CorpusRecord 135153

Board of Education Meeting: January 7th, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Spackenkill Schools
Date
2025-01-08
Location
Dutchess County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
15,471 words · about 86 min
Collected
2026-06-18

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001good evening and welcome to the January 7th 2025 meeting of the spaen kill Union Preschool District Board of Education I'd ask you to rise and join me inting Pledge of Allegiance Pledge Al United States America stand indivisible and justice for all okay first item here is 2.01 comments from the public on consent agenda items only we have comments from the public on consent agenda items okay hearing on a board discussion consent agenda items okay I'll entertain a motion to accept consent agenda as WR have a second all in favor I I passes by Z 4.01 is a motion to open the public hearing on repair Reserve expenditures I have a motion to open the public hearing on repair expenditures second all in favor you have any Community input on repair Reserve get B it's been

002a little bit of a while so let me just uh if you don't mind um there are three public sessions tonight the first we already gone through with the consent agenda the second is on the repair reserve the third is on uh non-agenda items later in the meeting um we generally limit speakers to 3 minutes um we don't expect this to be a back and forth necessarily uh we'll be taking any your input um we may or may not respond may or may not have any Administration respond or if we don't have an answer response we may be able to uh get that information to you at a later date so that being said if you'd approach the Mike and uh state your name and address and you have about up good evening my name

003is Christopher M Kraken I live at 19 Schoolhouse Lane in pipy uh thank you to the board for the opportunity to speak tonight um my family and I have lived in the district for about 18 years now and we currently have children attending Todd Middle School and Hagen Elementary uh to us youth sports have always been a way to bring the community together and especially important now in a time that so many choose to be indoors over choosing to participate in outdoor activities that encourage physical fitness in particular School athletics have been a way to encourage Community participation which can be seen by the attendance at our District's football games the overall quality of facilities for these Sports plays an important part in encouraging player participation spectator attendance as well as the overall presentation of

004the district to those visiting for all these Reasons I'm here to express my support for Spen kill's Board of Education to consider making use of the monies from the reserve repair fund to invest in a new Turf INF field for the baseball and softball field at tot Middle School the baseball field has not received the typical level of Maintenance attention for many years making a project of this nature a potential major Improvement for the district's facilities although turf fields typically have a higher initial insulation cost than a grass field they're known to offer many benefits and cost Savings in the long term the maintenance costs are far lower on an annual basis leading to long-term Savings in comparison with upkeep and maintenance of a dirt and grass and field planing surface on a similar field

005turf fields also don't require the application of chemicals or the regular water usage associated with grass fields and eliminate the concern related to drought very similar to what we experienced this past year additionally they far better draining allowing games to remain on as scheduled in comparison with grass and dir Fields finally tur Fields have a long lasting professional exper appearance as can be seen by the recently installed field at the Hudson Valley Renegades facility as well as our own specken kill football field I asked the board to consider all the positive long-term attributes that a Turf infield could offer to our District's baseball and softball teams while you work towards a decision as to what to do with the reserve funding again I thank you for the time to speak thank you I'm ask this

006to the board would it be appropriate or do we have a presentation that folks can what is being proposed because I think that might be helpful and then we can resume the the public comment after that so that Mak sense to everybody yeah okay okay so we had previously identified um areas that needed some uh repair throughout the district um some of those areas were identified as baseball and softball fields tennis courts some fencing at multiple buildings um exterior stairs at Todd uh Outdoor Classroom area uh at Todd as well as um railings at the high school Courtyard so some of the things we were to do for the baseball softball fields was to remove some overgrown vegetation uh Edge infield remove some old clay um rebuild pitching Mount and install packing clay uh top

007dress grade and SE the infield Turf uh build an upgrade uh and relocate the bullpen um and possible consideration of a Turf uh in the batting cages yep just to be clear that that's for two Fields that's for the and Sofi singular word there you two Fields yes sorry baseb and soft ball fields two Fields um so at the tennis courts we would look to pressure wash remove the dirt um level and fill the low spots uh fix upheaving Around the Net posts refinish the face colors and um have some new court striping pained um there's several areas throughout the district that uh some fencing needs to be replaced and or repaired um so here at Todd we would remove a fallen damaged wooden fence and replace it with a new PVC at Nassau we

008would remove damaged post rails uh and fencing replace with new um we would do this a similar scenario over at Hagen um and add some barrier arms uh to help with some traffic control um some important concrete work here at Todd um we would uh demolish um two sets of concrete stairs and the railings and pour new concrete stairs and install new railings um they you know this is really important for safety um in those locations um we'd also look to install a concrete pad for a new dumpster location um uh here at Todd there is a structure that we're looking to repair to um to use as an outdoor classroom um we built to repair both structurally and aesthetically um and we would look sand Glass and paint that entire structure um also again

009some cosmetic upgrades uh so at the high school there is beautiful Courtyard uh recently installed there um however we do need some safety railings along the rock wall and stairway there so it can be utilized um so we would look to do that uh through the repair Reserve as well so some of the district considerations that these are significant repairs repairs that needed uh that are needed in multiple areas got quotes from multiple vendors with New York State contracts all the repairs uh the overall cost was based on lowest quotes from responsible vendors and timing scheduling of the work would be weather dependent so these were the um initial estimated costs for um those repairs uh being funded by the repair Reserve um as you can see there baseball and S footb field was uh

010about 94,000 the tennis courts were 66 the fencing were 14 concrete uh 56 The Outdoor Classroom was 44 and the railings in the courtyard at the high school were 22 for a total just under 300,000 so this repair Reserve was established in 2022 um the maximum uh that we could use in permitted to be used is 750,000 um it's been funded over the years uh from available unappropriated fund balance at the end of the year um it's used for non- reoccurring repairs uh to District improvements uh or equipment um so these are repairs that just um we just kind of couldn't quite handle on the uh with the general fund um so we'd like to use this reserve for um for some of these larger costs so in order to use the repair uh Reserve

011we need to uh present the proposed repairs to the board hold a public hearing on those proposed repairs uh Board of Education vote to authorize the expenditure from the repair reserve and uh the work would be scheduled uh as whether permit starting spring 2025 so just a quick review on thank you I appreciate that you're welcome helps clear up what is before the board this evening for The public's information on what proposal is with that I would ask if there's anybody else in the audience should we clarify before that um no Val if you want to clarify that I believe people will probably talk about the benefit of a tur field which is which is a good idea um we don't disagree with the benefits of turf field however what I think the public needs

012to know is that this particular fund that we are particularly looking to authorize a turfield could not be part of that because it wouldn't be a repair it would be um a change of the field so the question tonight is whether or not we should utilize this fund to have the dirt repairs the question of turfing is a good question to have but that's something that's not voted on tonight on this particular repair Reserve fund so I just want everyone to be clear that really what tonight's hearing is about is whether or not to authorize uh some the fixing up of both the softball and baseball field uh so two Fields um turf not be considered in this particular thing so if the board or the public would like to explore the Avenue of turf

013for the future that is something we can do but that is something that's separate from what is being asked tonight so I still think it's important to hear the public and their uh values of turf versus non- Turf but that is not something that would be resolved tonight tonight we're just trying to figure out whether not we should uh put you know fix up the fields for for this year for the next couple years the idea of turf is probably something that would take a little bit more time uh probably a few years that would have to um figure out how to how to utilize the best way to do that so I just for clarity sake I wanted to put that out there and see if there's any questions from the board on that

014um or if Val can uh say it more more eloquently than me uh before we proceed right and part of the differentiation between what can be used in for the repair Reserve is s's definition of what is a repair and a repair according Tod is to return something to its original usable form whereas if we what we propose is to put top soil and keep the dirt F and make it more usable immediately where a field is considered an improvement and under SC law that's a capital Improvement which can't be used by this particular fund if we were to do a tur field at some point it would be a capital Improvement it would be a slightly different process we would ask we would make our same presentations to the board but in order to

015extend those funds it would have to be put to a full public vote so that would be something that would be a separate proposition probably during a main Vote or really wanted to have a separate Community vote for that so that's the major difference between using a repair Reserve strictly for putting something back in its usable form and making an upgrade using the capital reserve so I have a couple questions on that um the S what we received was the repair funds is used to pay for the cost repairs to Capital Improvement or equipment which repairs are a type of not recurring annually or at a short interval so this would be a capital Improvement and a repair to a field that has not had any significant improve improvements in 25 years the way that

016that's read it's a repair to a capital Improvement so for example it would be a repair to the turf field which was a capital Improvement for the district so it's not implementing the I guess my next question would be why were we allowed to consider it at the last meeting and were offered a estimate on what it would be on whether or not we want to consider it at the last meeting and now we're being told that we should not even have been allowed to do that the reason that Turf even came up was because the board asked for the cost of a turf field and that's what we did you presented what F would cost and then we were given the option on whether or not we wanted to move forward with turf or

017if you wanted to stay with and the board did decide to move forward with turf at that point the explanation would have been made that that portion of that project would have to be funded through a capital reserve not the repair Reserve so that would required the public vote so this is an existing field it's a uh existing facility um that needs Improvement um and we are not able to use our repair funds for improvement correct even though it says that we were to use them for Capital Improvements it's referring to Capital Improvement as a now not improvements to Capital that's the I is that where is that coming from is an interpretation of the administration or is that something that we're getting directly from the SE that is how it's written the best it's

018repairs to Capital Improvement right and this is an improvement to the cap to one of our Capital facilities it's part of the capital we check into it it's just we can't use this fund for that no other way to say than that we can there's other vehicles that we could explore to use um you know and we're sorry the board uh misunderstood that I I I do think we tried to say at last boort meeting that we can't use this fun for that um it but it's okay I mean there's a lot going on um but that's just the reality where you that doesn't mean we can't pursue chur that means there's just other avenues we have to do to do that um which will probably be a a longer process but I mean if

