CorpusRecord 135456

Springs BOE Meeting 2/11/25

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / LTV East Hampton
Date
2025-02-12
Location
Suffolk County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
10,152 words · about 57 min
Collected
2026-06-18

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001spring School Board we are live thank youv hey can you roll call for us for in attendance tonight is Eric fck patri thank you very much welcome everybody thank you so much for coming going to get started those present tonight here and online I'd like to ask us all to stand for the Pledge of Allegiance thank you I pledge allegiance to unit stesk so to kick things off tonight we have an amazing uh presentation I'd like to invite our robotics team and their coaches to the podium uh to present some of the accomplishments that they've had so come on up guys oh were we G to turn the cameras thunder thund come on so those of you guys who weren't here last year for the Innovation project this is their research presentation for our first

002robotics program this is in addition to coding a robot on a game board um for points on on a worldwide level um and this part of the project actually counts for probably about 50% of their score and it's a research project they give us a theme this year's theme was called submerged um and it was basically all about the ocean and they had to discover their own problem that is occurring in the ocean and they had to come up with a research-based Innovative solution so this is the presentation that they went into a room this past Saturday with judges um the first Lego robotic judges and they were scored on their research and these guys this group right here is moving on to the Long Island championship finals which is awesome good evening Board of

003Education and Springs Community we are the Thunder Bots we proudly won the engineering Excellence award for both our robot design and Innovation project this past weekend at the first tournament at R FL high school tonight we are pres presenting our Innovation project for you my name is mar my name is Daniel W I'm Benny vill my name is s quen I'm Francisco Vasquez my name is W must I am Sophia R we are the Thunder when an animal has survived for 450 million years and survived five mass extinctions you might think the species will never go extinct Until you realize they might not survive the sixth Extinction us Hy crafts have been on the planet longer than dinosaurs and survive the ex kill them theyve also survived ice ages but we might be the ones

004that cause all of this to end horer crafts are a majestic species that have lived for over 450 years like SE said and it would be a shame to lose um just as their skin Shades uh their population is shedding too um and for many reasons one of those many reasons is that uh they are being hunted uh By Us Dreadful greedy humans uh just to want something else we are sacrificing a beautiful species of animal so we can do the same to other species like wel and Eels which are Delicacies in Asia Oro crabs are hunted and sold as bait to catch the aforementioned animals but thankfully uh over the past couple of years many states have banned their Harvest for that reason uh as you can see on this graph the number of

005for crabs harvested for bait is blue and it's decreased imagine you had a peanut butter allergy and ate another butter peanut butter cookie and needed an EpiPen but it was contaminated or C blood contains L lulous Amy late which is used to make sure blood is not contaminated before used in the medical field this prevents many great issues from appearing during por crops are collected when spawning during the full moon in summer and are taken to a lab by fishermen and given to the pharmaceutical companied the crbs are then strapped carefully strapped to a table and they are pierced with a pump which takes blood Straight From the Heart when Porsche C blood is taken onethird of their blood is taken they need time to recover but it is not known if they get that

006or not because they're not being monitored as you can see here on the board this is one of our own team members Thea Quinn she has worked with horseshoe crabs in the past and she inspired our entire Innovation project ory crabs are being under monitored after release from pharmaceutical flbs our Innovation project focuses on a tagging a tagging system which is a solution to to the problems we have identified while paint is permanent our tag isn't while paint is permanent our tag isn't and this is very important because our main our main goal is to count the mortality rates and also be able to know the migration patterns the so this is how the tag will be like right here as you can see here the tag would be a circular disc and in the

007middle of the disc would go down into the crab shell as you can see here and at the end of the um part that goes into the crab shell would be a little lift so if it gets into like with another animal if it hits a rock it w easily come out and here's a closer look of what the t look like and and as you can see um if the fisherman who catches the crab catches a m as you see here the the tag would be blue and if it catches a female as you can see here the T will be M tell us what uh what the information that tags collect you might have ready but I just was I was interested in seeing because I couldn't read there looked like there's five

008different things that tags on this um so on the ones we're wearing this would be reflective tape so it could be easily seen this is the date the hor she crab is tagged the facility where they were tagged each CRA a specific number so they can apart and this is kind of one of the whole GH that when they are put in and also lip would be so it wouldn't that's very inventive thank you guys so much this great job great job so where was this past competition that you just did high school high school oh what do we have here yeah so this is one of the Lego wall Monument that we made during the competition uh we gathered like most of the teams in the competition and we made them sign a brick

009and they all attached it and it's like one one of the core values in robotics inclusion and fun and we wanted to show that during the competition oh that's wonderful also this is the a can I look closer February 82 how did you guys come up with this idea um the idea of focus on horseshoe grabs um as I said earlier we got the inspiration from SIA because she had been working with fores you crows and tagging them to track them in the past but not to monitary their blood being taken who were you tracking them with so I would go out summer to Lazy Point in mon talk with Jimmy Grimes so we would go out with him with the trustees yeah that's great and did were the trustees helpful in getting you guys

010information on the Hors uh actually yeah they did help us they gave us you guys have any more questions is there anything different about horseshoe crab blood compared to our blood so if you look at this picture of the facility horsy crab blood is actually blue contains a lot of copper which makes it blue as opposed to R for us so that's a big difference it also when it detects Andia said when they are testing it they use it because it can detect harmful bacteria so when it they say put it in like a vaccine it would SL if it's detected something bad and it can detect um pical bacteria in as little as one part per trillion it's very very good wonderful thank you guys so much excellent job Sam's here I'm I'm Max

011I'm D I'm I'm I'm James I'm D I'm Kimmy and our two other teammates that are sick unfortunately sick so they weren't able to participate us according to Noah the National Oceanic ad Administration the world have lost 30 to 50% of his SCH already without significant intervention tropical Reef ecosystems could glob Global extinction by the end of the century we're more specifically researching the impact of coral re promotion certification according to the National scientist Foundation the rising aity friends cor by not making it able to grow their skeletons according to the intergovernmental panel of climate change CO2 removal technologies will be critical to get rid of 1,000 gons of carbon according to Noah cor reef is an animal called popse which is made up of colonies of hundreds thousands of China qu as stated from

