CorpusRecord 134268

BOE Business Meeting 2024-12-16

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
Vimeo / Scarsdale Streaming Network
Date
2024-12-17
Location
Westchester County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
19,151 words · about 107 min
Collected
2026-06-17

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001Good evening. I call this meeting to order and note that all board members are present. We are also joined by Dr. Patrick and his administrative cabinet. Thank you to those in the audience joining us tonight as well as those watching on the live stream or on Zoom. This is a public forum on the district-wide safety and emergency management plan. And with that, I'll first turn it over to Drew and Eric. Okay. I'm going to let Eric take it away. subsequent to our approval of the district emergency response plan in July of last year there was a state change requiring us to add an annex to the district emergency response plan we had discussed I believe it was two meetings ago that plan and opened it for a 30-day comment period that 30-day comment period has

002been open and we're looking to hear from any community members on concerns or questions and then have that on the board meeting for approval tonight Thank you. And with that, we will open up to public comments. I will read this procedural note. Members of the public are cordially invited to be present either in person or via remote means and to speak about the district-wide safety and emergency management plan. There is no time limit on comments during the public hearing. Please be mindful of the time so that everyone who wishes to speak has an opportunity. The order of public comment will be as follows. Community members present at the board meeting will speak first. Community members speaking via Zoom will speak second. Community members speaking via Zoom must have their cameras turned on when it is

003their turn to speak. When it is your turn to speak, please state your name, address, and if you are speaking on behalf of an organization. Comments may also be sent to the board via email at boardofed at scarsdaleschools.org. And with that, I'd like to invite anybody in the audience who might like to make a public comment regarding the safety and emergency management plan. Okay. Then next we will go to Zoom. Jim? Thank you. There's currently no attendees on Zoom. Okay. Thank you. And we will give it a couple seconds. See if anybody is trying to log on. Still no attendees. Okay, thank you. And with that, I will be closing the public comment forum portion of this evening's meeting. Would anybody like to make a motion to adjourn the public hearing? Thank you, Leah. I'd

004like to make a second. Thank you, Colleen. All those in favor, please say aye. Thank you. The ayes have it and the motion carries. And this public hearing is closed. And we're going to go right into our business meeting. So I guess maybe I get to do the gavel again. Good evening once again. I'd like to call this business meeting to order and note that all board members are present. We are joined by Superintendent Dr. Patrick and members of the administrative cabinet as well. Welcome once again to all those who have joined us this evening either in the audience or tuning in on our live stream via Zoom. Earlier this evening, the board met with the Scarsdale Principals Association. We hold this meeting each year and it is a wonderful opportunity for the board to

005meet with our building principals and assistant principals. Our discussion included topics such as the Off and Away Cell Phone Initiative and focused generally on student mental health and wellness. We appreciate the hard work of our principals. and assistant principals and thank them for taking the time to meet with us to share the details of their important work this year. Next, for those just tuning in, immediately prior to this business meeting, we held a public forum on the district-wide safety and emergency management plan. This plan was updated to reflect new New York State Education Department mandates enacted after we held our annual adoption of the safety and emergency management plan in the summer. This revised plan was introduced at October 21st's business meeting, after which followed a 30-day notice period, and now after this evening's public

006forum, the updated plan is slated for adoption in tonight's consent agenda. As part of the district and village collaboration and partnership, we held our bi-monthly meeting between district and village leadership a couple weeks ago. We discussed a number of items related to safety, security, and emergency management, the field study, and other current and potentially future joint items. We hold these joint meetings throughout the year in addition to the many joint meetings held between school and village administrators and staff members. Thank you to the mayor, village board, and village management for their partnership and collaboration on many items on behalf of our community. Next, the board has recently engaged in meetings to interview architecture and engineering firm candidates. And members of the board are also meeting with contractor management firm candidates. The board met with three

007finalists out of 17 architecture and engineering firms that submitted responses to our RFP and will be meeting a total of three contractor management firms as well. Thank you to Andrew Lennon and his staff for all the work vetting and conducting all the due diligence on these firms. We are excited to identify the teams that will spearhead the future capital improvements to our district that will further student learning, living, and leading. Lastly, I would like to wish everyone a joyous holiday break as this is our last board meeting of the calendar year. And with that, I'd like to turn it over to Drew. Thank you very much. Good evening to everyone. I add my welcome to all present and watching online. And I'd like to reiterate Ms. Hahn's words of thanks to our Principals Association. our

008principals and assistant principals are truly our lead teachers and support learning and teaching on top of managing the complexities that come with running our schools day to day they are our essential partners in this work and i'm going to take this opportunity to highlight one of them and that's sharon hill principal of green acres sharon will be retiring at the end of the month which is just a few short weeks away she joined the Scarsdale schools ten years ago and when she did we gained an expert in teaching and learning in reading and writing and in kids it took Sharon some time to win over the Green Acres school community but win them over she did her hallmarks a wide and deep knowledge base passion for learning optimistic spirit genuine smile and high expectations have

009helped Green Acres to grow and to thrive Sharon was a proactive champion for the renovation and addition at Greenacres as she helped the stakeholders work through decisions and overcome obstacles while keeping our students at the center she presided over the nomination application and receipt of a National Blue Ribbon School Award and most importantly she's contributed to the improvement of teaching and learning in Greenacres and across the district personally and professionally I will miss Sharon whom I consider both an expert educator and a friend we wish her nothing but the best in her retirement and know her impact will live on at green anchors I also want to thank you Susie for your update on the architect and engineering firms and CM firm search we're continuing our due diligence and we look forward to hopefully taking

010action or asking the board to take action on a recommendation in January The next updates I have tonight, sorry this is a little bit long tonight, but the next updates tonight pertain to state policy and legislation, everybody's favorite topics. First, on Monday, December 2nd, the Rockefeller Institute issued the results of their review of New York State's Foundation Aid Education Funding Formula, including their recommendations for improvement of that formula. The report is quite lengthy but full of interesting and important data and information. The report does a good job, or the executive summary I should say, does a good job of laying out a wide range of policy choices that the state legislature could consider. The two areas that I believe are potentially most relevant to Scarsdale include the recommendations pertaining to Save Harmless and to special

011education. The former comes as no real surprise. The proposal is to effectively eliminate Save Harmless, but recommends a gradual phase out over five years and couples this with the recommendation to raise the unrestricted fund balance level to 10%. You'll recall it's currently at 4%. The latter makes the case for returning all special education aid to a categorical rather than a formula aid, which it was before the foundation formula was in place. So it's to be responsive to the real needs in local districts. interestingly after the release of the report governor Hochul indicated that she would not be recommending any change to save harmless in her forthcoming budget proposal so we will continue to monitor this closely and advocate to the extent we can for the maintenance of same save harmless and just to remind people

012that means the proposal the governor had last year to phase out save harmless would have meant a decrease in state aid We don't expect an increase to be suggested, but we would prefer at least to have a long lead time to understand if there's a decrease, or better yet, no decrease at all. This past Friday, the governor also signed two pieces of legislation passed during the last session. First, she signed a bill that changes from 12 years to 8 years the length of time districts can receive their aid on zero-emission bus purchases. this better aligns to the expected useful life of zero emissions buses so could could be a impact positive impact remains to be seen based on what we do second the governor signed a bill setting maximum allowable temperatures in school classrooms and

013support spaces to 88 degrees It requires a plan for the removal of students and staff from these spaces where it is practical for the school district to do so. It also creates a definition of extreme heat condition days as well as a standard to measure room temperature when where in the room. The bill also directs school districts to take action to relieve heat related discomfort when classroom temperatures reach 82 degrees. such actions can include turning off overhead lights pulling down shades or blinds turning on fans opening classroom doors and windows turning off electronics and providing water breaks in remarks related to the signing of the bill the governor referred to an agreement with the legislature to and I quote clarify the process by which schools adopt extreme heat mitigation policies as well as ensuring school

014districts have the flexibility to determine how best to manage learning on extreme heat condition days while we don't know what this means exactly we will be examining our current building based cooling plans which have been in place for a number of years over the winter to determine what changes or adaptations we may need to make to ensure we're in compliance with the law so that was news over the weekend And then since it pertains to state policy, I also want to mention that we'll have an information and discussion item later in this meeting pertaining to regionalization. So I'll leave that to them. Okay. Next I'll move to around the district and tonight I'm going to recap the fall athletics season share some steam news and touch on the many performances our students have been engaged

015in before I do I have to point out that our students excel at so many different things inside and outside of school it is simply impossible to even know let alone capture everything so keep in mind this is a smattering so we'll start with fall sports and i'll highlight the outcomes since the last update that that i shared so when we last left off boys volleyball they had defeated ostening followed by yonkers to reach the sectional semifinals they had an unfortunate loss to north rockland but really had an amazing season and we congratulate them After boys soccer completed their three-peat by winning the Section 1 title game, they made it all the way to the state semifinals where they lost to a disappointing match to Shaker High School. Congrats to the boys soccer team on

016another amazing season. We last left our football team and just defeated Ossining, 28 to nothing, to reach the section semifinals versus Mimerneck, and they lost a heartbreaker on a field goal as time ran out. Again, another incredible season there. Our girls cross country team had just won the Westchester County Cross Country Championships with the boys team taking third. The girls went on to win the Section 1 Varsity Championships. And at the state meet, the Scarsdale girls team finished in fourth. Adriana Petinelli finished in fourth place overall with a time of 17.48. Rishi Sharapa took 15th place with a time of 15.46. And each race had 107 participants in it, so that's amazing. And finally, after finishing 9-0 and winning the conference two championships, the girls swimming and diving team went on to become sectional champs.

017At the state meet, Scarsdale swimmers finished in fifth place in the state and sixth in the federation. Just incredible. Lori Zhang was second in the 100 free and 10th in the 50 free. Sophie Reese came in 17th in the 100 free and 16th in the 200 free. Alex Horner came in 11th place in the 200 IM and 13th in the 100 breast. Sunny Kang came in 19th and Joy Kang came in 25th in the 200 IM. 400 free relay team came in fourth place the 200 medley relay team was in 11th place and the 200 free relay team which included Jim's daughter came in 19th place in the Federation so really just a like pretty much a record season for the girls swimming team so congratulations to them a season to remember I forgot to

018switch my slide here On to the STEAM and a few other happenings. Again, just a smattering of things. On December 4th, one of our eighth graders, William Tang, received a proclamation from Assemblywoman Amy Paulin. Some of us were there at the middle school to be part of that. After being a finalist in this year's 3M Young Scientist Competition, William developed an AI-smart artificial reef that is actually deployed in Long Island Sound right now. The very next day, his older brother, Vic, along with William, partnered with the Jed Foundation to deliver a Zoom focused on student mental health, and they got to describe the work they've done in their nonprofit called Fish Hut and how it works to promote mental health of young people through fishing. On December 7th, the Scarsdale Roborators had an undefeated qualifying

019competition in which they were also recognized with two awards, the Willing Alliance Team, first place in competition, and third place Inspire, which is a distinguished award for their exemplary role on and off the field. I guess it's for robotics, a field, playing field. So congratulations to the 30 students and advisors, Mr. McDonald and Mr. Anton for that. And then almost simultaneously to that, one of our seniors, Jessica Katz, was presenting her own authentic science research at the American Speech and Language Hearing Association Convention in Seattle. She's been studying speech apraxia as part of the science research program and was a very, very rare high school presenter at a national professional conference like that. So congratulations to them. On to our fall performance season, which has been a tremendous success. It started with the incredibly successful

020performance of Chicago. I know Jim will say a few words about that, but got to attend that. And we're grateful to Iona Prep for allowing our students to perform there. In addition to the incredible performance, the students and adults working on the show. really showed incredible flexibility and resilience to take on this work on the road outside of Scarsdale High School and be ready to perform in another space. So congratulations to the cast, crew, and entire team for their performances. As our calendar turned to December, our middle school and high school ensembles showed off their hard work with our Cooper and Popham 7th and 8th grade choral groups, 7th and 8th grade band, and jazz bands all performing along with our high school orchestra and chamber ensembles. The performances continued last week with our 6th

021grade band and chamber winds ensembles, our high school band, 7th grade orchestra, and Butler and Fountain 7 chorus and vocal music ensembles. as we speak our eighth grade orchestra and Butler Fountain 8 chorus and Sinfonietta ensembles are performing unfortunately a conflict with our board meeting and then the performances wrap up tomorrow night with our sixth grade orchestra Cooper and Popham and Butler Fountain sixth grade chorus ensembles and our high school choir so thank you to all our performers and their teachers for bringing joyful music to our schools and a special thanks to our middle school custodial team teachers and administrators and staff for accommodating a lot more performances this year as our auditorium is under renovation we're grateful to them okay a few important dates to note for those who celebrate Las Posadas is December

