001e e e good evening everyone please rise and join me in the pledge I aliance to the flag of the United States of am America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liy and justice for all good evening we will begin with dr's administrative report okay so shortly I'll be introducing Mr Cel to do his presentation on uh tax cap and a preview of the budget I'd like to start by thanking Mr wiid and M Na and and the booster club for an incredible incredible welcome for our national champion cheer team it was [Music] absolutely um the routine I saw the routine the routine was impeccable it was absolutely Flawless and these girls are incredible athletes the coaches and the girls to together worked so hard to accomplish
002this and we just really super proud of them so more to come on that but congratulations they deserve and we're going to honor them at a board meeting right yes of course of course we are uh also I just wanted to mention on the personal action tonight and on the agenda for approval are the retirees of um two of our teachers who are both um very strong contributors to both the middle school and our culture here in seford so first uh Kevin M Kevin molan has been a seventh grade science teacher uh he has done almost every extracurricular activity for science and math and he's just been so much part of the fabric here within the science department he'll be greatly missed he started his career here in 1997 and we're so proud that he's
003been part of our community for um all these years and we wish him the best in retirement so congratulations to him and as you know in June we do a big celebration where we say a lot of nice things about the retirees and and their legacies here in Seaford uh next is Barbara Sherwin and uh Barbara is just one of those magical people um she's she's been the director at the at the middle school since 2000 and she was in the district since 1999 at the high school but when you see Barber with the kids it's it's just such an incredible experience and when she goes to the high school even to visit the kids just clamor to her so she has a clearly a presence not to mention her contributions with regards to the
004Middle School Musical so we're dearly going to miss her she's a wonderful wonderful person as well as being a wonderful educator and absolutely wish you the best and retirement and then so as we have people um going we also have somebody joining us tonight so we have Cassidy Mullins in the audience wait cassid is going to be our lead replacement over at the middle school for the school counseling position she graduated from Sunni Brockport and then she has her master's degree in counseling from L post she's done a number of different leave Replacements throughout the island she spent a lot of time in Massa schools doing her uh observation work and she was a substitute teacher there throughout the interview process her warmth was very very very clear uh her child centered approach to counseling
005and we really look forward to your joining the team so congratulations and welcome and then just a couple of more things um as everybody knows we're in the throws of upk registration I'm really pleased to report that there are 137 families that are um are in or are completing the registration process right now and we have um um a number of seats that are open some of the vendors gave us a couple of more seats so right now we're looking at 107 seats open for 137 applications currently the registration process closes tomorrow the 13th and then next week we will be using our internal Auditors to run the lottery so there'll be more to report after that when we get back from the break and I think that um the only other thing that I
006wanted to mention is that every year scope runs an award ceremony for people of Excellence within a school district so this year we're we're recognizing three super super super people one is in the audience today m naal is going to be recognized for um her contribution school and then her well you have a lot of right-hand people but one of her right-and people uh Tony kaachi is going to be recognized as well and then Carrie Hansen is is retiring this year from the harbor and I cannot even begin to speak about the contributions that Carrie has made to not only the harbor but to so many districtwide initiatives even in the last eight years since I've been here but that's been her Legacy so we're really super excited uh we went to her classroom to
007tell her students about it and um of course Jen had P poms and everything and the kids were super excited they had lovely things very extemporaneously to say about the teacher said well what would you why why would you give him his handson this award and they said the most precious and fabulous things about car that's great deser so um now we're going to get all ready for that uh I think it's his favorite time of year not my favorite time of year budget season and Mr C is going to present our t love thank you thank you it is my favorite time of year and I was really excited actually when the board showed up tonight because they were all doled up and decked out and I thought it was for the budget season
008the launch tonight they were getting their photos T not a coincidence on the same night thought it was for me but it's okay uh yes so thank you uh you know first of many budget presentations here in budget season so I'm just going to start by going over the the U maximum allow allowable tax levy for this year uh just a reminder this is the convoluted tax cap formula that we use here in New York state and I will uh do my best to just give you the cliffnotes version of of where we stand so here's the really half the formula if you will uh and there's a couple of key numbers that are in the formula we start by taking the prior year tax levy and then we uh one key number there circled
