CorpusRecord 133008

Monroe Township Board of Education Regular Meeting 07.17.19

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Monroe Township School District
Date
2025-02-10
Location
Middlesex County, NJ
Material
Transcript
Extent
13,153 words · about 74 min
Collected
2026-06-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001meeting of mon Township Board of Education is now in session I'd ask everyone to please uh rise and join me in the pledge iedge algi to the flag of the United States of America and to theic for it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all thank you Mr Gorski R Mrs armeno Mr cherella Mrs Deo here Mrs colano Mrs Lang here Mr plur here Mr Ryback here Mrs seagull here Mr Tano here and Mr ruty here Mr board president you have a quarum president this evening thank you and in in accordance with the provisions of the New Jersey open public meetings law the Monroe Township Board of Education has caused notice of this meeting to be published by having the date time and place thereof posted July 12th 2019 at

002all schools the home News Tribune cranberry press and filed with the clerk of the municipality thank you very much now we can move to number five approval of minutes uh I'd like a motion to approve special public uh Board of Education meeting meeting May 30th 2019 so moved I have a second second uh any discussion question we'll take a vote all those in favor I any against opposed I I abstain abstain recusal recuse okay um motion to uh approve the Clos session meeting of May 30th 2019 second second okay any discussion questions all in favor I I she that again all in favor all any opposed accusal abstain abstain abstain okay special Board of Education meeting June 11th 2019 so moved second okay any discussion questions all in favor I I I opposed recusal abstain

003all right got everybody close session meeting June 11th 2019 so move second anyone second okay all any question or discussion all in favor I I opposed or abstentions no okay ready to go all right now we have a presentation I think Dr Alik is going to be taking uh this on harassment intimidation and bullying okay so each year we are required to report out on our HIV um report card uh twice a year so this is our report for the first half of this calendar year this is done by calendar year so this is January 1st through June 30th is the reporting period um and then we will do another one next January reporting on the second half of the year um so basically as part of the law the superintendent shares all HIV cases

004with the Board of Education in Clos session um at the board meeting immediately following the um Hib the conclusion of the Hib investigation um but this is an overall breakdown of our cases for this year um just so everyone knows this um presentation was shared with the Board of Education prior to the meeting but it will be on our district website tomorrow um this is the law as it pertains to HIV so this is the the New Jersey Law um it's very clear on what is considered HIV as we go through our investigations when a claim is made there are also very specific guidelines for all investigations and in order for it to be a founded Hib it must meet all of the requirements of the law we have um our Hib specialist in each

005school and our district anti-bullying coordinator is Lori McConnell so for our district data from January to June of this year we had 43 reports of HIV 30 were founded 11 were unfounded and two were unfounded inconclusive again this is all part of the definitions that are listed in the law of the founded HIV incidents there were um you can see the breakdown there of how many were at each school we also have to look at and something that we look at as a district is how the HIV that are founded so these are for the founded claims what the breakdown is for the HIV claim whether it's whatever the dis distinguishing characteristic is whether it's wrath ethnicity color religion ancestry gender sexual orientation gender identity medical condition disability or other now there you'll see our

006total for um Monroe Township and we're comparing it to last year at this time this year's this year's report is um we had 52 I know I said 43 and I 30 founded there are multiple there may be multip multiple students multiple perpetrators in the claim that's why the numbers are different so we take a look at that and and we actually look at it as a district as the affirmative action officer in the district this is something that I take very seriously and take a look and see if there are any um uh patterns anything that's going on within each school um there this is also done at each School through their school safety team again we break it down by the victim ethnicities and again we're comparing last year's um to the the

007fall of last year to the spring of this year then the state then has us complete a self-report card and this is what what needs to be posted on the district website there are 78 points maximum and this is based on us following all of the criteria for the law having all of the Personnel in place making sure we're meeting all of the timelines for all of the investigations and that we're doing um education for the students and the families in the district on what HIV is and we have programs in place for character education um and anti-bullying so you can see there our district grade is a 76 out of 78 which is very good so this will be posted on our website and it's broken down by each school when a cases founded

008Hib um discipline is determined by the code of conduct in each School but we also provide remediation for any of our offenders or and or victims as needed usually through our guidance Department who are our Hib coordinators we have multiple layers for remediation we have individual remediation for individual students or small group counseling um we also do many guidance lessons or classroom based activities the teachers do a wonderful job in the with their curriculum of incorporating Community Building within their classrooms we also have have school assemblies and programs like our character education programs um we have assemblies our challenge day assembly at here at the high school and we also work very closely with our with the mon Racha police department and um our dare program and work with our Police Department through law enforcement

009so we have uh Community inclusion also we have many many I could probably go on and on about our HIV programs and different things that we do in our districts for character education but these are just a few um that we have in our schools we do share the anti-bullying Bill of Rights with students every year there's an assembly done at each school um that's a requirement of the law but it's something that we do um take very seriously we do talk about cyber bullying we talk about Community Building character building peer relations within our Schools parent education um board of education training staff training we also talk about the strategies for bystanders because we want to make sure that we're supporting bystanders to stand up for other other students or if they see something

010going on how do we support them also um conflict resolution in the fall there's a week of respect that all schools look at and per and have different activities throughout the week um the high school does their challenge day assembly which is a wonderful assembly for our students I've been uh able to participate in that a couple of times and uh it's it's a very moving day it's a very emotional day but it really opens up communication between students and really recognizing that everyone has something that they're dealing with and making sure that we're accepting of that so it it really works on acceptance and all of our schools have some sort of a character education program um and depending on the school it looks different in each school and depending on the community there

011that is our Hib report well thank you very much Dr Ali uh that moves us to a closed session resolution uh be it resolved that the Board of Education of the township of Monroe hereby moves to go into closed session in accordance with the Sunshine Law chapter 231 of the public laws of 1975 njsa 10 col 4-6 through 10 4-21 to discuss the following subjects matters falling under the attorney client privilege including proposed confidential settlement agreement involving student 91351 following close session action may be taken the discussion conducted in closed session can be disclosed to the public at such time as the need for confidentiality no longer exists can I get move second all in favor any discussion I'm sorry any discussion all in favor in favor I I can we get a vote in

012favor any oppose refusals okay we'll be back in about 10 minutes okay thank you okay we're back in session yeah that's see a beautiful little baby in the back future student that's right okay I do have a motion uh to read um I'll make the following motion whereas njac 6A colon 3-1130 requires that a board of education provide a resolution authorizing settlement indicating that the District board of education has consented to the terms of the settlement get resolved that the board hereby consents to settlement with family and student identification number 91351 pursuant to the terms of the release and settlement agreement attached here to and authorizes the Board of Education president Mrs Kath Miss Kathy kapano to execute the agreement on behalf of the board hello do I have a some move the second second

013okay uh any questions comments all right Mr Gorski Mrs Deo yes Mrs seagull yes Mr Tano yes Mr retsky Mrs armenio yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr plur yes Mrs Lang yes Mr board president motion passes very good thank you very much now we can move on to item number eight committee reports any uh committee chair would like to report yes Mayo we had a curriculum committee meeting before this um we've discussed three things we have a updated dynamics of Algebra 2 curriculum document this is the class that um comes after algebra AB which we discussed last month algebra both one and two is the foundation of all high school mathematics courses this course the Dynamics of Algebra 2 typically follows algebra AB dynamics of geometry course for students where math is a challenge it follows

014the New Jersey student learning standards and some topics that it covers are line equations relations and functions quadratic equ functions pols inverse and radical functions exponential and L logarithmic functions um conics have been now taken out of this class and are now done in Geometry basic concepts are emphasized initially with a transfer to modeling real life app ations um students have the guidance of a teacher for immediate feedback as they work student centered group work is incouraged allowing for multiple Avenues of support um the second topic we discussed is a new high school Biology book um it's called the textbook is called biology Concepts and connections n9th Edition and it will be delivered digitally through the iPad the current um Monroe Township High School teachers were pleased with the selection and were involved in its

015vetting and selection the standard for biology textbook aligns directly with the AP resources provided by the district additionally this the book is driven by the national Next Generation science standards um the teacher resource platform is deep in its breath and resources for example active reading guides the digital book is completely interacted and have are embedded with a variety of media the third thing we discussed was the kindergarten report card upgrade update um so there was a few changes made to the kindergarten report C card um three line items were removed recognizes uppercase letters recognizes lowercase letters identifies letter sounds and isolation um these were removed not because we don't teach them and the children don't learn them but there is um they're doing this in other areas so there's it's really not relevant here they

