CorpusRecord 133017

Monroe Twp BOE citizens advisory committee 01.07.25

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Monroe Township School District
Date
2025-01-08
Location
Middlesex County, NJ
Material
Transcript
Extent
3,561 words · about 20 min
Collected
2026-06-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001even everybody happy New Year first meeting of the citizens advisory committee January 7th n 2025 my goodness I almost put my birth year in there and it would have been a long long spin um so I want to welcome everybody we're very H we had one student here last week last month and we have all three students from our high school here represent in the high school so we're happy to have them here and I think I'm going to turn it over to Mr morala because he's the one that came up with the um really insightful agenda for tonight so I hope I can live up to that introduction thank you everybody and awesome um not a have yeah we're talking about um so uh if you if you've been checking your email um or

002paying attention online you will have notice that our district announced that we need more over there um well not our district but the state has recently announced that there's going to be some opportunities for us or for the public to comment and offer testimony on uh the state funding formates and uh obviously it's been something that um we've been discussing not just as a group but as a community as an Administration um and uh most recently uh these discussions have been taking place throughout the state whereas in Monroe we've been talking about this from for some time um we didn't want to let the moment passes by uh and uh during our uh meeting or one of our discussions during the week we realized that hey we have our citizens advisory committee um we have

003a working draft and and some Concepts and some uh a vision that has been constructed through our legislative action uh and Community engagement committee and these objectives were starting to converge and uh with the announcement of the upcoming uh opportunities uh we thought it would be best to use our meeting time today to try to produce um some actionable uh items that can hopefully be turned over to our community and anyone else that wants to get involved with these upcoming dates so in the packet I gave you um uh what I did was I tried to really uh along with Dr Layman and Mr pay in the committee uh turn today's meeting into something that would be uh a very productive and working meeting uh we have two objectives that we would like to accomplish

004today uh with the and on the back of your agenda you can uh see that I outlined this is just a reproduction of the image that we s back to the public which itemizes all of the opportunities that are coming up the first of which is tomorrow um and then uh some next week one of which down in the Department of Education and then down in Camden the one tomorrow is in sumers um on the uh so these dates are also uh available on our uh Facebook page it also was sent out to uh our our Blackboard connect email service and the State website also has a publication of these dates um all of links were embedded in the email that we had sent out to the public um add on yeah because we got

005a little bit of more information today um so I know that shano myself SC all receive confirmation um Miss Alvarez as well um and so what we were told is that um you have to limit your testimony to three minutes if you're going to speak in person obviously written testimony they can't really limit I should really use that um but um and they also said that depending on how many people are do show up they may limit the number within that Community right so if there because it's from six to eight let's say right and if there's 100 people and 50 of them are from Monroe they're probably not going to let all 50 of us that would be great but also if it's written and you're there you could just you can give it

006to them so don't let the number of people there deter you if it well we won't even know so if you feel like you would like to join us then you know please do if if we don't all get an opportunity to speak we can at least submit our written testimony um so they can hear something from but then also just that try to keep it within that that three mon because they are very like at least if it's similar to what the budget testimony they're very strict on that they that time are staring at you in in the face um and yeah and my experience with this thank you for bringing that up because that that'll add some context to what we're going to do uh when when Dr Chanley and I had gone

007down there in uh spring of last year when uh she offered a testimony there was a lot of redundancy and the messaging that was being offered even from you know whether it's Jackson testifying or us or whether it's principal board president and whatever um so one of the things that I think would help us uh tactically would be to really diversify our message but maintain the them and so what we did was uh on the back of your pib U there were some talking points that and again this these are just these are just things that we came up with amongst our administrative team that we Cherry Picked out of our letter which we will be revising as well and the idea would be um to take these talking points and we'll work on them

008in a moment um and to hand them out or distribute them to your constituencies um you know I would be handing these out for let's say the people I associate say Hey listen if you're interested here are the talking points um you know how do we develop this into a message that resonates with our decision makers and I think one of the unique advantages that Monroe has and and and the fact that we are kind of game fighting for this is that we are very diverse and different we all have different state in the game but these talking points kind of speak to all of us um uh so what I would like to do uh before the end of today um and would be to look at these talking points see if we need

