001thank you good evening the meeting of the Monroe Township Board of Education will come to order please stand as our student board member leads us in the Pledge of Allegiance the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all good evening everyone at this time I'd like to make note of the passing of Miss Kathy foder who had been a 25-year employee of our food service program serving the past 19 years at the Brookside Elementary School Miss foder made a daily impact with the students and staff at Brookside and she will be dearly missed in addition to her service she is also the parent of two children who attended Monroe Township Schools at this time please join me
002for a moment of silence in memory of Kathy thank you may we have a roll call Mr Gorski Mrs armenio here Mr cherella here Mrs Deo here Mrs here Mrs Lang here Mr poori here Mr Ryback here Mrs seagull here Mr Tano here and Mr rutzky here Madame board president you have a quarum present this evening thank you in accordance with the provisions of the New Jersey open public meetings law the Monroe Township Board of Education has caused notice of this meeting to be published by having the date time and place thereof posted March 14th 2019 at all schools the home news Tribune cranberry press and filed with the clerk of the municipality thank you before we move on to the agenda I just um would like to spend a few minutes talking about the
003defeated referendum from last Tuesday and I'm sure Mr good will have something to say later on in his report I I think that we're very aware that the community does not support the new Middle School nor adding an addition onto the high school and there's been a lot of people that I've talked to in the last few days and a lot of information um that came through other other people and um questions about why or comments about why they did not support the referendum and uh a lot of what I'm going to say has already been discussed on our referendum Facebook page but I think it's important to know to to you know say this again um some of the reasons were that the schools will be overcrowded when built but there is a big
004difference between the functional capacity of a school and the operating capacity of a school and we would not have opened a capacity impact fees for developers while we all wish we had impact fees impact fees have been illegal in New Jersey since 1957 and only the legislators can change that and we have a committee that will be mentioning more on that later more than one family living in homes in Monroe we also have some information on that later we don't support a referendum in March why didn't we have it in May or June and the answer to that is the state will only give you six days during the year when you can go out for a referendum the fourth Tuesday of January the 2 Tuesday of March the 3D Tuesday of April the last
005Tuesday of September the first Tuesday in November or the second Tuesday in December December again that's a state mandate Jamesburg students coming to our high school it is not the Jamesburg students that are causing the overcrowding in the high school and they also pay tuition to go to our high school so that is not an issue it cost too much money for the board to use a PR firm the board did not use a PR firm for this referendum property taxes are too high and we understand that nobody wants to raise property taxes but until the state comes up with a new way of funding schools we are forced to use property taxes to do this so you have to contact or everybody needs to contact their legislators and let them know that we need
006a new funding for schools the board didn't advocate for fair funding we have done many things to advocate for fair funding and I think Mr Gorski you had two pages worth of information on the ways we did that we need to advocate for new formula and and we need to you know do do things to contact the State and let them know how unhappy we are the we at the beginning of this year we created a new educational advocacy committee and that that committee will be looking into suing the state and going for a new funding formula with a Township of over 44,000 residents think how Trenton would react if every one of our residents emailed our legislators every day with this request we are not suing the state the educational advocacy committee will be
007also be looking into suing the state we need to remove ourselves from the Abbot decision unfortunately this is state state supreme court ordered by the state of New Jersey they are the only ones that can change that and until they do that the money from our taxes will go continue to go to the Abbott districts the state will come in and build a school for us so I don't need to vote for it although it is possible that the state could come in and mandate the board to build a school they will never ever pay for a school in Monroe Township and the last thing is all the building going on in Monroe this was probably the biggest reason for not supporting the referendum unfortunately the board of education does not get involved with the
008planning of the community we are different governmental agencies following different regulations policies mandates our responsibility in the board of education's responsibility is to every is to educate every child coming into the school district and in the end it is our responsibility to find a place to put all of our onh housee students that currently is over 1,500 and will continue to grow so until we come up with something permanent we will continue to have to add trailers to our disc so where do we go from here at this time the board does not have another plan we went through plan a last year we went through Plan B this year so we must now reassess and develop next steps to introduce another Bond referendum into the future so we have permanent places for our children
009we have heard that the community members felt that they did not have an opportunity to provide input into the planning of how best to meet the needs of the growing student population in the school district although the board received input from the public through many ad hoc committee meetings through board meetings and a survey sent throughout the community last year that over 800 people responded to we will now once again reach out to our residents for additional input through a formal written process designed to engage the entire community on the parameters of any future referendum the steering committee will be disbanded and an ad hoc committee will be created and will consist of representatives from throughout Monro Community parents seniors yes voters no voies those who did not vote District personnel and board members anyone
010who is interested in serving on this ad hoc committee should should submit a letter of interest to the board office to my attention and should include your name address telephone number and an email address and I am asking that all letters of interest to serve on this ad hoc committee be submitted by Friday April 19th once the ad hoc committee is formed we will be asking all Monroe residents to provide their ideas their suggestions for consideration on how the Board of Education should proceed with a new referendum to meet the needs of our current and growing student population The information collected will be turned over to this new ad hoc committee who will consider all the written submissions from the community and there will be answers to every one of the questions that people ask
011every suggestion that meets the criteria will be reviewed and discussed by the ad hoc committee for educational feasibility ability it's excuse me educational feasibility ability to adequately provide for our current and growing enrollment and cost considerations following such review and discussion the chair of the ad hoc committee will report the outcome of this review to the full board and the public at a future Board of Education meeting an announcement regarding the timeline for submission of suggestions to be considered by by the ad hoc committee will be made once the ad hoc committee has been formed which will be probably towards the end of April into may as we don't want it to interfere with the superintendent search so anybody who has any questions about that process can contact myself or the board office so at
012this time we'll go to the agenda and the approval of the minutes for the special public Board of Education meeting of February 4th 2019 moved by Mr Ryback second second by Mr Mayo any additions or Corrections Miss armino um this is the special Board of Education meeting February 4th I just want to make sure where where we had school boards in yes okay I reviewed um the the written minutes and in the written minutes there's no indication of the discussions that uh any of the board members had with school boards or any of the questions um so I don't believe this is a sufficiently um comprehensive uh review of that meeting uh for instance uh there was an advertising question well let me go through the whole thing I'm sorry no go ahead did did
013you want to comment no go ahead okay uh we had a school board we had school board training recommendations that are not in here um we spoke of the V valid process we spoke of of um uh different things that school board suggested for our superintendent search that's not in here uh I asked a question at in within the hour 11544 Mr poori asked a question 11440 Mr Tano asked a question 11358 and Miss Mrs Lang asked a question on 10416 and again I think at 11141 so none of these were included in here this is supposed to be a comprehensive representation for if this is going to be an official document and we're going to sign it uh a vote on it then the in in a year from now when the public wants
014to review this it should have these kinds this kind of information in here so um I would recommend that my colleagues not vote for it until some of these things are put in because this is what people rely on if they want to um challenge the board or get information from what the board's activity has been at meetings that's the point of a public open meeting and comprehensive minutes thank you Mr Gorski yes um respectfully Mrs armeno and I seem to have a disagreement on what is reasonably comprehensive for the minutes I believe it is satisfactory as presented the the minutes are not supposed to have everybody's question and answer delineated in there it's not supposed to be a transcript or a court reporting of the meeting it's supposed to give the user of the
015minutes a reasonable picture of what occurred there and the action taken and the votes um I believe that it accomplishes that and you know if there was a suggestion to modify it in any way again I would respectfully asked that the the comments come before the board meeting where they're being approved so that we could consider it right now there's nothing we can do other than just keep the minutes we can certainly change it we can add we can add to it before it's voted on um that and I respectfully disagree with the fact that you think it's it's reasonably comprehensive it's not comprehensive at all it doesn't even make a suggestion that board members ask questions at a training seminar so it and I and I do believe that that we were challenged years
016ago as a board in the courts about comprehensive Clos minutes and and the Board of Education in Monroe lost so I think that we might want to revisit our our our a definition of reasonably comprehensive me it's not what we remember it's it's for the for the sake of the public to understand what actually went on at that meeting I Madam yes I I completely uh hear what you're saying uh the minutes previously uh per your objection were reviewed by school boards and the board attorney both of who agreed that they are meeting the state standard for minute keeping the minutes are consistent with the way other school districts keep minutes and there is a liability that the district would would take by putting in a complete transcript of every comment and and question and
017answer that occurs during deliberation that's not the purpose of minutes I am not asking for a complete transcript or verbatim I am asking for a comprehensive indication of what occurred at the meeting and I I won't if the whole board um you know o overrides my concerns that's up to each individual Madam president if I may Mr poori if if I may the the typical uh business practice in preparing minutes of the meeting is to capture the essential points of the meeting discussed uh I understand both sides of the the discussion that's going on here Mrs armeno is correct that it should capture everything that been discussed I also understand where uh Mr groski is coming from so my question is the questions that were raised by Mrs armenio the content of the question and
018the responses given by the by the person who was given the presentation if the items have been captured within the meeting minutes then the meeting minutes as presented would suffice that's um if the questions answered the answers were not part of the meeting minutes that were prepared then I agree with Mrs Armenia that they may have to go back and look at I can't recall a month and a half ago what questions have been asked what has been responded uh but I think that's the common practice I think having this kind of a discussion in front of a public is probably not the best case we should have discussed this uh before the meeting I think their time is a lot more worth than we going back and forth about meeting minutes well according to
019school boards you just you never put questions and answers you give a synopsis of what happened at the meeting so if we brought this to them I'm sure that they would agree that the what Mr grisy has forwarded to us is okay Mr Ryback um I do remember um school boards uh giving us something in writing as far as uh the minutes and it doesn't have to uh include everything that's being said but along the lines of Mrs amino's concerns that's why we videotape our board meetings because anyone who's really interested in finding out everything that's happening just has to go to the uh I want to say go to the videotape I sound like a sports cast but uh that's what they really have to do and um they'll have the information they want
020thank you madam Madam so I I think we've except that that is not an official record the official record is what we vote on M we have spent too much time right now on an approval of minutes so we're going to have uh all in favor but we're going to do this by a hand vote just to make sure that we get it right so everybody who is all in favor please raise your hand anybody opposed one abstain two three abstains recuse I'm anain I wasn't here I wasn't here so we an obain are they abstaining or recusing if they weren't here they would abstain they would abstain thank you motion passed okay so we're going to the approval of the minutes for the public Board of Education meeting of February 13th 2019 I make
021a motion to move the meeting minutes except the meeting Mr flori with any second by Mr Chella again additions or corrections to the minutes seeing none everybody who is all in favor please raise your hand opposed no oppose abstain and recuse okay the Clos session meeting of February 13 2019 some Mr Chella Mr Ryback any additions or corrections to the minutes Miss armeno yes once again um in close session they were uh not the this does not um fully explain what went on in the meeting so I will be opposing it thank you anyone else my question is we don't usually put the amounts and things like that okay no fair enough uh raise your hand if you're all in favor you in favor oh I'm sorry right oppos I am oos there you go
022one opposed abstain recuse okay at this time we will go to presentation of the support staff of the Year Dr alvic I think this Mr scano can you um join us FR I watch yes yeah yes it's the minutes my minutes good evening everyone at our last board event meeting uh we presented our staff our great staff with the district support staff member of the year unfortunately we were unable to award uh this particular recipient last month so we're here tonight uh to award it and this goes uh for the district office District support person of the year and that's miss Patricia Lee Patricia Le come on up yeah she's very nice she does a nice Jobo Happ [Applause] he next on our agenda is next on our agenda is the monthly mtea Pride presentation
023and I will turn this over to Dr El thank you so I have had the distinct pleasure of watching this program grow at Barkley Brook School um Barkley Brook School school has been working for the last five years on a steam maker program within our within the school this is providing opportunities for our students to um code learn how to actually actually code um build robots work with green screens um but ultimately it's to help them understand that it's okay to make a mistake that they may not know how to do it yet and to stretch their bubblegum brains so I'm going to turn it over to Mrs Miller Mrs madora Mrs Mahoney they're the kind of the um people who are behind this program with them I do I I'm supposed to make a
024um disclaimer on the video when M Mrs madora was vide tape for the for the video it was on Wacky Wednesday day so she wants you to ignore the clothes that she's wearing yes please do it's yes wait to see that one my name is Kristen Miller and I cheat second grade at Barkley Brook School Mrs madora our librarian sends her apologies for being unable to make it here tonight Barkley Brook School has had a schoolwide focus on growth mindset and the hour of yet we have been so proud of all the work that our students and teachers have made to build on their grit and resiliency I would like to take this opportunity to thank our principal Erin Mahoney for being front and center in this journey she has given both the teachers and
025the students tremendous support and continues to lead the way we are looking forward to even more great things to come although we do love visitors at Barkley Brook we could not bring all of you into the Barkley Brook classrooms in our steam maker lab this evening so Nicole and I thought we would bring Barkley Brook to you so please enjoy seeing our amazing students in action we're trying something new we are encouraging our students to fail to fail often and to fail magnificently we use Steam and making in our everyday curriculums to provide ample opportunities for them to experience failure in a controlled environment so they can see that failure is only the beginning we help our students to stretch their bubble gum brains in order to tackle any problem and overcome any obstacle they
026are not only learning science social studies language arts and math they are learning what to do when plan a does not succeed here's an example of what a steam lesson looks like embedded in the curriculum using only your keep planks as many as you need or as few as you think you need you're going to design a structure that is specially built for the weather conditions in your area think about what that force does whether it's high winds whether it's heavy heavy wet snow whether it's Rushing Water it's going to be challenging challenging is good right if it was too easy would your brains grow no no would you be maybe a little bit bored if it was too easy would you be done real fast yes yes this is going to take some time
027it's going to take some planning it's going to take bubble gum brain thinking while all curricular disciplines have areas in which Steam and making can be optimally inserted arguably it is the science curriculum which is the most natural fit Barkley Brook students have explored the solar system with the sky view app and mapped out the observed constellations they have taken Virtual Field Trips with Google expedition to visit celestial bodies in our universe they have hypothesized about elements of pitch and sound with 3D created instruments and then created their own while justifying material choices they made 3D art can demonstrate knowledge of symmetrical aspects of ice crystals while Kaa planks can show prior knowledge of destructive natural events watch as two students use green screen technology to bring their symbols of America research project to life
028she is is holding a tablet that that says that says July 4th in 1776 that that was America's first birthday we also use Kea planks to show what we know about features of land check out this Lighthouse and Google Expeditions is used to delve even further into the curricular unit on landforms through use of augmented reality Technologies second graders learning how nature can change the shape of land use Lego we do to both build and code a working Floodgate in order to understand more deeply the concept of controlling flood waters during the second grade around the world cultural awareness project many aspects of maker and steam activities are utilized when creating their presentations including computer coding and green screen Technologies there is so much fun to be had while trying and failing and trying again
029with math concepts in the steam maker lab we might be using doubles near doubles even an odd to make a freestanding monster or rolling the dice to find out how many blocks we need to add or subtract from our block towers at Barkley Brook Feats of engineering are all around what can't be done to tie in making into language arts units here is a Lego Story visualizer piece showing understanding of various story elements when learning about interviewing and adjectives first and second grade students also learned about designing in three dimensions with Tinker CAD they even had their finished pieces printed out and made into wearable art let's wrap this up with a green screen enhanced presentation of an all about writing piece Penguins love parades that can March for days some March for weeks and
030most March for hours they march to get to colder places so what does it all mean for far too long the trend has become to remove obstacles to make success as easy as possible for our children this lawnmower mentality has stripped our students of the resilience and coping skills necessary to truly succeed in both the academic arena and in life in general at Barkley Brook we are focusing our energies on teaching our students to become thinkers planners strategizes and perseveres we are giving them the ability to adapt and overcome in order to give them more control over their successes Steam and making afford our students the opportunity to develop this grit while simultaneously delivering quality curricular content we are so excited to see all the many ways that this will shape their lives thank you
031so much for taking time to watch we are very proud and we are open for visitors so if you would like to come visit us in action please that many of your board members already have please reach out to Mrs Mahoney or any of us and we would love to arrange that during the school day thank yeah we had an a awful um um an awesome time when we came to the maker spaces uh last year I believe yes it's yeah you're doing wonderful things over there thank you very much we all want to go back to second grade please do all right thank you thank you very much have a good night take [Applause] care okay at this time we will be going to the presentation and public hearing of the preliminary 201920 school
