CorpusRecord 135470

East Hampton Village Zoning Board Meeting 1/10/25

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / LTV East Hampton
Date
2025-01-11
Location
Suffolk County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
2,299 words · about 13 min
Collected
2026-06-18

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e good morning and welcome to the Zoning Board of Appeals meeting for Friday January 10th uh we have the minutes from December 13 2024 may I have a motion so moved second please second all in favor um we have one injour today Gil hold of East Hampton 158 Main Street and uh we now have the continued hearings for the uh from last month 2011 LPL LLC 2011 Lily Pon Lane morning Mr Goldstein we understood that um there was that we would have a determination today I think it's on the the hearing was still open I just in case any of the board members had any more any other yeah I think um the uh at the end of last meeting we were asking for that um rendering showing the uh house as it is

002now end with the construction from the beach side which you provided us yeah December 17th yeah so um so thank you for that I think uh we just wanted everybody to all the board members to look at that before uh we uh have any more questions or if we close the uh hearing still yeah but um we have one board member who's we're talking Mr Rose talking about 2011on Lane LLC start they did Supply the rendering ings on December 17 2024 from the beach um no other board any other board members have any they want to say do just want to point out that I think it's possible to look at I'm not going to make a stand over it but uh the height of the uh walkway that's to the West connecting the uh

003guest Cottage and the main house I think it's Poss to have the ceiling height and it would be beneficial if the seil if the if the roof line height on that could be a little lower but that's the design issue that uh just encourage you to look at I'm not going well okay so you're just saying that's your opinion well it's not it's an observation that what's happening is with the elevation of the massing as a result of the uh substructure that's being created for the FEA purpose there's a uh the height is increasing by about 4 and 1/2 ft I think across the uh I thought they were keeping in proportion to the whole thing well I again I'm just I'm pointing out I'm not listen listen to the point okay which is that

004if there's a the effect of raising everything 4 and a half feet across where you now have standing on the beach there's a uh the way it reads is uh it's below most of most of the structure currently looks to be below the the Dune level when you raise everything 4 and 1/2 ft which I understand the rationale the necessity in terms of the the structures right the only uh point that I'm making is that if the connection between the walkway connection between the two structures that have sub basement structure I don't think there's the same structure going at the uh uh the walkway the elevation of the uh the roof line makes it read from the beach will make it read from the beach as if it's a much more of a a wall

005across than if there were a a a dip in the area between again I just refer it I'm not guys I indicated to the chair I'm not going to make a big issue about it I just think it's design issue that could be looked at oh it's just not an issue I'm happy um thank you uh Mr Rose any other uh comments Billy would you like to come to the podium please thank you good morning chairman members of the board Billy hack for the village they also submitted a their amended construction protocol I just wanted to make remind the board of that and it did address the comments that I had um spoke with the engineer drewett about so I appreciate that questions for me about it you're happy with everything they submitted okay thank

006you thank you um we're going to motion to close the the hearing second second all in favor I we'll do the determination last today after the continued hearings we do have the determination already prepared um does everybody have a copy of this Tim I believe so I I only printed one for you and 10 all right well I'm gonna pass this around as we go along please just take a look at it uh continuing hearing for Ira and Heather Shapiro one 33 egyp Lane thank you Andrew goon for the applicant uh we submitted um our construction protocols and we also submitted a slightly revised diagram of the proposed development over the existing development just to make it clear that the uh house presently the overhang of the house is actually closer to the property line

007on Pond View then is the proposed house so um so we're still just so we're not going to close a hearing today I don't think we have we're waiting for the comments from uh Vinnie gordel uh at Rainer group and um I think Mr McMullen wants to want to discuss one thing here yeah I had a a question um regarding the height is I noticed that with the FEMA and New York State freeboard um requirements it's 12 feet but you have the height of the first floor at 13 feet is there a reason why there's an extra foot there possibly Ira can answer that question yeah I'm just afraid that because this is sitting so close to the road on two sides it's just going to seem very tall and looming um but if there's

008a way that we can bring that down that foot that might help with the uh because it's 39 39t in the it's 39.3 feet above amsl which puts it I think at 3195 or something and the height limit is 32 so uh I'm just questioning is there a way that you can lose that extra foot of floor height that you raised it up out of the ground to uh yes there yeah because it will change the character of the neighborhood because this house is going to be looming out of the ground in my op yes she can we we can bring it down the foot okay so we're going to keep the hearing open till we get uh the engineers report um anybody happens if he's not here by next month it open another month

