CorpusRecord 132986

Monroe Township Board of Education 06.14.17 Regular Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Monroe Township School District
Date
2025-02-12
Location
Middlesex County, NJ
Material
Transcript
Extent
22,943 words · about 128 min
Collected
2026-06-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001oh my God thank you good evening the meeting of the Monro tangent Board of Education will come to order please stand as our student board member leads us in the Pledge of Allegiance I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all may we have a roll call Mr Gorski certainly Mrs armeno Mr Braverman Mr cherella here Mrs Deo here Mrs Lang here Mrs Corino here Mr Ryback here Mr Russo here Mr rutsky here and Mrs kapano here Madame board president you have a quarum this evening thank you in accordance with the provisions of the New Jersey open public meetings law the Monro Township Board of Education has caused notice of this meeting to

002be published by having the date time and place thereof posted June 9th 2017 at all schools the home News Tribune the cranberry press and filed with the clerk of the municipality thank you first on the agenda is approval of the minutes for the special public Board of Education meeting of March 29th 2017 so move second so moved by Mr Chella second by Mr Ryback any additions or corrections I have I have a COR oh which one are we looking at 29th the March 29th all in favor I opposed abstentions or recused none the closed session meeting of March 29th 2017 so move Mr Ryback Mr Chella additions or corrections to the minutes okay seeing none all in favor opposed extensions or recusals okay the approval of the minutes for the public Board of Education meeting

003on April 26 2017 so move Mr Chella Mr Ryback again additions or Corrections to the minutes I have a correction Mr Mayo page eight under public forum Christine Lester the way this is written it makes it sound like she wanted to have it changed but she wanted to keep it she did not want the changes okay she wanted to keep policy 8505 prior form Adam yes very well well we'll we'll go through the audio tape again and just confirm that if that's the case then we'll uh make a correction in the minutes okay any other additions or Corrections then all in favor I opposed recusals or abstentions then with the Clos session meeting of April 26th 2017 Mr Chella Mr Ryback any additions or corrections to the closed session minutes all in favor opposed and

004no extensions or recusals okay then we were going we're going on to our presentations and at this time we will recognize our student athletes so Dr kosak Dr alvic and Mr Gorski join us at the um in the front yes we absolutely we will honor our student athletes this one come around to the front good evening oh I'm sorry hello I'm glad everyone's awake good evening everyone gives me great pleasure to recognize our student uh our student athletic Award winners we again as I said with the academics we could probably recognize every student athlete in the high school and and I'm sure the middle school as well but um the board you know told me that the 22-hour board meetings wouldn't be a good thing so we had to narrow it down and with that

005just like last year we chose criteria to uh recognize those student athletes who achieved a county or Statewide recognition so we have three teams with us tonight and uh I'm going to ask our athletic director Mr buers to give us an introduction we'll be starting with the boys bowling so Mr berer if you would we've had an unbelievable year this year highlighted by our bo boys bowling team we've had seven sectional championships in our school history we had an eighth this year it was the boys bowling team so let's give them a big again on top of that they went on and they won the actual group three state championship which is an unbelievable accomplishment because they're only the third team in school history to actually win a state championship so let's have a big

006hand for that we will be presenting the boys team team with rings for their state championship we'll also be presenting uh Big L with his 300 bowling ring um in case you're not familiar with a with bowling 300's a perfect game and it happens very very seldom and he got it so let's hear one for big lop and at this time what I'd like to do is call Coach galdi up and she's G to introduce each one of our [Applause] athletes by the way coach Grimaldi was GMC conference Coach of the Year [Applause] also um I'm going to call the boys up one at a time Joseph [Applause] holler Tyler [Applause] cresen Devin Maddox riy mckernan feel like she should tell us what their averag as Muhammad [Applause] Zach vulgan [Applause] Captain Zach wayer ring

007there bu and last but not least the gentleman who will be getting two rings tonight his state championship ring and his 300 ring for his January 31st very first 300 game Louis [Applause] Fulgore the study make sure you're right congratulations all right we'll bring everybody out for a picture we want a picture right yeah let's bring the boys out and we'll get a picture this guy that's something different actually want me in this picture come with me come with me I'm come with me tall tall more turn sideways turn sideways vot on that that includes the high school I should on that you should have to ask Mike I don't ever like chat congratulations [Applause] yep and next we have our girls bowling team so I don't get a lot of chances to drive up

008to Woodbridge to watch our bowling teams play um but this year I got a big opportunity and I'm shocked that the boys actually outdid the girls because the girls had an unbelievable season number one they went undefeated you can clap about that we moved up a division into the Red Division we won the division title you can collab about that and then in the conference Championship the county championships they also won that and it was just a fantastic accomplishment so I'll call the coach of the year up again [Applause] and we'll introduce the young ladies Bridget [Applause] Bolan Ashley bork Nina [Applause] carry Nicole man [Applause] Shannon [Applause] Glenn Alexa Hanna Victoria siki [Applause] and our captain could not be here tonight but Sarah wiekowski [Applause] girls lacrosse at the beginning of the season um

009unfortunately coach Welsh couldn't be here for a family emergency um but she looked up in the gym and we have banners all in our gym and she goes you know what the banner for girls lacrosse is blank and I said well you got a big job this year coach you're going to have to win the county Championship she says don't throw that on me and by the end of the season our team became so fine-tune that we went out against Oldbridge and we not only just beat them but we beat them 15 to8 which is pretty handly to the team that was the number one scene in our conference so it's a tremendous accomplishment that we get our first girls lacrosse County championship and now we'll call up the young ladies first We Have Allison

010Aken [Applause] Teresa [Applause] buffalino Leslie Lane Leslie's a 100 Point [Applause] scorer and Kendall lore [Applause] let's hear it for the girls across we'll get a team picture photo when we have the rest of the team together okay okay sure okay sure [Applause] our second presentation is another group of um distinguished individuals who also are part of a team or were part of a team and that is that they were part of the Monroe team and as I have the Good Fortune to interview candidates who come in after the interview process when I if they make it to the final round and I tell them that I'll be recommending them for approval for board approval at the next board meeting I always finish with if the board should uh decide to accept them to that

011I welcome them to our team so it's Bittersweet that I call up the next group of people who are members of our of our team who have retired and um I don't know anybody that truly retires anymore they go into a second career it seems or they go into a hobby or they go into something else they also you can tell they're retired because there's always a glow around them there's there's a smile there's a very relaxed glow about them so with that we're going to call up the number of retirees who were able to make the uh meeting tonight and we have a number of other retires who for all different reasons could not be here tonight but for the people that are here uh we'll be calling them up individually and we will

012start with Barbara da who is our director of Human Resources [Applause] next we have Dale Harris one of our teachers of the handicap please come up [Applause] next I would like to introduce Mr Kevin faden one of our [Applause] custodians okay uh looks like Mr faden is not here we will go to to Diane asosi a teacher one of our first grade teachers from Oak Tree School [Music] [Applause] with Judy borachi please come down one of our PR professionals [Applause] will Gloria PCH please come down also one of our power professionals for [Applause] next we have Alysa Surman one of our secretaries from Barkley Brook School [Applause] Susan ok ok Lich ok ok Lich and I took a lot of heat from my secretary who said you have a Polish name this is a Polish

013name there should be absolutely no issues with pronunciation and I did I had to isue so congratulations [Applause] Michelle Murphy one of our Spanish teachers [Applause] will Sharon selm please come a secretary for Mill Lake [Applause] we have Sharon rusnik our spe a special teacher from our Middle School [Applause] and last but certainly not least Cindy Wier a nurse our nurse from Mil Lake School [Applause] okay okay thank you I my glasses over there Wai for people gonna make that suggestion for next year so before we go to the next presentation on the agenda I would just like to congratulate all of our retirees today and um as Dr kak said it's really is a Bittersweet night and that's because while all of you want to leave we want you to stay here and we

014know that that's not fair of us to ask you so whether you are an administrator or a teacher or a par professional or a nurse you all have something in common and that's you all took care of children and did the best you could for every kid in this District so we'd like to thank you for your years of service to monre Township and especially to our students so thank you very much [Applause] [Music] [Applause] so at this time we will go to number three under presentations the new school building schematic drawings and uh Mr T would you do the honors thank you this evening we're gonna have a presentation by Mr Rich alderiso principal with the firm di group architecture you may recall that di group is the architect of the high school the

015presentation that you will be seeing is in response to a directive from the steering committee you may recall the steering committee was formed around a year ago to investigate and come up with a plan for how we should handle student growth during that process they evaluated data primarily demographic reports and information from the township on the unprecedented growth that is being experienced here in Monroe the conclusion and the recommendation from that committee to the board was that a referendum should be planned to build to accommodate approximately 3,000 students what you're going to see tonight is a follow-up to that after that recommendation came in Dr kak made a recommendation to the full board that the plan to address the 3,000 students should come in the form of a new Elementary School K to5 approximately 1,000

016students a middle school 67 and 8 second Middle School that would also accommodate approximately 1,000 students and finally in addition to the high school here again accommodating 3,000 students that will accommodate growth for somewhere in the 5 to 10 year range in this community so with that information Mr Aliso worked with Administration primarily with Dr alvic and Mr Goodall to determine the program that we have here in the district what we refer to is the educational specification to provide directive to the architect to ensure that the design would meet our educational specification and that all of the programs that we have would be accommodated through the design and that is what Mr Aliso will be presenting to you tonight at this time we invite several of the board members if they'd like to sit in

017the front row there'll be a presentation with schematics on both screens back here if you want to see easier feel free to move out to the front at this time I'll turn it over to Mr Rich alderiso di group architecture it's going to be on Bo okay to you whether watch from here or oh this one's bigger yeah yeah I like this one [Music] thanks very much Jerry um again my name is Rich Aliso from di group architecture and I'll start um with the high school okay um basically what we're doing here as as Jerry noted we're creating uh additional capacity for about 1,000 students um if you're familiar and I'll I'll try to use a pointer here um if you're familiar with the existing facility um which is all in light gray all in

018light gray we're proposing to add the uh the dark gray footprint okay or the or the brown print and just to orient you the uh this is Schoolhouse Road at the bottom of the screen Pineville on the left side of the screen um basically what we're trying to do with with this addition is a couple of things um maximize the available Site Area um try to create um additional efficiencies with with this addition um taking cues from the existing building and really trying to trying to integrate any lessons learned from uh what we've done at this building um in an attempt to um create an efficient plan um one that works and really to uh really try to create as small a footprint uh for this addition as we can um the smaller the footprint

019really the more efficient this is the less sight Improvement we need to make um the less we have to concern ourselves with um storm water and drainage management things like that um and I'll flip back and forth a bit so um this is really the first floor plan everything that is um that is black and white in color is the existing plan and anything that has been shaded or colored in is proposed or new or a renovation to existing um basically what we're looking at is a 30 classroom three-story edition of 30 General classrooms distributed over three floors um six science labs which we are going to officient ly stack on one side of the building to try to take advantage of um again the efficiency in running utilities from floor to floor um there

020will be four self-contained special ed rooms uh three resource rooms cafeteria culinary arts um a an auxiliary gym locker rooms storage um also adding band room storage and making some modifications to existing space and to just try to take you through the plan um and I'll use the pointer on the screen in the back uh if that's okay um basically you you enter currently from this side the the students enter from this side and if I go back um here's the the student drop off is in this area and they enter in the morning through this side okay basically what we're trying to do is um maintain that entrance but again since we're introducing an additional we're planning for 1,000 more students we're trying to make this a more um open and more spacious area

021for for entering the school um and also for giving um kind of an as the school grows It's always important to create an area to to orient um the students um so basically we're making connections from Corridor to corridor and we're trying to create again a very efficient uh plan whereby we we almost create a loop um so that we're not creating any long travel distances and around the the corridor Loop um we have science labs classrooms um the gymnasium which is an auxiliary gym and locker rooms adjacent to the existing athletic area Okay um cafeteria um uh serving area culinary arts support space and um again throughout the footprint on each plan we have special ed rooms resource rooms and the like um we're also adding a a band room down here off of

022the performance arts wing and we will within the space at the distance we'll be converting the distance learning um lab into a professional development lab and then also at the space that you're in today at the the the multi-purpose or the uh Media Center excuse me um there's uh a great opportunity here to create some faculty Flex space here and regain some space that exists on the second and third floors for um a growing um need for the special education department and I'll show you those as we go up to the next floor plan so this is the first floor plan for the high school uh this is the upper upper level floor plan um currently this is the classroom wing of the upper level floor plan and again we're trying to make connections here

023from Corridor to Corridor to make this addition feel like it's always been here and try to try to really make those connections uh seamless um same thing on this floor we we surround this with uh classrooms special ed spaces um science labs two per floor um and several resource rooms third floor very similar footprint again we're trying to take advantage of uh of of the what I call the stacking effect where we we kind of Stack spaces which again which have utilities and plumbing over one another so we're not we're not creating long runs of uh electric runs and um Plumbing runs things like that um and again uh classrooms classrooms resource rooms special ads special Leed spaces um and various support spaces um all told this is about 123,000 square foot of addition and

024um I think it U fits very nicely with uh within the existing footprint of the building and on the site um again just to orient you uh Pineville Schoolhouse Road existing and proposed addition and again given how how much space we're creating I think it's a very compact plan and efficient plan okay so that is the the proposed high school edition um I don't know you would you should I feeli any questions or go through each of them go we'll go through all the whole the whole thing and then we'll ask questions by the board sure okay let me just open up excuse me for one sec I'll open up I don't know Michelle you might have to yeah I can't hear you um she said that the public can't all see the the back

025screen as I point to it would it be possible for the board to sit up front um so I could present on this screen sure you can do that we just you can use that we because we've yeah point the rich just point use that one and then once in a while come over and just let the you know everybody know up here all right did start with start with the one for the public then very good okay um so we're going to present uh proposed uh Middle School um uh proposed new construction um again to ACC accomodate um in and around 1,000 students um in general again it's a 30 classroom building um we're looking at um integrating six science labs with shared prep rooms six special ed rooms uh about nine resource rooms

026three per grade this is a 678 um within the space um we also have um you know Performing Art Space gymnasium um uh cafeteria and a a three-story classroom wing and I'll go through the plan um to just give you a sense of of what we're trying to do here the uh so do the best I can to point um around the the speaker here is there a loose mic yeah take that one over from the side oops maybe one more time okay okay um so again in keeping with what we were attempting to do with the high school edition um what we're always trying to do is is in the in the name of efficiency trying to create as compact a plan as possible in other words try to take up as little footprint

