CorpusRecord 133003

Monroe Township Board of Education 02.04.19 Special Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Monroe Township School District
Date
2025-02-11
Location
Middlesex County, NJ
Material
Transcript
Extent
10,992 words · about 62 min
Collected
2026-06-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001sometimes we flip the coin good evening the meeting of a special meeting of the Monro Township Board of Education will come to order please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance Al to the flag of the United States of America and to the rep for it stands one nation under God indivisible and jce for all may we have a roll call Mr Gorski certainly Mrs armeno here Mr cherella Mrs Deo here Mrs kapano here Mrs Lang here Mr poori here Mr rybec Mrs Seagle here absolutely Mr Tano here and Mr rutsky here Madame board president you have a quarum present this evening in accordance with the provisions of the New Jersey open public meetings law the Monro Township Board of Education has caused notice of this meeting to be published by having the date time and

002place thereof posted February 1st 2019 at all schools the home News Tribune cranberry press and filed with the clerk of the municipality thank you Mr Gorski we'll go to number five on the agenda it is recommended that the Board of Education suspend the operation of policy bylaw 0164 to permit the board board to conduct only one public for at this evening's public meeting need a motion in a second Mrs Lang oh Peter got it he second it Peter did okay Peter to panel all in favor I opposed abstain I'll abstain on that one miss Armenia was abstaining we accuse okay then the motion carries and we will only have one public forum and tonight we're here because we as a board felt that we needed some training for the superintendent evaluation process which is pretty

003new and the superintendent search process which we will be going through pretty soon so we have with us tonight Kathy woff the field representative or the field service rep from New Jersey school boards and she is going to help us through um the process and we thank you for coming here on a Monday night after the Super Bowl that's okay I I only watched it for the um rumor commercial cuz my team didn't make it in so I really wasn't interested good evening um as Kathy said I'm Kathy winoff with New Jersey school boards and um I cover the districts in Mammoth County and I also have a handful of districts in Ocean County and it took me all of 15 minutes to get here so you're really closer than probably most of my districts

004that I go into to visit so just a little bit about me I've been with the association for 12 years prior to that um I was a board member for nine years just right up the road in in Millstone Township so you know I'm pretty close by um and um Maryanne couldn't be here so she asked me if I would pinch it so I'm here to pinch it um and we're going to talk about the evaluation process um I don't no I I would assume that last year whenever you did your evaluation you used the previous evaluation that we have always used and um over the past couple of years we have been revising the evaluation um with the help from njasa so both our association and the superintendent Association came together and it took

005them about three years to go through the process to update the evaluation you have a packet of information in front of you um the PowerPoint is on the right hand side if you want to follow through and make any notes but the biggest piece that you'll want to be following is this is the booklet for the evaluation process and as we go through it the actual document is contained within the booklet and I like to tell my boards to keep it close by for a handy reference um what has changed most of all in the new evaluation tool are is part two of the evaluation which contains the leadership standards what we did whenever we were going through the process um we looked at the Professional Standards for educational lead leaders um that were formally

006the isck standards um we looked at evaluation tools from other states um we relied heavily on the job description that we have um at New Jersey school boards um in our policy dep Department with regards to the superintendent job description and I would um say to you especially the newer board members that you may want to get a copy of the job description of the superintendent just to see what some of the duties and responsibilities are of the superintendent we also used the previous tool that we had used and more importantly we wanted to make sure that the new tool that we migrated to was really consistent with what the board's role is in the evaluation process um I will tell you um with my District's last year um of the 80 some districts that

007I um work with 63 of them used our evaluation tool and a third of them used the new tool and so I was really interested to get a lot of feedback from them as to you know did they like it did they not like it what did they like about it what didn't they like about it I will tell you overwhelmingly um superintendents like the tool as well as the board members were really um happy with it because it is now an evidencebased tool so as you're going through the process your superintendent is now going to be giving you evidence not only with regards to the goals because the superintendent previously gave you evidence with the goals but now for those leadership standards pieces there will be evidence that the board will be looking at

008as you go through the evaluation and I think for brand new board members because of the fact that it is now evidencebased new board members will feel confident that they'll be able to participate in the evaluation process because that evidence is going to be Supply but there will still be the opportunity that if you really don't feel comfortable in those standards that that not observed category is still there um and it's important to know that it's not a positive it's not a negative it's just indicating that as a board member I've not experienced this in my board member life to date and that's no problem um you know when it goes back to all about accountability you know what our roles and responsibilities are as board members and what the superintendent roles and responsibilities are

009using your goal setting process because when we do the goal setting that's where we get the goals that we evaluate the superintendent on if you have a strategic plan those goals are derived from that strategic plan the superintendent should be giving you updates on the progress towards the achievement of the goals and then once you complete the evaluation of the superintendent the final piece is for the board to its own self- evaluation that really kind of rounds out that entire cycle so if you look at the uh roles and responsibilities with regards to the board and superintendent you know the big piece that I always tell my boards is that they need to focus on the what that's the board's role what it is that we want to have happen here in the district and

010then why do we need it and how much is it going to cost because we you know we have to be mindful and be fiscally responsible and then once we establish the what along with the superintendent he is then going to create your action plans to accomplish your goals but then he's going to through the action plans determine how your what is going to get carried out when it's going to get carried out and who in The District's responsible for carrying it out and then at the end of the process the board then comes back and evaluates how well the superintendent carried out the what you asked him to do and we do that through the evaluation process um goals for our new board members you know we're sometimes working with four different sets of

011goals at one particular point in time we have the board goals and those are owned by everyone meaning you the board and the superintendent own those goals we have um those can revolve around um you know anything in the district professional development curriculum program you know finances uh facilities carries covers a whole um host of things that are going on in the district the board goals are owned by the board and those General generally revolve around board process and procedure but the board may have specific board goals that will assist the superintendent in carrying out the district goals so you know if a District's going to end up going through a referendum for se you know like I have one District that's getting ready to you know possibly think about going out to referendum so

012one of their board goals this year was for the board to get educated on the referendum process the timelines so that as they move forward with that initiative at the board has an idea of what their responsibilities are all through the process then you have superintendent goals those are the superintendent's personal goals and his professional development goals and the board generally you know does not see what those goals are the superintendent works on them on his own the only time that the board would be involved in the crafting of superintendent goals is if in fact something went kind of South in the evaluation and the board feels that the superintendent may need you know to get skills in whatever it may be I mean you know it's not a good one to use but the

