CorpusRecord 132987

Monroe Township Board of Education 09.13.17 Regular Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Monroe Township School District
Date
2025-02-12
Location
Middlesex County, NJ
Material
Transcript
Extent
23,979 words · about 134 min
Collected
2026-06-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001no okay good evening the meeting of the Monro Township Board of Education will come to order please stand for the salute to the flag to flag the United States of America [Music] stand andice may we have a roll call Mr Gorski certainly Mrs armeno here Mr Braverman Mr Chella here Mrs Deo here Mrs Lang here Mrs Corino Mr Rybeck here Mr Russo here Mr rutsky here Mrs kapano here Madame board president you have a quarum present this evening in accordance with the provisions of the New Jersey open public meetings law the Monroe Township Board of Education has caused notice of this meeting to be published by having the date time and place thereof posted September 8th 2017 at all schools the home News Tribune the cranberry press and filed with the clerk of the municipality

002thank you this time we will go to number five on the agenda the approval of minutes for the public Board of Education meeting of July 19th 2017 second second moved by Mr Chella second by Mr Ryback any additions or corrections to the minutes seeing none all in favor opposed I refuse myself I abstain whatever are you abstaining or recusing are you abstaining you're abstaining Mr Mayo abstains so noted okay uh the approval of the closed session meeting minutes July 19th 2017 so move Mr Chella second by Mr Ryback again additions or corrections to those minutes abstain Miss armeno yes um this is the closed session for July 19th is that correct yes it is uh my objection to it is in the superintendent's evaluation I don't I didn't think we were really sufficiently um finished

003with that to have put it on here and if if we were there's certainly not enough information in um in the minutes to suggest uh the dialogue that went on in that closed session so I I think um that's fine you can call the role I'll just I'll I'll be objecting to it did go through okay um I believe Mr Ryback might have done that one but but did he he might have submitted the minutes then I don't know I I believe they were checked by the uh the attorney or attorney to make sure I I I definitely think they're insufficient to um you know if the public wanted to read what the conversation was uh there would be no way for them to understand what went on but I also think that it it's

004not it's not complete so it shouldn't be on here to begin with yet I think tonight after tonight well we still had the closed session and that was on closed session so any any other comments or questions okay all in favor I opposed I Mr armino opposes extensions Miss Deo and Mr Russo you're abstaining I was in close okay thank you so I think you're recusing do you have all that yes okay thank you so at this time we're honored to have today with us Lieutenant Del from the fire department number three who is going to um uh come to the board and um give us a presentation and I'm going to ask Dr kak Mr Gorski and Dr alvik to come up to the um Podium with thanks r can I start oh how

005are you thank you when do I start now uh good evening members of the Board of Education and members of the community uh my name is Lieutenant Mike dy I work with mon Township Fire District number three I also serve as the Department's training officer the mission of our fire department is to protect all people in our community from any threat of not only fire but of also technical rescue and any other type of rescue needed that being said a proper risk assessment helps us to determine the level of training that we will need to provide that type of service to all the members of our community a risk assessment that shows that thousands and thousands of children are transported every day to the Monro Township Schools put our perspective into being able to protect

006them while they're being transported back and forth our ability to work with superintendent gorsky's office office to acquire some decondition buses to provide an extrication training for our members was no small task and I'm very grateful to all the members of superintendent gorsky's uh staff am I I pronouncing your name right am I sir drak superintend I'm I but I dealt with you so I know you's okay okay with the assistance of all the m members of the Board of Education we were able to deliver state-ofthe-art Dynamic training for over 100 firefighters of our community including members of communities that neighbor our area who we rely on for assistance that's no small order it took a lot of work and a lot of great assistance through a lot of organizations in this town we feel

007that it's very important to keep positive relationships with all these entities in our town and to do that I'm here to say thank you formally to the Board of Education I've brought two pictures framed from some of the training that we did along with that I have a plaque that I'd like to present to the superintendent so your mom will be proud too okay an appreciation to the board of ed of Monroe Township Monroe Township Fire District 3 hereby supports and commends the Monro Township Board of Education for their support and generosity towards our training thank you very much for all that you did for [Applause] us don't [Applause] you guys want to see this so we'd like to thank the lieutenant Del again for his presentation and when we talk about shared services and

008cooperation with the township different uh departments we're very happy to have had this partnership with the fire department so thank you again [Applause] okay thank thanks so at this time we are going to [Music] number seven on the on the board agenda a board discussion on proposed referendum so this is a very um it's been a very long time since we have talked about referendums and the need for new schools on our District so this is a very important res resolution we have on the agenda this evening so I'm going to read the resolution and have it moved in second and then there is a statement that um going to have Mr Gorski read from the township and then um I'm sure he's going to be able to give us some Financial figures and then

009Dr kosak can can give his input and then I will open the floor to the board members for any comments or questions you might have after that is done we will invite the public to come up and speak and give your comments or questions to us uh in regard to the proposed um resolution that I will be reading so at this time it's okay if I it's okay if I read it be it resolved by the Board of Education in parentheses the Board of Education of the township of Monroe in the county of middlex newy Jersey the school district as follows one a special school election of the legal voters of the school district shall be held on Tuesday March 13 2018 from 7:00 a.m. until 9:00 p.m. in the school district at the places

010and for the purpose of approving the construction of a new Middle School on land which is anticipated to be donated to the Board of Education by the township of Monroe two the board Board of Education hereby appoints a the law firm of mcarter and English LLP to provide the specialized Legal Services necessary in connection with the financing of the project and the authorization issuance and sale of any bonds or temporary notes therefore and other appropriate legal services in connection with such financing and B Phoenix advisor LLC to act as Municipal advisor and to provide specialized Financial Services necessary in connection with such financing the secretary of the board of education is hereby authorized to cause to be printed once in an official newspaper the notice required by njsa 18a colon 18 A-5 parentheses a parentheses

011parentheses 1 parentheses in connection with such appointments three this resolution tell shall take effect immediately I need a motion and a second to accept the resolution so move by Mr Ryback I second it second by Mrs Lang okay at this time um Mr Gorski would you like to read the letter from the township yes ma'am the letter I'm in possession of and about to read was requested by by the board president of the mayor in the township to express the Township's intent to transfer the deed to the board of education at no cost and I'll read the letter now dated September 12th 2017 to honorable Kathy kapano board president regarding property acquisition block 25 Lots 14.1 and 16 Dear Mrs kapano the township is in receipt of the board of education's August 23rd 2017 resolution

012requesting that the township acquire property designated on the official tax map as block 25 Lots 14.1 and 16 and transfer the property to the board of education at no cost for the site of a new Middle School be advised the township appropriated $125,000 into the capital Improvement fund for this land acquisition on September 6th 2017 the township Council unanimously approved a $2.5 million Bond ordinance which includes 5% down payment or the 125,000 from the aformentioned capital Improvement fund at my direction the township attorney is actively negotiating with the attorney for the property owners to acquire the property as expeditiously as possible we are also reaching out to the county of middlex to discuss the county roads adjacent to the site once acquired it is the intent of the township to transfer the deed to the

013board of education at no cost we will keep the board informed of the progress of our efforts very truly yours Gerald W tamboro thank you Mr Gorski and at this time do you have a um some financial information to pass on to the community and the board members MERS yes and if I if I may just elaborate on your introduction of the of the project the board of education has been engaged in a very Democratic committee process to study enrollment patterns in the district um a professional uh demographer was hired by the Board of Education to do enrollment projections for the next 20 years to come and the projections were studied at the student growth advisory committee uh which was a very fair representation of the entire Community parents administrators plan retirement community uh residents

014and even students were on the committee and the committee after studying all the information uh recommended to the board of education to proceed with three projects that the evidence supports the need for the addition the first was a new Monro Township Middle School the second was an elementary school the third was an addition to this High School which opened at capacity and is now over capacity then Administration was tasked with the design of a the referendum and uh we work closely with the township on this issue as well as members of the community and the Board of Education engaged in a land search with the use of Realtors with assistance asked by the township engineer and through our own efforts which ultimately led to the identification of a perfect piece of land for the middle

015school project the Middle School is the most emergent need as far as enrollment growth High pupil teacher ratios and uh bottleneck facilities that we have and um uh we went actually and just to give you a full picture Mr tag and I actually got to the point of desperation looking for land in this Township where 75% is encumbered already either in Green Acres Farmland preservation or otherwise to find a site of about 20 acres to 30 Acres suitable for a middle school and we identified about 20 properties where we we actually went on our own uh visiting these properties knocking on doors looking uh for a suitable property and uh as Fate has it we found one it's the golf driving range on Applegarth Road the board also pursued land that was offered by the

016township which was about 65 acres on old Church Road that property was planned for a new elementary school and a middle school because of the size of the property it could hold both but some of the Environmental Studies that were performed delineated a bigger Wetlands footprint on that property as well as other challenges including but not limited to narrow roads which would have to be widened costing over $10 million sewer connections because the infrastructure in town is not suitable um and was not um it was not in the best area of town as far as demographics go the golf driving range is perfect it has uh it doesn't need extensive deforestation it doesn't have environmental contamination like some of the Farms that we have uh visited in this Township we found a beautiful Apple Farm

017but it was assumed that there was arsenic uh issues that went back and um the the roads are uh a decent size that they don't need widening at an additional cost it's in the sewer connection Zone it has a very minimal Wetlands footprint which is also unusual in this area of town on the south where the most growth is uh occurring and uh it's adjacent to our other elementary school so from a transportation standpoint everything uh works very well so we went full steam ahead and then I was tasked with looking at how can we purchase this land an extensive review of the statutes with Bond counsel and the board attorney and I determined that a school district can only purchase land through voter approval voter approval through the budget by specific identification of the

018project of land that wish to be a purchase through the budget with a specific question as such known as a second question or through a bond referendum question the timetable for that was unfavorable for us because of the uniqueness of this proper proper the risk that it could be um purchased by another interested party and if it was lost we have no suitable second option so Mrs kapano and I uh visited uh the mayor and Wayne Hamilton the business administrator from the township and we ask for their cooperation because the statutes governing uh the procurement of land are different for the township all that is required is the passing of a bond ordinance a second hearing and then uh the purchase and they can transfer the land then to the bard of Ved at no

019cost all of that has been worked out the negotiations between the township and the seller are near conclusion I understand and um there is it could result in an imminent um successful negotiation for the land and then transferred to the board of ed the board hired a professional cost engineer to study the middle school project and come up with an estimate for the bond referendum question and the figure that was provided to us this week from epic engineering is the cost for a middle school with all the categories involved except for land which is being donated at no cost to the board of education is estimated to be 68 m845 545 I then worked with the financial advisor to look at a bunch of variables to calculate what the tax impact will be for the

020community there are assumptions in this very complicated calculation including ratable growth over a long period of time in the township we were very conservative with that estimate um I calculated from my internal records that we're we we were over 2% growth but we took a growth figure of 75% over the duration um interest rates is another and I would I'm pleased to report to the board that the average annual tax impact per $100,000 of assessed value that's not market value that's assessed value is $39.25 per year and again that's the average annual tax impact on a home in Monroe per $100,000 of assessed value if successful um the average will be $39.25 we are working very hard with the financial adviser now to develop a amortization schedule that's conforming with Department of Finance laws that

021will wrap around our current debt schedule so to have a very linear schedule going forward and there's no spikes or or drops in any years um over time our debt schedule falls off in about 10 years time we pay down a significant amount of principal which absorbs greater uh uh principal installments from this Bond sale uh again keeping a very linear track for the Board of Education and the residents of the township yes so um those those are the figures and uh if the board has any question I'll be happy to answer them I just like to uh turn this over to Dr kak and for his comments and input to the project yeah thank you madam president as Mr Gorski has stated uh this was this was a project that when I first entered

022the district two and a half years ago that I knew coming in that the student growth the the enrollment was continued to continuing to increase and it was a concern it was a concern that was shared by the board it was a concern shared by all the community members that I spoke to through working with the student growth advisory committee and as Mr Gori said I I think it was a good representative sample of people from throughout the township we worked together we collaborated we decided that this needs to be addressed and there was many different models and schedules and multiple things that were looked at and researched and the end result was the recommendation that we proceed with a middle school and Elementary School and in addition to the high school they're still needed

023they're absolutely needed some things have occurred to allow us to reexamine how we proceed for different reasons some of the building has slowed up a little bit we don't think it's going to be longterm but it's given us a little bit of a break and the construction vehicles are out there uh but it's slowed up a little bit and we're looking at our most pressing need our Middle School was identified from day one you know crowded classrooms crowded um uh the cafeteria the hallways um through working with schedules and through the um you know moving kids to different schools a couple years ago that has helped at the elementary we've been able to maintain what we think are reasonable class sizes at the elementary levels but the middle school has really been the the school

024that community members have come up and said that you know it's just too crowded there uh that's also the school that we targeted for trailers as well beginning a year from now September of 2018 I was very happy and I think I can speak on behalf of the board I think everyone was really happy that this past June after what seemed like a just a very long time that we were finally able to produce render drawings of what these buildings or these schools would look like not detailed they were rendered we you know but it was at least it was able to bring some some not not a conclusion but at least a stop Gap to show people in the community that we were moving we were Pro uh progressing so it's exciting to me

025to see that we are at the stage now where we're ready to move forward with the referendum and I think we're all certainly aware of the financial impact that this has on the community and I think we have also worked very hard to keep thei the fiscal impact or the financial impact to the taxpayers as low as possible while still while still producing an excellent school that everyone in the community can be proud of that will hopefully Mr armeno you would be able to tell me this whether it helps house values or not but I believe good schools do but it would be able to be a facility that would be able to uh for us to be able to continue to provide a quality education to our students this is a concerted effort Dr

026alvik was very involved Mr Gorski myself Mr tag and others and certainly certainly the Board of Education and it's only with the support of the board of education so it's exciting that we're we're moving forward and um you know that we're at this stage and I'm looking forward to seeing how this might progress and move forward to help the students and the families in this community that's all I have to say thank you thank you Dr kak so at this time I'm going to open up the floor to the board members for any comments or questions Mr Mayo um what is Monroe's Bond rating could you use your microphone what what's Monroe's Bond rating and what is how does that impact on our interest rate the bond rating is uh very important variable in determining

027the interest rate the bond rating is affected by uh reserves by uh Global uh impacts from the state at large as well as very important uh local issues having to do with the school district's audit a clean and perfect audit like we have had over the years our generation of surplus um all contribute and are evaluated with the bond rating and and I haven't checked the bond rating since we did a refunding a couple years ago but I did receive a report from the township recently where they had the very highest rating attainable uh for municipal B bonds and I know the school districts rating was the very highest attainable by S&P for school districts in New Jersey um very recently but I will have to uh check with the financial adviser and get the

