CorpusRecord 135468

East Hampton Town Planning Board Meeting 01/15/2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / LTV East Hampton
Date
2025-01-16
Location
Suffolk County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
14,367 words · about 80 min
Collected
2026-06-18

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e okay planning board we are live we are recording phone lines will remain off go for it okay welcome everybody to the town of East Hampton planning board meeting for January 15 2025 our first meeting of the year um as you can see there have been a few changes around the table including me sitting in the chair's position um but I wanted to start off by welcoming our newest member Reed Jones thank you who um ironically is the guy that got me involved in this public service stuff 10 years ago when he recommended that I speak to Larry kwell about an ARB position and then here we are you planning board chair at that time I believe right I think so yeah so we appreciate having your experience and history on the board thanks for

002stepping up um I also want to mention that Jen folks has stepped up to be Vice chair of the board so thanks for stepping up I look forward to working with you on this a couple of other acknowledgements Tina Laren is now the planning director moved up from acting planning director which we're really new happy to see um and in the spirit of rotation our attorneys are going to be switching places um Nancy thank you for your OBS service for how many years has it been since you've been our Council quite a number of years right yeah um Charlie uh Colin is going to be switching places with Nancy in the coming weeks uh and will be our Council going forward so lots of changes to look forward to and of course I want to

003acknowledge our other returning hardworking board members Lou Cortez Mike Hansen uh Bruce cisa who is on zoom and are not any longer newest member Ava Warren and of course Jody who keeps us all honest and on track so thank you um so I just I wanted to begin my tenure as the chairperson of the board with a few comments and an acknowledgment to my predecessor Sam Kramer uh for all the energy and intelligence that he has brought over the Decades of his public service to this town and to this County and particularly as chair of this board um he taught me a lot about the duty and responsibility of being a board member and I really appreciate that and appreciate his service but as he said to me a few weeks ago uh the board

004is built for Change and members and leaders will rotate and that's a good thing leadership styles will change and one of those things that will change uh comes from the fact that I'm not a lawyer like Sam uh I'm a builder and a designer so I'll be calling Upon Our Council and our planning department in perhaps a bit of a different way than than Sam did going forward um so what I do bring just to offer up a couple of of credentials for those of you who may not know me well uh is I do have an academic background in landscape of architecture and Urban Design from the University of Virginia School of Architecture and I have been a board member of the ponic land trust and most recently the chair of that board uh

005for the last 12 years and that of course is in addition to serving on this board for seven years and three years before that on the ARB so I do I've been around land conservation and planning issues for a long time uh just wanted to say too that at the at the core of the work that we do here it's clear to me that maintaining the rural character of this town that we love so much is rural character and a healthy environment is really the core principle that that I operate from um I think we have to strike a balance between conservation and property owners rights and the needs of the the community and for our economy but I'm committed to that idea and at service to that it's also important to note that I'm

006committed to maintaining the independence and autonomy of this board going forward so just a few comments about you know what to expect going forward we have some very challenging work to do as a team so thanks for indulging me in that um all right so we have four matters on for work session tonight and we have two for our regular meeting so we should get started um our first matter is an update on the senior center uh there have been a number of significant Milestones that we've passed uh since we last reviewed this project as a board many months ago so I've asked Tina to put together a presentation on what has transpired uh over the life of the project and uh including a timeline of where this you know the work that's been done

007on this project over the course of many years so Tina if you would than you good evening everybody um Tina from the planning department so we we wanted to take the opportunity to update the planning board on activities uh associated with the senior centor since the project was last seen by the planning board in June of 2023 um the plan will be coming back to the board for comments in the future and we figured to have this background would be a really good foundation for the those discussions the next few slides are going to review some of the timelines uh and Milestones that have occurred uh for the project as it's progressed in its different Realms Outreach craa and the Monro balancing test and after I go through that I will take you through a

008very high level review of some of the substantive analyses that have occurred um associated with those different project activities I can't go through everything it would it would take two hours um I can but I won't and you know we can definitely any question at the end we can definitely talk through so this uh slide just puts some background information regarding the design process this all happened or a lot of it did before the planning board saw the project in June of 2023 but it is just to provide um the context for the type of Outreach that was conducted in order to inform the design process that was undertaken um you'll see here that there's a variety of strategies that were used to facilitate public engagement meetings tours surveys and that's the appropriate way to

009kind of make sure you get participation from different folks some may be more comfortable participating in one venue vers another um so this just provides some highlights of like how the project design progressed I do want everybody to know that there is a um web page devoted to the senior center where more public documents are available regarding some of the things I'm going to talk about here tonight um and this does provide a more comprehensive listing of the types of activities the design as it's progress um the discussions with the town board um so that's an available resource and the um the website address is right on this presentation here regarding the state environment quality review or secret process the secret process has been progressing since December 2023 as a type one action under secra

010the long form and a coordinated review were both utilized to conduct the environmental review um as you can see the secer process included many um technical studies during that uh year-long period there were traffic impact studies storm water and W analyses archaeological reports a biological impact assessment so there were several um detailed environmental analyses as well as you know technical and Architectural environmental designs U that went into informing the secet process so the some of those parts are that CRA has been um complied with both in terms of the procedural and substantive requirements of the law and the project has provided a high level of Environmental Protection for the site where it will be located as I'll give you the overview of as we progress regarding the mro process the mro process was also conducted

011over um over a year of time the ninepoint Monroe balancing test as it's referred to uh was established via case law and it is a framework whereby public entities can immune themselves from local zoning requirements for specific types of projects um as you can see here there were public discussions on several occas regarding the substance of the Monro balancing test and uh it was concluded in December of 2024 and I will talk a little bit more about what that um involves later last week I sent the planning board a package of material that um included some of the highlights of the environmental review and the Monroe analysis I'm going to walk through some of those very quickly here um and it's going to contain some of the work I did for the planning department my

012staff did and as well as outside Council to the town um so I'm going to summarize all that at a high level now I am going to skip through all this detail as I said but um I gave two presentations to the town board regarding the environmental assessment for for part two that is the part of the environmental assessment process the secret process that we use the impacts of the proposed action and whether they are small or large just a quick refresher for some folks who haven't seen the site for a while the senior center is located at 403 Abrahams path in M ganit um this is Abraham's path the L tracks are right here um this is the sporttime facility Abraham Park le le haes Arc so um as I'm saying the two public

013presentations given sorry I clicked too much there um went through the eaf part two in great detail and the substance of those conversations were characterizing characterizing the impacts with respect to whether they were moderate to large or none to small and all of those conversations were Guided by the guidance of the New York State DEC they have workbooks for the eaf you are supposed to follow those framework the framework that DEC has set out in um in filling out those forms and I walked the town board through how we did that um on two separate occasions to highlight some of the information that was discussed in those some kind of the big picture environmental analyses of the project so so with respect to the impacts on land the first category really looks at the physical

014disturbance associated with the proposed project and this was actually the only um category where moderate to large impacts were noted you do have to check moderate to large when numerical thresholds and the um impact assessment criteria categories are exceeded and for two of the categories on land they were exceeded and that with respect uh with respect to the length of the construction period as well as construction on slopes 15 % or greater for both of those they were adequately addressed via um controls built into the project specifically stormw pollution prevention plan has been prepared by lkma licensed Engineers who have provided adequate erosion and fation controls to and and post construction storm water controls in order to ensure um minimization of storm water concerns and the construction phasing is necessary due to the presence of

015the northern longard bat I'll talk more about that later but the phasing plan prohibits construction during sensitive times of the bat's life cycle and only allows clearing during the winter cycle for dec's guidance um with respect to when um an incidental take perit is is not required moving along um those were the only moderate to large impacts so with respect to surface water ground water sanitary Wastewater management I mentioned the Swip the storm water management system is designed to a 3-in storm event that is um an excess of what the town cold requires again providing a higher level of environmental support the um IA system is going to be installed the proposed flow is less than the allowable density flow on the site which is appropriate no variances or anything else like that needed um

016clicking through um the northern longard bat this was an area where we did actually um perform technical analyses with the help of qu qualified um environmental biologists who conducted a site visit to determine whether or not incidental take might be triggered by the project um we also coordinated with New York State DEC and the US fish and wildlife serf uh surface regarding the northern La near bat potential presence DEC signed off and said that there was no permit required as long as we um adhered to the clearing window the US fish and wildlife service had suggested that we do an internal review to ensure that there'd be no impacts and um that's why we did the biological assessment there were no impacts identified and there was a second presentation that is later in the package