012Natural History Museum most pops have a hard exoskeleton which is made up of calcium carbonate have you ever seen the movie F Nemo and Marlin live on a Coro be according to Environmental Protection Agency Coro provide habitat nutrition and protection from natural disasters an estimated 25% of of marine life including over 4,000 species of fish like a down fish which I'm currently wearing are dependent on Cor at some point in the L ccle core re degradation is a process by which the re faes a decrease quality and function core RS around the world are currently dying due to a VAR of environmental disturbances including increased levels of carbon dioxide in our atmosphere the excessive carbon dioxide in global temperatur to a oce to become more acidic did you know oceans over 50% of CO2 from

013the Earth's atmosphere this is called ocean acidification in addition other cause of cor degradation include microplastics pollution over fishing destructive fishing practices tourism sunscreens earthquakes tsunamis and hurricanes Coral degradation impacts all of us in different ways according to the Museum of Natural History Coral extracts can actually be used to develop treatment for asthma arthritis cancer and heart disease people also depend on Coral for food jobs and cotion and the ridges in Coral can reduce w energy up to 95% providing FAL protection from things such as waves and T and tunies and in the end have a global value of 5.7 trillion in school our coach Mr sh showed us how acid affects carum carbonate and Limestone which is the same stuff cors are made of we saw that when we pour the acid on the

014LI it will bubble and a hole would develop this is our teammate um B but she is in I'm going to read it for her in our initial stages of research as the team we spent a lot of time trying to understand oan cerification and cor degradation is once we started to understand we were able to be we were better able to formul a plan and come up with a solution and Kimmy's research she discovered an atmospheric carbon scaring machine that removes CO2 from the air this led us to research if this can be done in the oceans because we thought this would be an amazing idea to create a prototype that removes carbon dioxide from the ocean like a vacuum Simi then discover an article from MCM University that discussed about removing acid from

015the water without any other additional substitute this process is called bipolar membrane Electro dialysis this technology is still being research till today as a team all gathered up in research or Electro dialysis does this technology uses electr Curren of separate dissolved and seaw water this allow allowing extracted extraction of molecules in our research we were able to find out that Cura and CO2 are two out of four companies that are currently pursuing this technology according to kapura um ocean holds 150 times more carbon than the air does Theus technology also uses renewable energy to fuel its process without using any iives or byproducts the company also aims to use existing infrastructures such as desalination PL for decommission Lo rates the company has gained support of the US Department of energy and Industry players like Norway's

016Ean two the two companies are currently working together on a pilot project in Hawaii that will remove 1,000 tons of CO2 annually CO2 CO2 does not have as large of a prototype as captura CO2 co2's prototype is currently being executed in a lab whereas captura has a smaller model in the ocean off the coast of California after finding capturas and co2's website we broke off into groups so we can reach out to them reach out to their company to interview them on how we can elaborate on their technology our team came up with questions to ask on how we can build upon their build and their design then we drafted a letter to send to their companies in hopes of an opportunity to meet with them we wanted to know what they did with the

017access carbon dioxide as we thought would be an Innovative solution to partner up with the building supply company and produce carbon bricks as a carbon negative Building Material in addition we wanted to combine this with renewable energy resources to power it such as windmills solar perils and ocean wave technology this is how we came up with a solution CS extracting carbon from the ocean won't break at a time SE BRS are a recycl way to recyclable way that sorry recyle of carbon dioxide that SC out of the ocean typically captured carbon is inject injected injected underground indefinitely however with the black of membrane Electro dialysis we are able to separate we can split carbon diox from the ocean into carbon oxygen followed by then taking the carbon and making a brick with these bricks we

018can build buildings and houses with which is better for the environment because we're not burning any fossil fuels to make them according to Noah carbon bricks are better for the environment because they compound and regulate on the Earth's temperature and makes up the food that sustains us and provides energy energy that FS our global economy after a few weeks of waiting we actually ended up hearing from CO2 cap did not respond we were able to meet with side who was the founder associate of CO2 we learned from Mr side that CO2 is a company based out of the Netherlands and also have a similar idea in mind of creating concrete bricks with excess carbon which made us feel like we on the right path with our project and ideas their prototype has not fully been

019executed but they and they docu sorry and they directed us to watch a documentary film called Legion 44 they have to have the Prototype up and running the captur by the end of the year it was really it was a really cool experience for us to be connected with Mr say from across the world we are also hoping to read to share our design with M with our coach Mrs H's friend who was an Environmental Protection agent Environmental Protection specialist at us Environmental Protection Agency he agreed to meet it with us we just haven't had the time for all of us to come together yet we had a plan to meet with our science teacher's father was a port agent from Noah he thought he would be a good contact to share our idea with

020to see which ports would be the best to host our prototype the bricks will take out carbon of the out of the ocean which will reduce the amount of carbon in the ocean with each brick created this will help reduce ocean acidification which then will positively impact the coral reefs because they will be able to sustain a tougher ex exoskeleton there will be less carbon in the water breaking down the reefs now we want to be clear that our research research shows that seab breaks alone will not fully solve this Global problem unless scaled up to unrealistic levels it will have to be a combination of reducing our Reliance on POS of use scrubbing carbon from the air and taking steps to protect our Coral reach from the dangers of human influence in order to

021reduce the aity of the entire ocean as a result of This research project our team has been has not only been able to help us but our class classmates at school more aware and of the problem and steps even someone our age can take to help to prevent the ocean ecosystem from collapsing thank you for taking the time to listen to our project wow you put a tremendous amount of work this this is super interesting um so the the seab bricks once the carbon is in that form it's no longer to the marine environment no because it uses bad polar MBR electric acid like I said to separate dissolved ions from water and like that's uh V prototype that's like that represents what happens to your process oh wow okay here is the carbon dioxide

022and inside if you can see that's where the that's where the bipol electri dioxide happens it's where it zaps it and takes out the carbon dioxide out it and here's what that's fascinating so what do it feel like when you call this company that's been working on this for a long time and you realize you have a similar idea were they like are you guys spying on us because that's pretty impressive right you guys are just working on this and like you know what we actually have we have something similar going on what was that like they're mostly excited that we came up with something like that is the adults there we I think that's I think that's phenomenal do you guys have any questions it's so impressive yeah great job see a robot over

023there and has addressed it was this your design or like who designed it who's who was the main Force behind designing this thing and why was it designed the way it is um so basically Johan opened up his computer and like we all had to make this there were four different parts to make and like each one of us had to make a different one like it was Johan me go and James who made each part and then we all just like put them all combining and then we made the robot how many of you guys are in eighth grade so are these guys ready take over from where you left off next year are they ready they're ready great [Music] job I love starting stting board meetings off with our students anytime we can

