CorpusRecord 133001

Monroe Township Board of Education 02.13.19 Regular Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Monroe Township School District
Date
2025-02-11
Location
Middlesex County, NJ
Material
Transcript
Extent
22,844 words · about 127 min
Collected
2026-06-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001good evening the meeting of the Monroe Township Board of Education will come to order please stand as our student board member leads us in the Pledge of Allegiance I pledge of allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible liberty and justice for all may we have a roll call Mr Gorski certainly Mrs armeno here Mr cherella here Mrs Deo here Mrs K Pano here Mrs Lang here Mr poori Mr Rybeck here Mr seagull here Mr Tano here Mr rutsky here Madame board president you have a quarum present this evening thank you in accordance with the provisions of the New Jersey New Jersey open public meetings law the Monroe Township Board of Education has caused notice of this meeting to be

002published by having the date time and place thereof posted February 8th 2018 20 9 excuse me at all schools the home News Tribune the cranberry press and filed with the clerk of the municipality thank you at this time we'll go to the approval of minutes for the public Board of Education meeting organ is public Board of Education organization meeting of January 3rd 2019 I need a motion in a second so moved second miss armeno Mr Tano are there any additions or corrections to the minutes seeing none all in favor I I opposed abstain recuse then everybody is in favor the approval of the minutes for the public Board of Education meeting of January 23rd 2019 so moved second Mrs Lang Mr Ryback again additions or corrections to the minutes seeing none all in favor opposed

003abstain or recuse everybody is is uh approving and the approval of minutes for the closed session meeting of January 23rd 2019 so move Mr Ryback second second by who would like that pat patty would like that Mrs Lang again additions or corrections to the minutes seeing none all in favor I opposed abstain or recusals then everybody is in favor we have quite a few presentations on our agenda this evening so the first one will be um Woodland Mill Lake student council I'm going to turn this over to Dr Alvi okay I have the pleasure of introducing two mtea Pride presentations this evening our first one is from Mil Lake Woodland schools these are the mil Lake and Woodland student councils under the direction of Mr Doug Dale and Miss Trish Abrams at both schools and

004they were um involved in a wonderful fundraising activity for another member another family in our community so I will turn it over to Mr Dale and Miss saams hello everyone thank you uh I'm Doug Dale student council advisor from Woodland School along with Trisha Abrams the student council advisor of M Lake School and the student council members here in attendance from both schools everyone say hi hi hello we are honored to have been invited to tonight's board meeting to report on an event the students came up with to help the local family in need um this family was a Monroe family and it uh the the story is that when uh I Dro my daughter off at mil Lake in the morning I come up Tindale Avenue and saw one day that there was a

005fire a house caught on fire um it was uh pretty badly burned um I went to school the next day that day and I was talking about it in the uh in the main office with some of the secretaries and the one of the secretaries Mrs Lobo actually knew who lived there and heard about the fire um she said that there it was uh the dad got badly burned uh the house was burned so they can't they they can't live there um so we started talking about that at this our student council meeting and the kids thought it was a great idea to do some fundraising for um their family and see what their needs were so we reached out and turned out that on Friday February 1st um actually I need the uh I

006need a slide clicker anybody got the slide clicker yeah you working now oh all right good thanks so there's a picture of the house actually on Tindale Avenue I got that from the fire department website um what had happened was the uh the dad was cooking and uh left something on the stove and fell asleep um the house caught on on fire right stair is where his kitchen was and um he was pulled out by uh some people some neighbors actually pulled him out of the house um he mentioned at our event when he when he showed up that he he tried to go back into the house and that's how he got burned um he tried to save some of his animals um and he got burned um Alex here Alex her uncle lives

007actually next door and was one of the one of the uh neighbors that helped him get out of the house so um but on Friday on uh you can go to the next slide please on uh Friday of the um February 1st we held a combined Woodland Mill Lake fundraiser to raise money for this family um like I said he lives nearby Woodland School right across the street from Woodland in between mil Lake and Woodland um one of the goals of our student council this year uh both student councils is to inspire civic responsibility and duty to the community and this fundraiser hit the hit that Mark the students came up with an idea to do a joint School pajama day for Don ation of $3 in addition to that they thought of having an

008assembly and inviting many guests who came including the family who we were doing the fundraiser for uh which is called Help which is actually the hod family um they um the mayor and members of the Town Council were there the school administration was there and the school board president and several school board members were also in attendance which we thank you guys for coming out to that was awesome and the kids loved it the kids love you know when when when I started telling them that the school board was showing up to the event uh they all got a little nervous we're like oh what is she the president of is she the president of the United States um it's got a lot of questions but they were inspired by you guys showing up we

009really appreciate that um on uh onto slide two there you should you see the uh Woodland student council what we did is to prepare for the fundraiser we started with uh a combined mil Lake and Woodland student council meeting through a Skype call um this is the Woodland student council in uh on our side of it if you go to the next slide you can see the uh that's the from the behind that's the mil Lake on on the the the computer and on the and projected on the wall there and we're all talking back and forth uh about some of the ideas that we were going to come up with for and suggestions that we were going to come up with for the for the event um on the next slide uh during that

010event this is those are the that's the hod family um that's Mr hod uh next to the podium and his and his children um his children are former mil Lake and Woodland School students um they are all both in college at this point um but we thought that you know listen these are people that went through our schools and some of us could have known them as teachers and staff uh and some of us did and so we decided to do this fundraiser for them because they were a local family that that you know we do a lot of fundraising and a lot of things for uh bigger Charities uh you know breast cancer awareness autism awareness and things like that and this really hit home to a lot of the kids and and they

011all came up the suggestions to do all of this and it was it was an idea that I um I uh introduced them to and they they they just ran with it so uh during the during the event we held an assembly in the gym with uh our special guests that were there um next slide shows the m l student council members um there's the mil Lake right there um they were watching the assembly from their school again through a Skype call um and they were projected on the the wall behind us so the people that were in attendance got to see it and the the the mil Lake students that were involved got to see it also mil mil Lake they uh coordinated all of the the pajama party pajama day uh donations and

012everything at their school and my guys here coordinator at Woodland um on the next slide is our president here Kaden sapola she is the student council president at Woodland School she spoke about the amazing efforts of the student bodies and their selfless involvement in helping this cause um the next slide shows our student council treasurer Julia Arts there she is our secretary Christina padulla okay and our public relations organizer pah G Ramen somewhere there she is um they presented the amount of our collection and the big check which is on the next uh slide I believe there we go uh to the hod family now the students of mil Lake and Woodland raised $2,600 in just that one day couple of the next slides shows uh Mr hods speaking about the fire and his recovery

013um he's doing well they are not back in their house just yet um it is not he from what uh councilman depiro said being also the fire chief at one point um and involved in the fire department he said that uh their house is not habitable they cannot even go back in to get things out of it so they've been out of it the fire happened in November so we we tried to raise some money for two things one uh for Mr Hood's medical bills we we understood that his insurance did not cover a lot of the time he spent in the hospital and two them obviously living in a hotel while their house is being uh looked at and and uh you know fixed up so so there they needed some they needed the

014money um we reached out to them see if they needed any clothes or anything for their animals unfortunately a lot of their animals perished in the fire um they did not need any clothes or anything like that so uh Kate hod who was the daughter just mentioned said you know if you could raising money for us would just be the best thing so you know $2,600 in one day just out of students wearing the pajamas was a great goal past our goal actually um the next slide um oh and also in that slide I'm sorry mayor Toro said some wonderful things about Mr hod and his involvement with the town little did we know that Mr Ho actually worked for the town of Monroe and uh he was um well known around the town I

015I noticed that in a couple of places around town they were doing fundraisers for them also um in the next slide at the conclusion of the assembly the guest joined the mil Lake student council and if you see on both on the left side is all of the Woodland student council the character crew our special guests and you know the the Hodes and the big check and on the right side is the mil Lakes side is all of the mil Lake student council and administration and it was nice that the mayor and all of you guys uh showed up at mil Lake afterwards to to see the students there they were like I said they were Beyond excited about having having you know just the special guests there and uh everyone I think was in

016awe of the event and and the kids really had a great time in um pulling it off so congratulate to them uh and the next um in addition to the pajama day collection um The District staff donated another $11,000 to uh make a grand total of this contribution to the hod family which is there's uh Kaden sapolo and I um presenting Mr hod with the final check which ended up being $3,624 so great [Applause] day uh this was a this was an allout full District effort that came together quickly and would not have been possible if not for the efforts of both the students in mil Lake and Woodland uh they really are an incredible group of good people that do good things for a good cause and when they went above our expectations to

017help their fellow mil Lake and Woodland School family um I want to thank you guys and all for allowing us the time tonight to you know bring this presentation um the Hodes do have a GoFundMe page that we were going to contribute but they said they would rather just i' ra it was easier just to give them a check because they you know GoFundMe me takes a little bit of a percentage out um so if anybody still wants to get involved I know their goal was about $25,000 and um when we started this this uh uh idea they were around 12 and you know we gave them uh 3600 and uh you know so there's still some things to do so if you if you just search the Hodes on on the GoFundMe page but

018I want to thank um a few people you guys especially for allowing us to do this uh our administration at both schools were so incredibly involved in it uh the uh the the the family members of and the parents that sent in money and contributed well above what we expected to get um some of the you know the the goal was $3 per kid but some some parents sent in checks for 50 $200 I mean it was amazing the outpouring of of uh of contributions from the families um I'd also like to thank the kids the kids did a great job and I know it's just PJ day to them but to the rest of our community it was really a great event and um they definitely take all the credit for it so thank

019you all for having us tonight and um go [Applause] FC I'd like to thank our students also I was very honored to be invited to this wonderful assembly and I was so impressed with our kids to come up with this idea because at such a young age they're so civically responsible and we find that in Monroe that when there's somebody in a time of need we all get together and and reach out and do whatever we can to support them so I'd like to thank all of our students for doing this this was a wonderful effort on your part and so much appreciated by the h family and we are so excited that you as young young students will grow up to be very civically responsible to everybody thank [Applause] you okay so uh Dr

020alvik I think you have the next presentation also I do so our Middle School Builders Club is also here this evening under the direction of Mr Fields they are a service or service leadership organization at our middle school and they have done a lot of activities and service projects this year to um again do some fundraisers help the community and also to help them become better leaders so Mr Fields good evening my name is Daniel fields and I along with Danielle samit are the co-advisors of the Monro Township Middle School Builders Club the builders Club is a service leadership organization and program that give students the opportunity to develop their leadership skills and abilities while volunteering and doing charitable work next slide please um so as you can see up there there's a quanis family

021tree um one of the great things about um the quanis family is that um there's different level of of service leadership and Builder Club is just one small part of that um so the Builder Club is actually part of this like great um international service organization that has opportunities from the club the state and the international level and um these students are given the opportunity in a sense to to fail and make mistakes and the philosophy behind the quanis service program is that they are given those opportunities to be mentored by advisers um to interact with a community to make mistakes learn how to serve uh their community so that one day they be they become more involved in the in the larger Community um so tonight the Builder Club is going to talk a

022little bit about why they are passionate about service so uh can you guys give a big round of applause we're [Applause] excited good good evening I'm Steven Yuro chairman of the Builder Club social committee my favorite thing about Builder Club is being able to help people who need it for example the blessing bags which help homeless people by giving them things they need such as food water deodorant razors Etc um my favorite thing about the blessing bags is hearing people's stories on how they got into their situation one example is Steve he had congestive heart failure and his on disability so he was very thankful for what we were able to to give him because he can not get a lot this made me smile and appreciate what I have and grateful for everyone and

023everything in my life thank [Applause] you hello everyone my name is suu dunga and I am Web Master chairman of the Builder Club what I love about Builder Club Is How We Run The fundraisers and what they achieve some of them include Pajama Day superhero day and hat day the students find these events enjoyable so they love participating in them also when our club hosts bigger events that have a bigger workload some of the students help and pitch in this makes it so that it's not only the club helping but the entire student body too along with that anything and everything we earn is sent out to help people whether it's giving the homeless giving the homeless food or giving the needy things they need like the blessing bags I can be happy knowing that

024somebody out there is grateful for what we've done everybody wins thank you [Applause] hello and good evening everyone my name is arini Sharma and my role in Builder Club is the keepi committee chairwoman so what I love in Builder Club is the advertising so in the club we have different methods for advertising our different events and our different projects one important method being the club's bulletin board the bulletin board is a huge board in the mtms cafeteria that shows the different projects that we have coming up and the keepay committee updates it on a regular basis another important method that we have is the Flyers uh this is my favorite part of Builder Club because students get to express their creativity and they also get to learn the they also get to learn um the

025importance of advertising during different campaigns and various events thank [Applause] you good evening my name is Danielle Yousef and I the Secretary of Builders Club my favorite thing about Builders Club is the Community Food Bank there we serve meals like chicken FM meatloaf and brownies to us that may not be much but to the people attending they enjoy it when I handed them the food their smile was so big that I saw that they were thankful for them to know that someone took the time out of their day to feed them there are students in this community who want to be more involved and Builders Club is a great opportunity to do that thank you [Applause] good evening my name is ARA and I'm the treasur of builders's Club my personal favorite thing about being

026a part of builders's Club is how great an impact make on the people we help for instance the builders Club had a project of Distributing socks to the individuals who require it the most the project was extremely successful and raised over 2,500 socks and one woman named dot sent the buers cup her thanks and in the letter she had stated you really shocked me with giving me all those socks for the needy what a blessing and I'll make sure they go to those who really need them even though I didn't know her her letter made a huge impact on me knowing that you cared about what we had done I also admire how helpful we can be without acknowledging it when the student body donated socks to the builders Club they didn't know how many

027people it would help but they knew it would help someone and our job as a club is to make sure we can carry this out and help as many people as possible this is important because a lot of people has impression and intention and we helped even more people than we could imagine this is my favorite thing about being a part of B Club thank you good evening everyone my name is Guy TR Kony and I'm the proud vice president of Builders Club my favorite aspect of Builders Club is the democracy and Leadership part of it when I was running for vice president last year I had to make a speech in front of the entire Club stting why I would be the perfect candidate to be vice president this was a new experience for

