001okay good evening the meeting the special meeting of the Monro tant Board of Education will come to order please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance stands is that Mr POI making that noise everybody I should turn mine off to may we have a roll call Mr Gorski yes ma'am Mrs armeno here let it be noted for members of the public that Mrs armeno is on the phone to my right and she will be part participating via teleconference in accordance with the board's policy Mr Chella I am here thank you let it also be known that Mr Chella is absent this evening and and under the same policy provision is participating via teleconference on the phone to my left Mrs Deo here Mrs Co Pano yes here Mrs Lang here Mr poori here Mr Ryback here
002Mrs seagull here Mr Tano here Mr rutsky Madame board president you have a quarum present this evening thank you in accordance with the provisions of the New Jersey open public meetings law the Monro Township Board of Education has caused notice of this meeting to be published by having the date time and place thereof posted May 24th 2019 at all schools the home News Tribune cranberry press and filed with the clerk of the municipality thank you Mr Gorski at this time I'd like to have a moment of silence to honor mayor tambor's wife Carol who passed away unexpectedly this week she was a very very sweet lady always had a smile on her face and a kind word for everybody and she will be very missed so a moment of silence for Mrs Tambour thank you
003very much this time we have a public forum but I have a statement before I want to before we go to the public forum because I think it's it might um answer or address some of the possible questions that could arise this evening during the public forum and although I expressed or explained the process of budget cuts at the last board meeting I feel I need to do so again at the March 2019 Board of Education meeting the members of the board approved the prelimary preliminary budget at that time Mrs armeno approved the budget but requested in public that the finance committee go back and look at potential areas that could possibly be cut from the budget the time to look at Cuts is between the preliminary budget meeting in March and the final adoption
004meeting in April and although it's usually it's un usual to make cuts at that time we have done that in the past after the March meeting other board members which included myself and Mr poori tasked the administration to come up with a list of areas that could be removed from the budget without impacting programs Staffing safety and then bring it to the finance committee there was also a request to restore $600,000 that we were going to use in the budget back into the reserve accounts for future use and to get the budget under two cents Central Administration along with principes supervisors and directors came up with a list of 20 possible areas that could be removed from the budget the finance committee reviewed and deliberated each and every line item and decided on approximately 800,000
005worth of cuts which was recommended and improved by the board of education at the final adoption Hearing in April in regard to the transport ation cuts it is imperative to note that the director of Transportation the director of security and other administrators felt that the courtesy busing routes that were eliminated were those districtwide that had the least impact on student safety and included developments near Oak tree that had sidewalks and were adjacent to the school and in Woodland where crossing guards were available for students the administrators did go out to the impacted areas walk the routes and calculate ated the mileage additionally non-mandated lat run bus routes or courtesy bus routes at Monroe Township High School and Monroe Township Middle School were eliminated for the past few years it has been recommended by the county
006the middlex county superintendent and business administrator that we consider removing all courtesy busing from our annual operation budget we hear you and we understand your concerns of your of the parents of our students and we have tasked the administration to see if they can come up with viable solutions to the busing issue and procedures for Walkers students being driven to school and any other considerations to ensure a safe and successful School opening in September any recommended changes must go through the Board of Education committee process for their review before being sent to the full board for approval which means that any recommendations coming from the Administration has to go through the to the Board of Education we are a board of committees they will probably go to the either the finance or probably buildings grounds
007and transportation committee for that committee to deliberate and then make a recommendation as to whether they wish to present to the full board all our committee meetings are open to the public and we invite you to come and attend them although you can participate in them you are able to hear the deliberation process a list of dates and times for committee meetings are on the district website I believe our next round of committee meetings is at is on June 11th at the this time I do not what I do not know what time the buildings grounds and transportation meeting is scheduled for the second issue I have is also related to the budget cuts a copy of the list of potential budget cuts was given to that was given to the finance committee was recently
008posted Ed on Facebook and was indicated that all 20 items that were on the list were cut from the budget this is not true the new math Honor Society was not cut it ran last year as a pilot club and will be continued this year as a stien position it's the same for the light camera action club that was not eliminated from the budget either for the same reason it ran last year as a pilot club and will continue at a as a stien position this year any new clubs that were proposed to the Board of Education such as the swim club were eliminated from the budget we are not going to be implementing payto playay for any sport or any club at either the high school or the middle school though this was on
009the this was considered on the proposed list there was never any intention by any Board of Education member to implement pay to play so I don't know how that got put on Facebook because it has never I've never seen anything coming from the Board of Education that said we were going to be implementing that we are designing redesigning the use of building program so that it not only recoups our expenses but could be used as an added Revenue source as there are many organizations throughout the community and outside wishing to utilize our facilities we did eliminate five teachers at the middle school from the budget the budget was created during the time of the referendum vote the B the board wished to add staff at the middle school to the operating budget yearly so that
010we could transfer staff over to the new Middle School when it opened without creating havoc in that Year's operating Bud budget since the new Middle School is not happening at this time we will continue to utilize the staff we have so in the end it's important to get your facts straight before believing everything that you see on Facebook I think the people who are um out there there that would like the answers to questions you can contact any board member our email addresses are on online on the district website you can also address or contact any of the administrators or the principles at any school so at this time we're going to the public forum anyone from the public wishing to speak please give your name and address for the record we will adhere to
011our 4minute time limit since there are so many people here today when the timer goes off your turn is up and you may only come up once during this process it's not that I don't trust your timing but I brought my own timer to make sure I get my four minutes we go by the official timer uh I came here prepared to speak at this point could you please give us your name and address oh Mark Klein s crore Court I came here thinking that we were going to have at least two uh portions for the um for the comments public comments but I see on the agenda there's only one so I'm going to go easy uh something that I would suggest to avoid what happened last month and has happened to me many
012times in front of this board and his president uh last month you had the first public part was for the agenda only the second one was for all comments and the third one was paining to the closed meeting that you had which turned out to be for the process of finding a new superintendent when I asked a question about it I was told I cannot ask that it's secret the uh the recommendation that I make to avoid what you did last time and every time before is if we're only allowed four minutes when we get down to 30 seconds it would be nice if somebody on the board Mike or yourself say you have 30 seconds left this way we're able to finish what we have to say without wasting time but to jump at
013me the way you did when I had two sentences more and you had to have a police officer come when I was already finished to walk away from the podium that is disgusting and your day will come the next time you're up for election thank you very much and that was below the four minutes anyone else wishing to speak hi um my name is visha and I'm from 32 tracker street so I'm here today in the interest of high schoolers and um The Cutting cutting of the after school buses the point I want to bring to the table here is that clubs are essential to high school to high schoolers um and they play a far greater role than many people realize uh many people see clubs as simply an advantage for college or a
014way to get ahead but really they're an opportunity to sorry they're an opportunity to um widen our world in a way that we've really been sheltered from before we're able to meet new people from different backgrounds and Pur pursue passions that we otherwise wouldn't be able to for example clubs such as peace ambassadors and GSA they Foster um a sense of diversity and acceptance in an otherwise very tumultuous um High School environment there's also other clubs such as art club and newspaper club that allow you to escape the stress of academics and any issues that you have in your home life basically the point I want to get across here is that clubs are far more important to students than many realize and it's really it's kind of your job as the Board of Education
015to um provide more than simply a competitive environment in our high school but also a way to relieve stress to help with mental health and to find support for students who otherwise don't have any opportunities for that to cut out the opportunities for students to stay after cuts out the chance to explore all the aforementioned um benefits of clubs and sorry uh every student every student situation is different and it's not plausible to Simply say that there's a way for um people to still have access to all these extracurriculars if there's no after school buses students shouldn't have to sacrifice either um either grades for extracurriculars they should be able to live in a system that doesn't cater to only one certain demographic but can be inclusive and non-discriminatory to to all so uh socioeconomic
016backgrounds the purpose of education is to increase the opportunities of our students and cutting after school buses does the exact opposite of that um this insation is supposed to provide more opportunities for our students more chances for them to develop and grow and that's what clubs do in addition to the very the very uh difficult and competitive environment that Monon chip High School is thank you thank [Applause] you hi um my name is Shela gidu I live on Harbor Court so hello everyone before I address the concern of after school buses no longer being provided in our district I would like to address the common goal that everyone in this room has to provide a well-rounded education whilst offering a multitude of learning opportunities to the students of Monro Township However unfortunately the lack of
