CorpusRecord 133015

Monroe Township Board of Education 01.15.25 Regular Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Monroe Township School District
Date
2025-01-16
Location
Middlesex County, NJ
Material
Transcript
Extent
15,042 words · about 84 min
Collected
2026-06-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001my name on the list good evening everybody it is Wednesday January 15th the first meeting of 20225 this is the Monroe Township Board of Education monthly meeting um can I please ask everybody to stand for the Pledge of Allegiance Pledge of Al of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liy and justice for all okay so I would I can do the rooll okay um okay we're gonna move I'm going to do our roll calls um Miss Alvarez here miss Bora here miss depay here miss Fabiano here Dr peek here Mr Piro here Miss Ratner here miss Sharma here Mr tuano Mr zner yes here okay we have a quorum in accordance with the provisions of the New Jersey open public meetings law

002the Monroe Township Board of Education has caused notice of this meeting to be published an electronic notice provided by having the date time and place thereof posted October 25th 2024 and January 10th 2025 at all schools on the district West website on the home News Tribune cranberry press and filed with the clerk of the municipality um then next item on our agenda is the Clos session resolution whereas the senator Byron M Bear open public meetings Act njsa 10 colum 4-6 provides that the Monro Township Board of Education May hold an executive session from which the public is excluded to discuss matters that are confidential or are one of the nine subject matters listed section 12b of the act and whereas that the board hereby declares that its discussion of the following subjects will be made

003public at a time when the Public's interest in disclosure is greater than any privacy or governmental Interest being protected from disclosure now therefore be it resolved by the Monro Township Board of Education that the board shall go into executive session to discuss the following items additional items may be determined and announced as needed pending or anticipated litigation and matters covered by the attorney client privilege um attorney advice on proposed confidential agreement personal matter be it further resolved that said discussion may be disclosed to the public when reasons for discussing and acting upon it in close session no longer exist action may be taken on any of the items stated above is there a motion make a motion motion by Mr Pio second by Miss Ratner um we also need to appoint an acting secretary since

004Miss Allen is not here do so if I can just make a suggestion um we have a pending motion on the floor to go into executive session um I would suggest that we we make um we resend that okay um make a motion to appoint an acting secretary until um the secretary arrives uh and then from there make the motion to go into executive session so the person that made the motion is the one serving it yes is that me mhm okay I resend the motion to go into close session Miss Alvarez offered to okay so I'd like to um make a motion to appoint Miss Alvarez as board temporary board secretary I second that and then I'd like to make a motion we go into close session no no you got to vot have

005AG can we do all in favor can you speak into the mic please so I can hear everyone you could do all in favor uh for the appointment of the temporary appointment of Miss Alvarez to cover as a secretary for this meeting okay all those in favor to appoint Miss Alvarez as a any opposed any extensions okay Mr Piro I'd like to make a motion we go on to close session second second um great miss rat and everything second it okay all all those in favor we would do a roll call vote okay so let me go back to the Roll Call um Miss Alvarez yes Miss Bora yes Miss depay yes Miss Fabiano yes Dr pek yes Mr Piro yes Mr Miss Ratner yes Miss Sharma yes Mr zner yes and for the benefit

006of those who are in attendance here and those who are watching at home the board's going to go into executive session for approximately one hour the board will not take any formal action while in executive session any formal action by the board will be taken out here in the public upon the board's return from executive session so we'll be in executive session for approximately 1 hour thank [Music] you the board is back in session we do have a uh not a resolution but an item that we need to vote on so it is recommended that the members of the Monroe Township Board of Education approve the previously submitted settlement agreement between the Monroe Township Board of Education and the Monroe Township Education Association is there a motion motion second motion by Miss deine second by

007Miss Bora U Miss Allen can we have a roll call please yes M Alvarez yes Miss B yes M yes Dr P yes Mr I'd like to abstain abstain M Sharma yes uh Mr Z I will obain and Miss Fabi yes motion passes okay the next item on our agenda is the approval of board minutes uh the first one is the public Board of Education meeting minutes from December 18th 2024 motion second motion by Miss Alvarez second by Miss Bora um any questions or comments all those in favor I I any oppose extensions okay then the next one is the close session meeting minutes from December 18th 2024 motion second motion by Mr Pay second by Miss B questions comments all those in favor I I any extensions right okay then the next item on

008our agenda is our student board members report happy New Year thank you Happy New Year everyone we're excited to be back for this new year um so we'll start off with the Barkley Brook Elementary School updates the day before winter break was a festive one at Barkley Brook School students and staff were invited to wear their favorite holiday or any pajamas and the school gathered together in the gymnasium for their annual holiday singalong students shared simple musical instruments and sang along with favorite holiday and seasonal songs that were projected on the screen students even danced along with some songs and the festive mood was palpable it was the perfect way to begin winter break the first graders at Barkley Brook School learned about holidays around the world in December and culminated with a Polar Express

009day on December 19th each Barkley Brook first grader received a ticket to board the Polar Express The Polar Express conductor greeted the students aboard as they paraded down the hallways with bells carolling around them the students arrived at their North Pole destination the Barkley Brook Cafe and viewed The Polar Express movie while enjoying the snack Barkley Brook's students began writing p pal letters to residents at Parker life a senior living facility located in Monroe students were assigned a Parker life resident as a pen pal and they wrote their pen pals letters before the holiday season they are eagerly awaiting a response from their Parker life pen pals and now we're going to be moving on to the Brookside School updates first the classrooms oh the classroom spelling bees took place on January 9th the Brookside

010School wide spelling be will occur on January 28th the students are continuing to do a great job meeting expectations the students earned enough feathers to receive a schoolwide pajama day on January 21st marking Period 2 ends for fourth and fifth graders on February 3rd next up is MIL Lake Elementary School mil Lakers have started the year with enthusiasm and excitement they kicked off the year with their third grade student council snow much spirit week activities included Pajama Day favorite winter sweaters day and toe bog and hat day all showcasing their school spirit their student council will continue their hard work raising Civic awareness with their upcoming events like the Super Bowl which is for soup collection taking place from February 3rd to the 7th Additionally the council is leading mil Lake's first ever serial Box

011challenge this event will culminate on February 14th with a thrilling domino challenge as students and staff set up a chain reaction of Serial boxes throughout mil Lake school this week super advisor Daniel drust arranged their annual historic lenp Lenape interp interpreter to present to mil lak's third grade students the presentation captivated everyone sparking excitement and curiosity among students and staff alike thank you Mr dress for bringing this winter highlight to their school our district team continues to Foster collaboration and connection on January 24th the high school athletes will visit mil Lake to read to their enthusiastic second graders this inspired IR ing interaction is sure to leave a lasting impression on both the readers and their young Monroe fans later this month on January 31st their preschoolers and kindergarteners will receive a special visit from

012a local dentist with much brushing and Bright Smiles this assembly promises to be both educational and fun mil Lake School continues to be a place where learning joy and togetherness Thrive here's to a fantastic start to 2025 Woodland Elementary School had many things happened this month the advanced band and core students performed their Winter concert for students and staff the students earned extra snack time for their good citizenship in December and Club code students had a showcase for their stem instruction at the Mt at Monro townships High School the Woodland student council is also hosting their annual Super Bowl by collecting cans and boxes of soup to help fight hunger in our town from January 15th through February 7th Friday student council is kicking off a spa Fida fundraiser by having students and staff Wear

013Yellow on Friday January 17th character crew is coordinating a coat drive from January 14th to January 24th Jamie new school counselor coordinated an assembly scheduled on Friday January 17th bullying prevention laser school assembly program called let's work together to keep your school safe and Bully free moving on to Oak Tree Elementary School on January 9th their self-contained students participated in a unified PE day with their unified grade three Pals and students from the high school as well it was an energetic funfilled hour for everyone involved January 27th uh kickoff assembly for their kids for hearts challenge which will begin that day through February 14th and on January 24th the high school athletes will visit oak tree to read to their second grade classes as part of the second and sth program in Applegarth many other

014things are happening as well miss fleser and Mr rigan kicked off their kids heart challenge assemblies on January 13th students will be fundraising for the American Heart Association into the month of February in various ways Apple guard's classes will be honoring the memory of Dr Martin Luther King Jr student council in collaboration with Mr Mrs lizzio's class is organizing a fundraiser called project Sunshine the class made a presentation to the principal about fundraising to purchase play kits for children to help them through Hospital experiences classes that will donate will then get a game period in school on Friday January 24th finalists have now been decided for Apple guard's schoolwide spelling be which is being held on Friday January 17th their PTA is hosting a snack sill on the early dismissal day Friday January 17th as

015well the principal's book club for January will be meeting on Thursday January 30th from 4:00 to 5:00 p.m. on Google meet on January 29th a group of students at Applegarth will be hosting a stem and Game Night the students are fundraising to try and enhance their play area admissions is $5 and students will rotate among six stations including physical games an escape room a scavenger hunt a stem activity and an art station coming out for a family night of fun alagar parent portal for February conferences will be opening up on February 5th more information will follow from Applegarth directly all right now moving on to mner Township Middle School the entire staff of mtms wishes Miss Pat Smith 7eventh grade assistant principal Miss Louie Balman uh principal secretary and Miss Amy pole school secretary a

016very happy retirement you will be missed and can never be replaced uh please join the mtms on January 16th for their 7th and eighth grade band concert at 700 p.m. their wonderful musicians have worked very hard and will be providing their guests with a wonderful night on Wednesday January 15th the Middle School celebrated its November and December students of the month with a breakfast where parents were invited to join them in celebrating their children November students of the month were Adrien Fardo Justin April and Jay zanon December students of the month were Colton Ian con Kennedy Bates and shambavi pond students are picked based on academic Excellence work ethic and exemplifying their pillars of character the mtms Falcon Jazz Ensemble purple Jazz Ensemble and Wind Ensemble will be performing for nearly 100 seniors at the