009in green is the tax based growth factor this year year for seford it's 1.76 uh which is actually a lot higher than it was last year and that's based on a number of factors growth and development in in the town and area and things like that and then as we move through the formula we put in the prior year Pilots uh exemptions and we and prior year uh Capital exclusion and we wind up with an adjusted prior your tax levy and then we take that number and we apply the allowed growth factor and just a reminder to the board and the public the growth factor is the lesser of the inflation factor or 2% so the inflation Factor Still Remains over 2% uh it's actually come down in the last year two years uh it's
010at 2.95 but we still have to use them up to them okay and then we take all that and see the second half of the formula we add the coming uh expected pilots in the coming year any available carryover a number of other factors and exemptions that typically don't apply uh last year we did have an ERS contribution this year we do not and then we take the you know coming year the capitals tax levy exclusions and we apply that all into the formula and we basically all this is telling everybody here that the maximum allowable tax levy for the 25 26 school year for our district would be 2.68% that would be the maximum allowable tax L and looking at the budget and looking at a lot of factors looking at our revenue and
011expenditures for 25 26 uh which I'll get into uh we're going to make the recommendation that the maximum allowable is 2.68% as I said we feel confident we can deliver a budget under that by not going to the maximum at 2.49% um so that would be our recommendation to I will say very early somewhat early preliminary numbers that I've heard from colleagues around the area especially into Southeast quadrant and nasso County I actually think this would be more on the lower side from the numbers that I've heard Dr Bora can ATT test to that um so I I think that that would be good if we went with a number in that range and I can confidently feel that I can deliver a budget in that range just to give you some history of the
012last several years here in Seaford we try our very best as you can see to uh provide relief to the taxpayer by going under the cap similar to this recommendation for next year so uh you can see the history there again uh trying to not go to that maximum level this also shows that we're we always do our best to um be fiscally responsible and once again the numbers came out for 202 before we have a no designation in our fiscal stress score which is great news now we dive into major major expenditures for 2526 just how the budget is looking so over 75% of the budget is contractual salaries and we do have multiple units entering negotiations so this is all going to affect the expenditure side of the budget for next year health
013insurance so our current bill as as again just to remind the board the bill does go by calendar year so we were very fortunate we just got the news as of January 1 that the increase for 2025 was smaller than we expected which is fantastic news but again in planning for next year's budget it it's we have to be prudent and plan for increases for January 26 in this budget at this time and just I did uh we ran some numbers and the T 10 year average for health just shows you how how you know these increases have been over time 74% increases in health over the last 10 years for both individual and family coverage and even worse so coming out of the pandemic and this is over the last four years it's a
01439% increase which is an average of 9.8 per year and that includes this minimum you know this this previous January 1 increase that was so minimal and it's still an average of 9.8 a years so we really need to be careful and prepare for the unknown of course other major cost drivers that go into the budget that we always have to look at of course TRS and ERS um we do have a slight slight decrease in TRS uh but we were our expenses were over budget the past two years so we need to just account for that and make out for that and ERS we have a slight increase utilities and insurance premiums uh unfortunately I we've gotten word that our insurance premium similar to you know last year to this year is due to
015go up 25 to 30% again um you know everybody at home and here in the audience knows that your own insurance premiums have been experiencing similar spikes so unfortunately that's just the reality and transportation is another area where we are publishing our RFP on Friday we're due to go out for an RFP for transportation services and again unfortunately the the the word the word out there for increases is 20 to 30% uh for next year so these are all things that we certainly need to account as we're building the budget for 25 26 on the expenditure side and then if you move over to the revenue side just to say tell you how things are looking and of course this picture will become clearer throughout you know the series of presentations over the next several
