CorpusRecord 132989

Monroe Township Board of Education 07.19.17 Regular Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Monroe Township School District
Date
2025-02-12
Location
Middlesex County, NJ
Material
Transcript
Extent
10,154 words · about 57 min
Collected
2026-06-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001good evening the meeting of the Monroe Township Board of Education will come to order please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance I pledge allegiance to the plag flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands nation under God indivisible liy and justice for all minutes may we have a roll call Mr Gorski Mrs armeno here Mr Braverman here Mr cherella here Mrs Deo Mrs Lang here Mrs Corino here Mr Ryback here Mr Russo Mr rutsky Mrs kapano here Madam board president you have a quum present this evening in accordance with the provisions of the New Jersey open public meetings law the Monroe Township Board of Education has caused notice of this meeting to be published by having the date time and place thereof posted July 14th 2017 at all

002schools the home News Tribune cranberry press and filed with the clerk of the municipality thank you at this time we will go to number five on the agenda approval of minutes for the public Board of Education meeting of May 10 2017 Mr sella Mr Ryback any additions or corrections to the minutes all in favor opposed abstentions recuse okay the approval of the minutes for the special public Board of Education meeting June 88th 2017 Mr rack Mr Chella additions or correction to the minutes seeing none all in favor I opposed abstentions or recusals Mr Mr Braverman abstaining and the approval of the minutes for the closed session meeting of June 8th 2017 second Mr Chella Mr Ryback again comments questions additions seeing none all in favor I I opposed abstentions Mr Braverman abstains recuse okay and

003at this time uh number six on the agenda do Madame board president as number six on the agenda requires a two-thirds vote of the Board of Education and as we have one member in transit um may I ask that we hold number six until later in the agenda yes thank you okay we'll get back to that so at this time we'll go to the student board members reports and since they are on summer break we will not be hearing from them tonight and I look forward to seeing our new board member new student board member in September in September so we'll go to committee reports are there any committees that need to report this evening none I I was waiting you she said need to report I don't would like to report has to report

004you want to report for no not for I'll report for Mr rutsky but not for Mr Braverman first the public I'm sure would like to hear you sir we have a wellness policy and it's done and I think there copies for the public and we try to accommodate everyone and we have three holidays which where we will serve food and that will come through our Food Services Program so everything is proper and otherwise we're foodless foodless and uh if there are any problems with this have a a special committee it's unfinished no we've been talking about this policy for at least four months now so I'm hoping that the revisions will satisfy everybody but I'm sure we have another month to find out can I suggest wording change on that particular policy you want me

005to save that from my report or no you can say it now you can yeah say okay all right this would be a good time all right so Mr Braverman with um you're the chairperson of the policy committee but I would like to bring up a slight wording change that Miss Lang brought to my attention that might provide better Clarity to that wellness policy so I would like to just uh State what that is go right ahead all right thank you so uh I think as Mr braan stated we're trying to find a compromise for the many different sides uh that parents have taken and staff members and others have taken regarding food school for celebrations and basically it uh this will take the food out of the birthday celebrations but it'll still allow food

006to be used for holiday parties either winter perhaps Thanksgiving uh things of that nature and we would encourage people to use our food service because they uh are well aware of the the student allergies and uh they prepare food that takes that into account so to provide better Clarity to this parag it's number four uh under Section B the uh wording change will be uh halfway down well I'll read the whole thing due to the Monroe Township Board of education's commitment to the health wellness and safety of our students and it's and its commitment to Healthy Living it is the intent of the Monroe Township School District that all classroom now right here the word birthday is going to be inserted so it'll read all classroom birthday celebrations during the school day be nine food

007celebrations that leaves it open to holiday parties now if we have a policy meeting between now and the second reading perhaps that wording might be clarified even further to to specify holiday parties but as it stands tonight uh that would be the wording and then the last sentence would be only nonf food goodie bags would be will be allowed of course earlier in or there's another section in the policy where food can still be used for instructional purposes there are times that the teachers use food for uh different uh roles in the classroom for instructional purposes so that'll be permitted is that all right Mr braan fine okay thank you thank you madam president thank you hey um anyone else with the committee report okay Mr tiella yes we had a buildings and grounds and

008transportation meeting on July 17th so we had we discussed uh our a new sound system what we're looking for is something that'll help the hearing pared so that both uh the uh members of our board who uh cannot always hear what's going on in the meeting because of the speaker system and the mic microphone system and also uh our you know the uh our taxpayers and visitors and and uh the people who come in here to to address US sometimes can't hear what's going on so um we looked at that with um read sound and they gave us a walkr of the of that system and how it would work and uh so that was that was very interesting we still have to we still have to look into it look at the uh and

009work out the Kinks and see how that will work for um you know those of us who need it we also had update on the Barkley Brook Roofing and mill work restoration project we and an update on the uh playground resurfacing and we picked the uh the color for that surface actually I'm going to blame them they they picked the color I I was I was neutral they pick blue if anybody hates it if you really like it I'm the chair of the committee and I let it be blue um but anyway the uh we also discussed the the trailers uh classroom trailers for the 18th 19th school year and um how that might look we have no idea how many trailers we will need we have no idea if we'll even need trailers at

010this point but we're guessing that we do uh based upon where we are with a referendum and where we would be you know how far out we'd be from being able to build and do do any of those things so um what we discussed was um going through with uh trying to find a plan that will be able to satisfy the needs of housing our students properly while also at the same time remaining cognizant of the costs and the uh you know the all those factors that going to being able to house the children properly and still maintain keep the cost down as much as possible and that was it okay thank you anyone else Miss armeno um while I am neither the chair nor the vice chair of the finance committee since Mr ruy

011is in transit and unfortunately Mr isn't here I will just since I was present at the finance committee meeting I'll I'll discuss the agenda uh we discussed the lease purchase and financing bid results for instructional equipment and buses contained in the 1718 budget uh we talked about insurance renewals with the exception of health benefits and uh if Mr of course he wants to elaborate on those um we also talked about a uh an appraisal company that appraises our fixed Assets in the district it's an annual review of our assets and we get a report we also get uh a notification from the company and it also helps to serve our insurance purposes that we we have uh all of our assets recorded and we know where everything is so that's a great we talked about

