CorpusRecord 134265

BOE Budget Study #1 2025-2-3

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
Vimeo / Scarsdale Streaming Network
Date
2025-02-04
Location
Westchester County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
24,756 words · about 138 min
Collected
2026-06-17

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001Good evening. I call this first budget study session to order and note that all board members are present along with Dr. Patrick and members of his cabinet. Welcome to all those who've joined us this evening either in the audience or tuning in on our live stream or via Zoom. Anyone wishing to make a public comment regarding this budget study session is invited to do so in one of two public comment sessions during our business meeting following this budget study session. We look forward to your feedback and input in our budget process. over to Drew. Thank you very much Susie. I'll just get the slideshow started here. Okay well thank you. Tonight we're gonna work to outline the why, how, and what of our budget. We'll present the overall preliminary budget draft, discuss the key budget

002components and drivers, And then we'll move on to discuss five key budget components, interscholastic athletics, transportation, facilities and capital projects, debt service and lease purchases, and employee benefits. We look forward to robust discussion once we've shared this information with the board. I also want to point out that this is just the starting point for the budget process. Sometimes when people... kind of tune into this it can look like this is where the budget is this is very much the starting point with ongoing discussion and a lot of work between tonight and our next meeting which is not for a month it's not till March 3rd so I just wanted to emphasize that forgot to advance the slide so that's what we're going to focus on tonight Okay, so tonight first I'm going to share a

003few process reminders and describe the key priorities and considerations that have gone into impacting the preliminary draft budget that you will see tonight. I always like to include this slide just as a reminder of this broader concept. that the school budget provides the necessary financial resources to operate the school district and to help achieve the goals and objectives of the school district as set forth in the strategic plan. In other words, our budget is a means to an end. Before we get too much further, just a reminder, as I said before, this is really a beginning point. This slide articulates the dates and the topics of... That's weird. It's going to be two slides. I don't know why. Let me see if I can, there we go. The dates and the topics of our major

004budget discussions. I'm not gonna go through them all, but we will review this slide again at the end just to remind people. But all of this work leads ultimately to the board's adoption of a proposed budget in April that the community will then consider as part of the annual budget vote in board election, which this year will be held on Tuesday, May 20th. and of course that's always held in Scarsdale Middle School. As we shared last week during our staffing presentation, there are four high-level principles that guide the administration's budget development and decision-making process. First and foremost, we're thinking about our recommendations in the context of our strategic plan, which outlines the priorities we are emphasizing. These priorities continue to reflect student achievement as a central goal of our work. We must also consider when

005mandates are put in place and when best practices and norms that have been in place for a long time or are new. And then finally, we look at opportunities to staff our programs more efficiently when possible to minimize the overall financial burden to the community. And sometimes this requires approaching what we currently do differently. And sometimes this requires us to ask. Do we need to keep supporting that particular expenditure? Tonight we'll be presenting examples of those questions and how we consider them. As we prepared, as the team here prepared for tonight's presentation, we carefully examined the strategic plan. And tonight's preliminary budget proposal emphasizes four priorities that are the most essential to achieve right now in our view. In terms of special education and the continuum of services, we believe we must support the students

006who are here with us to complete their course of study and of course to comply with the legal mandates and requirements that accompany special education. We have to support and foster the long-term financial health and sustainability of our budget in our district by presenting a balanced budget that uses reserves judiciously and garners support from the community. We believe we need to emphasize thoughtful, prioritized capital projects and planning, including ultimately bond planning, though that is not part of this proposed budget. It is something to take into account, keep in the back of our minds. And finally, the improvement of program. We believe we need to continue to improve learning by supporting targeted professional development of teachers, adaptation to our curriculum, and the continuous improvement of instructional practice. Some thoughts related to staffing efficiencies and overall financial

007impact. It's impossible not to recognize or say out loud that the tax cap continues to place constraints on our ideal program or what we would want to do. While I firmly believe we cannot ask our public to support a budget that's over the tax cap this year, our ability to run school the way it is, let alone add programming, with only a 2% rate of growth is simply not realistic. Salary and benefit growth still exceeds 2%, though only by a little bit, including mandated pension costs. Health plan costs are growing close to 10% nationally, and while we continue to be lower than that, see lower than that trend, we have seen an unusually abrupt rise in high-cost claims on our plan this year, which is a projected impact on next year. These realities compel us

008to look at some of our assumptions and contemplate some different approaches to how we do things. Before moving on, I'd like to make a few additional observations. One is we sometimes get the question about how does our staffing compare? Well, when we look at our staffing on a per-pupil basis, which is reported annually to the State Education Department, it's evident that we are generally in line with both the county and the region in terms of staffing. This chart, well, I'm not going to go through every row, breaks down different categories of staffing on a number of students per staff member basis in that category, and it shows Scarsdale schools compared to Westchester County compared to mid-Hudson region. So that's one thing that we look at when we think about this. I would also note that

009increases in programs and services for students, our core mission, has been the largest contributor to our use of available tax levy growth in recent years. That both makes sense, that's what we're here for, but also creates constraints. This year, our preliminary proposed budget will show that program increases will be more than offset by staffing reductions. But other costs are still causing growth to exceed the tax levy cap without making additional changes or before making additional changes. And then finally, we are leaning heavily into this guiding principle, the guiding principle around staffing efficiency and overall financial impact, to arrive at a budget consistent with the priorities outlined on the strategic plan slide. So just frame tonight's... PRESENTATION IN THE CONTEXT OF THESE FIVE THINGS AND KEEPING THEM IN MIND. ON THIS SLIDE, I'VE OUTLINED FOUR IDEAS

010THAT ARE EITHER ALREADY REFLECTED IN THE BUDGET WE'RE GOING TO SHARE TONIGHT OR WILL BE CONTEMPLATED AS POTENTIAL STRATEGIES TO HELP BRING OUR EXPENDITURES DOWN AND CLOSE THE GAP BETWEEN REVENUES AND EXPENSES FOR NEXT YEAR. So again, I'm introducing this just to have a frame of reference before we get into numbers and details in the budget slides. So first, the administrative team has looked to use, potentially use attrition or... retirements as an opportunity to examine what it would mean to not replace an outgoing position thereby lowering potentially lowering proposed expenditures we'll share examples of that where where that's baked into this this budget second we're reassessing some of our long-standing assumptions and asking if taking a more flexible approach could yield cost savings so I'm going to give an example of that now So, for

011example, last week at our staffing presentation, we proposed two contingency positions in the budget. This week, we're proposing to eliminate those contingency positions and consider the possibility of allowing elementary class size to exceed the cap by one student per section if and only if enrollment grows after the budget is adopted. Now, this is what that might look like. I'm going to give an example so that we can think about this when the time comes. So our practice, at least as far back as I'm aware, has been to budget to the projected enrollment at each grade in each school. So we're doing that right now, and we're projecting for September of 2025. Megan has done that and presented that last week. We estimate the number of class sections consistent with a maximum class size of 22

012students in grades K through 3 and 24 students in grades 4 and 5. So we've done so this year, and that right now is projecting 104 sections for next year. So what I'm suggesting to think about a little differently will illustrate with a hypothetical example. So let's say we're thinking about fourth grade at school X, one of our five schools. Pretend we're projecting 71 students next year, spread across three sections of 23, 24, and 24 students, respectively. That falls within our current class-side guidelines, and that's what we would do in any given year. What's new would be potentially this if a new student enrolled We would still be at our class size it would move from 23 24 24 to all 24 in each class Traditionally if yet another new student enrolled any time prior

013to August 15 in the summer We would break the section and hire a teacher resulting in four sections of 18 18 18 and 19 Again, traditionally speaking, if that same student enrolled on or after August 15th, we would not hire a teacher and run sections of 24, 24, and 25. What I just described is sort of our current practice. Incidentally, we take this same approach when we collapse a section, which does periodically happen. So, for example, if we had only 49 fourth graders... three sections of 16 16 and 17 and one moved away before August 15th we would collapse that into two sections of 24 and 24 by eliminating the budgeting of contingency sections we would essentially be acknowledging that we would allow any section to exceed the cap by one student however If we

014reach August 15th and the three sections in our example are now 25, 25, and 26, one section is now two students over, we would come to the board to request the appropriation of undesignated fund balance to hire an additional teacher. Anticipating some of your questions, a review of our current elementary class size averages shows that our averages across all five schools for grades K through two is 19 students in a class and 21 in grades three through five. That's just how what it happens to be this year. Ten of our 105 sections currently are at class size maximum and three sections are one student over. Now that's due to the enrollment of students after August 15th. It does happen. It's typically very few sections, but it does happen. When a class section exceeds the class

015max during a year, we plan for an additional section in the next year. So if it were 105 sections and we knew it was going to break, we'd plan for 106 in the next year. So the only exception to that would be when it's from third grade to fourth grade where we increase from 22 to 24 students anyway. Obviously, we'll monitor that new class cap of 24. There have been past years where we've used contingency for elementary sections. In years where we have not in the budgeting process, it's been roughly even back to probably 2005-06. We also know that our co-taught classes potentially aid in maintaining favorable student to teacher ratios. So just share that as background. You'll see in our proposal that we are suggesting we reduce those two contingency sections to zero with

016sort of the caveat that we bend a little bit on that assumption according to what I laid out there. Another example of being flexible with some of our assumptions, we did allude to last week, but giving on some of our priorities to maximize schedules. So an example here is we have lots of things we value in constructing the elementary schedule. One of the things we value is providing teachers on a grade level common planning time as many days during the week as possible. Sometimes we've done that and it's created the need for an additional time of day to have a section of music or art or something like that. We're at a time where we probably can't afford to do that. We've got to give up a little bit of that. We'd love to have

017to be able to more efficiently schedule those art and music. classes and need less part-time staff or shared staff as a result that's a that's another example and then a third example would be tolerating a lower rate of flexibility and in the high school schedule a little bit so for example last week we proposed a half a math addition to the high school we're gonna with retract that request this week for budgetary reasons. And what that would mean is we talked about the reason being to lower class size. It also creates a little bit of flexibility to have a different section. We would lose that benefit that we would gain. So that's an example there. A third idea is to examine where we are going above and beyond and to stick with what is core.

018We're going to discuss an example of that tonight in the area of athletics. I suspect that's why some people are in the audience. And look at things that we really like doing, but go beyond sort of what's core. So we'll discuss that during the athletics, interscholastic athletics portion of the budget. That has not been a change to what's proposed tonight. It's a discussion item. finally the fourth item where it's a seek alternative funding for would love to haves an example of that and we've utilized this book before we've been delighted to add more flexible furniture to our classroom spaces we've had some projects underway in various schools in particular at the high school the high school included a budget proposal to outfit some more rooms and the library here with flexible furniture we've removed that

019request from the budget it's something we don't think we can fund this particular year but have had productive conversations with our partners at the Scarsdale Schools Education Foundation as that being an area they may like may consider continuing to try to support it probably won't get us to a replacement of all the furniture we'd want to replace in the in the ideal time frame but it is an option that we have to consider in my view So again, those are four things that are related to what we've come forward to you tonight to propose. So with those concepts in mind, I'm going to turn it over to Andrew to begin discussing our draft budget plan for 2025-26. Again, reminding everyone, everything we're discussing tonight, next year, not current year. Thank you, Drew. So as we

020begin to look at the budget projections for the 25-26 fiscal year, it's important for us to first look at our current year and where we stand at the moment. We started our fiscal year with just over $22 million in total fund balance. And based on the revenue and expense projections we have developed, we expect to have approximately $20.8 million at the end of the current fiscal year. That's as of today's projections. This slide outlines the various reserve balances we are anticipating along with the unassigned fund balance, which we are projecting at about 3.75% of the current proposed 25-26 budget. The next slide shows the trend of our fund balance and reserves over a five-year period, including our projection for the current year. The most notable changes over time are the reduction in the health insurance

021reserve, a topic of much discussion in recent years. and the reduction in the reserve for encumbrances. The latter shows that payments are simply being processed more quickly at the end of a fiscal year. Therefore, they are included in the year-end actual expenses and do not need to be accounted for in the reserve. It's also appropriate to mention that the ending fund balance is projected to be approximately $1.1 million better than the fund balance we projected at the time of our long-range financial planning discussion in November. And that is a result as improved revenue and expense projections over the last few months. I'll now talk a bit about the tax cap. Based on the most current information available, the property tax cap for next year is projected to be 3.36% or a levy amount of $175,749,220.

022A budget requiring a levy at or below the cap requires a simple majority of votes to be approved. Should the district request a budget that exceeds that amount, a supermajority of 60% is required, as was the case last year for the current school year's budget. I will walk through the calculation on the next slide. We begin the calculation with the prior year's tax levy of $170 million and multiply that by the tax-based growth factor, which is a measure of the new development or renovation work throughout the community. That figure has been set by New York State at 1.0087, or less than 1% growth. We then add the value of the revenue associated with payments in lieu of taxes or pilots and remove prior exclusions for capital improvements, including debt service and capital projects. The resulting

023figure is then multiplied by 1 plus the lesser of CPI, or 2%. That number was capped at 2% for the current year and for the projected year. PILOTS FOR THE COMING YEAR ARE THEN REMOVED FOR THAT VALUE AND THEN THE CAPITAL EXCLUSIONS FOR THE COMING YEAR ARE ADDED, RESULTING IN A TAX LEVY LIMIT FOR THE COMING YEAR OF $175,749,220 OR A LEVY GROWTH OF $5.7 MILLION. THE SINGLE LARGEST SOURCE OF REVENUE IN SCARS DELETE IS PROPERTY TAXES. HOWEVER, WE DO RECEIVE A VARIETY OF OTHER FUNDS. IN THIS CHART, shows the multi-year view of financial resources available to us, including our projections for next year. Some of the important variances to observe in this chart include a current year revenue being projected to exceed budget by more than $2 million due to state aid, primarily the

024foundation aid that was not withheld in the final budget for the state this year, and interest earnings and miscellaneous other revenue sources being above budget. For next year, the budget-to-budget increases in revenue reflects the tax levy limit increase I mentioned a moment ago, a decrease of $421,000 for the expiring pilot payment, and state aid and interest earning increases that are being projected. It's important to note that last year's budget assumed that foundation aid would be reduced by approximately half a million dollars. That reduction ultimately did not happen in the current fiscal year and is not projected to happen in 25-26 either, thanks to the governor's latest state aid proposals. As I mentioned during our January 27th presentation, the governor has proposed a budget that maintains the safe, harmless provision of foundation aid. which we are

025grateful for and has even proposed a minimum increase for all districts which increases our foundation aid by approximately $75,000 for next year. Our proposed budget reflects an additional $6.1 million in revenues available and continues to use the use of fund balance reserves at the prior year's budget amounts. Finally, it should be noted that if our latest revenue and expense projection that IF OF OUR LATEST REVENUE EXPENSE REJECTIONS WHICH I SHOWED PREVIOUSLY ON SLIDE 12 COME ON TARGET, THE ACTUAL USE OF FUND BALANCE RESERVES WOULD BE LESS THAN THE BUDGETED 2.38 MILLION I'VE HAD LISTED HERE FOR THE CURRENT FISCAL YEAR. AND NOW I'LL SWITCH TO OUR EXPENSE BUDGET. THE NEXT SLIDE SHOWS THE DRAFT BUDGET AND THE PRIOR YEAR INFORMATION BROKEN DOWN BY MAJOR FUNCTIONAL CATEGORIES. In the middle column, you can see that our

026current year projected expenses are above the original approved budget in total by roughly about $900,000. This includes budget increases associated with carryover purchase orders from the prior fiscal year, appropriate fund balance for a legal settlement that we approved earlier this year, and additional funding received for specific expenditure from an outside entity to cover those costs directly. In that current year projected expense column, you can also see the employee benefits are over the approved budget by more than $2.1 million, while categories like general support and instruction are under budget. As I mentioned earlier, these cost savings coupled with projections of additional revenue help to minimize the impact on fund balance in the current year from these health cost increases. The two columns on the right include draft 25-26 budget. which is projected to increase by $8.17

027million versus the current year. We will talk more about the individual budget variances within this number as we progress through our budget discussion. However, this next slide provides the high-level changes that bridge our 2024-25 voter-approved budget and the current draft 2025-26 budget we are presenting this evening. Salary and wages are growing at $2.59 million, or just under 2.5%. Our health plan increases are projected to grow at $3.7 million. Retirement and Social Security costs are growing by $564,000. And we will discuss increases in transportation, capital, and debt service in more detail shortly, but I've highlighted those variances as $245,000, $210,000, and $134,000, respectively. All other variances reflect an increase of $685,000 across multiple categories in our budget. And with that, I'll turn this over to Drew. Thank you very much, Andrew. So as I outlined earlier

