CorpusRecord 13493

MCPS Budget Work Session 12/17/2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Board Tube
Date
2024-12-18
Location
Mathews County, VA
Material
Transcript
Extent
9,448 words · about 53 min
Collected
2026-06-04

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001good two minute warning everybody good okay I hope I have enough battery I have 50 50 I'll be all right wow so nobody nobody's going to show up yeah I'm certain citizens or otherwise okay well the door wasn't unlocking properly so that Sharon went back to check is the door opening now okay people waiting outside I I came in fine okay okay I was maybe we were just a few minutes earlier than the set maybe okay maybe you can't program it open till after 3:30 or something oh you more new learning for me today I've had enough I think thank you Sarah good afternoon I'd like to call to order the December 17th 2024 Matthews County Schoolboard budget work session and Public Employee requests for the 2025 2026 school budget item two we'll begin with

0022.1 with the public budget requests is there anyone who would like to approach the podium regarding public or employee requests for the 2025 2026 school budget good afternoon thank you uh my name is Randy Applegate Matthews High School um I'm here to advocate for a line items funding specifically designated for consumables and competition needs for our CTE programs as you know CTE uh is a vital part of our students educational Journey providing them with Hands-On uh experience and practical skills that are critical to the workforce Readiness however unlike surrounding communities Matthews operates on a significantly smaller scale program that strives to meet the standards and outcomes to ensure our students receive highquality education instruction and training we are requesting a dedicated budget consideration for adequate funding to cover consumables and other learning Essentials one area

003of particular concern is the rising cost of materials in our programs while we have been fortunate to have been funded through several grants it is important to note that the grants are often content and items specific most grants don't cover consumables further further situations are different by program for example engineering has a lot less per student cost than carpentry engineering uses about $100 per student per year whereas carpentry is is significantly exponentially larger material cost as material costs continue to rise relying solely on grant funding creates unnecessary uncertainty and limits our ability to maintain quality scope of our offerings another potential issue that we face is the existence of the pay toplay scenario student fees while students may be asked to pay class fees for or a specific project cost to uh participate the model

004creates inequity and some students may not have the financial resources to cover these fees effectively limiting our access to to uh vulnerable learning experiences a lack of dedicated funding could exasperate this problem creating barriers for students who would otherwise thrive in our program additionally it is important to acknowledge the burden placed on our teachers some of our teachers feel like they are more of a sales staff or business owners rather than Educators as we spend significant amount of time fundraising seeking donations and managing costs instead of focusing on instruction this diversion of time and energy away from our teaching duties stresses the overall effectiveness of our programs and the quality of our student learning we are proud of what we have have accomplished with the resources that we have available to our program size and

005limited access uh to consumable funding this puts us at a little bit of disadvantage compared to other CT programs in the region securing a system in place for Budget that would provide stability and Equity enabling enabling us to sustain and grow our offerings to enhance student engagement I respectfully request the board consider working toward this allocation as a investment in our students by ensuring we have the necessary funding of consumables and essential student supplies we can continue to offer meaningful Hands-On learning experiences for our students as they grow and as they need to be able to thrive couple situations that have come up I don't know how much time I have but uh just real quick um we have students that uh are are underprivileged one in particular I'm thinking of is wanting to build

006a kitchen table for their trailer home we cannot fairly fund that for that particular student due to the five $600 cost of materials for the table um and it creates an inequity position for us to being able to offer that situation to other kids whereas if we are drawing from a pool we can better allocate funds to General resources for that class and people helping her on that project in the class just one situation um I have I failed to uh give this I do have some solutions that I typed up possible solutions all open for discussion but you know and the amount is somewhat you know up in the air but uh to be honest with you right now we're spending about $10,000 a year just on carpentry um the other programs not so

007much you know 50 $80 a student type thing uh but all that is coming out of individual specific grants that we write for our programs it's coming out of uh some big ticket grants that we get but there's very limit for instance that $125,000 grant that I got last year for the Building Trades program none of that could go to materials our Perkins fund none of that applies to consumables so we are limited in what we can do and a lot of the grants that we write are limited in the same way I'm going to give you a copy of basically what I just said and the solutions awesome thank you Mr Applegate oh is there anyone else who'd like to approach the podium good evening ladies and gentlemen uh Dr Daniel Miss Hunley ladies

008and gentlemen of the board um I too would like to request that our School Division incorporate a line item for additional funding for the CTE Department as you are all aware CTE growth is one of the components in our strategic planning and since we obtain Perkins funding based on student enrollment our grant money is relatively small and has to be rationed out amongst the current course offerings in the first two years of family and consumer science classes student fees in the amount of $10 per student were collected from grades six 7 and8 to offset the cost of expendable items such as food ingredients polyfill elastic detergent for washing dishes aprons and towels Perkins funds as you know cannot be utilized for these items this year no fees were collected from the nutrition and wellness students

009or any of the eighth grade students who were moved to the high school the lack of student fees cost my programs according to miss wheeler apprx o imately $775 this year alone as the board is aware I have spent the last three years fundraising and collecting material donations that the community has so generously provided which gave us things to start the classes with to stretch the financial donations and multiply what has been given I have used the student knife skills lab where they make soup to sell quarts of soup to make for faculty and staff earning back the cost of the ingredients and turning a small profit each time last year we hosted the Seahawk Cafe cart selling cookies donuts muffins coffee juice and cider to faculty staff and students earning back the cost of

010the ingredients and turning a small and profit small profit that could then be reinvested in each consecutive cooking lab each year I have used donated materials to host a make and take holiday ornament fundraiser during intermural basketball my FCCLA and FCS students have hosted concession sales to earn additional funds notifying the matth Community about taking my FCCLA students to State and national conferences rais thousands of dollars to enable students who would never have been able to afford to go the opportunities of a lifetime what the board may not be aware of is the time and hours that I personally have invested in speaking to local Civic organizations and collaborating with them to write grants twice a year my students and I volunteer with the weighted Angels organization at their stuffing parties wherein we are the

