CorpusRecord 132997

Monroe Township Board of Education 10.17.18 Regular Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Monroe Township School District
Date
2025-02-11
Location
Middlesex County, NJ
Material
Transcript
Extent
23,229 words · about 130 min
Collected
2026-06-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001good evening the meeting of the Monroe Township Board of Education will come to order please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance would you would you like to lead us in the pledge today sure over here you could go over to the microphone over there I pledge allegiance to the flag United States of America and to the Republic which stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all may we have a roll call Mr Gorski certainly Mrs armeno Mr Braverman here Mr cherella here Mrs Deo here m Mrs kapano here Mrs Lang here Mrs Corino Mr Ryback here Mr Russo thank you sir here and Mr rutsky here Madame board president you have a quarum present this evening thank you in accordance with the provisions of the New Jersey open public meetings law

002the Monroe Township Board of Education has caused notice of this meeting to be published by having the date time and place thereof posted October oober 12th 2018 at all schools the home News Tribune cranberry press and filed with the clerk of the municipality thank you and before we get into the agenda I have two things to to um say right now first is I'd like to welcome back Mrs Patty Lang we have not seen Patty since um May she's she's been battling an illness and we are very very happy to have you back in healthy thank you can I can I yes you can um thank you Kathy I I want to to to thank my fellow board members especially for for your support for the last few months um for those of you in

003the public who are not aware on June 6th I suffered my third stroke um most people are lucky enough not to have one but as an overachiever three sounded like a good number uh the third stroke has taken is has taken its toll I'm I'm very fortunate to here and um but I AP and I do apologize that I wasn't able to to um fully fulfill my role as a as a board member but and for the next couple of months I might not be here for entire meetings but please know that I'm I'm doing my best to to come back and and do what's best for the students of of Monroe and I appreciate the support that I've gotten from members of the community and the feedback and please if if you can do

004one thing please learn fast and teach it to your children teach it to your family members because my 13-year-old daughter recognized that I was having the stroke and her quick action saved my life and prevented much greater disabilities so thank you very much thank you Patty and welcome back we have a cake for you yes and um and now I have a to make a point of correct it has come to my attention that a member of the Board of Education and or a member of the public will be calling for my resignation as president of the board of education at this evening's meeting plee please excuse my voice I've had a cold for the last 5 days I'm still trying to get over it to be very clear I will not resign my position

005as president there has been a lot of misinformation that has been posted on social media and stated during public forums during previous board meetings I wish to set the record straight I have been an active member of this school Community for the past 30 years having served in various capacities such as officer of the middle the elementary middle and high school ptas sometimes at the same time I've done all three officer of the Monroe Education Foundation eight years of service on the Monroe Municipal Recreation Advisory Board representative of the ptas to the community Relations Committee Member of various District committees including DEC human relations teacher recognition school goals music parents and booster club member of every negotiations committee since 2000 member of the board of education for 19 years serving as president of the board

006for nine and serving as vice president for four years throughout the past 30 years I have served in these positions in a voluntary unpaid capacity I have faithfully and honestly served the school Community throughout this time and I have devoted countless hours of my time for the betterment of the school district and many times ignoring what has gone on with my children so that I could be with our children over here the first piece of advice that I ever received as a board member was to always make decisions based on what is best for children even if I was the only person to do that I have always followed that advice and have always put our students first I have consistently supported the exceptional staff in this District in order to ensure the educational advancement

007of all students in the district my record as a board of education member over the past 19 years speaks for itself during my tenure my fellow board members and I have accomplished the following and this is just some of the things that have been accomplished enhanced curriculum including expanding honors and AP offerings and expanding co-curricular clubs and Athletics so that all students feel a connection to the school in fact different school districts come to Monroe to observe Monroe's best practices both in and out of the classroom the passage of the referendum and the building of oak tree School under my presidency on time and under budget with the money that was saved going back to the public in tax relief enhanced IND District special education offerings resulting in the transition of many out of District

008special education students back to the home schools enhanced technology in the district through the use of iPads and laptops in the classroom expanded the IND District transportation Fleet which is now giving us the majority of our transportation routes in District the passage of two referenda and the building of the new high school including involvement in a 4-year legal battle over the land acquisition again coming in on time under budget and the Surplus going back to the taxpayers designed the framework with the Jamesburg board president for the Jamesburg agreement which ended an expensive and protracted litigation in the best interests of all students in the high school requested that the business administrator look at the feasibility of hiring in District Council as opposed to us utilizing an outof District Law Firm supported the installation of Stadium

009lights and two artificial fields that allowed for tearing of events and are shared by this district and the community and also for the first time we were able to have nighttime games in our community which we had never had before implemented the annual budget philosophy meeting giving the board more to say in the operating budget supported the implementation of the IND District Falcon care and early childhood education programs as enterprising funds which have made money for the district that we use in our to offset some of the costs in our operating budget participated in professional development for board members every year in my 19 years of service attaining the recognition of Master board member that is not accomplished by too many board members in the state of New Jersey I believe that there should be

010a good relationship between the Board of Education and the township government in order for us to make Monroe the best community it can possibly be for everybody however at no time have I ever forfeited my independent judgment as a board of education member to anyone at any time I categorically deny the false allegations and misinformation that has been circulated about me I hold my integrity and my self-respect in the highest regard and I always have and always will continue to make decision decisions in the best interest of the children and the entire School Community once again to be very clear I have no intention of resigning my position of board President we are supposed to be role models for children so we need to stop all this nonsense focus on the reason that each of

011us was elected to do a job to educate our children in Monroe so at this time we're going to go to the approval of the minutes on the agenda which is number five is there a motion a second Mr Ryback is there a second Mr Mayo any additions or corrections to the minutes okay we will have a hand vote all in favor one two three four five one two three excuse me four five 67 all opposed can I can Madam can I ask why we're having a hand vote and not a roll call vote because in the last few months we've had a lot of um misin not misinformation it's been hard to know who's who's voting for what so I I would I would ask that we have a roll call vote on these

012things we can do that in the future I agree thank um abstains any the abstentions Miss Mrs Lang is abstaining any recusals none okay at this time we will have a we have the public you have the close session minutes too oh I'm sorry thank you for letting me know that the approval of the Clos session minutes for August 22nd 2018 so moved M Mr Mayo Mr Ryback I have a question Miss uh Mino there were uh in the packet uh we received the um the minutes of the Clos session and then on the uh board docks it was redacted and that what was redacted did not seem to me to be confidential it was talking about um did you know what you're speaking I mean I I I didn't understand why that would have

013been redacted I pulled it out of board du I only read the ones that were with included with this I know that's my point my point is if we're voting on something we should know what we're voting on and the redactions had to had to do with Dr alvix some of the things she was talking about clubs I don't know that that was confidential no was not the sidebar not no not in the in the 20 me I'm sorry I'm not following but I will tell you that all the redactions go through U not only myself but the board attorney also okay well I have I have both here so well and they both are August I mean if you can pass this on may I suggest that uh you could abstain on the minutes

014and you're welcome to send an email for clarification because if they get approved then then it doesn't matter right I mean had I had the question been posed before the meeting I certainly could had clarification but I'm sorry I'm not following okay I I don't know what the red well the front the part first part is the unredacted so I don't see why the second part on the board doc should be redact acted can we include that now I mean so so my thing would I would like to add to the close session minutes our attorney is here maybe she'd like to take a look um I I don't think that would be appropriate Miss Mrs armino um why not if our attorney is here and I do you because the approp with all respect

015the appropriate time to address changes in the or questions would be before the meeting via question through email no this is a public this we don't have the resources here to be able to answer some of that or have a a well okay I would like to say that I believe if you want to pass that around I don't see why those things should be redacted can we T yeah I'll T you want to table the uh I'd like to vote to table the a motion to table yes I make a motion to table the close session minutes second second by Mr Russo so we'll have a vote have a roll call on tabling the closed session minutes until the next board meeting we need a vote for that you can pass those that back

016to me please you can look it motion to table is a priority motion we'll go right to a vote motion was moved by Mrs armenio seconded by Mr Russo Mr Rybeck yes Mrs Deo no Mr cherella yes Mrs Lang abstain Mr Braverman no not Mr rety you vote to read can you phrase the question again s uh the motion is to table the yes yes I vote Yes vote Yes to table the minutes Mr Russo yes Mrs armeno yes Mrs Kap panovich yes motion to table the minutes has passed thank you okay so we will go may I Madam if I may m M Aro please if you could send an email uh with your specific question uh we could then address it before presentation at the next meeting and I I I appreciate that

017and I've said this before I have time constraints as well I do have a full-time job um and sometimes I can only get to you know I take hours and hours to read all of this stuff and I do work on weekends so it's difficult for me to sometimes get it I spent uh most of my day today getting caught up with all of the paperwork and I actually do read all this paperwork so I apologize if it's untimely on for for your schedule sir but this is a public forum so I just want to facilitate the board and investigate and find whatever information is available for your inquiry okay I have a question is it on regard to the minutes yes well it's regarding to what we were talking about because you opened up

018by you you opened up by saying that somebody was going to ask you to resign Mr Mr Russo we're on I know but you we are on approval of minutes and that's where we are right now I know that but you took a lot of time we're staying at the approval of minutes now we're going to number six presentation so you don't want to elaborate on that not at this point we we're going to the agenda you took the board's time to give a lengthy you're out of order if you'd like to say something you can do it under other board business so at this time we're going to to elaborate we don't know if that's even true I mean um yes do you want to um introduce them and why we're doing this and

019the and the principal of the school so this year we are um the mtea is has again offered their pride grants to some of our to all of our schools so we'll be um sharing some of the highlights of things that are happening in our school and the first month this month in October we are celebrating oak tree school's 10th birthday [Applause] [Music] so they had a wonderful week of celebration last week uh Mr Goodall Miss calano and I actually attended one of their um assemblies that happened uh students and teachers were involved the entire week in different activities so I will turn it over to Mrs Dinsmore good evening can you hear me okay a little closer good evening I am Patty dmore the proud principal of oak tree School in September a little

020lower thank you mski please okay you don't have to keep we'll fix it in September 2008 oak tree opened its doors to 662 students in grades prek through six under the supervision of Mr Dennis villo Through The Years many changes occurred including growing student and staff population and grade configuration 10 years later our doors open to over 700 students in grades prek to three and we are very excited to be celebrating our 10th birthday our birthday steering committee comprised of Cassy Shay Stephanie Zori Denise Cil Amanda McGary Nancy hanlin Ashley peepy Amanda Lee fretz and Kim sonari and some other very talented volunteers have been working tirelessly to decorate the school with balloons created by our families birthday gifts with the staff's 10-year-old photos on them and glass cases filled with memorabilia that showcase oak

021tree through the years tonight we are going to show you a little of what occurred during our birthday week which was last week many thanks to Boris and his film crew who came every single day for creating and creating a wonderful Keepsake video which you'll be able to see tonight also special thanks to our PTA for providing a rocking assembly last Friday and many many thanks to the mtea for assisting with the funding of the project called oak tree rocks we will end our presentation with the rendition of the birthday song performed by some of our students and as you can see we have a beautiful birthday cake sorry it's not real um that was created by our art teacher at this time kindergarten teacher Cassie Shay will share what some of the festivities [Applause]

022were our birthday committee worked hard to create a week of multidisciplinary activities that could be implemented across all our grade levels pre to third on the Tuesday of our week students were given blank birthday crowns to decorate and wear throughout the school day on Wednesday students were asked to create a birthday cake for the school and using stem procedures students worked collaboratively to plan their design they used materials such as straws plates cups and paper towel rolls to make their cake and using differentiated templates students reflected upon their work and their team interactions throughout the week students painted rocks to go along with our oak tree rocks theme the Rocks were generously donated by teacher Carmela Adas family's Nursery the students painted the rocks with vibrant colors and designs and the rocks are going to

023be on display in the fer of our school for years to come on Thursday we had our dress like a rock star day and staff and students came in dressed like the rock stars that they are in leather jackets jewelry sunglasses and a lot more they were adorable Friday was our culminating event with a wonderful rock music technology assembly presented by Brent Daniels Brent is a sound designer and and producer who composed movie trail for Black Panther and A Wrinkle in Time as as well as many more uh movies he demonstrated How Sound can be recorded and combined to make music he asked for student volunteers to record their voices and he created songs right on the spot the students laughed danced and smiled the entire time students wore their oak tree rocks birthday shirts

024and dressed in their birthday best for the assembly there are several birthday displays in place throughout the school one is a pictorial timeline of the construction of Oak Tre school from down breaking to the ribbon cutting ceremony which Mr Gorski said he remembered today another is a photo display of teachers when they were 10 years old and the students are enjoying guessing who's who the celebration will continue with events throughout this school year so stay tuned for our time capsule ceremony which will take place in the spring Through The Years oak tree continues to grow and change but one thing That Remains the Same is that we always strive to provide our students with Rich learning opportunities and unique experiences just like our celebration week for our 10th birthday we are so grateful to the

025monor township Education Association for Their donation and for the fast Grant we're thankful for Miss Karin Masters in the oak treg PTA for making these events possible the activities celebrated a wonderful School dedicated administrators innovating teachers and a beautiful community of students and parents thank you so much [Music] not yet Mrs denore do you want the video to run yes okay sorry sorry [Music] he [Music] happy birth [Music] [Applause] [Music] yes we do have 700 plus rocks in the building right now waiting to be dry and placed at this time we're going to ask the children to come up to sing Happy Birthday to Oak Tree you're G to face that ready one two bir to you happy birthday to you happy birthday dear o Tre birthday to you all right great job everybody thank

026you for listening can can your students turn around so that we could see them we just want to wave and say thank you for coming to our Board of Education meeting and singing to us today thank you thank you Mrs denmore I had the best time at your presentation on Friday and and the little girl I wish you had sound on here the little girl who loved eat the cookies oh that was hysterical she was phenomenal it was a great day we really had a awesome and I do have my oat tree rocks t-shirt good and I look forward to wearing it on special occasions thank you very much thank you we're going to just take the cake okay we have to get it okay well you do that and we'll go on to our

027next presentation HIV good evening everyone for the sake of not blocking the screen I'll stand over here each year uh the superintendent and central office administration is responsible for reporting out uh results and statistics under the Hib harass intimidation and bullying law this is done twice a year at a board meeting so what I'm reporting out on uh tonight is the second half of last year so they give you a timeline of the reporting periods and the call that the superintendent will report to Board of Ed all acts of harassment intimidation or bullying which occurred during their previous reporting period and we're currently reporting out on period two for school year 201718 and of course the superintendent also reports out to the board in close session on those uh HIV incidents for the sake of