028this evening, in order to prepare a more realistic budget draft for this conversation, we have reduced proposed expenditures across a number of categories led by reductions in staffing, some contractual costs and supplies. Specific to staffing, and we're showing a version of the slide we shared last week with some updates to it. We have withdrawn our Tier 1 request for the half-time SHS math edition, though preserved the 2.0 SMS and SHS special ed editions. We've also developed a number of other reductions that we've already made in the draft budget plan financially. We've not had adequate time to hold necessary discussions with building leaders, department leaders, and individuals that may be directly or indirectly impacted by these decisions. So we're reporting these reductions as a total FTE reduction, and we'll provide more detail next budget study session

029number two. But this budget does include additional reductions totaling 6.5 FTE. So at the summary level, this chart shows the draft budget, which includes expenditure growth of $8.17 million, or 4.42% year over year. Other revenue sources are projected to grow roughly $396,000, or 3.16%. And currently, the draft budget maintains the level of reserve usage at $1.28 million, which was included in the current year. This budget would require a tax levy of $177,810,699 or an increase of $7,774,785 versus the current year, a growth of 4.57%. This levy amount would fund just under 92% of the total budget, which is consistent with the current year. This next budget overview slide will have more relevance as we've... as we complete our budget discussions further. But it shows again, the draft budget is just over $193 million, along with

030the budget-to-budget and levy increase amounts we just talked about. Most importantly, it highlights the gap we're working to close in the coming month of $2,061,479. That's essentially our target for these discussions coming in a month or so. So with that overview, I think we'll turn it over to... We'll have our first component budget and we invite Cindy Parrott, our athletic director, to the podium. Thank you. Hello, thank you. So in Drew's next slide, I think you can see what is allocated towards athletics. in our proposed budget. And our proposed budget maintains the support for the current level of athletic offerings. Salary and wages reflects anticipated expenses based upon existing collective bargaining agreements. I want to also mention that There were several unfilled or vacated coaching positions during the 2023-2024 school year that may have skewed

031this current year's budget projection. All coaching positions in Article 14 have been filled for the 2024-2025 school year, except for one this spring, which is still in open posting. That enabled us to really just have a more accurate projection for salaries and wages pertaining to athletics that I just wanted to point out. This budget does maintain programming for all seasons including necessary supplies, equipment, and uniforms. The additional $15,000 requested is to allow for increases due to inflation, purchase some new sideline seating for gyms, and a larger than usual expenditure for replacement football helmets which are getting very costly but necessary. The budget defers nonessential equipment replacements such as items in the fitness center that are aging with some items close to their functional lifespan. So that is a bit of a larger conversation that we'll

032be having. with the athletics department and Andrew's office over the next year or two. This budget supports proper supervision and prioritizes student athlete health and safety. Notable increases are related to a new agreement that we will have to go into place with this year with our athletic trainers. We're in the last year of a four-year contract, and in that four-year contract, there were no annual increases. As such, we're anticipating approximately a $20,000 increase. I'm also suggesting an increase of $7,000 for supervision, as we are now required to have medical sign-line coverage not only in home football games, but all levels of home hockey games. Additionally, I would like to staff home varsity football games with two police officers. Currently, we only do that for homecoming. There's also a $20,000 increase to facility rental fees. Currently,

033we rent facilities for bowling, crew, fencing, squash, ice hockey, ski, swimming, and diving, and gymnastics. This budget allows for increases due to inflation as well as allowing for additional ice time to better support our varsity ice hockey program. Lastly, this current budget proposal anticipates a decent increase in BOCES costs due to an increase in BOCES fees as well as a new contract that was signed with officials for all sports and all seasons. I'm going to kick off this next slide. So this, as I alluded to this earlier, falls under one of the four concepts that we think we need to consider in finding... expenditure reductions in next year's budget. And we're thinking about this not exclusive to athletics, but in every area of the budget that we're looking at. And this falls under one of

034those four areas about going sort of beyond core. It's always difficult to talk about programs that our students enjoy and are successful in. There's nothing personal in this. It's just an open, honest discussion about The fact that crew fencing and squash are different from our other sports in that they're not Section 1 sanctioned sports. We love being able to do these, but they carry a cost. They're all outside rentals and carry a cost and have different challenges with them. So we are using this tonight. It's Cindy's turn to present the athletics budget. So this is the time to talk about a potential reduction in expenditures. These costs are included in the proposed budget that you're seeing tonight and that Cindy just described. But I asked her a lot of difficult questions, and she's doing her

035job by answering them. These particular programs and a potential cost savings if we were not to do them or not to do them in the way We've currently done them So can you share some thoughts on each of these, Cindy? Sure. Before I get into each sport, I just want to say, you know, I was looking at all those numbers, and the math teacher in me can't help but start to do some calculations. And when you look at a proposed budget that's almost $200 million, and the athletics budget is somewhere between $2 and $3 million, you know, I think about that as a pie chart. And if I were to see the pie chart, the small, little, tiny, almost not visible slice that the athletics. department takes out of that pie chart makes me very

036protective of every one of those athletics dollars because you know when you look at the big picture it may sound like a lot of money as you see these things but you know preserving athletics and allowing maximum participation i believe is part of this role i also understand the current fiscal environment so this is this is difficult but you know, a necessary piece of what we need to do through this process. So I'll start with crew. And crew is pretty much the most expensive sport we run. As last year's, we contract this out with Pelham Rowing. And last year's contract was... paid at $56,000. We allocated about $60,000 for this year's contract. That came before your board approval just recently. So you've seen that contract. CREW initially started over a decade ago with a grant

037from the Madoff family who covered the $12,000 cost of starting the program back then. Since then, it's been assumed by the athletics budget and the costs have obviously increased five-fold at least. I did consult with other Section 1 schools to see who was offering crew and what their situations are. I didn't get full response. Like, I understand Arlington has a crew. I did not hear from them. But North Rockland and Clarkstown do have crew teams that are funded by the district. Their cost is much less than our PCRA contract is. Wappingers offers crew and provides transportation to the boathouse, but families then cover the costs of participation. for the sport. One of the issues I think that has come up with the crew, particularly the crew situation, is that our rowers, once they go to

038PCRA, are oftentimes placed in boats with rowers that are not part of the Scarsdale High School. rowing team that we send over there, but just other members of PCRA. They get placed, as my understanding, by skill level or other parameters. And additionally, you know, we had, I guess, an issue last year. There's one regatta that is for high school teams only and not the private clubs. And we, you know, are contracted to go to that regatta. The coach at PCRA has typically not allowed our better rowers to go to this event as part of the SHS team. He keeps them back to practice with PCRA for nationals, rowing as a PCRA rower and not a Scarsdale High School rower. So it is an expensive contract. You know, it dwarfs what we pay in ice hockey

039time, which is very well known to be also expensive. We have a head coach's salary. We have an assistant coach's salary. There are bus personnel that we often have to pay for. So the total costs come to roughly, for the team, around the $75,000 mark. And that is... lot when you compare it to the other teams we offer and when you consider it's not a sanctioned sport by New York State Public High School Athletic Association you know it is something that has to be considered now I also know we have a committed group of about two dozen rowers who greatly enjoy that program another small piece of maybe noteworthy information we did have a couple of rowers at our signing day event this past fall and neither one of them rode with our Scarsdale High

040School group they rode with their own private club they're not on the team no I'm talking about this current year's signees yeah I don't want to name them I'm not sure if it's okay squash we contract with seeing as you brought up one of those gentlemen he was one of the gentlemen that was not allowed to go to the regatta because he was asked to stay back because he was one of the better rowers So, squash, we do contract with Westchester Squash. We do not provide a coach for the team. We pay Westchester Squash to do the coaching. We do have a staff member who acts as more of a liaison between the squash, and we also have bus personnel to. accompany our players back and forth to WSA and all of the competitions that

041the teams participate in. We have a JV squash team and a varsity squash team, which means we have about two dozen kids total. The team participates in the Fair West League, which is comprised of teams from Fairfield and Westchester counties. Almost all of our opponents are private squash clubs and not other high schools. This season, the schedule from the Fair West League came out really quite late. There have been several changes along the way to this schedule, and it does present. unique challenge for our office we don't have you know most of our sports get a section one schedule you know it's on our school it's visible it's given to us we can build our schedule we have input in the teams we play when we play them where we play them with something like

042this we have no input it's given to us from the the fair west league and it transportation chaperoning all of those logistics become tricky travel for matches is also you know some of its local some of its as close as Port Chester and it goes as far as Yale University it goes to Chelsea Piers in Stanford Connecticut it can be you know a variety of different places there's some places in Norwalk as well and the scheduling for these you know for example Wednesday night we have a match it's 830 to 1030 p.m. so our student our athletes are out there playing to me that's a late night and it's that's not including the bus ride back So the schedules can be challenging. You know, there's even Sunday matches, which become challenging for busing, and obviously

043the weekends. Attendance has been, you know, we have a bus monitor that we asked this year to take attendance. Attendance has been a little challenging, a little concerning, especially the JV team for what I deem as an expensive contract. I again checked in with some other Section 1 schools to see what happens. Bronxville offers squash. They fund high school squash. Middle school squash is at parents' expense. Briarcliff offers squash. They use Sleepy Hollow Country Club. There's no rental fee for that. They cover the Fair West League fee, and they provide a coach and only some transportation. Rye offers squash, but the players each pay a significant sum to participate. I did not hear back from any of the other teams that may offer, but those were the ones who did get back to me. Cost

044associated with squash, the WSA contract is $16,000. There's roughly $1,600 in league fees and dues. The bus personnel and team coordinator are another several thousand dollars, so it's just over $21,000 allotted to the squash team. Again, not a sanctioned sport. The last one we have is fencing. We contract this one out as well, and the coaching happens at the Fencing Academy. So that's similar to squash. We don't have a coach, again, for that one as well. We do have bus monitors. Unlike squash and crew though. This is the first year the schedule has come from section one. It's more like a pilot So even though it's not New York State Public High School Athletic Association sanctioned section one is starting to Get involved and see if the sport will be viable. However, they had to

045cancel one There were only six competitions scheduled. They had to cancel one because there's such a severe shortage of fencing officials There were five competitions on the schedule, and I've learned a little about fencing for those of you who are not familiar with the sport. Fencing competition requires the team to have four athletes per gender per sword. Three fencers is possible but comes with penalties. There's two swords, and obviously you need a boys' group and a girls' group. We only have two girls on the team, so we did not have a viable girls group. We had to work with the sports scheduler to allow our boys to compete, even though we didn't have the girls. So that took some workings to have that done, and they've allowed it. The teams that have fencing in Section

0461 are Arlington, Ardsley, Clarkstown, Irvington, Nyack, Mamaroneck, Tappan Zee, and Woodlands. All of these teams fund fencing, but most have their own coach and a practice space rather than contracting it out. And our contract, at the cost that we have, only contracts two days a week for coaching. So, you know, most of those schools are doing it as a, you know, with a dedicated coach in-house. Again, you know, we've asked our bus monitor to take attendance and... It's it's been challenging. There's 15 athletes signed up at the team the most we've ever had at a practice is 12 There's an average of nine attending each session The costs associated with the Fencing Academy, the contract is $6,000. The bus personnel and some officials' fees and things like that bring it up to about $9,000. So

047the total cost savings for those three sports is a little over $100,000. That does not factor in transportation costs, which don't come from the athletic. We don't see that as part of the athletics, but we all know transportation has been very challenging. We can only run so many trips a day. um and uh you know having additional strain on the transportation system can be tough so um again i just want to reiterate this is difficult for me to talk about reductions because it's not something i really want to favor because i am protective over every one of those athletics dollars but it's it's the task i was given so thank you thank you very much cindy The rest of tonight's component budgets are in Andrew's purview. I wonder if it makes sense if the board

048has questions for Cindy while it's fresh. That might make sense or not. Yeah. Cindy, a little bit better, the comment you made about the Putnam Rowing Association not allowing a varsity athlete to attend a regatta. Could you describe that? So it's my understanding last year, and I've reached out because it was brought to my attention recently as I was putting all of this information together. So I reached out to speak to the gentleman who runs it, and he has not gotten back to me yet, so hopefully he will soon. But the coach has told me, and I understand this is what's happened in the past, is there's that. particular regatta that is high school only and The gentleman that was named before was one of the kids who last year was told not to go

049and participate to stay back because he was one of our better rowers and Trained for nationals in lieu of going to the high school tournament to to row with the high school scores the high school team Stokes berry Stokes berry. Thank you. There'll be public comment in the next meeting Okay. This is a budget study session. When we wrap this up, we move into the business meeting, and very shortly thereafter, there's public comment. You might need to stay at the podium. Sorry. Cindy, I just had a few questions. Sorry. Thank you for this. I know this is not something you wanted to present. I don't think it's something we wanted to have presented, but appreciate you taking the time to really look at all the athletics and try to identify cost savings. I'm just also

050a little confused about the crew. Do these students also row for that, what, PCR? PCR, Pelham Community Rowing Association. So they also row for that organization? Off-season? I don't know. I'm just curious, like, why was that coach allowed to keep that student back? Okay. All right. Well, maybe you guys can share that when you have public comment, but I'm just confused about. My kid rode crew last year. All the kids who participate in Scarsdale Varsity also are part of Pelham Rowing Association during the Scarsdale season, but the Pelham Rowing Association has a full year operation, and we only have a spring operation. Okay. Thank you. And then you made a referral to a request to increase police presence during all the home football games from one police officer to two. So most of our other,

051Homecoming has two. We added one to the Mariner game because we anticipated a very big crowd, right? It is our quote-unquote rivalry game. But the other home games had none. None at all. None at all. And so you felt there was a need. Yeah. Yeah, I mean, we provide our own chaperones, but there's really nothing like having a police officer standing at the gate or standing there. Most other schools, when we've gone to all the away games, I mean, you go to Rockland, they bring out the horses. It's impressive. You know, crowd control, it can get tricky. You know, there's been a couple of days we've been out there, and, you know, there can be, you know, it gets exciting sometimes. And I feel... You know, I think we do a good job with supervision.

