CorpusRecord 133016

Monroe Twp BOE Finance, Shared Services, Buildings, Grounds, Transportation & Security Comm 01.07.25

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Monroe Township School District
Date
2025-01-08
Location
Middlesex County, NJ
Material
Transcript
Extent
11,836 words · about 66 min
Collected
2026-06-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001the chair committee long have M kazal Bora who's the chair of the finance committee and tonight we'll be doing a joint building grounds transportation and finance to discuss Esau present for tonight's meeting is uh Dr Chanley Dr Layman Miss rner Miss Laura Allen Miss Katie Fabiana Manda peek Mr Gerald take from our facilities Department um we're going to start this meeting off speaking about the ESF program as the Energy savings Improvement program that the district's working on fulfilling uh hopefully tonight there a lot of questions that we may have that need to be answered and I guess we'll start with uh Mr P yes good evening everyone so tonight is a continuation of the process that we've been doing with the pgns committee this is a presentation that you have seen before but it's been

002refined as you worked through the process tonight we have here with us again Miss carollyn Jackson from Honeywell she'll be doing the presentation she has our supporting team Paul Peters Tim laick Emily Lee and Cath galz we also brought tonight with us uh panel in case there's any questions to specific areas we have Mr Anthony envero who hand financing from Phoenix advisers we have Miss jacqulyn shanus attorney with marter in English he's on on Council he's been dealing with us probably for about a quarter Century now feel old [Laughter] jury and remotely not yet tied in but should be shortly is Miss hope Blackburn for legal councel from brsh law she'll be done so this time we'll turn over to Captain and she'll be going through the presentation which each of the committee members hi

003everybody Caroline Jackson um thanks so much for having me again um I guess we're here in November speaking about this we've done a lot of work since then um I'll take you through the presentation some of the slides I'm going to go through very quickly because you've seen them before can you guys have it do you guys you here okay you don't have it here so do you not oh I have a copy you have a copy any need a copy I do some extra copies if anyone needs to have um sorry I usually have a separate one I want to make sure good yeah so we've um working through the process um just going to again you guys know when an energy savings Improvement program is a program paid for with um energy and

004operational savings grants and rebates over the term we are um you know looking at taking the savings and applying them over um the 20 years the um funding in additional to Energy savings is um estimated rebates which are C prescripted from um PG and Jersey Central we also have one and you'll see I think you probably notice those an alternate that um we're it's a new grant for decarbonization that would relate to that Capital car school project you're already doing we're trying to secure you some additional grants for that so but that's why there's an alternate because it's a brand new program started this year it's been approved but until we see it on paper we don't want to like you know we can't do that obviously but we want to make sure that you

005know that we're looking at for you we're already doing that work we could offset our cost by 1.2 million if that Grant comes through right well so what we would do is we could apply to this program like you already have your funding I believe set for that project so any we can mix and match projects so where you have projects that we can take Energy savings it can help build this project as well so um there's so that Grant is one of them if we're doing rebates and grants for everything else we can do that as well like I said it's a new program it is defined the amount of the grant per I'll help me BPS for THM saved uh thir save until until hour Sav right so that's determined but we don't

006see an application yet there's not a program director so we think in the next by January 30th that will be set and we'll be able to know if we can go with that alternate or not all right so in terms of our process here here we've um we are really still in the end of the phase one we're moving once this goes forward and you have funding we can then um move on the design and the procurement of the project but um just again for review where we've been and where we're going um your LGA reports have been complete you've um been we've been in communication with ESF director Michelle Rossy um they you've done the resolution to select us again this is and then we've gone through and done the energy savings plan that's

007being that's under review now with the BPU it's already been approved by the third party and um we've selected the measur so here's the um presentation of all the different measures I don't know how much you want to go through the measures um I have the slides that we did last time where it kind of shows the different measures I speak through each one but just again I'll just like tell you what this is so these are all the measures we looked at um all the schools and the green looks very neon in this slide but the green is where um we chose those measures and then um the Orange is things you're doing already that maybe we took savings or we're getting a rebate for and the blue has to do with what we

008put as the alternate if we can get that decarbonization Grant all right now part of um what we're doing right now is building a there's a very specific schedule you have to do for your for your funding Bond your you a funding bond for this in terms of putting in your application and um being at a local um New Jersey Finance board meeting so part of this project that we're putting out to you is the largest project we want to show you not to exceed so you can get approval but then we're going to be pulling it back as as you know like again these are the the higher numbers and we're going to pull it back you know we have some operational savings to confirm and some different things to confirm but Anthony and

009um Jackie can speak to that so um I don't think this is a place to go over the project I have other slides a little ahead so I'm going to go over a little bit of the financials and then we'll come back to what's in the project so um one of the things that was asked the last time was how do we select and how do we prioritize the things are in the project so we did go back and compare this slide I have right here is all the different large mechanical systems we're placing in the district and as you can see the age of the equipment is past what the ashery useful lightess so that was really the main priority there probably more things we could select if there were more savings but we

010um did the best we could so I don't know Jerry there say for that um these are our most pressing meets and children at the school large capital projects and this is our opportunity to completed if you go through some of the documents in terms of Energy savings we replace boil of barkle Brook you're not looking at a great energy savings there but you're looking at a critical infrastructure need to keep that school op your Energy savings will come from some of the other things primarily the can I uh just on that SL you expand rtu and ahu please oh I'm so sorry I should have to put so rooftop unit we have so many small spreadsheets working on and air handling unit so a lot of times the rooftop units the air handling units

011the split systems kind of get they look the same to people if you go to a roof you could an air handling unit it could be a rooftop unit they're a little different in the engineering definition but I think the key and the most important thing on this slide is that most of them were installed in 1999 or 2000 they're 25 or 26 years old and they are a passer useful light so like a um Split unit or rooftop unit has a little less of a light because there's a lot more moving parts then maybe an air handing unit that is a little less but they're all older than what um you know they're meant to last so I mean I know in this District you'd have a great history of keeping your systems updated

012maintained and having a replacement plan and so that's what this is is basically a plan to use the Energy savings from things like solar from lighting from building envelope all these do give you efficiencies and save you but it's really being paid for by the mix of the solutions that we've selected makes sense and then um in the controls we've kind of gone back and forth we're going to work on some controls at the middle school a little bit the high school and the admin the transportation building Jerry's going to be doing some projects you funded separately but those controls are very old as well and um so some of the controls are obsolete so if you lose like the controls in the unit ventilator or air handling their schools that's a big emergency expense

013to replace all those controlers you can't get the components unless you forge for them all right so in terms of the project scenarios we have our base project which is um 11.9 million and our alternate project if we can get you that decarbonization Grant looking at about 12.6 million um and when you go through and look at how the financing is built up you'll see that in addition to that we have um money that you'll Finance for the audit that you completed as well as the cost to go through the financing right so this is a part that's portion to the honey project but there are other numbers and if you have a confustion it's just because of what's added it and we can explain that so um the rate we've been running with and