027on any site that we can um it helps us with cost with storm drainage with um any site related um you know regulatory agencies that we have to work with and also it makes a a large school less challenging to travel through and and to um to access um for the students so again this this footprint is the first floor um and it is uh again um proposed for a thousand to accommodate plus or minus a thousand students and um just to take you through um basically we have a entry point um secured vestibule main office area um this is a special services office suite one of the things we're trying to to do here um is to uh we're doing a groundup building here to bring the special services back into the district so

028space does not have to be uh leased outside of the district and we have a great opportunity to do that here um this is kind of a a central circulation spine once you enter off to the side is uh Media Center um Performing Arts here we have um band and vocal music um and then this is a athletic wing with locker rooms auxiliary gym main gym um cafeteria kitchen um kind of A Faculty Flex space or workroom and this is really right here on the other side is a classroom Wing which would be a three-story classroom wing uh with several connecting corridors over to the one-story uh core space um again um General class rooms science labs uh two per floor which would be stacked again special ed rooms within um resource rooms and support

029spaces and the third the second floor um very similar to the first floor classroom Wing um classroom spaces um again special ed spaces science labs um small prep rooms for the science labs and support spaces nested within of course elevator toilet rooms all of those types support spaces um all told uh this addition or this building is approximately right now with this program about 152,000 Square ft can you explain sorry can you explain when at this time the public we we we'll have a public for where you'll be able to speak later and that's the that's really the Middle School plan footprint I'll go to the proposed Elementary School now [Music] okay this is um the proposed elementary school again looking to um accommodate approximately 1,000 students um we're looking at um the Applegarth site

030for this project so if you if you're familiar with the Applegarth school um here's the existing Applegarth building Applegarth Road and we're looking to place the new building to this side of the site maintain the Applegarth School as an operational School while construction is going on here um complete the majority of construction and then um demolish the Applegarth school and complete the site work and parking um basically this is designed right now as a a K through five um it's a first grade kindergarten wing and a second grade through fifth grade uh Wing right here and these would be all the core spaces main office gymnasium stage um cafeteria um we are creating separate areas for um bus entrance and drop off and separate um entrances for parent parking faculty uh entrance and parking this

031so this uh classroom Wing um basically consists right now have six kindergartens seven first through third grade classrooms and eight fourth and fifth grade classrooms um we also have um six small group instruction rooms six uh special ed spaces um oot PT Space and um all of the core facilities so this this would be the main entrance this is a single story Wing here where we have um main office child study special services nurses Suite um Media Center excuse me gymnasium cafeteria Stage Music um along this Wing we have first grade on this side um kindergarten classrooms on this side which open up into this enclosed U secured Courtyard um in this Wing here we have second grade third grade on the first floor and fourth and fifth grade on the second floor um again

032trying to take advantage of the the site here that exists it's a a really good piece of property it's flat it's um we have the right amount of space right where we we need it on this property and again we're trying to create as Compact and efficient footprint for the elementary as uh as we can here um just trying to think what else uh we could we could go with questions at this point um in any more detail I could just talk about as I answer any questions okay we will have um questions from the members of the Board of Education and if the public will hold their questions to the public for Forum after all the presentations then you'll have an opportunity to ask any questions you have then so is any any questions

033comments from the Board of Education Miss armeno sure um on the I just like some AC acreage how much acreage will you be um taking from I guess the back of the building how much do that footprint take in reference to this school to to the high school I'm going to go down the list um it's again the footprint is about um 50 to 60,000 square foot so it's a little over an acre of of building okay and you don't need to go beyond what what the Board of Ed owns no this all sits within within the board of Ed's property lines well within and you mentioned um detention basins and uh storm water management do we need to increase any of those at all on this property for this footprint more than likely we

034would need to add a A detention Basin and would and basic you know what we've done in the past is um either put them under parking instead of adding another physical base and put them on under a parking lot or under a field or within you know within another area of the site so it's not a um not a visible site Improvement if it's under parking I mean is that stable enough to hold all the cars and I'm sure you're going to do all the proper engineering and everything but has that been done before yes it's been done here we have we have underground there is one yes didn't know that okay underground parking so so so it's not happening it's very common I mean underground uh detention the next one is on the um

035Middle School how many acres do you require for that space um again with everything not just the footprint um for the whole footprint in the field um again and trying to keep that plan as compact as possible um we'd like to you know be in the the 20 acre 20 to 30 acre range uh minimally okay and then I guess um well we have the property on Apple guard so we just going to utilize what we have there for the apple G school yes okay I think I think I that might be it thank you okay Mr Rybeck not so much a question just a point of clarification I guess mainly for the public that may not be aware at this point that um um was mentioned in middle school that we're going to be

036having a suite for special ed um that's because special ed is now in a rental property and so we're going to be saving a lot of money by being being able to bring them back into a school setting I just wanted to highlight that thank you thank you Mr Rob also uh so we have a special ed Suite we're showing one at the middle school end at the elementary school anyone else from Mr Russo regarding the flexible space you mentioned can you just give a little more information on that sure um so and we could U Jerry if it's possible to go back to the high school plan I could I could show a little bit more on that um so if you you look at a space like this today when the when this

037building was designed designed um technology actually in just those few years has changed so much um and we require so much less space for media centers today and what we're proposing to do is take a portion of the media center that we're in today which is which is right here and um dedicate that to uh flexible teaching a flexible space for teachers so it's basically um taking the work rooms that exist um on the second and third floor here which is are really the house faculty Suites and moving those down to part of this space and reclaiming those spaces for um for special ed um they're perfectly suited for special ed the classroom Si from the room sizes uh there are toilet rooms there already there are offices there are smaller spaces I they're they

038Pro they serve uh they'll serve special ed much better than they serve the house faculty right now if you if you go into those spaces with the house faculty um they're very small cubicles they're very tight storage is an issue um there's really no opportunity to um to to have kind of a communal um discussion about work or research or anything um also there are issues with again with storage and um work areas so we're considering taking a good portion of this space using half of it for media center and the other half um for again that kind of a house faculty space um but again it it could be a much more I think much more efficient space than we currently have upstairs Mr Chella and if you if you uh if if you

039want it mine I know the last time when we we were at buildings and grounds you we talked about this space and and how we would change that and Dr kak at that time had asked um if there was a way to make it flexible enough so that when we have a you know a large a turnout of the from the public that we could open it back up or is that part of the new plan um we haven't gotten that far with the planning but there are certainly ways to um use movable partitions to open these spaces up um we have a we have several movable partitions in this facility now and it's um it's a it's a very good option uh they make very good uh quality partitions for sound so if it

040it's um something we certainly consider and talk about and continue to plan just a follow up Mr Mr Russo just to follow up is is there any way that current space office space not classroom space but office space can be because I noticed there were a lot of officers uh on different floors throughout the building uh you have Vice principal's offices secretaries next to them and maybe a meeting room room and so on and then there's other offices down the hallway can they be Consolidated into a one larger open space environment um if if they're not if they're not connected if they're not next to one another um it becomes challenging to find the best use for those spaces um aside from a small group instruction or or something like that um if if we

041had a suite of those type spaces um there's certainly consideration for looking at how to use them in an alternative uh manner one thing that happened when this school was built and it was expressed to me by the people who actually occupy the office that is that um they went a little too far in providing a large amount of space more than what they needed and what you find now is that that space is being taken from them little by little when it's needed uh so it would be best to do it right from the beginning and cluster the operation people that's people that have offices like the vice principal and other administrative people into one area uh they can have one on each floor third floor second floor they would because they uh they

042say they have certain requirements so we always looked at where I work we went through this exercise and we had requirements so you had a you had to uh defend your space right make an argument why you need that space and why you need that location and then uh point out any physical requirements that you have in operational requirements that you have and that allows the managers to take um all the administrative staff in a given area and cluster them together and they find out the work environment is actually much better again with the teacher scenario that's what we're trying to do in in this area rather than have um teacher work rooms all over the place and things we're really looking to consolidate and and and can it be done with uh existing offices

043or you would have to look into that we would we would because again in in adding the Thousand students we really have to see how um we don't want any one's space to be too far from from the new footprint because we're really starting to build out now as compact as we're we're trying to stay um I I I want to make sure that we don't wind up with a a cluster of offices you know a football field away from from any one uh classroom or wing of the building sure sure okay so you would have to look into it but you haven't done that yet we haven't Mr arm Mino um after the buildout in the High School uh this proposed buildout is there any other room or opportunity to build out of this

044again in other words if we continue to have the a massive amount of enrollment and we need in five in five years from now to 15 years from now um is that the end of of the expansion on this particular site um it tough to say it's really tough to say you you can always add to a building but um if you had another, student um Spike um in enrollment that that's going to stay um not sure if we I we couldn't get another addition this size onto this building after this one we can add small pieces here and there for for certain needs or um we could you know again we find ourselves repurposing spaces like this quite often to try to accommodate specific needs but the the big uh the big volume of

045students um to try to put another you know 30 classroom Wings somewhere on site would be challenging so after this particular proposed um expansion what would be the capacity of the building then for students um slightly over 3,000 over 3,000 we rapidly getting to that to begin with and that was the problem here by the time we opened it it was already tight it happens quickly okay thank you are there any more questions from members of the Board of Education just one Mr Russo yeah just on the cafeteria there's a second one being built um what's is there a reason for that I guess more students but uh you existing one it it's it's capacity driven okay um and also um proximity um we we came here um one morning to well we came here

046a few times to observe circulation in the school uh one at one meeting here was at 7:00 in the morning to to observe students coming into the school um and then we we came through after um one of the main lunch settings to watch students leaving and getting around and it's really um circulation is really uh becoming challenging so to to try to continue on with another thousand students down at that end it starts to um we observe some log jams at stairwells things like that which we really want to try to avoid so it's this aside from not having enough capacity in those spaces it's another way of uh drawing students away from one one part of the building to really help out with circulation just one more how how do you de what

047students will eat in what cafeterias just curious um Dr alvich decides that for in conjunction with Mr Goodall yes that would be a high school administration issue right I I'm sorry one more because I did write this down yes um cafeteria space has been and thank you for bringing that up because that's been the subject of some concern from parents in a lot of the different schools so I hope that we actually put a lot of uh um you know uh energy into the cafeteria spaces and how they work because some of the children in the in the Apple in the Applegarth school now are having a real hard time middle middle middle school I'm sorry the Middle School are having a hard time with the cafeteria space and things so we have to be

048cognizant of that that's been a concern of parents you know for quite a while now and and controlling capacity within those spaces is Paramount to to making it work and I think giving the enough time to have their lunches I think that's the big issue as well not just the capacity but I mean I guess that goes hand inand with that once you once you uh control the capacity you can make it easier for them to have a decent lunch time okay thank you anyone else from the board okay seeing none thank you Mr alderiso and um you might want to stay for a few minutes so if anybody has questions during public forum you'll be able to answer them certainly thank you thank you so at this time we will do presentation number four

049um by the members of The Wellness committee regarding policy 8505 the wellness policy um Nancy mitac sorry Welcome to our meeting well thank you uh do you need a light no I'm I'm good I brought my glasses this evening uh last night uh last time I met with the board I forgot to bring my glasses so this time I'm prepared um good evening Madame President um Board of Education members uh Dr kak Dr alvic and Michael Gorski uh members of the public and colleagues I see a lot um I am Nancy mitac I am the coordinator for the wellness Council uh just a little about the wellness Council let me get this gadget going uh the werness council is a completely voluntary uh uh Council uh it's comprised of parents teachers um School nurses uh

050it consists of food service directors athletic director we have a physician uh a uh train physical education trainer administrators and students uh these folks give their time outside of the school day um and they have one primary concern they really are looking for the best uh interest of the students uh in terms of health and wellness so all the folks on this are really really seeking all the best for our kids um just a little about the wellness Council it the we have a district Wellness Council and it the district Wellness Council focus focuses primarily on policy it identifies um gaps and locates re resources to address them uh it supports new and existing programs and and related to health Wellness at the school level and we have in each School level elementary middle and

051high school a uh Council uh we have access to school health environment we identify ways to strengthen and improve the health of students and staff and uh one of the very exciting things is we plan Wellness week uh this year we had a tremendous this Wellness week and um I do plan to meet with the board uh later at some point to really do the wellness assessment uh which we'll be posting on our our website but uh we do have a very exciting uh program to share with you all the fun things that they did uh the wellness policy elements basically we focus on nutrition education nutrition policy physical activ ity all schools available all foods available on campus that encompasses School meals com competitive food and beverages classroom celebrations student incentives rewards fundraisers other

052school board school-based activities um areas that we have identified uh in the wellness Council because we do look where can we string in each year in our goal setting and one of the things is we looked at and this has been an ongoing uh topic for I would say since 2010 the classroom celebration um and it has not left our agenda since then um Dr kak uh called me into his office and had shared that it has been coming up in his meetings and consequently I had shared with him that we have new regulations um that are coming out that the final regulations for uh School Wellness um actually came into being they formulated them in July of uh July of 2016 and at that point one of the new add conditions was that school

053districts had to address uh School celebrations they had to have something in their wellness policy about school celebrations prior to that it was never a part of the school celebration so Dr kak tasked the wellness council with making a recommendation uh we took this very seriously and one of the his recommendations was that we go and uh expand this to include the School principles because certainly they are the leaders in the building and we did not want to exclude them uh in any way so um we we went and um we had a uh we had several meetings uh and they were very very thoughtful meetings uh where we contemplated this in a very very serious serious way um I will say before I because I did skip a slide here I am not a

054PR professional presenter um the wellness policy regulations are broken up into several categories its general program wellness policy assessment administrative review public no notification goals Wellness leadership areas that we felt needed to be identified were wellness policy assessment and public notification so that was another two items that we had on our list um so towards that end when [Music] we we um had our key points and the group unanimously and we had 24 people working very hard and really uh unanimously came up with contemplated the celebrations and it was a new unanimous at at the end of the day unanimously came up with that the recommendation was that there should be non food uh celebrations primarily um we were looking mostly at the elementary schools because that's really where it happens um and for these