028most recent one thank you anybody else have any comments or questions Mr Ryback along the lines of um Mr Mayo um a bond rating now let's say I'm assuming is a good one if this goes off well would we have a more advantageous rating or a better interest rate down the road it's unlikely that the school district's rating if I understand your question correctly can better than it already is okay um what could affect the matter going forward uh not to get political but we are at a a point now where our state aid has gotten slightly better from the horrors that we've gone through in the last um several years and um it is anticipated that state aid will uh get more uh lucrative in the future and certainly that is the biggest variable

029in reducing taxes in this Township the amount of state aid that the municipality and the school district in particular receive anyone else have any comments or questions Mr [Music] Russo regarding the high school extension I'm just curious why that wasn't chosen first and what would be the cost of that do you want to answer that yes I'll take it as I mentioned before out of the three projects the middle school was the most critical to address first the bottlenecks that are occurring in the cafeteria would not even allow um trailers to the point where that could help we are already planning 12 portable classroom uh trailers next year 10 for instructional and two for cardio labs uh the the P per pupil class numbers are also the highest in the middle school so that was

030the committee's recommendation and administrations to address first that was also the first one to come to fruition to be able to do because of the land coming into um view um we anticipate that soon the elementary school because of the redistricting that the district engaged in two years ago has leveled the load of students throughout the district in the northern area of town we're we're experiencing slightly declining enrollments and by changing the uh the borders through the redistricting it pulled a lot of students out of overcrowded schools and offered a lot of breathing room there we closely review the attendants and the teacher pupil ratios in the elementary schools regularly and we speak with the principes regularly and we believe that the elementary schools can handle their current capacities um and and manage for a

031couple of years in the future the high school has Believe It or Not the most flexibility because of the ability to schedule and um um course offerings I just had one followup what in terms of the date of the election for such an important election wouldn't it make more sense to have it in November since it's a governor's race and there'll be quite a few voters coming out number of Voters we know will be larger in the fall which would better serve the community and the voters than to have it in March there's a significant amount of preceding work and required submission of paperwork that precedes the election and uh the earliest that we could accomplish all of that and properly Market this uh referendum to the community so they fully understand this project as

032of this juncture is March I have a problem with that I would I would prefer seeing it held in November when is the the governor's race and all the other candidates can appreciate that but we would never be able to have all the required submissions in uh by November you mean this November yeah and it's also that the state only allows us to go out for a referendum I think there's only five dates throughout the whole year and I'm not sure if November is one of those dates I I don't have all of them with me because I know we can go out in September we can go out in December I think we can go out in um March and April and I'm not sure what the what the other date is so in

033order to go out for a certain date you need to have all the information about 6 months ahead of time to the DOA I was talking about November 2018 I don't know if we can wait another year and two months because at that every every year we go out so if we pass this now in March we probably won't have a school till 2021 but it would it would better serve the the public who who is actually making the decision on this yeah but I I know we need to have this sooner rather than later Madam yes to that point it it's imperative to know that the district is planning uh portable classroom trailers as I mentioned for the 1819 school year that's estimated to be at a cost of about $500,000 that money has

034to be budgeted in the general fund which right now is at cap so that means that that $500,000 is going to have to supplant current programs and instructions in the general fund in order to fit uh to delay any longer would require a much more extensive number of trailers at a significant cost and impact to the budget that's why it it really is imperative and we've mentioned this throughout the two years that we've been getting engaged in this Pro process that uh we get a referendum on as soon as possible and now that this land has come to a near fruition um March is the earliest date where we could do that we talking about six months thank you yes Mr Chella yeah is that me no I think it's me I uh I have

035a couple questions and then I just and then and then a statement I guess but um if the referendum doesn't pass in March what's with just doing the middle school not doing everything that we need and it doesn't pass in March are we then not able to go forward with a referendum in the future for the other projects because don't we have aren't we Bound by Statute with regards to a referendum and when they could be held and when we can go out again for a referendum well I'm sure Mr Gorski will uh check but I believe that if the referendum doesn't pass we can go out again for a for the same referendum a second time if it doesn't pass the second time the state can come in probably will come in find that

036there is a need for us to go out for the referendum because of the we're going to have a 3,000 unhoused students they will see that need for the 3,000 and require us to build the middle school I think then that at that point it would it would be smart for us to go out for everything that we need if that's the case then to peac mail it although I know why that makes sense because you'd want to you you know you want to make break it down into smaller uh chunks so that it's more palatable to the public and less of a burden but um in the long run if if for instance uh it didn't pass then we're going to be stuck with um having then to go to another referendum for that

037particular school and then if that doesn't work then we go to the state in the meantime we have nothing else going on in any of the other schools at least then we'd be able to solve all of the issues with growth at one point um my other issue with this uh thing at this point and I want to just preface this by saying that I absolutely agree that we need to build schools and we need to make room and the the uh building in this town is outrageous and we just keep on going and we've bent over backwards to allow the developers to do what they've done to this town with that being said we need to fix it right and we need to come up with Solutions but we don't have any information on

038this land we haven't been given uh any details as to what how much it's going to even cost uh we're told 2.5 million but we don't know that for sure we don't know because it's still in negotiations it could be whatever uh we don't know any of the details coming out of this thing including whether or not we're going going to have land and we're we're we're going out for a referendum for a school on a piece of property that we don't even own yet and we're it just it all just doesn't make sense to me I have no idea why we're doing any of this um except that maybe it's politically expedient um I have no I have no idea and I'm not I'm not saying that about anyone running on this board I'm

039saying that overall you know political expediency we're in an election year where the entire legislature the governor the council I think there are four seats up on the council are up it's an opportune time for them to uh make some deals and really make this look good which is why I think they've worked so hard to either have us do the 65 acres and when that didn't work out to do this and I'll tell you a couple things where I disagree one is on why it had nothing to do with turtles so 65 acres had nothing to do with Turtle studies and wetlands and things like that it absolutely had to do with the threat of a lawsuit and the fact that the Builder sold that land to the to the people there by saying

040that it would be open space forever and when you look at how cluster zoning is is is done in the in New Jersey the byproduct of cluster zoning is open space and that open space has to be used as open space you can't build on it here in Monro they've deviated from that in the state the precedent is you can't do that so in a court of law we would lose the state the township would lose and there would be no land that's why they mooved moved away from the land we have to get to my my whole problem with the whole process is somehow not dealing with the truth and all the facts so that's fact number one on that land fact number two is I'd love to see where the development slowed down

041because Mount Mills Road Route 33 everywhere I look there's trucks there's more development there's things going on it's going up faster than ever so I don't know where that came from or if that was some kind of you know thought up selling point but in my mind it's an insult to my intelligence and I think that it's an insult to our taxpayers so I'm going to vote no on this and that and these are the reasons why thank you thank you Mr Chella Miss armino yeah I I have to Echo some of Mr chel and Mr Russo's concerns um that I I see this uh language on number one I mean first of all I think all three of us recognize the need and of course the whole board and the and the administration and

042thank everybody for coming out I see full seat so I'm delighted that you're all here um but I the concern that I have is I've been here since 1980 I've watched a lot of this uh Construction in in spurts um and you know 15 years ago we were having this actual same conversation and my concern is in the particular resolution is which is anticipated to be donated to the Board of Education by Monroe Township I have heard this before I heard this 16 years ago um it doesn't always work out as we are told I sometimes think that the information is distilled to be palatable as Mr uh Chella has said and not by not by the board to tell you the truth I feel that the some of the information that we get because

043we are not experts um in uh land acquisition and uh building and uh you know we're getting to be experts in enrollment uh crises that we have but um the the the information for to allow us to make a decision that we are all responsible for making a multi-million dollar decision when we get information that is so distilled it makes it very difficult to make the right decision I have no problem making the right decision the problem is sometimes given the information and what we are told again not by our experts on this board but by experts that we are supposed to consider uh the difficulty is not M again not a problem to make the right decision to decide what the right decision actually is um I I have a logistical question can we

044separate on this resolution number one and number two I mean it seems that we would need number two to go forward but I certainly understand the need for getting our paperwork work um for a referendum and I could vote for number one the reason why I have a problem with number two is it is extremely vague it doesn't tell us what how much money is involved how much money will be going to soft um or secondary um vendors and things like that and you know we've already paid I think it was macter English that did project for church La I mean I was reluctant to spend I think it was what $30 million I was Rel 30,000 I'm sorry 30,000 excuse me lot of zero almost got us lot sorry we could have built our

045own School Mich okay so but even $330,000 because when it's taken away from the educational instruction of our students it's $30,000 that is displaced in my opinion not wasted because it's necessity but displaced and we were told that that was the perfect spot at the time and that the township was going to deliver that at the time so reluctantly I voted for it and I have to stand behind the vote but the problem is having the right information to make the right decision so to say that we are anticipating the land to be donated scares me um I also hear um that it's the perfect piece of land which it very well might be but once again I've heard that before and the $68 million projected is that um for all of the is that

046for just the building the physical building or is that for the ancillary um projects like for uh engineering and other things can someone answer that Madam doc um doctor I was going to give you a doctor tonight I'm the superintendent I've earned a doctorate degre a lot of jobs Mr G I'm sharking my way up um a point of clarification this 65 acres of land is still being pursued by the Board of Education correct it has a timetable of ownership and transfer very unfavorable to us it has other uh negative characteristics such as the road widening the utility Zone and hookup uh and the wetlands mitigation which are all very large costs for the project that we uh hoped which was a Elementary and a middle school on that property but the board of educ

047is still pursuing that for a long-term strategic option for down the road and we're talking well beyond 10 years from now yeah um and but let me let me stop you for the sake of brevity um we knew that going in we knew that when we agreed to the $30,000 so we knew that it was had difficulty we knew that there were some issues there might have been but we still pursued it because again it was the perfect land at the time so again I'm I'm really concerned about you know language um but if you you can answer the $68 million is that for all of the costs projected for all the costs for that construction Madam yes yes the $68 million estimate is all costs it is on a cost estimate form that was

048prepared by epic management uh along with efforts by Mr T and I and it is all costs uh for example what you call soft cost bonding legal fees um um Bond issuance costs Etc are estimated to be half of 1% of the total project costs that is customary and reasonable for an estimate I remind the board also that the number two on the agenda where I'm recommending to the board the law firm of mcarter and English LLP and Phoenix advisors as the financial advisor Bond Council and financial advisor resp itively uh those those that team of professionals mcarter and Phoenix have served this board very well very admirably and very coste efficiently over over the past 15 years they did all of the refundings and at this juncture it is necessary to have those firms

049approved I have proposals in my office where I could have put all of the costs in here it would have put a couple more more pages on this resolution and um and uh we can we can again go back to finance and disclose all of those costs until everybody's heart's content I'm very happy to do that but this appointment you know tonight I'm talking about the tax impact on the community I would not have that information if we didn't have a financial adviser it will kneecap Administration not to have those professionals engaged and they have a perfect track history of nothing but Ultra professional service at a very cost efficient price to the board but um you make a good point I was not available for the last Finance meeting so these costs were not

050specifically discussed in the last Finance commit they were not they were not okay that I think should have happened um this is a big number is does number two this this part of this resolution is there a t a price tag that we can anticipate on number two between as I as I said is part of the 1 half of 1% right now Michelle we're we're at Mrs Armano at the um cost estimate range and we are at the infancy of this project and the infancy of using the services from these professionals but uh but we're getting to a point now where we we are 100% relying upon them and need these Services um their fees have been approved by this board of education consistently over time again with all of the refundings that were

051approved where we save taxpayers millions of dollars over $9 million of Interest costs were saved on all of the refundings that I with this team of professionals that simply can't do alone because I'm not a bond counsel and I'm not a financial adviser there's a lot of specialty work with these two and and again with the track history here with the board I I assumed that the board would be comfortable continuing this relationship it is definitely to our advantage okay I I just personally I think it is my responsibility when I make a decision of this magnitude I would have liked to have had that I mean we we get uh the fin fincial information for this month I mean check Registries and I actually go through all that I would I would have have

052had appreciated that um detailed information uh regarding this if they've already sent it to you you know um if this goes through or if it doesn't go through I would ask that you would uh email it to me tomorrow may I recommend approve it as it is presented tonight and recommended by me and I will bring to finance committee the entire proposal for the board to go through and will precede any payment to these professionals if the board should so choose not to engage them in the future they will not get paid but but but with time is of the essence and um and and that would certainly stress this situation not to have these professionals engaged at this very late juncture to this critical need in the district and I remind the board that

053this Middle School land um which I discussed in detail has no substitute there is no plan B for the middle school if this referendum is not successful tonight there is no ability to build on existing schools you can't do that with something like a middle school and then the campus um um uh that we have now with the current high school and the current Middle School could not accommodate another middle school because it would provide for extreme congestion we looked at all of this information at the student growth advisory committee all of these ideas were explored and dismissed so so this is a very critical Junction tonight if this is not passed we have no plan B it will blow the March time table for the election it will exacerbate the need for trailers and

054programs and services currently enjoyed by parents and students and this community at large will be supplanted by trailer costs at the time that this high school was being built we had 89 portable classroom trailer units in this District at a at a least cost of $1.5 million a year plus other costs such as utility Staffing um that brought it over $2 million a year the board gained nothing from that it was not an investment it was a rental and and this this is an investment in your future it is is adding another critically needed school that quite frankly should have been pursued with a little more Vigor years ago but here we are yeah and uh and and actually no plan B if as you said there's no plan B and there's no suitable second

055option which terrifies me because we're still building so if there's no suitable second option now and if there's no other land and you know it's sort of a catch22 the more we build the more we need school property the more we build the less property we have available for the future so the district this the educational district is really in a quand and I I feel very disturbed by that and it's always a crisis that we have to make these decisions um so so this this not suitable second option is is you know I I think we have to also go forward and continue to look for more properties um you know again going back to the word anticipation we're anticipating this land to be donated and it better be or else obviously we're going

056to be really in big trouble we're anticip ating state aid and we haven't gotten that for 17 years any additional we got four what uh less than a half a million dollars and we're anticipating the land possibly in in Church Lane these are really big numbers for anticipation um Madam I I I wait and the current debt we have the current debt you can correct me if I'm wrong I think it's down to either 125 million or 130 million million currently we have as debt that's approximately correct right so then we're going to have 68 million and and I know we need it but I want the public to understand we already have a debt of aund and at least $125 million that we're paying what about3 million a month Madam yes uh we're paying

057currently about $6 million a year in principal that $130 million um obligation that's owed is long-term debt it's been refunded at the at at historic low interest rates and it's down significantly from where the district was years ago when we opened the high school and will will some of the projects be coming off the books as we go ahead with this yes as I mentioned we're paying off about about $6 million forward looking in the next couple years off of the amortization schedule it's about $6 million of principal per year and um and we're going to wrap the debt around as best as possible so yes our debt obligation is going down and uh the district can easily accommodate this on our debt borrowing capacity I just calculated and it's going to be presented in

