CorpusRecord 132992

Monroe Township Board of Education 10.18.17 Regular Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Monroe Township School District
Date
2025-02-12
Location
Middlesex County, NJ
Material
Transcript
Extent
14,787 words · about 83 min
Collected
2026-06-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001you can get on okay good evening the meeting of the Monroe Township Board of Education will come to order please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance I pledge Alle Al to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for stand one nation under God indivisible with libery and justice for all may we have a roll call Mr Gorski certainly Mrs armeno Mr Braverman Mr cherella here Mrs Deo here Mrs Lang here Mrs Corino Mr Rybeck here Mr Russo Mr rutsky here Mrs K panowich here Madame board president you have a quarum present this evening in accordance with the provisions of the New Jersey open public meetings law the Monro Township Board of Education has caused notice of this meeting to be published by having the date time and place thereof posted

002October 13th 2017 at all schools the home News Tribune the cranberry press and filed with the clerk of the municipality thank you very much at this time we are going to number five on the agenda the approval of minutes for the public Board of Education meeting of August 23rd 2017 move by Mr chellis second by Mr Ryback any additions or corrections to the minutes seeing none all in favor opposed extensions okay the closed session meeting of August 23rd 2017 so move Mr tiarella Mr Ryback additions or corrections to the minutes seeing none all in favor opposed extensions okay that is passed the approval of the minutes for the special Board of Education meeting of August 29th 2017 so Mr CH Mr Ryback additions or corrections to the minutes again seeing none all in favor I

003opposed extensions then that has passed and we will go to the approval of the minutes for the closed session meeting of August 29th 2017 second Mr Ryback Mr Mayo again last time additions or corrections to the minutes seeing none all all in favor I opposed abstentions okay thank you so now we're going to go on to presentations we have three presentations this afternoon or this evening and I think we're very excited to have all three of them um the first one is a student presentation given by the mono Township middle school students and I'm very excited to have this tonight because um we are working and I'm going to have uh Dr Alvi explain it better than I will but we're working with the mtea and they have um been offered a grant to promote

004our schools during the school year and tonight we'll be doing that with the middle school but Dr Alvi can better explain it so we are proud to um offer you our one of our middle school programs tonight this is through the pride Grant p r i d and working with mtea and Mrs agback um we're going to be featuring one of our schools at each of our board me our board meetings throughout the year so you'll get to see some of the great programs that are happening um The Pride program also covers um other things like helping with school referendums um helping with literacy evenings some of the activities and presentations you've seen at some of the back to school nights um so these are all done by our uh teachers union so this evening

005we're welcoming the monotona middle school and reading superpowers these are sixth graders who are discovering their reading superpowers um as Educators we know the power of reading is to help us reach um new possibilities and to think creatively so our teachers want our students to feel that power that reading gives them so they are here this evening to talk about what they are doing in their classroom so I'm going to turn it over to Mrs Smith and our sixth grade reading superpowers [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music] which ready sixth graders are discovering their reading superpowers as teachers we know the power of reading is to help us imagine new possibilities think creatively and explore new worlds and ideas we want our students to feel the power that reading gives them and we are challenging them to

006think like superheroes the excitement is building as students select books to read spend quality time with their stories and talking about the text with their classmates we are hearing conversations about the power of knowledge imagination and strong vocabulary every day their reading superpowers become stronger reading this book a single Stone gave me the power to understand that you should never give up no matter how tall the mountain I gained this power by seeing how Jenna overcame the mountain even though the village leaders thought no one would survive if they went into the mountain alone reading the book The Fulton are stars gave me the power to be compassionate I gained this power by thinking if Augustus was not nice to Hazel she would still be bitter about her life in this way if I'm compassionate

007to everyone I come across their day will be much better than it previously was the Percy Jackson series gave me the power to feel like I had the world at my fingertips I gained this power by reading about the character's struggles like I was watching from above reading the hunger gam Theory gave me the power to be more brave and strong during heartbreaking and bone breaking moments and times I gained this power by reading how Katniss everine stood up for her sister survived the Hunger Games and was really determined reading the book The One and Only Ivan gave me the power to be a superhero and save anyone around the world I gained this power by reading my favorite genres when I read a book there's always a hero at the end of each book

008like in the book The One and Only Ivan Ivan was the hero because when Stella the baby elephant's mother died at the circus Ivan the gorilla had been taking care of her in this book I felt like I'm the hero because if my mom or dad go somewhere together I have to take care of my brother just like Ivan took care of Stella this is how reading makes me powerful reading gives me superpowers by opening my imagination I get into the book I sometimes imagine that I am that character in the book I like when the antagonist and protagonist battle in different books it also helps me to go to sleep reading really opens my imagination reading gives you the power of imagination I like to write my own stories and I get most of

009my ideas from the many books I read reading this book beastly gave me the power to believe in the power and magic of kindness and love I gained this power by reading how Beauty and the Beast conquered the curse by falling in love with each other no matter how their appearance is reading the book Allegient by Veronica Roth gave me the power to experience Adventures through the character shoes I gained this power by transporting myself in an astonishing New World allowing my visualization to work its gears alongside of the characters reading the book The Dark prophecy gave me the power to imagine new possibilities I gained this power by seeing how Leo was able to build a magical metal dragon out of just spare parts reading the book The girl in the blue coat gave

010me the power to make connections with things I've learned and experienced in the past I gained this power by analyzing each sentence carefully and having questions discussions and Connections In My Head reading Wonder gave me the power to understand a little more about struggles in life and that everyone should be treated equally I gained this power by Augie character having so many surgeries and how people think he is not ordinary and he just wants to be treated equally reading the book Steve Jobs The Man Who Thought different gave me the power to deepen the thought of how hard it is to succeed and to put me in someone else's shoes I gained this power by imagining what it would feel like if I was there reading this book Life As We Knew It gave me

011the power to realize that in life there will be ups and downs but family will always stay together no matter what I gained this power by realizing that the whole world might be coming to an end and Miranda's family no matter what helped and protected each other reading this book where the mountain meets the moon gave me the power to understand that fortune doesn't mean money it means a powerful friendship I gained this power by seeing how minley could only ask one question to the old man of the Moon and instead of asking about her Fortune she asked how she could help her friend reading the book reading the Bry Jackson series gave me the power to find a new interest in Greek mythology and start learning more and more about it until I became

012an expert I gained this power by learning more and more about Greek mythology and also trying out other books about ancient Greece and their beliefs reading the book Wonder Roman gave me the power to always believe that even through hard times I can still push through and make everyday count I gained this power by reading about the sacrifices that the character made to make everyone's life better I I read the Harry Potter series it gave me the power to believe I can do anything I put my mind to I gained this power by reading about the tough obstacles Harry and his friends went through reading the book Insurgent by Veronica Roth gave me the power to face my fears not to risk my life for no reason and to be brave I gained this power

013by learning from the main character Tris she used to risk her life for no reason but her friend stopped her from doing something that could harm her [Applause] would like to thank all of our students for being here today and helping to get us to understand what you're doing in your sixth grade class and we hope that you continue to read because that is um one of the most important things that we can do is read and it you sound like you all enjoy reading I know I do and most of the people up here do so um we'd like to you know thank you congratulate you for being here um we also look forward to the many other um schools and programs that we will be seeing towards the rest of the school year

014so thank you very much for being with us today [Applause] they should we should we should we should have all worn our costumes too that's what we were saying okay at this time uh we will go to a assessment data presentation with Dr alvic I know this one's going to be almost as exciting I will try okay okay so every year we're required to report out our assessment data from the previous school year so that's what this um presentation is for those of you in the audience this presentation will be available on the district website after I finish the presentation tonight so you don't need to take pictures it will be available to you afterwards so 2017 marked the third year of our Park Administration we give um all of our students the park English

015language arts and literacy assessment ass Assessments in grades 3 through 11 and the math assessments are grades 3 through 8 then with end of course Park Assessments in algebra one geometry and Algebra 2 the scores are reported out in five levels so oops sorry scores are reported out in five levels so when the parents received each individual student score report they would have seen how their their students compared with the five levels passing is considered level four or above um at the state level the first couple of slides this is the overall New Jersey data so this is the whole entire State all of the students that took the park assessment in the spring for the entire state in English language arts and then in math so again this will be available to you on

016the district website that you'll be able to see everything so those are the New Jersey results when we break it down I've broken it down for you for new J for the Monro Township School District so you have the past three years percentages for each grade level um in English English language arts and math and you also have the change in percentages so obviously we want less students to be at the level one level two area and more students to be at the level four and level five and then math is the same so it's also printed out um available to for math for the three years and then the change for each one one of the things we also look at as a district is we follow the students because yes on this chart

017you're looking at third grade across so third year third grade in 2015 third grade in 2016 third grade in 2017 obviously different students each year if you follow down diagonally and follow the students through the cohort 2015 they could they were in third grade 20166 they were in fourth grade 2017 they were in fifth grade you can Al also follow it that way this is the total number of students that took the assessment in English language arts and the total number of students who took the assessment in math this is the slide um that would kind of make the most sense I think to the audience so this is a comparison of Monroe Township scores to the um State percentages in all cases we are above the state average that's not good enough for us

