001oh okay planing board we are live we are recording phone lines will remain off go for it okay thank you um welcome to the town of East Hampton planning boards uh July July I guess I'm wishing right uh January 22nd meeting uh we have five matters on for work session tonight we have very slim agenda for a regular meeting but we'll get started with our work session items the first of which is bayy Estates which is a preliminary subdivision Dan that's yours and Jen that's yours on this side okay is the applicant here D okay great thanks all right well uh good evening board um so this is the application for Bayberry States um this was an application that was reviewed uh about early in 2024 and Since U subsequent reviews and now finally before
002board tonight just to give kind of a context and reminder where we're located um this is a approximately 17 AC lot located on 476 um at way Scott Northwest Road um it's located in the A5 resident zoning district and also in several important areas of important environmental consideration that includes the water recharge D District the sub County Pine Barons and the groundwater management zone five of which identify uh its importance to water protection and recharge of the to town Soul aquifer um there are large tracks Reserve lands in the areas you can see right across which are owned from town either owned by the town of East Hampton or suff County um but besides for that is mostly surrounded by other Residential Properties which are mostly developed um which are also zoned as A5 um
003at the time of this review so the project itself is to subdivide this 17 acre lot into three individual Lots um in addition to preserving around 70% of the over L area given that the parcel is located within the A5 resident zoning district and the water recharge overway District the town code does require um for it to be subdivided as an open space subdivision which approximately 70% of that to be preserved which the applicants have compli with um in the past and also with this review as well um during that board's previous review in 2024 there were several other minor comments issued more about the access some comments about the design but overall more particulars with this application um which are kind of the primary focus of this evaluation uh but before diving to those
004elements I just wanted to bring a reminder to the board that this is an unlisted action pursuing to secra chapter 12 of the town code um during prior reviews there was request for eaf part one to be submitted which the applicants have since submitted uh for the board's review and that's contained within the files um plan Department reviewed most of uh review the efl was submitted and had a couple comments in there about some of items that need to be addressed um those are outlined throughout memo and again I'm happy to go through further any of those should be needed um but ultimately given that the planning board in the past has indicated that they have declare lead Agency for this project um once those comments are kind of addressed uh we're recommending that the
005planning board conduct a coordinated review of this application and begin coordinate the other other involved agencies uh that the agency be coordinated with be St County department of health services and New York State Department of environment of conservation so so in terms of those comments from the previous meeing um the first one had to do with kind of these the uh developable area on the building of the Lots themselves really focusing around the actual building envelopes so it was requested that the applicant dep pick the building envelopes on the property which should avoid the areas of steep slopes as you can tell um from the subdivision map those areas not let me drag around there you go um are kind of these ones that are highlighted and colored and show the steeper contour lines um
006because the town code be requires those to be protected not developable the applicat you can tell from the plans have complied with these requirements showing the proposed building envelopes and I've also indicated the setbacks for those building envelopes um we found that these typically comply with those of lots of this similar size which is that range between 40,000 and 83,000 square ft um except for the steep slopes NE necessitate greater setbacks um which is something that we recommend are appropriate the only point that we wanted to mention was the there's previous requests that the map itself be annotated to indicate that the building envelopes have been designed primarily because of those steep slopes um just to kind of avoid future uity on that point um it doesn't seem that has been addressed as part of
007this it's something that um we're recommending if the board should want require is condition of preliminary approval U should they choose to granted that could be something that could be uh required at that point um going from there uh the next comment had to do primar with the reserved area so the applicants had previously indicated this be dedicated to the town of eastampton um and the board found that to be acceptable so the plan Department uh we previously indicated that that was something that should be indicated on the map which applicant have done so there's no issue on that part the only thing we wanted to me just remind the board and the applicant is that reminder just to coordinate with the town attorne office part of land acquisition management to kind of coordinate those
008next steps about actually dedicating that land and going from there um so going from that comment uh next we to do with the actual access of parcels themselves so during previous reviews the planing Department recommended that a common driveway be provided in order to avoid excessive clearing reduce curb cuts and preserve traffic flow along way Scott Northwest Road um as part of their latest submission you can see here you see they have add the common driveway area um all kind of along these this flag portion the flag portions of these Lots um and situated within what's identified as an access to utility easement um which was previously recommended um the applicants in addition to this have also submitted a common driveway plan uh you shown the B dimensions and details of the common driveway itself
009um we did have a couple small comments well to add in addition to this as part of this however we did kind of talk to the applicant about this before the meeting so that's something we're going to try to um discuss in addition to maybe something that maybe before the future kind of clarification about the design of it and made sure it's consisten between the maps um and the common driveway plan um it was mentioned during previous reviews as well but in terms of what's presented here tonight so um couple comments that we've had first we we were recommending that the sitting of the driveways appears to be the most appropriate location um you know it's within Northern yard of the project site we along these Lots um and given that there's steep slopes located
010throughout more of the Southern yard it seems that this seems to be the best fitted for this slot in terms of what the town code kind of guides towards um the other com we had is that you know they submitted the common driveway plan as requested um which was reviewed by the town consultant engineer um who recommended that these the plans themselves satisfactory address the comments that have been previously issued to them so this was something that they willing uh found willing to sign off on um and finally the only thing we noted was that in terms of the actual excess utility easement um were recommend well we're noting that as part as this process and access utility easement uh setting forth the rights of access for each property and form acceptance of the clan
011board attorney would need to be recorded as part of the prary subdivision um and an additional reminder just that the utilities according to the town Cod should be placed below ground um part of the general policies for subdivisions within the town going back to the map itself um there was also some other comments that had to do with some of the requirements for prary subdivisions um that are identified throughout the Talent Code uh we found the applicat addressed most of these but there were still a few minor ones that didn't appear to be addressed the last time first of these had to do with the requirement to identify the location of fire hydrants uh Wells or sistern locations um and a letter of approval from the appropriate department and or fire district regarding this so
012we reviewed the map it didn't based on our review of it didn't see to find the location of those items um having provided on this submission um and something that we the app comp with as part of this review the only thing is if these features uh for some reason don't have to be required we just requesting that fire marshall sign off or fire department sign off be provided just indicating that those aren't provided at this time um but otherwise um that was really the only comment with respect to those items the only other thing we had in addition to this was there was an item regarding drainage calculations um for the common driveway area itself um which wasn't indicated in the last review the applicant has with their Comm dve plan indicated um you
013know has provided draing calculations and specifications for the prosed area uh which was reviewed by the T consultant engineer and also found to be satisfactory so consequen that the plan Department had no objections to the drain plan or the c or this uh common driveway plan as currently presented furthermore um there was a minor comment about the um this map happens to be located within a certain V of the airport that requires the applicants record an airport nor seasment essentially just acknowledging that their potential noise of issu of the airport that might create uh potentially impact some of the development here um now that was something that was requested to be added to the map just a notation indicating that um which it is located like count of these subn notes here um so we
014found this app successfully comply with that request um and generally recommend it will be appropriate for the playboard to include the requirement that this easement uh again in a form acceptable Town attorney's office be recorded with sub County as a condition of final or final subdivision approval if they choose to Grant it um going from there kind of going back a little bit with the fire marshal aspects of it because we had a few other comments about um a note that there the common driveway itself was required to have an intern uh vehicle emergency turn around sorry emergency turn around area and a turnoff area given its length um of over 500 ft The Advocates have revised their plans and including this accordingly um and again recognizing the uh oh and then recognizing that the
015board previously found um hold on I was reading the wrong section um again so recognize the applicat um they have revised their plans to include this the town Engineers has also reviewed these as well and signed off on them um So the plan Department recommends again just as a condition approv that that fire marshal sign off be Reeds as part of this um and that's some of the plan discuss whether or not that approval is required uh on for this point I guess in terms of this uh development of the driveways presented um now finally there was a few other comments that were just kind of additional comments that we had after reviewing this and that weren't mentioned previously but thought were relevant to bring up as part of this uh the first had to
016do uh with the lot area requirements so during previous reviews there was a indication that the uh the applicat indicated the lot area on the subdivision map and seem to include both the lot itself and this flag portion however town code currently doesn't allow the flag portion to be included um in the lot area um so the applicant have since revised this and indicated on their plans that they um that show calculations both with and without that that flag for to lot um and you know given that the planning board had previously found the size lay in configuration of requested subdivision to be appropriate and that these changes made were kind of to meet the town code uh we had no objections um to these aspects of the map is currently presented um from there
017we also had a small Comm of water supply and sanitary systems um we know during the previous review they have kind Revis their PL include the picture of neighboring Wells and sanitary systems around the subject property which is part of those requirements for plinary sub divisions um this is an important note just to ensure that there are locations of the lot that would not that would have sufficient step backs which are over 150 ft from existing water supply and sanitary systems so lots one and two do appear to be in close proximity however we've also noted that the county department of health services um we'll have to review these and address compliance standards as part of their review um for this aspect and just something we want the applicant to take consideration as well um
018and finally there's just small comment that this is another project that would also require sub County Planning Commission given that is within the sub County Pine baren region uh so that's something that will be referred to the sub County for comments once planning board has accepted the overall plan so summarizing everything together here the applicants have respondents and many of the requests previously issued by the planning board you know there's some minor updates required to the map with specifically those locations of fire hydrant well or sistern uh sisters um in addition the potential commas be talked about with the driveway that may have to be addressed as following this review um but ultimately um in addition to the need for Seeker review at this time um this again this will also require the review of
019the fire Mar's office for compliance with Ada standards fire safety and design requirements and this doesn't have to appear to have been received at the time of this meeting um and from there I guess I'm um yeah M for any questions and some re were you okay thank you Dan uh Dam would you like to be heard before we start our discussion good evening um thank you board thank you Dan for your presentation um this is uh Dan Weaver from wallbridge surveyors I'm representing the applicant on this project um just a few things I want to uh add to the discussion um this was originally an application in 2022 not 2024 um and at that time the board did approve the general configuration um and lot design of the subdivision uh including the access eement
020as currently shown it has been modified some to add the turnoff areas that were requested by the fire Marshall's office um but other than that there's always been an access easement over the flag strips in this General configuration and was generally approved by the board in 2022 um the dedication and the easements um as discussed would not be a problem that's usually not done until basically it's a condition of approval so it wouldn't be something we would dedicate at this time would be something that we would dedicate upon completion of the subdivision and before the map is recorded would be a requirement of um you know that don't think it needs to be particularly addressed now um as far as the fire system and firewell if the fire Marsh Marshall's office uh believe one should