028time I won't read every definition but if you just take a moment uh the um HIV definition that we um fall under making sure that everyone's safe at secure here just take a moment to glance at those I think everyone could see them at either screen and most importantly when uh looking at all these definitions we just want to again have a safe environment uh for all of our students and that they could go to class and feel safe feel safe in their activities feel safe at Athletics feel safe in cafeterias hallways and buses we have very highly trained HIV specialists at each school they go through yearly professional development and they also do a wonderful job of providing professional development to our teachers and staff to recognize uh when Hib events might be happening

029in the classroom in the hallways or in the gymnasium cafeteria these people on the screen do just wonderful job making sure again that our kids feel comfortable and they run so many programs and do so many interventions even before the Hib actually takes place to prevent things so my hats off to these staff members so in Period two last year we had 23 reports of potential Hib 12 were founded nine were unfounded and two were inconclusive there was some evidence that H might have occurred but not enough to substantiate it per School these were the confirmed Hib incidents as reported by the superintendent to the board in close session for period to of last year with a grand total of 23 founded hip cases the nature of hi based on protected categories and distinguishing C

030characteristics so you see at each school um how some of these hibs um were classified as part of the Hib report in terms of ethnicity um victims of Hib are characterized in this chart here black white non-specific Asian Hispanic Latina and again this is for period two of school year 1718 this is a chart I hope everyone could see it um The Bullying Specialists do a self assessment at the end of the year and uh the maximum score you can get is a 78 uh the district score was a 74 and I know the Specialists are very hard on themselves and making and ensuring that the staff is trained uh that they follow all of the things they're supposed to follow as Hib Specialists and uh they do really do a true and genuine assessment

031of how they carry out the uh Hib law in our schools so here's our district grade report and the grade report is actually because the report is not out yet for 1718 this was the final report for 1617 discipline and Remediation obviously uh the anti The Bullying Specialists and the administration of each schools uh do interventions and perhaps hand out discipline based on the appropriate age and grade level of that student there's a different levels of remediation that happens uh within a counseling and a social group group within the classroom with guided lessons from teachers betting character education in what we do we have so many school assemblies at each level promoting um equity and fairness to each other and at times when situations go too far sometimes law enforcement uh is involved but also

032law enforcement serves as uh uh do they do programs in schools uh to promote uh Safety and Security of students too and these are finally some of the Hib programs that we've had uh over the past few years um I know I've been very impressed over the past few years with a lot of the character education that goes on I participated in the high school challenge day staff does uh so many programs on conflict resolution and uh we have all different training for staff and um support staff so they're aware of how to help kids who are experiencing difficulty in schools and that is it for period two Madam president will this be um going on the district website we will post it to the website okay thank you is there any questions for Mr

033Goodall from the board members okay seeing none we will go to our student board members report which is looks like it's just you today yeah just me today okay so I'm just going to start with the elementary schools first uh mil lake is actually holding a Fire Prevention Day on October 18th and 19th and representatives from the local fire department will meet every class and uh they'll talk about various fire safety programs and they can even participate in the fire safety poster contest and the winners are awarded gift certificates and and entered in the county contest the PTA is also organizing a trunk Retreat for the students of Oak Tree in Barkley Brook on October 19th casers get to go around the parking lot collect candy from trunks in a safe School environment which is

034pretty cool um as for the high school the college fair was on October 4th students got the chance to learn about uh schools they potentially want to go to and talk to Representatives some face t- face action Justin senent a representative October 10th to talk about the class of 21 about class rings other jewelry and those orders are being taken right about now mths Deca is holding their 15th annual truck uh car and motorcycle show on Sunday at the high school to benefit Alex's Lemonade Stand the show is free for all Spectators and anyone is welcome to visit next week the PSAT will be administered to sophomores and juniors during the school day and uh there's a chance to win the National Merit Scholarship FBA will be H hosting the haunted high school that evening

035too several clubs will be setting up like Halloween theme stations activities for kids to enjoy while they kind of collect candy similar to the trunk Retreat and all the proceeds will go to the mam mayor Breast Cancer Foundation which is a partner of fpla and uh finally from October 25th to 27th there's the 2018 showcase by the foot lights Club it's just an evening of songs plays and musical scenes for anyone to come to yeah that's it thank you very much okay this time we'll go to committee reports are there any committees that need to report this evening Mr Mayo um the curriculum the curriculum committee met tonight we reviewed um one curriculum document AP Computer Science this um class discovers or investigates the fundamentals of commuting Computing including problem solving working with data understanding

036the internet cyber security and programming it is a it broadens um the students understandings of computer science for use in a diversity of majors and careers there are two projects during the course and one endof year exam this is the second AP Computer Science course in our program of studies we have over 80 students in three sections and it covers a wide variety of topics from computers to algorithm also how computers function in terms of binary numbers efficiency it also branches into real world issues such as hacking fishing cyber security and additionally students learn how to create audio image and video artifacts for their work we had three other agendum items we had a club overview which looked at um our clubs we have approximately 62 clubs um in order to to start a new

037club it must be initiated by the students they need to find an advisor um they need a student interest sheet and then it gets reviewed by um Administration to make sure there's no overlap with other clubs and their sufficient interest um if you're interested in looking at the clubs and the club offering that we have if you go to the main page um of Monroe Township High School up on the top bar it says clubs and you can pull that down and it gives you a calendar and um the requirements for starting a club um we also reviewed the clubs um we looked at you know every year the clubs get reviewed how many students are involved in clubs how many meetings they have how many kids show up at every meetings there was also

038a survey given um at least 58% of our high school kids are in at least one Club 81% of the students involved in clubs were involved in charitable organizations we are looking to field a second robotics competition team because we had such um a strong interest in the first robotics competition team students feel strong social connections from the clubs and they also have stronger teacher action interactions from the clubs the next thing we looked at and reviewed was um senior option senior option is the ability for students in senior year to go out and work within the community they can do external internships school-based internships work studies community service they could obtain college credit and they can be involved in mentorship and tutoring programs um we also looked at we have the ability to um

039a a new opportunity came up for us for professional certifications within the stem and Engineering um Project Lead the Way um curriculum uh the department for the applied arts and careers technology is proud to announce that in the beginning of the spring of 2019 we will be offering students professional certification exams for Autodesk Inventor and Autodesk rivet these certifications will follow students through college and their journey into the professional Arena they are driven by Project Lead the Way curriculum for introduction into engineering design and civil engineering and architect these exams are optional and all students enrolled in the high school stem engineering Academy or engineering course sequence are eligible to take these and get their certification are there any questions for Mr Mayo Mr Ryback I don't have a question I really just have to

040make a comment I'd like to compliment you Dr alvic and all the members of the curriculum committee because that's what I want to see brought out at these meetings I think that we need more of it uh I think the public needs to see it and I'd ask if possible we could have maybe demonstrations so the entire board and the public can see some of the exemplary programs that uh you're um initiating in in these schools thank you thank you Mr rack anyone else a question for Mr Mayo are there any other committee reports okay see I was waiting to see if anybody else but Mr of course I was like to go last I thought for sure there would be others but finance committee so we were uh notified that the state of New

041Jersey nutrition program we'll be coming to the school uh and we will be subject to a school nutrition program audit for the 2017 2018 school year ironically while nutrition is in the title of this audit it does not involve nutrition whatsoever so they don't they don't audit what we serve they just simply audit and I I take simply back they do audit um our procurement documentation our assessment of compliance to ensure competitive procurement of goods and services uh awarded contracts and contractor performance so that's a state uh audit of our nutrition program excuse me the New Jersey qac review is also going to start taking place this is a full documentation audit um of our district it covers five key areas of operation including instruction and program fiscal management governance operations and personnel these areas

042include a lot of subcategories underneath them which will all require written documentation to prove that the district is in compliance all the paperwork will then be scanned and uploaded into the New Jersey home room and an auditor from the state will come in and visit the district to inspect Dr alvik thank you very much has taken leadership in assigning specific areas to Key Personnel for the uh compilation of these said materials so that's the New Jersey qac audit then there's the caffer audit comprehensive annual financial report audit that we're in the middle of and so our notice from our auditing company Mr stankowitz has indicated that we're through the majority of our audit Services they've been completed so we're closer and closer to finishing our audit um which we'll report back when it's done of

043course and last but not least least uh speaking of the auditing we Mr Gorski and his office did put together an RFP a request for proposal for auditing Services going forward um as it was resolved by the board um this has gone through legal review insurance review and contributions from staff Incorporated all into the RFP for reference purposes an RFP is similar to a bid except that in addition to price in this case professional fees there are many qualitative areas considered the we also a draft of the RFP and an advertisement will be made on October 27th out to in local newspapers and um various ways and then companies have until November 27th to submit back to us um if they want to participate in and be considered in the RFP that ends my report

044questions for Mr redy have a bg& oh you have a report okay is there any questions for Mr redy no questions he did such a great job Mr Ryback okay Mr uh with Mr jerel's permission I'll review the minutes of bg& T Monro down baseball association request for oak tree field representatives of the mtba provided a handout with detail information on a baseball batting cage and scoreboard that their organization would like to donate and have installed at Oak Tree school at no cost to the district the equipment would be used by mtba but also would be available for use by the school and District teams the committee endorsed accepting the donations and asked that the uh that they work closely with the administration on undertaking the installations and be reminded of use of building scheduling

045requirements and expectations for users to respect the School boundaries parking and access next item stadium turfield and anual engineering review of bleachers Administration provided a copy of the professional engineering structural review of The District bleaches and indicated that they are budgeting as a capital expenditure to undertake the replacement of wood bleachers bleacher boards with aluminum bleacher boards as noted in their report Administration also sh shared photos of the STA of the stadium turfield the field was installed in 2008 and is currently Beyond its 8-year warranty the athletic director has stressed the need to have this field replaced as shown in handout photos the field surface is greatly deteriorating and could soon be unsafe or problematic for further use Administration noted that this could be added for a consideration in the 2019 2020 capital expenditure next

046item is District security upgrades Administration presented a check and the amount of $ 39,7 18397 I think we have a uh um a copy of the check there Mr Gorski for a security upgrade grant that was awarded to the district the committee request that these funds be utilized to explore design and Engineering options for adding controlled access vestibules at these at those schools uh not having these items and look to look into potential upgrades for the lobby guard visitor access program and security cameras Church Road land Wetlands Loi since this item was last reported at the June bg& meeting the district received from New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection the freshwater wetlands letter of interpretation that's the LOI and the wood turtle habitat assessment and site special survey for the site as has been anticipated

047the buildable area of the 65 Acre Site has been reduced drastically due to Wetland delineation therefore the committee recommends that no further action be taken for vetting the site and no additional monies be spent in this regard Brookside HVAC project update Administration noted that the uh that all the rooftop equipment has been delivered and set with a crane on Monday October 8th and that the contractor will be working in the coming weeks to finish up uh final connections and startup of the new HVAC system and Equipment the last item forsgate drive and oakill drive bus stop committee review Administration and committee discussed existing conditions and requested modifications to the current route the topic was open for public discussion with handouts provided by residents and lengthy discussion ensued the committee requested that Administration further explore this

048matter and visit the site to witness bus turnaround in the cue saac before further action is this item thank you is there any questions for Mr Ryback Mr Mino uh yes going back to the 65 acres when you say there's no further action are is the township still going to deed that property over to the district to the Board of Education I think that we said that we're not going to be interested if I'm right uh in in getting that land because um does that require a vote because we've accepted it through resolution do we does it require a vote to reject it then I don't believe that we accepted it for for through resolution because they have not gotten the land yet from the Builder so they have therefore not turned it over to

049us so it's nearly 2 and 1/2 years that we've been saying how wonderful it was it was the best option um it was going to be ours and all this stuff and now it's nothing and we spent over $60,000 I believe over the objections of a and I and I know I voted to spend that money but I know I had some reservations uh back two and a half years ago uh because of that what I don't understand is if the LOI which is the um letter of uh interpretation from of the wetlands why we did not know that from the builders Loi I believe that the builders and and why that research wasn't done prior to us spending all that money because we were assured that it was going to be a wonderful thing

050so my point is we were it a a big um public I guess uh discussion disc well no it was more than a public discussion a lot of people took credit of how wonderful that this land was going to be for us and we and we were persuaded to spend a lot of money going in and now we have nothing so you know I know we've over the years have the the public has come to here and say well you know what are our plans what are we doing and we assured them all these times that all these things were so wonderful and we still have no land yet so I just I just don't know how it got that far how we spent that much money if I can some I just my own

051I know we're all involved in that we're all interested in it and that's one of the reasons why we wanted independent um companies looking at the land and because we just wanted to make sure that we were doing it right and getting all the right information was the information that we received from the township um incorrect because I know we were we had people from the administration going in and looking at the file the the Planning and Zoning file so I'm my point I mean it's it's over now I um I feel bad now that I that I voted for the spending of that money and and we come up empty-handed once again like you said we didn't know and we were trying to do we were trying to do the best thing at the

052time numerous discussions and again we were persuaded that it was it was everything we should I'd say that all of us were well intentioned there well even though we may you know good or bad we were all well intentioned and and I guess we have to take it with that live Al well I hope next time we're more judicious about that's a good idea and we still have to do our due diligence with looking at any piece of property that we would either buy or get through a referendum or get through a donation but as we went along with this one we found that the footprint for a school kept shrinking we could still build a school but with all the the money it would go for the infrastructure for um roads and things like

053that that it wasn't worth right to keep this land but that's usually when we go into land we go in and blind and we just look for it there were reports in the Township in the municipal building that should and I know we spent $30,000 originally I think to have those reports reviewed and then we spent another $30,000 after the encouragement by the administration um I just think we probably shouldn't have done that and I take responsibility for that too thank you Mrs Lang I I I just and this could just be a memory in my head but I thought that the original reports from the township everything it looked good but then what because of superstorm Sandy and hurricane I was going to say Katrina but that's not right but the the the hurricane

054the one that came the following year that it changed the topography and that it made it bigger wet so I think that there was that you know this was prior to myself being on the board but Mr gski I I remember that so please you know Madam Mr G uh to Mrs armino and Mrs Lang and Mr Ryback's comments um we were in need of schools plural at that time we still are let me finish and um there were no good land options this was a offer from the township to donate the 65 acres and the transaction was to be Toll Brothers to the township to the board of education at no cost now there was an original wet lens map that the board looked at and the architect also looked at and at the

