CorpusRecord 133013

Monroe Township Board of Education Special Meeting 09.24.19

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Monroe Township School District
Date
2025-02-10
Location
Middlesex County, NJ
Material
Transcript
Extent
7,205 words · about 41 min
Collected
2026-06-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001good evening the mon the special meeting of the Monroe Township Board of Education will come to order please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance Al to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all oops since our board secretary is not here this evening I'd like to read a uh recommendation it is recommended that the Board of Education appoint Steven Ryback as temporary board secretary for this meeting in accordance with njsa 18a col 16-11 need a motion in a second second so mooved by Mrs Lang okay second by Mr Tano okay all in favor I opposed then at this time Mr Ryback you will be our board secretary for the evening take the and take the roll

002call Miss armino here Mr May here Mr K Pano here Mrs Lang here Mr poori here I am here Mr seagull here Mr tufano here Mr rutsky here Madam president you have a qu read the yes whereas whereas following the in accordance with the provision no I'm I'm sorry number four yeah in accordance with the provisions of New Jersey public uh meetings law the Monroe Township Board of Education has caused notice of this meeting to be published by having the date time and place thereof posted September 20th 2019 at all schools home News Tribune cranberry press filed with the clerk of the municipality thank you Mr Ryback so before we go into the public forum I just want to um give you an idea the public and idea of the process of how we came

003to this evening um on August 21st 2019 the Board of Education and members of the Monroe Community received an email from Mr Kella resigning his position on the board due to health reasons at the Board of Education meeting that evening the board members voted to accept his resignation the board of education has an obligation through State Statute and board policy to appoint a replacement member to the Board of Education within 60 days if we do not do so the middle sex County Superintendent is required to come in and fill that position the board was not allowed to leave the position taken for the rest of the year it was something we had asked if we could just forego the last three months of this year and we were told we could not since our board

004has never been in the position to replace a board member Mr Rybeck and myself met with the B board attorney to come up with a fair process to fulfill our state and policy obligations that would be conducted in strict compliance of the law and in a public setting a public notice vacancy on the Monroe Township Board of Education was put in the newspapers and in all district buildings on Friday August 30th while we would normally have a 10day deadline it was felt that a 20-day deadline would give the community more time to consider applying the public notice was also placed before the Labor Day weekend so that was another reason to extend the deadline for 20 days there was also an announcement made at the September third board meeting underneath the board president's report in

005regard to the vacancy on the board of Education board members were then asked to submit questions so that they would that they would like to be considered in interviewing the candidates since we had no idea how many people would apply and we planned to interview all of them on the same day it was decided to give each candidate approximately 20 minutes to answer between five and six questions all being asked by the board president followup questions will be permitted at the deadline of 3:00 p.m. on Friday sep September 20th only one letter of intent and a resume had been received therefore this evening we will be interviewing one candidate at the end of the interview board members will go into Clos session in accordance to New Jersey open public meetings act njsa 12 4-12 parenthesis

006B on parenthesis parenthesis 8 for a discussion on the candidate a majority vote is needed and any vote taken will be done in public if appointed the candidate will be sworn in at the October 3rd Board of Education meeting and assume the responsibilities of member of the Board of Education until the board reorganization meeting in January 2020 Steve do you believe that's the whole thing or do you have anything you could add no I think that's fine okay can I miss Armenia when you say majority vote majority of the Quorum or a majority of the board members majority of the people who were here this evening of okay thank you because there are nine of us and there are only nine members of a board of education at this time so it's a majority of

007everyone yes okay thank you so that um is the process and at this time we'll go to the public forum anyone from the public wishing to speak please come to the microphone state your name and address for the record and we will adhere to our four minutes hi hi uh pradep Milam 4 Jake Place Monro Township uh the next meeting on October 3rd is this a regular meeting monthly meeting or is it a special meeting it is a special meeting um that we will be doing regular board some regular board business we will be doing um what the um oh my gosh what are we doing budget philosophy the what budget philosophy yes so there will be two meetings in October October 3rd and 16th yes okay so is there any chance that the committee

008meetings can happen between now and October 3 October 3rd or no no I think they're scheduled for the second Monday or the the um 14th maybe I'm not quite sure but they've already been scheduled all right thanks um that's it thank you okay thank you Betty sabito to Barry Mor Drive um I just wanted to express my disappointment I had some email exchanges where you were all copied I sent my letter of intent and resum last Tuesday somehow it didn't get to you and you only have one candidate I mean we're talking about transparency I find it very odd it was in a self- addressed envelope that the district actually gave me so where this letter and resume went um I don't understand I think I'm a qualified candidate I think I'm a good candidate