021exist we have no problem adding one um the reason there are none shown there are none within proximity of the project the um when the sub County Water Authority expanded Water Service in this part of way Scott did not come this far north past the airport so there are no uh hydrants in this area but we will add a sistern or firewell if needed in in the common driveway that's pretty much all I had to add to the discussion and I'm just looking forward to hear what you have to come back with thanks Dan Jen thanks Dan and Dan um I think this is a pretty you know I don't see any real issues with this application I think that you know the open space is good the you know they minor issues really that
022I think need to be just addressed um so I really don't have any issues does anyone else have any I have a question is is suff County water have plans to expand their water main lines up that far in North I hope question you work not that we're aware of and um you know the health department would review that as part of their review if the water man has been extended then they would require us to hook up but you know we're not within distance of what is required for a hookup so at this point the intention is not to hook up because it is too far away right gotcha okay water main line would go right on R Scott Northwest Road I mean what do you mean too far it's not far it's not
023far enough up the road it's down that's right I'm projecting to the Future any other questions or comments Bruce Reed we're good okay um I guess the biggest remaining thing is getting the short form EA done and submitted right so we can uh get the secret the secret review going um so Dan I think that's probably the next to do um you know thanks for remedying many of the other things that the other Dan brought up in in his review yeah just I will make the changes to the eaf as asked for that doesn't seem to be a problem we can get that into the board immediately okay great thanks all right so we'll go to the questions the first of which is should the applicant revise the short form environmental assessments as indicated by
024the planning [Music] department once the revised short form environmental assessment form is submitted does the planning board wish to initiate the coordinated review with involved agencies yes yes and we are we already declared lead Agency on this previously um does the board agree that as a condition of final subdivision approval if they choose to Grant it will be the requirement to annotate the map to recognize that the envelopes have been designed to avoid the areas of Steve slopes as Dan mentioned earlier yes should the applicant coordinate with Town attorney's office Department of land acquisition and management for next steps regarding the dedication of the easement yes in due course right yes um does the planning board agree that the condition of final subdivision approval if they choose to Grant it will be the requirement to
025submit proof of recording of an access utility easement setting forth the rights of access for each property in a form acceptable to the planning board's attorney yes yes should the applicant address the additional items needed for the preliminary map including the addition of fire hydrant well or sistern locations along with letter of appr approval from the appropriate fire department and our fire district yes you agree to that does the planning board agree that a condition of final subdivision approval if they choose to Grant it will be the requirement to be to submit proof of recording to the airport airport noise easement and that the noise easement must be in a form acceptable to the attorney's office Town attorney's office and avoid it okay awesome thank you very much we'll see you again all right so
026next up is the Royal Atlantic North outdoor canopy Lounge beds and that is you will and Jen has that and is the applicant present okay great take it away will so this is a preliminary site plan application that has been made regarding five proposed canopy Lounge beds at the Royal Atlantic Resort in monok um you can see here it's south of the traffic circle and to the water will can you move the microphone a little closer does that move is it better is that better no not really is it on yeah it's definitely on if you you might have to actually speak into the microphone I'll try speaking closer um so because this is a preliminary site plan application technical details including ADA compliance will be reviewed by the town Consulting engineer upon formal submission
027of the application here's another aerial um the proposed poolside Lounge beds are approximately 100 ft each and 8 ft tall the lounge beds are proposed to be located on an existing grass area just south of the existing pool and pool patio the pool Guard Station is proposed to be moved North onto the pool patio and closer to the pool per Town Geographic informational systems aerial imagery seen here it appears the proposed Lounge beds were already present on site when the most recent aerial images were taken in early 2024 the applicant should explain if these structures are already exist on site the partial site plans submitted do not depict many features required by the town code section necessary elements of site plans including property lines lot area floor area of buildings and structures setbacks between buildings
028and structures locations of easement parking lighting topography structure elevations or locations of any easements the applicant should submit a revised site plan depicting these in order to facilitate a more complete review of the proposed work no survey was submitted as part of this application resulting in a lack of information required for a full and complete review the applicant should submit a survey depicting all existing and proposed structures parking spaces building coverage and lot coverage labeled to proceed with this review as the proposed work does not require variances does not require approval from the suffa county department of health services is not habitable is 500 ft in size will not affect parking requirements does not appear to require any unusual planning considerations and has not created public controversy this project may be considered a minor site
029plan upon formal submission in conclusion the applicant should clarify the presence of the Lun bed structures and submit a revised site plan and Survey which include all existing and proposed structures coverage and parking great thank you will thank you does the applicant wish to be heard would please state your name or the record and and address and spell your last name name is Anthony K it's k a l i m n i oos I represent the Royal Atlantic um we put those there in 2023 we really just thought they were lawn furniture um we actually got them from gurny who's toing them we revitalized them and put them in our Courtyard that was it and then a year later we got a violation and I wound up in court so I'm really just here to
030find out if I need a permit then go through with what I have to do to get it that's about it okay thank you thank you Jan it's you again that's me again um thank you so much um for coming and for trying to remedy this I have um just a couple of questions I I understand that you you know you put them in they're there what is the pool Guard Station where is that red dot that's here the Red Dot and is that the Lifeguard State the lifeguard chair okay so you're proposing to move that so it's just is it like just a chair that's all it is okay chair so yeah so I think the big thing is um to get these you know legalized we need to see the whole site plan
031and Survey uh because without that it's hard to really comment on it I think awesome any other comments around the table I think without a survey it's hard to yeah we need to survey um yeah so these are structures they do require a permit um so thanks for following up with with this and uh yeah that's really our next step s plan and Survey so we'll go through the our questions um and you can follow up later with the planning department if you have any other questions about the process should the applicant provide a survey depicting all existing and proposed structures absolutely okay should the applicant submit a revised site plan depicting the entire property and comply with necessary elements of site plans upon formal submissions yes right does the board agree this project may
032be considered a minor site plan upon formal submission okay all right so thank you thank you very much okay all you so L you're on now you're our designate going forward here uh so our next matter is the three mile Harbor affordable housing and will that's you again a modification has been submitted proposing minor changes to the affordable housing complex located at 286 and 290 3 Mile Harbor Road the applicant proposes to correct a mistake made during building and replace oh I'm sorry hang on will okay is the applicant here ah okay thank you very much sorry all right um the applicant proposes to correct a mistake made during building and replace the fence on top of the sewage treatment plant retaining wall with the previously approved 4ft railing Additionally the applicant proposes to add
033vegetation on top of the retaining wall and modify the Meandering path to comply with ADA requirements the sewage treatment plant has a retaining wall which reaches a maximum height of approximately 6 ft and you can see that on the site plan is this Dark full BL this modification proposes to replace the 6t 6ft tall fence on top of that retaining wall with a previously approved 4ft railing to provide a permanent safety solution due to the height of the wall and the grade changes surrounding it a railing is necessary for safety the planning department has no objection to the railing aside from aesthetic impacts of the wall just G to pull up a picture the planning department recommends additional vegetation be added to screen areas of the wall which are most visible from public spaces and
034navigation areas on the site if the planning board agrees the planning department recommends as a condition of approval the applicant submit a revised landscape plan with additional screening in this [Music] area the path which runs from building one to the property line on 3 Mile Harbor seen here has been modified to comply with ADA requirements the path has had the pitch and slope of some areas changed to ensure accessibility the Fire Marshall and town Consulting engineer have confirmed the changes to the path are appropriate the planning department notes these changes are relatively minor and overall the overall path remains consistent with the original design and recommends the changes are acceptable in conclusion the board should consider if additional vegetative screening should be added to shield parts of the retaining Mall from visible areas on site
035thank you wel do the applicant wish to be heard state your name address and spell your last name for the record please Walter Beal b a l i run Georgia Construction um 81 Salsbury Avenue Garden City New York firstly I'd like to apologize for not being present last week that's squarely on me no excuse I missed an email there's no excuse for that and um I made a point to be here this evening myself um secondly I'd like to take this opportunity to um thank the planning board for its its reasonableness and its thoughtfulness throughout this entire process which is years long and the good news is that it C culminated in there are 50 affordable housing units that are occupied at this property as we speak which is significant and we need more of
036that um with regard to this particular um modification we we are happy to screen the lower half of that wall with whatever the the the planning board or natural resources um necessary and we'll we'll update our our our documents accordingly that's it thank you Mr Beal thank yeah um hopefully this is the last time we'll hear on this application it seems like it's an application that just won't die or get approv agree I think it's you know I I'm all in favor of this project and I think this this is just a minor last uh a but since you know my suggestion was to screen that wall the wall looks terrible it's uh concrete and it's raw State uh the Aesthetics are horrible so there it is I mean you can see so the solution
037which the applicant is willing to implement it's needed now you mentioned the bottom of the wall is getting screen the upper portion of the wall we added those aritis on the most recent application at the top of the wall and that orange netting is temporary which we hope to replace with a black vinyl coated steel rail of 4 foot high which will be not necessarily obviously move like that and have you determined how you're going to screen I hopefully it'll get fully screened that you won't be able to see any of that horrible looking wall as I said we'll we'll accommodate what the department or natural resources deems necessary well then there's nothing else to be said you're not a fan of brutalist architecture all range right now really lovely thanks Lou anybody else have
038any comments yeah I guess my question was the screening is on proposed on top of the wall or in front of the wall down low in front front of the front of the concrete The Shield absolutely all in favor yeah anyone else I would just you know concur that it's uh you know work with the planning department on this but I would concur that something that is you know that covers most of this is really in order um that the deers need and that the deers don't need of course but the planning department can direct you on on that but thank you for accommodating us on this I appreciate it yeah they're going to be more trees than that more at the top that more than the you want to add more on top well
039no I'm okay more along the bottom yeah so I think you understand what it is that we want and the planning department does as well so if you can work with Mr Beal on determining what the plant species should be we'll make it happen can I ask one question you You' mentioned on the top your replacing the black vence or explain to me what what so on the original her and and put a 8T high or 6 high DBC vinyl fence on top of that wall okay that was wrong but what was on the original documents and and still is on the approved drawings is a 4 foot tall um um vinyl coated black steel railing okay so that's a 6 6 drop that's why I had the temporary fence there right now until I
040got this approved um because we need we it needs it requires a railing for safety purposes okay so even the railing will be screened from the other because of the other plants there right behind it the ones that are currently there right yeah behind it not in front because I assume the path is on the other side of these this row of there's really no path it's it's it's on the other side it's the field of the SE treatment plan really no one should really even be up there but okay than you so so um I did not think you will see the black rail the drawing the approv the approved drawing shows the rail on top of the wall itself not behind those Hedges okay so see that I do whatever you want these
041guys they have to have the rail rail okay all right so I think we we trust between you and the planning department you know you'll figure out interpret our comments do something appropriate here within code so thank you for that maybe next time will be the last time thanks good thanks very much all right so our next matter is Springs Brewery oh questions oh man I'm yeah she's anxious to talk about that Brewery I know um does the planning board agree that the changes to the Meandering path for ada8 compliance are acceptable yes yes okay good does the planning board agree the new railing on top of the sewage treatment plant retaining wall is appropriate and requir uh does the planning board agree that additional screening of the sewage treatment plant retaining wall is appropriate
