001All right, GBA, you are live. You're recording. Phone lines will remain off. Go for it. >> Thank you, Matt. Welcome to the December 22nd, 2025 special meeting of the zoning board of appeals, East Hampton Town. Um, we are here to adopt some resolutions. Before that, we have a decision to make on Nigel Curtis. Um, which is uh 393 Cranberry Hall Road, Navig 300-128-1-28.3. And it's a decision to to board to make a motion that the application is complete and can move to a hearing. And why are we doing this on this one? >> It's when we sign this one. >> Oh, so it's a step. It's part of the step >> stipulation that we would do this. I don't >> It's just we're already >> That's correct. 2023 >> and the SIP and the SIP
002>> told us that we had to do it expeditiously. >> Yeah. And and we are and I believe uh I don't do we >> sorry >> January 27th is the public hearing. >> Okay. >> 22nd. >> Sorry, forgive me. I wasn't on the board. So just this is just the application it or was this related to a SRA or something? No, it's related to a um this is the one >> we denied application, but this is the one with the emergency uh sandbags that there was an article 78 with the town light legal proceeding. the court uh came to a stipulation of settlement in that settle settlement and I don't remember the specifics of the settlement being uh that we had to look at a new application >> okay >> to retreat the house they
003were going to remove the sandbags >> as a result of it am I right Charlie so far >> yes and yeah so that's going to be they submitted a that was >> so right now so but this is the application that they're putting they're going to move forward with the retreat of the house >> yeah and then it was just As per the stipulation, we would do this just to on the record state that the it was decompleted. >> So, there's nothing for us to review in the >> No, not yet. It says that. Okay. Thank you. I just want to make sure I knew it was >> Excuse me one second, ZBA. Just very quickly, um, we are experiencing a little bit of audio crackling on the channel. Um, we are aware of this,
004but we are still recording and live. Uh, just want to make it known. Thank you. >> Okay, me crackling. It's a chestnut over roasting over the open fire. >> So, can we have a motion to uh deem the application complete? >> Uh, yes. I'll make that motion. In the matter of Nigel Curtis, 393 Cranberry Hall Road, I'm against it. Suffoc County Tax Map 300-128-1-28.3. I make a motion that the application is complete and can move forward to a hearing. >> Second. >> Concur. >> I concur. >> Concur. Thank you. Okay, we're going to move on to resolutions now. We have Marine 51 LLC at 51 Marine Boulevard suffic number 300-179-17. >> Okay. Um, everyone will remember this is an application um the house itself has already been renovated. This is an application to replace a
005pool, a pool deck, a rear deck um mostly in place and in kind. Um in addition there are removals of things like some retaining uh uh small walls and a very uh significant rey vegetation um of uh removal of invasives and and ornamentals. Um, so this was a unanimous approval. Um, and in the matter of Marine 51 LLC, 51 Marine Boulevard, Amagansit, Suffet County Tax Map 300-179-1-07, I make a a motion to accept to approve the resolution as written. >> Second. >> Concur. Thank you. Next, we have Alapa at 235 Fairview Avenue, Montto suffet map number 300-9-7-6.2. 2. >> Okay. This was originally an application for a pool and an upgraded IIA system and a couple of egresses from the the basement. Um the at the time of hearing it had been modified to remove
006the pool and the IIA system from the application. This is the one that had the steep slopes down to uh Peter's run. And um this was a so they agreed to a buffer and um this and added a hot tub in lie of the pool but on a different portion of the house farther from the wetlands. Uh so on 33 surf 33 surf never mind on Alcapra 235 Fairview Avenue Monttox map 300-019-07-6.2 make a motion to approve the resolution as written. >> Second >> Concur. Thank you. Next we have 33 Surf LLC at 33 Surf Drive and I'm against it >> sufficient number 300-174-3-5. >> Yeah. So I I just finished this one. Um and I sent it out uh but like obviously was within like you you guys probably haven't even seen your email.
