001right okay planning board we are live we are recording phone lines will remain off go for it thank you Matt welcome to the planning board of the town of East Hampton our February 5th meeting um we have an agenda that includes four matters for our work session and three matters for our regular session um no that's not true they're all for the work session um but we're going to start with the c application and that is yours yes it is well that is yours and is the applicant here that's what we figured thank you very much um go ahead Mr Edwards my screen can you see the screen yes thank you so this is an application seeking subdivision waiver approval for a property located on Springs fireplace Road in strings if granted this project would
002create two 20,000 ft Lots both having road Frontage on Springs fireplace room the subject property is currently 40,000 ft or 0.92 acres in size and is located within the B residence zoning District the site is considered partially cleared and is improved with a single story single family residence with sun room shed and Patio proposed lot one which is the northern lot is proposed to contain the existing residence shed and Patio while lot two the southern proposed lot is proposed to contain a nuke residence toach garage deck and pool which are yet to be constructed this site was originally created as part of the Clearwater Beach subdivision approval approved by resolution on February 24th 1960 the lot is surrounded by Residential Properties on all sides with one vacant parcel across the street all of which are
003zoned B residents the project is an unlisted action pursuant to SEC and chapter 128 of the town code and the applicant should prepare a short environmental assessment form part one for review Once the seaf is submitted in an acceptable form the planning department recommends the planning board request lead agency statuses for the project the proposed Lots both meet minimum lot area requirements for the B resident zoning District however both lots are approximately 100 ft wide where the B resident zoning District typically requires a a 110t lot width this would trigger a variance from the zoning board of appeals both proposed Lots will be rectangular in shape which is appropriate per town code section 220-10 the existing residence which will be modified to only occupy lot one will comply with all required setbacks for a lot
004of its size for town code subdivision waivers or minor subdivisions must adhere to the provisions of town code articles 10 subdivisions waiver design 11 subdivision waiver improvements commmon driveway and 12 subdivision waiver review application requirements each proposed lot has Road Frontage making a common driveway unnecessary and the other requirements of these sections seem to be generally met the planning department recommends the planning dep planning board consider the following policy regarding reserved area it is the policy of the planning board to require reserved area in all subdivisions although this requirement may be waved for minor subdivisions the planning board should consider if they will wave this requirement in this case the surrounding neighborhood is the Clearwater neighborhood of Springs which does not have a consistent wooded area along fireplace Road as many streets in the town
005do if an easement or Reserve required here the lot area would no longer be conforming to the B resident Zone minimum size and a variance would be required as areas within easements where structures cannot be erected are not counted as part of lot area the planning board should consider whether to require a reserve and the planning department recommends a waiver to this requirement may be appropriate in this case the survey provided indicates the proposed sub waver is to be served by public water supply systems located on Springs fireplace road which the planning department finds appropriate this survey also depicts the location of the new sanitary system for Lot 2 according to town code the construction of new buildings and areas without sanitary systems to serve them requires the installation of a low nitrogen sanitary system
006based on the application materials provided it is unclear whether the proposed sanitary system on Lot 2 conforms to these requirements as no additional information on sanitation has been provided the applicant should confirm the sanitary system proposed on lot two will be a low nitrogen system the property currently takes access from Springs fireplace Road by way of a U-shaped driveway with one point of entry at the southeast corner of the lot and the other at the northwest corner of the lot as proposed lot one will utilize the Northwest access and lot two will make use of the Southeastern access with a disconnected space at the proposed new property line by utilizing the existing driveway the need to create new access from Springs fireplace road is eliminated which planning department finds appropriate this slot was originally created
007as part of the Clearwater Beach subdivision approved by resolution on February 24th 1960 the subdivision approval contained covenants and restrictions which apply to the subdivision as a whole and none which apply specifically to the subject property the proposed subdivision waiver appears to be compliant with all requirements of the original subdivision the applicant is advised additional approval for the project will be required from the suffa County Water Authority for approval of connections to existing infrastructure and for water services approval as well as the suffa county department of health services for the approval of the subdivision waiver though the applicant included a resident and other structures on the property to be created lot two these structures were not reviewed as part of this application but the planning department notes these structures must meet all applicable setbacks as
008required by the town code or clearw Beach subdivision in conclusion pending applicant submission of the short environmental assessment form the planning department recommends this application is complete okay well thanks very much uh does the applicant wish to be heard before we have our discussion as a board I please State your uh your name spell your last name and give us your address for the record um hello everyone how you guys doing um my name is theas Khan um I'm currently resident of um resident at address of 1195 Springs 5 Place Road and I I've been living in the area for over 20 years right um the reason I'm here today is uh because we would like to build a house on lot two which is lot 523 on C Beach down uh 31 22 um
009it would be a single residence home um approximately 3,000 square fet um two story um similar style like this uh this town hall actually looks like that uh with a pool and detach garage um so basically yeah that's uh that's pretty much what we would like to do thank you Mr Chen this is yours thank you thank you so much um thanks will for the for the memo and thank you Mr um I think that it's pretty straightforward it's an initial evaluation um I would like to discuss the um topic of waving the requirement for reserved area um given the neighborhood you know if you look will do you have a topo there if you look at the neighborhood Hood it's not you know an area of much Scenic significance I believe so I think
010that it would you know it's something that we should consider I would be okay with that and I think we just I would just also like to point out that all of the what you know what will said earlier about the proposed house needs to you know conform to all the setbacks of the of the area um but yeah if you take a look at it I I don't think we yeah can you zoom up a little bit I don't think that we need to require um any sort of Scenic easement along the front especially if you look at the the houses directly to the right um there's you know they're pretty much cleared as well and I think you know having two Halfacre Lots in that area it's you know consistent with the rest
011of the neighborhood that's all I have to say all right good thanks uh anyone else have any comments about this application yeah I just want to agree with Jen uh I you know normally I would always opt for a reserved area that's something that I feel very strongly about in this case I think uh because of the neighborhood the character of the neighborhood I don't think it's really going to make that much of a difference and uh it's not any also the house is not near any uh preserved area that uh would make it essential to have additional reserved area so for those two reasons I think and that's you know that particular topic is the one important topic here toh consider so I would wave that requirement okay anyone else have a comment yeah
012I'd have to agree with the same was this was this two lots originally it looks like it probably might have been I couldn't find any any paper it almost looks like it does all right so it's basically going back to the original okay all right so that's interesting right yeah it's the only lot in the neighborhood and the other thing I want to point out is that what you've submitted here in terms of where the house is to go and the set that we're not we're not uh opining on that at all that remains to be seen you need to meet setbacks and all of that that's in the future so yeah we're not giving approval to the way you blade everything out okay there not an our perview to do that okay um just
013one thing to point out so everyone's aware of it is that the part of the uh house on lot one is needs to be demolished yes in order to make the subdivision happen right okay yes that was the um the later Edition not later 1980s previous own did that addition the original house is just uh without the hatch and then he did that addition and uh which we just went over the line so but we're okay to take it off okay all right so I think what I'm hearing there's consensus that we do not need to consider a scen easement in this case can wave that right okay um one other thing I wanted to point out was that uh you know Charlie I don't know the fact this was if it was then that
014would that variance thing would go away okay okay so we're just gonna have to the applicant should provide or we can you know we can find okay yeah you might want to speak to the planning department about this there there is a requirement for 110 ft of Road Frontage typically but because this was two lots in the past that were merged that probably does not need to need to have confirm I have it actually at 1960 February 24th it was uh boths approximately 100 ft and which was the requirement back then in 1960 okay but even today if you were you subing this live that hadn't at one point been two lots you would need to have 110 ft and go to to the uh zoning board of appeals for that but doesn't look like
