001good evening the meeting of the Monro Township Board of Education will come to order please stand as our student board member leads us in the pledge of allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible liberty and justice for all may we have a roll call Mr Gorski certainly Mrs armeno here Mr cherel here Mrs Deo here Mrs K Pano here Mrs Lang here Mr poori here Mr Rybeck here Mrs seagull here Mr Tano here Mr rutsky here madam board president you have a quarum present this evening thank you in accordance with the provisions of the New Jersey open public meetings law the Monroe Township Board of Education has caused notice of this meeting to be published by having the date
002time and place thereof posted May 3rd 2019 at all schools the home News Tribune cranberry press and filed with the clerk of the municipality okay and before we get into the agenda I just want to let everybody know that um Boy Scout Troop 60 is in attendance this evening and this attendance fulfills our requirement for them for the citizenship in the community or Communications Merit Badge so we welcome them to have us s our Board of Education [Applause] [Music] meeting and at this time we will go to the approval of the minutes for the special public Board of Education meeting of April 16 2019 so Mo second Mr Chella Mr Ryback comments or questions any additions or corrections to the minutes uh I Madame President I I did send some in although it was late
003this afternoon so um I don't know if they've been incorporated into the minutes but that's fine either way okay thank you anyone else all in favor opposed Miss arminia was opposing abstain or recuse okay then the close session minutes of April 16 2019 Mr cherella Mr poori again additions or corrections to the minutes Miss armeno again I just wanted to say that um you know reading some of the minutes on first read um I I feel that there is still uh information that could be put in that uh is not so it's just going to seem to be unfortunately how I feel about uh minutes we have a we have a uh a discrepancy between how what I think is uh comprehensive and informative and what uh the administration does so thank you well I
004will just say that this our minutes always go through um attorney yes I've had a discussion with our attorney Mariam we we choose to uh amicably disagree okay thank you anyone else all in favor opposed Miss armia wased opposing abstain and recuse okay then at this time we will have a report from our student board member I would like to start by thanking all the teachers that work in our school district as this week is Teacher Appreciation Week all your hard work doesn't go unnoticed also high school students are currently taking AP exams and students in grades 3 to 11 are almost finished with NJ SLA testing the second annual own memorial 5K run and one mile walk is being held on May 19th also the second annual FBLA meet the alumni event will be
005held on May 30th 2019 oak tree will hold its second mindfulness matters Day on May 22nd where students will gain a deeper understanding on how mindfulness is a way to keep our bodies and Minds calm healthy and happy thank you thank you very much and at this time we will go to number seven on the agenda which is presentations our first presentation is um we are delighted today to have Miss maryan fredman from New Jersey school boards Association to give out some um um nice presentations to some board members thank you so much for having me um as you know most of the board members know we offer an academy program through New Jersey school boards Association for board members and these Academy programs or certifications go beyond the the regular mandatory training that each
006board member needs to take so in your first second and third year of your first term it's mandatory that you take training and then in any reelected year and the board members that I'm going to recognize tonight were just recognized last week at the middle sex County meeting excuse me for going above and beyond that and they have gone and achieved higher credits than that and so I have two board members whove received their certified board member award and this is the second tier the New Jersey school board Academy of credits and to earn a CBM a board member earns Academy credits in which here he participates and attends at least 20 credits are needed to achieve this and they include at least four County meetings one annual Workshop a delegates assembly and at least
007one Regional program and completion of at least one three-year term of their local Board of Education so it's 20 credits in addition to the mandatory training and those areas of training cover all different are areas of governance effective boardsmy curriculum School Finance School law Labor Relations and board operations so in Li of that I'd like to ask Patty Lang and Steve Rybeck to come [Applause] up okay Patty this is this one is for you and this says New Jersey school boards Academy board member Academy Patricia Lang Monroe Township Board of Education has having successfully completed the requirements for level two of the board member Academy program has established by the New Jersey school boards Association is hereby awarded the designation of certified board member [Applause] [Music] congratulations and then Steve St I have one for
008you as well and this says pretty much the same thing Steven rybec having successfully completed the requirements for level two the board member Academy program has established by the New Jersey school boards Association is hereby awarded the designation of certified board member congratulations [Applause] and one of my previous superintendents would say those are not to go on your refrigerator those need those need to be framed okay now I have a special award another special award and this is awarding 20 years of board service and what I'd like to do is take you all back to 1999 For a Moment The Sixth Sense the movie The Sixth Sense was released Bill Clinton was acqu acquitted of perjury and obstruction of justice that was particularly low Point um in our history I think SpongeBob SquarePants not because
009he was acquitted but just because of the whole situation SpongeBob square prants premiered on Nickelodeon The Simpsons and Beverly Hills 90210 were two of the most popular TV shows and 90210 became the most popular zip code in the country the average price of a movie ticket was about $5 how much do we pay for movie tickets now a lot the academy for Award for best picture was Shakespeare and love a gallon of gas was a122 I'm seeing 285 and above last night I was down in Ocean County and it was 295 Myspace remember Myspace the social media the first the first evil social media that was put out was officially introduced to the internet a postage stamp was 33 cents Internet Explorer version five had just been released the Y2K problem and the millennium bug
010were the two most important things on B big business and most companies Minds the world's population exceeded six billion and the Bluetooth the thing that I typically have in my ear all day long when I'm working was first introduced and was announced and Kathy Kap panowitz was elected to the school board in Monroe Township for the first time so a lot has changed since 1999 serving on a board has changed greatly with increased mandatory training accountability regulations and increased public scrutiny but some things have stayed the same board members still devote countless hours to ensure that the children in their communities receive the best education possible in a fiscally responsible Manner and a local public school board's salary is still $0 and0 on behalf of njsba officers and staff congratulations Kathy on your devotion persistence
011and commitment and dedication to the children of your school district and to public education for the past 20 years come on up [Music] [Applause] [Music] thank you wver very much for all you do for the students in Monroe Township we greatly appreciate your service thank [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music] you before we move on I just want to say that 1999 I never thought I'd still be sitting here in 2019 so it's been an honor and a privilege to represent the students of Monroe Township for all these years and as the presenter last week who gave me my plaque at the county meeting said to me I had an influence over a whole generation of students which is very hard to believe and I also want to congratulate Steve and Patty and I think Patty might
012be the only person I know who has gotten her certification in the first two years that she's been on a board of education so that both of them it's it's it's been amazing and they're really good board members so thank you congratulations so our second presentation is the mtea pride presentation at Brookside from Brookside School Dr Alvi so on April 17th Brookside School hosted the Brookside family math night and the third fourth and fifth graders and their families enjoyed an evening of math activities and fun games um thanks to the teachers who put it together so Mrs Nagel and Mrs Mills are here this evening from Brookside school and some of their students to share about the night thank you very much for inviting us to come and speak to you and share a little
013bit about the one of the many wonderful things Brookside school is doing this year and as Dr alvik said we we enjoyed our second annual uh family math night on April 17th it was a success at least as much as the first year when we did this last year and knew for sure that it was going to become something we'd want to do every year uh so we did it again and certainly uh fabulous feedback from students and parents and teachers who joined us this year to do it so we have a PowerPoint to share so this year we had over 80 students join us use your microphone please a little bit more this year we had over 80 students join us um and they came along with their families um and as Mrs Mills
014said we received the grant last year but we only did it for fourth grade this year we tried it with our entire school and it was a Comm it was a community Affair we also had some Middle School students volunteer to help set up and run some of the tables there were a lot of tables it was very busy and we really appreciated appreciated their help a representative from the mtea assisted Brookside Administration and various grade level special areas teachers and office staff planned and assisted and Barkley Brook Brookside PTA attended with their families what the students did there uh we had different tables set up with different activities to work on place value fractions geometry word problems we also had a math selfie station that was extremely popular uh beat the teacher in basic
015multiplication facts uh guess the Koo Tower and uh some osmo activities as well as some websites and apps that parents could use with their kids so now we have a few pictures to show you of the event this was our Keo tower that the students built and then during the night um Activity one of one of the activities was to guess how many blocks were involved in this and then the next day our students got to knock it down [Music] [Laughter] we had uh prices offered the students went around with the Bingo board and tried to get to as many activities that they could go to or at least complete their bingo and some of the prizes they received were homework passes um special chair for the day pass uh basketball with Mr Pepe maker
016space with Miss Fedora um and the Koo Tower winners received a cool 3D printed prize and then the overall winner received principal for the day okay that's it um and now we have we have to go through our selfies oh selfies sorry selfies we have uh some students who enjoyed the evening with us who volunteered to come up and share some of their experiences um hi I'm am z shanora a fourth grader from Brookside school I think math night was very fun I love that you had the opportunity to compete against teachers and parents it was also math night was also a great place to teach a younger sibling or or a friend some math I also like math night because if you were getting bored of math there were other stations like the Keo
017block estimation station and the selfie station thank [Applause] you um good evening good evening my name is NeNe I go to Brookside school on April 17th I went to family math name these are a few things I will be sh sharing with you I will talk about the osmo the game headful of numbers and the geometric shape building osmo one reason the osmo is fun is that when you put the shapes correctly the color of the shape would be shown on the screen I really thought that was cool the head the game headful of numbers I like the game headful of numbers because when they give you specific numbers to work with it really gets your mind going also the goal was to make 21 math equations in 1 minute when I did it I