017Monroe senior CI Citizen Center on Friday January 10th the seniors were delighted to watch the hardworking ensembles provide a sample of the array of Music performed in the mtms winter concert series Miss suit's 7th grade ELA classes participated in a mock trial of Edgar Allen Po's famous horror story The Tell Tale Heart after a dramatic two-day trial the narrator of the story accused of first-degree murder was found free from blame following a compelling argument backed by the insanity plea and last but not least we're moving on to mro Township's High School the Monro Township High School drama club will be putting on their wonderful winter play on January 31st and February 1st feel free to come out and join them the mths College and Career Counseling Center will be hosting an information night for parents

018of current 9th and 10th grade students on January 23rd in the high school performing arts center last week on Thursday January 9th the high school Winter band concert took place with amazing performances from various different ensembles thank you everyone for listening and have a good night thank you guys very much I didn't realize so much happened from the time we came left in December until now so thank you for that um the next item on our agenda is our committee reports are there any committees wishing to give a report I know we had a joint committee meeting of the finance and buildings grounds Transportation um I don't know how we wanted to Mr P will start and then I have mine so we're doing a joint report okay um Mr P do you want to

019give the building's grounds report um does this Bor want to combine the with Finance Oh I thought you were going to do the first part and you want me to do the first that's fine up I first part yeah just do your part and then I'll continue with the details okay thank you just pull it up pull it up I we can do policy first all right here we go um Miss Carolyn Jackson and the Honeywell team provide an update to their Energy savings Improvement plan Esa and the following team of experts address their specific areas of the esap um Jaclyn Shane Esquire mcarter English Debon councel Mr Anthony anderso Phoenix advisors Municipal advisor Miss hope Blackburn Esquire uh the bush Law Group uh Miss shanes provided and thoroughly reviewed three draft resolutions pertaining to

020the esep that the board will be asked to take action on at the upcoming public meeting a resolution authorizing the local Finance board application a resolution approving the esap and a resolution for the refunding bond ordinance Mr inverso addressed the bonding process and financial projections committee members had a discussion on the merits of the contract guarantee and decided to table a discussion on the guarantee until they an opportunity to review additional references and data requested from Honeywell um s shanes and Mr and inverso noted the delaying of decision on the guarant until February board meeting will not delay the overall project so basically we want to go forward with the resolutions there's a part of insuring and a cost to the district for the insurance and we were waiting for more information uh the Honeywell

021people told us that they 100% never ever District's ever used the insurance that they paid for so we were looking for more information yeah and I'll share some more details on that so the total cost of the project if we get the additional decarbon ization Grant which will allow us to increase the scope of the project will be $12.6 million in the absence of the grant it'll be $1.9 million with a reduced scope the total energy cost savings to the district over 20 years is expected to be over 14.1 million 2.4 million of which will come from the solar savings which will be realized through the solar power purchase agreement the bond ordinance which will be introduced tonight will be for $13.5 million uh it is important to understand that the way esip projects work

022is that we work with the contractor to get financing for the project and pay back using the yearly cost savings and rebates and incentives provided by the state we do not expect to spend any capital from the operational budget towards these projects not unless we choose to buy a guarantee for the Energy savings like Mr P just explained and that is still a pending discussion for this board um to understand the timing of of the payments the projects are slated to start hopefully the summer if we follow the timeline we have started on the total timeline is 18 months and honey will will ensure that the cost saving LED lighting project is implemented quickly so we start seeing the monthly Energy savings immediately after the first payment of the financing would be due in the

023beginning of the school year 2026 27 so that buys us at time um and thus the payments will happen using the money saved by the district on the energy cost it is also important for taxpayers to understand that the scope of this project covers the replacement of 11 boilers that are aged 25 years while the life expectancy is 24 years on them it covers one rooftop unit and split one Split unit um aged 26 years whose life expectancy is 15 years um two chillers and five air handling units age 26 years and their life expectancy is 20 years so we aren't just focusing on energy saving aspect uh with these measures but are being proactive to replace aging equipment that could become a maintenance issue in the coming years and would then cost us money

024from the operational budget so the Hope here is that we will reduce the stress on our overburdened operational budget by handling these infrastructure needs through esip I'm happy to report that that was one of the goals board goals which we which will get realized by this board approving this undertaking um by The District administration um to to do our due diligence with the risk analysis uh after this committee meeting we did reach out to Honeyville to see data on neighboring districts uh where they have completed these projects and we wanted to see the comparison of uh projected Energy savings numbers and the realized Energy savings and all the data met our expectations we saw no no cause for concern and like Mr P just said anybody that had bought the garantee um they never had

025to pay back because the Energy savings were more than what was projected in the initial proposals um a lot of thought and deliberation has gone into this by the board it started with the previous board has continued with this board uh and a lot of preliminary work has been put into this administ into this by the administration uh under the able leadership of Mr T uh just to ensure that what we do is absolutely necessary for the district with minimal Financial Risk so in full transparency to the public uh access has been given to the detailed presentation by Honeywell and we welcome public opinion on the hearing next month I'm excited truly excited to vote on this um and get this um going thank you yeah just and just like you said Miss Bo the

026hearing will be next month that we're voting on an introduction to the the ordinance ordinance correct that's what we're voting on tonight yeah any questions for the finance btts committee M Ratner yep um I was going to make that clarification that was one of them the other question though that I did have is I think you sort of just mentioned that it has been provided um to the public I went on to the website and I saw the solar PPA RFP but I I couldn't find the the honey well presentation is that we also have a new website so I don't know if it's just not easily accessible I just wanted to see if we can get it either on the homepage or somewhere that's visible yeah I know the email from Dr said that

027access has been given but I didn't if somebody knows where it is I might just not I believe that it wasn't on the website yet because the presentation was listed as confidential and we were waiting for Dr L it's on the district website under uh Board of Education Board of Education presentations Honeywell EIP project overview January 2024 see it yeah and for the board members whatever we asked for after the committee meeting in terms of proof of how well the project have done that was added to our executive attachments for uh for tonight thank you and then I also just wanted to follow up the mention of discussion about the the guarantee because I know at the committee meeting we said that we wanted to hold off to have a a discussion throughout the board

028just as to whether or not this is something we wanted to commit to I know like we've expressed sort of what our thoughts were at that night but I don't know if this would be an appropriate time or if you you're right and and just to give the amount $36,000 a year 36252 is what it would cost us and that would go out of our operational budget so what I just said that this is not going to be part of our operational budget but if we buy the guarantee we're looking at 36252 per year and what that guarantees is that if they told us we going to get $500,000 of energy Savings in year one from uh you know in and if we don't get it they will make sure it is 00,000 so that

029number goes from you will see in the presentation that number goes from 500,000 all the way up to 900,000 in Energy savings they don't guarantee the rebates and the incentives from the state and they don't guarantee the solar PPA which is it's directly with a Solar Company so for for that amount if we not comfortable we feel there's a risk we can pay the after the committee showed us that a few towns that had bought the guarantee some kept it for a year and then cancelled it some kept it for two years and canceled it the numbers were looking good um typically I am one of those people who would say let's just buy the guarantee you know we don't we're balancing dimes and nickels and so it's a question and that's why it's up

030for discussion right now so if anybody has any thoughts on this I think this is like Kate said this is a good time to talk about it and and the guarantee would only be like U Miss bour said if it was guaranteed 500 it would have to come in more than 37,000 the first 37,000 we would get our money back and if it was so either way we're in the plus I believe but to buy the guarantee when we're seeing other districts have bought it and they meet their expectations and basically lose that guaranteed money most districts like she said it canceled it they did it two years in a row both years they honey well met the expectations and so basically you know I don't want to say thrown away but you're basically losing

031if it's 36 $72,000 and if they meet the expectation they don't give you your money back it's only the guarantee they make it so I I I mean it's yeah Dr and I think Dr chy stated at the meeting that you know Administration feels like yes we can get the guarantee that's fine or no we don't need the guarantee and that's fine also so um it really is a discussion of the board of how the board feels about it I mean my you know which I mentioned in the committee meeting if you haven't had a chance to look at it though is that anything that we might save with the guarantee it really isn't that much and there's a much greater chance of us spending more on the guarantee than we would get back year

032after year so if like you would to ask me what my opinion is I would say we wouldn't move forward with the guarantee that I don't I don't believe we need that but I'm just one member of a 10- member board so are there any other thoughts on the guarantee I guess everybody feels kind of the same way so you know of the districts that they shared examples for a few of them had taken the guarantee and I like I said ended up canceling it there were quite a few districts also that did not take the guarantee and they weren't able to show me the numbers for those District but they did say that one of those districts actually did a project phe two because it was working out so well for them and none

033other other districts didn't have a challenge with what was proposed so I feel comfortable not taking the guarantee right now which is very unlike me but given our current situation and U the work Honeywell has done um I think I feel comfortable going without I agree and the facts are that like they have 100% nobody ever using in 30 years in 30 years in 30 years kind of leads me to the same conclusion at why spend $336,000 we're already at a cost saving and say we made $490 we would have still lost 20 6,000 to gain 10,000 back so we would have to be under 37,000 of the projected to even use it which if they've never used it in 30 years I I don't I agree I think that that's something that we absolutely