015that's necessary but if you're if you can be in contact with the planning department and just confirm all that that would be great okay and we look forward to seeing you again and with a short environmental assessment form and we'll take it Forward okay thank you very much that's our initial thoughts thank you so we have some questions to go over does the board agree the proposed work is an unlisted action pursuing to secra yes does board agree the applicant should submit more details regarding the proposed sanitary system anyway yeah it'll be required you'll have to do that does board believe the site is eligible for a waiver from the reserve area or S eement requirements and I think we're all agreeing with okay thanks for your time I appreciate it we'll see you again
016okay our next uh application is Southampton masonry storage bins um will that's you again is the applicant here Ro sure um okay well this is a site plan application seeking approval for a change of use from bus storage and maintenance to warehouse and storage yard this project includes the construction of a gate fence dumpster enclosure and material storage bins near the southwestern property line of the site in addition the applicant proposes legalizing an existing set of storage bins and a retaining wall which are located along the Southeastern property line the subject property is approximately 1.03 acres in size and is located in the commercial industrial zoning District currently the site is improved with two one-story masonry buildings material storage bins retaining wall and parking area the applicants proposed to change the use of the site
017from bus storage and maintenance to Warehouse Supply yard and building supply distribution both of which are permitted in the commercial industrial zoning District in which the site is located both existing garages and a wall near the property's frontage with Route 114 do not conform to the 15t required sidey yard setback though they do appear on the most recent certificate of occupancy dated 2017 the wall is noted in the submission as in poor condition and the applicant should explain if there are plans to improve this non-conforming structure the existing retaining oil and storage bins and proposed storage bins in the rear of the site also do not comply with the required side yard side and rear yard setbacks the existing storage bins and retaining wall are approximately 5.75 ft from the side yard line for 15
018ft is required and the proposed storage bins are approximately 6.8 ft from the rear sh rear yard line where 25 ft is required these setbacks are not marked on the survey and future submissions must include those details given the proposed and existing storage bins and retaining wall do not already have site plan approval the board should consider if their locations are appropriate as they do not meet the minimum required setbacks and are located immediately adjacent to Residential Properties the site is bordered to the south and east by residential sites and to the west and across the street by other commercial properties if the board determines it is in the interest of good planning it may wave these setback requirements the planning department recommends waving the setbacks may not be appropriate in this situation and recommends
019maintaining buffers between industrial and residential sites is in the interest of good planning the applicant should describe the anticipated use of the storage bins as is as it is likely trucks and other heavy equipment would be operating at these locations and allowing them close to property lines May permit the noise to encroach on neighboring residences currently the site does not have Landscaping at its Southern and Eastern property lines to Shield the residential Neighbors from viewing the site the planning department recommends Landscaping in this area be enhanced and the bins be configured to meet or exceed the required setbacks currently 20 existing parking spaces are provided on the site fronting Sag Harbor turn bike with the change in use from bus storage and maintenance to warehouse storage yard and building supply distribution the par parking requirements
020may increase for the site with a storage garage use town code requires two parking spaces while a warehouse use requires one parking space space per employee the applicant should clarify the number of employees expected for the site and show the parking requirements and calculations on the site plan as required by town code town code site plan sit standards State wherever feasible parking areas shall be placed at the rear of buildings and or screened by planting so as not to be visible from the highway the submitted site plan depicts parking in the front yard of the property with no apparent screening and is not consistent with the standard if the change in use results in a change in parking requirements the site plan should be revised to show compliance with this either by putting parking in
021the rear or providing plantings to screen the parking area information regarding the existing Andor proposed sanitary system has not been proved provided as part of this application the applicant should provide sanitary calculations which demonstrate whether the sanitary flow values are changing due to the use of change of use and clarify if the existing sanitary system will remain in place the site plan notes the removal of a fuel tank in the site of the proposed dumpster applicant should provide details on the applicable suffa County regulations with respect to these facilities and provide confirmation that all required permits are in place and provide cop cies of the applicable permits removal of the fuel tanks must follow appropriate safety protocols to ensure no discharges to the environment a number of items are missing from the application which are
022required as necessary elements of site plan including the dimensions of property line setbacks are not entirely present on the submitted survey and the applicant should submit a revised survey clearly depicting these the applicant should include any existing or proposed utility lines hydrants fire sisters and firewalls which are on the site dimensional compliance for Drive aisle and parking stall design must be shown methods for computing parking and drainage requirements and the specifications of drainage structures must also be shown if parking requirements change as part of the previously mentioned parking calculations the applicant should submit a new comprehensive lighting plan for the site the existing sewage Disposal system is not depicted on the survey the applicant should submit a revised survey showing the location of the existing system and the location of any proposed new system in
023conclusion the application is incomplete pending additional information regarding Landscaping number of expected employees for parking requirements parking area configuration and screening details regarding the proposed structures and sanitary system calculations importantly should the planning board decline to wave setbacks the configuration of the storage bins will need to be changed because the submission lacked technical detail a detailed engineering review was not conducted once appropriate computations and dimensions are added to the plans the town Consulting engineer will provide comments thank you very much will um does the applicant wish to be heard yes thank you to resolve a couple of things today um for the record Lori we Sorry Lori wi for land planning Services representing Southampton masonry and Katherine Tuscano one of the principal there is here with me today um so I just wrote notes and
024now don't know what page they're on okay so with regard to parking requirements because this is a warehouse use and they only have three to four um employees on site at any time the parking requirements actually go down so we shouldn't have to um address parking or lighting as a result um I did confirm with the health department today also that um a bus uh storage and maintenance facility and a warehouse and storage yard are both classified by the health department as general industrial uses and therefore are both at 04 gallons per day per square feet the square feet of these buildings are not changing so the health department and the sanitary is no longer an issue the one of the fuel tanks has already been removed um and we will uh be submitting revised
025surveys and um a narrative answering the other questions that you've brought up here uh that that remain that still need to be answered so there's anything else you let me know okay thanks Lor Bruce this is yours all right thank you will thank you Lori um yeah I think we're off to a good start um couple things that um I want to sort of discuss as we we move along with this um the one thing that we don't understand and you have to go to the site to really appreciate is a difference and grade from the level of the back area the buildings to the property on the East um there is a drastic uh change in topography and I think as part of one of our questions um I think we should have some
026Topo info on that because it does make a big difference when you're standing down in the back area um the East property line which is a residential um that property owner has done a really good job a of screening the property and also fencing the property so screening along that Eastern side whatever we talk about whatever they decide on I don't think it's going to help at all just because the difference in grade you'd have to have 100 foot trees to do anything with that plus the residential house is is close to the road um screening along the South Side we can talk about about that as well but if you look at the aerial um the residential property in the South extends all the way to buan extension and that residence is on bu
027Lane Extension so there was quite a bit of property between the backyard of the house and um the property line of um this property um the retaining walls and the storage bins um obviously the ones that are there now are movable so you know maybe we could discuss or talk about setbacks for those um again along the the east side I didn't see much of a problem um they are acting as a retaining wall as well um the permanent ones along the South Side you know the property sort of skews back so the 6.8 or that that close Dimension is the the worst case and then the property line fans off one way the bins go the other way so it actually gets bigger as you head to the West so you know we may