019this is the highest priority and this is what the board is directing us to do we would have to look into how to Turf the fields a different way um when you look at the estimated cost of turfing it would be very difficult to utilize the budget or even some of our funds because it would exhaust them um but again if that is what the board is looking to do is to exhaust the funds for tur Fields that's something we can look into we're not against that I mean I think the the benefits of there's a lot of benefits to Fields I had some experience with it um I think it's definitely something we should do a full report on I think Mr lanon should be involved um you know this is really a question

020of whether we should do some repairs to the field uh when Anthony came aboard and was hired we had asked him what can we do to the fields you know we want them to get them in better shape um and you got a plan um do you want to talk a little bit about the the dirt plan with that with this with this play from the minor Lees and all that stuff that you had that might that might also help people understand what we're not just getting a dump truck of dirt and driving away sure sure I mean this would this would involve of course a a contractor that that does this um this is their specialty or one of their Specialties lantech um and there are others as well um but uh if there's

021F to come in and and and you know grade and reced infields and um we spoke about a a proprietary blend uh that uh for clay that is used in a lot of minor league major league fields that we have access to that we uh will use to put down that in itself will help with the drainage Alone um everything will be re- edged remeasured re-calibrated um so it's more than just using uh what m what equipment we have available to kind of help uh get the fields ready for um for the season rather a um a a larger um repair to the fields that can then be U maintained moving forward um so that it stays in this kind of more pristine uh feel um who did you speak you said you spoke with

022somebody at s and said that this is not something that we can do no I just there's definitions on the s website of what a repair Reserve can be used for and that's where I would just like to see those um possible please um you know I think we quoted it in a response you might have seen they but the response doesn't give a definition of it it just says that it needs to be a capital Improvement a repair to a capital Improvement so that's sounds like it's being interpreted you said you spoke with somebody and being told you can't do it is it that we talked with somebody I want to make sure I hope I didn't say I spoke with someone s because I have not and if I made that we spoke

023if I did say that I I apologize we did not speak with someone from s we just looking at it from yeah thank you there's a definition of res of what a repair is and what an improvement is in our interpretation is based on that because there's other types of capital reserves there's ones that are entitled to repair some that are titled so there's other funds that you can use for this this particular one we believe is for repairs there's other ones that aren't for and like I said we can explore using those for Turf that just wasn't what we were presenting tonight or the other you mentioned capital reserve when you were speaking before yes that's a fund that's potentially available that is the process is just a little more involved because that requires

024a full community similar in that respect to the recently concluded Capital campaign correct corre what is our capital reserve right now do we know um we have a couple of them which be set up to cover the cost of the EV buses and the infrastructure that's required of them I think between the two of them is probably about $5 million in this between the two the EV was set to so we both maxed out at 10 both both maxed out at 10 okay which we also didn't believe would be enough to cover the electric bus initiative but we were trying to be prudent and have money's available have to go out to the public it would be less money we be asking for so repair is used in educational section 48 refers specifically to the

025requirement that and specifications for major repairs which affect the health and safety of occupants must be approved by the commission and those those those are repairs usually to buildings and since this is outside of that it's the second part of that other repairs are occasional work of recurring nature which are intended to restore the satisfactory condition that which has decayed deterior weathered or become broken torn or otherwise in opal maintenance is recurring work which is intended to promote the upkeep of property and properly operating condition repairs and maintenance are not eligible for how me think it's Claire we'll directly ask a direct question to s u um so that we could say that's where so we started the repair Reserve from in 2022 and 2023 the capital reserve Fund in 2023 2024 and electric bus

026Reserve Fund in 2024 2025 so we have extra money every year that we're putting into these and just those three alone that we've approved in the last three years has almost $6 million into it and we're saying that we're not having the funds right now to be able to do a $500,000 re turfing to the field the reason we were able to have that much to put into the reserves because during those years we also had Federal Co money which alleviated a lot of the expenditures that we usually funded through the general fund so there were unusually larger fund balances at the end of the year which was why those reserves were created to say okay we can put this money away for future expenses and this seems like a future expense that would be

027one that we could afford to do um without having to increase the taxpayers it's money that has come from extra taxes each year to be able to do this as a smaller project versus adding it to a large Capital project um and yeah I would like to hear the exact whether or not from SD if we're allowed to use these repair funds to only this one's a repair fund the other ones so the other ones we believe could be used for the turf field that just wasn't what we were considering tonight that is something that's a future project that we'd have to look to see we would I would recommend the district do what needs assessed um because the there is many needs in the district including the electric bus that we would probably have

028to go to the public for for monies to expend in order to meet that demand um and there's also a lot of HVAC uh there's internal there's a High School auditorium there's a lot of things that are on the list it would make sense to do A needs assessment and then ask the you know the board to help us prioritize um and then look at the money and see how we should allocate those uh Capital reserves that's a correct term um for that and and turfing could be a great idea for that that's just not what we were asking for tonight so I'll read what I rent a little earlier with it but I do agree that there are other high priority capital projects that we need to look at tackling in the near future

029but most of those are outside of what the district could afford individually or without a bond um or would take possible years to come to fruition um this one sounds to be something we can afford to do on our own without the increase of taxes um individually and was identified as an area of needed repair and Improvement this is something that was you know just put up there as a a need a significant need of repair and approval this is a repair and Improvement to a current facility that we have yes so I I believe that the repair funds can be used towards doing that and I would just like clarification fromd specifically this fund because this is the only fund we're talking about the other funds We Believe can be used you believe this

030fund specifically this fund I'd like clarification from SD specifically we can use repair Reserve funds from our for turke we believe that we don't know the answer but let's get clarity so we all know and I think that's a good idea yeah a clarification question uh so you mentioned that um an improvement such as a tur field which again I think would only be equitably you know feasible if it were both fields of the baseball and the softball field would be considered Capital Improvement and it could be I guess either a loan or conjoined with other Capital Improvements as part of a a project that would have to be approved by public I mean a capital project historically for this district has been millions and millions of we conceivably there could be a if board

031wants to go that way have a smaller Capital project that could be almost entirely fled through a reserve if right like a stand alone yes so yeah my question then I guess relates to that I I seem to recall that during the recently concluded Capital project when the turfield was part of of the project only one part of a much larger project that um that project was as a whole aidable from the state yes right and if the turf field say the football field the turf field of the football field was um pursued or approved as a separate taple project would that have been fundable I seem to recall the requirement that such an improvement needed to be connected to an internal School Improvement or to an existing physical to to to get to be

032from s it has to be connected to something in a building right yeah to do ins side project in order to do an outside project right well I think that was a persuasive uh issue or persuasive point in joining the the tur field to uh to that project so so I would be concerned I mean maybe it's I absolutely understand PA this is a separate issue um but if we were to talk about that I think that would be a major issue to confront is whether a standalone Turf Improvement project would be fundable or aable rather aable if not I think that's a significant issue whether it is or not Capital project however in a in a capital reserve that's probably different right believe we would probably need s approval for it and at that

033point would not be able we would not get building Aid on those expenses if we used our capital reserve fund for that if and if we did if we were approved to use right wejust the field without any interior work to make that qualified to corre um I guess another point is um as you spoke um or Anthony presented the other parts of the project are up on the screen I guess I mean I I'm concerned that we not get Sidetrack a little bit from the other parts of this project know improvements proposed improvements to softball and baseball are part of it but I think the rest of part parts of the project seem to be of you know significant need and I hate to see um those issues possibly sacrificed you know the expense

034of of uh the baseball and softball field and again appreciating and understanding that these are separate issues I think that that understanding isn't isn't entirely clear still uh I think it was clear at the previous meeting on December 10th certainly was clear to me that these were separate issues and I understood the presentation on the turfield or the presting up the estimate on the turfield to be just a information for the board um but it was my understanding coming out of that meeting that that we couldn't pursue that as part of the reserve fund so you know you characterize that as a misunderstanding look Bo it was not for me I have to say now what percentage when we talk about aable a what type what are we talking about 5% 20% 50% what what

035does the state give do we owe them back on it is it is it just money that they're giving as part of it it's money we're expending either we bonded and spend it so that the building aid helps us pay back the bond or we fund it ourselves but what building Aid is done is based on the expenses it's calculated every year based on the whole financial state of the district but it usually hovers around for the district for our district it's been some between 65 and 70% so if we have inside component then the state would contribute 65 to 70% or so of the entire cost of the project over the but that's spaced out over the course of 20 years right over 20 years okay that's good good to know and we have

036internal work we could do like there's there's a way to do this this is just not what we're asking today and I do think it'll take time your feel doesn't even if you said if we said today we could do it it takes it'll take a while um like I said I I recommend doing this and then also pursuing the possibility of turfing our Fields um you know we might find that I don't know Anthony's magical minor Le Clay is something that um we like or we might find it it doesn't but I think it would repair the fields both of them um and then allow us the time to pursue turf field uh where we know sat would approve it and it would be fundable um and I think if that's something the board

037wishes for us to do I I don't think that's a problem for us to do um it's just going to take time and and it's it's not what tonight is for so again I I believe it would be a good idea to do this because otherwise I don't even know if the baseball field will be able to be the softball field be able to be improved on this year um but the real question is if the board believes we we're going to be able to get turfield whatever a season later which I'm not sure of uh an you think that would be too soon too that just saw your yeah likely yeah so if we're talking at least two seasons three seasons out really what we're asking people to consider is does it make sense