011beneficiary of the leftover polyfill that aren't used in the animals I bring them back in garbage bags full and they could use them uh as a free resource for their projects this free resource has enabled my students to make a variety of sewing projects but once it's gone more has to be purchased parents and community members have donated food line gift cards groceries and cash for purchasing ingredients part of building this program is showing the community what the students are doing with what has been given to them and that I and that I strive to be as Frugal and responsible as possible with every dollar we have made cookies for Meals on Wheels food trays for Matthews count high school prom refreshment for the stem expose Founders Day celebration The Art of Living exhibition and

012this Thursday night The Taste sites and sounds of the seasons band concert and electives exhibition all of which did not get reimbursed any kind of money came out of that this week alone we are baking the Christmas cookies that are on your tables a gift from us to you for for all that you do for us as well as the same for our bus drivers who are often overlooked at this time of year and we are also selling them by the Dozen again to offset the cost of the ingredients my students are not just playing in the kitchen they are experiencing firsthand how to shop prepare and be safe in a work environment and hopefully learning how to take a skill and turn it around into a profit each Food Lab costs anywhere from $100

013to $400 because of the number of students each what each Food Lab depending on the event and the amount of ingredients donated a 20 lb box of polyfill used to stuff pillows and and their pumpkins cost about $100 when it's not on sale that's for one box this year the students made repurpose recycle sweater pumpkins and pillows and we would have used approximately three boxes full just with that those two projects fortunately we were able to use what we had Don ated to us at this time it's all gone now I have to go by more one of the points from the strategic planning session over the summer was providing professional development opportunities for CTE teachers according to Mr Applegate Perkins funds are allocated on a rotating basis to the teachers which unfortunately leads to

014someone not having the opportunity to attend in the most recent CTE advisory council meeting discussions were had regarding the amount of time we as CTE teachers are spending outside of contract hours working to fund our programs not to mention the commitment to ensure that our students are provided travel opportunities that they might never get any other time elsewhere I have worked with students after school on the weekends over spring and summer vacation breaks to create develop and implement this FCCLA competition pieces that have earned both state and National recognition I have done this for my students not for me don't misunderstand however in years past I was not compensated for those additional hours I would like the school board to not only consider the line item in the upcoming budget for expendable items and professional

015development opportunities as well as a stipend to compensate those of us teachers for the hours we currently donate administering our Career and Technical service organizations which is an important competency outlined in the CTE list of student required competencies for each course thank you for your time and your consideration thank you Mrs Williams thank you yes thank you if you don't mind thank you members do you have any responses so far would we like Dr Daniel to move on to the survey um Mr Dobson I had talked to the mik went blank huh of Miss Williams Miss Williams That's I had talked to her about 6 months ago about trying to find funding for CTE materials because I think initially you charged what $10 up front correct sir $10 Ain going to go far and the

016amount that goes into it and I know they're always selling something always and that puts a lot of pressure on kids in my opinion other than the world I remember when I was in school I had to go sell stuff for because I belong to this so that puts pressure on kids and I don't like to see that especially younger ones and I don't think there's a reason why in a world we can't find some money to fund uh the cooking class and Mr Applebee's classes um it's uh I know we're strapped for money and everything but if they could do half of of the fundraising and get some money I think that would be a little bit better off and I know you're always busy I see you all the time you're busy and

017uh I understand that and we shouldn't we shouldn't have to do that that's my opinion Mr I'll speak to you too uh I just want to thank both of you for what you said today and thank you for your gift up here and I know these students they gain so much because we've listened to them you know and we've seen yours in action and um I I certainly am for uh what Mr doson has said trying to find the money for you guys and for your children push buttons Mrs Hodges um first of all thank you for taking the time to come and speak today um I do have a couple questions because carpentry is it's clear when you talk about consumables there could you just elaborate for me some of the other consumables and

018I I understand with your program what they might be some of the other uh classes and what those consumables might be so I have a better understanding as far as I'm concerned we have consumables in we do model homes in the architecture class that have the Mr Applegate I'm sorry could you take the podium please thank you as far as our our programs go uh other than carpentry um we have model homes that we build for architecture class that are you know 125 a piece we project those together but that's just one project and we we have uh scientific notebooks that we use for the engineering classes we have some modeling blocks that we use for 3D modeling to let them build different parts and uh those are wooden blocks that they are use and

019they end up at the end of about a 4-we project they keep the wooden puzzle that they build so um there's just things like that and it comes to the tomb of about $60 to $80 per student for my classes um the architecture is a little bit more than that um and Miss Hayes is similar hers aren't quite as much there she's about 40 to 60 per student in our classes but uh you know it all adds up uh to the tune of you know $2 $3,000 that we are basically having to go out and get ourselves or spend ourselves or uh whatever it is because it doesn't fall into a category from Perkins or somewhere else um but those are the type of things I I could get you a list i' be glad

020I just wanted to get a better better understanding um some some were more obvious than than others to me the cartridge for the color printers well I wondered if those part of it all those are considered consumables and okay and we just you know so so so from the I don't know if you two have talked but from um from for the CTE as a whole what kind of additional monies are you thinking you would like to be put in a line item in the budget for this next year what's your wish like to see what we can do um realistic it's about right now we're spending about 15,000 on on consumables give or take and that include um Miss Williams coures as a well yeah that includes all the money that I have oversee

021okay and I don't oversee a lot of her stuff because she's doing it a lot of it on her own okay and that's what we want to try to alleviate her having teachers having to do stuff on their own exactly so how much M William would you add to that mine usually runs somewhere in the neighborhood of 2,000 to 2500 a year in total in total yes is that just consumables that's consum I mean as to this point the only thing that I have asked Perkins for is a new refrigerator and a new stove and a cabinet to put the uh chemicals in because we had a safety issue but those are the only three thing and one KitchenAid mixer was bought by Miss bird before she left everything else has been either donated or

022fundraised or grant money not from the school okay thank you Mr Applegate what was the amount you told me I should have written it down you said 15,000 you said right now we're at about the $15,000 Mark yes for year I hadn't read that yet okay thank you and and what is your thinking about you know pay to play how I mean that's kind of a well if you're a student and want to take architecture class I've got three students in architecture each one of those you know is paying a100 $120 fee to take the class that's an exorbitant amount for some families um so you're talking the front end you're not talking about going to some competition or anything like that you're talking about just to be able to take the class yeah well