024do that it's amazing um now we have other stuff to go over students and parents don't feel obligated to stay um if you have homework or other things to do uh but thank you so much we're now going to uh hold a public hearing concerning the proposed use of the repair Reserve uh the time is now 7 30 on the dot if there are no objections from my fellow board members I'd like to invite our business official Stam Schneider to give us a presentation Hi how are you thanks very much thanks Sam uh just as we get the presentation going here so this is I think our third if I'm not mistaken use of the most use of the repair Reserve uh the repair Reserve exists as a savings account to fund uh work that

025uh par nature all right so the repair Reserve fund was created to fund repair work at Spring School uh as of last month it's $572,000 left in the repair reserve and the format for Access accessing the repair Reserve is wait so let's define repairs first the magic words here the the optimal words you need to use something has become un broken torn born or inoperable that's what you need to have in order to make it a repair and the way that we access the repair Reserve three-step process The District administration has identified projects uh that feels are needed and I want to give credit to Nancy and the building Administration and Greg coobel the facilities director from East Hampton who have shared service with they have spent an awful lot of time working with the

026facilities committee to identify projects that need to be done uh here that will help maintain this building in the condition that it needs to be in for the students and the taxpayers uh the second step is that you're going to hold a public hearing which is what you're doing right now so you can educate yourselves on the use of the proposed repair Reserve by uses and third is later on this evening is an it on your agenda to about to authorized use the repair Reser so let's look at the projects the first is classroom floor tile we did this last year with four classrooms I think or the commons area uh this is so we have nine classrooms left that have a speci this tile either the tile is asbest or the mastic which is

027the glue that holds the tile of the floor has aestus in it there's cracks you can see examples of some the photographs there it's got to go uh so we're going to do the same way we did it last time there's going to be uh work done with air tenting there's going to be laborers there who are going to show up that look that head to looks like a space outfit in order to make make sure that the asees is contained it will be removed and a separate company will monitor the a as that's going on and a third company is going to install the new tile uh when that's finished uh the second project that we're looking at is the classroom doors we have uh 19 classrooms where the doors I guess have been

028well used they've seen better days um you can't really sand them down because they're made of they have multiple layers to them and if you sand them down just going to make it all uneven so we're proposing to replace these 19 doors with new doors you can see examples here uh of how they are scratched and cracking classroom lines is our third project see there it's very hard to act as a blind if it's completely broken and so we're going to replace the blinds in classrooms the next project is actually going to be in this room if you look up you can see the library ceiling so it looks like a drop ceiling but it's not it's adhered directly to the uh the subsurface so if you have for example there's staining in one of

029the tiles over there you can't just take out the tile like you would in a regular drop ceiling because it's literally adhere directly to the ceiling so we're going to put in a new system here I know there is some concern about whether or not that would change the Acoustics of the room we're fairly confident it's going to work if there's any issues afterwards we'll address that on an as needed basis uh but you can see from stains and the way that the ceiling is this room needs a new ceiling Uh Wood panel through throughout the district the best place to see this if you'd like to see it yourself is just in the front lobby here uh it's kicked it's scratched it's we're going to here we can try to sand it down and

030that's what the cont contractor is going to do to the greatest extent possible sand it down restain it where that isn't going to work we will replace it you want the classrooms and the entrance way to look sharp so that it presents a a unified look for the district and so that's that project um in one of the science rooms the demonstration desk has had a lot of great use over the years uh it is time for a new demonstration desk it is got cracks it's got stains it is it has done its Duty for the taxpayers of Springs it's time for a new piece of equipment there uh and then obviously we did this in the I think in the second repair Reserve presentation so now we're going to do this again we have

031some additional trees that need to go having trees fall down in school property is obviously a very dangerous proposition there are rather extensive area so we need to clear that out to make sure we're maintaining safety and getting rid of the trees that are no longer operating as a tree uh so that's the repair Reserve there's an item on the ballot later this evening to uh appropriate money from the repair Reserve if you wish to do that you have any questions on that have your thank you Sam do we have any questions with regard to the repair Reserve no we did a walk through with you guys last weekend last Bo it was good to see all the stuff using the repair Reserve is a good way to prevent problems from building up and building

032up and building up so that one day you have to do a major Bond project to rectify this situation and I think that you will see that from the work we've done so far like the tile in the common room tile some of the classrooms some of the other work projects we've done able to accomplish things when they are size small rather than when they get size large they cost a lot more money and there's no impact on the taxes no and it's a win-win situation I mean what you're dealing with is an aesthetic standpoint a safety standpoint and then on the back end a cost standpoint so you know when we're when we're doing preventive maintenance when we're doing safety evaluations you know this money is going to good use uh and there's also

033things you know when it comes time for Reserve that you don't know about so some of these things are obviously planned but there are many things that the nature and environment does that we have no control over and in the absence of a repair Reserve we don't have the money to fix it we have to pull it from somewhere else which could affect our students and everything else aside from the education of students in this community your you know one of your biggest responsibilities is maintaining this building because it is the largest investment of public money in this in this taxpaying district and the repairs Z go of making that happen right thank you very much um and so no questions from the board on that all right at this time uh for the hearing

034standpoint are there any questions from members of the public who'd like to speak on us please come up to the podium and announce Yourself by the way do you have extra copies of the agenda available see I saw it online just looking for uh good evening my name is David David G and I am a resident of the spring School District I only learned of the P dependency of these two public hearings yesterday when the agenda was posted on the school website proposed expenditures from the school's repair Reserve fund are governed as you know by New York state general Municipal law sections 6D which requires publication in the district's official newspapers of a public notice stating the proposal to appropriate specified amounts from the repair reserve for particular purposes the public hearing notice must occur

035at least 5 days before the hearing date however I have searched the eastampton store one of the three official uh papers newspapers of the district and I have watch the videotape of the recent school board meetings which unfortunately I could not personally attend but I did watch them I could find no resolution scheduling this particular public hearing and directing the publication of the required public notice in the official newspapers needless to say I could not find any such published public notice so I have to inquire whether you have proper legal jurisdiction to proceed with this public hearing at this time hopefully someone will be able to answer that when I'm finished school Financial records document that as of January 1st 2025 the repair Reserve account does have a balance of 572,000 and change however I