018we want to keep going even higher than that um but we are above the state average in all of our scores these are the English language arts scores and then the math scores [Applause] yes what you'll notice with the math scores is it's broken down a little bit differently because of our acceleration math program our students who are in The Accelerated math program in e8th grade take Mrs Gasco will correct me if I'm wrong here take the algebra one assessment so so they're not taking the eighth grade assessment they're taking the algebra 1 assessment so they're pulled out of the eighth grade results and they have their own separate results there so that's why you see um multiple ones um the little star next to the eth grade so it's also broken down for you

019by demographics however if we had a group of students in any specific demographic that there were less than 25 students they are not on these slides for confidentiality re reasons so this is all broken down for you same way um broken down by the percentages comparing last year to this year for each of those subgroups we call them subgroups so that's done for each grade level and each subject so third grade is going to be you're going to have a language arts slide math slide fourth grade language arts math I'm just going to go through these quickly so we're not going through every single one okay so that's the Park results now the other thing that we're doing with the park and I'll talk a little bit more about this at the end is these

020are just the overall scores that we get as a district but we actually get evidence statements so every standard every question that was that our students took on the park assessment we have data on and our teachers are actually in the process now of going through that specific data and taking a look at how did our students do on every single state standard do we need to adjust our curriculum move things into a different order um is there something that maybe we didn't teach enough and we need to add into it so all of that is happening in the schools um through our teacher work so this is our science score so this year um you'll see the New Jersey ask for grades four New Jersey ask grade eight and the end of course biology

021assessment and these are our results and again we are above the state average for all of our science scores well above the state average we also give the AP assessments to all of our students it's offered to all of our students who are taking AP courses at the high school this past year we had 354 students take the AP Assessments in order for students to be eligible for college credit and to consider and have it consider that they passed the AP assessments they need to score a level three so again what are what's next we're looking at this data we're digging down into the data we're digging into the evidence statements we're looking at the standards we're always looking to improve so our teachers are doing that with our supervisors now there are resources on

022this PowerPoint for parents um how to read the score reports the score reports did go home end of August beginning of September um they should have been in your home so you should have gotten your um individual child score report it's a conversation you can have with teachers at conferences um when you get them and again these are our next steps so we are looking at those evidence statements teachers are using this data to help guide them in their student growth objectives all of our teachers are required to do um student growth objectives every year um based on student data and they can use this data as part of it they don't use the park as their sgo so they don't say okay my students are all going to increase because we don't get the

023scores back in time to do that but a lot of them are using NWA map scores which I know a lot of parents are familiar with um they're using other activities that they're doing in their classrooms other assessments that they're doing grade levels and then the school goals committees are also working on their goals using this data as well as the principal sgos so principles have to also set their own goals so all of this data is being used in that and help us guide our curriculum that's it I just I say yeah I'm G to open it up for questions thank you I don't have a question but I do have a a quick statement I just wanted to well you know I want to thank the administration obviously but I really think that

024the thanks we have so many teachers here and I'm not running for anything so I could just I could do this right uh I just want to thank you for these results and we're very lucky to have each and every one of you in our district so thank [Applause] you anyone else from the board questions well and i' I've said many times too that well we have great facilities and great technology and and great um things going on here we have great programs but none of them is good without the staff that teaches these programs and the and the kids in this District so the we we notice that we've been trending upwards and it's all thanks to whom we have working in this building so or not this building I mean more like this

025District so we we thank you for what you do every day in partnering with the board of education for our children thank [Applause] you okay if there's no more comments or questions by the board we will go to our budget philosophy discussion uh Mr Gorski I think you're going to handle this [Music] thank you madam board president and I can't believe it's time to introduce discussion on the budget again because it seems like it was just two meetings ago when we received an additional state aid award that affected the current year budget um but here we are it's the time of year to discuss a budget Philosophy for the 1819 school year and we would like to recognize the board members um Kathy kapano board president Paul rutsky finance committee chair what is a budget

026philosophy the philosophy of establishing the annual school budget should entail the creation of a framework for a budget that supports a democratic plan of appropriate funding for the implementation of educational programs so that students May develop and learn from quality experiences based on educationally sound and fiscally prudent planning a solid Financial base is Paramount to ensuring that the school district will be able to meet the responsibility of preparing our students for an increasingly competitive environment the budget philosophy stage should be macro focused rather than micro focused as a as much more refinement will be required and implemented in the future through a rigorous budget process tonight we are looking at First Blood budget demands for next year and what our resources are projected to be to meet those demands and the board will uh come

027to a resolution um accordingly budgets are driven by student enrollment and this slide dramatically shows that Monroe has picked up 1,781 new students over the past eight years it's important to note that the last two columns to the right are projections we do a a audit of all of our students on October 15 and the first six columns are accurate Assa Counts from the October 15th report that the state certifies and the last two columns are projected as we have not completed the report for October 15 2017 yet but it's safe to say that we will pick up almost 1,800 students over the past 8 years that puts an incredible Demand on the budget some more specific appropriation considerations salaries and benefits are approximately 75% of the general fund budget for the 1819 budget philosophy

028the salary and benefit cost increases have to be conservatively estimated as the largest Collective negotiations unit the mtea is currently in negotiation thus the mtea and the non-affiliated staff currently have undefined salary and benefits for next year which are subject to change aggregate District salaries are approximately $65 million health benefits have been projected to increase 8.5% with the caveat that claims will have to be monitored at least through January 2018 to receive an accurate estimate and 2017 2018 health benefit premiums were $22.3 million and were offset by contractual contributions of approximately $4 million so with the largest components of 75% of the budget being undefined at this time uh we cannot project exactly what the salary demands are going to be for next year nor can we accurately Define what the health benefit premiums will

029be we've been very successful over the past five years and keeping health benefit increased is below a 5% average last year they were 25% increase and when netted with the contributions from staff they were at 0% increase we will continue to aggressively fight to keep the health benefit cost down while providing excellent plans for staff Dr alic So speaking about staff what I did is I worked with the supervisors and the building principles to start thinking about next year we start planning for the 1819 budget already um so these are some items that have come out of these preliminary discussions there is a very large budget defense that everyone goes through when they finally go through their budget rounds um so these are just kind of a as Mr Gorski said a first blush this

030is things that we know we need to start thinking about and considering it is not necessarily that they are in the budget um but these are things that we need to think about as we plan for it so we're looking at in increasing staff and the reason for increasing staff is because we have more students um so looking at that um 12 to possibly 12 to 15 additional teachers or certificated staff members special education staff um additional custodians grounds person because of all of our um athletic events that are that are happening in our district we're also looking at transportation we again we have more students coming we need to transport them so not only are six of the 54 passenger buses and five 24 passenger vans are recommended to be replaced due to age

031mileage restrictions we're also looking to add a few more to help with our growing enrollment students and the difficulty that we have with getting contracted buses um to get all of our students to and from school as well as some of the activities Dr alvic if I may it's very important to note that the additional buses beyond the required replacements require a development of a new bus depot on Schoolhouse Road uh whereas the township is is in the process of transferring the land to the school district but there's still a large development appropriation coming in the facilities part for that so a lot of this is is tied to that uh land need um technology we're always looking at our technology um there are technology um wears out after a few years um kind of

032gets behind the time so we need to upgrade and also increase some it excuse me and also looking at because we're looking at trailers at the middle school next year we're going to need to outfit those classrooms with projectors um and computers in those classrooms too so we're looking at um increase in technology um as Mr Gorski me mentioned we do have some facility needs that are coming next year the 10 portable classrooms at the middle school being one of our facility needs um also looking at creating that Transportation Depot because there is no space at the board office where the buses are currently housed we do have buses van housed at the middle school now and bus is housed at Oak Tree school um so we need more space for that some of our

033boilers and HVAC units are beyond their serviceable life so looking at replacing those in some of our schools looking at our sports facilities the cage turf field is over 13 years old in a life expectancy of about ten years um bleachers that are needed at those fields because of our um growing Student Activities we have more people that come and watch the games um furniture for the portable classrooms at the middle school we not only do we have to outfit it with the technology but we need Student desks teacher desks chairs uh shelving cabinets a security desk the high school needs more lockers we're out of lockers for our high school students or or nearing that um so we need more lockers at the high school and then again additional furniture at the high school

034to accommodate that student growth including some cafeteria tables um we're always we look at our textbooks on a fiveyear cycle so we take a look at what our needs are going to be for the following year we've done a great job of keeping up to date with that as the standards have been um revised and our curriculum have been revised but these are the curriculum or these are the textbooks that are up for um renewal next year and again we have some programs again looking at our student needs our marching band uniforms are over 17 years old um so we're looking at possibly replacing those um and looking at some sports at the middle school um part of the problem at the middle school is we have so many more students trying out for the

035same number of sports what that means is more students get cut so we we want to offer more opportunities for our middle school students the sub varsity volleyball that's the second year of this this year volley the boys volleyball is being run as a club as we go to Varsity Sports the first year is a club the second year is a sub Varsity Club the third year is the full Varsity so it incre increases some sports uh increases the sports there we're the only High School in the area without a boys volleyball team and Unified sports Unified sports involve our special needs students as well as our general education students so giving more opportunities for all of our students that's great with all of these things just some pieces of out some data for you

