CorpusRecord 133010

Monroe Township Board of Education Special Meeting 10.03.19

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Monroe Township School District
Date
2025-02-10
Location
Middlesex County, NJ
Material
Transcript
Extent
19,122 words · about 107 min
Collected
2026-06-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001the meeting of the Monroe Township Board of Education will come to order please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance I pled to the FL flag of the United States of America the for stands one nation God indivisible with liy and Justice all may we have a roll call Mr Gorski certainly Mrs armeno here Mrs Deo here Mrs Kono here Mrs Lang here Mr Masters he's not a board member not here yet take pardon thank you pardon Mr flurry here Mr Ryback here Mrs seagull here Mr Tano here and Mr ratsky here Madame board president you have a quarum present this evening thank you in accordance with the provisions of the New Jersey open public meetings law the Monro Township Board of Education has caused notice of this meeting to be published by having the date

002time and place thereof posted September 27th 2019 at all schools the home News Tribune cranberry press and filed with the clerk of the municipality thank you very much much before we get to this statutory oath I'd like to let everybody on the public know that we have a new face on our board table today we'd like to welcome Dr Layman who is now our assistant superintendent and we look forward to working with him so congratulations and welcome on the statutory oath now Mr Gorski yes well Mr Masters please now join me at the front of this table sorry Prem all right please repeat after me I Louis C Masters I Lou C Masters do solemnly swear or affirm do solemnly swear or affirm that I will support the Constitution of the United States that I

003will support the Constitution of the United States and the con ition of the state of New Jersey and the constitution of the state of New Jersey and that I will bear true faith and Allegiance and that I will bear true faith and allegiance to the same to the same and to the governments established and to the governments established in the United States and this state in the United States and this state under the authority of the people under the authority of the people so help me God so helpy God I I Louis C Masters l c Masters do solemnly swear or affirm do Solly swear or affirm that I possess the qualifications prescribed by law that I possess the qualifications prescribed by law law for the office of member of a board of education for

004the for the office of member of a board of education and that I will faithfully and that I will faithfully impartially impartially and justly and justly perform all the duties of that office perform all the duties of that office according to the best of my ability according to the best of my ability so help me God so help me God I I Lou C Masters Lou C Masters do solemnly swear or affirm do solemnly swear orm and declare and declare that I am not disqualified as a voter that I not disqualified as a voter pursuing to rs19 col 4-1 pursuant to rs19 4-1 and I am not disqualified to hold this office and that I'm not disqualified to hold this office due to a conviction of crime du a conviction of crime or offense listed

005in njsa 1881 12-1 or offense listing MJS 18a calling 12-1 so help me God so help me God congratulations [Applause] thank you congratulations Mr Masters and you have a seat and a a uh I believe we didn't even have to buy a new name tag so we saved the district some money it's a little old yeah that's okay so is mine um so welcome thank you okay at this time we will go to the approval of the minutes for the public Board of Education meeting of August 21st 2019 a motion and a second approved by Miss Mrs Lang and Mr Tano any additions or corrections to the minutes seeing none all in favor I opposed I Michelle Michelle armino is opposed abstain Mr Masters is abstaining recuse okay so at this time we have a

006couple of important presentations this evening um the first is from New Jersey School Board Association um one of the goals that Dr Ali would like to have this year is a strategic action plan without the community or involving the whole community and we have Maryann fredman from New Jersey school boards who is going to explain the process to us this evening good oh excuse me good evening everybody and thank you for having me in this evening um it's my pleasure to talk to you about our strategic planning process it's a dynamic process that's really going to assist the board and the district in moving forward and in developing plans for the next 3 to five years so we'll talk a little bit about what strategic planning is what the advantages are how to be a

007part of the process and then any questions that you might have mic so I'm sorry I think you need to be closer to the mic is that better yes okay thank you so strategic planning really is creating a vision and a mission for this for the district that's with the um cooperation and the collaboration of your community members and your stakeholder groups it is a ground up process not a top down process and I always suggest to boards because this is a leap of faith um pretty much because you're not really sure what your community and your stakehold groups will come up with that if you're not willing to not only invite folks in to participate in this process but then truly listen to what they have to say that that wouldn't be a process

008for you so I'm part of this process is the commitment of the Board of Education to not only invite folks in from your stakeholder groups but also to listen to what they have to say and Implement those things and in that way everybody's working together towards the betterment of the district so some of the advantages are at allow you to be more proactive a lot of times today boards are being more reactive because of all of the things that come down to us from Trenton and this really gives you the opportunity to be proactive because you're planning over a 3 to 5e period it allows the board to be creative and Innovative it's a planning process that somewhat flexible in that the board always retains the authority to rep prioritize things in terms of when

009they will happen it is a plan that will take you over the next 3 to 5 years so everyone needs to recognize that everything can't happen in year one which is what everybody pretty much wants to happen because everything's exciting and you want it all to happen but you'll need to be able to build up resources for some of the things to be able to occur it provides a really good participation of a cross-section of your community members and your stakeholder groups and it provides an ongoing planning process for you your District goals will really be derived from the strategic planning goals once they're set and once they're adopted by the board it also allows you to optimize your limited resources we know today more than ever that school districts really do have limited resources

010you have tremendous amounts of mandates and the resources that you have are fairly limited and it also helps to increase communication because at least once a year we will recommend that you have a state-of the strategic planning report out to your community members anybody that has participated in the process moving forward it also helps to provide clear decision-making paths for the Board of Education because you know and you really do have your finger on the pulse of what your community members aspirations for your students are and it helps to create a dis a a districtwide mission and vision for the school district that really inspires folks in your community to work towards the common good of the students so why would whoops sorry I jumped why would you want to plan and get involved in

011a strategic planning if your high if your school enrollment is changing whether it's increasing or decreasing is the makeup of your school population changing at all um are there more Comm members in your community that do not have children that attend the schools than there are children uh community members who have students that are attending the schools are there changes in the family structure in your community is the economic structure changing um are the educational levels of your community members changing is there competition for your public schools do you have other schools that that students and families are wanting their kids to attend and then is limited funding impacting your ability to enact programs and services for your kids so if you answered yes to any of those questions or to more than one of

012those questions then strategic planning really is for you this is how the goals Cascade down I apologize to folks oh you have it over there so you can probably see it a little bit better than even the board can um what happens is you have your strategic planning goals and they will inform your district and Board of Education goals that are done on an annual basis those inform your superintendent goals which inform your administrator's Ro goals building goals Department goals and that all goes down to staff and student growth um grow student growth objectives professional development plans and ultimately impacts your students in a positive way so the components of strategic planning we have the the um the triangle or the diamond here that really shows the commitment of the board of education at the

013base of the plan and also going all the way up through the plan and what this will in will involve is three nights over a 3 to four month period we like to have the meetings at least three to four weeks apart and the first meeting there will be a state of the schools report that's done by the superintendent and then we'll talk about the knowing what the state of the schools are we'll be able to identify strengths and challenges the attendees that come and you can have you don't have to limit this we advise and recommend being more inclusive than exclusive they will participate in small groups and then in larger groups and we have lots of different activities and ways that we split people up so that you're generally not with the same

014group if you were with one group one meeting you probably will not be with that same group the next meeting just because it's a very random assignment come up with strengths and challenges in small groups and then the each group will come to consensus and this is a consensus based process so it may not be your first choice but it's something that you can live with and support and then each small group will report out to the larger group and we'll get consensus overall and come up with common threads at the end of that first meeting the second meeting will identify a vision for the district and initiatives that you would like to have focused on the district in the next couple of years in addition to all the wonderful things that you're already doing

015here and I've heard about all the wonderful things you're doing because when I came for goal setting you had a couple of reports beforehand that were really very impressive so I know you're already doing great things here so what would you like to see in addition we'll end that evening by identifying goal areas that will come to cons the group at large will come to consensus on and then at the next meeting the third and final meeting we'll develop those goal areas to develop goal statements and objectives for those goals once that's completed everybody again you'll work in small groups and Report out as a large group then the administrative team Dr alvik and the administrative team will take those goal areas and those goal statements and objectives and we'll come up with action plans

016for those once the action plans are developed then I'll be able to incorporate those into a final report and come back and present that to the board at the end of the the actual plan and that will start you off then with the plan for the next 3 to 5 years so a lot of times folks want to know how they can participate so as I said this is pretty much a four-month process once we get started so you can participants in in the community family members community members um we usually ask suggest that you involve ministerium and also um the police department and fire department and any groups that you may have adult groups in the community and I can send Dr alvic a list of stakeholder groups that we've identified as an association

017that may be a part you're sending District you may invite them in as well and to attend at least one of the meetings if they can attend all three of the meetings that's perfect but they can attend one two or three after each meeting that we have as a group I'll report out the following day I'll be able to send the outcomes a memo with the outcomes of that to Dr alvic and she'll be able to post that onto the website so anybody who wasn't able to attend meeting one but wants to come to meeting two will be a ble to see those outcomes on the website and hit the ground running with meeting to and vice versa become involved in the schools to the best of your ability and attend board meetings that have

018updates on the strategic planning process and the strategic planning goals so what questions might you have any of the board members have any questions do you have a timeline that typically if Florida District goes through sometimes districts will start in September there's a a sample calendar in your packet um sometimes boards will start in September sometimes they'll start in January so if if the board decides to go and approve this then I'll meet with Dr alvic and we'll talk about dates that won't conflict with most of what you have going on and I know that'll be difficult in a district this size to try and and navigate through dates that don't have a majority of things happening when districts have high schools and the number of schools that you have that can be difficult but

019we'll do our best to isolate some of those dates and um we try and make it so that there are meetings that are on different nights of the week because we find some people are taking classes on Monday nights so they would never be able to attend all Monday nights so we might try a Monday Tuesday Wednesday or Tuesday Wednesday Thursday um but I'll get together with Dr alvic and we'll be able to identify those time frames but generally once once we decide those time frames from the first Mee it's about a 3mon process to four months thank you Mr Ryback thank you uh just a couple of thoughts Maran uh I'm sure I'm not alone in thinking uh about the amount of work this could be in in uh you know participating in this

020and I know how important it is so is there any way we can have an informal uh uh Workshop or or if not a workshop or have somebody from a district that's done this available to meet with any board memb to uh come in and and ask questions that's okay come in and ask questions and and hear from them about the process and and and the kind of um work that is required to do a good job I have not been asked that in the past I can see about doing that but at the back of this packet that I gave to you there are a list of the school districts that we've worked with over the past few years and so usually you can go to their website and you can see what their

021their website looks like and then you would be able to go to their list of board members and any board member would be able to contact another board member I I just feel that you know we want to be as informed as possible before making a a a decision to participate in something like this as an individual I mean I can see if if if I have somebody from a previous District that's worked with me to see if they would be able to do that and I can let you know okay thank you okay so you're saying right now that we would be meeting three times over course of maybe every month for three months correct and and the meetings would probably go for how long the first meeting is generally 2 hours because there's

022the state of the schools report and we're getting a lot of business out of you know just strategy and how we're going to run the meetings out of the way but after that each meeting is about an hour and a half now if you have a hundred people attend or more than that and when I've had more I've had one District down in the southern part of the state that had 130 people at their first meeting I need to bring in an additional reinforcement because I we always do this in twos but we'll bring in an additional reinforcement or two because we're constantly moving around to facilitate the process and make sure that things are moving and for two of us it could be hard if we have that many small groups because we don't

023really want the small groups to have more than 8 to 10 people in them so if you have 130 people or 100 people you've got 10 to 13 groups then um it might take a little bit longer just because the reporting out process can take a little bit longer because each group we're asking them to report out but generally I haven't had any meeting go over two hours so at most it would be two hours two hours and two hours so I would assume it would be the um superintendent that would send out an email or an invitation out to the public asking anyone who wishes to be involved in this process to be involved correct and to notify us so that we have an idea of who would be coming how many people would

