CorpusRecord 13492

MCPS School Board Meeting 12/17/2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Board Tube
Date
2024-12-18
Location
Mathews County, VA
Material
Transcript
Extent
21,878 words · about 122 min
Collected
2026-06-04

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e Oh Linda who's responsible for e all right here we go good evening I'd like to call to order the December 17th 2024 Matthews County Schoolboard regular month meeting we all please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance I pledge aliance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for stands one nation under God indivisible with liy Justice for All before we get started I'd just like to remind everybody in case you didn't have a chance to look at the agenda that the wise proposal for the toddler CARE program will not be an action item on tonight's agenda however we welcome any and all comments at the podium on the topic item 1.3 roll call Miss Morgan would you please call the rooll present I am here present here

002present item 1.4 I'm looking for a motion for the approval of the agenda additions and deletions I make a motion to approve the agenda as listed do we have a second I second that do we have any discussion all those in favor say I I any opposed motion passes item 1.5 I'm looking for a motion for the consent agenda and the recommended action I make a motion to approve minutes of November 9th 2024 joint work session November 14th 2024 School tour November 19th 2024 regular monthly meeting and monthly claims as presented on the consent agenda agenda excuse me do we have a second second is there any discussion all those in favor say I I any opposed motion passes and I would like to note that the claims uh to be reviewed we are looking

003for a March 17th date and a June 16th if anybody is able to commit to those now if not we will hold it until next month we'll hold till next month item 1.6 well uh we are going to as usual review the Matthews County Schoolboard government norms and protocols and we review two of these items each month uh Miss Diggs would you review the two that we have on the agenda tonight [Music] certainly um you turn it y you're good just talk he's got you okay how when and whom to notify about attending school events concerts sporting advents Etc the board members are encouraged to attend school events the second ex uh exceptions for participation in professional development school board members are required to participate in professional development absolutely thank you very much item number

004two under recognitions we have our 2.1 item fall sports with Mrs Amy W O'Neal Matthews High School athletic director welcome okay it is on okay um good evening board Dr Daniel Miss Hunley and Suki and the community members um I'm just giving a recap again for our fall Sports um I forgot I got a clicker okay um I want to start off by acknowledging our cheer team we have um sometimes three sometimes five cheerleaders but they do a lot for us they they bring the spirit they're always there they um we I don't think they get enough attention because they really do a lot for the just the few that's there and they're at everything so I just wanted to acknowledge them and thank them for their their service to our school they um they're

005wonderful wonderful team cross country I'm just going to give you some pictures real quick this is our cross country team at various events here's our boys team okay we are so proud of our cross country team every single year that that goes back to I don't know how long they have gone to the state meet we represent Matthews High School very well in cross country and very very proud of everything they've accomplished we have an all region uh runner of the Year Gavin Dustin um you see here we have all district we have many kids on here for all district and All Region I'm super proud of them and they're multi multi AET so that's very very cool um we have our girls team here and we are proud to have the runner of the

006Year Elizabeth Moore also um for the region we also have a lot of all district um play uh Runners and a lot of All Region runners okay and we are very fortunate to have all state Runners we have Elizabeth Moore who came in 11th and Gavin Dustin who came in 12 and that's a really big deal I don't know if you guys have ever been to Virginia Tech and seen their it's very like Cobblestone rocks Hills and for them to come in 11th and 12th is a really big deal and I'm very proud of them um as you know we have started State send off so anytime our teams go to state the whole entire school gets together the band goes around and picks up all the um the athletes and we go through the

007entire school where all the classes come out to the hallway and claps for them yells for them and then we all empty out into to the parking lot and we give them a send off we um Deputy Barry thank thankful for her for leading them through the county with their sirens on so it's really in her lights and it's really um a great experience for the kids makes them feel special like they should football is back so we are so excited that we had a football team this year um we had a limited number of games which you knew um but I can't say enough about the boys that came out there 90% of those boys had never played football before some of them had played maybe a year or two but for everything they've

008given and the Improvement that they made it's just amazing and um I let I let them know that their Victory is not in wins and losses which we knew we kind of figured it wasn't going to be the greatest uh win record but they will always forever be remember remembered as the team that brought Matthews High School football back so that's a huge victory for them we did get some um honors for our football team we got all district members even though we had a short season um the way that it was told to us if we had had a traditional season that these players would have gotten these Awards anyway so why not give them to them in our abbreviated um season so we're very proud of them all district team we have S

009cardinas who was all region second team so that was fantastic that was a surprise to us I didn't know until I got the report in the email we have JV football team we didn't know coming into this if we were going to have a football team for one we didn't know if we were going to have a JB team we didn't know we were going to have a varsity team as it turns out we had enough boys where they could and and we were fortunate in this this instance that usually if you have a full if you have a full season um you can't there's so many quarters that you can play in a in the season well our JV players played some whoever could play Up played up but we didn't have to worry

010about that because we didn't have a full season so they got to play as much as they wanted to in the varsity level got as much as they wanted to in the JV level so as long as they were Varsity eligible then they could play both so that was really cool for them because it gave them more experience and we had some exciting times in football too because they scored some touchdowns they did some really great great plays and um this is just the foundation to a great future so just put some pictures of homecoming a lot of times we don't get to see um our homecoming Court our we had the parade and all these um Everybody deserves a shout out this school is very special the kids are very special um we're all

011like family and I think we all feel that right suuki um we did a blue and gold scrimmage at the end unfortunately we had to Forfeit to Middle sex because of injuries so we were down a lot of players and there was really no sense in playing that game because um if we you know to get for few other players hurt and so we forfeited that game but we ended up doing a blue and gold game that had some JV players on some varsity players on it and it was outstanding we had um we had students that were the the MC's of the night so it was comical everybody had a really great time and I think we're going to make this a tradition neat here's our golf team we had a new coach this

012year he's very very excited about getting this team um building it adding new players hopefully get some girls in there too um but they they had a great time here's our varsity volleyball team and we did have um volleyball honors we had second Team all district Lindsay Coons very proud of her our JV volleyball team and we had a blue and gold scrimmage for volleyball Suki is a manager there's Suki right up front um she is the manager of the volleyball team she does a great job and um we this is always a fun time so I feel like it's kind of a neat thing to do with all teams to do like a blue and gold thing at the end of the year because it gets everybody pumped up brings everybody in to to

013see it it's a lot of fun um we do have teams that give back um volleyball always does a pink a dig pink game they all the money that's raised they do big um um bake sh F sales and and whatnot and and donations they sell some shirts but all this goes to the giving Garden in Gloucester um for cancer um so we are super proud of this um coach Moen does a wonderful job with it the girls really buy into it and really um do a great job we we started this thing last year um athlete of the week what we do is um I PLL the coaches of the season on to give me nominations on who they think is their athlete of the week and then they vote on it so it's

014coach Le so we have some great great athletes that um got that honor this year or this season I guess um we had senior nights and like I told you before we have a and I think I've got it on the next slide this is where they come out on the field just a traditional senior night but they also honor someone special to them in the school system that's made an impact in their life so that's what we call Blue Devil impact they get a shirt they become part of the club and they're celebrated as such I feel like our athletes get a lot of attention but sometimes our School Employees staff and teachers don't always hear that feedback um they don't always hear that feedback on what they meant to a student I know

015that I had several myself that meant a lot to me and I didn't tell them so I this is giving them an opportunity to really share that um this is the the current Blue Devil impact Club this year um what we have is you can tell some really fantastic teachers who get nominated over and over and over again and I I thought about going okay maybe you should only nominate this one particular teacher or move on to someone else but I mean if they're doing a great job in making an impact they should be it's it's it's something it's great so I really appreciate everything that they do to make an impact on our student athletes um we got a lot of our community is wonderful whenever we have a need everybody pours out their

016their heart in their pocketbook um we are very fortunate first of all I guess I'll start with um Wendy harlo she does a lot of our and a lot of you probably know Wendy Wendy does our our t-shirts our banners our um yard signs she's great and she charges us a minimal fee she she just wants to do it for the athletes so we really appreciate her we have Woody hog up there Woody hog has no connection to our high school at all he has a summer home here and he happened to be walking his dog the same day that Pat mowen was walking hers and he said I want to get back to the local high school how can I do that he bought every player in the football team on Varsity a leather

017letter jacket they are $260 $300 a piece so and for someone not to have a connection to the high school to give back that I I feel like that's wonderful and he's been at all the games and he's just a big supporter um we have the hudgin family and the Wyatt family who helped put a um a new countertop into in our U concession stand um Keith Morgan is always doing something for me we got a new new speakers in the gym so you could hear across the way we're getting ready to get a new sound system in the baseball uh area um hoping to have carpentry build a press box for our softball team we got a lot of good changes coming um Deputy Barry bought all of our um football players a yard

018sign and we really appreciate her donation um there it says Anonymous donor but I have to say um this this man has been another another person who's not from Matthews not from around here he just has a home he goes back and forth to um near Co pepper his name is Randy hudgin it was Anonymous Randy hudgin came into my office and gave me $500 to buy something for the cross country team two days later he passed away very sad um his I talked to his brother since and he had his heart was so dedicated to Matthews County he just and he was a tennis coach where he's from in that area in Co pepper and he he was apparently did the same thing for schools around there too but um he and his obituary

019wanted um well his brother wanted to for anybody to make donations to Matthews High School athletic so I thought that was very special and the last thing is we entered a contest for T-Mobile um to have your St our Stadium rebuilt or re furbished you had a level of $5,000 you could win then you had to do an essay on why why we had the need and then if you won that you go to the $16,000 pot then you go to the $225,000 pot then multi-millions we made the $5,000 we got a $5,000 check from T-Mobile so that was very very cool didn't make it further but 5,000 is a great thing so um I just want to put my coaches up there I'm super super thankful to all of our coach coaches we have

020a dedicated coaching staff in every aspect um you've got a couple up there that's been there for you got Pat Moen Dr greeve who have been there for a very long time and continue to pour their heart into this program uh we've got several new coaches also who um are are buying into the program and want to help Matthews and support the kids and that's it thank y'all so much any questions what was the name again of the person who donated the um the jackets uh Woody hog Woody hog thank you yes and I have addresses if anybody would like that phone numbers got the same for Randy hudgin thank you okay thank you so much fantastic report coach amen [Applause] [Music] goodness all right we're moving on to items three with Miss Shang our

021student representative and her monthly [Music] report good evening um I would just like to start off with my experience at the annual vsba conference for those who don't know vsba stands for Virginia School Board Association I was blessed to have the opportunity to attend this Workshop Workshop session in November and we had wonderful guest speakers attend and share their stories of success one of them was a former assistant superintendent at a county and then transferred to a different county to become the now current superintendent another one was just a current superintendent so as we can see most of them are just School District leaders that came in and shared their experiences uh another one was we had a group of students attending from I don't know if you've heard of the school but George C

022Marshall High School up near Fairfax they talked about their program advocating for leadership and change and they also have an organiz gation formed called Center for initiative Center for voters initiative and action so cvia a.ch is their website and then we also had an architect come in and talk about building a safe space for students to learn in our core Focus for the meeting was a cell phone policy upcoming in January and I got to share our school divisions as cell phone policy as well as listening to others from across the Commonwealth of Virginia talk about their District's own policy with the coming bill in January for Banning cell phones completely in schools across the state um we discussed proposals and what we could do to quote unquote give a win-win situation to both students

023and the assembly and the assembly that's being uh parents teachers advisers and all the people just besides the students although I sat with counties that were similar to our size including king and queen Charles City and ess6 they were all wonderful people um I Heard students from larger counties talk about their cell phone policy and they were from Charlottesville Pennsylvania Prince William Manasses Northern Virginia and there's a few more we discussed Co Peppers County adjustment to a pouch named Yonder I don't know if you've heard of this at a price of $15 to $30 per pouch of course it's impactful but it's not always feasible so one of the key takeaways was that solutions to any school should always be impactful and feasible in regards to the cell fund policy we also talked about possibly

024having them in between classes or during lunch or having incentives to go along with following the policy or even similar to miss bra's be present award at the elementary school we can conduct a similar incentive at the high school that says if any student participates and follows procedures for the cell phone policy then they would have a free cookie or something a free ice cream or something small like that at the end of the month that'll encourage them to follow the policy with kids putting their phones away whether it's in pouches or being collected by teachers we can check students who are actually following this policy so that not one student is not accidentally caught and the kids following the procedure are not at a disadvantage this will ensure that no student will be using

025their phones from their backpack or pencil pouch and such one of the key points everyone knows but I just wanted to emphasize is that every voice matters so with that being said I enjoy this opportunity to speak on administrative matters at the conference and hope that policies run smoothly and then now we have a few updates just pass this down um the first one we have an update from Miss Bray at the elementary school it's one page Matthew's Elementary School it's one page had a festive December several grades had field trips this month which is a great way to extend learning outside of the classroom fourth grade students visited the Virginia Museum of Fine Arts also kindergarten and first grade students got all dressed up and went to the theater in norick to see hoay

026for the holidays both field trips got rave reviews from the teachers and students prek and kindergarten students had a winter showcase last week each student had artwork on display and the students performed a play called light up the holidays families left Mees feeling happy and filled with holiday spirit today 12:17 the na NAACP came and r a story and distributed a book to each first grade student on Friday Matthew's Elementary School will be having a Christmas Sing Along we are expecting a visit from Karma the Matthews County Sheriff's Office deputy dog we are also expecting a visit from Santa after the sing along all classes will enjoy some Christmas cookies prepared by our wonderful cafeteria ladies December is a very exciting time in elementary school our Halls are filled with special Christmas projects we've had