036our June 16 graduates over 90% of our students attended College whether it be a two-year or a four-year College um we had quite a few students go into the military this year so there's a lot happening 84% of our students that took the AP test as I reported out before um scored a three or better and we are registered or we are recognized as number 65 in nich last year as the best schools of New Jersey and number 59 in school Digger as best school in New Jersey so we're continuing to monitor our programs and to try and offer as much as we can for our students even with the increased student growth well what new what resources are available to meet the demands of all those new programs and services that are required and

037and enhancing the current offerings last year the district received $3.3 million in general funds state aid that's a little more than $450 a pupil it's it's uh very uh disproportionately low compared to our peers um we are engaged in a fair funding committee chaired by Ken Chella and we are actively seeking all political Avenues to get an increase in Aid we've lobbied as hard as we have possibly can we've met with everybody who will welcome us we've even written our own legislation to to bring more Aid to the district and we are going to keep the pedal down in that regard to fight for every dollar that's available to school districts because uh as Ken has reported out on the committee in the past Monroe's taxes are being diverted to other communities to provide state

038Aid to other districts where Monroe doesn't qualify and basically we're only getting categorical state aid which is a reimbursement for our cost in categories such as special education transportation and security but where the state doesn't give us we provide for ourselves uh the Board of Education created a new proprietary fund a couple years ago called Falcon care Early Childhood enrichment and that program has uh uh supplanted uh the pre-existing one and offered a much better curriculum and has re uh generated very nice profits of $1.1 million in their first two years of operations the finance committee has recommended that $600,000 of that retained earnings be transferred to the general fund budget in 1819 to generally offset instructional trailer costs and then and um Monroe re receives about 269 students from Jamesburg school district and um

039thanks to the hard work of this board uh there is an agreement in place where Jamesburg is providing um the full amount of tuition that's required for the current year and in and in as early as when we do the next report it's assumed that Jamesburg will have overpaid their tuition through the budget which will be applied to for the aage Jamesburg revenues for tuition are about 3.7% of general fund revenues this calculation will be available on the website but this determines um the next year's projected cap the Monroe's uh tax levy is the largest revenue source to the budget and uh Governor Christie had imposed a cap on the general fund Levy a 2% cap with certain adjustments that takes Monroe to about a 3% increase over the past few years and it's made

040uh uh living within that cap very difficult for a lot of school districts many have foregone facility improvements kick the leaking can uh kick the roof down the road uh type things um because it's very hard to budget for that and all of the other increases that Dr alvik Illustrated but we've addressed our facilities every year consistently by picking up at least a million doll roof project every year within the cap and this shows you the the cap calculation starts with a pre-year general fund tax levy there's an automatic adjustment that the state calculates for enrollment we don't know what that will be at this time but the last one was $1.1 Million then it's inflated by 2% then there's a a health care cost adjustment that's uh available if your costs exceed uh an

041average of the State Health Benefit plan because Monroe was so effective in negotiating health insurance rates to a two 2.5% increase last year we disqualified oursel from any cap adjustment for health care costs and um a couple years ago the district went under cap by $600,000 which is available as as a what's called banked cap so the maximum cap for the general fund Levy is 101 milli 57312 and if the board was to use the bank cap it would be 102 1731 124 that's an increase of only $3.1 million or $3.7 million with the use of the bank cap that is a small adjustment um when you calculate the percentage increases on a $65 million wage base throughout the District 20 $ million of health benefit costs at 85% all of the new student needs

042the requirements and mandates to replace buses and the facility needs the next slide shows another Revenue Source uh which is the excess Surplus Administration works very hard to pinch every penny and manage the budget as effectively as possible health benefits is one of our our best fiscal practices that is a model that districts have used and we've shared through our budget efficiency rounds um last year we had $6.1 million of excess Surplus this year the estimate shrunk slightly to 6, 55,000 a decrease of $ 79,3 51 which will mean if that was the only Revenue source to the budget we we would have a constriction of about $80,000 to the budget but it still shows a lot of hard work um controlling costs purchasing efficiently and maximizing all other Revenue sources one of the most

043important variables in calculating the tax rate is ratables the calculation is to take the the uh tax levy and divide it by the rable base and that that comes up with the tax rate as the rateable base grows as more people move into Monroe and property values are added more people share the burden and the individual tax rates decrease it is anticipated that for the 1819 school year rate of bulls will increase again 1.5% that is a significant um percentage increase which will suppress taxes throughout the entire community so what does this present illustrate that you have a very high- performing School District with numerous best practices comparatively low taxation which is an incredible value for all of our constituents administration's recommendations to the board uh are as follows because there are many unknowns at

044this point with salary increases to a large percentage of Staff health benefit increases um state aid don't know what the award is yet we're recommending conservatism be applied in in the approach to developing a philosophy by budgeting to the maximum spending Authority that the statute allows budgeting to cap it would be in my opinion irresponsible to budget anything less than cap in this environment with heavy growth heavy demands on on the district incredible new staffing needs incredible facility needs expend in transportation needs um just to meet those responsibilities is an incredible feat um and to do it within the cap is also an incredible feat so our recommendation to the board of education is to prioritize all the construction projects presented curriculum projects recommended and presented salary benefit increases we're going to have to conservatively

045estimate um because of their contingent status the Transportation recommendations which are presented and of course to transfer $600,000 of profits known as retained earnings from the Falcon care Early Childhood enrichment program to generally offset new trailer costs for the 1819 school year we have our work cut out for us to refine this budget everything you see here is very preliminary and subject to review through the budget process which is very vigorous and involves teams AC uh from the schools uh through Administration to the finance committee to the Board of Education okay so I'm going to read a resolution and then I'll open the uh resolution up for discussion by board members questions comments it is recommended that the Board of Education establish and adopt a budget Philosophy for the 2018 2019 school year which tasks

046Administration to to prepare a budget that responsibly meets the demands of continuing significant student growth and facility needs as well as program and service requirements without exceeding the board's maximum spending Authority which would necess necessitate going out to a vote while prioritizing the following items subject to the restrictions presented by Administration one construction projects as presented two curriculum recommendations as presented three salary and benefit increases at a conservative range due to their contingent status four Transportation recommendations as presented and five to transfer 600,000 from the retained earnings of the Falcon care Early Childhood enrichment proprietary fund to generally offset new trailer costs for the 201829 school year this action by the board will enable the board to fulfill its educational responsibility to District students in a thorough efficient and fiscally prudent man manner while non-c

047committedly ensuring the maintenance of District resources and Facilities so move move by Mr chela second by Mr Ryback I see we have a team today so is there any comments or questions by any member of the board Miss armino um the $600,000 um being put into the general fund correct it does that um have we satisfied the loan from the old Mecca program before we take that I believe we have but I just want to confirm that yes ma'am that's confirmed the loan from Mecca was completely paid off a couple years ago okay I I think it's a good idea to put that 600,000 um the other question I have is the 2% cap that was created by the state through the governor is that correct yes 2010 budget law okay and is that going

048to sunset at any time soon uh we haven't heard anything about it sunsetting so dep right now the whether we get a new governor or not that there that's not scheduled to Sunset unless somebody changes things in the new in8 uh 2018 is that correct correct and we and we really can't anticipate that at the time right um and that adds to some of the contingencies within this budget that's a concern um you know it's been said that um going to the maximum uh spending Authority if we don't do that is is irresponsible but on the other hand I think uh not considering that within six months we're going to be asking the same people who were raising taxes for today um to vote on a referendum so I I would like to think that

049we would have some slight consideration and perhaps go slightly underc cap um I know it's been very very difficult and our hands are tied we cannot control uh the rapid enrollment I'm only across the street at the at the township Council can do that through their ordinance and planning and zoning and we are you know responsible for our children and and all of the great work that the staff does and the parents and the and the students but we're asking the whole Community to continually um you know go to the max and I think I'd like to reserve that for March 13th of 2018 that's just my position at this point uh madam the umu the resolution before you generally authorizes Administration on on what type of budget to to build what what priorities should

050be contained in the budget of course as that process gets refined and as we get closer to the tenative budget if it's feasible to accomplish all of those goals that were outlined by Dr alvic and Dr kak and um still present a budget under Capital which we did two years ago uh we would be most pleased to recommend that however at this time I think our work is certainly cut out for us with the effects of growth and I also remind you that the Board of Education directed the $458,000 additional state aid award back to the taxpayers in in the form of tax relief as the 1617 budget uh was satisfactory in administration's view right and and I totally agree and I again I I think it's it's a a really very difficult position to

051put a board of education and students in uh with this kind of Rapid enrollment again that we have absolutely no control over but we do have control over at least um some suggestion of being very very cautious about our budget so has there ever been a budget that when the philosophy said go to cap has gone under cap I think we've had undercap philosophies and we've gotten undercap by a little bit but anytime I think we've gone to historically said go to cap we just go to cap I mean I think the budget Philosophy for the year that we went $600,000 underap I'm going by memory but I believe that was to stay within the statutory spending Authority as excess Surplus um grew to a very handsome number that year it afforded us the ability

