001Good evening. I call this board business meeting to order and note that all board members are present. We are also joined by Superintendent Dr. Patrick and his administrative cabinet. Thank you to all joining us in person, on the live stream, and on Zoom. Welcome back to school. I hope everyone had a joyful, restorative holiday break. Thank you. Sorry for the technical difficulties. And at this first board meeting of 2025, I would like to wish everyone all the best in the new year. May this year bring good health and fulfillment and meaning with friends and family. January is not only the beginning of the calendar year, but also the start of budget season on the state level, which our board will, of course, be following closely. Tomorrow, January 14th, Governor Hochul is expected to deliver her
002State of the State Address. And our executive budget is due to be released on January 21st. With the reformulation of foundation aid and uncertainty around safe harmless, this advocacy season might prove to be a busy one for our board. Advocacy by the board can take various forms. Board members can advocate as individual board members. The board as a body can make a statement. And or the board could advocate through one or both school board associations our Scarsdale board is a member of. Westchester Putnam School Board Association and the New York State School Board Association. You might recall in the fall, Leah as our NISPA liaison attended their annual business meeting and cast our votes on a long list of proposed resolutions. Thank you, Leah. Over the next few weeks, West Putts Legislative Advocacy Forum will
003be held as well as West Putts Legislative Round Tables where our board liaison will meet virtually with our local legislators to provide feedback to specific legislative priorities facing our district. Thank you Ron for serving as West Putts board liaison this year. These advocacy efforts, which alongside and in partnership with other organizations such as LHEC and NISQIS, the superintendent's organization, we aim to support legislation that meets the needs of our students, to promote teaching and learning for all our students, to care for student health and well-being, and to help manage operations and infrastructure of our aging buildings. Next, I'd like to invite the community to our third Board Coffee of the Year. It will be held this week, Wednesday, January 15th at 10 AM here in room 170, 172. The evening coffee originally scheduled for January
00422nd is being rescheduled so as not to conflict with an upcoming PT Council programming event and nominating committee elections. So please stay tuned for that. The board very much looks forward to meeting community members and to fostering communication and transparency through these informal get togethers. And with that, I'll hand it over to Drew. Terrific. Thank you very much, Susie. I appreciate it, and I add my welcome to everyone in the audience and online, and wish a happy new year to everyone in our community as well. I'd like to start my update tonight by recognizing one of our seniors, Kelly Dang, who was named a semifinalist in the Regeneron Science Talent Search, one of 17 semifinals in Westchester and only 300 across the nation. Her research is entitled Macrophage Stimulating Protein Slash RON, Sensitivity Underlies the
005Pathogenesis of Premenstrual Dysphoric Disorder, Potential for Novel Pharmacological Interventions via Transcriptomic Imputation. Just let you digest that for a second. But that's fantastic. Congratulations to Kelly. and as Susie mentioned January is a busy time of year there's a lot of planning that is now very much underway for next year including online kindergarten registration which opened on January 8th current residents who expect to have a child attend kindergarten during the 25-26 school year are encouraged to complete this process by the end of the month January 31st although prospective kindergartners of course may register at any time before the start of the school year completing this process early ensures the smoothest screening and placement process Children whose fifth birthday falls on or before December 31st, 2025 may be registered. If you're unsure which school your child should
006attend, feel free to contact our registrar. She's in our office, Nunzia Morrow at 721-2444 or email registrar at scarsdaleschools.org. And as Susie also mentioned, we're entering actually the heart of our budget development process. So I thought I'd take a few moments in the opening comments here to outline the steps in the process and highlight some upcoming meetings, which of course are in the agenda and will be also reviewed at the end of tonight's meeting. Just to remind folks, the board held a special meeting on November 18th to invite community input on 2025-26 budget priorities. the board will hold a business meeting on January 27th in this room to discuss the initial budget development and staffing recommendations for the 25-26 school year following that a week later will be budget study session number one where we
007will cover current year-end projections that's for the current school year because they impact our draft budget plan for 2025-26 we'll discuss the budget drivers and budget components including debt service transportation where we'll follow up our earlier transportation study with some recommendations for next year's budget benefits and athletics then a month later budget study session two will be held that will be march 3rd we'll provide as we always do an updated draft budget plan and then focus on budget components and instruction, special education, facilities, safety and security, and technology. Then a week after that, on March 10th, we'll have the next budget study session, number three, where again we'll provide an update based on the prior meeting, and then a full budget presentation from top to bottom. At the business meeting on March 24th, there will
