001good evening everybody it is Wednesday December 18th 202024 this is the mono Township Board of Education monthly meeting can I ask everybody to please stand for the pledge of allegiance to the flag the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible Justice Miss alen can we have a roll call please yes Miss Alvarez here miss Bora here miss depan here miss Fabiano here Dr PE here Mr pero here miss Ratner here miss Sharma here Mr Tano here Mr Zer we have a quarum in accordance with the provisions of the New Jersey open public meetings law the Monroe Township Board of Education has caused notice of this meeting to be published an electronic notice provided by having the day time in place thereof posted October 25th 2024
002and December 13th 2024 at all schools on the district website home News Tribune cranberry press and filed with the clerk of the municipality okay our next item on the agenda is our close session resolution whereas the senator Byron and Bear open public meetings Act njsa 10 col 4-6 provides that the Monro Township Board of Education May hold an executive session from which the public is excluded to discuss matters that are confidential or are one of the nine subject matters listed in SE excuse me section 12b of the act and whereas that the board hereby declares that its discussion of the following subjects will be made public at a time when the Public's interest in disclosure is greater than any privacy or governmental Interest being protected from disclosure now therefore be it resolved by the monor
003Township Board of Education that the board shall go into executive session to discuss the following items additional items may be determined and announced as needed um pending or anticipated litigation matters covered by attorney client privilege Hib investigation attorney advice on proposed confidential agreements is there a motion I'm sorry hold on Personnel Personnel matter is there a motion to Second all those in favor I will you should return from close session at around 715 and um no formal action will be taken in Clos session we're going to call the meeting back to order the board has returned from executive session and we do have um action to take I have a uh I have something to read um it is recommended that the members of the Monro Township Board of Education approved the previously provided Proposal
004with policy find to provide confidential and attorney client privileged Insurance archaeology services not to exceed $4,900 motion second motion by Mr tufano second by Miss Bora Miss Allen can we have a roll call yes Miss Alvarez yes Miss Bora yes Miss depay yes Mr Piro yes Miss Ratner yes Miss Sharma yes Mr Tano yes Miss Fabiano yes motion passes thank you the next item on our agenda is the approval of minutes um the first is public Board of Education meeting minutes from November 20th motion motion by Mr Tano second by Miss Bora um are there any comments questions any all those in favor I I any extensions recusals okay seeing none um the Clos session meeting minutes from November 20th 2024 motion second uh motion by Miss Boris second by miss tpan any comments all
005those in favor I I any extensions or recusals obstain pertaining to the superintendent goals okay okay the next item on our agenda is our student board members report welcome back thank you so much and good evening everyone thank you for being here uh we'll start off with mil Lake Elementary School's report mil Lake School continues to thrive as a Vibrant Community filled with excitement learning and meaningful contributions December has brought a season of joy and activity living up to all our expectations the month began with a PTO holiday shop held from December 2nd to 4th where students thoughtfully selected gifts for family and friends the third grade student council has been hard at work this month they organized an intergenerational service project spreading kindness and cheer by creating New Year's cards for senior citizens in
006the township these heartfelt cards were distributed to residents of a multi-level Care Community Additionally the student council launched mil Lake's first ever serial Box challenge this exciting initiative is underway with collections continuing through January 31st thank you for your support in making this event a success The Challenge culminates on February 14th with the students and staff setting up a domino challenge throughout mil Lake School as the holidays wind down um milake participated in various themed events and activities including Toys for Tots a holiday song practice and 12 days of holiday fun they're thrilled to end the year with celebration cheer and a strong sense of community finally they will close the month with their annual mil Lake Winter singalong on Friday December 20th featuring a very special guest Olaf mil Lake School continues to shine
007as a place where learning joy and togetherness come together for all and now we're going to be moving on to Woodland Elementary School in celebration of Thanksgiving in the Macy's day parade many of their teachers and students engaged in fun and challenging stem projects some of their classes even designed created and marched in their very own parade the November growth log lottery winners were rewarded with additional recess time with Dr Setta miss Mr Dale and the student Council sponsored fun and exciting holiday spirit days during the month of December the Woodland Mill Lake PTO sponsored holiday shop for their school students had an opportunity to shop for their families and friends in conjunction with this fun holiday Time Event Mrs newom and the fifth grade character crew coordinated gift wrapping students and staff participated in
008Woodland school's annual Deck the Halls door decorating contest this year classroom doors Incorporated the school te theme we grow together a panel of Judges voted on their favorite doors the winner from each grade level will earn a prize of a movie in popcorn we are happy to announce wooden school's 2024 Governor's education educators of the Year Mrs Erica Emmons teacher of the year Mrs Karen Ki educational professional of the year and Mr Matthew Verdun educational support staff of the Year congratulations to all the staff who got awarded next up is Barkley Brook Elementary School Barkley Brook recognized a student from each classroom who consistently embodied their school's great traits which are growth mindset respect empathy acceptance and Trust they held an assembly where the great winners from each grade level were announced and honored one
009of the most wonderful aspects of the assembly was the way in which all the students cheered for and celebrated the great kid winners they were truly excited for their classmates who were nominated which reinforced that all the students are truly great kids they are also so pleased to share the 2024 to 2025 Governor's educator of the Year Award winners for Barkley Brook teacher of the year Mrs Yates grade 2 teacher Educational Services professional Mrs Barry bcba and educational support staff Mrs zeni special education par professional they are so grateful for all that they do for the students at Barkley Brook and are very proud to have them represent the school Barkley Brook School also hosted their annual holiday steam maker night on December 5th they were so excited to welcome over 120 families to the
010event event where they participated in Holiday themed coding and maker activities it was an amazing night for all and a great way to get into the holiday spirit a huge thank you to the teachers who helped run the evening and to the families who joined us for an evening of fun and now we're going to move on to their partner School Brookside Elementary School Brookside held their first family night math night on December 5th we had they had an excellent turnout with over a 100 families attending to complete a variety of math challenges on December 10th they had their Winter concert the students did an incredible job performing and put on an amazing show the Brookside band and chorus will be performing for the entire Brookside student body on Friday December 20th during the school
011day moving on to Oak Tree Elementary School December has been a month filled with holiday cheer at Oak Tree some highlights include their annual 10 days of Oak Tree in which each day is a theme from ugly sweaters to flannel to secret snowman students shopped at their PTA sponsored Hol holiday shop and their polar Express trip where kindergarteners Carol throughout the building with the big guy in their homemade train their holiday gift drive also took place where hundreds of gifts were donated to surprise their families in need and lastly Oak tre's annual door decorating contest occurred and winners will be announced this Friday and now at Applegarth students at Applegarth are wrapping up their classroom spelling bees in preparation for the schoolwide bee which will be held on January 17th Applegarth is also wrapping up
012their annual gift drive to support their school community the PTA sponsored the holiday shop which was held on December 9th and 10th a beautiful winter concert was also performed by Apple's band in chorus on December 11th the principal's book club for Three Times Lucky by Sheila Turnage will be held tomorrow December 19th from 4 to 5 p.m. Samantha farus was awarded teacher of the year at Applegarth Allison kersis was awarded Educational Service professional of the year and Nancy Agy was honored as our as their educational support professional of the year congratulations once again to all of their honores thank you to Applegarth room parents who are recording winter parties over the next 3 days happy winter break from the Apple Guard School next up is monor Township Middle School the first lady of New Jersey
013Mrs Tammy Murphy as well as the New Jersey Commissioner of Education Mr Kevin damer visited the middle school on December 12th their state leaders joined mtms students staff and administration in evaluating the school's history happened here program which is currently being piloted by 42 students under the direction of Mrs Christy vaki teacher of social studies at mtms please join me in congratulating Miss nah schmetterer mpms chorus director who has been named the 2024 to 2025 njmea Master music teacher for New Jersey the middle school also has the following concerts coming up so if you are free to come please feel free to come and support their talented students on January 13th Jazz and percussion concert will be taking place and January 16th the 7th and e8th grade band concert will be taking place lastly the
014seventh grade Winter Dance will be held on February 21st more information to come out for that after the break and now we're moving on to the final School the MRA Township's High School on December 10th unified Winterfest was held which was a wonderful time for all who attended on December 12th the winter chorus concert where mths choir students sang holiday songs and pieces they worked on during class was also held it was an amazing event December 17th was the mts's winter wonderland hosted by the Red Cross Club of the school and included various mths clubs transforming the school into a magical experience there was a frozen Me ingry karaoke and gingerbread house building and so much more lastly this week was Winter Spirit Week at the high school and everyone was looking forward to pajama
015day on Friday thank you thank you very much I I always I think I say this every meeting but this is my favorite part of the meeting is hearing all the updates from all the schools thank you guys very much the next item on our agenda is um presentation we have some awards that we'll be giving out this evening yep so at this time I'd like to invite uh Mr uh Bara down he's our thletic director and uh we will present our student recognitions and athlete recognitions as well as we have some B Ed Foundation grants to uh award as well so if you'd like to join us to hand out the certificate good evening everyone I'm thrilled to be here tonight to recognize several of our student athletes who have achieved conference and state
016honors either individually or as part of a team before we begin I want to take a moment to commend all of our fall student athletes being a student athlete is no small accomplishment requiring them to balance practices games and team commitments alongside with other responsibilities our student athletes dedicate a tremendous amount of time and effort consistently meeting the high expectations set by their coaches we are incredibly proud of their achievements and the way they represent our community both on and off the field when your name is called please come up to be recognized we will begin with boys and girls cross country boys are coached by Nicholas pulo and the girls are coached by Mary howy Steven Barbara GMC All Conference James Yordano GMC All Conference for the boys team uh just a couple extra