038to do this improve the fields and then pursue a turf field um ask the voters and all that stuff and so have the fields in better shape and then if it's decided yes you to put this to a vote put it to a vote and you get a to field um in the meantime if we don't do this then the fields will be the same for a couple more seasons at at least and so that be now if there's some way through vals magic and and other things we need that we could do a Turf yield through our Capital not Reserve not repair there um that is something we also could look at but that still wouldn't be for this season um so that that's really what we're talking about it's not no Turf it's

039hey if the board wants to pursue Turf let us pursue it and let us try to get it but in the meantime let us make the fields uh best shape we can see if Anthony can uh work his magic that he's you know uh and a lot of pressure on that I know get involved get that and see what we can do with those Capital funds or a capital project you know similar to what how we got the other turf field so timeline wise if we decided to do a turf field later on and doing this now we're looking at a couple years down the line CU last week or last meeting when I asked I was told that the board would decide it's kind of a non- answer to be like we decide because

040we're not deciding it's a couple years I'm line if we put the money into this then we're obviously not doing a tur field next year right so you're talking about a couple years on the line if we were to do this ahead of time or now again this is with Anthony as just said like you it doesn't look like it could be like we saw how long it took to do the other field like it doesn't look like we have it for next season is what he said you know if we do a full search and get Marco involved and get companies here and say that you we could give you actual accurate but it's just our belief through our experience that it's at least two seasons out I would say three but um we

041also try to work magic here right if this is a priority we want to do it we will then look at the capital reserve um we do have to do the needs assess but you know if we spend this does that make sense because we have this Mandate of electric buses or we have a we got to look at all that but if turf fields is the priority we will try to figure a way how to do it but based on what people here just said it's at least two seasons away before something would be installed so to Joanne's Point she did ask that at the last meeting because I did review this at the you know prior to coming to the meeting when I watched our last meeting and that was asked when would

042this project be able to be started and how long would it take and the answer at that time was potentially in the spring and approximately two months and that was specifically regarding the turf field discussion really I don't know any I don't think anyone said that maybe it's a misunderstanding on that but that's what was you know it was going to be around two months to do a tur turf field installation um I don't think it was going to be done this season either I don't think that was the uh the thought of doing it was because there's no way we'd be able to do it in the middle of the spring and that was exactly how I felt about it when you said it was that it wouldn't be for this season right um

043but that it would be done in the springtime of you know once baseball is over with and possibly be ready for The Following season and that the time frame of putting in the turf field would be approximately two months from your prior experience of having them installed yes i' I've seen turf fields installed over Summers so yes Anthony is that include all the uh all the leading up to yeah uh you mean once everything is set that's correct once s has approved it which can be a 6 to 8 months approval process and review even at that um there's some serious lead time there um so you know if if it was done as a capital project or that from the capital reserve this is the process that it would take and unfortunately that does

044take some time so um you may be looking at some two years until a field could be installed doesn't it is there an environmental review that's part of that usually doesn't well I remember that Dan might know that even more so it's it's just I recall it's just what I recall I I just sensed a lot of Doubt so if there's doubt we won't we could pull this not put any dirt down and pursue Turf as an Avenue and and and and do it the right way where we have the experts come in and Marco come in and do all that I just think it's going to take I think it's just going to take a couple years um I could be wrong but I I I know S I know how how things take

045forever we just finished a capital project that took that started before I started here and just finished uh you know whenever that was that last year um this summer um so that's okay it's all okay I just I sense doubt and I don't want you to vote on something with there's doubt um I was under the at least I felt that by using the repair Reserve fund versus a capital reserve fund or doing a capital Bond project that it was an easier Avenue of pursuing this than um the years of going through a bond process and the years of going through a capital reserve uh project to get this approved so it would it would be easier to use quicker to use a reserve fund but you still need SED approval and you need people

046coming in to give you the quotes and choose the right person and all that's a process if it was a capital project it would take even longer because you have to you got to marry it with Ure stuff really do it appropriately you want to do A needs assessment so that you can look at everything you need and make that determination um the so the concept of the capital reserve exists and that's something we can pursue but I still think that is two seasons away would that be accurate our thought we could be wrong and if we so if there's doubt let's not do this we won't do any repairs to the field this year and we'll pursue Turf and see and maybe through everything we can get it in a season uh which I'm

047not sure of or do this get the fields up to up the snuff you know it's really the board is looking at is spending this money worth it if we happen to get turf fields in a season or two or three so just for clarification when you say not do this do you mean extract the baseball softball field repairs from this project and go ahead with the rest of it because again I'm I'm concerned I mean correct two3 of the cost here is for other things I think we would extract it um we couldn't vote on it tonight we'd have to put out another hearing and do all that which is fine um but if there's doubt I don't I don't want a doubt I don't want the bo because otherwise it seems like it's

048a false economy you know it's it's apples and oranges I mean these two these two projects are mutually exclusive and what everything that 94 is cut that in half or however you want to cut it because that's for that's for both Fields so it's really where at is 40 and 50 40,000 for one 50,000 for the other I had asked at the last me even before this one when it was first proposed in this manner um of doing dirt and I asked for estimates to be provided and the information to be provided on on the turf option that's what I was expecting was that estimates were going to be getting gotten of what it was going to cost and a timeline of when this was going to be and um we provided that information um

049we were given a a number of 525 without ever seeing any of the estimates um even after asking for copies of the estimates um and being told you know very generically that is not supported at this time and that was the reason of not wanting to move forward with it um just you know financially it was not uh not um being advised by the uh by the Admin to move forward with it um so again I ask the information to be more informed about this of um the quote to see what the estimates are for and a timeline from those companies of when they would expect to be able to do this and the timeline from you know the the expectations here would take to do um in addition of asking for a quot of

050what the current Renovations that are being proposed of the dirt um cost analysis of it of just asking for you know the past couple years I know it it it's a long time to go back that far but um you know just seeing how much we we have spent in it and you know an estimate of what the annual expenses were going to be and did not receive that information and and I agree with I was not um you know uh misinformed in the last meeting um I just felt I wasn't fully informed and requested the additional information so we could be fully informed before making a decision on this and we still have not received the information that um was requested for um I have a concern of deciding to do a uh more

051or less a bandaid at this point hoping to make this last a couple of years to wait till we get Turf on it and then wasting the money that we're doing now just to dig it up two years from now or a year from now um which is why again I asked for quotes and quotes were given you received the quote but I guess timelines were not given is that accurate I did not receive a copy of the quote I was told what it was but I never received a copy of the quote gotcha so by quote as you wanted to see it not know specifically I asked a copy of each each quote the district received from each company for the turf V okay anything do you have I do the lowest one was

052the one we we showed other quote was higher um soft that was just for the baseball field yeah that was just the baseball field yeah okay so let's get clarity questions we want Anthony to find we want you we want you to get quotes on a baseball field and a softball field we want you to get a timeline of how long a company thinks it would take including s approval and to do that um we would then have to interpret if we could use the capital reserve for it um and then we would have to put a timeline in as if there was a vote which normally coincides with a budget vote the public would vote whether they want to use the funds for that um so that has to all be included in the

053timeline I believe also was asked and I believe the answer it but we didn't give a number was how much has it cost previously to manage the field and you felt you really didn't have a number on that because in your estimation more should have been done over the years so whatever number you would come up with would not be accurate but I think we're still being asked for a number so come up with a number um that you feel is accurate and then also come up with a number of what it would cost to continue on with with dirt management or whatever you want to call properly properly managed going forward one thing I would say I don't think the intention of this of this particular thing was a Band-Aid for the field I

054believe that this we believe would make the field uh very appropriate for for wasn't it wasn't a to do this for something else it was actually to get the fields up to what we believe and Anthony believes would be at an appropriate level um but obviously a brand new turf field will pop and will be charar but um this was not when this was put up here was not put up here to be an intermediary um we thought it might actually be something the district would be proud of um to uh kind of have the minor league clay and the look of that uh maybe but U so I just want to clarify that this was this was not an intermediary however we're kind of characterizing that way now because if the board is asking

055us to pursue Turf and we were to pass this then it would be an inter um except there's a lot of steps that would have to happen and we could not do this put it up for the voters and the voters could say no and then we wouldn't have either so it's just kind of like a a decision you have you have to make um and it's okay this is a good discussion and I I think the concept of Turk is good this is just our current reality of what we can do um and we want clar clear or clarify as best we can so if there's more questions please ask them so that we can have something prepared where everyone feels their questions answer Anthony you say you have the two quotes I do

056what are they I'm sorry how much were they uh for the baseball field not not the two for the baseball field alone this is broken out um I don't know if you hav remember you put the lowest one on there so one was for25 and one was for more than that but I don't know Yep they're also broken out with not a total on it so quick math in what area is we actually we could just get those forwarded to us yeah um I would still like to hear further from the public on uh on this thir here rep so I'd like to allow them to continue I definitely plan on doing that I I did have a quick question though on on another side you mention back in Auditorium right now do do we

057have a concept of scale of those right now time frame on those the work that needs to be done we have not put any of that together this is all that's what I suggested doing the full me assessment these are just things that were on our radar um to do uh we haven't even put the board on that radar because we you know the question of turf kind of came up recently and that that changed the uh dynamics of what we were planning on we were planning on going to the public for a capital project just yet um because we thought we just had one we wanted to finish and we wanted to get a little more information on the electric buses because we do believe that might be a capital project we have to

