001good evening the meeting of the Monroe Township Bo of Education will come to order please stand for the Pledge of [Music] Allegiance i al to the flag of the United States of America and to the stands nais may we have a roll call Mr Gorski certainly Mrs armeno yes Mr Braverman here Mr cherella here Mrs Deo yes Mrs kapano here Mrs Lang Mrs Corino here Mr Ryback here Mr Russo here and Mr rutzky here Madame board president you have a quarum present this evening thank you in accordance with the provisions of the New Jersey open public meetings law the Monro Township Board of Education has cause notice of this meeting to be published by having the date time and place thereof posted August 17 2018 at all schools the home News Tribune the cranberry press
002and filed with the clerk of the municipality thank you um if everybody could see their agenda they will notice that the board president's report has been moved to the beginning of the agenda this evening and as you as I would like to address the concerns of the community in regard to the trailers and I'd like to do this at the beginning of the meeting instead of having everybody wait and have their questions asked at the um second public forum because the trailers are not on the agenda today so I'm going to be reading a chronology of the trailer project development and it might be a little bit long but please bear with me and everything that I will mention is has been documented and I have the whole chronology right here of um the trailer
003project so to begin a community ad hoc meeting was held on December 7th 2015 this was the first recorded public discussion on the potential need for classroom trailers the need for the trailers carried throughout the ad hoc process the student growth advisory committee met five times times between January and June 2016 the need for trailers was discussed at various times during during those five meetings in September 2016 after the student growth advisory committee had was finished District administration began to explore trailer options for monreal Township Middle School to establish budgets for board consideration the initial discussion revolved around the replicating the trailer installations that had previously been done at this site when it was the Monro Township High School the public board meeting of September 14th 2016 appears to be the first discussions on potential
004for adding trailers when a member of the public inquired about the need for trailers in the district during the course of the 2016 2017 school year there were references at various meetings regarding the potential for trailers and the early thoughts were that they would needed at both oak tree school and the Monro tangent Middle School at the public board meeting of June 14 2017 during public forum the same member of the public made a request for water and restroom facilities in the trailers at the middle school the bg& meeting of July 17th 2017 included a discussion of potential trailer needs for the middle school and for oak tree School the g&t committee requested that Administration explore the option of Porter John's for use at the middle school trailers Dr kosak conducted administrative meetings on July
00520th and July 27th 2017 to review demographic reports location of the trailers and potential sites and schools for trailers required attendees at these meetings included the principles of both oak tree school and the middle school between August 15th excuse me between August 11th and August 15 2017 Dr kak directed the administration to meet to specifically review the need for trailers at Oak Tree the bg& committee met on August 21st 2017 which was a year ago this month and included a discussion and a recommendation for the installation of trailers with restrooms at the middle school only an aerial view of the proposed trailer placement was provided for the committee to review at the meeting the public Board of Education meeting on August 23rd included a committee report that updated the public on the trailers with restrooms
006the pgnt committee meeting of October 2nd 2017 included a discussion on planning for the trailers at the middle school and again an aerial view of the proposed trailer placement was again provided to the committee for review at the meeting meeting the public board meeting of October 18th 2017 included a bg& committee report that informed the public of the forthcoming trailers on December 4th 2017 an email was sent to the Monro Township Middle School principal from the director of facilities when it attached proposal of the Middle School trailers including a diagram showing the placement of the trailers that same evening December 4th 2017 a bg& committee met and reviewed the detailed proposal from the trailer contractor for the trailers at the middle school the public Board of Education meeting of December 13 2017 included a committee
007report that informed the the public the contract for the trailers at uh the middle school at the public Board of Education meeting of January 24th the board passed a resolution award in a contract for trailers at the middle school and approved the submission of a trailer project application through the department the New Jersey Department of Education the resolution for the trailers was unanimously approved by the board 10 to0 attached to the January 24th agenda that went home to the board members was a copy of the contract including a diagram of the area where the trailers would be placed that information was also available to to all the members of the public who attended the board meeting that a that evening along with the copy of the agenda the board agenda the location of the trailers
008was selected long before the referendum was voted on and not in any retaliation to the referendum defeat the results of the referendum was going to determine whether we would need to lease the trailers for three years or for 5 years so if that had passed we would only need to have the trailers for 3 years since it did not pass we need to at least um rent those trailers for 5 years miscellaneous news articles informed the public that trailers would be installed to address the growth at the middle school articles in the Sentinel and home news included quotes from the superintendent and the building principal of the Middle School in regard to the need for the trailers the trailer project was also discussed at many referendum presentations throughout the community on May 20 second the
009Department of Education issued trailer project approvals the need for trailers also went through the budget philosophy meeting last September 2017 and had to go through the budget defense rounds with the Middle School Administration in order to have the cost of the trailers included in the 2018 2019 operating budget the trailer project and location of the trailers was approved by our district architect design ideas group the county interim superintendent the New Jersey Department of Education the township also gave the district building permits for the trailers it did not need to go through the zoning board or the planning board the decision of the trailer placement was not taken Lighty and was deliberate on deliberated on by many people many times during the past year and a half and no one person should be blamed for this
010decision we have listened to the public about their Safety and Security concerns and are doing everything in our power to make sure all students and staff will be in a safe secure and healthy environment lastly there have been many questions about the growth at of the student population at the middle school in the past month of July 73 new students were registered including 10 new students at the high school and 18 new students at the middle school which indicates that the student population continues to grow at the middle school so that's the chronological um explanation of the trailers and how we got to them today and at this time I would like to open up the public for public forum for anybody who has questions or needs would like to make a comment or um
011just has a question for anybody in in the district in regard to the safety concerns where the trailers are why where how um so I I will do that but I'm also we're going to stick to our 4-minute time limit a participant must be recognized by the presiding officer each statement will be limited to four minutes duration or less and the four minutes shall include any response by the representative representative of the board if they're still continued to answer we will continue to um if they're in the middle of answering we will continue to let them answer no participant may speak more than once during each of the three public forums so at this time I I know I believe we have um the building super uh building principal for and vice principal and vice
012principal here to ask School questions and um Mr tag is here to answer other questions so anyone who wishes to come to the microphone please state your name your and your address for the record and we will adhere to our for minute time limit and be available to answer your questions okay hi Lauren clerkin 33d Avenue um my concern is I understand the need for trailers and I'm okay with that and the location is not desirable to most parents my other issue besides the location and the safety is the kids going in and out of the school I mean I understand that they talked about the Jersey blocks and putting a fence up and stuff what about the kids going in and out of the school for lunch gym electives how are they going to
013handle that like I emailed Miss Chanley I have not heard anything about how she's going to handle that and I'm just curious how that safety and Logistics is going to work Mrs Chanley would you like to come up here and we have um okay yes so yeah that that would be fine it doesn't it doesn't make a differ thank you very much I don't have to State my name do I do I need to State my name oh okay welcome everybody um that is really an easy question to respond to as a person who has tremendous experience with trailers I've been here 15 plus years and I had three sets of trailers at Apple goth Middle School um which actually totaled more than the amount of trailers I'm going to have at this current middle
014school and in that situation exactly like the situation we had to have children that go back and forth so what we're going to do is exactly what we did then we're going to do once again except I'm actually more comfortable with this situation because the trailers are directly in front of our main entrance to the building we will have Security in the trailers at all times one security guard at a minimum at all times will be located in the trailers I'm just trying to be respectful and speak directly to them um so we're going to have a security guard that will be in the trailers as well as a security guard at the main entrance desk once again that's always and we always you use our utilize our radios and walkie-talkies so for those individualized
015children who may need to come in for the nurse guidance speech um child study team an administrative office work with the teacher extra time during Maybe per where they were told to retake a test they will then be escorted if not by the specific security guard but by an individualized adult regardless of who that adult is at all times that's the first thing also our side of vision is exceptional we actually have the ability which we did not at Apple go to look out and actually see a child come down the ramp we have two areas one is the long ramp that you will see that's elongated as well as the stair area and both of those areas go directly to the sidewalk they do not need in any way to step into the street
016or the actual parking lot area so that's the first thing as far as the lunch is concerned we did a change this year for whatever reason our Lunch Period had always gone 68 and seven there was a logical reason at the time and I have to be honest it was eight years ago I don't remember what the logical reason was we have revamped the bell schedule we now go 6th 7th and 8th the reason being is when the children come in for lunch they will also then go to their respective either cycle or gym depending upon the ab schedule so that means they will have to come in as a group force not talking about the individualized children I'm talking about the entire two teams will then enter the building they will then go to
017lunch and they will then go to their respective either gym or elective so these are things that we've already looked at um did I answer your specific questionsa and we've also discussed weather M chy can you also add the um process for drop off in the morning and pickup sure and then I'll talk about weather if you'd like me to so the process for drop off and pickup really is is also very much more simplistic than you would think think because the drop off is always in the back so children that come through the back and may have a classroom I don't know 101 which is literally right where they would come to the front of the building those same children are going to walk through the school just like they would as if they
018were going to M Smith's classroom or um you know I'm trying to think of someone else someone else's classroom right there they're located right there in the front of the building and they will then walk right out where once again we have security guards administrat and we always have approximately five to seven teachers that are on duty so drop off won't be any different I would like to if I may fin so the drop off though let's say your child is late it's not going to be any different your child is late your child must come to the main entrance sign in they get the same pass they've always gotten and now the same routine will happen that security guard we always have two in the morning just so you know at the front desk
019will get up and will physically escort your child they will radio up to the other security guard that will come out of the trailer building once again eyesight very very convenient we didn't have that I remember we didn't we it was far away this is really close there so children will always have some form of an adult escort I would say that 85% of the time it will be a security guard but for any reason the security guard is not available then it'll be an adult have three BPS and myself it could be one of us but it will be an adult inclement weather we already have what we call a plan B schedule so what's going to happen is every teacher who's assigned a classroom in the trailers will have an Al location an
020alternative classroom within the school so that if we have inclement weather which we have had we actually snow is probably not even as bad as rain but let's say we had a torrential rain you know the skies opened up and here comes that rain it could last an hour it could last 20 minutes we know those children will be given an alternate schedule and we'll make the same announcements I do now when I have the situation because now I have the situation where maybe kids are going outside to gym so it's going to be treated as part of our school and it's going to be handled with the same problem more consideration of these inclement weather or whatever the issues might be thank you you're very welcome thank you Mrs Chanley uh prakash parab 33
021Dana Drive uh during the buildings and grounds and building committee meeting I thanks the chair for allowing parents to speak and it went for 1 hour so did you make a list of the question the parent asked so we don't want to go through the drama again because did you all make the list of the questions and did you all pass on to the principal of the Middle School to address those so that is my first question why that list was not prepared you went through the long list to say how logical it was for we knew the trailers were coming but the placement of the trailer you give us the areial view God only knows who can see that so when the trailers were put people start you had 2,000 people signed and give
022you the petition where is the answer for that and you decided to put certain barriers and all why you all didn't report today you all have to report what was the conclusion of the meeting we had last week no youall are not doing that giving a laundry list how it was logical to put the trailers there youall you know there is a Transformer pole there with a Transformer on the top you know bad weather or anything the fire Sparks can come and put the fire on the trailers the guy's crazy guy can stand next to the road and start shooting at the trailers is the trailer bulletproof now you are saying oh we'll put the barriers now we are going to put the barriers that barriers were not even included in the budget now you're
023giving me 4 minutes to talk I answer all the questions which were asked during the committee meeting please that's my question can I'm going to ask Mr T to please um come up and address the security and the safety issues that we discussed at the meeting um on I believe it was last Wednesday and give an update on what we plan to do certainly good evening Jerry T uh the discussion and the conclusion was that we were going with two rows of concrete Jersey barriers uh the first delivery came in today the installation will start tomorrow and in between that will be a solid steel corated metal fence to serve as a barrier there also be some Landscaping to buffer some of the Acoustics as well okay is the um because I know the one
024of the questions would be would the the fence that we're installing is it bulletproof no it is not it's not Bulletproof the trailer is not bulletproof nor is the school building itself any of our bu none of our buildings are bulletproof okay um in regard to the I know the question and regarding the um the Transformer yes we we reached out to JC PN jcpnl who was the installer for that and they said that it cannot be moved and that is the placement for the poll in the Transformer okay and I know that we have already requested um that the the county because Pineville is a County Road see if that that the um speed limit can be decreased yes and we were contacted by I believe Sergeant jeno at from the mono Township Police
025Department uh he has reached out to the county on that they have talked about adding additional signage through the road department reinforcing what already exists in terms of a slower speed limit they also made a suggestion for the board to consider uh to put flashing lights as is done at the other schools they are not currently in front of the high school or middle school but they are at the other schools okay thank you and I will I will announ say too that at many of the presentations that we've done and here too we've always said that the the um trailers will be located in the upper parking lot of the middle school and that's exactly where they are located as in the upper parking lot of the middle school thank you president you know
026the questions there were several questions from the parents that day I wish we had 185 students are going to go there so which grade students are going to go are they going to be rotated or the same students are going to stay there for 12 months whatever school year so that was a concern you know okay thank you sure Dr Pros so I took all of the information that we had from the committee I met with Mrs chandley and Mr Jocko for an extended period of time they were very prepared to respond to all the concerns of the parents especially operational dayt day um so any other question that comes up I know Mr jockel and Mrs Chanley are here to answer any questions that we may have missed and any discussions uh from the
027meeting the other night um so they're fully prepared to answer parent questions if we missed one in responding to any of the parents tonight Mr gal thank you very much I think it will parents will be very calm the answers to those questions will be published or whatever the good way the communication is done we do appreciate what you done thank you very much please communicate those so we are also uh as soon as the trailers are get a CEO to occupy Mr T will let us know and Mrs Chanley Mr Jocko are planning an orientation for the students date and time to be determined and uh we hope to invite parents to that as well so they feel uh less concerned about their child being out there thank you Mrs Chanley would you like
028to address the question about who is going to be in the trailers and are they going to be rotated with different uh during the whole year the different classes so we intentionally sat down and had a conversation to see which group because they're all equal to me I mean not all equal to you because they're your kids but to me sixth seventh and eighth grade and we really felt that seventh graders would have the least difficult time actually I'm going to make a statement the children are not going to have any difficult times just like I say all my orientations the problems and I respect this as a mother the problems are always with us as the adults the children are extremely adaptable and they usually wind up having zero issues so the children that
029we selected purposely were the seventh graders sixth graders are my babies they come in they're in an environment all downstairs which is actually where my my office is located as well as the sixth grade vice principal and the eighth graders are the big guys on campus and they want to feel like the big guys on campus so they want to be upstairs that's just the mentality of a middle school child so we selected seventh graders what we did was and and I want to do thank the board um as well as when we went through all of our budget considerations we were permitted to go ahead and extend our growth and now we will have four te in the sixth grade six teams in the seventh grade and four teams in the eighth grade why
030the larger excuse me the more teams I have the smaller the team is the smaller the class size is so by having six teams in seventh grade it allows me to put two teams outside and no they will not be rotated that is not what would be best um academically pedagogically emotionally or socially for children and the children will be selected randomly all children have selected randomly as of right now for those of you that have come to my orientation either this year or any of the years that I've had your older children they are literally selected almost like playing cards and then the computer does the rest so two teams will be placed in the outside will any considerations be given medical considerations are given but other than that what I do for one
031I'd have to do for all and we do have approximately 100 to 185 children placed out there and um similar like we did once again I've had two other sets of trailers at the at the last school where I was vice principal and principal and that is what it looks like so no they will not be rotated out they will remain on those two teams okay thank you you're welcome anyone else from the public have any comments or questions in regard to the trailers hi Ram ragat 6 strive mandro um question I had is uh for this year right if we had not put in the trailers would would we have been able to get by what is the differential in enrollment we're going to see this year what is the last I heard the
032middle school has eclipsed 1,700 students um that's estimated 500 students over functional capacity of that building um could we survive uh probably but uh the idea was to reduce class size so teachers can focus on less students in class and we continue to see from whatever report we get or actual enrollment that the Middle School is certainly in need of additional classroom space and um so yes could we survive without them but it would not be ideal classroom situations uh that we have seen over the last few years that's why the decision made was made to get the trailers okay thank you uh the other question I had is were were all the Boe members did you vote unanimously in terms of the location of the trailers or was someone else made that decision well
033the Board of Education always has to be the the last um right group of people who support anything and it was unanimously supported in January the board of education did get um the all the information that came in their packet and there was a a a um illustration um and I believe it was an area photo of where the trailers would be located great and then the last question I had is uh in considering putting these trailers in the back uh was that for example even considered and what would have been the difference or additional cost or what have you in putting it in the back is um Jerry can Jerry sure Jerry I I'll I'll steal from Mr T uh you can do anything but at a cost and Mr T if you want
034to just follow up because you have a long history of trailers in the back at that current building certainly there had been trailers behind the former high school and that was prior to the 1997 Edition so where the addition and the team rooms are constructed is where those trailers set the sewer service for the building exits through the front of the building there is a sewage ejection pump which is located in the interior of the former Boiler Room so in essence if you needed to tie in sewer and water or sewer for the trailers you would have had to literally you know gone through the building itself board underneath the building or open up the back section of the building something that really just wasn't feasible could it have been done yes was it appropriate
035for a three-year window no it didn't seem appropriate Mr Goodall would you like to um talk about when the trailers were there at the high school when you were there having had experience uh at the old high school now the current Middle School uh we had about 15 trailer classrooms on a double Y trailer for extra physical education classes um they did not have access to running water and sewer uh it posed although we uh lessened class size which was ideal for teaching it caused a lot it caused a lot of logistical problems and supervision problems with kids constantly going in and out of the building to use the restrooms uh in the near the gym area uh kids being called to come in and out uh for going to the nurse going to the
036vice principal's office coming to the main office being picked up and it was just very very difficult for 3 years two to three years I got phone calls and complaints about children being out in those trailers and it it the calls and complaints did um go down once they started to see the framework for the new high school so there was light at the end of the tunel but our experience it was not an ideal situation not having water and sewer and I would adly anytime we have trailers have water and sewer thank you I know my time is up uh I guess many of us wish it was a bit different much more safer days differently of course the Aesthetics looks pretty bad we're paying a lot of taxes and you drive by manro
037Middle School we'll be thinking wait a minute is this the town I want to move in but I guess putting all that aside I think we have to trust that you have done the right uh risk reward benefit analysis of putting in the sewer in the back and tying it up maybe even pushing it by a year that's why I asked my first question so I guess we have to trust that you have done that risk reward cost analysis and you're comfortable with the risk and what have you with the kids that this is the best outcome because we have to live with it I would say for at least 5 years and so we the public at least myself I'm putting the Trust on you that you have done that analysis and you feel
038that uh there's no other better solution and this is the best thing keeping the children in mind okay thank you for that sir and we are going to try to have a better aesthetically pleasing view from the road for the community but we're focusing on function and safety first got it thank you vessing 13 Jake Place uh my question is does anybody looked into moving the administrat office or some office to the trailer in of the classroom oh is it the um moving the moving the offices into the trailers yeah and then having the classrooms in the offices I'll let Mrs Chan speak to that and then another question to her uh I think like right now she has decided to just keep only two teams in the trailer yes I'm thinking just revisit that
039logic was my personal feeling uh those two teams might feel I don't know like offended or something like that they are not feeling good that they always have to go to the uh trailer instead of we can rotate it that will be good so whatever like we decided how we decided if is possible to have some more discussion on that that will help thanks thank you and I'll let Mrs Chanley talk about the um having offices in the trailers for anyone that's had an opportunity I know some of the board members have to come and view what we've done we have pinched every single square foot out of that building we have I just recently relocated um closets and made them offices to be honest with you for additional support staff so it would have
040been impossible we if we moved our offices out and let's say um our administrative offices speech um guidance the room capacity that we are in if you saw it does not fit classrooms it would even fit small group instruction but yet accommodate a class of anywhere between 23 to 30 so that was not possible that was definitely not possible we did look at other scenarios we did look at other scenarios what would it look like if we put World Language outside which I had a World Language trailer over at appleo previously rather than to do it as teams we looked at so many different scenarios because for us the least upsetting way of doing it for our parents for our public for our children is better for us less stress so we wanted to make
041it that way it the only way it really worked to truly equally get class siiz down in all of the content areas was to place teams because the way we are we actually function as now a 14 school school so in other words your child's team has their own schedule it almost functions as an its individual school so the only way that would make utilization of the best time for 56 minutes and have less children in and out on a on a 56 minute period was to place two teams out there um we did respectfully we hear you and we did look at it we were thinking maybe a Ral language trailer things that were feasible that would work and um I can't speak yet because I wouldn't think to speak for the children or
042the parents but um the activities and everything else that they're doing it's really not going to be any different because we're parted so whether they walk out of the trailer classroom and walk walk next door and walk across the hall for there for a classroom pod is not any different what they're going to do in the building as far as large group instruction activities uh performances in the pack um any type of um award ceremonies and activities that they do per team everything is going to be treated identical to those teams that are in the building there will not be any differences of any kinds as far as the classroom the classrooms are just newer actually nicer in the trailers other than that there will be no differences they will not in any way and
043I'm going to use the Expression be sure changed the activities that they have currently are going to be the same activities whether they're on a team in the trailer or team in the building thank you deal any I don't know if if people realize and I would be happy to have this discussion with people if they wanted me to what goes into scheduling and classroom location is enormous today was the very first day that I could even allow the teachers back into the building where I know elementary schools had opened up a little bit earlier it is not feasible from an operational standpoint I'm not even talking educationally right now I'm talking actual management if we had to move those and do a flip let's say nine weeks like we used to do for the
044Mustang Cafe before it was the Falcon Cafe that was doable because all we were doing was telling the children eating this cafeteria versus this cafeteria if we were to change the teams you're changing everything from the setup of the classrooms the Comfort level and the comfortability of children children life routine and that's the other part of it so that would for managerial purposes it would not be a positive experience for the kids or for the teachers and that is why we decided to place two teams out there um and not do a rotation because once we're set we give classroom Keys we give um classroom information uh did teachers learn you're worried about safety they learn about protocol and routine and procedure as far as fire drill evacuation lockdown shelter in place all of these
