to

023do something this year we hope with a new governor we're all hoping that a new governor will take a much better approach to school funding than the last one has taken and I don't know if any of you realize we're constantly hearing people say in the last eight years well think about what has happened in the last eight years we've been under this governor and the school funding formula has not been followed it definitely is not perfect it needs to be changed and I'll explain how in a second as one of the gentlemen said but we do need to do something and this has pretty much been let's see how we can kill the public schools over the last eight years and that's what we're facing and that's part of the problem with the funding

024um so this year we feel there may be a unique opportunity because everybody's talking about two things and they both affect Monroe one is hold harmless or adjustment Aid funding that funding is one of the things that's making Monroe come out so badly when you look at all 500 something towns Monroe is high up there in terms of not doing well under the the way it's presently funded and it's not being done under the 2008 school funding formula it's just the way it's been done for the last eight years Monroe and a number of other towns are not doing well and everybody is lobbying not just for change under the new governor next year everybody's assuming almost that that's going to happen and that may not be a good assumption but everybody's assuming it we're

025trying for this year that's what this letter is about please please please give us something this year now you might say well we haven't had it before there's been a shortage that's true um when we try to get our colleagues to support us they're answer is well it's not helping my town so we're not going to help you which is pretty common um and that's what we've been facing but this year there uh really is an opportunity there's always extra money in the budget they always find it for something and we've been making our plea to try to get into some of that money even if it's a small amount even if it is as we call it in here a down payment to get us started we're looking to get a start on our

026school funding because we have done terribly under hold harmless what that was back back around 08 when the new school funding formula came in um certain towns were at a point in time when they were getting a certain amount of money and they were allowed to keep that money and as the years went on and they didn't need it anymore because they were doing better they still kept that money so I refer to it this is my own I should get it patented I love it I call it the Robin Hood approach we need to take from the towns that don't deserve to have it anymore and give it to the towns like this one um that really do deserve to have it and need to have it and that's the plea that we're making

027the other thing of course that really affects Monroe is the growth and there's no accounting for the growth in the way that the school funding formula has been given out for the last eight years those two things hold harmless and growth are the problem in a nutshell we also have transportation not funded properly special ed not funded properly but the two that I named are the main problem and in all of the Committees and even with the governor there's discussion about we have to try to get rid of that whole Harless I personally believe if we fail this year that by next year with a new governor um depending on who it is but most of the people who are up for governor of both parties I think will recognize that we have to get

028rid of hold harmless that we have to do something about grow about growth and that the school funding formula will reflect those things but right now that's not the case we are in a stagnant situation with no money for anybody and we're just saying let us go into these monies that float around here and there that are always kind of invisible but we know they're there um and let us get something so we can give it to I'm worried about my town now you somebody mentioned Mr Po I think mentioned um working with other towns and trying to get you know the formula changed well all of those things are well and good but right now I'm interested in one thing doing what we can for Monroe I'd love to help Robinsville too it's in

029my district but we've put a lot of our focus on Monroe we talk about it constantly and it's really a a important to us um basically that's it it's a combination of all three the governor and the two houses working on it um everyone recognizing the problems with hold harmless the economy being a little bit better and that's the reason why we think maybe we'll be able to get into a few people have told us that maybe we can one of the AIDS to the Senate President and um and the chair of the budget Committee in the assembly these are the things that are giving us hope we're not making up the hope it's real hope but can I say that I'm positive it will happen I can't say that we're going to do our

030level best as we always do and we're going to try this approach but last point the reason for this approach was which we haven't tried before we want to get as many we want to wow them with the number of names we and the petitions we want to show them how serious a problem this is we are constantly telling them that it's a serious problem I think they hear it but it's much better to see than to hear when they see these petitions I think they will have to take some notice I hope so anyway so that's where we stand can I answer any questions if that's appropriate any questions from uh board members Mr Russo we um supposedly in the past did a letter writing Campaign which um generated about 2,000 letters from the

031community of Monroe to the to the legislators I believe you were in office at the time do you know about when because we've gotten many groups of letters over the years on schools I don't I don't there's a recent group that I have not answered yet because we were embroiled in all of these new developments and I wanted to answer them when I really had something to say I I didn't want to write the usual letter like we're working on it you see in a few months Mr I wasn't on the board then uh but since I've been advocating to send out letters now uh this has been U stalled and now I find we're taking a new Direction so as part of the argument against the letter writing campaign uh it was said that

0322,000 letters were sent and that wasn't enough no I I find that to be no yeah if I'll wait till you're finished and then I'll and so the question is because you said you want to get the wow factor um how many people okay when you are writing letters to the three legislators you're basically preaching to the choir we're with you we've been working for you we've been trying we know have you wowed us I don't quite remember 2000 but I'm not going to deny we didn't receive 2000 I just don't know I know I got some recent letters but I can tell you that we notice them we are wowed by them but we're on your side already what we're trying to do is to use and I like your term the wow factor

033with the leadership of the legislature they're the people that make the ultimate decision um when I tried to get my bill through a couple of years ago and some people here were present the Senate President had to come in and twist arms to get that bill through the committee as a favor to me he does that for everybody when he knows something's going to happen or has to happen and some people don't want to vote for it he twists arms if he hadn't come into that room would it have gone through I'm not sure but he twisted arms and he said you just do this and they did it um we got it through but everybody said to me after you know it doesn't help my district I don't think I can go further with

034this that's why we're going right to leadership and not just to the other Democrats and Republicans because they're going to worry about their own districts we are trying our best to see if we can get leadership to see our need to see the extreme amount of work we have done on this now I will tell you we had an a few gentlemen here were at the meeting um we had a meeting with Hesby the former education commissioner in my office one of several we had with him and at the meeting he made a joke about Monroe see they're shaking um he was saying there is no town I have heard about more than Monroe if I could Snap My Fingers just pull some money out of a hat it would go to Monroe because I've

035heard so much I mean we have been advocating for several years many years this little paper that we did I don't know if you found a copy it went back to 2012 but our advocacy went back well before that we just listed events from 2012 and it took several page of single spaced so we truly have been working on it to say that we've been sitting back just because we haven't succeeded in pulling some money out of a hat doesn't mean we haven't been trying very hard we really have I can assure you so getting back to the question okay what number would wow you I'm wowed by any number I'm wowed by what you sent it wowing me is not the issue wowing the Senate President and the governor and the speaker is the