027fun spirit days and teachers have done a fabulous job mixing fun with learning it's been a fantastic month some Thomas onenter Middle School updates students in 7th and fifth grade are going to the Wells theater to to play a Merry Christmas Carol classes are participating in the door decorating contest and we will have a judging later this week students are collecting non-p perishable food items for the thms sca items will be donated to the hands of cross Matthews families can bring items to the tastes sights and sounds of the Season thms band concert taste Sight and Sounds of the Season presentation will be Thursday December 19 19 there will be displays from the art technology and family and consumer science classes families can purchase cookies to take home from the program you can contact Miss

028Williams if you're still interested in getting holiday cookies students are still continuing to work on reading and math skills through the all and tutoring program after school if your child needs additional support please check with your reading or math teacher lastly we have an up date from Dr geve at Matthews High School Matthews High School is enjoying a Christmas spirit week as we approach winter vacation with students dressing according to different themes each day we enjoyed a concert by our music department on December 5th followed by their performance in the Matthews Christmas parade on December 14th chesp Bay Governor school held an open house to showcase the work of our students who attend and the cbgs seniors who are working hard on their research projects to prepare for the Symposium in the spring our Beta

029Club has been active in filling several boxes in our main office for Toys for Tots to provide Christmas presents to families in need and our Key Club raised $37 for the Wounded Warrior Project during their fundraiser which in which also included writing Christmas cards to active duty members of our military our junior class is selling $30 certificates for a tital Wave car wash for only $15 each to raise money for prom so if you want to purchase a car wash at half price and support the Junior/Senior prom please consider buying a ticket from one of our Juniors thank you can I have when you were discussing phone policies with other schools what did they say about our phone policy um well we didn't really speak on other phone policies as much we kind of just

030described our own uh cell phone policy we also went through Jeopardy like Schoolboard Jeopardy um to start off the session okay yeah thank you I do have a question also sure um regarding uh the safe space um that she learned about at the conference can you tell us a little bit more about that the learning environments of course so uh he came in and talked to us about how he designed little studying nooks in different counties across the Commonwealth of Virginia and I talked about our school constantly you know having problems here and there but I felt that we had a safe space included in our County and he also talked about having glass windows as a source of light um so there were a lot of different factors incorporated into that so there were

031glass windows learning Nooks uh things like teachers were also a very important part not that it's architecture but teachers are a very important part for students okay thank you you're welcome thank you excellent thank you for that report Miss Shang excellent yeah I Dr Daniel you are up with student achievement we'll be talking about the ASVAB scores and aows response plan your documents are all under the 4.1 okay so as part of um um home and watching later um so every month we do a student achievement update so we try to highlight different aspects of student achievement as we go through the year typically this is reading and math um but this year is um this month's report is uh slightly different part of I think we talked about last month or may have been

032the month prior about the new accountability framework coming to the state of Virginia and they're working through the business rules of that accountability framework part of that framework has the three EAS enrollment employment and enlistment and those three factors are part of an index called the three e that go into that overall accountability framework so as a response School divisions are um taking some action steps to look at that enlistment category within the 3E currently the only um way for a school to earn credit towards that 3E component or that enlistment component in the 3E in the accountability framework is through the ASVAB test historically in Matthews we only tested ASVAB or gave the ASVAB to students who asked to so we would have kind of a testing session students who may have an interest

033in going into the military or just wanted an overall battery of skills so the ASVAB um is a um a valuable assessment to provide students with um kind of a career inventory a capacity kind of a career um guidance um tool if you will but it's administered primarily through the armed services so last year we only had 15 students take the take the ASVAB the ASVAB is scored and I'll go through a little bit but basically it's on a score of 0 to 100 so as this goes into the 3 e and the accountability framework the way we get points is based on how students score on that ASVAB test so students who um score I believe above 665 and above would earn one point students who were from I think 51 to 64 would

034be 75 so on and so on kind of down the line so what I tried to do was go back and look at the students who tested last year how that looked in terms of what score bands those students fell in to give us a little bit of predictability last year and then this year so what we are doing this year is testing all 12th grade and 11th grade students on the ASVAB the way it works with the accountability framework is it's it's a cohort-based model so it looks at as students go through High School how many of those students at graduation scored at a certain level on the ASVAB okay so last year we had 15 students four of whom tested in kind of that full onepoint range meaning they scored 65 are better

035on that ASVAB test one student was in that next score band five students and five students and those other score bands so that was last year this year where we stand and um is a is again we're giving the test to more students um so we have more students obviously then scoring in that um highest band more students in that next band um third band and then that that final band um again this is kind of a benchmark year for us because we've not given um a a grade level wide uh assessment on the ASVAB it's always been you know if you if you had an interest you wanted to get that um career inventory feedback or you were interested in going into the military and wanted to go into certain careers within the military

036you needed a certain score on the ASVAB um So based on the state changing the accountability framework we wanted to get ahead of that curve and be able to um give our students um an assessment on the asbab so our seniors most of our seniors took it in the fall we will again give it in the spring our 11th graders will take it in the spring and if there are any seniors who want to retake or who miss the fall assessment will also be able to take the Assessments in the spring so I it's I guess the easiest way to say it it is what it is I don't know you know we don't I don't have an indicator how these new scores will end up impacting our accountability framework at this point we'll get

037some templates from the state as they begin to finalize all of those business rules and we'll be able to plug some of these numbers into those working documents and those working templates um so we'll we'll see see what it means any questions on ASVAB anything along those lines yes okay um do you do any prep for this test to help help the kids out now we we haven't um geared any sort of instruction or prep um test prep with regards to the ASVAB the reason I say that is the test is a little weird to me okay and I got a grandson that I've sat down with him and I'm working through this with him and there's a lot of stuff on there he's never seen before so um according to the last last statistics

038I saw only 177% of the people that are eligible for the military are Quantified that's a real low number MH and if this is part of the reason cuz I'm looking at numbers here you got 3/4 of the people failed this thing so um now I don't know what the what the recruiters tell these kids or I they U they gave my grandson a site to go to to practice well that's fine if you can go and practice if you know what the hell you're doing but like I said some of these things he's never seen before right and a couple of those things I've never seen before it was shapes and stuff and you had to get in with a rhythm of how this looks against this bunch and it was not easy so

039I I can understand why the numbers here don't look very good I still think there's there's going to be a motivation piece here too so we're we're basically corralling everybody and say hey you're now going to take this three-hour test that you may or may not have a great interest in uh spending your morning taking um so I mean I I I completely get that and when I looked at the raw data it kind of shows um there are some students who really didn't kind of I'm I feel certain in saying that didn't give it their full effort in their attempts to take the take the test so but I think for the students who do want to improve their scores um I feel also equally certain that there's a way for us to provide

040tutoring or support at the high school to help them improve their improve their performance on the ASVAB okay but it's not something that we going to begin gearing instructional practices to or curriculum steered to that so I have a question regarding the follow through with the students um or followup with the students on their results yes so miss Dodge I think has a score debriefing session um that she goes through I'm not sure if she goes into English classes or how she scheduled it I got copied on an email saying what the date was for score debriefing but the school counseling office at the high school goes through and has a debrief and how to interpret your score score reports and stuff along those lines thank you you're welcome um some other pieces about this

041just kind of um again I think I talked about about that but basically we gave the test to 15 students last year again it's on a z to 100 scale um that kind of outlines the score bands for students again it's a cohort index and that's something to keep in mind as we talk more about the accountability framework especially with with folks who have um worked or had kids in Virginia for the last 25 years or so um we've always talked about school accreditation based on that Year's test performance so as we move into this new accountability framework with the state especially at the high school level the measure of the high school isn't necess necessarily going to be on every test given that year but will a lot of it is going to be

042based on how that Year's graduating class did on those tests during their career at the high school and that's a very different way of looking at it instead of looking at almost like a vertical of how everybody did this year we're looking at more of a horizontal kind of timeline about how this cohort of students did during their time at Matthews high school so some of that's going to be better for us some of that may be worse for us and so but it's just a mind shift or a logic shift for how we're talking about a high schools quality if you will or that their accountability so the the business rules again change a little bit um so again sum total of students um this year was 33 actually it's um we had a

043couple students who were counted in there because they were Juniors who took it last year so their numbers are also included in that senior Tally from this year so and again parents are able to opt their students out so we send notices home this is going to happen so um parents do have the opportunity to say um I'm not interested in my child um participating in that test and so that's the case then we don't test them so and then moving forward we'll test um 11th graders annually and that's pretty common with the superintendents that I've spoken with for how how they're addressing it at their High School get it if you give that test too too soon they may not have the reading and math skills in place while you may want to do

044it for some of the career planning aspects from the ASVAB you may not get the scores that you're looking for because the skill development is hasn't quite gotten there yet so most of the folks I've talked to are planning to do um a a grade level wide assessment in 11th grade okay vows response so last month we talked about um our initial vowels assessment again as a reminder vows is replacing Pals um so a new test for our um youngest students this is Statewide it's a mandatory Statewide test we give it in the fall um there's a midyear and then there's a a spring assessment um students are then score into one of three bands high risk is high risk for developing reading problems at a later age moderate risk and then low risk so

045quick review so we had 40 students at the time in kindergarten um who were given the assessment 24 of those that 40 scored in the highrisk range um 11 in the moderate and then five in the low risk so without going into every um score band but I just wanted to um kind of look at like just show the data one more time um before then talking about okay so now we know uh the results what are we doing about it so in preparation coming into this school year knowing that we were moving to vs knowing that they was going to be um a VA implementation knowing that we have hurdles um for students in reading and math the elementary school committed to a literacy block or kind of increased their literacy block to 120

046Minutes daily Additionally the elementary school and the leadership at the elementary school um had the forethought to go in and do a 30 minute plan a 30 minute intervention block into their master schedule selected interventionists um we provided professional development um on how to lead interventions so very scripted interventions so let's select intervent individuals so that they can provide um and become really competent at delivering the interventions the scripted interventions to our students rather than hey here's an intervention you kind of go do the intervention today or maybe you tomorrow Etc so it was a very um intentional process of aligning um staff members with interventions and the master schedule to be able to have predictability and structure and then also a key component of the intervention process is making sure we're monitoring the student

047progress within that intervention because we need to know if the intervention is working or not so that's a big piece this year of progress monitoring because if the intervention isn't working then we need to pick a different intervention and apply that and give that to the students for them to have the opportunity to make progress okay so what's happening with our students in the high-risk range so they're receiving in addition to the 120 Minutes they are receiving an additional 30 minutes of targeted intervention daily um that's based on the reading plan that is developed by our reading Specialists that specifically lays out the interventions and strategies for that student so those are individually driv driven for every single student who scored in the highrisk range K through three so that's that's a lot of very

048specific scripted reading plans that go into how are we addressing the needs of individual kids in our elementary school so to give you an idea of what what's happening in terms of the the elementary school response so in kindergarten um reading plans were developed for 24 students the intervention for those students is sound sensible so what we are doing is deploying four staff members plus a teacher assistant to work on delivering sound sensible or another intervention primarily sound sensible though to those 24 students in kindergarten at first grade we're talking about 16 students there Inspire level one different intervention but um so they're receiving Spire at level one so we have two interventionists and a special education teacher who are deployed to provide those interventions for those 16 kids and in some cases interventionists based

049on their schedule they're kind of their schedules are mapped out during the day so we can deploy them um at different grade levels during the day um so we don't I don't have eight interventionists per se so but at each grade level so for example at second grade we have 17 students they're receiving intervention in Spire level one and level two so as students get older the intensity of spire may increase so Spire one is that one level of intensity Spire two Spire three Etc so at um second grade we have 17 students Spire level one Spire level two we have three interventionists one special education teacher and one teacher assistant again deployed to work on on addressing reading needs third grade 14 students again we're looking at Spire level one two and three three

050interventionists a sped teacher and a TA um we're also the elementary school is also providing pushin support in grade second and third grade from interventionists from Tas and also our division ESL teacher which is English as a second language so we're providing pushin support into some of our upper grade classrooms the these interventions are pull out Services where H that's happening 30 minutes daily to address um student needs also for students who are in the medium and the lowrisk range so they're using that 30 minute intervention block to either work on specific skills for the students in that moderate band to kind of tweak and provide just a boost if you will whereas students in that lowrisk range May then be receiving intervention excuse me enrichment um Services some differentiation that's um kind of where

051what is taking place for those students in that 30 minute kind of intervention block where they're actually receiving enrichment um what we're using in some of that that 30 minute time frame so some of our students are in K4 using Lexia newella youly which is a product out of the University of Florida um all of these are approved materials from the Department of Education meet the criteria for high quality instructional materials um so those all based on kind of the the doe um list of materials all students in grade three through four have been offered the opportunity to participate in our all-in tutoring after school that's one hour two days a week we have 26 students who are participating in that Allin tutoring program the Allin tutoring is a state grou grant that provides um

052compensation we've got I think we received about 26ish thousand to provide all in tutoring um and also part of that money has to be used towards attendance um kind of tracking and motivation and some of those things so the the elementary school has um deployed um they planned well for it in advance they're executing that plan they're tweaking that plan as it needs to happen they've got all hands on deck uh making it making it happen and that's not part of the student achievement so we'll leave that for later sorry the next piece is meals and attendance data but I'll get to that later question on the vs response yes ma'am for the students that need the 30 minutes um is that what what are they missing to to get that are they missing PE