045things we train our teachers regularly and ongoing based upon the location of where they are so it would not have been feasible or would have been in the best interest of the children from a safety Point operational point educational or social emotional and that is why we didn't do a rotation Mrs Chanley um a teacher setting up a a their classroom in the trailer would do it the same way they would set it up if this identical right except everything they have is brand new okay that helps nice yeah thank you you're welcome Krishna deal love and Jake BL um you said um it was previously mentioned in this meeting that um on in January meeting there was a discussion about the trailers right so I went back um last meeting it was discussed so
046I went back looked at the agenda and the Board of Education approved meetings um so if I was to recollect without looking at the agenda I can recall three things from the January meeting one Dr kak U was given his notice letter two the teachers did not have a contract and three we had a referendum in March so anyways going back looking at the um approved meeting um agenda and U the minutes here's what is in the agenda uh this is item P mandro Township Middle School temporary classroom units it is recommended that members of the mro Township Board of Education approve the submission of portable classrooms and card cardiovascular PE trailers SP number as temporary space at the mundro township Middle School to the state of New Jersey Department of Education School of facilities
047for review as an other Capital project furthermore the Board of Education authorizes the amendment of the director districts approved long range facilities plan correct correct U so this was discussed and it was no at that point of time it was not mentioned that these trailers are going to be on the parking lot where they are located the board of educ oh go ahead if you no no go ahead um the Board of Education had received that information uh in their packet we had been they had received it before that too because we talked about it numerous times over the past year and a half with a diagram as to where those those trailers would be placed it was also available to the public who attended that evening there's agenda and then there's the follow-up backup
048information so that information including the diagram of where the trailers were going to be was available ailable to the public in January when we voted on the trailers right here's the question that I'm saying but that doesn't that you know the plan does not say or the language here in the board of meeting minutes or the agenda does not say that is where the trailers are going to be located it says it is recommended that the member of members of mandro Township approve the um approve the submission of portable units it's like you know hey you're submitting Port trailers for facilities and everybody would look at it and say yes you know what irrespective of where the referendum lands we are going to have trailers well the I mean we we we are dissecting legal
049e here right I mean if you're trying to hang it on a legal e matter that's fine well I believe any resolution goes through our board attorney so she approves the resolutions but the information the backup information did go home to all the board members so they should have had an understanding of what they were voting on that evening sure and the other comment that I made last time and I want to make it again is you know there was no active involvement of the parent Community asking them for feedback a lot of the things that uh the parents had brought in um good bad or ugly there were some options that were provided not necessarily all of them maybe valid but some of them were worth looking into um we should have had some
050parents come in and get this feedback to you and saying that you know we've approved it the board of members approved it and it was not even on the I mean a lot of parents that day came out and spoke in favor of the in favor of the parents Dr kak and the referenda okay all right thank you thank you gazala Bora one Miko Drive um I want to start by apologizing um after last week's 15th August meeting we found out that there was an aerial map in the uh meeting minutes and the meeting agenda that was circulated um I am apologizing because I as a citizen did not look into it I did not pay attention I knew the trailers were coming they'd been coming for a long time and I knew the board
051was voting on it and the board did vote on it and that would have been what I expected the board to do yes please vote because we need a trailers I did not dig deep into it I did not look at the aerial map so I yes that was I didn't do my due diligence had I seen the map would have probably made some noise then and most of us would have made some noise then so while we didn't do our due diligence I have to say that the members of the board also didn't do the due diligence and the reason I'm saying that today is because um in July when we actually realized where the trailers are going to be and we signed a petition 2,000 people signed the petition it was an issue
052then and then the board also realized the need for the Jersey um barriers uh they realized that there is a security issue why was this not realized in January I know you elected officials you all have your own lives and you're volunteering your time but there is a level of responsibility that is more yours than mine in this in doing due diligence um this is the this is the future of our Town's children this is their safety um a mistake has happened and the board has scrambled in the past month and I do appreciate the effort of the administrators um I would specifically say thank you to Mr Goodall for taking the time to meet I I don't know how many people he has met off late who' have complained to him through emails and
053try to put the concerns to rest um I do not doubt Mrs chandy's ability to handle the situation even for a second because she has been handling a middle school with 1700 kids seamlessly so no we do not doubt our Educators but we have been let down by the administration in approving a plan like this and and scrambling for something so last minute when the kids are going to be in it two week two weeks later um I do am a little bit at peace with the road safety issue now with the Jersey barriers I know the cars can't directly get to the trailers anymore so that is a little relieving however my security safety concerns about a perpetrator throwing a stone in or shooting a gun in is still there I still as a
054parent am going to worry about it um just in March we put we decided to put armed guards in schools and we have come to a point where most of our schools all of our schools have armed guards so now the two questions I have is um the first one is is there going to be an armed guard in the trailer Mrs Chanley is shaking her head yes okay can which is something that we would do we I think on our agenda tonight we have three retired police officers on the agenda for approval all of them will be armed and um I believe one of them will be in the trailers that does give me some peace now the other question that I had in mind was that the vulnerability of the trailers is to
055the roadside and the armed God is probably going to have his desk facing the school because he's going to be collaborating with the other God on the other side so is there is there any possibility of having somebody do rounds I'm sure yeah that's one of those rounds off the trailer towards the street all our armed guards do rounds during the day throughout the building many times there will be somebody walking wonderful now my last question is the fire drills how do we handle fire drills for students who are in the trailer Mrs Chanley would you like to respond to that one um our plans that we've been doing were not within the last couple weeks so we had you know we knew that the trailers were coming so we sat down even before school
056ended I actually met with Mr Pio and we discussed all of these things as far as um scheduling the children changing the lunch schedule and so forth so I did want everybody to know that that's something that we did even before any meeting took place um we went ahead and addressed the fire drills the only difference really is that that used to be one of the locations where we were allowed to do our um fryer drill as well as our evacuation drill because we also do a bomb thread drill so we do the mandated Plus usually a few extra drills um monthly so now what's going to happen is the children that would normally be standing where the actual trailers are are now going to go to the turf field along with the children in
057that building for those of you that may have gone by recently although we're going to be using the front entrance way so that's the entrance way that we be facing um on the closest side I should say to the main entrance with the long spiral because that's what's going to have the canopy over it that particular area will be the natural egress however during a fire Dr we're going to sit down and also go through the fact that we split up the building just like we do now and we have four classrooms that'll go out the back four classrooms that will go out the front and then once again they will only be on sidewalks so it is not going to cause any threat of any kind we will follow the same procedure that we
058do now the children will exit the building I'm calling it a building because I want them to feel like it's going to be their home so they will exit that building and they will follow the same exact line of retriev retrieval and removal except instead of walking back toward the front they come down the ramp they follow the walkway which is the actual which has been there it's our sidewalk all the way down and then they'll follow the rest of the children that are going out towards the um which is actually the soccer field our turf field that we refer to is actually our soccer field and we've made those changes and we'll follow the same guidelines the fire department does come in they go over our egress Maps they go over our which is
059also visual to the children and then of course we practice it with the kids so it's not going to affect us at all it's just a different space that the children will go to thank you Mrs chair um you can ask a question if you have because your time is up just 30 30 thank you Mrs Chanley just 30 more seconds uh since this has been done in such a rush and there are still parents not very convinced I just wanted to make a suggestion that if a committee could be set up for after a month or two after the school starts of parents whose kids are in the trailer and get a feedback as to what the Comfort level is how the children are dealing with this and and maybe if needed if this
060needs to be rethought then we have the whole year to plan that I know nothing can be done for this whole but I I I would like to suggest as a parent I and my kid is not a seventh grader this year but I feel like if my kid was a seventh grader I would have liked to revisit this a couple months after school stars um a small committee with parents who that would not be a problem wonderful and the last suggest request that I have for the board now that this has happened this is behind us we have bigger problems bigger fish to fry in this district with referendums coming up for high school extensions and new Middle School I feel like there should be more deliberation at every process there is a lot
061of things that are sliding through the cracks and then there is Major appro happening every time I feel like we need to be a little bit more transparent if possible and more due diligence on both our part and your part because we are going through some challenging times in our town and we'll get through this but we need to get through this without all the drama that's happening around everything thank you so much thank you I will say too um all of our committee meetings are open to the public we do our deliberation during our committee meetings because um it it's it lacks a quarum so we can't make any um we can't vote on committee so we bring that to the full board but the deliberation part happens in all our committee so anybody
062in the public is welcome to attend anyone except for personnel M pres I just make a quick comment about that can we go through the um all right but I need to comment exactly what you just said though goad just very quickly um we do have limit and taking uh a member of the Public's uh advice one of the problems with the Committees is that they're only an hour and very often close very often we are rushed through and we can't get to the details very often of it and don't forget we're not supposed to micromanage the uh District so a lot of times we're told that we just have to take um the recommendations of uh you know the supervisors or administrators or things like that and sometimes we don't get all of the
063details that we've asked for uh and so I would I hope that that we open that up a little bit more and maybe we need more time in committees we can't just have an hour sometimes sometimes we're talking about very important things oh and I agree with you because I know that even policy we've had special policy meetings this year we don't have enough time so it's something that I think we need to look at starting in September maybe we need two days of committee meetings and have them go an hour and a half because that I know that has been an issue in the past and and sometimes uh and deliberation is good in committee meetings but the open public meetings act and I'll talk about that in a few minutes the open public
064meetings act does require that we deliberate in public we can't just vote yet yes or no I mean we can and a lot of municipalities and a lot of board of educations just have yes votes or no votes mostly just yes across the board but that's not really a democratic process the open public meetings act says sometimes we have to take long meetings and deliberate and give everybody all board members a chance to express their their views so thank you to that point yes sir seven cruna even though I did say 3 months ago I'd never come back to a meeting I'm here uh I have been watching the meetings and I just want to start off by saying Dr Goodall you look perfect there okay so I just want to let when you have
065to get a superintendent that's my man um concerning the trailers and maybe Mike can answer this isn't it true that the state will only allow you to use a trailer for five years that is correct okay we know how long it takes add to that no no you we know how long it takes to build a school right they're temporary structures their County approves them for 5 years yeah great County I love the county um the other thing is New Brunswick a number of years ago um they closed one of the schools one of the old schools to build a new school and they went to an industrial park and they they broke down the warehouse into classrooms with a Lobby if if somebody blown mind folded you and walked you into the building you
066swear you would win you would be in a regular a regular school and I was wondering I know how expensive it is for the trailers setting them up getting rid of them um that is something that I would look into um the other thing I do want to say is that I was on a board I guess it was 2009 10 and 11 going into 12 I guess and and um the only thing that we had concerning the increase in school population was the redistricting if you remember that and we knew at that time and it's probably around 2010 we knew at that time we were going to have a problem and you know with with all due respect I blame the problem on the whoever the president was of the board and the board
067because the superintendent end is to be led in other words you set goals for the superintendent and the superintendent that we had before Dr kak did not want to get involved in new schools or referendums so the problem that we find ourselves in now is that nobody forced the issue and we had in that time Miss kapovich we had maybe three other presidents and nobody really addressed that problem and now we find ourselves in a um the last thing which I probably should talk about later on um as of I think it was in the Asbury Park Press or the Sentinel last week uh there are now 95 school districts suing the state for more money and some of them get a hell of a lot more than we do Freehold burrow had 17700 students
068that we're getting 9.7 million when we were getting Less Than 3 million they now got another million before Christie left we got what 200 and some odd thousand yes we did get more money now nowhere in near enough for 6700 kids and G knows what the new the new deal is going to be but I would hate to have to be in your seat all of you and I can only say you know where I come from I call a spade a spade but our backs are against the wall people and I I don't know what you can do and what's going to wind up Happ happening and I know my time is up what's going to wind up happening is what happened with Freehold burrow when they had two referendums voted down the state
069came in and ordered the school board to sell bonds to build a new school so what's going to happen is we're in such bad shape as far as school population and overcrowding that I wouldn't be a bit surprised to see this the state come in and say Monroe Township sell bonds and I believe the figure is 225 million to build the two schools and the addition on the high school uh good luck I don't know what you got to do thank you thank you is anyone else from the public wishing to speak in regard to the trailers uh Amika sukla to here cot um the first thing I would like to talk about is transparency uh you mentioned that yeah we did have uh the location of the trailers attached to some agenda that was
070given on that particular day so whoever came they must have received it somehow you know they should have come back and protested and so on if if the uh fact that um that day uh the location well if if location itself was on the agenda like Krishna pointed out I would have been in that meeting it was never put in the agenda so I of all the things you said you spent 10 minutes talking about the chronology nowhere did I hear you say that we went out to the public and we said that this is where the trailers are going to be and the public uh agreed or they brought their questions and so on that's the reason why there was so much of surprise when people suddenly when they put the trailers there everybody
071thought that it's temporary they're going to pull them back and then next thing is they moved them near the road which was shocking to everyone so that's number one I believe that we are uh grossly lacking transparency in this uh School District um the second question I would like to ask is uh when was the last time uh when in Applegarth Road trailers were there how far off they were from the road and the third thing I want to talk about is uh I know that if I uh go to the zoning board tomorrow and I put in a request to have a shed put right next to the Street Lamp is going to get rejected right we're going to have 30 uh not 30 I mean it's probably 100 kids sitting right the the
072the lamp is stuck to the trailers right and I heard earlier today that that is safe right for the record I want to say that I I completely disagree with that statement again I don't want any more answers on that I just want to say I totally disagree with that statement I'm sure if you go to and you just mentioned that um we you know it was not required to get zoning permit for this obviously I mean that's very convenient right if I go and get zoning permit for something like that immediately it's going to be get rejected so I I I just don't understand how that is possible right uh that's all I mean so the only question I mean I'm not going looking for any answers from you I think I got got
073the point you're going to say something that's not going to answer my questions the only specific answer I'm looking for is uh when was the last time we had trailers um 20 25 or 30 ft from the road I I would have to ask Mr T but I don't know when the last time they were that close to the road was uh so when uh the trailers were Apple Road where were they the trail they were they were on the towards the side in the back just for the record uh there is no precedent of having uh trailers this close to the road and and and you you just said that you're very comfortable managing a situation like this well clearly it's the first time you want to do it right what I said was
074for purposes of eyesight right when the trailers were set up did not have more than two security guards maybe three in the whole building they came and went they came and now when I wasn't speaking about traff I Happ to qualify I was speaking specifically about my comfort level as building administrator knowing that theight allows for the visual observ of children to and any and not comparison the safety of trail location to the traffic I was making a statement regarding the safety of being able to physically see children come to and from them uh I I just want to clarify something to um what was I the um the one of the reasons one of the major reasons they're put where they are is because of the water in the sewer hookup and the fact
075that the kids did not need to go in and out of the buildings all day long to go to bathrooms this included the bathroom facilities This was um the best spot to put those trailers in and um it we we considered this many times over the past year and a half all right thanks I just want to end that for the record uh I do not uh believe the you know sticking a trailer right next to the lamp uh can be safe from we have the approvals from the county and we have the approvals for the record again that there has been no precedent of trailers being this close to the road and uh you know the public was not not notified about it thank you thank you and I'm just going to since there
076three more people online after that we're going to close off the um trailer discussion because it'll be an hour oh Mr well four people and then we're closing off the trailer discussion so at at um I'm going to close it off at 8:15 because that will be over an hour of discussion on the trailers Mrs scurby good evening uh Mrs scurby 21 pness Drive um I just you know hearing about the transparency we could have done a better job Al uh alerting the parents we have a falcon flyer that we've utilized for uh countless emails about go getting out last year for the referendum vote um it's been utilized inappropriately sometimes to send out information to the district um clearly the district could have sent out a falcon flyer that goes home to every parent
077with that schematic and with an understanding of where the trailers were going to go that would have been transparent what went on saying that it was part of an agenda hidden um you had to go online to download the aerial that is not being transparent we've had presentations here um when we were going through the referendum process we saw what the um outlay for the high school edition was going to look like we saw what the middle school edition was going to or new middle school was going to look like you could have had a presentation what the trailers were going to look like um couple of questions um I know lunch came up at the buildings and grounds meeting um I guess it's a question for Mrs Chanley um will the children in the
078trailers that the two teams will they be eating lunch at the same time in the same uh cafeteria as the rest of the seventh grade they will um will that lunch period be extended for them to get out to the trailers and then back back from lunch Mrs Chanley would you mind standing up at the microphone so everyone can hear that lunch period will consist of all the seventh graders which would be basically the same size um maybe a little bit larger but we've we fed up to 610 children previously that were eighth grade I think is now your junior class um so what's going to happen is we will do exactly what we do regardless whether or not we would have trailers the first couple weeks of school we're physically in there we say
079children don't leave make sure you eat and then what we do is we sit down and we s we speak with the security guards as well as the teachers that have duty that period and we talk about how long did it take them to get in the building how long did it take them to get their launch how long to take them and we see what needs to be changed they were about I want to say one year we had probably up to 3 months of children that we extended the lunch period if necessary so that's a good question and absolutely so we're going to evaluate it we're going to actually see they will make sure they will be given adequate enough time to get their food eat just like any other child and and
080to get back out to the trailers and if we need to extend it by a few minutes then it'll be extended because lunch will take a precedence for sure thank you and um my other question is about uh pickup at the end of the day how will um the pickup work because I know when the Bell Rings the students all come out and um if they're getting picked up they meet at the flag pole or they go to the buses um if they're in the trailers um how will that take place because you if you've ever been to pickup at the middle school the parking lot is a nightmare um it's very dangerous now um and the concern is how will the CH what will the process be for the cars coming into the into
081the parking lot and the children Crossing to go to their buses okay we already worked that out and actually it's not any different I'll tell you why the lack of safety I unfortunately it is the behavior of the parents I I I don't mean anything disrespectful but if you're in we're not we don't tell parents what to do you know we tell children what to do so the parents Park we would hope that they Park appropriately they remain near their car get out of their car when the appropriate time and then go over to the flag hole to answer Miss gery's question it's really very simple it's not going to be any different what's going to happen is the children are there in the trailers we are going to we've already mapped it out I
082actually walked it with Mr T and then my assistant principal so there's going to be a spot in the middle we're no longer going to have a bus pull up there so for those of you that are pick her uppers which is the cute way that I say it when you pick up your children now there is a space in front of the student main entrance way where the children are the only space if they are permitted to then be escorted it's usually Miss herker but it can be a different security guard but she's the one that happens to do it they are actually escorted there is like a double wide space where let's say a bus plus space on each right left side normally would be and they are escorted directly to the flare
083pole the children in the trailers will never cross over back to the building so if you could picture this they're going to come out of one entrance way which is the front designated entrance way that I said had the swirly a little bit more of a swirl to it as far as the um ramp they will come out of that ramp they will then if they're taking a bus home they will then once again be a sport the same designated space which we've had for the last seven plus years for the children to go to their parents they will then be escorted we'll have our normal teachers out there the administrations out there as well as our Securities out there they walk to the middle and then they find a bus the children that are
084being picked up will never do that they will stay on the sidewalk on the opposite side of the fence that currently exists they will walk down the sidewalk and they will walk to the flag pole instead of coming to the flag pole this way they come to the flag pole this way so they're not going to experience any traffic although we had extra spots that were left over Mr T and I had this discussion and we both agree that there will be no parking including myself the administration there will be no parking in the entire area that now or where the trailers are except for overnight bus parkings which we discussed so there is no reason if go there's a parent they will not be permitted to pull in there at under any circumstances so
085the children literally are going to walk down the sidewalk so what you're picturing don't picture they're not coming towards the building again to be escorted back they walk down the sidewalk and they walk directly to the flag pole so actually they're only going to have to deal with probably 40 kids rather than let's say the 100 kids that have picked up because they're almost their own they have their own private walkway no one no child who's not in the trail is going to walk to that area to then walk to the flag po they're coming from two different directions I I Tred to do it visual I apologize to help you understand what would that would look like thank you yeah will there still be that roadway that separates they come down yeah but they're
086not walking in that roadway so in other words he has he has that'll still be the same what happens as you walk down you know we have we have I apologize we have the um sidewalk so you know where the Sidewalk Ends Where the Sidewalk Ends if I'm not mistaken and Mr take correct me that's where you start having that patchy grass and that's where the flag ball is if you picture it so when you walk down when you walk down right you have a FL maybe we need to have a presentation over there on how that would work well as Mr Goodall did say earlier we're waiting of course to follow the proper Logistics in CFO and that is why we couldn't do anything in advance but two things are going to happen number
087one when all of the we do a a 6 through2 Continuum that we've done this for many years where once the portal is open we send our welcome we send our connect 5 we let you know the portals open you go online you see what team your child has you see what classrooms so right there we're also going to put in a little little verbiage that I wrote that's going to say those any child who's placed on two teams that are going to be in Trails you're going to meet us in the path so the administration is going to meet the children to go through the whole thing in the path additionally as you know fingers crossed everything being done appropriately timing um it is tentatively schedule that we'd like to do for those children
088once again that will have their schedule and that will be in the trails we're going to myself my Administration certain teachers that are going to be in the out in the trailers as well as Mr Good said that he would be love to come we're going to be there to do an orientation we're looking at probably the day before only because of time constraints and that is tensa thank so people have it more comfortable yes thank you okay I'd like to get yeah I just wanted to say thank you Mrs chy I know that she's doing everything in her power to make sure it's safe and I know the parents do trust you yeah we we understand and appreciate that ourselves thank [Applause] you hi I'm Barbara Lee from Monroe my child is entering the
089middle school I have great anxiety and stress about him going into a trailer I want to know what you're going to do about gun safety because anyone could drive by and shoot up those 10 cans on the side of the road that's a reality of today you didn't take that into consideration my child's safety is a lot more important than what it would cost you guys to run a waterline to the back of the school I also would like to know how much would it cost to run a water line because you're putting in barriers you're putting in a fence and you're putting in trees why not run a water line and put our kids in a safe position Mr T would you like to answer the question about the cost of of putting the