018got a 21 out of 21 the geometric shape building I like this station because if you want to be an engineer you could build also when you build one thing you can use leftover pieces to make another one this is why I like this event I really hope you bring it back next time thank [Applause] you good evening everyone my name is frya bridgelin and I'm a fourth grade student at at Brookside Elementary School I went to math night on April 17th that evening I really liked math night at Brookside it was very fun I liked a lot of games and couldn't pick which one was my favorite I really like the fraction game where you would have to place the card backwards on the answer of the sum or difference of two fractions and
019it would make a picture I also like the one in the library where you would have to guess how many blocks the teachers used to make the large Tower they were all very fun and educational even my parents had fun I think it would be a great idea if the school did it again so many people arrived and did the Bingo board it's it's also fun for everyone not just kids for parents too also if your parents usually have a lot of work and you barely get to hang out with them it is a great way to spend time with your family and have some fun math night was awesome uh hello I am Remy burgelin from seventh grade and I go to mon tonship middle school so the math and I at Brookside Elementary
020School was very enjoyable and fun for the whole family even though I'm in seventh grade I was able to volunteer at different stations and enjoy the different topics that were there for the math challenge I was able to revisit some of my elementary school teachers as well which was amazing all in all math night was a great experience where students from different schools worked and played together in a fun Community way I hope to be able to come and help out at the next math night thank you thank you very much thank you thank thank thank you it was um nice to see kids so excited about math and math night and involving their parents so we look look forward to more math nights dur in our school district at our elementary level okay at
021this time we will go to our teacher of the year Educational Services professional of the Year presentations with Mr Goodall um before I turn this over to him I I just want to say a few words to our staff I we just um before this meeting we had an opportunity to honor our teachers of the year and support staff of the year at a dinner prepared by our culinary arts department it was awesome they did such a great job and the food was delicious it Rivals any restaurant in Monroe Township and unfortunately I didn't have a a chance to um speak to the staff because um Mr Good old's secretary kept us on on um strict schedule so I said I would do that at the board meeting um I'd like to congratulate all our
022award winners this this evening every day you go above and beyond and you make a difference in the lives of countless children not just this year but the years's past and in the years to come you help shape the future and you probably don't even know that you're doing that until kids come back many years later and say you made a difference in my life we are so honored as a board of education to have such wonderful staff members in our district we're proud to call have have you as part of our Monro staff and um tonight we're honoring teacher of special education a social worker kindergarten teacher ldtc teacher special education teachers a network operations manager autistic teacher physical therapist grade three a par professional grade five teacher speech and language specialist a social
023studies teacher a psychologist a teacher of special education a substance abuse counselor these are all positions in our district that we could not do without and and again you make a difference in the lives of all countless students in our in our school all our schools and we're very proud of you so at this time I'm going to turn this over to Doc Mr goodle for the presentations of the award winners thank you Mrs kapan wit uh at this time I'd ask Dr Ali and Mrs kapano to join me in front and we call up the winners for this year for each school and I'd ask that each School's principal uh join uh the winners for the picture for each school so would you like to join me up front for we'll start with Monroe
024Township High School the teacher of the year is Miss Michelle Ballard [Applause] our educational Professional Services Award winner at the high school Miss Dorene malne she's our student assistant coordinator she could not make it tonight but how about we give her a round of applause for Miss now representing Monroe Township Middle School teacher of the year Christine faki [Applause] our educational Professional Service award winner at Monroe Township Middle School is Jessica Snider [Applause] at Applegarth Elementary School winner of the teacher of the year is Adrien shanfield [Applause] and and at Applegarth Elementary School Educational Services professional of the Year Jamie Julian [Applause] at Oak Tree school teacher of the year Kimble sonari [Applause] at Oak Tree School Educational Services professional of the Year Cindy [Applause] Ferguson yeah [Applause] Barkley Brook Elementary School teacher of the
025year Sarah Richards [Applause] Educational Services Award winner Moren Sutter [Applause] Brookside school teacher of the year Teresa Anthony [Music] [Applause] and our Educational Services professional of the year he could not make it tonight he's coach in little league is Mr Elliot [Applause] Feldman mil Lake Elementary School teacher of the year is Jennifer bid think [Applause] Educational Services professional of the Year Annette Hardy [Applause] Woodland Elementary School teacher of the year Lisa girl [Applause] and finally Educational Services professional of the year at Woodland Elementary School is Mr Douglas [Applause] Dale congratulations again to all the winners our Board of Education likes to say that this is our second day favorite day of the year after GR graduation so congratulations to all our award winners and we look forward to continuing seeing you continue your careers in
026Monroe uh this time committee reports are there any committees that need to report this evening I think we we reported last week I don't think there's been any more okay public forum anyone from the public wishing to speak to the agenda please state your name and address for the your name and address for the record uh we will adhere to our 4-minute time limit when the timer goes off your turn is over and you can only come up once during each public forum count it did not Mark Klein 7 cruncher Court um looking at the agenda I see the enrollment now is 6872 could you tell me how much over capacity we are does anybody have the exact number I could give you an approximate we're we're approximately 1,550 students okay above capacity and it
027is going to get much worse because as you know all of those developments that are going in on Apple goth and 33 is shocking and I spoke up at the council meeting that is going to just blow up your enrollment um I was fortunate to have a meeting with Mr Gorski and uh and Rob uh concerning some of the questions that I had and I got an education uh something that I I don't understand with the state is um in the Freehold burrow decision by commissioner hesie there were 400 overc capacity with 1700 kids and he stated I quote the students cannot a thorough and efficient education in overcrowded classrooms that's hpie that's the commissioner of Education when we had our meeting and I brought that up I was told that um our school district
028does a fabulous job with the overcrowding and we're thorough and efficient now we could be thorough and efficient but not according to what has to be said um if we're thorough and efficient how much better could we be if we weren't overcrowded if the kids all had a seat um so that part I disagree with and and when it comes to the state they can have it both ways I I have a lot more to talk about which I'll do later on because it's not a genda but uh I could thank you for the job that you do I did keep track of the meetings when I was in Florida uh I want to add one thing I don't know what transpired as far as uh the superintendent search uh has done but you got
029a win is sitting right there in Mr Good Old we're we're we're we are not discussing the superintendent I'm just making my opinion so that is not on the agenda okay I'll tell I'll bring it up again later okay thank you good evening Betty Sab burito to Barrymore Drive I wanted to give a big congratulations to Teacher of the Year Jen bck at mil L if you're still here yes I see you back there um who teaches the autism program this is the most deserving teacher ever for reasons that many of you that do not have autistic children will just never understand words will never be able to express the admiration and respect that I feel for this incredible educator and person she is truly oneof a kind we were privileged and I use the
030word privileged to have had her teach our son for four years from prek to second grade when she came into his life he was severely impacted by autism ISM he is moderately now he had very few words and no communication skills Miss bck provided him with skills necessary not only to succeed academically but to reach his potential and be successful in life she taught him to communicate and to sit and attend so that he could learn she taught him to express his feelings and to calm himself down and so many life skills such as eating and dressing and playing and now reading and math for a neurotypical child these skills usually come pretty naturally and on their own for children like my son they do not they are difficult and without adequate help children like
031him would never be able to achieve them the foundation given not just to my son but to all of her students by Miss bck is unmeasurable to have seen the progress all these children have made that she has worked with is commendable miss bck you will always be the teacher of reference in our lives and you are the person who has made the difference without you Lucas would not have met goals he has and would never have met his potential I have given him life but you miss bck gave him his best life so thank you and thank you all for recognizing [Applause] her good evening prakash Pura 33 dinner Drive uh congratulations to all the teachers they are one of the best and we always salute them my son is in the school we
032know how deated devoted the children's are I know some of the teachers they are well deserved uh coming to the agenda the committee reports I was here to hear the committee reports but they have not not here today but um I saw that there are policies on vaping and drugs have in there today in the discussion The Vaping has become a biggest problem uh in our Township New Jersey throughout the country so I look forward not only to the policies what we are writing please I'm very happy are imposing them having dialogue with the parents and the students we all are doing good job and continue more than that what I expect is a leadership is no issue you all should write also concerns about these industries bringing in different flavors different goodies of this
033tobacco which is highly concentrated 45% solution and I tell you this will cause addiction to the to the students anyone even to the adults and there is I'm a pharmaceutical scientist there is no immediate remedy to get rid of that addictions it is very Troublesome so even as a president of the Boe or anyone of you all please voice your opinion to the legislates voice your opinion right to the board of education to Lobby that this should be the ban should be there okay so I'm very happy to see that and um like to hear from the advocacy committee last time I came and said funding for our school has been the issue for last 8 years next 5 years we are not getting full funding we are not getting full funding for the special
034education so what actions we're taking other districts are suing they are suing joining together last year also Jamesburg they had a cause they joined together with the other district and sued the state we are not building a wrong relationship with our legislatures or state I tell you by suing them nothing will happen just we put them on the toe so that we are active and we in public will back you all and want to know how much it cost if the money is the issue we will pitch in okay we want to sue the state unless you put the push them to the corner nothing will happen for the special education the money should follow the students we spend more than $30 million on special education we support it but the district gives only 2.5
035million and the current Formula adequately does not take into consideration special education so we have every right to sue the state so I would like to hear today what the opinion are and president's report I look forward about the adoc committee and where we stand on superintendent so thank you very much Anthony preso at equestrian way I'd like to thank the teachers that received the award today they deserve it and a special thanks to Jackie Winters and Sharon aptaker uh special kudos to Sharon aptaker that's another special needs Advocate who she did great work with my son and many other kids and we're going to miss her I have a question for the board president and Michael um who puts together the Personnel on the agenda the superintendent does uh does the board president look