034don't need but like we're just one vote exactly and it's not on the agenda for approval tonight it's tonight just so that it's just a start the discussion so we can always next month we'll it will probably be on the agenda um and then we can also if continue this discussion further we can talk about it more in committee um but I would agree that we would need before the next meeting so yeah if things change M Ju Just to clarify because you both mentioned this is not to approve the to approve the application is there I believe there is no cost it's just a matter of moving forward with the next steps but I I did want to confirm that they're we're not spending anything in order to move forward with this with this

035vote it's just to say yes go ahead and continue to pursue we're going into contract with honey yes we're going into contract with honey well is and please correct me Laura if I'm wrong I think one of the resolutions is saying that we're going to going into contract with uh honey will and the other is about the B which is the born ordinance is the one where we are just introducing it and we'll vote on it February but the contract with hanu Will commence after today right am I right yes she said yes yes can you clarify I guess oh there's confusion clarify should what clarify what it there were just a couple of community members who I gu would want to hear it like repeated maybe explained either in more I guess what are

036the three resolutions that we are voting on which what is each so one is being introduced and the other two are being approved tonight yeah don't they come up in the yeah I was going to talk about it in my in her report correct when you does the business administators report so do do you want to talk about it now or we it's up to you I would just say maybe it might be better to if if Miss Allen is okay with it to do it that way if people have questions they can ask prior to when we vote so we have two resolutions and a bond we have two resolutions and a bond refunding ordinance that is only being introduced as we've said or or adopted on first reading tonight and we will'll be

037back at the February meeting for public hearing and final adoption the ordinance is of no force and effect until after the local Finance board has approved it um there's been a public hearing and an adoption so the first resolution is the authorization to make application to the local Finance board for the financing of the Energy savings plan um so the meeting of the local Finance board is on February 12th and we would have to get their approval to do the refunding bond if they don't approve it we can't do it um so the application is due to the local Finance board on January 22nd that's why we had to you know try to get this approved tonight or otherwise it just delays the whole process by months [Music] um so that's that's the first one

038so we would go down to Trenton or we would actually do a zoom um with the local Finance board for this process to get approved um the Energy savings refunding bond ordinance which is only being introduced tonight all authorizes an amount of not to exceed $13.5 million for the issuance of Energy savings obligation refunding bonds to finan the energy conservation improvements at school district facilities so the final amount can be less than the 13.5 million that's the maximum amount that we are asking for approval um the second resolution is to approve the Energy savings plan and a contract with Honeywell to provide and install the energy conservation measures that they have laid out in their plan um so those are the those are the two resolutions and the one um Bond ordinance that's being adopted

039tonight thank you okay are there any is there any more discussion on the btts committee nope okay so then we're going to go on to the next committee policy Miss Alvarez the policy committee met on Tuesday January 7th 20 25 present at the meeting were Dr Layman Mrs Fabiano Dr peek and Mrs Ratner Strauss estimate issued policy alert 234 in December and the committee began reviewing nine of the policies and regulations recommended for updating the remaining policies will be reviewed at the February meeting these updates are a result of the uniform State memorandum of agreement between education and law enforcement officials which was revised in 2023 all districts must annually review REI revise when appropriate and adopt the mo MOA pursuant to njac 6A colon 16-6 13-4 the mo MOA provides a much greater level

040of detail regarding this statute and all the requirements outlined therein a discussion on the organizational chart was tabled for the February policy meeting due to Dr Chan's absence this concludes my my report there was no Personnel meeting this month any questions or comments for Miss Alvarez for policy okay um Mr Pay citizens advisory citizens advisory committee met on Tuesday January 7th those in attendance were myself Dr Layman Mr moraldo Mrs Fabiano Mrs Alvarez Miss Ratner and committee members and it was very nice we had um one high school school student a gentleman come last month and we had two more come this month and our board rep U I don't know where she fits it in her time her busy time was there that evening uh the first 20 minutes uh as everybody knows the

041last um the State Department of Education is holding hearings regarding the um Fair funding task uh they're going to put a fair funding task force together and they wanted comments from anybody that really wanted to come and speak so there was one last week which I couldn't go to I went to the one this pasted yesterday in Trenton uh Miss Bor was there and uh we spoke on behalf of Monroe about how we are not getting the right amount of money that we should be getting to give their most thorough and efficient education to our students but the night of the CAC meeting we broke up into two groups of eight with um Mr moral being a moderator for one group Dr Layman being a moderator for the other group and help them discuss and

042talk about the issues and their concerns regarding our um finances and what to say if you wanted to go to speak or on the uh Mr moraldo sent them all uh something on the website with with the letter that we're actually still revising uh we asked for their comments about the letter to send to the um legislators but also give them information on what to say when they went to speak so um we had a lot of dialogue a lot of discussion we closed the meeting after the first 20 minutes because when you break off into groups it's very hard to actually capture what everybody's saying um a few of them a lot of the people work so they were going to send in um a statement into this into Trenton and um I think

043we'll see what happens after they have one more session if they're going to it's terrible to say I'm very skeptical but I hope they listen to everybody um it was 10 to 12 I didn't get home till 3:00 that day and they waited and listened to everyone so I hope they take what they said into consideration um we listen to um groups um a lot of Bas and I kind of felt bad for all the business administ rators around this around New Jersey all complaining about I was sitting next to I think it was eom and they couldn't they couldn't Finance I think the next uh box of paper clips so uh it was really heartening disheartening to hear how other districts are functioning or not functioning because of this formula so uh we just

044have to keep our fingers crossed and CAC has been wonderful the people are very energetic about everything that we bring to them and want to be a part of everything about this District in order to bring more funding and get more um programs and things so uh it's a great group so um I think that's that's it that's the end of my report does anybody have any questions or comments for Mr pay Miss Ratner I if no one else has I had a um report because we did not have our lace committee and it sort of goes into what Miss deine just spoke about regarding the hearing so um so I don't think there's any questions or comments for Mr Pay but to be clear there was no citizens advisory committee meeting lace Comm sorry

045lace meeting there was no lace meeting held this month we did not go to the middle school but in lie of the committee meeting the committee members went to testify at the school funding hearings in Trenton curriculum also show well three of the four members of the committee went together and then miss testified another night but you took her place that night no would we cancel curriculum for the so miss Ratner if you would like to which I I really do appreciate I I didn't like to cancel the committee meeting just because we hadn't had one in December as well but we all felt and we sort of spoke about this at the meeting in December that this was such a crucial time for us to get out there and to tell these people who

046haven't necessarily asked for our opinion you know the Department of Education which is different than the legislation right legislators sort of draft the bills but the Department of Education is the one eventually tasked Le say I've understood it with the creation of the funding formula so we're sort of speaking straight to the man I guess would be the best way to do it um so yes so last week on Wednesday Miss Alvarez Miss Bora Miss Fabiano and myself we attended the hearing um that was being held by the Department of Education uh there were two members of the Department of Education there that night I don't actually know who the second person was one one of them was David Coro who is in charge of Finance for the Department of Education um there was also

047another hearing that was held yesterday um with you know Miss deine just uh mentioned that Miss Bor attended as long as well as previous uh Board of Education member Miss gerby and councilman Ziro um I did want to share just a few highlights um I won't read all the speeches cuz get those eyes from my fellow board members um however if you do want to hear all of the testimonies Miss Bora was kind enough to record them um and they're available on social media on a number of pages if anybody here uh wanted to see them I'm sure she would you know be willing to share them or you can reach out um and so just a couple of the highlights of what we brought up um one thing was the specific flaw in the

048formula which you know we've discussed here that NE negatively impacts communities like ourselves that have that high senior citizen population um due to just due to the way that the retirement income is accounted for um because essentially from what I've understood and the equation is like high level calculus like I you know I don't I I can't really understand it but essentially because the income is calculated as part of the townships income we do not receive the equalization Aid um that's that which is what is used to offset whatever you are not getting from your local fair share however some of that income is not actually received by the township and so essentially they're calculating income that we're not getting but we're not getting what is used to account for that income as well um

049so that was a big thing and I will say I think that was one of the things that was really unique to what we brought up um I know we when we were there last week we spoke to um there Department the the people that were there um about how it really has hurt Monroe not just since us too you know and you know I even there was also a rep from New Jersey school boards there who said like what was really great about you guys was everyone is coming and saying you know this fing formula is hurting our kids you need to do better and and and that's true and I think we all agreed on that but we sort of have been doing this so long that we understand why and some of

050the changes that need to be made and so that's um one of the things that we were bringing up um another was the fact that we received zero Equalization Aid um we have not received that I don't know if we actually ever did because it was I think that was part of the initial formula in 2008 and I don't think Equalization I think that was part of that legislation so ever I've always said last 15 years but ever sounds more powerful um and so despite the fact that there are townships Miss Bora had actually used the specific some of our surround in towns that have a higher income you know but receive millions of dollars in Equalization Aid that we don't um a lot of people brought up the trans transparency aspect of budgeting which

051you know I know we've discussed here and um you always feel bad for our administration because essentially they have to create a budget within two weeks after getting the numbers you know this is definitely something that a lot of people brought up at that hearing you know give us more time let us look on line to find out what we're getting and why don't make it so complicated that nobody understands it um you know one of the I forget if it was a ba or a superintendent had mentioned like we lose so many hours because we have to create five different scenarios you know that could be used for better things so um that's also in one of the legislative bills that had been brought up but is hasn't moved since it was brought up