036issue that's what we're trying to do what number would wow them I can't say but I would say a visibly large group of petitions that we can barely hold and carry and we're straining under it that would wow them especially if I fall you know we we don't have we don't have a number I don't that would raise the flag and say the public is really concerned yeah Town needs money because 2,000 letter is could mean could mean uh 4,000 adults and maybe another 6,000 kids who are going to the school that are asking for funding so 2,000 letters is to me wow I think they would be very impressed by that many signatures but I don't have a good feel for that so I would almost look to other people to decide that I

037I can't tell you a number that would definitely be the right number to give them I would just say as many as you can get within whatever amount of time and if you ask me the time which has been asked this is what I I've thought of um the um I'm just wrote here first group um the education commissioner is going to be um questioned by the budget committee and that's one possible time to come in one of the dates I think is April 24th and the other is another date in April one's the assembly one's the Senate May 2nd it's May 2nd okay those are the two dates that the education commissioner so that would be one time I don't think you have to get all the petitions at once you just get what

038you can get by a certain date so that would be a nice date to be able to bring them in and give it there right at the State House another date that's possible is around May 10th because that's when the budget hearings end where we question the Commissioners and then we go into discussions of the budget so that would be a good date for some signatures and finally in early June we do what are called the bud resolutions um where we ask for certain money and that's sort of another good date so those are a few different times there's no one time to absolutely have them in and that would be the end of it I would say as as many as you could get just doing your best I have to say and I'm

039trying to be very honest with you there's no guarantee this will work I would just say do your best to get the signatures let's try this approach it has not been tried before we're already working on like you wouldn't believe talking to as many people as we can but this would be a voice from Monroe saying we really really need this see concern so let me see if there's any other board members who have questions okay is there any questions from any other board members I just have Mr Mayo um do we know how many districts are um benefiting from the hold harmless provision you know I don't have those numbers with with me they do exist though and I could get you that information um I know some folks here have tables you do

040you know the answer to I actually have the tables uh been communicating with about 15 other superintendents from other districts to Mr Po Point uh throughout the state South Central and New Jersey and several school districts have put together numbers and we have a table um with the number every District in the state how much they're underfunded how much they're fund it we have it broken out by County it's highly organized actually uh I can certainly share that with you that would be great thank you sure maybe you could send that to every board member so we ABS okay absolutely okay Mr Rybeck thank you Senator um I was at those meetings that you arranged with Sweeney and hesie and and thank you for all that I know you've been working for us uh but

041of course the result isn't what any of us uh wanted so far especially me I bet uh well you can see the interest here um and thank everybody for coming out um but you know the bottom line right now is the taxes state aid what and what we could do for Monroe you mentioned something about uh you know the political climate and getting a even if it's a small down payment which struck my interest uh I need to you know just emphasize the fact that I think a small down payment wouldn't satisfy the taxpayers here in Monroe we need more than that I I know you're going to shoot for more than that all I'm saying is please remember that it's a small down payment won't satisfy this you know these taxpayers they're really hard

042pressed and and I agree I guess the thought would be get something now as a recognition of where we're at that we're upfront um get something this year at a time when virtually no one else would get something and that kind of puts us up front and then by next year with the new governor we're all putting so much stock that in this we would have um hopefully a return to the good parts of the school funding formula but getting rid of these bad parts like the hold harmless and the and the growth and trying our best to really be not only in the Forefront at that point but to be funded properly because the formula is proper thank you so that's what we're hoping for okay and um m lang hello Senator greenson how

043are you very it's funny to see you on the other side I'm usually testifying in front of you um my my questions kind of go hand inand with the funding in addition to the funding and one of the big concerns that I have right now as a member of this community as a board member and of as a parent is that we are not the only District that's get is struggling that there are other districts that are fighting for funding if we don't get the funding we're still and as my grandmother would say up the creek without a paddle for the things that we need to do such as build a new school and meet the needs of our students Lakewood is screaming that they need millions of dollars there's other districts doing that what

044can be put into place or what can be done hand inand with fighting for funding to maybe put a limit on some of the unfunded mandates that the state is putting on school districts for a district such as Lakewood which they're going to be losing 100 plus teachers that sending $2.5 million to Charter Schools doesn't make sense in our own District we're going to be spending $150,000 next year to Charter Schools to me this doesn't make sense it doesn't make sense to me that we spend hundreds of thousands of dollars or whatever on Park testing when we need to be spending money on classrooms for our kids so is there something that you can do or that you can work within this 100 days of the budget to maybe say okay if you can't have

045if you don't have money to give our school districts then it's time that we change the way that we're doing business with our school districts because it's very unfair I know in my own family we've struggled financially my kids have their things that they don't get because it's not there but if somebody comes to me and says well you have to I'm like well you can't get blood from a stone so can you do something along those lines well so many of the the things you mentioned are going on right now I mean there's um a real push to get rid of the park testing I guess we just had a bill very recently on that um some of the other areas that you talked about are being worked on but I work closely with

046the school administrator business administrator and and superintendent and Kathy um and anything that you come up with as a board I want you to communicate to me it may be something as a legislature are already working on like a few I was trying to think what else you mentioned I think there were other things you mentioned that we are already working on so we don't just work on this one area of trying to get funding we're always looking at all the parallel areas that could potentially save you money the negative to it is how slowly the system Lumbers along um so you put an idea through and you know if someone or other like the Senate President thinks it's an emergency it's an emergency and if most of the rest of us think it's an

047emergency it may or may not be it probably isn't so it just takes a really long time for some things to happen but that doesn't mean we aren't working on them um but if you have any ideas do not hesitate to give me the ideas and I'll check if it's being worked on and if not we'll work on it appreciate I would appreciate the input Mr tiella Senator Greenstein I want to thank you for uh coming here today I also want to thank you for coming to the end of of the last meeting to uh to to answer our questions the committee's questions thank you uh which was only last week by the way that was our first meeting what I'd like to ask you though is that you know we have we have issues

048in Monroe on top of the funding the fair funding issue uh that are that impact us immensely and I don't think I don't think everyone gets the the complete picture of what's going on here in Monroe but I think when we look to you and our representatives in Trenton what we're looking for is for uh is for help tackling some of the issues that are in some in some ways very unique to Monroe so we have a we have unique demographics um we have uh things like a need for impact fees to be assessed of developers we we have to have that ability and that isn't something that seems to be addressed it seems that we we bend over backwards in Trenton to help Developers for whatever for whatever reason um when others States uh