036over those names uh I I we all get a copy of the agenda so we should be all looking at at the agenda before the meeting but you okay the names you go over I do not okay the names but you see all the names I get a copy of the names we just approve the superintendent's report but the superintendent puts it together okay who checks who puts out the minutes the minutes of the meeting comes from the business uh board secretary uh also does he check the names on the minutes Mr preso in terms of personel I'll make the recommendation and then in a few minutes after my superintendent's report I'll ask them to approve them uh recommendation well you see I I have an issue with that because in January somebody's name was
037on the personnel and that name didn't match the minutes in other words she was using dual minutes dual names and evidently people on the board knew that this person was using one name for minutes and one name for personnel and I'm sure the board did not know that and if I'm not mistaken that's a friend of yours Kathy I have no idea what you're talking about I will come tomorrow if you would allow me and I'll discuss this with you you have a person using two names one to get a job and one when she comes up here and she speaks okay and you know who I'm talking about I do not know who you're talking about the teachers should realize that there's a lot of cronyism going on and you should start sending Anonymous
038letters if you feel like you're getting slided but I'll be at your office tomorrow and this person is using two names anyone else good evening Chrissy scurby 21 pness Drive I had a question under uh letter H School Aly um I was wondering if that is a yearly cost uh to the district for $41,000 um what students will be using that program and how does that differ from the Google classrooms currently being used are you talking about the superintendent's report or the business administrator's report business administrator business administrator and then the letter again H schoology schology page 34 of 364 Dr Al will take this that is an annual um fee because it is a um license to use schooly ology is a learning management system which is what is different than Google um Google
039is something that the teachers use to share assignments to collect assignments that Google can also be used within schooly schooly is the answer to some of the questions that the public has asked and the parents have asked for in the last few years about why are we using all of these different um systems I can't find my child's homework I can't I can't follow what their class is um what their assignments are and so this was the answer was going to one learning math management system different than Google Google classroom and who what what students will be using that because right now currently now half of the high school teachers have been trained in it um during our year-long professional development next year the other half of the high school teachers will be trained in
040it so at that time the entire high school will be using it um and then we will start rolling it down into middle school and then the elementary schools okay so that's uh the 41,000 that's a yearly cost it's a yearly cost all right thank you anyone else else from the public wishing to speak to the agenda then we will close the public forum and uh something new on the agenda due to um policy change uh we it's a new permanent addition to the agenda by policy um the assistant superintendent uh monthly report so Dr alvik okay so I'm excited to be able to have this um report on the board agenda so that I can share some of the work that comes out of the curriculum office um this this month what I'd like
041to focus on is our professional development program so what the board members have in front of them is a two-page handout um the first page is actually um the the outline the flowchart of our professional development that we offer for our certificated staff and I'll go over that in a second the second page is just a copy of the slides that you see in front of you we have a very differentiated um approach to professional development development in our district and depending on how many years of of experience a staff member has that's what we give them the opportunity for their professional development so the chart you have in front of you kind of goes through it all of our year one staff members go through the same course during their year-long um professional development
042it includes our Marzano um learning map which is what we use to evaluate our teachers on it um I observation which is the program we use for observations and um classroom management Basics these are things that we've found that all of our first year teachers are in need of as they come out of college and come into the classroom our year 2 teachers we really focus on curriculum design and the understanding by Design and and be for for teachers to be able to read our curriculum and use our curriculum to the benefit of our students um and we also look at sharing differentiated instruction with our teachers at this point more in depth than what they've gotten in college our year three teachers we focus on assessment and data so our first three years of
043of um professional development for our teachers is really pretty much standard for all of our staff after that starting with their fourth year the teachers can choose a year-long course that year-long course would is actually is our list of courses is created based on A needs assessment that we give our staff so our school um and District professional development committees work on A needs assessment it goes out to every staff member they respond and say these are the typ of of professional development that they would like to see next year and they can choose from that course or if they did don't want to take a course that year they can choose to do a professional development project as a PLC a PLC is a professional Learning Community um which means teachers are not working
044alone they are working with a group of peers those plc's are overseen by an administrator there's an administrator assigned to them who meets with them on in service days um and tracks attendance and tracks the progress of their work and offers any resources that they might need so this gives our teachers a chance to study something that they might not normally be um taking in a class some of our classes include um we actually just worked on our um professional development catalog for next year so this teachers will be getting this next week um writing strategy groups guided reading um opening up Communication in a two-teacher classroom when you have two teachers a general education and a special education teacher working together um embedding non-fiction text differentia instruction utilizing technology um integrating stem and NextGen
045science standards into into the Arts so we we take a look at what the teachers are looking for and we create it so that's for our certificated staff um every year teacher has to complete a professional development plan that gets um overseen by their building administrator they have to submit it by October 15th in the fall and they um have have it approved at their Summit of meeting at the end of the year we also offer many courses through out the year so anything from the needs assessment that maybe didn't make it to the final list we can offer one day or half day courses for staff that they can they can take it and we've trained over 150 teachers in our district to be trainers um and they're the ones that are conducting this
046professional development it really has a cost savings to the district because if we send a teacher out for a workshop it could run anywhere from $150 to $400 $500 sometimes for a one-day Workshop if we do it in house we're paying the trainer um two hours to prepare um 10 hours to prepare it for the first time but if they repeat the course it's two hours of prep time um so it saves the district a lot of money and then instead of one person being trained we're training 20 to 25 people in that one course we also offer a lot of professional development for our power professionals this is something we've started over the last few years so on the first full inservice day at the beginning of the year first day in September before
047the students come the par professionals get a menu of options that they can take professional development um and this also comes from A needs assessment that goes out to our power professionals so they have the opportunity to indicate what their choice is for some of our um professional development for Paras and they are not paid for this time but on a half day in the spring two of the half days in the spring they're able to um get comp time so they're not leaving the students unattended they're staying for the students but they're able to leave when there's normally a full day so instead of paying them for the hours that they're spending on the first day before students arrive we give them um release time at the end of the year we also have
048many many many mandatory trainings that we must do for staff every year most of it falls on the building principal however um Mr Pio does do the school safety training for all staff at the beginning of the year um I do the affirmative action training um Mrs McConnell who's our Hib um coordinator does the Hib training but we have many other um trainings that we must incorporate um throughout the year we we have a lot of support for our new staff members so just as I described the three-year plan for professional development every new teacher who does not have a standard certificate which are these are the brand new teachers coming out of school have to have a mentor our mentors are trained in the district and the mentor works with them for the entire
049year they help them with getting ready for back for parent teacher conferences getting ready for back to school night um informal meetings um especially for special education teachers how do they use the the online program for IEPs to make sure that they can see them and this is someone in the building who's there for them who can help them out we also offer coaching our our professional development um team is uh one full-time professional development coordinator one part-time professional development coordinator coordinator and our Ed technology facilitator they go in and they coach all of our new staff they are on the teachers scale so they are not evaluating these staff members in any way they really are there as a coach and as a mentor for these new staff members and from what I understand
050and have heard from new staff members this is really a huge benefit to them that a lot of other districts don't offer um again these are our staff um thank you to all of our PD staff we do have the staff development coordinator Sher phobic Stephanie Goldberg Ryan tolboom is our Ed educational technology facilitator um a huge thank you to our district and our school PD committees um our trainers and our mentors that you see being um approved on the board minutes every month that's it does anyone have any questions for Dr Ali okay seeing n we look forward to more curriculum information as we move forward during the year uh this time we'll go to the superintendent's report Mr Goodall thank you very much just following up on the wonderful evening that we had
051uh with our honoring and recognizing the incredible staff that we have the incredible students that we had that put that all together uh I would be remiss if I didn't extend a very important thank you to my secretary Mrs Kathy baraco uh Mr Zach marala who's our Fine Arts supervisor and all of the teachers in The Culinary and Fine Arts staff and then again especially the students who did that uh for their teachers and Ed service Professionals in as Mrs kapano said it's one of the uh top evenings that we have during the course of the year and once again I've been to so many of them uh it was a fabulous uh event and I know the teachers and the uh Prof other professionals really appreciate what the kids did for them so job
052well done uh Monroe uh I continue to uh invite and encourage people to attend our special ed parents Advisory Group or cpeg um Mrs sabaro was very um it wasc incredible description of her experience with one of our special education teachers I feel the same way after uh seeing what goes on at M Lake Elementary elementary school but that type of dialogue and positive feedback uh with parents uh who have students who are posing unique challenges uh to our teachers and um you saw how one of our parents feel about what the teachers are doing for for children and I really encourage anyone and you don't have to be a parent of a child with special needs to attend it's a it's a great meeting and um you see lot and hear a lot about