042focused on publicly prominent views of the wall and that a revised Landscaping plan should be submitted for review by the planning department yes yes does the planning board agree this application is complete once these things are done yeah all this stuff yeah all right good thank you God willing tired thank you all right so the Springs Brewery uh that is Chris ster and Lou again that's the board and I see the applicant is here good to go all right well this is the initial review of The Springs Brewery site plan application um let me to share my screen folks can see it there so the subject parcel is zoned ND neighborhood business it is 10,932 square ft large um quarter acre and it contains an existing one-story building slab on grade um that was previously
043used as an auto body repair shop um the parcel is not within any Town overlay districts however it is adjacent to the springs historic district the harbor protection overlay District as well as the aabon harbor uh critical environmental area so going into the application itself so a site plan application has been submitted to remodel the existing 20680 ft² building from an auto body repair shop to a brewery the existing building with aluminum siding two garage doors and the subject parcel had five existing parking spaces uh when it was the repair shop the remodel building would include a brewery retail area three bathrooms employee office pantry and separate areas for dry and Cold Storage thead changes are proposed to remove and seal off one of the existing garage doors paint the metal siding offwhite and add
044Windows around the front and sides of the existing building um Paving improvements are also proposed including a permeable driveway and parking area um which would replace the existing asphalt and a new walkway and Patio um on the exterior shown here the proposal includes removing the existing septic system and installing an Innovative and alternative on-site wastewater treatment system an IA septic and the applicant has applied for the use to be considered a wholesale business use with an accessory retail area and a brewery for town code there are two uses related to wholesale business one for lumber and Building Products the other to retail beverage distribution and wholesale Bakery operations I'll further discuss discuss the uh proposed use classification in a moment regarding the existing conditions on site just want to pull up this photo from a
045site visit this was on December 2024 a walk-in refrigerator was absorbed towards the West Corner along the rear property line and this should be added to plans or the applicant should just confirm that it will be um removed just given that it appears the is currently uh operating out of compliance with this structure um being present regarding secra um the State Environmental Quality review act this is a type two action pursuant to secra and the town code the project is considered the ReUse of a commercial structure um where the use is permitted under zoning and it does not exceed any thresholds of a type one action there's uh no additional review subject to type two actions so with respect to the change in use the existing use of the auto body repair shop is defined
046by town code AS Garage repair the proposal includes changing the existing use to the uses wholesale business Brewery and an accessory retail area as I mentioned breweries are not specifically permitted use by town code or defined however a brewery does in the town and it offers a relevant precedent for consideration so we reference a building inspector determination dated January 3 2013 issued by then senior building inspector Thomas priato and this included the determination that The Monto Brewery site plan application qualified as a retail store use that determination noted that the on-site Brewery at that location was primarily for walk-in customers and beer purchase to go and it was considered similar to a bagel store and that's with respect to the floor layout as well as the operations um of the nature there was no kitchen
047or bar proposed the applicant has stated in their project narrative that the intent for this location quote mainly a beer production space with a small public retail space where items can be purchased to go and minimally for Onsite enjoyment end quote the planning department notes the similarities between this and the mon talk Brewery site plan and the applicant should provide further details on the proposed operations to facilitate the confirmation of an appropriate classification and I'll further discuss this with the project description so wholesale business which is what the applicant applied for is a special permit use and retail stores are also a permitted use um in the neighborhood business Zone the planning department has no objection to the proposed application being classified as these uses pending additional clarification of the project description from the applicant
048it's noted that the special permit use wholesale retail beverage distribution does not have specific standards and safeguards under town code however it would still be subject to the procedure for special permit uses so with respect to the project description The Narrative details to retail space will include minimal indoor seating for customers to sample Beverages and the business will provide a year round location for people to socialize the planning department notes that the board gave unanimous General support to the year round use during the preliminary review for the Springs Brewery in 2020 and the applicant the applicant should confirm that they intend to sell some alcoholic beverages to be consumed within the retail area and detail the number of indoor seats that will be provided the applicant should also confirm the proposed use of the patio
049seating that's indicated here you can see my cursor and whether the seating will be used for on-site consumption finally the applicant should also confirm the use of the pantry area and if it will be used to serve food to on-site patents the revised project description should also detail the type of permit the applicants intend to obain obtain from the New York state liquor authority to allow the planning board to better understand the proposed operations with respect to coverage which is the next issue the applicant did not include any calculations for building coverage or total loot coverage the building coverage is approximately 2,680 Square ft and should be added to the revised submission the planning department calculated the proposed lot coverage by subtracting the area of the proposed structures and the existing building from the total
050lot area the proposed coverage is approximately 9,414 Square fet which equates to 86% which exceeds the maximum of 70% for this parcel um in the NB Zone the applicant should explain whether they intend to meet coverage requirements or if they will seek a variance from the zoning board of appeals and the revised Mission should include a survey with annotated calculations for building coverage and total coverage with respect to the sanitary system the proposed IIA system the applicants must receive approval from the suffa county department of health services scdhs for the proposed IIA septic the total proposed hydraulic load is 696 gallons per day which includes 500 gallons per day for Brewing process the brewery process the planning department notes scdhs does require a separate permit and Disposal facilities for Brewery processed Waters which will determine
051the allowable gray water load the applicant should consult with the sdhs and apply to that agency early in the planning process first suff county sanary code article 6 for commercial projects the population density equivalent is calculated by multiplying the gross lot area in acres by 600 gallons per day in ground groundw management Zone 4 for the subject parcel the population density equivalent would be approximately 150 gallons per day in review of the estimated potential demand flow the planning department notes that the existing building at 2,680 sare FT the applicant has applied a mix of density load multipliers this is used to calculate the allowable load um they use wet store with food and Winery Brewery and that result in a proposed flow of approximately 100 Gall per day for the density flow so just the
052septic the sewage output um which is below the allowable flow for the property but the planning department notes for this application that the additional proposed gry load increases the total hydraulic load to much higher than the allowable flow for the property also the submitted sanitary flow calculations used a gross floor area of 2717 Square fet when in fact the building is 2,680 Ft so the revised submission should reflect the accurate gross floor area the applicant should explain if they have already submitted to the scdhs and if this level of flow will be permitted on the property scdhs will confirm the flow rates applied to the different spaces if those rates are appropriate the project narrative includes details on conserving water by quote harvesting hot water from our exchanger for Brewing and harvesting gray water from
053the large roof for cleaning end quote these systems were not observed on the submitted plan and may be more applicable to the building permit review the applicant should clearly indicate the mentioned systems in the revised submission including anticipated hydraulic loads for each system the applicant has advised that additional approvals are required from the scdhs moving on to parking I'm just going to pan over to the engineer plans so for parking the submitted parking calculations indicate the required number of parking space for the retail Brewery is one space per 300 ft of Rose floor area the existing 280 2,680 ft building is proposed to be remodeled as a retail use which would in fact require one parking space per 180 Square ft of gross flare area per town code therefore if it's classified as retail The
054Proposal would require parking spaces whereas the proposal only includes nine parking spaces including the one required handicap space the applicant should revise the parking calculations to accurately reflect the required parking and if compliant parking cannot be accommodated on site a variance from the zoning board of appeals would be required with respect to site navigation and traffic the existing two-way driveway on the east side of the building is non-residential properties must have a minimum unobstructed width of 20 ft but the planning department notes that the most recent site plan approval from 1988 for this property references a town engineer review which determined that the minimum driveway width of only 16 ft was required to allow for emergency vehicle access and other service Vehicles given the previous approval for the narrower driveway the Chief Fire Marshall and
055chief building inspector reviewed the existing driveway and did not find any issues therefore the existing unobstructed width of 18.440 7 ft whereas town code requires um 24 feet of width um when parking spaces are at a 90° angle with the aisle so the applicant should reconfigure the proposed parking to comply with town code and the planning department notes that a variance application to the zba is not typical for parking lot Dimensions therefore the applicant should find a compliant solution regarding the handicap space the town engineer noted that the space could be switched with the location of the access aisle just to avoid any physical conflict with opening a door um to the vehicle so it would not be obstructed by the wall um that's not a requirement but that is just a suggest suggestion um
056for the Ada space provided moving on to drainage and storm water control the proposed storm water control involves replacing the existing asphalt driveway and parking lot with gravel to increase permeability and also proposes the installation of four storm water dry Wells toward the southern corner of the property those are shown on this plant the town Consulting engineer reviewed the submitted grading and drainage plan and found it to comply with design standards and the requirements of town code with respect to Landscaping the planning department is satisfied that six of the seven proposed plant species are native which requires which the town considers approvable for revation although it's not necessary on the subject parcel it's clearly beneficial to the natural environment that native species are proposed the Landscaping key um should include symbology for each plant species
057to indicate where each species is proposed and the applicant should confirm the osmanthus fragrance are not planned to be planted in the Native Garden um however there is no objection to it being used given it is not invasive it's just not um Native also the Landscaping plan should indicate whether plants are proposed or existing note that one tree is indicated as existing along the southern property line the revised Landscaping plan should provide details on proposed screening and indicate what method of screening would be used for exterior Utility Equipment along the southern facade of the building that's here and the planning department notes that the engineer plans show a proposed fence enclosure for this area whereas the architect Landscaping plans appear to indicate plants used for screening so that should be made consistent um in the
058revised submission in summary a revised comprehensive Landscaping plan should be submitted that meets all the elements listed in this evaluation and the planning department notes that naturally occurring vegetation should not be indicated on this given that the site is fully cleared with respect to the proposed outdoor lighting the number of proposed light fixtures is different between the lighting plan key The annotation on the lighting plan and the lighting plan itself quite slow there you go provis submission should ensure the number of fixtures is consistent and they should also indicate if the existing outdoor lighting will be removed aside from the issues mentioned the comprehensive lighting plan appears to comply with all provisions of town code and the planning board guidelines uh for exterior l with respect to noise generation and noise standards the applicant should
059provide manufacturer manufacturer specification sheets with sound data in decb a for the exterior equipment for the proposed generator air conditioner and glycol Chiller to show the compliance of town code noise standards the locations of the mentioned equipment are not indicated consistently between the engineer and architect plans and as I mentioned the fence enclosures on the engineer plans whereas uh plantings are shown on the architect plans um the location of each equipment should be consistent I'll note that the generator um was in different locations on both plans um AC unit was different on both plans and then the glycol Chiller is not indicated on engineering plans however it was indicated along that southern facade um with the architect plans so we just need all that exterior equipment to be indicated consistently and the manufacturer sheets to
060make sure that no none of the noise standards um would be violated by this proposal regarding the engineering comments the town Consulting engineer reviewed the plans and issued several comments with respect to the parking and navigation which I've already discussed regarding the proposed retaining wall construction and this retaining wall is shown in dark gray sort of horses shoes around the rear property line and the one to be removed and replaced would be along the street here and also going along the side property line you can all see that and the engineer just noted with the construction of these there is concerned that this could encroach onto the adjacent Properties or that the workers would need to be on the adjacent properties to complete this work um and these issues must all be addressed and the