028me and I really enjoyed it outside of school I do a leadership program called Toast Masters and in that program your adviser picks whether you're president or vice president so when Builder Club introduced this new type of leadership and democracy to me I instantly fell in love with it builders's Club also makes sure that we exit as Leaders when we exit our club one way we do that is by doing happy thoughts at the end of all of our meetings happy thoughts is a chance for every Club member to stand up and state something positive about their day in the end builder's club make sure that we're leaders and not followers thank you good evening Board of Education my name is Son kakumanu and I'm the proud president of Builder Club I genuinely love Builder

029Club because if it of its potential for growth in sixth grade I was The Bu the book quiet kid until I joined Builder club and was welcomed with open arms and I got Insight on how the lead on the leadership aspect of running the club it wasn't until seventh grade where I became secretary where I learned the intense effort and work we put into our projects even more so when I became president I was able to understand the potential we have in our members to get involved with service for our club to have an impact on our community and school and even more so the same potential in myself to grow moving forward I'll be getting into my high school years and I can use the experiences experiences I've had from Builder Club to become

030a better leader and future member of Kanis and more importantly make an impact on my community in the end we all join for our different reasons but we all say say we all join and we stay for our same reason thank [Applause] you thank you thank you for giving us the opportunity to speak about our wonderful Monro Township Middle School Builders Club thank you thank thank you for coming to see us today and to give us an understanding or more better understanding of what the builders Club does and again we have young children here and or young students here getting involved with fundraising and helping out those less fortunate in the community so thank you [Applause] okay next on our agenda is Middle States accreditation middle State Mr Goodall good evening everyone clearly we do

031a lot of great things in our district we have great schools in Monroe Township uh but often times we want some independent evaluation and validation of what we do Monro Township High School from roughly 1999 on uh has been involved in the middle state Association well they where they accredit your school for the programs that you run uh your academic programs your uh curriculum that you develop of your co-curricular programs your athletic programs how you handle School discipline how you run your and maintain your buildings and Facilities so it's a pretty comprehensive uh validation of what you do and periodically you go through a starting point a midpoint review and then you go through through the process again so uh tonight we have from the high school Miss Danielle drust she's a teacher of biology

032she's also the coordinator of the science department and she was very brave enough to take on this task of coordinating 225 staff members at the high school to come to a common ground uh and put together a presentation as we look towards our Middle School visitation next week M Russ thank you it's going to be a very tough Act to follow those kidss were wonderful so um my presentation's a little more dry I apologize um ellot so I just want to um explain a little bit about what we're going to be doing in the accreditation process um basically we are looking as Mr Goodall says as objective measures of school quality and student achievement while Al also fostering the uh continuing idea of school Improvement movement um the process begins when the school conducts a

033very comprehensive self-study and evaluation and submits to a very rigorous um peer review process a group from the middle States Association will be coming to our school evaluating us on 12 standards as well as our institution's own personal plan for growth once the group uh visit is complete the determination will be made if if our continuation of accreditation will be re awarded um the dates for our visit are March 19th through March 21st 2019 these are the 12 standards that are set forth by middle States um we have had to provide a lot of documentation to illustrate how our school is in most cases exceeding these standards um such as our facilities our school organization our wonderful staff the tremendous educational programs that we run um the amazing amount of Student Activities and sports that

034we offer so when looking at these standards it's really an opportunity for us to show off um how wonderful our district is doing and um some of the great programs that we run in our school so um it also provides us though the opportunity to examine the school and Implement a plan to work on areas that need Improvement um just so you know the middle States Association recommends that we need at least three objectives which I'll be going over in a few short moments two of the objectives have to focus directly on student achievement the other one is the third is what they call organizational capacity something that will help the overall School Organization um much like a classroom rubric uh that we would use to Grade Student Success we went through as I said

035this very extensive selfs survey as well as self- evaluation to try to determine areas that we could work on as a school organization so a survey was sent out to all staff students and parents um we tabulated all that data and uh we again as I've been saying have been reflecting on those 12 standards as well as other areas that we would need to improve on as a school community the middle State's review cycle is for seven years so all of the goals you're going to be seeing are going to seem very long reaching because that's the point of them so our first goal which is more of our um student academic goal we said by the year 2027 the students at Monroe Township High School will demonstrate improved academic skills and abilities as indicated

036by proved critical reading and math skills by a 3% increase in our sat um erw English Reading Writing as well as our SAT Math scores so our scores are very good but we want to always have room for improvement so um this was a goal that we that we felt we could manage our second goal can't see that is that um by 2027 students at Monroe Township High School will have an increased knowledge of career preparation skills I apologize that it's so small um this will be by a 2% increase in exposure to programs such as Avid and using Avid strategies in the classroom a two 2% increase or 3% increase in the number of students involved in the academic acmy that we have at the high school and by 2025 we're hoping that 85%

037of students will complete the career um profiler found on navian and use that tool more to its advantage to give them some ideas about future career goals and our third and final goal again had to do more with not so much student achievement but with um the organization itself and we said in this goal that we were going to improve um District communication between all stakeholders including parents staff students um the one key Lynch pin we felt in all of this was that we would be moving over to the school learning program so that everyone is in contact we also hope to increase our social media presence on Twitter and Instagram by having more parents and students seeing the wonderful things that we're doing and also just having more of the community involved with receiving

038things like the Falcon flyer which indicates the great things going on within the community now the one thing that is not included in this presentation because I tried to compress it is that all for all of these goals we we have action plans that we're going to be undertaking to try to make these goals a reality um there will be a midpoint review where we check in check how we're doing with our data and much like an sgo we get to change as the organization changes because we are a living School District that's going to be facing different challenges as we move forward thank you open up to the if you have any questions so just curious if we get the accreditation if we're blessed how long is that just for one year or is

039it a three year five year seven a seven year cycle excellent seven years is a good time that way yeah we don't want to do it every three years right right that's a lot of work anyone else have a question okay thank you very much Mr R thank you for all the work you did uh and I know firsthand when I got started with you in doing that it's it's not a report rep that a principal or Dr Ava can write about a school it comes Grassroots from the teaching and support staff and she did an incredible amount of work to put this together so thank you very much thank you okay our next presentation we will be honoring our support staff of the year with a plaque and Mr Goodall and Dr Alik and

040Mr orski if you would so each year um we recognize our support staff that are an integral part of our organization our our support staff members of the of the Year provide our teachers our administrators and most importantly our students with Incredible support throughout the school year they essentially uh make our finally tuned clock click they are the people who work in the background they are the secretary they are the bus driver maintenance cons cians they do an incredible job supporting everyone in the school district so if they're in the audience tonight we'd like to show them a token of our appreciation with the plet to to uh come on up and once we call your name if you could uh stay there so we could take a picture that would be great okay from

041the Woodland School Deborah peny py can you help us [Applause] from Oak Tree Daniel Fredericks [Applause] you Mo my computer too it's okay Stacy daversa mil Lake School I think I'm feel I'm [Applause] So Lisa Romano Brookside School [Applause] Andrea Marsh Monroe Township High School Francine sarento Barkley Brook [Applause] School chair [Applause] Carol majusi transportation department [Applause] Christopher Beerman appleg School [Applause] and Louise Balman Monroe Township Middle School [Applause] back to the Reg okay our last presentation of the evening is something we look forward to every year it's the 201728 comprehensive annual financial report and I will turn uh the program over to Mr Gorski thank you madam it's my pleasure to introduce Mr Gerald stankowitz of Samuel kleining company the board appointed auditor to give a presentation to the board on the results of

042the June [Applause] audit he might have to use her yeah pass that down good evening uh members of the board uh Administration and board president um can't go any further we're pleased need that one's that we're I'm pleased to be here tonight to present the audit and in following with all the prior presentations this evening I have actually good news as well um we issued the audit last Wednesday the audit was on delay there was some new accounting pronouncements that were believe it or not released in June of 15 that were applicable to the school year ended June 30th of 18 that the not the department of Ed but the Department of Treasury division of pension and benefits did not release until two weeks ago and we needed time to assimilate that information into the

043main cafra and to look at the accounting ramifications of it and for the record there really are none other than Note disclosures because the information they released is not the obligation of the board there are numbers that are allocated to the board based on the number of employees however this board's not paying for it it's involved the tpaf and PS post-retirement benefits so that information added about eight pages to the audit however there's really no Financial impact to the district at this time so basically the audit which uh we view as a joint venture with the business office the finance department uh sort of a yearr round uh Venture um there's dialogue constantly questions answers concerns uh bouncing stuff off of us to see what we think so it's not just the uh month of

044August and September it's it's a yearr round uh situation an audit is a sample well the root word of audit it the word comes out audition so it's a sample and basically um what we what we end up with during an audit is we do testing we test Revenue we test expenses we test payroll we test the the bank reconciliations uh we test the enrollment counts we test compliance of various different items which I'll get into briefly but the uh what you have in front of you are two separate documents there's a thick document which is the caffer the comprehensive annual financial report it's actually the board's document the board's finance office document and the board's document and inside this document the only thing that belongs to us is our independent Auditor's opinion and to

045get to the chase the independent auditor opinion expresses what's known as an unmodified opinion in the old days it was known as an unqualified opinion and in layman terms it's a clean opinion and what it means is that based on our testing and our good results that the records as presented by the business office the finance department were presented fairly in conformance with uh accounting principles related to school districts okay the governmental Accounting Standards Board which is this National oversight group mandates and dictates what procedures we have to follow I believe only two states in the country don't follow gby for school districts I don't know which ones they are but they're not they're not in the Northeast so um basically inside this document and I want to refer you to um page nine uh

046page nine just to give you an idea we're engaged to be the independent Auditors okay to give a report on the financial statements so you'll see the first bullet there is report on financial statements Management's responsibility which would be Mike Gorski Laura Allen and her the whole business office their responsibility is to present us with the financial statements they present us with financial records General ledgers expenditure reports revenue reports Bank reconciliations as well as all the invoices and supporting documentation for virtually everything that occurred every transaction that occurred during the year those transactions are subject to our testing so we give we're going to give a report management gives up the records our responsibility is to an Express opinion on those records okay so again we we we issue which is on the next page

047the opinion it doesn't say unmodified but it means unmodified what it what it means is the records as presented present fairly the in all material respects the respective financial position of government entity activities which is your main business fund I'm sorry your main operating fund your business activities which is your food service your early childhood and your Falcon care okay and also your trust funds so in that regard based on our testing we're giving you what's what is known as an unmodified opinion although it does say present fairly fairly does not mean as in Fair good poor excellent it means it's a proper representation of the records as well as uh in this report there's other lengthy verbiage about the operation of the municipality which is contained in the management discuss I'm sorry the district

048there's a management discussion and Analysis which is actually the administration's representation to the board about items relative to the district some of it converts our audit report into more user friendly um let's say language and user friendly presentation but it's also a chance for the district as a whole to toot its horn that's contained in the mdna in The Upfront section other sections which I want to point out contain various financial information and you know the old joke about people maintaining two sets of books well we have three sets of books okay we have our basic financial statements we have our uh conversion to generally accepted accounting principle of financial statements and then we have our conversion to the gby required financial statements the gby basically converts your basic financials which we'll get to to

049more of a corporate model where we measured the appreciation we measure long-term liabilities we measure compensated absences it tries to convert convert it to a corporate mold to see okay what does it really cost to run the district okay it's cumbersome it's been in effect for the past 25 years and every year they add more requirements to it which also push the ability of Auditors to issue the report on time back even further okay so inside the document there's different financial statements but I want to just highlight critical ones for you um page 5 is your business type activities and business type activities are are activities that could otherwise be performed by a corporate commercial entity for example Food Service Early Childhood enrichment and Falcon care okay those are not in the regular mainstream of

050your your general fund which is where your budget is and uh you just want to point out to you that your your food service fund which is about a $3 million year operation okay is Sol and doesn't have a loss you're you're not allowed to lose money but you're not allowed to make too much money so it's it's in a good position your Early Childhood enrichment is is a positive 192,000 and your Falcon care is a positive 1.2 million however 600,000 of that is being brought over into the general fund as a revenue item in your 1819 budget so I want to just point out that those those funds were uh properly maintained and all the records were actually actually in very good shape another section of the order I want to direct you to

051is page where are we page 107 and you kind of need to turn the book sideways that's called your general fund it's a $120 million operation okay um it is where all your main expenditures occur salaries health benefit methods teaching supplies books all the Specialists that you hire all the special fees that you pay for handling special kids tuition to the special schools for all the kids and it it just it just contains a lot of information on a line byline basis as to exactly you know what was spent by the district during the year and again every year that somewhere maybe it's in Washington they expand the the chart of accounts because there's always someone looking at school districts and trying to figure out you know what are we spending it on and what's

052the result so again we we test for that that coding as well but I want to direct you to page 107 okay to the actual column there's a recapitulation of fund balance halfway down the page okay now I'll give you the components because I don't want to give you or the impression or the public the impression that we have all this money because quite frankly it's spoken for example 125,000 is for incumbrances those items that weren't delivered before year end but we're still out there as a purchase order 6,44 that's a revenue item in your 1819 budget and for all intents and purposes it it's been absorbed in your 1819 budget and it's gone the next one which results from your operations from 201718 is excess surplus of $5 million that's mandated for uh uh

053Miss that's mandated for use in your 1920 budget that's the statute work that way you also have a capital reserve which is a wonderful thing to have you have 980,000 however 890 of that is being used in your 1819 budget for Capital related expenses the last number then is 2.1 million 2.17 uh $2,157 th000 which is uh the 2% ceiling that you're allowed to keep in the old days we call that the free balance okay and the old days weren't that long ago but but the the that would be your free balance it can be eaten into but that's what the statute allows you to keep a reserve in case you have a problem you know money to roll forward into subsequent years so although it looks like a big number it it's spoken for

054in various components the rest of the document contains notes the financial statement which describe all the accounting requirements that you're supposed to follow um and again it keeps it getting expanded year after year and quite frankly I think the Lords of the profession have made it too complicated okay and but we have to follow it we put a lot of time in making sure your disclosures are proper because believe or not somebody soon will be reading that if your referendum is successful they'll be looking at this document quite closely and they will be looking at and look favorably upon your mdna which describes a lot about the district so yeah and it has information that you know appears in corporate uh it appears in corporate reports as well I don't really look at a lot

