001to continue this use uh the next concern was how the restrictions against on-site alcohol consumption will be enforced and the applicant's agent indicated that um well they didn't actually indicate a response but as I um mentioned there were three members of the public who spoke in favor of the application and vouched for the honesty and the character of the applicant and indirectly supporting the position that the applicant would restrict the used to what is legally permitted because that's what they said that they would do um the department notes that the New York state liquor Authority violations um can cause a liquor license to be suspended or canceled if there are any violations and we had discussed the planning board had discussed requiring as a condition of approval of the subject plan that any changes to
002the proposed use of the site with respect to the liquor license be subject to site plan approval again so that they would come back if there were any changes there was a a a question a concern that it was difficult to read the site plan and whether there actually were 13 parking stalls proposed as was indicated and the applicant at the hearing pointed out where the parking stalls were and that they were all indicated and that they had been um working with the planning board um to define the parking stalls and to um make them so that there would be a one-way traffic circulation and an improvement over the kind of for free form parking that's on the site right now and um the planning department agrees that we had been working with the applicant
003to come up with um a more defined uh parking layout um 13 parking stalls are proposed including one handicapped that this number meets the parking standards of the zoning code that there is a defined layout uh replacing the existing free form um that also right now has a wide long open curb cut adjoining to the street allowing for cars to just back out which won't be there anymore um there was another um concern requesting that there be a traffic study before the approval as the site is near the queuing line for a nearby um school and the food pantry that's operating out of the nearby Church um applicant uh didn't respond at the hearing we um looked at this and note that traffic studies typically evaluate the proposed use with respect to what the use
004is and what the size is and we note that the application is to convert an existing 175q foot shed for an organic wine store that is not anticipated to have uh to generate a large increase in the amount of traffic in the area um we note that existing peak times for use of the nearby food pantry and the school and the um existing Springs General Store can create some um traffic backups but the proposed wine store is not anticipated to add to the traffic at these peak times we noted that um uh some photographs of Springs General Store were submitted I think they were showing uh July 30th um we note that is probably one of the peak traffic and parking days for all of East Hampton and um that is generally not um a
005day that we um come up with a parking plan to meet it's almost like a making a shopping mall meet the number of cars that are parked on Christmas Eve you know to be able to to accommodate them on site you don't you don't me the Peak parking ever on site um there was a request to improve the parking and circulation to better coordinate with the existing traffic flows and conditions associated with the school and the food pantry operations they pointed out that there is a pedestrian pathway um crosswalk right near the um exit uh yeah that's shown thank you Chris um right near the where the exit for the site is and we referred this issue to uh rer group The Consulting Engineers for the planning board and um they did not find a
006problem uh with the traffic circulation onsite and and uh as it meets the off-site traffic circulation they did request or suggest that there be the installation of signs for the one-way access on the site and um the planning department was just concerned that you know they were suggesting like some do signs or whatever and we were concerned of what that might look like we're in a historic building in a historic district and we don't want the signs to be the dominant thing that is seen so that um we would suggest that there were will be uhu that there should be some indication of the one-way traffic flow but that be subject to the ARB review to come up with either something painted in the street or some sort of sign that will um not be
007the dominant thing that you see associated with springs General store and then um there was a comment that the applicant has backed away from the commitment to install a low nitrogen IIA septic system at the hearing and the applicant agent indicated that a low nitrogen AI system is not a requirement for this project and that they had always made made it clear that they will install one if the town Awards a grant to the project and they noted that as this is a commercial facility requiring a grease trap the cost for installing a low nitrogen IIA system is much greater than for a single family residents um the planning department checked with the East Hampton Water Quality Technical advisory committee and they had previously recommended uh funding for an IIA for this site it went
008to the town board at that point I think the application had not evolved to the point where it is now where there's no on-site consumption of alcohol um as part of the application so I believe it was for that reason that the town board declined to um go with a recommendation to help fund the IIA we are recommending that the applicant um go forward uh and reapply um for a fund and the Grant application opens December 16th and closes in mid-February of 2025 and we note that the town and um other private um and semi-private facilities in this area have uh expended a great deal of money and effort um to do nitrogen reduction in this area with the spring school doing an up upgrade with the town and um Cooperative Extension um putting in
009um those nitrogen prbs permeable membrane and it is a very sensitive part of the harbor and um we would imagine that this would um be a very high recommendation uh for the town to be installing an IIA in this area um we so that's it for the public hearing comments the office of the fire prevention um had indicated no further review is uh necessary um and so we have just summarized the um items to be approved if you're ready to go forward with it in terms of what site plans um have been prepared and we note that the um there was a natural resource special permit um issued and so there are conditions of that that must be met there was a DEC permit issued and those um uh standards uh must be met um
010and uh I think I've covered everything else um so in conclusion the applicants should be required to resubmit for RFA funding for low IIA system in the upcoming grant grant round opening on December 16th um we would recommend the planning board determin that the project will not substantially increase the traffic and therefore no traffic study would be required that the planning board requireed directional signs or arrows be installed to alert the drivers to the one-way traffic circulation pattern subject to the ARB to ensure compatibility with the historic character of the area and the planning board requireed the applicant to submit site plan approval if changes to the liquor Authority license permit or a new permit is sought for the future thanks very much okay the record is Clos so I just have some notes here
011I just want to mention you know with the regard to this uh application that I want to clarify that our job as a planning board is not to allow uh to design how a business is to be run uh whatever permitted use is to be conducted over another or whether to serve breakfast egg sandwiches or not that's not our job we're charged with the authority to determine whether the applicant in establishing its business and structures is doing so within the strictures of the zoning code and good planning without endangering the interest of the community the look and Aesthetics of the St site still needs the approval of the ARB and it's a condition of the planning board anticipated approval and I think those directional signs is something that they need to look at uh um
012I'm also hopeful and optimistic that the applicant will receive the grant it's applied for I think the town board didn't deny it I think they said that they were going to wait for planning board approval okay yeah and I'm sure they they will approve it I'm sorry if I misspoken it really would be criminal if a new system is not put in on the site because of its close proximity to very sensitive water body um also to address another complaint that the applicant had this was an application that prompted a large community interest for a number of good reasons the fear that a long-standing neighborhood treasure would be transformed into a local nuisance that the consumption of alcohol would attract an unsavory clientele inimical to the area and that loud music congregations would disturb the
