CorpusRecord 135481

East Hampton Town Board Work Session MTK - 12/10/24

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / LTV East Hampton
Date
2024-12-10
Location
Suffolk County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
22,289 words · about 124 min
Collected
2026-06-18

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e East Hampton Town board we are live thank you LTV good morning everyone and welcome to the eastampton town board work session of December 10th 2024 here at the monok library Carol if you could please read the roll call council member flight present council member lease present council member Rogers present counc a member called to pedman pres supervisor Burke Gonzalez pres if we could all stand for the Pledge of Allegiance I pledge aliance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all so this morning we're going to open up with public portion and then once everyone's had an opportunity to speak we'll move on we have five topics today the first is our senior purchasing agent

002jeie cor Roa will'll be introducing bids that we have coming up then council member David Lee superintendent of recreation John Rooney and chief life lifeguard John Ryan Jr will give us our 2024 Beach season review that'll be followed by assistant Town attorney Charlie Collins uh reviewing proposed amendment to chapter 91 beaches and Parks Charlie will also take us through an urban renewal modification at 41 Rosevelt Avenue East Hampton and then uh Deputy supervisor Kate Rogers will lead a discussion of alternate zba and ARB board members that'll be followed by liaison reports and then resolutions so first we'll start with uh those folks that have signed up to speak and first up is Jeff bragman and we ask folks to try to keep their comments to the 3 minute uh time limit because we have an

003extensive agenda to welcome Jeff good morning board members and supervisor I want to talk about the senior center and money the price of the senior center is likely to be north of $30 million and I wanted to give an idea of the scale of the project by comparing it to the town's unrestricted Surplus reserves which are only $25 million and those reserves are there for eventualities that we can't always predict and in fact the town recently used some of those reserved funds uh to because it had spent more than it could raise in uh without breaking through the tax limit that the state has set on raising our taxes so they broke through that limit and they also used unrestricted funds took funds from elsewhere to lessen the hit that happened from that um the

004uh the uh project really uh paid very little uh attention no attention the board to the attendance in the current Senior Center which is Spar it's generally about 15 to 30 persons nor did the size and scale of the building uh relate to the information you got from your online survey in which 50% of the respondents to the survey indicated they had not used the senior center in 5 years and the other 50% said we only use it one to three times per year it's oversized for its site it's oversized for the use also public participation was deliberately and intentionally uh thwarted uh in July and August of 2022 there were four meetings where people could discuss activities at the senior center but no no discussion of the site plan or the building and it

005which wasn't selected until January of 2023 and at that point the board waited for almost a year till December 7th uh 2023 and then hustled through all the steps uh to start this project on the road to approval um and in the December 7th uh on December 7th you held the one and only public hearing one public hearing on it uh shortly between Thanksgiving and Christmas about six people attended and at the hearing the town denied that it would exempt itself from zoning that was untrue it denied that and the supervisor specifically denied that it required variances that was untrue a work session was quickly scheduled uh in the following week in which they discussed Monroe which is the case that allows the town to completely vacate any kind of zoning review and at that

006work session they discussed this Monroe case but they denied that it related to the senior center this was untrue and then what they did is on January 4th on 7 days notice very short you scheduled your Monroe hearing oddly it's taken you about a year after you closed that hearing on Monroe to publish the results it seems very strange and deliberate that it was only last night that you published the findings um that were just released and uh I want the point of Monroe is that it exempts the town from any kind of review puts the town board solely in charge the findings uh are illustrative because they admit the variances that the supervisor was unaware of and they're enormous the variances for this thing the total lot coverage uh the plan exceeds total lot

007coverage limitations by more than an acre the bill building coverage exceeds building coverage limitations by nearly half an acre the clearing limits that are going to um uh are 880,000 square feet this project is going to is going to take 300% more clearing it's going to do three times the limit of clearing to a total of 240,000 square ft and the US Fish and Wild Life recently advised the board that it's Habitat for an endangered bat I know nobody want wants to hear about it but they're pollinators and they're on the verge of Extinction the population's very important and they warned the town board to go and get a permit for incidental taking of the bats they didn't follow that advice and there are many other variances at least six other variances the findings are

008worth the Public's attention it finds that zoning and planning processes would foil the Fulfillment of a public purpose and it says that existing land use regulation would have a prohibitive effect on the project it also claims uh it it they make no recogn no recognition of the concerns that are you know a foot in the town today about rightsizing development on Lots the concerns expressed by residents about rapacious developers who come in in clear-cut sites before they build exactly what the town board proposes to do with this project and I say to the town board that there they were not elected you were not elected to be the largest developers in the town of East Hampton in the alternative section there's no mention of the adjacent Disturbed lot the same size as this lot where

009they're going to have to tear down a house but instead this plan calls for building a uh flag pole access at a cost of a million dollars just for the access to get to the rear lot and decimate the habitat on the lot no mention of a smaller compact design no mention of clear-cutting the lot and last and most insulting in the findings which were just released last night one year later from the date that you conducted the hearing I've never heard of the Town board uh hiding the result of a public hearing you had you had 12 months in which you could have publicized this and let the public know about it but you hid it in your back pocket the most insulting and arrogant part of the findings are that they denigrate Community

010object and they say oh they were just generalized opposition and it says the town board finds that public concerns do not rise to the level of local interests of substance and significance they didn't provide enough technical analysis or documentation of substantial concerns this is a project of Reckless spending it is dismissive of community concerns it sets a hypocritical example for others in the town who are forced to go through a rigorous and required planning review process that's good enough for Citizens but it's not good enough for the town board the design and size are jarringly in congruous it looks like an airport terminal it does not speak to rural character it does not reflect our Visual History of construction with natural materials and it reflects a fear and an arrogance uh with respect to public

011comment this is the town treating its runs like Monopoly money while it gives itself a get out of jail free card this project should not move forward that's everyone that that's everyone that s that's everyone that signed up is there anyone else here that would like to address the board Mr Peters Alexander Peters president amig at Springs aquafer protection Our Town comprehensive plan mandates the town board to take forceful measures to protect and reduce human impacts to highquality grounded drinking water resources which exist beneath the land east of aabon Road South of Red Dirt Road north of the railroad track s which includes this parcel north of the railroad tracks and Inland from Gardener Bay it recommends Our Town comprehensive plan perhaps the town board members should read it the highest level of protection acquisition

012is recommended for all Parcels within this area and now to top it all off the town board is violating all of our Town's Environmental Protections ramming ahead with a close to 30 million project that virtually nobody wants building a new Senior Center we already have a senior center right next to Windmill Village which is an absolutely appropriate place for a senior center why not either we build or adapt the senior center we already have even spend 5 million doing that but no Kathy Brook Gonzalez wants to blow 30 million of our tax dollars your tax bill is about to go way up for a building virtually nobody wants I canvased 40 of my over 65-year-old local friends and only one was in favor of a brand new Senior Center one 39 were completely against it

013nobody uses it nobody wants the tax bill and nobody wants to raise seven acres of land that are vital AC for protection and the home of an endangered species that is almost extinct everywhere else in in the world but thrives in this little piece of Woodland nobody wants this building nobody uses the present Senior Center and nobody wants the tax burden of a new $30 million building at a recent aak meeting which you should know all about 14 folks who were over 65 were asked about the building and everybody was against it didn't want the tax burden and were horrified by the environmental costs in this day of global climate crisis we need the Seven Acres of trees this town board wants to demolish to absorb carbon this beautiful Forest is also home to an

014endangered bat that is almost extinct everywhere else but thrives in these Woods next to the railroad track off of Abraham's path the town board is violating every environmental law applicable to this piece of land how the town is not following its own zoning or planning laws to force this project down our throats no developer could ever get away with this but this town board doesn't care just after the town board decided that no houses above 10,000 square ft will be allowed the town wants to ram a 22,000 square foot building demolishing most of a 7 acre unique Forest down our throats and increase our taxes to pay for it so let's check on what the town comprehensive plan had to say about this it recommended the land between Abraham's path the railroad tracks and Windmill