012that being a really good situation for the board and the district to know where all the properties are so that is being done uh we had Mr Gorski uh updated us on the audit that also occurs every year and the audit has begun correct Mr Gorski so they have uh begun the audit and he can explain uh where we are in the process at this point and then I'll the we'll save the best till last we've got with all of the um activity and participation of our city citizens in Monroe um we did get a revision of the state funding uh a very slight one but uh I think it represents that when people participate in their government and uh react civically uh and appeal to their government we do get heard um I think

013we could do I think our government officials can do much better for us on the state level but we have a slight increase in funds and we'll talk about that in the resolution uh and Mr Gorski can uh explain the accounting of that if he chooses now or before the resolution whatever uh whatever works best Madam um as Mrs armeno covered the um lease purchase financing results came in at a very advantageous rate for the district 1.9 approximately uh for a 5year lease purchase for instructional equipment and buses and the advantage you again of lease purchasing these items instead of buying them all at once is it frees up about a million dollars of budget room um and uh defers payment over these items over five years so each year you're paying a one5 installment

014plus a minuscule amount of Interest which better matches the the cost of the assets to their um lifespan and the insurance renew RS came in $118,000 less than last year for all policies with the exception of health and student accd and insurance um our workers compensation premiums are down um because as our broker has indicated uh claims are down because we have a safe and orderly School environment that our staff is working in and we have good policies and procedures to safeguard um employees and and um property casualty uh automobile they're all down from last year so from the amount that we had in the budget we're recognizing $118,000 worth of savings and we hope to continue those practices going into next year the only insurance policy that uh increased significantly was student accident we

015had a couple couple um noteworthy student accidents recently and those have negatively affected claims but um ad Administration has addressed all of those accidents we've developed new procedures and uh policies for safeguarding students in those areas where uh you know fate had it where these injuries occurred before and um we're working on that uh fixed asset appraisal as Mrs armenio said we have uh two compilations of uh reports the first one is for assets $500 and up and the next one's $2,000 and up per item the 500 and up is uh compreh of list for insurance purposes God forbid there is a fire or flood in a building we will know exactly what equipment assets computers you name it is in that building at that particular time because it was uh tagged and computer recorded

016uh to be present while the audit was commencing and the other one is $2,000 and up and that's for an accounting update a few years back the accounting um uh regulations required gby 34 which requires depreciation on school assets on a government-wide financial statement so that's calculated as part of this fixed asset appraisal and the audit update uh the Auditors are beginning with uh reviewing all of the minutes uh which are posted on the district's website from the minutes they extract contract approvals and professional appointments and so on and Trace those to actual um dollar spent and check verification to make sure everything from start to finish checks out on those appointments and everything that is uh expended during the year is approved by the Board of Education the other area that begins the audit

017is the Student Activity accounts and that's where um principals at each School location have discretionary money um which is intended to have students raise money for their own welfare for programs such as field trips and things like that and they audit those accounts because those involve um um Cash number five the additional state aid award uh is um very good news it's it's a dividend that the state has paid back to the administration the Board of Education the taxpayers uh the ad hoc committee for school funding and everybody who testified and signed petitions on the district's behalf to uh get our fair share of state aid funding and I would appreciate if we could hold that till Mr Rudy's here as the finance chair and talk more about that when we present the resolution can

018I just make one comment B B on that um Mr Gorski I believe you so generously said our fair share we're still we're still not at our fair share but we've gotten a little bit more uh funds that is a very good point um this this extra Aid award was actually calculated by taking your a District's underfunding which is what you were supposed to get if you were fully funded and what you actually received and initially we Monroe was supposed to get 10% of that underfunding difference which first calculated a $512,000 uh then the government shut down and there were some reallocations so we wound up with a little bit less but even at the 10% we're higher than the state average of 7% of funding on those uh that underfunded aggregate amount but that

019still leaves 90% that uh we still have a lot of work to do but you know this is we've been in fighting for state aid now for at least seven years uh aggressively and um this is the first dividend that the first fruit that we have to show for our efforts so it is a milestone but there's still a lot of work to be done and again I think the committee was very clear to acknowledge and uh wish to thank the participations and the citizens in Monroe uh for their attention to this and we hope to continue uh attending to this issue because we're not satisfied uh with with the with the results although we accept and we gratefully accept the results we're not satisfied that we are getting our fair share and we hope

020that um citizen participation just continues to go up and we still appeal to our elected officials and keep very close watch on their activities and behavior and um you know if we're not satisfied we actually uh get get keep fighting yes thank you so Mr Gorski with the addition of the $458,000 what percentage are we now getting from the state do we have any idea because we weren't getting a big percentage to begin with unfortunately this additional award didn't really move the needle as far as those percentages go um the state uh funding for this district is still to the best of my knowledge only about the 3% 2% 3% range um local taxpayers are still footing 87 88% of the requirement of revenues to fund the school district and um you know as as

021this um resolution that's forthcoming appropriates this to the levy keep in mind that uh if we're going to be 45800 ,000 approximately under cap now because we're it's recommended that the board take this money and apply it against the levy if we received a more Equitable amount of money we could be millions of dollars under and that's that's what we need to keep our eye on going forward not just you know this amount here which is you know certainly tasty but what we deserve here is tax reductions through the community Through Millions more of state aid which comes back to Monroe and I say back because it's Monroe's contributions to the state coffers that fund a significant amount of state aid to other districts and it's redistributed to other districts under the current Formula that's

022correct okay thank you any comments or questions from Mr Gorski okay then we'll go to the public forum and anyone from the public wishing to speak please come to the microphone and state your name and address for the record and we will ad here to a 4minute time limit I told okay so we we just need her name not her address hi my name is Josephina my mom has been telling me about the new food policy and whenever she comes home with bad news I feel upset since I've been two I had life-threatening food allergies I can't eat nuts I can't eat anything manufactured with nuts and I can't touch nuts if I do I can die my epip pant are for adults because my allergies are so severe recently my testing came back so

023bad that my I just told me I have to wear a life bracelet so this is my life bracelet and it says what I'm allergic to my mom's phone number and to call 911 and in kindergarten first and second grade Whenever there was food for a party and I I didn't know what to do about it I got scared this happened a couple of times a week when there were birthday parties or star student I felt left out because I had to eat food for my safe snack box and everyone else in my class saw that I was different I even had teachers who would send home food in my lunch box that they weren't sure I could eat so I could ask my mom if it was safe for me they thought they were

