001East Hampton we are live morning everyone I call to order the planning board for January 9th 2025 the first item on our agenda the minutes of December 13 2024 any questions or Corrections if not I would entertain a motion to approve do I have that motion I'll make a motion thank you Dennis do I have a second second thank you all in favor all great the next item on our agenda is dun me Lane properties at 5759 Dum Lane um is the applicant present no okay and what they want here is Billy you want to describe it uh good morning chairman members of the board Billy ha for the village the applicant has requested a six-month extension in order to complete the conditions of their approval which was demolishing certain structures and obtaining Health Department
002approval they're actively working on it so I don't have any objection to the granting of an extension thank you very much so let's just take a vote on that do I have a motion to approve the extension yes make motion thank you do I have a second second all in favor great the next item um is the 8 189 uh further Lane and uh okay and uh is the applicant present oh great could you just introduce yourself and tell us what you'd like to do good morning good morning um Elizabeth Baldwin attorney with Essex Hefner angel I'm on behalf of the Roberts who are the owners of 74 cross Highway and the shinman who are the owners of 189 further Lane um I think we are we are here for a lot line modification between
003these two lots um I think the board will find this is kind of unusual because uh the applicants are seeking to return the lots to how they originally uh were configured um right now 189 further is basically a dog leg type lot um it was originally the rear portion of 74 cross Highway and we are seeking to return that um dog leg portion which has uh currently has the um tennis court in it back to 74 where it originally was um I guess at the time this was in 1988 um the owner of 74 oh the owner of 189 purchased 74 and had I guess one of the rain main reasons was he wanted that tennis court and he wanted to incorporate it into his main residence lot which was the 189 lot and so
004he came to the zoning board got a variance in order to um incorporate it and and and it's been like that since the 80s um the properties are now owned by two separate people and the owners of 74 would like to incorporate the tennis court into their lot and uh so they' worked out this Arrangement so we're just seeking um permission from the board to um to put it back to how it was it's a flipflop it is okay I've never seen it's it's it's it was interesting to see that in the history and be like oh this is how it was that makes sense great thank thank you thank you uh Billy comments on good morning chairman members of the board uh bill hijack again for the village I prepared a report for the
005board uh December dated December 27th uh outlined the project as described by Beth I don't have any comments of substance um you know it puts the Lots back to their original configuration it creates rectangular shaped Lots which is an objective of the subdivision regulations so I think from that perspective it's a good you know it's a good design uh I think the project does require some variances or variance relief so the the planning board can't act on it until they obtain the necessary relief from the zoning board uh I did have two suggestions or recommendations one just verifying that the gross floor area um is supported on the proposed lot sizes and I had suggested uh consideration for a road wiing easement on the further Lane parcel uh because there are further Lane in this
006area you're PR most people are familiar with the condition of the roadway it's a pretty narrow road the road right of way is substandard um some properties their property lines extend up to the edge of asphalt in some areas there's a two or three foot wide Road RightWay um we have situations of fencing being installed directly on the roadway um and then utilities are being installed close on you know onto private property or you know on property where there's no right of way and there's some pavement encroachments so I just think from good you know it's a good planning tool to use and you know whether or not the applicant is willing to do that is to be determined but it's a suggestion that I'd recommend be considered um other than that I have no
007other real comments unless the board has questions for me any questions board members okay yes please um Elizabeth Baldin again um I just wanted to discuss the roadwi widening easement um we actually don't believe that uh the planning board would could ask for a road widening easement in this application um we are not uh we're we're not really changing anything here there's no new no additional density no new curb cuts no nothing new no one's even going to know that this change has occurred within the town um we think to take away Bas our the the 189's right um for public use um would not be permitted in this situation so we would be pushing back on that if that does become a condition or if the board is seeking to make that a condition
008so I just wanted to let the board know that that um that we are not comfortable with that condition at this point okay okay thank you um and with regard to the GFA I know Billy had brought that up in his memo um we were able to obtain from um I know from Zilla and from the um prior uh real estate listings the sizes of the house um 189 is listed at 7400 square feet which is well below the I think they would be with the new configurations they would be entitled to a GFA of um where is it 11,910 and they're listed and I understand that it's from the real estate listing it's not you know an AR architectural certified but the AR the listing says 7400 which seems well below um and then