023okay I I Mis $30 of my $80 per k did is for skills USA or whatever we just this year we're going to do TSA but you know whatever the student organization is you know there's a cost for that for the student and that fortunately we can take some of that out of of Perkins um but then you've got travel fees and hotel and stuff that's not included uh that's not part of that plan so uh that comes up just happens to come up you know during the year and we got to figure out how to get get them or go out and fund raise or whatever it is so okay thank you so much this very helpful I got another question yes sir do you do any 3D printing do I do a lot

024of 3D printing you do a lot yeah what is the cost uh just a a spool typically c a typical of pla plastic right typically cost about $40 $40 to $48 depending on the type of material there's other types of materials which we're starting to get into like elastometric or the spongy stuff that's a little bit more you know stuff like that but I'll go through probably four spools a year um between the two machines um what I have not bought a lot of that we have the ability to buy now is engraving Metals for certificates and stuff like that we bought an engraver we paid for that out of funds you know from Perkins but we don't have the money to buy the materials for it so um you know it's a it's a

025cool thing and we've been doing little projects of cardboard and wood but we don't have you know does we're not meeting all the ability or the potential if you will of what we can do with the things that we do have now that 3D printer is that separate from the rest of the printers in the school system we actually have three in the high school we have three 3D printing units actually four two are three access Milling machines which do metal and uh wood and Plastics and stuff like that and then there's the small we have two small tabletop that do all the little figurines and gears and little little tiny objects they'll do stuff up to about a 8 by8 by8 uh build we have two of those uh Dr Daniels is that separate

026from your regular uh uh printers that we have contracts out on or is it with that no so our 3D printers are completely separate from any of the other copiers or printers that we have in the division it's a so it's you know the only students who are or employees who are going to have access to those are going to be coming through Mr Applegate or Mr Williams in on this campus all right now they're owned by us or we leas them no they're owned by us so we would use Perkins money to purchase those yeah most of them have been Perkins or Community Foundation money that's purchased and M Williams yes your refrigerator and oven or stove whatever you need does that have to be commercial grade not for not for current FCS and

027nutrition and wellness at the time we expand course offerings if that is on the table later for introduction to culinary or culinary one and two at that point it would have to be an OSHA certified commercial kitchen okay but right now I have a residential kitchen that I'm covered for the classes that I currently teach thank you uh Mr Morgan yeah just couple of brief comments um when I was teaching carpentry there was a a um course fee of $50 per student and that was intended to cover consumables such as drill bits saw blades you know screws Nails glue that sort of thing that you you know you're going to use up um it was not intended at that time to cover any materials for student projects reason being one student may build a project

028that cost $30 in material and one may build a project that cost several hundred and and I had that happen uh and I'm saying that to say that every year there was always a few students who could not or did not for whatever the reason pay the $50 fee and no one ever went after the money so to speak we were all of the opinion that let's give the student the opportunity to take this class and somehow it all it all worked itself out we built some projects we built backyard sheds gazebos at one point we built a ton of picnic tables and we'd make a very modest profit on those things and that profit went back into the fund for consumables um so I say all that to say I would have no problem

029whatsoever with school board finding money to cover consumables um because number one not every student pays the fee for whatever reason Maybe the family is just not able to pay it I don't know the circumstances uh so I would have no problem at all with that um and I don't know anything about uh consumables I mean about projects so to speak in your courses but in um in carpentry and probably some of Mr Applegates uh courses that he teaches maybe projects would vary in cost and I think we would almost have to look to the student or the parents and Guardians of the students to cover the cost of projects however I would certainly be in favor of covering the cost of consumables absolutely I agree one point that I disagree I guess with Mr

030Dobson is on the business aspect of the projects I think uh selling learning how to make something to sell to um make a profit and all of the benefits that go along with learning that I think that's valuable for children but I don't think that should be where you rely on getting your funds I think it is incumbent on the board to be able to seek funding for consum consumables at an appropriate level what I would be interested in seeing would be a proposed budget of sorts um be presented so that we could have a better idea there's a lot of numbers floating around and just one final one question regarding the architecture class Mr Applegate um at $120 per student has there ever been a student who has expressed interest in the class but

031was unable or did not sign up for the class because they they knew they were were unable to pay that fee that you're aware of not that you're aware of okay good thank you thank you any more questions or comments I appreciate your uh both being here and speaking uh on this topic and bringing this to our attention it's very important and Dr Daniel would you like to move into the survey results of sure thank you um I apologize to the board um I was anticipating some um representation from The Faculty staff advisory to help walk through the survey results so I'll I have access to the survey results so I'll kind of go over but I'll um follow up with a slide or the actual results so for the sake of our discussion right

032now I'll kind of read through some of the highlights from the survey but I'll follow up later with um some hard numbers for you all to take a look at um so the survey had 56 responses it asked some demographic questions um so basically the demographics were kind of what what school do you primarily work at um that was pretty representative of what our population um um where they work so about 34% is the high school um about 29% is the elementary school Thomas Hunter is about 21% and then we've got Transportation Office of special education cafeteria staff Schoolboard office Etc um so they were given a list of options um so they were asked to choose what is most important to you when considering budget requests for next year so they could pick one

033it wasn't kind of a rank order it was just what what of these items is the most important to you 53.6% said that salary increase in salary was the most important piece right now um the second at 28.6% was an increase in staff uh coming in third at 12.5% was facilities improvements and then the remainer were the remaining items were technology improvements health benefits increase in salary and staff and increase in clinic Supply budget so again the overwhelming at about just under 54% was salary increase going into this next budget cycle at 29 just under 29% was an increase in staff the survey also to offer an opportunity for respondents to add comments add clarifying pieces some um General um you know just general comments without doing a true qualitative analysis of all of it

034I would say just and glancing through it the last two days or so um it's making sure that salaries are competitive with our neighboring School Division staying ahead of cost of living staying ahead of inflation being able to recruit and retain teachers and as one of the as the main reasons for salary increases some of it gets into a little bit more detail in terms of looking at the individual steps that we've had some conversation about our steps as a reminder are 1% each step so do we need to look at an audit of some kind to move to a 1.25 or a 1.5% increase at each step um some of the Staffing concerns relate to really a reaction to where we've reduced in staff over the last year especially um they bring up the