013Peace of the local it took longer than the applicant and the planning board would have helped but I believe the hard work and patience of all interested parties including the members of the community was worth it I believe we have a plan that mitigates the original fears and one which the applicant can be proud of and we all wish the owners a ton of success and I think this application is ready for approval thank you Luke does anybody at the table have anything they want to add and we will go with the single question before us which is is the application ready for approval yes yes yes okay the application is ready for approval we'll have a resolution um I when I guess in the next meeting but I don't want to commit to the
014planning board uh planning department but uh it'll be there'll be a resolution thank you very much thank you for your participation and for working to get this application now is ready for Happy New Year to all Merry Christmas to all thank you all right the next item on the agenda and I'm refused oh okay yes bar the um this is the Hampton 310 LLC Barn Chris this is yours Bruce this is yours okay um this yours okay very good Sam may I interrupt for one minute can this monitor get turned let try to resolve that we're having issues with that one so me thank you thanks chrises like too big yeah there we go actually it's good if you step on your then you can see I can scooch over we need to get you
015a spinning shair that's what I need that nice you're welcome much thank you Chris oh I see us a little bit that is yeah you're right yeah we have two barns two barns let's let's let's not mix up our barns this is the Hampton 310 LLC bar yeah yeah yeah what a great [Laughter] movie favorite show is the broadcast of this on channel 22 repeated over it's on YouTube apologies for the delay everyone if it's going to take that long let's just roll with it [Music] [Applause] [Music] again to the TV iall games [Music] tonight what we doing with that yeah turn on the S Harbor Concert school [Laughter] concert so we just we just learned that my daughter is a push-ups she's a push-up winner doesn't teenagers don't talk to us that's funny how
016old is she [Music] 13 we doing any there we go we got itoll that [Music] good wrong everything's a little messed up with it the right plan there there you go that's it F the lane yeah that's the one just a site plan I guess apologies for the it's a modern a masterpiece I think we'll just go with the site no that it's a b don't touch anything this property is on further Lane um can't really see it the map um this is between the Tyson lanes and further Lane um sort of towards Easter end of the East Hampton Hamlet closer to M again it um just for location reference and this will be the board's second time uh discussing this application as it was first reviewed at the September 25 meeting so just to
017give some context on the site especially for the new board member um subject property is Zone A5 residential and it's 349 Square 349 and 480 Square ft or just over 8 Acres um the entire property has an ag ag ultural conservation easement in the favor of the eonic land trust um the properties within the town agricultural overlay district and is therefore exempt from clearing restrictions it's also a Scenic area of Statewide significance uh which is encourages the protection of us and scen qualities of the property and just to note her conversations with the property manager the produce grown on site is not s sold or and the owners have no intention uh to ever sell anything produced on site so a background for the application itself a site plan application has been submitted to relocate
018a 1,184 ft Barn shown here in yellow um and that's from Tyson Lane which is to the south of this property to the subject property uh 310 further Lane and the barn is proposes an agricultural support structure that would be used for equipment storage and the temporary storage of produce grown on site um the proposed Barn includes a sink for washing produce a new septic system an underground water and electrical service lines connecting to the east to Tyson Lane the applicant also proposes a pervious driveway and parking area um taking access from the Eastern side of Tyson Lane indicated here so moving on to the issues for discussion following the review of the planning board from the September 25 meeting the board issued written comments to the applicant regarding several issues and I'll go over
019each comment with the applicant's response and the planning Department's assessment of each response so the first comment mentioned that the board had agreed to wave the requirement for additional details on parking to be provided um however did not wave the requirement for hydrant fire hydrant to be added to the site plan um the applicants has since revised to show the fire hydrants um and the planning department is satisfied with that requirement and then the second comment was that the applicant should revise the site plan to reroute the proposed uh utility lines Tyson Lane originally they were going to go north through the orchard to further Lane but have since been uh rerouted to the east to reduce the distance and overall disturbance regarding the site navigation and traffic as I mentioned the original uh submission
020proposed site access across a 450 ft driveway from the West property line to the proposed Barn um and the applicant was encouraged to relocate it as such and has then done so with this revised submission however where this driveway is taking from access from uh there is no gate existing um where it connects to Tyson Lane so the submission should be revised to include a proposed gate on the site plan and provide elevation drawing of such gate or the proposed driveway should be modified on the site plan to take access from an existing gate on the same property line and that exists on the same line but more to the South and it's something that we ask to be added to the revised submission it was not included in this one um but when they
021revise their driveway plan they should show that existing gate whether or not they decide to take access using it so moving on to outdoor lighting the revised submission includes some details on proposed exterior lighting for the barn and the planning department notes that no exterior lighting was included in the original submission so a comprehensive lighting plan which meets all the provision of the town code as well as planning board guidelines for exterior lighting should be submitted just given that it's the first time a structure um gross floor area that's being introduced to the site and the submission is missing the necessary manufacturers specification sheets for all the proposed fixtures as well as a photometric plot plan illustrating lighting incidents and flip candles throughout the site that meet the requirements listed in this evaluation um so
022the applicant should review the comprehensive site lighting plan requirements and submit that in the revised submission regarding the sanitary system which is proposed the applicant proposes a gray flow volume of 25 gallons per day and there's no sanitary flow given that Su will not be produced on site there's no bathroom planned the only use of water um be connected to the produce washing on site and the planing Department would note that the agricultural agricultural conservation eement in place um mentions that a leeching or sewage disposal field is prohibited except in accordance with sound agricultural management practices um and the suffa county department of health services is requiring the applicant to connect the proposed sync to an IA system an Innovative and alternative on-site Waste Water treatment system and since the scdhs the county is uh
023requiring the system and no seage disposal is proposed the planning department finds a proposed IA system would be in accordance with sound agricultural management practices and thus would not have any issues with the easement in place on this property planning department notes that the sanitary plan has not been revised from the original submission and still indicates Ates a traditional septic system therefore the applicant should include the uh AI system in the revised submission regarding the office of fire prevention that has been reviewed by the Chief Fire Marshal and found that uh the information is submitted and there is no additional review necessary for fire protection purposes the applicants advised of the additional approvals required from the Architectural Review Board for the structures mentioned um suff County department Health Services for the AI system as mentioned