090trailers in a different spot and and and um I don't have a cost for that but okay so what if these kids get shut up what's the cost worth to you guys cuz it's my child who's going in these trailers we're doing everything we possibly can we're working with our director of um uh security to make sure that a barrier is not going to stop a bullet and that's the reality of today and that I would say is any school is is that not not a brick and mortar school you have a shoot at a ten can I have we're putting two rows of barriers and a steel offense again and now you want people to vote for a referendum where you're putting our children In Harm's way and you think you're going to get
091a referendum voted just saying I mean you guys have to think of the reality you're putting our children in danger and and and you don't seem to worry about that oh I I I would not say that we don't worry about that we're all consider if you were doing the right thing you'd be moving those trailers because my other children went to schools in the trailers and never were they on the road that's all I have to say thank you good evening I'm Pima um my question is um how are you going to arrange the children with disabilities or that the children that have health concerns the children that don't want to walk in the cold my son suffers with asthma and cold is the biggest Trigger he has how would he probably walk all
092the way to the nurse to the main building when he's suffering with asthma and cold is a trigger time is an Essence call it EpiPen call it his spray you know he has to be in the main building how are you how are you managing it why does a child have to walk in the cold every day for his lunch I considering it's a decent space between uh the trailer and the main building when it's cold it's not I mean it's not good for the children to walk like that and as as the the mother that spoke before me said yes I have that concern that there might be a shooting and it's really not safe safety is my child's for I mean it's my primary concern I believe Mrs Chanley said at the beginning
093of the meeting that their medical issues will be taken into consideration and there will be times where a medically needed child will be in the building and not in a trailer if that is the necessity or an IEP or a medical condition that needs to be in the in the in the building and not in the trailer thank you good evening Andy poori 16 St James Street thank you very much for giving me the opportunity to speak this evening I want to thank the administration and the board of education for allowing my daughter to graduate I just dropped her off at TCNJ I'm a proud parent of a junior at T freshman at TCNJ today uh thank you very much but I this is the first time I learned that the 7th graders are actually
094going to the trailers and my second daughter happens to be a seventh grader yes I share the same concern everybody else is sharing in terms of safety but after I heard what I heard at the grounds and uh uh buildings uh presentation I'm a little more comfortable than I was before when I first saw the trailers out there uh I think the trailers are trailers they are where they are right now whether we like them or not I don't think it's going to anything is going to happen about moving those but my concern is what is it moving forward that we need to do so the question that I want to ask the uh maybe the super today is at the pace at which we're going the referendum still in the works when would the
095high school need trailers because it will be the same scenario in 2 three years from now if we don't get the referendum passed More Trailers in front of the middle school and new trailers in front of the high school then we'll be sitting here and arguing about the same thing all over again I think we need to come here whether you're speaking out of the podium or sitting there as a board member we got to look for Solutions not just for problems s to come and complain here I think this complaint got to stop and we got to come together to pass a referendum so that our students deserve what they need to get out of it and get out of the trailers as quickly as possible so my question Still Remains What would be
096the high school's threshold before we start putting trailers in front of high schools Mr Gall do you have an answer for that I would prob we would have to work with the high school administrative team to do a study considering class sizes um hallway uh flow uh use of the cafeteria use of the gymnasium use of the pack to do a study and come back and Report out on that um the all I know is once I became part of the steering committee meeting as the high school principal when all of the facts and Figures were presented to me certainly I was first there to Advocate let's build an addition to the high school first um I wound up walking out of there and supporting a referendum for a middle school because I was convinced
097that was our greatest need this building allowed you're not threatened you were just convinced I'm surprised because somebody told me you were threatened to say so I was the tallest guy in the room so I was convinced okay and the strongest too thank you now we're all collaborative here and so I supported the Middle School referendum and certainly um I'm still going to be a part of whatever decision we need to move forward um we would have to study that with the high schol so I couldn't answer that today but uh adding trailers to the footprint of the high school would be extremely problem atic as well it could be for other reasons maybe not access to Water and Sewer but certainly parking high school student parking elimination of spots a lot of ban practice
098areas a lot of things to consider so I couldn't answer that now but certainly we could as a with the High School administration look at that and have some answers moving forward yeah I want to be respectful for people who are standing behind me so I want to move along so if you could get that information I'm sure every parents who's sitting here has a need to understand that and when that's that's going to be coming if that's going to come because we know that by the time the referendum passes to the time actually the school opens we're looking at a good six to seven years at a minimum for that to happen so if the referendum is still in flux that's going to be a problem now my last request uh before my time
099is up is the discussion about how the the circulation is going to work at the middle school it would be beneficial for those who are not attending this meeting today to also understand principal uh shanley's discussion about how the the kids move if you can put something like that in Falcon Express then it'll be helpful for everybody else to know that as well thank you very much thank you and our last speaker on the trailers hi my name is Ann Roman I live at 434 school house could you please speak into the microphone thank you thank you my name is Ann Roman I live at 434 Schoolhouse Road um I'd like to start off by addressing the questions from everyone here about about the trailers I think they were really great questions all well thought
100out and extremely valuable however we spent the first part of the meeting listen to an extremely detailed list of all the meetings going back to 2016 bg& reports emails that were sent committee meetings committee reports approvals that were asked for and granted all the reports were in the newspaper newspaper articles all over contracts that were put out and then awarded diagrams of the area provided perhaps not in the way somebody may have wanted them but we're going back to 2016 when this all appeared to have started um the location of the trail is at some point were not a secret I would have liked to have thought and the 2,000 people signed a petition I don't know I don't know the exact population of this town or parents that have children in the school system
1012,000 just doesn't sound like a lot of people and maybe I'm 100% wrong um I would just like to assume that people that are here with the questions extremely valuable questions were perhaps at the beginning when this all stored in 2016 and might have perhaps then been able to steer this in a different direction I just feel as though the people here we have to trust what they did they been doing this for a long time they've been involved from the start as we all have been hopefully and perhaps the last thing you have to trust is your child's ability to adapt thank you thank you Mr Mr Goodall would you like to make a comment just um in summary so in speaking to members of the community parents receiving some emails offline conversations bg&
102committee meeting and now tonight there seems to be a theme of planning and being transparent with parents and Community certainly um we always take feedback I did it as a high school principal and will continue to do it as superintendent this year one of the reasons we connected the trailers uh in that area was the connection that was feedback from our experience erence with other trailer situations particularly that building over there so moving forward I know the administrative team will certainly look at um presenting if we have to add more trailers presenting a plan of its location and consider some of the security concerns that parents have at you know looking at the Timeline that Mrs kapano which read out today was before some of the incidents that we saw across the country in which
103as parents we our concerns were heightened about school security and gun violence so moving forward I know the administrative team is willing for that I can't speak for the board but I'm sure they are too we are going to be looking and considering a lot of the considerations that we had tonight and that we've heard from parents at the bg& committee and here tonight moving forward when we plan to add more trailers I don't know if we'll ever satisfy everybody's litmus test on that but we will do our best to do that thank you Mr good okay and now we'll go back to the um can we are we can we uh ask questions oh sure Mr gella well I want to I want to make a comment first I want to thank you madam
104president for having this and uh in your in your in your report and inviting the public to uh ask questions I think that was and I think that was well thought out I also want to thank Mrs Chanley for um coming in today and answering everyone's questions I we had a lot of questions last week at building buildings grounds and transportation so I think this helps um what I'd like to do though since we're putting all the rumors to rest I'd like to put all the rumors to rest myself I'd like to make sure that everything is put to rest so when we leave here today there aren't any more rumors so you know I've been challenged myself uh by members of the public who are saying that saying things like uh maybe we put
105the trailers there to sell the referendum to the public so maybe the cost of those trailers uh was was part of the selling tactic to sell the referendum to the public the need for just the middle school for instance instead of a comprehensive package of all our needs being addressed so what I'd like to ask Miss Chanley if she's open to answering more questions is is this something that you requested is this is this or the trailers something that you felt that uh were needed uh did you think that and I I could ask these one at a time but did you think that the creation of uh the the new team and the disruption that that takes and the the you know the outlay of uh the outlay financially the lunch scheduled changes and
106all of those things that those were things that were definitely needed for this this school year and are you happy with what you know what what we've done as far as that's concerned and I'm going to speak very appropriately so the previous superintendant who was my immediate supervisor came to me and said you know how are things going had like I had said he had probably walked a few of the different board members through my building we are extremely crowded last year um and the year before that we had to go to a delayed bell schedule which I also had to do in my previous building of Apple gooth which is really not what's best for children so we had two different Bell schedules because we couldn't have the children in the hallway at the
107same time so it wasn't even a matter of instruction at that point it was just pure safety um and I'm just giving you a little background so basically we had to change the bell schedule to stagger it because children be in State Building we then had to remove science teachers from science classrooms and then make makeshift science environment classrooms in other Wings in order to pod the building appropriately because we had seventh and eighth grade science classrooms in the same wing and if you don't think that's a big deal oh my goodness when the bell rings it is because we couldn't have children crossing over we then had very open transparent PTO meetings where the children were permitted to come and they would give us some feedback and what it was like to go up
108and down the stairwells so if you're asking me to trailers help absolutely if you're saying to me and and I don't want to speak about an individual who's not here but basically I was told can you live without them my answer is always yes because my answer is yes to everything I can do everything I need to do to always make something work that's just who I am I started out in this District where there was 565 children in a seventh and eighth grade building I am now the principal of 175 I asked my secretary as of today 175 children and a building that was built for 1,200 children so if they said is absolutely no way you can have trailers um can you make it work the answer would have been yes would we
109have class size of 23 or 24 no we would probably have class size which we did um 31 32 um additionally if I had been requested to be on some of these committees to be part of the transparency of the trailers to maybe ease everybody's stress like I'm I'm hoping I'm doing tonight I would have been I was not requested I am an individual who works for the parents who works for the kids but I also like to come on I am requested I I don't always feel it's appropriate for me to say things unless that's asked of me and that was not asked of me at the time so basically to be specific um to your question I did not openly go and say give me trailers no I did not I did not
110openly say I have to have them am I glad I have them yes I am do I think it's what's best for children yes I do do I understand why they're in the front of the school yes I do I walk the entire outside we I used to call Back 40 I walked it Mr T physically walked it and my ideal of course would have been there and the question was I have to have water I not an architect I'm not an engineer I am not a zoning planning person I will not discuss any of those reasons why I am only a human being that has worked with trailers in the past I do want to apologize to that gentleman if it came out the wrong way I meant that I prefer these trailers because
111we can see that's what I was I was not referring to the traffic on the road I was referring to having the ability to security purposes of seeing children back and forth but I will let you know that the one thing I did say is I wanted water as far as the placement and so forth and having to live with the trailers I was told I was asked by the previous I I don't know else to say it how do you feel you could do a trailers what do they look like what who would you put in there and we came up with maybe three or four different options for scheduling purposes one of which was World Language trailers which I did have at the previous school what that looked like then we started doing
112a synopsis and and a data analysis of how many times children would be going in and out what it looked like and from a pedology of middle school and I live breath and eat middle school for those of you that know me I'm all that from the middle school kid placing the teams in the trailers I still stand by is the best way but what I I don't like to go backwards because no I did not I was not an individual said give me trailers but I was also not an individual that said I do not want trailers if if that answers your question I don't know if it does Okay I uh no I just I just wanted for transparency sake I wanted to just have you on the record because there's a lot
113of there's a lot of rumors and there's a lot of things that that are out there and and I'm glad we were able to put those AR rest I will say though that I my my son is is in your school and I know that they're going to be chosen randomly but I'd like to say and I'd like to request this of everyone because I've never asked for special favors for my kids and I'm not going to start today but I am going to ask you that if you could please make sure my son is in those trailers I would appreciate that that's it thank you Mr chel thank you and and thank you Mrs Chanley and Mr T for being here this evening and answering questions I I think it's been very helpful and
114I hope that the parents go home with a better understanding of what's going to be happening at the middle school and I know you're going to be reaching out to them through orientation and apparent letters really would like to possible think it's and I apologize could you please again use just so you know and I received seven emails including Miss clerkin and I am Ty for those you that know me I do respond usually very quickly for those that know me even in the middle of the night that being said I really wanted to give the same answers to the questions to everybody this for this particular evening but I am happy to have um anything that you feel is appropriate um and any type of additional informational sessions now that our building's open our
115building was closed officially um so I'm very comfortable doing that and once the CFO is received um I would love to be able to also have um an additional orientation preferably 5 6 7:00 at night discuss 6:00 like right in the middle the night before and I can send out a parent connect and by then I believe on the 29th portal open so the parents that have children in the trailers will be aware of that be my pleasure I'm sure Mr Goodall will work with you and absolutely yes absolutely thank you thank you okay Mr Russ yeah because um close not only Mr Chella but many people mentioned U um transparency and these rumors that are spreading around and one thing I find is that goes back to that document that the document of justification
116for the decisions you have subject matter experts that are involved making important decisions for example in this case might have been Jerry T who decided the trailers can go in this location and he may have not been alone but he was the key subject matter expert that decided that but we don't have any documentation as to how these decisions are made and BAS based on what and this is what I find is the biggest problem here the administration because before the board always gets blamed and I'm really tired of that we vote Yes or No based on recommendations from the superintendent and I don't want to say we can assume that the subject matter experts are making the proper decisions but Mr goodle should should make sure they do there should be checks and balance
117is to make sure that those decisions that they make are the right decisions because we can't make them we can only ask questions now you had director of security meeting with the school principal nothing wrong with that they discussed certain things nothing's documented so that's what happens people come here and they say no we did this and we did that but nothing's documented so the story can change from you know this month to January it might be a different story and that's why everybody gets confused thank you Mr Russo okay at this time we're going to get back to our regular agenda because we're only on number six um we're going to go to the approval of minutes for the first for the special public Board of Education meeting of May 23rd 2018 move move
118my Mr Chella second by Mr Ryback any additions or corrections to the minutes yes M armino um the uh May 23rd previous uh special public meeting uh minutes uh pre failed at a previous meeting um I would ask that under the motion on page two uh where it says under motion to become a member of fair funding action uh the third paragraph I objected to after much deliberation and this sort of goes to what we've been talking about um after much deliberation is not detailed enough to provide the open meetings act requirement of reasonably compreh comprehensible language I believe some comments from board members provides important insight into policy formation and decision making and that does that is not shown in in this in these minutes and I would also ask that the comments from
119the members of the public be more verbatim and less interpretive so um I really on this one don't have specific except that I I do object to the way it's written so I'll just be voting no but in the future I would like to have instead of just saying there's much deliberation because if like we have talked about if we have to go back to January meeting and the only information on here is that through much deliberation the public is not a aware of what kind of deliberation has gone by and I think it's important that they need to know what certain members say I mean and I know we can't do a Verbatim I mean actually years ago we used to have a Verbatim minutes so that you could go into the board office
120and read every single detail and I thought that was wonderful may be expensive I don't know but ju but cutting it down to just making a statement after much deliberation I think does not go far enough um for for the public to go back in time and see what each board member did so that's just on this one thank you we will note your comments in the record thank you um any other comments questions okay all in favor I I opposed I miss armeno opposes abstain or recuse okay then the Clos session meeting of May 23rd 2018 Mr Chella Mr Ryback any additions or corrections to them Miss armino yes again this failed in a previous meeting because I objected to it uh where the discussion we're not allowed to dis disclose the discussion that
121happened in in Clos session well if we're voting we are not allowed to discuss what the conversation was in closed session well I disagree that's my point according to our attorney we are not allowed to discuss what the discussion was in closed session well I think think what I have given you are you telling me that what I handed out before the meeting you are you are saying that I cannot read this part I am saying that you are and first of all you this came to us right before the meeting correct and I don't think that everybody's had that opportunity to to really read this well we we tabled it last meeting I I understand it's I think what I'm saying you know close session minutes and things that are confidential are supposed to
122protect the privacy of people and I get that I'm all for confidentiality appropriately however again the public has a right after a resolution has been things have been resolved the public has a right and I advocate for this very strongly to know exactly what went on if there is somebody's name that has to be eliminated or if some something that is a confidential it the the public has a greater right to in my opinion on this one to know what went on than confidentiality is in this I don't think I have in in this that anything was done my objection to the last meeting was that I I I I'm going to read you have this as a as an approved minutes you have the 20 May 23rd closed session the previous one in our
123packet this is these are these are the words that we're going to be voted on you so I couldn't read you're telling me that I couldn't read that Miss Mrs Smith noted concern regarding AC according to Mrs Smith she said that you should not have been saying that at the last meeting okay and I don't want to go into this this is of course you don't of course you don't okay but let me ask a question once these minute meeting minutes are approved these are the these the one the one I'm holding in my hand not the one that I wrote the one that I'm holding in my hand these typed minutes once these are approved these are available under the open public records act for the public to see they're not approved well you're
124asking me if I'm going to approve it and in order for me to approve it I would like an addition to the minutes I don't understand why I can't tell you what the addition should be because according to our attorney you cannot discuss would happen in closed session well no I I for members of the public confidentiality is very important to me and I will always play by the rules even if it hurts me specifically however I am going to again say that then we'll table this particular one again until the board attorney reads us and I think we are subject to lawsuits from the public because we are not allowing transparen you want to say something well you would need a motion to table Madam may I say something yes please I was not
125the minute keeper for these but I would I would like to say that we have a policy on when minutes have to be approved we could also lose qack points uh if you would like content in close session minutes to be changed before they're approved by the board by all means you have every opportunity to contact the other board members or Administration to make a change ahead of time we could send out confidential revised minutes if the if it's warranted to all the members and then you could feel comfortable approving it well I would love to do that I would love to have all the time in the world that I do not because I am a full-time worker to do this and unfortunately sometimes I have to do things at the last minute as
126we receive things I received uh additional board agenda today at 2:01 so p.m. so I mean yeah a lot of things can be done in advance and I agree with you but unfortunately I have time constraints as well however to be compliant with confidentiality I will again but you see here's what's going to happen if the rest of the board members approves this then whatever I have down here is not going to be included in the minutes and then I have to live with that so that's my problem Miss Amino at the last minute meeting you you objected to this also that's correct you were requested to we speak to speak to Mr Ryback since he took the minutes of the meeting that evening you never reached out to him that's a month ago and
127we just got this today as we were starting our meeting you're absolutely correct so if you want to make a motion to hold this again we could you can make a motion see if it's second and we vote on that otherwise we need to get moving with these minutes but I I would like it very clearly stated in the record for tonight's minutes that there is nothing I believe there is nothing in my position here that say say that is particularly confidential and I would never breach confidentiality however I'm going to play by the rules let you do what you you want to do and then I'm going to submit this to the board for a for rec for open public records and if the attorney wants to say that that she has to redact
128any of this then that'll be on her okay okay so we're we're uh the closed session meeting of May 23rd all in favor I I I opposed I I can you please beos okay would the opposing members please raise your hand so I can noted in a minutes okay at the Clos session meeting of June 7th I have a question um and Frank vote on the minutes because they were excused from the meeting um we were there we were there you were there yes okay because it says you dismissed this is where I never know what we're supposed to do because sometimes we're there for a little while and then we leave so it wasn't advertised as a meeting when we went in that room that's well the first part of it they were Avail
129they were in involved in the discussion on the second part you may have you you can have an objection to that they left this so actually if I remember correctly M Smith took the opportunity before we left to make some comments I I would have to go back and look at them all because that's why we were there okay okay so I think we're up to the Clos session meeting of June 7th so Mr Chella Mr R back any additions or Corrections does well president K panowitz do you have an objection to my two sentences because I'd like to put that into the minutes I don't think there's anything confidential in that I think that shows what we did I does anybody have an objection to that oh one for June 7th yeah yeah no
130no no that's fine then I would like to put in there that interviews were conducted that the members present did not come to a consensus on acting internal candidate and then no action was taken I think that's an accurate addition all in favor I opposed that addition abstain recuse both of you are recusing okay Mr Russ on Miss cor recusing okay the think close session meeting of June 13 2018 so move second Mr Chella Mr Mayo additions or corrections to the minutes seeing none all in favor opposed m armenio is opposing abstain refus are you refusing or abstaining Mr Russo and Miss uh Kino recusing Madam I make request for um accountability and and mini keeping uh when the members vote affirmatively on the minutes we need some kind of reaction from everybody otherwise it's
131to be included as a no vote maybe we'll just have a hand not a no vote but not casting a vote okay maybe we'll have a hand so we need some kind of response to um approved not approved you want us to verbalize that say approved some kind of reaction so we can go back on the tape and and definitively see how the members voted on the minutes okay that was um June 13th the special Board of Education meeting for June 14th so move Mr Chella Mr Ryback additions or corrections to the minutes okay all in favor please raise your hand I I oppose recuse Mr Russo is recusing the Clos session meeting of June 14th so move Mr Chella Mr Ryback again additions or corrections to those minutes Mr Mino my only uh my
132only opposition to this is the June 14th we enter it was the superintendent evaluation by title we entered into uh the discussion at 8:15 p.m. we didn't finish until 10 p.m. and the close session minutes are 754 words so we were there an hour and 45 minutes and 74 words to describe what went on for an hour and 74 minutes so I'll be voting no okay all in favor please raise your hand opposed mrin um abstain or recuse recuse and recuse he the public Board of Education meeting of July 18th 2018 Mr Chella Mr Ryback again any comments or questions okay all in favor I you weren't there accuse opposed Miss Armenia is opposing obstain recuse recuse Mr rutsky is recusing okay and the last one is the Clos session meeting of July 18th so
133move Mr Mr TR Mr Ryback additions or corrections to the minutes seeing none all in favor I opposed Miss armino abstain you're abstain you're recusing Miss corino's recusing I will recuse and you will abstain or recuse I left early no you can abstain I'll abstain my uh he voted voted yes I'm sorry Mr kski did you the last July 18th I have Mrs Aro as opposed that's correct and actually I made a mistake on the hold up I was going to vote on the PB the public Board of Education meeting July 18th I was going to vote Yes I think I I said no you did I will change that to that's yes July it is noted public board meeting July 18th Mr armeno cast a vote as yes yes it is the Clos session
134meetings that I say not to thank you okay at this time uh since our students are not here in the summer they will be back in September where we will greet a new student board member we'll go to committee reports Mr Chella yes thank you we had a buildings grounds and transportation meeting on 8:15 so I'm going to read uh briefly I'm not going to read the whole thing cuz we had a long it was a long meeting we covered a lot of topics but I want to explain as best I can the things that we did go through go over so the brook we the number one was Brookside School HVAC upgrades and the project status so the administrative Administration provid an overview of the project highlighting that boilers hot water heaters have been