036must inquire as to precisely when the district voters approved the funding of the repair Reserve accounts to that extent as you will recall from the various interactions that occurred last September and October there is clear Authority that Express voter approval is required to fund a repair Reserve school account there have been only one I'm sorry there are at least my knowledge I am aware of only two such voter approvals for depositing monies into the this District's repair Reserve account when I inquired about the history of the district's repair Reserve account last year we ascertained that in 2007 the voters approved clearing creating a reserve uh repair Reserve account and a $100,000 I think initial deposit again in 2011 additional repair Reserve were legally appropriate properly authorized by the voters uh to the extent of $150,000

037though the repair Reserve however had grew after 2011 to more than a million dollars my surmise is that the district got into the practice practice and habit of every year at the end of the year taking unexpended funds and simply adding it to the reserve repair Reserve without the proper legal authorization were those deposits over the years duly authorized by the district voters I do not know for certain so I'm asking the district Financial officials to investigate and Report before you make any further expenditures from your reserve account thank you very much thank you do we have answers that we can make now I have I have a copy of the ad in R we pay for when please East Hampton on Thursday P Thursday I have a copy inside good I look couldn't find

038it thank you okay you're welcome uh and I think to the other point the the removal of doubt we are putting this in the hands of the voters uh and that's what tonight is about so you know for the removal of anything I I can't speak to the past but um there is an item on the agenda later this evening to approp funds from the repair Reserve uh are there any more questions from the public on this matter before I read the rest uh if there are no other questions I ask for a motion to close the public hearing on the repair Reserve do I have a motion I have a second all right motion carries the time is now 7:42 PM so we're now going to hold another public hearing concerning the New York

039State real property tax law section 466 uh we're going to start that and the time is still 7:42 so let me read this statement whereas for certain volunteer firefighters and certain volunteer ambulance workers and whereas the law has been amended to including with the exempt class certain members of the East Hampton volunteer ocean rescue and auxiliary Squad members uh we're looking to uh approve that for them are there any questions first from the board with regard to the approval of that for our uh ocean rescue and auxiliary Squad folks okay okay do do you want me to give a brief summ yeah can we so yeah basically this is something that we've done for the firefighters in the past and now we have another group that Sam you're going to explain a little bit on

040this for us right so for members of the public or for the board if you want to know uh there are certain exemptions for property taxes that are permitted under the law the most wellknown is that members of the fire department who are active members get a uh can qualify if they own a home and it's their primary residence 10% reduction in their uh property assessment the state legislature passed law of this past spring the governor signed which would allow that uh similar program to be created for the East Hampton volunteer rescue and exil Squad members so that's what this hearing is tonight to essentially extend that same concept that folks in the fire department would have if they're members of the of the volunteer rescue squad I will tell you that I spoke with

041the assess office there are throughout the town of East Hampton 75 people who are in the squad the assessor's office is not ready to give any information about how many actually live in this district and how many of them own a home which would be their primary residence so the number is going to be small I can tell you having just come from a hearing uh with your neighboring District in East Hampton they are there are six people who were qualified for this exemption so I imagine we're going to look at similarly sized numbers the district doesn't get any less of its money you continue to receive the full Levy amount it's just that the tax burden for that 10% reduction is spread out amongst everybody else the impact for the rest of the taxpayers

042will be Minimus very small uh because there are very few of them and the reduction is very small and as a personal man I could say if I ever found myself in the ocean I would certainly hope one of these people would be fishing me out so right yeah this is something that we had previously voted on for uh for our volunteer ambulance workers and firefighters and you know these are volunteers who perform a critical function in our community and by extending it to the firefighters and ambulance workers uh this group is so adjacent to them providing an essential service for us that uh that we'll we'll vote on it later on but you know we certainly uh believe in it so the town has already Exempted uh the squad members for the town portion

043of the taxes uh it's up to if you want to exemp the those folks who qualify who live in this district for the School portion of their thank you very much with that information any other questions from the board or more questions and uh for this one as well the public uh certainly can ask questions are there any questions from members of the public on this particular one all right so as I mentioned there's an item later on the agenda the evening to approve this specific resolution uh if there are no other questions I ask for a motion to close the public hearing do I have a motion do I have a second any opposed no motion carries the time is now 7:46 pm. all right so we're going to enter uh the public comment

044period uh of the meeting and before public comment I I like to read this I I probably could have read this before uh even the hearing but uh ladies and gentlemen we're about to convene into the public comment period of our meeting it's absolutely crucial for us to hear from our community members about their concerns and issues and appreciate all of your comments while we may not be able to respond to your concerns and questions tonight we do take them very seriously and want to have sufficient time to process and research issues if need be so we can respond thoughtfully at a future meeting or have the proper staff member get back to you at the appropriate time I also want to point out that under state and federal privacy laws we are unable to

045entertain any comments or questions about school Personnel or any individual identities on these matters we would ask you to go through the appropriate administrative channels finally we intend that our school board meetings serve as an example to our students that members of our school board and members of our community can deal with controversial issues in a civil Manner and demonstrate mutual respect in that Spirit we ask that all speakers and members of the audience maintain Civility and respect for any Divergent views that may be expressed we ask that speakers please address their comments to the board directly rather than the audience thank you thank you very much and uh having said that we are going to move to the public comment where this is would be for uh comment on agenda items only this evening

046so moving from the hearing to public comment number one uh are there any public comments for the agenda items yes please come on up good evening again David would I have a couple of quick comments with regard to items on the agenda first um I would really um appreciate if uh the board president could explain the consent agenda procedure for how members of the board um can move items off the consent agenda um because uh I am familiar with consent agendas or usually members of the board if they have reason to think it's a matter of importance or significance or dis debate that you can move it off the consent agenda which means you'll have to discuss it separately and approve it separately um I I raise that because the one thing that clearly in

047my opinion should never have been put on a centage agenda is the five-year instruction contract with the high school for tuition I know that you that is also subject to voter approval but it's quite a significant matter for the district it's a matter that needs to be discussed and in reviewing what was been uh provided as part of your agenda I noticed that there really was no explanation or even identification of the fact that there is a year-to-year increase of about 7% from last year's general education rate to this year's proposed excuse me next year's proposed general education rate an increase from $2,870 amount of 27,000 all that was mentioned in the discussion or that you'll be discussing apparently is the fact that over the next five years thereafter it's only a 7% increase over