024be coming correct and one of the things that that I can do is send Dr alvic invitation forms so that she can then you know you can tailor them however you would like to the information is on there and um then those can be sent out along with the stakeholder list so you see you know what stakeholder groups we've identified there may be some that you haven't thought of most of them I'm sure you have already known because you've done this before um and then we ask that the district maintain some kind or have some kind of a registration um mechanism so that we know about how many people will come because if we think 60 people are coming and then we have 130 it's a little bit Wiggly to navigate that we can do

025it but and we'll do whatever we need to do but I would just ask more more of my colleagues to come okay if we have that many people any other questions okay it looks like there are no more questions so okay thank you I thank you very much for your attention and if anybody has any questions please give me a call Mr Rybeck I will certainly look to see if um I just I finished up with middle sex burrow earlier this year so I'll ask if there's anybody who might be able to come to one of your meetings and then I'll get in touch with you I appreciate that thanks very much okay well we look forward to starting this process very exciting me too it's a very Dynamic process and we do have a

026lot of fun we really do it's a great process and it also gives people the opportunity to work together in a way that they don't typically have parents are able to work with teachers and AD administrators in a way because everybody's equal and it's a Level Playing Field so nobody's opinion is higher than anybody else's um so people really get to interact in ways that they don't typically get to do that it's great for a new superintendent to be able to have those interactions too and you'll probably end up getting more people that want to come because they would want to meet Dr alvic as the new superintendent so that's in your favor as well but I'm looking forward to working with you guys if you decide to do this okay thank you thank you

027okay problem okay thanks okay so at this time we have a a budget philosophy discussion that I will ask Dr alvik and Mr Gorski to um H and Dr Layman oh Dr Layman is good and Dr Layman I apologize hey good evening so we are here this evening to talk to you about budget philosophy so this basically kicks off our budget cycle and our process for the 2020 2021 school year um oops so as always I want to thank the Board of Education um for all of their support as we're moving through this um through this process and hopefully um we'll continue to do this and and to continue to move forward with our budget so what is a budget philosophy so basically this is the District establishing the annual school budget and the creation

028of a framework for this for for the budget for the school year it will give the administration the guidance as we move forward and make decisions about the budget for the following school year and I and I will read this to you because I think this is really important um I don't usually like to read off slides um the philosophy of establishing the annual school budget should entail the creation of a framework work for a budget that supports a democratic plan of appropriate funding for the implementation of educational programs so that students May develop and learn from quality experiences based on educationally sound and fiscally prudent planning a solid Financial base is Paramount to ensuring that the school district will be able to meet the responsibility of preparing our students for an increasingly competitive environment

029and the B the budget philosophy stage should be macro Focus this is an important piece macro Focus rather than Micro Focus as much more refinement will be required and implemented in the future through the rigorous budget process so this is just a main overview of what our Appropriations are our revenues are and our and our needs are for the upcoming school year we have not gone through the budget defense rounds or the budget process yet so this is a macro View for the district thank you Dr El first I'd like to say what a pleasure it was putting together the budget the information with Dr Al and Dr L can you hear me okay thank you it was a pleasure compiling all of this information which comes from a lot of source departments principls Vice

030principles teachers directors and supervisors all contributed what their Outlook is next year for preparation of the budget and this was an important step in a former board member Mr Tom dawon described this process very well that this is the stage where the Board of Education tells Administration what kind of cake debate and then we go into the oven and put it all together this is the directive on on what to do with the budget what is the goal of this year's budget is it to reduce taxes is it to accommodate growth is it to accommodate facilities we want to hear a message from the board to see if into resolution establishing what that should be and every budget begins with res ource uh considerations what money do you have to frame how much you have

031to spend last year we received just under $6 million in state aid which was only 4.4% of all revenues now S2 is known as the pathway to full funding benefits Monroe where a lot of other school districts are losing funding it is projected that Monroe will receive an additional $400,000 for the 2021 budget year now we've said at Noam at the advocacy committee meeting even full funding for this District when this plan is fully implemented in five years is unsatisfactory to this District we will never reach the goal uh of where we have to be we need a new funding formula and we've already started lobbying for that in the appropriate places but we'll take what we can get in the meantime and squeeze what we can out of a tired integrated formula we're very

032proud of our proprietary funds here particularly Falcon care and early childhood enrichment These funds are combined making about $600,000 every year which is unrestricted money that the board has the Liberty to transfer into any appropriation line item they choose once again with the 2021 budget we asked the board to consider harvesting another $600,000 of retained earnings from this fund to help offset generally the cost of growth curriculum needs facility needs that we outline later and Jamesburg sends their high school students to Monroe as was directed by court order we have a tuition agreement between the districts Jamesburg is actually overpaying their actual tuition charge every year through the budget and that is paying down the debt that exists currently James Berg's fees for tuition and transportation are approximately 3.3% of all general fund revenues they

033send that in an email to unfortunately with the lack of state aid contributing the majority of Monro School District budget 86 to 88% depending on the year comes from the local tax L and the calculation for cap expansion which allows growth in taxes to support additional spending needs for school districts is outlined here we're going to put all this information on the website so you don't have to worry about copying it but takes your base year general fund Levy makes an adjustment for enrollment according to the state's trend line we have no input in this like we used to then they raise it by 2% then there's an adjustment for health care costs compared to inflation and the state health benefits plan which Monroe does not participate in we'll talk about that a little later

034then you have your general fund tax levy cap prior to additional use of banked cap for Ely this district has $48,990 million with the use of banked cap another important Revenue consideration in the budget is excess Surplus this is the savings of Prior year budgets that carries over as a revenue source to two years later unfortunately due to the effects of growth and facilities and security infrastructure but mainly because of enrollment growth this district has consumed $1.7 million of excess Surplus which causes a deficit of that amount applying to this year so all things staying the same we're starting off the budget with $1.7 million less Revenue than we had last year the next slide summarizes all of the new projected resources for the 2021 budget as I mentioned additional general fund state aid uh

035we're expecting $400,000 from the state under the S2 Pathway to full funding additional general fund Levy we're recommending and to go to cap and use Bank cap of $3.3 million of growth with tax the depletion of excess Surplus is a negative to this equation so the total net projected budget resoures is only $2 million that is the most that we could squeeze out of next year's budget uh outside of any unforeseen revenues $2 million and as we all know one of our challenges is our is our student enrollment figures so the data that you see here on the slide are the is the October 15th data every school district in New Jersey has to report out on October 15th all of the students that are currently in that building currently in our buildings in our

036school district so you have all of the data starting back from 2011 2012 school year October 15th of 2011 the 2018 2019 number that you see there 687 students that was last October 15th and the projection for next year oh I'm sorry yes the projection for this year is 6,989 89 students and that will be taken on October 15th so obviously we that is a project projected number we won't have the official number until that date this district will likely break 7,000 students this year which is a milestone yeah next we're now that revenues has been explained we're going to talk about Appropriations what spending is anticipated for next year and this was uh a lot of effort from again the principls the assistant principls supervisors directors Dr Alvi and Dr Layman to go through

037the district and ask everyone to anticipate what you could need next year now a lot of the these needs are going to be far in excess of what we're going to be able to fit in that $2 million growth of the budget but we want to show it to you because this is your school district we want to show you some of the facility needs that have come across our radar and um some other factors salaries and benefits are approximately 75% of the general fund budget schools are very labor intensive organization that's no surprise aggregate District salaries are approximately 65 million health benefits have been projected preliminarily to increase 8 to 10% above last year's premiums with the caveat that claims will have to be monitored at least through January of 2020 to receive an

038accurate estimate the 1819 health benefit premiums for the district were $24,300 th000 and were offset by contractual contributions of approximately $4 million by District staff contributing to their health care costs now we do a if I may to our own horn in the business office we do a fantastic job every year analyzing our health insurance premiums getting competitive quotes looking at our loss ratios and and going back to Horizon who is our private plan and negotiating with them our private plan with Horizon has beaten the pants off of the State Health Benefit Plan every year with the exception of one in the last 10 years everybody every colleague that I have is trying to get out of the state health benefit plan this year due to political reasons you're reading in the paper that there's

039going to be a suppression for this one year only of the State Health Benefit Plan rates we expect Horizon to consider that when offering us our projections for the year and to be in line with it and and more information will come on that but as you could see salaries $65 million and benefits at $24 million is a significant amount of our general fund budget so as we move forward into the uh next series of slides one way to think of what we're about to see is this is our to-do list there's Appropriations here that will far greatly exceed uh what we can accomplish in this year's budget but we want you to see what's on Horizon some of these projects are today issu ises some of them are tomorrow issues and some of them

040are we can get to it at some point uh and the budget process we're going to go through this year will help us prioritize what we address now what we have right on Horizon and what's kind of a long-term project so up on the screen the first phase we're looking at is Personnel you can see that there's uh the completion of a multi-year phas in of the Middle School uh a new academic team there there's Staffing for the high school there's Staffing at the elementary level most of this is related to our increasing enrollment can't hear you can't hear me this better a little bit a little better no it's better okay good so the uh the bottom piece that's a special education we're continuing to expand our special education programs this Staffing would support

041the grow the growth of our multiple disabilities classrooms our physical therapist which is a support staff as well as PA professionals to support those classrooms transportation we have to replace six buses so one of the things we uh always try and cycle into the budget is our 54 passenger buses uh we're budgeting for hopefully budgeting for two lift vans that uh addresses our special needs students they have some uh unique Transportation requirements and this will allow us to bring some of that contracted uh bus routing back into the district uh we much prefer to use our own drivers uh we can communicate with them we can solve problems with them much more effectively than when dealing with contractors technology there's a range of uh technology uh Appropriations here everything from increasing our security uh we

042have crowd strike up there that's a uh a service that we would kind of implement to prevent us or help us uh fend off ransomware um mware antivirus software we're also looking to expand and refresh some of the technology for the staff at the high school Middle School uh Hunter technology that's a uh reunification program reunification software uh in a worst case scenario if we have to bring the staff together and reunite students with parents after something happened that's a uh a critical piece of technology that would assist us in doing that effectively the next few slides and I'm not going to go over everything on this these are our facilities needs and as you'll see there are some items in here that are multi-million dollar projects those would be things that we have to

043look at through potentially other avenues but it's important to have this front and center so we can see what's ahead of us and we can plan as we go through the ad hoc committee process as well as this bu the budget process we know what's in front of us couple of the things on here the Synthetic Turf and running track we were at the homecoming football game it was absolutely jamming there we're uh we need to look at more seating a larger area for the crowds the uh the field and the running track are safe but that's the replacement of that is coming up extremely quickly and that's a uh large ticket item that we need to plan for we also have pretty much projects for every school mil Lake the Middle School playground equipment

044uh as we continue to grow we're trying to address bus pickup and Bus drop off at different schools you can see here oak tree uh one of the things we're trying to look at is how do we fit more buses at Oak Tree school do we have to extend sidewalks so students can be get on and get off the buses safely uh Brookside we have some warn carpeting that's just a wear and tear issue uh traditional Building Maintenance pieces um the high school again maintenance in our industrial arts equipment we're looking at storage at the transportation department there's also a underground storage tank that needs to be replaced again everything is safe and functioning but these are projects that if we don't plan for we have to deal with in an emergency situation so they

045need to be out in front of us textbooks we have a growing population we also have changing standards uh we want to make sure we're up to date with our curriculum documents all these textbooks here some of them could be digital some of them are print texts as we go through the uh acquisition process that will kind of be narrowed down but these are definitely uh priority issues for us as we try and stay competitive with our high school classes and then these are some more programs uh a lot of these center around our music programs we have a bank of instruments uh larger instruments that students like tubas and baritone saxes and stuff we have a kind of a bank of those so students have don't have to purchase them on their own we