032budget Mr Goodall Dr alvic Mr Gorski good evening every one Welcome to our annual uh District school budget presentation uh this is one of the most important uh items that the central office Board of Education our administrators our entire School Community uh presents to ensure that we create a annual school budget that meets all of the needs of the students in our district but also considers the impact to the taxpayers in our community I'm joined here tonight by my colleagues Dr Dory alvik our assistant superintendent of schools who had an a tremendous input on the budget in developing programs and in the area of curriculum and instruction and also with me is Mr Michael Gorski our board administrator board secretary who this year as Acting Superintendent I was in lock step with Mike from the
033beginning of the development of this budget and I have a new appreci iation of what goes into creating an efficient budget and a budget that meets the needs of all of our student students so just wanted to thank Mike and thank Dory for all their hard work and efforts and putting together our budget in addition there's a lot of principles and supervisors in in the audience tonight uh what they did in doing A needs assessment of what our teachers and students need they just did a incredible job and we're limited by by a 2% cap uh so when we went back to those principles and supervisors and asked them what they could do without and foro till next year they were extremely responsible in getting back to us and putting together this great budget I
034think you're going to be very very pleased as a board of education and a community of course the Board of Education led by our leader Kathy kapano board president and our vice president Steve Ryback give the administr ation directive during the budget philosophy meeting and um we feel that uh some of the items that were identified within that budget philosophy uh as directed by the Board of Education um really came through and we are accomplished all the things that the board wanted us to do with our annual budget of course our finance committee chaired by Mr ruty keeps the administrative team on its toes and provides oversight of the district's finances they do a tremendous job in helping us give direction for the district and also our budget what do we do what do we
035here for why do we do it well our vision statement says that the Monro Township Board of Education commits itself to all children by preparing them to reach their full potential and to function in a global Society through a preeminent education we believe we have the budget to accomplish that our mission statement the Monroe Public Schools in collaboration with the members of the community shall ensure that all children receive an exemplary education by well-trained committed staff in a safe and orderly environment and we also believe this budget accomplishes that back in the fall with the help of New Jersey school boards and the District administration Board of Education uh Central Administration put together District goals that we have been reporting out on and will continue to do next month we'll report out uh another faction
036of these goals uh we wanted to in gold one in gold one to develop Innovative student programs you just saw an example of that with stem initiatives we want to continue and expand our stem initiatives K through 12 we want to continue to develop the whole child through expanding professional development cultural awareness and Community engagement we've had many activities during the course of the Year under Dr Ali's leadership expand our current UniFi program districtwide using high school students integrated with special education students K through 12 I I an I'm sorry monthly report out in my superintendent report about updates and we'll have some more information on some of the things that we're doing and the kids have been accomplishing accomplishing in our unified program and we want to develop learning opportunities for students to understand
037their civic responsibility historically as Citizens and we'll have a presentation uh at next month's board meeting as part of updating the board on how we're accomplishing that part of the goal and goal number two we wanted to expand and improve school facilities we engaged the district and Community discussions for a spring 2019 referendum using the latest enrollment and data projections and as we know we were we came up short in that goal but we look forward to looking at the next steps to make sure our kids have a great place to go to school we want to continue to develop a plan for expanded bus parking lot we know that the goal is to have a complete inhouse uh Fleet so that U you know our local drivers and people vested in our community are
038the ones uh transporting our kids so uh we continue to look for how we can uh expand the parking lot and uh increase our Fleet we wanted to develop expanded safety improvements for all district schools as we know last year uh during a CommunityWide safety meeting uh the board uh got feedback from the community about how we can improve and make sure that our schools are safe the board responded very quickly by uh putting armed officers with the help of mono Township Police and then train and dispatched our own Security offers to ensure safety at schools the second piece of that plan was to improve five of our schools that don't have uh updated vestibules to ensure school security so you'll see that as part of our budget and responding from um feedback from the
039community and with board support we've been able to put that as a plan for this coming summer and Beyond to improve those facilities goal number three was to improve management and operations continue to seek fair and Equitable state aid funding through engagement with legislators Community involvement and contributions to a new funding formula in the interest of the Monroe Township School District we at every meeting we discuss how Monroe is entitled to more state aid and how we will accomplish that so more information on that to come research search and review the administrative organizational structure to determine the administrative efficiency with recommendations we've been observing that as an administrative Team all year and we'll have recommendations for the board at the end close of the school year the board also developed uh goals with New Jersey
040school boards to evaluate and adopt a plan for enrollment growth and facility needs goal number two to encourage professional development for the board working towards new Jers school board's board certification and for individual board members the board will review the samplings of programs to decide upon programs for additional training and I know uh several board members have been attending these training sessions goal number three to engage in a superintendent search process and I know that's going to be underway soon so in summary the uh mon Township school budget for 20192020 school year was developed with specific parameters set forth by the board philosophy directive we believe this board encompasses all of these requests from the Board of Education to prepare a comprehensive budget meeting the needs of 182 projected additional students in our district construct
041security vestibules and five remaining schools and address aging facilities Mr Jerry T does an incredible job maintaining in and being proactive at all of our schools to ensure that they're in the best possible condition for teachers to teach and students to learn create budget savings through Surplus and use of reserves replace contracted bus routes with new in-house Fleet expand curriculum and Staffing that's one of the most important things that we do to develop programs to meet the needs of all of our students and to ensure that our kids are as competitive as our neighbors and competitive Statewide and globally so they can uh move on and uh have a career pathway and attend the best universities and colleges that are out there and we are doing that we want a budget to cap U utilizing
042expanded Bank cap of $600,000 to meet the needs of student growth the budget has profession been professionally constructed to afford every student an opportunity for an exemplary education by well-trained committed staff in a secure and safe environment opportunity is made available through a comprehensive curriculum which offers diverse course offerings and co-curricular clubs and activity activities we believe that our proposed budget continues to become more efficient as evidenced by a successful County budget efficiency review you whereas Monro was exemplified for many best financial practices and that's a credit to the entire central office ex especially the business office so again key budgetary considerations an increase of 182 additional students projected aging facilities Core Curriculum content area student teacher ratios or budget in increase in Staffing is running alongside those increasing student enrollment projections uh that we've
043been talking about all year you know reasonable class size makes for Effective teachers and then of course the tax impact on the community what is in the budget creation timeline establish of that budget philosophy the board directed uh the central office administration in early fall to follow a budget philosophy we look at historical enrollment patterns so we could properly staff our buildings and budget review of staffing needs budget development central office worked very closely with the building principles and our district supervisors who uh did A needs assessment with teachers and provided very responsible budget uh that we work through in order to get within the 2% cap and I just really have to again thank the building principles and the supervisors for a job well done they go through their defense rounds at times we
044have to make needed Cuts because we are limited by that 2% cap and again they respond uh very responsive responsibly in order to meet the needs of all of the students so it's it's just a a great collaborative and collegial effort by the administrative team we look forward to the governor's budget address in terms of what financial help the state might give us in terms of easing the tax burden and making the budget work uh within that 2% cap and we await our award for state aid and then we adopt a tenative budget which we're presenting tonight and we have a hearing to discuss that budget this time I'll turn it over to do alic to talk about all the great things program uh programs and curriculum that are in this budget good evening so
045at this time I always enjoy sharing with you some of our accomplishments that we did during this past um the past year as we were preparing our budget the 2018 graduation rate was 97.5% that's actually up 2% from the previous year um and we monitor the students who do not graduate remember that's a June graduation rate so some students need to take a course in the summer and they do graduate in August so we kind of work through that but that's the June graduation rate according to the New Jersey doe the 2018 graduates included 89.2% of our students going to either a two or a four-year College um 2.7% attend career or technical schools we had 1.4% students enter the military 4.9% entered the workforce 1.8% were undecided 87.3% of our students taking the AP
046test scored a three or better we had 85 805 AP tests were taken last spring and of that number 703 students scored a three or better so which is wonderful um we continue to have our um higher than the state average scores on the SAT and ACT and last June 27 seniors graduated the with the new Jersey seal of biliteracy this year we have I think we found out 19 right 19 students just passed the test to graduate this June with the New Jersey seal of biliteracy which means they are they're able to communicate in at least two languages um we're continuing to um evaluate revise our programs the only new program that is um actually in the there two new additions to our budget for this year one of them is a new science
047resource a new science textbook for K to5 students that is in our in our budget um and the other is a civics class that we will be implementing as a half-year course in the seventh grade for all students next year at our Middle School we are continually using data to assess our students to assess our programs to see what we need to include um and one of those ways that we're doing that is through the map assessment U measures of academic progress we implemented that k28 um 3 years ago this year we've implemented it 9th through 11th grade so we're starting to use that data at the high school level we also utilize the um dr2 which is the developmental reading assessment K through five and some in the middle school we continuously um offer
048professional development to all of our staff one way we're able to keep the cost down on that is we train our teachers and our staff members to be the trainers so we're not sending a lot of people out for outof district workshops which are a lot more expensive we use our trainers or we bring people into the district so we're able to save some money that way um we do offer professional memberships some of our teachers such as our music teachers or our band teachers must have professional memberships in order to take our students to all of the wonderful um competitions and programs that they have so we maintain those memberships we're also continuing continuously growing the AVID program at our middle and high school and next school year year we will be looking to
049Pilot it at the Woodland Elementary School utilizing title funds it's a little bit different at the elementary level Middle School you've heard there's an elective class students take the elective class in place of um one of their other electives they're in a cohort they're identified they have to apply for the program at the elementary school it's a little different it's more that we train all of the teachers and all of the best practices best strategies from Avid so that all of the students at the elementary school um can take advantage of the the um strategies that are offered so we're going to start piloting that next year at the Woodland School and see how that kind of goes um as well as all of the programs that you'll see here pictured um in our program
050we are also having um we've added 32 new staff members to the budget for next year that is primarily teachers there is no new administrative staff in this budget um we recognize the need that we have student students coming to our district and we have to make sure that we have a the certified teachers in front of the classroom so there are 34 new staff members these include an Elementary art teacher I'm not going to go through every single one of them um a um several teachers at the high school including family and consumer science business and math um five new Middle School teachers a PE teacher three new um self-contained teachers for our special education population and several Power professionals two new drivers and um a social worker and a guidance counsel for our
051Middle School that that includes some of them but it's 3 32 staff members no new Administration so some of the programs you see all of our um wonderful things that are happening in our schools we're expanding our school Gardens at all of our elementary schools we continuously Implement uh technology throughout our schools seal stands for social emotional learning that's all of the work that that the the schools are doing with character education and also the whole child committee and the work that they're doing um project unified is continuing to expand we are moving it down into the elementary and the Middle School level um Mrs Dyan is working with the administrators at the middle school and all the elementary schools where we have self-contained classes and we're implementing um different programs in the schools depending
052on the students I'm not going to take your report Patty but Patty will have something else to share about our project unified soccer team later on in the meeting um we continuously offer programs for our students such as our award-winning music programs our extracurricular clubs at the middle and high school we offer geography bees spelling bees math counts competitions there's lots of things going on in all of our schools all the time within this budget again we um you you heard already tonight about the Barkley Brook stem and maker space but there are maker spaces in all of our elementary schools Media Center our media center at the middle school and here at the high school and they are continuously used by students um improving our uh Robotics and our engineering program using Project Lead
053the Way we're also offering to our students the um a certification in Auto auto RI Auto rivet Autodesk rivet yes and Autodesk um ventor so our students at the high school level in some of these classes will be able to take that that certification with them outside of the outside of school similar to the Seal of biliteracy Education uh certification um as Mr Goodall mentioned we are adding school security vestibules in five of our schools that do not have the double locked entrance so those will be added within this budget um that's just another way that we're trying to secure our buildings our portable classroom units we still will need to pay the rent on the portable classroom units at the middle school that will be ongoing we do not have additional portable classroom units
054in this budget however for the 2021 school year we absolutely will need more trailers based on our students um we have a transportation Fleet expansion we are getting nine new 54 passenger buses eight of those are required because those buses are aging out one of them is an additional U um an additional 54 passenger bus we're also getting two two new Vans one is for an aging 25 passenger van the other van is an additional van again that's to help bring back some of the um routes that are out of District to bring them back back into District so we're we're trying to grow that as um fiscally responsibly as we [Music] can and that's where you see the information about that um I mentioned the the security vestibules there were also looking to upgrade
055our lobby guard system which is our screening system for any of our visitors coming in from out of out um outside so that will we will be looking to do that adding additional security cameras and we're also looking to replace the wood flooring on the high school bleachers in the football stadium um with aluminum and that is due to um a recommendation from the engineer that we have every year that um that looks at all of our our facilities and that's a recommendation that came from him so we need to do that and include that in this budget now I'll turn it over to Mr Gorski thank you Doctor good evening everyone thanks for coming to the budget presentation where does the money come from the budget is defined by revenues that that determines the
056size of the budget and this particular pie chart is going to win no fans in this audience this shows that state a Aid is less than 5% of the overall budget federal aid is less than 1% we're a public school district and that's all the entitlement we have to state and federal aid the majority of the budget is mandated and and by the state however fund balance which is savings from prior year budgets makes up almost 4% of the budget transfers from other funds is a little less than 1% and we'll go through that a little later local taxes is 86% of the revenue sources that support the school district tuition from Jamesburg or receiving school district is a little less than 4% transportation fees miscellaneous Revenue uh account for about a half a percent
057so that's where the monies come from and that defines the size of our budget so when you heard Mr goodle talk about the constrictions of being a cap it cap is a calculation that comes into how much we can grow the general fund tax levy every year and here's some facts on Monroe state aid there are two types of state aid and we'll get more into this in a moment Equalization Aid is the largest type of state aid if you look at some of our surrounding school districts like South Brunswick you could go to their website and pull up their userfriendly budget and you'll see their revenue categories for state aid they get over $20 million in Equalization Aid Monroe has never received any Equalization Aid is designed to support a District's adequacy budget and
058the state uh formula determines how much of this Equalization Aid you get from your award where districts have high income levels from your New Jersey 1040s that's that four-digit code that you may be familiar with from filing your taxes and also your property rable base which is how the property taxes are assessed those two factors are key in the determination of how much Equalization Aid you can get now we've contended over the years that every child should get some minimum amount of Equalization Aid factored into this calculation we receive zero so to make to finance an adequate budget it's on the backs of the Monroe taxpayers the other type of Aid that we qualify for is called categorical Aid and like the name uh describes there are different categories that you qualify for in this
059category special education Aid uh Transportation Aid security Aid are a few of them and we'll get to some of the details on that in a moment our transportation department by the way is the highest efficiently rated transportation department in the county and among among the highest in the state and that is why half of our categorical Aid is in the form of transportation Aid and again total state aid is less than 5% of total revenues one of the lowest state aid per pupil ratios in the county this is a a comparison of our general fund state aid and uh I would I would describe this as a what's known in the business field as a deadcat bounce last year we received $5.3 million of Aid this year we're slightly off the bottom with a 12%
060increase that sounds bigger than it is it's a little more than $600,000 of additional state aid now S2 which is part of the school funding uh formula uh adjusting it is a framework to take districts to full funding over the next five years and Monroe is on the pathway to full funding but I contend that even fully funded our district will only get an additional $3 million above where we are now and we will not be satisfied as a community until we receive a new funding formula so we had to go and look at additional Revenue sources because taxes are growing uh up to the cap amount where else can you meet the needs of of 186 new students aging facilities a million dollars required for school vestibule projects new curriculum editions new textbooks new
061buses uh Etc fortunately the board created a very successful Falcon care and early childhood enrichment program these are proprietary programs that operate as business models not like the general fund School District which is designed to break even every year the uh the Falcon care and ECE is a uh a profit source and every year has earned between five and $600,000 the funds have earned 1.6 million in their first three years of of inception and the board is able to transfer $600,000 of of retained earnings which is unrestricted to the general fund to offset some of the cost of growth and to keep taxes down $400,000 is recommended to be transferred from the the iPad Insurance Fund this is as per board policy where a collection of money is raised by students to uh pay for
