CorpusRecord 132994

Monroe Township Board of Education 12.13.17 Regular Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Monroe Township School District
Date
2025-02-12
Location
Middlesex County, NJ
Material
Transcript
Extent
17,412 words · about 97 min
Collected
2026-06-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001just sing a holiday song maybe that would work too good evening everyone good evening thank you P you're welcome the meeting of the Monroe Township Board of Education will come to order please stand as our student board member leads us in the Pledge of Allegiance I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible for liberty justice for all thank you may we have a roll call Mr Gorski certainly Mrs armeno yes here Mr [Music] Braverman Mr Mr cherella here Mrs Deo here Mrs Lang here Mrs Corino Mr Rybeck here Mr Russo Mr rutsky Mrs kapano here Madame board president you have a quarum present this evening in accordance with the provisions of the New Jersey open public meetings law

002the Monroe Township Board of Education has caused notice of this meeting to be published by having the date time and place thereof posted December 8th 2017 at all schools the home News Tribune cranberry press and filed with the clerk of the municipality thank you at this time we will go to number five in the agenda approval of the minutes for the public Board of Education meeting of November 2017 need a motion in a second moved by Mr Ryback second second by Mr de Mayo are there any additions or corrections to the minutes okay seeing none all in favor I opposed abstentions Mr tiella is abstaining and refusal none the approval of the minutes for the closed session meeting of November 15 2017 Mr Ryback second Mr Mayo again any additions or corrections to the minutes

003Mr arm Mino yes uh Madam president I submitted earlier today my revisions to those minutes uh I feel that the current minutes are not sufficient to explain what occurred in the Clos session I am not going to burden the public with the comments however I will resubmit them and I would like to be added to the to the written record I will say that um your request was given to the our board attorney and um we did revise the minutes not not sufficiently to um provide uh the uh comprehensible like if if the public wanted to read them they it was they were not comprehensible enough for the public to understand what the proceedings were I just I'm just making that statement I'm I'm going to say that there's my copy of them if you

004don't want to include them people don't want to vote for them that's fine but my copy will be in the administration office and uh should be made a public record okay thank you uh all in favor of any other comments or questions seeing n all in favor I opposed M Mino opposes yep abstentions Mr tiella No recusals so at this time we number six on the agenda we have a presentation continuing with the mtea pride Grant tonight we are happy to have a presentation from milake school and they will present their Veterans Day project so the mtea pride Grant will be the mil Lake students in Mrs papandrea and Miss Pandy's class um every year this class writes letters to the American Legion Post 924 in the United States Southern command located in Miami Florida

005in addition to writing letters to the veterans this year the students made a movie sharing their gratitude to the veterans for their service to the United States of America so they are going to share that movie with you tonight um also with the Board of Education members I've shared with you the thank you note that the students rece received from the American Legion it's on the table in front of you so I will turn it over to Mrs magnoli it's a beautiful thing when we could combine language arts social studies and civic duty um to see what our first grade students did for the veterans was absolutely beautiful they were inspired by reading a Scholastic News Article and from there they were prompted to do something special for veterans um I was be remiss if

006I didn't thank Miss pep Andrea and Mrs Pandi if they could just come on out because they were the inspiration and that is true teaching when you inspire students to do something really special and beautiful um some of the really awesome things that I just want to share with everyone is number one they've been in contact with the Hampton Bay American Legion number 924 they've been in contact with the United States Southern command they've written holiday cards for veterans at the Walter Reed hospital and we actually we just found out today we are going to have a chief Navy Commander coming to our school in a token of their gratitude for what our students did so again I that's wonderful I'm a lucky principal I have amazing teachers I have amazing students thank you to

007the families um for supporting this and at this point this is about the students and my teacher so I'm going to hand it over to them thank you so much [Applause] kids come pictures to the Amic and for day please enjoy our video [Applause] [Music] of the veterans we are free to play because of the veterans we are free to go to school because of the veterans we are free to sing because of the veterans we are free to vote because of the veterans we are free to celebrate because of the veterans we are free to travel each Today We Live in Freedom and our memory must not F the reason for this Freedom comes from sacrifice made so we celebrate our veterans on the 11th of November we thank them for their courage and

008pledge always to remember veterans are white men and women who are still alive today we thank them for their servants and their Christ to chose to pray we are thankful to our veterans for Freedom dear veteran thank you for S saving our country from bad people your friend me dear veterans thank you for protecting our country your friend Morgan thank dear veterans thank you for taking care of our country thank you for saving our [Music] country your friend Justin dear veterans thank you for all the help and rescues we are so proud of you good job for saving us your friend Joseph Sao dear veterans thank you for all the hard work your friend Donnie dear veteran thank you for helping us when we are veteran okay you friend the veteran thank you for helping

009my friends and thank you for helping our country and thank you for keeping us safe your friend James dear veterans thank you for protecting your friend AR dear veteran thank you for keeping the USA safe your friend M dear veterans thank you I thank you Veterans for helping and helping us and other people I love you veterans I love your work your friend Max dear veterans thank you for keeping our country safe you are the best veterans we can have in the world your friend Karina thank you for protecting our country thank you for also saving people that are hurt your friend Marita dear re thank you for saving our country and you are awesome your friend James dear every thank you for protecting the USA and protecting us and giving up your family your

010friend Danielle dear veteran Thank You For Fighting For Work country thank you thank you you very much veterans your friend mckenzy dear veterans thank you you you for protecting our country and making freedom and keeping our country safe your friend jnon dear veterans thank you for saving us and our country I am your friend I know that you care for us dear veterans thank you for keeping us safe from the bad people you I think you guys have have the best job and the best job for the country your friend Breza dear veterans thank you for keeping us safe thank you for keeping our country your friend AJ dear friends thank you for make free making Freedom thank you for keep keeping our country safe thank you for keeping the USA safe you are the

011best your friend Samantha dear veterans thank you for protecting our country your friend xav dear vs thank you for giving freedom to us thank you for doing a important job your friend Ally dear veteran thank you for saving our country from bad people I want to be a veter when I am older I love you veterans I want to see a vet one day your friend Jake when I lay my head down every night and to sleep in peace [Music] I standing on your keep to [Applause] o the the BL you oh thank you and brave and strong to those who Ser so G we sing this grateful [Music] song [Music] and you the W each morning and [Music] that your great sacri sing than you thank you and brave and strong he sing this

012grateful song you [Music] [Applause] you and this grateful song Happy [Applause] [Music] [Applause] in the audience please [Applause] stand Mets what's his name thank you [Applause] well that was awesome and I'm sure that the veterans were very appreciative of receiving all your letters and I'm sure you made their day you brightened up their day a little bit more thank you very much for being here this evening okay so at this time at this time we will be having a presentation of the monio Education Foundation grants and when we we have with us this evening Mr Todd Edelman who is president of the mono Ed Foundation [Applause] welcome it's a hard act to follow the Monro Education Foundation has been around for many years uh every year we try to give out grants this year we

013are giving out 12 grants in the tune of $ 16,45 5.94 um we in 2018 are going to try to ramp up our fundraising efforts if you know anybody well first the teachers definitely keep you know next year a hand in Grants we love reading through them they're creative they're awesome uh if you know need a parent anyone that would be willing to be involved with us uh help us out fundraising and just ideas to bring to the table uh so we can make these possible for years to come the first grant we are giving out is the 2018 poetry slam and that is going to Joan Kofi help [Applause] okay uh next up we have escape room in the classroom Christopher [Applause] Sidler next poetry out loud residency Andrea feminella and Michelle next up

014we have penguins on Parade we have Lisa McHugh Michelle giaquinto Sarah Richards Lauren deiro and Christy Brown and Melissa [Applause] Cortino next up we have Rock Garden by Britney Rus rusa and Tina Pine [Applause] bringing the composer's vision to life yel Snider and Rebecca Palmer [Applause] the next one I want to be a part of it's carpool history Nicole dorenzo Benjamin mvy Christopher seidler and Christy V vaki [Applause] next we have full steam ahead creating a sustained a culture of thinkers and makers Aaron Mahoney and Nicole [Applause] madora differentiating our learning through F flexibility Kristen Miller [Applause] next we have maker space in action it's the oak tree School maker space committee I don't know who's oh Danielle Pugi Benjamin Howard Howard and John gleon Stephanie chin Maggie padera Alysa Veron Brianna kerer that's congratulations

015thank you thank [Applause] you next we have a book a day and digital storytelling Stacy lav Susan pace and Don [Applause] graciano last we have the Revolutionary War traveling trunk program and that's Rika Patel [Applause] I'm holding a check uh for all the grants the 6,455 N4 that's going to the board again if anyone's interested please get in touch with me my name's Todd Edelman I'll be here for the rest of the meeting uh would love to have you guys help us out with the MEF thank [Applause] you thank you very much I know um what a great job the monio foundation does for our students and like Mr Edelman said we can use a lot more help there's um only a a few people left on the MEF and it's been uh we've had

016a little Hiatus time but we want to get back to working and doing uh the great things for our kids in order to do that we need to do some fundraising and to do some fundraising we need some help so anybody who wishes to help um I'm here Mr edelman's here you can reach the I think we still have a a Facebook page or website or something that that has the information on it so um please reach out to us thank you at this time we will go to um the presentation of the 2016 2017 comprehensive annual financial report Mr Gorski thanks thanks um tonight's presentation is going to be by Mr Jerry stankowitz partner in the CPA firm of Samuel Klein company thank you Michael see as the president said this is the uh

017presentation on the audit for the fiscal year June 30th 2017 um the audit is an is an annual event required by Statute the audit is conducted in accordance with the auditing standards established by the American Institute of CPA generally accepted auditing standards governmental Accounting Standards uh and general accounting office and as well as the uh Office of Financial regulation in the Department of Education so we have six or seven five or six different entities that we sort of answer to and they all try to blend in their uh requirements of us to perform the audit they're all pretty much the same in terms of uh their scope and in what they're trying to accomplish uh but the the audit process that we go through um we like to think of it as a year- round

018relationship with the board business office um you know we start in actually November for the year that we're in we we already have audited the Assa and the free and reduced applications going into the year that we're in so the year that we're discussing right now we we had done that work back in November and December of last year so we then uh come back in in July and look at the minutes we then start auditing the Student Activity funds we start preparing our samples and start formulating our game plan for the audit um again the process is is uh cumbersome in terms of uh trying to achieve what we're trying to do and that is to get a good feeling uh about how the recordkeeping was done for the year and I will give

019you some examples when we we run samples random samples very simple sampling statistical um and we sample for example payroll transactions we run a sample throughout the year we also look at other transactions involving payroll throughout the year here um we verify that the gross pay is correct that the net pay is correct that the proper withholdings are are done and that those withholdings are remitted properly to the various agencies most especially the IRS and the state of New Jersey so um that's all done timely um and accurately we might say uh we also also do this too we not only do the sample but we also make sure we do a side sample that a your chief executive officer and your Chief Financial Officer your payroll people and all key financial people are paid