017they changed their guidance Midstream of us doing this environmental review and once they issued the changed guidance we then again had the qualified biologist go look at the changed guidance and make sure that that didn't change any conclusions and it did not turn out our protections proposed restrictor than what the US Fish Wildlife service would prescribe um so that issue was thoroughly analyzed and carefully addressed um regarding remainer there no Aesthetics not really um viewable from the main roads there was a traffic impact study done with a level of service analysis that concluded no impacts to level of service would be um occurring there was a noise analysis done to Ure that the emergency generator um noise levels were not inappropriate and um inconsistent with the noise code there is an assertion that the project

018is consistent with the comprehensive plan an important an important consideration um and then I I mentioned the archaeological study but I through that so that was the impact assessment that was discussed on October 15th and then there was a second follow-up presentation in November that really focused on the bat just um to confirm that the change tiance didn't change the conclusions in the package I provided to you guys um the eaf form was included for some reason the check marks disappeared in the public version I will repost that online but the one I sent the board did have the check marks included um then the negative Declaration was issued in November 19th the negative declaration again um was adopted via resolution by the town board and really summarized all the impact analyses and concluded that

019there was no potential significant adverse impacts on the environment on Monroe um as I mentioned earlier case law has resulted in the Monroe balancing test being a tool for local governments um that recog izes that Municipal entities or actions proposed by those entities may be exempt from zoning um there's a nine Factor test that a project must analyze in order to determine whether or not the balancing is an appropriate course of action and here's the nine factors um that is involved so in December the town board did adopt a resolution that um went through each of these in detail as is appropriate when an entity is going to make a decision like this they are required to do the balancing test and the findings are um all in the resolution issued in December so just

020to give a quick overview of those um regarding one two and three really cover the nature and scope of the action the authority of the entity proposing it and the kind of functions involved right the town board is an entity that has the authority to do this and this is a a public use project so so these are the types of projects that the test is intended to look at regarding criteria 4 it looks like the impact of local land use regulation and what would happen to the project if it were subject to those regulations so in this case the analysis set forth how the implementation of the full amount of zoning controls would inhibit the ability of the project to meet the full scope that it is intended to meet this section of the

021analysis also noted that the town board in order to inform the scope had consulted with the town's population on multiple occasions to inform what was needed on the site regarding criteria five that says are there alternative locations and less restrictive zoning districts that would allow the purpose of the project to be met um in a way that didn't require Monroe the analysis here goes through that there were alternate sites looked at but were not the size um including the existing center of the senior um Center which is quite constrained in terms of um size and is not a central location like the other facility were so there were some sighting criteria that the town board wanted would achieve central location ample size close to public transportation those are kind of hard to find in this

022town um this site met all the criteria and um is also located near other facili ities that are like publicly used support time facilities say community location lots of different um activities happen there the parks which are also kind of gathering places um you know maybe the grandsons at the Abraham pathfield playing a game or Terry King and you know Senior Center they can hang out and have a couple coffee or something who knows um regarding item six the impact of local interests um 67 and8 just combined the the impact of local interests alternative methods for providing the service and the extent of public interest to be served right so there's really no alternative to providing a senior center than than building one right so this is um just sums up that it's a needed

023function it's consistent with the comprehensive plan and the need is growing right based on the demographic studies that the town has has performed um and it'll also be just just to remind everybody because I think we forget a lot it will also be the office of Human Services we have a human services department that their offices are also d ated and constrained they need a place to function they they perform a huge amount of um services to the town and then item nine is regarding um public participation and intergovernmental participation and the Monro analysis does say that the planning board will have another chance to comment as will the ARB and again that a lot of participation has already been um encouraged so that concludes my very very very quick I hope it was quick

024enough overview um just to sum it up I hope it's clear how much work has done into this and you know the planning department has conducted the environmental analysis working with Town's engineers and Architects we've applied the same standard of care that we would to any other project to this one so the work was thoroughly done and and in accordance with um professional guidelines and and accepted practices in zra I'm happy to answer any questions thanks te that was really a very comprehensive and quick overview of a very complicated project so thank you for that are there any questions about the materials that are that were in the packet or anything that so will there be geothermal and solar panels in this yes both okay yes the facility aspires to be net zero right so

025um maximizing those types of facilities is important I just recall some question about geothermal so thank you yeah any other questions about we just presented or any of the materials that we have in our packets not so much about uh the material that was presented but my question is what is our function in all of this in the approval process for this project what is expected of the planning board we are going to talk about that but eventually it's site we have site plan review we have a 30-day period in which to react to to the site plan we have that that is on the calendar for us to review the site plan but you know this is really this is now being driven by the town board um so when you say we're going

026to review the site plan we're going to review the site plan like we would for any other site plan that comes in front of us except that whatever we whatever comments we come up with simply just be forwarded to the town board for their consideration essentially yes that's right yeah you know we are advisory to them on on this you know particularly since they've applied this monal balancing test they are kind of exempt from any zoning considerations they don't need site plan approval but they still want the planning board to comment on the plan and when it's ready um it will come back and you guys can review it I me I guess similar to his Zing code change you know like you'll have a discussion and we we'll send formal written comments to the

027board for their consideration and they'll think about how to address them okay thank you any other questions for for Tina okay um so yeah know I think it's pretty clear that this was a very thorough process right they're you know going back to 2022 and even before that you know there have been listening sessions tours public hearings there's been you know all sorts of opportunities for input along the way um and this was brought to us actually for it's kind of preliminary site review in 2023 we actually had reasonably positive things to say about it at that point that was before however the town board became lead agency right which sort of changed the dynamic a little bit but nonetheless once they did become lead agency all the things that Tina just described happened you

028know eaf the biological review by the outside Consultants on the longear bat situation you know all the thorough review that the planning department did on environmental impacts and I think they you know it's clear from you're having written a negative declaration for the town board that the impacts can be and will be minimized in the plan going forward so I think you know a thorough job was really done by the town board um I just want to be clear though that my feelings about this are that we could have added a lot to this process you know if we had been involved in this in a different way and from an earlier point in in the design process um I think there's a lot that we could have that we could have offered up uh

029but and we did in fact as everyone knows challenge the lead agency bid by the town board with the dec the dec decided on the town board's behalf in that in that matter um but the work that Tina described went on you know after that obviously and uh has concluded with this negative declaration the second thing that Tina talked about in terms of you know actions the town board took was this Monroe balancing test right and you know thanks for going through the nine points and you know how each of them was addressed by the balancing test um I think uh I I do think that in in many ways the towns adopting that uh does diminish to some degree our standing as a board you know and I really would have preferred that that

030that this not happened but it did and having done a little bit of homework on this it's very clear to me that any kind of action that we might take in article 78 for example um uh to to challenge that would our chances of prevailing in such a matter are pretty much nil of and I have that on good authority um so I'm bringing this up of of course because this has been suggested that this is something that we might do by by Sam and it's in the minutes actually from a December 18th meeting that that was brought up and other people in the community also seemed to sort of support this idea um but you know it's my own opinion I want to go around the around the the table and hear what everyone

031else has to say about this but my feeling is that you know given that our chances are prevailing are slim it seems like a pointless exercise I know that some people people who Pro were promoting this idea may not thinking that winning this is really the point so much but uh I think most people in this town would find this to be kind of a waste of time and and taxpayer money moving forward and frankly even if we were in somehow to Prevail the role that we would have you know going forward is very unclear right and it doesn't really comport with the purview of of this board particularly um so it's pretty clear to me that um it's not something that we should pursue um and continue to move along quickly and devote our

032time and energy to other matters and that we have several very important and significant uh applications coming up this year and I think it's a it's a better use of our time to move ahead that way um so but I do want to hear from everyone else on the board their their feelings about this so I think we need to close out that question question Jen we'll start with you um so thank you first of all thank you Tina um I I agree with Ed um that you know having done a little bit of research on article 78 proceedings I I don't think that you know for lack of a better word I don't think we'd be successful in challenging um personally I don't feel that we should be challenging the town board I do

033think that this action and this project is well within their purview as the town board um considering that it is you know kind of a municipal use and they did have every right to use this Monro balancing um formula to to decide it while I do think that it would have been wonderful if we did have some more input on the actual planning process I think that the town has done due diligence has worked very hard with the planning department and I don't see any reason to um you know consider any sort of challenge to the town's Authority on this one thanks Jane so I appreciate Sam Kramer's uh effort to uh uh signify Mark present the independence and autonomy of this board as you have also done just a moment ago goad uh that's

034important uh I said all along when I if if there had been an application in front of us that had the work that the senior center had put together I would I would be jumping for joy there's so much work that's already been done in this project and this is this is the town board's baby thanks Michael Bruce we'll go to you next you with us Bruce hi can you hear me yes yes yes yeah um I agree pretty much with everything that Ed and Jen and Mike have said um obviously you know I came on to this board sort of in the end of this process but you know I'm happy to hear that the planning department has put in their due diligence and it sounds like they've sort of went over and above

