001good evening and welcome to the January 21st 2025 meeting of the spaen Hill Union Free School District Board of Education I'd ask that you rise and like to pledge allegiance with [Music] me I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to theic for it stands one nation under God indivisible with liy and justice for all thank you okay our first item is 2.01 comments from the public on consent agenda items only do we have any comments from the public said a quick comment um regarding item 3.12 the donation great to see a donation like that I just was on familiar with the chestnut Market anybody familiar with it it's not a question really just just curious gas station yeah is is anyone here but what's the connection representative from Chestnut
002here because we're expecting someone the uh closest one is in uh Red Oaks Mill for us but I also think one of the ones on Route n is also by gas station so family that's their connection that's connection to I I believe yes part of their corporate um you know uh pledge is to get back to the community and and we're within their community and I think they chose us uh which we're very grateful for yeah great to see says how we choose fit do we know how that's going to be or where it's going to be allocated to or anything like that we do not no good problem to have yeah anybody else from the board okay I entertain a motion to accept the consent agenda as written motion by I a second second
003second by Richard all in favor I passes 5 Z okay that brings us to item 4.01 do I have a motion to take from the table agenda item 5.01 from the January 17 2025 board meeting have a second second favor 5 I believe we have some discussions here 4.02 so the board received uh pretty comprehensive packet on uh everything that we've been talking about trying to answer all questions and have uh Clarity uh before uh the board vote today on on the repair Reserve fund um some of the people who are instrumental in helping us compile this information are here today uh representatives from uh CPL Clark pison Lee our Architecture Firm are here uh timm who's on uh screen or it will be and uh Chris lean are also here so I know Tim
004is a little bit of a time crunch so I would imagine we should lead off with him and Chris you could join in with that so sure um are there any questions from the board to Tim or Chris about cpl's uh analysis of you know the concept of uh turfing our fields and and the timelines and the cost and you know I think sometimes we've thrown cost out and I think the board has questions over some of the numbers that I've gotten so CPL is here because uh they can speak to the numbers and um you I think their numbers have come back that are even higher than what we've discussed before so I figure that that would probably lead to questions um of them and also the timeline and anything else really anything else
005that was in the the packet so we can start with that board questions we could have Tim start with an overview of what he uh um the analys they gave uh Tim do you want to start with that do you want to talk a little bit about the preliminary cost estimate you had you you talked about you you gave an estimate on the baseball turfing the baseball field turfing the softball field um and costs and do you want to talk a little bit about that sure thing good evening everyone uh the superintendent indicated of Tim moot I handle the civil engineering side of CPL um sorry I'm not there in person tonight I'm double booked and really have a hard stop at 7:05 so I just wanted to be able to you know facilitate what
006you need to move on through the meeting um I was asked at a very high level to come up with what I thought a potential budget to basically put Synthetic Turf on the infields of the Middle School baseball field and the soft upall Field behind Nassau um I understand it's it's a simple concept and often times it can be oversimplified um I'm not trying to basically be an alarmist here but just make sure what Eyes Wide Open that we're making other considerations and not just focused on the turf um I asked one of our contractors Clark Industries not one of our contractors but a contractor we've worked with they're on the State Co-Op they've done a myriad of athletic fields both natural grass and Synthetic Turf inside on scene I asked uh the representative there
007for a high level construction estimate of what they thought it would take um I don't have an itemized quote but basically I believe it was 500,000 for the softball 700 for the baseball infield um from those numbers I started to think of what I personally knew about the two sites uh there's a lot more area to work with at the middle school in terms of drainage the way the Synthetic Turf infield behaves and is built is with an infiltrating stone with collector pipes under drain underneath basically funnels the water away from the play surface and we need to basically manage that uh infiltrated water typically through Dry Wells um but the big big assumption is that the soils will allow dry Wells to work often times in our design we have to install an overflow
008pipe in case the drywell gets inundated for whatever reason the excess water needs to be able to get out of there without back charging and sarging the infield so typically we would have to re reinstall a new back stop because of the level of work that's involved in earth work to basically create a concrete curb around the footprint of the infield and that's what the stone gets infilled on the inside and then the Synthetic Turf gets a fix to that uh around the perimeter um normally we've done baseball fields where it's Turf on the infield and the Outfield so that construction methods are similar but in this case if you're only doing the infield there'll be a curb buried curb at the transition from the Synthetic Turf to the natural grass Outfield it's not ideal
009I just caution that it can become a maintenance item because you're talking about two different types of materials and it can also be somewhat of a trip Hazard or a transition if somebody's if you imagine running back over for a fly over their shoulder and run off the turf and onto the grass um additionally I just brought up you know relative to Nassau the the field is at a very low spot it's almost like in a bowl Field's located at the bottom of the bowl um we have done some drainage improvements out there that did involve dry Wells I just caution that I think a little extra care should be done on our behalf to do a soils investigation to make sure the soils will perform because immediately adjacent and behind the field are residences
010so we didn't want to basically create a new problem uh for the residents um alternatively you know it was like we'll just do the infield we can keep the dugouts um but we have a project going on in Western New York where that was the intent and as we got through our soils investigation found that the grades were not going to work uh in order for the drainage and the stone to behave as designed so we needed to basically adjust the elevation of the field which in turn requ the dugouts to be raised um so that was a surprise it's an added cost it was already sort of mid stream and everybody thought it was just going to be a simple project um so basically you know my number that I gave was an inflated
011probably number based on the contractors when we make a submission for this type of project it has to go to state Ed uh we would uh include additional building work which Chris leany there the architect can talk to to what that would entail but um once we make a submission like this to SED they're going to look at things that a lot of people don't really consider one of them is emergency vehicle access and the big one is uh Ada access so um I I don't know that that's necessarily going to come back nine times out of 10 at least the Ada piece comes back so there's other considerations from a Global Perspective um I know we're focused on just the ter in the infield but point of my kind of broad brush estimate was
012to cover some of these unknowns um I think we put together a proposal that basically call for an initial study in that study phase we could do a toppo survey of each field we could do a soils investigation and better frame what we think the scope could be and at that point could certainly solicit whomever as as long as they're on Ste big contract and kind of get an Apples to Apples price quote so that was my Global intent thank you Tim questions for Tim I just one quick question uh from me um regarding that you said submission to State add a general idea about the timeline are we we've had a project you know not too distant past here so I think we're generally familiar with the timeline but have there been any changes
013in that process in terms of the timeline you know that would lead you to expect U you know significantly different amount of time to get this all approved Chris might be able to speak to that I I've heard things that it is improving but I don't know if it's at 20 weeks now Chris is this on should should this be on uh it's okay all right I can I can project so yeah so basic basically the the SED review times are at 16 weeks but that's a little um it's a really we we give so if you did that it's about four months right but there's a comment response period after that so once we submit we're going to get an architectural review and an engineering review and then the project manager up at s
014does a does a fiscal review of it all and and each three of those entities are going to typically has comments sometimes they don't but typically they do and there's a comment response period so that that's where some of the time gets chewed up is right there so yes they they will come back and have some comments in that 16we period but you're not going to get that building permit you know at your 16 weeks they did bring back the third party review process um which will expedite the review it would be like a firm like CPL would do it for S and get paid for it and that's a thing you would have the spack and kill would have to cut a check to um any given third party review uh entity and uh
015you know I'll be I'll be frank with you it's not it's not cheap it's not cheap by any means and it's typically based on the cost of construction so they do like a percentage of that and that's a new requirement you said they've added that back they added that back for an option just in case you get uh um if the schedule doesn't work out for you um you know there's when third party reviews were were were implemented in about 2018 uh there was some success and they and then they started to go sideways a little bit so they got rid of them and now they're back with some new framework you know so it's an option but it's you know it's do you recall if there if we had to go through that with
016the football field we we we did not do it for the football field but we actually we might yes we did do it so we did it with with Dr Valente that was uh the superintendent at that time for phase one of that project we did the the roof the roofing at the uh elementary schools I believe and that was done third party second phase I believe so all three phases were done and at that point we did the math of you know uh basically inflation and stuff like that it makes sense to get this done this summer or way this Summer that that type of thing and uh you know as a group decision you know we decided to do the third party ni okay thank you you're welcome and in terms of process
017what can be run concurrently to streamline these processes well yeah so basically so right now that we have you know one field at this building and then we have another field at Nassau there's going to be two project submissions so you know the state basically anytime you do a project you need to tie it to a building um so both designs can be from our our side run concurrently um really try to to the only other way that you could potentially um shorten up the schedule a little bit again would be that third party review and then um when you do get to the point of um you know bidding for construction uh like like Tim had mentioned uh you know some of this type of work is on a state contract list um you
018know Clark for example you you could uh go direct with them when when you guys did your track and field at the high school uh the carpet was done direct purchase the scoreboard was done direct purchase you could do some pieces of it direct purchase and bid out the rest uh you know depending on you know uh it's the district's prerogative at that point so um but did I answer your question B partially I I think um just but just you just raised some interesting thoughts the the materials come from the state contract the work comes from the bidding of a contractor you could do it that way you don't have to but you can yeah different was going to do all the site work as well so they're number that I don't know the
019other quote if that had all the site work labor in there or not but Clark's did yeah Clark is one of the entities that could do everything not only just Supply the material but also put it in I think the other question I had in terms of that concurrent process is when do you submit to S and what point are you will you be able to submit to S yep and and Tim if you could you know confirm this but basically a design of this scale you know we we marked out about three months to do it on on our end and then it would be let's say we got the green light tonight hypothetically 3 months from now um well based we have to do the survey and things like that so some of
020the stuff is weather dependent um obviously you know there's snow on the ground so um but uh in a in a vacuum you know 3 months would be good for us to to to turn this around at least a month of that three months we're waiting on either subc Consultants or the weather to to basically get the field data and then from there hopefully it's it's a simple process project right but U right we also have to accommodate like Chris are you you accommodating your building improvements yes that yep so yeah on the proposal it listed and we took this from the BCS which is a billing condition survey um also you know which the billing condition survey turns into The Five-Year Plan The Five-Year Plan is this you know uh living breathing document with
021everything you know to get done with the district as you know Roofing down to flooring and everything in between so uh pulling from the the the BCS uh you know so basically taking a step back to get building aid for doing site work you have to do some building work right like before I said like every project is has a building number to it that's the way that s thinks is just building building building every dollar and cense has to be tied to a building um so you want to try to keep uh the the work somewhat simple in a sense not to you know uh you know so I always recommend doing you know an architectural piece like some flooring some you know that wouldn't be asbestos some ceiling Replacements or a simple one
022that came from your BCS is uh brick repointing so basically a lot of the facades of your buildings are brick and the mortar between the joints uh degrades especially down below where you're throwing salt and things like that especially on your chimneys when you're dealing with heat and you know you know hot cold hot cold that that that reeks Havoc um so uh we we have on there to do some repointing and about you know do about 10 to 15 grand of repointing and that way you can get building aid for your site work we did recommend us doing a needs assessment to see if there's some inside work talk about the auditorium and some heating stuff that we might want to right include if we're doing sure sure yep yep yeah and and in
023the background speaking with the administration Miss Murphy and Mr fuell and Mr diato um getting together and and reviewing that that fiveyear plan reviewing some of the stuff on the BCS you know if there's something that is more important to get done in the buildings than some brick repointing that has come up well by all means if it's a pain point in the district then we should address it uh and maybe you can kind of capitalize on a submission that way too um but it's up to you guys it's up to everybody you know but you know I'm here to help and Tim's here to help and but the decision you know is going to come from the group so you said the the repointing of the uh the brick would be about 10 to
024$15,000 and that would qualify us to get the building a on that that's correct so they the state's requirement is that you have to spend at least $110,000 on the building itself and if I apologize because I really actually can't hear anything right now completely de um but did you say it' be if if you got a green light eye tonight it'd be three months yeah three three months of the design process so three months of our Engineers going through it all um I would be handling the S workbook which is basically a stack of you know form that's part of that three months is the that's part y yep that would be part of it that's you know uh Murphy's uh you know familiar with the all those form forms and you know the
025financial forms and all these different you know pieces of the puzzle you got to submit per per project so that would be part of that three Monon period take them through the timetable though I don't want confusion Yeah so basically it would be talked about a year or something take them each each stage I think it's in your letter that is in your packet but like uh so basically yeah just to go through it all so let's say design is three months right um you know weather dependent so let's let's add a month on there just in case right 3 to four months and then you know the SED timeline I'm going to say it's 6 months you know it says four months on the website but that's a little deceiving 6 months for for
026from submission to building permit is six months and then your bidding period is typically a month um and uh that way you package all everything up put it on the street have you know contractors come and bid on it um and then and then you're ready to go so this isn't something that would be done for this season but is there any reason that it wouldn't be by the following 2026 season that's well no that would be a good timeline would be not this summer The Following yeah yeah yeah yep clar yeah Clark Clark indicated roughly a month and a half per field for the work three months once it's in construction right yeah got the mention or at the same time I don't know Tim would would they be doing far but they're big
027enough that they can do both yeah Chris just want clarification because you just said something to the board that you thought next season when we spoke you thought it was they play two more seasons at minimum talked about so let's say if we're saying a year for after voter approval after voter approval so that that's where once the voter approval does happen so that I mean so I'm saying not this summer next summer if it happened tonight so I'm sorry to be confusing but if if if once we get that green light for argument safe give it a year a year until shovel hits the ground optimistically it could be this fall though optimistically if you if you did some of the third party review and that was successful there's a little couple unknowns there
028but you know you you could shorten that s review time down you good with this third party review but it's going to cost you yeah it's it's possible though yeah I mean I I think the number we are provided with is quite inflated which is fair because I'm in the field I understand you normally want to try to give a a bit of a high estimate to so that your pants aren't caught down so I I completely understand it I I have uh you know a number of contacts in my field I have some ideas in my mind where it where where it would come in yeah um you know I I think um you know just knowing some of the soils I guess I know that Middle School area is probably going to be
029more silty and little more challenging on the drainage I think the uh the over at Nassau is actually a little more Sandy LOM over there it's pretty deep but um I know some of that field was already cut out too so I don't know how much has been cut out in the past to know how how deep it goes so I think there's a lot of um potential to uh to to see if we can move this faster and um and I think it might come in a little bit less than what you're saying which is you know something that we can also work with you on value engineering as well I I suppose but um I wanted to go back to what one thing Tim had said there um you know this is becoming
030a much more frequent Improvement to baseball fields throughout the area um so frankly I think that they've got the curb to to Grass transition down pretty good and I I really don't think it's really a safety issue I I think it's really um you know obviously you got to keep watching it but that's that's our responsibility is to keep watching it and you know periodic maintenance on the turf fields is always going to require they're going to be checking for safety as well so right I don't want want to make it sound like right out of the bat it's a safety issue like you say if it's not maintained and it's not kept an eye on it could become a safety issue the other thing to consider and again I'm not trying to talk you