052last month um to require additional time for districts um you know and then I'd say the the last um oh there was the exceptions to the 2% cap because that really limits us and I know Dr Leman had actually um brought this up when we were at the citizens advisory committee and I think we've actually discussed this a couple of times before that while there are certain like a very few exemptions to the 2% cap such as Healthcare whereas if those costs are you know higher you can increase your total amount over that there are other categories that are just growing at so much of a higher rate than that 2% cap right so a couple of the things that were brought up were Transportation you know and out of District special education because um

053right um Staffing salary needs as well um but essentially we want to make sure that all students are getting what they rightfully should have right but we need the tools in order to be able to do that um and then just like the last thing that we all sort of touched on was that full day kindergarten component and I think that where the dispar like where they don't understand necessarily and I shouldn't say they because maybe a few of the people at the state do but it's not just the funding for us it that is a part of it right like we we need to be able to provide Staffing and you know curriculum and things like that but it's the fact that the affordable housing mandates and things like that created such a population

054boom in Monroe that we had to build two new schools in 20 years and they were essentially overcrowded when they opened we just we literally don't have this space so even if we were to find room in our very limited budget to accommodate Staffing and curricular needs we need that part of it first um and so and it obviously really hurts us because we can't get preschool Aid because we don't have full day kindergarten it's just a never ending cycle so you know there have been some um talked I won't go into too much detail about what was put on the on um from the the governor's us yesterday and things like that but essentially there's a lot of focus on this issue right now more so I feel like than ever before because of

055the number of people that are hurting um and because S2 just just finished um and you know we've reached out um multiple times and Miss Fabiano um can you know talk about that um we're doing as much as we can and I think as a community the more we can do the better um they are accepting the email testimonies until January 17th at the Department of Education um so I know we had something sent something out districtwide to all of our people that are on our mailing list um with the hearing dates and that they could submit written testimony um but I also think it would be great if we could possibly maybe provide a sample written testimony um which Miss Bor I think actually shared something like that on social media today as well

056um for people to submit before the 17th because we want to get as many numbers in there as we can and that was also discussed at the citizens advisory committee um at least the group that I that Miss Alvarez and I were with there was a sample testimony that was like shared I think Mr morala was sharing it with the group um you know and they get that we have a a folder right with key points and things like that um to your point we did make sure to grab the doe official who was standing off on the side of the room um and just put in a quick plug for yes David um to for Monroe uh and he was like oh yeah Monroe he's like yeah you know you're you're a unique situation

057and Miss Bora was having a different conversation and she's like but that doesn't mean we're not entitled to our fair share um so we we are trying our best um I did reach out to Senator Greenstein um assembly M D'Angelo assembly McCoy again I sent a follow-up email um again reattaching the letter that Ratner sent in October I believe it was so that's where we're at it's definitely not for lack of effort but we are really trying to hopefully get some change Happening Here Miss Bora yeah I was going to uh talk about this in my other board business but I think this is a more appropriate time I you know I as a rule I try my best not to impart any board related information on social media but I've broken that rule consciously

058twice in my board career which is my 4 year one was when we were going out to the budget question I held open you know information sessions and I really engaged actively on social media to give people the right information and I did that again today um actually in the last week sharing everybody's testimonies to create Awareness on Facebook and then today during my lunch hour I reached out on what is a more effective social media channel these days WhatsApp um I must have reached out to 10 groups and I know those 10 groups forwarded it to many more groups I shared a modified version of My Testimony as a template um I gave them a four-step process I told them it's going to take them one minute to give the testimony and my phone's

059been going off the hook all day um before we started this meeting I already knew of 60 testimonies that had been sent today as a result of that and I know we have two more days so across the community I think um just making it easy giving them the step ah has helped um if we could put more templates out there it'll add more value to the testimony that's going in because right now 60 same exactly duplicate testimonies have gone in but it's better than nothing and I want to uh just share this opinion on on my take on what's going on at this moment and how it's different from whatever we've done as a town and we've done a lot um I know Miss scurby was there yesterday and I want to you know

060give a shout out to to to councilman Mr toira who's here who showed up at the testimony yesterday as well um Miss Kirby was wearing her Fair funding shirt from 2010 and that's a 15-year-old shirt and that made a statement as to how long we've been doing this um we've always gone and Tred to get the attention of legislator who really weren't concerned because we were the minority District facing the challenges we were facing after S2 issue happened six years ago multiple districts have been facing a lot of challenges because they lost the money they were using to operate and then Co hit and you know inflation hit skyrocketed the 2% Levy is becoming hard for everybody so with the with the loss and funding and the tax 2% tax levy it's a perfect storm

061for hundreds of districts so in the two hearings that I went to I honestly felt very proud as a Monroe resident knowing that we didn't have the millions these districts have had for over a decade and we have not yet come to a point where our programs are being cut we have yes we've burdened our taxpayers and yes you know we have balanced pennies and nickels and but we've been doing it despite not getting our fair share we didn't lose anything we never got anything um what's different this time is that they're looking at it with so many school districts screaming at them that they need help so it's important for us to be front and even though we have we're not an S2 District if we don't become a big part of this noise

062we will get ignored again they will only look at districts that are losing funding and we cannot let that happen now is our chance when they're looking at the formula again and so I plead and I urge everybody that's listening in that's here today please spread the word in your network it takes one minute to give your written testimony there is another opportunity tomorrow night in Camden from 6:00 p.m. to 8:00 p.m. I do have a couple people who promised me they'll show up tomorrow they did sign up today to show up tomorrow from Monroe the more people that can show up in person and the more people that can give a written testimony Monro will hopefully not get ignored in this round so um and hopefully we will get enough Aid so that we

063can put kindergarten front and center full day kindergarten front and center and if you register and don't get a confirmation email still go the confirmation email does not mean that they will not be hearing your testimony yes um I think we only wound up getting a confirmation email the day before but I know miss toay you did not get one and you still testified spoke yesterday I got it yesterday morning yeah so even if you register and you don't get an email the gentlemen are is so nice that even if you've not registered you're sitting in the room and you signed in so the testimony was supposed to be 2 hours um all the night all the four nights all the four sessions yesterday we started at 10:00 a.m. and myself Miss de and Mr

064deiro literally left the room at 2:30 uh the gentleman who was hearing the testimony allowed everybody to speak and did not leave till the last person had spoken so they are really doing the part and this time we not speaking to legislators we legislators we are speaking to people who are working on the formula so hopefully you know we will um see the benefit of this Mr P yeah I just want to piggy back on all that too um I noticed yesterday most of the districts were speaking about transportation and special ed issues I don't know if you noticed that too it was a very very hot topic for a lot of the districts and like you said we've been very fortunate but that we haven't lost any money but we've been unfortunate that they

065haven't given us enough money to go forward so you you try your best to give the best education to our students but like it's like taking a step forward no money taking two steps back and I spoke yesterday on behalf of being a senior citizen in Monroe because I know that the old task for the funding formula had something in there that was detrimental to districts that had a large senior citizen population so I asked them to reconsider that part of the um formula when they redid it as not to penalize the seniors because I mentioned that we had a um uh referendum and the last referendum I think I was running and it didn't pass and a lot of people blame the seniors apparently it was not the seniors passed it so I I

066think and I said to them I paid all my life for people and people paid for my children to go to school so even as a senior if I'm on limited income I'm still want to pay for the students of this District to get the best education possible so that's where I came from yesterday as a senior being on this board and I said I was one of two I didn't mention Mr zener's name but I did mention to and I want to tell you too I also reiterated that we were Monroe Township middle sex County yes I said that also and I must have said it 10 times and everybody's looking at me because there's another Monroe in in New Jersey and I want them not to get mixed up with that Monroe cuz

067I don't know how their finances are so I kept saying and from Monroe Township and middle sex County so I was I said it a few times I also volunteered to be on the task force I told the mom is retired and the gentleman said oh good I have your email I'll give you a tax I okay sure like he's going to do that but if they I said do you need board members on your task force board members that have been hit and the ones that are in the trenches to give you some advice as to where we should go I said get board members across the state to volunteer and come and help so I don't know if they listen listen to that I really truthfully hope they listened at all uh I

068was I wrote myself notes the night before I are they listening so I I hope they are and I hope something good comes out of it for monrell and for all the districts that spoke yesterday I actually felt really bad for the one sitting next to me I was like I said I don't think they had pencils I mean they said they were going to go back from full day kindergarten to half day kindergarten that's how bad it was well actually that was something that Toms River when I was at the legislative committee session from New Jersey school boards they said that they have full day kindergarten they've been one of those districts that lost so much funding they were told well you can still budget get rid of your full Daye kindergarten and go

069to half like as much as it's bad to not have it ever like can imagine having them being told you have to get rid of it it was the district said next to me but um I did just want to like clarify unless maybe you've got information I don't because the legislators had been considering creation of a task force for school there was a bill in 2022 there was another one brought up in the beginning of 2024 those never came out to fruition so from my understanding the Department of Education is not looking for a task force although it it would be a great idea well hopefully hopefully if one of the legislators gets back to us and we open up a discussion then we can ask yes right I think so any is there

070any more discussion on this I have a I have a request for our student board members um could you also help in the next two days with this Outreach because when you send your testimony it students are allowed to set send a testimony and I was so proud yesterday there were two gen Z board members 24y old um children I would call them children cuz I'm old but um young men who were very impressive but I I it would be it would be phenomenal if we could um you know mobilize our student population to send that it takes a as long as you all have a template of the written material it can just be four sentences but um and please reach out to me if you need any help help us mobilize the student