053what goes on in our schools so uh the next meeting is May 23rd uh at two uh in 2019 at 6:30 p.m. right in this room here in the media center so try to come out and uh support the group uh in advance I would like to thank Miss man uh Nancy mitac the Food Service staff Debbie vanl the high school secretary and the 2019 High School class advisors for all they do in preparation for uh the junior prom which is upcoming uh we moved a prom to our high school a few years ago and that was in consideration of cost to families uh location of venues and uh actually the lack of nearby venues that can host our student enrollment and our class sizes so instead of having the event at Forest Gate we
054moved it back to our great high school and it was very seamless and it's been a big hit so uh in advance I I wanted get an opportunity to thank them for all of their hard work I saw them today they're getting prepared for it and um you know they they've demonstrated that they're the best Caterers around so thank you again and then finally I've been recognizing staff who uh decides to retire at the end of the school year I wanted to um recognize on behalf of everyone in the district Mrs Fran balant teacher of science at Monroe Township middle school and we just wish her the very very best uh in her next journey and thank you for the service uh to all of the children here at Monroe Township uh School District so
055congratulations Madam board president and members of the Board of Education it is recommended that Personnel item action items a through t under the Su superintendent report be approved by consent roll call so move second Mr tiella Mr Ryback are there any comments or question questions for Mr Goodall okay seeing none we'll have a roll call Mrs armeno yes Mr tiella yes Mrs Deo yes Mrs Lang yes Mr poori yes Mr Ryback yes Mr ruty yes Mrs seagull yes Mr Tano yes Mrs K pich yes Madam board president Personnel items a through T has passed unanimously thank you mam board president members of the board of ed education it is recommended that board action items a through H be approved by consent roll call so move second Mr Chella Mr Rybeck any comments or questions from
056Mr Goodall again see none we will have a roll call Mrs seagull yes Mr rutsky yes Mrs too yes Mr Tano yes Mr poori yes Mr Ryback yes Mrs Lang yes Mrs armeno yes Mr tiella yes Mrs K Pano yes on board president board action items a through H is passed un anoun he I believe that and that ends the superintendent's report okay then we will go to the business administrator's report Mr Gorski Madame board president and members of the Monro Township Board of Education it is recommended that board action items a through I be approved by consent roll call so move Mr rybach a second Mr rutsky comments or questions for Mr Gorski okay moving right along we'll have a roll call Mrs Deo yes Mr Ryback yes Mrs armenio yes Mrs Lang yes
057put re's on I thank you Mr poori yes Mr Chella yes Mr rutsky yes Mr seagull yes Mr Tano yes Mrs col panovich yes Madam board president board action items a through I has passed I includes my report thank you okay so moving right along we will go to the board president's report and I have two things today the first one is in regard to the ad hoc committee that we've been talking about that's going to be discussing future School District building plans members of that committee has been selected and an email was sent out to inform all of them of their participation on this committee the first meeting of the ad hoc committee will be held on Thursday May 16th at 6:30 p.m. in the high school um there will be more information coming
058about the next steps of the process at the next board meeting um I I think we have a good mixed representation on the committee we have senior committee members from the Senior Communities some who voted yes some who voted no we have parents from Mil Lake and Woodland area the Barkley Brook Brookside oak tree Applegarth parents who voted yes parents who voted no we have community members with no students in the school some who voted yes some are V who voted no we have former student we have some Administration members we have members representing the indan Indian Community so I think we did a really good job of selecting um New Blood people that um have not been involved in the process before and I think it's going to be a really good working committee
059the second thing I have is I want to talk a little a little bit about the budget process that we just went through recently um there was talk about the difference between the preliminary budget meeting and the final budget adoption meeting that there's always a month between the preliminary budget and the final adoption because while it rarely happen rarely happens changes have been made to the budget during this period of time in the past so first I want to stress that there is nobody sitting around this table who wants to retaliate against parents because of the defeat of the referendum there um what had happened uh or how this began was at the preliminary budget meeting Mrs Miss ormino asked that the finance committee go back and review some of the things in the budget
060that are non-academic that could possibly be removed um a number of other board members also reached out to Mr Gorski with the same request because we went to many different Board of Education referendum presentations we heard the same thing all the time taxes are too high we need to reduce taxes in Monroe so I asked Mr Gorski to see what could be done to reduce the tax levy from 2.17 cents which was at the preliminary budget to under 2 cents and while this doesn't seem like much it does send a message to our community that we've heard them we understand their issues and we're we were willing to revisit the budget Mr Gorski brought a list of possible cuts to the finance committee meeting and those committee me Members I they were all five of
061them there went through every single line item and they discussed the pros and cons of of eliminating adding keeping every single thing that we discussed and while the cuts made to the budget we wanted to make sure that any Cuts made to the budget would not hurt staff or programs the finance committee unanimously agreed on the cuts to be made and they were presented during the final budget presentation which the board adopted at uh two meetings ago I believe we especially looked at areas that make our district over adequacy being over adequate adequacy hurts our position when we look for additional funding from the state the state believes we do a thorough and efficient education for our students and because we're above VA quacy and they feel that the community members are able to pay
062for Education they're not going to give us any more funding we currently are looking um at different Avenues to sue the state but I I I just uh to make cuts to things that are over adequacy is only going to help us the budget process is not an easy one it goes on for many many months and different difficult decisions have to be made our committee meeting are always open to the public and we encourage you to come out listen to the deliberation and the discussion of our members so that you have an opportunity to know what we're talking about before um coming to the meeting so um again I would suggest that um come to an open meeting and committee meeting and see how our board operates because we are a board of committees
063so that concludes my report and at this time we'll go to Board of Education business is there any business by any member Mr Chella yes I think we disagree obviously and I think the cuts that were made were punitive and they were to punish and I'm going to tell you why because I think that if we were really serious about cutting where we're over adequate we'd be looking at the salaries of our administrators and how uh how many administrators we have and we've had our representatives from Trenton tell us that when they look at those line items that we're over adequate in administration so before we cut anything for kids and busing and things like that I think that's where we we we where we really need to look and if we really put our
064priori straight and we really stop telling untruths and stretching the truth and and and and making secret back door deals and creating hate packets and things like that if we really start to put the kids first we'll pass referenda in this town that's all I have to say thank [Applause] anyone else Mrs Lang um I wanted to um once again congratulate the teachers who were um recognized today at teacher appreciation and all the teachers in the district over the week um that have been recognized for all the work that they do um you're our most valuable asset and I know we appreciate you next week May 12th through May 18th um Governor Murphy has signed a proclamation proclaiming special education week I will quote from his Proclamation it says it calls upon all residents to
065recognize the achievements of New Jersey special education students and the outstanding contributions made by Educators school board members schools agencies for the disabled and their parents my journey in special education started in 1986 when I graduated with my bachelor's degree and my special ed teaching certificate it moved into being the parent of three classified students who when your child is classified and when your child has special education needs it's not something that happens just during the school day it's a lifelong journey and from the the age of from early intervention to now in their 20s there are issues that we are still dealing with and it's my life every day special education also changed in my life because I am disabled I became disabled in 2008 and I specifically struggle with many issues from my
066Strokes from my brain tumor and from other things I think it's important to note that in Monroe we have 1,123 students from ages 3 to 21 that receive some level of special education that's incredible that we are providing supports and services for that kids for that many children we employ 110 special education teachers 15 speech providers six occupational therapists two physical therapists nine learning disability teachers Consultants seven social workers 12 psychologists three behavioral specialist 130 Special Ed Powers and 21 Transportation Powers we have great administrators and office staff that are supporting our special education students we have students in District we have students out of District we're always trying to improve our ability to provide the appropriate Sur services to all these children special education is not a place special education is providing all students
067with the supports and services necessary for them to be successful it doesn't it is not a classroom it is about our attitude toward our kids and recognizing that everybody is different everybody has special needs and they we have to take the time to meet people where they are and address those needs at the time and i' just like to add that um at the County school board meeting last week um Chris Jones who was the legislative representative um from the school boards Association talked about how through the path to progress um Governor Steve Sweeney and his team I'm not presid Senate President Steve Sween and his team are trying to move to special educa um full funding of extraordinary special education um expenses those are the funding that we need to educate our children who
068are in at a District placements the issue remains that the federal government has failed to fully fund Ida which is the individuals with disabilities Education Act and it was passed um in the it's been 20 plus years that they have not funded it currently they fund most School States maybe 10% there is a move within our legislature to move it up to 40% but I think that it's important that we all know that we can reach out to our elected off officials in Washington to push for full funding of Ida so that we can get the funding that we need for our special a kids in schools and I just want to thank everybody who takes the time to welcome our students to welcome our parents and know that as parents this is our lives
069every day 24 hours a day seven days a week thank you and Mrs Mr Mayo um yeah I would just like to say congratulations to all the teachers of the year and the Educational Service Professionals of the year it was really nice to hear all their accomplishments and the positive impact they have on the children of this District um I'd like also like to say congratulations to Kathy Patty and Steve on their accomplishments they work um their work in dedication shows how they truly care about the children in this District so thank you thank you anyone else Mr poori Madame President the fellow members of the Board of Education and the public uh I want to start off first by congratulating the wonderful dinner uh our students serve today uh first thing is the taking