024um I system as well as suff County Planning Commission review will be required um given the properties in an agricultural overlay District so moving on to the necessary elements of a site plan um for the submission in the previous evaluation the planning board um the applicant was referred to the necessary elements to revise the submission to meet the minimum standards detailed um that were missing in the original submission the board however chose to wave the requirement for additional parking details as I mentioned however some of the required items noted in that original evaluation are still not addressed in the most recent submissions um so I'll go over those just by letter and that includes the ones that were not addressed along with the new issues um with respect to outdoor lighting so for b um
025still missing is the ground elevation of the proposed barn and parking area just to have an idea if the ground elevation there is still required um and then the Eastern Gate to Tyson Lane must be indicated and specify whether it is a driveway or vehicle access and theate that's on this property line further to the South with respect to lighting Elements which I'm not going to repeat but it's just that a comprehensive lighting plan should be submitted um for the section of town code and then with respect to Elevation drawings of buildings and structures if a new gate is proposed along the Eastern property line uh elevation drawings should be provided for set gate so in conclusion um the planning department is satisfied that the proposed driveway and utility lines have been rerouted the applicant
026should provide details on the proposed entrance gate or Revis plans to use the existing gate on the Eastern property line which should be indicated on the revised submission the applicant should also provide details on the proposed exterior lighting as indicated above before and the planning board uh unanimously agreed during their last review that the proposal doesn't align with the intent of the Agricultural conservation eement um the board should review the necessary elements of the site plan which are missing from the submission and discuss whether they will wave any requirements and lastly the applicant must add the proposed I system onto the as I thank you for your patience with us know what we're looking at now thanks at least you guys can see well we don't get to see the picture of the uh baseball
027field next door but does the applicant wish to be here certainly Mr chair good evening everyone Eric Brown acrian partners for the applicant uh Chris thank you for excellent memo as always um we are certainly prepared to address all the deficiencies I think the gate is not in there because the applicant has not yet decided how they're going to deal with that it's going to be you know a standard farm gate it's not going to be anything you know anything particularly fancy uh so we'll we'll get those uh those drugs and elevations to you the sanitary now that that's been worked out with the building inspector the county and the applicant we'll have that put on um the lighting I I just want the board to know that if you if you refer to uh
028Ferguson shamian drawing A1 100.1 there are only three exterior lights proposed on this uh on this there's there's no existing lighting now on the site and no additional lighting is proposed other than on each end of the West uh facade of the building and one light on the south facade so we'll you know we'll Supply you with all the you know you know with those lighting specs but this is not a site that's designed to be used utilized after dark I mean you know these are really just you know you know lights that if somebody does have to go there at night you you have some kind of light motion activated I I don't know I can find out for you we could certainly do it that way I you know I mean you know
029although amount of deer that go through there you know like you know like just go Inferno or something so um so in any case that's you know there there other exterior lights proposed for the property uh the three on the structure are the only ones that are proposed and we'll we'll submit to everybody uh uh the revisions and go from there very well thanks very much thank thank you me thanks Chris thanks Eric um yeah I think this is actually looking really good um couple things you know Ed the fire hydrant which I think is super important along with the utilities along um Tyson Lane East um instead of coming across the orchard I think that's a great um addition to this um couple questions I had about a the gate um and then location
030is sanitary system and parking just looking at the um the survey um obviously Chris mentioned there's a gate well further down to the South I I can't imagine you guys are going to be using that driving I think would utilize the the uh the access closest to the to the location where the board had recommended we you know we take access so I I don't think that makes any more sense than coming all the way across the the West so I think with that in mind um there are a lot of mature trees along that Eastern Edge so where you're going to come through is probably pretty important to figure out because we're where it is indicated now I don't think it's going to work um and then is there a basement under the barn
031or or no okay so that'll get to my next point so um just thinking about the parking area and the sanitary field I was wondering if maybe that could get flipped and have your water M come in on the North side where your um sink is okay because otherwise you're going to the water lines coming in the southeast side and to get it all the way across the barn without a basement I think it's going to be probably pose an issue so you know maybe parking is on the east side and then you know your sanitary is either on the North or the West um the AI system is kind of an interesting concept where I'm not quite sure how that's going to work with gray water but that's I guess that's already been decided
032um and then the last thing with the lighting uh like Eric said there just three very small lights um two on the West Side um facing into the property um 8 and a half LED wattage I think is is equivalent to like a 75 watt bulb yeah um it says you know cross the glass so that the source won't be won't be seen um and I guess you know with that spec we probably need a Kelvin temperature for the LED Bolt um other than that that's it are you okay with the uh lighting given the proximity of houses the residential yeah um you know we're 200 feet from further Lane 80 feet from Tyson and we're oh that's gone we are don't ask a long way from everything to the South so you're okay with
033yeah does anybody else have anything they want to add on this okay so does the planning board wave the requirement for a comprehensive lighting plan to be submitted I'm a little I'm a little Ley about that you know just because if only because it's been added subsequent to the additional application uh I think small enough amount of lights that it shouldn't be too honorous to good point I mean I can I can represent to the board that that's that's that's it to the extent it's comprehensive it's three it's three lights there's nothing but the idea is that no I I understand I'm not disagreeing I'm just saying that that's pretty much as comprehensive as it's going to get the photo metric is going to be super easy to do so that's fine yeah yeah small
034small uh live yeah okay all right so uh we're not going to wait okay uh does the planning board agree the planning Department's assessment of additional information must be provided uh per town code 2556 D50 item that yeah okay there plan is y that's what it requires very well see appreciate it okay next item on the agenda Ed you can rejoin us now is the Wayne Scott Holdings LLC modification thank thank you for assigning that to me you to walk over have an opportunity to see your neighborhood old okay will this is yours you're going to do it if I may planning board uh Brian Frank or Chris or anybody on that other monitor if you want to hit the input on that monitor with that remote that might switch your picture this this stands
035out you're going to have to keep hitting the input until the uh the picture shows up what do they want to do plan plane board to go that was a joke hey that looks good got to give Matt the credit thanks thank you ran thank [Music] you taking away will great um so this is an application that has been made seeking a modification to the way Scott holding subdivision to expand the previously approved driveway access to a lot not part of the original subdivision but owned by the same family um the highlighted lots are the original subdivision and this lot here along the pond is the additional lot the subdivision is approximately 38.7 acres in size and the pond lot is approximately 20 acres or 87441 ft in size the lots are zoned A5 residents