016get um they learn these and the teachers can evaluate the students doing these using the Dr and the map testing that we current currently use um and we also eliminated compl completes homework on time because of the new homework policy kindergartners don't get homework um and these um changes were brought to Dory by the kindergarten teachers so this is something the teachers wanted um and it makes a more efficient report card thank you any other committee chair Mr Lang so we met um for the policy committee and tonight we're going to be voting on three uh well there's two regulations and one policy that we actually app approved as a committee but never were presented to the board so they'll be presented tonight to the full board for a vote we also have um a

017new policy 9400 news media relations and this was brought to Dr Ali's attention by our board attorney and it required language revisions to delineate who was permitted to speak on behalf of the board to Media representatives and the additional revisions were made to the policy to ensure that the staff our staff members First Amendment rights are protected we also elected to reaffirm policy 013 for board self- evaluation with no changes which Mr Ryback will be speaking about later on board self- evaluation and we updated the committee on the smoking VAP vaping substance abuse policy the state just released their guidance last Monday and Dr alvic shared that um packet with all the board members and we are going to be working with Mary Smith forwarding on our policy and we're being have a meeting with

018the middle school and high school principls and administrative team so that we we can come up with an appropriate policy for our district we also did a quick update on the request to investigate the board policy regarding seat belts on school buses for field trips and we determine that it is actually not in the field trip policies it doesn't it's not addressed there we believe it's addressed in the transportation policy so we're going to be looking at what we need to do to make sure our students are safe when they go on field trip since many contracted buses do not if you use a coach bus they are not equipped with seat belts so we have to decide and make some decisions on that and we are moving forward with our reaffirmation and our update

019of our policy book and we've actually finished a complete section so which is it sounds like maybe we should have done more but there is a lot of work in reaffirming and going through the policy book so thank you any questions from Mr L I'm M did you have a question also from Mrs no that's fine okay I thought thank you um yes I read the uh W self- evaluation policy I thought that that that was great especially the section where it says um we we would like to have a systematic program of self- evaluation and and um appraisal and our responsibilities are both to know our weaknesses and our strengths I thought that that that works really well for the board um on the new policy the media I'm going to read it again

020I made some notes but one one of the things I think is really important and the citizens and the and employees should know is speaking as a private citizen is still a right and and um a uh and I'm glad it's in this policy so people know that they can speak but they have to be clear about speaking as a private citizen so um I think that's wonderful I would always I would always want our first amendment rights of Staff members and and even board members um in any situation to be uh upheld on the on the other one the regulation of 32 uh 12 uh the certified staff attendance review and Implement uh Improvement plan excuse me on that one I was hoping that we might re re-evaluate the language uh since you you

021I think you have it not as a new policy to be read but just to um reaffirm it so I'm wondering if we can change on implementation it's talking about the implementation of attendance and it talks without on D the principal may require teachers to evaluate the work done by substitutes in their absence I'm not sure how it I would like that re-evaluated I'm not sure how a teacher could evaluate the substitute if the teacher is absent so I don't know if that needs clarification but I would hope that instead of may they shall that the principal shall or at least either uh the principle shall require maybe supervisors to evaluate the work done by substitutes in their absence this is when a teacher is um absent we have a substitute I know over the

022years even before I was on the board that many parents are concerned in some cases and I know substitutes sometimes come last minute um I think what they have the the minimum an hour and 15 minutes in order to call in um to be absent so I know that's a very short window to get a substitute but on a regular basis substitutes um there have been complaints sometimes just you know not all substitutes again I want to make it clear um that children are given movies they're not really taught the subject matter um so I think it should be that the principal shall evalu uh shall require either supervisors or maybe Vice principles to evaluate the work done by substitutes in their in the absence of the teachers because I think it's critical not to

023have any um you know change in instruction or you know a time frame where instruction isn't being given so I would ask that the committee uh take a look at that and and work with the superintendent and um yeah the other members to look at that maybe some teachers or or principles so that's that's regulation 3212 okay I just want to respond real quickly to that the um we do have a process in place for all of our subs and our teachers our subs actually um write a reflection at the end of the day back to the teacher um through we actually use ASAP to do that um so that the substitute is actually saying whether the teacher left enough plans or maybe there were more plans needed or give and then gives the teacher

024an update on the classroom the teacher also does the same thing because a teacher can go back and evaluate the next day whether the work was done whether the plans were completed and believe me the students do share so um I don't know if it would be possible for a a a building administrator to observe every sub all the time during the day especially in some of our elementary schools where we have one administrator in there at a time because we share assistant principles and supervisors are K to 12 so I'm not sure if that would be a feasible thing to say sh instead of May well may means it doesn't have to happen at all right I mean it is happening because ultimately the principal is responsible for the Personnel in their building even

025Subs okay and we do evaluate Subs we have removed subs from the district okay because like I know uh parents are very frustrated when their kids come home and say they've watched a a a movie they may be happy to have watched the movie but it's irrelevant to the subject matter and or um they really aren't getting taught and I mean we've all had those experien we actually you know a lot of kids love those kind of substitutes because they they get a free day but I think that it's our responsibility to make sure our instruction is is consistent and our substitutes do go through training they're required to go through but then if that stuff still will happen so we need to be vigilant about that thank you yes Mr Po this question is

026for the policy compy uh I believe over the past couple weeks or so there were at least three or four emails coming from uh middle school regarding uh gym dress code and there's a lot of confusion with the parents and a lot of us reached out to various members I don't recall anything being voted upon by this board uh in terms of the dress code for the gym uh I just would like to get a little bit more information on how this came about in terms of requiring and then asking partial and then taking the policy away so my question to Patty is did that go through the policy committee we I I can tell you we don't have a dress code policy what we have is guidelines in our our handbooks and our be

027um what's that word our student code books and and that that say what you're supposed to wear for gym class and things like that but I think I'm going to turn it back over to Dory to give a bit more to Dr Al I was going to say I think to give more information on that but you were you're correct we don't have a policy that says this is what you have to wear these colors for Jim and and or for any dress in in school um my understanding is it came from um the school because the um the staff wanted the students to be dressed appropriately for PE class um I I did not learn about it until after it went out I I was not aware of it um but it has been

028rescinded okay the only reason I bring it up is that there's a perception in the public and some of the parents said is this the way the board is going to try to make more money by making forcing them to to buy the the uh the dress from the school itself so thank you thanks for the response anybody else Mr T I'm going to do my committee meetings okay bgt yes okay uh on July 9th the buildings and grounds committee met um we had an update on the flashing school school sign projects at the mono Township High School and Middle School administration provided uh committee members with correspondents from the project design engineer Bill Edwards regarding speed limits proposed for parville Road the committee concurred with Mr Edward's recommendation of 25 miles per hour along

029parville uh parville Road and requested the administration proceed with a regulatory approval process through the township and County the committee further requested that in lie of installing the flashing sign uh flashing signs in the school zone um that only would be operational during occupied school hours that a 25 mph sign with a digital readout be substituted this sign would alert drivers to their actual speed alerting them to speeding and it would be operational 24 hours 365 days a year Administration will direct Edwards engineering to explore the altim the alternate option uh we also had an update on the Monroe uh Middle School water heating system replacement project Administration provide an overview of the project and progress photos substantially completion of this project is August 23rd 2019 also one of the two air conditioners is out

030in the Middle School uh we're sending it out to bid and and hoping to resolve it in a timely fashion um we have an update on the security vestle project administrator provided an update on the Contracting process and noted that the contractor has mobilized and will undertake demolition work starting this week um that is a promise that we made uh to the parents in the district and we're trying to keep that promise we are keeping that promise Rutter's Cooperative Extension Water Resource program at the April 17 2019 committee meeting admin ation provided an overview of a grant program to for a rain Garden project at the middle school and an overview of the project that this the district would be requesting Administration advised that the New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection has agreed to fund

031the rain Garden project in the area between the Performing Arts Center and the Middle School building and providing con concept design photos for the committee to review the committee will recommend accepting this Grant and have Administration proceed with the project uh we also discussed the oak tree sraak uh program that's the solar panels on the roof uh admin Administration provided a handout of financial performance of the solar system at Oak Tree since its Inception uh it is estimated that the cost of construction will be fully offset in 5 years from that point forward all Energy savings and revenue from the srack sales will be 100% profit that saves the district a lot of money we had an overview of the typical trailer project timelines Administration advised that they will be meeting internally this week to