020properly as well and that they didn't get overpaid um that worked out very nicely so there was no no problems there the other part of the sample that we do is we test your expenditures other expenditures health benefits electric bills various other expenditures again on a random basis to start with and then we start looking at um and verifying other expenditures as well above certain dollar levels below certain dollar levels and here's what we look for and i' I've given this speech before and it took me several years to narrow down exactly what's important and here is the thing with expenditures a in this District they're all properly documented B they're coded correctly with respect to the correct budget account state of New Jersey and the governmental accounting St has a mandatory chart of accounts

021that you're required to follow and that's followed they're cut off properly with respect the fiscal year so bills that start coming in in May and June that get paid in July and August they're properly cut off with respect to the fiscal year they relate to June 30th or prior they're charged there although they might not be paid they're set up as accounts payable okay so that the cut off is proper and then because it's a sizable District we spent a little bit of extra time looking at your compliance with the public school contracts law okay and we have found that to be and otherwise known as the bid law so we found that to be in complete compliance and it's because of the fact that you have the proper human infrastructure set up within the

022uh within the office that that you know there people are able to flag a problem down before it occurs or uh make sure that the documentation for uh the contracts law is proper in place before you authorize the purchase because once you authorize the purchase and the goods are delivered it's a little late so we didn't have any of those problems so that was good and we also do it in two ways we do it based on your quote threshold and at the higher level based on the bid threshold it helps when you have a person and people like a Jerry tag who knows the bid law cold it helps when your accounting records are um overseen and commandeered by Aura Allen who's a CPA with many years experience um they make our life a

023lot easier because we we rely that that as good as they are we know that they know what they're doing so when we go in to do the audit we get a comfort level you know we still do our testing but we have a good Comfort level that they're knowledgeable which is key in an audit in in this day and age we also look at revenues okay obviously your your tax levy I mean that that's easy to audit uh your state aid is easy to audit but we look at revenues as well in your um Enterprise funds which is the Food Service fund the Falcon care and then the uh the child care initiative so we checked those out and that that system has evolved over the last few years we spent some time extra

024time with the the person who's in charge of it and she's quite competent and the records were quite wellmaintained she had all the answers um and we were comfortable that what was happening with within her little software area there was is working properly with respect to the revenues um food service is another big area that you have um we have permission to look at your service vendors records they leave them at the municipal I'm sorry at the board office for us we look at their payroll we look at their receipts we also do a verification of all the meal claims okay and the meal claims are used for our uh reimbursement that we put in for that we get from the government uh for lunch and and for breakfast where applicable so yeah we we

025do look at that but the most important thing we do is when we get the general ledger and this underlying records um the expression and it will last forever is Cash is King okay the records as presented are in agreement with the bank reconciliations as presented that really gives us a good starting point for the audit cuz we know what we're looking at is is reconciled Okay so we've had and always have had here good results with those Bank reconciliations a lot has to do with again the boards giving the business office and the administration the ability to build the proper for a lack of better human infrastructure Personnel within that business office okay so that worked out very nice so as a result we had all good audit results um the system is set

026up here very very well and um as a result of that we end up with um an unmodified audit opinion which means otherwise known as in the old days a clean opinion or an unqualified opinion basically what it is is that the records get presented to us by management okay our responsibility is to audit them and to give to the board an opinion so our opinion is that it is that really it's it's weird how they do it it it's modified opinion but the wording says they present fairly okay so the records are a and they don't mean Fair as in good poor excellent fair and fairly they mean is is a it's a proper representation of the records our job is really to verify the numbers as presented by the board uh business office

027and like I said uh it it helps I I want to give credit to uh people within the office that we work in the support staff um and Laura Allen and you know they they've made the whole process go a lot smother it helps when you have someone who was an auditor working inside your department your business because they know what we go through and they know what to give and what how to react and how to help move things along and how to present it properly so that it everything meets the proper audit tests uh so that that that is a big help but that's a year round process it's an everyday process um you know I gave a speech to a group a couple weeks ago about how like everything you do could

028be subject to audit so don't get complacent and think that oh I I I'll miss the audit Lottery well we don't have we don't have that worry here because everything is reviewed everything is heads up at least by time we get it so and that's important too that the system here is set up so that if there is a boooo it can be fixed or it can be caught before it becomes a problem and like I said when I started if if things are being purchased without purchase orders then that's a problem but that is not a problem here so in the end uh there's there's two documents that we issue um and I think just for the record we had a an extensive exit conference with management uh prior to issuing the audit and

029then about a week and a half ago we had a rather long and involved uh meeting with the members of the finance committee who were there that night to discuss the audit uh at length and to troubleshoot any any any concerns or questions they had so in the end we issued two documents the first document the thicker of the two primarily is all information that's given to us by the board okay we we take all the different computer runs merge them into report format okay and basically they're your they're your numbers our only job with in this document is to give an opinion and like like I said that opinion is that the records present fairly okay now I know Michael and Dr kak uh they spend time preparing certain parts of this audit uh

030this this cfra I think and it's critical as you're moving into an era where there's potential for financing and believe it not someone will read this document okay someone at standard and pores or moody or they will read and they will question believe me they they they will and um it's important that all this information be lined up properly so we we appreciate Mike's efforts and trying to get us the correct documentation there's a lot of statistical information in here some of which we of which we author others were provided by for example the CFO of the town the CFO of the county um and various other authoritative sources all gets merged into the back section of this document all the information in the middle though is all information that available internally which we just

031translate into report format there's also information here about it's called the notes to financial statement which is information about the how you're supposed to be operating your accounting U what what proper accounting procedures you're supposed to follow this more boilerplate and it's probably every Board of Ed in the country that's done under gby like we are it's it's all all that information is in here it just talks about you know the procedures that you follow in terms of how you present things you know what which fund is which what's a special Revenue fund what's a Debt Service fund a capital projects fund Enterprise fund so all that information is contained in this document so the other document is actually my representation uh to the board um about the operation of the business office and prior

032to going through this with you I explained uh how we got involved and get involved in the Departments and doing our various testing now if we didn't have good results okay this this document would contain comments that would indicate that there was a procedural problem or some other problem we don't have that okay U so in this document it really is information that the department of Ed requires that we put in there but every now and then if there is a problem we required to disclose we don't have that problem here um and as a result there are no audit recommendations that require a plan of action by the board if there were and you know we get in in the summertime M mid August through the end of September if there were if there

033were a problem it would be in here however it knowing the operation here it would have already been implemented you know you don't we tell clients don't if we find something don't wait till we go to the board to talk about it fix it right away cuz the a fair question from a board member is well are we going to fix this and sometimes Thea not not this one or the prior one they don't they wait till it it becomes a problem you can't do that you got to address it immediately and fix it again we didn't have that okay but like I said if we did we we we would make sure that it was in process uh before we came here this evening so there's two documents and I know there's a piece

034that Mike Gorski prepares that is sort of like a almost a highlight film or just information about the district that is over and above what we do but it's it's in it's required to be here it's an opportunity for the district actually to toot its horn about operations and or even test scores I have other places where they they discuss you know I mean they discuss a lot about the test scores of their kids and the progress of their kids well that's why we're here you know obviously so that that's important to be in here so um if there's any specific questions yes there there and there's actually I don't know why they do it the Lords of the profession they have two sections where they discuss it I I don't know why but yes

035Michelle that starts at page one okay and then again it's rather extensive and it's okay that it be that way um again someone in the next six months most likely will be reviewing this document for real in terms of your creditworthiness which I don't think is going to be a problem but um that information is in there so the only thing in the bigger of the two docs that belongs to us is Pages 10 11 and 12 and that's the independent auditor report we have the honor of having our secretaries type it but it's really all your District's information and like I said we render an opinion and that's what we're hired to do is give an opinion in accordance with the statute and the Professional Standards so I know I want to thank the

036support staff most especially um they want to do a good job they're interested in feedback uh and that's that's good that's good for the district too so Michael thank you Mr Switz now it was a particularly difficult year we went through three bookkeepers during the year we had two different payroll service providers we had two payroll supervisors and for three months we had no payroll supervisor and all the supervision of payroll had to be performed by Laur Allen and myself um that's but we had you know great success as Jerry said and it's a PR moment Falcon care has now $1.1 million of retained earnings in two years that's a proprietary fund that we designed we created the business plan and it's the Envy of many school districts now in January it's anticipated that the

037board is going to commit $600,000 of that retain earnings to offset trailer costs and reduce taxes and we're very proud of that Surplus is in line with the previous year that's very difficult to maintain we go to war every year with Horizon Blue Cross Blue Shield with the budget to keep premiums down and this year is no different not only were we audited by Samuel kleining company which is required by Statute but this year we are also audited by idea individuals with disabilities Education Act semi Grant reporting and the Child Nutrition program and all the results are the same and that evidence that was provided from all the audience uh all the Auditors is that the financial statement and financial disclosures that come out of the business office are relevant and reliable and that is

038especially important as we embark on a referendum for a new school you know we've proven to the taxpayers that we use your your funds very preciously and efficiently and um for full transparency I would encourage the public to visit the website tomorrow once these documents are hopefully uh accepted by the board where you could you could um bre through the comprehensive annual financial report and the auditor um management opinion report and there is a plethora of good information about The District in this comprehensive annual Financial uh report everything from the unemployment rate in Monroe Township to ratables to per pupil spending to enrollment growth over over the the last decade you can find a great deal of information in here Beyond um numbers and uh I would especially like to thank Laura Allen uh Laura

039is the best accountant that I've ever worked with in my career I'm very fortunate that the board um encouraged her to join our staff and and she's a a great asset to this District in many different departments many many different ways and I'd like to thank Dr kak and the board of education for all your support and um you know we look forward to the next steps now which is the March referendum and and um asking the tax payers to again ante up for new schools that we've provided enough evidence that are desperately needed thank you okay Mr Mayo I believe you have a resolution read yes I move that the members of the Monroe Township Board of Education accept and approve the comprehensive annual financial report and the auditor management report on administrative findings

040Financial compliance performance and hereby approve approve and authorize the submission of the required corrective action plan to the county office indicating that there are no recommendations for the fiscal year ending June 30th 2017 is SAR a second second by Mr Ryback is there any comments or questions for Mr Gorski Mr stankowitz I just have a a quick question really unrelated to the the entire um Pro books here and thank you for your efficiency but I just have a question about bid threshold maybe you could just enlighten me uh our current bid threshold is 36,000 is that correct Madam and yeah you may be um with the qualified purchasing agent certification which which uh I have it's $40,000 for a bid threshold that means if I wanted to buy any one item um $40,000 or more