035library they bring up um our advanced math program um there's requests for um additional teacher assistance one of the pieces that's highlighted with teacher assistance is um really related to substitute teachers and because when we have subs and we can't get subs then we're pulling Tas so then we don't have enough Tas to fill the subs when it's probably more of a we don't have enough Subs um kind of situation um but we're and then going talking a little bit about the facilities um piece it really um the bulk of those have to do with our elementary school and just the repeated issues at the elementary school the boilers turning off leaking classrooms I think um I'd have to go back and look at the spreadsheet there were a couple people who talked about it's

036always freezing in my classroom or it's always piping hot in my classroom so just looking at the um this one screen I don't know if that's a high school or an elementary school or a Thomas Hunter issue I'd have to go and look at the spreadsheet and kind of line line that location up with that comment and I had just haven't I didn't go into that much depth um prior to this so El schools a is a central system right correct it's a boiler system with fan cool units in the ceiling and hot water lines and cold water lines you shouldn't have no problem with heat if it's a boiler type system um there there are lots of problems currently with the with the elementary system in terms of you can have malfunctioning dampers and

037the pneumatic controls within those uh fan coal units um when the boiler goes off line then nobody's getting things so it's um it's a constant massaging of the two boilers and the burners and the pumps and then if one of them goes offline the temperature drops in the pipes then the pipes leak and then it's tiles and it's a series of unfortunate events the controls and stuff you're talking about we have a maintenance with with one of the companies correct why why aren't we getting stuff repaired we are I mean we're I've signed a PO for $111,000 today to get a pump the valves on a pump repaired so it's it's a 30-year-old piece of equipment that we've that we've replaced various parts on last year and into this year we're awaiting an estimate on

038the cost for repairing the piping um the solution right now appears to be all new piping with welding the joints as opposed to some other kind of solution I am no HVAC expert I know way more than I've ever wanted to know about HVAC systems um well they they could have used solid pipe to start with but the the other route with the clamps I'd like to jump in here and just mention that we're going to have uh the assessment of our school buildings this is an item on our agenda our business meeting so if we could just keep Dr Daniel on target with the with the survey and then we'll be talking about these issues at length later this evening um so that that kind of encapsulates um the survey data from the staff

039again I'll follow up with um some more detailed information and can share those survey results uh with you all to review I apologize um for kind of the the ad hoc presentation currently so I'll I'll follow up with some more concrete data for you all members do you have any questions about these basic items that Dr Daniel has asked has answered uh the people should uh I mean you can always hire teachers AIDS right um no um to one it's got to fit in the budget and two it's many cases where we have budgeted positions it's finding people to do it part of that is what the compensation package is for most of our TA positions and where we're constrained with with the budget so you know how honestly we really don't compensate our Tas

040particularly well or particularly competitively within the region they're typically folks who live locally who want to be a part who want to be around kids who may want to just have the school system's calendar and schedule and it works for their lifestyle as much probably more so than it does for the compensation piece so we've been skating All Along on all this um it's it's a demographic employee group within our division that's not well compensated I mean I don't there's several lots of our employ employee groups are compensated below Regional average um could you possibly before our next budget work session give a just a couple other counties of what they pay their Tas sure we can take a look and see what we can I don't remember ever getting that information before maybe we

041didn't I just have forgotten it um and also secondly the Tas we have it's kind of toold is some are associated with special education and some are just Tas to be used as the principals and teachers want right the ones in the elementary school correct correct the compensation is the same right I know that I knew that so we get Federal money for some positions some of those are local money some of yeah right but some are um associated with with the IEP IEPs and so therefore if that student graduates there might not be a need for another ta to replace to replace that in theory yes our sped numbers tend to go up um but yes in theory yes if a student had a one on one to one um with a TA that

042student graduates um in theory yes okay other comments Dr Daniel on the number of respondents you have 56 six respondents would you say that's about out of 188 potential employees in the school division including admin um it's a it's a relatively low response rate in my opinion um when I did the climate survey we were at 96 last year's climate survey was about 112 so I wouldn't expect 100% um but I would say it's a relatively low uh response rate so I'll have more conversation with the faculty and staff advisory to kind of figure out how we can do this better next year was it um you know was it poor communication on my part was was there you know were they expecting me to send it out me to do a presentation they to

043do a something along those lines did they have enough time was the was the I'm not sure I mean we talked about it at my last meeting so I'll and we um I had kind of a reminder kind of a check in hey where are we kind of situation so I'll I'll go back and do some do some digging right I just think there's some more there's probably some valuable information out there that that we don't have agreed okay all right okay well moving on to number three discussion by board members further further discussion that anyone would like to have at this point on the buildings repair of the buildings regarding the public employee requests for the 2526 school budget um I don't know if we're at the point where we're going to start cobbling

044together a budget I don't know if we're at the point yet we're going to Cobble together a budget but I do think we need what I'm hearing today is is worthy of consideration to include in the budget I did not realize that there were not enough that taking it away from the the focus of One Fund has kept um students from getting what they need in the consumables or the teachers having to be responsible for um beg borrow and stealing not stealing sorry um but you know it's it's been burden the burden is on them to figure out how to fill these gaps and that could be wear should be you know you know one year you might be able to be energetic about it but year after year after year it gets very wearing

045um and I'm I'm I'm always excited that we have that committed of teachers but it still can get old over time so I think we need to look at that and I think this highlights the the need for communication um kind of specific communication on issues that are out there that the board may not be aware of um this is very helpful very enlight lightning and we can have a proactive realistic um launch point now to address this need and for the sake of the teachers and the students so I think this was very important that you both spoke tonight thank you for that Miss um did you say that we could speak to the staff as well at this point it's a board discussion um would you are you looking to speak to go

046question okay um hey do you want me to do present with the Staffing um the staffing needs okay that we have some lacks in something near and dear to my heart and all of our hearts I think are the reading scores in the county which affect every subject matter um and I as a library media specialist endorsed person I would love to see I know reading Specialists are great but to have a librarian at both schools I think is so advantageous for the children as well as the teachers right I am aware also that this year has been a struggle with the sharing of Mrs Ule between two schools and I do think this uh contributes to reading obvious obviously the nature of the business and that a librarian um does more than a librarian