009and I just want to express my disappointment because everything that I send the district gets there and this didn't it just it didn't sit well with me um I don't think it's a fair option and like I said there's only one candidate which the majority of of the board has endorsed in one way shape or form for the next election so it just it makes me question the transparency of this board and I've tried really hard to kind of come out here and see that everybody's trying to do what's best but this this makes me question that so I just wanted to express that disappointment thank you Anthony preso at equestrian way your resume is probably into garbage we know who's going to be on the board all right this nepotism and cronyism has got

010to stop I see the handwriting on the wall there's only one person that put put the resume in well that's because everybody knows that there's no way they're going to get involved in the Board of Ed if you have your heart set on certain people being on the board the deck is stacked like someone said they gave you the application and it disappeared that's terrible now there's things on the board there's there's things that happen that the board members don't even know some of the agenda is not even right and you're voting on the agenda and I'm going to bring that up later thank you we'd only have one public forum this evening so if you need to bring something up it needs to be done now prash 33 dinner Drive uh with respect you

011know always public is questioning transparency so let us make one simple thing if someone goes and gives a envelope to the board District or wherever it is it should be stamped or some receipt should be given saying that you don't know what is inside it we received the envelope this address to this dated this and give it so that this this thing shouldn't be there okay so that's my request okay humble request chance should be given you know another one thing as uh you said next October 3rd meeting good clarified I think we are going to talk about preliminary budget looks like there so there you might have seen very recently uh Edison Middle School they expanded using modular classes they didn't even go to the trailers so that is there so you all are

012the officials please go and see what type of mod modular classes they have put and what did they cost because what is the time frame because we are going to bring in trailers and put them next to here you know so what's the cost so whe whether we can go with the modular classrooms it's so that way they are permanent so we don't lose this these trailers are only good for 5 years we throw away so please consider this in the preliminary budget or explain to us why what Edison this and why we can be away from you know why we are justifying trailers cost versus so I I'll humbly request you all to do that okay so if necessary Mr T if you want I will send that information to take tomorrow it is

013on the what Edison did it is on the news okay I'll send it today Mr T I believe that modular classrooms is being discussed in the ad hoc committees no no I'm talking about instead of trailers can we put modular classes next if we are putting three class trailers somewhere whether we can have model classes is not nothing to adoc committee it is the discussion of trailor coming okay so we have we want to know in the budget because we are going to put in the budget certain amount for the trailers why not we are going to ask why not model our classrooms okay yeah that's the okay thank you thank you anyone else from the public blue Masters n Mela Court I'll address the ad hoc we are looking into the modular classrooms and

014Modular Buildings um the first we had a proposal I think the first company um they don't do school construction for modular there's too many regulations and stipulations so they actually um decline to provide us with more of more of information um but the other thing is which we were discussing with Jerry tag is if you start discussing or if you start considering modular classrooms which are pretty much permanent structures right the you need a lot more money than would have that coming out of the general fund um and we can recommend that as part of the ad hoc so far we've we've we've kind of added it as a side note as something we still want to discuss um I know one of the ad hoc members would saying that they're easier to build on

015top of a building with ad hoc with with um modular construction so we're still going to look into it much like split sessions that's still kind of tabled uh but again what we're seeing so far is it's a lot more expensive and if you're going to consume that in your general fund it's going to impact the students more if you conse it out of the general fund you have to go for a referendum so that's what we saw um as for some of the other statements I was hearing I I mean anybody could have applied right so yeah not just get up here and complain about who they think is going to be the member right it was an open invitation for anybody to submit a letter of intent and a resume because they cast

016dispersions on people for trying to volunteer and do something right it's just bad uh and I have a big problem with that um and again um when I sent mine in I sent it by email return receipt return receipt failed because you that turned off which is fine and then I sat and waited for Mr Gorski to respond I'm guessing the person that came up before must have sent a certified mail if they wanted to make sure that it that it was received right and they'd have proof or did they just put it in the mail and hope for the best um again if it's that important to you make sure it happens don't depend on everybody else and then just arbitrarily say it's your fault or it's somebody else's fault take responsibility for your

017actions thank you anyone else from the public wishing to speak okay then I will close the public forum and at this time I will invite Mr Masters to come up and sit at this nice table with two chairs if you'd like to bring a partner Cel I don't know but maybe Mr rutsky could give him the other bottle of water want me give him a third chair another chair or a couch yeah thank you I am in a lot of susea fed so I'll probably need that water I know the feeling so may we call you Lou because I think we all know who you are yes and most of us know you as Lou so I'd like to thank you for applying for the position or the open position of Board of Education member