046need to kind of cycle in and continue to replace those uh s shell there are other schools around us that have that uh it makes us more competitive kind of puts us on a equal playing field uh the swim teams back on there that was something we uh put on last year we'd like to bring that back up again this year we're taking another look at the special education classrooms outfitting them as we continue to grow those programs TV production uh production broadcast server again we have one but that's something the technolog is continually changing and we need to kind of stay up to date with that so to summarize all that Dr Layman just introduced salary increases are difficult to project because we are out of contract as of June 30th with the mtea

047our largest labor organization but just a range of of projected increases on us on a wage base uh districtwide of about 65 million there's at least $2 million of salary increased in es that will be contractually driven once a new agreement's set benefit increases these are not additional benefits these are premium increases that um we've been projected the rate increases from Horizon uh we're unsatisfied with the number we're going to chew this down as much as possible but right now conservatively $2.4 million looks like the increas is in the health benefit line 10% the additional staffing needs to accommodate growth 1 .6 million Transportation needs to replace buses due to an aging schedule and also bring back routes from the contractors particularly in the areas of special education Vans where we believe will do a

048better job 1,126 th000 instructional technology needs $888,000 facility needs this is a wish list $2,960 th000 included in that number is the address of Applegarth School our facility director wanted to disclose that we have a a school in appleg guard that was built with New Deal money so it's got a boiler system there that's older than I I want to State uh it's had some minor facelifts and cosmetic upgrades over the years it's had all of the known asbestos removed and it's safe and clean but all of the major systems in the school need replacement we we had a line item in that previously a $1 million $15 million for a construction project is not something that is feasible in an annual school budget but transparency U urges us to to disclose this at this

049time textbooks $270,300 we've been doing a fantastic job with the supervisors refreshing textbooks according to uh the curriculum schedule and new program needs total projected appropriation ations see $29 million now as I said before revenues can only grow two so most of what you see here probably is not going to be able to make it and if you if you could just work with the numbers a little bit here you could also forecast that some existing programs and services that District currently offers are going to have to be reviewed for their uh alignment with board and District goals and the value that they contribute to the organization so one of our favorite slides for the budget philosophy is our um accomplishments and things that we've done so even with the constraints of the budget and

050with the constraints of growing enrollment we are continually increasing our graduation rate our graduation rate last June was 97% um so we're very proud of that um you can see that many of our students do go on and attend college we do have students that go on and attend career technical schools and enter the military so we're very proud of our students and proud of our um High School graduation rate as you heard last month we have very high AP scores and we're continuing to look at those and move forward so you can see there we had 86% of our students taking the AP test scoring a three or better and our average scores on sats are always higher much higher than the state average so this is something that we're very proud of um

051even with the constraints of the budget and it's due to all of the hard work of our Administration our teachers our students and our parents next now that you've projected the revenues and Appropriations how does this come into play with the tax consequence of all this one of the major variables in calculating the tax rate is ratables the rateable base throughout town this is the valuation of all property throughout town which is how the general fund tax levy and The Debt Service tax levy combin are shared the money is needed to support the schools every year are advertised through the community in the form of taxes based on property valuations um this district is growing we're picking up additional ratables every year and the pro the projection now is that ratables will increase 1.5% that's

052extremely favorable from a tax consequence standpoint because as there's more businesses and homeowners sharing in the tax levy everybody's individual rate goes down my first year as ba here I mentioned this before we have a $75 million decrease in ratables and it was equivalent to a 5 a half cent increase in the budget without increasing Appropriations by $1 so this is a very important factor we have a Tailwind this year fortunately with increasing radal of course's another of this coin you got deal with the infrastructure some schools but as far as the tax rate dror I'm sorry there's one more thing I'd like to mention with Appropriations one of the areas that we've done extremely well on is consolidating and eliminating administrative costs with last year's budget we presented to you that our per pupil

053administrative costs and this is not our information it comes from the state of New Jersey taxpayer guide educational spending and if you're not familiar with that report I suggest Googling it because there is a plethora of information in there to evaluate how efficiently your school district is running $1,555 per pupil we spent on administrative costs that's far below the state average of 1,619 and the state median of 1,674 for a district with 3,500 plus students so we are far below and this is from 2018 the 19 report was released and that's extremely favorable we're getting even more efficient we're saving that uh surprise for the tenative budget as ation so in conclusion we would like to ask the board to um guide us and direct us to prepare a budget that responsibly meets the demands

054of our continuing student student growth and facility needs as well as program and service requirements without exceeding the board's maximum spending Authority while prioritizing the following items so as we as we go through the budget process again this is just in macro overview we now spend several months having the the buildings create their budget from a zerob based budget they start from scratch every year what are your needs for your school and then then we go through budget defense rounds and we look at every line item that's being proposed and we take a look and see exactly where we can make adjustments so that we can fit all of our needs into the budget so this is not a final budget in any way shape or form this is just the first step so we

055want to make sure that we're looking at our construction projects and making sure that we're looking at them and recommending them on a priority basis looking at our curriculum recommendations um as recommended by Administration making sure we're taking into account our salary and benefit increases at a conservative range due to their contingent status Transportation recommendations transferring $600,000 from retained earnings of the Falcon care Early Childhood enrichment proprietary fund and looking at other programs as recommended by Administration and administration review of non-mandated programs and services with elimination as a possibility and I know that this was was a discussion that we had last year so what we what our plan is is we will not be waiting until March to share out any of this information we will be giving regular updates at our monthly Board

056of Education meetings of where we are in the budget process and any possible Cuts we do not know what they are at this time we have not started that process yet but at this time we are promising you that we will be giving regular updates to the community on where we will be throughout the budget process thank you okay so we'll open it up to the board for any comments or questions that from anybody anyone I I have one miss armeno I have several thank you uh for the presentation um uh in the past in the in the past almost every year since I got on the board which will be six years soon enough um we've talked about how the uh tax levy and the rateable increase we will help us survive any increases

057that we need to make but that doesn't seem to be the case and Mr Gorski you you mentioned that the tax levy helps relieve um the taxpayers but we're not getting relief from the tax levy it's not going down um it may it may help us not go higher but the tax we don't seem to the ratables don't seem to be compensating for the growth that we need that to have so everybody everybody's taxes I think we don't need a show of hands but I bet everybody's taxes in this room who lives in Monroe have gone up considerably over the years and um you know the the township um from their tax bill that they gave out one of their Council meetings was you know they bragged about not having the budget go their budget

058go up but our budget has gone up we've gotten uh unfortunately we've gotten the blame for the tax raises um but we know that 100% of all all of the building and the construction comes from the other from the township uh uh Council and everything so so the tax levy has not really benefited our cost Rises it seems to me I'm not an economist and it's just that like I said everybody in this rooms taxes have gone up may I elaborate on that briefly um with regard to the rateable presentation picture if you will a a fixed and finite spending amount like a rental of a movie if we go on Netflix and we rent a movie and we spend 15 bucks that's a fixed amount just like our Capp budget and our Capp general

059fund tax levy every year it's a finite amount of money we can't grow it Beyond and that has to get shared through the community and this example that would be like viewers coming to watch the Netflix movie in your par the more people that come to watch the movie share the cost and everybody's individual rate go down that's the effect that growing ratables has in the suppression of the tax rate but to your point that taxes are still going up even though more people are sharing in it that is valid School costs as have we as we projected here have a a great deal of facility needs staff to accommodate um students we have trailer rental costs that were identified in the slides and um you know we had a gentleman come to the public

060forum years back and say you know a lot of businesses are introducing zero spending increases this year why can't you do it well the reason we can't do it is because we're picking up hundreds of new students every year our facilities are not in a stagnant State they constantly need a dress Transportation vehicles are aging out and our costs are ever increasing here at the school district uh thank you for that and and that is something I totally agree with you for my my point was that when there there's no comfort in saying our ratables are going to help us because they're not um and and to use your example if if everybody pays the N you use Netflix or everybody goes to the movies and pays the same thing pays the same cost to

061go to the movies well that's fine everybody pays the same but the rables are not the same for everybody we are not getting the same value of ratables as perhaps we've had in the past and the increase in population let's face it the municipalities um you know our cost is really dependent on population and the population is far far exceeds based on higher densities uh you know smaller houses we are it's not a corollary and I'm just saying that we really can't find comfort so much that the ratables are going to satisfy us so I think we still need to be cognizant when we do our budget philosophy that there's not really a um a pot of gold at the end of that rable rainbow Mr Rybeck just a couple of things also uh just

062to I guess make it very simple uh we talk about ratables and amount of um new development coming in uh you know it costs so much money to educate each child here uh so I doubt very much if the amount of tax revenue we get from every unit is enough to cover two or three students of course uh you know they could be paying $8,000 I'm just picking a number I've had for a unit and they can have three kids and in no way does that $8,000 or the portion of it that goes to education pay for for the students you know uh just yesterday I was talking to a bunch of uh seniors friends of mine uh who were very angry at the amount of money they're paying in taxes and um one of

063the things they wanted was well why can't seniors get a break on their taxes of course we can't do that that's a state issue but um I think that's something that maybe we need to push for if that's possible on the state level is uh seeing what they could do to uh and how they um fund uh education uh and maybe they have to not just change a formula which is what um um advocating for but actually take a look at changing the whole system the way they uh the way they are getting taxes in general and how they divy it out Madam just very briefly on Mr Rick's comment uh years back the district did introduce our own in-house legislation which was s701 at the time superintendent tasked us with coming up with legislation

064to help Monroe state aid formula and it was that angle that we took by saying if it district has greater than 1/3 senior population 65 years of rollover the state should fully fund the formula back then which they weren't doing to even to the extent of doing now right um it got some traction it was sponsored by legislators but uh never came to fruition and we required a governor signature anyway uh which wasn't going to happen but and did we have a whole U contingent of uh residents and school board members I remember was a beautiful thing we took buses down to Trenton we got out of committee with the legislation which was the first hurdle we faced and right but now that that's the topic is still alive senior supplemental stabilization Aid is is

065still in the funding formula although it's not funded it could offer relief to seniors by offering an additional amount per pupil of state aid for senior populations who are greater than onethird of your census Monroe would qualify I just want to emphasize uh they have no problem with funding education they want to have an ed a quality educational system they're just tired of of of paying all that money and they have no kids in the school and they're on fixed incomes and and uh you know I I understand where they're coming from and and uh um they have a point and I think uh it's going to take a lot of people to join forces and work on that but Mr Gorski you're 100% right that that bill is could be something just that uh

066made to order for them Mr poori a couple of quick questions um looking at the 2019 2020 uh budget the capital projects was about 0.86% Which is less than 1% uh Mr groski and today we have seen the wish list U and I by the way I agree with that is about $21 million um clearly the pressing need is the accommodation of additional students that we have as one of the priorities if not the priority how do you envision changing within the operating budget to go from 0.86% to 21% is probably what 18 17 18% yeah that's the privilege that the board of education has to direct resources to wherever you see fit certainly we've done a fantastic job in my opinion of keeping up with aging facilities here in the district that the current

067school funding formula has no Provisions for financing Capital repairs there is zero money available for Rod grants that we took advantage of in the past where they reimbursed us 40% of the cost to upgrade and repair and even make new facilities um and there's no cap relief to address these aging facilities so if you have to do a major window boiler Roof System you're fitting that in a CT budget competing with teacher salaries and additional students uh and textbooks and everything else that was presented tonight so we're going to have to do it on a priority basis you're right in the past when we presented the budget it was already refined with the director of facilities to to be a little sobering of what money is available and how much you have to spend because

068certainly $24 million that he presented here tonight is just not practical but but he felt it's important at this stage because we have we have held these expenditures and there's a lot of pent up need to disclose this to the community um but uh other than other than hoping that we have Rod grants or couple some of these projects with future uh referendum there there is no um there is no uh solution oh my request is that knowing that this is a wish list maybe prioritizing fully understanding that the priorities do change based on the conditions is to create like prioritized capital projects rather than having the entire list my last question is that you mentioned that the the Teachers Association contract negotiation ends in June when do we start the negotiations so that we