058the in the next comprehensive annual financial report the new borrowing capacity for the school district is approximately $191 million so we're far below that and um the whole Debt Service budget is about $10 million a year we a young District we have a lot of uh bonds still um being paid off we have a lot of young schools just like this one uh we are experiencing a lot of growth right now and um and and and as as I mentioned before uh this was provided to the board multiple times this is a list of the 20 properties that we viewed colorcoded by their expectation of uh of meeting our needs and um there are very few um uh that that could be considered the one for the middle school this is unique there is no

059other one now I want to be clear too to Mr Cher Ella's point there are other options that the board can engage into which we don't have prepared administratively yet you could you could pursue an elementary school we would have to put together a cost estimate and see what that's involved would that be something that replaces appart school would that be additions to the current elementary schools we're not there yet because the focus that we've been test with has been the middle school again that's the most immediate need and and the high school is also in need but again if you ignore the most critical element of this being the Middle School you will be um not satisfying the the the blaring red light on this on this issue and and you will not have

060a solution and as many trailers as you could put there will not help with the middle school because of the infrastructure with lunches and everything else one I just want to finish one one more comment given given the experience we've had on Church Lane that may eventually that money will be well spent um do we have to in order to prepare for the bond spend this money that is uh put that is suggested in in the second part of this this resolution no okay no but I would like an authorization by the board to utilize these professionals or I feel as your business ad administrator I'm I'm I'm causing an encumbrance that I don't have the authority to satisfy the Board needs to commit to this project this is part of it there are you

061know respectfully you're you're uh certainly in the field of real estate and you understand the soft cost needed to purchase a home uh there's always closing costs that uh surprise a lot of folks uh in this instance here we have uh Financial cost and we need Bond counsel and we need the financial advisor and we need to begin working on that yesterday and that's why the this really needs to get approved tonight no expenditures will be made again until we go and present every fee with every proposal in finance and pass another more detailed resolution in the future but this at least authorizes us to begin um um working with them which without is going to compromise going forward with this I just had a hypothetical question um let's say the public votes down to

062referendums the state comes in would that in any way help us if we then wanted to sue the state for fa Fair funding Madam that's a very good question Mr Russo and U we we read a lot of of U of speculation recently uh on social media and things like that Freehold burrow had two referendum defeats the state came in and they looked at their enrollment information and they looked at their facilities and they saw the need and the state overrode the voters and approved it and uh because of the uh affluence or lack thereof of the community the state pitched in 85% of the project cost because the rateable base was not enough to support it in Monroe Township under that hypothetical situation we're hoping this is successful off the bat and we're going

063to make it so but if if under that scenario it's not it would go for a second election if that's not successful the state will come in they will review all the demographic reports and all the submissions and all and in the project itself and they may override to voters and say yes you've demonstrated a need here for thorough fion education you need this school we're going to approve it but in no circumstance will they pay for it in Monroe with our degree of affluence here by our very strong rable base and the and the average incomes as reported in aggregate by this community okay and the other thing was the cost of the extension on the high school you didn't give me the price of that we don't we don't have a definitive cost

064on the extension of the high school we don't we don't have a project scope for an elementary school because uh we've been going Full Tilt with the most immediate need which is the middle school and we have brought that to your um presentation tonight yes we will be coming back um uh in the future with a need to expand the elementary schools and uh in addition to the high school that was planned when this school opened this community has always approved referendums on an installment basis never prepaying for any available space before it's needed and um and uh you know we will have a need for those referendum uh in the future Mr Russo um at the board meeting in I guess it was August somebody had asked us about suing the state why don't

065we sue the state and I I mentioned at that time we have no basis to sue the state we're looking for a basis to sue the state and as of now maybe the public will help us it would be nice but we give our kids a thorough and efficient education and it's that quote thorough and efficient that the state looks at we're also above adequacy so they feel that they don't need to give us more than they've already given so while we'd like to sue the state we don't want to just use the taxpayer money when we know right now that there's probably not a basis to do that and that we would lose so I I think we are still doing our due diligence by looking into that area of sewing Mrs Lang thank

066you um so I I have just a couple questions I've learned I don't want to sound like a Debbie Downer but I've learned that our best laid plans of mice and men go Ary what happens if the land doesn't come through can we pull the referendum can we we what is that what is our next step if we we vote this tonight but for some reason some Act of God we don't get the land and we can't go forward thank you Patty you're welcome I'll be happy to take that I can attest that from my vantage point as as as well as um the boards Dr kak's that the township has every intention as they expressed to Kathy and I when we first humbly went and asked for their help to buy this land and

067donate it at no cost to the board to us um we also have been apprised of the negotiations and some specifics some specific last requests of the seller which I brought to the board's attention in and we had uh support from the board on that issue uh to use an analogy the negotiations on this land with the township and the seller I believe are on on the on the one or two yard line and are imminent for a settlement on negotiations and then if the township owns this land they've already communicated their intent of what to do with it in both Bond ordinances that they passed and we have a letter of intent from the township indicating that they are going to transfer it to the board of education at no cost I believe there

068is an extremely high probability that this will execute very quickly if in the hypothetical something goes wrong with the negotiations the township still has the right of eminent domain with the process so there still is a an option of of acquiring the land through that way the board has expressed their desire to do it through Fair negotiations processes and that is where it is um however even if under the hypothetical that wasn't to work for whatever reason uh then certainly uh the timetable could be delayed on the referendum or it could be pulled okay so my my other question is um I I really believe that we need to support the referendum I believe our role as Board of Ed members is to do what's in the best interest of our students and right now

069our Middle School is not in the best interest of our students and I think that it's very important that we move as quickly as we can but I am also greatly concerned that as the time goes by that it will be more expensive to do the addition on the high school and the additions on the elementary school if and and I'm I don't want to put negative out to the um the the cosmos but if we have to go if we have to redo it it doesn't go through the first time but we're ready then to add on and get the high schooling maybe that's a better CH a chunk you know is that something that we can look at into am I making sense yes Madam Madam to Mrs Lang's question if if the

070hypothetical that the um the middle school project was to be defeated in the referendum could the board double down then and add a very significant cost to the project with another school project with it and couple it to have two construction projects with the one referendum the answer to that certainly yes but I I would anticipate it would make the probability of success less okay thank you very much Mrs Lang when we when we put the referendum out for the high school the high school was defeated the first time it came back to the board so the board always has that opportunity to re-evaluate the plan either come up with the same plan come up with a new plan so it should and we hope it doesn't fail we can go back and look at

071that again Madam can I clarify something yes okay sure what plan did we come up with after that failed we we came up with the same plan to BU to build this school to yes because the first that was directed by the township wasn't it were weren't they big on that I I I don't recall them I I really don't like put being pushed into something and I really feel that I'm being pushed into this two years ago I suggested to Mike that we build a middle school where Apple goth is now put an addition on Oak Tree and finish this school we would have had the land a year ago we could have come to the public for referendum now you tell us we have to go through the township because we're not allowed

072to purchase property when I heard that you were we were we were looking at the golf property I spoke to Mr Gorski and I said can you manipulate the budget some way that we can write a check and take that property immediately as fast as we can get it and I think he said you had the money but you didn't say you'd write the check I contacted New Jersey school boards because I think they're the authority my answer to the question is could we purchase the property the answer was write the check so personally I'm not getting pushed into this I'm not for this project I think it's uh I don't I don't think it's in our best interest Madam a point of uh uh um clarification and addition to Mr Bran's uh comments U

073yes we certainly had those conversations and and I enjoy speaking with you on a host of different issues um and yes the board of education has right now 975,000 in a capital reserve account that was approved for projects in our 5-year facility plan but a Middle School on a golf property uh that could not have been anticipated years ago when that money was reserved was not part of uh what we went to the voters for for the use of that money so it's certainly possible that I could um transfer $2.5 million um into the capital reserve account and then put forth a question to the voters with a specific budget question that's going to look exactly like the referendum approving the money for the use for the uh for the purchase of the land um

074but that that that does not satisfy number one the safeguarding of this property which I have expressed to the boort repeatedly is extremely rare there is no other piece of land that we've identified in all of our searches and all of the realtor searches and all of the searches through the township engineer which would satisfy a middle school project a middle school project also couldn't be satisfied on Apple G's footprint that was studied and rejected by the student growth advisory committee and I have opinions that I've shared with the board from a Carter and English Bond Council on the acquisition of land process and what I stated before I I is represented in the letters in the ADV advice to the board that we cannot purchase land and I'll say this again except through voter

075approv approval either by putting it as a referendum question with the budget as a second question or by approving a referendum both of the with the budget I don't even want to talk about the impact that that would have on the school operations to put that much in into a school budget but it would not secure um ownership immediate ownership and possession of this land which if it's lost again I'm expressing uh concerned because there is no there is no option otherwise your middle school need which is the most emergent will be left and abandoned unsatisfied and I understand um you know the concern about being pushed we certainly weren't pushed we went to the township and and pleaded for their cooperation which we were gracefully granted and um and and we we desperately need

076this Middle School referendum project we need this to pass we need to show the voters of this community tonight that the board word is behind this project and and um and we will do everything humanly possible to make this successful and demonstrate to the taxpayers why it is their in best interest now to approve this Middle School referendum Mr Ryback uh just a couple of thoughts forgive me I'm having problem with asthma so it's a little hard for me but um you know expediency is is key here here uh we're sort of under the eightball unfortunately the way it turned out kids are coming because of all this development uh we need the right piece of property to build a school we have to build a school so we can educate these kids properly I

077don't think there's anybody on this board that disagrees with that and I don't think there's anybody in this board doesn't doesn't want to uh um spend money uh as frugally as possible uh nobody has a spend Thrift we're very aware of of tax dollars uh it's something that I think H has to be done now if we if we if the town does not um purchase this land and we have a letter from the mayor a letter of intent which certainly is very meaningful and and I personally appreciate that but if we if we uh if the town does not purchase this land somebody else will and where are we going to put a school where are we going to educate these kids that are coming we have develop Vel opers that are under no

078obligation to help the school system out with their developments because the state does not allow impact fees on Developers for schools to me that's ludicrous and I've challenged our uh legislators in Trenton to do something about that they also have to increase state aid realize that our taxpayers are over taxed here and doing everything they can to pay for a proper education for our students and they're getting it and we appreciate that but we are trying to be sensitive to them as well as the needs of the student this this state needs impact fees because developers can't keep building these projects without consideration for where these students would be going to school than thank you one more question misso um well you know Mr uh Rybeck thank you for that and I agree with you

079except that it's not as if the the uh the referendum does here doesn't talk about the uh municipality buying the land the ordinance has been signed and and read on the second reading in the township Council so they are moving ahead unless something changes with buying the land so that's really not the issue and I don't think it's the issue for if we had a deed tonight that said we had the land I would be happy to to sign off on this whole resolution but that that is sort of the Crux of the problem maybe I can do this when are we getting the land where we and when can we start building the the earliest we can start building that's information I think is critical to the we we talked about all of this

080in the timetable um uh intimately in closed session where I had those uh that that information readily but I will tell you that the First Step again is the township successful negotiations for the land that is imminent we believe that that closure will come soon by the way there is another offer on this property too secondly um the Board of Education once the township owns the land will engage in required Studies by the Department of Education for a school facility there is a host of different environmental and and and and different test that have to be performed and that will go over a period of months before we are satisfied once we are satisfied that that that uh can be owned and all the preliminary engineering work that we have has been a perfect green

081light on that issue and as a forecasted that it will be uh then it then the district can have the official recognition of acceptance of the deed from the township um you're probably talking um about nine months away if I recall what I presented to the board in close session however however to go for a referendum and to submit all the required paperwork to the Department of Education you don't have to have deed in hand you have to have the land identified and with the township holding the deed and through all of their Express intent through the two Bond ordinance that they passed and this letter of intent it is certainly reliable of the Board of Education to proceed with the referendum that way that land will be transferred to the Board of Education well

082this is the first time I'm hearing that there's another offer on it and that disturbs me because when when the township when when you Mr Gorski and Mr T identified that land as something the Board of Education might be interested in we did it in close session it was confidential there it was not brought out to the public and we could have negotiated and and maybe have been done with it once the township took over um interest in the land then it became uh everybody knew about it and everybody knew about all the details so it that disturbs me which which probably prompted somebody else to make an offer on the property which may raise the cost to the taxpayers whether it's from the school district or from the municipal budget um the fact that

083it was broadcasted I me when we held it close to our vest and tried to do the right thing and I believe me I'm in I'm all about transparency but in a negotiation system I definitely understand and the O open public uh meeting act says you know one of the things you can go into close session for is negotiations which I have would have been happy to keep that under wrap so this very thing wouldn't happen so my concern is somebody's going to get the benefit um they may get the benefit of this land and raise the stakes for the for the overall community and the and the school district I don't know if and and it you know might this might change my vote but I don't know if voting for this is going

084to preclude a second buyer from creating a real problem for both the municipal budget and the and the District budget and that's a shame I I it's it's been communicated to me uh the specifics of that other offer I do not believe it was from any uh suspect information leaked by the board um I could say that quite definitively not our board for sure no or the township on in this regard because of the specific nature of of of who's interested in the property um it will not cause the township to pay one nickel more for it than they would have through regular negotiations process that's that's we don't have anything in writing they don't have an intent so I don't see in from a real estate perspective how we can be guaranteed that Mr

085armo we have had Mr gski Dr kak and I we've had many conversations with them over the last last six or seven months they understand our need for the school and they also know that we're in a time crunch that we need to get this land ASAP in order to have a bond referendum going out in March um I I know that when we first started this process when Dr kosak came here we um they offered us the Church Road land we've had some issues with that weren't able to get that in a timely manner we still wouldn't able to get that so I know that it got to the point where the board had to go out and look for land on its own and I know that Mr Gorski and Mr tag identified

086pieces of land and then knocked on on people's doors for property this was the piece of property that was identified as the best plan for the for the Middle School um after Mike Mr Gorski looked at all the options for us to purchase it and we couldn't do that we reached out to the township they didn't come to us we went to them and they and they understood they had they didn't know that they knew that we were looking to build a school but they didn't they weren't involved in the property search they weren't involved in anything like that until we approached them and they they really got on board and thought it was a great idea to work with us as a shared services where they would purchase the land and give it to

087us and and that's where we are they know um because we've had recent conversations how desperate we are to get this going Mr Russo those two new things were introduced the emminent domain and this this potential buyer this other potential buyer so how do those things play out why why would we be talking about eminent domain and then another buyer the township has the option of eminent domain on the property meaning that if negotiations aren't successful it serves the public interest for the township to acquire this land and they'll get appraisals on the property which we've had two and then the sellers getting their own that's a third appraisal and then um it'll be determined what the what the price will be and then the township will get the land that way does this other

