001good evening the meeting of the Monroe Township Board of Education will come to order please stand as our student representatives of the student board members does the Pledge of Allegiance leads us I pledge of allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which stands godible andice thank you may we have a roll call Mr [Music] try roll call Mrs arminia here Mr bra Mr cherro here may here Mrs here Mrs Lang Mrs kin here Mr R here Mr Russo Mr Ry Madam board president you have a farm presence this evening thank you in accordance with the provisions of the New Jersey open public meetings law the Monro Township Board of Education has caused notice of this meeting to be published by having the date time and place thereof
002posted September 7th 2018 at all schools the home news TR cranberry press and filed with cler of the municipality let's go for sorry TR at this at this time we're going [Music] okay at this time we will be going to number five on the agenda the approval of minutes for the closed session meeting of May 23rd 2018 moved by Mr tiella second by Mr Ryback any additions or corrections to the minutes okay seeing none we're going to have a hand vote because last time it got a little complicated so all in favor raise your hand okay one two three four five all opposed one uh abstain two extensions okay thank you there uh this time we will go to our student board members reports and I would like to introduce our new student board member
003as a junior welcome to the Monro Board of Education uh your name Manan man Manan Shaw so welcome uh you have a good um helper there to show you the ropes here and we hope your experience on the board of education is a very positive and successful one so thank you so at this time we will go to your reports um on Friday during Home Room Mr match sorry on Friday during Home Room Mr match Pella made the announcement about her community being a place of respect and diversity we also have bracelets with our theme kindness matters the students will get the bracelets through PE classes thanks Mrs Dylan for approving this last year also high school students receive their new iPads with attached keyboards the increase in apps and restrictions make the iPad a
004greater educational tool students will have their pictures taken during PE classes on September 12th and 13th okay so tomorrow night is back to school night so parents and Guardians will receive a brief overview of each class um of their child's a and bday teachers and also get the chance to attend other programs there's a presentation on the Hib process there's the Falcon school store they can join the PTO and they can meet with the representative from Justin's class rings this Friday the Falcons football team is also playing against New Brunswick and next week is spirit week so every day students get the chance to wear something different depending on the day of the week and it ends on Friday with the pep rally and the homecoming coming game against North Brunswick and finally on October
0054th there will be Club rush so students will get the chance to visit various stalls set up around the commment during the lunch block and get information or join clubs and organizations they're interested in thank you okay at this time we'll go to the closed session resolution be it resolved that the Board of Education of the township of Monroe hereby moves to go into Clos session in accordance with the Sunshine Law chapter 231 of the public laws of 1975 njsa 10 col 4-6 through 10 col 4-21 to discuss the following subject pending litigation Michael G kosac Ed versus Monroe uh Board of Education of the township of Monroe midx County o docket number edu 07970 d18 following closed session action may be taken the discussion conducted in closed session can be disclosed to the public
006at such time as the need for confidentiality no longer exists I need a motion in a second um um Mr Ryback Mr Chella all in favor I opposed Miss armenio is opposing I'm opposed to the timing to the timing to the timing I I think it's not fair to the uh public to have them wait for Clos session until I mean I think it should have been done later in the evening okay thank you and at this time the board will move to go into a close session and I'm thinking it should be about a half hour okay at this time the board will go back into public session and on the agenda we have today a presentation by Maryanne fredman from the New Jersey school boards Association and she is going to help us
007facilitate a conversation on District goals and Board of Education goals so thank you for being here tonight good evening everybody and thank you for having me I just need to put my PowerPoint weren't you supposed to have a public at least announce the public for it's not on the agenda we don't have a public for I thought Mr goodle you told me that it was changed it's number eight I have Nate but I don't have a public for on the closed session okay I don't I'm sorry Michelle I have an old agenda okay before we go into the public forum I mean the presentation by New Jersey school boards um let me see there is a public form for the closed session item only so anyone from the public wishing to speak on the Clos
008session item please come to the microphone state your name and address for the record prakash parab 33 Dana Drive good evening everyone so want to understand the close is for the litigation filed by Dr kak versus Board of Education the litigation is pending litigation between Dr kak and the board of education so Dr kak has filed a case against Board of Education that's as a lay man that's my question we have been saying that for a few months that there is litigation by Dr kak thank you um do you all know how much this litigation is going to cost any estimates at this time I cannot divulge any any information okay uh will publicly notified when the case begins and um all the deliberations go on in the court will the Monro Township Public will
009be parents will be notified on this uh we have not even reached that that um part yet so uh depending on what we can tell you and what we can't we will notify the public as to what we can tell you yeah I advise you all I request you all consult with um the lawyers and make that the public want to be known let it be transparent when the court deliberations go on we want to be there if necessary we want to be witness we will be witness so I request the the Board of Education members to make sure that this process is transparent um this is a statement this all started in October November last year so we need to investigate who started this and why because it is going to cost the taxpayers
010the money now so we need to investigate whether the bylaws were followed if the bylaws were not followed by the members of the or the District administration they should be responsible to pay we public otherwise you'll get another one case from the Public Public will sue you all so let us thank you let us be transparent so that is the request and I'm tired of requesting that is the demand so thank you very much I I have several questions but as this is for close session I will I have no more question thank you anyone else wishing to speak on a closed session item okay seeing not good evening Ram ragat 6 ens Drive mandro uh a quick question will at this point do you will this impact the search process for the new super
011attendant of Monro schools this litigation will that impede the search process this is two different um items so no will not affect the search process no impact and second uh I think just to add to what prakash said uh first of all kudos to prakash I know he's under the weather but appreciate uh again as a responsible mro Township resident coming here to the Boe meetings um I just want to make sure again from a Boe team um as you remember in the public forum many of us had predicted that this is going to be the outcome of the actions uh of not renewing uh Dr kak's contract and and even when the when he was willing to come back how it was handled so uh so so you know we are not surprised as
012a public that this has happened and of course we are worried now this is going to cost us the money uh to the township and as prakash G said uh you know I hope internally within the Boe and the administration some soul searching happens to understand the root cause why we are here and again at some point if there is actually lack of following of the laws or neglect of Duty within the Boe or the administration I think the public should not be accountable uh for any payments to be made if we do end up losing this litigation uh so just wanted to make that comment thank you anyone else okay then at this time we will go to our presentation by um Miss fredman of the New Jersey Schoolboard Association good evening again and
013thank you for having me in tonight I think everybody was here everybody on the board was here last year when we went through this process is that correct everybody here okay so um what I'd like to do is go through the beginning part rather quickly so we can get to the goals if you're okay with that okay okay so you know what the vision is of the district and um actually you have a sheet within your packet a yellow sheet that talks about the district vision statement which is the Monroe Township Board of Education commits itself to all children by preparing them to reach their full potential and to function in a global Society through a preeminent education um goals really are the foundation of your effective policy development they also help for communication they
014hold accountable the district to the community the board to the to the community as well it also forms the basis half of the basis of your superintendence evaluation provides for accountability and continuous Improvement we do believe in a systems approach which means that the total is not just the sum of its parts but that actions are both linked and interwoven and you have the board governance cycle in front of you you completed your superintendent evaluation before July 1st you also have the opportunity to do your board self- evaluation there's no time limit on that so I would encourage you to do that um this year's will be available through the end of December so those that are seated now can take part in that in that self- evaluation and as you know that gives you
015an opportunity to evaluate how you've worked together as a board and how you feel you've done as an individual Board of Education so it's really very important for reflection on how the board is doing and how you all are doing each did you have a question okay um so some data sources that you want to be taking a look at and thinking of when you preparing to set District goals or school performance reports any proprietary assessments that you have um staff community and student input your self- evaluation is always good um and then board committee recommendations additional is suspension and discipline data absentee rates both for students and staff your violence and vandalism reports and then any um bullying intimidation and harassment statistics and culture and climate surveys um moving into the goal development so
016everyone owns the district goals as you all know tonight hopefully you'll develop those collaboratively I believe that the superintendent the Acting Superintendent has has some ideas as to what he would like to see the focus be on the district for the next coming for the upcoming year but everybody owns those after their collabor collaboratively developed the superintendent's responsibility is to achieve those goals but the board's responsibility is to make sure that you're supporting the Acting Superintendent and providing the resources for those District goals they have to do with programs student achievement instruction Personnel um professional development for personnel facilities finance things like that then board goals are to improve board governance structure boards may want to take a look at their committee structure see if they would like to go to a board of the
017whole as opposed to committees or vice versa from committees to a board of the whole and um everyone on the board owns those as well including the superintendent and the business administrator who are considered members of the board non- voting members superintendent's personal goals are usually derived from the previous year's evaluation so they don't apply at this point but um Mr Goodall are you working with a mentor this year yes through CSA ASA okay so they would probably have developed goals with you for this year that would be your superintendent goals and then Merit goals are found can be found in the in the superintendent contract if they're if they exist are miracles in in existence right now no okay okay so you want to consider your vision your mission statement which is also on
018um the sheet that I have in front of you and I'll go through that again in a minute the Strategic plan which you have in place which I have listed on there as well data and then previous goals that have been what's been achieved and what's in progress so these are some of the essential questions we want you to be able to think about what it's going to take to make your students critical thinkers collaborative problem solvers really be able to be civically responsible digitally responsible um culturally responsive with a love of learning the clicker is not doing a very good job I oh okay well we'll go right to the mission statement then the Monroe Public Schools in collaboration with the members of the community shall ensure that all children receive an exemplary education
019by well-trained committed staff in a safe and orderly environment and then you have your strategic planning goals which you have in your packet as well they focus on curriculum and instruction community and engagement and Business Partnership find and facilities and then technology and the Arts and communication so usually what will take place is that your strategic planning go your mission is first and then your strategic planning goals and then your District goals will your annual District goals will fall from that so last year's District goals were to improve student achievement and then there were a number of bulleted items underneath that oops the second was to improve school facilities and I know you have a referendum coming up the third is increased Community involvement and the fourth is improve management and operations so I'd like
020to just ask how you feel you did towards last year's goals I know it was you have an Acting Superintendent now so he can't really address that but from a board's perspective is there anything from last year's District goals that you feel need to be needs to be continued in this year's goals anyone on the board CU I have oh here we are so last year's goals were improved student achievement and the other thing is that a lot of districts are keeping those very broad goal statements and goal areas and then changing the action plans within as you improve and as you move forward with the those goals yes well certainly we have some very important goals we have you know referendum Etc superintendent search but um I'd like to focus for a minute on
021academics because that's something that's near dear to my heart I'm sure um my colleagues here on the board might agree um we did improve we did uh make the 100 uh 99 out of 100 at least uh of the 100 best uh high schools in in uh New Jersey on new from New Jersey a monthly magazine but I'd like to see that I'd like to see us do better I'd like to see that come up and um in general have academic Improvement across the board for a Bo a board goal I'm sorry a board goal District district a district goal District goal okay so that would go in line with improving student achievement so you would have items then underneath that that you could as that the super the assist the acting super could address
022right okay was there anything specific under those under the improved student achievement that you wanted to see continued of those bulleted items you're asking me specifically on the board I'm sorry you ask me specifically anybody you or anybody this works best if everybody provides some feedback yes so the first bullet was to continue to develop Innovation through real world and project-based learning explore programs and Partnerships to advance stem initiatives use data to continue to improve student Proficiency in language arts literature Math and Science and develop the whole child through cultural awareness character development and an emphasis on healthy lifestyle yes I'd like to see um I think more students taking AP and taking the test and passing uh advanced placement a test I can't hear so an increase in the number of students taking AP
023classes and passing the AP test a actually I think we could continue with all of them because I don't think I don't think you ever achieve them you but you continue to move all of these goals forward I just like to see the I I know that I'm just that's fine I just um you know when looking at these I think so I I think you're right I think these are things that we we have to continue to strive for I mean uh uh you know academic achievement is one thing but getting our our children into the best university should be another but I don't know that that needs to be you know bulleted under the under the goals but it's something that I'd like to see you know that we're always looking to increase
024enrollment in the best schools that our that our kids are getting into in more IB League schools right right in speaking to the administrative team and looking back at uh last year's goals uh we had an idea of streamlining and I'll show I have a few slides to present streamlining you like to do would you like to do that now if if when you're finished with your presentation well that's that would be good because then we could they could discuss those and consider those for actual goals for the district do you want me to flip that yeah I'll have to I didn't know my ears this this yours yeah okay so just to continue my point in speaking with the administrative team um central office the building principal's supervisors um that we made an effort
025to streamline some of the goals from last year into our goals for this year and we felt that some of the goals from last year should be ongoing and continuous this year so in the area of student programs not specifically uh improving a test score but just the development of programs to continue and develop and expand our stem initiatives K through 12 we do a lot at the high school we have an stem academy uh we have uh Project Lead the Way which is an engineering program some of the elementary schools have a lot of stem initiatives where they have parent uh family nights and a lot of stem activi so we were looking across the board uh to increase those initiatives throughout the district uh in addition we did a lot of work last
026year through the whole child committee to work on not only the academic but the social and emotional um supports for students for their success so there's a lot of professional development that we're going to plan for this year to go along in ensuring that wellness and uh activities are embedded in everything that teachers do so we have a lot planned for that this year in addition uh one of our more successful programs I don't want to steal the Thunder of the curriculum committee report but uh our unified programs at the high school which is an integrated phys program for our regular students and special needs students has been very successful and in me speaking with parents in our district um there was a call for to they know about this program at the high school
027but a call to expand it throughout the district and so the unified program which I'll you'll hear at the uh curriculum committee uh report uh some of the things that are going on there we'd like to discuss and expand that um even throughout the district K2 can may I ask a question or make a statement sure um for bullet number two the whole develop the whole child expanding professional development Community engagement I I know I've said it before and I and I'm just going to just say it again because I think it's important just to our our student population has changed you know our demographics are shifting are we have uh from what I what I remember 34 or 35% of our student population now is of Indian descent and I think that if we're
028going to look at community engag engagement um it has to be you know all all all those different parts have to be recognized so I really think it's important for us to look at our calendar and look at creating holidays um that also reflect so cultural awareness those cultural holidays right and I think that's important and when I grew up um you know we we grew up and and Jewish holidays were implemented it I didn't know what those were rashash Shana yam kapor and things like that but as over time we learned it because we were celebrating those holidays also we had off so you start learning why you're off what and those kind of things and I think that helps you as a as a child understand the you know your your your peers
029so I just think that we're at a point now where 34 or 35% of our children should be recognized you know that that that should be embraced and we should and I know we we use in staff and service days and things like that but I think we need a Bonafide holiday like we do with Easter and things like that so that's all you could actually address that if you don't mind um continue to develop the whole child through expanding professional development cultural awareness and Community engagement would that work Mr um I don't know if you're going to address it in another place but um I would like to see and we've had calls from the community I think everyone would be happy to see a little bit more Civic un understanding and government teaching
030our children uh what it means to be uh an active and engaged CI citizen historically as well as current um you know I I know we have things like where the kids go to the municipality and they have a government thing but I'm talking about across the board um to in a specific uh um program that talks directly about New Jersey governmental things uh uh state government and federal government and you know I I just think it's it's lacking I I've been told that it's over a broad curriculum a lot of it's embedded in what we do but I certainly not acceptable I think we need a specific a specific program that talks about it in a very a con a very specific form of how government of how our government works I mean we're
031supposed to we we want our children to be Global ready and intellectually prepared for it but I think we also need to have them prepared for their engagement as Citizens and I think now more than ever uh we need we need an actual program that talks about that how you want to develop it is something uh that the the academics uh need to decide but I I think it should be very specific and not spread out Mr rck yeah um I just want to pick up on what Miss alino said because I think it's pretty important so thank you um if I'm not mistaken Dr alvic good all you can correct me if I'm not factual on this I think the state is actually looking at the creation of a course at the middle school
032specifically for civics so maybe it be worth our while to sort of be the head of the pack so to speak and start investigating this the creation of such a I was going to make the we were going to bring the district supervisor of social studies involved in the conversation with me and Dr ALC too she is looking at that to implement that now she she ordered a uh textbook last year to be used in the eth grade social studies classes on Civic education can we make that part of the district goal though specifically specifically mentioned just like you have a stem you have stem mentioned specifically I'd like to see a Civic program mentioned as a goal I agree so add a add a bullet for civic understanding and engagement state and federal government
033um and and yeah and and actual governance you know or local state and federal local state andal locate Federal okay everybody on board with that okay with that thank you Michelle you're welcome the second uh District goal was to expand and improve school facilities as you know uh the board approved the resolution to go out for referendum details to follow for the spring of 2019 and as part of a goal the administrative team would like to be a part of and the critical part of um detailing uh the plan for that referendum using the latest enrollment data and projections to ensure we have a number of unhoused students in the middle school and the high school to ensure that our future uh is bright and that we have facilities to match the enrollment uh now
034and for the future we would also like to uh continue to develop plan for expanded Bus Parking deep um right now we have to contract out for a few buses we don't have a full in-house busing uh Transportation um which we think is much more preferable so we would like to continue the plan of trying to um finalize an expanded uh Bus Parking Depot and in addition to that as a result of uh a lot of conversations safety meetings last year actions and support uh from our Police Department the training of armed officers in our schools but to continue to evaluate and develop uh potential security measures at some of our schools identified um through uh the administrative team and some of the brought to our attention from the parents uh some of our uh