036and are located within the harbor production ction overlay District agricultural overlay District a recommended Scenic area of Statewide significance and are on the recommended Community preservation fund of blist the subdivision is mostly cleared due to ongoing agricultural use of some of the Lots lot one down here is improved with a two-story single family residence detached garage swimming pool porches and wood decking Lots two and four have driveways leading to lot one these two the pond lot is mostly cleared for farming as well but has a section of dunand vegetation in its southern part between wcot Pond and the Atlantic Ocean so that's this sort of L-shaped area here and that area is unlikely to be impacted by the proposed access modification the original subdivision was approved on March 9th 2018 and included driveway access running
037along the edge of the agriculture reserved area to the southern Lots located along Atlantic and that access is this white driveway the applicant has indicated the driveway was designed to preserve access to the pond lot and seeks to formalize that access with this modification the project is a type two action pursuant to secra and chapter 128 of the town code and requires no further secret action at this time the applicant stated that the pond lot has been accessed by a similar route to the approved driveway for many years including before the family came into ownership of the properties in 1983 so here's an aerial from 1978 and it's a little bit hard to see but the access kind of goes along here and this is from before the families owned the land this is from
038after they own the land and you can see that same access running along here and this is a modern aial image showing access over this common driveway so I I just Ty a question because the photos were not clear uh is the pond lot the driveway the want add is is just here is that what's going on yeah just here because this all exists it's all it's all very nice driveway there's just in right that's that's what we're talking about [Applause] okay here's an image uh taken recently showing the path of driving over into that font lot and so this is the final Subdivision map and this is that same driveway here and this is approximately where they would add that access okay all lots are owned by the same family under different llc's and
039the pond lot was given its own LLC within the last year access to the pond lot currently exists along the approved driveway over an unimproved section of grass although no material change of circumstances is present in this proposed modification the planning department recommends the recognition of access to the PM lot already accessed by the common driveway is a relatively minor modification and not likely to create negative impacts to the surrounding area though the original subdivision created four Lots this access modification proposes to provide access for a fifth lot which is the pond lot for town code a common driveway is not permitted to Ser serve more than four residential lots however Lot 4 is an agricultural reserved area and only referred to as a lot for Health Department purposes and does not count towards the
040total number of lots per common driveway requirements after consultation with the town attorney's office the planning department has determined that proposed access modification is compliant with town code in conclusion the planning department recommends that applicant submit a revised survey displaying the proposed access to the pond lot in the next submission thank you very much will M Baldwin good evening board um Elizabeth Baldwin um SXF and angel I'm here also with for from science on behalf of the applicant um which is actually Townline Holdings LLC way Scott colors LLC and way Scott Pond LLC which are all different entities within the same family um as we explain we're really here to just Memorial memorialize what we think everyone kind of assumed back in 2018 that there was the access for the pond lot would continue um
041how it was but it wasn't included in because it wasn't included in the subdivision it was not included as part of the common driveway easement that was filed um so now that the family is in their in a process of um State planning and reorganizing um properties amongst themselves they just wanted to clarify that the access from Town Line can continue down the uh common driveway and and that Pon lot does in fact have access uh so that that's really why we're here um and in in discussions with the planning department and with the town attorney's office everyone felt that um while because the family it's all owned by the same family the family themselves could give access to the pond lot just to benefit the pond lot it was felt it would be better
042um for planning purposes to amend not replace the existing um common driveway easement with a new common driveway easement that incorporates the pond lot onto it to make it a cleaner um uh easement for the future and this way there's no overlapping or anything and and this way that um Pon lot would have that access and it wouldn't be questioned down the road um so that's that's basically why we're here I'm not sure um I don't think we have a proposed access defin access at this point it's really just that we can use the road itself the common driveway itself to access the pwn lot should this property ever go through a site plan or some sort of review process if it was ever built upon which is not in the cards for this property
043right now um I think at that point would be when the board would probably want to set where the access is I don't think you want to lock yourself into an access point on this lot at this time I think it's just a matter matter of saying that this lot can be accessed from this road from Town Line rather than at what point will the um access to the pond lot cross over the property boundary of the um a area because I think the board would want to do that at the point when if if and when this ever is built upon um so well thank you Michael thank you it this seems very straightforward uh uh I I noticed that the pond lot has a cover crop so that is is is being farmed
044on right now and historically and and that's what the that's why they they still access and I believe they hunt off of there and and and there's farming so they use it for both purposes I saw about six bald eagles flying over there when I visited there too um it seems cut and dry to me I have no objection to it my only issue with it is that my understanding is that the uh narrative contains a reference to estate planning as a change in circumstance I'm really wary about making any kind of precedent that says that because if we start making aate planning a change in circumstance we're going to have modifications from here to uh the basement I mean I just I really think that's a dangerous thing if the basis for the modification
045on the other hand is is that you're correcting a mistake an obvious mistake then I don't have a particular problem with it and I don't think we have to delve into the change and circumstances uh uh dialogue that we have with applicants um we recently had a change in circumstance that we were able to find because there was a building envelope that was uh made smaller and that was call it a quid proquo but we found that the the change in circumstance was the fact that there was a smaller building envelope you have a building envelope here maybe you might want to look at that if indeed you're interested in change in circumstance on the other hand if it's just a matter of fixing something that everybody knows was a mistake that might be the
046cleaner easier way to do it I just would want to make sure that the record doesn't contain any reference at all to uh the estate planning needs as being a change in circumstance cuz like I say that's just good we saying a change in the Nar should be Chang well yeah saying I don't think that it's the estate planning that um is the change in circumstance I think the estate planning made them realize that the estate needed to be corrected that's not the first time that's happened in the history of the world and that's understandable but let let's just make sure all right work with with the planning department and Council if to make sure that there's no implication that this is driven by or or not driven by right but that it's not an
047estate planning change in circumstance that's not the reason it's understood good yeah okay with that anybody have anything else they want add oh I totally agree with what you said yep so should the applicant submit a revised survey displaying the proposed access to the pond lot and do we yeah I know I think right well I think it's like a floating access like we have we've seen floating easements here this is kind of the same thing right and I think that's been done before and that it really should be when the property is being built on that you make that decision as far as where you want the access because you don't want to lock yourself in now in 20 years you just side wait a minute it really should have been down here and
