001good evening the meeting of the Monro Township Board of Education will come to order please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance I pled aliance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all Mr Gorski may we please have a roll call certainly Mrs armenio here Mr Chella Mrs Deo here Mrs Kono here Mrs Lang here Mr poori here Mr Ryback here Mrs seagull here Mr Tano here Mr rutsky here Madame board president you have a quarum present this evening in accordance with the provisions of the New Jersey open public meetings law the Monroe Township Board of Education has caused notice of this meeting to be published by having the DAT time and place thereof posted August
00216th 2019 at all schools the home News Tribune primberry press and filed with the clerk of the municipality thank you so before we get into the approval of the minutes I would just like to thank Mr Ryback for the fantastic job you did in filling in for me when I was away in July and um this makes me feel like I could do it again and and know that I'm left the board in capable hands and I'm sure you did but I would like to welcome because this is the first time that I've had the opportunity to sit here with Dr alvik as our new superintendent and I'm very excited to move Mo forward uh sitting next to you with Mr um Gorski and working together thank thank you so at this time we'll have
003the approval of the minutes for the public Board of Education meeting June 19th 2019 so moved Mr poori and second by Miss Deo any additions or Corrections okay all in favor I opposed abstain recuse okay then the Clos session meeting of June 19th 2019 Motion in a second second so moved Mr Mayo second by Mr Ryback additions or corrections to the minutes uh I'd just like to say that the um Clos session minute meeting since it it's over not going to say anything specific however you have a oneline uh uh statement about the superintendent evaluation and I think it should be a little bit more detailed than that it was a lively discussion and um again I don't think it's reasonably comprehensible to have but nothing at all on that closed session so okay thank
004you for your comments all in favor I opposed M yes you're opposing okay Miss armeno is opposing any abstain or recusals okay then the public Board of Education meeting of July 17 2019 so Mr POI second by Mr Ryback uh additions or corrections to the minutes okay seeing none all in favor I opposed I am going to abstain so no any recusals then last the closed session meeting of July 17 2019 Motion in a second motion second m Miss am Mino Mr I keep thinking of what Mrs Mrs um Lang always says about you but we'll call you Mr rutsky okay that's good yeah it was nothing bad um any additions or corrections to the close session minutes I would just like to say since I frequently um object to close session minutes in this
005one was about students and a um a settlement so I do think that it it was reasonable that um these closed under this particular case that these closed minutes uh were appropriate okay but P primarily they are not but this one is thank you all in favor I I opposed I'm going to recuse so not and I'm going to abstain not recuse okay and no recuses so at this time we have one presentation on our agenda this evening um we would like to have an update on the ad hoc committee and I have asked Mr Lou Masters who is chair of the ad hoc committee to come before the board in the public this evening to give us an update on what's been going on with the ad hoc and where we stand at this
006point Thank you Mr Masters thank you don't worry it's not that long I have a lot of papers though so again thank you for letting me give an update uh to the board president and to the board of V I know I can there you go can you hear me hear me now I don't want to get too close CU then it's um so yeah I am the chair of the newly sanctioned ad hoc basically the extension of this Board of Ed to look at growth uh or issues with growth and how it relates to this Board of Ed and this District I want to make this a regular update to the board of ed so you're all filled in yes it is a public meeting very transparent you can come but again I'd rather
007come here and basically brief you and answer questions about what's been going on and what we've been talking about now the committee I'm going to start from the very beginning then and hopefully this is the last time we have to talk about this uh the committee was built from a a wide varied different demographic of the entire District right we have parents and teachers and retired folks and business people and all kinds of that uh we did that basically so that we can get a a different level of brainstorming and try to figure out what we're going to do to address these this growth now the function of the committee uh in case you've you've heard is a little bit different than what we've done in the past I mean in the past we've all
008gotten together as a committee hundreds and hundreds of people we've brainstormed ideas we've vetted them we've gone through the same people have talked about it and we've proposed them to the Board of Ed this one we thought we're not going to be the sole source of ideas this time we're going to go out to the community and ask them for help right now why did we do that U well recognizing that a committee can't have all the expertise that your community is going to have we need to leverage all the educational expertise we have in town teachers and administrators past staff uh all the people with the business Acumen that we have a lot of people with a lot of business expertise a lot of political expertise that we have and how to move around
009the bureaucracy and also the people that have this passion to uh see this this school district succeed um so that's why we wanted to go out and solicit ideas now that doesn't mean people on the committee couldn't have ideas too but we wanted just make sure we got a u a wide a varied um uh uh set of proposals to the committee um my son always says it's like we were crowdsourcing ideas for how to address uh issues with the district now over several weeks uh we held open for several weeks we extended a little bit uh we got 31 plus uh proposals I think there was two extras that were actually submitted the night of um the last uh day for the proposals um they all went to the committee right the only thing
010I asked um Dr oit to do was obfuscate the names or any kind of identifying remarks but everything else was intact um and what we did after that was we met about 3 weeks ago uh to basically develop the proposal requirements right we didn't want to do it ahead of time we wanted to do it in collaborative we wanted to do it in public so everybody saw what we were doing uh we also had to establish expectations going into this there was a lot of expectations about um we're going to do this we're going to do that and we had to make sure that the committee knew that all we can do basically is recommend to this Board of Ed uh what we think is a really good idea or we think is a good
011idea for growth or addressing some of this and that's pretty much where it stops all right I always say that this committee the ad hoc committee for growth is an extension of the Board of Ed uh it's a temporary committee that the Board of Ed is using to basically Source ideas so after that what we did is we had to address these 31 or we had to look into these 31 uh plus proposals 32 or 34 whatever it is now um we broke it into two different uh phases right the first phase we always call called triage um that's what we always call it where you basically get out of the ones that a are illegal you know some of them are some of the proposals were illegal not overtly illegal but things you can't
012do because of state law or U Municipal law anything that was unethical you know they recommended firing people or massive layoffs or stuff like that um anything that negatively impact thorough and efficient education we removed and the last one which actually is really important but you have to keep remember anything that wasn't under this Bo of edge perview so when we had stuff about this state and have the state do this and have this again we weren't going to review those because there's nothing this Board of Ed can do in that aspect um so once that was done we developed that uh set of requirements we also developed the requirements for an advanced review so that's going to be the ones that have the meat and the ones we really want to dig into uh
013and there were basically two were they two requirements are they sound and able to be implemented by the bo Board of Ed and the other one was was it worth expending this board of Ed's resources we don't want to come to you with a bunch of ideas and and it's not in the realm of even being considered um so those were the two basically stratifications of review that we were going to do now one thing I will say as a caveat is some of them had good ideas and some some triaged ideas mixed in we pulled out the good ideas um we said we' put them in a bucket and those would be other ideas that we could mix together later on it wasn't that it was an all or nothing you know we don't
014like something on and it's gone we did um try to yank out what we had and there was some very common threads which I'll get to at the next meeting not this meeting because I told Kathy I try to keep this to about eight minutes um so where are we now um that's if there's any questions on that I can answer but where are we now so we removed 59% of the proposals um roughly 19 of them uh didn't satisfy the triage uh because of some one of the things I um talked about uh we have 13 pretty meaty ones left we also have about six or seven pieces from those other 19 that we have some of them do overlap with the 13 that's not a big deal um and we've requested more information
015from our experts now this is where the experts come in where we are we're relying on the board experts um or any industry experts to come in and tell us more information about some of these ideas basically provide all that background information um just a couple of things that we did keep on the list I know were we had a big discussion about donations and how far donations can come um you know can you get $137 million in donations probably not but maybe you can get enough donations for a new a new classroom retrofiting a classroom or something like that um we had a lot of discussion about changes in sessions and the school year which we're going to discuss tomorrow night again these are ideas that we have to vet and discuss we're not
016saying we're going with any of these these are just some of the great ideas um one of the other things the committee did was we did ask for an updated demog graphic study and I think it's under ba report A2 so I would hope that you would vote for that we need upto-date numbers so we can basically uh feed them into some of these ideas we're looking at and and get an accurate representation of what we're looking at so that was a lot right um we are meeting tomorrow night at 6:30 please come by we are going over the action items from the last meeting uh we had some you know go look into some things for us we we were curious about how the district would do certain things um and we also requested
017some data some class data some grade data things like that we want to go over that and then we will start doing the level two review of proposals this is the more mey review of the proposals where you get into them and see if they actually hold water um not in light of of education but also in light of the district um now the committee does keep I actually write them and approves all the minutes they are approved by the committee uh and they will be posted I think on the district website for everybody to review now the reason I'm saying that is I hate to bring it up there were some that were posted on social media that weren't 100% accurate I want to make sure that people come to the committee or you
018can call me or go U Facebook message me and I'll tell you any information you want um I want to make sure you're getting the accurate representation of what the committee is considering uh there there was a couple things on there that weren't even mentioned during the meeting I want to make sure everybody knows that um if you want the source of Truth go to the committee itself um so that's all I really have if you have questions uh thank you for the time was that 8 minutes probably a little longer sorry uh and one last thing I just want to wish my wife a happy anniversary uh for the third time this is the third board meeting that I've actually separated my anniversary I do bring you to the greatest places hun sorry so