017things uh in addition to the conference um Awards the All State and postseason honors were also uh sent out uh Steven Barbara was named to the third Team all group four he was also named the nj.com GMC Player of the Year and individually he achieved uh the GMC Red Division title the GMC title uh was number fourth in central group four 27th overall group four and he was top 25 at the meet of Champions uh posted a 16 minute and 22 3.1 miles which was the best time at me a champions in school history next for girls cross country we have an Raja GMC All Conference and we also have Maya Davis GMC all [Applause] division next slide all right next we have boy soccer coached by head coach Steve McKenzie Christian Tay GMC all
018[Applause] Division and Nate offenberg GMC [Applause] division Aiden ay GMC all Division and All Conference and Christopher Duran DMC all Division and all [Applause] conference for the boy soccer Aiden a was also Nam to the second Team all group 4 and nj.com GMC Player of the Year next team we have is girl soccer coached by Christian Jessup Meredith Arts GMC all [Music] Division and Angelina roacha GMC all [Applause] division next we have Jamie baninda GMC all Division and All Conference Sophia Gartner GMC all Division and all [Applause] conference and missan uru wahan GMC all Division and All Conference additionally Jamie Benda was named to the second Team all group four Sophia Gartner was named to First Team all group 4 second Team all state nj.com GMC Player of the Year and and masan was named
019to the second Team all group four and she will also represent Monroe at Ruckers University on January 12th for the 2025 National girls and women in sports event as a team our girls soccer program this year uh achieved the red we red division champs they were back-to-back GMC Conference champions and this year they were also the njsiaa central group four sectional Champions next up we have girls volleyball coached by coach Victoria STC Sarah Levy GMC all Division and Natalie Grant GMC all Division and all [Applause] conference for gymnastics even though we do not have a gymnastics team we do have uh some gymnasts who compete as independent uh this year we had um Melissa colantino who was our chaperon and our athlete Kesha Gandhi was named to the GMC All Conference at [Applause] large next
020up we have field hockey coached by coach Melissa lad Victoria dusza and Melo GMC All Conference uh di Daniela Rubino GMC all conference and all Division and as a team our team was uh named with the GMC sportsmanship award for the [Applause] GMC next we have our football program coached by head coach Nick Isola Logan Fates National Gold Team first the first team Brandon Macaluso National gold division first team and Logan RoR National gold division first team Anthony cissi National gold division second [Applause] team and kamman ywood National gold division second [Applause] Team all right next we have our cheer leading program our fall sideline team team competed in the GMC performance competition on December 8th for the first time in school history we not only hosted the competition but also won the Red Division
021which is the highest division our team is coached by head coach Kim Lawson and our athletes on the team Meredith Armstrong kly batowski [Applause] McKenzie Casey Ava Citron Juliana Dow Ava F Kobe Fernandez Victoria F [Applause] delizo Isabella grippa Brinley Hoy G Jara llaya Kea Jenna luga Angelina Mayo Daniela Mayo Alysa Puglia Brianna Pres bazooki summer reneo Juliana scooty Leah scooty Addison Shay Christa tramontana Delila updale and Ariana [Applause] Walters lastly we also had our national Signing Day event on November 13th 20124 and we did have five student athletes who were recognized for playing um After High School um we have summer reneo who um will be attending Quinn Pak University for acrobatics and tumbling we have Sophia Garner who will be attending coal Carolina University Meredith Arts will be attending St Francis University for
022Sofer Angelina roacha will be attending McDaniel College and Jamie binda will be attending Lebanon Valley College that concludes this thank you so much and congratulations to all the student athletes and your families [Music] you next we would like to recognize our staff and schools in the awarding of the 2024 2025 Monroe Education Foundation minig grants at this time if the foundation president Mr Ryback would please come up to assist in presenting the [Applause] grants the Monro Education Foundation has been funding districtwide grants for over 25 years through the foundation's grant Awards program this year the foundation is excited to present eight Min grants throughout the district first we have from mro Township High School Bona ganker for a grant titled engineering design and development PTW from Applegarth School radika Patel for a grant titled colonial
023era Mammoth Historical Society from Monro Township High School Linda Chu for a grant titled immersive travel virtual reality experience from Monro Township High School and Middle Middle School David Ratner for a grant titled Master Class featuring Jerry welen from Barkley Brook Diane aren and Sarah crane for a grant titled Barkley book Barkley Brook excuse me land sensory path [Applause] from Brookside School Nancy Dempsey Kimberly bertini and Lisa Zimmer for a grant titled secl character education [Applause] books from Mil Lake School Nicole mascola Christine cassella and Jennifer to for a grant titled sensory pathway and last but not least from Barkley Brook Christine duet for a grant titled the pencil the paper and the first [Applause] grader thank you st thank you and congratulations to all of our award recipients this evening um the next item
024on our agenda is discussion of board goals so last month we had the presentation they were up on the screen um we talked about some edits and revisions the edits and revisions have been shared with the board and so now we're just looking to discuss and approve the goals so that we can put them up on the website so um I'd like to open it up to discussion for the board if anybody has any questions or comments Miss Ratner um just one quick thing and I apologize for not realizing this earlier um just the goal it's goal number four um um just the the sub text um I know someone had come up last month to discuss this would it be possible to I guess I don't think we should have to describe each type
025each part of our population but I don't want to exclude any part of our community either so so just say communities create a network with our communities with like right or create a network throughout our Township I I understand what we were trying to do I also just think that we also want to also network with parents and also people like adults who necessarily don't have children in the district so Dr lemman I know you're looking suggestion for wording adults create a network with throughout our community inclusive of students if if you wanted to highlight students as uh a demographic that often may be overlooked in terms of our communication efforts right that would highlight that but it would be inclusive of the entire community at large whether that's our school Community or our community
026members in small businesses local businesses Etc okay so create a network with create a network throughout our community including students and hold events together but I'll read these all out in entirety once we finish the discussion just to make sure that we're clear so we're agreeing to take out the word active adult yes is that just yeah and make it more GIC any other comments okay so I'll just go through and read each goal um just so it's the public can hear them and then we'll um we can vote to approve to have these posted to our website so goal number one to be fiscally responsible to our taxpayers while maintaining an EXC an excellent quality of Education to accomplish to accomplish this goal we will continue our focus on Alternate Revenue driving initiatives I.E
027the EIT program goal number two to support districtwide use of artificial intelligence AI to enhance personalized learning with educational experiences tailored to individual students needs to accomplish this goal will we we will create and review the district's AI policy and support professional development opportunities for staff goal three to continue to expand our advocacy at the state and Community level for additional funding and legislative changes that benefit our school district District to accomplish this goal the board will work with the community will work with community members through the citizens advisory committee to increase awareness of the current financial status and needs of the district and then lastly goal number four to enhance communication throughout our community by identifying areas where we can improve communication to to accomplish this goal we will identify areas where we can
028improve communication create a network throughout our community including students and hold events to GA input from community members so can I have if there's no questions or comments then can we have a motion to approve second motion by Miss Ratner second by Miss Alvarez um Miss alen can we have a roll call yes Miss Alvarez yes Miss borak yes Miss dep yes Dr peek yes Mr Piro yes Miss Ratner yes Miss Sharma yes Mr Tano yes Mr uh Miss Fabiano yes motion passes great thank you okay so these will be um I will send the edits to Mr marala um and then we'll have these uploaded to our uh District website okay the next item on our agenda is our committee report are there any committees that would like to give a report Miss Bora
029I'll start with the finance committee the finance committee met on December 10th the board members in attendance were myself Mr Piro Miss Ratner who was sitting in for Miss uh Sharma Dr peek uh Mrs Fabiano and the administrators and attendance with Dr Chanley Dr Layman and Miss Allen the attorney office the attorney invoice for the month of September and October for both Bush and porio were reviewed uh next the bill list totaling $ 5,317 th000 was reviewed at the time of the finance committee that was all the billers we had we do have a couple addendums for tonight um next the committee discuss the Township Police Service cost the committee had asked Dr chandley and Miss Allen to present a report that detailed the money that Mt booe had paid to the township for the
030police services they had provide provided for district events like games Boe meetings School graduation ceremonies Etc the report showed that we paid $ 26,28 in the school year 2223 to the township of police services then in the last school year 2324 we paid 36,2 $58 for the police services uh in the last 3 months we have paid $8,155 an hour in 2022 $128 an hour in 2023 and currently in 2024 we have been paying $132 per hour in comparison North Brunswick pays $55 an hour it's $62 per hour with a car Edison pays dollar uh $58.99 per hour and East Brunswick Which is closest to us right now pays $110 per hour the difference between these hourly rates was a cause of concern but the administration stated that this was a conversation to have with
031the town as the administration had no control over it Dr Chanley and the board president Mrs Fabiano have been trying to set up a meeting with the mayor and would include this in their conversation when that happens the other thing that can be controlled by the administration is to refine the process and guidelines to determine the need for police presence Dr chandley assured the committee that she has been in conversation uh with the director of security Mr salby and the Athletics director Mr barandica to ensure we ask for police presence when appropriate and ensure that we only ask for as many officers as absolutely needed uh it is imperative that the public understand that the goal of this board is to optimize our spend on on this line item but never at the cost of