018and this um should go pretty quickly we have about six questions that we have for you and um then if anybody has a followup to any of those questions we'll ask them and when the interview is uh completed we will go into close session to have a discussion and then come out and make or not make an appointment please I don't stand on procedure if you have questions I'm in the middle you don't have to wait till the end because then I'll probably forget what I was talking about please ask me right in the middle of the question okay so the first question is to tell us a little bit about yourself and why you would like to fill the open position on the board of education and what you wish to accomplish okay that's

019an easy question right that's the standard introductory question so I did send in my resume it details all of my Technical and volunteer but I'll go into it a little bit more um so I've been in Monroe for about 12 years now uh ever since the beginning I've been volunteering um one of the original founders of the oak tree PTA put that together um and from there I was actually on the board from 2010 to 2013 the Board of Ed um that was the Board of Ed that put in the initial iPads and some of the new technology uh curriculum um from there after 2013 um I have been running for the board of vet a couple more times uh but I've also been on most of all of the ad hoc committees um growth

020technology curriculum uh in addition I'm now the chair of the ad hoc um I call it the growth committee part two um but it is the edoc committee for growth again um so that's what I've been doing more recently um my background is in it uh real exciting originally it was anthropology but I switched over because I wasn't be able to get a job anywhere um I work for the federal Home Loan Bank of New York uh it's actually a federally mandated but not federally funded bank so I don't have all those great Federal uh benefits that everybody else has uh but most of what I do is in the field of affordable housing we Grant uh loans to underprivileged poor uh families so that they may build construction or or build homes uh that's

021what I've been doing on my professional side U I can go on does anybody have any more so why do I want so I actually wasn't 100% sure I was the only one uh and that that is true there's only one person that applied yes that's actually sad um we have so many people that come up and have concerns and comments and criticisms I thought for sure we would have had 20 30 people coming up here to apply for this to try to get on the board and and make um make a difference um it it's a big deal volunteering and I think it's also detrimental to the people that are up here that nobody wants to volunteer they just want to tell you how to do things but they don't want to you know

022uh get their uh get in the game and try to make a difference um so yeah with that I think this is one of the most important things you could do uh especially when you consider that in the lives of a children of the lives of the children this is uh where the where they're at their most formative uh and what we do now again Echoes years later so I think this is probably and I will not have a problem saying this this is the most important board that you can be in in this town and that's why I want to be part of it again and what do you wish to accomplish during your next few months so yeah it's only three months um but it's it could be a pretty pretty significant three

023months I'd like to uh partner with Mr poori on the advoc advocacy group I believe it's called um to talk about Fair funding uh as most of you know we've been talking about that for years but I I have some different opinions on what we should be doing I know we should always be fighting for fair funding um to be quite honest and I've said this in the past I don't know if it's going to work um if you look back man probably to 1975 when this all of this started and they you know they put in the whole Abbot decision in 8 W um and if you remember I don't really remember this but Florio and Whitman tried to fix the uh the failed funding formula and then of course in 2008 uh we

024have what we have now and what they're proposing now either between Sweeney or Murphy right um I get these mixed up Murphy's was the one where he was going to dump couple hundred million but he was going to keep the caps in uh which is what kills us right that's what Mike Gorski always talks about those two uh enrollment caps are really what murders us right uh because we can only no matter what we can still only get 10% uh thankfully that that's not going to be implemented but the Sweeney plan I don't know what you think about that um it it removes the Caps uh it's filtering in the money over what 5 years 2020 to 2025 he's expecting a great economy uh and to be able to focus I guess two billion of

025the state's money per year uh to prop up school funding uh the formula is not really changing they have changed what they're doing the capping is now called defici thing I don't know if you've seen that there's really no good um explanation of what that means basically they're taking what your deficit is in your funding and they're going to give you a percentage of that to me that sounds exactly like what the capping was the enrollment capping um so in my opinion uh I I think both of them are Dead on Arrival uh and I think we really need to get back to it either attack it as what what is this deficit what are you guys trying to do uh is this an end around you're doing basically the same thing um you know

026recession or not in the next five years most most people think there will be some sort of limited recession I don't think the state's going to be able to fund two2 billion a year um and even if they do with the deficit uh algorithm that they're doing they'd still only be responsible for say what they could cover say 10% so even if we're again through the funding formula are respons ible for 50 million uh it'll be what the state can actually afford so again we're going to be back to where we are asking the state to um fulfill what they've said you got to remember this whole funding formula was meant to push school districts towards the middle right towards a adequate education and since again we've heard this time and time again we're on

