001Springs Boe we are live and being recorded thank you thank you uh loc call looll call we have in attendance tonight we have Patrick brafield Kate sarus and der Quin you we just got exact session we now go into a public meeting we set up for pledge of allegiance motion to go make a motion now motion to go to leave executive session oh a motion to leave executive session I have a motion motion all in favor all right there we go P Pat debut and I just you got a she up my memory to the flag United States of America to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible liy and justice for i' like to this point take moment silence back p thank you we have public comment and uh agenda
002board uh agenda uh items only anybody have any comments we have no callers on the line as well thank you we'll go to consent agenda I like motion to approve items 3.2 3.8 to consent agenda a motion all in favor opposed C the business right as motion to approve items 4.1 to 4.8 on the business items agenda have a motion all in favor post you want to go into that little detail please um we'll start off we have our regular um warrant claims out report Treasures report we have our November and December special education PSU reports and CP report um I'd like to highlight the budget transfers um we finally have all the teachers in the correct categories um so we're now realloc reallocating the budget to make sure it fits the spot a key
003highlight is is we're now reporting um teachers in lines where we're eligible to get Aid on them um so we could possibly have an increas in Aid in the future years now that we're reporting teachers um probably based on what they um teach um we have as well um r um divis will come in and do a property and insurance valuation in fiscal inventory count it takes a day or two they'll come in and go through every closet to make sure we have every asset that we claim we have um this is at no cost to the district um our insurance company pays for it and it also helps because um you typically see a lot of things getting disposed of as we no longer have them so also help reduce costs for insurance as
004we no longer going to pay insurance for ITP don't have um the last thing on the list is um your rental agreement for Guild Hall um the Middle School Musical um they're going to be lucky enough to uh hopefully be performing there this year to go back all right um and I think that's really great it's um it's a great theater the kids are very excited to be there um and to be performing there um and I think it's going to be a great show where we do the middle school musicals before just on risers school things change and then we we got back is a very nice venue yeah and they're going to be providing all of the lights and audio and all of that um which is um a great benefit to us
005because then we don't have to worry about it yeah that's f the kids I know the kids are all very excited all different feeling yeah that great anything else anybody have questions I guess Sam's gonna give his presentation on a budget on the first presentation he okay all right great all right uh guess I'll stand over there the risk of being seen on all right so we're going to do a first of our three budget presentations tonight we have a a great all right so go ahead uh so it's always nice to start off with accomplishments are um academically and fiscally I don't need to read the slide to you you can see what it says the district is in great shape under your new superintendent leadership we've had some really excellent uh results academically
006uh fiscally under Nancy and Jonathan's direction we have taken care of a number of projects through the repair Reserve you've entered into a number of Municipal intermunicipal agreements which are saving the taxpayers money and you are also now off the fiscal stress list that the state com controller put you on last year so I think in general for both academic and fiscal reasons this district is moving in a great Direction I do just need to mention those scores are from last year so we also need to give uh credit to all the people that really worked hard last year yes disc where they are um so let's talk about the budget formation process so here's how uh we're going to work uh so the District administration has consulted with the teachers and staff to determine
007what the programmatic needs of the district are for next year your goals where we wish to see the district go you've looked at Administration has looked at the value and efficacy of the programs to see what's working what needs to be changed what needs to be improved what needs to be increased um District administration and then working to gather the contractual price and the obligations best estimates this is an ongoing process and we're going to talk about this as an example a little bit later so just keep in your head that gathering this pricing information is part of an ongoing moving Target uh we're going to monitor changes in state aid formulas to determine how we can formulate a plan uh there's uncertainty this I I obviously the governor has put forward a spending plan
008at this point how that ends up impacting in its finality when the legislature enacts its budget is a question mark you are reviewing these you as the board are reviewing these presentations as they come along determine that they represent the proper direction for that you you see as a board for the district and taxpayers we have four main budget goals that we want to outline here uh the I want to highlight the second one most importantly which is to stay within the property tax cap voters have been very patient with the last few years in order to formulate budgets that needed to be met at the time we are going to stay within property tax cap this year subject to your direction otherwise and I don't see it coming uh the voters need that and
009the district needs it as well uh so those are the goals the Administration has in putting this together there are two sides to the budget and I think it's important that we just take a moment to talk about this the expenditure plan that's the plan of what how the money is going to be spent that's what the voters are voting on in May how you pay for that is the revenue that's the money that's coming in to pay for the expenses that's determined by the Board of Education it's a little confusing in the way that the property tax cap law works because the property tax cap law has to do with the revenue side of things even though really you are presenting to the voters the expenditure side of things and so we can talk