017after school transportation greatly affects this in addition to clubs every week throughout the academic school year there are after school sessions and tutoring sessions in the high school students are able to attend said sessions because of the Rel reliability they have on the provided transport after school while means of transportation such as car pooling can be arranged occasionally many students have parents that unfortunately come home at a much more later time and therefore cannot consistently pick up their children from school especially given that the school cafeteria closes at 6 p.m. additionally while it's possible for the upper classman to drive the school has limited parking and regardless many students would be facing a huge inconvenience due to the inability to attend tutoring sessions or help sessions students grades will drop will drop due to physically
018not being able to reach out for academic help and utilizing the resources that are available furthermore in the high school if one misses an exam due to an absence they're expected to make it up in a testing center after school though the testing center is open from Monday to Thursday the average student cannot make it up on a Monday or a Wednesday the most popular days are Tuesdays and Thursdays because after school busing is provided however if the after school buses are cut many students will not be able to make up these tests drastically lowering their grades throughout the school year creating a domino effect of the school not being as highly scored in terms of education and the school ratings going down Excellence is our expectation but without transportation a reliability a key component
019in EN enabling students to make up their tests and obtain the help they need through after school mentoring sessions how can that expectation be reached thank you thank [Applause] you bisha Patel 15 elderado way Excellence is our expectation mths students are held to this expectation by faculty and administration some go beyond that that aformentioned Excellence a prime example of this is the Environmental action club we began our 2017 2018 Academic Year with two members throughout throughout our year with hard work and a a lot of dedication we are now at 45 actively involved members five of which are sitting along with me as we are now the newly elected executive board we were told that this year we needed to accomplish 20 hours of Community Club service in order to remain in good standing so
020we did that was in September to date we have over a 100 cumulative Club hours whether it was at Green fair or various events with NASA moon rocks it wasn't easy but we made it work not because we wanted to show great numbers but because our members were genuinely passionate about the work they were doing outside of their classrooms and across grade levels this genuine passion is nearly impossible to Foster through a classroom this dedication put forth was only made possible by logistical practicality we never hold meetings on any other day besides Tuesdays and Thursdays so Sol for the purpose of busing because we understand that our members do not have the luxury of having a parent that can pick them up in the middle of a work week at 3: or 400 p.m. if
021our high school wants to continue having a diverse Club repertoire and student successes Beyond just the four walls of a classroom we implore you to look at your expenditures and your practices the fact that we are at a point that transportation is being cut is telling the student body that our interests our Ambitions as well as paths for lifelong Discovery are only worth the dollars on a bus seat or a gym seat well clubs can function without busing but the longevity of that plan is not long at all without busing our clubs are left with only those that have the luxury of an available ride or a parent we lose the countless students that can no longer find a way home and their ideas their Helping Hands and they lose valuable opportunities that a school
022should be providing them we're here to let you know that without transportation our clubs will likely diminish in size and impact according to District goal number one as stated in your District goals presentation and on the district website your goals are to expand stem initiatives develop the whole child through Community engagement and develop learning opportunities for students to understand their civic responsibility well our clubs seem to be the most utilized Avenue for students to do exactly as your goals State no longer will our club be able to effectively educate younger children on deforestation and renewable resources no longer will we be able to effectively plant the seed of environmental advocacy and education in younger Minds so that they can find themselves hopefully prolonging the natural beauty that we are lucky to live in as an
023over adequate District but beyond extracurriculars take a look at the impact that these Cuts will have on academic achievements after speaking with a few faculty members they told me that the pressure is on them to deal with student absences and when they're going to make up their projects their tests their quizzes as previously mentioned testing centers are only popular on busing days we pay for the after school tutoring brought To Us by our teachers but students are less likely to take advantage of of those resources that you are paying money for if they don't have a way home let us ask this how do you expect students to Excel and go beyond by minimizing necessary resources if all they are to you are numbers on a budget forcing us to take two steps back and
024no steps [Applause] forward thank you kumaran 32 sheller dve um I'm just here to point out couple of uh issues with the courtesy bus Cuts uh what we feel is uh the bus Cuts have not been made across the board and it has been targeted toward certain areas of the township the reason why we we I'm kind of bringing it up is I've been living in Edison until couple of years back and I moved here uh what had happened in Edison is they had cut the bus across board irrespective whether there is proper driving conditions proper walking conditions what not right there have been uh communities from where you got across the Edison station cross couple of traffic lights before getting into uh John Marshall school right compare that with uh the situation in some
025of the schools in mandro you don't have that kind of uh an issue but still only some of the buses in oak tree has been elimin eliminated so we want the board and the administration to look at options of bringing back the bus that will be our best Cas scenario if not cut the buses for everybody under 2 miles [Applause] universally number two most of the parents they would be willing to accept some kind of subscription bossing uh so with the amount that was basically put out as part of the uh um what do you say the list of cuts that were done uh the list was the amount was about $192,000 with 250 kids this basically comes around $780 this is probably in line with what is happening across New Jersey in Edison this
026year they have basically increased the subscription bus bus cost to $650 and that is being paid upfront if Mand Board of Education can do something of that sort that is before middle of July you ask the parents of these affected communities that is pretty much everybody under 2 miles pay these fees you can use that money to get additional buses and you can still have those uh buses for the kids and those kids are under 10 and they are the most vulnerable in the society thank you very much [Applause] hi thanks for taking time to listen to us my name is Amit agrawal I'm a father of 8-year-old who goes to Monro um school district and I live about 1.95 M from from the jur addiction perspective so I'm one of the affected father uh
027professionally I'm a chief executive officer of a 400 people company so I do interact with Finance team on a daily basis and understand little bit of Finance uh because of nature of my job one thing that uh kind of um stood out to me was uh Board of Education didn't really understand the opportunity cost there are about 300 kids affected taking about 45 minute of walk two way every single day assuming about 200 working day in a year you are wasting 90,000 man hour every year now because of walking I'm surprised that uh I'm surprised that you're counting $90,000 so cheap 90,000 man hours so cheaply that you don't think that it is it is worth more than 200k and and considering that the financial team manages about $133 million per year I'm also very
028surprised that they couldn't find better saving opportunity than the one that is affecting so many kids at such a such a huge [Applause] level another another I I I keep hearing about a lot of points about safety and the and the number of measures that that you're going to take with respect to Safety in last 2 days and I travel quite a bit uh but even in last 2 days I haven't been able to take a flight out of New Jersey because in my phone I received about seven tornado warning if my 7-year-old is walking down the path from from the elementary school to home and there's a torado warning what measure do you have to keep her safe I would really like to know that and if something happens to her I I just
029fail to understand the pathways are not even snow clean you can give me all the legal reasons but I understand just one thing you guys have taken Cuts wherever you could legally do without considering the impact on us anything that you could legally defend you have just taken those cuts without considering impact on people like us what do you expect do you really expect a 78y old kid to walk in unpaved Road on on on a snow day or on a tornado day to school or you are just expecting PE the parents to pick up the burden either to pay for those buses or to drop them and pick them from the school and and take away the productive time that we have out at our job I really think that you have just done
030what you could legally do as opposed to thinking about us and the kids that's that's all I feel about what the committee has done last but not the least if there is a way if my legal team can find a way to impeach or could move no confidence Motion in this finance committee I would really like to explore that it's just that I haven't understood the concept yet so I haven't been able to do that but if I could I would because I think you guys do not care about us you guys just have taken the easy way out as opposed to really finding a way to make it work one sorry one more point I understand the finance there was 2 million in reserve 600k was short they're leaving 1.4 million in reserve you
031guys need only about 8 to 900k for trilers that will be required next year you do not even require the 1.4 million that you currently have in reserve so there was no need for you to add another 810,000 to reserve you could have lived with 1.4 million Reserve that you have or even if you wanted to replenish Reserve you could have gone at much softer Pace say 200k a year as opposed to 810k a year there is absolutely no need unless you are hiding something that you are building reserve for something that you haven't disclosed yet but with the current disclosure there's no need to rebuild the Reserve at the pace you are trying to rebuild because the reserve will go to 2.2 million and you need only 800k all right thank you I guess
032I Le out [Applause] of can can we just um hold all Applause so that we can hear the speakers because we can't do that while everybody's clapping so we would like to hear what they have to say so if you want to just hold it good evening Chrissy scurby 21 pre yes we are here to listen to the to the community we cannot hear from the microphones if everybody's clapping we can't hear the the clapping and the person speaking so if you can hold your applause to the end of the speaker's turn that would be appreciated please go ahead Chrissy scurby 21 pness Drive um I was here for the preliminary budget as well as the final budget adoption and that night it was very confusing as to what was being cut since something had