027the other side the over adequacy uh By Design it will not benefit us so I think we have to start looking at yes we can still Tech through the advocacy or through our elected officials which I don't know what your opinion is has worked or not worked in the past but I think we really started out we have to start looking at different ways of funding now I'm not saying go back to the 75 where we just basically paid for it all out of pocket and taxes covered Almost 100% we're almost there right we're at 86% uh but that's what it was back then right we just basically paid for it and that's why the Abbot uh decisions came in because you had a lot of very wealthy disc districts uh that were funding very

028wealthy schools and then you had poor districts that had really poor schools so and I'm not an advocate for abitor against it they're also being I guess maligned in the news media and they don't they actually newark's actually owed 100 million out of their Fair funding too and they're an Abbott District so again uh you take that for what it's worth sorry I drone on but I'm a little bit passionate about the funding for we've been trying to figure it out for years and we still can't figure out do anybody have a uh a question they'd like to ask I do Mr um thanks for putting your an application um I I just have one question when did you receive a response from Gorski because you said it was delayed because the system was down

029when did you receive a response for your application I can tell you almost exactly hold on well I can tell you after the meeting I did get an email no no I'd like to know now if you don't mind okay hold on a second this won't count for my time right no it won't cuz do you know what time we started I don't that's okay no you're not going to count the time though I don't know what time we even started it was 8 minutes so started it now yeah it was received at hold on no when he did he respond to yeah that's what I'm getting where I received it so that would be it was received by me uh so I sent my application in at 12:30 on FR what day September 20th

030September 20th Thursday Friday Friday that was Friday yes that was Friday right nothing like waiting till the last minute and it looks like it was I'm sorry I'm struggling with my browser 12:41 looks like that yeah that's what it looks like to me so 11 minutes later 11 minutes that's my best guess right now when I go home I can actually print it out for you so Friday the 20th at 12:30 yes and you received the r at 12:41 that's what it looks like yes all right thank you you're welcome okay Mr Masters we have 15 minutes left so the next one's easy and what school or District activities have you been involved in um from Inception again I've been part of the oak tree which is now the oak tree appor PTA um I

031really enjoy that um I'm also part of some of the wreck uh it's not really school but some of the wre soccer um curricular activities um from there again most of it's been advocacy for the school district either through ad hoc committees or boards and I covered that I don't want to go through it again I'd rather take my four minutes you are appointed to the mono Township zoning board by the mayor and the township Council isn't that a conflict a conflict of interest during this time of Rapid residential building and cost of housing students so yeah I am a member of the zoning board for about four four or five years I've been a member of the an alternative of the zoning board um appointed by the council not the mayor uh just I

032know there's been a lot of uh um incorrect statements going on it is a council appointment um and no it's not there is actually no conflict between those two and actually I see it as an asset um as I've said many many times before having an advocate or a aison from the board member and we used to have I believe Mr Chella was the planning board lays on from the um Board of Ed having an advoc kit for the Board of Ed on that side of it um helps us with getting our point across or even um adding to some of the consideration now we can't because of the impact fees and all those laws we can't make decisions on the zoning board based on the schools um but again they can be heard and

033we can discuss them and I know even Mark Klein comes to pretty much every meeting and tries to advocate for it I have a follow follow Miss Miss arminia um you you use the word advocate for the Board of Ed as a M of the zoning board M uh I think you need to elaborate on that I mean are you there you will be there so you're there as a member of the zoning board correct I see what you're getting at yeah because if you're if as an if you're an advocate so if you're an advocate for the board you would you would it would seem like you'd be speaking for the board you'd have to have uh additional permission from oh yeah it we never be speaking for the board as you know when

034you get up and you say I'm speaking as a personal not as a board member that's how it would always be so that so that's what I'm saying how could you be an advocate and still be on well you don't so you're not so maybe Advocate isn't the right word no it is and I think we all all everybody here is an advocate for the Board of Education right and for what we do okay not officially then you're saying okay yeah because I wonder how that was going to work even on the zoning board I wonder how developers would feel about that but again remember we used to have a Las on um on planning and they would actually bring in zone or um Board of Ed comments and and things like that now and

035we know how well that worked well but again I think it's something that is a again an asset and not a liability okay thank you number four should you should you support a majority board decision if you were not in favor of it please explain wow that's a good one um so so no you're all elected everybody's elected or appointed as individual voting members you shouldn't um again vote for the overall majority right that's part of how this all works um that's actually an easy one and I I find that um again that's a home run um there's never been a time that I was ever even on the board or anything like that where I was is told to just go along with the majority we always voiced our opinions and we would Voice