007Um, I don't I have it printed out if you want to look at it or we could uh >> I guess we could put it off or if you want to you want to just skip this one and come back to it and we can discuss what you want to do and do the or whatever you guys I mean I have the resolutions here. I printed out copies for everybody. >> I mean we we just made the decision, right? So we have time. >> This was what I haven't seen approval. This was an approval. This was yes >> the deck expansion. This was the >> deck extension. We This is You want to take a look at this and then while we If you want to take a break, I can read it, but I
008just I mean, whatever you want to do or I can just >> I mean, I would like to get to see None of us got >> No, I didn't see it at all. You >> said you have a copy. >> You have a copy of it. Yeah, just pass that over. >> Why don't we take time to look at it? >> Okay, we can take time to read it. >> Maybe we Thank you. What's your name? This is pretty standard. >> Yeah, this is >> Yeah, the coverage totals are good. Okay. It seems like >> I just want to I haven't gotten to We had a Is it in here, Charlie? I haven't gotten there yet. Um because we discussed that Um, in the second hearing, the continuation, the applicant's agent told us that they
009were removing the step, the stone steps or uh pathway and the gravel area per um what had been noted with the building department. And I I think we said a condition would be reve. So we should note that those things are coming out and that they're being I guess reveated with I don't know something native. Is that in here Charlie? >> Um let me >> did the survey did the survey >> the new survey reflected the one we got on the 19th? >> I think the issue was um if the survey reflected the removal it didn't reflect the reveation. Is that am I right? No, no, it didn't reflect the removal. >> It didn't reflect the removal. >> No, it it didn't, but it had been noted in the public hearing file on a prior
010survey. There was a note that it was coming out and at the public hearing the applicant's agent stated that it would come out. Um, we we didn't get and then at the p at the post hearing I asked did we nail down that they're reveating in there. So, we made that a condition. So we just clarify that on there. >> Well, I know. Yeah, I know they submitted a new survey. >> Oh, they did? Okay. >> They submitted a new survey on the 16th >> to the board. >> Um I'm looking at it right now. >> Yeah, >> because the new survey should show that and the correct, you know, the clearing and the coverages will change. So the new survey >> the new survey was updated >> updated the too on 1119 it was
011updated um what I don't Oh, that >> the financial statement. >> This isn't too mine out except I So, what was being removed again? I don't was it the walk? >> I'm sorry, Charlie. The There was a uh stepping stone walkway from the front gate to to the rear on the north side of the property. And then there was a large gravel area around that. And I believe from the notes in the public hearing file on a prior survey, it said that the gravel and the stone step uh pathway was to be removed. >> Okay. >> Did you look up that November 19th survey? >> I'm looking up. Yeah, I have the 1119 survey. >> Did that make it into the record? November. It said approved survey 19th November 19th, 2025. So it's >> Yeah.