031out of this but if at someday you decide hey I want to I want to Turf the whole field that curb is going to be in there and would have to come out my understanding but you could cross that bridge down the road Timmy Chris why don't you talk about this uh Dan I just said the popular of this is what are you seeing in districts are a lot of turf fields coming up like what do we have in our area so uh so we we did spa and kill when back in 2006 they talking about baseball field baseball infield right uh we had done all the tur fields at spa or at I'm sorry Arlington and you know the infield was one of the last things to get I think there was a donation
032for that we're we're doing a ton of these multi-purpose Fields where you know it's taking a soccer field in in laying this this diamond so you have now converted to cross breeding Sports if you will that seems to be the flavor of the day um and then in that case you would have alter Outfield so I I think it's a modest Improvement on what you can do and and you know I don't know that at the end of the day you'd want to consider turfing everything in Nassau but maybe more so at the middle school but um money is a factor we understand that and we want to work with you and get this to be the best project for everyone so I you know I don't want to overinflate this to like kill the
033project that's not my intent my intent is like like you said eyes wide open and we'll do everything we can to zero in on the critical scope here which could be a cost reduction what do you think what could the cost be I mean Mr Coler said some some stuff of his knowledge like what do you think so we have eyes wide like I said I mean all the drainage disappears at Nassau and there's residences right behind there so I wouldn't want to have a concentrated scenario that changes the way things are I don't have a full understanding of where it all goes I mean that would be part of our study um you know and then as far as Ada we'd have to look at grades and whatnot and come up come up with
034a bigger scenario iio there would be site work to make a walkway or a pathway I don't know parking wise where that falls relative to this um and then it's emergency access to get back there if there was an injury so um I just I can't tell you any any real hard fast numbers I mean the first thing to do would be what we're recommending is a little bit of a study so you threw out 2.2 million but we're obviously thinking it's going to be less than that um uh so I had 500,000 and 700,000 from the contractor that's all parts materials and labor and then I threw in uh a buffer on top of that for additional site work if drainage doesn't work and we have to do something above and beyond dry Wells
035uh and then it's the site access so I don't know maybe it's half of that I don't know okay a little bit over a million yeah I mean Tim does bring up a good point you know SD is going to make you want to make this Ada accessible um so that's going to be cost there yeah can you talk about that a little bit is it Ada access all the way down to say the dugouts or is it Ada access for the patrons watching it would be both really all of the above yeah I would think that's something that we' want anyways to be ADA Compliant exactly exactly yeah it's something that we would be proactive with and put it in the design sure can I have a question for maybe Val or PA here
036um the money on our Consultants is that also aidable the money to get the pay our Consultants to pay them before the Project's act anything that's done really before the project starts is not able come out of the what is that point of start when we get voter approval voter approval is a start because there is a possibility of of starting like you could technically order kind of the check the soils and do that think was like a $50,000 piece um but we would have to find that in our budget which we couldn't do this year but we would have to budget for that but then we wouldn't get eight on that we have to pay for that fully but if after that stage it was deemed hey this project is doable uh that stage
037would count towards the timeline if he said this three to four months right that would count that would take some of that away um so then once you got voter approval uh that piece could have been completed except that we would be on the hook for the full lot of that and it would have to come from it would have to come from the budget not from a fund so just to clarify you're talking about a scenario in which we start the study do the study prior to voter approval and then have voter approval and then go forward uh of course if the voters don't approve it that's money that goes waste right yes well you would have your site surveys and you would have your Geotech information so you would have data right it
038wouldn't be all for nothing I I trying to be positive if you were to if you were to approve it at some later point you have that done already exactly would that be time and materials because I I frankly I think you can do better than 50,000 for it well basically so that 50k would be so task one of our s submission we have labeled as roughly 255k right so that's the schematic design basically data Gathering things like that Tim and I agree that letter Yeah Yeah Tim and I agree that a good thing would be the doing the Geotech and the site survey which would be Consultants that would be subc Consultants of us that would need to get so that would be roughly 25k and that that to me again getting that data
039would be would be great and then if you guys wanted us to you know keep moving on the study once we get that data and yeah we you know we're like Tim said we want this to be a successful project so whatever you need us to do and and whatever you know um schedule we'll be happy to accommodate within within reason um so that that 50k number is basically for a full-blown schematic design after the data is all gathered I'm sure once the data is gathered we could all get it together and have you know since you're in the industry and you and Tim could look at that stuff and go nuts you know you could definitely um you know get a lot more clarity on on on what the true scope of work is
040out there so you're saying this $50,000 investment would be closer to a 25,000 initial yes and then yes if we decide to move forward yep yep and that 25 any of the self-c Consultants would be a direct pass through to you guys I mean we have to pay prevailing range or you have for this type of work so both the Drillers and the surveyor so whatever their quotes are would just be a direct pass so you would see those numbers we're not marking them up right is there any reason that we don't have $225,000 in this budget this year to be able to do that we could but that would mean that we would there would be other things that we would not do with this budg so we do have the funds to be
041able to do it but it just might mean less there not extra funds there are if I were to if we were to decide to do this then other things would have to ear Mark for other things that we have to une Mark over July 1 starts a new um new budget season things wouldn't be year so at the end of it each year we've have Surplus that goes into our Reserve funds and that's Surplus based on the revenues what the voters vote on are the expenditures that's the solid budget any money that we have left over is because we got extra state aid or we got extra money along the way so that's where the extra comes from it's not left over unex so is any of that use can use towards those year
042marks it could but I wouldn't know what that number is at this point we not far enough in the year okay where did the 50 come from that's that's phas task one task one plus the the the Geotech and the um site survey so you take your subc Consultants right 25k and then CPL to get us through schematic design would be 25k I'm saying that you do the data portion of it first hold off on the schematic design until it's a real you know again they the reason why they're not doing building Aid on something prior because they don't have a building number to tie it to that's that whole thing again you know the s number right you always hear that at least you know in my industry we hear it all time every
043single dollar and cense has to be tied to some sort of you know and you think that this uh data collection uh would take about three months to you know given the weather I would have to lean on our um on Tim to to to coordinate that with our Consultants I know uh Geotech engineering and uh core drilling is a unique somewhat unique thing uh I know a couple companies that do it and uh last time I talked to him which was probably about a year ago pretty busy pretty busy these days um so hopefully you would able to get a drill rig out here uh sooner than later but that's somebody else's schedule unfortunately but you know we work with these people all the time so they're they're usually pretty good with us so
044you had discussed with me that you didn't think if if we were able to do this authorize it in July it wouldn't affect we wouldn't miss because we were on the depression we would take at least two baseball Seasons sure so waiting until July wouldn't change that if you yeah if you waited till July then it would truly be those two seasons like we talked yep yeah I add a little confus right yeah I added a little confusion saying starting now but that's not realistic so forgive me so it sounds like whether we're doing this um hoping that the chips fall right I guess for that terminology um whether we're moving forward with this now or 3 to 5 years from now this uh data collection will be able to be used then yep um
045I think it'd be beneficial to us to know if this is even something that we can consider um and getting this done sooner rather than later because if it's something that's just not feasible then St putting our efforts towards it sure sure I would like to see this um authorized to move forward on um spending the 25,000 to do this data collection right and we can get you you know real hard numbers on those quotes basically we would uh engage those consultants and they would provide us with a proposal how long do you think that would take to that could that could be quick that could be yeah that could be quick we could probably hone in on the drainage aspect right after that work is done then Y and that's to me that's where
046we get to the little nuts and bolts of this whole thing exactly based on the drainage that we're going to have to do underneath so 100 that's what Tim talked about yeah that that's you know that could that could be 100K 200 I mean that that could really be depending on how much subbase and you know I'm no civil engineer but I understand that you know truck loads and truck loads of stone and you know it's it gets quick it gets expensive very fast you know so it's basically the stone sandwich that you put under the field so everything can kind of drain and so yeah it's uh it's not cheap but anything we didn't cover for CPL Mr lanzon here he is here standing in the back he is I I didn't hear any
047questions to it but uh Marco did talk about the the concept of one field I think a lot of that was in here I don't know you wanted to talk to that a little bit and sure anything else yep so I did look at the feasibility of sharing both the the baseball and softball fields in my opinion talking to the softball and baseball coaches I think that would be not practical for three reasons so one there's not enough practice time on our fields we have one baseball field One softball team six teams so it's difficult finding practice times on the fields we we have um Varsity JB practiced on our Todd and NASA fields we sent our modified teams to the town of pipy parks for practice they can't play games there usually the town
048takes over the field at 5:00 but they do allow us to practice for a modifi teams uh two um you know the baseball teams all play their games on the Todd field um the game schedule's packed so if you look at it right now we still have to add three or four more Varsity non- League games but I once preseason ends we have three to four baseball games on that field per week there's one week we have five five games Spring Breaks if spring break it's late because a lot of schools don't schedule games but it it's 3 to five games on that field baseball games so if you're going to try to squeeze softball games in there that would be a challenge and if you took the rest of the Open dates baseball would
049have no practice time on the field and the last challenge is um the league schedule so the League schedules uh varsity baseball JV baseball I'm sorry varsity baseball softball JV baseball and softball and modified baseball set um together so they send their teams to us on the same date and they do that because most teams don't have a they don't have two baseball fields or two softball fields that's why they send softball and baseball together and it's a it's a big savings for the for the districts um on combining those teams um it's about $450 per trip when you send an athletic team to to a um school so combining them saves money and then the last thing is um it's really not feasible for schools to split them up so if we ask Highland
050to bring their softball on Monday and baseball on Tuesday districts are having more and more difficult time getting buses some schools are limited with only two or three trips per day um so we couldn't we couldn't make them split all those teams up because a lot of schools wouldn't be able to get a bus to send you know the other team on a on a separate date the other thing I want to add so you were talking about how common it is Tim said it's it's getting more and more common um just so the board's aware in our in our County Duchess County I believe Arlington is the only team that has um Turf on baseball and softball in our league the 18 schools within Mid Hudson Athletic League um there's nobody that has turf
051fields in our section which has comprised of 46 teams um Monroe Woodberry and Middletown are the two schools that have it just for context any any questions what was weren't you involved in the dirt proposal you and yeah Anthony walk the field or something so and I I wanted to start out with just thanking the board thanking Dr fuell for the conversations about upgrading our athletic fields you know this is two or three meetings here that we're talking about improving our facilities and our and our athletic facilities so I I really appreciate you know Dr fandi putting a proposal together the board with all these conversations I take great pride in our athletic facilities you'll often see me out there prepping the softball and baseball field for games I'm out there scuffing marks on our
052brand new high school um basketball court um I'm on the turf you know every day in the fall so I appreciate all this conversation of of trying to you know give our kids the best so thank you for that so my role in this process um back in June our head baseball coach Don n and I met with Anthony um on the baseball field and we met because we wanted to talk about the concerns of uh how our particularly the infield was playing so over time our infield has become uneven some high spots and some low spots the lips where the clay meets the uh grass has become a little bit of a mound and over years that that happens the clay pushes over into the grass um so we met with uh Anthony to
053kind of go over some of the improvements that we thought could make the field safe and uh um something that the kids could be proud of so in that proposal that list of um repairs came from from that meeting um coaches coaches coaches and I really want that food that that field repaired as soon as possible so I like the conversation about you know about Turf and all you know future but really and I met with the coaches again um and I think the comments from baseball parents in the last meeting uh tells you that you know the field has progressively gotten worse it's time for repairs we're hoping that these repairs get done as soon as possible when we met with Anthony and June we were hoping that they were get they were going
054to get done in June in the summer understandably the quotes that came came back Val said you know the District budget can't cover the cost we have to put it through a repair fund we have to do a proposal to the board to get it done you know we we wish it got done we're hoping that some work gets done in March to make the field safer and the kids could be proud of it and then we hope the rest of the work gets done after the season because like some of the parents said you know at times it can be dangerous but if the field is done correctly and and those repairs are made it's going to be a field that that it's beautiful that plays well and something that we we can be
055proud of any questions from Martha I lot of questions but um I'm sorry riche um I guess I do have one question would if you had your choice between a um a turf field a dirt field for a baseball field which would you prefer so we've talked about it um I know we have yeah I uh um Turf is beautiful I'm not I don't have a lot of familiarity with it we don't play any teams that have turf field so I'm not familiar with it our turf field at the high school has been great you know plays even and and uh um our baseball and this is something the board might know our baseball and softball teams use the turf in March so when our field is uh um under under if they snow and
056ice on it they've been practicing they split the field and our baseball and softball team are are using it so that's been very beneficial having that tur field at the high school um I want a save field I want a field that we could be proud of so if this if this is um something that's going to be down the road I'm I'm really hoping that the board will start repairing the field immediately and then if you want to pursue Turf down the road that's that's one thing and I'm and I'm fearful from my experience here I'll be honest with you um we' put I've been here long enough to see the district put up a a vote a capital project where we did we separated the inside work of what needs to be done
057and the district needs and the turf field and the turf field was rejected so my fear is that we don't do any work on the field to repair it now and then down the road you know there's uh not community support for salt ball and baseball and um we're we're back to square one all right so B the the softball football field track was a community uh project you know it it was a lot of uh Community used that a lot of our s soccer U um football team you know multi-purpose field um so that's we just got to we just got to make sure that we are uh um we can get the community support for for our baseball and softball fields CU it's a little bit less um of a community uh field
058it's more of a program field I agree with you um I I'm also concerned about the uh Community Support of it you know we have baseball compared to a football field a soccer field we redo the basketball courts we do redo the uh stands in there and baseball and softball are often uh the Forgotten sport for whatever reason I'm sure there there's definitely other ones as well and not just uh athletic programs but other ones that are also uh don't get as much attention or Community Support that maybe could um but I uh I do think that we do need to get work done on the field this year uh regardless of how we choose to move forward at this point that would be um a uh a stop right there for me if we
059weren't able to move forward with some kind of work on the field this year um we do work on the field every year right we come and we put something down every year on it we work on it every year that's what was a full fall spring and an inseason plan right so regardless we'll be bringing in something um and working on the field this year because that's what we've done every year before so we'll still get worked on it doesn't sound like this year that the grass or the field would be able to or the mound or anything like that would be able to be fixed this season anyways um but just a a a possibility that we might be able to bring in clay if the season is right no guarantees of that
060just a uh a possibility that we might be able to get the clay in here and the 4 in dug out and uh a little bit of drainage done on it um but that's uh that's no guarantee on this year with it um but that no matter what we would still be able to bring in some you know some Top Sand and redo the field like we' done each year to repair it uh so it sounds like no matter what this season uh it will get some maintenance done to it um to we don't know if we're going to be able to do the clay we don't know we definitely know we're not going to be able to do the uh the seating uh we just did the same thing at at Red Oaks Mill