013one that always comes to the top of my head is anger management you know the board may say to the superintendent we really need you to go and get some professional development and work on this particular issue and the four set of goals that you may or may not have are Merit goals and those are contractual and um are negotiated with the superintendent on an annual basis and that does increase his salary if in fact those Merit goals are accomplished not all district have miror goals but some do our governance cycle so our goal setting begins generally over the summer whenever you formally sit down and you have a discussion and come to mutual agreement on the goals with the superintendent um then by September hopefully the superintendent has created his action plans to carry

014out the goals has shared them with the board and then begins um working on those and then throughout the year he gives updates on the progress towards the achievement of the goals you do the evaluation you do your board evaluation and then we start the cycle all over again um with regards to the evaluation process um one of the more important ones um in recent past is to make sure that you get the evaluation completely put to bed me means all pieces of the evaluation by July 1st um otherwise you'll lose six points for qac and I do know that the executive County superintendents throughout the state are asking and looking for documentation in the district that that evaluation has been completed by July 1st in the past a board could have done it in

015December and it was no big deal but the statutory requirement for that evaluation has always been July 1st it's just that the board has never been accountable and held to that July deadline until this pre this past year so you know there is a sample calendar in here on the left hand side of the packet and you all know we love colored paper so it is the salmon colored paper and if you follow um the timeline the suggested timelines that are in this calendar it will get you to that July 1 deadline you know you have to take into account you know how how many times a month does your board meet once or twice a month once just once okay so you may have to push that timeline up a little bit in order

016to meet all of the benchmarks or you may have to do like you did tonight and when it gets to be the the end of May or June schedule a special meeting just for the purposes of completing that evaluation and you can always do that too because of the timelines to get this done and if you see in the calendar they really suggest that you start doing it late April chances are you're going to be evaluating the superintendent on the progress towards the achievement of the goals because he still has May and June to finish up the goals so most often it will be on the progress towards the achievement of the goals and as I said you know the evaluation is in statute and code has to be done once a year the evaluation

017the final evaluation does have to be in writing the board and the superintendent meet in Clos session to discuss the evaluation um and as I said it's based on goals and objectives and those responsibilities and then in code you see where that July one deadline is there and it's important to note that the evaluation the the final written evaluation reflects the majority opinion of the board so if the majority of the board has indicated that the superintendent is the next best thing since Li spread that's how the evaluation gets written I'm probably dating Myself by making that saying I think still and but that doesn't mean that that Minority opinion goes away the minority opinion that is contained within the evaluation gets expressed verbally to the superintendent at the summary conference all right I'm sorry

018you'll have to like shout out your name okay no problem um Michelle arm Mino real quick the um evaluation the board meets in close session to discuss it originally then we without the superintendent correct okay then we go into our written evaluation and then we review our in another close session we review the results so what you're going to do is and we'll walk through that process a little bit so so if you follow this calendar okay one of the things that they've added with this new evaluation tool so let's look at the middle of the calendar where it talks about an evaluation pre-conference that is something that we have added this year it is not required but that is the opportunity for the superintendent to give the board one final update on the pro

019progress towards the goals before the evaluation process begins and then the superintendent will first access the evaluation he'll go online enter his goals upload the evidence for the goals and the standards once he completes it they put into the evaluation a 48h hour time lack meaning once he hits save and complete 48 hours after that each one of you who were able to participate in the evaluation will receive an email from njsba telling you that the evaluation is ready for you to go in and for you to complete your portion the reason why we put the 48 hours in is because we had quite a few instances where a superint endent may have gone in and entered complete and then a board member may have started it and a superintendent would say oh I forgot

020to add something really important and then he's not able to go back in and access unless we wipe out all of that information for him to start back over so this 48 Hours gives him time to go in and make any last minute changes to that evaluation and then you'll all receive notification and then you're all going to go in and you're going to complete your portion and then once that gets finished the evaluation is going to be compiled once the board president lets Maryann know that everybody has completed it and it's ready for compilation Maryanne does her magic we all have magic that we get it compiled and then we deliver it to the board now it gets delivered to the board in one of two ways the board president can access it download

021it and then she makes copies for all of the board members and then shares it with you or Maryanne has our administrative assistant make copies for all of you and then hand delivers it either to the board president or sometimes the board the board asks that we deliver it to the full board in close session which we do so that is when the board has this first executive session that is listed here at the end of May Kathy yes when we do the individual members evaluation about how long should that time period be like do we have a a standard is there something no it can take you as as long as it needs for you to take there the first time it came out online you they have add in there a time frame

022and now you could do it over several days so as long as you log out and log back in you're going it's going to bring you to the last place that you left off in that evaluation okay so it's not like you have to sit down and do it all in one setting you know so you have time to you know come back so when you meet in that first closed session the superintendent needs to receive a rice notice for that meeting and the board meets in close session by itself the ba is not there there's nobody there for the board to review the results of the compiled evaluation and determine what the majority opinion of the board is and then the board president or the board president can assign some lucky board member to

023write that final evaluation so you're taking all of the information that you discussed at that Clos session meeting at the end of May and you're coming up with a written evaluation and then you may determine that you want a second close session meeting for the board to see what that final written evaluation looks like before it's given to the superintendent so I would also suggest every time that you're meeting to discuss the evaluation in Clos session you need to ensure that the superintendent has a rice notice then when you're going to have the summary conference with the superintendent he receives a rice notice for that meeting also and then he will meet with the board in close session to discuss the evaluation so what you should do is at least give the evaluation to the

024superintendent at a minimum 5 days before your meeting with him so that he has the opportunity to read through the evaluation and thoughtfully come up with any questions that he may have about the evaluation I mean I can remember the first time I was on my board I mean I felt sorry for our superintendent because the board President we came into the meeting she gave him the evaluation and she said here sit here and read it and then we're going to discuss it well that's not fair to the superintendent because he's just looking at it for the very first time and you know sometimes you need to read come back and read it again and then be able to thoughtfully come up with any questions that you may want to have with the board so

025then once you have that that final summary conference which would most likely be at your last your meeting in June and you have that summary conference with the superintendent the board president signs the evaluation the superintendent signs the evaluation and it's also important to note that just because the superintendent signs the evaluation does not necessarily mean that he agrees with it he is signing to say that he received it and then he has 10 days after that to attach anything or if the evaluation is such that he needs to write a rebuttal he can write a rebuttal to the evaluation and I have had some superintendant do that and when when the superintendent attaches anything he has to let the board know that there's been an attachment to the evaluation and in most of my