055reasons um number one food allergies um in every aspect of our school Community we look at safety and the well-being of our students and it is our primary concern we are charged with the safety of our children and we wanted to take this seriously and proactively one in 13 students has a food allergy and 40% of them experience a severe and life-threatening reaction secondly we talked to teachers and it was interesting because we have teachers on our Council and they talked about the amount of class time that is spent dedicated to the birth party um it is not just that you know the cupcakes come out it is we we talked to them and they said on average it is 20 to 30 minutes of class time um and they said it's not just the

056the food it's usually you know it's multiple foods and that it's goodie bags after the teacher has inspected them often times they're looking for paper plates forks napkins whatever was you know not sent in uh it's trips to deliver treats um so there's actually a lot of time that uh academic time that's committed to these activities lastly we can't ignore the parent concerns many parents in this community have Express concerns that they do not condone all of the additional snacks being given to their child without consent and on such a regular basis they do not feed their children all the sugar and snacks food consumed on a regular basis the most compelling piece was a statement that was put out by our School nurses it was a position statement supporting non food celebrations in our

057schools I am not going to read it but we are going to post this on our website it was so compelling our Council after reading this because this was all based in in studies uh through journals of medical documentation and it is really worth anybody in the community reading to really know uh the facts on why it's important that we really look at this on a serious basis I'm not keeping up here so I'm not going to go through this but what I'd like to do is just maybe show a few pictures um just to demonstrate what goes on every day and we didn't we just randomly these were just we just for a few days took a a couple pictures just to put up here to show you what goes on every day in

058the schools um I received the Dunkin Donuts picture and I actually wrote back does Dunkin Donuts deliver because it was so lined up and organized by um we know for a fact Dunkin Donuts is not a nutree establishment um you can see there's the multiple of different foods now any parent you know parents kind of want to follow suit with what's going on in the classroom you know they just if if if the other parents are sending in several items well you know then you're going to send in several items you can notice in this photo as well that there's the goodie bags that the the candies are being taken out of um just a couple more pictures I mean I think you can get the drift it's these are multiple food items this is

059what goes on every day um you know 25 to 30 students in a class you know it's frequent and a lot of a lot of parents don't feed their kids this way so there's there's you know we spoke about we can do this differently um I thought it would be interesting to collect some data uh this is a a slide that shows the overweight and obesity rates in our schools I I have no data for the high school but this is what I have um and you can see that um we fit within the norm for the nation I think our nurses speak best to that but it's somewhere about 30% uh Nationwide so I'd like to say what this these policy changes are and what they are not because there's been a lot of

060misinformation what they are we feel very very strongly that a birthday party is so important to a child and we don't want to take away that Joy all elementary school students will be celebrated we don't want to take away that Joy teachers will develop a way to celebrate birthdays holidays uh Rich Traditions bringing Joy enjoyment using nonf food cell celebrations um the new policy has flexibility it allows the principal some discretion um for following situations provided that the food meets the healthy hunger-free kids act what that means is that there are dietary guidelines attached to it and uh they are healthful dietary guidelines um incentives or rewards for students accomplishments Club activity achievements success in competitions with school-based activities field days all of those things will be allowable but they'll be healthful snacks uh that

061the approved through the principal what they are not um there are no changes to the current PTO fundraising um not at all food cannot be sold during the school day and has not been able to be sold during the school day it can however be sold on a half day and as has been it does need to meet those dietary guidelines uh this does not affect activities outside of the school day so anything a half hour after school it does not affect that uh and it is not taking away an Elementary birthday celebration for each child that makes them feel special I'd like to share with you just some of the communities in the area that already have taken this step and they are local communities and I will tell you because districts are looking

062at this right here right now this list is going to grow uh by Leaps and Bounds um and we would like to add Monroe Township to this list we think it's the right thing to do for kids we think that kids adapt and we also think that we can provide um celebrations for kids in class without food that will be special for them finally I'd like to say that we have the full endorsement of the School nurses unanimously we have the full endorsement of the wellness Council the full endorsement unanimously from the principles the administration team endorses it unanimously and teachers overwhelmingly endorse uh the revisions to the policy I'd like to take a moment I have two colleagues here tonight uh representing the school nurses uh um and um I just for two minutes

063I'd like to invite Mrs um tocka up from Brookside school um just to say a few words um from a nurse's perspective she works in one of our elementary schools um and I am so grateful that she was willing to come tonight to speak thank you good evening um as Nancy said my name is Susan tilaka uh I've been a school a registered nurse in New Jersey for more years than I care to admit to but I've been the nurse at Brookside for the past 13 years I'd like to just give you a few fast facts and maybe some better insight as to why the nurses feel strongly that this policy needs to be updated uh for starters the present food procedure that we have in for student birthdays and class celebration does not even

064come close to representing the current standards for best practice those are standards that are set by the powers that b namely the American Academy of Pediatrics the school National Association of School nurses and the food allergy and asthma Association those are pretty important people who are very much on the front lines and have a lot of knowledge that most of us at this level don't have so in light of that we feel strongly that the district needs to respond to this with the same diligence that it affords to academic standards student health and safety need to be our priority and without compromise as far as far as the safety aspect food allergies have certainly become more common more complex and increasingly more life-threatening the allergies are no longer just limited to peanuts and tree nuts

065currently in our district there are 634 students who have a diagnosed food allergy most of these students have physician action plans with orders for epinephrine furthermore we know as nurses that in the population 25% of allergic reactions that occur in our schools are seen in students without a previously diagnosed allergy when you have the amount of food coming into our Elementary classrooms that we see daily you significantly increase the potential for these reactions to occur there's also a clear contradiction in the fact that this school year alone in order to comply with the state's Universal delegate mandate our district has invested time and dollars in procuring more epipens for each of our schools and in training delegates but yet we are unwisely allowing huge quantities of food to be distributed in our classroom usually without

066individual parents being aware of the day the time or the food that's being served to their child the nurses have been clear that we no longer feel competent checking food labels and hence we will not do so it is not up to us to decide what children of others should be eating recent labeling has become un clear with ingredients listed That masquerade as allergens for example casine is milk tahini is cesame and these are both allergens with increasing incidents of anaphylactic reactions the food man manufacturers don't even want to be responsible for the allergies as an increasing number of the labels coming into the school now have a global disclaimer that says may contain other allergens due to Shared production areas which to us means it's not safe for anyone that has a food allergy

067also there are an increased frequently frequency of recall on food items for undisclosed allergens which may not we may not receive notification of in a timely fashion in order to protect our students the nurses are not in the classrooms every time food is being served and at times even the regular teacher who knows the students is out this is very concerning because if there was an allergy developing no one's going to pick up on that change in that student early enough and we all know that early intervention for an allergic reaction is the best prevention for a a serious outcome it's not possible for the nurses to keep up with all of this for the hundreds of students in our buildings and for that reason we feel strongly that parents need to be the ones

068to determine what their own children are eating not the teacher not the nurses not any of the other school staff as far as Wellness comp position while trying to focus on wellness and encouraging healthy food choices aimed aimed to address the rising student obesity rates it seems kind of hypocritical to continue to offer this quantity and frequency of unhealthy eating in our classrooms in all the other areas in the district as Nancy had mentioned the food is regulated by requirements for USDA standards that we must follow and it begs the question as to why these endless classroom food celebrations are still taking place here in Monroe from emotional social standpoint the nurses are concerned about the food practices as they now exist we know of no other activity at the elementary level that creates more

069opportunities for students to feel left out and it's not just about the food allergies there are many students in our district who are strict vegetarian or vegans whose parents refuse to have them eat sweets and treats all the time who have family preferences for non-GMO non-gluten non-preserved non- food dye or people whose religious practices prevent them from eating food at all for certain times of the year these students are left excluded and it doesn't seem like it's the right thing to do in conclusion if anyone remains unconvinced that the wellness policy put forth by this committee is unnecessary I ask you to consider the following there are a great many parents that have expressed how relieve they would be to have a non-f food policy the risk the expense the inconvenience and conflict with their

070own family food choices are all factors many parents share the concerns of our teachers regarding how much Interruption this creates in the classroom we're here to educate not host parties you should consider also from what I see on a regular basis the students are less enthusiastic about these treats than their parents may expect often the food sent in for a class party is returned to my freezer goes to the faculty room or is simply thrown out if you go into a class room during or immediately after a party there's a lot of food on the floor and in the trash and maybe some icing is eaten off a couple of the cupcakes or a bite or two is taken out of a cookie we have students going around the building trying to get adults to

071take some of the food because they don't want to bring it home on the bus or Mom specifically told them not to bring it back home from the student standpoint I really don't see that this is something that is going to be greatly missed I think we will have other ways to recognize and celebrate that will interest the students and be inclusive equally to all of our students food is not a requirement for fun also I would like to make this CH change because student health and safety should be our main priority over all other factors when considering this policy we need to bring the district food policy in line with current best practice by accepting the proposal that has been thoroughly researched by the wellness committee any compromise to establish best practice is really

072unacceptable especially when it comes to health and safety change is difficult but I have I know that our students will do well with it and I feel that it will be successful as it has been in some of those districts listed up there for 10 years now is my hope that in September parents will be making decisions for what their children consume and all of our classroom celebrations will be non-f food thank you thank you should ask for the L to thank you Susan and just one last endorsement uh on behalf of the principles uh Mr Tony pepy would like just to say a word and we are Nancy do you need the screen anymore no because I can't see you okay um just a quick endorsement good evening everyone thank you for having me

073um thank you for giving me the opportunity to speak about the wellness Council and the wellness policy um obviously there's a lot that's been said about this just to let you guys know at the committee level this evolved very organically um everyone that is at the table has a different lens so a parent has the lens of their child and maybe some of their child's friends teacher has the lens of their entire class and some of the stuff that comes along with this we have the lens of the entire building and obviously some have the lens of the entire District so all perspectives were kind of kicked around um one thing is for certain we have a lot of parent support in this District you know you looked at the pictures that are included in

074the slideshow tonight um you look at it from a food perspective but those are all parents that are looking to get involved and be a part of their child's classroom so that's to be commended for sure um the other piece in terms of the celebrations and birthdays and stuff like that that is such so vitally important to us as building administrators to ensure that the kids have a celebratory happy experience in school um you know with or without food and in this case we do support M towards a non-food celebratory policy um some of the stuff that uh Mrs tilaka so perfectly stated um was stuff that evolved during the committee um discussions and and the other side of this that I kind of wanted to to feature here before I I enclose is the

075wellness side of things and the health and wellness um I kind of think on a personal level it was a little ironic that at Brookside we celebrated Wellness week last week where we featured healthy healthy lifestyle um eating healthy healthy choices active um staying active and such we had students track their healthy activities as an example of that um and now this week as we transition to the end of year parties we have have pounds and pounds of cupcakes coming in and things like that so which is great and again our priority is to make sure the kids have fun but I I kind of being that we are the wellness Council and these are the type of issues that we do need to consider um it kind of seems like it is a little

076contradictory so thank you very much for your time thank you and at this time I'll open it up to the board if you have any questions for Nancy of the wellness committee Mr tiarella I I have a I have a a couple questions because I heard a lot about um classroom time being impacted uh by having parties and celebrations and and then uh we're still talking about having parties and celebrations but just without cupcakes or without food so and you even made a comment that it's not it wasn't it's not the food that's causing the extra time it's the celebrations themselves but yet we're still going to have the celebrations just minus the food so my what you know one of my questions is why why wouldn't the wellness Committee just look to ban celebrations

077altogether if we're going to look if we're looking to ban things and make sure everything is equal and not exclusive why would we why would why wouldn't we just just ban them and the second question is aren't we looking shouldn't we also be looking at who we're excluding by saying well we're going to still have celebrations but now you have to bring non-f food items which are more expensive you're going to bring toys and things like that so now you have kids who can't afford it who will not be able to celebrate their birthdays because they can't afford to bring things in the other kids can bring in so I have a I have a you know I have issues with those things I also think that um what you know as far as I

078heard I heard a lot of things we have a lot of parents that are concerned because of GMO and and those kind of things and that's the kind of stuff that that being brought into these classroom parties sure well but I could tell you that I'm personally against refined refined Foods processed foods carbohy hydrates simple carbohydrates and sugar um so maybe you know maybe my kids now will be excluded because when they go to the lunchroom those things are on the menu so are we going to make sure that we're you know that we're we're satisfying everyone to the point where we're going to satisfy no one I mean I I just want to make sure that we're we're being smallart here I just I think either we should exclude it for everyone or we

079should just leave it the way it is I excellent excellent questions um we in tend on providing a list um and recommendations suggestions for teachers for principles uh to come up with uh ideas for classroom celebrations we do not intend to have fullscale parties in the classroom so even though there's going to be a celebration it is not going to be the 20 minute celebration the kids can have fun uh we had kicked around a lot of ideas um during the meeting um of things that they that would make that child feel special for their birthday um that were fun that were special but um we're not real time consuming we're not talking about full-on birthday parties in classrooms um you know the full-on birthday party takes place at home um so you know um

080I I hope that I didn't misrepresent what um you know the party would be like it would be um you know something more modified um I have a question Mr Mayo um shouldn't it be up to the teacher to set the parameters for the birthday parties um you know that is a good question and we were going to empower teachers to come up with I mean that was one of our recommendations what we we intended to do uh at this stage was give principals teachers a toolbox these are ideas and to have teachers come up with a plan on how they are going to um you know we weren't going to say this is how you have to do your birthday party to empower them to come up and you know how they're going to

081uh have birthday parties so I know but my point is they could have been doing this all along thus controlling how their classroom time is spent so if they're having these huge birthday parties shouldn't it be up to the teacher to to set the parameters within their classroom to say if you're sending something in for your kids we're allotting 15 minutes and and this is what you're getting why mostly what has been reported and I understand what you're saying but mostly what happens although they might send in a food product it's the hitches they forgot to send a knife they have to go looking for a knife they forgot to send plates they have to go finding plates they have to go find napkins they that is the kind of thing that expands the birthday

082party that is what we're hearing and that's the thing that takes the time um sometimes there's you know goodie bags that have to be passed out sometimes goodie bags have to gone be gone through um so it's it's dependent on you know Case by case you know sometimes it's a simple the cupcakes came in they got handed out and that birthday party went you know 10 minutes you know but not every every party is like that thank you Mr Ryback I have couple of thoughts and first Mr metac I want to thank you for your work in our schools thank you uh you do a fantastic job you and your whole staff and thank you very much we all appreciate it that being said what we're looking at here seems to be um a cultural