035elementary schools lack the inclosures um that perhaps can prevent uh uh something unfortunate from happening and through capital projects we would like to explore and through security grants offered by the state some potential capital projects for the following year to ensure that our schools are as safe as they can be and then the final goal is over the summer um I was fortunate enough to be at the sign the S2 signing in which the district received additional State funding and we will continue that fight um we're not completely satisfied with the amount of money this district is getting we believe that we are still underfunded but we will continue uh to seek fair and Equitable state aid funding engaging our legislators and engaging the community was all part of the fight in our past the
036community the Board of Education the administrative team was very active in uh fighting for more additional state aid uh for our district and we will we want to continue that as part of our uh goals for this year does anybody have any questions for Mr Goodall I I agree I I I agree with uh I I agree with the goals uh District goal two though I think that I just wanted to reiterate what you said about the busing uh we need to move toward having our own Fleet entirely 100% our own um there are too many too many issues there are too many issues with communication um we I think our transportation department does an excellent job of managing uh the bus the bus routes and the and our employees and and and the communication
037between the the buses when they're out on those routes uh it's very difficult and I know I'm preaching to the choir here but it's very difficult to reach the buses once they the the contract buses once they leave uh we also have security measures on the buses we have cameras and things like that and I just think we're we're we're cutting our nose off to spite our face by going with contract buses I know I know it's been a problem with growth because of growth and and how quickly we grew and so the need was there to bridge the gap but I think uh and and budget budgetary concerns and things like that but I think that we really need to just move toward 100% of our own Fleet and that's it I'm done anyone
038else have any comments or questions from Mr goodle is the board comfortable with those three goals okay so with the with the additions so what we'll have I'm going to ask Michael would you please email me this PowerPoint tomorrow that would be great I did write most of it down but some of it I missed um so the what happens now is that the board is collaboratively has collaboratively agreed to these goals with the superintendent and the goals are the what they are what you want to see happen in the district the superintendent then with the administrative team will develop action plans for those and the action plans are the quote unquote the how so he determines how he's going to get you from point A to point B you should be able to see
039those action plans and review them but you really excuse me you really don't want to dabble in the action plans okay because that's the how his responsibility is to take you from point A to point B he has until June 30th to do that because that's the year so what you want to do then is to have conversations and to develop a timeline for how often you want to have updates on the progress towards the achievement of those District goals we recommend usually three or four times a year so September you would appro you would approve those goals or adopt those goals then in November or December you could have an update in February or March you would have an update which coincides with getting ready for the superintendent's evaluation which works nicely and then
040in June he would give you a final update on how he did towards the achievement of the goals so keep in mind when you do the superintendent evaluation because there that's a process and it takes time for everybody to be able to get their information in you really need to give about two months to complete that and then by Statute it has to be completed Soup To Nuts by July 1st or you will lose points in qack for that okay so that's important yes I I think um going back to District goals and I'm sorry I didn't bring this up before but I think one of our district goals at least should be under discussion is um a search for a superintendent that would be a board goal okay so we'll we'll get into that
041we'll do that okay yes yeah on the this District goals uh did we go through number four improve management operations that's actually the last if you click to the next goal okay streamline a little bit from uh last year I would like to make one suggestion if I can that can be included okay yeah sure okay so due to the growth in the district I would like to see a comprehensive review of the current organizational structure what works what doesn't and recommendations for a new structure do you want the Acting Superintendent to do that yes structure meaning administrative structure structure or yeah the organizational structure for administration yes do you be able to handle four goals well that would be part that would be part of this one part of improved management and operations okay
042so that would be another action item under that it's a big one overwhelm him with too many goals having not had well you're right but I would think that something like this can actually uh make things work better and will underwhelm him maybe he'll have more time for other can you can you repeat that language cuz I want want to write it down too Mr Goodall did you give us these goals anywhere this isn't written anywhere no I'm going to update that and and then I will send it to you okay but can we what kind of language and you'll also have them in my memo which I'll send you tomorrow afternoon did you write down I wrote down comprehensive review of the organizational structure with recommendations okay would have does that satisfy well I
043would no no comprehensive revieww I would like him to identify what works and what does that's important and then to make recommendations for for a new structure all due respect you can't make recommendations for a new structure unless that should be a if in fact it's deemed to be well ins insufficient right so you you you have put a little you've been here a number of years I'm sure the structure will be new so I have I took it as a comprehensive review of organizational structure with recommendations and he you wanted added what works and what doesn't work yes because if I mean I think that would go along with the comprehensive review but if you'd like the wording in there and the rest of the board is okay with that sometimes it's better to
044spell it out I think it just the rest of the board has to agree that's all okay all right CU these aren't my goals for you these are your goals for you and to Mr we can we can change last part and say and recommendations as SE if necessary more details are are better you're right there you go and if it's if it's deemed necessary then recommendations should follow so the goals that we are creating today would they have to be formally adopted at the next board meeting yes they should be formally adopted at the next board meeting and then um you need to give the the Mr Goodall some time with the administrative team to come up with the action plan items for each of these the action plans um when I get back
045to to my um PowerPoint will determine what the the stepbystep action items are for each of those and then we'll give who the resources are for that who's responsible for it what the timeline is and how will we know when we've achieved it how we know that it's been accomplished so those are the things then that you want to be looking at As you move forward through the year to see because you're always evaluating the superintendent didn't come this spring on progress towards the achievement of the goals so if you're seeing the action plans and you're seeing in December that everything that was supposed to be completed by November 31st was or I don't even know how many days November has 30 I think right 30 30 okay I was never good at that um
046so you would look at it and see anything that was supposed to be completed before November 30th was were those things all completed and if they were then you know you're on progress and then the next time you have the the update would probably be in March and then you would have you would go through and say okay everything that was supposed to be done by the end of February was was it completed if it wasn't what was the you know what was the cause of that was it something that was unavoidable and how are we moving forward with that and what's the new time frame for completing that and that way when you go in to sit down because superintendent as you know will need to drop in the goals in the evaluation the
047online evaluation and we'll need to give himself a rating on whether he achieved them satisfactory progress was made or little or no progress was made and then he writes comments and then when the board goes in you'll be able to see the district goal statements what the superintendent has written and you'll be able to give achieved satisfactory progress or little or no progress has been made and you'll be able to write comments when you add first of all when you go in you can see the superintendent's information but you can't change it okay so that will be gray out for you you'll be able to see it you won't see what anybody else has written in terms of board comments until the very end when you get that compilation back okay so you would only
048be able to see your own comments but it's really important that you have these updates on the progress because when you sit down first of all Mr Goodall it's to his benefit and it's to your benefit to know where you are with the district goals when you sit down to do his evaluation because half of it is on the district goals and on progress towards the achievement of that but Mr Goodall can start the action plan today yes no he's he will he can start he know I think he has a good idea that you're going to approve these goals I'll be typing up a memo of what we talked about tonight sending it to you by tomorrow afternoon I usually send it to the superintendent the business administrator the board president vice president and
049I ask you to review it it'll have a boatload of attachments to it and I'll ask you to review it and send it out to the rest of the board and then you can even make adjustments to that as you see fit while you know before you adopt the goals so when you look at that if there's something in there that wasn't that wasn't included that we talk that I missed if I missed something you can add that or at the next meeting when you go to adopt those if there's something else that you'd like to see considered you can bring that up and ask if it can be added if the rest of the board is is on board with that then that's okay to add okay thanks okay so we good with the
050the district goals there are three District goals with a number of B under each one everybody's good every okay okay okay board gos okay so these were your board goals for last year comments on whether you feel anything on here needs to be included and up and continued for next year you had evaluate and adopt a plan for enrollment growth and facility needs continue professional development for board members reviewing the sampling of programs um and I did come in I think once or twice over the course of the year and then improve committee communication and reports with other board members is there anything on there that you feel you would like to continue for this upcoming year would goal one continue to be the ref a referendum it can be because we would have to
051do that's an important piece that the board has to do this year you could have the board involved in the referendum okay and you could also develop and Implement a plan with Administration to provide um um I just lost my my train of thought education on for the to the community on the referendum so you could do something like that or you could have that one doesn't matter I think they both say the same thing the one speaks specifically to developing and implementing a plan with the superintendent and the administrative team to to engage in education to the community on the referendum and I think uh I think that that first goal also balances with the overall um District goals because we're supporting them that because they're doing facility needs and and those kind of
052things and then we're also working together working together to make sure that that happens okay so we'll keep the first goal yeah okay what about two and three I think we can still improve on number three I'm sorry you said to continue with number three I think so everybody WR in board dos you could find all your committee rep all your board dos was a big help with that it was yeah something it is because you can go in and just pull it you can pull the policies you can pull the different things that would discussed and review it right it has all the agendas for the meetings meeting minutes I I I don't know what else because otherwise you'd have to look at another venue for doing that I think we spent a lot
053of time doing that yeah okay but if you think it's important no I think I think for number two we may want to continue to encourage professional development of board members because obviously we can't de demand it although you know we I think we'd like I know I like um professional development but I think uh to encourage it uh might be a little better warning I agree you agree am I am I hearing number two I'm sorry I'm getting very dry number two is okay to continue with yeah encourage professional for all board members H how do we encourage people motivate just ask them to take more training classes yeah I think so and I think that you know we we we get those those are those things online maybe there's a way to just
054well we we ask our staff and our Administration to do professional development it's to our benefit to do it ourselves too and we always have the Atlantic City um Workshop that's very good in helping that so if I can add on October 2nd the um you probably are aware that we had a task force on non-college bound student Learners and the task force will be rolling out that report in North Brunswick on October 2nd October 3rd is a middle sex County meeting association meeting so you can go to to those it doesn't cost you anything to go to those doesn't cost you to go to the roll out either um if you can't make October 2nd for the roll out it will also be rolled out at Workshop in Atlantic City in October so you
055might be able to do that if you can't do October 2nd but you have County meetings four times a year that you can go to and it doesn't cost anything and they do provide training for you and I'm there so and there's a legal course um October I think October third governance four will be held on Thursday in at in Atlantic City at Workshop oh no no there's one though in the county meeting is going to have a school law component to it on October 3rd what time is the county meeting County meetings usually start at 6 you're provided with dinner and networking opportunity and then we usually start the meeting at about 6:45 and we're usually done between 800 and 8:30 there's legal there's a legal training seminar in Trenton tomorrow there is but
056that and uh it it that I think would have to be voted on tonight because it has to be registered through the business administrator yeah there was a cost to that that's why it needs to yeah but there was there's leg there's legal seminars that they they say who who can go but board members can go as well I unfortunately I can't go tomorrow or I would have signed up for but they're very informative they are yeah we signed up for one um for October but it was free so we didn't we didn't have to go through the board Maryann that's Madam yes that's an important consideration is there any cost for this because if there's no cost then there's no uh re requirement to for which the legal program tomorrow there is a cost
057for that but not for the county meeting on October 3rd and not for the roll out of the task force on non- colge bound Learners on October 2 was not 1999 tomorrow I think was $199 yeah but I'm not I'm not positive but I know there was a cost to it okay but we've also so you know our County programs run run four times a year four or five times a year and there's always is an educational component to that and you get credit you get individual credit when you go out to the county meetings when I come in for the amount of time that I'm here you get an hour as a credit you have seven and a half credits there's 16 needed in a 4-year period so you board for the board so
058remember there's a board bucket of credits and there's an individual bucket of credits when somebody from njsba comes into you you get board credit for that if seven of nine of you were here with the superintendent and an hour is a credit when you come out for anything any programs County meetings to the task force there'll be credit for that the legal program tomorrow I believe has credits assigned to it um when you go to Workshop if you go to any action labs and group sessions you get credits for those as well but that's all individual credits so you can achieve certification as an individual board member and as a board right now you have 7 and A2 plus whatever tonight brings um credits toward board certification that you could work towards that 16 and
059become a certified board through njsba okay okay so maybe that's how you encourage it Frank right we would make the goal that we're moving towards certification and then and so then we would encourage board members to go because we' get certified would would that be part of number two or would that you want that two two okay so in terms of board certification or individual Mr Russo had asked how we how we encourage that so that would be one way that we're moving toward the gold board certification so if we have if we if we're always cognizant of the how many credits we need then we could maybe as these things pop up say all right I'll go to this one you go to that one and this way we get that certification you think
060it's it's more like when you come in and speak to the board as a whole than you get bored certification so every time you get some board training or when we do this or you know when we sometimes in the spring when we have uh you come in and tell us how to do the superintendent evaluation that's how you get your board credit right but I I it doesn't hurt to try to become board ass certified either and the two buckets never mix so but you can always find on our website when you log in if you log in on the upper right side you can get your transcripts and you can see ex and and what happens is individual credits never expire board credits fall off after four years so right now that 7
061and a half credits is actually from 2015 so credits I don't remember how many I think you had two in 2015 two or three so you would need another eight and a half to get to six0 I'm sorry so I need to attend one of your math classes go um well it you would need to get you would need to get to 16 and if you got to 16 by March you could get your award in the at the spring County meeting so if not that two or three credits that you had from 15 will fall off but then you'll still have another you know four or five credits as of right now not counting tonight I'll I'll all of that will be included in the the memo that I sent you Mr Ryback I
062I just want to say Maran we're very fortunate to have you as a rep because thank you um I know I wasn't sure where I stood with credits and um I contacted you and you were good enough to look up everything and tell me exactly what I needed so uh we have somebody here that's knowledgeable and very helpful thank you thank you you're welcome there was yes number four superintendent search okay as a Bo goal okay did you want can I just ask did you want to keep three or was three you felt that three was need three okay so put that as three please okay so engage in the super in a superintendent search process yes everybody good with that okay yes okay so instead of me going over there and typing and you
063can't see me and nobody can hear me um what happens next with the board goals so I'll type all of this up so what happens next with the board was there anything else that you wanted to add to board goals we're at three that's good okay so what'll happen next is you'll need to develop action plans for the board goals so usually what will happen is sometimes the board president will ask committee chairs if you work with committees to get the committee chairs to get together and to come up with action plan items you have a sample template in on the leand side of your packet and there's also a sample of board goals and what an action plan can look like for them I'm going to send you all of this electronically tomorrow with
064the plethora of attachments that I send to you so you will have it electronically but the Board needs to develop action plans for the board goals with the same thing what are the items that are going to fall under each one what are the time frames excuse me what are the time frames that you want to accomplish these things by and how will you know that you've achieved those okay and we really suggest that the board report out on the board goals when you ask the superintendent to report out on the district goals because what happens a lot of times what happen I was on my board for nine years the first couple of years we did this with our field service rep she came in we established district and board goals we set up
065time frames for the superintendent talked to us about progress on the district goals we never talked about the board goals she'd come in at the end of the next year and she'd say so how you do on the board goals last year haven't talked about them since we developed them so you want to be moving forward on the on the board goals just like you want the superintendent to be moving forward on the district goals so that's why we always recommend that somebody report out on the board goals each time the superintendent reports out okay so that's four times a year four times before it's really up to you all to determine how often you want to do that um we usually recommend that in September goals are adopted and then that there be a
066November update then a March update and then a June update so the June would be the final one the March one would coincide with the starting of so it could be the end of March the starting of the superintendent evaluation you want the superintendent to give you a verbal update a couple of times a year but specifically before he goes in and sits down to do that superintendent evaluation because he wants you to know exactly where the district is and you want to know and need to know where the district is so that you can do an informed evaluation of the superintendent now I understood from training that if we do that we should also give the superintendent suggestions before their evaluation is that correct we shouldn't have there shouldn't be anything uh surprising really
067s yeah surprising or very very negative on the evaluation he should be informed before we get to the evaluation in the end of the year as to what our either concerns are or well typic so typically it would fall in line with no surprises okay so we believe very firmly in and strongly in no surprises from the board to the superintendent and no surprises from the superintendent to the board so if things are going on you have ample opportunity during the course of the year to have those conversations you can have them individually with the superintendent if you have them with the board with the superintendent you have to rise the superintendent and you have to do those things in executive session because that wouldn't be public um but the other thing that I want
068to really point out and strongly about with the superintendent's evaluation is you need to look at the entire year in review when you're doing the superintendent evaluation right not just the last conversation that you had right so I probably said this last year if I did I apologize for repeating myself but if you have a conversation with the superintendent the day before you sit down to do his evaluation and he says by the way I got your son or daughter into Harvard and it's not going to cost you anything don't give him Exemplar and commenda bles on everything but likewise if he call if you have a conversation with him the day before you sit down to do that and he says I couldn't help get your child into Harvard and there isn't any money
069so you're going to have to pay the full ride don't give him any of the items that are in um executive which would be Personnel student Personnel negotiations anything like that acquisition of land contracts those kinds of things okay okay this really just does not want to work okay so now you have District goals for the upcoming year you have board goals for the upcoming year I'll type everything up tomorrow morning send it to you tomorrow afternoon again there'll be a bunch of attachments I'll send it to the board President and Vice President the superintendent and the business administrator I'll ask them to take a look at it just to make sure I got everything um Mr Gorski if you could send me the superintendent's um PowerPoint in the morning I can just make sure
