CorpusRecord 133023

Monroe Twp BOE Finance & Shared Services Committee 12.10.24

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Monroe Township School District
Date
2024-12-11
Location
Middlesex County, NJ
Material
Transcript
Extent
2,975 words · about 17 min
Collected
2026-06-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001evening everyone this is the finance and shared services committee meeting for the month of December uh we are running a little behind so we're going to get started we have a very short agenda um the first item on the agenda is the review of the monthly attorney fees um any of the board members have any concerns um that they would like to bring up as low as possible that's it that's it um the next item on the agenda is the Bist um anybody have any in particular on the bid list that they would like to ask Sora about I already did my asking the pre me it was pretty it was pretty we have about 5 million um $300,000 in this bu will and there will be an Abend as always yes by 374 about

002you set the penny to the penny to the penny all right no seeing no questions U the last item on the agenda which is the review of The Police Service cost so a little background on this uh over the last few bull list um I had observed that we pay the M Township uh for police services for uh some of the school district events which is being with be games the Boe meetings um and we brought up the discussion to the administration to kind of prepare a report of when is it that we require police presence um and how is it charged um how does it compare to our neighboring District so Dr Chanley and Miss Allan um pulled up uh a report and the board members have access to it um we were uh

003we also in our pre- meeting discussed the various uh rules that the head of security and uh Dr Chanley have in place to determine what Security will be required for what event um but with this purpose of this meeting we are looking at the numbers um and I hope all of you got a chance to see the attachment um we have three years worth of numbers so we have numbers uh for what we paid for police services from for the year 2022 23 uh which was $226,000 um that for the year 23 24 we paid $36,000 and so far for this year we've paid approximately $88,000 so uh the these are the costs that we we incur as a school district this is not something that an outside provider is going to reimburse us well

004so when we when our buildings are used by an outside organization they incur the cost for the security correctly but for our games our Boe meetings our graduations those are the items that that you can see in this list um we incur the cost of um having police presence in those events and um like this board is supposed to do we are looking at you know optimizing making sure that we are doing the best weekend with the taxpayers dollars so we took a look at it um our early rates for the last three years and I'm going to read those out are $116 for the year 2022 $10 8 for the year 2023 and $132 per hour for for this current year um we did do a comparison with neighboring school districts so um based

005on the Intel that Dr chandley and her team had provided us um not Brunswick has $55 per hour 62 per hour with the car um East brunic school has $110 per hour and Edison school district has $150 $59 per hour so the range is is there between these school districts but we definitely are are paying a much higher amount and so this call you know I would I open it up for discussion right now and then we can determine what should what is it that we can do to make it better I can I can comment on some of the things that we're doing at our level and then um you know regarding the hourly rates that's set by the police department they have unions they have organizations just like way do and they have

006to have their standard wage which I totally respect however which I agree people should be paid the couple things we're all going to do is I've been working and it's something that's ongoing so U Mr Selby as well as Mr barandika as well as myself and Dr Layman and Miss Allen we know that we do share responsibility so one of the things that we've been doing is viewing where the need is so know out of respect for the director of security which is completely important we have to make sure that they know well chry when we are arrival we want to have police presence when we have so for example we had wrestling internal you know he's shaking his head because we used to do the same thing nothing's changed the only thing that we

007did start to look at is we had more um we had more police presence at basketball and now we're starting to think that we might need a little bit less we're going to ask if they allow us to have only one officer sometimes they require two I do agree when it's outside for the football it should be a minimum of two perhaps when we do the inside it's basketball we can say to only have one to do some savings there I feel very confident and very um strong currently with um director of with the director of security as I did prior director of security that when they say we have a need I respect that need and we do it and I know you agree with security so I'm not worried about that I think

008what we'd like to do we don't even know it's possible is we are um Miss Fabiano has asked me and I I want to thank my secretary who is continually and about three or four times now reaching out to the mayor we would like to have a conversation however to say can we partner and can we have some help because we believe there might be a little bit of AD we talked about it this afternoon administrative fees involved not where our police officers they should get paid exactly what their contract say they should get paid but I believe there may be additional fees that are in there that perhaps would allow us to be a little bit less so on my end as a person you know who makes a recommendation in charge I will

009continue to work with the director of security and Mr baranda to say if it's a need we're going to recommend it because it's safety person I know we all agree if it's a need and now we look based upon um parent involved in community involved and who comes maybe we don't need the four offices maybe we need two maybe we don't need the two officers maybe we need one so that's something we're going to continually to look at but as far as the cost um even though we're higher I don't think there's anything we could do about that except ask the mayor if perhaps they I I I don't want to say put the bill but I I think you used the expression um it's the same pot but one side of the pot versus