008be another public forum for comments related to the budget and a review of the draft budget plan. And remember, we call it a draft. until the board adopts the budget and we call it a plan because the budget really is a plan. It's our best thinking at the time when it's put forward around estimated expenses and estimated revenues knowing that things happen and that plan changes but that we do our best to come in or under budget. Then the board will hold a business meeting on April 7th where we expect that you'll act to adopt a budget and that timing is important because there's a number of benchmarks that follow after that that are statutorily required prior to the ultimate budget vote so we submit a tax report card to the state education department after
009that the budget is adopted by the board we develop and distribute the budget insight mailer that goes to every home in the community we mail budget notice related to that The board will hold a statutory budget hearing that will take place on May 12th, which is eight days before the budget vote, which will occur on Tuesday, May 20th. And as a reminder, that's not just a budget vote. That's also the board election, and that will take place at the Scarsdale Middle School Gymnasium. so a reminder that that's the work ahead of us among other business to propose and then work through a budget to the point where the board adopts it and puts it to the public for a vote okay next I'm gonna shift to around the district and tonight I'm just gonna focus
010on some examples of the non-cibi activities that our students are engaged in across the district again please keep in mind this is just these are just some some highlights this is not a comprehensive report but just to give you an idea of of some of the things and tonight whoops tonight just making the connection with our strategic plan this emphasizes on really on leading the goal of leading where the student facing goal is to foster student understanding of interdependence and nurture self-efficacy and agency to make an impact in the world. And we think these activities are part of the story, part of what helps that happen. And these things always depend on partnership, partnership with outside organizations or agencies, partnership with our parents, our PTAs, and members of the community. So we really appreciate that
011part of it too. So we'll start with an example from Edgewood. This is where second grade students delivered donations from a toy and gift drive to Cardinal McCloskey Community Services. That organization provides holiday gifts for early childhood centers, children in foster care, and adults with developmental disabilities. And on this trip, students learned about the process for checking in gifts so that they can be distributed to the people who need them most. They went straight to work sorting toys and gifts from Edgewood and other donating organizations and spread some holiday cheer to those in need. This goes back to last spring where Fox Meadow participated in the cereal box challenge where they collected 2,100 boxes of cereal that were donated to Feeding Westchester. One of the cool things here is you'll notice some bigger people in
012the picture. Those are high school students who, as part of non-civy day, came over and helped them organize. And they kicked this off with the domino challenge. So the cereal boxes. went through both floors of the building, or three floors of the building, and ended in the gym with every box knocking over the one in front of it. It was pretty cool, some good math activities, and there they are delivering it to Feeding Westchester. This year after the turkey trot at Green Acres, fifth grade students counted, bundled, and boxed a total of 448 pairs of gently worn or new shoes to make a positive impact on their community. They called it Souls for Souls shoe drive, and the collection provides relief to people in need and helps the planet by extending the life of shoes
013that might not otherwise have been. you know they might have been discarded we'll move to some examples at the middle school Butler six has been actively engaged in a whole bunch of non-civile activities dedicating their time and energy for positive impact they focused in December on the goal middle school why goal of purpose they made holiday cards for the residents of the white plane senior center designing and writing over a hundred cards and they organized a school-wide holiday toy drive for toys for tots and they donated a total of 390 toys, surpassing their goal of 300. Meanwhile, Cooper House students here are making sandwiches for those in need, served by the Dorothy Day Hospitality House in Danbury. Another example, students in Keystone created cards for veterans and hospitalized military members as part of Operation Gratitude.
014It's something that's been done for several years around the holidays, and this year they're going to also make Valentine's Day cards in February. Back to Human Rights Day. This is, non-civi is a big part of Human Rights Day in the middle school. There are a variety of activities. that enabled students to learn about local and global issues affecting people and their access to human rights. They constructed toys for dogs in the Guiding Eyes program, assembled bicycles for students or for children who participated in programs in El Centro Hispano, harvested fresh produce and made cookies which were donated to Meals on Main. They made bracelets with supportive messages for athletes in the Able Athletics program, collected and sorted hygiene supplies for the FIAA Foundation. created pop-up cards for seniors in our community, decorated candles for patients
015at White Plains Hospital, and more. Scarcell High School students also participated at the middle school by educating students on topics ranging from ASL to the challenges of differently abled athletes participating with ABLE, and the Human Rights Club constructed quilts with the middle schoolers following a presentation on refugees, and here is one of those quilts, and it's our segue to the high school. Club officers help take what the students did and sew these together and make a quilt and they send these quilts to an organization called Wrap the World with Quilts, which donates quilts to refugees around the world. If anyone has done it, making a quilt is a time-consuming endeavor, but fosters a real sense of pride and accomplishment. These are some scenes from the Help Animals Club. The Help Animals Club at the high