026districts the attachment that gets added to the evaluation are student performance test scores the you know the ones that they do at you know that they may do inhouse at the end of the year they may attach that to the evaluation if there is something attached to the evaluation as I said the board's entitled to see it you cannot remove it and then a copy goes to the superintendent for his personnel file and the board is to retain a copy also for their records and what most of my boards do is they give it to their board attorney to keep in their permanent file so I mean that's you know following the calendar but you know as I said you know that pre-evaluation conference is really you know that final update and so you'll see

027the goals assessment piece is not much different than what it was in the past um the other thing I should talk about um is that the other thing that has changed in this evaluation are the actual ratings so if you um look in your booklet on page four okay you will see you know what part one is going to look like um and this booklet will be updated but here at the very top where it talks about uh remarks supporting the rating um there will be an added um box in there and that's where the superintendent is going to upload links to the goals so you can go in and check his progress towards the goals that way you won't have that great big long Litany of superintendent comments um because he'll be able to

028add links but then here are our new scorings you'll see exemplary proficient area for growth unsatisfactory and not observed so those are the new the new ratings that we have um here's the new standards um we're going to Mission Vision and core values for standard number one governance ethics and professional norms for number two so you'll see what those six new indicators [Music] are um as I said here's the ratings now this happens to be for standard one and I would caution you to please make make sure that you read the definition for the rating for all six standards because they are slightly different standard to standard so that's the other piece that um has changed here is the sample resources so this will give the superintendent an idea of some of the resources that

029he can provide as evidence to the board and for the board to be aware that this may be some of the evidence that you are getting with regard to that particular standard and then the links are provided by the superintendent so for you those links are live links that are going to direct the board back to your District your your District server so so the hint that most of my superintendents that have gone through the new tool said that they were going to be using for this year is um they're doing most of them are using Google platform they're creating one folder that says superintendent valuation and then inside that folder are subfolders one for each goal so if there's four goals and then the six standards so there could be 10 uh subfolders in

030there and then you're able to Uplink as as the time goes on the evidence into each one of those folders so that it could potentially be that the link that you're providing is just to that one folder or you could put the links to the individual folders however however it's best for you to work out with your it department so that that link then will get the board to wherever it is that they need to be to get that information um and this is the other thing that has really changed so let's see in this booklet that's on page two um where you see the Mission Vision for standard one you see the ratings and then there are indicators underneath so this is only showing four of them there's more than four so you're going

031to go through and you're going to mark your boxes for each indicator but what the new evaluation now is requiring you to do as a board member is once you get that standard done is for you to go back up and look at your individual ratings for those in indicators and then make an overall assessment and you'll see it down at the bottom of the page for that overall standard so this will kind of take away from you know a board member putting exemplary proficient proficient proficient and then giving an overall sat unsatisfactory rating kind of takes that away because you're looking at those those indicators where you mark them and now you're directing them towards the proficient area which will assist Kathy or whomever is writing the evaluation to come up with what that

032majority opinion of the board is for that particular standard that kind of takes away a little bit of that guesswork then the last thing that we've added that my superintendent absolutely loved was um the CSA summative evaluation template and that is on page 10 page it starts on page 10 here 13 13 on page 13 so what will happen is the board president will have access to this document and it it will allow you to copy and paste from the compiled evaluation because the board president has access to it the comments from board members versus retyping everything and it will then be standard so District goal you know you would just kind of fill in the blanks with regards to the temp you would you know copy put in here what the goal statement is

033you know where the board members the majority of the board landed under those ratings and then supporting remarks you'll be able to copy and paste those remarks that support the majority opinion of the board into this document and so you'll do that for each of the goals and then each of the standards so this becomes pretty much performa across the state that if a board is using our evaluation tool this is pretty much what that final evaluation will look like um and then at the end there is an area for the board to put any overall um comments that you may want to put in there for instance you know we would like to thank the superintendent for the tremendous amount of work he did in improving test scores in the district and whatever else

034you may want to include in those summary comments again that template so you know then what comes up next is I mean because that's pretty much the whole process the whole new process so you know the superintendent like I said will go in enter everything once he hits save and complete 48 hours after you'll all receive an email do you have any board members who are conflicted from participating that means any board members who have family members who work in the district I don't think we do this year okay so that means then that all of you should be able to complete the evaluation um and then you know once you're all finished then it can be compiled now the other thing that they've done Kathy is you know um Maryann and I are kind

035of sticklers oh this probably shouldn't be taped um too late too late but here's what we do generally what happens is once I I get notification that one of my boards has completed the evaluation because when you get your notification that the superintendent has completed the evaluation I get one also I follow that up with an email to the board president saying I've received notification the superintendent has completed his or her portion of the evaluation can you share with me your timeline and then I start annoying the Daylights out of my board presidents because then I generally send two emails a week I usually send one on Friday and then on Monday or Tuesday on Friday the email says as of today's date no board members have completed the evaluation and then on Monday or

036Tuesday because that's when most board members do their work I would send an email to the board president and say oh by the way as of this morning one board member has completed the evaluation so when I do that that means then that my board presidents then annoy the Daylights out of all of the board members and says oh I received an email from Kathy she says only one board member has completed the evaluation please get it done but with the new system in addition to maryan being able to check the status the board president will be able to go in and see who has and who has not completed the evaluation um I still follow up with my boards because I do not want the executive county superintendent from Mammoth County who I happen

037to know very well call me up and say Kathy what happened with X Y and Z board that they didn't get their superintendence evaluation done within the time frame so I try to keep everybody on Target because I don't want to receive that phone call from the executive County Superintendent yes sorry Michelle armino again um when you say that the board president can go in can they only see who has completed they can't see the evaluation see the valuation they will be able because what happens is even I can't see I mean if I you know if something came up and a board member's evaluation needed to be wiped out because every now and then we will get some from a board member that says you know what I really made a mistake is there

038any way for that evaluation to be wiped out I mean I got to dance through like a lot of Hoops to get our it people so I mean I don't even have access to the indiv idual board members evaluation I just see a list of names of every board member and it tells me the date and the status so it may say you know part one is finished but part two is not done part one and two are finished and if you've hit the save and complete button it will tell me the date and the time that you completed the evaluation so that's all she'll be able to see and then it if she so say she decides she's going to download the evaluation her herself and make copies for the board to bring into