070care of the stomach which they did um definitely very uh delicious and great service as well and then I want to congratulate all the teachers and appreciate them for all the the hard work what was really rewarding to see was that some of the the students of Monro Township uh graduate from Monro and go into the real world get their degrees work elsewhere sometimes but eventually they come back to Monroe uh because they'll love the town that they were born and brought up in and that says a lot about that um just like Jill said I congratulate Steve and paty uh for receiving the the board certified board membership Awards last week I had the for the fortune of actually attending that meeting it went well and especially Kathy for 20 years I don't know
071how you did it uh um and I hope I don't do it for 20 years people think that there's water in here and U you know I uh and I'm only kiding I know I know we have to to care for the community and care for the township to be sitting here and do what we do uh when these things turn into politics it becomes a real problem uh and I'll tell you this um anybody uh who uh kind of elude to the fact that this is punitive punishment or anything else on the people for voting no is absolutely wrong in saying that because the people who got really let me finish how your breast Mr cherella can you please let me finish was excellent because I cared for my community and I needed a
072traffic signal where people are dying so I had so you know what stop it let me have my my my two s Mr cheer Mr poori has the floor here yeah here is the here is the uh the ense of it uh right after I heard and I heard the community's outcry on what has impacted with the uh uh the uh courtesy busing I actually went and looked at because I validate my facts I just don't sit here and try to make everything po political uh what I found out was that actually the development that got most impacted was Stratford which is near the oak tree and Applegarth so I went to the election results to see how they voted to see that that they deserve the so-called punishment and fortunately majority of the people
073in Stratford voted for the referend so if anything that we want to do to scrutinize or undercut the people in Stratford uh as a vindictive measure is absolutely ridiculous in my opinion I say that again it's absolutely ridiculous on top of that after I learned what was going on I actually took half a day off from from work I went to Mr groski and also to the transportation lead Kathy I can't remember her last name m m I'm sorry and we I took them out to the site we walked around for about half an hour to an hour we drove across to see what can we do and I actually printed a map of the area to see who's going to get impacted we looked at the sidewalks we looked at the speed limits we
074looked at the distance to the house that is located furtherest from the oak oak Tre School the amount of time it takes I researched on the Google Maps and this is what we concluded from it I just want the public to know that when it came to cutting something we have to cut what general public and the state and the legislators view as over adequacy and the one thing that we do provide that most of the townships are moving away from is I'm not happy about this let let me just make it abundantly clear we don't want to take away a dollar from anybody on any of the facilities they have however the courtesy busing is definitely something that is being cut by many school districts and with within the the available available resources so
075from what I learned is that the high school and the middle school do not have the sidewalks and crosswalks adequately and safely accommodate the students so those two schools are not a candidates similarly Brad Barkley Brook and Brookside are two schools also don't have adequate sidewalks and crosswalks to safely accommodate the students so that leaves only with the two schools uh and looking at the sidewalks and crosswalks that are available there I still don't think that it's 100% safe I think the speed limit on Station Road is very high mere coincidence that uh the speed limit was reduced from 50 to 40 m hour as of yesterday uh and I think in terms of the sidewalks they exist leading up to it however it still takes about 30 minutes for students in Stratford from the
076furtherest house to walk to Oak Tree so I think there are things that we probably need to do to that Community to appease their anxiety and see how we can accommodate that better through maybe getting some easements through some private properties and provide them some linkages and also I spoke to Kathy about about why the school was selected and and how the the ridership on the buses were and she indicated that she doesn't have a hard numbers however she felt that more than half the bus is typically empty that people do drop kids off now obviously there's no doubt in my mind that several PE families and kids are going to be impacted because of this and none of us are proud of doing this but I believe the process that was followed which was
077asked by some of the commune members last time I actually did it and I went and looked at what actually happened and that's the report that I want to give that I think based on everything I heard there may be other things that can be cut off but as a board member I think each and every person sitting on this side of the table have the right to go to the board District uh office and ask the question on what needs to be cut and give their suggestions the day the referendum was Was Defeated I I sent an email to Mr groski and copied you madam president and the vice president and requested that we need to revisit it and I'm glad to know that Michelle armeno did the same thing because we want to
078be responsible we don't want to have the taxpayers pick up for all the trailers that may be needed in a couple years rather than taking it from reserves that's what I felt strongly and that's what I did and I'm happy that I did it thank you very much okay Mr T yeah I I just have a couple things to say because I'm I'm I'm I'm always being called out for being political or or crazy or a sociopath because I disagree now when we were sold at the last meeting these Cuts we didn't have anybody that could give us provide any details as to why they were being cut or what what was going on and then the board in usual fashion votes yes for things that they don't understand and then later on goes back
079and tries to figure out if it was a right or wrong decision we need that stuff that that information up front and I'm glad that you went out and did your due diligence but it's a meeting too late because there's nothing you can do about it at this point so I say that if we want to if we want to if we want to get the politics off the board then what we need to do is provide the information that we need so that the people that we represent could understand the ramifications of the votes that we have but if we don't even understand what we're voting for how can they that's all if that's political well then I'm sorry but I'll tell you what I think I think it's being diligent and and and
080and worrying about our children if if what what am I running for the mayor am I still running for mayor Mr POI because I don't think I am so how is this political how is this political I'm the only let's not get into a political debate this went through the the finance company all the cuts went through the finance company we spent probably more than an hour going over every single one and the F the whole finance company was there we the committee was there and and we agreed on what cut should be made we brought it to the Board of Education put it on the agenda as we do with every committee report Madam so mad Madam president if I may respond to Mr chellis Ken what you said was not wrong the way
081you said it is what I have a problem with which is that we are taking punitive action and and that automatically leads to politics like you said I had breakfast with the mayor why did you bring that up about me having a breakfast with the mayor yous I I can't have breakfast with the mayor you mentioned politics Andy When you mention politics and you say that I'm being let not let's not we're going to cation and children exactly uh it's only political when you're not in League with the mayor I no it has nothing to do with it there's a lot of things going on in the town that I worry about people get killed at the intersection you know on a regular basis that we are taking ears and ears to together again I
082don't want to go on a on a tangent here but there is something that I feel very passionately about that needs to get done at the intersection that that I spoke about to at the council and I want to make sure that M understands it but more importantly I agree with you the part that we should have known a little better and unfortunately I could not be at the at the finance meeting but that's no reason I chose not to be there for another reason but that's the reason I did my due diligence and I think as members of the board each and every one of us need to do that rather than sit in the meeting talk to the camera and talk to the people to get Applause that is what I consider as
083we go again so now I'm doing it to get Applause Madam move can we can we just move on keep taking shots I'm I have broad shoulders and I'll and I'll fire right back Madam I have the floor for a moment um the these proposed Cuts were created from the the stakeholders in the district and I'm referring to the principles the vice principls the transportation directors that's where the ideas and the seeds for these Cuts came from I compiled the list I work closely with Dr alvic and and Mr Goodall on on the on the feasibility and the the value of these items before we present them to the finance committee there was a list of about $1.2 million of cuts that were deemed by staff and administration to be the the the less painful
084Less impactful on program and instruction Cuts finance committee did deliberate on this very effectively for over an hour and unanimously recommended the cuts to the board the board was fully notified of these cuts and other information having to do with them on two occasions uh with a weekly conf idential that I believe I sent out and the finance committee notes there was not one comment back so you know I I I believe we met our thresold for you know divulging what these Cuts were and what was affected by that as as best we possibly can miss ormino keep in mind by the way one final sentence the finance committee this board operates as a board of committees the work the Assembly of of of recommendations and resolutions gets done at the committee level that's where
085the guts of all these issues gets discussed that's where the sausage is made not at the board meeting at the committee meetings that's the most efficient way that this board can operate and it did so in this fashion as I complemented the last meeting Miss armeno okay just just as a little bit of historic um information also um we there there's two ways to look at it um yes the board members at the committee level are going through some of the information however two things that I've been told in the last five and a half years I've been on the board is one to trust the recommendations because we as board members are not allowed to micromanage so we really don't have the ability to choose what we can what we can um uh cut
086so while I think that we should have a little bit more say in that when some of us make recommendations about uh discussing what we should and shouldn't do we are told we're micromanaging and that we should trust the recommendations so there's there's not always a Hands-On ability from at least certain board members to be able to um take a look at things in depth and I did go I spent several hours at the board meeting with a huge uh budget however I was disappointed th because things were really not um the I it wasn't really line item numbers it was um and to my disappointment because I was was willing to spend hours there looking at the budget and looking line item uh for each item and what was spent it was a lot
087by title it was a lot by total so it really was very very difficult as a board member for me to really delve into the financial aspects of it so there's good and bad to the system I think I would have been I would have preferred to really have light items even though the uh the the package was this big there were a lot of blanks and a lot of empty p and I was hoping to do a little bit more in-depth research the other thing about um deciding how to uh use our transportation facilities uh and this goes back to a difference between the board of education's finances and budget and the townships and we are again tasked with spending a great many dollars on Transportation being concerned in a in a uh municipal