053are they is it is it really after school I think I think we have a very um a variety of things that are happening so some kids are doing that after school um the intensity piece is happening during the school day so that may be um during that intervention um piece they're not being pulled from that 120 minutes so it may be they're getting pulled from some of their exploratory or some of their elective rotation um it may be a little bit here maybe a little bit there thank you you're welcome questions from the board I've got a couple okay um first of all could uh we've talked about vals versus Pals and the difference in that assessment tool or that the screener tool can you CL clarify or classify the rigor of the vals

054screener itself um I would classify I mean I don't I'll be honest I don't have firsthand so I'm relying on um kind of the feedback that I've received from the elementary school leadership and also some of the teachers who are charged with administering the vows um but the expectation the what is considered grade level is much higher for the vows than it has been for the pals so the expectation the rigor level is um greatly increased so for me to put a number I would probably say it's ballpark at least a grade level ahead I'm going to look at Miss Bray and it has more components as well okay Miss Bray is saying it has more components as well for those folks listening at home also administer individually stud by student individually administered student by

055student and 30 minutes and the 30 minutes not missing anything it's built into the schedule so I was wrong okay so that all that's occurring during the built-in intervention block okay good thank you and the vows assessment that's going to be given three times a year fall winter and spring is essentially the same tool so we're really having we should be able to see growth at midy year whereas Pals historically was a very different midyear assessment so we would have to go from Fall to Spring to really assess growth so we should be able to see um growth from fall to winter winter to spring because the the questions in the skill pieces line up much better with fouls than it did with Pals so would it be safe to say that the screening tool

056when administered in the fall as a baseline is is really an end-of-year measure that they are being evaluated upon yeah an end ofe measure or um I mean in some ways you can drill down and say you know kind of what happened over the summer as well but I think it's really an indicator of where students are coming into that grade level um so I think if if we were to look at our fall second grade scores going forward we would take a look at okay well what happened in first grade is there was there a drop off from Spring of first grade to fall of second grade what happened is there some piece that we need to look at in terms of Summer supports or did we really kind of nail it in in

057first grade um to make sure those skills were solidified prior to coming into second grade okay so um regarding the lowrisk category since there isn't a no-risk category there is some there's a builtin expectation that there are some no risk students who are receiving enrichment types of um activities MH okay um and regarding uh well I'll I'll skip that for now um I want to applaud the elementary school and the leadership at the elementary school The Vows and the bla lift is unbelievable um I've looked at that Val screener it's unreal and the one-on-one administration of that tool is incredible uh and Dr Daniel for you to take us to be a datadriven division and it all fits because it's Dr David Daniel data driven division there's a lot of D's there I've thought about

058that uh I'm thrilled would would it would I be accurate in saying that um well at least with your Limited knowledge a superintendent in our division is this the most targeted approach to intervention that uh you have led um I would say it models what best practice is going to be at an elementary school so you really want to have um the data for how your students are performing and then making very specific targeted plans to address what that data is showing you whether it's deficits or a need for enhancement or enrichment for student St so getting in the habit of looking at whether it's our star data or our vows or so we can then make really targeted decisions and getting into that practice um is is how high achieving schools get and actually

059stay that way in my opinion that's right and we're well on the path and and you're leading that and I I I'm very um I'm thrilled to hear this response and Mrs Bray great job [Music] MH it seems like vows is a stronger course than what Pals was with more built into it from what she said so are you anticipating for having the additional training that it will be more difficult to bring the kids up up to park the vows aligns with the Virginia literacy act better than what Pal's was set up to do so the way the the instruction the the overall umbrella of the science of reading has a different focus and um approach to how to instruct reading so the vows is a way to better assess and also diagnose what then

060to do where students where it identifies shortfalls for students overall the the VA and our textbook series that we've adopted has a higher level of rigor a higher level of expectation of vocabulary of reading comprehension of all the things within scar borers rope so like the kids um are being asked to do a lot so I think students who historically have um without a ton of effort been able to earn A's in classes some of them are B's and C's and that's a K5 experience um and in some ways it's VA is also a much more scripted stepbystep um learning program um so that also lends itself better to a diagnosis and also hears the um prescribed intervention to then meet the various aspects of that VA so I think all of it is a

061rigor lift um for not just all kids but reading instruction across the state so I anti I anticipate as our teachers um become more fluent in the science of reading and the instructional strategies in our textbook they're going to find more comfort with it but I think we're going to pretty quickly see we should be seeing student growth I would anticipate some pretty good growth um by the winter time but if not then we'll have to go back and look at our interventions and look at our tier one instructional practices to see you know you know where are we offline if you will go back to the draw board a little bit if we need to monitoring the data and AD monitoring the data progress monitoring making sure our students are making um Regular progress

062and so we're checking in at shorter intervals to make sure we're doing the right things more more frequently and the next screener will be administered end of January for I believe it's end of January maybe mid January uh the window opens so we have a couple week window and then we have to wait for this for the state to then upload and share that data for us to get access to it right so we should be able to report back probably February kind of where we are on our midyear vs and then we also will have star midyear screening as well in reading and math and for the most part the star reading aligns pretty closely with what we're seeing on vowels there was some benchmarking stuff with with star that we had to adjust

063but with the adjustment in The Benchmark um for Star reading it lines It lines up pretty good great Dr Daniels could you go back one slide thank you yes ma'am looking at that slide you have uh we have for kindergarten Four staff and one ta for 24 students helping for for the intervention aspect for the intervention aspect I just noted how focused and how intentional this program is with the number of staff that are being used in this because I've never seen stats this high before for intervention so that's significant so when they're building the master schedule we have to um build in the what I would call these are resources so our interventionists our whether it's the ESL teacher our special education teachers when is the kindergarten reading intervention block going to take place

064because it can't conflict with the first grade or the second grade or the third grade because I need those staff members to kind of move through the schedule to serve kids across the schedule so all of that has to be extremely intentional and mapped out and planned to because we have to schedule that as a resource for our kids as well and so it went into a lot of how are we grouping students and kind of it gets down into every every classroom and what students are in what classrooms thinking ahead about what interventions this group of students may need so I can line up intervention to student to skill set across the day thank you so you're very welcome any other questions or comments from the board that was very informative thank you Dr

065Daniel right item five we will be having citizen questions comments or res requests comments not pertaining to Personnel or student matters are limited to one opportunity of 3 minutes please state your name and address for the school board clerk protocol for public comment period Matthews County residents and School Employees wishing to speak should sign up with their name and address on the sheet if provided comment period will end after 90 minutes all comments should be directed to the school board speakers shall not address matters involving students or personnel as these topics May violate confidentiality and are not appropriate in a public forum public comment is the school board's opportunity to listen to the speaker since our purpose is to hear from you the board will not engage in dialogue with the audience or whomever is

066at the podium matters requiring a response will be directed to the superintendent for research and response the superintendent May report back on such matters at a subsequent business meeting session as appropriate the school board carefully considers your comments when deciding on matters brought before us we appreciate your attendance and your input okay all right Mrs Michelle Williams I think she may have had to leave Mr Byron Roush Byron Rous 1430 nightwood Road Diggs thank you for this opportunity to come before you this evening and speak I come before you in opposition of the YMCA having a daycare in Matthew Public Schools the proposal to establish a YMC daycare within the Matthew public Public School raises significant concerns regarding its compatibility with the priorities and responsibilities of the Matthews County School Board while supporting families is

067a noble goal this initiative as presented is not aligned with the mission of the school board nor is it in the best interest of the schools or the taxpayers first and foremost the school board's primary responsibility is to assure the achievement and well-being of enrolled students diverting School resources classroom space staff time and potentially other material support towards a daycare program risks compromising the efficiency of our schools which is expressly prohibited under Virginia code moreover the school board is currently evaluating School consolidation options indicating limited capacity to accommodate additional programs without impairing existing operations secondly the ymcs stated that if the school board does not support the proposal they will look elsewhere this raises the question why not start elsewhere now the YMCA already receives approximately 85,000 85,000 annually from Matthews County taxpayers asking for

068free use of school facilities while securing no guaranteed long-term funding creates potential hidden costs and liabilities for the school district for example Human Resources Insurance maintenance and security considerations are unanswered leaving taxpayers to potential bear the burden lastly schools are not Community Senators they are institutions for Education while daycare is an important community service it is not the school board's mandate to host or subsidize such a program at the potential expense of its primary mission in conclusion while the YMCA's intentions are commendable this proposal is better suited for a different location the school board School Board should firmly prioritize the needs of its students and the efficient use of its resources declining this proposal in favor of safeguarding its educational Mission and fiscal responsibility and I thank you for your time thank you Mr [Applause]

069Rousch missu Henshaw hello and thank you for your service to our children in our community and and all you do for them my name is Sue Henshaw I live 174 Snug Harbor Lan in cops Creek and I just wanted to say that I don't think the daycare does belong in the schools and that's because I was a single parent of a son who I put through daycare and I was very excited uh when he was turning five and getting ready to go to kindergarten um but his birthday is in September so he would have been the youngest in the school instead of the oldest and the teachers took me aside with some other parents and said children need to be a little more mature before they go in the setting of the schools and so

070they convinced me that that my son needed to stay in a more intimate uh setting until he was older and didn't have all the distractions from the school so I just wanted to to make that comment I I I think they do need to grow up a little bit more before they're in this massive setting thank you thank you Miss Henshaw [Applause] Mr Jack Kirby Jack Jack Kirby 100 River bin uh cobs Creek Virginia and I also thank you for y'all's work it's it's it's not an easy job you have in some of the decisions you have to make but as well as you know the Matthews County School Board is currently struggling with uh deciding on uh which buildings to needs repair or maybe even closing one of the school buildings and with the

071continuing with the continuing decline in in uh student enrollment this will be a constant challenge in the future and we should not be obligating space to a private entity which will be more distracting to the school board and by agreeing agreeing to How uh two to four year old Matthew in Matthews County Public Schools what liability is it is the uh taxpayers legally held for um U as far as being responsible for the safety and Welfare of these children what liability are you placing the taxpayers in and if the Y has $200,000 to invest in the in the in the U upstart of this program in in the school system could they consider adding on to the the current building they have plus they getting $85,000 from the taxpayer so that's 285 right there and

072uh and and uh that's one of things they could consider and one of the examples of what not to do is with the current business that's that's currently going on with uh Matthews County the board of supervisor hous back some time back entered into a contract with the local business and it's my understanding that so far has costed the Matthews County taxpayers about $300,000 in in legal fees and other of the fees so um I would think the fiduciary's responsibility for the school board and the Board of Supervisors is to the taxpayers and not to a private entity and you will be also obligating future school boards if you do this if you accept this why thing uh to make some difficult decisions because should in the future the why uh have insufficient funding and

073they request financial assistance from the school school board is is who's going to be the bad guy and say no so and one more one one other thing if another entity whether it's a um a u Civic Civic or organization or whatever approaches you and wants the same deal to start a daycare center can you say no is that a discrimination issue so uh I don't think we need to be the school needs to be in daycare it we don't need to be be in it I'm against it thank you thank you Mr Kirby [Applause] Mrs Jean [Applause] Howard hi Jean Howard 5620 East River Road mobjack um I've been very active in the county since 1997 when we moved here and I'm also on the social services board so I'm very much aware that

074an affordable daycare is very much needed in our County and at first when I heard about them wanting to be in the schools I thought it was a good idea I thought yeah you know we need it so bad but after some investigation I've changed my mind I know our schools are very busy adjusting to the changing needs the teacher shortage and much much more that I won't even go into even when I have simply volunteered in the schools I realize I'm a distraction from the utmost important mission of educating the County's children I think it would be a major distraction and a liability too to have a daycare in the schools they have said they would go ahead uh creating one an affordable daycare in the county even if it's not allowed in the

075schools and I do think another location would be the best for everyone ultimately thank you for your time thank you Mrs [Applause] Howard Mr Richard Hicks Richard Hicks North Virginia just great instead of instead of talking about your mission which is to provide an appropriate education for grades 1- 12 and staying on task like all students should tonight we get to talk about the why again wasting public resources time and money how inconsiderate of these bleeding heart liberals that want to fix other people's problems with our tax dollars they never seem to want to do it with their own money amazing isn't it the Y has said they will proceed with their plans either in our schools or at some other location now today is the time to tell the why to do just that

076to move on to some other location and stop trying to abuse County resources and tax dollars so some questions about this can of worms the why wants you to get involved with if you let the why use school facilities what other organizations or businesses will be allowed to start a daycare using a few School classrooms how about mobjack Christian Academy you using some classroom space their goal is to educate so what a deal that would be questions who's in charge and what happens if a person with a restraining order of some sort shows up and who's in charge if there is an active shooter situation or a daycare parents car hits a student school student lots of bad scenarios and who has to deal with simple day to-day complaints toilet clogs burned a light bulbs

077it's too hot it's too cold I could make a long list ultimately the school superintendent and you the board will have to come up with some policies to cover every possibility at Great expense of time resources and tax money let's face it someone has to ultimately be in charge the boss so no matter how you no matter how you frame this ultimately you and a school superintendent will be running a daycare for twoyear olds on school grounds when what you should be doing is providing the above mentioned appropriate education don't you folks have enough on your plate after a year you still haven't figured out how to quit maintaining classroom space for 500 plus school students at taxpayer expense and what are you going to do when the Y says we would really like to

