CorpusRecord 133021

Monroe Twp BOE Policy Committee 12.10.24

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Monroe Township School District
Date
2024-12-11
Location
Middlesex County, NJ
Material
Transcript
Extent
3,602 words · about 21 min
Collected
2026-06-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001tonight is policy we're starting our committee meetings this evening with policy uh today's December 10th present at the meeting is Dr Celli y Dr Higgins from the high school Dr Layman Dr Chanley Miss Ratner Dr peek Mr zner and Mrs Fabiano we all have a short agenda today we have two items we're going to start with uh regulation number 5440 honoring pupil achievement this uh policy has been brought forth to the committee because we would like to align this policy with the current practices that are taking place all right I don't know um one of you would like to elaborate a further on it uh so this was this was a topic that was brought to my attention over the summer uh and in speaking with uh Dr Layman and Dr Chanley we wanted to

002bring this to uh this committee to discuss what's written in the regulation as compared to um what the practice is in the high school specifically in regulation 544 there is a caveat for principal list um and in that caveat it states that any any student um normally to get to a principal's list you would have to have your student would have to have a 90 or above in all of your classes there is a section in here that would say that says if a student has one grade of 85 to 90 in an honors class that would also qualify the student to be on the principal's list um that has not been the practice at uh the high school um Dr Catelli who has been in this position um for a number of years uh

003recently discovered that the practice changed around 2008 um what we believe happened was when the regulation was updated in 2008 that that was supposed to be removed and it never was so we believe that the the regulation is actually in error um and the practice that changed at the time through our uh we could tell through our program of studies when it actually changed um was to remove that 85 changed the practice but for some reason we don't know why the regulation never changed um so since 200829 any student that has been on the principal's list at the high school has had a 90 or above and that's it uh in doing my research in calling around to some of my um uh co-principal in Middle sex County it seems that every school that I've

004talked to whatever their High honors is whether it's high honor role or principal's list are all 90 or above there is some discussion about the possibility of an honors class because they get a a GPA bump would be affected by that uh we would counter that discussion or counter that argument with the fact that we don't actually um we don't actually incorporate those bumps in GPA until they're a senior anyway so there should be no recognition of that eight point or 10p Point bump for for honors or AP additionally the regulation does not indicate anything for an AP class only for an honors class this again is a reason why we think that this is a this is an error in the regulation um Andor just something that was never taken out when the update

005happen so my request after having this conversation and realizing this error uh my request to um Dr Chanley and Dr Layman was to ask the board to remove that number two under principal's list to have the regulation conform more to what our practice has been page 204 okay that's in that's in the nutshell that's really and and that is our recommendation so um and I've been here since 2003 so I do recall as well I know Dr L we had this conversation detail and if there had been any fluctuation in the practice then I would say it's probably a conversation we need to maybe entertain but there has been no fluctuation since 2008 it's been a 90 it's always been a 90 and basically the policy then really should match the practice and I do

006agree that um principal's list is and should be a big deal for lack of you know in layman's terms it should be honorary and big ZL and 90 is an appropriate rate well it looks like the high school is able to track back the change so their program on studies Sy toly had it as an 85 the policy update in 2008 then led to the change in the program of studies in 2009 this wasn't removed but it looks like none of us were here this was updated in ' 08 and then the program of studies was updated again so I think everything else would solid updated to reflect whatever the Genesis was updated also so that so everything is appropriate at in alignment with the exception of two being in there it should be removed

007and then you can move three to two four to three and everything else stays there's no other issues in the policy um I had just one question what happens if there's a family that noticed that this was in writing in our POS and is asking us to um adhere to it you know being that this is the policy that we have in place so that that has happened um the response that I had given at the time was that uh the practice of the high school has always been I said always probably in my time or my knowledge and in speaking with Dr Catelli that it was always a 90 or above which then sparked this conversation so we would not change our practice um that's why we're asking the the board to to to

008align align that regulation I guess if they wanted to they wanted to um what's the word not way help me mediate or compromise no when they go they go above you they want to put in thank you excuse me public I couldn't think of the word today right we had one of those days um yes so if they wanted to appeal it then they could appeal it to Dr Layman and then he would have to make a decision and then if they didn't like his decision they would appeal to me and to make my decision and I do agree that policy is very important we have to respect policy it is our governing body that being said if we have always maintained the practice through Genesis which is our online uh student management system comp