055preliminary inspection it appeared feasible that there could be two schools constructed on that property however by the very very nature of wetlands they they move they transition they relocate themselves they grow at at times and I'm by no means an expert on this but when we had the further Wetlands study done as Mrs kapano said it kept shrinking and shrinking the footprint for the available school plus you have to reserve space for the endangered turtles which further Shrunk the property and there were some other uh liabilities with the property which we discussed from the beginning but they were not deal breakers including the utility um hookups and the roads which may have needed widening um and some other issues at this juncture with the information we have at current it was administration's recom recommendation to

056abandon that project and since then we do have a better option well I'm wondering if if may I Madam president that if um if it's just a matter of wet land why can't we still accept it from the township as fields for the future I mean we may be able to use it just for sports or something like that or um I mean if it's going to be free land as you point out let's let's take it and just use it as passive Recreation M we could if it if the if the um if the gift is still on the table from the township Madam it it is my understanding that um there could be a liability to the district at some point because of the the the nature of the wetlands also and and

057the committee the building grounds Transportation committee reviewed this uh asked questions and determine that it was not worth uh future consideration Mr Chella yes thank you I think that going forward when we look at these kind of parcels and uh and gifts that what we should do is also do a a legal um get a legal ruling and and do our due diligence around the the the legal aspects of acquiring this land and I'll tell you why because from what I understand and I've been saying this now since before I was on the board when this land deal came up is that when you have cluster zoning which is what happened over there in colron you had cluster zoning that the the the benefit of the cluster zoning is that the to the to the

058developers that they they get to build houses on smaller pieces of property and then the the residual uh effect of that is that they give the they give open space land they donate open space land to the town so in Monroe in the past like on the the land at Oak Tree we we use that land the open space to build a school it went unchallenged and so we were able to do that no one challenged it but if someone had challenged this and there was a challenge in in the in the works because we had residents from there and from what I understand uh Toll Brothers was also talking about joining any any theoretical lawsuit any potential lawsuit in favor of the residents because they told them in perpetuity that that land would be

059open space and there wouldn't be anything there so my understanding is that that uh open space uh that our laws Monroe laws are preempted by state law and in state law that open space has to be used as open space when you when you when you when the cluster zoning provision is is uh is activated so when you when we do that uh we're we would be we would be putting ourselves on the wrong side of the law we probably would have lost that lawsuit it's my understanding that that's really why we walked away from this deal so I think that I think that that's one of the things that you know going forward in the future we need to look at the legal aspects of this stuff so that we don't have to spend

060money look at things and then and then come back and say you know we had turtles mating over there so we're walking away uh it's it was probably more due to the lawsuit in my opinion but that's just my opinion thank you okay so at this time we will go to public forum because I don't think there's any committee reports left uh anyone from the public wishing to speak to the agenda please come to the microphone state your name and address for the record and we will adhere to our 4minute timeline time liit is this agenda items only mhm agenda items only yeah prash 33 Dana dry could you please raise the microphone yeah yes pleas prash pup 33 did not drive I understand the minutes of the meeting are in the agenda the August

061minutes if I remember the August uh meeting there are three-hour discussion or 2hour discussion because the wrong document was circulated uh to the committee and the investigation was supposed to be done by Mr good all so that has been captured in that this is this is um Mr armino brought up close session minutes not the regular minutes of of a regular meeting anyway whatever whever it is as long as it is captured I'm fine okay so thank you I don't see that anyone else from the public wishing to speak to the agenda good evening I'm Ira Nelson 87 Crescent Way um my question is this um I believe there are approximately 100 school districts which are suing the state department of education pertaining to the Floyd uh state aid formula is there a reason that

062this District doesn't seem to be joining in I know I've asked this question before and and it just seems remarkable with all the overcrowding going on in the schools and the fact that uh every student is supposed to receive a thorough and efficient education that I don't know how that could actually be happening with the overcrowding being what it is why are we involved in this lawsuit with the with our fellow districts some districts have certain criteria that they need in order or that they have in order to file a lawsuit if we don't fit that criteria then we cannot be part of that lawsuit there are now other um districts who were suing because their funding has been cut and they're not happy with that so they're looking to sue the state because they

063some of them we were told the other day um one one uh Town lost, 1600 students still getting the same amount of of um support from the state and they should be it should be equivalent to the child so where they're getting the same amount of funding for having 1,600 students less we're not we're getting the same amount of funding for 1600 students more uh at this point we have not fit any criteria to sue the state because they feel we're getting or giving our students a thorough and efficient education do you feel that way can't we make our own criteria isn't overcrowding itself a problem an issue can can a student actually receive the kind of education they should when I just heard today one of one of the students has to sit on

064a floor I don't understand it I just cannot understand it I am not an attorney but Common Sense tells me that there's something wrong and you refuse to join in with hundred I I believe it's approximately 100 school districts each one probably has their own criteria well we certainly have uh superb criteria with the overcrowding situation which is only going to get worse we all acknowledge that what is the plan well one of our district goals this year is to explore options for us to address um fairness and Equitable school funding and Aid um I'm not sure if at this time after the S2 legislation if it's appropriate for us to sue since we got money in trying to um find criteria of schools I don't know if we'll find anyone uh who will be

065suing the state because they received the disal aid but it's certainly something that we can discuss you received correct me if I'm wrong is a mere fraction of what you basically need right you're not close $2 million or so that you're received and our state legislators taking Victory laps at the high school isn't going to cut it this is a victory I I can speak to that a little bit more in my superintendent's report what happened there but um we certainly are taking the approach that um lobbying and speaking to our legislative officials elected legislative officials is a strong approach in continuing to secure more aid for us you're being irresponsible that's all I can say you're being very irresponsible and very little will happen as we've dealt with over the last several years dealing

066with this if this is your if this is your approach you're on the wrong track thank [Applause] you good evening Rupa seagull 12 Mitchell Drive I just want to thank Mr Kella for a very thorough and informative presentation on the high school clubs it was really nice to learn about all the opportunities that we have for the high school students after school in the clubs um another question I had was in ref refer in reference to the referendum has a communication plan been developed and if so when will presentations begin for the community we're in the process of of coming together and and coming up with a plan on how to sell a refer referendum um we we found out last year that it was better to wait until after the holidays than before the

067holidays so the steering committee will be meeting and discussing that will be part of the discussion as how are we going to handle this what are what is going to be our plan what um media we're going to use to get out the word and as soon as we um come up every time every step that we take we will be notifying the public okay great thank you you're welcome good evening Chrissy scurby 21 pness Drive um I had a question um with what Mr ibeck was saying I guess that was maybe the buildings and grounds committee report is that what you were giving that is correct um I I couldn't hear in the back what are we doing with um what is the agreement with mtba was that something that was passed this evening

068this one oh okay Mr R yeah the baseball okay Mr R I couldn't hear that well all the representatives of the mtba provided handout detail information on baseball batting cage and scoreboard their organization and would like to donate and have installed at Oak Tree school at no cost to the district the district would be used by uh mtba but also would be available for use by the school and District teams the committee endorsed accepting the donations and asked that they work closely with Administration on undertaking the installations and be reminded of use of building scheduling requirements and expectations for users to respect the School boundaries parking and access okay um was that approve is that approved or is that something that's going to be voted on tonight no we don't need to vote on that

069we we the the committee agreed to accept all they're going to do everything for nothing so um we the committee agreed to let them start the work so that they uh the the baseball fields will be in the good condition that they need to be playing and have extra um parking and extra um Bach I I know about five six years ago that was an initiative under something called Field of Dreams that didn't the board didn't allow um I'm just is that going to be the um teams the through Monroe Township wreck would be able to use those fields now and school school will have the first use of our fields and the rec department will have the Second Use of our fields and would they be class one users or class two users direct

070Department I believe they're class one users yes Ma so no would you be allowing um other sports like the soccer club to use the soccer fields at the high school I I um because I know I know they have problem with lighting sometimes and they don't have lights or they they had to raise money to bring in lights um so I'm just wondering would all of the Rec Sports now be allowed to use our field such as soccer would they be allowed to use the soccer fields at the high school we have a really good relationship with the rec department and if they need our facilities they go through building use just like anybody else would if they're available for them to use they they are welcome to use it okay and that goes to

071any of the fields whether it's soccer baseball football whatever um in indoor they football could use the uh High School football field if they put they don't they usually have their own could they is that allowed if they wanted to is that we had a um if theyve had a building use and it was available but usually it conflicts but they're also allowed to use our gymnasiums and um indoor facilities okay and is there a blueprint for you said they're going to expand the parking lot at Oak Tree they're talking about expanding the parking lot because uh a lot of the area where you park now there's a long walk to get to the bleachers on the other side of oak tree so it I I don't know if they can do it this year

072but they're within the next couple of years to expand the parking lot so that you could park right where you're going to be sitting just for a point of clarity at the end of the presentation was a request to work with the Board of Education to assist in allowing access better access uh to the fields perhaps uh working on getting Pathways from the parking lots for some of our more senior grandparents who want to watch games we've all been at fields and sometimes you have to walk over mountains to get to the field from the parking lot so that was the request from the association to work with the Board of Ed somehow to allow for better access of their members okay great thank you good evening Ram ragat 60 and strive mandro um lot

073of questions I know I just have four minutes uh so regarding um uh the report on the uh 65 acres of band uh right so many of the in the public were here as part of those meetings and discussions we voice concerns on that uh you know it's a shame right we lost I don't know 8 months a year of time in building the schools we lost $60,000 in those studies and I'm appalled that both the president as well as the the Boe is willing to let it slide except for one uh de or one concern raised that even without a probe shouldn't you be asking for a probe maybe passing a motion and someone voting and saying we need a probe of this right we lost time the mayor's office and the admin promised

074to give you guys something and it was fake Goods right and we have lost time and money and effort who's going to compensate for that right just between a Euro now it's 20 million more for construction so I I I'm just a Paul that you're taking it so lightly you know if it was Corporate America people would have lost their jobs on this right so we need to be running this as if we run this business it cannot be where no one is impacted so Madame President i' would like to hear your feedback on my comment if it was this piece of land or another piece of land we would have had to do our due diligence and making sure that that piece of land was appropriate to build a school on so um you

075know sometimes you could build a school on a small piece of property this property was not the viable to build the longer we waited the longer we found out that with the wetlands that it was impossible to do that we have a piece of property going across the street from the township that we need to use for our bus depot we have to do the same thing we have to do our due diligence and work with um different organizations to see that that's appropriate to build a a a bus depot on if we get another piece of land we're still going to have to do our due diligence in making sure that there's no let's say you have an apple orchard or it used to be an apple orchard that there's nothing in the contaminated

076soil that would prevent us from using a a um the piece of land for a school this all takes a little bit of time no I understand I I don't want to interrupt you I just want conscious of my time it's I understand this is due diligence everyone has to do it but there's a huge price that has now been paid someone was slept on the switch here right we have lost time money and effort on this and I just I'm just bothered that this has just been gone next agenda item right and we don't even want to do anything with that 65 cuz I would go and park the buses there on that 65 acre lot and think about it the planning board or the zoning board who rezoned it as clustering why did

077they reone it I mean the Builder could have built anything homes are fine but schools it's a problem right suddenly all these birds come in and the land is drying up and look at all the theatrics right I mean just think about it common sense What's Happening Here uh I'm very appall the second thing is uh the um uh the on the book clubs right in the school I'm sorry I'm jumping topic because of the time um it was great to hear the report from dawn on the book clubs and uh on the sorry on the clubs uh after school clubs but the feedback or some of the firsthand feedback I've gotten at least from the Middle School is I don't know she mentioned about some report or survey on those clubs it'll be good

078for us to see that information unless it has been shared and I missed that it'll be good to get that but from what I have received is sometimes sits kids are just sitting there watching videos and movies uh you know where there's nothing going on it's more like a glorified daycare uh that's happening after school so uh so I just would make sure before you add more uh clubs or after school activities make sure one there are competent teachers that are brought in and and second let's look at the data and get the feedback from the students and the parents and that's exactly what we do every year we we go from the beginning of the year to the end of the year see what clubs are working see what clubs are not working see

079where there's participation see where there's none I know last year we got rid of a few clubs that had no participation or didn't meet um so we we do that every year we do an analysis of our clubs and and after school activities okay thank you let's make sure it's it is quantitative qualita of those surveys and the feedback and please share that with the public thank you and and you could find a list of the clubs on the website under the high school if you go to the high school part of the website they have a an area for clubs so you can know what clubs are there when they meet and and information like that okay thank you Roger Mani 22 haragan Avenue um I keep hearing that you guys are working on

080a new referendum a new referendum yet the golf course that the township took eminent o main is going in front of a three judge panel with no set court date if the township doesn't prove its burden that this was the only land out of the 18 other pieces of property that they looked at in their study this whole thing could revert back to the owner and we've been told for a year and a half now by our business administrator at the Town Council how amicable the owner is if the owner was that amicable this would be done already you know who's lying here Madam yes how how do you work on something when we we don't even have it it was like being asked to vote on a referendum when we didn't have all the

081all the figures and all the facts how are you working on this Mr meanie would you like an explanation yes the I it's my understanding from the township that there is an agreement between the former owner and the township to transfer the land via eminent domain and the only only thing that remains is the determination of price to to protect the taxpayer's interest in buying it at the best price that's what the court is determining now that's all well I was told a week and a half ago at the business at the township council meeting that the land is going that this whole issue is going in front of a three judge panel that the owner of the driving range is not an agreement with the township and the township now has to meet the

082burden of proving that this was the only available land that they could build on so who's lying that's that's that's what we were told is that the township owns the land and at any time that the board requests that land we could get that land through a resolution from the township and acceptance from the Board of Education the only thing that we know is that the cost of the land is between the former owners and the um the the township and that is in the that's what is in court the cost of the land not the land itself you guys are working with blinders on cuz if this land reverts back to the owner you guys have put a lot of work in for nothing anyone else from the public hi there Deborah Pella 15

083Louise Lane I just want to reiterate um what an earlier um the other gentleman over there had said about the question regarding suing I understand Mr G Goodall you had said about taking our time um and and being patient let's say with the I'll call it the the government my child my oldest is in eth grade and as far as I know if I could recall correctly the first time we went down to Trenton I believe he was in kindergarten by the time this gets through by the time we're done he will be long gone we will be long gone out of this town I'll my opinion is we should sue based on the fact that each child in New Jersey is worth the same value whether you live in Monroe Township on Louise Lane