069don't have the same situation that we had where the teachers were working without a contract for quite some time we have not received the request to negotiate yet which is the first step of negotiations from the teachers union um however we have had some preliminary requests for scattergram information both salary scattergram and health insurance scat which is just a a map of where the the members are and where their salaries are which step and what benefit cost they have so that you can begin some preliminary prep work for negotiations so we're at a very early stage thank you yeah it's been in the past that we've started negotiations after the new year and they they come to us and they request to go into the start of negotiations and then we go with that Mrs

070Lang Mr gski I um I have a question about the referendum and capital Improvement projects I'm sorry and and the work that we need to do on on our schools to maintain them and things like that I've had the impression that a lot of school districts put off maintaining their buildings and updating their buildings and taking care of all of that and keep it out of their budget and then hope and pray that they will pass a referendum and then repair their buildings that way I think they just did that in Tom's river and other districts and I was reading recently that there's something like $184 million in repair referendums up for vote in this next election cycle can you explain our philosophy just a little bit because I think it's really important that we

071understand that our buildings are topnotch and the way that we've addressed it because I I think I'm always amazed when I go to our meetings and we're hearing school districts tell us oh we have to get all new lights for you know the gym and it's a but we're going to put it off another year or there's a hole in our roof and we're going to put it off another year so I just you know I just trying to understand that a little bit better just briefly because we could talk about this topic for a whole bgt committee meeting but uh there was a keyst magazine article called the the school fiscal cliff and it had to do with kicking the facility can down the road with repairs and capital upgrades because the school funding

072formula and the annual budget is not designed to accommodate or allow room for capital projects and expansion it there is just just no room especially when your budget's capped there's no state aid to help you that said this district has always been very responsible to the taxpayers who paid for these schools to upgrade them and maintain them over time if you look at all of the essential systems of our schools they are all properly maintained every year filters are changed um broken things are fixed and our schools in my opinion are among the best that I've seen we've visited a lot of school districts looking at uh offers to uh you know take some of our students and things like that and uh what I see is no Nets and basketball nets and I see

073uh just problems everywhere I look you come into our schools when they reopen in September that every floor shines our in-house custodial staff through the direction of Mr T do an incredible job and and I think we are the best of all the public schools in the area when it comes to the the quality and state of our facilities that doesn't say that some schools like appleg guard that were built with New Deal money need major infrastructure Replacements and upgrades already or perhaps a uh a raising and a a new structure perform if it's more uh cost efficient because like like an old car when you're talking about replacing an engine a transmission a drivetrain a the roof's still leaking radiators broke where do you start and when you fix the radiator you still have

074everything else waiting for you so if you abandon the car at some part of the process was that wasted investment all of these are are difficult decisions that Administration is going to be looking at going forward but we we we've made it a priority to always include in the general fund budget capital projects including roofs including um HVAC systems parking lots um asbest remediation and many other items every single year to the tune of of about $3 million on average every year and that's significant when we you consider how much we can only grow the budget each year can go ahead is it okay if I give it um you know because I think it goes along with this so at our last meeting we had talked about um how we're going to advocate for

075New Jersey school boards Association to help us change the funding formula and one of the things that they did agree to look into to see if they would be willing is to recognize District that do take care of their facility problems within house without going to referendum as getting that back in you had said the rod grants that getting that back re re restored into the budget so we um though I will tell you we're not presenting anything at this delegate assembly we really did catch the ear of New Jersey school boards Association and they're willing to work with us to identify things that need to be changed in the funding formula um we couldn't get them to agree 100% to fighting for a a new funding formula simply because the fear of going back

076into the Abbot lawsuits that took eight plus years to to get everything settled before the state supreme court agreed to Affair that this was a good funding formula but we really made some headways in getting them to agree to look into what changes need to be made recognizing our senior population and doing something in funding where we would actually get more funding based on the numbers of seniors because they they were blown away when I explained to them we have over 62% of our community is senior citizens and they were in living in the in their developments and Mr Ryback and I spent a long time with them that day and they were very open to yeah they were very open to listening to us so we made Headway with um changes for having them

077and they're considering these these advocacy platform so they have to come back to us but um changes in the financing through senior citizens changing in rewarding districts that are fiscally responsible and especially taking care of their facilities within their means definitely changing how districts are recognized when their student populations are changing because they were blown away when we gave them our numbers and we showed them exactly what was happening to us in terms of the change of in our student population there was a couple of other things but I just thought this might be a good place to share that with you guys certainly thank you Mrs Lang for your advocacy at the school board's level for our facilities you know anyone else Mrs Mr Mayo I ask a question sure it's my understanding that

078the delegates at the delegate it's my understanding that the delegates at the delegate assembly put questions forth to be voted on by the delegates that ask the New Jersey school boards to do something so how could you how could they if you brought that question to the delegates to ask them to Advocate more for funding um I don't know how it happened and I'll I'll be 100% honest I I don't know how in our communication with school boards it happened but when we sent the request for them to help us to fill out a the paperwork so that we could present at delegate assembly we got a request back from school boards to meet with the legislative finance committee and it was almost like a step ahead of the game so it's a it's a

079finance committee who on the legislative level of school boards and they work with the delegate assembly usually what happens is when something is presented to the delegate assembly then this committee goes and looks at the economic feasibility the impacts everything that's going on they took a hold of it before that so and the way that they presented it to us was so that they could help us develop something that's really going to get traction and it's going to get the support of other school districts around the state New the school boards had never has never advocated for more funding no so it sounds to me like they're trying to subvert what you're doing no I think they're trying what they're trying to do Jill is trying to get us to move away from asking for

080a new funding formula because they're really afraid of that big long fight so it's a slow and easy it's like a slow step process to get them to see at a different level they I mean for them to sit there and say they agree that there's changes that need to be made to the funding formula that the funding formula is not working I don't think we we we've heard them say even that much so it's it's a different process but um I'm going to be hopefully optimistic and cross my fingers that we've made some Headway and you know just to even be sitting at that table and having the people who are making those decisions listening to us and actually listening to I I think it's one of the first times that they've sat and

081listened to the the exact plight of Monroe Township and having it um heard and their willingness to help us work through that process was it just you guys there no that was whole committe okay and the committee people were all in in agreement and the biggest fear for them is the the fact that if they just Advocate right now to throw out the funding formula then that whole process of the fight that the districts were in for over eight years um for with the state and the educational law Center that led to the Abbott District's development is going to start all over again and I think that's their biggest Rel reluctance to to just throw they never even advocated for just more funding forget throwing out the formula they're starting to do that be and

082and the big thing that they kept talking about is that um there's a terrible feedback and I apologize um is that one of the big issues is that we talk about everybody needing more funding but there's a reality that the state's revenues that's the money coming in are not it is it is so far from the money that's going out that you know and the state itself has basically said to school boards and to the education Community we're already spending over 30 it was 35% of the state budget goes to education so there's a you know there's a lot of changes that have to be made and unfortunately we have the ear of our legislators but other legislators around the state they don't care about Monroe and that's you know to make some of those

083changes we talked about um impact fees and everything so it was a productive meeting can I just thing yes I know Jill you asked about other represent other Representatives the districts other than ours were members of that finance committee Patty and I were the invited guests so that was that was very good but yes you you touched on something that uh you know we've been fighting for uh obviously more money fighting for uh a new formula and fighting for impact fee um there aren't too many people there that are uh behind impact fees which bothers me because that's something that we've been fighting for for years now um we're going to continue to fight we're going to continue to fight for a new formula and to get more money uh but I felt very gratified

084and I think Patty did as well uh that we were the invited guests and they gave us the floor and really spend time with us and I think on top of the fact that we were able to show them quite a number of points where the formula needs to be changed it kind of like I don't think they looked at that before like they're just looking at the the the lawsuits and the fight that and the delay that that's going to take to get it so but to have them even just willing to look at all these different components I I wasn't I was surprised that they were as receptive they didn't throw us out so it was a good thing I thought they would go into it Mr Masters a couple sorry not used

085to this a couple of things I don't think we're ever going to see impact fees in our lifetime they have much more the builders have much more money in lobbyists than every than everybody else um I disagree a little bit with what Patty was saying I don't the funding formula was Antiquated it it doesn't work it's it hasn't been funded from inception right and some people even believe it was unconstitutional when they implemented it I think we need to scrap it and go back so again to have school boards try to help us with that okay but I don't see that going anywhere um if you're looking for direction um one of the things I I I believe is I know Mr gski you were saying that we've been kind of uh depending on the

086bad Mr tag and the backs of some of our staff for some of these schools but I really would believe myself that preventive maintenance and some of these facility projects should be prioritized um we I mean what would happen if we lost the boiler at Applegarth and we had to redo all the HVAC that's millions of dollars that we'd have to find somewhere in the budget correct in emergency funding yes yes and the District administration does have an alternative plan if something catastrophic should happen and you can't hold school at appleg guard school so again we would have we'd have unhoused students then additional unhoused students well we have an alternate location where we would uh host those students and until that repair is made but but you're talking about one hypothetical repair there that

087whole building is again I'm just using as an example but yeah for Direction that's what I would urge the administration to make sure they prioritize M armeno you go I've already spoken mran thank you is it uh possible for the board to is it possible for the board to request uh that the mayor put forth a moratorium on building until we're we're at the point where we can catch up and there's no further unhoused students because this I think we're in a state of emergency actually and and the building the progression is just putting us deeper into the hole when we're not able to catch up financially I I personally don't know if that can be done because I know that there are if Builders and Mr POI probably knows better than I do um

088if if they have met all the requirements to build I don't think you can stop them from building well it's it's not uh stopping them it's just pausing hitting the pause button until the district is able to catch up and maybe that would um initiate some of them to say hey we want to develop this we want to make the money money maybe we could put an addition on a school for somebody not that it's mandatory um but maybe we can help them out maybe put this addition on a school so we can get this big development in that we want because that's what's holding us up maybe it'll initiate a little bit of help from the people that are making millions off of us something to consider I don't know Mr Mr Gorski do

089you have any I I certainly can't speak to the legal aspects of of a moratorium on building it um but it's certainly something that you could ask the council meeting um you certainly representing yourself as a member of the public and not the board and asked a question there I think once a developer makes an investment to build something and all of a sudden you say stop the more investment and we put a motorum on it they would view that as lost revenue for them having said that I think something along the lines of no more applications can be approved which maybe too late at this point may be something that don't oh I'm sorry um but at a minimum if there are more applications coming to the to the board it's zoning board or

090a planning board to say that we're not going to take any more application this is hypothetical in my opinion it's worth a discussion with the with the council to see what can we what can be done from that perspective I I I honestly think that um us as a board will have a stronger of of uh effect on that request than if I go there and ask as a taxpayer right so I think we should as a board vote if we should pursue asking the mayor I I think it might go in a different way have the um Administration from the board have a conversation with the township yeah I think that's a little bit instead of having us vote on that right okay Miss armino yeah well first of all we have we did

091vote to ask the state legislators to do something with impact fees I can't imagine why we can't do a similar resolution to the our local I mean I don't know why the Administration has to when we've done things like um have petitions signed and all incent we could do the same thing for our local people because that's really planning board zoning board councel uh uh you know master plan that's where all the development is going I mean even that at the state level no one's paying attention to us but the real issues are H are happening in our backyard and the real control is happening from our local officials so I I I don't understand why we would have to rely on our Administration when uh the board in a sincere effort to um address

092the issue that we've had public coming before us for years and asking us uh can't make that decision as or a resolution as a board but that just was a an aside from from Mr um uh Pete to and I and I thank you for that information okay my question is um and I appreciate everybody's advocacy and the and the concerns of the public regarding the uh state aid we've talked for years between 17 and 20 years about state aid I agree that we should pursue that and continue to be concerned about the lack of state aid that we get but as Mr Gorski pointed out that is only 4.4% of all the revenue we get in to constantly um just pursue that Avenue when we have time and time again um been absolutely shut