052Our chaperones, our athletic department, our coaches, our parents are mostly great. You know, sometimes some things happen, and I, you know, I sat through a course recently that talked about 80% of the lawsuits related to athletics pertain to supervision. So... Okay. Supervision, I do believe, is... I just want a little bit more information around that. Yeah. So I appreciate it. Providing police officers. It's not cheap. They have a four-hour minimum. And it's just, to me, something that their presence does change the tone. Thank you. Thank you, Cindy, for your presentation today. Appreciate it, hearing the numbers. And you touched a little bit on transportation. I know you didn't have the full numbers, but I'm trying to understand. Do these athletes get transportation to all of their practices? So rowing, we provide. Yes, the buses to

053and from PCRA during the week. It's my understanding some of these regattas, they were on their own to get to, and some of them required travel. As far as fencing and squash, we have been providing the buses to the practices. There were a couple of squash... Matches that we were not going to be able to provide and we let them know because there were just shortages and and parents were able to provide their there but yes for most of them that's that's the model and I think think it was fencing that has maybe the matches or whatever that are kind of further away Do we provide like Norwalk? Are we providing transportation school buses? Okay But I'm sort of curious as to, because I know for hockey, we don't provide transportation to practice. So, yeah,

054well, these kids leave from Scarsdale High School to go there. So when you're talking about that 6 a.m. to 7 a.m. Or even the 3.30 p.m. practice at Murray's right after school, they don't get a bus to practice. So I'm kind of curious as to why these sports are getting buses to practice. That's a fair question. Okay. Thank you. Hi, Cindy. Thank you. So just to clarify one more time, regarding rowing, so they just compete through Pelham Rowing. They're not competing against other high schools except for this one regatta that they're not necessarily always allowed to go to. Correct. Okay. And then I'm just wondering, too, I think it would be helpful to know, as we discuss this as a board, to kind of see more fully, because I know you listed some of the

055peer school districts that include some of these sports. It would kind of be helpful for me at some point to see it. kind of written out, if possible, as we're considering it. And also to understand more fully the participation over the past five years, you know, to know if there's a dip in fencing, if we normally have more girls or not, that kind of thing to understand more fully. Fencing and squash are both within the last couple of years, so we don't have a lot of good data. The crew's been around. little over a decade obviously we have a dedicated group of crew growers because I'm pretty sure that's what a lot of them are behind me so I don't know that attendance has been an issue with that sport I've not you know that's

056not a report I've received but it is one of our you know it falls into the category with squash and fencing just because it's not sanctioned and then I have another question about transportation athletics but I don't know if that should wait for the transportation Why don't you ask and we'll place it in the best spot. So for example, and I know you didn't speak to this specifically, but like for football or JV football, and I know sometimes the league we are in determines where the kids get bused to North Rockland, right? Arlington, yes. Arlington, Suffern, instead of, and I know there are different sizes of districts and things like that, instead of Rye or... Just to understand more fully if there's a way to kind of look at that for this next year to

057save time and money. That's not possible. So for football, geography is a non-starter in Section 1. I've been on those conversations for at least, you know, this. Short time I've been in this role, but I did ask the history of it because to me geography makes sense right as an outsider It does not in section one and the reason why they went to the leagues that we're in and it does require a decent amount of travel for football mostly is is level of skill and the size of the schools and If we were to go back to geography too many of our local schools would pull out and become independent And they've already stated that that if we go back to geography will go independent Which means they get to build their own schedule and

058they're not eligible for postseason. They won't compete in the leagues They just won't compete against teams like us and suffer in North Rockland and my Marinic They just they know they can't even though they're in our size school They know they can't compete and that's unfortunately for us Some of the ones that are really close by and would be great a team like Rye who has great football in their league would likely not ever choose to play up in a league our size. They may win, I don't know, but they would probably not choose it. So even though they have good football programs in the lower levels, they're not looking to play out of league. Thank you, that's very helpful. Okay. Thanks, Cindy. What would be helpful for me before contemplating cutting anything from our

059students would be... broad analysis of what this you know cost per participant looks like across all athletics to me you know just picking non-sanctioned athletics like we do a lot of stuff here that doesn't follow the trend we don't offer AP classes here you know everybody else does so I understand the challenges of it but I think if we're gonna be looking then I think we need to look for me personally Just that, you know, what is the cost per participant, that kind of analysis. I heard you just before this talk about all the increases in other sports for trainers, police, ambulance, new equipment. That might be warranted, but I just think that's the type of analysis I would personally like to see. I know it's some work, but before we cut anything for our

060kids, that's what I'd like to talk about. Thanks. Sure. Thanks, everybody. Excuse me, sorry. I'm very sorry. We have public comment and... No, I'm sorry. This is out of order. This is out of order. Should we take a recess? Yes? Okay. We will be taking a brief recess. Thank you. We're going to move on to transportation, and Andrew will pick up from here. Thank you, Drew. So this next slide is our summary of transportation expenses for next year. As the draft budget currently presents it, our transportation budget is going up. Just 1.6 percent year-to-year or eighty eight thousand dollars in total Wage increases for our drivers are projected to go up four point five percent We have also included in this budget three large EV buses or electric buses that will be partially funded through

061the EPA grants that we previously discussed at this board table and Some NYSERDA funding that we believe is available to help supplement that EPA funding Additionally, due to the aging fleet of minivans, we are requesting two gasoline-powered minivans as part of this year's budget. Minivans are the workhorse of our fleet due to the extensive use for our out-of-district runs, both general ed and special ed, and we anticipate needing to use those buses extensively over the next 10 years as we slowly transition our fleet over to zero-emissions buses through 2035. This budget, I should note, given the conversation we just had a moment ago, does include transportation costs related to contract transportation for our athletic department, including coach buses when those are needed for various sports and events. So I'd like to take a few minutes

062now just to discuss our plans for EV bus conversion and the impact that it will have on this budget for 25-26. To do that, I'd like to take a little bird walk for a second and do a brief history of how we arrived at where we are today. Under the current state law, all school buses sold in New York State must be zero emissions by 2027. And by 2035, all buses on the road will need to be zero emission buses. In the 23-24 budget, the district conducted a transportation study in two parts. The first part, we utilized our district's internal auditors to review our transportation operations for efficiency and best practices. And then we second hired a firm, Highland Fleet, to perform an electrification study for us. Highland's work was included in a... Highland's work

063included an exploration of opportunities and barriers and outlined a transition plan to the 2035 deadline for zero emissions buses as well. This study was presented to the board last October and is attached to that board agenda. On the next slide, Highland was also instrumental in the district applying for EPA grant funding and helped us achieve $800,000 in EPA grants. The Highland electrification plan that was issued included an overview of the infrastructure needs, recommended vehicle procurement schedule that took into account not only the age of our buses, but the mileage demands we place on each of them, and a phased approach to the infrastructure build-out and cost estimates for completing this work. For anyone who's looking for more information on this plan, you can find Highland's work attached to item number 11.02 of the October 2024

064board agenda. Now, with all this background in mind, we then began to review how we might be able to accomplish the task of fleet electrification. Broadly speaking, we have two options for electrification of our fleet. First is go it alone, or we can partner with an experienced firm. To go it alone would actually require extensive work with others outside the district. Everything from procurement specifications for vehicles and chargers to design and build out the infrastructure necessary needed to be coordinated by the district. High voltage maintenance work would need to be done by trained technicians that we do not currently have on staff or through the village. We'd need help searching and applying for grants that would be needed to offset the significant costs of electric buses. We would have several financing options to work through,

065and we would ultimately be responsible for the power consumption of all these EV buses. Alternatively, we could seek to partner with an outside company that would assume all of these responsibilities and others. This company would essentially project manage the entire rollout and cover the majority of the operating and maintenance expenses of this new fleet. The costs would be spread over a 10-year period as a lease stream, and future vehicles, as they are purchased, could be folded into this new agreement in a per-unit basis in a variety of different ways. So our recommendation is this second option, and we would partner with Highland Fleet to do that. So recommendation option number two, the rationale for this recommendation, as noted... on this slide boils down to two general reasons. We would immediately acquire the knowledge base necessary

066to implement this conversion utilizing an experienced EV fleet operator in Highland Fleet. And two, it is a fiscally responsible approach to this challenge. Why is this fiscally responsible? The commitment we are suggesting would only be phase one of this infrastructure and maintenance and management agreement for four buses. We would maintain the flexibility to change our approach to financing of future investments based on industry changes and the availability of expertise locally if it should further develop in the coming years. This budget would include $64,000 as a placeholder for this lease stream, and this number is based on six months of a proposed leasing model that Highland Fleet has proposed to us based on their understanding of our fleet needs in the coming year. This novel approach to financing district transportation options, which NYSED has been working

067on with Highland Fleet due to the unique mandate that has been placed on schools across the state. So our next steps would be to include board discussion and perhaps a formal presentation from Highland on their services. We'd need to do some formal negotiations with Highland to determine the terms and scope of their work and the ultimate price that we would be charged. And those negotiations would need to include input not only from our school attorney, but also from NYSED directly in order to maximize the transportation aid we receive on these expenses. I recognize that was a lot to go over in a short amount of time, but I thank you for your patience. And if I've got any questions on that for the board, maybe I should stop there for transportation. Andrew? Sure. Can you

068just speak? So the infrastructure would be at the current bus depot? It would. That's shared with the village? Okay, and can you clarify, maybe talk a little bit more about, has there been communication between the schools and the village about this potential project? In general, yes. So we've been speaking with the village because they are simultaneously looking to outfit their section of that property for their electric sanitation vehicles that they've been purchasing. So we've actually put in touch. Highland fleet with the village engineer to talk about some of the due diligence that Highland fleet did for our electrification study to understand the capacity needs that we would have based on our phase rollout and they could mirror that with their or merge that with their needs for the Sanitation vehicles so that Con Ed could

069support the site in total for both Thank you Yeah, thank you. That was very interesting. My question is, are we allowed as a district to create a relationship or a contract with Highland Fleet without doing it in a competitive format? Because normally as a public entity, it's required to receive competitive bids on. So I'm just curious how that would work. So this particular agreement that Highland Fleet offers is actually, has already been competitively bid through a cooperative purchasing agreement that is kind of the governing document that Highland built the model around. That has been reviewed with NYSID, and they've been supportive of the concept going forward. Thanks for the subject just a quick question. So this 64,000 is for three buses. It's actually for four It's for the three buses were purchasing in the 2526

070budget proposed also you saw tonight and the one we're going to attempt to buy this year with our remaining resources in the transportation of vehicle line, okay got it and this is This is a number, it says placeholder. I'm trying to just get a sense of scale, like we're pretty comfortable with this number. I am, for two reasons. One, I do have an estimate from Highland right now. We've not negotiated terms and conditions, right, so that number will change based on the actual scope that we finally agree to. But their bills would not start. until the infrastructure has been built out and i find it quite challenging for them to think that they could get this infrastructure fully built out and operational you know by six months into the next fiscal year so likely they

071would probably start closer to to you know the end of next fiscal year billing us okay so this is the financing charge for the buses the lease payments, and all of their other work? So it would cover, in theory, again, because this is the starting of the discussion, it would cover the infrastructure build-out, all the permitting required, and the construction cost. And it would cover, from a maintenance perspective, all of the high-voltage maintenance for the vehicle, all the electric for the buses, all the fleet optimization and routing work that they could help us with their expertise. as we try to assign buses to routes. And... The electricity cost? The electricity cost, yeah, the fuel cost. And I'm missing something else. Does it include the buses? Well, we're buying those buses. So in this model, we

072would own the buses and the drivers, of course, and everything else about the EV buses would be financed through this lease stream. Okay, so in the budget... for next year are three buses net of our grants. Yes, correct. And this is for everything else. So the software around the charge maximization and the charging stations, right, that was the other piece that I was forgetting a moment ago. It says next steps that there could be a possible presentation by Highland Fleet. What would the timeframe of that be? We don't have many budget sessions. We would work to factor it into these budget conversations. Certainly there'd be a lot of work to do over the next month to get a more firm understanding of the contractual relationship that we'd be entering into and put a more firm

073proposal from Highland in front of the board. And I think that it would be appropriate for Highland. probably describe their services themselves rather than me trying to do that for them. Yeah, that would be very helpful. Thank you so much. Maybe we could target budget study session number three. I think the important thing that I was hoping to get is, is there an appetite from the board to pursue this particular model, which is new and unusual because of the novelty of electric buses across the state. Are you looking for an answer tonight on that? Not directly, but we'll get a sense, I think, in the next few days of discussion. Anybody else? Should we move on then? Thank you, Andrew. So, still me. I will now transition to our operations budget discussions. Currently, our proposed

074budget for operations and maintenance is increasing by $333,000 across both categories. We continue to see rising costs in the contractual lines for various professional service contracts and the work of various trades that supplement our maintenance staff across the district. Notably included in this category is funding for the pre-bond work that our architect and engineer and our construction managers will do as part of the RFP process that we had them propose and we awarded in January. The staffing levels of the proposed budget are remaining flat year to year based on our current staffing makeup. And just as a good reminder, it is helpful to remember that we have almost a million square feet of space across the district and 118 acres that's manicured and taken care of by our maintenance and facility staff across all of

075our buildings, and we really appreciate the good work that they do. If I would transition here from operations maintenance to capital projects, perhaps. It's slow for some reason. That's okay. That's all right. I've been accused of being slow as well. The transfer to capital is a portion of the budget that is facilities related, but this is the large capital project work that we fund through the operating budget. We're proposing in this year's budget two major pieces. One is the implementation of the first kind of component of the joint field study that we did with the village. the final results of which are still pending but we put a placeholder in the budget to accomplish some of that work and the second piece is we began to think about the the necessary replacement of many of

076the aging playground structures across our entire district this $250,000 that's noted for that certainly would not do all buildings but it would do one building for a new modern place structure and we have some thoughts on how that would kind of be implemented across the across the district. I'm also suggesting that we include about $200,000 or exactly $200,000 in this budget to do related repair, building repair work, both internal and external, that would be coupled with the work for the fields or the playground in order for us to maximize the building aid associated with that project. work outside the building site work such as fields or play spaces you really need to have something happening inside the building in order for us to get state aid on any portion of that project so that that

077was the rationale behind that and we do have an extensive list of smaller projects in our building condition survey that was done last time that that we could put plenty of things for each of our school buildings on that list that would accomplish that roughly hundred thousand dollars per building in that category. So I'm just going to share a few more words about two of those three, not the one Andrew just referred to. But first, the field study implementation. We've been hard at work. I want to thank Ron publicly for all the time that he has spent in particular in conversation to get the field study report in a really good format to be clear and answer the questions as clearly as possible that we asked and charged CHA with. We anticipate a presentation of

078the report at our next meeting on March 3rd, so there'll be more detail about that, but because we're covering this section of the budget tonight, we wanted to put out there. a commitment to or propose a commitment to begin some of that work that we'll look at in detail on March 3rd. As for the playgrounds, we are, Andrew's correct, our five elementary schools, while there's a range of ages in the playground structures themselves, many of them are at or close to exceeding their useful life. And we're at a decision point now. around whether we try to repair knowing that the repair would be temporary. Obviously, we do not, we make every piece of equipment safe. We get it inspected regularly. But to make a decision about continuation or taking something out of service, we're really

079at a point where we need to do some replacement. We we I know we have a bond conversation coming up, but we review the the playgrounds as Possibly something that we could really try to tackle outside of that knowing there'll be more than we can possibly do In a coming bond so we I've been in conversation with our friends at the Scarsdale schools Education Foundation and with our parent teacher associations to potentially think about viewing these replacement projects as a student and family engagement opportunity to sort of co-design what the desired needs and desires are of each individual school and look for three-way partnership where the foundation, the PTAs, and the school district are contributing money together toward trying to achieve a renewed playground site for each of the schools. So those conversations have been

080ongoing for the last several months. We're at this point in the budget process where we think putting a dollar amount out there is necessary to not put bad money into something that we know needs replacing and that we would move forward in the next several months to try to develop a clear picture and a commitment from each of those parties to help. achieve this across probably will take more than one year but to achieve this across all five of our elementary schools take questions on capital thank you for that information actually I have a question about the playgrounds so the Greenacres playground is recently updated but you said all five elementary schools what are you thinking about so there so which which one So there's a brand new village playground at Green Acres that's not

081the property of the district. Okay, so you're thinking about the other playgrounds. The other pieces of equipment. And then the other elementary schools each have, I assume, two playgrounds as well. So are we considering all those other, I'm going to say, eight and then one Green Acres, nine playgrounds? Yeah, I think we're viewing the playground, whether it's... connected or in separate locations as one one entity okay where there are two separate spaces and where there is an older one in the newer will obviously focus on the older one to bring that up but you know I think our intentions looking at the ages of everything generally we're talking 30 closing in on 30 years old for many of them many of the pieces of equipment thank you I just had a question about the PTA

082potentially fundraising for the playgrounds. Would it be then by school as opposed to a pooled amount? I don't think they can do that necessarily, but we have a gifting policy of equity, so it would be something that we'll have to watch carefully. Agreed. I think we would... What the intention is is to design the process together across those five schools and PTAs go about their design. We're generating just a first initial cost estimate from a vendor for like a replacement level and then quite a bit nicer level to have end members of a range share that with all five schools. and think collectively as we go through proposing a process and anticipating an amount that any entity might gift. Also knowing there's a metric we have some ideas about, but to understand the sort of

083equipment per student ratio, if you will, because some schools are larger and some schools are bigger and more kids or fewer kids are sharing the playground at any one time. I think those considerations are very valuable and helpful. Thank you. Anybody else? I just wanted to say, too, because I recall that this has been an advocacy issue for PTC and the PTAs for the past several years. So, you know, not to opine on it per se, but I think it's nice to see that there's movement forward. The question I have, Andrew, just in terms of placeholder. So when you have the 1.25 million placeholder, So that's how, is that something that you'd foresee, like being in the budget for five years as part related to field study work, playground work? Is that something that would

084just be part of facilities eventually? Let me take one step back for a second and just remind the implications of the capital line and the debt service line as well. These have impacts. on the tax cap, tax levy cap. So trying to look at maintaining or at least continuing to contribute to those lines in order to minimize swings in the peaks and valleys in the tax cap. We put placeholder in this budget conversation. It would be a 25-26 funding line. The placeholder concept being we're not certain at this moment without the field study being 100% finalized. Which component of that field study we would be presenting as part of this budget We've got an inkling based on cost estimates that have been received by the district in the village, but We don't want to kind