061full report is attached with this evaluation regarding the office of fire prevention the Fire Marshall findings indicate the proposed project is near public water and fire hydrants provide adequate Supply uh for firefighting purposes however their findings did also detail the project is not compliant with the Americans with Disabilities Act the Ada and requires revisions um to ensure that adequate clearance is provided for the egis to the Ada um bathroom with respect to other approvals that this application will need the applicant is advised that the Architectural Review board approval is required for all commercial structures which require site plan approvals except for parking lots and driveways and this review will also address the proposed change to the exterior color of the building the office of fire prevention Fire Marshal must approve for compliance with the Ada
062as I mentioned as well as a New York state uniform fire prevention and building code the zba is to be determined the zoning board for the number of parking spaces and minimum requirement as well as the total off coverage suff County department Health Services for the proposed IIA system as mentioned getting into the necessary elements of a site plan the following lettered items from town code detail the required items that are missing from the application and I would just note that the planning board has the authority to wave one or more materials for good cause shown beginning with a the adjacent land ownership should be indicated on plans B the existing walk-in refrigerator in the west corner of the parcel should be indicated or the applicant should confirm that it will be removed the walkway
063in the front yard should be indicated as proposed and the existing walkway to be removed that's just given their different shapes it's clear that this is a new walkway if an enclosure fence is proposed for the exterior Utility Equipment it should uh be indicated on both s the plans which I've mentioned for C the lot area should be indicated and confirmed with a certified survey for this property um for D the front and rear property line setbacks for the existing building should be indicated and inaccurate side property line setbacks for the existing building should be removed the accurate figure of 1844 ft for the northern side yard should remain and the sidey yard property line setbacks for the southern yard um should be added and these are just the incorrect measurements that should be removed
064there's there's some errors there the for E regarding fire hydrants the location of the existing fire hydrant fronting the adjacent parcel should be indicated F uh for parking sidewalks and curbing as I mentioned the parking aisle width of 23.07% and curve Cuts should also be indicated on the plans with respect to G there is no signage proposed and the applicant should confirm given a new business is being proposed uh with respect to H on comprehensive lighting um the applicant should confirm if the existing exterior lighting will be removed and the proposed quantity of fixtures uh should be made consistent with the revised lighting plan okay the revised Landscaping plan should include symbology and indicate which plants are proposed and the applicant should confirm if existing bushes in the front and southernly side yard will be
065removed for n regarding elevations of buildings and structures we are missing elevation drawings for the retaining wall to be removed and replaced the proposed retaining wall and the fence around the exterior Utility Equipment along the southern facade of the existing building that proposed also noted as the digital submission for the architectural plans is not accurately to scale in conclusion this is the initial review of the site plan application to remodel the existing one-story building from an auto body repair shop to a retail use for a brewery the applicant should discuss their intent for the proposed parking configuration and whether alternative configurations are being considered the applicant should also detail if any applications or discussions have been initiated with the scdhs for the proposed IA system the board should discuss the anticipated impact the proposal would
066have on the surrounding community and whether the proposal is compatible the planning department notes as I mentioned the boards during the preliminary review gave unanimous General support to the application pending the resolution of concerns regarding the proposed parking and sanitary system planing Department advises the applicant to make a revised submission based on this evaluation and the board's feedback thank you very much Chris for that very comprehensive and thorough review of the project does the applicant wish to be heard name and address please and spell your last names uh gunar Burke b r ke uh for West way eastampton uh Lindsay rart l or sorry rart REI chart uh also for us uh good evening chairman and members of the board uh I'm Lindsay breart and this is Gunner Burke uh we founded Springs Brewery in
0672020 after several years of home brewing um our my family has lived in springs for many years um founding and leading the Springs Fire Department as well as the Springs food pantry my dad who um also attended Springs and East Hampton High Schools like me uh built and opened the shop 35 years ago and has continued to do auto the auto body work at the shop um himself to this day uh about 10 years ago when my dad began to consider retirement he initially planned to sell the building securing a future for my parents um in addition to Brewers gunar and I also work in architecture Gunner on residential and Hospital projects and me on cultural and uh Community oriented projects um our project actually began as a reimagining of my father's auto body shop
068and um when gunar and I envisioned the future of this space uh we thought given the location that it rather than sell it it could be a opportunity to use the space to serve the community and offer um the beer that we're making at home uh and offer that Quality Craft Beer to the community and create a welcoming environment for all um in just a few years through our hard work our small business has grown to become a Cornerstone of the Springs Farmers Market as well as the community our dedication to our craft is created well-loved products that are available at local restaurants and markets as well as restaurants in New York City several of which are on the top 50 lists of the best restaurants in 2024 we are devoted to supporting local organizations
069like Quail Hill Farm Amber Waves farm and the Springs food pantry and to fostering a culture culture of sustainability and collaboration in everything we do we believe strongly in the good that comes from community-minded yearound businesses in our community and as our business evolves the need for a production space of our own is Paramount to our own growth and success as a business um we are working with Britain bistrian of land use Solutions and uh David rhods of TF engineering um so I uh I have some comments on the responses to the comments um that I'll just go through um you know this is an existing commercial site um and we see that you know the majority of the comments um can be summarized as as minor revisions to adjust to the proposed use um
070we look forward to working with the board um to make the minor revisions to the submission um so we can quickly begin to realize the goals of our 2025 um business plan we are a small family business um right now it's just the two of us um you know we're not figureheads uh for wealthy investors or or anything you know it's just us um so uh because of this we you know ask for um we need to be incredibly budget conscious in this whole process and um you know ask that everything be you know time efficiency in this in this process as much as possible um the um under the existing conditions the refrigerator that's currently there is not part of the proposed site plan um the change in use uh and project description sections
071there are a few questions in there um so the project is first and foremost a production facility and brick and mortar home for our existing wholesale business um we currently contract Brew at a facility in Riverhead but we plan to produce the entirety of our products at this facility um we plan to invite the public into the designated retail space only um and we propos 16 seats uh where products can be purchased to go along with limited on-site tastings the patio seating will be used is proposed to be used by the public in conjunction with that retail use um the licenses from the SLA that we plan to obtain our uh farm brewer license which authorizes the lensey to operate a brewery for the manufacturer of uh 75,000 barrels of New York State labeled beer
072um in addition to that we also plan to get the micro Brewer license which um authorizes lcy to operate a brewery for the manufacturer of up to 75,000 barrels a year annually um regarding the concerns on lot coverage uh we will amend the site plan to adhere to the 70% coverage um the current coverage is 70% total coverage um the our intent with uh the creating the pathways through the site is to contribute to a pedestrian friendly and parklike Landscape um so we are we will look to the board for um permeable strategies to create Pathways that maybe don't um uh contribute to the coverage if that's possible um yeah regarding the concerns on sanitary systems um we do have our application submitted into the county um and we plan to work with them as
073necessary to ensure the design is in compliance um the water the water use savings and strategies that I I mentioned or that we mentioned in the um uh in the letter for reusing harvesting water those do not those are not part of the the sanitary calculations those are just kind of strategies I wanted to highlight um to show how you know we're committed to sustainability and and industry-leading um kind of processes that save water usage in that regard um uh our engineer David will speak to some of the concerns um that were brought up is here tonight um then uh regarding the parking site navigation and traffic uh we proposed the combined wholesale and Retail use for acquired um which creates you know nine spaces which are provided on the site plan we believe this
074proposal is in keeping with the previously approved Monto Brewing um in in uh you know kind of same strategy uh so we're proposing five parking spots that would be dedicated for the retail area that's the the size would dictate those five spots um plus two for employee parking um because as you can see on our plan most of the the vast majority of the the wholesale space in the back is storage and would not there would typically just be one person um working back there um the drive aisle deficiency that was brought up uh will be addressed um by allowing the car front to overhang the proposed retaining wall in the back currently it's the dimension starts after that retaining wall um so we think that can be easily fixed uh the Ada parking um
075we will look work with our engineer on on updating that strategy um parking space number one was flagged as potentially being an awkward position and we will propose that that space is a staffon space um with minimal anticipated daily use to minimize any kind of traffic concerns um the and then the Landscaping plan we will update uh for the comments and then David uh can you speak to some of the sanitary good evening even my name is David rhs R h8 Dees I'm with TF engineering uh 17 Main Street s Harbor New York I just want to address a couple of items that were in the Tam just so we can have them make sure they're clear uh it does state in there and in the health department standards that separate permit and disposal is
076required for the process water we're proposing a system on the east side for the processed water where the one on the west side is for the IIA for the uh bathrooms and kitchen um the current uh policy with the health department is that both of those systems can be permitted under the same application and the same permit there's no need to have them separate right now so that was confirmed with just yesterday so um is talking about the uh the proposed kitchen load and the hydraulic load increases the flow above the allowable that's not the case the uh Health Department only requires that the density load be underneath the allowable kitchen loads uh graywater loads and um uh and processed water are excluded from any density calculation so the uh as was stated earlier it
077was 150 is the allowable 100.8 is the actual density and this project is under the 150 so it meets the health department standards excuse me sorry to interrupt on the gray water are there same type of maximums or minimums that are that they have as they do with the flow rate no there are no as much gray water as you want that is true yes the reason is is because there's no the whole reason why the uh densities were set up is because it was all based on a nitrogen loading and nitrogen all comes from your urine which comes in your your normal bathroom so there is no nitrogen in your gray water kitchen or processed water why bother measuring the gray water at all every time we we get an application you see the
078the gray water uh numbers as well so why have those if there because we still have to dispose of it so it's we still have to make the system big enough to handle the gray water but it's not required to be under the density calculation so the system has to be big enough to handle all that flow and that's why we have to design the septic system for the total hydraulic load but it doesn't have to be under the the uh allowable so I just wanted to clarify that because it seemed a little bit clear on this um uh as far as swapping the ada8 parking and the aisle it's very common practice to always have the aisle on a single ada8 parking space and on a van accessible parking space on the right side
079of the car more important with with a van accessible vehicle because typically on the passenger side is where your ramp comes out or your lift comes out and you want that ramp or lift to go down into the aisle so it's it's it's more common than not to put that on the right hand side if you got a single space or van accessible and in this case if we swap them if somebody is getting out of that passenger side they're right on that property rying where the wall is so our I feel our our our configuration is is a better situation so um and as far as the constructing the uh retaining wall it is tight and it is tough but you know it can be done uh these soils can handle a three-foot vertical
080cut uh and as far as H you know they can use uh uh you know plywood for shoring instead instead of uh uh you know the big forms and stuff it can be we do them all the time and uh see people don't seem to have a problem with it so I don't see it as being a huge issue on this case contractor just needs to be careful and make sure that they don't uh you know get on other people's property so all you're retaining well so these are all filled walls so they're we have to go down three feet to get to the the footy and then we come up a couple feet I I don't recall off top my head what the the heights are I'd have to go back so all we're
081Excavating down to the bottom of splitting is stre feet um I think those are the only items that I wanted to cover tonight unless you guys have any questions regarding anything else I'm sure we will have some so stay close we'll have have our discussion which knew was going to leave yeah I I just want to say that I was impressed with the applicants narrative I think they had a lot of things to say that um comport with the interest of good planning such as uh you stress sustainability Community Harmony environmentally friendly practices so I hope that that's what you finally come through with and stick to that um you mentioned that the establishment will cater to a minimal customer base uh both indoor and outdoor uh serving low alcohol beer and and also you're