033been proposed previously to be cut I asked about cuts and I was told that I had to contact the business administrator that he couldn't answer my questions that evening I've sent emails which went un unanswered and then I sent an Oprah on May 23rd 2019 I I received an answer to my Oprah request which had a list of final committee recommendations budget modifications it was 21 items on that list was the sports and the clubs paid to participate if that is not cut from the budget can you also indicate what else on this list of 21 is not cut from the budget I mentioned a few before I do not have that list in front of me okay so there was um is the freshman orientation cut or will that take place this summer the
034freshman orientation has been eliminated completely yes so we are not allowing our freshmen to come and tour the building prior to September like has been done every year eth grade orientation you want to answer that um our eighth grade students uh from uh our middle school and gmbb have an eighth grade orientation before that yes they did I believe it was in February in February I attended that every single door in this building was locked every light was off there were absolutely no staff taking any parent or any student through this building and giving any sort of a tour what we all told our children that evening was wait till the summer when you go for a proper orientation and now that's not occurring that's a disgrace to this district and to our our income
035freshman and again I was here for both of those meetings never were these discussed out publicly with anybody you you you had a public hearing on the final budget adoption yet nobody knew any of these were were up for for cuts that that's terrible um but then tonight on the agenda we see that we have contracts up for uh a approval so last month we're cutting we're cutting things that make a difference in the in the students lives we're not having orientation we're not having buses so students can stay after and take tests so that they can have opportunities to participate in clubs that will help they get into better colleges yet you're proposing tonight to give yet another raise to our business administrator which will bring his salary up to $211,000 that that is
036a disgrace when you're cutting from our children to give further increases to administrative salaries that that's absolutely ludicrous that we're doing that this evening I'd like to know can you answer is there any pending litigation on the business administrator uh that would be a confidential Personnel matter oh that that speaks of volumes there is I hope that this board before you vote tonight to give yet another raise to our business administrator consider what you're doing we know there is pending litigation and that should that should any type of a raise or contract negotiation should be pending in until that is [Applause] settled Roger mey 22 haragan Avenue um Madam president you spoke about the Woodland neighborhood and you said crossing guards there is one crossing guard spots with English town road and quainton road up
037until two months ago I said this person sat in the back lot of the church and never got out of their car four weeks later they were out front sitting in their car after I said it again now they stand outside that it's warm out we have one crossing guard okay for Woodland none of those roads have sidewalks I explained last month that the state mandates does not request but mandates courtesy busing when that criteria is not met I sent the link to Mr Gorski I was out of town he asked me to come into his office I just got back into town and I'm playing catchup on being out of town but it was stated in the documentation that I sent to Mr Gorski that since the state mandates the courtesy busing be put
038into effect if certain criteria is met which it is met in the Woodland area I can't speak so much about the other side because I don't live over there but from what I can see it fits a criteria too just on the traffic itself okay the state will bear the expense okay none of the roads on Mammoth Road are striped for pedestrian Crossing we have no crossing guards on Mammoth Road but if you go to mil wake when they're getting out they got got five crossing guards okay and yet we're going to pay our T our board attorney here $193,000 a year when they sub out 80% of the work and then a business administrator who does a Public Presentation of the budget and every question that we asked was well you'll have to come
039to my office for the answer and we're supposed to accept this cutting the courtesy busing is a violation of state law if you do it I am going to seek to get us get a slew of signatures a slew of signatures okay and file a qu action Watson you're devaluing us you're devaluing our property you're devaluing our neighborhoods you say you want safety for the children provide the Bing [Applause] hello good evening everyone my name is Joi and I'm coming from five can you put the mic down a little bit I'm Joy I'm from piton Lane and I'm from one of the communities that is affected um mon Chase Stratford statford Meadows and Crossings at mro these are the four communities we have been meeting every single day for a couple of hours brainstorming and
040trying to come up with the options um one of the options you already heard about the subscription busing and then we have been trying to look at all the details and then you know try to look at all the board meetings gather details from Facebook uh try to put everything together so here are few pointers that we all discussed as a community we heard that the buses are cut because there is only 50% occupancy is that right if it's only 50% occupancy why should we cut six passes can we decrease it to three and then still provide the service and and why do we have only where did we get the statistics from who gathered it can we get another Statistics from the school who are the kids who's been picked up by the parents
041and who is dropping them off and then maybe there are only 50% of the kids who need busing so rather than having the busing for 250 children you might be able to provide for 125 at half the cost that's our first point next one is there is Construction going on in some of the areas of the of the communities where the bus is cut and kids can't go they can't walk and there are no sidewalks this has been all been discussed as a team there are a couple of major accidents that happened on Applegarth Road right outside the school and probably like 0.1 to1 2 miles away in the last 3 to 6 months and it's not because the car was going in the same direction but the car actually turned around and then it
042came in the opposite direction and then there was one patal accident and we can send our kids with a speed limit in a speed limit which is like 45 to 35 mil an hour trying to walk or by drive and there like 250 kids if you walk or if he drive they'll be every parent will will be dropping the kids off at the school imagine the somebody said it's going to take around 40 to 45 minutes every single day every single time we walk from the house to the school so consider that and also another 20 to 25 minutes to drop a child or to pick up a kid because we have to show our ID it has to be Security check has to be done only then the kid will be released so we
043talking about close to an hour every single time we either drop the kid or we pick up the kid from the school there's lot of traffic on app guard and Station Road inter section too many houses too much congestion and too much traffic jam and that's a busy hour it's not just the parents who are coming to drop the kids or pick them up are going to be there but also people who are traveling who are going to work who are coming back from work will also be there in that busy hours so how do you account for that and at the same time we are trying to save the money by cutting down the buses but we should also account for the cross guards the security people at the school and maybe you might
044need more staff members at the school at Oak Tree where you know people are there to accommodate 10 to 20 parents at the same time trying to get them around get them out of the school what is it that we can do we are all here to find a solution we understand there is an issue with the budget but what is it that we can do collectively and come up with the solution which is going to make sure that the kids are safe and give some you know uh so we can take away this pain point from the parents from the residents we have tasked the administration to look into different areas that that that could possibly work um and they will come up with recommendations to the Board of Education uh to see if
045they could or if they could not work for the for the September school year and I would have appreciated the timer has just gone off all right sounds good thank you [Applause] hi good evening my name is pradep I live in for Jake Place friends I'll pause if you want to applaud you can pause I'll I'll stop excuse me c can you speak into the microphone to us friends when I pause you can applaud I will stop when you are applauding so that they won't miss a beat okay my question to Boe especially the finance committee is how much money are owed by Jamesburg excuse me how much money do we get by Jamesburg no how much money still ow ow by Jamesburg it's owed by Jamesburg yeah I do not have that offand but
046they are they are paying their portion of their aages in fact they're overpaying their portion of the re a the aages for the last two years so they're ahead of schedule they're ahead of schedule they're ahead of schedule and paying off their what they owe to Monro okay yes may I elaborate on that briefly you really want to or let I I think I think I would uh add uh some context to the gentleman's question Jamesburg begger pardon Jamesburg is overpaying their budgeted tuition every year they're paying more tuition than their actual charge and that overpayment is being applied consistently against what they owe Monroe and that balance has been steadily decreasing from from about 1.9 million to I I believe off the top of my head it's about 1.6 now and it and it
047is in it is in line with the conditions of the agreement for satisfaction within that time period so that means if Jamesburg don't want to send their kids here we owe them extra money back the state mandates that Jamesburg students come here indefinitely for high school students on a tuition basis okay so that is another deficit over there thank [Applause] you good evening everyone my name is Vishal MAA I'm on 42 green a street in Stratford uh first let me start by saying that that my talking here may not make um any decision changes the busing may just remain the issue just remain as it is but we have a lot of future politics all the young kids here look at them they will be future politicians of the United States they are here they're
048missing their daily activities right now someone could be doing their homework someone can be in some karate class or something but they are here because the distinguished board members decided to do so they are here because you decided to cut the busing from the four communities that other speaker just mentioned um while I was coming here my son was with me in the car he goes to second grade in oak tree and he was asking me daddy why are we going there and I said because there is a vote on um pay raise for some of the you know board members and and ba and he said why pay raise we are cutting the busing and we are giving the pay raise I said don't talk you are just second grader they are smarter than
049the second graders all right so you have no rights to talk I told my son that the other thing he said um if I'm walking to the school what if there is some bad guy following me what if someone kidnap some kid I said no I'm your parent Board of Education are not your parents they don't care about you right I have to care about you they are just worried about their own self so that's it you don't worry about that I'll take care of you I'll drop you off I'll pick you up I'll make sure you don't walk and he said but I if I walk someday say if you're running late from work I want in the city so if I'm running late from work someday you will have to I have to