036or we would uh vote against or for things based on what we believe and based on what was produced evidence that was produced now that doesn't mean you can't have a discussion to try to come to an agreement and that's what being part of this collaborative board is right you're always trying to come to an agreement um and see all the different Avenues and different points of interest again that's how the board works now that doesn't mean that doesn't mandate that everybody has to vote for the same thing in the same way I don't think it ever has Mr Ryback I just Lou I just need a clarification yes sir once the board votes the majority of the board votes let's in favor or against something as a board member would you support that decis

037oh yes once it becomes something that's been again approved by the board I know we we had a lot of that last year or so where um there were people posting on Facebook and and following up but again all it does is demean and undermine the power of the board right you shouldn't doing things like that once it's done you voice your desent and then you support the board as a whole that's what you're here for than wow what was that Mr I said wow wow why I'm amazed at that statement you just made go ahead no I'm good no please I would love to hear this and you know what I'm good you don't have to address you I let's remove the formalities you can you call me on Facebook yesterday you are you

038are we are here to ask you questions you're not to ask question I you would not comment and make I can say whatever I want you know I'm going to say to you but I don't have to answer to you wow okay Mr teano that's not necessary you're that's why I said I'm good okay Mr wow that's all I'm going to say wow if you were to get on the board what do you see as the district's strengths and weaknesses so like I said um I think for a while there um when I was first running in 2010 29 and I I kept using the words lumbering Behemoth right the board would just move along not a lot of changes that's changed now and I and it's more of I call it fighting fires and

039being more reactive um you have a split board uh the majority of which again I believe is working for in the best interest and you have um some members of the board that aren't um it's obvious and everybody sees that and I think what happens is even for the case of the referendum when we had the referendum you had board members that were actively campaigning against the referendum that was previously approved by the board back to Mr Ryback's question what we said before once it's approved by the board you don't go out and campaign against something the board thinks will actually benefit the students and I think that's one of the biggest problems we have here um the board is not coming together even after votes um there's a very um I guess a very

040negative connotation about the communication of the board uh and again it's warranted there's a lot of different comments coming out you hear different statements um after the fact about what's going on or or negative uh dis again I'll use it dispersions about the board and it shouldn't happen you're here to help the kids you've all been elected you're all volunteering you're all contributing a lot of time I've been there um you should be doing your best in the best interest of the kids not for some political agenda um if you ever read the book uh Barbarians at the gate uh it's actually the movie was a lot better I think uh but what happens is you get uh I say political money that tries to come in and start to steer the conversation right and

041I think we're starting to see that now even on a federal level and on a local level is you have a lot more money coming in into these local elections and trying to steer it from the ground up and I think that's a major problem because you're not talking about council elections and stuff like that you're talking about Board of Ed elections where the kids are at stake um people are playing political games with the children in this district and I think once that happens you have what you call the Lost generations of kids um because you're fighting and there's infire and people the board isn't really doing anything right you're just reacting to ethics violations and things like that um nobody's wondering or nobody's worrying or caring for the schools and the children and

042stuff like that and I think that's one of the things this board is going to have to fix what about the school district itself not necessarily the board of education but the school district the strengths and weaknesses oh this is a great District I think you have some of the best staff um around and I think if it wasn't for that staff we would be in a lot more Pro a lot more trouble um the biggest issue I think we have right now is the attrition rate of your teachers um I was trying to get some numbers it's like 10 12 15% and that's an awful number um now is that based on salary or based on perks or benefits um yes it's based on all of them um they can go up to Woodbridge

043and get another 20% or 30% increase and that's not much of a commute um they can go over and get maybe um um Child Care full-time child care for free or discounted child care if they go to Edison or something like that um we need to keep our most important assets which are our teachers and and uh by extension our administrators and staff and I think that's the biggest issue we have right now if we don't we're going to keep losing 10 or 20% of our good students they're our good teachers uh they're going to move off we're going to keep re um refilling those those numbers and they're going to keep moving off basically we'll basically become a training center for all the other districts in this state we can't do that now I'm

044not saying throwing money at it is the way to do it I honestly I don't know if you could that's a something that has to do with uh uh the union and everything like that but I think there's other ways that you can try to keep this the uh teachers and the staff right we talked about having Child Care uh we talked about giving them discounts on things or even giving more back from the opt out program I think that's it's a minimal amount that we actually give them back give them more back it's still a win-win we keep our teachers we don't have to retrain our educational staff and again we'll still make a profit on it we don't have to make all of our programs cash cows some of them have to benefit