047used to do and um anyway that's another great topic that I think we should incorporate and as Dr Daniel uh begins to show us the budget work session uh we can continue that conversation I I agree with you there Mr Dobson yes years ago used to have class mothers that would work in the classroom occasionally um they helped out helped the teacher out of casually and stuff like that I assume that's no longer done not really okay I have a I don't know if I'm still on I have you were I was did I just turn it off you did it's the opposite of what you say I'm bad with buttons uh with the um institution though uh this year with the PTO at the elementary school I think they have have helped out like

048you were saying um on various occasions not all the time but I think that has been at least a plus there I'm not sure about Thomas hunter or the high school at all right most of the time I saw it done it was done at the elementary or right around seventh grade is uh when I used to see the the used to call them class mothers my uh my wife did it when my son went to the elementary school and she'd go in and help out if they were having a party or something she'd go in there and help her get everything straight and up and and about once a week go in and help organize stuff stuff like that and of course all the kids in the class got to know know why we

049still go places day you're ride's mother you know so I mean it's something that always H in there but I I I remember when I was a kid it was done my mother didn't be a half School M she was she worked in a cafeteria so I guess we've done away with all that things are definitely different but I will say that upcoming uh in the upcoming meeting we do have a discussion item on the volunteers the status of the volunteers in our schools which may be um you know a a different type of that same um element that used to be helpful in our schools and so we will we'll continue to talk about that Mr Morgan do you have any comments before Dr Daniel continues on no that on just copy no all

050right great [Music] good evening it's good to stand up um all right so some of this is going to be a bit of review from our joint work session with the Board of Supervisors some of it's new some of it's just kind of informational um slides so we'll work through the goal for me is getting some priorities from the board at this point when we as we finish up this work session some priorities for me to work with begin crafting the budget in terms ter of what do we want to look at in terms of salary increas and there'll be some highlights um at the end of the slide deck okay so um a little bit of overview in terms of and um overview in terms of where we've been in terms of Revenue sources

051so what you have on the screen is the last threeyear Revenue sources right now fy2 is that's what working off of it's entirely possible that our state revenue can go up or um go down that's based on our ADM and so our September 30 count and then our March 30 count Etc the governor is expected to release his tentative budget uh tomorrow I believe that may include funding for this year that may impact state revenue so the last column indic indicates a variance from FY 23 to this current year that we're operating off of so you see a um a variance or a decline in almost $800,000 in state revenue from FY 23 to fy2 thankfully the locality has um met that shortfall and the shortfall in federal revenue by almost a million dollar in

052Revenue increased Revenue over the last um three budget Cycles so um that increase from the the county towards um towards us this year then really helped buoy provide a pretty significant pay increase over the last 12 months for our faculty and staff so the total variance from FY 23 to currently is about $50,000 um but that's from a significant contribution from the from the county towards the school division um expenditures giving you an idea of line items and expenditures sort of where our variances have again same comparison variance from FY 23 to currently um and uh some the next couple slides will also give you a little bit of description about what comes out of the instruction line item what comes out of attendance Administration health Transportation Etc so in the instruction line item you

053see um a decline of about $600,000 our overall um expenditures um from FY 23 to fy2 come down to about um $694,000 um in terms of our expenditures going down so right now we're operating off of about a 17 17.4 million budget whereas two years ago we're operating off of a $8.1 million budget so I'll not spend a ton of time on these explanations um we'll post this slide deck to board docs um this evening I apologize to the board and to folks watching from home um I was making adjustments and edits up until probably about 2:30 this afternoon trying to add some some data and some information for our discussion um but what you the next couple slides like I said were um descriptions on what comes out of those those line items so

054folks who are looking at the budget from home or looking at our line items at home can have a little bit of understanding about what gets pulled out or how we um what items we pull from each category area so 6,100 for instruction 62 sorry 62,000 for admin attendance and health what you know again what gets pulled out of those line items out of Transportation operations and maintenance our technology okay so those are there for your reference again I'll um we'll have the slide deck posted so you can kind of go back to the the second slot and look at expenditures and compare it against okay what's getting pulled out of this line item so you can kind of take a look at um what we're doing again just a reminder review of local Composite

055Index the formula that goes into developing the LCI kind of how how it's impacted by student attendance students within the county um property value sales tax um real income etc etc within and how all those factors go into um establishing the local Composite Index that's our that's where the formula for our values um get pulled in all right so kind of a historical review of our local Composite Index So currently for this bium we're operating off of an LCI of 0.5 904 the um the higher the number the higher the um amount the locality is expected to contribute to the school division so over the last four bium we've gone up um almost 10% in terms of um the expectation so that's a that's a lot in terms of it it seems like a pretty

056small number but when you factor it all out because every bit of State funding gets filtered through that local Composite Index so if the state has um a benchmark value for what it pays for a teacher they then slide that through the LCI and so they contribute 041 towards the cost of that teacher whereas we can have to pick up basically or roughly 59% of any sort of State funding or state allocation kind of a map or not really a map but I guess a chart of where our local Composite Index Falls in relation to some of our regional Partners um so every blue column is a School Division in Virginia U Middle sex is listed with us Gloucester and West Point if it looks fun M kind of like a flat top on the

057far right it's because um per code a division's composite index can be no higher than 08 so there are several School divisions in Virginia that are at 08 um again Matthews is there at 0. 5904 middle sex is a little bit above us um our neighbor I guess to the South Gloucester is at 399 and folks tend to look at West Point but their um local Composite Index is . 2489 um so our enrollment um yes wow is um from from the audience is a good way to put it so in um in the last 21 years we're at almost a 50% um enrollment reduction um so right now we're operating at about 760 students in the school Vision currently let me kind I guess clarify that a little bit so in terms of K

058through 12 numbers we're at 7 760 because we don't get funding well we get some funding we don't get um s soq funding for preschool we get VPI um funding um taking a look at class size and class size ratios kind of where we are per grade level so it's helpful in a lot of ways to do some projections in terms of where we are enrollment wise and looking for budgeting purposes going into next year um an easy way to look at it is how many students do we have in grade 12 so that 69 students are currently in grade 12 versus how many students do we have in kindergarten or would we expect to be coming into kindergarten so the last three kindergarten classes have been 50 or smaller so um we're looking at