048those five years but I see that there's a 7% increase from this year to next year that you should all be concerned about and discuss number two another item on the agenda is the construction time track with the administrators and this really appli my concerns apply also to teachers in general I noticed that um I'm sorry that's a different paper not that the memorandum of agreement is also going to be reviewed tonight on the agenda with the Springs Administration Association and I want as a taxpayer on mention me make mention of two great concerns of my part 17 six sick days is outrageous in my opinion most School dist districts have most uh people in the private or public sector have seven or eight and many teachers have no more than 10 17 sick days

049is quite overly generous in my opinion also to have a contract allows that uh payment can be made for up to 210 days at time of retirement uh that have been saved unused sick days is really excessive and Beyond the norm that you should discuss uh at length next uh an item on the agenda that you have tonight item 63 is to approve the anticipated property tax cap calculation I want to make note of the fact that there appears to be some unexplained discrepancy between what you authorize by approv what the vo is authorized by way of the budget last year they did approve a uh Revenue tax revenue of amount of 33 million 900 thou, 488 however the actual tax warrant and I have a copy which I'll provide to your officials indicates a

050discrepancy of a little less than $300,000 in the amount of tax revenue that actually will be collected and will be provided to you and therefore that number may need to be revised I don't know where I do know that by making that reduction in the amount the tax rate increase came down to what you had predicted instead of what it would have been as I had anticipated and I think that's all that I have by way of matters that you will be discussing I will be watching the uh budget presentation and make some comments afterwards thank you thank you what I could say on the the consent agenda items is for certain personnel and contract s it should be known that the board for those special circumstances do discuss items like that but when it

051comes to sensitive information like that that is not uh under the open meetings law just know that we take that stuff very seriously and have that time reserved for that um yeah that's all I have to say about that were there any other for public comment do we have any more for agenda items only okay so from the staff do you want to make any comments or anything on our consent agenda items no okay so this moment i' I'd like to ask for motion to approve items 5.2 to 5.6 on our consent agenda do I have a motion do I have a second all those in favor I any opposed motion carries all right so we're going to move to the uh business item section we're going to discuss this one uh so business items

052I ask for a motion to approve items 6.1 to 6.7 under the business items on our agenda do I have a motion I have a second all right thank you uh Sam can you please review the business items with us uh sure I'll deliver 6.1 and just moment uh that's all right yes 6.2 is obviously the uh tax exemption we talked about a few minutes ago uh 6.3 is related to the repair Reserve that we talked about a few minutes ago 6.4 is the anticipated property tax calculation so let's let's be clear here the voters do not approve the tax levy which was referred to a moment ago the voters approv the expenditure budget tax levy is an estimate based on the other revenues where you think you're going to end up we are required

053by law to notify the state comproller as to what we anticipate that the tax levy is going to be for next year's budget and we have to do that by March 1 because the Board needs to make the decision about whether or not it's going to seek to put a uh budget to the voters that would require piercing the tax cap we think it's important that we ask the board to vote to approve this calculation you can see that there's a condition there that allows some deviations when facts change so for example in calculating the capital tax levy Capital tax levy is a measure of what we're going to spend on among other things Debt Service offset by state aid so we've used the governor's budget as to what we think the state aid is

054going to be the legislature can increase your state aid and that affects what your Levy calculation is going to be which will uh amount for the discrepancy we heard before there no Mal feance going on but it's a number that moves we have said before and we'll say it again in a few minutes so that we're superintendent is not going to recommend to you a budget that's going to require P the tax Gap so that's what this calculation is the state tax Gap uh the remaining two items are are you know fairly uh normally in routine there accept the warrants which is a list of checks that you've cut anual appropriation St Revenue status report are there any questions on that and then I can give you the budget presentation is that okay no questions

055on 62 to 67 and we could go to 61 thank you s all right so this is our second budget presentation we talked about last time let's remember we're dividing this into essentially three sections the budget has follow the chart of accounts that the state com controller has there are essentially call it five major sections the budget the first is Central support Second is instruction all matters of instruction third is trans fourth is uh benefits and fifth is Debt Service so last time we did Central support tonight we are doing instruction and in our next presentation we're going to handle the remaining three Transportation benefits de service so with that in mind let's just review what we talked about last time obviously we've had some Great accomplishments here in the district both academically and fiscally

056to read this to you see where you stand teachers are an excellent job in providing the kind of instruction the students this community deserve and board has done an excellent job in managing finances so deliver superet Direction with fiscal program as well the budget formation process the way it works is superintendent working with uh administrative team I sit here and the business department along with John Page District Treasurer are looking at where the state of the budget is what works what doesn't what needs to be changed District gathers information about what the contract ual obligations are best estimates the spending plan there's a lot of guess work involved in this you know for example and we can talk about this a little bit next time health insurance we are trying to predict what health insurance

057costs are going to be as much as 18 months from now so there's a little bit guesswork involved where we're going here uh District uh put that all together we monitor changes to the state a formulas that determine what kind of Revenue we can expect from the state and it's up the board to review these decisions to see what the superintendent recommending our your in the budget in order to put together a budget you're going to present to the voters in May in doing that we have some goals that Nancy has set out with her administrative team most importantly is that we are designing a budget that is going to stay with the property tax cap we very generous in District over the last two years to support a program that needed it we are

058not going to go well for a third time taxpayers deserve the respected District to stay within the property tax account so let's briefly talk about uh so the first section we talk about tonight is academic Administration there are superintendent three academic administrators here they overse 75 teachers and providing all the instruction to the students of this District uh on top of that you have really a great collection of uh non- instructional Personnel who help to supplement what's going on by working with students one onone keep on task obviously as part of that Administration you're at classroom instruction you're paying tuition to Hampton School District for high school education now have a high school program here there are three categories of spending that I just want to highlight to you um if I could take that

059so that Middle Point says classroom equipment and the last one it says materials and supplies so if we buy something and it cost more than $1,000 it is called equipment so if this pen $1,000 it is classified in the equipment section of your budget this is not always been done this District in the past but with Jonathan here we are making sure that we stay within this rule that you have an equipment section of the budget so again in this hypothetical example this pen is $1,000 it goes in the equipment code under the state law you cannot transfer money from a non-equipment code to an equipment code so we have to be very careful what we recommend is the appropriation for equipment in the budget because once the budget is set by the voters that