035um what they typically do which I think is great so I think you know unfortunately you know we don't get our sort of say in the matter however I think um our planning department has done what they needed to do to to sort of guide this project along and you know I do appreciate what what Sam has or did start and and sort of wanted us to follow through with however I I I I just feel that it's it's at this point it's kind of a waste of waste of our time our energy taxpayer money and in the end I really don't think we're going to be any further ahead um than we are right now so I I I'm good with you know just taking a step back and and forging forging ahead okay

036thanks Bruce Reed did you want to opine well well thank you and and I I think Tina I thought she gave a very good overview of the the situation um I'm relatively uh well I'm new to the board I'm new to the application but I'm familiar with it um my feeling is uh an article 78 or lawsuit of any nature at this point would be counterproductive and I think it's time to move forward good thanks appreciate it AA just kind of to Echo what everyone's saying and especially where Bruce left off you know coming in a little later on this application having some background on it um I can certainly appreciate the extreme due diligence that the planning department and Tina specifically you know has done on this application and again going over and Beyond

037you know like Michael said this is this was granted to the town it is their baby and I think you know pursuing any litigation is just going to further prolong issues and halt you know what could potentially be you know a good addition to this town so I I think let's just go forward and provide our comments you know within the the 30-day window and if they're taken they're taken at least we'll have some skin in the game in that sense providing our recommendations okay thanks L yeah I I agree with everyone uh that I I think uh in article 78 right now would be counterproductive it wouldn't really gain us anything but having said that I I do want to make some comments about our role and uh the lack of our role in

038the process um I I think um you know although Tina and the planning department have done a very thorough review as they do of all applications that come in front of them and they haven't done anything differently here I think that's great but there are issues that come up which is always the case the way we operate they do a review they bring us the issues and then we deliberate over those issues and we decide whether or not to Grant certain variances relax certain restrictions and so forth and you know what what one of the things that I've always felt uh strongly about we a lot of times we get applications in front of us where the applicant has uh put together a plan for the project and then they feel as though going through

039the process of going in front of the planning board for site plan review is just sort of like a rubber stamp and my feeling is that in those cases uh there are certain factors that are more important than the plan that was put together by the applicant uh and the way to remedy that is not to relax those restrictions those zoning code restrictions but to change change the plan that the applicant has come in front of a in front of the board with so having said all that I think that's the case in my my view and I don't want to minimize the work that the town board has put into this I think it's a Monumental project I think it's a very necessary project and I give all the credit due to the board

040for putting it together and working hard to do it I however having said that I have some questions about certain aspects of the project which I would have felt more comfortable if we had the power of the planning board as we usually do to bring that to the four I don't want to get into those issues now there's another time for us to go through it but uh so article 78 not you know not going to be a good thing to do right now but I do want to voice my concerns that I wish we would have had the usual site plan review that we have for for other projects and I and I think I have good reasons for it and one one last thing I again I don't want to be too critical

041of the Town board because I'm all for what they're trying to do with this project but I also think that there's a conflict of interest here with regard to the Monroe uh balancing test and so forth I think they have a certain bias that again would have been uh mitigated if we had done a site plan review instead of the Town board deciding whether or not the projects uh the way the project is put together should be the project that they go through with those are my comments thanks Lou yeah you know I agree with you I I think I Ed out by saying that that I think we could have added a lot to this process and I think that uh that the well first of all the Monro balancing test adopting it was

042really not a unanimous decision by the town board which is revealing I think in a way right but they did it did pass they did adopt it they are exempt from our input uh it's it's uh it's something that I hope the town doesn't continue to do with newer projects but yeah I agree we could have added a lot I think I have some very specific ific uh comments about it myself that I would have shared if we'd had proper site plan review but here we are and I think that we're the consensus here is that we are not pursuing any other legal action um is that fair to say yes it's unanimous so I think we can we can move on do Bruce Bruce yeah he's with us he's with us okay all right

043if there's nothing else on that let's move on to the next uh application which is the three mile Harbor affordable housing um Lou that is yours Dan are you presenting on that will oh will I sorry okay and the applicant is here for that it's the well no it's the housing author Housing Authority yeah actually ith oh right yeah but it's the Housing Authority though what do we the applicant is not present yeah not present um I think usually we do not um discuss it I did not know they were not going to be here I'm sure they were contacted both by email and phone as is our regular practice um he in the application I think we should I mean because we need their reaction to to this right it's difficult to discuss the

044application if they're not here to to contribute to it yeah I agree along all right sorry all right in that case we'll move right all right thanks for coming will um we'll move on to 267 aabon uh Jen that's yours Dan you are going to present this time right okay all right oh and the applicant is here right great [Music] [Applause] [Music] okay all right well uh good evening uh Mr chairman in planning board and happy uh Happy New Year first meeting of the year so this is a application U followup review of an application to subdivide a approximately 1.2 acre LT on AC on aconic road it's two individual Lots one of which is parked 28,000 ft size the other which is parly 24,000 ft in size uh the size is currently improved single

045family residence have shed septic system and a driveway um which all appear to improved for the most recent certificate of occupany um except for a few minor structures which you discussed later in the memo um as a reminder the site of zone is be residence it's located within the P bar and South for special groundwater potenti area which are two sub designated groundw and natur resour protection areas um initially does not related to previous subdivision is considered partially clear natural vitation for the toal records so given that this is a seconds here for the later reviews of the uh application there were several comments that were issued to the applica during the previous review U we found for most part the applicat have primarily responded to most of these um comments that are previously issued

046and there's more just a few smaller minor things that we're going to kind of discuss tonight for the application um before diving into those though we first wanted to bring back um the reminder this is an unlisted action pursuant to uh Seeker in chapter 1 128 the town code um previously indicated that a short form short form AF part one was going to be required for review um and this has since been recently submitted to the board um while we reviewed this we did notied several Corrections of it that should uh we should be eded and are kind of described throughout the memo um but generally speaking um once these Corrections are in we're well actually before get to that part um so generally speaking we're recommending that the plan board the CL the agency

047initiate cour review with the involved interested agencies uh for this application um we're before the um transmittal can be sent though thus we do require that corrected e part one to be submitted uh which again that's how I F the memo uh the agenc is according with their sub County Department of Services New York State Department of of conservation uh and the East Hampton Town board and um so going on to the issues the uh first comment from the board had to do specifically with the c Ean area along the front of property um previously was noted that large portion of Ean area was cleared with the exception of a few exis mature trees um and some new plantings have been planting it's almost screening the front yard um the applicants have since submitted uh

048reation plan um indicating that they're going to preserve the existing trees that are there also plant approx Northern Bayberry throughout the C Ean area and I'll show the pl there now um and so we have reviewed this plan and um find it to be generally acceptable but there were a few just kind of minor edits that we uh need indicated on the plan um sort things included just the area the square footage to be regit addition into the overall St Ean area on the the size of the scen eement area these are things that were noted on the survey but just not included on the plant um we've also noted again that there during the previous review that there was some perimeter screening that was there a new vegetation um but it's not clear based

049on this plan what the attention is for those that's something we're just asking for clarification on and if appropriate just indication on the actual plan itself of where of the resistance terain to be removed Etc um we're also asking to be updated just to indicate the prepare of the plan itself just for the board's records um and otherwise though we have this has also been submitted to the natural resource department and they also generally found it to be acceptable um noting willing to wait um that and also noting that it doesn't have to be implemented until the playing board uh comes to their decision on so overall we recommend that the uh just because this is so far along we're recommending that the submission of registation plan with those edits is only requires a condition

050of final approval should the board uh choose to Grant it going through there there was a small comment regarding the size of the C keesman area um on the actual map this wasn't indicated on the previous review of this application they have since added it to add indicate the actual size of it we reviewed it based on the town code and we found it to be compliant with everything uh the code requires in terms of depth and size uh so therefore down the applicants appropriate responded to this there were comments last time also issued regarding the storm water drainage um asking foral details about the specifications the calculations the actual design of it um the applications have also submitted a common driveway plan U showing dra driveway and Road drainage plan uh clarifying A lot

051of this information for us uh We've also since sent this to the town engineer who's reviewed these plans um and overall it was found to be acceptable there were just a few min comments that were needed to be addressed um the support of those really was being the actual calculations provided between um this drainage the survey and that road drainage plan uh were appeared to be inconsistent in terms of in addition to the dimensions of those structures just um recommending that it was it was recommended by the engineer those be kind of removed from this survey and only shown on the com driveway plan with the final specifications for those plants um besides for that there was just a few minored details that were piled in the memo and should we just recommend be committed