041uh except for those that are exempt that would have to go out the public bid and that's to serve the interest of the taxpayers to make sure we're buying everything efficiently and no favoritism in vendors okay and um that's for purchasing how does that also include contracts that we get enter into all all contracts except uh professional service contracts where you have a professional who was issued a license by the state of New Jersey those are exempt from bidding Okay C go ahead and also so there's other items available that you don't have to bid that are available through uh the state contract method it's it's already bid and negotiated by the Department of Treasury also there are these they're springing up all over the state now these purchasing co-ops with a bunch of school

042districts uh I think the most active one is the Ed Services Commission of New Jersey I believe so it's very difficult and I we talked about it's it's very difficult to violate the bid law in this day and age there's so much help out there okay and the other thing about the 40,000 threshold is it also ratchets up your quote threshold okay just explain that a little okay the difference is well bids are formal documents they are released to the public to the industry where and they are opened in a sealed um environment where you know it's secretive until it's opened okay and that is 40,000 if you have a qpa which is say what that means qpa qualified purchasing agent thank okay the the state enacted it about 10 or 15 years ago to

043take the administrative burden off of the towns because in all honesty although a lot of people think and I think it is a lot a lot like 25,000 is a lot of money but in some places it's not and the administrative burden of writing specs for a $25,000 item it might take somebody three days it it might not be worth it so but so that after 40,000 you have to get bids right they have to be authorized to go to bid then you have to set a date where you're going to receive the bids and I believe the minimum date that you you need to have it advertised out there for 10 days okay other places choose more for example if you're going to build a school you're not going to go 10 days you're

044probably going to go 60 days or 90 so you know um that's what the bid is all about and you're somewhat obligated to go to the lowest bidder okay unless you can prove otherwise that they may be there may be a defect in their bid um so then if if you don't go to bid if you're below 40,000 the statute allows for 15% of the bid threshold requiring you to get a minimum of two written quotes okay they're not as formal they can be phoned in they could be faxed in uh they can be emailed in it's just it's not going through this cumbersome secretive bidding process again I'm not saying bids are done in secret but you know bids are supposed to be sealed and opened in a public forum like this with people

045other you know with Witnesses and people standing around so the quotes are less formal okay but again just there's so much available through State contract and through these buying co-ops that it's impossible to violate the law I I think in this day and age I wasn't just I wasn't suggesting any violation of the law but my my question is just to understand it and once we're in these consortiums and these group I think we're in with some Tri-State areas right even Pennsylvania I think I read last month Madam yeah the biggest one we have is Ed data which is um the purchase of anything that's considered a supply through all the different Departments of the district everything from tissue paper to consumable workbooks in the classroom those are all ordered through a Consortium called Ed

046data through the county office and I think at last check since we've joined that Consortium we've saved over $2 million as opposed to buying them off a state contract okay and and state contracts and those kinds of things does that mean we can buy things over 40,000 000 without yes so we can so there are things that can be purchased over $40,000 but you have to be careful sometimes because and I don't I I've heard sometimes the state contract price is not always the best price there's you you and you have to be careful too when you buy computers because like I don't know a lot about computers but you just got to be careful sometimes a lot of people don't know what they're buying fortunately you have good tech people here at this District

047so uh that's just an example but you know you have to shop around and um you know I think Mike they negotiate directly with the manufacturer correct I don't know that there's even anybody between like for example for supplies I'm not 100% sure but well you know throughout the county all the school districts that that participate in uh Education data um you're buying in such bulk that it it saves money even beyond what the state's purchasing power is and that's what the state contract is that's where the state has gone out and prepared bid specs that they're expense and gone through the process and allows everybody else to participate on it okay thank you very much for the explanation Mr cherella yeah I just want to thank you for the comprehensive report um you can

048see how for for everyone out there you see how big this is I think this is my eighth and I have finally gotten probably six pages into the first one so far that I got by eight years ago so it's very detailed but it's very uh dry you know and it's hard to it's it's hard to comprehend but but I have I have tried but I'll take your word for it but and I also want to thank uh Mr Gorski and his and his team Laura Allen and everyone for uh continuing to do a great job with regards to this and and um maintaining the Integrity not only of your office but of our district so thank you thank you I think the only one if everybody remembers Mr ly this was his favorite day

049because he loved reading that document Super Bowl Sunday yes and Christmas and New Year's all rolled into he and he'd have he'd come in and every page you'd have it marked with yes he read it keep you on your toes that's for sure yes any other questions I would like to also commend um Mr Gorski and Laura Allen in the business office because uh they did an excellent job this year with no recommendations considering the um some of the problems they had to go through and uh they continue to do a great job in in um mon in representing Monroe Township so thank you thank you um if there's no further comments or questions we'll have a roll call Mrs armeno yes Mr Chella yes Mrs Deo yes Mrs Lang yes Mr Ryback yes and

050Mrs col Pano yes mam board president motion passes thank you thank you thank you Mr stankowitz for being with us again thank you than you have a good holiday any questions please Channel them through Michael and we'll be happy to answer them but he is a former auditor and pretty good accountant and uh he he can handle most of it so thank you thank you hey at this time we'll go to a uh student board members report um on November 14th Mona Township High School had its coffee house which had a very high turnout um FBA has the largest group of students in mon Township history to advance to the state conference and model un is having their conference in Pennsylvania January 5th through January 7 okay thank you very much uh this time we'll

051go to committee reports are there any committees that need to report this evening Mr Mayo I have two okay we had just had the presentation of his 2016 2017 comprehensive annual financial report Mr Gerard stankowitz partner with Samuel kimman company presented the results of the 2016 2017 audit to the finance committee his comprehensive pres presentation covered all key areas of the cafra udit's management report and a discussion on internal controls Mr stano represented there was no audit recommendations no audit comments and the auditor's opinion letter expressly expressed an unmodified or clear opinion on the financial statements committee members ask questions many to the scope of the engagement whereby Mr stankowitz expressed that the financial statements contained in the cafra are the financial representation and responsibility of management who he defined as mainly Mr Gorski his

052job as an auditor is to test the transaction to form a basis of an independent auditor opinion whether the financial statements are presented fairly in accordance with the generally accepted auditing standards and are free from Material statements Mr stankowitz stated that after spending 400 to 450 hours of testing that in fact the financial statements presented are presented fairly and earned his clean or unmodified opinion with no audit recommendations Mr stankowitz commended Mr Gorski Miss alen and the business office I would like to thank Mr Gorski Miss Allen and the business entire business office for all their hard work it is because of their work that we are so fiscally sound have an excellent Bond rating and great credit such excellent records and financial documents translate into money that directly and positively impact our students so

053thank you again and that was came from the finance committee finance committee I apologize and I have the curriculum oh here it is we had a curriculum meeting today and we went [Applause] through two curriculum documents Community Based Fitness for 18 to 21y old class this is a curriculum document for special needs students to prepare them to live on their own sorry I can't read my own handwriting and um take charge of their own physical fitness they are introduced to activities such as disf and um sorry and um and other physical activities it also teaches them how to um get a membership in a fitness club and how to conduct themselves in these type of facilities um oh it also introduces them to pickle ball and yoga the other one is the prevention and care

054of athletic injuries this class is taught by the trainers kids and is mainly um and is um interested towards kids who are going into medicine they learn um a lot about human anatomy um they focus on individual body parts like arms and legs and typical injuries associated with these body parts how to evaluate the injury tape it um and five students have been working with the athletic trainers um to to further their education um we also have a sharing resource the schoolwide fundamental pilot this is for elementary school teachers and it is a resource for the request to intervention um it's an it's a it's a it's a pilot it's an online resource and it's to help teachers um for reading and writing with their students um it helps them with books and lessons plans

055and that's that one and the last one is the online Finance course we about a year a this was it this summer two AG two summers ago we had a pilot where we allowed students to take the online Finance course online um now we're in phase two and what we're doing is we are condensing this class and it's going to be we're going to have all the students meet in the media center there's going to be three teachers there and the class the students are going to be watching mod modules which are essentially lesson plans and then they're going to go into breakout sessions and this teaches students to work at their own pace um and it teaches them Independence in learning and it's a great model and and I did not do it just

056this in my description um but it's a great model um on how to enact an online learning module um for students and it really it allows them to teach themselves but with a lot of support from teachers do you want to add anything because I know I did not do that Justice the personal finance and economics is a graduation requirement for all high school students a few years ago we started a pilot where we offered this as an online course to students to get them um used to the online platform since a lot of businesses a lot of colleges um are offering this now so we want to make sure that our students have that opportunity but even though they're be doing an online course they're doing it in a room with the teacher so

057there is a lot of support there a lot of guidance um a lot of help if they need it and or a lot of enrichment if they need that so it's been very successful this year we um have continued with it and opened it up to to our students with next year's incoming freshmen we're we're offering this to we'd like all freshmen to take the personal finance online course in this type of setting so it would be three teachers with three classes of students in here in the media center and the teachers could support their learning through the online format and they're right there face to face if needed um this would give the every student a chance to take an online course in their High School experience because every student has to take the

058personal finance and the economics course um students are not required to take personal finance in their freshman year so if they choose not to take it in their freshman year because maybe they need a little more maturity a little more Readiness and Tech skills um to take it they could take it in sophomore junior or even senior year but it is a requirement for high school graduation thank you you did a much better job than I did would you like to give an update on the homework policy going to wait till they oh oh but I can do that yeah I have it we also discussed the homework policy um so Dory outlined how we're going to evaluate the homework policy and create a new one she's started off she's starting off by forming a

059committee of teachers and administrators and in January and for the next following months they're going to um brainstorm about how they want this policy to be written she's they're also going to take a survey of parents and students um like I said this will take about two to three months and any changes and what they decide will be presented to the curriculum and policy meeting and and we're thinking that it will be ready for next September thank you is there any questions from Mr Mayo okay any other committee meetings none you I have one but you well I I miss Armenia okay I wasn't unfortunately I was at a town uh on business for the um policy committee meeting however I was reviewing the policies that are on tonight for the first uh reading and

060I would just suggest to the uh to the public because we all we get a lot of um questions about uh why can't we project farther into the future about our facilities what you know and how we uh acquire land and what our restraints are so I would recommend to the public if anybody has the um agenda with them on page 14 of 18 there are several policies that would help explain not entirely but sort of uh help explain some of the policies that have to do with our um ability to build facilities or ability to acquire land and I'll just mention a couple of them again on page 14 of 18 on the AG on tonight's agenda for the first reading you have the long range facility planning that's uh 7,100 uh the educational

061adequacy of capital projects that's 7,11 uh site selection and acquisition that is 7,12 and disposition of property that is 7300 um I think if uh the public especially those who are interested in how we have to go forward with our um our school building and things like that that would help for the for the public to know and understand what some of the policies are and what some of the restraints are for the district so I would thank you and there and these policies are online after tonight after the first reading they'll be available online is that correct yes okay thank you thank you Michelle that's very helpful to the public and to us uh anyone else Mr tiella yes thank you we had a buildings grounds and transportation committee meeting on December 4th and