024being nice but luckily I was smart enough to know not to eat it on the bus or something really bad could have happened to me but in third grade everything changed and it was awesome my teacher never had foods for birthday parties or start our student we got to celebrate by singing getting a book and bookmark from the office and a pencil and sticker from our teacher presents are much better than eating food all day for holiday parties we played games did crafts and got to take home a gift from the class moms that didn't have food involved we got to eat our own snack that our mom sent that day everyone felt perfectly about great about that and loved the party I still get to go to events like the Candyland dance and ice

025cream Bingo after school because my mom is there to help me decide what I can and what I can't eat after school is a good time to have events with food not during the school day I think this policy will help me and everyone else who has food allergies feel safe in school instead of scared and left out all the time I hope you will think of me and my S severe food allergies when you vote for this policy thank you thank you Josephina for coming to the board and expressing your your opinions to us it's much appreciated and it's not easy to do that to come to us before us and give up your time in the summer thank you anyone else from the public wishing to speak so at this time we will

026close public forum and go to the superintendent's report Dr KAC thank you madam president I can certainly see after Josephine that no one wanted to follow that uh that was very well done um I'm pleased to a knowled the hard work and the perseverance of our dedicated staff Board of Education our mtea which is our teachers union uh representatives and community members who devoted considerable time and energy in attending meetings pres uh presenting to the legislators in Trenton and in signing petitions all in a concerted effort to secure additional state aid as been board president president Mrs K panov just stated and M armenio and others the amount we received is not nearly enough to make up for the shortfall in Aid the district has endured over the past eight years however it is a

027step in the right direction and it shows the power of our community in effectuating positive change at the state level on another topic uh the district leadership team collaborated during the three days or during three days during the last week of June on a variety of top topics included in our summer administrators Workshop we reviewed student data our new special education manual our policies and procedures we received training on Microsoft 365 we engage in a book discussion of car Dr Carol D's mindset which discusses the advantage of a growth mindset as opposed to a fixed mindset and we reviewed our previous study of innovation and dispositions or habits of mind I would like to thank the Monroe Public Monroe Township Public Library and staff for allowing us to use their conference room for our um

028exotic getaway we got a cross town to the library um the past several weeks have been extremely busy with the interviews of the new and the Le replacement teachers and staff members who are listed on the person Personnel agenda tonight however I know that our rigorous interview process has produced a highly qualified candidate pool who I am proud to recommend for approval to the Board of Education hello Mr Ry I'm sorry did I announce you good to see you oh you mean you're not hiring Mr R you're here for the interview our first question you were talking about inter and he says hello Mr rutsky so we so whatever job you J thank you thank you so uh with that at the Personnel committee a question regarding abutter was asked during the Personnel committee uh

029abot is a program to help our what I refer to as our middle of the road students uh it realized the dream the possibility of attending college and uh we've had a lot of success Dr Ali did a nice presentation on that I guess about a year ago and uh to see the success of our students that are involved in that program and a big part of that program is something called tuty where we have older students work with younger students uh and in some cases is uh college students come back and work with our uh our uh high school and middle school students so the college students are utilized as tutors under the guidance of our Avid teachers to run our Tut tuty sessions during the Avid elective so I just wanted to clarify

030that question that was brought up at the Personnel committee uh meeting so with that I um recommend approval of the Personnel items a a through b g so move so move by Mr Chella and second by Mr Ryback are there any comments or questions for Dr KAC Miss armeno yes uh the Avid tutors Are all uh College age and college students I believe that's uh some I'm not sure to be honest with you Dr uh alvic is really involved in that program and she's actually at an AB IT training this week um so I I I can't speak for every one of those people listed on the agenda if they were all and how and how are the Avid tutors selected uh through the avit uh program so Dr Ali's involved the uh other staff

031members that are involved in that program work and they select who is going to be the tutors to work with the uh students and all these have passed the um the criminal background and the they get their fingerprints just like the Board of Ed people do if the volunteers are working with a certified staff member who is fingerprinted or has a fingerprint approval then they don't necessarily have to have the fingerprint um process they don't go through a background check the background check uh not if they're as long as they're working with our certified teachers so if they come in to work in a maybe an after school situation or come into a classroom uh just like when we have college students come back in any of our classes if they want to come back

032alumni and speak they don't necessarily have to go through the criminal history review because they're in the classroom and I'm not suggesting any of them should I'm just wondering the procedure what I'm what but you meant you said two things one you you mentioned to me that they are getting paid and then you said volunteers which one is it are they getting paid the Avid tutors to my understanding they're getting paid if we do bring people paid people into the system don't they have to go through that process uh they if they're working on their own they would I would have to get clarification as long as they're working with a certified staff member uh and they may very well go through the criminal history uh process okay any other comments or questions I did

033I did have a comment because I I wrote down the same questions actually as Mr Mino just asked so I had the same questions and one of my other questions is what is the pay rate we didn't you know for approving them for Renewal as substitutes is it at a substitute pay rate is it at a different pay rate because they're students so but I didn't see I couldn't find anything that what is the pay rate for them uh actually I don't have that amount I Mr Gorski I don't know if you know what that amount is or not no I'm sorry no no I'm I'm I'm sorry I don't know what that amount is but this was recommended by the um um assistant superintendent this is yes her perview okay yes yeah we we've

034been running this program I was before I got here so I I know about the right but all the people on the list have been filtered through okay okay any other comments or questions see none we'll have a roll call Mr Gorski thank you this is a roll call for personnel items a through BG Mrs armeno I don't know if I can split my vote on a one item on BF uh but at this point um I vote Yes for everything except no for the Avid tutor even but the rest of BF is okay with me no no on BF correct well not really or just the aid BF so noted Mr Braverman yes Mr cherella yes Mrs Lang yes Mrs karino yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr rutsky yes that I heard Mrs K yes

035uh thank you madam word president Personnel items a through BG has passed oh yeah I got oh you got a we'll go back to Dr kosac for board action items yes uh thank you Madame board president uh before we yes that's why I'm just getting to that uh before we get to the um board action I would like to uh publicly recognize uh a an individual who was on the Personnel agenda that was uh has just been approved as our new assistant principal at the high school and that's Dr jeppe Joe Kella and if you would please stand welcome to Monroe but you're welcome back to Monroe yes thank you for um board AC I would like to again note the revision that I had mentioned earlier in the wording of policy 8505 the local