052spitt upon that formal review going from uh the next as we kind of indicated in the past this was an application um that does require Urban R uh Ur map modification um during the previous review the board kind of given this application has been submitted for so long um agreed to allow the um modification of the while the sub Contin be reviewed but also allowed to go to the town board to go to that final Ur M modification mostly because they accepting of the configuration the Lots themselves um so we've as the planning department have begun processing the applicant's request for the modification um which his to be heard probably sometime in February um you know we've drafted comments to the town board um they're supposed to be test thism but I guess there was

053a little error but there they are in the desk um they're available to you now um but if you if the planet board agrees that the subdivision is acceptable these comments along with the report from the plan board will be sent to the town board but that's following the completion of Seeker review which again requires the clarifications request in the beginning of this evaluation there in addition to those trining PL drain calculations requested earlier there's also clarification requested regarding the common driveway plan um it was a little bit debated of the access during the last time but ultim became um the board agreed that com dve should be provided off laab onic roow the applicants have again submitted that plan um which generally speaking was found to be in conformance with the town code requirements

054for common driveways um there were a few minor things the first being that um for all common driveways propos for subdivision there is requirement for emergency vehicle turnaround area um and this doesn't appear to been provided on either the the survey or the to driving plan is something that should the plans uh technically have to have in order to comply with town code um the second was as minor colleges mention location utilities should be placed below ground to the town code and this is should be situated within access within the access easement given that the access easement is PIV utilities we also recommended the name be updated to and reported as an access utility easement as opposed to the access as indicated the plan now outside of the board's pest comments there's just a minor

055comment regarding the existing structures again we found mostly everything here to be compliant with town code there was just a small um indication about the the existing fencing here in the shed that didn't appear to be on that building permit or the co um so generally speaking we're just recommending that as a condition of final approval the applicant should be required to legalize those structures and or REM the property in order to go compliance um with the town records so overall um as we've indicated the applicants have responded to many the requests previously issue by the planning board um several minor updates are required to the plans maps and addition to the secret review having to be complied with um again this will also require the review of the Town board for Renewal man modification

056but this has not been reviewed yet pending Seeker um and ultimately uh once this once that is complied with the board to discuss or not it's ready to refer to town board to uh discuss simultaneously to this review okay thank you Dan it's very thorough does the applicant wish to be heard that's about it okay all right fair enough fair enough thank you uh Jen thank you um thank you Dan for the very thorough briefing um you know we did see this application once before and I think we've talked through most of the issues I just want to point out that the planning board did receive a letter from a neighbor um this afternoon which I hadn't had a chance to review until I got here um asking that we can consider moving the common

057driveway to the north of the property to the north side so directly opposite where it is now and I I think we discussed this at our last meeting but I honestly cannot recall yeah so um is there a reason is there is there a planning reason that it couldn't be moved to the north to um her her comment is that her concern is the common driveway plan plan prepared um has been designed to be pitched towards the property line rather than to the interior of the property the two drywalls and catch bases are proposed to be what appears to be directly on the property line I question the feasibility of having these structures installed without encroaching during excavation on my property there is also concern that the common driveway will exacerbate the already existing drainage

058issues from the subject property onto my property during heavy rainfalls H so and it should it might it might be noted that the um neighbor is actually a land planner appear before this board um there's also the issue that there's already a clearing for a driveway on the Northern side I don't think there is there's one kind of in the middle one of the pictures that one of the photographs oh interesting but the southern driveway also exists yeah right it is clear here see that yeah I mean the existing driveway is kind of in the middle you couldn't really use that as a common access for the two lots as is needed right here um I think the applicant will have to describe whether or not they they want to move it I think we

059have asked them in the past to consider this is this for this I I think we discussed and let me just say from the aerial it does look as though if we if it gets moved to the north it would be actually closer to the northern house right residence than to the because it's it's going to be on the part of Maple Street that's been abandoned so yeah I agree with that and and the other thing the concern about construction encroaching onto the adjacent property is certainly valid right so the applicant should be able to show how they are going to construct the driveway like the unobstructed with it's necessary without encroaching um Can the driveway just be on the right on the property line too there are no setbacks forve so it could could

060be right to the northern property yeah to either one yeah um I just want to add one quick thing so there is an uh we talked probably a little bit about this earlier there is a CD eement recorded on this property that was already existing yes one of the concerns is potentially the overlap between the C easement and the access driveway so right now I'll show you the survey again it does show that the scenic easan area is going across that whole right um area exactly and that they potentially would be overlapping easements with this um but when we looked at the actual building building card records as very included I think in the original revieww the cement does actually end right around this area so as currently configured these would be separate p overlaps

061I just don't know the town board side for the UR map what kind of complications that would create because the meets in bounds of the existing right right right um and I think the requirement is along aabon road to have that 50ft easement so if it's not on the part of Maple Street that's been abandoned then a separate ement would have to be recorded in addition like a separate Scenic easement would have to be recorded or extend to the Curren cic casement if that yeah or if we moved it yeah we moved it um but so so that's that's my main thing I think all of the other things that were pointed out are kind of Minor Adjustments you know the revegetation um details clarification on you know what's going to happen to the the

062current shed and fencing you know if that gets taken down or but I think the big thing would be just a question about whether there's a possibility of moving the driveway just to address the concern right and I'm but I am concerned that we're just sort of Shifting the problem from one side to the other essentially right um you know if there was some way of mitigating Shannon's concerns about this it would you know in terms of construction protocols and storm water you know there might be a solution here we can leave it where it is which seems the easier softer way here yeah right yeah yeah I mean I think um that public comment just came in right we weren't even I didn't even see it wasw until this afternoon so I think as

063part of the board discussion today we should ask the applicant to like formally respond during the next submission um and we do how they'll mitigate the concerns exactly um how they wish to respond to the neighbor um's concerns Dan's point about the easement is a good one if if the driveway as configured now is not encroaching onto that easement and moving it would require encroachment I wouldn't recommend doing that I mean the easement are important kind of memorialization of what the UR map and those procedures put in place going back to move a driveway through it you know I don't think would be the most straightforward way to handle the application but softening the driveway's impact on the neighbors is certainly something that could occur um if the applicant agrees to look at and Implement

064those measures great so we probably should do is have do you want to comment now can we have your name spell your last name please and your address Elliot Fisher f e r and for tarb and Lester for the applicant um so I we definitely consider you know looking into um mitigating the how much the driveway will affect the neighbor but it seems like they're really only going to be there's really only that front part the first like 100 ft or so that you know have even have both sides of the Maple Drive abandoned right right so like the back part of Maple Drive is still half of the half of the other side isn't abandoned yet so really it seems like it would probably be best to keep it on this side um moving

065it up there then would would be directly on the neighbor property line versus down here you still have a a 20ft strip that is not abandoned yet yeah right agreed I think though the you know the the letter writer has a sort of valid concern though about storm water runoff um and construction you know problems during construction so I think uh you you need to come back maybe discussed this with the planning department how you might suggest mitigating those things so in the next round we can we can have a better solution okay any other comments or thoughts you ready thank you thank you so much okay so let's go to the questions um first should the applicant revise the short form environmental assessment form eaf as indicated by the planning department and prepare it

066by utilizing the New York State Department of Environmental conservations eaf mapper yes yes okay does planning board wish to declare lead agency status and initiate the coordinated review with involved agencies yes yes press do you want to do that do you want to make a motion to declare lead agency I make a motion to declare lead agency I'll second all right all in favor let's do it are we all we're all down with that okay um Bruce isn't here yeah I don't know I think Bruce may have left after the first uh member Cisco has left yes six um does the planning board wish to require the minor updates to the Rev plan as indicated by the planning department as a condition of approval yes should the applicant revise the submitted plans with respect to

067storm water drainage and management as indicated by the town Consulting engineer the review of projects yes yes does the planning board agree that the UR map modification is ready for referral to the town board when Seeker is complied with yeah that's sort of in process right should the applicant revise the proposed common driveway plan is indicated by the planning department of town Consulting engineer including providing an emergency vehicle turnaround area at the Terminus of the driveway and revising the section details to be consistent throughout the application yes yes and and um address the and address construction protocol and uh run off okay um should the applicant update the map to include an access and utility easement as opposed to an access easement along the common driveway portion of the subway sub waver yes does the

068planning board wish to require the applicant to legalize and or remove the existing shed and fencing on the on the proposed lot one as a condition of approval yes all right have they said they're going to move it Andor Andor and legalize no but have as the applicant I'm just curious is are you going to remove the shed or leave [Music] it hopefully they're going to say [Laughter] yes um legalize or got do one or the other yeah whichever the uh owner decides she wants to do which in this case seems probably hey either or just leave it at that that's where we're at all right thanks thank you okay so we're moving on to 552 West Lake car charging station uh and Michael is H pin for Bruce and Dan this is you again