049allow impact fees um the other things are things like uh some of the the rules and regulations with regards to affordable affordable housing obligations um and things like that and even just then funding prop funding schools through property taxes which is just is is uh is utterly outrageous and shouldn't even be it shouldn't even happen but um so it's it's those things but then on top of that we have we have we have the local situation where we have you know we have uh we have an Administration in this town that is very friendly to the developers and uh I've I've fought against that there are a number of people on the board of ed that have fought against that off the board and on the board Mr Ryback's one of them uh with a

050card uh and and uh you know we're what we're looking for is is help and in some cases protection from the very people that are in power and I think that if the voters uh really want to do something they need to put pressure not only on on uh our representatives and Trenton and our legislators but they need to go across the street and they need to hold the mayor and they need to hold the council accountable and that's something that's not happening they point over here or they point to Trenton and they never point to their own pocketbooks or their or or their own campaign financing and funding and I think that that's something that has to be done I think it's in coming upon all the residents that if we're upset and we're

051and we're angry with Trenton we need to be just as upset because the funding would not be as glaring the funding in equity would not be as glaring if we did not have an Administration in town that was overly friendly with developers and have caused all this stuff so when they sit back and they go hey it's Trenton and it's the affordable housing obligation well I have some news for everyone this the building going on in 33 the building going on in 522 the JSM developments that was all prior to this affordable housing obligation ruling this was all done years ago and uh and we're suffering from it now so for them to blame the affordable housing obligation is just wrong we so I don't want to I don't want to get up on my

052own St I just wanted to thank you for coming but there are also other issues that I hope we can address um I think that our committee is taking a nonpar partisan approach to this you know I'd like to just say too to our to the detractors you know there we had one meeting so far and there are people that are trying to kill us in the crib we haven't even we haven't even learned to walk yet we're just trying to figure out who we are the committee who the people are introduce each other uh introduce ourselves and and get a firm plan going and we have people standing up here who have been on the port of Ed in the past saying that it's a shame that we haven't done anything you know we're

053not doing anything we're not planning on doing anything well I I have a challenge for all those people where what is your plan what would you have us do who would you have us talk to if not to our and work with if it not with our elected officials then who just to sit here and complain all day or how about this we can create a budget that's just $600,000 under cap as a sham when we have schools bursting at the seam seams we need new schools we need trailers we need all of these things and then we're going to create a sham and say hey we're going to just cut the budget by $600,000 under cap which by the way is a tax increase and try to sell that as a to the public

054as a great thing that's a that's a miscarriage of Justice too so if there's a sham going on here we're trying to fix it now and hopefully this board will recognize that and move to fix it today but I wanted to thank you Senator I agree with some of what you said M Mr ch I just want to clarify you're talking about the ad hoc committee on Fair fund okay cuz you didn't say ad hoc I don't want to think it's the Board of Education thank you I actually I I just wanted to respond on one thing and that was about the impact fees for those who don't know there have been bills in for I don't know 20s something years they have never gone anywhere obviously it must be because I've never gotten a

055straight answer otherwise there must be a tremendously tight hold on Trenton by the builders I don't understand why it's that big uh but apparently it must be because I see no other reason we just haven't been able to get it through um I think it's a great idea I think absolutely when Builders come into a community they should be building the schools and there are impact fees for certain purposes but not for schools and that would solve a lot of our problems as for the part about um how we fund schools we've we've pondered that in the legislature for many years it all if years ago we used to talk about it a lot more um it is true that property taxes are not the best way to do it except there really are no

056great ways to do it because if you lower property taxes you raise income taxes you're always getting people upset one way or another the only difference is that Pro um income taxes are more Progressive than property taxes those are regressive if you're rich or poor you live in a certain house you pay the C same property taxes but with income taxes that isn't the case so in a theoretical sense that would be a more Fair Way um you there are other but in the end it always comes down to moving from one tax to another and you know you Gore someone's Ox no matter what you do so the legislature toyed with it a number of times talked about it a number of times and just hasn't really come up with anything but there's no

057question the way we fund the schools is pretty bad I don't think it's done that way in all states we did look at this in 2007 we had a big special session where we looked at how schools were funded and we just couldn't come up with anything that would uh work better for New Jersey that anyone was willing to do I should say um it's a very tough issue politically to get done and maybe someday we will get it done maybe we'll find a fair way but right now it seems to be the way it's done Mr Mino thank you senator for coming out this evening um I'll be speaking on my you know as a board member but also on behalf of the citizen uh and residents that put me here um I've heard

058a lot from people over the years as you will know I've been involved in trying to educate myself and my fellow residents for 15 years I go to a lot of the meetings you've seen me before um so I I some of the things are are things that I have gained from my experience and some are definitely uh and mostly from the people that I represent so um let me just begin with a couple questions um um the Ju Just from some of the things that you said that that the you know we're hoping that a new governor might change certain things but the same legislature has been there and would and is it not the case that the majority has had control for the last eight years that's true okay so we were hoping

059that and and I and I believe in this case you're part of the majority yeah so if if the majority has been in control of the legislature cannot the legislature override the governor's um uh things uh even his vetos with good legislation well here's the problem if there was a will if there was a will but here's the problem because the governor in our state the governor any governor of New Jersey has a tremendous amount of power because of the types of vetos that he can do right um You need uh a large number of legislators not only all the Democrats we have but a number of Republicans not a lot but a couple of Republicans to overcome a gubernatorial V we haven't done it once in 8 years we have tried and tried on

060many many bills all kinds of bills and we've not been able to overcome him the closest we came was on a certain gun bill it was the most innocuous bill that Republicans had voted for but when it came to the veto they would not vote for it which is crazy there is I just we'll stick to school funding well specifically to school funding was there a v was there a veto of the governor that the the majority put out are you talking about any change in school funding any help for well the kinds of things I'm talking about would be pieces of legislation and the school funding formula was done as legislation back in 2008 at the time when Corine was still in office so there hasn't been um an opportunity to try to overcome