071population thank you yeah and then just to to add to that can we also because we're doing a lot of it on our Facebook page and then miss you know Miss Bor mentioned WhatsApp is there a way for us to reach out to our Senior Communities because some of them are on Facebook some of them are on our mailing list but I know a lot of them have their own email list so I don't know I know mral that has a lot of those contacts but to say hey we could really use your immediate assistance with this to help our entire Community um to get that to them to get as many numbers as we can I just wanted to quickly add that um I was actually going to ask if we had a minute

072because I believe we talked about it at the citizens advisory committee that students can also send testimonies so that's something that I will on the behalf of students be encouraging um in the next two days at school I know it's until the 17 so that is a deadline that's coming up quick but it's obviously much easier than you know going out there but I think if they receive a great volume of testimonies not from the entire Monroe Community whether that be students adults senior citizens that' be so impactful especially when they see the students themselves reaching out it's their own unique individual story and like you said it it doesn't take more than a few minutes to do so um I think it's also just wanted to add really amazing that everyone who works here

073at Monroe hasn't made the students realize like I didn't realize until the citizens advisory committee how underfunded we were um because of all the programs and opportunities that we've been given but at the meeting I also you know my eyes were open to how I guess unjust our funding was compared to a lot of other school districts that you know I have friends from who got who get so much more funding for their programs for their activities for their curriculum so I hope to see in the future that we get more Equitable funding and it's much easier and we don't have to sacrifice anything for the sake of saving funding so I definitely encourage again anyone who's out here anyone who's watching and all students as well um which I'll continue to do in the

074next two days to write testimonies to talk to their parents about this see if they can come out or at least write testimonies as well so thank you for bringing this up thank thank you and what you just said about not even realizing as a student um that's kudos to the administration um because you shouldn't feel the impacts of that that's it's it is the job of the administration um and us as a board right to make sure that it impacts students as least as possible so kudos to the administration for that um okay so we're going to move on to the next item on our agenda which is our public forum I think Dr Layman was saying something I'm sorry were you I was just going to follow up and say you know Mr

075moral is in the back and we can certainly touch base about oh he's here further Outreach yep hi Mr moral okay so then now we're going to move on to the next item on our agenda which is our public forum for agenda items only members will have four minutes to speak anybody wishing to do so can come up to the microphone and state your name and municipality for the record um I don't think anybody's thank you good evening hello can you hear me my name is Luc Al Panos I live in uh Clearbrook 128 Candera Plaza um about the fair funding meeting I would hope that maybe this District go get a bus rent a bus for $400 for the day and get a bunch of people down there um I'm quite impressed that an

076elected official was there any other elected officials from the township there but I am am I also impressed that somebody wore a shirt 15 years old and it still fit that was nice um then my the main thing here is this honey well thing you said you didn't see it online correct the whole honey well thing is there anybody else here who looked and didn't see it cuz I didn't either did you look could you know did everybody read that thing online I know you're saying yes I'm saying if you didn't read it don't vote for any part of it give you know be don't be Penny wise and pound found po found foolish you're comparing it to other districts if the other districts get royes and do this are you comparing Apples to Apples

077or apples to oranges so we don't know that I don't know if any of you real know that yet but I think it's incumbent upon you to go read this was there a bid going out for this honey Wells get the contract was there more people is is there something funny no I'm I'm smiling is there was there a bid going out there I'm one of those seniors $13 million Bond $ 13.5 million bond is a lot right so before you do that and a vote to approve anything you're going to vote to approve something and the presentation is going to be made to the public at the next meeting isn't that putting the car beh before the horse or something I'm asking you table this hold off give everybody the chance to read it

078online make your presentation to the public and then vote if it holds off a few years few months well that's the way it is you better be safe than sorry compare your little townships and that they again the same thing make sure you read the whole thing and don't vote on it tonight table it St be honest to yourself if you didn't read that contract of State okay just just to be clear the presentation has been made was public the night of the committee meeting um and it's been on the it's under the it's in two spots on the district website it's under the committee we have board who didn't read it excuse me I have the floor thank you no problem so what's the presentation next month what presentation next month yeah that honey

079Well's coming to do Honey's not coming you say happening next month yes we're voting we'll be we'll be voting next month a public hearing there's a public hearing next month hearing so on public hearing before you vote that would be prudent for next yes that that will happen next month the public hearing will be next month before you vote on any of your issues tonight we got a 13 million doll Bond Miss rner yeah I just wanted to to clarify was I appreciate you because I don't like to vote on anything without doing my deal diligence and I I'm pretty sure the people that are here can tell you I I I definitely do my research um this was presented at our uh budget btts um committee meeting which I attended um which was also

080made available to the public however the presentation itself the PowerPoint um we had asked to also be put on our district website so that anyone in the public could see it um it was also shared with all of the board members um to review for the meeting tonight much was there any other companies that you got to look at and can I answer Miss Fabiano can I answer was there was there any other company do was this went out to bid you're just appointing honey well no there were two there were two companies that came to the buildings ground committee meeting in May I believe um this was the company that the board elected to go with and they gave their presentations and bids and how much it would cost well they gave us a

081presentation yes noost it started in they do an RFP 202 Time Out Mr would be able to answer we started this process almost a year ago excuse me your time is submit an RFP to three companies submit an RFP you're it wasn't that wasn't we that that need proposal yeah your time is up whoa please people if you didn't read it don't vote it my time is up but yours is not thank you sh armeno Monroe um I I have to say that that's not the way to do it um and I ALS also object that if if uh committee meetings are not open I mean they are open to the public but it in terms of transparency I think presentations like that that are going to be involved with millions of dollars should be

082either a separate or special uh Board of Education meeting that's open to the public like we understand and the public should be able to be there and then ask questions of those people so I I object to how you're handling this and I think it is unfortunate and when you guys were not on the board this was the kind of thing that you would have objected to as well so I'm disappointed that it's happened this way it's a very important thing and I think probably what you're doing is right for the community but this is not the way to do it transparency has to be upheld more than anything and in that vein I'd like to ask on page two of 23 the pending or anticipated litigation and matters covered by attorney client privilege were

083there any dockets or legis uh anything that you would give us a docket number for no litigation you did not discuss litigation we talked about anticipated litigation for which litigation has not yet been filed so there's no docket numbers or anything like that okay how's the armeno versus the Board of Education coming that's still an open coming along nicely that's an open litigation still that was not discussed tonight okay good is there going to be another closed session meeting uh later on this evening no okay um on page 1723 the policy find what purpose is the insurance archaeological services or archaeology service yes um so uh there the board is involved in litigation for which um a an applicable insurance policy has not been found due to the fact that the incident arose in the

0841970s um and so in order to try and protect the public funds the district um retain this this is an these are assault issues that have been publicized well it's public it was public I'm not going to is it the 1970s it's the 1970s okay I don't need any more thank you I know what it is um next um how about oh the transfer 16-23 the transfer number five where is the amount where is it from and where is it going to please so that would be um an attachment a financial I know could you tell us the number in public please use your mic and I'm losing time here do you have any other questions and she can answer after uh no okay well I do have a comment so all right so I'll

085make my comment and I would like the answer to that question um now the $13 million that is what we were putting out towards a bond oh and my question was if the the contract is signed and Honeywell uh with Honeywell are there any clauses is because that has to do the contract has to do with the bond ordinance right so if if the uh local Finance board does not approve the bonds are we still committed to the Honeywell contract are there any Escape Clauses is what I'm saying you're using my time in silence that's not acceptable is that something Mr W can answer or um since I'm since I'm not on the Bond Council that's been handling this so I really can't answer that okay so that goes to the point where um if

086you can't answer these kinds of questions then $13 million proposal is a big thing one the public isn't fully aware of it second wait a minute no may I finish my train of thought the public isn't fully aware of it and apparently all of the questions surrounding it and what our obligations will be um are not answered so I think things need to be postponed Miss Allen did you have the um answer to her transfer question I do um total transfers um for fund 20 can't hear you and it needs to be total transfers for fund 20 it's several different accounts the total amount is 13182 and for fund 10 which is several accounts is 95402 900 5 I'm sorry 9,000 let get 90542 okay could I can I just make M president miss Bora

087just to the honey will I just want to clarify the way honey Well's contract Works based on the understanding from the from all the presentations I've been in they get paid when they do the project so if there is no the B Bond ordinance fails there are no we won't do anything they don't get so we're not paying honey well anything they cont about the contract though within the contract is there a provision that if they don't begin or we es programs esip programs are so Honeywell is our umbrella for doing everything isip so we chose to go with Honeywell besides the other contractors that had come and given us a presentation whatever project we do they will choose the contractor to do that project which is Honeywell when they do the project they get

088the money so we are in contract with them if the B my understanding would be if the bond ordinance failed or does not pass here there will be no projects and there will be no the the contract I don't think we need an exit cluse the last question is have you all read the contract I have yes those of you who are voting for it so in that contract there's there a provision yeah I believe like Miss B said that the this has and I think the reason that we're moving forward to drive to get this for a hearing next month and and to get it done is a lot of this has to do with boilers and chillers and schools and if we don't get it started now and we delay it it delays

089the whole project for a year because a lot of these projects need to be done when school's out of that isn't the issue the issue is due diligence in terms of contractual issues and I believe finan from everything I understand and everything presented to me like Miss Bor was that the only way this happens is for the bonding to go through and unless we do the project we're not obligated to pay anything it's all contingent on honey well filling their obligations to the district is the is the public you keep saying public hearing public hearing for what is it the public hearing for the budget or I Bond ordinance for the for the refunding bond can you since it has to do with the honey well project can you bring honey well in to have

