CorpusRecord 13490

MCPS Joint Work Session 02/04/2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Board Tube
Date
2025-02-05
Location
Mathews County, VA
Material
Transcript
Extent
11,465 words · about 64 min
Collected
2026-06-04

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e The Joint budget work session it with the school board and the Board of Supervisors this afternoon 4:00 February 4th 2025 would everybody please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance I pledge aliance to flag un States Amer stands na god indis with liberty and justice for all [Music] thank you may we now have roll call please Miss Morgan for the school board mrgan present Mr I'm here M here M here Dr G present yes could you do a roll call for us this Mr Jones here Mr Wallace here M Phillips here Mr Bowen here Mr DS here thank you wonderful we'll move right into number item number two Dr Daniels uh our division superintendent Brief Review of the 2025 2026 draft Matthews County Public Schools operating budget right there thank you everyone um

002many of these slides at the the end of the are I oober okay all right so I'll um I'll go into a get this fired up hang that chair hang all right what's what's listed on the screen is a difference from fy2 to what is what we're currently operating under fy2 and then what we are anticipating and budgeting for FY 26 so other local other local includes our um when we're renting out facilities or other income from say the sale of old cars things along those lines but it's not typically um regularly budgeted um but we um it's it's not um established predictable uh Revenue resources but we have an idea year to year of what that typically is State funding we're anticipating a decline of about $170,000 for next year based on um projections

003in the governor's budget also due to again declining enrollment um Federal funding we're budgeting to be roughly stable um this budget is looking at local operating uh an additional ask of about $290,000 um that subtotal um looking at FY 25 to FY 26 is a roughly an increase of about $98,000 Thrifty spot School food textbook and uh Matthews Community Foundation kind of round out some of the other um Revenue sources in terms of expenditures going through the expenditures briefly um we're looking at um a decline for um Thrifty spot really what that has to do with some of our staffing models at Thrifty spot um operating um our instructional operating line item um going up about $550,000 $549,000 the bulk of that is related to what is project and I'll hit some highlights in terms

004of where the increases are coming from but the bulk of that difference in instruction comes from a projection of a 4% um plus a step salary increase for current staff um the admin attendance in health um is expected to see a decline of about $1,000 we're anticipating a need for in increasing the transportation line item to about $445,000 that's going to be from parts and uh we're kind of budgeting for fuel but primarily um Parts the operations in maintenance um has a decline of $544,000 that's related to the shift of maintenance and operation I've got another slide see the face I've got another slide that will kind of break out the different um line items and things along those lines um I'm anticipating we probably want to go ahead and jump to jump to that

005slide um so that's a decline of about 34% okay so overall budget highlights yes sir Mr walls yes sir okay and we'll post this um um this is a I've have two new slides on this so this will be posted we'll send a new version put that on board docs a little bit later I'll share that with Miss Morgan to post um this um slide here is already on board docs but the next two slides I added today anticipating questions about the maintenance part do you want questions during or you want us to hold them to the end um I think this is a work session so we can go through some of that some of my notes may be over there so I may be crisscrossing um but I can um answer questions as

006we go along if reference okay reference the um under the instruction the 549 and that would oh I was already on okay thank you reference to 549 239 that was the 4% raise proposed and then this one step increase right so just clarification in terms of the um School Division has a the salary scale each step on that scale is 1% so we're proposing everybody is moving um forward on that step and then it's increased the entire scale by 4% okay so how much are you um estimating 1% cost that's in my NES I can I can share kind of a 1% a 3% and a 5% what that what that looks actually I think it's in the slide and it's a it's in a future slide so I'm a little premature thank you it's

007okay it's okay that's all I had right now thank so that increase of 5.05% is that just teachers does that include everybody cafeteria custodians or so the salary increase is um in the projected budget is across the board it is for all the existing staff employed by the division currently okay so that's from bus drivers ta um up to assistant superintendent so another question I I see the the numbers just put up is 129 so last year it was 142 for 1% so we've declined about 20 20 positions from last year to this year so that's that's going to be some of that does your budget assume the same number of people as you have this year so what we have budgeted is with the existing staff that we have right now what we're going

008to do as we move through the spring is where we have opportunities to um consolidate not necessar neily fill positions we're going to look to not fill those positions and so that then is going to shrink the overall percent increase cost but then also um the overall kind of payroll costs as well excuse me Mr doson did you have a question yeah in the event that there's an overrun on the money that we gave to the county to take care of the mainten since we combined it who's going to fill that if we run out in that area I think there's so here's if we want to accelerate a little bit to um accounts related to maintenance so this is what based on our conversations with theou what we are then pulling out not budgeting

009for with regards to maintenance and the costs associated with those um those line items so what we then need to keep related to maintenance um based on our understanding with the mou is going to I think some of the confusion exists because our custodial staff things that we do for custodial services and we're still going to need to have something figure out a solution for grounds um those are the line items that we still hold are planning to hold then um with regards to some of the maintenance line items now if we want to have continued conversations on what thatou looks like what goes over what stays what um what we need to be responsible for what the county is thinking that they would be responsible for in terms of this merger um but we

010do have some um monies for some maintenance costs but the bulk of the maintenance would really come from after the merger from the county side okay cuz last year we were we were over on a couple of those line items in the budget that's why I was concerned about about that so you you have a part-time full-time groundskeeper proposed proposed okay that's proposed yes and so part of that conversation is I need a spot either for a person or a spot then for Contracting with a vendor um to handle our lawn and maintenance and going into the mou a little bit it's right now our maintenance staff covers some of the lawn care um process during the summer no not I don't not to not to La care so we discussed it but we decided

011we didn't have the Personnel for there I think we we talked about having that as a Mrs Wilson correct me if I'm wrong sort of phase two not taking that on in this first adjustment but looking at it in the future yeah it's not included in this right so some again part of the maintenance stuff is we still have um Security Contracts for our door systems Fire Systems um updates on camera systems things along those lines that fall under that maintenance budget that wouldn't necessarily then slide over to the county so what of the so I'm correct me if I'm I'm wrong so the the line item was was it 1.7 in the current budget and I know all of this is included there's variety of areas areas that are included in that I'd have

012to go back and look I don't know that number I don't have that one number in my well there's lots of numbers I don't have in my head so um this breaks down what's paid for out of that line item is that yes am I understanding this correct so is there anything else in this list that's proposed is not currently paid not currently in this current budget so what these two slides lay out is of the existing maintenance what this is what remains under the proposed School Board maintenance category area the previous slide is what used to be part of our maintenance budgeting process and what we are then intending to remain with the county okay and that comes to the $544,000 okay I knew as we had had some conversation I knew there was

013confusion some questions about the number that we were proposing was lower than I think what was um anticipated and so um having some clarity about okay here are these specific accounts that we're talking about moving over um remaining with the county side versus what we based on our conversations on theou what would remain with the school Division and what we would need to continue to budget for with the school division so these all of these with the exception of the I hate the harp on this I'm just making sure I understand it right all of these that you have listed here which is what the county would take over the next slide which is what would stay with the school system correct all of those are current except for the building and grounds all those