015Lane be up Zone from A2 to A3 because quote This Land occupied by artist Woods a Riding Academy in the cemetery is within the New York State special groundwater protection area and the 5- foot groundwater Contour boundary both criteria identified as critical for protecting East Hampton's ground and drinking water resources so the town board is usurping and making a laughing stock of its own environmental laws by using the Monro doct Doctrine to allow itself to raise a beautiful Forest the town board is is further polluting the Stony Hill aquifer by violating its own laws it's time for a lawsuit and a recall we need a town board that follows its own environmental laws and listens to its citizens we don't want or need this building we the people of the town of East Hampton want

016a town board and we elected you to protect our water and protect endangered species that exist almost nowhere else Judy hope Tony bulock Kathy Lester and all past Democrats would be horrified by this terrible destruction and I just want to ask two questions you're a you're a family man you have beautiful children and a lovely wife how would you like it if one day you went off to work and came back to find your entire neighborhood raised leveled okay that's what you're doing to this endangered species and you are a thoroughly good man I know it I feel it I talk to you I know you care how can you allow this to happen this is our Vital aquafer responsible for all the water for firefighting and drinking water for amaganset Springs Monto NEP and

017all the public order going to Mok SAS we need to wrap it up thank you thank you is there anyone else here that would like to address the board yes good morning my name is orley fredman I'm a resident of Springs I've been living here for 40 years uh I'd like to Echo some of the sentiments that have been presented by Mr Peters um aside hold Mr Peters please it's it's a small room and it's hard to hear so I'd like to Echo uh the sentiments that were presented by Mr Peters about the tax burden the clear cutting of land the violations of zoning and planning laws the endangered bat species which I think are vital with the loss of bees and other pollinators now the lantern flies I mean these are Critters that are

018important to our ecosystem out here um but in addition to just the overall construction of this massive Center I would like to know if anybody has done any kind of study that says this is how much it's going to cost taxpayers to operate a 20,000 plus facility also the fact that it's so far out of proximity to where a lot of the seniors live in windmill Villages one and two there's going to be additional costs to transport people there's going to be additional labor needed to transport people there's going to be certainly more of possibilities of accidents we're going to need more Vehicles we're we're supposed to be taking care of our environment we're just adding for costs and transportation and labor and people can't even afford to live here we can't as a business

019owner I can't find help where are we going to get these people were we going to hire seniors to drive each other around the beauty of where the senior center is for the people that use it is their proximity to it and so I don't understand the need to rush this through I understand it's been in the planning stages for many many years but I think we need to come together more often give people more of an opportunity to present their side and whether or not they use it I mean recently the gaming commission just came down on bingo at the senior center two nights a week they spent a125 a card that's now been banned so what are we using this Center for and why do we need such a large Center how many

020people are we actually serving I would like to know if somebody has done like a square footage to say these are this many centers that are these are this many senior citizens that use this Center what are they getting 200 square feet per person or per use I don't know I don't understand the level of service that this new center is supposed to provide is it going to be a rehab fac what is it I don't understand so I would like to have a little bit more clarification in not only the initial costs and the initial damage to the environment but the longterm operating expenses you know I think back to the year where the Y was established and then it had to be turned over because the town couldn't afford to run it so

021we're going to be stuck in that same position where suddenly we now have to bring in a private entity to take over I just I just think there's too many unknown variables for me to be able to support this project on top of the known variables of the over clearing and the damage to the aquafer and the damage to the environment so I would I would urge the board to really reconsider what its citizens and the people who we like to do really feel is the actual need for a senior center CU I agree we do need a center and I think it's important to have something but I think this is grossly being overdone for thank you for your comments thank you for the time I appreciate you is there anyone else here that

022would like to address the board Jason is there anyone on the line we currently have three callers on the line I will unmute them thank you starting with the first let's see hello caller ending 5615 you're on the air hello oh hi that's me um this is Terry burer and I'm a m talk Citizen and a member of the zoning board of appeals um I'm calling about the memorandum that I'm reading in regard to the discussion for alternates the Architectural Review Terry Terry please are you speaking as a private citizen or a member of the zba can I speak as both speaking private Cien if you were speaking uh in in regards to the zba you would have needed to had a vote on the zba to appoint you to appoint you to speak on

023each member's behalf okay you can certainly but please speak as a private citizen that's totally appropriate okay I am well I'm reading this memorandum and as a private citizen I do uh I do think I'm going to address the last paragraph first which actually uh made me call in whether an applicant should have the right or ability to request a certain member either regular or alternate deliberate on its application where both have been present for and participated I think that is I don't know I don't recall seeing this in the documentation prior to this and I think that's really kind of crazy um I do want to go to some of the things I I the have some value in this um the first bullet item up above should alternate members be required to attend

024all meetings even when all regular members will be present um I am in I do think that is a good idea um they we don't always know when an alterate member may be needed for a meeting uh due to an absence which could occur on short notice or no notice at all and that would better prepare them for any instance such as that um I do think they may an alterate member ask questions and submit input when not appointed to replace an absent member I disagree with that I do not think that they should be uh unless they are appointed uh because of a to replace a member and and also that they only be permitted to vote um when a regular member is absent or accused and they have followed through uh when they

025fill in I'll go to that that bullet item there there are things in all of these that I think need some work but um when an alternate member fills in I do think that if they filled in for a hearing that they should possibly that they should follow that through all the way to the point of an ultimate decision and so that's in a sub bullet item there some municipalities on this notice say that they do have them follow through and others do not I do think that should be the case if and when they replace a member for a hearing that they follow that right through to the decision and I do think also that they they don't have any authority to uh unless unless they are covering for an actual member of the

026board um at whether it's a decision or a hearing and I think that's it [Music] thank you Terry Jason if you could put the next caller through please all right call our ending 6412 you're on the air uh good morning board it's uh Rona cman and I'm calling um in reference to the amaganset citizens advisory meeting that met last night and we had 18 people present the senior center was was a great uh topic of discussion um many of the people if not all felt it was an enormous project and uh that $2 million for 30 years uh on a financial basis is extraordinary for this town um you know the town if we have a a a tragic event like a hurricane which can happen in the next 30 Years uh we are at

027risk uh for Road repairs building repairs and the town will not have enough funds in its Reserve uh to really function uh so I think it would be totally inappropriate for the town to uh continue on the basis of what it has in the resolution uh that's that's before this board I've read it through and um the citizens advisory committee felt uh that one of the things which was read from the resolution that the impact on local uh interests will be positive is a ridiculous statement uh also the the statement that the generalized opposition to building a senior center cannot undermine the town board's Monroe analysis and I'm reading from your uh your resolution itself that the town board finds that the articulated concerns by members of the public do not rise to to the

028level of a countervailing local interest of substance and significance uh that is really anti- transparency for this town you are not listening to the residents I've listened to SAS Peters I've listen to Jeff bragman they make really good points and this town board doesn't seem to be listening which is a failure on its part and uh to me uh you are not acknowledging uh the the the people who are in this town who have to pay the taxes you are going to cause seniors to leave this town they're not going to be able to you're not going to be able to have people coming to the senior center if you continue on this uh taxation um on on this Senior Center which right now I see uh there are 15 seniors a day to about

02930 5 if you have an event and that certainly doesn't signify a need for a 22,000 sqt Center particularly when you have a zoning code committee it's been working for over a year to change the zoning in the town so that it's more applicable to the acreage and now you have something that needs 13 variances uh that you alone are going to justify so I think you really have to go back to the drawing board and see what you can do um as another Resident has said uh this morning about redoing the the the current building and remodeling it and um uh I I think uh you have to really listen to the people of this town thank you next Jason if you could put the next call yep and hello call ending 4221 thank