078run our babysitting daycare operation year round can't you accommodate that pretty please with big bleeding heart liberal tears it's for the children you know of course there is quote demand for affordable daycare in Matthews and affordable homes and affordable this and affordable that and personally I'd like affordable cars food and especially real estate taxes and income taxes Mr Hicks your time is up oh geez thank [Applause] you Miss K Dyer K Dyer Cardinal Virginia a lot of what I'm going to say is has already been said but I will just proceed the number one job of the Matthews County school system is the education of its children from kindergarten through 12th grade at this point in time there is an almost this is an almost overwhelming task now the Y has asked to operate a

079daycare program in school facilities using classroom space and using it free of charge parents of attendees use uh will be charged using a sliding scale system with uh children enrolled on a first come first serve basis for this project the Y has received $2,000 from One Source $330,000 from the Matthews women circle of giving and expects to receive $100,000 in Grants it is presently being given $85,000 a year by the county for operation of its various programs should they um should the schools be asked they can ill afford to participate in funding now or in the foreseeable future which is a concern there is no space in the schools to house the wise daycare considering long neglected problems with its buildings especially Thomas Hunter Middle School which may have to be raised or at the

080very least renovated the matter is huge it will require a lot of money and will will require unimaginable time and effort from the school board and that alone is reason enough to deny the wise proposal to my in my understanding is the Y has yet to submit a memorandum of understanding to the board which must be done before a contract can even be considered aside from availability of space issues of liability School oversight legal fees demands on School staff time um details of meals for daycare attendees and staff cost of utility services and utility maintenance have to be worked out all this will require time from the school staff and School Board time which should be spent on the education of the children the county schools that are in the county schools Target population the

081why should look outside the schools for a home for its daycare operation thank you thank you Miss Dyer Mr Randall Dobson Randall Dobson 1085 Rome Point Drive cobs Creek Virginia I'd like to start out by saying I think you should vote this down it's not a good idea if I wanted to look like a genius I should have signed up first I heard more good reasons than I even come with but I'll make it real simple a you're not getting enough money from the county to do K through 12 that you want you're constantly having to cut and do more with less B this project sounds like it would be better suited to go with another nonprofit such as a church or whatever and D it's real simple most of your residents in this County

082are retired don't use the services of the school or a daycare but yet are going to be the ones to pay for it because let's face facts personal property tax and real estate tax pay for everything in this County okay we're not getting any freebies from anybody and we don't have an Amazon distribution center with free money so it's all of all the oarts money if you will that you're looking to spend so like I say turn it down thank you thank you Mr doson [Applause] Miss Sharon fry good evening Sharon fry Port Hayward Virginia I'm here to speak about the why also I am totally opposed to placing the why or any other business on our school campus about the why first and foremost you will not have any jurisdiction over their policies or

083their procedures you will undertake great maybe hidden responsibilities this business on our campus becomes our business our responsibility as you know there's been another school shooting this if it happens in our school and don't say it can't always be on the alert that why that business in our school will be our responsibility with this added added daycare SL preschool it will impact our present school system in fact it already has take a look around all this Schoolboard talk about daycare why daycare why we have present concerns that are in need we have children that can't read we have S so scores that are low we have impending safety issues in the school system we don't need another business to be responsible for yes I agree that this county is in need of a daycare we

084are we are totally in need of a daycare and slash I hope it is a preschool when the why does it the why has stated that they have the financial ability to proceed without being on our public school campus I hope they do we need to take care of our own problems and our own school system system our students should come first so that we can have them achieve the best education possible now on another note I did have a question about the veils as I looked at the staff per student it says five and I'm looking down at the third I guess I was looking down at the third grade it said five staff to 14 students um now on these Interventional interv ition alist are they paid employees or are they volunteer employees

085and my question is if you're a little child and you have five different people coming in to talk to you and teaching you and teaching you and it's not the same person that's teaching you where's the trust where are you getting that trust you're getting five different people that are coming in and all of them probably have different ideas of how to teach why to teach language up language down that person talks loud that person talks slow I don't know I'm just asking thank you thank you Miss [Applause] fry Miss Judy salatino again I want my voice to be heard in regard to the issue of the why sponsoring a preschool in Matthews Public School building before the vote I've spoken before in support of this and I still feel strongly that this is an

086important for the education of Matthew's children I have 30 plus years experience in teaching preschool in different communities and I've seen the benefit would this not help the statistics that you had up on the um slide earlier in this meeting to have a preschool to help educate them earlier as the slide showed last time 60% of kindergartens are not at grade level this is a fact black and white the children need a preschool to start their educational Journey from reading and hearing ing different opinions I feel that many are thinking that preschool and daycare are the same thing they are not we need both please look at the benefits for the future of the children having a preschool there's no question a preschool in our school would be positive the children would get acclimated to

087the building for the future to help the kindergarten teacher for the future there would be a community of Educators around to see how the program works there is room the why is willing to compromise they have the funding to get this off the ground why say no work with them solve the problem we have an responsibility to educate all the children let's start with a preschool thank you Miss saltino [Applause] Mrs Diane Grace good evening Diane Grace 151 blue heren Lane I am again speaking tonight on behalf of the proposal the house of preschool program in the schools and I'm very carefully identifying it as a preschool you've heard many reasons why people do not support a daycare fine separate the two this County needs preschool you've seen many statistics tonight and last month about

088why this County needs preschool Services Matthews County Public Schools faces numerous challenges like most school districts in Virginia and Nationwide dwindling enrollment crumbling infrastructure and inability to attract teaching staff low student achievement I'm sure you know the problems better than I you have a front row seat Dr Daniels has shared data last month and this month that shows 60% of the kids entering kindergarten in the fall are at very high risk for developing reading difficulties those children would have benefited from a preschool curriculum before they entered kindergarten a preschool curriculum which the why proposes to use created by the University of Virginia the same people who create vs and Pals and all of those assessments Matthew's teachers are doing a phenomenal job of helping students catch up but roughly half still can't pass the reading

089so in third grade there's abundant research showing this problem can be mitigated by access to appropriate preschool you have been given a proposal to address the complete absence of appropriate preschool in this County still some of you are uncertain uncertain about supporting the proposal I don't even understand how you can say no to trying to find a solution for three of your largest problems Mr tobson correctly identified the assessments are getting more rigorous in kindergarten not less how can you not prepare those children to the best of your ability to meet that assessment you talked about the needing to prepare students to take that army military thing you want to prepare them you want to give them ass assistance but we're not talking about giving kindergarteners preschoolers assistants that's what preschool does there are other

090groups who use the schools and who are not directly involved in educating K through 12 students why not this group this is voluntary it doesn't seek to remove students from homeschooling or parental care if the family has the luxury to make those choices if you intend to vote against this proposal what's your alternative you the school board members Mr Dobson Dr Gibbs Mr Morgan what are your what is your alternative to helping those kindergarteners when they arrive at school be ready to start learning from day one Mrs Grace your time is up thank you well that's convenient because I've said everything I can say no thank you [Applause] Mr Stan Grace all the family good evening Stan GCE cobs Creek um I'm speaking tonight in favor of the YMCA's proposal to launch a preschool program

091here at the school a lot of opposition is against a YMCA daycare program well okay you can oppose that but I'm in support of a preschool program we didn't have a preschool we didn't have a kindergarten program in the hometown that where I grew up much less a preschool as a first grader I struggled with reading and reading comprehension and this issue lasted up to the third grade that struggle was terrifying for me I remember it I remembered it a lot today when I was writing this no child should have to begin their education terrified I have benefited from the pro I I could have benefited from the program uh that the YMC the preschool program that the YMCA um um is is proposing last month Dr Daniels Shar share the results of the Val

092scores 87.5% of the kindergarten age uh children in Matthews public schools are in high to moderate risk these kids are struggling if you reject the wise proposal for a preschool program and doc Dr Daniels I appreciate your um um response to those scores I didn't see those before I wrote so my my question is if you don't do this preschool program what is your plan um you're elected to fix all the problems not the easy ones this is a hard problem and the community is stepping up to help please let them help the curriculum the why is going to use for this program is one of the Virginia Department of Education uses across all state supported programs in over 5,000 schools uh classrooms in Virginia as I understand it research consistently indicates that highquality preschool

093uh uh programs have a positive impact on children's reading scores when they enter kindergarten children who attend a pre program generally demonstrate better early literac literacy SK skills like letter identification sound letter Association vocabulary upon entering uh kindergarten which are crucial which is crucial for reading development the number of young families in Matthews the 35 to 49 a age group do dropped 30% from 2010 to 2022 we need families in this County we need young families in this County as they are critical to the web of success for our County and its future some estimates say that 87% of the workers that have jobs in in in Matthews travel about 2 and 1/2 hours daily outside uh for employment the wise program is a safe place for these families and their precious children to prepare

094for kindergarten Mr chce I'm sorry your time is up I'm sorry too so I support a preschool not a daycare thank you thank you Mr Grace Miss Susan Austin good evening School Board my name is Susan Austin and I'm from Gloucester County I hope you don't hold that against me but I have a lot of friends and acquaintances in this County and we talk about these things and what happens in Matthews is usually what happens in Gloucester so I feel strongly that um I just have one one thing to say um I read an article in a newspaper from Ohio I think it was Columbus Ohio where a manager of a YMCA had some complaints about this man who was identifying as a woman undressing in the women's locker room and when they complained the

095manager says well I'm sorry I can't do anything about it well the problem is with the why is becoming so woke and taken over with this um woke philosophy philosophy that I don't think a a parent would want to subject their kids to that early training that is touted uh I certainly wouldn't want my children in that so um that's all I'd like to say thank you very much thank you Miss Austin W Miss D Russell good evening D Russell 276 y r Lan oops um I am also here to speak in favor of a preschool not a daycare doesn't matter how many times you call it that that's not what we're talking about okay and also I'm amazed at how many people tonight make it sound like this is the first preschool ever ever

096in any public environment in any public school it's not this is not new it's been going on in other places for years we have one over in Lancaster I mean these are this is not a New Concept it may be new to us and of course we as Matthews folks have a little harder time accepting change than maybe some others but it's not new I want to throw some stats at you cuz that's what I like according to the US Census as of July 1st 2023 Matthews county has 8,514 people of those only 3.9% are under 5 years old we're not talking about a lot of kids here an interesting other number is 32% 32.6% of that number are over the age of 65 so we're not talking about that many families in civilian labor

097total percent of population 16 plus in this County total is 49% interesting why I give you that number is because this number is even more interesting and civilian labor force female percentage is 43.2 what does that tell you it tells you we have a lot of working moms out there per capita income for Matthews County between 2019 and 2023 is $ 4,767 and our poverty number is 99.2% and guess how many people are part of that poverty level and guess what demographic it is it isn't the 65 and over it's families with children roughly 80 8% of 5year olds 69% of 4y olds and 40% of threeyear olds in the United States of America go to preschool in Virginia roughly 18,000 children go to preschool research has shown children learn better they develop social skills

098they become more emotionally intelligent We complain about our children sitting in front of games and TVs and phones we're talking about getting children more interactive with human beings at an earlier age the benefits they're more prepared for school less likely to be identified with special needs and they are less likely to be held back in school and more likely to graduate is preschool for everyone nope that's why it's voluntary okay my guess is some of you members of the board have been inundated with emails this past week because a Facebook post went out on a quasi private Facebook site that said you need to tell all those people we don't want this here because people I believe the term was well I'll have to find it but we were referred to as specific people coming

099to voice our positivity positivity to this we're the certain demographic what we are is a certain demographic that want the best for the children of this County this is not a political issue this should not be treated as a political issue these children are the future of this County we're going to all be dead and buried when these kids are running our counties we need them to be as smart as they can be M Russell your time your time is exceeding absolutely thank you thank you very [Applause] much Mr Mike walls M Mike walls hudgin Virginia excuse me I'll let you know I'm not feeling the best but I found out I'm not contagious so that's why I'm here tonight um call it a daycare program a preschool program it's kind of irrelevant in my

100book anybody that's under the age of four or 5 years old their parents are working they need preschool they need daycare it's just that simple I'm not opposed at all to a preschool or a daycare program here in Matthews County as a matter of fact I would support it because that's absolutely what we need here however last month we all participated both boards in a joint planning session and we as the board had asked the school board to give us a recommendation by December of 2025 on what your facility needs are excuse me this I am sure of when this program starts it's going to expand and I would certainly expect it to what I don't want to see it doing is expand abing in our school system now somebody said they like statistics I

101like statistics too so I'm going to address the elephant in the room worldwide the YMCA is worth 64 billion that's B billion with a B here in the United States it's worth $164 million they can absolutely afford to purchase or rent one of our vacant buildings in downtown Matthews we've already been told by the why that they would seek an alternative location in Matthews County for their preschool daycare program if the school board do not approve it let's hold them to that let's encourage them to do that it should not be the school board's responsibility or position to offer facilities for this type in our Public School System once again again let me reiterate not opposed to a daycare preschool program I just don't think it should be housed in our school system as we

102go forward you guys we we as a board you all as a school board we have some really hard decisions we got to make if we have the daycare preschool program here in our school systems when it goes to three or four classrooms it's going to be that much harder to make the decisions we got to make thank you for your service I appreciate your time thank you Mr [Applause] Walsh that is the end of public comment as far as people who have signed up is there anyone else who would like to approach the podium right there be none what we we have one more please state your name and address Johns Johns from AER I just have one quick thing to say I'm I'm agree with that last man 100% if there needs to

103be a preschool or something like that then you guys can do it not Farm it out to a private entity and have that private entity work within the school system because you create a lot of problems that all these other people have just enumerated there's so many people that I talk to around Matthews County and around the whole area that are toally opposed to a private entity like the YMCA if they said they have other options let them do that there will create the other options somewhere else and then people can bring their kids to that place totally fine but if you cave then it's going to fester and it's going to be a Cancer and it's going to keep growing and it's never going to go away and you're going to have all those