090them do a small synopsis of what it entails that would be we could do that and ask Mr take to come just so you know we we want to be transparent but we also want to like the the thing was that if we didn't move forward to get some of these things approved to do it we lose that there're two different issues no I I agree I agree and we never as a board myself would never want to spend money that we're not getting a result done yes Miss Alan for next month maybe we can have Honeywell and Bon Council here and Mr T Y right it's just just I'm sorry so just to just to clarify where this last line right here uh this is this is the resolution that's on the agenda it

091just says we are voting to approve a contract with Honeywell to to like a desire to approve a contract so we are not actually entering into the contract as we would like to move forward with a contract anybody else wishing to speak yes hi uh Christy scurby Monroe Township the resolution says resolution of the Board of Education of Monroe Township to approve a contract approving the Energy savings plan and a contract to provide and install energy conservation measures and there's a dollar amount that the that the contract is worth which is up around $12.5 million you're approving the contract tonight and I agree with Miss armenio um that this is this is putting the part before the course you should be having a presentation here for the public to see um in light of transparency

092that you all promise the community having a discussion with the community of this one of the things that Miss armeno if you haven't watched you would you should know Honeywell is like the um goet so they they are going to hire the other contractors one of the contractors that they had talked about was a solar contract that that Honeywell said was not going to be guaranteed money back to us I do want to talk about what you miss Ratner and you miss Bora had said and I know Miss Bor and I have had conversations about this the guarantee the guarantee is almost like an insurance policy things happen unforeseen things maybe in however many years that they say they haven't paid out the guarantee maybe that's true I don't know if you've seen proof or

093not but things do happen to pay $3,000 to know that you're going to get $500,000 at the end seems like a reasonable outlay of money you know you're taking a gamble you're going out $13.5 million don't say it's not taxpayer money or the taxpayers aren't going to be affected by it because anything that you save here is our money and if you take this Gamble and that's what it is it's taking a gamble it's especially on the solar piece because she made a point to keep saying the solar is not guaranteed the only thing that Honeywell was guaranteeing was the money coming in from the lighting uh correct me if I'm wrong she said that over and over again that's what the guarantee was for so to sit here and say you don't think that

094you want to take out an insurance policy when you're talking about 13 and A5 million we couldn't get the town to come out and drove us to vote for for $2 million to not cut busing that was a narrow vote how do you think the taxpayers are going to feel when you're going out for 13.5 million they don't even know they have questions a presentation hasn't been made that's a huge gamble to take with and it is it's our money so I would ask that you table this as well um a a and do it the right way introduce it have a hearing the contract I don't know if the contract has to be approved tonight but it seems like you're approving a contract but then you're going to approve the money to pay for

095the contract another time well if you don't approve that money you're still in a contract like Miss armino said unless there's a clause that get you out of it I don't know the public hasn't been made aware of the contract so I I I I really think you're you're rushing to meet a deadline in January of a of refund or February the refunding bond in Trenton that meeting you're rushing to get there and you're doing it at the expens of our Township and I don't think that's a good thing um one question on the on here that you're going to be voting for the field trip buses to have Coach buses you're going to be approving that is that approving field trips to all have Coach buses if the schools require them or are you

096going to cancel them like you did last year which agenda item is it that you're referring it's somewhere in here where it said to approve a comp it was a certain company for field trips for Coach buses report page 18 it's on page 18 nine or 10 member 10 it's 10 it's 10 member it's it's an approval of a company so that they can request quotes from them if if necessary when transportation is looking for um a bus um company they go out they have different companies we've approved that they can call for quotes So this is just an approval of a quote to obtain quotes from this company as necessary okay if you'll just let me just ask one question please I know you gave s some extra time last year the field trips

097across the district at the end at the elementary schools had their coach buses canceled parents paid for them already they the schools had to issue up around 500 checks each back to parent for $4 or $10 whatever the difference was because the business office didn't realize that they were going to go over the bid threshold we had conversations with board attorney and he said to avoid that going forward that you could go out to bid for a specifically for Coach buses if you don't get somebody to bid you can go out again for a second bid if nobody answers that bid the district can hire whichever coach bus company that they would want for those field trips I'm asking because I've been being told by my school that the the go around is to go

098through the ptas this year for them to hire coach buses for the field trips and it didn't sound right to me so I've emailed I have not gotten an answer back um so I'm asking are the elementary schools that want to have Coach buses going to be able to get coach buses the district does not pay one dime of it the parents fund that we pay 100% of our field including the buses so are the schools going to be allowed to have Coach buses this year so the issue we ran into last year is we hit the cap and the workaround that you know was communicated was to have the ptas become involved um I will cycle back to see where that is um clearly we're reaching out for more contractors so if we're approaching

099caps we have more contractors in options um but I will I will get back to you with an answer the wrap around for the PT was only for last year yep and I'll get back to you with the status of where we stand this year I'll talk with Miss Allen Dr Chanley and get back to you okay thank you you're welcome okay the next item on our agenda is our assistant superintendent report I'm sorry hold on sorry hold on is there any other members of the public wishing to speak okay seeing n we will close the public forum um the next item on our agenda is the assistant superintendence report so I'm going to merge again this month with the uh superintendent's report so very quickly um we have something and the student board members

100do an amazing job uh and I was expecting them to actually cover this so I'm kind of glad they didn't so it's not a second time you're hearing this but on Friday January 3rd the monot Township High School welcomed an internationally acclaimed percussionist Miss Julie Dila uh to work with our high school percussionist and percussion ensembles as well as our student our both students and staff uh she joined us from Middle Tennessee State University she treated students to a master class and offered critical feedback as our mths students prepare for upcoming concerts and honors and state level auditions uh it's a wonderful experience for all our high school percussion students and teachers and I just wanted to use this this is a good example of um our professional staff using their Network and leveraging opportunities

101uh this we didn't bring this person in from Middle Tennessee this this professional was in the area on other professional business and we were able to leverage uh their presence in the State uh and network and bring them in to provide this opportunity for our students so um those opportunities don't happen when we don't get out there and professionally Network so um this happens throughout the year in many many disciplines um it saves we wouldn't we wouldn't traditionally pay travel and bring this person in unless we had a grant or some special funding um but this is an opportunity like I said she was in the state on other professional business in the state um we were able to bring her in and engage with the students so uh kudos to the entire staff that

102made those connections and brought this professional in but also uh you know the students and the teachers uh had a tremendous opportunity to work with uh a leader in their field um so that concludes my assistant superintendent report and uh I'm going to move into the superintendent's report so for 10 member vote Personnel it's recommended that the board approve the attached Personnel items a through o motion motion by Miss moris second by main are there any questions or comments Miss for I have a comment um I did share my concerns um with the administration but I do want to speak to it publicly as well um we're voting to um um we're voting to approve the current District special ed uh supervisor for grade 6 through2 uh to become the assistant principal at mths and

103while I have no doubt and this recommendation has my support that he will do great I do have a concern about the open position for the special ex supervisor I spoke with uh Dr Layman about it and um I have been assured that uh like has happened in the district in the in the past um um the current you know the the I I believe I can take the name right Mr Weiss because he's on the agenda I'm talking about we need to be careful all right so um I've been assured that both the roles will be uh will have his attention um in the span that we fill the special ed supervisor role because for for our district with 20% special and student population it is critical that um this position is filled quickly

104and in in the time that it is not it has the attention of our Administration that we you know we don't um Miss A Beat and um that's my hope and I do support this recommendation but I did want to you know share my concern publicly any other questions or comments okay Miss alen can we have a roll call please yes Miss Alvarez yes Miss Bora yes Miss depay yes Dr peek yes Mr Pio yes Miss ranner um yes but I am going to recuse on letter A okay Miss Sharma yes Mr ziker yes Miss Fabiano yes motion passes so I'm going to do another 10 member because uh there's an additional letter P now in that section so and under 10 member vote there's a different Personnel it's just at the bottom of the

105last page so I would like to uh it's recommended that the board approve attached uh items o or P rather there a motion motion second motion by Miss Boris second by sorry motion by mray second by Miss Ratner any questions or comments about that one item yeah I I'm not understanding what the extra item is I don't see it either because my agenda says board actions items a through P well this is 10 member it's the substitutes right y it's under 10 members p but I think on his agenda mine said a through sorry yes so I'm just adding P now y mine mine said a through o I'm corre so that's why I didn't want to miss peek it's on the agenda okay I just make I understand thank you yep Miss Al have

106a roll call please yes um Miss Alvarez yes Miss Bora yes Miss depan yes M Mr pero yes Miss Ratner yes Miss Sharma yes Mr tufo oh sorry Mr ziker yes M Fabiano yes um Dr peek Dr peek yes okay motion passes okay so under the nine member it's recommended that the board approve the attached I Personnel items Q through AG motion second motion by Miss Ratner second by Miss depay are there any questions or comments I have a question Mr yes on um ad the amount of chaperon for the seventh grade dance is that normal to have 15 chaperons with dance that's you always have that yes it's that is a consistent number um and it's a function of they're very well attended okay and student safety is always our priority okay thank you

107any other questions or comments Mr rner yep I just had a quick question um regarding the I guess this is letter AC but with the title one programs are those those are Grant funded or is that a I was just curious like is there for us to know that it's coming from like it can only be used for that purpose is title title one is assigned to specific schools right um and then when we like it says in AC for title one winter so these are allocated the account number is a title account um and they're each school has an allotment each school has a plan in terms of their implementation of using uh the title funds so you'll see different programs from our different title schools okay sounds guys no we had asked for