055of corporate reports but I used to do corporate and I know some of the disclosures are exact they want to know about your debt they want to know about your fixed assets your other liabilities it's all contained in there okay but like I said also a lot of information on pension a lot of information on postretirement uh benefits which is mostly medical benefits th those are at least 25 pages of stuff that we had to add in the past few years for information purposes okay some of the numbers look and the allocated numbers towards Monroe are in these notes and they are absolutely staggering okay but they're not immediate liabilities they're theoretical in that they're actuar determined and quite frankly they could with the changing of interest rates they could change every 15 minutes okay

056but the numbers are in there it gives you a rough idea as to what the obligation is for the board and in two cases there is no obligation because by Statute it's paid by the state okay so it's just information so you can see what it actually costs on behalf of the district it's actually called a special funding situation and it's quite popular in the country and it's in your notes it's an obligation of the state it actually appears in the state audit they they have to book it as a liability and it's just an incredible number so the rest of the financial statement document the Caff which again is it's really representations of the board and all we merely do is audit it and help the finance office kind of move it into uh

057report format there's another section it's called the statistical section the J section we call it gives a 10e history of a lot of information uh of the of the municipality okay and it talks things about things like rable base uh borrowing capacity tax rate information largest taxpayers of which you have some seriously large taxpayers um and it talks about taxes your your borrowing capacity so it's a lot of information that will be looked at closely eventually so basically in this document it it's it's a reflection of the board it's a document that we kind of quarterback putting together but really it's it's overseen by and proof read by the finance offic because it's it's your information okay in a corporate setting the auditor doesn't put the report together the auditor is handed the report we

058we're we're very close to that actually here the other document the thinner of the two is actually my representation the board if you'll note you'll see on the thick document there is no uh there is no gold lettering but on the thinner one there is cu that's my representation to to the board now we we have an unmodified opinion and we got there because we had successful results in all of our testing so I'm going to just highlight some of the things quickly okay that that are key and just for the record before we issued the report uh we had a a required exit conference with management of the district and uh which included uh Mr Goodall Mr Gorski Laura Allen uh who's the assistant CFO of the of the district um and we we

059discussed you know or we really didn't have any finances us we actually reviewed the report made sure everything was in order made sure the numbers agreed to what the district felt um how did we get there well number one no matter how fancy of an audit you want or get cash is still King your bank reconciliation ations agreed to the penny to the general ledger 100% of the time next we Ed expenditures the four important things in expenditures are a all expenditures were properly documented B they were properly coded with respect to budget account which as I said before was critical because somewhere in this world someone's looking at individual line items and although we might think it's ridiculous it means something to some bureaucrat somewhere looking at what we spent on security or administrative

060technology or whatever so everything's properly coded um it's cut off properly with respect to the fiscal year so if a bill is paid in July August or September okay and it relates to the period end of June 30th it was properly cut off it's set up as an account payable that's also a corporate type thing but that worked its way into the uh School Board auditing ring about 35 years ago when they felt that it was necessary to move towards more proper accounting and year- end cut off and the fourth thing which is important with expenditures is that we're in compliance with the public school contracts law we prepare a test we review various expenditures uh throughout the year as part of our testing as well as a more focused test for any uh for

061compliance with the public school contracts law right now because of the size of the district uh the board has elected and has appointed Mike Gorski as the chief purchasing official who's also a qpa it's called the qualified purchasing agent that raises your uh threshold for bidding up to 40,000 as opposed to 29,000 it also raises your threshold for obtaining quotes Okay which it goes from it's 15% of your bid threshold so that amount is $6,000 also the district fortunately is involved in a lot of purchasing co-ops okay which takes the pressure off of the purchasing people to you know not not to violate the bid law or the quote law so we're the district is involved in a lot of Cooperative purchasing Arrangements they set up throughout the state they're all approved by the state

062so so I think there's been a lot of savings here I know Mr Gorski may have information on the actual savings so in that area we expenditures overall outstanding payroll we spend a lot of time on payroll obviously it's your biggest expense uh the payroll department is set up to provide an adequate audit Trail okay uh we spent a lot of time down in that basement with Matt and the his two assistants um we check to make sure that the gross payroll on a sample basis is properly paid we check to make sure their withholdings are proper that they're adequate we check to make sure that the base pays are paid that certain contractual people are paid properly we check to see part-timers are paid properly overtime is paid properly we run a pretty extensive

063sample all the documentation is there and lined up properly for us and it's highly highly computerized out there uh when I tell you the entire records for the year are on a thumb drive as big as my pinky it's kind of amazing to me so and it's all there and properly lined up so payroll is also working properly with regards to your food service fund we spend time looking at mets' records we look at their payroll records They they're uh you know generous enough and kind enough to provide us with their records we look at their invoices because they're really their invoices but we get built for them we look at their invoices we look at their time sheets we look at their payroll records um we check their calculation and the trail for our

064uh monthly uh reimbursement claim there was nice audit Trail for that required to have that we also check uh cash receipts and revenue in that area in the past couple years since the uh what's it called the Falcon care and the a child have taken off we've spent a lot more time in that area because it's quite frankly one of them is a million-dollar entity and it deserves audit attention not only from us but from the management as well and U over there at the the school I don't remember the name of the school but the woman's name is Sharon Jensen she does a very nice job her an assistant keeping the records okay so that that all worked out and that's all overseen and checked and it it worked out very nicely it's critical

065I think for the board to know that in all these key areas although I get it that the kids come first there needs to be a few bucks always set aside to make sure that the business operation office is adequately staffed you you just you don't want to have a blip in the in the process after having had developed over the last 30 years a pretty darn good internal control system okay you don't want to have to fall back and it can happen change in Personnel it can happen Okay but as long as you have a good feeder system and everyone in there is properly trained and they are that that's all minimized okay so I think that that all worked out very well I do want to say the employees in the business office

066were very cooperative and they were you know wanted to know how good they were doing and we made them aware you know know okay this this was all fine this worked well um I do want to acknowledge Laura Allen because in the last several years since she's joined the district uh she's taking a higher and a more prominent role um L Laura's a CPA like Mike but Laura is one of the CPA that got like a 99 in the CPA exam so uh she's quite qualified to handle the job so um we do appreciate her her help and one of the other areas we look into as well is we we do uh quite exensive audit in the enrollment count okay and also in the district's report of transported uh students we check that quite

067quite closely and we also verify the IEPs uh you have a lot of them here and uh we just make sure they they're a there and on file and there's a good system again there was a good audit system set up we go over to the the office over there in I don't know the name of it uh Monroe Commons I believe it is and so uh our staff goes in there they spend two days in there and check a lot of things Student Activities properly administered however the key thing there is it's such a small dollar amount that we can't spend you know four weeks looking at Student Activities when the biggest part of the audit is in the you know the main part but it is reviewed by the administration finance office uh

068couple times a year and uh when it's presented for audit okay it's in relatively good shape um key there there too is to make sure when there's turnover that if a new principal or a new person takes it over that immediately they're trained and they're given the ground rules because again every now and then change in Personnel there's a little blip in the process and all of a sudden we have havoc and we that that's been avoided so in the end we end up with this document that indicates everything that we had talked about and uh it has information relative to your student counts your excess Surplus calculation your number of meals claimed uh your net cash resources and your food service fund every year the doe adds another page for us to fill out

069uh this year they wanted us to check your your lead uh now I'm not an engineer but I flip through the book and uh so again they keep putting stuff on us too as well as your Administration for to check so we had to make a comment on that but in the end as a as a result we end up with fantastic auditing results uh and we end up with an unmodified opinion which is is the best that you can get thank you Mr swards um because we have a lot on the agenda tonight I would just like the board to indulge me for a minute or two just to talk about some of the highlights from uh my perspective um Surplus this year every the board has always been interested in two areas of

070the audit predominantly are there any audit recommendations did you do anything wrong and the answer to that according to Mr stanitz is no there are no audit recommendations there are no audit comments and what happened with Surplus this year the Board of Education consumed about 17% of the available excess Surplus about a million dollars because of of uh mainly the effects of growth and the stress of growth on the district uh special education programs that were beyond what was budgeted for and labor agreements that came in higher than what was budgeted for so some Surplus was consumed but we still have a reasonable amount there um to carry on an operation of this size the board's proprietary fund which picked up in the ashes of Mecca has early childhood uh enrichment and Falcon care and

071due to the guidance of Sharon Jensen that fund has made a net income of $1.6 million in its first three years of operation that the board has unrestricted access to and has transferred over into the general fund to reduce taxes and meet the demands of growth in the District that is a financial highlight here that cannot be underscored and this year it was about a $500,000 profit as well um we have joined a purchasing Consortium as Mr stank withth said and we saved over $4 million in the first seven years of participation in that purchasing Consortium by buying supplies and bulk through the county office supply is every consumable item you can imagine and this requires staff to go online requisition to supply the item that they need it gets approved in accordance with that

072and we buy through bulk that $ million is a savings beyond what we would recognize through State contract purchases and bidding which are both allowable by law and very advantageous and we've done even better my office is rather lean um we have a number of staff that you can count on one hand and I can introduce very quickly um but everybody is very dedicated works very hard to to improve operations to save money where possible and to keep money in the classroom and I want to thank uh the board of education for giving me the Assets in that department especially Laura Allen who does a fantastic job as Jerry mentioned uh she's a very unique uh talented person who who who works in so many areas to make all the different departments that she helps

073uh better and I appreciate uh all her assistance I would encourage everybody board members and members of the public to read through the comprehensive annual financial report it appears intimidating but once you get into it especially the demographic and statistical information it you can understand it um without too much sophistication if you have any questions don't hesitate to give me a call we spent three hours with a couple new board members going through this report and I encourage anybody whether you knew or been on the board for a few years if you want to go through this and have that presentation performed again I would be more more than happy to we're going to post this on our website any members of the public are welcome to take a look at this and this will

074be examined closely by standard and pores once our bond referendum is successful March 12th and they will extract information from here which will lead to a a very attractive Bond rating we currently have the best Bond rating a public school district can attain and that will reduce the borrowing cost of this community so thank you very much if there's any questions we'll be happy to take them okay Mr I believe you have a a resolution I do have a resolution but can she ask a question first we'll have a resolution a second then we'll have common questions gotcha okay it is recommended that the members of the Monroe Township Board of Education accept and approve the comprehensive annual financial report and the auditor's management report on administrative findings Financial compliance and performance and hereby approve

075and authorize the submission of the required corrective action plan to the county office indicating that there are no recommendations for fiscal year ending June 30th 2018 so he moved it he moved it so Steve second it sorry Patty okay now we'll open it up for comments or questions Miss armeno okay on the management report the auditor management report page eight um under Child Care initiative and Falcon care uh it says interfund payable to general fund was liquidated during the year does that mean the loan that was taken out in the previous administration that needed that that was a typo that we've given Mike revised copies of okay uh that that phrase in there Mike that was that was revised it it was liquidated in in the previous year that loan from Mecca has been completely

076satisfied as per board uh resolution for yes what so not this year last last year yes ma'am so then the okay so I got that so that's a very good thing so the Surplus then the excess Revenue over expenditures is the 39 $397,900 back to the general fund and that has been fully satisfied and as you stated this represents that $397,000 is the net income from uh Falcon care and $86,000 is the net income from Falcon uh from uh ECE and those can go into our general fund right it it's unrestricted the board can pass a resolution um using that money and it was established in the board prior uh budget philosophy to use it once again this year and we'll make a recommendation soon um to harvest some of those profits again to keep

077taxes down and to meet the advance of growth in the district and the reason why I asked I did remember celebrating that we had paid for it prior to that so I was wondering uh oh what happened there um I have a question about and this is just informational um about when uh Mr St stank would said you know paid by the state the state liability special funding yeah and that that that is um for pension benefits that is for tpaf pension T not PS pension okay TP TPA teachers pension and annuity fund okay it's all for all certificated professionals within the district as well as this year they talk about um postretirement health benefits that's in there as well and that that's a different situation than pension okay but it it is a number

078okay but that that is you said a state liability the tpaf pension is the legal obligation of the state of New Jersey okay so my real question is that's just the background information my real question is the the state and I'm not familiar it's just a question for information that there are times when the state does not pay into their Li liabilities and their P their funds is is this kind of fund um you know could at risk of of where the state doesn't come through and pay these funds yeah there are real they're actuar determined numbers correct okay got that part the state comes nowhere near paying and off the top of my head I believe it it may be 20% uh Mike you might know it might be higher but I your pension

079obligation I think was in the area for tpf that was allocated to you uh I thought the number was like $18 million but I think they only paid a portion of that we're not on the hook for it we're not no but I mean it's a shame it it should be paid by the state I mean that's one of the things that you know our employees deserve they paid and they pay into that is that correct they contribute towards it but the state contributes as well but they're not paying the full amount the number the number that they should have contributed was 18 million what page are you on Sir page 80 80 okay yeah but that's that's act determined and by the way when I mentioned at the exit conference that if you look

080and see uh our state aid is is listed there but that expense is reflected on our records in the front section but it it's also has a related offsetting Revenue it's called an on behalf payment what it's done is why it's done is to show the public what it really costs to run the district and the assumption is if they really paid all that which they haven't okay so but it's an unbelievable number so so probably our employees should be very cognizant of that with our state representatives right I mean as yes I guess yes as something that we should look at for ourselves well every state is struggling pions okay and but A promise is a promise right yeah and I don't know what the future of Pensions brings so I okay don't want

081to get emotional about it because my wife works in the school district okay thank you very much I think I'm done thank you okay any other questions Mr poor so the obligation is uh it's not just the Mundo Township that's going through this kind of a differential between the state payment versus nonpayment right other school districts are experiencing about the same thing oh in New Jersey yes absolutely you know you're not singled out it's Statewide it's even in some colleges and also a little bit in some police unions as well that they have these these special funding situations but it's not a big number it's the teachers the tpaf is the big boy and by the way it's it's a lot of states too a lot of states are have the same thing going on

082with with this as well so one other question uh you said that when you start doing your audit you pick stuff randomly and do you pick them randomly randomly or oh yeah yeah we W random samples and boom you know we have a random number generator it's very simple we ran a random number generator and we we run random numbers and boom we we send the Selections in and that's what we pick we do that for uh our transaction testing for expenditures as well as our payroll transaction testing we also supplement that with other tests okay we pick certain dollar amounts that we want to look at and then you know sometimes I'll just say hey let's look at uh let's look at those let's look at something else okay so the basis is statistical