014are currently paid for out of that 1.7 or whatever that dollar figure is okay correct and there and there's nothing else that's proposed in these the only thing that's proposed in this is the groundskeeper salary benefits that's that's the new piece I'd have to go back and look at individual line items and see if we based on looking at his hisorical budget pieces if we needed to bump something more for say if we needed we knew our phone system contract was going to go up or we know some various repair parts or supplies maybe going up stuff like that thank you okay excuse me um yes ma'am so I'm looking at um your final adopted plan I guess was in it's I think this F final adopted for 2025 uh and it was I guess

015I would add the maintenance manager and the Building Services together to come up with what it's costing you right now so that's about a million little over a million3 million million 350 say yeah but it's got 82,000 up above it too for the maintenance management so of that 1 1.32 um so we're looking at 500 plus thousand coming to the county and 800 staying with the schools well go to the final to their final line I mean their final budget look at your comparison all you got to do is just take their final budget number and reduce it by the amount of what we're taking yeah okay so or or you added back into it and it tell you incre well I gu yeah yeah um so but but that's the in got the salary

016increases and everything I'm just looking at them maintenance situation [Music] um I guess I'm looking at the right piece of paper I'm looking at a piece of paper I got earlier that I printed off um I'll show it to you are there any um salaries that are the the funding that's currently with the school system being moved over to the county for the those two those two positions that's included in the 544 correct so um two salaries um okay basically um energy costs um service contracts um things along those lines I need a verification from heat you paid that like that from [Music] out it should be relatively easy I mean we sent all of those to um Schneider so I can go back and pull some the emails that we sent to like to

017see the actual your mic's on you want the Bills or the yeah what I mean if I mean do you want like the receipt is that what I'm yeah copies of the receipts if you give them to me or either population of if so you I assume you get the Heat and oil from the same place right mhm yeah so we can calculate what the heating oil is if it's on the same buend the power we know that comes from uh Dominion Virginia Power the sewage that line item is fixed and I would assume that you buy your propane from the same people what do you mean nobody buying oil and gas and all that through W well what I'm saying is I just said through the say people what I'm saying is is they

018will have an account running account of of an annual cost that's what I'm looking for the actual annual cost which you actually paid them I'd like to see it how it Compares up to that chart so for FY 24 Dominion our Dominion power bill for all of FY 24 was $328,000 69 and I can print out a report for you Mr James but just just appreciate Ren was $247,800 heating oil up a is 75,000 we got a big deficit don't we we got a big deficit right there so because so if if rooten oil was $247,000 I think that's under that's under the vehicle maintenance side so that may be for the I have is that bus garage yes the hea oil and the gasoline diesel is all combined under that water line does it

019come does your does your gasoline come from come from root noil yes okay so I need that broke out what you that up there says heat no so if I get what you PID heat no what you pay Dominion power and what your sewage bill is and what your protan build is I appreciate that heat and oil and diesel fuel is the same thing one of them's died one of them's not well can't put D fuel in the school buses I know a lot of people that do but right well I'm just saying Mr James we can we'll we'll break that out I appreciate you sure question sure of course this is trying to see this from here and and add it up here so just making sure I understand the list on that that's

020up there right now is those the monies that are listed listed there or what the county will be keeping to cover the maintenance sections correct okay so unless I added it wrong that adds up to 847 how do we get the difference between 847 and 544 it's the addition subtraction is throughout our entire budget so it's taking the entire maintenance budget and it's the additions and subtractions okay so then everything on this list is not coming over is that right everything on there will be coming over okay so in terms of what's I'm miscommunicating so what is actually staying with the county is closer to you're saying 800 in terms of the sum total of those line items is actually what is then going to be remaining yes okay so the 544 is a Delta

021between what is moving over and that amount is about 8 something and then increases other line items staying okay so that's a miscommunication on my part does that make sense probably not say it again okay I mean I'm looking at your previous a million 3 something and 800,000 stays with you and 500,000 goes to the those numbers are probably inverted I think where I you I think I miscommunicated that b but what I'm saying is correct am I not 500,000 for the County comes to the county 800,000 stays with the schools that doesn't equate to that figure up there that number is closer to the 800,000 that will stay with the county that's stay with the county that's my whole point numers there on lining up to five something so if you take all of

022those and line them up it should be let's see that's 400,000 five roughly we up in8 $800,000 Mark that me put a calculator to yeah I was going off of the 544 in in the other line item as a summary for what then was saying with the with the county and that's that's an inaccuracy on my part that's that's a miscommunication on my part okay thank you sure miss Phillips are you good yeah maybe move on okay um I think I kind of went over um skipped over a couple slides to get to the maintenance piece um but in terms of again some some of the budget highlights so this is based off a projected enrollment of 725 students So currently we're about 760 students so we're budgeting based on 725 looking at our senior

023class and what our kindergarten and first grade class sizes have been we're anticipating a drop off of about 25 um students give or take um so we went ahead and budgeted at 725 um it this budget proposal includes the 4% plus a step it also um absorbs anticipated health insurance increases so right now we're budgeting about an 8% increase in health insurance that may be um that may be short of what um the health insurance increases may come back we don't have anything official yet on insurance estimates um rumors have double digit increases kind of around the region so we're still waiting for um what that what that number is going to look like yes sir the teachers that are resigning at the end of the year are they going to be teachers we have

024to rep place or you going to write some of them off or what the case is we're going to have to look at class sizes enrollment sizes um what services those teachers are providing and maybe we absorb some positions and um create different positions in place we may be able to absorb several positions I think it just depends on where those vacancies occur um we have some tentative uh we know a couple people who are retiring U but we won't know really until closer to the spring who exactly is retiring who may be relocating um who may um just excuse me decide that they're um going to work in another division so but this budget in terms of planning purposes um is based off every position being filled returning next year so My Hope Is

025then that we'll be able to find some um savings so I'm assuming you got it you got everything funded now in your proposal so at the end of spring and then once you determine if you have you know can I absorb one here can I absorb one there all of those then I'm assuming that would reduce the request to the county that your bottom line would Reduce by that amount correct okay thank you correct and you've added one position for Rounds maintenance correct so the additional positions factored into this are a secondary reading specialist a teacher/ athletic trainer a combo position a CTE teacher and that custodial grounds position that we've talked about so the secondary reading specialist position is related to the Virginia literacy act being expanded um into grades six seven and 8

026so we're anticipating that um that requirement coming down from the state will it come with additional funding probably not um but we're anticipating that coming um we've historically have contracted with a company to provide an athletic trainer uh for our practices and um games um that that individual left in the early fall we have not been able the contractor has not been able to fill that position as we talk with with other school divisions um how do they fill that position typically it's a position where they teach two classes or some some classes in the afternoon and then they remain um in the afternoon for athletic training purposes um again as part of our strategic plan and having conversations about CTE programs um we've reduced the CTE program over the years uh there's a desire

027to provide um greater opportunities for CTE classes at the middle school on high school levels um so this right now isn't um specifically designed for one building or the other um but just to increase the number of CTE positions in in the division and then the custodial kind of grounds position so what we're looking at in that scenario is basically a grounds person uh when when the grass is growing and then in the off months a custodial position to kind of fill in um right now we're we're at the bare minimum of custodian and finding substitute custodians is pretty impossible so having flexibility in our custodial staff to clean the buildings at night things along those lines um again other highlights salary increase to the existing scale what those numbers are projected to look like