010about that as this process goes along it's important to say that a budget is an aspirational document we are designing a budget now in January and February and March that's going to be in effect for months and you know more than a year into the future we are making good faith estimates about what things are going to cost sometimes we have to build contingencies into the budget because things can happen or it's simply too early to determine with finality what an expense is going to be we're going to talk about that a little bit in a future presentation specifically when it comes to health insurance and how that impacts but that's important to look here there are a number of budgeting I want to highlight as just an example one of many where we are
011real property insurance so this is the insurance that you carry to protect uh to protect against uh damage to the real property the fixtures the building and liability that comes along with that now let's remember state has said we are capped at 2% increase there's certain exceptions to that you can see what the rates have gone up up in the last five years there I don't think except for one year we were anywhere close to 2% right as th as the insurance costs which I think we can all agree are mandatory we have to have this insurance have gone up as they are in excess of 2% we've had to contract other areas of expense in order to stay within the budget and because it's become so impossible in the past that's why you've had
012to exceed the property tax Gap in the last two consecutive years what we have here just back one second what we have here for next year and again this is just one of many examples is an estimate of what we think the cost is going to be next year Jonathan and I have been speaking to our colleagues in other districts I think that a number of business officials are concerned about where the cost of real property insurance is going in the United States particularly in light of the massive uh and completely unprecedented losses that are being seen in Los Angeles area as well for wildfires we anticipate that some of that loss is going to end up being pushed down to raid paays all across the country companies are not going able to survive without
013it we are estimating a 7% increase at the moment I'm giving you fair warning this is probably going to go up but for purposes of our discussion tonight we're going 70% so the budget I want you to recommend that you think of it in four General categories and we've select these categories because they're in with how the near State com controller organizes Municipal budgets there's General support which is everything that goes from superintendent office business office facilities property insurance if you are reading the actual budget lines it's the budget lines that start with a one see it starts with a one it's General the next major area of instruction sorry next next major area of budget is instruction general education special education tuition youer high school students extracurricular Athletics these are things that in your
014budget when you look at the budget lines it start with a two the next major area is transportation that's your busing busing to bring the kids here to Spring School busing to bring it bring the kids down the road to the high school busing for field trips for Sports in your budget that starts with five and then you have benefits of Debt Service which is mandatory payment the Retirement Systems the Social Security System health insurance bond payments that starts with N if you think about the budget these four categories that's how we're going to lay out our budget presentations and we're going to do one category night presentation we'll do the last two together and that's how we're going to lay everything out so there's a logical approach to how we l out for the
015Lord and those voters who are followable right so uh the way we're going to do this to just show you is we're going to talk about what's in the various sections as an orientation both of the board and the public and then we'll show you what the numbers are and that'll be the pattern that we're going to carry through this entire process over the next few weeks so Board of educator service unpaid volunteers back jobs and I'm sure the community and administration would all agree thank you for your than job thank you for your service your dedication District your primary jobs are to adopt board policies approve h dismissal District employees oversee the Public's tax dollars the district clerk which is included in this section serves as a board secretary reports official action board and
016the annual meeting that's the vote we hold in May superintendent business office auditing IL legal see what involved with that obviously the superintendent is the chief executive officer of the district business office supports that permission with purchasing payroll benefits Debt Service Revenue receipt treasury auditing compliance there are a number of outside contractors that you hire in order to help accomplish these goals your mandatory external auditor mandatory claims auditor Legal Services the list it goes on and on we do the L selection here now for robust facilities and security here obviously the facilities department is responsible for day-to-day custodial maintenance of of this building uh the department also oversees periodic repairs outside maintenance contractors and of course the life systems the building heating cooling water septic maintaining those things to ensure that this building is safe
017and operational for use is a major job you have dedicated employees who participate in that and obviously security probably nothing is more important than the safety of the students who come here and you have uh security guards and safety technology that go into making this building safe and secure place for people come to school and finally one the section where one of the sections we're look at the overall category call the data processing postage Property Insurance bage Administration most of the stuff is fairly self-explanatory property insurance we talked about that a couple slides ago for the board's refresher and for the public to know District gets its liability insurance its property insurance through a reciprocal called New York school Insurance reciprocal it is a insurance company for word that is owned and operated by its