062insurance for the iPads uh damages and claims have been down and and the Surplus in this fund was designed to help the refreshment which the least payment for the iPads is in this year's budget so that's a that's a uh a prudent offset of that cost and fortunately um as we presented with the district fin uh comprehensive annual financial report we are experiencing uh near full employment right now and our unemployment compensation fund which is self-funded has a surplus which Administration feels comfortable in in reclaiming $200,000 that was transferred into this fund back in 2008 so you could say we're looking under every cushion to to help meet the obl ations of growth and um facilities there were handouts up front and we're going to post all of this information on our website the first
063one labeled a shows a comparative sources of revenue in too much detail to put on a PowerPoint slide but we want you to see where every penny comes from what's noteworthy here is our general fund balance that carries over from prior year budgets has depl completed this year by about a million dollar that means we're living off of savings a little bit to finance this year's budget that is not a good fiscal practice but it's one that doesn't raise too much alarm because we still have a decent fund balance to carry over we talked about transfers from other fund thank goodness we have the um Falcon care ECE program that has been a cash cow generating money uh every year via board resolution to help offset the budget iPad renewal uh capital reserve local taxes
064is 85% of the budget it it is growing to the maximum capped amount and utilizing $600,000 of Bank cap as per the board's budget philosophy directive other Revenue consists of tuition transportation fees and miscellaneous Revenue state aid all the different categories are delineated and federal aid total revenues are 135,50 for all funds it is a 2.96% increase to the total budget for All funds general fund special Revenue fund Debt Service fund the next uh sheet is B and touched on this moment ago B is the historical chart of state aid from 2008 2009 school year to present and you could see that our state aid has been fairly linear during this whole period of time despite the district picking up over 1,800 students we are on a pathway to full funding where in the next
065five years we are entitled to $3 million more but that's dependent upon State revenues and again we're very proud of the transportation Aid that we earned here by being the most efficient Transportation Fleet in the county and among the highest in the state by running a four tier system where we have the same bus and bus driver on the road serving all of the schools instead of doing individual routes and going back to the yard the next packet is stap together is is uh letter C this is all of the Appropriations for all funds for next year it covers all of the general fund programs the special education programs um The Debt Service fund which pays principal and interest on the outstanding bonds 85% of the Appropriations are fixed meaning they're contractually driven by labor
066agreements uh that also includes health insurance which is one of our largest items in the budget it is approxim L A $24 million account one which my office and I take particular interest in uh negotiating as low as possible every year and um we have a rather unfortunate claims history in Monroe we have a 90% loss ratio which is kind of like if your your automobile it would be akin to uh having a bad crash history okay when you run up claims your premium go up and that's how health insurance works with us um because of that Horizon came out and gave us a written proposal for a 10% increase in premiums that's unaffordable and it will not fit in this budget so that gra gave us great anxiety and a challenge we went and
067met with other health insurance carriers and we got competitive quotes but we were not going to present to the board a competitive quote that may have been uh advantageous without a rate lock for year two because we didn't want a teaser rate and disrupt everybody's current um health insurance for such a practice from 10% we negotiated it down to 5.4 and we still weren't satisfied and it ended at a very favorable 4.8% increase our average over the last few years is under 5% and that is a fiscal best practice for this District we have a very rich um benefits package that we all enjoy and um and uh through this process of of negotiations with our broker uh with our HR Director with my accounting supervisor myself we twist Horizon's arm until they Buckle every
068year will this continue next year I can't say we'll give it our best shot every year there may be a year where I have to recommend a changing carrier to the board but this is not one of them budgets are driven by student enrollment the question came up a few years ago how come you can't produce a budget that's flat in taxes or even give us a tax reduction private companies can do that private companies don't have variable costs going up as much as our enrollment has over the last seven years we picked up 910 students a 15% increase it's even more dramatic if you look slightly back further than that and uh as Dr alvik pointed out this drives the amount of teachers that we need in this budget the amount of bus drivers
069that are required to be uh employed security guards uh we also have a new technology staff member because of the needs of the district these all went through defense rounds and are consistent with the board's goals and um policies and where does the money go this pipe chart which again was put on our website shows 52% is directly spent on educational programs as meeting the state's definition of instructional categories however I contend that transportation of students and benefits which is largely for educational staff members if included in that number would boost it over 60% the money goes and stays in the classroom Athletics co-curricular is about 1.3% Debt Service about 9% we don't have uh any play in that that's all based on prior amortization schedules administrations 2.8% capital projects are less than 1% grants
0701% and uh transportations about 6% the money does not go to administrative costs from the latest taxpayer guide to educ ational spending and if anybody uh would like to familiarize themselves with that document it's produced by the Department of Education you simply Google the New Jersey taxpayer guide educational spending the latest one out is for 2018 and it shows that the state median for administrative costs for a district that is K to2 3500 plus students which we are in that category is $1,674 per student the state average is $1,619 per student Monroe's is $1,555 we are very proud of our administrative costs and uh we compare very favorably in any state comparative metric the Appropriations detail I talked about before you will see a lot of account decreases in there Monroe starts with a zerob
071based budget which if you're not familiar with the term it means that we don't just P 2% 3% on last year's budget number and hand that out that's common in school districts we don't do that here we we uh wipe this the Blackboard clean and start over every year by going into the supply cabinets seeking how much inventory is on hand how many students are coming next year what your actual needs are what mandates are required and each department and each School builds their own zerob based budget from scratch and they go through a a rigorous round of Defense with the superintendent assistant superintendent and I to make sure that all those Appropriations are consistent with board goals and District goals we are confident that this year they are and soon we will post the
072userfriendly budget for this year's budget once adopted tonight we are very proud of the cost savings from shared services these are how we remain so efficient of an operation Food Service program applies for USDA government Commodities these are no cost Commodities that we that Mrs mitac food service director and I have to go through a lengthy application process to get but we get um non- perishable goods and some perishable Goods delivered in Secure trucks that meet the standard for delivery from the government and that saves us200 ,000 in cost of goods sold for food products that's why our our lunch prices here are among the lowest in the county technology Services we have interlocal service agreements with the municipality that share the costs of the Motorola radio system and 911 system we save $55,000 a
073year eate educational rate program which creates reimbursements for technology and telecommunication costs we uh participate in that and we save $125,000 we also have interlocal service agreements with the municipality to share TV hosting Services where we save $50,000 as if we had to go it on our own professional staff and development Dr alvik does a fine job incorporating uh the development of curriculum with uh input from Jamesburg our our receiving school district and that saves us $7,500 um as I mentioned the district is very proud of one of our best fiscal practices which is the development of two spectacular programs Falcon care and early childhood enrichment where we've made over $1.6 million in the last three years unrestricted money to help keep taxes down and meet the needs of growth the district shared $1 million
074of additional state aid Award with the taxpayers in lie of appropriating it last year we received $1.6 million of additional state aid after last year's budget was set and this board resolved to send 1 million Back Against The Levy and put 600,000 to meet the needs of Aging facilities we also have solar Renewal Energy credits of $30,000 a year oak tree has solar panels that generate electricity and we sell it back to the utility company for 30 grand and use a building policy um raises about $120,000 purchasing we have an interlocal services agreement with the municipality uh regarding the refurbishing of our tennis courts that saved the district $300,000 previously that agreement's in place for the next few years we have a Cooperative purchasing system for the procurement of everything that's considered a supply item
075and many other goods and services we've saved over $4 million since joining that program just in supplies as compared to if we bought it through bid or state contract this year we're expecting 350 000 in savings and that's from the Consortium we recycle everything we can we make $155,000 from that transportation services one of the reasons that we're so efficient is our directors constantly on the phone with other school districts trying to share routes with them where we may be uh sending students to the same private schools we save about $100,000 a year through Transportation joint jues we have an interlocal agreement that was just established with the the fire department for the use of diesel fuel pumps it's budgeted that's going to save $1,000 in for the district we participate in New Jersey School
076Board Association Insurance Group Eric North every year we entitled to a safety Grant um this year is 3978 workers compensation policy through New Jersey school board Insurance Group versus New Jersey uh crib rates $471,000 savings was saved just in workers comp this year and finally I mentioned we're very proud of the negotiation of a 4.8% increase in health insurance rates from an initial 10% with Horizon and that's not so easy Horizon is a monopoly that controls 70% of the marketplace in New Jersey and it's very difficult to get that kind of success what factors influence the tax rate number one is state aid the Monroe has the second lowest taxes in the county however our amount of state aid is is very unattractive compared to other school districts that are slightly less affluent and with
077less property wealth than we are if we had more state aid like for example if I had the award from South Brunswick we would be looking at a head spending reduction in taxes in this year's budget despite all of the new appropriation ations number two is fund balance this is something we can control superintendent has put down in January a a non-essential purchase order freeze where um quite frankly if anything hasn't been purchased for use in schools by January you probably don't need it or can forego it until next year and um that believe it or not saves about $900,000 a year ratables are a big factor in controlling the tax my first year as business administrator we had an unprecedented $71 million drop in ratables which caused approximately a 5cent increase in the budget
078without additional appropriations of a dollar ratables are the property valuations through town that share the levy so the more homes in in Monroe's case that are built there are more homeowners sharing in the levy so everybody's individual rate is suppressed this year ratables grew 2% compared to last year that is very favorable and increased student enrollment certainly has an effect on Appropriations it's a variable cost and an important one and here's how everything pans out for this year we've given you four years of History here because every one of those preceding four years is extremely attractive in my opinion my predecessor said if you roll out a budget mic and you're at 7 cents or less it's a winner and what you could see here is 17 we went up three and a. half cents
079less than a Cent and 18 1.7 cents last year 2.1 cents increase this year for an average assessed home at approximately $315,000 that is a tax increase in the 1920s budget of school taxes for $688 and unlike our budget presentation that is not on a assessment of a $100,000 increment that is based on an average assessed home at 315,000 to give a better Fair picture of what the school tax increase will be considering all of the new mandates programs facility needs curriculum needs uh that this District faces I want to thank everybody who'll contribute to this budget especially many of the folks at the back table thank you Mr Gorski so we feel we thank you that sounds very well received thank you again to everyone who helped put this budget together and we feel
080it's very efficient it's very resp responsible but is also creative and Innovative to meet all of our uh students needs so thank you very [Applause] much you're wel you're okay Madam board president if it pleases the board I would like to uh read a resolution for the adoption of the tenative budget for years 1920 okay it is recommended to the Monroe Township Board of Education that the 19 20 tenative general fund budget be adopted in the amount of 122,123 666 an ATT tenative general fund local tax levy in the amount of$ 104 m788 1898 an ATT tenative special Revenue Fund in the amount of $1,231 733 an ATT tenative Debt Service budget in the amount of 11,687 $76 and a tenative Debt Service Levy in the amount of 11,182 375 whereby the tenant of 1920
081budget totals $135,200 475 and whereas the Mona Township Board of Education has been notified of state aid amounts and whereas such state aid amounts are for the 1920 year categorical special education a Aid $3,587 something4 and for the 1920 categorical security Aid is $3,764 and the 1920 categorical Transportation Aid is $2,753 199 and the 1920 Debt Service Aid is $425,900 and for the 1920 year the estimated extraordinary Aid is$ 350,677 and whereas policy number 6471 and njac 6A colon 23A d7.3 provides that the Board of Education shall establish in the annual school budget a maximum expenditure amount that may be allotted for travel and expense reimbursement for the 1920 school year now therefore be it resolved that the Mony Township Board of Education hereby establishes the school district travel maximum for the 1920 school year
082at the tenant of sum of $158,400 and be it further resolved that the school business administrator shall track and record these costs to ensure that the maximum amount is not exceeded and be it further resolved that as recommended by the board's budget philosophy resolution that the board transfers $600,000 of retain earnings from the proprietary Falcon care fund as a revenue Source in the 1920 general fund budget and that the board transfer $400,000 from the iPad Insurance Fund Surplus as a revenue Source in the 1920 general fund budget and that the board transferred $200,000 from the unemployment compensation fund Surplus as a revenue Source in the 1920 general fund budget whereas due to consistent student enrollment and growth and facility needs and other priorities set forth in the board's budget philosophy resolution the board is budgeting
083to maximum spending Authority including $600,000 of Bank cap now therefore let it be resolved that the Acting Superintendent of Schools and the business administrative board secretary file all the required documents with the executive county superintendent so move Mr Chella Mr Ryback are there any comments questions for Mr Gorski or anybody else on Mr tiella yes I I'm going to I'm going to support this budget um there's a couple things in here though that I just wanted to mention uh and I think that I think are pretty important you know so first is the the importance of our own Fleet and and uh you know the transition that transition that we're making so uh what I've been told is that we're about we're at about 85% of our own Fleet at this point I just I
084I just want to just keep impressing upon this board the importance of us moving toward uh as close to 100% as possible because we vet our own bus drivers uh Kathy McDonald does a very good job of overseeing the program making sure it's properly staffed making sure that the the the background checks are done and then and then the everyday management of not only the routes but of our of our team and I think that we don't get that same benefit by Outsourcing so uh we we have to keep moving in that direction now what scares me though is that we're you know we're we're going to have trailers next year um obviously the ones at the middle school but we're probably going to end up with trailers here at the high school as well
085and uh my my fear and and hopefully uh Mr Gori speak to it a little bit is just that without the $600,000 in Bank cap next year and um with the you know with the need for the trailers the referendum didn't pass uh do we foresee see any cuts for the for the next budget and I know this is too soon we haven't gone through that yet but it it it does worry me that we're heading in that direction at this point and um the the one thing that I will say with regards to that is that we we SP we send approximately and you can correct me if I'm wrong $40 million to Trent every year we get back about $5 million uh from Trenton in Aid and basically on $135 million budget it
086really means we still self fund and uh and that's a crime uh we're our our our taxpayers are being wrong we all are I I'm going to you know I I don't want to go all over the place I'd like to just have those things addressed but I will say to Mr POI who and I wish him lock in the new in his you know with his committee but um if it we really need to look toward and actually have some action with suing the state whether it you know what I don't we we we want you were on the committee on our Fair funding committee we looked at a number of different things that we might be able to go after I think that we just need to take the gloves off and go
087after them and uh and and and just do what we have to do so if if if that's going to be the direction of that committee I'm on board 100% with with with helping you the way you helped us uh you know and I'll leave it at that but that's it thank [Applause] you so to to to clarify what Mr cherella is saying the the money in the budget for the trailers for next year are the current trailers at middle SEC the Middle School yes as Dr alvic um and Mr Goodall and I presented there are no additional trailers budgeted for in the 1920 budget we still have the current rent payment for the ones that are in front of the Middle School however for the next year which is going to be 2021s budget
088it is projected that there will be a material increase in the budget for trailer lease payments now uh where you have a capped budget and you have an additional appropriation requirement for trailer rental that has to come from the general fund budget unlike principal and interest for a new school which would come from a separate Debt Service fund it will have to um be uh budgeted for and it will inherently supplant existing programs and services to which extent we don't know because we haven't studied how many exactly we're going to need yet but um Dr alvik Mr Goodall and I presented to the communities on our on our vast tour of the bond referendum presentations that trailers are the greatest fiscal threat to this district and unfortunately that is uh causing anxiety right now as
089it is not in the 1920 budget but in 2021 which will be here soon thank you anyone Mr POI Kathy um thank you first of all thank you very much Ken for wishing me but you're not wishing me you're wishing the entire Community because although I'm chairing the committee I'm just being a representative and hoping that a lot of more people would join this and I'll give my report later on uh am I to believe that although the referendum failed we will not be putting any new trailers in the year 20 either at the middle or the high school and the reason for asking the question is I know that we looked at the budget first of all I want to congratulate uh Mr groski and and the superent everybody involved in doing the budget
090having been to a few of these and looking at the actual size of the budget I think that's the book that you have Mike in front of you that's the actual size of the uh the budget for 20 2020 thank you very much for doing that and thanks for your efforts so my question is we have done that before the referendum failed on Tuesday so does the budget remain the same for 2019 2020 fiscal year Madam yes uh it was incumbent upon Dr alvic Mr tag Mr Goodall and I to meet with the principles at the uh beginning process of the construction of the 1920 budget and project student enrollment growth facility limitations and the need for trailers it was a consensus of all the principles supervisors and administrators that we do not need additional
091trailers Beyond what's deployed already at the middle school for the next budget year which is 1920 however for 2021 there was a strong indication that there will be trailers needed perhaps at more than one site and we have to study this yet and they are going to be costly and they're going to have to um supplant existing programs and services and Appropriations in a Capp budget and it's going to be a challenge in order to fit that and jam those costs into the budget anyone Mr Rybeck yes I just like to um thank Mr Chella for his comments and certainly like to say I support them can spot on um Andy I certainly wish you the the best uh the whole committee I know how motivated we all are on this but uh I just
092want to say as to the budget uh I congratulate certainly Mr Gorski is team and superintendent Dr alic for all their work Kathy was always great working with you on this I know we're involved with it but I I just want to mention I know how hard you worked Mike on the health uh issue and the health insurance issue and um you know it it would it would have been a totally different story uh if you weren't leading to charge on those negotiations there so thank you uh it was it made a big difference thank you madam yes Mr G pleasure uh certainly you know don't mean to toot my own horn but had we settled for something in the middle between 10% and the 4.8 which where we we ended up I would have