009to chop them up add some things and then ideally this would be something that we would push out to the public and say hey if you guys want here's a starting point if you'd like to go speak um as a as an exercise to what I had done personally just I took the talking points and then I went and I typed up a written testimony for myself as a Monro employee and as a no onni as a 30 plus year resent of town um and I tried to write a personal message uh you know driven by these talking points and I felt like I was able to do that um that was unique that spoke to my position but also spoke to the larger issue of the town and my guess is that that would

010be hoping our community to do they have the guut to get up there and speak publicly that would be even better but um I think if we were able to submit anything whether it be written um but I I think redundancy won't necessarily help us um I'm not going to go through all these talking points right now um in a moment uh we'll go into workshop and then we could I I would suggest maybe breaking up to a couple groups yeah definitely take I would like to go through the a ton of time and then maybe add or remove some things that know Dr you said you had some thoughts about some things to add and then um recollect this I will take all of our ideas maybe we can go through them put it

011into one document and then um if if the committee's good that with it we could we could say hey here just put different through our committee obviously these are not gospel um this is just what the committee feels is good start anyone in monre can go testify they could even testify for L they would but um that's yeah please don't do that um but please uh you know obviously participation is good but I think authentic and meaningful participation I gotta be honest with you when I went to tr and I heard it was like I mean I would have been bored if I was on the other side of that day everyone said the same thing we need money you're screwing kids you can't do this everyone for the same thing you know and they're

012not not like right from the perspective but I think we need to do a little bit different and if you look at the talking points that at the top of the list you can see that right out of the gate there are some things that make Monroe unique um so that's kind of what a uh what our starting point would be um and then uh if we if we take a look at that we pause maybe in about 20 25 minutes re Dean and also in your packet um many of you have submitted feedback uh digitally what I did was I compiled all that into your packets um and then what we could try to do is as we sitting there um and I can kind of FO around I'll try to take any of

013the feedback that has been provided you guys want to look that over when we reconvene um and maybe about 20 of or quarter of we can talk about the letter again um and then try to put this to bed as well that don't you think U Mr moral or Dr Layman too that the letter could be handed in once we finally put the uh draft on it because it's going to include everything that we want so I mean if we get down to the letter and anybody's going to go to Trenton or what's the other place Trenton Somerville um I put in to go to Trenton next week so if we can't get up to talk if we have the letter that we want to go out to our legislators you know we can run

014up and just hand it to them after it's finalized if I if I can I I don't think that's I think that St I can work my question I guess where we want to focus with this because I feel like this hearing is different than a budget testimony um for this I feel and you know sort of talk goes into when we're going into our groups to do those talking points where we should focus right because they're looking to revise the entire formula so like when we went down it was you know how is Monroe affected is there a way you can give our district more funding but I feel like for this while we certainly want to to address that in some ways it's more about here is how the school funding formula is

015flawed and we can list the ways that Monroe is affected but it really like the more that we have in common with other districts that are having problem like I mean obviously we know as two districts social districts that have lost funding over the last you know seven years are you know different than we are um but I just I feel like that might be where we want to to focus for for this specific hearing as opposed to like the ones that are in March that are for the budget yeah I think like what you were just saying it's important to focus on what makes Monroe unique with regard to the funding formula um that was definitely the stance that I was going to take in going to the hearing is not talking about the

016formula and what it's going to look like you know with the proposed revisions but what the funding formula has looked like here in monre and impact on us and what we would hope could be fixed so that it doesn't have the kind of negative impact that it's had on us so I think that's Miss Al do we know if anyone else or another District does not receive Equalization Aid or are we the only one there are others it's not it's not a lot I would say there's probably about hundred in within the states I I can pull it up um I know with in like our County I think there's there's two or three I gave you our County County that are by the shore that are you know are smaller and so there's more

017of those in those counties um and do they have a large senior population too is that the fact I mean without like I for me I don't know for sure I know that we are unless things have changed within the you know demographics in the last 10 years certainly the highest and I think that's the primary focal point of this is what you know the major flaw in it because we are penalized not because we have like we we love the fact I love the fact that we have you know my parents in here like so I certainly am not suggesting that you know we are penalized because we have senior citizens living with us but because the formula negatively penalizes us um which I can actually pull up the reason for it it's because

018the income that they receive is um that seniors receive we are then um that's used to calculate the equalization Aid cost so that's why we don't get anything I think we need to explain that because that's if we can be very specific and explain that piece I think that would be helpful because you don't want to just come out and say it's the seniors you know because of the no because of the formula and the senior part of the formula blah blah Kate then you explain what you just said because I know Tom's River Berkeley Township probably has a high senior rate also uh I'm just guessing because I know a lot of people go down to whiting and that area so that's another area that probably has but I think they've only migrated down