135installed and they'll be ready for the operations the the they'll be operational for the start of school um there was also we also had a delivery of several roof top HVAC units and that will start to happen uh as soon as possible and then the installations will happen um you know over holidays weekends and things like that to make sure that they go in without students present uh the second thing was Turf replacement project so we received an overview of the project noting that the replacement installation of the new Synthetic Turf fields at the Monro uh Monro Township Middle School is substantially complete and that the students the student athletes of have started using the field this week uh the athletic director will work with facilities uh to complete a punch list so again that
136was the you know this is this this is a non-toxic um substitute for what we had before on as Turf so it's uh it doesn't heat like the like the other AstroTurf did which is better for the for the students and it also doesn't leech toxins into the ground so it's non-toxic which is which was a big cell you know for it was a big selling point uh so that is that is nearly done so we had a steering committee update for the bomb Bond referendum recommendation uh and so the administra the administration reported that the committee met several times since the failed referendum in March and concluded their meetings this past week which was last week and uh basically what they came up with uh was uh in they expanded the uh the meeting
137the um the group the steering committee and what they came up with was a two question solution uh to the B Bond referendum issue so the first one of the questions the first question will be Middle School only and the second question which well let me let me go back the middle school question will be well the the one the first question will be Middle School only $75 million so I want to get the dollar the dollars out and then the second question will be middle school and high school together for a total of $146 million so there are two different questions that'll be on the ballot uh and uh that'll be from March 2019 and our residents will have the ability to vote on that if I may give my own opinion on this
138I think that it's very important that uh we we have the high school and middle school together and that that passes because that's our that's our need we have a a Monumental need for for space and if we don't do that we're going to be cutting our nose off to spite our face because down the road we're going to be spend spending money on trailers and things like that to patch and a Band-Aid and uh you know find small stop Gap solutions to this problem that'll never end so we we need we really need to push this hard and I would I would implore the public to vote on the the both schools the next thing that we discussed was the Middle School trailer produ project and you know I was very I was very
139happy to see that it turn out unfortunately you know it was under this under those circumstances you know so they people came out because they weren't happy which is usually the case uh that's when you know people are fired up to come out they don't usually come out just to say hey you guys are doing a great job they come out to say you you stink and then they tell us why we stink and they and then other people tell us and they keep going which is fine I think that's good that's our that's democracy and that's really what makes us better I will say that uh we got a lot of great ideas from that meeting from our from our residents and I think that a lot of those those ideas uh are being
140imple implemented in to some some degree so over time you know we heard about we heard about security concerns and things like that I I would like to say though that like like we said earlier we all own this decision we all own what happened uh is it the best solution that they're right where they are and no the best solution would be that we didn't even need trailers that we had a a middle school referendum that passed and an even better solution would be that our Township would listen to our residents and stop building and that they and they would you know they they would get the uh they would get the develop excuse me excuse me so I think that uh I I you know I think that with that being said you
141know we're doing what we can do uh and and so we discussed that at length then the next thing that we discussed was the property for sale at 417 Buckaloo Avenue so uh it's it's being listed by matrix and that's for potentially for a a bus Depot we have two different things that we're looking at one is land being given to us by the township for a bus depot to expand what we already have and then I think it was Mr Russo who brought up uh this this land that's for sale right across on the board office and so we were just looking into that so there was nothing definitive but it was a conversation we were just looking at it so and and you know more to come on that as we as we
142move forward with the uh with this uh you know with with with with the land and the need for the bus depot and the development of that and there's more on that shortly um the township we also discussed the township use of buses so I know Mr Braverman you had asked about that so the township is charged 79 cents a mile to use buses for summer Recreation our buses District buses and Recreation programs like Mount sea Camp also use our bus and they charged at that rate now in addition to the charge they pay their own bus driver or they pay for the bus drivers so that's why it's a lower rate then when they use it for Fourth of July and for grandparents day and things like that where we then charge the township
143a133 per mile for the use of the buses so I hope that satisfies your question I know it satisfied mine and I was happy to see that we're charging and we're uh doing what we're supposed to be doing here protecting the Public's wallets the next thing that we discussed was a middle school PSA PTO and that also was a pretty contentious debate you know we talked about various different things and policy adjustments and the need for uh whether or not we needed to go back to policy or whether this had to go to a full board many of us felt that uh we that it that the decision ision to GL to Grant class one status rested with uh the superintendent and the building administrator for instance other um you know other members thought that
144it rested with the Board of Ed so we were debating that and I think that that's probably something that we should debate now because as far as I've been on the board on and off for almost nine years I guess little over eight years and I've never I've never seen us uh okay or approve a parent group you know and and now there's a parent group in the Middle School who has all their all of their documentation their credentials and they weren't they're not being given uh building you status they went to the superintendent they went to the building administrator they went back and forth and somehow because board members got involved and things like that it ended up here I don't think it should be here I think we're over you know we're over
145overstepping our bounds I think that we're you know we're we're going into a dangerous territory here where we're going to start micromanaging organizations in in in our different you know in the schools and I think that that could end up being a problem so what I what I'm going to ask today is for us to discuss it and then I'm going to make a motion to Grant class one status because I have no idea why why we're even discussing this and why this would come before us I think that uh we have bylaws those bylaws say certain things they allow parent groups and then we turn around and for whatever reason turn turn turn that down and got involved to the point where uh it's it's causing issues that shouldn't be caused I think we
146need to put this to rest today turn it over to the the building administrator and then never you know never deal with this again if we have to change policy then we can change policy but today I think we have to deal with what you know what our bylaws dictate I don't know if anyone else wants to discuss that are you making a motion because we'll have a discussion after there's a motion yeah I'm going to make a motion that we Grant class one status to this PSA I'll second it thank you thank you okay now we can open it for discussion Mr Ryback okay Ken I can't agree with what you said I said that during um the bg& meeting um first of all the policy asked us to endorse we're being asked to
147endorse this uh organization we have to look at you know what does that mean if we're endorsing what are the repercussions of that how would it infect impact the school the parents the teachers this hasn't come up before my guess is because it never existed before there's no school that has two equal parent groups and it's not and they don't have it because I think it would lead to confusion infighting divisiveness among parents and maybe even kids uh when when this first was coming about all of us know this isn't we're not hearing this for the first time I um called Maryann Freeman who's our uh New Jersey school board rep because I wanted to know if in fact there were any other schools in middlex County uh that had two equal parent groups I'd
148like to read back what and we had a discussion but she also sent me uh an email she said the colleagues who are available have not heard of any of their district schools having more than one parent group there are the obvious conflicts that we have spoken about fundraising from the same group of parent staff soliciting volunteers from the same group of parent staff scheduling issues for both organizations so that they do not conflict this could be very divisive among parents and staff population personally I don't see how this can work for the good of students and that should be the main concern in fact it should be uh the main concern and that's what what we have to look at if we're granting an endorsement to another group how will that affect that school
149how will it effect the relationships between parents right now we know there's a lot of drama divisiveness going on well yeah and and and and and I agree with you there's a lot of drama and divisiveness going on and it's emanating from the board well I have I I don't think it's emanated from the boy 10 I think well I'm going to disagree because I'm going to tell you why well let me just finish my thought let let Mr Ryback finish his comment um we all got a packet of on Friday um I read all these letters the letters were filled with all kinds of uh uh examples of harassment on Facebook and and things like that things that shouldn't be going on that didn't eminate from the board that started because of there there
150were two groups uh really really fighting with each other and that's where it emanated from we didn't start that we didn't create a say we didn't create a PT a PTO the PTO was created was the parent group in that school or all the schools and there was an election the PTO won that election the PSA came out of it after that uh uh election shouldn't be the case I'd like to say there are there are multiple parent groups so and I think we heard that at buildings and grounds and Mr Goodall even highlighted the multiple parent groups that were that are even in this school this that we're in right now but it's different it's different because why is it different because we like those parent groups no no let's not make it that
151way no no we're going to make it this way cuz I'm going to explain this to let me finish let let's do one at a time let's let me finish let me finish you're saying you're saying there's multiple parent groups well sure in the high school there's multiple parent groups uh there's groups that baseball and and and and they they fundraise for different things when you have an elementary school middle school can have different parent groups but they have different functions we have two groups here that are basically are doing the same type of thing there should have been uh I guess a delineation between them but it doesn't seem to be working that's why I'm opposing uh the creation of this PSA now it's all you okay so this is this is the the
152history as I have learned it is that this went to Dr kak Who then kicked it over to the building administrator who then um made her own determination that wasn't good enough for members of this board who then asked Dr kak to then go back and redo his decision and fix it that's what we were told to fix it whatever that means fix it in their favor I don't know what that means but it's a concern and I'm going to you don't need to finish again right because now I'm going to now I said it's all so I said I don't even know the politics I don't care I'm I'm basing my decision as the chair of buildings and grounds and as a board of ed member on our bylaws and our our bylaw stipulate
153that if we have a Bonafide group that has all of their credentials that we approve them for class one status period and the building administrator if it has to go before the board then it does I don't remember ever ever uh voting on any other parent group during my tenure here but I'm going to tell you something this packet Disturbed me because this is the Board of Ed getting involved in something that's Petty and trivial and getting involved in that fight on that l that we shouldn't be involved in and here's some more I'd like to know I'd like to know this who who thought of it who put this packet together I have no idea who put that packet together you have no idea I have no idea who put that packet together and
154who asked our secretaries to put it together who authorized that transparency I'll be transparent for you if you would like because I seem to be being blamed for things I did not do and I will tell you I was in the board office the other day with Mr Gorski Mary Smith Mr Goodall and Mary walked out for something I think she was getting her lunch and she walked in and she said somebody left a packet of information for you and let her finish I'm trying to be respectful for you I wish you would have the same respect for me whether you like me or you don't I do I I couldn't read those materials because I did not have my glasses that day and they will affirm that and Mr Goodall looked at them and
155he said it has to do with the PTA PSA so I took them home and I read them and I felt that it had to do a lot of things that I get I will have sent home with the board when appropriate that this should have gone to because some of them were written to the board members and some of them were written to me they all seem to be attached and I had them sent home with the board confidential not with the agenda with the confidential the other thing I want to say is that I never got in involved into in the PTO issue the PSA issue because at the time there was no PSA until somebody requested to have a date changed for a dance because their child was involved in another activity
156that night they were denied that and then Dr kak approved that that what had happened after that I think there are people here that will will testify to that they they the three other PTO the three um Elementary PTO had been denied the same request and they sent both Steve and I and we have those emails why were we denied and somebody else was not so we gave those to Dr kak and we said he needed to look into it and somehow fix that problem so that everybody is on the same page and and afforded the same opportunity to do something why we don't have um District uh functions on a half a day had to do with the um I believe the co custodian contract where they don't work at night they only work
157in the if they have a if we have a half a day they work during the day so they don't have to come in at night well my problem is with this with this whole thing this is a campaign against a member of the public it's it's a campaign against a PTA mom number one number two and I I understand what you're saying it's just miraculously appeared there are I don't know brought them into the board office there are a bunch of police reports here from everything uh from snow removal filed by one member of who this is all about this whole packet it's about one member of the public all the police reports that she had filed some maybe filed against her some filed by most filed by her and this is sent to
158us right this is sent to us now we have 2,000 people sign a a petition to move the trailers that never makes its way to us never s we have 800 people trying to save a superintendent that never makes its way to us yes you did get a copy of that petition I never got a copy of the 2000 petition the 2000 for the trailers I never got a copy copy of that well maybe somebody should have just miraculously dropped it off and maybe come to us so my question is I'd like an investigation as to why number one there are police reports here and how they were obtained number two why we're expending board resources Madam president to compile this to have our secretaries put this stuff together they had to put it together
159did they did the P person drop it off with individual envelopes for everybody or label I I got one packet and my name wasn't on it my name was on the list of and then it says here from our secretary that the the enclosed letters were mailed to central office with the exception of the last two which were emailed to Kathy calovich so you added to this packet yes I did and then you sent it out to us no I did not add it they added it because it came to the board office they added your emails without you saying so well you you didn't approve of your emails being put in the packet they just I did approve that it was the same subject I said add it on in a campaign against a
160member of the public so if I have a problem with somebody who's running for the board Ved are you going to do the same thing for me am I going to be able to send out a packet of information on those people and distribute out to the board and then have our secretaries put together and have our delivery have it delivered by board vehicle to our houses this is [Applause] disgusting if you've overstepped I had nothing to do with it except to send it home you have nothing nothing to do with this I I did not write any letters I did not solicit any letter members of the administration have anything to do with this Madam not that I know of Madam when when when um mail is delivered to the board office and it's
161addressed to the Board of Education it is sent usually to every board member that week with with the board packet or the weekly confidential so these were addressed to the Board of Education um that's and and with your directive they were sent to the board individually because they were addressed to the board so that individually created by somebody and and dropped off like this or we had a secretary I got a I got a packet of information just the packet it was an in envelope there was no um there was no uh a a title there was no no and in there were the anonymous letters right the anonymous emails this this one's Anonymous this one they separately I I got this this is what Mary gave to me Mary gave me this so Mary
162Mary Smith our attorney you're talking about should you should you approve this she receive first no she I she came into the room somebody she said this was left for me that this packet of information was dropped off from me for me for you can can I say something can I just say something I I think what we need is a written explanation of how this thing was put together and sent out and how that decision was made it all goes back to that document that I had been P tell document of justification but that's the problem when we're told if we put it in writing Mary was involved you're telling us a lot of people were involved let's get it on paper so we know who was involved I agree Mary came into the
163board office we were having a meeting to discuss the agenda I understand right I understand so I don't she doesn't know where they came from she came in and said this was this dropped off from me when people have to write things down and put their name to it they usually tell the truth so let let everybody document it and and I'm going to tell you something because this really gets me aggravated because when I talk to our attorney she goes out of her way to tell me I'm wrong and she's given me advice that has not been perfect as you we know and I can prove that if you want to call me on it I'll prove it right now but this is fine to be disseminated and sent out Anonymous stuff and every
164this has validity this this is important okay I've made my case and there's going to be a lot more to come because this is awful and so Mr Braverman I'd like to say use your mic sir based on your comments Steve his motion will eliminate the infighting if there's infighting I'd also like to say the policy on school usage was bastardized when you took the $300,000 from the Town Council that should never have happened but you would you pushed it through with Mr gski and only two people voted against it it's still bastardized and it shouldn't be further bastardized I'd like to say this packet when I saw it it was obviously orchestrated and I thought it was interesting that there were two police reports in it that had nothing to do with education that
165I couldn't understand at all so what I'd like to do is call his question let's have a vote I'm ready I I I don't know if anything needs to be said I guess once you call it it has to go yes okay okay we'll go to vote the question was Mrs colano asked if this could be opened up to the public for discussion such as we had with the trailer but in order to do so you would have to resend the call of the question well I think I think do not wish to then we I think Mrs Cal Miss calap panovich is friends have already spoken in this packet with Anonymous things and things like that so I I I'm not going to resend this we're going to vote and then they no I'm
166not asking you to resend your vote he's asking to resend the call no they could there's there's a forum there are two more forums and everybody can say their peace then and again this isn't about personalities it's not about politics for me anyway and it shouldn't be for this board it should be about policy we should be a policy body just voting on policies and just doing what's right for the kids not playing politics not being Mis poopular not being a queen or a king but just doing what's right for the kids let's get back to educating our kids let's build schools let's fix the nonsense and stop it and just stop the [Applause] garbage okay we'll have a roll call all right motion on the floor made by Mr cherella seconded by Mrs armenio
167is to Grant class one status to the Middle School PSA yes this has no this has no consequence on the existing PTO so uh just for for full disclosure that would still be in that's correct recognition so you would have two we're merely talking about the the uh paperwork being in order essentially class one status for building use paperwork being in order okay Mr Rybeck no Mrs k panich i uh we're going to wait for Mrs K Pano at the end of the vote as is the case uh we changed the order on the roll call as recommended at the last meeting to make it random and uh I beg your pardon you were supposed to be last as board president Mrs Deo no Mr Braverman yes Mr Chella yes Mrs Corino yes Mr rsky
168I believe I have to recuse I believe you're correct thank you Mr Russo yes Mrs armeno yes Mrs Lang is absent and Mrs K Pano no there are five Ys there are three NOS there is one recus and one absent motion passes we had can I speak we had a person a board member call the question and when that happens we have to go directly to the vote you have the opportunity to speak under um because now the public forum and it's been brought up if we will let you speak under public for could are we continuing with committee me yes we are okay I would like to talk about the um polic Mr U Mr chair I'm Sor Mr can I I'd like to say something just to clarify something that you said when
169it we talked when you talked about the referendum and the two questions the public needs to know that each question will be a yes or no so you can vote yes or no on the middle school you can vote yes or no on the high school and you can vote Yes for both and no for both no the number question two is yes for high school and middle school together right question one is just for Middle School so they they're voting for they're each question is a yes or no question yes so the public can vote Yes for both or no for both or yes for one and no for the other so it's it's a little confusing you're right so you're vot you could technically vote for the Middle School twice but you're still
170right right you're not going to get two middle schools no you're not going to get two middle schools just one yeah um regarding that packet that we all got are we going to follow through because this is pretty serious stuff are we going to follow through to see how this thing happened I I would like to I'm thinking about going to the prosecutor's office to have them check this out because this is this to me this is Major there are police reports in here 10 police reports all kinds of interesting things I'd like to know how it was obtained what happened who did it when they did it why they did it I'd love I'd love to hear it I'm not getting many answers can we make a motion on that because I think that
171I think it's important because I would hate to see something like this happen again going and it seems like unless this can be done legally to get these uh police reports yeah you can get police you can well we yeah but we don't know who provided them see that's if it was appropriate for somebody on in the district so I think we do need to follow up we need to investigate this okay we need to investigate make a motion okay I'd like to U motion that uh we look we I don't know we'd have to get an independent outside investigator to find out how this packet was put together and who made those decisions and yeah who who compiled the report I could I'm telling you that I I private we don't need to spend
172money on a private investigator telling you put I I put the I no but we don't know who got the police reports I don't know who gave me this right we need to find out that's nobody gave me this it was dropped off or sent to the board office with my name on it I don't know where this came from I can tell you what happen since I got it but that's okay so anything that's dropped off to the school board with everybody's name you just disseminate it we've done that many times we've done that with Anonymous letters I think that's a pretty flawed system Madam if it's addressed to the board it would go home that's why these went home most Anonymous documents would be would be sent to the board Anonymous letters have
173yes been sent home to the board of educationa I'll be sending a bunch of documents to you tonight for dissemination to the entire okay fine send it yourself you don't have to go through me I'm not okay with that I think we should still get somebody to to look into this I I I don't think we need to waste the money I would like to motion that we investigate who compiled the report what report who who delivered it to the school I have no idea well somebody knows who got the police report so whoever does the investigation can start there they can go to the police department and see who pulled those reports right that can be done and the good news is we have cameras we have surveillance so we we'll be see somebody
174had we can open the O it's important because we can't have this type of thing happening and we could look at when the day it was delivered and we could look at video and we could see who was who remember anybody can become a victim of this so I second your motion make a pardon what was the motion that we hire an outside investigator to look into who compiled this report who got the police reports and who dropped them off at the school and then if we can get a written statement from whoever sent them out can I ask a question sure he made a motion it has to be either seconded or not it was second thank you okay so my question is Mr this stuff is This Confidential no it's not well it
175was sent home with the confidential no there was no confidential with this home the Friday confidential the Friday confidential I I did not receive a confidential it was sent separately it was just sent it was just my concern it was left our let's talk one at a time my concern is if we research who sent this it will prevent PE people in the future from contacting us and expressing concern about other things my thought is this is confidential we keep this and it's not I that's what I assumed it was confidential and under what under what statute are you saying that it's confidential because we are ruled by the open public records act and we are ruled by the common law right of access so under what statute are you recommending that confidential part of
176our confidential board that we get every Friday it did not come that way it did not say confidential on it but my question is there are only a few things under these statutes that are considered confidential so we can't just decide you see this is what happens in municipalities and Boards they we just decide arbitrarily or unilaterally that we want to keep a secret and then we say it's confidential you cannot just say it's confidential okay but but if we so okay it's not confidential but if we go after the people that created this this will intimidate other people from contacting us in the future that's a different I totally accept your argument however do not use the wrong language it's not I agree with you I don't think we should be going after members
177of the public to find out who did this I think it came from the board I think it came from the administration I think it came from somebody here sitting at this table right now and I think that's what our investigation will find out and when we find that out it's going to be ugly uglier than it already is and here for the camera there's nothing on this that says confidential because I can tell you that's where they're going to go next that I violated confidentiality by talking about this attack piece that was put together in our Board office by our employees and delivered to us you can take me to the police office right now I'll take a lie detector test I had nothing to do with this okay there's a motion on the
178table if you will and I I I is this the discussion because I I would like to say while I agree with Mr cherell and Mr Russo i h I would like to make it a more sober uh uh discussion I don't think that we should pay for and I'm sorry Mr but I don't think we should pay for an investigation I don't want to have a chilling effect on anybody if we have an investigation internally and say that if there's somebody in the district who pulled certain documents and put it together that's fine I do not believe but I also don't want a chilling effect on anybody that puts anything together that the board should be notified with however this is stuff we should not have got to begin with so in some ways
179I'm conflicted because we shouldn't this is information while we while I understand that we would get it because it came to the board it is not something we should be involved in we've gone down this very slippery slope when you asked Mr uh Dr kak to fix it because it was settled then it wasn't settled then it was resettled and then it wasn't resettled so this is where all the training that and and all the things that you guys have told me about micromanaging went out the window apparently and we're stuck with this uh this situation so if you would like to make a motion to have an internal invest we have a motion onon that so can we even use like an organization like School boards to advise the boards what should be sent
180out in weekly confidentials or what information that's brought to their attention should be sent out to the board in a productive I think it's I think the statutes are very clear Mr Goodall you have things that are of public domain and again we forget all the money we ask the all the public to to spend that and then and then we don't want them to know what's going on the public domain says these things are not confidential I don't think well not in labeling them confidential but just information that the board should be privy to as a board member that comes to the attention of central office board president or the board entirely you can't keep anything some discuss I'm sorry I don't think you can keep anything from the board as a whole that