093to have a serious conversation with Mr Goodall and say that the board's budget philosophy directive of the security vestibule projects which are approximately a million dollars for five schools and 32 new staff um is an impossibility because it just won't fit in the cap fortunately we never had to have that conversation but the concern remains in the future anyone else I I just like to add i' just like to add that uh I think it's it's very commendable that this this school district kept its promises uh to the parents of all the students about safety um I'm glad that we added that into our budget for the vestibules and um our security guards because we we uh we saw huge huge outcry uh for that after the tragedies that happened in Florida and uh i'
094just like to commend everybody for keeping promises thank you thank you any Miss armano yes um so this budget is a preliminary budget right there could be discussions about reviewing some of the things in the budget is that correct there could be changes between now and the final budget in April okay um when we were at the finance meeting I had um made a few comments about some uh some projected new clubs or uh some other things and while they are minimal uh impact on the budget uh especially now after the referendum passed uh failed two years in a row um I would think that it would be prudent of us as a board to review some things that are nonacademic um and and go over a few things and maybe show a little bit
095of consideration for the concerns of some of our stakeholders and maybe eliminate um some again non-essential nonacademic uh programs that we might have wanted to uh put into play so I would ask that we would consider that going forward before we have the final budget U but I do have a question about um uh something that was said U Mr Gorski said that uh Monroe is the second lowest property taxes in the county is that the municipal budget or is that our whole overall budget it's combined actually it's combined combined so with with the increase in taxes for all of our uh enrollment it's we're still the lowest in the second lowest in the county that is correct okay um the a the only thing that I'm I'm concerned about um with resolutions going forward
096about state state aid is we are impacted most generally uh on the local level on the construction level things that are going on so as we approach the state which we've tried to do for 17 years to no avail I would also ask that we consider approaching uh the township and and speaking to them about the kinds of con the rapid construction that is compelling us and necessitating uh the construction of new schools which we we desperately need and I'm sorry that uh twice the budget has uh the referendums have failed but I think um we need to listen to the concerns and fears of the people um maybe somewhat um misplaced uh by and and uh voting down the referendum but there are fears and concerns nevertheless and I think if we want to
097uh address uh these issues with the our state officials I think we also have to be um responsible for addressing it with our local officials because that is where the construction issues are coming from that is where the overwhelming um necessity for uh constructing uh schools in Monroe is coming from um so I I think that we need to take a look at the budget a few things in the budget to show at least a some humility and concern for what the stakeholders have have told us and and it's not just these last two referendums it's been years and years and years and I think that we've been hearing what people have been saying but we really haven't been listening so I think as a as [Applause] a um so I again I think as
098a respectful re-evaluation of some of the non-essential things that we have in the budget yes we want a Cadillac Community uh Monroe has has served uh its Community well and it's students well but there are some things in here again minor costs but uh costs nonetheless that we should reconsider for the before we um solidify this budget thank you thank you anyone else comments Mr Ryback I just have one thing to say so looks like you know I have a little disputes uh here and there but um this is just wording and I understand where you're coming from and I just want to clarify one thing at least for me um I know the um de feat of the referendum is going to be difficult uh on uh certainly the 2020 21 budget it seems
099something's going to have to go I just be cautious about using nonessential uh and and non-academic to me not everything that's nonacademic is not if it's not if it's non academic it could still be essential there are a lot of children that um certainly benefit from non-academic courses uh so I'd be careful about you know making them uh they're not really um equal I guess I I'd like to clarify um I am definitely not talking about any courses um in fact uh after the uh referendum went down I was a little dismayed to hear some um and and and it may have been just the Heat of the Moment but some administrators talking about taking away um uh AP courses or taking away certain uh electives and things like that that is that is definitely
100not um my position I don't believe we as a board or or as Administration there should be any punitive responses to this uh referendum failing um and there should and there should be no like response in the negative it's but there are times that we and I and again I might not have the right word but there there may be times that we uh have some things in our budget that we really can do without that's fine so I I definitely was dismayed that there were some seemingly punitive uh responses to the the bud the referendum going down and I would definitely not like to hear that Mr arm respectfully um during our referendum presentations the administrative team um spoke about the impact the trailers would have on our general operating budget and we talked
101about uh if the situation compounded year toe and the more money we took out of that General operating budget in fact as part of our presentation we spoke about um the inability of the administration and the teachers to provide a lot of our programs that we've added since we eliminated the uh trailers the first time through referendum a successful referendum and buildings opening um just to clarify I I don't recall and I was there too when the referendum went down any administrator making any comments uh about eliminating essential programs of the success of the kids um we did mention it during um our presentations as uh you know the inability to hire teachers um the reduction of some programs um because there are some of our AP courses are not mandated so some things would
102be on the table but I just wanted to clarify that because the administrative team worked very very hard to pass this referendum and certainly you know we have to be realists about um what our next steps are and if we have to lease trailers but certainly we didn't put it out there that um we would come in any vindictive uh nature or take it out on the kids because the referendum didn't pass and I I I just felt it was important to I certainly hope so um Mr grisy I think I asked this question every year but if we were to cut one cent from the tax rate how much does that equal a penny is approximately $1.6 million so that would mean if if we needed to cut a penny out of the tax
103rate we'd have to to find $1.6 million in the operating budget to to cut yeah that we have a large Penny valuation here based upon the ratables and the reeval that happened years ago and it's approximately 1.6 million dollar to reduce it by a penny Okay Madame President or we could get $1.6 million in additional aid from the state if we got 1.6 that would be wonderful then we could cut a penny out of the budget yeah does any other board member have any comments or questions okay then this time I'm going to open it up to the public if anybody has any comments to make in regard to just the budget please come to the microphone state your name and address for the record and we will adhere to our 4minute timeline thank you
104very much Madame President yes Mr poori I think we have a motion on the table I know but this is a public this is part of the public um participation thanks for the budget okay thank you very much again U you know as Mr gski mentioned we got $600,000 or from the state funding increase now we were also discussing outside the thoughts how we can sue the government because that that's what we want to be winners if you sue so please consider this sue the state for not fully funding they as per the formula they say the formula is constitutional so they didn't fund fully for LA from 2008 to 2018 so you're talking about $55 million there then they are not going to fund us fully for next 5 years so neither you are
105talking about 5 to 10 million so we have think over it we have a chance to sue because because the state itself is not following the Constitutional formula to fund us okay so lakeood has been very powerful they went and sued even they didn't get full funding for the special education and transportation and we have been saying that we are not getting full funding for the special education so first item is Sue them they didn't fund us for last 10 years they're not funding us fully for next 5 years then like Lakewood let us go and sue them they're not giving funding us adequately for special education and transportation and Lakewood got 15 million more so this is the thought process please consider it okay we are all in the same board and second thing
106is as referendum is mentioned every parent is we are not happy about we all are not happy so is no blaming game here how we can think and solve the problem the one thing is from last two years you all have saying that if the referendum fails twice we can ask state to intervene the state intervenes and builds a very lousy or whatever the term is say not a good school but you know in per Amo the state is building 125 $1 130 million they paying to build a state ofth Art School so we can tell okay interven come and build state of the art school here so we need not to worry about this vote no no SES so let the state come let them build it state of the art will Lobby for
107it so the process starts working so let's start go and tell the state come and intervene okay so that is my request thank you please consider this president Madam okay Anthony preso a question way Michael can you tell me when I have one minute left please um on the budget presentation it says continue to develop whole child expanding cultural awareness did you know that Governor Murphy signed into law a cultural awareness mandate in January 4 disability gay and lesbian transgender cultural awareness mandate did you know that yes okay where's this money coming from when you make this class and it's mandated did you know that they added disability in order to pass that mandate so this social awareness thing is being taken away from our special needs children it's going to come out of the
108budget for special needs that's why they put disability there okay that's one and I think that's very unfair but it is what it is maybe as far as our accomplishments that you mentioned that's great in 2018 we did a lot of accomplishments and that's a great thing but Dr kak was our Superintendent at that time and we accomplished a lot and you let him go not only did you let him go it cost you to let him go so that's the accomplishments that you made okay also maybe it's time now that the referendum failed twice why don't you get Linda Greenstein D'Angelo and Benson to come over here and start talking it's saying hey wait all the voters that voted for us for the last 10 years they need our help what do they under
109Iraq now you don't hear from them that they haven't been here they got elected and they're gone even Bonnie Coleman said something the last time she was here about our president has not taking care of our education system but this is what's going on they don't want to fight for us you should get them here thank you [Applause] hi good evening um my name is Gail depay I'm a new Resident to Monroe and I live in Rossmore Village um first I I was at one of your presentations for the referendum with the League of Women Voters and I have to say you did a great job putting this referendum together I've been in your I've been where you people are sitting right now for 18 years in a pre in another district and to have
110it fall down after all that you did is horrible uh I went out and talked to as many I I don't want to say I'm a senior are you do you have a question in regard to the budget yeah I'm talking about the budget and but when you were talking about the referendum I just want to commend you on that but the budget and the stuff that you want to do with the state I think you cannot do it just with Monroe I think you have to go out to the surrounding districts in your area that are of equal pupil population and equal problems of course it's not South Brunswick but I know North Brunswick has that problem and a couple other ones get not yourself but a bunch of of the districts together then
111go after the state then go after your representatives and then you I think you'll make a mark on something I mean with with presidential with the votes forget it she's she's a waste but you have to realize more power if you go out to your surrounding districts exactly what you guys said at your presentation on the referendum and now with your budget you you can't keep putting it back on yourself all the time you've got to really worry about your children but so do a lot of other districts in this state there needs to be changed the way our state schools are fulfilled and budget they have nothing to say to us because they don't give us anything so you need to go after them I'll be there to help you if you need help
112I'll be glad to be on the committee to go after the state to give everybody the appropriate amount of money that they deserve for all the work that you do thank you thank you uh Doug PO for tamarak Road uh I have specific questions about the budget I noticed under the uh expenditure listing uh there's a new library staff being added uh I was wondering if Dr alage could uh elaborate on that um so that's one of the questions and I I couldn't find uh where the cost of the trailers for The Middle School uh is reflected in these documents so if you could also elaborate on that Mr Gorski that would be appreciated and and uh some years ago the teachers uh started contributing to the cost of their health care um once again
113I don't know if if that contribution by the teachers is reflected as a uh Revenue Source or I I don't know how that's reflected in these documents that that you provided for us so those are my three questions uh why the need for an additional librarian um the cost of of the portable classroom trailers where is that reflected in the budget uh because we are we understand that it is supposed to impact the operating budget and then finally uh where would we find uh if they are continued to do that the contributions of the teacher toward their healthc CARE program thank you Dr Ali do you have uh okay so every year I meet with the Elementary School principles and we take before we even start the budget process we take a look at our
114enrollment and the number of class sections we have at each school um and make sure our class sizes are Equitable across all of the schools across the grade levels so we do that before we even start the budget process and plan for um the projected growth once we do that and we identify how many sections are in each school then we know how many specialists we need by Specialists I mean physical education teachers because every class has PE twice a week a media specialist an art teacher and um um a music teacher so the every class has five specials a week two PE one art one music one media once we figure that out then we take a look at our current staff that are Staffing those programs and we figure out where we need
115staff and it's like a huge puzzle we have posters on the wall wall and we figure out um Barkley Brook needs 32 sections of PE um oak tree needs 42 sections of PE Woodland needs 18 section whatever the number is and we move staff around and play a puzzle because staff can work 30 sections a week that's f um six per day at the elementary level um and to have 100% of their contract we've been doing this since I've been in this position and and we are at a point with the increased number of sections in our schools that we have to add some special ed some some special area staff that's where the media special is coming in it will be shared between two schools oak tree and mil Lake which is where our
116highest number of sections are we're also adding an art teacher and we're adding a PE teacher to cover those additional sections so that's where those positions come from Mr Gorski I really would like to commend Dr alvik and U and uh her company for putting that together in other words instead of budgeting for all of the new needs for staff which are extraordinary based on the projected number of students they look at every existing uh uh class in each school to determine if there's any efficiency that could be transferred over and utilized in lie of hiring new and it really suppresses the amount of new staff it's it's most impressive and it it saves a lot of money as far as your questions Mr Po um the trailer lease payment is under instructional programs and
117an account called other purchase Services it has the account category 11 190 100500 and it's an Eclectic grouping of trailer instructional trailer lease costs as well as um instructional downloads for media and textbooks um and things of that nature but that's where that's budgeted and to your second question about health benefits staff are still paying uh a a a high amount of um benefit cost to the district even with some relief uh attained through negotiations in the 1920 budget there is a offset to the appropriation for health insurance of $4.4 million which is the calculated figure of what we call 170 uh chapter 178 deductions from all staff and that is a a very difficult calculation that's performed with our broker and our HR Director Christine Christie and it has a lot of variables but
118$4.4 million is uh a reduction of the appropriation for health insurance it's not an additional Revenue Source anyone else from the the public wishing to speak to the budget good evening Betty Saito to Barry more drive with regard to the Mandate that came out um in January from Governor Murphy can you tell us where the money is coming from is that coming out of our special needs budget good um that the law came out and it's not exactly as was just stated it is a um a law that requires districts in not next year's budget the following Year's budget 2021 um to provide information and awareness to students on the contributions of people with special needs and people in the lbgt community um I actually just shared this information with my supervisors last week at
119a supervisor's meeting and what we will be looking at is as we're looking at our curriculum where can we fit it in so it is not coming out of a special education budget it's not a class it's raising awareness for those groups um of their similar to what we do with March women wh women's month February Black History Month similar to something like that how can we fit that in but it's not for the next school year budget it's actually for the 2021 school year okay thank you hi good evening Ram rut 6 s strive um first of all I want to thank uh Mr Goodall Mr take Mr Gorski Miss Kal panovich and some of the Boe members who really campaigned hard over the last few months presenting the referendum patiently answer the question
120I know in some cases there probably a couple of people showing up but you guys were very patient uh so hats off to you all you know A+ for the effort uh that he put in obviously for all of us it was an F right with the referendum not passing um so again talking about the budgets right as you can see we lot of questions opening up not only 1920 but beyond we know trailers are are needed uh right I saw some 3.5 million run rate uh in the next 3 years and the presentations I maybe not be completely accurate with those numbers but but in that regard right so so we have failed twice right so Madame President can we now trigger the state to intervene and help us here we need help desperately
121we don't we cannot afford it looks like in the budget so can can you go ahead and Trigger the state intervention for the Middle School the Board of Education could petition the state to come in it would be a long process it would be a costly process and in the end they could probably ask us to or mandate us to build a state school they will not pay for it so I um am creating an ad hoc committee I don't know if you were here at the beginning of the meeting um for all um Monroe residents to have input into what our next steps will be whether um for because we know we need a referendum we know we need to put kids someplace and we have to figure out something that the public will
122support and and vote on yes so I think at this point that's our next step is to see um involve the public see we want to go because that could be done much quicker than having the state come in and and do their investigation yeah appreciate the feedback but really I don't see even if you put on the referendum it's not going to pass the public has spoken I doubt it as a member of uh public requesting really it's like we have failed twice let's move fast looks like the state is only an option for us so I kindly request that the board please consider that second Point can the board I think Miss um Michel armino raised that about uh you know uh you know communicating to the mayor and the council about how
123this excessive construction growth is impacting uh the quality of lives of our children the education so would the board consider drafting a strong letter whatever you call it to the mayor and the council really raising this concern in official terms on how it is impacting your budget your ability to run the schools and asking them to come back to you with a solution I I think that's something um that we're we have to have a discussion with the township first because they're doing things they have laws they have to follow they have mandates that we have to follow we might not understand what they're doing and why they're doing that why they're all this Bud uh this this uh communication the um the conu development of the of Monroe is going on um but I
124don't I don't think that at the board at this point should be finger pointing to them because we don't we don't know what their process is that they're following okay and then third point right I saw the capital outlay budget uh it's down 42% right down by 800k uh right and we know we need to be constructing we know we have to start building for the high school so why why is it that we have really we're bringing down our Capital outlay um uh and I seen like Princeton for example instead of the 2% cap they're actually going at 2.63% uh right and funding program Mr gski can you answer that question the capital outlay may appear that it's going down compared to last year where there were more budget priorities in the Capital outlay