062we had four items that we discussed and the our committee recommended that we that the board move forward with all four of those the first one was uh the princ University resource recovery program so uh the administration was able to uh find a great opportunity for us to be able to get uh used furniture for offices and things like that from this program where that we could use for uh to furnish our offices to furnish the school offices uh in the future the new school offices hopefully and trailers and things like that so um we we asked them to to go ahead and move forward with that um the we also discussed the uh trailers for the for the middle school so we looked at uh the eight Trailers Plus the uh uh the the

063uh the what do you call that the fizzed one yeah the fizzed The Double trailer such a hard word um yeah The Double trailer and you know with bathroom connectivity and things like that where we uh what we're really looking at though is that there are threeyear and 5year contracts with the referendum still being a question obviously for March uh and us not knowing uh how that will turn out hopefully it turns out positively but um we we don't want to enter into an agreement a long-term agreement and uh and then not need to have those trailers and then be you know have to break that agreement or or pay that out so what we're going to do is try to push that down the road at least until March and then make a determination

064as to what we'll need after March so in the meantime um you know we're going through with that now the uh the administration uh has saved us probably about 20% on those trailer unit rentals by looking at or having us go through and uh purchase or rent used trailers so that's a you know that's a good thing so those trailers are 100% in good shape you know and they're and they're not leaking they're not drafty they have heat and air conditioning and bathrooms and that whole thing but they're they're used so um that'll help from a from a financial standpoint then number three was Verizon claim settlement so we had a truck driver uh drive through some wires and knocked out our Verizon service for a while um Verizon you know the the truck driver

065didn't want to to pay we went we entered into litigation it turns out that the wires were low so uh uh the our Administration was has uh fought that battle with Verizon with the driver uh with various various people various entities I should should say and Verizon has finally agreed to reimburse us for 75% of that cost and then the uh the the rest of that the other 25% will come from the hopefully from the truck driver but we're still litigating that going through negotiations for that and then the uh the final thing that I that we discussed was about the Church Road uh land uh so we have two things that we're still looking at besides the really exciting thing that we always like to talk about just uh Turtle fornication out there but

066uh we're what we what the things that we still have to look at is uh pesticide use on the land because that was a former farm and also flood flood zone uh or the flood zone maps both of those things are going to be required for in order for us to be able to acquire that land we won't be able to move forward and acquire that land the board won't unless we have those things done so uh the committee also asked the uh the full board to approve that so that we can move forward and and and then get those two tests done get that finished and then uh get the land that's it thank you very good questions for Mr Chella Miss armino has that land been uh conveyed to the township I don't

067know I don't believe so Madam um I do not believe that has occurred yet and one of the things that we talked about was that this is a strategic U holding and ipated for the board meaning we're probably not going to need to develop that property for at least a decade but but um you know land in this Township is scarce you know as we represented before about 75% is encumbered meaning it's in Farmland preservation Green Acres or Wetlands did you I'm sorry 75% No 7 75% not really but okay the 75% of the township is in encumbered by open 75% of the land available to build a school is encumbered by either Green Acres uh okay uh open space or Wetlands or W yeah we have a problem so you know to have that

068in your back pocket that you could look at 10 years from now uh is is a good asset okay my other question on that however is because the township will be receiving that land first and it would be in my opinion in incumbent on the township to do their due diligence as well on the property I'm wondering if maybe in the next meeting um the township could be we can negotiate with the township and a a a shared services agreement that they would contribute to uh part of the cost of accepting that land under our due diligence because if they if they accept the land and we haven't done all of that work yet or nor should we I mean they're going to be the first landh holders and then if they con Cony it

069well when they convey it to us um I think that they should do like a their phase one their due diligence and perhaps under a shared services agreement because we should I I don't think the board or the district because it takes away again from instructional whatever funds we expend it takes away from instructional even though it's coming out of the same big pot of taxpayers it comes out of instructional funds for our children so I would highly recommend or ask maybe at the next meeting if the committee could discuss a shared services agreement to pay for some of or all of course or part of the cost of of those doesn't hurt to have that conversation no no no no and and yeah thank you I appreciate and I appreciate that the administration keeps

070on this but again and there was no mention here about the other land that we're you know by January 1st we'll have less than 90 days for our referendum will we have land on for that referendum by January 1st do we have that land yet the uh proposed site for the new Monroe Township Middle School is a certainty that it will come to the board uh the township right now is in the process of negotiating the purchase of the land with the with the owner and although I haven't been able to connect with Ellen Weinberg Township business administrator and in about a week it is our understanding that negotiations are still proceeding and um and um that we were confirmed that that land will be ours period okay I it has nothing to do with

071this Administration I have worked diligently and very very hard but I think for the purpose of moving forward in March and for you know for our community our educational Community I would feel a whole lot better if we knew that the the land was under contract and I I would I would ask and maybe I'm not asking at the right meeting but I would ask that that get done really quickly it it's a complex transaction and and uh from the Township's representations they're acting not only in the school's interest but the taxpayers interest as well is trying to negotiate the best and and most fair price for the property okay thank you and thank you Mr cherella for being on top of this I know you're thank you keeping this I don't think there's any

072more committee meetings that need to report so we will go to public forum anyone from the public wishing to speak to the agenda please come to the microphone and give your name and address for the record and we will adhere to our 4 minute time limit uh prakash parab from 33 Dana Drive uh chairperson uh chairwoman there was discussion on curriculum there is a discussion on here today about the homework policy homework policy coming in September I'm impatient about it because there are reasons for that I look today at the our ranking of our district the niche ranking for our district has dropped from 60 to 65 our school ranking is 140 compared to Robinsville we are not doing well so the curriculum the homework policy everything is so important so our request you know

073I represent the community so I get all these questions from my friends so our request is Boe has board of education has all the data we are not the experts when the niche looks at the categories there are different categories they look at and they rank the district they rank the schools so you have the data so request is please conduct complete analysis and see where there are deficiencies and come back and to the public tell us where are the deficiencies how we can where are you are putting your resources to improve on it where the deficiency are there so we can understand so that our ranking of the school goes up okay so that is the request can we do it so that is my question can we do that I I think um

074I think I think every member of this board of education would like to do that and we're always asking to find we've asked Dr kak and and Dr alvic to look into these things to find out where we are and we know a lot of times they change the criteria and then it it you know we we not quite sure what they're testing us but um definitely moving forward we will do that um as part of the homework policy as Mr Mayo said it's very hard to do something in in a month or two because there's a lot of work that goes in there's a lot of buying we need from different people we want to make sure that when we when we do a policy we do it right and we never usually start

075in the middle of a school year so by the time we finish a policy it's for the next school year because that makes it fair to everybody so that everybody starts on a on a clean slate so both of them we will be working on um we will have the homework policy by next September and we are always considering where we stand in the rankings yeah so we'll appreciate in at least two months you all can give us the you know something about how we can look at the ranking we will appreciate and we'll support you all okay thank you I I know Dr kosek would like to add to that too thank you madam president um Dr for UAB prash I would want to say Dr PAB um the the question of the uh

076I think it's the niche um rankings has come up before and I looked at it again today just in case the question came up tonight and just to be aware they still are using 20156 data School academic data if you go through their site there's little question marks that you can click on and it tells you where they're getting their data from now that being said uh I would be it would be my pleasure to certainly report in January on how we're doing but I would like to just you know it it's kind of what I hear about our our economy in the country we're doing a lot better than you when people might Believe by what we hear in the media um I I will have something in a little bit during my superintendent

077report where I will state that based on the data from the last three years uh We've improved dramatically um but how are we comparing to other schools that's always good for us to look at we have taking teams of Administrators out to other school districts who are ranked higher than us to see why they're a ranked Tire what are they doing that we can learn from we can always always improve and I think it's incoming upon us to always be looking at that to see how we can improve so absolutely we'll have that for January thank you very much thank you anyone else from the public wishing to speak good evening Betty saberito to Barrymore Drive my one of my sons is a and Miss P Andrea and Miss pandi's class and I want to

078commend them on the fabulous job they are doing in honoring our veterans so thank you very much this is a pure example of how to educate the whole child academically socially and civically our teachers are currently working without a contract members of the Board of Ed I urge you to look at these amaz amazing individuals such as Miss Pap Andrea and miss pandaly that you have educating our children in Monroe and settle on their contract I have met some of the most amazing teachers in this District and it is thanks to these professionals that our children are progressing I have two children at mil Lake one with a diagnosis of autism and I am certain that without the teachers they have been lucky enough to have they would not have progressed as they have please

079give our teachers the credit they deserve in terms of salary benefits and recognition they deserve to be compensated in a fair manner teachers such as Jennifer bidik Paula DeBlasio Lisa papandrea Danielle pandaly Jean Barca Sue huuki Jim Bo and Hardy Stacy libros and all the other teachers are the best that there are out there I know for certain my children would not be where they are without them let's show these teachers how valuable they are to this District so that we don't lose them to other districts thank you thank you [Applause] hello my name is Sarah Aziz I live on three lelot Drive in Monroe um I had my son is a first grader also in Miss Pap Andrea and Miss pandolf's class um I moved back to Monroe last year from Connecticut and since

080I moved to Monroe I've been paying almost double the property taxes however in this year my children have made more progress in their year in Monroe than they had years in Connecticut and I strongly feel that my property taxes are well spent on our teachers and our schools and that Monroe has so much to offer children of all levels of ability I also have a child with a disability um and uh I'm here to support the teachers union and I believe they deserve a fair contract and one that is competitive and consistent with other teachers in middle sex County and if they don't get a fair contract the best teachers are going to leave they're going to have no reason to stay here and our children children will lose um I feel that our Town's

081budget is a reflection of our values and our teachers and our school is something that we should really value thank you good evening my name is Danielle drust my address is 200 Schoolhouse Road I am here speaking tonight in a dual role both as a resident of the community and an educator at the high school I have been a teacher in Monroe for the last 16 years I fell in love with the community and decided to move to the town a few years ago tonight I want to share some information with the board and the community so that a clearer picture of Our Lives as teachers can be seen I first would like to share a story about one of my colleagues this individual has been teaching science in our district for years they are

082extremely qualified and have a passion for the profession that I have never seen at this point in time this individual is not even making $50,000 a year in salary after8 years of dedic ated service another one of my colleagues is paying over ,000 per month for health benefits over the last several years their take-home pay has declined every year is this how our town chooses to reward its amazing professionals it is very difficult to plan for a future when every year your pay actually decreases due to health care cost over the last three years my personal take-home pay has decreased about six over $6,000 I work additional jobs as a matter of fact I was at one this evening before I came here to make up for this loss to basically maintain a home other