060is all the equipment money we have and we can move equipment money from one section to another but you cannot create equipment money from non-equipment so contrast that with the last point on the screen if this pen is now $999 even though it is the same pen is now materials and supplies and you can move money into the materials and supplies code of the state law so again we have to be careful about what's equipment what's not the middle section there is related to contractual expenses so that's field trip fees that's when you're paying outside Consultants who do work need a free instructional program uh if you were to have an outside contractor come in to let's say provide an OT or PT service that would be a contractual expenses uh we touched briefly a

061moment ago on tuition to East Hampton district has negotiated a new five-year agreement with East let me say a word about that uh and I you know I recognize that I work for eastampton school district the numbers that were settled on by East Hampton and the districts that send students are rightsizing the or relocating the tuition rate that make it mirror what the state non-resident tuition rate is you have a very good thing here in that the year-to-year increase is not tied to what the state says is the non-res is the non-resident tuition rate to educate a student but rather it's tied to a 2% increase or less the last five years with East Hampton uh the tuition has uh the rate has gone up by 2% per year if the voters approve this contract

062the rate will go up I think by 1.7 or 1.8% for several years and then 2% in the last year problem is is that the non-res tuition rate has increased by more than 2% a year over the last five years parties agreed that there would have to be a resetting of the the base number in order to make the expenses equal to what the taxpayers of East hampt are spending operate their high school and then the increases would be very moderate for the remaining four years of the contract so the that's the rates that are laid out there you can see them there the voters are going to be asked to approve this contract uh later on in May this is a summary of Where the budget is for all those things that we just

063talked about I want to focus on the section in Orange just for a second you can see oh large decrease so one of the things that Jonathan and I are trying to do here is we trying to make the budget sections match what the comproller expects the budg the budget sections to be and what the state education department expects the budget section to be in the past there has been an appropriation in uh in this ad academic Administration section of the budget for a Administration and oversight in your special education department that is in the wrong spot that needs to go to the special education expenses because it is related to special education and by putting it there it will help generate additional state aid for your special education costs it more accurately reflects what

064it costs to run your special education program and the state will Aid you on that fact so the reduction there couple slides we're going to see that it's going to reappear in special education section of the budget okay um and you can see in yellow we are now pulling out of the budget the specific equipment costs remember we talked about my hypothetical pen purchase and so that's the appropriation we need there okay special education we're talking about here is so obviously we know special education this is individually tailored plans to meet student need specific to uh the individual student the committee on special education makes that determination uh M there uh heads up the department they're making sure that students who have special education needs uh have an individual education plan that is matched for

065those needs we uh in the financial side of things do not get involved in those decisions Esa tells us what her needs are and that's what we appropriate we are not questioning what the needs are we just need to know what they are so we know how to budget for them another a special area budget that I want to call out that we have not previously isolated in the budget before but again I want to do that is going to help generate some additional aid for us is our elll department know we have one of our priz elll teachers here we have two of our teachers here uh obviously students come to this country they don't speak English they need to learn they need to learn all aspects of speaking listening writing reading that's what

066your fabulous teachers do we're going to highlight the costs of that so again we can help generate some aid for this District on that another important section of the structal component of your budget is uh guidance counseling and health you have a social workers psychologists here who help students who are suffering with mental health challenges with anxiety with any manner of things uh you also have a nurse here whoors the health of students in this district and works with local families works with families and local positions to promote Healthy Lifestyles so put all that together that's where the expenses are so again you can see in the El education sale gosh almost 2,000% increase no no this has always been in the other section of the budget we've moved it over here so that we

067can all attention to it to the state state will see what we're spending when we report our expenses every year and they will help generate additional M for the district okay uh another great thing that goes on here in Springs is your co-curricular and athletic program a lot of wonderful things going on for the kids after school I know that you have the junior high play uh I think it was last weekend for nothing but really positive reviews of how that went a lot of clubs you obviously saw the robotics Club earlier today and on top of that you also have a really Dynamic Athletics program those are the sports we offer here uh for boys and girls in grades seven and eight and you can see on our next slide what the cost of

068that is costs are primarily driven by uh Personnel costs although there was also an expense to the athletic governing body of sectional life so you can see what that is if we just keep going all right that was the expense side of the instructional component let's transition to the revenue side for a minute uh let's take a look at State a the governor has issued a budget the state legislature is now going to debate this they're supposed to come up with the budget by April 1st for a long time April 1 was a fum of everybody's imagination they missed it every year then then like a brief period they got it right and they were able to adopt the budget by April 1 I think we hit like three years in a row they met

069the deadline and now we seem to be falling back into they missed the deadline uh State a is going to increase here by 57,000 now if you read the state aid runs I'm sure everybody in this room did you say hang on it was more than that there was a big increase problem is the state confusingly lists in the state aid runs what you're getting for upk pro your upk program you have to deduct that when you're looking at the state aid because the upk program is funded not in the general fund but in the federal fund so once you take out the upk money in your comp compon that's the increase that the governor is giving you in state a that's a year-over-year comparison you can see uh I will point out that we

070have talked about in the past the importance of wrapping up uh our uh construction project and closing it you can see the building Aid is a little anemic once we get this state once we get this this project closed that number is going to go up and deservedly so for taxpayers that's community you can see some up some Downs some of the state aid is driven by levels of measures of poverty in the district like Foundation Aid some of the calculations are based on a certain per people expenditure that's like software Library tax book there's variations of how that works that's what we're looking for state aid Governor that's the governor's proposal the legislature can increase it in the past they have some years a lot some years not a lot we'll see what happens

071hopefully by April 1st let's review the pro tax cap law I lost track at this point I think we're probably in year 14 or so of the property tax cap law essentially it says that the levy which again is not voted on by the voters voters vote on the expenditure budget not the levy uset the levy Levy can increase by no more than 2% or CPI whichever is less PR several exemptions the only exemption in place next year is capital costs last year current the Year we're in some pension costs were exempt that is not the case in the 25 26 budget cycle this is the calculation of where you are for the property tax levy we talked about this a moment ago it's on your agenda uh we have to file this at the

072state I think we've reviewed all this material that's where we are we are going to stay within the property tax cap this year so again next steps we're going to continue to monitor what comes out of Albany uh we're going to continue to evaluate the educational needs of the district and see how that all fits in together and we will continue this this budget presentation with the schedule which we will see now next time as I talked about we're going to talk about Transportation benefits and Debt Service that's the remaining expenditure portions of budget we haven't talked about yet now we're going to discuss revenue and we're going to discuss other ballot items there are to my knowledge at least two important questions that need to be put to the voters need to be put