028um kind of an overview again that's a Mis type on my part I'll go back and correct that number um in terms of the maintenance consolidation what that looks like so the 56 the 565 the 565 is 4 + 1 4% plus the correct yes yes um the next couple slides or are just kind of um crib notes on what goes into each object category um so as you're going through um the the print out from our finance software this is kind of an easy way to go in and look at okay what are the things that go into each of those category areas um again these are basically review slides from October the local Composite Index what goes into calculating the local Composite Index how all that's calculated what are current go yes sir

029I'm sorry I just don't want to forget later can I get you to back up to that 1% and 5% apologize that's okay so the the 1% is 129 and if I remember right you had said that they the step increased pretty much averages to the same it it's going to go up a little bit more so are you talking going from 1% to 3% or are you talking on our salary scale well the the reason I'm asking is when I times I just went ahead quickly times 129 Time 5 and it comes up to 645 which is about what 880,000 more so as you get into vrs benefits and hybrid one the different hybrid versions and so the percentage and I'm going to have to lean on my finance folks in terms of the

030calculation for um all the benefit costs but straight salary will be one thing but then the benefits and fight Social Security and vrs um numbers fluctuate that so it's not going to be a clean each percent is exactly exactly the same okay so the 565 is without benefits or with the benefits that's that includes that's everything isn't it that's soups and nuts so that's retirement benefits Etc okay yeah that includes all the healthcare everything 5% 565 9868 a is a 5% in increase and the and the associated cost of vrs cost yeah I understand I got you because the healthc care cost would be the same so that's going to Flatline across kind of a historical review of local Composite Index so from the 2018 um 2020 bium where we we're at 5060 um to

031where we are in this current bium is 5904 again roughly that equates to about a 59 the the thinking is Matthews County would be responsible for approximately 59% of the costs of um funding the School Division um I'm pretty sure Matthews county is above that 59% we went over this in October but this is class sizes um basically kind of um a snapshot of where we were in the fall with regards to what the um class sizes or average class size um at our school buildings is currently so we range from AOW of about 14 and a half we we don't have half kids but so about 15 kids um per class um in kindergarten um to about a high of about 20 students per class that's again that's slightly different than when you look

032on the the State website and it talks about student teacher ratios the student teacher ratio looks at all the kids who are enrolled and then every licensed position in that school this is looking at the number of kids in desks at say first Bell or at the high school it's a little bit different because you're moving um kids around but it's like what if you were to walk into any class that is occurring at that time that's basically what you would expect to see so moving forward to our positions what we will then look at is okay where can we um shrink positions where can we um afford to grow in class size I'm kind of a review of where we are in terms of um homeschool instruction and um religious exemption so we remained

033this year so for the um I don't know why I don't I need to update that slide but we're about we're a little bit less than um the 2223 school year so we're still at around the 140 145 Mark um somewhere in that in that range some staffing overviews comparison of last year in the fall and this school year in the fall in terms of the number of full-time and part-time staff um last year to this year Food Services popped up yeah we were running short staff um last year in terms of food services and again so some of that's um it's full-time and part-time so I think we've added part-time positions and i' have to think too I think we carry the Meals on Wheels payroll in our budget so I'm not sure I'm

034kind of looking for it does this include meals on Wheel Staffing yes yes it do [Music] okay so seven so what we've done so in order to do that um we've got several we've got some long-term Subs in position that's typically why our substitute teacher um budget um is goes over um some teachers at the high school are have picked up extra teaching assignments so they're receiving a supplement for um losing basically a planning period to fill some of those some of those vacancies for Grand a year salary comparison that I did in the fall of 23 showing where we were in the fall of 23 um kind of keeping an eye on it's kind of hard to see on this display but the numbers in red show the difference from where our salary scale

035was to some of our neighboring School divisions um so um looking at where we stand this year um we've were able to enlarge and dramatic support from the supervisors working to um provide additional salary increase last year for staff Clos closed the Gap um but looking at kind of where where we are this year conversations with superintendent it's a little um it's a little bit like poker in terms of they'll um Everybody kind of says one number about what they're projecting in their budget for for salary increases U but nobody really is completely on and also too they don't know so it's going to depend on at this time of year nobody knows what general assembly budgets are going to be and local budget funding is going to be most of the conversation is around

0363% with other school divisions te teachers who were approaching 30 years uh experience what are you seeing with them are they staying with Matthews in teaching are they leaving for other school systems I think of um I think it I would I would want to go back and look at the actual exit surveys because every teacher is asked to fill out an exit survey when they retire or when they leave so I would want to go back and look at the um actual survey data um I don't get the sense that a lot of our teachers who have been with with us for a long period of time are leaving in year 27 to go to another locality to finish those three years does it happen it does um and I think a lot of

037folks at that 20year Mark are tempted to begin looking at okay I'm coming up on the last 10 years before I can retire where do I want to go work for these last several years to boost my vrs retirement um so I think it it depends on on an individual um but without I don't know that I've got the hard numbers to say and I'm I like to come back to the numbers to say okay last year we had three teachers who at this point left in year 27 and went um for greener pastures I know we did have some teachers who left our division for salary incentives um to go to go work in other divisions with higher income potential they weren't necessarily though off the top of my head they weren't necessarily at

038that year 25 and Beyond Mark I'm not familiar with the hybrid retirement but the H am I correct in assuming the hybrid there's not an incentive to move as you get your 20 30 plus years under under the hybrid retirement system I'm not an expert on the the plan one the hybrid in in in plan two particular I'd have to ask some questions of the folks in HR just I don't know I know that there what we have to pay is different and the benefits they receive are slightly different um and there's a pay in option um but on the details I don't know those details well enough I'll add that to my study of boilers it would appear to me that as looking at the number the budget numbers compared to West Point middle

039sex and Gloucester three proximity counties let's just say I'm looking at we're about $7,000 late on a 30-year position from being right dead in the middle then as you walk it on back you can do the math if you talk to these parents out here they concern MO is with who's teaching the class and the level of Education that's coming out of the school system and it's like anything else I'm a I'm a proponent of paying top dollar for top people I would be willing to make that investment that would have to be some policy changes made me personally would be willing to make that investment okay I'm just going to tell you I put five of them through Matthews County schools at a time that they were impeccable I mean people were clamoring to

040come here people were moving into Matthews County because we didn't have a lot of the um political challenges that we've had in the past you know that we didn't have those then you look at West Point and you look at over the years have they've been able to maintain these people in those positions and they achieve accreditation they're well sought after their whole all of their programs are Top Notch and I get it because they got a plant there they have the they have their money my opinion is is we're not we don't have at many students here we're going down to 725 students we what I'd like to see is on the teacher salary we close that Gap to be more competitive that's what I'd like to see and that has to come that's

041an ear Mark in my book if you want to get them here and you want to be competitive we got to be better than the next guy out there we do okay and you offer those incentives a butter pay there's nothing not to like about Matthews County wants to come here then I think once we get it back to where maybe it used to be you may see some of the home schoolers start to come back you may see some kids starting to move into the county you may have some kids that want to come come away from the other localities but the only thing is we're never going to know unless we try so one of the discussion points that we've had is looking at the actual scale itself and so instead of each