009please talk to the Village administrator fair is fair John Y no I get it this is we responded to his comments and is I'm not we were willing to put in a condition that uh the building building uh permit be conditioned on us responding to any further comments we're going to keep it open one more month and then we'll shut shut the meeting down does anybody have any more comments from Mr Gold okay thank you thank you uh so third continued hearing of the day Gregory L and Lisa C Wilson 30th [Music] Circle hi John tarbet for the applicant we were here last month introduced as mitigation for the first time that we would be willing to upgrade the sanitary system to a new low nitrogen sanitary system as a mitigation for the coverage variants

010uh I think you wanted to adjourn for that reason to consider it as well as I think Mr Rose had wanted to go to the property and and look at it any board board members have any comments questions were asked last week or last month rather Mr Rose the comment would be I think this is an ER again not gonna make a Last Stand over this but this isn't this street is overdeveloped in terms of coverage and compared a obviously a unique Street in the in the village but there's and the fact that the neighbors don't uh object I mean everybody is is somewhat overbuilt or most of the properties are overbuilt on this site and it's it's gone from a a a little culdesac not culdesac but a little a little Street to a

011highly developed over coveraged uh Street I think it's uh should be clear that the mitigation of the new septic system is not really a mitigation for the the excessive coverage on this street that being said this particular project is not out of character with the surrounding uh over coverage streets so it's a a point to make I I just don't want to EST have that be a precedent that we deal with coverage as an issue of of the septic system because they're really two different two different animals that being said in this case and the house was built in 2016 I mean I'm not I'm not arguing about it I'm just making the point it's an apples and oranges things and coverage is coverage is important it's an important issue that goes to the the

012character and and the principles laid down in in the zoning and in this case the hor has pretty much left the barn on on the circle but I'm not disagreeing with you I just I think part of what you seeing there is two-story homes and the circle it's not a real street it's a driveway so there's no there's no Road bed so those homes which are which meet setbacks are very close to the road so actually the surrounding properties are not significantly overcoverage it's a it's it's a perception issue with the two-story homes no I understand all the factors that's why I'm not making a big deal about it but I don't I don't think it's the precedent of saying okay we'll deal with coverage by a septic system is it and is a this

013is a unique situation Visa the nature of this particular Street um any other comments motion to close the hearing so moved second second all in favor I thank you Jonathan thank you um to Cove Hollow Road uh we left open for written comment only I know Mr Rose wanted to go by um you have any other comments no you're okay uh motion to close the hearing moved second second I'm sorry I didn't ask if anybody wanted to speak on it but I don't think there's anybody here 207 okay uh new hearings of the day Abby and who's sitting on these just so we're clear so for um Floyd mlo 2022 trust and Barbara mlo 20 2022 trust um we have Mr mcer Mr McMullen Mr Rose Mr Baris and Miss Fitz Simons um and then

014I'll go ahead and read application of Lloyd mlo 2022 trust and Barbara mlo 2022 trust suff County tax map number 301-853-6074 is 4,000 ft and the legally pre-existing gross floor area is 4,334 Ft the subject property is 30,000 ft² in area and is located at six board and Lane in Residence District R40 this project is classified as a type 2 action in accordance with SEC Jonathan hi good morning uh so uh the property is owned by a trust but the person behind the trust is a lady called Amanda Atlas she purchased the home about two years ago it was a dated home uh she went about redoing renovating and making her own very insignificant changes one is that the where you enter the house there was a front front porch which was notched in she

015just wanted to move that over four or five feet uh so that's a one part of the variance is like a 20 square foot uh uh GFA variant in order to fill in that Notch and then she wanted to just bump out the kitchen in the back which added another 60 square feet of uh gross floor area so in all it's an 80 foot um gross floor area that's all she's asking for and um it doesn't appear to be bigger because the house itself was pre-existing non-conforming to the groc floor area law and the house is already over 400 square feet right from the I think it's 366 3 what sorry okay 334 334 yeah board members any comments I just I feel that that it's not changing the character of the building um enclosing