061a particular piece of legislation that I could think of I may be okay missing something but I can't think of a piece that we would have tried to overcome cuz everything here it goes back to the school funding formula and then the changes the State Department of Education have made whoever was the education commissioner working with and for the governor would have put through certain approaches and when they did that was what um okay and you mentioned that again uh with maybe some changes down the road uh or next year after the election what do you expect or or if we put this uh resolution in what do you expect from the current leadership with a resolution like this um what we're looking for is to have the Senate President who I think of the

062three parties we're writing the letter to is the most apt to be favorable to this because he's pushing very hard to get rid of hold harmless that's his goal and that's what he's going around the state doing so he likes this approach he's the most likely to be on our side I'm not sure about the speaker because he's um I'm not sure where he's coming from on this to be candid I can't I'm not in that house and I can't speak for it but I think he'd be more difficult and the governor I'm just not sure if he's serious about working with us maybe he'll be willing to do a few things but this succeeding this year as we're asking for is going to be premised on the idea that our leaders are going to

063go in and really fight and say we've got to do this for maybe a couple of towns Monroe being one of them um if don't go in and do it and the governor isn't going to take it up on his own I'm sure it probably wouldn't happen we're depending on that happening but because but but as you've pointed out that even um your colleagues have sort of um declined in in the appeals to help Monroe here when we tried to do the legislation we needed our colleagues to do it right this will not need our colleagues this will be a leadership initiative Senator Sweeny says we're taking x amount out of some fund somewhere to uh make this happen this year for Monroe if he says it maybe it'll happen um if the governor is

064willing to work with him that makes it even better so what is the action in this letter because I really see it as an informative that's what I did mean to respond to that somebody said um I know what you mean it it goes through and it informs and we're not really pushing a there there are a few little places where we say we need more money we need it this year but we didn't put in a specific amount intentionally because we have no idea how much it might be we just don't know now I suppose we could change it and put in a specific amount but if that's weigh more than they're hoping to give you know that could derail it if it's weigh less then we lose out so we wanted to leave

065it a little bit vague so that um it could start a discussion I mean we that's what we did we just sort of said you know we need money we need it now I mean that's the message of the letter we're saying we we're first giving all those facts and we're saying what a terrible situation we're in and then we're saying we really need to get some help but that would just echo in my opinion that would just Echo what everybody else is saying there's nothing specific we need I mean we can come in with something definitive and we need an action plan as we've heard from a lot of our residents in terms of building the schools and all that we need something specific that we can draw on to say well it either

066didn't happen or it did just saying please help us um I think that's echoed throughout the state it doesn't distinguish Monroe from anybody one difference and I mean this very sincerely is you don't have too many legislators who are out there the way we are it sounds like Senator Beck is and there may be a few others but most of the other legislators are pretty much not and so this is a case that we're hoping of the squeaky wheel getting the grease so that's part of it um as for an action plan um we're kind of setting out for them the problems here uh with all the statistics and information H where they would read it and say oh gee you know this they probably know it already but oh gee this is pretty bad

067and uh it would give them some ammunition if they want to try to help why should they help us well we're asking a lot we're asking loud we're asking constantly and we've been doing it for a very very long time um and there's really no other reason other than Monroe is very low on the list of getting money much lower than most other towns you're well right up there with the town's not getting anything under the way the governor's been putting for and we spend $124 million in operating budget alone every year for Monroe and if 80 to and uh 88 to 89% of it is is the taxpayer burden that people are sitting in this room that's right um we can't really wait uh you said it takes a long time to work work

068on things and it takes a long time uh to get things accomplished and I think certain things yeah you you've we have echoed that we can't wait that long oh that's what we're saying in here we're saying we can't wait right and our residents have to take a long time to work they work a long time to pay these taxes Y and they get they have to pay their taxes every year or every month to the municipality so as long as they're working we're we're putting in our taxes on a regular basis so we really need some Rel what I would suggest you you also mentioned um and I think you just said um that there is no accounting for growth well I would does it say that yeah you no you said that oh

069you said that while you were talking when you were talking about the school funding there's no accounting for growth I think that's lacking in in this letter um because I think there should be some accounting for growth because the growth is what feeds the enrollment if I said that I might have misspoken cuz I no no no no you you didn't mean it in the in terms of accounting on this letter what you said well I don't I we'll have to go to the videotape to figure out exactly what but essentially you said in maybe in this subject matter it growth is not accounted for in the kind of money that Monroe receives if I can be clear about that but I think it should be right now oh absolutely yes right now so I

070think if you're going that's an action plan item that could be put in a letter like this that we have to come up with um and as Mr cherel Appley put um developers impact fees that is something definitive that we can ask the leadership to to do because um 100% like I said 89% of the local residents are paying taxes but 100% of the growth comes from local Municipal decisions on Planning and Zoning patterns so one is not devoid of the other and we keep hearing that one makes no difference to the other it truly does so I think if we're going to appeal to our leaders we have to appeal and and I don't know if you signed the sarlo ACT but just as I didn't vote for that you didn't well that was

071good because that hurt Monroe specifically not because of um it's just because of the enormity of the building at one time so I think impact fees are are very much in in the same uh subject matter as this we could put it in and as I said I'm very much in favor of them the only thing is this was focusing on money strictly the impact fees are a type of legislation we can push for that in a parallel way as I said it's been very hard it it's never gone anywhere we should continue to push we just don't want to make getting the money in any way contingent on getting the impact fees cuz that's like a separate action this is more of a budgetary action that would be legislative I mean I that's how

072I see it anyway okay but we can certainly do separate letters to the leadership talking about would would you be willing to sponsor an impact fee legislation absolutely absolutely see I've had them in in the past and I will be very happy to Y are there any other because we need to get moving with this agenda mrback I make thank you Mr omia for mentioning um and Mr cherel also for mentioning impact fees it's been a um a hardfought campaign of ours uh Charlie Len's out there Victor Cooper we've been fighting for this for a long time advocating for it and I I personally would like to see this come to fruition but I I I want to ask you a question I'm doing a little political analysis here so if I'm wrong forgive me

073you said you didn't know exactly where the speaker was on this issue concerning Monroe I can tell you more than I think but it will be a guess that he represents Jersey City and Jersey City does not stand to benefit if we eliminate the hold homeless that's what I think I I I always hear about Jersey City because they're one of the towns that benefits from hold harmless and it's I don't remember if he represents them he might uh but certainly he's a close Ally of the mayor there and that has got to be coloring his thinking there may also be other towns that um would benefit from hold harmless so he has some of his own political reasons I guess not to want to um hurt the hold harmless towns thank you so that