070that I got everything and then you can send it out to everybody else and um you'll be good to go to start working okay any questions yes Maran I have a question that's um well it doesn't pertain to board goals or District goals but it has to do with board professional development okay so if it's okay I'd like to ask that sure um we've been having some discussions lately about what's appropriate in closed session as far as minutes okay and I just think it might help us uh um if you can give us New Jersey school boards bent on that okay usually executive session has to do with student Personnel staff personnel um any kind of negotiations could have to do with any litigation it could have to do with um any kind of contracts
071that you might be talking about negotiating whether it's with an outside Source or a busing company or whatever um any kind of land acquisition there are things that are delineated that are the only things that you can talk about in executive session and those things have to remain confidential until they no longer are deemed necessary to be confidential so if you're you're talking about negotiations in executive session you would likely have on your minutes that you all get or that go out to the public for executive session minutes that the board went into executive session and discussed negotiation okay it may be the Teachers Association contract it may be administrators it may be Transportation however you might do that usually the business administrator will keep a little bit more detailed of an executive session minutes
072so that if and when that information is no longer considered confidential or detrimental to the district by releasing that information then that information can be released but until that time you would have for instance for tonight you went into executive session to discuss litigation you would have on the public minutes that are for executive session litigation so it's not specific it's General it's it's usually very general what goes out to the public and what you would actually approve at the meeting okay because it's confidential for a reason if it's not kept confidential it could impede the negotiations it could impede negotiations on the litigation it could impede um land acquisition any of those things it could harm staff or students so whatever the item whatever the need for the confidentiality is until it's no longer
073deemed confidential where it could impact the district in a negative way or or whoever it's about in a negative way it's not it's you you there are some things you cannot be transparent about that's the the long and the short of it there are things that that go on in executive session that you cannot be transparent about until the need for confidential confidentiality is no longer needed okay thank you does that answer your question and just to follow up because we keep having this discussion in public but once the confidentiality is no longer and I understand you can't put names or or certain things but once that confidentiality is over it can it can be released what kind of discussion went on within that closed session usually it's that a discussion took place and then
074and then what will happen is you can't vote on anything in executive session that's correct so when you come out you would take a vote and that would give the public the information that they needed to know which was what action did the board take because they have a right to know what action you're taking but sometimes the deliberations have to remain confidential for obvious reasons so they may not necessarily be able to know why you voted the way you did I I I respectfully disagree with that assessment but I think there's some law there's some in fact Monroe at one point was sued by John path for not having comprehensive Clos session minutes so I think there's some documentation out there that suggests that we can be a little bit more detailed with some
075of the close session minutes I would encourage you then to check with your board attorney on that okay because that's the person that is empowered to give you legal advice because you hire them for that I know School boards is is not fond of O Oprah and op open public records and open public meetings act but it is the public after all that is governing us well they've put their trust in you right to get the information to make sure that you have the information you need to make an informed decision in the manner in which they should know how that decision in which you vote sometimes that's not possible for as I said for obvious reasons there are times that you're going to need to to be able to say to somebody I can't
076I can't share with you all the information that led me to my vote because it's confidential but I can tell you that I did the best job that I could with the information that I had and I made sure I had enough information to make an informed decision okay okay but check with your board attorney I'm not an attorney and I've never played one on TV so thank you okay all right thank you so much okay have a good rest of the evening good rest of the meeting and I will talk to you all soon thank you for being here with us this evening thank you okay so we will move on with the our agenda and have a excuse me budget philosophy discussion Mr Goodall Mr Gorski Dr Ali are you I think we're
077doing it from here I don't know we doing okay we should have a do you need a mic yeah that would be great thanks sor thanks no we don't have it is there anything on our pet we don't have a copy of this right correct okay good evening on behalf of Acting Superintendent Goodall Dr alvic and most importantly significant contributors toward this development of a budget philosophy coming from the principles the vice principles all the way down to the teaching level we want to impress upon everybody that this development of a budget philosophy is a Grassroots initiative that goes all the way down to the classroom vice principal supervisor director assistant principal uh level so that we can ascertain from them what their needs are for the forthcoming school year and this would be a
078budget Philosophy for the fiscal year 20192020 mon Township Board of Education consists of board president Kathy kapano board vice president Mr Steven Ryback Mrs Michelle armeno Mr Marvin Braverman Mr Ken Chella Mrs Jill Deo Mrs Patty Lang Mr Frank Russo da Corino and James Berg representative and finance committee chair Mr Paul rutsky what is a budget philosophy the philosophy of establishing the annual school budget should entail the creation of a framework for a budget that supports a democratic plan of appropriate funding for the implementation of educational programs so that students May develop and learn from quality experiences based upon educationally sound and fiscally prudent planning a solid Financial base is Paramount to ensuring that the school district will be able to meet the responsibility of preparing our students for an increasingly competitive environment the budget
079philosophy stage should be macro focused rather than micr focused as much more refinement will be required and implemented in the future through the rigorous budget process budget Appropriations Appropriations are are a sophisticated word for spending are based upon student enrollment this this slide shows how the district enrollment has grown over the years and next year for 1920 we are conservatively expecting approximately 200 additional students a lot of that enrollment projection depends upon when the students are going to materialize from the Housing Development which is not an easy assertation but we can conservatively say we are expecting 200 additional students for next year some budget appropriation considerations are as follows salary and benefits are approximately 75% of the general fund budget aggregate District salaries are approximately $66 million and on average will con contractually increase 3%
080or $2 million in next year's budget health benefits have been projected to increase 8.5% at this very early stage with the caveat that claims will have to be monitored at least through January 200 uh 20 to receive an accurate estimate 1819 health benefit premiums are budgeted to be 22 m774 th000 and are offset by contractual contributions of approximately $4.1 Million by District staff members okay Dr Dr alvic you want to talk about the Personnel uh budget Appropriations okay so working with the building principles the directors in the district and the supervisors these are some considerations that we have for next year's budget um with regards to Personnel this is due to increased Staffing uh increase student enrollment um and increase needs within our districts we've tried to maintain as best we can um throughout the
081years with the Staffing that we have um but with the in with the increased number of students we are increasing this so we are um considering again these are just considerations for the budget none of these have been gone through the budget defense rounds or um final looks at numbers and final look at classroom spaces um but these are some things that we're looking at so uh looking at certificated teaching staff members you can see the list there um special education Staffing members including teachers speech therapists power professionals and nurses um specific the nurse is for the esy program um our numbers in our esy program continue to increase each year um technology Personnel we continue with with the more students we have more devices in our district and more programs that we're using online
082so having additional technology Personnel um and two down from that is the E educational technology facilitator um currently we have one in our district that works with all of our current uh certificated sta staff members and our teaching staff members um so a um a need would be to increase that support for our staff um as we're moving towards schooly in our district as we're moving to and at the high school we have the online um textbooks online resources um online uh programs that we use in our classrooms a K to 12 having that extra support for the teacher so that we are utilizing these to the best of our abilities in the classroom um and helping the teachers use them as much as they can with the students to support learning um we have
083not increased our supervisors in this district and they are maxed out with their responsibilities we continuously add um responsibilities to their workload um so looking to support educa uh special education um and looking to support some of our um programs that are in the district um that would be recommended um and an athletic trainer we are increasing our number of Sports at the Middle School we have not increased our athletic trainers position there um so looking at we added three more Sports to the Middle School this year we still have the same athletic trainer there um and looking at the grounds maintenance worker again more students in sports means more grounds that need to be covered um so looking at that the grounds maintenance um also looking at our technology so one of the things
084that we do look at each year is technology wears out so we have to continuously replace and replenish our technology so not only replacements for some of our outdated outdated devices outdated um wireless network but also additional devices for increased student enrollment um specifically looking at some of our programs at the high school in digital art TV production business educ education and Technology education resource uh courses to support the technology needs of those classes um and then also our special education population the continuous needs there to add technology devices um looking at our textbooks the supervisors each have a five-year plan that they take a look at their their textbooks within their programs um we are more and more moving to classrooms without textbooks such as our um English language arts classes do not have
085textbooks um we provide the teachers with libraries in their classroom so that students have more choice in what they're reading um and they use a lot of online resources but we still use textbooks in French one and science so really looking at those books to support the curriculum documents um and science specifically because we've just we we have are in the process of still implementing the new nextg science standards so making sure we're updating our resources to go along with the updated um standards some of our programs looking at considerations there um some of our instruments we need need to add and replace some of our aging um band equipment and some of it is quite expensive when you start looking at some of the bigger pieces so um appropriating some money for for in
086that area we are also continuously increasing again our student student uh special education population because we're keeping more students in house so making sure we're providing those programs so self-contained classrooms um we would need to increase possibly two next year so that would that cost would include everything from outfitting the classroom Staffing um Power professionals making sure that uh and all of the resources that are needed for the students again our high school weight room um because we it is used very often by students we have to monitor the equipment and it gets um um looked at every year we evaluate it but it is there are some pieces that are in need of replacement as you know we have been increasing um or adding to our volleyball program boys volleyball program next year will
087be the third year which means we will then we will finally have a high school boys varsity volleyball team um so that would include the coaching stipend and something that comes up every year from the community something that we continuously look at is to be start to begin to add a swim team and this is something we've looked at it doesn't always make the cut when we come down to the final budgeting um process but it's something that we definitely are still looking at to in to imp um Implement into the high school transportation it is recommended that Fleet replacements for safety and enrollment growth occur according to our facility director and our schedule of required retirements for buses we will need to budget for nine new 54 passenger buses with video GPS and radio
088components that'll cost over a million dollar 425 passenger vans with video GPS radio components nine additional contracted drivers with Benefits four additional Transportation AIDS the this projected number of new buses Vans and staff includes going online with the new bus depot where land is being donated by the township on schoolhouse of Buckaloo Avenue behind the firehouse to expand the bus fleet we are maxed out right now with the amount of In-House bus staff and the ability to service buses in the transportation department we are spilling over parking buses at the schools now but that doesn't allow for servicing it doesn't allow for snow removal in the winter we need to expand that Fleet and as was mentioned previously this will supplant our need for contracted buses which I believe we are all in agreement transportation
089and administration uh is is best served by in-house Transportation uh staff from a facility standpoint we have the following projects that have been compiled by our facility director Mr Jerry T flooring projects at Brookside School are required $41,000 replace wooden bleacher boards with aluminum $67,000 Barkley Brook carpet replacement in paint $104,000 replace in transa security camera system servers and software upgrades 88,000 replace Stadium synthetic field and rubber running track $1 million new wireless microphones to replace existing 600 MHz equipment 34,000 Athletic Field line striping unit field service grooming Tractor $34,200 Monroe Township Middle School design and Engineering Services for New Jersey doe submission and bidding for the replacement of the 1997 Edition roof and mechanical equipment for the summer of $132,000 for the design and Engineering Services for the roof replacement so that we could
090start that process storage shed building for winter salt truck and supplies 48,000 construct bus lot at new site on Route 522 and repay the existing bus parking lot we're waiting for a proposal from epic management but we're estimating for the time being that the cost for that could be2 million to $2.5 million that is going to be a very large consumption of Appropriations if approved by the board in the 1920 budget and as I mentioned previously please do not focus on any individual line items here this is very rough look at it in the aggregate we want you to just get a flavor of what we're seeing coming for next year none none of this stuff is guaranteed to make it even into the defense rounds but this is what we're seeing at this juncture
091Dr Alvi do you want to talk about our accomplishments so some of our accomplishments um our 2017 18 graduation rate was 98.2% of students which is very high for our um and it's the highest we've been um our June 2017 graduates we have not compiled the June 2018 data yet we will be have we will have that once we do the final budget presentation um but our June 2017 graduates 90.4% attended either a two or fouryear college 1.1% attended Career technical schools 88.5% either entered the military the workforce or they were undecided at the time that the survey was done um I know Ryback you mentioned earlier about AP exams we had 664 AP exams taken this spring um and 84% of our students achieved a three or better um and also our average scores
092on the SAT are well above the state average our math is a 576 the state average is a 537 and our um reading and writing uh assessment it's 575 and again the state average is 539 so our students are doing very well academically budget resource considerations where's the money coming from to fund the 1920 budget general fund state aid this year we got $5.3 million which was our current year award to be conservative it is recommended to base preliminary budget for 1920 on the same level of funding as the prior year although we have been informed by Mr Mark magiar from uh the Senate Office that Monroe could receive up to $1 million additional state aid funds for the 1920 school year under S2 which is now in law proprietary fund considerations we made a
093resource for ourselves here by by creating a business plan for Falcon care and early childhood en enrichment programs which as I reported the last meeting has brought in $1.6 million of retained earnings in the first three years years of operations we are very pleased to project that we could transfer if approved by the board again another $600,000 from Falcon care ECE retain earnings to be a resource in the 1920 budget and finally Jamesburg tuition uh James BG's tuition is approximately 3.6% of general fund revenues and Jamesburg is overpaying tuition as per the Jamesburg agreement with the Board of Education projected schedule of cap for use in the 1920 school year all of this will be posted on the website but basically to to calculate cap you look at your prior year general fund tax levy
094there's an automatic calculated adjustment from the state for enrollment last year we received a little over a million so that's fair to estimate again you have then your adjusted pre-year general fund tax levy base that is in ated then by 2% you then get an adjustment for health care cost that gives you additional cap growth last year we received zero because we did such an aggressive job and succeeded in negotiating health insurance rates that were lower than what would afford US a cap adjustment to tax our citizens more General and then that gives you the general fund tax levy cap prior to use of banked cap board of education has $600,000 of Bank cap available which we have not used over the last few years and is set to expire if not appropriated in the
0951920 school year that would bring the cap adjustment to just over $3 million if the bank cap is not used and $3.6 million of growth with the bank cap utilized excess Surplus is a big consideration for a revenue Source in the next year's budget unfortunately as I've previously reported to the board we consumed over a million dollars of surplus in operations in the 1819 School uh in the 1819 school year which carries over so we've dropped a million doar in excess Surplus what does that mean that means that the 1920 budget will be constricted in size by $1 million less of surplus that carries over from year to year one favorable tax consideration is ratable growth in this community the more people that move in the more ratables that hit the books the more the
096tax levy is shared amongst all the residents and and and land owners and Property Owners uh last year ratables grew by 1.9% this will very favorably impact tax rates and we anticipate that ratables are still growing although we don't have any definitive information from the township yet but I would not be surprised if again ratable growth is between 1.5% and 2% a lot of our district has proven to have very high performance numerous best practices and comparatively low taxation when you look at it on a county level we believe we're providing incredible value to the taxpayers of Monroe Township and that said I would like to review administration's recommendation for the budget it is recommended that Administration prepare a budget that responsibly meets the demands of of continuing significant student growth and facility needs as
097well as program and service requirements without exceeding the board's maximum spending Authority while prioritizing the following items subject to the restrictions presented by Administration the construction projects as presented curriculum and staffing recommendations as presented salary and benefit increases and at a conservative range Transportation recommendations to transfer $600,000 from the retain earnings of Falcon care ECE to be a revenue Source in the 1920 budget and to use the expiring 600,00 of Bank cap so at this time it is [Music] recommended that the Board of Education establish a budget Philosophy for the 1920 school year which tasks Administration to prepare a budget that responsibly meets the demands of continuing significant student growth and facility needs as well as program and service requirements with without exceeding the board's maximum spending Authority which would necessitate going out to voters
098for a vote on the school budget while prioritizing the following items subject to restrictions presented by Administration construction projects as presented curriculum and staffing recommendations as presented salary and benefit increases Transportation recommendations to transfer $600,000 of retain earnings for Falcon care ECE to offset possible trailer costs which would expand in the 1920 school budget we have not met administratively yet to assess that but there's a strong possibility that trailers will expand for next year and to utilize the expiring $600,000 of Bank cap to provide resources for all the aforementioned priorities this action by the board will enable the board to fulfill its educational responsibility to District students in a thorough and efficient fiscally prudent manner while continuingly ensuring maintenance of District resources and facilities in short There's a summary of of of of what we've
099presented the Appropriations and the needs of this District that are we are contractually bound to and that we have a responsibility to meet in terms of uh facility up upgrades and and and uh facility uh Transportation Depot expansion exceed the amount of Revenue that you're able to grow the budget next year from Surplus from tax cap and from state aid expansion by millions of dollars every year Administration goes through every line item in the budget in order to fit all of the appropriation needs to the revenues uh in in their maximum Aggregate and we're going to continue to do that and that's a task that uh we're going to be challenged with once again okay so is there a motion in a second to accept the budget philosophy I will make a motion to accept
100it thank you Mr retsky and Mr Ryback will second that uh Now comments and questions for the board uh members M Armel yes so what is the the cap percentage 2% the cap and you're recommend I'm sorry and you're recommending us to go to that right uh uh the first question is uh what is the cap percentage it is not a 2% cap as is commonly known or misunderstood from uh the Christie initiative with imposing a cap there are adjustments as I discussed with enrollment with Health Care adjustments and relief that we're not eligible for so our actual tax levy growth increase is approximately 3% not 2% with the adjustments for enrollment okay and that amounts to what did you say approximately $3 million of additional revenue for next year or 3.6 million if the
101bank Bank cap is appropriated and it is my recommendation to the board to appropriate that bank cap for next year as the depletion of excess Surplus shows you that our needs are exceeding our revenues right now we need that additional $600,000 of budget expansion and in a time where you have ratables growing 1.5 to 2% the effect of $600,000 of additional taxes raise should not be felt that that painfully through the community Mr M Mr Chella yeah I just want to talk on behalf of that uh and uh that reserve and the importance of it because I think um you know we've been able to fund a number of of projects that have popped up over over time and uh without having to go out and have a referendum and those kind of things so