084Monroe Township on matchaponix in East Brunswick in Oldbridge in botwood it doesn't matter if you are in Newark or Camden the fact is I believe that is enough of a reason in the lawyers that I've spoken to that children should be worth the same dollar amount investment from our state in my eyes they all should be worth the same as well so if that's not enough of a reason and the length of time that we've had our patience with this it's really just trying for all of us here to continually hear that we need to wait I was at that meeting the first time I went senator Ruiz said to our face in front of Linda Greenstein I'll say it again she said why would I give your District money towns in my district want

085money what are you going to do for me it is a political game of scratching their backs and what Senators is going to vote for this and what did you do in your for for my for my district versus yours I don't know how far we're going to get we all know political red tape this is it and we need to think about this really much stronger than we have years we've been doing this the first time I hopped on a bus to Trenton from this town was probably six or seven years ago and that's when this and that probably started before I was even in the school system here so I just want to reiterate again we can wait until who knows how many other schools are built in this town before we're going

086to get any more money the waiting game is not working in our favor if we had anything and we said whether it was class if we if we even put uh any sort of racial anything in any of the sentences they would look at our suit first this is a a a crazy amount of time that we've waited for money and while everyone is happy that we got more it is not enough and that's it thank [Applause] you ukla to see cot uh I would like to talk about a couple of things uh the first uh thing is regarding referendum and I have uh two questions one is how much delay we have had overall since we first realized that we need these schools uh to the point where we don't have anything is it

0873 years four years 5 years I when when Dr kak came to The District in 200 when did he come 14 14 he was tasked that's the first thing that the board T them with getting a referendum on the ballot so that we can have schools um so that took almost three years for him to do that with working through different um committees with working with the public with working with the staff so that that that was last March was following District do you want to speak to no and that was prior to Dr kak's arrival with Mr ventrello uh serving as interm there was um a dist a redistricting among the elementary schools to deal with overcrowding in some of the schools that was the first step so I went back even further well

088it goes back to Dr Hamilton but then Dr Hamilton left our district and um yeah so is that five years or is it more than five years I'm just curious probably one five district thing was so for five years we have had we have known that we need new schools and we don't have anything to show so far and we don't even know if the next referendum is we are going to win or not we don't know if the land uh if we have done due diligence on the land for all you know you know after all the legal stuff is done the due diligence will start that'll go for a year and then we realize oh you know what there is uh it's wasteline or whatever so that could pretty much take it to

089seven or 8 years uh just to kind of get started if at all we get started right which I believe is a is a big failure on the part of the town and the Board of Education uh the second question I would like to ask is how much money have we spent on the referendum in these last 5 to six years in assessing land and creating these plans uh you know selling trying to sell it to people and so on I I I I don't have that cost off hand I don't know Mr Gorski if you can say that offand how much we've spent I would hate to Hazard a guess at the figure but I will say that those are required costs for any exploration of a school project and it's consistent with other

090projects that we've been successful with and other school districts that have been successful with referenda you have to do exploration work there's a lot of work required by the Department of Education that costs Mone money where you would uh expect to have somebody fired is if you didn't do this work up front and you you recommended or you began a building process on that land without doing the board's due diligence and we would never do that uh well I I would like to get estimate of the cost if not today perhaps in the next one because I think the public needs to know how much money we have blown up on this even though that is consistent with you know whatever standards that you are comparing it with um I do have a third thing

091and this is not about this is about funding uh if uh but I think I'm going to run out of time if I talk about it but it's a totally different topic would you allow me to I'm not going to ask you difficult questions trust me well you have two seconds left so you might have to wait till the next public forum well you don't want to know about uh something that that I I sent you a email long time back breaking giving a detailed breakdown of funding we we have we to the public forum time if I give you more time I would have to give everybody more time so we do have another public forum which shouldn't be that far away in the agenda so well you know just for the record I

092I just want to mention for the record before I leave I'm sorry but your your time is up at this point there's still people behind you who wish to speak I'll take two seconds of your time sir we have sir we have to move on to the I sent you a ma about I'm sorry but sir your time is up thank great awesome that's that's that's the reason why uh you just affirm what how I feel about this management okay so um let me continue um Krishna deal 11 Jake place um the question about Fair funding we have is um if you simply change the equation Monro is in a special situation right where we have 50% of our population being um senior citizens um if you um no other um Township in the state

093has this um situation ahead of them so how are we dealing with the lawmakers I know you there's a talk about lobing with the law lawmakers and everything so that you know they cover for this this is this takes a special case of the formula to get get us additional funding are you do you have any plans on solving this uh special situation for Monro well we're not the only um District in New Jersey that has 50% % seniors there's a lot of other districts my parents live in a district that has 50% or more senior citizens so it's not unusual for that to happen there's a lot of shore districts that have that our when we spoke to Senator Sweeney the other day he knows about Monroe he knows about the seniors I did

094bring it up to him about the inability for seniors to pay and keep paying so it it's not um it's not just a Monroe issue it's it's a fair funding issue and the only way that that is going to change is when the funding formula changes so we can we can keep fighting for our fair share of funding and they will fund us our fair share but it's not enough what they what we need to do is fight for a fair funding formula to be changed so that everybody in New Jersey gets funded fairly if that makes any sense right um let me give you a simple equation right if you change the um wealth of the seniors with the income the fixed income that the seniors have we would get $19 million more we

095we' back we reverse engineered the data that we have on the fair funding well apparently the the the uh state does not have the same numbers that we think that they should have and they think we're a wealthy community they think the seniors are wealthy and they can afford to um pay for the education of our students we know they can't we know that we give um treat $9 million we get back now we're getting back almost $5 million um so we have to change the formula because we are okay with the formula right now but so you have said you are okay with the formula was that something no I don't mean that I'm okay or anybody's okay I mean that we're getting or we will be getting because they they have promised us

096that they will fully fund our formula but at the point we're only going to get N9 or10 million so the the formula needs to be changed so when you said 9 or 10 Millions just a quick question um is it next year or the year after Madam okay Madam may I ask the may I answer the gentleman's question sure I I've spoken previously about uh the state aid issue uh having been with the district for a number of years now and and and and fighting hand inand with a lot of residents and members of the board of education current and previous the states uh criteria according to two firms that have reviewed our situation we we asked expert attorneys from W Goldman and Spitzer about the viability of a lawsuit and we asked a representative

097from New Jersey Association of school business officials Mr John Don who the executive director and we asked Mary Smith and others that I'm probably leaving off the the criteria for suing the state is that if you can demonstrate the current level of funding is not meeting thorough and efficient education tne Monroe certainly is as a matter of fact we're $13 million above adequacy so we are more than meeting the students needs here as far as uh dollars in the classroom the second is that the funding formula is being applied fairly and in everybody's review the funding formula as it is written is being applied fairly and consistently to Monroe I agree completely with the board president that is is the funding formula school funding Reform Act of 2008 which is the Fault here even at

098full funding our full limit of funding will just pass $9 million that's a disgrace we need more money we need a new formula and some of the legislators who we met with were amenable to addressing it that way through a constitutional convention and a new formula that is the only way we in my opinion we will receive satis action quick question so your your time is now up to I know so we we're going to say the same thing to you that we just said to the gentleman before you you can come up again at the second public forum there's one thing I want just wanted a clarification sorry Mr deal you're welcome to call me anytime you want to talk about that Andy plor uh 16 St James Street uh three points I want

099to make first is uh I heard from uh uh Jill Deo about the the course that they want to add as a civil engineer I can tell you that it's an excellent course uh for AutoCAD micro station and rivet I humbly request that you also look into the Bim uh it's a building information system management systems that's also a course that uh typically civil engineers use in building uh actual buildings um Mr Ry you talked about doing the comprehensive financial review plan I believe it's done on an annual basis uh it would be very helpful if you may if you could uh actually do an annualized one to see what the spending patterns have been at least not at every line item but at the bottom line of the each uh line item to see

100operating cost and things like that because obviously there's tremendous amount of concern in terms of the funding for the schools if um there's any opportunity for us to uh make some savings out of it that would be very helpful I looked at at least four or five reports and the numbers seem to vary by pupil's cost uh year to year so if there's some consistency we can bring to that so I guess but my point is I think we got to be efficient and our our own doings before we ask the government and I can tell you that having testified in front of the assembly that there's no way things are going to be changed in terms of funding very quickly uh the minute I we walked up but I I'm not sure who from

101the from the board member spoke but by the time I got up and spoke the Jersey City uh assembly lady who was sitting there was extremely upset that we were really annoying because her constituents need to get the money that they need to get and quite honestly the urban centers are where all the votes are so the politicians are going to gravitate through those it's going to be a long time but I remember being a part of the ad hoc finance committee that we were looking at some ways to sue the state and one of the items that we were looking at at that point was Transportation as means of using the the suing but I don't think that we pursued that any further I'll be more than happy if the board permits the through

102the committee of or any committee that you may have to work on that the last question I have is uh I understand there was a meeting that took place in the high school with the Senate President and uh a few of the members of the Board of Education could you shed some light on what exactly has been discussed and what as public that we should know thank you um Mr Goodall will be bringing that up in his superintendent report and I will be saying something in my board president's report about that meeting on Friday thank you anyone else from the public good evening uh goam Gia from three M Drive um I had a comment on U same topic um sir can you speak up just a little bit sure yes so I have comment

103about Fair funding um so I along with some of my friends we have dissected the formula so the question to the board is uh how much we under understand the formula or is there a component in the formula where Monro is getting a hit according to the formula Monro is getting a fair funding but which component is really contributing to the fact that we are not getting enough that we should be getting which component so you're asking the the current formula and and why Monroe is getting what it's getting if it's a fair formula so the formula is not fair we all know right so why is it so have we approached to the to the Trenton with right and I don't want to get into a debate back and forth with um the funding

104formula because I think we all agree that we're not getting what we deserve here in Monroe and in it the formula when they feel Monroe because it's based on the wealth of communities they feel that Monroe is a wealthy community and we can pay we can afford to pay for our own education one comment I want to make on The Wealth so there is a affiliate factor that uh Board of Education assigns to every school district according to that Monro is equivalent to Oldbridge Oldbridge is getting $25 million in Aid Monro is getting 2 million and it got increased to 4 million and that's still nothing compared to North BR Oldbridge in fact even Hillsboro is getting hillsbor is in fact more affluent than Monro according to that District factor I think we all agree

105with you so so what so so as a board member do you understand the formula I do not understand the formula Mr Gorski might understand the formula a little better than I so isn't it I I can I can sit down I have I have few people who knows even more than me we can sit down and explain to you guys sir um it is a very complex formula I'm not aware of any board member who can really speak uh and give it justification I've studied this now for uh over a decade and and specific to your question an area of address with the formula is with the uh Equalization Aid that is the largest type of Aid and that is distributed based upon a local fair share calculation that calculation is what determines how

106much your district has to uh subsidize your own uh adequacy budget and in Monroe's case for the last 20 years or longer we've received zero dollar from Equalization Aid because the formula itself determines that we are not only affluent in terms of income but affluent in terms of property ratables those two factors come into the local fair share calculation and uh that is what should be addressed if we were to take on a new formula we need our fair share of Equalization Aid that's a supports an adequacy budget that's where most of the spending goes so yeah that that exactly was our finding the the the property values in Monroe um are affecting the formula and and the fight with the Trenton should be on that particular piece of the formula um and we have

107mentioned that to Trenton many times it's been everybody has mentioned until the until the legislators want to create a new form funding formula we will be continuing to get is there a time frame no there is no what are Township next steps ICT goals District goals well one of our district goals will be to continue the fight for funding formula are we planning to sue the state at this time your time is up also okay thank so we will refer you to the next public forum so funny I'm being fair I missed it uh Lum Masters I'm Mela Court um welcome back Patty actually that's the first thing I want to say you're a very strong person to come back after three right thank you all right get that out of the way um for

108what Mr Gorski was saying thanks for clarifying we are made whole via the formula correct the the funding formula school funding Reform Act of 2008 is is being applied fairly and consistently in Monroe as it is written yes so if we what would we sue for then if we're they're basically from what I've Madam yes from what I've gathered from the attorneys who reviewed this from executive director of New Jersey asbo my own assumption is that we would be a weak candidate for a lawsuit because the following reason many districts that are suing are showing bleeding in instructional programs in classrooms for example Freehold burrow had students being educated in hallways okay that's one of the reasons that the state came in and had sympathy that sympathy is is not going to be gained by

109looking at the programs in Monroe which we are very proud of which are $13 million above what the state considers to be uh adequate um it's fine you're killing my time I only have four minutes um I urge the board we do this every once in a while we start talking about suing the state Mr Masters yes um we're getting tunnel vision again with this uh I think the Board needs to at least in parallel start looking at other avenues of Revenue if we get stuck on this and then we get another 100,000 or 200 or a million we're going to be saying the same thing a year from now if we don't have anything else kind of going on we need to start cutting expenses uh more shared services we talk about that all

110the time but we need to really expand on that um economy is a scale we're doing a lot of great things here in Monroe we need to start doing things like that um creative sources of uh Revenue we always used to say stuff about putting ads on the uh that wasn't me U putting ads on the field things like that but we really need to start I mean those are just examples but we really need to start looking at things like that instead of just talking about suing for a couple million dollars which is great um which we might not even get um and again it's just working in parallel which I urge the board to do um that was my Spiel the other thing um for curriculum there's a I missed it there's another

111a how many APS or what were you talking about for the computer science because I have a stem background um no we just talked about the new curriculum document for AP Computer Science principles okay does that have anything to do with machine learning or anything like that do you know off top of your head I I don't believe so but that's only open to to um isn't this for 11th and 12th graders no that's so it is for more seniors right okay because it's from where I am that's that's a big we're looking at that for people coming out of school for out of college um that seems to be the newest uh I don't want to say the uh Paradigm um so I think we should really start looking into stuff like that if

112we can uh including it in the curriculum um anything with neural networking all that kind of stuff that's that's the way of tomorrow that's what everybody's going to you can look on uh a lot of the sites that are out there and they talk about um adding this into curriculum so um that's just my uh my take on what we should be doing there thank you thank you anyone else good evening Russ Church 15 Taylor Avenue I'm actually from the mtba we met at the meeting I just wanted to thank you guys for uh approving it uh just to put it out there it's not for wreck it's not for school we look at it as for the kids in the town okay and these these upgrades are just give them a better experience for