074that may be true I'm almost sure it is but I I don't know that for absolutely sure okay is there any other questions for the senator from the board members okay thank you Senator very much every we're going to move on with the agenda if you need to go I understand if you'd like to stay we might have some questions later from either um public forum or board member questions underneath the I could say a couple of minutes no not at this time I could stay a few minutes I have another meeting okay thank you thank you the public session is closed we have another one after um we have the um the school funding and then a close session and then another public forum so at this time we're going to go to number

075six and I'm going to ask Mr Chella to please read the um resolution thank you in his continuing fight for fundamental fairness in state aid school funding I hereby move that the Monro Township Board of Education support and endorse the legislative initiatives of Senator Lind de Greenstein assemblyman Wayne D'Angelo and assemblyman Daniel Benson as set forth in our letter to the governor speaker and Senate President dated March 22nd 2017 to number one eliminate growth limitations and hold harmless Provisions in the school funding formula in the current budget cycle to provide additional state aid to Monro Township School District number two reform the school funding formula in the current budget cycle to provide additional state aid to the Monro Township School District and number three design and legislate a new funding formula which will create more

076Equitable state aid funding for the Monro Township School District I further move that the Board of Education authoriz and direct the superintendent of schools and a business business administrator slbo secretary to take all necessary steps to implement this action by the Board of Education including the development and dissemination of a petition in support of the letter and this resolution to the taxpayers of Monroe Township Mr Tiel moved it Mr Ryback would you like to Second it okay thank you second by Mr Ryback are there any comments or questions for the from any member of Mr Chella yeah I just have a couple quick questions and I and I and I thank I just want to thank everyone for you know for coming today for being here uh I also want to thank the board members

077for for being here today and then I want to thank our committee members uh like I said earlier to the senator uh this was our first meeting so the committee met for the first time last week we we uh we decided to have another meeting tonight where we'll discuss further uh some of our our uh you know our our future endeavors I want to be clear that that this isn't the end of the committee this is the beginning of the committee now we're just looking at all avenues uh we're looking at whatever we can do in order to make a lot of noise in order to cause uh pain and hopefully get oil for lack of a better term as as a senator put it because we're going to be the squeaky wheel so I

078just want to I just want to ensure everyone that we're this is not an endorsement this is not uh we're not we're it's a bipartisan committee and for anyone who wants to come tonight and and witness it uh it's open to the public and you're going to see Republicans and Democrats and independents and uh senior citizens and young people and you know a whole cross section of the public um so the there are a couple Provisions in here that I think uh matter a great deal but I want to say that the reason that I'm I am endorsing this is because it takes action before November it's not a promise of future future action where for us to say hey thank you great job and let's uh let's hope something happens after November we're asking

079them through this letter and through the petition through this action to take action prior to November if that fails then it's on them you know it's on it's uh but we're going to still keep moving forward everything in my mind is still on the table everything from a letter like this working with our local politicians to suing the state if we have to uh I think everything should be on the table everything is still on the table and I think that we have to keep it that way until we get a resolution to our problem because our problem continues to grow and that's all I have to say thank you any other board members Mr Russo yeah um I was a little disappointed because the ad hoc committee we only had one meeting uh we

080really didn't as Ken said didn't even get to know each other or know who was on the on the committee uh we never developed a strategy suddenly a letter came out um which was like maybe a letter from from some Shadow group that uh is asking everybody to sign and uh everybody on the board to to endorse so I'm a little apprehensive to go forward I think that the ad hoc committee would need more time to meet uh to develop a strategy and to agree on on the on the scope and the purpose and um and and that would be the way to move forward I'm also a little reluctant because um if we did send 2,000 Letters Out in the past and you can see the response was null it concerns me because much

081of this is dependent on getting signatures so I'm I'm concerned about that I have some reservations about how the committee has been uh Ken I I give Ken a lot of credit for taking on the task it's a it's a risk and it's it is a big task but I think that the committee needs more time to develop a strategy that's my opinion anyone else Mr Rybeck thank you madam president I've been hearing a lot of things uh especially today before this meeting and um some things came to my mind that I think it's important for me to to bring out to the community as well as my fellow board members one is that um we are not getting involved in any kind of a political race we're not endorsing candidates we're working with our

082current legislators to bring what we think this town needs to fruition as soon as possible before the election Ken has uh very appropriately mentioned that at the atack committee which I he invited me to attend and I thank him for that uh that was made clear time and time again uh there are three areas here that we're coming out if we vote in favor of this obviously supporting it's not supporting a candidate or any candidate it's supporting three ideas that can bring money if these ideas are brought forth can bring money to Monroe to help our taxpayers and just to emphasize to do this we're doing what I think uh is our job and that's working with our current legislators to achieve these ends we can't wait till after an election why not do it

083now H in a way I have uh a lot of respect for our legislators for com to the adoc committee and today also and telling us they've been trying over eight years haven't been successful takes a lot to say you haven't been successful um and I admire that in them but they're not giving up we're not giving up it's who we're working with we're working with our Representatives that's how I look at it and um it's not an endorsement or or not saying no it's we're not getting involved politically which we cannot as a board of education thank you Mr Gorski did you want to say sayi go ahead Miss no Miss armino um well I would agree with everything on here except the actual word endorse the legislative uh the legislative initiatives and then

084it names the people so it is an endorsement um I would I would think that if it were uh structured the opposite way that the Board of Education and all of these things um and and we say all of these things and then the our legislators end for us putting these initiatives forward I would be in favor of that I mean we could send the the the good Senator has said that they are all on board with us so why can't the board structure the letter in such a way that it doesn't look like a political endorsement and say that we are approaching the leadership and our legislators sign our requests for the same exact thing just re just reformatting the letter and asking our legislators to endorse the Monroe Township Board of Education going

085to the leadership that would feel a lot more like a nonpartisan and um non-political uh a letter to me and I would and and since the senator says that uh all three of our Representatives will endorse us if we have all this I would ask that the letter be reformatted to not look like a political um endorsement of their initiatives these are really our initiatives these are things that we've been asking for all along so that would be my reason if um if I decide not to agree it would only be if if we can change the format and ask our representatives to sign our endorsement of these uh uh three issues thank you anyone else Mr Gorski Madam having the pleasure of working with the board and uh Administration um I could bear witness