059at least a 19 to 20 um 25 student deficit just if everything sort of continues on that Trend so as we go to start budgeting for next year we'll probably look at a budget um based on about 730 students or so um 725 730 just to um be be careful um so then that then drives what are we looking at in terms of Staffing ratios and class class sizes and um effective use of taxpayer dollars and um matching policy and things along those lines So currently at the elementary school we have three teachers per grade level uh when we get into the middle school it gets a little bit different um but basically it's three teachers um per grade level some of those teachers at the middle school kind of cross content a little bit

060so they're teaching two grade levels um so our science and our social studies folks in sixth and seventh grade teach social studies or science but to two different grade levels whereas in fifth grade that teacher is teaching Science teaching to content but to fifth grade if that makes sense um so basically we're about three teachers per grade level K through 7 it gets super um it's it's not as easy to describe it for 8 through 12 because you're looking at content areas and English teachers or Math teachers teaching multiple contents in multiple um grades um but what you have in front of you um kind of in not on the bottom row but in the next to the bottom row is average class sizes in the core classes um so that gives you an idea

061of of where our class sizes current ly are and then in that very bottom row is where we stand with regard to board policy which reflects so soq funding um criteria have at any point board members have questions um please stop and ask homeschool um our home school numbers for the 2324 are are slightly lower than 2223 not a ton we're probably about 5 to 5 to 10 fewer but we're still in the 140 um 135 range in terms of overall homeschool students that varies from day to day as families move um various reasons that come up in households um folks can elect to homeschool at any point in time so excuse me I have a question can you back up on that the dip on 21 to 22 is there an explanation for that

062that's I was going to ask okay I don't know I don't know I don't I don't know okay um the rationale for homeschool varies um by the person who the the parent who turns it in so um I don't know if there was anything unique about 21 22 it may have been hey we're so tired of covid and quarantine and virtual school that we're going to come back in and give in person a try and then found that it didn't work as well or various other reasons um popped up so it's it it really it it varies greatly and you do I know this question has been asked many times you do seek to find the reasons and um from our families who choose to homeschool as to the best of your ability we will

063gently ask um typically if I'm in the Schoolboard office when it gets turned in I'll ask hey do you mind me asking what what could we do differently is there something that that has impacted your decision and it ranges it ranges from we're traveling a lot I'm frustrated by any number of things whether it's I can't get my kid to attend school I'm not going to jail for attendance purposes I'm mad about a discipline consequence we've got some um health issues that we're trying to address it's easier for us to educate our child in an asynchronous virtual manner than trying to work with doctor's appointments and um coming into the building and health is a broad you know maybe any number of Health factors whether it's mental health physical health um any number of things

064um some of it's may be frustration with curriculum frustration with expectations within the School Division I mean it really does run the gam it really does run the gamut thanks um some faculty and staff overview again we presented this um at our October joint work session um but in general General synopsis is we're employing about 20 fewer um full-time and part-time staff this year from last year so we still have I don't think we're at seven positions currently vacant um I think we've filled um I think two of those positions but we still have vacant positions that we're attempting to fill salary comparison so we brought I brought this up last year this is the comparison last year so that's for 2023 what's in red is the deficit between Matthew's um leers of experience and

065our regional Partners or re you know our regional competition um so we I'm benchmarked at 0 years 10 20 and then 30 so you can see kind of the the deficit at each one of those marks um a key note on this is how that deficit continues to increase as we get to 30 years experience lots of investment lots of commitment um especially lots of hard work from the county um to get addition funding for compensation last year and commitment from the school board to going to meetings and working with the supervisors to really fight for teachers and get uh the compensation up so we've closed the gaps in a lot of areas um but again you still see that when we get to that 20 and 30y year mark that that Gap continues to

066widen so what we need to do what I hope to be able to do is going into next school year begin having a a compensation study looking at having a a really a professional to look at our um salary scale to figure out a way to um provide greater increase at each step rather than every year you know fighting for x% that way it's it's built in and it helps us close that Gap or make it more competitive for us to retain teachers but also then recruit veteran and teachers to come in and help our kids because that's they're not a lot of young teachers coming out of college who are coming in at zero years of experience so what ends up happening is we're trying to attract veteran teachers from other localities I mean

067there are colleges are still producing teachers but it is not a wave of recent graduates um with resume in hand and trying to interview and find a teaching position anymore it's hey do you have anybody do you have miss hunley's calling and on different websites with different colleges and universities hey do you have anybody do you have anybody do you have anybody it's kind of what happens so all right so we met with principes and directors um to field their requests um so in terms of category with regard to Staffing and I'll add to this after the work session um so as one of the issues that we were're currently having at the high school is our the athletic trainer that we contract for um with a company with a physical therapy company um that

068that trainer took a different position elsewhere so we've been without an athletic trainer since probably mid October mid to late October um so we um in polling other high schools within the region many of them um have within their with on their faculty a trainer who in many cases also teaches some sort of sports medicine class during the day but they have kind of a flex flexed schedule where they come in after lunch teach two classes and are there for practices and games um some other requests looking at a typ and for um athletic director um at one point there was theater I think if we could get a theater program that would be great um additional FTE for Career and Technical education trying to expand the CTE offerings um with the Virginia literacy act

069expanding into the middle school we're going to have to seriously um look at hiring um an additional reading specialist um currently the elementary school reading specialist is funded through Title One funds so by that because the elementary school is the title one designated School the middle school is not we can't deploy Title One resources in a non-titled one school so um but with VA expanding into eighth grade shortly we really need to look at having a Middle School reading specialist projecting out our special education numbers we're going to be in the market or in the need for a middle school self-contained special education teacher we've got to do something for landscaping and grounds maintenance um we really to stay competitive um in part of the regional superintendent meeting last week we kind of went around