014I'm not sure what rate you used Anthony but you can speak to it but we used her 4% in all our like cash flows that we did internally to make sure it paid for itself but then we turn it over to Phoenix advisors and they do it differently based on exactly how the project will fall into place so um you know there's a very significant amount of energy Savings in both projects and um utility incentives obious obviously are a little bit less for the one where we can't get that decarbonization Grant but we've kind of gone through and laid that out there I'm sorry I'm going to go back to my question about the decarbonization grant I'm really confused so we're saying that the cost of the project would we would do more things if

015we get that Grant correct correct we could choose not to do more things and push that grant money towards because we're already doing the project that's going to get us a grant money we have a rod grant that is funding the work at Apple school right that is not you grant no but this decarbonization grant of $1.2 million is something new correct that we're going to apply for because we're doing the work but we not we already doing we already it's the work that we are contracted under the rod Grant is currently under construction or to be under construction at Apple school so the timing just came about it's an opportunity for us to take that money and apply it to other right so my question is if we get the money and don't put

016towards other project it would reduce our overall base project no because you you get he'll explain you getting two grants and they have to be U they both have to be utilized use the for that not for any other correct has to be correct pushed into the same project well just I I want to clarify what you just said it can be used for other parts uh that are similar to this doesn't have to be specifically used for Apple because that's already being covered by that BR but it would be used for for other facility needs that are within the scope of this cor okay so those projects those alternate projects would need to be done that one am I the board issued a contract in November eacm for $5.7 million which is being funded

017through the ride branch and that work is happened because of the nature of decarbonization component of this there's the opportunity to realize some money for the district which we can apply to so the two columns the base project cost the value is 11.9 but with the decarbonization grant is 12.6 million we're doing more work different work yes if we get the grant right and those Brands just so you know it's more than just filling out an application they're usually and we don't know all the specifics that's part of the problem it's brand new but there's usually some engineering and followup you know like kind of like paper performance or the engineer Solutions um we don't know the specifics of what's needed probably do need engineering support to apply for the grant and then show what

018happens after the grant but we don't know so that's again um we could have just come and just said oh let's do the first project and that would have been a lot easier to explain but we don't want to leave anything on the table for you like there are other incentive programs that we are still researching for you behind the scenes and as soon as we know them will bring them forward and integrate them in the project as it goes um just in regards to the the savings total um and sort of was on the next page that you went to as well where there's a guarantee energy guarantee required to provide is that also um in line with like the cost savings guarantee I I think one of the the big concerns that came

019up was that we are sort of laying out this money you know through a a bond and there are certain projects like Mr T said that we really need to do anyway and so this would at least help us cover the costs of some of these I guess my big concern is if we are you know not expecting if we're expecting to get a certain amount back when that doesn't come through we are a district that you know is we have a very tight budget and so I just wanted to sort of understand if we do these projects that cost that much and then we only you know this cost of energy goes up and skyrockets from what it was or right is there any type of guarantee those are very very good questions and

020so important there's a couple components to that so in terms of our project we we'll be guaranteeing if you choose a guarantee like again we offer that no matter what so you can choose based on you know your discussions between you and you guys are all talking about it the other day too so it's really important that you understand that this is a guarantee for the amount of energy saved so it's at the the cost that's current today so it's still very important I spoke to L Jerry and Laur about this that you in increase and escalate your energy budget as you normally would because um if those costs go up you're still going to pay more but you're not going to be buying the energy that we save with this project and that's where

021your savings will be it starts at the rate that's set today and then we do escalate the savings place and what BPU gives us there are lots of changes coming in utility bills and some maintenance that is being done some additional cost so I definitely recommend like having all extra in there next June there's supposed to be some increases depending what contract you're in for buying your supply por for your bill really another discussion but so what esip has done is kind of put a standard way to measure and calculate the energy savings you've had a thirdparty engineer Johnson Urban um did the review of the savings to make sure they're correct and then the BPU checks that all the processes were taken and then we're required to offer you a guarantee the cost to

022guarantee those Energy savings is $36,250 a year in the first year that would increase like a regular maintenance contract and we'll give that to you ahead if you decide to move forward you can do that as long as you decide to need to do that um trying to think so that gives you assurance that if there's any difference we can take the time to figure it out and calculate the difference now we were speaking the other day about what's included in the guarantee and what's not and I think it's to move on this is a cash flow based or not to ex seed project or bigger project um and I get these are really little numbers for everyone but there is the Energy savings that's basically your gas and electric there's the solar savings which

023we have right now there's a bit out for solar we budgeted based on this project but we think the numbers will come back based on other recent projects and then there's the um operational savings which again is not to exceed amount we're going to pair those down we're going to work with Jerry and lore on those and then there's the um energy incentives right we're feel very sure about the prescriptive and custom rebates that are in there it's a decarbonization rebate again they looking at not to exceed amount here but the solar guarantee will come right from solar so they're going to guarantee that they're going to produce x amount of energy at each of the schools identified and that it's going to be you're only going to have to pay 4 cents per kwh

024let say if you're between four and like where you are now which is like 12 so that guarantee comes from them the um rebates and utility incenses we calculate very carefully based on the published data but we cannot guarantee that know um it's from the utility company that they change things but we don't expect any changes now except for like I said there's compation so those are not guarantees so you're really guaranteeing the column one or column two there's a year and then the annual end savings that's what our guarantee would cover that portion is that a good based on what we were talking the other day you can that explain just kind an insurance it is is that one of the res if that's the decision of the board goes so that is annual

025Energy savings and solar solar is guaranteed by the the company that you will select that'll happen in the next Energy savings and the operational savings are the ones that you're well the operational savings is more of an upfront like we see that that we're going to save that so again that's a not to exceed number we're going to bring that down but um it's it's more it's in the guarantee but it's written as assumed you know based on savings that you the 170,000 well that's in the yeah that's in the um installation period year one is 500 I can't see yes and again um so does that answer your question it is that's that's very important question and every so we we try to like we should probably put on a spreadsheet which how many

026districts select the guarantee and how many they don't so um you know it's like the different things people consider is how some some projects are very small like you have a small project the guarantee might cost the same amount because it's the same activity so you have a larger District larger project so you actually your Energy savings guarantee is like a smaller percentage of your actual savings right but we would have to miss by 36,000 for you to get a benefit from that um right but we're talking about potentially millions of dollars in savings I mean don't get me wrong like I would take $36,000 if anybody wanted to offer it to me but it's not dollar be careful don't say that because it's it's yearly so you are paying $36,000 every year for the

027guarantee so if you're saving x amount dollar you're not saving million Millions over the life of the time period like the cost is not Millions because we have to the activities have to go into to showing that am I am I right Mr take yes so the 36,000 for the first year is applicable to the projected roughly $565,000 in savings right so you're actually paying less than 10% of the probable Savings in cost to guarantee that savings just just to make it lame in terms a guaranteed of 500,000 correct of Energy savings a energy you have to come in you know 50,000 under in order to realize any benefit because the thir first 36,000 under washed out by prev and I would assume that you have to to decide on the guarantee right away yes

028this isn't something where we could say like in two years we we really need to we have to decide before the project starts because there's like there's activities that we do with an installation for metering and monitoring and setup to make sure you're set up for us to do that guaranteed so um I think this might be a well on that sheet could I ask you a question about what is the operational savings and why is it only five years what what what does it comp that's a BPU requirement like so in it's very funny in other states they go up to 20 years with it so so we kind of get a place Mark placeholder there for you at a bigger amount and we're going to whittle it down Lauren Jerry asked a lot