088where if we don't have sidewalks now that is not the board of education's problem it is the Township's problem and during uh developers applications and construction they're and I've said this a million times they're going to continue to say it to put things in perspective they constantly ask for variances and waivers to not put sidewalks in to not put curbing in and then lo and behold years later the board of education is tasked with with one the costly transportation of children which we should do for their safety but this is really not where we should be spending our dollars we should be spending our dollars in educational and instructional things but we have to live with the consequences of one things that are out of our control in terms of decision in terms of construction
089cost and the fact that they let developers get away with not putting sidewalks in to in developments where our kids can safely walk so who who where does it cost and then we have a discussion because we're worried about the safety of our children as we should be but those dollars should be going into instructional things and um not into worrying about putting the infrastructure in that should very much be the responsibility of zoning board planning board and the township Council so any any time we have to worry about speed limits and all those things yes and we should be working with uh the township but that we should trust the township to do the right thing at the planning board meetings and the zoning board meetings and not allow these very wealthy uh con
090uh developers to take shortcuts really on our children's uh safety because they're not having to put we have to fight there are residents that come into those rooms and fight for for sidewalks for water for sore but then it ends up that we the taxpayers end up paying for it so there's a real disconnect in my opinion of where we should be putting our money and finally however I'm going to say a few nice things the students in the culinary arts have always been very impressive they've done a great deal of work I'm very honored to be part of that and to see the diligence and the the the quality of uh the the food that they put out and the way they conduct themselves also the student musicians I know Mr Goodall and I
091were talking about how wonderful they were I want to thank every one of the student musicians with enormous Talent we are very fortunate in this community one to be able to uh have music I I wish I had had that when I was growing up I always Lov the piano but I can't play for anything even as an adult I tried um so I'm so pleased that we have the talent of this children but then finally um all of the teachers that were uh awarded uh teacher of the year and all of the staff but it's not just the people in those rooms every single one for the most part uh from from the people who help keep our buildings clean our facilities everyone uh who contributes to the good quality of life for our
092students and really gives them the opportunity and enhances their talents for music for culinary arts I thank you all very much and thank you for the parents who are there for their children and uh I am I'm very grateful uh for the for the children and the talents and the hard work that they have they have shown so thank you anyone else Madam president very quickly I know this is dragging on for a little little longer but uh being a member of the planning board I think it's prudent on me to represent what the planning board does there is a a clear ordinance in place where we request all the new development to put sidewalks and curbing in in all over the town in places where they don't put the sidewalk of the curbing we
093take funds from the developers that go into a a a funding that that that's with the township so anytime we need to draw money from that there's money that's that's available 95% of the time I'll say that every developer who comes in and asks for a a variance not to put a sidewalk or a curb in we take money for that so we do have the funds so that's why when Roger Mei came in Mr mini came in last time and and said that at Woodland there was not adequate sidewalks which I looked at and he is corrected I think there are some links that are missing that's where we should be going and saying ask the township to say put in the sidewalks then we complete the network okay I would like to respond
094to Mr Miss Armenia yes and that should we should not have to get to that point is my question it is my uh concern even though the developers contribute to it why have that delay let them do it it should be something substantial that they are required to do it should not be a waiver they come ask asking for waivers it's in the ordinance I can't tell you how many times I sit there and I see that an ordinance is supposed to be for 50% of something and they get a waiver for to only do 10% this is not uh a shared services in my opinion the children and the community should be the first uh concern of the at these meetings and to just say that the developers put money aside so someday if
095we need it why should we have to go through that and and the again the school budget is not benefiting from that but we're we we can't use that money put aside for for sidewalks for transportation okay if that's the case let us let us get that money for transportation and buy a bus and use it and use that but we can't because they're two separate governmental um a uh agencies so my point is let's get to the other side of it and make sure that we're getting an awful lot of development and the people in Monroe are paying the price and we shouldn't be the price should be established for the developers who are making a ton of money in this they wouldn't be here if they weren't going to make a lot of
096money and the people of Monroe are paying the [Applause] tab and Mr Rybeck yes um there so many of you struck aord with me i' just like to add a little bit to it um uh first of all yes I also as my colleague said would like to congratulate all the students of the culinary arts they did a fantastic job I uh certainly enjoyed the Jazz Band brought me back to my days when I was playing some the same songs as they were playing um just want to touch on something when a developer submits a plans for development I think consideration has to be given to the distance from a school are sidewalks necessary and something else can school buses go in and turn around if it's a colder sack I know we had a
097problem I remember residents coming here uh was it last year to complain that the school bus couldn't get into the cold the sack and it was a dangerous situation uh well you know I we work with them obviously we got something up but but we shouldn't get to that point right when a developer submits plans they should submit plans so that consideration for school systems needs uh is considered and uh it's unfortunate that um impact fees were legal because we would be in a much better position today with these developments coming up here if impact fees were legal thank you Mrs Lang I I I forgot next Saturday the 18th May 18th is um delegate assembly and I needed to speak to the board um at delegate assembly there is one resolution and what it
098is is asking permission for New Jersey school boards Association to advocate for districts that are losing their funding due to O being over adequate I um as as our delegate um assembly rep feel that it's very inappropriate for New Jersey school boards to pick sides and to fight for districts who are are are overfunded to keep that funding while not and then how do they support those of us that are underfunded so um if the if there's a consensus that we agree that that is you can't do those two things effectively um I would like to work with Mary to prepare a statement to read to the at at the delegate assembly so that I can encourage other schools to vote no and instead of giving them that the okay for school boards to advocate
099to get the funding for school districts that are overfunded and losing their funding well they're losing their funding because they're losing their students yes yes yes not because not necessarily because they're over adequacy but they're losing students therefore they're losing funding where we're gaining students but we're not gaining funding there there are school districts that have who have over the last 10 years lost more than a thousand students but are still getting the same amount of funding that they were getting 10 years ago and the school boards Association wants to be able to fight for them so that they do not need to lose their funding and I just think it's wrong do we have to make a motion to do that I beg a pardon I'm sorry I missed no I don't think I
100think it's just a consensus yeah I don't think it's a motion either I just wanted to let the board know I didn't want to go we we to give you the opportunity to vote any way that you see based on the conversation does anybody have a problem with that Madam president because she will be representing the entire board I think at least there got to be a motion and then the approval process you could do a voice motion yeah we can somebody wants to make a motion to give Patty the the right to vote I make a motion I second that motion okay so so what what Bo so that so she's going to the um school board's delegate assembly okay and to give her the right to um represent the Board of Education in
101a vote whatever votes come up because sometimes it's more than one as of right now there's just the one yeah the motion was moved by Mr plur and second by Mr Mayo all in favor I opposed abstain okay so then Patty you have that thank you that responsibility is there any other board business Mrs uh Madam president I have one thing I um I wanted to congratulate all the students that were recognized last night at the Town council meeting the human Relations Committee had um recognized the students for character education on the different pillars of caring responsibility respect fairness citizenship and trustworthiness so I want to recognize those students they span all through our district and I also want to thank all the teachers tonight and Educational Services professionals who were recognized um it was
102really a nice event to be at and the col students did a phenomenal job uh with their preparing of a wonderful meal and I did want to thank and I actually want to congratulate Kathy for 20 years of service to our Board of Education thank you thank you for all that you've done and Patty and Steve on your certifications from the school boards thank you okay Mr Ryback I I just made me think I I was congratulated the students culinary uh program I forgot to congratulate the teachers as well uh and and I think that's so important because it's all about the kids and they're in the front lines with the kids doing such a great job and uh equally congratulate Patty and and you for the recognition that that you so well deserve both
103of you okay at this time we will go to public forum anybody from the public wishing to come up please state your name and address for the record and we will here to a 4 minute time limit and when the timer goes off your time is over Drive um I just I I would like to um reiterate Mr shella's I am Mr shella's comments having been in this district for uh many many years and and seeing budget defeats and and the repercussions of those and and the first cuts that come being made to kids it does look like retribution and retaliation we've been hearing residents asking for their taxes to be roduced for many many years yet 4 months ago 3 months ago we went out with over $100 million referendum and we thought that
104was legitimate to ask the taxpayers to fund yet we're making on the average assessed tax levy impact the the decrease that you've made is only a $5 decrease on the average assessed home I just find that comical that that's what we do we asked for 140 million and and we're going to turn we have a committee now formed to yet again talk about building more schools but we're going to cut $5 out of our budget that does impact the students and Mr plor I I think that's wonderful that you went out and did that research but did you do the research of how many students are going to be affected at the middle school for no buses for after school programs because the state law for busing to and from school I believe is two
1052 and 1 half miles I would rather see the courtesy bus busing to and from school taken rather than the after school buses that that take away the opportunities for students to stay after and and participate in clubs um you talk about the speed limit on cranberry station however the speed limit on 522 where Brookside and Barkley Brook is is 50 at one point and I believe it goes down to 45 uh as you approach Brookside school there is a development there at Devonshire that does walk there's not there are no sidewalks from Devonshire to Barkley Brook what those students have to do is walk through the Brookside School in one door out another through the parking lot at Barkley Brook and it's Barkley Brook School so when you're talking about and and the Devonshire