102I think uh we we we've obviously depleted it I think by a million dollars and now we have an opportunity to to recharge it so that's why I think that it's a it's a it's a smart thing to be able to have that Reserve so that we're not stuck with a major project that we can't fix you know we can't work on Mr Ryback I just want to Echo what Mr chologist said I think that we always have to look at you know the unexpected as well as uh what we are expecting I think that what we heard today was a very realistic um analysis of what we need and what we expect uh in the future and I think we I mean just recently we've had two unplanned things we had the mold which
103is costing us about $77,000 and we had the additional um barriers and trees outside of the the uh the uh trailers so um those were not planned for and I think the trees were also about 70 that whole that package about 70,000 so so you have almost $150,000 that was not included in the budget included in the budget so yeah Mr Russo yeah some people complain that um salaries are high on the administrative side not not teaching staff but on support staff and administrators and I just wanted to ask um when was the last time we went out and did like a salary survey or review of salaries to find what's the market rate for similar types of uh functions that are done in the school I think you can get some of that information
104from the state under um educational spending it talks about the percentage and the amount that districts are paying and you can see how much our district is compared to other districts and when the student report card comes out I think it comes out in what April it it when does the student report card come out I'm not quite sure but it has that information there but have have we done anything like that not that I know of I I can't I can't recall Madam um with regard to administrative salaries they're um they're included in an account called administrative costs and I know it's not specific to your question but we present slides on administrative costs that are still available on last year's budget presentation on the website that shows the Divergence between the county minimum
105um Mount per pupil and this District's administrative costs we are flat to down from previous years where the county average continues to rise as far as specific administrative contracts uh 6A employees which re or the superintendent the assistant superintendent and the business administrator go through a lengthy review process for analytical review with biographies on each person at the county level before the county approves all those cont contracts and that's performed every year and what about all the support staff so basically it hasn't been done that's I mean for support St so for example you have um maybe drivers can be compared with other school districts it support staff can be compared with who has there been a market a market negotiated in the contract no I know but um but I think you can find
106some of that in the taxpayers guide educational spending about what what's being spent and comparing it to other districts yeah but what about the private sector as well well this because we the private sector well I mean there are certain you know things are changing right and you now the school districts um hire people in different roles than they did maybe years ago so you have uh staff who have job descriptions which are very similar to what job description might may find outside in the public sector so how do you how do you make those comparisons in terms of what you pay here and what uh uh salaries are paid for outside I I don't know if you can pair them because you have different um responsibilities well they're not different responsibilities job descriptions are
107very similar but on top of that uh working in the school district you have many other benefits like uh the hours you have uh great job security you can't beat the job security and a lot of other benefits that you won't find outside I can rattle off a number of examples I'm not going to do it here but I'm just surprised that a salary survey for administrative and support staff hasn't been done um and it's never been done it just surprises me I I don't know any school district that doesn't a salary you know okay Miss armino um I I have a question again about we a uh nearly 3% hike in the budget and I know we've always talked about or or other uh Municipal people talk about how wonderful it is uh all
108the construction is going to get us all these ratables but it seems like the ratables fall far below uh what we have to increase as our budget so if if the ratables are increasing by 1.9% uh roughly and we have to increase our budget by three now I know they're not the same numbers but the thought is we're not really getting much more I mean I think compared I I compared to the cost of the enrollment the the additional enrollment I don't think that the tax ratables are really satisfying our position it's really not so uh it's unfortunate because we are we are uh obligated as Kathy's often said about educating our children and I'm all for that but it's unfortunate that we have no control over the type of En uh of Rapid enrollment
109and it's just it's really out of control and we are you know based on the on the budget philosophy it would not be my budget philosophy on a regular basis to to always go to cap to always increase because that means in the next year it's that much more that we're increasing the budget um but I feel as if we are really um with our backs against the wall and we have to do this to to give our children a proper education but it is it's burdensome to try to think how we can spend the funds that we have even though it we keep we're keep being told that we're getting more ratables I find that that's not that's really not a good good argument unfortunately it just buffers it a little bit it's definitely
110not going to cover it right it's it it's a buffer it's it's fluff when somebody says oh we're getting more ratables it's not it's not part of the district reality and the more I I always feel that the more we have to spend on facilities and as it as it is NE necessary the more we have to spend on Transportation that's the less we have for instruction for our children on a on a daily basis so while I welcome all the children to our community I welcome everybody to our community it is the the rapid growth is just really putting a lot of pressure on on the children as well as the parents and and other stakeholders it just needs to be said Mr tiella yeah I just want to just want to uh talk
111about that for a second so so I I well I agree with you I mean I think that uh you know a 1.9% rable uh increases does help buffer until you need new facilities and then and then you have to have that large outlay and we have to bond for it and that's where the impact is and that's what we're feeling now and that's what we're going to feel shortly so yeah as a buffer yes but then then the then the bill comes and that's where we're at now Mr ryb back I'm sorry um I just want to pick up on something Mr Russo was saying um Frank you were talking about comparing us to the private sector you said there's a lot of changes in the private sector um what I'd like to caution
112everybody when I think about the private sector is um you look out west in in in Arizona for example of what uh the private sector and the go the federal government support for private schools and vouchers Charter Schools is doing to Public School System um it's decimating the public school system the private sector does not have the benefit of Union support and therefore those teachers those administrators um are not getting the kind of support they need and they're work working conditions are being set back years Mr uh Mr Mayo I always say that to you um it's okay I agree with what you said Michelle it's really unfortunate that we have to deal with this influx of students and it puts pressure on the whole District um but I'd like to remind people that even
113though this is the budget philosophy you know it doesn't mean we have to go to that amount and in the past year we've given back to the to the taxpayers $1.4 million so we do we are aware of the tax implication on the taxpayers of this town and I think we're very cognizant of it and we do give back whenever we can so this is a philosophy and you know we may not need to go all the way past the 3.6 million so things could change so hopefully anyone else Mr Russo just just a follow up on what Steve said to clarify myself I didn't say that there were a lot of change on in the public sector what I was saying is that to me the core of what the school should do is
114educate and then so you have your teaching staff and I can understand uh that they can only be compared their salaries and benefits can only be compared to other schools but there are a lot of uh staff and supporting roles and in those roles you can compare to similar jobs that are done in the in the public sector and I'm wondering how the salaries compare in that area I thought you said private sector private sector and school system yeah anyone else okay can I can I just bring up one thing it's just it's just I'm not sure if it's the right time or not but I'm I'm thinking about it's really more for future budgets but I'm thinking about one of the slides that Dory went over with regards to adding Middle School sports and
115and costs associated with that and it and it it just has me thinking again if if it's the wrong time to bring this up you could stop me but if had a lot of discussion I've thought a lot about this premise of building a second middle school and all the fields and all that goes with it and then having two sets of all the Middle School sports and all that that's going to do to the budget where and I've never been involved in any of the committies that talked about the the uh upcoming projects of facilities but in my mind if we take the middle school would make it a 78 and that's all the Middle School sports and the new school becomes a 5'6 with no sport and no field and not a second
116volleyball team or basketball team or wrestling team CU it's just 56 and you don't need chemistry labs and I think budget wise we're going to feel the impact of that tremendously as the years go on if we do a second Middle School whereas and again I don't know if it's ever been discussed or if it's been shot down why but in my mind as I'm just like a numbers guy it just makes a lot of sense to me to not have two middle schools competing against each other and then having all those secondary Sports and activities and clubs and advisors and buses and to just make it a 56 and keep this as a 78 and then this is your high school so I I'll just throw it out there it's really more for future
117budgets that would really I think save the district a lot of a lot of money and future referendums too right that too okay I know we be on that point but no more comments questions then we'll have a roll call on accepting the budget philosophy no it is because sorry could hear we Mr ruty yes sir I I think where are we how do you vote sir on the budget V yes thank you Mrs Corino yes Mrs Deo yes Mr cherella yes Mr Ryback yes Mrs armeno yes Mr Russo no Mrs Co Pano yes Madam board president motion to adopt the budget Philosophy for the 1920 school year has passed thank you very much oh thank you and at this time we will have a park presentation and Dr Al Mr Al she's doing it
118on her own okay do I'm just curious to see how you have some things the clicker is very popular okay as required um we are presenting this evening our Park results from the spring 2018 Administration yeah I don't know why this isn't all right you know what it's here Al I will take that it might be easier for me to stand hope you keep pointing there shouldn't you point here I did point it here it wasn't working that's okay yeah thank you okay so our I the 2018 marked the fourth year of the administration of the park assessments we give the park Assessments in grades 3 through 11 in English language arts and in math we give it in grades 3 through 8 and at the end of courses in Algebra 1 Algebra 2 and
119geometry at the high school the park performance levels are level one level two level three level four and level five the state considers level four and five to be passing the park this is New Jersey school scores so this is a comparison of the last 3 years of scores um this is across the state of New Jersey in the final two columns what you see are the numbers of students who either decreased or in increased or decreased in the levels one and two you want to see the number decrease in those levels because we want students to be doing better in the higher levels so you want to see the decrease in levels one and two and you want to see an increase in the levels four and five so this is the state performance
120in English language arts this presentation will be available on the district website after tonight's presentation this is the states performance in math and again same same um as the last one you have the last three years uh the percentages of students at each level and then the percentage of student students the change in levels 1 and two and the change in levels four and five so this is Monroe Township's performance so again we're comparing the last three years of the park assessments this is language arts across the grade levels 3 through 11 again in the final columns you want to see the the number of students the percentage of students in levels one and two decreasing you want to see the percentages in four and five increasing so we have some areas where we've decreased
121some areas where we've increased we have only had this data in the district less than two months actually it's less than a month we have not had a chance to completely analyze all of the data but as required by the state we are required to do this presentation within 60 days of receiving the data we received it on August 17th if I waited or received it on August August 16th if I waited till the October board meeting to do this presentation we would have been out of compliance which is why we're doing it this evening so we have not had a chance to really dig down and analyze this data yet so this is really very raw data for us but this is so this is the language arts and here is our math percentages
122so looking at grades 3 through eight math Algebra 1 in the middle school algebra 1 in the high school we also offer geometry to some of our students in the middle school and then geometry at the high school and then Algebra 2 this is the number of students who took the exam in Monroe in 2017 as compared to 2018 and the number of students who took the math exams um in 2017 as compared to 2018 so this is the comparison of Monroe Township to the state scores in 2018 so if you look at our district score as compared to our state scores the last two columns on the right we are well above the state average in all areas so the state average obviously we want to be better than that but we are well
123above the state average in all grade levels for English language arts and well above the state average in math in all at all grade levels um I know in the past the board has requested that we look at our three upper elementary schools or the grade levels at the schools um third grade is at mil Lake and Oak Tree and Brookside so kind of comparing our numbers across the three schools and in um third grade language arts fourth grade language arts fifth grade language arts and then again in third grade math fourth grade math and fifth grade math um I am not going to go through each one of these slides but what you will see for each grade level language arts and math a comparison of all of our subgroups and their um their
124performance on the assessment so I'm going to flick through these pretty quickly um grade three English language arts grade three math grade four English language arts grade four math grade five English language arts grade five math 6 7 8 9 10 11 in language arts Algebra 1 Algebra 2 geometry so the other assessment that we gave this spring was the New Jersey student learning assessment in science this was given at grades 5 8 and 11 this was considered a field test so we will not be re re receiving scores for these assessments so you will not see them on this report um our advanced placement score so we have a total number of um AP students is 376 students I know I said we took 644 exams students take multiple AP exams so one student
125may take four AP exams in a year um so that's why the number is different there but you'll see we that's the number of students we have in 29 different subjects in our high school school and again a score of three is considered passing in AP um and many colleges accept a three not all colleges except a three as the passing score um but many do so we want to see our students in the three four and five range and again this is um an area where the supervisors do take a very close look at the students in the class our curriculum how it aligns making sure that our students are prepared so our next steps we will now use this data to to identify our strengths and gaps that exist in our curriculum and
126our instruction we utilize it um to see if there's any areas in need of improvement or enhancement and we also look to provide additional resources and support for our Educators we do look at this for individual students we this is one of the Possible graduation requirements and one graduation requirement currently for for um students in the high school so we want to make sure that we're monitoring that closely there are many resources for parents on Park so you have this um these websites are available to you they explain how the student reports the student reports did go home the first week of school um so you should have received your child's reports in the in the mail the first week of school um and there are ways to you know scoring guides um so that
127parents can better understand what the score reports mean and again our next steps we are are currently in the process of developing school goals and sgos for all of our staff members that's required by by the end of October every staff member has two sgos and they use this data excuse me to help guide them as they're looking at their student growth objectives um again we look at every evidence statement from the park assessments we can really dig down with these reports online um to see exactly which statements which standards we're either not meeting or exceeding and see how we need to adjust our curriculum and we have done that over the last two years we've made adjustments to our curriculum based on this um and we look at uh school goals and how we
128can better improve that that's it again this will be available online after this presentation okay are there any questions for Dr Alvi so what do you anticipate is the governor is saying he's that Park done and we're doing SOS and plans and there you know graduation requirements and all that stuff but how disrupt will that be if that does go away I mean what's the I'm imagining that's going to make your job and everyone else's job a lot harder because harder I think it would make our jobs easier no no no I understand that but I'm just saying that all the plans that you're creating now be yeah well we're still required even if the part goes away we're still required to teach the standards our curriculum documents are written to the standards so I
129don't think that the state is going to do away with an assessment okay it just may not be Park um I know currently I know I know currently they're looking to just reduce the number of Assessments they're not looking to get away get get rid of park yet um they're just looking to reduce the number specifically at the high school and to also offer um other options for the graduation assessment requirement at the high school um you know since I've been teaching and I've been in education for a long time we've had some sort of an assessment um and each ass assessment kind of just follows whenever the standards change okay so I don't think that assessments will go away um but we've been utilizing the map assessments our teachers work very closely together and
130we've developed common benchmark assessments um and I think those really guide what's happening day-to- dat in the classroom because this data doesn't come out until well after the school year has ended Goa so we really utilize that data that we do every day the map assessments and the teacher assessments the through the RTI process and Gathering the Dr assessments and Gathering all that data um to actually work in the classroom I think it would make our lives a little easier if we didn't have to focus on the assessment as much and teaching to it exactly any other questions for Dr Alik okay then we will go on to committee reports is there any committees that wish to re report this evening Mr Mayo okay the curriculum committee started by reviewing the key features of the
131grade seven and8 language arts curriculum um these were collabora developed by multiple teachers they're Rewritten to reflect readers and Writers Workshop which promotes independent reading of appropriately challenging Choice books in different genres um the units of study spiral through through the middle school increasing with in complexity throughout the grades and each unit contains the lessons and resources teachers need to be consistent but also allows flexibility to meet the needs of individual students in their classes we also reviewed the humanities tag and the stem tag curriculum um the humanities tag curriculum is project-based learning it's teaching kids to solve real world problems it's um based on historical research um and the themes are in grade five individual in history taking sides of perspective in history grade seven Triumph or tragedy and grade eth is oral history
132with someone who witnessed or took part in a historic event the stem tag curriculum is also project-based learning um and does real world problems and contains an element of self-reflection now just so people know elements of project-based learning um focus on challenging problem or question sustained inquiry authenticity student voice and choice reflection critique and revision and public product we also highlighted the algebra 1 curriculum document um and these follow the New Jersey student learning standards for Ma mathematics they focus on Expressions equations inequality reasoning functioning modeling application based problem solving there are quadratic functions um that are um introduced but they get more in depth into Algebra 2 statistics are also introduced [Music] um and they include collaborative work groups and active activities to Foster working as a team we also had wait a minute
133uh we also had the seventh eth and 7th 8th and 10th grade physical education um curriculum um the physical education curriculums has three periods of physical education and one Health and in seventh and eth grade they FOC they focus on drug alcohol um where's seven seventh grade focuses on drug and alcohol and tobacco the reproductive body systems and decision-makings decisionmaking um and the fizzed focuses on team games such as football basketball and softball the eighth grade curriculum focuses on drug and alcohol sexually transmitted infections nutrition and the physical education part focuses on volleyball rugby Golf and bading as examples the 10th grade curriculum the health part focuses is is in the first marking period and that's driver's ed and the fizzed focuses on team games there's a few individual games such as badm and the
134kids are introducing to the wait room um in addition we had um where's my oh we have a new book adopted for our STEM Academy we currently have seven students in the stem Academy um and this book where did I put my notes is for on it's it's for honors physics and the students in the T STEM Academy will be taking honors physics but they will then be allowed to take the AP Physics exam and this book is a supplemental book um to help them bridge the gap and it's called Uh MCG Hill College physics we then reviewed the upfitness club which is part of the Monroe Township Schools unified partnership um our up program was recently recognized by the special exempt Special Olympics as Exemplar um we also received a $5,500 grant for that
135which we talking in a little bit um we we are expanding the up program now to include upfitness um Special Olympics have provided the Monroe Township High School with a grant to Pilot a new initiative to incorporate Fitness in a unified setting with this initiative we will be providing our students with intellectual disabilities a chance to engage in Lifetime Fitness activities alongside their typical peers specifically on Thursday afternoon students will be taken part in one of the following activities led by an advised with that expertise weight training yoga or Zumba and that is it it was a very exciting day in the curriculum off meeting are there any questions from Mr Mayo okay any other committees Mr Chella yes thank you on 9:4 uh we had a buildings grounds and transportation committee meeting so we