016weeks state aid uh as a right now we're due to receive $246,000 increase in Foundation Aid and you know that sounds nice uh but unfortunately it's nowhere near what we received from last year as far as an increase when we had 978,000 so it's a little smaller and than we were hoping uh so that's certainly something we're going to have to um look out for and we'll see what's in the final state budget when the governor finalizes her budget whenever that may be uh reserve for tax reduction this is uh again just to remind the public and the board this is due to the sale of the secret Avenue School so that was uh a little over 10 years ago so we we did use funds in this current budget that we're living in uh
017the final funds from that uh sale of that property so that is officially ended therefore that's creating a $625,000 revenue Gap already starting out for 25 26 uh so we are going to look to use some reserves to help we do have uh reserves that have been climbing nicely due to some interest Investments uh so particularly with TRS and eelr Reserve we will most likely look to use those for 25 26 there is a cap limit of how much we can carry in our in many of these reserves particularly the TRS Reserve is getting close to that cap anyway so it would be prudent for us to start using that a little bit even as we making money and interest and again the last point about interest uh we we've done exceptionally well making interest
018uh especially with our you know Investments and relationship with your class and we'll continue to do so uh but again you know we do expect based on things we hear from economic experts um I serve on the nass board and think I get some nice reports from uh some economic experts and they do expect rates to uh taper down slowly moving into facilities uh this is an update to The Graphic that we had presented last year based on our Five-Year Plan uh Capital Improvement and facility Improvement plan the yellow was what the that First Column was what was already done last May the voters approved as as everyone knows the Middle School roof will be breaking ground this summer on that project and we also established a new capital reserve to start planning uh and
019saving for our next future mes and projects so now if we jump to 2526 and I'll go back and forth here we're looking to add uh two propositions this may one uh referring to as the infrastructure proposition again to help our infrastructure and particularly our roofs we we have the funds available to tackle the both the harbor roof and Mana roof projects and this by using the capital res serve uh and asking voters to yet again approve that to work on these these roof projects in addition we have a constant problem of of water uh getting into our wrestling room in particular at the high school and flooding that out repeatedly we've replaced mats we've removed mats we've had a uh do some work for U water damage and you know it's something we definitely
020need to address it's a significant problem so we would like to also take part of the money in this proposition to address our infrastructure and we're working with our Architects to come up with a series of options and plans to address the water in this area uh it could involve a number of things uh seal coating Paving the area uh caulking uh seal coating grout again it could be a number of things and as future presentations over the next several weeks will be the picture become clearer that we can share more details of that so that would be one extra uh one additional proposition and then the other proposition is really addressing uh all Safety and Security so it's really a Safety and Security upgrade proposition for the community to consider and the goal here
021would be the following to install a door jar system at both the Middle School and High School uh increase our security camera uh not only add cameras and address blind spots but upgrade them a lot of our cameras uh are a little outdated and don't really present clear enough pictures for things that we need uh so that would be a part of this package as well and then lastly a new elevator indoor refurbishment of the high school elevator and again as the next coming weeks we go we'll have a clearer picture if we we can do a new elevator versus a refurbishment we'd like to do a new elevator a completely new elevator it is the original elevator at the high school so these are the that's you know these are included in the Safety
022and Security proposition so these are things that we're looking to do in this budget as well and again just to go back to the plan the fiveyear plan you can see those things written in for 25 26 or the revised plan if you will and then you know thinking long term similar to last year you know last year when we first laid out the plan we will probably need a year to uh recoup we could do some smaller projects in 26 27 but we definitely wouldn't be able to attack the high school roof to most likely the year after okay and just want to let the public and board know we have again a whole series of budget presentations coming our our next one is going to be on March 12th uh the curriculum team
023will be doing that one and then again on March 26 leading up to our budget adoption on April 9th of course our budget hearing on May 7th and then our budget vote on May 20th so a lot more to come I was going to say can you just remind the board about the amount of money and interest we're saving by self-funding these abs using capital reserve absolutely yes when we first laid out this plan last year and I appreciate the question and clarifying this when we first laid out this plan last year we we had discussed the whole plan and purpose of self funding these roofs all four roofs are in uh definite need of replacement complete RI and replace and in order to afford that by bonding we would have had to borrow x