083surrounding districts have offered relief to their staff in health care costs and I'm asking you to do the same look at maror township there the staff maxes out at an 18.5 contribution towards benefits while here our members can pay upwards of 30% in Wall Township they reached a similar agreement in Neptune the teachers have a maximum fixed dollar amount where the staff maxes out how can these three districts do what our board seems unwilling to do I want to read to you a portion of an email that a student has sent to me at the beginning of this school year dear mistress I wanted you to know that I'll never forget the time I spent in AP Bio third block of my senior year at mths and especially will never forget all the kindness patience

084and endurance you showed with me both after my absences and even when I was just being a regular old pain in the butt I could have never succeeded on the AP exam or over the course of the second half of senior year without you and I'm forever touched by your experience in your class you have shown me what it means to be both a great educator and a great person and I'm beyond grateful for that I owe you so much mistrust and I just wanted to say thank you so very much in closing when I first read this email it brought tears to my eyes it represents everything that I got into education for however my colleagues and I need a livable wage remember you get what you pay for and our Educators in this

085community deserve more thank you I'm sure the Applause is not for me [Applause] though good evening uh my name is Andy poori I'm from 16 St James Street I just want to Echo the sentiments of the folks who spoken uh before me both my kids who go to the m Township High School initially came back home and said what do you want to become when you grow up uh both of them used to say that they want to become a teacher so I guess the influence of the teacher is so strong even compared to the parents that I think they make a a significant impact on their life so I fully understand the financial situation with the Board of Education and how difficult it is to get into an agreement quickly but I personally feel

086that it's taken way too long for the contract negotiations and I think there needs to be a closure on this as soon as possible in the best interest of the students best interest of the Board of Education and the best interest most more most importantly the best interest of the teachers and one of the concerns that I have is the number of teachers who come in and leave it's a relationship that the teachers build with the students so if there's a constant turnover that relationship never never really gels and the teachers and the students don't have that Bond and connection for a better education so I plead the Board of Education I'm sure you're working hard I have no doubt in my mind but let's come to the closure on this as quickly as possible

087the second point I want to bring up is something that I heard from a bunch of students uh who are the high school seniors and uh this is to Dr kak uh apparently the parking is a first come first serve basis at the high school for the kids to come in but apparently uh a lot of kids do feel that they own the parking spot and if somebody else comes and Parks the car uh some undesirable things tend to happen either to the car or to the individual and it seems to be uh mostly between the male and female ver have a conflict uh and apparently there were quite a few incidences that that that took place and I was just asking the young lady while before coming here and she said that yeah they

088do happen from time to time at the at the Mundo Township High School parking lot so all I ask is that put out a memo saying that it's a first come first serve basis and respect the other drivers who are coming in the car uh to to have their own parking spot uh M plor well just clarification because what you're bringing up is I'm just hearing about this when you're saying there there's a conflict between male and female students adults I'm I'm students students I I heard of at least three incidences in the last month or so where a young lady went and parked the car and somebody one of the gentlemen one of the students who had a car who was parking in the same spot and bulli is probably a strong word and

089we don't like the b word but was uh got into an altercation of verbal altercation all right thank I I think it's just to bring it up to the people's attention especially with the cold weather coming upon us people tend to want to park closer to the school to the cl to the classes so okay and I thank you for uh bringing that to my attention I would encourage you and anyone else that when situations like that occur for for the most immediate action uh please if you contact the school and the same for the students or the parents um to contact the school immediately but I will follow up with this uh to ensure that um you know this is monitored I appreciate that absolutely and I assume that same answer for the first

090point that I try to make making the teacher contract done soon too thank you I can't speak uh I I just I I just want to clarify that this public forum is for the things on the agenda and parking was not on the agenda I at least I didn't see it so sorry that's okay so if you have any questions pertaining to the agenda otherwise we have another P public forum coming up I think this does my name is Ira Nelson I live at 87 Crescent Way um I recall a little while back there were discussions about how to get more dollars out of Trenton for State Ed um I recall also reading I I think it was Dr kak in one of the local newspapers indicating that we received all of $458,000 to be

091honest with you I didn't know whether I should laugh or cry with that amount uh when bud when a budget uh goes up um approximately if I understand it correctly well that's for you I don't know if that was for me uh $3.5 million do a year we have a bond issue that's coming up uh obviously there are an awful lot of expenses and you hear the plight of the teachers uh in the district I guess my question is what efforts are really being made uh to uh acquire more dollars from the state for the situation that we're facing here uh I know that there were some discussion as I said a while back uh some meetings were held in Trenton there's a new Administration that's coming in in January but can somebody give us

092an update uh a status report as to where we stand I'm going to let Mr tiella handle that um he is the chairperson of the ad hoc committee for fair funding and I know that he's been meeting with his group um on on a regular basis so we we met thank you by the way for coming up and bringing this up but we met I was going to bring this up at the uh other board business section but by then it's usually everybody's usually gone and I'm just talking to myself and and them you know which is like talking to me they don't listen to me I just but anyway we we met about two weeks ago uh again our our group and um uh we were discussing our next steps and what we need

093to do in order to get in order to re-engage with our elected officials in Trenton and and just I wanted to also take the Pulse of our committee just to see where they were where their heads were at and then get everybody you know get us all past the partisanship that is natural during an election M uh our committee is made up of Democrats and Republicans and independents you know it's a it's uh it's pretty much across the board it's a mix it's it's it's nonpartisan and bipartisan I should say and um and the reason for that is because we all we all need to work together because I think this issue goes beyond political boundaries this is a Monroe issue you know this is an issue that we all share this is a problem

094that we all this is all all of our burden and I think it's a fight that we all have to take together so anyway with that being said what we're what we're looking to do is just to re-engage with those politicians so our governor-elect promised on the campaign trail that he would that one of the first things that he would do was to fully fund the current funding formula that would be step one our our legislators our Senator Senator Greenstein and and our both of our assemblymen promised us that they would you know they would support that they would support fully funding of of that which would mean millions of dollars more for us but on the other on the other side of that that they also said that they would support going back to

095the drawing board and and and submitting legis ation or joining legislation that would change the funding formula and and and and rid us of the things that are penalizing us for being the kind of District that we are so our job I think and I'm I'm motioning because some of the members of our committee are here uh our job is to re-engage with them hold them to those promises and help make you know ensure that they do what they promised to do for us it sounds well and good uh I hate to sound very skeptical but um in terms of anything immediate uh anything short range anything even mid-range with all of the issues that we're facing here in this District which are a lot revolve around finances and money and taxpayers paying paying the

096bills for for all kinds of things it really doesn't seem like much is going to change um I I I hope I'm wrong uh for everybody's sake but uh this this can take a very long time for anything really to be resolved in any kind of satisfactory way thank you thank you for your comments um I I both um Jill Steve and I we ran on the position that we want to continue that fight and as part of the steering committee we have already reached out towards legislators we know that um the the new governor has his transition teams we have already asked to be part of those transition teams team so that we can get the message to those people right away about the plate of Monroe and what we need and how important

097it is for them to hear us so we we pledge to continue this fight and we will continue to do so until we we're we're hoping that at least the funding formula is fully funded this year so that we have that money coming into our budget th this for next school year at least so I at this time um thank you if there's anyone else from the public wishing to speak good evening Ram rnat 6 ens stri mro um again I know we had some discussions on the referendum and the school expansion needs um I guess this is the question right I guess we are working for the March referendum concerning that we still don't have that land hopefully uh next time we come uh we have that already email before that this is a

098question why are we I think we some of us have asked this before uh you know with the referend there's a concern that not including the expansion of the high school at least probably weakens the case for the referendum um and secondly is it doing enough for the township right given the lack of capacity and we heard about our rankings dropping right from the high school I know there's some analysis done and we'll hear more in January uh but it's important that we address issues from the high school because ultimately that's what counts from rankings and so on and so forth so so this is the question I guess you know have we really looked at adding the high school as well to the referendum what is the Delta um and other issues around this

099is in terms of the capacity I think the members of the community are not clear what exactly is the underc capacity issue we heard it's 1500 we are already at under capacity by 1500 and in the next 5 years I think it's going to be another 1500 are those the right numbers is when is the high school going to reach its capacity limit can someone share projection and information around that and then importantly again why can't we add the high school uh as well to the referendum because I think that improves the chance of success of the referendum and then importantly it address a big concern uh that uh people have that we need to address the high school situation as well okay I'll let Mr Gorski answer those thanks thanks the Board of Education

100and um the student growth advisory committee have been studying this problem for over two years and one of the most challenging aspects of our needs which we want to be clear include not only a middle school but also an elementary school and we inherited a need for an ADD addition to this high school as well all three of those projects are in need but the most uh challenging part of accomplishing them was the identification of land to build the middle school on it is extremely difficult as we found to find 20 to 30 Acres of buildable land that's flat it's not Wetlands it's in the location of growth it's it's got the right uh roads and infrastructure and utility zones um it makes at a a very rare piece of land indeed and when we

101identified such a property that is the reason why the middle school project became Paramount uh for address because had we not addressed that one first and that piece of land um was lost right uh it couldi sorry not to interrupt but I really appreciate that right so assuming we get that golf course we can put up the middle school there but with the high school we have the land it was already part of the original plan to extend it right so why not do both the middle school as well as the high school there's a lot of considerations uh other than just bundling all three number one the school district went through an extensive Elementary School redistricting project a couple years ago and that project uh basically balance the load from the sections of town

102that are are seeing uh decreasing enrollment to those uh increasing the southern area of Town's elementary schools are are managing just fine now there's available space as we work with our demographer that handle the load for at least the next five uh six years out so one of the problems there has been temporarily solved um likewise the one at the high school has also been very well managed by the high school administration by scheduling and by uh making the most utilization of current space another consideration and there are many and I'll just share with you you know what comes to mind is the uh outfitting of all of these facilities when you open them online there used to be a budget cap waiver for opening a new school because the cost of outfitting a school

103could be significant when you're talking Staffing and supplying and getting everything geared up to to receive kids in September um in my opinion as the business administrator it would be unaffordable to open up all three of those facilities additions at once within the current budget structure we simply don't have enough room it will be an immense challenge for this District uh and this Administration to open a middle school and outfit it with Staffing and all the operational cost not Capital cost because that can be bonded but the operational costs that are required in a school budget that's already capped and we are already at cap so we are doing this on a very intelligent installment design which also uh is in the taxpayers interest not to prepay for any facilities that you don't need immediately

104so this this is a a very well carefully thought out plan the most stressed and the most need is at the middle school and then the the board and the Committees will work again together to see once that's successful this March which one needs to be tackled if not both next thank you thank you is is this an agenda question how would I know if it's an agenda question if we would because you don't you don't have a copy of the agenda no I don't okay okay all right um Krishna deal 11 Jak pleas um I have a question on what Mr gski just said um considering that the new school is coming up and if we are already at cap we would have issues hiring new teachers for the new school right um so