012So the new the 19th. >> Yeah. I have a survey from that was dated 619. That's the most recent one. That one shows a gravel walkway on the north side of the property. The new survey has that removed. >> And the gravel does it show it? >> Uh it it's just not on the survey anymore. It it shows it as removed. So, I know that that means that I guess they have they already removed it. I I don't know. It's just not there. Uh, this is on the Yeah, I'm looking at the 619. There's a a gravel path off of the gravel driveway. And on the new survey, that's gone. >> The gravel area and the walkway because there had been another >> flag as well. Yeah, there's a gravel area and a flagstone walk
013and both are not on the current service. Very good. >> Okay. So, we can move on. >> Okay. So, and that will be reveated per the approval of the planning department. Yeah. >> Condition of approval. >> Okay. Good. >> Yeah. >> All right. I'll make a motion. Thank you. Um in the motion of 33 ser Oh, so so what we were just talking about that was an application to add about 156 square ft extension of a rear decking an elevated rear decking. Um the current is about 733 square feet although it required a substantial um wet variance to the wetland to the property to the north. Um we found that it would create no environmental um issues and so it was unanimous approval um in the matter of 33 Surf LLC 33 Surf Driveansit Suffach
014County Tax Map 300-174-3-05. I make a motion to um accept the uh resolution as we've just discussed to be amended. >> Yeah. Does that work? Okay. >> Yeah. >> Second. Oh, >> second. >> Okay. Okay. Then I concur. >> I concur. >> Concur. Thank you. We have Scott Aer at 70 Cliff Road and Amigans tax Map number 300- 174-2-24. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Um, you will recall we just heard this uh or made the decision last week on this uh application. It's for a complete redevelopment um of a uh um property on Cliff Road um that needed an NRSP because of the uh dune land protected dune land on the property. Um we all approved the house and the most of the other um pertinances. Well, everyone else approved everything. I approved the redevelopment but
015desented on the pos the current position of the shower um and the pool of equipment. I thought there would be a better location for it. Um, and we um looked for a uh we're receiving a scenic easement over the most um uh uh protected or or the most sensitive topography on the property and there'll be a um extensive reveation. So in the matter of Scott Aer 70 cliff road amigansit suff county county tax map 300-174-02-24 I make a motion to approve the resolution as drafted >> secondur thank you >> we have Nina Rachel Leman and Rowena Lumbbe Argel's trust at 39 old fireplace road sub tax number 300-24-7-45 Five. This was um a minor increase in the size of the existing residence and construction of a slightly smaller detached garage. Uh one of the big
016um improvements to the site was a sept new septic system. I'd like to make a motion to approve the resolution as written for Nina Rachel Letterman and Rowena Langume Bay Aguilles Trust 39 Old Fireplace Road Springs 300-24-7-45 >> secondur Thank you. Next we have Charlie Of LLC at 59 Sancast Lane Amaganz number 300-152-2-28.1. Okay. Council, did you write back and I missed it or I saw what you wrote? >> Yeah, I I reviewed So, I don't the board of I mean, we can still talk about it if you want. Um, I didn't see anything about reducing the temporary clearing. That wasn't brought up as far as I could find in the record. Right. It was proposed to do a temporary clearing of around 6600 square feet, I think, per the construction. Um, and that's what
017was noticed. And I there was a question as if the board had said that they could do less of that clearing. I don't I I don't recall that. I don't Yeah, that's I didn't either. And I looked I rewatched the hearing and I didn't see it. >> Recall that. >> I don't either. >> Okay. Going to look it up. >> Um, okay. So in the matter of Charlie O FP LLC 59 San Castle lane amigans atit suffet county taxp 300-152-2-28.10 I make a motion to um adopt the resolution as written. >> Concur. Thank you. Next we have Malk7668 LLC at 33 North Surfside Avenue. Malkmap number 300-29-1-9.2. >> Okay. If you recall, this was for an an application to legalize uh some things on the property related to the driveway that was oversized and uh
018to remove a shed that had been illegally placed within 10 ft of the scenic easement on the property and the uh structure, the stone and everything underneath it. and also to put a smaller shed in for on the lambwood side of the property along with an egress from the basement on the lambwood side of the property. This is an unanimous approval. Uh so for MOK 007668 LLC 33 North Side Avenue, Montalk 300-29-01-9.2 make a motion to approve the resolution as written. >> Second, thank you. We have 840 Springs Fireplace Road LLC at 840 Springs Fireplace Road Springs. Suffic Math number 300-62-7-2.3. This was an approval to construct a 1439 ft twotory house, a 561 ft pool, 806 ft deck, and outdoor shower. I would like to make a motion to um approve the resolution as