018members districts they only ensure school districts across the state there's no other business they so they they provide service that we need and the BOS Administration costs which is another line of the budget all of the component districts of EIC bosies are required to pay a mandatory fee that goes towards the central operation of bosies whether the district selects no additional Bosey services or every additional Bosey service they offer the district has to pay proportionate share of the cost of operating the bosies at large that's the boses Administration costs so those the overall concepts of what you can see here the cost of of of this so the way we're going to do this for the board's uh View for the public as we show you what we're projecting to be our cost for next
019year we're going to highlight in yellow where there's certain where you may have a question we provide an explanation on the slide that's what it is so you can see that there are some large increases superintendent business office lines and the auditing legal lines so it taking the the first one first there is an increase because we have moved somebody from a different section of the budget into one of those one of those offices so there really just a reclassification of expense it's not like the overall spending in the budget has gone at this lines it's just a reclassification where the person is allocated the budget the second large increase you can see there are aing illegal has to do with some additional closy Services District anticipates needing for next year this is the overall
020big picture of how this works we can delve into the detail of where these numbers arrived at if you wish I will tell you that you can see the last line in bosis we have been notified by Bose that most of their expenses are going 3% next year there are of course exceptions uh certain special education services I think are going up 3.6 7% and other special education services are going as much as 5% we will help that in more detail as we get to those sections of the budget that have that uh obviously you saw the real property insurance number there we're anticipated 7% I think it's going to end up being higher but that's where we are for now um and the the rest the increases are somewhat self-explanatory all right um so
021here's next steps obviously we're going to continue to monitor the education to the district uh for next year between now and when the budget has to be finalized we're going to continue to monitor changes in state aid obviously the legislature is supposed to by law adopt a budget by April 1st or they are considered late uh for a very long time New York was constantly Rel the budget the right track last couple years itally hopefully be on time this year uh and we're going to do more of these budget presentations over the next board meetings to the schedule so next time we're going to take a look at uh basically the structural component of the budget and we're going to show you the tax level we are required to file with sa com controller an
022estimate of what our taxy limit is going to be by the end of next month so we're going to show you the calculation at the February meeting we're actually vote to ask you to vote to that you approve our calculation because that's what we're going to file with the state we' like board to take ownership with that as well in March we're going to talk about the uh Transportation costs and Debt Service and the benefits in April is when the board has to adopt the budget so between March and April there's going to Visions as we get more information so for example that's when we might know more information about the property insurance costs and adjustments that's when we need to get the feedback from you about what you see wanting to add or subtract
023the voters can have opportunity to talk to the board about the budget on April 13 sorry May 13th at a public budget hearing and calls May 20 anyone in the public I guess I should say his questions obviously superintendent is person contact and or there any questions but we went through answer questions or defer super you go back to screen I just noticed something on that U going with the uh percentages yeah this one yes that one the um notice that the facilities and the order facilities is some of those fees not going to administrative cost why there's a decrease it's a decreasing that because we have services using with East Hampton right now where where does that funds go they they transferred over to somewhere else no it's in there I mean you know
024the the money you're spending for your facilities director through an interm agreement with East hon is probably less than half of what you were spending when you had somebody here fulltime so that's where you so the cost for the contract Le Hampton is still in that facility line contractual expense where so we have that contractual expense expense compared to what it would have been that you have the salary line in that same section to pay a person be here which is had a wonderful example of how M Municipal UNS are beneficial for the taxpayers here at Springs getting the services need sa money have any questions um just have a question about um the insurance percentage because it obviously it always goes up plummeting down with the expectation it might go up but why is
025it going down like from 177% I guess the year before it went up and now it's a lot of is driven by lot of have ni set the rates obviously there's some involvement with there's some involvement with how nicer it does with other districts that insures right I think it's it's fairly well acknowledged in insurance industry that schools not this one have taken a insurance hit because of the uh State's reopening of the sexual victims so sexual sexual assault public uh newspaper articles about this about how M of districts have the pads settlements some of which have been covered by insurance so that has been ahead ner has also had to pad a number of losses over the year recent years I think that uh myself of my colleagues have communicated T so there's limit