088buyer impact that the other the other the other interested party in the land is a religious organization uh it's it's not somebody looking to run up the price or do anything disingenuous here and it will not affect the price okay Mr Mayo can I say something um I understand everybody's concern about the growth we all have that concern I also understand you know the uncertainty of this but um I as a parent who had a kid in this school last year feel the need we we need to move forward with this I saw firsthand how crowded that school is and um my son's class had over 550 kids I think now they're closer to 600 um the hallways are crowded um my son had 30 kids in several of his classes um critical classes not

089you know specials and I can't imagine that school handling any more kids and personally I don't want to spend money on trailers for an unknown amount of time when that money could be better spent actually educating our children whereas we get a greater benefit of about having an actual new school built so um you know as a parent I feel for all the parents who have kids who have to deal with that overcrowding because it is it's a lot and um so that's why what I feel about it and I could say um since August 1st has been approximately 180 new students added to the district this year so we are growing we are growing at a fast rate and I know that um we wouldn't be just doing a middle school if we didn't

090feel that the the major need is at that middle school and it it doesn't just affect the students going it affects the parents going it affects the staff that are working in the middle school and I and I think sometimes we forget about them and and how they have to deal with the growth and and they have more students in their classes also but I I think it's important that we we expect if we pass this in Mar right if we pass it tonight have a referendum in March the school will not be available until 2021 by then we will have almost 3,000 unhoused students I and I I don't know as a board how we can justify doing that Madam yes two more seconds it's a very important to understand this this statistic currently

091we have, 1500 unhoused students in this District that's defined as students enrolled beyond the aggregate capacities of the school 1,500 unhoused students right now and the five-year projection is for an additional 1550 students that's 3,50 unhoused students in the next 5 years if the if the board does not step up and pass this resolution and and get us on the path to a referendum as I've mentioned and I mean this with the greatest respect we have no other plan B for the middle school because there is no other available land this is a very unique piece of land and you have no other option to vote no on this tonight we'll leave that undefined and have a problem on resolved where we've we've gone through Herculean efforts to find this land to come up with

092a means of ownership that's immediate and safeguards the property and pres and I've presented a a a a tax Schedule which shows it's certainly affordable anyone else from the board have any comments or questions like to clarify yes Dr kak yes thank you madam president uh Mr cheral I just want to clarify some a statement that I made earlier about the the construction slowing down uh I did hear that that there was some issue with the construction slowing down but I certainly don't have anything that I would consider factual uh and it was also based on my observations on 33 uh off of Applegarth on the um I guess that would be on the South Side uh you know or the west side you know i' I noticed that they started working out there and

093they seem to have not been working for the past maybe a couple months or so so not meant to take the wrong way and I certainly didn't mean to insult your intelligence or anyone else's uh with that statement apologies for that okay if there's no more com comments or comments or questions by members of the board I will open this up to the public so anyone from the public wishing to speak just to this resolution um please state your name and address for the record and we are we will adhere to our for minute time limit my name is Victor Cooper my address is 525 AB Abid Court in monmo Township I serve on as you know probably on the ad hoc committee along with other members of the board and the public and um

094I'm confused because we recommended I believe that three schools be taken care of an new elementary school was needed a middle school was needed and the expansion of this high school and this high school was built with the ability to expand it my question is this do we keep going back to the public for resolution after resolution after resolution asking them to approve the expenditures of multi-millions of dollars repeatedly over the next several years why couldn't we put at least the expansion of the high school and the middle school on one resolution I know you don't have land for the elementary school as as of yet but I don't understand why we don't have that both those both of those things on the resolution why do we have to wait for another one Mr Cooper

095a as we discussed there certainly is a need for a new Elementary School a new middle school and in addition to the high school to satisfy the growth in this district for the next 10-year period those three projects satisfy it for the next 10 years the first project to come to fruition where we could have acted upon it is the middle school that is the most blaring emergent need that's why that one is going first we don't have an immediate plan on how to address the uh uh Elementary School need it could be tearing down appleg school and building an elementary school there it could be something totally different like adding on to all the other elementaries and redistricting through the uh community and the high school also is a need but through uh scheduling

096flexibility we can uh probably hold on that one the longest so because the first one has come into view where we can actualize it now being the Middle School we're pushing that out immediately because we can't afford to wait and Bund f it with other projects as they uh meet uh the time uh come to fruition this one came together first and it was our recommendation to the board let's immediately go for this plus out of respect for this community they have always um appreciated approving referendums on installment basis is and not prepaying for growth we're very sensitive to the taxpayers here and uh by doing it on an installment basis it defers the princip for those other projects that can hold years out longer okay my concern is this the existing rate of growth

097is immense we know that there's not a heck of a lot more space to build non-ag restricted residential units however the the town is under the city mon Township is under a court ordered mandate to build affordable housing 800 units of affordable housing I believe that's the number for each affordable housing unit you you build you have to build three non-affordability recent demographic report which which is the basis for everything that I have presented tonight the affordable housing is not included in what you're talking about am I correct our projections include everything that is known and agreed to with the housing settlement yes it does it includes it does we we went over this it includes 3200 units yes it does yes okay yes the timer how much four minutes good evening uh Chrissy scurby

09821 pness Drive um I have to say I feel a little blindsided um being as involved as I've been for the last 10 years in this District I know the absolute need in all of our schools for more room um I've been coming to these meetings I've been a part of ad hoc committees I've been part of District education Council meetings um involved in the school on the PTO and this project has always been that we were going to add on to the high school we were going to build a middle school and we were going to build a new elementary school we sat here and we saw renderings of the high school edition how the school was going to lay out on Applegarth and the new Middle School like I said I feel very

099blindsided coming that the two big projects are being put on hold I don't know how you drive into Monroe Dr kak building has not ceased it has been going Full Speed Ahead all summer there are four or five units complete townhouse units already up on the corner of 33 in Applegarth and they are continuing to build those kids will be here quicker than we know it in my area Alone by the Colts run I counted this morning 30 elementary school kids getting on the bus those are new students into this District this year it is not slowing down for the elementary schools it is not slowing down in the high school yes do we need the Middle School absolutely we also need the addition to the high school now and we need another Elementary School

100now we cannot wait we cannot wait to see what happens with this project how many years down the road are we talking about addressing the high school it's at capacity ask any parent ask any student that comes through here it's at capacity here and it's at capacity at Oak tree and it's at capacity at Applegarth oh and one other thing if I have a second as a taxpayer I think we all have the right to know and I understand it's not the board purchasing it but we as the taxpayers of Monroe Township deserve to know the purchase price of the land because you keep saying that we're getting it for free no we're not we're paying through our taxes it's not coming in the Board of Ed budget it's coming in the municiple budget I'm

101a taxpayer how much money is being spent on this land nobody will answer it it's the Town Council won't answer it we're not hearing it here we're we're the taxpayers it's our money we deserve to know how much money the purchase price of that land is going to cost us before we even approve another 68 million for a middle school that's all right we should know we should have all of the facts in front of us as taxpayers and again Mrs armino you know me for years I've always been at this Podium yelling we need more room we need more schools I am absolutely for it but I think this project just having the middle school is absolutely wrong for our students and wrong for our district we need to have all three at once

102thank you thank [Applause] you hi I'm Misty Karo and I work in the district and I also live in the district I just have a quick question I've heard many many rumors about what the middle school is actually going to be is it going to be fifth and sixth grade a lower elementary and then keep the middle school now as 7eventh and eth or I don't is it going to be two middle schools I'm not sure of what the exact plan is I was just wondering Dr kosak yes thank you madam president uh yeah through the work with the student growth advisory committee and others the the idea is to have two middle schools to match the facilities and and the offerings so that they will be as equal as possible uh at both schools

103the gray configuration would still be six to eight at both middle schools in a very similar fashion to other uh townships or or districts near us uh that we checked two summers ago and we drove around and I talked to people on East Brunswick and South Brunswick and and not everybody did the 6 to8 configuration but that was the recommendation from everyone as well as my own experience that we keep it to be as equal as possible thank you sure good even everyone uh Andy poori 16 St James Street first of all I want to thank the board and the ad hoc committee for finance uh for getting the additional $458,000 to the township every penny helps and I commend the board and the adog committee members that are sitting here for doing that uh

104I agree with the sentiment that I I think Miss Lang said this at the uh outside of her speech that you folks are responsible for our children and I think you have a mandate to make sure that the kids are going into schools and getting decent education with trailers coming in and the numbers that Mr groski has put out there it's inconceivable to think that we pay close to 20 to 25 million, in in property taxes to send our KS uh kids to study in in trailers that's not acceptable um I have asked almost 10 months ago to this board to provide a list of what they anticipate the growth to be and what school system that that the growth will be encountered in and then plan accordingly I know I hear a lot about

105the the township building a lot lot going on and I agree that it's going on not that the planning board of the council wants to see this Township to be overcrowded but it's a mandate as Victor um mentioned earlier so we're trying to do the best we can to bring it down but I am not speaking as a a member of the planning board today uh I asked for those documents and I haven't seen it and also I see this uh deadline of only planning for 5 years and not beyond that as you have seen by the time the high school came online the high school was at capacity right now so it's my understanding based on some of the meetings that I have attended in the past that the middle school is going to

106be built for 30 classrooms to accommodate thousand kids and if that's correct then we automatically are getting into a situation where you're going to have 30 plus students in each of the class classroom so I would like to get a clarification on that and this is the thing that bothers me the most the last point I heard a lot of testimony from the members of the board with the acronym using I I I it doesn't matter who you are it is we the township that needs this to be happening and I want to make sure that you put your egos on the side and make sure you do the right thing for the kids of Mand Township thank you madam board president if I made just have a moment to talk about two quick things

107that that have come up from both the uh speakers the township by buying this property on behalf of the Board of Education will save taxpayers money by issuing notes instead of school district longer term bonds for the uh the uh the purchase so it is actually a coste effective means of doing it the bond ordinance calls for up to $2.5 million and we don't know what the actual price will be because like said repeatedly it's still being negotiated and it is it is expected to be resolved imminently as soon as it is it will be public information and and and regarding uh Mr Poor's um uh request um from the the board's demographic study there is anticipated to be 2,000 middle school students in the district in 10 years time so like I said this

108project will satisfy the board for the next decade and as Dr kak indicated by equally splitting the load between the two schools it's also been that when we build a school and we we go we start the process the state only allowed us to look into the future five years so when we built the school and the school opens it's that 5-year period we're always at capacity because the state won't look at won't let us look six years or 10 years down the road they only say five so right now if we start today and we've passed a referendum there's your fiveyear window is 2023 if we open a school in 2021 or 2022 we're almost at capacity which is what happened with oak tree school and what happened with the high school um unfortunately

109that is um a a state mandate it's not something board has been able to control over those years um the next speaker uh Peter to fin out 10 Katherine Street uh you had stated that the state came and enforced uh free hole to build a a school and paid uh I think you said 85% of the cost and that we wouldn't receive 85% of the cost to us because we're an affluent neighborhood I'm not part of that affluent neighborhood but anyway um do you have an estimate on what they would pay towards that do you have an cost yeah okay yep as I stated before under the hypothetical that the referendum loses twice and then the state comes in to make the determination if it's needed for thorough and efficient education I am most confident

110that the state would contribute zero to that project Monroe is not freeold burrow and I'm speaking at the township and aggregate by these figures as presented in the aggregate numbers from the New Jersey 1040s and also the rable base in town which is very supportive of of of uh the the um adequacy budget here in town which is why we get no Equalization Aid the state considers us an affluent district and again I'm not speaking to you specifically but this is an affluent school district and I am most confident to say that if the referendum went down twice and the state came in they would probably approve it because would demonstrate the need but they would not give you any money in my opinion okay the second part of my question is once the state

111comes in and demands that we build another school and they sell your golf course before this all happens where are they going to force us to put the school if there's no land available if if the township owns the land then it will be safeguarded which was one of the uh main considerations from the Inception here my my question is if the township doesn't acquire this land and the religious group that you said is in competition with it buys it from underneath the town with eminent domain at their disposal the township will secure and purchase this land so no matter what the Township's getting this land is what you're telling me the township is purchasing this land with the intent to transfer to the board of education for the construction of a new Middle School

112that was in their bond ordinance twice and that's in their opinion uh so they're definitely buying the land to give to the no matter what even if you say even if everybody in the town says we don't want the Board of Education to take this land and build another school on it they're still going to buy the land yes okay thank you prakash pup 33 Dana Drive you know we have been coming here I have been coming here for one year I've been seeing all the things drama going on I've seen that 18 sites were evaluated and when we went to the council meeting people came and asked several questions they said the board of education has special adoc committee they're looking into different sites and they have selected this site so go and ask

113questions to them so I came last four months saw that the builders came in they showed the plan for the expansion of the high school how we'll have Elementary School no one talked about kindergarten there are a lot of young families here they need even kindergarten and they've talked about kindergarten and today I was surprised to see the agenda only focusing on the middle school I respect everyone so my request is don't keep us in the dark if that that is the projection come ahead and say this is the projection we are concentrating on the middle school then we have a plan like to know when we are thinking of high school elementary school and kindergarten don't tell us that state tells only five years who cares about the state we have we have elected

114you you think on longterm don't worry about the state let us think on long term the people are frustrated here why everyone is here because their children need good school we have a good school even the high school today lunchtime do students are crowded we know that we need expansion of the high school we need elementary school so you are put today on the spot we have to vote for the referendum because our children in Middle School are the high priority so let us vote for the referendum move forward and let us we put pressure on board of education to tell us in the next meeting what are the plans for the high school what are the plans for the elementary school and kindergarten okay but let us not Kick the Can again here okay

115take a decision always you'll not have 100% facts coming in that is the decision you have to take and there'll be always a 5% uncertainty your intelligence you have to use here you the board members to decide and take a decision so I say that please today move forward with the referendum provided a request that in the next meeting we have some plans for the other high school and everything else thank you thank you hi my name is Katherine Crowley move the mic sorry my name is kathern Crowley and I live at 56 Spruce Meadows Drive I have been hearing that I know that we are only or the state only allows us to project 5 years is there no exception to that rule is there any way to apply for that rule Madam Madam

116to the L's uh question and to the comments before our demographic reports here indicate extreme pressure Beyond five years 10 15 years of pressure Mr T and I went down to uh the Department of Education officials and the construction department and we presented our argument that we have to look Beyond five years for this particular project project that the uh the enrollment projections up through five don't do justice and they as Mrs kapano said uh although they've limited us to that in the past we need an exception here and uh they said that they would consider our request favorably and let us know um we we both left there feeling optimistic that we might get an exception on that uh five-year limitation of considering enrollment information coupled with a referendum project so that is in