024amount of dollars and then it would have cost us 77.9 million in interest uh of borrowing that money so you know I'm really proud that we're able to sell fund already the middle school and that's going going to be happening we just as I mentioned we just open bids for that and that we're going to be able to tackle the both the manor and harbor already in year two so three out of the four buildings will be taken care of if you will the next you know two years which is pretty good yeah and again saving the tax pair money in interest so we're earning interest instead of paying interest I think that that's really important for our community and I'd be happy to thank you for your support and I'd be happy to any
025questions that the board may have questions thank you Andre thank to your future detailed presentation thank you just I know it's not time for this but I have the microphone so I'm sorry uh before I sit down I just want to publicly thank our custodians our groundsmen and our maintainers we have gotten you know the snow over the last several days uh three or four storms just keep piling up and they have been unbelievable in getting our buildings ready so I just want to publicly thank them and of course the Maestro uh Russ Casta orchestrating it all behind the scenes I just want to thank them and appreciate it thank Youk you thank you thank you very [Applause] much okay going to move on to some business okay can I have a um motion for
026agenda item 5 a through C2 move it second any discussion all in favor I this is the resident comment section would anybody like to speak in keeping with its philosophy of open communication and informed decision making the Board of Ed welcomes input from the community however it is important to note that while the Board of Education meets in public it is not a meeting of the public respectful input and behavior by each member of the community is appropriate and expected at all times and should observe the following rules at Board of Ed meetings the Board of Education will listen to comments and input from the public debate between members of the audience and or board members is inappropriate and will not be permitted the board is not permitted to address Personnel or student individual student
027matters in public no person shall present orally or discuss at any Board of Education meeting charges or complaints against individual employees directly or indirectly the speaker shall identify themselves and confirm their residency as Seaford within the Seaford School District the normal time limit allotted for individual speakers shall be 3 minutes the Board of Education May in its discretion decrease or increase the time for individual speakers to allow for public participation a period not to exceed 30 minutes shall be set aside as a specific agenda item during each regular and special Board of Education meeting the period may be extended by a majority vote of the board event and with all of that hello please state your name and confirm you are resident Seer uh my name is Brian Mohler and I live on will be
028thank you Brian welcome um just Brian is Brian's mic on thank you for the opportunity to come and speak to you guys um my daughter is in the Middle School in seventh grade and I understand there has been issues in the district have attempting to address I know a teacher was removed it's explained to me that the teacher would still uh it was explained to me that the teacher would still be writing lessons and the certified Ela teacher who would be replacing them would implement the lessons was made clear to me that all Hands-On deck approach from the building level to the district office and I appreciate that uh however I made a phone call last week until I made a phone call last week uh my daughter has not had a graded assessment since
029December her last graded quiz was December 11th last graded test was December 20th the last graded homework was January 13th shortly after the teacher was move that's about four weeks of no assessment almost half a marking period I do not care what the grades are uh but I I do care that she is being evaluated so that she can improve her skills how does anyone how does anyone know if she or the other students are learning this is the the beginning of my concerns if this was an all on on if this was an all hands on deck approach with many eyes involved how is it possible for zero sesss to go unnoticed for that long the second concern is that the work they've been doing has been root wording work of writing in a
030journal reading from a book a discussion and then more writing if all educational lives are involved in the lesson planning from the teacher through the district office why is it the same lesson every day one could have the most amazing lesson plan possible but if the format is repeatedly used consecutively for weeks the result would be a destruction of intrinsic learning and a daily dread of repetition I know it takes hours and hours to create interesting and creative lessons with so many people involved why does appear that the solution for the instruction was to develop a cookie cutter model that is rope and simple this is stereotypical subw workk where busy tasks are left to students to complete until until the classroom teacher returns with that personal matter uncertain it gives the appearance and I
031say the appearance that the actual education of the kid seems to have faded to the background when dealing with a difficult Personnel issue my last concern in this matter is that when the letter was sent out parents were told we would have a certifi a quote certified Ela teacher covering the class it's come to my attention that is not what is what happened happened while certified for elementary school the individual is not certified to teach seventh grade if that's the case I believe the secret school district has broken New York State educational law no District made place an uncertified substitute in a room with a full schedule for an extended period of time in addition to that why sent out a letter to parents that said something that was incorrect to sum up my concerns