02216th start so starting today through 24th our schools will be closed starting next monday the 23rd and we reopen january 6th christmas is celebrated december 25th hanukkah december 25th through january 2nd and of course new year's day january 1st so like susie as 2024 comes to a close i also want to express my gratitude to our parents our family members our community members and our staff who all give their time and share their knowledge skills their customs their traditions with and for our students benefit Scarsdale is an engaged caring community invest invested in enriching the lives and the educational experiences of our youth on behalf of our school family we wish our students and their families and you and yours a restful break a joyous holiday season and a peaceful start to 2025 Thank you,

023Drew. What a wonderful superintendent update. So much going on in our schools right now, really a highlight. I'd like to also add my congratulations to Sharon. Sharon, in case you're listening, congratulations and best wishes on your retirement. I hope it's a relaxing and joyous one. Okay, next item, let's see. We're gonna do cabinet updates. Oh no, sorry, we're gonna do board updates. Would anybody like to go first? Okay, Jim jump in really quickly on the Chicago performance So it was a really wonderful performance of Chicago put on by the Scars Dell High School Drama Club. And I was lucky enough to catch two of the three performances over at Iona Prep's auditorium. And it was really a great show. I think the entire team did really a wonderful job. I want to thank Kevin Viviano,

024Barbara Malecki, David Graybill, and Michael Kumarasan, who were the principal production team supervising everything. And they really did. quite a good job with that. And just a lot of kids at the high school, both in terms of performance and in terms of behind the scenes work, technical work, scene building, everything was done at a very high level. And so I think it was a performance that our drama club could be very proud of. I know it was highly enjoyed by everyone in the community who saw it. So kudos to them. It really was a wonderful. wonderful time and performance and I could speak firsthand the amount of time that the cast members put in to rehearsing many weeks, many hours, and it really was worth it I think. So it was a great performance. Any

025other reports? Thank you, Leah. Thank you, Susan. On Wednesday, November 20th, Susie and I attended a NSBA webinar on school budgeting and long-term financial planning in an era of uncertainty. The webinar was led by Michael Vespi, member of Board of Directors of the Association of School Business Officials, and Jamie McPherson, the Deputy Director of Leadership Development for NSBA. It covered topics such as school budgeting and major revenue sources, the events leading to the full funding of foundation aid, complexities of the tax cap including inflation factors, state aid funding in place of expiring COVID funds, the difference between budgeting and long-term financial planning with extensive discussion on the importance of long-term planning. fund balances and reserves a framework for making budget reductions and communication strategies to inform the community and voters and to help manage concerns

026and questions. Thank you. Thank you, Leah. Anybody else? Amber? Thanks, Susie. I guess you were really busy on November 20th because also on November 20th Susie Hahn and I had the opportunity to attend the PTC's presentation, Phone Smart. Dr. Patrick introduced a discussion on the impact of smartphones and social media on students' learning and well-being. He emphasized the need for partnership between teachers, students, and parents to manage smartphone use effectively. Panelists, including teachers and students, shared insights, with many advocating for a stricter bell-to-bell, phone-free policy, citing benefits such as improved focus, reduced anxiety, and better social connections. Governor Hochul has suggested that she will introduce a bell-to-bell policy in her upcoming budget, and we look forward to learning more about her plans. Thank you to the PTC for hosting this informative presentation. Thank you, Amber.

027Anyone else? No? Okay, I'll turn it back to Drew. So we have a handful of cabinet updates tonight. We'll start with Eric, Safety, Security, and Emergency Management. Just wanted to report out that our DIRT team met last week or the week before. I can't actually remember. to really discuss our updated bus protocols around the new radio system that's been installed in our buses. We did tabletop drills using those new protocols that mirrored some of the things we've experienced in the past and some of the things that other districts have experienced with buses. We've also discussed the correlating of our bus routes to Scarsdale Police Department's zoning of their of the town so they have their own specific zones that they carved the town up into for their responses and we have now made sure our

028bus routes we know exactly which bus routes are in what section that they communicate with so they can easily tell us if there are issues in particular sections of Scarsdale that will allow us to better coordinate our bus our buses when they're rolling or bring them out of an area so that was quite successful also I wanted to report and it's timely given the headlines today that SPD will be at our high school over February break doing tactical training mostly in the new wing we will be coordinating communication to the community because there will be this will be a full tactical drill while no kids are in the building they'll have responding vehicles and they'll be using all of their their gear and tactical response gear for that later in the year probably the second

029weekend of March although it is not fully set yet. SFAC and SPD want to do a joint response using Green Acres School that includes volunteer victims and the transporting of victims to local hospitals so again when that's scheduled we will make sure the community is aware that those things are happening both through press releases from the village and communication out through parent square for us so that no one is alarmed at those at those situations. Unfortunately in this day and age it is a requirement, not a requirement, it's a duty that we have to make sure we're prepared for situations in which that type of response would need to happen. And SPD is very serious about making sure they are trained and ready to respond in a worst case scenario. So those things will be

030happening as we go through the year. Thanks Eric, appreciate that. Megan? I just want to share and congratulate a few retirees, one being Sharon. I'll extend my congratulations to Sharon Hill. The only thing I would add is just that Sharon is someone who, you know, everyone who knows Sharon knows she cares about people and is someone who will listen to learn and not necessarily always to respond. And her sense of calm brings calm to those around her. And the care she shares for students really is a model for all of us and I know will continue long after she leaves us. then congratulations to Gerson Katimatema our transportation supervisor who will be retiring on January 10th I think that's actually the first time I've ever said Gerson's last name because in practice he's like many

031celebrities he's known as Gerson just by his first name Gerson has served the district for over 39 years with grace and patience which you really need to have in that role and I've known Gerson as both a teacher who planned field trips and busing that went along with it as a principal who worked with gerson figuring out covid protocols and now in my current role and no matter the position people hold gerson always treats them with the highest level of respect and care and always with his smile and he'll be deeply missed by us all and i'll turn things over to andrew just to share a few more remarks Yeah, I'm very grateful for the time that Gers has spent with me personally here in the Transportation Department. After 39 years of service, I think

032he's entitled to a very restful and pleasant retirement, although I think he's got some great plans ahead of him. I won't go into too much detail, but in 1985, Gerson joined the district after completing a biology degree at Mercy College. And clearly he felt that sitting at a lab table looking through a microscope was way too boring for him, and he chose to be part of student transportation here as a bus driver when we had just about four or five district-owned vehicles at the time. Since then, Gerson drove buses through the 80s and 90s, and he also accompanied many of our athletic teams to state and local. competitions where he really became a Raider rooter. He really talked to me about the times he spent following our athletic teams closely and really cheering them on

033as if they were his own students. So we appreciate his connection to our kids that way. He was promoted in 2004 to head bus driver. Where he really took his leadership skills to a new level new level in the transportation office before then being promoted again in 2014 to the role of supervisor of transportation Throughout his time Gerson has really been a patient kind understanding individual who seriously concern and care about the well-being of our students while also dutifully following through the rules, procedures, and policies that we've set and that the state has set for his role as a transportation supervisor. So it is not often that you have to say no to people in a very kind way even though you care deeply about the request that they have, but he's done it gracefully

034and I appreciate that very much. As my predecessor, Mr. Stewart Maddy said about Gerson. Gerson is just a good, good man. So with great thanks, I congratulate Gerson on his retirement after 39 years with the Scarstow Schools. Thank you, Andrew and Megan. That was really, really nice. I will miss Gerson tremendously. Edgar, a few curriculum updates. Yes, thank you. So I have two updates from the curriculum realm. First, I want to share the topics of upcoming education reports. Our next one will be centered on elementary math in which we'll describe how our educators are taking the research-based resources, progressions, and structures of Reveal Math and applying them in our classrooms to enhance student learning. We'll discuss the adaptations and enrichments of materials, evolution of our practices, and importantly, how we are measuring student improvement, especially

035in the area of mathematical practice. I will be relying on our coordinators, teachers, and student voices, most likely videos of our students because we want to be mindful of their bedtimes. Sometimes we go later than that. And that's it for March 24th. Next we'll be focusing on the living area of the strategic plan, specifically on well-being. We'll be giving updates on responsive classroom, engagement of social workers, the middle school keystone structure, community council, and high school wellness campus initiatives. Also, I'll collaborate with colleagues to highlight some innovative student-centered high school courses in which learning goes deep, involves meaningful inquiry, and they have wide access to students. Also, Ray Pappalardi, Director of Physical Education and Health, and I will host a webinar for parents and guardians who have children in grades K through 5 to describe

036changes to the elementary health program. The webinar is scheduled for 6.30 p.m. on Tuesday, January 7th, and will cover three areas. Ray will describe the current health program status, an overview of the K-5 health curriculum. He will also discuss the integration of Aaron's Law into the curriculum. Aaron's Law directs school-based body safety lessons designed to prevent sexual abuse. These lessons are currently focused on fourth grade and Ray will discuss the updates for the coming year. Then I will discuss fifth grade puberty education. I'll review last year's changes including the introduction of mixed gender groups, gender identity content, and new learning formats. I'll discuss this year's revisions based on student questions and educator feedback which have helped us improve our focus and delivery. The webinar audience members can submit questions during the presentation, which we'll address

037at the end. For those who prefer an in-person experience, we'll have an elementary health coffee held at the district office the next morning on Wednesday, January 8th at 9 a.m. This will give interested parents an opportunity to review the curriculum materials closely and ask Ray or me any follow-up questions. A link to the digital sign up will be sent the week preceding the presentation for Scarsdale parents and guardians to sign up for the webinar and in person coffee. Thank you Edgar and back to Andrew. So the traditional auditorium update. So we remain about a month behind schedule in the auditorium as we kind of discussed last time. The long lead items of those acoustical panels are on their way as are the seats for the auditorium. drywall is up, some paint is being applied to

038the ceiling and the walls at the upper level. However, the scaffolding is still in place because there's some high-level work, namely some steel work that needs to get completed before we can take that down. So we anticipate sometime over the next week, week and a half, that scaffolding will start to come down and work will move to the ground level where we really will see the auditorium coming together. So talking to high school last week, the high school administration is eagerly waiting and prepared for... breaking in the new space in March and April, which we think we still are on track for. So we're excited about that, to see students performing in that new space. Also, in terms of facilities, the middle school gym, unfortunately, and the Veterans Day weekend experienced a pipe break in

039a bathroom that we thought was contained to solid surfaces, concrete and tile. Unfortunately, it appeared that water seeped its way in through a door threshold into Gym A, and rather quickly that week made its way through the entire gym floor and required us to... file an insurance claim and have that gym floor replaced. The contractors were hired through our insurance provider, NICER, so it's all going to be covered by insurance, save a small deductible. The floor was removed. The concrete was dried, resealed, and the wood flooring is actually on site as of today. It'll have to acclimatize for a few days, but we will be installing that over the next week or week and a half. And then the process for sanding, lining. and sealing will happen mostly over the break and then hopefully that

040will be dried and ready for use mid-January so we can turn that back over not only to our PE program, our athletic program, but also the community users, which we know this is disrupted. So we apologize for the inconvenience that was quite clearly beyond our control as the pipe burst right down a seam. So it was certainly nothing we could control. It was just a faulty piece of pipe that unfortunately was there for quite some time. So we appreciate everyone for being patient with us and accommodating our changes to that space's use. Thank you. Any questions from board members on any of those updates? Okay, thank you. Thank you so much. I just have a quick question. Just depending on timing for the ceiling, anyone that's redone floors can know certain sealers can off-gas a

041lot. I just want to make sure we'll have some, if students are back when that's still happening, we'll have some way to monitor the air quality. They'll have some negative ventilation in there to pull that out through the exterior doorways there, and they will be using as low VOC ceiling as possible. Just to clarify a little further related to the auditorium so March or April so will it you foresee it being open for the kind of spring season with the plays and concerts the students can rehearse and things like that? I won't steal any of the thunder from the high school right but I think that the the concert schedules and the student Talent show and those types of things that happen in the spring. We are we are anticipating will take place in there