083it has to be you have to test government entity you have to test transactions you have to test controls it's required in all governmental audits which is is and you find those expenses to be somewhat on par with other school districts do you make that comparison at all no not really every district is different every district has different demographics they have different goals um different structure different revenue streams for example you're you don't have a lot of state aid but that's common knowledge other districts I do have lot of state aid that so it it affect it's all affected by the revenue stream how you're capitalized you know um in an ideal situation this is not auditing it's just fine ideally you want to be able to balance your recurring expenses with recurring revenues sometimes

084districts can't get there you know and it's a heavy lift to try and move towards that because you're so dependent on fund balance uh and the rebuild of fund balance that it becomes a problem but some every district is different you know you and different policies different goals different demands by parents that you try to meet so yeah it's it's really not comparable thank you Mr groski when would this CER be available to the public online I wait till the board adopts it um which hopefully will be in a few minutes and then I'll post both the comprehensive annual financial report and the auditor's management report tomorrow morning thank you it's also available on there's a State website that's called cfer search in the department of aded you can look up audits from other districts

085going back about eight or nine years but it takes a while for them to get on you know like the districts now everyone's issuing a report so it's kind of jammed up we're one of the first guys out of the Vox so we're we'll be up there soon Mr tiella yeah well thank you for putting this together uh I also I also want to thank you for explaining the importance of the of the reserve right because we often use that uh we' We've looked to that reserve a number of times for different uh projects that we wouldn't have been able to do or we'd have to go out and and do a referendum for and we've been lucky enough to be able to draw on that fund so I think it's it's also important for

086all of us to remember that when it comes time to keep that fund um replenished that we that we continue to do that because when it when when it comes uh pinch time you know we've we've looked at that a lot for roof replacement for things like that where it's really come come in handy so Madam yes Mr with regard to capital reserve there was approximately $90,000 left after the money was dedicated through the budget however the board dedicated about $670,000 of that additional state aid award last year which was post this audit um to go back into and replenish the capital reserve so there'll be a balance in there of about 7 40,000 once again which is which is not a lot for a district this size and we we should keep an eye

087on it yes any other questions Mrs Lang more of a comment than a question I was lucky enough to spend Friday morning with Rupa and Kathy going through the cfer with Mr Gorski and really getting a great understanding for it and I just want to urge the public if you have questions about where your money is going where we are are financing this document is so valuable and to go through and even there's a whole section on page um one I'll tell you in a second because I have it marked 43 that outlines the growth of the district over the past 10 years and what school enrollment we have and I think for anybody who's doubting that we need to work toward the referendum and work toward the needs of our students this document explains

088how fiscally responsible the board has been and just how much there is a need for our additional School spaces so I just want to say thank you to Mr Gorski to Mrs Allen she was wonderful um to to work with and to the staff and you know I am afraid of numbers I have an issue but I understood this and I understand where are money's going in the different things and I greatly appreciate all the hard work and of our finance committee also of keeping up a good job thank you Mr Rybeck I just want to mention in listening to Mr stank's report um I know how hard we all work as far as um um T saving tax saving the taxpayers as much money as we can being cost effective and I just like

089to mention the importance of the Early Childhood enrichment and Falcon care programs those programs are really a source of income to this board that we use to keep costs down that save the taxpayers money I don't think we really U mention it enough and this is a perfect time to mention how beneficial those programs are anyone else I actually just remembered one question I when I was reading this um it says that our food service Mets that we've hired they're a nonprofit is that correct I think it said Mets is a for-profit organization I okay the Food Service fund is I'm sorry the Food Service fund is supposed to be a not for profit so the Food Service fund that we have your F our fund is not for profit okay I misunderstood it's but

090it's it's not for loss either you're not supposed to L understand I you can't make too much money right just just then I I misunderstood in here because it's um so it's our fund that is nonprofit it's not Mets yeah that's what I have that's correct we have three Enterprise funds the cafeteria fund which as Mr s with said is designed to break even every year that's federally and State uh funded in in part as well as the student lunch prices go into that so there's a design not to have too large of a profit in that fund so we we sway back and forth every year but we do have enough retain earnings to keep it solvent which is the most important thing other boards of Education transfer money from the general fund to

091the cafeteria fund to subsidize it we never have and the two other proprietary funds that are unrestricted Falcon care and ECE have made $1.6 million in their first three years of operations and that's unrestricted money that the board can use and and you said that the Mets made about 3 million so no no no the the our food service operation is approximately $3 million the operation our operation yeah which which is a nice it's a nice business even though it's not a business but it's run like a business yeah it's a $3 million operation so it's not uh and we can only uh and again please correct me if I'm wrong because these are just notes I made the net cash cannot exceed three months average expenditures yes that's page seven that's in the thin

092document yes yes a statutory required calculation that they so our net cash our net cash resources yes cannot exceed 30% of the operating expenses net of depreciation okay one more the USDA Commodities received by Monroe amount to 155,156 SL it's cheese it's government surplus Commodities that Nancy Mitek and I apply for every year it's a lot of work to apply for it and get these uh Commodities and account for them and inventory them and use them properly um we do some other districts don't but it it subsidizes and keeps the lunch cost down because it's a free ingredient that's you it's actual food commodities right it's a solid commodity okay thank you and he's not he's not kidding it there was a pink we did turn down the pink slime we did remember I remember

093that that was a big that was a big thing anyone else okay I also filler would like to to congratulate the business office because we have been a growing district and this we still have the same amount of members in the or people working in the business office that we've had for years and they continue to do more and more work each year and obviously they're doing a great job because we keep getting an unqualified opinion um so they they need to be thanked very much because of what they do and they always work hard and they're always there and they always have a every time I've seen them they have a smile on their face and they're doing their job so they they they really do need to be um congratulated for their job

094so if there's no other questions we will have a roll call Mr Gorski Mrs Deo yes Mrs seagull yes Mr Tano yes Mr rutsky yes Mrs armino yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr yes Mrs Lang yes Mr cherella yes Mrs K Pano yes madame board president the board has unanimously accepted the CER AMR and corrective action plan which indicates that there are no recommendations for the year end of June 318 and I will submit the comprehensive annual financial report the AMR and the uh the federal single audit information to everybody that's required and post this on our website as we have done previous years and I extend a warm invitation to anybody who wants to come in and go over this uh we were we're very happy to go through this it's it's a lot of

095information to compile every year and it's a shame just to put it on a shelf there's a lot of good information in here about our borrowing capacity about mro specific unemployment rate um you'd be surprised what's in here great thank you Mr Gorski at this time we'll go to our student thank you Mr stank thank you Mr St Valentine's Day thank you thank you you yes um at this time we'll go to our student board members report board member report thank you I don't know if that could be as comprehensive as a last presentation um several high school students took the New Jersey seal by literacy test also the Spanish Honor Society will be holding a dance Aon next week to raise money for Operation Smile an organization that helps children with cl deformities the

096mon Township FBLA held a karaoke fundraiser with proceeds going to March of Dimes the mon Township High School Media Center is hosting a one book read on Tuesday the 26th and Oak Tree Elementary held a PJ for police day and all proceeds went to the help sponsor local Monro policeman participating in the Police Unity Tour thank you thank you so at this time number eight on our agenda is closed session be it resolved that the Board of Education of the township of Monroe hereby moves to go into Clos session in accordance with the Sunshine Law chapter 231 of the public laws of 1975 njsa 10 colum 4-6 through 10 colum 4-21 to discuss the following subject pending litigation Michael G kosac Ed versus Mon Board of Education of the township of Monroe middlex County oal

097docket number edu 07970 d18 following closed session action may be taken the discussion conducted in Clos session can be disclosed to the public at such time as the need for confidentiality no longer exists some of so Mr cherella Mr Ryback all in favor opposed none then at this time we will go in to close session we will be there approximately 30 minutes and um then we will come out okay at this time the board will move back into public session and Mr goodle will read a resolution it is recommended that the Board of Education approved the previously submitted settlement agreement in general release in the matter entitled Michael G kak Ed first Monroe Township Board of Education before the commissioner of Education capital o o docket number colon capital edu numers 07 970-218-1336 is there

098a motion and a second so moved is there a second okay Mr mayo and Mrs Lang is there any comments or questions then we will have a roll call on this matter Mrs Lang yes Mr cherella yes Mrs Deo yes Mrs armeno yes Mrs seagull yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr rudsky yes Mr plor yes Mr Tano yes Mrs Kino yes on the board president motion passes unanimous thank you very much and at this time we'll go to committee report so are there any committees that need to report this evening Mr I have a committee report okay we had a lovely curriculum meeting today the first thing we discussed was the computer science and coding curriculum document for Middle School this course has been designed to introduce and expose middle school students to the world of

099coding and its revent re revent relevant relevance excuse me in 21st century Society students of all abilities and educational backgrounds in grade 8 are encouraged to engage in this rapidly growing field within academic and the professional Arenas units of study include problem solving and the design process web development digital animation and gaming and programming for robotics this course is the first of its kind at the middle school level and will ultimately involve evolve to fit within the district's engineering and Robotics initiative introductory robotics programs will include SPO Finch and Vex robotics this new course and its subsequent future will be discussed at the next Monroe Township School District engineering and robotic steering committee meetings we also discussed the Monroe Township middle school math competition team it's an extracurricular that's proposed at the middle school um

100the current middle school math competition Club um is uses stem teachers to prepare students for math counts as part of the tag program two teachers are being paid at the instructional rate as a club to prepare students for the February 2nd 2019 competition at Union County College and there are two administr two teachers administer the amc8 competition as well and the math League competition the proposed Middle School mathematics competition team the goal for the 20192020 proposal the goal is to create a competitive team approach toward multiple mathematic competitions appropriate at the middle school grade level two advisers will advise the team working to instill a friendly competitive environment using goals of the math Olympiad for elementary and middle school program this is to stimulate enthusiasm and a love for mathematics to introduce important mathematical Concepts

101to teach major major strategies for problem solving to develop mathematical flexibility in problem solving to strengthen mathematic mathematical int intuition to Foster mathematical creativity and Ingenuity and to provide for the satisfaction joy and thrill of meeting challenges the math team will run during the club times 90 minutes weekly throughout the year two teams for up to 30 students each will be selected to participate through the year a year-long commitment is an expectation from the students and competitions will include but not be limited to amc8 math counts Math League and math Olympiad we also discussed human trafficking and I want to thank Patty Lang for bringing this to the curriculum meeting she had been to the League of Women Voters um presentation on human trafficking and we had two of the League of Women Voters there

102during this presentation and I would like to thank them for coming and I think I'm going to turn this over to Patty to discuss a little bit more about the human trafficking thank you jel um uh it last earlier this month um Kathy Ken Peter Andy Rupa and M Michelle and myself all attended the human trafficking presentation by the League of Women Voters I've been a member of the league for a little over a year before so I had been um working with these ladies a little bit beforehand and the League of Women Voters recognizes that human trafficking in all of its forms is probably one of the fastest raising crimes and it targets mostly uh very often it targets our young people so the League of Women Voters really wanted to partner with the

103school district so that we could educate our children about the dangers and we can educate parents so we had brought the information to Dr alvic and Dr alvic is going to take some of the curriculums that the the League of Women Voters provided us with with information from other school districts like Prince William County in um Maryland Marland thank you and and good information like that and just in that curriculum committee meeting and I always I always Rave about our curriculum committee because they're fantastic and the supervisors as we were talking about the problems of human trafficking and why this has to be a priority you know the educating of our kids because prevention is really the only tool that we have to put an end to human trafficking at this point so education and

104prevention is what will save people's lives going forward and that the enthusiasm from the supervisors and their willingness to talk with Dory to see where this can come into our our Civics and everything like that we're doing and where it can fall into our curriculum is really something that I was very excited about so Dory is going to be meeting with her her um supervisors and talking about it we do know that um the Monroe Township High School rppa Honor Society is continuing this they're going to have a meeting um they they work with their adviser Jackie ab bruy and they're on March 14th they're going to have a presentation in the pack about becoming an abolitionist how do you fight slavery in today's world and that they're going to be charging $2 fee to

105help offset costs and to do some fundraising but I think this is a great thing for us going forward and I think any of us who were at the meeting got a lot of information from that first one and then the one today so I appreciate that we were able to bring it to curriculum and and get it looked at thank you Patty that was very comprehensive thank you okay is there any other committee reports Mr Ryback I just wanted to to mention um one thing that I can talk about from the Personnel committee uh is that uh Personnel committee is looking into the visibility of increasing raising the pay rate for pum Subs U we looked at a comparison of all the school districts in Middle sex and um notice that we weren't all

106that competitive and that um a lot of people that were subing here are now working in in other districts so um the committee certainly uh the consensus of the committee was that uh we' be uh um a little bit more competitive so that's something that we're investigating we're also looking uh to increase our pool of Subs by uh trying to attract new uh newly appointed teachers as well as retirees so I guess ultimately we'll have more substitutes available to us Mr Chella yeah I have a question for Mr ryac on that so thank you for bringing that up because I think that's a that's it's very important from what I understand and please you know you guys correct me if I'm wrong but from what I understand we're having a problem uh finding enough Subs

107who will come in and part of that is pay rate I'm guessing um and then we're we're we're asking in in some cases for teachers to use prep time or whatever and their covering classes now I know they get a pum uh stipended or something for that but still I don't think that's the best case scenario when you have prep time should be prep time um you know and and uh uh lunchtime should be lunch time that kind of thing so is that is that right I mean is that one of the things that is is happening now and one of things you know one of the reasons why we need to really make because we're less competitive it seems that a lot of uh County approved substitutes go to other districts for a higher

108rate of pay which when we have a short-handed situation at each school we ask teachers to cover that during either their prep time or their Duty time and uh we compensate them and it's not cost efficient as well and it also taxes the teacher uh they're typically not uh as prepared as uh the regular teacher would have been so when they uh cover um it's it's more of a supervision uh piece than actual instructional piece so um we think if we explore increasing our rate of pay that we'll bring better quality substitutes back to the district great thank you if I can i' just like to add uh a benefit of of increasing the pool is being able to get subs that uh have an expertise in the area which they're subbing and I think