093down from in our Pursuits sort of deflects our real issues our issues in our own backyard so while we are doing that uh 4.4% of our what is it now about $130 million operating budget I mean the the public needs to know that we have a $130 million operating budget what do we go through between 11 million uh 10 million And1 million a month to operate our schools and I appreciate all of the seniors who if we're already not making ends meet all those seniors that have been paying without relief I appreciate their contribution to our schools and to our community because without them God knows where we'll be so you know I do appreciate what they've done so far and I understand their need for some relief but thank God for them because where

094would we be without them if we're all already running uh shy so I do want the public to understand that pursuing only as an as an option uh the state the state fair funding is only 4.4% of our whole budget um my other concern is technology we talked about technology um there's always been uh an ambivalence for me between our laptops um when I before I got on the board I was against some of the purchases of laptops and then uh as it turned out uh they weren't the right laptops we had a loss uh and then subsequently I did vote for laptops so my question is um I saw that we need laptops I don't have a problem with that is there a way either to refresh the laptops that we have or Mo

095instead of buying new ones constantly moving them down to the other um grades and using the older ones or having the teachers use some of the like how can we move these laptop shps around without constantly buying new we all like new things I like a new pair of shoes every once in a while but we can't always get it wear my old shoes all the time so comfortable because they're comfortable because they get comfortable okay but my thought is what can we these look I'd like to start thinking out of the box everybody says you know uh we we want to give our kids the best that's true but if we are going to have to start looking at some things let's talk about laptops and then I I do have some other questions

096as well so after that I'll ask you more um unfortunately technology is almost a product that after a few years it's doesn't work anymore what about for the lower grades though even we utilize our laptops and our lap we actually use Chromebooks at the lower grades because we don't we don't the teachers have laptops which they we have have to be on a a cycle to refresh but at the elementary level and the Middle School level we're really using Chromebooks which are much cheaper because they're cloud-based so they don't have all of the memory that they need teachers are different but for our students we do la we do the the and and have we had any reports I mean we I we we keep asking for reports and sometimes we get them sometimes we

097don't of the efficacy of the laptops of if they have really helped our our children move forward you you know the utilization of these laptops have they worked do we have the right software are we buying the right software for these laptops should we get a report on a regular basis especially if the technology moves so fast can the board and and the parents actually either be surveyed that well I'd like maybe sometimes the parents and the teachers to be surveyed to see what their opinion they're surveyed the teachers are surveyed every single year okay we look at our um purchasing software every single year what are we looking at what are we doing we actually have done it through curriculum committee so it has been shared with with the board from the curriculum committee

098so it is something that we've looked at every single year we do not just buy things to buy things um in fact we had a little bit um we had a couple of parents that I I know I heard from um in September because we did stop using one piece of software because we were duplicating it with something better that they weren't aware of so we we also communicate out to parents through Genesis of what their what their children can log into with all their passwords and things like that so parents are we we do share that information with parents it is something that is that every year it is not just refreshed to be refreshed we make sure that that we're using it we look at utilization records um of how all of the

099technology is being used and if we find a software product that is no longer being used in the classroom or being used by very few teachers we look and see if there's another option for it and we don't renew that so that is something that is an ongoing process through our technology department um Ryan tolboom was our former educational technology facilitator he really took really took charge of that over the last few years and we've really streamlined a lot of what we do with that so um that is something that's an ongoing process okay and still in the technology realm we've had two breaches in the last few months uh in the technology did we ever get a report as to the finale of that or Madam we we do not have a report and

100um you know I just want to respectfully remind the committee that the we're looking at a really macro picture here with regard to the budget philosophy it's identifying the the need for $30 million of Appropriations 2 millions of limited in Revenue growth and and a resolution on on how to approach the budget for there um we do not have a report yet from crowd strike but that's respectfully beyond the scope of the budget philosophy and and just one other point I want to address although currently our revenues from the state are only 4.4% of total revenues for our district there are many other school districts getting 20% of their District's revenues paid for by the state 30% 50% 70% up to 90% absolutely so even at full funding our 4.4% may only grow to 7

101or 8% we need a new funding formula and we've been saying this we've been studying this at the educational advocacy committee we're hoping that sometime in the in the very near future that the residents join with us and and and pressuring everybody for a new funding formula one that's Monroe Centric for once also at the educational advocacy committee we haven't abandoned the concept of of suing this state right I've turned over over 60 documents and numerous schedules to the weer Law Group uh in their examination of whether we have a claim or not so we're hitting this on all fronts Mr I have no argument with any of that and I'm certainly in agreement with it so that that's that wasn't my point my point is we have to step at that that is one

102aspect of the kind of concerns that we have so I'd like to move on um the oak tree sidewalk and and I would respectfully disagree that um you know we're talking about a budget philosophy and sometimes we have to talk about the small things as well as the macro things because I think sometimes and I and I've heard the public say that they they want to look at some line item things and they they want some specific so I apologize if I'm only going to talk about $150,000 but I'm going to anyway uh the oak tree sidewalk extending the sidewalks are we are compelled to do that because of the enrollment and the new buses so before you answer it I think the answer is yes my question is is is this not one of

103the things we can go to the township for and ask them to um give us $150,000 for uh the sidewalks since they weren't built before with this presentation we wanted to disclose the need for sidewalks okay um it is not only because of growing enrollment but it's more so to allow more Walkers through the neighborhood uh to minimize the stress on the transportation um component to create safe Pathways and absolutely as Mr poori has discussed with the board previously there is a reserve of money at the township level that's I can't speak to with much um accuracy but there is money for sidewalks that the township has expressed their their cooperation and working with the school district to help pay for those well since it was on there you know is is why I'm speaking

104about it so uh maybe we can look into something look every little bit helps in my opinion um the next thing I'd like to talk about is the facilities um I want to go on record of course as saying I am uh in favor of our uh new construction and and we need to do that and but we have the re our reality is that we've had two failed referendums in that regard and uh in in previous boards we've talked about having plan B's and I remember disappointingly that there were no plan B's very often so I'd like to talk about our plan B um and talk about you know some of the um changes like maybe reviewing all of the architect in in the facilities that we have maybe downscaling our uh our proposals

105for new construction and um you know that could be a plan B to present I'm not saying I but miss armeno I don't think that has anything to do with the budget philosophy that's more well it has to do with money that we don't have and we need facilities let me finish that's fine if you don't think that I'm going to go to the next one uh plan C I'm I'm wondering if we can have as a bud because if we don't have the funds to do our um facility maintenance maybe we should think about having a smaller referendum that won't give us new schools but might give us modular instead of trailers that might um do so so I'm just trying to think out of the box here and present it in our budget

106because once we establish a budget philosophy where do we go from there I'd like to say that maybe we should also have a plan C and have a much smaller facilities Improvement referendum that I think the people can get around just trying to think of things we currently have 1,500 unhoused students at least right which is students beyond the capacities of the schools thanks to the efforts of the principles we're managing quite effectively but in the next 5 years we're projected to have another 1,5 50 students that's 3,000 students as we disclose with the um Bond referendum presentations the only plan B available for that magnitude of unhoused students is trailers and they are included in the slides for uh consideration for next year that's an expensive consequence of failed referenda and that's why we're

107working so hard again with the ad hoc committee with Mr Masters to make sure that this plan is going to be effective and is supported by everyone aren't modular more permanent if we purchase modular instead of rent trailers we are looking at the modular option everything would have to be bid everything would have to be approved by the Department of Education specifications for school construction uh the cheapest available option would certainly be one that we consider Mrs but again this is a longer term issue not onee fiscal operational cycle of a budget philosophy well the reason why I I and I'll complete my statement the reason why I'm bringing it up because yes we have long-term plans but we have short-term needs I'm all for long-term planning but our short-term needs I thought that the

108things that I have said could help us understand our or accommodate our short-term needs and some of that with the with the um facility needs could be part of the Strategic plan of three to five year plan but I I think what they what the list is this wish list that we have tonight on of facilities and books and everything thing it's the the responsibility of the administration to look at every single one of those to go line by line by line and then make that recommendation through committee to the Board of Education as to what they feel that we should have and what we shouldn't so I don't think we're approving having every single thing in the budget this year but these are the needs that we have for the future some of them

109I like I said will be through the ad hoc some of them will be through strategic plan um but I think the immediate needs for the next year has to be um recommended by the the um superintendent the ba the assistant superintendent because they're the people who are in the schools and they have a better idea of what is needed than I know that I do well I'm not speaking for myself only I was at the I was at the green fair and I had a whole lot of different people talking to me I mean I had one woman who was in an age restricted community she had never had children and she said she didn't want to pay school taxes I had a gentleman with school AG children who said he he we certainly

110should build new schools but not an extravagant facility and I I have this written down because I spoke to the people and I want their voice to be heard he said a new a modern building is important to provide classrooms for the student but he he also agreed that the quality of teachers is most important and then over the years ironically Monroe residents who are also teachers and employees have indicated to me that taxes are too high so this is all the macro thought of of the people and that I've also heard um again continually heard criticism that the high school architecture leaves too much space unusable for classrooms so all I'm trying to do in our macro idea is let the administration know what not only I have thought of based on feedback from

111the community so keep in mind when you are doing your budgets that these are the wishes of the community as well as the district yeah and I think all of us have been in that position to hear from the members of the community of what we want and I think that's why we made the ad hoc committee a part of the community and get the input from the community Dr alvik and I had over 30 presentations for the bond referendum we heard from the community loud and clear also with the ultimate speaking which was the results of the referendum we're looking at a new design uh but again that's far beyond the scope of what we're have on the table with the budget philosophy Mrs Lang so in the budget philosophy we're talking about what

112we we anticipate needing to spend in the the forthcoming school year when do we get a chance to talk about other Revenue sources I I think as an Administration you guys did an outstanding job developing building picking up Falcon care and the revenue that's that's springing but we're talking about money going out where do we in this budget process or in the process as a board where do we get to brainstorm or think about ways to bring an additional Revenue into the district or is that just not like I'm not sure how that that works no it certainly doesn't it has started already Dr Alva can speak to this but she's already looking at enhancements of our proprietary funds and our and our summer camps uh Mr uh Tano has offered uh some good suggestive

113ideas for areas to expand the programs we are constantly looking outside of the box to use that tired expression for new Revenue sources here okay we have up as you know a policy for building use that we're looking at also to enhance um maybe people from the outside of the community using our facilities instead of just Monroe people okay but it doesn't it doesn't actually get outlined in like the budget philosophy that's just the work that we're ongoing it it it will be outlined in the uh the every step of the way that we are embarking on going forward with this every committee meeting every business administrator report at every board meeting we're going to talk budget until people don't want to hear it anymore and you're going to hear about all of the creative

114Revenue sources that we're so proud to create because it's a lot easier to create new Revenue sources than to cut right and um and also if cuts are um uh practical and and recommended we will disclose those very early great thank you anyone else Mr M very quick and this might be going into the minutia but I had questions you had a line on them that just said Elementary education two special ed programs $35,000 what is that or it was just General on one of those slides if it's that that's too small to be a Personnel item so it it's probably um outfitting classrooms for that special needs population and then one more thing from the back of my 15-year-old in high school why do we still have textbooks in the high school depends on

115the textbook and it depends on the class there are some textbooks that we cannot get through EB ebooks okay so we have to continue to do textbooks that's something that's reviewed by the um supervisors with the departments at the high school and they decide on what would be the best way to deliver whatever information is being delivered to students can they make ebook a priority or ebooks we have been making it a priority but it really is what's best for whatever that program is okay that I'm not going to go through it not the time and and I just like to to let the public know that there'll be a lot of conversations in probably every committee that has to do with Finance as we move on whether it's Transportation or curriculum especially Finance buildings