019if there's any questions now or if you want to wait till later I can talk to anybody later do anybody have any questions for Mr Masters Mr poori I have a couple of questions uh did you look at the demographic report that was done last year we looked at it and that's why we came up with the we want a newer demographic report yes okay so how many viable options do you have with the committee right now now 13 of them I heard we have 133 proposals now some of them overlap and also from some of the other decline proposals we pulled we cherry-picked some of the ideas and again some of them do overlap uh with even the 13 so 13 is a rough number okay Mr Masters I want to thank you and
020the committee for doing a wonderful job we appreciate it however I do suggest that we sort of put a time frame on when the ad hog committee is going to give results and what the implementation plan is going to be uh I heard that the demographic report is not going to be done until the middle of January so we're losing a lot of time and I think the time is of by said so I just wanted to request that so we are going to move forward with the existing demographic report understood we knew that uh we asked um Mr Gorski and he gave us those time frames and then hopefully I don't know if we're going to go towards January however long it takes again um I want to get to a good solution not
021a fast solution I'd rather take a little bit more time I know there's been people complaining about what you taking too long but I'd rather vet all these Solutions and not just push them aside um we'll what we'll do is like you do in business we'll work with the data we have until we have new data and then exchange that in thank you looking for a good solution thank you m armo yes um thank you Mr Masters and and the committee I was able to go to for a few minutes on one of the uh your last um meeting um in terms of timing I'd like to read at Mr Polaris um I do believe it we cannot wait till January for the new uh demographic I think that the committee I mean if you
022if we have some kind of projection we know I all we have to do is walk uh right around Monroe and see all of the bulldozers and trucks going in and out and uh I think we sort of get an idea that we are still moving forward we have a settlement for the affordable housing that uh maybe maybe the ad hoc committee can ask for the settlement the uh affordable housing settlement and that would give you really some idea of the amount of houses that will be uh proposed okay um and you know some of them are going to be built right away and some of they going to take uh according to them between five and 10 year build out but uh we certainly want to be aware of that so maybe if the
023ad hoc committee gets a copy of the settlement that would be good um and also I would ask that um because we have social media and because we have all kinds of places where information can be posted I would ask that we only post the information on the board website and and thank you for asking people to call you but I think that would be inappropriate I think it should that the official and formal information should be only on on our website I if other people do whatever they want on social media that would be one thing but for us to go to One Source uh for information so I would ask and I don't know if I need a resolution for that or just make aend that was our intent is to once the
024minutes are approved tomorrow to put the minutes on to put the agenda on for tomorrow and the the list of um who attends the meeting so it will be on the district website right but he graciously said people can call him and get information but I think we have to disseminate the information from One Source I resend my offer okay thank you don't call me I just think for for clarity sake no that makes sense it does make sense okay thank you for your time and for the affordable housing that's a great idea I've added it as an action item and I will do that thank you yeah because it's our reality so I would ask that we consider that thank you awesome idea Madam may I just add to M Zino's comment thank you
025the um the educational advocacy committee and the ad hoc committee recommended an update to the demographic study the enrollment projections yes I was there that update is required by the Department of Education for any submission misss that would be for a forthcoming plan but the last projections that we received from Russ habber and Associates particularly the shortterm projections the one to three years are still very useful and accurate and we feel comfortable using those and and providing those to the committee to use it's where you go longer in in duration they get a little bit fuzzy but a 1 to threee Outlook should be still very accurate and reliable from the most recent report well unfortunately we know that when this uh beautiful building was built uh it was already close to a capacity so
026I know one to three years but I I don't think it would hurt so so maybe I don't understand are you suggesting they don't take a look at the settlement uh I am making no comment on the settlement just the demographic stuff okay that's fine um I yeah I think they should include the settlement because again that's part of our reality even though we have nothing to do with it Mr Ryback I I I think uh Mr I think the settlement I could be wrong but my memory serves me correct I think it was 850 units for affordable housing for the town and that's what I think they settled does that number ring a bell two years ago yes I think it's 850 units so my question is and I think they did this in
027Ross habber I think that he uh include that 850 in his projections I it's my understanding I think he did that I believe that's correct well I I don't think it would hurt to give them more information no I'm not opposed that but I I just want to say number let's be clear the 850 is just the affordable housing aspect of the settle they do what is it four times four to one four four to one so you multiply that by four and then you get what the projected uh housing stock is going to be get the number that's why it's important to take a look at it thank you okay thank thank you Mr M president one to mention I apologize uh I I think I've brought this up in the previous meetings I
028think the entire community of Monro Lou Masters um if you could have like an open session uh for the ad hoc committee for people to come in and kind of look at and review some of the recommendations that are coming up but also have people kind of give their input because I know that you're looking for emails and want to do this in a systematic way we don't want to leave any stone unturned at the end of the day give them an opportunity sometime at least an October time frame uh if you could do that that'll be great be helpful okay thank you I have no problem with that okay since there are no more questions Mr Masters thank you for your thank you your update this evening hopefully I'll see you tomorrow okay you
029will yes I'm like What's tomorrow okay no I get it thank you very much okay we'll go to committee reports are there any committees that need to report this evening I know Mr Mayo has a a really nice one we had the curricul can you is that picking me up the curriculum committee met today at 5:30 and the summer is a big time for curriculum writing so we went through a lot of documents and I'll try to be quick but they're very interesting so I don't want you guys to miss anything we went through financial literacy which is a curriculum mathing and so the where is it financial literacy so there's a new state mandate that we have to Tei teach financial literacy in the Middle School um and so the teachers got together the
030where's my notes I lost them there no no that's yeah here it is sorry okay so a panel of teachers from the Middle School got together mathematics Department Middle School social studies as well as high school business teachers and took part in the two-day mapping and essentially um what they did is they discussed each of the standards in length and they determined where was the best place for implementation they're not creating a whole new class but they're embedding it in current class current classwork already the document was created with the standard and course name to ensure that all standards will be met standards will be placed in one of three courses grade six the pbl math which which is problem-based learning math which incorporates grade six Math standards into real life real life application projects
031with embedded differentiation uh grade seven Civics and grade eight social studies it was noted that many of the standards were already included but more depth was necessary so they talked about the depth once the group narrowed down which topics needed to be placed in which course then they had discussions about um how to put it in the course with the best fit without taking away from what was already being taught um during the year several of the Middle School teachers from the panel will be working on their year-long professional development to create in-depth activities and what was so interesting about this literacy mapping is it brought together a group of three PE you know three types of teachers Middle School mathematics um Middle School social studies and high school business teachers and had them talking
032together which they usually don't do so it really brought an interesting and an in-depth discussion to the mapping yeah okay the the next um ones we talked about which were social studies in grade K through n and so the essence is what is social studies and why it is important within the school program social studies provides coordinated systematic study drawing upon disciplines such as anthropology AR archaeology economics G geography history law philosophy political science psychology religion and social sociology as well as appropriate content from the humanities mathematics and natural science so social studies is really all-encompassing the primary purpose of social studies is to help young people make informed and reasonable decisions for the public good as citizens of a culturally diverse Democratic Society in an interdependent World um so the K through 12 social
033studies um curriculum docu document focused on the development of classroom Community active classroom citizenship Civics Monroe day Constitution Day social institutions people culture and diversity economic forces americ americ government American leaders American symbols geography maps and our environment and historical figures in leadership it's K2 I said that you said K12 I said K 12 my apologies K through two the next one is grade three- five for social studies and this focuses on our community Monroe day Constitution Day American culture past and present inventions in inventors American government founding of our nation American Revolution slavery to the Civil Rights industry immigration Westward Expansion Civil War and reconstruction Global perspectives Incas Aztec and Mayan civilizations um so in both of these I mentioned Monroe and so um there Monroe was created in part parip with the Monroe
034historical pre preservation commission and it's going to engage students in our local Township history and they're going to be day farm field trips they're going to be doing scavenger hunts um traveling historical Trunks and more and so this is really going to teach the kids about the town they're growing up in the history and it really is an engaging Hands-On day for them so it's pretty exciting that this is being developed uh the next one was grade six social studies um this one focuses on early humans mesot Mesopotamia Mesopotamia the Fertile Crescent ancient Egypt religions of the world ancient India and ancient China grade seven focuses on ancient Greece ancient Rome Middle Ages Renaissance and Reformation grade eight focuses on the American colonies growing tensions the American Revolution the Articles of Confederation the American Constitution
035the Preamble article one and the voice of the people article two and government power article three and American Justice articles 4 to7 and the Bill of Rights formation of political parties local government and contemporary World issues I'm not done yet we also have a um we talked about a research and development stem it's a high school level course that was developed in conjunction with Ruckers and it's a biology based course we also this we also had um the head of our um chorus um come in and talk about freshman chorus and mixed course she has written all the documents for our chorus as a result of her expertise and her engagement with the students enrollment in our chorus classes have increased 150% since she has come on board so we have a fabulous chorus teacher