032begin planning for trailers for next year this is a lengthy process with regulatory approvals design construction and delivery of trailers the committee requested that unhoused student data that has provided during that was provided during referendum marketing be furnished at the next committee meeting to guide decisions making administration's Administration noted that if the board intends to provide new trailers for school year 2020 2021 that formal direction to proceed with design regulatory submissions must be authorized by SE by the September board meeting um we had a little discussion about the Apple goth School infrastructure um he we were provided some photos of deteriorating infrastructure piping at appleo school the main building in 83 is 83 years old and has not seen any Renovations or Improvement at that address for its infrastructure Administration informed the committee that previous

033referendum had considered infrastructure work at the school but those projects were tabled for further consideration in 2010 a facelift was given to the school to convert it from a middle school to ele to an elementary school for reopening in 2011 however no infrastructure work was completed at this time and many Administration is growing increasing increasingly concerned and requested that the board consider Capital expenditures for this facility we also discussed land at the Eagle River Day Camp Administration provided a site plan drawing for the site on perville road which formerly housed Eagle River Day Camp I presented far various ideas to the monell township borded to potentially lease this site or have it develop for district needs by the current property owner uh I will have the owners of those of that facility uh meet with

034us at the next bg& meeting um to see how we could bring some income into the district and uh expand our our programs here uh and that's it that's all I got thank you Mr T any well any question from Mr tuo Mr Ma you talked about um you talked about reducing the speed limmit on Pineville Road to 25 miles an hour right where would that start and where would it how far would it be from the Middle School all the way to the end of the high school it's going to be from from the beginning of the Middle School to from the beginning of the high school right to where the sign is now basically uh right past the rear entrance rear drop off facility at of the Middle School okay so it's pretty

035much the same areas we just Dro in the speed limit and is that a County Road or a Township Road it's a county road but the county kicked it down to the township to approve okay they they said do whatever you want you know it's your school sometimes the county and also I fail to mention the uh the township has also agreed to pay for those signs oh good and uh we also found out that they could be run by solar lights by solar panels so that would cut down on the course significantly because we don't have to run power to them okay great thank you you wel Mr President yeah I would like to report on the education advocacy committee just just one second I failed to provide Mr Tano with a resolution regarding

036the speed limit reduction if you wouldn't mind sir just I I have it I was going to do that next okay okay yeah all right so you're still on yeah I'm sorry uh I have to make a motion here I hereby move that the Monroe Township Board of Education authorized the business administrator board secretary to transmit correspondence on behalf of the board of Monroe Township seeking the township approval of a reduction in the speed limit in the school zone on perville Road in Monroe Township from 35 to 25 dated July 17 2019 second second okay a roll call vote so motion made by Peter Tano second by paty L yes Mrs Lang yes Mrs Deo yes Mrs armeno yes Mrs seagull yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr rutsky yes Mr plur yes Mr Tano yes Mr

037board president motion passes thank you very much thank you Mr Tano any other uh committee chair Mr poor good evening everyone uh on Thursday July 11th the education advocacy committee met uh that included Steven Ryback Jill Deo um Dr alvik and Mr groski and myself and we discussed the various items uh on this the committee has been progressing the first was a letter to the to the state legislators uh on June of 2 June 24th uh we sent out letters uh to to various elected officials throughout the state from the governor all the way down to the commissioner of Education um and that letter is actually posted on the uh uh the district website uh I also we also discussed about the RFP to hire a law firm uh to sue the state and that

038has been uh progressing relatively slow slower to my expectations uh but I do understand that there's a tremendous amount of uh pressure on the uh the board attorney uh responding to the Oprah request that coming in at a very fast pace U so finally I believe uh on Friday the July 12th uh it has been advertised and we're hoping to get the bids by the end of this month and then we'll get them on board and see what avenues that we have uh for monor Township School District to sue the state uh on June 27th uh a meeting has been uh facilitated by assemblyman Dan Benson for which uh Mr groski Dr alwick and Miss Allen and myself attended uh to meet up with the the commissioner of Department of Education uh we made a

039strong pitch about our situation financially and the growth needs that the district is facing and we had an ask to see what uh the um the Department of Education commissioner can do for us uh obviously it's beyond the budget so we asked for a a minimum number of a half a million dollars to uh for in emergency Reserve uh I believe that we got a fairly positive response uh that the commissioner said he's going to look into it and we also invited the commissioner to come back uh I believe he's from card red and uh he has remembered Monro from almost 30 35 years ago uh so we said it's not the same Monro anymore so he should come and take a look at it and uh he said he will certainly do that and

040hopefully we'll start building a relationship with the the Department of Education and see what we could do from that perspective uh the other last item I have is that uh we have been invited by the the Roosevelt P public school uh to come and look at their facility uh the reason for that being that they had a severe reduction in state aid uh under the S2 and they wanted to see if anybody is interested in moving into sharing the um the facilities uh but upon looking at some of the logistics and everything else uh the board the the the committee that visited the the school decided that that's not going to be practical um so that's all I have on the from the thank you Mr any questions for Mr poori any other committee chair

041Finance Mr rutsky so a couple things from the finance meeting first we discussed Mr Gori gave us an update on the the audit the What's called the application for state school aid the Assa um is getting underway uh for the school year that just ended June 30th the uh next step of that audit will be reviewing all the district's minutes not only to verify compliance of minute keeping requirements but also extracting the bid Awards tracing the awards to purchase orders and contracts all the way through to the paid bill to make sure they reconcile um so that's an interesting place to start and uh I'm sure they'll see everything's in in very good order there um next we talked about the and New Jersey qac and an update there on the What's called the fiscal

042IND indicator is the uh the the score that's given to just the the financial section of the school district and the great news is is we earned a perfect score of 100 and what that indicates is that all re required documentation substantiating the many indicators of the fiscal management sections were presented for audit and were found to be satisfactory so 100 on that and and actually that's on uh the agenda tonight on board action F there's a few other categories as well but this just pertains to the uh finances great news on our lease purchase um we put a bid out for $2.8 Million worth of educational equipment Transportation equipment and Facilities equipment and uh we did get three bids back and we gave the award to Bank of America was the lowest bid at

0432.01% for 5 years so that's a really attractive uh interest rate for 5 years so that'll now start taking place probably the most exciting part and I mean exciting part of the finance meeting was when we went through the specifics on the Falcon care and the Early Childhood enrichment programs and so for the year that just ended um great news is there was combined net income of $69,000 and so we were running close to 500,000 over the last few years this is a a a jump of $126,000 uh or 26% to put it into uh percentages that's a great uh continued program two great programs that are continuing um attendance wise Falcon care has 310 students and the EC had 104 students uh as of the close of the school year so those programs are

044very popular doing very well and um it's great to have that extra um money to be able to reallocated and put to to other uses throughout the district may be interesting may be exciting is the uh the New Jersey Department of Education 2020 Appropriations act update and so basically on that I say maybe because it's all a big giant question mark but they the the state is talking about adding roughly 50 million to the state aid and there's a good chance that that's going to flow through as what's called extraordinary Aid which is with regards to our special needs population and it it looks like it may come into play with where tuitions are greater than $50,000 per student where they may cap our expense at 50,000 and and we may get Aid uh for

045any of the uh balance over and above that so stay tuned hopefully we'll have an update uh with some positive numbers on that as time goes by and then the last thing we talked about which Peter touched on is the um air condition unit at the middle school so unfortunately that looks like that is uh Dead on Arrival and estimated cost looks to be $660,000 um which is unbudgeted for and will require public bidding so unfortunately throughout the summer is too quick and the project is not anticipated to be completed until October so hopefully we have a mile September and the Middle School can manage any questions yes ma'am all right you said that the state is talking about adding 50 million for special ed and this would be for tuition greater than 50,000 is

046that 50,000 per student per student per student okay is how I understand it okay any other question one thing that I forgot mentioned that I know there's a lot of folks in the public uh that are interested in the school funding formula it definitely seems like the the uh the commissioner of Department of Education is going to start looking at it uh from September onwards and it's definitely taking some traction uh in Trenton so that's a good news I don't know when it's going to be done but certainly uh it's a positive note Mrs yeah I I don't have my documents I think I spoke to to it last meeting um but of the Department of Education that's that 50 million isn't I don't want anybody to think it's just coming to Monroe that's going