036wellness [Applause] policy and with that I would like to recommend board action items a through o second all moved Mr back Miss armino okay any comments or questions Mr cherella yeah my my question is on Jay and policy 8505 so not not really a question but a statement and and my my issue with that policy still stands so even even though I'm all for making sure that we're keeping our children safe and that they don't have allergens or toxins or bad water or anything like that my my my problem with this policy still is that we're still advocating a a nonf food goodie bag uh for birthdays instead of food and I know that you know if we have food and not all children can participate it alienates them and it and it and and

037it shows them as you know it kind of depicts them as being different from the other kids and they can't participate and I understand that and and I'm all for that uh for making sure that they're not feeling that being ostracized um but on the flip side of that when we have non-f food goodie bags we're going to have parents who go overboard with those non-f food goodie bags and we're going to have other kids who can't afford to have non- food goodie bags so now you're going to now you're going to point out children in a different way and you're going to say that now these children can't afford it or their parents weren't thoughtful enough so they don't have a party or a goodie bag while the these other children do and and

038so now we have a new class of children that are being ostracized so I would just like to have that removed and just say if we're not going to have celebrations we could have a celebration where we say it's so and so birthday and they get to have some you know something in the classroom where they you know a star or not do homework or something like that but having goodie bags or having and that H having that parental influence in the classroom I think that that could be detrimental to a new group of children I just want to make sure that that we're if we're going to level the playing field we should be doing it for everyone so your recommendation would be to eliminate goodie bags all together all together okay anyone else

039Mr minia I I thought that might come up I did not speak to to it in the policy meeting but I don't know if a compromise could be if we limit it to $3 I wouldn't have a problem with thatan I don't know how much it cost to buy I just don't know 30 30 cupcakes I mean what is that $5 $10 I mean right but then you could get you could get elaborate with PR bags you could end up with you know some and then other kids have a birthday maybe the same day or the next day and they're bringing right nothing or popcorn or you know they can't even bring that or bringing uh plas yeah like like I said we we also talked about putting making it CL clarifying it and like

040making a list of the only things that are acceptable even in a goody a non-f food goodie bag I mean it's really been difficult to satisfy everyone to protect the children even though um you know I know that kids feel differently when they're in the classroom and they can't but it's a lifestyle change that they have to accommodate for the rest of the their lives so there'll always be that difference anyway even in public so you know that's that's an issue as well that that it's something that they have to learn how to live with um but I certainly don't want to put the district in a position where where we're at at risk of you know having a child have an allergy reaction but so we're still tweaking it and trying I mean instead

041of like eliminating that I maybe we can pass this and then the next po Med talk about a a further restriction I think we I think because what we had talked about with the goodie bags thank you I'm sorry okay so what we had talked about with the goodie bags was more so even at the holiday parties and that we expect the teachers to say this is what's allowed and what's not allowed in a goodie bag so that we're putting those that the the teachers take some of the the responsibility and the power saying what this is what we can do and then being able for the front office to say guess what you're not bringing balloon into the classroom you're not bringing that so that was the thought between so at the end of

042a holiday party so for Christmas they can go home with pencils or they could go home with something so that was it wasn't really connect you know just connected to the birthday parties that just in case you bring in goodie bags they must be non-f food goodie bags Mr I just want to I and I and I appreciate that my only fear like I said is that we're going to end up with teachers decide and not that they're not capable of doing doing that but teachers deciding based upon their school or where they're at what they're going to allow to have come in and and that's still going to I think if we're going to have a policy then it should just be a policy if you're going to have a policy that says you

043can't have food and we're and we're going to limit uh goodie bags or whatever this is how we're going to celebrate then it's a clear policy and you don't have one classroom saying we're going to we're going to want to allow $30 per student and another one saying $300 per student you know I have a my daughter just went to her um the to the to her her dance her eighth grade dance and you know there were I they it looked like some looked like some of the kids were going to a wedding they were getting married you know and limousines and things like that I mean it there's that level of difference and disparity out there and and that could also be reflected in the classroom and I just think that we need to

044make sure that we don't it's one of the reasons why parochial schools have uniforms right everybody looks the same everybody's doing the same thing and you don't have those things and I I don't want to get to that level but I just think that if we're going to have a policy and we have to make sure we're helping all the children Mr ryck I just want to know I I I know how emotional and important this policy and the discussions about it have been since the last meeting and and how much research we've put into it and um I know we want what's best for the children of this district and and and certainly the district itself and I'd like to take a moment to um commend really the policy committee because it seems like

045they took into account both sides and came up with something that's viable at least in my view uh a step in the right direction and I understand this is a first reading it still could be tweaked somewhat U Mr Chella brought up some points today that I'm sure you'll you know you consider but I really just wanted to commend the the policy committee for uh understanding the importance and of the issues that both sides raised uh for this thank you I Mr uh Brave would would a dollar amount maximum solve your problem I don't I don't I don't think I don't think a dollar amount would I don't know that it's not even about a dollar amount Mr Braverman it's more it's because because some parents might have dollars but they might not be thoughtful

046you're right I understand that but you know that that's really life well and if and if if school is is is life we shouldn't be doing something that's taking place well then if school is life we shouldn't be leg ating all this other stuff people refer to school as not the real thing but everything is life including including being around people that are eating things that that you can't tolerate you know that's life also all I'm saying is if we're going to level it let's level it if if we're not if we're going to make policies and and and mandates then we should be we should make them fair for everyone and I and I know this polic is trying to do that for for for some let's do it for all let's just go

047that extra step and let's see if we're willing to do that I don't know what the the sticking point is about having the need for having goodie bags as opposed to just not well we thought it was fair for everyone but you'd like it fairer I I'd like it fairer I I don't think that I you know I I don't know what the percentage of kids of the kids who have allergies in our classes are so but let's say we have let's say it's 10% and let's say now there are 10% of kids whose parents don't care enough to have to send them in with goodie bags and birday do we are we going to you know we're just going to allow that to happen we're going to allow that injury to their to you

048know to their psyche all I'm saying is we're we're making a move here to ensure that children are safe and we're making a move here to to ensure that we're not making children feel different but by doing this we could be making children feel different okay I know that we've been spending about four or five months on this policy and I think we've tried to look at every angle that we Poss possibly can I don't think there's a perfect policy out there for this whatever we do we know that there's going to be people that are happy and there's not going to be people that are happy and I can't remember another policy in recent memory that has taken up so much time and effort from a lot of people um Mr Mino one more