009you know computerized that does it for us and I think the other key and you said this I don't know if anybody realized this well you said it if we were going to say that it is more rigorous class why aren't we doing that for AP as well so therefore you could see it's an anomaly that was an error because otherwise you would have AP honors class so that would be my expense so and no one has come to me to appeal I I believe every circumstance should be looked at in its own value but if someone just blanketly asked me the question the answer would be that we would maintain the 9 because that's what we've always done does anybody have questions so Mr Ze can I assume then assume uh that the term

010um academic distinction will come off wait what number says number two people in grades 9 through 12 who have achieved academic no it's you're on the wrong area it's a principales list one number two page two and four okay and number two better no not I'm not referring to that I'm what I'm referring to has to deal with ter academic yeah within it it says people in grades 9 through 12 where are you who have achieved academic distinction that's page one a okay um I would assume that's going to come off academic distinction that's labed open a lot of possibility well that that would be an additional discussion that's not what I'm I'm requesting what you're what you're speaking of falls under the honor rolles a what I'm talking about is under principal list um

011which I guess I mean under that subsection of honor honor roles um it's the honor to the next level so if you I'm just looking for continuity that's Co no they that see number two and then they go for the second page and and I just I know that's what you're looking for within the high school and throughout the entire district is continuity because I I did a I did a form up together so I can look at it from that perspective and so I I wasn't sure and that was my question so so if I may I think um the section that you're speaking of a to under honor roles which is uh an overarching section right uh what it is describing there is that there are two uh two lists all right for

012lack of a better term at the high school that shows academic distinction one being an honor rooll list and one being a principal list what we're discussing is the principal list which would be considered the higher of the two lists the higher of the two honors that's my next question um so that higher of the two honors would be 90 or above for all grades in that Mark we do Market period of semesters for in that market I I I I think we should look at that though just because it's not clear until they move on to the next item not when I it says will be listed on honorable at the end of the school year for two for a to under honoral pupils in grades 9 through 12 who have achieved academic honorable

013so it's distinguishing between principles with andol okay it's just that we're we're placed um and then when we move up um it's just not it wasn't clear at least it wasn't clear to me uh where is where it is currently placed I'm just suggesting maybe a movement um would be in our best interest in terms of the policy that's I'm sugges any other questions maybe we just listed if I may maybe we list what you're saying in both places it's an academic Extinction we we're it's an academic Extinction for honoral and it's also an academic Extinction for principal list so perhaps we need what you're saying and put it in both places why we moove it it is an academic exension but I understand because you're almost saying well is an academic only honorable but

014where is it for the I hear you I think that might be a good idea so what you're saying just repeat it because I understand what you're saying you're delineating honor rooll and then you delineate the other you just repeat it twice so people know it's an academic Extinction of so it relates to relates to both particular Mak sense so it become principal list item it'll be number four because if you move three to two it'll still be a number four but you you won't have a number two yeah M don't B with number two just other oh that's true that way so you know when they first put number two yeah right because other words it's directly under it so you're talking about it and then you say it's an active Extinction and then

015you say the honoral will be prepared by the director of guidance and that each principal will display it makes sense yeah so I a couple questions are I'm going excuse myself cuz he's stuck my my son just sto no we'll be going to put the Dr chy really quick because you you would probably well when what we're talking about but just because we're looking at it when did the sixth grade move through the middle school 2011 okay I did notice the very first part of the regulation talks about pupils in grades five to six and so I'm wondering if we need to change five to six to eight yeah fifth is incorrect so where are weang so if you go to page one and four to be eligible for the honorable pupils in grades 6

016through eight must achieve an honorable average of 85% coures taken during the regular school dat so it's not no longer yeah it has been fifth grade in Forever fifth grade still does get notified we don't it doesn't affect us though if you look at A1 it talks about pupils in grades five to six so basically I think any of that says grade five five needs to come out and it should be six now they can be acknowledged with distinction in the elementary school by the elementary principles but it wouldn't have any effect or relationship with Middle School well I think Mr R's point is that in the current regulation grade seven and eight are not noted it's noted under honorable on the bottom of page one but on the top of page one but not

017here so I don't know if we're giving the the criteria for elementary school want to modify let's ask let's ask an elementary principal Dr Wayman when you were in the upper elementary and how did you do it so you could say so so is this pertaining I kind of agree what he's saying it structured off it makes you feel like what are you talking about we should have one section measy one section and one SE PR I agree maybe it needs to be re yes I C but no you wouldn't it's matched together as a separate honorable compl like right my thought was that maybe we had one for the upper elementary school there and then when the sixth grade moved poliy reg so let me ask you so grade five still gets acknowledgement of