047to be dispersed uh uh around the state but also I believe that there's they're going to be taking $20 million out of that so the really the available monies again to be dispersed in the state is going to be 50 uh 30 million so that whole 50 million is not going to really be available it's going to be I think something that we would be eligible for would only be within the $30 million that they've allocated and then we're not guaranteed anything I just want to be clear about that is that correct yes ma'am okay any other committee CH Peter just passed on to me and uh one one resolution we discussed at the bg& was the uh the board to make a resolution uh to the uh to the council requesting that uh some

048missing sidewalks be constructed uh thereby you know it provides us with the option of if there's a courtesy busing eliminations in the future at least there are sidewalk to go by I did bring it up at the planning board uh requesting this and uh the planning board suggested that there's a resolution from the board to do that so well you could consider that thing other board businesses if that's what you want to do I just don't think this is the time unless you're going to bring discussed in the committee meeting so so well you don't bring it up your CAU you could do that now if you want to could you want to you want to do it now I would yes okay so I'd like to uh to to make a motion that we

049go ahead and and ask the township to to take some money out of that Pro out of their program to build some sidewalks where there much needed around the schools is that a resolution is that a motion I'll second can I make them uh I I think the intent here is that there are certain areas closer to the school district uh to the school facilities that do not have sidewalks I guess the resolution that we will look for is that we would like to authorize the administration to explore what sidewalk areas are missing in the closed vicinity or within the two miles of the uh schools and prepare a memorandum on behalf of the the board to be passed on to the township Mr FL there was a motion on that was raised so now

050you want uh to amend the motion make an amendment to that motion so yes that's what you want to do I think you should uh he said I want he asked me to make a motion he made the motion so you can strike mine and just you want to withdraw your motion that's fine I withdraw my motion that's fine okay so what's the motion so could you repeat that again did you get it I got it okay repeat it a motion to authorize the the the District administration to prepare a letter requesting the township to install sidewalks within the 2 mile radius from the school facilities where they're missing sidewalks okay and we have a second second for that all right any questions comments and this I do have questions this is for every school

051we're asking them okay okay good okay um I guess we could take a roll call and just for further explanation there is a reserve fund that the township has with available funds for these sidewalks isn't that correct that's correct that is correct and to respond to miss deo's uh question I believe within the available funding in other words if the uh if you're trying to put sidewalks onto the high school I don't think the funding may or may not be adequate So within the available resources we won't explore what can be done okay yeah because you don't know okay I just want to make one comment I think in the future if this is possible I think when Builders submit plans for developments those plans have to include sidewalks those plans have to include roads

052that are wide enough for school buses to go in and I've said this before make u-turns because we've had problems I last year especially uh with uh and rightfully so people coming in the colder sacks the buses couldn't make the turns and they had to be out on forsgate road it's a highly traveled and dangerous road we need the township to um really think about this when build a submit plans for future developments Mr rayback I think I mentioned this several times and I'm going to repeat myself one more time that the planning board does not give waivers to sidewalks either we ask the developer to do the sidewalks or at least contribute to fund where the sidewalks are being I'm not I'm not asking about the planning board when a when a builder submits

053a plan he submits it to the Town Council first if I'm not mistaken no it goes to the engineer then comes to the planning board they don't do an impact analysis to the planning C to the Town Council that's what they should do but I believe they I believe they not to the coun I thought they did no but I and um I can be corrected if I'm mistaken but also just so the this our citizens know that that fund is contributed to by the developer if they are not going to build no if they are not going to build the sidewalk they will put money into the fund I believe for use however I agree and I've been say stating that and and actually citizens of Monroe who go to the planning board and

054zoning boards are very vocal often enough about um requesting that sidewalks be put in so think it it it's incumbent upon citizens as well just like they come here to the Board of Education that they go to the planning board especially when when a big development's coming up because inevitably if there's not going to be a school there there may be one soon and um I think at this point in the development of Monroe we're sadly in my personal opinion we're no longer a rural community we're more like a Suburban to getting close to urbanizing um and I think think that um we're going to need sidewalks just about everywhere we agree I mean whatever the process is when the plans go in right which have agency plans have instead of the instead of the

055citizens having to compensate for it down the road when the builders have um you know taken their profits out of the community I think it's time that they they put those sidewalks in now uh any other discussion I guess we can take a vote now Mr yes sir Mr blurry yes Mrs armeno yes Mrs Deo yes Mrs Lang yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr rutsky yes Mrs seagull yes Mr Tano yes Mr board president motion passes unanimously thank you okay uh now we can move on to item number nine which is public forum let me just state that this portion is for agenda items only you have four minutes at the microphone uh I respectfully ask that you uh respect and H that time limit anybody from the public would like to address the agenda yes

056just state your name and address please for the record good evening my name is Claudia Lunen and I live at 136 Bank Street in Redbank with me here tonight is my husband Jeff and our daughter Sienna tonight I have come here with my family because on the agenda you will be voting to accept my resignation the reason for my resignation is not because I haven't loved working in in this district for the past 3 years but rather because in May our family grew with the addition of our beautiful daughter Sienna teaching has always been my calling but at least for now I have a different calling and that is to finally be a mother I say finally because our road to meet Sienna has been a long and at times painful one but today I

057stand Here complete and that road has now faded in the distance behind us my name might sound familiar because you have already voted on my original parental leave request while these leave requests are often and routinely voted on mine was unique because our daughter was born through surrogacy I recognized that this request was complicated by the fact that we might have been the first family in the history of Monroe employees to have become parents through the gift of surrogacy however I assure you we won't be the last this is the reason I'm here tonight Over The Last 5 Years my journey to Motherhood has included eight rounds of IVF nine miscarriages hundreds of hormone injections two surgeries four egg retrievals three dnc's and mental trauma that I'm still working to recover from these unsuccessful attempts

058at pregnancy led me to pursue gestational surrogacy out of medical necessity I am here to urge this board to adopt a policy that expands upon the classification of maternity leave requests to be equally and wholly inclusive of surrogacy maternity leave is defined as a period of absence from work granted to a mother before and after the birth of her child you see for me when I first read that I was being granted leave under the term child rearing as opposed to the set policy of traditional maternity leave it made me feel as though my journey to Motherhood was not equal or as whole as any other expecting mother despite expressing this to the C office administration the wording and designated benefits were not changed for me little things like being told I was not allowed

059to use my sick days because I wasn't physically pregnant despite the fact that I had to attend every single doctor's appointment with my surrogate for me it felt belittling and dismissive of my journey it is this feeling I hope no other teacher and expecting mother ever has to feel but I'm not here to litigate the past like I said I'm now officially complete and the rocky road behind me has faded away but that same road lies ahead for many women and some might just end up teaching in Monroe and you have the power here to make that road just a little less painful and a little more fair please as a mother and always as a teacher please see that this is fixed thank you thank you and congratulations so thank you very much anyone

060else from the public prakash purup 33 Dana Drive first of all in the agenda I noted that Mr gal is living us as a principal so I would like to the item is here on page seven and U mostly I'd like to appreciate Mr gal's contributions towards our high school you know he he was very approachable and what level he has brought up the school so we have to appreciate and acknowledge that and also going to the other topics of today's discussions really appreciate lot of good things happening in the committee meetings and thank you all the chairs of the committee meeting for giving the reports thoroughly thank you for taking out of the box thinking many of the time so please continue to do that um because of 4 minutes I have very few

061comments and some questions the air conditioning in the Middle School will not be working and you know that is the concern you all know that I'm not you all are expert the mold the mold development will take place and then we spend lot of of money so humidity control has to be taken into consideration so I request immediately engineering to look into it act on it before it takes its own action and regarding the advocacy advocacy I know that uh the letter has been published uh posted so I'll read it but also four things of two things are very impact important that we have been lobing for impact Fe on Builders towards the school that is the number one the resolution was passed by the Board of Education also the council and we public request

062you all to lobby for that it is a high hanging fruit but let's start it and secondly there are three bills on special education so we uh in public are lobing for that I request the Boe is lobing for that I hope it is there in the posted letter then coming to 2020 2021 trailers I'll tell you before you take action in September there is a committee going on what are the new plans so be careful because there are several ideas we may not need trailers we have to think out of the box so before you jump to the conclusion there are many ways we can redistribute the students and you can see many of the proposals are coming by 31st so please read those proposals which are coming in okay so jump don't jump

063in and order trailers for 2021 because we want to know actual growth of the students and how we can manage them okay so that is the request regarding the sidewalks the comment again I'll be talking to the council and I'll be going there with friends I think when the Builder builds it is requirement that that sidewalks are there okay I went to Europe they use bicycles we don't have bicycle tracks here let the people in the community have sidewalk to walk if they want to walk outside and it be good to have sidewalks throughout our Township in the builders are building 30 seconds sir thank you uh so just Lobby for that and I don't think anything else I congratulate and happy that most of the committee members your reports thank you very much thank