109that's you know a problem in most districts you know you want to certainly get especially if it's somebody's going to be out for a while you want to get somebody that's has a certificate in in whatever that curriculum area is so that can only serve to benefit us in there uh that way as well Mr poori Quick question Mr rayback um I 100% support the idea that we got to be competitive in the marketplace but have you given some thought or I'm assuming you do in terms of its impact to the budget is there a line item that's being allocated for that kind of Mr Mayo so one thing we discussed was that the teachers who sub during their period get paid for a full day so it's very expensive to use teachers so by

110getting more subs and not asking the teachers to give up their prep time we will actually be saving some money and I think Mike estimated about $177,000 a year yeah there's an offsetting higher premium that was being paid to the teacher coverage uh that saved with the sub piece and and yes we do have available resources in the budget to increase uh the sub rate of pay that's something that we talked about for a while and uh we have a reserve for that if I if I can I should explain it maybe you can you understand it in in real life terms um as a principal if I had a a cover a program and I had to hire four or five regular teachers and give pay them coverages that would cost more than hiring

111a sub for the whole day got it thank you okay any other committee reports Mr tiella yes thank you we had a uh buildings and buildings grounds and transportation meeting on 25 and we had several topics that we discussed and uh some of those are in our agenda tonight uh the first thing we had was the uh girls soccer announcement board uh for the stadium Fieldhouse so the we we uh as a committee uh have asked to for us to move forward with that uh uh athletic director Greg berer will pursue a universal board for all sports but right now what's missing is a girl soccer announcement board and um you know they at no cost to the to the district uh the girl soccer uh team they want to they want to take that

112and fund it and put a board up there so that they could put their announcements out there and we thought that was a good idea so uh we're going to we're asking to move that forward um we also had Sergeant Jangles in from the Monroe Township Police Department uh they had a request for us to put flashing lights at two schools so for instance at the high school here when you're coming up the hill you don't know it's dark and you don't know really where that 25 M an hour Zone it starts or where the kids are and so they were requesting that which we thought was a good idea but the uh the board the uh Council I mean the committee uh asked that we also look at some other ways to fund that

113to maybe work something out with the township or with the county uh to pay for the signs themselves or some kind of agreement where we could maybe offset the cost of the district itself um that is going to be pursued it's going to be looked into we don't know if that we're going to be able to do that but what we did ask and what we're asking you all to approve is for the engineering portion of that so that when we go to those entities we're able to say this is where we need those signs this is what we're looking for this is where they're going to go and and have a you know a good written plan as to what we need um just so uh just so you know there was also a

114followup to that where our Administration went to uh Alan Weinberg Mr Weinberg is the uh ba for the township and that's they so they're they're currently looking into that they're going to go to the mayor and and talk to that through now one of my favorite topics is uh we also reviewed the annual Don't Laugh at Me Andy the annual IPM uh program review so I love I I love this program and uh Jerry tag makes fun of me every year because I because I do love it but what the IPM program is it's integrated Pest Management it's it's a way for us to uh minimize the amount of chemicals and things like that that we use to go after pests which means less chemicals in the environment less chances that our children will come

115in contact with dangerous chemicals and things like that and we have a great program here so we reviewed the plan again we we we're asking this to put that plan forward again as it is uh it went through review by all the building Administration and uh uh the administration of each school and uh everyone was happy with the way it currently is but Patty I know you're looking at but things like mint keep away there's all kinds of peint in put it in your dish your soap when you're washing your kitchen floor it keeps ants out of your house that's right so those are so and there are inst instances where we have to use uh chemicals and when that happens uh we do send information home we do email we do we we let

116people we let we let the parents know that uh there could be you know that that chemicals are going to be used so but anyway it's it's a great program and that's that's on our agenda we also uh saw the uh bid reviews and administration presented the uh snowplow contract and recommended that uh we we we remain using the current uh the uh the current company that we're using and that that also does not have an increase so for the school year so no cost increase for us which is always a good thing and then the last thing that we reviewed are bus cameras so on the outside so sorry had to have a drink um one of the things that I noticed an article where uh down south in North Carolina Virginia there are

117bus cameras on the outside of the buses and we've had a lot of issues with people going around buses I don't know I don't know if it's just I'm if I'm just hyp sensitive and I'm noticing it or if there's just more of it but it seems like everywhere I look there are people you on Facebook and social Twitter just saying you know showing videos of buses of cars going around buses kids loading which is just a horrible horrible thing and so I just asked that we look into maybe getting these cameras ourselves where we could we could see the license plate maybe even position them so that we could see who's in the car and then and so that we could then move forward and maybe prosecute these people as they you know put

118our children in Jeopardy and Harm's Way um Sergeant Jangles who was already there for the for the flashing lights said that he didn't know the about the legalities but he's going to look into it and get back to us and see if it's something that we can do and then if it was cost effective and those kind of things but uh but it was just something that uh we're going to look into so when he brings that information back then our committee will report back out to the full board but I think you know at some point if it's legal and we could do it that is something that we should probably look into doing because I think it would it would help keep our children safe and and and start Prosecuting the people who

119are breaking the law that's it okay Mr retsky so I'll conclude with the finance committee next oh you go next you want to go now no okay so the finance committee met uh last Tuesday and we basically got a preview of the cafer report from Mr stankowitz um so we basically knew ahead of time which was nice that there was a as Mr stankowitz represented there were no audit recommendations there were no audit comments and the auditor's opinion expressed an unmodified or what is known as a clean opinion on the financial statements and so um that was a little bit of an opportunity to do a Q&A dig you know drill down a little deeper and and and basically just confirm what we had already believed and what everybody here tonight heard about all good

120things all good things yes Mrs Lang okay policy committee so um I lost my microphone um we had our policy committing last week and I have to say there this is a great committee to be working with this year um we do have on the agenda today the following bylaws that are approved by the committee for reaffirmation um Kathy and and rup and I attended a njsba um training this past weekend and one of the things that they brought up is that the policy this is the time to be reviewing your entire policy committee so we're right on target bookc yes your entire policy book and updating pulling out things that are not important and things like that so just to once again explain how we're going through the policies to decide which can just

121be put in for reaffirmation is that we're we're using a list of updated policies that and school boards has put out and stra as May to make sure that if we have met the statutory requirements and if there's been no statutory requirements and the policy still applicable then it is being reviewed by Administration and including Mar Smith just to make sure that it's all okay and then it's brought to the policy committee so this month we did um the bylaws and next month we're going to be starting the next section with if anybody wants to have fun reading is section 1,000 which is AD Administration so you can start looking at um the different policies and then in our um in our policy oh I just lost my my notes I'm sorry we also had

122to approve the the new sending District policy um that covers sending and receiving District we are putting on for a first reading the policy regarding and I apologize I'm not feeling so good tonight and my voice just went out the window but the policies we have the sending receiving District policy the ones that are on the agenda we have the we've looked through them all yeah so they're all good agendas and there were a couple the other thing I wanted to thank um Mr Goodall I'm really Sun feeling good all of a sudden um for putting the policy notes are now on board docs so anybody else who wants to see what we're doing in policy committees you can just pull up the policy notes and see what what we talked about could okay okay

123thank you you're welcome okay thank you Patty um okay at this time we'll go to public forum anyone from the public wishing to speak to the agenda please come to the microphone give your name and address for the record we will adhere to our 4minute timeline um when the timer goes off your time is over and we per our policy you are only allowed to come to the microphone once per um public forum and this is for agenda items only so if it's not on the agenda oh it's no it's not then you have to wait for the second public for second public thanks prakash pup 33 D drive today let me see what the time is 9:18 the public forum 918 how many parents are there they came and went home 7:00 the meeting

124starts and public forum 9:18 9:30 when the parents can come and speak so last year I said that we should have public forum earlier and we all said that we had to change the policies and I don't see it to be discussed into the policies the yeah so the next thing is referendum ref referendum is not on the agenda yeah so the question is the resolution is passed by our Council to collect to have a loft for collection of you know impact fees the impact fees are not on the agenda yeah I know that nothing is on the agenda so I know that well then you cannot speak if something is not on the agenda okay I'll speak of what is on the agenda what is on the agenda I will speak to that I

125will speak to that I saw the today's report on the audit and if you look at that our if I am correct it is $122 million something our budget is and in that 35 million are for the benefits isn't it Mr morski benefits is a broad category it includes health benefits it includes pension contributions um and some other items and um the health benefits is about um a gross premium of 24 million so the 24 million is fors to about 18 million yeah so 24 million what we are giving for the current that's okay thank you that is for the correction so if I correct per student how much we are spending per student in the High School per student in the middle school and per students the elementary school if you take total it

126comes to around 17,900 but do you categorize how much we spend per student in high school versus middle school and elementary school and what was in the past two years and what we are doing at present can we see that in that calculation that calculation you're referring to is available in a couple different places number one it's in the budget documents every year where it's a budgeted cost per puple for those various grade levels that you mentioned also we have as part of our A4 1 a42 calculation that certifies the tuition costs with the state they give us actual not budgeted but actual per pupil costs for those grade levels and you can get a plethora of other information that compares us with like kind districts on the taxpayer guide to educational spending my question

127okay I understand now uh the SE the how much money we received from the government I see $17 million there that's correct what we got some 7 $ million in that sheet is there looks like $17 million that's correct if you want I can I didn't think it was that much but if you if you were if you're picking up the um on behalf payments that the state makes for us it could be that high yeah because state state Source it says 17 million there that's correct I'd have to see the document you're referring to but that seems high that must include the on which is distributed yeah and that's what it is the funding from the state so this is here I can speak about this is on the sheet here Jesus so I'm

128saying that we are not getting adequate funding from the state so we we have to have a resolution similar to our Council passed asking having a law so that yeah so yeah so I want to hear from you all this is too late 6 9:20 coming for the public for is anybody else from the public wishing to speak to the agenda okay seeing no one we'll close public forum and go to the superintendent's report Mr Goodall thank you in keeping in updating the community on our referendum scheduled for March 12th uh just uh if it's a little bit redundant I apologize but we're trying to keep on message the steering committee has been very active in strategizing and implementing our plan to promote the school referendum schedule for March 12th 2019 the committee continuously meets

129to ensure transparent and accurate communication is distributed to our residents especially parents so informed decisions can be made by each voter on March 12th The District administration continues its tour of Monroe Township at several planned presentations throughout the community including many of our planned retirement communities our appreciate the willingness of all of our residents to listen to the needs of the district and many of our completed presentations resulted in very few favorable feedback on our plan a big thank you to our parent organizations for scheduling local presentations in neighborhood schools I know that families have different perspectives all over town so we try to present information geared to their interest please reference our district referendum page on our website for up-to-date scheduling for the parent organization presentation schedule as mentioned previously continued thanks to mtea

130for their partnership and active support for our plan and their efforts to communicate the importance of the vote we have two uh districtwide public presentations our next one is February 21st 2019 at the high school auditorium at 700 p.m. and then we scheduled another one March 11th 2019 at the Monroe Township Rec Center at 700 p.m. the day before for the referendum vote so we continue to encourage residents to seek information on the referendum from our district uh Facebook referendum page District Twitter our mobile app and District referendum website page we will be constantly sending the community updates look for the these District social media sites for accurate and transparent information on our referendum please mark your calendars to make an informed vote on March 12th 2019 I've been updating the school community on our

131efforts to communicate and be more inclusive of our students with special needs in their families and neighborhood schools and across the district at our last cpeg meeting we had a panel discussion on student placement inclusion reading programs and other important topics with parents that were very informational for parents and the administration on CH challenges parents and teachers face in and out of the classroom I'd like to thank Mrs Marietta rella miss Monica Hines and school psychologist Miss Irene barata for being a part of the panel with me we have our next cpeg meeting tentatively scheduled for March 14th in the high school media center at 700 p.m. more details to follow and uh also I got this from Mr berer our athletic director congratulations to the Monroe Township boys varsity bowling team who won the

132Central Jersey group four state championship this is our second championship in three years congratulations coach Marissa Guerrera and the players and good luck tomorrow as they look to win the overall group four final championship and that's at the Bolero Lanes Route 130 in North Brunswick so good luck to the boys bowling team we have some personal Personnel items to be approved Madam Bor president and members of the Board of Education it is recommended that Personnel action items a through AE under the superintendent report be approved by consent roll call so Mo second Mr Chella Mr Rybeck are there any comments or questions for Mr Goodall seeing none we'll have a roll call Mrs armenio yes Mr Chella yes Mrs Deo yes Mrs Lang yes Mr poori yes Mr Ryback yes Mr rutsky yes Mrs seagull

133yes Mr Tano yes Mrs kich yes Madam board president Personnel items a through AE has passed thank you madam board president and members of the Board of Ed it is recommended that board action items a through Q be approved by consent roll call please with the exception of item number k please strike k Mr Chella and Mr Ryback again any comments or questions for Mr Goodall Miss arino uh yes yes I have some uh questions about the policy um first the at the uh the reaffirming of some of the policies I'll start with um policy it's really a bylaw 0131 um the bylaw the place that I have I would like to have reconsideration of this language on number two it suggests uh for a new or revised bylaw or policy may be referred at

134the discretion of the president and as appropriate to the subject to the superintendent a board committee or a public advisory committee for a study but my concern is the discretion of the president um I would hope that it would go first to the um the committee and should always be um you if if the board if the language means that o only the board president May refer uh a new or revised bylaw policy um I would I would have an objection to that because I think that could get be subjective and I would hope that we could um clear that language up if it means that that any of the above in that par paragraph should be able to recommend it that would be a different story so I would just like clarification on paragraph

135two uh Z of the bylaw 131 page 2 of three so I would I would ask that we can hold that uh reaffirmation until such time as we get clarification for that paragraph that's on 101 um bylaw 167 that is a public participation in the meeting um it's is does State on number three of the bylaw 0167 page one of3 on the first page it does State at number three um of three public forums but I would also like that the first two paragraphs should should state that there are three public forums just to make sure that it's clear that there will be three public fors in our agenda I know we have that now but I I don't know if we need to have it stated in the beginning of that bylaw so again

136I'd like that to be considered um before it's reaffirmed they were okay excuse me or attorney looked at these policies and said they were fine I understand that but that's sort of my point about um unilateral recommendations I am asking as a board member that we take a look at this I mean because we're voting on as a re affirmation so as a board member now I'm asking that that would be acceptable to take a look at that and just add it I don't think there's any harm in adding it to the language is our attorney still here she is I I believe that in the policy it says public forum number one public forum number two and public forum number three and what each of them are for so you're saying that is correct