061shut down for an entire season and we couldn't step foot on that field for an entire season right after they uh they redid it so we if we did it we're not going to use that field for an entire season so it's probably something that's going to have to wait until after this season regardless um possibly until the summer other than us bringing in some sand and top you know doing some top dressing on it um Anthony you want to speak to that because I thought we were hopeful that we could get the you sure yeah there's a there's a in the packet there's a repair work timeline um it is under the past and future maintenance estimates it's at the bottom of that that one page the one you have your hand in well
062this is the resolution that no he included a repair work timeline oh yeah the table we had said I said to Anthony look if we if we somehow we're going to do the dirt we have to have we have to get something done and he was I think a little pessimistic but then you spoke to the contractor and you put together this this thing and is that still true today yes so I did review with the contractor um what he felt he would be able to get done for the baseball season and what would have to get done after the baseball season it does sound like he'll be able to come in cut that lip out do all the shape up um bring in all of the new clay put it down redo the pitchers
063mound the batter boxes that'll all be able to get done for the beginning of the Season according to the contractor the part that won't work obviously is we can't top dress the infield we can't plant plant grass put seed down because obviously won't grow before the baseball season so that portion of it will have to be likely done the best time for that is in September um late September so it'll it'll won't be too hot and and the seed will grow but we will be able to get a good portion of the work done and and uh some of that new clay brought in um a bit more can be done than our typical uh maintenance for the the beginning of the spring how much are you uh estimating Phase 1 to be I haven't
064split up the cost um but I if I'm a rough estimate might might be about 2third of that uh cost that we have listed under the um the repair reserve for it I'd have to give you a I'd have to actually do the work and split split that up okay but that phase one was the bulk of it it was it's it's everything aside from uh top soil and exing the because you can't grow grass in that that's just that's the baseball field the softball field can be done completely correct yes right yes okay we had asked for a copy of the estimate for what this was going to be what of what um you know that the um option was going to be I don't think I've seen it project was of 94,000 just
065asking for the estimate on that no I think he's we we thought you had asked for the the baseball softball cost estimates for Turf um so what you're asking for now is like an itemized list of what the $94,000 is going for that's what I had asked for prior to the previous meeting soly asking for that and that's that's we'll work together I would still like to see that is that something you have Anthony or is that something you have to create no we have we have it yep Anthony is the baseball field crowned properly right now so that if you put this clay that it's going to drain off properly or are we going to be double handling this material and then ruining some of the material we're bringing in to regroup it properly
066to establish the right Crown yes yes we're removing material that's part of this project be removing the old material creating the appropriate crown and um while laying the new clay in yeah so you're going to be able to the grass doesn't change that's to me there's an issue there sure if the grass on the infield that's your set elevations you got pinch points now so I I just don't want to get into a point where we end up spending some money while we're also considering a Turf option but then that money isn't well spent so I'm I'm just trying to get my arms around this whole concept because I I feel like the tying in of the final clay elevations around the grass whether it's the grass on the foul side the in the Outfield
067side or the grass on the infield you're really stuck to same the same elevations unless you're going to rip up the grass and redo the grass so I I'm just not sure if phase one is really feasible for the baseball field understood I can review with the contractor and see what his thoughts are and get that information um see if he has a way of doing it or that he's done I think my more importantly is if they break it up into the two phases does it escalate the 94 370 understood information I'd have to get yeah although if I could clarify uh what you've got in the project list there is top dress grade and see the infield Dan's referring to the sidelines fou areas in the Outfield but there would be no plan
068necessarily to seed top dress and so forth those other parts just the infield right that's true yes I'm no engineer but I would imagine that's a little easier to manage in terms of the elevation depends how you how you establish the crown it's okay if you know not really it's about it's about establishing the crown to make sure it drains off properly um so sometimes that means that you push the work past other areas as a result of that to where the turf will meet the grass right where where the where the clay will meet the infield meets the INF grass meets infield skin because if because he says he could take that down so would they be because we talked about it they talked about taking that lip that you had discussed that is
069there that they'd be able to take that down in phase one then he raises a good point does that without growing new grass are they able to I mean he seemed to think it was safe but but his question is pretty interesting does it agreed um yeah I'll I'll follow up and get some information and see what his thoughts are on that and um get back to it it also says for phase one phase 2 right below that that this is all weather dependent is there any possibility that phase one couldn't happen because of weather I think there's always a possibility um there always a possibility you know um who knows if we have a snowstorm in in March right um but the idea is that um given the past few ERS that we should
070be able to get uh that work done regardless if we go with phase one or just bringing in um you know the sand like we usually do each year and um redoing the field that way um we could do some kind of work to the field this year whether we approve phase one phase two or we just do another year of regular maintenance that we've been doing for the past couple years as we consider whether or not turf's going to be an option yes thank youc I you know I had a question earlier for uh Mr Lon and it it relates actually to you Anthony as well but um in part I think you've answered it I mean I I wanted to say first of all I really appreciate the context that you just laid
071out in terms of the uh discussions earliest discussions about improving the field um I think you know my sentiments are I think very much the same as yours my my children have played Sports here as well played baseball for a long time and I feel that Field's in need of repair has been for a while it's been this last at the last meeting so I appreciate year forward you know kind of uh looking attention to this back starting last June uh and um that's how I understood what what had been proposed here as uh coming together of of those discussions earlier and Anthony I appreciated your efforts here uh in this respect from even before you were hired you know I mentioned that before this is something you saw and targeted you know from early
072on so I appreciate that information and the timeline um the question I had actually I think was more or less answered you know whether it would be feasible to have the phase one work done for this coming season right and and I I understand it's weather dependent but it sounds like it's possible um when do we start playing games Mark I guess that's first Weil first week April so so you know yeah so I don't know the exact date but we're still working on our non League schedule so the season starts March 18th we'll have some scrimmages in some non- leagues possibly you know the first week of April that aren't currently listed on a schedule but we're working on finalizing that schedule so it's a couple weeks of practice and then we uh you
073know weather dependent we cross our fingers and hope to uh to to start some contests right yeah okay appreciate that I mean my my feeling is you know in response to that information you know much of what you said I much like what you you had said Marco I mean I I saw this as a real opportunity to improve our our Fields um in uh immediate term that would you know carry over for next several years to me you know it's it seemed from the very beginning that that was The Prudent way to go about this um and I remain a bit confused about uh you know about the whole history of the turfield idea uh you know I guess pun intended it seems to me it feels to me that that whole idea came
074out of left field um recently you know I know it was broached as a question in in October late October early November um and and while I appreciate the discussion you know as you uh mentioned earlier Margo and I share many of the sentiments you know that have been expressed about the desirability of of a turfield perhaps down the road it just seems to me like we're talking about two different things um you know I don't see how they're mutually exclusive um the improvements to the field that would carry us over the next several seasons would be a real boom to the program I think and an improvement to the facilities and I think if we as a board and as a community decided we wanted to go toward a third field that's still a
075possibility you know down the road U you know I I see this as part of a if it happens as part of a larger project I don't think in good conscience I could support you know a capital Improvement that would be primarily or almost entirely T fields for baseball teams I think would have to be tied to as has been mentioned before A needs assessment for the district as a whole um I think um that's what I'd feel comfortable supporting I think that's what to your point as well Mr L that's what I think our community would be looking for so I'm hopeful that we can move ahead um you know with the project as it's been proposed uh perhaps with the understanding that there might be some additional costs regarding to the infield and
076the crowning issue uh if we can get a bit more information on that that would probably be helpful but um my feeling is you know we should move ahead with what's been proposed that's what's been planned uh and presented to us going back a ways uh and then also perhaps research and think you know kind of prudently in a broader context about how turfield could be a possibility down the road um that's my you know that's my that's where I stand on this but I appreciate certainly all the effort that's gone into this because I know it's been a while that you've been putting this all together I understand that point and I I also think that spending you know 94,3 70 if this is really in the cards is isn't exactly the best use
077of funds right now either so I I'm I'm just trying to get a better understanding I understand what you said about it coming out of left field I think when this was brought to the board was it you Jeff that first first Gro the concept of turf and yeah I believe corre I I would say that the project in general came out of of left field that uh we're going to be doing a a $100,000 repairs to the uh to the softball and uh baseball field they all came to us in October is a full part of it and yeah from there the discussion was asked if we could consider Turf instead of so it was all all started in October not just uh you know the well just to clarify I mean I didn't
078understand that the question about the tur Fields when it was raised in October as an ore as an alternative at that time I certainly didn't understand it at that point I I understood it as a question that was being asked about an estimate of costs for comparison sake uh I certainly didn't understand it then as a as as an alternative to uh the repair work that's that propose now maybe that was a misunderstanding but that was that was my frame of mind from from that point forward right and I think it was supposed to was intended to be a discussion at that point to be able to understand what our options might be and and what they could look like going forward um I particularly don't like the concept of spending a lot of money
079if we're going to do something different there eventually um you know it's just um something that if we can if we can streamline the process and get it done quickly um with building Aid it's we either spending the 100,000 out of the repair which is just spending a 100 we don't get any of that back uh that's the money we have in a reserve for the for repair work um and based on some of the the thoughts that we have here I think we end up getting paying a little over 200,000 overall once we get building Aid back for Turf and the concept for me of seeing more practice time more games played um kind of really giving that opportunity for the kids to not have lost time out there is great um you know
080and I appreciate that that they're using the football field to do some practices um awesome does that impact any other sports when they're doing no no track uses it but it's uh they can arrange their drills and setup to not impact our track right so they've been using it they've been using it at night they've been using it during you know after school it's really it's really been a great resource to continue in the past you know if this was on um ice and under snow we were kind of in a waiting game but the turf um clears off much quicker and they've really been utilizing it even our JB teams right and and the fact that we have a program where we can use lose the football field for rentals I think we could
081also maybe possibly consider teaming up the town of pyy or something making some Revenue off in these fields if we were to have a Turk as well so be an interesting concept to look into right that's something that the district could uh pursue I think we need to be looking towards any kinds of Revenue sources we can get um it's tough on the taxpayers obviously we understand that so I'm just trying to weigh the best possible product long-term shortterm um so I'm really tussling with this one it's it's a difficult uh it's a difficult it is uh topic and I really appreciate all the things that you guys have brought to the table everybody here all the discussions by the board the people from the public last week or last two we two weeks ago
082I guess it was so um what really got me I think one one of the parents says you know if one kid one more kid could get prevent from getting knocked in the teeth or broke broken nose if we can do that to to uh if we can eliminate that this is all worth the conversation so you know you hear that I'm like you know let's let's repair this field as soon as possible and then uh you know if you want to continue the conversations about Turf but that really got me saying you know and and talking to the coaches that you know please let let's try to um get this field to safe and and something that they could be proud of as soon as possible and then if turf's an option down the
083road it's an option um and if it passes down the road you know so I don't think there's any I mean I'll speak for myself but um I don't think anybody on the board doesn't want to see work done to the field this season I think that's a must for safety reasons I uh think it's whether or not we want to do this phase one phase two $100,000 worth or if we need to just do what we have been doing for the past couple years to fix up our field on it while we're considering tur and I appreciate uh Richard's opinion on this and I respect that um him sharing that with us and where he stands on it um I I would share mine as well um but I'm going to read it just
084because I easier that way I don't Mumble as much um I'd like to uh thank everyone who's helped gather all of this information um this has been exactly the information that I've been hoping for since we first started this discussion back in October um you know from CPL coming bring all that great data in that's great Anthony thank you you know I couldn't ask more from our FL department on what they've been bringing forward for us so it's really great um but uh I would like the board to consider to move forward with the option of Turing both the softball and the baseball field um and includ at its proposition uh to the voters in the upcoming budget so the community can vote on that uh using a portion of the district's $33.75 million capital
085reserve fund um that was brought up last time by uh by Richard that that should be something that the voters should get a chance to vote on and it sounds like capital reserve funds uh is an option to do that with versus uh the repair Reserve funds we uh cannot for financial reasons for legal reasons for uh logistical reasons it just does not work for us to be able to do one field right now but uh my reasons for this are as followed um there is a difference between wants versus needs uh if my family or I need something uh then we do whatever we have to for it if our car breaks down we fix it uh we can't go without a car if our furnace breaks it or braks we fix it we
086can't go without heat uh depending on how much those things may cost we may have to use a credit card or a loan to pay for these things um well if my family wants something uh then we save up for until we can afford it maybe a vacation maybe a new pool whatever it may be uh we wouldn't look to um you know pay a credit card or a loan for uh for those kinds of things that we may want I feel a turf field for our softball and baseball fields are a want more than a need uh the district has done a good job at saving close to $6 million of taxpayer money over the past three or four years um and that using 1.7 million of the 3.75 million in our c Reserve
087fund is a good way to use some of that money without adding additional taxes to the backs of our taxpayers we've heard the community members board members administrators I don't think anyone is opposed to uh Turf I I I heard it said last time you know when all the uh community members were here that nobody was here was opposed to it it's just uh how do we do it um so the question was just how should it be funded uh the repair Reserve fund is not an option or a capital project that's been brought up um I request the board consider using funds from the capital reserve fund for this project and that the proposition be included in the May budget for the voters to consider a lot of the work has already been done
088on this uh from CPL we've gotten a lot of the information right here in from of us along with a lot of the questions that we need to answer here tonight uh but let's try to get this done together let's try to move forward with it I'd like to see if the uh board would consider giving directive to um the district to allow us to move forward with this consideration trying to get this to happen just want to respon to the re reality uh very nicely done um did meet with Val and uh all of us felt May would be too soon to be able to have a vote because all that information would have to be given to the board in March um which in order to do A needs assessment in order to
089figure all that out um just probably can't be done however we thought the fall was possible um which would give us time to do that and to have a fall boat um we didn't think that affected based on the timetable Chris had given us affected the number of Seasons that it would um uh take away from was we were onun the oppression in two seasons would before the turf would come um lot the process a lot of Pros in each way um you know I guess we have to decide whether spending the amount of money for the dirt is worth it now if if there's a possibility of turf coming but it also seems that the possibility of turf coming isn't a guarantee you know so you're um the concept of doing the 20,000 you
090know makes sense to do before any decision would be made on Turf in my opinion um that'll give us chance to get true numbers and not guested its uh but that's a commitment um I still think we're with timing and to do it right and to get voter approval will take time um so the investment into the dirt I don't think would be a waste because I think it would correct the field sooner rather than later um allow us to do the not rush allow us to get the what do you call it that first phase not the design phase the schematics schematics schematic uh really look at the drainage which I think at at naso probably will be a problem uh really look at you know maybe some of the Ada uh which we
091need to have done so we couldn't do it without it um I think it is more in line with kind of the planning that spacking kill is always done where we could we could plan for it and make sure it's successful versus trying to do it quickly I'm wondering if we get the dirt if and it's done right because I think Marco you had said said something to me that I don't want to put words in your mouth but you know a well manicured field is better than Turf you know if it's well manicured W you know and I think we've learned over the years that we haven't done that um so I I would hope for a commitment to well manure our field uh have a spotlight on if the spotlight is not on