030you good morning Town board uh this is Jane miring and I'm speaking as a a citizen well I live in amag excuse me and I'm speaking as an individual citizen member of the public um I knew the issue of Alternatives oh sorry alternate alternates was on the agenda for today um but I just this morning became aware of the December 10th memorandum from town attorney Rob Conley to the town board um regarding alternates for ARB and zba um just I was a little surprised not to have seen it come up earlier I think this board has a really strong record of getting their documentation up on a Friday before a Tuesday work session so I just happened to stumble across it um as you know this was an issue that was work sessioned in May

031public Hearing in June and adopted by aot of the board um and I was under the impression that the town was just simply waiting for the requisite approval from the state to make this effective um so it was a little uh surprised when I read the memo it seems to be addressing some topics um that are more substantial and material and ways beyond what was discussed during the you know robust work session and public hearing process um so I just want to touch on a few things um in the application so in the third paragraph um the town attorney rights at the public serving two speakers spoke in support of the Amendments the one speaker who is a zoning Board member requested that alternate members not be utilized in instances where a regular member is

032on vcation I just want to address this in two ways um I spoke at that hearing as an individual member of the public but here I am identified as a zoning Board member so it might confuse in what capacity I spoke also my comments were not just about when a member is on vacation I made the point that the board has a strong history if someone is taken sick at the last minute or has a family emergency last minute or um you know might be on vacation and they can't participate generally the members are able to watch everything they read everything and they have a history of being able to then come back and make the decision so I just wanted to address that I'm not going to go into them I actually heard citizen

033berer um speaking and the things that she uh was in favor of I I also um would would uh um uh also say are good but the two parts of the memo May an alternate member ask questions and submit input when not appointed to replace may an alternate member be permitted to vote only when a regular member is absent or accused um that is something that I look forward to your discussion today but that I I think takes uh an alternate uh abilities so I mean that would mean we could have six votes on something and then the last paragraph I must call out should be I won't read it again um but the idea that an applicant would have a right to pick in choose which board members they want to uh deliver at

034on its application um is something that sounds like it would be unprecedented um and I don't want to come down to hard on it but that's uh that this takes us into a very material new area and Allin um I I my question is should this will this meet another public hearing some of these things seem so material that maybe there's another public hearing that needs to be had so I look forward to hearing your discussion later thank you so much board thank you Jane Jason is there anyone else on the line yes we have two more callers remaining so far caller ending 6554 you're on the air and could we mute the TV in the background potentially and I want to come back to them yeah they may just be listening in they very

035well could be hello caller ending 2777 you're on the air thank you this is Michael chinue I can confirm Rona that we was we are pretty unanimous at the meeting the other night about uh this space and the clearing the size of the building and the budget also uh being a pay officer of the fire department the topic came up about Emergency Shelters I think we're going to have uh you know we're due for another one real soon uh there's really no place to run to I think that'd be a great place uh was just talking to a Mason friend of mine who said the basement is the cheapest part of a building you're going down three or four feet for footings anyway so why don't we just keep going a couple more feet I

036don't really think if we built a more efficient building that was more rectangular or Square uh I think that would be easier to do and more cost effective so I'm not against against the senior center but I think we need something more in our budget uh maybe go down for emergency shelter and storage maybe go up on some part of it for offices because I know there's offices and uh I also just think we have to live with a budget we can all afford so that would be my take but I do thank you guys for uh making all these great considerations thank you very much thank you Michael okay and that was our last caller so the the folks that you that were listening in did they hang up or they still there they

037they hung up okay all right beautiful thank you one last call here and in the main meeting oh the library is anyone else went they just called back they just hopped back on the line all right hello color ending 6554 more in our budget hello hello you on the air oh and everything is totally out of sync uh this is I am if you could mute your hold up please stop mute your TV in the background first it's it's muted oh thank you very much I heard it for I heard at the beginning thank you please begin okay hi this is Lauren Boulder calling and I am calling about the uh Center for modern aging which is also known as the senior center I was at the amaganset citizens advisory committee meeting last night just

038to see what was going on and I am in I am in total favor of a new Senior Center I think it's needed and frankly I think everybody or the seniors in this town support such a thing but this building as it is conceived does not really fill the needs um of the community number and I know that a lot of money has been spent to uh get this project going but I think it's ill advised not to go right back to the drawing board and look at the needs of the community and see what design would best fill those needs and maybe this is not the proper place for it either um also last night the idea of a an emergency shelter came up uh I hadn't even thought of that before but this

039is a great opportunity to provide this town with an emergency shelter that at one point sooner or later we are going to need so my suggestion is or my ask is that this uh project continue to be looked at and maybe really even start again and um see what people need and want and how that can be brought to the town in in the most expeditious way so thank you thank you Lauren and that's it okay so I just wanted to make a comment because a couple of folks brought up in their uh public comment about town funds and fund balance and Reserve so I'm looking at page four of the 2025 adopted budget and the town across its five funds has over $772 million in uh in fund balance uh almost a little over

04031 million in the general whole town close to 20 million in the general part Town Highway has 9.7 million sanitation refuges 4.3 million and the airport has 6.7 million and that's projected obviously for the for year end 2024 we probably won't have those numbers till about end of first quarter of 2 but I just wanted folks to know uh that you know we're in obviously we have a Moody's AAA Bond rating and um you know we're financially uh secure okay so now we've got sure absolutely in 1981 I moved on to Thomas Avenue I learned how to ride my bike there for many of the individuals in here I'm one of the only people that grew up in the town of eastampton I was born in Southampton I am still here today there's only a

041couple people in this room I don't know if anyone that spoke to today as someone that have that can either say that they're born here and live their entire life in East Hampton that's for one for Thomas Avenue it's a street that my dad cut and it's directly across from the artist Woods which is directly across for where the entrance for the center for modern aging will be learned to ride my bike it was a banana bike on there my parents grew up there and I was fortunate for my dad who came on a freighter from Indonesia here and immigrated here and also my mother who was a teacher for 29 years they were now 0 and 87 they are seniors they want to see this facility built as you've heard from me about my

042children being my lens these are my parents they are also my lens then two the senior center that we have is wly inadequate to provide the services that we need for our aging population then too and make it to a point where it's modern for individuals that want to stay here live here age in place here to have facilities where they can cognitively physically emotionally socially develop as we have state in goal 10 the town of East Hampton goal 10 of the coner apprehensive plan says provide Advocate facilities land and programs for schools town offices and other functions daycare senior care families and other educational cultural and recreational and Health Care needs many of these can all be encompassed within the new center for modern Asian we have looked at this location and the demands

043we needed over multiple years nearly seven of them on there then too uh the we have looked at this in a very methodical approach to get the information out to where the town board has been discussing to what the feelings of community members pro and con to the facility and listening to get to a point where we as decision makers have to and legislators have to make decisions for what how how and where we want to move forward as many of the voices we heard today might not be in favor of it we've heard same if not many many more that are extremely in favor of this facility as far as protecting land we have Sav dozens of acreage in this Aqua Feller of Stony Hill including acreage of one of the individuals that even

044spoke today so if you say that I don't care what my family wants you're wrong I care tremendously what my family wants my lens is my children my lens is my parents 80 and 87 they're fortunate still to live here they came here they want to still be here but they also need to have a place to do all those senses that I just expressed in a nice facility cuz what we have currently right now is outdated and we need to move on and forward with it in a way that is appropriate also as far as the size we should design things that are needed for future use 20 30 50 years I heard the same discussion when we discussed the uh Southampton Emergency Center which is a beautiful facility if anyone wants to go

045down there we had individuals that wanted to make it smaller they wanted to design Emergency Center from a board not from what emergency centers or individuals that build hospitals should do now the overall result looks spectacular and some of the similarities there are the same it backs up on against a public utility it backs up on other property that the town owns it backs up on some woodlands and it backs up on other large tracks of land then too there's a lot of similarities there and unfortunately the voices we heard then are the same we're hearing now what we need to do is make sure this town is prepared for the next 20 30 to 50 years to make sure East Hampton as I first came here was born in 19 1976 is as good