032why did we have any assessments for four weeks why are the lessons sub planned like and why the parents told we have a certified Ela teacher in the room if they done thank you we appreciate your comments um you know we appreciate you coming and speaking tonight um we're not going to be able to respond off the cuff to many of the things you said um but we are going to look into the issue um and um somebody will be in will be in touch with you this first of all thank you for um your composure and the manner in which you presented the information I greatly appreciate it um I will be meeting with the instructional team in addition to meeting with uh the building principal there is a plan in place I have
033seen what the overall goal is for that I think you know that a significant amount of time was spent making sure that the assessments for the second quarter Fair evaluated the student work um and that letter went home to the parents and we're very confident of that um with regards to the teacher that is in the classroom now um Miss Paris Miss Paris is a certified English teacher and I understand the substitute that was in there before was a certified New York State teacher she was not certified in ela and I understand that I am very happy that a certified Ela teacher is in there talking about and I'm not and I'm not trying to have it back and for I understand I appreciate express myself um that we had um you know six weeks
034or or four weeks of instruction without a a person who's a person who's certified that that is that's a real problem and I and I would love to hear an answer as to why that was done because I know that you that we in education can uh pull in someone retired and say hey we need you for a bit I know we can pass off and say hey let's have an overage you take one you take one you take one there's other options than throwing a substitute in the room four weeks and and and again you know I I will do some more research and I'll be glad to have a con a follow-up conversation with you I will say that immediately the position was posted and the search was to get a more permanent
035solution with an English certified teacher and they would which is what the situation is right now but I I promise I will get back to you um I understand it's board policy to limit comments of citizens uh I was wondering if I could just get a minute or two more of your time that's unless anybody else wants to go um thank you I appreciate that I only have two more questions um my seventh grade daughter came home to me and explained that her family in consumer science class was reduced from half a year to a quarter of a year limiting what they could learn in the class and that she would be placed into another computer class I explained to her this cannot be true her older sister who's in eth grade had the class
036the previous year and loved it her sister said it was one of her favorite classes with a wonderful teacher I went and checked the Seaford Middle School website for this information and it clearly states that family and consumer science is a class for half a year she tells me that I am incorrect I'm asking if things have changed if they have changed we're parents informed about the change and why would we get rid of a Hands-On lesson skills that kids like to do in school for another computer class and there was supposed to be an exploratory cooking class that they had signed up for so is there any information about that that I can find out for you guys so um there are new New York state requirements that require computer science instruction that is
037mandated by New York State education department so there was a shift the computer science program that we had was over the state requirement so there was a shift made to more computer science but that is a state requirement to offer that level of support for students in that discipline and that's that's a new requirement that came in this year I understand that um if we're over it why would we cut family and consumer science which again different kids learn different ways and Hands-On learning is something that I think kids need more of in school um on top of it it doesn't say that on the website on our website it says it's half a year I will make sure that we go back and look at the website and look at what's Illustrated and and
038written on the on the website regarding the coursework I believe that Dr M when he does the overview for for courses um does explain that and we and we have had some public presentations where we spoke about the need to shift uh and add more computer science to our program we did that publicly at the board meetings last spring but there was no letter that went directly to parents saying that this is going to be cut I'm I'm I'm just asking for clarification cuz I I can't it to all the board Mee don't I don't believe that there was a specific letter that said that we were going to offer more computer science and that we were not going to have as much family and consumer science in the program okay um one last thing