117the works right now hopefully is is that what I just and that would would qualify us for more qualified costs um with the middle school project um and would subject the district to more Debt Service Aid it's very important and I was negligent and and and speaking to this point before in the in that tax projection is uh a calculation for Debt Service Aid School District receives two types of aid general fund Aid which we get very little $400 a pupil but they do give us a standard amount for principal and interest on our outstanding debt every year subject to State appropriation in their budget and we will get an eligibility for Debt Service Aid with these Middle School bonds that we're anticipating selling that will reduce the tax burden to the figure that I

118gave out before so the projections on the middle school that you just that you talked about is that only four or fiveyear projection or is there a second projection for 10 years that's there we have we have out to a 30-year projection oh I see the most impactful growth is going to occur in the next five years okay that is when the strongest Spike of growth occurs and then it's consistent and level through the remaining years and just one more so am I given to understand that over the course of the next five years you're expecting another 1550 new students that is based on the development I see going around here already Yes yes yeah that doesn't sound like enough it really doesn't it's oh I mean we we went through this when we did

119the redistricting they told us that the that the development over on Mount Mills was going to produce what was it something like 70 students out of 400 and something units which was a crazy number so what tell what demographics is different now I mean like if I could um so some of the projections that you're referencing occurred before I was here I think in a previous uh uh you know referendum so when the de demographer worked or we worked with the demographer we made it a point to really go back double and triple check the numbers uh go back and make sure that it's accurate Mr T Dr Ali myself Mr Gori we looked at this over and over again and the demographer came back with many different drafts and we really did project out

120to that 30-year period which again is why if there's other land like that 65 acres it's good for any given School District in an area of growth to have something available for the future now as Mr Gori Gorski stated most of the growth based on the demographers reports and as you can see going on yes I I'm very well aware of the building and the mounts Mills I drive by it as often as possible and certainly 33 I drive by every single day um I'm aware of that but uh affordable housing other type of things that may occur down further down the line uh the district needs to be prepared for that so using the demographic report we're looking at most of the growth within the next five years but we're also looking at that

1215 to 10 year range and then 10 up to 30 years understanding that once you get past 5 to 10 years the best demographer will tell you that you know they there's too many other factors that could influence it there's the economy there's different um elections both at the presidential on the the state level there's so many different things that could impact housing crisis there's so many different things that could impact it but we feel very confident with the approvals that have been granted by the township that developments that are taking place now and developments that may you know be expanded or take place in the future that that this will accommodate that um you know for the next five to 10 years okay well thank you thank you four and just keep it running

122hi good evening my name is Chand Muka I live 13 Edington Lane I have a quick question I uh understand that the state might not help with the project uh uh budget but I did read that state might uh increase the school aid and I'm hoping that's different from the project analysis you guys were talking about and if it if we are in favor of getting the school uh increase in school aid when would that happen would it happen this current year when would we know the decision from the state well we we created a a an AOG committee on Fair funding and we spent the whole spring fighting for or share of fair funding and the we were awarded by the state an additional $458,000 we already got and I believe we're going to

123be getting that for the next five years we don't believe it's enough and we are still fighting for more money because we we it with the additional 4 and what was it 458,000 it still didn't bring us up to where we should be so we would at least like to be where where we were years ago when they took all the money away from us so that that um would be in addition to our operating budget had nothing to do with a referendum So when you say it would be awarded to us for next 5 years can we recontest the amount that they awarded us are we we cannot do it until the next 5 years no we could if it's $458,000 every year um we can decide what to do with that money this

124year we we decided as a unanimously the board gave it back to the taxpayers in tax relief no I think um sorry you misunderstood my question so we don't think $458,000 was n in8 increase can we recontest that next year with the state or do we have to wait five years M Madam if I may um to to the L's question uh we're hearing that uh from State officials uh from our local legislators that the uh the picture for state aid will be better for Monroe in the future than it has been in the past few years I believe that to be true it can't get any worse and the and the and yes the 458 the 458,000 was based upon a a 10% number of our amount underfunded from the state formula the state

125calculates what we should get under the school funding Reform Act of 2008 that amount less what we were actually receiving they gave us 10% which was approximately that 458,000 we will be at the Forefront of of of pushing the state to understand Monroe's inequity and state funding going forward and we'll do everything we can uh to maximize our our award that's humanly possible and one last thing I would Echo with everybody's sentiments today who said yes middle school project is important so we need to put more focus on it but I think we shouldn't delay when bringing up uh adding a new high school and uh sorry adding extension to high school and uh Elementary School rather than waiting uh I we should start planning and do all the preliminary work that is done and

126when it is being done I don't think we should be in a place where we are today with middle school where you have only one choice for the land I just hope that the planning would be better for whatever we need to do for the high school and the elementary that we at least have multiple options available for whatever uh we need to decide on and you're not uh pressurized just to look at that one option and then see there is no plan B what is our next step wait for two more years no so I just hope there would be a better planning and speed increase the speed on how we are planning it thank you than you good evening uh RAM ragat 6 ens strive mandro um it's uh I think it's few

127chrisy scurby and few other members um the community has mentioned it's a little frustrating right I've also been attending the meetings the last I don't know probably a year and a half where so much effort was uh spent discussing the need for both the elementary school the middle school the high school extension um you know and of course the the town I think on the wild good Chase with the whole Church Street property and and so on and so forth so while we talk about 10e projection and so on I think we know the fiveyear projections we know we have problems in all the three schools right so yet we are saying that from now to March we're going to be yes we're going to be doing some activity but March is when the referendum

128thing or the special election will take place potentially construction will start 2021 this brand new middle school will be in place but then what about the elementary school and high school uh right uh is nothing going to happen uh it's not like we have pressure 5 years out we have the pressure now uh you know my kids are in elementary and middle school I see the pressure and I just feel that we are punting the ball further I'm very concerned is it just because of the again election year this November why conveniently a March timing is happening uh for this uh referendum uh and also this whole figure as you mentioned $40 per year for 100,000 of uh SS value which is let's say it's a half a million house you're talking about $200 more

129but shouldn't you be actually as the board be responsible and be able to really estimate the cost of all three the middle Elementary and high school what is that amount it's whatever 68 million plus plus plus and then what is their impact on the taxes and so on and you tranch it out is a tranch a that you're going in March but at least have that full tranch a tranch b Tran C what is that total cost the other thing is we said we have an excellent Bond rating the interest rate is at the lowest and we know that interest rate is predicted to start to shoot up inflation is going to go up right and we know we have to build these things ultimately the taxpayers are going to be taking on a significantly

130higher burden uh right uh uh because of the higher cost of constructions and land purchase and so on so how do you kind of take all that together uh so that you can one inform the community but as a board take a really holistic set of actions and the last piece I want to say is that I think you guys are giving a pass to the township um the mayor and the township Administration in fact you guys should be drafting a memo chiding them for having the taken you guys off track and really not supported you in your objectives right I hope the board will be bold enough to actually uh put out such a statement you know uh Ching the administration and uh and really showing that this board is truly independent and separate

131of the political process thank you madam Madam I appreciate the certainly appreciate the gentleman's comments um they were very well stated and well thought out administ a um and the board have discussed this three combined projects in detail and like I said the middle school has come to fruition first where we can get that immediately out um we could have held that and coupled it with designs for the other projects yes the design for an expansion to the high school exists the elementary school one option was discussed and presented but there are numerous that could be less costly that haven't been fully explored yet the question is you know understanding probabilities and statistics and particularly the past election success or lack thereof that the board of education has had with the budgets when we had

132an election on the budget we've had numerous defeats in a row um consecutively with overwhelming numbers against and that's the annual school budget what is the probability of success of coupling almost a $69 million middle school with an ex an addition to this high school that could be in the $60 million range and a new Elementary which is undefined you could be looking at a total combined project somewhere between 160 and $190 million now I recommended to this board not to be that aggressive and take that low chance that that will be successful because if you were to go out for all three projects at once and it was to fail you have no option of rebundling or doing anything else you would have to go a second time then the state would come in

133and they would reveiew your data it would be five years before the state even comes in to make a determination on what you have to do um approving or not approving some of the projects it will be not your will as taxpayers what you're getting approved with but that of the state bureaucrats in Trenton who determine what you're going to get and and it is in my opinion irresponsible to risk that much that long when we could take a higher probability Road of success by going for the middle school first and we're not talking about a long delay before uh the elementary and the uh addition to the high school is is presented to the taxpayers that could be out as ear we haven't discussed this as a board yet but certainly that could be

134put together in a year's time or less even so you're looking at it again I use the word installment basis going for the most immediate needed first the one that's come to fruition first the one that we understand and have to find the best the one where we have mapped out and secured the land which is critical to this Middle School piece and then immediately come up and refine what's going to happen with the elementary need as I said the the the high school part is pretty much to find and then and then tackle those separately but at least then we will hopefully have a shovel in the ground here and begin work as opposed to risking it all okay uh yeah thank you I know I'm running out of time but my thing is

135you know I I just want to make sure things are not positioned because of political convenience right it's it's one having the public know what that true figure is going to be and then trch it out and then in chunks uh in a digestible chunks going after it people don't know that full figure and I think by not having that full figure being discussed now I think you're giving a pass to the current Administration uh uh and even the past administrations for that matter right so I think in the urge of transparency and full ultimately I feel is this approach is going to cost more for the taxpayers uh right so it's it's important that you be as transparent and and really independent of the town as Board of Education share that information to the

136public so we can make some good decisions in the way thank you thank you Krishna 11 Jak place um the comment I have to make is that we need to have this memorandum passed today for middle school I'll take whatever comes my way um I agree that we need a high school and we also need an elementary school but if it is Middle School is up for or um you know we can start our work on middle school I'll take that but my concern is for the next it would probably take four years for the Middle School to come up and we would be going through um the numbers around 2,000 or 2,500 um onh house students and we would be having trailers for the next 5 years till the school comes up um so

137it is very imperative that we pass this and start work on the middle school as soon as we can and U at the next Board of Board of Education meeting or the uh couple of uh meetings down the lane we need to have an plan for high school and we need to have a plan for elementary school thank you thank you do you think it's for either you or I okay Miss let me just see if there's anybody else from the public wish and then I can close the public for is there anybody else from the public wishing to speak on the resolution uh good evening my name is Donald isacson 39 Lake Hurst and I represent a sizable community that not here that's the active adult community that because of the expenditures of the

138school on the schools are going to be forced out of this town uh I understand you can't do anything about it especially when I hear that the board says they're going hopefully they're going to get more money well hopefully uh you know uh the Giants are going to win the Super Bowl uh hopefully but you don't seem to have a concrete I know your your your uh main thrust is how to run the schools but your other main thrust is how to fund that and just hoping uh that we're going to get the money from the legislature it's the uh the courts that made these rulings uh that we are so underfunded and if you don't go back to the courts and do something it's not going to be changed hoping is not going to

139do it I think it's wonderful you got $450,000 which every taxpayer will get I guess 11 or 12 and it's uh it makes them feel better but that is really literally A Drop In The Bu bucket and you've got to seriously get into a plan to get more funding for this District thank you anyone else from the public okay seeing no one in the public I will close public forum and uh Miss Armenia you had a question material fact that one of the members of the public asked for how uh the projection uh the enrollment projection was determined um I I think it would again when we had distilled information from the Builder and the planning uh in front of the planning boards and the zoning boards when the Mount smill Project said they were

140only going to be 90 children coming out of a 570 something project uh Mr Rybeck uh as a c as a concerned Citizen and actually Mr Cooper uh got together a Grassroots organization called card citizens about responsible development and they actually went to the blowstein School of Business and talked to the gentleman who made the formula and he actually said that that formula was obsolete Mr Rybeck and the organization brought it back to the township Council uh and I think Mr Gorski can attest to this we were held to a two uh with the they they went they did projections based on 2000 the year 2000 census when it was already after 2010 senses and Mr Gorski had no choice but to use the projections cuz that and I and and I don't remember the

141date you said it but you said it at an open meeting that the um Ruckers me the that the Ruckers that the Rucker formula was the only thing that the state would recognize so congratulations to our Grassroots people and Mr Rybeck especially who brought that to the attention of the township brought it to uh Mr Gorski and they were they were material in changing the formula to make it more accurate so we can make better decision so kudos to Grassroots and and to Mr Rybeck thank you very much and that's the that's the kind of thing we need thank you okay is there any other comments or questions from the board of education then at this time we will have a roll call on the resolution authorizing a special election okay this is the resolution

142authorizing a special election for a Monroe Township Middle School also appointing M Carter and English Bond Council and Phoenix advisor's financial adviser and a resolution shall take effect immediately moved by Mr Ryback seconded by Mrs Lang Jamesburg representative is not eligible to vote on this project um as it's a statutory requirements don't meet it there are nine eligible voter uh uh members of the Board of Education it would need a simple majority five out of nine in order to pass however as I stated before Dr kak and and Dr Alvi and I on behalf of Mr T we're very optimistic that we have the support of the full board behind this resolution that we will be going to the taxpayers and asking for a lot of money for we've we've certainly done our due diligence

143here we provided an immense amount of information warranting this project we' talked about the precarious nature of what happens if this is not successful and I will take a vote at this time Mrs armeno okay because I can't help myself I'm just goingon to make a few comments um I thank the Board of Education members for doing a very good job of deliberating in public which has not been done you know this board has been very good at that so I I realize it's sometimes tedious and repetitive but these are tens of millions of dollars that we're making decisions on and I thank the public for their Indulgence and the board members for their deliberations I will Vote for This referendum despite my concerns I have concerns about the timing I have concerns about the

144conveyance of the land and the unanticipated costs I I will be account and I am saying I because I know I am accountable for my vote but I also will hold the township councel for accurate information and I will hold the professionals that I relied on for this information um I will hold them accountable for that information if what has been stated tonight doesn't go through uh because it is important that we get our educational system uh going forward and our children a house properly so um I have two I will say yes but tomorrow after this vote we better start looking for land for the rest of our projects and one last comment if the state allows construction if the state allows construction projects for only five years the state should then elimate the

145runaway building for only five years too so we can catch our breath thank you that's recorded as a yes Mrs Aro thank you we kind of we kind of forgot no I want this in the record the whole thing not just the yes Mr Braverman like uh M armeno I would make a comment as well I know we need we need the space for kids I know that I'm just opposed to this particular project so I'm voting no thank you sir Mr cherella okay no without the High School addition added to it no without the elementary school added to it no without any details and no because March is a time of the year with when a significant portion of our population is in other states and that's wrong and so without any of that

146information I have to vote no on this thank you sir Mrs Deo yes Mrs Lang I'm going to join the party I I vote Yes I also want to say say that I really hope that we take the um Public's comments and we put start right away to build because we really should have had a referendum that had all of our needs met in my opinion and I think it's very important that we get our middle school students needs met but I really hope that starting next month we can start addressing the Public's concern about how we are going to address that further growth feed but yes I vote yes thank you ma'am Mr Rybeck I'll just add that I think we heard some very wonderful uh comments from uh board members as well as