050walk and I said good luck with that you will have to walk someday depends on the traffic and everything right so he said that is crazy a second grader summed it up that is crazy right I said yes and he said they are crazy I said yes all the board of educat members are crazy he said that they're crazy it's not my words I don't have to say anything else thanks [Applause] uh good evening uh my name is Ravi uh from 113 Morgan way I am from Stratford Meadows Community I'm also here to talk about the uh courtesy buses being cut from Stratford Meadows to Tre I'm here as a father of a 5-year-old daughter who is going to start going to kindergarten this September and this is the worst news uh one can expect
051um what I've been hearing so far is that only Selected Few ctis y buses have been cut off this year not all of them across the district that baffles me I don't understand okay you gave a reason saying that someone has done uh some some analysis based on safety and where there are direct routes or sidewalks to the school from these communities and they deem it to be safe well I can assure you and each and everyone over here can assure you none of those rots are safe I don't know who did the analysis how they came up to that conclusion but none of the routs are safe I took the route myself today there are no sidewalks for 50% of the route from Stratford Meadows to Oak Tree school and on top of that
052there is construction going on of single family homes where you expect large volume of trucks minivans cars going in and out all through the day do you expect kids between 5 and 9 years to walk that route every day I would like each and every board member to take that route only once and give their feed back if this is really feasible or [Applause] not I personally took pictures of the route where there are no sideways where there is construction going on and I have sent it today to each and every board member I hope you guys take a look and you know put a thought to it is this really worth is this 200,000 or $300,000 that you're saving of these buses is it really worth okay the other thing is we have been
053talking about subscription buses we are ready to pay you know to get this going but all we are hearing is it needs to follow a process it needs to take some time it may not happen this September okay wait so are are we saying that we are ready to face a major incident to happen and then we'll think about it why wasn't this thought about it before you know putting this into budget that you know we are going to take off the buses why the administration didn't come up with a plan B saying that if we take these buses off this is the plan B this is the subscription that we can provide to the parents this is the option we can give to the parents why was never that option put down on the
054table you know to the parents or you know to the Boe I don't know if it was put forward or not to you guys so I really hope you guys as a team consider this all these safety concerns that all of us here are to talk about you know and really put your thoughts into mind that you know the kids that are affected are between 5 and 9 these are not middle school kids these are not high school kids who can at least walk a mile and half half these are five and nyear old kids you cannot you you cannot expect them to walk a mile and a half every day to school that's [Applause] it hi uh my name is anant madabushi 133 Charles Place I want to talk about two things safety you
055had mentioned that somebody actually walked um to make make sure uh there are sidewalks and it is safe I hope they didn't walk in this nice 75° weather and stroll through it take a walk when there is winter and there's snow and internally maybe in the community the snow is cleared but not outside there were two fatalities that happened recently on these roads there is a lawsuit waiting to happen if some something happens to some kid I can guarantee that there will be lawsuits coming right so we don't want to take that risk second um with regards to the budget cuts you had mentioned that you know um there were some administrative costs that have increased in terms of salaries so why would why didn't you look inward to First Take a look at what
056administrative cost in terms of salaries can be cut before looking at other options I hope before you go to bed tonight you think about the safety of the kids that are going to walk and if something is going to happen to them this winter it will be on you [Applause] respons good evening all um um my name's Audrey Chen I'm from five Driftwood Court um now I've been in quite a few clubs throughout my high school career some told me some of my friends told me it was a waste of time some told me it was only good for the college credit but I can tell you without a doubt that I have learned several life skills in those very clubs that no single school class could provide me with take for example youth in
057government this program allows students to actually reenact the bill making process and expose the students to the political world around them the political world that they will one day enter we become prepared for the future and how to fulfill our roles as American citizens additionally leadership position leadership experience in clubs is something invaluable to students like me that I have exper that I have gained from the robotics Club as Secretary of that club I've learned so much about taking responsibility and doing what others do what others do not want to do taking the initiative being reliable and leading creativity all these skills are necessary for adults to succeed so why not let students gain them ahead of schedule why not let students maximize their potential and grow in more ways than we thought possible I
058know many of my friends parents work very late to support their families and they rely on laate buses to get their children home safely and we can see how much buses affect Club attendance on Wednesdays when there's no after school buses many clubs report half their attendance compared to Tuesdays when there is uh busing avail ailable there's no denying how crucial it is we keep the late buses elim eliminating this necess necessary service is closing off opportunity to many eager ambitious students like myself who simply cannot afford to stay after school without a means of going home additionally many students have to take makeup tests in after school testing centers due to sports field trips and illnesses sports sports are something that many students um work dedicate their entire lives to and um rely on
059to get into college and illnesses are unavoidable if they can no longer stay after their Glades will irrecoverably irrecoverably plummet and with no excuse safety and the future of our students should be this board's number one priority now I want to ask how many of you out there have children nieces nephews or even [Applause] grandchildren do do you not wish to see the best version of themselves do you not want them to have an edge in college and future academic adventures and internships in jobs and their social impact you may think that after school buses are a luxury but in reality this proposal is an attack on equality the disadvantage will not have the same opportunities they once had to participate in enriching activities and truly push themselves to the Limit the excluded will feel
060left out and behind other student with their resume the concerned n9th grader will feel guilty each time asking his parents to drive out of their way from work to pick him up think not of the now but of the future of these very bright ambitious and hardworking students thank [Applause] you hi everyone good evening uh this is Santos from statford MOS I want to raise two points here I know the C is bus is been cut you guys have already planned you already done Lou okay can hear me yeah so I know you guys already planned already cut everything is done and we don't have any options but as a parent we are really boiling up to the bottom of heart because the main thing concern is safety and Hazard as a safety hazard raised
061cup want to start him again Mike tell he started at 3:30 hello can you hear me guys yeah I'm raising two points here safety and Hazard so we have already raised couple of people like we don't have a side walkway and we need to come to the site walkway and first of all it's like 7 miles to come to at least to walkway condition and especially when it comes to a snow or any kind of stuff is we had couple of fatal accidents there just because we slipped and lot of things going happen there so this kind of Hazard I'm not sure if you guys take a decision please come in the winter walk with your with your kid or with with your family till school then take the decision so this is really just
062taking decision because of budget please safety is more important than budget see the options let's have options what options we have make a committee we all join so it's we it's community board of education nothing but we we are made of together so I want each one of you to see the options what we have currently we are really getting to the bottom of our requesting you to get the solution and we see what whether subscription buses or whatever come with a solution we can really work together thank you than [Applause] you hi good evening everyone my name is Ram I live in uh Morgan B chat from meows and uh he he's my son Surya he's four years old and he'll be fine next year and he'll be going to the elementary school next
063year just picture himself like you know 100 Kids of his age walking the pathway for prob in all like 2 miles every day right and I happen to see the video of the Boe meeting last time right and Mr Andy mentioned like he did his due diligence he walked like 2 miles from the father's home in sford and was okay but you cannot compare yourself with kids right walking uh 2 mil a day walking 2 miles a day it's good for you good for me but not for kids right so I request the board please consider please consider the kids safety before you make any decision this kids right he doesn't know anything I mean last week he almost lost his finger he was playing with the grill he lost his finger almost he lost
064his finger I I spoke to him for several minutes and again the guy was placed in the grill again because the kids of his age doesn't know the consequence right they don't know how to read the road signals and we have lots of trucks it's almost like in a several Tru you can you can Drive in you know the um the Station Road Cranberry Station Road and the apple G Road there lots of vehicles and know it's almost like putting a kids at risk knowingly right and picture himself like you know walking 100 kids in snow rain as everyone mentioned like you know with 5 lbs of books water bottle whatever right so I request the board and we are everyone with you so please do the needful thank you [Applause] one thing what do
065you need I want school bus to go to school thank you hi my name is Ajit kapali 12 Hastings Le Monro Chase uh you've already heard about all the reasons for reinstating school buses I'm not going to repeat myself that my concern is mainly around subscription busing so as I understand uh subscription busing is not ready yet right so first F I mean they have two concerns around this why did the board make the decision to scrap buses without having a fallback plan that's one and second is can you at least look at options of providing courtesy busing at least uh till we have an affordable subscription offering uh till you at least have a plan around that because there's no you know I mean there's no point uh you know having uh just scrap
066the buses without having a subscription plan I hope somebody answers this question we're looking at everything we're looking at subscription busing we're looking at um different options that we could Implement buses we we're looking at restoring some of the bus routes but um everything is on the table we hope to have some kind of solution that would be fair to everybody okay so do you have any timelines around this when when are you going to get back well I I think they've already started doing some research so it's going to take a little bit it's not going to happen in a day or a week it's going to take a little bit of time to um investigate different options and different um what other different towns do with their courtesy busing and um working with