010the other side of the pot but as far as the hour yeah as far as the hourly rates you know they have I don't know if they call the union or organization but it's the same that that's their hourly rate so but we are very conscientious we're not just saying bring cops we don't do that he sits down and he exam just like we've always done he sits down and he examines what he thinks our needs are and and just to reate I don't think yes so that same thing the board's goal is not to compromise security and safety of our students and you know of our staff that is of course Paramount but can we do it at a lesser cost than we are currently and and there where is aspects to it what

011is how many officers needed which is a call that you guys would make what is the rate that we are paying can we have a conversation with the town like like you just said it's the same tax dollars it's it's whether it goes out of the school budget or out of the town's budget in my opinion we're very limited with our 2% L whereas yeah the same may not be the case on the other side so they might have the ability to spend more funds go ahead M RIT so um I up the article because I remember reading something in one of the njpa magazines that sent to us um and about this this topic um and Mr probably knows more about this than than I would but it discussed um some districts that had

012employed class three special law enforcement officers and one thing that it says is that there was new legislation passed um in P 2016 um that normally it would be about 150 this is for full-time offic mind you but it was for $150,000 per officer on an annual basis but the legislation allowed the district to hire class three officers for $35,000 per year um I don't know enough they can only work the school day school hour they're not allow time events we we puros went they're only they're the same as your security except they're they're forbidden work more than their ship and they only have police power off for right so so just let you know when this topic came up I'll speak because I I was actually with Pete working with the we purposely went

013the direction we went with with our own security and arms orics because doing that they belong to the district for lack of a better term they're hours and we can utilize them in any way in any fashion they're willing to work with those class three officers which some school districts do he's 100% right it actually defer it actually um stops US it deters us from being able to do what we do so very happy the way we do it I think the topic on the conversation is not that it's the additional cost above what we have with our own security guards I believe that like uh girls basketball the crowds aren't very big yeah we making changes they were only one officer I think it was one officer L I think that's why the cost

014down I'm pretty sure football sport football boys boys basketball was always two so last year I think last year basketball yeah girls basketball I'm 99% sure it was only one officer for the girls games two officers for the boys games and are only here for two hours so what happened was last year was 11,000 this year it's 18,000 whereas football last year was 6,000 this year was 11,000 because both football and basketball went up in the last two uh school years not this year we're not talking about this year just started that's probably because you're playing more games correct because we won more so we went further further no I'm serious but how we play games we just play the GMC Division and then we play uh the the championship game how the play games

015cons if you if what is the expression also you're better yeah so that we have to se but it's I I think if you I mean we could ask Mr s the next year but I'm pretty sure that um we started com back that football was always the most expensive and um boys basketball two guys I'm not sure about wrestling and there was three extra extra games it's one I think girls basketball only one off so I think we're gonna be able to get I I think I'm not concerned that all without forsaking security as we all agree we're going to be able to really take a good look at this and see to to narrow where are possible I think the conversation needs to be that when we're afforded an opportunity to meet with

016the mayor to speak about these issues or these concerns to ask how can you help because they've done a fabulous job Serv it's a union thing but you're looking at an hourly rate right the hour what's their hour very close BR is 62 per hour guarantee them 4 hours pay of the way it works notun doesn't say guarante I check with every town most pwns have a a four hour they allow to hours North brunwick they they have a minimum so if you hire an officer for North brunwick you have to pay them if he's there 1 hour or four hours I'm pretty sure they get four hours of pay to show up so in tell that that's why they low he's three Edison is 3 hours North brunwick does not put a minimum hour

017there but Edison uh and East brunwick do say minimum of three hours I think think they you I'm pretty sure North BR it's the same with us too no no we only require two hours two hours and we always need it two hours and basketball they only come for two hours they only come for the barity game so it's definely all the other stuff something we can look at and we can see where it's appropriate we're very fortunate that we have excellent security guards we are security guards we don't want to get into the particular as we talk about what we need what we don't need but but in general I think we can do better and we should do better but when we're affording an opportunity to speak with the mayor it's just like

018share Services we can have the conversation how can we work together and collaborate is there any opportunity they can give us for you know what can we do we don't know what it looks like but we'll have that security I'm sorry what has armed everybody else is not may now but I know North Brunswick doesn't they employ that doesn't impact what they're paying the police department right what we have we have onse security but we're paying the if you hire a class three the school district pays the town to for that the the town doesn't acquired up say you want 10 class three officers they figure at the pay at eight hours a day and then the board EDS pays the police and then the township pays that just like an officer but the town

019doesn't pay for class 3es it's all paid for by the board of education so we're better off I like our structure better than 100% we're definitely not discussing that I think our our discussion is being AFF an opportunity perhaps after the new year we'll be able to get a time and that works for us and works for the mayor to sit down and have this conversation about you could go by the amount of people St for games to know how many people you actually need so you may not always be four and now we have a new system it with your own way the way we're doing our new ticket sales is a system also that allows us to calculate how many people exactly so it goes hand the new things that we've been doing