046as hopefully I can be as my dad is and when I'm 87 those are my comments thank you David okay so let's move on jeie if you'd like to start us off with bids welcome Genie hello thank you um I have a couple of bids um to accept today the first is for the Star Island dredging the apparent low bidder is Keith Grimes and the amount is $1,280 and next is the tree clearing for 203 403 Abrahams path the apparent low bidder for that is green velvet Landscaping in the amount of 215,000 thank you does anyone have questions for Genie no no no question I know that you had wanted to address the board hello Town board members Tina leren acting planning director um I did want to take a few minutes to assure the

047board that the environmental review conducted for the proposed Senior Center was both extensive and thorough and complied with State Environmental Quality review law specifically an overview of the environmental review includes the following highlights we prepared our full EA part one we use the long form it's the form that's reserved for the larger actions an expanded environmental assessment accompanied the part one and it was sent to interested and involved agencies for comment all required impact categories in the full eaf part two were thoroughly evaluated and reviewed with the board in detail at two separate work station uh sessions detailed technical studies and Designs were also prepared by qualified experts in their respective fields for stormm water and wastewater management which provides for groundwater protection traffic noise archaeology and also for the study of potential impacts to

048endangered species namely the northern long-eared bad or nleb and I'm going to talk a little bit about that now um a lot of Prior public comment focused on the nleb so I do want to make sure the record is clear on that regarding nleb we coordinated with both DEC and the US fish and wildlife service several times during both 2023 and 2024 as the environmental review progressed and in the final months of 2024 the process was completed our first element of the 2024 coordination was with DEC they're typically the only agency we would coordinate uh with for something like this they've got jurisdiction of matters with no federal permits they issued a letter in June 20124 clearly indicating that no permit was necessary and no incidental take permit um was required with adherence to the

049clearing window that the town board offered to commit to which is clearing is only allowed in the wintered months we then took more steps recognizing that the US fish and wildlife service had upgraded the species from threatened to endangered at April 2024 in an abundance of caution we coordinated with the US fish and wildlife Service Long Island office as well in August 2024 us fish and wildlife Service issued a comment letter which recommended that the town conduct an internal review because there was a confirmed detection with of nleb within a mile of the project site and due to concerns about habitat fragmentation their letter did not indicate any confirmed NLB nleb activity directly on the site their leather further noted that after the internal review there was a voluntary incidental take permit process available should

050the town choose to pursue it you us fish and wildlife service did not give us criteria for what type of internal review we should undertake but nevertheless again showing the utmost of caution regarding this issue we pursued a scientific approach and sought the services of individuals qualified to prepare biological assessments so I'm going to note here that there are federal criteria that professionals must meet in order to be able to prepare credible scientific reports of this nature we hired professionals Nelson Pope and Vorhees and they are us fish and wildlife service approved non-federal preparers with qualifications to prepare biological assessments for the review of federal and state agencies so it's not the town who determined that they're qualified they meet the federal criteria for being qualified for this type of work the qualified biologists at

051Nelson Pope and Vorhees conducted the biological assessment study and concluded that there was no significant adverse impacts anticipated and that was in September specifically based on their findings no incidental take was anticipated and this is consistent with dec's findings in September and therefore they did not recommend the pursuit of the voluntary incidental take permit basically the conclusion you don't need a permit if you're not proposing to do the regulated activity then in October us fish and wildlife service Service issued updated guidance for Northern longard bat assessments we again stopped and paused and and then conducted a thorough analysis of what the new guidance meant for the previous conclusions that the qualified biologist had found that the incidental take was not anticipated after review of that October guidance our qualified biologists concluded that the protections we

052proposed adherence to the winter clearing window when the bats are not expected to be in the vicinity of the project site are more protective and I'm going to say that one more time more protective than what would be required by the US Fish and Wild life service guidance and all of this is supported um by detailed technical reports and Analysis available in the planning department files so then for context I want to remind everyone that the entire town is shown on the mapers of DEC as potential northern long-eared bat habitat for discretionary actions that we review including clearing of wetlands private developers are reer uh referred to DEC to confer about the impacts as DEC is the appropriate Agency for New York State reviewed these matters this is no different than where we started our

053nleb analysis we just went a step further seeking Federal guidance too recognizing the change in regulatory status we wanted to be very cautious and we were so to conclude the environmental review We conducted absolutely meets the requirements of the State Environmental Quality review act AKA secra it was extensive prepared by the planning Department's professional planners and other qualified experts in many fields including storm water and sanitary management which provides for groundwater protection traffic noise archaeology biology and it was informed by a team of Engineers and Architects the conclusions of the review that I'm talking about here today are supported by detailed technical studies and have been thoroughly vetted by myself and all of you and they concluded that there are no significant adverse environmental impacts from the project including none to the NL and n

054Leb anticipated thank you thank you Tina does anyone have questions for Tina no I have no questions just just uh also uh Tina thank you uh for that presentation and and thank you for the timeliness of it because um unfortunately I'm hearing so much misinformation I think it's important to um to get the information out to folks so I thank you for coming here today and speaking to that thanks for having me thank you Tina okay so next up we have the 2024 Beach season review and that's with uh my colleague David lease superintendent of recreation John Rooney and chief lifeguard John Ryan Jr welcome folks I want to uh thank the supervisor and the members of the board for allowing me to present today an overall recap of the town's Beach Parks and uh

055recreational activities for the summer season particularly our beaches uh I want to thank uh uh John Ryan Jr uh chief of uh Easttown lifeguards specifically him and his staff immediately for a wonderful season that you had John Rudy for putting together your staff also um if I want to move forward on this uh again this advisory uh group was actually formed during Co in response to co uh 19 to try to be able to make sure we open our beaches within the executive orders of the governor at the time then too uh the town board continued to move uh uh move this group forward so we can actually make sure we have a good collaborative working relationship with all our town entities to make sure that everyone has a very safe and safe and uh

056enjoyable summer season then too uh members of this Comm uh Advisory Group is myself as council member Chief Michael sarlo uh John Rooney who's a uh recreation department head uh buildings of ground department head Steve O'Brien uh Town Marine Patrol uh Tim Treadwell Chief lifeguard John Ryan Jr Town trustees Francis Bach and also the advisory capacity Ed Michaels Jeff Thompson Haley Ryan John Ryan senior Barnaby freed fredman and James pingot but also underneath of every single individual there are dozens of other individuals to make the summer very very safe next if you don't mind as we have done in the past uh this report will include a summary of the pre-season hiring and certification activity summary of our beach operations seasonal protected and unprotected Beach responses our town uh police uh Department recap the small

057one uh Marine Patrol buildings of grounds recap recreational recap and recommendations for the 2025 season again we will have this up we have this up on the website and we also have our n Season Beach Report too uh with that I will bring uh John Ryan Jr the chief of the East Anon toown lifeguards forward to present the next couple slides thank you for letting me come and present um yes thank you it was a great great summer uh great preseason postseason I got to say um but um just to be give a summary of our hiring and certification um we start our year off certifying Stillwater lifeguards and ocean lifeguards and we conducted this in the early spring and the summer and qualified 40 uh 39 still waterer lifeguards and 47 ocean lifeguards an

058additional three lifeguards recertified and there still water certification and 49 recertified their ocean certification our overall enrollment for the Junior and Nipper program was pretty much the same as 2023 um with the exception of our Cadet program which doubled uh in uh since since last last summer um John John Rooney my boss will speak about those uh those enrollments of the different programs uh the town of East Hampton employed 140 uh 46 lifeguards this summer5 lifeguards and uh 31 officers um this may seem like a lot but it's really not because some of them like these day and ages um we with the programs that we are uh engaged in uh in helping to waterproof the community um a lot of lot of those individuals are two-day weekers uh and for two hours a day