026to what districts can reasonably expect to absorb in light the 2% tax cap rules shirts is what it is some people may suggest want shop R for other insurance and that's certainly an option I recommend the advantage of being nicer for the most part is that because you we are district owner of the company it's very hard to drop and anybody who's ever suffered a large loss in property insurance of their own home or automobile insurance you're onun the risk that you're insance companies consider too high risk drop you when the time comes back to your insurance it's very unusual for ncer to do that because it's member districts are its holders so you know I think my recommendation to superintendent has on board is we have to find a way to absorb these increases
027because going out for private insurance f up to the risk of dro do you think that insurance through nyser will insulate us somewhat from the catastrophes that we're seeing on the west coast that's a little bit outside of my knowledge I'd like to hope it is I know that nyser has heard from number of my colleagues including me that there's a limit to what they can continue to increase the rat spine and allow us to sustain we try to do here we is have kids the insurance Market is what it is unfortunately it's a litigious time but I don't know how we I don't how we get up not having it so I think this is one of these instances where I would say no it's the best of bad options than look at more
028presentations than looking more okay anybody pleas nobody there right um no nobody has signed on or called in or anything fantastic um if you want me to I'll put the number back on the screen for a little bit and then we can just make absolutely sure but uh we only had two viewers on our YouTube channel uh our Peak was four so I just want to let you know thank you I've change the way we the recommendation in the beginning that we approve I didn't realize that I'm sorry things Chang I'm old I asked a motion to approve items 6.1 6.3 of this super attended report and recommendations I need two motions motion okay Nancy can you please present them thank you Pat and you are doing a great job we have h two appointments
029this evening the first is Rael Burns and she is being appointed with board approval as a teaching assistant it's a position that we've had vacant and we're very happy we're able to fill it um the second is Jee Marie MAA far and she's being appointed as a lead replacement for special education position and uh we welcome them both to the spring scho family we're appointing as a lead replacement now instead of a permanent position so and we can really determine what our needs are for next year so she's being appointed through the end of June um at this time too I really want to publicly thank our neighboring school districts uh Monto amaganset and eastampton for their support during a very difficult time at Spring school as our staff and students are grieving the loss
030of our beloved teacher Megan pay they provided additional counselors to meet with both staff and students and also teachers to cover classes so our Springs teachers could attend Services we appreciate the overwhelming support we were offered and provided by our neighbor districts so I want to publicly thank them it was very much appreciated by all of our staff and our students we also want to thank our PTA they invited hospice to their meeting to provide guidance on dealing with Greek and talking to children and we're just so fortunate to have in such a supportive and caring community and we thank everyone uh for getting us through that difficult time and um just on a note uh the first semester is ending it's hard to believe uh it's ending next Friday January 31st and as our
031new semester is about to begin I we're excited that our foot students are now going to have the opportunity to choose an instrument and participate in band and uh they're very excited to begin this they didn't start in the beginning of the year and now they're excited that they're going to be able to start in middle of the year we also have a new chess club that's beginning um with our middle school students and that's going to be an a school club we're excited to be able to provide our students with that opportunity as well and also there's going to uh our middle school students going to be performing the musical Moana at Guild fall and there'll be three performances Thursday February 6th at 700 p.m. we'll be open to all the public so we
032invite everyone to come and uh real enjoy the show then Friday February 7th at 9:15 and 11 um our the students and staff of the school are going to all have the opportunity to go and see the show and support the middle school students so they'll uh want to participate themselves when they get to the middle school and um now I just want to show our enrollment report as we do each budget each uh board meeting uh interestingly we're up uh 13 students at 3K through 8 uh from last from December uh was December 6 was our last meeting and we're actually up 13 students in the 3K through eight and we're up four students at the high school at this time so as I said one thing that's really important to us is that
033we continue to look at enrollment not only for Springs but for our neighboring districts as we work through the budgeting process for next year then I just want to remind everybody that uh there's going to be no school on Wednesday January 29th in celebration of the Lunar New Year it's now a state holiday and school public schools are required uh to be closed that there thank you very much how we can approve a motion to approve nany's uh 6.1 to 6.3 post who oh sorry um all in favor all in favor then we go to First public comment NY is the uh School Union the budget count is GNA be on the website we can put it on the website it be helpful to put that on the website can also put the presentation yeah
034we can put the presentation there and then also one of the applications doe for I guess we have a couple of them start up school board this year I don't know comes up but for for school board truste what is the deadine out the exact dat is on there they should be on the the deadline to nominate need someone okay right there uh April 21st okay you got it perfect and we'll go to public commentary number two still nobody fantastic think a motion toour all in favor bye thank you very