064you very much anybody else from the public please state your name and address yes my name is Pradip mam at 4 Jake place thank you um so regarding the subcommittees I don't see any meetings of the subcommittee meetings are being published in in board dos that's my first point why can't we have the minutes of the meetings that are being publicly available on board dogs the agendas on board do I believe the agendas are on board dos agenda is on the board but not the meeting minutes the minutes of the we have we have a meeting coming up on the 30th of July no the he means the minutes for the committee meetings oh oh the committee meeting meetings yeah I aren they okay this is the lack of the transparency because most of the

065items are being discussed very widely and the background of that particular items will be in the subcommittees and they are coming as a line items in into the public here why can't we have the video recordings of the subcommittees I don't understand why can't we have the second question is even the minutes of meeting of the Boe meeting they are coming out as yes no and who opposed who accepted or who voted yes for that particular meeting but there is no cross question details there is no comments details are being published they might be videotaped but they are not being published thoroughly so not finished I know go ahead go ahead it's okay go ahead and I schemed through all the minutes of the meetings from the September meeting of last year I didn't see

066any closure session details have been revealed so when are they will be revealed so every time you go to closure session you will read a standard statement that it will be available publicly when it is appropriate when is the appropriate time and why can't you guys record the closure sessions if you don't have time and resources to document the closure sessions why can't you record it and whenever it is appropriate upload it we can watch it at our own time uh if you don't have money for these transparency acts you can get it from other resources like your Atlantic trip uh finally I have one straight question there was a a specific um meeting regarding the media person relations I have a question question to the Boe who publishes on the Facebook Monroe Falcons page

067could you say again who publishes what on who maintains and publishes the post on Monroe Falcon's page I know it's the board president or the superintendent that does that yeah but in in the recent events somebody answered a public question here asked in the in the Monro Facebook page can we take that as the board stand not if it's not been published by the board president or the board or the superintendent then if it's a if it's a Community member I would say I I'm not sure I I don't know what what would be written there is that an official page for our Board of Education and our Township educ our school district a Facebook page yes there's a man ran School District Facebook page yes yes if somebody posts on that particular page not

068as a comment but as a post if somebody posts there can we take that as a our school district standing on that particular topic no why can't because that it's not the school district posting it's someone commenting on a school district I I'm not talking about comments I'm talking about the posting posting nobody can post other than one or of the particular page the school district posts it yes it's a school district post but if someone comments on it I would say no is your policy somewhere stating that the answers are asked by the public are being discussed on the Facebook page are you going to answer all the questions that are being asked there that that's a discussion that I haven't had a chance to have with the Board of Education because that is

069a 247 job for someone to do so I don't know what the answer to the that is yet your time is up thank you very much but I'm expecting some kind of behavior some kind of recordings and meeting minutes for the subcommittees and detailed meeting minutes if not I'm going to take it this to the code that is happened if you guys remember in 201 we'll do the best we can anybody else Roger man 22 haragan Avenue um I had a couple questions first I was at the same planning board as Mr poori and I don't remember anybody saying go ahead and uh take this to the school board and have it voted on um the places you're talking about putting sidewalks are front doors 14 ft from a curb you put a sidewalk in

070a grass apron and then a little another grass apron Aon you might as well have people walking through the living rooms of those homes these homes have been there for a hundred years these are not new construction these were beach bungalows and they swam in the lake over at the American Legion in the 20s okay there is no reason to be talking about putting sidewalks in places where people have paid $3 to $5,000 to have the front of their house paved with asphalt in order to park in something that isn't mud and to take that and to put it somewhere else okay that my area and I'm the only one if there's anybody here who lives north of First Avenue raise your hand okay so I'm the only one I don't see anybody from my

071neighborhood asking for sidewalks Woodland receives one courtesy bus for that area okay to put sidewalks in would cost Millions you'd have to rerun the sewers you'd have to put them in a different place and then are you going to go with Force mains you going to go with gravity Mains what are you going to do there because they just ran all the new utilities five years ago that the township and the county put money into you know there's a lot more than just yeah let's pop sidewalks in and I do believe Mr Asimo it said something like we'll have to look into it into the future there was no direction to take it to the school board for a vote to put in sidewalks and neighborhoods and if there is I'd like the minutes produced

072from that planning board meeting saying so my only other question was we're now using durm School service for busing how much cheaper were they than Mercy I don't have the difference between Durham and mercy but I will tell you that it went out to bid through the middle sex Regional head service commission and they were deemed to be the lowest bidder so we're required to accept that bid okay cuz my fear I mean I know that Mercy wasn't all hot but they kind of got their routes under control after a couple months and learned it now we're bringing in a new skull bus service and we're going to run into the same problems of people not knowing their stops where to go and everything else and the delays happening that we heard about when mercy

073first came aboard so I'm kind of thinking you know sometimes saving a couple bucks here or there is going to cost us a lot more down the road as far as aggravation but you know that's just my input on that it's already contracted I don't know what the cost difference would be but all right but the sidewalk thing I mean I was at the planning board meeting and I even spoke there and there was no you know go ahead take it to a vote at the school board and see what they say that was not said one time thanks thank you thank you anyone else yeah my name is Charlie depiro I am a councilman in Monroe Township I'm a fire commissioner and I'm a resident 404 Spotswood Gravel Hill Road I'm speaking as a

074resident um as reference to the sidewalk um there's a board member on the planning board here that made a statement that no no funds have been waved he just went through a subdivision called the longgo property that no funds were received and no sidewalks are being being done and that's close to your Oak Tree schools and your appleg guard school this property there's another one on this road called Gina Ker's property right across the street from the park that no money was was given to the town for waivers in fact Walter Toto the attorney made it clear when he came there he used those subdivisions that he went through and used used them as an example as a councilman I pushed hard to get that $547,000 freed up as for the taxpayers and the board

075and the mayor agreed and we did it we got it accomplished we put in sidewalks on on ellingham Avenue and it was $130,000 in a change order that money was allocated ated at $547,000 towards that project also we just did another project called Daniel Road and Daniel Ryan Fields same thing so I've sent numerous emails to our Township attorney and I'm still waiting to see if this money that you guys are requesting from the mayor and counsel be used for sidewalks for schools okay you went through a subdivision called Devonshire right next to Brookside school with no sidewalks Mr Gorski knows what I'm talking about had no sidewalks the Board of Ed had to put sidewalks from Devonshire to Brookside he just went through Gary fouser subdivision which you guys are well aware of no

076sidewalk in the culdesac only a sidewalk on 522 so I think when when Jay Brown was on the board and he was on the planning board I think that's something that you guys should be looking at instead of looking at the town to mop up the planning board waivers as he sits on that planning board and he and they Grant waivers which he's saying that it wasn't done I can give him more examples because I've been here for over 50 years and I watched them give waivers and no money exchanged and leaving the taxpayers to pay the bill it's happening with the infrastructure with traffic lights as he's supporting the traffic light by my house there's 10 different developers that came and gone and that one penny was was allocated for that $1.7 million Improvement

077so I'm supporting the sidewalks I'm supporting moving the money towards it I've asked the township attorney I'm waiting for a response I'm waiting for a response if they can allocate that money to help the school board put up sidewalks for the children safety but however I I I put the question back on the planning board members why are you granting waivers there should be no waivers let's stick to the master plan let's build what we say we're going to build thank you thank you anyone else Chrissy scurby 21 pness Drive uh before I begin I just want to be clear that my comments are not directed toward Mr trano Mr Sharell or Miss armino I am utterly disappointed that the resignation of Mr Goodall is on the agenda tonight since coming to Monroe in 2005

078m Mr Goodall has proven to be an administrator for the kids the staff parents students alike have so much admiration and respect for Mr Goodall he's done so much to move our district forward for our students this year alone he has helped so many for the special needs to to make so many strides for the special needs students that have positively changed their lives last year the Board of Ed voted unanimously to appoint Mr Goodall as Acting Superintendent he came in with the full support of the community parents staff and students and we had a great year under his leadership in this District the board then voted to not conduct an external search for superintendent and interviewed only two internal candidates it was all done secretively the public was not involved the teachers union was