045the people and the TR and the children that we have here Mr poori did you have a question followup yes uh Mr basts uh we all get on the board to make a difference the Board of Education we want to do something positive but sitting on this side of the table over the last eight months I can tell you that's it's fairly frustrating to see that there are constraints on the side of the board on what you can and cannot communicate with public and you see the public come back and start attacking us for things that they perceive and there are a lot of rumor Mills and and untrue statements put on the Facebook at the end of the day it becomes a difficult job to accomplish are you ready for something like that to

046go through and still try to make a difference and if so how do you plan to do that oh 100% um if you think back to the last election what I went through um I don't think any candidate should be subjected to uh one of the reasons I even wasn't going to run for the uh um the election in November was what my children and family would put through in the last um campaign uh I asked my children which is a really really sad conversation to have if they were okay that Daddy ran again that they would be impacted and people would attack them verbally and on Facebook um and to have your 8-year-old son tell you that's okay um he's okay with it I mean that is a conversation I wouldn't want to have

047until he's a teenager at least right um even my my teenager who was the was subjected to some verbal insults last year um and and he's he's very um emotional and he has again he has an IEP and he he has some anxiety disorder um he was the one who finally said you have to do it dad you can't let those bad people win right that's how it refers to everything to evil people um so I have no problem doing it my family has been Reed um if anything like that would happen again and I'm sure it will this is a I mean the campaigns in this town are as dirty I've ever seen um I'm sure that will and I and I think I'm ready for it I have no problem with it now

048back to with the communication yeah I've been on the board before and I know it is frustrating um there's a lot you want to change you get on there and then there's a lot you can't change so you try to make do with what little you can you try to come up with some creative ideas you try to again you try to make you have your advocacy committee you try you try to Advocate you try to go up to the state level again uh most of it is try but again uh if you don't try uh again for even being up here uh and applying for this then nothing will ever change right again we'll be that lumbering Behemoth again and we'll just go on and 10 years will go by and while failing schools

049or something like that so that's why I'm here Mr rutsky if I may Mr M thank you for being here tonight thank you throwing your hat in the ring we appreciate it um you mentioned politics a little bit there and a few of your answers and so my question is where do you see the role of politics within the Monro Township Board B board there should be no politics yeah we have one minute left okay so there should be no politics in the board of B now it is a nonpartisan but again um with that said every every board like this is has some sort of political Edge to it right um what Mr poori is doing at the state level is politicking and you have to so it's one of the things where you

050don't want to get into your operational uh what you're doing on the operational level but outside your strategic and your your strategic plans have to include some of the politics now again you have to draw a a firewall between those two things and never let that local politics which we're seeing somewhat um get involved in what we're trying to do here again what we're trying to do for the kids I'm sorry the drum is the drum beat is actually throwing me off my heart I know I'm actually trying to talk to that drum beat okay so you have 14 seconds which will take me the the last set but you probably won't be able to finish so how do we know if our goals are being accomplished yeah well you again just like a and

051again I hate to say this just like of business you have to have Milestones which we have Madam Madam may may I ask that Mr U Masters be allowed to finish she's the only one here I think we could wave our as as situation I would ask that the whole board would allow him to finish okay so let me ask the whole question thank you thank you you're welcome thank you Miss armeno how does the board know if its goals are being accomplished and its policies are being carried out and just to say if call you Michelle if she's for nothing she is for fairness I will say that I could always say that uh we might argue on certain things but she's always been Fair um so how do we again I I take

052a business lean on this right and when we used to do any kind of our goal reviews even here or on our on a at the bank um you have to have Milestone set up ahead of time and make sure you're hitting them it's a real simple process um if you don't set them up and again this isn't it's a board it's a collaborative effort with the board and the administ ation right so you'd have the superintendent come in and most likely the principles um supervisors staff things like that uh create goals for the year create milestones for those goals and then track back and have again um meetings where you analyze to make sure you're hitting those time frames I hate again I hate to apply business but but it works um and it's

053not too busy it really just says if you're going to do what you do make sure you're doing what you do okay so that concludes the question but I just want to ask had did you receive these questions before this evening I did not okay although the first one I knew was going to be that one about why you're were here so well that's pretty typical okay thank you Mr Masters thank you I want to thank you for your time and an advance and for uh your deliberation time so I assume you're going to be sticking around while we're in Clos session because we shouldn't be very long yes I will be here okay Kathy may I ask a question before we conclude uh to Mr Masters no to you okay Mr Master is leave