036her name is Ariel Klein um so the Freshman course is for all incoming freshmen experienced and new um there's five core units that help develop The Ensemble through literacy performance practice pedagogi um the course also prepares students for advanced ensembles at the district Regional and state level the mixed course is a non aition in Ensemble just like the Freshman one for grades 10 through 12th it's a collaboration and rigorous Ensemble for students which has resulted in 115 I'm sorry 115% enrollment since the program was restructured four years ago the structure of the course allows for students to use prior knowledge in regard to literacy and music theory from their freshman course experience to improve their overall performing abilities back in was it January the Mandate from the government a 1335 um there was a bill
037that was signed into law and it is um and it it would was signed by the governor and it would ensure that lesbian gay bisexual and transgendered people and individual and and individuals with disabilities are included in instructional materials which Studies have shown is linked to Greater student safety lower rates of bullying and reduced Prejudice towards members and allies of these groups so this law was passed and we we have to insert some of this teaching into um each new new document that we write and what was amazing so students will understand the importance of global diversity respectful listening constructive problem solving and consideration of others backgrounds and beliefs so it's just another way to teach our students about tolerance but what was amazing about this is that this mandate to include materials about contributions
038of the lgbq community and special ed communities into all our curricul the our gay straight Alliance in the high school came and approached the administration about contributing and giving input about the Mandate and they are going to be actively helping the administration include this mandate into our curriculum documents and I thought that was really an amazing thing that they approached the uh Administration all on their own to help this and I think that was it okay that was a lot to digest tonight very exciting okay anyone else have a committee Miss uh Mrs Lang hello so the policy committee we met on August 15th and we were able to discuss we first went through our policies for reaffirmation as part of our going over and updating our policy book so we have um one 2
0393 4 five six seven seven policies for reaffirmation tonight we have two policies for first reading and regulations they had some um word changing in them in the course guides for changing to the New Jersey from the New Jersey cor curriculum content standards and then in policy 24313 which is practice and preseason um we that policy we got the input from Mr Greg Brier the coaches and the school position so now that accurately reflects what we're doing within the district on that so that policy is up for its first read tonight we're also going to do our second readings on regulation 3212 4212 and policy 8860 and policy 9400 I um also wanted to update we updated the policy committee and I just want to repeat it to the public that when the board works
040it's our goal and our role is to make sure that the district we give the the what we want to happen and the district gives us back how they're going to make it happen we do the what through the policy they do the how through the regulation so when wording comes back from the administration as to how they want a regulation worded or how they feel best that a regulation's going to work we basically that it that is their work we don't set up the the regulations the administration does the regulations we do the policies we also updated the committee on the smoking and VAP vaping and substance abuse policy Dr alvic are our board Attorney Mary Smith myself two Middle School administrators a high school administrator and the student assistant counselor met and we
041began drafting a vaping policy that will meet our District's exact needs and the most exciting part about that is that there's going to be a really strong emphasis on education and parental participation because vaping is so dangerous and the best way for us to stop it is to have parents understand how dangerous this is and what's happening I know I personally have been sharing lots of articles about the dangers of vaping and what they're finding with lung diseases and how um young people are overdosing on nicotine or unknown substances so we really want to push education as a big part instead of making it just punitive because punitive isn't going to change anything hopefully education will we also updated the committee on the request to in investigate um seat belts and Dr Alvi let us
042know that for our trips where we're required to do coach buses we are going to be requesting coach buses with seat belts which we did find out there are enough out there hopefully um it's important to keep in mind that the availability there's not a whole bunch of them but availability and cost of those buses may have an impact on our trips where we need to use a coach bus that has seat belts and I was also asked to bring back a discussion that was brought up by in the public forum and I have to add that we can't discuss personal person Personnel items in public so when we had our meeting we asked the member of the public who was in attendance to step out so that we could talk it um to have
043a really thorough discussion about our concerns and what I can share is that at this time everything was handled in accordance with the current Collective negotiations agreement and laws and that any changes hopefully that we can make into our policies will happen through the next Collective negotiations and the real part on that is as long as those changes are what they call um not void AB initio or a void on its SP or illegal so hopefully you know as we move forward we'll work closely in negotiations and and make any changes we have to and we're going to keep working as a board to update our policy manual we're we're getting there there's a lot but our goal is to get it done by the end of the year and have our policy manual all
044updated and everything have been looked at so thank you again for the support of the policy committee thank you Mrs Lang anyone Mr Ryback thank you um just to let everyone know the Personnel committee met and uh supported Mr M Pearl's continuance as acting principal of the high school the position of Transportation specialist was recommended to assist in planning developing and implementing our transportation program it's quite a busy office and additional help was needed we also updated the job description for Department coordinator uh so that it better describes roles we voted to approve increases in the substitute nurses rate of pay as we have a growing need and have been losing people to higher paying districts in our area we voted to approve the rate of pay for substitute security guards to $20 for part-time
045unarmed guards in 28 for part-time armed guards of course the board must vote to approve the rates of pay for nurses and security guards to become effective uh we also uh voted to approve an increase in pay for substitute secretaries to bring them to minimum wage that's my report thank you thank you any other reports Miss armeno yes I'm going to read the uh financial report uh the financial committee report first um I sat through all but one of the Committees on uh August 15th so from 4 o'clock to about 8 o'clock except for one hour um and the finance committee uh was scheduled last I think maybe um we should start looking at the finance committee first because that sort of everything else develops from our finances and um I think we have some
046some news that we're going to have to uh start to pay attention to um Mr gors on uh June 30th we have an audit update uh from Mr Gorski uh that he provided an update on June 30th for the comprehensive annual fin Financial audit where he informed members of the auditing team uh that they have they've that Mr Samuel Klein and Company have audited the application for the state school aid which is Assa as of October 15 2018 they've created a random and targeted trans transaction sampling list and have audited the minutes and is now auditing the Student Activity accounts so they're in the preliminary stages of the current audit it is however the same auditor for I think the last quite a few years um so they should be used to doing this uh
047there was also a discussion related to the preliminary excess Surplus calculations Mr Gorski provided the committee with a draft of the audit schedule C1 which calculates SX excess surplus of the June 30th 2019 and five-year excess Surplus uh cumulative schedule will that be on the on the website um Madam I could certainly post it on the website if it's the board's desire okay yeah I think we're going to start to talk heavy duty about uh our our Surplus and our fund so I think the public should know since they're the ones paying the bill uh Mr Gorski directed the members attention to steadily declining excess Surplus from $6 million two years ago to $5 million last year to 3,200,000 this year Mr Gorski said says that the reason for the draw down in Surplus can
048be attributed to spending in excess of total revenues and I Circle that I'll repeat that um the reason for the draw down in the Surplus can be attributed to spending in excess of total revenues particularly in the following areas student enrollment growth technology and curriculum needs facility Capital Improvement upgrades trailer leases and increase labor and benefits cost Mr Gorski indicated that there will be more present in this topic October 3rd 2019 at the budget philosophy but we also talked about um well we also talked about the decrease in the uh in the excess Surplus and how that could impact our future and some of our you know going forward in some of our the salaries so sometimes I think that um we should have the finance first before we start granting a lot of increases
049in some of our spending that's just my opinion um I also asked and there were other people at the meeting uh Mr POI Rupa seagull and Mr Chell I believe was there um president K panitz was there um I also asked my concerns about and I know we don't have a direct uh control over this but I I'm concerned about going forward there are in the in the overall uh economy there's talk about possible recession and what would that do to our long-term and short-term um interest rates and I don't know if Mr Gorski would like to talk about that but it's a concern that I have and I think as a board we have to not just consider what's in front of us and what's immediate but we have to start being concerned that
050they you know something down the road don't know if it can happen it might not happen but I do remember in 2008 um public officials said that they had no idea no one could predict predict that this was coming but I think um recessions are are probable and predictable on in certain ways and we should be cognizant of that again my personal opinion Mr gorsky if you would like to Madam M president if he may um just briefly we did discuss during the finance committee that there are increasing predictions for recession in the country um the last time there was a recession it was the the Great Recession it was an unusual one very steep uh but that resulted in the suspension and cut of our state aid after the award was made midy year
051the state pulled back from us $1.5 million which did affect programs and services and put it a great strain on uh the board and District goals um you know certainly being an accountant and not an economist I it's hard for me to say what the effective interest rates would be other other than in general terms but um state aid is the biggest threat that we have generally during recessions you have a a cut or decline in interest rates that might be a a a Tailwind with the bond referendum because it actually it could make borrowing uh less expensive if there's a a bright side to this but um certainly a recession is going to hurt because it could impair the state's ability to continue on their framework under S2 to bring us to full funding
052in the next five years or they could actually not meet Revenue projections and pull back aid from us like they did a few years ago but we barely get State a as it is I mean the maybe the Silver Lining on that one is if they don't give us any more we're not really sadly we're not relying on it sadly and fortunately I guess at the same time but I'll will move on if you're done Mr gors yes ma'am okay I also have buildings and grounds Mr cherella was attending uh buildings and grounds he's not here so I will read the um buildings and grounds report uh we have gov deals uh go deals is a for-profit organization um that administers the sale of District Vehicles we're disposing of surplus property the administration provided a