181has been my I think that's the point that Mr Gorski made that when it's addressed to the Board of Education it's disseminated to the board yes Prudence but Prudence would say the way it was disseminated it was inappropriate I think yeah but okay so then maybe someone like the school boards can advise us on that I think there's another Factor here you know I've done investigations of this type before this thing was sent out it was time sensitive I didn't know we were voting on any of this tonight and I don't think anyone that wasn't at the buildings and grounds meeting knew it because that's probably when it was decided so that narrows the number of people who knew about that vote and had to get this document out before do you know when I
182got this document I got it on Thursday Madam that's what I'm saying but it was I got it on Thursday so I I don't know that people had I had time to contact all these people some of them I don't even who have an idea who they and ask them to write a letter and give it to me in Thursday yeah but you want to do an internal make a make an amendment to do an internal uh investigation and we'll do that I don't want to disrespect Mr Russo's uh Madam may I make a point of clarification this was not sent home as part of the weekly confidential this was delivered like any parcel of mail to the board because the majority of the content was addressed to the Board of Education okay just like
183any parcel of mail that's delivered to the central office or mailed and picked up by post office if it's addressed to the Board of Education broadly like that without a name of the board member it's copied and given to every member that's been the practice and and is the practice also then that the that the board president will add extra emails and extra content to it to send home so here's here's some more so here's something that bashes some member of the public and here's a few more that I had to address to the Board of Education well let's go through them if you want here Board of Ed Board of you know I I don't know I didn't add anything anything that came you just said you added two emails I have the emails
184that came to me we all have a note from the a board secretary saying that you added two emails to it Mr Trella there was an email that came to you and I that is added to this because it all had the same content but what does it have to do with the the police reports that had nothing I have no idea I didn't create this I don't know what you want me to tell you I'm saying like you thought it was prudent for us to have right but somebody having arguments about this packet came to me in addition to this packet there were two emails sent to me that I included with this packet I'm afraid that we've opened ourselves up here to a major lawsuit and I think this is not just the
185first time because I think Dr you know we're probably going to have a lawsuit based upon what happened earlier this year and now we're going to have potentially another one and I think we need to stop stop doing things that puts our taxpayers money in Jeopardy for personal animus I mean it's it's just insane to me I don't I just don't understand it I don't understand what's happening where I am I'm in bizar World Mr Ryback I certainly want to just add a few thoughts and and open up uh you know uh to the other board members um I was just curious if I don't think we necessarily have to go Mr Min I'm sort of agreeing with you I don't think we have to go outside and hire a special investigator um I don't
186know Rob I don't mean to be dumping on you forgive me but uh um I think you might certainly be able to conduct somewhat of Investigation on you know from your office and uh I thought your idea of working of using New Jersey school boards just as a as a a a source you know get some information I know they have a legal department but and we have our own attorney but uh you know Justice a source to get some information and uh maybe we can uh work together to um prevent some this kind of disc Steve I want I I I to I do respect you but I'm going to tell you something every time members who disagree with the the ruling Council here we we end up having a a a lesson from
187school boards right and and we get how we supposed to do things and Meanwhile we're all sitting here looking at each other like wait they do all this stuff and why why are we given the lesson so we're going to have a lesson now to learn that this was okay to do is that what the is that the object of the lesson because I I have an idea let's have them come in and look at this stuff and let them spend a couple hours with me and I'll guarantee you there will be other different people in that lesson not us yeah I'm not comfortable with that so there's a motion on the table right thank you well Ro are you still with about getting a investigator to pay for investiga motion on the floor made
188by Mr Russo seconded by Mr cherell as to hire a private investigator um who will investigate who compiled the report correct me if I'm wrong and and then uh how was it distributed to the the central office and then and I think I answered how why it was delivered to the board who compiled it which includes the collection of the police reports yeah I would be satisfied with just finding that out that must be the person who delivered me too I would be satisfied with the police reports that'll tell us a lot but as long as we had a good open honest investigation where the video was reviewed not all of a sudden hey there's a really odd thing that happened there was a power that just so happened to eclipse the cameras at the
189exact moment that this person dropped us off and I know that was uh weird Madam but that's exactly what I don't want any of that I want the truth that's all it'll be easy we look at the cameras we go who is this what is their what is their license play who is it and if it turns out that there isn't a person there then we look internally and we get a report back look internally anyway I would love to have an internal investigation add that make a motion and make a uh an an addendum or to his motion we'll do an internal investigation I would I I would like to ask Mr Russo and he can certainly say no if that we elim I mean again because if members of the if if people
190put their names on it even anonymous because you can even ask for records anonymously um I don't want to disrupt anybody in the public from uh speaking their mind or making whether it's slanderous or inappropriate or anything I believe in Free Speech even if I don't even if I disagree with it um I'm wondering if however we can limit it to what we thought was the inappropriate part of the package which was like the the internal police report no the police reports which I felt were I I started reading everything and I was trying to take everything with an open mind and then I realized two things one it was really getting out of control that it was not nice and I don't like it from any side and two when people put that in
191they lost me because I thought that it was totally done on to you know to to yeah to disparage someone and and I'm not going to be a part of that so I think that if if I don't know if you're willing to if you're not I I respect and AC accept your position but that's the that's the part that got me out of uh out of kilter everybody else has has a right to say what they want to say right or wrong um I don't appreciate some of the language and and what was said I don't know if it's true but again to Mr chiarella's point it is not our place I don't think we need school boards to tell us that it's not our place to do this this should have been handled
192uh the way it was handled originally with Dr kak when he said to the superint uh to the the building uh principal and it should have been what was happening in in my opinion was that the decisions that the superintendent was making were not acceptable and people again were unilaterally going in to change his mind and to have him fix things that they thought and tweak things that shouldn't have been tweaked so that's where I am at also not just this package it's the history prior to this package that is making me feel that we're doing something wrong by addressing for a point of and and just for a point of clarity my suggestion of using school boards or another organization like school boards was not to um chastise anyone or teach anyone a lesson
193it actually when it popped into my head how can we make this better that it I know they're an organization that works with Board of EDS and it was just simply even for my own learning uh curve being new to the role that I would have some questions and also get information so I could serve the board better and to give advice about what should be sent home and what should not be sent home and I and I agree with you Mr and that was not aimed toward you at all know there has just been a prior history want to point of us being pulled in to go through school boards training every time they think we need a lesson you know I need a lesson uh on on whatever you know or we need
194to tweak our social media policy or we need to do something like that to control me or to control other board members when really I think we need to control the people doing this stuff and since last September we've had one school board training which was our goal this year as a board goal to have a school board training and we've had one and that was it this year that was our goal I'm talking about history but to have I'd like to know if we're going to have future policy issues like every policy like the homework polic is coming up will we have police reports going back to 2011 uh you know from the people that put that policy together because I'd love to see that because that's what you did what I did I
195went and got the police reports I received it I gave them to you because they were given to the Board of Education okay we should get things that go to the Board of Education certainly but we but we have a resolution can you limit would you be willing to re um re phrase your motion you want me to rephrase it to what well like as Mrs Miss armeno said no well he I I said I would respect whatever he says if you want to put a number value on it so we don't go Haywire Madam if if it pleases the board that you could make this motion so that I am directed to solicit proposals for an investigation and then you can ultimately approve the the dollar amount first before you proceed we could have
196that by the next meeting I don't know how much this investigation's going to cost I don't know if it's over the the quote threshold if it warrants an RFP I I don't know what's involved with this okay let me ask a question first to the board uh would it satisfy everybody to get um a written document from Mary that she okay to send this out because she she must have reviewed it I believe she did and a report on who who um who is the one who obtained the the reports from the police department that yes that would be good yes and and I'm and I'm perfectly comfortable with having Mr Goodall looking in look look into this but I would limit it to just Mr Goodall so you know not to bring any outside
197people in I don't want to put more work on you but what I'm asking is just to look at the video talk to the secretaries alone and and and and then come back to the board I trust you come back to the board with your with your you know with a report to us Madam Madam so procedurally Mr Russo if you wanted to withdraw your motion yes and then the board president can direct Mr Goodall to conduct this internal investigation as was just stated no just make a new resolution make a new motion yeah you don't need a resolution for the for the board president to ask for an investigation well I don't think anybody from the board should be involved in the investigation no I don't think anybody in the board would be involved
198in the investigation what we I would not be involved in the investigation Mr kski just said you would be she would she would direct uh well she to conduct an investigation I don't think it's I could do that right now if that makes you all comfortable I will ask Mr Goodall if he will investigate start an investigation so what we want is a signed document from Mary that she reviewed and okay the release of this information and can can do that and M wait we're not and M for M I would have to I would be asking the board attorney if I could get a sign copy from the board attorney no I'm asking you she to do that oh yeah sure yes and we would like a report on U who who uh obtained
199the police reports yeah I would accept that way you're asking if any board employees obtained the police report or who dropped off who did well we could Oprah the Oprah that pulled those police reports so we could find out who it was now again if it was a member of the public I don't I I don't necessarily need to know that right but if it was a member if it was an employee or if it was a member of this board a board of ed member or a member of this Administration I'd like to know that but Ken if it's you know we could be told it's a member of the public and we don't know who it is and maybe it wasn't that's a good point that's what it has to be in writing
200in writing is someone someone will put their name to it if it's a lie it's a lie I think Mr goodoff can handle that and I will I'll look into I hope he does because I have another investigation I'm going to ask you to look up to do as well when we get to it so Mr Russo do you wish to withdraw your motion uh yes and um I everybody's breathing a little easier now seem like some people were really worried about this but I think it's better if we if we can resolve the problem the right way so do I have to make another motion or do we have it on I have an agreement yes okay so what is the agreement okay I'm willing to accept that okay so what is no I
201just want you to repeat it back so so we know to that you would like the superintendent of schools to investigate and look into circumstances rounding a packet of information that was dropped off it seems anonymous ly to the board of education and then was uh addressed to the Board of Ed and then distributed to board members no but there's two important points who collected who who obtained the police uh reports that's what we want to know we want to know who who yeah that's the main one I don't know if I could ascertain who would yes and from the private private citizens uh from the police department they should be able to uh we can do that's this would prove that either a board member did it or an administrator did it or a
202member of the public and if it wasn't opra there has to be an audit Trail because that's the way the government works they don't just give you stuff out and I'm going to tell you something I I opra stuff about a councilman Council woman and about a candidate who was running for for an office and I was told by the police department that I couldn't get that information because it was personal because it was about it happened during a divorce where there was arrests uh that happened during a divorce proceeding B and because of that they told me I couldn't get that you couldn't get it from about a private citizen so when I saw this I thought oh this is interesting because we even have stuff back in 2011 from this person calling because
203the snow wasn't the snow on the street wasn't plowed that's incredible to me so I think that this had to have been opena and if it wasn't opra if there's no Auto Trail at all then that tells me something totally different and we have a bigger problem on our hand and we're in a really dangerous situation because then there's some collusion here between somebody on this board somebody in this in in this district and and the township all right so I'm I'm certainly open to using any means that I can to get all of the information including the police reports and if I could not legally get them then I would come back and report that thank you sir and and that has to be done strictly by you not with the assistance of anybody
204else in the school has to be done by you okay so for example an email to the police department uh which would be a nice thing an email to the police department requesting who was the one who received that report or who's the one who filed the oer that's allowed but I will I will do what I can as superintendent and that would be good within law statute policy to obtain and if I could not then or got got a ro block I would report that out to the board and additional steps could be taken thank you Mr good and then we have to well we get into the consequences later I guess since there never seems to be any okay I think we're still on committee report go ahead Mr Chella are you done
205I am done thank you goe I have curriculum okay [Applause] we the curriculum um committee reviewed seven curriculum documents the first one was the grade four grade five and grade six language arts curriculum documents um they were revised this summer key updates to the documents include lessons and assessments that reflect the updated New Jersey student learning standards and the readers and Writers Workshop model in addition the utilization of Atlas Atlas is our online curriculum tool to link websites assessments lessons Google gole drive and other resources also a comprehensive scope and sequence to not only address the standards but also strengthen each student's individual reading and writing skills through exposure to and instruction in various genres of texts and types of writing the sixth grade Spanish curriculum was also updated it's a half aye course students
206take Spanish every other marking period the goal of the revised curriculum is to meet the needs of sixth graders who now sixth grade with a stronger foundation in Spanish as a result of the Blended learning language program in grades three through grade five students learn the reason for studying a second language and advantages of biliteracy as well as culture and their homes this class prepares them for future language studies we had three new music um curriculum documents we had we have I'm sorry yeah we have a new class an unified elective it's a music class it's a general music class and it's designed in partnership with the special education department this Partners Dynamic Learners of all abilities skills to learn about General music in a Collaborative Learning environment the latest addition to our unified elective
207course or offering in addition to the family and consumer science offerings and fine art Arts offerings there are six units that Center on Center on learning about music notation concert etiquette both as a performer and an audience member music composition and music appreciation we now have a treble chorus which was previously known as The Women's Chorus it's an audition based chorus um it has a strong emphasis on the development of repertoire performance and reading composition vocal production and vocal technique performance assessments are conducted in 8 to 12 member groups collaboratively and singularly there are concert performance that are in three to six parts and they progress in difficulty throughout the year we also now have a a honors concert choir this is um an honors Elite choir it's very rigorous and students are held to
208very high expectations there's a strong emphasis on music literacy and the and highlevel performance at various venues it's a highlevel rep repertoire and it's selected annually tryouts are in June sections and Ensemble sections are run by students the unit also features conducting skills score study and College Prep [Music] um the treble chorus and the pop a capella are awaiting a response from an all Eastern Conference application prior to this time no Monroe choir has ever been admitted before so we're keeping our fingers crossed that they get admitted would be great for the Monroe uh chorus Community um there are numerous performances throughout the community Miss Ariel Klein director of choir activities spent the summer in France touring with the University of Delaware as a lead soloist um and enrollment has increased annually in our choir
209programs since Miss Klein took over so um it's good to hear that the choir programs are growing in scope and depth we also adopted a new Social Studies textbook um the it's called The American Pageant Kennedy by Kennedy and Cohen um it will replace a hard C it's going to be a eBook it is replacing a hard copy text used by students since 2005 our current book is now get outdated and provides no support or helpful suggestions to augment or modify instructions the 220 ebooks to be purchased provides for continued number of needed to keep Pace with increased school and Department enrollment and growth the purchase of this new ebook digital only um provides ample instruction guidance and support for staff the selected text also keeps the honors US History program in line with the
210rigor of our AP program in in addition we reviewed um I know it.com last year it was used by a few teachers as a free service um this year a few teachers um want to use it in their classroom um it provides math practice based on skill it also provides data for the teacher regarding what skills need more work so the teacher can see how the student is progressing and where they me may need more help it also allows teachers to set parameters to tailor the experience and make it more engaging um and the data has been useful for specialist teachers and principles in the RTI process um this is available for teachers it's cost $150 per 30 licenses which means two classrooms so if teachers are interested it um it's available for them and
211that is it thank you Mr Ryback just very briefly from Personnel um I we're looking for a teacher for um because of increased enrollment in special ed we're looking for what's called a prechool integrated teacher that's a combination of regular Ed and special ed and um it's a it's a wonderful program and it's a needed program um but it's due because of the increase in enrollment and also uh what gets me and I'm sure you'll all agree with me it's an unfunded mandate so this is money now that we I believe we have Mr Gorski but it's money that has to be spent on this program because the the um legislator deems that necessary but they don't fund it that's something to keep in the back of our minds when we talk about state aid
212as as it goes on thank you you anyone else Finance oh Mr redsky Finance few things from the finance meeting uh of last Wednesday we had a uh guest join us Mr Edo Mali who is the district insurance broker from Gallagher Benefit Services he works very closely with Mr Gorski on all of our insurance needs we went over the district employee assistance plan which currently we have a contract with RWJ barnabus One Source um what the EAP Employee Assistance Plan does is it provides 247 consulting services to staff for reasons of stress family problems depression psychological problems and more and unfortunately it doesn't get utilized uh nearly enough and and to the tune of about 1 to two% of our staff uh utilizes this per year so the proposal is to look at a new
213company called carebridge has sort of a larger scope of clients throughout the the country um and and they have a historically significantly higher usage ratio in a range of more to six to 7% which still doesn't seem like a heck of a lot to me but it's progress um I think one of the things we discussed in the meeting is just being more active with um announcing it making it available reminding people of it that you know the staff and the and the uh employees of the district and uh making it as user friendly as possible so that's uh something we considered and then actually based on the price we are currently paying almost 25,000 for barnabus one and the price for the new carebridge would be 16,000 so roughly a savings of $8 to
214$9,000 a year and the service it provides uh could only be better so we did vote in favor of that excuse me actually from the looks of these board meetings maybe they could be made available to board bed members as well as District employees and then we'll definitely bring the percentage usage up so okay aside from that sorry I is that a dig it's it's not a dig it's a reality um but it's just something that just troubles me anyway student accident policy was also something we discussed uh the last couple of years there's been three serious student injuries um unfortunately and because of that rates have been escalating each of the last two years uh Mr Gorski and Mr Ali actually this year were able to negotiate a 0% increase uh which was a
215nice accomplishment and saved money from what was previously budgeted um that was great news um again Mr Ali is the person who works very close with Mr Gorski on all of the insurance and when Mr Russo always ask does Mr Gorski work alone the answer is no he works with Mr omali as the insurance broker so so it was nice to meet him and uh get get some of that information last but not least Falcon care ECE financial report for the year ended June 30th combined the programs had a profit of 483,000 which a very good respectable year of pro profits uh for note P respectfully last two years was 62,500 26,000 so this was a little lower looks like there's a demographic shift that took place uh went up came back down we believe
216that it should head back in a positive direction um this year or next year at the latest um in total those last three years is $1.6 million of which as a reminder we took 600,000 of that um and we because it's retained earnings we are able to shift it towards the cost of the trailers this year which was nice uh to offset that expense and that much less we had to ask the taxpayers for that concludes my finance report anyone else you have a report just a no not a report but since he mentioned my name uh yes I did say Mr Gorski works alone because he does work alone we we're using a broker outside that broker doesn't work for the school Madam point point of correction I i' I've I've corrected Mr on
217this issue before and and with the utmost respect for a board member sir I do not work alone in the capacity of negotiating the health insurance rates the Property and Casualty rates student accident rates the board retained the services of a broker I work closely with the broker to set goals as far as what is feasible with the school district budget so I wouldn't have to go back to the superintendent and say sorry sir the recommendation from Horizon this year is a 133% increase a $2 and A5 million um increase in the appropriation line item that's half the growth that the budget is able to grow in a year you're going to have to cut programs and services universally in order to make that fit I work closely with the broker I make recommendations to
218go out and get competitive quotes I make recommendations to the broker to this year we almost um switch carriers by bringing it to the board and making a switch I do not in any way determine these uh $20 million appropriation amounts by myself so who hope that's clear everybody in everything you've always said and even now you answered my question you are the one who negotiates the rates with the broker you do you bring them to the board but you negotiate them I know nobody else here is involved with negotiating that's not true and nobody in the school is involved with negotiating that's that's incorrect I do not negotiate the rates with Horizon I don't speak to Horizon with the broker you do the BR which I find even more troubling and the broker is
219trying to serve the board's best interest and getting the rates down as best as possible I contribute what is what is hisory on supposed to do and uh that's what a broke is supposed to do but to have one person what's feasible with the budget I'm going to make a motion that read it now this this should Madam while Mr Russo's um um contemplating motion I would like to remind the board and this community that the health insurance savings that are not only negotiated with the broker with my participation are presented at every finance committee meeting before the budget is voted on at every administrative meeting and at the board meeting at the tenative and final adoption of the budget this is one of the areas that the county office has said is one of
220our fiscal best practices I don't understand the problem with this well I don't mean this is a fantastic accomplishment I should be saying you're welcome not defending practice pointing out it was nice to meet Mr omali who works with Mr Gorski on these health insurance issues and projects and and contracts let me just find I have it I pointed out to the board before that Benefit Services has a very large book of business including Philadelphia School District so when they negotiate on our behalf they get they have clout they have negotiating leverage they bring all their clients together and they get very competitive rates unlike the arrangement we had before where you had uh several small school districts um handled by one small brokerage firm and it was subject to Wild swings and in a
221member of the mtea joined me the insurance representative and we presented it to the finance committee to make the change it was done in an open transparent and collaborative way and it serves the taxpayers and the employees of this District in a way that the county office States over and over is a fiscal best practice County business administrator asked even asked me to write an article for ke Post Magazine on the successes we've had in controlling Insurance r is that funny Mr Russo um I I think it I think it's uh ridiculous that one person works with a broker to negotiate $21 million contract per year I do I do what about the superintendent what about the finance commit what about the board all those people years working doing contracts and negotiating deals and never
222would they never let one person work alone never I don't know how many times I have to say I can work can we move on with the agenda while you're looking for your MO okay I have it here so I would like to make a motion that um we need to establish well I'm not going to say it's a policy that any contract of $100,000 or more requires a committee be established with a minimum of three people who work in the district in different areas and do not report to each other to be involved in negotiations one of the committee person would be designated as the subject matter expert one as a chair and the other as a secretary and we can discuss the the worklow in in detail Madam why don't we just bring
223it back to policy bring it to policy and let the policy discuss it Madam may I ask Mr Russo If he if he looked at all at the procurement laws involved with this matter before before creating such a motion do you understand what laws are on contracts no I think it's in the best interest of the school district to have more people involved in negotiation can we bring it to policy and discuss it there why can't we vote on it there's there's large ramifications here that have to do with procurement laws the procur laws information before they would why don't we bring it back to finance I mean to me it violates every rule of common sense you have one person think about it one person my go involved with a $21 million Pere contract
224Mr Russo I am one person I am one being but but the finance committee is multiple beings they not involve with negotiation you the board of education is a larger group subset that that that votes on this who who meet 10 members of the board who ultimately approve the insurance contract who meets with the broker only you who talks to the broker only you who negotiates with the rat administration's job is to manage the schools sir not well that's what I'm saying so we want to we want to make it more robust we want to make it enhance it allow three people to be involved so maybe we'll get better rates we don't know and who are you suggesting do so and have that knowledge and background and theoretical experience other than the business administrator