029of questions I do have backup for all those numbers the you're allowed two years for mechanical related savings so we took a certain amount for each air handle Unit were changing a chiller boiler assuming that you're going to save some maintenance on that you're not going to have an emergency you're not you have it like you have to do two new tubes in the chiller um the lighting is based on the number of lamps in Palace um the number of like compound fluorescent it's each and every type of light the average cost of that material only for um over a certain amount of period so if it's like $6 a tube and that tube would last three years we take $2 each year for the five years for that tube times how many tubes car

030so it's an a just just overall so the BPU the two 5 years so two years operational savings on equipment controls uh and 5 years on lighting that's protected District so BPU put that rule in there so we're not going to take 20 years of of operational savings so that's where those those time frames come okay okay doesn't mean that you don't get the savings longer like there's 10e warranties on lamps and fixtures now they're thinking about extending it you'll get the savings but we're not allowed not allowed to factor that in into these numbers thank you I guess so in terms of the um I think this this is this C qu is actually our numbers and our savings projections we provided to Phoenix and then they um provided the cash flow I didn't

031know if you wanted to talk about a little bit or get into how be financ and how that work we can you want to go there um so just just real quick I'll start off and then if there's questions um regarding process that maybe we can handle later so you can get through the the slides but um but as Caroline mentioned we rely on the Energy savings operational savings solar savings rebates Etc that they provide to us and that have been verified we don't independently calculate those um so using that information we structure the payback on the bonds uh to ensure that you're going to have positive Savings in each year um we're required to have positive savings from each year we can't um do a $20 million project um with with this cash flow

032because you'd have negative savings every year probably so we've sized um the issue based on the projects that were provided um roughly 12.7 million of project cost we used the 4% interest rate that um that honey well had assumed initially um as a safe number we think we're going to be below that but um that was a nice round number to use and we felt comfortable with it so we'll just stick with that for now um if if we were sell today we probably would be a little bit better than that but um we we're not selling for a couple of months now so so we thought that was a good safe number um we've advertised the bonds um essentially over uh 21 years 20 years of uh of principal repayments um the first year

033is interest only uh as we get through the installation period and during that period because the Project's going to ramp up in in terms of projects that are completed and produce savings uh we want to make sure that the district isn't in a situation where you have to pay interest on the bonds but we don't have enough savings to pay for it so we structured in what's called capitalized interest um for that first year so you'll see that in the in the orange section of estimated Debt Service the $62,000 what that is is we're just essentially borrowing that money in advance so you're borrowing $62,000 um sticking into an account that will then pay the interest on the bonds so that you're not uh coming out of your budget or that that those interest payments

034um and um and then we as you can see we we sructure the the repayments um around the total savings um frontload some of the debt repayment um for when we um expect the Energy rebates to come in um and those yeah we're always careful about because sometimes those take a little longer than expected so we want to make sure that that's um that that's in line and we're not being too aggressive there um and as you can see that after all this is said and done after we structured in the capitalized interest any cost of doing the financing um and then the size of the project we have about $220,000 of net Savings in each year um and that's more than what's required by the BPU for a financing like this now of course

035we want to kind of keep that in our back pocket because if uh rates move against us and and we have to borrow at four and a quar or 4 and a half which I would think be unlikely you know that that 20,000 will will start going away so uh so we do like that cushion that we have right now um and you know as as the projects change and any savings numbers get adjusted you know we'll look at the cash flow to make sure that it's still sufficient U you know and we're still providing that positive savings uh we're assuming that these bonds would be issued in in March um and then have the um you know the first uh interest payment as I mentioned be capitalized that would be in September of 2025

036U and then the first payment that the district will have to make out of its budget that would be covered by fully covered by the uh savings from the project would be in um uh let me get this right September of 2026 which would be in your 26 27 budget here any questions on that follow one question when when you talked about the 20,000 extra we always leave a little extra too because you still have a variable of the solar we expect it to come in you know anything under 12 cents would give you savings 12 cents KW is about your average we're expecting it to be around four but we you know if it came in four and a half or four and a quarter like we would always leave ourselves a Laur these

037on what we just heard we're not going to use any money from our operating budget because and we when we have to make that payment we would have already realized savings and if we did not realize the savings we have the insurance like a guarantee and it'll come from honey right well the guarantee starts at when the Project's complete so um and then but it does look backwards and forwards so we eventually have it like we usually do a year after the Project's complete is when we would like have to like look back and look at the savings so just let's think about that in terms of timing for for this project so installation essentially ET months I think is and again that's worst case probably talk to that our project manager but some of

038the rooftop units recently have been giving a very long lead time so you know we we hoping to move that thing faster right so let's just say say it ends up being a year so we have that capitalized interest period built in purposely protect the district so that um if the savings are slower than anticipated they're not coming out of pocket for Deb fee is um so27 would be kind of the cling of that guarantee right be so will fall 2027 or it would be the that would be beyond the 27th budget for the district that would kind of fall into the 28th budget where in 27 they would have a principal and interest payment on the bonds that hopefully the hopefully the savings are covered yeah so typically I mean again we can look

039at it or or we need to alter look at it but help me out that it's usually when the project finishes start guarantee monthly and up right but as soon as the project starts Di and c will start doing basically LED lighting installing so you're sa right away yeah what we what we try to do is we always do is start the lighting right away that's the biggest payback item LED lights nowadays are pretty readily available um pretty much as soon as we execute a contract issue a purchase order and get started on that's biggest b b um like Caroline said the mechanical has longer lead times um but those aren't the big energy saber thing but it's the lighting that really drives it the solar as well um but we do our our best

040to get the LI start soon as possible so a month or two into the project you're already seeing savings as soon as those lights are being installed I say about four fifths of the project looking at the numbers here are from lighting savings so it's like $459,000 a year is budgeted for lighting SA savings and um 565 is the total savings so you're going to be in good shape that was one of my questions too the the number keeps changing right year over year there's more savings and that's the 2.2% escalation for electricity one's 2.2 one's two 2.4 based on the BPU um and that's at the bottom the cost of the type should 2 G 2.2 for and 2.2 for electric does our guarantee also cover as much as being is being projected and

041use calculations it'll it's based on that's what we talked about a little bit earlier it's based on the amount of energy the cost is is different right so that's what I was saying earlier the war is have to still increase her budget as per at least at minimum the market could change and say it's going to be more increased we don't know like what you know it's it's a market now for energy but you should always increase your budget by these prescribed you know by the Board of Public Utilities prescribed these and the savings is escalated what the cost is expected to go up and it is conservative it usually goes up more yeah what have you seen like for the last several years it's been like like I looked at a project recently where

042we had a new ba to manage their price have gone up 30% in four years ago it was it was crazy this is out by the shore but so so it's negative that the price keeps going up but it's very positive that you're doing this because the price keeps going up so you're actually saving more every time energy goes up% you know it goes up by by 2% you're saving two cents because you would have been spending the four but actually you would have been spending the six but now you're only spending the two yeah how my mind works in simplest terms there are three components to the savings we have the savings from the Sal which is independent and not covered by the guarantee right we have the savings by the gr again not