016school raised $550 to help cover medical costs for animals located at Safe Haven Farm Sanctuary. This is Virginia, the pig there on the right. She suffered from an infection in her hoof, and her caretakers were hoping that good medical care would stave off an amputation, and their donation helped actually accomplish that. So this is a different type of club, and the students get first-hand experience with the animals. And, of course, a tried-and-true club, the Midnight Run, where our students at Scarcell High School collect goods for people in need in the city, and then they go into Manhattan and hand them out to people who... are seeking shelter and need supplies. So our students consistently demonstrate compassion, leadership, and a strong sense of responsibility when they engage in these. And the experience has not only enriched
017them personally, but they really foster that spirit of collaboration and service. And their commitment to helping others really reflects one of our core values, leading it back to our community and to the strategic plan. So I wanted to share those things. Okay. And just in closing, some important dates, three dates coming up to note that are important. First, Monday, January 20th, is, of course, Martin Luther King Jr. Day, and our schools are closed in observation of that day. On January 27th is International Holocaust Remembrance Day, and on January 29th will be Lunar New Year, and our schools will be closed on that Wednesday as well. Thank you. Thank you, Drew. Affirming our Scarsdale value of non-CIVI is such a wonderful way to start the new year. Thank you. Okay, great. Next on the agenda would
018be board member reports. Do we have any board member reports? Thank you, Bob. I attended a presentation titled The Arrival of Generative AI in Schools on January 6th at the Middle School Auditorium. The presenter was Jesse Dukes, who is a journalist and researcher with the MIT Teaching Systems Lab. The goal of the presentation was to further explain what AI is, how it is currently being used within various school systems, and to report on what he observed following his day talking to the schools in Scarsdale. For me, the takeaway was a better understanding of generative AI, such as chat GPT, and what the future might hold for districts like Scarsdale in terms of embracing the new technology. One comment Jesse Dukes made, which resonated with me, is that we as a community should be proud of
019the fact that Scarsdale is thinking about AI in a very organized and thoughtful way. And that not all districts are doing that. It's definitely a big unknown as far as a future role of AI in curriculum development and teaching. But there is no denying that it is here to stay and must be managed and acknowledged. Scarsdale appears to be on the right track. Thank you, Bob. I was at that presentation as well and really did find it very informative. I especially appreciated the school's perspective on how we are handling AI here in Scarsdale. Principal Bonamo, Meredith Dutra, and William Yang were all there in attendance, and I thought that was very nice as well. Thank you. Are there any other board member reports today? I guess we'll go next to cabinet updates. Great. We have
020four updates. We'll start with Edgar in curriculum. Thank you Drew. Ray Papalardi, Director of Physical Education and Health and I hosted a webinar last Tuesday for K-5 parents and guardians. Purpose was to explain recent and upcoming changes to the elementary health program. Ray described his work gathering information, aligning standards and collecting resources. This includes expanding lessons required by Aaron's Law on personal body safety. I reviewed the updates to the fifth grade puberty education incorporating recent student questions and educator feedback. Participants could submit questions during the webinar and it was recorded for those unable to attend live and the recording will be available in the coming days. The following morning, Ray and I hosted a well-attended elementary health coffee session in this room. This event was specifically for families with current fifth graders, allowing them to
021review curriculum materials and ask follow up questions in person. Special thanks to Jeannie and her tech team for managing Wi-Fi, website access, and setting up 24 laptops around this room, giving parents a kind of parallel experience to their children. We plan to make this an annual event to reflect the ongoing refinement to our resources. And regarding puberty education, I wanted to highlight a PTC-sponsored speaker, Vanessa Kroll-Bennett, who will be speaking at the Middle School Auditorium this Wednesday at 7 p.m. She's the co-author of This Is So Awkward, Modern Puberty Explained, and co-host of the accompanying podcast. The work of Ms. Bennett and her collaborator, Dr. Kara Patterson. offers valuable valuable guidance and helped inform our curriculum design team and ray and i will meet with both of them on friday via zoom to discuss their
022newest work in curriculum and resource development Terrific. Thank you very much, Edgar. We'll turn it over to Andrew for two updates, auditorium and the middle school gym. So I'll start with the auditorium. We've got about two-thirds of our scaffolding has been removed, so a lot of the contractors are now working at ground level for the first time in several months, which is nice. We're starting to see paint go up all throughout the auditorium, and it's really nice to see that actually when you come in the hallway. I took a sneak peek, some of the new finishes in that hallway as you come in and then along the... the high walls now you can see the paint jobs that are going up so it's really exciting to start to see some of that come together. We