042as planned Thank you next on the agenda item 5.01 Hearing from those present. I will read the public comment preamble Members of the public are cordially invited to speak on district related items or other non personnel related matters during two separate public comment periods When it is your turn to speak Please state your name, address, and if you are speaking on behalf of an organization. For those commenting remotely, please mute the live stream voice, turn on your camera, and then unmute yourself. This might be a good time to do that now. Speakers will be asked to conclude their remarks after four minutes and will be given a verbal cue at the three minute mark. If at this point a speaker has additional comments, they may send them in writing to the board via email at

043boardofed at scarsdaleschools.org. The public comment period is reserved for comments only. The board will not engage in dialogue. The board reserves the right to respond to comments and questions at its discretion, either during response to public comment or at a later time and place. Response to public comment will take place after the first and second public comment periods. And with that, I'd like to ask if anybody would like to make a public comment from the audience? Okay. Next, we'll check on Zoom. Jim? There are currently no attendees on Zoom. I guess we'll give it a couple. Anybody join? Still no attendees on see. Okay. Thank you, Jim. So with that we will close the first public comment period and Item six follow up to public comment Obviously there will be none and we're gonna go

044right to agenda item seven written communications Thank You Susie, please note that the Board of Education email is also viewed by the superintendent and district clerk open meetings law Requires all board deliberations which may lead to action or policy changes to occur in public Therefore your written communications and emails will be reported at an upcoming public board meeting a board member will respond at their earliest convenience a Formal response requires that you include your full name in the communication More detailed information regarding written communications received by the Board of Education may be found in today's meeting agenda located in board Doc's on the Scarsdale school districts website with respect to the written communications that have been received since our last meeting. There have been 15 communications received and responded to regarding district matters and I

045believe seven received and responded to regarding board matters, board meetings, highlights and invitations. Thank you so much, Jim. Next will be item eight. the consent agenda and I will now read the preamble. The board may conduct some of its business using a consent agenda in an effort to achieve greater efficiency at board meetings. A consent agenda condenses some of the routine business of the Board of Education into a single motion. The consent agenda is prepared by the superintendent of schools in consultation with the president and or the vice president of the board. Items are selected for the consent agenda when the officers of the board and the superintendent believe there is no controversy regarding them. The items on the consent agenda will have the same background material as ordinary items on the board agenda. If

046any member of the board feels that any item on the consent agenda requires discussion prior to action, that board member may remove that item from the consent agenda merely by requesting same at the meeting. The exempted item then moves to the regular agenda. However, all non-exempted items would be moved, seconded, and voted upon without discussion in order to provide greater efficiency to conducting the routine items of business of the school district. And with that, I'd like to ask the board if anybody would like to remove any item from the consent agenda. Okay, well then we'll move to the consent agenda, and I believe this is Bob. Yes, so tonight we have 10 items on the agenda. On 9.01 minutes, business meeting November 18, 2024. Item 9.02 minutes, special meeting, executive session December 9, 2024. 9.03

047minutes, special meeting, executive session December 11, 2024, pending. 9.04, personnel certified. 9.05 personnel non-certified 9.06 claims audit report november 2024 9.07 district emergency response safety plan 9.08 memorandum of agreement association of scarisdale teacher aides and assistants 9.09 budget amendment 9.10 i would like to recommend that we accept the consent agenda. Thank you Bob. Is there a second? Thank you Leah. All those in favor please say aye. Aye. All those opposed or would like to abstain? Is that me? I don't... We did the ayes thing. Okay so the ayes have it and the motion passes. Thank you. Next would be item 10, information items and discussion. The first one being the treasurer's report and schedule investments. Thank you, Lisa. Good evening. The Treasurer's Report being reported tonight is the month of September of 2024. Some items

048to note, your tax receipts, a little less than $1.6 million was received in September. Tax bills are issued September 1st with a due date for the first half of the payment of September 30th. Therefore, that September remittance is a little on the low side. The majority comes in at the end of the month near the due date and is remitted to us in the following month. So you'll see a much larger tax receipt in October. State and federal aid is comprised of $46,000 in excess cost aid, $94,000 in lottery aid, and $17,000 in grant funds. Interest continues to rain high. About 70% is earning 5.23 to 5.24. under disbursements your payrolls we pay semi-monthly meaning we pay the 15th and the 30th of the month so you'll note payroll number five the September 13th payroll

049is the first ten month payroll ten month staff salaried payroll I'm in addition to the 12-month hourly employees are paid on a delay due to timesheet and time clock processing so therefore the 930 payroll the payroll number six is a little larger because that includes not only your 12 month but also your 10 month and all hourly employees as of 9 30 the district had general fund revenues of 5.2 million and expenditures of 27.2 million any questions thank you so much okay appreciate it um okay great uh item 10.02 or budget transfers So as we've discussed, not only did we transition to new software, but we've also recoded all of our expenditure codes to align with the New York State Uniform System of Accounts. For state reporting purposes, we're required to break out costs by

050building level and grade level. So for example, our elementary buildings include grades K through five, but for state reporting purposes, we need to break that down even more and break out K to three and four to six. So obviously sixth grade is included in your middle school, so we have to break those costs out. In our previous system, a lot of that breakout was done manually outside of the software. So what we're trying to do is to incorporate that into our coding system so all of that data is readily available. So we spent a lot of time going through all of our staffing to make sure that they are appropriately allocated to the correct buildings, to the correct grade levels, and also again, breaking out those expenses between the state requirements. So that has resulted

051in some movement of staff between codes, which also needs a corresponding budget transfer. So as you'll note, this transfer is all salaries to salaries, so it's just moving salary budgets to other salary codes. There's no additional salary budgets in there. I just have a quick question. So for example, when you see the transfer from teachers to special education teachers, it's just related to the shifting around the codes or is there anything else with it? It could be a teacher that was either incorrectly coded as a regular ed teacher versus special ed. It could be movement between the two. A lot of times we'll see that with aides. They fluctuate between. Some of it is the placement, breaking out again, moving. A third grade teacher may have been in fourth grade and has to be moved

052to a different code. Thank you. Thank you. Next on the agenda, item 10.03, fund balance and reserve plan. So during the November 4th board meeting where I presented the long draft long-range financial plan Sorry tongue twister I made reference to a fund balance and reserve plan document that I'd shared with the board earlier that evening that we would talk about in the future so this evening we've Made some time for the board to have the opportunity to discuss that document which is also linked in the agenda Ask me any questions or provide some feedback to dr Patrick or me about how we might want to see revisions to future versions of this document Before I do that, I thought it would be helpful to just provide a little bit of context. So Board of Education

053Policy 6250 actually talks about fund balances and reserves. And it states in there that the board should annually review the district fund balances and reserves and consider the required levels for prudent financial management among other things. So this is typically done in our budget making process, right? We have a slide that we're all familiar with that we've talked about in our budget making process. We also have our external auditors report each year to the board, and in that report we make reference to the fund balances and their intended purposes. This year we introduced the long range financial plan, which is a third down place where the board has that opportunity. However, in those discussions sometimes there's a a lack of nuance or history or information that may be helpful for the board as they try

054to make determinations about what the appropriate funding level is or how we should use those reserves going forward. So this fund balance and reserve document is really meant to be a tool to help with that by providing some history and context of the reserves that we have implemented, those which may be implemented in the future should the board choose to do so. And just... Basically a reference point for the reserve balances going forward into the future I will be updating this document annually and sharing with the board through the the budget making process as well as at the end of the fiscal year when our audit financial statements are completed, but I Welcome any feedback and questions from the board. Thank you Andrew for this document. It's very helpful My question, so it's just related

055to kind of the future considerations, which I know is jumping ahead a little bit, but insurance reserve and capital reserve, are those both reserves you would suggest we potentially have? So potentially. So capital reserves are something that is a tool for funding capital work. It is... One of several tools that the board has been discussing, such as bonds and capital appropriations, it's something that I just wanted to put on the table as something that the board could consider as we enter a larger bond conversation. Should something not make the list of a bond project, this is something we could say is important to us. When the funds become available, we would establish it. It's there just for the board's consideration. So the other piece would be insurance reserve and as you know we have a

056health insurance reserve which under the same legislation that would authorize this. This would allow us to look at things. I know there was a question from Colleen a few months ago about another school district that has stopped paying for flood insurance and has self-funded that insurance plan. This is the mechanism where we might consider doing that, right? So for things. such as a deductible, we might want to raise our insurance deductible so that we have lower insurance fees. We would use a reserve like this to pay for it. Or if we just wanted to outright stop an insurance product that we purchased today and use this reserve, that would be an option for us. I want to be clear about my intention of including that. We have several reserves that have room for additional funding

057that I think. probably more important than that at this time but it's something to consider in the future. Anybody else? First thank you for putting this together it's really helpful I think reserves are an important part of our budget process and there's a lot of different ones I think it's great for the board I think it's also great for the community so people can understand how we save money in different accounts for what reasons I have a couple suggestions that I think would be I would find helpful as a board member I think I really appreciate the way in under funding level you've given an explanation not just a number. I think having the number in addition to that explanation would be very helpful. So when it says guidance should be X percent of some

058number, I would find a chart helpful that says okay for this current budget year, what is that guidance number? What is our current fund balance? and what is the delta are we at, above, or below. To me, that would be the main priority of adding that. I do think there would be value. I know going forward, it would be easy to keep that. I do think there would be value with a look back, looking back three to five years and putting that in. It would be easier going forward because we'll just keep adding it. But I think there would be value in having that history because... depending on our fund balance bucket it can move for various reasons sometimes it's a mechanism to smooth things out sometimes it's a mechanism because we have a big

059hit in one area so one year could look very different than a three to five year average so I think that would be valuable I I also think in general be valuable, but especially since we're going to the bond market, well, we may be going to the bond market, putting in what the rating agencies put, I understand they look at a lot. And we are very fortunate to be in a community that can support our budget through tax dollars, which is, I think, well received by the bond market. But I think they do have parameters they look for in fund balance overall. Whether we meet them, exceed them or not, that's a discussion. But I think that context for the board will be helpful always, but especially in the next couple years. And then my

060last... suggestion, not exactly sure how to effectuate this, but I'll just put this out there, would be the numbers we're using for guidance are all very, or that, Andrew, that you've put in the document, are all very rational. They come from entities that look at this. But that is an entity or a person creating that, and they could be wrong. Or they could be, it may not work for our unique circumstances, right? The big one would be our health insurance. We are self-insured. I think what you've chosen as the guidance makes a lot of sense, but it is not exactly for one district because we are pretty unique in that. being a one district self-insured. So I think there would be some value in a methodology to test the guidance that we have in each

061of these versus our actual lived experience. So for example, we could look and say, if we had just followed this guidance, what would have happened over some lived experience? Would it have been enough? Are we overfunded? Remember, we also don't want to hold our taxpayers' money, their money. So we want to find the right balance there. I think that last one, again, I'm still wrapping my head around how that looks. So I never like to give a suggestion that I don't understand how to exactly do yet, but I wanted to put it out there for food for thought. And again, thank you for putting this together. I think it's a very valuable talk. Thank you for that. I appreciate it. I think historical values are a piece that I definitely am missing in here that

062I think would be helpful to see the trend. I think that also goes towards what my experience has been with the rating agencies as I've been in districts that are going out to borrow. I think... Having a plan also strengthens that rating agency view of our work because if we have a plan and we're trying to follow that plan, I think that that's as important as simply just looking at the numbers. So I think moving in the right direction, I think your feedback is very helpful and I appreciate that. Some of the reserves are so unique that I think We we could update them annually to say this is what this recommendation would be based on this year's circumstances And we can find a way to fit filter that in as well. Yes, Amber Thanks,

063Susie. Thanks Andrew for this document. I'm hoping you can explain to me a little bit So the TRS reserve sub fund so right now if we need to fund we need excess contributions for TRS we get that out of the reserve for retirement contributions is that right and you're proposing adding a sub fund to there so this board or a previous board had actually authorized a TRS sub reserve and that Going back a little bit, for the longest time, there was opposition to allowing districts to create a TRS reserve. There was political opposition. It was successful through legislation as a sub-fund of an existing retirement reserve. So that's the history of the legislation. This district created the sub-fund but never funded it. So right now, that sub-fund is $0. and we have money as many

064other municipalities and school districts do in a retirement reserve for our ERS eligible employees, our clerical, custodial, and bus drivers. Right now, any increase to TRS on a budget-to-budget basis really is just a burden on the budget. We have no reserve that we can use other than our undesignated fund balance to help soften that. If we were to have the funds available to institute a TRS, to fund the TRS sub fund, that would help us in years where the TRS rate does spike. And right now, we just don't have that flexibility. Okay, great. Thank you. That's what I was trying to understand. Appreciate that. Thank you so much, Andrew. This is a great document, very helpful for board members to understand our fund balances and reserves. As Ron mentioned, it's a... very important part of

065our budget thank you I'll make the adjustments and I'll make this a review draft yes put the data I just want to thank Andrew too he and Lisa have taken on a lot of process and information projects not to mention Envision and the whole office really has just done tremendous amount to kind of bring us you know in a place where we can ask and answer questions more easily I think to me that's that's the biggest takeaway and just appreciate your running fast sometimes I want to slow them down a little bit just for sustainability but I really just want to thank you publicly and Lisa as well Thank you both Item 10.04 the Education Report Thank you, Susie. First, I'd like to invite Dr. Amy Chemelia. She's going to be helping me with the...