067the director transportation and the director security okay thank [Applause] you gazala Bora one moo Drive I want to start by thanking people standing behind me who let me come in the front so I could get back home in time to break my fast um I want to ask all you people sitting all the board members sitting out there that do you realize that there's something terribly terribly wrong with this picture that within 10 months this room is full of people screaming for their kids safety 10 months ago we did that for the Middle School trailers 10 months ago we came here and said those trailers are unsafe there was so many arguments the the president said you guys were not involved all this was told to you before end of the day that problem got
068fixed the trailers are now safe they are way better than they would have been had we not filled the room like this now we are talking about 7 and 8 year olds walking 30 minutes one way to school while at the same time on the agenda today is increasing the salary of the highest paid business administrator in this district is there something wrong with this picture or not I have been very polite when I normally come up to the microphone but today I am sorry I am losing all politeness in me because this there's something terribly wrong with this picture how can we within two meetings cut such programs and in the second meeting increase put on the agenda and increase to the salary of a bus business administrator and it is public knowledge that
069there was a litigation against him and it is public knowledge that the previous board did not renew his contract and as soon as it came to work with the new board without discussion it was approved with a retroactive salary increase we're okay about that as long as you don't cut buses for 8-year-old kids we're okay as long as you give my son a high school orientation because I'm sorry the one on February was not an orientation classrooms were closed it was a waste of time of most of the parents who were in this building that night nobody walked out saying oh I know where my kid is going nobody that orientation in the summer is critical do you know how many kids are lost when they walk into this building and parents so we can
070go do away with that without a second thought without trying to find out can volunteers run this program at no cost to the district was that even considered no there was there there are towns around us that do town halls for such decisions how can we cut buses to elementary school kids expect the parents to pick this uh pick the tab on that expect the kids to walk 30 to 35 minutes but not do a town hall before that what respect do we have for the taxpayers here none and to say that there's something on Facebook and you should not listen to it well if you're on Facebook you should refute it you should say this program has not been cut that documentation needs to be available well our source of information a lot of
071times you could of lack of transparency of this board time and again lack of transparency of this board has been people who attend these meetings the videos of these meetings and Facebook yes so if you think there is wrong information being circulated please do your duty as a citizen and correct it out there and we will be obliged thank you very [Applause] much my name is uh baves Patel 8 Morgan way um and I'm from Stratford Meadows townhouse Community uh I'm here to talk about uh the courtesy busing that is been cut starting from September uh first of all uh let me uh tell you that uh Stratford Meadows uh doesn't even have walkways so I'm I'm I'm not sure like how this decision was even taken uh and I'm pretty sure that the uh
072the board has not done its uh due diligence and I'm pretty sure even the transportation department might not have taken full round of our community to see how unsafe and uh and how much um like it could be a major uh safety concern for for the small kids walking in our community and uh let me just explain one more thing is here uh let's say uh let's take one scenario a parent having U two kids one is in second grade another is in fourth grade so what does the board of education is expecting a parent that they should drop their four year fourth grader by sorry they should drop this second grader by car while leaving the fourth grader at the bus stop and we don't even know whether the bus will come on time
073or how they are going to make it so is it like safe for leaving that fourth grader uh at the bus stop since because the uh busing for Apple guard is still there but not for the oak tree and similarly in the afternoon the parent will be picking up one child whereas the other child will be taking bus to the school to the home and it is quite possible that the parent might not reach home or the bus stop before the bus reaches with that second child and dropping that second child so I I'm I'm pretty sure that the board of education has not thought about it and they should have thought about this kind of scenarios because these two schools are facing each other and it is very likely that one child is in
074oak tree and other child is in is a Apple that's it thank [Applause] you hi good evening my name is Bala satam morti I'm coming from statford Ms um I'm just I'm sure you guys are aware what is happening in this world I'm just reading an security event happened in your neighboring Township on 523 and approximately 655 hours an unknown white male approached a 12-year-old female asked if he could give a ride and drop her half as she waited for her school bus the female declined the ride and the male Drew off so this is a decision the 12-year-old can make but unfortunately I don't know if any of the 5-year-old or six-year-old can make this is a situation where the bus this is just at a place where the student was waiting for a
075bus and we are talking about fire and - old walking two miles God forbid if something happens is there anybody in this room will take a direct responsibility and if you guys say I can take the responsibility is it worth the risk of like $200,000 for the future of our kids I hope you guys can can sleep well tonight thank you [Applause] hi I'm getting last minute instructions here my name is Jan escco I'm at 14 Rosewood Lane uh we're pretty new to the district we came from East Brunswick what East Brunswick I'm here to mainly talk about the courtesy busing for after school high school students um I believe that if it's a safety issue then we need to consider the stressful environment that kids have at school especially my honors kids and several
076of the honors kids they don't have time for the extracurricular activities during the day um my child you know barely gets to take one elective and even then they're encouraged to take oh take an elective that'll look good on your school transcript um so one thing that we're really glossing over is the suicide prevention of getting to know somebody they have 30 minute lunches then they're in classes all day and then they go home and maybe they have one or two friends and they're like this you know you see the back of their heads but when they're in clubs they are talking to each other they're interacting with each other they're coming up with ways my kids are in clubs to prevent bullying to um make the school a better place they've given um presentations
077to the teachers about how to have inclusive inclusiveness in the classroom so this is stuff that can't be taught in the classroom and this is stuff that is just vital for their mental health um also I needed to bring up a point of that I think has already been brought up a little bit that if athletic buses can be paid for than the after school buses for clubs can be paid for so the amount saved by cutting after school busing apparently is 68,276 7,000 so the amount of money saved through shared services by sharing route costs for busing through joint I can't even read that with other school districts is $98,000 there is currently a Statewide bus driver shortage so the district is trying to attract bus drivers Transportation received the largest financial cut of
078all instructional divisions at the difference of more than 270,000 from last year so um this is some information that I was just given so I just think that if we're talking about safety we're talking about little kids safety getting to school without getting hit by a car or construction vehicle we really really have to think of the high school kids safety by making friendships Making Connections being allowed to explore um their broader selves thank you be before we start with the next person um I just because of time constraints and the fact that the board has a lot of business to discuss today we're going to we're we're going to close public forum at at 8:30 um we we understand your concerns we are willing to look at your issues we have heard heard from
079you tonight we've heard from you in the past but at 8:30 the board really has to get to their their part of the agenda that we need to do can please have the speaker please speak hi Deborah Pella 15 Louise Lane uh I've been up here before so I should look familiar I know everyone is discussing the busing and I don't need you can hear me yes okay I don't need to beat that but to go off of what um the student Audrey said and the woman Janet that was just here said um very important aspect of something that I've heard you guys talk about before our rankings our state rankings how we look and if we cut after school busing for these children who do extracurricular activities they're applications will look worse our overall
080school district will this look worse because our offerings will not be the same because not as many children can participate so by voiding that out for children that cannot get Transportation home we're either going to have kids who are going to be loitering on school property won't get home will Uber because they need to um and the issue is for me is I'm able to get my kids now but for some reason I couldn't and I know there are plenty of children that can't get picked up that busing is crucial to these students being part of a school when they don't participate in a sport maybe it's the chess club maybe it's the ping pong Club they are part of something and that's really an important part of what high school is about and for
081them to just feel included in something may be a difference in this kid's overall Outlook not just an application in school but suicide rates in interaction in depression I think it all goes I know there's plenty of research that supports it so I just wanted to mention the whole part about um the busing one more time and about a well-rounded student and our overall rankings I know we've talked about that before um in the past I guess because now I have an eighth grader I'm curious if there is an average of how many incoming ninth graders leave Monroe District to go to private school I was wondering if there's an average for that the reason I ask is because I'm new to this this year and I'm surprised at how many students students I know
082of that are leaving the district for that I didn't know if that was a number that's a common knowledge yeah um the exact percentage I I don't have in front of me it would be statistically untrue to say a large number of students do that um we get projected enrollments from both middle schools and um they're pretty much on target each year what are both middle schools uh Jamesburg okay and Monroe so they're pretty On Target but there's no way to know that for example over the course of the last 5 years 10 children went to private school and then in 5 years later 20 uh some of the students from Monroe Township Middle School do take advantage uh and it's on a very select criteria some of theems that are available in Middle sex