136uh we went over five things the first one was the annual IPM review which is integrated Pest Management and the committee uh decided to move forward with our existing plan uh so integrated Pest Management is a is is a way where we go about managing pests in a v in various ways so we use a lot of natural remedies and things like that to reduce the need for poisons or chemicals and those kind of things there are instances where uh those those things are needed uh for instance if we have large beehives or hornets nests or mice or anything like that but in those cases is uh we do send out uh notifications to parents so that they understand what's going on if if we have to treat something but for the most part we
137use a strategy that does not rely on chemicals and and those kind of things so we just went over that plan and um we we we moved that forward from the committee uh we we also looked at the mar the Barkley Brook neighbor development so the the development going up across from Barkley brook or by on the side of Barkley Brook next to Barkley Brook and um the the one issue so we've been working through with them uh working uh to look at the easement uh and uh that's still in the works I still saw I've still seen emails today right we still saw email we had emails going back and forth between Mary and a couple board members based on the easement and the wording in in the documentation so we're just waiting for
138clarification on that uh Mary's going to go back our attorney's going to go back to the planning board and we'll get clarification on that and I'll report back on where we stand with that but everything else was good you know from that standpoint they're they're doing everything that uh we've asked them to do for the most part I think what we're looking for is the memorialization of that on the on the planning board side to make sure that that's locked in and once we have that then we'll be good we also looked at the the lead paint project clearance for the Monro Township Middle School on the steel column so uh that remediation is over uh where we've uh we we had everything tested afterward you know in the ground we test the soil and
139all that stuff and there's no residual lead or anything like that so that's that's a good thing um and we also had an update for the Brookside HVAC project we're on target with that uh the uh the workers who are working on that will be working on that through October I think we'll be done at some point in the at the end of October but they'll be working uh nights weekends and things like that so that they're not there working while the students are in the school and then the last thing that we had were was just an update on where we stood with the trailers at the middle school um at that point we were still looking at some things being completed and it looks it looks like we we're 100% at this point
140so that's a good thing I I know it's not beautiful but I you know I think it looks pretty good so uh uh it's not it wasn't the optimal thing but I think that I I'm I'm I'm satisfied that our children are safe and that um that I think we we did the right thing and I think it was a you know a mix I'm grateful for the uh for the input that we had that we received from the public and I think that that goes a long way it's it's uh it's important to have open public discourse and I think that that helps us a lot of times make decisions it helps us fix things and it helps us see things from another perspective so that's it hey any questions for Mr Chella Mr
141Chella may I just add something regarding the um the Barkley Brook neighborhood development um one of the emails that I sent out was a um question again for clarification I think on on several occasions when we spoke in public and also at the committee meeting uh we talked about a pathway that included the uh emergency access and I and I believe the members who were there we talked about being able to have the children walk through not necessarily on an emergency access basis um but to be able to go from that development to the grounds that was not really clarified so on tonight's agenda there's um an acceptance of a letter uh dated August 31st from the applicant so I'm going to probably uh ask for an addendum to that if you don't mind no
142I think that's if that's okay with yeah I I think that's a good idea and you're right and I and I apologize I I hadn't seen your last email I saw it come in please don't apologize I got it very late this I I formulated it very late this but I think that's a good idea to put it on there at least then we get we get moving so that the planning board isn't held up and then we're able to we'll do it under the business administrator's report great thank you okay so I just wanted to ask your permission sorry to go ahead and do that when it comes up okay anyone else um I have Miss armini yeah okay so the uh policy committee met we had some language changes to the homework policy
143again I didn't want um I was hoping not to have anything negative in there like discourage uh from from from getting homework so we changed it to the discretion of the teachers although in the regulations it does say that there's no expectations of homework during the breaks but I want to be clear that there are only three breaks there's the spring break the winter break and the Thanksgiving break that doesn't mean that every holiday or every long-term um uh weekend or some long weekend or anything that that this policy uh this policy is involved in that it is not it is only for those limited periods of time and I still think it should be up to the discretion of the teachers but the language in there is as such and so is the regulation
144and if parents want to see that and and write to the board then go for it um also we had some mandatory changes to policies I'm going to go briefly uh five five one two was harassment intimidation and bullying and the uh mandatory change was that they actually um that's not they generally when we have mandatory changes to those we really have no choice um and we just put new language in so um I would ask you if you're interested it's uh harassment intimidation and bullying it's revised and the bullying investigation procedure is abolished actually um so again take a look at that 5512 we are going back and forth with the use of physical restraint and seclusion techniques for students with disabilities that's a revised a mandatory um policy and that's number 5561 we
145have not really come to terms with that because the committee asks for a lot of clarification as to uh as to the techniques and you know how this is going to be performed so uh definitely would encourage uh parents of students with disabilities and any um any other you know children special needs that they take a look at 5561 we are adapting we have an option of not using restraints at all as a board however uh we have in the past apparently um accepted that we are going to use and uh use this use of restraint and seclusion techniques for students with disabilities so that's has that's not on on the agenda tonight but it's still in the discussion so if if anybody wants to hear what's going on they can join the policy committee
146next month uh just take a look at the website and procurement uh the next one uh policy 8561 procurement procedures for school nutrition program that's mandatory Revis all that was was removal of language um that really didn't affect uh our use of that policy so that was 85 61 and that's my report thank you thank you anyone else Finance Finance we did not have a finance meeting this didn't know that's good I guess okay I'm sorry I'm sorry about the um there was one I didn't say I apologize there was one I didn't mention that's uh policy 1613 disclosure and review of applicants employment history this is a new policy I think it's going to serve us well um one of the things is they they call it the law has been referred to there's
147a new law I uh in New Jersey and it's called Uh the law has been referred to as pass the trash and it's a consideration of employment and what it does is it does not allow um or you you can you can be um sanctioned uh if if we get an employee for instance if we get an employee and we ask for their employment history and unfortunately if they have um a history of abuse uh with children the school must tell us about that employee and likewise if we let an employee go and they apply for a job somewhere else if we have reason to believe that there's been abusive acts we are obligated to tell people so we can't pass on a bad employee anymore nor nor uh can another District pass one on
148to us so I think it's a very good uh policy it's a new law and it will serve us well because we certainly should not be allowing anyone to come into our district that has that kind of History nor should we um keep quiet and I just received something today uh I'm going to be very quick it was an email from Cooper levenson which is not our attorneys but they are attorneys and it says in a cautionary tale for all school districts in New Jersey August 21st 2018 oh it's a federal oh a Federal Court ruled a $600,000 settlement must be paid by that School's district taxpayers and not its insurance carrier because the district failed to notify authorities and agreed not to tell potential future employers about a teacher's resignation stemming from a sex
149abuse allegation involving students so it's a very serious law I'm glad it's on the books and I'm sure we're going to comply I hope other districts comply with it thank you okay so at this time we will go to a public forum for the agenda items only so anyone from the public wishing to speak to the agenda please come to the microphone give your name and address for the record and we will adhere to our 4minute time limit hi uh my name is shendu and I'm a parent coming from uh Princeton and uh I have some colleagues here from Monroe District uh four years back uh I started a company in Princeton called steamwork studio and it is is this an agenda item yes okay so um I wanted to uh kind of get an
150introduction to the superintendent and assistant superintendent because we do a lot lot of programs in lot many schools Across the Nation and they're all highly application oriented for kids and um so and we do very large school relationships like Hoboken uh hell where we teach every day 400 kids so uh these are highly experiential direct U uh application oriented programs and I I just came here to see uh if I can make a introduction and um pass my card and see if I can get some um direct engagement sir sir if you can give your contact information to miss Tagle faroh over here okay and I'll reach out to you okay thank you okay anyone else wishing to speak to the agenda Joan Cardone 11 Gravel Hill Spotswood Road it was previously mentioned by a
151board member about the administrative salaries being a little topheavy in Monroe and yet our teach teachers salary is this an agenda item yes because it's referring to a new position that's being okay in the that was in the budget and yet our teachers are on the lower end of the scale what quau my eye was the hiring of two new supervisors for next year and yet as I go through the budget this month and last month I saw that there were so many teachers having to teach extra CL classes why aren't we taking the salaries that we would pay these supervisors to hire more teachers we have language classes in the high school of 35 we have honors math classes with 32 and 31 students we need that money to go towards teachers we have
152five administrators in the middle school I'm sorry four for6 00 students five in the high school for 2,300 students I think that's plenty of Supervisors already not that it would be as Vice principles but my concern is that we get these class numbers down and start thinking of hiring more teachers and not supervisors I think our supervisors are doing a fine job uh we have five departments that have teachers teaching six classes and that's only here in the high school I I have no idea how many of them are doing extra classes in the middle school but that's my request that they look into using that money for those supervisory jobs to hire more teachers where we need them okay thank you [Applause] okay my name is Renee kakasa I live at 231 Mount Mills
153Road Monro Township I'm speaking you spoke about the uh Outsourcing of buses that's that was on the agenda I cannot begin to tell you the woman on bus 347 Mercy Transportation took my son over the railroad tracks did not not stop did not put on lights she I followed the bus because I had intuition and I'm glad I did okay I I called her company who said it was against the law to do that I she can give me a statute number saying it's against the law that's fine with following her on Friday September 7th she pulled the bus over on Mount SMS Road by where the backside of the Greeks property is got off the bus while my son was on the the bus if a car hit the bus if her brakes malfunctioned
154if something happened I would own this town I was told today she won't be there anymore that's not good enough for me what if it's your kid or your kid or your kid I don't want to hear I have children blah blah blah I don't want to hear that I'm not talking about your children I'm talking about mine he's my life I will continue to follow the buses and I will continue to be a squeaky wheel you're concerned with your space your contracts that's not my concern my taxes are paid and they're paid on time and I expect the service that had most of Monroe is getting there's two contracted buses I want a Monroe bus today I was told that that was going to happen I was told on Friday that that was going
155to happen today when the bus pulled up to pick up my son it was the same woman who blew past the track the railroad tracks who pulled over and got off the bus who abandoned my son on the bus that's not acceptable you can look that up it's the law you cannot abandon a child on a bus if she was afraid that I was following her why did she wait till my son was the last kid on the bus to get off and then confront me no that's not acceptable it's not thank you Mr Gorski would you like to reply to that yes nice to meet you Mrs kakasa after speaking speaking with you today uh as I've reported to the board we have had some very serious safety concerns with one of our contractors
156Mercy bus I have not only videos from Mrs kakasa but other parents as well showing serious safety violations from Mercy bus uh employees what have we done to uh address that number one we have contacted Mercy bus and had telephone conversations with them about six times I've demanded audience with the president of Mercy bus who has come to my office three times I've contacted Mr Pat Moran from the Ed Services Commission who these routes are Bid through two times and emailed him four videos of of these very uh egregious safety violations I have also contacted the Monroe Township Police Department two times to report to two sets of videos I contacted them today after speaking with Mrs kakasa and reviewing additional videos that I did not have last week Mercy bus has taken two drivers
157off of Monroe's routes and replaced them what what I was told was their best driver their best driver was the one that Mrs kakasa was unfortunately referring to uh in in in her report which is accurate I am pleased to say that the Board of Education through uh my work with the transportation director has pulled back Mercy route number five and will be performing that bus inhouse with an in-house spare bus spare buses as I've reported to the board are are needed these are older buses that we keep on on on lot in case a bus breaks down you have to immediately dispat dispatch a bus to get the kids off the broken one and get them on the new one this happens unfortunately occasionally um the problem we're facing here districtwide is we don't
158have the ability to expand expand the bus fleet beyond our current capabilities and we are having uh we're feeling the effects of the extreme bus driver shortage that's going through the state I have this much sympathy for Mercy bus in that regard too because they are having as all the contractors are difficulty in hiring they're trying to keep their business going by hiring perhaps staff that they wouldn't have hired in previous years and we're noticing more problems now than ever before um as we've discussed tonight on two occasions I feel that the the red light is on now and it is it is uh strongly urging the members of the board and administration to prioritize the development of the bus depot so that we can um bring back nearly all of the contracted routes there
159will still be some certain instances with special education for example where you may have a lift that would be impractical to to to buy one bus for for one or two children so you contract that route out but uh I I would love to have an completely in-house otherwise bus fleet because as I stated before the performance of our staff is second to none um I review every every driver motor vehicle transcript for every driver recommended to the superintendent for hire we don't hire and I won't recommend a driver with any infraction on their license I can't say that's true for the contractors for example but they are required to have a background check and a CDL our bid specs are such that they're required to have cameras on the buses or face fines and
160penalties we are I'm speaking with Council to impose the maximum amount of fines and penalties we can on Mercy bus um and we are continuing to try to break contract with them to bring routes back in but again the the constraint we're facing is uh where to put the buses how to service the buses and where to get the St and we and as as Mr Goodall and I spoke last week and I hate to be too wordy with this we are aggressively targeting bus drivers right now um and we will do an emergent hire if necessary to bring back more routes and I just want to add I think you um if if you today there was a at least two board members who also agreed that we need to have our bus fleet
161inhouse 100% % and that's our goal of the whole Board of Education and that's what we're working to do Madam I believe just for some figurative information we're about 90% inhouse now okay and we're we're striving aggressively to to get that number higher okay anyone else rard Mar six court if I may can I step up to the the board just to hand some information oh you could give it to um Miss a pharaoh after you are or now it does let him distribute it I have to you told her it was okay um just hand them out please just for um public information if there's ever a need to hand out materials to the board of education at a future meeting the bylaws require that such materials get uh handed to the board secretary
162in advance so that I could make the proper distribution and and get the approval of the board president okay okay [Applause] okay once again my name is rard Mor and I'm a resident at the states of Monroe on behalf of all the residents at the states of Monroe I'm hereby to notify the board an issue that has been created by a newly hired transportation coordinator Kathleen McDonald the issu is regarding the school bus stop location that was changed from the inside development to the corner of forsgate drive and O kill drive for the school year of 2018 2019 in 1994 my wife's family moved into the first house built in Estates of Monroe and the first assigned bus stop for the 9495 school year was at the intersection of forsgate drive and oakill drive having
163the children cross forsgate drive to enter the bus after almost being struck by a vehicle the transportation coordinator was notified and changed the Bus location to Door side of forsgate drive and oakill drive unfortunately this did not solve the problem the buses were almost rended daily by Vehicles turning on to forsgate drive from Halfacre Road also due to the bus stopping close proximity of the intersection of forsgate drive and Halfacre Road the traffic would back up when the light turned red for forsgate Drive the vehicles from Halfacre Road would not be able to cross the intersection please see page seven of an example of that once again the transportation coordinator business administrator and superintendent schools were notified and advised to observe the safety and traffic concerns after one day of those administrators observing such issues
164the bus stop was determined to be unsafe and was relocated into the development at the intersection of oakill drive and fwn Court the bus stop has been at that location for 24 years with no incidence pertaining to the geometric design of the roads and culde saacs on the Estates of onroad development initially the bus drivers would make a kurn but found it easier to turn around at the culdesac now after your newly hired transportation coordinator Kathleen McDonald has taken over she has decided to change the bus stop location back to the location of forsgate drive and oakill drive with no factual basis to support her decision let me repeat that location was deemed an unsafe Bus location 24 years ago and traffic has only since increased since that time Mr Goodall Mr Gorski and Mrs
165McDonald were notified regarding the safety and traffic concerns of this Bus location by several parents of development Mr Gorski stated that he was advised by Mrs McDonald that the C the saacks at the Estates of Monroe were unsafe and that a 54 passenger school bus was unable to safely turn around Mr Gorski also stated that 90% of the C saacs in the township do not accommodate a school bus to safely turn around I asked Mr orski for any facts to support his statements but unfortunately he was unable to Mrs McDonald was then contacted and she stated that she personally went out to the states of Monro and determined that the cue saacs were unsafe she was questioned as to how she determined that she stated that these cue saacs were unsafe and she just said
166they just looked unsafe she also stated that the new bus stop location is safe and there have been no traffic issues at that location at this time I would like to provide you with factual information instead of opinions that have been provided by Mrs McDonald and Mrs Gorski and Mr Gorski as to why the cold Stacks are safe and also dispute any and all statements made by Mr Gorski and Mrs McDonald the national School's transportation specification the procedure states that the maximum turning radius for a bus chassis wheelbase of 264 in or less shall have a maximum turning radius of 42 1/2 ft also according to the policy on the geometric design in Highway streets adopted by the Federal Highway uh Administration page six of your attachments the ma maximum the Min sorry the minimum
167radius required for the conventional school bus to safely make a U-turn is 40 is 39 1/2 ft upon speaking to Mr McDonald she stated that the maximum turning radius for Township or contracted school buses is 40 ft both caacs were then measured and found to be 100t wide and 120 ft long which is a 50ft wide radius and a 60t long radius with such radi a 54 School P passenger School Bus can safely turn around and Theus act even with garbage cans basketball hoops or even Vehicles parked curbside still leaving extra room please see page eight that document has been provided to the board which is a true present true representation from a civil engineering software called micro station do you have a lot more to say because your your your four minutes is up
168and Mr Gorski would like to respond that's fine we we have several uh um parents that are here instead of us repeating exactly the same thing I take it upon myself if the the board allows me to instead of having five six parents speaking for 4 minutes be able to open up to allow me I have probably about two and a half more minutes to go we're not allowed to do that according to policy okay so it's fine so he can speak and then I can have someone else continue on from where I stopped Madam I I've spoken with the gentleman and um others in that Street location and there's some incorrect information I would just like to present at this time number one it wasn't Mrs McDonald newly hired Mrs McDonald who's been here
1693 years who made the change in not going into culde saxs because that's the issue that that's we we're speaking to it was it was Dr kak Who uh declared to the transportation director years ago that we are ceasing going into culdesac Dr Hamilton previously also uh had the same uh order and I will tell you that I go to new nous roundt meetings of business administrators where we often speak to Transportation issues and transportation funding issues and and there you're not going to find a transportation department that has a practice of taking a 54 passenger bus down to culdesac that is unsafe for the following reasons C thex in order to turn around a 54 passenger bus and you can talk about turning radiuses all you want and I mean that respectfully but in
170dealing with this issue for 20 years now I will tell you that when you're dealing with basketball uh Nets put in the street park cars garbage cans leaf piles and especially when it's winter and you have snow piles and drifts in the street you cannot safely get a 54 passenger bus down the street and have a circular turning radius with the bus to pull out now certain drivers in the past have deviated from the route instructions and gone into CX because of pressure placed upon them by parents and then that's a very dangerous practice that the district is unaware of Mrs McDonald um has uniformly addressed her staff not to go into cult sacks with the exception of those that she has physically gone to and measured and has uh validated the safety of the