225that would like ask better worked with Laura you have we've all we all buy insurance that would be like asking you know the business administrator to weigh in on on the curriculum design you're wrong you're wrong we all buy insurance we're all familiar with uh insurance and rates you're involved you're one person and there'll be two people working with you every large organization that's the way it's done Frank I just have to if you know I have to just second the motion huh it's like the weigh in on something you're saying he's wrong but that's in your opinion it's not a fact it's just your op I'm saying he's the only one negotiating the rates it's not about wrong he was just responding and you said you're wrong you're wrong that's your opinion it's not
226a fact um for years even before I was a board member Mr Gorski gives his reports saves us all kinds of money on insurance and that's his you don't know if it's a fact that's what he tells you he we know what it starts out with we know what they ask for Madam I I presented to the board and I presented to the finance committee a letter from Gallagher Benefit Services is that board's attain broker that's stated where Horizon's initial proposal came in and where it was ultimately negotiated saving the taxpayers the employees of this District why do you have such a problem with two other people involved why do you have such a problem with that Mr Mr best practice that you're insulting and humiliating without an understanding of what you're speaking to I
227understand I've been involved with negotiations for many years and I know that the best practice is to have more than one person involved especially especially with such a large contract I didn't finish and all right Mr Ryback you go and then Mr Mr bra how come he's first because he was not finished and I interrupted him just interrupt I I think that we're trying what we're doing here is imputing the reputation of a business administrator who's done an outstanding job for us for for many years uh on his budgets and and in negotiations in fact it's the job of the business administrator to look into this but he doesn't uh to negotiate but he doesn't really do it alone because Common Sense he reports to the finance committee he reports to the board he gives
228us facts uh and he gives us his opinion you don't have to agree with me this is my opinion it's not agreement Steve you don't get it he's not negoti he informs the board we don't negotiate no you don't that's not our job to who negotiates but that's his business department business administrator that's his job that's hisob part of his job description that's his job what I'm saying is there should be more people involved with such a large can we hear from you yeah I I appreciate what Mr Russo is saying but I think it should be handled in a policy and just as an aside I had a Course once in Business Administration for schools and the professor said if you really want to make hay with your board what you ought to do
229is tell them tell tell them that you saved the a lot of money first put too much too much in the budget and then then then tell them what the real figure is and tell them you saved it I'm not saying that happens here but it'll make Mr Russo feel a lot better if we had at least a policy and go ahead with this and you certainly don't have to pass the policy unless you're happy with it yeah I think that's we bring it back to the policy committee and look at it that way on the table Excuse Me Miss I think there is a motion on the table was it second yes and not not to be uncooperative but we you have to consider the limitations and the resources that we have here at
230central office it may be different from any private organization in terms of negotia so it sounds like the best practice is that the business administrator at Monroe Township uh neoti $21 million contract it's once per year I think it's worth putting more with all du respect I I I can understand if we were paying um way more we don't know we don't know the the data in the report tells us that there is a significant savings to the board of education and and certainly if the if our rates had increased to a point where we had a cut programs and we had to cut staff and and so forth that certainly um that practice ractice may may be looked at but not being invol I think Mr Russo is really right on on on track
231I just don't think we should do it the way he's suggesting but um limited resources that's ridiculous I think from what I understand Mr rutsky is a finance person uh he's he's in security we have a lot of lot of people here we've got people on staff that are also very experienced in different things so uh I I I I just think it should be policy do you want to continue with your motion or you want to withdraw it and send it to policy well I would like to continue with this because I think this one is very important all right then we'll have a roll call Mam I'm going to ask the gentleman to repeat the motion do you have it written down yeah there's maybe we can just give it to any contract
232of $100,000 or more requires a committee be established with it with a minimum of three people who will work in the district in different areas and do not report to each other so has to be three people who don't report to each other who work in different areas because you can't have three people and two of them who work under misorski that would be like not having any um security at all uh one of the committee persons would be designated as a subject matter expert one as a chair and one as the um one other as a secretary so are you looking for like an athletic director to work with him or the science curriculum person you can you can find people from any Department who's who's who are available this is not hard stuff
233to learn right but they'll be involved in the process it's not hard stuff learn you have one subject Madam I have you have one accounting I'm a certified public accountant I have a master's degree with distinction we talking about negotiating health insurance we're talking about negotiating Health don't make it more comp career to be able to be successful with this listen we've had people on on procurement committees that that bought very complicated systems and they don't have to know how the system works how many resources do you think we have in the central office it doesn't have to be from the central office it can be a vice principal it can be an athletic coach sure athletic coach is negotiate you're the subject matter expert you have two those employees report to the superintendent the
234key behind having the three people is for transparency I understand having him there by himself we don't know what's happening I can't believe what I'm hearing does that happen in any other school district this happens nowhere in in any industry well it does happen we have health insurance rates that average 6% over the last few private or public sector has don't diminish your colleagues okay it's not that complicated neoti industry where you're going to get 6% average health insurance increases over the last few years that's in your opinion Mr Mr no that's brought up the the the the the saying this is a a solution looking for a problem what is your objective this is a fisal best practice that you're looking to why are you fighting having two other people involved in the process
235what what is the finance Comm much to this you're put if if you can't pick two people in the school who are not capable of working with you on a contract what I what I don't understand you by limiting that they can't report to anyone either you're limiting the people who could participate such a Comm they wouldn't be able to report to to him so I don't understand what the end game is with the committee because you have people who are transparency okay transparency but the but he brings it to the finance committee last year that's not last year he had a zero but the finance committee is not negotiating the race but when he has a zero increase in healthcare rat I mean I don't know I don't know based on what what do
236you mean based on what those are the numbers how do you know they could have been lower you mean that they would pay us to have healthare instead of a zero increase rate is that what you're saying you know wouldn't be lower lower than a zero increase rate zero increase means no increase means you're paying the same amount we had a zero increase rate last year Mr fori Zer increase right maybe there could have been a decrease in the rates would we don't know first of all your your level of 100,000 is why are you objecting that's the that's the case first of all first of all you we haven't even gotten through the one contract 21 million employee assistance 21 million you feel by putting a threshold of 100,000 we haven't even really delay
237and we would not get a lot of things accomplished by going through such a commit okay well let's start with just this one this one just the health insurance because the single biggest one so you're just picking out one specific because based on I'm thinking about what you're saying at a $100,000 level like that's almost every decision in the district not you want to redo the turf field that's more than $100,000 you want to buy iPad PA you're in finance and you you you think this is normal to have one person negotiate every year 21 million when I I deal with contracts over $20 million I've never seen any procurement done with $21 million I get your Madam Madam Mr Russo's motion to have a committee look at every $100,000 contract okay would gum up
238the procurement process so bad here that vendors wouldn't get paid and and the and the instructional goods and services that we delivered to this district will seize up not to mention you would be duding this with let's bring it to policy or finance and discuss it there no but he's putting up a lot of resistance so what would be a good figure that wouldn't come up because he has Mr Russo with all due respect he has an expertise in with in in in procurement with uh all the companies and that he has been working with and negotiating with with the broker so there's your subject matter expert what's wrong with having two more people involved because they don't have the expertise in negotiating contracts for what happens if something happened to him cuz it's in
239my job description and it's not in anybody else's that's the answer to the question one business administ that's public school districts operate yeah so well maybe that it's time for them to change I think I think it opens the door to potential corruption to have one person who's negotiating a21 milon I don't think there has been a wait I don't think there's been a problem with our audits or with anybody complaining that's another thing we had the same guy doing the audits for 30 years with one person you know what I don't think he wants to have his license taken away because he's did we motion to check motion to change the order did that go out what the auditor did that did we go out for I don't know has that been advertised yet
240that's a we're on a different topic now okay I asked I asked Mrs armeno you made the motion to switch orders do you recall when I presented to the board and the finance committee the size of the RFP document for Food Service management company it is a very involved process it is not something that hire another auditor this is a a lengthy process there's a lot of law involved and it's being performed okay it's being done okay that's all you want to call that Mr Russo with with all due respect you're a member of the Board of Education and I and I I respect you and I respect the public who elected you I don't think you have enough understanding of the process here of procurement in order to make a motion like this I
241would invite you into the office to speak more with Mr godall and myself or to investigate this further perhaps speak with the broker perhaps speak with the county business administrator so that you could be better informed on better informed from a practical point do you think it makes any sense to have one person who has all the knowledge about negotiating with for Insurance Mr Russo policy for $21 million every year every year I've expressed this as many ways as I can there is not one person negotiating health insurance rates and this is going on in other it is the standard practice for school districts right and there are other districts who are have higher I think it's a very bad practice it's the broker it's the business administrator it's the finance committee it's the ultimately
242the board who's been approving it look you're throwing in all these names the only one who negotiates is you that's false sir and I'm not going to argue with you anymore how do we negotiate with anybody you mentioned the board how do we negotiate yeah how you don't negotiate it you approve it the finance committee provided the information deliberates on it and recommends it to the board that's how it works so you're saying Mr Goodall negotiates Mr you everybody kind of negotiates when you when you're talking about a budget with st negoti he negotiates with staff on on salaries he does negotiate okay we need to move we are not we are not negotiating can we bring it back to policy or because we're wasting a lot of time when we haven't even gotten into
243a page three of the agenda all right I'm certainly okay with looking at transparency but if the standard practice for all New Jersey Public School Systems is to have the designate Mr Gorski negotiate uh contracts in this case insurance contract and just because I don't see the necessity for Monroe to be a standalone well we don't want to be the the um what do you call it the um the district the district that goes against best practice Yeah it's not a best practice that's the problem the the county is considering this one of our best practices it's not it's but that's what your opinion is County opinion is we are yeah where is that do you want we'll get a letter from if you want we'll get something in writing if you want that we
244can get a letter from the county I don't see why we can't we get yeah we will having one person negotiate we will get a count we will get an opinion okay well you know there's a resolution that the board passes that gives me the authority to negotiate contracts it's also in my job description and in and it's inherent in my license as business administrator see my only fear about taking to policy is goes to policy it gets dragged out like every other thing we brought to policy and nothing gets done well then let's see what the county says about this because they're they have they deal with every District in every school district in the county all right I I'm still going to push for more than one person particularly for insurance because it's
245too much of a contract for one person to be dealing with a broker by themselves without anybody else in the school district are are you keeping your motion on the table no I'll pull it okay I before I just like to say that as frustrating and upsetting or whatever this is again this is deliberation folks but also it is it is a good thing wait Mr gki please I understand and it is it's I don't think it's just about you in particular but my my question is sometimes people have to and I I don't know if he's in his comfort zone or not but I mean I'm a little uncomfortable I'm Adam my comfort zone a little bit but I would like to thank board members who are willing to risk you know being laugh
246at yeah being laughed at I guess or or whatever to to at least entertain different things so let's let's try as frustrating as it is and may be difficult to hear at least appreciate people who are trying to in their own you know way make things you know make things at least more transparent or better or whatever it is but I I you know let's we can move on since Mr Russo pulled it I'll pull it we'll take it to policy but I'm not going to stop it and I I it's particularly for insurance and then there may be other contracts as well okay I think it's highly ridiculous to have one person dealing with a broker for a $21 million year contract you said it are we still on committee reports true I I
247just closed Finance it's up to Michelle I'm I'm going to do real quick uh we have two policies that are for the second reading the student suicide prevention as second and final reading and the homework policy I noticed a we had a change on the actual policy for homework on number nine where we said it would be at the discretion of the teacher during uh defined breaks and then I noticed on the regulation it says there's no expectation for work to be done during the break uh we can vote on this tonight I'm going to bring it back to the policy just for consistency um and I would also like the teachers um to consider this policy review it and if they have any concerns to bring it to um I guess me I'm the
248chair of the policy through uh the president of the board and then we'll we'll we'll talk about it I want to make sure it works for them as well the teachers should be in charge of that as as much just to address that the teachers were involved in this completely there was a huge committee that looked at this I know but all the teachers can read it now once it's passed because it wasn't passed before all the teachers can read it and if there are teachers and I hope that if there are teachers who speak up they're well their their voices are welcome okay um uh I will just say please there are several policies for the first reading uh 155 is equal employment and discrimination practice there's a student smoking policy so I would
249encourage all of the parents to take a look at these policies online not going to go through each one and um if there are any issues please email us thank you I do want to talk to Mary okay can we move on now from committee reports I'm done okay um public forum anyone wants to speak to the agenda come to the microphone state your name and address for the record boy for tamarak Road um I'll give you the item numbers in the agenda that I'm referring to that may uh make it a little bit easier uh you have an item AJ through am uh well it's items AJ through am and there's even some subsequent items that are related to that uh that deal with these after school extra help uh programs that operate at
250the high school uh you're approving the teachers for those programs uh I I would encourage you uh to evaluate how well those programs are working uh in comments that I've heard from students over the years because I have tutored students as well as I have grandchildren in the system uh they indicate that sometimes when particularly when they go to the CAC uh uh after school program that there are 20 25 students there and only one teacher so if they get five minutes with that teacher you know they're lucky uh I I've uh said well what about getting extra help after school from your own classroom teacher and they said most of the times the classroom teacher says we go to one of the after school labs to get the extra help so I would just
251say that I think it's great to offer these extra extra help sessions but I think uh I would encourage that the administration evaluate those in terms of their effectiveness are they really serving uh the best interest of the students in terms of their getting extra help uh you have item AZ which is a Personnel item uh and I notice that you're approving six Math teachers to well six teachers to teach additional sections of math because of increased enrollments uh you're also being asked to approve five business teachers uh to to pick up additional sections of business because in enrollments and for uh physics teachers to do the same kind of thing uh it concerns me that that this is the practice that is done uh because I think it puts an extra load on those
252teachers that are already carrying the full load I think it has a NE impact on that teacher's ability to prepare for the classes that they're supposed to teach I think it has a negative impact upon that teacher stamina the fact that they're simply they're not getting any downtime or very very little downtime and in terms of your homework policy that you are doing a second reading on tonight I think it has an impact on the implementation of that homework policy because a teacher that's teaching more than the ordinary number of sections if they're required to evaluate homework that's assigned then they may reduce the amount of homework they're assigning because they simply don't have the time to to evaluate uh so I'm just concerned that you didn't hire another math teacher you didn't hire another
253business teacher you didn't hire another physics teacher or aort time PHS teacher uh by assigning these extra sections uh and finally the policy on student smoking I read that carefully uh as some of you know I'm a former High School principal and it does not instruct the principal or the principal's designate on what to do uh with any substances that are found on students which are suspected uh to be something other than tobacco now I realize that that may be specified in a separate policy dealing with drugs but I know that sometimes particularly if you have inexperienced administrators they may simply go to the first policy that they find or regulation that they find and um this particular policy on student smoking does not tell them what they should do and newspapers have reported in
254fact recently that some administrators in New Jersey have found themselves faced with disciplinary action because they flush the substances down the toilet Mr Po your time is up I realize that I simp to say that in that policy I think there should be a direction in terms of what the administrator should do if they suspect that thank you good evening group of seagull 12 Mitchell Drive I just want to take the opportunity to thank uh the committee that reviewed the homework policy I know it's been lots of months looking through surveys teachers involved a lot of people looking at the policy it's very comprehensive and seems to cover a lot of the issues and concerns that parents have been discussing and even some of the students um going along the lines with the homework policy
255and looking at the whole child have we ever had midterms in our school district at the high school level um I've recently been talking to some of the going back probably 10 years ago is this something that can be looked at just looking at workload for the the kids um I was recently talking to some high school students and we were talking about what high School looked at like when I went to school and we were talking to them about midterms finals just how our structure was so when the high school uh made a move towards block scheduling uh as part of also the collective bargaining with the Teachers Association a decision was made to just do final exams with the option of a teacher if they wanted to put in a midyear assessment uh
256as to not overburden and over tax kids for having to test on a Year's worth of material so it's been a good practice at the high school and that's where we stand right now okay thank you and the poori 16 St James Street 53 five votes against three votes that's what you have displayed for the last two hours not a single reference to the kids not a single reference to the education it's all about your internal politics and your bickering you could not care less for kids or education I request each and every Board of of Education member to go back and look at and review the tape that you have displayed here today it's a disgrace and you should stop it it's a personal attack to the president of the I don't know whether
257she's right or wrong whether she did whatever she did or not not but it's clearly attacking her and attacking him you guys got to be bigger than that honestly you have to be bigger than that this is all being articulated by one or two people on the board trying to get six people who can clap here and feel good about it because they reviewed on on the television you got to stop this nonsense you got to work for the kids of this this this community if you don't want to do that get out of here somebody who can do this will come up here and and I tell you you are taking no responsibility of what's going on so if I come over and I say I have a 5013c I got a bunch of
258parents behind me you going to approve me another parent Organization for the middle school yeah I did not ask you I did not ask you I'm asking M superintendent Goodall if I come back with a with a 5013c and say that I want to have a parent organization I can have a parent organization what kind of a message are we sending in this community so if you lose an election you I'm going to start another Board of Education if I lose my election on the side is that's how we're going to do business in this Township it is disgusting guys everybody who's watching this tapate see this and realize what you're putting up here is an articulated story of trying to unseed a couple of people please stop that please think about the kids please
259think about the schools here if you can't do that then please resign and get out thank you hello my name is Lucy chafi 6 Annie Lane first I would like to say thank you to the board I know this is a very difficult job to do second of all I'm very happy that you placed in an investigation against that um the PTO and all these members that you received and now that you voted for the PCA my second um my third motion is that I have been in this town about 18 years I moved from New York City to come here because I loved it was a country atmosphere it was a HomeTown where people cared about about our children we're developing way too much now you mentioned about the referendum I've read about other
260uh towns where they uh have the builders um contribute or help in these extensions where our taxes will be kept lower I don't know where to go but I definitely think it's something we need to look at we continue to grow we continue to put for these town houses and the taxpayers continue to pay it's not us it really needs to be addressed it really needs someone to do something about it we have looked at that and building impact fees for schools are illegal in New Jersey we cannot ask a builder to build a school or to help with the school so they want we continue to build if we don't have the room for these kids that is the township that is not the Board of Education the responsibility of the board of education
261is to educate any child coming into this District I mean this is ridiculous all the building is the township not the Board of Education we don't have a say in in in in none of the it's a separate governmental issue and entity really they have to follow their own rules and regulations or whatever they need to do I don't know I'm not part of the township our job here is to educate children exactly that's what we do I thought you kind of had a word and I just wanted to get that out there so can help sorry I'm very nervous that's okay speaking it really is a big concern of everyone I think that we really need to kind of look at all this and see we got to stop somewhere we got to say
262hey we don't have room and we don't have the money in the budget but I am very glad of all you do and I appreciate it and let's look at other means thank you hi um Katherine Crowley 56 Spruce Meadows Drive I would like to ask that you also when you're doing this investigation should it come out that it is somebody who is currently put their name out to run for the board as the person who is causing all of this that they should not be allowed to run that that should be announced so that the public knows what kind of person we're voting for so that's one two in question in answer to what Mr ploro said that meeting that the PTO had was not did not have Quorum so the meeting the the
263people who were voted in were not legally voted in so the fact that there was this whole big discussion about the PTO officers were voted improperly they were not so I don't know if anyone is aware of that but that is an issue so they are not sanctioned they're not board certified they're not anything and I'm tired of people bashing the P the PSA as as if we have done nothing I have spent I don't know since my daughter has been in kindergarten she is now a sophomore in college I have been a PTA mom I have been part of the membership I have put out every single thing that I have for the good of the all the kids in in in the schools I have fed the teachers in high school middle school
264elementary school even when I didn't have children there I was there feeding the kids and Mrs alage can attest to that so to have people say that I as part of the P PSA is not here for the good of the kids you're wrong I have been well that's you pleas excuse me could you pleas address the Board of Education okay so the fact that you have now allowed the PSA into the schools I would like to know whose decision it is to make that which organization goes in I mean there are obviously two two so the building principle should have the right to vote on that or should have the voice I mean you have told us how how you know they have she has she and her Administration has come up with all
265these amazing policies about safety of the kids we've entrusted the safety of the children to her and her kids I think she should have the right to decide which group actually comes into her building to do what needs to be done that decision should never be taken away from her ever again like it just was earlier in the year so the games that you guys play I don't know what that that's all about I'm not usually about a drama person but this is this is [Applause] ridiculous prash 33 Dana drive a big picture I request you all late in the night so please go ahead with referendum middle school middle school plus high school please vote for that so go ahead so that next march we'll have people will vote to choices yes or no
266please do that because I'll not be here till 12:00 tonight and um Dr alich one question uh for you regarding the homework policy uh is special assignments special projects posters you know they have where the students have to prepare is not a homework is a duration defined minimum duration defined in the policy answer yes please do you mean for how long a student would have to do the project or are we talking about the homework breaks how much the teacher gives a time okay if the project no that is not defined in the policy or the regulation that would be up to the teachers that is the one I requested two things I requested when the major assignments are given you cannot tell the student on Friday and next Wednesday present it and at the
267same time biology teacher is G giving assignment La you know English teacher is giving assignment multiple assignments are coming to the students at the same time so that is what I spoke last year and if you have not addressed that please not we're not addressing it in the policy and regulation but now the policy and regulation goes to the buildings and the buildings will work with their staff with their teachers and their Department chairs um the elementaries will work together to make sure that it's consistent across the elementary schools in order to update the student handbooks that would be something that would go in the student handbook not in a policy or regulation okay I would like to see that wherever it is that was my concern last year another one thing is the AP
268teacher in biology gives a assignment the English teacher gives a assignment suddenly students end up with four big assignments and the students are confused so my question is students are here to learn capture the knowledge give them a time let it be one teacher doesn't know who is giving what assignment I told last year there should be transparency across so that all the teachers know what assignments are given that one what I was looking for I even I met you so anyway that is the I want not something that would be in the policy or the regulation that would be something that would work at the school level wherever it is at school level like to see that please it it hasn't been completed because the policy hasn't been approved yet okay like to see