105as an extension to that question how many um classes do we have with teachers how many Subs are taking those classes or are there any plans to hire new teachers even if we were to bring in trailers we would have the same issue right we would still have to have new teachers for those trailer classrooms do we have that well I I could start with that because if you're going to to have a new school and you're going to have to put people in the new school we're going to have people in trailers for the next two three years at least those teachers and the equipment in those trailers will be given to the new school so we probably won't need the teachers as much as you would need the support staff being um your

106nurse and your principal and your guidance counselors and your um gy gym teachers and things like that your support staff but the teachers should be in place now we hire teachers on a regular basis due to need and and enrollment and growth so that we're we're doing on on going but I'll let Dr KAC um add to that okay thank you madam president uh the hiring teachers goes with the student enrollment that as a student enrollment increases so as Mrs K panovich has said uh this for this year that we're in now the school year we hired 30 new staff members for next year's budget we're working on that budget now and as needed we hire staff to accommodate the growing student so regardless of the building space we want to make sure that our

107class sizes are manageable and are uh and an you know provide an appropriate learning environment meaning that that they're smaller class sizes so we have been hiring teachers and we'll continue to hire teachers as needed as the student enrollment increases um so a continuation of that question is that you know um I can understand a few vacancies but are there um I've heard from my friends and my neighbors that there are some classes that are um exclusively being run by Subs um so is that uh something that I can speak today yeah um the only classes that are being R run by substitute teachers are classes where students are out on a a leave perhaps a medical leave where um teachers are out on a leave yeah you said students oh did I say students

108I'm sorry thank you thank you thank you I'm glad you're listening uh we're teachers out on a medical leave my my apologies um the last Personnel meeting that uh I believe I had I do the the new staff enrollment I believe all of our positions were filled except for Lee positions now with that even on the agenda tonight you'll see that we have um retirements resignations uh so as they come up we work as quickly as we can to fill those positions there are some positions where if we can't fill them quick enough some of our teachers will we'll pay them you'll see it on the agenda as 117% we'll pay them an extra amount to teach an extra class to make sure that it's being covered um but we want a teacher in for

109every class there have been some uh other positions that we have had trouble filling such as a um you know uh ldtc for our child study team a learning disabled uh teacher uh you know those position positions are hard to fill throughout the state so we've worked around that but that's not directly a teacher in a classroom but as much as possible we have a teacher in the class and we only use substitute teachers on an as needed basis to deal with teachers who are out on leave sure thank you okay again I'm going to ask if there's a gender questions we'll do that now if there is not an agenda question we have a public forum later on in in the on the agenda sure ruchu 23 Green Street have two questions uh one

110regarding the high school uh uh the building option um what criteria did we use to make a decision to go with a new Middle School um is it the number of students per class or is it the teacher to student ratio or the total student limit per school like you know we're not clear I've been attending this multiple times but I've never got an answer for that the reason for asking that is I want to compare that metrics with the high school now so where do we stand when do we reach that threshold and when do we really need that High School additional classes that's one question and second one is regarding the teacher retention I've seen um uh lot of couple of teachers are like you know working more than 100% capacity and uh

111some are like hired for middle of the year like half three months 6 months like that right if the teachers are not consistent for the students I see I personally feel that you know the the students may not have that continuous uh progress from the same teacher it will impact their grades right I mean the bottom line again it boils down to the the teachers contracts I guess um we would like to see I mean support the teachers contract and help from the board to make sure we conclude these contracts it's been for a while right I mean these are impacting our students and another thing that I I want to ask about the same the teachers part is um how will it impact the advanced AP courses I mean are there enough teachers there

112because for the regular classes itself if are the teachers are not available and If teachers are working at over capacity or being hired for a very short stin how does it impact or how many AP courses are being offered here and how are the teachers there how consistent the teachers are there for those classes if if if board can share those stats for the AP courses it would help us understand I mean where we lack on the uh the teacher negotiations or the contracts Dr K do you want to start and then question okay okay so regarding substitute teachers uh if a teacher's out for one day there is a pool of substitute teachers and every substitute teacher has to be qualified we interview every substitute teacher they have to go through training we also

113include uh writing samples to make sure that they can write effectively they can communicate effectively and uh if they're teaching math at a lower level uh or at a higher level as well we require that uh that they demonstrate that knowledge if they're going for if they're teaching a longer let's say um a maternity leave and someone's out for two or three months we want that same high quality teaching to occur so when we hire a person to cover a longer period of time we again we follow all that criteria to make sure they are the most qualified substitute teachers that are available we also allow for transition time when possible if a teacher doesn't go out suddenly we allow for transition time for the The Substitute Teacher to work with the teacher who's going

114to go out and leave to make sure that he or she understands the material where they're at uh and that the uh curriculum is being followed properly and um we also have supervisors and administrators that monitor uh that as well regarding the AP classes uh we currently uh this is a report that Dr Ali provided for the public in uh I believe it was October I think it was October and as far as advanced placement courses right now uh I'm not aware of any AP teachers who are out on leave I I not off the top of my head I can't think of of it but just uh we have 354 students taking AP courses we have 26 subjects that we offer advanced placement courses in I think if you compare that to other high

115schools I think you would be very happy because I I won't say we're the highest number of AP courses being or we offer the the highest number of AP courses but I think we're up there with some of the schools that offer the highest so we offer a lot of courses um uh we offered a lot of advanced placement courses for a variety of subjects and based on last year the most recent data that we have we had the a four and a five are really out of it's a five uh Point rubric that's used to pass an AP exam and four and five are generally accepted as uh N3 but the level at that you you know that that colleges will accept that at so out of the 354 students uh 122 received a

116three 155 received a four and 129 received a five which would give me a quick 300 uh probably a little around right around students um which is over the number of of students taking that but you have to consider that some students take more than one AP test Okay so generally our students do well uh on the AP test cool and Mr Gorski yes thanks um with regard to your questions about uh capacities at the schools the middle school was identified as having not only the highest pupil teacher ratios which are demonstrated on page 137 of the comprehensive annual financial report like I said there's a lot of good information in here but the middle school has also um anticipated to have trailers coming next year which is further evidence of the need to hit

117that first and it's 10 portable classroom units and uh to to purchase these and Lease them it has a shocking $1.5 million effect on next year's budget for 10 portable classroom trailer units and that includes Staffing and the lease payments can I interrupt sure sorry my question is about the criteria what criteria was used to make a decision that we need to have a new I mean trailers for the school middle school is it the number of students trailers is based upon number of students pupil teacher ratios classrooms available is the main one and as I was going to get to bottlenecks in the school uh we cannot uh properly educate children in the middle school with physical education there's just no more room in the gym you can't have any more classes throughout the

118scheduling so there was a requirement to have a cardio lab uh lease through the trailers so every criteria available was studied every criteria that was relevant was studied and it was it was determined that the middle school was the most in need of address and uh some of the evidence that was studied is in the demographic report enrollment projections in other words that the board adopted and just to share with you a couple numbers from here I spoke with u Mrs Shanley the principal of the school and recently she told me there's 1,665 students in the Monro Township Middle School five years from now it's going to exceed 19900 that's a few hundred beyond the capacity of the school and with the bottlenecks that I I mentioned you you really cannot accommodate um much more

119without addressing the problem with a new school and trailers are not the answer they are the most inefficient way to educate students we're budgeting over $7,500 a pupil just for these trailers for next year and uh it it's just a waste and a lot of the infrastructure that goes into there with wiring and Wi-Fi and all that stuff goes in a heap when you when you throw it out except like um Mrs kapano said a lot of it will transfer over with the students that go to to hopefully the new middle school and that will split that load equally uh and it will be between 900 and 1,000 students in the two schools over time so what criteria for the high school now like you know where do we stand in terms of the CR

120the high school per pupil teacher ratios are um much lower than the Middle School although they're higher than the elementary schools and they're being managed very well there's still some flexibility in scheduling and there's still still some flexibility with um some of the infrastructure here the gyms and the cafeterias that were servicing students without an immediate need the immediate need exists at the middle school it does not exist here had we had our DRS sure we could do all three there's justification for that but none more severe than at the middle school and that's why we're doing that one first totally understand about the Middle School my concern is about how long does it take like you know to reach the threshold for the high school if the middle school is successful in March I

121anticipate and this is just my opinion that Administration and his board will begin to work diligently to address the needs at the elementary and the and the um the high school level and probably we'll be packaging out another referendum for one or both of those within uh within a year's time certainly thank you thank you good evening my name is Sal saola I live at ten glor Lane I'm here as a taxpayer and also I'm here for the teachers with all due respect I want to start off by saying how disgraceful it is that our teachers are without a contract since chrisy took office teachers and all public employees have seen their pay go down every single year but I'm sure you guys know that they pay for health care they got their steps Frozen

122for two years they even got added steps tons of steps from 12year contracts to somewhere in excess of a 20-year contract in the middle of their career and not to mention if they live in Monroe they're getting it on both ends okay my my taxes and my wife's taxes went up 70% in 6 years from $10,000 to $177,000 so you're get you live in the town you're paying all these taxes and you're not getting your raises at school every year your pay is going down and down and down these teachers dedicate their lives it to these students it doesn't end in the classroom I personally see it with my wife and her colleagues my wife has got to football games and other teachers for their students on weekends taking time out of their own life

123with their own family I've seen teachers have lunch with their students to reward them and not to mention half the teachers that I know personally have one teacher of the year my wife along with many other teachers had have an excess of 26 students in first grade it is unfair both for teachers and students they do more and more the teachers and get less and less they have done their part now it's your turn to make it right thank you good evening Tracy b Sam 5 Leela Court I am not only here as a taxpayer and a mother of three that are in our district but I am also here as a Monroe Township employee as a substitute teacher unfortunately I do not substitute anymore in the district being for other reasons that I just

124feel and I know this is a state thing but as some of the people were speaking before was that our substitutes cannot sub for more than 4 days a week when you do have a teacher out for a long term and we are put in it's not fair to our students that the consistency is not there that we only have our subs there for four days a week and then a new person comes in to take over the class so I just wanted to address that this has been a big problem that not only as a parent do I see that my son has had many difficulties being in a math class when a teacher has gone out because he's only there the sub is there for four days and this you know a new

125sub comes in on the fifth day the consistency is not good for our students my main reason why I am here is for our teachers not only do our teachers deserve to have a contract our staff in Monroe is unbelievable I am not standing here saying this just to say it is coming from my heart you should be very very extremely proud of the people that are here that couldn't be here but that represent Monroe Township they are what we they represent what we are what our students are what our children are every day that my child wakes up they want to go to school why because they have teachers like Mrs Silverman like Mrs huy kuchi Mrs berety Mrs Walters Mrs Roth Mrs Sher Denise gz who is our secretary at mil Lake Mrs