108the I think it was field I remember what it was but we had asked about grant funding for other things which you were grateful enough to put on there for us so just for transparency these are Grant funded Pro yep title Miss alen can we have a any other questions comments Miss alen can we have a roll call please yes Miss Alvarez yes Miss Bora yes Miss depay yes Mr Pio yes Miss Ratner yes Miss Sharma yes Mr zner yes Miss Fabiano yes motion passes for board action 10 member vote it's recommended that the board approve the attached board action items a through I motion second motion by Miss Boris second by Miss Alvarez are there any questions or comments I have a question Mr on the um there's a professional development for a summit

109in Florida for um $3,037 in March for the superintendent use your mic please there's a a uh Summit it says in March for $3,000 $3,373 send a superintendent to Florida for 5 days for a conference um I would just question the same conferences in New York and it's a lot less I think that with our budget constrictions and trying to save money I think that's a lot of money to send somebody to Florida for a conference um and then I also had another question there is another conference in Atlantic City where we're sending the director of transportation and we're sending a mechanic I was just curious um if we're why would we I don't know what the conference is it doesn't say that one it says 50 STS STS 55th annual conference and I didn't

110know if that was common to um send a mechanic to the conference along with um just yep so those two personnels going down to Atlantic City are going to the transportation conference is that what it is a transportation yep yep and that's a Atlantic City is a very common place for State conferences to occur so that's very that's standard um and regarding the other question you had um that is you know another common place for conferences to happen it's a national conference um my my um thing is though if it's held right here in New York um would it make more sense for our superintendent to attend a conference in New York instead of going all the way to Florida for the same conference I mean it would be definitely a savings to the district

111um I just I just think that's that's a little expensive at a time when we're trying to save some money that's my comment okay any other questions or comments okay Miss alen can have a roll call please yes um Miss Alvarez uh no to a the last item on the professional development list yes to the rest okay um Miss Bora yes to all Miss depan um yes to all but no to the last item person on the professional development list okay um Dr P yes Miss Ratner sorry yes however I need to recuse on letter A for Dr Chanley and Mr snater okay uh Mr pero yes to all and no to the last one on the agenda also for personel I mean for uh personal development okay Miss Sharma yes to all and no

112for the staff professional development the last item okay um Mr ziker uh yes to all except for the last item on the agenda okay and Mr shy and Miss Fabiano yes to all no on the last item for professional development okay so motion passes accept for that um item on professional development so okay under board action nine member vote it's recommended that the board approve attached board action items J through o motion second motion by Miss Boris second by Miss depay are there any questions or comments okay seeing none let's have a roll call please okay Miss Alvarez yes Miss Bora yes Miss yes Mr pero yes Miss Ratner um yes however recuse on letter J for Mr lurry and Miss Francis okay um okay um Miss Sharma yes Mr zner yes Miss Fabiano yes

113motion passes okay thank you the next item on our agenda is our business administrator report okay um so we've already discussed the uh resolutions and the ordinance um that are on the uh agenda so that's it um it is recommended that board action items a through L be approved by consent roll call under a 10 member vote motion second motion by Miss Bora second by Miss Ratner are there any questions or comments um Miss Ratner I wanted to thank um the pond Community for Their donation to The High School Coral program as well as resident uh Joseph Winters for his donation to The Graphic Design program at the high school can I add Miss Bora to that I thank also Bo wine burgers for Their donation uh which has been I presented in a very

114creative way I just saw the advertisement on the mths sports business social media that for our basketball games in halftime they'll have a three-point shooting competition and winners will get a $25 gift card from Bo Burger so I think that's a very creative uh way to increase Community engagement in our Sports and um not funded out of our budget so thank you anybody else okay Miss Allen can we have a roll call please yes Miss Alvarez yes Miss Bora yes Miss depay yes Dr pek yes Mr pero yes Miss Ratner um yes I would like to recuse on the bill list uh c0 for 820 and c0 48 0481 for methal worble um c048 one9 for Mr Ruben and then on the addendum for c0 4698 for Mr Lorry okay um Miss Sharma yes Mr

115ziker yes Miss Fabiano yes to all reuses on items on the bill list per meth vessell okay a motion passes um it is recommended the board action items M through n be approved by consent roll call under a nine member vote motion second motion by Miss Alvarez second by Miss depay are there any questions or comments Miss rner I just had a quick question the rebate from BNL um is that something that the district had paid for because that's who takes our our the photographs for the students um is that a rebate that parents had paid more is it that we paid for them to do Staff pictures and they're giving us a rebate for that I just want of the clarification um no I think that is for um a rebate from the school

116yeah from the school for the student pictures um I believe I can I can double check on that let you know okay thank you m anybody else okay Miss alen can we a roll call please uh Miss Alvarez yes Miss Bora yes M depay yes Mr Piro yes Miss Ratner yes R is on letter M Miss Sharma yes Mr ziker yes Miss Fabiano yes motion [Music] passes and that concludes my report okay the next item on the agenda is our board president's report um my report basically happened during the lace committee because I was talking about the testimony um I do want to wish everybody happy New Year um this is our first general meeting for 2025 um I do appreciate all of the board members that have attended the testimonies uh these past couple

117of weeks and to the community members who have either gone in person or submitted written testimony we appreciate all of your efforts um and we are hopeful that we will see some change so um that's really it I as I mentioned earlier I did uh reach out to Senator Greenstein um tinel McCoy and Wayne D'Angelo again to uh reshare the letter for that Miss Ratner and the committee had drafted during the uh lace committee back in October so um we just we'll wait to see if we get a response and I will be following up again soon um and that concludes my report because we already talked about everything so we'll go to the next part of the agenda which is other board business are there any board members wishing to speak Miss Bora I

118I just want to comment um on the whole es of discussion one more time um and address I think the person who talked about the due diligence is no longer here but I still want to give the timeline to the public and speak to the transparency of this process um I understand that I understand the concerns that miss armino and miss Kirby brought to the public forum but at the same time um this process was started if I am if my memory served me right it was towards the end of 2023 when we first met um hanell and other contractors that provide the esup services um and then you know the board change happened and we were going through the intense public question period so we kind of did not discuss this for a few

119months board change happened and we brought it back into bg& as soon as I could you know uh um get the attention everybody was still settling in but we've had multiple discussions in bg& these are public meetings um and um there there is there has been no work done that the public has not been made aware of um it in committee reports in the board meeting we' have talked in detail in the previous two months ago we talked in detail about what the solar PPA looks like and whether or not so we have had discussions on this we've done our due diligence I can speak for myself that um there are going to be tariffs coming with the new government the cost of goods are going to go up one of the questions I did

120ask at the committee meeting was that we're being pressed to get go you know take action in January because the cost right now of 12 $6 million is based on the cost of the equipment right now uh if we don't do this in January and we you know push this to February the cost is going to change um one of the things that we have to be mindful of is is you know how are we going to do this in a fiscally responsible way we didn't rush into it within a month's time we gave a whole year to this discussion um the public due process um given that our our meetings are public even the committee meetings uh nothing was hidden we are going to do we checked with the lawyers in again especially today

121because a concern was brought to me um if we are following the process by law um you know we're not violating opma and I was assured we are not violating opma We are following the process and um you know I I get it you don't see everything when you're not doing the work on it as a board member but I just wanted to assure you that we did do our due diligence at least the committee has done its complete due deligence other board members have seen the committee meetings have had discussions here and I am uh hopeful we've made the right decision for the district today thank you thank you Miss Bora and just to to follow up on that we have asked questions and questions of the questions and questions of the questions of

122the questions that were answered um we have asked for a lot of information and Honeywell has been very very forthcoming with us with the information that they have um so I do wholeheartedly agree that we really have done done our due diligence as a board to move this project forward Miss Ratner um just really quick I'll make it as short as I I can um so this the solar component um from what we were told and again this is on the committee meeting it does not cost us except you know for the the the small amount I forget the the number but to get the PPA because they will be handling the cost because it's a it's a lease and not a purchase um which you know there are pluses and minuses to both however

123the research was done to assure us that this is the route that we should be taking so any savings that we receive from that is not offsetting the cost of it it's it's savings um in its entirety for that um and so then just the other thing that I just wanted to um highlight quickly was um first of all I wanted to just say that I've gotten to attend a lot of um the concerts I went to the coral concert last week There's a middle School uh 7th eth grade concert band concert tomorrow I know um others have as well they're they're absolutely fantastic to watch it's um it's great to see our students performing um and then to tie into that what I had wanted to add was it's also really nice to see

124these things coming from our our new website on the calendar um because a lot of these events now are being autop populated onto our calendars which is something that I absolutely love um and so I guess my only questions regarding that were in order to like integrate certain schools events are those automatically being populated with the link on the homepage and then also um committee meetings are I guess because those aren't necessarily District events I don't think those are going on there yet but know like our board meetings have been um so I wasn't sure if that's I guess those are my two questions regarding that part of it yeah I think it's a work in progress each school has an individual calendar and the district has a separate calendar so if you are a

125woodland parent you subscribe to the Woodland calendar which is doesn't provide you the Brookside dates or the Applegarth dates um if we were to funnel everything to the district calendar then the district calendar would be overwhelmed with the school-based activities so I think right now there's a flexibility of syncing to the calendars that you are relevant to you um well whether it be the district calendar and then the schools that your children are attending to um and you have to go to each school's website from the homepage in order to subscribe to that school's calendar correct that's each School's calendar is hosted on the school website yep Mr P I would just like to make a comment in reference to bg& um my opinion is that I understand all the questions and I make sure