009same with cross Highway uh the permitted GFA would be 9,741 and it's the Zillow listing listed it at 4,300 um usually you would think they would want to make it a bigger you know for the listing so we feel like we're well below anything and therefore to the expense of having an architect have to go in and really do that GFA authorization seemed a bit excessive but obviously we um understand that if we need if Tom requires it um we did get a um turn down letter from Tom already with regard to the variances we do know we at this point we need five variances so we are um preparing our zba application and we'll be submitting that to shortly okay great thank you very much we'll send this off to the CBA and okay
010thank you uh the next item on the agenda is uh uh the uh 176 new town Lane uh is the applicant present oh hi could you come introduce yourself and just tell us what you'd like to do thank just some phot so you can have a sense of what's there right now thank you thank you so good morning Richard whan from whan fer pllc I represent Jack forest and helain silver blank Forest who are the owners of the property at 176 Newtown Lane that's a flag lot off the east side of New Town Lane it was created in 1989 minor subdivision uh called Robert David so the Robert David subdivision uh established to Scenic Ean Al the perimeter of the property we're really concerned with the area on the south side of the property uh
011the it AB buts lots that front on Bor Street and a couple years ago just south of the the U uh the forest house that part of the CES and had become grown over with bamboo so the village I guess complained uh and said you know to Jack and Elaine to to do something about that so they removed it and then replanted with what you're seeing today which is kind of you know light in terms of um planting it's there's mostly Arbor and obviously there's some grass there and so forth so uh the the immediately adjoining neighbor to the South complained to the about the disturbance of the C G and said it should be in its National State uh Jack and Elaine had opposed their variance application so we think that was a bit
012of a tit fortat kind of activity but in any event uh we have interface with the village and come up with we hired the fors hired James Grimes Jim Grimes Land Design to come up with a revegetation plan for the 15ot wide cenes on the south side and that would basically we would keep the arbid that were that are there but we would be supplementing that area with uh I think nine red SE Eastern red cedar trees and some Bayberry and high Bush blueberry and and ground cover so that's the plan um we would like to have until November November 15th of this year to complete it so they could hopefully get the best price on the you know PL planting materials which would be more likely to be in the fall I think than
013in the springtime but the work would be done this year if you approve the revegetation plan I just note that the similar application similar project was done on the neighboring property to the West which is also part of the subdivision I was involved in that uh the owner of that was um what was the fellow's name is still the owner right now yeah Walter Brewster uh also had to do a revegetation plan for SL different reasons for the area of the scenes so by the bottom line is we would make that much more uh you know fill that out in terms of vegetation so it would look more like an area in its natural state the um the neighbors objected to what we're currently looking at that's depicted in these photos no no well yeah
014the neighbors the neighbors objected to what's there today which is lacking which is what we're looking but but you removed the bamb am I correct I don't see bamboo so there was a lot of bamboo and you removed a lot of bamboo right and obviously that then opened up the area the ARB were planted after the bamboo was removed and it only depicts two Arbor here are there more than two there's more than if you look at the gr and how many feet apart are they planted are they looks like I'll just I'll just point out on the sure gr it does show the existing orb yes but it it shows like they're it looks like they're 10 ft apart or something on the map here it's depicting yeah yeah it's dener on the map
015than it is on the photog yeah they're not it's not very dense and that's why we're proposing to put in all the additional vegetation were the neighbors informed or or shown the uh the plan that you're proposing from gr no not to my knowledge so we didn't get any any feedback from them regarding that yes the whole situation occurred where the neighbor on mcer street was going for a variance to have a cabana built 20 inches off of my property line it was an existing structure that Walter Bobby owned okay and it was basically called out that it was for the sole use of Walter Bobby to use as a rider Studio they came in and they wanted to put increase the size of it and turn it into Cabana knock the whole structure down