032compromising the safety of our students and staff this that is and will always be Paramount it is also important to mention that this police presence is always in in addition to our armed security staff that is always present for all district events um Dr Chanley concluded uh the finance committee meeting by sharing that the budget defense rounds with all building heads and department heads had been concluded and the administration um uh is not just looking at dollars but also at pennies as they work through the school budget for the year 2025 26 Dr Chanley specifically shared that she was working closely with the new direct new head of Transportation Miss morr to review the current budget the schedule and Route maps to find opportunities for optimization she assured that through all of the defense and
033optimization rounds they ensured that our students are never at a loss and our programs contined to be over adequate and that concludes the finance committee report thank you does anybody have any questions or comments for Miss Bora okay do you want to do curriculum sure the curriculum uh co-curricular Athletics and pupil Personnel committee met on December 10th the committee met only for an hour this month but that but had a very exciting agenda the first item on the agenda was a curriculum update presented by the science and social studies supervisor M trust she shared the details of the forensic course which is an elective available to students in grades 9 through 12 this course used to be offered as a half-yearly course till last year and was transitioned to a full year elective for the
034school year which prompted the course update uh Mr morala and Mr Schneider then presented six proposed course addition to our program of studies five of which will be available in upcoming school year 2526 and one will be available in 2627 school year uh the first two courses fell under the computer science career Readiness life literacies and key skills uh the first one was computer science Essentials it would be offered from Grade 9 through 12 12 and is an excellent entry point into computer science curriculum in the high school um the students would learn visual block based programming and then transition onto text based programming like Python and if they desire to take their computer education further this class would provide the perfect foundation for uh computer science principles and computer science a which are higher
035rigor programming classes the second course um was cyber security which would be offered from grades 10 through 12 uh prerequisite for this would be computer science Essentials regular or AP and AP comia this course would introduce tools and concepts of cyber security and help create solutions that allow people to share Computing resources while protecting privacy students will use Virtual labs to discover key Concepts and raise their knowledge and commitment to ethical Computing behavior um this course would be a great way for our students to get a feel of a very popular undergrad major in computer science before they head out to college to actually take it uh the next course was in video uh and media production broadcasting and career Readiness uh life literacies and key skills Mr morala shared that the idea for a
036course called mths Morning Show which would be offered from grades 9 through 12 this is in addition to video uh media production 1 2 and three that are currently being offered in mths some of these students help us during the board meetings um every every time these courses will go through rewrites or updated um in or will be updated in summer of 20 25 with the introduction of this new course uh this new course will help students immerse themselves in the dynamic world of broadcast multimedia production by contributing to a periodic morning announcement show intended for the school Community uh this course is designed for all levels of content creators and will provide an opportunity for students to express themselves and inform entertain the community and Gain real world experiences in media production uh then
037Mr Schneider presented two courses in fine and Performing Arts that will be part of program of studies in 2025 uh it was the first one was digital photography 3 which allows for a progression in this discipline for students in grade 11 and 12 that have taken digital photography too and are looking to learn more and have teacher recommend and would need teacher recommendation to take this course this level of digital photography will allow students an advanced professional level exploration of digital for photography and editing and it'll give them the opportunity to do college level projects and professional quality work next course was honors piano 3 which through communed deliberation and Dr hiin suggestion would be called honors piano the prerequisite for this course would be piano 2 or an audition or teacher recommendation uh this
038course will focus on more advanced concepts of Music Theory and how they apply key uh they apply that to keyboarding students will perform a variety of repertoire from classical to J Jazz and will have two solo piano recital the last addtion to the program of studies for the for the school year 2627 is in FID pH physical education this is a progression course called strength and conditioning three given that sophomores have been allowed to take this course starting this year they will need a third year of this if they continue to do this through senior year and so the Genesis of this course the prerequisite would be strength and conditioning two with a grade of 85 or higher uh next on the agenda uh that night was a very detailed presentation on the district AVID
039program that was given by Dr crell and Dr saski uh Monro adopted Avid in 2009 and the committee learned all about the 15-year history progression and accomplishment of this program and the impact on the lives of students and teachers from this program um I would encourage community members to watch the video recording for this to learn more today Avid is a districtwide effort with mths mtms and one of the three upper elementary schools Woodling having adopted the program the administration shared their goal of including the other two elementary schools soon and also putting processes in place that would allow every District student and not just the selected cohorts to benefit from the Avid methodologies um and that concludes the very lengthy curriculum Med update thank you thank you Miss Bor does anybody have any questions
040or comments for Miss Bora okay seeing none then we're going to go to our next committee report Mr Pay hey thank you very much the citizens advisory committee meeting was on Tuesday December 10th presid were myself Dr Chanley Dr Layman Mr moraldo M Fabiano Mrs Alvarez and M Ratner Mr moraldo spoke about the communications flow in the district and the District overview to all that were present he spoke about the F pitfalls I.E gaps in messaging in the district and I don't think the gaps are with the parents but maybe with outside community and maybe adult active communities where Sometimes some of information doesn't get to the um to the seniors the Jamesburg representative we have one person from Jamesburg who is onor committee um had some comments and spoke about her concerns with the
041Jamesburg students coming to Monroe from 8th to 9th uh Dr Chanley spoke about the good transition program we have with the students from 8th to 9th we bring them up here we um show them around to the school um Dr Layman and it's pretty decent she had some other concerns and Dr Chanley said that she would handle the issues for the sake of an easier transition from the Jamesburg students to our high school the meeting was ended at 7:30 the committee broke off into small groups and were presented the letter from the um legislative action Community engagement committee that we want to send to our legislators and we actually U Mr morala sent it to all the community members where they can report back any comments or the concerns that they had and maybe any
042kind of ideas that they had to bring this letter to fruition for all of us from all different genres in the town to send one to our um uh to the legislators oh my God that went right out of my head thank you and it's right here uh we gave them an assignment to look over the letter and I know from looking at the emails that some of them have reported back to Mr moraldo already uh the meeting with is ended at 8:00 p.m. the next meeting is uh January 7th 2025 7 to 8 in the high school um media center and thank you that's my report for this evening thank you Mr P does anybody have any questions or comments for Mr P yep real quick uh the one of the agenda items for
043next month's meeting will be to take all the feedback that we're receiving and then work through it as a committee to edit and and tweak the letter were you going to say the same thing yes simar with um I also just wanted to comment and I don't know ask the opinion of other board members one thing that we've discussed is having one form letter versus having a a template like multiple templates based on the person who is submitting the letter um so there you know there's obviously pros and cons because obviously if you're you know a parent of a student in the district you may have different reasons for wanting things if if you are you're not a parent or if you are a student or things like that so I was just curious I
044guess if and you feel we don't have to discuss it here and now but if you have input as to whether it should be this one form letter which you know we've sort of heard isn't necessarily the most productive way of getting things done because they see the same thing over over again or having more personalized templates which could then possibly become confusing I just wanted to bring that up so that was and that's one of the things that uh this committee was asked to do when they're reading the the letter is from their lens what does it look like and does it make sense to them from their perspective in the community when we bring them back next month one of the outcomes potentially could be a letter addressing these issues more appropriate to
045come from these people and a letter addressing those issues is more appropriate come from the from you know this other group so I think it's still up in the air um the form letter is I think a simple quick you know plop your name in get it out quickly but now you know maybe the feedback will be let's make it more personalized um and you know something coming with specific numbers for construction and things that might be an appropriate letter for some people whereas someone else might say we just need a quick you know this is our position this is what we're looking for you know representing our our demographic subgroup thank you Miss Bora just my opinion is that that's a great suggestion given the unique demographic of our town where we do know
046that 50% of our town is notay parents of children they may be grandparents but they're not parents of children in the school district so at the very least I think we could come up with two version which is and call it parent and not parent version um programmatically it would still be plug andplay it would still be clicking on that one link but they would probably relate more to that content and and we have a team of people that could contribute to that content so I think it's a great idea to have two versions given how our town is right now it it it just it it just makes all the sense in my head right now yeah I so and truthfully we don't know how many versions we might have I agree with your
047two versions but we have such a variety of people on this committee we don't know where they're going to come from so I think when we have our next meeting we we could narrow it down to two we could we could mention it to them um from the feedback we might have to so I think we have to wait until they all come back and have had a chance to look at the letter and give their feedback already so I mean we'll keep that in mind thank you anybody else okay um Miss Alvarez you want to do your committee okay the policy committee met on Tuesday October 10th present at the meeting were Dr Chanley Dr Layman Dr Higgins from the high school Dr Celli Mrs Fabiano Dr peek Mr ziker and Mrs Ratner there
048were two items on the agenda for discussion regul 5440 honoring pupil achievement was brought forth to the committee current practice at the high school which has been in place for at least 10 years I don't remember the exact date that couldn't recall it when I was writing this is at a grade of 90 or above is needed for a student to be eligible for principal's list however it is written in the regulation that a grade of 85 or better in honors courses will also qualify for principal's list the administration is recommending that the board align this regulation with current practices while reviewing this regulation the committee found additional inconsistencies with the language and the regulation will be Revisited again at the January meeting and the second item on the agenda was a discussion on policy