092it right now uh um you know make the improvements we might find that we like it um but in the meantime do the investigation you know uh you know in July when the new uh budget season comes we'll have budget for the 20,000 do it let's see let's see let's see if it comes back you know if it comes back that it is 2.2 million you know maybe we have you know we could call it there but if it comes back and it's 900,000 you know uh and and we could talk to some of Dan's friends um to give us some of those good rates uh maybe we want to do it you know and at least we'll have everything in um so it seems like we could have the best of both worlds maybe
093repair it we'll get to play on it for a season or two to see if it's if it's worthy of of what we want but in the meantime do the investigation to figure out whether or not Turf is I guess feasible in a you know in a cost effective way and look at uh Dan brought up a good idea of renting out like would we would would there be any income on on renting Fields out I know that it's so hard to rent out our own Fields now because we're always using it during the season but maybe there is um you know so that's processing all this you know that's what what seems to kind of work almost get the best of both fix the field maybe we like it if we don't we've done
094the investigation I think Dan brought up or Jeff might have brought up that if for some reason we don't do it right now that that stuff doesn't go bad right that investigation um and then if we happen to have you know you want to pursue it later it's it's not a waste of money we've done the the amount so uh it's kind of my process of all this I think I think from my perspective I listening to what Jeff said listen to what you just said I I like the concept of knowing sooner than later what the voters want to say about it and the only way to do that is to get it to the boat as fast as possible how so what exactly would need to be done to be able to get
095this onto a May proposition so that it's during the normal time because in my mind I'm also thinking if it gets shot down in May well then we go right back we revert right back to repair Reserve we just do it in the in the fall and The Field's in great shape for the spring spring of 26 the timeline for that proposition would follow the timeline for the budget so we would have to have solid costs because the solid cost would have to be part of that proposition at this point we've got estimates of what the turf is but we have no idea what the building piece of that is we'd have to Define what those projects are and cost those things out and according you'll see in my later presentation right now the board
096is scheduled to adopt the budget on April 8th which means all of that has to be solidified and in place before April 8 CPL said that it' be about A10 to $15,000 estimate to re re what the repoint um each building so that's semi estimate established and that's determing if that is what we truly want to do yeah we never we haven't talking about need he was just trying to give an example of something that could be done for $10,000 but that is something that needs to be done yes that that is on the BCA so something that's already on our needs yes that could be taken off of it and used towards this a smaller project if I may um I I've been in you know other districts where there's questions for the public
097that you you know forgive me if this is not the way you guys do things but basically polling Mr caller if you could potentially do uh you know a poll to the community um to to see their thoughts on it we typically do it with if there's a big project that's going to have it a large tax impact we usually go out to the community prior to that and say hey what's your tolerance for that you know is it ex you know whatever it is and then you get feedback and you you know you would like to have more participation with most things but uh it could give you a slice of at least uh um some people's mentality just a thought you know I'd like to Circle back to the logic of um you
098know when when this could be feasibly voted on um and again I'm I'm supportive of the idea of of a turf field I don't think I'm supportive of that idea of committing to it right now um and you know what you're outlining Dan you know let's get this to the public as quickly as possible seems to me looking at it logically more a recipe for defeating this than than for ultimately getting it approved um given some of the things that b just mentioned the need to tie this to a building project that would um not only you know earn state aid but make it more sellable to the public um you know my history here you know in this District goes back far enough to remember what Mr lone was talking about the way in
099which the tur field project the football field got defeated twice uh there was a lot of strategizing involved in how to you know package that and present it to the public in the context of a pretty large Capital project to get it approved ultimately I think it was approved because people saw it as an enhancement to every part of the district dist and all of its buildings I just am not confident I have to say I'm not confident at all that a project like this could uh guar the support of the community if it were primarily uh in terms of cost uh you know centered on the Improvement of you know the tur Fields uh there are other needs in the district I think that you know we've heard about over the last years months
100that I think would need to be addressed I mean I'm thinking of you brought this up several times Dr F the aium I mean the people who use that Auditorium uh here's how I think a member of the community might look at it you know the the auditorium is used by lots and lots of our students by members of our community uh and if um if I think as a voter again this is someone who's supportive of baseball and and have been involved in it for a long long time um with my children here in the district and outside the district but if I were a voter in the district presented with you know a project that was primarily a turf baseball field Improvement and um I didn't see included in that a crying need
101it seems to me like like the auditorium um I would be you know have have a hard time supporting it I mean for one thing uh the auditorium Services you know on a numbers basis I think a lot more people than our baseball fields do and I'm just you know concerned that that's how many people in the committee would look at it so for those kinds of reasons trying to kind of move this to a point where we can vote on it quickly seems to be more like a self-defeating proposition and I you know for that reason amongst others that I mentioned earlier I you know again I I just see this as potentially a win-win if we were to go ahead with the improvements of the field that are proposed now you know for
102the next couple of Seasons at least you know we'd have a really better facility for those students who are you know our students who are playing on that field and we retain and you know the possibility of a of a longer range Improvement and maybe in that respect the $25 or $20,000 is well spent uh not insignificant amount of money I mean that's a quarter of the the amount of money that is being proposed for the enhancements of the field right now but I think it might be money well spent if it could allow us to make a you know a decision that would pay off in um in a way that could be supported by the community I think it just take more time for that just being honest I just don't see how
103it's feasible in the short term that's great insight as as far as I'm concerned I think that's well well thought out and the history of what you've seen is is very helpful um do we have a a scope generally in our mind of the auditorium type of repairs or improvements and how long something like that would take to package up and uh we don't have a scope I do have a meeting um coincidentally uh scheduled for as it scheduled uh with with some of the drama people and the music people to to discuss their concerns we've already met anon's met with uh Steve merser myself Val to look at it and we realized it was it wasn't something like we could do in the budget you know you know it's something that would require a
104bigger look uh that's sort of what we're using this year for to kind of go through and talk to people and um look at what are the immediate safety kind of things that need to be done and then what are the um longer term things uh we thought that that was very possibly a capital project or or or could be a capital reserve um but again to have to have those type of numbers you know for March we just we just can't um that that's that's what I would suggest to do you know saying that a little bit is I think we just need to complete our needs assessment um you know the the the idea of turf is great the idea of turf rapidly uh you know uh maybe it's just my own nature
105uh I I want to plan and make sure it's it's the right thing for the district and and the district can afford it along with many other things right I got a call today that the the heat in the high school we had many classrooms under 55 degrees that is something that's on our needs assessment to address the you know the hbac concerns uh I hear that um Governor hokel signed the the I call it the air conditioning act you know that there's now heating days where if it's too hot um and I think we need to look at air conditioning some of our bigger areas um in the building you know like a cafeteria at the at the elementaries or something where you can put a lot of people in if there's not enough
106um we just haven't fulfill that needs assessment because we didn't we didn't know we had to because we weren't we weren't at that stage I did not feel we're going to ask the community uh to vote this year uh because Capital project just ending uh last year um I do think our budget this year will be higher than what we've had in the past uh that's just a product of some funds drying up um so you know I know I am I know Val is even more so than me as a planner uh to try to plan to make sure things are sustainable um you know so that that's just my opinion I whether people know it or not I most of my life I was an athlete I think as each year I get
107older I'm less of an athlete um I played baseball in high school I obviously played basketball in college I am a full support of Athletics you'll see me at events uh the concept of a turf field to me is very intriguing and exciting and um I just don't know if we're in position to do that right now but I think we can be I think I think looking at everything and and putting things together uh I think we can be but I I that's just my opinion um you know the the board I love the passion you know I I love the idea um I'm I guess I'm here just to you know the people here that came here today were more towards to talk about you know the reality like I'm confused a little
108bit because we get CPL giving us numbers um and then we actually have a board president who who who knows this stuff you know so I don't most boards have that you know so you know I usually go by numbers you know like hey 2.2 million and then he said maybe half that 1.1 million you know and then we have an engineer saying no it's going to be less than that you know so without me knowing that you know uh 2.2 million that's a lot I don't know if we could afford that you know if it's 300,000 yes um so you know that's why I'm for the the the 20,000 or $25,000 kind of let's get real numbers let's get that right um because in my field I was trained to all right CPL says
109that that's what it is uh we have we get you get a couple quotes and that's what they are but I'm intrigued by our own knowledge on our own board could it could it be less um you know if we go by what CPL says I think I think it's a lot um you go by cheaper rate than that you know maybe maybe starts to bridge it down closer I just even what CPL is saying is that those are their higher end inflated numbers that they would expect you know once they get back this $225,000 they'd have a better understanding of that's like their sounded like their doomsday kind of price right there um so to a couple of points on it you know is with Richard's concerns of whether or not voters would support
110this or not I have the same concern if we were to throw the this on to a larger Capital project that this would be one of the first things that's bumped off a larger Capital project is a uh um is any improvements to uh to the turf fields because that sounds like it was difficulty to get past just with the football field so it's going to be that much harder with the baseball field um I would argue the opposite that I feel that the voters and taxpayers would be more in favor of this because this is not something that's going to increase their taxes but it's money that is being use from money that they have saved over the past few years for these kinds of projects um me as a taxpayer I would prefer
111a bunch of mini capital projects such as this to chip away at these larger projects than having to do one large project and watch my taxes go up so I would prefer seeing something like this saying on our proposition that we're looking to do these two Fields with some um improvements to some of the build buildings um and that it's not going to increase your taxes at all and we hope to be able to continue doing these smaller projects as we can again this being more of a want than a need um you I think it's a little bit easier of a pill to swallow um when it's not going to be more taxes um being increased because of these projects whereas if it's our air condition that needs to be fixed or um you
112know a uh the the auditorium or heating whatever it may be those turn into uh needs um that you know we we would need to take out a loan for a bond for it to be able to because our capital reserve fund doesn't have that kind of funding in it um so that would end up costing the taxpayers money if we bundled this all together until one larger Capital project I would assume that we'd have to take a bond out for uh for this larger project versus chipping away at some of the things that we want to put on this larger project now my point was we could use the capital reserve to do some of those needs because that we would be able to do some of the hbac stuff some of the auditorium
113needs through not a capital project need a capital reserve so do you think it's something that the auditorium and the fields are within the price range of our current capital budget I don't know that because we haven't done the needs assessment that's that was kind was more than we could handle in the budget um we also have to remember that those Capital reserves right are going to help us for electri buses yeah $2 million in a capital reserve fund just for our electric buses don't we have $2 million in a electric bus fund it would be a drop in the bucket it would be yes muchy $300,000 for a bus plus infrastructure plus charging we're trying to save over the next few years to to build that up uh in order to afford that unless
114we build that up we will have to do a capital project for electric buses if that that stays um um if that you know again and I'm I don't know that that's just what that's just what we've been told we have to follow right now right so we're following what you have right now we can't buy any more diesel buses after 2027 we have to have our Fleet by 2032 will those numbers change I hope I was always hopeful they would get extended we just kind of move them out a little bit um my concern is just that if we continue delaying this that it's going to be delayed till it's completely not just on the back burner but completely taking off the burners or right now um we have the funding to be able
115to do it um we have a uh a tight time frame to try to um get this on the table I don't think that it's impossible to uh gather the information that's needed um even if it is just the point work or the repointing that needs to be done that's on our current needs assessment I think that there's enough information for us to be able to have something together um by March so you're saying the quinain um if you attach it to the feel that you would let the voters vote on that yeah it' be the turfield and the pointing or whatever they're able to come up with if there's something other than that between now and March so they wouldn't need a need assessment right they've already done the need assessment the repointing is
116part of their current needs assessment well that's we haven't done A needs assessment we did is a a b BCS what is it building condition survey building condition survey said that these are things that we should consider when we do the needs assessment the needs assessment is kind of a deeper dive and communicate however we all know I know where's John like we've been talking about we do need to do the repointing um we definitely need could see spots so we know that that is is something that we would need to have done um so that's accurate you don't have to have A needs assessment to be able to put that on to do not except uh My worry is that there's other things that maybe should be in that but we wouldn't put in
117that because we haven't done the the work to do that but that is something that we need to be done like I we know that uh we've been putting it off because we we've done other things uh but that is on the list of things that we have to do um especially if you look coincidentally near the baseball field and where the Outdoor Classroom is there's some definely some reporting that needs to be done there um so who would do the need assessment be done by us I mean we work with CPL but um we would then take he says the building condition survey says X Y and Z then we need to explore what x y and z are to what degree we want to do that how what's the you know how deep
118do we want to go in that do we want to repoint or do we want to repoint with the best bricks in the world or do we want you know the our HVAC needs to be do we want to just put the regular HVAC in do we want this do we want to add air conditioning here like it's all those are all part of a lengthy discussion in terms of the timeline when would you get that done you how we going to do a need assessment you probably take the rest in Val and jump in the rest of this school year take kind of yeah it would so it's not a month or two it's the entire it would be talking with all the administration going through all the buildings the building condition survey usually
119just talks about structure like repointing and sidewalks but we look into the classrooms and like Paul said you know hbac what classrooms do what classrooms don't what other spaces need it especially with Governor hok saying if it's 82 degrees then kids have to move out of the classroom so those are the kinds of things that would be in the needs assessment we'd be looking at the interior we'd be talking to the building administrators the teachers that kind of thing to get the day-to-day needs included in that study do we have to vote now because people people have to go we I want you know every you know that the the point of this and I'm sorry that the other thing wasn't in there try to I think we all try to sandre to make sure
120is everything in here um and I'm sorry that we did not have that other piece uh uh that you had mentioned here before but the point was to try to give you every bit of information so that you can make an informed decision nothing we're saying here is for or against it's for this is our reality um and how to best go forward with our reality you know and I guess we at that point where you are GNA be as the I guess because there other questions yeah I just wanted to just I I got to Circle back to the auditorium stuff we obviously are identifying it what are some of the specific things that we are talking about just generally generally specific the specific you can be generally specific lighting the sound system lighting
121sound just the the floor the seating we either need new seating or we need figure out if if we could repair the seating we have keep going back and forth every time you take seating out is it still the case that they can't take heavy equipment onto the stage 4 right it's not being supported no you can't um there was a fly bar issue a while ago fix able to do that that was an immediate so we actually found funds for that um you know it really just hasn't been touched in a meaningful way since it was redone 2000 I don't know when it was redone um probably around there was before I I got here but it was R Done um I don't know because we haven't done that but we would like to