028want to talk about or think about screening there because I don't think there's a drastic change in in gr elevation between those two properties um the the existing retaining wall up front in poor condition I think is kind of generous um um I don't I didn't see a retaining wall I saw parts of a retaining wall so that might be something that that gets addressed as as we sort of uh Move Along here um I think the parking is is probably a big thing that we should probably talk about and think about as well um when I was there the the back part of the property was heavily used with inventory equipment material so I'm not sure that you know employee parking is is really a good idea back there there was a lot of
029trucks moving around tractors moving around there's a lot of chaos back there so I think parking in the front I I don't see as an issue um you know there have been school buses there ever since I can remember so a couple cars up in front of the building I don't I I don't see as an issue maybe it can be screened out um maybe we can do something with the circulation to make that a little better um I think yeah topography was a big thing that's that's pretty much all I have okay thanks Bruce any comments read on this no I completely agree with what I think Bruce did an outstanding job there and uh it is a visible property um but I wasn't aware of the topography change that's it's pretty yeah it's
030pretty amazing is that how you described it what about the parking uh I understand I agree with you that although the town likes to see parking in back of a property I think with this one it's it's really not feasible um for a number of reasons however the parking in the front seems to spill over into the right of way so that needs to be cleaned up I think so there something's got to be done with that uh parking in the front I'm not sure what I don't have a suggestion but I do recognize that there is a problem right now yeah I wasn't sure what to do either because I guess the question for me was how many spots are actually required well that's a good question so without knowing that it's kind of
031hard to figure that out one of the things we wanted to know was how many you know how many employees you've told us they're going to be four so yeah what was the two parking two parking spaces per employee so that would be eight there's no changing oh well it is the parking increase with the storage garage use town code requires the two parking spaces total but this isn't storage garage this is Warehouse warehous use oh I'm sorry I read it wrong so it go so it actually decreases so so perhaps the number of parking spaces that are currently there can be decreased and the ones in front that encroach on the right away can be removed but there's a retail component here right I mean you can walk in I've done it myself I've
032gone in there to look at Stone uh so will do we have any sense or do we need to do some more digging on that to come up with the ultimate parking requirement here I I think we'll have to look at a little bit more okay okay but it's not going to be 20 right I think that's that's pretty clear it's not a high intensity use yeah yeah right so on on the east side there's a good buffer I agree you know from the residential property owners but so visible buffer um but there'll be coming in unloading stuff in those storage bins do you think that U that's going to be a nuisance and maybe moving them further in further back I'd actually like to address that I think the further away you move from
033the giant embank embankment the more the neighbors are going to hear the noise I think the EMB embankment actually act acts as the buffer for sound and then they put a fence on top which Mak taller yeah like where the bigger bin is that's probably the highest part of the grade change and then it sort of falls back to that Southeast corner right deliveries I interrupted you I think J um no I think I I think I manag to talk over you for Point yeah that's how we work right here um okay um yeah so I think I I actually agree that the bins I think are probably better where they are than move into further out into that space and it makes that more congested and difficult for tracks trucks to turn around in
034and so on so it seems to me that that's probably not really necessary in my in my view um and I think it would be noisier up above quite honestly if they were further back so I I agree with that um so I think one of the things to do is to is to work with the planning department and just finalize the number of parking spaces you know I think you know we typically would like to see some screening in the front when there's front parking so let's think about that too think about it but we can't block the yeah I know it's it's a little tricky in that situation right with your neighbors there as well on the on the railroad side of the property it makes it difficult but think about that how
035you might do that um any other comments okay I so yeah so we will need to you know we'll outline the things you're going to need to do next we would like to see a real site plan once the park to really put the whole thing on a legitimate site plan not just a survey um but I think it's looking good so we're going to go through the questions which are does the planning board agree with the planning Department that waving the setbacks Jason res Resident Properties for propos storage bins and retaining walls is not in the interest of good planning I would say we don't agree with that that um should the applicant include parking calculations and their submission including the number of proposed employees as required by town code you said you will
036you'll work with the plane department on that should the applicant comply with uh 25566 site plan standard either by moving parking to the rear of the building or by providing plantings to screen the parking stalls from View From New York State 114 I think we're leaning towards screening scre we're leaning towards keeping it in the front and somehow screening as we can figure that out should the applicant specify if any new or modified lighting is proposed on the site you should indicate that sounds like you're not leaning toward that um should the applicant provide details of the proposed improvements including elevations materials and appearances we did that already do we have that well we have it was received late so it wasn't um added to the evaluation but you have it okay good good uh
037should the applicant submit details about existing fuel tank Regulatory Compliance and safety protocols Regulatory Compliance approaches for removal of fuel tanks that are proposed yeah yes right sound they started yeah yeah it sounds like you've started that already should the applicant uh submit sanitary calculations to ensure the proposed flows have not changed and confirmed the existing system in place is sufficient for the new use yes you've told us what it is but [Music] yeah all right everybody good all right thank you very much before we move on to our next application um Mt uh MTV LTV is is Lisa Lori on the line yes she's in the participants yes planning for dance we'll do total request live later it's a new it's a whole new world okay Lisa are you with us yes can you
038hear me yes absolutely the app great well um good evening it's my pleasure being here my name is Lisa Lori and I'm a consultant to the planning department on this application um it is the long housee reserve and I think everybody's familiar with where it is on um the west side of um Hans Creek Road um a little bit less than a half a mile from uh Cedar Street to the north of that and the application is for site plan special permit approval to convert the existing long housee Reserve residential Museum that's what it's got a permit for now to a semi-public facility use and also to legalize for existing accessory structures so with respect to the future use of the existing house the proposal is to use the ground floor as an exhibition space
039to hold Public tours on the second floor Limited in the number of visitors and limited in the frequency and to hold cultivation um cultivation I'm not sure maybe cultural events why don't we say such as Gatherings concerts and discussions um in the house um there had been a recent uh site plan application for this property which has been removed and withdrawn and um the plan plan Department notes that the applicant submitted a detailed narrative regarding the intended operations which is very useful for the understanding when this was first approved as a residential Museum uh Jack Leonard L Larson who founded the long house was living in the house and that made sense then for it to be a residential Museum but um he is no longer with us sadly past and so there is no
040occupant in the residence anymore so it really doesn't even meet the definition of a residential Museum so we find it appropriate for them to be applying to become a semi-public facility um and this then will also require compliance with the general and specific special permit public facility standards and we've um provided a copy of that um with memo um as I've already noted they're applying to legalize um some existing structures uh they are two containers a carport and a shed with a ramp um and uh they're also showing or proposing um some screening from those uh to the roadway um they haven't shown actually the actual dimensions um between the setbacks and the structures is is required and we're asking them to call that out um there's also a number of permanent art installations and
041a geodesic dome on the property which have not received building permits and uh we're recommending that the applicant consult with the building inspector to determine the need for building permit approval for these um we note that many of these structures have been on the site for quite some time probably when that it was just a residence before it even became a residential Museum or a semi-public facility um so uh we're aware of that but we do note that the use is now changing to a semi-public facility so we really want to make sure that this is comply with what the building inspector would require and we also note that there are gates at the entrance to the property and a fence both the gates and the fence are within the existing Scenic easement um and
042we note that while the gates received ARB approval and a building permit um in error uh these structures are not permitted within the scene easement um it is really not a matter of the planning board jurisdiction it's something that's in in the easement and the planning board couldn't permit it granted permission or not so we're just noting that in terms of the parking stalls um The Proposal is for 51 stalls um it's unclear from the wallbridge map whether one or two stalls are ADA Compliant uh this should be clarified I believe on the site there are two but it needs to be called out on the site plan um the applicant has indicated that the current parking spaces are sufficient to manage the visitor parking during open hours although the number of spaces will be