137Mrs Lang yes we don't need the PO we don't need the bylaw to to represent the same language that the policy has no is that what you're saying not that okay I would I would ask us to take a look at that but if you're saying that we that the three public fors are secured in the policy I would accept that um the next one uh policy that is for the first reading tonight policy and regulation 7510 um 7510 use of school facilities yeah that that one was a change by the the insurance broker needed us to put in that Monroe is held harmless so we need to be named in that policy as the other insured so anybody outside organization using our facilities so that's what the change in that policy is okay well

138we've had some discussion heated at times uh about uh class one users yes and I I'll address that we what we decided to do no because it's actually really simple what we are going to do is this is the first reading just because Mary needed this to be added so that it was addressing the need of our insur insance broker but this policy is actually going to be coming back so your question is actually being answered because it hasn't been addressed yet and that's what we as the policy committee had agreed to well I would appreciate being able to ask my question before I'm stopped especially since the president had given me the floor um so the question was because it exists and I'm always worried about if we don't do something the right way

139on a first reading and it goes to the second reading and then we're told that it doesn't it doesn't work um that on the uh education foundations pto's ptas and PSA would be added uh as as the previous board um we talked about parent any parent organization that had the right certifications and everything should be included so I don't know if it's semantics but I I think that should be included in um the first reading well that that is not something that the board or the committee has looked at again again Mrs Lang said and she's correct that there was a piece that we had to put in there right now from the insurance company so we're doing that so that makes that in in there that works and then we will re be revisiting

140that again in future um policy meetings so what does that mean if this is a second reading so will it be will we're we're just trying to get the insurance piece in the policy and we're doing um some re research and leg work especially with our parent organizations about uh things they want to do with some changes to legislation and how we can line up our uh policies with that so we're going to revisit that once we meet and unfortunately yesterday because of the snow day I wasn't able to meet with the parent organizations so it's a a deliberate it's a a deliberate um situation where you you are leaving that out because it hasn't been discussed yet is that what you're saying yes and it will be addressed it's on okay then it was

141a time of the essence um situation that the insurance company needs that wording changed immediately and the only way to do it was to put it through before we got a chance to really put it it was on the list that the committee was going to be talking about but we couldn't put it forward that the rest of it until but this has to be done immediately the insurance broker gave us time of the essence okay and I understand that but since we have a legitimate PSA that is functioning I don't understand why that couldn't have been put on here and then again if you were going to revisit the policy and change that that would have been acceptable but clearly there's an issue with that and I do see as um something that was

142left out on purpose if I believe I'm correct that we made a um that we had asked Mr Goodall at the last meeting to do a to look into that situation he's doing that we can't fix a Mr Armen the we we voted on it last year sir we had it voted it's a legitimate organization as far as I understand it it should have been if you were going to revise this policy and it is in existence it should have been put in here as a recognized organization and if you wanted to change it down the road then fine but right now it's a legitimate organization that was voted on in the affirmative last year and I just I just think there's something um the specific naming of parent organizations we most certainly could look

143into that are recognized by our board the intent of putting this policy up now was just to address the insurance piece and we're going to revisit and we explain that in the policy committee um looking at the policy again where it needs to be updated and especially looking at um fundraisers that are games of chance to make sure that we have lined up and every parent organization is doing the right thing it really had nothing to do with specific U parent organizations acronyms that needed to be added it was more about the games of chance piece and the use of facilities so there would have been no harm to put that put that name on there but um we we didn't we didn't get to that revision yet well we we did we did get

144to it we didn't get to the revision but it was um voted on at the last last year's board and so it's an existing situation so it would have been actually a courtesy I think to have included it but thank you any other comments or questions okay then we'll have a roll call Mr Gorski board action items a through Q with the exception of K Mrs armino uh yes on everything except no on uh n31 no on N 067 and sir certainly no on o 7510 so noted Mr cherella yes Mrs Deo yes Mrs Lang yes Mr poori yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr rutsky yes Mrs seagull yes Mr Tano yes Mrs K Pano yes on board president board action items a through Q with the exception of K has passed thank you and uh

145does that conclude your that concludes the superintendent's report we will go on to the business administrator's report Mr Gorski thank you i' just like to introduce two items on my report of significance professional appointments number one the bo there's a recommendation here that the Board of Education approve Edwards Engineering Group to provide survey and construction Management Services to the board of ed for flashing school zone speed signs at a cost of $1,240 plus bid phase expens at an additional cost of 22750 if needed now this is for the engineering work for blinking street signs as was discussed with the bg& T committee notes uh before subsequent to the committee meeting Mr tag and I met with Township officials Ellen Weinberg and George Lang no relation to our board member Patty Lang and we uh we

146solicited the Township's help in paying for not only the engineering cost as being proposed tonight but the entire cost of the project which could range somewhere in a vicinity of $120,000 and it was warmly received and um taken back to uh the officials for determination and uh I'm optimistic uh waiting for the results yes um letter G also in my report security vestibules at appleguard school Brookside school manship high school manship middle school Barkley Brook School I remind everybody um and uh point out to the new members that this was part of the board's budget priority during the budget philosophy stage it was determined that some schools had vules that were allowed for safe entrance into school and screening of people coming in uh but all of these that I just mentioned did not so

147this is a major capital outlay expenditure that the board's engaging in to improve secur infrastructure at five of our schools we do not have an amount uh yet because this is asking permission to submit it to the state for review and to revise the long range facility plan accordingly um we will go out to bid after they're approved and what's noteworthy here too is unlike Princeton schools which we've been compared to recently who put out a referendum and bonded for these costs we're doing it in our cap in our general fund budget saving all of the interest cost that would have accumulated on that that uh Bond issuance so Madame board president and members of the Monro Township Board of Education it is recommended that board action items a through I be approved by consent

148roll call so move second Mr Chella Mr Ryback any comments or questions for Mr Gorski Miss armino uh just clarification on uh seven The Horizon healthc Care staff and that's merely for our substitute nurses and just what it says the physical speech and occupational therapy and just and substitute nurses right because the contract or the agreement the clinical Staffing agreement seemed to add a lot of other things but our only purpose is what is on the agenda sir yes ma'am okay um and I think I just a little bit of a um explanation of the transfer six there were a lot of there were a lot of transfers is is that it is goad yes um regarding budget transfers they are a result of administration's management of the budget and what do I mean by

149that there are hundreds of budget accounts going down to individual cost center uh uh School amounts and it is a task to go through the entire budget review every single account to make sure that the appropriation that the board approved with the initial budget is satisfactory to make it through the the uh the 12-month school year and uh we have various determination methods to to look into that additionally often principes and directors uh almost on a weekly basis submit budget revisions uh and budget adjustments for for example they they budgeted for a widget and they want to exchange it for something else in a different line item category so uh to allow the flexibility in the classroom we would make a budget adjustment and um and it would have a Net Zero Effect on the

150budget as as these transfers do a withdrawal of funds on the transfer list is shown as a credit and an infusion of funds on the budget account is shown as a debit and in no instance can we overexp a line item so this uh transfer list is tailoring and management of the budget and um as you know we have a very large budget we have very Dynamic circumstances with special education in particular where we have uh you know one student who could literally come in and make it go from eight students per teacher to nine and then we have to have another staff member that wasn't budgeted for so this uh transfer is normal and customary every other school district has similar transfers they're within our 10% limit where we would have to see County

151approval so I hope that answered the question so the the top one the uh the $140,000 was that is that another $140,000 or is that the same one we voted on a while ago it is not the same one you voted on a while ago it is a new budget transfer okay so quite often circumstances could occur which cause us to uh revise previous transfers uh by offsetting it with new transfers okay and they can go from one Department to another without issue yes and and had had we not engaged in this management of the budget then uh when requests come through for new Staffing or flexibility in then school-based expenditures or for example snow plowing expenses very understated to what we had put in the budget this year we would have no no aptitude

152to change anything and and a lot of folks would be told no so um this is affording flexibility instruction okay thank you Mr other comments or questions very quick I'll try to very quick Mr groski uh on the item a number one so the intent is that you're going to move forward with the the engineering drawings and specifications and get reimbursement possibly from the township so we're not waiting for the township to come in before we engage the engineering firm is that correct uh yeah to put it another way we're taking the risk tonight by approving this that if the town ship comes back and says no we will fit the bill for this but I I am uh cautiously optimistic that the answer may come back and say yes not only will we pick

153up this but we'll pay for the whole flashing sign project and we did discuss the uh grant opportunities available to the township the safe school grants that you brought up at the committee level and they're going to pursue those for us and uh along with some other available resources that excellent Mr weberg knows about Mr G may I M very quickly did did we ask them about the um Department of uh public works if they would construct our signs did that ever get discussed I think that was something we talked about at at the meeting I thought that was a a possibility as well because that if if the township does do that it's really Less on both ends I'm gonna I'm gonna go out on a limb here so don't hold me to it

154but I don't think the DPW and Monro has the sophistication or aptitude to make this type of sign that requires this type engineering uh it's a little more advanced than putting in like a crosswalk sign or something okay you anyone else okay seeing no one Mr Gorski may we have a roll call Mrs Areno yes Mr tiella yes Mrs Deo yes Mrs Lang Yes except re cues on I Patricia Lang so noted thank you Mr plor same uh recuse on item I yes thank you Mr Ryback um a yes except I refuse on item I as well thank you Mr rutzky yes Mrs seagull yes and we cu's on letter I thank you Mr Tano yes Mrs colano yes Madam board president motion passes board action a through I and the individual recusals are for

155under I or not for the whole line item I it's for those specific people's name so motion passes for that as well okay thank you very much uh at this time we'll go to the board president's report so I have three things this evening um the first is um there's been a lot of misinformation going around about the referendum on Facebook and in the community so for anyone looking for correct information or accurate information please make sure it's Monroe Township School District coming from the Monro Township School District whether it's from the refer uh the website the referendum Facebook page the district handouts um any presentations that we do throughout the community where we're giving out information and mailings from the district to um the residents because sometimes we see that other people are using

156the Falcon people think that it's Now official and it's not always from the board of education so just make sure that you are getting the correct information information from the correct sources um the second thing I have is um Patty mentioned this before but last Saturday Patty Rupa and I attended an excellent New Jersey school board's workshop on making meetings work more efficiently and for me it reaffirmed the fact that we have been running our meetings the way that they are supposed to be run both legally and through policy in fact our district goes over and Beyond what the rest of of New Jersey schools districts do as part of the folder of information received was a handout from the November December 2018 issue of school leader magazine entitled 13 things school board members wish

157people knew about them I thought it was very important for those in the public to understand what some of our responsibilities are so I asked to have this handout copied and available to those here this evening so um it looks like this I hope you've had an opportunity to pick one up and all the board members also received this so I wanted to bring uh the attention of the public to number seven because this item has come up numerous times over the years at Board of Education meetings the public comment period or public forums is for the members of the public to comment not engage in a discussion with board members or Q&A session and this is all coming from school boards if a member of the public ask questions School District staffers will sometimes

158answer but most of the times we'll get back to to the ladder with the information requested boards are allowed to establish reasonable restrictions on time place and manner of public comment for instance School boards typically set guidelines on the length of an individual's timeline uh for an individual's comment time so no one person dominates the meeting there is no required form format for public comment some boards have one public comment period per meeting others have more out of all the districts that we met that attended the workshop last Saturday we were the only District that had three public forums the rest had two we were the only board who had a 4minute time limit the rest had a two or three minute limit and we were the only board who allowed for questions to be

159asked and answered at public board meetings and I I think that was a surprise to not only the people that attended that meeting but to Schoolboard um people who were holding the meeting that that we would do a Q&A because they advise not to do that um a Board of Education meeting is one that is held in public it is not a public meeting so in the future we're going to be looking to see or we look at our district polies on public par public participation to see if it needs to be um Revisited or looked at again and the third thing I have is at the January me board meeting I talked about the need to start the superintendent search process and since we had four board members who had never been in the

160process who had never been involved in the search before the board requested some training from through through in this area in the area of superintendent searches so on March 4th we had a representative from New Jersey school school boards come to a special meeting and discuss the search process with us and answer any of the questions that the board members had what we learned was that the superintendent search process is a highly confidential process that only the board members can be involved in the community and District staff can be involved only for input into the identification of District strengths and issues and for the establishment of criteria and credentials that they would like to see in a new superintendent so the last board meeting I mentioned that this month we would have two questions that

161the board needed to decide one whether to do an internal posting only or we open the search up out of District also and after we decide on that we need to decide on who will do the search whether we will do it ourselves whether we will use New Jersey school boards or we will use a search firm so at this time um I think we need to talk about whether we're to do an an internal search post posting whether we're going to do a posting for an internal search or we open up a search throughout the um outside the district so I'm going to open it up to the board members for comments and questions and then we will have to end up taking a vote later on on this subject so Mr Chella it's

162a it's more of a question I mean maybe and maybe it's just a comment but when we use school boards in the past for that now I know they're good with the trainings and stuff but I don't think think I don't remember us being particularly happy with uh what the way they went about sourcing candidates and and and the and the things we got and I remember at that point and I'm talking a couple superintendents ago we we we talked about maybe sourcing you know doing it ourselves and and searching I I but I wasn't on the board uh when the when the Dr kak you know when Dr kak was chosen so I don't know what the board did at that point but um but I was just I was just wondering what the

163cost differential El were and uh you know between uh going with school boards as opposed to an outside Farm or doing it ourselves I haven't been through that process many times um going back two superintendent ago the board president at that time which was not me fired School boards in the middle of the process because we were not happy with the way things were going we took on that responsibility ourselves and it it worked out um the last time we used school boards when we were looking at um Dr kak and um the first search did not yield any candidate so we decided to again we were not happy with the way school boards was um conducting that search so we went with a search firm um we did get and I don't think I

164have that with me we did get information on the cost to use School boards I believe the search firm did not it did not cost us anything unless we hired one of their people if I remember um we would have to pay for an ad no matter who we use the the information that we Post in a lot of different places we would have to pay for that ourselves and I believe that was approximately $3,000 thank you if I may sorry it was $12,000 if I recall correctly I think uh at the last training session uh the the lady who gave us the presentation about this to Super and search gave it different categories of uh service that they provide um but however she did also mention the fact that some of the resources in