042each step being 1% looking at projections of can we make each step 1 point to 5% to generally look to close that Gap over the year so year to year the increase is a little greater and it's targeting teachers over over the years to close in that Gap so I did some rough numbers to look and we need some work on our entire scale system um but at a I believe at a 1.25 at 30 years we close that to I think it's about U between us and Gloucester um I think it was about a three or $4,000 difference at at that point um and again I I need somebody with some expertise to come in and really look at salary scales and um labor laws and all those kinds of things to kind of

043provide some oversight but just projecting it out and having a look at it that's that's one way it may not be the policy piece that you're thinking about but that's one way in terms of a systematic way to show and invest in the education the teachers in the classrooms to close that that gap between where Matthews currently sits and some of our neighboring School divisions well my point is is the resources need to go directly to that situation and we have as a board are looking at this maintenance issue that we've had on the schools and we we we looking at a lot of different way ways because it's going to have to be improved we got to update systems in the schools and things of that nature and we're willing my opinion is you

044got to put that on this sideb burner over here because it's gone so long without any attention is what's brought us to to this level but at this point I you know I look at bringing these teachers in my opinion is there only so many teachers you got from looking at your staff well and okay so if you do it relatively to what you're paying those teachers specifically that's not a whole lot of money there okay it's not it's not a whole lot of money that's what I'm talking about I say make Matthews great again when a school system that's the way I look at it and way you going to get them here is you going to pay them you pay them they'll come here okay if you pay if you got a better

045pay you mean to tell me somebody sitting over there in Gloucester is not going to make it trip over here okay they will they'll make it trip over if they getting better pay I'm sit down and we can continue the conversation that's the last that's the last slide that I have yeah same can can we get emailed updated copies of the slides sure this morning can you remind me to do that tomorrow okay last you finished at [Applause] that yes ma'am and Tak at the maintenance side Miss Phillips Miss Phillips can you turn your oh I'm sorry thank you I'm sorry thank you um so I was just looking at the 17.2 million 17.7 million and you're now going to 18.0 um and you have transferred the maintenance of the schools to to the county

046uh and that was about half a million dollars so I've been and looking through this I'm just wondering um I see occasionally on the salaries instead of a 5% I see other in like 7% or 8% and I don't I I I'm not sure why but I see that in some of these places may be just tweaking but nevertheless I'm wondering about about that can you give me an example of what salary that you're taking well I'll just look at Building Services real quick um your salaries were are 8 8.5% increase that one and then the office of the principal that's another one that's I think we need to look so I can clarify that so that comes from um the staffing change in that situation so we went from a principal overseeing two buildings

047and two assistant so if you look there's a reduction of the assistant principal in that line yeah so we've removed that assistant principal position and we replaced that with a principal position but would that have been reflected in your prior year numbers that was done after the that was after the budget so this number I'm looking at is not your actual numbers actual numbers actual where did you finish last year that's where we finished the last year we moved we just absorbed we did it off budget so once the budget is set in the computer computer system uh then we have to move money right and so to accurately reflect that that's in in this FY 26 proposed it's then straightened out where it's we have three principles and two assistant principles across the division

048that's one of my frustrations with all of these budgets is I want to know where you finished last year where did you finish not where did you bud budget but where did you finish and that's but but but the changes came July 1st so it wouldn't have shown up in last year's budget what you're talking about well it it would I mean your actual your your actual numbers would reflect it because it was done last year right we made the change this July right July 24th should be in the current local year yeah well okay she's looking she's asking correct me if I'm wrong s she for last year's budget finishing numbers for the collective year for that budget year so FY 24 yeah where did we finish I think that's that's what that's the

049number we looking for CU we looking for the increase Because by the time you take your maintenance money out okay you show in two M negative $275,000 but you take that $800,000 out of that okay that's an increase of almost 600,000 I I don't think they took it I don't know well that's what I'm TR but according to the numbers we got a yeah right um I'll have to I don't have the hard copy of the end of the year FY 24 well yeah I think but you when I said you finish at 17722 you really didn't finish at 17 7.22 last year that was a different number where you actually came in the dollars you spent now I believe that's exactly that is right the budg in budos so this doesn't have fy4 numbers

050yeah this is the current budget to doesn't have got to do a comparison between the budget STA and what you had the year before not budget but more you no no no what I'm saying is you take where finished there's no fy4 Mig a differential that we can pull that and email it to you all in other words am I just comp are we just comparing budget to budget that's theint the information that you have right now is to budget so if you have a bad budget then I know you change for Appropriations and so forth but actuals actuals way you ended up is is really important when you're looking at budgets I think I what you plan to spend and then what you actually spent you need to know that and I'm not to

051valuate your budget I've always said a bad budget doesn't mean you don't do the right things but we need to have actuals why you finished how much did you really spend on any topic and I want it's you may be close when do we get one year we turn what 3,00 300,000 back and then we you gave it back to us when we invested yeah I mean I can go back and look at various board dos and but there's a finished number yeah the problem with the finished number is you got to wait 3 months to find out what it is six it's six I know it's tough we're we're going through the same thing and it's my frustration yeah so really I mean we can look at the expected what the upcoming budget is

052but comparon to actually spent 5 10 minute break is there any way well theoretically I use the word theoretically those numbers should be on that column here yeah and that's theoretically that's theoretic that's the and that's that's what I was hoping I was looking atend money you Mrs Hodes my question is to the point that they're bringing up is our system Financial system able to pull the actual expenditures versus the budgeted or it's not able to do that and put it on one spreadsheet you know what I'm asking the question that they're asking is are there should be a printouts from that we can pull some f end of the year FY 24 um print out that shows each of the line items and this is are we over you know 5% are we you

053know under 10% etc etc for each of those category areas I mean we can do that pull it from what June June 30 or whatever 24 it should be your June 30 report right and then you're going to get into some the audit and then the Auditors are going to move well it should be after your Auditors have moved all their numbers well then that's we're going to have to then pull the audit report and that's probably we I don't think we got the audit until um oh I know December we were six months into the year I had to take May last May report is that what the numbers I worked with and what we went over on and what have you and everything that's what numbers I was using because I never see

054anything that shows the uh the end of that year with everything in because I know some of that stuff takes three months to catch up yeah and even the May number would be helpful but and I I think I could pull that too but I I I was just thinking and I was looking at actuals but I'm not that's what I thought that 17.7 actually and and to your point I know you came pretty close to the total you were off but it still doesn't give you by line item so therefore you can't really understand where buy a line item when you're budgeting if you're right or wrong because I know that you had some unexpected things this year like I saw some big overages in the U maintenance side in fact big ones yeah

055big ones in the maintenance side so is that the fact that you came out okay at the bottom line doesn't mean that that's going to be urr would you be able if we took a pause would you be able to pull that can you tickle the keyboard and able to get that to happen or do we need to email that at a later time okay so question um what is the total salary with benefits for the entire school system I mean you you I would I would think you would have to know that in order to come up to the 1% um from my perspective what we look at is divided by admin instruction unfortunately it's you know it's by that band um started and it's so I I cuz I took the reports and

056I just put the it's like 10 11 million it's the by the time you put everything in it and that maybe more it's probably close to 67% of the budget I'm assuming could you get I don't have to have that tonight could you just get that the total salary with total compensation with Benefits was it about 24 Grand I'd like it same cop but instructional instructural only instructural salaries only all right defined instruction those are different things teachers okay so because in our category system in terms of instruction I'm that's going to include um like principles assistant principles Tas that's going to be in that in that instruction category in our budgeting system that's I'm not trying to be understand that's what your budgeting system is set up but I don't like that well it's