269that when it is done it is already more than a year now the second thing is PTA PTO whatever it is parent teachers I want the parent Teachers Association where the teachers and parents are discussing also about education homework Sports Arts not only just raising money yeah I'm not aware of that but I that's the request the parents teachers organizations means the parents and teachers are talking to each other every day what the children are telling to the parents and parents say is a cooperation between the parents teach teachers and the students makes the school the best in ranking so I want these associations organizations to look into it okay that's my comment thank you very much good evening Chrissy scurby 21 pness Drive um I have a question on the homework policy I'm reading
270it and it a it talks about um the definition of school breaks school breaks are defined as Thanksgiving winter and spring recess why isn't there any um consideration into any holidays um we have a 4-day weekend in I think it's September this year around a Jewish holiday why why isn't that in that policy as well that's a 4-day Thanksgiving is a 4-day weekend we have a large student population that um we give off for these for these 4day weekends around religious holidays why wouldn't the homework policy and be for that for that break as well M armo well I uh and I can be corrected please feel free to um first of all I don't believe we really give off for technically religious holidays for starters um I know that a lot of times the
271days fall fall on every year it coincides with that holiday okay um I think uh any of any of those holidays that are considered religious might be a national lays and I think that there's there's um you know those are the holidays like winter break and all that the other thing is I'm just saying I I know I'm sorry I didn't mean to cut you off I'm just saying I know I know the homework policy came about because a board member was upset that their child had to take a backpack on an airplane over Thanksgiving break what I'm saying is somebody that celebrates this holiday should not be are we saying that it doesn't matter if they have to do homework now o over that break look personally I'm not an educator and so I
272Rely again on the recommendations of the Educators but I and I you know I've gotten both sides I've gotten parents and CH and children believe it or not who believe in in homework I don't I don't think we should be that restrictive I think we're we're going too far I mean I was not I was not pleased by this to begin with but I went along because of of consensus and and recommendations from the the uh professionals that's why I ask that the teachers take a look at this and are and be and are happy with it so to answer your question I I I personally would not want to start taking every single 4-day weekend and making it restrictive I think it's I think we shouldn't be restrictive I should be restrictive at all
273yeah um my other question is on there it it has under Elementary K through 5 summative assessments cannot be given until the third day upon the return from break however in middle school and high school it does not have that as a requirement I'm just I'm just again I will I will have a discussion since again I was not invited or privy to the um formulation of this policy it started out in curriculum uh we were handed the policy and asked to take a look at it so I don't know the iterations that it went through I can't answer the question I would ask Dr alvic to have a meeting with me and go over it before the next meeting if she if we have time and you know but I I don't think it's
274our place to answer those kind of questions I I would like to leave it to the yeah I mean my concern is you I don't think it's a harmful policy but I also think no but if we're saying we're saying that we they can't take a test in elementary school after a break but we can in high school and middle school that doesn't make it doesn't make sense to me it should be across the board then I mean the policy I think isn't it that the older the children get the look we have to we're trying to the older the children get the harder the tests become and if we're if if the policy is to give them a break over break then why would we expect high schoolers and middle schoolers to take a
275summative assessment upon coming back from break that that's my problem it seems like a logical thing but I remember in I remember well not getting away with things in high school either but definitely not in college when you're asked to you know do work even for important things so I'll I'll discuss that and we'll go but I'll take I take your point thank you okay and just one last question that packet that you have is that confidential information did we say that was confidential cuz I'd like to know if I can get a copy of that turns out it's not I I don't Madam in my opinion it is not confidential because it was a letter that was dropped off for distribution to the Board of Education it was not part of the weekly confidential
276okay you have to open it it's it's a it's a public document oh I have to put an oer request that okay hey Lou Masters and I'm Mela Court um about the the uh parent organization originally the discussion started by saying it was going to be a blanket approval for all upcoming organizations but then you specifically worded the motion to include only one additional parent organization so what happens if another parent organization comes along is it a blanket approval or we would have to do the same thing bring it to the board and get the approval and then depending on wording in the policy right now it's it says PT and PTO it does not say PSA so we'd have to change policy we I know Mrs Aro is going to we had we had
277said we would uh re re relook at that policy that that's good I would make it more my suggestion more General because again if somebody comes in and says PTR you'll be changing the policy actually my position was originally that if if a parent organization has the proper documentation I don't I didn't think we need I think it was implied in the policy so I guess we'll clean it up but I I think it was implied in the policy if if the proper documentation exists then we'll go and and move forward Ian I see what you're saying it's a little scary though about the tier one so they would automatic excuse me thank you yeah um I'm getting heckled from behind it's childish but it's hard to concentrate on talking to you when they're talking
278to me um so yeah it's just a slippery slope because you now you're going to have all kinds of again charitable organizations coming in and bumping or actually competing right at that tier one level I mean Mr braan was exactly right we had to go through hell when the township um they wanted to be tier one right they were we bumped them to tier two and it was fights and stuff like that so now you're going to have I think we were we meant a parent organization let him but it could be any parent organization right that's charitable I'm just saying we might want to actually tighten up those bies you got it uh the other thing can I talk about anything on the agenda doesn't have to be up to this point on agenda
279there is a note under professional appointments number four about Edwards engineer group paying them to look at the uh Schoolhouse Road property yes where is that in here the Schoolhouse Road property Madam Mr Gorski um as deliberated previously there is a parcel of land by the firehouse on Schoolhouse and Buckaloo Avenue that's being considered as a donation from the township to the school uh building grounds Transportation unanimously recommended to the board that Edwards engineering engage in a two tiered study for the development of that property into Transportation lots to expand the fleet and bring back more inhouse busing as opposed to contracted busing okay and Edwards is going to do a two-tiered proposal one for a smaller developed lot and one for a larger one we uh and this this authorizes Edwards to do so
280in the 5400 that's for both tiers or just one of the both the whole stud now I know we've considered that that land before isn't that Wetlands or something or swamp the board of education did not accept the parts that were Wetlands all right you all right thank you very much that was it anybody else wants to speak to the board okay then we will close public forum and before we go on to Mr Goodall's report would anybody like to make a motion for a five minute recess I'll make a motion for a five minute recess second all in favor I I raise your hands opposed okay five minutes time the board will go back into public session and we will go to the superintendent Report with Mr Goodall good evening as part of the
281superintendent report just to give you uh an overview of some of the things going on uh within our district uh we are currently running our annual new teacher orientation for our new staff the purpose of that is to accl acclimate them to our district give them strategies for a successful beginning as a staff member here in our district I wanted to thank Dr alic and our professional development staff Mrs fatovic Mrs Goldberg and M Mr tolboom for their Stellar PD program I had an opportunity to say hello uh to the new staff and new teachers got a lot of uh meeting time with them as they came to Cal office of uh through processing through human resources and the feedback always on our new teacher orientation is an incredible support for our teachers and staff
282who are going to work in our district with the goal is to train Monitor and retain the best teachers that we have here so uh thank you again to all of those who participated and continue to participate I believe it ends tomorrow our administrative team participated in our annual summer administrative workshop last Friday last Thursday and Friday uh again thanks to Dr alvic for helping to put that agenda together um we received policy statute regulation updates from Mr David Nash uh an attorney uh who works from legal one and he gave the workshop to the administrative team was very informative uh the team also continued to work within and learn about our whole child committee for this year and we also developed uh amongst the team collaboratively uh District school and individual goals for each
283administrator so the feedback from that Workshop as well was that it was very informative and worthwhile uh to prepare for the school year as uh the board approved me to be the liaison for the district to the Ed Services Commission so I worked with Mr finlin to uh participate in an orientation where I toured some of the facilities on behalf of the district and discussed our relationship with the ESC NJ Human Resources continues to work hard on Staffing Art District for the school opening so we have some agenda items that need to be approved Madam board president members of the Board of Education it is recommended that personel action items a through BC under the superintendent report be appr be approved by consent roll call sove second Mr cherella Miss armenio comments or questions from
284Mr Goodall Mr comment is just so under letter BB the list of hundreds of substitute teachers I just would respectfully like to take my daughter's name off the list um that must have been an oversight that she never took it all she never removed herself from the district she has a full-time job in North brunck she will not be substitute teaching in Monro I don't want anybody to come back to me later because I voted on something with my daughter's name on it so if we could just retract her name I would be great with that would be Jenna Jenna rutsky okay thank you anyone else Miss armino um I just like to ask a question I was reviewing all of uh specifically ah and AJ um there are a lot of the same names
285on after school activities and um and I know that's it's on a rotating basis and two hours here and two hours I'm just wondering isn't that a nightmare to keep together like and and some teachers may be working all week anyway it seems that a lot of the teachers will or the employees I should just say because I think it's it's not just teachers are on all of the the different after school programs or extra programs and I would I I don't how are you keep the it's outside of their contractual time so these positions are posted um and then they're recommended to the board for approval and and uh the teachers choose to apply for these positions it is a bit of a balancing act for some of them because they uh offer their
286services to a number of different programs uh there are times when some teachers will come to us and say it's a little too much please remove me from the schedule and uh it is a little bit of a balancing act but with um Mr Kella the other administrators and the teachers themselves sometimes they make up the schedule uh to cover classes based on subject uh expertise for example like in CMAC we're going to have an algebra day we we'll have a geometry day well my concern is how do you keep it um like for for um pay salary purposes or or I know it's not their salary but it's extra it's extra and what happens if there's overlap if a teacher is scheduled well they can what we would call double dip so each teacher
287would be assigned to an assigned time per day and if there wasn't overlap um we would find a replacement from the list for that teacher for that particular I but my concern again is for the student that you don't want to do that five minutes before a a teacher is supposed to be uh attending something right so a lot of planning goes into organizing teachers and sometimes we have a misstep and then we fix it so okay so you're saying that works you've got it under Som although it looks overwhelming it works and it's a credit to the teachers organize that I mean I'm happy if if they can do the fill in and all that stuff but I take Mr Po also I take Mr Po's concern that you know teachers unfortunately have to
288take a lot of these extra things and do they have time to do their actual da you're talking about the the 117 percenters yeah Mr was talking so we budget and I appreciate Mr Po's comments a lot they're a lot of validity to them um but each year as we prepare our budget especially at the high school um we try to budget to complete student schedules as best we can at times to complete those schedules we do have to offer additional sections however it doesn't equal the amount of hiring a full-time teacher in this case this year just glancing at this there's a business teacher there's a mathematics teacher uh but I should say is a number of sections that would really you should hire a full-time teacher that I'm sure will be in the
289high school budget for next year okay uh the physics uh uh additional 177% had to do we couldn't find a certificated uh teacher for that area which is very difficult for some of the science and math uh okay certifications to find so we covered that in-house but in the spring we will look for a physics teacher again I'm satisfied with that uh AZ uh there's a lot of pending um pending satisfactory completions of pre-employment we we have quite a few people on that again nothing specific about uh any individual person but are we clear that before they get in front of students they will all be completely satisfactory yes okay all right and all right Mr on uh the uh substitute teachers that is there a reason why some of them are in uh capital
290letters I I I don't think there's any um I think it's just the data entry issue I don't think there's anything significant about that Mr Russo yeah um I had sent Mr Good Old an email he was supposed to get back to me about there was one staff member that was this goes back to uh may I think board meeting that was was a part-time staff member with relatively was relatively new 6 months maybe experience in the school district and was listed on this document the agenda as a transfer into a full-time job and we know that that's not possible we can't transfer staff members from parttime to full-time so I had brought it up at that meeting and it was going to be looked into and I haven't gotten this respon um well In
291fairness I did look into it and I sent out a report to the board of ed Pro obviously not to your satisfaction um my research into the issues that you brought to me and in speaking with the administrators and Personnel who would bring something to an agenda who would do the hiring from my viewpoint and vantage point it was uh done in proper fashion and I know I've asked you to come and speak to me if you know anything else that maybe I don't see new to the role is it is that is that a new procedure that you can take somebody who's part-time and just make them full-time because we should be told that it shouldn't just be a transfer you know I hate to criticize my predecessor's decision to recommend something to an
292agenda and I know you spoke to him and he gave you an answer um but at this point I would hate to and and could not undo the decision that he made I think we would expose the board to at a minimum griev grievance or litigation okay but let's let's let's so I can only look forward in our hiring practices to make sure that there's fairness and Equity to all of our positions well obviously you don't know the status of everybody here right you couldn't know it you couldn't know it there could be mistakes here M the vast majority of these appointments uh come through the superintendent's office and I go through a checklist based on the feedback additional checklist that I got about um some of the concerns that maybe in our hiring practices
293so I feel very confident in the agenda tonight that you're feeling confident and and knowing for certainty is are two different things right so I look at it a different way we can we can look at Mr kak and say you know well he made a mistake or we could say you know what if you look at the situation he was in where he was under pressure and he was going to be leaving the school district maybe the people who work below him those uh staff members that now we have this thank you thank you for putting that on the agenda the list list of all the Departments because to hire somebody from uh to give them a full-time job the job has to be posted it has to be a vacancy and people have
294to apply for it none of that happened here and I see it was is a power professional job you have 53 power professionals here you must have had around the same amount at that time so let's say five or 10 might have been qualified probably more qualified to apply for that job if it was posted and it wasn't going back to the issue in going back in yeah so so the question is maybe um Mr kak didn't make a mistake maybe those people who are involved in for example somebody puts his name creates this list somebody says it was a transfer right somebody decides it's a transfer you don't decide that well as superintendent I make ultimately the recommendation to the board that's right and it was the wrong one it was the wrong one
295because it was not having been in the room when the discussion took place I'm sure there was uh a search out for Council on this and it seemed that it it seemed that um well an article within the collective bargaining agreement uh made that uh I don't see I don't see satisfactory I copied that that article back to you and I don't see how it applies but let's look at some of the other factors that are involved you mentioned that that person has a relative in the school they have a family member in the school you mentioned it to me in the email well I I gave the board my report right yeah uh that person also works for a company outside and that company has um three people who work in the school who
296own the company so you have in special ed you have a speech therapist a physical therapist and a behavioral therapist that own a company outside okay do you know how many people in the school district work for that company I do not okay this is a question I brought to Mary and she didn't know either and I thought that would be a big concern of us because that type of thing is ripe for conflict of interest wouldn't you think so there's there there anytime um that employees work together you know essentially during the day and if that they have a company that has some association with the line of work that they do there potentially could be but potentially and we don't know how many right we don't know how many but do know that
297this woman this part-time staff member that was pulled into a full-time job works for that company is see where I'm going right but um the principal or director of pupil Personnel Services makes uh interviews there's a and makes a recommendation to the superintendent than the superintendent the people who determine who gets hired are the people who own that company I'm not aware of uh any of the administrative team that owns a outside consulting company if that's what we're talking about they own a a company outside that provides um similar Services same Services the members of the current administrative team yes you have a speech therapist physical therapist Behavior Mr Russo they're not administr trors well I'm just saying they fall under MTA EA's umbrella okay but they have influence as a matter of fact the
298you have a test that's required that crisis training or restraint training test that's um created administered and scored by those people so basically they're the ones who administer the test they're the ones that create the test admin administer the test and score the test so they have great amount of influence on who gets hired they also determine who gets trained and now you have training is a requirement the training is put out to my understanding the training is put out to um anyone who would be in contact with any student who has the need they decide who gets trained they have that ability to decide who gets trained and who doesn't they do I yeah that that would be an administrative decision well they because that then that is approved through Frontline and they put
299in for the workshop so the administrators decide that they have well they can influence the administrators then because they they are the ones that decide so you have you don't find it troubling that somebody that three people in one area special ed own a company outside and you have no idea how many people in the school work for that company Mr Russo what would you like to happen here okay so I would like to make a motion and now I will ask for the outside investigator that we have an independent outside investigator investigate this school this um this office these people in that company and the and the relationship and I'll tell you why I did speak with Mary and so I figured okay let me call up school boards and I spoke with the
300attorney there and I mentioned to them that just and I didn't even go into the detail that I that I mentioned to you and what he said to me was is you have a big problem in the school this is what he said so everybody should listen to this you have a big problem in the school because those three people in those positions can manipulate IEPs now this is his words to enrich their company okay so I asked him what should I do he said well try to develop a policy so you at least you can find out first how many people work in that company and then discuss it with the administration to see how we can um fix this problem now probably nothing would have happened we were working on the policy but
301then this one person I see get sneak you know sneaks through the um the hiring and gets a full-time job which I think is in violation of the procedures so I uh draft up a policy and I reached out to uh Mr kak Dr kak and uh he decided that we should call up Phil necastro from uh Strauss Esme and we did we had a couple of calls with him so the idea was that we wanted to have a a document which would be required for staff members to disclose if they own a company outside and they hire Board of Ed uh District staff or if they District staff and they work for that company or a company that that provides similar services and stuff I have a Disclosure document here a Disclosure document so
302he was worried that um the the document I created was a little too strict I said well we can water it now I want that to fit it into his conflict of interest policy to have as part of the conflict of interest policy this Disclosure document which had to be filled out so in the phone conversation I think Phil said um he asked so do you have a problem in the school and Dr kak said well I have somebody who owns an income tax company who solicits um his business in the school and I really wish I had this policy in place so I could have done something about that I briefly mentioned the issue with with the three people who work in special ed so he continued to work on the policy then he
303wanted to align it with that online ethics thing that we have to fill out that's the administrative team does and then so and and I still had my documents so the LA last thing we did was we took it to policy and I don't know where where Mary stood with it she she's trying she's trying to block it well she's giving uh legal advice to the board that it could potentially open up the board for litigation that it's not something that was collectively bargained with mtea and that there were perk laws involved and again I'm not an attorney so I prefer for her to report out um specifically what she's but uh during the meeting she kind of laid it out why she would be against something like that so you spoke to her about
304it no I was there and you weren't there with me no not after the the second meeting has a policy and I I believe um members of the policy committee were there okay yeah right okay all right and and my she also reported out that Mr necastro yeah um said that it was not a good idea we would be again a standalone okay so that being said and I KN Mary was resisting from the beginning and she didn't even more discussion she was question me questioning me as to where I'm getting my information from and I can give the same kind of answer you gave to me about the person who has a relative in the school that I've been here a long time as well so I know uh these things that are going
305on I find this to be very troubling I think that that person that got the job that needs to be investigated and I think we need to investigate this company and what's going on in this school and I think Kathy you're the board president this is what should we should be looking at this is what we really should be focusing on because this is going to give us a big problem so are you making a motion did you make a motion what would would you like Mr Goodall to look at it no I think this we I think we've gone too far with this uh the the the um I think and I I warned um Mr Co Dr kak of the same same thing that if you let thing continue it's going to get
306too big nobody knows how many people work for this company and there's there are quite a few they're using a lot of resources in the school they're using up photoc copies to create insurance forms um you know the deal with the IP and how the whole process works and how you can benefit outside and that's from That's from the school board attorney well this is what school boards told me that's what they said you have a big problem so it needs to be corrected but I think it grown to such a point where uh I think it's if we can't get that Disclosure document and we can't get them to to um if we if we can't Implement that then I think we need to investigate so I would like to make a motion that
307we that we look to hire an external investigator someone out outside the school system independent to um look at this special ed this area and that and the linkage between that company and the school it's a problem and we're going to have to deal with it and I would think that every board member here should be concerned it creates tremendous morale problem in the school and everyone knows it don't be fooled by it everyone knows it a lot of people are afraid to talk about it everybody knows it so it's going to come out please don't you find that funny Mr gy sounds like it is out I sorry but you know we we I just said to the board president as chair of the meeting we have a very lengthy agenda with some very
308material items that are this is very material it's a business meeting I'm afraid that the public is is waiting for the the referendum decision and stuff I why can't you just let Mr Goodall look at it I just gave you my motion what was the motion is there a second to that if I if I could just respond that since I took over the role I think I've been responsive to try to seek out more transparency and recommend for more transparency and I gave my report on the information that I had at hand and tonight I'm getting information that I would have liked to have heard when I asked for it um going back a few weeks well between exchange between you and I because perhaps I could have reported out on something different okay
309but Mary knows about this why didn't she say something why isn't she trying to correct this problem why do I have to do this see it's certainly something that the hiring practices here I certainly could be a part of and made corrections I recently workshopped the administrative team on how we are to hire to its completion post interview and hire to its completion and then I will make the recommendation yeah but this information that you're giving me about a conflict of interest I I did not know about till this moment well that's why I brought up this this case about this one staff member right so and this seems to get you know just tossed aside and I spoke to Mary about it too and I don't know I I didn't get a good response
310from her I don't want to go into all the details but I I get a I get from the information that I got and I investigated I thought thoroughly there was no impropriety that I saw as part of our hiring process the concern about what you brought to light tonight was not information provided to me so when Mary knew speak Mary because Mary is not here right now and I you and in doing that I did not and in doing that I did not want to revisit a decision from my predecessor I thought that was unfair and also on advice of council that it may um trigger either grievance or litigation against the board by doing that well I and all I can do moving forward yeah is to ensure that uh anyone who applies
311for a job in Monroe whether inhouse or outside has fair and equal access and opportunity and then we hire the best person well that person I'll make that that person that got that job didn't apply didn't have to apply work that particular case has explained to me was an emergent situation it's not true it's not true that's what I'm saying from the people involved that's what has been explained to me yeah retroactively so I I I would like to keep that motion I would like to I I think we could do an internal well I would I I think this needs an external thing this this is this is probably the most important thing that's happening in this school it I just would may I sure uh if there is I mean one of the
312problems we have that no one really likes to talk about if perceptions of impropriety or or perceptions of conflict of interest I mean we are in a social and cultural situation now where people are coming forward and I'm talking about in generalities people are coming forward finally to say some things are going on that are not appropriate um um just in general so I think that perceptions of impropriety or conflict should be investigated I don't know if we should go into detail about specific things but I understood uh Mr Russo's concern and I think there are a lot of things that that may go on again speculative and that some people know go on that we don't have full knowledge of that um we need to be concerned about conflicts of interest are are serious
313in the culture of any organization and um I I don't disagree that some things should be researched and I do uh and these things you know this a lot of things have been talked about for a long period of time and we don't want to bring this up we don't want to talk about it we don't want to address it and then things can can just become a culture that is is not healthy so any of the the in additional information that was discussed tonight I have no way of validating that right now I would have liked to have known that before as I wrote a report to the board of ed when we others know information that could have been vital to my investigation I think on I think our Council knew that well