125Area including um things such as roofs and so on uh this year the priority was um instructional busing and still we were able to budget for over a million dollars of vesu projects and some other facility projects such as bleachers um there was a uh a couple machines that Mr T uh put in the budget we efficiently budgeted for those items by lease purchasing lease purchasing many of them so you don't see them in the capital outlay account they're in the uh facility section 11261 because they're being financed over a fiveyear period so it could be a little misleading to see a decrease in the capital outlay account but I will say this we have done a Herculean job of addressing your Investments as a community and your facilities every year through the budget by
126no less than uh $2 to3 million a year and that's within cap and it's been a challenge for us we don't go out the bond for construction repair projects such as roofs and windows and security projects like your common place now yeah we do it every year in the budget thank you good evening uh Christy scurby 21 pness Drive I had a question on the budget presentation um it was said that there is a spending freeze as of January that equates to about $900,000 is that correct how much is the spending freeze yes uh Jan approximately January 15th the superintendent of schools directed all staff to Institute a non-essential purchase order freeze and that's for anything that's not contractually or otherwise obligated uh to be an appropriation so anything that was non-essential spending was frozen
127and based on previous year's numbers that total is approximately $900,000 of savings of non-essential spending from January through June 30 so where does that money go to the money money goes to meet the obligations of growth in the district and also could uh in theory add to the excess Surplus calculation each year which is the savings that carries over from budgets to budget and as we presented was actually depleted by a million dollars from last year of the 1920 budget so then that's replenished so we'll have about a million dollars in Surplus is that what it will contribute there's many items that contribute to Surplus maximizing revenues beyond what was budgeted contributes to Surplus cutting Appropriations uh through purchase order frees and purchasing consortiums and transportation joint uh all contributes to Surplus that is Management's
128hands in uh in in suppressing taxes and and and uh keeping dollars in the classroom while being efficient sure and I guess that's my point if we have if we're able to um have a spending freeze that equates almost a million dollars um which is cost of trailers um going forward maybe we look more carefully at our budget if we have a million dollars that we can cut right now out of our budget not spend a non-essential well then maybe that million dollars in the budget should have gone to something more essential like you know it could go in the future than to trailers maybe we need to be more diligent with the budgets if if we have a million dollars in there of non-essential items that as of January you got septe half of
129September October November December four months of school and and you know you got six more months and we don't need that million dollars you need to look more carefully at that as you're budgeting um and just going back to what um Ram said there are districts that do go above cap we can go above cap we you decided as a board years ago to stop going out to the public and asking for the public to vote on the budget we can go back to that if we need to go over to 2.5% we we can do that you can do that it's not a law that you cannot that you have to stay under the 2% it can go out to the voters and the voters can decide whether or not to go over cap
130or not so that's important to note as we move forward before we start cutting essential programs and and cut making Cuts because of our growth we should look at going back to the voters to vote on the budget if we need to go over the [Applause] 2% my name is surh Kumar I had the benefit of working in the uh in the corporate sector and currently I'm in the education sector I'm a professor at NGIT so I'm just kind of uh wanted to revisit one important concept and it's not directly related to the budget but I think it's important it plays a role so if you can indulge me for a couple of minutes uh the important concept is to understand the role of the board of how you understand the role of the board
131of uh education which is similar to the board of directors that a company has so basically it is governance and oversight being the two important things on in in the company side for example the customers are people who pay for the service in in the case of Education there are two elements to this one is the users which is the students and the second is V the taxpayers who actually pay for it so you have two elements of customers so I'm just wanting to put together a few recommendations based on all the experience that we have had over the last few I would say years the referendum process Etc one is and I'm I was happy to hear Michelle speak about it which is to take the customer feedback before and during the process not
132after the process I think that's what happened in the referendum although you you did a great job but the feedback was listened to but not acted upon because it was already planned so I would encourage that uh I would encourage greater transparency of the bod deliberations customers obviously have a right to know everything one thing I would recommend is if you could move move this public forum to the front of a meeting you can understand how difficult it is for all of us who are going to a job coming back looking after our kids then sitting here until 10: p.m. for a public forum if you can move that maybe towards a little bit earlier that would really make it really useful uh finally there has been some comments about some political pressures happening at
133least in the past I hope that we will keep it separate so that that that would not interfere with the in terms of decision making it should always be the interest of the kids uh and the only final thing would be that how do we make decisions faster I think few of the recommendations was about how do we move forward quicker can we push the envelope a little bit more given the state we are in hold people responsible so these are uh recommendations hopefully you will take into consideration as you move forward thank you thank you [Applause] any more people for the budget this is for the budget Krishna 11 Jake pleas um I'm uh specific to the budget microphone can you hear me now right Krishna deal 11 J place um if you look
134at um the on the first page of um C the it says the test books cost has gone down um now it's yet textbooks have gone down is there a particular reason why the cost of textbooks have gone down this year Mr Cory I'm going to ask the gentleman to please uh repeat what what line item did you have a question on um it says um textbooks have gone down um no it's not the textbooks or is the other objects that have gone down from 449,000 it's on the first page of C yeah there's a 37% drop on that yes yes um if I recall correctly last year there were many addition additional textbook adoptions that come up on a cycle that Dr ala can speak of uh the textbooks are on a fiveyear cycle
135where they have to be uh studied by the curriculum committee and refreshed um this year we have many new adoptions that I would encourage Dr alic to talk about if you wish that are in here and um like many of the uh assets that are being purchased by our facilities Department we are now engaging in the lease of textbooks through the textbook companies where we match the cost of the addition over the usefulness of the books so in the past couple of years we've um adopted more textbooks than we needed to adopt this year that's basically the answer so um we've in the last couple years we've gotten um Social Studies books we've gotten math books um and what we're doing is working with the companies to get a zero % three-year payment plan and
136the books will actually last six or seven years based on the licenses that we get for the online version so in the last couple of years we've needed more new new purchases where this year we're only purchasing a new social studies K to5 book got it so that's why you see a decrease in this year's version as Mr Gorski mentioned earlier we start with a zero based budget so we don't just okay last year we spent this much on textbooks so next year we're going to spend 2% more we really look at our needs every supervisor has a five-year cycle that they look at all their resources and review all of their resources before we come to the budget table right and um there's a lot of talk that has gone on about the need
137of trailers at multiple facilities in 2021 not this year or the year after and I um would be as a corporate person right if I had to cut something out I would cut something which is non-essential um our Core Business our uh Boe is responsible for educating the children to the best um the abilities a thorough and efficient education so anything that has AP classes or honors classes I would plead with you to keep them and cut out non-essential uh Services that's the second point I wanted to make uh we're being realistic here um the we are where we are now but if we have to cut out let's look at non-essential Services first thank you right and third thing is that's for next year yeah agreed um and the third thing is there was
138a discussion about S Services right where uh we could um share our services with other communities and everything else um looking uh casually at the millstone uh Middle School they seem to be uh under um admitted for the middle school they have a uh admission of about 500 versus 50 00 can we evaluate if we can send our children there or am I of Target Madam yes uh last year maybe it's two years ago now um Mr T facilities director and I actually did reach out to I believe it was Millstone because we were presented with information that they had an empty school and uh we spoke to the business administrator there who said that is not the case they built a new school uh it's one of the most uh occupied ones ones that
139they're proud of they have no school to lease or um assist us with but it's a creative thought and and I thank you for that thank you so much hi my name is Jennifer Edelman I'm at 48 cherry blossom I did vote for the referendum and I was disappointed that it did not pass one of the biggest comments I got up from you know all my neighbors and co-workers and other parents that I spoke to all said oh don't worry about it the state will they'll build another school anyway that literally was the biggest comment that I got from anybody that I talked to from hearing from you guys from you all tonight it doesn't seem like that's an automatic thing that happens and I'm just kind of wondering what that process is and take
140that and what that looks like because that seems to me to have been the consensus that all you know all these other parents thought oh the state will just come in and they'll build another School Mr Gorski Madam um Mr Goodall Dr alvic Mr T and I talked about this at length that everyone of our presentations in fact if I recall correctly we may have even had a slide on it but the process as as uh defined by our board attorney who researched this is uh when a school district has two consecutive defeats they can appeal to the state for Relief the state will come in they'll look at much of the information we presented with our budget presentation such as your enrollment current your enrollment projections your facility limitations and uh the state could
141determine that they they it's in their interest to provide a thorough and efficient education and then there is a need to override the voters and approve the projects um in very rare instances the state can also contribute funds toward the project now Freehold burrow is one of these instances that made the the papers Freehold burrow is very dissimilar to Monroe they are a failing they have failing schools they are not meeting thorough and efficient and they had students literally being taught in the hallways the state came in and saw that and said this is this is a a recipe for disaster we are approving your referendum despite the voters defeating it twice and then Freehold burrow further appealed and said thank you for doing so uh we just want to point out too that we
142don't have the revenues in terms of tax levies that are sustainable to raise the levy in order toay pay the debt service on the referendum the state came in reviewed the circumstance determined that it was factual and paid for 85% of the project Monroe is is not at all similar to that situation we are over adequacy we are are more than meeting the uh thorough and efficient standard and if the state was to come in they would approve a school um and we believe the evidence could be there to do so but it would be only on approved State cost now what's the difference parking lots uh athletic fields Performing Arts centers um class rooms for non-mandated programs such as AP are are are not um uh approved costs so they would cut those out
143and you would get a barebone school that would not look anything similar to your other schools here in Monroe and we would not have parity with programs or services and it would not make this community proud whatsoever and most importantly the state would not contribute a nickel to the project because Monroe has very high income numbers and very high property ratables no I understand that um thank you for your clarification on that my only further question is would the state coming in have to be something that the school board would ask them to do what would the chance be that they would come in on their own is that something down the road or is that like an imminent no good question it's not an automatic the school district would have to engage in a
144legal appeal to the state and um engage in a lengthy expensive legal process and provide much information to the state uh attorney to attorney in order to get this process going it's not something administrative can do and it's not something that's automatic okay thank you thank you hello I'm Ira Nelson 87 Cresent way um we've had two referendums that have uh come and have failed um what has the cost been to the district for these referendums um we I know there was a lot of planning going on about a year ago there were a lot of presentations I don't know if Engineers Architects have been hired do we have a cost total of of of what this the expenditures have been for this Mr Gorski some of the expenditures through architecture design with the schematic
145uh presentations that we presented um were covered under the architect's um contract so there were certain costs and they are not uh the majority of of what you would think that were paid to the architect for basic designs of schematics most of the architect's time um is just an acrel for the ultimate project success in which case it comes from their contract it's it's kind of like they have a a an interest in getting this through because they have a large amount of time that's deferred until it's successful and unfortunately it's going to be deferred longer the real cost of the district sir is the increased construction cost increased in interest rates trailer release payments um because the need for these schools and these additional seats is not abated by the referendum defeat these aren't
146luxury items we've defined the need and that was without question so that's Still Remains and the cost to address those is is escalating but you really haven't answered the question be more specific you you in other words we've had engineer reports we've found property that uh uh went to imminent domain time has been spent on this right um isn't there a cost total for this well you asked the school district's perspective the the the land was acquired by the township uhhuh I believe it was three half million I'm going by memory I thought it was three um did it go it was three I I could be wrong three I beg your pardon it was three and um so that was a Township expense yes that is going to be uh born by the taxpayers
147um the school district had to pay for the election cost that's about 70 grand an election um for both both referendums each one each one was $70,000 for the co workers and all that stuff so it's starting to total up yes and we have nothing to show for it okay interesting okay thank you because we have a resolution that is is on the agenda that we haven't voted for I'm asking only questions in regard to the budget referendum questions will be later in the in the um program but right now we we have a budget question on the on the floor so only questions from the public in regard to to the budget so if there's no more questions we'll close public forum and we'll have a roll call on the resolution for to accept
148the 1920 budget the 1920 preliminary budget yes ma'am 2020 no it's 19 20 20 what is it 19 1920 1920 no not 1920 2019 2019 19 20 preliminary budget school year 19 that's what did I say that I thought I said that roll call uh for the adoption of the 19 2019 2020 budget for the resolution I read into the record a few minutes ago okay Mrs Lang yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr Tano yes Mr rutsky yes Mr porori yes Mrs seagull yes Mr Chella yes Mr M armino with the hopes of re uh looking at some things I'm going to vote no hope for it to be changed recorded as a no thank you Mrs Deo yes Mrs colano yes madame board president motion passes okay thank you so we're on to our student
149board member reports this evening I hope you thought that budget presentation was very exciting very exciting okay on the mths unified basketball team made history on Saturday March 2nd by winning the first ever unified B bracket NJ SI AA State Championship uh the monor Township High School cheer team made state champions and are currently in Orlando Florida competing [Applause] nationally uh the boys bowling team won the state sectional championship uh the national English Honor Society went to barklay Brook to read to K through 12 students K2 students for read Across America lastly monor Township High School Deca made a successful state conference with 31 finalists 21 of which are eligible to compete at the International Conference a state scholarship winner and a new state officer this is the largest amount of success in chapter history
150[Applause] okay and I'm going to talk a little bit of the about the elementary schools so the Applegarth PTA is holding a book fair in school available to students during the school day on March 21st and this is 22nd and next month they're also organizing the 10th Annual oak tree appleg GS trick tray which is actually a premium dinner in the forgate country club and the theme this year is adventures and Wonderland barklay Brook is having an assembly on March 22nd called the science circus which is a stem-based comedy show that teaches children to embrace science from a young age and from the high school there's a college fair for sophomores and juniors in the auxiliary gym on March 21st for sophomores and juniors and more than 100 representatives from different Colleges and Schools will
151be available for students to talk to and finally uh on March 20th to 22nd this Wednesday to Friday a group of fpla members will be attending the FPL State leadership conference in Atlantic City around 95 members they'll be competing for advancing to Nationals business opportunities and scholarships thank you oh did you have a question Mr Rybeck okay okay at this time we'll go to committee reports Mr Chella all right I'll be I'll be quick um on March 12th we had a buildings grounds and transportation committee meeting uh we had we had uh Mr Eric Garing from middlex County parks department presented he came in and presented the uh maps of the committee of the walking trails that would go that go through the park and then through the middle school and the high school uh
152he brought signs and um thank you thank you and uh colored markers and things like that he laid and and maps and he laid out a plan uh for those walking trail Trails which go through our school property uh the the committee although they they were we were very supportive of the of the idea asked that Mr Gorski go back to our insurance broker and take a take a look at that and see if uh uh if there are any concerns with having the public on our property and then see if we can get maybe a hold harmless agreement from the from the county and then if we could do that then we're more than willing to move forward with that so we just wanted to make sure that we had some things in place
153um we also Mr uh Mr Gorski uh informed us about the death of uh our mail truck uh so it's a 2005 mail truck and it's dead it's gone so he said passing he didn't say de passing he did say he did say passing I I embellished death dead but uh it's in incapacitated how's that but anyway the committee is asking the the full board to uh replace that with a Transit van we need that mail truck that Ma the mail truck is very important to the district it moves a lot of mail and uh without without it we would we would be in trouble so that's that's on our agenda uh and then we had a very good uh presentation a question and answer session I guess by Kathleen McDonald so uh she's our
154director of transportation and she came in and reviewed some of the new things that we have going on and some and some some of them are older maybe a year old that we approved last year uh for instance the GPS system the the uh the new software the routing systems and uh some of the things that uh that she's worked on so I can tell you that from my perspective anyway and I think I could speak for our committee buildings and grounds committee she does a great job so and I think for anybody out there who is who lives on a main artery Main Road 522 Applegarth Road and has their children getting on and off buses uh prior to uh m m McDonald doing her her magic and I call it magic because she
155actually we learn creates those those roots herself so even though she has a software to help her she she she Maps out those roots and writes them and figures them out so I could tell you that I live on a main road and prior you know prior to this my kids would have to cross a major highway which is crazy with the amount of people that don't stop for buses it's just it's just dangerous well then uh last year I started noticing that the bus was coming on the other side both both to pick up and drop off and that's not because I'm a board member because we did for years we had it the other way and I've been a board member for a long time it's because of the way she the way
156she routed it and when I brought that up to her at our meeting she said that that has been done all over town that they made a a concerted effort to do that uh because the safety of the children are you know it's so important so I want to commend her for that but I uh anyway she went through that stuff with us talked about where we are with uh our own bus fleet and how we're moving ahead with uh getting as many buses as we possibly can of our own as I mentioned earlier so anyway uh great update and I was happy to see uh happy to hear from her and happy to see what she was doing and I think that uh I think we're well served with cath Kath uh Kathleen McDonald