019there maybe had a shorehouse and you know decided to not stay up here and go down to their shorehouse but here these are actual Senior Communities that have been established for years so you have establishment and then may be starting to be established you know I don't know we'd have to check the demographics justly through the the list here if you're I'm looking at all the the um districts that get zero Equalization there's smaller so like lavet bur Seager Shore Regional um Manis Fon bur going up to Middle sex there's that's M Henry Hudson Regional matachin that's small yeah um what about Highland Park rece because they're in Middle sex so we know that there's only the two Well Middle sex is say does does get Equalization well I thought so yeah I question yes

020all this Public Funding data is available on on every every school district's websites and everything so this is I don't know if it's on our website I just I just Googled um New Jersey state Equalization Aid um and it bring brought me to the State website um and I just clicked on 24 25 state aid summaries by school districts and it gives me a list a breakdown of all of the a PDF sheet of all of the districts across the state and the amount of Aid that they receive okay in that case if someone has really tried to put some comparative data analysis on that like when we try to compare mandro Township with the other Township the way our population is getting increased I can see that year on year the number of students

021are getting more and more enroll into the school districts and against that what percentage of kind of funding is getting increased for the school district in compared to the other similar district and that way we can kind of the case study particularly for the town and and that will put us in a strong position to justify one we are looking for that's a good idea but yeah and also isn't free and reduced lunches part of this funding formula or am I wrong not directly not directly it doesn't so it definitely you get funding for for those things it's not regarding like the type I just want to Circle back to your comment by night and then if we want to action we should break yeah we should break up into groups now no data is

022publicly available then I think one can one can make those compar and stuff so Dr Chanley had had had mentioned earlier today that the district will be preparing District administration will be preparing its own written testimony um and my original thought had been to make that that that would be an appropriate place to include a data a data analysis um I I think it would be difficult to uh verbally communicate that but um that's something that I think uh we will consider when assembling our our own um official testimony on behalf of the district Administration and that would be like written testimony you could do more that way yeah and don't you think the other districts that are losing the money are going to do the same thing as what you said if they're going

023before these people they're going to have that written data also saying well you know we didn't either and at least monrell will be back there saying well we didn't either here's our information so yeah and some of the basic parameters are are very well supporting our town like the population increase or number of enrollment for students on year year basis is getting increased major chunk is going with the senior citizens where we have fixed income so right another 50% of the kind of residents they are they are taking care of the kind of common funding with the taxes and all these things some some kind of detailed kind of you know explanations we can we can give it to the authorities and then on what's not in that is the fact that all of our

024program you know we serve we're a whole child District so we serve as all types of Learners not not just speaking about special ed you know when you think about our paths you know we invest just as much into our prevocational training as we do into our technical applications our our computer science and inflationary costs you know in order to maintain I tried to include this in my own statement today the costs forget about operational costs you know we we're at aask with how a sustain curriculum growth because these programs are becoming ex I mean just think about wood shop the price of lumber that doesn't maintain the 2% grow allowable grow right so you know these are other consequences embedded in this reality that when you really want to get into the teaching and

025learning side of it is that keeps me up at night more so than crowded classrooms because you know especially with the trajectory that this District that currently are with our commitment to that type of learning I agree with you in the same context like this the school funding formula also if if it is not getting changed for almost like a 10 years I'm not sure what kind of detailed formula it is all about how they are calculated but I just want to kind of be curious about whether they are they are considering the the inflation and everything into that and they are really giving some impact because of particular you know kind of price increase and and everything well this task force has been put together for this year um and it's been an upand

026cominging task force that they talked about for probably the last five years if I'm right or wrong this is so this is the Department of Education so the school funding Reform Act was passed in 2008 um and that's what hasn't necessarily been completely modified however I think it was in 2017 or 2018 there was a law pass that is known as S2 which sort of modified the formula in terms of districts that were getting less started getting a little bit more Monroe was one of those um and there were districts that were um considered over adequacy um which are a lot of our surrounding districts right South Brunswick East Brunswick so we sought a lot of that um so there have been like slight modifications but not like a complete overhaul of the formula and