043increased to accommodate the proposed use um but they have not indicated the method for determining the parking requirements and the zoning code doesn't specific list what it should be but the code does say that you should if there isn't if you use proposed isn't specifically listed you should go to the next closest use um and so that um could be a public art gallery library or Museum well that seems to be pretty close to what they're proposing um and that parking requirement is one stall per three permanent seats or one per each 40 square ft of seating area where fixed seats are not provided plus one per employee so there is no fixed seat proposed and um the applicant has indicated there are nine full-time and two part-time employees um so uh if this is
044the standard to be applied we're going to need additional information from the applicant um and in terms of special events they're going to be um need to comply with Section 151 of the town code um so we'll need a little bit different information if the planning board agrees that that's the standard that should be used for the parking um we have some questions about the parking dimensions and layout um it's a little hard to see on this but there's uh parking stalls 33 to 37 um kind of in um a horseshoe area um and we're questioning where the backup is um aisle space for those and then there's a blue line on kind of going through some of the parking areas and we question whether that is denoting a difference in surface materials and if
045it is going from gravel to to Wood ships or to something else and you've got parking stalls just going right across there that um we recommend some changes there so that parking stalls each one would be consistent with what the surface area is but there's no notation on the site plan as to what that blue line really means um and there's also red dashed lines um in uh the area of uh parking stalls maybe 26 to 31 and oh 18 to 29 I'm sorry and we're questioning whether that corresponds to back stops um and in which case they should be relocated to allow the proper proper parking stall dimensions and finally um the prior site plan indicated uh six EV charging stations um and they showed their location um I believe there are EV charging
046stations still on the site I don't know whether all six are there um but that should be clarified whether they're there and they should be put on the site application as well um so we do note that all the existing conditions um which is a requirement of the code has not really been submitted by the application so it makes it a little bit difficult to review some of these things are existing some of these things are proposed but really to clarify things a survey of everything that's there and then a site plan showing what's being proposed and that will really clear up a lot of these questions that I have um in terms of the parking surface materials I've already alluded to a little bit of it um there is a stone drive as the
047surface material for the entrance and exit Stone and oil driveway for the circular turnaround proximate to The Visitor Center and a Stone Drive uh to serve parking stalls 1 through 31 and 46 to 51 and then wood ship parking and presumably the access is proposed for 33 to 35 and also wood chips are proposed for the bus parking stall um so we really appreciate what the applicant is doing here trying to keep the existing natural setting as close to possible and not bring in a lot of meum or you know clear trees or do things to disturb the bucolic environment um but um we were questioning whether the proposed parking and driveway materials are adequate to prevent pond mud puddles and other um unusable conditions and um we give uh difference to the town Consulting
048engineer um his memo is attached saying consideration should be given to enhancing the existing conditions by regrading and resurfacing the parking area with gravel to assure the areas uh remain stable and that water runoff is properly maintained so we're we're not trying to be requiring um very high end or great changes to it but we still do have some questions as to how that the wood chips are going to work and um some of the surfacing areas that seem to be changing in a particular parking stall um we note that the planning board has leeway in approving the physical improvements for parking and the standards for pavement appear to have been waved for the prior application U for the residential Museum and we're we're also suggesting um waving the standards or requirements for pavement on
049the site but come up with a good surface um this sanitary flow requirements um Are all uh within what is required for this site um the applicant has proposed to install an AI low nitrogen septic system and um provided that town Grant is um granted to it um and then the we'll need to see that the application complies with all the town and the suffa County Health Department requirements the applicant is requested to update the planning board with respect to the status of the Grant application uh for the IIA low nitrogen system um whether it has been approved or whether the decision um has been made um ADA compliance and rest rooms um the the site has been the in improvements have been made to put in a bathroom that is Ada um compliant within
050the residents um but uh the site plan needs to be amended to depict the accessible parking in a manner that conforms to the Ada and um the Fire Marshall has also um issued comments on the Ada parking which must be complied with um the lighting the Walbridge map indicates the location of the existing light posts um and there were two prior approvals um regarding lighting so we don't know quite which ones um this map is complying with but in any event um in so far as additional parking is proposed for the site to meet the new use as a semi-public facility um a comprehensive site lighting plan must be um provided to meet all the code requirements um it meets the Fire Marshall um standards uh in terms of the ARB the site is partially
051within an agricultural overlay District so approval from the ARB is required we note that uh no exterior changes to the main building or proposed but approval of the four accessory structures that no permits is required um now they have not submitted elevations for these structures as required but we recommend that the um applicant work with the ARB to determine whether these are necessary in so far as these buildings are already existing um and we uh note that the Walbridge plan depicts an approximately 70t by 20ft fence to Shield these accessory structures but no information about the materials or the height and all of that's going to be required for the ARB um the drainage is indicated in the um parking area but no drainage calculations um have been provided um so we're going to need
052that as well it's a type two action pursuant to SEC so no further seet review will be required and in terms of the fees the earlier application that has been withdrawn obtained a waiver from the town board for submitting the fees um so the applicant will need to confirm that that um waiver is also applicable to this application um there are some um elements of the site plan that are missing um that are listed things that have pretty much talked about the parking dimensional spaces in the aisles and the street approaches and the exterior lighting a comprehensive lighting plan um and the existing and proposed sewage Disposal Systems need to be indicated um so in conclusion it appears that the application complies with the definition and the special permit conditions for semiu facility we note
053that only 11% of the 15 Acre Site is covered with impervious surfaces which we applaud as it helps to keep the site open and undeveloped and the applicant is directed to respond to the attached Memo from the town Consulting Engineers and the questions raised um in this memo um and um we're just recommending that additional or revised information be um submitted and called out on the plans okay that's it thank you Lisa very much the applicant wishes to be heard I can see a name uh and address and spell your last name please sure Karen hog H oeg from timy leam address 33 west2 Street Riverhead New York on behalf of long housee uh here with me today is Carrie Barrett the executive director of long housee as well as Nina Gilman the board member
054and former board president of long housee uh thank you Lisa for your thorough report and thank you to the town for your support and continuous support of long housee um I just wanted to touch on a couple of things that uh Lisa had raised um we are working with our engineer and also with Walbridge on addressing the points that were made in regard to parking um the parking will end up shifting in that horseshoe area now that some of those diseased beach trees have been removed um so we are working with Walbridge on on the layout of that the red Dash lines are actually curb cuts which once the parking gets finalized we will align that up so that the parking stalls are all properly um spaced out with Dimensions um and then that will
055also as we we're working through that it will also line up with whatever the materials are and the number of parking spaces and whether that will be increased and we'll show the calculations on the revised survey um in regard to the sanitary uh happy to report that we did get a town Grant uh we have a health department permit for an IA system we hope we're going to have that permit in hand in the next few weeks and then we will get that started hopefully in March um so that is all good news uh the other thing to bring to the board's attention is um I leis had mentioned about the ADA Bathroom we did have a a building permit for that that was constructed in April of 2024 um the drainage um will work
056on with the survey and the engineer and we we'll note that information in our resubmittal as well and we'll address the town engineer's comments in his letter um the EV stations are gone um so that is um something to mention and you know in addition we we understand about the screening of the storage containers we'll provide more detail in a revised survey as to that as well um and in regarding the fee waiver we hope that the board will look at this is still the same applicant it's just a you know change in what we're asking for as opposed to the residential Museum to the semiu facility um but the applicant is still a 501c3 not for-profit I'm happy to answer any questions that the board may have or at Leisa may have okay thanks