058do um so we were not going to we were not going to look for Capital project at that point now that has changed you know because of conversation we have here um that will take time to to process to go through and to have so we'd be willing to do that that's what the board like us to do I'm asking that just because I wanted to see if there's a way to bump anything if then if there was something that was ready to lump in for internal that we could you know capture some of the building Aid that would be important 100% we wanted to do some inside work to do theide anybody else from the board have anything to add at this moment okay why don't we open it back up to the public

059for any from the public at this point appreciate your patience thank you pleas my name is Ray Cody I'm a resident of 25 oral Drive uh I've resided there for the last years my life was born and raised in his school district and went through his entire School District I will say how long that is was I'll be in a lot of trouble if I how old she is and my son is currently a student here in Todd eth grade um I was going to speak on a support of the turf fields but uh what Mr McCracken said was spot on and I agree what everything he has and I still do support the turfield but as the other discussion went on through here and I don't want to this out I became a little

060confused was it seems we're talking about this one fund if we going to use that money things can to happen a lot faster but if we have to go another route it's going to take more time and I hear the discussion between repair versus replacement that we can't use these funds because it be replacing the turf with uh the replace in the other field but yet I look at l other expenditures we're replacing concrete steps we're taking them out putting in new ones that's replacement we're tearing down fencing replacing it with new all that is replacement so I think we're getting caught up with semantics repair versus replacement what really matters is doing the best for our kids and the students they're our investment I mean there's a reason why yeah thank you there's a

061reason why this school district in this area is so hot for hborg everyone wants to live here one of the number one reasons is the school district let's spend the extra money let's invest in our kids in our future and that's all I have to say but thank for you good evening Rich Trent for Timber Line Drive uh had a board meeting maybe seven or eight years ago uh former superintendent Mark valant spoke about the need for establishing what he called a culture of Maintenance uh we've seen twice in the century we've had to Embark upon very costly capital projects in part because we allow the facilities to deteriorate to the point where it was almost embarrassing to walk through the buildings or on the grounds and I think I think establishing the repair Reserve

062fund was a good positive step toward establishing the culture of Maintenance I think what we're seeing tonight the list of repairs uh it's very important that we try to address these things as they become uh as a need becom apparent rather than waiting for the once in a decade Capital project so I I do support uh in general the the uh proposal tonight I'd like to add one one item for consideration so during the last uh discussion at the last board meeting uh a couple board members mentioned that the baseball field is is in poor condition in part because it's shaded during the day in the morning it doesn't even have the ability to dry off by the time that the team practices in the afternoon uh the last time I saw the baseball field

063of close was when I was a student here and that was a very long time ago trees were much shorter and so on Saturday morning I I stopped by this school as I did my errands and I I observed that there are a lot of tall trees just to the south of the field and they were shading it at that time and I figure just given the layout of the field and the trees they'd probably be shading it even in the middle of the summer at least during the morning so I'd like to propose that that you consider removing the trees that are on District property many of those trees are they do appear to be on District property I pulled the the property map from the County website and looking at the property lines

064many of the trees that are shading the the the uh field are on school grounds the others are are you know growing at the back end of the lots of the adjoining residences you might be able to convince the people who live there to you know allow the district to remove those trees at District expense so I would just like to propose that as something for additional consideration thank you thank you [Music] good evening thank you for your time my name is Brad cookingham my boys reside at 16 darling Drive uh my oldest Braden is a junior at Spackenkill high school and my youngest is a freshman at Spackenkill High School both my boys play baseball and enjoy doing so uh when I brought this up the other night uh my youngest Tyler was in

065thrilled that there was going to be a discussion on the baseball field because it's in such poor condition um this year I saw a kid at third base catch a ball that should have been easier to be played but it wasn't and it called him and I believe it broke his notse um a couple things I would like to bring up is that my ex-wife and I moved to this District because of the district that it is my boys have come up through Nassau Hagen Orval Todd and now they're at the high school um I work in the town of pyy I am a police officer in the town of pyy and what I see in my experience of 24 years in law enforcement is that kids that are in sports don't interact with law

066enforcement so it is truly an investment for our district for our community um another thing that I would like to add to that is that um lost my train of thought so bear with me for a second um should have wrote it all down um I would like you just to invest in our kids I like you to invest in our community and I think the turfield is the way to do that uh I also have been part of uh this is what I was part of uh an organization that such as yourself with the executive board and I know things can be delayed so the last thing I want to see is this to be delayed a couple years and to have no capital or improvements on the on the field so whatever kind

067of semantics we need to figure out on the wording of how this gets done I don't want it to be tabled it continue to be table and that not have any kind of improvement to the field because my boys have a couple years left here to play some baseball and I want them to do it on the good baseball field thank you very much good evening my name is Richard Decker and I live at nine Stewart drive from pipy I'd like to first and foremost thank the board and the administration for everything you do I know you take a lot of time and energy to make sure that this district and our kids are taken care of I'm a proud parent of three kids that have either gone through the spack and kill system or

068are in the spack and kill system my oldest is 27 my middle one is 20 at Quinnipiac and my youngest is a freshman in high school um you know I I I got to tell you um and Dr F Well knows quite well we went to high school together and I just uh you know I call it as I see it there was a lot of tension at this board I felt you know I felt there was a lot of division or hidden agenda I don't know what it was I couldn't put my finger on it but when you go back and look and evaluate I think you'd be very surprised at my comment and uh as far as I'm concerned there's been a lot of talk but nothing about risk risk and reward right

069and there and there's a relationship I don't care what business we're talking about there's a relationship and the fields that we have here are despicable we have a team a tradition here at Spackenkill High School where we have won three state championships in the last 20 years Ketchum has a very rich tradition in baseball Arlington has a very rich tradition in baseball Ketchum has two Arlington has one and I was a proud member of it in history and so for our facilities to look like that and we have the best record in Duchess County you should really look in the mirror and you should take a look go out on that field and see if you would like your kids playing on that field and taking a ball to the eye or twisting and tearing

070an ankle or an ACL and then evaluate based on your needs cuz a stairwell from outside is needed I'm shocked to be honest with you and that football field turn turned over in a summer if I'm not mistaken it was we did not miss a season so whatever it takes for everybody to get along and figure this out for the kids I would greatly appreciate it thank you anybody else hello how are you guys doing my name is Nick Parco I live at 37 Beachwood Park I have three children in the uh District uh they go to Nassau and U and Hagen these guys do a fantastic job I'm also a police officer in the community uh have over 20 years um and I'm on the current board for the uh Little League here and

071one of my duties there is I'm in charge of field maintenance uh we've done two Fields over the summer because our town has a completely deand abandoned art program and we pay out of our own pockets and dads do a lot of uh their own maintenance on the field just some questions I have if if you guys did end up going with the dirt which I'm not in favor for does the do the fields have uh irrigation why don't you go ahead and finish your points and then I'll I'll jot down any your questions and then we'll address them afterwards okay that's okay um just just in my um my last five 5 years being on the town involved in the town little league with field maintenance we've been doing dirt fields and over the

072last 15 years we've had to redo Red Oaks meal field four times because it's very hard upkeep um you need a a village to take care of the field properly to have proper drainage to make sure it's safe uh this year we hosted the allstar state tournament and we got over a 100 complaints from families coming in and out of town because kids were getting hurt on the field so um if these fields are in rough shape I understand where the complaints from and talk about putting a Band-Aid over the field it is a Band-Aid because if you don't have a proper facility manager spending eight hours a day on a baseball field it's not going to be meticulously U maintained just something to think about um I'm a Ketchum graduate I play baseball at

073Ketchum my wife went there she's a teacher there we moved to this District because of the school district that's why we lived here we lived here now for 10 years and I agree with these guys let's spend some money on our kids that's all I have to say thank [Applause] you Anthony there is if I'm not mistaken there's one uh water area near the mound is that correct for for irrigation I believe so and then they do uh they are able to bring out large scale watering devices to uh help with that but is it basically a spigot and then you tie a hose to it and use it to uh there it's a larger water source so it's a you know it's it's not just like Garden Hol but uh but essentially but essentially

074it's it's um yeah can I just say uh without IR proper irrigation it's going to be very hard to maintain the grass on the I'm sorry if you don't mind just so it's on the record and everybody can hear you through the microphone thank you appreciate it just with the irrigation that I've dealt with with our Fields here in the town without proper irrigation which we have here in the town it's very hard to keep the the fields looking plus especially with a drought that we had this year um the fields dry up very fast the infields become concrete they literally will become concrete kids slide on the field their pants get ripped it's like sliding on concrete so without proper irrigation when you're redoing a baseball field it's really going to be hard for

075that field to be presstine and we also spent the money with the town Cal riin League uh we spent the money and we got minor league uh dirt clay so we spent the money we got it shipped in from Connecticut came highly recommended from a a a landscaper who redo fields and um and they also Renegades at the time when they were dirt they were using this company also so you know that's something too that you got to think about if you do redo the fields it will look nice but without proper irrigation be very very hard to maintain that's [Music] all anyone else okay I think I think it's still appropiate continue discussion so to Echo what a lot of them are saying is um something I I wrote down earlier is the students

076who play on these fields do deserve better uh expenses aside the benefit of providing a turf field to our districts baseball and softball teams are needed uh the same benefits a lot of our other sports are getting from practicing on uh practicing playing on the turf football and soccer fields um the feeling that both softball field or baseball and softball field needs to be done at the same time um in my opinion is is debatable uh both so both the softball team and the baseball team can play on the turf to baseball field uh we have seen that at plenty of tournaments that it's possible to do that uh doing these field separately also allows the initial cost um and future maintenance cost to be spread out a year or two so we don't have