039the meeting and you decide you don't need to Maryanne to bring them in and you don't need her to walk you through the process although with three new board members you may want to have her come in and just go over that process for you know getting it completed so that you're all sure um of of what your next steps are she's the one who's supposed to make the copies of the evaluation she can't give it to the ba she can't give it to a secretary to make copies she needs to be the one to make the copies because you know it's it's kind of hard to ask one of the employees of the superintendent to make a copy of his evaluation for the board so the board you know the board president would need

040to do that when you meet in close session to discuss the evaluation she hands out copies of the evaluation to all of you when you leave that meeting she's got to collect all nine of them because they can't go home they can't you know and then once the evaluation is completely finished those compiled evaluations should be shredded because that compiled evaluation contains both the majority and the minority opin of the board and it's a working document for the board to be able to review and come up with what that majority opinion um for the written evaluation is are we good so far okay so um you know for those of you who have done the evaluation in the past this tool accessing it is no different than the previous one you'll go on um oh

041and I don't like the way they told you to go in there so I'm going to give you a short cut versus this one because instead of going to field services you know the drop- down menu for Field Services all you have to do is scroll down to the very bottom of the page of our homepage and on the bottom it says on CSA MH and board evaluation resources and you click on it and it takes you right to where you need to be to complete both the superintendent and the board evaluation and so that's the same spot it's always been right same spot okay same spot I like shortcuts um and then if you have your password if you have a current password with your dist strict email address you are good to go

042and if you don't have a password you should get a password and you can go on to the website um and under board information you just go in your user ID is your District email address and then you create your own password and then make sure you write it down because that password gets you into all areas of our website that our password protected for board member information only so that part is is really no different um you know and then you know kind of to wrap this one up you know it's not a once a year process it's something that's ongoing um you all need to you know develop some kind of aist system for you to have your own evidence to use for the evaluation so most often what happens is that board

043members will use the last thing that kind of went South in the district and use that as a basis for the superintendence evaluation not really fair because it really needs to Encompass the entire Year's worth of work so what I did as a board member was I had a notebook that I called my evaluation notebook and I used it for both the board evaluation and the superintendent evaluation and anything that I thought I might want to include in the superintendent evaluation I would jot it down it might even be you know a page from the meeting minutes from a report that the superintendent gave just so when it came time for me to do the superintendence evaluation I was doing a thoughtful evaluation that encompassed the entire Year's worth of work and then that means

044that the biggest piece that my boards if you talk to them that they tell you that I am unyielding about because there are some things that I am unyielding about and that is comments there is a an area of the evaluation under each goal and each indicator for the board to include comments and so if the superintendent is doing something that is spectacular you should note that in the comments if something really did go south you should include comments so that when it comes time to do that summary conference if something went South as part of the minority can have a discussion there was a minority opinion and it was around this one particular issue and here are some of the things the feedback that came from the board um you know because if he's

045doing something really well he can use those skills that he's doing really well in that one particular area to address something that maybe he needs some assistance in so that's why that um those comments are important and not only that it makes it much easier for the person who ends up writing the evaluation that there are comments to include that doesn't make it look like the comments are coming from the person who's writing the evaluation because there's no comments there because that's not fair to the person who's writing the evaluation either so you know when it comes time to do it you you make a note Kathy was unyielding about this I have to include comments you know and you can't say and even for the board evaluation don't say that the board is doing

046something wrong and then don't include comments because what I say to people is if somebody says that you're unsatisfactory or you need Improvement in something and you don't include a comment I would disregard it because if you just give an overall rating of unsatisfactory or needs Improvement and you don't have any comments there how are they supposed to know what to fix they don't so that's why that's important and it goes for the board evaluation too I mean because it's very easy if you happen to be the minority on the board that you're going to go through and say that everything the board does is just really not good just because but if you're going to say that the Board needs to improve its skills in some area put it in comments so that the

047board is able to you know kind of reflect to see do we need to make this a goal and do something to address it or or not how can we fix whatever that issue happens to be so then in that same area of the evaluation the first section is for the superintendent evaluation and the and the bottom couple of areas in that same area are for the board self evaluation and then go in and do the board do you usually do a board self evaluation we didn't do one last year but we did one I think the prior two years yeah it's it's it's a good thing you know it's it's a good thing to do because I think sometimes times it gives us you know a perspective you know on the board especially a

048board leader about you know what kind of Direction the board is going in and as I said it really helps Drive um your board your specific board goals but there may be something in that board evaluation that may have to be translated over into into a district goal depending on you know whatever it is that the board may put in there and so the 4 evaluation has not changed yet it's going to be down the road but not for a while um we need to make sure that this one is up and running so that's really the board you know the superintendent and board evaluation process so I don't know if you have any questions for the board evaluation when do we start the period is get a time period one year period one of

049no so there's no deadline for the board evaluation so whenever the board determines that they would like to go in and do it is usually what they do um most of my boards that I deal with like to have the evaluation for their summer Retreat and they go over it and they use that like I said to develop their board goals for for the upcoming year um some you know sometimes my boards will because you can access the board evaluation anytime the superintendent evaluation just opened up so the superintendent can go in now and begin to create the folders you know start to upload evidence and stuff so that they have it for for that particular time frame um you know so there's not really any specific deadline to get that done Kathy you just

050clarify one thing in the written summary only the majority of the the majority of board opinion of the board is included in the written evaluation okay so and then but the other part can be discussed verbally at that's verbally and and some of that sometimes is how the board determines that they want to go about doing it you know for some reason I have you know some board members that may feel you know may be in the minority and feel that the superintendent's not doing such a good job but they themselves don't want to bring it up but to me if you're going to say somebody's unsatisfactory and needs Improvement and you're the one who own who wrote the comment to me you got to own it you know but if you don't I have

051other boards that when they're coming up and doing that majority opinion at their meeting they're also making notes about the minority opinion so that this the board president may be the one at the meeting to say to the superintendent you know I just want to make you aware that there was a minority opinion in the evaluation and here's what it was and here were some of the comments that were made you know and and I would encourage you that if there is a minority opinion that you express it to the superintendent before it all of a sudden morphs into a majority opinion and he had no idea all along that there may have been issues so that you know the first time it comes up you know he can reflect on what that Minority opinion