054thank you um I'm surprised to hear uh the lady who came up and said that her application was not received is there any more information from our side um is that true and is confirm that we haven't received anything we have not received anything there we looked at the board office today when we found out that she said she applied and there has been nothing they went through all the the secretaries in the board office they went through the the um the mail room and everything there's been nothing but we all know too that sometimes you can't you can't rely on the post office but this is a week since she said she mailed it but we could have done um you know certified mail she could have texted the um business administrator to see

055if uh he received it and knowing that maybe he didn't that she could have forwarded to him so it's not like we received after the deadline or anything we have not received I just want to confirm no it was not thrown in the mail okay in the trash in the trash you mean it is a shame yeah it is I can M Aria yeah I would just like to state that uh when I received that information uh I was upset that uh she did not you know I I didn't know at the time when I first received the email that there was no that it was not received I thought it was received late I did asked my uh colleagues via email if they would consider allowing her to interview um apparently that is not

056going to be the case but I did uh make that request of my colleague so if anybody wants to comment on that I would when you say colleagues who are you referring to well you are my colleagues sir my colleagues on the board I I sent an email oh this afternoon because I I just got it this afterno you may everybody should have received an email or response to Michelle's email yes oh that I didn't get no I had received I had received an email this morning um and as soon as I received the email we started looking for the package or envelope or whatever we couldn't find it and then we did again this afternoon when we received the second email and your email response so there there is nothing there okay so Mr

057no thank you [Applause] okay be it resolved that the Board of Education of the township of Monroe hereby moves to go into close session in accordance with the Sunshine Law chapter 231 of the public laws of 1975 njsa 10 col 4-6 through K 10 col 4-21 to discuss the following subject appointment of a public official discussion of candidate following close session action may be taken the discuss discussion conducted in Clos session can be disclosed to the public at such time as the need for confidentiality no longer exists I need a motion in second Mr poori second second by Mr rutsky all in favor well I think oppose and I'd like to read a statement please I just want yeah I'm I'm opposing this motion I'd like to make a statement there's a discussion that's the

058discuss well we don't usually have a discussion when we do a a a Clos session resolution all right so I could read my statement then just read it okay I would like the public to know why I will be voting but not participating in this closed session tonight this applicant we have in front of us just ran this past November and the tax payers voted they sent a clear message that they did not want Masters on the board of ed since his loss he has not shown himself at any board meetings only when he was added by the board president to lead the adha committee this committee was formed in order to gain the Public's trust trust involve them more involve them more and gain their trust again so that we can pass a much

059needed referendum imagine that the board president put in putting in charge of person the taxpayers didn't have enough confidence to elect to this board now we have this special meeting meeting tonight to Phil Kent's position two of our members tonight ran a campaign with Mr Masters last November six current board members have publicly and privately endorsed him for that very position he fa to win in my opinion the vote tonight has been predetermined it may not be legal but again in my opinion it is unethical thank you [Applause] Madam president I want to ask a question and this is what the problem is and I know I want to make it right but I can't make it right if somebody does not approve Mr Masters application I have my own feelings about that as well

060which I conveyed to Mr Masters why would they go through the entire interview process and then make a statement at the end of all of this well it was probably inappropriate and I let that let that person do it no no we're not gonna have a conversation out here we are now in Clos session and when we come out of closed session we will make a resolution okay at this time the board will come back into public session and I will read a resolution whereas following the resignation of Mr Ken shella from the Monro Township Board of Education parentheses board on August 21st 2019 the board actively sought candidates for this open seat reviewed one letter of interest and resume and interviewed the candidate and having identified a qualified candidate to fill this vacant seat

061on the board now therefore be it resolved that the Monroe Township Board of Education hereby appoints Mr lwis C Masters to F really that's uncalled for to fill the seat recently vacated by Mr Chella effective immediately and continuing through the 2020 board organization meeting tentatively scheduled for January 20 January 2nd 2020 is there a motion in a second I'll make the motion second Mr rutzky Miss um Deo it's been a long time since I seen you D any comments or questions Miss um Lang Mrs Lang Madam president I will be um abstaining from the vote I fully support Lum Masters I think he's a wonderful Choice as a board member and that is why I'm making the decision because though it is not legally unethical for me to vote in this vote I feel it

062is personally unethical and I have to follow my own ethics first thank you okay miss armeno my vote will also be an exstension because um Mr uh Masters is also running in the next election as am I so I think it would uh be appropriate for me to abstain thank you anything else okay then at this point Mr Ryback we will have a roll call M seagull yes Mr Lang abstains obstain uh I vote Yes Mr rutsky yes Mr poori yes Mr tufano no Mr Mayo yes Mrs K Pon yes I'm sorry Mr how many you you abstained yes Mr kovich yes yes U Madam president motion passes how many yeses please one two three four five six okay six yeses one no and two abstains that equals the nine of us so Mr Masters