085of get ahead of ourselves too far. I have um, what about synergistic for a minute? Sure. Yeah, so Are they hitting their targets? So if you recall earlier this year, we did do a contract amendment with them to lower. Are they hitting their revised lower targets? We have yet to see the heating season is driving some of that so If they don't understanding they didn't have somebody here full-time for a while. Are they gonna lower it again? That would be a topic of conversation for sure. Yeah, so I just want to be clear either they're gonna hit it or we're gonna ask them to lower it and adjust our budget If they choose not to lower it, they still do owe us a credit for not achieving that number. So we did get a credit

086at the end of last year's, well, last contractual year for them, and that was applied to this year's invoices. And they're giving us detailed reports proving whether they're hitting their targets? There's an online app that Drew and I have access to, and John Antonichelli and the maintenance staff and I have been reviewing that. We certainly go back and... We ask them to refine things based on work we're doing that would generate the savings based on our investment, not theirs. Right. I just want to make sure, you know, this has been a bumpy road. Great idea, bumpy road. These things happen. But I want to make sure that this doesn't turn into a cost for us rather than a savings, which is what we paid for. Yep. I think I should say that this has been

087an eye-opening experience for us, right? It certainly changed the philosophy of our building management in terms of temperature, both hot and cold. I think it also highlighted to the maintenance staff several of the existing building conditions that I don't want to say have become in disrepair, but certainly didn't support the dynamic management of building temperature that Synergistics kind of has. kind of developed as their model. So we're finding trouble. So we're finding that there's lots of existing building conditions that need repair. And now that we know them... We are taking efforts to repair those things through our, you'll see in the contractual line of our operations maintenance budget, you know, we're investing in those repairs. And those are the types of things I was mentioning earlier. We're trying to make sure that we get credit

088for that investment, not Center Logistics, although the discussions have highlighted those items. Thank you. So just to confirm, sorry, excuse me, the liaison person is staffed right now? It is staffed right now, yeah. They've had quite a bumpy road. The first, I'd say, eight or ten months, we had a really good energy manager. We then had a bit of a revolving door. The most recent energy manager has been on staff for, I'd say, about a month now. Really working hard to learn the district learn the synergistic way because he was hired newly to synergistic But I must say that there's there's a whole cavalry of synergistic staff that have been throughout our buildings for the last year whether they be programmers for our BMS system actual mechanics working on different boiler items, even doing some

089replacements of things on their dime just to help continue to achieve those energy savings. So they've really tapped into their knowledge base across their company on quite a regular basis in the effort to try to attain the savings they've now committed to. BBS and ARIS are going to be doing their facilities walkthrough soon too, right? So do you anticipate they might have ideas on this front as well? Yeah, we actually had a kickoff meeting, and Drew will talk more about it later this evening, but I think we had a kickoff meeting where the topic of synergistic and partnership with ARIS and BBS was discussed at that meeting. We're going to come back to that discussion in more detail, but certainly they are all on board. Sorry to jump in. No, that's okay. Thank you. All

090right, we're getting there. I think we're turning the corner here. So debt service and lease payments, this is our budget projection for next year. We've tried to maintain a flat debt service and lease budget line. The one increase you'll see here is regarding the interest payment that's due for the ban on our auditorium project. A ban is a bond anticipation note. We issued that note last fall. It comes due next fall, and at that point we anticipate we would finance. the full bond project at that point as all of our expenses should be done at that point. All of the building project bills will be paid, we hope. Included also in this budget is the lease for technology devices that happens through the Genie Corrales office. Last year we introduced a lease for some large

091maintenance equipment including some significantly large mowers that help with our field mowing. And then you'll see that last year the energy performance contract expired. That was done several years prior. That's that's the summary of that and then the next chart basically is a visual of the debt service as we look out for the next several years The small circle there in yellow that that that is the interest only payment on the debt for the auditorium That was at the top there. I've currently projected the bond In the out years based on what was presented at the time of the auditorium project being presented to the voters We don't have any better information at this point. So hold that number steady going forward. And then employee benefits. So this chart shows the various benefits categories we

092offer to all of our employees. All of our employee benefits are either mandated through law or collective bargaining agreements. And overall, our benefits are increasing $4.3 million in the draft budget. And we'll talk more about the larger components in the next few slides. But I'll pause there for just a moment as there is a lot to read on the slide. The next slide, we presented last meeting in draft format based on the Estimated TRS and ERS rates. Since our last meeting, the TRS rate has been refined to 9.59. Previous was 9.5 to 10%. We were assuming 10%. So you'll see, based on the proposed budget salaries in the draft budget, the TRS contribution for next year actually declines by about $175,000, and our estimated increase for ERS is increasing $425,000. The TRS rate is estimated

093because that rate will not be finalized until July, but the ERS rate is an average rate across the entire employee's retirement system, but it has been set and is finalized based on the current rate. And we certainly need to continue to talk about our self-funded health plan and the ongoing labor negotiations, so those are still on there from our last meeting. Okay, so... As you saw from the budget presentation, our self-insured health plan is a big budget driver of increase. So I thought it made sense tonight just to share a little bit of background information for the board and the public. I know the board is aware of this through many instances, but including negotiations. But we do operate a self-insured health plan. For those who don't know, that means that we budget for and

094pay for all of the health claims for our eligible employees and retirees on an annual basis. rather than have an insured product where the individual or family premium is a fixed number that we pay to an insurance company to deliver the services. Now, we have two major partners in this. We have a third-party planned administrator. They are UMR, and that relationship gives us access to a network like... Anyone who uses health care is probably familiar with in-network and out-of-network. So we have a network of doctors and hospitals and so on that have negotiated rates negotiated by UnitedHealthcare that helps control our costs. We also... We organize ourselves into a health advisory committee that meets quarterly to examine the trend of claims and the experience of the plan. We have a consultant, so our second partner

095is a consultant through One Digital. His name is Pat Cowburn. He's been with us for over two decades, is very familiar with the plan. He's there to represent the board and the district's interests. One of the things that has given us the ability to tolerate the ups and downs of a self-insured plan where when we pay for every claim, you can have a number of people with a very negative health experience in a given year push beyond the budget that you anticipated, but we have the allowance under New York State law to hold a reserve specific to health. insurance or our self-insured health plan. So that reserve has been used over time to smooth out the differences. So in a year where claims and costs exceed what we budgeted, we're responsible for paying those, unlike...

096an insured product. However, in years where we underspend the budget, we don't have to pay that because we've paid less in claims. And the under years are how we fund the reserve and the over years are when we draw down the reserve. So we thought it made sense just to share a little bit about the current year claims experience. Part of the challenge is we are We have six months of planned data with six months to go. So everything we do is an estimate of what the year end will be. Of course, each month brings us the real detail because it's the real experience. So the graph on the top left shows our budgeted versus actual expenditures and illustrates the difference between our monthly budgeted plan costs in the current year that we're experiencing this

097year and the actual experience costs. Our budgeted amount includes claims, administrative, projected claims and administrative costs, our collection of premium share from users of the plan. projected Medicare Part D premiums and the claim costs currently this year are running 25% higher than last year resulting in a negative budget performance of about $539,000 through December with additional that always gets cleaned up additional payables but also receivables for example we get rebates from our prescription drug plan and other things So we take that information and we project. So when we look at the bottom right, we're looking at actual versus projected claim comparison showing the performance with the total plans compared claim projections for the current year. So the current projection that we planned for this year was a 7.8% increase from the prior year. Right now,

098claims are presently running 24% higher than last year, resulting in a 15% increase to our one-year projected claims. So this is the detail behind what Andrew showed before of expenses higher than budget in the current year in this area. This shows the sort of growth over... Sorry, I don't know why that... There it is. This shows the growth back to 1999-2000 of our self-insured health plan, inpatient, outpatient, major medical, and the drug plan, and just showing... Steeper ups lower ups some downs year to year this kind of illustrates the difference between a self-insured plan whereas in a in a Insured plan certainly there would never be a doubt very likely not be a down And you'd see different a different cost trend We do ask ourselves the question every year around the budget process and

099certainly when we go into negotiations with the Teachers Association around the health plan. Is it still beneficial to the district to remain on a self-insured plan or is it more prudent to consider an insured product? One of the ways we look at that is to compare ourselves to... Probably the biggest public plan, the Empire Plan. And this is a graph we include in the budget book every year. There is some year-to-year variation, but the red bar shows the Scarsdale plan. The blue shows what the equivalent cost would be on premiums. And over the period of this graph, which is roughly 10 years, On this estimate, our plan, the self-insured plan, has saved $24 million collectively over the empire plan. So we continue, while we recognize the volatility and having several years in a row of

100higher than expected health claims because people are sicker than... We would want them to be, obviously. We don't want that. We still believe that staying in the self-insured plan is fiscally sound and prudent and that we should continue to think and have a discussion around this table around how to prudently use the health reserve to try to... mitigate some of these fluctuations. I think one of the things that we've asked, well definitely one of the things that we've asked our consultant and UMR to work together to analyze is what accounts for this adverse claim experience. So we know some of the high level detail, but to drill into individuals and their health experience and determine as detailed a way as possible, is it right to expect that experience to continue for those individuals? Or are

101these more conditions that will be resolved? And does that influence our projection for right now? In the budget you're seeing tonight, the health budget projection for next year is built off of the the negative projection for this year. So not the budgeted amount, but the higher experience that we're having and predicting out to June. We want to make sure that's a valid decision, or should we be making the budget increase for next year on the health budget from a lower projection for this year, depending on what we learn about the individuals having this health experience this year, whether it's likely to continue or not. I hope that makes sense. So again, we're in February 3rd. It's early. We don't have January claims yet, so there's more information that will come in that could cause us

102to revise either direction the health budget for next year. our fingers are crossed that it will improve, but we'll see. So really as we think about next steps, we did think it was important to take a second on the health plan and we can certainly answer additional questions or come back to that if the board desires. Our next steps, just to go back to the beginning, is we expect to be proposing a budget that is at or under the tax cap, not above. To do that right now, we still have work to do. What we presented to you tonight is about $2 million above the tax levy cap that Andrew calculated. So what we are going back to do in the next month, we don't meet again for a month, is to review, go through

103all of our codes again, our lines and our priorities. It's what we would do anyway, but... is there anything that we included that we didn't need to is there anything that we can lower or delay or put off to a future year refiner revenue assumptions is there more positive news on the revenue front because the revenue also helps close that gap we know we're going to have to identify further expense reductions we talked about some of them tonight that have already been made we talked about one that is a concept and then of course thoughtful consideration of of uncertainties we know for example that there's been you know activity at the federal level that suggests some federal funding might be in jeopardy although it's you know been put on hold the The federal government did

104clarify after the executive order that froze some federal payments that they did not intend to include What's our biggest source of federal funding which is special education funding we get about 1.1 million dollars in that in special ed funding But it's just it would be foolish not to acknowledge that that's a potential uncertainty Andrew talked about state aid it does seem from Our meetings with our elected representatives that maybe there's going to be a focus elsewhere, not on state aid for the budget conversation this year, but again, it's the governor's proposal. It's not yet enacted into law, so that's always a variability. We will certainly keep an eye on that. And that's our presentation. Does anyone have any questions? Oh, just the budget timeline again. I'll leave that up there while we. Well, thank you.

105Bob. Yeah. Regarding the graph that shows the increase in health care costs over the last, say, 10, 11 years, whatever, is it fair to say that in conjunction with health care costs going up, we've also increased our staffing numbers? So if you have more people, it doesn't necessarily mean people are sicker. It could mean that we have more people. Therefore, people could, in fact, be healthier, but there are just more of them. So I think we want to be careful not to conflate an increase in health care costs with some. epidemiological trend as opposed to the fact that obviously we're serving more people if we look at our staffing is that is that a correct you bring up a point I totally overlooked and I appreciate you bringing that up we can come back to

106you with that's probably a graph we should have included is our census over time so we call it the census they're the number of covered lives in the plan right we have added staff that doesn't necessarily mean that staff takes the health plan. That's not always the case. We also cover retirees and they come off our health plan when they're no longer alive. So actually our census is more stable than you would expect. In this particular year, the data that we actually had our health advisory committee for this quarter last week is actually showing exactly what I said is. a greater number of adverse health experiences for individuals than normal. And that's represented by, you know, whatever, a larger than usual number of individuals with higher total claims, which means they're sicker or going through

107some kind of, you know, experience that's adverse. So it is true what I said, but it's also important to put it in the context that you brought up of the census. Could I just I just had one other question I don't know if this is a controversial suggestion or not, but I know that in some districts There are periods of time when districts offer incentives for long-standing faculty or staff to retire because if I'm correct in saying that someone who, let's say, has been in the district 30, 40 years, there could be, when they replace, a lowering of that salary for that position. so that I know from my own family situation that school districts sometimes try incentivize people that are sort of on the fence. They're not sure if this is the year they

108want to do it, but if you offer them a stipend to encourage them to do it, it may be a tipping point. And it seems to me one potential avenue of savings would be to voluntarily replace people with younger teachers that you know to you know to fill the position but lower the it just I don't know if Scarsdale does that but I know it is it is a tool that districts use so I don't know if you want to say anything on that Megan so we do have for faculty if they announce their retirement by January 15 there is a dollar amount that they receive. So that allows us to, at least in this process, help plan and look at what the potential savings. But obviously we honor all of their experience and having

109those experienced faculty members is an asset to our school district. But there is that built in to our January 15th. And behind the scenes, we do account for that. So you saw there were nine retirees on the agenda last meeting, last week. We know what all their salaries are, and we have an average replacement for that that we do calculate as part of our cost savings in the budget. And it's real. It's just a fact. It's not a comment on anybody's experience, but you're right on. Well, I got questions. Oh, good. I want to start with the health plan first. I mean, this is a very precarious situation we're in because it's not the first year of bad results. And we had the same discussion last year. So a couple things. I'd love to get

110the, not here, but before the next meeting, sort of the underlying calculations that compares us to this empire plan. I'm personally struggling to understand how the empire plan is so much more given. very high level of benefits that we offer and that we expanded benefits this year. So I would like to see that calculation a little bit in more detail from our consultant. I'd like to talk a little bit about the planned use of reserves for next year. If we go back to the slide with the reserves, we were at $5 million of health reserves not too long ago. It's supposed to be for these times, but If it happens year after year, we have to start asking ourselves, is this just the new normal? Maybe it's not, but we have to budget to that.