082manufacturing other products like kombucha Selsa things like that um which you know it's great I you know that sounds wonderful uh the one thing that the one concern that I think maybe we need to get a better idea of is what kind of uh congre ation of people will there be what kind of atmosphere do you want to create that kind of thing and you know what I'm getting to you know if it starts to become a party scene loud noise type of thing then that's not something that I think is in harmony with the the community yeah that's absolutely not what we're proposing this is a very um very lowkey very refined experiences about tasting the beer that we're producing there um along with other um products that do not contain alcohol um and
083um yeah minimal indoor seating very not a bar atmosphere whatsoever not uh I think you I think the question of coverage was uh answered so there won't be a necessity for variance with the zba on that um so you you know it's the wholesale and retail business classification requires uh that you meet General standards of a special permit I think you meet all those standards except parking parking is an issue I think you're going to have to get a variance because I think the requirement is 15 spaces you only have nine so that that's something that other than that I think all the other General standards are met um I'm glad that uh an IIA system is going in I think that's important although that's required uh and uh you know I I was glad
084to hear that the gray water is not an issue I thought that there might be a maximum on that that you were going to exceed but it seems that that's not a problem and as far as the allowable Flow versus the uh actual flow you're well under those numbers um in summary I think the project is uh in harmony within the neighborhood business Zone and springs it's a substantial approvement I think from the existing establishment um I think it's going to be constructed U with Town zoning requirements and standards hopefully um you're going to need that variance as I mentioned for you know with regard to parking the parking might change depending on the use once that's confirmed so if it's retail it would be 15 however this will be confirmed and something will work
085with the applicant T great great um and just in ending I think in my in my opinion this uh furthers the spirit of homegrown small business entrepreneurial spirit I I'm all for that I'm glad that that's happening in Springs and I wish you the greatest of luck and I hope you succeed and I'm in favor of this application thank you thanks Lou than AA did you want to comment on this so you no I I was going to make comment about the parking but it was just made mention about the uh the use so yeah I would think that would be the only problem if it is determined retail then the parking is going to be an issue um I like Lou um in favor of this project I think it's a great use of
086the space uh I think it will really add to the neighborhood and I'm really happy that you guys are here before us and I hope that we can work out my my I did have a comment about parking as well but I was going to say that you know because so much of it so much of the space is going to be used as wholesale or as production I think the the retail you know we really have to determine just how big that retail space is but I I love this project thank you Michael I am in support of this project uh I visited the site today next to you is a pizza place yeah and pizza and beer my goodness I think it's going to be very popular and the type of person is
087going to be there is me um uh yeah so that that's because it's going to be popular despite what you say it's going to be popular I'm I'm concerned about the parking uh I know years ago I would go I went to the uh the apic house and I had a park on the side of the road and it was really just uh not a safe situation so uh where are you going to get your barley and hops they be locally sourced uh some of them will be yeah ftic yeah we've we've already used local uh local barley in end hops in a few of our beers um it's a much smaller scale though so it's hard to all great good luck I love it right there's hops grown and Igan that yeah Michael done
088yeah thank you Bruce um I really don't have anything more to um I think this is a great project and uh yeah good luck Reed uh yeah I thought Lou actually had a very good overview um I agree with uh all the previous comments um I wish you success uh to your business and I'd like to be helpful to you um I think a brewery in the springs would be a nice addition to the community um you did mention some cost constraints and I'm mindful of that but at the same time you know we got to make sure everything's right here in conforming um I did have one question and that is um it was uh auto repair shop which presumably would be kind of a 9 to5 sort of operation and maybe we're getting
089ahead of ourselves with this question but I mean is this kind of a 9 to5 operation or is this 9 to midnight or or um and and the reason for my question is uh in the not too distant past and perhaps I'm comparing an apple to an orange but there was a brewery proposed in the village and there were some very interesting comments from uh some of the neighbors that came out about that so um certainly not till midnight um but um I I believe we listed proposed hours in the submission maybe um I think it was I think we listed that but it was not midnight yeah again not a not a bar scene this is a retail establishment okay and I think just one more quick comment I think you could probably you
090can use the Mok brewery as kind of an example you know they're they don't have seats inside they're not open late you know and that really has been a boon to mon talk so but they they do have bench seating out front there they have they don't have picnic benches anymore they have like high top tables they can stand at no seats we are proposing some proposing 16 seats I know yeah inside yeah good we still um wanted to get up and speak just for a minute if you would allow me to good evening new chairman and members of the board Britain bistrian uh my office at 9 North Main Street East Hampton I just want to um I've been helping ther and Lindsay and working with David and I thought that them telling their
091story was much more compelling than than myself um but I wanted to add a couple um factual details to the record just so that um some of the planning issues as you walk away from the table and you sort of mle over this and your and and look at our new sub midle um as many of you probably know I opened a brewery in West Hampton um I did all the work and in the owner of it and the thing about a brewery in its model in terms of use is that it's never really it never becomes a an evening place it's always somewhere it's really you know when we originally opened because we were you know needed to make money we're like we're going to be open till 9:00 and at the end of
092the day we're 6 years in right now and we open at 1 and we close at 600 because those are the hours in which people you know come and have a beer and then go out to dinner somewhere else so the model itself of a of a brewery in the sort of you know family or limited tasting atmosphere sort of self-limiting in of Zone I don't foresee that this could be a bar there is no bar in there um but I just wanted to you know if you look at any other there's so many burgies you go almost anywhere and find that that's kind of consistent through throughout the island um and we did take um the parking when we looked at this we looked at The Monto Brewery and um I believe their tasting
093room is something around 3 or 400 square fet um and then they have a production so it's a very it's a very good model and Tom priato did make that determination here if it just so you have the numbers in your head 29% of this it's one story 29% of that first floor is is a retail area and that includes the bathrooms um and the the balance of it is is production which you never want the public in there and the purpose of using the retail calculation is is for 180 F feet for people to come in and buy a shirt in a retail store you don't want people in your production facility we don't even give tours anymore because there's just too many moving parts and canning and the it's wet it's stinky you
094know it's you're just not somewhere you want the public so I just want to highlight that because so much of this building 71% of this building is production Warehouse that will have two employees in it and that's why we designed the parking we have five for the retail space which includes people standing in the bathroom and two for the production facility and then we put two more spaces just because we could so we do feel comfortable with our use and the town code and how the model of Monto was modeled their parking we used it and then we added a little bit so I just wanted to make sure that that was clear in the record okay thank you thanks Britain um where are you producing now I'm just curious Brey there's a brewery there
095okay be nice to have it have it home right yeah like others on the board I I support the idea I think it's a really great addition to the neighborhood I think it's you know wonderful that you guys are Springs Springs folk you know uh this brings something really unique and interesting to the to the neighborhood for sure but having said that you know I just want to be kind of clear about intention and you know Britain has clarified some of this but you know saying stuff like year round socializing opportunities you know and then talking about limited uh on-site taste and sort of sound like two different things to me um you know there have been not only controversy about the proposed Brewery in eastampton village that Reed mentioned but there's also been another
096there was another application nearby in Springs where uh the the you know the idea that there would be alcohol served on premise was a really major your concern and this is right around the corner from you so I think there's there's got to be some way to to Really clarify a little bit about what I know as Britain was sort of saying the nature of breweries is such that it it isn't sort of a bar but we need to kind of really be certain that this idea of on-site tasting is kind of what it's what it's limited to and I think you know there use conversations that really have to be clarified here you know is it wholesale is it retail are you a bar you know I think we need to really understand what
097use were talking about because that will inform everything else that happens and what else we're able to approve and what else you might need a variance for but I think you get the sense that everyone on the board is sort of with you on this we want to work through those issues and make sure everybody is happy and the community is too on this so more work to be done thank you what Grand Spring Brewery Springs Brewery that's what it says on it's around good it's good good good thanks so much thank you David thank you guys questions once again questions yeah right thank God for you guys all right uh does the planning board agree with the planning Department's assessment of additional information must be provided per town code necess elements of a site
098plan yes yes does the planning board agree with the proposal is compatible with the surrounding area yes yeah is the planning board satisfied with the building inspector determination that the proposal should be considered a retail store I think that's TBD yeah agree with that everyone yeah yeah yeah all right thanks again okay all right so moving along uh the final matter that we're going to on for tonight is the way Scot commercial center uh this is a little bit of an unusual uh addition to a work session uh this is really going to be an informational session this is this is the first of two work sessions that the planning department and the applicants have worked together on that we're going to be having over the course of the next few weeks uh and this
099one because the planning board hasn't really been actively Eng engaged in this application since the public hearing which was I believe in February of 2023 the idea here is that we we're going to have a conversation and a presentation uh from our secret consultants and from the planning department on what's transpired since you know what have the communications been what kind of documentation has been submitted you know where do we stand and then from that uh the idea is that we will the recommendations will be made by our consultant that'll be shared with us and with the applicant and then we'll have an opportunity when the applicant is ready to have a substantive conversation so we're not going to be asking for any public comment you know after this presentation just think of it as
100in this is information okay the applicant will have an opportunity to to uh to share at the end of the presentation however thank thank you Ed uh Tina Lan for the planning department um I just want to make sure that our consultant team has joined Dan Russo um from White austman and Hannah our Seer outside Seer council is here as well as Peter f um from akrf um and Gwen re from akf there're the two of those are our lead planning Consultants so I'm just going to give a brief um a very brief overview before I turn it over to Peter as Edie mentioned tonight we we want to update the planning board on events that have transpired since the deis public Hearing in February of 2023 which is the last time the planning board
101as a entity interacted with the application um I just intro our Consultants um some of the members of the board have not met them um Peter and Fen were added during 2024 to the team to help facilitate uh draft environmental impact statement review and coordin very quickly after the public hearing and Reed of significant public comments in February 2023 the planning department had written a detailed comment report on the deis noting our recommendation that the um planning board did not have enough information to proceed to Seeker findings and requesting that a dialogue between the planning department um and the applic applicant be opened in order to figure out a Way Forward um from there a chain of events ensued including a significant amount of Correspondence between the planning department and the applicant and several meetings
102with the applicant where we coordinated um hands in hand with Sam Kramer the then chair of the planning board um as our m point of contact for the board Peter from akf is going to go through the details of those interactions because we want to bring the board up to speed on all that has transpired just from a high level so the board has that context tonight we're not going to talk about the detailed technical analysis that was performed during that time um we do want to have that conversation with the board um but that's not today today we just wanted to update you so you're all aware of everything that has happened that we're aware of and then in future conversation hopefully um in February or soon after we will talk about our recommendations
103for a draft scope for a supplemental Eis um so at at this point I want to turn it over to Peter and Peter if you want to share your screen you can or I can just flip through the presentation I'm happy to share it thank you and everyone can hear me okay sorry I get nervous with oh I'm so [Music] sorry did I hear it was very hard to hear me I should speak up no it was me oh okay thanks Peter go on okay good evening everyone um as Tina said my name is Peter foro um with the planning and engineering firm akrf uh I'm based out of our White Plains office and have been working with the town on this project uh for a little over a year um also been fortunate enough