083shift MH certainly for this country sure if it's such a growing thing um and something that's uh you know a little difficult for many of us just to uh you know accept uh I know my computer is being inundated with letters from parents and I'm sure other board members as well uh opposing this this I want to make sure that you know we get all our questions uh answered so and and I completely understand that okay and have a few uh right now um the students able to buy snacks yes they are all right uh do those snack machines or whatever have uh sugar and uh candies and things like that they don't have candy in them they don't have anything all of them are considered a smart snack and they are um the USDA

084set out standards uh that have to be set at to meet a spe specific uh regulation for snacks uh they have Cal restrictions they have sugar restrictions and food service is not permitted to sell anything that is not a smart snack what about ice cream um it's all lowfat ice cream or fat free so um all of that is uh you know you can come okay well small thing I I I think that part of it certainly you know concerned about health in general obesity and all this I know s chart on that um we need to work with the homes and I'm sure we do uh but it seems to me that the onus is really on the home more the home than the school ours is to educate and make people aware we

085can't control what happens at home it's still the parent of the child has control rightfully so of that of that uh situation and I think that that seems to be where most most of it has to has to come from not from us but from the home um so I think we need to really look at how we are uh educating parents uh are we reaching out properly are we being successful in educating parents um as far as labeling of food that seems to be a national problem uh if companies are doing this so so that it it could be confusing to anyone even people at home sure uh you know we can't just think of the school this we we certainly care about the safety and Welfare of everybody uh especially the children because

086that's what we're here for we're here for the kids and that's the most important thing for us and and uh certainly what happens at ball games or something at snack Shacks anything uh a kid can get an allergic reaction just about anywhere outside of the the classroom or the cafeteria so I think that you know maybe we need to look at what we're doing with with the home and and I don't know what we're going to do nationally as far as putting pressure on companies to to label using a plain English so to speak uh because most of us don't understand what these chemical uh uh ingredients are well yeah I mean you really uh things are hidden as Mrs tilaka said I mean you really have to know how to read all these ingredients

087and they are very hidden um two more things well one of the uh things that I know a few of us had uh on the board here had uh um asked the um the policy committee to look at a compromise I know I myself when this first came up I was looking uh online and asking people outside of this District what they do and uh quite a few districts I you listed districts here that are are are Banning uh food and I think um uh Mr Chella brought up a good point on that also but that being said uh couldn't we come with a compromise uh to a compromise where we cluster birthdays so that you have three or four celebrations across the year so you don't have that many and then I think uh

088we need to look at the parameters we put on parties uh so that we you know it's controlled more uh so that maybe um parents are really aware of what's accepted what has to be included that maybe with a checklist or something like that so that we know how long it will take we won't allow more than so much time I think you know part of uh school and don't misinterpret what I'm saying please but kids have to have a little fun here also it can't just be academics all day long um they need to have a little fun they need to laugh and and then and certainly a party teaches socialization skills and I think that's important for all students to understand so you know we can't take a a look away from the

089importance of having a party the importance of experiencing um uh different different foods cultural experiences I know we had uh I was experienced that and I can mention that later on uh at a celebration uh by our Indian Community and uh it was wonderful to to be exposed to that to that culture and I think that that's a a learning situ a learning situ a learning situation in itself you know it's a teachable moment that that's the that's what I was looking to say it's a teachable moment we have to take advantage of all this so I I think there's U some things that we could look at some things that we could do and and frankly I was a little taken aback when I was understood that uh you know it was said before

090that uh there is no compromise um I I think that you know you have to look at opposing views this is a community you know it's it's this isn't a dictatorship this is a community we represent a Comm we represent the community I think we need to understand the other side and and and take a look at the possibility of what can be done if you cluster uh birthday party sure this this was heard uh I think Mrs TOA would like to answer this sure Mr ryck I just have a comment on one of your questions that may clarify something for you at at the the school level in the elementaries what we had envisioned was for the nonf food celebration birthdays was not necessarily a party or a substitute celebration that's taking more class

091time we had envisioned some type of a recognition for each child's birthday that would include maybe two or three consistent things among all the elementary schools of the same grade level so everyone's getting the same thing and some of the ideas we had thought about was a morning announcement recognizing their birthday giving you know Elementary level a treat like you're the line leader for the day or or things of that nature that don't take up instructional time but everybody can participate in equally uh the party aspect of it was three parties a year which are typically the Halloween the winter celebration and the end of school party they would be non-food parties and we would allow a m an hour time say for those three parties that each Elementary School would have the same three

092parties the same hour length of time and we would work with the teachers at each grade level come up with appropriate activities that would be fun that everyone in that classroom could participate in such as crafts Games music dancing things like that um we feel that the children would enjoy that more than having a lot of food that's just getting thrown around but also again it's something that is controlled it's equal not only across the school but across all of the district schools and and also accessible to everyone in that classroom and I also want to make a point someone had made uh an idea of having a quarterly type birthday celebration I kind of had an experience like that today one of um our grade levels decided that they were going to make today

093the unbirthday for all of the summer birthdays I had an enormous amount of parents coming in with food and what it it ended up being in just in one classroom to give you an example four students brought in Italian IES one student brought in ice cream cups two students brought in cookies and one student brought in cupcakes so each of each student in the class had four Italian ices one ice cream cup cookies and cupcakes that's unacceptable so that would be what you're asking for if you have a quarterly birthday well I I'm I have to say I can understand what you're saying but if we set up some parameters for for these for the all the time and effort we put in and sitting around talking and and you know and and you certainly

094did a lot of time uh put in a lot of time uh for in this situation so I'm asking you do you think it's possible to set some parameters so that you don't get inundated with food like that after 13 years of doing this at this grade level my answer would be emphatically no and and the reason is we have tried and we've tried to work with this on so many levels we tried limiting what the choices are for people to bring in we've tried getting people to bring things at certain times and inevitably we're blindsided by someone showing up at the school at 7:45 in the morning wanting to drop off things for their child's birthday on their way to work and then it creates a lot of confusion because the teacher didn't know

095was coming maybe the teacher isn't in that day and it just doesn't work no matter how many ways we've tried to inform parents that this is what we need to do to have some semblance of order and again safety so my feeling is no it would not work I could be wrong but that's just from my experience Miss armeno um just to answer some of the board's questions uh board members questions at the at the policy committee meeting all of the questions that have just been uh asked were also asked and discussed at the at the policy committee meeting um you know half of us I I think it's safe to say went in with the same concerns compromise changes um you know allowing certain things um but the the compelling reasons in my personal

096opinion uh that the that the policy committee understood are really important and sort of grave consequences if we don't do it um and I think uh you know judging from from the studies and and what what people what the professionals have said um I think we need to really consider it very seriously it seems to be a wellth thought out policy it is not a pleasant policy um clearly I and I and I want to thank all the parents in the audience and on all the parents who've sent emails um hoping that we don't pass this policy I understand and I agree with a lot of their arguments I just think a more compelling argument is that we need to uh accept this wellness policy and move forward and try to be more creative and

097to think that each indivi I think it would be more disastrous for either uh a principal to be responsible and we've seen it if if one principal in one school has a has a stricter policy than a a principle and another there's disturbances throughout the district if one teacher who has a strong Constitution and is able to make those strict uh rules I think then then that person becomes the bad guy or or an and not an unfair judgment against that student against that teacher or a principal so I I I think and one of the things that I was hoping for during the policy was a consistency throughout the district because more than More Than This policy or not this policy um our parents would like consistency throughout the district so um and again

098I think there's a compelling Health reason um we don't want to put Children at Risk and yes are there children who don't have these allergies that would would you know maybe the first year or so be unhappy that they're not bringing cupcakes in and gosh knows I like a cupcake I wish that wasn't the case so I so I get the I so I get the disappointment both of parents and and children but you know a lot of times we say we have to we have to listen to our teachers we have to listen to our Educators I think this is a time and especially I'd like to thank the nurses because they're at the front lines and if something goes wrong they're the first people and as well as the teachers that that will

099be responsible so I think we have to at this point listen to our district professionals and pass this policy thank you Mrs Lang um my one my big concern is that at I have attended the three committee meetings where we really hashed this out and went over and asked for things and and everything and at our last meeting Dr kak asked for and I wrote down the last two lines of B5 to be removed that food used for instructional purposes should not be consumed with the exception of curriculum based culinary arts and if Foods used um for instructional purposes it will be the responsibility of the teacher to ensure that no food is consumed and I thought we had agreed that those two lines were going to come out but they're not out so I

100can't vote Yes on the policy if it's not printed correctly M president oh yeah Dr kide yeah uh thank you Miss Lang for for pointing that out uh there was there were two lines as Miss Lang just referred to uh one was that the um I have it in here the um that the teachers would be responsible for ensuring that the that there was no food consumed and I had made that uh suggestion at the at the committee meeting as like Miss Lang had just said that we should take that out because they didn't want to put that onus on the teachers that if they use food for instructional purposes that they would have to make sure that no one ate like a marshmallow and you know I just said it might be better to

101take that off the teachers the other part of that uh makes a lot of sense that it should be removed as well and it just came up to today and I agree with Miss Lang and that is the part about food being used for instructional purposes that it I believe that it it says that it's not consumed right um and the the argument with that was there I I know at least one teacher used food or uses food for salt sweet things like that and in that case that the students would have to consume the food so if it was used for instructional purposes and it fit the dietary guidelines um then that in fact that would make sense then right to take that sentence you're saying out or I yes to take those two

102sentences out because there are times where food is an important part of instruction and there is also great use on even the high school level um of using food to introdu to teach cultures and and all sorts of other different things but there's also that case like if if we're putting it as strictly as that there was recently a class trip the I believe it was the the middle school went to Dorney Park and a student had not had lunch breakfast before they left home and they did not have lunch with them they didn't bring their mail with them and if you read what this says if a teacher is not allowed to give a child food then that that's a real dilemma so I think I I've said from the beginning I think this

103is a very unclear policy I don't think it explains things as well it's not in my opinion a well written policy because I think that anybody should be able to pick it up and know what where it stands from reading it and I think that the it doesn't communicate the fact that we want to put an end to the to the birthday parties for the reasons that we are and and meet the children's Wellness but that the principal still has the option to do um re food rewards pizza parties and I just think that not that we it's just if we're going to be fair to the entire District it should be clearly it should be able to be read clearly by all the parents and those two lines just really bother me cuz I

104just think food especially in like your preschool disabled classes or in your early grades when you're teaching those things there's a there's a time that you need to a child has to taste a lime you even check you know they put the litmus um test in I think it's chemistry when you're in high school you put it on your your tongue so are we going you know Mrs Lang um we did we did agree to that I don't know why that is in there so I want to I I don't know know why you're looking at a copy that it's in there I don't that's a copy that we were given yeah I think the one the one sentence was removed but it was the other sentence right above it that says Foods used for

105instructional purposes should not be consumed with the except should be exception of the curriculum based culinary arts classes okay I think the point would be that if if food's used for instructional purposes and it's appropriate and I think the teacher could make that decision that it would be the food be allowed to be consumed sure sure so that's a minor change that might have been a um misunderstand misunderstanding when the policy was was corrected uh and I thank you Miss Lang for uh thank you for bringing that to our attention uh I think it conceptually we did agree to all of that and the other piece uh it is in there but it's in a different place where we talk about the principles it is actually on the first page of the policy um if

106you were to go down um a little um towards the bottom of it uh there is a place and and I I'm I apologize I don't have the policy in front of me oh c okay so but it it does it does state that uh it just is not in that that particular place Mr Mayo I have to agree with Patty um the whole using food as manipulatives and not allowing kids to eat I think really cu food can be a great teaching sure and as a parent who had a son who was so picky wouldn't try anything for me but we when he went to other people's houses or when there was something going on at school he was trying new things and so that was something that was important to me to have

107food in school in addition even though it says principles this example when the kids went to Dorney Park and I've talked to people frequently children going on class trips their parents don't send them lunch and it always shocked me but Dorney Park was a 7:00 a.m. trip to 10:00 at night and I spoke to another person who said this child did not have any food you can't rely on the principal at that point the teacher needs to make a decision and if we don't allow the teacher to have that power then the teacher may not want to take that risk and let that kid go hungry until they dinner time we are not trying to affect that I know but it's not clear through the policy that because you give the principes the power but

108you also need to give teachers the power okay that's that's good feedback okay I think at this point we probably discussed every Mr Ryback did you have something quickly very quickly we're on page three of a 90 page agenda do you think Madam president might be possible with all that's being said to um have this rewarded and then brought back for for a vote if there it's on the agenda so if somebody made a motion and second to send it back to policy we we can do that I would make a motion uh rather than vote on this today and do anything at haste make a motion that we send this policy back back to the policy committee for rewarding and then for a consideration at a future date or the next board meeting whenever

109it's ready is any second okay any comments or questions on that motion so we'll vote on the motion we'll have a roll [Music] call [Music] yes Mrs armeno yes Mr Chella yes Mrs Deo yes Mrs Lang yes Mrs Corino Mr Rybeck yes Mr Russo yes Mr rutsky yes and Mrs kopano Madam board president it's unanimous policy will go back to committee okay Dr kak will remove letter L from your agenda yes okay oh thank you for your your comprehensive presentation and we're going to work on this until we make sure that we get it right abely all together thanks okay so I think we have finished with all of our presentations and we will go to our student board member report but before we do that um we have a prese presentation for you and

110if you'd like to come up and help do you want to come up yes get the on you don't get the the table someone's to need yes Mr Jamal you're leaving us Mr Jamal well Dr coak can hold this while I speak because I have to read um s has been with us for two years now and you're leaving us to go on to bigger and better things so Mr Jamal has been a per he's been on the principal's list in the honor rooll he's been an AP scholar a member of the computer Club the academic team Youth and government National Honor Society and National Science Honor Society as I said he's been a student board member for the past two years he's a m Muslim inter Scholastic tournament finalist a codable camps instructor an