049quick comment could we try to pass this policy and then uh uh let's say by the after the first semester if we have some issues that arise because of it that come to our attention I mean we we were really trying to be responsive to the public we want to protect the children but you know I'm also I'm one who always wants everything equal for everybody and yet Mr Braverman makes a good point that we have you know life is disappointments and things and certainly not putting children in a health problem but not everybody it's like giving our participation trophy I just I almost I didn't want to put myself in that position but the truth is personally and I know other parents feel differently yeah not you know not everybody gets an award all

050the time I mean it's it I think we almost do a disservice to our children to make them to make everything equal every time because that is not the reality and we're supposed to be preparing them for life so my my suggestion would be if we could pass this and then I I understand and agree with your position then maybe by the end of the next semester if we have issues with it and it becomes a problem the teachers let us know because we need feedback um then we can we can revisit it right policy I think even before the end of the semester probably the end of October we would know because at the end of October we'll probably hear about Halloween okay and there you go with the peanuts okay well that's this

051is this is on for the first reading we we'll bring your suggestions back to the policy committee and then next next um month we'll vote on the policy is there any other comments or questions for Dr kak for the um board action items did you want just ask for clarification since this is the first reading um is there going to be a vote for the first reading and then any changes we go back to the policy committee to to look at before the second reading yes okay I just wasn't I just wanted to clarify can I ask Mr why does this have to be Why Can't This be considered a second reading since we've gone over this five times over the last five months because the amount of changes that were made to the policy

052makes it a new policy yes is what we've gotten from the attorney got okay where were you when I made that argument oh you made that argum think you're right I think I think you're right and I think our is wrong one more reading after this okay I Mary Smith so that yes it the question had been asked to her and that was the um advice she gave us so if there's no more comments or questions we'll have a roll call Mrs armeno yes Mr Braverman yes Mr Chella yes on everything except Jay policy 8505 that's a no Mrs Lang yes Mrs Corino yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr rutsky so I'm GNA say regretfully I can't even vote on Jay so I abstain for everything except items L MN yes L MN n o yes

053thank you Mrs Kono yes mam board president board action items a through o has passed thank you and that Dr yes that concludes my report thank you madam president so we'll go to the business administrator's report thank you Madame board president and members of the Monroe Township Board of Education it is recommended that board action items A through Z be approved by consent roll call cheating oh move Mr Braverman seconded Mrs Lang comments or questions M Corino I have a question about P for the school Physicians so I know forever we had a pediatrician who was the monor township physician pediatrician right so um then at some point we changed to this Emergency Services type of group and I'm just curious as to why we would do that when um you know the wording in

054here says that they're supposed to have subst anal experience with adolescents and children and I went on to this group's website and read their resumés and they have nothing about children it's all just emergency room situations so what was the issue that we just got rid of the physician that was here for 25 years who everyone respected and was a very good pediatrician what what was the issue yes unfortunately that was a few years ago and there was numerous discussions um by all of the principles involved particularly maretta Rella and her staff the nursing staff superintendent office um on that issue and um I really don't recall the the reason that it was changed but I do know that uh what's on the board agenda tonight was properly vetted and has the high recommendation of

055maretta and to my knowledge Dr kak please chime in uh is performing admirably since we've made the change but why why would we not have a pediatrician for children okay so uh I wasn't here when that change was made so I can't I can't speak to why the change was made I can only speak to what we have now um the the nurses really provide the medical attention to the students and the nurse consult with a district physician when there's a medical uh concern so they they have that ability to do that and the uh sta the uh service that we have now I know for our sports physicals has made a a drastic difference and again I'm not compar we don't sports physicals I'm sorry we don't do sports physicals anymore though well no

056they go to that that Medical Practice they get the sports physicals done and it's uh through an online system wait I could have gone there and gotten to sports physical for your child that's not correct G correct on that one no because no we don't do them anymore we used to do them when the other doctor was I'm sorry they don't do the sports physicals they do the processing of the paperwork you're right you're right I'm sorry um but the parents can go online so again I'm not this is not any um anything against the physician because I don't I wasn't here when that change was made I'm only speaking to the current practice that the practice that we have right now with them handling the online portion of uh going through the the information

057brought from the parents that they their pediatricians have done for the sports physicals has been my first summer here was was pretty shaky with that process and it's been refined and it seems to be working very well so no reflection on the previous District physician as far as I know it's not online because we hand in the papers just like we always did to the nurse but then the paperwork is done entered entered online from that point on and it's it seems to be a very good process at least for the sport physical end of things how it works I mean what's online when the sports physical are hand are handed in that information is entered online to this service this medical service whatever so who's entering all of that information into online who who

058are we paying to do that our nurses do that the nurses take every single piece of paper and they physically enter everything online either that or they scan it one of the two yes they give it to this new yeah they've been handling it every summer for a while I mean I think probably for a long time um but this process it does it it's entered online it's tracked it's also easier to my understanding if you're going from one sport to another because the information is entered it's it's online so I'm just speaking to that one aspect of it I can't compare to the previous District physici because I wasn't here when that change was made it just makes sense to me that you would have a pediatrician and not an emergency physician but that's

059why I wanted to know Ju Just for just for clarification I'm sorry so it so as I understand what you're saying it goes it whoever inputs since since the documents go to the nurses and our district inputs it online to this service and it's then that the service takes it and reviews all of the uh examinations and reports yes so it's online to the service and the service reviews it and then what sends back an okay or a re saying that all these students can participate yes so with Dr has to have the ultimate say whether it was the former District phys or the new District position which happens to be um you know the service here um but it's entered with this service it's entered online and they review everything to make sure all

060the forms are correct make sure that the all the forms have been submitted because if you're been involved with sports physicals as a parent you know that there's multiple things that have to be checked new regulation that they're handled properly uh so I'm just speaking to that one aspect it seems to be handled very well so all of our students are who want to participate in sports are seen by their own private physicians yes and these Physicians really don't see the students physically they right because their own my understanding is that change was made several years ago so that the students used to come to the district and somebody would actually perform the physical and part of that and again I wasn't here but I'm just speaking if you're seeing 200 students in a short

061period of time I don't know if the quality of the physical is the same as if you go to your own pediatrician who maybe you've been going to for 14 years or 15 years and they do a more in-depth um you know physical and then the paperwork it's just a matter of the paperwork is submitted to the district and that's submitted to this medical service and have any of them uh looked at the documentation and said this student should not be participating in sports has anything come back as well if if the if the student's pediatrician they'll make the determination whether they should be participating not or not based on their health history but if the if the forms aren't properly done or if they don't have the correct um I'm going to say immunizations