027then um in 20202 and then again in 2024 the legisl legislature had passed or not passed they had proposed bills that would create a school funding formula task force none of those have had any movement yet so this is a hearing that's being done through the Department of Education um and so I think that there's sort of like those two sides of it where there's the legislature side of it that will you know potentially pass that that bill um which might give the Department of Education guidelines as to what they are and are not allowed to do and then there's Department of Education um that was probably tasked with creating the actual formula itself I know I just like said a lot of things at once but well but well for yeah and this problem

028with school funding formula has been around for quite a while I was on another District board we had it there too and we fought and fought and fought and we never got the same amount of money so I come here to Monroe and we're still fighting to have you know to be equal with everybody else and give our children the right right amount of money for the best education like Mr moraldo said we run the gamut here with education with wood shop and there's a lot of uh districts around that have stopped wood shop and uh because either the person retired they never replaced it they can't find the teachers and here in Monroe we try very hard to get these things up and stay working so that's why as Mr moral said we need

029what we can so I think we need to break up in groups Mr can I just highlight with this was actually this came from dran last week um in addition to these you had discuss like the cap and and certain things is that so just because we're going to those talking points so it's a broad strategy and I I think this is kind of addresses everything the school funding piece is extremely complicated and there's multiple layers and I think that's why it probably hasn't been addressed is because if you change one thing it hurts somebody over here if you help these people it hurts these people over here um and with S2 being completed I think everyone is looking at the formula because now in their minds it's fully funded we've come up up to

030what that funding formula has us scheduled to get we don't believe it's what we should be getting for the reasons we're going to talk about other districts around us have come down because they were being overfunded for a period of time so we're at this neutral stage right now S2 is fully funded and we are at this kind of neutral place I think from my perspective if we weave in the Monroe specific Unique Piece which is strongly connected to the way they look at income or fixed incomes in the township and and the balance of our population combined with a broad look at giving a district flexibility to adapt to changing economic conditions for instance wood and and our like we deal with people that don't have a 2% cap vendors out of District placements

031Transportation costs Healthcare has a waiver which gives us some flexibility over there I think this is an opportunity to put some things in place in a funding formula and later in the M Unique Piece to it to have a place that gives us flexibility as time changes but also hit the why why didn't we get what we were supposed to get or what we believe we should have gotten because of the core issue we have here which is very unique to us um the equalization need is zero because of the way they look at income in our town um so we need to bring that to their attention but we also need to provide some you know if security is systemically a priority for districts across the way should that be part of a 2%

032cap or should we move that outside the cap and let districts protect their schools separately not regardless of the cost but within a different parameter of a 2% piece because maybe there maybe inevitably our priority of students St safety which is going to stay a priority is going to with with the increased expectations of our community and those that are legally bestowed upon us they it's inevitably going to cut into our ability to deliver deliver teaching and learning um they recognize that with the uh burden of healthcare cost you know who's to say that they wouldn't recognize that with security and some of the other right yeah facility driven another example we're in a labor market that is drastically different than it was 10 or 15 years ago we we have staff that can and

033choose other districts very easily hop around and get make small adjustments and get better pay we don't have a a a reasonable tool to be able to either effectively adjust the way we compensate um because we're operating underneath the 2% cap and one of the biggest pieces that pushes up against that is how much we're allowed to negotiate and how much we have to play with so are there things that we can put in place again that give us flexibility ility to adjust to a labor market that's changing to adjust to expenses that are growing exponentially faster than 2% um and that that is a core piece for us in terms of like I just call it flexibility because there can there certainly could be parameters on that but right now we're strictly we're constrained

034um you know if we keep everything the same in one year there are costs that are exponentially growing we're cutting just naturally shrinking Pro you know things U even if we maintain uh so in in parallel to the Monroe specific stuff that Miss Fabiano highlighted that's what makes us unique that's why we are where we are but I think having some kind of broad Solutions also will help our case and say Hey you know if if we had the ability to kind of slide some things around or you know a little bit more flexibility some other things wouldn't be an issue as well so so how you would you like to break up you want just slice right down the middle here yeah I'd like to see some students over with this side too so

035we can intermingle the uh the youth in with the I think problem yeah yeah we can all divide yep we can all divide up too but I'd like to see some of the students in in this side whoever wants to go with these lovely people to the to the right of me you want to on because we're going to move around the room so so can we stop

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.