069right y okay and the applicant is here all right so this is technically a first time review of a site plan but it was originally here as a prary site plan back in uh July of this year uh for new application to construct electri vehical charging stations existing multiple business complex site in Monto uh the proposal itself includes proposing two new charging stations should provide electric vehicle charging for four space four existing spaces um that are currently on this site which will be converted for um e charging available access Via mobile app and other web applications uh the site itself is located wake Drive monok its Zone as CB Central Business located within a New York state C area C area Statewide significance uh the site itself doesn't appear to the previous subdivision it's considered

070been fully cleared of natural vegetation per the town records um generally speaking regarding the structure here um the plan special prr was granted back in September 2002 of the construction of the two story M business complex um includes a um three retail spaces and a accessory apartment space um the SE was granted for all these structures which also includes the existing asphalt parking area um where the new charging stations are proposed there is a question that's a few minor accessory structures which describe more throughout the memo um so diving into the review of this application and I'll begin pulling up the plans themselves so as I've mentioned this was something that was reviewed um as a progr AR site plan application back in July of 2024 the planning board at that time issued several comments

071that are typically required for the formal site plan review processing Origins about additional information such as required by necessary site plans clarification of landscaping lighting and importantly further details regarding the intended use of the proposed charging stations uh which were not fully described in the previous review um the applicants have since a lot of information detailed cover letter um and revised plans with backup documentation responding to any of those comments however there are a few items that we still noted were mentioned not fully addressed so those are some of those are repeated here in addition to some new comments throughout the memo so beginning everything off uh terms of secret review this is a type two action Forum to secra chapter2 the town code uh there's specific categories described throughout the memo But ultimately it

072doesn't appear that any further secret review is required at this time um regarding the project itself so as I've mentioned through the prary review one of the primary discussion points was really understanding whether the pros charging stations themselves were going to be used by the existing site users meaning those currently using uh the existing retail spaces and apartment or some other function that's not currently there um you know we've indicated in the past that if additional users were anticipated uh issues such as parking traffic and general other considerations with development might be triggered uh would be likely be triggered with this application so the applicants have included a very detailed narrative kind of describe the use the development kind of the overall intent of this project with the submission we put a lot of bullets

073in the memo just kind of giving some key key points for this application obviously um I'll try to summarize it for you guys instead of going through all of those um but generally speaking it's our understanding based on those comments that it app tend to establish a publicly accessible charging station at 52 West Lake Drive uh it would allow local community members to locate travel to and utilize each charging station Via mobile app or other web application um while they have indicated in this memo that the charges will prbly be used by Patriot at the store the language of the narrative um talk about public accessibility also comparing locations similar to a gas station in the case that the stations will be accessible to both existing site users and those traveling specifically there uh to

074use the EV charging stations so this is something that's not the town code doesn't currently contain a definition for is like it's defined use for what your vehicle charging um in light of this we did the plan Department uh and U and with the attorney's office consulted with the Chief bity Inspector for interpretation of whether or not this proposal would constitute new use the answer the site um it was bu determination that if the site is anticipated to Ed by anyone in the community as suggesting the cover letter rather than just those who are currently anticipated for to use the site for the uses there um installing operating EV charg stations this matter would would constitute a new use uh on the site so in terms of the site itself so multiple business complex is

075something that's special permanent within the town code within the central business zoning District um as you know as you board is likely aware there are certain parameters within special permits that allow either continue to exist or if there's something called substantial expansion whether or not a new special perview would be required um based on our review of this uh we we we found that new special permit is likely not triggered as use improve it's not really the order of magnitud that were constitute a substantial expansion based on the definitions in the code um it's also noted that in addition to the use itself the number of uses on site still complies with the density standards that are required for um commercial uses on site which requires 3,000 square feet for each use in the central

076Buona District uh with the four uses it ends up being 12,000 feet and the site itself is 19,000 Square F feet so we found no issues in that front either um however again as you mentioned before very beginning that this may have other issues such as traffic parking and navig um and U anticipated use and those are kind of what gets further described the lder portion of this memo so in terms of the plans itself and I'll go to the more close-up review of it now um we orally initially noted that the uh the board during the previous review agreed that these stations were likely appropriate for a setback waiver um this decision is based on a section of town code which allows the planning board to wave accessory structure setbacks essentially the interest of

077good planning based on what's being proposed so the specific standards for that are kind of highlighted throughout the memo however the before could really be made on that there was a couple clarifications that were requested um princip to this was really saying they proposed setbacks of those structures because during the previous review it wasn't directly indicated um based on the plans here the applicants have since revised it to indicate some of the proposed setbacks as you can tell from the plans and I'll zoom in uh the two charging stations are proposed at 5' 11 in and one other at 6' 3 in away from that Northern property line uh where a minimum setback of 10 ft would typically be required based on the town code however considering the small size of these features uh we

078had no issues with the uh with the setbacks being provided um and something that we're requesting is the plan board confirm if their inclination to allow setback W remains to be addition to these details the only other caveat to this is we did note while those setbacks have't provided setbacks in the other structures like the addition so utilities Transformers wasn't directly indicated and this would be should be you know required submitted with the plans um the lines the property itself uh has a commercial use to the north it also has residential uses to the West so understanding those kind of setbacks and uh seems to play a relevant role in the board's decision on this point [Applause] um so outside of Dimensions um there was a small little note about these structures on the property

079so um we previously indicated that the site substantially conforms to those previous site plan reviews is the original review back 2002 and there was also an updated review for additional ada8 compliance and drainage in 2005 and we found to be substantially performance to that the um the only thing we notice that there's this concrete slab in the kind of the bottom quarter it didn't appear this appear building building perits or cosos at the time so something they asking for clarification if that was approved at some point um not ultimately we're recommending that this is something that's included as part of this review in this site plan review process to help bring it into [Music] compliance that so going back to PL themselves and I guess the easiest one is to show see overall plan again

080um so the next commas have to do with kind of the one of the biggest talking points we feel for this application which is really the parking and navigation requirements so so during the prary riew we indicated the pro project involved converting the four existing parking spaces which these um the northwest corner of the site um into EV only charging spaces um the existing number of spaces which currently there is 20 is consistent with the original spaces proved as part of that original site plan for back in um the um the one thing that we are asking for is just the applicant to confirm the uses have not changed those current spaces again those retail spaces and the apartments since the original sa approv approval to confirm with the parking demand um parking demand that's

081required of them has not changed uh but ultimately we found to be at this time consistent with that previous review going in addition to that though we do have some additional ACC with parking uh first having to do with Dimensions themselves um the plans themselves indicate the parking spaces are going to be approximately 8' 7 in wide by 20 ft in depth however this does not meet the current town code which requires a width of 10 ft um to FR or a minimum length of 18 feet or a width of 9t and 20 feet in depth um sorry about that it's 10 feet uh wide by 18 ft in depth or 9 ft wide by 20 ft in depth um and this is something that we don't recommend uh should be um we recommend seeking

082a variance for us and that the pl should more so come into compliance with mostly for safety standards um addition to that we also know the other site details such as to mention Drive aisles driveways turn areas um now the required elements for the to code have not been uh indicated on this plans um and so we're asking rise the plans accordingly just ensure that proposed comply with the standard set for in town code which has been attached as part of this memo uh these plans will also be reviewed by the engineer Town consultant engineer and fire office when they're formally received to ensure and safety standards and formal compliance is appropriate um finally and this is most importantly um because the proposal is to be considered a new use space and determination be received

083additional parking spaces are something that are likely required to accommodate the use so allocating for the existing part 20 spaces for the E charging use limits the total available for the existing use of the retail spaces and the apartment to 16 which doesn't comply with the 20 required of the town code um based on our review of the plan itself it appears that providing additional spaces for this is likely difficult uh the site is relatively constrained and there are concerns with whether or not it could meet the coverage requirements with those additional spaces um however we still recommending the app can consider options that would allow them to meet that parking requirement if possible um however if it appears that additional Park spaces to me the codes cannot be accommodated uh we know that there

084are several options primarily to that we've find out um that may allow that project to proceed um the first of this and I'll go through those now so the first option is what we call the fee and R parking option so essentially there's a current town code that allows um if a project site cannot meet the current parking requirements uh there's a town code that specifically allows a fee to be accepted in R of those parking requirements uh or all those spaces being provided that goes to u a fund created for municipal uh municial parking for the district um because this parcel is located within the central business zoning District it is technically eligible for this waiver based on the town code however there are some other considerations that we think are relevant to consider

085as part of this um first the concern has to do with the actual benef potential benefit of this fund itself uh this site is located over 12200 ft away from nearest public parking space um Municipal lot and allowing on street parking but neither support good Planet crys nor align with the adjacent lots to the north and south of it which both have on-site parking as opposed to off-site parking um second before this feed can actually be collected uh the board is required to adopt a overall policy governing the computation of the fee the use of the fee and generally how it's going to be regulated um choosing this option would likely require several meetings to do that because at this time it doesn't appear that those regulations have been established um however we do note