157now the the last thing that I have is a SP Commons lease agreement so Mr Gorski presented the uh lease agreement to us on behalf of Mary Smith the board attorney um we we we because of space constraints we used to have uh pupil personel services in Applegarth in trailers and we ran out of space when we got rid of the trailers so we moved them offsite uh and we've been renting a uh a storefront really I mean it's it's a couple stores together and that and uh that is that that has served us well uh with uh going into our meeting on the 12th we didn't know where we were going to where were we didn't know the results of the referendum yet obviously so uh we had hedged our bets and we and
158that's what we're bringing to you today is just that we want to continue that lease so we would have had to have continued that lease anyway even if the referendum passed because the schools aren't built yet but we had hoped that if we had a passing of the referendum we'd be able to bring pupil Personnel Services back into the schools themselves and then not have that additional cost of uh of the rentals so uh I'm I'm also our committee is also asking that we move forward with that lease agreement for the next three years that is uh a fiveyear lease agreement isn't it because I thought we had said three if the referendum didn't pass three if the referendum passed and five if it didn't pass if I Madam I believe u Mrs Smith's negotiating
159a three-year lease uh to get us the most advantageous price but there are options that the district could go further but um the core of it a three-year lease okay that's it thank you Mr rybach thank you uh first i' just like to uh mention that I'm very glad that the Personnel committee saw fit to bring before you today for your consideration in Improvement in the substitute pay I think that's a winning situation for everyone uh next uh I'm uh as you know member of the New Jersey school board legislative committee we had a meeting uh about uh two weeks ago and one of the things that was brought to our attention that committee feels will really have a lot of legs is legislation uh called every child counts since before the legislature now um
160I just like to touch some of the highlights of it because it does impact some of the conversations we've had today one it would eliminate the census approach to uh so school districts are funded based on their exact number of special education students instead of the state average it would restore uh the special ed tiers with the task force to set the appropriate funding amounts for the various needs make special education 100% categorical instead of the 13d categorical and 2/3 we wealth equalized commit to fully funding extraordinary special education we would amend the state constitution to ensure that the statutory school funding formula is followed every year even if it's on a pro-rated basis dependent upon how much school aid can be afforded within the state budget each year would eliminate one-day enrollment numbers for
161state aid calculations and move to an average annual enrollment finally it used the federal small area income and poverty estimate currently used for Title One funding as the measure of at risk instead of self-reported and easily manipulated free reduced uh reduced lunch numbers thank you thank you Mr Marbach Mr Mayo we'll go around the table okay we had a curriculum meeting today um the supervisors prevented we next we have a new curriculum document for probability and statistics um it's an elective course for those who have successfully completed Algebra 2 this class is taught through a variety of project performance lab case studies analysis of data in addition to quizzes and tests it's an introductory course to the basics of probability statistics and it's designed for those students interested in pursuing a in a pursuing in
162a career in business marketing psychology mathematics or any field requiring data analysis some of the topics in this course are graphical techniques analysis of data probability permutations combin combinations the binomial distribution the normal curve random sampling Central limit theorem hypothesis testing and the linear correlation and regression um the final endof year project is a carnival Fair which is open to students during lunch break this is where the kids in the class create games knowing the probability and statistics of the games they create um for the kids visiting to play we also talked about a eyelet pilot this is a for special needs students in high school in the resource room and it's for reading it's a supplemental program to complement their the students current curriculum we have found through map testing that there are gaps
163in these students reading ability and this will help them get to their individual goals we also discussed the summer reading um soon you will be getting letters and suggested titles for all incoming students in grade 1 through 12 the titles reflect the concept of window and mirrors and thereby appeal to interest genre pref preference race ethnicities genders and reading levels um there are links for the resources for the parents to review the books we also had a discussion about the restructuring of World Language um in grades Seven 8 and N we are implementing a civics class at the middle school and as a result it's a halfe class and as a result we have to configure the world language classes in grades seven and 8 um grade seven the civics class is for grade seven
164they will have a half year of World Language and a half year of civics um as a result um the eighth grade curriculum will be need to be visited because the seventh grade will only be getting half a year of World Language and then the ninth grade curriculum will also need to be Revisited as a result of changes to the seventh grade curriculum we're hoping by by 10th grade um things will equalize out but um Dory and her supervisors will keep an eye on this to make sure things are going as they should we also talked about um a Performing Arts Academy which is a summer program which will be presented by the Monroe Township High School chorus program the objectives is to provide current and aspiring artists specifically with the within the content area
165of bands chorus musical theater and Orchestra and with a forum to maintain and develop their individual skills Ensemble skills and overall musicianship the target audience is students entering grade 4 through 9th um there will be volunteers from the music Honor Society band and chorus and um the high school and middle school Bandon chorus programs um um the different sessions they're offering is the Monroe Township summer course program um the musical there's a musical theater Camp there's a Summer band program there's a junior Jazz Academy there's an intermediate Jazz Academy there's an a percussion Academy and there's an orchestra Academy for kids who are studying strings so this is new to our district which is really exciting um I've asked Zach about strings before for but we're bringing it through the Performing Arts Academy and these
166will be um in the summer so they're paid sessions there's weeks they go from July 22nd to the 26th July 29th to August 2nd and August 5th through August 9th so this is something that um parents can sign their kids up for and that's it thank you we'll go to this side Mr bretsky so in for the finance committee in light of the budget presentation tonight I would say that at our finance meeting we reviewed the budget and I would just respectfully say I wanted to thank Miss Dr alvik Mr Goodall Mr Gorski for putting together a wonderfully responsible and Incredibly creative budget job well done thank you thank you Mr poori I wish I can top that report good evening everyone uh just to build upon what Miss Deo talked about the some of
167the the programs we're planning to uh introduce in the summer uh we had a very good presentation by by Zach morala um at the uh educ uh education advocacy committee and he indicated that there are a couple of handful of uh courses that are being taught in the past uh materials and methods introduction to engineering design uh cabinet making and construction technology and uh thank you very much looks like there's a long waiting list uh for people to to enroll in this as well because of the constraints that they have and also there's a feeling that these are mostly malale dominated uh items so they wanted to introduce a little bit more U oriented towards uh the things that Mrs Deo just talked about uh such as fashion design uh cosmetology and and things of
168that nature and basically these are all G towards people who are non- colge bound uh in in the future so irrespective of the uh the referendum U we at the Boe continue to see how we can introduce more programs and also we're looking at possibility of raising any funds through these courses in the summer uh as well uh so coming back to some of the interactions with the uh elected officials I had a conversation with the assembly speaker uh Craig Coughlin and he said that the funding formula changes uh to take place in this year is not going to happen so so that's a non-starter from their perspective um we had at least two or three meetings with uh assemblyman um Dan Benson uh we had a conference call with the District staff along with
169the vice chair of this committee uh and we understand that some of the public also met with him in the past uh we're looking at various uh Avenues uh we are looking to sue the state uh I don't want to Promise Too Much in deliver over promise and under deliver but we want to First explore the possibility of is there a reasonable cause uh including some of the suggestions made that are today uh to see we most likely will engage uh a reputed uh uh uh law firm uh to to advise us on this because what we don't want to do is spend a sixf figure uh fee uh in in legal battle at the end of the day only to be ridicule for for suing the state I know there's a lot of discussion
170in the public about suing along with the eight other districts that are suing the state uh people need to realize the fact that the reason they're suing uh is because their money is being taken away whereas mro Township we actually gained some money uh so the the reasons are different so we can't possibly harp on that particular one but I like the idea of looking for similar uh municipalities that are having similar issues like us and kind of coming together to sue um as many of you know although the budget the draft budget has been announced by the governor uh there's going to be a lot of finagling that takes place between February and Jun soon um I request everybody I know Ken and Steve said that it's on my shoulders I don't have such
171broad shoulders unfortunately I need we need everybody's help and we are all in this together like you said uh is to go to the state house and make sure that we talk to the elected officials uh we are from the Board of Education trying to get some slots to give a testimony both in front of the state senate uh hearing for the budget and as well as for the assembly budget hearings I've been in touch with both the legislators that we have right now um so like we received uh 1.6 million additional funding last year that's what we need to focus right now for the immediate purpose to see if we can get something like Lakewood got but the lakewood's problems are slightly different than ours so to speak um so let me just make
172sure that I'm not missing anything I believe that's it uh we we are looking at a couple of other items like the department of educational Reserve funds uh and Mr GR identified as a matter of fact senior supplemental stabilization Aid uh that would give districts that have 50% of the population over 65 uh years or older uh about $500 per student which would enable us to get about three and a half million dollars we'll take anything we can get so we're going to look at all these options uh working with the with the community as well as the other board members thank you madam president do we have anything yes I do yes okay so thank you very much for reminding me uh in terms of the impact fee we did uh draft a resolution
173which I had it a second ago here I'm going to read this um it was a resolution of the Monro Township Board of Education calling for the New Jersey legislature to pass legalization permitting municipalities to impose impact fees for increased school cost on developers of new residential units whereas New Jersey Law prohibits municipalities from charging impact fees to offset costs associated with increased demands on schools leaving the financial burden to be born by the local taxpayers and whereas over the last several decades the Monroe town the township of Monroe like many municipalities has experienced residential development due to due in large part to the excellent quality of life geographic location and Superior Public School System and whereas mro Township is required by the state to accommodate 850 new affordable uh housing units and several thousand
174Market units as a part of the fair share uh Fair fairhouse share settlement and whereas this experience is is occurring in municipalities across the state and demand for new school Services increases and whereas it is fair and reasonable to shift some of the financial effects of residential development on local public schools from the taxpayers to the developers whose projects clearly and directly create the need for additional funding now therefore be it resolved that the Monro Township Board of Education urges the New Jersey legislature to pass legislation permitting municipalities to enact ordinances imposing impact fee for necessary Public School improvements and expansion on the developers who build the new housing in their communities be it further resolved that the copies of the resolution be mailed to the Senate President Steve Sweeney Senate minority leader Tom Kane
175and speaker CRA Coughlin and assembly minority leader John bramnik dated March 18th 2019 is there a second is that the second by Mrs Lang comments or questions by members of the board Mrs Miss Armenia yes I I would ask uh Mr POI to add uh something an addendum to that by um something that we both experienced last at the last planning board meeting the uh I would ask that the legislature uh re-evaluate or or actually get rid of the uh demographics the way the builders and and I don't know you know specific language we can simply lfy it but the builders are using debunk formulas to tell um in their applications about how many students will come out from a an application and we went the ruer Ser the ruer formula from 2000 um and
176Mr uh Ryback was among some people along with uh Linda Greenstein and I'm I'm actually quite surprised that after uh her taking us to the blowstein uh business where the gentleman who actually uh none of promulgated the formula said that it wasn't it it didn't work anymore so I would like some kind of addition to that have the legislature not allow that formula to be used during applications because it doesn't work it doesn't it and it's it's giving us a false um a false false am no not just it's a a false number the number is not false they said for 213 tow houses market rate tow houses there would only be 23 children that's absurd and and we are suffering for that uh and it is in it is an inappropriate and a I
177mean the information is incorrect how could the legislature allow it and how could our local officials allow it I mean we even got the chair of the planning board to admit that that formula doesn't work so we shouldn't that should be an addendum to that resolution please M it's significant for us um point of correction I believe that the Department of Education has removed the Rutter's method from the enrollment projections um and I and I and I believe that it also has been removed from uh the municipal submissions that you were referring to I could say that none of our applications to the state use the ruter method any longer for the last two referenda attempts well I can tell you that La the last planning board meeting the applicant absolutely used that formula and
178suggested that it was acceptable that it was accepted by the state so he is under oath to tell the truth and give accurate information so we have to figure out what's going on Mr rback I just wanted uh to say along Ong the lines what of what Mrs armano brought up correctly that I remember when um the development on Mount Mills Road called Monroe Park when that application first went in it wasn't called Mount SMS it wasn't called Monroe Park something else but it was like 520 some OD units and the developer said it would it would yield 80 or 81 students at which point I think we all went a little crazy there because it's ridiculous and and we can't allow that ruu survey to continue being used it's it's ridiculous um Al along
179those lines though I I'd like to say as far as impact fees I certainly support it but you know what I'm going to say sounds a little pie in the sky but I ask you to bear with me a little bit wouldn't it be wonderful if um the state and the courts because they're just as guilty of it they don't take into account the impacts on on education um but wouldn't it be wonderful if they got together and allowed us to make impact fees for the developments that are going up here now retroactive where they could say I know you're smiling it's not going to happen but but where they could say um I heard there's a $450 million uh Lottery no wouldn't it be wonderful if they could say to us in town no
180you know you you you you have to sit down with these developers developers have to sit down with you work contribution well you know said it's pie in the sky but it's only Pie in the Sky until it's not Pie in the Sky until it becomes reality I mean a lot of things in history have been considered pie in the sky and now they're reality uh cars were probably laugh at years ago and now we all have them so you know I I think that has to be done and if if we could stop construction uh while this is being done I think that would be a benefit or slow construction and force these developers to sit down and work something out with us but that would require a whole Community effort where everybody who's
181here today who's listening all of us have to really write our uh representatives and let them know um you know how we feel and how how difficult it is for us now uh in the school system Mr R back there there are a couple of items here in in in any kind of projections there are standards that are set the standards are typically set either Statewide or nationally and in this particular case the Rodgers study is focused on New Jersey and they come up with the standards based on that so if you build a residential unit in Sussex County or gler County versus you build in in in middlex County the projections are the same what we should be doing and what I advocate that we do is we uh engage Ross Harbor and have
182him look at the two-bedroom tow houses for age targeted units that were built that's what they call them age targeted and compare apples to apples so if you build them in our community with the same exact parameters how many school goinging kids a 200 unit um development is sending I think that's what we need to do and then take that back to the planning board to show them I voted no on on the application but I could not say that you are wrong because we didn't have the data to back up to it so I think that's the first thing to do and and the second thing you you talked about the um I talked about a lot a lot of things about the impact funding uh as well or do doing it retroactive uh
183I don't I know I said that it's pie in the sky but you know what at this point we're really desperate and and we have to do something and if that's what we have to ask for let's ask the most they can say is no so I I think one of the the bigger bigger bones that I have is you know having the affordable housing uh mandate is one thing but requiring that for every affordable housing unit you can build four market rate is what is really killing us U I think that's also an arbitrary number that's that's brought up by a judge I'm not sure how much of legalities or rational is behind it and I think that's something that we should be looking at and that's the question I asked at the planning
184board and we were told that pretty much most of the development that is supposed to take place to accommodate the affordable housing I would guess about 70 to 80% of it is already in place so you know the bottom line I just want to make one comment is is is money well if the governor can finded 15 additional million dollar to give Lakewood for transportation that's not in the school funding formula don't tell me that the state has no money to help Monroe thank you Mr Tano um Andy I would also like to see you add a a letter in that to our mayor and ask that he uh enact a moratorium on the building until the school district can uh catch up to its responsibility uh to educate all students coming into the district
185properly I I think that we're we're um we're asking the taxpayers to come out and vote for this referendum because we all really know that we need it but also the taxpayers are voting uh down our referendum because they're very angry at the constant constant you know being ignored constantly uh when they come to these meetings and say they don't they don't want any more building that infrastructure is not able to Su substain it the schools are not able to substain it and and uh sustain it and uh and he's not listening so I think if the board or we send him a request to issue a a moratorium which is not stopping all the building permanently but putting a temporary halt on it until we can catch up to give all these students the
186education they deserve properly I I think that that that would help I I just want to bring it back to what this resolution is all about this is about the impact fee only not about the uh the school children projections which I'm not disagreeing with either one of you I think it can be something that can be looked at that would be a separate letter this is going this is not going to the township no this is actually going to the legislators right right so that's what we're voting for we're voting on so are you are you just you're refusing my request to uh put an addendum on that I I would need to consult with the attorney to find out if if we're talking yeah did you have a a comment yeah I just
187I'm going to I'm going to support your uh your motion um Mr POI because I know it's well placed uh I just want to say unfortunately that it's too late you know everything that's already built is or approved is in the works um by the time the state gets around the state Trust Me Maybe maybe it'll be the next election cycle after this one they will get around to doing it but it'll be too late it'll be after we're built out and then they're going to come in and say look what we're doing we're we're we're uh we're doing these things and and we're going to put we're going to demand impact fees but that's after the faucet turns off from all the developers and all the all the money that comes in uh from