113the middle school and the mtba kids so I just wanted to thank you and we'll do everything the way thank you we're we're looking forward to working for you because we're all here for kids okay I just want thank you thank you seeing no one else we will close public forum and move on with the agenda Mrs Lang excuse me Mrs I I need to go okay okay yes sorry no feel better thank you and and we we so happy that you finally back and thank you pretty soon you'll be back for all the meetings okay uh we will go to the superintendent's report Mr Goodall thank you Madame board president I just wanted to report out on a couple of items uh one very special to me um what I'm passionate about as a

114educator and that's working with students with special needs we are really going to try to increase our efforts to support all of our special education students and their fam Ames by working with parents of special needs children in a parent organization known as cpeg or special education parent advisory group the goal is to make the group more meaningful and influential in the school district and it supporting those students we'll be meeting with a group of parents to strategize how the district can support and most importantly better include these children within our school culture a general meeting of cpeg is tentatively scheduled for November 29th 9th but we will be sharing further details soon on Friday October 12th and we had a presentation tonight myself Dr alvic Mrs kapano our board president attended a student celebration

115at Oak Tree Elementary celebrating the school's 10th birthday the students and staff enjoyed a very interactive engaging and informative performance by a professional sound engineer the presenter really got the kids involved and you saw on the video how much fun they had and all fun was had by all and we celebrated that oak tree rocks and I just wanted to thank Mrs Densmore and her teaching staff and support staff for making it such a great celebration and a little bit after that after extending an open invitation during the est2 fair funding legislation this past summer uh New Jersey Senate Majority Leader Steve Sweeney um took us up on our offer and requested a Roundtable discussion opportunity with some of our high school students our PTO president Mr Mar pero the acting principal of the high

116school central office administration Mrs kapano and Mr Ryback uh the the round table was also uh a in attendance with Senator Greenstein assemblyman D'Angelo and Benson and mayor tamboro the discussion focused on Monroe's long fight for fair funding and review and a review of how our additional Aid supported programs including special education ation programs and gave tax relief back to the community we recognize the efforts of so many community members past and current board members who have lobbied for years for our fair share most importantly our audience of elected officials heard loud and clear that our expectation is to continue to demand increases in additional funding that Monroe is entitled to through changing of the funding formula we also have uh some Personnel items to approve so Madame board president and members of the Board

117of Education it is recommended that Personnel action items a through a n under the superintendent report be approved by consent roll call so move Mr Braverman moved it second by Mr Ryback are there any comments or questions from Mr Goodall none okay then we will have a roll call Mr Ryback yes Mr Braverman yes Mr rutsky yes Mr cherella yes Mrs armeno yes Mrs Deo yes Mr Russo yes Mrs K Pano yes Madam board president Personnel items a through a n under superintendent report has passed thank you we also have some board action items Madame board president and members of the board of edit is recommend recommended that board action items a through S be approved by consent roll call so move move by Mr Mr Braverman second second by Mr Ryback again any comments

118or questions Miss armino yes on the um board uh goals I'm sorry on the district goals number one District goal number one uh number six I know we had asked for uh a creation of a Civic education but could you explain number six cuz it looks like it's just a online uh what page are you on I'm on it's it's R recommend that the board approve the previously submitted District goals okay on the district goals specifically number one District goals number six I'll I'll read it creation of District digital Civic Ed link to homepage which will facilitate a hub to share content specific research student work Civic Club happenings collaborative leadership work with District Civic Ed partners and staff and students and community at large wow okay so what is that please okay yes Miss

119Dr Al Miss caletto is working to create a space on our web page that would share out resources for civic education this is not the course that you were that you were referencing right um this is just another way to share out resources and to share out some of the things that we're currently doing with our students with the community okay but I thought that when we had our meeting to discuss uh District goals that it was specifically a course a classroom instruction so have we done any that doesn't need to be a district goal because that's a state mandate that is something that we are in that we do have to create to begin in the 1920 school year so that's something where is that going to be where that's ongoing in development at

120the middle school it's going to be development at the middle school what about the high school we already have a civics class at the high school a specific class an instructional class that kids go into the classroom and yes it's not a mandated class for graduation but it's an elective class an elective okay I think what I was trying to get at at that at our go goal is that we we should have a mandated class or we should do it like someone in the public said recently that we should go beyond what's mandated sometimes governance the history of our country and um you know specifically I think a classroom and I thought that was the intention I thought that was what was agreed to at that meeting so you're saying that that's that's not

121happening yet well it's happening at the middle school a lot of that is embedded you in what they do in our social studies classes at the high school but certainly uh this is a work in progress and that could be explored moving forward okay that was the answer that I got last time I thought we were going to be more specific in this goal so I'm disappointed that we haven't come up with classroom instruction at this point I mean in our in in our democracy is is a very important thing to me and I think one of the um responsibilities of a public school education is to really bring out especially in high school kids going in you know some of our high school students in their senior year could could um register to vote

122I think it's really incumbent upon us to make good citizens and I I don't see that we do have them registered to vote when they're a senior and they turn don't we registering to vote and knowing about governance and our history and they learn that during their high school years as part of the curriculum well there's no specific CL and and I that's I'm told embedded into the curricul I know but we don't know what's embedded it can be embedded into literature be there's no specific govern I I just object to keep keep in mind at the high school there's a sequence and required courses to meet graduation so just because uh we might want to have a mandated Civics course at the high school within one year you really couldn't do that that would

123be unfair uh to the students as they come in we usually pilot something and then bring it online um not on literally online but as part of what their sequence is to graduate as students enter the ninth grade so developing a a similar course in the middle school is probably your best first action step Mr Russo and I might be wrong but I'm just um I think what Miss armeno means that the embedded way that we currently do do it is not working am I right yeah it appears not to I I understand your point but it's not just as simple they they when you get to the high school there's sequence and a list of required courses that the kids have to take that's why currently the Civics is a elective class so it

124makes sense uh to have a exposure class in the middle school and then potentially uh add a required course of civics um but you would do that with a beginning entering ninth class and you would outline that in the program of studies so parents and students know upfront that they need that as part of their requirement from Monroe Township to graduate I I would just say that we are very fortunate to have engaged citizens that come to our meetings uh whether they agree with me or not I am grateful for their presence I'm grateful for the um you know what how they show their children to be engaged democracy is important it should not be an elective we need to make responsible uh citizens going forward and I it shouldn't be something that that's just

125elective I I'm I'm disappointed in in the way this was because this is what we've been hearing for years we keep hearing it and I I thought I was specific and I thought there was agreement about a specific um information I I'm you know I get flabbergasted a lot lately but I'm flabbergasted it's not an important enough issue if I'm if I misspoke in presenting the goals I I wouldn't have promised having a high school requirement uh for our current students within a year's time or six months time because I know in the past whenever we introduced a new requirement such as like an economics class which was a state mandate um we did that with the entering 9th grade no fine anyone else okay then we'll have a roll call Mr Rybeck yes Mr

126rutsky yes Mrs Deo yes Mr Chella yes Mrs armeno I vote Yes except for I vote no on E and no on r e and r like emergency got it so noted Mr Braverman yes Mr Russo yes on everything no on E no on h no on E no on H thank you sir Mrs K Pano yes mam board president board action items a through S has passed okay so we go to the Ed I'm assuming that concludes your report we will go to the business administrator's report thank you uh Mrs K Pano if You' help me in doing the honors of presenting the check something to check play B white for a moment this is a check payable to the Monro Township Board of Education for $3 39,7 183 this represents the administrative efforts

127to go to meetings from New Jersey Schoolboard Insurance Group Eric North and apply for a grant called the safety Grant which we do every year through the efforts of Mr tag mainly this year this is one of the highest amounts that I've seen $339,700 and I believe it was discussed before what our intentions were to do with this money but it is money uh much needed and will be put to good use yes thank you I I believe Mr Ryback mentioned that in your report or I think so I saw the check also on my report I want to um draw attention to item o which is a resolution of the Board of Education of the township of Monroe authorizing certain action with respect to information Reed from the New Jersey Department of Education we

128have received two preliminary cost uh letters preliminary eligible cost letters PE letters from the Department of Education pursuant to application these letters have indicated that the Monroe Township Board of Education has a preliminary eligible cost for the Monro Township Middle School of 75,6 187,000 from that we are eligible for Debt Service Aid of $ 7,516 th000 and I will put all this information on the site so uh don't feel the need to feverishly uh document everything we have also asked uh cooperation from The District's financial advisor in calculating what the average annual tax impact would be on a referendum of that dollar amount before I get there that dollar amount has increased from the previous referendum which was 68 m845 ,000 to now 75,6 187,000 because of two reasons increased construction costs which Mr T

129estimates go up estimated go up about a million dollars a year but also because of engineering estimates of commodity prices particularly steel um that is a major component of the construction um and a reserve of additional monies for the effect of tariffs and a threat of tariffs so you know we had indicated previously with this referendum that unfortunately if it was to be defeated it was going to cost more unfortunately it has but some of the good news is that the tax impact has not gone up that substantially for a home assessed at $100,000 the average annual impact on the new middle school project would be $488 per year per per hundred sir per $100,000 of assessed value $488 the second preliminary eligible cost letter that we received is the second component of the planed

130Bond referendum which is the additions to the mon Township High School be reminded that this school opened to capacity and has now exceeded capacity and we are a year later than where we were last year where this was not part of the question um the cost for the addition to the Monro Township High School is 71 million $30,000 the average annual tax impact per $100,000 of assessed value is $43.95 the resolution you have this evening as part of my report is to accept a preliminary cost uh letters from the Department of Education not to challenge them and to send a certified resolution of this U action to the Department of Education it is recommended by the superintendent assistant superintendent business administrator and Facilities director to accept these preliminary eligible cost letters as we believe them

131to be uh fair and accurate that said Madame board president and members of the Monro Township Board of Education it is recommended that boort action items a through o be approved by consent roll call is there a motion so moved Mr de Mayo Mr Ryback comments or questions from Mr Gorski go ahead job um thank you I would just like to thank um the donation of two $500 gift cards from Ocean First for Barkley Brook and Oak Tree school I think I think that was a very generous and the donation um for STEM related materials for donor choose for instruction at mil Lake School and the donation from RBC Capital markets for Brookside school it's $1,000 to support the empty bows project and the donation from the mtba for their for the scoreboard and batting

132cage at Oak Tree I think these are um wonderful additions to our school and they are greatly appreciated thank you thank you Mr Mayo Miss armeno yes and thank you that's thank you uh Mr Mayo for that I I 100% agree thank you everybody who is so generous to our students um on the board action a through N I have a question regarding I have a couple questions on number one professional appointments uh we're talking about Princeton Health Care systems and it talks about on-site Educational Services for some of our students who are hospitalized um and Princeton Health Care system is providing that are they certified teachers it says it it says Princeton Healthcare engages certified tutors to provide on-site educational instructions so it's their their teachers and their tutors that go into to our

133to our children if they're in the hospital that is Mr Good's understanding okay so we don't have any so when they say certified so they've they've had all the um background checks and all that kind of stuff that we would normally do with teachers and tutors in our district okay so we're providing that and just um in that regard number 9 10 and 11 they it also talks about we're hiring individual people to um it says provide Hospital Education Services to students admitted in different places so that looks to me to be individual I just like verification of that are they like for specific students or is this are we getting four contracts for in general one is Barbara Mark 10 11 I I yeah and the other is silvergate prep and the other's professional

134Educational Services they seem to be um not yeah they seem to be for specific students I just want to know or are they overlapping Madam they are not um like our um time and material bids anticipatory there is an IEP driven need for these for it it seems to me that's what I thought 9 10 and 11 correct and number one is uh just in general that is my understanding by the recommendation of the special they do overlap they do overlap so if we're paying so if a child is in Princeton Health Care system and they're getting tutors from them they may also be getting additional teach teachers from us no from from the like are two of these organizations or Health Care Systems working with one child no no okay that's not so I

135get it that Princeton Health Care Systems if we send a child there we are agreeing that they can bring teachers in to help that child get that so that's a general contract I thought that 9 10 and 11 might be specific contracts but are they open to anybody or do we have specific children now that we doing this are these like professional for like the whole year Madam that could be uh temporary depending on the placement of the student right but and I I couldn't answer if right now uh we have a child who's receiving that okay where you're approving them to actually provide the service if necessary but I mean if we're not sending two Stu two teachers into one child if it's you know what I'm trying to say you take a sh

136um Princeton isn't the only Hospital use if we need to send a child out for any kind of treatment so these other placements could be in other hospitals no I that I get that's and that was my question what I'm saying is there's no overlap 9 10 and 11 won't be sending someone to Princeton hospital because we're already covered under that contract I can't speak to that it would depend on the student if they have if if Princeton doesn't have someone available to work with the student we would have to send someone in well I get that as long as it's not an overlap an over it would only be one okay then I also have a question on um transfer number three in the bills list um it and you can clarify this for

137me as well um we had $140,000 was taken from the regular program instruction teacher salaries and was put in into it was divided into $20,000 for legal services and another $120,000 for General Administration miscellaneous purchase Services is that how that was broken up and transferred uh bear with me I'm looking for the transfer schedule Okay I uh I have it here transfer number three if you'd like I'll just pass this would you mind it'll save time uh this transfer number three is for the 1819 budget and it only has a few line items here so I'll be happy to go through them the first one is undistributed expenditure Support Services General Administration legal services that is getting an infusion of money for $20,000 uh I I anticipate a question coming up why are we transferring

138money in there am I correct the reason for that is we have a number of special education um lawsuits which are sent to the district's insurance carrier subject to a deductible each time and those cannot uh reasonably be estimated at the time the budget's put together uh we have had numerous special education lawsuits they have been sent to the insurance carrier this is to uh replenish that account line item with additional funds to cover the deductibles um in in regular programs instructional teacher salaries um now that we have a defined agreement with um the mte and so on and uh it is it is one of the largest line items in the budget this is a transfer out of that account for $140,000 okay U some of the money is going into 110 23590 undistributed