116and grounds these these committees are open to the public so you're welcome to come and listen to the debate and the discussions that we will be having because I think um every month from now on until the budget um is is the preliminary budgets due probably in March so we'll be doing this until March so they're open to the community so please come and and listen to the discussion so if there's no further comment I believe there's going to be a resolution read by Mr rutsky I could do that good evening as the uh fin Finance chairman I would like to make a motion that the board of AD establish and adopt a budget Philosophy for the 2020 2021 school year which tasks Administration to prepare a budget that responsibly meets the demands of continuing

117significant student growth and facility needs as well as program and service requirements without exceeding the board's maximum spending Authority which would necessitate going out to a vote while prioritizing the following items subject to the restrictions presented by Administration Seven Things One construction projects to be recommended by Administration on a priority basis curriculum recommendations to be recommended by Administration salary and benefit increases at a conservative range due to their contingent status Transportation recommendations recommended by Administration uh number five to transfer $600,000 from the retained earnings of the Falcon care Early Childhood enrichment proprietary fund as an unrestricted Revenue Source once again this year number six programs as recommended by Administration and last Administration will review existing non-mandated programs and services as deemed necessary with eliminations as a possibility so that's that's always the tough one this

118action by the board will enable the board to fulfill its educational responsibility to District students in a thorough efficient and fiscally prudent manner while concomittant ensuring the maintenance of District resources and Facilities Sarah second are you second Mr Ryback second it guess we've had comment so we'll just no I I second Mr R second Mr R so that it does not talk about the cap are we going to cap above cap what do you recommend to clarify it says without exceeding the board's maximum spending Authority which is Cap plus the use of Bank cap okay anything more than that would necessitate necessitate a vote um and taking the measure as a second question to the community okay and uh from from past results and from what we uh have uh looked at administratively we would

119not recommend that to the board at this time so so 2% cap plus the bank the bank plus the $458,000 a bank Cap all those resources are needed all um un unforeseen revenues that we haven't identified yet as external Revenue sources and grants are needed um everything under the couch is needed this year to meet the needs of this budget Mr poori did you have a question no I I I just want to make a statement especially the last bullet Mr rutsky read about the possible elimination of programs which is a last resort I think we have had a a not a very pleasant experience uh this year about some School uh busing cuts and things like that if we are going to go through any of such things I think we need to put

120a plan uh in place for the parents to choose an option uh rather than letting them know in the last minute I think we we made a mistake in that in that aspect in my opinion so would like to get a little bit more uh to into the weeds before we start looking at cuts that would impact the students or the the families anyone else yes madam that's a very good point Mr P made last year after the bond referendum defeat there was a a strong defensive reaction here administratively and at a board level to conserve resources and that that was the uh the stimulation for the cuts but this is different we have our time we have our our budget timetable which will be posted on the website the calendar soon and uh we

121will disclose everything every step of the way thank you okay roll call Mr gski Mrs Lang yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr Mr Tano yes Mr rutsky yes Mr poori yes Mrs seagull yes Mr Masters yes Mrs armeno yes Mrs Deo yes Mrs K panowich yes madame board president motion establishing a board budget philosophy has passed unanimously and Dr alvic Dr Layman and I appreciate the board's support thank you thank you at this time we'll go to committee reports are there committees that need to report this toight because I know um I think next Monday we have committee reports anyone quick ad hoc update okay quick quick all right so again I'm just following up on some action items uh that the board had requested to the ad hoc committee we are still reviewing I know

122Mr Layman or Dr Layman sorry I can't get that um is reviewing some of the numbers to make sure the four roughly the four proposals that we're looking at or should say ideas um would would be viable uh I had another Committee Member suggest adding one more which was not to remove the ninth grade at all um we're going to review that at the next meeting as an additional proposal uh I had another action item where a board member was asking be which proposals we were were part of the consideration I can give the numbers um quickly it was 479 12 13 14 17 21 24 for a part not really because it's duplicate 27 29 30 31 and 32 uh those are in the meeting minutes in case you don't have your documentation um

123the other ideas I know there's been some discussion about other ideas that the the ad hoc should consider uh we were tasked with addressing the unhoused unit or the unhoused kids units really uh of 3,000 over five years so most of the proposals or the ideas we pulled out um had to do with those 3,000 unhoused students we had other ideas come in for example we had one talking about donations or crowdfunding um although it won't apply really to addressing the 3,000 on housee students we kept it in our like a back burner um something we still could do on a smaller scale so that was one uh split sessions was also still being discussed uh year-long school was not that was removed those was there was some confusion people were asking about that uh

124we are still discussing leasing buildings or leasing other District's uh facilities and we are still discussing modular construction uh actually Jerry T has been doing some research into that we had two proposals one from an actual modular Construction Company um it turned out they would not actually submit a proposal because they don't do school construction um because of a lot of the regulations that that they have uh but we are looking at other modular construction companies uh I know we're trying to contact Edison uh the issue I will warn people though with modular construction we did start doing some number data um usually the the biggest uh uh benefit of modular construction is the speed right because you can be breaking ground and constructing your building at the same time that of doing it sequentially

125uh it's not a do usually not a dollar um benefit uh and if you look at for example what happened up in Edison they added 20 classrooms at a cost of over $4 million for 20 classrooms um and that replaced four trailers so you again it's the enormity of what we're trying to do here with our 3,000 un unhoused students um but again we're going to consider it uh they are a a permanent I'm sorry permanent modular classrooms are good there's something called temporary modular classrooms and I think they're just trailers I think it's a fancy word to say trailers um so we are is still be considered I want to make sure everybody knows that but again we need to make sure that um The Money numbers make sense too do you have a

126date oh do do you have a date for the next Sor it is next week the 14th yeah I had to think about it the 14th yes next week please come out we're going to be discussing some of these things two weeks I think not next next week is the 8th I think so it's October 14 oober 14 okay but please come out it's a public meeting um 7 o' 7 uh 7 o'cl yes okay Madam president since we're talking about the ad hoc committee I just uh want to express my displeasure is probably a strong statement but lack of uh arranging for this Workshop that we've been talking about um I think at at a minimum at the next Bo next ad hoc meeting we should establish a time frame where you would like

127to invite the public to share their thoughts uh if not maybe we should make a motion here to make sure that the ad hog committee gets a date I I think we had been talking about that and we want to break it down so that we have clear pictures of where we want to go and the and then if they're completed if they've completed the work that they have next Monday two two Mondays then we will come up with a date to have the a Township keep in mind that we need to give at least three weeks to four weeks for public to be able to attend it and you know we're already getting into the holiday season we're we're already in October so I'm really concerned that this is being pushed out as as

128long long as it's been as far as it's been we had that conversation already Okay so we've always had the I guess mandate that we wouldn't have the public meeting just to have a public meeting right we wanted to make sure we had decisions made or at least we've had our proposals reviewed and vetted I can have a meeting tomorrow and we won't have the numbers and we won't know which uh proposals we're going to move forward and it'll be of zero usage to the public or this board so again that's what I said at the last meeting we want to make sure we know the committee knows what it's proposing before it proposes it again we just had another Committee Member add a proposal okay no I I perfectly understand it but at the

129same time it it cannot be in its perpetuity that it Cas keeps going on we got to end this ad committee at some point in time with the recommendation without a timeline I don't I don't think anybody any one of us should work so I I can we expect a date to be announced after your next meeting at the next board meeting I'll have to talk to the committee thank you okay any other committees need to report okay then we'll go to public forum anyone from the public wishing to speak to the agenda please come to the microphone state your name and address for the record we have a 4minute timeline and when the timer goes off your time is over and we can only come up once per public forum thank you Pradip Milam

130for place so let's talk about budget philosophy at a macro level our priority is kids first that's our district philosophy as well so we want kids first kids programs first kids teachers first then remaining anything that you are going to cut or not it's up to you that's at a macro level but in micro level if I go through I've been hearing we have been exploring the growth growth growth from 16 to 17 there was 136 more students on 17 to 18 sorry from 16 to 17 to 17 to 18 there are only 136 kids or more in our schools from 18 to 19 we have only 22 students we added and from last year to this year we opened according to your today's agenda we have added only 65 kids we are not adding

131hundreds of hundreds of students as we expected as it's been repeated I don't know whether you guys read the Ross Harbor Associates uh given the the last demographic report on 91 2018 I read through it according to them in 2090 and any demographic report they are not going to give one number to you they always give you two numbers one without housing two with maximum housing that is being according to the master plan now according to their number the 2019 and 2020 number is 6904 without housing and right now we are at 6827 Which is far below than that okay and with the full housing if at all full housing and according to the demographer it should be 7,341 we are nowhere near to that I don't know why you guys are like every time

132you guys are every statement they are saying like we are exploding in growth we are exploding in growth these are the numbers these are the facts from your agendas and your thing and I don't know why you guys are not accommodating the second one this is according to the kids now teachers from the last four five agendas and four five meetings of minutes I read through there are 20 resignations from the teachers and all are these 20 resignations are I'm talking about only teachers and I go through the High School requirements or like open positions still there is a physics and chemistry teacher at highest at high school two family counselors and science teachers at food and one special education teacher and a math teacher these are all open since an year I don't know

133what you guys are doing like without recruiting these guys and how our students are excelling and what if if you included if you recruited these many teachers and we might have in a better position and there was a statement 65 million is going towards the salaries I agree we are a big school district we have to pay the teachers sufficiently I want to know and this is a direct question what percentage or what is the actual dollar amount that we are paying for teachers actual teachers and what the actual amount that we are paying for teaching staff and the rest of it I want to know it and that's it and one more last question Mr Masters is going to attend the ad hoc committee meetings as a Boe member or ad hoc committee chairman

134I think it's a conflict of interest how can he be on board he can be on ad hoc committee board I don't know unless legal is cleared can he attend at a board member and ad hoc committee president I think it's very unusual situation it um we have talked to the board attorney about that and he has every right to be a board member and the chair of the ad hoc committee the ad hoc committee or any ad hoc committee is created by the board president and only the board president can um create the ad hoc make chairs remove chairs and at this time there is no reason to remove Mr Masters as chair of the ad hoc okay is there any answer there there was bug okay is there any answer for the the

135the salaries Madam if gentleman wishes to give me a call I could I could uh calculate that information for him but aggregate District at salaries is the macro presentation that we've always taken with the budget philosophy we don't show that level of detail it's it's uh necessary for this stage of the budget but give me a call and I'll be happy to give you the information I'm not asking for like more details like how much you are paying for high school how much you are paying for math how much you paying for science I'm asking at a global at a macro level only how much is teaching percentage how much is not teaching assistant percentage how much is non- teaching staff and I don't think we have that information here with us this evening that's

136beyond the scope of tonight's presentation F further you know you mentioned about the enrollment the gentleman Oprah requested 15 years worth of enrollment data and enrollment projections I'm not sure which data he's referring to I have I have the from the last eight years from the that we presented which are audited asssa numbers we picked up 1100 students over the last8 years no I'm talking okay I didn't say last 8 years I've been talking about from 16 to 16 17 years to 1718 the timer has gone off I understand I'm waiting for an answer and he pointing that I'm I'm representing a wrong data I'm representing exactly your data here well he just gave you the answer from the last eight years we've made over 1100 students 1100 over the last date that's indisputable it's

137audited information okay so at this time in my comments I added only last three years of data we didn't increase like not more than all together not more than 200 students anyone else from the public wishing to speak to the agenda prash parab 33 D I drive is not political I know we are struggling with the budget I wish our mayor and the council people are here here because it is our district issue it is our district it is our Township issue not a legislation issue the growth and all we are facing I wish they were there and I wish they watch the video and understand my simple question is you know more people are coming in the town more houses are there what is the revenue suppose 100 people are there they're paying only