062so it's probably not what's needed I'm trying to remember for my own kids what was needed uh the certain certain tests that have to be done or certain evaluations that have to be done not first of all the nurses are the ones who call and say you didn't fill this form out or I still need that form MH so these guys are not doing that right but by law that still has to go to a physician to do the nurses uh you're right they they actually do that and I trust our nurses but by Statute we still have to send it to a physician to check are there any other questions or comments seeing none we'll do a have a roll call board action items A through Z Mrs armeno um after this discussion yes

063for everything and I'll abstain for pain on P thank you Mr Braverman yes Mr cherella yes Mrs Lang yes Mrs Kino yes and no for p thank you Mr Ry Yes except for one where I have to recuse myself one letter number one number one one thank you rutsky so I'm gonna I'm going to um obain from everything except I'll start with letter A these are the ones I'm not abstaining a b c l MN o p and Q of course I thank you a one okay because I'm looking for one I don't see one Mr Ryback is staining from A1 no I'm I'm recusing recusing from A1 noted and Mrs Co Pano yes mam board president board action items A through Z has passed and that now takes me back with your permission to

064agenda item number six okay going back on the agenda agenda item number six is the revised state aid award for the 201728 school year and uh Madame board president I just like to remind um the board members and members of the public and the audience a little bit of the history on the district's uh engagement in the state aid issue um going back about five about seven to five years ago um there was a year where Monroe lost 95% of their state aid funding and we only received $238,000 of state aid to support all the operations in the school district a public school district and that year essentially shifted $4.4 million of what was formally the state's obligation to fund education in Monroe to that of the local taxpayers because of a special provision to

065shift that burden that year into that uh local tax levy and otherwise it would have had catastrophic effects on School District's programs and services it has remained there ever since and although there's been a deadcat bounce in state aid funding where Monroe has received a little bit more based on the prior year you're going back to a year where 95% of ours was removed to get a a BAL BCE from that on these slight increases that we've recognized every year Monroe receives a little more than $400 currently per puple and state aid funding which is one of the lowest numbers you'll find anywhere in the state and we have never received Equalization Aid which is the largest type of state aid designed to support a District's adequacy budget and adequacy budget as you probably know

066is mostly mandated by the state including the requirement to have a thorough and efficient education for all students um the district even wrote Our Own legislation um which was supported by Senator Greenstein Benson and D'Angelo and made it through a successful hearing at the um uh Senate but um you know never came to fruition and we knew that was a long whole because we had to ultimately receive the governor's signature on that we've met with everybody who would hear our cause and I believe at this juncture every legislator knows Monroe quite specifically and our problems over here and um when Senator Greenstein addressed the um the adock committee which is chaired by Mr Chella she mentioned a um a twart plan in order to address our state aid funding first was to try to legislate

067changes in the exist existing formula to get rid of the adjustment Aid and the growth limitation adjustments adjustment Aid goes back to the school funding Reform Act of 2008 to try to bridge the gap from those who lost money from the previous funding formula in 07 it was meant to be phased out over five years but but districts are still receiving adjustment Aid because the state froze state aid funding so those who have should have been phased out for it are still getting it and the growth limitation adjustment is really hurting districts like Monroe with growing increased enrollment hold harmless provision has allowed districts with declining enrollment to receive the same amount of state aid uh as a frozen District who has increasing enrollment as Monroe all of these items were discussed in the testimony

068before the Senate and the assembly hearings on funding and that was Senator greenstein's first approach was to again eliminate adjustment Aid and redistribute it and U eliminate the growth limitation adjustments that is what essentially was done to create some of the monies with this additional state aid um that was distributed to school districts and we were um impacted because we received about 458,000 98 of additional state aid in the categorical special education Aid category [Music] well earned dividend to all of the taxpayers who have worked so hard to try to get this issue to the Forefront and get Monroe's uh taxpayers relieved from their burden of overfunding the school districts and uh therefore at finance committee we discussed the options of what to do with this money first option was uh to appropriate it the

069district could appropriate this additional state aid amount and spend it now you may recall from the budget final adoption um where Dr alvic and Dr kak were asked by me if this comprehensive budget covered all educational program and instruction needs if they were satisfied and the answer to that was yes there certainly are other areas that could always use Financial address but we were satisfied with the amount of funding that went into the 1718 budget um therefore the second option was to take that additional state aid award and this was the intent of all of those who had worked toward this all along appropriate it against the levy reduce taxes with the money and that is what the finance committee uh recommended unanimously to do so we have a resolution that's included in the agenda

070and I'd like to read it it is recommended that the members of the Monro Township Board of Education number one accept the revised categorical special education state aid amount of 243497 an increase of $48,900 from the previous reported state aid amount and two reduced the general fund local tax levy for the 17 18th school year by $48,990 school year any amount of bear with me m m got cut off 98 million1 13,993 it is further recommended that the Board of Education recognize and extend its appreciation for all of the efforts of the District administration State and Township officials the members of the ad hoc committee for fair funding the township residents who signed the petition in support of an increase in school aid and the township residents who travel to Trenton to testify at the

071Senate and assembly hearings the business administrative board secretary is hereby authorized and directed to take all steps necessary to implement this action by the Board of Education moved by Mr Ryback second by Mr rutsky comments questions I just have one question Mr you were asked if your budget is okay and you said yes does that include the baseballs number of baseballs that we might need yes thank you thank you Mr Braverman anyone else miss armino you know I almost lost my train of thought give me a minute he took the same question I was trying to count baseballs is that soft balls or just hard balls hard balls title alls included we we give everything it's fair to our equity okay good I'm happy to hear it I want to make sure we have soft

072balls in there but that was a hard ball question wasn't it yeah give me a minute to oh I lost my drain of anybody else like yeah somebody else talk before I Michelle speechless Michelle make not please put that in the record M Mr chirella yeah I I just wanted I want to uh just say that I I agree with this um I I do think that this should go uh toward tax abatement I think that it sends a message to our taxpayers that um even though our fight I believe anyway our fight is just beginning and there's a lot more for us to do um that nothing is off the table as of right now and that we need to continue to fight as hard as we can uh that we need to show