171larger what I estimated to be 10% of those cacs in town that would allow for a bus to go through and make a circular turning radius without doing a very dangerous K turn where a bus driver is illegally backing up the bus which could lead to a child getting Trampled Under the back wheels and I could just stop you right there for a minute the measurement excuse me Mr Gorski has the floor okay so further to help improve the situation Mrs McDonald has gone to zoning board meetings on her time and has addressed this meeting with Township officials so that any planning considerations for future called to saacks take this into consideration and they're designed to be bigger bigger turning radius so that the bus can uh perform certain instances we can split a 54
172passenger route into a couple Vans and we can go into C saxs but in your case we could not Kathy McDonald did go out to your particular Street more than once and has made a determination to me that it is unsafe it is not wide enough for the bus to get through and I have 100% confidence in her assessment so I I I stand with Mrs uh McDonald and um and I will not um uh in order to gain the favor of of some parents send a bus down and do a k turn or Worse have a staff member have to come out and back the bus up back out the street uh which is an extremely unsafe maneuver I agree with you that that street is very busy I have offered to contact the
173the Township Police who could put out patrols there you declined I've asked our security director to consider going out to the stop to see if we can monitor this a little more closely and uh that's where we stand in my opinion in my opinion of the of uh Kathy McDonald this is an unsafe call to sack that we cannot turn a 54 passenger bus around in am I able to no com because you're four minutes of okay so we're going to have another person to just continue on with with the conversation and be able to respond to any of the comments is that okay okay hi my name is John fam and I also a resident of um the state of Monroe and I just wanted to refer to page the last page and the
174exhibit that you have on the handout basically um we use a civil engineering software called micro station and auto turn to modulate the school bus making the turn assuming the worst case scenario as you see cars parked parallel to the curb around the cold sack the two green lines that you see are the pass of the bus front and back overhang the bus is able to make the turn with 2 ft to 4T cleance from each side of the cesac from the park car so basically what we try to say here is the history as well as the engineering analysis prove that the school bus can get in and out from the development safely it has been 24 years no incidence pertaining to the geometric design of that street and the cold SEC it's a
175perfectly fine I person I personally modated it I've been a civil engineer for 18 years working on on the field of transportation and traffic one more things I wanted to refer is is basically all the parents here are very anxious and worry about the safety of our kids waiting for the school bus at this location for the following reason a high speed it's it's a it's a 40 it's posted 40 m per hour speed limits close proximity to the very busy intersection of the force gate and Halfacre Road especially during the P hour no shoulder provided the kids are very close to the life traffic accident history on the proximity of this location please refer to the page one showing the motor vehicle accidents occurred occurred on half a mile before and after this intersection
176we have 164 total accident in the past 15 years with an average of 10 to 11 accidents every year 29 of them are fixed object accidents and that's really Our concern here please refer to page 2 3 and four those are just an example just a sample of the fixed object accidents not all of them on those example the vehicle would typically leave the roadway drive up into the curve continue on the grass or the sidewalk striking a utility pole fire hydrant or regulatory sign this is an actual accident that happened in the past God forbid we don't want our kids or us to be this fixed object page one shows a 72 same direction rear end accents almost 45% of the total accident on the past 15 years which support the statement that Mr
177um morero St stated earlier that the 24 years ago when the administrator observed that such an issue the bus stopped was determined the bus stop was determined to be unsafe and was relocated into the development another safety concern or another safety aspect for the residents who have their kids that their kids can basically get in in and out um get on the on and off the bus bys they are concerned about having their kids standing by themselves on such a busy road which will make them vulnerable and easy target to what they call it crime of opportunity there is no doubt that exposing our kids to a highly traveled roadway we'll put them at risk for any offenders who is looking for a target with a little effort basically we have about 13,000 cars passing
178every day in this road this is a very busy road according to the straight line diagram issued by Department of New Jersey Department of Transportation in back in 2014 they surveyed 14,000 as an average annual daily traffic this is a very very busy road all what we ask for is we wanted the bus to get inside we have proved this using the engineering method and also the history tells us there is not even one single incidence that proof in the past that this place is inadequate so thank you lastly the resident at the state of mono are very worried and concerned about the safety of their children if we have a safer alternative for the kids to be picked up and dropped off why not use it we are all respectively requesting for these boards
179to relocate this bus stop back to the area of Oak Hill and found as soon as possible sorry thank you Michael wife I live in Monro States since 2005 I've been watching this bus very easily with to pick up my children drive right down the street and turn around there's no basketball poles there's no kids uh lying down in the street uh imagine your children waiting at forsgate drive people rushing to the New Jersey Turnpike every single morning looking at their cell phones drinking their coffee we've had so many polls hit over there so many accidents you imagine your children standing on that street waiting for a bus uh for 26 years I was an assistant prosecutor at the middle County prosecutor's office and two weeks after I started 1990 a coworker of mine he's
180now the first assistant prosecure Christopher kuite uh you know you talk about his two-year-old was run over by a school bus so sir don't tell me that it's a dangerous thing for a bus to go down a s a culde saac where there's no cars and no traffic to turn around so our kids are safe I saw what that little girl looked like 2-year-old sitting there with her Barney pajamas on and her Barney next to me nobody in my neighborhood is going to put up with that because you guys are can't just do one thing I used to when I did trials I always said to the jury in my closing arms said D ladies and gentlemen don't throw out your common sense when you look at this and that's all we're asking you to
181do use your common sense and think about would you rather have your children on forsgate Drive you've all been on it you've all gone to the turnpike or should the children be back a block so the bus could go down the street where for 24 years have been very easily turning around and you have some administrator that went out there and looked at the street and said a bus can't turn around but it's been doing it for 24 years if that makes common sense to you then keep this up my name is Jeff fega 12 vill in the same development um we've attempted to appeal to your sense of rationality by presenting the facts and a sense of emotion we're parents that care about our children you could run the clock for the four minutes
182that you want we're not going to end here and what just to let you know the gentleman that you that spoke here with all the facts he's an engineer with the New Jersey Department of Transportation Mr morero he's a police officer you just also heard from a former assistant prosecutor Compu a current attorney I'm a communication uh specialist and I work with philanthropists across the state we're not going to stop I will I will end here by saying that where I've been my son's been picked up for five years in the culdesac with no problems where you've decided to stop the bus there have been 26 accidents in The Last 5 Years does that make sense to you we're not going to stop I will also conclude by telling you that on day one your
183bus driver bullied and harassed my son and I called and I had a I called to speak with you superintendent your assistant uh referred me to Kathleen McDonald and I don't even know if she took the time to tell you what happened on day one we did motion to tell the bus driver to come into the culdesac and she came in at the end of the day when all the kids got on the bus she walked to the end of the bus yelled at my son and said because of your father I almost lost my job today and all of those kids were shocked these kids were shocked and as soon as they got off the bus they're telling us the parents what happened it is clear from what we've heard here today you guys
184don't have a handle on the transportation issues that are going on we care about our children all we're asking is for that bus to turn into the culde saac so we could protect our children we are not going to stop you could run the four minutes on each one of us we're not not going to go quiet thank [Applause] you my name is Arthur Walker I'm at 54 Court in Monroe Township I was the person who had that stop changed 24 years ago because my kids were on the corner cars skidding all over the place it was chaos they one I called the transportation department I told them they say oh it's a safe location day two of the school 1994 it happened again I went to the transportation transportation department and asked the coordinator
185to come out with the superintendent and take a look for themselves they did that afternoon the bus came into the development and it's been that way for 24 years without an incident so I don't know how you can turn around and say that the cue sacks are dangerous when you got forsgate drive out there flying by they blew past the buses I wish you would have seen it you'd have a whole different change of heart right now that's [Applause] it Andy P 16 St James Street that was very emotional and I'm sure uh I feel for the parents especially I drive the Forest Gate Drive and I know the speed limit on it um and I have also seen them do the autoturn uh at the col I don't want to labor the issue but
186I think uh I request the bo to uh and the District administration to look into it uh the reason I came up here is to talk about a couple of items on the agenda uh we talked about the cultural integration uh I think one of the board member talked about uh the number of uh the Asian uh American kids in the school system one of the things uh that could be considered as a possibility is integration of culture uh as a part of learning as well uh I think I was fortunate in enough to be exposed into the Jewish Community the Muslim Community and the Catholic Community uh and going to these places of worship gives you a a completed different ideals in terms of what you're thinking about the culture they're not so much
187different than what you are when you actually see it I think that goes along long way with the kids the second point I want to make is uh I believe this is almost um six years ago or so uh in the uh middle school or maybe even Elementary School I was given an opportunity along with a few other parents to speak to the kids about the professional work we do uh I was only one of the four people there was a police officer there and uh I believe there's a prison security guard there as well uh unfortunately all the kids wanted to become either teachers or pizza delivery people at fourth grade but definitely it was educational for them to understand I talked about the drainage structures and how water backs up if you don't
188have a catch Basin they never noticed it I think that kind of an education also goes a long way to create the young minds to think about their future in which direction they want to go uh the last point I want to make is more trailers I'm going to be on this Crusade uh as long as I have to be I know we have um trailers right now at the middle school I requested at the last meeting to see when we would potentially need a new uh trailers at the high school but now after seeing the budget we haven't budgeted for any trailers in 2019 2020 physical year are there going to be need for additional trailers at the middle school and if so where they're going to go that's all I have okay Mr
189corsky Mr P's question uh we have not met administratively yet to determine uh if we need more trailers or where they would go uh my feeling is I would doubt that more would have to come to the middle school but there there could be needs uh elsewhere in the district for trailers more information will be provided uh the next couple weeks we're going to do a study um potentially for additional trailers at the high school it may not be for next year but the year after but we're going to look into it thank thank you very much uh my name is s Gandhi I'm also a resident of oakill Drive I think my uh neighbors have said a lot I hope that you've uh it has gone into the de years uh it's surprising to
190me to see that while my kids safety is your responsibility and here we are begging for in front of you to make our kids safe which ideally should be your responsibility and you are putting them in danger I I don't know what else to say but I hope that you guys will consider prakash purup 33 Dina Drive I drive every day on half Road and the street you're talking about it is highly traffick Dr per yes could you speak here to I speak to the entire world I can rotate there is no law said that I cannot rotate I can speak to you all address you all the way I want not shouting at you all in a candid way the gentleman's which have spoken is exactly correct and I support them so coming back
191to the I was very happy to see the performance of the AP you know students scoring four and five that is very positive what I request is also budget and include into the goal goals to strengthen our stem program arts and business and have some measurable you know you can majure the improvements so I request that so that we Leap Forward in these programs the ACT scores I was not happy 576 out of 800 in math 539 in English writing and reading whatever it is 539 out of 800 I think a is very important so we have to improve on that and how we all can do that you all are the best judges so please make sure that resources are provided the total score looks like around 1100 out of 1,00 does not look
192good we are not looking at the average versus the state what is the standard deviation what is the range the data has to be presented into range and standard Dev ation not just the average so I request you all to look at ACT scores and AC AC also the another one thing I would like to talk about is the trailers as building and committee Kera talked about the orientation of the parents for the students who are in the trailers was postponed because of the um the you know some issues very ATM you know weather and air conditioners were not working so I request Mr gal to make sure that that orientation takes place as soon as possible and also lastly this is the question I would like to hear from you we have to budget
193for the robotic lab we have converted the science club into robotics so please stepwise consider budgeting we cannot even you know budget all the money in the same year can be done in stepwise and if necessarily we can get grants from the sponsor but I don't want to take time on that so can you please take into considering the robotic Labs so that's my question in stepwise for the budget philosophy uh High School for the high school well we have a robotics classroom you're talking about the comp competition robot robotic the increase in robotics competition as we discussed previously okay and I don't know robotic class or robotic lab it would be very expensive so look out look at the cost and we can help what we can do on that we did invest sizable
194money when we opened up the high school but uh certainly we will look at maintaining the feasibility of maintaining it and improving it okay thank you very much good evening again Ram ragat six Serv tribe mandro um it was interesting first time I'm kind of going through that budget philosophy presentation was very good um very informative uh I know the the philosophy was I guess focus on the macro uh approach right but I just wonder uh in terms of the micro level uh you know shouldn't we also pay some level of attention to that and how does that eventually get into the budgeting process example uh uh we I think a couple of members talked about the trailers uh additional trailers needed potentially in the Middle School in the high school my son this week
195I found out he's in apple cart School found out one the music uh I think it's the music teacher who has lost her room so she's carrying a dolly around uh to teach music I think Arts is as important as uh stem there was there used to be room for accelerated math my when my daughter was in apple guard now the special room for Accelerated math is gone uh right the teacher is using some other teachers classroom right so do we have an accounting of all these things that have happened just for let's say from last year to this year and how is the Board of Education being informed about these changes because these micr level issues are actually going to hurt us the new school is going to take 5 years to come up
196or more but we should try to give the best quality education now and this is what I'm aware of if you interview a lot more parents and the teachers you'll find a huge list so in the budgeting process I just don't see I didn't see anything to be addressing that uh so I would like to understand from the board uh you know any immediate answers you have or what steps if you agree that this is an important item to be looked at and then brought into the budgeting process um as you know today we we adopted a philosophy so it's just a philosophy there everything will be looked at everything has to uh match or growth and the board goals for next year um this the this specific principal in schools will have to go
197through a budget defense rounds with the administrators to defend why they need something everything they come in with a list of things they want and then they have to defend why they want certain things or what they need immediately what they don't so uh at this point I don't know what anybody's um lists are going to look like I don't know that the administrators do but as the um months go by and they get more deeper into the budget process we will have a better understanding of what we really need in each of our schools and in the district okay thank you I appreciate again paying attention to that second piece is just on the park scores notice right I think in third grade fifth grade the scores have dropped compared to 2017 obviously I'll
198be studying it very deeply when the presentation is out my point there was as you go through the goals the action plans I'm hoping that you'll have good set of metrics to measure success against those goals so hopefully there are some tangible goals against Park scores the ranking of the school which is 99 kind of bringing it five notches down above improve Improvement I hope you'll be thinking about some tangible measurable goals uh to uh sorry measures to go against those goals I'll strongly encourage that okay thank you anyone else good evening Betty saparo to Barrymore Drive I have two questions with regard to the busing um so the first one is last year at the beginning of the school year when the special education students were sent to the back of the building I
199had a big to-do about that because you cannot separate children because they special needs and and we had a little bit of a conversation and Mr Gorski and I exchanged some emails about how general education students were placed on those buses because of the C the sack so it actually wasn't separating the special ed students and that there were and I believe I have the email about 70% of the population on the smaller buses again because of the cue-x were general education so are we now no longer picking up general education students in culdesac on the smaller buses so we're back to separating those special needs kids to the back of that building is that what the case is you have any idea I I don't know uh I had a little difficulty following you
200but I will say that we have not deviated from the practice of integrating General Ed and special ed students on the Vans okay Vans no longer and they haven't for a long time had the stigma of of speciala not in this District okay so we do still pick up students we do still pick up gened students and call correct we uh we do pick up in in certain instances probably General Ed kids in culdesac on Vans if Vans go into culdesac and I don't know if that's true or not true I'd have to look at the specific route that you're you're thinking about but in general I want to make sure our children are being integrated if we children absolutely are integrated we do not deliver special ed students to the back of the school
201uh we didn't last year we still don't and if a van goes into a culde-sac we will make every uh we will fulfill every opportunity to pick up all students in that CA sack not not just special ed to clarify you do not put the small buses at mil Lake to the back of the school entrance we do not segregate the delivery of special ed students I'm not saying that you segregate the delivery you do not send those small buses that contain mostly special ed students to the back of mil Lake I believe you do those buses I don't want to get into an argument with you but those aru those buses are not um those buses are integrated and they are delivering students to the back of the school but integrated means there are
202gened and special ed students on the Vans okay so I'll follow up with an email because I'd like to know the percentage of General Ed and Special Ed I actually wasn't coming here to speak about that but I didn't know about the culde acts I have a question and I understand that coordinating transportation in our population has to be a nightmare I understand that but right now some of or a lot of the buses including the one my children are on end somewhere in a development near 33 around 310 maybe a little later mil Lake Ends the school day at 3:19 so clearly you can't get from there to milake at a safe speed on time is that something that we've contemplated is it is it just because it's the beginning of the school year
203anybody Madam sure I I asked Mrs sabaro to take that specific question and contact the transportation director who could ask answer that with h information give you an informed decision okay fair Lou Masters I'm Mel Court um it's mostly about the the original Mercy busing do we have multiple contracted bus companies Madam sure yes we do is Mercy would you say that Mercy's having a majority of the issues right now or is it across all the contract buses Mercy has the extreme majority of all the problems that we're having now we have had uh an extremely rare occurrence where a district in-house route has been a problem we have had contractor problems with votch delivery which is another contractor whose Name Escapes me at this time I reported it to the board earlier but uh
204Mercy is the far majority of all the problems that we're having with with Transportation do we receive all the contracts from the Educational Services Commission we have copies of all no that's where we get them from now right go through that yeah just so there's a full understanding uh we tell the commission that we have a need for a specific route they put it out the bid uh multiple contractors bid on it and then uh we have to go with the lowest uh responsible bidder that's what I didn't want you to say okay and by the way Mr Masters um forgive me for taking up your time but the but the process of breaking contract with the contracted bus company no matter how horrific pretty much the uh performance is it's not something that the
205business administrator has the authority to do because because it becomes a legal process and the attorneys battle it out and generally there's a lot of remedies that have to get put in place first for the contractors to make Improvement so it's a process that unfortunately we've lived through and lingers on and on and on and that's another reason for the need for in-house yeah you you took my question I was going to ask if we could terminate the contract for cause but I guess you're saying that would be a nightmare to do and have the other bus contracts it's an extremely cumbersome legal process they the legal process will look at remedies to be put in place first first and then if you can prove that those remedies weren't properly performed by the contractor you