070the room and okay what what kind of pay raise y'all looking at what are y'all looking at what are y'all looking at and again it's kind of a poker game with superintendant um and so nobody wants to really say so if they honestly if they say three I would expect five because that's what I would do um so I'm I'm guessing most divisions are going to be shooting for a 5 to7 um part of the rumor that was taking place in that meeting was a relatively large School Division that is not in Region 3 um was starting with was the ask was a 9% um from that division so that was a ripple effect to some of our Region Three neighbors who are they're kind of wedge between Northern Virginia and Richmond area that they're

071having to fight for teachers between those two markets thankfully we're not competing between those two markets um but that's that's kind of where they were stuck with um and then we talked about Tas and substitute teachers a couple minutes ago um so we probably need to look at um a way to attract um substitute teachers um along with you know the pay increase for our teachers assistance so at the bottom of the screen I asked Miss LA to do a calculation for what a 1% a 3% and a 5% uh would be in um in Revenue in terms of what it costs based on our current staff so 5% increase for current staff is about $576,000 so um instructional items increased funding for journalism and art um I'll go back and add CTE to that

072um looking at funding for technology department subscriptions so we've um we made some Cuts in terms of um software and web-based um systems this past year so there's some requests iel um and being able to re access ISL and some of those other kind of online programs um we've got a math textbook adoption coming up you are going back into EXL it's been a request so we're looking at well the other piece that's coming up is the state is looking the contract with canvas um is up so we're waiting on the budget to see if the state is going to continue to fund canvas or not if they do not then we need to make some decisions about do we go with canvas do we not go with canvas m Rec connect etc etc and

073so that then has an impact on local budgets and again those technology department subscriptions and any other kind of software add-ons that we may need um we also have a math textbook adoption that will be coming shortly we know we're going to have increased costs for our regional special ed programs capital projects um lots of painting that needs to happen trophy case um and some of many of these pieces I will have on the capital Improvement um submission to the county like for example the bathroom Renovations replacing the flooring in the high school team room um renovating the consumer Sciences also looking at kitchen equipment some of that stuff I'm going to put in our Capital Improvement program um some some of these items under capital projects would be included with the investment grade audit

074that the county is doing and their commitment to that investment grade audit um and moving forward so any sort of HVAC HVAC issues electrical issues boiler issues I've taken most of those off of that um but we still have an abundant amount of um facility issues that that need to be addressed are we looking at uh I see you got three bus is listed there mhm are we looking at a a smaller mhm okay M so the bus the the county is um doing uh a slightly different process with regards to their Capital Improvement so they want vehicles on a completely separate a list separate from their regular CIP um so we've submitted an inventory and an audit of all of our vehicles for them to review and so we'll submit a request for additional

075buses um and then the goal I believe for their CIP is to build a multi-year CIP to be able to project several years out so if we don't get it this year then next year etc etc no electric buses not even to get to us free no I mean we haven't looked at um okay so some of our challenges and unanswered questions so again declining enrollment moment um our increased local Composite Index right now we believe vrs rates are going to hold where they've been uh we won't know health insurance rates until probably um mid to late January the local choice is out forbid so we won't have um results for or information regarding rate increases until that bid process is finalized so the health insurance rate where Miss Lao is is kind of um

076as a placeholder putting in an 8% increase um for health insurance rates so we'll need to really attempt to factor that into compensation so I don't I really don't want any sort of pay raise to then get eaten up by a health and a corresponding raise in health insurance rates um we really have no idea what the governor's budget will look like we got some I guess breadcrumbs Easter eggs I don't know the right phrase to use but the um Dr Coons said for us to keep an eye on the budget that there will be some good news for schools but I don't know if that's good news this year I don't know if that's good news next year I don't know if it's good news for things that we would qualify for or is

077it good news for all the other divisions or what so I it it's hard for me to um really know what what that looks like um and we don't know what utility costs are going to be those remain somewhat unpredictable um hopefully with improvements from the investment grade audit and if we're changing um over to less fossil fuel costs and more efficient energy usage than our utilities costs will go down um also too as the the Broadband piece continues to move forward in Matthews hopefully that will reduce our internet cost as well kind of the stuff that we're reviewing we're still looking at uh we're reviewing is existing contracts wherever possible um still trying to upgrade equipment um I'm going through a copier um renewal to get better copiers in our schools there's it's it's

078probably twice a week I get copied on an email where a copy machine has is on the outs isn't working we're waiting on the repair person to come um so we're trying to get the copier piece um resolved yes sir I was shocked the other day I wouldn't hadn't paid attention before on an item like I should have we pay for every copy that is produced by the copying machines so part of the service contract for copers is based on per copy so it's like and it's the difference um the schools only have black and white copies the Schoolboard office is the only color copy machine so the rate for color copies is different than paper copies it's like 0.0 I want to say it's like 0.07 cents a copy even if we own a

079machine yeah because we still that's how they base the service contract on we don't I don't have an internal person to fix copy machines so I have to have service contract on a copy machine even if we own it I'm still paying for a service contract for them to come and do the repairs usually that includes toner costs and um replacement costs and all that stuff it just sounds weird that you got to pay for every there's there's no cheap way um to get out of the copy machine business that's just um I I've spent probably since I signed my contract to be superintendent trying to figure out a way to reduce our copy machine costs and I haven't found it yet I'm now resigned to figuring out a way to without much of a

080hit get better copy machines at Le right now I'm looking at 2/3 replacing 2/3 of our machines remember the old blue thing yeah but it's yeah so um I think we're in a we're in a decent spot for the copy machines but we've got some copy machines that we won't even be they're so old we won't be able to get service contracts on them they won't come service them they are so old so that's sort of where we are so my agreement with them is will you please just take it away um as we replace it with either a different kind of machine smaller machines do we need to have fewer machines Etc so we've Revisited or visited all those questions to figure out can we just decrease the fleet so those are kind of

081the questions that we ask when we talk about reviewing ex existing contracts our HVAC performance contract um looking at ways to many of our things that we have to have contracts for have proprietary software attached to them so as we're doing upgraded equipment I ask is it agnostic software is it proprietary software because then you're beholden to that proprietary software contract vendor for however long you've got their equipment in place so as we're doing overhauls with equipment part of my goal is to have Matthews with agnostic software that we can shop vendor to vendor going forward or we own the software we own um the piece so that's that's been a big part of my goal um we're going to continue to um consolidation of services we're continue to having debate or conversation with the