0492365 on the acceptable use of generative artificial intelligence the administration wanted to begin the process of creating a policy which will be used used as a framework to address Ai and its appropri appropriate use in the classroom this is a working collaborative document and it will be Revisited Again by the committee in January as a result there are no policies on today's agenda for first read any questions Miss Bora I I actually would like to discuss this a little so but I want to start by commending Dr lman on the work on the AI policy cuz I think we made great progress really quickly from the template that you guys had it it looks like a great start and and we can continue working on it the thing that I would like to discuss is
050policy 5 the regulation 5440 um and um I just to let all the board members know I've been in discussion about this since June of this year uh it was brought to uh my attention by a Community member a parent whose child according to the policy should have made the principal list but you know when they approach this High School administration the administration said our process is that we don't give principal L unless it's 90 the parent cited the policy and then you know included me on that email showing this is the policy but this is not being done so that's when I started conversation with the administration and we found out that maybe at some point there was a policy that aligned with the school processes and at some point that policy changed so
051our current policy on our website says that for honors and AP students 85 and over should call qualify them in the principal's list while if you have a regular rigor Coast it it would be 90 and over um logically that makes sense in my hand and to the parents besides that one parent I've had a conversations with plenty of parents in the last few months I had asked to Administration to bring this to curriculum for discussion because the current policy states that the process is wrong and we cannot have that the policies and processes have to be aligned so for that parent the parent was right the parent is in a policy that's active on our website which is not aligned to the process in the high school and I was hoping that we could
052have a discussion with the High School Administration in curriculum as to why we think that's the right way to do it and then make them changes to the policy I believe we've been straight to policy and so I'm using this moment here to share with the rest of the board that in my opinion um when a child is taking a higher rigor course and our class ranks and I know that the argument I've heard is that the class ranks only happen in senior year but they use weighted averages for that um the the whole goal of principles list in class rank is pretty similar trying to say that you are you achieving that level of excellence in what you're doing and so there is a differentiation in honors and higher rigor courses and regular courses
053and that differentiation seems reasonable so I would as a board member agree with the current policy on our website and I would like a discussion with the administration as to why because I did watch the policy committee meeting and I did not see a reasoning except that's how we've always done it and that's how I know other principles in the areas do it I went on to a multiple schools policies and honestly our policy document is very detailed and I know it has a lot of things that need to be cleaned up other schools don't have it like that so their policy doesn't state it our policy states it so we are technically wrong right now so other schools are doing it because they don't have regulations that say that it needs to be done
054otherwise so at this point I would argue for the community and say if our policy says the principal list should be awarded to students who have 85 or higher in honors we should honor that and this should be a discussion for the curriculum committee and then the policy should change based on the reasoning we you know we do things because we've been doing it for so long a certain way but that status quo is what we tend to question all the time and I'm questioning that status quo that this principles list should take into account honors and AP level courses and they should be able to make the principal list the way we give them weighted averages for everything they should get that that you know benefit in the principal list as well uh Miss
055rner goe okay um so you know I definitely think it warrants more discussion I know Dr Chanley has said she was going to reach out to the the administrators at all the different levels because you know I also noticed we had said like there were multiple inconsistencies one thing it mentions is pupils in grades 5 to8 must achieve an overall average of 85% in all the courses taken um in order to get um honorable and for principes um which to me um it says only one course may have a grade in 75 79% range I don't believe that's what I've seen um so my thought is if this is going to become a discussion at curriculum I would also include administrators from the lower levels as well who also have these recognitions just to make
056sure that that discussion whether we change it to reflect what we're doing or we change you know or we change our policy um I you know what I'm saying I think we have to make sure we have that discussion from you know fifth grade end up I definitely the conversation is definitely not over um I think what happened with the the discussion of this policy is it kind of opened the book up a little bit and we went through and we're like okay like this definitely needs to be looked at in its entirety um so definitely it'll be discussed again I'm sure in January so would this be a policy discussion or would this be a curriculum discussion um Dr Dr Le did you want to chime in so we can certainly bring it to
057to curriculum I think it warrants a discussion there uh just a few points of clarification and then kind of a an update as to the reality of when the discussion will probably happen uh it speaks to honors not AP and I think that's one of the issues we have the current policy what happened was the practice in 2008 was uh 8590 which is what is the current policy the policy was there was a revision made to the policy in 2008 all of the program of studies prior inclusive of 2008 included the 8590 starting in 2009 the program of studies was updated so what we've determined is the changes from the 2008 curriculum or policy meeting wherever it was done wasn't translated into the document that was adopted in 2008 so that's why there's the high
058school is operating on what the changes were in the meeting the document that was approved in 2008 wasn't up so that's where the discrepancy originated and that's why it wasn't actually even noticed by anyone because it was a done deal and sence delivered in 2008 2009 so that's the origin of the discrepancy um in terms of the reality of when we can all talk about this our next committee meetings we get back from break on Thursday we have a committee agenda item committee uh agendas are created that Friday so we've already pushed out this to our administrative team to review but in reality I don't think we're going to have have that finalized document two days from now essentially um so I think a realistic discussion is I think a realistic discussion will be February
059yeah and uh you know regarding AI I know Mr Weiss is reviewing the policy as well from his legal perspective um we have subgroups that are continuously working on that so I think both of these discussions um specifically that uh student recognition one uh is probably a topic for the February policy meeting just in terms of the short timing we pushed it out to the the administrative team uh to review and I know they're doing that the elementaries they weet they meet almost weekly as a as a cohort and they do it on Zoom so they this was one of their agenda topics um but we'd like all that information to be pulled together and realistically having it done the Friday after we get back a final draft is probably not realistic so just for
060expectation purposes I think this is a f a February agenda item that's realistic but I do have a a comment Dr Layman uh one of my uh issues with this was the parent was not hearing back often knowing the parent is in the right and we are doing our investigation I feel I feel like it it would be uh and given that we're probably not discussing this till February maybe not even changing it till March uh if there there are a lot of parents that are concerned about this I don't know if that can if anybody has approached the administration about it maybe a letter can go out to them that we are in Pro in discussion with the bo of v on these policies and so this is on hold hold for now because
061there are some parents who haven't heard back yet and I did you know yep yes okay thank you just really quick dual enrollment courses just because I know we've been adding these um are those considered as honors or AP courses and with the dual enrollment status doesn't Define them as either AP or honors we take our existing courses and we share them with the university and based on their screening process that includes the qualifications of the instructor they determine the dual enrollment piece so it doesn't whether their honors or AP is not related to most of them tend to be an AP course or an honors course more often than not um but that's not the defining Factor all right thank you else Mr Pay yeah um the delegate assembly regarding resolutions was held on
062December hold on we're still this was still the curriculum this is the curriculum sorry policy discussion yep we're not another board business so any other questions on policy okay so then personel the Personnel committee met on Tuesday December 10th present at the meeting were Dr Chanley Dr Layman Mrs Fabiano Mr Pio and Mrs depan the administration continues to work diligently to fill vacancies and there are seven new certificated teachers for approval on tonight's agenda additionally the superintendent is recommending two individuals for administrative position the first recommendation will fill a vice principal vacancy at the middle school due to retirement and the second is a recommendation for the newly created position of director of School counseling and student support services this concludes my report any questions for Miss Alvarez okay seeing none then we were going
063to move on to our public forum for agenda items only any members of the public wishing to speak you have four minutes to do so please state your name and municipality for the record good evening Township uh I have two comments uh and I think they relate to your agenda tonight because of the discussion you've already had uh at your last meeting there was a gentleman that was concerned about attention no I think it's I think it's on it's on it's on I think John M I think it's on yeah yes yeah we're good thank you uh there was a gentleman that spoke about uh how much attention members of the board were giving to communicating with the uh senior citizens mhm of the township I am a senior citizen of the township I I've
064been a citizen of Monroe Township since 1969 uh but uh I don't think this gentleman really understood the percentage of the population that are senior citizens I don't think he took into account the fact that we contribute heavily financially to the support of the school systems uh in my community my adult community Regency we have 1,274 homes the average amount of taxes on that those homes this is an average is around 11 to 12,000 a year over 50% of that goes to support of the schools so I did a little quick arithmetic and estimated that over seven somewhere between 7 and 8 million dollar comes from Regency to support the school system that's one point the other point is just because we don't have anything to personally gain from the school system as citizens of
065this country we believe in how important education is and therefore we will support the schools if we feel those schools are doing a good job it is vital that this board enhanced their Communications to the adult communities so that they have a better understanding of what you're attempting to do for the students who are the future citizens the future doctors the future attorneys the future Engineers the future scientists the future teachers I I just believe that that needs some some comment on uh the other point uh just came to mind as I was listing to your discussion about Ai and I don't know if any of you saw the 60 Minutes presentation this past Sunday but they were talking about Ai and how a high school student oh yes we did so coincidentally I did