073to the voters in May besides the budget and so we'll talk about that April 8th it's going to be an overview with any final adjustments and the board will asked to adop the budget it's going to be a public hearing May 13th and then it's in the hands of the voters in this room on May 20th from here tonight thank you Sam have any questions from the board very clear no I thought that was very clear thank you for explaining uh some of the changes and the reappropriation it's wonderful uh to be more organized and as such open us up to Greater funding so not only is it easier to track but anytime that we can get more Aid is is a win for everyone so at this time there are no questions from my

074fellow board members I'd like uh I'd like to approve 61 through 67 all those in favor I any opposed motion carries at this point we're going to move into the superintendence report and recommendations I so I'll ask for a motion to approve item 7.1 to 7.3 under the superintendent's report and recommendations do I have a motion I have a second all right Nancy can you please review these thank you Eric um yes our first item is we are approving an inter recommending to approve an intermunicipal agreement with East Hampton School District for school bus rental service um this is an agreement in case we need to rent a bus for the day we recently had two bus buses Offline that needed to be repaired and we wanted to be sure that we had a backup

075plan in place in case we need another bus to uh take care of our students this would be on a daily basis and as I said we don't need it the service right now but we do just want to have a backup service in case it's something that we need in the future or at any time um our second item is uh the memorandum of agreement with our Springs administrator Association uh their contract ran out in June of 2023 uh we've been negotiating since the beginning of the year we're very happy that we came to an agreement that we think is very fair and uh consistent with what administrators uh make in other districts um even we think that we're in a good place in uh comparison we're very pleased with the administrative team here

076and all that we're doing at Spring school and as I said we think this is a very fair agreement and very pleased that we were all able uh to come to consensus um next I am very pleased to accept the donation of ail from our Springs PTA thank them very much uh we're just so excited to uh have a Kil in our art room so that our kids can uh have Pottery as part of their curriculum and program I know I still have uh different uh Pottery pieces that my children made when they were here at Springs uh many many years ago so I think that's something our kids are going to really enjoy and then I just want to go over um a few little things that have been occurring as was mentioned before

077uh we had play uh over uh Thursday night and I just do need to say kudos to all our staff and students it was really a spectacular performance of Moana Jr it was held at gil Guild Hall it was a really wonderful venue and hope to be able to use it in the future it's one of the best student performances I've seen in my many years as an educator so very very proud of our students and staff it was a pack house uh the thunderous applause was really a tribute to the talent of our students and staff our students the next day on Friday most of our students had the opportunity to go to uh Guild Hall and see the performance as well um all coming back uh just really in awe of the performances

078so kudos to all of them it was really wonderful um also on Saturday February 8th this past Saturday we had uh two students Hudson mcleer and Charlie Fay they traveled with one of our teachers Christy lamanda to North Hamstead Beach they competed in the Special Olympics Long Island Regional Snowshoe competition and Hudson won a gold in both the 50 meter and 100 meter dash Charlie won a brought home the bronze in the 50 meter dash so we just want to congratulate both of those students and also miss lamanda for uh participating and coaching these students in this event um next up for the team is a bowling tournament that's going to be held on March 2nd at Allstar Bowl in Riverhead so we wish them luck in that event as well and just want to

079mention we did have a new semester began on February 3rd and very pleased our fourth grade students are now able to participate in band we have 50 students um that have signed up for lessons uh it's really a wonderful participation and we look forward to hearing them perform at our Spring Concert then also on February 27th we'll be having a pre-registration evening here for incoming pre kindergarten and kindergarten students for the 2526 school year um staff is going to be available to help with the registration process and answer any questions it's going to take place here in the library from 5:30 to 7: we'll have an interpreter here as well as tech support and laptop set up so that we can really Provide support for parents in helping their kids register this is going to

080help us with our budgeting and with our classroom usage so we know early on how many students we may have in both our prek program and our kindergarten program program um also on February 27th our fourth grade students are going to be visiting the Liberty Science Center in New Jersey and the Liberty Science Center is an Interactive Science Museum and it's home of the largest planetarian in the US and we want to really thank the pts PTA for all their support not only with this field trip but with so many field trips we have for our students it's wonderful experiences both educational for our students and things that they're going to remember for the rest of their lives so we're very thankful to our PTA um just so everyone's aware students going to have a

081half day of school this Friday Fe uary 14th teachers are going to be participating in professional development activities and then the week after is our winter break so they'll be no school from February 17th through the 24th uh during that week just so people are aware project most is going to be hosting a school vacation lab um during that break uh Monday through Friday for uh students in grades prek through it's going to be held at the Community Learning Center on meadway in East Hampton uh Advanced registration is inquired it it's uh required it's a great service for working parents uh to have available for their students uh during the winter break then I do wish to publicly thank our robotics team and their coaches for being here tonight I congratulate the Thunder bots on

082winning the engineering Excellence award and advancing to the championship event in Hicksville on March 9th um I was so impressed with their presentation uh their memory uh was really amazing how they presented uh not reading and memorizing ing everything that they needed to say tonight and I'm so proud of them I think they did a great job and I'm sure they're going to do very well um in future competitions and we put our enrollment up uh each meeting as uh as we've been asked and just so you're aware the enrollment from uh our last presentation is pretty much uh the the exact same we lost one student in the prek through 8 and we gained one student at the high school school so we remained very steady as we're going forward and um just want

083to wish everyone a very wonderful winter break and a restful winter break and looking forward to the second semester of the school year thank you thank you so much Nancy that update is just a one fantastic example of uh all the wonderful things that we have going on here at Spring school and that our budget supports uh you know that's just one meeting's worth of what's going on our our students are doing so many wonderful things of course the robotics team just being one demonstration but so many other students are having fantastic accomplishments here too um and I really appreciate the the shared services with East Hampton the fact that we can continue to do that and expand into things in case we have an emergency with a rental bus uh we very much uh

084appreciate our Administration and are grateful to you and we're uh appreciative that we we have that contract in place and our PTA is incredible they are such amazing ad advocates for students they're constantly uh looking for new things whether it's supporting field trips and they've been working on the Kil and they got it we got it on the agenda tonight so thank you to them uh and with that uh I would like to know if there's any questions from the board on those items 71 to 74 all right so uh with that said do I have a motion or or all those in favor to approve items uh 71 to 73 on the agenda all those in favor I any opposed no all right motion carries at this point we're going to move to public