083County very familiar but um very high large percentage most of our students from Jamesburg and the Middle School attend Monro Township High School yes that I understand I was just curious if there's any sort of back information of how many years did it go back to see how many student are leaving the district we wouldn't keep a statistic like that it's so nominal that it really doesn't impact us okay okay thank you very [Applause] much prakash pup 33 DNR drive I'm sure you heard the parents today what they said and we are not going to wait till September for for your decision I request that I request that take the decision by coming June meeting June 19th we expect the decision on this by June 19th that is the [Applause] request second point I want
084to make to public and Board of Education State funding for our transportation is not adequate you guys would have gone and the state because they are not given adequate funding for transportation instead of that you are impacting children and parents okay where we stand with respect to the state funding you fight for the state funding get adequate State funding they supposed to give us $8 million for last 10 years they are giving less and now we are cutting all the things that is not acceptable the next point is you the middle sex county is telling us to cut the courtesy busing who are them we are paying the tax not the middle sex county is paying anything for us the government is not paying we are paying the premium tax tell that lady or man
085to walk 2 miles from their parking lot before telling us cut the courtesy busing this is not acceptable overcrowding of the school is a problem underfunding is a problem think of that special education not funded properly we have to stand and Sue the state Jamesburg stood sued the state the governor came and talked to them we don't have to be scared that if you sue the state legislator or Governor will be angry with us no they will not be and then I heard oh we have to give back money to seniors okay I'm a senior too just giving $5 a year back reduction in tax per year you cannot even buy Starbucks Coffee there and cutting it would have given us $250,000 okay and taken care of this so I request again everything can be
086changed it is in your hand you can amend the budget and amend the budget get back we all clapped when gosi did the first presentation in March thinking we all went happy then came in April I was not there because I was sick and I heard we are giving back $5 and all these Cuts you know I don't want to go I I tell you today I have to move this I feel sorry 3.5% raises all across 3 .5 inflation rate is 2% yeah 3.5 okay the union ask 3% give the union 3% teaching staff non-teaching staff inflation rate is 2% then the average I'm talking about average increase should be only 2% and the administrative non-teaching people who are called managers directors VPS they should be increase in salary depending on performance not just
087blank [Applause] Chuck so I request Madame President and the bo members that June 19th please come and give recommendations so we all will be happy we'll go to our summer vacation thank you very much [Applause] my name is teni Desai I live at 29 Orchard Grove I live in Stratford which is one of the communities that are affected by the strongly in my belief irresponsible cuts that were made by the Board of Ed except one person K cherella who said no I I am really really concerned I have been here in the town for 9 years and it's the first time I'm coming here to speak as a board of uh in front of a board of ed meeting which is sad on my part but I'm here today I'm worried that the cuts that
088you have made affects a large number of students across the town the middle school students the after school clubs the high school students all of the busing cuts that are happening for the little kids I have a 7-year-old who Bikes 2 to three miles daily she's running a 5k race on Sunday all right she was not able to bike to the school 2 miles 2 miles is what you say one of you told in the Board of Ed meeting tape on tape that day that you took a walk along with some people in Stratford in the area to find out if there was walkable distances did you walk to Oak Tree did you walk at 8:00 in the morning do you walk in the shoes of a seven-year-old no you don't so you do not
089have the right to make these Cuts without information one of you one of Board of members specifically said that she would consider a noot if she had more information related to the effects of these cuts that hasn't happened yet we are requesting you we are asking you to make a motion if one of you has a conscience to please make a motion to over overthrow all of these cuts that are affecting our kids and it is so shameful that on the agenda today you have voting for the business administrator who is getting a raised where in front of a room full of people who are affected by your Cuts in the last meeting just the next month last month was the cuts and this month we are here trying to vote on a race for
090Mr Gorski I think you should be very very ashamed I hope you can all sleep that is all I'm going to say and last question that I have for you guys are you working with the township with the parents to provide barriers on Station Road on Apple Road on the streets in Woodland because guess what there was a fatal accident just last month there have been many many accidents all over Apple guard people have died well I don't want to lose my kid I don't think anybody else wants to hear to lose their kids either so let's be responsible we want to know by the next board meeting what your plan is well in fact we want you to reinstate all the cuts you decided to do $200,000 is the value of our kids lives
091really I think you should be so ashamed of yourself thank you very much good [Applause] night so I don't have any serious question I want to ask the serious question with the Funway this is especially for newly elected people because could you please give me your name and address for the record I'm vishu 47 seven Green Street I want to ask the question Funway with a serious question this is this question especially for the newly elected people because I'm the I'm the one of the person so who is voted for those guys who is elected so are you guys happy to cut the bses this this question is especially for newly elected people they they do not have to answer at this time thank you no problem is anyone here who are sitting here in
092the chair those kids are going in the public school [Applause] now any of you guys are dropping your kid in the school on traffic I'm I'm seriously we are totally disappointed we are voted we have a chance again we're going to select right person next time make sure you guys make our happy thank [Applause] you um good evening ladies and gentlemen uh my name is Mary ashalata and I'm from 91 Morgan way um I'm also here to represent my community and the other uh three communities that have been affected because of the courtesy buses which have been cut um I just want to stress on the safety issue and I want to I can't stress enough to say that it is absolutely unsafe for the children to walk to school walk two miles to school
093and especially from the Stratford Meadows area there is no sidewalk even today for the past 2 three years every parent every parent in Stratford Meadows drops their children drop their children to the bus stop it is not safe for our children even to go till the bus stop we pick up our children we drop our children from the bus stop and home because it's not safe and if we are not able to go we tell a neighbor or someone because that road is not safe and even if with the children were to navigate out and come out of Stratford Meadows when they turn right the construction is still going on in Stratford the single family homes and even if they were to navigate that and still cross ahead and come to Hy Road even there
094the construction is still going on and when I drop my kids and when we drive on that road we are driving with such care and because we don't know what is coming next so for adults if it is so hard I just want to give you an idea this is the kind this is the child next year you expect her to walk just just tell her go to school she doesn't want to go to preschool here she attends the Falcon Nest here she doesn't want to come she's cared and next year by this time I have to tell her put a backpack on her and say okay go to school could you please will not go to school she will not go to school and so this is the Board of Education I understand the
095budget constraints I understand all of it we all understand that but somehow somewhere something has something is missing something has to be done we have to work together and we have to come to a safe way of transporting because if the board of education is not about education how the kids are able to reach that education there is a gap here and we have to fill that Gap and we have to think together we just cannot say the law says so this is what it is this is the budget where do I get these millions what do I do we are all parents we are all responsible community members we are all well educated everything and all we want right now this whole group here wants just the safety we cannot we cannot we cannot
096wait for a casuality to happen we cannot wait for something bad to happen and then say you know what let's three think about it because everything is open in front of you there's nothing that you have to rethink later on the roads are there the the roads will be getting stuck because of the traffic congestion I drop my child to Apple go for chorus it takes me a long time just to after dropping him to come out and take a right turn I have to wait a lot lot of time I cannot take a left turn I can go easily from the left and go through my but I go all the way around because that's easier so there is going to be congestion and all that but all that is also can be dealt
097with congestion can be dealt with with anything can be dealt with with the safety of this little girl and all her friends in the neighborhood that cannot be compromised thank [Music] you right good evening at this time we have time for two more people because it will be 8:30 yes thank you you I'll make it quick my name is p I'm from 97 can you please give your name and address for the record yes my name is pan 97 Morgan way um I'd like to raise a few points quickly 50% occupancy that's wrong I dropped my kid it's not 50% most of the buses are packed packed that's the word packed second safety I'm not going to talk about safety because you know everybody has talked about it enough um of course adults versus children
098an adult walking is very different than a child walking somebody has to consider that difference lot it's it's a significant difference coming I'll stay at walking I travel to New York City every day I get down at the bus stop near Monro Chase it's a ston throw from Oak Tree school I walk to my home in Morgan way it takes me not a second less than 25 minutes I don't know who's throwing the number out that the kids is going to take 30 minutes sorry I would like to see these kids who are these kids these 5-year-olds and six year olds that're taking 30 minutes to travel that distance when I hustle at 25 minutes for that distance and I only walk a fraction of that distance I'm not walking the entire distance secondly there's
099construction going on lot of insects along the way lot of insects and what not crawling along the way I got bitten by so many insects along the way especially in spring and summer what if these kids get bitten by a scorpion or a snake or something much more dangerous can their immune system cope with it not a chance second thirdly who can talk about abductions we can talk about safety around the school what if some abduct what if some kid gets abducted right we cannot give them security all along the walkway it's a 2 m stretch that's not possible the saving that's happening is 0.495 of the budget that is for every $100 we spend we're saving almost a nickel and a dime the saying that we're saving an ni and a dime is not