126moli um I'm looking right at him and I can't even say his name right now cuz I'm just so emotionally Mr ventrillo Mr Layman I mean there are so many people that Mrs sapola I I mean I can go on Mrs worth Mrs P Andrea Mrs pandaly I can just keep going on but these teachers do this for not only for the money not it's not even there they they do it out of their heart out of the love that they have for our children I mean when I see teachers my son is in the middle school he's in e8th grade I still see his first grade teacher and she always says to me how is Nicholas doing and you know how that makes me feel these are not people that just come to a

1279to five job 9 to3 job and leave they are with us 24 hours a day many many years out of their lives and I don't want to lose any of them so please think about it think about your own children's teachers what an important part of these people make in these children's lives because let me tell you something my fifth grade teacher gave me such a an idea of being a teacher and gave me this love of wanting to be a teacher so please think about it even in your own personal experience what teach has done for you growing up and I really think but think about it put a contract out there for them give them what they deserve they deserve to have a contract they really do and if you want to continue

128staying with Monroe honestly wake up and be proud of these people please thank you thank [Applause] you is there anyone else who wishes to speak to the agenda no okay seeing none we will close the public forum and go to the superintendence report Dr kak okay thank you uh Madam president so uh this is a I'm going to give my report and I'm also going to read a letter to the board that um uh regretfully this letter serves as my notice in Monro Township Board of Education to resign from my position as superintendent of schools effective June 30th 2018 due to contractual obligations I have to provide the Board of Education dutiful notice of my plans to resign it has been and continues to be and honor to serve the students the families the teachers

129the staff the administrators the Board of Education and community members of monr Township the past two and a half half years have been extremely gratifying as I witness students engaged in their learning teachers delivering quality educational programming administrators providing educational leadership and parents and community members supporting students and our schools I'm proud of the accomplishments that have occurred during the past two and a half years as a result of the collaborative efforts of the leadership team we have improved student learning through and I did say we we have improved student learning through a data informed approach to instruction through the use of measures of academic performance known as map and other formative styles of Assessments Park scores have increased in almost every grade all but two and those two there was a slight decrease over

130a three-year period um but over in every other grade over the last three years with some gains as much as 41% increased internship opportunities for students have been provided we provided an opportunity for high school students to learn entrepreneurship and business plan skills from a volunteer who is an esteemed graduate professor of Education from the College of William am we've enhanced communication to the community through our Facebook and Twitter pages the Falcon flyer focus on education show which is on cable TV and our district app en we've enhanced communication and collaboration throughout the district through the introduction and application of Google Apps we've increased the science technology engineering arts and math instruction sometimes known as stem or steam including computer coding with robots and expanding our focus on creating innovators with the habits of mind

131to be successful in college and a career we've increased our focus on the delivery of our services to our special need students uh as outlined in our study that was done by consultan we provided tax relief by allocating surplus funds to Residents we finally through the work of many many people helped achieve additional State funding after eight years of approximately a half a million milon doll and sure that's certainly not enough and the fight needs to continue but it was a coordinated effort with the ad hoc committee Mr tiello um and other board members and certainly with superintendent from other districts throughout Central and South Jersey and we've engaged the community in our student growth advisory committee in identifying solutions to our growing student enrollment resulting in a referendum for March 133 2018 my work

132in a district is not done however as I intend to continue to collaborate with the leadership team including Mr Gorski and Dr alvik to ensure that we continually improve the delivery of instruction that we drive uh Innovation and ensure that our students are educated in a safe and secure learning environment most importantly we need to continue to inform the residents of Monroe Township about a referendum vote on March 13th 2018 we have a lot of work to do to ensure the community is informed about the need for a new middle school before they cast their vote on March 13th there are presentations there these are all listed on the website uh of when on this referendum for instance December 20th at the Renaissance on Route 33 Dr Ali will be presenting to the community members

133January 11th 2018 3:00 p.m. in our Monro Township Library January 18th from 7:00 to 9:00 p.m. at Barkley Brook School in the cath in the auditorium January 25th in Woodland School February 1st in oak tree School February 7th Monroe Township community center and February 15th in our Middle School I encourage people to come out to these meetings these Town Hall type meetings we're going to uh sponsor other meetings as needed we're encouraging neighbors to get involved in our neighbor to neighbor project to help inform their neighbors or or our community on this referendum you've heard many many people speak tonight uh not only for our teachers and and I certainly applaud our teachers uh but also for the need for um you know or a new school or schools so this is very important that

134the community is informed about that just going to mention a couple other things before I go into the personel section um I attended the uh uh band concert at the uh Middle School last night the uh band teachers did an excellent job the kids did an excellent job under the direction of our talent at music teachers and they they performed to in an excellent manner to a packed House of parents uh relatives and community members and before the concert just what every parent wants when they're waiting to go in to see the concert I'm sitting there with the referendum materials but they were were very receptive and and I provided a lot of copies of our plane talk to our parents to inform them of um you know what's coming up with the referendum moving

135on to the Personnel items uh I want to mention two items in there item J is I would like to commend Miss Barbara uh grossa is who is a custodian at our high school for her 14 years of service to the students stff in community of Monroe Township and I wish her much happiness in her retirement and item K I would also like to commend Miss uh Deborah Scott who is a power professional at the at our middle school for her 21 years of service to the students staff and the community of Monroe Township and I wish wish her much happiness in her uh retirement so with that I respectfully uh it's up to you it's up to you how you want to do it however you want to do that okay okay sure okay

136and um in light of Dr kac's um uh Personnel matter um I make a motion that the Monroe Township Board of Education accept the resignation of Dr Michael G kosac from his employment by the board as the superintendent of schools effective June 30th 2018 at 11:59 p.m. the business administrator board secretary is hereby authorized and directed to take all necessary steps to implement this action by the Board of Education I need a second okay any discussion Mr Ryback well I I just would like to say that um it's been a very special three years as of you know in June and um working with you is a certainly bit of pleasure uh your words especially your desire to continue the work uh as forcefully as uh you have been shows uh the kind of professional

137you are Dr kosak I just want to thank thank you and um certainly wish you the best in your future endeavors thank you Mrs L Dr kak I just want to thank you for what you've done here in Monroe especially in your involvement in the fair funding fight and the dedication that you put into that and I wish you the best of luck in all your new Endeavors that you will go forward to thank you Mr Chella yeah I have a few things i' I'd like to thank you for your service also Dr kak but I'd also like to say I'm going to vote no and I'm not I'm not voting to accept this um I think that um you're you're you're uh tendering your resignation based upon the the the factors that are going

138on behind the scenes uh I don't think this is what you really want I I don't care about votes and I don't care about the politics of it but what I do care about is this District what I do care about is making sure that we have a referendum that passes and having a and fighting for a referendum with a superintendent who's going to leave so we have three months until the referendum and then three months after that our superintendent leaves um it still leaves a lot of our plans on finish so we're still looking at the need for another high school or the high school edition we're looking at the need for an elementary school and not to mention that we're looking to make sure that we're not a Ru rudderless ship during the

139interim dur while during that that entire period when we have to do our main task which is to educate our children properly um and I have you know I have children in this District in the school system and I so I've invested interest in making sure that we're doing the right things as far as making sure that we're focused on educating kids and not on anything else so with that I'm going to say that I'm going to vote no I implore the rest of the board to vote no too if we have to if we have to um offer a a shorter duration contract of a year to get us past the referendum and through the implementation of the next one then then I would be open to that but I'm not open to this

140thank you thank you Mr Mayo um I just want to thank you for your work on behalf of the students here and the enthusiasm you have brought to the job here and I wish you the best thank you madam yes uh on behalf of the leadership team uh Dr kak has a poster in his office that said the road to success is always under construction um Dr kak you you uh fixed quite a few potholes during during the the last period of time here and and it's a pleasure working with you um thank you oops and Dr kak if nothing else and I know there's been a lot your fight for funding you're I think you've heard the word referendum a 100 times a day since you've been here I'm I'm sure that we would

141all like not to hear that word again um you brought the IEC Club to us which had a very Rocky start but it had a an awesome ending um the seam initiative so many things but I think your love of Education Your Love of Monroe and especially the love of students is what we're all going to take with that that um you you brought that every day your your attitude and your your smile and and how you treat kids is has been phenomenal so um I to um wish you the best of luck in wherever your future might take you thank you so if there is no other comments or I will comment when I vote no the comments should be made before we vote okay um Dr kak I respect your position however I

142regret hearing this and I'm disappointed for our district um I I believe that you have fought in the best interest of the students and you bring a great deal of academic Integrity to the district that wasn't here in the in the past I also believe that you have supported the the good employees of this town and uh of this district and I I believe that you have supported the teachers to to encourage them to do their very best um and I think you have given a lot of time over and above the time that is in the classroom and you during classroom uh days uh so you'll hear my vote in a minute I would hope that um it is possible that you might reconsider in the new year and uh I I know you

143have an affection for this community and I believe you've brought things to this District that had not been there before and they were positive things so uh I hope you reconsider in the next few months thank you okay at this time we'll take a roll call and this is to accept the resignation of Dr KAC Mrs armeno Dr KAC I accept your whatever you need but I do not accept your resignation so no Mr cherella no Mrs Deo yes Mrs Lang yes Mr Rybeck yes Mrs colano yes madame board president motion passes thank you okay at this time we'll go through the rest of the personel yes not easy but we'll do that before I do just just a quick thank you for everyone's comments I do appreciate that because then we don't have a

144meeting Mr tiella Mr Trella we we if you leave we don't have a quorum and we have to don't have five we don't have five no we need six Madam you're absolutely correct uh in order for the board to conduct business we need a quorum which is a minimum of six members so therefore if Mr chair Cella cannot be encouraged to come back um we would have to discontinue business this evening may I recommend perhaps beg your pardon 5 minute recess I would I would recommend take a recess and try to get Mr we'll take a 10-minute recess I a motion so moved Mr Ryback m a 10-minute recess all in favor I I but I don't have a for the vote at this time um I think we're back into public session I would

145like to thank Mr rutsky for running over here because I know you had an event tonight so without you we would have had to go home early um and I I just want to say that um it's probably um been here I've been here many years I've never had to deal with this before so as as board members we always have um many votes that we like and many votes that we don't like but our responsibility is to the board of education and to just pick up and leave and leave the board in a predicament where we can't carry on is uh regretfully wrong inappropriate um so I just want to say that so I I think we're back to Dr kak and his Personnel Report with that Madam president I would ask the board

146I would recommend items uh a through a l for approval Mr Rybeck is there a second second second by Miss armino is there any comments or questions for Dr kosac okay seeing none we'll have a roll call Mrs armeno yes Mrs Deo yes Mrs Lang yes Mr Rybeck Mr rutsky yes and Mrs kapano Madame board president Personnel items a through a has passed unanimously thank you the uh board action uh respectfully asked the board to um I recommend to the board the passage of items a through o please move Mr Ryback second it Mrs Lang comments or questions again see none one one second it was it might be the revision the revised um agenda no okay good you're good oh okay everybody good yes okay then we'll have roll call thank you Mrs armeno