139expenditure Support Services General Administration miscellaneous purchased services for $120,000 and um um another one for cleaning and maintenance services for 5,000 the money is coming from custodial service salaries transfers are um are are part of managing the budget um inherently when you put together a budget it's based on estimates and projections and this allows you the flexibility to work through that during the year there are strict restrictions on some accounts for transfers such as administrative accounts and overall you can't transfer more than 10% of an appropriation amount uh to or from a particular account item okay I'm satisfied with that I was just nervous that it was coming out of regular program instruction teacher salaries that's all any any other questions Miss misso I sorry I just wanted to say I was remiss in not

140thanking Eric North for the safety award that we received too so I would like to thank them thank you Mr cherella yeah I also have a question on transfer number three so we're taking $140,000 out of teacher salary out of that bucket and we're and we're putting $120,000 into General Administration miscellaneous what what is that what is General ad Administration miscellaneous do you want to see that again uh no no um although the exact uh expenditure uh escapes me that account is for um purchased Services of an administrative nature uh it could very much involve in this particular case the uh District environmental engineer who was engaged with the mold remediation project um but I would have to uh uh really look at that more specifically in order to give an exact answer but that

141that's my uh estimate we have a very large budget teacher salary account has an appropriation amount exceeding $25 million in the aggregate so that's a very small percentage um coming out and uh I wouldn't be surprised if there's more transfers either in or out throughout the year I will say that no U instructional staff have been cut or from the budget in fact quite the contrary we've added positions that have not been budgeted for for growth and those also need to be accommodated for through transfer okay any other questions Mr Russo just um on oh why do we have to accept the resolution discre what's the significance of of accepting it because Mr Russo it's required by the Department of Education to finalize uh the preliminary eligible cost letter into what becomes the final eligible

142cost letter the Fe letter so this is the board action accepting the costs um that have been compiled for these projects um and the amount of Debt Service Aid that is estimated per the schedule so that we can proceed with process if if these two projects are approved uh what would be the total debt that the district would be in including the current debt I'm going to estimate that number uh right now we have total debt of approximately $25 million so that exact number will be reported short when we present the comprehensive annual financial report but it's approximately $120 million outstanding for bonds to build schools so you would take your $120 million and you would add to it 75 million and then 71 million assuming that both pieces of that referendum are successful that

143would take the amount of outstanding debt to approximately 266 million and that is uh within our our current borrowing capacity it is and um just curious a ballpark figure best guess what do you what would that cost in terms of Debt Service per year uh please rephrase your question what would what would the extra borrowing cost in debt service per year like now we pay I don't know about $10 million or $9 million per year in debt service that's correct uh that I I appreciate the question right now our debt service budget is about $10 million but keep in mind we have bonds that are maturing we have interest and and principle that are being uh satisfied that are falling off that schedule fortunately so I would have to calculate that to figure out what

144the addition of this debt and the falloff of the existing debt would actually uh amount to okay I mean considering rates are going up borrowing another 140 or so what would that cost I'm sorry I'd have to calculate that uh if you wish I could get you that information tomorrow I don't know off hand that's that's a calculation at 4% it's about 6 million a year so additional 61,000 any other questions from Mr Gorski I I I do have one more on N the contractual renewal I just have actually have a comment that is to renew our um contract with g& Technologies for our video of the meetings um my question is I we don't seem to be a like the the videos are on our website um and it seems like the public like

145if you wanted to or I tried to download the video just so I have a record of it it's not possible under this technology that we have it doesn't seem to be is that it's a question because I I would like to to know that the public can download the video if they wanted to for nothing rather than paying a small fee for for getting um a copy of the video of the meetings uh I beg a pardon I don't have that technical understanding but but if a member of the public wanted to uh request a copy of the meetings Mr you requested and we would provide them with a link no but they can't can can you download you can't download it from the link I don't think hi as a matter of fact

146hi um we can make the Board of Ed videos um available for download you can but the public can't right I can't like it's just something that needs to be turned on that feature will hasn't been requested up until you just mentioned it now um but if the board so desires we can make it available we can make the board of Ved video videos available for download could does that have to be would that have to be included in this renewal because then I would i' like to either have it included or does the language have part that technology and would it cost a lot more to have that no it doesn't cost anything more oh it's just something that it's it's basically a switch that needs to be flipped so that doesn't have to

147be part of so so we need to do it what a trans what a thing for transparency no cost how you talking no cost to the district do we have to vote on that nothing I mean we still to be clear we still need to uh renew the contract with the streaming and hosting provider but the feature is available it's just we need requested yeah we just need to activate I'm going to do a little bartering here I would I will vote Yes for this contract as long as I'm promised that we can activate that feature so the public can Mr alot can you turn on that feature please at your earliest convenience for this board meeting thank you so much absolutely great thank you what a concept bartering are there any other questions for

148Mr Gorski I see none we'll have a roll call once again board action items a through o under the business administrator report Mr rutsky yes Mrs Deo yes Mr Chella yes on everything except for B uh transfer number three that's I'm voting no on that so noted Mrs armeno oh uh yes on everything no on B Mr Rybeck uh yes on everything except number two where I have to recuse myself Mr R um where am I are you lost yes oh uh Mr Russo did I call you yet sir no Mr Russo call me um yes on everything no or no thank you Mr Braverman yes Mrs K panovich yes Madam board president board action items a through o passes once again I'd like to thank Jerry take for all of his attendance at the

149meetings and the application for the safety grant that money will go to good use once again thank you thank you at this time we'll go to the board president's report and I'm just going to reiterate some of the things that Mr Goodall stated about the um visit from Senator Sweeney uh during the past summer Mr Goodall Mr Gorski and Mr Ryback had the opportunity to attend the S2 legislative signing which gave more State funding to underfunded school districts and made the state funding more equitable throughout the district I mean throughout the state Monroe received an additional $2 million or about a 62% increase in the funding that we had been receiving the majority of which we went went back to the taxpayers by a vote by the members of the board of education at that

150time they spoke to Senator state senator president Sweeney about funding in Monroe and gave him an open-ended invitation to visit our school district so we could showcase our program programs in our schools to him this past Friday president Sweeney took up Monroe on its offer and visited our district and I believe um Mr Goodall told you already who the invitation list came from and this was not a district event but an event that came out of Trenton from Senator Sweeney's office we took a tour of the special education apartment located in the high school and Senator Sweeney had an opportunity to speak with the students and the staff about the program and what our students have accomplished and will continue to accomplish and both the senator and our state representatives were very much impressed with

151our students and our special education programs that we can have hold in District uh after the tour we all met in the high school conference room for a round table discussion on state funding and how it affects Monroe Township and what we can expect in the future Senator Sweeny mentioned that mon has been due to the efforts of our uh legislators to in the Forefront of discussions about additional State funding and um how our local leaders were very vocal when it came to Monroe and its funding He also mentioned some of the things that the state was working on to help alleviate the cost of special education which he understands is a big burden to districts all across New Jersey they hope to have something in place where they can releas Rel some of the

152burden to the school districts he also said that Monroe can expect additional increases in funding in the next few years to get us to where we are fully funded fairly it was mentioned to him about the growing School District the growing student population and the need for additional schools in our district and the senior population who can no longer assume the tax increases for additional building referendums and hopefully that we could get money from that in the future um and while we're happy as I said before we're happy to receive any additional in any additional funding from the state it is not enough for us we need to continue to advocate for a new and fair funding formula that will help relieve the tax burden for our taxpayers in Monroe Township and that in concludes

153my board president's report at this time we'll go to number 13 Other Board of Education business any member of the Board of Education Mr Ryback um just two things first one on on Tuesday October 2nd Mr Deo Mrs Lang and I attended New Jersey School Board Association workshop on Career and Technical education at North Brunswick High School it emphasized the importance of preparing our students not only for college but for the world of work it's no secret that companies have a shortage of skilled workers who command excellent salaries just this past Sunday there was an article in Star Ledger about new Jersey Transit uh shortage of train Engineers who can ultimately make $100,000 a year so it's it's right now it's a matter of conversations about creating these types of programs without certainly losing any

154stress uh emphasis rather on on the academics we need we need both the the second thing I want to just mention uh is something I noticed today um I want to certainly uh Echo the words of my colleague Mrs armino about how important it is for the public to come here and how much we appreciate you all being here and when someone comes up to the podium to speak it's important there's no such thing as a stupid question uh they have that right to speak and we're interested what they have to say but what I noticed today unfortunately was some people laughing and making faces as some people were speaking and I think that's something that we have to stop and I know my colleagues on the board would join me in saying that we'd

155appreciate uh everyone showing respect to whoever is at that Podium speaking to this board of education thank you anyone else Miss armino um I I just have a question how um are we paying for uh a Monroe Township uh police officer to be here this evening there's two there two yes we are and who authorized that please we had I beg your pardon did you want to answer yes it is the business administrator's uh authority to administer the meetings and based upon uh reports that I had received there was an anticipated uh presence this evening that whether it was a board meeting or a an athletic event or a use of building I would have required um police officers at that event now some of those instances they they get charged for those Services here

156we have the rates approved already by the board of education for the police department and certainly maintaining order and safety of the occupants is of paramont Paramount of importance and that that's um that that opinion is is solely on your discretion yes ma'am okay so what was the threat what was the threat yes there was supposed to be a large um turnout to the meeting based upon estimates of uh information that I was reported and to maintain safety and order I I thought it was um appropriate to have the police here okay and how many security uh officers do we have paid security officers from from the district at least two I believe there's two here this evening okay I I I had a um I was very upset last meeting because I think and

157Mr Rybeck just talked about people coming up and our engaged citizens I do not perceive a threat um that's personal I mean I don't I don't think we need armed guards to have our our children when our children are here and when our parents talk yes do people every once in a while get um a little upset or raise their voices but I think um it sends a very bad message in a democracy such as ours that we have to put armed guards here and sometimes our security guards and I I'm not being specific but I think as a matter of procedure um that seems to be happening that they um in my opinion aost the uh members of the public tell them to be quiet or move them off La last uh week uh

158last month I'm sorry they moved them off the podium I think that's an inappropriate use of uh the security guard I and I'd like to know I mean Mr um Russo months ago when we were talking about uh regulations and everything about armed security guards he he was asking for a job description he was asking for what was protocol we never got that and now I see four armed uh people in here and I think it it sends a chilling effect on our democracy on on the public and I don't think it's necessary I respect my husband was a police officer I respect the job I know what it entails however I think that under monro's current circumstances we don't have I I just think it's an inappropriate use of force if I may Madam

159Madam if if I overestimated uh the the need of uh security this evening I apologize I'll I'll be more careful in the future but I have to take exception of one thing you uh you said you Ed the word a cost uh with ref reference to our security director's address of a uh public speaker at the last meeting who had become out of order pardon you would be surprised to know that that public speaker actually had had uh furnished the security director with a thank you gift basket after that exchange because of The Cordial uh introduction that that was made afterwards so was I don't think there was an ACC costing forgive me if that's in use of the word of anybody at that meeting well I physic I saw that the that the person

160was physically moved away from arino we're discussing Personnel now when you're talking about no I'm I'm discussing an action that should not be Tak but you're what you're taking what you you are doing is a discussing a p person in the district then we need to have a discussion about about who's choosing Miss AR of force I will say to you that after the meeting last time you requested a meeting right and you we we we haven't established a meeting date yet right because you never responded back to the twice that you were asked to respond to us right right if I can I just like to clarify something where I think maybe you misinterpreted what I was saying I was only talking about this evening when I saw some people laughing at somebody who

161was at the podium has nothing to do with security or any of that I just think it was disrespectful that's all I was referring to I I think it's disrespectful when the public is isn't free to speak I have a I believe we've always let our public be free to speak anyone else yeah I have a question Mr Russo um Mr Gorski mentioned that he got some information and that's why he acted and and U brought the security in can you share that information I mean where do you get this information from I could share that information but for the efficiency of the meeting I I don't I don't think it's productive um so I apologize if my estimate was uh on the heavier side and I'll do a better job of estimating the need

162for security going forward but I'm just wondering what is the nature of it or how do you collect this information from where Madam i i i respectfully uh declined to answer that question it has to do with security and um I again I overestimated the need for tonight um but the safety of the memb of the public attending the meeting as well as the members of the Board of Education as well as the children that were here before should be everybody's first priority and it was mine in this instance and if I overestimated and I I wasted a couple hundred dollars trust me I have more the made up for it that's that's that's understood the concern the children and the people who come here the public should be taken into consideration but um I'm

163asking where did you get the information from I think you've asked that question answered that question to the best what was the answer his his response right now is he's not responding to that question oh so I didn't get an answer he gave you an answer due to Safety and Security reason okay so I didn't get an answer that's what you're saying he gave you an answer not the answer you were looking for but he gave you an answer okay let's go is there any other any other I I just have uh just something quick so the U and I I do appre appreciate our Administration having a meeting with our with our elected officials with with the with the Senators and uh with Sweeney and and Senator Greenstein and and and the rest of

164them but um but this is the second meeting where I was excluded as a fair funding committee chair so there was a meeting that the board president attended in I think uh May that was held at one of our schools and I was not alerted to that meeting I did go to the OM Patel Memorial uh that night so I wouldn't have gone to that meeting anyway even if I had been invited because that to me took precedence over over uh a sham funding meeting to to to be honest but I wasn't invited to that then the followup is that this one I wasn't invited to now listen my ego is that big that I think I need to be invited to these things but as the chair I have to tell you that we

165have some people that are on our Fair funding committee here that worked very hard that were Liaisons between our Fair funding committee and the uh and those Ed uh officials and it would have been nice to at least be able to tell them that this this kind of stuff was uh that these meetings were happening uh so that they could they could at least be aware of it it's marginalized the committee I think it's uh it's it's also marginalized the the effort that they've put out and and how hard they've worked the nights that they've spent the weekends that they've spent uh on their own time to go and do this they're not being paid for that um and and and so I I'm just from my standpoint I'm just going to tell you that

166I think that uh this was a political thing you know to to to uh because they didn't want you guys or they didn't want anybody there that was going to ask real questions and maybe hold their feet to the fire and maybe that's why the invitation didn't go because maybe there'd be real questions asked so I'm respectfully going to resign from that committee I asked that commit I asked for that fair funding committee to be created when I first got sworn in in January 2017 and I am asking now to be removed from that and then we'll see where it goes from there but I'm not going to waste any more money my time uh in with a political you know dog and pony show thank you thank you Mr cheer point taken and noted