111I have to tell you, just me personally sitting here, I would not be comfortable budgeting another million dollar drawdown of our health reserve to balance the budget. That would make getting to the tax cap harder, I understand that. But if we... If we pull budget for another million dollars of reserve, we would talk about planning for our health insurance to go down to 1.8. And I just want us to recognize, we actually, everything broke our way on the revenue side this year. State aid came back. We pulled it out of the budget, went up. Interest earnings came back. We are plus $2 million on the revenue side. This should be the year we can drop money to fund balance. All else being equal, if you had told me without the expense side, we're plus $2

112million on the revenue side, I would have said, amazing. This is the year we're going to be able to fund our reserves back up. It's better than what we budgeted. But even with that $2 million in the plus, we're still budgeting to drop our fund balance $1.3 million or $1.4 million. I just have to tell you, it's very concerning for me. as a fiduciary where we sit right here. So I just I think we have to really start thinking about these health insurance numbers until the trend changes in our decision making. I mean, Andrew, I really appreciate the slide you showed, which sort of is the drivers year to year. I mean, I don't remember exactly in past years, but going forward. Let's go to slide 18. Our health plan cost is way higher than

113our salary cost as a driver. It's becoming like the biggest item. I appreciate that we have the census, but as Bob mentioned, if we're talking about adding FTEs, we have to be thinking about these health costs. It's just we want people to get health care and good health care. The plan has to support itself. It has to fund itself. It just can't drop all to the taxpayer. So going forward, I would like to understand a little bit more what the option, I'm not saying we should do it, but I think we need to understand a little bit more of the option of what does NYSHIP look like? What are the options there? I just think it's a prudent thing to do for our taxpayers. I'm not going to speak for the rest of the board,

114but I'm just telling you all, when you come back in March 3rd, that's what I want to tell you now, I'm not comfortable using another million dollars or the $400,000 for TRS and ERS. Because that number is partly based on stock returns. Stock market's been on a tear. Stock market goes down. It is, I think, a five-year weighted average. I don't want to be using our fund balance in the years where we shouldn't be having to use it. I want to save that for those concerning years. I gave you a lot. I'm going to pause there. Can you just clarify? So the assumption or the part of the plan where we proposed including the same level of reserves and fund balance use, you're saying you don't support that? That's correct. Okay. I just think we

115did it last year, we did it the year before. If this is the new normal, I think we have to budget towards it. I think we just have to accept that that's what health costs and we have to then make decisions based on that, which will make some very tough, I acknowledge, will make some very tough decisions. But I just, I can't see continually. running deficit spending. I mean, that's what we are doing. We have been doing. We've been doing it. We did it last year because of the state aid uncertainty and some other things, but we still have a lot of uncertainty. I think our fund balance, you know, I will note not only is our fund balance going down, our budget is going up. So as a percent of our budget, that gap

116is increasing even more. I will just say also while I'm talking, I will see what happens with the rest of the stuff. I do just want to give the feedback. I recognize a lot of the things that were presented to us for reductions were student experience items. I would have expected to see those to be the last things we talk about, not the first. I don't. I personally support touching our class sizes. I think that's a core value of what people believe in here. So I just wanted to share that before March 3rd so you had that feedback. This is a big period where you would do a lot of work. Thank you, Susie. I actually had a similar subject area with Teron. My question was initially what do we want or need to keep

117in our health insurance reserve? Because I noted as well we're taking $1 million out for this budget and that it's been cut in half basically, depleted over the last five years. and that was concerning. The fund balance, the assigned fund balance slide, I just want to make sure I understand it all. So this is the portion of the unassigned fund balance that gets assigned to go toward the annual budget in a given year, right? So in 2021, still COVID, we had assigned two plus million from an unassigned fund balance to pay toward the annual budget to reduce the tax levy. And then we've gradually reduced that number over the past five years to 1.1. Where we are now is this so is this a norm? Does this seem like a general range that is good

118best practice to use from the fund balance? I'm just thinking about fund balance depletion stuff like that. Yes So the assigned fund balance really that's our undesignated fund balance that we're using for the following year. I mean, I think When you say norm, do you mean Scarsdale norm or do you mean just norm in general? Because I think the context that we need to have is how much flexibility is in the budget to generate savings, whether it be conservative revenue estimates or budgeting with flexibility that ultimately drives savings in the budget. So the more confidence we have that our budget has flexibility. the more we can be confident that we're going to generate fund balance to kind of replenish that use of reserves. Now, that could be the health reserves that we're talking about or

119the unassigned fund balance. I think that the challenge that we're facing is as we continue to budget tighter and tighter, you know, Dr. Patrick talked about removing two contingency positions from our budget, right? Much like the excess revenue this year, if we didn't need the contingency budget items, that would be available fund balance to do things with. difficult financial times put pressure in multiple aspects of our budget-making process. And I think the $1.1 million we do feel is still attainable in the current context of the economics. Perhaps it's appropriate. I think I also want to add though when we talk about the health reserve and and the retirement reserve You know we were able to put money back into the health reserve at the end of last year because as things became more clear and

120the final financials were Kind of posted we had money available we thought it was appropriate to maximize unassigned fund balance of 4% and Still put money back in the reserves to help replenish that Thanks for bringing up the contingency. That was actually one of my questions, like what are the implications of not including it? Financially, but also one other question related to specifically to reserves at this point We're all will our reserve levels impact our ability to go to bond and is that something that you foresee being an issue? Next year at the current levels that we're projecting right now. I don't believe so in fact some of the early kind of messaging that I think leads me to be comfortable in that is we recently had our New York State fiscal Stress fiscal stress

121monitoring and and we've got no designation and no designation basically is you know like the orders say a clean opinion, right? Like there's no signs of fiscal stress now. They're looking at the 20,000 foot view But based on on the data that they look at they still think we have a solid tax base Support of community and a fair amount of reserves in the general state context Thank you. And yeah, my question related to contingency, you know, what are the other, which you kind of touched on, what are the other implications, if any, of not budgeting for contingency? And as you mentioned, and I've learned from previous conversations, right, for example, if we budget for two contingency and one is not used, that money does potentially roll over to our fund balance and kind of

122helps keep it going. And also, you know, if we don't have contingency, would a position be pulled? I know we wouldn't do a class break, but is it possible during the year we would be searching for money for something, and then would that come from the fund balance if we don't have that extra cushion of a contingency? Yeah, I'll say something slightly different than the way Drew said it a minute ago. So Drew mentioned in his section earlier that if we have a section that we've got five kids moved into a certain building and all of a sudden that grade is over, nothing prevents the board from giving us the directive. use unassigned fund balance to appropriate it in August to hire an additional teacher that wasn't budgeted, right? Like, we're just deferring that decision,

123but it requires the board to act, whereas if we have the contingency position in the budget, we can simply move forward with hiring. So we are somewhat kind of... delaying that hiring decision to when the data comes in on student enrollment and the board then gives us the authorization to move forward. And it gets pulled from fund balance and isn't necessarily a levy. Correct. At that point, the levy would be set in May. So that's just whatever. Sorry, the budget would be set in May and the levy in July. But, yeah, we wouldn't increase the levy for that. And then just a few questions related to class. Well, not really class size, just a comment and a few questions related. So I agree with Ron. I think preserving elementary class size is a hallmark of

124our school district, and I would be wary of any shifts. I feel like it's a slippery slope and will affect student experience and quality of learning. Many elementary classrooms, you know, specifically those with ICT, when you get the extra adults, they're full spaces, and I think we've seen that when we tour the schools, or I've seen that when I've toured the schools. And, you know, would this potentially further strain our physical spaces if we're having, you know, larger class sizes? you know the additional adults not larger but kind of consistently having a larger class size um you know i would be interested to know potentially you know before if we talk about this further how much change there tends to be in terms of new student ads from post-adopted budget before august 15th to understand

125you know how often it breaks um and then for attrition Would that just be an evaluation, like a yearly evaluation, like we'd see what happens if we're not replacing a teacher or a faculty member in a given year? But would that potentially create spikes and dips in our... I'm just thinking about kind of other issues related to that. I mean, every year is its own unique budget year. I mean, obviously there are patterns and trends and all of that. If we made a decision that did not seem sustainable... adversely impacted the student experience nothing would prevent us from you know coming forward the next budget cycle and saying we need to you know restore this position the problem is how do we pay for that and to avoid the spike it would be to not

126fund something else I mean it goes back to the trajectory under the tax cap means at least right now with everything the way it is that expenses to run school somewhat driven by external forces somewhat by decisions we've made this board has made are exceeding the revenue available without changing what we do and I in a budget that's 80% people and you know I don't know how to achieve reductions that don't in some way, shape, or form involve the adults. Thank you. And then just related to that, I'm just thinking again of AT stats. And I know that this was pulled out. And I was a little curious as to why it was pulled out. I didn't know if you felt that that was direction from the board or that was just part of trying

127to realize you wanted to, you know. get closer to the cap. But also, you know, looking at enrollment numbers for AT stats and seeing 28 students, 29 students in a very challenging AT class, I'd imagine that student experience is affected. So I just want to put that out there. I don't know if we're going to still discuss this at any point. And I understand, you know. the potential that this was an ask to add and then you're pulling that back to get closer to the cap which i totally you know understand is a very serious part of our discussion i just wanted to understand are we is that no longer something that is going to be considered at all Is this going to be an opportunity for additional comment? I mean, my answer to that

128is that's what this discussion is for. That's what budget study session number two is for. That's what budget study session number three is for. Like, yes, there'll be new things presented at those subsequent budget study sessions. Other components of the budget, we did some of them tonight, but you'll hear from Eric and Edgar and, you know. yeah others but will also provide a revisions to what we've learned you know in another month of experiencing the school year and having expenditures and savings but then also new thinking from our part but yes this is you know the discussion and public comment and all of it is part of it so the floor is open for you to comment on those things throughout this process, including right now. Okay, thank you. Well, I would be open to

129discussing the .5 again at another point in the process just to understand, because I do think those are very large classes for a very challenging subject, and I'd imagine it affects student experience, and just keeping an eye on class size with a holistic view to the budget would be meaningful. Amber. Thank you, Leah and Ron, for your comments. Ron, I actually wanted to say thank you for your candor and your thoughtful comments about your concerns about... I appreciated hearing your thought process and it got me thinking too. I don't necessarily feel as passionately about some of the things you said and shared tonight, but there's one thing that I feel that if we're moving forward, I would agree that having a better understanding of our healthcare options and not just that one graph, which sort

130of shows like, okay, this is what it would cost, like really. diving in a little bit more there because we are facing a difficult situation and drew i don't envy you as you look to to try to stay under the cap um but i think understanding that given that's a big source of our variance this year i think i'd really like to better understand can we drill down on that a little bit so we know what to go do for you know both of you so um so specific to the empire plan The approach that Pat Calvern has taken is to examine our census and apply our census to the rates that are published for the Empire Plan and make some guesses about other ancillary costs that might be associated with it and estimate member

131cost share, right? That we have. can share can share that um and then we can ask pat for maybe those assumptions like what assumptions i think that would be a great place to start and then you know i mean i'd love to take a look at that and just to better understand i don't know all the options for health plans either so if that's the only option that's available if there's other options that are available and i understand that there can be a lot of you know variability and i didn't ask this earlier but And I am not implying that we ever should deny a claim, but I know a lot of insurance companies do deny claims. And I don't know, does a self-insured plan ever deny claims? So the plan defines the benefits that

132are available. Okay. And negotiates. If you have UnitedHealthcare, it's the same doctors, network, and fees, cost per service. And there are... certain so doctors submit the codes that they that represent the services they performed or hospitals do that it goes to our third our tpa their you know our plan manager and it goes through the defined plan benefits and if it's not allowed under the benefit it's denied like that happens all over so yeah i think getting some of that analysis more than just that I feel like, you know, when you look at it, it's hard to imagine that we're $2 million over what we thought we were going to be, and yet we still would be better off with this self-insurance. It just seems it's really hard for me to wrap my head around,

133I guess, is where I'm at. And I think to move forward, having a better understanding of that would be helpful. Just to give you a sense, like the Empire plan, I think the premium cost for the current year for family is almost $30,000. Thank you. I don't have too much because I feel like you have all covered it. I did want to just circle a little bit back to, you know, the things that we have said make Scarsdale Scarsdale, small class size, houses in the middle school, and the high school students having the ability to, you know, take courses that they find, that they feel passionate about. The removal of the .5, I don't know if that, what impact that will have, but I do think it's important that the high school students, you know,

134they have one foot out the door. They need to, if they have a passion or an interest, we need to be able to support that so that as they head out into the world, they can continue to follow those interests and passions. And I know, you know, you sent us some data now on enrollment today. I appreciate that. I think what you're realizing is this board is... it's pretty data driven. We really like to see the data around your decisions. And so I think the data around the elementary class size and how often do they split in the past is helpful for us. The enrollment data for the high school classes this year is helpful for us. I know deans are meeting with students right now. If they have ideas of classes that students are

135really interested in, I think that's helpful for us. I just, and I think that's really what we need moving forward to kind of help guide you a little bit better. When we looked at the long-term financial plan, we were very concerned about the fund balances, and I think we continue to be. I don't know what the solution is, but I'm just as concerned around the health care reserves, lower and lower every year. We're at this rate, we're going to run out of money if it continues in this trend. I think that the data around that would also be helpful. Thank you, Drew and Andrew, for all the work you've put into this presentation, but also maybe more so the work you're going to do, especially in the next month, as this is an extremely challenging

136budget. These health care costs are obviously setting us back a lot, and it is concerning. I share the concerns of the other board members that have spoken about it. more than even just looking at other plans, which I do think we need to do, but I am. I worry that this is just a new healthcare paradigm that we're in. As we see in technology, how it changes so rapidly, I feel like healthcare is kind of going through its own transformative process, too. Medicine is different and so much more expensive, and the treatments available now, they're great advances for medicine and will hopefully save lives. you know, is medicine just going to be more expensive from here on out? I, you know, I appreciate looking at historical claim data, but, you know, I think we have

137to look at also, like, you know, the setting we're in now, you know, like in terms of health care. I don't, I'm certainly not an expert in that, you know, so I appreciate that, you know, Pat Coburn and UMR will be looking at that, but if we can kind of ask them to, you know, look at specifically, like, you know, you know, I'm sure they are, you know. these trends and trying to budget for next year and the years ahead. So with that, would someone like to make a motion to adjourn this budget study session number one to move into tonight's business meeting? Maybe with a little break first. Thank you, Amber. Is there a second? Thank you, Leah. Any discussion? All those in favor, please say aye. thank you the motion passes um i

138hate to keep people waiting but uh we have been going for over two hours now would people like to take maybe a five minute wellness break before starting okay thank you good evening thank you i'd like to call this meeting to order and note that all board members are present we are joined by superintendent dr patrick and members of his administrative cabinet welcome to those who joined us this evening either in the audience tuning in on the live stream or on zoom IMMEDIATELY BEFORE THIS BUSINESS MEETING, OUR FIRST BUDGET STUDY SESSION WAS HELD FOR THE 2025-26 BUDGET SEASON. THIS FIRST BUDGET STUDY PRESENTED OUR FINANCIAL POSITION ON AN ACTUAL VERSUS BUDGETED BASIS AS WELL AS AN OVERVIEW OF THE MAJOR CONSIDERATIONS AND DECISIONS TO BE MADE TO ARRIVE AT A POSED BUDGET FOR THE 2025-26

139SCHOOL YEAR. THANK YOU TO DR. PATRICK, ANDREW LENNON AND HIS TEAM FOR ALL THEIR HARD WORK PREPARING THE MATERIALS FOR THIS BUDGET STUDY. Tonight's meeting also includes an information item and discussion around possible board advocacy. Advocacy is a board goal and with the reformulation of foundation aid, as well as Governor Hochul's call for a statewide cell phone ban this year, the board as well as the administration is staying engaged in the legislative process. With that, I'd like to turn it over to Drew. Thank you. I'm going to make my comments briefer than I intended, but I add my welcome to everyone who's here. Thank you for your patience. I do need to start my comments tonight by providing an important legal update. As many may be aware, in 2019, New York State enacted the Child

140Victims Act, a law that extended the time frame during which a survivor of childhood sexual abuse can pursue criminal charges against their alleged offender. This legislation allowed victims to initiate legal action regardless of the length of time that has passed since that abuse took place. In tonight's consent agenda, the board is being asked to approve a settlement in a legal matter brought under the 2019 Child Victim Act legislation, as school districts across the state have been named in such lawsuits. The allegations made in the case before the board tonight date back to the early 1970s. If approved, the fully executed agreement will bring to a close the only remaining CVA suit in which Scarsdale School District was a named defendant. This case does not involve any current employee or anyone employed in Scarsdale more than

14135 years. As this case falls into the category of pending litigation, I cannot comment further on it. I will, however, reiterate our collective condemnation of all forms of abuse and mistreatment of children and extend our care and concern to all victims of abuse and to their loved ones. One quick announcement. On last Thursday, Susie, Ron, and I were honored to attend the Transfer of Command Ceremony for the Scarsdale Police Department. Outgoing Police Chief Andrew Maturo transferred command to incoming Chief Stephen DelBene in a heartwarming ceremony in Scarsdale Public Library. Chief Maturo has been a steadfast partner of the Scarsdale Public Schools throughout his tenure. He and the entire Scarsdale Police Department, including incoming Chief DelBene, have helped us shape the practices and procedures that keep our students and staff safe. On behalf of the district,

142we extend our gratitude to Chief Maturo and wish him the best in his well-deserved retirement, and we look forward to continuing our strong and productive partnership with Chief DelBene and the entire Scarsdale Police Department. I'll skip a few other things and just point out. Upcoming dates, we don't meet again until March. So on February 12th is the Chinese Lantern Festival, the 15th day of the first lunar month, two weeks after Chinese New Year, marking the first full moon of the new lunar year. February 17th is President's Day, and we will be closed on that day as well as the winter recess that week, the 17th through the 21st. And at the end of the month, Ramadan will begin, sundown on Friday, February 28th. AND AT SUN DOWN ON SUNDAY, MARCH 30TH. THANK YOU, DREW. NEXT

143ON THE AGENDA WOULD BE BOARD MEMBER REPORTS AND UPDATES, IF ANYBODY HAS. BACK TO YOU, DREW. Okay, quick auditorium update? Very quick. So not much to offer in terms of timeline changes from our last discussion. However, I will share that the scaffolding is now completely down. The new proscenium brow is being installed, and the woodwork just really does make the space look amazing. We also have had Dr. Graybill up on the catwalk fully installing all of the theatrical lighting, which is really exciting. The space is really starting to show its new face, and we are excited to see auditorium seats and related work being installed in the next couple weeks. Thank you so much. Next we will be moving to our first public comment session of this meeting. Bear with me as I read the