052is and begin to address some of those issues so that it it doesn't continue to grow anything else so that's the new superintendent evaluation okay so for the um superintendent um search process I do not have a power so I don't know if um we could do that um somebody want to make a motion for like a 10-minute recess I make a motion for a 10-minute recess second second Mr Tano all in favor I opposed okay we'll take a 10-minute reset okay at this time the board will move back into public uh session and we will go on to the next presentation which is the superintendent search process okay so you all have um a little booklet in front of you um if you open up to page one um you know I always like

053to um start off uh when I talk to my boards to say our process um is geared more towards board function so we're associate we're your Association we work with you to ensure that you get the best candidate based on your criteria for the district um and as I sometimes thoughtfully like to say you know one of our big pluses is that um we ask our candidates to provide a comprehensive uh application form for us so that as your field service person we're able to go through those candidates and come up with a a checkl list of things that you're looking for in your candidate to ensure that any candidate that we bring to you meets your criteria what you're looking for in a superintendent with me um you know I'm probably um the one

054field service representative who has worked with my districts for the longest so I've been with the association for 12 years so I've worked with the districts in Mammoth County for 12 years so over those 12 years I've really gotten to know my districts so that when it comes time to assist them with their search I'm able to go through the candidates and make a determination whether they're going to be number one a good fit for the district a good fit for the board and and meet the board's criteria um and you know our process is not for the faint of heart um because it is it is comprehensive it is time intensive for our board members we depending on the level of search that you use us for really makes a determination on how much

055work you as a board need to do um you know our process is all confidential um you know and we do get good results um and I'm here to tell you that um you know our candidates are responding to your search not you know putting my resume out and saying put me in whatever District you're going to go to we work for you where sometimes I think outside firms have candidates that they're looking to place in a district where we want to make sure you get the best person for your District um we've got a lot of experience all of us that are in field service um you know we do talk there's nine there are eight other of me which is either a good thing or a bad thing um but we talk to

056each other with regards to candidates for instance you know somebody may call me I and say Kathy this this person is from one of your districts what can you tell me about them so that we're doing Outreach to among each other you know to get feedback on candidates before we bring them to you um our our recruiting we we do what we call flexible recruiting we don't do go out into a district and pull one superintendent from another uh from one district and put them into to another um although if there is a candidate you know that comes and asks us about a particular search that we're running we would encourage them to apply for the search but you know I don't go and and pull superintendents from districts because I have relationships with all

05760 districts in Mammoth County and it would be a little hard for me to pull the superintendent from a neighboring District over into another and then continue you to have a good working relationship with the board so we do send letters out to candidates if there is you know a search opening and somebody has asked to be on our list of noted you know people to be notified we do let them know ahead of time before the ad hits the paper that your your district has an opening um and we provide the biggest piece that we do is provide training through through every step of our process so you know if you hire us we come in and we meet with the board and we go through an exercise to get your criteria what you're

058looking for in a superintendent because in the end the board is the only group that can hire the superintendent superintendent's your only employee it's the only direct hire that you have as a board um and and so we would sit and meet with you come up with what your criteria is have you fill out paperwork so that we can get come to consensus on what the criteria is that you're looking for we help you develop an ad um and then we have an ad agency that we use that places the ads depending on where you want to be where you want to advertise um still you know being oldfashioned and it's not oldfashioned but the newspaper of record for educ across the state is still the Star Ledger so if you want to find out

059all of the openings across the state you're going to go to The Star Ledger to be able to find them although I will tell you that anymore one of the biggest one of the places that everybody goes to is our our website to see what openings are out there and that would be for any District that's doing the search on their own or one of the searches that we are doing so if you hire an outside consultant somebody else we will not put your ad on our website um and then we would meet with your staff and your community so to do forums you know do um forums with them to go through the process share the calendar with them and then we have you know about five questions that we ask them to find

060out what your community and staff are looking for um in this superintendent and then we use that as we're beginning to build our rating form that we will use to score all of the candidates who apply for the search in um staff members are not part of sitting in on the interview process with our process um there's not many places out there that allow employees to hire um their boss um and so we get any information from them um we asked them you know to share questions with us so I will use um any Community questions I share those with the board and I include those um in the interview process so that you know those community and staff questions are asked to any candidate and you know then you know we deliver a fully

061a full pull to the board so you get to see if you get 100 people that apply in your search you get to see all 100 applications we have them ranked as those who you know we we rate them as a b and C's the A's are those who exceed your criteria B's are those who meet your criteria and sometimes candidates don't meet your criteria but you're able to see everybody who who has applied in your search um and then make a determination as to who the majority of the board would like to bring in an interview um we help you develop those interview questions um because one of the things that we do through our process is to ensure that it's a legally defensible process um we have our legal team that you know

062if questions come to us that somebody wants to ask you during the interview process we run those questions by um our legal department to make sure that they are in fact questions that we can ask um during the search our Labor Relations Department will come out and assist you with contract training if you would like to ensure that you know your contract meets all all of the standards um that are to be met I mean pretty much anymore the contract is what it is there's not a lot of extras um that boards can include in those um contracts since the Advent of of the accountability RS um and then you know we provide pool reports to the board to let them know what their pool looks like um and then as I said we process

063all of the applications um you know if you get a 100 applications I read all 100 applications and I look at all of those applications and I line them up with all of the criteria that the board has established you know to help you make a determination as to whether it's somebody that you want to interview or you don't want to interview um and then after the new superintendent starts in District we come in and we can do a transition workshop with with the board and the superintendent to talk about expectations expectations that the board may have of the superintendent and that the superintendent may have of the board board and then we help you in developing those um goals for the new superintendent once they come on board any questions before I move to

064the next part so if you go to page five it really lays out um our four levels of search that we have and if you start at the right hand side with the $4,000 search even though it's the least amount of money that one is more time and labor intensive for the board because if you look you know that I would still come in you know we would Maryann would still come in meet with you get your criteria help you put the ad together um and then the applications would come in we would review them we would bring them to you hand the applications over to you and let you run with it then you can review them all you can determine who you want to bring in do the interviews we will help you