111American Legion Jersey Boys State graduate and he will oh no ruter University win lab summer intern and you will be attending ruter University SAS for computer science and I know just recently we've had a um student awards night and you won some awards there so congratulations we wish you the best of luck and we hope you come back and see us and we will miss you [Applause] Dr thank you y so keep this short but the first thing I want to talk about is this weekend a select group of juniors are going to be going uh to the American Legion uh boys and girls State programs they're weeklong programs in Civic engagement and I went to the boy State one last year uh just as it was just mentioned and I think it's really beneficial

112and all the kids are going I talked to some of them and they're all really excited uh today marked the beginning of fin final exams in the high school they're going to be going on until Monday and then before we know it on Wednesday we'll be the graduation for seniors at the Sun Sun Center in Trenton and before I wrap up I just wanted to thank all the current and former board members for like the past two years for making this position a really great learning experience for me uh for anyone who knows me personally I probably wouldn't have done this on my own and it was mostly because uh Nick thorney from last year kind of just talked me into it but and we know Nicholas could talk you into anything right he's really

113good at that but uh I'm really happy he did because it's helped me learn a lot and not only uh learning about how things work but also kind of shaping parts of my personality and my experiences in high school uh and with all that being said I think whenever I think back to my years on High School uh years in high school my experiences here are always going to be some of the more uh positive and cherished memories I have so thank you all for that and and we know that you will be very successful no matter what you do so thank you again okay I think we're up to committee reports now so is there any committee that needs to report Mr Mayo yes we had a very interesting curriculum meeting today um we

114went through a bunch of documents uh we had the new lab biology and the honors biology documents um what's really interesting is that we are moving into real problem solving in these classes is very unlike when I was in high school and you just um did a sequence of going through the steps we did honors Algebra 2 and um we did graphic design it's graphic design is a really popular class we had over 200 students pick this as an alternate and we have 136 students um request graphic design as a class next year we had an update on ourmes we had have threey and hold on let me go academies are um very focused um academic tracks and we have a business and law government Academy we have a communication arts academy and we have

115a STEM Academy and um we've had 11 students apply for the business law and government we didn't have enough for the communication and arts academy but we're looking to change the way it was the classes were picked or Chosen and to get a a better um we invited 55 kids we had three kids apply so we need a little bit more for that so we're reworking that maybe next year we'll get enough to actually have the academy move forward the STEM Academy we have um 25 kids in that and that's biomed Premed engineering and information technology and these acmis have a very specific class schedule they will be going on field trips related to the courses of study they will have mentoring and at the end of their junior or senior year they will have

116a Capstone project and or an internship so these are really really really exciting what what we're creating in our school we also have a new teachers program the tomorrow's teacher program which is a program for students who want to become teachers this is a program that's endorsed by the njaa and the New Jersey doe and it's going to revamp our current working with kids program and it will give students more in classroom practice at the high school level so that's really exciting we're they're they will also receive college credits for some of the classes that they take we've upgraded our prek report card we recently upgraded our K to3 report card and instead of just talking about you know work the kids are doing it's it's a whole um system a evaluating other things more

117socio um emotional learning type stuff we also have a we are applying to do a language Muse activity pet and this is a pilot program or it's a study by ETS using a computer program that will help English language learners um become more literate and I really can't speak to the finess the the the specifics of this but it sounded really interesting and so we're applying to be a pilot with that and the good news with that is if we are part of the pilot then at the end of the year we'll have access to the computer programming either way so we'll be able to use it in the year thank you very much Mr cherella did you oh I have did you raise your hand I don't have a question I just have a

118report I thought you did we had a buildings grounds and transportation meeting on June 5th ours was much more exciting than than Jill's so at our meeting is this more exciting than my meeting wait I don't so we absolutely not what we talked about or uh we went we went over what we really did was we rehashed a lot of the things that we already had in the works and we just got updates on a lot of stuff so some of the things that uh we we were updated on were the roofing project and the mill work project at Barkley Brook and also the paving project so those those are two different projects actually three different projects the painting is uh lead abatement in the coupal on the outside of the building um and so

119that that's going to be taken the lead's going to be removed it's going to be repainted and then the uh the roof the the roof will be partially uh be done um now that's going to be timed to be done at the end of the year and then the paving will be done after those things are done so uh they're all they're all everything is is scheduled to be to just uh to be to work one you know one right after the other until we're until we're finished so um that was uh very exciting as I said that was and then we had uh ingred ratano come in who of Pupil Transportation Solutions so she's been uh she's been helping us out catalog our old buses are broken down buses that are behind the middle

120school we have roughly 10 of those that are pretty much gutted old and destroyed um because we've taken Parts out of them to fix our our new Fleet and just so everybody knows um you know there are certain restrictions by the state where we can only use buses for a certain period of time and then those buses have to be retired uh and that's why they were behind the middle school and then what happens is now what ing's going to do for us is U facilitate the sale of those buses so that we could uh get rid of them and make some money and then put that money toward new buses uh which is which were budgeted for earlier in the year and we had already talked about the purchase of those buses and budgeted

121for those buses um we also talked about the food service replacement project for the some of the the Food Service um yeah equipment things like that but I was going to ask you Mr Gorski if you wouldn't mind explaining some of that because there were some there were some parts of that that uh where we went out to bid and then we had to you know we're going to do some of that work ourselves so I just wanted to clarify that through you yes um our food service program under the um directorship of Mrs M miss Mr saac uh has a unique problem uh it provides the very finest quality of food ingredients um to the students of this district and we have the lowest lunch prices or among the lowest lunch prices in the

122county but yet we've accumulated cash to the point where statutorily it's it's approaching exceeding 3 months of average expenditures in the fund which is prohibited by the Department of Education to try to uh prohibit districts from overcharging lunches and creating a large cash Surplus in the fund some projects that have been in the works for a while but just haven't gotten through the budget process are the replacement of a walk-in freezer at the Monroe Township Middle School which is decades Beyond its useful service and needs replacement um it's a very fragile um freezer right now and it could go and lead to spoilage and and big problems there and there's also some Steamers and some other items that we were going to replace using that cash and when we had gone out to bid the

123first time we Consolidated all of these food uh equipment items together as required and we had no biders so now we're going to change the bid specs to hopefully attract um um biders and procure those items using that excess cash as quickly as possible thank you I never would have been able to say any of that um the next thing that we discussed was the mil Lake playground resurfacing using the Eric North Grant and that that's uh that's proceeding and that you know that was still um a great Grant 30 if you want to and and the beauty of that is all of the playground resurfacing at mil lake is is being done through a grant that was um secured through the efforts of Mr T um so that we're not spending any District funds

124on that uh project and and will provide for a safer playground for students and then um the the last thing that we had was we we uh had an update on the proposed land transfer on Church Road and um this is where it really gets exciting so you might want to just pay attention so right now as we speak and for the last couple weeks there are people camped out on that land in tense I don't know what they're wearing if they're in camouflage but there are definitely tents there and they're waiting to see turtles and catch Turtles breeding and do all kinds of all all kinds of things so um we're we'll get a report back later as to what they've seen maybe they'll capture some of that on video and really really get

125us that be exting then that'll be really exciting but um and that's that's all I have thank you I don't know how anybody can follow that Mr BR y so finance committee I sat in for uh took the day off thank you very much welld deserved they off but first I'd like to thank Mr Jamal for being the student board president uh I enjoyed all his presentations and uh I want to wish him the best of luck at Rodas I do agree with you thorney has a way with people convinced me to run for the board so that's true so um just the first item is the um indiv idual uh individuals with Disability Act um I guess was some type of um monitoring so I'm just going to read the text as prepared uh

126Mr Gorski furnished the committee with a Consolidated monitoring report dated may6 2017 from the state of New Jersey Department of Education Office of fiscal accountability and compliance the report presents the audit results of the idea basic and pre School Grant whereas a review of the expenditures policies and business records CH charged to the uh ID Grant did not yield any findings and I guess that's a good thing negative findings right yeah so uh the committee accepted the report and express their congratulations to all the administration administrators involved that last line I don't remember I'm just joking uh the next thing was Food Service audit and this is a very interesting one uh Mr Gorski presented a correspondence from the state of New Jersey Department of Agriculture whereby the division of food and nutrition nutrition's review

127of The District's audit report for the fiscal year ending June 30th 2016 indicated that the net Food Service cash resources exceeded 3 months average expenditures by 245,000 what do you think we'll do with that money so Mr Gorski indicated that this is a fluctuating calculation and the committee accepted his plan to reduce the said excess buy we're going to do these three things uh replacing Antiquated fully depreciated equipment such as the walkin freezer and Steamers with new with new ones replacing other small equipment serving in cafeteria program and by more aggressively allocating District custodial services and energy costs to that program okay now we'll get into the lease purchase this I guess is the the buses we discussed that so Mr Gorski again uh provided the committee with a resolution authorizing the acquisition of various

128vehicles and equipment and the financing thereof which were all approved and contained within the 1718 budget Mr Gorski indicated that these lease purchase Method of financing with its low interest rate and you know the rates just went up today so you got got it in on time better matches cash expended for each asset with its estimated useful life uh the committee unanimously recommended such to the full board that's that's true and um there audit update for June uh 2017 is going to be tabled for a future meeting and now we go to the special services lease renewal and MOSI again provided the committee with a resolution to renew the special services and Central registration office lease along with the negotiated lease documents by our attorney Suites a101 and c203 are recommended to be extended two

129years based on a 2% annual increase the committee unanimously recommended such to the full board he reminded the committee that there is a uh concrete plan to bring these functions back into disc School ref within the school referendum and we touched on that earlier in the presentation so that that's that the last one oh again this is about the referendum interactive dialogue the it's a company that was could we say selected okay so Dr kak was on this one and Mr sigi presented as recommended by the steering committee a contract with interactive dialogue as presented to the steering committee interactive dialogue will facilitate the district and bond referendum strategies for a successful marketing campaign for a fee of 20,000 after discounts what type of discounts the committee approved the proposal and recommended it to the

130full board and the next finance committee meeting will be scheduled for Monday July 17th Mr Rosy what time July 17th at 7 o'clock P.M make sure you're there so um okay and the the only other bid that we got was 90,000 for this same contract was it 90 okay that concludes the uh Finance U well thank you Mr Mr thank you very much Mr Russo you're welcome anyone else have a committee report oh Mr I'm not going to report tonight due to the time uh constraints but uh I attended the state assembly for the New Jersey um I just just went school boards thanks New Jersey school board so I'll report on it next month okay thank you so we will go to I think we're still on page three um the public forum and

131so anyone wishing to speak to the agenda please come to the microphone state your name and address for the record and as many of you know the the public forum policy has been revised and adopted at the last meeting so there will be a 4 minute time limit but there will be no stoppage of the clock thank you you're prash pup 33 Dina Drive I I have with respect to the construction of new schools I have few questions number one is what is the cost cost number two is do we plan to have solar panels for the new middle school high schools Etc in expansion as a source of alternate energy third is do we plan to requirement to support stem do we have technology lab engineering lab I heard about science lab like to

132have technology lab and Engineering lab number this is important 1,000 students 30 classrooms so 33 students per class unacceptable maximum students should be 25 because the teachers had to give attention and the students I think this is planned for 7 750 students expansion because 30 classes will efficiently hold students so efficiency good teaching and the students can grasp so that is very important so we are spending money please think over it okay and the middle and the kindergarten it is going to be a full day or half day it is good to have full day so we want to have an answer on that and lastly the sixth question is Middle School we are going to have enough playground okay thank you okay I and I think Mr Gorski can answer the the cost questions

133and you can answer the technology in kindergarten yes ma'am uh good evening dror as far as the cost goes we I we were planning on addressing this issue if this was a referendum project like a A5 or $10 million addition to a school I think the average referendum last year was about $10 million it would be easy to work with the architect and come up with a cost estimate this is a very complex project it's two schools and in addition to to the school it's newly acquired land and um just regarding the land alone there it's it's undetermined at this time how much work is going to be required uh to make that land suitable for a school that's going to be uh need uh expertise from engineers and so on so we the board

134of education has engaged in a professional engineering firm to come up with a cost estimate for this project because it goes up beyond the sophistication of what we can provide administratively and we will provide that information thoroughly and completely as soon as it's available and and along with that will be the tax impact that is projected to the community associated with the cost on the successful passing of the referendum um Madam regarding the solar panels stem Labs the full dayk and the and the mon retentive Middle School playground would it be okay if Mr Al deriso addressed those well yeah about I I would like to add some before Mr ariso I'm not going to touch on the solar panels uh you bring up a great point about engineering Labs or engineering space uh it

135we're not in the at to the detailed area yet but trust me on that that is a very important area for me as well and a lot of that can be accomplished with flexible learning spaces it's different than a traditional lab where you need the exhaust fan and things like that but we've already started adding more engineering at our Middle School certainly in our high school and that'll be a uh very big part of the design process um also the number of classrooms and this Rich you you know maybe could clarify I believe it's 36 classrooms so that the average class size uh will not be uh 30 we we're looking at a lower number um so but that is a good point to check we're building to the capacity where it may reach in

1365 to 10 years so we wouldn't hit that um that number right away for a th000 students it would be over a period of time but we certainly don't want to build schools if we're building new why build something where it's going to be uh you know crowded classroom so uh it's a great point and we will certainly take that into consideration the kindergarten uh I think it's a little too early to determine full day half day there's a cost issue I strongly believe and I I I can't speak for the board because we really haven't discussed it uh but I strongly believe in full day kindergarten as well I think it's so so needed and so important part of what we're looking at with the new elementary school is if that's going to be

137where Applegarth is oak tree is already K to3 we're building the kindergarten classrooms now so that in the event that we can add kindergarten that the the um the facility the the plumbing and everything else is already in place what the gray configurations will be has not been determined whether the new school placed on apagar would be in in actuality a k to 5 or we would keep the sister School concept with oak tree and Applegarth maybe a k to2 3 to 5 or k to 3 four to five so that hasn't been determined yet we're that's still uh coming up but great questions thank you very much thank you I don't know if which okay a playground for Middle School okay good evening timo2 Court um first and foremost I want to congratulate all

138the student athletes tonight that was a wonderful recognition the Board of Education gave them very nice thank you and with that said um I'd like to know if possibly uh we had a freshman baseball team this year that won the GMC tournament and uh we'd like to see if they could be recognized as well um with as along with Coach fields and uh volunteer coach bagula they win 16 and three this year which was a a feat in itself and I think we got some pretty great some great student athletes coming up uh through this program um I like to add as well that um I appreciate this recognition being noticed by the Board of Education okay and that uh this if you can if it is all possible uh you recognize uh the freshman's