057M we're gonna have our conversations aboard we'll bring you back up if we need you L this is you well first I want to say that uh this is a great site it's I think it's a Hidden Gem in the community and it provides a Serene atmosphere where public can not only admire art but engage with it so um and it's also an easy application as far as I'm concerned I think all the items that Lisa brought up are going to be taken care of the applicant seems uh very willing to do so compliance with regard to the parking the surfaces the drainage I'm glad the septic that they've gotten they've gotten a grant for that so yeah I mean everything is U is on track uh no issues nothing catastrophic everything is easy peasy
058as far as I'm concerned uh the only issue which Lisa brought up uh that I'll just mentioned but we have absolutely no authority to either deny or uh approve is the scenic easement issue with the fence in the gate and I don't know how that's going to be taken care of but again it's not something that uh is under our purview so hopefully that'll get resolved and we can move forward and uh have everybody enjoy this wonderful uh piece of property that we have thanks L anyone else like to comment I I support the application uh actually we have a family home within close proximity uh um and so I know the property quite well um I do like the idea of additional parking because um you guys do have a lot of special events
059there and what happens is when they have special events there there's never enough parking all the cars end up on H Creek Road which can sometimes be a little hazardous I mean you have people out there directing and helping but um no think it's great yeah I agree I I agree with what L said I guess the only question I really had was some of the higher number parking spots I'm assuming that's overflow parking that's why it's in wood chips and whatever else the higher number closer the building step up 30 through well I can't even read this side I'm sorry like 33 through 40 the Horseshoe area is that overflow yes that's correct and that as I said will change a bit now and it's going to shift over a little bit now that
060those trees that were there have been removed yeah I think with what everyone has said I think this is Hidden Gem I agree with youu and seems like the African is Will and able to comply with with everything on there so agreed agreed okay someone said easy peasy EAS easiest peasi we've ever had around this place um yeah I think just the one thing I want to make a further comment on is the uh you know we are waving the typical requirements around paving materials but I think it is would be useful to really you know take into consideration you know how much wood chips really are kind of appropriate and whether there is going to be a drainage problem especially relative to Bus Parking that's my only minor comment otherwise I think everything looks
061really good um and as has been pointed out a couple of times the gate issue is not something that we have jurisdiction over and I think you know we have had some discussions you know with other eight departments within the town who do have jurisdiction and I think that there's a conversation coming that we can all kind of engage in to talk about that but it's not up to us to address it specifically tonight so with that I'm going to ask the questions which are should the applicant clarify their parking calculations and increase the amount of parking if required I think there are still some discussions about parking requirements well no okay reement are layout it's more layout really it's more layout I think yeah um should the applicant clarify the lighting scheme for the
062property specifically for the new propos parking areas and provide a lighting plan in compliance with the town code for the new parking areas yes yes should the requirement for improvements to parking areas be waved for this application very good side of that provided adequate drainage and prepared dust free parking stalls are provided yes does the planning board recommend site plan and other required fees for this application be waved I would say yes yes for that um and on here is should the applicant address the gates and other structures within the scene easement yes keep agenc um so that's it that's where we're at thank you very much we'll see you again thank you soon we hope thank you I'm gonna sign off good night sure so Inlet Seafood is our next application I see that
063the applicant is here Mr hammer and Brian you're going to take us through that good evening Mr chairman board members Brian Frank behalf of the planning department um so uh this is Inlet Seafood this is an application from modification of a 2018 s plan approval which uh granted the following in um two phases uh phase one consisted of altering the existing retail building or existing retail space to a 27 seat bar on the first floor and enlargement of the second floor deck the construction of an office building for the marina the conversion of an existing building on the property to a manager's residence and the relocation of shipping containers a dumpster and some minor reconfiguration of the parking and that's that's how was described in the in the site plan approval um also associated with
064uh phase one presumably as mitigation um was a new sanitary system for the restaurant uh and the residents and uh what was described as a comprehensive revegetation plan that revation uh consisted of a little over 32,000 Square ft to reduce the clearing from um 147 just under 148,000 to 11 5,604 Square ft and the significance of that 115,000 ft is that brought them into compliance with the 50% clearing restriction of the harbor protection overlay District uh phase two of that approval consisted of constructing um about a 5,500 Square fot uh ice house which included an office and storage the relocation of a I guess another shipping container and uh an approval of an existing shed that was on the property um that 2018 approval uh remains valid it has uh been extended um I think
065through the the present time no building permits have been issued for any of the um site plan improvements that uh were approved back in 2018 there was a a building permit and a certificate of occupancy issued in 2019 uh that allowed the movement of seats um from uh the bar from the second floor to the first floor with no additional increase in seating um so this modification is seeking to uh limit the authorized activities uh to the following the Ice House the conversion of the of the existing building to the manager's residents the construction of the office building that was approved in the 2018 site plan and a reduction in the square footage of revation and its locations from uh 32 a little over 32,000 square feet to a little over 20,000 Square fet um
066and the modification would presumably extinguish um well it would extinguish the approval for the changes to the restaurant the shipping containers the dumpsters and the parking area and it presumably would also extinguish the requirement of upgrading the sanitary system uh for the restaurant um and if there is no increase in flow or seating presumably that's what the sanitary upgrade was was required an association for the increase in flow associated with that uh 27 seed increase in the bar um and any new sanitary systems associated with the office or the residence or even the ice houses you see uh on the on the side plan would have to be uh one of the newer the you know we still call them IIA systems but they're not really Alternatives anymore they're they're kind of the the industry
067standards so whether you call it an IA system or a low nitrogen system those uh th those requirements were still largely under development in 2018 I think the law was established in 2018 so I think the sanitary systems that you see on the approved site plan are conventional they look like they have conventional uh septic tanks and um uh leeching Fields commensurate with with the flow whether they're commercial or residential what you don't see are those onsite wastewater treatment systems that have those biological components designed to um accelerate the breakdown of uh of nitrogen um the uh plan that was submitted with the modification that that there's a a 2024 wallbridge site plan that really just has the uh changes um proposed in the revegetation and if you'd like me to bring that up on
068the screen um will was kind enough to to get both uh surveys uh set up for me before he he left so I could uh start my presentation um it doesn't have any of the uh improvements under consideration right now um the the planning department wants to acknowledge the importance of uh the of the Ice House the the importance of uh of ice production should be I'm sure it's probably obvious to the uh to the planning board members uh as an integral and crucial imponent to uh commercial fishing I'll um I probably don't need to remind the board either that the uh adopted local Waterfront revitalization plan places a great emphasis on uh the retention and even the expansion of uh commercial fishing uh recognizes it as uh really an integral uh both culturally and
069economic uh component of of the town's identity so the 2018 application uh found that the application was both consistent with the lwrp and a negative Declaration was issued pursuant to secra um the planning department has not identified any of these changes uh that would warrant uh a different conclusion from from either of those uh determinations for the for the board's consideration um there is uh this is kind of an opportunity to to to clean up some things in the history there is some some older history that I included in the in in the memorandum I provided uh uh to the board most of that was uh uh recycled from uh Eric Chance's uh 2008 evaluation um but there were uh phased approvals associated with the multi- buus complex that was approved by in uh 2004
070phase two was never really implemented there was 5 years after the uh 5 years granted to get a building permit for those activities that kind of expired in 2009 they're they're just kind of out there right now um I was a little bit surprised that the 2018 site plan doesn't label the buildings it's probably obvious where the ice house is on the property and um maybe a little less so where the office building and and the residents are um but this is kind of an opportunity to get a a site plan that that has a little bit of clarity uh going forward with the activities that the applicant is is seeking um I'm sure the most important component of that is or I shouldn't say I'm sure I'm presuming that the most important consideration uh