053handout identifying 13 out ofservice District Vehicles proposed for sale through gov uh Deal's auction site and the committee uh supports and will recommend to the board inates on page 37 of 40 of your agenda tonight um we are recommending that they get sold through this gub deals uh the demographics uh demographic study that was discussed that's on page 37 uh 36 out of 40 of your uh agenda this evening and the administration provided a proposal from Ross habber and Associates for updated demographic study uh using the forthcoming October 2019 as sa data this that that that I already spoke about um with the auditor this data after being certified by The District's auditor will be available to the de demographer in early December and a new demographic study issued in the F uh to the
054full board in January 2020 the request for updating the demographic study came from the ad hoc committee as we've previously mentioned and the educational advocacy committee the building and grounds committee will recommend proceeding with the update of the demographic study and I think that's a little over $4,000 on in your on page 36 update in the Middle School water heating system replacement project Administration shared photos of an ongoing project and noted that the job is substantially complete a punch list uh was prepared and issued this week the project is projected to be 100% complete and a new heating system officially operable uh prior to the start of school that's good news update on the security vestibule project Administration provided an overview of the construction at the five schools highlighting construction field changes that were necessary
055at Barkley Brook due to the newly discovered sublayer of asbestos floor tile and code revision required by the local construction department and to add a sprinkler head in apple GTH vestibule although these projects were not slated to be completed for the start of School Mr pero was working closely um Mr perar security director he was working closely with the affected School principles and man and made arrangements for alternative secure access to the school while the vestibules are under construction next potential trailer projects for 2020 Administration provided a handout which requested in uh we requested information regarding the existing school capacity current enrollment and um result in unhoused students Administration noted that they will be having an IND discussion with the Middle School administrator regarding needs for potential additional trailers possibly to house a second cafeteria
056Andor more classrooms furthermore the uh Administration share departing High School principal Rob Goodall's recommendation for adding six to eight instructional classrooms at the high school the the committee requested that additional data pertaining to projected growth be provided for the schools to Aid in their analysis of trailers I'm wondering also Mr G Ori if we can put that analysis on the um board on the website we talked about that madam are you referring to the uh anticipated trailer need analis I think we had um I don't know if what we called it but it had um Capac the existing capacity enrollment and then unhoused students yes we have an updated schedule that uh we are going to present to the ad hoc committee tomorrow tomorrow and um uh if it's the board's desire we can certainly
057post that to the website okay um I would I would recommend it and ask that we agree to do that updating on the flashing School signs and projects at the Monroe Township High School and the Munroe Township Middle School the committee review design engineering drawings prepared by um Edwards Engineering Group on August 8th 2019 these drawings have been submitted to the Monroe Township engineer and Monroe Township Police traffic safety department for review the township recently conducted conducted a first reading of an ordinance to change the speed limit everybody pay attention speed limit on Pineville Road to 25 miles per hour during school hours but we have uh Mr poori requested that the administration follow up with the engineer regarding this matter as there might be an issue between changing uh reducing the uh the speed
058limit that drastically from 25 from a 45 M hour which is the current road speed um we will post the meeting followup from Edwards we have not officially submitted plans to the middle sex County engineer yet and our our office has spoken to M oh this was the follow-up sorry our office has spoken to Mr um not going to say his last name supervising engineer and the County Traffic Division about our proposal to add flashing signs and to reduce the speed limit to the school zone to 35 as is currently posted 25 uh they did not give any indication that would be an issue he stated that we would okay we need approvals uh and the county would review the plan once the town has acted so this is in conjunction with the township under
059state law uh the speed limit in school zones is automatically 25 miles hour unless legally posted otherwise only a governing body May adopt an ordinance to allow higher speed limit which in the case of Pineville Road would be middle 6 County so this is good information for for the start of school uh the Federal Highway Administration Manual of uniform traffic control devices states that speed zone reduction sign should be placed at a minimum 200 feet from the school and said distance should be increased if the speed limit reduction is more than 30 miles per hour so please just be cognizant of where these uh signs go up and then um very quickly request a commodity resale system Mr Gorski would you like to briefly just talk about that and this way we'll sure move on
060yes um the administration presented to the board's committee I believe it was a building grounds transportation and the board um previously a request from the fire department um adjacent to the administration building for them to get rid of an above ground diesel tank and have their fire Tru use the diesel facilities across the street at the Board of Education uh we worked out with a lot of uh collaboration from Mary Smith and the Township's attorney uh very good uh agreement where the township will pay and be invoiced uh periodically for their specifically used diesel which we will track with a fob fob is like a like a keychain device that shows how much fuel you're pumping into the vehicle they'll also pay the district I believe it was $2,400 a year uh for administrative search
061charge and they've provided all the necessary Insurance paperwork which is part of the rider that you have tonight to approve uh that satisfies the board attorney and most importantly our insurance carrier so this is a win-win for the fire department and the Board of Ed and the environment we get rid of an above ground tank we share a facility that's relative ly new the board of aded picks up an administrative cost to help offset the tanks and the charges um and the access will be limited to after school hours so it doesn't interfere with operations here okay thank you and briefly just because the uh the committee just had some discussions Mr POI requested the administration explore the possibility of GPS systems on buses that would allow parents to track their Stu their child's bus
062we went back and forth on that one some of us thought it was a good idea and some of us thought that it might be um not such a good idea so that was a discussion um Mr Ryback uh requested the administration explore options for Vaping detectors to be installed in high schools but we also noted that we're talking about a vaping policy and we also discussed how smart kids are to sort of overcome those um de detectors so those are still discussion items thank you very much for your patience you're welcome and is the other committees just want to add to Mrs aro's comment that the signs are going to be paid for by the township as we requested it's not going to be coming out of our budget just want to let it
063the flashing signs corre yes thank you okay public form for agenda items only anyone from the public wishing to speak to the agenda please come to the microphone state your name and address for the record we will adhere to our 4minute timeline once the um timer goes off your time is over and um you can only come up once during each public forum so you want okay okay hi my name is pradep for Jake Place uh I had some questions about uh transparency especially me minutes of meeting of subcommittees so me and Madame President went back and forth with couple of emails and on the final email today I sent to all other board members for your reference the main concern is not what you are hiding why you are hiding that's what bothers all
064the taxpayers why can't you reveal whatever the meeting minutes what is happening in that 1 hour long sessions in 1 hour long session you can't just describe in like just one liner like we meet and we discussed about this blah blah blah that's and in the email I received from Miss kpo saying that all the meeting minutes are available on your website so I went back and I thoroughly skimm through the G boards doc whatever the site that you guys are running and curriculum committee meetings in the last from the last September 2018 to July 2019 there were 10 meetings held at least 10 agendas I can found and only four meeting minutes are there the second place goes to policy committee meeting one out of 10 and the winners are bg& committee 0 out
065of 10 finance committee meeting 0 out of 9 and the grand prize win goes to educational advocacy committee they don't even have agenda over there okay so our Bo meetings are not greater than fomc meetings or closed sessions of Senate even those committee meetings minutes what to word verbatim are coming to the light at certain point of life but these committee meetings these closure sessions are not coming up okay I request you all Boe members to think a truthful answer to the taxpayers and if you believe transparency in the Democracy okay think what you said before you coming onto the board in the public meetings about the transparency transparency transparency please answer truthfully to your heart and I I'm requesting and challenging at the same time the board please make a resolution to have at
066least an video or audio recordings of subcommittee meetings if cost is a primary concern I will donate two of these mics you can connect to your laptop and you just click one button you are done all the minutes will be audio recorded on your laptop you can upload in 2 minutes okay if you guys are not taking any action then I want to remind you a old case that was defeated for the Board of Education in 2006 there is one gentleman who went to Superior Court of middle sex and won against this same board for lack of transparency the Court ruled in favor of him and board of education has paid a hefty sum for the cost you want to repeat that I am up for that are you are you want to waste the
067the taxpayers money on the court cases the energy so if you want if you are not taking any resolution and if the meetings are not there what will happen if I oper a detailed minutes of meeting you have no idea what happened in that meeting and okay the next point if I go to the court and if I attach this old resolution to the same case that I'm going to put up now then you ready for a reinstallation of this whole board including the administration and the members I think my 4 minutes is not over yet but I'm done any answer for me time's up at this time I don't I don't have an answer but I I I think that the um the answers to your questions was open and honest what I said
068was that um as of July 2019 all committee meetings um minutes will be posted I I never said that I just check it today the scores are same I didn't even see we have to we have to approve them as a board first so um all the subcommittee meetings are approved after the right after that particular month board meeting then why don't you up I will respond to your your latest email okay okay at this time your time is up any board members want to take up this challenge board members cannot speak at public forum okay prash 33 Dana Drive I EO the prep's feeling because I know that the minutes are very important and transparency in the minutes are very important how we can we are not done in the past let us catch
069up to it so that is the request but I agree with that let us be transparent another one about the adoc committee uh 19 out of 59% there are good proposals very good proposals have come and 19 out of 34 are rejected so in the minutes of the meeting be very because people are taken time to write the proposals on what grounds they have been rejected put a line so the people will appreciate and we will also be happy to see on what grounds they have been rejected okay and the development Advanced criteria I didn't hear I missed it that particular day the proposal has to be sound the definition of proposal has to be sound is very gray it has to be defined what the sound means okay otherwise it is very gray area