106parents came out here and they they spoke about their concerns um and the board continued to do that Applegarth Road is a 45 M hour road that's a very heavily traveled thoroughfare through Monroe Township in the morning if we're looking at cranberry station and that being too dangerous to walk then walking on Applegarth Road would equally be dangerous so would on 522 because you have a lot of man alipin coming through and Monroe residents that's a thorough fair to the turnpike so then you should be looking back at Devonshire walking as well and I just wanted to find out did you confirm what Ro Mr meanie said last month there are no sidewalk your your comments to the chair and not to specific board members did Mr poori confirm what Mr Mei had said that
107there were no sidewalks on the wood where Woodland was being asked to walk next year I do not know the answer to that can can you let Mr not having a conversation between the public and the board members okay I guess that answers my question um and and I just like to say you know taxes are important and and tax increase and I I do think that you should be looking I do agree with Mr shella that we have a lot of administrative costs we we've given raises this year we've given retroactive pay maybe that's where you start cutting first if that's where Trent is telling us we're over adequate we should be looking at that and not taking away from the kids I mean look Monroe there are so many residents struggling um it
108is sad and we do have to be diligent you go on middlesexcc county.gov and you could pull up the foreclosure list there a lot of residents struggling a lot of residents and foreclosure so we do need to be responsible but I also think that we should not be cutting first the kids Mark Klein 7 crun or I'm not going to address the the funding problems because I've done that until I'm blew in the face and I have other things that are more important to talk about today uh first of all quickly um it was pointed out to me after I spoke earlier that on the agenda you will be in Clos session talking about the superintendent so in reality when I said what I said that fell within the agenda but I'm not going to
109get into a match with you on that um Miriam con who was on the Town Council last month in the April meeting asked the uh Township attorney whether the township is able to join in a lawsuit with the board of readed against the state to get our fair share the answer was yes so I would suggest that you look into that the most important thing that I want to bring up now is I don't know how many of you know about it but I got it on uh New Jersey Spotlight and some other newsletters and newspapers NAACP is getting ready to sue the state stating that our school districts are segregated now uh if you go back into the 50s and 60s down south they were purposely separated we have neighborhood schools any child of
110any ethnic group attends our schools nobody is kept from attending the school because of their ethnic or racial background um what I'm afraid of knowing this Governor he's going to appease them as he did with the mount that was done with the Mount Laurel decision for affordable housing that they brought also uh I brought that up the sociologist who came up with the brainstorm of school busing going back in probably 1960s had stated the reason for busing was to take the the afroamerican children into the white schools and it would raise the quality of education for them 20 years later he was in interviewed on a 60 minutes program and he came out and said it was a failure a total failure that it accomplished the opposite not only did it accomplish the opposite it
111brought in more crime more fighting more attacks against the students and the teachers and totally totally opposite now picture this picture this and this is the end of it people bought home homes families in Monroe Township because we have a fabulous fabulous school system they pay high prices for their homes they're paying anywhere from $114,000 a year to upwards of 20,000 a year in property taxes so this way their kids can get an excellent education in our schools if this goes through can you see your children or your grand children having to be bust into an inner city school with all the violence with all the crime and have their kids come into our school what happens with all the funding to the Abbot districts that's where all your money is going you know you
112talk about school funding the cut if we received our fair share per student which I said when I was on this board and Christy finally came out with it before he went before he left you wouldn't have to worry about cutting when you take a look at the way the money that that the governor came out for this school year I believe was over 200 million 250 million and then for the next school year another 10 and some odd million we get nothing we got $2 million because your friend who you bank on who you bank on and that's Greenstein time is over Benson well I'm not finished time is over grein Benson and D'Angelo who she brought in twice they did nothing for us and when we got when they had two Mr here
113did all you want $250 million we got $2 million that doesn't even cover the increase in our budget for one year and then when he came up with it I'm going another 10 and some going right now we got 620 $3,000 thank you very much you got it Roger man 22 harrian Avenue um just a little follow-up I spoke to Mr Gorski before the meeting um I did a little research after last week regarding the courtesy busing and state law school district that provides busing Services shall adopt the policy requiring the transportation of students who must walk to and from school along hazardous routes the policy shall include a list of hazardous routes in the district requiring the busing of students and the criteria used in designating the Hazardous routes and adopting its policy the
114school district will consider but shall not be limited to the following criteria population density traffic volume average vehicle velocity exist distance or absence of sufficient sidewalk space roads and highways roads and highways with steep inclines drop offs bridges are over passes and it goes on and on okay but there's something after the criteria to be met that I don't think anybody looked at and if they looked past that criteria it says a school district shall work in conjunction with Municipal officials in determining the criteria necessary for the designation in a hazardous route any additional cost incurred by a school district in implementing this will be borne by the state that means the state is going to pay for the courtesy busing plain and simple English Okay this cut was done without anybody even looking at
115criteria this cut was done without anybody looking at the roads to see if they were striped and prepared I mean you know you're get the courtesy busing that you're going to cut go out and get prices on striping those roads okay because when I talked to the mayor on Monday and I said well if we don't have busing we need to add crossing guards and he goes that comes out of our side you know so now it's GNA you say it's not political but the mayor doesn't want crossing guards on his budget and the board the school board doesn't want courtesy busing on their budget when in fact the state well I mean the state's supposed to give us money on other things I don't know if we can go back this came into law
116effective 2012 2013 okay Benson and D'Angelo brought it in it's official I call Trenton I made sure was still in and this bill is still in play it has not been amended in any way so we might be able to go back and get six years worth of courtesy busing funds and get the rest of it paid for that's been cut you know but I don't think cutting a few buses is worth the life of a child and I don't know if anybody here has ever seen spots with English Town Road at 8:00 a.m. when kids are walking the Woodland nobody's doing 35 kid gets hit by a car doing 45 miles an hour and all you're going to see a splatter and I'm not trying to use the scare tactic I'm just I'm just
117being real as conv you know and I'm kind of disappointed that nobody looked into the criteria that needed to be set nobody looked in and nobody came prepared you know I did a five-minute Google search and I came up with it you know but um so like I said to Mr Gorski I hope we can recover that money and you know get the money for the courtesy busing because it's right in there in the law and I forwarded the link to Mr Gorski to his email if anybody else wants it I'll be more than happy to forward it to you as well thanks Madam yes Mr G may I address Mr mean's comments I certainly welcome the link and our communication before I I really appreciate when when any members of the public want to
118make a suggestion of anything impacting finances um I'm going to speak with our transportation director it's been a number of years since I looked at this topic but I think the hangup here is what the state determines and defines as a hazardous route as you began your comments a hazardous route is quite different than courtesy busing a hazardous route has to meet a high threshold by the state we do have hazardous routes here in the district we do have a policy on hazardous routes um I'm going to look at it forward so I have I'm more familiar with the actual um requirements and I'm going to reach out to you if it's okay to so I can uh we can reconcile on this issue yeah you have my email but they do designate hazardous r
119is lack of adequate pedestrian walkways and from the most North End of Monroe which is Erikson okay every Side Road and there's about 10 to 12 side roads that run east to west north to south between spots with English toown Road and Monmouth which runs parallel but slightly diagonal okay the first sidewalk you see on the side road is First Avenue so this impacts over 350 homes and possibly 700 700 students let's say two houses to a home okay we will check it out thanks well I hope so thank you good evening everybody Patrick homie I'm a teacher here at the high school um coming as a member of the World Language department on behalf of my entire department at the high school um we had a meeting today and they asked me to come
120and speak to you all tonight I have a couple comments and questions regarding uh proposed um curricular changes at the Middle School uh it is being pushed through that we're going to Institute a Civics curriculum for one semester in seventh grade which will eliminate one semester of World Language instruction at the seventh grade uh that would force some of our students to take World language for the first semester of seventh grade then go to Civics for the other half of the grade it would be switched uh and then they would go to e8th grade to continue on with their study of the same language that is going to have such a huge negative impact at the high school and I do not feel that adequate consideration was given to that uh students are placed after
1218th grade if they continue on in the same language of study they're either placed back into level one to repeat the language and just go over some of the basics again or they're placed into a standard level two track or they're placed into two honors which will set them up for APS seniors uh over the past few years we've instituted the Seal of biliteracy through the stamp test we've been widely successful with that largely in part due to the Middle School curriculum that we currently have in place our AP numbers are great we are running AP courses in French Spanish and Italian due to the Strong Middle School program that we have um my department feels very slighted that we were not consulted regarding this it's not right for the students it's going to have
122a huge negative impact on their performance uh the legislation in question it was Senate Bill 2762 has a date that this will be pushed through by 2020 2021 uh we really do feel that this is is being rushed uh if the legislation is not supposed to be pushed through for another year it's still in committee this isn't even law yet I really do feel that we're rushing on this um if you guys could just shed some light on that as to what your thought process was and going through that process um a lot of civics has to do with being Global Citizens and being globally and culturally aware and diverse by attacking World Language to accomplish that goal it it's kind of counterintuitive in our opinion Dr Al do you have a answer to that
123I can answer part of it yeah um when the board goals were included to add a Civics course at the middle school um we worked with the Middle School administration to try and figure out how do we fit this into a student schedule and that was what was suggested we're going to be looking very closely this summer at the curriculum of both the Civics and the seventh grade language courses um to see how we can adjust that one of the benefits of of what we've been doing at the elementary level is our students are coming into sixth grade a little bit more prepared based on our um Blended learning program at the elementary school with the Teach the World Language teacher and Rosetta Stone that they're supporting that in the classroom um so we're going