059working with uh the young kids in the junior program and and the Nipper program um but back on the beaches we have to make sure our beaches are safe so um and then then you get those guards that go off back off to college and and when they when they leave we in come August when we have these individuals recertifying we're looking to pull in some of those to help finish the season off so we're not closing open uh closing uh beaches uh and keeping people safe so uh the recruitment I I will say uh this was very noticeable Improvement um this this year since 2023 where we really struggling um and that was due to uh thank thank you to the board for allowing us to increase the ranking uh the ranks um in

060in efforts to uh hire back a lot of the lifeguards that or higher lifeguards that maybe would have taken a job somewhere else um one other uh uh way in which we helped the public was to uh put QR stickers um uh signs signage at at all the uh beach access points uh this uh this QR code helped uh direct lifeguards to rather patrons to uh to access to our our site which we we populate every day with the with the ocean conditions uh whether it be temperature wind uh the weather the uh surf conditions all right uh and and and we also actually post warnings on that page as well which might tell somebody that's going to maybe an unprotected Beach that there's a lot of rip currents out there maybe they shouldn't be

061going to an unprotected Beach they should be going to a protected Beach and we always suggest swim near lifeguard um beaches were manned by uh by lifeguards from May 25th through the just September 15th for n uh for 91 operational days this included two postseason weekends U following Labor Day in 2024 was a moderate surf condition we had moderate surf conditions with 62 uh green flag days 19 yellow flag days 11 red flag days and we had no no flag days uh which we would have if we say a hurricane that came in and we we didn't want anybody on the beach um so East ston toown beaches hosted approximately 2,000 bathers from last year uh and and just so you know uh that's that's you might may not think that's a lot but that's

062in the protected areas that's protected bathing beaches that's not all of the beaches that's protected areas as the they proceeds the guards try to keep uh have to at the end of the day get an estimate as to how many how many patrons are at the beach on that given day and they enter that on a daily basis and those those numbers get populated at the uh on an ongoing basis um with Beach operations suspended as of now uh we have our crew out there presently um inventorying supplies and and equipment in preparation for the 2025 season um lifeguard uh units uh responded uh or sorry recorded uh 24 aided injury responses uh thus far in 2024 of these 11 required EMS 7 resulted in hospitalization uh no fatalities yeah no fatalities on Town East

063Ham Town beaches during this these operating operational hours um mobile units log 25 emergency responses across both districts mon talk and amaganset uh including five jet ski responses three ATV responses 17 truck responses this season um we we were able to purchase three aeds due to a donation by a gentleman that we saved years ago Dave plin uh um and those were put in the trucks three of the trucks that didn't have aeds um so that we may have uh access to cardiac response capabilities uh Narcan kits were also placed in uh in all beaches and vehicle AED kits um lifeguards our lifeguards the summer performed 202 rescues this this year at protected beaches and additional 24 made on unprotected beaches uh both both metrics have doubled uh from last year and together represent the

064most recorded in a single season uh the uh the highlights uh this highlights the importance of BS to swim in protected areas and the need for lifeguards patrolling uh pres uh Pres in the stretches of unprotected beaches um you know on yellow flag days or green to yellow or red flag days we make it a point to get down to those areas where there are no lifeguards to make sure that people know that beaches are unsafe the waterers conditions are are uh dangerous and to swim in the protected areas uh lastly I I I do want to uh I do want to say uh thank you to the town board and John Rooney for allowing us to produce programs that waterproof this community um I can't say enough as how important it is uh to

065our our young groups of children growing up um I just showed John that I put this F bold here with me and and in here was my transcript from 1994 1994 with uh and as well as my thes my my project seminar paper I wrote and the paper I wrote in 1994 was making a a of safety Appo of your community uh which I did quite well with I got an A+ in that classroom uh the followup from that time really kind of helped in developing all these programs and I couldn't do without the support of the Town board I can't I can I can also I got to make sure I also say thank you to the eastampton town PD and East hampon Town Marine Patrol and the fire districts that provide the ambulance

066services for these individuals that uh there is nothing more pleasing to a lifeguard when they're dealing with an emergency on the beach to hear those Sirens coming and getting closer and closer to be able to hand them off to again professionals that can take them to an ambulance or with an ambulance to to the hospital where they need need that Care thank you Johnny can I ask you a question do you have any hypothesis as to why rescues you know almost doubled uh you know it's it's some Seasons we don't have a lot of rescues a lot of time times it it comes to really comes down to the number of rip currents you have 99% of all rescues are rip current related um so it it depends on how the the the beach is

067set up if you have a sandbar the which our our beaches did uh the sand bars were built up and uh you're going to get rips you're going to get Cuts in those Sands and that water just floods right out through those those rips um and and then those they they fill in uh from day to day and um some are there for most of the you know set up the stands and all of a sudden there Atlantic Avenue there's a giant rip right right smack in front of the stand um just showed up and it was there most of the most of the season and there were days where they were making 10 rescues a day uh trying to keep people out of it yeah they do but unfortunately people go in and they

068you know they get swept down the beach to get pulled in by that inside Eddie current that just brings him right into it where they step off the the bar into into rip so we just had a fortunate year where there were and I say fortunate because you know the hardest job of a lifeguard is dealing with dull days not you know things not happening the most exciting part of a lifeguard is making rescues so well thank you very much John as your uhron is going off I know you're also a volunteer fireman for how many years 202 20 it just shows your service to this to this Community is also as another lifelong resident then too but also shows the respect that you have between your life Guardian cors right now to educate all

069these individuals that have come through your ranks through multiple different ways to protect our waterfronts of our 71 miles of of beach myself I love going to the beach I don't want to really see anyone at the beach so I have my own little sliver of life and if you're from Town Line Road to Dish plane to Albert landing on there than two one of the things that many of us all value here is being able to learn how to swim in the ocean swim in the swim in general but also the same thing to know that we always have our back the lifeu course so thank you very much I'm going to move forward on to the next portion which is about the East Hampton Town Police Department and uh conferring with Chief Michael

070sarlo uh he wants to make sure that everyone knows the continued Spirit of cooperation between all the Departments led to a successful and safe season on the beaches uh prototypically it's the Marine Patrol that will guard the beaches for the for the police department but this group that we have right now allows face-to-face interaction all the department heads and all the staff to be able to make an easy phone call for assistance need or such not the next day or the next week but in real time um he also wants to let us know that the use of the license plate readers in mon talk specifically this season was a great Improvement in the traffic uh impr Improvement for the Traffic Control Officers uh part of the modernization of of uh Town town uh enforcement

071agencies uh we added license plate readers to our cars for daily parking uh permit parking and also paid parking and that proved to be of great success uh it didn't happen fully until about Midway through the season uh because of try just trying to integrate everything and then also get all of the tcos uh used to the equipment and also we add an extra set of cameras to cars but the effort uh sorry uh the Improvement in what they were able to do was markedly noticed lastly chief of police wants to make sure that the town bar continues to move toward uh toward a UniFi command headquarters for the monal camlet I know that's been discussion for multiple years this would be a location for code enforcment for lifeguards uh for PD Marine Patrol uh

072Imon talk as the facility that we currently have right now uh is uh being been outgrown so we continue to move that forward Marine Patrol um uh senior Harbor Master treadmill is not here today but also J Sharon who was going to uh he is actually cross training today with the United States Coast Guard so that happens a lot and these are things that you might not get mentioned in report like this but there's cross training between ocean rescue uh lifeguards state parks uh Village uh uh Village lifeguards uh Coast Guard and others and two when you have so many different in municipalities in one Township uh what these individuals do as far as the head of these departments they want to make sure we uh we cross train a lot so that's great to