065um with some questions for interviews with that particular one but that one is the mostly the board's responsibility the biggest other the other thing I wanted to tell you is that advertising costs are in addition to the the cost of the search I think the last time I did a search um I think the advertising ran about $3,000 I think yes um are we still telling our names Michelle or no Michelle you've told me your name three times three times so you get me now I got you now okay um the uh advertising how long do we advertise for and I would say to you it depends usually what I do with atast is is they advertise one week we lag a week and then advertise the second week you know so there's a week

066in between um that gets you a little more exposure I think what I'm talking about is overall I mean should we advertise like for I mean PE one week to me does even two weeks doesn't no because then you advertise and then when Maryanne comes in and sets a calendar with you there will be a cut off time for applications and it generally is a month okay that's more more like yeah you know so between the oh dear the first time that I advertise and then um cut off the applications is generally a month because I figure if somebody's going to complete an application a month I hope is plenty of time for them to go in and do it but how long does it really take for the word to get out in the

067in the educational Arena not long at all not long at all because in addition to the advertising I mean we send out notices to all 21 County round tables so so it goes to every County office to let them know that there is an opening in Monroe to now is that cost also no okay so the advertising that you're discussing is like for like the Star Ledger I'm sorry I talk with my hands I'm really sorry um so oh I see uh so but if you're gonna you know and that also if you advertising with um the New York Star Ledger that gets you also on to NJ do NJ do jobs.com um we also do um and it just went right out of my head there is um a website that's just for is

068it New Jersey school jobs.com or something we advertise on that we use we put your advertisement on our Facebook page okay that gets out to everybody so I mean there's a lot of of advertising that doesn't cost you anything and I will tell you depending on the district um districts down in the southern part of the state they only advertise on our website and they're getting good pools of candidate you're a larger District you may want to do Outreach because if you're considering candidates from out of state chances are they're going to go to Newark Star Ledger or the website that's attached to them I mean there are all kinds of places that they'll be able to do that I've even had some of my searches do um um National advertising through education week but

069those were districts that were really you know open to bringing somebody from another state in and is Apple track just for teachers and other staff members or does Apple no we use appet Trak so all of the PE the candidates fill out the application through applet TR okay so that's who we use um and then you know we bring all of that information information back to the board um moving across the $7,000 program is our traditional search so if you've used our search before and done a traditional search that is what that level is and that just adds on to the fact that you know I'm bringing in you know the pool of candidates I schedule all of the interviews so all of the inter all of your interviews I set up a schedule and

070I set up all of the interviews I help you with the questions and I mean so then we would come back after your first round of interviews so if you interview three nights and your last interview ends at 10 o'clock at night we're here to meet with you and process out after that first round of interviews we help you you know come to consensus on who you're going to move to the second round of interviews we help you develop questions for second round of interviews we you know schedule those interviews we come and meet with you hand off the interview questions prior to each round of interviews we would come back again at the end of the second round of interviews and then you could make a determination whether you have a candidate you want

071to hire after the second round or do you want to do a third round of interviews and give them some kind of activity to do and it depends you know some boards by the end of the second round know who they want and some like to go the added Mile and I'm sorry you are Andy Andy P Andy okay is a couple of questions uh is the board required to go through the njsba for super search or can they can the board do it by themselves you can do it by yourself you can hire an an outside consulting firm okay if you don't mind me asking Kathy it looks like we did this in 2014 do you know what level that we went with uh for the last superintendent we went started with school boards

072and then when we had to do a a second search we went with a search company I see okay and do you know which level that we went with what do you mean which level um I think we went with level three you did yesel you did a premium search with the the the one that would be with the 125 12 the differ between that and the Seven is that you had 3D modeling we meaning Maryanne Maryann I get to push it off she would do all of the first round interviews and then she would come in and and give the board you know those candidates that She interviewed and you know help you and kind of say to you based on your criteria and my interviews here are the candidates that I would recommend

073that you interview but just because she recommends somebody doesn't mean you have to interview them and if there's somebody else in the pool that's an A or a B candidate that maybe she's not recommending you can bring them in to interview Maran if if we need if Kathy Kathy now you said Mar that's no but I told her Maran and I are like very best friends she's like my sister from another mother so I won't be offended if she calls me mar thank you Kathy um if so we talked about the advertising cost and where you would send out the information you know even out of state but what if we want to hire from within first like if we want to take just an internal search first how do is there rules against that

074or there no no if so you know there's two schools of thought with regards to internal candidates um one you can put an internal candidate through the process just like any other candidate because that will give you the ability to look at that candidate along with other candidates in that pool and if in fact that internal candidate ends up being somebody that you move through the search process by putting them through all of the steps that you're putting an external candidate through helps the Board to validate their appointment in the district because too often what happens is a board will appoint just not go go not go through a search process and they will just appoint an internal candidate but then there may be backlash from your stakeholders that they come back and say that

075the board did not do their due diligence to see if there was another candidate out there who might have been better for the district so that's a conversation that you as a board really need to have as you move through the search process I will tell you in the 12 years that I did a on my board we appointed two superintendents and see there I am with my hands again one we went through a search process one we just appointed an internal candidate and the board got a tremendous amount of flack from our community by just appointing that internal candidate because our community was going was changing during that time and they really felt that we did a disservice to the students by not looking to see what other candidates had been out there uh

076you are Peter are you Peter Tano I have I have a question for Kathy so in 2004 we spent uh 12,500 for this program and in 2014 2014 probably would have been last it was probably $10,000 when you did it that time okay so you said that we spent the money on this program and then we had to use an an external program besides this we we we did the search we did not find a candidate that the board the to the there was even a consensus from the board so so this program didn't find that candidate for us it did not find a candidate and so we decided when we decided to do the search over again the board decided to use a search firm okay so I'm going the opposite direction I'm saying

077that if first question to you Kathy is if we don't engage njsba are we still as a member of the njsba be allowed to post the position on your website as long as you do the search on your own if you hire an outside consultant no but if you do the search on your own yes okay so you know and and I will tell you um one of the things that I do at the association is I track superintendent movement across the state so I will tell you the average length of time that a superintendent is in school dist in a school district anybody have a guess 7 years no three four years three that's okay three is the average year that the average amount of time that a superintendent is saying in a district

078yes do you have a study as to why that's the case because that statistic is meaningless unless there's reasons and sometimes boards want to get rid of their sometimes superintendent leave for greener pastures or retire so whenever I track these I go through all of the searches whether it's a search that we did a board did it on their own or an outside consultant did and I track also the reason why they leave I will tell you that um the majority of of movement that I we have been seeing is that superintendant are leaving small smaller districts and going to larger districts we have some superintendant that you know are are at that retirement age and and the salary cap even though its purpose was to hold taxes down in a district we've lost a