066Can I share a few words, too, just to get started? No, that's fine. I just want to just share with the board and the community. Tonight's education report is focused, obviously, on special education programming. and as a key priority of our strategic plan, we are committed to the belief that the students who reside in our community, to the extent possible, should have the programs and support necessary to be successful in our schools. So that's the context for this particular report. The Board of Ed and community have generously supported the growth and expansion of our special education programming to meet those... aforementioned educational needs of our students. We purposefully scheduled this presentation for tonight's meeting. before our first budget presentation, which will be in January, so we can provide the context for decisions that we will

067encounter and grapple with together during that process. So before I turn it over, I wanted to give that context and also to express my gratitude to Eric and to Amy for their leadership in this arena, along with their team members, including Dina, Christina, Dana, Nicole, and our new team member, Alex. Indeed, all of the special educators, related service providers, and general education co-teachers who played a critical role in bringing these programs to life for our students and their families. So, thank you and turn it over to you. Thank you, Drew. There we go. First and foremost, thank you for the opportunity to talk about special education tonight. Special education has a vibrant faculty and a set of successful programs that I'm always happy to talk about. Amy and I are thrilled to dive into the

068work. and talk about the vision for the future. The strategic plan is really the starting point for all of the information you're about to be presented with. Our strategic plan outlines not only the systemic focuses for the district, but it illustrates a vision for all of our students. The presentation will very directly connect to the three major priorities in our plan. While these special education goals live in the learning bucket, Embedded in those priorities is the drive to bring the goals we have for all students in living and in leading to special education students. Tonight's presentation will have four main sections. A brief overview of special education, including its purpose and the overarching mandates of federal and state law. A review of the current student profile and historical trends. We will also, to the extent

069possible, look at what we see happening in the next few years. We will review how the district assesses our programs, both on an individual student level and on a programmatic level. And finally, we'll talk about the programmatic and professional development priorities in the coming year. Before we dive into specifics, I think it's important to reiterate that the goals for special education students are the same goals we have for all students, to give them the tools to live independent, purposeful lives with as many choices as their desires and talents allow. Special education is simply the mechanism for students who need specialized methods and tools to get there. Those methods and tools address four main things, access, self-understanding, self-advocacy, and planning for the future. All of the programs and services you'll hear us reference tonight are in

070service to one of those four areas. When you look at Scarsdale's philosophy of special education, it's a natural extension of our values around belonging. Celebrating diversity includes many aspects, including students with disabilities. Inclusionary practices are at the center of our focus in special education programming, both for its academic potential and because it's a manifestation of our charge to embrace all learners. All students learn better in an environment that exposes them to a diversity of thinking and abilities. However, our purpose and philosophy lives within a framework of mandates dictated by federal and state law. New York State Section 200 regulations and the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act, our first acronym for today, IDEA, are laws that govern special education. They dictate the types of programs, student-teacher ratio, and the structure on how decisions are made for

071students with disabilities. It's easy to critique these mandates, but they do provide a safety net around our most vulnerable students and assure all students with disabilities get a base of service. With that being said, the frameworks it creates are prescribed without concern for context or local situations. In the next few slides, we'll focus on what we are charged to do at the systemic level in order to provide context around the data and programmatic priorities you're about to see. As we think about special education, it's helpful to start at the end, what students are working towards and what is required for graduation in New York State. Everything I'm about to explain must be caveated, as we know New York State is in the process of overhauling their graduation requirements. That's including retiring the Regents exam. This

072change is to adjust education towards the skills needed for tomorrow's world. On its face, it seems to move New York State's view of education more in line with our own strategic plan, including their own portrait of a graduate, but the details are yet to be seen. We do know that the current fourth grade cohort will be the first cohort to graduate without a region's exam requirement. With that caveat in mind, for all of our students in fifth grade and beyond, New York State has two educational tracks. The first is a regular assessment track that leads to a region's or local diploma. This includes requirements to pass five region's exams, earn 22 credits, and fulfill a number of sequences in major subjects. There are no adjustments to the requirements for special education students. and these regular

073assessment requirements impact the way we prepare students for graduation and shape the programs and accommodations that schools recommend. The second track, which less than 1% of our population qualifies for, is the alternate assessment track. This track is for students with disabilities that make achieving the regular assessment requirements impossible. Students on an alternate assessment track focus on basic foundational academics, life, work, and independent living skills, and focus on achieving the largest level of self-determination possible. Students on alternate assessment also receive extensive transition planning for adulthood and are often eligible for state services after graduation. In service of these two assessment tracks, the IDEA and PAR 200 outline the rights a student with disabilities are afforded in public schools. If we boil down the federal and state regulations, the requirement that all students with a disability receive

074a free and appropriate education would be at the center. We refer to this as FAPE. If there is a disagreement or litigation in special education, the outcome always revolves around whether or not a student was provided FAPE according to the structures set out in law and regulation. This begs the question, What constitutes an appropriate education in light of a student with special needs? There are reams of legal briefs that outline the answer to this question, but it revolves around two things. Addressing individual student needs so as to allow them to access the general education curriculum and offering a continuum of educational programs to meet those needs. Amy? In order to understand how to support students, it really is all about understanding how we bring together the art and science of teaching while meeting the diverse

075needs of learners in our classrooms. In order to do that, it's critical that we examine the pedagogy we're using while continuing to develop an understanding of our students' needs and how we are creating balanced programming. Effective pedagogy is based on continuous and meaningful professional development that help to develop targeted programs for learners that require additional support. It also aligns with utilizing universal design to develop robust and flexible classrooms to meet the variety of learners in our rooms and feedback loops that include teacher input, feedback, and support to reflect and make adjustments as needed. So how does our pedagogy currently support students? Some examples, not an exhaustive list, that we currently use include ICT at both the elementary and middle school levels, supplementary math programming, Wilson reading, and the Scarsdale support programs, which are based out

076of the Scarsdale Middle School and Scarsdale High School, respectively. To best support all learners, not just students with educational disabilities, it's critical to understand the needs of the stakeholders. For our students, we need to understand their academic, social, emotional, and overall physical or health needs, and when possible, learn of the needs from the students themselves. Oftentimes, we hear exactly what we need from the students themselves. From our families, teams need to understand their hopes, dreams, and even fears for their child. Parents bring their own knowledge of their child and their own thoughts and perceived challenges around what education and even what post-secondary may look like. It is important to understand a parent's perspective. In terms of the community, we need to understand the norms around behavior, acceptance of inclusive practices, and what are the social

077skills needed to help students gain inclusion among peers. All of this pedagogy and the understanding helps to create this balance that we try to foster when working with our students. There is an intentional discussion around how and when to support the needs of a particular student while moving them towards more inter independence and less intervention Some examples of that include where are there the opportunities for students to participate inclusion versus the need for more direct instruction that might look for a student a conversation around do they need integrated co-teaching or might they benefit from intensive supports in a special education classroom a self-contained classroom the discussion also frequently happens on the other end where we're talking about lessening the intervention when we're talking about less support than they currently are provided students can be provided

078or recommended for declassification which means at the time that they no longer warrant the direct support provided by a special education teacher all of these conversations and more happen frequently throughout the year to make sure that students are provided support in a way that best meets their needs In addition to individual student needs, IDEA and Part 200 outline a continuum of services that a student must have access to if needed. It also focuses on the idea of having students learn in the least restrictive environment that's educationally appropriate. While not a legal requirement that a district have all the recognized program types as in-district option, Scarsdale has worked hard over the past 10 years to expand the options students have within our district schools to allow as many students as possible to be educated within their

079community. As you will see later in this presentation, that goal has largely been realized. Let's take a look at the current programs available in the district. On the elementary level, all of our buildings have learning resource centers which service students needing pre-referral services, consultant teacher services, or resource room services. We have our integrated co-teaching classes at four out of our five elementary schools, with K classes starting every year at two different buildings. Our most intensive special class programs, Bridge, which is a 12-1-1 program, and our intensive support program, which is an 8-1-2 program, are housed at the Edgewood School. These programs represent the breadth of special education continuum and have dramatically lessened our reliance on out-of-district placements at the elementary level, and they've allowed the vast majority of students to attend a district school. As

080you can see, there's a consistent enrollment in all of our ICT classes with a range of three to five sections of ICT at each grade level. Currently Quaker Ridge has the most sections but over the next two years all four schools housing ICT will have comparable numbers of ICT sections. This is being accomplished through adjusting where we start kindergarten not by moving students who are currently attending Quaker Ridge. Our special classes are all enrolled at a level that make an in-district program more cost-effective than an out-of-district placement but this is an area where we are beginning to look to take on students from other districts as a revenue stream. Currently, there is only one out of district student paying tuition at the district and that's in the high school. At our middle school, we have

081learning resource centers in all of our houses which offer consultant teacher and resource room services. On the sixth and seventh grade, the parallel program offers a mix of true ICT and science and social studies and special class options in math and English. The eighth grade parallel currently offers the same special classes with push-in services for science and social studies. The Bridge Program is present at SMS, as is our Scarsdale Support Program, or the SSP. The SSP, which is a combination of resource room and counseling, serves as a specialized program for students with social and emotional disabilities. At our high school, we also have consultant teacher and resource room served through the LRC and the Scarsdale Support Program, which is similar to the middle school. We do not have ICT options currently at the high school,

082but our skills level classes serve students, although in a general education setting, who have academic challenges and need a smaller, more structured class. We are currently building the continuum at the secondary level. SMS has introduced pedagogic ICT in sixth and seventh grade, and it will be moving up to eighth grade next year. There is also a plan to expand ICT service to English 6 and Math 6 this coming year. Further, there are students in our 8-1-2 class who will age into the middle school for the 25-26 school year and expand our continuum. At SHS, we have the narrowest continuum, mainly due to the lack of ICT offerings. Our skills program does serve as a more supportive class for students in need of more academic support. And as you will see in our plans for the

083future, this is an area which we are proposing expanding continuum. We'll spend more time talking about the next steps regarding continuum later in the presentation. Before that, we're going to take a look at the trends we are seeing in special education and how they've shaped the needs in our district. The next slides look at the current special education numbers and a 10-year history. As we go through these slides, I hope to illustrate the increased needs in special education has experienced in both terms of numbers and expanding profiles of students that we serve. I will also try to analyze the trends where they may go and where they may go as best as possible. As you will see in the next two slides, Scarsdale is experiencing what many other places around the county, state, and country

084are. increasing numbers in special education without necessarily experiencing overall population expansion. So currently, we have 627 special education students and 82 preschoolers with an IEP. As we have presented in the past, the classification rate has risen significantly since the 18-19 school year. Additionally, preschool has also risen post-COVID, but has remained steady for about three years, although at the post-COVID level. Scarsdale's classification rates have always trailed state and local averages. Currently the county has an average classification rate of 17% and the state is at 19. The gap between Scarsdale and the county and state has narrowed, but adjustments and improvements in our MTSS practices in 2015 and 16 were a cause and actually moved our numbers to a more appropriate level. That adjustment was magnified post-COVID, not just in Scarsdale, but in the county and state,

085as well as the nation. Classification rates have risen significantly across all measures. To give context, a 1% rise in classification rate represents approximately 47 students. Since 2018 and 19, Scarsdale has seen an increase of 267 students who are classified, and this represents slightly over a 50% rise in students with IEPs. In thinking about future growth or decline, initial referrals are a leading indicator of special education classification rates, and our school-age referrals have seen a declining trend recently. However, they're still hovering slightly above the break-even point for the classification rate. Year-to-date were similar to last year, which would indicate that this year will be similar to last year in referrals overall. Preschool referrals have remained high post-COVID, although since the rise in 2020, the actual numbers of preschoolers with a disability has been stable, indicating that