100just a saying here we're actually saving a nickel and a dime for every $100 spent just by the Board of Education I find it tough to understand that of all the Township's budget we had to cut the Cy busing busing just to save a nickel and a dime off the board of education's budget that is really surprising and last but not the least I understand that legally you're entitled to cut the bus in fair enough but it's inappropriate there's a difference between I can cut the line at Subway or Costco people are not going to like that why it's legal but it's highly inappropriate the K Bing being discontinued is unsafe and I would say it's very inappropriate it's like gifting a car but ceiling shut the gas tank kids just cannot reach the school
101that's what it's going to be in the end thanks guys hey you will be our last um person at the public forum I'm sorry I'm sorry you canot wait if you cannot wait 2 minutes if you cannot wait 2 minutes or 5 minutes Beyond 8:30 and you expect every parent to be waiting for their work every day throughout the year I'm really surprised M madam president this is Michelle armino may I speak not at this time Michelle we are in public forum yes but I would like Michelle say I believe that the public forum should not be concluded we have had presentations and award ceremonies that thank you Michelle but at this time we have other business to conduct after a public forum so Mr Krishna deal 11 Jake please I just like it on
102the record then please thank you Krishna deal 11 Jake please two things I want wanted to bring out I saw the list of cuts that have been published on Facebook and you said that some of those cuts are not there but none of none in the list point out to any administrative Cuts non-essential teaching staff or non-essential um administrative staff not no no Cuts in ad Administration but what has been cut is the busing for the students the clubs the uh the some of the clubs have been cut U the high school orientation has been cut so somehow we need to look at other revenues to cut rather than this uh courtesy bussing that has been eliminated secondly um the question that I have um is did we go back and negotiate with other bus
103companies to see if they can provide the busing at reduced cost as opposed to what our current vendor is providing well very small part of our budget is for um out of out of District busing so we do have a um Mike maybe you can explain it better yes uh I we have a procedure we have to follow the uh the majority of the busing is in-house now uh we value that our inhouse staff performs a better service than Contracting it's more reliable it's safer we understand the training that went involved and I'll go on record to say that um we cannot meet all of our transportation needs inhouse we don't have the buses we don't have the drivers we don't have the resources so we have to contract some of them out it's Pro
104probably about 10 to 15% of the services get contract contracted out it's a public bidding service that goes through the middle sex ed Service Commission and they put out a bid to our specifications uh with the route information and then bus companies bid on it and as the law requires the lowest responsible bidder is awarded uh the contract it's very difficult to break a contract as I've mentioned before if you get a lemon if you get a bad contractor uh this the law allows a lot of remedies to be put in place before you sever a contract and and go to another uh second lowest bidder perhaps so I hope that answered a question that helps thank you okay so at at this time we're going to close the public forum and I okay but
105before at we're closing public forum but I'm going to ask if the administrators up here would work with the director of Transportation the director of security the director of facilities and the principal at at Oak Tree school to come up with a to see if there is a possible solution to resolve this busing issue and bring it to the bg& committee meeting on uh June 11th Madam Madam yes Madam Madam Madam Madam board president Administration accepts that challenge and and uh and I want to say we sincerely appreciate the comments tonight um we will take back everything that we heard tonight that's on tape and in notes back to the administration office and we will seek aggressively a remedy to to these Cuts if one uh if if one is recommended by the bg& committee
106so so please leave leave tonight whenever you choose and understand that you've been heard and and and we have great um sensitivity to your points made so at this time um could make a motion for recess a 10-minute recess I make a motion for recess For Recess Not For Recess for something else Madam presid this time we're going to make mtion for but I'd like to make a motion I we're not excuse me sir sir sorry but public form has been closed I i' I'd like to make I'd like to make a motion uh that in lie of all these people that I mean we we've I've never seen anybody this amount of people in the meeting and I think that it's overwhelming majority of people feel that it's not safe for their children to
107walk to school Mr Tano has the floor Mr Tano could you please repeat that I I would like to make a motion that the the board here uh does an emergency vote tonight to end uh taking away of buses because it's not [Music] for it I I for one can say that I did do the walk that Andy did and fat as I am I couldn't do it [Applause] I I I also I also one second one second one second second I also Mella seconds the motion I will I will also admit that I'm a new board member and I didn't realize with my yes vote how it would impact these people and their families [Applause] I also I also feel that the amount of money that we're saving is not worth any of those
108kids Mr [Applause] poori Excuse me but the public forum is is closed Mr poori has the floor Madam president uh fellow members and the public my motion wasn't answered yes it was no can we make a vote no we're we're in discussion you made a motion Mr Mr tiella second that motion okay may I uh as I mentioned I think some of them took my comment about walking the distance as something that I'm approving I still said if you go back to the tape that it's not safe so let me just say this over the last can you can you please excuse me please please I understand the emotions are high I fully understand that and I also did not real the let him let him finish let him finish talking let let the man
109finish talking Mr poori has the floor as I said I did not even realize the impact the the budget cuts would have other than the fact that the 2 m radius was something that state mandated however I was the only member who went to the community when they invited me to talk to them and understand I wrote three pages excuse me [Music] right right right right M Mr ladies and gentlemen folks folks please everyone take a deep breath let the board take their sir please sir sir sir at this point of time at this point of Mr at this point in time guys it's all serious that there's two options either we stick with what we cut or we change it right let's talk about the change instead of getting emotional and accusing people so
110what I suggest is we I'm the suggestion would be and the right way to do this would be to have the administration come up with a plan and bring it to the board of education on the on the that would be the correct way to do it so at this time we're going to take a vote okay L ladies and Gentlemen please please know this is a hot ladies and Gentlemen please please there is a please allow please allow the board to conduct their business M kapano thank you there is a process that the board has to follow we just can't say yes to something we have to go back we have to have a plan in place we have to look at the cuts that were made and we have to evaluate them it
111should be done by the committee system but at this time we'll have a we have a motion and we will vote on it Mr Mr Gorski we have a motion on the floor made by Mr Tano seconded by Mr Chella correct me if I'm wrong can you please hold please maintain order order for the meeting uh correct me if I'm wrong with the resolution but it is to restore all Transportation Cuts made between the tenative budget and the final adoption correct okay we will go to a vote Yes Mrs armeno Mrs armeno how do you vote ma'am I'm abstaining abstain so noted Mr Chella yes Mrs Deo no Mrs Lang yes Mr poori I would suggest restoring all the school buses no we're just voting on the motion so it's yes or no I want
112to make it's a yes or no at this point we're not changing the motion I'm going to make another motion I would say no okay Mr Rybeck no Mr i b of Pardon Mrs seagull no Mr Tano yes Mrs kapano no Madame board president motion fails and at this time we're going to take a recess I I need a motion for a recess because I think we need one I'll make a motion for a recess a second Miss Mrs seagull Mrs uh Miss Deo all in favor we're going to take a 15minute recess okay at this time the board will come back into public session Mr Flor Madame President I would like to make a motion uh B based on what we heard today and some of the investigation and the conversations I had with
113the residents of Stratford and the areas around oak tree I would like to make a motion to restore the courtesy busing to Oak tree for the school year 2019 and 2020 and I request the administration to look into an amicable solution moving forward beyond that time frame is there a second to that second Miss Mrs Lang did you second that can we please I I think can we can we ladies gentlem get your buses can we please quiet you have to let the board conduct its business please can you please stand over in the back can we please sir there's a excuse me sir there's a motion Mr P is making a motion please allow the board to conduct their business please please and so it was Mr poori second by Mrs Lang any comments
114or question I didn't hear a motion I'm sorry okay Mr P would you please repeat that yes I will I would like to make a motion to restore the courtesy busing to and from Oak Tree school for the school year 2019 and 2020 a request to the administration to look forward uh look up uh for an amicable solution between the residents for the long-term solution and it was second by Mrs Lang that that's just Stratford it's for no everything to go to O Tre Madam may may I give an interpretation to that um that resolution that is to restore Transportation cuts to the oak tree area including three communities it's the crossing Stratford State and chase behind oak tree those were the ones affected by the cuts and to direct Administration to come up with
115a sensible solution to the late run cuts that we will bring back to building grounds Transportation that's correct about wood can is uh any comments or questions then we will have a roll call what about what about Woodland that's not part of the ladies and ladies and gentlemen plee Mr poori will the Woodland consideration be that of administrations as part of the review with the with the late runs unfortunately I have to say that I haven't done the kind of due diligence I did with the oak tree so I don't know so I I cannot speak for Woodland in terms of how many buses how many students are impacted so if anybody wants to amend my motion you're more than welcome to do so Mr Po may I suggest you you just consider uh directing
116Administration not only to look at the 4:15 late runs but the Woodland Cuts as well as part of our deliberation yes I yes I do I would like to amend his motion to include Woodland excuse me Mr I would like to amend his motion to include Woodland is there a second is is there a second I'm confused I'm sorry I'm confused we should have just gone with the first motion and first motion is for f guys folks please help please I'm going to have to ask everybody to leave if you don't behave ple please allow the board to conduct their business yeah we're trying to do what's right so help us one step at a time but everyone keeps yelling back at the board and they can't even hear the Motions we don't we don't