079lot of superintendence to out of state because there are no caps in other states I just had two super superintendent in Mammoth County who left one well no he not technically true he left Mammoth went to Edison was making a lot of money a lot more money in Edison but then he went to South Carolina where he could make even more money I had another one that ended up going out west so they are leave and you know so some of it are in Pockets like up in the northern part of the state you've got superintend leaving districts there and going across the border to New York or they're going to Connecticut where they can make more money down in the south southern part of the state they're going to Pennsylvania and Delaware and Maryland

080where they can make more money so that salary cap kind of put a little bit of a problem for us I think as far as keeping superintendance but are those people leaving the state generally retiring and then going to another job no they're retiring and going to be a superintendent in a district out of state that's what I that's that was the question yes so in a sense there's an incentive okay we can talk about that the cap is a problem but there's also an incentive to get a second salary it's not just that the cap is our issue it's that they're going to be able to collect their retirement pension and then be a superintendent making more money in another state so I doubt it I I and maybe you can correct me but

081the people who are leaving the state are they are they leaving before retirement age or after before they still are they've they've put in their years for retirement here in New Jersey I mean the one who just no but that's my point is that they're they're young right and they can re they have enough years to collect pension in New Jersey right and go to another state and make more money and then staying there long enough to end up with a second pension no I I got that but that's sort of my point we're not seeing any 10year or not or not eligible for retirement superintendents going out of state unless it's really a huge compensation right they're not forfeiting their New Jersey pension to go to other states okay no so to just say

082that it's you know I think we have to be clear that there's an incent to get a double you know for people who are moving out of state but for most of the superintendant where that move where the movement is occurring within state they're they're leaving smaller districts and going to larger as far as you're concerned I mean your district is a larger District which should make you more attractive and get a pool of candidates who are seated superintendents in small smaller districts who may have experience as a superintendent to come into District um you know but but what I would say too okay is sometimes it's not always necessary to hire somebody with superintendent experience so I and I can talk from my biggest success story my biggest success story is now the commissioner

083of education because I did the search in Asbury Park that brought him there to district and he was a principal at Carter at high school now a lot of times boards would say well that might not be somebody that we would normally consider but go back to the comment that I made to you about knowing my districts and I know that District I've worked with that district and I will tell you this they did one of our premium searches I knew the very first time that I interviewed him that he was the candidate for Asbury Park why because he had all of the experiences that those students in Asbury Park have experienced so after hearing his story and knowing what the board in Asbury Park was was looking for I knew from the first interview

084that he was their candidate now I will tell you that it took seven interviews with the board before they hired him so it's not always an easy guaranteed process um and not everybody is going you know you're not going to know I sometimes that the first time that you meet a candidate that they are the right person for your District but I think think if you ask the right questions during the interview process that you will find a candidate you know that's going to meet the needs that that you have here in the district and it could well be an internal candidate you know but then I would say to you you have to be very mindful about how you how you go establishing your criteria that it doesn't cut out that in internal candidate

085you know so one of my colleagues was doing a search in one of their districts that as part of their criteria the board said the candidate needed to have a doctorate so once you say that a doctorate is required that cuts out a tremendous number of people in your pool and there was was an internal candidate that the board was really interested in hearing from who didn't have a doctorate so that cut that internal candidate out of the pool so what the bull board ended up doing was they closed out that search and redefined their criteria in order for it to be more inclusive to allow for a larger pool because the more requirements that you add in your criteria the smaller your pool becomes and so sometimes that's what having somebody from our association

086or a search firm is able to kind of help you with to ensure that you're going to get the broadest pull available for you to be able to narrow down th th those candidates um is it 100% guarantee that the person that you're going to hire is going to stay here no the other thing I tell my boards all the time is this you think that you're interviewing them but guess what they're also interviewing you to make a determination as to whether you are going to be a fit for them and that doesn't always happen and unfortunately you know sometimes things things happen that create a problem the whole way around is you've got candidates who are applying in multiple searches because they just don't apply to Monroe Township and say that's it that's the

087only District I'm applying to and they're applying in other districts and you know nothing happens and nothing happens and they come here and they let you know this is the place I want to be but when that job comes up that they were really really looking for we're gone but that's not your fault it's not the consultant's fault it's the candidate's fault because because to me it's like if you're applying for this job you need to want this job as much as you want the job down the street you're know because I want somebody who's interested in coming to my district to be the superintendent and as a consultant I want a candidate that's going to come and stay in the district if it's only for those three years that you know that for that

088average length of time and actually accomplish what you're going to tell me you're going to accomplish during the interview process so I think you know some of it depends on what it is that you as a group are looking for and I wouldn't discourage you if you really think you know that your internal candidate is the person and you feel that you have the ability to do the search on your own go for it but just be mindful it is a confidential process and so when you have those interviews candidates names shouldn't be getting out um you know because if you're out sharing candidates names with anybody or their name gets out there you in turn may be creating a problem for them in the district that they're currently working in especially if they're a

089seed superintendent because if you're a board and you have a superintendent that you love and all of a sudden you hear that the superintendent is interviewing down the street it's going to make me as a board member think well does he really want to be here if his name or her name is getting out there so the biggest piece about this is it has to be confidential those applications need to be locked up that the only people who have access to them is the board and that those names don't get out there because it is is really critical that it does remain a confidential process so with the 125 and the 15 we do the first round of interviews and we sit through every single interview with you so as you're interviewing candidates for first

090round if you're doing three consecutive nights of interviews I'm Maryann not me Maryann is sitting here three consecutive nights listening to each interview that you're going through first round second round whatever so that one is a little more time intensive on our end and the difference between the 125 and the 15 is at the end after the superintendent has kind of transitioned into the district we do a strategic plan with with the district Patty Kathy um so my question is as you're saying it's a confidential process and you can't share canidate information with the public so when can we involve the public or to what level or not with our process the only time and opportunity that this public has is whenever we do the input sessions with them okay so the input session and

091then because in the end in the end it's a board decision because you nine people and five of you as a majority can can appoint a superintendent okay and the difference between you and them is that if you involve the public any point during the interview process they don't have to maintain confidentiality you can say well I'll have you sign a confidentiality agreement but it's not legally binding so so I guess where I'm confused we've seen in in the past where superintendents or people trying to get a job do like a public presentation at board meeting that's usually at the very end of a search okay but let me ask you something that's because I'm going to play The Devil's Advocate you've gone through a search process where you've you have interviewed this candidate one