104liabilities that they talked about all those problems that they talked about all those issues that they talked about and the taxpayers are going to be on the hook for it so that's all I got to say thank you thank you Mr [Applause] Mills is there anyone else who'd like to approach the podium thank you for all of your uh discussion points tonight we are up to 5.2 with Schoolboard comments does anyone have a comment they'd like to make amen amen Mr doson you have a public school which is paid for by the taxpayers in liability today is what's killing this country if something was to happen to a child in this program in this school the we're going to go after the deepest Pockets which is going to be Matthews County Grant you the why's

105going to have insurance but they're going to go after both this is we can't afford this it can happen to us with our regular students so let's not add more students to the pot now the other way to look at it is you got four foury old which I don't see a problem going to like a Head Start program or something in the school don't have a problem with that at all what I have a problem with is two and three year olds in the school two-year-old going to be changing diapers that's a daycare I don't care what anybody says if the child can't support itself it's a daycare center same with a three-year-old most three-year-olds are going to have problems so we're strapping enough on the people now the the wife said they were

106going to have one teacher one teacher's aid per seven children and one administrator all right so if you got several two-year-olds in a class you're going to have your hands full and you can't keep an eye on a rest of the kids the other problem is in the by the law of the state of Virginia if you go down this Venture that means any employee that has to work to assure this thing is running properly would violate the law from the way I read it if you're going to have them here somebody has to supervise them to be sure they're doing what they're supposed to be doing if not it's going to come back on us so and it would have to be either the super or the superintendent as far as I look at

107it would have to spend time down here on a daily basis to make sure they're doing what they're supposed to be doing and keeping us straight and that violates the law because it can't take away from people that are working already in the system like I said I don't have a problem with 4 year olds because we got them now but the two and three year olds I got a problem and that's like I said that's day care so if they want to do the fouryear old and we can accommodate them I have no problem but when you throw the two and three year olds in I would say let them go find another place and that's all I have to say thank you Mr Dobson anyone else have any comments they'd like to make

108Miss digs when Dr Daniels did the survey uh with parents in this County uh a while back that survey they had respondents from it and 80% of those those people who did respond the parents in this County 80% wanted to enroll their children into the educational enrichment program and the afford and 54% wanted to enroll their children in the child care um you all know the why proposal and to my understanding they have the money and the people they have asked for us to house it I have listened and read many of your comments recently about having it in the school and not having it in the school I tried to understand all of the comments and I sadly don't I think I have a pretty good head on my shoulders but I don't understand

109and the um opposition I I hear the concern on the liability um I hear the concerns across the board but when I look at um the needs what we've all seen tonight the needs in this County of these children in the elementary school and on up we I I listened to Mr Morgan recently say when he was teaching at the high school some of those students were struggling to read and the high school grade levels um everything that I have read about this program and other preschool programs has been the positive impact that it has upon children and in this County with the statistics that we know we don't know them as clearly as we did because our children now receive lunch and breakfast we don't have the stats on um who gets free lunch

110and who does not but we do have a lot of people who parents who work single parent families who need and want care and they want their children to Excel and as Dr Gibbs has said many times we all want student achievement as the very top thing here in Matthews County I think we're all basically after the same thing but we go about different ways and we have different views on it my view is that this would be uh beneficial to the children if the program is started here um it is approved by the Virginia Department of Education I talk to the lady who runs the program currently in Lancaster County this past week they have 13 students over there the statistics that she gave me now this is across the board with kindergarten not

111just those that are in this program with the why but they Benchmark those children in kindergarten are currently meeting the end of the year Benchmark in Reading at 70% that's a huge statement when we can make that statement for our kindergarteners how wonderful that will be and those of you who have said your concerns tonight I think we all hear them but I am greatly concerned these children are our future we do need them to be prepared when they come into the school system and so many of our poor families they don't have books at home that they read to their little ones and we know that that is a huge impact the statistics are on the board with the intervention that is given here now and I just I want what is best for

112this County I want what's best for these kids and I see this as a pro for Matthews County in many ways thank you thank you [Applause] mes Mrs hajes yes first of all I want to thank everybody who took the time to speak tonight um I I do want to clarify a couple things one um I Heard over and over again this is child care it is preschool primarily by the hours there is a component of child care but it's a smaller hour for hours it's only I believe two hours versus the whole day is preschool so I just wanted to clarify that um and also we have received anou we just received it last week and that's why we're not voting on it tonight so we have a chance to review that and to

113look at that and ask any questions so I did want to clarify that and thirdly um I did receive as I as um I think um my colleague um Miss digs mentioned receiv received many emails this past week um not in support of this program and many people mentioned that it would be at Thomas Hunter and that was the re one of the reasons that they did not support it it is not slated if it's approved to be at Thomas Hunter it is slated to be approved to be at the elementary school so I just wanted to clarify that as well I I think Miss Diggs my colleague Miss digs mentioned um confusion at some of the reasons that have been given to not have this program because we have a Head Start program and

114those are three and four year olds also we've had it for 20 years and I've never heard any push back against that program we have not had any civil suits we have not had anybody sue us we've had Parents take their children in the high school to the classroom and the mornings i' when I worked there I saw them and they it's it's it's worked as far as I know wonderfully and it's been great for the students that in the Head Start program and great for the high school students that interact with them we have intramural basketball in our schools throughout the winter on Saturdays all day in both gyms and practices after school what greater liability is there than Middle School students playing basketball I've never heard any push back about that I'm perplexed

115we have a Auditorium a beautiful Auditorium where senior citizens go to listen to concerts High liability age I've never heard any push back for that I'm perplexed I'm just perplexed by why is there so much concern about liability about this program where we have so many other programs in our schools that have in my opinion have greater liability than this program we had a a camp at the high school for one week where students stayed not just from the county from throughout the state stayed there overnight in the classrooms there was no push back from the community that was huge liability so again I'm I'm per I'm as my colleague said more eloquently than me this is very perplexing in to me we already have young children in our schools through special education there is

116an entire classroom full of children who are at least three years old I don't believe two years old because they are in a different program I could be wrong on that but we've had that for 15 20 years as well so we have children that age already in our elementary school and they are being picked up on school buses to be brought there so that again it could be a liability we're required to provide that but we've never had a problem as far as liability in that area um I've heard suits if we're suit they go to Deep Pockets that's absolutely correct but when I heard tonight $164 billion dollar from the YMCA this County doesn't have the Deep Pockets the YMCA has the Deep Pockets not us certainly um and again we know as

117some of the speakers said and as Miss Dig said preschool can make a difference for children to be able to read by third grade that is our task our task is to teach every child that comes through our doors to make sure that they have the best education that we can provide and this program it won't Co it won't it won't be the solution for every single child certainly I'm not I'm not going to offer that up but I do believe it will make a difference to children who are struggling now in reading and cannot read by third grade we have a significant number of those children and and to the question have it elsewhere I thought about that I hear you and I think about these things but we know transitions are difficult for

118children we spent a lot of time talking about transitioning um eighth graders to ninth grade now seventh grade to eth grade they have an entire day to help them transition to talk about it that's teenagers we have talk about the fifth graders going to the Middle School transitioning because we know that's difficult and so having it in our school would keep them from having to transition from one facility to another because it is it is a problem children don't we can't just assume for them to go into a new building and be comfortable there um so from where I sit that is a reason to have it in our schools we know we are losing students to homeschool we are losing students to private schools and we have talked we have talked publicly and and

119in our work sessions about how to get students here in our schools we have a great program and one of the ways is if they come to the preschool they're less likely to leave to go to a private school that in itself will save you tax money tax because we'll get more money for those students when they come to school if you're worried about taxes you should want more students in our schools because it's less money that our county has to pay in the local match and finally and this is a bit of an aside and I apologize but there has been some Mis I don't want to Mis misinformation but it talks about the um the county paying $85,000 to the Y and I think it Bears some history there that our County previously

120to the Y had a had a Parks and Recreation program as Gloucester has and when the Y came along there were two simultaneous programs so the county as I remember chose to say why we're going to give you this money take over our parks and wreck program and that's where that the beginning of that that came from because now the county doesn't have to pay a coordinator of that program and hire staff to run that program they gave the why the money to run all those programs so I think a point of clarification on the reason that the reason it started to be in the county budget came from no longer having a County Parks and wreck program thank you thank you for your time [Applause] Mr Morgan very briefly um Miss Hodes went brain

121dead for a moment I'm Sorry Miss Hodges mentioned that we do now or or have recently received the mou from the YMCA um we've had chance to look at it but I don't think we've really had the time to study it thoroughly and have discussion over it and so on um I believe and Dr Gibb correct me if I am wrong um that we also want our insurance carrier and the schools Matthews County Public Schools attorney to look over this mou and I'm I'm very anxious to see see what that turns up um I will say I see the need for a program like this I truly do I taught in the high school for a few years and I had high school students that struggled with reading and basic things um so I do

122recognize the need however I think this Board needs to make absolutely certain or as as certain as we possibly can that everything is going to be in in accordance with the law and far as what it State requires of school boards and what our duties truly are also that we are in coordination with the uh insurance companies and that everything is done legal and proper and that all of the eyes get dotted and all the tees get crossed uh that being said I'm still waiting to hear here from insurance companies and attorneys thank you very much thank you Mr Morgan I I just have a few comments here basically as usual speaking last everything has been said um but I will still uh feel compelled to give my input here I do want to clarify

123that the presentation by the why was brought to us entitled toddler CARE program so that is how the program was presented to us when asked if it was a dayare care or a preschool the answer was both so I I do want to clarify that and I will confirm that anou a sample draft mou was received last week at the end of last week um approximately one month after it was requested and it is in the process of being moved forward to the insurance uh carrier representative and to the school uh School Board attorney I anticipate that not much will happen over the break but that when we resume in January we will start to be getting information that we can review all that aside uh there's no doubt that this issue is one filled

124with passion I've said this before we have tons of compassion in our community everybody on this board is compassionate about children no one disputes the need for affordable daycare services or preschool Services if you wish to call that them that in our County that's indisputable the great news is that the first night that this was presented by Miss Levens from the Y the intention is to provide this service in our County regardless of if it is approved in our schools or not clear eyed Doe D diligence in assessing the wise proposal is what is required by every member of this five member board that is what we were elected to do and that is what we miss must remain dedicated to doing I have a few considerations to highlight that are very Salient in my

125mind the first one is code Virginia code title 22.1 in education chapter nine is entitled school property and section 22.11 31 boards May permit use of various school property and underneath that is a school board May permit the use upon such terms and conditions as it deems proper of such school property as will not impair the efficiency of the schools the school board May authorize the division superintendent to permit use of the school property including buildings grounds vehicles and other property under such conditions as it deems will not impair the efficiency of the schools and are therefore proper the division superintendent shall report to the school board at the end of each month his actions under this section permitted use of buildings may include but are not limited to use as voting places in any

126primary regular or special election which we do indeed do one day a year just as a quick reminder the toddler care proposal would run from approximately 700 a.m. to 6:00 p.m. 5 days a week for 36 weeks to begin with that's the school year with the intention of growing from 14 students to what survey indicates dozens up to as my I counted 50 2 students whose parents were seeking affordable daycare as of last spring a great many of them were two-year-olds by the way so just for clarification on that permitted use of our schools must be deemed proper and not to impair the efficiency of our Schools board members have received many Communications from citizens highlighting concerns that may be characterized as impairments to efficiency in areas of functional daily operations reduced classroom flexibility impact

127on maintenance safety School Personnel material resources food time for planning collaboration and a whole host of other potential items related to insurance and liability known and unknown that would or could present as impairments to the efficiency of our schools that must be regarded by each of our members this code number two as several people mentioned and as this board is well aware consolidation of our school division is one of our top five priorities on our strategic plan process of assessing health and safety of our buildings which is a topic that will come up later as I've mentioned earlier uh in our meeting has barely begun but it has begun by the end of the year by December 2025 the school board will have given based on assessments starting with health and safety and then architectural

128information assessments and informative information about how we would like to proceed in terms of the format of our School Division we are doing something that is won't need to be done for a long time that hasn't been done probably since any of us have been around this is the time when major undertakings for determining the future of the school division are being made so there is a collision in my mind with this proposal with our one of our top priorities which is determining the consolidation of our School Division and as such it would seem to me that we would need to maintain the ultimate inflexibility of our classroom spaces given that we do not have assessments of health and safety of our buildings yet there are scenarios you can imagine where we may need to

129have students be educated in other classrooms that than what we have typically planned for there may be we may have to shift things around we don't know so we need to have full control of the flexibility of the classroom space with initially starting with 14 students but with the explicitly stated desire to grow the program that would mean a additional classroom space as time rolls on so over time the Y could possibly be seeking additional classrooms while simultaneously we're trying to consolidate spaces and decide are we going to a one School Division a two- School Division some sort of modified three School Division we don't know and as again as I said according to the survey data we have dozens of young children whose parents are seeking affordable daycare for their children no doubt about

130that the why needs to be free to be able to grow its organization as it sees fit over time and finally as a board member I do have concern future concern for our local funders of our schools those are the taxpayers we are accountable to all stakeholders we are accountable to students staff taxpayers everyone and we try to balance all of the needs from all of those constituents if there were to come a day when funding were no longer available for the why and no one can say that day will never come no one will say they promise it won't come it will we don't know we don't know that's another unknown the taxpayers will be asked depending on the structures of both boards in the county the potential is there for the taxpayers to