077to repair both fields in the same year each time uh with the spring weather in our area uh leads to multiple practices and Gams being canceled due to the field uh conditions the baseball infield in particular has uh apparent drainage issues and is in the shade uh most of the day making practices and games consistently cancelled uh even on a sunny day if it's been uh raining the day before we found that it's still not a usable field the following day uh sitting in the Sun or the lack thereof uh it's a very short season for these teams um to practice or to play and even harder with the Rainy conditions causing field issues to cancel Turf would allow them to play rain or shine um seen full tournaments held in the rain on turf

078fields um but I'm sure both the softball and the baseball would like a field to practice on during the rainy season uh and turf can provide that um I am still in support of um trying to see if we are allowed to use the repair Reserve funds to uh to make uh this happen um and if not if we're being told by the s that is uh not something that we could do I would like to see what um considerations we have available to us um to expedite a a tur field rather than um a another dirt field being uh brought in U for us to tear up later on um you know I don't using the word bandaid May up in the proper I know will look great if it's if that's the route

079um that we had to go with but I think Turf is going to be more beneficial and I would like to try to see that happening sooner rather than later and not years down the road from now if that's possibility to match thank you I'd like make one for the comment uh as well I mean I um I think I I use the phrase false economy before I think this still is at least if I'm understanding that the uh regulations and and uh restrictions on and how we use the funds still is I think a false choice between uh what's on the screen now and and what we're talking about in the main here the installation of a turf field I'm very sympathetic frankly to all of the people who spoken today to the desire

080for a turf field uh I'm a supporter of it um it's been a while but I I've had four Sons go through the district all of whom played baseball uh my three older Sons played probably a total of 16 17 years on those fields uh here uh I'm very familiar with what the fields look like felt back then that the fields needed to be improved I had meetings with Dave DS and others in the district about that uh it's been a slow slow process and one of the things I was really Overjoyed about when Anthony came on board was that he addressed this uh situation directly you know even before he was hired I think uh so I was happy to hear that I'm in in that respect very sympathetic to everything people have said

081about the desire to improve the fields but the desire to do well by our our students isn't I I think a brand new desire this has been in place for a long time um Mr Trent spoke about the culture of Maintenance I agree uh perhaps youve turned a page in that respect and can try to maintain the facilities I know that's a concern it's an issue with the her football field maintaining that properly uh that's not uh you know free of Maintenance um so so I'm happy to see things moving in a different Direction but I want to make it very clear that that uh at least as far as I'm concerned I'm speaking really for myself here but I think this is shared by others in the board as well uh I am not

082unsympathetic to the desire for a turf field I think I'm very much in favor of that but it would have to be I think pursued in a different way than what we're talking about right here and there are needs I think as Dr FIA said in the district that uh could be conjoined with this um whether they are conjoined or not the turf field it sounds to me would have we put up to a public vote and um another thing I remember in our district and and others do I'm sure as well was back in roughly 2008 you know when we had a a capital project proposed to include a turf field a turf football field uh that referendum Was Defeated uh because people in the in the district uh didn't widely share the desire

083to to fund it at that level so uh while we're hearing from a very committed group of people today and I certainly appreciate all of that we have to also recognize that there are others in thect District to who uh who would have to be weighing in on this and I think uh to me that is another reason for us why why we might want to consider conjoining a turf field with other components of a capital project that would make uh this more sellable to the community as a whole so guess I just want to stress that that uh it seems like there's some antagonism or perception of antagonism here on the part of some but I don't think as far as I'm concerned anyway there's there's any lack of sympathy to this I think

084I'm strong in favor but I just just a matter of how to do it anyone else I would agree with with what people said here today I I have an athletic background I played baseball uh Mr Decker uh had quite a curveball uh back in his day I believe that's what he was known for uh he could play hoop also um and we definitely want I mean the whole concept of actually making sure that this dirt not the turf was in it was because we really felt improvements needed to be done U I felt that about baseball since I've been here uh I advocated strongly and we got to uh scoreboards which is something that I could not believe we didn't have you know how do we not have a scoreboard um especially with the

085ability to just put them on the building like it just was very cost uh effective um having a tur field would be something I would love to have uh it's just figuring out the best way of doing it and looking at everything and not just one component we have the ability to do that and and and figure this out you know I think most of the challenges that we've had here uh since I've been here we we be with optimistically and and try to figure it out and I think we've done that and I feel this is the same there's no antagonism I think what everyone said here today was was correct you know it would be beautiful to have it there benefits to Turf um it's just a matter of I in my experience

086I know things take time and I know Mr deer talked about the football field being turnover in in in in one season that was because all the all the behind the scenes were took a little bit of time and that was just from construction to to end you know so uh anyone who deals with st everything takes a long time because it has to go through all you know Architects and and it just time uh and it's unfortunate I don't like it you know um this was trying to repair the fields as quickly as possible um maybe even like we said we might like it you know I don't know that I know the look of the I've seen minor league I think Ketchum still has a dirt field I know Harlington doesn't but I

087think Ketchum and they have a dirt field you know which just just adding to the right thing um so I I still kind of where where where I am I think it would be prudent to make these improvements and get them done um and then try to figure out a way to Turf the field I think really what we're asking is is is the amount of money to spend now would that be wasteful if we do get a turf field in two years or two seasons if that's what it takes um I don't think it is um I think it's it's worth having our our children have that better field right now and then pursue this also okay it's not one or the other uh I think it's uh do do do this because I

088know we can do this now and then pursue and see uh the best way to get uh Turf in if that's you get to come back up may I public hearing is not closed so great um 30 seconds I don't necessarily mine but I'm going to keep you to the 30 seconds okay um I just want to I want to I want to just point out um on behalf of all these dads and and people in support in the baseball Community look what we really really want is we want a playable field for our kids to be on if that means that you do this um project this funding right now for this season and But please understand the seriousness of how important it is is for these kids to have an improved facility and

089I think that the program deserves it that's why it's on there yeah all right so I I just don't want to get anybody wrong you know if if that's the solution for right now you know I I believe we we want our kids to be on a playable field right but please understand the seriousness and and the importance of really considering down the road here to get on moving on S and all this other stuff so that in the future we can have it all right thank you everybody Happy New Year I think you went a little over but I agree I would like to make still a more informed decision I would like to hear from the S I would like to see what these quotes are and the uh estimated time frame before

090making a uh a decision on this if it turns that we aren't able to do I would like to explore the other options of what we can do to make this happen uh sooner rather than later I would not be opposed to uh I I certainly wouldn't want us to continue with the field that we have um and uh time that we'll have to wait uh for a turfield to come in and not do any kind of repairs between now and then but I would still like to have a more informed decision with the uh proper quotes and time frame and SC um if this is something that can be done through the repair Reserve fund I agree with you Richard I I do think that um we would need to have another public session

091so that there any you know we have people here in support of it if there is a opposition to it gives the public that opportunity um as required with the repair Reserve fund for them to come and and voice their uh opposition to it or their disapproval of it um so if it is something we could do we can uh obviously schedule another uh uh public hearing for uh that consideration I I would propose that we uh know somebody said they didn't like the word table but I would uh propose that we table this um until the following meeting in hopes that we have that s information and uh those quotes so we can make a more informed decision as well as the uh other requested information as far as the work um annual work

092uh the past work that's been done um that that's possible to get that would be my propos when's our next meeting two weeks I believe what's on the table though is there's a whether the board accepts it or not is on the table for tonight and I'm proposing to take and then if then we would have to have another meeting which is fine and explain all that stuff and then we'd have to have another hearing which have to be the meeting after that have on it um and all that is fine yeah and we'll do all that I just want to be clear right because Anthony's already saying this the longer we take with determining this and it's okay this is not I'm just trying to be clear this is not a anything anything bad

093the odds of getting the clay for the field this year diminish so want to talk to that so everyone just has Clarity because I do not want another meeting where and then people find out that that we repairs aren't going to be done this year any yeah I think it's difficult get and it's really weather dependent depends on what kind of winner we have right I mean you know it's typical to even see if we can get the the kids on the field playing at that point you know so um that being said we don't know what we're going to have we don't know how soft the ground is going to be we don't know if we'll be able to actually do the appropriate work to it um given the time of year and getting

094it done before they would need to use the field it's my opinion that it's unlikely at this point to even do these repairs because of where we sit in time you know for it to be ready in the spring so you're saying it's not possible to have this ready in in the at this point I don't believe so I want you to clarify that because we talk after tonight we thought it wouldn't be able to happen but if we were able to get going we thought that that we had a good chance of repairs to the field if it was to pass if it was to pass tonight we we have we may have a chance but again it's weather dependent at this point um yeah just one Clarity to seeing Clarity y after tonight

095it greatly Dimensions is what you're saying agreed yeah and are we talking in that respect about just the baseball softball field component of this or all parts of it specifically baseball softball but tennis courts what OB I'd have to wait for better weather to yeah that would have to wait that's not really what we're talking about right right the the the time restraints on on uh fencing and concrete work and that sort of stuff right we you know there's yeah there's there's not quite the yeah what specifically in the next two weeks would you be doing to make it so it could happen you know in the spring versus not I I that's good information okay so then there's between now and the next two weeks but the next if it changes then the vote

096wouldn't be in two weeks it I would see some clarification on what sort of sequence we're talking about here are we talking about a sequence where we get more information about the cost that you've referred to Jeff and then review this exact same proposal or are we talking about if we keep the proposal as is you would not have to have another hearing you would just and you could just vote next meeting with that information if you were to deviate from what's there so let's say remove the fields from it and just do the rest or uh if we learn that you could use this fund and the board decides they want to use it and for turfing and then you put that in there that would be another hearing requ changing the time um