092round two rounds three rounds you have a preference that you all have come to agreement on you bring two candidates to a forum what if the public decides they like C you like candidate a and the C public likes candidate B but you know through the interview process the candidate a is the best candidate for your District public likes be and then at a board meeting the board appoints candidate a what do you think the Public's going to say so I tell you to be careful okay about having those public forums because the public may end up forcing your hand to hire a candidate that you felt the other candidate was better so I I tell you to be careful I will also tell you that I had a superintendent in one of my districts

093last year who was a final candidate up in Essex County they had a public forum his name was out there and guess what happened his board decided they weren't renewing his contract because they felt he was looking anyway so why should we renegotiate his contract so if I'm a superintendent in another district and I have had superintendence say to me if you're doing a public forum then I want to withdraw my name so you have to be careful about those public forums I think I was asking more because I know our public has requested often to be included in the whole process and know everything that we're doing but what you're basically saying is no we get their criteria we get their input and then um what I do for my boards is at each

094Benchmark in the search I will type up a report and give it to the superintendent that I'm superintendent to the board president that they can read at the at the meeting so for instance after you know I've re I've re received all of the applications and I've run through them I do a pool report kind of indicate you know um 100 candidates applied in the you know 100 candidates access the application for your search process of those 100 85 completed the application process of those 85 80 were from New Jersey one was from Pennsylvania one was from New York wherever and then I then list okay here this is how many are superintendents this is how many are assistant superintendent I go down through the list here's how many hold doctor and that information can

095be shared with a public at a public board meeting okay you're not giving names but you can share the Mee and so then after the first round of interviews you could say to Maryann okay we're ready here's the ones we want to move to the second round you could give you know an update at a public meeting that you know the board had first round interviews and we interviewed I don't know 20 25 candidates um and of those 25 candidates we're going to move and to second round interviews you know there's nothing wrong with just giving them facts through the process to keep them updated on where you are in the process Kathy one thing Andy poori again uh one thing that you kept referring to throughout your presentation is whatever the board decides board

096has the right to app Point that's given the fact that we are a United board but it's simple majority counts at every step of the way the superintendent needs to be appointed I think by a simple majority of the board it's not a majority of the full membership I think it's a majority of the board I think it's a majority of full members I I think here we have 10 members okay and we needed six six okay so where's your 10th member from Mr rutsky he's uh uh we're receiving district and we get kids from Jamesburg and he's a Jamesburg representative so learn something new every day yes okay so you would need sex yes yes Michelle okay um now so the only people receiving actual names and of candidates and applications should be the

097board the board so no even if we hire a search company or anything we should not have applications going either to the business administrator or the Human Resources no we tell them to send them to us every now and then we do get somebody who figures they'll get a leg up if they send them directly to the ba and if that happens then the ba generally will call us and say I received blah blah blah and then I would get in touch with the candidate and say I understand that you sent a resume package to the board office mhm please go on to app track and fill out our application because through our process you get more than just the application you get the application you get um references you get um we check to

098ensure that you know the candidates if they have any postgraduate work or getting them from an accredited school um you get um their most recent evaluation um for you know for superintendents generally we tell them you know we want your last three however with everybody going to Danielson and everything getting three evaluations ends up being way too much paper um but you know we we get all you get more than just an application um whenever you're going through you know and the application process you know and and I get to the point where I as I said I look at every piece of paper that somebody submits and there is nothing worse nothing worse than to go through an application and you say this is a great person this is a great person however their

099cover letter has the wrong School District on and it happens and I sit there and say I'd love to recommend this this applicant but I really can't because if they can't have pay too much attention to detail to ensure that their paperwork is correct what does that tell me about the work that they may do in District so I mean I'm looking at all kinds of things as I'm reviewing that application to ensure sure that you're getting good applicants that will apply in your search process and and I will tell you Maryann is I'm not good at it that's not not my area really on top of things I mean we take we both take OCD to the next level just saying as far as applications go which is not a good thing to say

100but I figure you're hiring me for my expertise that I want to make sure that the candidates that I'm bringing to you meet my standards if they don't meet my standards then you know I don't think they're worth bringing I mean and that's part of what you're paying us for especially whenever you start hitting that 12 to do that premium search you know so I you know I just think it's you know it's really important there is on page six um a sample calendar that we use through the process and then on page seven talks about the no cost advertising placements where we send um all of our applications and then you know and then there's um colleges that we send applications to I mean so you know you're getting them all over the place

101um and you know then and the list of the most recent searches I will tell you when I look at my list there's not a lot here from Mammoth because I had an enormous turnover when the salary caps came into play and so once the and all districts in MMO except for two Chang they all Chang superintendent and most of them other than the you listed here have stayed in their districts so that's our process any other questions since for three of us who are the new board members is the first three new board members you're new who else is new you said you were new oh okay so all of us every board member gets to interview is that correct unless you're conflicted but nobody's conflicted so you're all in on the interviews so

102I you know that brings up you know a good point because there are some boards I haven't seen it but I um who will use a search that will do committees um and I'm not a fan not I'm not a fan of board search committees right um because I really feel strongly that if you need the majority of theard board to appoint a candidate that every single board member needs to be involved in the process to hear all of the interviews the responses to hear what everybody else is hearing in order to make the best decision for your school district I mean I I mean that's my personal preference um you have to have a lot of faith in a committee you know to make sure that they're ask asking the right you know the

103right kind of questions and the same kind of questions that you would ask so you know I just really think it's important for everybody to be involved in the process thank you no more questions thank you very much thank you that was very helpful you're welcome thank you um where are we we are for the public forum and anyone from the public wishing to speak although I do not see anyone in the public so if anybody wishes to speak please come to the microphone and give your name and address for the record and seeing no one our next scheduled Board of Education meeting will be on uh February 13th 2019 7:00 p.m. at the Monroe Township School District and and just before I conclude that I think at that next meeting we'll have a more

104in-depth conversation about where this board wants to go so that we can have a conversation and have everything ready by you hopefully the end of June so uh motion to adjourn wow there was a lot Miss laang who's second second by Mr Tano all in favor opposed meeting is adjourned

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.