043guarantee strictly applies to units of energy right not the cost per unit the unit you know right now we're paying 12 14 cents hour the guarantee will evaluate energy usage basically evaluate all of our bills to an engineering study and say we were using million outet we're now using 700,000 that's what the guarantee will do for you I can tell you very simply as Caroline pointed out four fits of the project is covered by the lighting and the lighting is the easiest thing to track it it's simply we're going from light fixture call a car that gets 30 miles a gallon to a car that will get 15 miles a gallon so those units of energy be very EAS the track and guarantee we just gas is still the same it's just how much gas

044we need exactly gas PR might go up but it Downs you as long as continue to use that yes we can I can I trademark that explanation point out to add to that U assuming that the school continues to operate like it always does then you'll see those savings if God forbid we have another covid situation or something like that where school I am sorry I have to say it though I have it's never gonna happen again if schools are shut down or something like that and you're not operating the same way then all this goes out the window because you're not using the same energy you were before so yeah you're still probably saving money but not to the same extent so um I don't know what those numbers would actually look like and

045what the what the history has been with with districts that in these programs um during that time but even that was a short period of time it's not not over once again God willing five 10 15 year period but but yeah it it does assume that you're operating in the same way that you always have SCH open the same hours you know the same months every year but schools do changes and then we find ways to like calculate that you add night school in a wing or you put an addition on there's ways to calculate what that is now that we have base sh and that's established and that's why there's different things that they on during our installation where we meter and monitor certain things to capture how it is right now um talking

046of unusual circumstances I the whole budget the whole cost of the project is based on the price of goods right now and we're all expecting things to change significantly in the next few months with based on the cost of price of goods right so right the supplies so I I don't know hopefully it doesn't change by much but if it does does everything change here the number this has been built as a um a you know not to exceed price our job for you in this project is to provide you a price that's that we can't really change it because it's all based on it so it's no change orders if we do get better pricing we will share that back with you and Tim Tim will be responsible for that piece of it but

047um but that's why we have budgetary language but we're ready to go to a final not to ex price no change orders within the next like month for you right like that's why we're looking for these approvals we have our you know all the different people we' have certain parts of the projects are vendors we know will use maybe buy through a co-op other vendors will be bid but we know like we know the price we've done this enough times so if the process gets pushed or the decision gets gets pushed by another month these numbers could change and your numbers would accordingly adjust to whatever your numbers are right if there if there's substantial enough change uh we also have right now we're perfect for summer construction like you know we're the perfect time

048for that right and we're relying on the the cost that they provide which is roughly 12.7 million if that number for the same projects went to $13 million then yes we would rerun our cash flow and make sure everything still works um but I think this team probably has experienced in the last few years you know when when cost of everything were skyrocketing making sure that you're cushioning everything appropriately so that we don't have that kind of situation but um but yeah we we will adjust things when when we get to the point where we're going to the market to sell bonds we need to know okay this is the number we're using this is the project we just like if you did a referendum you know you know the project is X number of

049dollars that's what we're financing can't do a dollar more you know this is it this is the number that we're doing there might be you know a few dollars here and there EXT extra but this is the the number we're going so that would be absolutely fine- tuned over the the course one of the questions I had was related to this that you're putting you got four resolutions that we read through today and right we don't yet have the final approval from the BPU well it's it's it's will be she had some trouble with her team's rooms but I think it'll be the next three days like we confident that's coming before a board meet yeah if if not it'll be we have the resolution read pending pbu approval but um Michelle was like she

050told me she have to me last Friday but then you know she always has to come with questions we always go back and forth on a lot of different things it's just how it works but we her team's room everyone's teams are too secure and she couldn't two different rooms she couldn't get into so she just has a few more things to look at I think we'll have it in the next I think we'll have it in the next 48 hours she got an email back to us today we should have the resolutions are conditioned on BPU approval when we go down to get the local Finance board approval that's one of the things they will ask us or they will condition their approval if they're willing to do it on BPU approval also that

051one of my concerns like is it normal to do that resolution with the language that it currently has that is conditional to the it it varies I think a large driving Factor here is what you heard Caroline say that you're slotted if you do it now you're slotted to get this done dur summer construction so in those situations school districts and Boards of Education will do things subject to receiving other approvals in order to get all their approvals lined up and not have to wait potentially another month to get your approval done does the does the guarantee cost come out of our operating budget or is that Finance that's not fin that's not Finance good questions really good questions well we're looking at pennies and Di in our budget so how how many districts would

052you say do the we that question and and how many of them benef like 50% about do it and our our we never pay out it's like I think we have like a 99.9% um success rate but districts our side yeah I mean but I don't like to I like I I was like I just try to keep quiet on that I really want that to be your decision right it be good to know like similar size District like Mr Barrow said like if really not using the guarantee again you know it's not nothing I think everything can go towards something else not like that we feel like we would need when you first came Miss Jackson didn't you bring uh examples of I do I have so many examples and I can go back

053and get some that have chosen the guarantee and and um Oldbridge East see what it is I'm sorry Oldbridge East BR Oldbridge and East BR to in your county I don't know if call they weren't my personal they to guarantee um I think they both did yeah we have the scway also which is finishing up now they took a guarantee we don't have a result on it yeah we're still finishing up construction now but they did take a guarantee I think for three years yeah if we do it yearly which we have that ability we do it yearly it is just like with any other service contract so let's say it's board approved uh January 15th with the guarantee does that mean the following January like when will we have to know if we want

054to spend the guarante the guarantee starts so like with um when the project ends so if it's an 18-month Pro all right so it's whenever the project ends the guarantee begins so we have one calendar year from that year and we have to make and we can make the decision with no penalty of any kind to take a guarantee again or not correct it's usually decided before contract like that's included in your contract with so so we'd have to decide right now whe we wanton next two months we have done oh okay yeah we that's my question most of our districts that have done that have usually dropped after their year two that is our point exactly that's why I wanted to ask that thank you no no no he for got exactly what I

055was asking so would you say sorry you're success rate on the savings that have been projected and what actually will say he's never paid out like I'm a guarantee just never so so your your number very good yeah we have to be we go through all kinds of reviews Paul has to do internally Paul and EMily do a peer review on the savings then they and we paid and we also pay weit to take the I agree so we and we also paid for the additional um you you know what we paid I apologize the independent yeah third party audit so we already we already vetted it yeah we paid the third party audit to begin with because even if we let if let's suggest we didn't take the guarantee it's still like looking at

056that first year Savings of you know $560,000 it's not like it' be so contrastingly different like over under that 36,000 that we'd be paying that I feel like it's worth it to waste that money in my in my you're saying it is worth it or it isn't okay I I don't from from what I'm understanding especially considering you said that it's never really had to be paid out it's only worth it if if all of a sudden we only realize $200,000 savings it was worth $300,000 then we have a problem 50,000 first kick correct well is it I would imagine he I would also Imagine you must have a clause I'm sure Act of God it's for closing that you're not responsible there's so many Clauses I'm sure there's there I can't imagine that no