048and considering that there's nothing going on on the property maybe it can all be dealt with in the context of your narrative so that you can describe the intention in your narrative and I think that would uh yeah cover cover cover you cover us now make a record so you all know what we're talking about and then down the road if somebody you know decides they want to uh live there do we want to show that there is an existing access now yeah I think it's access from rather than access to it's access from town line to the property versus right right because that's what they need that's what they they want to clarify and make sure that it's clear down the road is that they do in fact have access to Townline maybe we
049can maybe we can see if it'll work in a narrative when you come back and if if if the board isn't satisfied with the narrative then we'll you know you'll have to go for a survey but if that's the way the board decides that that the narrative issue can be improved okay all right um question number two does the board agree a change in circumstances as present not really hear that and doesn't need to and doesn't need to be and doesn't need and doesn't need to be right right exactly we're expecting an existing B did you have anything else on this one thank you very much thank you very so as far as just the narrative is that just a letter or am I how do you it's English language paragraphs type it out no
050no you don't want to do that go go home take out the laptop okay thank you thank you very much all right uh finally on the work session we have the mcarver bond modification um that's listed as Dan but I guess will you're pin okay Ed and uh Mr Crouch I see okay welcome okay take it away take it away uh this is an application that has been made seeking a modification to a previous site plan approval to remove a firew well add a curb cut remove the performance bond allow longer turnout time for the horses and allow fence L irrigation the original application approved a barn with Second Story Hay Loft four paddocks a jumping ring and seven parking spaces the subject property is approximately 5.1 Acres or 222,50 ft in size and is
051zoned A3 residence the lot is located within the S South Fort groundwater protection area and the suffa county Pine Barons the site is considered to be exempt from clearing regulations due to its agriculture use the lot is currently improved with a two-story single family residence with attached garage covered porches roof deck Barn four paddocks jumping Rings seven parking spaces horse shelter swimming pool pool fencing hot tub patio and pool housee this project is a type two action pursuant to Seca in chapter 128 of the town code and requires no further Seeker action at this time the applicant submitted an email exchange between themselves and the Chief Fire Marshall in which the Fire Marshall indicated public water access will be extended to within 1,000 ft of the property by the suffa County Water Authority with public
052water access being available closer to the property the previously approved firew well would be unnecessary to maintain the applicant stated the fire department requested a new curb cut to be installed at the northwest corner of the property and Hunting Road that proposed curb cut is up here in this northwest corner the town Consulting engineer indicated at the new curb cut and driveway are acceptable but requested the applicant submit a revised site plan showing the new locations of the drainage soil and fencing if they are to remain um that drainage soil is present here in an area that would be disrupted by the proposed driveway and the wood fencing similarly isn't an area that would be disrupted the original site plan approval included a pasture management plan which contained two conditions of a typical turnout time
053of 4 hours and underground irrigation the applicant has stated a four out turnout time 4-Hour turnout time is not sufficient for the horses and below ground irrigation within the paddocks is prone to damage by the horses the applicant has suggested the turnout time limit be removed from the pasture management plan as the pasture management plan also required rotation and rest of the paddocks to prevent overuse regarding irrigation the applicant proposes amending the condition to permit to permit fence line irrigation to prevent further horse related damage the original site plan approval for the project included Security in amount of $65,000 in the form of a performance bond the applicant attached the town board resolution dated September 15 2011 which eliminated the requirement of performance bonds for work related to site planine approvals the applicant has indicated
054in their cover letter based on consultation with the plan Department the performance bond is no longer necessary in conclusion the applicant should submit a revised site plan illustrating the new locations of the items to be displaced by the new curb cut and driveway if they are to remain on site thanks will very much Mr Crouch Thomas Crouch of wh fer here for the applicants David and Lori mcgara they're also here with their vet uh Dr Nora KPS uh as will summarize we really asking for four modifications or four changes to the original approval um yes the we met with the fire fire department a while ago and discussed um that they had gotten notied that uh the Water Authority was going to extend the main within a th000 ft of the property so the well
055wouldn't be necessary worked with them they wanted a curb cut which we put on the amended site plan um and and that would satisfy their needs so I you know would ask the board and the planning department please reach out to the fire department and confirm you know whatever you need from them uh the performance bond that was uh eliminated as a requirement by the town board in 2011 uh Eric chance sent me the resolution so uh you know Nancy if you want to confirm that you're welcome to um the other two items we have uh the applicants in their vet can speak more fully on that um these are basically we we're asking for the removal of the requirement for 4-Hour turnabout um the the standard practice is for no requirement no such requirement
056for a horse farm um they have they'll have six horses uh it's not good for the horses and they'll have four paddocks that they can use to rotate uh to prevent overwear um of the you know paddocks themselves um and then the irrigation uh you know that's another the standard practice is for fence line irrigation because if you have sprinkler heads underground horses tend to trample on things and um it would you know damage the lines damage that sprinkler heads so uh my clients are here if you have any questions about specifically the 4-Hour turnabout in the fence line irrigation um I'm not an expert in horse farms so uh anyway uh let us know if you have any questions we're happy to uh make those changes to the side plan itself just to we
057put in the curb cut in the driveway and didn't really think about the you know the drain of soil and the trees that need to be adjusted so anyway uh thanks for your time is the um waiver from the town board in the record oh yes I submitted the resolution itself so we have my letter the planning department has that now yes okay G okay good uh yeah thanks Thomas we're not experts on this either amazingly enough yeah I've been in this board for seven years I don't think I've ever heard the term pasture management Plan before um so it's this is a really interesting one so yeah just taking your requests sort of one by one the uh you know the new curb cut makes perfect sense of course coming in from the hunting
058road side um and yeah so we just need to have the site plan amended as you've already suggested you'll do including modifications to the Swale at that side of property um in terms of the irrigation that certainly seems you know perfectly reasonable and fine to me to move to move that out of the pasture land itself um I think you know in terms of you know the turnout time I'm sure that you know you know what what is sort of conventional and what's sort of acceptable in in the industry around that um I don't think any of us well I don't I'll speak for myself you know have any issue with with that being amended I think though we'd like to have something in writing from some you know Professional Organization that establishes standards for
059things like this right you know something that indicates that it's you know eight hours or there's no set what whatever it is we I think we need something from Professional Organization that do that will sort of substantiate what an appropriate turnout time actually is I think that's one thing I'd like to see um in terms of the performance bond you know if that if the town board has already determined that they don't need them any longer I think we need to you know deal with that but I think think we might want to take a moment to think make sure that we're on you know proper legal footing about how we we deal with that issue but I think conceptually um I'm fine with that that certainly makes sense it's not required you know why