131be asked to fund that if you were at our early session when we were talking about budget requests and seeking employee and public input on that we discussed among many other things we discussed teacher retention and the number one goal of our Educators in terms of our budget is making sure that they have reasonable increases that is something that we fought for last time last year and we will continue to have to fight for that that is significant to have to compete with that and ask for additional funding for a program that is becomes in meshed in our school system is a burden I would not want to put on a future board that I will probably not be part of but I would not want to do that a logical decision a logical decision

132based on the Y's own comments is for the why to provide their services in their way of choosing in a setting of their choice with the ability to grow at its own pace in its own way to meet the needs of our community in an alternative location outside of the school division finally I'll say this the school board must remain dedicated to its designated responsibility of focusing on providing oversight and governance of Matthews County Public Schools it is up to each of us to see that every budget dollar and all of our superintendence efforts be tied to supporting improved achievement for the 760 enrolled students K to 12 in our schools members do you have anything else anything to add nothing okay all right I would like to call for a f minute break at

133this point board members yes yes yes agreed okay 5 minute break please we will resume at 8:20 thank you e e e a dayare CER now e can I speak oh thank you if we could have the board members re return to the tables please and those audience members who would like to stay please take a seat we're going to resume I apologize for the um extra 5 minutes thank you thank you thank you all right we're resuming Dr Daniel thank you it's time for um item six superintendent informational reports beginning with the attendance update do you want us to scroll back to to that previous document on 4.1 if we wanted oh if we wanted to look at it 4.1 here but all right we'll turn yeah it's all in the same slide deck

134so folks again from home um who or who are looking online later um these are um it's all the same slide deck so what I'm going to go over and talk a little bit about is uh meals data and attendance data we haven't while it's not student achievement per se it's a way of looking at kind of like what are you know how are we doing within the School Division Etc um so um one of the things I have regular monthly meetings with our directors of various departments and have conversations about data and performance and the health of their various departments and how it's contributing to the school division so part of what I started asking uh Miss Lindberg to do was preparing sort of um meal served data for us to look at while

135our enrollment goes down how are we doing under the C in terms of reimbursement um how are we going about feeding um feeding our students and meeting meeting those um kind of nutritional needs so what Miss limberg uh does is provide me U meal served last year versus meal served this year by month so what you have in front of you is the number of meals served in September of the 24th 4 25 school year on that top um just below that is September of last year a piece to keep in mind that I didn't put on the graph to over complicate but um from year to year the number of school days during a month may change so it may be 19 days or 20 days or 21 days or 17 days depending on

136on the month obviously they're not going to be as as many school days in December as there are in say October or um March so um so within probably on those months um shown on the screen within probably one day difference year to year we're talking about the same number of days so this year um we are up in especially in September in terms of meals the number of meals served this year versus meals served last year the difference is about 2300 additional meals served um in September of this year versus last year excuse me that's incorrect um so the Delta um yeah it's about 2,300 um the difference in 2300 meals um served so in terms of additional Revenue that's about an additional $8,000 coming into the their food the Nutrition department Food Services

137Department um in October comparison of October October last year to October this year that increase um results in about $144,000 an additional um Revenue coming in to the Food Services Department um that difference in November is not as great as there's only about 821 um difference in meals served so that's only about an additional um $190 and a lot of what goes into that is going to be um the cost isn't necessarily every meal doesn't cost the same to prepare obviously so depending on what foods come in what she's able to access in terms of suppliers what's reimbursable also part of that um um reimburse money or income into the Food Services is going to come from some alart items and things along those lines so it's not a straight um meal served directly equates

138to the number of the The increased Revenue so it's meal served as one thing but we also are looking at Revenue generated during that month so not every part of the re revenue generated is directly from meal served or reimbursement for meal served if that makes sense because I'm looking at some like um some questioning sorts of of faces when we look at the meal served so the main thing for me to share this is each month this year we're feeding with less kids more meals to students um so whether that's breakfast or lunch in addition to that we're also the cafer is also generating more Revenue each month um than they did last year same month Mr doson the uh I know you all started like a snack program is that included in this

139so um there are alart items included in this um and then there's also um Regular breakfast and then there's also Second Chance breakfast at the elementary school and the high school um we've kind of pushed pause on the Middle School Second Chance breakfast for right now so we'll have conversations about the merits of Second Chance breakfast at the middle school and supervision and things along those lines um but right now we um excuse I don't think we're doing it at the elementary school are we doing second chance at the elementary school okay all right and one other question um what are we getting what are we getting back on the dollar I knew you'd ask me that um and she gave me that number and I didn't include it in the slide I don't know

140I'll how about this I'll email it to you tomorrow sure I apologize that's something I should know with the reur can't keep all them num sorry too many numbers tonight too long a day yes ma'am so this is how much Sor this is how much money we're receiving but on and I know that's not all the things the focus of this but but our expenditures I mean is it making a difference as far as what we're spending and what we're receiving like we're making a little more profit my my impression is that our profit the profit margin is up in terms of cafeteria yes thank you yes does is that the same thing as saying we are on budget yes okay I have a question for you miss Lindberg and I spoke about this she

141was very excited as she is about everything always she's wonderful she attributes the increase in the meals participation I think she doesn't like to toot her own horn but in part due to she's being very creative with meals um she's building relationships with students and food and the whole and the whole thing she's very excited that these numbers are going up would you agree with that or do you have other pieces to that puz completely I mean she having conversations with students about what their favorite meals are she's doing some taste testing with students she's thinking outside the box um she's being responsive she's also having to juggle a ton with supply chain issues and so what she has planned in many cases like for example the chicken nuggets weren't on the truck this week

142and so she's got a pivot and offer some other things she's being um smart about how she's um you know everybody uses leftovers but she's smart about how does she kind of use ingredients um in multiple settings so hamburger can we use hamburger on this hamburger on that um in terms of multiple ingredients and recipes um and so she you know she just whoa um but sorry um so she's just she's engaging in relationships with students having conversations with students responding to feedback um just being smart and intelligent about her budget and purchasing items and when to purchase kind of more expensive things um to gauge interest and how to kind of stretch stretch a dollar at times the kids don't want to hurt her feelings but she encourages them to give them their true

143feedback so she can improve the situation make it more appealing for them she's very very creative and um proactive and then she I mean she incentivizes kids I mean she's good to kids um like I mean the the cookie piece at the elementary school and rewards and you know she'll recognize students at the high school for various achievements and events and we'll have you know special lunches or breakfasts um to celebrate students at different locations great food good yeah I i' I've eaten over there many times and for for school food the food's pretty good okay um so a little bit about attendance last month we talked about um attendance and um the ability for folks um to to see it if the if they don't have access to their computers to see the report

144in board docs um so this is October's data so one of the key pieces that I look at is um the fourth I guess one two three four the fifth column from the left so the number of at students at risk for being considered chronically absent and so what uh Miss Thomas does our school social worker who generates this report for me she looks at where we are currently this month with where we were this month last year because that number for at risk is theoretically going to continue to increase as we add more days to the school year there's more opportunities for students um to miss days so in October it's pretty alarming to look at okay last year there were 33 students at risk at the high school this year were at 60

14522 and 22 for the Middle School in 51 and 28 um so that's one of the pieces that I look at so when we go to November it then looks like we're getting a bit back on track in terms of what we where we were last year ideally we want lower numbers this year compared to last year as we want want those at risk for being considered chronically absent to continue to go down um but at this point right now we're at about on Pace for where we were last year at the high school we're slightly up at Thomas Hunter but markedly improved at the elementary school in terms of this month compared to last month I'm looking at um students in Jeopardy of chronic being considered chronically absent again that's 18 um being considered

146chronically absent is missing 18 days um of the school year so it's missing 10% of the school year yes ma'am I feel like I'm I'm I'm just not getting this because it's gone down how can it go down when you have when you have Thomas Hunter you had 22 at risk um in October okay and how can you have less the next month is it by month you understand what I'm saying okay I don't know that 16 in November and 22 in October so you have less students at risk so how can you when you're at risk how can you back out that's a great that's a really good question I don't think I picked up that that detail when I put it in there so I'll have to go back and get some more

147V get some more clarification on that thank you sure and regarding the 12 chronically absent at at the high school in November do we have any idea what this was last year um I would have to go back and um check to see exactly where we were at this point last year I don't I don't know could we could we look at doing that for for the next time where we're doing attendance can we do not only all the columns compared chronologically but a year-over-year comparison not that it's I don't know if it's meaningful but I think it it might be I'm just trying to um ensure that the attendance policy I know there are more components but the theend attendants policy is still working right or if it needs to be reviewed we need

148to tweak it or do other things right okay that's all for me on that good thank you tiny I'm sorry tiny house okay we we're going to be having item 6.3 now the tiny house update okay so a bit um a bit of update regarding our tiny house um I just wanted to start with a bit of clarification often times at um in conversations uh regarding the tiny house or our CTE programs at the high school our carpentry program can be referred to as Building Trades that's kind of a historic um name but and to be completely factual and accurate it is a carpentry program um Building Trades tends to bring in other trades requires different um lure and um different components so I just to make sure that we're being accurate when we talk

149about tiny house you can um it's part of our carpentry program and part of that tiny house is to expose our students to other skills and other trades but the class is still a carpentry class um so at this point um tiny house we've raised approximately $14,000 through contributions from the community the goal is to get us to about $40,000 we've been having conversations about um codes in lining up building codes and residency codes for um within our region so Matthews Gloucester middlex um we've also had conversations about um in terms of selling the tiny house once complete where can we sell that so we've had conversations with um some individuals associated with FEMA um to construct a tiny house to then have it um sent to the mountains of North Carolina for um hurricane

150can victims we've had conversations with um tentative conversations with um a possible buyer who wants to locate to actually purchase two um to locate in another locality within Virginia so we're looking at different options whether somebody can kind of pre-order to get us through to get us started rather than continuing to look at raising money but we are still um very much moving along the path path of um getting getting that tiny house on underway um that's exciting it is it's very exciting it's a great project um you know as most new things we require a little bit of working working through some of the Kinks um but we are working through those um pretty rapidly and the more people who find out about it the more um conversation we get the more phone calls

151the more emails and um ideas that we get in terms of trying to find solutions for some of the challenges that we're coming into and you also got some historical work going on so they're doing a lot of interesting things in the carpentry class so they're working on repairing historical shutters um they're working on some boat building um they're building you know individual student projects so they're um they're looking at lots of different ways and again going back to some of our budget Workshop they're looking at opportunities to generate a little bit of profit to continue to bring those profits into the program for students to continue to develop skills and all that you know the craftsmanship that comes comes with that carpentry program can you let us know how much um money so far

152has $14,000 $14,000 has been donated to the tiny house project correct in from the community from the community at this point yes wonderful yes great news thank you um 6.4 some um updates regarding our volunteers so the elementary school and the middle school have dedicated staff members who are Point people for our um coordinating volunteers um I think I I heard um earlier today I don't it was during one of the speakers or something along those lines so coord I think it was when Mr doson was talking about kind of the room mother piece um somebody had mentioned I think that well there's there's some work for teachers to have and um and kind of organize the the room mother that's the same um challenge with you've got a plan often times with volunteers so

153as especially in the elementary school as our elementary teachers are working through VA and a lot of the new challenges um being able to plan then for the volunteer um is a bit of a challenge however um we're working on solutions to coordinate volunteers coming into the LI both libraries middle school and Elementary School I think we have some at the elementary school we have some book fair volunteers lined up up um I think we also have a pretty cool um therapy dog um program that's coming in so we've got some volunteers um with with a super deliciously cute dog coming in to do some uh reading with students um the elementary school is also starting a math closet so there's kind of a dedicated volunteer to coordinate the signing out of kind of math

154games for students to take home and do math games with their families uh we have a volunteer who's part of the interventionist team in the literacy program and the Intervention Program who comes in um a lot of hours a week um and she's part of that system already but she is volunteering all of her all of her time um they's still the elementary school and the middle school are still looking for ways in the right fits for a lot of volunteers the widespread component of bringing in you know a fleet of like eight citizens to come do something requires preemptive organization and planning that that's still a challenge um it's almost like doing the lesson plans for a sub when you know you're going to be out um for for some of our teachers um

155at the middle school we've had volunteers coming into our technology classroom helping with some of the robotics pieces U volunteers coming into our family and consumer Sciences class and our band class and again working on kind of kind of the library piece um really at the high school our volunteers are essential to our Athletics program so from taking tickets um helping in the athletic boosters and concessions um and things along those lines there is um no way that we could run the Athletics program that we do without the volunteers and Miss O'Neal she's kind of the person I'm trying to coordinate all of those Athletics um volunteers and making sure we've got people at all the stations and all the places so it's you know it's growing it's getting there I think as trust builds

156and as especially in the elementary school as our teachers become more um I think I referred to it as fluent with science of reading and VA and our textbook they're going to be better able to I guess what I would say see around the corner to um plan for here's how I think a volunteer can come in and assist me um so it's they're still thinking about it but I think they're right now it's keeping their heads above water with all the all the new things that are happening but but we do have volunteers ready at the ready when if that does happen we have a list of volunteers we vet all the volunteers they have to go through all the um the the background checks um currently our Schoolboard office is vetting all of