167any other business from the Board of Education okay then we'll go to the public forum again anybody wishing to speak please come to the microphone give your name and address for the record we will adhere to 4 minutes again good evening Ram rnat s soen stri mro um a lot of points again four minutes so the first point uh Mr cherala I think you should take back your resignation from the fair funding we need people like you to be on that committee the we the public were disappointed that the head of the fair funding committee Mr Chella was not invited to this meeting uh you know so Madame President could you provide an explanation why he was not invited to that meeting because if the invitations came from Trenton it was not a board invite

168it was not um a a board activity it was an event but uh but there's nothing I had no right but there's nothing preventing you from bringing folks of my team this happens in Corporate America every time you can bring who you want from your team I I could not invite people it would be like you inviting me to your house and me bringing 10 friends but this is your house they came to your house this was not a a this was certainly even as superintendent I acknowledge that I I would have preferred to have the whole board there and including Mr Chella as chair of that committee the invitation uh from the Senate Office was a limited invitation and I guess you have to weigh whether it was important to have that dialogue with

169them or make a stand and in this particular case my recommendation was to continue with the meeting and have the meting and Lobby for our Equitable funding and it was an opportunity to showcase to our legislators that um the work that they're doing uh is not in vain and that we use the money appropriately and excellently and so admittedly I would have preferred Mr good I don't want to I'm not cutting you off because my time is is going right I'm sorry that's why I'm being a bit rude or whatever but see the message you're sending to the public right the as kill said so many people have spend a lot of time working on the fair to was on Fair funding right wasn't this such a big mess it was it was part of

170my dialogue with them that so many people past and present have fought the fight okay so I do recognize that sir second in that meeting uh were there any prepared remarks made by either Madame President or you uh and can those be made public I can just answer for myself I had no prepared remarks it was a Roundtable discussion where where uh Senator Sweeney asked questions of our students our PTO president the high school principal myself Mrs kapano it was nothing prepared it was spontanous I did not have anything prepared either I know Mr Ryback was there he had nothing prepared but he yes their questions were asked and we answered them and we also made sure that we uh explained to him what the problems were in Monroe that there the Senior Communities the

171building of our our um schools that are needed uh and he understood all that uh so we had that opportunity to talk to him about Monroe specific okay I guess the my thing is again if there had been prepared remarks again the public would have benefited from this and with prepared remarks this was such a great opportunity for you to make that case as someone was saying what are the issues with the fair funding formula get into that level of detail and have that tough conversation as the lady said for 10 years we have been fighting this with no success so something is wrong in our strategy and we are losing opportunities with this again interest time let me move forward on some of the reports I saw that we have classrooms with uh greater

172than 25 students uh do we have stats on how many classrooms in the middle school and high school where we have made more than 25 students this year I I we did request of the high school and middle school administration to create room utilization and uh one of the requests had to do with the potential of adding additional trailers so we're hoping to have that report for the November meeting okay thank you okay thank you uh prakash par 33 din Drive I want the public to know that we are supposed to get $9 million per year from the state and it was stated that from 2008 onward they have Frozen it and we got very minimum now we have been told by the legislators that we will get our 9 million stepwise in next 5

173years so they are not doing any favor to us I tell you giving $2 million is a not big favor we they owe us this year another $7 million they are not going to give us okay okay so that is the fact so no glory we all fought and they gave us only 2 million wish they would have given nine and they had to give more and we will work on it there are flaws my friend Amba wrote a email to Mr groski showing where there are defects in the formula and we will come to you we'll follow up with the meeting with you because we have looked at the process we have looked at other schools so we want want to discuss with you you're the expert so we will discuss with you okay

174this I would be happy to meet with you or anybody else's subject matter that I I I enjoy speaking about so thank you your heart is there I know it yeah now there is this is the topic everyone is talking about in the town I'm not afraid of it I'll never be afraid of it there is a recording on the Facebook which says that some of the our leadership here received a input from the mayor which which was regarding the timing and the content of the memor referendum which took place in March this year the referendum was supposed to take place in November last year but we were having council elections so in not have to interfere referendum and the council election so it was moved to March and the content of the referendum we

175we all came here in October last year and said include high school and middle school but only Middle School was included and what happened the people who wanted high school they didn't vote for it the teachers were upset didn't vote for the referendum and we lost the referend only by 143 votes we would have won it with major major if we would have included high school so what is happening is we the Boe has to be independent organiz ganization we have to take the decisions based on the children taxpayers and the parents' interest not because of the political reasons the politicians try to get their benefits we are the independent organization I'm sure that was going on in the public so the today we have police officers here so there is nothing to hide about

176okay my request is don't take political advice here even in the election I'm seeing the politicians are dividing no the Boe leadership next year I want to be unified the leader who has to keep all the 10 people United not divided thank you very [Applause] much good evening George gunman 5 Kelly Court um I'd like to ask a couple questions about the the mold remediation at the morasco center I'd like to know what its current status is and I'd like to know what the cost to date is for that work and thirdly I'd like to know if there's an explanation as to how this happened uh specifically with the hbac turned off or run less than normal and who made that decision Madam Mr Mr Gorski may I answer Mr Gunman's question uh first to

177the cost the um I the first question was status is the work complet yes status the work is completed uh we have had inspections of the area and it is has been deemed mold-free so the work is completed uh your second question I believe went to cost we were proposed $108,000 contract from a mold remediation company which has work off the charts right now because the particular environmental conditions of this summer has led to mold growth across the state there were many school districts that were late in opening and are spending big dollars on mold remediation which is UN insured uh by uh uh intent of the uh insurance companies there are very strict limits on the amount of insurance you can get on mold remediation so we negotiated the $108,000 contract down to not

178to exceed 75,000 and there are also costs of the engineer from environmental Safety Management who did independent testing uh at the board's request um and I've forgive me I don't have those exact time charges I don't know if he furnished us with the bill yet for that but if I had to estimate the total sir I would say that it is well under 100,000 and I got an insurance check for the maximum we could get of 25,000 this week so the district is out of pocket approximately 75,000 as far as how did this happen uh it is it was a very damp wet moist summer that the conditions are right for development particularly in the Performing Arts Center where there's no uh Windows uh we do have a schedule uh that is monitored by a

179professional organization called um energy for America who the board contracts with to manage our uh energy costs including lighting air conditioning and heating um uh per School room down to that specific level uh we had a schedule set up that has been effective in the past for managing the uh the air conditioning over the summer in the Performing Arts Center but we were compounded with another problem of of some ferocious storms and power outages which we seem to be uh very subject to especially off of Pineville Road for some reason so the constant power outages did cause some uh dysfunction of the air conditioning equipment which was quickly remediated but there were times where it was not running to design and again that was because of the uh the frequent power outages that we had

180experien over the summer so the the the program that you contract for does make no adjustments for weather no it does not it does not it manages the utilities uh to each School each classroom shuts off classroom if it's not in use for example like this room would be reduced in the amount of uh air conditioning or heting I understand how those programs work but they you know I mean you get what you contract for why wouldn't you contract for something or at least advise them that you're having a wetter than normal season I mean we all live here yes the idea I mean you don't need to tell this Hall that the electricity went off a few times we know it we live here you know you don't need to tell us that it

181was wetter than normal we all know that we live here I point Mr gunman we we have come up with a plan going forward to better address this and make sure that there are dehumidifying uh stations and uh and um we we've taken up a issue with jcpnl also but we will better manage this going forward it it just seems that issue that after issue the come up there's nobody responsible for the the results and or no one that wants to answer the question as to who's responsible I it's hard for us to understand when there's lack of accountability for things that are costing the taxpayers money one last comment and that would simply be that there's a lot of talk coming out that would you know saying that Trenton doesn't understand the condition of

182our taxpayers they have our tax returns they know exactly what how much money we make it's silly to talk about it that they don't appreciate how poor we are they know how much money we have that's a just a silly defense and it's somewhat insulting [Applause] Amika sukla to cot uh so I want to go back to the topic that I was trying to uh discuss earlier um so it looks like we have spent nearly 5 years and possibly will have spent 8 years trying to come up with a referendum and uh you know even get started with schools uh it seems um no one has any idea how much money has uh been wasted in that effort so far um when a topic comes to Fair funding uh I was going to say something

183but shut me out uh I did spend you know hours researching Fair funding you know going through data from you know six seven different sites putting them together and reconstructing the school uh formula from ground up from scratch and trying to pinpoint exactly what where the issues are and I send a mail to everyone in the board the only person who responded is is Ken there was no other response from anyone not not even an acknowledgement uh from anyone else that I sent this email to uh and looks like he just resigned and he didn't seem to um it didn't seem to matter to anyone when he said that I don't know how so given um you just admitted that um you know you have you don't know anything about the formula but you somehow

184are fighting for fair funding um so put when I put all of this together I would you know give most of my 3 minutes that is left to try to understand and this is a question that I've been asking myself time and again as we are getting closer to the bo elections you know why why should we continue to have faith in your leaders ERS ship that's a question for the Board of Education it's a question for you you are the president of the Board of Education Madame President it's a direct question to to you that that is a question for the Board of Education they decide they and they vote on leadership every year at the reorganization meeting I'm give an opportunity for you to tell us why we specifically personally from your point

185of like if I were you I would probably let somebody else who can do this job better uh do it well were you here at the beginning of the meeting I I I got the contents in the gist of what you said and well I'll read it again if you would like this is my accomplishments over the last 30 years in this District I'm talking about the last 8 years that I have been here and so far I haven't seen any accomplishment Worth to be of you haven't seen the new high school open up you haven't seen an increase in curriculum I'm talking about the last last 8 years you haven't seen that only this m presid I'm giving an opportunity to tell me give answer me this question so I'm I'm asking you that

186I've been here for 8 years and so far I haven't all I've heard is excuses you know I I just heard Mr Gorski say 10 times that oh you know what we had mold so what all the other people had molded you know we had X so what everybody else had X you know if if my son comes home and he says he gets a c not that he does and they say that well I got to see because everybody else did that's not a good answer that's just not a good answer I really don't want to hear excuses like that I will read you my accomplishments if you would like please okay when you're finished I will read this because I don't want to take up your time I am finished I'm asking you

187this question and I'll read the whole thing again after public forum I would like you to for the the last 8 years and I will do that after public forum is over all right I will be glad to do that sure [Applause] thanks Roger mey 22 haragan Avenue Mr chel I wish you'd reconsider your resignation but I admire you is an intelligent man who knows what he needs to do and the old saying of why do I bang stop hanging my head against the wall cuz it feels good when I stop Madame President you said that you refused to resign over false allegations I heard an audio of a woman speaking saying she was told things by mayor tamboro last night are you saying that was not you on the Audio I don't know what

188audio you're referring to so I the audio on Facebook that has been out ma'am and I did not see the audio on Facebook would you like me to play it for you no okay there's an audio of you saying that mayor tamboro did not want the resolu the referendum to be posted in November because he had four Council seats up and he didn't want to lose them and push it to March okay you were on audio saying it now so if you're pretending that you don't know what audio you're on I'm not that stup stupid you can lie to everybody else but I don't believe you okay so you've politicized the school board first of all this is my four minutes I gave you your 15 to Pat yourself on the back for doing a

189job that you chose to do okay I was elected I don't get a p on the back every day I leave work for doing what I'm supposed to do okay I admire you for what you've done but at the same time there comes a point where if you've been in this for 30 years when Monroe had 8,000 people we're now at 49,000 you may not be best suited for the job at 49,000 people okay and from what I heard from that audio last night you're just following what the mayor wants to do and you've politicized the school board I I see the way you treat certain people and the manner and tone that you use with certain people and there's a Great Divide and I think you should rule with principles over personalities rather than

190what mayor T Boro wants because you're doing a horrible disservice to the children by staying [Applause] onnot one M Drive um I have a question about the referendum and I think it's a procedural question can't hear me yeah better now good evening gazala Bora one mik drive um we went through a lot of Heartache a lot of arguments a lot of um um you know div divide in the town for the previous referendum and there was a lot of um assumptions made as to why just the middle school was put on that referendum um now with current with facts that have come out in the recent past I would like to ask a question to understand the procedure and the power of the Board of Education um I was involved in the student growth advisory

191committee there was parallel steering committee at that time um we had hired Consultants the Ross haer Associates to do our you know study of our um growth uh student growth we had a lot of information that we could use to to design the referendum and most of the recommendations included three schools um and the need for the middle school high school and Elementary School were not ever put at a certain level by the Committees and I think the Board of Ed also agreed to put the middle school and the high school in the referendum I'm thinking this now hypothetically speaking if the Board of Ed decides to go for a referendum for a middle school and a high school and the mayor does not agree to it what is the power of the Board of

192Ed to go over the mayor and put that on the ballot that's my question can the Board of Ed go against the mayor and put something that has been recommended by several committees and consultants and all the data that the border of Ed has been has access to if they decide to put on a referendum two schools and the mo mayor says no I just want one does the Board of Ed have the power to go ahead and put two schools on the referendum still that's my question to the board of ed right now the Board of Education acts on the recommendation of the administration we as a board none of us have the power to say this is what we want on a referendum this is what we don't want a referendum let me

193we do have the power to to put whatever the what the administration has the power to put whatever they wish on a referendum the board votes on that so I will rephrase my question then if the administration recommends something the Board of Ed also thinks on the same lines but the town mayor does not agree to it what choice does the Board of Ed have I'm asking a very black and white question here and you know why I'm asking that but I would really like to know the answer can we go against the mayor for the sake of our students we can if the if the administration feels that they have the right plan they will bring it to the Board of Education in a resolution on an agenda and the board will vote for

194that okay so there is I do not create a referendum Mr Mayo does not create a referendum Mr Mino does not create the referendum it comes from the administration they are the experts and they I do know the process madam presid president I do know that recommendations are made and then the Board of Ed I'm repeating your words right now and the Board of Ed votes on the recommendations and picks one I do know that and I do know that there was interference from the town government and I do know that because of that we've lost not one year but two years and that is the reason I'm asking that what power does this Board of Ed that we have elected have over the town government and I know you have the power I know

195that you are an autonomous body but we have you have not acted as one there is all the proof that the town was directing the Board of Ed and the District administration to go a certain way and that that was what was done and today we are two years too late and the blame is going to be put on people like me who who refused to vote on the first referendum because we we believed that that was a wrong solution but no what happened in the last March 2018 to now what progress have we made on the referendum very little there was a lot of asking questions but what what came back is at this time your time is up and we will go to the next [Applause] person Roslin bratsky 57c Yorkshire Drive I