122do I know Anthony is there any you mean you electrical issues right there's yeah I think there's electrical issues there's seating there's flooring uh Acoustics uh house lights um yeah sound system it kind of the list goes on and there things that we really have to hone in on again necessity as opposed to want and so on and um part of my meeting that was coming up with with uh you know some of the trama people is to identify some things that we could pick away at you know so instead of a capital project which I think we wanted to do at this point as you know kind of brought up is is there something all right so is there a an electrical issue that we could use either through the budget or through the
123capital uh Reserve in order to to address that so that's really that's where we are with that literally when's the meeting next week Monday I think she said she couldn't make Monday I might not be so so generally what would the at what point would we know approximately how much should be put into the auditorium overall versus what we could do with capital reserve so that sounds this sounds like an awful lot it sounds like a basic revamp of the whole thing so yeah um we'd have to bring everybody you know the experts in their lighting sound Chris will put you on the spot how much what are we talking about here couple mil Yeah couple mil 2 million at least with all that yeah yeah for sure y auditoriums are expensive and and you
124know part of that kind of needs assessment is really you know we would bring from the the building condition survey kind of the nuts and bolts of things and say Hey you know I don't need anybody to tell me the condition of a window right I could look at that purely and be like okay that needs to be replaced but then you know some of the things that vow was mentioning meeting with the different buildings and meeting with different user groups is hugely hugely important because those are the things that we don't see on a day-to-day basis we call that the programmatic work um I can't tell if your cafeteria is too small based on that you know so it things I mean I could but in essence you know where I'm getting at so
125really that that and then the priority of all that so you're going to have typically the way the process goes if you're really prepping for a capital project is that you put everything on paper and it's going to be way more than you could ever imagine but then you got to chip away at it you know um a lot of school districts in in New York state you know have buildings this vintage large huge instit institutional type buildings that take a lot of uh a lot of money to to revamp certain Building Systems so um but all part of the pro process all part of you know actually I I love that process I love meeting with the people that actually use the space and here and there uh paying points and things like that
126because really at the end of the day we're just trying to solve the problem you know so and how realistic is phasing an auditorium project like that is it is it really is it best to do all at once is it typically yeah if you if you have the ability to kind of do it all at the same time it it's helpful I I always for an example I would rather if you were to renovate a science wing of a building I would rather do one science classroom fully than six science classrooms phased and get some things here certain things here because the way we have to do public bidding construction and separate Prime construction where we have a separate general contractor separate separate mechanical contractor all that is is it could be done we
127do it every day but there's just more layers to it it's a little tougher to you know gather everybody think think there's some things that are more of a safety issue that need to be done sooner with the auditorium where waiting so that's probably that's what some of these meetings are for sure to figure out all right what which components should we just do now and which components can we do later either be the same mechanism budget capital reserve um if you can do some of those you could chip away and then not have to do the capital project for that specific thing right or at least get get the urgent things done and then do the seating another time you know seats still work so that's not urgent but like you know the lighting's
128not working or there's a hole in the stage or whatever that's we want that taken care of yep before I do like the seats and sure do you think some of these urgent repairs that need to be done could be tied into could this yes um instead of doing a repointing of doing these things that need to be done right away I I do think that I would prefer or I think in in the email I sent the board was that if we are able to do A needs assessment I think I would have different things tied to the interior or maybe not different more tied to the interior versus sounds like some things that are Urgent right now to pick from though real real quick before so it's a different building we're talking about
129the high school yeah so thank you separate project number it's like its own world now it's like it's everything is so separate they're just so building obsessed so so that doesn't count when the capital reserve has to be also kind of looked at as separate right if if you're building he means it won't give Aid to the turfield so we need the we need the interior might add the auditorium stuff to it it's a very good point right well but that's not necessarily a bad thing I mean if there's something that's urgent that needs to get done now that's outside of our budget that we could use capital reserve funds for right now to make these urgent repairs that tie into what well you know the consideration is that also the repair Reserve what's that
130the repair Reserve could be used for that as well could be I guess so yeah you're right could be it just goes back to we haven't had those conversations because it know we know we needed to do it now but we didn't know it wasn't on our plan to do that right this moment because we weren't going to go to the community for and I was just those meetings were just being set up literally coincidentally not because of this but uh well that's that's an interesting question so um not to prolong this but but if if repointing for example brick work could be considered repair would C could it also be considered Capital Improvement I this is the opposite side of the discussion we were having earlier right so then we'd have to get into
131all of that it's building work I guess is the the differentiation there yeah internal building work is that how it's viewed by the state it could just be building work talk for hours honestly um it's subjective a touch at you the State education department doesn't in capital projects they don't want to see repairs yeah but you know a repair to one is a different I think what he's talking about is the the confusion the difference between the repair reserve and the capital reserve because some items in the repair Reserve were considered Capital things in are out so would repairing the auditorium be a capital reserve project or a repair Reserve project so we have to that's all part of the needs assessment and figure out what that is but you are correct it might be
132you know might not be able to use the capital reserve for that if if it's not new stuff it's interesting that's part of you can't use the repair Reserve fund and you can't use the repair Reserve fund either okay do we have uh do we ever authorize C be able to do that uh study for the electric charging and what that infrastructure was going to cost I think we talked about that a while back I just I don't know if we ever authorized it we author we have done just a study to see where we could physically put the buses but now the next step of that is to work with Central Hudson to see what upgrades are going to be needed and all of that but the initial study that's been done says that
133we can keep our buses right where they are we can have them all there so now we just have to get to essential Hudson piece and the infrastructure piece and see what that's going to cost okay so we don't have those numbers we don't have okay it's a little bit of game of chicken do we don't want to get into it too early where it becomes obsolete or yeah if it happens to go away but we don't want to be too far behind and that was the theory of of putting the money in the reserves is at least we're doing something to save to save so when we have to make our move uh there would be some money there to make a move like if we have to buy five buses you know maybe
134we have enough in that fund to do that or we have to put in half of our charging stations because we don't have a full Fleet of 15 16 you know we might be able to do that and then replenish it and then do so there's just a lot of questions you know uh there's no answers because of the um I don't say vagueness because of the uncertainty of the electric bus uh mandate but it remains it remains steadfast in it at this moment um that's also we could learn a lot like if we again were to do the dirt work and then do the um assessment on the fields the $25,000 think that would buy us time to see maybe the electric bus thing goes away maybe it doesn't um you know I I
135guess just what's maybe the board could help us understand what's the urgency of turf is it just simply don't want to spend the money on the dirt if we're going to Turf right that's my personal concern yes I also agree with that I also am concerned if we continue just tailing it over and over or putting it off over and over that it will get pled into a capital a larger Capal it's never come up before I mean we've never talked about it before no I know I'm just saying like over and over my concern that's misleading with the spotlight that's now on the field do you think it's worth giving it a shot to see if we can get a wellmaintained dirt field or do we think that that we just think that's that's
136not going to happen we don't know I mean my my preference would not to be do that I would prefer to see a tur field over a dirk field and how come um multiple reasons but you know if you speak with any kid who's played on a turf field versus a baseball field or dirt field they're going to prefer Turf I've spoken with the coaches that would prefer having Turf our field currently has a drainage problem uh where Turf may be a solution to that we have shading over the fields that's making it so it's not drying out um even if it does have good drainage if it's a rainy day out and that field gets wet it's not going to be used where you can play on a turf field in the middle of
137the Ring I've been through full tournaments in the middle of turf field um you know the the maintenance of it you don't have to continue to line it you don't have to have your kids staying after practice or Mr lanzon out there breaking the fields or putting down lines you know I can go on with benefits of it but that's uh that's my reasoning for it we talked about the rain is there is there a lot of rain outs I yeah we talked about it with the coaches are we don't have any more postponed games than any they feel and I feel talking to athletic directors we don't have any more than anybody else in our league well also nobody else has any other turf fields right so they're in the same boat everybody's in
138the same boat yeah so it's not unusual to have you know depending it's it was dry the one spring so we maybe had a couple we had a rainy season a few years back so we had not to interrupt it's not just the the games it's practices that get canceled is a very uh short season uh regardless so to not be able to have practices because it's uh because it's raining um it's spring I mean spring is known for heavy amounts of rain and does that I mean so they use the gym and then they'll utilize the turf High School turf field at times as well especially early in the season you know we were we were in the in March we used to get a lot more ice and and snow years ago too
139but you're right that that shaded area did take a while for that home plate area to uh to dry out um and we didn't have an alternative so it was a lot of indoor practices um but the high school turfield has helped with that some there are other schools that are considering putting in Turf I know wers has it on their uh Capital project right now to add three turf fields to two softball fields a multi-use field so there are other uh school districts around us that are putting them in did the voters no they're being proposed proposition to the voters to vote on I wasn't aware of that yeah I just was made aware of it myself I they just put up they're putting up a capital project but I didn't see the contents
140of it but I know wers was putting up had to sit through the entire thing so I I definitely picked up on that one I mean I my opinion we've done a really good job of creating a great track know we have football and soccer now our our gymnasium at the high school has been uh really uh revamped with seating and the flooring so now we've got basketball and volleyball we were talking about these incred incredibly important things for the tennis court too the tennis courts really need that thank you for bring that up tennis courts are going to be there now too so then it does it leaves it leaves the baseball and the softball and the reason I think we're belaboring this point at this on this is is because now this is
141money that's going to go towards baseball and softball the what's being presented to us and is there a better option overall you know so that that's that's why I'm having the hard time that I am with this of just allowing the dirt to go in at this point yeah so that I agree with all those improvements that that have been made and that was part of the reason why coach and I wanted to sit down with Anthony and kind of go over those discuss the field and how it's playing and what we thought could bring it up to uh to par um so we're on the same wavelength and that that's where it initiated I did speak with uh coach n about it as well to make sure I wasn't stepping on his toes about
142it and and yourself as well to make sure I didn't step on your toes with it um but he also said the same thing that you know having a turfield would be beneficial to the program to practices to uh the drainage issues that they have to you know just the overall you know baseball experience I mean you look at our football football soccer well was a football team at the time and to where it is now yeah it was you know it does alleviate a lot of those issues and it's a program that you know we're proud of all of our programs but this is a program that has three you know three different state championships I didn't even know we had three I thought we only had two but apparently we had three two
143recently back six um so I mean it'd be nice to give them that same support back and uh you know be able to have a good facility for them not that the dirt wouldn't be I just think that the Turk would be a better option than a dir I think uh I I really don't know if baseball player have asked if they had a choice between playing on dirt or turf they're going to choose dirt as their home field I think if you ask our current players you know if we can do some work to repair that field to make it safe for the next couple years I think they would absolutely say please I agree I also think if we ask those same players if we could have turf in the next year or
144two which would you prefer and they would say Turf yeah but this is what it yeah I mean it's I just don't see how a turf field is feasible for the next year or two it just seems like we keep going around and CES on this I understand the passion I understand all the points and I agree with them longer term but just seems like there's such an advantage to be gained for the current when you talk about wanting to support our baseball team right now well this would be a way to do it CPL just told us that they could do it within two seasons so possibly everything went right possibly by everything falls right if the voter there so many if involved with that if the voters approve it if you know State
145aded comes through and so forth it just we're looking at the same ifs with our current field if it's not raining out if the fields aren't flooded we should be able to get the clay done we should be able to get phase one done not phase two until the next year so there's the same ifs and you can argue you're right we go around in circles with it that's fine so the current item that's tabled is if we're moving forward with the current repair Reserve funds proposal as is and I would propose an amendment to it propose away then I propose that the uh repair Reserve Remain the way that it is um minus the 90 I don't have the number in front of me now the 95,000 for baseball s95 94 370 with the
146understanding that we are still going to do the regular maintenance work that we do each year to those fields of bringing in the sand and bringing in the um you know the routine work that we would keep to maintain that field that we've done every year up to this point okay with the understanding that it's going to play just as it has in the past for this year yeah yep and then if we find that we until until it's we find that we can't do it we'll be in the same position a couple of months from now that we can uh come back and revisit a repair Reserve fund request on it and uh it'll still be ready for the 2026 season as most of this would be done in 2026 season anyways I I
147think it's two baseball Seasons that it would take just want to be clear on that yeah possibly so that's all just just one no no I agree it's it's more than likely I would agree with you that it's going to take two seasons but it's possible that it could happen in 2026 if things go smoothly can I have a ask a question yeah so the back stops were part of that 990,000 that breakdown would we would we still want to do some of the work if you're not if you're going to pull oh I honestly I don't know what the uh it didn't say anything about back stops in the fa in Phase One or phase two and anon's back stops in the turf they in the turf yeah they were in the turf just
148there was there was no new there were not new back stops in the dir okay that's what I was asking thank you the CP said that we probably need new back stops if you're going to a Turf in and probably led to you probably will need new dugouts um I would just speak again my concern is if we're spending $100,000 now on this versus doing a capital project that we could get a majority of that back from the state and only really only cost us $200,000 I'd rather get two turf fields for $200,000 than two dirt fields for $100,000 I I your numbers I don't know I just just my clarity I I don't think there would be $200,000 yeah I mean there's too many contingencies but regardless your point is it goes back to
149everything do you want to spend the $100,000 now and then possibly two years from now have exhausted that because we haven't kept kept up with it and put it to field in I think that's really what what you're asking so how much would it cost us to repair the um Fields without this $100,000 in order to do it right that's what we have to do it any other way I think Marco said it would just play the way it's been playing if we do our regular maintenance is what is our regular maintenance consist of yeah we've already we've already done some edging of the field that's been done um in the fall so that you know we're ahead of a game in the spring we will bring in some some clay obviously we won't remove
150the amount of clay that we would be doing we might pull a little bit out but mostly we just kind of lay down on top um reedge reine and and do a little bit of overseeding um costs are nominal um and you know it's not going to address you know most of the issues that we're trying to address with in the repair Reserve um how big of a difference do you see um that where you're still bringing in clay but possibly not digging it up digging it up sounds more like it's for the drainage part of it but as far as the play goes and our concerns of I'm assuming the the balls popping up and hidden kids in the face is what we really want to try to avoid do you think that bringing
151in this uh clay as a as a secondary option um would help alleviate some of that I do yeah I do especially given the expertise of the contractor and the grading process um I also know that the infield the grass if I'm if I'm correct that's that's kind of a bit of an issue of the of the inconsistency of the ball popping and all that so um while it's unlikely that we'd be able to top soil and Seed the infield for this season it would certainly be ready for next season so just just to clarify my my proposal would be to keep the uh capital reserve um I'm sorry not the capital reserve the repair Reserve proposal as is minus the baseball portion of it um and still have the regular maintenance done that we
152have been doing um additionally um think you said you're okay with us moving forward with the $25,000 on the data collection from CPL well would we have to authorize that as well no but that's something we wouldn't be able to do until July new the new budget just I struggle with uh with that that we aren't able to come up with $25,000 to do this study before July um that's it just would be out of a cost we wouldn't do something that we had ear marked it for which is fine that we figure out what I would want to see what we're cutting off for putting ACK on until and that would that's a hard thing to say especially halfway through the year yeah because I don't know what's coming between now and may yeah