157the the basketball coaches and all the volunteers to help coach our youth basketball program um so we screen all of those um applicants so um we're utilizing a ton of volunteers um in the school and there we I think our teachers know their Folks at the ready it's kind of making that making that connection with skill set and time with need classroom need and ability and um time for the teacher to plan appropriately and then once that happens it becomes kind of a trust and a predictability piece okay so information some Schoolboard information so before you are um our financial reports our expenditure reports um thing to keep in mind is our grade three through five science instructional materials adoption timeline along with our nutrition and wellness instructional material adoption timeline so for um you

158all to take notes um of those and then also the um statement of conflict of interest um criteria just keeping that in mind that we need to complete those and submit those I Believe Miss um La sent some um just explanation on some of the expenditures and trying to anticipate again seeing around the corner but trying to anticipate there were any questions or concerns that um you know stood out so I think she sent out some responses or kind of some clarifying information to that so yes okay uh you going to teach people how to tie boats down am I going to do what how to tie boats down the Cru sh uh I don't think you want me teaching anybody how to tie a boat down that's not that's not going to end well

159we we bought a boat right yeah so that's yes so I think that's part of what we say part of crew is that what that was somebody somebody secure went down a rout Insurance paid for that oh yeah so yeah okay now I'm all right now I'm picking up what you're putting down okay 149 yes MH okay okay okay any last questions for Dr Daniel item six in the six section nope all right all right moving on to item seven School Board informational reports we'll start off with 7.1 assessment of school [Music] buildings and I I think this is a timely thing that we need to discuss publicly as and Dr Daniel if you wouldn't mind giving an update on kind of what's what has happened regarding not rfps exactly but um trying to get

160service providers into do the very beginning steps of determining the health and safety of our building so we can start building information uh that will guide us in our decision making with the consolidation process so from our joint meeting with the Board of Supervisors in early November the request that I think Mr walls referred to and the goal for us to have a a pretty solid recommendation by December of 2025 on what uh we will be requesting from the supervisor so in order to do that in kind of backwards plan U we needed to send out a request for for bids and I guess there's two tiers of doing that the common is a request for proposal or an RFP or you can also do what's called an informal solicitation so um in collaboration with

161um Ramona Wilson the County Administrator I developed a informal solicitation bid for a facility study of our three schools to give us an idea of um renovation costs versus new construction costs um we can pull the data that's coming from the investment grade audits that the county is currently doing on our buildings to help inform that process um but the we should be receiving proposals the deadline was the end of January um hopefully I can bring proposals to the board in February for approval um to begin that facility study process um I've been in conversation or answering questions with at least one firm um currently who's inquired and who's interested um right now in performing the work um just giving some clarification um to that individual on kind of what what we're trying to do

162um I've also reached out to a firm and scheduled a time to um get a second opinion on um asbest and because part of part of what we're going to have to look at with any sort of renovation or or even new construction is going to be what do we how do we handle the existing Es as bestas that we know is in the buildings it's encapsulated um but we wanted to get um additional information as to kind of where and how much and um because that's going to inform our costs related to renovation or any other projects um so we have a firm who's coming in on January 3rd it worked out as a pretty good day we don't necessarily have kids we have some staff back in the building um so we can

163begin some of that we can take samples in different areas um I'm also going to request um just do some air quality analysis in different classrooms in different parts of the building so where we may have had questions about mold or humidity or anything else let's go ahead and get some um air quality um samples taken while the while the firm is on site to give us just give us the information to hopefully confirm what we believe to be true um but if not then we know how to adjust and move forward so how about a water quality test can we get that done um we tend to have water quality done pretty regularly through Sidner um they um I've only ever seen one test done that was about three years ago okay I'll see

164what I can pull for you because one of the tests had me concerned was no I mean we have to I mean in terms of we have to do regular like lead and copper it had a lot of mdle yeah I mean we do we do lead and copper annually so we have to um provide that to the state and lead and copper test results to V one of those reports I saw was like 750 and that's extremely high okay Dr Daniel regarding the uh a Fus refresh me is that firm going to be looking at the high school and the middle school current okay sorry go ahead and finish just the Middle School currently I have them scheduled just to come to the middle school right now I can um I think I can

165have them part of what they asked of me is kind of laying out specific areas um to look at and either pull samples from materials that we suspect ECT or no has um asbest we're also we we engage in a three-year I think it's called a oara but because we know there's asbestos they come every 3 years and do um a visual inspection of the identified areas with espb bestas to make sure it's encapsulated it's in good quality um it meets all the criteria codes and regulations surrounding asbestos in place um what what I'm asking them to do is um come in and do some additional um sampling of materials to confirm does this have as besta senate or does it not and so we can remove some of the I think it is I'm

166not sure it is and also remove um any kind of concern especially at Thomas Hunter uh we we think that's a you know anything anything that is white and Dusty often folks think is asbestos and that may may not be the case case so we want to get um multiple parts of the buildings get um samples and confirm kind of what's going on tile under the floor down the end of this hallway has Aus and it's starting to break up you saw that so what what I will need to do in terms of the high school is kind of coord go back and look at the high school O'Hara reports and then also have conversations with Dr grieve about areas that we may have concerns then move through that part of the building and I'm

167pretty sure I can schedule um another visit with them it's it's a pretty reasonable um expense um to coordinate that yeah and thank for bringing that up um Dr Gibbs because you know there was that huge renovation um now 20 years ago but but there were some spots in the high school that were not renovated in the original part of the building and um I know the school counseling office was not renovated part of that and I don't know some of those original classrooms um how if that was actually R gut it and renovate or not I you know the ones that go around the library I just don't know if some of those I think those just to be sure that would be the area that I would be concerned about the high school

168the other areas are are more um 1970s they were they were built so um I don't think there's a problem there and with this be the firm also that would address um assessment of mold at the elementary school yeah the same firm can do both okay they're not scheduled for the third to do that so so currently right now I'm I've scheduled them to be on this campus to look at asbest and mold on this campus I currently have not scheduled anything for the high school or the elementary school I've scheduled when I say this campus I mean the middle school and the elementary school Sor okay great I I do have a I I guess I'm perplexed as to they're they're going to some samplings like identified areas that we we think there might

169be asbest is that do I understand that correctly or will they go so two types of samplings so um air quality to see if there's any particulate okay in the space along with hey can you check this tile and tell me if this tile component has asbest or not so we have to say check this tile or check that tile we correct correct this wouldn't be an inspection where they're going up into they're popping every sealant tile or they're scurrying through it hey can I'm directing where they're going to go and take samples to confirm um or refute what we what we think is going on and so I'll have the O'Hara reports um that have been done to help guide those locations um but in terms of crawling through everywhere um that's that's not

170what this inspection has been ear marked for okay I just didn't know if we knew the areas that were like I think we have some I mean I think we have a pretty good um a pretty good handle on where we'd want to go I mean we're going to want to go to the kind of the 8 in the any room that has 8 in floor tiles uh we want to look at some of our ceiling um decking some of our ceiling tiles we're going to go into the boiler room and look at insulation on some piping from 1950 um to check on those pieces thank you so sure do we feel do we Sorry do we feel that that this will be definitive is this is this going to be a great enough sampling

171do you think to make to inform these these big decisions this is this is where I'm going I'm not saying you're not an expert on asbest I'll say I'm not an expert on um I will it give us will it give us a cost for um a full abatement of one of our schools no right um I think in terms of will it give us a current measure of health and safety yes for where we are cuz um in terms my while not an expert my understanding for asbest is so long as it's encapsulated it's not in a Frable State it's not being ground down into a dust it's it's not harmful it's when it's um when it's being ground down and getting into it's it's breaking it's getting you're grinding it it's moving into

172to a dust and the the particles are in the air where it becomes quite hazardous to be exposed it could be encapsulated but it's breaking down it'll enter the air then okay it's it's goes by like so many parts per Mill or something like that and that's how it's measured so I think we can go to the classrooms where we have concerns test areas where and we can do a little bit of evaluation um and there the expense isn't great so we can schedule return visits and have them come out and test other areas and hey have you can we check this room that space whatever so I mean I have you know I can coordinate with Miss Simpson and our custodial and our maintenance staff to like hey where are the rooms where are

173the spaces where we have the concerns and also you know if we want to take samples um where you know can we do that when the room isn't occupied like I don't know we wouldn't go breaking up a bunch of stuff to take samples um to get ATT tested for for asbest when there a bunch of people in there obviously so wouldn't look good again not an expert but I don't I think that would be a bad idea I agree just are there any more questions on at the stage in the game on this okay this will be an I'm sure even if in brief and ongoing subject that we will be discussing as we want to maintain full transparency with the community uh about this process moving on to 7.2 you have your notices

174of Schoolboard conferences and webinars um and we do have a red line there on Mr Morgan and Mr Dobson for your ethics Coya training due this month both of you I need I thought I did if please see Miss Morgan if you have any questions wonderful I did one of those last month discuss with her um at a at yes at another Moment In Time item 7.3 we have board and committee reports by the Schoolboard members and the superintendent uh again um members you'll see that we will will not be filling in the meeting dates for the Board of Supervisors meetings until our January meeting so we will forego on that after we reorganized in January but um I do believe that this is where um Mrs Hodges and maybe Miss Diggs and I also

175would like to report on the experience at the vsba conference and the uh s spma conference so with that sound good well let me get mine out of the way because Mine mine's very mine's very part is very boring and very dull um I do want to um mention that I I was the delegate um to the vsba um their annual meeting and um in the meeting it's it's primarily Accolade for people who have done um certain things over the last year and they've spent a lot of time recognizing them but they always have um bylaws or proposed changes to their vsba bylaws and I um what I am proposing is that next year or every year in October whoever the um delegate is that they bring these to this board so we can have

176a conversation about how we want the delegate to vote I did not do that in October so I felt like I wasn't sure what the wishes of this board were were when these amendments came up um and that was my that was my responsibility I I did not I did not do that so I if we put it as a standing item for our October meeting then we'll know whoever the delegate is that they can bring that information forward um there were four uh proposed amendments two of them passed two of them did not the ones that did not pass um one was um asking about an ex including an ex officio members of the uh vsba um board and that did not pass because it was and I'd be glad to answer all questions

177but for the um for time constraints um it did not because it was not clear enough exactly who should be an ex officio member how long they would serve there were just a lot of questions that were not answered in the proposal and so that was not U supported the second one they wanted to switch um has to do with our regions and when we um as you know we're in the Eastern region and we make um proposals as to who um we want to elect every two years to represent our region and then to uh move forward to the vsba board and they wanted right now they're doing it at the uh fall and they wanted to switch it at to the re the spring regional meeting um and and that did not pass

178as well because they felt like these um the fall excuse me I'm saying it backwards the spring meeting is better attended than the fall meeting um and so they wanted to make sure they were consistent with having someone that was well represented at the meet at the regional meetings and not one when there was least attendance at it so it did not pass because I felt like too many people were not at the ones that they were proposing so that did not pass the third one just had to do with taking parenthesis out of an an Amendment and it was just really um just that was the only piece it had to do with the membership excuse me a typo a typographical error on indemnification and the last one had to do with membership and

179dues um and that did in fact pass um about members suspended for non-payment of dues may be reinstated by the board of directors at any time that was removed from um the the um the amendment so any questions very an interesting information so I did ask Miss Morgan to please include next October um to provide this board with um the Amendments so we could have input for the delegate to better represent our County great idea yes perfect M digs okay um it was my first year attending the school board um conference over in Williamsburg and I am I'm so glad I went because it was extremely informative um these ladies went on a day earlier than I did but anyway I spent a day and a half there and I'm so glad uh for the

180information that I got from the different um workshops that were offered um we all went through and I think we were trying to split up to cover our ground um a couple of workshops I went to I ended up getting up and leaving because I wasn't getting the information that I needed um that I expected I should say anyway overall they were excellent and the very um and you got I got to meet people from you know the other parts of Virginia and get their input and insights and wealth of information most of the time on what was happening in their school district um the last day was probably the most impressive for me there was a lady from Washington State who spoke um at the final meeting and she was raised in poverty in

181Washington state for 26 years of her life uh with her brothers and sisters and Mom and Dad and her presentation to us was absolutely captivating to me I I spent some years in Africa and one comment she made she has she has spoken in the states um widely but she's also spoken in different countries and she said if you ask a child in Malawi uh what they want most they want education they want to go to school if you ask a child in the United States what they want most it's the latest Tech equipment and she said the reason for those answers of course is because those children want to fit in and having lived in Africa for a few years and seeing the poverty in so many of those areas um she's right on

182with that comment and uh here I think right on with the comment as well but um it was it was very impactful to me and I'm very glad that I went thank you I I also went to the vsba conference and I found the law session which I think most all of us attended except for Miss Diggs um was was extremely informative um however I do want to mention that three of the board members also belong to an alternative support Organization for school boards and that is called the Schoolboard member Alliance and I attended that two-day event as well in December and um I so in a way that was a good compare and contrast uh vsba is a very large event um although not as large as it was last year I I don't

183don't believe sbma is a is a newer organization about two years old but the striking difference to me was um we did also s spma Drew school board members from throughout the state uh to discuss educational strategies and to share breast practices but specifically SP focused on student achievement and leadership development um and the speakers that were available to us at that event included Secretary of Education Amy guidera attorney general mayaras lieutenant governor winom Sears and Governor Yun yunan himself so it was really um exciting to hear uh more about the accountability framework uh and hopefully uh we will be getting Schoolboard training on the accountability framework as well as Dr Daniel gets superintendent training um there there was a um a request for Schoolboard members to be able to have some specific training from