073them that if we do uh if we are victorious that we're not going to just take this money and and misappropriate it or squander it or buy helicopters or pools or something like that that were that this is all about um them and making sure that that they're that they're reimbursed for all of the money that uh they've been giving in excess to the state you know that that the state's been taking and I just want to I just want to quickly say and I don't want to step on this and make it negative but the state has been the bully on the Block and the state you know it's like this bully that comes down the street and takes shakes you down for your lunch money every day and then one day the bully's

074a little sick and not feeling so well so he only shakes you down for a little a little bit of money and he leaves you with a couple bucks in your pocket and you go away go ah he's not so bad thank you thank you for not taking all my money today and that's exactly what we're doing right now we're saying thank you thank you for doing this thank you for giving us $458,000 back when You' been taking Millions from us and giving us taking $40 million a year and giving us back 10% of that less than 10% of that and uh so I just want to make sure that that's clear so although you know I know uh we have a lot of people that are fighting out there and doing things we we

075still have to be cognizant of the of the exact predicament that we're in and I don't want us to get overzealous but I do want us to give this money back to the people thank you I I I remember right um and and we talked about for for the Public's sake because I was happy for the clarification we were we are still in time to return this money as a as a tax not really an abatement but to return this to the taxpayers because there would have been a time in the year that we couldn't do that is that correct could you just explain that a little bit yes I thought that was an important aspect that you um you know found you went to the source to make sure we could actually do this

076yes thank you for reminding me um the Board of Education and the residents may recall that uh two years ago the Board of Education resolved to put together a budget that was $600,000 under cap that money reduced what otherwise would have been required as an increase to the levy by that amount obviously if you went to cap and you you had to raise $600,000 more it would have increased taxes that year we had a satisfactory budget due to the excess Surplus that carried over um that um left $600,000 um under cap that $600,000 by Statute carries over to up to two years in the future as banked cap where the board May resolve to um appropriate it once again in a year in the future um it would of course would have a tax effect

077raising it when that money would be reappropriated in the future by specific guidance uh released by the state of New Jersey this money that's being used to reduce taxes this $458,000 is not eligible for Bank cap so the Board of Education will have only $600,000 of Bank cap available for next year's budget um and this $458,000 will be specifically excluded there was a lot of special terms and conditions with the state aid award um I had to contact the State on that because even according to our board attorney the language on here is so poor it can't be interpreted by a reasonable person either way but uh we got an answer from the state and it is not bankable uh the money is used direct one year to reduce the levy and that special award

078is gone they will consider that in the future with an anticipation there will be more special Awards coming I assume with that comment and we'll see but actually I also meant in addition to that that we have enough time to talk to the tax assessor and and put that in as part return part of this year's return to the taxpayer that is correct that was um one of the top things in the guidance was before you determined what you want to do with the money contact your local tax assessor and make sure that you can your your your estimated tax bills haven't gone out yet I spoke to George Lang uh the Chief Financial Officer of Monroe Township he said he it has not gone out yet we still have an opportunity to change it

079uh if if resolved by the board tonight to appropriate this against the tax levy I will revise the form a4f which is a certification of taxes downward by $458,000 reducing taxes through the community for the 171 18 year and then the bills will go out thank you anyone else Mr Ryback I too I have to agree with my colleague Mr Chella and Mr armino that um while we certainly need this money it's not anywhere's near enough um our state and I look forward to mentioning more on this and other board business uh has given us some money and is I guess given other districts some money um and I'm sure the other districts are saying it's not enough and we thank them for it I'm glad we're helping to reduce the tax bill you have

080taxpayers paying 87% of the uh cost of Education they deserve a break and we're trying to give them as much as we can but what I'm going to speak on later is that our state our governor is still approving charter schools and that's that's costing the public schools money so they get they have money for the charter schools but they're giving us this much uh in state aid and I'd like to mention a few things about that later but I just I just felt it was appropriate to bring that up now something that we might might want to consider in the ad High committee it's a great idea anyone else okay no I just wanted to say something um because I too um was grateful to get something from the state but when you're underfunded

081by $5 million and they give you 10% of that we're still underfunded and to think that we only get 3% of our budget from the state is just just very sad we're probably I don't think there's too many school districts out there that get lower percentage from the state than we do so I I know there there were districts out there who say well we get 40% we're underfunded and and you have to look at that and and you you're you think that's crazy because we only get 3% they get 40% and how how is that fair so I I also knew that when we were doing the petitions we spent a lot of time talking to our community and our residents and and especially our seniors and what we want to do to them

082is we we reduce the tax burden on them because it's not fair to our senior citizens who are probably 60% of Monroe Township maybe 50% live in in gated communities paying 88% of the share of Education in Monroe and for our students they're all supportive of what we do that's not the problem the problem is that it's just not fair to them to have to do that so um you know it's it's a little bit but I I think we don't stop fighting that we need to continue the fight because they can't think that we're complacent and say okay that's it we've got it and that's the end we need to keep working on this because not even a half a million dollars isn't going to do much for for our taxpayers so I just

083wanted to to say that so um roll call and Madam board president to that point phase two from uh the Greenstein letter and plan that was adopted by the board of education is to work toward a new funding formula and ultimately uh the school funding Reform Act of 2008 identifies Monroe Township as being too affluent and Wealthy to receive an adequate and fair amount of state aid and uh we must all work collaboratively to have a new funding formula and keep an eye on that uh for the first first available opportunity all right this resolution uh by Statute requires a 2third vote of the Board of Education to pass if it does not pass we will be required to have a special Board of Education meeting in order to uh resolve the matter so that

084is seven affirmative votes that are needed Mrs arino yes Mr Braverman yes Mr Chella yes m m lang yes Mrs Kino yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr rutsky yes and Mrs Kap panich yes madame board president I'm very pleased to say that the motion has passed unanimously thank you this is good news for our community okay so at this time we'll go to the board president's report and I'm going to be brief um usually in August sometime we do a board retreat where we can set goals and for both board goals and District goals so um we're looking at doing something probably the last week in August after our board meeting I think the board meeting is August 23rd so um what we're going to do is send home a little information and uh dates and

085see which dates available for what board members and whatever we can get the majority of the board to come to will be the date that we have our board retreat um we are also required to do a board self evaluation very similar to the board um superintendent evaluation it's online it can be accessed the same way so I'm going to um ask that we all complete that and then at the same time that we do the board retreat with the board goals we'll be able to talk about the board self-evaluation um I will be sending reminders home I think there's like five weeks that we can get that accomplished it's not going to take long to do that so um we'll we'll see as we go along how many can how how many we keep