052to use our savings from the preceding Year's budgets to apply in in Le of taxes uh so certainly the authorization today to stay within the statutory Authority enables us to begin the budget process right now with the goal of course keeping in mind uh to do it efficiently as possible to refine the numbers as sharply as possible and um if it's feasible to go under cap and that will certainly be discussed more at the finance committee level sure Dr um yeah to just to add to that Mr the couple things that we're considering as you heard in the presentation tonight is the addition of trailers at the middle school so funding that um we're also looking at expanding our transportation a lot across the street and that'll take some money to to do that and

053the budget defense rounds are will be coming up shortly the pre pre-budget defense rounds are being conducted right now by Dr alvik and the supervisors and principles but when we get to those budget defense rounds we really take a very very hard look at you know just keeping to what we need to keep a quality Education Without adding above that especially as you stated we're very cognizant of the of the referendum coming up and I agree with you I mean we we're you know we're aware of what the taxpayers and the community members have said about the the rising taxes and and we want to be very careful that we honor and we keep their Respect by keeping our spending within reasonable limits while still maintaining a quality education and trying to find other ways

054to fund like the trailers and the um you know the the additional parking lot within the budget that we have without adding that to a loan or referendum but I I agree with what you're saying I I just thought of something if I may uh president CS um you know is there a possible way in our to since our job is education is there a possible way to ask the township Council to provide some funds for our trailers um can we write a letter asking them to do that because again uh our enrollment is really not controlled by us and I'm just wondering and they can ask the builders to provide some trailers the the builders are providing our students maybe they can provide help with the trailers and that would I I don't see

055why we couldn't ask I'm not sure that we could get anything but in terms of budgeting uh I think it would be prudent of us to seek other sources Madam Mr I just I the only thing that I had on that I just wanted to answer that for a second because I don't know that we could ask them for to cross funds like that I don't know maybe we could doesn't hurt to ask I guess or look into it but I think where we can ask for Relief is in the and I was going to bring that up at for our committee reports is in uh our committee the um buildings and grounds Transportation committee is asking that we go to the township and asked them to foro um sewer and water connection fees so

056they charged us to connect this high school they charg us to connect oak tree oak tree and it was millions of dollars and what we'd like to do is have them forego that and that would be a good way for them to uh not donate but to alleviate some of the pressure yeah Madam can I Mr to Mr cherel as Point um and as I've stated previously Administration has already discussed uh the um the sewer connection fee issue uh with the township and uh I will say that it it was warmly received and it's still being negotiated else I would like to say something just to clarify Mike yes this is a philosophy and there are no numbers on the board right now and we get the governor's state aid when we got it state

057aid comes out in in the the latter part of January probably the third week of January right but the budget process has begun already so this in a very macro sense tells uh Administration from the board what type of cake you want baked right so let me interrupt you so we're going to bake this cake and if the the new Governor's coming in and whoever that may be if they decide to give us more of the state aid we deserve then we could revisit how much we're actually going to cap or not or not so if they come back and say we're fully funding the formula you're getting this amount of money then we can look and say we don't need to go to cap that's correct if the the formula was fully funded it

058would be an approximate uh infusion of about $5 million that most likely would be offset from the tax levy so yes it's a very Dynamic uh process uh we are at the very earliest stage uh this is just general instructions on what type of cake again to use an analogy that you would like bake um and we will begin the baking process but we will have to be flexible to change layers and toppings and whatever um to roll out something that's delicious at the end like we did last year thank you Mr rybe thank you I just want to follow up on some of the comments certainly started by Mr Mino fiscal efficiency is fiscal efficiency is I think a key thing for all of us here and I appreciate your statements there but we

059have a lot to um to deal with ahead of us and I I understand that we really can't come up with much until we've settled many many things and know what's coming down the pike but one of the things that I have to say that we we probably could start the ball rolling now and there's no harm in it is asking why developers who are going to be making millions of dollars off of the uh residents of this town and residents moving in can't help pay for some of the costs that we're we're dealing with my opinion they should be building the schools not not the taxpayers here they should be building the schools but obviously that's illegal um I realize impact fees are legal but uh if we ask the worst that happens is

060we're in the same boat we have now we're in now so I think that's something that that U we should seriously do as well as the uh sewer and connection fees I think we can't forget about those either thank you and also I think knowing that we're going to have a new governor in January we're going to need as a board to keep advocating for more money for next year not any less or at least the same amount which isn't even helping us so we have our work cut out to do too by advocating to the state that you know we need this for formula for next year to help us out we we're in um a situation where we're adding 3 400 kids a year that we're asking our taxpayers to cover more than

061they should be covering and we we need help here and that's our job is to continue to do that knowing we also have a referendum that is is so important to the education of our students any other comments or questions just a small question hello so with regards to the expense of the trailers my question comes down to the furniture inside the computers inside will we be buying that or will we be leasing that like we lease the trailers computers and uh office equipment generally has a five-year useful life and we found it an effective process to lease purchase those items in aggregate uh by putting the financing out to bid and getting the lowest interest rates on it and and this way the the service of the equipment uh is equally matched over its

062useful life so we will seek again a lease purchase and recommend to the board to aggregate all of the equipment purchase anything that can be considered collateral and uh lease purchase it so not to require you to provide financing for an an equipment item in one year when it has a useful life for five this better matches and it eases the burden of a of a very uh tight budget got it thank you anyone else well then at this time we'll have a roll call on the resolution Mrs armenio um since this is a Phil philosophy budget hearing um uh saying I represent many people in the community I'm going to say no because philosophically I think many people would like us to go a little bit under uh under the max thank you Mr

063Braverman yes Mr cherella yes Mrs Deo yes Mrs Lang yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr rutsky yes Mrs kapano yes madame board president motion has passed okay thank you and at this time we will go to our student board members report thank you um the marching band is attending a competition on October 21st use your microphone please um also the monor township Footlights production is hosting their annual showcase on October 26th 27th and 28th also on Menor Township the green fair is being held on October 28th thank you good stuff all good stuff um committee reports is there any committee that needs to report this evening Miss Mayo yes okay I am reporting on the curriculum um we have a good time in the curriculum committee if any parent really wants to understand the education of

064their children they really should come and attend the curriculum uh committee uh the meeting is open to anybody who wants to attend um and it's 5:30 the night of the board meeting um the board members and the supervisors are all pretty enthusiastic about what's going on tonight we um reviewed Mathematics grade 2 and Mathematics Grade 5 new curriculum um this is what the curriculum document looks like it's very dry looking but this is what it translates for the kids um and it's pretty exciting stuff so we also reviewed there's a New Jersey poetry out loud contest and what this is it's a national poetry contest for students in Grade 9 through 12 um it's a competition so all 50 states um there'll be a a school competition then it'll be Statewide and all the states

065will compete then after that um there the focus is on two clubs the literacy club and the tedex club they're going to um participate in this but the it's open to everybody who wants to participate um students will review and select from more than n 900 poetries and they will engage in Reading analyzing discussing and reciting the poem that they have chosen so it's pretty exciting we also talked about um the middle school is having a multicultural literacy partnership with a school in India and so they've partnered with a school in India it's a private school in Mumbai um the students do speak English they will work um with Multicultural lit literacy it's a multicultural literacy club and so what they will do is they will read three books they will read a book about

066India they will read a book about global issues and then they will read a book of their choice and have a virtual book club with their Indian counterparts um the club will go through January through April the reason the club is short is because um the two Calenders of our school and the Indian School don't only match during April January through April so that's pretty exciting for the middle school students we also reviewed um social studies and science Mentor texts and what these are are these are um books that show a student how to do something in writing it's it's teaching science through literacy and this the the books the these are leveled readers so the so the science books are moving away from your standard textbooks and they're they're they're teaching science through literacy

067there could be stories teaching kids how to about chemical reactions um and it takes science to a new to a new level because it's quality reading it's not that dry textbook um and it's a better way to communicate the science and it's more interesting for students we also talked about leveled readers and leveled readers are what when there's kid the kids in elementary school are studying a topic right say they're studying water on Earth they each get a book and this book comes in different levels depending on where the child Falls in their reading skills so you have you know level um orange for kids who are Advanced readers blue and then you have green so all the kids are learning the same topic they're just being taught at their reading level so it really

068is personalized learning for these students we also I pulled this up before this is another way that kids are getting personalized um learning this is the grade 2 math curriculum and what happens is first of all the books are really cute they they've got characters and they bright colors and they're really interesting they're not that you know here's 20 questions please answer them and this is also um personalized because a student according to their level will be told which questions to answer so there will be questions for higher level learners for lower level Learners and so all the kids are learning the same concept but at their own level so it's really pretty exciting um and that was pretty much it thank you I I just want to add on to that today because um

069a lot of parents cannot teach their children how to do math homework anymore so we had a little lesson today on how to do new math and I think it was really exciting for us to do that and to know see really firsthand how our kids are learning differently than we did when we had that opportunity m second grade grade second grade but it was really cool because it's not it's also not about having the kids in second grade get the right answer it's about having them think through the process and learn the process which is something that understanding what they're doing which we did not have or I didn't growing up Mr Chella I saw you had your hand up I just was going to give my committee report I know oh can I

070can I ask oh you want to ask a question Miss um I I was at the last uh curriculum meeting and I thought it was really interesting about the levels um but how does and and I didn't think of this before but after what you said how does a child from one level advance to another is there room for doing that in the curriculum okay abut that would be important we don't want to keep people at just one level we want to make sure that if they are starting at one level they they have the ability to advance thank you call it flexible grouping now so no student is ever in one group all the time I'm in classrooms where students are moving groups during the lesson and watching the teachers as they're going around