057also the state accounting system the way that's set up right you know because let let me tell you a lot of your decisions I just my decisions made is is what the Gap level is between the administration and the teaches okay you understand it's too many chiefs not enough Indians okay so we need to look at that I I'd like to know what that Gap is and I mean there there should be you have so many teachers right and you could take an average salary from that of what you're paying out I mean that'd be good enough enough for me but I just that would help me greatly to kind of understand what your structure is okay as that that's the best way for me to to put it is with structure sure happy to

058share I have a question I can't figure out if this is on or off it's on okay um on the very last page of your of the packet that you have what p is at the top was it at at the very last page good in the packet which say p not not the back page but the page before that at the very bottom there's a number 51500 Appropriations operations that's the money that the county gives to the school transfers to the school M and if you look at it for this year it's going up $236,400 even though they're supposedly giving back yeah so I yeah I don't that doesn't make any sense well I I just I guess I need clarification for that number where that number is coming from out I think that's

059the overall County's contribution to the school division so it's in a regular operating fund so it's not operations in the sense of it's where the utilities and Etc so that that increase includes the additional increase of the 5% and these additional Staffing positions even though the $800 odd th000 is anticipated to remain with the the county for maintenance and the energy costs if you will the increase is right now based off of 5% salary increase additional staff positions and not absorbing any staff currently that's that's where that that Delta comes in so that's a big opportunity I guess or some opportunity so if if if we weren't doing the maintenance then this number would be would be larger 1.2 million or 1.1 million we would add $847,000 to that number that's right yeah I have

060a question u u I have a question so I heard you say earlier that the two current positions in your all's maintenance department the county will absorb them come July I'm looking here under building and grounds where you were over 38% that's the reason why you still why you want to employee a a full-time building grounds person is is that am I seeing that correctly I'm trying to find where you on page um page five down under um 64300 ground um you appropriated 7500 apparently You' spent 30, 602 so is that why you're requesting a building and grounds person cu is so much we're talking 64 3 300 yes sir I'm just making sure that I'm responding to about the increase here it's this all this yes so the increase it would be that that

061position but that's but that 30,000 is not what he spent no that's just what he proposing well no that's is what you spent last year right so we still contract with we do have to contract with outside vendors for some like Lawn Care stuff spraying weeding um we allocate money to the schools for mulch purchases things along those lines so let's get straight on these columns that column that might that you're talking about which is the third the middle column which is called Appropriations for pre-year appropriation is that it well where I'm looking yeah uh salar ground Services right so you're looking at so but you're basing it on 30,000 right that's what that's what you all you all spent correct so last year we budgeted $7,500 so and so as part of the projection

062going forward it's an additional 30,000 for that position and then below that the 22341 is the FICA and then budgeting for health insurance for that position right so that's so we're moving from what was budgeted last year at about 22,000 $23,000 to what we're budgeting for this year at about 70 which is yeah the the Delta is basically in that that position which isn't necessarily what you spend it's just what you plan to spend in the next year cor it's not we don't have that so question just right you're requesting the 5% increase a grounds building and grounds position be it part-time or full-time well custodian grounds yes custodian grounds and a teacher SL trainer correct is is there anything else I'm missing reading specialist a CTE teacher in the Middle School secondary reading specialist

063okay thank you some extra positions can you tell me what um under your operating frund um category code 3000 purchase services page going up 52 Point 52% page huh what page you have there page one p number one I'm sorry page one code 3000 under operating fund says purchase Services is going up 52% purchased Services seems to be under it's just about every category I what he talking about under operating the first one yeah under operating fund you created a cheat sheet for that yeah I think um I'll have to go back and look for sure but I think we're anticipating additional cost for regional special education programs and so we're anticipating um the tuition per seat increasing so we have to contract out for certain programs certain staff members and so that I believe

064without looking at my notes but I think that is related to the increased costs of those seats and anticipating needing more seats would have decline in enrollment this some that out there this one here and other and on page two the top that those salaries popped up 11% as opposed to five or five plus perc I'm sure there's some reasons for it but when I see that it just makes me wonder then you have some are below 5% social worker services this this budget this year they've moved a lot of stuff like shuffled the cards and mooved here moved here moved here and that's I believe is based on what state of Virginia says how to do things cuz I I had some of the same problems why ain't stuff where it was last year

065yeah so it changes every year Virginia changes the way they want it put on on the report am I right in some in some cases yes um Okay so Miss Miss Phillips I'm going back to your to your question so School social worker Services um so that category area is moving that position from 10 month to 11 month so that's why it's a larger increase [Applause] ah and is that just needed yeah just there's a lot of um Court hearings and intervention work that occurs over those months and so by going to 11 months we can Flex Flex th that those additional days over the two months so they wouldn't necessarily just stop in June but that's an additional days um of work that we can um provide I think there's a lot more of

066that than there ever was from what my meetings I missed the Monday right that's a lot I know so I want to make a statement here I'm on the very back page which is marked page two I'm just looking at the grand total number uh 18281 for adopted budget 2025 and then uh 2026 1806 so what you representing to us is a 1 and a half% decrease in what you're asking but we're getting ready if I understood the the U conversation we're getting ready to inherit almost a million dollars worth of um I mean I just we're going to take over the maintenance I I absolutely would expect more than a 1 and a half% decrease in your all's budget in light of the fact that enrollments gone down well I'll be honest to to

067clarify I think this is actually saying a 1.6 increase from FY in let me make sure that I'm that I'm talking on the same okay I'm looking at the wrong page excuse me yeah okay my my apologies I'm I was looking at a different page $275,000 decrease is what it's showing one and half% you got take away with the uh maintenance 800 something code do the math between those two and then add all the rest of it up it's uh so Mrs Hodes please but again um I think as uh Dr Daniel pointed out there are four new positions that we've asked for CTE um reading specialist um athletic trainer pardon athletic trainer yeah yeah athletic Trader and there's a fourth one so so I'm I'm sure in part that that's reflecting those four four

068additional positions four positions and a 5% increase right so when I look at this the concern that I have is well first you know we want I think all of us collectively on both sides everybody sitting up here wants to support our the teachers and the staff all of the staff across Ross the board we want the pay to be competitive and we want the services that they provide to the students is critical and we want it to be the best as possible but when I sit here and look at this I mean it's a $236,000 increase request we're going to keep $847,000 on our side and I venture to say that that 847 th000 won't come close to what it's going to take to maintain the maintenance appropriately so we're also looking at a

069$7 million energy project I don't know how much it's going to cost to fix the pipe all the way down the hallway so let's just say another million or a million and a half with that and that just gets us to I don't even know what else Mr till is back there that can tell us but um how much more are we going to have to spend to get us to this to the point to where we're at the decision of how to move forward with one school two schools or three schools so you know we're looking at what's it n on one roof $9 million $8 million um so I'm I'm just I'm having a difficult time swallowing this a little bit um so I just wanted to say that thank you Dr Daniel