060tie the money up right so that's what I have on it I think uh you know conceptually it all look SE fine to us but we do need to have some some you know substantiation on the turnout time and I think we want to figure out a little more closely how to deal with this per performance bond issue so we know we're doing it correctly I have a question why why is there why was there a 4H hour limit in the first place my question as well come if you go to speak um go ahead Thomas you I don't know I mean the approval is from 2007 so I don't know you know and and I'm not sure why um you know there's no I can't go back and watch the video but um there's
061not yeah so I'm not sure I just know from speaking with my clients in their vet that that's just not a standard requirement and I so I can't really do you do you propose to have the horses or one or two horses out 247 365 days a year possible okay yeah it's healthier for that need you're going to speak you need to come up and introduce yourself and microphone won't pick you up back there thanks hi I'm Dr kleps and I've been practicing since 92 um and I've had horses personally for over 40 years and the consensus in the equine Community is for the best health of the horse because they are prey animals and also Grazy animals if you can find them in a store for a long period of time uh they become
062they develop bad habits they their mental state deteriorates they're standing in their own mess they have a 12 by 12 box stall the best thing for them is to be out moving imitating grazing grazing if there's grass there's fewer respiratory problems fewer upset stomach problems and their mental health is better um that's that's pretty much it it's it's for the health of a horse it wouldn't be too much to put something together I can go to our organization it's called the American Association of equin practitioners and that's our kind of go-to place where we have questions about I AMA avma AAP is the equin profession understand that you know we're we're making a determination and none of us at least far as I know has any expertise so in order for us to be able
063to endorse the request and say sure no problem the record really needs to contain something in the nature of an expert's opinion some kind of something that something that if somebody complains down the road we can say the experts told us this is how you do it I'm not an expert but they are well if you can find they are there you go see the agenda I'm sorry that's okay my question um is I I don't know who to you you probably work with other farms and and barns horses are there any other restrictions on any other no barns in the area not that I know just curious yeah okay yeah well this is the application that we have before us now today I understand it's all about making a record and all about making
064sure that like I say nobody's going to say as of that I know we like records too okay okay thank you very thank you very much thanks for listening does anyone else have any questions comments issues they want to raise does the you know I'm wondering about this does do we agree to remove the performance mon I mean if the town board's already done it you know there is a kind of supremacy clause just like a release of security type something I think we should just say pending you know consultation with our Council about how to do that yeah and it may be that the bond itself um says that this board and not the town board is the one that has to issue the release so if you could look into that council could
065look into that then Sam it's very easy it's done by resolution releasing the security we but it's our resolution right not the town's resolution planning board plan it's the planning board so okay so thank you now we know the answer okay so well okay in that case will we agree to to remove the performance bond yes okay yeah you are should the 4-Hour turnaround time be removed from the pasture management planing some expert rep opinion okay should the pasture management plan permit fence line irrigation I think we can say yes on that on that and should the applicant submit a site uh a site depicting the new proposed locations of the drainage sale and fencing that's that you know okay thank you very much we F see you again you thank you thank you thank
066you for coming out okay we moving to the regular meeting now um first item on the agenda is uh of the regular meeting is the m talk Shores condo sewage treatment PL Ed that's yours do you need uh I've got it right here thank you very much uh in the matter of the application of Monto Shores Condominium sewer sewer treatment plan site plan suffer County tax map 300- 32.1 D1 D2 67.1 site plan special permit approval I've read the findings and determination of the board and call for the adoption of this is there determination than is there a second I'll second that those in favor I pass seven uh SN phas commercial right in the matter of the application of Snyder phase commercial site plan special permit SE County tax map 300-1 43-1 d12.3 12.4
067and 12.5 extension of time I've read the resolution for the extension of time and approved the extension uh that's du December 18th 2025 yes very good is there a second second those in favor pass seven whether it was an i or a s okay s nothing so we have that um then finally we have the Heritage Farm uh and Michael that's you in the matter of the application of Heritage Farm Laney final subdivision modification to the county tax map 3000-1 15737 point one I have read the resolution and move for its adoption is there a second second Wasing it out sorry I is usually not this time all those in favor said enough right the last three things fall for me I'm gon to do the um I'm gonna do the Border review first um
068this is the request of Claver Lopez um hope I pronounce the first name correctly apologize if I didn't uh locate for the premise is located at 317 Street South County tax map 300 76-7 d5.5 the uh work to be performed is um on 6th Street and 7th Street um the uh repair on Sixth Street it's repair existing asphalt as necessary um starting at Garden Avenue and continuing along Sixth Street for 24 ft uh and also paves 26 linear feet along 6th Street starting at the intersection of Garden ravenue continuing South um minimum of 1 A2 in um New York State type 6f asphal top um to the culdesac including I'm sorry the cuac as directed by the town engineer and on Seventh Street repair the existing asphalt pavement as necessary with base course asphalt starting
069at 155 ft from the intersection of Garder Avenue and continuing along 7th Street for a distance of 30 ft as directed by the town engine near and likewise pave 240 ft along 7th Street starting at the edge of the existing top course uh top course asphalt pavement approximately 155 ft from the intersection of Garder Avenue and continuing South uh with a minimum of one and a half inches of New York State type 6f asphalt as directed by the town engineer the bond on this is $16,500 I have reviewed the board of review and I move for its adoption second all those in favor c s nothing finally I read the board minutes of December 4th 2024 they appear correct and complete and I move for their adoption all those in favor pass board minut are
070ad okay folks the last thing on the plate is the senior senator Monroe balancing the public interest P which I had added to the agenda um I want to say a few words about the town's Monroe resolution which was adopted by 3 to one vote on December 10th uh which was after our last meeting I do not want this to become any kind of discussion I just want while I'm still chair and still on the board to address this matter because it's important now we all know I'm a lawyer but I'm not a land attorney or a municipal attorney and I do not give this board legal advice so I rely on the good advice of the Town attorney when it comes to the legal matters that come before this board so I made an
071inquiry of the Town attorney with respect to the time frame within which the planning board could bring an article 78 proceeding with respect to the town's Monroe resolution and I sent all of you a copy of that letter and um you will have that yesterday the town attorney advised the planning board you all got a copy of that email that the planning board would have four months to bring an article 78 proceeding regarding the Monroe resolution so there is no immediate du it today urgency this issue can wait until next year the planning board has the time to consult with an attorney and make a legally informed decision about what its rights are and if on the basis of its Council advi advice the planning board decides it wants to bring an article 78 proceeding