196live in an adult community I would like to say that I'm listening and um what I would like to say is that from my perspective the mayor gave you land he gave you the the wherever that golf thing is he gave that to you so you could go forward the only people that publicized the referendum were Kathy and Mr Gorski no one else from this board of education came to any adult community in this whole Township to the senior center to the rec center when we had candidates speaking and when we asked for Board of Education members to come and talk so you're going to do a referendum we want to back a referendum but get out and get the vote out thank you madam president I'd like to correct I'm sorry she she gave

197misinformation going to correct her because I know that Mr and she's on the board she's on the planning board too she should say so and she has the right to make her statement absolutely but it should be accurate I'm also I'm also the chairperson of the mayor's advisory Adult Community there we go committee and I'm speaking for them too thank you so correct M miss armeno this is public forum and we're going to leave it she has the right to make her statement and if she felt that she hasn't seen anybody else at her then that's her statement but Madam that's but Madam you correct people when they when it's in your best interest you correct people's information I do I I answer questions next I'm taking a deep breath good good evening or good

198night Andy poori 16 St James Street I'm not even sure where to begin um I supported the referendum and did whatever I can do within my power thinking that that's the right thing to do because that's what the board of education has put forward if I'm to be told or proven that a political agenda is behind it that'll probably be the biggest disappointment that I have experienced in this Township since I'm not here to question who put the video clip Up or the audio clip whatever the clip was that they were talking about but I just want to know the facts was the referendum delayed deliberately because of the election Madam may I may I address this sure because I was privity to uh most of the discussions pertaining to the referendum I believe all

199of them having to do with the mayor and the township I will tell you like all of the stakeholders in this community uh hundreds that participate ated in a democratic process on the student growth advisory committee the mayor also offered his opinion recommendation suggestion and support for the referendum but I want to make this clear under no circumstance did the mayor influence the date that this referendum was to be held or the components of this referendum specifically it only being a middle school the mayor does not have that power and in the 20 years years that I've been employed by this school district we've had a collaborative relationship with the township they have never come down on this board with a heavy hand or forced us to do anything the only time we would ever

200need assistance from the township is if we exceeded our borrowing capacity for the size of the referendum they could lend us some of theirs but in this instance here to secure a very rare piece of land we asked I was priv I was at a lunch where we asked the mayor for help and and Wayne Hamilton the township business administrator for help to consider buying the land for us and that came from the suggestion of our bond counselor from marter and English at the time that was not my idea it is my impression and that's the reason I'm running for the board of education is because 56% of the township budget goes to the Board of Education in my opinion humble opinion Maybe I'm Wrong board of education is an autonomous body so is the

201township Administration they both need to function separately but at the same time coordinate with each other and I see the overcrowding of the schools because of lack of communication that's what I made into a big pitch about my campaign but for me to s stand here and realize last night that there some clip was put out somebody's influencing how the Board of Education should conduct business is really disturbing um and I would like to get a little bit more clarification on that and I sure I I'll take your word for it U administer groski for saying it but if there is an Evidence I want to see the evidence because I'm little bit tired of he said she said they said you know I came in front of the board in the past twoo and

202asked the same exact questions and I got some clarification on things but I need I think I'm at a point where I need some evidence to see who is doing what in the Board of Education thank you Betty sarito to Barrymore Drive can we can we play the flamous clip so that we can get up down to the bottom of this we are not playing any tapes of course not Krishna deal Jak place um I'll ask my questions right there two questions primarily one um when you met with the electric Representatives where did you leave after the meeting and two uh regarding the referend that we are planning for next April April or March or March of next year um you've mentioned that we are going to go and do a media blit starting January

203or after the holidays I'm just trying to understand um what's um are we using the same plan like we did last year which one are we emphasizing on because there are now two options that the township residents could pick both the high school and the middle school um or just the Middle School um and uh the other thing I have is do you have the proposed architectural plans for the high school how the classrooms would look like and Architectural plans for the high school uh Madam if I may we do have architectural plans for the high school we do not have them president at the meeting if you wish to make an appointment you were welcome to come in and review them sure about the first question what how did we leave off the meeting

204with the elected representatives can you repeat that um when you met with the um elected representatives regarding Fair funding right Friday yeah how did how did we end the meeting of where did we leave it off are we following up with them are they giving us an update I recall specifically that there was a recommendation made by Senate President Sweeny to work towards additional State funding or state aid for the specific category of special education funding we said we more than qualify he was very impressed with our programs and our teachers and that is how the meeting was concluded Senate President Sweeney was working towards additional State legislation for funding for special education Aid that Monro would be eligible for would that be uh when would that be coming in um certainly the budget for

205this year has passed would that be a part of next year's budget yeah I'm sorry we don't have that information okay and um the second question I asked was uh what's the plan about the media blits for the high school and the middle school referendum in March and we're we're working on a plan I know they had a steering committee meeting Monday I was not there I was very ill um so um the next committee meeting I think is November 1st something like that and they we will be discussing how the plan for communication to the public and would want I think are we is it 1 it's it's November 1st and and uhu like I think I said a couple meetings ago we invited the mtea to be a part of it I think

206they're being um very helpful part of what we're going to be doing and they're going to we're going to be using them to get the information out also and um the question related question to that is how are we selling this referendum to the public because um there are two options now I mean high school and a middle school or middle school only which one are is the board of head um we're putting both of them on the ball and we're letting the public decide what they feel that they can support it's a two question thing it's an either or either you vote for the middle school or you vote for the middle school and the high school edition okay so does that mean that the middle school is a more higher priority than the

207high school or uh the administration believes that the middle school is the highest priority Madam the the evidence uh the number of unhoused students which is students in in enrollment Beyond the capacity of the school demonstrates that need that the middle school is a higher priority there's more flexibility as Mr Goodall could certainly speak to in managing uh a slightly uh less overcrowded High School than there is in the middle school and how many I mean all the all the students in high school housed P how much do this does it cost I mean are are all the school um students in high school housed or are there any unhoused students we have unhoused students at the high school just like we have at the middle School ah correct but there with um different kinds

208of scheduling we can cope with that a lot easier than we can at the middle school there is no more room at the middle school at all okay all right thank you uh Doug poy uh for tamarak Road I live in an adult community and I'm sorry that the lady left that made a comment uh so I just wanted to clarify that uh the Board of Education made every effort possible to uh make presentations in all the adult communities uh prior to the last referendum I know they made a presentation in Regency where I live I also know they made a presentation in uh Concordia I believe and there were other communities that they may have made presentations in where I was not present but I can tell you that some communities discourage these things

209they make it very very difficult and I do not understand why they do that and I think that's an issue that needs to be addressed with the mayor they also uh do they discourage candidates for the Board of Education from Pro providing their literature within the community so that the residents of those communities don't have the information that would benefit them in terms of making an informed decision I I think this is unfortunate I don't know why the adult communities behave in that fashion but some of them do so just I want all the members of the public uh to be very clear that the Board of Education made every effort to make presentations in every Adult Community for the prior referendum uh a a suggestion this is on a totally different topic but one

210that was dealt with tonight I think it would be helpful the next time we have a presentation on the uh harassment intimidation and bullying report that there be some comparison with the prior year so that the public and the members of the board can get some sense of are we having uh essentially fewer of these incidences reported are we having more is it somewhat stable I mean we have a schoolwide program to reduce harassment intimidation bullying is that program being effective in reducing the number of those incidences I I think that would be very very helpful also uh the last gentleman spoke uh brought up this matter of unhoused students I think it's important for the public to understand what that term means so I would ask that someone on the board please explain what

211an unhoused student count actually is thank you madam uh thank you Mr Po thank you uh for clarification please don't confuse uh unhoused students with homeless students they are not the same thing by any means um unhoused students is simply students enrolled in a particular School beyond the capacity of the school that is considered an unhoused student it's an important factor and Metric that the state uses to determine eligible costs of the project and also uh the level of Debt Service Aid that they are going to provide so once again to be clear unhoused students is students enrolled in the school beyond the capacity of the building ruchii 23 green ey Street Madam president uh just an observation and a suggestion based on I've been attending these meetings for past one and a half years

212and the common perception among the people who are attending these meetings as well as people outside the politics are influencing this board decisions it is you know as a president I request you to step up and try to clear that you know board of education is the last place that I would like to have any political influences the decisions that we make should be beneficial to the students to the community and should not be driven by like political agenda uh to back up my reasoning is the way Mr Chala was neglected for the uh uh meeting I know as a president if your C team member is missing uh probably if I were you in a position probably I would have stepped up and say like you know hey one of the core Committee Member

213is missing you know you need to bring him into the into the like of meeting such event such uh such scenarios will confirm that lot of political influences are taking place on the board I request you to as a leader as a president of this board I request you to like you know clear that perception what people have this board has to be independent of political influences and I request to Chala Mr Chala please reconsider your resignation you know we need people like you to be on the board and help us out and second request um I worked for a nonprofit organization called man uh which teaches a South Indian language uh which is the fastest growing South Indian language in the United States right now looks like my uh committee or my board has

214reached out to Mr Gorski for uh using the facilities of either oakry or apple guard for running classes on Friday evenings uh when we did a comparison analysis like they were declined for multiple reasons one it is not registered um this this organization is started in California it's a nationwide organization they have a these are nonprofit organizations don't have a franchises but they do teach at local level that is one and second is the cost that we were asked to incur for running those classes were very high compared to the neighboring school districts be it south bronek or Plainsboro or west WI why is it like it's it's a nonprofit organization what it takes for the board to you know get an easy approval like you know why why do our prices are so high

215compared to other other neighboring school districts Madam yes uh to the gentleman's question um in order to have eligibility to use the school district facilities which are in great demand um because they they have a very attractive forum for outside events uh you have to be a nonprofit organization and you have to be headquartered in Monroe Township um quite often we have outside of Monroe Township headquartered organizations who claim they have a member that lives in Monro therefore they should have the entitlement of the publicly funded school system to uh uh enjoy and that is not how the policy currently is written you have to once again be a nonprofit and headquartered uh in Monroe Township um the second question is the fee structure the mon Township Board of Education does not profit off of

216the use of building fee schedule whatsoever uh with the exception of the $100 application fee but we have a full-time person who manages this so that partially offsets their salary if you want to look at it that way we had professionals uh again energy for America being one who came in and told us what hourly rates uh for utility usage is based upon each room that we were um uh considering uh uh using during use of building so uh in in in summary the Monro Township Board of Education recoups the taxpayer costs only through use of building fees and does not profit off of it so if you think it's expensive to reimburse the Board of Education you could imagine what it cost to run a school district of this size with all the facilities

217we have even my organization was ready to take up their High fees too but um the Clause that you just mentioned that the it has to be headquartered at local M Township we did not follow the same rule for other classes too like Hindi mahavidyalaya or Hindi USA why that new rule for the Hindi Hindi USA was grandfathered in because they had uh Provisions in place before the policy was changed I did not make that determination okay thank you Peter Tano 10 Katherine Street Monroe Township uh my first question is how much did uh the Boe spend on a public Rel relations firm for the referendum so far as the date you know that there was no Public Relation firm for the referendum we had uh a particular person uh come in and and facilitate

218uh who build the board of education but there was no specific firm for that purpose um have we hired any Township employees to assist with the referendum not to my knowledge no okay the answer is no okay uh my last question is if um if board president was accused of such a a heinous act why would she refuse to play audio that can exonerate her from that claim big question madam because the veracity and the full context of that recording cannot be determined that's why well who and what you have reference to is a very deceiving um uh caption that is untruthful well who makes that determination shouldn't the public have should hear that and then a determination could be made that's my opinion the public uh the public can make their own determination I

219would just suggest that anybody who wants to weigh in on this topic get all the and do your homework don't take what's being sold to you on social media well that's that's fine I I understand what you're saying to me but for the residents that are now hearing this I think that they should be able to hear the audio and then ask questions in regards to the audio so we can clear it up why why are we all why would you want us to all assume because there all the facts are not out that you didn't do anything wrong I mean that you did do something wrong wouldn't you want to hear the audio and then be able to explain it this way people get the facts and can make the right decisions this is

220not the venue for us to listen to audio tapes because it is not but with the microphone will play it I mean everybody can hear it Madam I I I don't think it's going to cause a r and we need a couple of cops to come during it but Madam you're not that's it yeah that's it um no more comment very well no comment we have no comment okay thank you anyone else somebody say good evening Chrissy scurby 21 pness Drive um through an oah request I uh received the investigation report that Mr Goodall did on the board of ed um hate packet um I just wanted to go through it um during the Monroe Township Board of Education meeting on Wednesday August 22nd 2018 the Acting Superintendent of Schools was requested to investigate circumstances

221regarding Board of Ed mail and its contents of a packet of community emails letters and police reports related to public resident number one the Board of Education members were sent bard of Ed business mail that included the packet on Friday August 17th 2018 on on August 15th 2018 Mrs Smith the board attorney was delivered a package addressed to the Monroe Township Board of Education by public resident number two the contents of the letters and emails were an attempt to influence the board board's decision not to recognize the Monroe Township Middle School Parent staff Association public resident number two collected letters emails and police reports related to public resident number one public resident number three requested police report reports through an oer request and delivered them to public resident number two public resident number two delivered

222the packet to the board of ed attorney on the morning of August 15 2018 at the August 22nd meeting Mr Ryback brought forth the packet in the discussion against the mtms PSA being approved for building use Mr Mayo wholeheartedly fought for the name of the packet organizer to remain anonymous through my own investigation speaking with people who were approached and refused to write for the packet as well as people who were involved I found out that public resident number one is myself public resident number three I found through an O request at the police department was Regina giio camini and public resident number two was Rupa seagull who was running for the Board of Education anyone else from the public wishing to speak okay at this time I was closing public forum and I while

223I did promise to read my o opening again it is in the record I am not going to do that although I will just say to the person who said I've been here too long I was reelected last year put it on the website thank you yeah good 30 years I mean it's something to be proud of I am very proud of my record I would do that thank you Mr Russo next is okay um no close session do we have I'm happy Madam board president in terms of closed session I'm happy to report there were no incidents or reporting of HIV in Monroe Township Schools so there is no uh reason to have a closed session thank you very much so then our next scheduled Board of Education meeting will be November Tuesday Tuesday

224just just notice that Tuesday November 20th 2018 7:00 p.m. at the Monroe Township High School motion to adjourn no Mr cherella Mr Ryback all in favor I opposed then at this time the meeting is adjourned

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.