070and you know all in public we know that we all always have a doubt already predefined two proposals are going to be there new middle school and expansion of high school okay that is the thing but I tell you people are given several ideas so naturally I feel expansion of high school is required but whether new Middle School is required there are certain ideas have come which will be very helpful for taxpayers and Implement them otherwise I'll bet you the referendum will again fail with a policy committee I appreciate vaping education to The Vaping should start at at least 7th grade the nicotin content in The Vaping is 45% and there are cases where the the students who were excellent in AP classes and all started vaping there are the if they the parents were
071there there are cases they lose their concentration their grades go down there everything goes down the grade down so they are very addictive and lung cancer and all brain damage and all side effects are very so I hope I'm very happy that you all are taking uh concerns and I request or talk to the expert whether we start educating students right from seventh grade you know so that is the request and um I'm not going to comment on on the minutes of the meeting I have this item page 34 the transportation specialist and Department coordinator are there item e page 34 are these new positions or these are the existing positions that is the question mad yes uh to answer the gentleman's question it's a new position and the rationale provided to the board for
072the position um is that uh I I will I sorry Mr GOI because of limited time the budgets are tight the budgets are typ so I I I I at least have a concerns of how adding any new position so reconsider that's what I can say and the next question is what is this item L what is this new MD program at high school I don't understand what is MD means okay because what I'm thinking my thought is we have good programs now budgets are tight let us keep the good programs and look at which programs are good and so I don't know what this MD is so please provide me the answer thank you yes can thank you um the depart Mr gors the transportation job description is a new position the department coordinators
073are not a new position they are an existing position we just revised the job description an MD class is a multiply disabled class it's a special education class okay thank you good evening Betty saberito to Barry M Drive um as you know I'm the parent of a special education child he's classified with autism I'm also the leader of cpag which is the special education parent advisory group I just have um a question with regard to the curriculum could we start also including special education not just in our ccul meetings but also when we recap our committee meetings because I think that's very important I don't know if you guys on the board are aware we have a huge reading comprehension program right now with these children there seemed to be a misconnect somewhere between curriculum
074and special education there wasn't ass set reading program for them especially for self-contained so I think we need to start including these programs in children as part of not just your meetings but your reporting as well and also um Mrs Deo spoke about this new legislation that came into effect with regard with children with disabilities and you're pulling in some of your students from your um school to kind of give you ideas on how to better some of the programs for special education the students may not always be available or have the um cognitive wherewithal to participate but certainly cpeg can and certainly some of the parents can so that we can kind of make this um distributed across the board so if you could start including that being that 18% I believe of our
075students are classified I think it's an important percentage we need to start including that as a part of our curriculum meetings and committee reports okay and if you could also Dr alvic I know you're very aware we need to start looking at this reading program because we've been looking at it through cpag but we have a ton of students at the middle and high school that are not able to read at this point that do not have any reading comprehension skills which means they're not going to be successful once they're out of school and at the lower grades that's where that needs to start self-contained I understand the IEPs Drive the programs but if we don't have a program in place that's a problem so if we could please revisit that okay doc Dr Al
076will'll take care of that thank you hi good evening Gail toay 356c old Nassau um regarding the the first gentleman and the second gentleman's comments about transparency in your Clos sessions your closed sessions are closed and your minutes are not not exposed because it contains Personnel issues about children parents teachers and the attorneys are present and a certain committee is there to judge it you you guys would be you're legally bound not to put those people's names out there in minutes I'm correct am I right you are you are correct and I know that we follow the law you do we follow New Jersey school boards that's right we follow our board attorney advice right and we know in fact we had school boards here and that question was asked in at one of our
077board meetings as what we can include enclosed session meetings correct the very minimal like we discuss so and so sure and that's all that we are allowed to you'll have a lawsuit the next minute that somebody sees that on your board website especially and I think um Miss armeno mentioned tonight about you know I didn't want to mention the gentleman's name and and she had the right to say that because maybe that person didn't want to be mentioned in one of your uh reports that he was involved with something so you don't you have to be so care couldn't say his re I couldn't say his name oh you couldn't pronounce oh okay well I'm just saying you have to be careful about what you say about anybody nowadays I mean it doesn't even have
078to be pertaining to a closed session meeting it's anywhere you could be outside you could be well I worked in the hospital and and doctors would be in the elevators with us years ago and they all got yelled at for it and that's why hippers around uh because they were talking about patients and that could have been the patient family standing right there so if you were in a closed session and you're out in shoppr or wherever you are and you're saying and sometimes you whisper and sometimes you don't know who's there so I was in a close session the other night and you know Mary Smith boy did they throw her out of that District the gentleman is entirely wrong this is a very trans to me since I've been coming here is a
079very transparent Bo of education and you can only go by what law tells you to do state mandate that's what you have to do so I commend you your reports were wonderful this evening very detailed and very informational thank you anyone else from the public Krishna 11 Jake place um the what my friend spoke about uh the first gentleman who spoke here he spoke about what is being discussed a gist of what is being discussed he did not ask for names to be named so um I just want to point that out right I mean he was very explicit that he did not want the names to come out all he wanted was what was discussed what was approved what was voted and what wasn't voted so um having corrected the um misconception that was
080out here um the question I have um retains is uh is related to the um general fund the beginning cash balance started at around 5.7 million and it ended at 2.2 million um just trying to figure out uh where did that go there were more cash dispersements of what changed I was trying to find that out could not find that information in the package that was handed out Madam yes Mr caliy has reported to finance committee uh for the year June 305 we had excess Surplus which is which is important to understand what that concept is it's monies from previous budgets that were not spent to their uh Fidelity so you either had some efficiencies and savings or you recognize revenues in excess of what you had in the budget um so you created Surplus
081that Surplus by law carries over to two years later and as part of the budget as a revenue Source June 35 we had excess surplus of 5 milli ion June 36 it came 6.1 million we'll put the schedule on our website June 37 it spay the same at about 6 million June 318 it dropped to 5 million and I reported to the board that drop and and the reasons why and then June 309 we're reporting now a drop 3.2 million um the theoretical reason for that is your spending beyond your abilities to raise revenues through state aid tuition and the cap with emphasis on the cap the cap is a governing agent on our budget that determines how much money you're able to raise through taxes and we are at cap however our our spending
082throughout the district um has been growing at a steady Pace due to some very specific demands special education um we meet the needs of our special ed population very very uh um completely and thoroughly facilities We inherited a longrange facility plan that has projects in the millions of dollars that have been identified of need in the next 5 years we've been doing that on an installment basis every year that's been eating into this to a large amount security vestibules are a perfect example this year additional Staffing I think we put 35 new staff on for uh the 1920 budget because of growth trailer costs and um because of those needs that were respond responsble and and of value to the organization we've been drawing down on on Surplus so this was an alert to the
083board for a second year in a row that we are spending beyond our ability to raise revenues and um it would be wise to develop a philosophy that puts the breakes on um any non-mandated spending going forward so um in essence U we actually overran our budget for last year and we we've spent uh more than what we have and we've draw down on our um sess that we've been carrying over is that a correct statement Mr Gorski I don't like the word overspent the budget uh we were within the budget range okay um but we did consume some of our savings AKA EXs Surplus and it's been declining steadily and and aggressively so uh that was the reason for the alert at the finance committee sure all right thank you Mr Gorski thank you
084good evening Christy scurby 21 pness Drive um I spoke last month about how um sad I was seeing uh one of our best administrators leave the district and I was equally upset looking at the Personnel um items this evening and seeing one of our top Math teachers leaving our district um we have a real problem here in Monroe we're losing staff month after month there is a long list of resignations and it's not because they're leaving to to to uh retire they're going to other districts we're losing our top staff to other districts and that is hurting our students that is hurting the education here in Monroe and we need to figure out a way that we're going to keep our teachers here and hearing now that we're we're adding more administrative you're you're being
085asked to approve a new administrative position yet we have no money I I I don't understand we we have teacher negotiations that are going to be coming up that's that's no secret the contracts are up this year this Board needs to really your your philosophy should be how to keep our teachers here how to pay them fairly because we are not paying our teachers what they deserve here and it's showing because they're leaving and that's hurting our district and that's what's truly important here is retaining our staff and making the education the best that could be here in Monroe that's what you guys need to start looking at um in regards to the ad hoc committee um I didn't hear any of the proposals um presented I know that uh Pros perab did a very
086extensive recap of that meeting I know he attended and he detailed every proposal um what they were what what recommendations those were um is there a way that you can put on the website what the proposals were so that the public can see what was out there because the update really didn't say anything of what was being proposed by the public and to Mr Poor's point if we do that if you can put that out there for the public and then hold a public meeting where residents can come out and speak to those proposals you can get an understanding for what the public will support and get behind and and potentially have a referendum that will pass but I I think you need to engage the public to let them know if you're saying only