066just talk about this we did just speak about this okay all right so so then you're you're aware of of of my concern there my question is do we have a policy that somehow deals with the student use of school issued technology because all of our students have laptops if a student is sitting at home or they're on the weekend and they harass another student using the school's laptop do we have a policy that deals with that issue if not then I strongly encourage you to look into establishing such a policy because as you move toward AI kids are very creative they're they're young they do stupid things but there are other kids that are affected by it that can affect them for the rest of their lives that could even possibly lead them to
067commit suicide so it is vital that we have some kind of regul students um Dr Dr did you just want to comment on that sure so we do we have an acceptable use of Technology policy but uh situation any situation involving student Behavior then would clearly go under the code of conduct um and there's multiple I would say there's an overlapping availability for us to address situations like that that are both policy related as well as code of conduct related lap yeah and it doesn't matter if it's a school laptop or their own laptop but there would be consequences in place thank you any other members of the public wishing to speak George gunkelman 5 Kelly Court Monro um I received some information um online um about grants that were given out in Middle sex
068County uh totaling 12 over $122 million um Carterette received 5.8 Mr gunman is this an agenda item uh if you look at the administrator's report there's several Grant uh items in there and this is what I'm talking about if you want I can wait till the end no it's fine I'll do it now anyway the basically there are four different communities in Middle sex County that received grant money uh apparently from the county or the state [Music] and I don't know whose job it is to track these uh or how we miss them these grants were for preschool um education yes and it's one of our deficiencies in Monroe uh that's often talked about here and I don't when I received that I thought okay we obviously we missed it we didn't get anything I
069don't know if we applied or were been informed that there was an opportunity to apply or if we had something prepared for such an application I don't know what the requirements were uh the the information I got was just that it was awarded uh how the what the process was to to getting that award I don't know but it was it would be significant help I mean um Carteret got 5.8 million Dunellen got 3 3 and2 million bis sadway two 2 and A4 you know um pretty soon you're talking about real money and it's real money is always an issue here so um I asked the same question at the council meeting that I just bailed out of and no one addressed it but they will uh when I see them next but um somewhere
070in there we missed an opportunity and and let's I not miss I wish that this was an opportunity that we could have taken advantage of Mr Gan believe believe you me everybody here is sitting at this table would have loved to have received some of this money um unfortunately we don't qualify um we can't we can't apply for these because we don't have kindergarten um and we full day kindergarten excuse me full day kindergarten and so we when our legislators were here in July we had asked if we could apply for these grants to use them to apply towards full day kindergarten if they could change somehow change some verbiage or something so that we could at least apply for these um and we can't so it's exclusively preschool it's exclusively preschool because we don't
071have full kindergarten full day kindergarten first have school yep we have don't quite understand the logic of that but I'm not in adist yeah we we definitely wish that we could but we can't we can't apply for these we're trying we're we we talk for fulling yeah it has been a discussion um it's part of our 5year strategic plan and bringing in full day kindergarten um but unfortunately we can't apply for these grants thank you no problem any other members of the public wishing to speak good evening Christy scurby um mon Ro Township I just wanted to comment on the policy committee I watched it the evening that it was broadcast and the thing that caught my attention was the high school is not following the policy the number one thing that the board of
072education does is set policy it doesn't matter if a school or an Administration or parents don't like that policy you can't just change procedure and and the information that was given by Dr Higgins that perhaps the board made a mistake back in 2006 really sat with me because in 10 15 20 years I don't want some other administrator to say that policies we set when I was on the board was just a mistake I have not been able to find the minutes from that meeting I didn't find a recording of any such meeting where that policy was changed I don't know Dr Layman maybe if you have that information but the policy is the policy and the policy is the policy because probably back in 2006 when they looked at how they wait a honors
073course you get eight additional points and it's not during graduation year that you receive those eight points that course is weighted when you take it so if you take it in freshman year that grade is weighted eight points it doesn't become important until you're app applying for college when your class rank is being calculated but those grades are earned when they're taken and that eight points you add 855 + 8 you're over 90 many times parents have come to me and voice their displeasure that at the high school when kids are taking honors naap courses the teachers start off the Year by telling the students I don't give 90s there is a culture at our high school that is is not pro student I've said it when I was running for the board I said
074it the three years I sat on the board and I continue to say it the culture has to change we need to be a district that is for the children this is an Accolade this is not something that is Earth shattering it's not something that's going to change the course of their life it is an accolate showing their achievement in that type of a course it's an honors course it's weighted by eight points eight points if you have an 85 is over the 90 I don't know why we would continue to not honor our students for their achievement in these courses and honestly it really stunned me sitting there hearing that the procedure there that's not their procedure so you should change the policy I'm sorry if you break the law do you go and
075say well I don't I don't believe in that law so change the law because it shouldn't be the law no this is your policy the policy drives everything in this district and they're not following the policy and shame on the high school how many students should have received the principal's list over the course of all of those years that didn't those students deserve that Accolade the board of education at that time the superintendent at that time the principal at that time all made that policy if it was wrong and you feel it was wrong then you need to change it but until that time that is your policy and you have to follow that until you change it and if you're not changing it until February March April those students that met the requirements of
076that policy should get that Accolade on their report card not doing so is doing Injustice to the student honestly and you're supposed to be here to support the students and honor their success and that's what you should be doing thank you um just for the members of the board um to the extent that the board wishes to suspend anyone or part of its policies the board can do so by way of a vote so we could we would have there would have to be a motion to suspend the portion of the policy to until further review if that if that's what the that's what the board wanted to do missano for clarification then would we not be recognizing students because we wouldn't have a policy to do so or would it just I like I
077I just I feel I don't want to do this on a whim right yeah I don't want to penalize the students for not for get my interpretation of doing something like that would be that we're siding with the administration and not with the students if you want to change the suspend a part of the policy because the process being follow follow is wrong I I I would that would might be my interpretation I'm not necessarily suggesting it I'm just saying to the board that to the extent that the board feels that action should be taken now as opposed to waiting uh the board has the ability to do it I'm not saying it's a recommendation because that's not really a legal issue yeah thank you Mr Jano well the only action that should be taken
078is that the administration should be following our policy that's the only action that should be taken and that should be enforced by us Som I do want to add that I um during the policy meeting I did ask about what happens to those students that you know want to challenge this and um Dr Higgins did say that there is an appeal process to contact the administration and and I'm personally you know I I witnessed an appeal process that was just stuck that there was no response and so I do not support that a process is being followed okay right now and I I think we can can fix that it's been brought up now that we've had a discussion um and I know we can't you know these things take meetings and processes to be
079followed but till then we follow the policy is the thing that should be done till then the policy needs to be followed when the policy changes through board action then the new process or new policy can be followed if that's the way shouldn't the superintendent ensure that the administrators are following the policy yeah I think and yes and I think what came out of that policy discussion is it's actually it's not just the high school it's the middle school it's the elementary school that it is across the district so it's it's we have discovered in discussing this policy that it is not just a high school thing um that there is language across the policy that affects the entire District right one of the things that we realized was that this was last modified before
080the sixth grade moved to the middle school so there's you know I'm glad that you know as much as you never want problems to occur we have an eye on it now we can fix what needs to be fixed but the reality is there's a lot of stuff in here that has to get changed because you know there's no sixth grade at the elementary school anymore so they're going to be reviewed differently it definitely was it was definitely a policy that needed to be brought up and discussed I would I would like to you know share that this only being discussed because the parent complained so somebody did complain and that's why this came up but it shouldn't even be a complaint if that's the policy then the ad the follow exactly that but I
081think that comes from the superintendent or assistant superintendent to the administration to ensure that the policy is being followed we set the policy but I believe it's they're the on who make sure that it's followed any other members of the public wishing to speak okay seeing them we're going to close the public forum and move on to our assistant superintendent report so I'm going to combine both assistant soup and superintendent report uh Dr Chanley was unavailable tonight she is ill U we wish her well uh so I'm with that said I will run through a brief assistant superintendent report and then go right into the superintend report uh a few highlights from tonight I'd like to congratulate those student athletes who participated in the fall season and who were recognized tonight also congratulations to our
082coaches uh all of our Sports had a really strong uh fall season and we look forward to our winter season additionally I want to thank the monored foundation for the Grants awarded tonight I look forward to seeing the implementation of those grants this school year uh on the agenda for approval is the acceptance of the money that would fund those grants uh this year the total is uh just over $14,000 so thank you very much monored Foundation uh we're in the middle of our Winter concert series throughout the district school performances have been taking place the past couple of weeks um we have also have performances that have been taking place out in the community uh the concert series continues after winter break um and this was highlighted by our student uh one of our