097but I do believe we should have the answer to whether which I believe we have the answer but we want Clarity on whether we could use this fund so maybe it makes sense to get that answer I don't know if in two weeks you're going to get the other answers to uh timelines and all that stuff we hope but I would imagine we would have the answer to a direct answer to a direct question on can you use the repair fund for turkey and then you'll have that knowledge at the next meeting so let's say it is no you would then have the knowledge do we want to do this or not if it's yes and we can talk about do we want to put up another have another hearing that includes those costs and

098at that point would probably not be happening in the season at the season anyways be a project over turfield would not uh we would hope that so we'd still be okay at this point I think so just talking based on your question to him right so the dirt getting between tonight and two weeks from now would still be the same timeline it's if we have to go even deeper is that even fair to ask you these questions like do you even I you know I I have to check a little bit more with the contractor to see what they think is is completely uh able to be done um you know it's it's more than a matter of just clay here we're talking about the uh top coating and seating as well um so you

099know I would really have to uh review with the contractor uh to see what what they think could be done at this pointor I think for me to be able to make a decision on this I need information on fourth fourth coming costs as well so it's really important for me to be able to understand how much effort in terms of materials and labor labor time that we could be using on other parts of the school district anywhere um in order to maintain a dirt field the way it should be maintained um and then we can at least project that forward to understand the life expectancy of turf versus all this what's the cost now being higher what's the cost overall in 10 years 15 years 20 years those are the things I need to

100to be able to make a decision that is an informed decision um I I tend to agree with what everybody's saying here I mean I I think Turk would be the best option long term for us so uh I think you know it's it's a matter of being able to walk and chew gum we need to be able to try to get these things done as quickly as possible if if that's the case but I'd like to know what those options are so that I can I can make a real decision cuz I I can't right now so that I believe you actually have a motion to lay on the table yes is that correct is that accurate so that would be a motion to lay item 4.03 on the table which would put it

101to the January 21 meeting for contined discussion does anybody want to second that motion we still have to do that regardless okay you know sorry sorry point of Bo no that's fine point of Bo all right I'll take a I'll entertain a motion to close the public hearing on the repair Reserve expenditures so do I have a second second all in favor I passes 5 and then we have a motion to lay item 4.03 on the table pushing it to the January 21 meeting for continued discussion I have a second on that that's you're right I'm sorry 5.01 thank you for that repair Reserve fund resolution is item 5.01 so that's what proposed to lay on the table to January okay all in favor is there discussion is there opportunity for discussion of that um

102the motion SP hold on a second cheat sheet interest territory there's always regarding a motion my understanding is there's always opportunity for discussion the motion to lay on the table needs a second is not debatable is not amendable and requires a majority vote so no discussion that's how I read that debatable I think it's the that I'm not even sure if I'm allowed to say anything further if there's no if there's opportunity for discussion or debate I think you're correct what I'll do is I'll I'll ask for a roll call vote then just to make it very clear uh we'll start with Joan the vote on uh tabling 51 yes Richard Iain stay I just don't have the information that I would have saw okay Sasha I'm not sure um the question it's a motion

103to lay item 5.01 on the table which pushes it to January 21 meeting it's yes Jen I agree I wish I had gotten the information that was requested so I can make a more inform decision but I also a yes for that okay and I will vote Yes as well so that's or one extension okay all right that will bring us to item 6.01 we have a presentation from Dr fi and Mr Lynch Mr Lynch where are you going to feel C want to go there wherever you want me yeah you want to go there I'll stay here sure thank you uh who's leaving thank you thank you I love to hear might have died died yeah I got to replace the battery okay yeah it's all good Dr fui would you like to kick

104it off or you want me to get going start all right uh good evening everyone so um Dr fui and I are going to speak about um a trip that we took we applied last spring to be a part of an international delegation um to the Iberian Peninsula in Portugal and Spain and the purpose of that trip it's a yearly trip um is to connect with our educational counterparts and to to really learn from uh their education systems and the differences and to bring things back uh to the district so um couple of the other places they've gone in years pass last year they went to Japan uh the previous year was was Finland um and then Germany before that um a really interesting um trip which we'll get into but one of the things

105that I thought was uh unique was the in their selection process they I think they emphasize um diversity of of geography so there were uh there was representation from Oregon uh California Illinois Pennsylvania New York Virginia uh Georgia and North Carolina um which made it um unique not just to um see the schools that we went into which we'll talk about but um I learned a lot about our own country's educational system uh through the process just uh learning from them so a combined the learning was combined because we learned from our us counterparts if you will U and then obviously being together Spain and Portugal all right so the trip uh began in Spain and Madrid um we went to um the school there then went down to um Sevilla and to Lisbon and

106we saw two more schools there um Sandra if you can just go to the next slide so uh each time they go on a trip they are selective of where they go and they try to uh get a mixture of public schools they don't use the word charter school there but they have uh publicly subsidized schools which we did see um and we also saw and this this was the first of this type that I've ever seen an an American School uh in Lisbon so really three types of schools we saw we saw what I would consider a public private hybrid you saw an international school which uh where like delegates send their kids uh and we saw a full public school um and you could see differences just like you would see here items

107there so yes so the first Sandra if you can just go back to that that last one so the first school that we went to was in Madrid um that's an aerial photo uh was in the inner city this was that um publicly subsidized School believe they said it was 30% subsidized um and privately run uh there was a heavy religious component to this particular school um across the country um um the Catholic religion in particular is is a very strong religion there within the school system couple about that impact at the end y a couple of the the takeaways from this school is um so it was a K12 school and it began at the age of of three which is unique um not something that I'm familiar with um in Duchess County or

108in the states um here so that was pretty cool to see see um so there is an English component to this school where the the core subjects are taught in Spanish but the specials are taught in English and every class has a language assistant within that class in addition to the teacher um and that's part of their dual language uh certification process um you know we also learned about the Spanish education system generally and it was interesting to hear that um students can graduate by the age of 15 and they kind of um they get on a track at that age and some of them choose to go to a trade school some of them choose to go to a university um and some of them uh go into the workforce so it was interesting

109to learn about that uh we were all um speaking from um all of the participants on the trip really interested in um it's going to sound crazy that we were interested in this but they had a 2-hour lunch every day and the the meal came out in three different courses um and you can tell that that was really a cultural thing um that they prioritized and and believed and we we were pretty mesmerized by it um we also it was also very noticeable and I think you know part part of this is you know the the geography in in Europe but um there were student presentations and the the students so there's a program that they call arasmus plus it's an exchange program and many of them um spend so they apply through their own

110government and they go to different countries Europe Asia North America um last year 40 high schoolers went on that trip and we thought that was pretty special as well uh this as you can I guess you can't see in that particular picture um but they they also had school uniforms all right so the uh the next school we went to was in Lisbon this is that international school that I spoke about um there were 59 different nationalities represented within this school um it was notice noticeable that when we pulled into this school it was a very different experience in terms of security um in the other schools there really wasn't security and in this one uh before we could even pull into the lot they were checking for bombs underneath the bus um yeah it

111was it was kind of a surreal experience there was a gate that was closed that had open up for us and they talked they talked about uh unfortunately um soft soft targets kids of ambassadors Etc um we'll talk later Stark difference in the other two schools which kind of have the opposite approach to security but we'll talk about that at theend conclusion yeah and and so this this is a school that in many ways tries to be American by Design and and uh the director of the the school system I I guess that would be similar to a superintendent here he was not a principal he was he was in charge of the entire uh multiple schools there um he talked about how American education system is known for creating problem solvers um and really

112U prioritizing creativity so they they in many ways try to mimic the American system uh we we thought it was pretty pretty neat where um the student body went after they graduated from this school and I I wrote down some notes uh so out of the 68 seniors last year 11 went on to American universities nine to Dutch universities 12 to British universities nine to Portuguese universities 16 to different other countries and then 11 and this this is a I think uniquely European thing um 11 took a gap here all right so uh this was an inner city school public school in Lisbon uh when I look at that picture over to the left and I've told this story and I'm still wrapping my head around it um but we we arrived and it took

113a couple minutes for the principal to come out who was giving us the tour and this is in the inner city the heart of Lisbon and there was a group of of kids outside not that group on the bikes but they were clearly Upper Elementary and one was trying to climb a tree the other ones throwing baseballs against the side of the school they're playing tag they had some unique game that they played on the railing yeah that had some sort of objective but it wasn't clear to any of us but they clearly had this railing game um and we just watched them all right they probably have some free time you know KS your kids this is the complete public school um sorry I this was just and then we were in the school

114for a while long time and then when we were coming out to leave and the same exact kids are doing the same exact stuff and we just kind of looked at each other and I we asked the the principal who was the woman there like what's going on and she said I quote I think their teacher isn't here today she didn't know for sure uh we didn't Challenger on it we just went with it but it was such a unique thing to see that they basically were free and there was no and they were they stayed within the comp you know they played their rallying game or whatever uh it blew our minds talk about it Eric yeah I I I think For Better or Worse um we were blown away because whether it's you

115know upper elementary kids whether it's Hagen or a school in in Georgia or or or Oregon that doesn't happen it doesn't happen anywhere and and you could say maybe they're better for for having a little uh more freedom and feeling that those kids were safe or you could say well they were safe but they weren't they weren't learning math and and reading that day because when when we left after the presentation those same students were there um so just just fascinating a different culture and a different different part of the world um this was also very diverse School 66 different nationalities were represented it was a first grade through nth grade school um I see Mrs Spiegel here um she would appreciate this given the kindergarten bike program we talked about Miss Spiegel in Lisbon