023are still anxiously awaiting the arrival of many of the bigger items so the case work for the changing rooms. the seats the wall panels and the woodwork that goes around the proscenium browse so we're still watching those very closely but the high school and the contractors have been working together and we are anxiously waiting for that March turnover date where we'll really see students performing in that space for the first time which is going to be exciting and Jabberfest I think will be on the schedule in April too I think that's a big high school thing In the other item on my cabinet update is the middle school gym. So I spoke last time about how we had an unfortunate flooding incident because of a broke pipe. I'm happy to say that the gym has
024been replaced and is now back in service with the middle school PE program using that space this week and towards the end of last week as well, I believe. So there are some minor kind of touch-ups to go back that we have to deal with, but I think from... based on my discussion with principal coughlin this afternoon the appreciation goes to the facilities and custodial staff for really turning that place over so quickly during the break and having it back up and running and it's really a nice job that they did and we appreciate that i would be remiss to say that that if i didn't talk about our insurance company nicer who really quickly mobilized got contractors in here and paid them directly so there was no delay in getting them paid and those
025contractors really did a great job for us over the break so thank you to the facility staff and to nicer for for supporting us through that awful flood experience there so that's my update Thank you. Thank you, Andrew. And Eric's going to note a gift. I am thrilled to note this gift from the Edgewood PTA, which is for supplies and startup funds for a coffee cafe at the Edgewood School, which is a project through Allison Lerner and Elise Kosky, who will be building out a coffee cafe for our older students in the special classes, really focusing in on foundational... academic skills such as life math skills functional math skills organization task initiation and then that coupled with the social aspect and verbal communication practice that it takes to run a coffee cafe for the teachers
026at Edgewood so I'm really really thrilled to see this get off the ground and hearty thanks to the Edgewood PC PTA Thank you Eric and we'll conclude with Megan regarding the parent survey So this week I'll be sending out our annual survey to parents and guardians asking for feedback on our faculty during their probationary period of employment and our part-time and leave replacement teachers and this feedback helps the district with the decision-making as we contemplate recommendations for tenure and continuation a number of years ago the district initiated a parent feedback survey designed to respond to parents' requests for a chance to comment on the performance of their children's teachers prior to tenure. And this was done as a result of a dialogue with the PTC, the Scarsdale Teachers Association, and the district administration. The survey
027looks and asks parents to share their perspectives on their child's experience in the teacher's class or the faculty member's class. And so we ask about communication in this survey between home and school, their perspective on their child's learning and growth with the classroom environment and the classroom environment. It's just one piece in a robust process that I know the board is able to hear part of those portfolio conversations that involves multiple classroom observations each year. portfolio that's reviewed by building and district administrators and all of this feedback is shared in the end with the faculty member and we really view it as an opportunity for their growth and development as well as part of the the tenure process and so I just ask that parents and guardians keep an eye out for that survey this
028week and we would appreciate your involvement in that way thank you all does anybody on the board have any questions or comments Quick question on the middle school gym. I know that space historically was also used by the rec department and others. Is that back open to them now? I know that they fairly significantly rearranged their schedule for the rec program this winter. I don't know if they're going to now undo any of those scheduling updates they made and turn it over, but I think the space is now available if those spaces need to be reserved by the rec department. Has someone communicated that to them? I'll have to follow up and see if the facilities department spoke with them, but I know that the rec department and facilities department have been actively talking. I
029just don't know that if they've got their schedules in place, I don't know if they're going to be revisiting that. I'll find out for you. That's up to them. I just acknowledge having watched a bunch of eighth graders play on a small Heathcote gym. It is tight, and they may want to if it's available. Thank you to everybody getting that space back. up and running so fast. It was really amazing. Thank you. And you also triggered a remembrance. I should have thanked the rec department because they are a significant user of that space and they were very gracious and understanding in rescheduling everything. I think everything a terrible, unfortunate experience, but we were able to get all the programs operating in other spaces across the district, which was really good. Thank you so much. A
030lot of good work going on right now. Thank you. Okay. Item four on the agenda would be our public comment period. This will be the first of two public comment periods this evening. And I will start with the preamble. Members of the public are cordially invited to speak on district related items or other non-personnel related matters during two separate public comment periods. When it is your turn to speak, please state your name, address, and if you are speaking on behalf of an organization. For those commenting remotely, please mute the live stream voice, turn on your camera, and then unmute yourself. This may be a good time to do that now. Speakers will be asked to conclude their remarks after four minutes and will be given a verbal cue at the three-minute mark. If at this