144public comment preamble. Members of the public are cordially invited to speak on district related items or other non-personnel related matters during two separate public comment periods. When it is your turn to speak, please state your name, address, and if you are speaking on behalf of an organization. For those commenting remotely, please mute the live stream voice, turn on your camera, and then unmute yourself. This might be a good time to do that now. Speakers will be asked to conclude their remarks after four minutes and will be given a verbal cue at the three-minute mark. If at this point a speaker has additional comments, they may send them in writing to the board via email at boardofed at scarsdaleschools.org. The public comment period is reserved for comments only. The board will not engage in dialogue. The

145board reserves the right to respond to comments and questions at its discretion, either during response to public comment or at a later time and place. Response to public comment will take place after the first and second public comment periods. And with that, I'd like to invite anybody from the audience who'd like to speak to please approach the podium. Thank you. Thank you for your patience. So, hi. My name is Kabir Balja. I am a sophomore here at Scarcell High School. And I'm a member of both the Scarsdale rowing team and the PCRA rowing team, because they work in conjunction. Firstly, I understand that there's no real decisions being made here. This is just analysis on how certain factors affect the budget and just observations and that. So I'd just like to present some observations on

146my own. Firstly, I think there's a misconception that I heard being said a lot that some of the top members of our team who are Scarsdale and PCRA. were asked to, well forced to stay behind for the Stotesbury Cup for the only, you know, scholastic event that we participate in as a school. That's not true. All rowers from PCRI were given a choice, me included. I went to the Stotesbury Cup to whether to participate there or to go to nationals. Ian Zao, Alex Sharp, who isn't here anymore, he had to go, and Viren Dollywell. Those three were given the choice. They were not forced at all. I don't want anybody to think that. They decided to go to nationals because, you know, that's a really big opportunity for a rower. It's, you know, arguably the

147biggest competition in youth row. Secondly, in the talk about coaches' salaries, I'd like to mention that there was no boys' Scarzill coach last year. So in terms of two coaches, I only know of one Scarzill coach, and that... One Scarsdale coach admittedly I know really only played a role in the girls team I think and I don't to be fair really did not play much a role in the girls team all the coaching I know for the boys and girls was mainly received from the PC area coaches and was essentially glorified to chaperone and I just want to say that Scarsdale Roan a lot of Scarsdale alumni go on to do really good things like Ian Zhao was in the head of the Charles, they placed 11th. Head of the Charles is the biggest inter-scholastic,

148international competition for youth rowing. And PCI regularly places nationally ranked at rowing competitions. So Scarsdale is enabling their kids to do something really special. That really means a lot to us. I know that a lot of sports only have one season. Rowing is different. It's every single season, including summer, which, you know, admittedly, there aren't many people who do summer. Every day, every week, every month of the school year, we don't get exemptions for PE. We're at practice all the time. It's a really big part of our lives. Yeah, I think that's it. Hi, if I may. My name is Matthew Bachner. I am a senior at Scarborough High School and a one-me member of the PCRA club. I would just like to say that... Would you mention your address? I'm sorry. Sorry, yeah. I

149live on One Barker Lane, Scarborough, New York. I would just like to say that along with everything that my friend Kabir here said, Scarsdale really prizes themselves in their ability to send students, hundreds of students every single year to some of the greatest higher level education places in the US or in the world. Rowing has given such an amazing opportunity to so many students at this school to reach those places. For example, if you're in Dollywall, I'm sure you guys know about him. He was a very dedicated member of the Scarsville crew team and the PCRA crew team, and he went on to get recruited to Cornell University. Ian Zhao, same story. He got recruited at Colby University. And me, I am currently in the process of getting recruited thanks to the Scarsdale crew who

150I got recommended to join it my freshman year three years ago. And may I say it was the best decision I have ever made. My life has changed so much thanks to that opportunity. And I just feel like it is a sin to take that opportunity away from the future generation of Scarsdale students. So, thank you. My name is Daphna Ehrenstein. I live in 1 Rectory Lane, Scarsdale, New York. I just want to speak, I think, for the whole girls team, correct me if I'm wrong, but most of us started spring of last year. Not spring. Yeah, spring. Sorry. As freshmen, and I think already, I've known these girls for a while, and I've seen all three of us and the other girls who couldn't make it grow as people. I think that rowing teaches

151you a very valuable lesson in the sport and out of the sport, like community, team building. You're rowing yourself, but you're also carrying the whole boat with you. And I just think that if this sport is taken away, I think that it's taken away from almost all the next future generations, and they won't be able to experience what us three have experienced, which has been in the only one and a half years that we've been doing this, for me, has been life-saving and life-changing. If I could just say one more thing, I remember hearing that, talking about other schools, like I think it was North Rockland and Clarkstown, which also have their own rowing teams. I think that's what I was hearing at least. Scarsdale sends its athletes to PCRA, which is one of the

152finest clubs in the nation, nationally ranked. So I think there's definitely something different over there, that Scarsdale is really allowing their students to be part of something much greater and much bigger than any of them could achieve just on their own. Would anybody else like to make a public comment? Hi, my name is Anya Huja. I live at 30 Sequel Road, and I'm a sophomore on the squash team. I joined the squash team last year, and it had been my first time on a Scarsdale High School sports team, and it made me realize how much I loved squash. So I wonder why this sport, why squash, crew, and fencing, why those three are the ones that are being considered to cut. I know squash is not a very popular or known sport, but it's a

153sport that I love, and I know so many students do too. If everyone else can play the sport that they love, why can't I? I've gone to every match, every practice, and so has everyone else on the team. We all show so much dedication and support for this team. The team is growing in so many ways, in so many positive ways, and it just needs more time, especially since it's a new team and it has only been around for a year. I would also like to point out that the coaching is solely done by the coaches at WSA. This team has already affected my life in so many good ways socially mentally and physically Most importantly it has given me a strong sense of community and connections to other people in my culture in all

154different grades So I hope you all consider keeping such an important part of our high school experience For all of us no matter the sport we play not just for people who play soccer and basketball. Thank you Samira who juh on his dad 30 sequel road Scarsdale First of all, thank you all for your effort. Meetings go really late. Full disclosure, I understand better than most how hard this work is. I'm here speaking in my personal capacity, but I'm a member of the Scarsdale Village Board of Trustees. And also for full disclosure, so there's no appearance of any conflict, I, in my professional life, lead the country's largest youth sports streaming platform, a company called Game Changer. But I am here as Anya's dad. So three thoughts. One, there was some frustration earlier during the

155work session. I know everyone's working very hard, but if I took the time, and I think a lot of people could do this, we could go through that presentation that was very well put together and a lot of work was put into it. But it felt like a foregone conclusion and facts were assigned. to that conclusion. I could talk to you about buses and coaching and equipment costs for every single sport. So all I would ask as a resident and a taxpayer is on any of these topics, just say what the real message is. If the message is these are non-sanctioned sports and that's a rationale for considering cutting them, say that. Don't tell the people. the kids and the parents who are doing the work that their kids aren't showing up the bus experience

156is terrible because we have to bring our kids back to the school to go all the way to mamaroneck for squash i have no interest We all have busy lives. So a lot of the kids are showing up and aren't taking the bus. So all I ask is just present the facts as they are on all of these topics. As it relates to this topic of participation, and some of the kids probably did a better job than I can, four or five reasons why I think you should strongly consider keeping niche sports or low participation sports going. A lot of those sports... are a basis for equitable access and inclusivity because there's a lot of kids who may not gravitate to the popular sports. This is what I do all day long. We spend a

157lot of time with kids in the so-called popular sports. I get it. I get that there's kids who want other things. One of the kids mentioned unique pathways to college through these sports. I think that's a big part of what educating our kids here is. It's to send them forward. and most if not all of them go on to college. The smaller teams have focused coaching and personal attention by being smaller. We talked about class sizes. We all care about that personalized attention. A coach can change a person's life, a kid's life, an adult's life. I don't think we should get in the way of that. I think there's a reputational element to participate, to offering. Some of these things, yeah, they cost money, but so do a lot of other things. I think it

158sort of is part of Scarsdale, whether it's our infrastructure or our school district. Is that the end or the one minute? Thank you. You know, that being able to do these things that aren't just for the masses, you know, for like what most people want. And the last thing is, and I think some other people said this, you know, some of these sports have... have just gotten going. And we're here to invest in the future. A lot of people grow up here and move back. I'm one of those people. Many other people here are as well. And I think we should invest in these things that might seem small and niche. Sports participation in the United States is flat across the board in every major team sport. So if we want it, if we believe

159in sports, if we believe in the power of sports to improve the mental and physical lives of... children and allow them to become adults, then I think we should open our aperture to thinking about new ways to do that. And I think niche sports represent one way. Again, thank you for your time. And most importantly, thank you for your service. It is not an easy job. And by that, I mean the volunteers and the staff. Hi, I'm Seema Saranahooja. I live at 30 Secor Road. I'm Anya's mom, Sameer's wife. And it's sort of a joke that this is my first Board of Education meeting, and I'm here for athletics after 10 years of being in the district because I have zero interest in sports, even though my family really does. I want to tell you

160a little bit about myself. to help you understand why I am also here with my daughter. I'm a first generation South Asian woman. I grew up on Long Island. In my family, sports was discouraged. We were supposed to read and not go out and play and not do sports in school for cultural reasons. But I also think because my immigrant parents didn't understand American sports, it wasn't accessible to them. They didn't understand the culture and how to get us. involved. They didn't know the sports that my peer groups played. Squash is, at least squash, and I think fencing and probably some other sports that are being discussed today, is a sport that my background understands. And I'd like to tell you... A little bit about why it's so important to us. Anya entered squash because

161Samir took her on Father's Day for her first lesson. I thought it was a really bad idea because I didn't think she'd like it. She plays tennis. But Samir wanted to honor his father, who played squash throughout the Middle East when they were growing up, and it was a sport that stayed with him through his life, and Samir played in business school. Anya and our younger daughter. loved squash on that Father's Day. They honored their grandfather, they spent time with their father. Unbeknownst to us, two months later when Ani entered high school, we learned that a squash team was being formed. And I can't explain to you how much I felt like the universe was telling us that scorers would have been the right choice for us and here was a sport that our daughter

162could participate in and connect. with something that was not just something we see on screens and see other people play, but that had been a part of her lived experience and her family's lived experience, and so many of the other kids on that team, and they connect through that. I want you to consider that because... The profile of students who are playing squash, who are engaging in fencing, who are on the crew team, reflect the diversity that Scarsdale, I think, has worked so hard to achieve. These are sports that are played by a different profile of student. They engage in fitness and wellness and athletics in a different way. And I think taking away that athletic outlet for them would really... ultimately take away from the diversity of experience and student experience that we care

163so much about here. And it would be a shame that these three sports, which I think have a very high percentage of non-traditional students, and quite frankly, I'll just come out and say diverse students, is something I really urge the board to consider. I want to end by saying that The reason I haven't come to a Board of Education meeting in 10 years is not because I don't care about education. In fact, I'm deeply committed to it. I'm general counsel at Marist College, a D1 school. I spent an hour with my AD this morning. I deeply believe in what athletics does for the student experience and how it builds community. And I think taking away even two or three things would take away from the hallmark of Scarsdale School District, which is the student experience,

164doing things differently, doing things creatively. And I will also say that I've never come to a Board of Ed meeting because I believe in this board. I believe in the work you all do. our teachers, our faculty, our coaches. I trust you all. And so please do the right thing in this budget analysis and study to look at things fairly, look at all the data, speak to all the constituencies, not just the bus personnel. If you can, please talk to the students, the coaching liaisons, and get their perspectives as well, especially for teams like squash, which are just starting, and it would send such a bad message to cut it off at this early stage. Thank you so much. Thank you. Is there anybody else who would like to make a public comment? Good evening,

165everyone. My name is Alina Yang. I live at 24 Farragut Road. I'm a junior at Scarsdale High School, and I am here tonight representing Guardians of the Heart. It's a student-led 501c3 nonprofit dedicated to cardiovascular health promotion and disease prevention among youth. Now, I'd just like to start by saying that every hour of every day, a student dies from sudden cardiac arrest. And you know what the single biggest variable in whether a student lives or dies is? How quickly they receive CPR. Sudden cardiac arrest is the leading cause of death on school campuses as well as the leading cause of death among student athletes and it would be a preventable tragedy if we sit here and wait for disaster to strike. As a CPR certified individual with a family history of heart disease, I believe

166it is essential for all students to have access to this life-saving skill and starting at a young age. Over 436,000 sudden cardiac arrests occur each year in the U.S., and of these, over 23,000 are children under the age of 18. Tragically, most of these occur in an out-of-hospital setting, where the survival rate is less than 10%, and this figure has remained stagnant for the past 20 years. However, implementing widespread CPR certification and education can dramatically improve survival rates. For each minute that CPR and the use of an AED is delayed, survival rates decrease by 10%. Yet, immediate CPR can triple this rate. Beyond improving survival rates, CPR certification also empowers individuals in life or death situations. 48% of cases where bystander CPR is administered resulted in a shockable rhythm compared to just 27% where CPR

167was not administered, demonstrating the critical role of CPR in increasing the chances of survival. And by increasing the number of CPR certified citizens, we increase the likelihood that CPR will be administered, which in turn increases the likelihood of survival. So why not make this skill available and accessible to all students? With rising rates of sudden cardiac arrest among youth athletes, as witnessed even tragically in famous athletes such as you see Damar Hamlin, you see Bronny James, and we cannot and must not wait for disaster to reach us before we take action. To that end, we urge the board to allocate the necessary funding and resources, review the current educational regulations, and support the formal integration of CPR training as well as certification into our school curriculums, whether that's part of an existing health class, adding

168a new elective, or as part of a broader first aid curriculum. Here lies not simply a certification, but an investment in the safety and well-being of every student, every family, and the entire community. Imagine a future where every high school student has the ability to save a life, whether it's here at school, at home, at a sports game, or at a party, whether they are alone or they're in a crowd, whether it's a split-second decision or has become their muscle memory. This is a future where we are equipped with a critical life-saving skill that we can carry with us throughout the rest of our lives, empowering us to make a difference whenever and wherever it may be needed. And that future is within our reach. As American author and philanthropist Sheryl Sandberg once said, we

169cannot change what we are not aware of, and once we are aware, we cannot help but change. Thank you for your time and consideration. Would anybody else like to make a public comment at this time? Can I touch this? Hello, I'm Alex Sharp. I live in 8 Wheelock Road. So, Scarsdale Crew... is really deep-rooted in the Scarsdale community. I've had the privilege to race in two boats that were named after prior Scarsdale kids, Tyler Madoff and Brian Lilly, two tragedies that deeply inflicted this community before I was part of the team and part of the Scarsdale High School community. that I feel a connection to because I've raced in shells that bear their names. The Brian Lilly is the name of our first varsity boat, which we've raced at Youth Nationals and the head of

170the Charles. Each year we've brought it to Youth Nationals and had his name and his catchphrase, yeah, buddy, on the bow. Brian was a Scarsdale kid who really stood for overcoming. adversity that faced him. He had a junior rheumatoid arthritis and he was an Ironman athlete. He was a PCRA and Scarsdale athlete, Scarsdale crew athlete. And he got recruited to UCSD where in his second year there from abuse from the coach and other details that I won't get into, tragically committed suicide. In a few weeks, I think it was two weeks, over $50,000 was raised for the Brendan Lilly USP boat, which we've raced in to this day. Scarsdale crew has let me find myself. I came out of middle school with a lack of identity. I was a member of Scarsdale hockey. I was

171in the drama club, and I was on the novice rowing team. I missed a lot of rowing practice, which my coaches have not let me forget to this day. But at the end, And I didn't really know what I wanted to do going forward because it just wasn't possible to do these three things and keep up with high school. But once we got to spring, which is when I became a Scarsdale crew athlete, those bus rides every day and those new team members who joined the team because of the affiliation with Scarsdale who would have no clue what rowing is or have no idea they'd be interested in it. join the team and I would look forward to those bus rides with them. We would like laugh and watch movies. We would crack jokes with