139GMC tournament win this year or Championship this year that it is not uh has nothing to do with any parent organization booster club or any kind of Diamond Club affiliation this is strictly for our student athletes who uh had a great accomplishment this year in going 16 and3 and winning the GMC crown and uh if it all possible you could recognize them okay we'll look at something for the because our next meeting is in July right okay thank you okay thank you heather Corona and I'm at 225 old Ford drone good evening I'm here tonight to dispel the myths of the proposed wellness policy which caused a knee-jerk reaction from the public when they became aware of it back in April as time has gone on I would have hoped that the board as well

140as these individuals have done their research as well as look at what our neighboring Progressive districts have been successfully implementing for many years and thank you to the wellness committee for the informative slideshow and moving our district in that right direction One this wellness policy does not limit parents rights to choose what foods they feed their children what you feed your family is a very personal decision and should be respected by others this policy says it's not okay to feed other people's children parents are unaware of the sheer volume of junk food that we saw on the screen that is being distributed to our children every day without our consent eliminating Collective food at holiday and birthday celebrations is the solution children can still gather as a community and eat the snack that their parents

141have provided for them that day and this way parents know what their children are eating during the school day their birthdays and holidays will still be be recognized by a simple Act of being a line leader getting their bookmark and made to feel special but the safety of our children with allergies and other health impairments is Paramount and parents will know exactly what their child is consuming during the school day because they are only eating what we provided two the wellness policy does not impact students with IEPs that have food needs considerations as you know IEPs are legal documents prepared with input from parents school officials and even doctors so this proposed policy has no effect on these children three the wellness policy does not impact culinary arts classes students choose these courses and families

142are made aware of the curriculum four this policy has no effect on PTO sponsored snack sales or after school events again because we as parents choose to send our children to those events and those snack sale items already should be meaning District Wellness guidelines five this policy has no effect on school lunches because those meet local and nutrient standards and once again we as a parent have a choice whether or not we want our child to purchase that I'm proud of the work and research that has been done to create this policy the fact that it has 100% support from every building principal and 100% from every building nurse should speak volumes it exemplifies that these individuals that work with our children closely closer than anyone here every single day should let you know that

143they see that parents need to choose what their kids are eating and what they feed their children Mr rback you said the Board of Education represents the people we are the people we are the parents we are the teachers we are the administrators we have the nurses the reason why there's no compromise is because it's not in the best interest of the children you said parents need to have control and wellness starts at home you take away that control when you let other parents feed my children again cultural Foods as learning experience great that could be an Afterschool activity that I can choose to take my child to Mr kirella you stated that um about goodie bags and having to spend money on that but the policy states no goodie bags um Michelle thank you

144for your support and understanding of the importance and if we're here talking about verbiage let's work together to get that verbiage um the way that the board would like it to be seen so that we can move a policy forward that's um aiming to keep all children in our District safe healthy and included I don't think anyone can argue with that thank you thank you anyone else from the public wishing to speak good evening my name is tab andot I'm at 4 Ino Court um my question is around the schematic drawings that were presented to this evening and mostly around the timelines involved um so is there a plan to have a referendum is there any idea when that referendum will come come to a vote uh if so do we have an order for

145I guess the construction and which what school is going to break ground first and when that's going to happen and the timelines regarding the construction how long that's anticipated and the completion date from the time we break ground we do not have any of that information yet at this time we don't even have a formal referendum it's still in the in the stages of um we're looking for uh property there is negotiations for prop property until we have that we can't move forward on um knowing exactly where we're putting every piece we're at the schematic stage which you just saw they are not definitive we can be adding and taking away from that so until the referendum process is complete then we will have all that information we need the costs which we don't have

146yet my understanding was that the sites have all been established or set aside no two out of the three have then um there's an addition to the high school and there we were looking to put an elementary school on Applegarth property the uh the sites for the middle school is still in negotiation and at that time at at this time we cannot speak to that all right thank you hi my name is is Christine Lester I live at 261 Cranberry halfer Road um I'm in speaking um in regard to the food policy I understand and support the concerns the food committee has um as I have a child with um multiple congenital heart defects he also has food allergies and restrictions and is frequently unable to eat because he has am esophagus I've come up

147here before um with that said um what you are proposing and is no way solving any of the concerns and therefore I'm against it the board has um not really provided did any data showing that the Obesity rates in our school have actually increased um if this was actually a concern then removing all the unhealthy food that the school cafeterias are selling would be the first place you should start that would have a larger and more immediate impact than a few parties a year or a food based activity I'm also in favor if we were going to limit the birthday parties but I'm just talk like I don't think that we need to do all that um these snacks are sugar-based high calorie foods and have some known allergens in fact when my child issues

148due to food it has always occurred in the lunchroom most notably due to the snacks you are selling never has anything occurred in the classroom from a teaching activity or party um as I recall someone asked the board um recently if there were any reports from the nurses um that a party or activity resulted in allergic reaction to date there have been none the only reports I heard were in the higher gr grades were appear had given you know shared food um I would like our teachers to have control over their own classrooms let the children learn to self- Advocate they can alter things as needed so if star of the week always brings a cupcake maybe they bring a favorite coloring page and again for the birthday parties to it doesn't have to be

149a food- based activity um in the presentation they said there's a lot of time wasted I think there's more time wasted watching movies in the middle school and in the classrooms um where they'll watch movies for a week um also if this is actually about obesity rates in the poor Pacer testing then remove the sugary junk food that you sell and expose the children to daily allow the kids more time at recess rather than using that time to eat the junk limit homework to a few days a week or follow a District's lead by eliminating homework altogether something like this would have an enormous impact on the health of our kids this will allow them to actually play outside participate in sports versus doing homework till bedtime we personally have opted out of sports because

150we have too much homework um we are promoting healthy living and telling kids to get up and move and eat healthy while selling them appetizers for lunch followed by ice cream or CH cheros 5 days a week so if I send my child with $2 for lunch they can buy ice cream they don't have to buy lunch um do you realize that the district loses all credibility while these foods are pushed on the kids for profit um how can you encourage children to be healthy and and be a good role model we do this as parents by providing healthy food and teaching moderation I don't tell my kids that they have five minutes to eat lunch on the weekends and then after they have a few bites tell them to toss it out we're going

151to have snack we don't offer ice cream or dessert for eating a bite of their lunch you don't let their your children pet like throw out their whole dinner plate to have that cookie we have to lead by example that includes that the district handles things teach them to keep trying activities allow them to see what is a good fit for as far as Sports Go provide them healthy food and the social aspect of breaking bread with their peers this has been very important to my child feed them something other than appetizers for lunch bread sticks and mozzarella sticks are not it's not lunch um and make sure that the cafeteria doesn't run out of fruit every Lunch Period should be able to have the ility to grab an apple or a pear not just

152the first Lunch Period by eliminating snacks sold the kids would have time to eat their lunch first and finish their food instead of tossing it to eat chips basic hunger would encourage them to actually eat I would also suggest that our kids are able to eat lunch daily and our children are not shamed over overdue accounts or lack of money yesterday a child at the middle school was not allowed to have lunch because it was the end of the year and they didn't want to have a balance so that's not an excuse instead she went hungry while other children cost Out full trads of food I just would like you to consider this thank you do do you want to respond to that yes with regard to the Middle School incident that was reported to

153me today and I spoke to Nancy mitac food service director who interviewed everybody who works in the Middle School cafeteria and and the fact that a student went hungry and was not provided a lunch it it could not be um determined at all in fact the policy and procedure that we have in place is that if a child doesn't have enough credit on their school Child Nutrition account that's funded online by the parent then they are provided with a traditional type lunch uh a reimbursable lunch it is called and their account goes into the deficit the parent has then written a letter but in no circumstances here have we ever to my knowledge sent a kid away hungry from lunch because they didn't have money or shame them in any way right and that's when

154I wrote to the board I said that I don't know if it was explained to her that she could have a cheese sandwich or that you know we can call a parent or anything like that I'm not sure that but I do know that she had animal crackers that she obtained for my child and then she went back to class hungry so it's just it was just something I wanted to bring up to the board um but again I'm not opposed to like implementing some kind of food policy okay thank you very much anyone else wish to speak hi uh my name is Jessica is I'm at 21 Oliver Street I just felt compelled to expand upon the extravagant amount of food celebrations in school my kids they don't have allergies or any health issues

155and I just try to my best to feed them a healthy balanced diet while also allowing a healthy amount of indulgences with health consistency is key and unfortunately this school year has been downright disrespectful to my efforts for stability and nutrition during the brief 2 and 1 half hours my child's at school she regularly Downs more more added sugar than the recommended daily maximum for an adult and this is all before lunch this is directly because of the extra sweets she's given at school there is a flyer that comes home in the beginning of the school year encouraging healthy snacks so I was under the impression that Monroe was a health conscious School District I do my part and I send her in with healthy food why is the school allowing her other people to

156feed her junk food and as often as they are sure it was annoying when my daughter would come home from school and skip lunch because she had a stomach ache lamenting that she shouldn't have eaten all the extra Treats but it quickly became infuriating when the sheer volume of celebration days revolving around the extra treat treats became apparent to me the last time I spoke here in April there were four days out of that week where extra desserts were handed out that's four out of five consecutive days my daughter basically had sugar for lunch and she had stomach aches for two of those days because of this and I'm D to report that nothing has changed this week is turning isn't turning out to be much different in keeping with the excessiveness uh kindergarten has

157two end of the Year celebrations they had one Bounty full celebration on Friday and tomorrow they're having another one that again revolves around more snacks and this is all on top of all the summer birthday kids who get their own special day to bring in a celebratory snack I don't even know how many there are going to be this week and all of this is crammed into the last few weeks of school School the school is sending a message that uh we celebrate everything with junk food and this blatantly contradicts the current AAP recommendations to promote healthy ways to celebrate it also diminishes the meaning of a celebration by habitually celebrating life's not one big party and we don't need junk food to help kids learn let's make it healthy it's not too late to

158change our outdated and frankly embarrassing School culture according to Dr CLA McCarthy spokesperson for the American Academy of Pediatrics Banning Suites at parties or for rewards forces people to think of healthy ways to celebrate it also forces people to stop and think about what they're doing and how it might impact students it makes a statement about how the school values students health and helps create a a school culture of healthy eating let that be our new culture cupcakes don't make or break the party thank you thank you hi I was going to read my notes but I think I'm going go back and forth me one second okay Cory and Masters n Court I just want to say we had our kindergarten toat oak tree today and we did not have junk food we had

159mini bagels for our celebration that the PTA sponsored which to me would be fine to have and and I don't think a food policy should you know impact that I will also say that um my kindergarten made this lovely book for me today and as you can see we have pictures of our Thanksgiving feast which I still think should be included and due to the current policy would not be um also it's a picture of my children my son and my husband and I having um his uh gingerbread house that we did in December with the food policy that's before you this evening that would not be allowed which again would make this book very sad to the next set of parents who have kindergarteners still to come up um I'd also like to add

160that both oak tree and Applegarth have Gardens and the thought that the children wouldn't be able to eat what they grow is very sad yesterday my son brought home two onion plants that he grew he named them stinky and scramble he was so excited today because he gave was able to give them to my husband for his birthday today if he wasn't able to grow these and to try these onions we would he it would be lost so it's very sad we had Healthy Living night last week at Oak Tree um Mrs Densmore alone with some of the teachers of the staff I helped them raise money and they ate crickets in order to buy fruit trees so we can start an orchard there well if the children can't eat the fruit that the orchard

161grows it's kind of pointless um I was actually on the middle school trip to dony park standing next to the to the faculty member when the child came over and said she had no food and that she hadn't eaten from the night before it was a 16-hour trip we weren't getting our dinner meal tickets till after the award ceremony which is approximately 6 p.m. the thought that this this faculty member would be in trouble for giving a child half for lunch um you know concerns me because I wouldn't want that faculty member to be reprimanded and I don't want to see a child go for not eating dinner the night before till not eating you know dinner the next night at 6 p.m. um also the wellness committee doesn't really address at all um mental

162health and that's a huge portion of this as I'm on the Applegarth and the oak tree Wellness committee and it was trying to be addressed both those places but yet this districtwide committee hasn't addressed it at all if that's really a concern maybe then we should increase the time of physical activity we want to be more like West Windor that was one of the examples yet West Windsor has no homework policy days maybe we should Institute something similar to that also maybe the board members would like to look at some of the menus in the elementary school I work school store twice a month in oak tree and Applegarth I can tell you there is funnel cakes and I know they meet all the guidelines there's baked Doritos there's baked lace it's 180 days my

163that my sons can buy baked Doritos ice cream whatever they like that doesn't necessarily go in our home but if he has money on his lunch account they know they can do it and unless I put a lock on his account then they can't and then sometimes they get a friend to buy it for them so it doesn't always work also I wonder if the slideshow that you just showed this evening will be online because I couldn't copy down some of the information fast enough will you be able to put that slideshow online great um let's see what else and then as far as like wasting time with movies and things at the middle school during Park I mean we have so much downtime during Park we could use that for maybe some Mental Health

164you know days and minutes and do breaks during teach the kids yoga do something more constructive I didn't go let's see what else I have on here um I think I think I'm good for tonight all right thank you everyone thank you I appreciate taking time to speak thank you uh good evening Doug boy I live at for tamarak Road uh uh first of all I'd like to commend the board for uh having uh provided time for the schematics of the anticipated buildings uh sharing that with the public uh I think that was uh very wise of you to do to try to get that information out to the public as soon as possible with the understanding that uh there will be a lot of changes in that but at any rate you're beginning to

165get the information out so the public uh becomes more aware of of what's taking place uh there was a comment made by one member of the board that uh I wanted to bring up uh and I bring it up in the context that a school environment is quite different from a corporate environment uh and particularly in a high school uh I do not think that it would be wise at all to uh concentrate all the administrative staff in one section of the building uh for purposes of both emergencies and safety uh you need those Vice principles deployed uh throughout the building and not all clustered together in one part of the building uh I I I've seen the mistakes that some schools make when they've done that and I've seen schools that operate much better