188those developers and from special services and things like that so I I know I know it's well placed and I'm going to support it but I'd like to I'd also like to say and address your point which was perfect on the uh on the on on the market rate versus the affordable housing one for four and the judge uh who who presided over the affordable housing obligation and his now is now retired and working for JSM and that says it all JSM is the developer who's developing on 522 and then out on 33 so that 4 to1 that ratio was I think any anyway created for developers and I think that one of the things that we might want to look at from a lawsuit perspective is that because South Bruno I think was uh
189I don't know what happened with their litigation but they were looking at suing also because of because of the relationship between the judge and uh and the and the developer and I think that might be something that we could look at also that's it okay so at this time we're going to have a roll call on supporting this letter of impact fees to our legislators Mr Cher yes Mrs Deo yes Mr Tano I'd like to vote Yes uh with the condition that we sit down and and see what we could add to that letter um no we're just voting on that letter the way it is letter all right so yes Mrs Lang yes Mr poori yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr rutsky yes Mrs seagull yes Mrs armeno yes Mrs colan yes yes madame board
190president I'm pleased to say the motion passed unanimously if we want to write other letters we'll bring it to Mr Poor's committee and we'll work it through that way but at this time we we have but may I will Mr poori have a conflict since he's on the planning board if if I address a resolution specifically the planning board and the township Council we would have to ask Mary I'm a board of education member yeah also but you're also well it's two separate entities I don't know that there is a yeah but we will ask our board attorney so I think oh Mrs I know I'm so sorry last but not least Mrs Lang hello no so we had our policy meeting on March 12th and once again our policy committee is working very wonderfully
191together we have quite a few mandated policies that we are going to put up for first read tonight and the important thing to keep in mind with mandated policies is that despite what we might feel personally and what we want to do mandated policies are basically law and when we um take our oath of office as board members it's to uphold the laws of the state of New Jersey so we need to um continue to pass policies that are mandated and support them also I think tonight was a great great um example of what a true Board of Education meeting is a board of Education meeting is a meeting of the Board of Education in public it is not a public meeting it is for the purpose of us to conduct our business with the
192public observing us so we have one meeting a month in which to do this and I know as a resident when I would come to the microphone I would get very frustrated with having to wait to get to talk I remember staying one board meeting until I think it was 1:00 in the morning to to speak and I spoke and I think I you know and so I think it's really important to know that we follow a format for our conduct of board meetings that is given to us basically by New Jersey school boards this is the recommended there's a we've looked at why we can't change it and what happens if you do change it so I think that's just an important part for us to be aware of so tonight when we do
193our conduct of the a board meeting um bylaw 0164 the one thing that we did add is that we recognize that what the biggest role of the board of education is to always meet the needs of our students and we're supposed to be celebrating student achievement at every meeting so we have asked um to have added to our conduct of board meetings a spot for our assistant superintendent director curriculum to give us more information about the great things that are going on in the district so that's pretty exciting I think and then finally during the referendum presentations we had a lot of questions about the eligibility of non-resident students and in fact this is a mandated policy that we're about to present for first reading tonight and what happens is that pursuant to federal and
194state law the board of V is required to provide all children in the district with equal access to public education we can't pick and choose we can't we are prohibited from implementing any discriminatory enrollment practices is either intentionally or unintentionally we can't that might just exclude children from enrolling in schools New Jersey Law prohibits school districts from making enrollment contingent upon the receipt of certain documents so we are allowed to use um a driver's license where not no I take that back we cannot use income tax returns we cannot use um citizenship papers immigration status we cannot use Social Security so what we do when enrolling a student into the district we look at utility bills and Lease agreements so and even at that we can't deny enrollment based on failure to provide a particular
195form or subset of documents we also during the process of um doing the referendum we had a lot of people talking about homes with multi families in them so back a couple years ago the district did a study on how many residents and it was determined through this study that homes with three students per residence accounted for only 8% of our student population and homes with four or more students per residents accounted only for 8% we really don't have a problem of having multiple families sending children to school we have a lot of multigenerational families but it's also important important to note that as a school board we cannot say that you can't live with other family members and in your household your house is your domain that is your ability to live in it
196and I think that's an important thing to note the other thing that we are going to be doing is that we are going to revise policy 511 because we are not going to allow F1 Visa students to be admitted into the school district we just felt that because the our school district is growing so much to have extra students who are here on visas would not be in our best interest and finally we did there's one policy for recision bylaw 0135 and that is only because it is a duplicate of a policy that we passed last year thank you thank you Mrs Lang you're welcome so at this time we will go to the public forum anyone wishing to speak to the agenda which does not include the referendum this is just the agenda there's
197no referendum on the agenda anyone wishing to speak to the agenda please come to the microphone state your name and address for the record we will adhere to our 4minute timeline and when the timer goes off so is your um your time prakash pup 33 I drive um I was in Trenton last year for the meeting and there was a as assembly men from Camden or Jersey City they said that when the student comes parents come to enroll the child don't ask whether they are citizens non-citizens what is their immigration status and all so please think over when you are saying that F1 Visa student visa the children I don't know what you're talking about before you put it into that policy be careful we have lot of immigrants in our Monroe Township so we
198cannot say no to a child coming okay so this is not I'm just requesting look because there's already a New Jersey Law there and if you all are overriding the New Jersey Law it will not be good okay so another one thing the discussion on the impact fees came affordable housing today the main problem is we don't have a legislation and the bill I have been studying affordable housing a lot and what has happened is the affordable H housing Lobby filed a suits so the courts said the verdict in favor of the builders so now what we are doing is we are meeting the legislators indivisible group of Highland Park is very active I have joined with them I a part of the indivisual group so working with the legislature so that there is a
199bill which defines very well the need of the affordable housing region wise or what we are not talking about how the bill should be and I was told that League of municipalities is drafting a bill to talk to them so we are doing that so please you all also uh have a advocacy group so please do that that is very important because Builders are building High in city houses and that is impacting the schools if it will not serve the purpose of Monroe it will serve the purpose of other District we'll do that we are planning to build 4,000 houses because we have to build support 850 houses affordable and I tell you there are lot of people waiting for the houses you know and this it will take 10 years for this to happen
200that is not good it is not serving the people also so we need a Bill to do a proper Justice to the people so I request to board to consider and I also thank the board for passing the resolution last time I kept came and requested that our Council has passed a resolution it will look very nice the board also passed a resolution so I'm very uh thankful okay so I'll be coming and meeting you all with our group and talking about how we can have win-win situation we'll do brainstorming so be working with the Board of Education we'll be going to the council meeting the legislations too so we learn from each other and we win the battle okay thank you very much good evening Christy scurby 21 pness Drive um while it is
201very well deserved I'm very sad to see item a under Personnel uh the retirement of Jackie Winters I'm Jackie has been a teacher here in Monroe Township for over 35 years and she has been a huge supporter of our school district she has made an impact on hundreds and hundreds of children throughout those years I had the great pleasure of working with Jackie while I was the president of the Barkley Brook Brookside PTA and Jackie is going to be um absolutely missed and um her work at Monroe um should definitely be recognized and remembered for a long time um it's with Jackie's dedication and hard work um and really getting out there that this building um even stands here today she was very instrumental in getting the referendum passed for the high school and she
202worked tirelessly for this past referendum so I just want to thank Jackie for all her years of service here in Monroe she's going to be greatly missed and I hope she has a wonderful retirement [Applause] Joanne Cardone 11 Gravel Hill Spotswood year for almost 50 years I've been in this Township quite a long time I've seen a lot of changes some good some bad but I'm still here and I'm still very much an advocate of Education I have 43 years of teaching under my belt and for the last nine years since my retirement I've been subbing in the high school and I thank you for my pay raise um my sincerest thanks to Rob Goodall and the administrative team for putting on over 30 presentations to get that referendum passed I know I'm not supposed
203to be talking about that but I had to thank him and the administrative team uh I also agree with Michelle our IO as far as being more involved with the zoning board and the planning board as far as Construction in the town years ago uh they changed a lot of the zoning variances which allowed bigger homes to be built and I think a lot of the problems have been a lack of communication between the Board of Ed and the zoning and planning boards so we definitely need to have more communication between the two groups or three groups however you want to refer to it um Mr poori had mentioned some non-bound students education and that's another thing that I have been asking for for many years being a special Leed teacher uh with a majority
204of our students especially the low Cog students not going on to college how are we preparing them for the real world many years ago we had uh Mr Millie teaching some wonderful construction classes and I don't understand why we can't bring some of this in I think it's about time we realize that everyone is not going to college look how many college graduates are out there unable to get jobs in their degree programs in 15 20 years we're probably not going to be able to find a plumber or a good electrician I'm not saying that we put vocational programs like that into the building but we do need to prepare these kids for other types of work besides college so I would ask that the board at least try to bring something in if Oldbridge
205can bring cosmetology into their school system which they have had for decades and there are other vocational courses that they've had somehow we have to find the way even if it means now I'm an advocate of AP courses trust me and deca of course so we don't want to eliminate extracurricular but there should be some way that we can bring something in our shop teachers are probably certified to teach these programs so every little bit will help uh I guess that's it because Kathy took care of a lot of the things that I was going to mention in your opening presentation so that's good thank you how do you do folks uh Richard Gibbons 415 uh Schoolhouse Road I've been here so long tonight I almost forgot why I came but um I come bearing
206gifts and by the way I just wish like to wish you all happy belated St Patrick's at all the board members and you too Mr Gorski um I have some gifts tonight for you but before I uh give them out does this have to do with the agenda yes yes it is my my comments will be on on the um committee reports curriculum if that's okay or no if it's on the agenda okay okay um I'm going to read you some notes I wrote down and um I see survey after survey showing that too many of our students Nationwide are embracing socialist ISM over capitalism our country didn't become the greatest country in the world by accident the founders came up with a formula that advanced the world more in the last 200 years than
207the rest of the world did in the last 5,000 years I'm really afraid that we may lose this formula if we don't start passing it on to our students I have a gift for all the board members tonight it's a book called The 5,000-year Leap now you people are all educated individuals with direct influence over our students I just hope that you'll check out this book and hopefully incorporate some of these ideas into the curriculum but before I hand out the books I would just like to read you a comment on the back of one of the books it's a quote it's from a high school principal it's as a high school teacher of American government I've thrilled to observe the reaction of students when exposed to these founding principles they have a much better
208understanding of the political world they being they are being thrust into they can make decisions about real life situations based on correct principles and are much better prepared to enter college and bling and bring political truth to college classrooms many of my graduated students have returned to thank me for teaching the them the foundational principles contained in this book perhap this this book's motto should be don't leave high school without it and this was a quote from Earl Taylor Jr a high school principal teacher in Mesa Arizona uh so with that in mind I would just like to U hand out these books if you don't mind we'll give them to Mr Gorski and Mr Gorski will as the board secretary will be glad to do that oh okay good Madame President looking at the
209clock at 1010 I thought actually Mr Gibbons got us something to eat um do you need a do we need think we need about a 10-minute break okay somebody makes a motion I make a motion thanks for the gift rich okay all in favor I okay at this time we will take a 10-minute recess back into public session and we will go to the superintendent's report Mr Goodall thank you each month we've been updating the school community on our efforts to communicate with and be more inclusive of our student with special needs in their families in their neighborhood schools and across the district at our last cpeg meeting members of The District Administrative team presented a year-long action plan in response to discussions with parents related to short and long-term reading interventions and programs K
210through 12 activities and practices aimed at complete inclusion of students and professional development for staff in the area of restraint training and autism awareness thank you to Dr Kelly Rosell Dr Kevin Higgins miss Monica Hines and Miss Marietta ruella for their contribution to a great meeting I also wanted to thank all of the additional administrators CST members and teachers for attending as well we are really sending a positive message to parents of a re-energizing of our school Community for special education students and their families I had a great day celebrating Pi Day with the staff and students at the Woodland Elementary School for those of you unfamiliar with Pi Day Pi Day is celebrated on March 14th 3:14 around the world and is the symbol used in mathematics to represent a constant the ratio of
211the circumference of a circle to its diameter which is 3 approximately 3.14 however at the Woodland Elementary School they celebrate by under the guise inviting Mr Goodall for a slice of pie uh to hit Mr Goodall with pies so not once but twice Mr Goodall was hit by a pie with a student anything to promote mathematics in the district and he's still here I want to thank Dr Layman for uh inviting me to celebrate with the students at Woodland it was a great uh activity and the kids really enjoyed and Mr Layman also got a p to the phase two as well so he was a good sport Dr lman I'm sorry he was a good sport but it was a great event after countless hour hours of preparation and promotion we unfortunately did not
212pass our referendum projects I want to thank our administrative team Mr Gorski Dr alvic Mr tag the board of education for their constant support during our presentations the building principles District content supervisors all of the parent organizations who rally behind our efforts especially want to thank uh mtea Jackie wners and bethanne aach and all of the residents they organized to help to promote the referendum it was very disappointing evening and though I respect the outcome and decision of the voters the need for the additional facility does not change I look forward to working with everyone on a solution to this issue failure and delay will compound this problem over time the progress of our district will eventually be challenged uh a number of years ago as uh you know being hired as a new principal
213of the high school I was challenged with uh increasing student achievement and making us uh competitive with our neighboring districts uh South Brunswick East Brunswick West Windsor um and we accomplished that uh once we got rid of the trailers my fear is by continual delay and failure um we will regress as a school district so I'm looking really forward to however the board wishes to proceed be an active part and participant in in uh making sure that our school school district is at its very best so uh we need a solution here on a better note but uh regrettably I wanted also to congratulate Miss Jackie wners at the Barkley Brook School Miss Karen Earl from the Middle School Miss Jan Jernigan from the high school Anna cabanisi a m Lake custodian for who submitted
214their retirement papers effective of July 1st uh in addition I missed an opportunity last month where Sharon aptaker from the high school and Faith felin from Oak Tree and Applegarth also submitted their retirements it's a tremendous loss to the school district and we wish them the very best in their next steps and I know um they'll finish up strong i m zap taker was at the cpag meeting the other night advocating for kids and Miss Winter's uh her advocacy of the uh School referendum she worked tirelessly uh but it's going to be a real loss to the district when we have to replace those individuals so I wish them well so with that Madame board president and members of the Board of Education it is recommended that Personnel action items a through a under the
215superintendent report be approved by consent roll call so move second um Mr tiella Mr ryack comments or questions for Mr Goodall Mr fryback uh I just just want to make a comment about the retirees certainly I wish all of them best of luck and I just to note that you know I've been able to work with Jackie wines for the past few years and very closely on this steering committee and she absolutely is an asset to that committee and asset this to this whole District um we're going to really miss her but I have a feeling she's going to be involved I hope so thank you Mr Chella uh same uh same uh ditto I say you know but um yeah uh Jackie wyers has been an asset I served on uh kids first under
216her under her leadership um and she taught me a lot about you know just about public service and a lot about um fighting for what you believe in and and how to and and just doing the right thing um and I and I'm I I'm gonna miss her personally I think she's been I think she's been a huge asset to our our our district and I also I I I consider Jackie a friend I also see that uh Miss Earl is retiring and she's also a friend of mine so uh every I I wish everyone well on here but those those two people are friends and I and I hate to see them retire although I'm happy for them and I'll never retire and you can't retire and Jackie wyers has had most of my
217children but the children that she has had is still probably double anybody else's children here that's it any other comments question president I have I want to say something about Jackie Winters too I've known her since the day I moved here um on a personal note one of my favorite things that Jackie Winters has done is square dancing second grade square dancing we can't forget that there is no one else that does that um but she has been um a great leader in that school I've worked with her many years as a PTA president at Barkley Brook and Brookside and she truly will be missed so I wish her the best of luck and all the other retirees somehow I think if we keep saying all these things she'll come back and she won't retire
218Mrs l i on that list um there it's sad when anybody retires but I just have to say something about Sharon aptaker as a case manager and an lbtc here in the high school she is so giving and so dedicated to her students and everything that she did to make sure that our special needs students were getting what they they actually required is is beyond and Sharon has been a blessing to my family as has Faith Vin been when she did speech therapy I think for four of my kids Ken I might win no and you know our relationship with Jackie Winters and Karen Earl is you know that will always be very special and my daughter still thinks of Hello Dolly every time we mention Jackie winter name because she used to sing Hello
219Dolly every time my daughter got off the school bus so I wish the best of luck to all of our retirees we will miss you greatly anyone else okay then we'll have a roll call on the superintendent report Personnel items Madam if I may before I take the Roll Call I also would like to chime in on the congratulations to Jackie winners working with her on and the mtea leadership over the years uh I've appreciated her fairness and and her support for the schools and the programs and and uh we're always able to meet in the middle even on some complex issues having to do with the gray areas of contract interpretation and I'll certainly miss her from a a business administration standpoint and we did spend and even with Mr Chella we spent a