031point a speaker has additional comments, they may send them in writing to the board via email at boardofed at scarsaleschools.org. The public comment period is reserved for comments only. The board will not engage in dialogue. The board reserves the right to respond to comments and questions at its discretion, either during response to public comment or at a later time and place. Response to public comment will take place after the first and second public comment periods. And with that, I'd like to invite anybody in the audience tonight who would like to make a public comment. No? Okay. Then we'll turn to Zoom. Jim? There are currently no attendees on Zoom. People are still in the holiday. We'll give it a couple seconds. Anybody join? No. Okay. And with that, we will be closing our first public
032comment period. And therefore, the item five, follow-up to public comment, we can skip as there were none. And moving right along to item six, written communications. Jim, do you want to read the preamble? Thank you, Susie. Please note the Board of Education email is also viewed by the superintendent and district clerk. Open meetings law requires all board deliberations which may lead to action or policy changes to occur in public. Therefore, your written communications and emails will be reported at an upcoming public board meeting. A board member will respond at their earliest convenience. Formal response requires that you include your full name, address, and if you are writing on behalf of an organization in the communication. More detailed information regarding written communications received by the board may be found in today's meeting agenda located in board
033docs on the Scarsdale school district's website and in terms of the written communications that have been received since our last meeting a total of six Responded to all of which were on district matters Thank You Jim Next item seven would be the consent agenda and first I will read the preamble to the consent agenda The board may conduct some of its business using a consent agenda in an effort to achieve greater efficiency at the board meetings. A consent agenda condenses some of the routine business of the Board of Education into a single motion. The consent agenda is prepared by the superintendent of schools in consultation with the president and or the vice president of the board. Items are selected for the consent agenda when the officers of the board and the superintendent believe there is
034no controversy regarding them. The items on the consent agenda will have the same background material as ordinary items on the board agenda. If any member of the board feels that any item on the consent agenda requires discussion prior to action, that board member may remove that item from the consent agenda merely by requesting same at the meeting. The exempted item then moves to the regular agenda. However, all non-exempted items would be moved, seconded, and voted upon without discussion in order to provide greater efficiency to conducting the routine items of business of the school district. At this time, I'd like to ask the board if there are any items on the consent agenda that they would like to pull out of the consent agenda. No? Okay. Next then would be item eight, the consent agenda. And
035I believe this is Leah. Thank you, Suzy. Tonight, we have nine items on the consent agenda. Item 8.01, minutes, education report business meeting, December 16th, 2024. Item 8.02, personnel certified. Item 8.03, personnel non-certified. Item 8.04, claims audit report December 2024. Item 8.05, contracts over 20K, special education. Item 8.06, contracts over 20K, crew team. Item 8.07, high school band room roof bid recommendations, Milcon Construction Corp. Item 8.08, district village agreement, Green Acres Playground. and item 8.09, accept consent agenda. I move that the board accept the consent agenda as presented. Thank you, Leah. Is there a second? Thank you, Ron. Any discussion? All those in favor, please say aye. Aye. The ayes have it and the motion carries. Next on the agenda would be item nine, information items for discussion. 9.01 would be the treasurer's report. Thank
036you, Lisa. Good evening. um tonight there are two treasurer reports being presented for the months of october and november of 2024. this will bring us up to date we were a little behind with the new system so we're finally caught up So some items to note, taxes. Tax bills were issued September 1st with the first half payment due September 30th. So a substantial portion of that revenue did come in in October and November. In October you'll see there's 86.8 million in taxes received and another 10 million in November. As of November 30th, approximately 63% of the 169 million warrant has been received. So in November there was also the third quarter sales tax payment for $518,000. Over the two months, state and federal aid, there was a total of $691,000 in state aid and a
037total of $246,000 in grant funds. Interest earnings, combined interest earnings over the two months is still approximately $600,000. The rates are dropping, so not a huge significant shift yet. They went from a high of 5.1 in September and it's down to about 4.6 in November. So we are continuing to monitor the revenue, but as far as current year projections and budget, as of 11-30, we're at $1.17 million, which is about 67% of the original budget for interest earnings. So as of now, we still are in good shape. For disbursements, vendor warrants were approximately $7.6 million in October and $8.9 million in November. And semi-monthly gross payrolls for the combined two months is approximately $18.4 million. Any questions? Thank you, Lisa. Now, just a question about the two installments, if you're paying in two separate payments.