172our coach Nick and then we would go to practice and we would kill it on the course on the lagoon and that spring we placed second in the state championship for the novice eight. and over half of the kids in that boat were Scarsdale kids. It was Reid Armis, who was a junior. Oliver Bansma, who was a junior. Oliver Bansma was a freshman. I was a freshman. Tavish Millen was a freshman. And Matt Bauchner was a sophomore. Scarsdale Crew has meant the world to me, and it's helped me find out who I am, and it's helped me become the person I am today. and I want to pursue it further than high school, and I want to give others the opportunity that this sport has given me. Thank you for your time. Is there anybody

173else who would like to make a public comment? Hi. My name is Claudine Jassel, and I live at 10 Kent Road. And I do want to say that this presentation is really quite nice, and it does highlight some big-ticket items that are turning into a... big ticket budget gap for the tax cap. So I just wanted to comment and the sports are interesting and they're very small ticket items and I don't know if we, you know, you could look at it like the physical and mental health of the kids and the physical and mental health of the grown-ups. And when we fly in an airplane, they always tell you make sure you put your oxygen mask on first before you take care of your kids or you know whoever's infirm and with this health reserve

174for the adults it's this happened before you know when I first moved here the same thing was happening and Drew was saying that it was a $24 million savings over a 10-year period, which is significant, but it's starting to go against the district now for some reason, which we don't know, but UnitedHealthcare also had a similar experience, and that's the largest insurer with the most lives, and so that's a trend for whatever reason, and maybe it is the aging of the population. But at any rate, I just wanted to put out there that since there's two HR people here that did work with these plans and the consultant, maybe you could look at there are small insurance companies that reinsure what's called special risk. and they're small boutique firms. I used to invest in them

175in the United States. They reinsure all kinds of sort of very offbeat risks, and this is a smallish type of financial entity. And there might be, you might ask the consultant, if there is one of these smaller reinsurers that if you want to stick with the... self-insured plan because it has a nice savings historically, maybe that's going to change, but if you want to take another look at keeping it. maybe there would be some contract that you could sign with a smaller specialty firm that would, like an option risk, and they would look at the lives too, just like you're going to look at the lives, and they would say maybe it's worth it, maybe it's not, this is the premium for that, and it might be worth it. So I don't know because I

176don't. spend all day on it but there are two people who have spent time on it here and maybe it might be worth it i haven't heard anybody say they looked into it and it might be nothing but i did want to mention that so thank you would anybody else like to make a public comment i'm just more crouch i live at 12 south woods lane um i just figured i've been here so i might as well say something um i'm here to support um Crew I'm a crew parent and it's a great program It's something we could never I think afford to do as a school ourselves the boats cost like thirty to fifty thousand for one boat It's a unique opportunity that these kids have and I don't think my son would have

177done it if it hadn't been offered here because it's such a commitment. It's a nice way to experience this really amazing sport without... without having to make such a huge commitment. You're doing it as a Scarcell High School athlete. It's a very nurturing environment when they're freshmen, and then they grow into this love of it. And I think it's really a lot of bang for your buck. Like, it's expensive. It's $60,000, but when you look at the big picture, it's a really small-ticket item, and it has such an impact on these kids. So I hope you'll keep it in the budget if you can. Is there anybody else who would like to make a public comment? Then we will next go to Zoom. Jim, I do see them on the Zoom. If they can unmute

178themselves and, yeah, turn on the camera. Can they hear you? Hello, whoever just joined, could you turn on your camera, please? Oh, sorry, turn it on. There's no button to turn on the camera. Sorry, sorry, hold on. There's no button to turn on the camera. Apologies, it doesn't seem to be possible right now. There's no button to turn on the camera. So you have to accept the promotion the panelists Sorry, this is Tara and Jeffrey Sharp. We live at 8 Wheelock Road, parents of Alexander Sharp, who just spoke there in person. And we're speaking on behalf of Scarsdale Crew. I think there's a lot to say about the Scarsdale Crew program. And to be frank, we weren't really prepared until a little while ago that this was happening tonight. So apologies if it's not super

179organized. You know, we had a lot of choices. As Alexander mentioned briefly, he was involved in a lot of different things before he chose crew. He played ice hockey. He was part of the drama club. He was a very involved student. And his freshman year was on the crew team. He did development before that. It was really a tough choice, but being a part, as he said, that freshman spring season of something that was not only... an activity, a sport that he did outside of school, but something that was part of the district was really important. And, you know, we had a choice. There are a number of really. high, well-regarded crew programs in the area, some of which have been spoken about tonight, Rye, for example. And part of our decision, a lot of

180things factored in. There's a warm, welcoming, really encouraging atmosphere at PCRA in addition to their kind of winning record. But their association with Scarsdale was one of the... really most important determining factors in our decision because for Alexander and I think for a lot of students, being an athlete for the school and feeling like you're a part of the athletic community in the high school is really crucial to an athlete because it is so much of your life. I mean, it basically is all of your life outside of academics. And so being able to be a part of the school. in that way is really important. I also just want to mention that I think CRU is somewhat interesting in that it brings both male and female athletes together, working together collaboratively, even on the

181same boat. So for example, last year, the Varsity One boat, Coxon, was a female. And, you know, they're really learning to work together and support each other. both as individual athletes as they compete against their own records for their 2Ks and as boats and encouraging people to get better and to rise to the next level boat. I think the district as a whole stands out. as offering excellence across the board. And, you know, in that vein, doesn't seek to cut arts programs because they're deemed really important, is really on the, you know, cutting edge of academics and offering AT instead of AP classes. And I know schools around the country have followed Scarsdale's lead in that respect. And I think offering sports that aren't necessarily... the money-making sports. We've talked a lot about football and

182adding police cars and adding trainers and things like that. I think some of the sports that are really... allow students to develop and to be different are equally important. And I would urge the district to brainstorm ways we can keep these other sports that are just as valuable and are really crucial to not only the students, but to the district and offering opportunities for future generations of students. Thank you. Maybe we'll give it a couple seconds to see if our present attendees want to make a public comment. At this time, please raise your hand if you would like to make a public comment on Zoom. There will be a second comment period. So in case this attendee was having technical difficulties and couldn't make a public comment, we can circle back and have that person

183speak later on in the meeting. Okay, and with that, we will close public comment. And next item on the agenda would be item five, follow up to public comment. I would just thank all of our students. Sorry for keeping you so late. Please go. Go ahead. It's totally fine. We've kept you late enough. Thank you for your patience and persistence on sticking with it to share your viewpoints. Same to the parents who communicated. Claudine, thank you for an idea. If she's still here, maybe she will. And just so the board is aware, I do know that Alina and Leah, who was here earlier but I don't think could stay, who spoke about CPR, have been in contact with our director of health and the high school administration about their advocacy there as well. So I

184know they wanted to address the board. They approached Honoré to figure out how it works and just wanted you to know that. Wow. Yeah, she should say it in the mic. Okay. Yeah. Yeah, hard to hear, but yeah. So our track team is involved with that organization and working to bring an opportunity to the track team. I'm paraphrasing Cindy Parrott in the audience. So thank you. No, thank you. Appreciate it. Thank you. I just also very quickly wanted to echo many thanks to everybody who spoke tonight, especially our students, of course. Thank you, Cindy, for your presentation. Okay, great. Next would be item six, written communications, and I believe that is Jim. Thank you, Susie. Please note that the Board of Education email is also viewed by the superintendent and district clerk. Open meeting call

185requires all board deliberations which may lead to action or policy changes to occur in public. Therefore, your written communications and emails will be reported at an upcoming public board meeting. A board member will respond at their earliest convenience. A formal response requires that you include your full name, address, and if you are writing on behalf of an organization, in the communication. More detailed information regarding written communications received by the Board of Education may be found in today's meeting agenda, located in Board Docs on the Scarsdale School District's website. And since the last meeting, there have been a number of emails received by the board. I think basically seven, I'm just roughly on district matters and two on board matters, communications, invitations and highlights. Thank you, Jim. Next would be the consent agenda. In the interest

186of time, I will... I'll describe it briefly. The full preamble is available on the meeting agenda. Briefly, a consent agenda condenses some of the routine business of the Board of Education into a single motion. The items on the consent agenda will have the same background material as ordinary items on the Board agenda. Would any Board member like to move an item from the consent agenda to a separate action item? Consent agenda, I believe this is wrong. Thanks, Susie. There are six items on tonight's consent agenda. Item 8.01, minutes from the business meeting from January 27th, 2025. 8.02, personnel certified. 8.03, personnel non-certified. 8.04, quarterly report student activities fund. 8.05, settlement and confidential agreement. 8.06 accepting the consent agenda I move that the board accept the consent agenda as presented Thank You Ron is there a

187second Thank You Leah any discussion all those in favor please say aye motion carries thank you the next item would be the treasurer's report I believe this would be Lisa thank you Okay, the Treasurer's Reports being presented tonight are for December of 2024. 1.7 million in tax receipts were received from the Village of Scarsdale in December, and an additional 40,000 was received from Mamaroneck. State and federal aid, we received a $50,000 grant and aid from New York State. This is an additional allocation of state aid. It has no restrictions. It can be used to offset general expenditures. We also received $393,000 in excess cost aid and the monthly distribution of lottery aid. Interest earnings for December were approximately $256,000 with the highest investment accounts earning between 4.3% and 4.4%. So again, the rates are dropping,

188but they're still at... decent rates it brings total interest revenue in the general fund to 1 million 168 393 as of December 31st again in line with our projection for disbursements we had December vendor warrants totaling approximately eight point six million and semi-monthly gross payrolls for nine point two million any questions Thank You Lisa would be the STI course proposals item nine point oh two Good evening everyone. Thank you for having me. The course is submitted here for board approval support individual teacher goals, district goals, building goals, and departmental level goals. And they address Scarsdale's district strategic plan around learning, living, and leading. The STI supports district learning by creating a collaborative future-oriented academic culture. In STI courses, students are at the center of teacher collaboration. Courses steeped in reflective practice, such as Skillful Teacher,

189Collegial Research Groups, and Understanding by Design, help teachers develop common language around curriculum and instruction. And a myriad of courses specific to special education give teachers the strategies to reach all students. Teachers become further adept at connecting curriculum to student interests by deepening their knowledge base in interdisciplinary courses that integrate arts and technology. In the living category, we offer courses on this list such as cultivating resilience, responsive classroom, foundations of behavior management, mindfulness for educators, positive education, trauma-informed teaching, among many others. These directly support the district's goal of creating educational environments that promote well-being, belonging, and resilience. Staying at the forefront of inquiry and innovation makes Scarsdale a leading district. And STI courses in artificial intelligence, digital media, exploring innovative educational models, and various technology courses give teachers the expertise to not only keep up

190with their students, but to inspire them to use new tools ethically and empathically as they solve real world problems. The courses that are attached here are proposed by teachers who have expertise in a specific area. and are willing to develop valuable learning experiences for teachers so that teachers can create the best learning experiences for their students. When you approve these courses, the STI office works with teachers to schedule, refine, and publicize the courses. Not all courses on this list will run, unfortunately. We need to make sure that they fit in the schedule and that they have enough teachers to run the course. Each course has a minimum number of teachers taking it. So there are five new courses listed, and then there's also a listing of repeat courses, courses that have been approved in the

191past. So I'm here essentially to answer any of your questions. I just want to thank you for all this, but I also wanted to thank you for connecting it to the strategic plan. I found it very helpful to read it that way, so I appreciate that. Thank you. When the accreditation committee meets, that's the first thing we look for. Does this course satisfy the goals of the district? And in fact, the strategic plan, as you all know, was developed very collaboratively, and we had an STI course that involved teachers in that process. So they're all aware of learning, living, and leading. Thank you so much for these courses. Thank you very much for all your support. Thank you. Thank you. And that will come back March 3rd as an action. Great. Thank you. Moving right

192along. Bond planning. I assume this is Andrew or Drew to start. Yes. Okay. Just as a point of note. neglected to add the slides we're about to share to the agenda it's in there now just so for posterity and if you want to follow along So as Andrew mentioned this past Wednesday we had our first planning meeting with the architects engineers and construction managers so we wanted to provide an update on sort of what came out of that meeting and where we where we are headed but first just to ground us you will call when we presented back in September September laid out a plan or an idea asked for your input and support or okay to go forward with this so here we are there's a Connection to our strategic plan leading goal here,

193and there's of course a specific board goal around bond planning So that's we're rooted this process is rooted in those those goals We also had talked about at that time just to remind everybody a handful of guiding principles In thinking about this sort of touchstones to go back to as we ultimately reach a point of making decisions or weighing alternatives One is that student learning and the strategic plan goals should guide and inform decisions about our capital investments. We should test ourselves on that. The second is that facilities maintenance and improvement is actually an ongoing responsibility that requires both an annual financial allocation, such as what we talked about earlier tonight, and also periodic injections of capital. like through bonds. The required five-year building condition survey and five-year facilities capital plan should be crafted to

194help meaningfully identify and prioritize short, medium, and long-term projects and guide decision-making. Stakeholder engagement should be ongoing and iterative rather than as a step in any particular part of the process. And then alternatives and decisions should be informed by a long-range financial plan and a fund balance and reserve plan, which Andrew brought forward after we presented these guiding principles back in September. He shared that in November. And we talked about that tonight, indeed. So we had laid out a five-step process. happy to report steps one and two are complete we set the stage back in September at the January 13th meeting the board approved agreements with BBS and with Aris construction management firm we are now going to talk tonight a little bit about number three engaging district-wide facilities committee so that portion of the

195the five steps of this process has multiple Components to it for the facilities committee. So I think we're going to just focus on those first two committee composition in charge and recruitment vetting and selection of members so Presenting this to the board for your input consideration suggestions ideas and so forth So we we've modeled Committee composition this would be a district-wide facilities committee that would help Shape the ultimate package of projects and components of that of that project And therefore also would need to have a deep understanding of the facilities, the state, the condition of them, and so forth, so that that group would be starting pretty soon and continue pretty much all the way through the process. And we modeled the committee composition on what we did last time around. So there's a balance

196between having stakeholder representation and an unwieldy size. The group was pretty large last time. I think this total is 33, but it kind of has a broad stakeholder engagement, again, for your input. So the numbers are presented there. Board of Education representation, administration, that includes facilities, leadership staff there, a collection of teachers, parents, community members, and hopefully a student as well, along with our engineering team. The thinking would be that we empower our PTA organizations to lead a selection process building by building and for the PTC of a parent representative group and that we would put out. call for interest from community members who hopefully have some expertise in various areas that we would and I'll share some potential questions with you but put out an application from the community and some of the administration

197and perhaps some board members would be involved in reviewing those applications and selecting those those individuals And I'm going to kind of finish thinking about the facilities committee before talking about the other steps that will also be underway and ask Andrew to share some of that as well. So, of course, along with the committee and its membership would be our partners from BBS and ARIS at the table as well. We have some sort of... ideas for questions that might be in an application you know why are you interested in serving on the community we'd explain it obviously what the charge is but why are you interested in serving on the committee skills experiences or professional background do you have that would contribute describe your role and contributions in any past community school or municipal projects

198you might have been involved in you know part of the responsibility is recommending a final scope of work it requires collaboration consensus building consideration alternatives and trade-offs all of this stuff so describe any related experiences you have with those types of things and then what unique viewpoint or insight would you bring and we'd ask for a resume as well so Just to kind of jump we we tried to piece together as clear a picture as possible for you but also for potential committee members and Ambitious but desired would be to follow at least an initial schedule of meetings to have one in March one in April Probably two in May three in June so as to not have to have a meeting in July. Let the Kind of a lot of work take place then

199and then reconvene in August at least once before imagining what the fall So this is big ask So keep that rolling rolling around Simultaneous to that both BBS and Eris will be getting to know We're getting to know all of our buildings both the guts and insides and outsides and envelope and roof, but also the educational program and talking to stakeholders. Do you want to say a little bit more about what each of those parties might do building by building? So we talked a lot with BBS and ARIS at our last meeting about the role that they'll take in reimagining our buildings, but also just reassessing what's already here. So part of that process, I think, as the board might remember, ARIS contracting has... implemented a 3D scanning model of every building space that really

200helps them create a record of existing conditions so that we can plan around those and be more efficient in our kind of... solution analysis discussions with the architects and engineers. BBS has also taken the approach to do a full comprehensive facility study that really looks at all the building systems, building envelope. So they'd really be going space by space, mechanical system by mechanical system, just to understand what has transpired since the last bond conversations that they were a part of to make sure that they really do know what our existing conditions are. That work will be happening simultaneously with the facility community's conversations as they gather information and then begin to present that to our committee. We'll also certainly have a fiscal aspect to this. It's almost another parallel that we'll be doing some analysis