104to work with the town on a few other projects um and uh am grateful for that opportunity um Tina said this is um the first planning board meeting um that this application the way Scott commercial center has been um before the board uh since March 2023 when the public hearing closed so tonight as Tina said we want to give you an overview of what has happened um since that public hearing closed um basically there have been a lot of comments received on the E there as Tina said correspondents uh meetings with the applicant we received um new and additional information and as Tina said we're not going to talk about the state of the technical analyses um that'll be subject of a future meeting with the board um and as both Tina and Ed said
105this is leading up to um a decision that the planning board needs to make acting in its capacity as Seeker lead Agency on the next steps in the Seeker process so tonight we're really just focusing on what's happened over the past nearly two years since this application has been in front of the board um all of this information is in the public record uh for the application but we wanted to make sure that we took this opportunity to kind of go over it um with you directly that's just a little bit about us Tina already talked about us we don't need to go in that so uh quick overview um for those who are not uh as familiar the this is kind of the basic outline of the project it's about uh it's a about
106a 70 70 and a half acre site in Wayne Scott um the applicant proposes it's a excuse me that the majority of the site is a former um and reclaimed sand and gravel mine um sine and um there are some existing uses on the project site uh mostly concentrated in the southern end of the site um the applicant proposes to subdivide the site um into 50 commercial Lots plus um two or three uh buffer Lots around the edges um two of those commercial Lots uh would be larger than all the rest they're in the southern end of the site they would have uh two of the existing uses on the site and the remaining 48 Lots would be be undeveloped um and would be planned to be um developed by separate entities over time with
107separate site plan approvals um Etc as part of the uh development the applicant proposes to install new roadways um certain utilities Drainage Systems um Etc so quick overview the deis for this project um was accepted as complete in November of 2022 comment period was held open until the end of March 23 um between that time the end of the comment period and uh let's call it April of 24 there was a procedural pause um in the application um the applicant submitted new material the department reviewed that material we're going to go through all of this in a lot more detail this is just kind of the big picture um between April and June there were uh several meetings between the applicant and the planning department and from June of 24 through now there were additional
108submissions by the applicant um there was review by the planning department and consultants and the development of next steps and recommendations and we'll go into all of that in a little bit more detail so the deis comment period um there were uh there was a public hearing on February 8th at which approximately 50 speakers spoke uh at two different time frames written comments All of which are in the public record um we received approximately 152 letters um from members of the public from various organizations uh many issues were discussed um you can read them all here I think you are familiar with many of them um and there were I want to note some additional public comments received after the close of the comment period um also in the public record they occupy kind of
109an interesting spot in Seeker procedure in that they don't necessarily have to be responded to um like a typical comment in a in an FIS um but they do need to be considered um in in kind of a uh in the board's review and we can get into that in a little bit later but again all of that is in the public record um in addition to public comments the board received comments from involved and interested agencies the FAA uh the Water Authority which appin that there was sufficient water capacity to serve the project the New York State DEC uh commented nyop provided some comments um and the suffk county uh Department of Health Services uh provided comments as you know they um that department um oversees sanitary disposal and and other items as well
110um their letters had a few different um important themes that it'll kind of carry through um they required uh this is a direct quote from their letter um an analysis of any and all alternative wastewater treatment disposal methods as well as a complete application um which application the applicant uh did make subsequent um the county department of health services also requested additional soil and groundwater investigations um and they recommended the incorporation of additional um mitigation measures um to address any uh subsurface contamination they also noted that they are the permitting Authority for certain on-site activities um with regards to the storage of certain hazardous materials petroleum products um and and others the suffa County Planning Commission ALS also submitted comments um as an in involved agency as you know the application was sent to them
111pursuant to uh the general Municipal law for referrals um the Planning Commission determined that the application um or referral was incomplete um and required additional information including an updated traffic study coordination with NIS do um an additional consideration of certain Alternatives after the close of the public comment period the planning department um issued its own letter um this letter had their own comments as well as summarized comments made by the town's other uh technical consultants uh which we'll get to um as Tina said um the letter requested additional information and analysis and stated its opinion that that information analysis was necessary um to provide the board with the information it needed to make its own secret findings um there were there were comments raised uh by the department around certain assumptions that were made across
112various impact categories that had to do with density and uses and and the consistency of those assumptions across impact categories um the letter noted that the project was um appeared inconsistent with certain aspects of the comprehensive plan and the Hamlet plan um but it's also important to note that the subdivision itself is substantially dimensionally and use compliant um with respect to the existing zoning on the site after the deis was accepted as complete um the zoning board of appeals made a determination that the subdivision itself is a planned Industrial Park use pursuant to the town zoning code and that use which is the subdivision requires the issuance of a special permit U that was also mentioned in the planning department letter um and as I said the town's traffic consultant engineering consultant and um um
113subsurface and groundwater consultant also supplied letters again in the public record and were referenced in the town's letters so that's what happened immediately after kind of the the deis was accepted as complete and the comment period was closed so after that letter was received um the applicant requested an adjournment of the application um the board agreed and executed a stipulation uh among the board and the applicant basically staying the timelines for review of the application pursuant to seeker and pursuant to uh Town regulations until um a mutually agreed upon time um the applicant requested that the department not appear before the planning board to discuss the comment letter in detail until the applicant had time to review it um noting that it was a very substantial letter uh the applicant said they would be happy
114to to meet with the Department um and would let the department know uh when that when they were ready and also important to note the applicant um strenuously objected to the Department's recommendation to the board that a supplemental environmental impact statement was required and they set forth their reasons uh for that objection uh as we said the department agreed um both you know recommended to the board to stay the timelines and also agreed not to discuss the comment letter until the applicant was ready um the department requested that the applicant contact the planning department set up the meetings um and noted that there was information that needed to be provided and kind of a dialogue that needed to be had regarding how um various agency comments um were responded to um and and they reiterated
115the department reiterated its recommendation of why they believe a supplemental was required um and provided a memorandum from the special Seeker Council um to that effect um a couple months later so now we're in September of 23 uh the applicant requested that a meeting was be scheduled between the planning board planning department um and the applicant to discuss um the process moving forward and other items uh at that point the planning board chair responded um and advised that the that in accordance with kind of previous conversations uh I'm Excuse me previous correspondents that the applicant should meet with the planning department before being on the planning board agenda um and you know let the let the applicant know it was their opinion that any technical reports that would be discussed uh obviously should be provided
116ahead of time um the planning board chair followed up with an email uh a couple weeks later um letting them know that it would not be possible to place them on a 2023 agenda at that point as it was now the middle of November um so after that correspondence uh the applicant again wrote a letter to the planning board chair advising that they were preparing a submission uh by the end of the year in response to the Department's comment letter and suggested that uh perhaps a meeting with the Department in January would be appropriate um and and agreed with the chair that um a meeting should have happen between the department and the applicant prior to being on a board agenda the chair responded to that letter um stating that they believe that timeline and
117procedural pathway was not uh well advised and was contrary to previous suggestions that prior to any submissions that a meeting beheld to discuss these issues and the pathway forward um and they the chair specifically noted that submissions that were made without the benefit of the planning department meetings could result in um delay of the application um on December 21st 2023 um the applicant made their submission the the submission that was noted in their November correspondence and that submission um in terms of substance um had uh quite a lot the within it was a an application for the special permit that was uh determined to be required by the zba it included um the applicant's responses to the planning department technical review letter and it included a new traffic impact study among other materials um there
118was also a number of procedural uh assertions that were made again setting forth the applicant's opinion uh that a supplemental impact statement wasn't required as well as the reasons um why they believe that to be the case um as well as asserting that the planning board did not have the authority or the basis to require uh additional subsurface environmental testing and a request that the planning board process the application in it in a regular way um and allow the applicant to complete responses to all substantive comments um that just as a note that December 23 submission uh was 7 to 800 Pages um as we kind of set forth it was not uh requested by the department or the board um and so it didn't benefit from a discussion about the format the topics the
119approach um and the new analysis that was presented um the traffic analysis um you know was didn't benefit necessarily from having a discussion about the scope of that study um so after that submission um early 2024 um there were several letters back and forth um the planning board chair acknowledged receipt of the submission uh requested a replenishment of the escrow uh reminded the the applicant that the deadlines continued to be stayed uh with respect to Seeker excuse me in town um review and uh noted that as was stated previously the department needed to review all submissions before the meetings and given that it was about 700 pages that that was likely going to take some time um the applicant responded uh less than a week later uh with an escrow replenishment check um and requested
120dates uh when the department would be ready uh for the meeting um so about two weeks later um the app the planning board chair responded um in two separate pieces of Correspondence um provided um time slots for the department and the staff and Consultants uh to meet um suggested two meetings to start with uh in early April um and noted that there were still a um in addition to some substantive uh disagreements there were still two major procedural issues that needed to be addressed uh one was the framework for addressing public comments um so not just the planning Department's comment letter which was addressed in the December submission U but the the balance of the public and agency comments as well as the approach to um responding to the suffa County Planning Commission uh which
121is in um procedurally is kind of an an odd interesting unique condition in that the town is actually the applicant to the Planning Commission uh as the referring agency um and so the town has this duty to um um perfect that application but obviously needs needs the information analysis from the applicant so that needs to be work through um so again immediately in response a couple days later the applicant agreed to the meeting dates um agreed to break out the uh responses to the Planning Commission um as well as to uh break out the approach um and framework for summarizing the comments um to ensure that they were addressed um and to and to ensure that um as you can see that both the teams the applicant team and the department and their Consultants uh
122would be satisfied um that those comments could be meaningfully addressed um the applicant again agreed to replenish the escrow but uh noted objections to certain uh consultant invoices um as it as was their right uh within the um framework of the agreement um setting up the escrow account so immediately PRI not immediately but prior to the first uh meetings between the applicant in the department the applicant did submit um various materials as as they indicated they would um including responses to the suffa County Planning Commission um and a description of the process to identify and categorize the public comments um not the categorization of the comments but the process by which that categorization would take place um and again you know reiterated their opinion um that an FIS or final environmental impact statement be prepared
123and not a supplemental and asserted the the reasons uh supporting that that opinion so moving on into April and June uh three meetings were held uh the first two were scheduled ahead of time um they were held at a town facility on Gan Road um the applicant was present as well as their Council and planners um that the planning department was represented along with the town attorney uh special Seer Council um and myself and Gwen uh to support the department so briefly I'm going to try to go through the the I'm not going to try I will I'm going to go through the agendas uh of the three meetings um they again those agendas are public record and they are uh in the public file and and in the packet that was prepared um so
124we began the April 10th meeting the first meeting um on a procedural basis just kind of laying out what the department um believed the pathway to be which was that the December 23 submission um was was very likely to form a part of a formal secret document there was a lot of information prepared um and and it it would definitely be able to form a part of a future document um but that the reality is the department still was of the opinion that additional information information was needed um in order to get in order for the board to have sufficient information to get to a finding statement which would close the Seeker process so we indicated that the goal of the meeting was to discuss how to get that information so we limit the back