038When is the second payment? January. In January. Okay, so just so the residents look out for that. Yes, so you'll see a larger chunk again probably in February. Okay. And then again, the towns make us whole in April. Okay, thank you. Okay, next, item 9.02, a policy review. Eric? Thank you. So this was an opportunity to take a look at our concussion management policy in 2023. At the end of the year, they changed the guidance out of the state, taking away final clearance for return to activities from the district physician for non athletes and returning that to the private medical practitioners. So this did not change the guidelines for student athletes, but it did change the guidelines back to pre return to play protocol days for non student athletes. So we've really updated the policy
039to reflect that and we've taken the opportunity to make our protocol a little bit more efficient, change a form for doctors to make it state very, very obviously exactly what we need in order to clear athletes as they come back and in order for us to make sure that we are following the doctor's orders as students come back. So happy to answer any questions on that. This is a first read, so it will come back later this month for a second read and adoption. Yeah. Thanks, Eric. So this is a change in policy, and I assume that when students get a concussion, the nurses will communicate to the parents, if they're not an athlete, that the doctor should clear them for physical activity, not return to play. Correct. Okay, great. Thank you. It will save
040a lot of time. It will. It actually will save a lot of time, and it actually was more difficult from a non-athlete standpoint to engage the return to play through phys ed, which only happens a few times a week versus the everyday practice. So we hope this will streamline the process. So this is a state change that? It was a state change that no longer requires the return to play protocol for non-athletes. I just have a question more related to athletes and just process, not necessarily the change in the update. Does our district physician and athletic director annually review for our athletes who do contact sports? the best equipment to use in a year, you know, that type of thing every year? So the concussion management team meets on a quarterly basis to review our
041policies and practices. That can certain, so our doctor, Dr. Englund, does stay up on the latest. concussion management best practices, which is not only the medical end of treating concussions, but it's how to prevent concussions. So there are not specific equipment reviews on a yearly basis, but that is a regular part of what the athletic director and the medical director for the district think about. Just one quick question. So the is the definition of an athlete the state defines that for us right? So interscholastic athlete in season. And so that excludes intramural? They would fall under the non? Correct. Okay. Yeah, the state specifically talks about interscholastic athletes. Thanks. Thank you. Should we move on? Okay. Item 9.03 give proposal to high school. Okay, this is a discussion item for a gift from maroon and
042white to two different high school athletic teams The first is some performance technology for our ski team totaling $5,898 and the second item is a competition mat for our wrestling team at thirteen thousand six hundred and fifty dollars background information on the attached letters, but it's a gift we are grateful for and would you have a couple of weeks to think about this before it would come back as an approval item. Okay. Item 9.04, request for proposals for architecture and engineering firm. Is this Andrew or Drew? Do you want to start? Okay, yep, so two big things on the agenda tonight architect and engineering and construction management firms So as we presented back in the fall one of the benchmarks or key actions for moving forward with our capital planning process and potentially leading toward
043a bond referendum is the Selection of an architect and engineer firm and a construction management firm So tonight that's what we have here there's background information in this item about the process including the request for proposals and I'll have Andrew talk a little bit about the selection of our incumbent actually BBS yeah we had 17 firms send in proposals for our architecture and engineering RFP. We subsequently went through all of those and down-selected to four, then to three, and then ultimately to two, which after meeting with the Board of Education in executive session in December, Drew and I were tasked with some follow-up due diligence questions, and it was very helpful, actually, for us to go back and do that due diligence with both. BBS and the other firm and it really for us solidified
044that the capabilities of BBS as evidenced in their work here in the district and elsewhere as well as their familiarity with the district with SED and all the requirements that we as an owner will have on this firm we really think that they can be successful in this process with us going forward so the recommendation that we have in front of you this evening is to put our incumbent back and help us have them help us through its next bond referendum process we at a number of different points we had conversations both with the board but separately about the idea of the benefit of fresh eyes on our facilities and we did address that question with BBS and they heard they heard us and we'll think about strategies for maybe some different folks to be
045part of our building walkthroughs and constructing of a sense of what is needed. But in addition to that, there will also be fresh eyes through the next information item, which is through the construction management firms. I just wanted to kind of – there are other things we probed as well, of course, but – I just wanted to talk a little bit about that. And with that, item 9.05, the RFP for the construction management firm. Do you want to see if there are any questions on this work first? We can do them both together or whatever. Yeah, that's fine. If anyone has questions for the architect firm item, or we could do... I just wanted to thank you because I think that was one of our concerns with BBS returning was would it be beneficial for
046the district to have a set of fresh eyes looking at the buildings not assuming that you know they already know what's going on so just wanted to to thank you for making sure that that concern was addressed You know more about this than I do. So the construction manager really is the owner advocate, but also an independent kind of view of the construction process and budgeting. And it's really in a project of the size and scope that we... are likely to go down. It's really a key partner in the process. And in this instance we had, I believe it was six firms submit proposals for construction management services. One firm proposed late. So it should be seven plus one was late. We down-selected that to three firms, had interviews, and quite frankly, knowing what the