086more parents may be coming to CPSC for initial referral, but the number of students qualifying has remained relatively stable. In addition to overall classification rate, and I'm sorry, I know this is a hard chart to read on the screen, we've had a significant change in the makeup of our special education population. As we talk about classification types, it's important to keep in mind the classification is not the full picture of a student, and it simply represents the most fitting classification given the student's functioning. Many disabilities are co-morbid and students often don't fit neatly into any of the 13 categories. However, IDEA does require one classification be selected. Be that as it may, the chart illustrates a trend of change that is instructive for planning and programmatic sense. The most striking change is the enormous rise

087in students with other health impairments. OHI is a catch-all disability under IEDEA, and the rise is fueled in large parts by students experiencing anxiety, depression, and attention issues, and this is part of a nationwide trend. These three areas represent the majority of the rise in students classified overall. Additionally, and importantly, the number of students with autism has more than tripled in 10 years. Unlike specific learning disabilities, which used to be our largest group of classified students, OHI and autism both often require more globalized supports across a spectrum of curriculum. This need for globalized support is highlighted in the rise in our need for ICT settings. Elementary ICT has grown enormously since 2016. With that being said, the numbers are seemingly and hopefully stabilizing over the last three years. Along with meeting the needs of a

088rising and changing population, our focus over the past 10 years has been to develop programs to allow as many Scarsdale students to be educated within their home district. ICT, special classes, and the Scarsdale support programs have significantly increased the percentage of students with disabilities that could be educated within our own community. This data, when viewed in conjunction with the next chart, really outlined the realization of the goal to educate as many of our students in their community as possible. The percentage of students outplaced has fallen from almost 12% to 3.4%. The data here represents the students who are placed privately who qualify for an IEP. There are many reasons for private placement, but we monitor this number to understand whether our own program changes are driving the number of students who are educated elsewhere. The

089red line indicates those who are in private special education schools, and the blue indicates all students privately placed. The differential between the two are either students who attend non-special education private schools, that could be a Masters, a Horace Mann, a Hackley, and red-shirted kindergartners who technically fall into the category of parentally placed. As this shows, the percentage of students privately placed has come down as a percentage of the special education population as we have increased our programming. All of this data gives a picture of the current makeup of our special education population and the increase seen in overall population and the complexity of disability profiles present. Given this data, it's no surprise this has led to hiring to address the rise and expansion in program, recent hiring. Major increases in FTEs stem from the increase

090in students qualifying for an IEP. 17 of the FTEs are a direct result of additional students participating in elementary ICT programs. The position for LRC on the secondary level account for the increased population and the need for additional sections. The additional district psychologists, behaviorists, and the assistant director have stemmed from the overall increased needs presented by 267 additional special education students. The remaining additions for our SSP and special class program are largely serving populations that would have required out of district placements prior to the programs being available. This hiring equates to 30 FTEs since the 2014 school year. So in summing up the trends in our current situation, here are some key takeaways. There's a 267 student increase, most of which coming in the last six years. Emotional disabilities, especially anxiety, depression, and autism. autism

091not being an emotional disability, have become much more prominent in the profiles of our students. Staffing has increased by 30 in the last 10 years at an approximate yearly cost of about $3.4 million. Out-of-district placements have fallen significantly in the past 10 years, assuring the vast majority of students can be educated in their community and reducing our yearly tuition expenditures by approximately $2.2 million a year. So... That being a lot of information, I'm going to stop now for any questions kind of based on where we are from a trend standpoint before we move into assessment and our vision for the future. Are there any questions thus far? I have one question on slide 27, the parentally placed. Yep. So is the red line a subset of the blue line? Or in addition? No, it's a

092subset. So the total all students are included in the blue line. So this doesn't it? Sorry. I'm sorry. Yeah, all of the students that are parent or privately placed that qualify for an IEP are included in the blue line. The red line is simply the subset of those that are going to actual special education schools outside of the district. I see. And this is separate from a parent that places their kids in private school who does not have an IEP. Correct. Those are not included in this. This is just IEP, not 504s. That's correct as well. And that's of our special education population. So it's a percentage of the overall 669 students that are both parentally placed and in our district. I guess what I'm... Okay, this is helpful. I guess what I... can't discern

093from this slide is this is the percent, but the number of students classified has gone up? Correct. So it is possible that there are actually a few more absolute numbers that are privately placed, but as a percentage of our population, it's smaller. But is that what's happening? Yes. Okay. So my question would be what... But we have all these additional options in districts. So why is the actual number of students not going down too? I think because you have to expect some percentage of parents to look for alternate placements besides in-district or out-of-district placements. Some of the students that are privately placed are also students that would be recommended for an out-of-district placement, that they may be looking at private placements as more attractive than the state-approved placements. Also, there are a number of red-shirted

094special education kindergartners. That number has actually gone up. Redshirting has gone up as a trend generally, general and special education, and that's part of what's going on there. Okay, thank you. Okay, I'm going to move us on to assessment. The next section of the presentation will look at how we assess special education. We'll start with taking a look at the hiring of an assistant director and its impact. Secondly, we will look at the way we assess the individual student's success and whether the programs we have are successful on a systemic level. For this school year, we added Assistant Director of Special Education, she's sitting next to me, to alleviate the CSE chairperson caseload, the administrative bottleneck for decision making, and to allow for more focus on the alignment of program and pedagogy. The original staff

095request form and the reorganization document shared internally are included in the agenda item if anybody would like to see them. Prior to the expansion, our chairpeople led more than 150 meetings per year each, and the CPSE CSE chairperson led just over 300. These numbers diminished the capacity for our CSE chairpeople to address other needs, including parental responsiveness, observing students, meeting with teams, collaborating to create consistent practice, and providing professional development around CSE compliance. The additional position is provided that increased capacity. Just a couple of examples include there has been an instituting of staff-wide compliance PD led by our attorneys and chairpeople. Secondary staff on special ed has already experienced that. The elementary is forthcoming. There's a formal focus on goal setting around progress monitoring, programmatic cohesion for elementary LRC. And there's been additional CPI de-escalation

096training for teaching assistants and aides. Similarly to the CSE process, there was a capacity issue around programmatic supervision. The assistant superintendent was the only administrator which caused a bottleneck around programming and student-based decisions with budgetary or supervisory impacts. The additional administrative position and the lowering of the caseload has allowed for more programmatic focus and greater support for teachers and building administrators. Overall, There has been a less of a need to focus on compliance with regards to dates and timelines given the adjustment of caseload and more focus put on individual students through the CSE process. Additionally, there has been an increase in the ability to focus on PD and program development, not just expansion, along with additional administrative decision-making capability for timely decisions, all of which benefits student, teacher, and parent experience. As we move on

097to assessing special education's overall success, we must look at both the individual student and the overall programmatic achievement. Amy's going to spend a few minutes focusing on how we assess the success of a given student and work with families to understand that process. Then we're going to take a look at some assessment data for our special education cohort performer. Thank you. In terms of assessing individual student success, one of the key aspects of special education is determining and reviewing if a student requires additional support through special education to help them access the curriculum. We do this by identifying the needs of each student. So how do we identify and discuss needs, right? Committees meet yearly at meetings known as annual reviews in which a variety of information is reviewed to discuss growth and areas of

098continual need. Every three years, through meetings known as re-evaluations, updated comprehensive evaluations that measure cognitive and educational processes are completed. These evaluations highlight student growth in comparison to data from three years prior and this allows for the members of the team to have additional standardized data to measure a student's growth against themselves and same-aged peers. In terms of developing goals, the goals on IEPs are aligned to both student needs and curricular standards. These goals are developed to help students develop progress within the curriculum. In order to understand goal development, the next two slides will highlight or illustrate a writing goal progression from elementary to middle, then to high. Please note that these goals are exemplars and individual student goals may differ based on need. You can have writing goals for a variety of reasons, including

099for and not limited to difficulty with organization, writing, conventions, and spellings. And as we kind of go through this... IEPs and goals are developed explicitly for the child that they represent. So every IEP will look different based on the need of that individual student. For these goals, we broke it down by grades one, two, grade three, four, and grade five. If you notice in grades one, two, we're talking about writing a sentence using a prompt, right? So given a prompt by the educator, can that student develop kind of a sentence? Grades three, four, we're building up. our writing to five sentences and we're starting to move and think about going from the sentence to the paragraph level and then in grade five we're building to a multi-paragraph on a specific topic When we move to

100the middle school and the high school, these goals are going to be much more nuanced based on the needs of the student and the level of support needed to apply their knowledge. The overall goal is to increase independence, especially as we start to think about planning for post-secondary for that youngster. For the middle school goal, you know, please note that the goal is to add details and or evidence to support or expand their ideas. And for the exemplar goal for the high school, the shift is to develop topic sentences that support the thesis. This allows for a student, if they're writing a research paper or a five-paragraph essay, to continue to generalize their skills around that goal. It's wonderful to have goals but goals are only worth it if we know how if a student

101is making progress One of the ways we have special education teachers monitor progress is literally by doing something called progress monitoring, right? And teachers use a variety of ways to progress monitor and depending on the goal or goals it can vary Again, please note that this is not an exhaustive list of the ways that teachers monitor progress. Some teachers may engage in the use of portfolios where they collect work samples throughout the year to show growth of a student in a particular area. For example, if we use the writing example in which a student may need high scaffolding in September, but through the course of the year, maybe December. and February and June the teacher is able to show the release of their scaffolding and the independence of the student. Exams may be another way,

102not always, but another way to progress monitor when directly related to a goal. For example, if a student may have a goal around making meaning from a chart or a graph and that exam provides explicit examples on how that child is able to work through that, that might also serve as progress monitoring. Observations may be used, specifically if a student is working on an executive functioning goal, working on organization. We're going to set up a process to keep you organized for all your classes. Let's sit down. Can I observe you? Are you able to kind of do these skills without my support? interviews are used to progress monitor when a student may be working on developing a language or approach to advocating for what they may need in a particular classroom or activity and very

103often teachers whether the students are classified or not may use do now or exit tickets in their classroom and those are just quick ways to monitor curricular access either at the beginning of a class or at the end of the class we have all this wonderful data We think our students are making progress. How do we make sure that our families know that their children are making progress? First and foremost, there are a tremendous amount of informal conversations that occur frequently between parents and special education teachers throughout the year. However, there is more of a formal approach too. IEPs are living documents. Families and teams can ask the committee at any time to meet or discuss current recommendations, goals, and programming. Families are also provided formal updates on progress towards goals every trimester at the

104elementary level or a quarter at the secondary level. While individual student success is paramount for parents when discussing special education programming, we need to look at data for special education in the aggregate to get an idea of the overall program success. Similar to general education, we look at our performance on state assessments as one marker of how our programs are performing. The following data shows the performance of our special education students on state exams. When we look at the data, there are a few things to keep in mind. First, students with IEPs have disabilities, which produce barriers to learning and often delay development of conceptual knowledge or production skills. Additionally, The cohort for each grade level is small, so unlike the overall data for the district and the state, which our performance is benchmarked against

105in the following slides, a difference in only a few tests can significantly change the overall proficiency number. Lastly, state tests are imperfect instruments for assessing learning. As Amy pointed out, there are very specific ways we measure progress of special education students right down to how they're writing sentence level work. The cartoon above rings true for many of our students with disabilities. This slide and the next slide show percentage of students with disabilities who achieve proficiency on the three to five ELA and math exams. Proficiency is defined as either a three or a four on the state exam. The data shows that while we have always outperformed the state, there has been a very positive trend in performance over the past 10 years. This trend coincides with the expansion of the ICT program, a concerted effort

106with regards to professional development, more focused MTSS procedures, and an increase in related services including reading and social-emotional support. The math numbers follow the same trend. Our middle school numbers show evidence of the same trend. The current work is focused on expanding pedagogic ICT into science and social studies with the expectation for expansion into English and math shortly. Additionally, less focus in the middle school is placed on the state exam as students move up and our opt-out rate actually jumps significantly from the single digits to the mid-teens year over year. anecdotally we feel some of the opt-out numbers stem from a greater amount of overall assessment in the middle school and testing fatigue especially for our students who already find testing tedious tries some to opt out math shows math shows a similarly increasing proficiency