147yes Mrs Deo uh yes on everything but no on graduation requirement section c so noted Mrs Lang same as Jill yes on everything except the graduation requirement policy letter say and Mr Rybeck yes Mr rutsky yes and Mrs k majority of the members have passed the resolution and board action items a through O Okay that concludes my report okay we will go to the business administrators Report with um Mr Gori Madame board president and members of the Monro Township Board of Education it is recommended that board action items a through F be approved by consent roll call so move Mr Ryback second second by Mrs Lang are there any comments or questions for Mr Gorski no okay roll call Mrs armeno yes Mrs Deo yes Mrs Lang yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr rutsky yes and

148Mrs colon Madam board president board action items a through F has passed I appreciate all the board members who who are here to vote especially Mr rutsky to come back because there was a lot of important business to resolve here with the Personnel reports and the business administrators report contracts uh there would have been a lot of impairments if this couldn't have gone through so thank you very much appreciate it that concludes my report thank you we'll go to the board president's report since this has been a a long meeting I'm just going to wish everybody a very safe and enjoyable holiday season and a very happy healthy prosperous New Year and um when this is all over we'll see everybody in January at this time we'll go to Other Board of Education business if

149anybody from Mr Mayo I do um oh on November 27th Kathy Patty and myself went to see the maker space at Barkley Brook School first I'd like to thank Nicole madira and Aaron Mahoney for inviting us in and showing us how the kids work in this environment for anybody who doesn't know a maker space provides handson creative ways for students to design experiment build and invent as they engage in science and engineering learning the environment is very Hands-On and the students work with many different Tools in groups and alone the room contains elements of a science lab computer lab art room and is designed to accommodate many activities happening simultaneous ously while we were there we saw a second grade class creating um in many different ways some were using 3D pens to create objects

150some were using marble Works to complete a building project and other students were using photo editing software during the second half of the class the students began working in groups they built a Lego robot and then used a computer program and created a code that told the robot which way to move the student students had to actively discuss their ideas with each other and come to a consensus on which way they wanted the robot to move it was really an amazing way for the kids to learn and um I think I can speak for Kathy and Patty also that we thoroughly enjoyed being in that classroom I wished I was in second grade again and I wanted to buy all those those creative things they were awesome I wanted to buy them from my grandson

151but unfortunately he's only 2 months old and not able to play for them for a while so I figured I'll just wait a year or so till he gets that Mr Ryback I just would like to follow up that I also had the pleasure of observing Mega space and um I was really so impressed with the the way the students really work together because you know it's not just academic their learning their social skills and all of those things come together to really produce the kind of uh students and um citizens that I think we're we're we're trying to U um help produce uh in in the schools here uh it's just wonderful to see what they were doing I actually saw I actually saw a 3D printer for the first time and that was

152quite exciting because I never saw one before and then how they use the product uh uh from it uh it's it's it's exciting it's it's what education is all about or at least the way it should be so thank you Mrs Lang um I wanted to share that our U Monica Hines who is our supervisor special ed is working diligently with the parents the special education parents to get the special education parent advisory group going and the meeting that we had hoped we were going to have um this month has been cancelled and instead we'll be meeting January 8th here in the high school media center at 6:30 and span is going to be providing a training on how to develop and Implement a special education parent group and we um really hope that not

153just parents of our special needs students attend but as many teachers and as many members in the community who would like to come please join us on that date um I also wanted to share that on 11 on November 18th I attended the delegate assembly meeting for the New Jersey school boards Association and it was a very interesting meeting what they do at delegate assembly is they come up with resol utions that then they go and and talk to our legislators to get them passed and to be considered into law and two of the big ones that were really important that they passed at this meeting were that um a resolution stating that once a district was given funding by the state that the state can't reduce the amount of funding because a lot of

154school districts last year got hit really hard and had to um lost a lot of money all in one shot so that was one of the resolutions and the second resolution was that um the school boards Association believes that the special education providers the added District providers they can raise their cost to school districts the price that they charge as much as they want every year so njsba is is put out forth the resolution saying that that these added District providers should only be allowed to raise comparable to the 2% cap that school districts do which I think you personally is a much fairer way of doing things so those were two really great things that um came out of of that meeting and then finally I just wanted to also mention that we got

155to come Kathy Steve and I came to watch Graham coac be inducted into the high school the Army High School oh my goodness Dr marching band and it was it was such a it was such a wonderful experience and to see Graham's excitement for the music and everything and I think in January we should all be watching Facebook live to watch Graham March in San Antonio at the all allar All-American All-Star High School football game it is my January 6 I don't know what the time the game is it's an afternoon game he will be marching at halftime which will not be shown on TV but it will be on Facebook so um and I think um we have already talked about honoring him when he comes back at our January I think it's the

15624th meeting and hopefully we'll have video of him watching in the band so that that will be good for all of us to see what what instrument does he play while he marches I believe he's uh low brass um uh Barone horn maybe um cool yeah because he plays bass guitar oh really yeah I think he played a he plays a couple different instruments but Mr Ryback didn't think to ask did you well yeah actually I had a whole conversation with graham about saxophone ah uh because we have a common interest there and uh he's had quite an experience with saxophone I thought he said he played a few different instruments he did but it it was it was very nice okay anyone else okay then we will go to um public forum anyone from

157the public wishing to speak please come to the uh to the microphone give your name and address for the record and we will adhere to our 4minute time limit okay um my name is Frost Khan and my address is by tallak Drive um thank you for allowing me to speak here today my name is froan and I'm a student here at monip high school I'm very grateful for the work this B has board has done and thankful to be able to go to school with the facilities and educational services that exist at this very high school but my peers and I have seen a sharp decline in the quality of the extracurriculars offered over the Year this very board has taken actions which directly hinders students abilities to engage in creativity and Innovation for example

158I recently Incorporated a club an efforts of teaching and inspiring students to embrace entrepreneurship we would do this by launching manyi ventures in which the members of this club would plan design and sell products online through a Drop Shipping model but in order to do this our club would need the initial funds to be able to start such a venture and every idea we sent to the board a me Administration from bake sales to events would end up getting denied who will support our club in these Financial struggles due to these restrictions my club has made little to no progress in its Mission encouraging students to explore entrepreneurship not only that but the new regulations being enforced effectively hinders the promotion of diversity in our school for instance a club by partaken named multiculture Club

159tried to organize a Thanksgiving event in the in the high school allowing students of different backgrounds to bring in food from their respective cultures and serve it to other students all the proceeds grows from this event would have eventually been donated to charitable organizations allowing students um furthermore we plan to allow students to bring canned foods instead of purchasing a ticket for entry which will be donated to food shelters potentially giving a Thanksgiving dinner to a struggling family though we were able to easily hold this event in previous years the policies this board established caused so much chaos that we were forced to cancel event at the 11th Hour you have not only blocked us from engaging in creativity but also from cherishing our student body you may say that fundraisers such as selling snacks

160are against state law but according to my research this is incorrect the New Jersey nutrition policy states that snacks and beverag can be sold before and after school hours as long as they contain no more than 8 gram of total fat per serving and no more than 2 gram of total saturated fats so Beverages and items such as coffee and bagels are completely acceptable under these policies I hope that you're able to address these issues by loosening your stance against student fundraisers and events I these regulations become more and more problematic as the year goes on thank you can you just give me the name of your Club CL again um I run two clubs one is Multicultural club and another club is Monro Corp Monro corp monor Corporation yes okay we we we'll have

161um we'll look into it yes we'll look into it and get back to you all right thank you [Applause] okay Anthony preso equestrian way uh we're going to be very unfortunate to lose you Dr kak I know through experience you're clar act your doors were always open test scores went up I don't know what the board is worried about that they're not going to find anybody better than you and to me one of the major things that you did was you prevented nepotism and cronyism and I know that through experience I can guarantee you when you're gone that's coming back back like the old days I guarantee you it's coming back because I could prove it to you I guarantee you that Dy alage will be superintendent and if I'm wrong I'll come up here

162and apologize I know what's happening here okay wait I could say it I'm in public this is my opinion I have a feeling you were pushed out I know you were pushed out and it's unfortunate the board's not going to get anybody better than you so I'm sorry to see you leave and I guarantee you this is a cronyism move and if I'm wrong I'll apologize but I'm not thank you prakash pup 33 Dina Drive uh I was just outside after the and came to know that Dr kak is resigning and I was shocked even the five people who are standing there outside were shocked I have been observing I have been coming to the board of education for last one year and I have been here in our mro of last 16 years I

163have seen the turnover we need a dynamic person like Dr kak Who has a vision who wants to introduce technology bring up our school our ranking shakes up here and there little bit so what you know we we we need a leadership if if something is forcing you to go we want to know the facts as a public we want to know why we resigning why the board is forcing out and we want to know who which board members are voting you out because it has to be transparent it cannot be oh we cannot disclose it that cannot be accepted because we are the public we are the taxpayers we want to know and if the board members are not renewing the contract this is a critical stage referendum we need vibrant School upcoming school

164so if this is a politics I know how to play the politics so I want to know we want to know the facts out we want him to continue we support him and if the board is not renewing his contract we want to know why who are the board members who are saying nay okay thank you very much thank you anyone else from the public then we will close this public forum and go to the close session resolution be it resolved that the Board of Education of the township of Monroe hereby moves to go into close session in accordance with the Sunshine Law chapter 231 of the public laws of 1975 njsa 10 col 4-6 through 10 col -21 to discuss the following subjects discuss uh discussion regarding pending litigation with student ID number 83636

165harassment intimidation and bullying following closed session action may be taken the discussion conducted in closed session can be disclosed to the public at such time as the need for confidentiality no longer exists is there a motion and a second Mr Ryback Mr Mayo all in favor I opposed then at this time the board will go into Public public uh close session we're roll okay at this time we are back into public session and I have a resolution what am I supposed to say iby move okay I knew should have wrote it down I hereby move whereas NJ a6a colon 3- 1.13 parentheses D parenthesis requires that a board of education provide a resolution authorizing settlement indicating that the District board of education has consented to the terms of the settlement be resolved that the board

166hereby consents to settlement with family and student identification number 83636 pursuant to the terms of the release and settlement agreement attached here to and authorizes the Board of Education president Miss Kath Calla Pano to execute the agreement on behalf of the board second by Mr you moved it so we just need a second right second by Mr Ryback comments questions all in favor U roll call I guess right yes Mrs armeno yes Mrs Deo yes Mrs Lang yes Mr Rybeck Mr rutsky yes and Mrs col yes Madam board president motion passes okay and at this time there we don't have anybody to have a public forum for so we will go to the next scheduled Board of Education meeting which is the reorganization meeting scheduled for January 3rd 2018 7:00 p.m at the Mona Township

167High School motion to adjourn Mr Mayo Mr Ryback all in favor I opposed then meeting is adjourned happy holidays everyone happy holidays

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.