147the public and I think it's important for us to uh take this into consideration I will vote Yes on this and and and hope that uh these suggestions will be uh taken seriously and I know they will be and that's recorded as a yes Mr so Madame board president may I have the microphone back please Mr Russo I'm going to vote no as I stated earlier I think it's unfair to all the voters in U in the town uh not to hold this um election when when U this referendum when most of them are here um another thing is regarding the um the survey are looking out we're only allowed to look out five years um that's been the issue for some time uh has our Senator or Representatives ever looked into to helping us

148with that to change that uh we're we're madam we're taking a vote at this time uh deliberation on the issue has ended no thank you sir uh as a formality I still have to ask Mr rutsky for his vote where I expect an exstension that's so painful um but yes according to that I abstain thank you sir and Mrs kapano I think this has been the longest roll call ever um and I would like to just um say also that we we need I'm going to vote Yes on this because we need to get started on the middle school but I also see the need that we need to and we've said this before we have three projects we need to go with three projects but we need to start and I it's not going

149to be something that we can come up with next month to have an an answer for you but I hope that we will be able to do that in the near future so I'm going to vote Yes on this [Applause] resolution thank you Madame board president and thank you to all the members of the Board of Education and the public who spoke on this issue uh the motion has passed an [Applause] Administration Administration is now tasked by making certain that number one the township negotiates to a a res a conclusion on the procurement of this land and the and the purchase price will be uh public information number two that it is then transferred to the board of education for the purpose of a middle school and number three that all EXP expenditures for this

150project are are most efficiently engaged which I think the board has come to expect of us and that uh we will create as much Surplus to return to the taxpayers from this project as possible Mr T has a track record with this District of providing only the best construction management of all of the projects I remind you that this High School referendum had $9 million of taxpayers of of dollars returned to the taxpayers oak tree school also came in all projects came in on time and under under budget and this will be another proud example of that once we're finished no no pressure Mr T but uh you know just no pressure pressure is the meeting over it seems I think we're just getting started here okay thank you very much for the support on

151this it's it's what I feel is best for children that we're going to be doing this so at this time we're going to um student board members reports and we have a new student board member and I'm going to ask you to please give us your name because I don't want to mess it up slowly hi I'm sria M poly okay we can't hear you shria yeah mamila poly correct oh I feel good so we'd like to welcome you to the board of education and we'd like to tell you I'm sorry oh we can help that that not all of our meetings are this much fun or this long so welcome I'm sure that this is going to be a great learning experience and when your other half comes back you be able to work

152together and I'm sure this is going to be a wonderful opportunity for you thank you so I don't know if you have any reports for us at this time or we're going to hold off until okay we'll hold off until October thank you thank you welcome somebody needs to make a a motion for recess okay I make a motion for a two-minute recess no we have about five about five minute recess so that we can just yes you know I would second that second you can I can do that all in favor opposed okay all right so at this at this time we will take a five minute recess it's 9:17 thank you okay at at this point at this time the board will come back into public session and we're going to number nine

153on the agenda committee reports are there any committees that need to report this evening Miss Deo I do yes the curriculum committee met today at 5:30 we reviewed 11 documents Mathematics grade 1 5 and 7 science grade 28 French Three French three honor American studies language arts and language arts honors um the math curriculum is the connected math program and it focuses on investigating investigations we are not teaching straight math anymore we are using math and we're teaching it in applicable world problems um and kids are learning why particular formula is the way it is they're not just learning how to plug numbers in it's getting them to think out of the box and a lot of these concepts are also pre-algebra Concepts Science 2 and8 we um are in the Next Generation science and

154if anybody's interested in learning about our science standards you can go to NextGen science.org the focus is on the natural phenomenon in the world around us and finding evidence um to support claims it's a more complex way to teach science and it's just not about getting the correct answer it's really about understanding how things happen and how to get to the right answer um um French three and French three honors is Project based learning it's a more application of the language it's not just learning the different tenses and how to spell it's really learning about how to communicate in the real world um and it's about being a participatory speaker American studies is an Ela class and it its focus is on um The Chronic the chronological growth of democracy and it starts with the

155birth of this nation and it looks at the Constitution historical speeches it looks at Wars and it ends at the Progressive Movement which is about um and that is I lost my notes for the ELA ones so I'm going to end there it was a very nice discussion and I have to say it's really a pleasure to work with the um the heads of the these um supervisors supervisors thank you um you know cuz Sue Gasco gets very excited when she talks about math and it's really nice to see her enthusiasm so love being on the curriculum committee thank you anyone else have a committee report Mr rutsky I'll go ahead and address the finance gets to speak tonight any notes yeah everybody left and now I get to speak um and that's probably best

156seriously so the finance committee met and by the way the notes are up on Google Docs uh on in the library for everybody to review if as they wish um we did review the adult education program and Maria uh Nori came in she's the director of adult education and she presented us with her thoughts of how the program is functioning and or why the program is not functioning as well as we would like because I guess this review started before me um two years ago and the program lost just under 34,000 so there were some recommendations made and um there was talk of trying to cut the loss in half and last year unfortunately that loss came in exactly just under 34,000 once again um and that was with reducing costs but also reducing revenues

157unfortunately by 17% so we're just seeing less of an interest in the adult education program So What We the finance committee decided to do was we're committed to continuing this current 171 18 school year continue operations for the fall and then the spring um but we did ask Miss Namek to once again go back and revisit some ideas of Partnerships with other entities and advertising maybe differently and distributing the program differently all of which is on the table and she's going to um work on all that and then possibly come back to the committee in the future with an update um we'd all I think the finance committee felt strongly we'd love to see it succeed and be more effective for the community but there's a lot of competition out there and it it's just

158becoming a more difficult task so we'll see how this year goes we also went on to continue our discussion of of appropriation of the Falcon care ECE Surplus if you remember um those were nicely profitable for the last school year where we brought in about $600,000 of new profit to bring the total uh Monies to about 1.1 million and What We the finance committee discussed and decided to do was leave $500,000 in that Surplus but peel off 600,000 and of that retained earnings and shifted in the budget over to cover the expense of the trailers for next year um it's a nice line item shift of one profitable entity being able to take care of and cover an expense that we're we're we're looking at and and basically covered in whole and what we did

159decide is roughly 600,000 is what we're comfortable with if in fact the trailer costs come in with a lesser amount Mr Gorski will ask the board attorney to write a resolution to be forwarded to the committee members and will bring back um any excess monies back into that Surplus so that concludes the finance committee notes one question thank you Mr Armenia go ahead M Mr ruty um I was like I said I was unable to attend the committee meetings this month um you know what I realized we didn't do in August and I was wondering if you discussed it in finance we didn't have a budget philosophy we did not discuss that yeah and we didn't discuss it are we going to address that at some point in the near future I think the budget

160season hasn't started yet so we should but we always did it in August so we're that I'm just asking about the time we did it like in September so we'll probably do it soon Madam um to miss arminio's point it was recommended by uh prior board president Mr NOS prior board member Mr nosin chair of the finance committee excuse me that um it's really fruitless to have a um a budget philosophy meeting without the Surplus number being confirmed by the auditor I just got that I'm going to release it immediately and we will plan for a budget philosophy meeting because that's an intrical part thank you Mr Ry good point and you like that answer right that was good Mr and thank you Mr Gorski there you go any other committee reports Mr Chella I

161um I just have a report on the uh on our Fair funding ad hoc committee um and if I could if uh if you'll entertain it if not then we can wait till the public portion but I'd like for after I read this I'd like for uh Mr Mr Cooper to be able to say a couple words on what the followup to this yes I'll let that happen What did what I have here is our committee met uh probably about three weeks ago and we came up with some ideas on how we would proceed with uh going after more you know more funding U but one of the things that we talked about was writing a letter to our legislators letting them know that although we were grateful for the $48,900 um that it's nowhere

162near what we need and that um we need them to act we can't wait years and years for them to make good on the funding formula or to fund the funding formula and we can't just sit here and hope that after November they'll do the right thing politicians have a way of not doing the right thing after they're reelected that's just the way it is that's the way it works so um we want to make sure that we're holding them to their promise and so we want I want to read this letter into the record and then have uh if everyone agrees I'd like to have that adopted um I don't know if I need to make a motion for that or not but you you would all right then I'm going to make a

163motion that this be accepted uh and then it could be you know signed by the by you or by the Board of Ed but this is I want to read this in if I may okay so it says Dear Senator Greenstein assemblyman D'Angelo and assemblyman Benson with the greatest respect the fair funding Committee created by the Monro Township Board of Education is hereby writing this letter to you to express that while grateful that we received an addition add $58,900 we still find this sum to be woefully inadequate furthermore we are requesting that the iniquity and funding be remedied prior to November prior to the November election our district cannot wait years for the school funding formula to be fixed or funded our taxpayers send upwards of $40 million to Trenton annually and we get back

164about 10% of that amount our committee along with many many members of our community took part in signing the funding petition Tes ifying before the assembly and Senate budget committees in Trenton and we've been working tirelessly to ensure that we receive our fair share of school funding we are not satisfied with the outcome and implore you to move prior to November to secure a funding formula fix our taxpayers can no longer shoulder the burden of self-funding the school district which is Laden with regulations and unfunded state and federal mandates that's that and I second it was it seconded no well Mr you moved it right and you read it so now we can use a second I'd second it Miss second by Miss armeno so is there any comments or questions by the board what

165are we voting on we're going to vote on supporting Mr tiel's letter to the senator and the assemblymen uh okay I mean it just sounds a little like it is um a thank you note in a way I know you you were against it but the opening line does I know you want to be politically correct in that sense and be polite but I think it was was kind of a slap in the face actually because she stood here before all of us and she really led us to believe that we were talking somewhere in the millions true anybody can deny that and she even went as far as to say there was money in the accounts that can be moved I mean she did the whole sales pitch true but I do think that

166we should be grateful for anything we get and fight for more because I I don't believe we got what we should be getting but I think we should as a a board be grateful for whatever we get and keep going yeah there was something interesting though that one of the things is uh yeah we should be grateful for whatever we get and the formula needs to be addressed but this fiveyear forecasting thing I think it's maybe something that should be looked into as well because that's true towns are different we're unique if we're really growing the way we're growing I mean it has to be addressed it has to be looked at we can't follow an old model yeah that's ex well I believe Mr Gorski and Mr T went down was a Department of

167Education yep construction Department of Department of Education and we uh Madam may I speak we we asked for cons special consideration in this matter because five years five years is inadequate and um and Mr T and I left with a warm feeling of optimism that we're going to be granted uh an ability to go beyond five years I mentioned that before and also you know one other important fact here that I I I've said uh at nauseum I'm certain is that um Senator Greenstein Benson D'Angelo's plan which was represented in the letter adopted by the Board of Education um was a two-phase plan the first phase was to milk as much out of the current funding formula in the current year as possible through the elimination of adjustment Aid and removal of the growth limitation

168adjustments both of those were accomplished and the district got $458,000 the second phase which is critical and essential to get any satisfaction on the state aid issue is the development and Monroe's contribution toward a new school funding formula and until that happens with specific contribution from Monroe you could fully fund the formula you could milk what you want out of it you will never be satisfied and actually just to go further she recently in I forget what newspaper it is but the Monroe newspaper Monroe okay so she said that this money was just part of a down payment and she did she did Express uh a figure that we should be receiving next year and I think that should be put in the letter that we we really expect to get that so I don't

169know if if can you tweak up the first can you tweak up the first line not being so soft no I think we're voting on this letter because we change the letter then we have to make amendments and then it gets a little complicated and we'll be here till tomorrow um so if there's any any other comments in regard to this typer from what I understand no okay then we will have a roll call on accepting Mr tiel's letter to our legislators um just just to be clear the the action item here by the board is to uh let me just use the vocab Mr cherell correct me if I'm wrong it's to accept and endorse Mr chell's letter on behalf of the funding formula and authorize it submission to uh the state officials yes

170on behalf of the ad on behalf of the adoc committee yes and that motion was moved by Mr cherel second by by Mr armeno Mrs armeno yes Mr Braverman yes Mr Chella yes Mrs Deo yes Mrs Lang yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr Russo yes Mr rsky yes Mrs K panovich yes mad Board of President motion passes unanimously thank you thank you fellow board members I appreciate that thank so part two of this was contingent upon this vote is that Mr Cooper um will be meeting with uh with Dr kak and uh the media tomorrow to work on getting this disseminating this which I'm grateful for so Mr Cooper if you may if you might tell us about that thank you uh again Vic Cooper 525 abot Court mon mode Township um at the last ad

171hoc committee meeting we agreed that I should proceed to try and get the news media to cover the failure of the state to fund schools not only here but elsewhere but we would concentrate here and as a result I contacted a almost a dozen newspapers two of them responded favorably that they would be interested in doing an iCal and learning about this the Sentinels reporter will be meeting tomorrow morning with Dr kak and myself at the Board of Education offices the other newspaper that responded favorably was the Wall Street Journal and I'm trying to continue a dialogue with them they requested information which Dr kak provided me uh along with uh Mr Mr gorsky's uh assistance I'm sure and uh I will be trying to get that information to them hopefully they will do an

172article about it the reporter I spoke to is familiar very familiar with the failure of the state to fund education because she previously was a reporter with the Bergen Record I will also and have I started to contact the news radio stations and news TV TV stations and news stations to see if we can get their interest as well um so that's under way and we wanted to convey that to you the other thing is that the amount of money that I just this has nothing to do with with this this a separate issue that the gentleman raised about uh Senator Greenstein and Sean D'Angelo and uh Benson they proposed an additional $3.1 million next year but it would be dependent on a democratic plan to get a millionaires tax enacted had nothing to do

173with filling the 2008 funding formula it's dependent on their plan to get a millionaires tax enacted and the funds from that would go towards hopefully additional funds for state aid for Education not only here but elsewhere thank you Mr Cooper thank you Mr Cooper and does that conclude your report Mr I'm tired I know not a guess uh anyone else have a report oh Dr kak you're okay I will keep my report short um just uh just wanted a couple quick what's up oh we missed the public sorry thank you thank you Dr I feel like I've been there all day um at this time we've had our committee reports so again we open up public forum for anything that is on the agenda if anyone wishes to speak please come to the microphone give

174your name and address for the record hi my name is Katherine crowy I'm at 56 Spruce Meadows Drive I'm not sure what's on the agenda so apologize if I make the mistake but is it PO is it can I speak on the food policy here at the school district I don't think the food policy is is on the agenda it was approved at the last board meeting so it is not on today's agenda okay so at what point can I speak about and question well there's another there is another public forum after the um well before the Clos session okay so then I'll be back okay anyone else think seeing no one we will close the public forum and go to Dr kak's superintendent report thank you madam president uh again I will keep my