070could you talk about the two RFP proposals not RFP but just and see if that dovetails into this conversation a little bit I mean in terms of consolidation so when we all had we had a joint meeting at I don't know if it's October November on a Saturday kind of talked about where we wanted to go timeline for proposal for renovation or construction and I think the supervisors requested a formal kind of proposal from the school board and what we just discussed was having a facilities study sent out RFP solicitation formal solicitation request um for a facility study so um responding to that we um worked with Miss Wilson to develop a um a bid request pushed that out deadline was um Friday at 4:00 we've received two bids to conduct um a facility study

071uh we need to go through the evaluation of those bids and make a recommendation for those bids to um part of that is um enrollment projection population student population projection looking at facility capacity energy capacity I think we can borrow some of the Schneider Electric information to to put into that but really to then develop a um recommendation from that um the winner of that proposal um to the school board to kind of share this is what they feel like is the best decision going forward so looking at both of the proposals both are about a four month four to five month kind of study um study timeline to take a look and get get results back so um I ask how much I don't know that I'm I don't know that we should discuss

072that at at this point in time um I would be a little nervous about in terms of the I mean I guess I could give a range would that be you can give them up it's public information it's publication okay so um without going into okay so just yeah Haven evaluated so okay so um one bid was approximately $79,000 with potential add-ons for other services and the other bid was about $105,000 um I guess as I sit here I think is it on now yeah as I sit here and I think we know that building a new school is probably out of the question I mean the money is just I think I look at Lancaster's budget and it was like $40 billion I can't remember what they had in there for a new school

073but it was you know something that for Matthews would be a big stretch um and I look at our schools and I just wonder don't we know what the answer is pretty much I mean don't we know that the elementary school and High School we're going to be probably two schools I think that to to know that we have to have the health and safety assessments of our buildings and we're in the process of that and we do not have those pieces of information so I don't think we can make that determination uh at this point the concern is of course the maintenance of how much we're going to be spending pretty quick I mean and that is why um we got as we sit and plan this stuff knowing how much we we uh

074you know are we going to fix a bathroom that we're going to tear not we going to use for the the next thing that's a easy one but I mean not so easy but those are the things that I I I'm this answer is so critical to have it and know have I plan in place before we keep doing another budget and so forth so uh I don't know four to five months I guess that's better than I thought I was that's feels pretty good do either one of those proposals deal with the health and safety specifically ASB bestus mold things like that I'd have to let me dive into the details of the proposal at one glance there I think one of the proposals had an add-on for additional but I believe they're taking

075the health of the buildings into consideration when factoring in renovation cost versus new construction costs in terms of their proposal their final propos but we do not have current asbestos reporting on the Middle School say at this point we have to go through three-year um reviews so we um they come in and look at ex where the known asbest is and making sure that it is um encapsulated and is an appropriate condition um so that happens on a regular basis in state reports and like Frable or non Frable that's what they have to determine we should have those reports already we did yeah that'd be good if I could get a look at those I appreciate it yeah um Mr I I I think we all agree with what you just said the conundrum we're

076in um with you know the building primarily this building there's so much that needs to be done um and and it's going to be you know even if you do whatever you do is not going to be next year you know so how much do you need to fix and repair before and then like you said if you decide to take part of it down you decide to level the whole thing and it's exactly what I think we're all thinking in our heads and in our conversations you don't want to spend money and then have leveled two years later um and I think that that's just really where the rubber be the road how do you best move this forward and the quicker the better I don't know if you are aware though we did

077um approach Senator McDougall about the spus abatement and he has put in a million dollars in the budget amendment at the state level for just for this school to for B for uh specious abatement a good to hear so thank you um I'm having the same gutrich process that Janice Phillips just spoke about and I've been trying to find out what the cost of new school construction might be uh Snider gave us a estimate of 40 million to build a new Middle School uh according to this news article that I'm looking at the cost of Lancaster High School which is is about 400 students 8 through 12 is 63 million uh and that's gone up since they and so now they have a uh maximum guaranteed price from the contractor of million and that's 400

078students uh of course it's not always Apples to Apples cuz I think they're building a new athletic center and and a new Auditorium uh but just the $4 million figure which I don't think we could build anything for in any Consolidated School for that amount of money um that's a tax increase of what about 14% 14 cents Davenport said something about 16 16 when I think it's I think it's more than that 16 okay so I think it's to 20% I calcul excuse me from us going to current 56 Cent to 81 Cent to cover all these cost okay so you know I know I was early on talking about maybe we should look at a new school and if we were to come back and have some catastrophic report that we can't use our

079current schools because of mold or anything else uh at that point we actually have no choice but to bite that bullet but if we're looking at spending over $7 million just to begin to fix some of the problems and if we go down that road and start fixing some of those problems I think that's and then we decide two or three years later well we we really want to build a new school I don't know that we can I don't think that's a certainly not a wise decision sure is and that's the problem I'm having I just I feel like we're going to have to make a decision within the next probably three months with Snider and this 78 million and maybe more than that um and I don't do you all have and maybe

080right now it's not the day to talk about it but I was hoping to get just a maybe a gut feeling from the school board as to whether you really think we need a k through 12 school and build a whole new school or can we do a good job for our students maybe with two schools and if we have to build a new Wing or something I don't know I don't know what the answer is but I feel like if if we wait a year to get that result from our consultants and we've in the process spent 7 million and they say you you really should have built a new school I mean I'd hate to I would just hate to be in that position at the November 9th meeting when we were all

081talking about this we put a due date from the school board of kind of giving the recommendation of how many school what number School Division by December of 2025 it sounds to me that the Schneider report of the urgency with which to act upon that is kind of driving your concern you need to get back to them sooner than later so is that something that need is going to drive the process is the Schneider report driving our determination of how many schools in the division or I mean in my opinion without knowing everything about the health of specifically this building on not willing to make that decision without knowing more about this building first how fast can we know more about this building that would be my question and hopefully that that would uh be

082able to timeline match with Schneider's requirements maybe we can act faster than we thought but these things seem to be taking an insurmountable amount of time so to inform us on this decision members do you have any comments on this well you got a you got a high school that was built in the mid1 1930s mhm you got this school which was built in the late 50s and you got the other school was built around 2000 the more money I think you put in the high school and this school you just might as well dig a big hole and throw it in the other school you can I would fix the problem in the other school but in the long run it would be better to build a I still say three schools Under One

083Roof don't go out go up it's cheaper okay why why schools cost more money is because they always spread out instead of go up you go up it's cheaper and go up where I think is the question second second third floor right but on what bit of land and um do we would County own that piece of land over by a high school but we would need an engineering firm an Architecture Firm to do an assessment how much do does that assessment run Dr Daniel to find out if that's possible I can I say something real quick about going up you go up past two two stories now we're talking about engineered piles to support because of the the souls that we have in this area so now you're going to take that same $75

084million school and you might as well put another $25 million on it okay because because if they have to drive the piles down to the Bedrock you don't know how deep you got to go you go up at third store and I agree under any other circumstances if you were on red clay up Northern Virginia something like that I could see that the other the other problem that it poses is that when you have a third story on a school and you don't have a fire department or a ladder truck to support it okay to safely evacuate people or get the fire department in this is not an easy subject to talk about it's very hard we're all trying to Pace it but I think I can help you are is the Thomas Hunter School