314should have counseled you on that I I can't validate I can't validate any of it but as I tried to do a and fair investigation and there was information there that could have been shared with me and it wasn't so here I am sitting here in public and I feel like I have a little leg on my face Mr Ryback has a comment because you you we keep hearing this you know we've been hear well I want to make my motion you a motion mrback thank you um I understand the points being brought up I think the superintendent is perfectly capable of looking into things like this without all kinds of things going on but but I have to say what I'm concerned about down the road I could see this interfering with people's lives
315and abilities to earn extra money as a former teacher I know how important it was for me to have extra jobs uh some people are able to um run camps uh and and maybe they hire teachers they have a right to do what they want after school it's not infringing on on their job uh job performance or their jobs I think that they have to have that right without us looking over their shoulders to to see every little thing they're doing uh if there's an impropriety I think that the superintendent uh uh it could be brought to the superintendent and he could take that up appropriately but I certainly wouldn't want to interfere with people's lives to to earn extra jobs or to uh go into um private businesses I I I agree with you
316Steve and I Mr Russo Mr Russo Jill did you have your hand up yeah I mean it's very hard to vote on a motion when you bring something to us that's vague that we don't have any of the details other than people have a company and they're using stuff in the school system and I am very uncomfortable with the thought of hiring an outside company to investigate these people with that they may or may not be doing this I mean I it's just your word the investigation how you find out I know but I don't I will not agree to hire an outside company that that is then vote no I think the job of the principal is to do the initial investigation superintendent the superintendent sorry to do it I mean yeah we've been
317down that road actually I I think in this case it might be better you're not involved because if it's as serious as a school board's attorne state it could be it could involve insurance fraud and other things and it's it I think I think it's it's better to let someone externally do it and provide the report Mr cherella did you have your hand up yes no I I I uh agree with Steve that I think uh I I don't think we should impinge upon people's rights to do have businesses after hours or on weekends and things like that what I'd be concerned with is if those businesses are operating during our school hours when they should be working so we hire employees to do work here at at the school not to run businesses not
318to use our equipment not to use our email system and our phones and our copers um and that I think needs to be investigated right yeah can I throw my hand up just just a quick I keep hearing this word investigator and I and I hear about going outside and and obviously that costs money not to throw responsibility at our director of security but I'm pretty sure we have people that are retired detectives that if we need something investigated can't we keep that inhouse somehow I'm just curious like that's what they did for a living they were detectives inv the purview of our current Security Department well I mean we're going outside the purview of a lot of things tonight I'm just saying that sort of yeah but I don't think that's their their position
319okay I got you I I know it R it's security but I'm just saying okay so would we rather someone go to the prosecutor and then we end up all over the front of the newspapers is that what we would rather if if it's uh the board's wish that I investigate matters within the district I'm very comfortable doing that uh on to on top of that though I would just ask board members in in the future if you have information that can contribute um to my investigation that you give it to me prior to I start in the investigation and that's all I'm asking that In fairness to me I rep I when I report out I would like to have all of the information so I could be confident in what I'm reporting out
320to the board and I I can't after the fact be given information that makes it look like um you know I was negligible or didn't do my job so I'm just asking if you whatever in the year that I'm here that if I'm given a task to look into something thing I just get all the information up front okay there's a motion on this on the floor in a second so we'll have a roll call Madam may ask that Mr Russo repeat the motion I I didn't get a clear motion that the board look to hire an investigator from outside external to investigate the relationship between careful that the company I I don't I don't need to mention it in public but there's a company that these three staff members work for and the relationship
321with the school the of look to hire an investigator to investigate the relationship between I lost you when you went off I didn't want to give you the name of the company and the employees the company and the employees who own it and the employees who work for it who also work in the district can you specify to company no uh I I can I can send it to you give it to you later because you know it should be incorporated in the resolution that this is so vague I don't know how we can act upon that investigate who what the a company a company this well I'll send it to you do we need do we need are we violating any it has to if we're voting on that resolution it has to be
322here conflict of interest in the school what how much just conflict of interest in the school I don't know no if you want us to investigate a company and employees we need to know who they are the comp we can mention employees now no there's a confidential no the the company that has employees I just want to make sure what when there motion is there any restriction to say the to give you the company's name emplo yeah but we don't know any restri to providing that why can't we just have Mr Goodall look at this he will know the company he will know the employees he could be that Kathy because for more than almost a year actually it's been almost two and a half years that have not gotten a good response and it's
323been going on and growing and I wanted to stop good response to this listen this issue even this last person that got this position I thought I would get a good response from Mr Goodall to be honest with you that I was say okay that that position is going to be advertised we're going to do it the right way but I didn't I got the same story I got from Mary it was a it was a rush it was urgent and all this other stuff and that's none of that is true so I'm tired of it you take they took a person gave them a full-time job spending taxpayer money don't you think the mtea would have filed agreements if that was something done wrong and it had an effect on the rest of their
324employees sometimes people are afraid to say things okay they're afraid to say it you can't you can't you can't expect the victims of these things to come forward you can't people are afraid they're going to lose their jobs and it's been going on for a long time and I'm telling you everybody in the school knows it it's not a secret what they living we need to have thean Mr In fairness um you brought up that for the past year or so you've been asking for a response to this I've been asking and I was asked as I transitioned into the position yet I didn't have all of the information I had been providing some information and the the it's absent of what you brought up tonight about a conflict of interest and it was more
325of a related to the transferring and the posting issue and so well connected dots this person works for that company and and suddenly gets a full-time job without going through going back and forth that it's it's not productive I needed that information and I didn't have it in fairness so I don't mind if it's the board's wish to relook at it you know why you don't have the information because these people aligned you the ones who you're asking because Dr kak did the same thing he went to certain people and asked him information he got the same answer I can't speak for I can always speak got the same answer you got and they gave him the same answer they gave to you okay I I again I would have preferred to have this information
326before if the bo president point of order is there a motion on the floor there is a motion on the Flor well then let's go Madam there's not a motion that could be acted upon because there's a compan are we inves can I write it down the name of a company no because he has to read the motion everybody needs to know that in order to vote so we either do it or we don't do what do you need in terms of the company what do you need the exact name what What entity should I tell the investigator to investigate I don't have a name will I be subjected to any penalties if I give you the name I can't offer you legal advice oh you can't offer me legal advice okay I'm not the
327board attorney and it's 11:30 and we have if we're not going to investigate it then it will be investigated other in other ways with the motion if if the board wants me to if this is the kind of see we're not working together he if he's playing these kind of games we're not working together so I withdraw the motion Mr Russo if the board if the board would like me to relook into this I will do so I have some additional information I'm sure uh it will take a few extra steps to find out some of the uh information that regards to the name of the company things like that but I'm more than willing to do that if the board wishes me to do that I know I know the board members are Kath
328I know the bo members are tired of hearing it but how can they honestly sit there and vote for things that they don't even know there's on the on this document whether it's true or not and they're voting and they don't care you don't care don't tell me what I care about what I don't care about you wor more about send doc out than you a very vague information we don't have the same I have no information on what you're talking about none I don't have a an employee I don't have a history I don't have um the name of a company I have nothing how how can I talk about that so we either give the name of a company or we move ask Mary she knows the name of the well Mary's not
329here I can't ask her I'm sure that the first thing Mr GLE will do in Monday we mtion has been withdrawn Point okay can we move on with the agenda Mr Russo has the motion been withdrawn it's withdrawn thank you so we have a motion to accept the board president uh the uh Mr goodles personel action it a through b did we have a I believe there was a second yes all right we'll have a roll call you want to introduce I do okay this is Personnel items a through BC under superintendent report motion moved by Kent Jella seconded by Mrs armeno would you like me to take a roll call yes please Mr Chella yes Mr rutsky yes Mrs Co Pano yes Mrs armeno uh yes excuse yes on everything except on BB starting
330with page 17 30 of to um so so no on that except for the volunteer coaches starting on 25 of 34 to 26 of 34 yes on that so I'm voting BB no B boy Victor boy boy boy boy s uh page 17 of 3 of 34 is no until um page 25 of 34 to 26 is yes for the uh volunteer coaches which by way so you're just voting yes on the volunteer coaches correct okay she's just voting yes on volunteer coaches no on everything else thank youo anything else in DD uh yes on all except a d Unis fansa ARB and ax Nancy Dempsey are reuse thank you Mr Rybeck yes Mrs Deo yes Mr Russo suain the W so noted Mr Braverman Mr Braverman left said good night I didn't see that
331Madam board president motion pass okay thank you action item Madam board president and members of the oh I'm sorry um just out to the school community members of the Board of Education I want to congratulate Michael Collins who's been a longtime teacher in the district he will be serving as the acting vice principal at the high school so now the high school administrative team is fully St Mr Collins good luck thank you and congratulations on your position good luck it it is a lot quieter down there Mr C I can assure you okay okay uh Madame board president and members of the Board of Ed it is recommended that the board action items a through L be approved by consent roll call second who who was the first Mr Mr Chella Mr I have I
332have a through was there I think there was an addition I have a through I don't know a l you have a through l i they have L there confir L okay yeah I think we got an updated one late this afternoon I'm sorry about that was that's okay yeah um Mr Chella Mr Ryback I believe yes comments or questions uh just one on G um that the uh instruct G or J the science club no so recommend the board approve the agreement between professional crisis management association it's G it's g g it's G it's G on the new one right 27 okay um is that the one that Mr rutsky was talking about in no it runs along with the restraint training policy okay never mind and that's the fee for the training and
333then we turn K thank you anyone else else then we'll have a roll call Mr Russo recuse or abstain was that a recuse or an obain so noted as an exstension MR Rybeck yes Mrs uh Mrs Deo yes Mrs Kino yes Mrs armeno yes Mr rutsky yes Mr cherella yes Mrs K yes word action items a through L has passed okay we will go to the business administrator report Mr bki oh your I am assuming your report is concluded that is my my report is concluded okay Mr Gorski uh Madame board president members of the Board of Education members of the public I would like to point out that within my report we have some very material items that are being voted on um professional appointment number four under the business administrator's report is again
334Edwards engineering and that's to develop the lot on Schoolhouse in Buckaloo Jason to the Firehouse for future development of a bus depot the the study was approved unanimously by building grounds transportation and we'll provide the Board of Education information on on how to proceed with that project also under my report item L is a very material resolution for a special election and there was some commentary on this before but this question for the referendum will have two parts first will be vote for a middle school referendum the construction of a middle school on land to be donated by the township you could vote yes or no on that the second question will be the middle school with a high school addition component the cost for those projects are if the referendum is held March of
3352019 the Middle School option is 75 million 687 th000 the middle school and high school addition is 146 m17 th000 these figures are subject to change once we get the bond referendum question established but that gives you a good understanding of of what it is for and item M authorizes the the utilization of professionals most importantly for the development of educational specifications which design the school facility for the purpose that it's being intended for um I would like to also report that the board directed me individually to come up with a business plan for Falcon CARE program and before and after school care program which I did so and I took to the finance committee and I'm very proud to report as Mr rutsky indicated in the finance uh agenda that in the first three
336years of operations Falcon care and ECE combined have earned over $1.6 million of profit which is the board's discretion on on what to do with and it's unlimited so I would like to give kudos to Sharon Jensen the program director H Dr alvic Who worked extensively with Miss Jensen in the development of the curriculum uh um for a program that has been extremely successful in its first three years Madame board president and members of the mon Township Board of Education it is recommended that board action items a through o be approved by consent roll call Ry Mr ryack Mr Mr Mayo comments or questions can I say something yes Mr Mayo um I just thought it was very nice of Mr John Brown to make a donation to the school district of an alpha mapboard
337and storage shelf valued at ,750 that was very generous and the donation of the mil Lake school PTO who donated $10,000 to uh mil Lake Woodland wait who donated $110,000 by mil L by the mil Lake Woodland PTO for the purpose of advancing stem activities at mil Lake School it's very generous too so I'd like to thank the individual Mr Brown and the mil Lake school PTO for their generous donations anyone else comment question um Mr Gori could I'm sorry could you point out to me where the SRE trade what n what at number or is that on Miss indeed k letter K looking for K top of page okay all right my only question on that was um there seem to be first of all I didn't see this as a contract I know
338you said after this is after this is approved there is a contract but the cont contract isn't isn't attached is it in the board docs sir there actual cont there's not a contract in the board docs there's a proposal uh We've we've engaged in this same entity now year after year after year since oak tree school started right got it and this is a brokerage service that allows the district to sell energy credits on an exchange yeah no I read the whole 28 Pages believe it or not my only thought was there there's three charges uh to us we get um a I wrote it down may I make it easy one second I have it we have uh the charges to um we get a fee for easy re fees easy wck fees that's
339a percentage based management fee and then plus the percentage based transfer fee and then there's an SRE trade res uh they said trade reserves the right to change to charge separate per wreck a minimum service fee of up to $250 $2.50 so just can you just explain the last one that's the one I didn't understand so much yes uh the the substance of this is that as a brokerage commission for selling our energy credits uh the company gets about 5% of the sale even after the other fees that they charge the about it's about 5% of the sale and um they they um they maximize our Revenue in a competitive environment with the the bidding process for the Shreks there was a lot more money in the past when there's Federal subsidies involved now it's
340dwindled down to where the district receives about $25,000 a year from the sale of these solar renewable energy credits because I know that well there's different ways to do it so I guess I'll talk to you afterwards but I just thought that they're they're probably I'd like to see how much they actually make from the even though we make 25,000 I maybe I can ask to come in and talk to you and see how much sure they get about 5% of the sale so total including all those things yeah so 25 25 so 5% of 25,000 you're saying approximately 5% yep that's correct thank you anybody else okay roll call have tostain school high school you're okay to go yeah yeah okay Mr rutsky oh I go first so I'm yes to everything but I
341abstain from letter O where I yeah so noted Mrs Kino yes Mrs Deo yes Mr Chella yes Mr Ryback yes Mr Russo sayain Mrs armeno yes and Mrs K pan yes madame board president very material motions in my report have passed along with the consent report that's great that concludes Business ministat Report okay is there any other business from any member of the board Board of Education what you I'm sorry any other business from any member of the Board of Education um I I just have a question I believe Mr um Gorski answered it already so we're in the process of the request for proposal for the auditor that's in the process he he yeah he said we're in the process of doing that of I think doing specs or is it um as I
342stated earlier the request for propos osal document um one which I Illustrated very recently with the food service management company is a very lengthy document it's designed to comply with procurement laws and also to um encourage a fair and open competitive market for um services in this case and an RFP unlike a bid allows the Board of Education discretion of considering not only quantitative uh considerations but also qualitative when it comes to accounting services and legal services and architectural services uh there there is an interest of the board and the taxpayer to get a quality service in the performance of such you don't just have to go with the lowest bidder because it's not a commodity uh it is a very voluminous document it's being put together it involves legal as well and it will
343be presented uh at the next finance committee meeting okay that's my goal and I have one more question when are we going to have um an advertisement for a superintendent do you do you have plans to or do we have to keep putting a resolution forward to advertise for superintendent of schools because I think that uh we need uh you know not nothing to do with Mr Goodall um but as he as he says he's you know he's in the process of of learning this stuff um and he you know I'm not going to comment otherwise but um if we need we should we're going to have a resolution for the referendum I think we should also be concerned about getting a superintendent in the school district so are we waiting for you Madame President
344to put that forward or should we be coming to the board every month asking for a resolution well I think what I had said at the last board meeting that it was a good idea to take a little break and have Mr Goodall do what he needed to do um get involved in in the dealings of the um the district I don't want to start a search and have to start it again with a new board in January so I was looking to to just work on the on the stuff that we're doing right now and doing search starting in the spring one of them not in the spring but in January February one of the biggest considerations was that at this time of year superintendents are are already in place for September and you're
345getting like the leftover superintendent and the best time of year to do a a um according to school boards and others is in the spring when superintendents are looking for a position it it's you seem to have suggested though that you're waiting and hopeful for a turnover on the board could be a turnover either way it could be no turnover so it doesn't I I I would think that it's a it's an important issue that we may be able to find somebody um you know there are a lot of people who we we may not we have Mr Goodall for a year and he also may be a candidate but if we we can have a superintendent to your point we could look for a superintendent that doesn't have to give notice until June 30th
346of 2019 uh 2019 based on uh Mr Goodall's contract so I so your point or your argument about not going out now I mean if there's a superintendent who is active a school system they still may be interested in coming to Monroe and they wouldn't have to give notice until June or or if they have to give notice in January of 2019 so I think because uh we have a lot of upheaval and we have a lot of things going on I think it would be prudent of us to uh start on that process right away so um maybe I'll and I wasn't prepared to but because I I'm not sure I think we have even enough time for Jan for June 30th um I'll make a resolution to advertise for superintendent make a motion
347make a I'm sorry make a motion to advertise for superintendent or to start the superintendent process because there's a lot that you would do before you would advertise well let's start it yep second oh I can't can I no I start superintendent process correct nobody second it was there second second Mr Russo comments or questions my only concern there certainly I realize we have to do a search for a new superintendent my concern is along the lines what you were saying is who's out there now you said that they might be willing to uh apply and then come in next year I don't think anybody would app you know what the word gets out if somebody comes in here and does an interview their District's going to find out about it and I I think
348in in reality mean that's what happens and real I mean if if Mr good all would be uh applying for superintendant in another District boy we'd find out about it and other District that's just the way it is and I think that that would that alone would prevent people from uh applying and I think we will take the short end of the stick if we did this now I think we're better wor waiting for January a few months I understand look the board can go either way that's not my concern my concern is you know who we going to get what kind of lead are we going to get and and we're better off smarter I think to wait for January or so then do it now and let the cat out of the big
349well also School boards in their workshop has a a lot of superintendent um connections for those who are looking for superintendent um and they do a a workshop to how to how to do a superintendent search well we've all been there so well there's a motion on not all of us have been there I don't think so all right we we'll take a roll call Mr Rybeck no Mrs Deo no Mr Chella yes Mrs Corino ruse Mr rutzky I prefer to wait no Mr Russo yes Mrs AR yes and Mrs colano no motion fails okay thank you I'm done any other board business then we'll go to public forum anyone wishing to come to the microphone please state your name and address to the [Applause] record and we will adhere to our 4minute time limit
350Doug PO for tamarak Road uh I know that uh you have settled the contract with the uh Teachers Association and since it is the taxpayers of Monroe who provide the bulk of the uh taxes that support the school system uh I would request that uh at our next board meeting you share with the public uh the results of that contract in terms of uh things such as salary uh such as any major benefits uh that were changes in uh in that uh I simply think that the public has a right to know since since we are essentially paying the bill so please give that some consideration uh actually Mr Po I carried that information around with me for a while nobody ever asked and we got involved in other things I don't have it tonight
351that's that's okay I didn't I you know like that's the reason I'm asking for next month okay um also I I've reviewed uh all the various minutes and videos of the uh board meetings uh over the SE last several months and there was a meeting uh in which the contracts for the assistant superintendent as well as the business administrator uh were not approved and uh I was just wondering what is the status of that and good and before you answer that question let let me say the following that uh I I think when you don't approve a contract for uh people that are in those significant positions it has an effect on their morale as well as the morale of the people who work in their uh their offices or their departments so uh I
352would encourage the board to give some thought to bringing that to a a a quick conclusion it's been several months now and uh it's just something that I I think uh it's time to to act on it uh you shouldn't be dragging that out um one last thing uh it's it's been very disappointing to be at this meeting tonight uh I I think in some cases there have been personal attacks that do not belong at a public board meeting uh I think it's a shame that you cannot as a board sit down behind closed doors and Air your thoughts with one another but I understand that legally you cannot do that that if you're all sitting there together then it has to be open to the public uh it would be nice if the public
353would consent to allow you to do that because you have some issues that need to be worked out uh Mr Chella says that it doesn't help to uh bring in the school boards and run us through a workshop but I don't know what I don't know what else you have at your disposal but personal attacks on each other personal attacks on our Administration are not in the best interest of this district and they are not in the best interest of educating our children uh I think you are spending far too much time on your own personal agendas and politics as opposed to focusing upon improving the educational system within our district thank you anyone else was first of all Falcon care again I've never heard a bad thing about oh who Masters I'm Mel never
354heard a bad thing about it um great job on that I was going to talk about HR 610 um that is the um uh repealing of the elementary SEC secondary Education Act uh if you remember that ties vouchers into block grants uh it's stuck in I think the House Representatives now but they're trying to reface it uh I wanted to call everybody to organize against it um also tucked in in that if they uh push that along is the repeal of the no hungry kids act which is all that healthy food repeal that'll be gone um you'll be able to do whatever you want in schools again so again whether you like vouchers or not which I'm kind of against or whether you like healthy kids or not which I I'm guessing everybody's against uh
355we really should start organizing for that now to something else that just came up so there the discussion Mr Russo the discussion what I heard and correct me if I'm wrong um you characterize it as a big problem and I'm agreeing with you um can you address the president please he is he is just Mr can you just talk to Mr well I want him to correct me if he if it's wrong so he said that we have evidence that people are manipulating IEPs in the school for monetary gain and that we should create a policy and that I know if you use the word illegal or illicit hiring practices you've you've seen uh and then we talked a little bit and then you decided not to follow up so I heard manipulating special ed
356kids for money and possibly illegal hiring practices and the board's going to do nothing so what I would recommend like you were saying is you should go to the mid County prosecutor's office and file a complaint with the office of Professional Standards that way they'll come in and they'll tell you if there's a problem here or not we don't have the board involved we don't have to hire any special people they will come in yes or no there's an issue if there's an issue then they will take it up and then it's out of everybody's hands so I just wanted to make sure we said a lot of things and then we said H all right maybe we'll look into it no I believe we let Mr Goodall look into it but I know there
357was a a push to maybe do it externally and there was did I would recommend you go to the middle sex County prosecutor's office with this again my son is an IEP if my son's being used for monetary gain by the school district I think the police should know that's all I have to say thank you anyone else from the public okay seeing none we'll go to close session resolution be resolve that the Board of Education of the township of hro hear my moves to go into Clos session in accordance with the Sunshine Law chapter 231 of the public laws of 1975 njsa 10 col 46 through can 10 Callum for 21 to discuss the following subject mtbo Essa negotiations propos MBO Monro Board of Education Monro mtea sidebar agreement following Clos session action may
358be taken the discussion conducted in closed session can be disclosed to the public at such time as the need for confidentiality no longer exists so second all in favor I opposed we'll move in close session it should take 15 minutes but it's going to give us a half an hour hey we are moving back into public session and I have a resolution it is recommended that the Board of Education approved the previously submitted sidebar agreement between the board and the Monroe Township Education Association regarding clubs and athletic trainer the board president and the business administrator board secretary are hereby authorized and directed to take all necessary steps to implement the afores said sidebo agreement so M move second Mr Ryback Miss armino comments or questions then we'll have a roll call Mrs armenio yes Mr
359cherella yes Mrs Deo yes Mr Russo yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr rutsky yes yes and Mrs colano Madam Bo president a motion passes unanimously okay is there anybody from the public who wishes to speak to the Clos session items okay seeing none our next schedule Board of Education meeting is scheduled for September 12th 2018 7:00 p.m. at the Monroe Township High School motion to adjourn so moveed second Mr Mayo Mr Ryback all in favor I opposed then the meeting is adjurned