175report short due to the uh length of time the meeting has already taken uh just a quick comment uh back to school nights um I've been to two and I plan to go uh to that was um Brookside and and uh High School last night and Barkley Brook uh tomorrow night uh I just want to tell the board uh couple of the board members um m k panovich Mr bryck were at Brookside uh was a Tuesday or Monday night last night the high school it's great parent turnout really nice seeing all the parents they're coming in they're excited um a lot of positive comments a lot of positive energy uh and again any of the board members that would like to come to any of those I think it's nice to see the um District

176goals and board goals were added to the agenda today Mr K panovich had uh brought that to my attention the original email from M uh Freeman from the school boards Association said September October uh I thought we would develop the action plans but I agree and we got it on the agenda and it's the same as we spoke about at the August meeting so there's nothing new there um and Mr moraldo has been working with our I believe our Graphics arts department at the high school we had talked about making poster boards and they're going to come up with three different uh samples to look at which I'm sure they're going to do an excellent job so I'm looking forward to to seeing them and to uh showing the board that result of that as

177well uh just a quick congratulations for the very quick start for our full sports teams some early wins uh not not every all the teams have won but they've done a great job and strong parent support out there uh just for the board to know that in observance of September 11th there was a moment of silence held throughout the district on Monday and uh as well as uh that issue being addressed at the um you know in different curricular areas throughout the district and our opening of schools yes we had a couple speed bumps if you will but uh I think the opening of schools went very well not only Transportation but from talking to the principles and some staff members um the kids are back they're excited most of them you know uh and

178it's it's nice to uh to to see their excited I've went to all the schools to see the kids getting off the buses and the parents taking pictures and it it's really nice and it does bring an air of excitement into the district and it's it's a good thing to see it's what we're really here for right it's a very positive thing uh lastly there's been several things that were brought to my attention about raising money for the hurri the victims of the hurricanes and it's plural okay because we had people in Texas and Florida uh there's been several classrooms that are interested in doing donations uh or sending donations adopting class rooms and the mtea has also uh they're collecting money for uh we're doing a jeans day uh they're collecting money for uh

179Hurricane Relief as well so I think that's positive again the generosity of our staff throughout the district and and our kids and our families and always always responding to uh help others in need so with that I'm going to move the Personnel I know I'm I'm getting looks no I'm not no no no it's it's uh uh Madam president I would ask respectfully ask the board uh recommend that the board approved the attached Personnel items a through AI so move second okay who mov that Mr Braverman Mrs Deo any comments or questions seeing none will have a roll call Mrs armeno yes Mr Braverman yes Mr Chella yes Mrs Deo yes Mrs Lang yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr Russo yes Mr rutsky yes and Mrs K Madam board president motion passes unanimously thank you and

180Madame President um board action items a uh through P I'm recommending that the board approve items a through P so move Mr Chella Mr bra would you like second a little bit more second third let's go comments or question questions I have questions oh Mr mayo oh I didn't mean it that way oh I think I'm a little insulted all right is f replacing G we're eliminating the multiple disabilities program at Woodland but we're putting in a new learning language disabled program at Woodland yes okay where to answer that yes I did yes yes Mrs L did you have a question no I have a comment oh um in in board action we're going to be asked to approve two policies which I understand are State mandated policy 5460 which is high school graduation and

1812622 which is student assessment and I will be voting no on both of these policies I believe Our intention to always make decisions in the best interest of our students neither of these policies are in the best interest of our students High School graduation policy what they are doing and the state is doing at the present time is to make Park the only graduation test and a requirement for all students there are only seven states in the entire nation that even require a graduation test and most of them use the AP scores or um sat or act acts as as their testing Med I think when we limit the ways that our children can show their intelligence we're doing a great deal of disservice to them and I'm also concerned that in the high school

182graduation policy they state is now saying that high schools need to send Park squares on with our children as part of their permanent records it's not going to serve any purpose to have those Park squares so that's that's my number one concern with high school graduation the students assessment policy at right now as it stands the education Law Center plus a number of Community Action groups have lawsuits against the state for the state assessment policy our um House of Representatives in the state has already said that this policy is against everything that the state has stood for educationally it should have gone and been presented by the to the state senate to vote so that we could get rid of Park and with get rid of Park um testing but instead our Senator Sweeney sent

183it back to the commissioner of education and put it in her hands and told her to do something with it our current people that are running for governor have said that they want to get rid of it I really feel that we have to make a change the only way that as a board something can change is as a board of ed to take a step to say we need to see something different done and I think the fir for me personally I think the first step is to say that we need this gra these requirements to be re-evaluated and looked at especially in light of the fact that the state mandates this and they give us I believe the park Aid is was 48,000 or50 $10 a pup $10 a person right and and

184they don't they're not giving us money to do these so if we're going to have to cut um from kids but it's it's very important to me that you know I state that my reason for this I really do believe these decisions hurt students the majority of students less than 46% passed of students overall in the state passed Park this year and even with the graduation requirements they don't commit to what a passing score will be and that is wrong we're moving our district into Hands-On learning and teaching the hold child we saw beautiful curriculums um presented the fact of the matter is Park test will not reflect whether our our kids are actually learning what they're learning because you can't reflect that in a standardized test so thank you I just wanted to share

185that with everyone thank you anyone else on goal four the um uh continue to pursue spending efficiencies and best fysical practices I don't so a goal is usually something that's measurable I don't know how how you measure that The Madam president the the action plans will be developed for each of these goals and for go four to improve the uh management and operations the steps under that if you will the objectives of that goal and to to continue to pursue spending efficiency in best FIS fiscal practices I think is um it could it's measurable uh like most things I mean it depends on what you're measuring against it's arbitrary it's not like a goal where you you're saying you're going to achieve something and then during a certain amount of time you have to achieve

186that it's something that's measurable here it's not true uh you could I I guess you could argue that can be worded differently in one way but um well this these were developed with the board I know at we discussed I know right uh at the you know board retreat or meeting and one of the the with the goals for the district you you'll notice that it's much expanded than it has been in the past and as I mentioned at the August meeting this is a point to for us to show the entire Community what we stand for what we're about so is every single objective the best measurable objective it's arguable I you know I it's debatable I guess so you could go back and forth but I think the overall effect of placing these

187goals throughout the district in the entrance to every school shows the community what we stand stand for and the action plan will certainly C certainly show how we'll measure each of these goals oh okay but I don't see how the these are measured anyway um I'd like to say a few things I along with Patty I am voting no on policy 2622 student assessment um I think we're over testing our kids this sentence the data derived from the state assessments will be utilized by teachers and administrators to pinpoint areas of difficulty and customize instruction accordingly this will never happen we cannot customize instruction when we get our Park scores six months after the a child takes the test and in the new school year it's completely unrealistic secondly New Jersey is over testing their kids

188the esa requires one year of testing in high school where testing three it's beyond ridiculous um I see it with my own kids they're completely over tested um I trust the teachers test more than I trust the park test as for the high school graduation rate I have a kid class of 20201 and the only Avenue to graduation is this test my kids's a good student if I had a kid who wasn't a good student I would be very concerned because this test requires this policy requires that a kid takes a test every year in high school and fails that test before being able to do the portfolio appeals process so I don't think this policy is in the best interest of our children and I think the New Jersey doe has fall has really

189done a disservice to this children as the state of New Jersey and I'm voting no on that um I have a concern with these goals there's 14 goals that's a lot we have a lot on our plate I don't want us I'm concerned it will be too much how many goals do we usually have in the past like what is our average three so we're going from three to 14 well could I answer that GE yeah and I certainly understand that Mr May and that was a concern and that's something I spoke to in August everything on here are things that we do it the goals that we have had in the past the three were strictly academic which are still there they're still there in in column one this was away there were comments

190that maybe people didn't understand everything we were doing so we included areas of like the facilities uh works that we're doing there these are projects that let's say Mr T overseas that we're doing on a routine basis the financial um goals that we work on every year so there's nothing it's not like we added uh 11 addition goals this is just what what I felt was a more transparent way to show the people in the community all the different things that go on every year and we were careful in the wording of things uh which you know to Mr Russo's Point yes some of it is is maybe could be considered vague um but I think it was a way also to just show the uh the community um you know all the different projects

191and and things that going on and by having it in the front of the school uh anybody walking in would be able to see at a glance what's going on in the school district would it go ahead and no finish make sense to show this without making it a district goal and having 14 of them well the the four there's really four goals and that was Maryann Freeman really narrowed it down right right so so underneath each of those goals the four goals are improve student achievement improve school facilities increase Community involvement and improve management and operations and then underneath each of those goals are subsets or objectives that are captured by that and it it's also a way to tie in our strategic plan our goals and um it it also ties in uh

192it allows our building based goals in each of the schools to to reflect also in what the district goals are even though they may have some things that are individual based just on the needs of their particular school so it's like the start of an action plan a subset with the action plan underneath them yes yes like I wouldn't ask I would ask the board to not expect an action plan for every single point under there but an action plan for for the four goals and I know the academic goals uh might be a little bit more detailed um like we've done in the past where we're looking for specific achievement we have the map test and and other types of assessment that we want to Target uh specific areas on uh with that but

193I I still have concerns but okay you know anyone else M just a quick question on K it's recommended the Board of Education prove the creation of the following two unbudgeted positions so how do we pay for that and how many we have full-time secretary clerk transportation department that's one person Madam yes yes that's that was U my recommendation to the previous director of Transportation I felt they were under staff for a long period of time uh he never brought that to fruition uh with the new director she immediately noticed that as well we talked about it and we recommended it to the board how are we funding it I'm sorry there yeah there there is available monies um in the transportation budget due to some of the breakage that we received uh before in

194the positions I carefully review all the line items in the budget before making recommendations like that we've had a a few key positions in this District um and forgive me the lateness of the hours not identifying them but we had several positions here in the budget that got filled late and and and months of budget surplus was growing with those salary line items I don't and also the same thing what the fulltime secretary Clerk and the Office of Pupil Services um how do we know how many people we have in that one like how many full-time secretary clerks in that office um I believe there is um I believe there is uh uh uh three okay and this uh three full-time there's one that's uh there they have shared responsibilities Central registration some and special

195ed secretary and um registra a number of I can't speak too intimately about the need for that one uh for for uh confidentiality reasons okay but I will attest to the fact that there is a need for another 1.0 FTE and special services for uh secretary there has also been an incredible growth in IEPs and student growth which also leads to that but there there are more factors okay thank you anyone else hey roll call Mrs armano yes Mr Braverman yes Mr Chella yes Mrs Deo yes but no on policy 2622 and policy 5460 got it thank you Mrs Lang yes and no on um policy 2622 and four 560 546 56 yeah I heard 5460 my dyslexia kicked in uh Mr Rybeck yes Mr Russo yes and abstain from I so noted Mr rutsky

196yes to all Mrs col pan yes but no to policy 2622 and 5460 uh give me a moment please uh Madame board president motion passes okay thank you so then at this time we go to the business administrator's report Madame board president and members of the Monro Township Board of Education it is recommended that board action items a through I be approved by consent roll call no move Mr bra second second by Mr Rybeck comments or questions for Mr Gorski Miss Armenia one question on three it is recommended the Board of Education approve sign language interpreter um is that for every public meeting number three it's about the sign language interpreter I can comment if you want thank you Dr kak okay yeah Mr uh to my understanding that's just for as on an as

197needed basis uh you know for anybody that has yeah we okay right that was going to be my next question not that I'm opposed to it but how many and like what is the need for it in in the district how many hearing impaired would this serve we don't know if someone asks for it you exactly yeah just like an interpreter uh for language we have to provide that and and I think we should oh so you can do that in the classroom as well or just for the meeting no I mean if it's like a well that's a separate issue if it's in a classroom this is for let's say a parent comes in has a parent teacher conference and her hearing impaired then we would provide I see it's not about the public

198meeting coming here every time no okay I didn't yeah if there's a need certainly and um one other question the bid for the snow plowing and snow removal um and we granted the bid to the one uh person who um put in the bid is the is that dollar amount 286,00 is that are we drawing from that or they're guaranteed that oh no there's no guarantee it's on an as no basis okay that's good the bid was determined to be very favorable according to Mr T as was the bidder so it was recommended by Mr T to uh be on the report of course I uh I I acknowledge a lot of the action items on my report are recommended from directors from other departments including special ed quite often and I did and I

199did look at the breakdown about the uh the inches and feet you know and how it so I I did understand in the past that depending on on the snow the amount of snow that's how that triggers their respon but I didn't know if he was guaranteed that it it's that's the money we've budgeted in case of snow events yeah no guarantees at all and it's noteworthy uh to for the board to understand that uh through Mr T supervision our facility staff does a very fine job of of shoveling removing snow ice repeatedly as it melts and refreezes and melts and refreezes um but this is this is more substantial snow where you need contractor thank you anyone else roll call Mrs armeno uh yes Mr Braverman Mr cheer yes Mrs Deo yes Mrs Lang

200yes but abstain on item G so noted Mr Rybeck yes Mr Russo yes Mr rutsky yes and Mrs kapano Madam Bo president passes that concludes my report thank you okay we'll go to board president's report and anything that I have to say I've said already tonight um I don't think there's anything more than I could I could add at this point so we'll just go to Other Board of Education business anyone have anything that they like like to mention real quick Mrs Lang yeah last night I attended the middlex County New Jersey school boards association meeting and it was um actually a very very good meeting um they had two presenters and the topic was special education and Ida how to save your District millions of dollars and they talked at length about the best

201way to save is to improve your conflict re re conflict resolution procedures and really seeing that everybody within the district is an advocate for all children that we're not special education and general education that we're all working together for the benefit of the children it was an excellent um uh presentation and they gave great information about why we do what we do in special ed thank you anyone else miss armo this is just before the close session is that or before the last public portion yeah okay I just want to thank uh those members of the Board of Education who voted no for the resolution because I think it's not it's it's it's not easy to make these decisions and I think we should respect all matters of uh the decision making because I know

202I've had a knot in my stomach all day uh reviewing the documentation and trying to make the best decision uh for the community and I don't think there's a wrong decision I think a no vote doesn't mean uh that that those members aren't concerned especially for the children so I want to thank my fellow members who had the um consideration to to vote no and I think we should respect everybody's position on that so thank you thank you m that's very well said I think because it was a very good discussion Y and I think at the end everybody has to vote their conscience and I think that's what happened yep uh anything else okay we are going to the public forum anyone from the public who would like to speak on anything they'd like

203uh please come to the microphone give your name and address for the record it's Katherine Crowley 56 BRS mows Drive okay so I have been I was at the committee I guess some kind of a committee I don't even know what it was um this was right before school started where we talked about the school policy this the food policy as set by you guys that this little committee was supposed to put together um some recommendations for the policy committee to approve or reject so I walked out of there pretty happy with what the principles and what that little committee had decided two weeks later I'm finding out that none of it is coming true there is a whole bunch of really weird um I guess uh comments made by people about how this thing