116so you need to know that yeah so did this is a so many of the students walk and still ride bikes to school and so they not only teach kindergarteners to ride bikes um but they actually have a bike class that that goes through fourth grade and there's a there's a road safety component that kind of goes with that um English is taught to all students beginning in first grade um and all students also get three years of French prek so again this is a different country than the other um the school I we began with but prek also begins at 3 years old which is you know obviously different than here where it's four um this particular school was busting at the seams and and you could feel it when the bell rang and

117students were in the hallway um they had said in the last 5 years their enrollment has increased uh 100% And they talked about um the impact that that has had on um on the school uh couple other things that I wrote down that I I thought were unique um that one picture doing it the kids aren't sleeping they were told to put their head down so that they wouldn't be photographed uh so if you look at everyone uh just interesting did I want to throw they weren't they weren't having a sleep time over in there uh there was a leadership class that the students took it was called bomb 2 and that was based on Nelson Mandela's uh leadership teachings we thought that was that was a special part of the school uh no mobile

118phones in the school at all with the exception of ninth graders um a deep belief that this is also unique um I I I don't believe this is um an American belief but a a deep belief in high stakes testing universally and you know this is something that is debated in all different types of circles um but but when some of the um some of the people ask questions about that cuz we we don't hear that in this country very often and they actually talked about high stakes testing being the most inclusive way to get children opportunities and um it was just fascinating to to hear and that that also that also goes along with the College admission process so when you're 15 years old you take this high stakes test and you don't write

119an essay and you don't get recommendations all of those other pieces that we do in this uh country to try to figure out a a big picture of a child they base it 100% off of this test and um it's just fascinating because it's it's the opposite of of fit well with us um it's kind of been some of the system does fit well where they they really had a a uh you know an academic you know kind of a career path too but you were really kind of pigeon ho into one of them at at at an early age and then the test you took really decided what type of degree pursue so if you wanted to be in the medical field you didn't take a medical test you took the same test but

120you just had a score higher on it um and what what really you know to be honest you know we're going to talk about this later but we might as to talk about it now um there was no story about the child so everyone have someone or you have someone in college or or going to college I know someone won't but one of the most important items you do is the college essay is is the letter recommendation is kind of the telling of the story there's no telling of the story it's just what did you do on that test um we struggle with that um um and I think there is some struggle with that there um but that was a system they have but um I would imagine be looking at that can I

121just ask one quick question on that did they allow the people to retake the test if they had a bad test day or how how does that work I don't know the answer to that question I know I would imagine you could take it again but uh I don't know that um it really was high Stak so maybe you could we have to we have to Google that um just what you got on that just determine I think it just didn't add up to us but uh determ of placement for like the successive year or yeah for where where you go and what you could pursue right um you know and if you want to you know be a doctor you just have you got to sore higher on it and if you want to

122be someone of different um what age was it given 15 15 so it was at the point that you could that's where that's where you divide off into kind of the career or or the academic you know uh U just seemed like and this and this cultural belief this was Portugal and Spain there were some differences between the two countries uh philosophically uh this was the same and not not just what they they showed in in their slides but they spoke very proudly of of of that philosophy all right um so in thinking about all three of of those schools I think um you know and and we've touched on these things but um I think in terms of trends that that we noticed uh number one technology I think they're going through a similar

123time period to what we are here and you know we've spoken about the anxious generation that is is clearly um there's a lot of questioning about us over pushing technology and I'm not just talking about schools Society um and so there is definitely a push towards um less technology in schools inclusive of mobile phones but also really being thoughtful about what we use technology for um a ton of diversity we saw in in all of these schools that was wonderful to to see um there was a um there was a a real focus on health and wellness of the child and you know we talked about a 2hour I'm not I'm not proposing that we have two-hour lunches at NAS orgen but that was that was that's part of their belief that hey we need

124to slow down when we eat we need more time more more um unstructured time and um you know that that was just one uh part of that so health and wellness was a was a big Focus infant education again I mentioned it but the age of three for that to be kind of the norm in those two countries um yeah prek was the norm and even obviously younger than us here we talked about we talked about the longer lunches the more free play the less supervision that whole story we told you about the school where they're playing on the railing um your earlier tracks placement test we kind of hit that they all teach English so English was uh everyone has to learn it's it's not you can choose another language or whatever you're learning

125English and at a young age um the school security was interesting you can talk about Volunteers in a second but that one school we talked about with the mirers but the other two was the opposite you know you you kind of oh you're here to visit come on in you know um you know I know we were with the delegation it was probably all planned before so there might been a little of that but kind of didn't feel like like it might feel here education you said that was pre pre it was in essence pre pre it was grade three uh that's where they started so before uh and then and then they go on to there's a focus on on that younger education there that's not at the public school level three years old

126teach going to school public yeah volunteerism yeah just one other thing I want to add the the less supervision part Dr fui talked about it was noticeable and we took some pictures um you know one of the the things if if we're hiring a a monitor here uh in spa and kill um you know one of the questions we ask is you know please to find uh your def please toine active supervision and what we're looking for is you know we we we see what's going on on the playground at lunch and you can tell they make a point to stay away and and and let kids figure out more than I think maybe uh what we've been trained to do here for good reason for safety but it was just it was very noticeable

127and there there's one photo that I have uh from the building where there's just these um two big fields and I couldn't find an adult on those fields and and there you know it was two hundred yard uh is Fields uh running parallel to each other I couldn't find an adult and um you know I think that's something that they that they do on on purpose which which is which is noticeable and um and notable so uh volunteerism I I do think this is similar to us here when I when I hear Mr maler come and present and you know frequently we have spack and kill high school students come in Nassau but uh they call it U voluntourism there and they they talk about how it's a requirement within their school system to volunteer

128for x amount of hours um but it really gets ingrained um um in in the student population gets them interested and a sense of purpose in their Community um and we actually had students speak about that which was which was nice in the hiden curriculum uh what we really saw was values P2 like that kind of uh um it was just kind of embedded everywhere um you can definitely feel the flavor of almost what we're doing with P2 we were definitely uh happy to see that the first one we really wondered like some of the things they did there really were based on cultural beliefs and we don't know you know the impact of religion in that first school like that's just something that we wouldn't see here in America you know so there there's

129some things that we were like all right they have that might be unique and and wouldn't translate you know versus same same stuff here uh you had another example what else uh the other cultural one you're talking about now so with that one that first school was a you should call it a hybrid right hybrid hybrid public private it was a public school that received some private funding so that gave them the Liberty freedom to kind of so do what they wanted would would then parents send their children to that school by choice or was it a public school kind of setup where they would have gone there if they were in that region I think it was based on where they live but um lot it wasn't kind of that New York City flavor

130um it it just was the public in that respect people going there were selected by by living there correct that's that's what I believe un likee a private school here where you could be sent go from anywhere U but there definitely was it was some some holiday or something and you you could see the the just the religious connotation love you know uh you we love the turn multiple Pathways here and we wondered do they really have that there when we're talking about the high State Testing but they did have Pathways you know that you could go into kind of the career you know versus versus academic kind of uh matter but this is what we wondered you know how how how much multiple pathways are there um the concept of technology this is really

131one of the it's on the next slide we should probably save it what we discovered we'll save uh what's happening in part of our next steps but but go ahead ER yeah and then you know so free play and again we're going to we're doing so much work with this and and exploring with with parents and teachers um all three schools had some type of rule where so one school for example after every hour of instruction it was an expectation schoolwide that there was a half hour of outside play or free play and so that you know that's not something besides lunch and recess mostly in the states certainly here at spacking hill we don't mandate our teachers to to to do things like that many of them do that on different days um and

132they have the autonomy to do that but you could tell this was a real Focus there um and mattered enough to them that they actually mandated it and so I you know I I don't know that that will will happen here but it it was just really interesting that that that was the case at all three of those schools um yeah Wellness talked about uh on gym days in one of the schools every kid wore their gym outfit the whole day and then the other kids wore a school uniform but when we first walked in I'm like oh their uniforms are very I don't know uh what would be the word you know not uniformy they're very was like ATT trct pads or TR discover that that was their gy uniform they have a profile

133of a graduat or a learner which is what New York is looking to instill with the pro Ren commission so we saw a lot of similarities with that really our next steps uh the connections we made with the aasa which is the the superintendent National superintendent Association was really got to know some some good people across the country uh we're trying to get together again to talk about our experiences kind of have a reunion um to have colleagues nationally and internationally and really the the coolest thing that we saw is in one of the schools we're we're walking out and uh Eric's like hey look at that book that's the anxious generation and it's kind of centered on on the bookshelf and it turns out that they're doing a book talk on it and that

134they're having the exact same conversations we are having about it and if you read that book or if you read it talks about how it's not an American thing it's it's it's it's throughout the you know the globe and they are literally wrestling with the exact same thing reading the exact same book so the cool thing is Nate Chapman um who was the leader was titled director there we've been in contact with him about uh what his how his book talks going how our book talk going and we're going to see if we could kind of put something together there's kind of this International uh discussion on what what what they are thinking and hearing and what we are thinking here and so just was fascinating to see which school was that which school was

135that that was International School international school and that age range is all the way up through High School level high school level and so in particular when I've when I've met with Nate and his team through Google meets uh what the particular part we're interested in in partnering on so right now by Design we are only focusing on what can we do in school tools to make the experience better for kids in school now the book talks about this this concept of collective action and there's a there's a part from uh from the parents as well and so what what we are working um through our PTA which we present to at PTA meetings is we we Nate um and I are very interested in actually connecting our parents group with their parent group so