165terms of where we can put it put the um the job posting up is free of charge because we are members of the njs sa so I Schoolboard Association so my I I think I said this in the past and I'm going to reiterate that again um we may have the best qualified candidate right on of knows within the district however I think it shows the transparency and also empowers whoever we select at the end of the search that they've been gone through the due process I recommend that we actually do both external and internal or do it external so that the internal can also um apply for the position would you like to make that into a motion I would like to make that as a motion okay could you make it into a

166motion then Mr Gorski will write it down and then that would be the motion we would second then we'd have comments or um you know discussion and then we would vote on that uh I would like to make a motion to uh advertise the position of a superintendent um in the external news media and seek candidates is there a second to that point of clarification yeah are are you recommending an outside search firm to do the process or just an internal handled search where we post to I think it's not an internal search yet but we're going to be not just posting internally but posting externally right yes yeah because we haven't decided how or who's going to do that yet so it's just a matter of where we're going to be looking for a

167candidate for superintendent got it so so he made a motion is there a second to his motion I would second the motion with the understanding if he could amend the motion to say are we going do you want us to do it or or that's not that's not not it the motion is just to do we just do it internally see are we doing an internal search no what is your motion I don't understand to go externally is that correct the the question was that do we conduct The Surge with the candidates who are internal to the district or we go outside of the district looking for candidates I'm making a motion to say that it should include both internal and external to show transparency they think you can do that you can you can

168well you do a search you do a search you open a search for that's all I'm saying right right and that's that's because any if you do a open a search to anybody an internal candidate can you don't have I don't it doesn't need to be in the motion if if if the motion I will second it if again you amend the motion to say we're going to do an external search that does not preclude internal candidates no it does not that's right so just simple no but you went back and forth so you need to amend your your resolution my mind is very very very clear okay I think we need to empower the candidate we're going to hire at the end of the day there may be a candidate right under our nose

169in the district who may be available but I think conducting a comprehensive external and internal search would help that candidate be empowered to take the position so I'm proposing that we have an external or an out of District search out of District search Okay does anybody want to Second it out of District search what Mrs ormino go ahead because I don't I I will second the uh motion to do an ex external an a comprehensive outof District search a comprehensive out of District search is that what you said Mr Mr poan a comprehensive out of District search because that's what I heard okay so let's open up for comments or questions on doing a comprehensive out of District search nobody no discussion I think we have very qualified candidates within the district and I think

170it's good for morale to hire within and search within first and so I'm going to vote no on your motion me me too I think we have gold already uh also um I think it also sends a message to our staff career pathing I think if we look internal first we have a lot of talent here so I think if we started that way first and then if we need to go out okay I also like us to start internal first I think that we have brought people from the outside in and they have not lived up to expectations they don't understand the ins and outs of Monroe and the changing Dynamics and I think we would be better off served by somebody that's been in the district who knows us who knows what flavor

171we are and where we're changing and growing and I I really like the idea as Rupa said the idea that you know you can start as a teacher here in the district and there's room for you to move up because we're going to nurture you and we're going to keep you a long time or a high school principal I think it's inappropriate we don't talk about Personnel we only talk about process Mr Ryback I I I have to say that I I think that we need to just start with uh an internal search um couple of reasons I think certainly we have outstanding Talent right here but I think and if I'm WR can correct me I think Mr Chella was alluding to something about costs and I think if we do a search internally

172and we find someone that we think is you know outstanding and again I know we have outstanding candidates then we could save a lot of money by not having to hire uh a search uh firm and I know going going through this last time uh that you know we're spending money we we ended our relationship with one firm and went with another company to because we weren't happy with the candidates we were bringing we can avoid all of that uh you could always do that afterwards but let's do an internal search First and it would save us an awful lot of time exactly what I mean time and money but what what is when you talk about a lot of money I don't think it costs more than $30,000 or I mean School boards whether

173we use them or not I think one of they they went from 7,000 to like 177,000 not saying that look any amount of money went from 4,000 to 15,000 thank you 4,000 to 15,000 but and I'm not saying that any amount of money that's taken away from instruction is taken away from children I get that but this is a very important situation it's probably about a $200,000 a year plus with benefits right salary it's an important district and I believe transparency um and we've we've heard you know over the years from the from the public that they have uh there's there's a slight there's slight issues with their our transparency so I think um I think we should absolutely vote to if our candidates are that good internally they will rise to the top anyway

174right I'm not so what's the problem I'm not if I if I can go ahead I you certainly bring up a point with money certainly not millions of dollars but it costs and it's time um I think that uh you know we have outstanding candidates here I think we should look at that first before before going out before going outside I don't think transparency is the right term here um Mr omo I think that you know we're being open uh in saying this is this is who we have let's take a look at who we have first and see who fits the bill and if we find someone who we agree on that's fine if not then we then we then we move on that's all I'm saying may I may I um I I

175I I thought I made it abundantly clear to everybody what I was suggesting I'm not suggesting spending a penny on anybody all I'm saying is the resources are available at njsba where they would allow us to post the position on a website there's no cost involved this will entitle the candidate whoever is going to be select Ed that I have been selected out of a pool of everybody they did not restrict anyone everything was transparent that's all I'm getting it uh and I'm not suggesting that we hire a firm we hire njsba n none of that there's no Penny I do agree with Madam president that yes there'll be more resumés coming in so it'll require us to go through a little bit more time consuming but like I don't know maybe Patty said it

176I think at the end of the day the candidate who knows our district best who knows the out of District challenges would raise up on the top and be able to be selected okay the only thing I'd like to say is that the last two times we've had a new superintendent um in fact uh School Board said that when they were here um the the salary for superintendent has been capped so people don't make a lateral move from one District to another District because they they want to go here um if they're not making any more money so what they do is you're going to get a smaller District trying to make more money coming into a bigger district and we found the last two times that coming from a small District you have a

177long or a a very it's not a short learning curve to come into Monroe and learn about the the district and the the issues that are happening here and it it takes them a long time to to understand Monroe and then get into the feel of things the other thing is um hopefully we will be doing a a referendum and you construction and how many superintendents out there have construction um experience in the past or referendum experience in the past so that's something else um you know we'll we'll take a vote we we will do what we always do it's um go with the majority of the board so unless anybody else has um any other comments or questions or disc discussion the the only other point I want to bring up is when we

178had the March 4th meeting was it when the njsba representative was here she also said that she highly recommends that we conduct not just internal but do external also um I she highly recommended it so anything else could we read the motion again yes it's to engage in a comprehensive added District search open to external and internal candidates okay we'll have a roll call Mr Rybeck no Mrs Lang no Mrs Deo no Mr Tano no Mr plur yes Mrs armenio yes Mr rutsky I am torn um but I'll I I'll stick with the yes doesn't matter it doesn't matter I'll stick with my yes so noted Mr Chella no Mrs seagull no Mrs kpano no madame board president motion fails that's my first failure I love it would somebody like to make a motion to

179do I will make a motion to do an internal search for a superintendent second second second by Mr Tano okay any discussion on that or do we want to just go to the vote we had the discussion I think we did okay motion on the floor made by Mrs Deo seconded by Mr Tano to engage in an internal search only Mr plur no Mrs armeno no Mrs Deo yes Mrs Lang yes Mr cherella yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr rutsky yes Mrs seagull yes Mr Tano yes Mrs kapano yes this motion requires a simple majority it has passed with eight y okay so the second question is which could be very easy thing do we want to use school boards for an internal search or do we want to do it ourselves we want to I

180want to do it ourselves motion I make a motion that we do it ourselves I second that do we need conversation about this yes I'd like to know how that's going to be handled who will be uh the the candidates have to apply to whom and who will be getting the records and who will be in the interview I I don't think we have discussed that yet that's part of well that's part of what I want to know to vote on from what I would be thinking is that they would apply to the Board of Education that how to whom and who's going to review it we all will we will every board member will review every and how how will Apple Apple cheack get it to it should not be to any administrators no

181to me you're going to get it directly from Apple track we we follow the same procedure that you did for in the past which was direct application to you and the board yeah that's independent of Apple track yeah we we can post it and instead of going through Apple track they could take every all the information and give it to the board president which will be available to all the board members so it'll go directly to you it won't be going to the board office correct uh it would go to the board office under my name I don't it's not coming to my house well the the problem is that no one in the in the board office should see who the candidates are or or any so how are you going to accumulate the

182well they would send it a confidential in an envelope okay with no names on it to you not not on the outside but on the inside right of course yeah so is that the plan is that how we did the search for the acting that's Mr good just explained to me that that's what we did um and and then once we get those applications I don't even know if we have to go through criteria then because you know um I I think there's only um a certain amount of people that have the the criteria because you need to have a a certification to do that so I think there's only a limited member people in Monroe who have that so once that happens we as a board can get together like we've done with school

183boards in the past go through all the applications decide who we want to um interview and and set up an interview schedule it it's and I'm going to make a very controversial statement but I guess it won't be my first or last but um it seems to me there's a very short list and I do feel that it's already being predetermined um by people other than myself so I'm very disappointed in the kind of um action we're taking but let let's have a vote well this has always been and we've always done this and we always will a a democratic Board of Education and the majority rules sometimes you're on the majority sometimes you're on the minority and I've been on both so I understand that but the the board has agreed as an 8

184to2 to do an uh what was it an 8 to2 to do an internal search um we I I can work with the board attorney to come up with a a plan and then send it out to all the board members to see if they would agree with that and um okay because I'm not sure and we should get clarification from somebody but I with all du respect to any of our staff I don't even know if the board attorney um should be part of it either because she she is would be an employee who would be but she would hired by the supervisor or recommended is that correct she no she would not probably would not be able to so I I will I could work with the Personnel committee if you want me

185to work with the Personnel committee I you know what I think it's already predetermined so I'm not sure that it matters but let's have a vote there's a vote on the floor I'll call the vote is there a vote on the floor I mean a resolution okay I think I was told by Steve I need to clarify my motion okay I have a noted as do it ourselves yes thank you I make a motion what what is it what did you say that the board condu that the board conducts an internal search for superintendent is that clear yes okay oh that that's it's more it's more formal yes okay so who second that who second Mr Mr I seconded and so you're agreeing to her that's y okay we'll just take a roll call okay

186the motion again is for the board to conduct an internal search for superintendent Mr Chella yes Mrs Deo yes Mr Tano yes Mrs Lang yes Mr poori yes Mr Ryback yes Mr rutsky yes Mrs seagull yes Mrs armino no Mrs K Pano yes Madam board president motion passes nine y one nay okay what I will probably do is sit with Steve my partner in crime we will discuss this and come up with a plan and then we'll send it to the rest of the board because I I think that will be our responsibility is that okay with you okay is that okay with you m Miss armini I'm sorry I I didn't hear that Steve and I will get together and work out a a plan on how to get this done once again it

187seems unilateral but you're the boss well does anybody else have a better suggestion no I just want to ask a question because I think I might I I'm having an an early senior moment did started early did we vote twice to do an internal search because I thought the second the second motion was to they go with school boards or not oh the second motion should be doesn't matter they're going to go maybe it was all right thank you I only all right well the second motion was that the board do the internal search not an outside Moe we we voted to do an internal search and then we voted to see who would do the internal search and we said the board okay all right so so is that clear enough for you I'm

188on J do I need to say it again so would any anybody besides Mr many you have an issue if Steve and I got together came up with a plan and then we before we do anything we share it with the board of education is that okay okay I see heads bobing like I think that would be great to have a plan that kind of gives us a date when you'll what we're we have to come up with the timeline yes I think and like Judge Judy says bobbleheads don't mean anything you have to say it out loud all right so are we good with this now yes I am good with it Madame President thank you Mr poori all right so we will go to now where are we um Other Board of Education

189business does anybody have anything they wish to bring to the board Mr Tano I would just like to make sure that uh people uh who have any questions or um uh anything that they anything that they want to learn about the referendum show up at the direct Center on March 11th that's a Monday at 7:00 um the superintendent will be there to answer any questions that anybody has um don't believe everything you hear some of it's not true and this is something that's very important that needs to be uh addressed and you need to have knowledge of it before you you make an uninformed vote that can can hurt our kids in the future that's all thank you anyone else oh I I call uh Mr T 's comment on that I got a couple

190things that I want to bring up as part of this first thing is the educational uh advocacy committee meeting was actually yesterday because of the weather we canceled it we're going to reschedule it and we'll notify the public on that the second item is that uh in Monro Township uh the high school students put together what's called as a 3M which is uh Monro mindful Mentor it's a me mentorship there's about 30 kids who enrolled in that the India USF form of Township is conducting that in the rec center uh there's about 30 students uh the mentees and the mentors and they're giving them uh positive psychology training public speaking sessions and things like that after a 12-hour program um each of the uh the mentees will be presenting on the women's History Month on

191March 9th uh in the rec center uh I I want to bring it to the board's attention that you know this is a voluntary thing that been done by the high school students uh and having seen some of the the kids speak so fearlessly in front of the mic it was very impressive uh but I think we can f- tune everybody's uh you know skill set in terms of public speaking so this is a great uh initiative that's taken by some of the kids so I just want to applaud them for that uh the other point is there's a lot of ambiguity and and a lot of questions that fly in the social media people taking advantage of the fact that we always come out and say that I speak as a not as a

192member of the board of education but as a public person so I I think having seen that and we've been um sent some emails and some derogatory comments on social media I would like to propose a motion uh maybe suggest to the Madame President that maybe we write a letter as a board supporting the referendum uh there's 10 of us here I believe that all 10 of us are going to vote yes and yes on it they're looking for the mayor to support it I think they finally got that I think the the board also putting our support behind it would go a long way with the public I second that so for me to write a letter to the editor on behalf of the board correct support of the referendum right because I I

193know we talked about it but it's I can't do that on my own without the support of the Board of Education um so I have no problem with that if you made a motion Joel made a second any comments or questions about that we'll take a roll call then please let me win this one motion on the floor moved by Mr plur second by Mrs Deo uh to have the board president draft a letter on behalf of the Board of Education supporting the referendum that was already Yes Mrs armeno yes Mr cherell yes Mrs Deo yes Mrs Lang thinking about it Andy yes noted as a yes Mr blurry yes Mr Rybeck um yes I'll go along I want it Mr rutsky yes Mr yes Mr Tano yes Mrs kapano thank oh thank you yes