057but it's not if the District closed though it's not like you didn't save you would probably save more so you still have to pay back your project it's not like you know like you're going to actually save more but if you do an addition or something like that we could help you calculate what that would be so you can add that to your budget like it's your base Year we're trying to like emulate what the base year was if if you um I don't know like I said if you if you close the schools that's like a that's like kind of then you're not spending any money yeah like again it wouldn't um say you pay your debt you know so um so should I move on sorry no no no don't be sorry at

058all I don't want to go too fast but I want to make sure I can you know I run out that I overheated it keep going stuck I'm trying yeah thank you so the next one was to kind of oh was to kind of just give you again these we were trying to build and not to exceed projects so these are the operational savings we grabbed for you that we have in our Energy savings plan a little different place the project the Energy savings plan we submit to the BPU is 90% 95% the same we're allowed to change projects it's just a it's a sample project everything gets reviewed but um so um this is how they came out the lighting operational savings based on Council of L Bas the maintenance cost savings based on

059the number of pieces of equipment and a budgeted amount and um Jerry and I are going to work through those to F tune those as we go through the other fine tuning I hypothetical question what if we put out a referendum and the referendum passes then what happens like what happens if all the these that's a great question figures and numbers and everything that we wouldn't get rid of these building no we still be the same needs you feel to apply any of this into our new facilities or no just probably just get LED lights if it was in new facility oh so for example let's hypothetically say we would put out a referendum included kindergart and we had some other projects which I know Mr T has talked about which are required and maybe

060perhaps a small addition onto the high school it's completely hypothetical okay I'm just thinking of our needs right very small different maybe the six that we talked about under the overhang just off the top of my head so if we were to do that what you're saying is the cost that we see like the savings cost that we see does that stay separate is that what you're asking does that stay separate from the money that we're saving like how do we look at that how does that become part of the EA project or does it become part of it does not okay he Shing said no everything need separate okay so it's it's like getting a groad grant versus the colonization they're separate like there so it's okay but we would but we could utilize

061what we learned in the project to change the way we the kind of lighting we put in the things that we do right exactly when you looked at your projects you would probably say okay we know we had savings just in general they doing LED lighting so we're going to put LED lighting we use our learning we would use our learning to save money and how we ever we did the projects you don't have additional cost because you're increasing your size your facilities and footprint but you would it would be less expensive to operate new LED lighting than to put in the old fluores I understand that makes sense but none of these projects would be redundant or not needed the project 18 months so whatever we putting the money into and doing that that's

062needed even if we expand our facility with a referendum in the future and what we keep on saying is actually some of them would benefit your projects take barle Brook for example if you're at kindergarten we have to add on to building the addition of the boiler at the school could not handle the addition got it so if you don't do the boilers through there we can't ref Cost needs to go the cost that's important know that makes sense yeah that's something that often times people will schools will either do a Esa before a referendum to reduce the size of the referendum or do it next to the referendum and pull out in the Energy savings so you don't have to go for quite as big you know it's and I think of the key

063things that I just wanted to interject which I think is so important is that even if we broke even for lack of a better term and didn't have extra monies these projects need to be done and we don't have the financial capital and I know you said that when you started I think I know that people are watching and we're being transparent you know why are we so excited why is this a project that we are recommending why why do we feel this is something we need to move forward with because we need to do what we need to do for our facilities and we don't have the ability do within our budget and I think what Mr T just said too like that's a big selling also that if we don't do this the

064reference money be very difficult to do anything not even if it wasn't the energy notg but it is it's suppressing infrastructure needs yes which if we did not go this route we would be H having to find money in our operational budget boiler breaks or you know so that's the reason we started talking to and it's always so much more to do on an emergency basis oh yes you can plan can I ask a quick question um it it was on the slide that you were on sorry I was no it's okay I was gonna point it out then I couldn't find it um so I see that the says the total price of says solar PPA is $38,000 so that's just a reuse of nalizing exterior consultant to help and so that's part of

065like um the fee that for that consultant and you have haven't really seen her work yet but we have done an RFP um I mean Jerry's seen it we we've done a um addendum I just gave an addendum to look that we're um putting out to answer questions of the solar people come and then the real work that she'll do and that you'll see is once all the vendors give us her proposals we do a real thorough analysis and it is really like a it's a it's a specialty job where she will um take that and rank All The People based on their rate their references the material they use so we need a little help with that because it's very special too so I guess my my question is when you had mentioned that

066most of the savings are is going to come from lightting right um and then I saw that you know the cost of of the potential Savings of that solar is I think it's a 2.4 obviously most of the savings for the guarantee come from light soar is very good though it's like 137 based on our our budget savings for 137,000 a year but doesn't guarantee it that's the point okay okay that's not guaranteed through honey will um we know what we don't know what the potential cost of the solar would be at so there's no cost we we looked at buying solar yeah it's okay it's very we looked at buying it but that did not it do make sense for you based on how New Jersey is inen incentivized and how you fit into

067the ESF so we're doing a power purchase agreement which is where different spaces throughout your district will be leased they will provide the system that will guaranteed to buy the energy at a lower rate to you I'm saying it you know for everybody no it's good it's good no it's good and people are listening which is good we want yeah and so and also there is an upside to what we've done because we put the high school canopies as an alternate so that'll be a decision down the road to see if that saves or or that best right and I know that they were they were studied to ensure that structurally like those buildings can handle solar panels and things like that now so from from first glance that all looks good but the Solar

068Company that's that's selected we'll do a structural um review as our first step and if we have to change some areas or move some to a different school we like we we might do some changes based on that result but at first glance everything is lot of it's life expectancy right in the roof so you're not put solar panels that's 30 years old no exactly you're going to put it on a roof that's two years old but we only have solar slotted where you have at least a 15year warranty okay why is all3 part of the solar PPA we already have this will be so we have our system which is on top of the roof there it's 50k W system this is additional panels in the field behind the baseball back it's not on

069it's not at Net Zero yet so what we would do is build we had the opportunity to do it and Woodland and um apple apple is getting a new roof Woodland roof is structurally good to M and the middle we have enough warranty left on but not the lake examp and and the solar doesn't do anything there was an issue with the roof the solar wouldn't affect the warranty in any way right that's something that gets coordinated okay but um that and they will look at every warranty and they'll make sure what system they provide works with the warranty different ballast different paddings that warranty approval in order to be able to do it if the roof company steps in and says we need some sort of balance of memory added then that would have

070to be bu the cost of solar okay you would not extra plus to you PPA thank you so yeah just C the solar side for that so um so yeah we did provide the cost per measure and that's an all-in cost but do supervision project management I'm going back to it right here this also um talks about the payback as you can see some of the paybacks are very large but they are um balanced by the paybacks that are shorter and that's the whole idea of this is to balance things like boilers and chillers with longer payback with things that are um I can go through each of the measures that's what I have next that number is years right what the payback number is that how many years are payback yeah yeah based on