136we're going to we're going to have these ideas for implementation and some shifts for next year in the school but we want to partner with our obviously our parents and their parents to generate ideas for the for the community and parents and that's that's exciting questions was the link the school day if they had a 2hour lunch and FreePlay um so so the the 2hour lunch was only that first school um and it was different in in all three of them but you know they teach the traditional subjects um I would say generalizing certainly for less time than we teach it here um but that's that's the approach that they take because their school day with the exception of one school was a similar time 8 8 to 3:00 that first school I believe went

137to 5:00 um and maybe that's how they you know account for that extra time lunch yeah but but but but the other schools they ended around 3:00 so the the tradition of eating there too dinner is traditionally eaten around 900 p.m. um so kind of like dinner for you guys tonight uh not not tradition like that was like it you don't you know you don't that's what you do like it was everyone it wasn't just just because a working family or someone had a meeting um that was fascinating um and they kind of eat more more it looks like grazing versus having big meals know it's defin that that dinner interesting stuff I think what it taught us in summary I mean when you look at this International test the the pza test and you

138have you know Finland always gets uh the the headlines because they're the top performing school and and and you know South Korea was on that list for a while it was just interesting to see a different country do school very different than us and not necessarily I think we always think um as a culture and part of this is through you know all of um you know race to the top Common Core a all all of these things a lot of time if you talk to a kindergarten teacher about what it was 15 years ago they would say hey now we're teaching the first grade curriculum and it never used to be that way we we have kind of grown up in this education system that more is better and that what we saw I

139would say generally they don't believe that and what about other stuff like is it nine months out of the year is it I me do they have summer breaks all that kind of stuff similar yeah I don't have that fancy um happy New Year everybody um just going to kind of give uh last time we were here was November so kind of a December synopsis of what went down at Hagen and kind of things to look forward to in January um so one of the things that really gets highlighted in December and and necessarily so is our is our music program um we have three winter concerts it used to be two um but with the burgeoning of of uh participation we just didn't have enough room in the auditorium or in the parking lot

140uh to house everybody so we did three nights which was really awesome for for families I know if you had kids in third fourth and fifth that mean multiple nights um but you know they they shortened the concerts and and was much more manageable backstage too with the amount of kids that we had um but it's probably one of the most perfect scenes of all three um contributors coming together right the students obviously are the urban musicians the teachers and their work but a lot of uh Hagen musicians it's it's a lot of the parent encouragement and practicing and getting them to ensembles early in the morning and uh the concerts are the culmination of all that coming together um and they do such a wonderful job our teaching staff uh is is truly dedicated

141our students put in the time and effort and energy um and you know Mr Andreas brings the fifth grade chorus to the Galleria and they sing uh holiday tunes for for pastor VI and a lot of spack and kill people go and support their kids there so it's it's really an awesome time period um and the greatest thing about it is the growth Arc is so steep you know we have beginner strings plucking away at Hot Cross Buns at the first concert and then our fifth graders are playing longer and more complicated uh pieces so um it it's it's very fast tracked um connected to that um in kind of the spirit of performances Queen City Dance which is a local dance company owned by a spa family had reached out to me and Mr

142Lynch uh about uh presenting a portion of their Nutcracker presentation to our students uh being about 10 spack and kill students who are older are in the performance we thought it was a phenomenal idea um they do a show at the Civic Center but not all families are able to go so it's a great way to expose kids to that kind of culture culture and and dance um and it was renowned how good our students were in the audience um they were in tuned the whole time even though there's no dialogue uh it's no flashy light we were in the gym um and it's ballet but they were intrigued my nephew's in fourth grade I asked him during the holidays how what he thought he was he loved it um so it was really a

143nice way to kind of interconnect the community and the stat kids got highlighted in that presentation we also had our second P2 assembly Avid students from both the high school and Todd came down highlighted uh you know kids in Hagen and Nassau uh that were caught using good character but I think the piece that was most fun for me is we played uh gratitude hot potato and um I asked kids what the underlying lesson was in gratitude Hot Potato so the rules of the game is each class passed around a kind of a dodgeball with the Avid students and every time the music stopped they had to share something they were grateful for and of course the underlying lesson there is even when you are out or you lose you still have things to be

144grateful for uh we up the challenge for fourth and fifth graders they weren't allowed to share anything their classmates shared so if you were laugh out you had the most difficult task cuz people took family and school and teacher um but the answers that they gave was pretty Renown I'm grateful for my brain um allows me to think so it really uh was was a cool program uh kind of culminating the year and going into the holiday break um and then we come back and it's uh spelling be time so our class bees are going on as we speak they'll be wrapped up by the end of next Friday and then we have our schoolwide spelling be on the 24th um where our champ Champion gets to go on to the regional um against other

145schools in New York state so um look forward to that and certainly we'll we'll bring that presentation forward to all right great okay that was part of 6.02 yeah sorry that's okay uh Eric do you have anything to uh continue to add to the on your side sure I don't I don't want to keep everybody it's fine I think he's good okay okay with that I'll go to uh move on to item 7.01 board correspondent uh we did get a few emails from a parent um General holiday wishes towards some of our teachers which was very nice um we also received some correspondence by mail from uh what was called spaen kills community of seniors and um it basically had to do with um taxable rates and things like that for uh senior citizens and

146stuff like that so um I was going to uh ask that maybe Val at some point um give us a response to that letter uh doesn't have to be right now but you would do that and then maybe we could just at least um you know I can read your response or have you have you say something at the next meeting to address that letter okay thank you 7.02 comments from the public on non-agenda items public comment on non-agenda items 703 comments from the board anyone I've just got I've got a couple of comments um quickly one one is just to uh know again what you just mentioned and regarding the really I thought U extraordinary uh gesture of appreciation on the part of Vicky Phillip to um a range of teachers at Todd who

147I thought uh really shine through her eyes and really appreciate as well Lori your response to Vick Phillips letter um expressing gratitude for that show of appreciation I can't remember um a gesture like that um is extended and thoughtful and extensive and really a credit as you noted in your reply to our our teachers here uh throughout the district but she was singling on teachers at Tod in particular so I really enjoyed seeing that appreciate your response thank you then the other thing I just would note is that there was a a a monthly meeting of the Dutchess County School Board Association on the 2nd unfortunately I I missed it I was in route back from upstate and ran into some snow so I wasn't able to get back in time for it but um

148the agenda was uh interesting and I I could perhaps share a little bit if I here by way of the minutes at at the next meeting there was a presentation at that meeting on Regional collective bargaining from an attorney who works with districts uh some of school districts so I'll seek to get a little more information about that uh maybe share at the next opportunity anyone else I was going to ask you Richard uh about the there some member concerns that were listed in the minutes from that meeting so maybe I'll just end up see watching it see catch up on it right right unfortunately I missed that y person okay with that I'm going to move on to 7.04 comments from our superintendent our first meeting back from the holidays uh and our extended

149time off so hope everyone out there had a had a good break everyone here had a good break um it's good to be back you know and kind of back in the back in the routine you know it really kind of came um from uh this week um got an email today uh some sad news um former board member and former board president Robert Morrison uh he's served from 1969 to 1979 including uh towards the end of his career as as president he's passed away um he's a little bit of an institution around here uh when I was principal of the high school and uh Dr Horvath mentioned that the the referendum went down at the high school that included the turf field uh the district sought out a Citizens committee to help um get

150a closer feel to to what the citizens uh were looking for and Robert Morrison volunteered to be on that committee I think he was only one of like 12 it wasn't very big um but he was very I I adored him he was he came with a lot of experience and very sound uh I was grateful to get to know him uh on a sad note he was on a short list of people we haven't gotten to yet that we wanted to talk to uh with the 160th anniversary coming up so we'll still try to pursue uh some of his relatives uh but just sad uh sad to learn of his passing he was 9 UM and as out a final note um about a month ago I ran into Corey Embler who is our

151newly hired school psychologist in the elementary uh schools and uh she spoke about Charlie Johnson who was an Arlington graduate and I was you know very knowledgeable him when I was was there and uh he was a a Korean war hero who passed away in the Korean War uh he passed away saving the life of another Arlington graduate so was kind of this just magical story and then saving you know roughly 10 more people that night so it was a very special human being I think in in the eyes of of everyone in our area but especially you know over at Arlington um and felt he was deserving of the Medal of Honor um for his actions which he never received so that was kind of a push that we had always trying to do

152that but but never really happened so I'm talking to Corey she goes hey you were heavily involved with that you know you know I saidwell how do you know him she goes I'm his great niece oh and we just started talking and she says you know I think they're finally G to give him the Medal of Honor I'm like what and then we pursued it and sure enough uh on Friday uh he received the Medal of Honor and I was honored to be invited for my previous uh involvement with it I was one of like five people went who weren't family just one of the most amazing experiences I've had and just the appreciation the veterans uh coincidentally Robert Morrison was a veteran of the Navy you know so just the appreciation of everything um

153was amazing and I'll talk a little bit about it uh in the uh newsletter uh but just kind of a neat thing for the Hudson Valley to have someone uh you know getting the mental about that all thank you I appreciate hearing that uh Bob is my next door neighbor so we'll miss him very very nice man uh so and that was down at the White House I assume the medal in the white house uh the president I was from here to Joan president just everything about it was special and then the next day the army did their version of it and that could have been even better like it just was amazing experience excellent congrats on that experience and good job pushing for that that's a great story to hear okay item 8.01 the

154board will take a vote to go directly into executive session for the purpose of seeking legal advice for contract negotiations after the executive session the board does not anticipate any further being business being discussed do I have a motion to go into executive session so do I have a second second all in favor that's 5 thank you and we'll see you next time

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.