047board discussed about the architecture and engineering wants and desires, a fresh set of eyes, and the skills. abilities to support the district that that was demonstrated through Aris Contracting's proposal and interview we really feel we've got a great partner in the project going forward Aris Contracting is a well-established construction management firm formerly they were a GC as well they really have taken the the role of construction management to a different level part of their fee includes 3d scans of all of our buildings so that there's really an electronic record of the existing conditions that will help making sure that our construction documents are really precise and accurate for when we go out to bid so there's no surprises no one unanticipated change orders or should say minimal and they really demonstrated to us that the
048the approach that they take is not one sitting back and just watching what the architect does they really help drive the process and I think that's going to be an important piece for us in this project any questions can I just note in the resolutions at the at the in section 10 both resolutions are subject to the approval by the district legal counsel of the contract we are still working through that construction managers contract that is attached to the agenda item I updated earlier this evening it is the final version but the architect agreement is still pending final I's dotting and T's crossed with the attorneys. Thank you. Thank you, Andrew, for managing this whole process and vetting all of those different responses to our RFP. I really appreciate the Partners of the two like
049the architecture firm and the construction management firm. I think they complement each other really well I was very impressed with with Aris as well, and they would be the new fresh eyes looking at this Not only was their technology that you mentioned, you know so impressive but They they presented so well. They really knew what they were doing. They also placed a lot of emphasis which I appreciated on safety of our students both while they're doing their work and you know in terms of you know who they're hiring who they're letting into our buildings i think that's you know especially since it will be such a big project that a lot of it will be happening while we're in school you know while school's in session so i really appreciated that you know bbs knows
050our schools and so i think it's a good it's a good balance thank you next item a 9.06 nice at a regionalization initiative follow-up we did speak about this at our last meeting I don't know yeah I'd be happy to so at the last meeting and I included in the agenda item sort of the the content from that meeting just so people have easy access to it talked about this effort that New York State Education Department is making to try to get districts to discuss with one another opportunities for collaboration and maybe program sharing or some other things that we're not very clear about it's an idea that requires a form to be submitted and then a conversation and a plan to be developed with your local BOCES and districts in your BOCES once every
05110 years. There's a lot of unknown about this. There's some sort of frustration among school districts about the... what really is being asked and why was this being done through in particular emergency regulation which is how this came came about so when we discussed this last time thinking about things we already do to collaborate that would not be prohibited whether we participate or not it was it was my sense that the board was leaning toward us not participating which is an option that we have um in discussing this with our attorney that's not a specific action the board needs to take there doesn't need to be a resolution i can just let the State Education Department know whether we are whether we're not interested in participating as of last communication from the state that notification
052to State Ed would need to happen by Wednesday of this week so we wanted to revisit this just to make sure my understanding was accurate Do you have a sense as to what some of our peer districts are doing? Have they opted out? I know of several that are opting out and some were as of last Friday uncommitted I would say about what exactly what they're gonna do some districts have taken board action we don't think that's necessary and or compelled in any way Thank you. I've spoken to some other boards as well, and there are several school districts who are opting out. As I said at the last discussion when we talked about this too, my concern lies in the unknown and the lack of clarity and what this will mean or does mean.
053I don't think it's clear enough to be compelling. And as Drew said and as we discussed in December, there are many ways that as a district we already liaise and collaborate and are open to partnerships. and so that's what concerns me about this and I think that we have a lot of complex compelling work at the local level at our own district that requires a lot of our time and attention as it is so I just want to share that again Thank you Leah Anybody else? I've thought about this a lot since our last discussion and I more firmly believe we should opt out. I think for three reasons, some which Lee just talked about. One is the amount of work we have here at the local level for our students and our community. Two,
054the uncertainty. And three, as I think about some of the liaison assignments, I'm our liaison at West Putt. I know we get these emails and I look and I see it's not just me attending. There's a lot of other board members, administrators. We have collaboration at the board level, at the administrative level, at the superintendent level, at the building level. I can't speak for the rest of the state, but it seems like Westchester and Putnam are doing it pretty well. I think we're having tangible benefits from that work. And we're doing it. In fact, what I would, I don't know if there's a way to do this, but if we end up telling the state we're opting out, I would even love us to go a little further and say back to SCD, you know,
055this is why, and our region's been a model. And if that, maybe others in the state have too. I have no idea. But if there's a sense that this isn't happening in other parts, like I've always thought we've done this really well in Scarsdale, helped others as we've been a model in areas and a leader, and let's do that here. I just think what we have going on is working really well in terms of collaboration. And I would love to share that out, and maybe that can get SED to think about it a little differently. I'd be happy to include that in the communication. that makes sense that's how I feel I think that's how many of the districts feel yeah I guess if I some what I want to make sure we sum up
056is we believe in collaboration and sharing we are doing that and this is how and we would share that out with others I agree. I think Ron and Leah put it so well. I think I don't have anything to add except I would be in favor of opting out at this time. We do collaborate with other districts, and I think we really don't know what this is at this point. The lack of clarity is a concern. We want to ensure that we believe in local control, and we just... I don't know what this really is at this time. Thank you. Next, item 10, action items. 10.01 is the appointment of the district architect and engineer, and I believe this one is Leah again. Thank you, Susie. I move that the board adopt the following resolution.