204is being implemented that I personally do not understand so I was given to understand that the principales had put together a request that for the three parties that were permitted where their food where food was permitted that the parents would pack their own children's snacks that took care of all the parents who complained about having junk food that took care of the parents who were concerned about allergies now from what I understand that policy was rejected instead it was said that the PTA would be the ones who are responsible for the party food um I know at the committee at this little meeting we had the ptas of oak tree and Applegarth and Woodland and mil Lake run a little differently than the ones from Barkley Brook and Brookside I'm not speaking for my I'm

205not speaking for Barkley Brook Brookside I am a member so I am confused about how the Board of Ed can tell the PTA how to run their business the room parents at Barkley Brook Brookside is not under the control of the PTA it's under the School principles where does the PTA tell the room parents to go take care of this I'm just really confused about all of this can somebody answer me yes yes I uh thank you madam president with with all due respect um the the policy committee and and as you know this was a very controversial controversial uh policy and you know with a lot of things uh sometimes compromise is is what occurs and the board I felt that the board board's intent uh and there was a spirit of discussions here

206in in public about whether food should be allowed for everything or taken away entirely or somehow met in the middle and it seemed to be the the intent of the board to allow food not just to take it away entirely but to allow it for the holiday parties three three holiday parties per year when it came back that the parents excuse me when it came back that the parents would bring in you know send in a snack um it it didn't seem to fit the intent of the discussion that was held with the board that the you know and I don't want to speak on behalf of the board I think I'm I if and I invite the board to to you know correct me or or add to this but it seemed like the

207board wanted to retain something of um a celebration if you will uh using food at these holiday parties and just sending a snack in really might not meet that request reement especially when you talk about maybe field day or or something like that um as far as the PTO bringing the food in or I I don't think the board got that specific other than to say that another option would be found the thought being perhaps can you turn it off thank you the thought being perhaps that um either the PTO the room parents but some other Arrangement and it was sent back to the committee to come up with guidelines to do that and I realized that that it didn't make everyone happy um but I I will say that overall you know it was

208a step in the direction of what the wellness committee had requested and uh that I I would guess that it would be considered a compromise but at least you know a big portion of what the wellness committee had requested was accomplished and yeah I think it was more like Dr KES said a compromise and there was discussions I don't think anything is specifically written in the policy the intent of the policy was to get eliminate all the food birthday parties because we understand that that's an issue but to keep food as an option for um the three um holiday parties during the year with a a because I I I'm not sure how parties are run I know um in some places the PTA collects money from students and then they go and they buy

209the food and bring it in so they would there should be or either through the principal or through the wellness committee a list of approved foods and if there's two or three choices then a child every child has the opportunity to pick the one that they can um that that they don't have any issues with or they are able to pack their own snack that day but I I think that's what we were trying to do is compromise again everything is always up to the discretion of the principal and um we we spent a good six months on more probably more on trying to um come up with a policy that the board felt was fair and a compromise with everybody so if the school principal at this that this time your four minuts are

210up okay so I just wanted to say that as a parent of a child with nut allergies if somebody brings in something that harms my child child whose responsibility is that please tell me whose responsibility is that from here on forward well I believe that the people who are bringing the food in are told not to bring anything or if they do bring anything with nuts it has to be um what would the wording am I looking for you have to let everybody know that there's nuts in here labeled thank you um but if if it's if we're hoping stay away from baked goods and have something like fruit and vegetables and things like that my child cannot have that okay this is the problem this is truly the problem okay and at this time

211I I understand but I do I just want everyone sit here we here to know my child dies because of something that something somebody else brought in against my wishes there is definitely going to be a lawsuit it's it's ridiculous good evening Chrissy scurby uh 21 pness Drive I just want to reiterate uh what Mrs Crawley was um talking about um I I spoke about it the night you were voting on The Food policy and I just want to reiterate um what has happened you did not pass a food policy you took away food at birthday parties the understanding is for these holiday parties three parties a year there's allowed to be food now the wellness committee the principal spoke they don't want food in the building apparently now um we're hearing at Barkley Brook

212and Brookside the nurses are no longer going to be checking the food it's going to be the rumor is that it's going to be up to the PTA to be responsible that is absolutely ridiculous this District owes it to the parents and to the children to create a food policy whatever goes on during that day is this District's responsibility it is the principal's responsibility it is not an outside organization parent groups responsibility if you don't want food brought in by the PTA then make that a policy somebody needs to make sure what is coming into the building is appropriate whether it be the Principal or the teacher or the nurse and if nobody wants to take that responsibility it is up to you then to make a policy to not allow it in because you

213cannot put the onus on a parent volunteer bringing something in and saying you're responsible that that is not fair to the children that is not fair to the other parents that is a it was a fantastic idea saying that you want to have food at the party parents pack the food you get very you know you you get the information for the party well in advance teachers remind them you want your child to eat food at the party they come in with it that's their snack for the day for the party we heard the wellness committee saying they don't want abundance amount of food so every kid bring in their snack that that was a wonderful compromise hearing now what's transpired over the last two weeks that it's going to be on the onus of

214the parent groups that that's not right and that's not a policy and that's the board that's the board failing the parents and the children of those schools I know there's a lot of other issues in this District beside food but when you have parents standing up here nurses standing up here principal standing up here begging you to make a policy to make it safe for the children that's your responsibility to do for them it's the least you can do it's food I mean the fact that we're going back and forth with this for so many months is ridiculous figure out what can be done and make a policy don't leave it up to volunteers and parent groups that that that's absolutely ridiculous so thank you anyone else from the public good evening uh Betty saberito

215to Barrymore Drive I wanted to bring to the attention something of great concern to myself and other parents of classified students as many of you in this room know many have left now but I have a child with autism who is at mil Lake in a first grade self-contained class and I have become a big advocate for special needs in the community not just for my son but for all of these children beginning this school year at mil Lake the smaller buses and vans that transport our special needs children are no longer dropped off at the main Bus Loop with their other general education peers but rather they are dropping them off at the back of the school while I am certain that the reason for this change is logical due to the amount of

216vehicles the people at the time of drop off this impact of separating these children can be severe it is my understanding that this was done due to crowding and safety and that is understandable but why was it this specific group of children that were selected and segregated I also understand that after I emailed my concern today an additional bus with general education students was added to that so while it may now not only be special needs students there are no special need students at the main building that is a concern this lack of inclusion is not acceptable studies show that integration and inclusion needs to start at a very early age so that these children are better able to adapt and more importantly so that their peers are exposed to them inclusion means different and

217diverse students side by side in the same environment I cannot stress that enough the term inclusion captures in one word and all embracing ideology it secures opportunities for these students to learn acad academically and socially so while I am certain that this separation was not done in any malicious form it needs to be Revisited immediately again studies show that special needs students are at risk for bullying and in order to decrease this it is important that their peers see them as integrated when our district is separating them what are the peers to think I am requesting this new policy be re Revisited as I said as soon as possible and while it is my understanding that this might be easier for the staff it is not an inclusive solution or situation as a district we

218need to do a better job of inclusion and integration and to date we are not I do want to commend principal mnol at mil Lake in her past two years at mil Lake she has made this school the most inclusive School in the district you know that just reading some of the reports including yours Dr kak where special needs inclusions are for M Lake only and you don't see that from other areas in the district we need this to roll over to every single area and every single department and that includes transportation we are seeing tremendous population growth in in row that is what the discussion has been about tonight but a large number of these students are now in District and they are special needs and as a community we need to be more

219sensitive and more inclusive giving all of these children what they deserve and what they are entitled to I am asking you to please revisit this again urgently because because this is simply not acceptable to us to be segregating the children in this manner and I don't think it was done maliciously I also want to say that the Board of Ed believes that we do a fabulous job in special education and as a parent I can tell you that we do an okay job but it is an uphill battle for us as parents every September I become that parent and I become that parent because this District makes me that parent my son is a first grader I've been through one mediation and one lawsuit and I can't even tell you the number of emails so

220I ask you to revisit this I ask you to revisit in general the way we are treating our population thank you thank you madam Madam thank you I would like to respond to the L's uh comments I was aware of this situation uh from forwarded email and I I number one nobody is more committed to inclusion and enhancing and supporting and offering resources to the special ed Department than this board and this Administration that's a fact I can show you figuratively where I am getting that statement from and in other areas I'll give you one specific when I interviewed candidates for the transportation of director one um one personal characteristic of the current director really caught my attention and that was her love for Trans supporting special education students it was it was an unsolicited

221offering in the interview and she went into detail how it it gives her personal pleasure to um not only make sure that there is inclusion that uh all special education students are given the very best transportation to suit their needs which sometimes is difficult to accomplish both this District in the transportation department right now and I have specific knowledge about this integrates not segregate students on All Buses that's 54 passengers and vans 54 passenger buses have students with IEPs that still enable them to be in a peer setting on a 54 Student Bus one that comes to mind is anxiety uh others that come to mind are those that require an aid if and sometimes we put an aid on the bus why was I denied an aid beg your pardon I have the floor

222and the and the point of that is to make sure we have integration on buses now the smaller buses and we don't even use adjectives to describe these things that could be determined to be offensive are also integrated and never segregated you would be surprised to know if you took a poll of students on the small vehicles that uh there are a large number of gened students integrated purposefully on the smaller Vehicles now I'll speak specifically and briefly to the queuing process at the school because we're having issues with that and and I I think that's adding to this problem our school front areas that receive students were never designed for the volume of buses that are lining up there right now and the incredible enrollment growth that we've had throughout this District it is

223requiring buses to deliver students to the uh rear entrance of the school in order to get students in time the larger buses cannot uh manage dropping off kids at the back of the school uh they can not turn around safely and discharge students the smaller buses obviously can accommodate that quite well and to my point before being that both buses contain integrated students there is no segregation issue there is no shame by being taken to the back of the building because it's both combinations of of of students and uh and and in some cases there are special needs students whose specific interests are served by delivery to the back of the school because it requires special removal from the vehicles special delivery into the school we have children who are Runners and I will just

224take off that have to be immediately met by a par professional very great care is given to safeguard students at all time and to deliver them to school on time the particular anxiety student that I was referring to before uh his problem was made worse by coming to school late so that everybody in the transportation department immediately stopped everything on the busiest day of school to make sure that that that particular route was put at Paramon uh importance and addressed right away and and that that mission is shared by everybody here so I I respect you immensely and um I appreciate your comments but I I certainly take exception to the term segregation um because that does not happen and I can attest to that and I respect your comments and thank you anyone else

225from the public seeing no one we'll close public session forum and go to close session resolution be it resolved that the Board of Education of the township of Monroe hereby moves to go into closed session in accordance with the Sunshine Law chapter 231 of the public laws of 1975 njsa 10 colum 4-6 through 10 colum 4-21 to discuss the following subject discussion regarding superintendent miracles pursuant to the employment agreement between the super tenant and the board following Clos session action may be taken the discussion conducted in closed session can be disclosed to the public as such time as the need for confidentiality no longer exists who was first first and you were second for first okay M Mr de Mayo Mr Ryback all in favor I opposed at this time we will go into Clos

226session okay at this time time the board will go back into public session and I have um two resolutions the first it is recommended that the Board of Education approve miracles for the superintendent of schools for the 2017 2018 school year subject to approval by the county the executive County Superintendent of Schools as followed goal number one to continue the goal of increasing students understanding of career opportunities connect student learning to issues facing the local and Global communities and enhance communication between staff and University professors practitioners in various career Fields by developing Partnerships with corporations and universities with up to 15 internships with no less than six it is a quantitative quantitative goal 3.3% of salary for 5,000 577 goal number two to increase the percentage of grade three students who met or exceeded expectations

227on Park Ela 2017 from 62.3% to 65% it is a quantitative goal 3.3% of salary for $557 goal number three to increase Community awareness of student learning through student presentation ations and or projects in the community it is a qualitative goal 2.5% of salary for $ 4,187 the superintendent is hereby directed to submit the aforementioned miracles to the executive County Superintendent for review and approval so moov so moved Ryback and Mrs Lang armeno it's fine Armen fine oh I'm sorry that's fine I wasn't looking we're here to help okay any comments or questions Madam president I just want to state so that there I know last year when the board goals when the Merit goals were approved it was a misunderstanding within the public that we've already said that we are giving that money um

228I just think it's important that we know that these are what your challenged to produce for this year and you there's a possibility that you can get up to all that dollar amount but we haven't right you know we're not giving it to you right now thank you okay does anybody have an extra set of a piece of paper because I have to do a roll call and I don't have everybody back well I would write rather have a piece of paper because then I'm on not on the back of lots of stuff so Mr Gorski is not going to be happy with me tomorrow so let me just write down the names and then I'll take the Roll Call I feel like you should be you want me to sing I could whistle will

229you whistle a tune please I can sing too but both are pretty bad I apologize no I didn't think I could have voted before too okay so yes no not here okay Miss Armenia yes Mr Braverman is not here Mr Chella is not here Mr Mayo yes Mrs Lang yes Miss Gino is not here Mr Ryback yes Mr Russo is not here Mr Russo was conflicted and so is so they could not have voted anyway Mr retsky I'm a yes and Mrs kapano is a yes and the motion has passed thank you okay so this is resolution one okay the second resolution it is recommended that the Board of Education one approve goal number one to assess the college preparedness of students who graduated from the Monro Township School District by gathering data related to

230Monro Township School District students academic success at the college level it's a 2.5% for $4,185 we believe that has been completed and goal number two to increase students understanding of career opportunities connect student learning to issues facing the local and Global communities and enhance communication between staff and University professors practitioners in various career Fields by developing Partnerships with corporations and universities the board believes it is 55% complete for $3,067 number two direct the superintendent to submit the Miracles to the executive County Superintendent for review and approval so moved second again thank you okay any comments or questions just want to make clear Madam president that this was for the two just the year for this this is the these are the goals that have already been done and we've been assessing that yes this is

231for the 2016 20 17 school year any other comments or questions seeing none um okay Miss armenio yes Mr Braverman is not here Mr Chella is not here Mr de Mayo yes Mrs Lang yes Miss Gino is not here she was conflicted yes Mr Ryback yes Mr Russo is not here Mr retsky yes and Kathy kapano and I say yes okay and that concludes the goals and um now I have to find my agenda I think you have to just ask for the public portion yeah and I don't think there's anybody here I think it's it's in here I think I should open up the page just here you go okay we're up to number 17 public forum but there's nobody left here at uh this time of night so we will the next schedule

232Board of Education meeting will be October 18 2017 7:00 p.m. at the Monroe Township High School I need a m motion to adjourn I make a motion um second let Steve second okay all in favor I opposed then the meeting is adjourned

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.