018honorable by itself and grade four so then what we probably need to do is probably need to have honoral in grades five who disting so in grades five and then we talk about in grade six to eight and then 12 of grades in high school and they all get academic extinction extinction we extin distinction and then my other question which does clarify for honorable mentions in grades 5 to8 that they have to have overall average of 85% um and one course can be AG grade in a 75% to 79% to my knowledge just from my own personal experience I thought that all of the classes that at least how I've seen it done have to be not how it is yeah they have to be at that now they have to be 80 or above

01980 or above inal grades this is old right so we need is really old more time for this yeah so what we do is if we take one more time to before we go to our first reading we can get all of our DS in a row realize that we change the format change the verbage put in what um what was commented here by all of the board members which makes sense and we're going to lay it out a little bit differently we'll have fifth grade six through eight high school and then wherever it pertains to I think that makes the most sense I agree yeah which won't be a problem at all and then the national person um has that changed with guidelines since this was last reviewed because I'm wondering if it makes

020sense to eliminate what's specifically listed there because it also says that we follow what the National Honor Society States so I don't know so yes uh it I think that's broad enough to any changes that we have made um has not has not been affected by this regulation because we do F follow the national uh honor Honor Society guidelines even though their guidelines are that we have to have our own uh bylaws so our bylaws are based on their guidelines but they're ours alone for so what's under number one at the bottom of page two is still what we do um I don't have the same Pages if you do oh okay so are you looking at C National Honor Society c naal h okay yes yes that is that that is what we do

021with the the Juniors after the first semester and seniors after the first Mark per okay Yes sounds good all right let's move on to the second item and second and last item in the agenda which is the acceptable use of generative generative artificial intelligence I have trouble okay do we need to read the whole policy out loud I'll give some highlights if you want and then if you guys want to ask questions again we can revisit this this this is another one we can bring back again um but we need to get something down um at least we thought at a district level we needed to get something down okay I know that the board I think is in the same thought so back in July Strauss ese released uh I guess the best way

022to describe that they typically give us a really strong policy connected to you know code and law and things they basically gave us some sence starters just the way I describe it um so then what we started to do and then I know several board members uh also started to kind of look out and see what other districts have in terms of their AI policies uh in our research we've noticed that there are many many many probably the majority of school district around us that did still have not adopted an AI policy um but again cycling back to us I think we need to get at least a starter down on paper and and and approved for us to to Define like a core uh set of expectations so this policy is kind of drawn

023from several districts that have gone and adopted a policy so a lot of this work uh really is kind of picking off the things that we felt were appropriate to Monroe Township um and I looked at the development of this through a couple different lenses and you can kind of see the way it's divided there's a district piece and there's a student and staff piece to it so there's kind of three sections to it and then there's uh a few lenses we took a look at you have a student privacy lens a staff privacy lens um there's an expectation of Education in there there's also an expectation of accepting that this is happening around us so we are going to adapt and uh utilize this as we do um one thing to think about is

024I feel like this will evolve eventually maybe kind of like our uh return to school policy coming out of Co where it doesn't exist anymore yeah but it does exist that return to school policy because a lot of the things that were in there are now embedded in other policies or other Pro uh processes and procedures we have for example we don't have policy on our like our search tools like our web search tools we don't have a policy on how students use digital research tools and things um so right now we'll lay the groundwork and then we can uh evolve this and tweak this as we need to go so the first page here is really just finding terms that's comes directly from St smme the second page um is what I would consider

025the district kind of the overarching piece there and again you can kind of see it has those highlights of um data privacy and security so all AI systems and tools must respect that um all AI systems and tools must align with the district collected vision for high quality instruction these are like the high standards we're setting right um the the AI tools and systems have to be monitorable on our side you know from a student learning perspective um safeguards have to be in place and they're essential uh when we identify or use tools that we can monitor and limit bias and things uh the fifth one here is the use of AI systems and tools by students teachers and professional staff must account for uh the concept context of teaching and learning and must work

026well in educational practice um again we're not going to take Ai and squeeze it in somewhere where it doesn't fit right is just a naturally evolving uh thing we're interacting with uh and then another overarching piece is the use of AI systems and tools must uh be safe and effective for students AI syst tools must include uh anti-discrimination practices protect data privacy provide notice and explanations provide resources to human users when uh problems arise again from a district perspective any technological tool that we interact with has to meet a certain threshold and standard for student staff data privacy that's everything from our Microsoft logins they all have an umbrella expectation and threshold that they meet all the way down to uh ad mum products study island and things we wouldn't interact with a business or

027a product um or an entity that if we put information in we were afraid we were afraid that that information would be violated or shared or something like that um the next section is students um this kind of defines not kind of this defines as a student some of the inter actions they may have um and it basically says when when assignments permit the use of AI for explanations of Concepts um make sure you verify those uh Concepts AI is not a primary source and that's a common understanding across the board um it's not going to a uh you know core reference and using that so AI is learning from its environment it's not a primary source um when students are permitted uh and we kind of Define this in in a few different ways