086that there have been times in the past where this has been used for other sites in monok um we mentioned the mon Brewery application was an example um and this was used primarily because this was a located centrally within the downtown business district and in a spot that was located close to Municipal parking spot or had availability of on street parking um so we were generally speaking uh plan Department not recommending this option for the those reasons described above um however the planning board should determine if they wish to pursue it and if so further analysis of the computation of the fee and the use of the SC would likely be required for that option second option to this um has to do with potentially seeking a variance for this project so if the board

087through the application kind of is currently configured uh a variance is required from the town code to allow 16 parking spaces to be dedicated to that multi business complex where 20 would typically required um historically this is something the plan board has supported for variances um from the required number of onsite parking spaces uh but typically this is in circumstances where uh there is room to potentially provide those parking spaces on site however good planning principles um seem to recommend that it be better situated off site such as allowing parking to be on street as opposed to um on the property itself in terms of development coverage and other considerations um so I know this doesn't typically directly apply to this circumstance giving its distance from Municipal parking um and it's uh overall constraints with

088the development um H my apologies one more part of this um so yes as we saying this doesn't appear to be directly acable those circumstances to this site um and the other real portion of this too is that on street parking doesn't appear to be appropriate in this location uh you know this is currently no other site has on uh designated on street parking uh within this area and it's also located on a County Road U 77 where there might be high voles of traffic and then also require additional approval for sou the county to actually go through uh with on street parking um so after discussing option of several board members though uh we are aware that there might be other considerations for potential third or alternative option for this uh where the use

089itself may not infect the potential parking requirements in this case scenario and also the case scenario with the zoning board um of appeals and the uh potential of Need for variance um it's really evident and important that the more details about the expected site activity such as the average charging time frequency of use the Stalls traffic potential traffic Etc uh should be provided to both the planing board and potentially zoning board uh for their revie in addition to details about the parking utilization on site what's it how those spices are anticipated to be used um ultimately due to the fundamental nature of the variants of this application um if the board um is decides to go in that matter the planning department recommends uh the applicant should be referred after this review uh for potential

090variance option if the board wishes to pursue that option just given how Central it is to this development um but in summary um principally our primary recommendation is to see if it's possible to meet the recommendation to show compliance with parking stall requirements based on the town code um and additional parking to meet the code of cards cannot be accommodated there are several options um the board might have to vet out and discuss tonight um I know I kind of overviewed those quickly and I'm also happy to answer any questions regarding those as well but this seems to be kind of the I think we think primary discussion point from the board tonight so going on from there there are a few other smaller details I'll just go through briefly um that are require other

091necessary elements of site plans or just additional plans that have been submitted first to do with water supply and sanitary systems so information pertaining to these existing proposed systems has not been directly Prov Ed um however with no expected water demand or sanary FL associated with these charging stations um we're not anticipating any changes to be used to these features so we're just asking the applicant to confirm whether there's no changes to these structures have been made since that original site plan approval um or if because if they have been changed or there's other changes that been made detailed information is going to be required um based on the town code necessary El the site plans uh in addition to the development uh we' also noted that part of board's previous request the landing plan

092has been submitted which on the screen now um this plan proposes to plant several Green Giant aaries along the northern and western property lines of the site which likely screen the charging stations from the neighboring commercial property to this Northern um however the only concern was while the screening does seem to be add the prior to the northern lot along this Western lot it seems that the screening provided only appears to protect from the internal Vantage points looking out whereas from neighboring properties which these ones located at residential looking in would likely see directly uh be able to see those other utilities and Transformers um so generally it was our recommendation to see if the additional screen could be added to these areas um in addition to this there was also know there was a

093few minor items for the reation plan itself that were required for the Town based on the plan board's typical uh requirements um run through these the plan here shows Ro plannings alternative plant spacing but does not indicate what approach be followed and something should be specified on the plans um additionally it also again we indicated only includes um one species to be used um however we just want the app to confirm whether or not this is the case or specify what other species may be utilized part of this plan um and finally we're just asking that the applicate specify the size and number um and of the specimens to be planted on here especially if there's others proposed to be used something should be included with the plant otherwise there are the details provided and

094those seem to be uh consistent with the town uh typical requirements now in addition to landscaping and here's just a few ADV Vantage points you guys can see um there was also a lighting plan sub with this application um so as you can see there's two new exterior fixtures proposed alongside the charging States um between each of the Char stations um while some specifications for these fixures have been provided and appear to um align with requir to the town code we also know there are several other details that are required in order to ensure the pro needs town code board policies um for example we've indicated you know things as Mountain height photographs and the Lum maximums have been provided but other things the color temperature um and the uh FL in foot cand does

095not appear EV through the submission this something that's typically required for a um Landing plan to be submitted now while we're not requiring the typical comprehensive plan we are requiring that this plan be revised to uh to that the applicant review the plan board the plan board specific guidelines for site lighting and the town general standard for Sight lighting ensure this could apply uh most importantly to this really has to be um the actual property line illuminance illuminance calculation to make sure that there's no spill over onto adjacent properties as that's for prohibited in the town code finally there were s of elements necessary element of site plan um which we've laid out in the in throughout the evaluation or additional clarifications details items that are required um I won't get through all those now

096but just if there's any questions about those I'm most happy to answer those um and finally just in terms of some other reviews that are required um some that mentioned before the some that ARB review arit Review Board review is required for this um in addition to planting boards review um and something that's just I should be noted forthcoming um as part of this uh we also had comments from the the far maral who reviewed the application recently um and indicated the submitt information is sufficient doesn't require further review for fire protection purposes however we haven't received comment yet regarding parking areas or Ada compliances primarily uh given that we're still pending uh dimensions on the plans um and once that information is submitted then we'll get further comments from the Fire Marshall regarding those

097um terms of other agencies again you we mentioned be already um so this is a project that would also require sub County Planning Commission um and this something that be referred for uh referred for review of recommendations once the applications deem complete in the planning board side and then there's the idea potential need for the zoning board of appeals if the parking requirements uh may not be met and the board wants to seek the potential variance so in conclusion there's a lot there uh so key the continuation of this discussion is whether additional parking can handy located on site to accommodate additional demand to whether variance F or another option might be puru uh pursued um generally speaking though the application is complete pending the submission additional details respect to proposed dimensions of parking stalls

098navigation aisles setback of structures Landscaping lighting and other Miss missing elements from necessary elements um otherwise from there um we're advising Advocate to spend additional revised plans the respon letter um and from there I'm happy to answer any questions or explain next further thanks Dad uh does the applicant wish to be heard Nicholas Garo g a s p a r o okay from Wood Hollow uh Energy Group so I think that you know understood on all the the notes and the additions to the site plans and the landscaping and I think that we could uh conform that uh everything that you're looking for to get to the next step on that I think the biggest question right is the is the parking spaces and how we understand them which you know is new for the

099board or East Hampton um you know typically because we do this in a lot of other states and Upstate the doe regulation usually is that these are not considered considered loss of spaces um which we we gave in that response as a reference uh New Jersey for instance building code actually enhances Spaces by adding EV parking spaces to the parking account so for instance this would actually be counted as additional spaces not lost of spaces so I think that's the biggest thing that we have to overcome because obviously we'd be happy to give you extra spaces but it'd be really difficult um you know I think that the general purpose of any of these things is to enhance the use of the building self um because EV charging generally is not although it's similar to

100a gas station model uh the you you know in terms of that you're selling energy for money um the the case uh the business case to it is not a profitable it's not a overly especially if in Long Island territory where demand rates are so high you're not doing it for the purposes of of making money you're doing it more to to you know increase customers increase you know maybe have tenants be happier to take on the space and all that um so I don't technically see this as a gas especially because of it's where it's located and the the type of business it is I don't see it as a as like a new gas station um I think this is mostly for you know for customers workplace Community but um so that's just

101U that's just my response to that okay so [Applause] good evening everyone my name is Mark rer last name Ru s c h e r i' like to thank you for this opportunity I'd like to thank Tina too for communicating with me helping me get through this um speaking for the landscape portion of this um the landscape plan we're open to using different variety trees if necessary obviously problem in East Hampton obviously is our biggest fear is a deer uh they eat everything um you can plant Mahoney Aqua foia come back the next day and the whole thing is gone like Garden salad so for those who don't know aolia has spines like this long on it they eat it when you're hungry and you're starving you'll eat whatever you can find um so um

102even though everybody are obviously not you know they're still susceptible to be eaten uh they do give a good barrier for light control which that was one of the biggest things that we brought up at the last meeting was headlights right people are coming into this area and they're going to have headlights shining into the north and west exposure these homes so we thought that was something could be dense enough to try to keep that up um and obviously for deer control ways that we can spray it with agitant or things like that that they won't try to eat them um in regards to parking I think the fee in Li of is really good idea um instead of the variance way there's really no way I mean we tried to manipulate this park lot