206can break route and then you're going to go with the second lowest bidder who's going to have to familiarize themselves with the route rather quickly and that's going to take at least a month to go through the bidding process it's a nightmare yeah it's provided by the Educational Services Commission why don't they do that for us because everyone would have to go out to bid all right um about what we said before about in the uh budget philosophy about teachers there was a about um wages versus private there was a study done last year it is only about teachers not administrators um I could send you it by the economic policy Institute and what they found was when they compared teachers against counterparts in the private sector um across the board now this was done
207in 2017 uh Public School teachers were paid 16.8% less uh in wages and 12.5% Less in overall compensation that was 2017 in 2018 I believe that chapter 78 Clause the last piece of that kicked in so that'll definitely go down even further um so again just to say I don't know about the administrators they didn't do a study on them but when it comes to teachers they did a pretty lengthy study I could send it to you and it says they are they are very underpaid in the state of New Jersey uh the last part is the park everybody knows I'm against park I think it's terrible um now they I think Maryland just pulled out today right or they're going to go with a hybrid they're coming up with their own um uh assessment
208um I think that leaves six and including the Department of Defense um so it's I know the uh didn't the governor just decreased the impact to to 5% today that wasn't this week 5% 5% of the teacher evaluation evaluation that done um the the first week of September that went into effect this year and he can't go to zero because it's a legal issue you have to vote on it at the legislature to get rid of park because you have to have an assessment that might happen right I know it was was said over here somebody said are we going to be prepared for that are we going to have another assessment or are we going to have to scramble and tryy to figure out what to do it's not up to the board it's
209up to the state okay thank you I I'm sorry but our policy Mr Gorski did you just say that the cumbersome activity is more it's worth more than my child I'm sorry did you just say that I beg Parton it's a cumbersome thing to get rid of a bus company that's more important than my child is that what you just said that would be a legal process but it's cumbersome right I didn't say it was cumbersome you did I said it's a ly a cumbersome process is that worth more than a child's life I beg your pardon it's a legal issue so mad point of order please I I really feel it's inappropriate that our security guard is is approaching someone I think it's up to you and and taking her I I I was
210trying Miss Miss Armenia well I mean please she didn't I'm sorry but he said it's a cumbersome process excuse me but you our policy states you've come to a public forum once during each public forum I didn't use my four minutes I I'm sorry I didn't know your policy I didn't have the full four minutes I walked away he cannot do that I mean that's misso I'm sorry I've never been here before I don't know and I'm telling you what our policy states dly noted I'll do respect duly noted okay thank you madam I I I have to strongly object to the presence of Miss Armenia we are in the middle of public forum yes and you cannot h i I find it so offensive that yes I'm happy we have security and I I
211think it's a wonderful thing but it is inappropriate for our and you're not doing anything about it intimidating the public for not speaking even if she's wrong and mistaken it the the person who is handling the the meeting can say that have but you're not doing it I'm I'm I'm flabbergasted it's it seems uh it seems so intimidating at to have law en like a law enforcement kind of thing doing there's there's a it's yes there's an armed guard moving someone out without I I have no words I it's wrong it's just wrong thank you is that of order anyone else wishing to speak to the agenda my head why was she excuse me good evening chy scurby 21 PR Drive I don't know why she was removed because I did not ask anybody to
212have her REM he's just talking to her no there's something I did not ask anybody to remove her I was telling her that her time was up she did not give me her name or address when she came back up and and she was confrontational she was hardly confrontational I'm sorry um well that's your opinion so no it's obvious if uh we'll we have a videotape of that there's no confrontation that at that point requires an armed guard to escort someone I did not ask the I know well then it then there's a problem with our structure and our procedures we I I think I think we don't have anything documented terms of operating proced can we continue with public form we can but it is under proper Circ inappropriate I think to have something
213like that done shaking is there is there a guideline that follow we talk about it under other board business right now talk about on the weekend but is there right now we're in the middle of public where we're going let's we could Russ let's discuss it order I think I was within my rights to say so okay all right let's continue with public forum rules and guidelines need that nothing good evening Chris scurby 21 preist drive I'm speaking in regards to the pending litigation on Dr kak I stood here many times at many board meetings and I had given my support and asked the board to reconsider um and have Dr kak continue here for that I feel that members of this District have retaliated against me I saw that last last month when I
214came to this meeting and Mr Ryback held up a packet that was a hate packet that was against me I know that Dr Goodall was tasked with doing an investigation I've not heard anything about that but I did my own investigation I found out that the mil Lake Woodland PTO president OA police reports about me however the 2018 police reports that were filed against me and a school administrator were not part of that Oprah I would like to know how if anyone on this board knows how those were received and entered into that packet that was deliver to all the board members I watched the last board meeting over and over again and I realized that Madame President you said that the packet was dropped off mysteriously while you met with the board attorney Mr
215Gorski and Mr Goodall yet Mr shella read a note that evening that that was inside the packet that said it was mailed to the board office you also said that you added two emails that you received those emails were from the PTO treasure yet the new Middle School PTO president said on Facebook that the letter she wrote was an email to you Mr Goodall and Mr shella to me it looks like you Madame President put this packet together along with the PTO president from Mil Lake Woodland and the former middle school PTO president I would like to know if there's any report tonight from Dr Goodall's investigation in this matter Dr Goodall did his investigation and send it as a confidential document to the Board of Education excuse me we have a member of the
216public here addressing us and there's side bars going on I apologize if we could pay attention that would be I'm Sorry Miss SM that's okay that's confidential the investigation's confidential yet you decided to deliver hate mail to all the board members against me and that wasn't confidential it's not confidential that anybody can go and Oprah this hate package that you delivered yet the findings are confidential why because you're trying to protect members that did this that's disgusting and this board should ask for your resignation anyone else then at this time we're closing public forum and going to the superintendent report Mr Goodall thank you Mrs kapano uh superintendent's report despite some uh HVAC challenges and batt battling the extreme heat and humidity our district our district enjoyed a very successful School opening the opening program
217on September 4th received the rave reviews from staff as we balanced important startup information with our teaching and support staff but allowing for classroom setups grade level meetings and department meetings in preparation for students arriving the next day had an opportunity as superintendent to welcome students back with the building administrations at Monroe Township middle School Brookside and Barkley Brook on day one and then on day two I visited oak tree and Applegarth on day two wanted to thank the efforts of the administrative teams and teaching staff especially in the lower elementary schools it was my first time ever um observing the student arrivals at those schools and I just want to thank them for their efforts in organizing and receiving all of the students and making sure that each child made it to their classrooms
218it's quite a task to the first day especially with some of our lower elementary students and I just want to thank the staff and the administrative teams for the job well done I also wanted to thank the middle school 7eventh grade uh teaching teams who did an incredible job acclim menting their students to the Middle School trailers I want to personally thank the administrative team and the teachers for their efforts and consideration knowing what um some of the feedback we got from the public I saw a number of the uh teaching staff giving uh personal tours while they were prepping and just to relieve the anxiety of some of the parents and students so they just did a wonderful job as previously reported Monro Township High School was recently ranked 99th in New Jersey monthly
219magazine as a top high school in New Jersey so congratulations to the teaching staff and administrative team at the high school I want to thank personally all of the custodians and maintenance technology and transportation departments for their efforts in the school opening the sung Heroes of our district continue their Excellence outstanding job to all those mentioned and lastly I want to congratulate uh Adam Layman principal of Woodland School who successfully defended his dissertation at Ruckers University on Friday he's now known as Dr Adam Layman so congratulations to Adam and we continue to um hire and uh transition new staff into our buildings uh within our staff so Madame board president and members of the Board of Education it is recommended that Personnel action items a through a l under the superintendent report be approved by
220consent roll call so move Mr cherella Mr Ryback any comments questions for Mr goodle Miss armeno um that is I just want to make sure that we're not on five board action items 8 through yet right no we're on Personnel Personnel a through a no Al no comment sorry anyone else then Mr grisy will have a roll call yeah one second I'm sorry um considering what had happened in the past you know the incident I brought up about the staff member being hired from part-time to full-time Mr Goodall provided his report so to everybody on the board um can you uh assure us that everybody you're recommending here followed the proper procedures because when we looked at what happened uh following the the process we can see that it really wasn't complete and somebody was
221U put in a full-time job that shouldn't have been put in a full-time job but the board voted for it so do we have any discrepancies here or is it just not to my knowledge not to your knowledge but they could be so all the measures that I put in place not to my knowledge okay but there could be some there may be right I would say with the measures that we put in place no okay if we happen to find some later what will happen in terms of well if we find a a situation in this um so no one no one on this agenda is being recommended with without proper posting uh evaluation of candidates a recommendation from the appropriate administrator and then follow through uh in human resources and uh for most
222staff uh me or Dr Al yeah but as we know on the previous in the previous case which still needs really to be looked into there was a missing signature and it was a critical signature that was missing and yet the action was executed and the person was promoted so I'm just asking if we find a situation like that here something like that comes up some discrepancy what will be done because everyone's going to vote Yes on this because we can't possibly know every case here if we find a discrepancy later month from now what would be done I guess we could uh speak to board counsel about what could be done um um all of the employees that are listed on this agenda or being recommended to positions they are certificated in or qualified
223for uh the proper posting was put in place um proper interviewing whatever to the level of each position that we do for each hiring process was done and full review of all the records and documents was done by human resources some of the things we put in place this summer and um this is the recommendation that you approve items a through a l I understand but I'm just asking if we find a discrepancy we have to go to the board attorney I guess it would be determined what discrepancy would be okay if we underpaid someone or overid someone I know you're trying to improve the process we we we discussed that and I do have confidence that uh you will do that thank you um so I I just have one more question I would
224like to the the person who's the U chair of the uh Personnel committee Mr Ry Mr Ryback okay so just curious U are you aware of the this case that I'm talking about yeah you are that up put that up a few months ago okay and you know that there was a discrepancy I'm not sure what Mr Russo where are we going with this I just want I I just want to ask what involvement the chair of the personel committee has in this board board members approve the recommendations of the superintendent I understand that and that's that's the job of I understand that and we did that the last time and there was a discrepancy we have no way of rolling it back so I'm just curious as to what role the chair of the
225Personnel committee plays in the process of the hiring if any I don't know we I don't know I'm play a role in the process of the hiring well you have a chair of the Personnel committee right so what they would bring to us is something that is not can the chair answer that I Mr I could certainly answer thank you number one Dr kosac at the time superintendent and he said he would be looking into this he did not discuss with me um any any of his findings uh so and as chair I'm not of of the committee I'm not privy to any of his findings until he's ready to speak to the board in general so I would not be involved in any of those things but that's something that he said he would
226be looking into okay because what I worry about I know you spoke with him multiple times I did and what I worry about is the process and how there were these gaps in the process so I went to see Mr Goodall and I did notice a significant Gap in the process actually it was very surprising and it resulted in somebody getting hired in a way that they shouldn't have been hired right to a full-time job so I I was just wondering if you as chair of that committee um look to make improvements in the process or looked at how the process it's not up to me to look to make improvements that's an administrative function which the superintendent would do I would be uh wrong in in well you can make suggestions and making suggestions
227to improve the process okay you you wouldn't make suggestion okay I would like to address that um we H we've had speculation about this issue but I think it's a greater issue if there's a problem in the hiring process yes we can't micromanage employees hiring employees however we're supposed to trust administrations and administators and the and the Committees and however that process is supposed to go to be done properly if there's a gap in the hiring process and this happens I think it is incumbent upon the board to make sure that the administration is is doing their due diligence to do the right thing because that would be that would be I think it is in our purview to make sure that the that the proper hiring process and I've I've I I would like
228to put this out because I'd like to address this in in the future that we have to maybe review and be and and have and and have a um explanation of how the hiring practice actually occurs I've heard over the years several different ways the hiring process has to be pure and it has to be done right or else we have no reason to take recommendations because our job is to take the recommendations at the end but if the beginning and the process is flawed and if there is a significant Gap then it is not it is our job to protect employees and hire properly because the board the the administration recommends it but is our responsibility to hire people so we have to hire the right people it's the entire board responsibility as you
229said to look look out for that I know um that Mr Russo spoke with Dr kosac a few times he mentioned it at an open board meeting Dr kosac said he would be looking into it um that recommendation should have been brought before the board I don't think it was I think he said it was uh um an error or something I forgot exactly what he said so I shouldn't even comment on it but uh there was no change in in in the procedure uh I would think that maybe that's something you wanted to since you brought it up you may have wanted to follow up with it was you know you could have come on to and said anything at Personnel level or more importantly at the board level but it's certainly up to
230the superintendent and the board in general to look into things like that if there's a discrepancy the administration should uh work with the board in correcting it I think I think Mr Russo has talked about it as a systemic problem and that's how we should view it not one incident but if there if there are are systemic issues about procedure I think that's something we do have a right to and I think that was brought to Mr Goodall when he became the actor and superintendent and he put a process into place to make sure that this doesn't happen again and i' I'd be happy I'd be happy to find out what that process and if it does happen again then we have to re Mr Goodall it would be his responsibility to re relook at
231the process that he put into place and and fix it the message was also copy you the reports I'm just curious did you look at it any further or which message from you the email that was sent by Mr Goodall his report was sent also to you so I'm just curious if you had taken looked at it any further or just I look at all the emails that I received yes so did you look into this issue because it's a significant issue I we have to think about it was not up to me the report not to rehash the report the report did not report out on a systemic issue there was two uh issues that were brought to my attention one I felt was handled appropriately in terms of hiring and the one you
232keep referring to which it's uh debatable whether um there was an issue or not well I don't think there's any debate there from previous administration they said there was not a debate and there's no debate there to me it's still an open issue I think that should be I I can assure the board that it's not a systemic issue well we don't know that we but we do know that because our Acting Superintendent just said that that that's no Pro the Acting Superintendent that's why he's in his role and his position I'm going to do superintendent you must have inside information that you're not sharing with everybody because the way you persist on this tells me you have inside information and it either slighted someone in your family or someone personal but you you know
233what we're supposed to be approving I feel like you have inside information so I I I I certainly can report out of the board uh some of the changes um some of the processes we use to hire there's I have no problem doing that Mr PA what you could do is inform yourself go to Mr Goodall's office and look at the process before you talk to me I could I like like I did I took the time out I certainly information I certainly would be open to meeting with any board member who would like to uh ask some questions about some of the things discussed but I can assure you that uh there is no systemic problem here um in my opinion that was an isolated incident and um we're putting things in place to
234ensure that um proper processes and postings and recommendations and to the agenda for the board to vote on or follow I agree and so can can we missina I just want have a quick question so since there was this there was a something that wasn't done and that paperwork said that it was required did you go to to our board attorney and ask this was all done prior to me taking over I mean it doesn't really matter it's just like a process that we have no I did uh one of the issues was um can uh a situation be undone and we were advised that no at this point it would be even if the paperwork says signature is required for this to occur we there's nothing we can do legally I'm a little uncomfortable
235discussing the particulars of a recommendation form for an employee um but um certain processes were in place prior to May to July 1st and some processes we put in place um I believe tightens up the ship in terms of hiring and uh that's what I'll continue to do moving forward we can't go back we can only work on fixing what we did what what happened and making sure it doesn't happen again I understand the problem we have with the board is that July 1st consequences when people make mistakes or do the wrong thing there are no consequences and we're being told we can't turn the clock back and he's asking well what if there's a mistake on what we're voting on right now I guess we can't turn the clock back so that's what you
236know what the problem we can't we can't undo something that a former superintendent did so there are consequences so the former superintendent missed that there was a gap there and he's no longer our superintendent so there are consequences Paul oh um visit Mr Goodall look at the document because we don't know to what we supposed to be approving superintendent report that's the point I feel like I feel like Mr Goodall can review the processes with all of us and then we have to trust in the process and trust in him we asked him to do a job we asked him to look into the process and fix it if there was mistakes passed that's what he's done and he is saying that he believes that there's nothing wrong with the people okay with this agenda
237so at this point we need to just move on more information I mean I feel like we have to trust Mr Goodall in what he said that he fixed the process unless you guys have information that we don't know about because Jill I trust him I'm going to vote Yes but I'm just asking if there is a mistake and we find out it's not going to be his mistake but the processes W followed what are going to be the consequences if there's a mistake on this agenda it's my mistake because I make the recommendations to the board and the items for approval are items a through a we have a roll call yes Mr redy there are none that's the point yes Mr Chella yes Mrs armeno yes Mrs Corino yes Mr Ryback yes Mrs
238Deo yes Mr Russo yes and Mrs kopanos yes madame board president motion unanimously passes okay we will go to the board action board action items Madam board president members of the board of editors recommended that board action items a through M be approved by consent roll call so move Mr chair Mr Ryback questions from Mr Goodall Mr E on um that is recommended approve the following textbook I'd like clarification The American Pageant US History honors one and to and I did read um the paperwork regarding this was just a question and answer multiple well that was multiple choice question and answer about the book however given um what I'd like to uh see in the curriculum is there any specific Civic lesson or go does it talk about the government and how uh and and
239our government practices in this book I don't know the answer to that question off the top of my head I had the book with me last at the last meeting for curriculum it did go through the curriculum committee meeting I understand that this is actually the same um textbook that they're currently using it's an updated version this is only one resource that the course uses so the course can use other resources also but we don't know if they're specific um because clearly we need education on our Civic duties and what we're responsible for and how government should be conducted so okay I'm just going to send you don't know I'll have to abstain on that one anyone else oh oh and for that I would also like to table h under the circumstances this evening
240I think we should table H for further review motion the table is a priority motion is there a second I'll second M Corino seconds we'll go to a roll call vote U I want to make sure everybody knows what H is before we vote everybody got it yes Mr cherella may we continue okay take a roll call Mrs Corino this is the table item H yes Mrs armenio yes Mr Chella no Mrs Deo no Mr rety no Mr Russo uh yes Mr Rybeck no Mrs kapano no B board president motion to table fails okay can we have a roll call on the board action it a through M can I also then ask if the certification has been obtained for this individual because I believe he does not need a certification anymore they when did