085leaking from the roof anywhere that you know of a little bit little bit just just a general overview you know is it leaking around the penetrations like we got it the you know does it need some up yes yes need some no thank you that's the point I'm getting to so when you go in so now we're talking about classrooms and we're talking about bathrooms right we're limited to 725 students how many students would be in the time of su school okay if you take it classroom by classroom I think as I walk through and I haven't looked up in here in some good time at some of the stuff but um most of that's a old tectum deck it's been recovered with metal up there and there's a air there's air space in between

086it up there if you can eliminate the areas that you go in those classrooms there shouldn't be any asbest products in those classrooms not unless it's in that tile floor there unless you create dust you don't have you won't but it's not a problem okay else we wouldn't have any children in there right now okay so a lot of these systems can be recovered and this I'm trying to tell you if you got a good roof on the building and you can go in and if you got to bait some parts of the building to get the asbestos out you still have a brick and morar building at the end of the day okay so what is it that we're looking for we're looking to see that the children um we want a good safe

087clean space for them to come be educated in okay that's what we want we want a good classroom the classrooms need to be maybe updated those types the things that's the things that we need to be looking as long as we don't have a major asbest problem the roof is good that roof is on there that they put on there as a 50 year just at the basic at the basic timel it's 50 years okay so it's not my opinion is that we can renovate these schools but the problem is you got a shrinking schools is shrinking by 30 students 25 30 students every year so that's one classroom gone another one gone okay well there's still usable space over there and that's the point I'm trying to get to I I like the two

088to three story thing but you got to remember where we at and what the cost it is to drive the file to support this [Music] stuff I I think I back to the the point can we make a decision before December which is what we decided at that Saturday meeting and I think we need to identify what do we need what information do we need and what's the earliest we can get it and it's going to be a cost to getting a lot of that information and I'm not sure I'm not sure where our budget is as far as being able to pay that but I think that's where if if what I'm hearing sooner rather than later is where what the board members understandably want to do rather than starting to address the lwh

089hanging fruit and then in two years you know say oh I'm sorry we we don't need that anymore so I think we need to make a list of what do we need and how soon can we get it and I we've kind of done that we have a work session I and what's the price tag on all of it what's the price tag on all of it yes we have a work session is it next week or the week after February 26th okay so we do have a work session an all day work session on that date that I I'd like to think that we would certainly be able to narrow where we're going now I'm just one of five obviously um and and I think Mr Dobson you're you've always said one Under One

090Roof I'm not always I'm not agreed with that particularly but I don't think any of us can make an informed decision until we have more information exactly so I think Miss Diggs well I have a question on what would be the shortest oh sorry it's on it's on what would be the shortest time frame that we could get the information from Snider answer these questions that we all have and come up with a decision well it's my understanding Schneider has nothing to do with ASB besta so if we're interested in knowing definitively from an ESP bestus specialist Orest firm that they're not the ones who can do that they've in fact referred us to someone else and Dr Daniel probably although not an ASB bestus expert has learned quite a bit about asbest and companies

091I mean it depends on the the the the amount of the the testing and so one of the things we talked about was the the roof decking that you referred to and if they need to take samples then the the size of the samples that need to get based on car there's some agency standards Cura code Cura standards I I don't know enough right so it's just it boils down to air quality that's what it boils down to I I think what what we had had conversations about was um confirming the tiles are they as best as tiles how many tiles do you have to pull up in order to then confirm that as bestus is in those tiles is in the glue is in the various places and going through and taking samples of

092the the various places um so I think it it ranges from like how many CL do we want to test every classroom do we just need a classroom where we know that these materials exist in similar classrooms of age across the building or are we just sampling one spot and then we can kind of project those results into other other parts of the building so you can take you got a busted tile you take it put it in a baggie take sealing tole put it in your baggie send it off get tested tell you exactly what you want to know that's it it's that simple I believe that the company you spoke to had a more of an elaborate um theirs was was more of a process um in terms of the amount the the

093amount of how many tiles how many squ feet of tiles how many square feet of ceiling tiles how many square feet of roof section that they would need and coming back and patching the roof and again that was there was one contractor one bid one one conversation about um in response to a request on um getting some asbest testing so that was that was their process and so we talked about timeline too and so being able to going into different rooms are those rooms occupied thankfully the kind of the the places that we're looking at are concerned about aren't currently occupied um so that wouldn't be much of an issue um but cost wise it was about between 25 and $35,000 I think for the testing and that's and that's to determine what percentage of

094asvestas is in the I think that was just determining do these um it wasn't going through every classroom it was not going through every square foot it was going through places that we determined for them like I want you to check out everything in this room and then we can go in and say okay the materials in this one classroom is the same materials in that classroom that classroom that classroom and then from that we can project that would be much more cost effective than pulling up a sample out of every classroom pulling a chunk of ceiling out of every classroom pulling the the glue off various places again that was one assessment one one one inquiry inquiry with one company that is that so that's definitely somebody said it earlier we're in a conundrum

095I think was the word they used we're in a terrible conundrum I'm like the rest of you I don't want to be throwing good money after bad but I do think that the sooner we can get this 30 to $35,000 study on ASB bestus that's going to be a really driving factor in what we're going to do especially with this building and I believe that will also help you guys U make your decision on whether or not you need two buildings three buildings or Everything Under One Roof I would encourage us to move forward with that as best to study as soon as we can I agree I think it's a it's a key it's a Lynch pin here we need that information uh now how that relates to our current topic that we're finalizing

096today day I'm not sure but I think we all see the the big the wheels are all moving sort of together and we're trying to find our vend diagram and see what we need to do first and move forward efficiently it's going to cost a lot of money we don't have money tucked away in the budget to do these testings so I guess we're going to have to have an understanding that if we move forward with this ASB bestus testing for example that that would be something that um we should go ahead we should engage uh we should get multiple referrals and and choose a company and do it and do we do we agree first of all board do we agree that is something that we would like to move forward with we're not

097voting here but we're just we that's important information to get and we'll have to be assure that um pay me later that it will be paid that it can be paid for did you have the facility study in your budget no you didn't have that in there either but you were planning to do it right I'm sorry not not necessarily right until November they already had their budget adopted I'm talking about for this budget so the budget request do you have the facility study proposed the funding in this no I mean part of my understanding from that Saturday was that the supervisors are requesting us to go forward to do that so I just yeah just asking yeah it wasn't I hadn't put it in our budget no and until Friday I had no idea

098where to start with in terms of a cost for that well out of an $18 million budget I find it hard to believe there's not $3 $335,000 worth of pork built into it I've done a lot of budgets down through my time and there's always pork built into a budget somewhere that being said if we have to pay for it then we got to pay for it but again you'll never convince me have an 18 million budget that there's not $35,000 in there that can pay for this as best of study that's just me just one man's opinion but it doesn't matter how it gets paid for it needs to be paid for and I I think uh we need to do it ASAP post tast I just want to make sure we're talking about

099two slightly different things so we're talking about a facility study that whether or not that facility study was part of the budget versus some ASB besta study and trying to like that has come up of recent so those aren't necessarily the same things okay so best I just I just want to try to clarify just so there's not confusion I hear your point Mr walls about kind of finding the money and trying to I just want to clarify about like two different two different studies that that we're discussing that's all my understanding of what Dr Gibbs was saying is that one of her primary concerns correct me if I'm wrong was asbestos and that was a key factor regarding the Middle School um I also have heard uh is there a a mold study or