194noted as a yes Mr congratulations I that's your first one we'll have many more all right is there any other Mr I just want to add a little more Thunder to what um Mr toffano said because it's so important um people really need to get out we're doing a lot of uh presentations and people need to really go to those to hear fact you know from us but also know you can ask questions it's not just sitting and listening you can ask questions and there's other ways you can certainly go on the website and find that information you could call and find it we're doing everything I think possible to answer these questions the thing you need to do is just don't listen to your friend your neighbor what you read on on Facebook or

195in in social media find out for yourself so thank you for bringing that up anybody else Miss Mrs Lang um I just wanted to remind everybody that on February 20th the Jamesburg cpag has invited us to attend their um meeting which is about transition and it's they're having a speaker from the um Arc is coming so that's February 20th 6:30 at the JFK School Mr rutsky said I was right with that and um our next as as Mr Goodall said our next meeting of the Monroe Township cpeg um Betty sabaro who's been working very hard to keep all parents involved and notified that's scheduled for March 14th at 7 o'clock and I know one of the things that Betty was talking about today is she wants parents to know that it doesn't matter what your

196child might be classified as if you have a child within special education or a child who might need extra help they haven't been classified yet please come this is not just exclus for one group of parents this is for all of us together to work together and then please try not to forget about the the wonderful um the rppa Honor Society thing on March 14th and I think that's going to be very interesting at 2:15 in the afternoon thank you okay anyone else then we're back to public forum anyone wishing to speak to the board please come to the microphone and state your name and address for the record again 4 minute time limit and we can only come up once hi my name is Helen R mois 14 carton Wood Court in Monro Township

197I have a freshman uh that swims so uh I've been asking questions around trying to figure out why Monroe who has so many good programs for athletes clubs educational all over the board but we don't have a swim program and this year we had six 16 swimmers who went out and swam at the GMC's and they can't go and practice they practice with their Club but no with the township they don't have that same that other high schools you know provide for their swimmers where they go to different meets to get a chair for each other they go there like a little group and they swim and they compete and they go home we had six people six kids who had medals who placed really well so we are wondering as a parent what can

198we parents do to help and what is the board doing because we like and love to have a swim team based on student interest uh the swim club is being proposed in the budget for next year M uh so that will be presented uh in the spring in March and and affirmed in April and um when we add a athletic team to our program we usually started as a club and then the following year we make it a program Athletic program okay thank you is it anything else we parents can do to help just to support the budget proposal okay support what we're doing here okay but we know it's time to add a swim team great thank you so much anyone else from the public Maria fante 7 Angelina Court um I'd just like

199to take this opportunity on behalf of the Monroe Township middle school PTO Board of officers to express our sincere appreciation to our Acting Superintendent Rob Goodall board president Kathy K and especially board Vice President Steve Ryback for launching an investigation regarding Middle School organizations it has been extremely challenging to remain positive and carry out the good work of the long-standing Middle School Organization the PTO amid the callous acts of deception and attempts to discredit and slander the good intention volunteers that have sacrificed and not give and given not only of our time but a piece of our spirit we have been ridiculed and lied about in public forum simply because because we chose to carry on the tradition of the PTO and support the faculty Administration parents and most importantly the middle school students thank

200you for believing in us and supporting us during this most difficult time your concern and Swift action during a time when you were consumed with passing the much-needed referendum speaks volumes about your concern for our children regardless of the outcome of your investigation thank you for acknowledging our dedication and passion thank you thank [Applause] you prakash per 33 uh Dana Drive U very appreciative about the curriculum regarding coding for the 8th grade thank you that's very nice and also math competition thank you very much that's uh very good uh what has happened is you all know that all across our town Town constructions are going on my tax has increased threefold Mr Ryback would like you to speak into the microphone cuz he can't hear you you thank you thank you so you know our

201goal is very important that we get this referendum passed in a positive way we all think and there's lot of on the Facebook I see a lot of NOS so we try to you know answer and pursue them so coming to the bottom line you know our taxes are going up and you know as the construction goes on when the new community comes in we need expansion of the schools we need Recreation we need parks and the impact fees okay so the builders also they contribute to the society and everyone it success for both you know so the resolution was passed it is good we have started it the council passed a resolution in December calling for the legislators to have a pass a law so that we the municipalities can collect impact fees to

202support the schools so it will be very good the similar type of resolution will be passed by Boe so that it supports you know we also are lobing for that so it it strengthens okay so that's a request um we have we were bringing that issue up to the educational advocacy committee and unfortunately yesterday uh because we had no school that committee had um okay did not have a chance to meet so it will be brought up at their next meeting thank you very much Madam president the second thing yesterday you know I saw that eight schools are suing the state because they don't like the bill which is become a law S2 youall all know what is S2 so they lost um you know the schools are getting less paid by 1 million or

2032 million they used to get I think 400 Millions now they are getting less 2 million or 3 million I don't know but eight schools are suing the state so we you know you all all know that our funding was frozen for 8 years and we didn't sue at all to the state you know so we have to I want the advocacy team to look at you know how we can we can sue the state okay because now the money we are going to get get back is phased into next 6 years suppose we were getting in 2008 $8 million that to get back last year we got 2 million this year another one addition so it is going to take 6 years plus you know you should look at the funding formula it doesn't

204pay much for us for our special education is very important we get funding for the special education you know and with the current Formula doesn't justify that so we should look into the different way to sue the state so that we get our funding Fair funding from this from the state you know so just a thought process so think about it okay that is another um uh piece that the educational advocacy committee will be looking into to because as we we've probably in the past talked to four or five different attorneys we don't have a reason to sue we cannot sue the state and win so if we want to make sure that we do win we have to have a a criteria to to sue the state and we haven't fallen under anybody's criteria

205yet so we will be looking because there are special ed there's Transportation there are issues that we can look at and that new committee will be doing that thank you very much you're welcome anyone else seeing no one we'll close public forum close session resolution um be it resolved that the Board of Education of the township of Monroe hereby moves to go into close session in accordance with the Sunshine Law chapter 231 of the public laws of 1975 njsa 10 colum 4-6 through1 colum 4-21 to discuss the following subjects student student discipline appeal at the high school harassment intimidation and bullying following Clos session action may be taken the discussion conducted in close session can be discussed to the public at such time as the need for confidentiality no longer exists I need a motion

206in a second second Mr Mayo Mr Ryback all in favor I opposed then at this time the board will move into closed session time the board will move back into public session and Mr good will read a resolution following a student discipline appeal during which the Board of Education heard the parents appeal and reviewed relevant evidence including a video of the incident in question it is recommended that the Monroe Township Board of Education affirmed the decision of the Acting Superintendent of Schools regarding the student disciplin appeal involving student number 90712 and directs the Acting Superintendent to Prov provide a copy of this resolution to the parents the Acting Superintendent is hereby authorized and directed to take all necessary steps to implement this action by the Board of Education move by Mr Ryback second second by

207Miss Deo comments or questions roll call Mr Gorski Mr rutsky I yes Mr cherella yes Mrs seagull yes Mrs Lang yes Mr poori yes Mr Rybeck yes Mrs armeno yes Mrs Deo yes Mr Tano abstain Mrs Co P yes Madam board president motion passes thank you uh at this time anybody from the public wish to speak uh on the Clos session item please please come to the to the microphone microphone and state your name and address for the record Patty Biz Nano for birwood Road Jamesburg New Jersey so your decision is to let me just clarify to go ahead with the suspension yes okay let me start by saying how extremely disappointed we are in the school administration and the security my daughter was attacked by three girls from another school at our school three

208girls when leaving that basketball game on January 7 uh 10th my daughter her boyfriend and her friend were walking out of the building those three girls from Oldbridge came behind them yelling and cursing at them I don't want to repeat what they said cuz it was pretty disgusting my daughter turned around and one girl continued to push my daughter's friend who was directly behind her and then grabbed my daughter by the hair pulled her down while her other two friends then started punching and kicking her on top of her and I have that on video my daughter was trying to do whatever she could to get that girl to let go of her and to get away thankfully detective degra came in and pulled that girl off my daughter but she got away from him

209he then fell into the crowd and onto the ground along with my daughter and I have that on video as well they both got up and he went outside to the Mayhem that was happening outside in the parking lot come to find out that the girl that did provoke and attack my daughter to begin with was outside finding other Monroe students and was arrested that night for it there were no security guards at the door when they were leaving not one if the school was aware of the past problems with Oldbridge high school and heard Rumblings that there may be an issue then why didn't they have security at all exits this for sure would not have happened if they did my daughter went to the police outside for help they helped her because she

210was bleeding from being hit in the face now you want to suspend her for 10 days for something she had no control over for defending herself when you couldn't protect her your blanket policy doesn't work here your attorney suggests that she doesn't have a right to defend herself and protect herself should she have just crawled up in a tiny ball and wait for somebody to come and save her I don't think so how unreasonable and dangerous does that sound what if that person had a weapon would that have made a difference cuz you don't know if she did or not if someone comes into our school starts attacking our kids will they be suspended for defending themselves those students from obridge high school came into our school with ill intent and boy did they succeed

211my daughter has never had a physical altercation with anyone she has not been suspended or had detention she has lost faith in all of you as do I while I understand your Zero Tolerance policy it doesn't apply here this wasn't an argument or a RI between students who have a history they never even met before these people came here to do harm to our kids your discipline policy clearly states Administration retains the right to modify when and where necessary and I believe this should have been one of those times you said you did a thorough invest vestigation not once did you question those that were with her how is it that you can make a rational and a and a logical decision without asking those that were there my daughter is not your sacrificial lamb

212the one that you need to make get your point across she was outs wasn't outside fighting in the Mayhem and not listening to the police if she was then we wouldn't be here she would have served her suspension and rightfully so she was the victim and that's why I'm here today and that's why I have these people here today fighting for her my name is Suzanne Kavanaugh and I am a parent and I have to say that I am extremely disappointed shame on you and I'm sure some of you are parents you're certainly not acting like parents but you are put on this board to to protect people and the person that you were supposed to protect was her and you let people come from the outside into this District that you are supposed to

213protect and they're calling the shots shame on you shame on you you have to go home and look in the mirror my name is Robert Kavanaugh um I'm Grace's cousin I'm actually a police officer in Hudson County um I just want to talk about the self-defense issue sometimes it's not as simple as a policy um everything is not always always how it is on paper and you can't look at everything like that um sometimes things happen and people react different ways at different times to different situations how would you react if you're getting assaulted by three different people I mean things are said but when you're when you're attacked by three different people and assaulted like that you have to defend yourself and and I just want you to think about that and just realize

214that for the future everything isn't always as simple as a policy and you have to put human you have to consider uh human emotion and how people are going to react in that situation thank you Bob rzza 5 Birchwood Road Jamesburg New Jersey I just have a question my son's coming here in September If somebody walks up and punches him strikes him pulls a knife on him clear I'm to tell him to do nothing that's a question please answer what is your ruling so I don't have to do what here tonight if someone attacks my son he's supposed to do nothing what is your policy I'm asking you have zero tolerance but yet you have no words what happens if someone attacks my son on September 10th I've got three more minutes I'll wait nothing

215what's the policy wow good looking out for the kids you got [Music] nothing you won't even tell me what the policy is as as a parent bringing a kid to this school not one of you cowards Chrissy scurby 21 pness drive it's really shocking what is going on here tonight um it's sad that you can't even answer what policy is you spoke in close session about bullying and intimidation we take bullying very seriously in our district I recently opened an email sent by the middle school PTO to Mr Goodall with a list of false accusations against the Middle School PSA the school administration and the security at the middle school I provided factual information to the board regarding every ridiculous accusation Mr Goodall what were your findings of your investigation did the principal do anything

216wrong did the PSA do anything we were accused of the only thing the PSA is guilty of being is successful this year no one other than the middle school PTO takes to social media to bully false claims about the P it started with the hate packet in August and it needs to end scurby this the focus of this Board needs to be the referendum you to pleas St or we're going to have you remove from the building I'm speaking about bullying intimidation that on your agenda to do with this closed session it's on the agenda is bullying and intimidation and we we' that that is not the agenda item is for students the focus of our board should be on educating ask to is not a public forum for General comments it's it's on a

217closed session item that's fine it's a shame it's a shame what our our district has become you don't answer policy questions but you'll stop me from talking because a mommy group failed this year and to blame everybody other than it's a very very sad evening here shame on all of you Robert Kavon the attorney for uh the family can I have your name and address for oh yes uh Robert kavanau wers mcferson mcneel uh 300 lighting way SE orus New Jersey um I'm the attorney for the family I just need to uh get a answer to one of two questions one does the 10-day suspension uh take place immediately uh the parents will be notified tomorrow from Administration on the details of a suspension okay and number two considering this is a significant 10day suspension

218and this child is uh taking classes such as physics and um Algebra 2 and other uh hafty classes is she going to be provided a tutor at home uh because the negative impact on her uh her class work could be that's Yes she'll be provided home instruction uh per the statute and they will discuss that with the parents and the student uh how to support that okay thank you anyone else from the public wishing to speak hi my name is Susan VI I live at 8 Wedgwood court and I've known the bizana family for a very very long time and I have to say that I'm very disappointed as they are with the results here tonight and I'm especially disappointed to know that a child can't defend themselves you know it would be a totally

219different situation if it were two students from under high school fighting each other that there might be history there but this was definitely just an assault on one of our children and I'm just really really scared where this is headed where we can't even defend our own children in this community that's all I have to say hi I'm Mara Canada I live um 7el Drive um I'm a student here and Grace has been my best friend for a long time and I just want to say that I don't feel safe with what is going on and I don't feel safe in the school if anyone were to harass me or or attack me in any way I would not feel safe because of your policy and because of your I just trying to suspend her

220for something she wasn't in any control of and I'm just speaking for her because I would not feel I just don't feel safe at all anymore I thought I did so I'm very disappointed in this school and the policy so thank you [Applause] anyone else wishing to speak seeing no one we will close that public forum our next scheduled Board of Education meeting is on Monday March 18th at 7 7 o'cl p.m. at the high school which is our preliminary budget hearing uh I need a motion to adjourn second Mr tiella Mr Ryback all in favor I opposed and the meeting is adjourned

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.