072the planning board will have enough time to go forward but I have my own opinion about why this board should retain Council regarding an article 78 proceeding which I would like to share I have misgivings about the towns Monroe resolution that have nothing to do with the senior center it's self my per se My misgivings are about how the Monroe resolution regards the planning board the issue at hand is whether the town will adhere to its own laws which as the resolution itself says the town is quote presumed to be subject to and that's at the bottom of page one of the resolution in other words the town admits that if this was a private application it would come before the planning board for site plan review now under the Monroe case the town has
073to employ a nine-part balancing test to determine whether to wave its own laws and as I read it the sole driving reason that the town gives to wave its own laws is that the delays that the town claims it will encounter if those laws are enforced outweigh the presumed needs of its aging population and speaking only for myself as an aside I'd add that in making these presumptions I believe the town's monal resolution falls short in any event section four of the Monroe resolution states it is the town board's position that given the immediate and increasing needs of the town's aging popul ation the senior center must be constructed as proposed and its existing land use regulations have a prohibitive effect upon the town's ability to construct the facility close quote and so the town
074board not the planning board will again quoting the resolution quote approve site work to ready the premises close quote and quote approve a final site plan for the construction of the senior center close quote now you'll recall that earlier this year the town we this board disputed the town taking lead agency uh status under secra that's a separate dispute from the uh the issue of the Monro declaration which is about in the enforceability of town law over the town but in making the uh resol the determination the acting commission I believe is the acting commissioner of the uh Department of Environmental Conservation in his findings stated the town board should be designated as lead Agency for the secr review of the construction of the proposed Senior Center based on the second Criterion there are three
075criterions that the dec looks at in deciding lead agents need disputes they identified the second criteria which uh basically said in in reaching that they said the town board has the greatest ability to amend its plans or avoid avoid to avoid or reduce the Project's impacts through its authority over the project and that was the basis that the dec ruled that the town board should be lead agency but in making that determination as in in the finding the next paragraph of the finding stated and I'm going to quote it takes a moment this designation does not change or diminish the responsibilities or authority of the planning board or other involved agencies with jurisdiction over the project to reiterate the planning board whether it remains as an involved or interested agency has a role to play
076in advising the town board given its statutory responsibilities and collective experience in managing the town's secret process in other regulatory reviews the town board indicated that it intends to consult with the planning board on the development of the senior center I encourage the town board to do so I likewise encourage the town board to solicit the advice of other involved interested agencies now the Monro resolution does mention the DEC dispute and the determination that the dec made that the town board should be the lead agency but it doesn't contain any mention of that last admonition from the dec that I just read instead the resolution states that quote it shall I'm sorry it quote shall request written comment from the planning board close quote and that the planning board quote shall have 30 days from
077the date of such request by by the town board in which to provide written comment after which the town board may take further action on the project as it deems appropriate close quote in other words the resolution gives this board the planning board one shot and 30 days to prepare that shot now I think it's incumbent on the planning board to it the very speak to an independent attorney and decide whether the Monroe resolution is good enough whether this BL should bring an article 78 proceeding that's the way I feel the good news is that we're not going to make any decisions now and in fact I don't want as I said have any discussion about it I wanted to raise the issue on my way out the door because while I'm still chairman and
078still on this board I wanted to express that opinion in a few weeks this board will have a new chairman and under the new chairman you can have that discussion just not now which is a kind of back way of saying that I've been uh informed in a conversation that I had a couple of weeks ago with the supervisor that I'm not going to be asked to continue as the chairman of the uh planning board um I have uh thought about it I have another year on my term as a member of this board and I'll tell you I've had a lot of I've lost a lot of sleep uh trying to come up with a decision about whether I want to remain on the planning board or not I have decided that I'm not
079going to I'm going to resign from the board I have to talk to uh the folks down at HR and make sure that I do that just exactly the right way uh so but that's going to happen um I I don't think I'm driven by really one consideration in terms of resign well two considerations uh in terms of resigning that is that you're going to have a new chair and I don't want to be looming over maybe a little Ecentric for me to say but I just don't want me to be on the board with a new chair here I want the new chair to have uh you know the same Freedom that I had to guide the board without somebody saying that's not the way I did it and I uh and so I
080think it's very important um that I move on and give somebody else uh who's U such as you guys who are new to the board the opportunity to come on board the board and uh and and and participate also um I've been doing things of a public nature in this town since well 28 or 29 years now first I did uh 10 years on the Wayne Scott cic eight years as chairman then I was uh on this planning board for about two years earlier in this century and uh at the beginning sometime and then in um then uh when there was a change in politic iCal parties I did political work and then uh I was appointed to the uh to the sou County Planning Commission for the town of eastampton I did that for
081five years and then uh I got named as Vice chair of the zba I did that for a year and then I was asked to serve as chairman of this body and I'll say without equivocation it's been the honor of a lifetime and great great privilege to have served as chairman of this body um it means it means all I can say to to to me and I'm just going to say a couple of personal things in 2019 when I was appointed chairman of the planning board I had only one personal goal and it was a simple one to be the best chairman of the planning board that there's ever been that was my goal I've been a lawyer I've been a lawyer for 40 over 40 years I've been on many boards and committees
082I've been a chairman of a number of them and I I think I knew what I needed to do to achieve that goal in the first place I wanted to make sure that this board always adhered to the law that the law was always applied fairly evenly and consistently I wanted to make sure that no favoritism was ever shown by the planning board but I wanted to make sure that we were flexible and practical within the bounds of the law and I like to think that we did that my next concern was to make sure that every applicant who appeared before the board was treated Tre with respect and dignity that's why I wore a jacket and tie at every meeting but I recognize that the applicants and the land owners had a lot at
083stake they had invested lots of money they had their vision and they had a right to have their applications treated fairly and evenly I've striven to do that I've striven to do that with good humor and I hope that they recognize that and that I've been able to do that throughout my next concern was to make sure that the town's planning professionals and I'm glad to see the two of them are still here grinding it out we're given the difference that they deserve while recognizing that we the planning board have the final word that's how this is structured this is a very careful balancing act because the town's professional but I'm really truthfully glad to see you guys here are professionals who are so good and so careful and so well-intentioned but at the same
084time we have a job to do and maybe once in a while we might disagree with the planning staff and and you know we're the ones who were appointed so and we get the big bucks for that so we we're the final word likewise I also learned very quickly that the input of the public had to be considered but that we were sometimes hamstrung by the public hearing rules in secret I may have had a few struggles on this score in the beginning but I like to think that over time we came to a consistent policy that permitted public input within the bounds of the law and one final concern which was of particular importance to me and by which I would judge my own success was to make sure that everyone at this table