079not involved no Administration was involved only you the Board of Ed members While most thought it was a slam dunk that Mr Goodall would be appointed superintendent based on his outstanding year he served as acting and his many years of service as princip no one wanted to believe that the personal agendas would Prevail we have a school district that isn't led by what is right for the students we don't look at what will help students get into better colleges we care about personal vendettas and personal agendas Mr Goodall came in as Acting Superintendent and his first job was to get rid of a parent group I founded at the middle school you people spent a year fighting parents of a parent group instead of focusing on what was truly important Mr Goodall gave a great

080speech to the graduating seniors this year at graduation he spoke about loyalty to co-workers and colleagues I know the board of EV members present couldn't hear the speech on stage but I recommend you go back and listen you can learn something from it because you lack any sort of loyalty you are about back room deals political opportunities and self-gain Mr Goodall didn't get appointed superintendent because his moral compass points in the right direction and you couldn't get him to change that while myself and many in our school and Community will miss Mr goodle I wish him well and I am happy that he will be rid of you people and your lies secret plans and unethical practices I can only hope that we will all witness a day when the universe writes the wrongs that

081you have caused I don't know how any of you can look yourselves in the mirror knowing how you have caused so much discourse in our district anyone else from the public he's always a gentleman oh how very nice of him he didn't see me hiding back there uh Gail depay 356c old Nassau drive just a couple of quick questions um I'm used to seeing board minutes a lot uh do you have you guys had a lot of great committee reports tonight very thorough very great to listen to uh do you have a student services uh committee here in this District where they handle only student issues because it was I'm I'm regarding that closed session one we don't have do you have a a you don't have a we don't have a student okay I

082I think it's a good idea to put one together that can handle some of these things outside and then you don't have to bring them back and people like the gentleman said he had to wait for a resolution so I don't know if that needed an attorney or not I know some do some don't but some of them can be handled on a board level through a student services committee and then that Committee just reports like you guys all did tonight but you I mean great job up another one is on page eight um Mrs Dow is going to check your defibrillators and you're it's so much I just want to know how many defibrillators in this district and how long does it take to check a defibrillator it depends on the school it's difficult

083to answer I I know we have multiple defibulators located in the schools we also have mobile defibrillators for the athletics department uh to bring on a golf court in casee an emergency ever happens we have them in all public buildings okay uh staff are trained on them they're regularly serviced um but I couldn't give you an exact number on how many okay well just curious to see somebody was doing that for the and then one big question too on all your resignations and um all the people that are leaving to me I'm not used to just seeing a name and resignation and this and that usually it would say how much time they had left and how much it's costing you for that person to leave or resign from this District so that the public

084can see how much it's going to cost the board of education for that person how many years did they have left 25 that's a lot of money you're getting from this District I'm just saying it's not transparent enough to list all the people that are resigning and retiring and everything without putting the years in r and the expense that it cost you to pay them to leave I mean I think that's something that everybody should see well we do celebrate people who are retiring um but it's not in your but it's not in your board minutes not the celebration the part of how much it cost this district for that person to retire well I certainly would defer to the superintendent on this but I think some of this may fall on a Personnel type

085thing right it's a Personnel issue and I don't think um it's anything that should be hidden should be transparent I think it's a it's something the public should see am I right um Miss superintendent I'm not sure I'd have to check on that we've never done it in the past you've never I just want to know if you've done it before I'm not exactly sure what you're what you're referring to what it like what we would pay out someone who the district yes yes I think that's a Personnel issue I don't think that's something that we can disclose it is I've been on a board that disclosed it and people could see how much these people are getting as they retire they they get it because they're it's part of their contract exactly cont but

086we it was public on in public minutes so I just want to know could somebody just look into it to see if that could be more transparent um for everybody in the public to see we'll look into it thank you very much thank you good evening uh Doug poy for tamarak Road uh my questions or comments concern the uh harassment intimidation and bullying report that was given earlier this evening uh I had difficulties see in the screen but it appeared to me that the number of cases was significantly higher for the same period compared to last year uh so I was a little concerned about that and I was just wondering what might be the cause uh and the reason I I have that concern is because I was speaking to a former colleague of

087mine who is a principle at a also a very large High School who indicated that uh that high school was experiencing a significant increase in cases of uh like this where there's a lack of Civility um I was wondering also and you don't necessarily have to answer that question but it's something to think about uh how do we engage the parents of those students that are uh found to have committed this lack of Civility toward their uh fellow classmates uh if if we're not doing something to involve the parent and it I don't think we can necessarily expect the student uh to make the necessary adjustments that they don't continue to uh commit such acts uh and then finally and I don't know if they exist but are there any legal recourses available to the

088school district uh for students who uh commit more than one such uh Act of uh lack of Civility toward fellow students uh I just feel that when one student suffers from harassment intimidation or bullying it has such a negative impact not only on that student's self-esteem but also on that student's ability to learn and uh I I don't think that this is something that you know we can just gloss over give a report and I'm not trying to say that that's all you've done tonight it's just give a report to give the report uh but I I would ask that we look into involving the parent more in those cases uh try to determine why there's been such an increase compared to previous years and have other high schools experience that as well and then

089finally do we have any legal recourses can we take them to Municipal Court uh the parents are that student and uh that might bring a little bit more to Bear upon uh students that commit those acts and the word we get around that hey this is not something you want to engage in uh there are consequences that are quite severe more than just maybe a suspension thank you thank you anyone anyone else from the public not seeing anyone else we'll close public forum and we're ready for number 10 superintendent report recommendation Dr Alvi yes so as it always is the high school graduation was a wonderful event celebrating our high school seniors so I would like to thank the high school administration and the staff members including Deb vano um for organizing it to run

090so smoothly and making it a true celebration um as you can see from the agenda we're continuing to interview and hire candidates for our open position so that we will be fully staffed in September um I want to congratulate Eileen Kelly who retired July 1st um she worked in the uh 40 years teaching in New Jersey public schools at the last 31 were here at the high school um as was mentioned already Mr Goodall has submitted a letter of resignation from Monroe I wish him all the best in his new role and thank him for all that he has done in the Monro Township High School and as as the acting super superintendent during the last year um we will work to fill his position with the best qualified candidate um I just wanted to

091do a quick report on the ad hoc committee I know that's come up a few times so the adoc committee has received 22 proposals to date um and we do have a meeting planned on July 30th 6:30 here in the media center to start reviewing the proposals as a committee so that we can decide on next steps for the committee um so um every Friday the committee gets a an email with any updated any additional proposals on the agenda this evening is our results from the New Jersey quality single accountability Continuum which is the New Jersey qac we spent the past year Gathering documents for all indicators for our site review we received a letter from the county office on June 27th that we've passed in all areas um I know fiscal management was already

092mentioned in finance so fiscal management governance and Personnel all received per perfect scores 100 out of 100 in operations we lost points in one area because although we conduct annual Transportation drills we did not have it board approved on the agenda we have since corrected that and it was shared with the visiting qac team but we did lose a couple of points there um for program and instructions we receiv received all points for our curriculum and our programs um they met all of the requirements that are needed for this for um the qac which includes modifications for all of our groups of students and all of U meeting all of the standards uh for the first half of the program and instructions the state actually calculates points in the assessment and the graduation areas so

093it's based on our um Park scores it's based on the percentage of students taking the park it's based on our attendance scores and our graduation rate we received 46.8 points out of 60 which gave us an 87 in program and instruction the requirement is above an 80% in all areas so the State letter will be available on the district website tomorrow with that information I've also received several questions about freshman orientation since it was cut from the budget I'm actually meeting with the High School administration tomorrow to see how we can ensure that students will get a chance to tour the school prior to the first day um to make them feel more comfortable as they're coming into the school and the high school administration will communicate any plan to parents and freshmen once it's

094been finalized question yes cusac in the past we've had a waiver for qac because of our high scores no what happens is every five years we're required to have the site visit in between that we just do a statement of assurance where we give them our information um but every five years they're required to come in now qac changed this year there were different indicators um so it was a different process we're the fir we're they have three cohorts in um middle sex County we were in the first cohort to go through the new process okay thank you I have a question just for clarification did you say that we are going to reinstate a high school orientation this year nope I did not say that we are looking at ways that we can make

095sure that students can come and visit the high school before the first day okay thank you yes so it is recommended that the board approve the attached Personnel items a through a n and is a Nancy move second okay any questions comments Mr Mayo second any questions comments a quick question question to Dr alwick uh you said that you received 21 or 22 proposals so far 22 22 22 now when you receive them do you submit them as they are all of them to the ad hoc committee or do you filter any of those I do not filter any they the only thing I do is I take out the email address that it came from and any name that's on there or phone number or address because some people have put that on there