086to Senator Greenstein Benson and D'Angelo's efforts which stem back to 2010 I regret I do not have the letter that shows uh all of this the chronology but I can say that uh with the senator in hand and and through many efforts with mayor tamboro and mayor pooie before him we've met with the governor Chief of Staff of the go as the governor wasn't available to meet with us we've met with the commissioner of Education we've testified before the Senate education hearing on funding fairness the assembly commission we've even developed our own legislation here in Monroe to offer t uh tax relief because that's where this additional form of Aid would have been directed towards um for the seniors in this population of Monroe that that exceed onethird of uh the population some of the

087frustration um has been attempting to squeeze more juice from an underfunded School school funding Reform Act of 2008 the governor has underfunded the school funding Reform Act of 2008 by over a billion dollars since his tenure all of the efforts that we've had to try to get so far with even our legislation has been trying to work with that existing formula and squeeze more out of it when inherently it's underfunded grossly to begin with it's trying to it's like trying to get more performance out of a lawn mower when you have a half a tank of gas to cut the lawn it's only going to go so far what the senator has in in her letter which is part of the resolution as number three tonight is unique one and two go to working with

088the current form the current school funding Reform Act of 2008 again to try to squeeze a little more out of it but number three is important because even if one and two are accomplished and some other items like the transportation fund we were looking at uh to reward us for being the most efficient Transportation unit in the county and the highest in the state were giving us more money it wouldn't satisfy as Mr Ryback said it wouldn't move the needle in here in Monroe but number three is unique to design and legislate a new funding formula which will create a more Equitable state aid school funding for the Monroe Township School District that is an ongoing process that will take time and um only through that number three in my opinion will Monroe really receive

089satisfaction from any initiative with state aid because finally we will be reaching into the equalization Aid through the local share local fair share Provisions where we have been excluded from that type of aid for decades and that is the largest part of Aid that funds the district's adequacy budget two thirds of which is mandated by the state by the way it may I Madam president um it seems to me that I agree with everything you just said uh Mr Gorski and that it seems to me the same thing could be accomplished again if we just change a little bit of the wording on this letter and uh it coming from We're elected officials also these three things we could put forward which we have in the past and we've been doing on a regular basis

090and ask our representatives to show their support of us by endorsing this from a from a letter from us to the leadership that's all I'm asking I'm asking for a perception that it may that it would be nonpartisan and um not not political as a political endorsement that's all I'm asking the same exact language just changing the letterhead a little bit okay any other comments questions from just a quick question because I wasn't sure Ken did you talk about is there a meeting tonight tonight at 7 pm ad hoc meeting yes open to the public or not yes this one's open to the public it's not open to all the board members the board members are going to be the only ones Deni the opportunity to no because that would make a quorum and yes

091I understand I was just clarifying because of other comments so I just thought that's what I heard just check it okay so before we go to the vote I just want to again um one question just yeah about the this board meeting um since this is um a big issue for all the residents in Monroe who PID property taxes many of them who work and don't wouldn't be able to make a meeting at 5:00 I'm just curious curious as to why the meeting was held at 5: and if it couldn't have been held later to accommodate those people who are still commuting well part of the reason is that we are sort of like in a time crunch we want to be able to get the petitions out so that we are um represented at

092the hearings that are coming up in April 24th and May 2nd so if we can get the petitions and then get it to the senator and then they get it to the the legislators that they need to get it for then we hopefully will be heard when time comes that we're going to the hearings um knowing that we had already scheduled an ad hoc committee meeting for this evening we decided that if we can get this letter um supported before and have the petitions ready we can get them out to the to the um ad hoc committee this evening instead of waiting another week um because at this point I think we need to have them back around the 18th which only gives us at this time about 3 weeks if we waited another week

093it would be another week less that we can go out there and get this done um so that is why we had the meeting tonight at 5:00 I don't know I don't know if you notice I was running that was I was running to come in here to get here on time right so yeah if it the future if they can be held at um at 7 just one more note I and I just want to make sure that everyone understands my point is not about the politics of it but I thought the committee needed more time the atart committee to develop a strategy so I just want to make that clear and I and I think that uh decision should be made once the committee agrees on something which we haven't we haven't done

094okay okay miss armino you I you haven't spos just go ahead I agree about that and I just have a question how was it that it was the first meeting and Linda greenson came like who called her how did that happen did someone make a decision without asking the whole group what they thought I thought it was like a brainstorming type of a committee and you were going to talk about things but yet it was already structured and ready to go before the meeting Mr tiell would you like to to respond to that question because I know that we've had some conversations and we've had some conversations with this the senator before the ad hoc committee meeting also we had we had meetings um we had a meeting with the with Senator Greenstein and uh

095assemblyman D'Angelo and assemblyman Benson in their office in in Senator greenstein's office to just to just look at what we were looking at and we had a very blunt conversation where we discussed funding we discussed the issues that they were facing with our voters and the and the climate uh basically telling them this is what uh this is what you're up against this is what's going on and this is you know there's a palpable anger uh amongst our voters and that and that uh it stems from a lot of different things but in in in a lot of ways uh it's being focused now on on Trenton in our state legislators and so we we you know we we were looking for avenues that we could take that would relieve Monroe anything that would help

096relieve the taxpayers of Monroe so before uh before our meeting uh our board president contacted me and said would it be okay if Senator Greenstein came at the end of the meeting to ask some questions or answer questions and bring up a letter that she's working on to see the committee things to read it to the committee so I said I don't think that would be a problem if it was at the end where you know we had already did our inter we we were meeting probably for at that point I don't even know an hour something yeah uh so and that's what happened so they she came in she talked about some of the things they were working on showed us read the letter to us and then also said that uh asked us

097if we would if it would be something we were interested in the committee at that point um after they heard the letter applauded her and uh we and then we just made some decisions to you know with everyone there everyone was present to move forward and bring it to the board yeah and I don't think because I I don't want to have a discussion on the at hoc committee because we do have a vote on the floor that we need to do but I don't think I did not hear any negative um comments coming out of that ad hoc about bringing the letter to the board of education so um I I I thought that it was very well received um and except it feels political to me that's well I just want to reiterate