125and forth and and are able to provide the planning board with information that they need uh in the most uh efficient way possible um the applicant again agreed on that and agreed to um provide the public comments which again form um a very important basis in Seeker for next steps um as it is the response to those comments from the public from agencies from organizations um that kind of help to inform the next Seeker steps um we moved on substantively to to speak about uh the Subdivision plat itself and the design and the documentation uh led by the the planning Department's engineering consultant um and supported by the applicants engineer as well um we discussed the layout and the roadways uh various easements and alignments of the new uh private roadways as well as the
126existing Private Road known as Hedges Lane uh we discussed storm water um types of storm water systems what would be required what documentation should be required what improvements uh may be needed and and that was uh discussed at length um issues related to noise uh were also discussed um the department reiterated kind of its um opinion and again the reasons therefore that an updated noise study was required um and that it should follow the dec guidance um akrf um and our um Acoustics group agreed to provide um a recommended scope and parameters to the applicant of what um it is that we believe the the noise study should um should should cover and and the applicant could then provide a scope um for kind of confirmation of this study at the next meeting uh about
127a week later um we discuss traffic uh unfortunately the town's Traffic Engineers couldn't be there there was a a late breaking illness that was uh best served by them not attending um the applicant traffic engineer uh did attend um and we we did speak through many uh of the traffic issues um issues regarding um the layout of the site U the the traffic model that was used in the deis as well as in the supplemental uh submission in December 23 um issues related to assumptions on routing and trip generation U mitigation measures dot coordination um and agreed that followup directly between the applicant's consultant and the planning board's consultant uh would take place to cover um the the precise next steps um that would be needed we then went in to is isues regarding subsurface
128contamination um the town's consultant from the fpm group joined uh the applicant consultant also uh joined from alpha alpha geoscience um we discussed some some difficult issues and some issues on which there was not um agreement necessarily um we discussed issues regarding um whether there was the need for additional characterization um additional sampling of the subsurface materials to um again characterize certain areas we discuss issues regarding potential mitigation measures um and again it was a difficult conversation but um it was a candid conversation and um at at the end of the conversation it was agreed that um a white paper um would be produced by the applicant um that would help uh present some more information present the existing information and in kind of a different way uh also including information on site history history
129of previous investigations applicable standards um and there was an agreement to um review the the scope the contents the table of contents uh and approach of that white paper prior to it being produced um which which act which did happen um that meeting went on to discuss issues of Wastewater and nitrogen loading um different Again difficult conversations um but uh meaningful substantive conversations regarding uh treatment systems models um comparisons of different Alternatives and impacts um again kind of resolution uh wasn't wasn't necessarily in the cards but but again there was this agreement to produce um some more information and a summary of these various issues um to better inform the discussions uh moving forward uh we discussed you know to end that meeting we discussed dates for for a third meeting um and um again
130kind of highlighted the need for the categorization of of public comments um so the final meeting the third and final meeting was June 20th um we began with uh again a procedural followup you know status of of kind of everyone's to-dos um we discussed the the need for and the implications of um the special permit for the planned Industrial Park uh which as I mentioned was determined to be required after the deis was complete so it was not addressed in the deis because it was not a known requirement excuse me um and so we we spoke about how that that need for the special permit would influence various analyses within the deis um and and we noted that the the plan for the project obviously had to comply with the special permit criteria um but
131that the special permit criteria um specifically consider and expect um what what's called what they what is defined in the code as an integrated plan for development um with and so we talked through kind of what that could mean what that does mean and how we might um how the department how the Consultants um might consider um evidence of that integrated plan for development and how it could impact the overall layout um we also spoke through um how to treat um the existing uses on the site um obviously we needed additional information um on those existing uses um as Tina said according to some of the um according to Department Records some of those uses on the site um lack certificates of occupancy some lack site plan um and this wasn't explicitly contemplated discussed in
132the deis um there was a mention in the deis that site plans would be required um it was UN the department understood uh we understood that to mean um when the lot lines got redrawn uh for the existing uses the access and configuration and coverage Etc would have to benefit from a site plan um but we didn't realize that the existing uses would would kind of need their own own site plan um today so we spoke through kind of how to uh address that um and then we spoke about the potential uh next steps with the planning board and the Department's um recommendations to the planning board and how we move forward um using all the information that was gathered the analysis that's provided and um and the coordination that had occurred so after those
133meetings were over um this is a little bit less this last section and I promise we're getting there to the end but the last section is a little less topical uh I'm sorry a little more topical and less chronological of kind of what happened after the end of the meeting so um the applicant produced um as was requested uh several technical um products so there's a product on on subsurface contamination um and the various investigations that occurred on the site um there was a product on Wastewater and nitrogen loading um a a new noise study um some traffic uh counts and um there was an annotation of theis um comment letters um and kind of a a markup so to speak of kind of what comments came out of various letters there was also an
134issue that the the board should be aware of with respect to the escrow which uh was covering the board's consultant fees um there was an initial agreement back when the application um first came in the applicant and and the town executed in Esco agreement where the applicant agreed to reimburse the town's cost of their Consultants up to the Limit established in the Seeker regulations and that limit um again per state regulations is half of 1% of the value of the land plus improvements um the value of the land is calculated as either the purchase price or the fair market value of the property as it is as it appears on the tax Ro so it's calculated on the tax R um at the end of September the applicant uh alerted the town that the limit
135uh was reached and and actually exceeded um the town um notified the applicant that you know they would review the calculations determine that um the applicant was correct that limit per secra was exceeded um per the assessment role uh the fair market value of the various tax Lots was a little over $17 million um and the the town engineer estimated the site improvements at approximately $5 million um so per Seeker regulations the maximum amount that the applicant um can be uh required to pay towards the review of this project was 113,000 um at that point the applicant had already funded the escrow at 150,000 and so the town um indicated that they needed to refund the applicant uh the balance of that money um so because of that there was a temporary pause in consultant
136work um our work um but Town staff continued to work on the application um the town board established a budget line to review the application and fund consultant works and and we were re-engaged um and that funding is now coming directly from the town so just a couple other notes on some other correspondents um after the meeting um the planning department and sent to the applicant uh I guess it's about two weeks after the the final meeting a summary of the action items um and established kind of next steps um the applicant responded um again reiterating they didn't believe that the next step should include an seis that it was not required um and suggested that the department waited until the end of the final meeting to uh make that recommendation um and they also
137stated um their belief that during the me during the meetings the second meeting um the department um agreed to withdraw its request or recommendation to the board that additional site characterization was required the planning department responded to that um stating its opinion that the Department's recommendation with respect to an seis was um pretty clear and consistently articulated throughout its correspondence um and that the meetings um helped to establish a framework for how to address various topical issues um and noted that the department did not believe and did not in in in actuality uh withdraw its recommendation or change its recommendation that additional subsurface testing um was required um there were some other correspondents that went back and forth some of this occurred um around the times of various submissions um that were made others with
138respect others occurred in and around the escro correspondence um and all of this was kind of pointing towards the next steps um which if the um planning board um decides that an seis is required would be the the scoping uh for that seis and so uh the applicant you know consistently requested that that process uh move forward so at the end of November um the planning department sent a letter to the applicant um kind of establishing the the the path forward um that noted that budget modifications uh were finally in place to allow the town to pay the consultant so that technical review could continue and it it indicated that the department would would schedule work sessions with the planning board um two of them uh the first is tonight and the first was you
139know the purpose of this meeting is to update the board with a summary of the events and the correspondence since the close of the deis and to kind of index a bunch of that correspondence and submissions um which which we did and that is what is occurred tonight just this kind of more procedural um update and then the second work session would be to discuss the next steps with Seeker um specifically to discuss the planning Department's recommendation um for supplemental environmental impact statement um but it's noted that this is a planning board decision that um that has to be made acting in the board's capacity as secet lead agency and there's a lot of technical information that needs to be digested and discussed um and uh certainly heard from the applicant as well so the
140department agreed to provide the board and the applicant um their detailed recommendations uh for a supplemental as well as um the scope or table of contents that it would recommend um and provide that information again to the department uh excuse me to the board and the applicant at the same time for review and schedule a work session when um the applicants had sufficient time to review that um information so that they could um be ready to have that technical discussion and that is the next work session um and so that's where we are now um I know it's a lot of material um and and uh you know I can take certain questions but again we want to focus on uh the procedure um and the correspondence uh tonight and not not get into the
141uh substantive discussion of various environmental topics um because one it's already getting late and and two we want to make sure that everyone's had enough time uh to be prepared uh for that so thank you very much for your time and attention um and again happy to discuss further if needed thank you Peter appreciate the very thorough review uh what's happened since the last time that we this in front of us formally excuse me U and we definitely look forward to getting your recommendations uh as I'm sure the applicant does and having a work session that's devoted to the substance of what happens next and you know the the rationale for and seis uh so as soon as we receive that and the applicant does we'll have an opportunity to both digest it and come
142back for that second work session that you described um Mr Ean did you want to address the the board I think the the idea here is that or Mr tintle Mr tintle would like to address oh okay uh yeah please but and again we're really here just to talk about this you know where we've come since the uh the public hearing and you know where we're going to go from here yes procedurally great John T N tle uh good evening board welcome new board members I believe we're down to just two original board members since we originally submitted uh thank you Tina thank you Peter for uh your thorough review well we're encouraged that the application has finally been put back on the agenda frankly continue to be frustrated by what can only be review
143reasonably viewed as dilatory tax tactics by both the planning department and this board this application was initially filed in January 2018 seven years ago we remind you that the application proposes A reduced density as of right subdivision the deis was finally declared complete and ready for public review in December 2022 over two years ago in April 2023 4 weeks after the closure of the public comment period the planning department filed 118 p pages of comments that asserted that after going through four rounds of completeness review and being accepted as complete and adequate for the purpose of public review that the disis should now be deemed incomplete Andor require substantial revision or even the preparation of a supplemental environmental impact statement which essentially triggers a redo of the entire secret process in response our experts were
144forced to work during the next eight months to prepare a lengthy submission submitted in December 2023 they clearly established that the planning Department's April 23 comments were nothing more than a baseless attempt to derail the application based on one backtracking of previous planning department and planning board decisions and guidance number two backtracking by the planning board's experts three multiple false claims that the deis did not file the final scope adopted by the planning board and finally fourth cherry-picking C of certain comments from the public hearing despite the fact fact that those comments conflicted with its own experts comments in the record and reflected in the de we note that while the planning Department's April 2823 submission is included in this evening's agenda the applicant's 873 page December 203 2023 response was omitted we then had