071and assessing their students informally seeing how they're doing and moving them to a different group during that time it's very flexible in the classroom it's based on the student needs thank you and I think our goal is to make sure that we raise the bar for all children right that's yeah I mean I think the program is good and it's like a progressive program but I just it just dawned on me that we're not keeping people at a certain level we it's it's about moving them into higher levels at every turn thank you are is this for Jill yeah okay the commit I just want to bring out one thing and thank Mrs Lang because her question uh to the curriculum supervisors brought out something that I think we should all bring out and that

072they all come all of them come to the curriculum committee meetings whether they're reporting or not they're there to lend their expertise because they really care about the kids and the teachers and and doing the right thing and I think it was really wonderful it's wonderful to have that expertise at that table every month and the good thing about that is that they work so closely together that if you ask one person a question the other person can answer the question in all different fields so it it just shows a good cross curriculum that we're doing here and it's really great okay Mr tiella I don't even know if I could follow all that excitement it was pretty exciting um we had um we just we had our meeting on October 2nd buildings grounds and

073transportation we had several things SE several topics but um we closed out the lead the lead water testing so there were there were concerns about the lead testing that was done we had some uh positive hits for lead uh at some of our schools and so we had to go about testing and then remediating um that's been accomplished and then uh follow-up testing was done and we're we're at normal normal level so thankfully now we we applied for a uh we applied to be to be reimbursed for that and we got I think it was 14,000 I have right here $1,397 which doesn't cover everything but it covers a good portion of that we also uh we also got a pretty cool area view aerial view of the middle school and where the eight or

074nine trailers will go so that was pretty interesting to see where they'll be set up in the front of the building and how they'll be set up and that brings us to our connection fees so I'm glad to hear that the followup to the to our meeting um was a conversation with the township I think that that's important because um every dollar counts and it really doesn't matter which pocket it's coming out of whether it's the board of Ed's pocket or the Township's pocket it's still our taxpayers pocket so could alleviate some of that somewhere uh I think that's a that that that goes a long way uh gov govdeals.com I've been fighting for the other one for a while but no that's that's a private joke but we uh we sold those eyesore dilapidated

075gutted buses um that were behind the Middle School uh through govdeals.com and we were able to get $28,269 and that'll go into the general fund so that's that's pretty that's pretty good because we're going to get rid of all that junk that that was behind there and replace that with money so that's important and then um there was a uh I don't even know how to say this p pios is that a complaint uh filed from Monroe Commons that there were some uh health concerns about the the the bathroom and cleanliness and things like that uh that was investigated and uh came back with that the finding was how would you even say that wasn't unfounded unfounded thank you unfounded no finding yeah finding of unfounded this and that's it that's all I had thank

076you anyone else Mr rety all right so the finance committee also not very exciting and uh and Ken already stole some of my thunder about the lead testing so what I'll just uh be a little bit specific on is so the amount of um the the expense that we laid out $1 4,397 30 we are have been submitted a request to be reimbursed but I do not believe we've yet been reimbursed right I think that has to be a whole process the the state has to reimburse everybody at one time so uh so that's the lead testing everything that Ken said um let's move on to oh well our meeting was on last uh Monday October 2nd uh at 7 o00 for the record so we went on to talk about the the two different

077advisors that we'll be using for the bond referendum uh their services we reviewed the two contracts uh the first was for Bond Council um services from marter and English LLP now these people have worked with the Monroe Board of Ed um without interruption since 1988 so it's a long-standing relationship and for that loyalty uh they grant us a discounted rate of $400 per hour as opposed to $550 per hour so that's that's could be substantial the that when you extrapolate it out is capped not to exceed $2500 for phase one so we know the maximum cost from macter and English for phase one is 2500 could be less and what that covers is All Professional Services leading up to the successful referendum some of those services but not limited to are writing the resolution for

078Bond sale preparing the bond offering documents and handling the closing for the bond issue so fingers crossed on that the second uh review we did was for the financial advisory firm of Phoenix advisors LLC we've also worked with them uh many times in the past this is with uh pertains to the also pre pre-referendum planning and Analysis uh specific specifically this includes financial planning tax impact analysis Financial modeling preparation of public information and presentations news releases and applications to oversight boards as well as other services this fee for the pre-planning um is not to exceed $500 um and if it's successful and we move on to phase two that $1,500 is credited towards our expenses in phase two so it supports the next phase of the project and I'll go back to the first part

079of my presentation I'm going to say that was actually very exciting review those were some good numbers um we went on to talk about a potential new school app for our iPhones or our cell phones so Dr kak presented uh a new app called School Info app um we looked at it we talked about it and after some discussion from the committee members we gave it back to Dr kak to um put together a more formal proposal one with some exciting Matrix and rubrics all right exciting as possible every step of the way the audit update uh came next we are about a third of the way through our exciting audit um right now they're focusing on payroll and transaction testing cafeteria operations as well as fixed assets on that we will continue to keep

080everyone one posted uh as we continue to make progress and make it up to 2/3 last but not least not on the agenda but we did end up having a discussion um and we are going to request Miss Maria nomic the director of adult education to be to come to the next finance committee meeting where we're going to ask her to give us an update on the fall enrollment and numbers so we continue to review and keep a uh continue to evaluate the adult education program that concludes my report okay is there any other reports because I don't know if I could take any more excitement tonight no other reports okay we will go to the public forum anyone from the public wishing to speak to the agenda please come to the microphone state your

081name and address for the record and we will adhere to our 4minute time limit good evening uh Chrissy scurby 21 pness Drive um I just wanted to say I've had the uh privilege of having I two children in the district I've had the privilege of having my children um due to redistricting go through Barkley Brook Brookside oak tree Applegarth the middle school and the high school we've been we the only schools we haven't been in Woodland and mil Lake and I have to tell you as a parent going through all of those schools we have absolutely fantastic staff and teachers in these schools we heard we heard tonight how we celebrate our schools we are touting our results on the park exam uh that is a direct reflection of our teachers and what is going

082on in the classrooms our teachers are handling increased enrollment they are handling situations that teachers shouldn't have to handle and it is as a parent it saddens me every morning when I drive my son to the high school to see the signs that our teachers are working without a contract our teachers are get their salaries are the bottom three they're three from the bottom in our County that is appalling to me as a parent we can do better in this district and I'd like to know Madame board president why is it being being such a tough negotiation for our teachers contracts it should not be tough we're sitting here touting our results touting what our teachers are doing touting the results that our students are seeing yet we don't want to pay them we are

083losing staff every day to other districts it is absolutely appalling what is going on we are crowding our schools with more and more students we're not addressing the real issue of the overcrowding in our buildings and we're asking our teachers to do more and more and we can't even come up with a good contract for them it is absolutely sad as a parent to see this going on in our district and I really hope Madame board president that you will do something quickly to to resolve this because we cannot lose any more staff to this our teachers deserve better thank you is there anyone else from the public wishing to speak Krishna 11 pleas um I have one comment to make first um I support the mte here um they have they need to get

084their contract having said that um there is one thing that I bought up last um during the last Board of Education meeting um there was a plan to get a Middle School uh uh the uh what do you call the public voting on it public referendum on it referendum right um is that still on track and do you have any updates on the uh middle school public referendum any steps have been taken what's happening there well you know at the September board meeting the board you uh passed the resolution to and I will have something in my board president's report about the referendum cool thank you and um a follow-up question do you have any plans or um updates on the middle uh high school and the elementary school the expansions um when are they

085being targeted and what's happening no we do not have any updates on the high school or the um uh proposed new elementary school at this time we're concentrating on the referendum for the middle school and making sure that that one gets passed okay and um so the Middle School uh the middle school after the referendum passes would be four years from that time out right or is it going to be any sooner um I think 2021 September 21 September if if it passes in sep in in this March March 13th we hope to open the doors to that school in September of 2021 sure thank you ma'am anyone else uh hello Amba sukla I live in si Court uh to sier court uh first of all I would like to thank all our teachers and

086members of the Board of Education guys are doing a great job um my question is about the slide where uh we presented the um ranking of the school and uh I did a quick check on the same websites that were mentioned in your uh presentation and uh this is what I saw uh the school Digger rank for Monroe Township School District is 158 um the school Digger rank for the middle school is 13 138 uh the middle school rank in the other website is 131 and the N high school rank is 140 which is below height town and it's also uh below um Oldbridge and a lot of other neighboring towns uh and if I go to uh Willow and just try to check the prices of my property it uh says that mono Township

087school is rated five which is uh I mean frankly pretty disturbing uh so I was just wondering if there is reason to worry if uh you have any opinion about uh these numbers that be Dr kak yeah I think between Dr alak and myself one thing I would like to check Dr alac is checking the websites right now there are two Monro townships um couple about a week or two ago we got were inated with phone calls thinking that we had mold in our schools and it was the other Monroe Township in South Jersey so I'm not sure about the rankings no I I've been I've been I've been following this very okay closely so with that rankings now I haven't looked at all of them I did look at the the what is it