166when that administrative staff is scattered around the building they're more accessible to the teachers they're more accessible to a classroom in the event that a fight excuse me should break out so uh I think by deploying that that administrative staff uh around the building you have a much safer uh situation for the students and the staff uh I also would like to uh uh commend the board for attempting to establish a policy dealing with uh Wellness um uh it's timely uh I I know it's not an easy task because you have those who want things to go along as they always have been uh and so you're having to listen to all those competing interest but I think it's a good thing to do uh I also was listening very carefully about the wellness program

167uh and I do believe that uh it's very very important uh and I did did discuss this with a prior superintendent some time ago uh we have students uh that their Wellness needs uh deal with their mental health and more needs to be done more needs to be available to students from the very small from the very young grades all the way through high school that are not necessarily with an i but definitely have some mental health issues uh that might be not being addressed and in my opinion those are the people that once they become adults they create the problems in our society because they have not been properly treated uh and had their anxieties and and uh their difficulties dealt with so I thank you for your attention and uh I commend you

168once again on giving those schematics and I hope that future board meetings will uh you will continue to share that information uh about the potential referendum that the community will be facing thank you thank you Mr Po anyone else from the public wishing to speak good evening Chrissy scurby 21 pness uh Drive um in regards to the uh schematics that we saw tonight um very excited to see uh the new Middle School um however I was a little um surprised that it would only be housing, students um the current middle school right now was built to house 1,200 students um that would only leave us with 2200 students currently there's over 1,700 students in the middle school I think we really need to look at the demographic studies uh very closely to see what how

169many students we do um anticipate because the numbers are growing and we have three huge developments going up condos and Tow houses um so I really think that you know you you have have to look at the demographic study very closely to see if that building is going to be big enough or if we're going to open and we're going to be at capacity on day one like we've been in this building and Oak Tree um also um in the interim I know that we talked about it at the district education council meeting last week um I know there are plans for trailers not this school year but the following school year at the middle school I think it's very important for this board to ensure that there's going to going to be water facilities

170water run out to those trailers um it would leave the students and the um the teachers in the administration really at a disadvantage if there's not water to those trailers you would have students that would need to be coming back and forth into the building and into the trailers to use the bathroom facilities so that's going to be something really important for this board to ensure um that the students are going to have the proper bathroom facilities in those trailers and then just in regards to the food policy um I have to say I was the PTA president over at Oak Tree school for seven years and I some of what was said tonight that goes on simply I I never saw I never saw hordes of food multiple cupcakes and and candy and everything

171being given out the the parents who um ran the parties were room parents um we weren't you know I was always a room parent in our room um we made sure we made healthy choices there's a lot of fruit brought in as Mrs Master said the kindergarten tea has Bagels um that that's been a tradition for our kindergarteners at the celebration to see something like that go away truly would be sad um maybe you maybe you can listen to what some of the parents were talking about and compromise if you want to take away sweet treats for birthdays come up with maybe a list of foods that you you would be okay with fruit vegetables but to say we're taking away all food out of the schools completely that's a that's a little rid ridiculous

172um I just I I think the board really needs to take a look at everything I I heard uh I haven't read the entire policy I heard it referred to that staff would not be allowed to provide food um I I think that would you you have to really look at that too because if you're having snack sales on a half a day that's going to be allowed there are children in the elementary school that come and they forget their money and I've seen it time and time again we ran those pretzel sales all the time at Oak Tree and children would get upset and either the parah in the room or the teacher would take a dollar out of their pocket and say here just you know you can buy on who you know

173we don't want you we feel bad for you you left your money on the bus or mom forgot to send the money you need to look at that too in the policy if if a teacher is not going to be allowed to do that anymore you know that that that's that's very strict and and that's going to be very concerning I think for parents and you don't want to put the staff members in in that position of children being upset or you know that that's going to cause another whole issue um so I I just really think that you you really need to go back and look at exactly how this policy is going to affect everybody across the district thank you thank you anyone else wishing to speak to the agenda seeing no one

174Dr kak would you like to do a superintendent report thank you madam president um there before I ask for the board's approval of the recommended I mean of the items on the Personnel agenda I would just like to bring up a couple points uh Mr Ryback will probably bring this up about our attendance at the teacher appreciation day but I I too wanted to say it was a very nice event uh present it to our elementary teachers in particular by members of our uh Indian Asian Indian or American Indian population it was very nice student performances there was uh food representing um the uh certain you know Indian culture uh it was very good and um uh Mrs Densmore and Mr Manilla were there as well as a number of our teachers uh middle school

175and elementary teachers and it was a very nice event uh held last Sunday the on the personel section I just want to bring to your attention uh letter AJ is Mr William joat as the new assistant principal for the um Middle School being recommended uh this uh he has demonstrated going through numerous interviews with the Middle School administration as well as two interviews with me and uh Dr Ali and he has demonstrated excellent leadership abilities uh he responded well to the interviews writing samples everything that we uh asked of him so he is on the agenda listed under AJ letters AZ through b d uh refer to our summer enrichment program for incoming ninth graders this is all title funded and it really is helping our transition for our eighth graders to ninth graders this

176some you know in some ways came out of a conversation last year um Dr Higgins at the uh Middle School we were talking about helping ninth graders who were struggling academically and we used some title money last year put an after school program in place and then this year using that to help these students before they even enter into the high school both coming from Jamesburg and our Monroe Township Middle School uh for those students who demonstrate a need so I I think that's I'm really excited about this and seeing that the students have this opportunity to get that kind of um extra help before they even uh start the school year and with that due to the length of uh everything else I will conclude that part and then ask for the board's approval

177for items a through CJ so move thank you Mr Chella you're waiting C uh no uh J I believe it is right CJ CJ CJ CJ CJ yeah who second that did anybody second it Mr Mayo any comments or questions for Dr kosac Miss AR I think I just need a clarification on the I think in here there was an it's an assistant principal and then there was a vice principal what's the difference ah it's just a wording change it it's uh whatever our job title is uh I use the the assistant or vice principal interchangeably I don't see any difference between the two but the correct one would be whatever our job title would which uh assistant I think it's assistant it's assistant yeah okay thank you any other comments or questions then we'll

178have a roll call thank you Personnel items a through CJ Mrs armeno yes Mr Chella yes Mrs M Deo yes Mrs Lang yes Mrs Keno yes Rees on Dempsey Nash and F thank you Mr Rybeck yes Mr Russo yes Mr rutsky yes and Mrs kapano Madame board president Personnel items a through CJ has passed thank you yes thank you madam president uh I recommend to the board approval of items a through S um under board action so move second with the exception of l oh thank you thank you I got it from both sides thank you with the no no please thank you um with the exception of L which is the policy yeah so moved again second Mr tiella Mr Ryback again comments or questions I wrot all the stuff down I forgot seeing

179none we'll have a roll call board action items a through S without L Mrs armeno yes Mr Chella yes Mrs Deo yes Mrs Lang yes Mrs Kino yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr Russo yes Mr rutsky so I abstain with the exception of items F G H and then O P Q where I vote yes thank you very much and Mrs kapano yes Madam board president board action items a through S with the exception of L has passed thank you and Dr Co I think you okay yeah uh thank you madam president just one quick announcement um uh this board has been very active in trying to secure additional State funding and I was very very happy tonight that during our curriculum committee I got a text from a superintendent who is one of about oh

180about about 20 superintendents from around the state that I've been working with collaborating with uh in each of their districts are working to secure more State funding as well that there was an announcement um from Senator Sweeney and assembly president uh Pio that they have come up with a plan to provide additional funding for underfunded school districts and I believe the wording will is part of the wording is specifically addresses the needs that the Monro Township School District has understand this is only a plan it's there supposed to be a press release tomorrow and I hope Mr cherella I hope I didn't steal your thunder on that one that's okay I did no no no okay I have plenty more Thunder but I thought that was exciting for considering the amount of work that this

181board has been uh spending on this and so many individuals over a number of years uh it was really uh something exciting to get that text tonight to see that maybe maybe there will finally be some movement and this district will uh receive some more state aid so thank great that would be great thank you so at this time we'll go to the business administrator's report thank you uh I I share Dr kak sentiments greatly um Mr cherel is going to uh speak about this during other board business and um this it's going to be with a lot of excitement I hope because uh this is going to have a significant impact on immediately on Monroe's Aid formula as well as the long-term prospects of um the development of a new funding formula um Madame

182board president and members of the Monro Township Board of Education it is recommended that board action items a through mm be approved by consent roll call so move second Mr Chella Mr Mayo any comments or questions for Mr Gorski Mr Mino yes Mr Gorski on um board action oh we're not on the professional appointments part yet right it's it's all one okay report then under a professional appointments item four um it talked about a savings but it can you tell us what the actual cost of the energy for America Incorporated will be that's item four yes okay I look I looked at this last year in energy for America is a a contracted uh professional firm that the district has engaged for many years they provide very sophisticated Green Technology to the district for example

183they've regulate all of the um temperatures in the classrooms and the schools including this room uh when there's no one in the room they moderate the Heat or air conditioning down to a minimal level to save money and it's all very scientifically approached um likewise they shut off the electricity uh During certain times and I asked energy for America for a report about a year or two ago the maximum um on how much money they believe they've saved and they gave me back a very lengthy report that goes into kilowatts per hour and thermal units of uh natural gas and whatever but the the amount of money that was saved at that time was in excess of a half a million dollars a year off of the energy bill and um that leaves a lot

184of District resources even after their fee which we negotiate very conservatively with them okay but what is their fee it's it's in the proposal I I didn't I didn't understand that there was 12,000 and then there was a 500 I didn't understand the numbers do you know the letter I'll look it up yeah I'll it was number four A4 A4 let me see if I energy from yeah talked about annual energy saving value of $ 81 19,200 net annual Energy savings value 67,341 saved for dollar fade but I didn't see on this do you want mine uh bear with me I have a lot of backup here in the backup that was sent to the m members um is the um the the fee and um according to the most recent proposal the net annual

185Energy savings has actually increased to 67,341 I can give you my letter if you contract that says 7,000 something right there with a payment yeah it's um $7,100 uh build quarterly 7100 build quarterly okay I'm reading this correctly yes I still don't see it on here but I that's fine thank you um stop over stop me afterwards and I'll I have a letter I just couldn't figure it out all right thank you Mr Russo F first I just wanted to say that seemed like there was some uh misunderstanding by a member of the public I never suggested clustering all the vice principles into one area but um I did go with u Dr coak we visited the schools and I did meet with is that on something on Mr gorsky's report uh no but I

186just want to I just want to clear it up because there was a comment that was made with can we do that on other board sure okay okay okay um but I I do have a question on this report as well okay question on the report so I on the technology list I see where're buying servers and I'm just wondering in a day and time when everybody's going to the cloud uh and getting rid of their service why are we buying them that goes to a technological uh sophistication that I can't answer that was uh very thoroughly deliberated during the budget process and at the various committee meetings at the time and uh I regret I can't give you an answer to that specifically if you want to send me an email I'll I'll be

187happy to talk with Mr Washington our technology director and give you a satisfactory answer um tomorrow has there ever been some an expert or someone consultant who can look at the architecture that you have uh for your network and for technology yeah we have a technology plan throughout the district and um everything that's being purchased is in accordance with the technology plan and I certainly after working with him for 18 years would consider Mr Washington an expert in that field the network architect network network architect he may be an expert on technology but not in that area so again uh that was during the budget process because there substantial savings going in that direction and I'm just surprised that you know we're buying service but okay any other comments or questions then we will have

188a roll call Mrs armeno yes Mr tiella yes Mrs Deo yes but I have to recuse myself from L but I vote Yes for everybody else okay Mrs Lang yes I recuse uh yes for everything recuse on Patricia Lang item L thank you Mr Rybeck I vote Yes except the L I need to recuse myself noted Mr Russo uh yes except for you I'll vote no Mr Gorski did I correct I need to recuse myself on L also just my name noted thank you thank you uh Mr Russo you are a yes and a no on you correct yes thank you Mr rutsky so you got your pen ready yes sir all right so I abstain with the exception of these following items a e h n is in Nancy s is in Sam V

189is in Victor y z as in zebra double c and double okay and there I vote yes thank you sir Mrs K panovich yes on everything except on letter L I'm going to re cues on my name only so noted Madame board president board action items a through M has passed oh you forgot Mrs me I had a check mark there he M now I beg your pardon that's the first time that's ever happened Mrs Corino thank you okay okay U Madam pres Talent on this board pardon I guess it's lateness of the evening um motion passes thank you okay um board president's report and I'm going to try to be very quick um now it's it's the end of the school year and there's so many events that we've been going to and all

190of our schools so recently I had the opportunity to attend two of them one was the annual Woodland poetry slam and the second was the kindergarten tea at Oak tree that I attended today and I was amazed at the creativity at of the students at Woodland because they wrote and acted out their own original poems and I can't write a poem to save my life and I was they did an unbelievable job and today the little kindergarten students they entertain their family and their friends and I was very honored to be invited and it's always nice when we get invited into the schools because I think I've said this before what we do here we don't get to see in the classroom so it's very important or or we're very happy and very excited when

191we do get that chance to see that so I I hope we do more of getting more invitations in the future um last time I I also talked about the evaluation process so I just want to give an update last week the non-conflicted Board of Education members met at a special board meeting to discuss the evaluation of the superintendent since that time a summary report has been written and that is going to be shared with the board members this evening in closed session and um when we come come to consensus then I will have an opportunity to share that with Dr kak um we will need to have one more special board meeting to conclude the whole evaluation so I'm looking to see if we could set something up for next week because we don't

192have much time left and it needs to be done by the end of June um so I wanted to see if there's any dates that we could possibly get together next week I know um Wednesday is graduation so I don't think we want to set one up then but I know we have Tuesday Monday and Tuesday are Middle School graduations but they're over four no they start at 4 right so they start at 4 so they so they start at 4 but we we could do that after we can always have it like at 6 o'clock or 6:30 or something I I don't think it would it should take very long to do that so would everybody be available on Tuesday night Tuesday I'm sorry or the other option is Thursday what's the date the

19322nd Thursday is the 22nd yes yeah I can't I think I I'm not available on the 22nd well then we will um this is for the non conflicted board members the non-conflicted board members we could do it a special extra meeting fore conflict we we you attend your own meeting Monday we have a Monday graduation to at 4:00 the other half of the middle school so we could always do it Monday evening if if that's I can't do it Monday I have a graduating middle schooler okay then we will try to set up a date tomorrow we'll we'll try to see what we can have and next we yeah I know all right then that concludes my report and then we will go to Other Board of Education business Mr Ryback yeah I just two