103a couple different ways there just no way to meet every other code without either pulling a variance to doing the L up I agree with that 100% wholeheartedly um something I'd like to bring up with the size of the parking spots and a lot of other um zones that we're working in especially like New York City and other different areas of the state they're considering electric vehicles compact cars so they actually have different size spots um a lot of them are now 8ot or even less in certain areas I'm not saying I want to go less than 86 anyway I feel like it's not feasible um but maybe that could be some kind of lency on that um the other thing is we do have the room however to go back to the 9 by2

104uh I believe on the on that side since we gave a barrier-free Zone in front of the charger I think we can manipulate that with the extra room ments by the building right so I'm definitely open to try to uh accommodate what you guys have or at least as close as possible okay thank you thank you we'll discuss it you're available for questions obviously uh Michael this is yours so I'm going to pontificate for 10 seconds are you ready uh we have this uh phrase called uh in the interest of good planning and uh I think that can be applied many different ways in in the macro way adding EV Chargers is in the interest of good planning for this town in my estimation um uh now for the micro what's what's that concrete slab

105can that be turned into a parking space what what I got something that I'm not sure what the use of that is that before we we're just the developers here um if there's a way to turn it into I'm sure that I just I don't see I was thinking that too I don't when I first visited the site come to the yeah I'm sorry yeah go so when I first visited the site when I first did the initial walk through with the engineers and the surveyors to survey the property there was a boat park there and it was the winter time so I I'm imagining that this land owner is keeping his boat there in the winter I was there this morning and there was no boat so okay just that was that was last

106year I'm not saying I don't know but that was last year so these are rapid Chargers yes and how long does it take I may have even asked this when you were here for the perimeter how long does it take to charge it all depends on that's hard to answer based on when are you pulling in are you pulling in with a half a battery you're pulling it with a quarter battery how long toally empty battery you have to figure if the person's there so they share right it's a load sharing system so if there's nobody else there that person can be full within an hour you know if if there's all four charge being used that person might be there for an hour and a half it depends so it load shares over all

107the kilowatts that are available on the system so if I don't if I don't know about this charger how do I find it so the charger itself has a software built within it that will actually show when it is available and when it is in being use so if you have an electric car you can download apps for that electric car let's just so let's just go say you go buy a Tesla tomorrow it'll tell you Tesla within it will have different things there's plug there's plug of there's plug share there's all these apps that you can have on your phone our system that we use is very smart it'll actually tell you when the car is when there's actually a charger open when it's being used approximately how long that person will be there

108for and then it'll tell you when it will be available so will it show up like I use Google Maps all the time will it will will show up on Google Maps as either being used open or what spots are without having to download anything else just corre into okay yep uh that also helps with traffic control because if you know it's being used you're technically going to you're probably going to buypass it if you have enough battery so I have a question for Dan about use so I so there you mentioned use and this this doesn't change anything when you say there's an extra use is this considered an extra use in this air in this property in this site right you're saying that oh being like the existing what was the question I'm

109sorry did you well maybe I got it wrong but I thought potentially e Chargers is another use yes okay yeah we talked to the cheap billing inspector on it and that was the termination we concluded with was that it would be additional use on the site but since it's 19,000 Square it's since it's over the square footage it's okay you're allowed four correct up to four yeah within the special perit standards it'sing for that so okay I'm just so you have a the two businesses there are a wine liquor store and then a spa yes I'm I'm curious how at the busiest time how many of these spaces are are filled I mean the liquor store I don't think people spend much more time than 10 to 15 minutes at a liquor store I mean

110if you do you're having one hell of a party and I also wonder if if folks even uh if they're parked across the street and walk over to rather than Park in the I'm just curious about the uh how much how busy this parking space get so we we asked the owner about that after you guys asked that uh question last time and he said that there's never more than half full this parking lot never seen it more than half full I so so do you know of other charging stations nearby no we uh we actually have a couple applications that you guys are going to see soon we're trying but um table yeah so yeah we hope to we hope to put more you know the the types and the the levels of them

111it's all VAR variations of like this is more like middle like CU it's more for for you know Community workplace use U but we have a couple gas stations we're talking to about like the superchargers which are like 15 minutes that's obviously a different use case and then and then obviously uh straight workplace which is like 48 Hours those are options too well I like the idea that when you said that this this is not taking away parking spaces it's an enhancement to the parking space but that's that's not what we are we deal with so if you are okay with option one I mean that's fine with me option one being fee pay a fee that goes to a municipal parking sense that makes a lot of sense that concludes my comments okay thank

112you who else has comments and questions yeah yeah I have a couple of comments one is I I personally you know I agree with Michael that this is a benefit it's good planning it's something that uh the community needs and should have so having said that as far as the parking requirements now you you consider those parking spaces to be available to anyone not just the electric vehicle charger so I I think that you he ask that last time so we're going to make them not Eevee only right so there's no there's no uh they want to be like a toe or fee or a towway or anything like that no signage that would restrict that because there's a parking lot in Monto the big parking lot across the street from the post office that

113has all those charging stations I think right those parking spaces and not too many people know this but they're available to anyone you don't need to have an electric vehic vehicle to park there so that that if that would be the case here I and also that would we would have to set a precedent for that because this is all new and you're going to come up with more applications and I'm sure there's going to be others we should somehow we should get it into the code as to how we treat these parking spaces maybe there should be a sign on them for people who park there that don't have an electric vehicle especially in this kind of retail environment where you're just going in and out you know 20 minute parking for gas powered

114vehicles or something like that ice ice vehicles I I personally don't I don't know how the rest of the board feels but if that were the case where anyone could park there I have no problem um keeping the parking spaces as they are without seeking a variance but I don't know how that but yeah I want to actually ask so I want to raise that very Point uh and Tina I believe that there is an opportunity for us to without a code change to make that happen right to not uh not create additional parking demand so we we did discuss today you know we have no code regarding this we're considering a new use we don't have any code regarding the new use um we took a very conservative review in the memo like considering

115that the demand is for spaces and you know that was kind of based like some of this signage in the thing says EV parking and we thought it was going to be restricted if it's not going to be restricted and the spots are open um and the board feels that that does not reduce the parking for the overall site then I think it's within your purview to not require a variance I would in that case however caution that we should just get a little bit more detail from the applicant in writing just about um how long cars will be there what the signage will be that will show that they're open um you know I do agree with Michael's Point wholeheartedly that it is in the interest of good planning to have charging available to

116folks who want to use it um but but I think we need to be careful and especially in light of there's many of these coming how are we going to handle them in a consistent fashion I also AG with L we need code for it um but you know creating code takes a considerable amount of time and also create predent couldn't we you whatever you do with this application will create precedent um for certain think signage is an important thing agreed yeah for to be clear actually in the Prem meeting Charlie Collins made a really good point that you know if we look down the road five or 10 years this is probably going to be a requirement you know for parking lots to have EV spaces and they will be have to be you

117know Universal spaces for everyone so sorry to interrupt but kind of what Tina said I think certainly we're going to see more and more of this so we have we do have to be cautious in terms of setting preceden for this is a multi-use you know property you know we're going to see something else that is not going to be a multiuse property may not meet the the square footage requirements so I while the code certainly probably should be changed and will take a long time to do that I think we need to evolve with it we certainly need to evolve so right yeah yeah agreed agreed yeah I think the key uh challenge here is really going to be making the spaces themselves the other spaces themselves compant right I mean I think that's

118that's the challenge and and to and to see if there's some opportunity to really maximize on-site parking is there you know the opportunity to add two spaces parallel you know to the uh what is that the southern side I guess right to parallel park there right um I think if if you're able to optimize that you know bring the space size up to code um I think we would consider I would consider yeah the notion of it not creating additional parking demand can I ask a question along those lines uh you were pretty quick to agree to the to the fee but then maybe I misunderstood you had suggested as well that maybe you over comply with the requirements because electrical charging bays are worth two spots as opposed is that right I this is

119this sorry this all comes down to I think the precedent that you guys are trying to set and how it works for the town but yes in New Jersey I mean in New Jersey if you expand on your parking lot you need add EV spaces if if you add an EV space it counts as a space so you can make your your quota so it's just there's different everybody has different takes on this I I love the idea I think in general that if we make this where there's a limited amount of time that internal combustion engine vehicle could park there something where you know it there turnover but not restricted to just EVs and we could take out the stencils to make it you know we put the stencils in so people know that