085comment number two public comment number two is more of an open public comment does not have to be with items on the agenda at this time is there anyone both on LTV sorry LTV I haven't asked you but I know you would have told me if there was someone out there waiting but if there is not uh anyone on LTV is there anyone present here tonight that would like to make a public comment this section thanks Eric just as a point of record there has been no callers this evening thank you yeah how are you everyone um my name is Casey delene I'm the Arts education chair of PTA and I'm Liam Alo I'm the secretary of the we just wanted to get up and sort of officially present the check for the Kil board

086to the school and give a little public background on where the money came from um as many people know uh the Springs area is very well known as a historic art community there are many world famous artists who have lived here and continue to live here um and work uh and inspired by this incredible history uh in 2014 a group of parents started the spring Myster art salale as an art benefit to benefit the art program at Spring school um it had stopped for covid and other reasons we were able to bring back the sale last year which was very exciting and the PTA ran the sale and raised 17 ,000 um to benefit uh the school um this was thanks to our incredible Community our families that are involved in Spring school as well

087as staff and the community so this event was really special because it reached more than just our sort of inner Springs Community um it reached artists across the East End and as well as art enthusiasts um as well that was wonderful thank you to everyone who um Leah and I are thrilled to be here to represent the PTA and all the volunteers that worked really hard on this event to present the check for $5,500 to buy a Kil for the spring school art Department um Mrs Marino and Mrs Bach uh who are incredible art teachers will now be able to expand their curriculum and uh teach students how to work three-dimensionally with Clay the Kil will allow them to fire the clay to harden it to be more permanent um sculpture and then also glaze

088and fire the clay and and for years to come people will be able to enjoy these artworks as Miss Kari mentioned um and thank you again to the spring School Community this community continues to show up for this school and um it's so heartwarming and I just want to say thank you and we're excited for the next generation of world famous artists thank you give thank you very much yes that's wonderful any other uh comments from the public I have but I'll defer if there's anyone else no I gu not Cala good evening first item I'm David G still uh first item is to inquire as to what happened to the January 31st Treasures report it seems to have been omitted from this uh meeting's agenda I'm sure there's the reason why it didn't get

089posted I wish you would uh provide it to the public as soon as it's can be made available and number two it may have just been inadvertent way of presenting it Mr President but I would ask in the future that it would be more appropriate to review matters that are not 100% before you approve them you actually approve them twice which I guess is doubly good well we approve to go over them and then we then we vote on on favoring them but just know that as I mentioned before certain items especially in the consent agenda are often discussed in executive session so they go through a thorough discussion that may not always occur in a public meeting uh so that you may not always hear that but we do look at it and talk

090about it I was I was referring to the superintendent's report and recommendations but that was just probably just slip of the tongue that you asked for approval and then has time it with you but that's really neither here nor there um I have to say I'm still very disappointed that um although um Sam did provide an explanation as to why there's a 7.6% increase in next year's High School tuition rate we have never been tied to the state formula I think it you need to query and question and the public needs to query and question the 7.6% increase from this year current year High School tuition rate and I'm only looking at the general students because I don't have the numbers on the special ed students in front of me that's a big big jump

091incl and it really needs to be justified you can't just simply say oh the state has a formula we've never been relied upon that we've never used that we've never been bound by it so I don't know how that slipped by without one PE from any of you questioning that publicly perhaps in your executive sessions you've discussed it but I think the public will be very much will wanting to discuss that next Sam's presid presentation this evening and last time there was a matter of reorganizing for the good of the community uh for the good of the district's finances some of the some of the uh locations of certain items in the in the budget this budget presentation showed that you are reallocating some of the administrative expenses for special education and it's being moved

092out of um one section which resulted a decrease of $360,000 which on his face sounds good but on the other hand if you turn the page a couple of pages you see that the English language learning um increase is $660,000 that's a $300,000 difference I don't think that's just a matter of moving something from column A to column B there's a $300,000 difference that needs to be explained lastly the public would like should have the benefit of the more detailed uh budget I know that it might not be appropriate to put it on the screen every time but I would like to know be assured that if I make a request for the detailed line by line breakdown of where these numbers come from and what specific items are included in each category that's been

093summarized in the bner that manner has been presented that I will be able to get that from either the superintendent or from the Financial officers and I do think someone should inquire as to what appears on its face to be a $660,000 increase in the English language learning education although it's offset by that change in characterization or car uh classification of some of the expenses but uh that's a big difference that needs to be understood well thank you for your comments but I do think Sam you did a very good job in your presentation with explaining how those budget lines I don't know if you want to comment you certainly don't have well taking the comments in reverse order yeah I mean just as we did last year we're going to have a line by

094line budget available for the voters it's going to be on the website it'll be uh you know presented to the community for their examination and uh review before uh before the vote there's there's too many moving Parts still in the budget right now in order to to put it out there with any veracity you know come up with a line by line budget and it'll change 10 times between now and and when the budget's going to be adopted so we will make that available as we always have always have we're talking about taxpayer money here there's no tricks involved very happy for the public to examine the the recommendations uh and the Appropriations in the budget for them to make an evaluation yeah you know in terms of the elll uh expenditures you you you're

095spending you're spending that this year but you're not classifying a correctly and thus you're not making yourself eligible for any Aid that may exist so you know we're putting it there it's no not new spending and when you're comparing uh sections of the budget from one year to the next you have to remember it's not static right different things happen you may have uh more staff you may have less staff in a section you may have greater student need you may have less of a student need you may have a greater contractual expense so you can't you can't compare this and make a simple comparison say well you know you move this over here and that's not exactly replicating over here because there's a number of moving Parts who did that you're not you know

096when you compare fractions you have to compare like denominators you got to do the same thing with the budget and so all all I will say is that you know one of the one of the contributory factors in the reduction that you see in the academic Administration is the shift of uh special education oversight to the special education component of the budget one of the contributory factors is the special education budget is you know the inclusion of that there but there's it's not an isolated things there number of things number of expenditures that go into those lines and we will have the line by line budget available for the public to examine thank you makes good sense uh are there any more comments from the public going once going twice LTV there still no callers

097on the line all right I'm going to make a motion to adjourn do I have a motion do I have a second all right all those in favor I any opposed no motion carries meeting adjourned

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.