220lot of time in negotiations with Jackie Winters a lot of nights yes a lot of nights yes she will be she will be missed yes thank you Mr rutsky I just feel sad I don't know Jackie oh you want me to vote Yes yes I feel like I obviously missed something you you did she's great Mr Tano yes Mrs Deo yes Mrs Lang yes Mr poori I will miss Jackie winter too and I want yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr tiella yes Mrs seagull yes Mrs arino yes Mrs K Pano yes Madam board president personal items a through a LS pass thank you madam board president and members of the Board of Education it is recommended that board action items a through S be approved by consent roll call so Mo second uh Mr cherella Mr
221Ryback again comments or questions for Mr Goodall Miss armeno yes on sorry bylaw um 0152 um it talks about uh not requiring uh on the second paragraph any member May place a memb name in uh nomination that is for when we uh do our uh when we vote for our officers our board officers and previously um there was no need for a second on a nomination and I think that's purposeful because uh that gives the minority an an an ability to nominate someone that doesn't require a second so I think that putting um and it's acknowledged here it says though not required a second is encouraged and permissible and I think uh that is um not good for the board uh it should it should be that any name could be nominated and then should
222be voted on but to require it doesn't require a second but it will be likely that a second will always be asked for and then again I think think that's a disadvantage to the minority on the board and I think that is not good for uh the way we should conduct business so I would be voting no on that again I ask my colleagues to consider that on um number uh 0164 on the agenda um it talks about uh the last paragraph or the second to the last paragraph talks about copies of theend this shall be distributed to the board prior to the meeting when possible and shall be made available for dist distribution to interested parties at the meeting and post it on District websites um I would ask that that be that when
223possible language be removed I think it's essential that members of the board certainly should have uh the agenda prior to the meetings and the agenda should be available to the public uh before a meeting and uh the above that and it talks excuse me and it talks about um the person uh the person presiding shall commence each meeting with the announcement of notice given for the meeting or a statement regarding the lack of adequate notice in accordance with the law I would ask that we insert the open public meetings act and any other pertinent law because this as well as this language is for the board members it is also for the public and I think if we uh let the public know what act and what law we are referring to they would have
224the opportunity to educate themselves and know what is going on so uh Mr Goodall if you can explain why uh you're recommending these changes I would appreciate it and then I have two more they came all on a recommendation from the board attorney and uh discussion uh at policy committee so do you think that my suggestions for change are in uh would you would you consider asking uh I mean none of these I I just think that it goes again to transparency and it helps uh the public understand what's going on so would you uh consider and maybe ask the uh committee to re-evaluate that language and perhaps reconsider it would you be willing to do that um I'll at this point I don't believe the policy chair and myself think it's appropriate to do
225that so um well it's a first reading so that's when it well we can accept the first reading and then if you would like to sub I can discuss it with the policy well I I have just submitted my request to Mr Goodall so I would hope that that would be taken into consideration um let me move forward on that since it's still on the first reading um policy number 7440 uh it talks about the last sentence when it talks about special risks um let me find that I'm hoping what determines a special risk again I think that's sort of a nebulous um statement and I would hope that we would have a little bit more defined understanding of what that means it's page two of two on School District security so that would be
226another thing I would ask to miss armeno with all due respect there is a a policy committee meeting and there is a meeting before the policy with the board attorney and if you these are recommended right if you don't like them just vote no on them we're not I would like the the public to be aware of what the reason for my voting no is and I will be voting no yes thank you very much but I think the public should know why I vote no not I'm not a contrar I think I have very good reasons um and and mostly because I'm hoping uh to protect the Public's interest so thank you for that but I I I think the public has a right to know why I'm voting no anyone else then we'll
227have a roll call board action items a through S on superintendent report Mrs Deo yes yes Mrs Lang yes Mrs armeno okay yes except for on in I bylaw 0152 bylaw 064 uh policy and regulation 7440 those are NOS all those three are no policy uh on the second reading uh policy 1110 the organizational chart and um that's it thank you Mr seagull yes Mr Tano yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr rutsky yes Mr cherel yes Mr blur yes Mrs kapano yes madame board president board action items a through s s p okay so we are on to the uh that concludes superintendent report okay I are we at the business administrator's report yes ma'am okay Madame board president and members of the Mona Township Board of Education it is recommended that board action items a
228through n as a Nancy be approved by consent roll call so move second oh Mr Chella Mr Mayo are there any comments or questions for Mr Gorski let good none Mr poori yes Mrs seagull yes Mrs Deo yes Mrs Lang Rees on E and yes on everything else so noted thank you Mrs armeno yes Mr Rybeck uh yes but I have to recuse on E my name so noted Mr ruty yes Mr cherella yes Mr Tano yes Mrs colano I yes to everything will recuse on letter e for myself so noted thank you um Madam board president board action items a through n has passed and that concludes my report thank you okay we will go to the um board president's report and this is be uh on regard to the superintendent search because we
229said that we would keep the public informed about the process of the superintendent search and at the last board meeting there was a question about having the board attorney working with the Board of Education um during the superintendent search because of the confidentiality of the process and because the board attorney works for the Board of Education it is appropriate for the board to work with her on the superintendent search so Mr Ryback and I met with her on February 21st to go over the process and the timeline for conducting the search and at the February meeting also the board approved doing an internal search only so we are currently working on a posting that will be sent out to all the schools on April 2nd and this date was chosen because we didn't want the
230search to interfere with the referendum the posting will be sent out to all the board members within the next day or two for your review before it's being posted in order to apply for the position a candidate would have to possess a school administrator certification interested candidates would be required to send a letter of interest and a resume in a sealed onvelope marked application for superintendent of schools and personel and confidential to the board president in care of Mary Smith all submissions will be available to be reviewed by all of the board members and it will be kept confidential every candidate that applies for the position will be interviewed and we will be scheduling special board meetings for those interviews uh I've asked the board members to contribute or sent to my um sent to
231me questions that are questions for the candidates that are Monro Centric and um it needs to be um just approved by the board attorney not for Content but for legalities and we don't have a specific time for appointing the next superintendent but our goal is to have somebody in place by July 1st and that concludes my report it's been a long meeting I needed to keep it short Madam president would would you place all the resumes that you receive on the board docks for the rest of members no you no we they will not be placed on anything electronically they will be kept sealed in Mary Smith's office you have the right to go there anytime you wish to review them and I would hope that anybody from the board uh takes the time to
232review them before we do the interviews but no they're not going to go on um email or anything like that thank you so we are at public forum anyone from the public wishing to speak please come to the microphone what about other board business oh other oh Jill I would like to did we stop okay I I apologize clearly there's no stop I'm just tring to go home oh that's because it's on a different page J no I because I don't have it that's why it's not here I don't have other board business on my agenda other board business I don't have it it's here no I have 14 and I have it's number M Mayo okay just two quick things I would like to thank the MTP mtea for supporting the referendum I know
233that they worked hard for our children um despite it not being passed so I want to thank them I would also like to thank the administration of Monroe Township School District Mr Goodall Mr Dr alvic Mr Gorski and Mr Tay who work tirelessly to educate the public about the referendum they are an amazing administrative team who deeply care about our children they have spent many evenings and weekends giving presentation and I want to thank them for this work and despite its failure they have shown how committed they are to our children and providing them the best education they can so thank you to them and the MTA any other board business Adam president oh go ahead you go first Mrs seagull sorry um first I want to thank the oak tree Applegarth PTA for inviting
234us to come read books to the students during read Across America week I have to say that was a lot of fun I went through I brought a big bag of books and I went through every single one of them so I did really enjoy I'm willing to read anytime so I'll put that out there to the principles um the next thing I wanted to update on Patty and I attended a school board sponsored Finance conference back in February um we participated in a General Session which featured an update from the state house we were shown a historical background video on how the school funding formula came about it took us through a chronological timeline dating back to the late 1800s to our current state um a presentation also was done on the state funding
235formula and what components make up that formula in addition they took us through um how they calculate and derive the P per puple cost so it was very well done presentation very informative and a couple other sessions we attended on um success how to run a successful school project such as building schools um capital projects and what to do when your projects are running into trouble in regards to schedule scope and cost uh they went through pros and cons of the low bidder which by state law schools have to go with the low bidder for projects and our last session focused on the hard times in education with the 2% Levy tax cap in effect school districts that lose State AIDS while other benefit and how to manage increasing costs and negotiation so it was
236very inform informative I would highly recommend if it does come up again for other board members to go because it did have a lot of good information thank you good anyone else Mrs Lang okay so I have three things um and I'll make it quick on March 9th I attended the Mind Monroe mindful Mentor programs uh presentation at the rec center of Monroe mindful mentors are part of the India us Forum of Monroe Township and this was a it was their women's History Month presentation and the the neatest thing is if you guys remember back to a couple months ago vishna Patel is a student at the high school she's in in 10th Grade she presented she actually manages this Monroe um the mindful mentors program where they team up high school kids with kids
237from the middle school and to down down to the elementary school and they work together on different projects and this month it was their focus on um on women's history and I I actually I walked out of there learning more about other W you know the great things that we women are doing and just felt very empowered and I think it's impressive that we have students that can mentor each other that can work together and they're building that relationship and um I think vishna Patel is a person that someday we're going to see doing great big things you did that on purpose no great big things in this world um but this is this is what I've been so excited about I I think we almost came to blows over who get to tell about
238this next thing our Mrs Dylan and and Kathy Dy in our school runs the Unified sports programs and she has been a Powerhouse of really bringing our special education students together with our typical what we call typical students and working together through Sports so it's an inclusive environment and we are thrilled that because of her hard work and the dedication New Jersey Special Olympics has invited our unified soccer team to represent New Jersey in a major league soccer program called the Major League Soccer unified Exchange program our unified soccer team will be this is so cool like this is you got just think about this right these are our our kids with disabilities and and some of them are more have are more involved than others but they're going to sign contracts like they're going
239to sign a contract to play for the Red Bulls like this is like for me they're going to get Red Bull uniforms they are also so um Special Olympics is flying these students to Kansas City to play a professional soccer game in in Kansas City on April 14th the Special Olympics is paying for everything it's all expenses paid red are paying for everything oh Red Bulls are pay sorry Red Bulls are paying for everything and then I think it's April 30th they are going to be playing at the Red Bulls arena in norc and it's going to be televised by ESPN so maybe like we can go and see them but our kids are going to have you know what an opportunity um to be able to do this and I'm just thrilled that we
240have had a board of education that supports Kathy Dylan in her work and that our kids are get that's an incredible opportunity so that's really good news I call field trip I think so I think we should all go and and somebody want to make a motion I'll make a motion I make a motion that the Board of Education attends the Red Bulls but okay Mr gorsky's dime and finally I just needed to add to what Mr Goodall said about um the cpeg we have a um Betty Saburo who would hate me saying her name it has been so wonderful working with Mr Goodall and with Monica Hines to get the cpeg um going and going forward I know at the end of our last meeting we had Parents walking out saying that this is
241an effect group because something was brought to the attention of the administration and Dr alvik Mr Goodall um Dr Rosel Mr Higgins and Monica and Marietta jumped right on it to solve this problem and I think as a parent of a special needs child I can share with you that it doesn't often move very fast and sometimes you feel like nobody's hearing you so I think that the idea that the cpag is is really going and that people are responding I think that's great the next meeting is actually April 6th and we're having an there an author his name is Carrie magro April 10th I said the wrong date again um Carrie mro he is a young man with autism and on the Spectrum he's auth also an author and an advocate and he's going
242to be presenting and then later in April um Mrs sabaro is trying to bring just the parents together of the cpeg so that they can talk about how they're going to organize their group a little bit better to kind of take the Reigns a little bit more so I just want to congratulate um everybody who's been helping with the cpeg because it's really good stuff and that's it Mr Ryback thank you well first I'd like to thank the Barkley Brook Brooks IPA for the donation of $10,000 to replace a marquee sign footside school that's really very generous yes I know must have taken a lot of hard work uh also um I have prepared a statement but most of it has been said already uh I just want to touch basic with how important it
243is to replace the school aid formula I came across a an article in NJ Spotlight called spelling out how school funding formula needs to be overhauled they're really saying it needs to be replaced and just briefly you know the current formula is designed to meet outcome standards that are over a decade old and based on conditions and costs from that period it's time for that formula to go and be replaced and I urge our state officials to um start working on a new one now and start putting it off Mr poori um not to extend the meeting any further but I will be remissed if I did not thank the District administration for a wonderful job you guys did and and also the rest of the colleagues On The Board of Education uh I don't
244think there's anything for us to be shameful that the uh referendum failed uh I really appreciate all your work and uh each every each and every one of us felt extremely passionate about winning about getting the referendum through uh and we will dust off get up and move again and I also want to thank everybody in the public who supported it uh for the right reasons uh one item that I do want to bring up is a couple of days ago in the nj.com uh newspaper there was an article about the grading of public schools um although some of these gradings have you know it doesn't give you the full story they're based on several different things our high school was scored at 65.0 Woodland School scored at 56.1 18 Brookside scored at 56.3 three
245and apple got at 67.8 4 the point is that they're in the mid-50s to mid-60s however our Middle School scored 35.7 uh when I when I look comp compared that to some of the Jersey City and Newark uh middle schools uh it's actually below some of those as well I would be really curious to see why our Middle School rated scored so low compared to other school systems uh again I'm not making a point about the referendum or anything uh I know that there is an issue at Middle School in terms of overcrowding uh is that directly related to the score or are there other issues I request uh Mr would all to look into it and get back to us oh sure meeting thank you anyone else okay anyone from the public wishing to
246speak please come to the microphone state your name and address for the record hello Chrissy scurby 21 prnis Drive um I just wanted to touch on what Dr alvic was saying earlier um with the AVID program being piloted next year at Woodland I think that is an excellent idea um I do have my middle schooler um enrolled in the AVID program right now um and it's I've see a complete difference in her experience in middle school and versus my son and um I think that the district should look toward extending the AVID program I i' much rather see as a parent the AVID program become our standard um Avid is not about extra help it's about pushing kids and giving them the tools for them to be successful so teaching organization showing them how to
247create study guides showing giving them the resources for them to make the most out of their education um I didn't know much about Avid when my son was in Middle School so he didn't take advantage of that but I learned a lot from it um based on what other I knew other students were in it so I'd like to see the district possibly instead of having a an application process where you have to be interviewed and go through a rigorous process to get into this program I think that should be the basis of what we're teaching our students across the district every student should be shown how to create a study guide how to make the most of their education it shouldn't be you know you you interview and you get into this program it
248should that that should be what we are striving for making every student have the ability to succeed um not just a certain group thank you sure um thank you for that um one couple of things that we are doing to expand the strategies that Avid um provides students so I know that Avid is a very specific program so it does require the application process it does require the electives at the middle and the high school um but a couple things that we've done is we've Incorporated Abid strategies into every one of our professional development courses that we offer so every one of our trainers in the district has been trained in Avid strategies to try and make sure that more teachers learn about the Avid strategy so that they can incorporate them into their classrooms
249the middle school does a lot of professional development after school with the Wicker program um I know uh Mrs Chanley Mr Higgins um Mr Higgins is the site coordinator for Avid at the middle school they have teachers who have been to the summer Institute for Avid that have learned the strategies TurnKey them to the staff at the middle school so they have done a lot of that to try and do exactly what you're saying get the strategies into more teachers hands so that we can get it into more students hands at the elementary level it's not a an interview process at the elementary level it is teaching all the teachers the strategies for so that students learn those strategies from early on sure and and I'm as a parent of a middle school and high
250schooler I would I would like to see us move in that direction where everybody has that because it it absolutely I I see it in my own children it makes a huge difference um to the way the students learn and and what they can achieve and it is a wonderful program it just I would hate for it to be a program I would like to see it as the curriculum here in Monroe thank you anyone else wishing to speak seeing none we'll close the public forum and go to the Clos session resolution be it resolved that the Board of Education of the township of Monroe hereby moves to go into Clos session in accordance with Sunshine Law chapter 231 of the public laws of 1975 njsa 10 colum 4-6 through 10 colum 4-21 to discuss
251the following subject harassment intimidation and bullying following closed session action may be taken the discussion conducted in closed session can be disclosed to the public at such time as the need for confidentiality no longer exists so move Miss Deo Mrs Miss Mrs Lang all in favor opposed okay at this time we'll move into close session okay seeing no one in the public our next scheduled Board of Education meeting and there is a change will be on Tuesday April 30th 7:00 p.m. at the Monro Township High School motion to adjourn Mr Chella Mr Mayo all all in favor oppos then the meeting is adjourned