126and what I would like to do if we're allowed is at the next bg& meeting advertise it do our meeting uh we will ask in a meeting I'll way ask about the contracts and guarantees and everything so everybody knows who's watching and then if anybody has questions we're going to have a hearing before we approve everything then everybody would have an opportunity to he if we have to bring Miss Jackson back in the committee to go over everything and check our guarantees with Mr T and everybody so everybody understands exactly what's going on U the way I understand it is um just like Miss Bor is that if we don't do the work we don't pay for it if the bonds don't get approved my my concern with the whole issue is and and moving

127forward is a lot of work needs to be done in the summer time um all almost every one of our schools besides Applegarth uh the boilers are already outdated this program helps us replace boilers and chillers and things that are needed for the district at a cost where we're going to get the money back in Energy savings we don't do the project the boiler goes 2 million here four million there 5 millionaire and I would say that probably every school uh the boilers are pretty much past their life expectancy so it it was a big thing to overtake but I I just think that I'm going to propose that at our next meeting I'll talk to m t and Miss Allen maybe we could do another combined Finance bg& meeting we'll do the presentation again

128we could ask some questions now that we know that the public wants to know and then if people aren't satisfied when we have the hearing before the next meeting people we could make a better determination if that helps the public thank you anybody else any questions or comments yeah I'd like to say that um I agree with Peter I think that's probably a good way to go and it gets more uh Community involvement and the whole concept of transparency has been an issue and we want to make sure as a board that in fact we are transparent so we are hearing what you are saying and we thank you for that I do miss rner I think this is a great idea I just wanted to get clarification because this idea has come up before

129and I always think the more input we can get the better but I just want to make sure that per like the policies that we have it's okay for us to do that I don't believe in our policy if there it allows for a public involvement no public involvement I just said have another meeting advise the public were having it so they could watch it and anybody who ask questions tonight can spread the word we could post on the website pleas please watch the bg& meeting they're going to go over and we could ask the questions that need that the public is asking us okay my apologies I thought you meant asking the questions at the meeting no would it be better to instead do it at the next Board of Ed meeting in February

130to do the esa presentation it it also benefits the other board members who are not on those committees to see the presentation if we could have Honeywell come in I don't know Dr Layman um Mr take if that is possible to be here to answer questions um from but we would still have to vote on it that night correct like it has to be the night the night of the public hearing do the presentation and then do the public hearing um yeah the presentations are on the website I I mean could we absolutely can do go through the presentation again um at buildings and grounds um but I did ask um Miss Allen too if we can ask Honeywell and our bond Council to come to the next board meeting in February that way they

131can that they can help us facilitate that discussion better definitely anybody else idea okay okay um see so the next item on our agenda is our second public forum um any member of the public wishing to speak you'll have four minutes to do so please state your name in municipality for the record um Mr Weiss is just going to make a few remarks yes before we start with the public comment I just want to make a comment myself if I can um this is with regard to uh the bus accident um which resulted in some injuries to um our students um the board feels uh as does every staff member here that students are our first priority top priority and and and really most precious resource um the board was horrified to learn of the

132accident um the board uh with the Administration has undertaken a complete review of the situation um and will be updating protocols and standard operating procedures based upon that review um while the board members um all of us being parents up here um want to express their sincere uh sympathies and empathy uh with the the students and their parents uh all of whom were affected by the accident um in view of anticipated litigation uh it's been my recommendation to the board members to not have any Communications concerning the accident so with that being said while we would certainly like to say more um under the circumstances uh they the board members have been advised not to um so I just wanted to make that statement to the extent that um any parents uh students are listening

133to this board meeting this board meeting being the first uh following the the bus accident so again we express our sincere sympathies um and empathy uh with all who were involved and we look forward to updating our policies procedures um based upon uh the review of the incident so thank you thank you Mr Weiss any members of the public wishing to speak Michelle McDonald monor Township um I understand you said you cannot speak but can I speak absolutely okay um both of my children were involved in the bus accident and from what I have seen from then until now your organization is supposed to have my children's best interest at heart and all I've seen is that your reaction is just trying to protect your liability there was no communication to any of the parents

134who were involved in this accident about what our next steps were those of us that had to put our children back on that bus that next day we had no answers for our children's questions these are middle schoolers these are not elementary kids they know what's going on and they ask us questions like is it going to be the same bus drive driver is it going to be the same bus what are they going to do and we had to just keep telling them we don't know we don't know we don't know but we need you to get back on the bus because most of us come from two parent working households and it's just not feasible to drive the kids to school every day and we're not that bus route is not exactly close

135to the school either what we need to know and I understand you can't answer any of my questions today was the driver drug tested what happened because we still don't know what happened we want to know why did we get zero communication as a group I'm not talking about as a Township as a group why did we get no communication about should we need to take our children to the emergency room should we need to take our children to the doctor what insurance were we supposed to be using I only received that information because I made emails and phone calls on my own personal time to get that information and it felt like we were kind of left to flounder because it was winter break we also want to know um are the bus drivers

136for the outside companies held to the same standers as the Board of Education drivers do they have to S pass all the same tests that's all I have to say thank you thank you are there any other members of the public wishing to speak um I don't nobody else has gotten up sh AR Mino Monroe and I'm so sorry to hear about the accident I was unaware so to all the children and the parents and the families and to the community um you know my uh my sympathies and my concerns are are there um yeah I think parents should be informed immediately and and given as much as possible um help as they can uh to support them uh I also want to be clear I was not asking for a communication at a one

137of the uh committee meetings but let's be clear about what a committee is a committee meeting is for the board to go through things to present to the full board and to the public that is really not where the deliberations are meant to happen for the Public's sake I believe in the committee meetings I think they're great I had you know I spent nine years going to committee meetings and I think they're important and they should be attended and when you can and and when when I first started I when I was a civilian we got the administration to open the committee meetings to the public so I'm all about that and I am not and I and I play by the rules so I don't intend to ask any questions what I do think

138think is important though not everybody and you know people's schedules change and it's hard as you can see for sometimes parents to come to the committee meeting uh to the regular public meetings so the committee meetings are equally as difficult in some cases so the open public meetings act as you were well aware um requires deliberations to go on at the public meeting and that's where the information I think should be presented to the public so while I agree and I'm happy and I do attend committee meetings when available when I'm available so it's not that I don't um and I thank you for all that that but the own public meeting Zach requires this meeting to be where the public sees the board deliberate on issues that are as important as that so again

139I wanted to make myself clear I thank you for all the work you do I know what it's about and still and I appreciate I think what your idea is Mr pero is excellent and also and I'm not saying they should that what the next public meeting that you should have a full presentation a synopsis would be fine but it should be a joint so we know all of the parts of this issue and again if the um business administrator would talk about the financing a little bit more in depth and in detail at that meeting as well I think that so because it's it's not one issue it's sort of several parts and I think it would important for the public look we have issues with votes and the more the public is informed

140about what we're trying to do the easier it is I think to get acquiescence to the budgets and the future and we certainly need more space thank you Mr bner and I want to thank all of you who spoke about what you're doing at the state but yeah keep keep people informed I think that's the biggest issue and then hopefully we'll get even far more support so all thank you very much I think Miss alen to miss armen's Point perhaps in addition to bond counsel and Honeywell being here can we also have someone from Phoenix financial advisers Reach Out y thank you hi Chrissy scurby again Monro Township um I just wanted to uh comment on the bus accident I feel terrible for everybody that was involved in it my deepest sympathy to the children

141and the families I can't imagine how traumatic that is for them um I understand you won't be talking about it but I do want to urge the board to go back and reconsider your decision to move us to more contracted routes last year we had I think it was nine this year we have 36 routes you you increased the risk using these contracted buses and parents didn't know what that meant to not have Monroe Township bus pick up their child and it does it there is a big difference you're talking about not having communication with the bus driver you're talking about not knowing who the bus driver is there are a lot of time language barriers with bus drivers from outside District um bus companies we heard from Kathy McDonald who was the director and

142Dr Chanley they both said on camera back in May at a committee meeting that the contracted buses weren't as safe as the Road Township buses and this board pushed the administration because kids were getting to school a few minutes late to go with contracted routes instead of double runs you guys are to blame there are consequences for what you do and you you quadrupled the bus runs and you put more children on contracted buses than you shouldn't of we as a district and Miss armino could attest we worked hard to get rid of the contracted runs and yes children we're getting to school late safety comes first and I said it here so many times but you didn't put the safety of our kids first I'm hoping that you will go back and reconsider I

143want to point out now that bus route has a Monroe Township bus why Why didn't it get replaced with a contracted bus because you know it wasn't safe and it's not right can we make a comment it is disgusting that that was just politicized are there any other members of the public wishing to speak it is disgusting that you have just politicized a bus accident are there any other members of the public wishing to speak could I comment on the bus SE no a com good evening Betty Sab on Township um I'm also the leader for the special education parent advisory group I just wanted to um commend Mr araro who was just appointed today as um our assistant principal at the high school now Mr araro um we advocated at cpeg for a long

144time to get two positions to get the positions filled um properly and I will say Mr arar is the best thing that happened in that position at least a decade he's done tremendous work I thank Dr Chanley and Dr Layman for a big support with that and for working with special education we do have big shoes to fill in that position now um I'm confident in the position because you know speaking a little bit with Administration with Dr Layman I know he'll also be very involved in special education but I did want to say thank you to Mr arar for all the work that he's done I know he'll continue to do great things at the high school for our students and um thank you all for your support of special education which is the

145majority of our funding so thank you thank you are there any other members of the public wishing to speak okay seeing none then we will close the public Forum um the there is no second closed session so the next item uh is our next scheduled Board of Education meeting which is February 19th 20202 can I have a motion to adjourn motion second all those in favor have a good night everybody

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.