071for the board is is moving forward uh with the Ice House although I'm sure those other elements are also important to the operation of the marina um there was a a a 2022 approval for an awning as well that doesn't appear to have been implemented if that's still under consideration um the validity of that site plan is probably close to expiring if it's valid for three years if it if it hasn't already Brian wasn't that you mentioned that the board granted an approval for the awning but wasn't that contingent on additional revation which was not done there hasn't been any revation done and I haven't looked at at that I haven't looked at the difference in the revegetation requirements from uh 2018 to 2022 the um areas that you see shaded in green on the
0722018 s plan um are the areas that I believe are also um this the same areas that were required to be revegetated in 2022 but I haven't I'm speculating and and I I don't want to add to anything in the in the record here that that that makes anything confusing so if you need that verified you know we can do that but I I think again there are a lot of loose ends on this property and I think it it's a potential to be a drag on both the applicant and the town and this is kind of an opportunity to to clean everything up get the mitigation associated with the activities where there's a where there's a Nexus between those um activities um I think there are some questions about the ration that the that
073the applicant should should address um there were was never a revation plan um submitted that I'm aware of I'm I'm sure Mr Hammer will will correct me if I'm if I'm wrong but I didn't see that in the file and rather than just say these areas need to be revegetated it really should um you know the board should have an idea what that means um in the areas to the uh to the uh north of the restaurant where it's lawn it could be as simple as as stripping the top soil and planting beach grass in the in in the native dun sand that that's underneath it uh another area that's proposed for revegetation is in the southern portion of the property right now and that area is used uh uh currently if you were to
074see the aerial that's where a lot of commercial fishing gear is stored and um the applicant should address it a revegetation in that area impacts the commercial fishing operation on the property so whatever happens with the revation if and how much that square footage which is is reduced Now's the Time to get a little bit more detail including what that what that revegetation actually um consists of uh I think that's that's kind of all that I had in my presentation I'm going to sit down unless there's uh if any board members have any questions that I can answer I'm I'm happy to give it a try any questions for Brian at this point not at this point stay close Mr Hammer I assume you want to be [Applause] heard for the record please Richard a
075hammer from bio Hammer I'm here representing Inlet seafood and its local fisherman I also have with me Amanda Jones who's the managing director of operation director of operation she's also married to Shawn Jones uh who we know locally as porgi uh the and Sean's father Richie is one of the original Inlet families uh I think Brian's review is thoughtful and helpful I can address some of the issues uh but I did want to address uh other items of Greater importance affecting this application and I think a little background for the board would uh help you in your understanding there is some history on our desire to break the ice house out from the phased approach previously approved it's pure necessity ice is one of the most essential and important Commodities required by commercial fishing it's
076required to maintain the catch at Sea and pack the catch for transport during packout just this last just this last year this commodity and the scarcity of it for these fishermen became a crisis it's analogous to having soil for a farmer without ice the product can't be produced and deemed acceptable for sale historically Inlet had its own ice house with a limited ice production capacity this would generally be enough to serve packout operations but not enough to ice boats up for trips some of these boats literally require t T of ice is that accurate yeah we take about 30 tons at a time yeah so I mean it's huge amounts of Ice uh this limited capacity was augmented by the ice house both at gosman's uh right across the harbor which had a much larger
077capacity as well as and and also had an AER system that's what we're proposing here that actually you know you can walk the hose out rather than having a shovel the Ice uh and there was another ice producer uh in Hampton Bays with a similar dock both were available and convenient and basically met the need Hampton Bay's ice house was sold it's no longer available for commercial Fisher operations it is likely converted into a high-end Marina for recreational users gosman's was similarly sold and closed up fall uh this fall it is pretty clear the ice house will not resume operations this application was designed to address the compelling need for the industry to remain in monw and perhaps even in New York State this ice house would serve not only Inlet seafood's commercial Fleet but
078operators from all over New York that that would get fuel ice and pack out fish at this facility however this ice house is an expensive when I say expensive really expensive facility to build and this industry is under intense Financial pressure basically I don't know that they could afford this investment in their industry or if they if they could it would be a wise investment at present our plan may be pivoting based on the reality of the situation that we're facing today with without ice being available most commercial boats go to Rhode Island to uh you know just North I think it's like 9 or 12 miles as crow flies to ice up as well as purchase fuel it's not convenient but it is necessary and the inlet fleet has done this as well although
079sometimes in a pinch they were ordering bag ice from Browski we're talking truckloads of baged Ice uh if you can imagine that it's a dire need that cannot be ignored another issue that was raised and just as an FYI the county and the town have been committed to trying to help this industry and want to see it remain viable uh and endure the onslaught of development pressures that are placed on all of these waterfront properties uh we've been in discussion with the county about a new Pro program that's modeled on the working Waterfront uh Covenant program that has been used in Maine for many years and has been an important tool to ensure that the water the working Waterfront uh of their state remains viable and available to their commercial Fisheries it's sort of like
080Farmland protection efforts with agricultural development right purchases to preserve Farm line Farm Lan and it's an effort we should all applaud and hopefully there's a m uh a way to make this work with the county in the town to have this Marina restricted in a manner to support commercial fishing as well as its vessels uh in perpetuity it's an interesting idea the relevance of this does sort of relate to one item in the memo there was a prior subdivision application on this property uh that was suggested that it be withdrawn I'm frankly not even aware what the application proposed but if if we do succeed in getting to uh the point that we have a working Waterfront Covenant uh and proposal that's viable it may require that we subdivide the lot or as I understand
081at the Covenant uh that the county is approving would would affect property solely related to commercial fishing uh and this property has a myriad of other uses including the restaurant a proposed manager residents uh as well as a retail store and when I met with the county they said yeah we would want to cut those off so that you know because we can't use our Waterfront easement funds for something that would have housing or retail basically it's solely for this purpose uh whether it's partition subdivision I don't know but it's something that we might be back in front of the board for in partnership with the county and the town I hope you support these efforts they frankly make a lot of sense to me um if you're going to spend public money to protect
082something it should have critical mass uh both in terms of what you're purchasing and infrastructure to support it uh so that it'll continue to serve the industry and not be duded with other interests the second financial crisis we're dealing with is the current state of the montalk inlet it's actually in the paper today uh frankly the strolling has gotten so bad that the inlet Fleet of larger boats uh cannot access Lake Monto at present and neither can any other vessel I think they said that it sh down to three foot depth three- foot depth is not a whole lot of Dept for any vessel um so none of these boats can access this facility to pack out obtain fuel get ice or obtain transi and accommodations this this in critically important Revenue stream and we're
083in a very important Revenue stream time of year the commercial fishing is probably more robust this time of year than it is in the summer months um is basically unavailable to mon talk Inlet Seafood uh at present uh they're talking about with the article I read or what I saw on news2 said oh they're trying to get it by the end of the month well you know that's three or four five months of the most important time of year for these commercial fishermen to actually make their uh their nut basically um it it's going to be unavailable to them at present and this is the single largest Seafood packout facility in New York state normally devastating blow to these owners in their bottom line and frankly with spending millions of dollars on infrastructure to support
084an industry without any Revenue at present is a really tough Prospect this is a very valuable time of year that's been basically runer valueless by by conditions outside of their controls all these items weighed on my mind when I first reviewed this memo but I can tell you we will try to resolve any issues raised in the memo uh but I can't commit right now to pursuing this application unless and until something changes they just don't have the financial wherewithal to make this happen to address some of the issues in the menu clearly we'll submit a revised site plan for reasons I can't explain and I will blame Joel because he is unavailable to be here tonight uh the proposed ice house uh and some of the labeling was deleted from the plans that we