153I don't want to do that I had another question I'm sorry um so if the if a project was presented to the community tur fields and some indoor work and it was defeated where would we go you know what's the next step for repairing B right back to this right back to this we'd have to propose another repair Reserve that would be in it we'd have to have another hearing and then the board would vote on it and what's that timeline we don't know until we know correct when the vote is correct well if if we really can't get to a vote until the fall then doing that work in the fall is is out of question so then we're in the same position where weather dependent for 26 and I I don't love that
154just based ond's timeline for Budget votes and Sandra just verified for me that everything would have that the resolution as it would appear on the ballot would have to be set in March so the end of March the March 26 or something 2 2 to approve the resolution order for me to includ on theot the weom we present that to you the week meeting before that just need to see itch there's also since this is exterior work and disturbing land there would be a secra requirement here so the State education quality review act so there's a lar long process with that piece of it as well so um that has to do with you know the the voting and and you know part one environmental assessment forms declaring Le the agency so that's it's it's
155a it's a quite the process too and then there's legal timelines of that and with votes and you know getting local newspaper so it's it the time just goes I me you adding time to the turf timeline right now for for the the the secret processes you would have to go through the secret process and and it's basically an investigation of it so you think it's a type one action I wouldn't say it would be because if it's over I would have to relate to or rely on Tim for that um I wouldn't necessarily say you would be type one I think would probably you know um you would have basically a field there already so you're kind of replacing that field but typ two but yet you're doing which is ministerial yeah but you
156would you would have to do your due diligence no matter what with all the different you know wildlife and all that type of stuff yeah repairs and stuff of that nature are type too so right but we would have an in-house planner to review all that you know especially if you're getting into drainage structures and things and piping going farther from the field um you know stuff like that so I I I just wanted to bring it up just so it doesn't you know um but the what is the impact of that so the tur field timeline would be extended a little bit because we have to do the Seca if go right but if you're going you know if you're going to do a vote on on the potential project you would have to
157do the secret process kind you know prior to that as well too so it's no matter what no matter what the project is as Mr CER probably knows it's like you that you got to do the secret process and typically so if you're doing a roofing project simple type two you're G you're done but uh you would still have to declare the the agency and things like that that's where the data collection of this is so important because then that would have your secret implications as well you know depending on certain things so I guess this brings us back to um whether or not to approve the dirt in the reserve um you know just process everything you've heard here tonight ask any further questions and then I guess we could vote um I think
158there's a way to have the best of both worlds where we could do the repairs take the time to you know figure out if it's feasible and take the time to maybe put something to the voters that uh would be more balanced but um it's up to the board to to decide that and let us know what you want to do I do think doing the 25,000 makes sense um either now or in J or authorize it in July I don't know if that really hurts our Tim table a whole lot if we wait until July I think we've already does because it takes four months to do that I think we're already two seasons out and I don't think that will affect more than two seasons but uh if the Hope was to try
159to get it done in one season then that would SWAT that I don't think one season would happen but you know you never know um but I get it I get it it's it's a decision you have to make um yeah much better estimates can make be made on the extent of the turf if we did the $25,000 study and then we would have more information to be able to Pivot at that point if we needed to so where would we get the $25,000 at this point we need don't authorize the district to do that and Val said you know she can do that but it's going to cost some other areas Poss and I want to know what the other areas are I don't want to sacrifice you know I'll just say I'm not
160prepared to vot on that either right now to approve that I'm about the same fine it's by uh majority so I would be in favor of authorizing the uh District to do that now well K how are these things related you know that that we're considering here it just seems like we're kind of moving several different directions here at the same time we've got a motion that's been brought back we're still considering that motion now we're entertaining another another I mean it's I'm not sure where we are well one kind of influence is the other if we can do the uh $25,000 approve the district to do that and start that then we'll have a better idea for whether or not it's even feasible to do a turf field or not so I need to
161know where the money is coming from I I would not I would not approve that like I need to know where the money is coming from doing it now just puts us in a tough spot I I don't think I don't think we want to do that um which puts us in a tough spot because then we're we're talking about using $100,000 and towards something that we might be replacing in two years so I can we table it I can't see spending 100,000 to do something if we're going to be red doing it in two years no can we table this subject and revisit it repair Reserve project or the 25,000 I mean I have to be I'm going to be very Frank here I'm going to be very Frank it seems like you know
162what's being proposed in terms of delaying the vote on the repair Reserve project is factually I think objectively is just delaying the possibility that that can happen in such time as will benefit Uh current players on on our baseball pro our baseball teams it seems as if you know we're cutting off our nose despite our face you know to to use an image um introducing these other contingencies and and conditions just seems to make it less and less likely that you know uh that the field will be improved in the short term and while $100,000 is a lot of money I would agree uh my view is that it's worth it for what what we would gain in the short term for the current players in the team which you two are professing is your
163primary concern so I'm just increasingly puzzled by this I have to be very honest it just seems like again I think agree with what Paul said earlier we could have both here potentially we can have something in the short term at a not terrible cost money that's already accounted for in the repair Reserve fund and and we can retain the possibility of of of her feel in the future in a way that makes it more um responsible I think to the community and also not to to say it's even less strategically more doable I think in terms of the support that we would need from the community so to me it it just seems like um I've said this enough times I don't know how many times I can say I think we have both
164I think we should go ahead with the one now um it doesn't preclude doing the study the $225,000 study but I think two we should do that in a responsible way I agree with Sasha we should do that in a responsible way uh and I'll just be honest I think we're advocating our responsibility to the entire Community if if we rush through rush into these things Marco would you come to the podium for I don't know I'm sorry if I'm speaking out of term but the tennis courts we we've talked about last year you know there's a real need for the tennis courts to get done so my fear of tabling and and moving this I know you know once we get this approved Anthony can start working on um getting schedules the the June
165to a um May to August is the busiest time for these um companies that redo resurface tennis courts and um I really really hope that we can get this um approved so we can get it on on the schedule um because I don't know how many more seasons our tennis coures are going to be playable so let's vote that's it okay so we can either entertain a motion to accept the item four 02 as written or we could we could have an amendment to it is your motion is it an actual formal motion did you make a formal motion here uh yeah I can make a motion to amend the repair Reserve proposal um to remain as is um minus the uh the baseball soft portion of it um with the understanding that the regular
166maintenance is still going to be done on the field that Anthony had spoken of of play being you know some play or some work still being done on that field to prepar for this season um and then if we find we can't move forward with the turf Capital project and I would want to revisit this again and consider using the repair Reserve fund for these phase one phase two proposals is that all part of the motion I'm not even sure if procedurally we can add things like that to a motion about a okay so just the motion to amend it so just the motion to amend it and remove the baseall portion of it and then authorize them to do that afterwards okay so there's a motion to accept the repair Reserve fund resolution as
167written minus the baseball and softball is there a second for that motion all right I'll second it we so we can do a vote uh I guess we'll do a roll call just to be very clear Joan uh no no Richard no Sasha no no Jeff yes yes okay and I guess I would say yes since I seconded the motion so now we have a vote and it's no um I think what Marco said is very concerning to me I do want the tennis courts to be done um sorry just trying to figure out how to procedurally get something done tonight think being that we're here I think just move forward with the original okay so I mean we is there a motion to accept the repair Reserve fund as written so moved okay Richard
168is there a second second Sasha okay again let's do a roll call vote then yes yes Richard yes yes Sasha yes yes Jeff yes yes and I will vote Yes then as well so that passes 5 appreciate everybody's patience out there trying to get through something difficult here okay um that being said I would still like to move forward with at least the study if there's a way to figure out how you can tell us exactly what possibly could be removed so we could do the study sooner than later and then we'll at least know because for me it's a lack of knowledge at this point I'd like to know we can find the money just let's look through it get excuse me we know what we have to do and I and I could
169solicit the the subc consultants and get hard numbers for for them so we'll we'll do that on our end and we'll forward that Tok you yeah that'll give us something to consider because you know obviously if the weather doesn't allow this work to be done we find out that the that this is a real option we can still not use that money at that time and I think as you said this money won't go to waste because if we even if we don't Turf our Fields we'll have the schematics for the future right and maybe we'll discover some drainage stuff we need to work on anyway which I'm sure we will discover so are we authorizing at 25,000 now um I believe he asked us to see if we could find it and we're going
170to get back to everyone and Chris will get us some hard numbers valid numb we're not we're not spending that money yet until we could see if we could find a spot for it but we worst case scenario we are planning for July 1 because that's when our new budget starts so we either going to have it sooner I think the board clearly said sooner knowledge is better so we'll see if we can do that give us that task we'll work on that all right again thank you for your patience everybody with that we'll move on to 6.01 that's a presentation from our business administrator Chris and an thank you for coming thank you thanks very much need a break to uh we see a gentleman from Chestnut here yes that's yeah would you like
171to uh uh tell us who you are and what you're holding we have a check presentation for you guys for the and my name is Ahmed Ramsey I'm the marketing coordinator for CH market and uh we were running a program last year it's called X on pump for a so every three gallons every 3 cents per gallon from a customer uh we use that money toward donation towards schools so we've been doing it across 8 locations between New York New Jersey and Connecticut so we're donate the schools how did you choose us uh we actually have one down the on South Road so we saw you guys in the area so we are for the program Stu yes please choose us all the time did we have to apply or anything or did you just
172did this from side so I actually called you guys and I spoke to uh I think her name is Stephanie marer or something sorry I forgot her name uh I I spoke to you spoke to Stacy McIntyre Stacy yes yes and I mentioned her the program then she got back to me so you guys the donation she came to us and we were very excited about your program so it's actually going to be a yearly program so every year there's going to be a donation wow we appreciate that so what are you presenting us uh a check for 2,150 that's how much we could like to wow excent thank you so much [Applause] come waited the midle John you able to take a picture of us you should be did you hear me you should
173be in here no say John on three no Chestnut on three thank you got it guy here wonder he get to check or you got to WIP it off so I was earlier in Old life well thank you for com definit have a good night guys thank any the water thato okay you're up Val I'm up it's that time of year again and this is the first and probably the simplest of our budget presentation this is a recap of the current years budget the 2425 budget is 5 3,938 245 which represents a 3.89% increase over the 2324 budget the current tax levy to support our current budget is 33 m867 39 which represents an increase of 1.7% over the 2324 tax liit just getting started on the budget for the 2526 school year some of
174the assumptions that are currently on the table is the change to the uh teachers retirement system right now the state estimates that it may decrease a little bit some to somewhere between 9.5 and 10% of salaries conversely the Employee Retirement System is anticipating an increase from 15.2% to 16.5% we CPI for last year is 2.9% and that's just the overall price increase for the state um another budget assumption is something that we've been talking about kind of tangentially which is all those stimulus grants that we got for Co have officially ended as in September of 2024 of budget assumptions um the collective baring agreements that are currently in place and we also have several contracts that will be ending in June of 2025 so we will have estimates for increases that will apply to those
175particular Ving units B Services speaking with the business official at bosis somewhere between 5 to 8% increase um that mear will be um visiting us at some point in the next few weeks to give us a little bit more clarity on at least the administrative portion for the bosy services so the cost of bosy services will increase but we're also as a district we're using more Bosey services so there's going to be an increased with additional Services plus the cost of services that we're using special education tuition this based on historical num we're looking at a 5 to 8% increase on those uh deck health insurance 6 to 8% increase that number hasn't been quite finalized yet that's kind of the the range for right now and for Debt Service we don't anticipate any additional
176borrowing unless the board has a capital project that I don't know about yet tempt at humor I can't anything I'm trying so hard like I can't hear anything she just took a big swipe at you of course she I'm just reading okay other budget factors that will you know will contribute it to the budget um any retirements and additional Staffing requirements so we may recognize some breakage in replacing some of our retiring staff but we also may have some staffing changes or additional Staffing which is right now being talked about um the final bosies numbers the final TRS and ERS numbers and the final health insurance increases will definitely have an impact if it falls within that 5 to 8% range or if it falls lower or higher that can impact the budget uh vehicle
177purchases right now I believe we're going to need two transportation vehicles um we may need one facilities vehicle one of the transportation Vehicles is going to be a bus a fuel based bus and what we're doing now because we have basically 10 years at the current law to replace all of our fuel buses we wanted to buy another bus this year so that we would have fuel buses that would last US 10 years out so as we gradually replace we wanted to make sure we had enough of our own current vehicles that would see us through the next 10 years that's a question I actually heard you um when when's the last year that we're allowed to stop or that we're not all27 okay so we have one more year still being able to hopefully
178buy okay unless that changes unless that changes yes cool um again the end of stimulus grants those grants were used to fund a some of the um social emotional programs like Avid and P2 so now those costs associated with those programs will now have to be in the general fund budget and the biggest piece is Governor hopel today gave her State of the State and released her budget numbers I took a quick look at the budget numbers it looks like we are not hurting we have not been cut So based on her budget which is not the final budget we will see a a bit of an increase in state aid not a huge increase for the but an increase a lot the big Hub and worry about Foundation Aid I think we probably avoided
179this year I think a lot of the work some of the superintendent groups did in in talking from the damaged that reducing Foundation Aid as dramatically as was thought so in today's I didn't I only read this the briefing of it it looks as if some of our biggest fears are not there so that's good the overall budget process is a line by line by function so there's a facilities there's instructional budgets Transportation budgets and also instructional budgets by building I will be meeting with all of the building administrators and with Marco and with Anthony to get um their ideas of what they need for the next year so that's going to be conversations going on amongst all the administrators and myself and Dr fuell and as we prioritize all of the wish lists we
180will have budget modifications along the process and come up with a draft budget which will be presented to the board with explanations of you know what went into those budget numbers Dr fenelli once we come up with what we believe is the best budget we'll present that as the superintendent's recommended budget to the board we will ask the board to adopt that budget and at that point you will be presented with um a three-part budget which will divide the budget into administrative cost program costs and capital costs the budget calendar is as we see here at the next meeting I may have some more details about additional initial assumptions may give some more clarity on Governor H's numbers on the 25th we'll have um an indication of what the key factors are for the budget
181and those are those big areas like Bose and salaries and um insurance benefits and retirement costs on the 11th board discussion was update probably present um a real budget number a first draft of a real budget number the 25th Dr fuell will present the recommended budget for the board on April 8th we'd be asking the board to adopt that budget May 6th is the legally required public hearing on the budget and May 20th we will have a budget vote and an election for one trustee and we also may have I'm thinking of using we have a bus Reserve for the bus purchases as opposed to putting that number in the budget that's concludes the first comments or questions from the board that last part you said the bus Reserve that's separate from the electric bus
182Reserve yes it is that was a reserve that was set up years ago before buses it's great historically we've needed to use that to purchase a bus but that was very good we actually used the budget to purchase the bus last year but usually it's through the anyone quick question on for you um you're mentioning about those programs that we're using coming out of the general fund now as opposed to some of the federal aid that we had coming in the co money and all that so things like Abid and all that have have we done an analysis of the efficacy of programs such as that and then are have those replaced others that we now don't have to purchase and things like that are we are we kind of scalping out some of the