184the state um on on that but anyway uh very um very good also to go to these kinds of conferences and learn from leaders in our state um and draw what you can to help improve your performance on your local school board so thank you for letting me share that and I think that's all the participation that we had in in those events so uh we'll move on to item 7.4 we are announcing that the Schoolboard Town Hall will be held on the next one will be held on February 25th at 6: p.m. in this auditorium at the Thomas Hunter Middle School and item 7.5 the next day February 26 there will be a Schoolboard winter work session and uh in the Chesapeake bank community room so that that'll be uh quite a busy week

185so again town hall on the 25th at 6 p.m. in this building and uh winter work session for the school board on the next day Wednesday the 26th 8 to3 in the Chesapeake bank community room moving on to item eight action items we have one action item tonight and this is the adoption of Schoolboard policies there are two policies that are up for adoption they're both being included on the same action item that we will be looking for a motion on and just as a reminder these were two policies that were presented for review last last month there has been edit made to the um to the uh uh standing committee uh policy so if just to make sure that you you know if you want to open those items up to review those and

186whenever you're ready uh I'll will take a motion and just so that the the community knows we are talking about two policies one that has to do with Schoolboard committees and one that has to do with the school board promotion of patriotism policy whenever the board is ready we'll entertain a motion I make a motion to adopt the school board committee policy um and the school board promotion of patriotism Poli policy as listed thank you do we have a second second thank you do we have discussion all right I know we're not going to change anything tonight but in your patriotism document here I know the Bill of Rights in the Constitution and guide We Trust are in the schools somewhere it sure would be nice to see them when you enter any of the

187fo years to the front of the schools as entrance so other words when you walk in the high school you would see it and when you walk in this building here you would see it and when you walk into Elementary School you would see it so I'd like to see that happen Mr Dobson may I just also say that there is policy on that that says that those documents are to be placed in highly visible locations in each School building I don't know you can't get any more highly visible than when you walk in the front door so I agree with you because I I I do not believe that that is where they are at the moment in all of our buildings right next item okay hold on yes they are they're in prominently

188placed at the entrance of your buildings at the elementary school and the high school and we don't have Middle School conf from October 27 that all principles responded that yes that posting requirement was met where are they located at the high school I don't see them when I walk in the building you got to go down the hall and go left you come in the front door they were on the right side they were on the right side have you ever seen them we'll all go check it out your trip okay it should be so everybody walks in that building sees them it okay confirm it tomorrow yeah confir all right thank you next item is students at the high school should learn flag ially other words they should post a flag in the morning

189and retire to colors in the evening that means run it up the pole the correct way bring it down correct way Fold It present it to the person that's going to take it in to rest for the for the next day it should be like a a detail a group of children once a week this will learn all about the flag and how to fold it how to take care of it we got a lot of people dive defending that thing so I think it would be a nice way to pay back to the country that high school students learn correct way with the flag I think it's very important and retiring the colors that's what you're doing by taking them down in the evening and I did this when I was in school by

190the way we took the flag down school was out at three we took the flag down folded it and then at uh 8:30 in the morning we shot it up the pole so it's it's been done in the past um I I don't see any problems um and I think it would be very very useful to the Youth of this country to learn learn about this then the next item I would like to for us to look at this is going to sound funny but I'm going to say it the national anthem I go to games and people stand there and you see them they forget the words so I think we need to teach children The Anthem and the reason it was written is just as important that was written by Francis Scott Key

191who was a prisoner on a British ship in the harbor of Baltimore and the reason he wrote that flag that song was CU When he woke up the next morning and looked out the flag was still flying and that's what that song was basically about the flag was still there so so that's some important history there that they need to look at and one other item because most people don't know this students should know what the song Taps is I thought Taps was a lot older song than what it was Taps was invented by a Union soldier during the Battle of seven pines and it was a union current and his bugler come up with that tune Taps and what Taps is is on an army base you'll hear Taps being played when the flag

192is coming down that is to retire to Colors the end of the day he was looking for a new a new song to come up with and I'm fortunate I've been around the world being in the military and everything one of the saddest in uh situations is I don't know if any of you been to a military funeral but when that song Taps is played tears still come to my eyes and I've been on at least 74 details where I was the person that had to present the flag to the Widow the wife the Father the Son the daughter and I have a little 45word speech I had to make that was was presented by the general to that person loved one and I never made it through that speech without choking up now I'm

193not saying the kids need to learn the speech but they they should understand what Taps was really intended for and I'll leave it at that that's that's some good work there thanks Mr Dobson any anyone else have anything to say small comment well just to the point about um the flag protocols we did talk about um at the end of the year after SOS were done is to bring someone in when to the students to to provide that information right so just the public knows that we we are addressing that yeah we had him during our last work session he was from American Legion or BFW American Legion Mr Joe Adare and he is more than willing to work with us and the leadership of the schools to begin a student Le flag raising program

194so that would that would be a wonderful addition um Mr Morgan did you have any comments or no I do not M digs sorry do you have comment I I just wanted to highlight a couple of things if anybody um has a chance to review this policy it does imply uh field trips to local places but not limited to gwin's Island Museum the American Revolution museum at Yorktown historic Jamestown and Colonial Williamsburg will be conducted to promote and celebrate our nation's history and finally with regard to patriotic holidays the superintendent shall ensure that appropriate observances are indicated on the school calendar and are scheduled each year on or about the dates of Memorial Day Patriot Day and Veterans Day in order to convey the meaning and significance of each each day to all students and

195staff if there's no more discussion maybe we have a vote all those in favor say I I all those opposed motion passes item nine citizens comments on items discussed during the meeting do we have anyone who would like to approach the podium [Music] hold please we are having a microphone issue so just wait wait one second I would say as a very old scout I believe FL that's that's right that's correct that's right and the American Legion Burns Flags once once a month so you turn it over to them and prop a protocol for burning the flag [Music] yes thank you Mr Anthony okay um again this is with regard to the preschool SL dayare whatever you're going to call it um just some comments on the liability um one of the studies that I

196saw or discussions on the um that that I read uh is they mentioned disadvantages to children being in daycare preschool one of them was decreased time with parents but the other one was accidents so I bring this up just to say you know if you've got younger children they're going to be accident prone and there can be a problem and also I think a lot of people mentioned Thomas Hunter um not because they really believed that the space was going to be provided for the daycare or the preschool in Thomas Hunter but just because it seems to be well known that there are so many problems with the infrastructure there and if you have to renovate or raise it then you're going to lose all that classroom space so it's just that much less space

197for for uh children K through 12 so why would you want to go ahead and okay a daycare preschool situation when you know that you are very likely going to be facing uh problems with um with space in the school um also this program that the Y is proposing is not enrolling high-risk um children at least not at this point it's first come first serve and the high-risk students a lot of times are the ones that show up better on these studies as far as Improvement in in academics and when you're looking at some of these studies you can find studies that support Head Start or preschool programs and then studies that that negate them and just bringing up one article that I saw this was um they allude to a uh 2016 study of

198children in Tennessee Statewide preschool program and this is reading from that study the tenness C study found that participants did worse academically several years into school into school than those who had not participated so I'm just bringing this up because it sounds like a wonderful idea and I'm really for I know we need daycare we need preschool but the why seems to have a lot of money I don't see why they can't find the money to rent space elsewhere because the funding um issues are huge the next few years with the schools here um trying to retain the teachers um and change the way that that funds are allocated to the schools uh by the state it seems very inequitable and the rural counties are suffering so I think that the school board has their

199hands full um right now and take on another program seems to me um not a good idea anyway thank you that's all I had to say Thank you Mr Dyer long night long night um I had a question about the survey you brought it up last night last month you brought it up this month and you said7 17 responded and I'm saying out of how many out of how many 8,000 surveys went out or did just 770 that they responded that they wanted this miss the why so the Y sent right the Y sent the survey so I used they requested that I help distribute the survey so it's it's a YMCA survey it wasn't a School Division survey so I can't I can't speak it was only YMCA so the YMCA is the one

200who um created the survey I helped in the dist there were two surveys so the YMCA did a survey and I believe um mcap the Matthews committee against poverty also submitted a survey related to child care and and daycare and preschool um needs so go out to all the citizens it didn't it was available to all the citizens excuse me I'm sorry it was available to all citizens what we were trying to do was use the School Division email to kind of help get the word out to get people to take the survey so it I don't know a person that got the survey okay I I'm just saying and Miss stigs mentioned it twice anyway um and I don't understand why we have to have it in this facility like you said you don't

201understand our view that we wanted it outside the facility so I can't understand why you would want it in the facility when the Y has said they would gladly go outside and establish a facility so that's my point and also I had a question on the um interventionalist you said they're hired Interventional list are hired so we have staff members who are designated as interventionists so on the um on the slide that I believe you're referring to so one of the interventionists is a volunteer um one is part-time and then uh one One is paid part-time and then we also have Tas who are designated as interventionists who are um and they have they have designated groups so it's not like we're rotating a kid between five different interventionist at any given time so they

202have specific groups that they are working with on on a regular basis but involved in the school system I'm sorry they're already involved in the school system they're not brought from the outside correct okay and also I had a question my question is a lot of questions about the town hall we only got to ask ask one question at the Town Hall my question is at the next town hall can we ask more than one question because I had about four so and my suggestion is if you have a lot of people that have a lot of questions I understand that the time has to be limited but if the time that you put a fourth for the town hall is not used can you have people come back and ask a second question thank

203you oh oh one other thing one other thing Bobby Bobby Bobby usually you speak too much and I do too so I have that fault also I love everything you said about patriotism every single thing it's very very very important our country is failing our children and we no longer have the pride in our country that we should have so Bobby please keep talking I wake up every day and thank to dear Lord I was born here thank you dear Lord for a free to free country Miss fry Miss Diggs would like to respond to you may I um yes to explain my point of view um having been in the classroom in these schools here also it seems to me that with young children probably any age but with young children that where they

204are if they start over here at the elementary school for example uh with this program if that were to happen it and from what I have read too because I have done some research on this um that they are more comfortable in without having to transition from one location to another how much much that is I don't know but think about think about your own children perhaps when they were young and the transition maybe with us what I had read has been they are more self-confident and the statistics have been given out tonight but there are a lot of positives with the children being in the same location they know where the bathroom is they know where the cafeteria is they know where Miss ashbury's room is or whoever is going to be there kindergarten

205teacher and so from that aspect that is why I made that comment well from my personal aspect and not my children because I put my personal aspect on my children I came out of the orphanage and went right into kindergarten it was great it was great kindergarten through the third grade was on the first floor we were not allowed to go on the second floor until we were finished third grade and that was exciting to go to that second floor this is how I feel about daycare if you're in daycare preschool or whatever you are so excited about going to that big school oh I'm going to go to the big school my kids went to to uh Elementary School in poan we only had three schools then they were so excited to move on

206to the Middle School so it's not not not that you have to be stabilized you can be excited about moving on and moving up I hear you the other aspect of that since we are trying we would love to have more families and more children here in Matthews County once they start in a location they are not likely to leave this preschool to go for example to monu and so we can main them here as we so want to dok you you know how much a better retention is if our school is showing good grades and superiority if we have the school that promotes this and we have high Achievers that's what going to get the people to stay here yes Miss fry thank you for your comments I do want to just add that

207I will um review the town hall uh instructions once again they seem to be edited every time but I will look into that based on our last EXP experience that's a hard job thank you all oh thank you do we have anybody else who'd like to approach the podium Mr Richard Hicks from North Virginia uh do I get 10 minutes also no okay special treatment I'm going to talk about water for a minute I happen to hold a class 4 Waterworks uh license in the state of Virginia and you mentioned somebody asked a question about water uh you have a Virginia Department of Health office of drinking water they regulate your water system you probably have a PWS ID number a seven digit the first four digits going to be 4073 I don't know what

208the last three are you probably also have separate ID numbers for each systems that' be the high school and then whatever water system you have here U soural Services building is taken care of by waterpro and Gloucester maybe you want to contract with them instead of H sner um you're probably having monthly bacteria tests uh probably every three years you're doing Metals inorganics lead copper you're probably doing something called nitrate nitrite uh yearly you're probably doing radon every three years and you're probably doing a wellhe head Source test uh once a year and we fall under the NAA District district engineer a young lady named Renee Hall and if you want to get a hold of me and have me look at whatever paperwork you have I might be able to you know give you

209some ideas what you have in hand and by the way um they Senor is probably doing a lot of doing your testing for you and I don't know if you see the results the state sees the res results uh Renee Hall gets those results if you get a pro if you have a problem somebody's getting an email and if you have a bacteria failure you'll really get an email and and I also add uh everybody gets all excited about bacteria failures it's just as easy to have a bacteria failure because somebody did a sloppy job of taking a sample all you got to do is is is look at that sample sideways and it'll get contaminated so don't with people get all excited of failing bacteria it's just just as likely you just didn't do

210a good job of taking it thank you thank you Mr thank you Mr Hicks is there anyone else who'd like to approach the podium there be none we will move on to um item 10 Schoolboard member reports do any of you have a report to give tonight I do there be none there being none we will move on to item 11 closed meeting may have a motion may I have a motion I make a motion to enter into closed meeting in accordance with the Virginia Freedom of Information Act section 2.2 3711 print a print one discussion or consideration of personnel matters uh professional staff resignations support staff appointment and intermural basketball volunteer coach appointments section 2.2 3711 print a print 2 discussion or consideration of admission or disciplinary matters concerning students in section 2.2 3711

211PR aint 7 cons consultation with legal counsel and briefings by staff members or Consultants pertaining to actual or probable litigation thank you do we have a second second is there any discussion there being none all those in favor say I I opposed we are now in closed session [Music]

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.