071the um cost minus the rebates and grants and um like a net cost and operational savings this is an all-inclusive cost so it's enough to exceed if there's Savings in any of the um procurement that will come back to the district um it includes also engineering design all the applications for um your energy and um things of that nature all right so did you want me to just go through the measures quick like I said I know we've been talking like holistically about the project that'll just kind of list off what the projects are so districtwide inter and ex tier anything that's not LED now will be led right so this involves new fixtures a lot of retrofit fixtures like these fixtures here are beautiful but we get an LED light in there we will

072no longer have a balance to maintain and you will you know save a lot of money certain fixtures aren't economical to retrofit and you'll have a new picture um D and the thing about LED lighting is you know every school is different like some districts have beautiful clean lighting like this other District you go they're different colors based on the different Ines it really does clean out it's beautiful for the spaces um we have in the high school art room this was just like a need and we wanted to you know something we often do with lighting um there's um it does get warm in that space and we feel like a D- strip fan really help with comfort in a area that does save energy too just by moving the air around and not

073losing long your heat and a cealing there'll be um new boilers at the metal and barkle book schools there's 11 units um because they'll be they'll be um oh what's the word I'm looking for small the smaller boil like sections right now you have bigger boilers they'll be smaller so they're more efficient because you can only use what you need to on your shoulder zones yeah yeah yeah yeah so we're not looking for oh condensing yeah condensing you already have very High efficient boiler but it's basically what we talked about before with the a life way over so little bit of savings if why you see a very small payback but it be basically the same thing thats ni but again you've had to do lots of work on those from with their their their

074hassle um in the middle Contin with shs and you know I just want to understand while you're going through these project a lot of these were selected for more schools than what we are now putting in the project what went into the decision making of which school to pick and which not to pick highest priority in terms of for example boilers High priorities the middle school they are the oldest outside of Apple bar and then the next Woodland and Barkley Brook and M Lake are all the same era Barkley Brook has been giving us the most trouble so like that go thank you um in terms of roof typ units um there's the middle school has one section that um will also be doing a new roof on that section and very large it's a

07530 or 40 time roof trap unit and then there's um selected air handling units and um split systems as well at the middle school um with the Middle School boiler and Chiller there'll also be new pumps and B frequency that um new chillers at Woodland and Barkley Brooks which are over 20 years old yeah and again we had a few schools that lost chillers this last summer and um we were in the middle of Ana with one and they took everything out to get the chiller because their parents did not want people at the school with no cooling it was it was really interesting but um it was very stressful for the district where we managed it and we have another school that's doing an EA but they're ordering the chiller first and then going

076to install it like they pre-ordered the chiller so a lot of chillers are going lately it seems like a trend um building management systems again um there'll be some other work going on but what we'll be working on is the middle school high school admin transportation and it's important to say at the middle school and particularly all your unit ventilators there your air handlers your rooftop units will get new controls in them a lot of the equipment will be replaced and that'll come with new controls at the middle school but like every unit ventil later your your unit is looking fine it's maybe older but we get all the insides new that'll have less breakdowns be more comfortable less overheating and failures and then building envelope is just tightening everything up in different places throughout

077the building which a really good Energy savings for us and it actually qualifies for a lot of the custom rebates um you're also going to be doing combined heat and power at the high school I know I've told you this before but I'll say it again it's a green technology this allows you to take advantage of the 20year financing by having this technology so it takes um gas and makes electricity and then the heat so also you get less expensive electricity that's put into the system and then the um heat that comes from that will get put into your system to supplement your hot water system um and then we're still going to work on some education programs but we've been so working so hard on this we haven't really gotten to them but we

078will we will in the education programs is that fully I guess I'm wondering how that it's basically we'll work with you to make this this in educational like we don't want to just do this and not take the learning experience so one of the things that really is fun is like as a solar gets done that's something that people can see and touch and feel the picture up there is we did a ribbon cutting for a solar um like an opening you know so like we could get maybe a stem class or group or you know we need to get with the we've been this has been very this been a lot of work so we will take any part of our team and share with you that every way works if it's you know

079talking about what our jobs are and what we went to school for you know doing like a solar ribbon cutting whatever it is that FS for you I I did mention to both I did speak we spoke at the conference and then I did speak to the middle school and high school principls just to say that you know we're still in the thick of this and no decision has been made but once this board approved that you would be coming in and perhaps we'd have a meeting or have a conversation about about what's a good P exactly so but not creating like new enough that something more like either it's work experience related or to technology program maybe another aspect of work based learning where we had the stem programs yeah yeah um all right

080we've kind of I think talked about this the solar PPA you want to advance again oh there we go it's working out again we talked about that um just to think oh this was more for the last time to bring up the conversation about the canopies the third party review is complete I really believe the board of buens will be done in the next 48 hours it fell was really quick she took put an email at the end of the today and we'll get back for in the morning and then um again we will keep updating you on the schedule you know I don't know if I've really tweaked this since November but we're um you know it looks like we're in good shape to move forward and and there's your the finance committee applications

081are due and your board meetings don't really line up so that's why we're trying to get this now go over that so um review of next steps complete the third riew the Board of Public children review is underway um and these are the resolutions so I don't know if um if there's any other conversation or questions on those we did take off two the bottom two on this list to um the long range facility plan and the approv the department education applications they can come later we just took them off for now they're just something that in the bundle of resolutions or something this is not on here this is not part of the resol to at this point we going to talk about the four resolutions briefly and if there are any questions on

082them yeah they were provided because we wanted everybody to have an opportunity to read them so that they had a comfortable level if they had questions so we would be at that point if anybody had any questions regarding that would be great sure we have in essence to really three resolutions and a refunding bond OU so the first resolution that would be on the agenda is to make application to the local Finance board down in Trenton their meeting is in February the 2 week of February and the applications are due January 20 is it 22nd 22nd and so um Phoenix would draft the initial draft of the application for board Administration and my myself to look at and we would submit that down to Trenton there would be a meeting in February that is done

083by Zoom mail that we would appear to get their approval because you cannot do the refunding bonds without their approval so that was the first resolution after you adopt that at the meeting we would adopt what we call the Energy savings refunding bond ords um it's similar to other I don't know how long each of you have been on the board but this district has done many refunding bonds since I've been working with you and it's a two-step process it's an introduction at the January meeting you then publish notice of its introduction and in the February meeting you would have a public hearing and a final adoption of that ordinance and that in essence sets forth a maximum amount of Brook funding bonds that would be authorized for this project currently based on the numbers

084we have we're looking at not to exceed number of about 13.5 5 million doesn't require you to go out and issue those bonds but it's a not to exceed to give us some push in in case something changes but once the numbers get fine tuned we can go out when we actually offer the bonds for sale for a lower amount right that's just to add to that um we for purpos of resolution we need an not to seed number and we wanted to make sure that you know you know the projects may change or you will will cost will change so we want to come up with a a higher number just to be safe you know in case something changes we also in our sizing of the bonds we assume that um purchasers will

085pay a premium for the bonds you know that could change as we move through the next couple of months if that gets reduced so we just want to make sure we have some cushion um so that uh you know we only have to do the resolution once we don't have to come back and ask for a couple hundred, um but as Jackie said we will only issue what we need to issue for project so we authorize a 13 and a half million and only issue $12 million your debt is $12 million that million and a half would then be canceled um when you do your your um you know your Deb statements and and your financials so so that a million half go um the third resol or the second resolution technically is to approve