063I don't know where you are there he is M so congratulations on your appointment to the board of education and I don't know if you have any comments you would like to make before you know we close for the evening name an address please BL master or you could sit at the table we're have four minutes BL Master this is fun no he gets again thank you for this process this time again I I actually had hoped that uh there were more people that applied for it but again um it's a lot of effort and dedication uh and again I hope I can rise to that challenge um again I also hope that Mr Cher is on the mend I know why he resigned I hope he's getting better and he can join us sometime

064soon uh I just want to clear up a couple of misconceptions about me um yes I am on the zoning board there's no conflict we covered that one thank you uh my wife does work for Rise she does not work for a Freeholder um I know somebody said that uh that's totally incorrect um my wife is not conflicted she's not part of the teachers union anymore I saw people saying I wife I couldn't vote on anything there's no conflict there and actually we've had people on this board that have more of a conflict than that they've had uh children and and and spouses that directly worked for um some of the schools so the only thing I did consult the lawyer is I would not be able to um uh talk about the superintendent evaluation

065or not be able to vote on the superintendent evaluation I actually would be able to sit on negotiations and I could vote on the MTA contract U again there was no conflict of that um I think that was pretty much it I want to thank everybody I know there's been some really nasty stuff going around I am now I guess known as a maggot coward thank you Mr Tiano that's great and actually I would really check with your ethics on that are you going to yell with him no I'm not he has four minutes to speak I have four minutes to talk but again um I do appre oo language wow again people walking out of Board of Ed meetings and not committed to these students is what we have to root out if you

066remember a quote from Watergate it's a cancer if you let it grow it will infect everything and we really have to get rid of that um again the only reason I bring that up is that again it was a um an actual open threat to me and about attending tonight so I have an issue with that with one of your board members I think it will be uh investigated by your board attorney um and again um I'm in this for the right things uh what was spoken about before there's actually no campaign law that says if you lose an election you can no longer run again right I've never heard of that um and actually the taxpayers only a portion of the taxpayers uh voted against me a portion did vote for me so again

067um it's an illogical and irresponsible argument uh to cast again dispersions on somebody else because of a issue with them being a maggot coward and I keep saying it because it's very colorful and um what the hell I like it so thank you very much again for your votes uh I will do the best I can and I will collaborate with everybody on this board I just want to let you know because I think I forgot to say it you will be sworn in at the October 3rd meeting which is next week and I still have my I think I still have my plaque so you don't have to purchase another one oh if I may I just want to say congratulations and I would I would actually argue that coward is anything but somebody

068who throws their hat in the ring and volunteers their time for whatever the reason in this case particularly for the kids not a coward and we look forward to having you on the board thank you that actually feels good I think most importantly we to put all this behind us very quickly and start working as a board AG you know as a board of education we don't have to like each other we don't have to socialize out of this room but we are all in here we have an obligation to our students especially our students and to our staff and we have to work together without the name calling without the bullying without the the the lies that are going on Facebook all the time with people assuming certain things that are not true um

069apparently I appointed Mr master as the ad hoc chair knowing he was going to run for the Board of Education I had no idea and I'm sure Mr Masters will tell everybody he had no idea until the end that he was going to do that so I'm tired of it and and there's no there's no reason for it we need to have come together as a community all together working for the good of the kids so that's all I have agreed thank you thank you can I say yes oh sure I know board secretary but I still would like to just say a few congratulatory words to you Lou um it's going to be a pleasure to work with you I know we've been on different sides of the fence definitely but we've always uh

070been able to to speak and and work together and uh I think that's Andy's right that's what we all have to do as a board and I guess the proof will be in the pudding so uh let let's let's all get together and and and do a great job for the kids and that's actually a perfect example when were running against each other we despised right despised each other we didn't get we disliked each other speak for um but again now I I think uh Mr Rybeck is a great asset to this board of education thank you nobody didn't get along more than me and Mr Ryback and now we are the best of friends and we make a good team up here I believe we do and we're always here for the same reason

071I know I can count on him and he can count on me sometimes your your first impressions of people turn out to be wrong and I think that's what we have to do is is learn about people instead of just you know believing everything that's out there and not trusting yes exactly thank you and I I need to see you after the meeting okay okay so the next scheduled Board of Education meeting will be October 3rd 2019 7 o'clock pm. at the Monroe Township High School we will be doing the budget philosophy motion to adjourn Mrs Lang Mr Mayo all in favor I I opposed then the meeting is adjourned thank you

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.