087look at the district website for the information then put it out there because like I said Mr parav did an excellent job detailing all of the proposals but that should be something that's on the district website as a recap of that meeting we'll take that under consideration okay and I hope again like Mr plor I know he's been asking um for quite a while now I hope you will maybe somebody make a motion or a recommendation that you do hold a public town hall meeting where residents are invited to come and speak to it because I know they're not allowed to speak at the ad hoc meeting and if you have an open meeting where P where residents can come out and speak to that I think that's a good idea I think bringing everybody
088together to come to an agreement on what we can do to address the student growth would be helpful we have said we're going to do that in the future but not over 33 Pro proposals so we want to eliminate the ones that aren't good or the ones that are not feasible and get down to a certain amount and then we will have the um a town hall where people could come in and say Here's five proposals what do you think you can get behind what questions do you have and we will we will well it sounded like the not ones that aren't feasible were taken out right but there's still others that we have a lot of of questions about so we want to uh get down from 13 15 16 proposals that we have
089to maybe four or five that sure but maybe all that could be shared with the public now I mean why not right it's it's not confidential information I mean I just think you're welcome to come to the meeting and and um but people can't come to the meetings why can't you post that on on your District website why do you have to come to a meeting to get the information we post the minutes of the meetings anyone else from the public seeing no one we will go to the superintendent's report Dr Alvi okay good evening so this past Monday and Tuesday the administrators met for our annual summer administrator Workshop this is a time for all of us to get together um some of our topics that that were included in the two-day training were
090uh legal training crisis training for all of our administrators ongoing uh map report stating map is the online assessment that we're using K through 12 um so doing some more extensive training on reading um the reports that are available to staff and administrators and we had a dis uh started a discussion about the district and vision statement um in preparation for hopefully moving forward moving toward a um strategic planning process that I would um that we'll talk about during our budget goals uh District goals and and um at a future meeting it was a wonderful day uh two days of team building and learning for all of our administrators um on Monday evening the high school did open its doors for all freshmen in a fresh open house the students received t-shirts they uh received
091their iPads and they had an opportunity to walk around the school teachers and student ambassadors were available to guide them and answer any questions I did attend along with the High School administration and it seemed to be a very festive evening students were excited a lot of um student older siblings came with them and and helped them tour the building also which was nice to see with their parents um I'm hoping that this allayed some of the nervousness for our students and the high school administration is um is also working to create some informational videos that will be sent out to students by the start of the school year um sent out to freshman students um by being pushed out to their new iPads um on the agenda this evening Mr maap pea is being
092recommended to continue his role as the acting High School principal um once the school year starts we will conduct a search for that position and just to let everyone know we are on track for the opening of school um on September 3rd for all staff and SE member 5th for all students and our new teachers will be attending a new teacher orientation next Monday through Thursday um with our Administration and our professional development coordinators to get all of a lot of information they kind of get overwhelmed in those four days information to help get them ready for the start of the school year so Madam president it is recommended that the board approve the attached Personnel items a through ba a mo Motion in a second please a motion Mr Ryback's making a motion second
093and second by Mr Deo are there any comments or questions for Dr Ali Miss armeno yes um on on the uh act advancing and continuing the Acting Superintendent so I'm talking about the position now not the person is there an increase in salary he did get an increase in salary and how was that determined was that negotiated by anyone it was negotiated um by me and it was an increase similar to what the administrators received this year based on what he made last year as the acting acting principal so it gave him the increase for the acting principle position since he did it for a year already what's the difference if I may ask I do not know that off the top of my head um but in also to let you know we are
094not filling his position so there's a savings the district for the time there will we will be down one assistant principal at the high school until that position is filled right but that that really is separate from actual giving you know it okay I don't I don't remember I don't remember what the actual number is of the increase any other questions he saying none we'll have a roll call Mr Gorski is is that on the um A2 a ba I didn't I don't it's AV AV page 16 16 okay Madam yes ready for a roll call um as it pertains to Personnel I just want to um point out cl to clarify it uh the transportation specialist position is a clerical secretarial position that's that's on the next one though right yeah that's on the
095Personnel report that we're voting on right now and we Oh I thought that was on over at on D no that's on the Personnel action items a through ba and that is a uh clerical secretary position and that's a new position it's a new position uh it will enable the district to bring routes back from the commission better serving the parents we've had a lot of difficulty with contracted routes previously and with all of the growth in addition to our Fleet and buses um it's it's overdue I know we discussed this at at the um meeting and then like I said afterwards we had the financial how many people are in that in in the administration and Transportation Administration one just a director no but there are two other people in the office right uh
096dispatcher um transportation coordinator I wouldn't consider that Administration by the definition of the term so really we just have one administrator in that in that office and and some middle level supervision for staff but uh just one administ okay and in the job description it says terms of employment work year and salary to be determined by the board is that the case does the board the board isn't negotiating that it's going to be a recommendation from the administration and then we just vote on it so we're not really deter there is no determination by the board except by recommendation is that correct yes the superintendent of schools recommends all Personnel um items and the board votes on it yay or nay right I I wish we could sever sometimes the actual uh hiring of someone
097with the a salary situation because even because we're in charge of hiring people but we and and I understand about getting recommendations from our Administration but again going forward I mean I'll I'll be voting tonight reluctantly but going forward we have to really uh press upon uh the administration about you know curtailing some of the uh some of management salaries I think thank you madam roll call for personnel items a through ba as moved by Mr Rybeck seconded by Mrs Deo Mrs seagull yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr rutsky yes Mr teeno yes Mr plri yes Mrs Deo yes yes Mrs Lang yes Mrs armeno yes Mrs K Pano yes on board president Personnel items a through ba has passed thank you very much and we'll go to board action items okay it is recommended that
098the board approve board action items a through R so move Mr Ryback second Mrs Lang comments or questions for Dr alvik um I do have all right no I'm fine okay roll call Mr dorski Mr piur yes Mrs armenio yes Mrs Deo yes Mr Tano yes Mr Rybeck yes Mrs Lang yes Mr rudsky yes Mrs seagull yes and Mrs Cole pit yes mam board president board action items a through R has passed thank you that concludes my report okay at this time we'll go to the business administrator's report Mr Gorski thank you very much um just want to report out uh a couple items of of significance that have occurred over the summer um the first item is some of the construction that's going on in our schools we are involved in a very large
099uh School vestibule enhancement project which was directed by the board to fortify the entrances to the school uh with specific security upgrades that will um uh hopefully strengthen the infrastructure and and keep students and staff safe um we are also creating rooms within the budget without borrowing from the public to create additional classroom space for example at the middle school we perform construction on three rooms turning them into six so we doubled the amount of space in those schools we did the construction within the budget and it was performed by our in-house staff so that's that's remarkable and in the high school as uh recommended by uh Mr uh Zach morala they repurposed the dark room uh because photography and dark rooms uh are are as my understanding goes a little Antiquated for the curriculum
100now uh all of the aspects of the dark room program will still be available to students if they wanted to learn about it but the dark room is being repurposed now to an additional classroom so there's a lot of construction going on throughout the district with regard to creation of four additional classrooms and also enhancements of school vestibule projects and also Replacements of major air conditioning units and water heater uh units as we had reported from the Committees um additionally uh I wanted to report out on a technology security incident that we uh learned about over summer break and that is that the district had identified a ransomware attack that impacted the availability of some of our school systems we immediately began an investigation um and we have been working diligently to secure our systems
101and bring them back online all critical systems have been restored to operation and we expect all systems uh um for the rest of it to be ready by the start of school now we put an insurance claim and as required when we learned about this incident because we didn't know the scope from the beginning um the insurance carrier provided two resources that are state-of-the-art one is a a global firm in dealing with malware restoration and fortification to prevent it from happening again the other one is a uh a large Law Firm with a specialty in privacy and that's an important component because we wanted to make sure that the Privacy attorney the technological firm that's going to help with the restoration and the fortification the work from our technology director Dr Alvi and I were
102all coordinated in the fashion so that uh an investigation was performed it we looked and checked and we learned that some employee usernames and passwords may have been involved in this incident so therefore we forced all employees to change passwords and um we're going to also recommend the same for students when they come back uh while our investigation is still ongoing at this time we have not found any evidence to suggest that information was taken by the attacker from our school systems this is where the Privacy attorney really focused a lot of attention it's very clear evidence when a a computer file is copied and then extracted from our Network there is no evidence that that has happened at all in fact a particular Ransom where that we were um we experienced here um has
103uh a history of just demanding a ransom and not doing anything malicious with the data other than to encrypt it where they asked for a ransom so um again the investigation is still ongoing but I want to point out that although this was an attack on our district and a crime that was committed through the Herculean efforts of our transportation director Kathleen McDonald our our fantastic longtime technology director Mr Reggie Washington Dr alvic Mary Smith and our Property and Casualty broker this was a Shining Moment for us because we've restored all all of our systems for the most part including a transportation server uh that required a great deal of overtime from Mrs McDonald uh taking a lot of her time over the sum summer and that was without pay of course so um our