073O see so I hope they're having a nice day out there it's a little warmer today anyway so the eastampton Marine Patrol uh provided law enforcement to our beaches with a focus on public safety education and protection of our valuable natural resources with seasonal Patrol 7 days a week from 2: to 4:00 a.m. um that was only provided because uh the current budgets and B budgets going forward have added other Marine Patrol positions in the last couple years and two we will continue to look about to do that the Marine Patrol responded over 500 calls for service on our beaches alone this year then too Mar Patrol worked closely with uh Town lifeguards uh of eastampton volunteer ocean rescue parts and wre code enforcement by safety and uh and share information uh the Marine Patrol

074provide uh issued provided they issued over 600 citations for violations of the town code pertaining the beaches approximately 46% of these pertain to Beach driving violations 24% to non-compliant Beach fires 8% is the dog 8% of dogs on the beach 6% the camping and other violations including littering ped littering pedling fireworks and the lack of proper Gathering permits one thing that's not in here is that we uh East the Marine Patrol this year just prior to the season took uh uh uh they we brought into our equipment rank the new uh Marine Patrol one uh vessel I know we had uh Tim trouble speak on that before but it aided tremendously in the search and rescues the SAR cases that we had this season so again it's a town board effectively spending uh uh tax

075dollars to make sure that we have the not just the equip the facilities but also the equipment to provide enforcement and also safety on our waterways then too uh John Rooney if you want to come in with the next slides morning morning John um I'm just going to go through even though buildings and grounds is not my department I'm going to go through their stats as well for this summer I'm glad I brought my copy because that's tough three um the parks department had swept uh and they keep up the the beaches all throughout the season keeping them clean um they do by hand and by tractor Sometimes some locations depending on Beach conditions you know for example the way ditch planes was this summer sometimes they got to go in by hand and uh

076clean them up and then when they can they bring in the tractor um and they uh in total they moved about 121,000 pounds of litter throughout the summer which is a tremendous amount um and they're Al they're very busy um my office is right there so see on a daily basis there a lot going on in summertime behind the scenes with the help of the Army Corps and the town lifeguards and buildings and grounds they installed and maintain the new Ada approved Beach maps here in M six locations and uh making beach access easier and safer and they have to be constantly maintained because wind and folks walking on them and everything they just have to need constant upkeep so they do a great job uh keeping them up daily um with the help of

077uh others the parks department rebuilt maintained several Beach heads as well and increased security fencing along the de Dunes to protect the ecosystem and protecting our town um sometimes examples of like big Albert's the water washes down through the parking lot it could take out the the foot paths going down to the beach can also take out the drive on areas and that has to be replenished and redone and sometimes you do it and then another storm comes in you got to do it again so there's a lot of a lot to do with with that keep that upkeep and buildings grounds Department repair and and maintained um 11 Comfort stations around the town for bathers providing amenities such as showers bathrooms water fountains throughout the season and that's a constant to that never goes

078away so that's just a little bit of what they do and then in terms for recreation for programming um so we run lifeguard uh programs for for juniors um really young kids swim programs all kinds of things throughout the summer and these are just some of the stats of of what we have going on so um in the summertime um through Johnny Ryan also Johnny Ryan senior and then Haley syu running uh those programs um we have a Cadet program that basically um doubled more than doubled over last year which is great that's 15y olds that uh come and do the do the program for the summertime learning how to be a lifeguard and then hopefully then they come on staff you know starting the following year you know and help to build into our

079uh life ging system going forward and then we also train up Juniors um who are basically ages nine to to 14 and during the summertime we had 295 um kids in that program and that divides out uh between East Hampton and monok uh we have about 256 of of that number are in Atlantic Avenue in the summer and at Kirk we have about 39 kids in that program and then we have Nippers um which goes down a little bit younger which goes from age 8 to age six and we had about 133 of those kids and that that program divides between East Hampton and also montalk as well the Nippers we had 109 uh kids ages 6 to8 um at Big Alberts and then East Lake gin Beach we had 24 kids in in program

080out here in M talk so both you know parts of the town we also run um free swimming lessons we've been doing this for many decades and uh this program runs for two we increments and we do it at four different locations through the course of the summer and this is for ages four and up so we cover four all the way up to uh into adulthood with with different programs and we run it at Haven beach at the beginning of the summer we had 19 kids during the first two weeks the second two weeks was at East Lake out in Jin we had 34 kids um then we had 40 at Maidstone after that for two more weeks and then we did two weeks at Big Alberts we had 37 kids and that told

081130 of that really young group and then Timmy Treadwell um runs our adult House program um which is is Town Open Water Swim training and that's to help adults who want to get into competing with Open Water Swim like triathlons or maybe races or just they're just really fit they want to get out in the open water and he averages um about 27 uh people per session he runs two sessions in the summer the first one this year at 25 second one at 29 so um like I said our our program just expands a huge basically all ages uh what's not on here we also start our our training programs indoors in March every year at the YMCA and um those numbers are pretty staggering too this year for the junior uh lifeguard training evaluation

082testing program at the Y that's ages 9 to 14 with 349 kids during the course of that program between March and June and for the Nippers ages 6 to8 we had 189 so this program starts in a couple months we still getting going again um yeah and it just runs for a lot of year so that just gives you an idea of what goes on also pre-season for the programs and we're very proud of our programs I'm proud of the programs to makes really good I saw how you look at each other saying this starts in a couple months yeah I'm already already early March right yeah yeah New Year's ends and we start a exactly so two of the things that we mentioned here that uh uh just expand upon uh the town uh

083started installing cameras into many of our beach conversations and the amount of vandalism down this this year was tremendously lowered on that major vandalism on there than too which is a cost savings by having the deterrent of of the camera systems there and it's also just for Public Safety there and too next one of the things we didn't necessarily touch on but been touched on in the past uh I want to thank the residents of M talk specifically then too because there was two major Beach replenishment projects here that occurred about a year ago one being the FI project that brought nearly 400,000 cubic yards of sand to the beach what we saw there is that the beaches uh were broader and wider and specifically down at Kirk Park Beach which actually had a great

084large increase of people that like to sit on the beach at Kirk park because it was so wide and Broad like they have hadn't seen in 30 years on there the other one was to the board and thank the board for supporting uh the requests of of many of the residents out in mon talk specifically was to uh replenish the disch PLS be dish plane Beach to make it a recreational beach by top dressing top dressing the s on there CU we know it's such a an iconic location for individuals to enjoy with all that that also then allow the town lifeu guards to make sure they Place their their lifeguarding stand in the appropriate locations based on some of the new traditional rips that are out there so I thank you both for that

085uh we're going to our recommendations and actions for the 2025 season lifeguards uh wound packing and trut kits were uh received late in the 24th season in 25 these kits will be deployed in all first uh uh first and uh first aid kits and lifeguards will receive additional annual first aid training for their use I believe you're even doing CPR maybe tomorrow John also so concentrating year long but we also want to make sure they have the appropriate uh uh um first responder medical equipment needed there too dogs PS failed to pick up a lot of doggy bags which were consistently washing up on the shores of high tide dogs have not been prevented from urinated in the area post lifeguard stands lifeguard equipment lifeguards personal property dogs control and regulations at baing beach should

086be discussed and updated for the 25 Seasons as needed we'll discuss this internally in our group I know we had that discussion offand last last season and I know that is a that is a subject that would produce interest to the residents parking with the growing population of bathers at the Lifeguard uh public bathing beaches and the lack of available parking of these beaches there should be a discussion and consideration for opening another public bathing Beach we've stated this multiple times yearly uh it's challenging to do very challenging to do but in addition to creating another safety guarded Beach lifeguard presence there we provide quicker response times to swimmers in distress calls um no worries on here very simply that's me I'm sorry yeah get closer oh you want me to get closer that's not

087a problem I can closer to the microphone great uh always uh swim to your lifeguards be respectful to others and clean up your litter those are the ABCs of some of our beaches uh part of this presentation which is on the T board's website under our meeting information you'll see the next slides and some of the appendixes which gives our approximate approximate bathers by protected beaches on there where the majority of all the bathers are going next slide bther attendance by Beach and many different graphs that Lieutenant uh Jeff Thompson has assist assisted on uh and last one if you don't mind and I think that is it is that correct injuries and more this a very uh comprehensive bathing report that we have on our on our website uh there's a lot thank you