016and put a cabana 20 inches off my property line I complained adamantly about it as I believe anybody in this room would also at that point they became very adamant and very upset with me and I was like I have the right to to voice my opinion I said you're impacting my property value by having this 20 in off of my property they ended up they needed to be 20 ft off of the property they ended up at six okay that was a VAR six feet is where this new structure is put because it was pre-existing um Walter Bob yeah exactly for Walter Bobby but it was not supposed to be it was supposed to be a riter studio which is a quiet application so I complained about it at that point they're upset with
017me literally I they were the ones who put the complaint into the village as far as the summons that I received from them they made the complaint okay as soon as I I have spent over $100,000 removing this bamboo okay because of them okay literally the trees that I had there were on the property for probably three weeks sitting there literally did they make a call to Tom when the guys were pulling out of the driveway and just completed the planting and said Jack plant the trees in the scenic easan and that's where we are okay and as I said the village came to me there's been questions whether I needed to remove it or not I felt I was being a a good neighbor by removing the bamboo because they were complaining about that
018I never planted the stuff but I took on the burden of removing it and I still have the burden to maintain it at this point which I've done all summer long I've been digging this stuff I mean if it was a summer time I'd be bleeding like crazy all around here because I'm a blood thinners but you know it is what it is but I just I just felt that I was discriminated against by virtue of them because I complained about their Varian which I felt they had the right to I don't know if anybody has any other questions or anything I can answer that because know a little bit more than thank you I have question thank you uh Billy you're oh okay [Music] yeah uh good morning CH chairman and the board Billy
019hack for the village uh I reviewed the plan by Jim Grimes uh I don't have any concerns with the plant selection that they're proposing I think it naturalizes the area it's native vegetation uh the the Evergreens that are there are not invasive so I don't think they're going to cause any more problems like the bamboo did so I I think this is a good you know a good mitigation uh plan and I don't have any objection to a condition that the planting be completed by I think it was November November 15th November 15 yeah that's that's that's fine it gives them the spring and the fall to get the plantings done the best deal you can yeah so if you have any questions for me um I have no problems with that the plan looks
020excellent and I wish you the best of luck and I I can prepare a resolution for the board for the next meeting okay good all right good thank you okay gentlemen thank you and good luck with that good luck okay the next item is the subdivision at 77 toome Lane is the applicant present yes thank you [Applause] uh good morning chairman and board um Dan Weaver from wallbridge surveyors on behalf of the applicant um so basically our our situation here is we have a a parcel of property that splits the town Village boundary um happens to be that we are one Acres Zone in the village half acres Zone in in the town we have about one and a half acres and it works just well that we're going to propose a subdivision here right
021along the village town boundary um that's the the general thesis of of our application and I'm happy to answer any questions the board has anyone thank you uh Billy you're an input thank you good morning again Billy hack for the village I prepared a written report for the board it's uh dated December 20th I I won't summarize the entire report uh but I will just point out that the the two Parcels being created you know the the town parcel appears to comply with Town zoning uh the village parcel appears to comply with Village zoning in terms of uh lot area lot width it's a pre-existing structure so it's not becoming more non-conforming uh the access is proposed via a shared common driveway over the existing driveway uh I am recommending that be referred to The
022Village's Consulting engineer for review just to ensure if there's any drainage issues we should be aware of and just it's it's a little tricky turning there's a couple of there's two turns there so we want to make sure that it's satisfactory for fire um and emergency vehicles um and whether or not a turnaround would be required at the Terminus um and um you know the the while the lot comp complies With You Know The Village's zoning regulations I would just point out that it is a little bit constrained a substantial portion of the lot is like the flag pole portion where the driveway is so the remaining bulk of the lot where they can develop is still it's kind of tied up between driveways existing buildings so for you know new accessory structures and swimming
023pools or swimming pool rather you know they it's going to be a little tight so they're you know they're gonna they might be boxing themselves in a little bit in terms of you know future planning for I mean they could always tear down what's there and start over again you know that's an option but I'm just pointing that out to the board and to the applicant thank you and will be the lead agency yeah it recommended that the planning board declare lead agency okay and then we can route the application to the other involved agencies um and the applicant can get started with their zoning board application thank you Billy yes my lead agency means that we would control some of the some of the Town property and no the so the lead agency is