086the Energy savings plan and a contract with honey well as parine mentioned you know you going enter into a contract that's going to provide for installation of the energy conservation measures and approving the contract um the last resolution and this will be dependent on the decision that comes out of I guess this committee and the board and we um your administration had us break it out separately to give you that flexibility to discuss it is whether or not you're going to authorize the guarantee um lots of times we do the guarantee paragraph in the other resolution but because we wanted to provide the flexibility for you to have a discussion and make a decision we could just always if you decide you're not going to do that it'll just get pulled from the agenda pretty

087much all the resolutions are final but for the addition of I wanted to confirm the dates that we were still on the schedule and the addition of the dollar amounts because we were sort of when I drafted them to get them to you here tonight we were sort of a little bit the state of fluxes to what maximum amounts we were using and course of the guarantee Etc the dollar amount right now as per whatever is on the on the table is 13.5 that's exceed R not to exceed it could come out 12 yeah but that what we put in the resolution would be 13.5 correct the only one that would have a different number would be the cost for the guarantee if you're going to do the guarantee one has a dollar amount for

088that which is $36,000 I wasn't sure if it was I I think it was even 306 252 all right that's Mr take um regarding that quick guarantee like I know we sort of disgusting do you have I guess what's your opinion on it do you feel like it's like it's a good idea for us to move forward with that do you feel like it's not necessarily A something we we should I just I know you've done this type of thing once or twice I'm I'm curious what your expertise says I think it really comes down to your pce of mind and again in simple terms you're going from the car get 30 mil a gall to 15 from 15 15 to 30 m g four fths of that is in the lighting the lighting will

089still be used in the same quantity plus or minus that you use so I think your units of energy in that four fth is pretty solid it give it gives you piece of mind though and if you want doent to show to the public what side you've already paid for that depend fromation the Board of Public Utilities is a completely independent agency that vs this so you've had it V voice so so we had the conversation the three of us as as a team myself and Mr sh and we we kept on going back at for because you know we want to feel comfortable you know as the administrative staff the administrative team to say you know what do we suggest I can make an argument either way EAS way the argument is exactly what

090he just said it's already been vetted really we at a third time for lack of a better saying but then we could also say well it's a half million dollarss that we're looking for $36,000 it's not a lot of money it's a lot of money we we check off every dollar as everybody knows we're saving pennies here but in the grand scope of the amount of money money we're about to realize I have to be careful because I'm being tapered when I say correctly the amount of money that we real we hope to realize it is not a lot of money in that amount to spend in that peace of mind the fiduciary responsibility of course lays with you know you know stays with the board the recommendation or the Comfort level is with the

091administration because we make all the recommendations I can easily recommend for to go ahead and pay for it it's $36,000 in the grant scheme of the 500,000 plus it is not a lot of money in comparisons or I could easily say it's $36,000 like you said we could utilize for something else and we've already vetted this process two to three times so we feel comfortable and with their track record which they make the statement that they haven't paid out yet on a guarantee so we can say let's say this not in this scenario the 30 something oh we'll take it wouldn't necessar be so and that's the other thing also is that we have to also miss it why like 50 we just use the number 50 because around number 50,000 so you could actually

092make a it really is a comfort level and I I think as Mr T I not we all agreed not that we don't want to give you our opinion but we want you to feel comfortable as a superintendent I would feel comfortable either spending the 36,000 or not spending was saving I think 36,000 take it or break it then correct spend it if if we really feel that in order for the board to move forward because you're a representation of the board for the for the vote you know in your opinion of how you feel your constituents on you know on this board feel if you feel that that would really solidify because I think this project does need to move forward and I like the timing of it because of board meetings next week

093then I feel if that's something that really makes few people feel I feel safe then I would spend the $36,000 can I ask you on the timing of it while other resolutions I know everything is kind of you know we we pressed for time for the guarantee can we push that resolution oh we can that could be to February oh that could be to February oh okay we don't need that till the final oh we don't need to the final contract find out you know and plus you know all of us get some time to think about I I send on email you know I deal with them you know they're part of just to see what and just say I know that you did reason we we want to get the financing in place

094to get every so the final contract is February so the February board meeting we can have the resolution for you couldn't sign even though you've approved the contract in January you wouldn't be able to sign it until you made your decision at your February meeting about the guarantee because the guarantee into the contract is it very late they I I just once we know it's more the financing oh it's the 19th February 19th when is and when is the the contract approval at the state their meeting February February 12 but that doesn't that do only need the other resoltion oh so so if that makes you feel more the reason I said if we can push that one resolu we can just the one resol push the others out you mention just a guarante about

095the contract you're you're approving you're approving officers to sign the contract subject to BPU approval and all the other approvals right the terms of the contract are going to be satisfactory to your attorneys and your administrators and your officers and so you you don't have to come back to approve the actual contract you would have to come back to approve whether or not if you were going to do the guarantee and then before they sign the contract they would make sure the guarantee would then be in the contract if you decide you know end of January we don't want to do the guarant we don't need away me because it's it's it's mve you're done you don't have to do anything or take other action and you could sign and then we can even discuss

096it in committee reports next week too and then we have like we'd like to know as soon as possible we go through our own internal review and whether we have measurement verification or not really does reflect that but we might get you the like the base contract and terms conditions about the scope like get all that to you minus the guarantee sections we can start to get that reviewed all this right so they have three quars if not more of of it right we can give you Bas contract and then we would add in the um guarantee language I would want you to have that reviewed if you decide not to do that right okay that's good but I don't want to hold it up because it'll be getting close and I think we with

097so for purposes of this committee we're we're good at moving forward the resolutions for next we resolutions and then we'll hold up on to do a little okay that's good we're going with the assumption that all the all you just coming down to the basics everything that has been proposed Mr take in in this project are things that you know it's smart to do it today we're not overdoing anything but at the same time we're making the maximum use of the services and incentives already lasted P really needs to this is really the means by which we can address needs that cannot be addressed in the regular budget that's and what the board is committing to is agreeing to get the financing and stop ball rolling on the projects and this is the perfect timing

098because we really want summer summer is import that's for school we will not see a financial impact for the next year's budget cycle but in the following year we will start to see money rolling in and out both ways right we'll be saving and unless we of course take the guarantee in which we will start to see the impact if you take the guarantee do we start paying in 2025 no not until the project not until the project the project done is when you would start paying that and start counting and the 2025 remember you provided the cushion so that the monies that you need to pay because we're not actually realizing your savings is there so that we're not it's it's like you're financing the extra because you know you need it to make

099the payment for a second we start which I think if we we wrap this all up we start in March we can probably start relating by end April into may I me Tim is like ready to go Tim and C to get the the lighting will start right away so as soon as we change the protocol from um you know T8 to L you're going to start save savings so you will but it's not going it's going to be more within six months and morein a year okay start it's good anybody else any questions thank you you you've been very patient you know Wise Wise Men once said that half of the learning comes from asking good questions I don't know if our questions are good but we do ask a lot of questions I