085submitted that showed the revised clearing it was just an oversight and we can uh relabel that you know I do think some of the other important things we're proposing here is the manager residence that's allowed in Marinas and it's a no-brainer in this town I mean the affordable housing crisis is ridiculous right now uh and to be able to house employees that will be able to maintain the security of this operation and and oversee the delivery of fish which doesn't happen 9 to5 you know these boats come in when they come in it's certainly something that is absolutely necessary uh on the lighting everything is proposed to be complying with the town code we'll get you co cut sheets and photometrics to demonstrate this there's very limited lighting proposed on the office and the residence
086probably just sconces outside the outside doors uh the Ia septics yes we are proposing uh IA septics for the manager's residence as well as the office uh uh I did meet with the building inspector and went over this and and you know he orally said yes this this will abide R code uh the deck that we is referenced on the survey is actually a floating dock Amanda might know more about it than I do it was pulled up and it'll just be removed it's not really a dock a dock and I didn't have a chance to uh or a deck I didn't have a chance to ask the surve but I guess it probably looks more like a a deck when it's sitting on land than it does a floating dock even though it might
087have floating on it uh um I I think we can come up with a proposal to conform the clearing to the C basically we're trying to restore it back to when the certificate occupancy was issued in a manageable manner or consistent with the valid concerns that Brian expressed basically if the storage needs in one area the commercial gear are important uh and need to be protected and that might become more critically important as we evaluate how we're going to uh uh talk about a potential protection effort we can offset this in other areas that can accommodate the square footage comfortably I I think Brian is correct I don't know if there has ever been a reveg plan but most of the site is so native soils and some and as a matter of fact if
088you look at some of the old Aerials most of this area is bare sand you know before any of this happen so it's just a a simple you know our plan would be to you know plant beach grass on this but we will get it planed together for the areas and and and have a a plan that will conform better to what the concerns were raised tonight uh I hope we continue down this path I just don't have a definitive answer based on all the Challen ches they're facing right now thanks Andy thanks Andy my heart breaks for what the commercial fishing industry is going through and I certainly support any measures that would uh support their continued livelihood and I think the Ice House you know you noted that the one in the Hampton
089Bays has been sold to a for Marina use that's terrible it's you know I think commercial fishing is one of the things that makes this area special uh so I'm I'm in fully support anything that we could do to bring this uh hle into compliance so you could do what you want with regard to the uh Ice House the manager's residence the manager's office I have no problem with that and I totally am encouraging and supporting all of that the problem for me is that like you said this property should really be subdivided into two different Parcels one is the one that you talked mostly about tonight where you have the ice house and everything else with regard that supports the fishing and the other is the restaurant and the restaurant concerns me because I
090think that there should be an IA system for that restaurant I think the vegetation should be increased along the area of the restaurant and I think it's in violation of what the what the restaurant should be used for the number of tables and so forth so I think all of that needs to be corrected well you you TW filter your head but uh what what is in the first floor of the restaurant right now which is labeled as retail space I believe there was a site plan and unfortunately Joel isn't here but they moved eight bar seats into the first floor of the restaurant which when I've been there that's exactly what is there it's a very lightly used accessory bar that they have downstairs I haven't heard any allegations that the you know the
091seing here is not compliant I go to in the sea food probably twice a month maybe three times a month it's one of the only things open in on talk and I haven't seen any any or observed or heard any allegation that they're not complying with there two weeks ago I had dinner there I like to go to the inlet myself and I I don't want the inlet restaurant to go away but yeah there's that fully stacked permanent bar with eight seats and every square inch of the rest of the room had tables I would you know guess that they seated maybe 30 30 people so that's that's not what you make it out to be it's so I don't I don't know that that's not compliant with their seating restrictions uh to be honest
092well it's never on all the applications that I've seen and all the documents that I've seen I've never seen that layout prescribed but anyway I you know the problem that I have is I want to be I want to make this process easy to have you get what you want with regard to the Ice House the manager residence and all of that on the south side of the property but I also think that we need to clear up the entire parcel which unfortunately is one parcel which includes the restur and I think you know we should be honest about what's going on there and I think an system for that area is necessary as well those those are my thoughts Ju Just for the boards I I did when we were expand talking about having
093the the downstairs as part of uh you know an expansion of it we priced the IIA system is somewhere around $800,000 just so that the board's aware of that so uh I mean that is probably nothing that can be offered unless there were substantial Town grants in any event uh we are not increasing the The Proposal that that we're in front of you from does not increase seating doesn't increase flow other than the two structures that we're talking about here the office facility and the uh manager C cottage which in fact will have an IA system there are also tables uh out in the back of the restaurant that's never been approved either so but any you know I I hate to I hate to bring these things up because like I said I'm really
094torn here because I want to I want to do whatever is necessary to get approval for the ice house and all that other stuff on the south side of the property and I'm sorry that this stuff with the restaurant is going on but I think it's important we can't just let it go we can't just dismiss it I think if we're going to have compliance the entire property need to be in compliance other thoughts around the table I have thoughts um I agree with Lou um and many of the the points that he just brought up I do think it probably is an easy solution for us to figure out what they're allowed to have so I'm sure Amanda has you know what the approved you know number of seats is for the for the
095restaurant and I think the two the two floors are one restaurant am I yeah I did want to say um come please and introduce yourself hi Amanda Jones thanks for having me tonight I did want to say that so the upstairs of the restaurant's closed so we're not increasing our seating it's just too expensive to heat upstairs in the winter so in order for us to be open in the winter we can only be open downstairs so we we just brought some tables from Upstairs Downstairs so we didn't increase any seating if anything it's a lot less seating than if we were to be open upstairs we so those tables are going to be removed once you open upstairs correct stairs is a waiting area in the summer so the eight seats at the bar
096and then the ader tables that you're talking about out outside are not serviced so they're just for people to come sit when they're waiting for a table because we don't take reservations sometimes we're on a three-hour wait in the summer so it gives somewhere for people to sit and wait well I think we need to have all that's one of the problems that we had with this application is that a lot of this information is not delineated so we you know we we don't know what's going on yeah I'm here to tell you any questions you have you can but honestly I don't think that the commercial fishing industry is in such dire need that if we have to wait six months or we have to wait a year or even five months to go
097through this permitting process I don't think that will still be there we're we're in I don't want I don't want that to happen like I'm just being honest put obstacles in front of you I'm here to you know right thing we're The Last of a Dying Breed here and we're we're uh we're going down pretty quick so well I don't want you to do that yeah it's unfortunate it's because of the dredging um it's about 5 months overdue and five months of no Revenue would do that to any business so unfortunately um that's just where we're at but yeah if we have to wait all this time to do all these things which we want to be in compliance and we want to do all these things but we don't have that time so I
098think we we we spoke a little bit earlier um with the planning department about kind of breaking out the ice house and the um manager you know residents and office as kind of a like while you're working on getting in compliance with the other stuff moving forward with this and I'm wondering how we how we can because I it's so important I mean it's you need the we appreciate and you've been talking about this excuse me you and I have talked about this you know two years ago yeah um so I I feel like we really do need to move quickly yeah that's I appreciate that yeah thank you so I just want to be clear about something you said earlier Andy you know the financial feasibility of the ice house project did I thought
099I understood that you said that you would might need to withdraw that aspect of it did you say that well we're going to pursue it but I don't know that we could fund it is got all right as of today I don't so we're still moving ahead here we're going to try because with if we don't try we die on the hell basically at this point so okay any other thoughts guys no no okay I I did also want to say that being in compliance I I wasn't aware that we're not in compliance uh other than the fact that hey we're asking for these improvements and if we revise the Rev or whatever it would be a condition of the approval uh so yeah we would be in compliance as part of this process if