194fast things I I also was able to attend the uh Woodland poetry slam on May 25th and um was just amazed at the performances but also they they um published a booklet of all their poems and I thought that in itself was wonderful so kudos to everyone Mr lame Mr McLoud all the teachers staff and especially to the kids they're fantastic and on June 4th as Dr kosac said we um attended celebration hosted by the Indian Community um if I'm I hope I'm pronouncing it right Guru vanana and Sans scrpt means reverence for the teacher and it's thanking teachers for their knowledge and wisdom that they give students and the event was culminated with a wonderful sharing of uh uh Indian food which was delicious it was a um very wonderful celebration a lot of

195work and effort uh went into it and we certainly were appreciative and I know the teachers administrators there will equally as a appreciative thank you thank you anyone else can I bring up that point now yes you may so because a member of the public mentioned something and I think they misunderstood what I was saying I didn't mean that we would consolidate all administrators into one area as a matter of fact I toured the school with Dr kak and met with uh almost every vice principal in uh in the high school and uh Str strangely enough after they got to listen to me uh which um the member from the public didn't get the opportunity to they agreed they actually agreed with what I was saying and I was even surprised at how quickly they

196were they were um willing to look into it and cooperate with that so uh it it it doesn't mean that anybody has to move uh other than maybe some of the other administrators in other words when you uh spell out the requirements for the space you need it's space mean the of the space the location then you have your physical operational functional requirements that you put into your um let's say your request and then the plan is collect that information and see how they can best place um the staff and and put them in a common area which can be shared the idea is that office space is no longer owned by anybody it's shared amongst a group now you could make uh a case for a certain individual that may uh have designated offices

197or shared with even other high level officials it can it can be broken down that way but the location because a lot of the discussions items that were brought up into discussion uh they're not documented like Vice principles uh provide a certain let's say concept of security because they happen to be there they and they're on a certain floor in a certain area where the students are moving around plus they're closer to the teachers in that area so they can help them and so on all those things put into their requirements and then based on those requirements you could create the flexible space that this type of environment where you can cluster them together so that's what that's what we would discussing and it seems like they were all uh eager to to look into

198it so because they did say that when they first moved into the high school um it was kind of overdone the space they got was too big they didn't need it they didn't need that much space and then over time some space had been taken away so to avoid that problem going going forward I think we should address it early on okay I'm sure we will be looking into it as we move forward because nothing is set in stone yet yeah and if you if you set up a committee to work with the Architects on that I would like to be a part of that okay thank you Mr cherella yeah I just I have uh some other board business so I wanted I wanted to congratulate the student athletes also and Mr Jamal who

199he uh had to go I'm sure he had homework in school tomorrow studying for an exam yes uh I I do want to talk quickly about the the funding committee uh so I was not until you sent me that article uh this evening I was not aware that there was a deal actually uh over the last few days I had reached out to a number of people to try to figure out if there were if there was any movement and I couldn't get any any Headway anywhere uh and that was disconcerting uh considering ing that as of the eth the uh Governor's challenge to the legislature to come up with a bipartisan plan to fund education and the fix the funding formula um was up so that was the deadline and to hear to to

200have that met have that deadline just arrive with silence uh bothered me so um I in my characteristic way lashed out uh you know and sent letters to the editor posted stuff on Facebook I was I was nice but I just but I also was firm uh anyway I just wanted to let everybody know what that article said to give a little more detail uh so they're going to apparently uh Senator Sweeney and assemblyman assembly speaker poo came together and have worked out a deal there was some contention I guess between them uh prior and there were a lot of things going on that I was hearing about the assembly speaker being replaced at sween's request and things like like that so apparently they work something out uh we're $146 million will be earmarked for

201the for the uh underfunded districts and that could mean several million dollars for us if that's if it's true and if that does work out and they talked about in that article lifting the growth cap and re reallocating adjustment Aid so I think those will be good things if uh if if that actually happens on the flip side I think we still need to move forward with uh making sure that we have our insurance you know and that insurance is keeping you know uh having a some steadfast resolve to move forward even if our politicians let us down and um so uh few a couple meetings ago the board uh gave us a vote of confidence gave the funding Committee of voter confidence to move forward and look at uh the possibility of a lawsuit

202uh I I worked with a couple of uh the committee me committee members to uh reach out to other districts we reached out to about 600 districts so I have a list here of that and the and uh some of the some of the things that we have we've heard back from the fields I don't know why every town with the name field in it responded but no one else did I'm I was thinking like maybe there's some kind of I'm getting some kind of message or something but I I can't figure it out so like Chesterfield Deerfield you you name it if it has a field in it some they've responded to us um Hamington they don't have a field they don't have a field respond they resp so I think um I think

203you know they what every District basically said though was they're they're they're still waiting they're hopefully optimistic but but they were willing to uh look at Alternatives once they knew for sure what was going on so I think that's where we're at I um I think that uh we may you know we may eventually have to look at seriously you know suing the state if they don't come to the table and and with meaningful Aid and relief and as promised meaningful relief before November we were promised that in this room by our Senator by our assemblyman that uh that that would take place before November I'm holding them to that uh and so as a as a followup to that we have a meeting of the funding committee on the 28th here at 7 o'clock

204for and it's open to the public for anyone that would like to attend that's it thank you thank you Mrs Lang hi um on on May 30th I attended a conference to the New Jersey school boards Association on student achievement through different lenses and I must say it was probably one of the best conferences I've ever um attended they really talked about using social emotional learning stud to increase student achievement and the the connection between staff and students and how that improves um student achievement and talked about empowering the stakeholders especially teachers and students in part of the collaborative process of making decisions and bringing about change in the school district and it tied right into something that here at the high school on June 6th um was held a the Monroe Township High School

205child study team and the school counselors presented an information session which was incredibly moving and and just wonderful to raise awareness about Teen mental health issues which came up again tonight and it was it was it was the brainchild of the counselors and the child study team they went to Michelle Celli and Miss Hines and Mr Goodall and said we want to do this and they did it and it was a very wonderful um open conversation between parents and we gave feedback I went as a parent you know always concerned about doing the best for my my children as well as um others and they gave us great information and they're going to be planning on doing sessions like that throughout next the next school year so I think it's a wonderful thing that we

206we had that opportunity and I think they should really be commended for what the work that they did thank you anyone else okay seeing no one uh we we're back to public forum so anyone wishing to speak to anything um please come to the microphone give your name and address for the record and we're going to adhere to the 4 minute no stoppage policy prakash pup 33 D drive I'm happy that we going to learn something tomorrow about uh funding from the state but uh the elections are coming we have to put a pressure you know I have heard Equalization Aid you know how $23 million other District gets and we get zero so we have to put pressure and we have I'm going to I'm going to talk to different communities and the pressure

207is on who is going to be our governor who all are going to stand for election from Council level Board of education and up so last time uh I had a question about performance academic ranking of our school so I'm following up what is the academic ranking of our school when factors include scores of sat sat state test number of students in AP courses and rate of graduation and how is the comparative performance for last 3 years on this second one is how is our school district ranked in niche in last three years because Niche looks like not only Academia overall performance of the school so i' like to have your comments and any opportunities as we move forward do you have that information yes okay thank you Doctor um the academic ranking is when

208we consider the SAT the or act and state test uh the number of AP courses in graduation it's it's hard to uh compare us using some of the outside rankings uh like uh Niche or other ones because they each had their own way that they rank districts and I'm going to speak about niche in a minute but overall um our scores uh have been going up which I'm very happy to report the um the uh SAT scores in particular are average scores have been going up above the state average uh this year our average is reading 5'11 uh not this year but the previous year 537 and 512 and that is above the state average which this District had been below the niche rankings uh two year in for 2016 we were rated as 86th

209in the uh State 2017 we moved up to 60 I couldn't find the 2015 because Niche doesn't I guess they don't archive it so I searched and search but I couldn't find it but it is I'm I'm very proud and very happy to note that we've moved up uh 26 spaces according to their rankings uh and I feel that the presentations that Dr alvik has done with our state test scores and we won't know that for this year until probably late August or September uh has shown uh considerable growth in in all of the tested areas we're also looking at our own internal uh type like our map test as a measure of academic performance that assessment which is in grades 3 through eight and uh the end of the year assessments are coming in

210so I know I looked at it mid year and I saw a considerable growth across the uh grades three to eight but I really need to look and analyze the final grades uh once all that data is in uh and I will be reporting that to the board so I feel that there's there's many different ways that we measure growth uh but academically from all the different measurements that we have uh across the board I feel like we're making considerable progress in that area and I attribute that to the hard work of our teachers I attribute that to the hard work of Dr Alvi of course uh certainly our principles our supervisors and we really have focused on a on the use of data um you know this year last year we really made a

211a a concerted effort to use data to inform our instruction and just as a side note I was stopped into one of our uh AP Chemistry classes today but on the way I ran into one of our physics teachers and she was telling me a story uh I don't want to get too much into the personal information but it was basically the use of data analytics she show showed me charts for a business outside of school that was just incredible how you can measure every step of the way and how important that is to run a business small business well that same type of data analytics is very very important that we use that in a school district to measure our our interventions effective how do we know what can we do better so it's

212not always a question of more testing but it's a question of taking the data that we have and making better use of it and that's something that that I would like to continue to see uh this District do to really find a way to measure everything that we're doing to make sure that we're being as effective as we possibly can because we want the best for our students we have very good students and we have very good parents and I think the expectations are high from our parents and I want to make sure that we meet or exceed their expectations thank you Dr kak and board members I'm really proud that we have gone up you know from Dr prash your time is up yeah 86 to so I'm very proud of that I'm proud

213of all of you all and I'm also Jill talked about stem that is and other programs we are very proud of that please continue okay thank you very much again it's Christine Lester 261 cranber half Road um I didn't see this on the agenda but I just want to bring it to the attention that we lost a teacher um Mrs fenari from Applegarth and I think her should be acknowledged I was really disappointed in the district's handling of her passing as it was just announced just via appar school as an alert now and I know other students in the other buildings were told in some buildings like I know the high school they weren't informed but the middle school was told but there was no communication from the administration that she had passed so a

214lot of us parents just took it as rumor um because we were waiting for some acknowledgement I did did email the board and Dr kak and there was no communication or anything sent out from the board or the district until a week after her passing I did attend the funeral and it was very disheartening to go at night with her peers and her colleagues and family to say where are the kids where are the parents um I know Dr kak's response is he didn't think that it affected a lot of people but it did there were kids crying on the buses there I had to you know I worked book fair with her students in her class I didn't even know how to refer to them um if we want to retain our teachers we

215have to treat them better and we have to acknowledge their passing she was a nationally recognized teacher and teacher of the year if she worked here for a week we have to acknowledge their passing um her kids were grieving and there was no acknowledgement the only thing that was sent was one Facebook message a week after I get calls every single day from Mr Brier from the athletic department and my child can't play sports I would not be offended if you sent out a blast an email a Facebook whatever however you would have done it or even if every school then sent out a blast but we want to retain these teachers and right now they feel like it doesn't matter if they pass that their time with our district is not important and it

216is her life mattered and I think her family was expecting more people to come and acknowledge they couldn't even send a condolence on her Facebook page or anything because nobody knew until a week after her passing so I would just just hope in the future that things like this unfortunately are going to arise that we handle it better so she was a great teacher and I just want to acknowledge her because it wasn't on anything but thank you thank you can respond do you want to respond to yeah I I would like to respond I I appreciate that feedback I I want you to know that that she uh was a great teacher and a great person and I did attend the the viewing uh and speak to the family and I spoke to you

217know her husband and and the you know her children and people there and express that I I didn't I knew the history I did consult when I mean I had been following her battle over the course of a year and a half two years speaking closely with uh Mr vollo in particular and uh visiting her classroom and and following all that uh not knowing the history as far as her presence in other schools I did consult about where she had taught and where she had worked um looking back in hindsight 2020 maybe something after the entire District but the initial information I received was that it was it was primarily Applegarth school and the middle school which is where we put the notices out um I receive anything from the Middle School just okay but

218but again I you know the last thing I want to do I mean if you saw tonight the way we honor our retirees our teacher of the year our educational staff our our support staff uh many different people my visits to the classroom the very last thing we want to do that I want to do is ever to not show full respect to our teachers our power professionals our custodians our bus drivers you name it I I make it a point to get out there and say hello to people and talk to them and a lot of Staff have commented about that I have the utmost regard and respect for for our staff again hindsights 2020 listening to your comments I thought you know that you you right um that should have been something uh

219a whole District wide announcement and uh but it wasn't for lack of it wasn't apathy on my part so I appreciate your your feedback heads up some people didn't know because she was out on leave for a while certainly certainly I understand thank you cor Masters and I'm Michaela Court I just want to take a minute to um congratulate Mrs schmeer and Mr capes um for the awards that they received when we were at dony Park the band had come in um third and the Falcon jazz band I think came in second in there um and the chorus came in second place or yes second place only be to be beaten by our chamber choir which came in first place so I know sometimes you know we don't always acknowledge the band in the chorus

220at the board of ed meetings so I just want to take a second and tell them it was great to see and it was it was really it was a long day but the kids all had a good time and it was actually not as nearly as stressful as you know we were all anticipating it's going to be so it was a great day thank you thanks anyone else wishing to speak then at this time public forum is closed and we will go to the closed session resolution be it resolved that the Board of Education of the township of Monroe hereby moves to go into Clos session in accordance with the Sunshine Law chapter 231 of the public laws of 1975 and JSA 10 Co colon 4-6 through1 colum 4-21 to discuss the following subjects

221harassment and intimidation and bullying superintendent evaluation following Clos session action may be taken the discussion conducted in closed session can be disclosed to the public at such time as a need for confidentiality no longer exists we need a motion in a second I'll motion that oh Mr rutsky oh Mrs Lang all in favor I opposed and then at this time we will move into closed session thank you so much okay seeing no in the audience for public forum our next uh Board of scheduled Board of Education meeting is July 19th 2017 7:00 p.m. at the Monroe Township High School motion to adjourn Mr Chella give it to jail Mr Deo all in favor I opposed meeting is adjourned

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.