083student board Bo reports but a big congratulations to Miss Nina schmeer the Middle School chorus director who's been named the 2425 njmea Master music teacher for New Jersey she will be uh she was nominated for this prestigious award and W uh was observed by a committee of retired Educators from around the state she'll be honored and receive her plaque at the 2025 njmea state conference this coming February in Atlantic City with hundreds of New Jersey music educators and attendance so congrat conratulations to Nina and then finally I just want to wish everyone a very safe uh winter break a Merry Christmas a happy Hanukkah and a healthy New Year and with that said I'll move through the superintendent's report so it's recommended that the board approve the attached Personnel items a through W this is
084the 10 member vote second question oh is there are there any questions or comments I have a comment please um I I would like to uh um um just mentioned that it it's with deep sadness that I see the resignation of Dr Miron the teacher of uh Latin in the high school he did wonders with our Latin program and he will be missed uh and it I would like to commend the administration for not skipping a bit beat with this we're bringing back Miss Hoffman who used to be our Latin teacher uh she's really loved in the high school so you know Mr meon will be here till the holiday as Miss Hoffman starts that's just the especially when it comes to well language teachers this is a feat in itself so I want to
085commend the administration for doing them both in the same agenda thank you any other questions or comments um there was a motion by Mr tufano and second by Mr Pay so can we have a roll call please yes Miss Alvarez yes Miss Bora yes Miss depay yes Dr pek yes Mr pero yes m rner yes Miss Sharma yes Mr Tano yes Miss Fabiano yes motion passes personal items X through Au it's a recommendation of the superintendent that the board approve those items this is under the nine member vote motion second motion by Mr Tano second by Miss Ratner are there any questions or comments okay can we have a roll call please yes Miss Alvarez yes Miss Bora yes M depan yes Mr yes M rner yes we on letter Au for Miss liscow okay
086um Miss Sharma yes Mr Tano yes Miss Fabiano yes motion passes so this is also nine member Personnel so this is the one you abstained on oh so the assistant superintendent recommends that the board approve letter Au under the nine member vote motion motion second second by motion by Miss Alvarez second by Miss Bora so can we have a roll call for just item Au questions discussion questions discussion sorry no okay now can we have a roll call please yes Miss Alvarez yes Miss Bor yes M dep yes Mr pero yes Miss Ratner I'll obain again miss Sharma yes Mr Tano yes Miss Fabiano yes motion passes board action 10 member vote it's recommended that the board approve attached board action items a through K motion second motion by Mr tufano second by Miss depay
087are there any questions or comments okay can we have a roll call yes Miss Alvarez yes Miss Bora yes Mr Pay yes Dr pep yes Mr pero yes M Ratner uh yes reuse on the professional development for Dr Chanley um I think the same thing is listed there twice but for anything pertaining to her Miss Sharma yes Mr Tiano yes Miss Fabiano yes motion passes and that concludes the superintendent's report did we do l through Q the nine member nine m board action board action nine M there we go so the superintendent recommends the board approved attached items l through Q motion second motion by Mr tufano second by miss depay any questions or comments okay roll call please Miss Alvarez yes Miss Bora yes Miss depe yes Mr pero yes Miss Ratner uh yes
088ruse on letter Q Miss Sharman yes Mr Tano yes Miss Fabiano yes motion passes okay the next item on our agenda is our business administrators report it is recommended the board action items a through e be approved by consent roll member second motion by Mr Tano second by Miss Ora any questions or comments Miss Bora I do um um Miss alen I did have a on the on the addendums um check 420 for auto body and trucks can you give us some background on this there's $34,000 yes that was um there was a bus accident um and that was covered by Insurance okay so that was the repairs insurance going to come back and and I had one more question so we the Education Service Commission there are you know there are tution invoices but
089then there is an invoice for September and an invoice for October I wanted to confirm those two so this is four check 4028 and check 4029 is that Transportation related for our subcontracting 4028 and um a different it says September and uh October invoice and they're high dollar amounts um I I'm going to say I'm trying to find it it's likely the typically it says under them and this one just says September invoice or October it doesn't say tution but there there are multiple lineup items but it totals to a big amount for both of these checks okay use to many in here you just put in the check number 4028 4028 Miss Bora the check number 428 4028 and 4029 all right um how how much was it um so one was they're both
090over $400,000 okay both the checks are over 400 so it's 4 sorry I don't have the bill list open I just have the number written here but it was one was I think 499 and the other was 428 that sounds like Transportation it sounds like Transportation okay just that that was my question on the bill list and I wanted to uh comment on the Monroe Education Foundation grants I'm so happy to see them come back I know it's been a few years and um the excitement in the district amongst teachers is palpable so um thank you to um the Monro Education Foundation for starting that uh Grant process for the teachers again much appreciated Miss rner um yeah I did actually just have a quick question about the Bist um I saw that there were
091two checks um it's 04112 um for $177,000 and then 0415 wait that's 0 4157 for $113,000 that were for tuition under charges from 2022 2023 yes I just if you can elaborate on that because yeah and we every year um we have to the the private schools um they get audited so their costs get audited so what they charge for tuition um gets adjusted according to what the actual cost ends up being so so actually two years after that year there'll be an adjustment that's why it's always two years back that's fine okay yeah so we have every year we have some type of adjustment that was definitely Transportation I did find itk Sor any other questions or comments okay can we have a roll call please yes um Miss Alvarez yes Miss Bora um
092I want to recuse on check 3778 on the bill list for myself and um yes for everything else okay Mr Pay yes Dr peek yes Mr pero yes Miss Ratner um yes recuse on letter e and then on the bill list I need to recuse on 03 616 for Mr Lorry uh 0 3799 for Dr Chanley 036 609 for Miss Francis and then on the addendum I need to recuse on 0 4326 and 0 4327 for Mr rner 04 313 for Mr Snider 0437 for Mr lurry and 04042 for methel merble okay okay um Miss Sharma yes Mr Tano yes Miss Fabiano yes but recu on Bill list items for meth FES warbell okay motion passes um it is recommended the board action items F through H be approved by consent roll call motion second
093motion by Mr tufano second by Miss Bora are there any questions or comments okay seeing none let's have a roll call please okay Miss Alvarez yes Miss Bora yes Miss dep yes Mr pero yes Miss Ratner yes recuse on letter H okay um Miss Sharma yes Mr Tano yes Miss Fabiano yes motion passes um that concludes my report thank you so the next item on our agenda is uh the board president's report and I'll keep this brief um but just a few things to to update the board on so last Thursday uh Miss Alvarez and I had the pleasure of attending um an event with the commissioner of Education Mr Kevin damer and first lady Tammy Murphy for the history happen here program um I want to commend Miss Baki and our students on uh
094it was just an amazing aming event um I learned a lot about the history of Monroe um even though I went to school here um I didn't realized the role that Monroe played in the Declaration of Independence it was very fascinating listening to them telling their stories um and it was uh just incredible to hear the first lady and the commissioner to commend our students and our program um they were thoroughly impressed so it was just it was anaz it was just it was an amazing morning and I was very thankful that we could be a part of it um to and to witness it it was just it was great um I also want to thank the Education Foundation for their grants this evening it is very exciting that this program has been revitalized
095um and I'm excited to see that our teachers are excited about it and it ultimately benefits our students so thank you to the MEF um also congratulations to all of our student uh award recipients this evening and lastly we are heading into the holidays um as Dr Layman said I want to wish everybody a happy and healthy holiday season um and ready to start up again in 2025 with um New Year and New Beginnings so I wish everybody uh well and thank you for all that you do for our students and our community and I hope you all get to relax and enjoy the holidays so with that um we will go on to Other Board business Mr tuano um I'd like to uh to thank the Resnik family for their generous donation of $2,000
096a piano work $2,000 that was nice of them and I just had a question when you guys uh met with the first lady last week was anything brought up about funding with her so I will say Miss Alvarez and I um did not get spend much time with the first lady she she was very much involved with the students her um her Focus was not about any of the adults in the room she was fully vested in our children and what they were doing so it really wasn't the time for us to do that but I do know that Mr moralde did speak with her a little bit how far in advance did we know that she was coming for that um I only knew th the week before Thursday the week before I'm just
097asking because one of our board goals is to do all we can to advocate for funding and I think we should have had you know maybe few residents meet her there and ask her why we're being ignored yeah that wasn't the purpose of the event we had specific we had Specific Instructions on what the event was supposed to look like no I I get it we have instructions where minions we supposed to be doing what we're supposed to be doing to keep peace with the legislators but Linda Greenstein comes here and we baby her and we have the first lady here the honor of the first lady here and we G it to her and we're keeping everything peaceful and everything quiet but we're not getting any results for years I've been on this board
098for years and every year we say we're going to fight fight fight and when they come here we give them bagels and candy and make them home feel great and we're not getting anything done Mr morala did have an opportunity to speak with the chief of staff yeah her chief of staff and blaming anybody no no no no he he I will say it wasn't a lost opportunity I will say I know that Mr morala did have an opportunity to speak with her chief of staff and did try to work it in there I mean I I don't know about everybody else on this board but I'm I'm personally pretty tired of yeah not getting anything accomplished with the funding it's very it is very frustrating to we and we have reached out several times
099um especially after following up from our meeting and we have gotten no response and then I will send a follow-up email to hopefully get a response and I did get one that just said we'll look into it thank you um but that's about it so one one other thing I'd like to say is the seniors in this community as Mr Po pointed out do contribute a huge amount of money to our schools and I appreciate that myself um in my opinion they they shouldn't have to in their days of retirement they shouldn't have to foot this bill the state should help us foot this huge bill and give the seniors in in their days of retirement a little bit of a tax break bigger tax break than what they get unfortunately in our Township they