088very much you can just take that down what we're saying is there's a lot of information that's public facing the lifeguards you see there protecting our beaches uh uh staff as far as taking uh collecting The Refuge which is always difficult to do than to uh maintaining uh our conversations to us uh to appropriate standards also and just cleaning cleaning our be beaches none of this could have happened without the wonderful staff of the town of eastampton okay the Town of eastampton Staff Works tremendously hard to actually provide some of the greatest services for some of the most beautiful beaches in the world that we have here we understand that but we also can't do that without the respect and all also without the input from the residents to what their needs are in their

089Community then too we work very hard as a town board but also as staff members of the Town working for the residents to provide these services and one on that we come to cherish and enjoy I hope you all get to enjoy that and with that that is an inclusion of our 2024 Beach season report any questions we're here yeah just the other point I was going to make is that I know folks uh earlier in the comments are and as they should be concerned where tax dollars go we spend $1.1 million in uh lifeguard salaries so that we can keep our beaches open and protected so just to give the community context for what services cost in this town and we're forever grateful for all that you folks do to keep our beaches safe

090and um and our kids trained and whether they go on to be go through the programs Junior lifeguard Nippers whether they go on to be lifeguards or not we know they're safer at the beach because they've gone through those programs yeah I went to a conference in mic I went to a conference in Hawaii tough tough conference uh no probably Johnny probably one of the best conferences I've ever gone to and they have a beach Guardian uh Workshop there and that beach Guardian Workshop was basically lifeguards teaching the community how to be water safe and uh and it's amazing to think that we're doing it here uh we are a benchmark to other agencies and they there it constantly comes up even John mcgean who's ex chief of mon talk leer he's building a program

091in ringcon Puerto Rico right now modeling it after what you have provided this community with the programs and and uh the Water waterproofing that Community down there yeah I just want to thank you so much for the safety you give to everyone who comes here when I look at these numbers 138,000 628 Beach patrons you're managing a city um that happens to be in front of a a Water Resource that you need to be prep prepared for and we have so many folks that come out here that aren't beachgoers in general or don't live in a coastal area like we do and the education and the human services that you and John provide is uh certainly when you talk about budgeting and we talk about money and what the town's spending on money money spent

092on helping humans and protecting humans it's invaluable and it's it's a small price to pay for helping our citizens and our V visitors uh live here safely and enjoy what we all can enjoy um and and more and more what you know we have a struggle for the regular folks to be able to enjoy our beaches are free and uh it's an amazing an amazing asset that your dep you guys are to our community and I want to thank you so much I'm also falling over at the litter um Tom I saw you made a note yeah 121,000 pounds of litter uh that's a number that we need to uh discuss more I'd like to get some more information on how the town processes that and what goes on uh with that and I know

093a lot of that needs to be picked up by hand because it's not properly disposed of so again these are departments that you know you don't see in the news every day um they're not the sexy departments that get everybody talking but they're the Departments that do the hard work for this town and I'm very grateful to all of you yeah I I just Echo that and I think we we often talk about the environment being one of of the keys but it's the recreation within the environment and and our beaches are are critical and having them safe and well guarded is you know that's what gets people going to that's what gets people coming out here so the investment we make in your department to do this is critical to the well-being of the

094town and you know John I I I both John sorry hey you know I see you at all hours I see you at all kind of venues you know training little kids you've trained my kids many times the job you guys do is absolutely phenomenal so I can't can't thank you enough thank you I think one of the things that's missing is also the proof is in the pudding uh for Chris Chen he was named in New York state lifeguard of the Year this year he was that doesn't happen every year that doesn't happen often so to have that happen in our Township it shows the quality of the lifeguards and the team that we have been able to put together to not just train but also to maintain and too so thank you all

095very much appreciate it thank you 130,000 visitors 130,000 lives saved so next up we have the proposed amendment to chapter 91 beaches and Parks Charlie thanks for joining us today to start this discussion you don't mind if I could just up one second here uh let me just get mine here first apologize about that no it's the next and I don't even know where it is but I know for her pretty well so hopefully thank you so very much um thank you very much Madam supervisor uh I have Charlie Collins with us assistant Town attorney and working with assistant Town attorney Nick cus uh uh Town attorney Rob Connelly Tina Laren uh Brian Frank and Tim treble from the planning department uh they took a deep look into uh initiative to try to stop individuals

096and to be able to force individuals from crossing over the Doom locations that weren't properly marked or properly authorized then too why is this important when sand paths start to be created uh in locations that aren't deemed appropriate they start to provide vulnerability to our greatest coastal defense system and that is our primary Dune system right now example this summer after the M talk fireworks uh I believe I was quoted stating they look like they were ants on the dunes because of the dozens and hundreds of people that on our dude systems in montta but also at other locations that we see part of what one discussing this with senior Harbor Master Tim Treadwell is that there's not an enforcement mechanism in the code to be able to uh uh enforce ticket and then adjudicate

097this so we came up with some uh potential changes to the town code in chapter 91 that uh would be able to uh uh enforce the initiative also part of chapter 91 is that this was presented potentially presented it has to be presented to the town trustees as chapter 91 has to be changed only in authority of both the majority of the Town trustees in the town board I believe they might have discussed it even last night they'll be reviewing this for some more comments but this is our first blush at some of this um uh draft legislation and Charlie I thank you so very much for your assistance no problem so again that was great uh synopsis of what's going on but the section of code is section 914 um and the proposed change

098is pretty pretty minimal U just so an addition but we'll go through it uh section 914 prohibited conduct a no person shall damage to face injur remove tamper with or destroy any legal town or trustee sign snow fencing flagging or other property located on the beach or the land where Dunes of that beach so this is just bringing dunes and making sure everyone knows that Dunes are part of the protected area and dunes is a defined term within this section of the code uh C uh no person shall throw place or deposit fill sand gravel or any other materials including but not limited to trees shrubs or brush on the beach or Dunes unless properly authorized by the trustees or town board and most of the language is always there we're just making yeah the

099only addition is is adding Dunes so people you can't just throw stuff in the dunes and get away with it uh section e no person shall maintain a camp trailer or other structure whether temporary or permanent on the beach and added or landward dunes and then this section R is completely new and added to the code and no person shall walk through or cross over any Dune unless at a location authorized by the town trustees or town board including but not limited to elevated walkways stairways other specifically designed doing Crossing structures or designated foot paths uh and that is the the extent of the proposed changes and this would allow as David said code enforcement to site and issue violation for anybody you know impinging on these rules that is correct so that's the primary

100uh uh discussion on there uh again uh looking at chapters of uh chapter 255 we thought it was best to put it into chapter 91 for beaches on there than two this uh uh the authority lays within the town board but also within the town trustees at their beaches and pretty much what we're trying to do here straight and simple we want to keep people to the designated historical foot paaths that we have currently already then two if we can do that instead of actually making other gaps in our primary Dune system we're going to be safer from cul of resiliency uh ALS and we're going to make sure that the environment uh as far as our Shrubbery our beach grass is going to stay in place and that just makes us safer and more

101environmentally protective of our of our dunescapes uh but there's still going to be others that AR aware of that and when they flaunt that their ability to flaunt that to uh Town officials being code enforcement or a Marine Patrol this gives the Marine Patrol or code enforcement the backing to site them for a violation of the code so it's a little bit simple additions there that might have a very meaningful response in the end then too we can do this appropriately with additional signage and methodologies as we go but we needed to do this section of the code first so for that this we're open discussion so I think this is super necessary um with uh what we see uh the damage being done I mean this isn't this is this is because we are