057Resolved that the Board of Education awards the RFP for Architect and Engineering Services to BBS Architects, Landscape Architects and Engineers, PC, and authorizes the Assistant Superintendent for Business to execute the contract subject to final review and approval by District Legal Counsel. Thank you, Leah. Is there a second? Thank you, Bob. Any discussion? I just want to say thank you for this update and the work to get us to this point. As those around this table know, I do have a different view on the architecture firm before us and will not be supporting the appointment tonight. And while I will not be voting in favor of the appointment, I, of course, will do everything I can to support the next steps of the bond planning process as we move forward. Thank you, Ron. Anyone else? Okay.
058All those in favor, please say aye. All those not in favor, please say nay. Opposed. Opposed. Okay. The ayes have it and the motion carries. Okay. Next item, item 10.02, the appointment of the construction manager. I believe this is Bob. I move that the Board of Education awards the RFP for construction manager services to Ares Contracting Company Inc. and authorizes the assistant superintendent for business to execute the contract. subject to final review and approval by District Legal Counsel. Thank you, Bob. Is there a second? Any discussion? All those in favor, please say aye. The ayes have it, and the motion carries. Next item, 11.01, we're into gifts. I believe this one is Colleen. Thank you. Be it resolved that the Board of Education accept with thanks the gift of $1,997.39 for stencils and paint to
059add a peace path and various obstacle course to the blacktop areas at Edgewood School as presented. Thank you, Colleen. Is there a second? Thank you, Ron. Any discussion? All those in favor, please say aye. Ayes have it and the motion carries. Next item, 11.02, another gift proposal to Edgewood Elementary. I believe this is Amber. Yes, thank you, Susie. I move that the board accept the following. Resolve that the board accept with thanks the grant proposal of $700 to fund the Coffee Cafe wish list as presented in the attached letters. Thank you, Amber. Is there a second? Thank you, Colleen. Any discussion? All those in favor, please say aye. Aye. The ayes have it, and the motion carries with thanks. Next gift item, Fox Meadow Elementary School, and I believe this one is Bob. Yes. I
060move that the board accept with thanks the gift of $1,625 for a new sensory path for the kindergarten wing of the Fox Meadow School as presented in the attached letters. Thank you, Bob. Is there a second? Thank you, Amber. Any discussion? All those in favor, please say aye. Aye. Ayes have it, and the motion carries. Next item would be a good proposal to, let's see, which one's next? The middle school? Fox Middle. Yeah, that would be Ron. Thank you. Thanks, Susie. I move the following, resolve that the board accept with thanks the gifts of $1,950.50 to fund supplies needed to host a World Language Day in March 2025 for all SMS students as presented in the attached letters. Thank you, Ron. Is there a second? Thank you, Leah. Any discussion? All those in favor, please
061say aye. Aye. The ayes have it and the motion carries with thanks. Okay, next. We are at our second public comment period. The preamble was read earlier in the meeting. I will read a little bit about the process. Members of the public are cordially invited to be present either in person or via remote means and to speak at designated times on agenda items or other non-personnel related matters. Each individual shall have four minutes to speak with a verbal cue at the three minute mark. There will be a 90 minute cap during the first public comment period. I believe that is an error. Community members present at the board meeting will speak first. Community members speaking via Zoom will speak second. And community members speaking via Zoom must have their cameras turned on when it is
062their turn to speak. At this time, I'd like to invite anybody from the audience to come to the podium and make a public comment. We'll look at Zoom. There are no attendees on Zoom. We'll give it a couple seconds. Still no attendees on Zoom. Okay. Thank you, Jim. Okay. Maybe at our next meeting Follow up to public comment item 13. There will there's no need item 14 wrap-up items And meeting dates for the coming month Jim Thank You Susie so for the coming month we have the following meeting dates Wednesday January 15th we have a board community coffee at 10 a.m. here in room 170 172 Monday January 27th we have a board special meeting executive session at 5 here in this room there's a budget staffing recommendations and business meeting starting at 630 in
063this room and if needed a special meeting executive session thereafter monday february 3rd 2025 a board budget study session number one and business meeting shall commence at 6 30 here afterwards a special meeting or executive session if needed monday february 10th 2025 special meeting executive session has been scheduled for 6 p.m in this room thank you jim would someone like to make a motion to adjourn this meeting Thank you, Ron. Is there a second? Thank you, Leah. Any discussion? Anybody opposed? All those in favor, please say aye. The ayes have it and the motion carries. Thank you so much. Have a good night, everybody.