100specifically do but I learned a whole lot through the process several meetings if you're probably to leave and another question please feel free to give it to Jerry provide any information um you know all of us were here to help and support if you ever wonder why his answers are so amazing and so sympath because he deals with a board that asks really Raymond questions all the time me being the first one but uh thank you for being patient yes thank you very much thanks everyone we have two more things we want to put go through the bill in um so Mr take I think this is where we're going to have the rest of the board look at all the documentation through and I'll make sure it's all ready I'll work with Laura we'll

101work with ncy mimer and everything ready you get information on the guarantee how many I'll I'll reach out to the superintendent thank you safely you tomorrow your packages tomorrow or Thursday I'll get you the final resolutions for gold we've heard so much about you it was great to finally meet you thank you thank you it's a pleasure thank you than take care have a good evening so good uh really quick um two more items left on the agenda we have the attorney uh Bill review um and I we all have concerns and I'm sure Laura is expecting that um I I know we all have the same concern so I can go out and say it with the porio bill was again pretty hard I thought he was tring to push I'm like What's the

102concern hi excuse me it's hope Blackburn I've been listening I don't know if you want me to sit through the rest of it I'm Adam's partner from Bush we apologize thank you sorry sorry good thank you thank you okay just want want to make sure before I before I signed out thank you okay bye bye so what is this I go about like anything regarding cases and stuff like that no we don't that I like I I reviewed it and I I reached out Bon for finance Sharon and Miss Bano because I don't like I without mentioning any details about it had a know ready there are several hours of multiple days of things that like I just can't imagine that I can tell you there was about almost 50 hours for a for drafting

103a summary judgment brief and we spent ,000 on it so our question Laura is that um I mean there was one day where it's 9.5 hours of one person drafting a brief no typically uh and I did do some research when you reached out at that time I was myself looking into it a summary brief can take 20 to 408 40 hours like but this is we've been doing this for three months right now so it is it all different cases is it one case we need to get into oh we ask ask questions basically what we saying we need ask no this is the same case one same for this this invoices that Cas but three consecutive invoices of really high amounts a lot of that being drafting the summaries right um I agree

104like I understand that you're not necessar going to finish a summary brief within two hours right but the idea of nine and a half hours SP because they they you know they bill us by the minute basically right so like is that is that an accurate count like is someone seriously spending almost 10 hours four days straight writing a summary read for us but you know like not taking break I just I mean I don't really think there's a way for us to to ensure that but it's it's you know like she said it's almost you know 20 $10,000 we start by asking that we start by asking we need to ask some questions and then if I feel that they're charging us more money than they should be charging us then we should follow

105this up with maybe our attorney to get an estimate on what we PID or maybe the New Jersey attorney general's office on if we're being built as a district because maybe somebody's not happy with us or somebody's charging us an astronomical amount of money I think that a we need over a lot of we've been we've been spending a lot of money and I think that I I just feel like the what he's charging us is it's not practice and in all transparency to the public there listening in right now the reason we are all concerned is we now have two law firms one that's handling all you know the it's just wrapping up the work on open PES and one that's handling our everyday business and the discrepancy between the two is has been

106significant three three months in a row so all board members at this point are concerned in asking questions and if there is you know this is what it is then we it would it would make us feel better once we've asked the questions and gotten detailed answers that so so perhaps it would in this particular case because we have to be very careful what we discussed we would put this I was just chatting Dr lame and I do believe it would be appropriate and we will confirm this to be a close session item for the board meeting to discuss the financial concerns of the money spent I think last time we did ask a question or two if you remember correctly where we did say and he did say that the cost was appropriate he

107did say so I think that would be appropriate so at least by us bringing it up here which I think is great the public knows that we are doing our due diligence the board is doing our diligence and then of course following through to say we respect the fact that money is being spent and we want to make sure the money is being spent appropriately so I think you know my suggestion would be that when uh we do our um we do our uh board agenda that we put on this as a closed closed session item um and I think that is appropriate that would really help we're also over getting buil tce right because then we have them charging us to talk to our law it's just something right and we're trying and we

108we did have the conversation that it does need to remain with them for the time we know that that is something we did right and need to know that too someone could say how come they don't just switch you know we we the amount the they they said it would be exorbitant to get someone up to speed right so we we have no choice we must remain but we want and if they and if they are legitimately spending monies that our attorney would confirm yes this is what it costs then we want to be respectful and say then we have no choice but paying but we just want to make sure that the money is being spent appropriately the right right that's it anybody else any concerns on the attorney um in I did have

109one for the bill list which is not on the agenda uh really quick Laura these are check numbers 4460 to 65 um they were for the same um vendor mean educational resources but only in one of the descriptions do it mentioned Brookside so I was just wondering is it all for one library or is it if you know if it's across the district because it $155,000 worth of supplies from the wender um so the first one 4460 would be um Brookside um the second one is so they different schools library library um do we us use this window or is this Scholastic I thought I no mag is a very common common one that we use and this is about the money that we spend for the libraries year everything coming through is 100% budgeted

110uh yeah okay yep it's a refreshing of the resources and okay because there were no other school names only Brookside I was wondering it was all one school and that felt like a lot School Cod it's the school code this a good question you know if they were saying all school that wouldn't have asked a question but you know I I understand everybody enters it differ that's all the question I had anybody else anybody list questions yes really quick I I don't want to like look with a gift horse in the mouth I think but I noticed that the hota payment was only $112,000 but for 2425 and school year which is what we're in I know it's been typically triple yeah but that's is actually an adjusted payment because they adjusted the pay the

111when they did the count in October and they determined how many students there are they changed it's last 27 and 30 so they changed our um monthly so that's why so this is an adjusted um amount we basically would have overpaid last month based on the original so they took it off for the money that they okay so what we owe now minus whatever we weren't supposed to have so so they the the payments SCH State changed because the number of students has decreased okay so it's not going to be this is an adjusted matter because we based on the old any other questions oh we're going to be finishing on time I just want to close the meeting by saying that we the the agenda the big agenda for discussion today was a really

112important one and there going to be a lot of uh misconceptions around looking at the number 13.5 million that the resolution is going to have I encourage all community members that are interested to listen to the meeting reach out to the administration with questions to get a better understanding we are doing this for the infrastructure needs and for Energy savings uh in our own district and that money is going to feed these projects we are not looking to spend out of our operating budget this is a great plan and if we can get this out and rolling hopefully with the complete board's approval at the next board meeting it's only going to serve us well so if you have any questions to all community members that are listening in please reach out with the administration

113and uh get answers um and you're welcome to the board meeting to come and ask questions then as well be you'll be able to answer them then at that time in that right on time what you said is this presentation available on the website or can it be made because I mean it's it's public they would have just seen so I don't know oh yeah it's available this one right but like someone wants to just look through the the PowerPoint sort of like what we get I mean it's not I'm not sure if it part of executive attachments or we only made as of right now we always make everything executive per this was an executive attachment today right but they've seen it so confid honey has it listed as confidential so we would we

114would ask done I saw that you're right at the bottom does say confidential we'll just confirm with them just to make sure that we're following their confidentiality as well we watch the meeting watch the meeting watch the meeting we meeting it's all recorded and thank you everyone good night uh the policy meeting is next um I'm

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.