096and then I put them together in a packet and I send them the entire packet to the ad hoc Committee in for the couple of weeks there it's been so busy for me I had didn't even have a chance to read them before I sent them out okay 100% of The Proposal that you're getting from public are being transmitted to the ad hoc committee yes there there is one currently right now in the email in the ad hoc email that will go out to the committee on Friday thank you anybody else Mr G Mr Tano yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr rutsky yes Mrs Lang yes Mr poori yes Mrs armenio yes on everything abstain on R so noted Mrs eagel yes Mrs Deo yes Mr board president Personnel items have passed thank you okay it

097is recommended that the board approve board action items a through o I have oh is it a3p or my gen is a3p what's P I believe it CH I believe it's p it's p I'm sorry okay so board action items a through P um can you tell I I think I might have yeah I don't have P you have o also you have o no I have it but that's what I'm saying what what on the new agenda what page are second p is the Service Commission New Jersey representative team so last month that was I was appointed as the um person but it's the different name so we just changed the title of the name but that's not the question what page are you on from eight I think I might have um abstained

098on the wrong thing that's why I well this is a different this is a different understand that because I thought I it starts over again at oh I see what you're saying did you just tell me the page please I don't have page numbers on mine it ends at page 18 we're on page 18 I don't have you obained on r that was R under Personnel right we're now under board action which starts at a again but I I think it I have the wrong we could are under Personnel that's incorrect Mr um yes so let it be noted for the minutes that Mrs Armenia wishes to change her abstention by deleting it there will be no abstention on item are so she votes affirmatively on all items yes so noted okay so now go

099to what your you have the v action now for some many on yes and I do need to abstain on something so I have to find it page 16 17 and Mrs Bo AC Pages 16 through just call me last and I'll figure it out well do we have a motion so moved you have a second we have a second second okay now we can have discussion or questions any discussion no question so repeat that again a through what a through p p so you have a you're going to have a question on this no I don't have a question just I have to find what I have to abstain at that's all okay so you can call the vote you can call the vote okay uh this is board action items a through P

100Mrs seagull yes yes Mr rutsky yes Mrs Deo yes Mr Tano uh yes and no on h no on H so noted Mr chory yes Mr Rybeck yes Mrs Lang this one it was and we conclude with Mrs AR no you can all vote Yes on everything I might have I have to change my phote back again on the first one Mr board president and board action items a through P has passed unanimously thank you and now we're up to you Mr business administ that concludes my superintendent report yes thank you Mr board president and Dr Alvi um before I get to my business administrator report I certainly would like to thank Mr Goodall for his 15 years of collaboration here in the district um we were through many diff different uh District crises and

101and challenges together uh Mr Goodall just from my recollection was responsible from the time that the the locker room sexual assault hit the news years ago uh to immediately reacting to inspect ours and making sure that our ours were all fortified and properly uh monitored by staff um he also very creatively handled the student protest where students were were planning on walking out of the high school and instead of having students just walk out in a in a chaotic um disorderly manner he worked it out with them that the administration would be supporting them walking around the track together and students uh expressed themselves constitutionally which they have the right and uh it was very supervised and they all returned to school um in his Acting Superintendent role it was a pleasure to serve with

102Mr Goodall through the creation of the budget which was very challenging and he offered some very creative ideas to um spread resources in in different areas and it was a pleasure serving with him and I wish him the best um they they they have a fine School administrator transitioning to um manisan schools so I wish him the best and also I'd be remissed if I didn't also Express as the board secretary a great deal of appreciation for Mr Al hadinger for all of his help with the Board of Education uh Mr Al hadinger handled all of the audio for the school district which was very challenging at times we had different microphones and um and uh you know the public appreciates I'm sure all of the board meetings and the clear audio that he was

103partially responsible for and uh and also his Services here as a a a teacher so Mr Gorski before you go on and I don't I I would imagine Robert's Rules allows me to correct a vote okay so I figured out um on the first Personnel item it happens to be 8 of 23 but it is you I abstain on you so the okay let it be noted for the minutes that for personnel items Mrs arminio votes yes on everything and abstains on you yes and I also got confused with that and I'd like to change my vote to H from no to yes on that h on H yeah that's on the board um Mr teeno voted no on letter h under board action items a through p and let it be reflected in the

104minutes that you uh resend your vote as no and vote Yes on all items correct so noted thank you sorry to about the confusion no problem to your report yes sir Mr board president and members of the monor Township Board of Education it is recommended that board action items a through M be approved by consent roll call so moved the second second we have a second second any discussion comments questions a through so I have a question sure how do we come to find on on A6 how do we come to find somebody in woa Hawaii to be our primary drill designer and are we paying for his travel expenses that's excellent question Mr chair um I'm Phil designer just like a choreographer and know we're not paying for their expenses that's a little bit

105of a schap from but good for him good for us I'll pick them up okay that was a good catch okay Mrs seagull Mr yes but I recuse for myself only on letter H Mr Rybeck I vote Yes but I recuse for myself on letter H as well Mrs Deo yes but I recuse for myself only on letter H Mrs Lang yes and recuse for Lang on letter H Mr plur yes and I recuse myself on H Mrs armino yes and recuse on H Mr rutsky yes on everything including letter h Mr Tano yes on everything no on eight Mr board president board action items a through M has passed that concludes my report thank you thank you very much um right now we're uh item 13 Other Board of Education I'm sorry board president

106report I got my report uh just very briefly I'd like to remind all uh board board of education members that uh we have to uh complete the board self- evaluation uh that's due July 31st uh it's uh on New Jersey School Board website but when you go on I'd like to advise you to uh It'll ask you for your District Please spell out Monroe spell out Township if you put TW WP it will um get you to the glower County Monroe Township but if you spell out Township it uh it'll get to middlex County so please spell that out and I appreciate you uh completing this uh onor before the 31st of July and um that completes my report for today so uh we have other board of education business Mr rutsky if I could

107I just wanted to clarify one thing from my finance committee meeting report earlier about the uh air conditioning unit at the middle school so for the record and correct me if I'm wrong Mr Gorski there's two air conditioning units at the at the middle school we're having difficulty with one unit the other unit will do its best job to keep as much of the school cold as possible correct Mr President that that's absolutely correct we have we have two units um one failed right before Middle School graduation which could explain why it felt a little bit warm in there it will feel a little bit warm operating on one unit uh hopefully as somebody mentioned before we have a a cooler September we are Expediting the installation of the new Chiller as soon as possible

108but we're required to go through the public bidding process to protect the taxpayer's interest in buying the unit at the lowest competitive price and the bidding timetable and everything will take us till about October until it's completed and installed gotcha so I just wanted there is one unit so I just wanted to clarify that and if I may just for Mr Po's sake so I looked at the the the report on the Hib and it's not a same time comparison it's the first six months of this year which is a full six months of school and and the last 6 months of last year which is really only four months of school so that could in effect have something to do with the dispar the this disparity of the numbers so I just wanted to

109point that out thank you you're welcome anybody else I also want to clarify on the side walks Mr amini came up about uh specific concern about his own house I don't think the funding is available to take any RightWay impact so if there is going to be a sidewalk that's going to be put it's going to be put in an area where it's feasible and it's practical anybody else go ahead go ahead goad Miss L did you I was just clarifying we're on new board business other other board business other board go ahead okay I would I would just like to make a plea once again to my colleagues that we and I appreciate all of the public input and every uh all the ad hoc committees again talking about our need for uh School

110Construction um however I would like to make a plea to get a referendum as soon as possible um we if we keep delaying it's just going to be more difficult to uh move forward uh you know I would I would actually suggest um that since the first referendum and I know everybody wants the the high school but since the first referendum only failed by 143 votes we might consider at least just to get that same information up and put it out there again and then of course work on the high school um that's not to diminish our needs for the high school but I would like us to start reconsidering at least getting something uh going some construction some some shovels in the ground for our children so that's I I don't know if it's

111thinking out of the box or bringing the old box back and taking a look into it again but let's do something we can't keep delaying and again I appreciate every person who's giving up their free time and all the 22 ideas that are out there but we know what we need we have to get it done and I'd like us to reconsider getting it on the ballot as soon as possible all I to say thank you just echoing U the comments that Mr arminia made uh I I think there got to be a timeline that's set up for the ad hoc committee so that it's not in it's peret an end date absolutely and and also uh I suggest strongly for the board to consider having a open public meeting not just necessarily focus on