145to wait many months for three meetings with the planning department and its experts held over a 3-month period in April through June of 2024 at the conclusion of those meetings we were promised a proposed scope for the supplemental deis by September of last year 3 months after the conclusion of of our meetings we're still waiting for it we retained New York litigation Council who after reviewing the record of this application have advised us that the above timeline clearly constit constitutes dilatory tactics by the planning department in this board designed to dissuade my family from pursuing this application my family has owned this property since 1984 when we purchased it purchased it from the degate family we reclaimed the former sand mine and surrendered our New York State DEC mine land R land reclamation permit and
146received our Reclamation shy Bond back signifying our successful completion of the Reclamation in 1998 this is the third attempt by my family to develop the property which as you know has been zoned as commercial industrial since the Inception of zoning in the late 50s zoning status has remained unchanged by two different town comprehensive plans and the Hamlet study we've spent millions of dollars and have devoted thousands of hours of my and our experts time pursuing this application rest assured that my family remains committed to pursuing this application in good faith finally I'd like to suggest the most reasonable path forward it is the Hamlet plan alternative that is included and extensively discussed in the deis the date the Hamlet plan alternative has been completely ignored by the planning department F board and its experts we
147repeatedly been told that our submission does not properly implement the hamlock plan we respectfully remind this board that the public use has called for in the hamlock plan a public park for almost half the property affordable housing a train station and public parking are inconsistent with the long-standing zoning classification for the site and therefore are Beyond a private party's legal ability to implement moreover as we have advised the board on multiple occasion the only occasions the only legal way for the town to develop a park at the site is for the town to purchase a port portion of the parcel for that purpose longstanding New York Court of Appeals president have made this clear to date we are the only party to offer a way for the town to implement the public portion of the
148Hammet plan namely we've agreed to the planning Department's request to develop the subdivision in two phases we've also offered to Grant the town board fiveyear options to purchase phase two of the subdivision the land subject to the options is sufficient to implement the public portion of the Hamet plan would also greatly reduce the density of the subdivision our New York lication Council has advised us that is legally untenable for the town to claim that our subdivision has failed to implement the Hamet plan when the town is the only entity with the legal capacity to do so but has failed to take any action New York Council has further advised us that the denial on these grounds will not survive judicial scrutiny the fact that our December submission was not included in the review uh uh
149I think is important and I implore the board to review that submission uh and the submissions that we have made sub subsequent to the meetings that we had with the planning uh Department in this past spring uh as I stated we remain committed to this this process we've been in it now seven years uh and we'll see it through to the end uh I encourage any of the board members especially new board members if you would like to see or tour the facility uh to contact me I'm there every day and'll be happy to lead you in a tour again I thank you for your time this evening thank you Mr titel I appreciate your comments some of us may actually take you up on the on the tour um yeah so next steps um
150are what they are which is for us to review the recommendations of uh our consultants and in the planning department and you know we will you know obviously take those in as well as the 700 plus pages of documentation that we have to to to look over and and take in your comments as well as we make a decision as to where we're going to go from here next seis or no seis um so there's not much more that we can say about that at this point you know until we receive those recommendations and we have an opportunity to talk again based around that can I just I'm sorry the um the December 2023 submission of the applicant is linked in the presentation and it is on the web um we didn't just include it
151in the package it was huge the package already um so there was a link and it is on the web I can definitely forward a link to the planning board just for easy access okay so what is in there and public on the web and linked and yes it's not in the PDF that you receive that is uploaded for this package um but the link to that material is in the package and the material itself has is on the website and has been along with the uh other submissions of the applicant um but Mr tindles corrected it was not included in that PDF of the packet okay but the public can access it yeah yes um okay I think we're good for now thank you very much for your attention this was very helpful to
152us and hopefully it was to you to remind you of where we've been where we've come where we're going and we will speak again soon yeah thank you everybody for that yeah all right uh so ends the work session we have a couple of other things to discuss a couple of housekeeping items first uh then we have to adopt our minutes from the last meeting um Dan and Peter and Gwen thank you if you're not already gone have a good night thank you yeah thanks very much thank you U so the first quick items these are three very quick items uh the first is pre- meating protocol going forward a couple of couple of us have talked about how we want to manage this AA has had an opportunity to sit on a few as
153a new member Reed is going to sit in on a few you know coming up as well he did today uh but you know once we sort of get past the Newbie phase we'll be opening this up to a third person to come on board you know as as they have you know significant uh applications that would benefit from discussion before the meeting and if there's more than one you know in any given meeting we'll figure out a way to have people come in and out of the meeting because as you know it's we're sort of limited to three so in the coming weeks um you know once Reed has sort of gotten up to speed on who everybody is and how we work things now he was on the planning board before of course
154but things have changed a little bit so I think it's important for Reed to take that spot we'll just play this a little bit by ear but it's Our intention to continue to have people come into the meeting it really makes this meeting go a lot better A lot faster uh the other thing Jen actually brought this up and I'm glad that you mentioned it the the annual disclosure statement that we're all meant to sign and give to the town clerk if you haven't done that yet please do it does need to be notorized but you actually there are notaries in the town's clerk town clerk's office so if you fill it out bring it to to the office there will be someone there to notorized it for you uh you don't need to do
155it and Reed I don't think you need to do it because it was for 2024 the year that just ended so I was you were appointed yes oh you were so you do need to do it did you receive it no okay I think Reed may still have to do it we'll find that out I didn't have to do it when I started last year at this time did you I don't think so I was ask where did we get it uh Jody sent it yeah it's in it's in your email it's an email from Jody right it's called double check annual closure HD adhs form or something like that and it's yeah and there is a notary as um Ed mentioned at the clerk's office two of them actually so you should BL out
156yeah well that's where you were return it to the clerk yeah exactly and they can notorized it right there and I believe that the meeting that they're all going to be reviewed at is the 31st I think so um yeah they theoretically were due last week yeah they were due on the 16th so if you haven't done that didn't take it I I actually guilty went down to the same thing clerk's office tu morning and turn fine in okay all right it's just a reminder about that uh and then the final thing is I wanted Tina just to talk a little bit about open gov and you know some some new things coming down the line regarding paper yes um and I'm I'm glad that you know Ed and Jen you were already thinking about
157how much paper we all use and the discharge of our duties here and and and it is a bit excessive um one of the initia uh that the town board has asked us all to implement is open it is an online application and permitting system the planning department is going to be migrating all the applications that we currently manage to the online environment um in the next few months and we invited the board members to an information session just to um preview what the changes that you were going to experience are going to be um you know we are still going to provide you the same reports that we do now we'll make sure you have access to the application materials but the format uh all all those things will be different and and the
158purpose of all of this um is really important right we're trying to enhance collaboration between Town departments enhance the efficiency with which we process applications just right now so many touches um really could be minimized and then you know of course reduce the amount of paper um we just have boxes and boxes and file and rooms and basement room and it's cous um the amount of paper so we're really you know we know it's going to be a change but we're hoping everybody will work with us to be comfortable with um reduction there all right so we'll learn if we come to the session on the 7th February I believe it is we can we can learn more about how it's going to yeah the details and then you know also going to have a
159um a meeting with the applicant Community we haven't scheduled that yet but we're going to invite everybody who files with us to a similar session that will go through how their um interaction with us will change with this new system um and it's a really intuitive system which is great I mean we all now interact with the environment of the you know the web all the time filling out online forms and stuff like this this system is very much based on kind of everything you do in those kind of Realms just very simple um you can kind of review your online queue um see where your applications are at um so I think it's really going to be great for the town okay that's great it's a a I'm not gonna be able to make
160that will there be a tape recording of we weren going to record it but you're not the only person who asked so I'll look into if we can get it recorded and how does this affect the current online uh information that's available for each app for each meeting actually you know how you can go on the meeting yeah we're still going to do that because we want to make sure that both the board and the public have access to like all the information they need to follow along with the meeting how is this new thing going to differ from what I can get online right now in terms of the meeting information it will not we're not going to change that but in terms of you know how you guys all have a mailbox right
161now and every time something comes in you get it in there we're not going to be doing stuff like that anymore um we're going to be sending you an email with a link or a PDF to the files asking you to review them so in other words files that are not available online right now at the planning board site which we get in our mailbox in paper form will now that that those documents in paper form will be available online to us that's the difference no the speed with which we like release those documents is going to change just like your first viewing of them and and and that will change um so what about the the uh documents themselves right now we get a planners report online yeah for we get a meeting's agenda
162and you can go on to the agenda look at every application you'll still get that that won't so what am I going to get new that's not online right now will not get the paper the all the background stuff and the applicant also will be work will apply via this online portal as well will be no the fire Marshall's determination kind of thing so right now the big stuff that I get in my mailbox usually are the plan yeah you're not going to get that anymore how the problem is that when you get a plan online it's so small sometimes that you can't make it out you know usually the paper plan is as wide as this table right so so how did you address that issue so we and that's why we wanted to
163have the information session with the board so we could get everybody's feedback and make sure that the board's needs are still met in the new system the thought was we would take one paper copy per submission for both the file and anybody who felt like they needed to view the paper copy that's preliminary that might not be enough maybe we'll take two copies per submission one for the f one for people to look at um but we're not going to right now we take nine okay and and nine yeah it's insane you know for like a big project it's it's boxes and boxes and it's it's a waste yeah um so one maybe two and like I'm saying very preliminary stuff right now we wanted to talk to everybody before we finalized the approach you
164know like here you like let us tell you what we're thinking you tell us what you need um but that's the thinking one or two Max maimum per submission and we all will have to adapt to the online I mean I review most plans digitally but for some big complicated ones you do have to unroll the paper so you know I get it one gross example of this terrible paper waste is this application the Wayne Scott commercial center I have in my office four or five binders this thick which the the information that you just sent the PDF form which was 500 and some odd page it's so much easier to screen and go through it and read online because you can scroll up and down you can reference stuff go back to it it's
165harder to do with the the paper itself an e is a perfect example of something that should never be printed in my opinion they're always really really long and aside from myself having read some of them cover to cover I don't think many people do you know you really look get the stuff that interest you and Skip around um so yeah huge reports that's not going to be we're not doing that anymore so more to come um please join us and we'll we'll try to record that session so people who aren't there session is this a state initiative is that where all this comes from no no this is the town board W to you know that's great that's terrific it is it's a great idea great thanks I just wanted our technology um department
166has done a ton to get this happening and really um really has been great so I want to just thank them good thumbs up to them absolutely yeah for sure all right the final thing is to adopt the minutes um did you want to make us yes um well I wanted we wanted to make that one change want to add to the minutes the notation that the board discussed and decided not to pursue an article 78 proceeding against the town on the I think it should be Senior Center I think that should be recorded um but after that change is made I move to adopt minutes second all in favor all right we need another motion I mov to end the meeting all right all in fav SLE at the wheel a second on that
167okay thank you