1381,000 tax we are 100,000 how if we are 125 Le than 125,000 so my simple question is what is the revenue coming in in the in the town from last last year to this year what is the revenue coming in that's a simple question do you have that information I cannot answer it's not a simple question how much revenue is coming into the town I could speak the school district issues then that's what we want to know because if the revenue is coming in and the government says give back the money back to the taxpayers and you have only 2% cap it doesn't add in you know we have suppose the last year budget was 135 you can only increase by another 2.7 million okay that is not sufficient now you look like yeah that

139is not sufficient Apple got you need $15 million to repair that school you know money is not sufficient the how the government is squeezing us not allowing us we cannot increase we cannot increase our budget at the same time the money is coming in and we have to redistribute to the town what is you guys have to think how get the if that is equation is lacking that is my single simple question Mr goosi please answer us in the next meeting because we want to know if they are squeezing Us in different ways how we can UNS squeeze them okay because this is not acceptable because we need construction of ha God we need repairs we need maintenance we need books for the children you know we have to hear today entire 45 minutes political

140discussion how we can fight the budget what the state level is doing what the formula is doing we know it what we can do we need money there what we can do what how we can get it without cutting the programs Dr PR I appreciate everything you just said you just added full support for a new funding formula which is the problem and the Restriction of where the school revenues are coming from we need a new funding formula that is not enough because new funding formula we may get another 10 million but our budget is 135 million 145 it is not going to solve you know impact fee some gentlemen says it's impossible come on talking about this for several years that is not true 25 states in United States have impact fees as IL

141legal and we can make it legal here if we have a strength okay so I want to know actually Mr GOI in simple terms go if the revenue is coming and they are putting only 2% cap on you to increase the budget okay and they're telling that revenue is coming give back money to the civilians something is wrong something is wrong I want to know I can meet you I want to discuss this you're welcome to call me meet any time yeah I want to meet you in person and want to understand and you can give it a simple way we don't understand budgetary language I tell you we want simple language right thank you hi good evening I Nelson 87 Crescent way to the mic ion Nelson 87 Crescent Way um my question is

142this um very interesting that you have a strategic uh action plan but since I've been coming to these meetings we've had three superintendents two interim superintendant various search committees um my understanding is we have a new high school principal and I happen to have thought he did a good job and I want to know how this ties in what is going on with all of these folks coming and going how does this tie in with our strategic plan you can have all the plans that you want but if if we don't have retention of key people let alone of regular teaching staff what are we left with plans well the Strategic plan will be a 5-year plan on where the district wants to go it could include Personnel it could not include Personnel how could

143it not include Personnel well it it when we get the community input it depends on what the community feels are the strengths weaknesses of our district and we will move in that direction um it it's it's not something that will be done in a day or a week why have we had this turnover of these people well the interims were here just for the for um the the one year um we've had U one superintendent that was not renewed we had one superintendent that that left the district for whatever reason years ago so we had one then we had an interim then we had another one who was not renewed by the Board of Education and then we had an interim and then we did a superintendent search last year and the board decided to

144go and um appoint Dr Alvi to that position if you find that acceptable that's great um on my end uh I certainly don't uh you need when you have key people in positions and they are doing a satisfactory job I mean I've worked in Industry you start losing people you start having turnover with your key people with teaching staff that hurts that affects you adversely there is no way that there's anything positive going on when these kinds of things happen sometimes sitting here you have to wonder if there's any kind of hostile environment between the folks up here and the administrative staff that's out there I mean I don't know I'm not close to it at all but just judging it just sitting here and seeing the results and activity in terms of what's been

145going on I mean I don't know what kind of conclusions you can have but certainly it's a very very negative thing and it's a reflection really on the folks sitting here that this thing keeps happening let's hope it doesn't happen again in the future thank you Krishna Le Jake please um I have a couple of questions um there was a talk about um turning down programs or um you know cancelling programs that are no longer functional or no longer feasible do we have a criteria for um I mean again uh for each of the programs do we have a success criteria a failure criteria what constitutes a success criteria what constitutes a failure criteria yeah Dr Al I could probably answer that question because I know we go through the course of studies and all

146the activities that we do every year to see what's working and what's not working but she can explain that a little bit better than I'm not sure what programs you mean we have so many different types of program for each of these programs when we set up a program are we saying hey we're um for example photography was one that I can pick up the that happened like you know we only ran for a year when we start off photography um there was a particular reason why we started off and then uh when we when you do that special U programs right I mean technically there should have been a success criteria why would why how can we call that program as being successful and why can and what under what circumstances can we call

147this program if you mean classes I think he means clubs clubs or clubs or any programs right yeah that that's that's what I'm confused about do you mean classes do you mean clubs do you mean sports clubs right so at the high school or at the middle school at both because it's different at each at each level but do you have the success and failure criteria yes okay absolutely we um Mr Kella comes to the curriculum committee every year at the high school and he he um shares the data of the clubs and um the attendance of the clubs he visits every Club at the high school um so there's an ongoing process at the high school at the middle school they actually survey the students each year to see what clubs would be and

148the teachers to see what clubs would be offered at at that level okay and um who would I have to reach out to get that information to get what information information about the clubs what kind of information that's what I'm asking crer the success failure criteria and what kind of so if if you should reach out to uh either school's Administration okay um and then U on the macro level you're talking about $20 million on construction projects right did the board or the administration ever consider going out with a smaller referendum to handle this um construction I I think that's the process that we're going through now with the ad hoc committee to find a a plan that we could go out for that the that is something that the residents of Monroe could support

149and is fiscally responsible to everybody so isn't that a scope crep because the way adoc committee was established was to handle the unhoused students goe and code but now we're saying that we're also adding in to see if we can go in with the smaller referendum for it well we're trying to come up with the plan which could be modular or something that is less costly than the plans we've had in the past that will house the 3,000 unhoused students that we expect to have within the next 5 years okay and about the unhoused students the question that I want to have is the unhoused students how are you calculating it are you calculating it on the day the school was opened or after the smaller constructions were done to handle this so each of

150the school when it opened up had a particular floor plan now you're um repurposed some of the rooms we've U made the room smaller and all that so are you looking at the newer constructions when you're calculating the unhoused students Madam the answer is yes when we add trailers for example uh those trailers accommodate unhoused students and they're no longer unhoused they're they're housed in the trailer so okay they reduced that number yes and all of that is through our long range facilities plan that has to be updated with any changes that are made to our buildings got it one question um change is my time up or yes okay Christy scurby 21 pness Drive uh we sit here tonight and we talk about a budget philosophy in order to move ahead and develop a

151budget we need to reflect on what we did this past year when we said we didn't have any money we found money to give the business administrator raise making him one of the highest paid Bas in the county we found money to hire a superintendent with a contract that increases the salary each year we found money to hire an assistant superintendent with a competitive salary we found money for all of this that's why I'm confident that when the teacher contract negotiations begin this year we will find the money to pay our teaching staff what they deserve our teachers are some of the lowest paid in the county while we find the money to keep our administrative salaries at the top range we continue in Monroe to see high quality teachers leave for other positions and

152other districts for more money we cannot allow this to continue we need to retain the exceptional staff we have this is what makes us a great dis District I'm also confident you can find the money to keep all the programs and services for our students that are offered that is Paramount here excellent staff and wonderful programs equal success for our students anything less is unacceptable and anyone else on the public wishing to speak to the agenda good evening ram ram rnat 60 strive um I appreciated the points uh last set of points Miss Lang raised about the revenue generation opportunities and ideas uh so is it possible I don't know maybe at the next meeting just like you went through the budget philosophy maybe you can go through your Revenue generation philosophy is the board

153and the president open to you know putting some of those on the table so that the public can hear and maybe even give some suggestions if anybody ever had a a revenue source that we could look at they're welcome to bring it to a board meeting or to finance meeting excuse me a finance meeting maybe next Monday Madam having a special meeting just to do that no no no no no no no just to be clear I thought in the finance meeting and stuff I don't think the public can speak right no right so two two things just to be very clear one I think one it's the responsibility of this board right to be putting that much thought also to the revenue generation right I want to hear your creative ideas what are those

15410 new ideas you have come up with right then the public can add on to it right just like you came you came up with a 29 million increase in Need for uh right right so that's what I'm asking for can the board members put some time think through what ideas they can come up with maybe walk through a presentation just like this Wars and then the public can add to it we can look at that for our future meeting yeah like example like if the Falcon care is a success why can can we challenge ourselves to double the revenue of Falcon care for next year right because of a lack of space I don't know I guess always for every problem there's a solution right so that's why I'm asking can we put that

155we can rename appleg as Johnson and Johnson Elementary School right so I don't know right so what are those things that can be put on the table I think we should put as much effort into that as we are trying to identify that um that's one second is I think prep's point and a couple of others right it's appalling to see the number of resignations of teachers and so on and again is that connected to the budget are we paying our teachers competitive salaries and I think the gentleman before we lost our superintendent we lost a couple of folks right are we doing a root cause analysis to see why are we losing so many good teachers some good administrators right and there's always an opportunity cost there's a cost for getting a new teacher

156on right and if you're still looking for physics chemistry Math teachers for over a year students are paying a price right so I think some of that thinking uh needs to to take place and you have to reflect that here um the last point I wanted to make connecting the budget this you talked about the Apple guard probably 20 million uh renovation I'm surprised right if we are I think it sounds like little desperation for me right why some of that didn't come up last year even in the referendum right there was never 20 20 million is a big number it could have been added in part of the previous referendums right but and then um Mr Masters uh made the point I guess in uh about about the Edison or where they paying 4

157million for 20 classrooms right modular construction what have you that sounds great to me if you can get 40 classrooms in the high school for 8 million for the next school year I think you can get away without having trailers uh in the high school right so again we need to have such quick rapid thinking and concrete ideas um right put on the table uh you know the last point I wanted to make is also I don't have the facts but I recall I was trying to Google it the internet is weak here I thought the Princeton board over the last couple of years have always gone sought permission to go over the 2% cap they have found creative ways to do that so why can't we do the same it we you could always

158go over the 2% cap but then the the the um it would be a second question and the um public would have to vote on that if you went over the 2% cap okay so again let's yes if we went above the maximum spending Authority which is a 2% cap and exhausted all the bank cap you'd have to go to the the community and uh present those needs of course you you do an analysis beforehand and you say what is the probability of success here the last time we did that we lost with 80% no 20% yes votes if I recall correctly when we put out a second question um and you had you made a a very um intriguing uh point before about welcoming The public's participation in looking for additional Revenue sources we

159certainly don't have all the answers here uh the ex the development of falc care and ECE came from a former board member Mr Luke hman Who challenged the board to take over a program that we were um allowing someone else to host and make all that money and we did so effectively so I would encourage anybody who's interested in look uh to to suggest additional Revenue sources for the district take a look at our website first we have comparative sources of revenue you'll see where all of our revenues come from from Grants taxes state aid Etc miscellaneous income and uh we would welcome any recommendations that anybody may have thank you for bringing up than you thank you anyone else wishing to speak to the agenda seeing none we'll close the public forum and go

160to the superintendent's report Dr Alvin okay so on this evening superintendent report you'll see the final proposed board and District goals um each member also has a copy of them in front of you and I've also provided with you the action plan for the district goals um just a brief update on those goals already um the whole child committee actually met last week um it was such an exciting day we had over 75 staff members who are interested in being on the committee this year and they are working um we've divided up into to six subgroups and you um you can see those listed on your action plans so each subgroup is uh working toward their goal um of providing parent nights providing professional development for staff providing um uh creating a crisis response protocol

161manual um so there's a lot of different things happening um we're actually looking to plan our uh a whole child parent night for K to 12 last year we just did Elementary this year we're actually looking to expand it to middle school and high school um because the the uh the subcommittee wants to do that um so we're going to be planning that for November and again that's just that's an ongoing process so we're still continuing that um tonight you also heard from Miss fredman um so uh at the next board meeting I will be proposing that we work with her on the Strategic action planning process um that she spoke about this evening on this board report you will see a recommendation for a wood for the Woodland School principal to replace Dr Layman