117know what's going on here because we hear parents and residents please allow the board to conduct their business the time for public input has been over it's now the time for the board to do its job so the motion is to restore all busing to and from Oak tree for the all the surrounding communities and look into possibly what we could do that's amicable to the parents at Woodland and the after school busing throughout the district that's what I was proposing is that correct well what my amendment was to also add to and from to Woodland and then also the after school can be looked at afterwards [Applause] and and a matter of a point Mr Chella I believe seconded the um amend am amendment is that correct Mr cherell yes sir so we have
118to vote on the amendment Amendment comes first that's a priority motion now M Deo I don't understand how that is different than what Peter said because Peter's included the 415 late mon he included all busing and I think we really have to look at all busing before we so we're talking about giving back oak tree but not giving back the 4:15 lb right right and Woodland and Woodland we not giving back Woodland either we're asking the administration to look at Woodland and the 415 busing and come out on to bg& with a recommendation on June 11th June 11 but we're giving back oak tree that's the motion Mr poori made my amendment was to give back Woodland as well so well why doesn't the whole we get we have the administration look at everything first
119we that's the way it should be but Mr poori made a motion to give back the Oakland Transportation Madam president this is Michelle armino may I speak yes Michelle okay I understand that if if someone asks Mr poori to amend his motion that can be done it is it will be done amending it Mr poori to include Woodland Madam board president point of clarification the amendment is a priority motion that has to get voted on to see the original motion is modified or not so we have to go to a vote there's no deliberation on the amendment so right now we must vote on Mr Tano's amendment to Mr pl's motion including Woodland in the restoration of cuts and directing Administration to look at the 415 late runs so once again the re re re
120we're voting on the amendment to the motion the amendment would include the restoration of the oak tree area cuts and Woodland the Woodland cuts and direct Administration to study and report back to the board soon on the 415 late run cuts that is what is being voted on that's that's not the amendment sir I thought the amendment Mr Tano concurs that is the amended motion so can we move on okay so let's just vote on the amendment we're voting on the amendment repeat the amendment again the amendment is to add add to add to Mr Poor's motion thank you that we add would to the oak tree busing restoration restoration the only busing we're taken away is the 415 busing then let's just vote on the amendment first because we can only we can't discuss
121anything else we can only discuss the we can't even discuss the amendment we have to vote on the amendment so the amendment is ADD Woodland to Mr Poor's I think I think Jill just wants clarification exactly what she's voting for we're voting to on the on the amendment not anything else right now right we're voting on the amendment of Mr Tan to add Woodland to the oak tree restoration of busing what're doing yes simply changes the motion on the floor including Woodland that's it okay so let's just vote on that Mrs armeno yes Mr Chella yes Mrs Deo yes Mrs Lang yes Mr poori yes Mr Rybeck yes Mrs seagull yes Mr Tano yes Mrs kapano yes beg your pardon yes so noted uh amendment has unanimously passed now the motion on the floor as
122amended is to restore the oak tree area transportation cuts the Woodland area transportation cuts and to direct Administration to study the 415 late run cuts that are still in place and to and to come back soon to bg& committee with a resolution or recommendation by January by June 11th by by the next uh public by by the next um committee meeting come yes okay so now we will vote on that amended motion Mr cherella yes Mrs seagull yes Mrs Lang yes Mr poori yes Mr Rybeck yes Mrs armenio yes Mrs Deo yes Mr Tano yes Mrs kapano yes Madam board president motion passes [Applause] next mad Madam president I just want to add to the community that we're also speaking to the uh to the legislators to see if there's any line item uh $300,000
123worth of transportation funding that they can be allocating to the school district and also we're talking to the Department of Education with the board president uh and and I will will be attending a meeting with the new commissioner to see if we can get more funding uh for transportation to the district as well if we were able to secure those funding we'll definitely be able to do a much better job of restoring everything uh moving forward right just wanted to share that i' I'd also like to add something Mr Tano I I'd also like to add something to the public to to say to the public this okay I'm sorry that's the first time somebody said they can't hear me I I just want everybody in the public to know and I I I I
124going to speak for myself not for everybody in the board but I can say to to you that sometimes we have to make something that's a very unpopular choice but not one person on this board hates your children so when you come up here and say that to us it's very disheartening to me I I think that was very rude and whoever said that should really rethink how hard it is to be up here and helping as much as we can sometimes they best choice is not always the popular choice but if people show up and and voice their concerns maybe we can think differently so maybe show up more [Applause] often and and I just want to re you know add to what Mr Tano said that there's nobody up here that is against
125kids or or children that's why we're here we're all here because we want education we want our kids to have the best that they could possibly have we have children or on many of our board members have children on the in in the school system and we want to do what's best for your kids and unless you're sitting on this side of the table and you understand the processes that we have to go through you don't understand how hard some of the decisions we have to make are and I've said too before it's going to get harder in the future when we're adding trailers a million or2 million dollars of trailers down the road and now we're have to cut millions of dollars out of the budget so you know things are not going to
126get easier the decisions that the board is going to make is not going to be easier in the future they're going to be harder we do not want to cut we do not want to cut programs we do not want to cut uh Staffing because it's our staff and our our teachers and our the people who work in this District who do such a phenomenal job for our students and we know we have phenomenal students in this District and we want to keep it that way so thank thank you for coming out and and at this time the board is going to move on with its um with its agenda and we will go to the superintendent's Report with Mr Goodall thank you Mrs kapano good evening everyone just have a brief report under our
127umbrella of engaging uh the school Community engaging the senior citizen Community wanted to give a very very special thank you to the staff at the Monroe Township recck department for continuing our annual senior and Senior event with our high school students each year our grade 12 students compete alongside our senior residents in heated games of Bot ball shuffle board bowling and pickle ball the rec department provides lunch for all of the competitors and award ceremony special thanks to miss drust miss Grimaldi Miss Pachi Miss tringali from the high school who organized our students in working with Rick Allen Norm from the recck Department this is a great event when we discuss how to engage our senior community Well Done by everyone once again so it was a great event yesterday we have a short list
128of personnel items Madame board president and members of the Board of Education it is recommended that Personnel action items a through a under the superintendence report be approved by consent roll call so move so move by Mr Ryback second second by Mrs seagull any comments or questions for Mr Goodall Madame President Michelle armino hi Michelle hi I just want to make sure that items d and e have stayed the same since uh Thursday's delivery of yes they have yes they have okay thank you all right seeing none we'll have a roll call Mr Gorski Mr poano yes Mrs Deo yes Mrs Lang yes Mr poori yes Mr Ryback yes Mr Chella recuse on D and no on E recuse on D no on E yes on everything else yes so noted Mrs seagull yes Mrs
129armeno uh yes on everything no on D as David So noted thank you Mrs K Pano yes madam president personel items a through e has passed thank you then we'll go to board action items Mr Madame board president and members of the Board of Education it is recommended that board action items a through C be approved by consent roll call so moved Mr poori second second by Mrs Lang again comments or questions on the three items on board action seeing none roll call Mr Gorski Mrs Deo yes Mrs Lang yes Mrs armenio yes Mrs seagull yes Mr Tano yes Mr Ryback yes Mr Chella yes Mr poori yes Mrs kapano yes madame board president board action items a through C has passed thank you then I and that ends the superintendent's report thank you we
130will go to the business administrator's report Mr Gorski um maybe we just this very good all right Madame board president and members of the Monroe Township Board of Education it is recommended that board action items a through C be approved by consent roll call Mr cherella was that you yes okay and Mr Ryback second that yes comments or questions by board members Mr Ryback I just want to thank all the donors and C the um Central Jersey music educators Association grant program the mu um beta PSI Alumni Association and Monro Township Education Association for their generous donations to this District very nice thank you anyone else then we'll have a roll call Mr poori yes Mrs seagull yes Mrs Deo yes Mrs Lang yes Mrs armenio yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr cherella yes Mr Tano
131yes Mrs kapano yes madame board president board action items a through C has passed that concludes my report for this evening thank you okay so at this time we'll go to the Clos session resolution be it resolved that the Board of Education of the township of Monroe hereby moves to go into Clos session in accordance with the Sunshine Law chapter 231 of the public laws of 1975 njs 10 col 4-6 to 10 col 4-21 to discuss the following subjects harassment intimidation and bullying and the superintendent evaluation following closed session no action will be taken the discussion conducted in closed session can be disclosed to the public at such time as the need for confidentiality no longer exists so moved so moved by Mr bori second by Mrs Lang all in favor Madam Madam president again
132Michelle can I inquire why there's no public another public portion this evening um because it that piece is not ready yet no there's no public there's no another public for excuse me oh because according to policy we do not have to have uh we do not have to have a third po uh or a second on when it we have a special meeting it it has been a special meeting this is a special meeting okay yes and in fact we had um it was it was a first and second reading in the last two board me meetings yep in policy of course thank you you're welcome so at this time I need a resolution to appoint Mr Ryback as the temporary board secretary for close session second Mrs Lang and Mr poori so all in
133favor I I I I I opposed okay then at this time the board will move into Clos session and I'm going to guess it's going to take us a little over an hour okay at this time the board will move back into public session and our next scheduled Board of Education meeting will be held on June 11th 2019 7:00 p.m. at the Monro Township High School motion to adjourn and that's special meeting correct it is a special meeting uh for superintendent evaluation thank you so move um Patty moved it and Mr Tano second it all in favor opposed then the meeting is adjourned