124to look at that we don't know how it's going to affect the numbers um but there's only so much time in the day to try and fit everything in cu the other the other requirement in middle school is the financial literacy piece which we had to figure out how we were going to fit that into an already tight Middle School schedule right and in regard to the elementary school the only thing with that is that it's exclusively Spanish so when students do to sth grade they could have the option of going to French or Italian so that does put them at a little disadvantage um also the piece of legislation that I find interesting it says that the board shall ensure that the course of study includes a minimum of one semester of instruction or
125the equivalent would it be possible to embed the Civics within a social studies course already and to go back to what the topic of discussion has been tonight finances uh by hiring two new social studies teacher at the middle school to teach these Civics courses you're spending over $100,000 on these two employees when if you just embedded it within courses that already exist and made it that equivalent of one semester we could save $100,000 right there yeah that that was something we looked at and I know we looked at the middle school the social study standards and trying to fit it within we already do Civics within a lot of our things but this was more specific so it would be adding it into the curriculum but this is something that we're aware of it
126and we're going to have to keep a close eye on it and how it affects the programs could we possibly keep somebody from the high school in the loop on that or can somebody be a voice from the high school to keep our opinions and our what we do because I mean it's going to see so impactful for level four honors you might want to call Dr alvik tomorrow because your timer went off sure thank you very much anyone else from the public wishing to speak hi um good evening I'm Maria fony from Seven Angelina Court and first I just wanted to congratulate our board members on your Awards I think that's great and you represent us very well and I I want to say that um I just wanted to thank the Board of
127Education and the school administration for all your hard work um that you've put into the budget process while I know budget cuts are not easy and I definitely don't envy any of you up there tonight um do appreciate all the effort and work that you've put into to this and trying to make these Cuts as as uh easy to take as possible and just wanted to thank you all thank you anyone else from the public prakash pup from 33 Dina Drive lot of discussion on the budget when I was there at the prel budget we all clapped it was a good job and now you cut from 2.17 cents to 2 cents and all this I don't think we need it just give back that 2.1 cents 17 is not going to make much difference
128you know keep everyone happy and let's move on uh anyway the Boe committee and the president I have you know I always go and meet the legislature so I had a chance to meet Senator Greenstein and we had one and a half an hour discussion I will bet you discussed on three topics um we discussed on impact fees on Builders towards School funding for special education and our current formula and lastly affordable housing I do that even in the council and I I'll not stop it and we will not stop it our community and will not stop it we'll work with entire Township we had a very good discussion candid discussion and Senator Greenstein agreed that there is a current bill on uh impact fees and it is impact fees is legal in more than
12925 states in United States so it is not don't talk about legal and illegal if it is not in the bill don't say it is illegal there are several things which are legal okay so don't please don't say it so it is good news that she's going to write a bill she'll promote a bill now it is our duty in bipar way support the bill Lobby the bill at Trenton because it is Builders have big Lobby there so we have to beat it so we the citizens Boe Council everyone should Lobby for that bill and we spoke about also funding Senator Greenstein also agreed that for special education is not adequately funded with the current Formula so Senator greenstyle will encourage Senate President who has come with this proposal s to establish a special education
130commission to look into the issue and have a Eng a bill on special education by end of this year so these two bills we should Lobby and we should support if we have let us read the bills if there are any deficiencies let us meet Greenstein and update the bill not sit here and say she's lying she will not do anything come on we'll put her on the spot and we will support her that's the way positively we should work at regarding affordable housing we had 30 minutes of discussion we know that the builders are taking opportunity what the verdict the court is passing the court has passing verdict in favors of the hideen city housing for the builders Builders are making money and we are and Builders give a big talk what they doing
131good for the affordable housing nonsense it takes 20 years to build affordable housing they are not doing anything for the affordable housing which we need she agreed that we don't have good bill and we should continue to debate at academic level and all by next year we'll surely we'll have some bill for affordable housing she said that the look at the plain BR look at cranberry look at e wi South Brunswick how the township has you know tackled affordable housing I'll tell you we have not done a good job okay the mayor and the Council made debate I'm ready to debate with them they are not done a good job so as a next step I request that that once these bills are in process we at the Board of Education you have every right
132what is good for the children you have every right to lobby for it we citizens other communities all will support it Council also will ask to support it so okay okay thank you very much thank you good evening George Gelman 5 Kelly Court Monroe um in the presentation discussing discussion about the ad hoc committee it seemed to be that the focus was to get people who are not previously involved I'm not real sure that that makes much sense um have no having no previous experience is not the qualification for many things in this life and I would think it's probably not the best qualifications for being on a committee that's going to recommend how we go go forward as a community but I guess if you want to try something new that might be a
133shot but no no previous experience in my experience is not the direction to go in when you're looking for advice on the topic of sidewalks I go to way too many meetings and how it works the only time that the planning board in general I won't say 100% but 90 some percent of the time and and these projects go ahead of before the planning board and the zoning board depending on it where they start the only time they're going to get relief some sidewalks is if if it's one very small and two not connecting to anything thank you and and then that money goes into a fund the money that is uh done by an engineer's estimate in other words what it would cost them if they had put had to put them in and
134that becomes available to put sidewalks in places where they're needed from previous developments or longstanding things where they might connect people up and and give a service to there now on the the particular topic of the kids having to walk through one school to get to the other school I think when that project was approved there was some obligation that was stated in the board meeting that the developer was going to participate in in extending the sidewalk so it did work if that didn't someone should investigate that and and that's certainly That Sidewalk should be built those people that are walking to those two schools should have a safe way to do it and if it's not in the approved uh plan from the planning or zoning board I forget which one it went before
135uh there is that fund that should build that so we can get That Sidewalk the kids shouldn't have to go through the school except maybe when it's raining um that's all I had thank you thank [Music] you uh good evening Doug PO for tamarak Road uh I'd like to applaud uh Dr alage for the uh her description of the professional development program that we have here in mon uh it sounds like a very outstanding program to help uh novice teachers as well as our veteran teachers and uh I I'm sure that it is comparable if not better than uh programs in other districts so congratulations on that uh last week uh at your meeting when you adopted your final budget uh I I did applaud your attempt to uh reduce uh the property taxes uh
136that are needed to support the schools but uh I got home and I did a little calculation and your reduction uh for for my home for what it's assessed at uh your reduction ends up being less than 50 cents a month for me that that's you can't even buy a cup of coffee or a donut for that kind of money and uh I looked at what what we are sacrificing W with such a small cut uh particularly the after school busing I'm not not talking about the courtesy busing because I think courtesy busing should have been examined some years ago here in in Monroe uh particularly over at the Oak Tree area uh but uh when we cut after school busing uh we have an impact on the students who have either a single parent
137or who both parents work and therefore they have no way that they could stay after school easily uh to participate in the clubs to get extra help after school school so uh I was very very disappointed uh that uh that you had decided to cut after school busing uh the other impact was the reduction in new Staffing uh I think there was going to be a new teacher for the oak tree School uh two teachers for the Middle School uh both of those schools are the schools that are most heavily impacted with new growth year after year so it seems to me that if you're going to do that then we're going to be shoving more more kids into classrooms that are probably already crowded uh I I was just disappointed in that uh so
138I don't have any questions for you uh I I'm just sharing my concerns and thoughts in terms of the discussion uh that you had last week and in terms of that final budget adoption thank you thank you is there anyone else from the public okay seeing no one we will close the public forum go to the Clos session resolution be resolved that the Board of Education of the township of Monroe hereby moves to go into closed session in accordance with the Sunshine Law chapter 231 of the public laws of 1975 njsa 10 col 4-6 to 10 col 4-21 to discuss the following subject position of superintendent of schools discussion of deliberation process following closed section session action may be taken the discussion conducted in Clos session can be disclosed to the public at such time
139as the need for confidentiality no longer exists mot Mr de Mayo second second by Miss seagull all in favor I opposed okay at this time the board will move into closed session but I have a resolution before we go in it is recommended that the Board of Education appoint Steve Ryback as temporary board secretary for this meeting in accordance with njsa 18a colon 16- 1.1 motion so moved second Deo and Andy poori all in favor opposed okay at this time the board will move into close session okay at this time the board will come back into public session uh anyone from the public wishing to speak to close session items please come up to the the board and state your name and address for the record Mar Klein s Kure the only reason where I
140want to get up now is to apologize to all the other people on the board for for me uh get Mr Mr Klein that is not a closed session item so you cannot speak to that well I figured that yeah now Clos session you're talking about the bit about the superintendent we are discussing the position of superintendent of school's discussion of deliberation process because I would have figured that if you made a decision and you're going to announce the decision then wouldn't it be right to have the public we're not announcing a decision oh you're not not tonight okay so if if I can address that issue um I'm not involved I don't know what you've done so far well this is about the process so you the process you cannot discuss could you explain
141what the process is no I cannot because it's a confidential process so how to help can I ask a question about the process exactly okay then I guess my time is up so I used my time to apologize to all of you all of you and Steve for what happened before but I wanted to finish what I had to say and I was not allowed to finish what I had to say so just keep up the good work and good luck enough okay i' finish okay thank you anyone else okay then the next scheduled Board of Education meeting is May 30th uh 2019 7:00 p.m. at the Monro Township High School motion to adjourn so moved second Mr POI second by Miss Armenia all in favor opposed then the meeting is adjourned