019written for 840 Springs Fireplace Road LLC. 840 Springs Fireplace Road, Suffach County Tax Map number 300-62-7-2.3. >> Second. >> Concur. Concur. >> Concur. Thank you. Next, we have 20 Ocean LLC at 20 Ocean Lane. I'm a self attachment number 300-176-3-7. Um, it was this was a >> Yeah, it was >> expansion of a of a property on Cliff Road. I think the main thing here was the the dune topography on >> Ocean Lane, I'm sorry. Ocean Lane. >> Um, but the dune topography was our main concern which we got in there as far as the condition. So, with that, I'll make a motion for 20 ocean LLC, 20 Ocean Lane test map number 300-176-3-7. Approve the resolution as written. >> Second. >> Concur. >> Accused. >> Next we have Robert Margaret and Richard Hirs at
02016 Dune Lane in Abigan at subject test map number 300-17. >> Thank you. Um this uh you'll recall was an application to legalize or allowed to remain a rear decking that was in had been very close to edge of wetlands. Um and there are some other things that had been uh structures that had been placed on the property a while back. the applicant was removing some um the we had a discussion and um look have be uh receiving a uh scenic easement over the steepest slopes um in the wetland area. um four members approved the remaining deck the the extra decking to remain want member Burgerer dissented on that and we were in agreement on all the other conditions and and factors in the application. So in the um matter of Margaret and Richard Hirs
02116 Dune Laneit Suffach County Tax Map 300-176-04-08 I make a motion to uh approve the resolution as drafted. >> Second >> Concur concur. Thank you. >> Roy, before you finish, uh I don't think we we didn't add this and that's might have been my fault for not asking Samantha to put it on. Um, >> I'm sorry. I can't hear you, Charlie. >> Sorry. Can we add a uh I had sent you guys that uh stipulation settlement >> uh last week for >> Lascalzo. Um we didn't put that on the agenda. Um but did the board get a chance to review it? >> Um and if if the board is comfortable, we could vote on that today as well. um to authorize a resolution for me to to sign a stipulation of settlement. >> Go. Yeah,
022I'm I'm okay with it. >> I'm okay with it, too. >> I didn't look at it. >> You haven't looked at I I did I was going through >> I mean, do you want to make I I mean, I can make a motion. I'm aware of the contents of it that I was fine with. But do we have the uh tax map and everything number to make a motion? >> I can uh give you one second. >> Um it is this is a this is going to be a motion to approve stipulation of salement terms. >> Mhm. Yes. >> Yeah. >> Just wanted to get that wording right. >> Thank you. >> Uh one second. It is Mford Lane. So it's 149 Mulford Lane in Amigans is the address and the tax map number is
023give me one second just loading. 300-84-2-7. uh owner's name is Brett Lascalzo and uh I had sent you a stipulation of settlement. Um this resolution would authorize me to sign the stipulation of settlement for the board. Um and then and that's it's a settlement pursuant to um conditions and a resolution after that will be drafted uh you know a determination will be drafted to be you know and I I'll send that out too but all the uh conditions in the TAM and everything there'll be scenic easement a uh there was a scenic easement reveation um and they're lifting the house to FEMA And um I think that was the main ones were the reveation and the scenicies went over in the backyard. That was the big >> It's going to be hard to remember. Can
024we say so? >> Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. >> Say what he said. >> Yeah. Sorry. Sorry. Yeah. That was a lot. I'm sorry. >> Approve the stipulation of settlement. >> Yes. So we can you want to make Did you write that down? >> I I think I got I Yes. Let me give it a try. Okay. In the matter of fretless skulls 149 Molford Lane, Amigansit tax map number 300-84-2-7. Was there something after the seven? >> No, that's just just >> that's it. Okay. Um I make a motion to approve the stipulation of settlement as summarized to us just now by council. >> Kur. >> Thank you. All right. Awesome. Thank you guys. I think that's and that was it uh for the year. >> Thank you. Uh that ends our 2025 year. Thank you
025board members. >> Um vice chair. >> Okay. I'd like to make a motion to adjourn the Sony board of appeals meeting on December 22nd at 2:24 p.m. Kur. >> Thank you all for coming in on a day off. Have a merry Christmas board.