088Zillow I think couple we ago yeah uh part of what I found with Zillow and I find it with nich and uh some of the other rankings Great Schools as well is sometimes the the school data is about two years old that they're using U they also different websites use different rankings some include parent comments some do not uh it's not the most reliable we did state it in the presentation tonight so you're absolutely right and if our numbers are wrong then we stand corrected we no your your numbers are not wrong just to 65 okay your numbers are not wrong you just pick the good numbers uh the bad numbers you were were not on the slide okay oh your numbers were correct yes high school high school is ranked 59 in school Digger

089and uh the school district is ranked 65 or 69 in the other website that's your numbers are good okay the only thing is uh the the numbers that are not good were are not on the slide and I I just looked them up yeah yeah I and again I I don't you know I didn't look at the numbers for the other schools but I would like to say this it's very difficult when you look and you try to rank one school or one District against one another but what we do look at is how do our students you know there's there's a very big push to personalize education to individualize education so we spent a lot of time looking at individual students or cohorts of students and saying are we advancing that cohort of students

090and how does that compare across the state now as was as was stated tonight we're above the state average that's that's nice but it's not good enough we have very high aspirations for our students expectations uh as been stated by several people and I concur with what they've stated our teachers do an excellent job teaching our students our students are good we have good families we see a continual increase in what our students are able to achieve and then there are other areas that those rankings don't always measure for instance the type of activities and clubs that we offer our students the Project based I'm being beeped Mr Gori excuse me is that exciting right that's you turn the time off my answer um the uh you know the the Project based learning that we're

091doing the the maker spaces that are going on the uh the work that our students do for instance you won't see in the rankings how our model un students have done or our Deca students or FBLA students last year and and again they're starting again this year they're excellent they're really doing some top level work so that's what excites me that's where I think we're really shining and that's why I look forward to these student presentations that we're having at the board meeting and we we put these student presentations on Channel 28 we need the community to really understand it's more than just a number we talk about Park testing you can't measure Everybody by just one test score it is part of the equation but it's not the entire equation and we really have

092to when I go around to the classrooms and see the wonderful learning activities God Bless you that's that are taking place that's what I want to get out to the community so that they know so that you as a parent and other parents are confident and are proud of what your children are doing and what we're doing as Educators with your children in collaboration with your children but I'm very proud to say that our students are are um doing outstanding work another indicator not shown on there is what kind of colleges are the the kids getting into our kids are getting into some very good universities uh so there are all type of things that are hard to measure and when I look at the different websites there's different reasons some are real estate you

093know that they're pushing their agenda and and others have their own different agenda um but I can't depend on those outside sources we have to look internally at what we're doing and we'll continue to improve because we're not done the the road to success is almost always under construction so we're going to continue every single day to improve what we're doing thank you thank you any Ready Set motion ruri 23 green ey Street okay I just want to thank the board of education for this meeting and I want to support the teachers uh who are Behind These grades uh par school that we just discussed about it I want to support them uh I want to check with you guys like you know follow regularly like what it takes for them to complete their contract

094or like you know negotiate the contracts that's one and second when you're Pres Ed the park scores you're comparing the Monro state or like our school district with the state averages is there any way that you can include the top performing school or like you know at least like in a ranking wise top five and then see where we are standing that makes a more in a competitive way what it takes or takes for us to progress further like in state average I know we are doing good now most of the times it is the same um for us to assess whether we are improved or not we should have some kind of a relative number with the top performing schools and yes and then I'm GNA talk about just mention about the contract so

095sure okay so um that that's an excellent point that you bring up the the state data the state test is the only data that we have that's a consistent a a constant to something that we can measure from school to school so we don't have all of the rest of the other school district's data yet I wish we did however the state does and they release something called the school performance report and in that school performance report sometimes known as the state's the school's report card they will compare the Monroe Township School District district against other school districts of similar similar socioeconomic status uh and S similar achievement status and that gives us a better understanding of how we do against some of these other schools um I we also look at things like the

096US News and World Report which I find to be a little bit more reliable in judging not only schools in the state but across the country but again the problem we run into is they they're always relying they're always using data that's a year or two old um but the school performance report comes out like feu January February and the data is from the previous school year but that will compare uh this district with other districts that are similar to us I mean will that be shared with the uh public or is it just only for school only for uh oh no it's it's it's shared with the public uh there are links on our website it's on the state department of Ed website um yeah we release it we want that to be transparent

097if anybody Googles um school report cards you'll go to that it'll take you to that website that has all the previous ones also okay and one last thing that somebody has already brought it up about the um high school and Elementary School last time was my first uh meeting attendance here and I was told that we ran into a situation where we don't have a choice but to go for a referendum for the middle school like you know we did not act much earlier and the influx of the new students has gone so high that it is unsafe for the students in the for the existing uh students in the middle school aren we getting into the same scenario for both high school as well as Elementary School like why do you want to wait

098for why isn't Board of Education or somebody picking up and trying to address it you know much ahead of time rather than just getting into the last scenario last stage like you know and where we don't have a choice but to just go for either like you know State make the decision or going by a referendum yeah and I and I understand that and you know we have to look at things in in their entirety so we look at the total scope of the project and through the redistricting that we did a couple years ago with the students we were able to balance the uh enrollment out a little easier in the elementary we hired additional staff uh and the same in the high school through some of the scheduling we've been able to look

099to say it's not the optimal situation but it's the best considering all the circumstances that the middle school is the highest priority we haven't forgotten the elementary and we certainly haven't forgotten the high school but we are able to keep the class sizes reasonable uh in those two areas um certainly it's still crowded uh we realize that but sometimes it's best to say okay we have these three issues let's focus on one get that one done be successful with it and let's move to the other projects I totally agreed on that part but you know what we wanted to see is uh if there is any progress can you share with us like you know on the next meeting for the both Elementary as well as the high school like know where we stand and

100what progress has been made uh in with regards to decision for the uh Improvement or maybe adding new schools whatever like the decision has been made uh we would like to get an update from the Board of Education in our next meeting for uh Elementary as well as high school to just not ignore them saying that you know we just our current prior is just Middle School only okay and at uh we we don't know that we will have a plan in place at the next board meeting but we will definitely be giving you updates as we go through the process and as I said before we are right now concentrating on getting the middle schol School referendum passed and as soon as we do that then we're and we're doing that right now also

101looking at the the needs of the the high school and the elementary school to get that going as soon as we can get the Middle School passed and um in regard to your question about the contract um it has always been the policy of the Board of Education that we never discuss the specifics of negotiations while we're in negotiations but I could say that we are meeting on a regular basis the talks are going I believe very well and um as long as we're continuing to talk that's that's a good thing talk with both sides thank you you're welcome anyone else he at this time we will close public forum and Dr kosak you can give your superintendence report thank you madam president I would like to invite the members of the board as well

102as all the members of the Monroe Township community to join with us on November 14th it's a Tuesday night November 14th for our technology Exposition this Tex Expo will feature several technology companies presenting their devices for consideration for our uh our high school and our onetoone technology integration participating students community and staff members and board members will have an opportunity to complete a survey at the end of their session to collect data on the suitability of the devices present at dney Expo for use by our high school students because we we're expecting a large number as in previous uh years we ask that you visit the district website to register it's right on the front of the district website it's very easy to do and you will receive an e ticket that you can either

103print out or use on your phone to it'll tell you which session so the first session will be at six o'clock and the second session may be 7:30 I think 7:30 uh you will receive an e ticket for admission to that and that's really helpful for the board as well because we try to avoid avoid having a quarum so if we can split it up if you would like to come but I would encourage you uh to come to that I think it'll be uh good and you get it at the end of the presentation you have a chance to complete a survey with your preferences for what you think would be the best device on the uh Personnel section of the board agenda you will see item a under Personnel um Miss Nancy debella

104is submitted her her retirement notice and I would just like to recognize Miss debella for her 27 years of service to the children in the community of Monroe Township and I certainly wish wish Mr Bella a wonderful retirement absolutely with that uh I would respectfully ask the board to approve the attached Personnel items letters a through letters aw oh move so second Mr braber Mr tiella are there any comments or questions for just one Dr KAC yes I have one under Middle School under at I think there's a misspelling of a name this just I think that should say Chris maybe what oh yeah yeah yeah okay ah thank you you're welome okay okay we will correct that Mr Mino the first um version of the uh agenda had uh and then we got it

105I I don't know what page because there's no page numbers but after Barkley Brook basic skills and that was the original I think it was originally A J there's there's list of names and clubs that I don't think are on the second version so I just want to know if we're voting on that as well it starts with Heidi LeBron acting for television Club is it on the second version where where AK oh I see it right there okay but the names are different are there are there additional names or they just moved around the the names for the um Club advisors should be the same uh unless there was a typo that was picked up in the first version maybe that's why it was revised well there's no there's a Sarah Cummings maker space

106Club on one right and not on the other so that's what I'm saying they're different okay yeah the when the when the agendas are revised um they're usually if it's a last minute addition or perhaps someone saw a mistake or an Omission they might have added that but the um I'm not sure which which version which the version the printed version from Friday the printed version from Friday and then there's a correction um because under under the Barkley Brook basic skills the the first version did not have all the other schools but it had um again but but the first one and the second one are not the same so are we omitting the first ver I mean if you want to take a look here I'll show you I only have the first version