039please I have all heard from all of my children that lunch at the middle school is going to change I have an eighth grader a seventh grader and a sixth grader they're middle school kids and they can be unreliable narrators uh there's a game room coming they say students will only be giving 20 minutes 20 minutes to eat lunch and students will only be allowed to sit with members of their own teams in a nutshell is any of this true and if there is a change to the lunch procedure would parents be informed about it prior to its implementation was I also have a middle schooler so um I know much of what you're talking about um this was communicated it was on parents Square from the principal of the Middle School um about a
040change to the lunch to the lunchtime uh period um it was also discussed at u a board meeting um I think it was maybe a month ago or so um and I and I and I recall that the impetus for the change is that um you you may or may not know um that the middle school was designated as a um school to watch right schools to watch and one of the things that that um body told us um among the you know all of the accolades was something that we could improve upon was to have a more Dynamic Lunch Period um because it was felt and it's happens in other districts that the 40 minutes for sitting there for lunch is is a long time for stagnant time for kids to sit there and
041so this program was created in conjunction with the schools to watch um as a more Dynamic approach to the Lunch Period um I will say um that in terms of what is offered for lunch is that was part of your children's complaint um no just that they would not be able to sit with their friends and that it would and this is conjecture I don't I don't again I don't know any of this yeah or that that they would only be able to sit with kids on their own team and they would only give be given 20 minutes to you so so Mr Muller one of the things that we do at the elementary school is is we have kind of shifts where kids go out for recess and kids eat it it's a similar
042structure but with just the older kids so that um they have more opportunities to not only just go outside but they have more opportunities to do things inside be and and we're hoping that we'll also be able students that want to go up to the library and there'll be more um things available to them like in in the future with regards to their maker space or some things they can do just in the library to so they have more opportunities so it's it's not meant to limit children it's meant to give them more opportunities to relax and to be able to you know interact with their friends so what I would say is if if Dr m is is not going to be able to speak with you tonight after the board meeting he will
043call you tomorrow and he will explain this we've gone to see this program in in neighboring school districts and it works really really nicely so we just ask you to have a little patience and see if your children like it and um I think it's amazing that you are still standing here when you have a sixth seventh and eighth grader for us so we will definitely we will continue the conversation with you and I'm I'm sure Dr Mo will reach out to you but I really do believe it's going to be a nice program for the children but just to reiterate because I and this is it um will they be allow to sit with their friends or were they forced to stay with the kids on their team I'm going to let Dr Mor
044handle that because that type of micro managing and knowing what how he's establishing that the greater vision of it is things that we've seen in action one of the wonderful things about being a Schools to Watch is that people provide you feedback and it's a loop of continuous Improvement so we're trying to continuously improve some of the things within the school school so um and I really do appreciate your you're coming to the microphone and sharing information for us with us tonight thank you very much thank you okay moving on cour there's nobody else who wanted to speak right okay um all correspondence has been responded to moving on to new business I need a motion for agenda item 8 A1 through D1 move it any discussion all in favor I need a motion for
045agenda item 8 E1 move it second any discussion all in favor I need a motion for agenda item 8 E2 move it second any discussion all in favor I need a motion for agenda item 8 E3 move Itor any discussion all in favor I any a motion for agenda item 8 E4 move it second any discussion all in favor I need a motion for agenda item 8 E5 it second any discussion all in favor I and I need a motion for agenda item 8 E6 move it second any discussion all in favor Iain okay um and then I need a motion for agenda item 9 1 through two oh um any motion for agenda item 91 move it second any discussion all in favor I and any a motion for agenda item 9 to moving
046second any discussion all in favor I okay miscellaneous discussion items anything from the board okay closing comments um just a really quick congratulations and best of luck to our retirees um welcome to miss um Miss Mullins happy to have you aboard uh we are really very happy to see the numbers jump in the upk program uh it's you know exponential improvement from last year and improvement from just a week ago so um I think the community will be gred about that so wonderful uh cheer we can't say enough so super proud of that team of those coaches Kevin Wick um just phenomenal phenomenal they have been on a Non-Stop uh rocket ship to the Moon over the last few years and it's been just a thrill to watch last night was so fun so thanks
047to everybody you know who helped give them the Champions welcome that they deserved um anything new different okay with that I need a motion to close the meeting second any discussion all in favor I thank you for joining [Music] do