016the AL Cove that exists for the front porch um minimal and the uh the small addition to the back which is 60 square feet it's not seen from the road and uh doesn't impact any of the neighbors so I don't have a problem with it I I did fail to mention that we did reach out to the neighbors and we did submit a letter you have one letter one letter thank you I just had a question you guys were here about eight months ago y I'm just curious why that this wasn't brought up then so um there we were here for uh we wanted to move the pool the first thing she did was take care of the pool it was in really bad shape so she uh we came to house plans weren't developed

017yet so uh we moved it was both these varant are pretty minor that was to move a uh and rebuild the cover for the pool equipment pre minor we wanted to get it done and get the pool fixed uh since then the plants have been fully developed and we're here for the house there should be no further I couldn't imagine a scenario where there any future applications um she's done okay this is a question for Tom Tom the septic system they have to redo the septic on the I mean it looks like they're doing major renovation I mean curious not holding it to it just curious yeah thanks John uh Tom PR for the village so um basically then the Nexus would be that if it's considered a substantial Improvement where by the value is

018increased by 50% that would kick in um a new system I'm not sure if that is the case inde needed here um the um you know they're they're not adding 25% that's the other trigger for the uh IIA systems so um that's I guess you have to be determined in in plan plan review we would uh that up just a little education for us thank you thank you um anybody have any other comments I actually just have a question to uh it's Tom and Billy in in the light of this septic issue that you that you raised which is and it really is an issue that comes up for the comprehensive plan revision it would be worthwhile in terms of what the what the triggers are and what the WEA code requirements are in terms

019of when renovations are done or applications are if if if there's a compelling reason and there's evidence to show that we need to in more than just Environ particularly environmentally sensitive locations that we need to be upgrading the the septic systems uh across the board and the village then that's something to put on the table I think for the comprehensive plan discussions and it should filter its way through ultimately the regulatory process so we're we're not sitting you know juggling here making it sort of caseby case determination but there should be a a clear direction from a comprehensive plan and then ultimately by Statute understood thank you Mr Rose uh a motion to close anybody in the audience like to speak on this a motion to close the hearing moved second please second favor um

020and we have the uh thank you thanks Jonathan uh the last hearing of the day please so for the Heather Lawless application we have Mr mcer Mr McMullen Mr Rose Mr Baris and Miss Simons sitting and then I'll go ahead and read it application of Heather Lawless suffa County tax map number 3018 D21 for an area variance from chapter 278 zoning to legalize coverage a 63 foot variance is requested from section 2783 a9a to legalize 4,278 ft of coverage where the maximum permitted is 4, 215 ft the subject property is 18579 Ft in area and is located at 87 fuel Lane and residence District R40 this project is classified as a type two action in accordance with secra good morning is some anyone hi good morning can you just get um please raise your right

021hand and state your name and address for the record he Lawless um and just your address please 87 VI Lane you swear to tell the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth I do thank you good morning morning um go ahead so I'm seeking a variance um of 63 square feet for Hardscape at my property I underwent a renovation about a year ago and um during that renovation I added more patio and my general contractor confer with my surveyor who um and when he did the the work apparently there was a miscommunication and my general contractor didn't um or the surveyor didn't take into account the postal access where I had some pavers so when we did The Hardscape the we um we lifted up the pavers over there but not knowing that

022the surveyor had already count did not count them in the original coverage limit so it was not my intent to be non-compliant for sure thank you um any board members have any issues with us who is the contractor who was the surveyor David sasz is a surveyor and Tom Schultz is the contractor thank you uh anybody in the audience have anything issues on this okay a motion to close the hearing so second second okay we have our one determination for today thank you thank you thank you very much uh we have one determination of the Day 2011 LPL LLC 2011 Lily Pon Lane uh the tire files are available at Village Hall and the application of 2011 LPL LLC 2011 Lily Pon Lane suffa County tax map number 301-5472 zoning and chapter 124 preservations of

023Dunes is granted subject to condition that full and ongoing adherence to the construction protocol as AIS as revised December 12 2024 is maintained at all times may I have a motion so moved second please second Gabby pull the board Mr mcer yes Mr McMullen yes Mr Rose yes Mr Baris yes Mr Darko yes uh and that that's all the business for today I'd like a motion to close the hearing so moved second please second all in favor I a nice say everybody thank you guys

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.