104systems are safe you can log on now we will have more information to provide to staff upon the return to school but um we have recovered for the most part from the Cent I ask a question Su question okay I had asked um Dr alvic and I I'd like to ask in public um will there be a formal written report of the incident I would I would ask that the board be provided with that and if there's anything that needs to be redacted for security purposes I have no problem but I'd like to know what we thought thought happened how it happened if possible I don't know you know I know it's not finished yet um the people you engaged in terms of um the attorneys and uh the security firms and the cost please
105certainly I have no objection to that if it pleases the board I'll be happy to do so but I I can report now that um our uh both of the experts who are helping us as part of this investigation have determined that our prevention methods uh and our safeguards and our firewalls um were more than adequate at the time of this attack this was a very large institutional malware attack and um we have 8,000 users of our Network and it just takes one click on an attachment to compromise the system um but uh that was one of the questions I asked and I I received a very favorable response that what we had in place beforehand was more than sufficient and above what a lot of school districts provide so how long was it the
106system down uh since uh summer break until um we're still restoring it now to to minor extent but all of the major systems are up and operational not to label this any further Mr Ki two questions one is a f police um case has been filed I assume the police were involved um Monroe Township Police the prosecutor's office was involved and the uh FBI was involved the FBI worked with our team and identifying if there was a key to this Ransom uh software that could be used unfortunately there was not but they have uh been reported of this and are still investigating on their end thank you just a yes or no question second one security breach did that impact any of the emails we might have gotten for the ad hoc committee that probably
107didn't get go through the answer is yes the uh server for the email was uh uh disabled for a short period of time okay okay you can have your report now okay so Madame board president and members of the mon Township Board of Education it is is recommended that board action items a through L be approved by consent roll call second Mrs Lang Mr Ryback any comments or questions from Mr Gorski I have one question Mr Tano on uh a number one and number three although I recognize how uh important those programs are did we uh send any of those programs out to bid or is this a company we've used before uh beg of Pardon you're referring to a professional appointments and a number one and a number three a number three um there
108is no bidding requirements for those as they are professional service contracts um so and and they are also below the bidding threshold so no there was no bidding but there was uh always the taxpayer's interest at heart when the recommendations are made by our special ed director she do a lot of shopping and comparative analysis when recommending these and as do we when we receive them in in the central office so so basically we got the lowest rate that she can find out there um lowest possible rate I I I believe that's correct when it comes to the rate but there's also a consideration for Quality when it comes to these type of contracts you don't you know right yes okay I'm done anyone else okay roll call Mr Gorski Mr Rybeck yes Mrs Deo
109yes Mrs seagull yes yes Mr purri yes Mrs armenio yes Mr rudsky yes Mr Tano yes Mrs Lang yes and Mrs kapano yes Madam board president that concludes uh my report and uh board action items athl has passed thank you very much okay then we'll go to the board president's report and and I have um two things um the first one is upon receiving a notification this evening from Mr Ken Chella whereby he expressed his intent to resign immediately from the Monro Township Board of Education I hereby move to accept the resignation of Mr Ken Chella from the Monroe Township Board of Education effective immediately and direct the board president and the business administrator board Secret to take all actions necessary to effectuate this action by the Board of Education Mr Ryback second second by
110Mrs Mr Mayo any comments or questions Mr Ryback I just want to thank Mr Chella for his years of service and and wish him well in the future thank you yeah he's been here he's been here a long time he's done a lot for children um he will be missed here but um for whatever reason he feels that this is the time for him to need to leave um we have to support his decision so if there's no other comments or questions uh we'll have a roll call to accept the resignation of Mr Chella Mrs Deo yes Mrs seagull yes Mr Tano no Mr rutsky yes Mrs armeno no Mr Rybeck yes Mr piur yes Mrs Lang yes and Mrs kapano yes madame board president this is a simple motion so it's the majority motion
111passes okay thank you very can I ask a procedural question yes when somebody submits a resignation and you say you vote no against it what is the cause of that how would that serve the purpose if everybody voted no Mr Chella still has the right to resign we can't tell somebody they can't resign just want to make sure yes um and the second thing I have is um it's the time of year where we have to come up with board and District goals for this coming school year and start the budget process with our annual budget philosophy discussion since both of these topics might require lengthy discussions especially the budget philosophy one um with administrative input it was decided to do of this on two separate days our next regular Board of Education meeting is
112Wednesday September 4th where we will create the goals for the 2019 2020 school year um both Bo board goals and District goals our next regular board meeting isn't scheduled until Wednesday October 16th so we will be adding a special meeting to the calendar for Thursday October 3rd to discuss the budget philosophy we as a district continue to expect an increase of our student population which affects everything from classroom space to Staffing to transportation to special education and many other areas and this could be the year where we have to start making some very difficult financial decisions there's a possibility that we will need to have trailers at the middle school and maybe or and or the high school uh we will be heading into negotiations with our bargaining units and there are many um things
113that this school district needs to be doing in the next year in a cap budget we need to begin looking at everything that goes into this budget and make sure that we balance the needs of our students and our fiscal responsibility to our community so I encourage everyone in the public to come to the October 3rd board meeting listen to the discussion that will begin the budget process so at this time time we will go to Other Board of Education business anyone from the Board of Education that has anything I I'll make it really quick uh first is I just want to confirm what I heard today from the adog committee chairman um Lou Masters that he said that at the next meeting he's going to come and talk about the plans that have been
114submitted did I hear that correctly yeah he's going to give us an update on on the plans that probably we will be discussing tomorrow okay the second item is that I think there's a perception that in the committee meetings we vote on resolutions and pass resolutions that's not my understanding I think we just discussed the items and then we vote on them in the public session it is our committee meetings are working meetings that's the the the administration brings us issu issues information and we discuss them we never vote in committee meetings we it would be inappropriate to vote on a committee meetings and if the committee recomends um moving forward it gets put on the agenda and that's where we vote otherwise the committee can turn around and ask for more information so it
115doesn't get on the agenda until the committee feels that the appropriate measures have been taken to make sure that they have everything they need the last item is I want to thank Dr alwick and the staff for conducting very efficiently although we cut it out of the budget the freshman orientation thank you very much and congratulations on a good job thank you anyone else have any anything Miss armino I would I'd like to just make mention in in regards to the open public meetings act that um and I certainly adhere to close session in privacy and protecting our students and private issues um private but the uh open public meetings act says that um public discussion is confined to the portion of the agenda in closed session unless permission is granted by board president prior
116to the start of the meeting when the uh board is considering I'm sorry I'm not going to read that again um from my memory the open public meetings act says that we can go into close session and when such time as the Clos session item is resolved and deemed finished then the uh public can be made aware of it so Clos session items are not permanently um closed to the public and um so I would like to to say uh to put a resolution out saying that the Board of Education uh will provide more detailed on the discussions and deliberations um at committee meetings and in Clos session uh and after close session when the public has um when the need of the public is greater than our need to keep it private when when
117things are resolved so I will make two two resolutions one to provide more comprehensive details on discussion and deliberation at committee meetings and post them that's a first resolution do you want to make that into a motion I would like to make that into a motion well then please do so make a motion to provide more detailed information um in writing on discussion and deliberation at committee meetings and post them on our board docs is there a second to that motion second thank you okay then we'll have discussion on that motion I honestly don't understand what the motion stands for but I think I do understand the fact that the meeting minutes that are being created and read in this meeting should be posted on the board dots I completely agree with that what more
118is being asked as a part of this resolution according to school boards and school boards was here and we asked them that question we put more into our minutes than most of the other school districts in the state of New Jersey it goes through New Jersey school boards it we follow the law we follow what our um board attorney tells us she goes through all the minutes before they come to us for um for approval at at at our board meetings we are doing nothing that we should not be doing we are doing more than we should be doing we're giving more more information minutes of a meeting are not a dialogue between people it is minutes of a meeting it's like this is what happened at a meeting it doesn't it's not supposed to
119be who said what and who is arguing with who and who voted yes for this because we don't vote in meetings so um as as far as I've seen and I've gone to school boards and I know that other people have gone to school boards and have specifically asked this question um we are doing everything appropriately can I Mr Bale I don't understand how we can give more information because in this meeting right here we gave the minutes of the meeting you were very thorough in your minutes Patty was very thorough in her minutes Steve was very thorough and I was very thorough they were very comprehensive so if anybody wants to know what went on the committee meetings all they have to do is watch this and the meetings are it's very comprehensive I
120mean there was no discussion when it came to curriculum you know the um supervisor of mathematics talked to us and we listened and we asked some questions and then we moved on to the next one it wasn't a big in-depth the information is about the curriculum it's really that's where the information is and we all the presentation of all the minutes was very thorough here and if someone is interested in knowing what went on in the meetings all they have to do is watch this and read watch the part about the committee report or come to the committee meetings or come to the committee meetings CU they're open to the public well the gentleman who came up there and complained about it said that he was at the committee meeting and not everything that he