183old stuff or I I would defer to my instructional experts yes uh we actually had a talk we're talking about some of our summer programming uh that we don't think it's as effective as it has been so yeah we're looking at um you know play and Absolution you know as they call it uh so yeah we do specific to Avid we actually we just had recent meetings and I saw Dan back there he'll probably jump up um you know the feedback we have from Avid has been been excellent so we definitely are um you know still pursuing uh you know running that with Fidelity yeah we've we've heard those presentations on on Avid and um I think everybody's been impressed about that I was I was really more concerned about some of the old stuff
184that we could you know kind of move on with some of the newer programs and um and then you know you're going to hear this from me until until it's ever done the IBM pilot yes that is I had a very preliminary conversation with the town supervisor and she had not really gotten into that process yet I will follow up with her during this whole budget process to see how far along and if they've started that process and to ask and suggest that we be a part of that process I appreciate that I think it's about 9% of our budget right now 5 million right four isn't it five no it's four four okay let's get it up well maybe okay thank you pal appreciate that anybody else okay another V presentation yes 6.02 is
185a discussion on the senior tax exemption U for the Public's purpose I think I could say uh we did get a a correspondence um and they had suggested that senior tax exemption our policy here is a little bit outdated so uh Val's been digging into that and that's the results of the digging this could lead to uh action by the board you know maybe not right this moment but it could um so uh just be aware of that going into this so uh this is not this is more than just informational this this could lead to uh decision um the reference for the senior tax exemption is part of the New York State Property law section 467 and basically that provides for a partial tax exemption for homeowners who are 65 and older that their
186home is their primary residence and they meet income requirements the New York State maximum income level to receive a partial exemption is $50,000 currently spacking kills policy for the senior exemption the maximum income level to receive receive any exemption is basically $37,500 um from of the criteria is they have to have owned and resided in their home for at least 12 consecutive months prior to applying for this exemption and it's an annual application that the homeowner homeowner would submit to the Town assessor's office this is back and Hill's current policy it's a graduated scale saying if you make $29,000 or less you're entitled to an exemption of 50% of your assessed value of your home and that scale goes on to if you make between 36,5 37,39 you are permitted a 5% exemption of your
187assess value for tax purposes how do we stack up with the rest of the county there are several counties who have a lower maximum and there are several counties who have a higher maximum and if you take a note at the last column the ones with the higher have recently adjusted that maximum limit so in the last 23 and 2024 you've got several districts who have now you know increased their maximum income for the 50% exemption just to get a little bit of an idea um the population of Spen kill School District according to the Census Data was 8,996 and approximately 22% of that population is 65 years years and older and I knew the board would want to know the tax [Music] impact my mind so at least for the current school year there
188were 51 Parcels in the district who received this exemption that the Exempted assessed value was 7% of total assessments of homeowners homeowner assessments and it was a tax impact of little over $124,000 and based on our tax levy of 33 million it's you know less than 1% so as Dr fui alluded to the board has several has a couple of opt options you can leave things the way they are with the maximum limit of 30 7 through 99 you can consider increasing those maximum income limits if you do that you may do it as a lump sum or an incremental increase over you know two or three years if you decide to increase the M the income limit it would require a public hearing and in order for to take effect for this upcoming tax
189year the board would have to agree to it and pass a resolution before March first so we go back to a couple of slides um for districts like High Park and Rybeck most of them were at the 29 th000 where we were and in one and they just did a lump sum of $5,000 increase for Whoppers they are doing an incremental increase because ultimately they want to get to the the state maximum of $50,000 so they did five year they did $5,000 in increments over the a couple of years so um we wouldn't compare ourselves to W Jersey and Arlington because they're a bigger District corre big area yes so I mean um line back is kind of comparable Red Hook kind of is of all the people who have all the districts who have
190you know modified this income limit over the past couple of years but again as you can see on the chart I mean Dober hasn't looked at there since 2003 or changed it since what would you like I would like some guidance from the board um if they want to consider an increase and if they want to consider an increase how much of an increase so that I can present what that would look like in that graduated table oh yeah at the next meeting and then subsequent to that if that was something the board wanted to move forward with then at the last meeting in February we could have uh a public hearing and the board could vote on a resolution which I could get to the the town so it it could take effect for
191this upcoming attention so if we would approve it to be 42,000 how many seniors would qualify that is a number that I've asked the assessor it changes every year because the seniors have to apply every year based on their income so income will change every year um assessments change every year so that also impact the actual taxes that would be Exempted I can say for the last couple of years the number of exemptions has been on the chart it was 51 for the 2324 school year there were 58 seniors who received the exemption so it's not a huge number but it seems to be somewhere in that 50 to 60 range at least over the last few years for clarification the the $124,000 that's basically um that's the taxes that was on the exemptive assessment
192right and that's spread amongst the other 8,950 owners right tax so it's about $13 to each homeowner now in addition so if we approve um maximum income we have to um um approve a m a minimum uh well yes what happens is if I go back to this that bottom number yeah there those intervals between those dollar amounts would are set by law so you would say for example you would you would really approve the what you want the maximum number to be and what the minimum number to be okay so you would up that that first number so up to 25 up to 29,000 this one they go the same so if you looks like everyone else up 5000 5000 interval would go up 5,000 okay okay and if you go back to the
193other one it looks like a lot of people were at 29 not a lot but look at High Park linebeck and High Park it looks like they did the $5,000 and they did it in last year the year before yeah and they did it in one year they just up every interval by $5,000 for me I think it's a no-brainer I mean we have a very difficult challenge for seniors to stay in this area and we want to try to keep family unit together and it's been very difficult and since 2006 the last time we've looked at this policy we've had a housing crisis we've had a pandemic we've had massive inflation I mean I to me the cost of a living has gone up tremendously I'm sure that uh some of those uh incomes
194for you know the seniors that are on set incomes have have gone up and are now not eligible but I really you know I think that the impact to the rest of the well the younger versions of us here I I don't think it's going to be that big but it could be something that's helpful to to some seniors in the area so I agree I'd like I'd like to see us you know get competitive with the you know like the the the Ryback type of version there as well my my two cents yeah his two cents my I agree I mean I agree I certainly agree U I'm not sure you have you wouldn't probably be able to get data about how many of the eligible um seniors actually apply for it the assessor
195have that it's pretty the assessor really just knows who applied appli I mean I guess it would take a dive into the IRS records to find out you so uh there's no way predicting you know there might be more percentage wise more that might apply for it going forward I mean you're saying the number Hold Steady between 50 and 60 at least the past couple of past two or three years I've been able to look and see exactly how many receive the exemption and it's been somewhere between that 56 yeah okay so are you asking us if we want to do it incrementally or all at once or something else I mean do you want to do increase and if you want to do it incrementally like I said most of the districts when they
196did the 5,000 they did it all at once you have enough data to know that if we did it all at once what the hit would be in the first year I would not because it they would have to apply based on their income right you know it all depends on it all dep I mean this time next year I could tell you what that number yeah ask next year but do you you don't feel it's it'll be your guess is that it's not going to get too far outside of that 50 to 60 range of people or just don't know well I would think it's going to be a little bit outside of that ring because you're going to now have more people who qualify but I can't with any certainty to tell you
197what that increase is going to look like what would it be incrementally the board could say that they wanted to increment it 2,000 2,000 1,000 you know over a couple of years 2500 2500 but I you I don't know how much of that would or how much of an impact that would have on our seniors right with just the $2,000 increase which is sorry is it possible to see with some of these other districts that went just did it 23 and 24 um that went up that 5,000 or whatever the number is to see what they were from 2022 to this year how much of a jump that was I could um it would probably only make sense for us to look at maybe like a high park or in Arlington because we're only dealing
198with the town of kipy so most of those other districts have multiple towns so their impact would be a lot larger we're fortunate that we have one town right I think I've created enough work for you I don't ask do anything else we could call High Park I mean I think we could yeah our AR is a different animal probably uh yeah I mean again it depends on how if you give us a ballpark we could have something prepared for next week and then for next board meeting and then try to talk to high par and see if they know how many increased that was what the other districts did right yeah yeah I would say at least 5,000 yeah 5,000 not more I mean I I could see Red Hook being you know 36
199you know we're we're slightly larger District than Red Hook correct it's pretty close we can we have a five seven I you know I'd see up to seven wouldn't wouldn't trouble me Joan you have a I'd be at five five Jeff you have a I mean I kind of agree Richard I wouldn't care if it was seven or five to be honest um I don't think it's that big of an impact but it may be a bigger impact to the seniors that get seven instead of yeah that's that's a good point yeah hurt us less than it will help them perhaps all seems like a lot of that you said a lot of the other districts looks like they did five any reasoning behind why they did five just nice round number I think it
200was just a round number and a lot of them didn't want to go all the way to the 50 like Arlington did yeah and again this is something that we can move the five now and a you know as a board could decide in a couple of years that you want to do another increase right good five by I will present what the graduated scale looks like at the next meeting and the board is agreeable then we can move on to public hearing thank you thank you are you just get the are you going to try for hyart or no I don't want to have a false I'll call Lon ask okay see it there there's some Trends there I mean they must have all been around the same at some point so I'm assuming
201like the on mber PING they all 29 and the 374 so yeah I mean a lot of that happened because New York State raised the maximum income level to the 50,000 so they started making adjustments upward there yeah I'm definitely comfortable with that okay that brings us to 603 a secondary Administration update Ken you're still awake all right do you have a clicker or are you going to click for these I'll click for you either or but we'll I probably could I can click through if you want okay all right thanks for having me here um it's been a while since I've been able to do a presentation so happy to be here um I'm I'm going to feature two things that we've been doing at the high school it's a busy it's there's a
202going on at the high school we in the middle of Regents exams um but these were two events that you're going to see a little bit of my bias here although I didn't do theater uh until I was a teacher I was involved with it um I've just learned through years uh the impact that it has uh really just in the Arts so just um in general I have always said that as Educators our number one charge is to make sure that students grow into adults that live fulfilling lives and we do that in lots of different ways um I always said that I did it through my content which was English um and you know that kind of encompasses the Arts so again I'm a little biased but Music Theater writing um singing all
203of that is uh what makes us who we are and I think maybe for me and for everybody here at some point we probably all wanted to be a rock star on stage I know I did uh that didn't really pan out but what band uh I try I tried a lot of different things but it just didn't work out I couldn't sing but um we all kind of have that aspiration I think and uh it's really important for kids to be able to express themselves and there's such a diverse group of students that uh that have talents that often times we don't even see so it's really important for me to uh in my career to highlight this as much as I can um I left the classroom eight years ago I didn't know
204anything about ni tea until I was an administrator and I didn't start chaperoning it until I was an administrator now I've become a sponsor and I've gotten more involved with the um with the organization in general but it's New York State Theater Education Association um and every year they put on a conference we've been able to to go a couple times since I've been at Spackenkill there's been some time well Co prevented us and then also last year the snowstorm prevented us so this year we were able to go we sent 10 students uh so I'm just going to kind of go over some things that the students and I experiened Mr Romani went as a chaperone um it's an opportunity for educators and students to network together so there's roughly 900 students that attend
205the conference and with that there's education chaperoning and it is a working weekend for us too it's very busy um but it's especially as you get to learn the faces it's an opportunity for me and the other people there to catch up and to talk about what's going on to share experiences when it comes to anything that goes uh with the Arts it's not just theater uh obviously that's the focus point but uh theater and Compasses all of all the the Arts in it so um that's why it's theater education uh the courses there it is really rigorous this is not just like um a convention for students to uh see theater this is a very rigorous uh there's a lot of rigorous course offerings that the students are mainly there to attend so um
206they're taught by Educators in schools uh they're taught by Professionals in the industry um there's also a college fair on the Saturday that we're there um and there's a red ribon a red ribbon banquet on Saturday night that is through Broadways care so we all uh we all get together and raise money uh for fighting AIDS uh which is what broad carees Equity is all about so um what you see on the screen there is just our arrival there on Friday the 10 students that we brought Mr Rani myself and then next to that picture I thought it would be it was cool to feature him it's Andrew bar Feldman he's an actor uh known for for Dean Hansen High School Musical um Saturday Night Live there's a movie on Netflix with Jennifer Lawrence called
207no heart feelings if you saw that that's a that was in the movie theaters last year um I want to highlight it because not because of who he is they did lose their minds it was a surprise nobody knew that he was there um but his message was through theater I thought it was really important I think it's important for anybody that's watching this to to hear it that you're not always going to get the part that you want but if you love what you do you really need to put in 100% to the part that you get often times because that will you know launch you into another part of life that you may not see and he just kind of went into his whole experience in theater and what what brought him to
208where he's at now um but a lot of the times where kids are are auditioning they don't get what they they they believe they should have and you can act two different ways with with that and you can be negative about that or positive and his whole message was to make sure that you are positive um and that you if you love it that you continue doing things and being a part of it um so I just thought that that was something really important to uh mention the cours work that I just want to I'm highlighting what our students attended uh because again this is this is an educational conference um it's exhausting so I'll do this real quick hands on sound for theater practical guide to lighting handson moving Lights Theater design and Tech
209for a college portfolio art of the que which is intro to Q lab it's programming uh one short day song and dance harmonizing for stage a new approach period dance for actors chorus numbers you'll never You'll Never sing on stage playing Shakespeare LED lighting course Tech talk musical theater performance technique tap for beginners musical theater dance for actors and singers improv Master Class ballet for beginners heels Jazz Chorus Line choreography Advanced tab uh tap sorry advanced swing dance choreography intensive Rhythm tap Westside Story choreography basic swing dance choreography intensive and costume design of yourself so there's fashion there's singing There's dancing there's writing there's College portfolio building um there's there's so much there it's I can't express how rigorous it is it is an exhausting weekend for the students and for the the staff there
210but it's a blast the most important thing I found and what Drew me to this uh is that I've never seen a situation where there's a thousand kids that are in a resort essentially they're supervised but unsupervised there there's a lot of um responsibility on them to be where they're supposed to be and nothing happens like nothing but positivity kids being their full selves and enjoying their time and meeting other people and networking um there there's just it's all positive and it's a full weekend of that and it's just an amazing thing to see so on the left one of our students uh quazy was chosen to do the light and sound for the Showcase Saturday night so that's another piece to it kids that go there through their skills in classes get selected uh
211to be part of the performances that are um practiced and auditioned through the weekend and they're performances that are written by students that are there on the conference and they're uh produced and directed by students and put on by students so czyy was a student uh that ran the lighting for the entire showcase Saturday night uh which is which is pretty awesome so those are just some more images um this was at the Red Ribbon banquet uh the Saturday night there again we're all wearing red ribbons and that's a a age relief Foundation uh where everybody donates for that and we raise money through the whole weekend for that there's a lot going on there um so that that's that was nice te last weekend um I'm going to kind of jump into our mural
212that we've talked to uh Community connections our organization uh organization our our Comm in the building uh compiled of students and staff in the high school have worked for a year and a half to creating mural um that really came out of just discussions about we there's a lot of murals in the building that we it's sad but we don't have a lot of connection to um a lot most of us don't know where they came from sometimes we hear history about it but the students aren't connected to it we felt like it was time to create something different and something new um so it began with a vision of uh doing something in the hall where some of the the NASA imagery is and then it kind of uh it changed it shifted into