107As we move to high school data, regions passing rates, 65 or higher, are the most comparable data set. This is appropriate for high school given that we're working specifically towards achieving graduation. It's important to note that the passing rate is not the higher standard for proficiency in the 3A tests. Given the very significant differences between the 3A tests and the regions, there's really no way to compare them directly, but this data is still instructive both in relativity to the state and overall performance of our special education students. Our passing rate is impressive and for the small number of students who don't pass on the first attempt, there are multiple opportunities and supports. These scores are also not inclusive of special education safety net, which allows students with a disability to graduate with a score of

10855 if they have met the passing requirements for the class. Finally, we have to look at our graduation rate for special education students. The variations in rate account for students who are alternately assessed and age out in the year of their 22nd birthday without receiving a diploma. These students receive very specific post K-12 planning that includes supported employment or living as needed through state services. You may notice that the 2024 numbers for graduation are not present. All of the data you have been presented with come from the state reported data site to assure common data sets. The 23-24 data is not published until later this year. With that being said, All of our students with disabilities who are on the regular assessment track graduated with a diploma, and all of the students who aged out

109of alternate assessment track were placed successfully in adult programs. Using data to assess is important, but it's also one part of assessing success. Regular feedback from staff, families, and students is important to gauge whether programs are both meeting needs and feasible. Regular opportunities for that feedback are woven into the system for staff and department and team meetings. These opportunities are expanded in areas where we are expanding or significantly changing programs. Similarly, in conjunction with CHILD, I hold six coffees, two for each level each year, to garner feedback and answer questions from parents. CHILD reps hold additional coffees at the elementary level, and the chairs of CHILD and I meet regularly to discuss any concerns. Parents also have regular contacts through the CSE and team meetings held at a minimum of once a year. Teachers also

110make a regular practice of engaging students on their experience through class and individual conversations. This practice is being further encouraged through our work with responsive. The data and feedback indicates success in our current programs. With that being said, there are always areas to improve, especially as we understand the changing state landscape around graduation requirements. And we're going to transition now into looking at priorities over the next few years. There are really four driving questions that decide, that guide our decision making around special education programming. The first, how does our programming forward the goals of the strategic plan? Are we able to implement the highest quality pedagogy and interventions for our students? Are we able to honestly say teachers have everything they need to do what we ask them to do? And do families feel supported

111in their programs? Are the programs we build sustainable and do they forward the inclusion of students with disabilities in the wider goals for all students? Amy will talk over the next few slides about our specific priorities at each level. In terms of elementary programming, we're going to be looking at continued professional development for learning resource centers, ICT, and special class teams. We're going to be monitoring the social-emotional disabilities and the need for additional related services or additional programming and continued multi-tiered services development to expand universal interventions and pre-referral services. terms of the middle school preparing for the expansion of the continuum through ICT and special class expansion of the 812 program so that cohort is expected to join the middle school next September and potential development of off ICT offerings in all four major academic

112areas for next September We'll continue to engage in professional development and alternate assessment curriculum, verbal communication-based classes, and integrated co-teaching and MTSS development to expand universal interventions and pre-referral services. the high school we'll be looking to bring the special class of regular assessment up next year introduce ICT in two level core classes in the 26-27 school year prepare for the 812 special class alternate assessment students to arrive in 2029 and continue PD in alternate assessment curriculum verbal communication based classes and integrated co-teaching to the extent possible we want to forecast the needs of special education over the next four years with regards to staffing as it represents a financial commitment that has real tax and budget implications. These protections assume the expanding of our 12-1 and 8-1 special class programs through the high school. These

113two programs serve students that would otherwise be placed out of district and represent an expense that is fixed regardless of whether it's actualized through FTE and program expansion or throughout of district tuition costs. On the elementary level, FTE needs are based solely on section needs. ICT, similar to a general education section, require one FTE and are directly connected to the number of incoming or newly recommended ICT students. On the secondary level, The introduction of the additional ICT programs and the special class expansion drives the need. The actual number of FTE will depend on the number of students that qualify for those programs and the extent that those opportunities draw students from existing programs like Parallel Skills and LRC. There are factors that could offset the needs and those factors are really twofold. Additional out of

114district student declines, this is a definite probability, although not at the rate of decline we've seen over the last six years. We do still have students who would qualify for our eight to one or 12 to one program that are older than the cohorts that are currently moving up through the school. So those out of district tuition costs would fall off as those students age out of the program. And then secondly, we could look to take on tuition paying students in our expanded programs. As we started these programs, we have been very selective in who we would think about taking now that they're a bit more established, especially on the elementary level. That is an area which we hope to increase the number of students who are coming into the district for tuition. We would

115never take on students that would fill a class, leaving no room for students who are moving in. But we would take on students right now in our three to five class and we would take on students in our bridge class for 12 to one. Currently, we're one short of a full class in our K-2, eight to one to two program. With that, some takeaways about programmatic priorities. Special classes in ICT will require more expansion on the secondary level. The students served in our special class would be placed out of district if the programming doesn't expand and they represent a fixed cost. It's also prudent for us to look at district acceptances to offset special education expenses looking forward. Admittedly, this was a long and enormous amount of information presented, so I thank you for taking

116the time to listen, and I'm happy to try and answer any questions. Thank you Eric and Amy for your presentation. I know I asked a lot of questions ahead of time but I still have another one. On slide 54 you talk about expanding the ICT, potentially expanding the ICT offerings in all four major academic areas for the middle school. Could you tell me what we have right now? And actually yeah, start with that. That'd be great. The parallel program which has been kind of the legacy program at the middle school has really changed on the sixth and seventh grade level introducing what I'll call pedagogic ICT. There's always been a push in support in social studies and science. Sixth and seventh grade now really have the PD behind it so that it looks on a

117developmentally appropriate level more like the elementary school. Station teaching, the six models of co-teaching, co-planning, co-grading, and a real expansion of differentiation. The parallel program offers special classes in English and math, so there's not an ICT option for English and math. The 12 to 1 to 1 program for parallel is a self-contained special education class, focuses on foundational English and math skills that work towards grade-level standards. The students who have... experienced full co-teaching through fifth grade, many of those students in fifth grade have to make a decision about going into regular level classes with LRC for English and math or moving into the special class 12 to 1 to 1 there are students that would really benefit from having the option of a ICT class in the English and math there will still be a

118need that some kids will need that more self-contained class but we do believe that there will be a draw from that class and a draw from some of the kids who push into the to into the regular level classes there are kids that are on the bubble essentially and they have to make a choice either to be a little bit more restrictive or less restrictive than maybe the perfect program for them would be so that ICT is looking to expand those choices so that a student could move from full ICT in fifth grade to full ICT in sixth grade okay and so then there's there's still then there's no more parallel in those classes or there is still parallel options If by parallel option we mean will there still be a 12 to 1 to

1191 class, there would be, but there would be less sections of them, most likely. Again, it's early in the year, so it's very hard to really be able to discern exactly what the exiting fifth grade. going to need exactly we have we have an idea but there are students who are gonna make three four five months of progress and they're really gonna start preparing for that middle school transition it's gonna become clearer in January February and March which students would benefit from which program most and we have these programs in two of our houses and is the plan to just continue in those houses correct We moved from, we used to place parallel in a different house every year. sometimes two houses depending on the size but in order to move to this more pedagogic

120ICT we really have to be cognizant of the professional development and the teams of teachers that work in these ICT classroom and if you're bouncing them around from house to house where you're an ICT teacher as a general education teacher and it may be three or four years before you do it again you don't build the professional expertise to have really effective ICT Okay I mean that makes sense to me I guess but the there to these houses then could potentially have the 12-1 class so ICT in general like they would have a lot going on in LRC Remember we're talking about the same general cohort of students some and and not every student who needs a 12-1 in English needs it in math So it's not that you're all in or all out. This

121is really more about picking the right combination of classes for a student. I would suspect that right now we have 12 to one classes in both houses. If those numbers drop, which I believe they would, maybe combining those to a double house class where there's one section of that. goes across both houses and then the ICTs are present in each class. So I don't think you're gonna see a major change in the population of those houses, but you're gonna see more choices for the student in that general. level where of those students who need that general level support who would have been in those houses anyway okay so I'm sorry for the continued questions but I just really want to understand so where we have ICT now in the middle school do we also I

122guess it's now science and social studies do we have the 12-1 classes yeah so right now so there is a high degree of overlap between the students who are taking ICT science and social studies and those students taking the 1211s for English and math. A full parallel program, right, would be those four classes plus an academic support period. What we're looking to do is allow for the additional choice of being able to take all four ICTs and have that academic support class. So you're really building in more choice for... More levels or grade more gradient in the amount of support that students can and that's sort of what you're looking to do as well in the high school a little bit further so yeah as we look towards the high school and we're talking about

123the idea of ICT skills classes currently serves if you will like our 12 to 1 to 1 classes in the in the high school That's the level one class. There's a level two class. We sometimes think about the students who are kind of those one and a half students who may be either underserved in the skills classes where they could be challenged and pushed more, and then there are certain students on the two level that are kind of really just hanging on to in a really challenging where LRC is not quite enough. But they could use more support in those in those sections. So we would expect when we move in that direction to see a draw from LRC for students who are in the two level now with LRC they would move out of

124LRC have some level of ICT classrooms and a larger ratio academic support class and then the kids moving out of skills would also move out of LRC into the same into the same you're really adding to the continuum of services looks different in middle school and high school because we departmentalize by subject this they might cringe if I try to say this and I'm wrong but you you could think about it similarly on the elementary level where we have a student in ICT let's say but we pull them for a Wilson reading program we have to provide additional staffing for the Wilson reading program Even though they're already plopped in the ICT and the continuum, the Wilson is basically a more restrictive program for that particular need. Translate that to the middle school, we've got

125a more restrictive program in the 12-1-1, at least in this case. We have students who have part of their day in a more restrictive environment, part of their day in a less restrictive environment. We're really trying to create all options. for all less restrictive, keeping all more restrictive, or a hybrid of both. Because that's at the CSE table, that's what the discussion will be about. What's the best program for those students, for this student, this one child right here. Yeah, and the slide that's up now is really instructive of what levels of the continuum are available at each school. and you see that that secondary curriculum on the high school level is more restricted. Because really you're talking about LRC from a named program. That's a little bit misleading because skills classes are supportive, but

126they're not a special education program. Yeah, and you know, I'm sorry, I have another question too. Keep going with this, but I can talk about it for a while, so good luck to anyone else trying to ask a question. So parallel classes are a... special education teacher with a push-in teacher as well I'm sorry so that so there's parallel is like I said the legacy name of the program it's probably more instructive to think about it as the integrated co-teaching options which is a two teacher class regular cap mixture of at minimum 60-40 general education to special education students two teachers one special one general education teacher they are working co-planning co-teaching models the whole nine yards the 12 to 1 to 1 program in English and math 12 students capped one special education teacher

127one aid to work specifically as a self-contained class. There's no general education teacher that pushes into that. And then skills is also. One important thing, but a different profile of student than the bridge. Yeah, a different, I'm sorry, this is really important. The ratio, the ratio is a ratio. You can have two different 12 to one classes that are very, very different classes, just like you can have two different eight to one classes that are very different classes. In our, in the. Bridge we are talking about students who need the foundational academics to build them towards a regular assessment diploma. The 8 to 1 to 2 is a verbal communication class for students mostly on the autism spectrum, although not completely, who have great difficulty verbalizing basic needs and they are working on independent living

128skills life skills foundational literacy in both math and ELA and they are on an alternate assessment track so they're the bridge students also on alternate they are they are not they are regularly assessed as the kids in the bridge move through their middle and high school there will come a point where there may be need to be a decision made on whether or not the regions are the right target for those students but that wouldn't happen until later in their secondary career after we really focus on trying to move them through the regular curriculum. Okay and then I think my final question so skills classes at the high school now how are those taught? Are those? Those are a general education teacher that has a special education teacher pushing in It's not real ICT, quote

129unquote. The work they do is really important. They're really... collaborating with the LRC to help students with the curricular pieces to bring some differentiation from a product standpoint into the skills classes they are working in team teaching sometimes and they are working in kind of a one teach one support type of model but it is a general education class so it is different from our 12 to 1 in the in the parallel Thank you for this Amy and Eric I'm gonna continue on just because I'm also a little confused I just want to make sure I understand as we're looking at the staffing needs. This is gonna come back in the budget and so Trying to differentiate the different programming it might be helpful for us to just maybe get like a I don't know,