100being done e maybe at the elementary school or so when I reached out about the ASB besta study the same company can do air quality testing for whether it's mold samples mold existence of mold spores asbestos spores things along those lines so that was um the quote that they gave me was for ASB bestus um if I wanted to go back and have more conversations about the number of rooms for air quality testing that we could do that when we were having conversations about the boiler process and the water process there was also conversations about a potential need for air quality testing to determine if when we thought the hot water lines had ethylin glycol if those had leaked into the classrooms needing to do air quality um to test for the existence of the

101ethyn glycol and and there's air sample so that's that's also where that has come up recently so two questions first from what you just said I'm assuming there's nothing no air test or air quality tests have been done in reference to the mold so we don't know what extent that is to be have that corrected correct I do not have um mold air air quality testing so that would that's going to put that on us for our maintenance next year whatever that cost is so my question to the board to the school board is what do you need paid for to be able to make the decision of the direction that you want us to go for the schools can I yes I mean rather than I know I'm not on the board but I

102think also too I think from our that Saturday meeting was a conversation about what information I think the the supervisors are looking for too as I've kind of listened to some of the dialogue regarding um the Schneider conversation and Schneider proposal it's do do the supervisors also have the amount of information that you all need to collaborate with the school board and making a decision about what what seems appropriate for funding so I think I would want to know exactly like in terms of supporting a Schoolboard proposal do you need to see do you want to see um projections on enroll capacity studies you know what what length of information is needed to help you all I mean ultimately you all are the ones who are going to have to approve kind of the the

103tax burden um so what information do you also want at your disposal in terms of a recommendation um so I mean the school board could base a decision on one set of factors but in terms of both boards being on the same page about what is Affordable and realistic for Matthews and I go back to Mr Jones's comment from a couple months ago about what sets us up for the next 50 years um what do we need to kind of have a plan I think we can sit around and talk about what we we feel like what it looks like in 50 years but I I I would urge some pursue professionals who do this for a living to do those projections and um provide some professional insight and guidance as to this is you

104know what we recommend for this community to set you up for the next 50 years so I think I'm I'm curious to hear from from your board also like what what additional information do we need to have and that because I mean that was part of what that Saturday meeting was about what do we you know trying to vet that out in the timeline is I think as we start talking numbers or and the concern for how do we solve the problems right in front of us but also project out that timeline is is accelerating and so we're trying to I mean I'm trying to adapt um to that timeline to figure out how do we how do we set things in motion but also have um solid um concrete information to act on I

105I think it's going to require the supervisors to sit down with Tim tillage and and maybe get back with Snyder but and and look at there's a lot of different variables and one of the things that has happened since that Saturday meeting is like the ethylene glycol situation came up and and now we're looking at if we have to replace that the water lines probably a million and a half and is it better to do that if it need if that needs to be done is it better to keep the boiler right about the whole system and just and come up with some more efficient system yeah well yes but so in in making that decision uh if if we were to decide we we're just going to rip out that system and and put

106in some new HVAC system uh and let's say that's a $2 million decision I don't think it would be prudent say it's in the elementary school and let's just say you have 30 rooms I don't know how many you have there but let's say you have 30 rooms to me if we're going to spend $2 million it'd be prudent to put HVAC in all 30 rooms and not not 25 rooms and so this student number uh may or may not be that much of a factor as far because if we can get our uh performance better if we can get our maintenance better if we can get our curbside appeal better uh we may find that we're starting to get more students we we don't know that uh so in in the school systems where

107we seem to have a good structural system and I'm looking at the elementary school for example uh if we decided we needed to replace the HVAC I think I would just go ahead and and vote for that as opposed to because in the long run we're talking about that's being a 20year at least to 20-year Bond and does it really make sense to be to scrim be trying to save it at that level over a 20-year period or more uh between a million and a half and two million and I'm not suggest we just throw money away but if we're talking about an HVAC system it seems like we should just go in and and plan for the whole school now the middle school is totally different in my plan I don't even know what

108parts of the middle school we may be able to use but I'm hoping the high school and the elementary school we can use all or certainly major portions of it Tim I'm sorry no you're board members in the interest of time I just want to everybody to to know we uh we'll have just a few minutes but Mr tillage I guess you're defer to let me and then introduce yourself for the record if we take the elementary school and we out re outfit it with a new HVAC system let me make youall understand how this works with the new systems that they have now the energy would be pushed to the most critical times during the day that is needed in the building a smart system okay so the smart system tells you whether the

109classrooms a full or not with that smart system at night it degenerates down uses less energy that is the benefit of getting away from the boilers okay and it can be done the nice part about this system it can be done in stages it doesn't you don't have to do the whole school you can do um uh um do it in stages however you want to plan it out um these systems are are are energy efficient so more than what we have now so the savings that we would having energy is is is going to pay for itself in the long run but they are Smart Systems and a lot of the you know a lot of school systems and and big commercial buildings are going to these now and they're getting incredible Energy savings

110on them so just want to keep that in mind I mean I I don't like the bowler system because in my opinion it's Antiquated it's all right for a ship okay but it's uh for buildings anymore we got we got better systems out there now so that just may be something you want to think about about thank you facilities manager so I just want to touch on a couple of things is is there asbest in this school yes um but you're also protected under a Hera which is a federal law okay you're not required to Abate any ASB bestas um in schools and that's federally protected why because the federal government has never banned the use of best bestes the other point I would like to say is Mr walls give me a chance to

111do testing I think that's a waste of $35,000 because the lab is in Norfolk I could take a sample just like I did the water and take it down there okay um and my other point I want to make is I had Colonial web which is mechanical company out of Richmond come out and give an estimate on abating the ethylene glycol and putting in propylene glycol in the system and fixing the seals and I think the estimate for that is going to come in a lot cheaper than we anticipated so if you guys will just be patient with me and give me a chance to do some work I think you'll be surprised thank you great news Mr tillage thank you that's that's good and hopefully uh send us off on a hopeful note here

112I think we're all feeling the urgency and and we all see this we've talked about it this is our time for these two boards to be dealing with a very difficult problem in this County one that's never been seen or approached before so uh and we all do want to do the right thing um and about ASB bestus whether it's legal or not or whether the government says it's okay or not um I guess I'll reserve my own my thoughts for that but safety of students comes first if it's not Disturbed that's the if that's the if if it's not Disturbed and that and that's the if okay do we have any final uh discussion points we we have a lot to discuss in the future but um we'll we'll work on getting all of

113the things that uh you requested regarding the budget information and more and we will um be in touch soon with that there's a leadership meeting also on Monday morning uh so maybe we can follow up on some of these things I want to thank everybody for their parti yes Mr walls Mr tellage what is the timeline on getting this getting this done if it can be done and as close as getting it to norol you got a timeline on when you can get this oh the the test is the test is pretty rapid it's just collecting the sample and just getting it to them if you could do that Pronto from what I wrote down we need an ASB bestus and mold and air quality test and that'll get us a long way to making

114a decision as quickly as thank training for a week or so there are no further comments I'll count this meeting adjourned thanks everybody thank you

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.