107I don't have this the there was a at about 2:34 this afternoon we got a second okay so you have the original one I have the original and the second this is the one I just she's looking at Fridays they h b skills right it's very different it's very different you know what this these this isn't Barkley Brook basic skills these are clubs yeah no I know but when you have the clubs in the second version they're not the same this is very different than this right they're two different things I think what happened in this cuz I did have a conversation a couple days ago in the board dos the electronic version right when they're moving or adding things occasionally keyboarding they might have picked up and cut accidentally cut something so what you

108see is those list of clubs is mixed in with the basic skills and that was picked up and corrected and relocated back to where it should be okay and I get that part right but the names on the first version are not the same so are we voting on both the first version and the second version I just want to know who I'm voting for we're voting on yeah we're voting on the version that's on board dos yeah were both on dos because but the board dos is the most current and no I got that so what are we doing with this this is eliminated is my question are these eliminated yeah I think those were voted on last time okay I think that's why I think it must have been kept from last time

109okay that's all I wanted to know thank you technology it's a wonderful thing when it works a AJ AJ AJ AJ AJ AJ thank you any any other questions okay then we'll have a roll call Personnel items a through aw Mrs armeno yes Mr Braverman yes Mr Chella yes Mrs Deo yes Mrs Lang yes Mr ryack yes Mr rutsky yes Mrs K panovich yes madame board president Personnel items a through aw has passed board action board action item thank you madam president I would like to ask the board I would recommend to the board approval of items a through p in uh under board action oh moved Mr Braverman second second by Mrs Lang again comments or questions for Dr kosac yes I have I have two comment um questions under letter N where it

110says physical examination for the certified and non-certified yes I know at our policy meeting we caught that the district is is supposed to bear the cost of the physical exam I was just wondering if that was something that needed to go through Finance before we vote on it because we did we weren't remember that was yes that one came up as a surprise yes uh that's um I did talk to Mr Gorski and we do have the funds to cover that it is a mandate so we we will cover that as well as we we did uh look at the cost of the recommended the recommendation in that policy to require new employees or candidates for employment to undergo drug testing and that cost would also be borne uh would be covered by the school

111district okay and that's in this policy because I didn't see that yes part in when I was reading it yeah um I can pull it upk tell you where that is it's about it's about uh let's see the um the one two three fourth paragraph down of policy 3160 and policy 4160 is is a similar policy but gotcha it says candidates for employment who have received the conditional off for employment will be required to be tested gotcha there it is for for us of right control dangerous substances okay did you have a second question um no actually okay it answered thank you question Mr Mayo um this TS letter of agreement that we're that we are going can you explain how this benefits us is that the language Muse pallet yes it's the we we're

112testing something for them yeah this was the one this was taken to curriculum okay already um and Dr Roselle had shared this is for us to for our elll students our English language students that's what this is so for us to participate in this pilot yep um for our teacher our elll teacher to get trained okay um and to be able to use this it's technology where she'll actually be able to pull multiple resources for our elll students for all of their classes in the high school okay to help them now so it was that one that we went over in curriculum thank you Mr Ryback not a question just something I'd like to note if the board approves I think it deserves mention we have a student that was invited to go to Atlantic

113City to participate in a jazz choir uh that's a very not notable accomplishment and not to forget also uh the uh percussion Workshop Now High School is not item we're voting on I think these are two things that shows the talent of our of our students and the expertise of our staff and I was looking at that because I wanted to know what njmea stood for it's New Jersey music educators Association and the students that are going to sing I believe we recognized in the spring I think isn't that yeah I think they they actually are um they audition and if they they make the audition in the springtime then they perform in the fall so we did recognize the students but I do agree that they're doing an excellent job anyone else I did

114have one at policy meeting the last policy meeting we also said that we wanted our student teachers to have The Substitute certificate so on this list of board approval they all have the county super um County substitute certificates yeah well we didn't change the policy because that's what the policy did but but Dr Ali has been in contact with the colleges all the colleges from where we draw our student teachers and let them know that that is a requirement that all of our um substit or our student teachers these so they don't have so they we don't know who has it and who doesn't no and all all of the student teachers that we currently have in our building do not have a substitute certification except for one okay but however I have reached out

115to all of the colleges and I've notified them of the change um so as we but these teachers were already placed okay in our districts and I wouldn't want to tell a student teacher that you just lost your placement two weeks before it started yes um so I will but they they've all been notified so from this point forward they will all be have their substitute certification except the pro part of the problem was that that policy actually was in place but it wasn't followed or Endo or enforced so I understand the grandfathering of the situation but that's a problem if we have policies that are not being enforced so what we do going forward I think the board expects that everyone is certified prop properly okay I also have if Mr um on C

116the recommended approval is submitted for field trips um I would just ask maybe the curriculum committee and also for future field trips that maybe we can take some of our students to the Constitution Center in Philadelphia we do we Okay it hasn't been on it's a May field trip and it's fifth grade okay I think it's extraordinary maybe we can expand it to other students because I think there's a lot going on there we do be uh it's part of their curriculum good I think that's an excellent idea and um Can someone explain on L uh the program pride in public education what that entails sure you want to that was the program that I mentioned at the beginning um having the students come it's the the reason that these two programs are on here

117is because the mtea is receiving grants for both of these programs from njaa and that that's the money that will be used for this so it's at no cost to the district um but I wanted to make sure that the board was aware that these programs were happening and that mtea would be using the money from njaa for these speciically and pride is the one where um it has to do with bringing uh our schools into the community so having our students come and present at a board meeting having our teachers um and our mtaa available at back to school nights for parents that type of thing helping with the referendum um and fast is a grant program for teachers okay how much do we have a number that goes along with that I do

118not have that number CU that's the mtaa number okay thank you anyone else okay roll call Mr Gorski Mrs armeno yes Mr bra Mr cherella yes Mrs Deo yes but I am voting no on policy 2622 so noted thank you and voting no I'm not done and voting no on policy 5460 are you done ma'am I am done thank you so noted Mrs Lang no on policy 2622 and policy 5460 and yes on the rest thank you Mr Ryback yes Mr rutsky yes Mrs K panowich yes madam board president board action items a through P has passed okay we will go to the business administrator's report Madame board president and members of the Monro Township Board of Education it is recommended that board action items a through L be approved by consent roll call move

119second Mr Chella Mr Ryback are there any questions for Mr Gorski one quick one on the memorandum for submitted signatories signatories uh authorized signatories um yeah in the package was just a list is that considered the memorandum or is there another yes there that was letter I there's a list those those are all of the board authorized signature um employees who have signing Authority on checkbooks um there are board accounts and there are numerous Student Activity accounts there's one at every school uh where the signature on those accounts would generally be the Principal or uh a supervisor or advisor type position but there's no there's no additional document memor I mean this to me was just a list so I guess it's a memorandum it's it's a list of names and uh the school or

120the account okay yep thank you anyone else okay we'll have a roll call Mrs armeno yes Mr braver yes Mr Chella yes Mrs Deo yes Mrs Lang yes Mr ryack yes Mr rutsky yes Mrs Kap Pano Madame board president motion passes unanimously that concludes my report thank you thank you uh board president's report okay as most of you know at the September Board of Education meeting the board passed a resolution to go out for a referendum on a new thousand seat Middle School on the corner of Applegarth Road and cranberry Station Road the steering committee who has been meeting very regularly for the last two years met yesterday along with a representative of interactive dialogue who will be working with us to get the correct information out about the referendum to all residents of Monroe

121starting with the community October Fest this coming Saturday we will be at events throughout the district and throughout the community with a a tabletop presentation a two-page fast fact sheet and voter registrations forms we'd like to make sure that we get as many people registered to vote as possible and we'll have some information you can talk to us ask us questions we are working on a number of different ways to reach out to the community so that everybody gets the correct information and we reach hopefully everybody uh information will be sent home through the mail you can get information by attending Board of Education meetings and Board of Ed presentations throughout the community information will be posted on the district website we'll have newspaper coverage the Falcon the Falcon flyer Channel 28 if you have

122a group or an organization or a neighborhood get together and would like us to attend to have a small gathering and and um just get a more intimate setting for questions and answers you can call the district office and request a presentation and we will very gladly be be able to want to come out if invited and have discussions with our community members lastly we are working on a Q&A document that we feel will be able to answer the voters questions about this referendum when the document is finalized we will put it on the website and we'll also have copies available for the public you can always email us at referendum monroe. k2. nj. us with questions about the referendum and all questions will be answered as quickly as possible and if needed we be

123used to update the Q&A document it is our hope to be able to reach all the residents of the community with accurate and up-to-date information we are also looking for volunteers to help us get that information out so if you're available and would like to help us please please contact the board office is there anything else you think um should be noted in that uh no Madam president I think that was pretty comprehensive um the we will update our website shortly with all that information also so the people will be able to go to our website and um have links and and information on there okay thank you uh Other Board of Education business I have something oh Mrs slang yes I do okay me you know that side always goes first I'll let Patty