241that change it got changed this year that's why he's being recently is there anything that was sent out to the board suggesting that can you tell me when that was or is there something no I know I read it um I'm not sure if it was I I think at the um state level there were so many right it's a letter from the state right that said um the people that were in this did who had the certific ation there were a lot of people who like no I understand there was a movement to get the person but I'd like to know that it actually happened I did see it it's on the it's on here so it's a question you wouldn't have it I don't I don't see it was this the letter from
242new uh NJ it might have been is it in board dos Homeland Security and preparedness no actually this was in my Jamesburg update but I maybe the letter you're referring to I'm just checking just give me a date and who it's from uh it was September 6th it's not an it's not an email you'll find but the the letter came out of the office of Homeland Security New Jersey on September 6th it's the letter about school safety this and it says I'm just checking to see if this is the letter you're referring very recent I didn't I I S I looked in board dos it's not on here as a um there's a letter from the Department of vet Mr Good send a letter tomorrow send everybody a copy of the letter tomorrow since it
243it doesn't seem to have but it's not in file attachments because I did look and file attachments so it might be in board Docks but not under the proper um section is this Madam yes there was communication from the state that went to the administration and it indicated from two different sources um Department of Education and also New Jersey Association of school business officials that the certification required for school safety Specialists was lifted the superintendent can recommend um any duly qualified person without a certificate be school safety specialist I'll be happy to to send that information to Mrs armeno I think you would send it to the whole board certainly had the question come up earlier we could have had that uh communication ready to support the superintendent recommendation had the file attachments been included
244that I wouldn't have had the question okay um I'm satisfied that you will send it to me we will have it sent to the whole board please so will have a roll call now on accepting the board action items for the superintendent a through M Mr Rybeck yes Mr retsky yes Mrs Deo yes Mrs Corino yes Mr cherella yes Mrs armeno um abstain on E and no on H so noted yes on everything else yes thank you Mr Russo yes Mrs K Pano yes Madam board president board action items a through M has passed okay at this time we'll go to the business administrator's report Madame board president and members of the Monro Township Board of Education it is recommended that board action items a through M be approved by consent roll call can I
245ask a question as soon as we have a first and a second Mr Chella Mr Ryback now you can ask a question we have one fund that has 17 cents in it uh yes ma'am that is can you explain why that is certainly that's one of the bond referendum of previous accounts for the high school and the account was closed all of the uh Appropriations were spent but I don't see it and then we had a last minute adjustment to appropriate interest earnings on a shared account and this that's how accurate we are with with the uh journal entries 17 cents was allocated to this fund that will be closed out this year there will there be no interest on the 17 cents that requires us to be kept open okay thank you any other
246questions for Mr borski yeah just I'm looking for the board action that has to do with um number two professional appointments under a A2 oh yeah okay I got it but also um uh the on oh can we ask questions yes okay on number one uh the contract that we have I mean this says it's not to exceed 75,000 and Mr Gorski uh reiterated that however the contract that is not signed yet says 77,4 7450 I'll take will that be changed to 75,000 Madam yes this contract initially came in at about 108,000 uh it's unbudgeted funds to pay for mold remediation Mr T and I as I reported to the board previously called the contractor expressed our opinion on the proposal and the opinion of uh Dr Lynch and our insurance broker for Property and
247Casualty um after uh after consideration the contractor was uh willing to reduce the contract not to exceed $75,000 the contract came back the itemization of the contract is slightly above 75,000 but in bold letters above the total it says contract not to exceed 75,000 so that's the driver of this contract what the board's approving tonight is that this contract will not exceed 75,000 there will be no further revision that's needed even even though it says um on page five of The Proposal that subcontractor Services subject to Cost Plus 20% if applicable is that excluded as well not to exceed 75,000 in bold that pertains to this contract now if some mediation uh further expansion is needed we would have to come back to the committee and the board and explain why and the uh the
248the need for more funds but right now as I've said 75,000 is what you're voting on not to exceed okay and um if it pleases uh the board president and the board uh number two uh there's there was discussion if if the board had an opportunity to read the letter from uh Mr clauser Mr Gary flet housers if I say it right fles housers uh attorney regarding the um the construction next to Barkley Brook uh the the letter talks about and and we've had this conversation several times the letter talks about an access an emergency access um some of us thought that that emergency access should in uh should be ex expanded to a walkway so we're going to put a resolution um as an addendum to this uh but now and I and this
249is not a surprise because it was a surprise to me this particular ha this particular development has a culdesac and after what I heard today and the fact that the children uh get picked up on 522 I hope that the transportation committee takes a look at this and maybe our buildings and grounds uh Mr T and Mr uh and I'm not saying that it's going to go on here but I hope this culdesac is wide enough for a large bus to turn around in if that's the case but that's another that's another conversation for another day um so as an addendum to number two as recommended by the buildings and grounds committee it is recommended that the Board of Education acknowledge receip and acceptance of the terms and conditions contained in this um August 31st
250letter in correspondence from Mr Peter h clauser esquire on behalf of his client Gary flesh Houser dated August 31st 2018 and exhibit a which is a sketch of the proposed sidewalk and access easement and in bold letters this is the change with further requirement that the easement be granted for emergency access as well as a walkway the board attorney is hereby authorized and directed to take all necessary steps to implement this action by the board Miss armeno are you asking to um make a motion to amend with the bold print yes okay so so you would be making that motion I am is there a second to the motion what bold print what I just read the boldprint reads with further no I guess with further requirement that the easement be granted for emergency access
251seen that yes I understand that's why I'm repeating it I need to read it read she I just read I need I need to read it Mr Gorski wrote it so I'm sure I wrote it minutes before the meeting this evening and I'll be happy to repeat it if if it pleases the board it's the same motion as the professional appointments number two except Miss armino is asking to amended with at the addition of with the further requirement that the easement be granted for emergency access as well as a walkway the emphasis interpretation of this is that in addition to just being an emergency access easement it would be a walkway okay I understand so is Mr Chella second that so now we have to have a roll call on the amendment Mrs Deo yes
252Mr rutsky yes Mrs Corino yes Mr cherella yes Mr Ryback yes Mrs Armenia yes Mr Russo yes Mrs kovich yes Madam board president motion has been amended to include the walkway component thank you say are there any other questions for Mr Gorski on this is he going to get mailed to the um planning Bo an attorney is that um I I believe there was a series of um letters between Mary and the their the other attorney okay so I I assume it has to go to the planning board yes I believe that after Mary speak to him it's my understanding that they would present our resolution at the planning board and we should be following up on the planning board to make sure it's the same as what we're asking for yes okay Mr uh
253Mr Gorski roll call Mr rutsky yes Mrs Corino yes Mrs Deo yes Mr Chella yes Mrs armeno yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr Russo yes Mrs colano yes Madam board president boort action items has passed under the ba report that concludes my report thank you okay so my report's going to be very short according to what uh Maryann fredman said of New Jersey school boards we should be doing a board self- evaluation which is online under njsba so I'm just going to ask because everybody on the board can do that so I'm just going to ask everybody to um go online and fill that out so that's it so other board business um Mr cherella I would like to ask a favor of you and your um um buildings grounds and transportation committee if you would
254put on your next agenda the transportation issue that we heard today yes I'm not going to make any guarantees that we're going to do anything or we could do anything but I think it's worth a discussion at the bg& committee level I'll make a note of that thank you the yeah the culdesac issue thank you Ken thank you all right any other board of education oh I just want to I just want to let everyone know that we're going to have a fair funding committee meeting on September 20th at 7 pm right here so thank you Mr Goodall for setting that up I appreciate it and uh it's open to the public Mr Min i' just like an update on the um auditor and and our um how how far we are with that have
255we put out an advertisement for an auditor because I believe now that we're doing isn't it time for the auditor to come in and take a look at the budget doesn't it usually start in October he he's been already working on the budget he starts in June the auditor Madam so for I I'm sorry we have a resolution may I may I uh clarify what I stated previously which I I thought was clear the auditor is engaged to audit the year already the for the year ended June 30 2018 you approved that last year he has been beginning with that last October and that is is uh about 75% complete if I had to estimate what you're referring to Mrs armino is the request for RFP request for proposal for auditing services for next year
256and this would be July 1st 18 through June 309 okay the word yeah and we usually um would vote on something like that at the vard meeting when we do all of our well it was already voted on it's been voted on by this board so it is already uh voted on to to go out for an RFP right we're going to be vot doing that going out for an RFP but we usually hire the auditor around January when we reor well if we have one by then I hope can I ask question Madam uh to to further elaborate on that the request for proposal as I discussed its uh composition at the last meeting is near completion we had intended on presenting it at finance committee which I stated previously but the finance committee
257was canceled due to the urgence nature of the trailers and a plan tour that unfortunately never took place so I would assume that at the next finance committee meeting the request for proposal would start as it should with the finance committee and then come to the full board okay well that was all I needed is an update thank you Mr Russo um what what would be that the scope of that RFP would it be to um to hire um a new auditor or is it just auditing services and we could end up with the same auditor M apparently you want to answer that if you wish I I think we get an RFP and we go through the process and we do what we would normally do we could have the same we could not
258have the same auditor but that would defeat the the intention of um that's the process I I feel I'm sorry I feel compelled to add because this is an important process quite often school districts and school business administrators will go out for rfps for multiple different Services it's not the auditor it's auditing services and they will do a uh review of the bids that come in um rates with other type of services and it may be concluded that what you have is um is efficient and um satisfying to the board because it's the board's decision so it's unclear what will come of this RFP process but it will be advertised and as I'm sure that the board appreciates it will be an open and Democratic process I don't know what what but many times organizations
259do choose to just change Auditors not just ating servic best prac PR yeah any other board of education business I have a motion that's ridicul you have a motion that's what's going to happen yeah that's ridic oh yes okay so I'm sorry I'm going to read the motion and then if you guys have questions I can explain it the motion to approve one unified partner Fitness Club in the Monroe Township High School for the school year 2018 2019 school year and and two three coaching positions with a stipend of $1,000 each in connection theret which stiens shall be paid with a portion of the grant money the board will be receiving from Special Olympics New Jersey the Acting Superintendent of school and the business administrator board secretary are hereby authorized and directed to take all
260necessary steps to implement this action by the board of education so wait wait you're the first I need a second I'll second Mr Mr just wanted to explain this we in I need to read it we just are you making fun of me no I am she said she needs to read I said I need to read it you are more than welome to read it thank you that's all I said I'm not making fun of you just yeah just reread it please cuz you're no well I want to explain it to you and then I can read it again so we just accepted a grant from play for play unified um from the Special Olympics in the the form of 5500 now this is a new Club and new clubs usually have no stiping
261the first year but we received this Grant and this grant is going to be used to pay for the instructors for this so if this is at no cost to the district but we need to have a motion to accept to use that grant money to pay for these instructors for this unified play um club and this is what we were discussing about Special Olympics and general yes ed students yes it's a fitness club for and it's a one-time Grant or can we anticipate getting this grant every year we've received the grant for the last six years and what we done with the money previously it's gone through to other unified programs for other resources that that uh Mrs Dylan has done with her Falcon pal students okay and we also implemented last year um
262up dance we've also uh had three Unified sports teams last year um that we've also expanded and um Special Olympics has supplemented and that's what this grant was for okay so Motion in a second we'll have a roll call on this Mr Rybeck yes Mrs Deo yes Mr cherella not come back come back we will we will skip skip Mr Cher Mrs Corino yes Mr rutsky yes Mr Russo yes Mrs armeno yes Mrs K Pano yes do you want to go into the bathroom with a microphone I've done a lot for the board over the years should have an intercom in there know we have to wait uh the motion passes um we could ask Mr cherella for his vote on this and continue on with the meeting when he returns if he pleases the
263board okay can I go to the public for can you explain a little more about it just curious about the program it's a it's I talked about it in my curriculum it's a um it's a program where is it here it is it's an integrated program that um has Monro it's a program in Monroe that has gained National recognition from Special Olympics and we're they're looking to expanded to this upfitness club um this initiative we will be providing our students with intellectual disabilities a chance to engage in Lifetime Fitness activities alongside their typical peers specifically on Thursday afternoon students will be taken part in one of the following activities led by an adviser with that expertise weight training yoga and Zumba and it's a way to get our students with intellectual disabilities into fitness and
264to teach them about Fitness okay can I go into the public forum yes you may and we can come back for Mr chell's vote for the record okay anybody from the public wishing to speak please come to the microphone state your name and address for the record and yes we will adhere to our four minut boy four uh for Tam Road uh one I'm I'm glad to hear that the president uh has asked the chairman of the transportation Etc committee uh to revisit the issue of the buses with the culdesac um I know that you want to support the uh recommendations or the the decisions of your employees however I think the parents that spoke tonight gave a very strong case for the safety of their children and uh I'm glad that that will be
265visited uh secondly uh I was at last month's uh board meeting and uh one of the reasons I came tonight as a member of the public was I was hoping to uh to hear what the results of the investigation that Mr Goodall was going to conduct I understand that he did send some type of an explanation or the results of that investigation to all the members of the board but but the issue here is that last month members of this board as well as this Administration uh your integrity was brought brought into question by some of your colleagues and so the board uh not the board the public with any without any information in terms of the results of that investigation we don't know if you did have involvement or you did not have involvement
266I understand that you might not want to be mentioning names but I think in some way the public is entitled to have some of an some what kind of an idea as to what the results of that investigation were were any members of the administration directly involved in the development of that packet were any members of the board complicit in the development of that packet okay I just think that that's very important in terms of your own integrity and I wish that that had been shared with the public tonight Mr Po I will tell you to the the answer to both those questions is no all right thank you uh finally but I'm go through the whole report because that would not be appropriate that's fine uh finally uh you know this issue of of
267the mold being discovered I I understand how that came about I know many other schools Elementary and high schools they all suddenly found themselves with that issue what I'm interested in is what will be done going forward like next summer the summer after that so that the district will not face that uh there's there are some districts that had that have had to close their schools uh and they're presently closed uh we would not want that to happen you know teachers are ready come back to school uh kids are ready to come back to school so I'm not so much interested in what has been done but but in terms of what will be done to avoid that going forward thank you just to answer that so in speaking to uh Dr Lynch today uh
268he said he was more than willing to provide all of our custodians with a summer mold inspection train in uh going into next year for the summer if the board was willing to take on uh Dr uh Dr Lynch to do the training for our custodians can I just add something I know the state Mr P is also U looking into a requirement that all schools test for mold once every five years they could decrease it or what I know but this is what they're at least talking about doing something you know and only when it's a hot humid summer right okay Betty sabito to Barrymore Drive I know it's late and we've all been here a long time but I wanted to address something that came up at the last Board of Ed meeting
269and seems to be coming up again today with regard to the district district employees that are running the outside special needs business um I can tell you that the information you're receiving is not correct I personally have used this company for for a number of years uh I went and searched for them they did not come looking for me I was looking for a company that was small enough that my son would not get lost there um most of their referrals when I started I was one of their first clients most of their referrals over 50% of their clients right now are my referrals people that I've gotten to them either via Monroe or outside of Monroe so I think we have to be very careful with how we're doing this investigation and we're bringing
270people's integrity and livelihood into play um as we all very well all know our teachers are not the best paid um people in New Jersey or anywhere else and we have to be careful with playing with their livelihood as to what they can and can't do afterwards um to begin with it is owned by two employees it is not owned by three employees um there was originally another owner she has not been there for over two years the power that went from part-time to full-time and that whole thing was never an employee of this company okay um they are not manipulating IEPs and those of you that know me well know that I am a huge advocate for what my son is legally entitled to and I would never go outside and pay for services
271that should be provided at the school because they're being recommended by somebody so I I really I want you to get your information clear before we put somebody's Integrity into question because that in and of itself is unethical um not just myself but I have numerous families that are willing to come up here and speak sign a letter whatever it is that the board feels and Mr goodle feels is necessary so that you can understand understand that they are not Crossing Lines somebody brought up the question of they're making copies on the phone I sit in that office 4 days a week with my child um they have an office manager they have a photocopy machine computers telephone not sure why they would do it um while on duty and I believe most of the
272therapist case loads are so large that they wouldn't have the time to do this so I think we really need to be careful with um what we're saying about this um the outside companies that are run by teachers or therapists in the District are numerous so I question why this is the one being targeted my opinion it's because they're successful um I also want to make it very well known I do not work for the district I did not work for the district in the past I do not have any relatives in The District in the past or currently so I just I really want you to be careful about why they're being targeted do this investigation with um open eyes I understand that there are lines that you know could be crossed I can
273assure you in my case and the families that I've recommended there on the contrary they will not touch your child if anybody that works there has your child in school yes they have't Monro employees they have been alapin employees they have sville Basking Ridge up north down south I mean they have employees from all over so I think we really before we have clear evidence we shouldn't bring this to the public because last month was the first meeting I've missed in years and I was watching this going these people are getting bashed and their reputations are being put into play when we don't have any clear facts if any of you I've already met with Mr Mr Goodall if any of you would like to meet with me or have a discussion with me I'm
274more than open like I said I'm their biggest marketing person because I'm the one because my son has been doing so well this is supplementing what he's getting in school I would never pay out of pocket services that the school should be getting because somebody at the school from what is said is recommending and I don't understand how a physical therapist or um a speech person could recommend different types of services without the entire child study team being involved and so our all child study teams across the district doing this it's just just give these these people a chance um Mr Goodall do your investigation is I mean Clearly Now You're a private detective doing all these investigations but if if you'd like to speak to me and like I said if you would like
275a letter if you'd like more parents to come up here I have about 20 parents that are more than willing to come up here that were my referrals and that are not that are just happening to go there thank you anyone else wishing to speak okay seeing no one the next schedule Board of Education meeting is October 17 2018 7:00 p.m. at the Monro Township High School um motion to adjourn so moved what just making sure we have enough for quarum to close we she mov it I'll second it Mr Mayo rutsky all in favor I opposed then meeting is adjourned