130like a user's guide to all of these, like in a document? So we can refer back to... We do. So there is a secondary special education handbook on the website that actually outlines what all of these programs are. So proverbial glossary. I'll make sure I share that. Yeah, no, I can find it. I thought I understood it, and then as we're talking more, I'm realizing I don't understand it. It's very hard to talk about in the abstract, it is. So I'm just looking at, I just want to understand the next steps because I know we're going to have to make some decisions moving forward. In middle school, you're talking about possibly adding one to two FTEs, and is that purely for the expansion of ICT into eighth grade? So looking at 25-26 under the middle

131school, one of those FTEs is specifically for the eight to one to two class. Coming from Edgewood? Coming from Edgewood. It's a full assignment. so there's no that is not a split assignment those students would have a teacher for their main academic programming across the board and if we didn't have that if we don't plan for that we would have to tuition out those students and how many students is that three the current transfer the current students transferring up are three and does that require any additional staffing aids It's an 8 to 1 to 2 so there would be two additional so that's two of the FTEs no it aids are hourly they're they're not at the rate of teachers okay and then the other one is for expanding the ICT into the eighth grade

132right it's one to two because we're looking also at what the needs are and whether or not there's a need to bring on more people in order to facilitate having the ICT we do expect there to be like I said a lessening of the sections of 12 to 1 which if you might free up which might free up so we're just not sure exactly what that math is yet and whether or not it can be absorbed into the current sectioning or if in order to do that we would need additional section now that to be that being said if you look at the following years the reason why there's questions is that's to expand that ICT across English and math, all three grades. We don't know exactly what the delta will be between what collapses

133versus what expands. earlier in the presentation you you referenced expanding the current sixth grade this year do you feel like you have you have enough staffing to do that again it's one to two there because we're still kind of waiting on the fifth grade and see what's coming up on who's gonna need what and where okay I thought you're saying at the end I thought you were saying this year you were going to try so you're time no first time this year meeting on this budget process yeah all right so that is helpful and then for the high school You're saying another FTE purely because you have the 12 to 1 moving into the high school Be clear, it's not necessarily that one teacher will be the only teacher for those students in the in

134the bridge They will have a subject based rotation But we will look to hire someone who can do some work based learning with them and some of those more Specific skills, but that won't it won't be one person for that group But it's the equivalent of one person to take on those FTEs or those sections which equates to a full person none of those come with additional FTE they may come with aids or something else but not additional FTEs once you have this program expanded in high school then you need to add another person another person you're just saying that's it all right thank you those are my questions first thanks for this presentation it's very helpful to you know talk about the programming separate from just budget although as you can hear a lot

135of our questions are sort of going into them Colleen and Amber asked a bunch of my questions about sort of the staffing. I think I have a handle on it now. So I do just want to understand, right now there are three students in the 3 to 5, 8 to 1 to 2 at Edgewood. All three are in fifth grade. Correct. There are seven students in the K to 2. Are any of them in second moving into 3 to 5? Yep. We're going to have between 3 and 4, one may be moving from... the K-2 to the 3-5 and then we are expecting between three and four students coming in as kindergarteners into that 8-1-2. So the K-2 will essentially stay about the same for 25-26. The 3-5 will gain either three or four students

136and then the three will be up in the middle school. You mentioned possibly bringing in students from out of district. When that is done, are we committing to that student a K to 12, an education through 12th grade? We have the right to say they no longer have a spot or that the student doesn't fit our profile anymore from year to year. If you take on a student from out of district, it's incumbent upon us to really think that if the student was appropriate, we would be able to move them through 12th. That's why when we think about it, we would never put it as the last spot in a class, knowing that you may have someone move in that would eventually bump that student. So that's why I asked, right? Because I don't remember

137the exact numbers, but having been through this since we started 8-1-2, there's been a lot of variance in the numbers. If I remember correctly, K to 2 was almost at capacity, but then it sort of, I don't, whatever. Yeah, it's one off of capacity now. It previously was at capacity. But right now, 3 to 5, we only have 3 out of 8 kids. Correct. What I'm articulating is, it seems, I don't, the two of you know the reasons much more than I do. but it seems like the numbers vary a lot. We only have this one class. We don't have any flexibility. And so it's not like breaking a section when somebody moves in. So I just want to make sure we are all understanding here what that would mean if we... I think right

138now it's safe to say that we could afford to take on... probably one in the two upper grade bands. So middle school, we wouldn't put somebody from out of district in a brand new program moving into the middle school, so we wouldn't look for a sixth grade person coming in. But having someone join the three, five, eight to one to two, I think would be a reasonably safe bet given the way the kids are progressing. We have had some move outs and we have had some move ins. These types of programs, when they are successful, actually are a magnet for families who move will move in towards these programs because they if it's the right profile of it so that tends to be the case as kids get older in the program though I think

139that variance does start to even out where you can be reasonably sure that you could have room from for for the duration that's through yeah yeah Just going back to this potential staffing request for the middle school. I understand, now I understand how the idea behind some of the old parallel or 12 to 1 to 1. Time of those faculty members now be able to, may be able to be shifted to ICT. My request for budget is that that is fleshed out. Sure. Because I would be very concerned if we moved ahead and then Come September, we're told we have to pull a contingency because the numbers didn't work out so well. We've added a lot of staffing. This is a lot of staffing. And this is just one aspect of our district. No, 100%.

140Sorry, I have one other question and then a comment for budget. A question, one of the themes we have heard from all of our buildings. we are very tight on space. At the middle school we brought choice back in, at the high school we brought the A school back in. Have you identified the space for these classes? We have. So the middle school has the room set up or which room it's going to be. There's light work that has to be painting and stuff like that. Nothing that's material. Is there something there today that's moving out? Yeah, there is an LRC meeting there that will be done in another room as, you know, worked into the schedule. It's an off-house LRC, so there's some off-house LRCs that are not in a house LRC room, if

141you will, so they kind of float between rooms. We're identifying one of the smaller rooms that works for that particular option, and then they'll use one of the other classrooms. for that LRC that's off house. Okay. It's just that, as I'm sure all of you know around this table, that in some of our buildings we have faculty and kids in spaces that are not ideal. And if we are adding new types of classes, I just want to make sure we all understand what that does. I also just want to make sure that if there's any chance that something comes in a potential bond planning process. We're talking about this up front before that we do this. I think it's probably safe to say that when we think about the high school and we think about

142special education. generally in the high school in the bond planning process looking at the area around the LRC and the room specifically across the hall from the LRC which I think over the 20 years since the last time any major work was done on that have been Frankenstein didn't in some very needed for the moment but maybe not Planfully. Planfully. They've been planned for the need of the moment. There's a lot of opportunity in that area to kind of think through from a strategic standpoint how do you have the different spaces that you need to use the different size groups and the different things that are there. Okay. No, I understand. I remember seeing those spaces on the tour. So I have a visual. They're slightly, when you look at them, they're strange, but they

143all were kind of created out of the need of the moment. Yeah. And then my last... comment is just a request for when you come during your budget meeting. I just ask that you sort of look at the assumptions you're making on the FTE costs. You have a slide there that has 30 FTEs at $3.4 million. That's $113,000. I mean, that can't be a fully loaded cost. That is sounds more like a average salary of a recent hire not including benefits, health care, pension, professional development, all the other costs that are associated. So I'd ask that you just look at that when you come back on budget. I think that needs to be refined. I'll connect with Andrew and we can take a look at that. I also would ask that you, some of these

144classes come with either aides, which are hourly, or our new teaching assistants, which are less than teachers, but also receive benefits. So I just, I think it's very important when we talk about it in the budget context that we have the firm numbers of what we're talking about. That's fair. Andrew will insist on it. Thank you for this presentation. Thank you, Eric and Amy. I just have two questions, kind of somewhat in the line with Ron's. Could you just remind me again, when you showed Quaker Ridge, which has had the majority of the ICT for the past few years and has the largest special education population, and then you said moving forward it won't even out. Can you just clarify that again? Yeah, absolutely. So we've moved to... easiest way to call it as a

145sister school type of model where two schools each year receive the kindergarten Quaker Ridge has had more sections than other other schools because we were at a kind of a two school model where Quaker Ridge got a class every other year and the whole of that ICT need right so three and four sections their upper grades still have those three and four section grades as those roll off will be starting with two one or two sections in the grades that are taking them rather than a three or a four section grade so as their older grades roll off and the kind of new paradigm moves up through the grades that will even out those sections because basically the expectation is we're always at least at two sections to start with we haven't been under two

146and I don't know how long the third section would go to the school that had less overall sections and then the fourth section would obviously go and that would make it two and a two and we kind of in the three four range of need each year so Quaker Ridge still has those upper grades where they have that fourth grade has five sections of and it's similar to Heathcote has three sections of fifth grade correct which wouldn't happen in the future correct And then I'm just, I'm really glad that the new staffing is allowing for PD. And I was wondering if you could talk a little bit about it. Like even moving forward, will there be a way, it would be nice even next year when we do this to understand how the PD, you

147know, is it available for all adults in the classroom and how is it kind of effective practice? Sure. You know, understand that more fully. Yeah, so the PD was on this year really focused on the CSE procedures IEP side which has been more difficult to get given the caseloads of the CSE chairs. So that's happened this year. The focus on progress monitoring is really focused in on elementary LRC. So that PD is going to happen with that team. That's really being led by Christina Beck, who was the CPSC CSE chair, now is just CSE chair. and we'll certainly keep you updated on the others. I mentioned the CPI training, which is a de-escalation training that's for aides and assistants, which really helps them understand the context of conflict amongst kids, and that Amy and our

148district behaviorist, Shauna, have really forwarded with that group, and that's really helpful. lunch and recess where you know our aides or our assistants are out there kind of observing this giving them real really good intervention strategies to to work with students who may be in budding conflict or war in conflict. Thank you. Great. Thank you. Thank you for joining us. We are back in session and continuing right along. We're going to be going to item 10.05, the New York State Education Department Regionalization Initiative, and hand that over to Drew. Thank you very much, Susie. I appreciate it. Over the course of the fall, there's been... Quite a bit of conversation about this effort that the New York State Education Department launched known as regionalization as Susie just said and We've started to get some questions

149about it. The State Ed Department has made some adjustments to it based on feedback Both from educators, but also from school boards in particularly on Long Island So we thought we'd create some space here for a little conversation about this I'll do my best to sort of summarize the background material on this and then maybe we can jump into any questions that the board members have So as the State Education Department tells it and they shared this with superintendents in a regional meeting up at Putnam, Northwestchester, BOCES a couple months ago. The effort of what they're calling regionalization, which they admit is probably a poor choice of names upon reflection, was designed to shift the paradigm around how the state education department is identifying priorities. I guess in a simple way of saying it, they

150would argue that traditionally State Education Department has sort of from Albany looked out into the field, looked out into the landscape, looked at the legislature and decided what was important to move their initiatives forward. And the claim now is that given lots of changes, the uncertainty of foundation aid, among other things, the declining enrollment in certain locations and parts of the state challenges in funding budgets and parts of the state that they'd be better off asking districts to develop regionally those priorities so both what would be perceived as legislative priorities that could remove barriers or create structures or processes that are helpful to school districts and then also sort of budget priorities for the State Education Department to get behind anyway that's how they described it so they put that theory of action into effect

151through this regionalization mandate So I think the way many of the superintendents experienced this was, well, here we go, another mandate when we're in an environment where there are many mandates, many of which are unfunded. So we're always on edge when mandate comes out. It seems that the mandate requires a process that starts with filling out a very lengthy form. I've shared that form with the board. that looks at achievement data, data the state has through their state data collection and that Edgar shares with you annually, comparing sort of maybe six, seven years ago to the most recent year. And then also asking about kinds of programs that school districts have. that kind of match up to the state's profile of a graduate that piece that they they put forward so they were they're trying

152to engage in a data collection effort to understand the variety of opportunities that individual school districts are providing to kids the mandate next requires District superintendents, and I want to be clear about in state of New York parlance, a district superintendent is actually the superintendent of your local BOCES. So I'm a school district superintendent, but a district superintendent, or DS, is the BOCES superintendent. So DSs, district superintendents, were charged with sort of from those submissions. holding a regional conversation within your BOCES area our BOCES is Southern Westchester BOCES our district superintendent is Harold Coles so he would facilitate a conversation and work toward drafting a plan that identifies opportunities for shared experiences, services, student opportunities between school districts. That's what it seems to be. And that the mandate requires that that happen, that process, that