112uh the in the the plans that we're receiving but also to seek the public input once we get to a phase where we're ready to present the 22 uh ideas that uh the proposal that came on board I think it should be inviting to the public to come and express their views on what should be the next uh steps to be taken for our district well sure the ADOT committee will be discussing that and um but where that happens and the time that's that's really up to the committee well that's the problem keep leaving 30 days and 30 days it turns into 60 days it turns into 6 months it turn turn turns into a year we really need to get this I mean it we just can't keep delaying it because we have to

113have another discussion I again I respect the the discussion but we've been discussing it for 10 years I'm not disputing that i' like to see it done quickly an end date would be great Patty goes first oh I'm sorry no I was clarifying where we were so I have a question for dor sure um Dr alvic I'm sorry um Dr alvic you you touched ba you touched uh base on on uh High School somewhat of a high school orientation um a lot of parents are concerned about that U they feel that CH child's going to have a lot of anxiety um starting to the big school um can you just give a little more detail on what you had in mind or I don't have any detail yet I'm meeting with the administration tomorrow okay

114thank you m Mr mail um I just wanted to thank um Claudia Lunen for sharing her deeply personal story with us I'm sure it wasn't easy for her to to do this in such a public forum and I want to thank you and maybe Patty can take a look at the policy and we can address that made a note thank you okay do we have to make a motion for that no not at all no I I I happen to agree I think that's a a very today kind of a topic and something that we we need to uh take a look at I agree and congratulations again on you beautiful baby okay uh any other board member for okay in that case we can go to the public forum uh this time you're not

115limited to the agenda but you still have four minutes I ask that you uh give your name and your address prash up 33 uh Data Drive the freshman orientation is very important if the child is coming to the high school the freshman orientation must be done there is no compromise in it okay so this is a strong statement because the children are entering into high school so it is a gateway and it is so important there's a stress as well as happiness so they get a clear idea so I request Board of Education and administration to think over it okay tomorrow's decision so I don't know when it will be posted when the public will come to know what decision was taken so I would like to request tomorrow's decision when it it will be

116posted somewhere the high school administration will notify parents and students when a decision is made okay when the decision is made when the Orient orentation is suppose it was there when it was supposed to be scheduled when orientation occurs just in August or September before the school starts before school starts so so the parents will be informed okay like to hear about it in next uh Boe meeting the the second question the school you know State funding it is this year we received about $63,000 6 $630,000 something more this year that's the question yeah I believe that's correct the lot of information is available on the website I would tell everybody from the public to take a look so what was given to us in March whatever before the budget session same money is allotted

117to us not a penny more or that is correct um uh per cash is a I believe referencing last year we got a post budget adoption award we have not received anything yet um we'll certainly notify the finance committee if something comes this year the last two years I think we did but I think the state has already decided isn't it this is what the governor signed it and that's the money other than that $50 million for special education I saw wi gopal Senator wi gopal announcing about that there was the $50 million under the 2020 Appropriations act uh that was dedicated toward emergency aid and also extraordinary which we talked about before but that's the only additional Aid that we've been notified about I just beg you all again the special education is a

118low hanging frood I talked to Senator assembly Benson and others they're fully supportive of it just push for it so those bills are approved by December then they said what I heard is they need about $200 million to make sure that money is there therefore if those bills are approved so I reest you all push for those bills for special education I have already written to you all on June 10th a letter was written to you all I didn't receive any uh reply on this so whenever the public writes to all cites the bill at least say received and will act on it or you'll don't act on it so that those bills if we passed I tell you I'll guarantee you next year we'll get at least 5 to6 million more okay so that

119is the the 30 seconds huh 30 seconds Sir 30 seconds remaining okay thank you and adoc committee another one thing just just don't jump to the referendum the ad committee there are 22 22 proposals are come more proposals will come only thing I request Bo tell the adoc committee there should be some timelines what I heard that out of all the proposals four proposals will be selected and the four proposals will be presented to the public and everyone and one will be selected so please develop a timeline for that thank you very much time's up thank you very much Roger mey 22 haragan a I just had a quick question and I want I meant to ask it earlier and uh slipped my mind are we in any discussion with Jamesburg about the 1.6 million

120they owe the district Mr President yes um as previously reported there is an agreement a legally binding agreement that was approved by the Department of Education between the two districts a few years ago and it sets forth a plan which in in short recognizes that Monro per pupil costs at the high school level are decreasing because our budget is capped our Appropriations are limited but our student enrollment at the high school is continually increasing Jamesburg when they have pinned their tuition rate at a previous level will eventually pass where Monroe's uh decreasing enrollment costs and then overpay through the budget that has come to fruition the last two years where Jamesburg has actually overpaid their tuition through the budget and that has been applied against the aage the aage was at its high point about

1211.9 million it's down to about 1.6 million now we are very confident that it will be satisfied within the terms of the agreement and Jamesburg has even been more aggressive than the agreement's requirement by paying paying and estimating more students in the budget than required and making uh excess Surplus payments uh toward the reage also so they're knocking off about 100K a year at least and and it it is expected to compound where the overpayment through the budget will actually increase every year thus reducing the uh reage more sharply over the next couple years I just find it strange that the state should dictate our terms when we're in a financial bind in the state isn't doing anything to help us why we're listening to them it just it baffles me you know I I

122know you guys are discussing seing the state and everything else and one one thing I even said to Mr POI one night I said when does it become cheaper just not to send money to them and let them sue us we send them 45 million we get 2 million back we'd spend less in court you know something to think about thank you Mr anyone else in the public that's an uh Chrissy scurby 21 pness Drive uh I heard it mentioned in the beginning of the meeting um is it a policy that kindergarteners don't have homework that could you say is it a policy I I I couldn't hear all the way in the back is it a policy that our kindergarten students don't get homework can me answer that yeah sure when we rote the

123policy um so yes it is a policy um in the regulations of the policy it talks about um kindergarten the teachers give um reading they give some some assignments but it's the way that the report card listed it was students turn in homework on time the kindergarten teacher said because they do things like it's the whole week that it didn't make sense to do that put that under learner Behavior so they they're not given homework as a third or fourth grader are given homework they're given reading they're given some some practice things but yes it is in the regulation that there's no homework or that not that there's no homework that there's no homework just heard somebody's phone on the report card it's an alert yes that's that's what we're changing we're not changing any

124practices we're changing the that we're getting rid of that wording on the report that's okay so the teachers are allowed to assign homework yes we're not changing any practices we're just changing the wording on the report card okay thank you mhm I think we're getting alerts about a possible flash flood so I'm going to ask all of you I you certainly stay but when you drive home please be careful care anybody else from the public sure name and address for the Claudia lunin 136 Bank Street in Red Bank and I would just like to sincer L thank you for listening so openly to my story and being open to change and progress thank you so much thank you seeing no one else in the public we can move to our close session resolution be it

125resolved that the Board of Education of Township Monroe hereby moves to go into closed session in accordance with the Sunshine Law chapter 231 of the public laws of 1975 and JSA 10 colon 4-6 through 10 col 4 there 21 excuse me to discuss the following subjects harassment intimidation and bullying discussion regarding memorandum of agreement in connection with the new Collective negotiations agreement between the board and local local number 11 affiliated with the International Brotherhood of teamsters following Clos session action may be taken the discussion conducted in Clos session could be disclosed in public at such time as as the need for confidentiality no longer exist yes so mov so move have a second okay uh any discussion no all in favor say I all in favor okay we should be back in about 20 minutes

126so we are back in session um I do have a motion motion to approve the previously submitted memorandum of agreement between the Board of Education and the local number 11 affiliated with the International Brotherhood of teamsters for the period from July 1st 2019 through through June 30th 2024 memorandum of agreement the board president and the business administrator board secretary as the attesting witness are hereby authorized and directed to sign a collective negotiations agreement which incorporates the terms of the mo MOA the business administrator board secretary is hereby further authorized and directed to take all necessary steps to implement this action by the board of education so moved second second any discussion questions that catch Mr Gorski we could have a roll call and vote Mr Ryback yes Mr Lang yes Mrs Deo yes Mr Tano

127yes Mr poori yes Mrs armenio yes Mr rety yes Mr seagull yes Mr board president motion passes unanimously very good thank you all uh next schedule Board of Education uh meeting was uh is August 21st at 7M right here at Monroe Township High School uh I now make a motion to adjourn okay any uh questions comments all in favor Mr rusy can I get some some votes the contract sign are we in favor I need some votes all in favor right thank you I think that's unanimous this meeting is ajour

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.