028here because the operational information we're going to give to the teachers and the students it's going to be a scale of use so picture you get a homework assignment you can't use it you can use it for idea generation you can use it for editing or you can use it all throughout so we will Define expectations for student use and we kind of work those expectations into two and three here so when an assignment permits the consultation of a AI for ideas right essays essay ideas and feedback um make sure that there's enough difference between what you got out of AI and what you're turning in as your own right it's academic Integrity plagiarism uh students should not upload any personal information that's a teachable piece as we expose students to this or they start

029using it we have to make sure they understand that they're not typing their name and their address and their phone number and their social security number and their friends information in there not that we think they would do that but um even if you take a short of information and copy and paste it into AI you may not think that the reason you're putting in there is is to uh you know get information about a student or something you want a different looking chart or something like that the fact that that personal information is input in there is a concern so we want to make sure we have expectations that they're not doing things like that um the the fourth bullet is really about citations you know so make sure you site um the fifth

030one is academic Integrity that students SAS and other writing assignments should be uh you know could be scrutinized with AI detection software so some of the things that we have in place uh have like Microsoft Word has like the automatic spell check some of the things that we are acquiring are beginning to have ai detection as a part of that so okay um one thing that's extremely notable and it's connected to uh the last section of of the number 10 for the teachers and it goes along with number five for the students is if there's something flagged by an AI detection software that is not the only uh source that we would we would look for for academic Integrity violations so that would be a flag for us to dig deeper and have a conversation

031with the student and that's outlined in number 10 um when we look at revision history in Google we look at um revision histories in Microsoft there's ways to look and see if things were generally copy and pasted over you know there there's an investigation and a conversation that can happen with a student it's not just going to be an ai ai detection software tells me that this is AI and it's done and we get a zero there's a lot more that would be you know taken into account that's good because I have heard that sometimes gramarly is picked up as AI correct yep yeah um and and and again we're gonna run out time turn so he turn it in has AI software detection software embedded in so um the last page of Staff yeah

032the last page of staff and and it goes through a similar process the first one's academic Integrity the second one is citations for any of the work they're providing us as a district not passing off as their own three is verifying the sources four is data privacy five is more data privacy um the other ones are educating students about uh over Reliance on AI how to use it properly um evaluating the use on a case-by Case basis number eight is a communication so if there's something as AI evolves in a classroom that is coming to fruition and they want to use AI in that in that uh vein just like any other Technologies process software we have we need to run through our screening process which we take a look at all the privacy issues

033and things that they have and they should have on their back end so that's the same expectation we have with anything else they do technology wise and then I highlighted 10 was where we uh we expect them to have a conversation so the core of this is this lays out expectations the Practical piece of this is we have um professional development that staff is already attending we have an intro to AI we've had started last year we probably have a 100 staff that have already uh signed up I've already taken it we have five more courses scheduled for the rest of this year we have cohorts of Staff through our title funding our title grant funding going out to Ruckers going out to uh professional development throughout the state um so we're doing some ground

034workor and then when everybody comes back we will start flipping this out with our guidance and our scale of use so we can teach the teachers and we can teach the teachers how to teach the students uh but this is the I guess the beginning of the Lan expect yeah um do you have a timeline as to when you want the policy in place I would say we had a brief discussion now I I'm sure it may come up in curriculum or we may come up with discussion in the board meeting yeah I I think I'm going to run this by the attorney as well and his feedback but like a group of principles is looking at it tomorrow at their principal meeting May bring it back I'm thinking we could have something better in

035January and then that also you know we're rolling it out we're creating the guidance like I said in in parallel to this um but this is the first look this is your guys will take feedback from a you know parent perspective and things like that a community perspective all right any questions so both of these are going back to committee none of them are going y right what what we're going to do is whether myself Dr L we do it together we it's very simple we'll just reach out to our Upper Elementary principles we have three of them we'll reach out to our Middle School principal we know what's going on with our high school and then we'll see what's the best way to format so it's it it is consistent the Lang and the

036verbage is consistent for the fifth six eight in high school and then you know maybe there's one paragraph at the end that talks about the academic distinction instead of having it as part of a which is what you were looking at we just have at the very end of the document or the very beginning of the document so that's not going to be a problem I already wrote myself some notes so this is something that we'll revisit back to January okay I think that makes sense both policies all right soy Good other questions this concludes the policy committee meeting for the month than thank you

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.