100are footing a huge part of the and they shouldn't have to so I would hope that the seniors of this community would would write to their legislators and and fight with us you know or alongside us to get more funding for our students so that you wouldn't have to foot such a huge part of the bill M I don't think it's fair y I agree I didn't want to Mr Miss Ratner so I was actually going to put this as part of my other board business um but it it really ties into what you had just said um because there was a legislative committee meeting this past Saturday and one thing that we've learned is that you know another bill has been introduced it's called s 3917 it was introduced literally just last week I
101guess maybe two weeks ago now December 5th which is the school funding Reform Act because as we know the time is up on what was there but the difference being now because they need to put something else in place because that's ended um they are accepting hearings specifically only for the um um the school funding formula um you know and there's also some changes that they have presented which is different than their normal will create a task force and talk about it I don't even know if I agree with all of these changes I'll just highlight a couple really quick um but one is that instead of a 2% increase um the bill would amend it uh allow a district to increase its tax levy up to the lesser of the district's local share which
102is the amount that the current school funding formula determines a district can afford to raise locally or a 7% increase so instead of 2% it be 7% I'm just sharing you what's there um it's also a gradual phas in of full funding of extraordinary special education aid over five years which I know is something that we've discussed as being you know in concern here it also will reduce the reimbursement for students that are educated in District that are integrated from 40,000 to 35,000 um it establishes a reduction adjustment Aid to Ure that no District loses more than 2% from year to year um and then it finally would address um the transparency surrounding school funding because a lot of districts as you know we've seen ourselves will say we have no clue what to expect
103we get our numbers a week before we have to submit our budget so this would require at least 30 days notice um for those things to happen um however they are having four hearings before they're you know they're moving forward on this um one was actually yes yesterday um and I actually spoke to someone who went who said that there were only five people who had gone to speak at this one now they only put this out the week before um but then the other three are in January and I can send this out to everyone but it's January 8th um from 6:00 to 8:00 p.m. uh in Somerville January 14th 10:00 a.m. to noon um at the department of Ed and Trenton and January 16th down in Camden from 6:00 to 8: our legislative
104Action meeting is on that day um and I I think Transportation was moved to the day before so I think there's still curriculum but I think we need to you know go to the committee that's pres presenting this bill share with them the things that we've discussed this won't be the same people we've talked to because maybe one of our legislators are on there but it's not you know it's other legislators as well and we need to share with them the specific problems that we're having in Monroe you know because of how the formula has been you know very detrimental to Monroe because of our you know higher population of seniors which has you know reduced the amount of Equalization Aid we get all the things that someone who's better with numbers can probably explain
105better than I but you know I think this will be the perfect chance because it's specifically related to school funding to really get people out there to speak about what needs to be changed and and why um yeah if you I'll put the link in my confidential um and so if anybody wants to sign up to testify I think the more people we can get there the better are you suggesting that instead of doing the legislative action committee in in District the committee should go I was I was think that's a brilliant idea the only problem is then curriculum it's that's the only way're meeting we talk about moving curriculum to another day didn't we already move I think we already moved it did we did already move it for January um I don't know
106it would Friday work for curriculum it's on sure last I saw it was on Wednesday at 700 instead of at 5:30 MH um I I just think listen this is exactly what we've been asking for to explain what we need and why and the fact that our committee that's supposed to talk about this literally meet at the same time they're having this is just to me maybe I can have a conversation Dr Layman with you to see if we can foro curriculum in I know we just talked about one big discussion but that's only going to happen in February so maybe if we can I think the more of us that can show up there without having a quorum but I don't know if you're physically not in Monro it's even a quorum mhm that's
107a Mr wise question it's a quorum you can't discuss board business amongst yourselves because it it have to be in a notice meeting only only four of us can well you could though um be in the same room and listening to testimony there's no issue with that each one of us individually gives testimony that's fine yes so long we just don't sit next to each other so long as you're not all discussing together uh in a quorum or more then it and then it's fine can I say maybe Miss Fabian we can have this discussion about not doing curriculum and just making sure that more yeah I think I think if we can get all any or all of us whoever is willing to go there I think that's great res that's that's what I
108wanted to speak to the citizens advisory committee at our first meeting they all mentioned that if we go to Trenton they want to be there whoever was there in the first meeting they would like to go too so there's your 13 citizens and three students so you have us and everybody else perhaps we can ask M Mr morala to put it on social media if you know res because we know residents have said that they would be happy and we've had people who've gone in the past to budget hearings but that's for everything and it's for one year um and see like strengthen numbers maybe as many people as we can get um I have a couple other things for other board business but yeah so um we will look at the committee schedule for
109next month and see what adjustments we can make but let's hopefully plan to for us all to try to go to the hearing um Miss can I Pig you back on Miss Ratner uh or is she not done she's not done okay I'm I'm almost done regarding legislative things okay yeah um just really quick the other things I was going to mention um I know actually miss deine you might be harping on this I won't put too much in there but there was the um middle sex County board meeting that I know Miss Fabiano um and I attended remotely Miss deine was there in person um it was a really excellent s which discussed budget and budget development um it was presented by the sville administration um and I'll just put a couple of things
110out there really quick that I really liked one thing that they mentioned is similar to how we have a strategic plan um that sort of gives us a year-by-year action plan they have that with their budget so like one year threee 5year budget planning um and so I think we sort of do that but to have something that's very similar to the Strategic plan you know as much as we can um look really cool it also um mentioned how with when they're developing their budget similar to the budget uh defense rounds that happen in in the district with the administration what they do is they have all of their supervisors come to board meetings and present what their wants needs and must haves are so like they did um you know schools and curriculum instruction
111presentations January 21st special education athletic presentations February 3rd February 18th um building grounds Transportation February March 4th technology Personnel just sort of give the community the idea of you know what's wanted what's needed um you know sort of explain what's happening there which I thought was a really neat idea um and then um you know there were definitely other things mentioned there but it was a great presentation I think they sent out the materials to everybody yeah the material was sent out by both the other person that spoke was Dr Brian zakowski who was a former superintendent from North Brunswick and is now um an executive director I forgot what position at Kane University University and the sville ba and the sville superintendent were both there and they were excellent they gave so many ideas
112um like M Mr Ratner was saying um when I was on North Bruns of board Dr zakowski was there and he said well we had our our budget meeting all day on a Saturday and it went from 99 to 3 he said 9 to one maybe because I think one of the their board members said because he talked past the one and didn't realize how much he was talking but we had breakfast and we had lunch and we went over line by line by line and we didn't leave that room that day until we know everything in the budget so I mean if you go on njs no middle sex County it was ours it was middle sex County uh School boards Association they should have their PowerPoints up there from Dr zakowski and the
113um two presenters from sville it it was excellent tons of questions and um a lot of good information so yeah I mean that was basically my report there's you know obviously wonderful events happening around the district unified Winterfest really like got to my heart I've loved it but um you know other than that I think this funding hearing is definitely a priority for us even though it's happening quickly we need to get it yeah it was one of those I feel like that came out very silently that was not a very big publicized thing so I think we need to jump on that um are there any other board members that have go ahead Miss um bills on the move that was a handout that was given out for the New Jersey school board's delegate
114assembly I'm not going to read them all because there's like six pages and I know you don't want to be here that long thank you okay one was on school funding a 4048 requires upcoming educational adequacy reports that include comprehensive review of certain components of school funding in consultation with stakeholders and experts now that is a support of njsba and that should be going through another one that I thought you might be interested was elections and that's a 2784 authorizes I don't know if we've said this already school districts at move its annual School elections in November to submit separate proposals for additional spending for Budget year and sub budget year that's also being supported but they haven't that hasn't moved yet njsba supported it was a couple of important ones I thought the rest
115were on school lunches safety but those things actually refer to our you know as a board member but some things that are going through there was a lot that were opposed uh a lot of discussion about opposition uh a lot were changed and I wanted to mention to the public too that um if there's any teachers a lot of them left but um it's also um policy 3713 which is uh pushed was also passed through the assembly where stiens will also be pensionable it's only through the assembly so we still have to wait um and I also wanted to say oh the freedom to read act which is a 3446 s 2471 that was supported with an amend amen Amendment and and that I I put a note here that I didn't mention before um
116that will go in effect in December of 2025 but the board of education has final authority to remove any material and that was something that they mentioned that day too so thank you just some and one more Monro Ed what if I say no no just go Monro Ed Foundation everybody else spoke a lot I'm just kidding here Monroe Ed Foundation has been started up again and it's wonderful to see the grants given out to the teachers so welld deserved this group is trying to raise money and I just want to encourage anybody in this town uh Mr Po is working on a Tricky Tray he and I are working on a Tricky Tray for sometime next year so we'll be looking for help with that but if you see something sponsored by the Ed