120there's an EV there you know cuz usually people are are are respectful of that hey list there's other spots here so why am I going to park in an EV spot you know if you know someone wants it you know so I think but I think that everything I agree with everything that you guys are saying so um I think that we could comply and add and I think we I'm actually excited to start a president so as far as the fee I I don't really I didn't really understand exactly what the fee was I know he saying I mean I think that we' be amendable to something like that if if it if that's the solution but I don't the issue with that is that we don't really we it's not encoded I don't

121even knowly talk about it's work to be done right and it doesn't really mitigate the problem because normally there would be another location near the site where you could park that wouldn't be the case oh I get it okay that makes sense you're paying a fee because you're going your customers are going to be using right spot I think yeah I think the solution to make this the solution you guys are bringing up just now seems better tonight yeah I think we should be very careful in how we approv this and what kind of precedent we set but I think we should Endeavor to set a precedent because I think it's important yeah and I think you know not make creating extra parking demand for this is the precedent we want to set yeah I

122mean I I think if other vehicles park there with no concern then I I that seems like more of a possibility to me the thing I will say we look we looked at aerial imagery on the site and just for the past couple of years and I did note that the there was never more than like a handful of cars in this parking lot I I don't think that's the only concern here cuz when you're setting precedent you're going to be looking at these that are in busy parking lots but the spots that they put the EV Chargers in those are the ones that are most frequently used so you know right oh that's like the high TR because it's right near the door um so you know just noting that like if they went

123below you know to the southern side maybe they would be areas that are less likely to be parked in by somebody else if there was other options available maybe there's a sign like don't park here if you're not EV unless there's no other spot here you know I mean spot people park at the last resort we honestly went there thinking that was the furthest away yeah everybody I can show you the are when you pull in like natural just to kind of go right towards that corner yeah that was our pattern though but the dimensional compliance is important I don't think we're we're going to consider going less than the nine yeah exactly I think you know in terms of thinking about precedent you know we were enumerating at the pre meeting today about you

124know what other Lots privately owned Lots there are in the eastampton town where this might be a problem and frankly there aren't that many right right there's the IGA and that it uh which would be great which would be great that um and we came up with with a couple a few others but there are not that many right so address mainway yeah um all right well I think we'll go to the questions I just and I I hate to delay the discussion um because I think as Michael said in the interest of good planning this is a good thing I just have a lighting safety question we did touch on um you know since it is you know a new use and it is it's you know theoretically going to be open 24 hours

125a day I'm wondering if there's a consideration for lighting that maybe could be motion activated so when you pull in you can see when you're you know charging your car at night especially you know I I go to the gas station you know by myself late at night I don't want it to be dark I want it you know I don't have an electric vehicle but just from a safety [Music] perspective um that it would would have to comply obviously with the standards but um you know something that could yeah I was trying to meet the minimum uh requirements for safety and then and obviously no spillage um so if motion would be is I don't know if motion meets if that brings a different issue to code I I don't know for lighting for

126parking I think the fixtures would still have to comply with the regulations but you know something so it's not on all night could for in but if someone does pull in there at 10:00 at night or 11:00 at night or 4:00 in the afternoon these days when it's dark um you know they can safely or feel safe you know filling up there they they do make uh even motion sensors that could be minimal and then on motion brighter so maybe this you know maybe that's even something because I feel like when you pulling in you might want some minimal to see where you're going and maybe then it triggers like okay now it's a safety concern go to full brightness which still full brightness meet all the requirements uh I could come up with something

127that's that would be great I think that would be good addition yeah that's maybe have that conversation with the planning department so you can make sure you're within code yeah right achieving that objective yeah that' be good great thank you excellent all right good terrific all right so I think we're ready to go to the questions does the planning board require information pertaining to expected traffic generation from the sites including expected usage and average charging times if Vehicles charging on site I think we'd want that documented yeah everyone agree yes should the applicant revise the plans to include the distance of setbacks to between each proposed structure and the adjacent property lines as requested by the planning department sure yeah should the applicant provide parking stall Dimensions compliant with town code confirmation that site usage

128has not changed since the last site plan approval and additional details including dimensions of navigational miles yes yes please okay if additional parking to meet code requirements cannot be accommodated does a planning board agree with the planning department that the application should be referred to the zba or does the board wish to pursue the option of a fee in Lo of parking spaces I think we've kind of determined that we want to pursue the third option option right the no increased parking demand yeah and that is clearly within our purview excellent to do okay is now well yeah new yeah exactly yeah this is a new sheriff we're ready to go showing that exactly uh should the applicant confirm if drainage grading or changes to impervious surfaces are changing on the site yes does the

129planning board wish to require additional screening between the proposed EV charging station util facilities and the Western property line yes okay right can we add a question about the lighting to see yeah I think there is a question about the lighting yeah there we go Gotta yeah I do thank you should the applicant update the landscape plan information as noted earlier by the planning department yes yes should the applicant revise the lighting plan as indicated by the planning department including details regarding the color temperature of each fixture and light incidents on foot candles along the property line and accommodate nighttime uh lighting with with motion detected fixtures yeah right yeah and you can work at the planning board on that does planning department does the planning board agree with the planning Department's assessment of additional

130information that must be provided per town code to 55650 necessary elements of a site plan which Dan enumerated what some of those are that sort of small details you can work with those guys on that so yes right yes okay we thank you thank you all right yes okay because we did have some last minute clarification so printed up a little late sorry about that oh I think it's already thought we were just doing an approval yeah this is the approval okay but I'm just showing everybody a quick okay thank you we had a couple versions thank you Nancy did I send you did I gave you the wrong oh okay so what changed I'm not sure Nancy can you just highlight for us what changes there were on this um yeah let me just

131yeah it wasn't much it was um you know the whole thing with the septic upgrade and it you know was like you know it was conditioned basically on so that was part of it so it wouldn't be that's been added or it was already in there but now it's phrased that it would be um a condition of a CO rather than a building permit so that was pretty much the main if funding if funding is Ava it's always been funny so that was clarified okay I think they would just yeah so sounds it's going to go that way yeah and then there were a couple um conditions that were already fulfilled that we already received um the was it the engineering thing I think it was yeah so it was just regularly like Min or

132things like that nothing um nothing major okay yeah yeah so that was condition just to clarify I put it up on the screen um the substantive change was that 3.3 is no longer a condition of the building permit and 3.3 has been revised to indicate that should the applicant be awarded the grant proof of compliance with suff County conditions is required prior to the CF but the planning board is previously agreed that all we were asking or requiring is that the grant applied for and if it's not you know if it's not obtained the conditions end there um and then some plan updates um were made the dates of the plans were updated the last thing was that the the language regarding the stamping of suffi county has been modified based on the um applicants

133feed fact that they're not providing this type of review they're providing something different in terms of their like a digital a digital signature instead of like a stamp um which we not aware of so I think that's it that I miss anything um I really appreciate the clarification on the our reest porium please thank [Music] you the um if there is a request for for permit for Onsite consumption which we withdrew in January we have to come back to you but yeah but a new permit regarding this doesn't the retail sale of alcohol for off premise consumption so if there's a new SLA permit request regarding on-site consumption if just on onsite consumption yeah we have to we we got a permit for both onsite and offsite at your request we we withdrew the onsite

134we we got a permit for offsite retail sales yeah now we have to renew that I just wanted to make sure that we're not coming back to you when we go to renew renew the renew the permit for the offsite okay where where are we looking by the way it's 3.99 39 Oh that might have changed I'm sorry might have changed no 399 add just that says it does not prohibit Al oh okay okay that's always great all right so the important thing here is that the planning department has had a chance to review this because usually we don't take things day off right they have reviewed it the whole thing the whole thing thing yeah okay all right not reading the whole thing I looked at these substantively and I did not type them

135but thank goodness Nancy did so I in agreement all right good so if we have if Council and planning director feel that we're good we will wave our usual requirements for Friday submission for you Mr to get to yeah soon um all right all right so with that in the matter of the application Springs General Store to site plan County tax number 3- 8-2-1 I have read the site plan special permit approval along with the most recent amendments I for adult second second all in favor okay c car 6 perect the other it's the other wait EV Bennett you used to seeing Daniel yeah say we look like no he looks lot he exhausted thank you guys thank you thank you good luck we look forward to it opening thank you any day now any

136day now yes any okay thank you um so we have the subw modification for ancient NES Jennifer that's me um in the matter of the application of ancient nolles - Lucy subw modification suffa County tax map number 300- 37.4 I have read this modific this resolution and I move for its approval second from RE all in favor I okay uh I guess our only other business is to adopt minutes of December 18th which I have read thoroughly and I have no comments does anyone else no comment I'll second okay second I I move you're second jump the gun you jumped the gun you want to get out of here okay um all in favor minutes I all right well Bruce is Bruce isn't here to for the next thing is he Bruce's usual move at

137this point oh is the move for yeah I make a motion to adjourn this meeting all in favor sorry Bruce I

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.