162um for Mrs Samantha McLoud uh Samantha started in our district as a teacher in 2006 and has been the assistant principal at mil Lake and Woodland School for the past four years um so at this time I would recommend that the board approve the attached Personnel items a through AQ so move Mr R Mr comments or questions for Dr Al Mr Masters can you just clarify AJ AJ so what um we approved the tag teachers at the middle school um but what we found is due to the enrollment we have to lower the number so in order to so instead of just saying we're just cutting certain teachers we're going to repost those positions so those those that those positions will be rescinded we will be reposting them after that okay thank you based on

163student enrollment that's good all right Mr Poes Dr alv do you have numbers of how many uh teaching staff is leaving and how many are coming in because there's a lot of talk about teachers leaving the district but we also have people coming in we do what's what's the number of proxim we we have a vacancy report I I actually will be presenting it at the Personnel committee on Monday evening I look at it every month um so we are replacing the position so one of the questions that I I I heard during public forum was we're not we don't have a math teacher we don't have a a physics teacher those positions we've never had those teachers used the 17% to cover those courses so it's not that the teacher left and we couldn't

164replace them that's why we use the 17% um we are fully staffed almost fully staffed remember we we have an acting principal at the high school right now um we did not replace his position because we knew it was a temporary position we're in the process of of of of a search for a high school principal so we don't have that there are a couple of positions that um are open because people are leaving we hold them their 60 days and then they go um we also do exit surveys for every single staff member who's leaving they're not all leaving for higher paying teaching jobs many of them are leaving for other administrative positions in the in the state or and others are leaving to go out of state thank you Mr R I'd just

165like to congratulate Mr McLoud on on H new position hopefully we'll vote in favor it and uh know that later I just I just was kind of excited because I got to know her over over the years and I personally feel that she's absolutely the right choice for this job anyone else then we will have a roll call Mr G Personnel items a through AQ Mr rutsky yes Mr Tano yes Mrs Deo yes Mrs Lang yes Mr poori yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr Masters yes Mrs seagull yes Mrs armino yes Mrs K Pano yes Madam board president indeed Mrs McLoud was appointed Personnel items a through AQ has passed unanimously okay congratulations [Applause] congratulations go on to board action items Madame president's recommended that the board approve the attached board action items a through n

166as in ncy so moved second Mr poori Mr Tano again comments or questions for Dr Alber seeing none we'll have a roll call Mrs Deo yes Mrs Lang yes Mrs armeno yes Mrs seagull yes Mr Tano yes Mr rybec yes Mr rutsky yes Mr Masters yes thank you sir Mr poori yes Mrs K Pano man on board president board action items a through n has passed unanimously and that concludes my report there's new report Madam this month there is no business administrative report okay so uh we'll go to the board president's report and mine is going to be um just an update on a couple of things um the first has to do with the special education bills that are in Trenton um we as a board don't support a bill until we know what

167the ramifications would be to our school district so just because the bill is out there doesn't necessarily mean it would be good for Monroe so before we do anything we me we need to have our administrators look at it make sure it's right from Monroe and at this point they're in the process of doing that so there has been no recommendation from um administration at this point to support those bills um my second item is looking to sue the state for a fair share of funding for a new funding formula or a funding of any kind um back in September the board approved and I know Mr Gorski mentioned this before the engaging the weener Law Group group to look into our ability to sue the state they have requested probably hundreds and hundreds of

168pages of documentation including our past budget information qack information information on the past two referendums state aid our different contracts and so much more they will be going over all this information that was sent to them and coming up with a recommendation to sue the state or reasons why we will not be able to sue the state to sue the St just to say that we are suing the state when we know we don't have a chance of winning would not be an appropriate expenditure of taxpayer monies so this this um log group is looking at everything we have and when they finish digesting all the information we will be meeting with them and they will come up with a recommendation for us so that's where we stand with um the state and and uh

169the law firm at this point um Other Board of Education business is there any new business or business from any member of the Board of Education Mr Masters I just wanted to recognize over this past weekend uh Monroe High School soccer uh triumphed over Monclair and it was a pretty great win for them that montclair's ranked much higher than uh our soccer team is so it was an exceptional win um but not only only that they showed really great deal good deal of sportsmanship in the wind so I just wanted to make sure they were recognized they did a great job um also on Saturday the high school marching band in the color guard not the twirlers I learned my lesson by calling them twirlers um took first place in their first competition so they

170did a really good job that was at South Brunswick it was uh it was pretty hot that day too so they really did uh did a great job so I just wanted to make sure we recognize them thank you anyone else okay so we're back to public forum anyone from the public wishing to speak please come to the microphone state your name and address for the record and we will um adhere to the same things we've always adhere to prakash pup 33 D drive you talked about the special education bills uh I will have a conversation with Mr GOI and others uh you know because I had written to we had written to three bills were there want to know why they are not acceptable to the administration because I received a letter response from

171our legislation that they will support one bill the first bill and the answer was it will bring Revenue uh to our Township so want to understand the thinking of the legislatures versus what is the thinking of the administrators here okay so that is important and another one thing is when we formed adoc committee okay we were not told that you are going to select people who have no bias okay and then you selected people who had no bias according to your presentation two or 3 months back okay now we are going to have new strategic planning team okay and you need 100 of people again don't tell us that we are selecting people who are no clue okay we come here for every meeting and stay here to 10:00 because we have interest in our

172school to go in a positive direction and you didn't even select me for that that's okay but you said I took the language that you will not you have selected people who don't have bias either way but there are people you know I need not to name them on the adoc committee who have view so what is the answer tell me the adoc committee you said you gave a statement when you finished when the ad committee was formed you said that President you said that you selected the people which you have there is no bias and are you satisfied that that the people who are on the adoc committee don't have any bias I am confident in the committee to do the job that they were asked to do I'm not I never I never

173Ed the word biased and the committee was chosen by two members of the Board of Education and five members of the administration who went over each and every application that came in I think we will get the what statement you gave you know we'll go over the statement the taping is there the videos we can go back yeah yeah St yeah yeah so let us go and make sure that what you said after the selection of the adoc committee and they you are following those okay that's the question okay yeah so anyway coming strategic plan any person can join that strategic plan there will be no we will not be leaving anybody off this strategic plan anybody who wishes to be a part of that will be a plan thank you that okay this is

174on the tape and hope that will be the case and I'll respect that okay I'll respect that if you follow that okay and another one thing on the impact fees you know you all found a resolution there is a bill on the impact fee in the legislation today there is a bill sitting in and it was introduced last year okay so if you're really interested don't tell me impact fee we cannot not do it in next 10 years there's a big lobing now the philosophy is changed if legislators want that bill I talk to you know Senator Greenstein and she said she wants to modify the bill I said five months back she said she will modify then I talked to her again and she said prakash I will try to other I will co-sponsor

175it so I will we you know so there is a will there so please talk to the legislatur on that impact fee bill is there okay and we can push it now you know the public backing is there public heart is there we can do that we did we did approve a resolution Tok to do that yeah thank you I know that thank you very much thank you good evening Betty s burito to Barry Moore Drive I want to address events that occurred at the last Board of Ed meeting and it is unfortunate what is currently going on with our board as board members you serve the public and as such as you very well know you're subject to being scrutinized and criticized that's part of the position of serving the public however as I

176mentioned to you madam president and yourself Mr paror it is not appropriate for you to do the same to taxpayers and residents at the end of the last meeting a member of the public and taxpayer Mrs scurby was verbally attacked by members of the Board of Ed that is what happen this was appalling to see and I ask both Madam president and Mr poori to please put a stop to this the attacks made were done so in front of my children they were very upset about this Mr Pio had to get involved um I do want to thank you Mrs armeno because you seem to be the only one who stood up for the resident this needs to stop as it seems that the board does not have a clear idea of what their mission

177and position is and the actions are showing that there are personal agendas here given the current situation in Monroe the Board needs to focus on the issues that affects taxpayers and students not on personal attacks of any Resident in this town this leads me to the fill in position of the board of ed for Mr cha seat I came up at the last meeting to voice my disappointment at not being interviewed and mentioned that it was concerning to me that my application wasn't received and that the only candidate that would be interviewed was a candidate that had already been endorsed for the upcoming election by several board members that was the essence of my statement I did not personally attack anyone as that is not the way I operate I don't find it productive however

178that candidate Mr Masters chose to personally attack me I don't take well to that you do not know me please do not do that again in the future you came up saying that I was irresponsible and that it wasn't important to me and that if it was I shouldn't have depended on anyone else so I ask you who did you depend on you sent your application only 2 hours before the deadline and then waited for a response which you got within 11 minutes you also said I should take responsibility for my actions so that I want to assume that you're going to take responsibility for your actions at the last board meeting you later stated that you should support the board as a whole and pro proceeded to aggressively confront a board member Mr tufano

179Madame President at that time you reprimanded Mr tufano oddly enough at a previous this board meeting Mr poori had done the had a similar exchange with members of the public but you reprimanded the public you then spoke at and advised the member at that time with Mr poori that that was uncalled for so I don't understand this double standard you need to understand that the public is taking notice of this division on the board and the favoritism to the new board member you then went on to speak about taxpayers speaking at Board of Ed meetings but not putting in the effort to volunteer were you implying that those of us who come to every board meeting not just during the election when we run but every board meeting should not be able to voice our

180concerns or comments when we are footing the bill for the education in this town is that how you think the board is going to be United cuz I don't to conclude what occurred the other night was inappropriate unacceptable and this town and Board needs a change before this gets worse I implore you Dr alvic to try and do something with this board I know you have a difficult job but what happened the other night was completely unacceptable and I want to say again my two children and another small child were here and to have to get security involved over a verbal attack of a citizen is never appropriate thank you anyone else on the public wishing to speak okay then I will close public forum and before we go into um Clos session I have

181a statement that I wish to read and um it has been approved by five other board members I feel is it imperative to make this statement at this time because Mr Ken Chella has made some very serious statements about six members of this board of education which are blatantly false members of the board are elected officials who serve the school community in a volunteer capacity without pay for the good of the students and the staff in this District these board members expend countless hours and effort in their capacity as board members attending committee meetings board meetings meetings with legislative officials as well as attending numerous events throughout the school Community these board members also expend countless hours attending workshops to receive training on every facet of the role of a board member and the responsibilities

182of boards of Education most importantly these board members take their ethical obligations extremely seriously and they comply with the code of ethics for school board members in return for all this time and effort these members are routinely subjected to false statements criticism and several of these members have been subjected to meritless ethics complaints in the past year all of which were summarily dismissed as a matter of law while I will not address all of Mr tiel's false statements at this time I want to be clear that my decision to not address each of his statements on social media does not indicate that any of these statements have any truth to them not withstanding the foregoing Mr Chella statement that six members of the Board of Education conducted an illegal meeting and violated their ethical obligations

183as Board of Education me Members is patently false and defamatory that's all I have to say on that study at this time I will go into the closed session resolution be it resolved that the Board of Education of the township of Monroe hereby moves to go into closed session in accordance with the Sunshine Law chapter 231 of the public laws of 1975 NJ ESS 10 col 4-6 through 10 col 4-21 to discuss the following subjects harassment intimidation and bullying I believe so following closed session action may be taken the discussion conducted in closed session can be disclosed to the public at such time as the need for confidentiality no longer exists second motion yes second M Mr Mr Rybeck Mrs Lang all in favor I oppos so we should be in 10 minutes at the

184most okay at this time the board is back public session and seeing no in the public to respond to the public forum for Clos session our next scheduled Board of Education meeting will be scheduled for October 16 2019 7:00 p.m. at the Monro Township High School motion to adjourn so moved Mr Mr Ryback Mrs Lang all in favor I opposed then at this time the meeting is adjourned Fant

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.