024just the environmental review it's to determine whether or not the project will have a substantial impact on the environment and it's just the the the lead agency is the the primary permitter for the project and the you're charged with taking a hard look at the environmental potential environmental impacts so what I would be con concerned about is if let's say that this driveway we do need to make modifications to it we wouldn't have the right to tell the town what that modification would be correct no it's anything that's within the village is going to be completely within your purview of review so if some changes have to be made to the driveway that's that's as recommended by You Know The Village's engineer or the fire department uh then you know we can make we can
025make those recommendations or requirements thank you y any what any other questions okay uh would you like to comment yes Dan we again just a few comments um we we are aware that the lot would be somewhat constrained for future development however with some uh slight modifications to the septic system we could fit a small pool uh the client is aware that it would be a very small pool wouldn't be as big as what exists on the you know what would become the rear lot um but there is room to do the minor developments that the current owner may want to make to be able to still have a swimming pool um if they so chose to um sell the rear lot um and as far as the driveway is concerned uh we're happy to
026have the engineer review and you know the easement could be modified as needed um and just a reminder it's would be the same fire department reviewing it so would you know the comments that come back from the fire department would support the town lot and all of the easement would be on the village portion so it's not like we have to work the easement between the town and the village the easement is on the village portion of the property only wouldn't extend into the town if we need a turnaround maybe some of it would then extend into the town portion of the property but I think we can mitigate the turnaround to remain on the village lot since that's the larger lot to begin with it's really going to be dependent on what's built on
027that second lot yeah I mean basically they would be limited to you know Town zoning what allows for for you know a half acre size lot um you know that shouldn't change the requirements of the driveway because we wouldn't be adding any you know basically we're adding one unit of density uh so it wouldn't require a fire Access Road driveway or something of that extent or or um usually when you get to three four Lots is when the larger share Drive way you know easements are and driveway designs are you know added to these types of subdivisions so I think we have the room we need to reconfigure the driveway within the easement okay okay thank you I I have another question for Billy um so if for our decision here what direction it's going
028to go it's there we will not have to collaborate with the town planning board this is based on our decision alone so for secra you would refer it it's we're going to send a letter to the town that the planning board has declared lead agency and ask them if they object um and then also because the the sub the action is within um close you know obviously it's within close proximity it actually some of it is part of the town we would still refer the application to the town for review it's like an intergovernmental review you and I think it's like 500t for any project within 500t of a Municipal boundary uh it's referred to that Agency for for just general comment regardless so this we would still refer to the town and just let
029them know that we have an application and if you care to opine know you can opine okay thank you I'm sorry would you another comment surely take your time just so you're aware we have put in an application to the town as well um that was submitted the same day it was submitted to the Village we're waiting for um to be put on the planning board schedule for the town but we do have to go through subsequent you know sequential planning board process and review with the town I mean you know they would only be commenting again on the town portion of the property but we do have an application in then we this would require um both boards to sign the final map to you know in order to finish the subdivision so while
030as Billy was saying as you would be leading Agy for for secra you would actually both be reviewing your particular zoning on this property it's a little complicated in that sense but you know basically what would come down to the end as long as both agencies approve it then we would have an approved subdivision thank you and Health Department as well thank you very much okay any other questions anybody okay so I'll declare that with I I'll make a motion that we will be the lead agency do I have a motion to approve that motion thank you do I have a second second all in favor great and we'll see you soon thank you very much and any other questions for today if not then this concludes our agenda for today do I have a
031motion to adjourn motion thank you you have a second second great thank you all in favor great thank you all see you at the next meeting thank you thank you