098because I I think we need to vote now that this is not an endorsement of the candidates who are running for election it is an effort to or where what we are endorsing is the legislative efforts of our legislators to support us in what we're doing um we are a board of education we are non partisan we do not support a pol itical parties but when somebody reaches out I I think that um we need to be able to um work together with with the others to hear our voices and make the appropriate um decisions um we also have on the ad hoc committee who is supporting this letter Township officials board members mtea members uh PTA members adult community members and parents so not one of them expressed any dissatis action with going in

099this direction at the ad hoc meeting last week so at this time I think we're just going to um take a vote Mr gski on may I offer an a ask Mr cherel if I we can offer an amendment to the resolution I think that's proper procedure at this point I would I would ask if he would amend the resolution to just change the format of the letter what we're doing is endorsing their letter we don't that's why I'm asking for an amendment to change that rather than table rather than table it until the next meting then we would be endorsing our letter we're not endorsing our letter we what we have on the table is an endorsement of the letter that they are SP think under Roberts rules I can ask for an amendment

100to that Mr cherella could deny or AC and I I don't know if I need a second on that I need a second to ask for I I I don't know I'm trying to figure out what the uh what the amendment would be I mean these are this is their letter with their uh their verbiage I mean I didn't you know they well that's sort of my point I I I agree with every this is our responsibility to ask for these things from our legislators and the leadership that's what you've been saying that's what the public has been asking for to do this all along I have no problem with putting this letter together and asking our three legislators to support us in in their signatures and then addressing it to that's that's what the

101amendment would be but we cannot make an amendment to somebody else's letter so what you have to do is just not support this and then you can make a recommendation to create create our own letter we need to do that so at this time we are so we have a second though should we there's a second well then you could withdraw your your motion because we cannot make an amendment into somebody else's letter we cannot change somebody else's letter that's true well they're here can we yeah that's true we can't because if that's wrong we'll re revisit it next month okay that's fine I so you can withdraw your I'll withdraw my and then miss Corino can withdraw her second okay so we're GNA have a Mr cherel is um um motion seconded by Mr

102Rybeck Mrs armeno I I cannot endorse it under the in the language that it exists so no Mr cherella yes Mrs Deo yes Mrs Lang yes Mrs Kino no Mr Rybeck Mr Russo no as I expressed there was some changes that I want to make as well Mr rutsky Iain and Mrs kapano yes that is five Ys uh the Y have it on this resolution motion passes okay thank you very much and again Senator thank you for being here with us today we appreciate your your attendance at our meeting so we're going to continue with the um agenda is there any other business by any member of the Board of Education Mr Ryback I told you I'm not bashful one something I want to bring up we're talking about State funding state aid and I

103think that one of the things that the legislature really needs to consider is how we fund education and I think part of this came up in general not just you know the the formula but how in general we fund education and I'd like to make reference to what I read I think in yesterday's paper about freeold Freehold is is thinking about laying off 119 teachers which is unconscionable it's really it's unconscionable they're they're they're paying $2.1 million as Mrs Lang said to support a Charter School Lakewood Lakewood right back Lakewood a Lakewood I'm sorry I said Freehold I got them on my mind too I but I meant I meant Freehold thank you at any R Lakewood Lakewood l L well okay they're free hold's benefiting also somewhere along the line but let's talk about

104Lakewood um and there spending all this money to support a charter school they're busing 30,000 nonpublic school students and I think if I'm not mistaken their public school student population is about 5,000 some's around there this is unbelievable why they have to pay to you know to bust3 ,000 nonpublic school students is I don't know but what I know is you could find inequities like this wherever we go we have our own problems here they have theirs the state has to do a better job in in in how it's funding uh these these public schools and maybe they have to cap uh the busing at some point I don't know uh but but that's that we can't leave these things out and and and say well you know we fixed the the uh state aid

105problem no it's it's a major problem it has to be worked on and and I don't think they're going to have an answer for a while but we can't let go of this because this is only going to get worse thank you anyone else oh can I just add to it Mr R back so as you was talking about freeold and the the fact of the matter is that $2.5 million that's going to the charter schools that Freehold is sending out is that Lakewood is sending out is coming from our taxpayers because we send so much money to Trenton every year and we're not getting back a an appropriate amount in order to fund our own schools so as Lakewood is sending um buses for 30,000 kids to private schools we're paying for that while

106our children are in overcrowded classrooms and we don't have a new school I really think that you know if money can be found for freeold to build a needed school then money should be able to be found to help Monroe build a new school so even if we can't get the funding done find money and help us meet our students needs immediately and that's what I would ask Mr Min yes um since I can't stay for the ad hoc committee meeting I would ask the chair to please consider um getting a letter with some the similar language that that is initiated by our board to the leadership to the same people and uh maybe put it in in such a way that we could disseminate it to our people and get like Mr ryy um

107I'm sorry Mr Russo's suggestion out we could give people a a letter to in the same regard and have them sign it and have them send it uh we've had this from the public all along that they've asked us what can they do to help us and I I would ask the ad hoc committee to come because there's nothing wrong with having more than one letter and and and and from different areas so I would ask that the ad hoc committee considered that seriously and at the next meeting if you can provide us with a a letter that we can also endorse coming from us because I think that that's what's important and we represent the people of Monroe I would like the people of Monroe to see that we actually go forward and speak

108to the uh leadership as well so I thank you for for having that consideration that's a good idea anyone else Mr Russo excellent idea I think it was yours originally about letter writing so I want to give credit where credits do and the public the public has asked us over and over and over again for Action that they can participate in and I think this is actually you know it's what 50 cents for a stamp these days I'm so confused if I is this not an action that the public can get behind I'm really I'm at a loss not coming why two coming from the public because you like you said one is a letter from a different party this is a letter from the board that the public can from Monroe Township from elected

109officials from Monroe yes I I don't think there's I don't think there's necessity for just one I think more than one is makes an even better statement thank you but everything in the letter is very good the points are valid there's no question okay but okay um if there's no other board business we'll go to close session resolution be it resolved that the Board of Education of the township of Monroe hereby moves to go into closed session in accordance with Sunshine Law chapter 231 of the public laws of 1975 njsa 10 colum 4-6 through 10 colum 4-21 to discuss the following subject harassment imitate in intimidation and bullying following closed session action may be taken the discussion conducted in Clos session can be disclosed to the public at such time as the need for confidentiality