117Foundation you should realize that money's going back to your de District to the teachers and to the children so please try to support the Ed Foundation um and I think that some of the ones that were presented tonight we could have them present at a board meeting I mean I think we should know and they could be here to the Ed Foundation members how the teachers are using the money that they were given so that other teachers will say Hey you know we're getting money let's try to put some more grants in so I commend the Ed Foundation members for working as hard as they do did and please Township support them in anything that they do in the upcoming years because it's going back to your kids and to your teachers thank you Miss
118Bora just like we were super happy to see the Monro Foundation grants come back I was I would like to share that we've gone back out to the community for the holiday concerts at the rockmore I attended this as a parent but it brought so much joy because this is one of the things that our uh music teachers do very well we you know for it before Co we would go out to a lot of Senior Communities and do holiday shows um and Rossmore is one that I've been to before the last one was in 2019 so it was excellent to see the cussion group there um under the direction of uh Mr Jonah neck they did an amazing job the seniors were very appreciative um they were it was the rossore Music Association they
119collect donations and they give scholarship they did give scholarship last year so um very happy to see that I also wanted to give a shout out to our student representative representative sah cha because she did make the New Jersey youth Senate at the alternate so it's a great accomplishment super proud of her um Trailblazer there um we had a few students uh that just the day that the rossore concert happened we had a few students that made all eastn for percussion and for chorus that all e means it's not just all state it's to Dr Layman can explain better but I felt like that was an amazing honor and tonight when we were honoring these athletes I don't know how many of you noticed but so many times Mr brand announced nj.com player of the
120year which so many of them so I think we are super blessed as a district uh to have so much talent in our students and we were able to support them with the work that you know all of us give our time and our administrators put in their hard work on blessed to be in a district like this I want to wish everybody Happy Holidays um you know Merry Christmas Happy Hanukah whatever you're celebrating I hope you're surrounded by love and family and everybody gets to take some time off in the next few weeks thank you thank you Miss Bora anybody any other board members wishing to speak I think Dr Layman wanted to say something okay then we are going to move on to our public forum if there's any members of the the
121public wishing to speak you have 4 minutes to do so please state your name in municipality for the record good evening Michelle armini 9 Nathaniel Street I just wanted to let you know that I just came back from the township council meeting and we are starting uh the state is going to start uh talking about our fourth round affordable uh housing obligation in Monroe there's a tentative and I I would like you know uh maybe the board members I know with all of the other activities and documents you must read there's a 43 page state document that talks about the affordable housing it is called fair housing I think it's called and I'm sorry I left it in my car uh fair housing obligation but you'll find it on State website it's 43 pages and
122there is a perspective of 751 units for mon row now I was told by the council uh attorney that that that that's not a firm number however let's be realistic we've had 851 affordable housing units on the third round that have not been delivered and that doesn't mean that's the total number that's only the total number of affordable housing what what the third round is is four market rate houses to one affordable housing unit so you multiply the 850 or 851 obligation that we have by four and that gives you a total of what's going to be built and the kind of construction that's going on in Monroe we haven't even completed the second round obligation we haven't completed the third round obligation I was told at the last prior meeting to that to the
123council that uh we are only 30% delivered on the affordable housing units for the third round and now they're already talking about the fourth round and that's from that's construction between 2025 and 2035 so they give it a 10-year range but we need to be cognizant of that because as we all know it impacts us and just from my perspective personally as much as I believe in the affordable housing necessity I think that the developers are coming to this town and using that as an excuse to get very very wealthy and build um yeah and get and and build market rate houses that really give them really make a lot of money for them and we're we still don't have impact fees so if we go down and talk about the budget please include the
124affordable housing uh as bring that up bring up impact fees those are all important to our budget and going forward for our students so it's everybody and and it's not anyone's fault but it seems like politicians or whoever is in charge of these things they try to keep them separate but it's a big it's a big macro picture it is not affordable housing it is not uh the budget for the school it is all the same and we need to be we need to really press the state as to what impact it's going to have in in our school system so I thank you all for the hard work you've been doing and I'm sorry to give you another 43 pages to read I hope you're there and I'm G to uh we'll have to
125see what day it is I'll have to take off from work um but I'm I'm still in support of this community and support of our you know getting getting funds for our community so thank you all for what you do happy uh holidays to all do they have any Cliff Notes on that Miss Armenia I haven't read the 43 Pages they just came if they have Cliff Notes let us know I'll I'll I'll read and maybe make an outline for everybody not every page is is significant to to the Monroe School System but like I said 751 is what they're projecting for Our obligation which means multiply now that now they're saying that instead of a one to four ratio they may do a 1:3 ratio who knows just hold on to your [Music] seats
126thank you miss armino any other members of the public wishing to speak hello again uh Christy scurby Monroe um to piggy back on what Miss arminio said the last demographers report that we did back in 22 had some of those developments listed but until the Builder pulls the permit the demographer does not include that in the demographer report so there is a lot of um information like M armino said on the affordable housing how many are coming but until the and and this is very important for the school district to realize until the permits pulled the demographers reports won't reflect that many houses that are going to be built so while you think that perhaps you're not going to have a large enrollment the numbers are kind of skewed because what the demographer will include
127in that um it's just something that miss rner you had mentioned with that um bill that's out there for the funding you mentioned you you said I don't know how I feel about this board does need to come up with how you feel before you go and testify so are you in support of uh 7% increase or not what are you going to be going there to say I I mean before you go and speak and bring the public because you might bring the public and the public might speak against that because I know people who ran didn't want to go above the 2% cap if this is Raising it 7% without a vote of the public that's millions and millions of do increase so I think the board before you go has to come
128up with a stance of how you feel and what are you going to be going down there to testify because be you can go and ask for money but that's not what that hearing is for that hearing is on that bill and yes absolutely let the public know what the board stance is and invite the public to come down and support it if they if they support that but you can't just invite people to come down to speak on a bill without knowing how the board supports it and just something that Mr pero mentioned before about um with the high school and and the policies we ran into this when I was on the board the high school was not following the law for the Arts credits hundreds of kids for many years graduated without
129the proper amount of credits for the Arts we didn't know that was going on the board and the administration set the policy policy goes down to the high school the high school creates their program of studies that is not a document that is approved by the board maybe it should be maybe while you're having your policy discussions maybe the discussion is that the board should start approving the program of studies and reviewing that because your names are on it your name is on the first page of the program of studies and that sets the policies for the high school so the high school has a document of their own policies that now we're seeing isn't the same as board policy so while you're discussing this in curriculum and in policy perhaps that becomes a discussion
130too of the board taking an active role in approving that program of studies because you could set the policies you don't know if they're being followed and like Miss Boris said a parent spoke up to say the policy was not being followed it got brought to the administration it sounded like they brought Dr Higgins to the policy meeting and he said well it was a board mistake based on what so while you say the the administration should be making sure the following the policy the administrator came and said what was just a mistake that's not that that wasn't the policy and that shouldn't be the policy our procedure should be the policy and and you got to watch out for that because that goes down a slippery slope procedure isn't the policy the policy that
131the board votes on and is there in the policy manual is what the policy is until you change that as a board that is what should would sck not what a procedure is the procedure should be based on the policy and when it's not you have to go back to what the policy says thank you are there any members of the public wishing to speak once again Doug P Monro Township uh item Q under superintendent report uh it's uh you approved a settlement agreement between the Board of Education and the uh educ Education Association my question is uh are members of the public uh are we allowed to know to know anything about the details of that excuse me of that of that settlement agreement um it it depends it depends on what the settlement
132agreement says um if it deals with funding um I would say yes but if it deals with matters of a personal Personnel nature perhaps not um it it really depends uh and as far as that item in particular this one right here it didn't get to your level it was a but it was a personal okay but yeah it's an agreement yeah I'm sorry sir I'm not familiar with that particular issue so I I can't provide you a a synopsis of it right now but I'm happy to do that um going forward well it was a it was a personel it's a Personnel matter of a personal nature I I have to parse some words to in order to figure out how to okay all right uh I do want to thank the various members
133of the board who thank the uh Education Foundation for the grants that we were able to make this year and I particularly want to thank uh Miss depan uh for asking you to support uh the Education Foundation we are trying to revitalize this organization it does benefit the students and the teachers of the district it affords funds which are not provided through the regular school budget but I do want to thank you for your support and we will look forward to that support in the coming years I also want to thank the members of the board for the time and the energy that you put in not only in your meetings but in the other things that you go to and attend so that you will be better informed and uh better equipped to work
134for the benefit of the district and I wish you all a a good holiday season and a healthy New Year you thank you thank you Mr P are there any other members of the public that would like to speak okay seeing none we're going to close the public forum um we are not I lost my page don't need a second Clos session so we are going to go to our next scheduled Board of Education meeting date which is January 15 2025 I can't believe it's going to be 2025 already um can we have a motion to adjourn motion second second all those in favor I happy holidays everybody happy holidays to all y oh