020to step forward and step up our game a little Le bill is probably more because I believe they were at all the big soccer games we just had and when the lacrosse go to the they won when you get to the playoffs that states it's a require njsi we still have to see those bills those builds will come now so but that's what I mean it goes by if your Athletics are doing really good the builds really high you are so that's why we were so cheap years ago because we weren't so great I think uh the major Crux of this converstion is that we are really looking at looking corners for pennies are balance our budget oh I can end by talking about every few thousand here and there if if it's you know

021it's going to go out of the taxpayers pocket whether it's going out from the town or from the school budget can we find a way a middle ground where it does we save some money that we could put towards Other M items on our budget always every before you end the meeting but yes but thank you for doing the work on this um Miss Alan Dr Chanley Mr you have something else on the same line yes very similar so what we wanted to say was we're very proud I use the Expression it's not we're not just about worrying about our our dollars we're absolutely woring about our pennies we are looking at every single line item we have completed our budget defense rounds it is appropriate to have this compensation in finance and I know

022we're coming to an end we have completed them we are Beyond proud of our of our principles and supervisors and directors because it's um we make sure our children are not at a loss we continue to give our children what they should have we continue to be over adequate because we are not adequate better than that at the same time however we look at programs that maybe through attrition they're no longer needed not taking anything away from children programs said or classes or whatever might be all of our principles came to the table saying you know what we looked at our wants our needs and our must haves and we all went with our must haves there were some areas with knees as well wants something that we're going to put on the back burner

023although we continue to grow certain programs like we do in our accelerated classes and the other thing that we're very proud of that we're looking we're working as a team so miss alen and myself we're working as a team because we have a new director of Transportation so when you have a new person in a position regard regardless of their background and we of how successful you were with your previous um leader they come in with fres eyes so miss Mar is now able to look at a schedule and look at the way we do things it's not better it's different she's not she hasn't worked with the schedule that we have for so many years that human nature the way the brain works you can't look at it any other way you can't help

024yourself so she's now looking with a first set of eyes in a different perspective so our goal is to also tighten without affecting children to the best of our ability to tighten the areas in which and become creative in the way do our scheduling you know we we do go out for bid and we do go out um for services because we don't want our children being late to school we don't want our children being late being picked up from school but at the same time we want to be fiduciary responsible to the taxpayers and to our budget so miss alen and I have been working we've already had three meetings we can continue to work with Miss Mo so that when we present our budget and it's inclusive in transportation we're going to look

025at to the best of our ability maybe going out to bit ourselves instead of just utilizing the one company that we work with to continue to save money so I'm very excited to have our Bo I know she's been here a couple times she just is came in with a fresh set of eyes and it helps us as the managers the leaders the supervisors we've been working together in collaboration to see in the areas in which maybe we can save some money and think out of the box to maybe do things differently so I did want to share that because it she it was one of our last um it was one of our last defense rounds because we had seen her more than once and and I just wanted to bring that out there

026because she's new and her being new is just that opportunity fresh us so we are excited about that yeah we don't want to reinvent the wheel but again there's you know the town has changed so much in the last DEC has been around the way you look at the way you drop off the way you pick up the way you utilize a bus or a train or a bus or a small vehicle you know a small van you just don't know and we need that extra set of eyes and um you know we we also let her know she has very open door a policy with both of us we usually meet as a team which I think is important also to work collaboratively and of course stayman as well we just want to not

027only support her but we want to hear her vision and her ideas and transportation been all right anybody any questions any comments go ahead just really quick I apologize for bringing this stff now I hadn't got a chance to over over the bill is but I did have a question about the hatia bill because I noticed that there was a a big increase since last year which was big already so we're spending almost a half a million dollars on tuition there which ultimately we have to allow them to go so um but I also noed that those students aren listed um under our enrollment under like out of district is that I guess how many other Charter students do we possibly have and is there a reason like that we don't have those numbers so

028I'm just curious like how many students that's covering and all of that um we had about 30 students that go to the Charter Schools just that one or the one um I yes I think there was one other um where we had one student um can't recall the name of it but all go to hot yeah because add a district is different we're talking the regular added district is a special education program and that is different okay that would not it's not the same asol right so they're not considered our students anymore whereas special education on District considered that is correct that is corre that's exactly how I would explain it okay kind makes sense right righted to pay it so I think Miss Allen had brought up this concern so that there's the the

029transportation aspect of it we've been charged more and more and we're probably not getting enough pain for it correct one of those things that they just yes yes one of our pain points but uh that bring us to the end of finan I know we're P minut slate for the CAC thank you very every thank you very much everybody

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.