124have her her okay on October 2nd our board president Kathy konoz welcomed her first grandchild Ethan and he is absolutely stunning he was 7 pounds 2 ounces and we just want to congratulate you and anybody who wants to see pictures Kathy will show you pictures of the so congratulations Kathy thank you Patty make me feel old now you're not alone i'me okay I know with older ones to miss de Mayo yes um I went to the State Board of Ed meeting on October I don't know what October 4th and um this is one of my favorite board of ed meetings because um it really it's honoring the teach teacher of the year of New Jersey and it really shows the great work that is being done by teachers across the state um the teacher of

125the year who won this year was Amy Anderson teacher of American sign language in Ocean City High School and um she's been teaching for 21 years she loves American Sign Language and she's passing that love on to her students um and it was just a really nice presentation so I congratulate her on her her win thank you anyone else Mr cherel I have a I have a couple things so our our committee for fair funding delivered the letter that was approved here at the last meeting to uh Senator Greenstein uh Wayne D'Angelo and Dan Benson's office 11 days ago on Saturday um they weren't there obviously not a lot of uh not a lot going on there on on a weekend I guess but but we were there and uh so we read the letter

126uh and then we delivered it to their office I just want to I just want to remind everyone that Election Day is coming up every one of our legislators including the governor is up for re-election they promised us money they gave us hardly anything after all the fighting that we did all the all the going to Trenton all the things over the prior years you know with the developing legislation and uh uh prior board members fighting for funding and and uh doing writing legislation with Michael Gorski and uh after all that they gave us less than $500,000 and they came and said well this is a down payment on the future you know this is we're going to promise you more it's really I think is a down payment on them getting reelected because in

127my opinion when the education Law Center gets involved after the election and starts to threaten to sue them and uh make noise they're going to all back down and we're not going to get any other funding so I think it's important that we weigh that going into November 7th and let them know what we think about the the the funding because in my opinion if they wanted to get us funding they would have done it before now and now that all of a sudden it's everything becomes tenuous uh elections are hanging in the balance their Futures are hanging in the balance now they're making promises that I don't think they can keep after November that's just my opinion now uh well thank you Mr Klein hello and there Mr Klein there's a a board member

128that has fought for uh for for funding for years and uh requested us s you know requested that this board Sue and uh I think that I just think that we need to we need to keep fighting but I want to I just want to bring up something else if I may um can you tell me can anyone tell me the percentage of um Indian students that are currently in our schools from what I understood it was it it was 30% or yeah I thought it was a third 30 somewhere between 30 and 40% I don't have the exact percentage but I would what I would like to recommend and I don't know if I'd need to make a motion but I would like for us to pursue it as a board of ed is

129that we have now with 30% of our children being of Indian descent Indian Americans um that we should be looking at making sure that today is is the volley it starts the volley so happy happy deali but I also think that uh we need to start looking at maybe allocating a holiday that would that would allow 30% of our kids to be recognized for who they are I'm not saying to segregate and things like that but we celebrate Christian holidays and Jewish holidays and things like that and I just think it it's important uh to also recognize those children 30% of our population so I'd like to see us either either earmark a holiday for them uh or do something that would allow us to to do that shuffle holidays or something uh it just

130so happens that our board meeting fell on the valley so I thought it was a good time to bring that up but I also think that uh with you know tomorrow is also a day off for the kids and that it would be easy for us to maybe recognize a sizable portion of our population and growing who has been very supportive of the educational system here and very supportive of us in a lot of cases and uh and and are contributing 30% of of their children to our population comment sure Dr K well miss Lang I was just gonna say I and Ken I'm glad you brought that up because that was something that during the past election we talked to parents about and I was just going to say I remember when the calendar

131came out I called Dr alvik and I said to her they have dwali Dali off and she said yes that it was B so I want Dr alvic to say that they planned that inservice day specifically so that we were meeting the requirements of the 180 school days meeting the requirements of the inservice and that we were able to at this time but I think we should do more I really do and I appreciate that I do I think we need to do that in a way where it's earmarked like we do Christmas or like we do other holidays just I mean uh and to respect both your points uh and I agree with what you're saying uh we have had conversations with several members of um of our Asian Indian or Indian Community and

132they have expressed that to us that dwali would be uh a day to be recognized and in the past couple years by the way that the calendar fell thew happened land on either a weekend or uh maybe Veterans Day one year so this year when Dr a came to me with the calender that was a discussion and uh and I agree with Miss Lang on that that that is a consideration um it's hard to balance all the holidays while still meeting all the requirements but we're doing what we can and we do have conversations um with uh members of all all sections of our community but certainly our Indian Community and they you're absolutely right they are very supportive um of the educational system here in Monroe and as with all of our constituents we

133want to uh respect what you know they consider important and work with them absolutely yeah thank you Mr chera anyone else okay seeing no one we will open up public forum again anyone wishing to speak please come to the microphone state your name and address and Mr Gorski is not here for the four minute time so first of all I would like to congratulate Miss kapovich of becoming a grandmother because that's the best anyway the reason why I'm speaking is I did send most of you a letter about the four football players now this pertains to O which are your new policies and had the NFL acted when compan did the kneel down I am a Vietnam er a veteran my father and most of your fathers and grandfathers served during World War II and

134Korea and what do we fight for for our flag and our country and before somebody comes up and says well they have their first amendment rights the NBA the Basketball Association has a rule that all players must stand up rightand over the heart and pay respect what's happened by the NFL not acting right away and shutting it down allowing it to happen it's now trickling down to the high schools there was an article in the paper on a weekend a girl soccer team a high school soccer team refuses to stand I take offense to that the veterans take offense to that and most Americans take offense to that what I ask is uh I don't know whether Mr Mino is still on the policy committee but whoever is in charge of the policy committee there

135has to be a policy that they must stand order they off the team and that's what the Kansas City chief pher did he made a statement they will all stand in respect they don't have to they don't have to pledge they don't have to say a word this country and its residents deserve respect and I would hope that the next time you come up with a new policy that you do come up with a policy for this for all of the players thank you very much for all your work thank you Mr Klein prash pup 33 d Drive um yesterday I was in high school and I really appreciate the Innovation and Entrepreneurship groups presented I really looked at you know I got the copy of the document 3 days in advance the students were

136very professional they had Vision the concept market analysis competitors and projection it was well written well presented so I first of all Dr Ash who is volunteering on that club I appreciate him but I also appreciate Dr kak for suing the seeds what the future of our school should be it is not just the studies and all but thinking they should be good in sports they should think well they should study well so I do appreciate Dr kak the principal vice principal and the two teachers and all the students so that is my first comment the second comment is fair funding for the school I take a deep breath here we have to be strategic it is it is the governor of New Jersey today it should be our Target because he was the one

137who froze the formula and we didn't get Fair funding for last 8 years it is not the senators or the assembly men whenever they put the line item he objects to it so I I my it is just not going on the Facebook and politicizing this we don't want to politicize anything our main goal is nonpartisan way have a strategy so we get a fair funding so I want I'm ready to help the strategy and planning should be there the most important three peoples in our New Jersey that is a governor speaker and president of the sen it so we have to have Coalition with the districts which are impacted and we should build a strategy I'm ready to help the team and work on it and last item president Trump is trying to divide

138our country it is the he was the one who started this NFL issue and then it is trickling down okay you you write a policy which impacts the First Amendment be ready for the lawsuits and I don't want the Board of Education or our school paying money to fight the lawsuits thank you very much thank you anyone else from the public wishing to speak okay seeing no one we will close the public forum and go to the closed session resolution be it resolved that the Board of Education of the township of Monroe hereby moves to go into Clos session in accordance with the Sunshine Law chapter chapter 231 of the public laws of 1975 njsa 10 colum 4-6 through 10 colum 4-21 to discuss the following subjects harassment intimidation and bullying mtea negoti negotiations update

139and the Personnel matter level three grievance the legal advice has been taken off the agenda following Clos session action may be taken the discussion conducted in closed session can be discussed to the public at such time as the need for confidentiality no longer exists second Ryback Mr Chella all in favor I I opposed okay then at this time we will move into close session half hour half hour we should be there about a half hour okay at this time the board will come back into public session and I believe I have two resolutions to read the first one it is recommended that the Board of Education approve the suspension with pay of employee number 1598 from October 19 2017 through October 20th 2017 the superintendent and the business administrator board secretary are hereby authorized and

140directed to take all steps necessary to implement this action by the board of education so moved Miss armino Miss Lang any comments or questions roll call Mrs armeno yes Mr tiella yes Mrs Deo yes Mrs Lang yes Mr Ryback yes Mr rutsky yes Mrs kapano yes mam board president motion passes unanimously thank you it is recommended that the Board of Education hereby denies the level three grievance regarding employee number 17 28 dated September 8th 2017 the superintendent of schools and the board's business administ business administrator board secretary are authorized to take all necessary steps to implement this action of the Board of Education Mr Rybeck patty patty Mrs Lang any comments or questions okay roll call Mrs armeno yes Mr cherella yes Mrs Deo yes Mrs Lang yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr rutsky yes PA

141P yes Madam board president motion passes unanimous okay at this time we will go to public forum I'm not sure but if there's anybody here that would like to speak please come to the microphone okay seeing no one our next schedule Board of Education meeting is November 15 2017 7:00 p.m. at the Monroe Township High School motion to adjourn Jour second Mr Chella Mr Ryback all in favor I oppos and meeting is adjourned

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.