110no longer exists I need a motion Madam Madam President should we have had a public portion before the close session it's coming after the close session today we will only be gone at the most 10 minutes before the there's usually a public portion before CL session we do it was after we did number five already that was we did so we only have two closed sessions or two public forums today number seven no eight Eight's closed session and then n I'm yeah so at this time I need a motion a second go to close s motion to go to close session thank second Miss Lang all in favor and oppos today we only have two closed sessions we're only going to be gone 10 minutes at this time that we are going into close session

111say it to the public at this time the board will move back into public session and go to number nine on the agenda the public forum anyone from the public wishing to speak please come to the microphone give your name and address for the record and we will adhere to our 3 minute time limit good evening um Chrissy scurby 21 pness Drive I'm a member of the ad hoc committee for fair funding and I would just like to say that the first meeting that we had I left there very enthused and very excited to be working with a group of individuals that were not political it was not politically driven and we were coming together as a United group of Monroe residents to fight for fair funding I think it is absolutely absurd that we

112have residents opposed to this we have been fighting this for many many years and we need to come together as a community working together I say it time and time again we are all in the same boat rowing in different directions and we're going in circles and we are not going to get anywhere if we continue as a board of ed to fight with each other I am appalled that time and time again things come up for a vote and if one person brings it up a group of people vote no for it it has to stop on this board and we have to come together as a community and fight for what is right thank you thank you Andy poori 16 St James Street thank you chrisy that's exactly what I saw today when

113I was here in January meeting when the the newly elected board members got elected and swear swore in I saw the politics between the two sides of this aisle this got to stop first before you point fingers anybody anybody else and you got to work United there is no need for a second letter okay you get behind the letter that's already there Empower us to go door too and we will do it get whatever signatures you need to make this this work the one thing that was disappointing throughout the entire meeting today is that we don't have an action plan of how we going to address the upcoming issues in the meetings uh what I suggest and what I'm going to propose is that I'm going to work with the state legislation including uh I

114just spoke to uh to Senator Linda Greenstein about getting State Senate President Steve Sweeney and we PR if possible to Monroe Township and have a open house Town Hall type of a meeting where we can express our views to them we just got to find an incentive to bring them here I also suggest that we need to go and make sure that a line item of the budget needs to go in before the sessions start not wait until the sessions are in progress It's Easy to add a line now then add a line later on because it's easy to remove that uh later on so I just want to make sure that we are working in motion and I apologize to uh to um Ken chera because I said I was disappointed that I was

115not on the committee Ken explained to me why it was the case and I appreciate him being candid about this whether we're on the committee or not whether we're sitting on that side or this side we're all in this together you have my full support our full support let us know how we can help you let's get this thing done this year the 100 days to come up with the new school formula is not going to happen I spoke to several Senators uh that I hosted a a meeting in forestgate they clearly told me I can give you a political answer or a practical answer and the political answer is yes we'll get it done and the Practical answer is nothing is going to change so we got to look for a line item to

116go into the budget now and as I presented at the assembly uh hearing I think there is a line item we can propose up to $5 million as one of the line items which is the the senior uh Mr grusi you got to help me out on this one Madam senior senior citizen equalizer fund senior C I'm going to stick to that and say that's a line item that should be able to go in right away that gets us about $5 million to start off with so please let us know Ken and everybody on the board how we can help and I really really hope that you all work together please do for the sake of the township thank you thank you anyone else Anthony foso ate a question way um Kathy attached to this

117letter isn't there some kind of parade that uh our kids are going to wear purple shirts and support of this letter no our our students are not involved in in anything that the ad hoc committee has been endorsing I think what we're looking at is a bus trip of um parents and Senior Communities and the the the community itself not the student Community Senate a leading the this committee this this group no she's not going to be there I don't know if the senator is going to be there I guarantee you she's going to be there I have no idea okay now everybody complain I hear some people say well we're against certain things you know what worried about we're all in the same boat when the boat Springs a leak and we're waiting for

118the plumber to fix that pipe after eight years you say time for a new plumber we're getting sandbagged again and I guarantee you you're not getting zero you might get a million because there a favor to her to try to get elected this is what she's trying to do I mean we're being faked again and again and again there's got to be another route their suggestion about not making this letter political and that's what it is it's political you know she's using you I mean how many times have I spoken to people on the board you all have a sentiment where nothing's getting done but now I hear oh it's it's a real good thing it's not a good thing we're getting sandbagged all it is is kicking a can down down the road here

119in November nothing's going to happen this bill if it goes before anybody they're going to go what is it recess they they recess in October that bill is never going to go before any Senate it's the election's going to be over and if there's a new governor maybe new assemblymen and probably maybe even a new Senator you're wasting your time thank you thank you Mr proso prash pup 33 dinner Drive I I think we should go ahead we should march to Trenton with the families senior citizens and everyone if the senator wants to be with us well good this we this is everyone is fighting for the same cause if the Republican leaders want to come please come independent everyone should be there nothing wrong with that but want to make sure that package we

120are sending testimony is inclusive of all the three items which Ken has said we are going to start fighting for the new formula I know that new governor will come next year but I cannot go to and for the signature drive and just say we are just fighting for the first budget here now so I want to make sure at least I have something strategy spelled out so when we go for the signature Drive okay so I want to know you know I don't know whether you all want to answer today or not that's what I'll be proposing for adoc committee okay thank you thank you Victor Cooper 525 Abbott Court um what I wanted to say is I highly disagree with the uh notion that this is political and I think that it would

121be much more effective to have that letter come from our elected representatives with signatures of thousands of residents if we can get them be much more effective than the other way around having the Board of Ed write the letter and the elected representatives endorse it so I don't think it's political and I think we have to join forces at this time we can't be a divided group we must be United in order to get the funding necessary for the school funding for our children that's the most important thing thank you anyone else from the public oh I want to say one other thing okay the ad hoc committee met once a week ago today um and didn't have any opportunity to devise strategies other than to listen to Senator Greenstein read the letter and talk

122about it we haven't even had alternative strategies which there are example publicity let's get the radio stations TV stations and newspapers tuned into this like Channel 4 sends out viaro have her come out and she'll get that money for us I'm kidding around but I mean that's the another strategy that we can use and there are others besides that so this isn't the only way that was what was considered at the meeting a week ago but we never got a chance to discuss Alternatives thank you again anyone else from the public seeing no one we'll close public forum on our next scheduled Board of Education meeting Wednesday April 26 2017 I need a motion to adjourn Mr Ryback second by miss armeno all in favor opposed and at this time the meeting is adjourned

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.