201helping us to frame the potential impact of both an unbridled scope by the facilities committee but also the more realistic Figures that we can try to shoehorn all the work. So what's not presented here would be a potential Building focused committee if there's a lot of work that is anticipated to be done at a specific building or Potentially a specific topic subcommittee on a particular idea So this isn't the sum total of what might exist This is a proposed next step to establish the district-wide facilities committee even as we know BBS and ARIS will be giving their work, again, both on the physical plant side of things, but also Kevin Walsh leading the educational discussions and imagining what's needed next, what projects are desired by the stakeholders. Yeah, thank you. So one of my questions

202is, and maybe this is sounding a little bit like semantics, but... You're calling it a facilities committee. I'm just curious why you're not calling it a steering committee. Because it seems to me, unless I'm misunderstanding what you're doing here, this group of whatever the final number ends up being, 30 or whatever, will be steering the project, correct? And they're going to be... It's not only facilities. There's a programmatic component to it. So it, to me, feels very tactical in a way that, frankly, to me would be disappointing if we see it as, you know, let's get our facilities in order. It's a bigger idea, and I think, frankly, I think facilities committee feels misleading to me from my perspective from what I do. And I think, you know, perhaps the question I'm going to ask

203is when one walks into that facilities committee, who's in charge? Who's leading that meeting? And who's setting out that agenda, you know, three days before to tell everyone what to prepare for? And that, to me, is key here. And I'm not sure whether, Drew, you're in charge of it or you're in charge of it or BBS. I mean, BBS. So, okay, so BBS has come up with a structure that they feel they need to keep with, you know, obviously in conversation with you to keep this thing moving. And I guess... That's great. I mean, that's what it should be. Again, I think that there's the sort of the programmatic and the facilities. The programmatic, to some degree, needs to drive the facility. So what they're doing is perfectly appropriate. You need to know what you

204have today and the condition of what you have. But you don't necessarily want to fix that right away because... at the end of the day, what's there now may not be there in the future. So you don't want to belabor fixing a room that may be totally repurposed or whatever. So, you know, and I know there's a gentleman from BBS, Kevin or? Kevin Walsh. Kevin Walsh, who will kind of lead that. You'll get very, very familiar with Kevin. Yeah, he's the big ideas guy. So I guess he's leading that, you know, those initial conversations will start very soon. Right. Yep. So I think what would help maybe people to understand, again, whether it's a facilities committee or a steering committee, correct me if I'm wrong, when there are a lot of options out there and

205people have to decide, you know, this is the direction we want to go, is this the committee that will do that? Or is there a smaller... voting committee? In other words, is everyone going to put their sticker on one of the three scenarios that they're going to put up there? In other words, is everybody equal or not? I mean, we don't need to resolve that today, but there is that nuance, right? Those are the expectations of membership of that group. I appreciate the suggestion to rethink the name, but yes, right, there's that. So what are the norms of the functioning of this group? Right. Just to be super clear, at the end of the day, you are the group making the decision. Well, that may be, but, you know, some of us may sit on

206it and participate. But at the end of the day, you know, there's going to have to be consensus. And, you know, again, from my experience, when it comes to the board. At that point, there should be consensus. So it's somewhat a formality, but it's not like we're really the ones that, I mean, yes, technically, ultimately, we're signing off on it. So I think if and when you roll this out even more, again, I'm questioning the name, but I think some sort of sense of the structure and logic of this process, which I know has been thought about, but... you know what's going to happen on march first so that we get a sense of how this is developing when do we need to make the decisions at what point is it coming to that so

207people are around and available because you know it's going to be hard corralling 30 something people to show up every time perhaps so you know i again that's just as an observation i think um You know there's a lot of work that has to be done but the tricky part is the consensus building and who gets to decide and to me that's really important that because everyone's not going to be happy with how it goes and happy in the sense that You know it's just like the budget you know There we need to understand that process so the consensus building is key to it. So I'd like to personally see a little bit more a little bit more other than just the dates to help kind of tie it together for me you know as

208I'm kind of reviewing it I think whether it's called the facilities committee or the steering committee I appreciate you know the thought that went into you know putting this together I think engaging the community will obviously be so important in coming up with you know the vision of what we want to you know create for our children and our students I think it looks great. I agree. Having sat on the facilities committee before, I know Susie has too. It does actually work pretty well, Bob, in my experience. I'm just curious, are there meetings when we were on it years ago, the meetings were after school, is that still the plan? And they were in person. That would be the plan. Okay. Next would be. Item 9.04, a board discussion about legislative advocacy. Now this, I

209realize it's late, so I do appreciate the space for us to talk about this a little bit. For this information item and discussion on advocacy, I'd like to start by highlighting that a board goal of ours is to and I'm quoting, participate in legislative advocacy impacting public education via efforts identified by the board or suggested by our administration or coordinated by the New York State School Board Association, Westchester Putnam School Board Association or West Putnam, and the Lower Hudson Education Coalition. In previous meetings, even tonight, Dr. Patrick and... Andrew Lennon have both mentioned, the state budget timeline and our advocacy efforts and even the federal picture, the uncertainty there. To recap on the state side for the community who have now gone to bed but might be interested to know, that Governor Hochul announced last

210year that there is to be a long overdue reformulation of foundation aid and possibly changes to save harmless as well. She commissioned the Rockefeller Institute to study foundation aid formula and to make recommendations for possible improvements. They published their findings and recommendations in December. Governor Hochul's budget incorporated some but not all of these suggestions in the governor's budget released just a couple weeks ago. The governor's budget did provide for a 2% raise to foundation aid, as Andrew mentioned, as well as preserved safe harmless, which was widely met with great appreciation. Governor Hochul also released a more learning, less scrolling report, which would ban Wi-Fi enabled devices from school bell to bell. So now, where we are now, the state senate and house are diligently working to create their one house budgets. On January 30th, Dr.

211Patrick, Leah, and I attended a joint West Putt and LHEC superintendent and school board legislative forum. A number of local legislators, including Assemblywoman Amy Pollen, Senator Shelly Mayer were on the webinar, as well as Senate Majority Leader Andrea Stewart-Cousins. A number of issues were brought up which we could discuss and if the board feels would be helpful advocate on. I will also be attending Westpac's legislative forums with our local electeds in the next week and wanted to be sure to represent the board's view when I address the small group discussion. We could follow if the board wishes we could follow up those meetings by writing to a letter to our legislators or potentially urge our community members to advocate as well. So, as we all saw in our budget study session, we have a lot

212of challenges to our budget and state aid and how it's calculated plays a big role in that. So, one of the things that the Rockefeller Institute suggested was the creation of separate aid categories to address needs involving students with disabilities distributed on an expense basis. So, we've talked a lot about expense based, how that should be. This practice was the case before Foundation Aid was actually enacted in 2007. The report also recommends varying the weighting for students in special education based on the nature of the services they received. And this was a practice also before Foundation Aid. So I'd like to, I think that's in basically NYSPA and NYSCIS. are all talking about expense-based aid, and specifically with regard to special education. I know Eric and you, Drew, have given information to some of those

213listening sessions that went into this Rockefeller Institute study, so thank you for that. We all see how special education has grown in our community, and we want to make sure to be able to adequately support them. That was the first one. The second one on the state's zero emission bus mandate that also came up tonight. The Rockefeller report advises that New York should fully underwrite the costs of the state initiative to transition each school district to an all electric bus fleet. Now this was not adopted in the governor's budget. Some other districts are advocating for changes in the timeline. like Andrew mentioned before that all new school buses right now are mandated to be electric by 2027 and the complete bus fleet should be zero emission by 2035. But some people are still saying that

214New York should fully underwrite this cost because it's just really impractical for many, many districts to be able to fund this, especially on this timeline. Sorry, this is the last one. On the cell phone ban, Dr. Patrick mentioned last week in Governor Hochul's More Learning, Less Scrolling report, a cell phone ban. This proposed device ban would generally cover all Wi-Fi-enabled devices. So it looks like it could impact our high school. As it appears, this could ban laptops that are brought in by our students and used for educational purposes. That right now doesn't look like we could advocate or ask for clarification. potentially advocate on that as well. I know the tax cap earlier today too, this came up on the call last week and it did not look like there was really bandwidth for reformulating

215that tax cap even though that's something in the past that Scarzo has advocated to be able to use inflation more directly in the formulation. So I was thinking of emphasizing the expense-based aid, the zero-emission bus mandate, and speaking about the cell phone ban and laptops. So I don't know how people feel about that. Yes, Susie, I think it's a great idea for us to advocate, especially related to the budget issues and the complexities of budgeting with state mandates. And I think it's also part of our... You know, it's part of the leading aspect of board work where it's important for us to use our voice as a board. And so I agree with the idea for these three areas, however you think. Obviously open to any other ideas. There's so many things that we can

216advocate on. I just wanted to keep the list short. I appreciate your leadership in this area, Susie, so thank you for taking this on. I am curious, when you were talking about the bus transition, were you planning on asking or advocating for fully funding that mandate or extending the timeline or both? Have you thought about? Well, this came up in our discussion in the fall, the NISPA resolutions, and I believe I heard at the time at the table that... And I want to ask again that we were not necessarily interested in extending the timeline. I don't know if people's thoughts have changed on that. I think advocating for fully underwriting the cost of the transition, I don't know that anybody would have a problem with that. But thoughts on the timeline. But yes, thoughts on

217the timeline. Actually, I would like to get thoughts on that. I mean, I'll just say, you know, I strongly dislike unfunded mandates, which I think could apply in some ways to the device situation as well, because not just for Scarsdale, but if students can no longer bring their devices in from home, then districts will have to supply devices for all the students if they need it in a classroom. So, you know, to me, those two are somewhat linked by that common thread. Actually, on one of the calls I was on recently, one of the school board members asked about students are able to bring non-Wi-Fi enabled school like cell phones and and you know because I guess the school would have to be able to provide a way for students to communicate with their parents

218I mean it could be just them going to the office really but some people interpreted that as students needing a like a dumb phone you know not a smartphone I personally don't. I'm just saying that conversation is out there. I wouldn't have ever thought of that. That conversation is out there. And that should be funded. So you would need a smartphone and a dumb phone, you know, potentially. Can I add a dimension to the time frame of the zero emissions bus mandate? So Andrew said tonight in the proposed budget are two gas vehicles. There's no way we could procure and operate. you know those vehicles without them being gas right now more or less i hope there's a chance they might last more than 10 years like some of our buses are older than 10

219years but many but but we're in a position now because of the timeline where the inventory of the supply chain is not there to supply the vehicles we need them for our aging fleet and we're now being forced to buy a vehicle that might Not be able to be on the road in nine years or nine and a half years that's a untenable position to be in and there might be some advocacy around that. Did I say anything I shouldn't have said? No, no. Well, I ask Andrew. I think it is a dimension to the budget conversation that I didn't touch on earlier, which is I do feel like we have an urgent need to replace some raging vehicles and now is pretty much our last window of opportunity under the current law. to buy

220vehicles that we can run basically for their entire life, and they're about coincide with the mandate to have only zero-emission buses in 2037. These small vans are 2035. Sorry, yes. These vehicles are our workhorses. We use them to go well out of state. They're all over the place. So is that okay then? Thank you. I think we're almost done. Action items, the school calendar. Item 10.01, I believe this is Leah. Thank you. I move that the board adopt the following resolution. Resolved that the board adopts the attached 2025-26 graphic and list view calendars as presented. Thank you, Leah. Is there a second? Any discussion? All those in favor, please say aye. The ayes have it and the motion carries. item would be the gift proposal to Heathcote School. I believe that is Bob. Resol, I

221make a motion that the board accepts with thanks the gift of $8,000 for a permanent kindness mural to be displayed in the multi-purpose room as described in the attached letters. Thank you, Bob. Is there a second? Thank you, Amber. Any discussion? All those in favor, please say aye. Ayes have it, and the motion carries with thanks. Next is our second public comments session of the evening. I will not repeat the preamble to the public comments session. I'd like to ask if anybody in the audience would like to come and make a public comment. Jim, is there anybody on Zoom? There are two attendees on Zoom right now. Raise their hand if they'd like to speak. If anyone on Zoom would like to speak, please raise your hand and we will promote you. We've got a

222hand raised. i promise i did i'm not sure why i didn't know there it is turn on the camera and um could you please turn on your camera yes hi can you hear me oh yeah i just promoted one person hi can you hear me i i am let me i will turn on my camera i just have to pull over i unfortunately am leaving the 24-hour pharmacy because i have a kid who is sick um and i'm just pulling in I wanted to just speak on behalf of my, yeah, of my child who does CRU, Serena Dugan, and really, I missed some of the earlier comments, but just to echo. Sorry, can you turn your camera at all? Oh, let me see. Yeah, let me see if I can turn my camera on. You've

223got to do that to speak. Hello? Can you see me? No, we just get your name. You have to do that to speak. There, now we can see you. Oh, there. There, now you can see me. Okay, great. Sorry. I'm not sure if other folks brought this up, but I wanted to just comment on the potential, the consideration to have crew removed as a varsity high school sport. And I just wanted to echo what I believe other folks may have already shared, but it's been a really transformative experience for our family and for our daughter who is a sophomore. and she did it for the very first time this past last year as a freshman and the camaraderie the the the team spirit and really the the coming together from just not just not just

224among you know the the girls team but really being able to kind of work alongside the boys to really have a real sense of just team spirit and a real sense of accomplishment. Learning a sport that's actually very physically demanding takes a great deal of time. It's something that these kids have to do every single day without, and they miss breaks, and they do a lot of... There's more than just team building and athleticism at play. And so I just wanted to emphasize that it would be a real shame and a real loss to Spursville High School if we didn't have crew continuing as a high school sport. What I found to be incredibly enlightening was just how incredibly close-knit this community is. In a way that I don't think we've been here 20 years.

225that I've ever come across any community out, you know, not just in athletics, but just, you know, even in other parts of our lives. It's an incredibly close-knit community. I was very, very impressed with how incredibly organized it is. And the kids who participate in it are very committed to it. And a lot of them move on and do it, continue on. continuing this sport in college. So it's just something that I think we should very carefully consider not removing. And I would urge the board members to really listen to the comments from the other parents and from the kids. And hopefully our child will be able to participate in the next meeting. But I just wanted to emphasize that I've been very impressed with not... not just the organization and the actual experience my

226child has had, but how incredibly diverse it is and how it's really elevated her sense of belonging and her self-confidence and her self-esteem in a way that nothing else at Scarzell High School has. And so I just wanted to share that with you. Thank you. Could you quickly state your address? Oh, yes, this is Shirley Dugan. I'm at 22 Butler Road, Scarzo, New York. Thank you very much. Is there anybody else on Zoom? No, nothing else for me. Thank you. I don't believe there's anyone else on Zoom. All right. Thank you. And with that, we will close the second public comment session of the meeting and move on to follow up to public comment. Thank you, Shirley. Last would be wrap-up items. Just so. The board is just going back to budget study session number

227one. I think it sounds like more detail on the calculations to the Empire Plan cost from our census. More considered description or detailed description of what health plan options might be out there and what that would look like. Does that sound right so far? Historical section breaks. and use of contingency? Oh, the cost per athlete. Mean that's dependent upon their response I just just if you're gonna do cost per athlete I know that Cindy didn't include transportation, but I think that is an important component of These programs. I know that's not easy to do so I'm not necessarily saying but even just outlining like okay, we transport, you know five days a week that distance Yes, exactly. I think that would be helpful to hourly cost. Yeah Next would be meeting dates for the coming

228month Jim Thank You Susie meeting dates for the coming month Monday February 10th There's a special meeting slash executive session here high school in this room Tuesday February 11th there is a board community coffee at 7 p.m. here in this room Monday March 3rd 2025 there will be a special meeting slash executive session at 6 p.m Here and then a budget study session our second one and a business meeting also here starting at 630 Monday March 10th 2025 there will be a third budget study session in this room and Monday March 24th 2025 there will be a Special meeting slash executive session starting at 530 here and then a budget forum slash business meeting starting at 6 30 in this room thank you jim uh and with that would anybody like to make a motion

229to adjourn this meeting thank you leah uh is there a second thank you amber any discussion all those in favor please say aye um as happen in motion carries good night everybody

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.