082county on consolidating services to find efficiencies to get improvements right now that's with our maintenance departments so we're working through a lot of details on that I'm going to continue to examine our staffing needs as attrition occurs um and kind of when we look at pure numbers kind of how many how many numbers of kids do we have at various places is there a need for you know three teachers at AT that grade level how many sections do we have how many you know it's it's questioning how we're deploying our staff um we're looking at collaboration with Regional School divisions on sharing Services Regional programs looking at ranic Community College if there's a way to provide other kind of CTE program offerings or other kinds of offerings um to help save money and the other

083thing I think can have a conversation about um hybrid options we we we are piloting we have a handful of students who are hybrid meaning they take a lot of their core classes online through virtual Virginia and they come in part day for some of elective courses so we can talk as as a board do we want to um begin to offer that up develop some regulations regarding what that would look like if that would help us attract some um homeschool or tuition students to come to Matthews who are very much interested in a hybrid solution for their kids um but yes yes ma'am so for those students who are hybrid what is the reimbursement from the state is Canada as one student a full student yeah if they um if they're enrolled and these

084students are enrolled in Virtual Virginia they're considered Matthews kids so virtual Virginia and so then we pay virtual Virginia a tuition cost for those for those students okay thank you yeah so we don't end up with the full amount of money because we're paying money back in theory to Virtual Virginia but my thought is some's better than none right and if we can manage that hybrid piece is it working and again the where we're piloting it piling P piloting it at is at the middle school um so right now we're not getting into Athletics questions and eligibility questions and um things along those lines so the students are coming in basically for some of their exploratory classes okay thank you it's helpful yeah it gets more complicated in other grade levels and stuff well no

085I just didn't know I didn't realize virtual Virginia charged us back in the day not yeah you get a certain number of free seats after you exhaust those free seats it's um you have have to pay based on your local Composite Index so the rate you pay is tied to um your LCI per student so not only do we get less we have to pay more to access virtual Virginia classes yes okay so priorities from where um what we've talked about is really what we've maintained all along is making sure that we're doing the things to increase student achievement making sure that we can um hire and retain quality staff deploy them effectively are we providing quality professional development do we have quality instructional materials how are we working to improve student attendance how do

086we improve compensation for faculty and staff because that's going to help us retain quality staff that's going to help us recruit quality staff and then we're going to look at models Staffing models for our enrollment Trends and then really looking at our facilities issues because I think that's as much of a recruiting tool as anything um we may pay really well but if you're not sure if you're going to be hot one day and freezing cold the next day based on what's going on in your classroom then that that leads to like like a physical climate challenge but also kind of a morale climate issue so but this is you know from from my perspective now if the board can I guess help me with some some marching orders and priorities or at least um

087things that you all um want us to go back and start digging in on to begin drafting some rough numbers to look at in January but we have some questions I'm sure okay I I can stay up here and I can roll back to them if you want or okay there's good okay Mr Morgan yes Dr Daniel sir uh just real quickly in regard to faculty and staff not just the uh increased U salary or compensation has any further um discussion or any further conversation taking place regarding uh adding a TA to the carpentry class um we have not had much conversation regarding a TA for carpentry primarily because we've had such difficulty hiring Tas so where I said we've got five positions still open most of those are TA positions so we can't get

088applicants to fill the current ta positions that we have currently so I mean we can again try to um once we get applicants and we see a good fit we can deploy an applicant to carpentry or to right now we're trying to get really support in the library um that's kind of our primary goal right now is to get the TA for the library um so and then we've got some special education needs that we've got to meet for I Necessities uh we just we haven't had the applicants but that's that's been a big part of that right and and understand that you know you have to have the applicants um and if with no applicant no job um or no position can we at least in your thinking can we at least look into

089the feasibility the cost effectiveness of this I personally think and when I was teaching I almost begged for one but it's you know there was never any money and I get it there's never any money for anything but I really feel strongly that it's something we should look into and of course if we can't fill the position we can't fill the position but I think we should at least look into this yeah placeholder would be salary benefits vrs you're prob it's probably a 50 to $60,000 placeholder for for that position right what okay all things considered sure yeah I think with what happened recently ta might be good in that class it's awful hard to watch a lot of kids yep other questions Mrs Hodes I have a couple questions quickly you mentioned the step

090scenario and I was just wondering um if you if there are other surrounding divisions that have similar one steps or are they 1.15 1.25 that you know of and would that be a consideration when we're looking at that um and would that be considered for this next school year or are you talking 26 um my thought is 26 looking at the because we're planning for the FY 26 budget right now I would look at that for FY 27 budget okay um informal poll of Superintendent at last week's meeting um I would say 23 are 1% okay um some of them had a mix where some steps were 1% some were 1.25 some were 1 point it was kind of a a hodg Podge based on probably Legacy um tight budget years where you had to

091compress salaries and so to reex press compress steps and then re-expand those it got muddy for some school divisions um a lot some of them were 1.25 and honestly some of the other superintendents were I'm not really sure oh um so it was kind of I would say the most of them were were 1% um across some of the um more equipped School divisions like some of the larger School divisions who had um a finance team were able to kind of manage you know um M their salary scales and maybe at 1.25 to one I think 1.25 to 1.5 of the folks who aren't doing 1% okay um do it that way okay well that will be interesting to um assess and then regarding the unfunded Mandate of the Middle School reading specialist I know

092we started talking about this last year when we knew that the potential for uh Middle School VA going up through 8th grade at that time we discussed the difficulty of getting reading Specialists is that still the case I'm assuming that is yes very much so and we would um necessarily build in a placeholder for that correct okay um and finally regarding the Mastery connect comment that was made M um I am I correct that it was possible that we would not continue on with Mastery connect as it is the key conduit my goal would be to continue with that and canvas um okay the I think we just need to have on our radar that if the state is no longer funding or paying for every division to access canvas we would then have to

093budget for adding that cost to us so Mastery connect is a key component then to CIP what we plan to use for CIP and benchmarking and student achievement but that's something we're just going to need to to plan for and budget for okay absolutely that's what I wanted to confirm thank you you're welcome if there are no further questions

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.