085had every opportunity to ask every question and to express his or her opinion without any feeling that they were being limited or hindered by me I've been on committees with overbearing chairman and I didn't like it one bit I didn't like it when chairman ran rough shot over the members and let them know how they should vote I hope that none of you ever felt short changed and that you always felt that you were able to express your own opinions I think we've accomplished a lot over the past six years we made a number of different and important changes to the process including how applications were assigned to board members to how we deal with phone towers most significantly to what was prioritized in applications and to how our meetings and Communications was structured there's
086still a lot more to do and I wish that I could have gotten all of us iPads because this stuff about making 10 copies of every document is nuts uh this planning board and really I guess all the other boards require that too much paper be used and uh we should change that so finally I'd like to um say some thank yous first and foremost my wife deorah I want to thank her because for the last six years we haven't taking a vacation that didn't begin on a Thursday or end on a Tuesday I also want to thank her for always having hot meal waiting for me when I came home on Wednesday nights I can't imagine what I've got waiting for me tonight next I want to thank the current supervisor and the current
087Town board I asked to be reappointed last year when the administration changed Town board the supervisor and the town board said yes I am not chairman for life and and I don't own this job and I appreciate very much the opportunity that they gave me to serve this last year I want to thank the town attorney's office it is not easy to represent attorneys as any attorney will tell you we're pains in the neck and we ask too many questions and we worry about things that nobody but an attorney will worry about and I'm sure that I was just as much of joy as any other attorney that the town board's had to deal with so I thank the town Attorneys Office Jason and Matt at LTV and everybody else who's worked I look up
088I don't know why I do that but I know I'm not the only one I want to thank you guys for the work that you've done over the years I particularly want to thank you for the work that was done during covid because you know I mean it seems like and it is ancient history but we had what was it a year a year and a half where we did meetings by zoom and and the rest of the town did meetings by zoom and that could not have been done without LTV and and so I thank LTV for the work that they did and uh and and that they continue to do right up to this minute I want to thank the professional planners there's a coder of planners that come in and represent applicants
089uh they come here and they are zealous Advocates which is a phrase that we use in another field but the the they they're professionals you know the the the town code and the the rules that this board and the other boards uh apply are I don't want to say Arcane but they're complex and they're multi-layered and there's a lot going on and I can't tell you the number of times and I'm sure I'm not the only one at the table who feels this way that we've had an applicant come before us without the benefit of a professional planner or an attorney and I've sat here and I said well go hire somebody it'll help you it'll be quicker and easier and uh and you guys do a great job you really do and and I
090admire the work you do in that same regard the attorneys now you know I I know that there's not always been a lot of oh there's one not a lot of of attorneys I've served as on this board or as chairman of the board I thank you for indulging me and and and going on uh excursions and conversation about the law the the quality of legal work on behalf of applicants in this town is just outstanding the again as I said regarding the planning uh professionals uh you know it ain't easy representing clients who have millions of dollars at stake and who want it the way they want it and I know and the planning the attorneys who do the work before this board uniformly to agree great job again the planning staff U I'm
091I'm glad that I have uh two of the most outstanding members Brian and Chris here with us to hear this so you guys could tell them that I said this but also um to Don and will and um Tina I'm glad that Tina was here last week because I had the opportunity to thank her uh it's not easy work what do you do you have to interface with the those members of the public and you have to tell them that I'm sorry you can't build a steel mill on first Lane and other things like that and it's very hard work and then you have to make us look good which is even harder work so thank you thank you for your professionalism and your knowledge of the the the law that you help us U
092to implement finally I want to thank Peter V because if I wanted for Peter I wouldn't be here uh I met Peter 20 some years ago when I was first appointed to the plan board uh he he was on the board already he and I I had there was a parking lot in amig that I think there was an issue with their dumpster uh he went out with me we were talking about it and I said well I don't know and he's I was and he says well is it in the interest of good planning and a bell rang in my head and the light went off and Peter's always been there and Peter was the one who appointed me as the well he was super when I was appointed as Vice chair of the
093zba and then a year later I got a phone call from him and he asked me to be chairman of this board and uh hung up spoke to my wife and called him right back and I said yes I'll be happy to do this and I was very very happy that he called and that he the confidence that he showed in me at the same time I'd also like to thank Sylvia over because from the time that I was on the WC the way Scott CAC uh and starting to get involved she was always there from in always helped me along and uh brought me on board different committees it was the comprehensive plan committee and so thank you wherever you are hopefully watching Miss Silvia finally finally Jody right over there uh jod is
094unfailing jod is is reliable jod cares more about this process than anyone I know and she'll more than she'll ever admit you can not be chairman of this board without Jody able assistance her honesty and her great guidance I cannot thank you enough thank you just that's it as for the rest the last thank you it's you guys thank you all very much also thanks to Ian Kathy Randy and Sharon wherever you are for the uh Dedication that you have for this process and for the love that you show for This Town by being here and doing this work this isn't easy anyone who watched just tonight's meeting know that you you didn't just come here and you know what's the phrase phone it in some you know there again there are complicated issues there
095are questions that have to be answered there are issues that require analysis you guys all bring it you bring it every week every we every two weeks that way here and I really thank you so uh fairly well uh I'm going to Brian will appreciate this let the words be yours I am done with mine you know where that comes from Brian thank you I know where that thanks Sam so much thank you you you've been chair for six of the seven years I've been on this board I have learned so much from you thank you very much learned so much from you I appreciate thank you thank you I was appointed the same year chairman you've been the best chairman that I've ever had well thank you that's good enough right there I to
096think about that I'm like oh seriously I've seen you deal with people get getting angry both the applicants and sometimes the board members and the one thing that I've you know really commend you for is you've handled every one of those things with a plum intelligence and what really struck me most was kindness and understanding and I really appreciated that and I've grown to love the way did this job I don't know if we'll ever get a chairman as good as you you've been and I'm really grateful that I was appointed that same year that you were because I learned a lot and I think the town is really lucky to have had you as a chairman thank thank you very much thank you very much I I was I was watching my fair lady
097the other day and the there's a line in there about you'll muddle through and uh I'm sure you will I I look I don't know officially who's going to be chair but I think you're going to be in good C very good thank you all very much I'm going to make the last resolution I hearby move that we are adjourned is there a second second all in favor six five to two