086getting in and sending out reminders so that on August whatever um 23rd uh 29th 30th 31st that we have a a good meeting to discuss goals and the evaluation so that concludes my report and we'll go to Other Board business which I know Mr Ryback has something to say yes I took a moment to write something because I was kind of upset with something I read um I'd like to take a moment to thank Mrs Deo actually for her Facebook posting of yet another Charter School sham by the state this past Monday the governor approved five more Charter Schools Newark will get two Patterson Asbury Park and Lakewood will each get one in May Lakewood received 8.5 million in extra aid from the state because it was facing a $15 million uh shortfall has our

087state Ed commissioner considered the fiscal impact of these charter schools on the public schools three of the approved charter schools are still waiting for fac for facilities so the process approves the money before any physical location is Sol solid who in the state Ed department is approving these applications how many people work on them how long does it take for an application to be approved how well are applications vetted are leaders of approved Charter Schools vetted or does anyone even with the failing record uh get the head one up the Facebook posting mentioned um someone who is uh uh chosen to head up uh I think two of these Charter Schools this person had failing records in other states uh I think this is just a shame that we're looking at getting um funding from

088the state in minuscule Manner and they say they have no money but they obviously have plenty of money to fund charter schools and I think they have to get their priorities uh in order either they support Public public education or they don't thank you anyone else I'm just going to be very quick on the same matter about funding um we also have to remember that locally part of our um our abundance of student enrollment has to do with the local uh construction that's going on and all of those decisions are made at the local level so as well as participation and our uh our voices to the state I think it's still uh prudent of us to make our voices known in the in the township Council in the planning board and because all of

089those decisions are are actually the impact that we're feeling with um uh the high enrollment that we're going so a lot of the and and a lot has been said about well we have no choice the state mandates it that's not entirely true um the the township is responsible for the master plan and of course once they vote for the master plan that's only a plan the ordinances are made by our local officials and those ordinances allow a lot of leeway to con to the to builders so who gets the profit the builders do who gets to pay the taxes the uh citizens do so citizen participation uh would be well spent also on on the local level thank you anyone else Mr tiella yes uh thank you I I uh well well said Mr

090Reno and and you know well said also to you Mr Ryback both both of you made wonder you know Wonderful points I think I think it's a travesty uh what's going on with the charter schools and how we're funding them and how we're taking uh money away from public education and supposedly free public schools which we' we know are not free um and Miss Armenia I think you're right you've hit the nail right on the head again uh with regards to that and I think it's very important and it's kind of disheartening to see the the the lack of the level of participation and knowledge by uh people in our community who feel you could see when you talk to them that they could feel that something's not right they know that they're not uh

091thrilled with things that are going on but they can't put their finger on it well they can't put their finger on it because they're not they don't know and the only way you can know is by getting involved so those were great points um everyone else stole my thunder tonight including Mr Gorski with the 458,000 so all I'm going to say is um uh we're we're going to have a uh funding a fair funding ad hoc committee meeting on the 9th I'll send that email out to the committee tonight uh at 7:00 p.m. here it's open to the public and um you know we'll we just we have our we have an agenda and we discuss it and we go through everything there so anybody who would like to come to that is welcome to

092come to that but our our committee will be um just be the ones participating obviously that's it thank you thank you for that information anyone else okay seeing no one we will go back to the public forum anyone from the public wishing to speak please come to the microphone uh state your name and address for the record and we will adhere to our 4minute timeline this way over here he's just going to take your picture he's smart uh good evening Harold Kane 40b Newport Way in Rossmore uh tonight I'm here on behalf of American post 522 um this past April I had the honor of sitting in on the boy State evaluation committee from the post uh it was the first time I've done it and I have to thank you guys for the 11

093outstanding young men who came to uh the interview uh I was astounded I couldn't believe it uh I made a couple of notes Here I expected educated young men but their perception maturity and focus especially on the future it flored the three of us uh we grew up in a different era um people graduated from high school back then and you went in service you might have gone to college uh there were no Junior community colleges at the time it was a whole different world and you kind of floundered around and hope you could find your spot in it uh these young men are going to make their own spots they're not going to wait for anybody to tell them what to do or give them permission so we we found that was fabulous uh

094the the down side to it was there were 11 young men we could only pick three so we had um three delegates to boy state three alternates and five right up front we had to tell them sorry guys we'd love to take you but we can't and that hurt a lot um of the three finalists and uh the one young man who's going to become an eagle scout next month um is going to probably choose between West Point and the Air Force Academy uh the other two young men and um the finalists also U both said they want to be biomedical engineers and they were interviewed separately so they weren't there together and both expect in the future to own their own companies uh for 16 years old that's phenomenal I mean these guys are

095looking at the future and they're part they're going to make the future we're going to sit here and all watch it Go by um I I guess just one other word other than it was it was an honor to meet them and to uh participate with boy State and we're going to do it again next year as well as the oratory contest I would just like to give you one word is just keep up the good work you're doing great thank you thank you thank you we're very proud of the education that is going on in mon Township and the quality of our students and the um the places that they're heading to after they get out of Monro Township High School they it's amazing where they're going and what they want to do and

096and a lot of them have a wonderful Futures ahead of them we're very proud of that thank you anyone else from the public okay seeing no one we'll close the public forum go to the close session resolution be it resolved that the Board of Education of the township of Monroe hereby moves to go into closed session in accordance with the Sunshine Law chapter 231 of the public laws of 1975 njsa 10 col 4-6 through 10 col 4-21 to discuss the following subjects harassment imitation in intimidation and bullying a Donaldson appearance a superintendent evaluation following Clos section action may be taken the discussion conducted in closed session can be disclosed to the public as such time as the need for confidentiality no longer exists Mr Mr Chella you moveed it he only has to be second

097oh and I didn't know that he just told me that so I second well we usually take a motion a move a second so okay good um all in favor I opposed abstain Mr Mr Mr grman opposes okay so at this time the board will go into close session we'll move into close session and we're going into the back room M the are you you're back for the beginning okay at this time the board will move into public session and I'm just writing down the time it's midnight I think no I think it's 10:08 and um seeing no recommendation from the superintendent is that's correct Madam president okay our next Board of Education meeting will be on Wednesday August 23rd 2017 at the mon Township High School Media Center I need a motion to adjourn

098motion Mr rutsky oh I got to write that down too and Mr Ryback okay all in favor I opposed then the meeting is adjourned

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.