121heard at a committee meeting was in our minutes so exactly because that would be a Verbatim conversation and we don't that's not what committee meetings minutes are it's well well there's some he's saying that there was some subjects that were left out so if some subjects are left left out that's we're not giving all information possible verbatim is impossible to do unless somebody's actually recording it uh we know we can't do that but uh if he's if he's saying that some information's left out well we don't know exactly what information he is saying that was left out either but if that's a complaint we need to address his complaint or or the Public's complaint in general if that's you know but we WE Post all of our regular board meeting minutes on on the website
122and we said as a July 2019 we will be posting all of our committee meetings on the website also Mrs Lang that leads me to a question because I do a committee report a written one and I send it out to the committee members every month but it doesn't get posted it is that's something okay it it does get posted so it's not something that I'm supposed to be the Comm meeting that you sent me last month was posted the board office thank you okay because the I didn't see the one I'll have to resend August but that's okay I I personally I'd like I haven't seen August yet that's I'll just resend it I I think that the idea of passing this resolution without talking to our board attorney and making sure is is
123shortsighted um making sure that we're following the laws making sure we set up the the guidelines as appropriate um I'd like to table this resolution and bring it back to Mary Smith so that we could disc you know if there's anything else that we have to add to it so you have a motion to table yes is there a second to that motion second second by Miss Deo so we will have a roll call on the motion to [Applause] table I make a comment on I don't know that you can comment priority motion motion the table we got to go right to the vote motion to the table go right to the vote U Mr Rybeck yes Mrs Lang yes Mrs Deo yes Mr Tano no Mr P yes Mrs armeno no Mr rutsky yes
124Mrs seagull yes Mrs colano yes m board president uh the yays have it the motion has been tabled thank you Miss armeno did you have a second motion no I will re I will uh reconsider my next motion thank you okay I would like to make a statement though um I I have on on many occasions asked for an analysis between the state constructing uh a a school I mean when we were going through the referenda and I'm repeating this probably for the fifth time in public um I would hope that the analysis would be brought to the board members in committee and also given to the ad hoc committee um the analysis between if the state constructed our school which is probably not uh feasible and um the our referendum uh proposals so a
125comparison between those two things I believe it was sent to the ad hoc committee that that the information was sent to the ad hoc committee or yes Administration uh was acting on Mrs arminio's request um and it was determined that so not to circumvent the work of the ad hoc committee which this C subject matter certainly pertains to that it it would be presented at the ad hoc committee so the ad Comm come to the board so the ad hoc committee got it and I did not or the board did not just just yes or no no no they did not get it they did not get it it was to be brought to the committee as a as a um a recommendation to see if they would consider it that's what was going that
126what cons all I wanted is an analysis I'm not asking that the state I it's not as easy as just doing that that was the issue that's what we there's a lot of things that Wen that are not very easy for us to do but we do at the request of for some board members but thank you very much any other um board business Mrs Lang on July 31st I attended our County school board meeting I just wanted to give you guys an update we voted on the new County um president vice president secretary I forgot their names but what I thought was really exciting that we're going to be doing is that we sat and and we actually talked about what kind of trainings we wanted as County School boards and we're going to
127try to be doing more sharing between each other and having meetings where we would bring like say I would bring our business administrator and our head of security so that we could talk a little bit about what we're doing in our district and get input from other districts so that we could bring it back into for different things we talked about doing that with the vaping po policy we talked about doing that with equity and learning more about what Equity means and with school Finance so I just wanted to give everyone an update for that thank you thank you anyone else okay then we'll go to public forum anyone from the public forum wishing to speak please come to the microphone and give your name and address for the record chrisy scurby uh 21 freakness
128Drive um since it was um mentioned here that Mr shella had resigned his position to the board um I'd like to read a message that uh Ken had sent um to Monroe Township residents friends and Monroe Township Board of Education I have recently been struck with a series of illnesses starting with a surgery in May that has taken me away from being able to serve this District the way it deserves to be served hopefully when I'm well again I will be able to resume my volunteer activ activities in some capacity serving the residents of Monroe T Township is my passion second only to being a dad to my children and a husband to Raquel after much consideration and another Health setback that requires another small surgery I have decided decided to resign my position to
129the Monroe Township Board of Education effective immediately my term ends December of 2019 I will also not seek reelection at this time I will be withdrawing my name from consideration for the November election I want to thank the people of Monroe Township for allowing me to serve you and I promise to return if you will have me when I am well again thank you Ken shella I hope Mr shella gets well again and I think this board should acknowledge that he is he is resigned due to health reasons not reasons that you have no idea about I did not say I had no idea why he resigned yes you did I did not she's so nasty prakash par 33 D drive it is sad to know that Ken has resigned from the board of education
130but his health and family is very important and we also thank for his contribution open discussions always you need some challenges so that best comes out of the board okay not that we vote on the party lines yes yes yes it is always is the issue and passion you guys are elected with passion and emotions with ideas so go and please do that continue to do that what today I would like to talk about is um you know our budgets are getting tied because we are not getting funding from the state every meeting we come and talk you all discuss you all have passion so first of all before going there uh the enrollment every every agenda I come the en enrollment in each school what is the enrollment compared to last last year is
131projected I I missed this in this agenda and it is very important important for the adoc committee as a public we sit so I have the information from the June I don't know why it was not posted this month the en enrollment in each elementary high school and middle school July 2019 versus 2018 I don't know why it was not posted so you can afterward you can comment after my 5 minutes or 4 minutes I'd like to know that answer to the public first of all you know I read the letter which was sent to Governor Linda Greenstein and Everyone by the Iraq committee and signed by our president Kathy you know the we give a background we know what is happening with enrollment group we know what is transportation they are not funding first
132we know what is there with our special education we know all these things but the last bang you have to give which is missing in this letter very good summary what we have to tell them is guys from 2008 you have not given us the money according to the formula so for last 10 years we have lost about 60 million to $65 million we never got from them okay we are to stress that and there are three legislations I have been telling you all there are three good legislations on special education they are there you would have talked about it especially s 3219 okay which will help us in special education funding and I talked to you know assembly Benson if that bill is passed in then this December I bet you these three bills
133are passed we will get at least 4 to5 million in the next budget so let us be strategic and push for that so I request that in the next letter summarize and push what we what we are not getting we are not the expert with the law but the already the bills are there so we have to lobby for these bills if we don't Lobby we are not going to get money okay so I request you to do that and also suing the state because already we get complaints we get sued by the parents because we are not adequately serving the special education because the law there are a lot of things we have to do for the special education we try our the best our school is doing best for the special education but
134we are inadequate in certain category so we should take that point and Sue the state you're not adequately funding our special education they're giving just $2.5 million so I think the letter has to be strong enough okay thank you very much anyone else from the public my name is Audrey Cornish I live at 431 Schoolhouse Road I have been watching you on TV and the reason I'm here is that I've been listening to complaints over and over again why is the town overbuilding what can we do about overbuilding well I can tell you right now I have have a property that my neighbor and I were going to sell for open space because Parker has destroyed the animals that live behind us we have deer and turkey and Bots and turtles and all that so
135we were going to sell our land for open space the town chose to buy the swamp they chose to buy Wetland knowing that we're going to put 19 houses on that property if they didn't buy it they prefer you to have 19 houses and them to buy swamp land for open space now I realize who I'm talking to I know that open space means nothing to this town because she built a high school on open space that was supposed to be open space into perpetuity but you didn't do that there were three places the state said you could have built that high school one of them was T&J all those tow houses are your fault and stop complaining about where all these kids come from because you don't do anything about going to Council meetings
136and making sure that these things don't continue to happen all three places where the state said that you could have had a high school are now built up there was one off Applegarth Road and there was one by that Park in the middle of town that the state we took around the road with them in the car and these places were going to be okay by the state but you'd prefer to build a school in a park on land that was supposed to be here for perpetuity people the taxpayers that voted for open space think it's into perpetuity but there's a little Cil every body that after 20 years they can re-evaluate so all of the states Open Spaces up for grabs because we broke precedent this town was the one that broke precedent because
137we had 42 miles to build a high school and we built it on Open Space and that's why you get rejected from the state they're not going to give you any money they were here they saw and the town chose I don't even blame you it's the voters the people that don't pay attention of what is going on in this town and I just want you to know this I don't care if they buy my property I'm going to make a whole lot more money with 19 houses than I ever will with open space money so I'm going to be the Richer for it but you're going to be the poorer for it because all those animals are going to have no place to go we were offering this to the town and they chose
138to choose swamp land over land that could be built on and it goes on over and over again and it's the town's fault you keep voting for the same people what do you expect a different result keep voting for them you're going to get what you get and I don't care I'm moving anyone else from the public wishing to speak okay at this time we will close public forum and our next schedule Board of Education meeting is uh schedule for September 4th 2019 7:00 P p.m. at the mon toship High School motion to adjourned so move Mr poori I second by Mr Ryback all in favor I opposed and then at this time the meeting is adjourned