153cycle happen once every 10 years. Alongside the mandate, which was described in memos and a website and so on, the State Ed Department published a notice of rulemaking. that's in the state register that's legislatures pass laws but the agency executive agencies pass rules that enact those those laws or those mandates and they promulgate their own of how they want to do things so when they created this initiative they promulgated rules in the register and upon close reading of that register it seemed that the rules empower the boces district superintendents to enforce some of those regionalization activities even against the will of a school board so that became a real focal point both for superintendents in our region but also in particular Long Island which is a very active school board community to take a stand

154write a letter the Lower Hudson superintendents wrote a letter as well to the Commissioner and the upshot of that is they have agreed to change that based on that feedback change that power and change the requirement or mandate to an optional regionalization participation on the part of school districts so none of the activities have changed the process still stands as it was laid out and is laid out in the in the website but districts can communicate to the State Education Department that they that they don't want to participate I will share my my personal viewpoint on this based on as much as I can glean from this is with the change in the register or in the in the rulemaking what I see staying in the effort would only require a conversation I've submitted our

155form to the State Education Department and it would require a conversation I think some of my colleagues worry about that being a slippery slope that maybe there is a form or force of pressure that would require but frankly I can't even name for you specific activities or agreements or arrangements that we would potentially engage with other districts in I think the most relevant one is one that we engage in already which is the tuition in and tuition out of special education students to districts that have programs that meet their needs that is a significant process that has students in the center of it and there's a whole process designed around how to do that including board action when you receive or we send out a student you you are asked to weigh in on that

156I also don't know what happens if we opt out opting out means we don't have to participate in those meetings and conversations and discussions I also don't know if it puts us on a list of districts that opted out which may communicate something to to the public that we don't intend I really don't know I do know some districts at least one that I know of Clarkstown as last week their board took a vote on a resolution to opt out they made that decision and we'll communicate that the result of that resolution to the Commissioner so let me pause there and see if there are questions or wonderings or puzzlement or opportunities of leveraging purchasing point of view, I would think in principle, right? You know, if you're going to buy electric buses, why not

157do it as a, maybe as a region versus individually, or charging or storage or, I don't know, whatever, creating new energy sources, something like that. So isn't, don't we already... I do think it's confusing so I think your description of the of our participation in BOCES I think is spot-on just for people who don't know BOCES stands for boards of cooperative educational services and Andrew can probably get my back here but they're constitutionally created and they we we have a mandated financial obligation to them for capital costs regardless of any services we do or do not use there's a an underlying cost that that we have this regionalization is not that has nothing to do with it doesn't impact those things that are already in place including cooperative purchasing like there are annual discussions about

158new opportunities using BOCES as you know, a leverage point because it represents so many districts. And in fact, statewide, there are certain BOCES that take on those roles and responsibilities for the whole state. They've got a niche or they've got people. So an example is we use an online recruiting system statewide called OLAS. That is managed by one of the BOCES. It happens to be Putnam, North Westchester. Anything you'd add to we talked about the Google agreement this morning Erie one boces there's a lot of negotiations around our software contracts and the Things around that is it any number of those types of activities? So part of our discussion of superintendents was like we are like how is this? Different and it's been a struggle to really understand how it's different and an example was

159floated and tested with the deputy commissioner and yes yes that's an example would be a rural district that has a course offering that their neighboring district cannot staff doesn't have the capacity doesn't have the enrollment could a student from that other neighboring district attend their course that might be a regionalization agreement those two districts come up with that's like an example yeah and I think state ed would also say it may also identify hey, we've been wanting to do this for a long time, but there's this law or there's this barrier to being able to do that. So that's part of what state ed would say. I just want to articulate that we do so many good things with our neighboring districts at the administrative level, at the faculty level, at the board level, and

160right up there with our people and our finances. One of our most precious resources is our time. I mean, I hear from people all the time in the community about wanting to do things, and so often my response is simply, we literally don't have the time. The idea that you, our superintendent, will be sitting in more meetings about this when we already do this, it's a hard pill to swallow. Your time and all of the administrator's time. We do not have enough of it to achieve what we are trying to do here. If you think getting on a list is just not worth it and it's just worth doing and doing those meetings, I'll defer to your judgment. I think this is a blind spot of often of governments at the state and federal level.

161It's very easy to say, oh, here's a good idea. You won't have to do anything. It's a meeting. You know what? Ten hours out of the year is a lot of time. So I just put that out there. I appreciate that perspective very much. Well, I mean, to follow up on Ron's point, what is the anticipated time commitment that you would have? There's not a lot of clarity about that. Okay. I mean, are you able to say, sorry, I can't go to this meeting this week? Would you have that flexibility? Is that also unclear, or would you actually have it? Oh, I'd say that's unclear. Well, in other words, let's say they schedule 10 meetings and you only went to five. Would there be any consequence to that? Probably not. I can't imagine it'll be

162regionalization police. Well, yes. I mean, I guess some sort of thing. To me, it seems like a nothing burger. You know, maybe I'm just being too dismissive, but it really seems like a nothing burger. Like, who knows what it's going to amount to. For us, it seems like it won't amount to much, but that's just my impression of it. Drew, you mentioned the idea that if there was a class that a neighboring district offered that maybe this would provide an opportunity for a student to take that another different type of class so if like a student wanted to take an IB program and we don't offer an IB program or AP classes would this open potentially those opportunities to take those types of classes in other districts theoretically that could be an activity of regionalization

163I suppose how that would work, transportation responsibilities, tuition responsibilities, all seem just unknowable at this time to me. Yeah, thank you. So I just want to say the unknowable concerns me, you know, the fact that this would happen. and maybe it would be all good and well for a year, but then maybe something else would come down to tighten it or change it. Is that possible? You know, we just don't know. And then would students then want to take classes at Scarsdale? Would there be that agreement, too? That's just something to think about as well. I don't want you to spend too much time on it either, because I know you're already extended, overextended with your time. Those are some of my thoughts. I agree with many of my fellow board members. It's unclear what

164we actually stand to gain from joining this. We already have a good relationship with BOCES and a good relationship with many of our neighboring districts. We partner where we see mutual benefit already. By being in a regionalization program that's very undefined. does tax you know you there's a 50 page form there's you know a bunch of meetings um you know and the way it kind of came down as originally being a mandate does scare me that like well are they going to try to reinstate that at some point that slippery slope you know aspect that you mentioned also whether it was explicitly stated or um perceived as you know I think you know many school districts particularly that you know rely heavily on state aid they saw this as you know a way of maybe

165you know efficiency and of maybe justifying cutting state aid so I think you know I think alarm bells went off a lot of districts around here so you know I know you already filled out the form you know thank you for that but I think You know, I think it was the January 16th is a deadline to opt out and You know, I I'm just not convinced that staying would actually benefit Anybody you know, really? Yeah, it's January 15th, which is a Sunday, which is a Wednesday And we're meeting that Monday we meet that Monday if the board wanted to Have a resolution Yeah, it's in line with some of what Ron said and some of what Leah said, which is time-consuming without much clarity around what the potential future is and what the unknowns

166are. There's not a lot of good feeling about it, even if the intentions of State Ed are genuinely good. Would we like to maybe think about it, maybe have an opportunity to ask more questions as this kind of evolves? This is evolving kind of quickly, right? It changes all the time. So it is convenient that we are meeting two days before the deadline. So maybe we can decide what we want to take action on then. Does that sound good to everybody? I would decide to the extent to sort of what Bob mentioned. think it would it would be valuable for me to know if some of our similar neighboring districts decided to also I would just like to know what they're doing yeah I've had unofficial conversations with my counterparts at other districts and they're

167having similar conversations that we are yeah I know whichever way we go I doubt we'll be alone on that thank you Next would be item 10.06 a gift proposal to Edgewood Elementary School presented by Drew okay thank you we've got this is the first of three gift proposals for information meaning they'll come back these fall over $1,000 the first one for Edgewood Elementary School you've got for $1,997.39 and this is to add a peace path and obstacle courses to blacktop areas at Edgewood School any questions about that one sounds great the next gift item 10.07 this is a gift in the amount of $1,625 from the Fox Meadow PTA and as I should have said in the previous one we're grateful to our PTAs who generously offer these gifts this one I'll say a little

168bit more about there this is to replace the sensory path in the kindergarten wing and these are if you've been in the buildings you've seen these they're very engaging on the floor paths that kind of give kids thing to focus on and kind of get engaged with as they move through the through the hallway but they do have a life they they wear out over time because they're being walked on despite being coated over and stuff so this is a replacement I think for one that was there and look at Melissa who's in the audience and it's kind of we might see more of these gifts coming forward as they wear out and the desire is to replace them so thank you item 10.08 the gift proposal to the middle school Okay, and this is

169an amount of $1,950.50 from the middle school PTA. Again, thank you to them. And this is a new event, the Scarsdale Middle School World Language Day that's being planned for March. This is a variety of materials and supplies that go beyond our normal materials and supplies to create a day that includes region and country specific crafts and games and activities that will put it shine a light and put a focus on our world language program wonderful thank you next would be our action items item 11.01 budget transfers and I believe this is Colleen thank you Susie Be it resolved that the Board of Ed approve the attached budget transfers in excess of $25,000 as presented. Thank you, Colleen. Is there a second? Thank you, Leah. All those in favor, please say aye. All those in

170favor, all those against, say nay. The ayes have it and the motion carries. Thank you. The next item would be the gifts. Item 12.01, the gift proposal to the middle school. I believe this is Leah. Thank you, Suzy. I move that the board adopt the following resolution. Resolved that the board accepts with thanks the gift of $454 for a SMS teacher grant to fund a human rights day project for the Cooper 6 teaching team as presented in the attached letters. Thank You Leah is there a second Thank You Bob all those in favor please say aye ayes have it in motion carries thank you next item 12.03 the gift proposal to the Fox Meadow Elementary School that would be Ron I apologize sorry getting ahead of myself item 12.02 a gift proposal to the middle

171school Amber I move to the board adopt the following resolve that the board accepts with thanks the gift of $950 for an SMS grant to fund a magician speaker for the SMS eighth graders on Friday December 20th 2024 as described in the attached letters Thank You Amber is there a second Thank You Colleen all those in favor please say aye Aye. Aye. Aye. The ayes have it and the motion carries. Thank you. To the middle school PTA. Item 12.03, the gift proposal to Fox Meadow Elementary School. I believe this is Ron. Thank you. Thank you, Susie. I move the following resolve that the board accepts with thanks the gift of $900 for a Fox Meadow PTA grant to fund shadow boxes for an interdisciplinary project for first graders as described in the attached letters. Thank

172you Ron. Is there a second? Thank you Colleen. All those in favor please say aye. Aye. Thank you. The ayes have it and the motion carries. Thank you to our PTAs. Okay. Next would be on the agenda item 13.01 public comment. I'll read the Public comment preamble. Members of the public are cordially invited to be present either in person or via remote means and to speak at designated times on agenda items or other non-personnel related matters. Each individual shall have three minutes to speak with a 90 minute cap. during the first public comment period. The order of public comment will be as follows. Community members present at the board meeting will speak first. Community members speaking via Zoom will speak second. Community members speaking via Zoom must have their camera turned on when it is

173their turn to speak. The Board of Education shall maintain these rules for public comment. And at this time, I'd like to ask if anybody would like to make a public comment in the audience. No? Okay, thank you. Next, we'll go to Zoom. No attendees on Zoom. Thank you. We'll give it a couple seconds. Yep, still no attendees. Okay, thank you. And with that, we will close our second public comment session of the evening. And item 14, there will be no public follow-up to public comment if there were no public commenters. Item 15, wrap-up items. Suggestions related to the fund balance and... reserve plan and preparation for our budget process take those into account thank you okay and next we'll have meeting dates for the coming month Jim Thank You Susie so meeting dates for the

174coming month Monday January 13th 2025 it'll be a special meeting slash executive session as needed at 6 p.m. in the high school here at room 170 72 there'll be a business meeting at 6 30 the high school same room on wednesday january 15th 2025 there'll be a board community coffee at 10 a.m here room 170 72. wednesday january 22nd 2025 aboard community coffee at 7 pm here in room 170 72. uh tuesday january 27th 2025 There'll be a budget staffing recommendations and business meeting at 630 here in room 170-72. There will be a special meeting executive session if needed here in room 170-72 on the same date. Monday February 3rd 2025 there'll be a budget study session first budget study session at 630 here in room 170 172 a business meeting at the high school

175here room 170 72 and a special meeting slash executive session if needed here in the same room thank you so much Jim at this time would anybody like to make a motion to adjourn this meeting Thank You Leah second Thank You Ron all those in favor please say aye The ayes have it. Happy holidays and have a good night, everybody.

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.