213we wanted to make it more of a focal point of the school and in our minds it was a little bit about like we think about Nashville and those that those wings that everybody sees taking uh people take pictures in front of in those murals um so we wanted to make something that was in a spot in the school that that was a focal point for kids to be drawn to for staff to be drawn to and for events uh for to be in the background of events um we started with a survey to students about what they thought that mural should look like and that was uh that was sent to the entire building that was about a year a year and a half ago um and we compiled all that data as a
214committee uh and we invited those students to attend the committee um throughout and that was a pretty fluid experience some students came one day and a different group of students came another day um but what we what we got out of that was it uh uniqueness individualism family lifting each other up representation were all important for for what we wanted to do for this mural um another important piece was the students talked about the idea of breaking through a ceiling because we still had work to do and we weren't finished but we were making progress um so ENT we developed an image with student input throughout the school as well as staff members in the community connections committee um and in order to actually create the mural we uh we recruited our national art Society
215our national junior art Society because somebody had to actually make it and we don't have the skills to do that so um I'll reveal it at the end but I would implore everybody to go see it in person if you haven't seen the finished product because the picture don't do it justice but we decided to put it in the cafeteria so it's in between the two doors um and we took that entire wall section uh I can't express like the it's it was a year and a half making and down to the colors down to each uh piece of the mural was really well thought out um and every piece of it has some aspect of meaning which I can go into in a second but these are just some I want to do justice
216and recognize who was responsible for uh creating the image but again the picture that we actually created on Photoshop was done with lots of hands lots of students that didn't have the artistic ability to put it on the wall um but we had a collective group of people um so these are just I'll just kind of scroll through so each uh flower represents something and they were all hand drawn and hand painted by one individual student so uh you'll see at the end but each student was responsible for one flower um the the the colors were all picked by other students who had involvement outside of this and I'll go through some of the artists some of them have graduated uh last year to have a the Corin Jazelle shakon Gabriella Murphy Isabella salmon Tamar
217Heyman festler and Trisha peni Julia deor renes and that is the finished product so beautiful yeah um so what I'll read if you notice on the top right right above the door not above it right to the left of the door there's a plaque uh that plaque says each flower and butterfly in this bouquet is unique fragile and beautiful in its own way just like every one of us the stems of the flowers grow from the same place symbolizing our shared experiences we've had at spacking Hill remember our humble beginnings and always nurture their beauty within each other uh the butter fly on the right flying out of the picture depicts us moving forward and continuing our journey and that is uh the finished product we are going to there's more to this plan but
218for that particular spot um that that is the product and the idea is and we've had it kids will stand in front of it kind of pose in front of it hold it you know and it's been kind of a focal point for although you know we've had a lot of conversations with anxious generation and social social media it is a focal point for some pictures and things like that it brings kids together so that's that's what we wanted that was what the vision was to to have people United in front of it and bring people together um each color in the flower is different each flower is different uh from different parts of the world I mean there's a lot that we could go into about it um but for the sake of time
219I just wanted to reveal it and express to everybody please go see it in person uh because the detail is just not you can't see on this image so thank you uh does anyone have any questions about Nic te or regent exams or um the mural I like the plaque on the mural so future Generations can understand what it is say I kind of lost context on some of the other ones so it's a nice to have up there yeah it was important for us to make sure we showcase parts of it I mean like said is I wish we we tried to capture the process but I don't think we captured all the conversations and the dialogue we had about why uh why each flower was picked each butterfly um and I you know
220we could have done better in that sense of being extra critical of myself but yeah it was important to us to showcase the meaning behind it and not just have it there yeah beautifully worded awesome Yellow Submarine still in the cafeteria it is it is and we have plans to uh expand on that not to change it we've had conversations about not painting over murals because now we've experienced it and you know 30 years from now if somebody painted over it there are people that there's a lot of people that had involvement with this and we know that that's the case for these other murals so we're trying to figure out ways to bring life into them and have more students currently in it involved with that so that's part of this next process there
221thank you thank you everybody thank you uh good evening everybody uh as always it's a glad to be here and uh thank you uh for having us um I thought tonight I would discuss the contents of a of a letter I recently sent to Guardians regarding um the dignity act and and Title Nine uh we go over these things with students um throughout the year but um I had never shared um what we go over specifically with guardians and I thought it would be important to because I think a lot of times um Guardians might not be aware of kind of some of the some of the things that we go over and to just kind of give them the actual slides that we use uh I thought that would be helpful because sometimes when
222we have conversations with guardians um we can kind of tell that you know um they aren't always aware of the extent of what their students are um exposing through mostly through their cell phones and through social media so I thought it would be I thought it would be good to to share that um so the so the letter talked about kind of what we go over when we talk about the dignity act and daa and what we go over when we talk about tile 9 and sexual harassment and um so I shared that information with them in the slides I also shared you know the signs that actually they're they're here in in the library and they're all around which are related to the dignity act which you all the various things we don't joke
223about you know that one we don't look about gender you know um can't read that one over there but um the um it it's it's important for them to to to to understand um kind of what the world that they that their that their children are are living in um in terms of um uh social media and cell phone because a lot of the information that most of the most of the time when we run into issues on the Middle School level regarding any of these it usually is a lot of it has connections to uh social media and to cell phones so um in my letter I also made reference to that um that you know we have our cell phone po we have a cell phone policy here but obviously um cell phones
224are not something that students don't have access to outside of school most of them have them here as well they um keep them away but you know they're they have them physically on them uh and I also made reference to the book The anxious generation which you know if uh I don't know if everybody's uh read it or have been exposed to it but it you know it's a it's a pretty um it's got a lot of data in there that is uh creates a convincing argument about um how uh harmful these devices are and how harmful social media is to especially middle-aged school students um as a principal here for the last 10 years I can attest to that uh I've uh i' I have watched it continue to grow I have watched it
225continue to get younger so if Mr dususu is here he could probably tell you what I was telling you eight years ago uh I don't know if eight years from now Mr Lynch will be telling you about it because I don't know how it seems to get younger and younger and the younger it is uh the more harmful it is to students um and um so the the the the um anxious generation talks you know he sell he uh the author uh as well as now our governor is suggesting that schools be banned I mean schools be I say not schools be banned from cell phones s it is almost 10 o'cl but cell phones be banned from schools and um I'm a little biased as the principal of the middle school but uh if
226that ban happened I would support it uh he also um suggests that uh students not be exposed um to to have a cell phone at all until age 14 and to not be exposed to social media till age 16 and um again I would support those measures uh and also um you know kind of the four the fourth major thing he talks about is having more time for fle free play having more kind of you know unstructured um independent time where students can kind of you know learn responsibility and and um you know we have that at Todd we have you know the launch time and the recess time is where we get to see that and you see it and just so everybody isn't worried you know uh kids are still kids you know
227nothing's changed it's not like you know it's not like they're taken over by AI even though uh they they are very connected to a they they're very connected to AI because the cell phone is just just a little AI machine that gives you anything you want do anything you want that being said you're you're children are fine uh and they are they socialize many of them socialize you know great but there are issues that come up and it's not it's not a thing of oh it's just a certain type of student or anything like that it's it's just it's it's it's everywhere so even as students who are you know well adjusted and you know and they've got everything they need at home um the exposure to these social media sites and and then all
228kinds of other stuff uh you know when you when you're that young and you have access to the entire world in your pocket it's a lot so um so that's why I wanted to send the letter out to kind of give that information to parents uh and the Guardians um and to let them know that you know we continue to work with with uh with the kids on on you know basically on a daily basis because the positivity project basically is everything that we do you know this week we're doing social intelligence you know I mean so everything about POS project is always you know can always be related to these kinds of things but the cell phone is a major part of child's life I it's a major part of child's life and um
229and you know so it's important to try to address those things as best we can um because it while it's a I I think it's a great device in many many ways uh it's um it's got It's got a side that uh isn't so great and for younger people uh it's um you know it it creates a lot of harm and uh and we see that from time to time here so um sounds very much of a downer if the following but it was important and I thought it was it was important to put out there and it was important to share with you uh and so you're aware of it um and that's something that I'm going to be doing annually and and try to do it a couple of times a year because
230I think it's really important my letter said look at the slides have conversations with your children's with your children about the slides uh you know it's really you know and and maybe over time I I'll give them I'll send some more things from time to time about maybe even some conversations to have because I I remember being a parent of a of a middle school of middle school students and you know Guardians are always many years behind their kids when it comes to this stuff they have no idea kids are they're flying they're flying and uh so trying to give trying to say Hey you my want and then when you know when they get the call from me from time to time and they're like why are you looking they're like what and I'm
231like yeah you need to be keeping an eye on this stuff so um uh like I said I I thought it was important to put out there to the parents Guardians I thought it was important to to bring it to the board uh to let to let them know that I that I went over this stuff with them and uh and U you know and I hope that uh over time we as a you know I think we as a middle school are doing a really good job I think we work really hard I think we give out a lot of information I don't know what every other Middle School in New York State or the county does but I I feel pretty confident that we are trying to be proactive trying to you know
232um address issues and um you know and hopefully over time Society you know the world outside Todd Middle School will uh get on the same page and take a look at at what's happening and how it's affecting young people so thank you thank you thank you very timely work with the anest generation like we've been doing you H addressed today talk more about P School Poli place next year regarding phones not being used during the school day thank you thank you very much thank you thanks part of a different conversation might be how much screen time we have during the school day on Chromebooks and everything else too I'd like to I'd like to learn a little bit more about that because I mean we we've delved into the anxious generation over the retreat and
233everything and um you know I I think we learned a lot from it I certainly don't understand a lot of the things my kids do and it has to do with phone a lot of it I could say so age okay uh item 7.01 is board correspondence I believe we had one piece of Correspondence that we've addressed on a few different occasions uh 7.02 is comments from the public on non-agenda items do we have public comment on non-agenda items I'll just mentioned just for the the sake of it uh generally the rule is about 3 minutes and then what we would do is uh you know we may or may not respond to you directly we may ask somebody to respond to at a later time and then we'll just disclose that information later but
234just very good um good evening everyone sorry for the late time but I wanted to take a minute I am Melissa Thompson I'm here tonight representing the support staff of Spackenkill School District um our group makes up two contracts right our teaching assistants clerical staff and monitors on one our custodial workers bus drivers um maintenance workers grounds Keepers and very soon um Our IT staff on the other contract um very soon you as Board of Education will be making decisions regarding our futures and I just want to give I thought it was important that you see us right there's a number of members of our support staff here tonight and you know I myself at one time for 9 years was a board member in the district where I live so I realize the commitment
235that you all make and one of the concerns I had as a board member was many times we were forced to make decisions but we didn't know who the players were we didn't know who or the jobs that they did right but we were required to make those decisions so I want to tell you about me I am the secretary the counseling office at the high school right we have three guidance counselors a social worker and a school psychologist and I provide support to each of them um if you ask your children do you know Mrs Thompson she will he or she will say she's that lady that stands in front of her office and tells all of us good morning in the morning sometimes I embarrass them because if I say good morning and
236they don't have the airpods right if the airpods are in you're not going to get a good morning but if they don't and they don't reply to me the next day I use their name because very often in the guidance office I see their pictures I know who they are so it's important right that I have that interaction with them and I've had students graduate that come back to say Mrs Thompson that good morning was what I needed that got me through my day or it got things better for my week so that's me in a nutshell I do want to very quickly Mr Kohler made a very precise comment just a few minutes ago about the cost of living so I sit with this little post it on my desk every day the last
237time our group came before you um was in 2021 and the unit then accepted on the contract that I am a part of 1.25% of an in increase okay I'm on step so was a little fair just slightly better but over four years I average about 61 cents an hour difference from four years ago but the cost of living in 2021 was 5.9 then we get to where Mr koher is talking about 2022 was 8.7 2023 was 8.7 2024 came down a little bit 3.2 and we're looking at 2.5 for 2025 right so the members of the support staff have looked at an increase of 1.25 over these years where the costs have gone this way right so we will be looking to hopefully repair some of the damage that we've seen um many of
238our members live in District I obviously do not um but many many do majority do and they're very proud to work here at sping hille they love their community and I have to say I love this community you talking about Athletics I think we've all seen me at baseball up in bingamon or football out in Sullivan West or you know the basketball team is a little different story because my nephew plays but I support these kids as does every member of the support staff and when our contracts come before you I ask that you support us thank you thank you thank you anyone else wish to speak 7.03 is comments from the board Joanne you either want to go home or you're cold both any no okay Richard no Sasha um I just want to
239let her know that we see you and we're working on it thank you yeah might be as quick as I can but I want to thank uh everybody um including the people that waited this long um and thank you for coming and thank you for saying what you did uh but thank you to my board members and to the administration um I I really like the uh the dialogue that we had um I I think that's uh the democracy at its best right there I'm in full support of how um you know our votes went tonight um I appreciate it and um I I wish that we did stuff like this more often not quite as long as it went tonight uh but I really appreciate that everybody said what they wanted to on it
240and a decision was made and um I support it wholly thank you guys thank you I missed the support staff Lun in this year um but often we go to support staff lunch and uh I've always said when I've had an opportunity there that the support staff is just this amazing backbone that helps this District function so we do greatly appreciate everything you do and we'll all take that into consideration I believe thank you thank you 704 comments from the superintendent kind climatic right uh just out Echo what Jeff said uh tonight was was different for us um but educational and um I appreciate the effort of everyone you know uh definely the bo but also everyone kind of behind the scenes who kind of together all that information uh um just wanted as much
241information out there as possible I think we got it um um just appreciate the dialogue already said this I was going to mention that that Governor hok did did have address today um and the cell phone piece that came up so I think I I definitely appreciate the principal's work um and Dan's work you know tying in uh you know the book we're working on and I know Ken's doing the same things he had a couple book talks the Generation Um and hidden focus soulen focus focus uh so we've done the work so now once we unpack what the governor says as we continue on in the year I think we'll be set for next year so I want to thank everyone for that and Ken you were the best dressed painter I don't know
242if I don't know that picture uh you're dressed as if you are here tonight uh oh yeah being that you brought it up I just want to mention the cover on the Spackle was closed and there was still a stickle sticker on the Spackle knife so you were really spackling there I am judgmental of what I did even to this day I'll walk it could have been a little smoother there you could kind of see my little spackling job but I did not go uh not get trained in that so I tried my best oh it was great thank you thank you okay do I have a motion to adjourn the meeting motion second second all in favor all right pass is 5 Z we'll see you February 11th I believe