100the board moves quickly to approve the ice house with the and all that and then say okay well you have to install the AA for the the two new structures revegetate prior to getting your Co or whatever it is we're fully in compliance at that point so we're not in violation tonight in front of you there are some loose ends that have been uh created over the years but in terms of the actual operations there's no outstanding violation we're here to clear up we just need this structure uh approved so that can maintain our commercial fishing I mean one thing we don't I don't think that we have is a site plan that actually depicts exactly what's there labeled right yeah and you know has you know the redge that moment it was I think
101Dan was just trying to print it at w wallbridge because he just had to put the materials back together it still might be cleanest for us to try to compartmentalize this you know um and I'm not exactly certain how the planning department would move ahead with that maybe you can share some insight into that Brian I don't think it qualifies for a minor site plan B well I mean this is a modification there there's a there's a in theory I I don't know what would stop them from getting a building permit for the ice house tomorrow there might be some some requisites associated with the 18 um site plan that were required to get a prior to a building permit but I I don't recall that off hand so I I think the bottom line
102is just making clear what what construction is under consideration going forward in the short term you know site plan uh approval is valid for three years without an extension so whatever is going to be pursued this year or even the next year get that on a site plan if there's no changes to the restaurant then the then the sanitary system for the for the uh restaurant shouldn't be on the S plan that that sanitary configuration wouldn't be eligible for a building permit now anyway cuz it's it's a conventional system the same with the um sanitary systems that you see on the plan now so I think it's really just a matter of um getting an an updated site plan that reflects what um the Proprietors are looking to do in the short term and then
103modifying your mitigation accordingly whether that's I think it's modifying to get rid of the phase that I think that was phase two was it that's kind of what this about so well actually there's more proposed that we're part of phase two exactly and we don't want not this is not a pH thing anymore you don't want to have to do all of the stuff that was corre FOC the Ice House the manager building okay and and this you know I'm just speaking for myself this should be pretty easy to get back on the planning board's agenda once we you know we probably you know if there wasn't a glitch in the site planine we'd probably be able to do a little bit more I do have the the the I'm sure you've seen it the
104the 2024 survey if you want her to approve something tonight you really don't have anything that you can approve cuz there's nothing that shows these buildings on on there yeah yeah they're right there they're right there on the uh on the side plan the The Ice House I assume the dark green building in the middle is the manager's office yeah here right and this is the res that's getting converted to a resident these are the three structures that the applicant is is talking about some of the stuff is is not applicable and you know the stuff with the restaurant and so the only the only thing that you don't want to do that you're proposing not to do which was approved in Phase One and phase two is the alteration of the retail space downstairs
105to a 27 seat bar right because we can't we did trigger the IIA we couldn't we can't so that's the only item that you're you're proposing not to go forward with there's a little bit more according according to Joel's Joel's letter any you know they're minor items again the um the stuff of the uh the changes to the restaurant were the were the biggest uh the reconfiguration of the parking shipping containers dumpsters stuff like that is all um pretty nickel and D stuff the basic the big item is the downstairs of the restaurant Turning that into a 27 seat B that's out which would have required a system for the restaurant those are the two big things that are not we're not going forward with so what you're saying Brian is that the rest of
106it has been approved with regard to the Ice House the manage his residence and so forth and all it needs now is a building permit unless there were any prerequisites to getting a building per permit that the um planning board had to sign off on but I I didn't see that in the in the conditions of approval but there's a right now this approval is tied to kind of some you know the changes to the restaurant and and again those septic systems wouldn't be eligible for approval from the health department now anyway right so if we decide tonight that that we approve going forward with the southide of the property and get a promise from the applicant that they'll resubmit a survey which will delineate and itemize everything what is supposed to happen yeah so
107essentially yes I will be able to bring a survey to you that shows everything clearly labeled what we're proposing and that's the extent of our construction I did want to point out on the IIA system in 2018 that was approved by the planning board two months later the town adopted the IIA it was it was literally with within months that that that approval the town board changed the code and that's when the IIA system became part of the uh the to yes that's correct so so when you guys approved that we had existing capacity in it everything was cop athetic we got it and then the town changed the code and now we no longer complied that's when we priced it out and said wait $850,000 for 22 seats or whatever it's not even worth
108it basically so that's why the restaurant has stayed static in compliance with their um thing but yes I will be able to get you the survey that shows just the Ice House the manager residence you know where the sanitaries are going and and and also the clearance numbers and the clear exactly it we'll modify the clearing please yeah maybe just a new narrative just that you know kind of clarifies you know where we're at because there's you know there a lot of moving Parts here over a long period of time so I just a crisp narrative I remember I worked for the to when this was first approved uh way back when so that was a yeah that was a while not that long ago all right uh yeah thank you so I think we
109know where we're going what we're doing what we need next uh but the questions are does the planning board agree that the proposed modification does not require the modification of the secret determination and remains consistent with the lwrp local Waterfront metalization yes does the board want to require a site plan revised to depict only the structures in parking seeking authorization for construction and the locations required to be reated in the approval I say that's a yes to the revised site plan clearly label proposed buildings their uses include locations and configurations of sanitary systems that comply with the health department regulations yes yes should the applicant submit additional lighting detail for the office and residents a yes does a planning board the applicant to address the 150q foot deck or dock in the location proposed to
110remain oh that's different remain cleared south of the restaurant and explore other methods of reducing clearing on the property that's go I think that's a deck dock yes uh should the board formally declare the approval of the 2004 Phase 2 improvements formally extinguished should the board require the applicant to formally withdraw the 2009 subdivision and modification as requested in 2018 I think we need more direction from the planning department I think we do I understand where this is coming from and I say I I don't know if like I'm allowed to talk when you're going no talk please I'm sorry I just just and I I'm sorry I left this out before in extinguishing that subdivision there is nothing you know whether you can consider it withdrawn abandoned denied without prejudice there is nothing that
111would prevent the applicant from for reapplying for any of that in the future if there is going to be a subdivision um of the nature that Andy described when when he was up here I don't know how much of what's on that 2009 plan is applicable anyway I don't know how much value there is from having these open except it just makes sorting through the history here um cumbersome it turns a marathon into a potato sa I think that goes to clear clearing things up yeah so that that was the reason of the suggestion there's nothing there's nothing intended to be punitive or judgmental about it at all it it's just what's open on the property what is the relevant history whenever stuff happens in the future in the interest of clearing up the story
112I think the answer is yes right wipe the Sligh clean wipe the SL wait all right that's all we've got thank you very much thank you guys all right see we have a couple more things yeah you know I'll take yours right so we have an extension of time I'm not sure what this was assigned to me but okay um in the matter of the application of this gelli minor subdivision SE County tax map 3-19-17 18 and 22 extension of time I have read the resolution and call for its adoption second second all in favor pass and carried 6 Z okay and then we have some boards of review to take care of we have a few of [Music] them the first is Stephen Allen and Kyle Allen for building permit on the premises located
113at 9 o clear Street in Springs block 23 Lots 1 to 5 and 31 to35 map 445 urp 97 in sp-11 in suffa County tax map 300- 62-4 d3.1 uh and this is to secure Road improvements uh required regarding this building permit and the undertaking will be the amount of $20,000 uh these requirements shall be subject to review one year from the date of this resolution for January 22nd 20126 I have read this Board review and call for its adoption than all in favor okay 6 z uh the second is also Stephen Allen and Kyle Allen for building permit is this a repeat it is JMP oh yeah yeah why there two of those okay sorry JMP Surfside LLC Evan silis for a building permit at 117 Fairview Avenue in Monto block 237a lot 7
114map 101 9 urp 34 in mn-6 and suff County tax map 300-1 19-6 -1 uh this is for road work uh improvements required and the undertaking is in the amount of $5,250 I have read this uh resolution and call for its adoption second is that it minutes that's it on the yeah that's it on Boards of review yes uh I have read the minutes they are excellent thorough and I call for their adoption second all in favor all right all in favor you um I make the motion to excellent great let's say all in favor of adjourning