102seeing more folks not stay to the traditional paths but just walk over the the dunes um and also when they do so they're trampling the beach grass which then kills the beach grass it's trampled um or it's smothered by this activity so I think this is uh very necessary I thank you for bringing it forward and I just wouldn't know if in terms of uh when we're doing we're calling things Dunes if you would just add uh primary Dune uh and and on the beach primary dunes or landord Dunes just to distinguish that there's also that primary Doom that should be included in a in anywhere in R and E just to make sure we're covering that yeah in a um so there's the beach which is the burm of the beach but then there's

103of that primary Dune just to point it out even okay thank you I would yeah I would Echo I mean I I think this is great legislation that's needed I I think your point about signage is key here I think um you know maybe new signage on those designated Pathways to really educate people as to why we're doing this um is necessary in conjunction so so just to add to that so I actually have some templates of the signage uh I like to find myself in Block Island sometimes with my wife having a Mudslide I do have to say celebrating their anniversary at times and uh they actually have some nice appropriate signage and some of their their beaches like the um their their Crescent Beach in which it tells why uh uh Beach vegetation

104is important uh and I I'll send that around to the board and we can discuss other methodology but I completely agree with you Tom that's that's a very critical step to the uh to the compliance let's educate uh individuals why it's important uh instead of just penalizing them let's give them the chance to comply first yeah I'm supportive of all the changes and we have Patrick here our public information officer said that we can do that next as we get approach next season because how many times have you seen families where the little kids have run ahead and they want to be up high and they're like rolling down the Dune and not only is it can it be you know destructive to the Dune but they could be picking up all kinds of you

105know ticks and whatnot so um I think education is is key agreed so what I will do here if you don't mind to the board members I will uh I will bring that primary Dune back to the group that's been assisting me with this I'll wait for Francis Bach uh the clerk of the trustees that there's any comments from them and I'll bring this back maybe in a Le on report uh to the town board as we move forward reason why we're trying to do this now at this stage summer 2025 is around the corner everyone it's a joke but planning starts already yeah thank you very much that's all we have char thank you very much I appreciate that we're going to keep Charlie there because we have an an urban renewal uh parcel

106that he wants to introduce to us I know Patrick if you could pull up you want to start with existing sure M just talk us through this Charlie yeah so um Lots 20 and 18 this is an urban renewal this is on sheet sp6 it's old file map 8 77 uh it's number 20 is 41 Roosevelt Avenue which is off of Harbor View Lane in Springs it uh the adjacent property number 18 is also owned by the same owner and they would like to that one is vacant currently and he would like to merge the lots to give them a little more space it's a 18 is a pretty tight lot as it is um it was sent to the uh so become one lot total so one less building lot uh interestingly number 20

107already has two houses on it so uh pre-existing zoning it's an old property but uh it will become one lot uh and take one building lot out of this old filed map uh minor change would be the change of the location of the access point um if you want to show what it will look like after the change so just one lot and the access point will be moved um to all to take access off of Roosevelt Avenue there is uh so that was that's the main that was the application that was brought to me just to merge the two lots um pretty pretty simple uh while I was reviewing the urban renewal map a couple other things came up uh on this map that I will eventually that hasn't gone to the engineer yet

108or the I've spoken to the engineer about it but he hasn't written up anything and planning hasn't seen it or anything like that yet but there's a few planning board has already seen this yeah planning board's already seen it Engineers signed off on it planning department has reviewed it as well uh it would take so there's two structures on the property two house residences so that was predate zoning yes so uh just so that everyone knows with the merger it wouldn't be able to they wouldn't be able to have a third structure on that no they could now you could build a house on 18 now right but now it would be taken out of that so now there'll be one less buildable lot in that neighborhood that's great so Charlie if you don't mind

109I believe there's a cloning Cemetery that backs up onto this property on there then too um and I believe it also has it own separate tax map on it yes this if you to the south of 208 I don't know there is a yes tiny little Cemetery if you look at the Aerials I don't know if you have that but could see it has its own tax map it's a separate lot within that lot that that's that's good good news on there if if it didn't even though it might be um encapsulated by neighboring property that is part of the recommendation for Colonial cemeteries say to get their own sep of tax maps on it mention it yeah the property the map I don't know you know these maps are drawn in the 70s so

110they were kind of I think some people I don't know obviously I wasn't around but I don't they didn't really take into account necessarily the full picture when they drew these maps all the time so there's the property with the cemetery it like right now where that access on the the existing access would drive right through the cemetery so that was just not thought of so that's why we're just moving the access point really yeah it's if the aerial uh is the memo on there there's an aerial and it looks like a red triangle that's the cemetery it looks like Cemetery yeah that's right um that's all I wanted to mention thank you much that's the cemetery um but yeah so that's why I'm looking more into the accesses and trying to get this to

111I think that's a proper because they not disturbing yeah where individuals had been intered potentially hundreds of years ago yes so that's yeah so then I'm proposing to put this on for a public hearing based on the timing of the holidays it probably won't be until January mid January yeah I'm supportive I think it's a uh it's good for the uh applicant of the homeowner and it's also taking away a potentially new structure so uh I'm in favor of it yeah yeah that question yeah I look forward to bringing the public hearing it makes a a lot more conforming to zing to there and let's see what the public says okay all right I agree as well thank you um so the supervisor had a step out for a minute uh any other questions on

112this topic so um we can slowly move to the next topic until she gets back and uh in that I think um uh I'll uh just give some background on why this is a topic for today uh if board members recall we've had uh discussions uh in in in work session and two public hearings on the um um additional um uh alternative board members both for the zba uh zoning board of appeals and for the Architectural Review Board um so we've discussed this before and this has to do with uh what is the process and what happens in today's times when a board member of one of the um ARB or a zba board member um can either has a conflict of interest and must recuse themselves from the public hearings and the application itself

113all discussions of the application and when board members take vacations they are allowed to do that as far as I remember but very few um or they have illnesses and and some we we see uh on the zoning board some uh short uh illnesses a week or one meeting or and then some we've seen some longer term illnesses where people have been out for months so uh the town attorney's office reviewed um other municipalities in New York state and uh reviewed these different types of codes that they had for appointing alternative members and then the process of how they would be brought up to be part of an application formally onto the either of the boards and therefore we're also uh so that's where we are today I now that you're here that's just the

114background uh and now I just wanted to um to go over a couple of things uh some of the callers in who who are board members I was on the zoning board for um nine and a half years David you've been a zoning Board member Ian you were on the planning board so um the reason uh some folks spoke about in the past and when I was first on the board 2003 um before there was actually recordings there was only tape recordings um audio tape recordings uh you could come back and review the either the videotape or the uh audio recording if you were absent however you know as we know with everything else in the world it's not 2003 anymore and times have changed and we need know that the strength of our determinations

115rely on the um the the Integrity of our determinations and part of our determinations that are written at the end of an application and decisions that are made are based on in my opinion a full five member board I think in these times the applicant deserves that um and I also think in terms of litigation a five member board uh takes away the idea of a 2 two denial uh a 2 two decision opposing decision which which is an automatic denial everybody has to go back to the starting uh point on that those are uh challenged in court quite frequently and usually what happens in that case and Rob I'm sorry to speak for the attorney's office so if you could back me up here those are back referred back to the board and the

116process has to begin again so it's basically a waste of taxpayers dollars and a waste of applicants dollars if we don't have full boards for these public hearings so then this memo then uh we've already had two P the two public hearings that were merged on this so we're looking more now to talk about amongst ourselves process um which is different from from codifying the law so there are a number of suggestions here um uh that uh have been brought forth to us by our attorney's office and we could walk through them one at a time and have a discussion if that's the way you'd like to go I think that's F can I just clarify one thing in here I I looking at the last bullet point and it was questioned by a couple

117of the callers it is I in artfully drafted that solid Point what I meant in bullet point 5 was that if a regular member or an alternate member sits through the entire application and it gets down to the point where a decision is going to be made and all of a sudden there's a different member sitting for the decision I was asking if the board thinks that the applicant should have the right to ask for an adjournment of that meeting to allow for the the member who had been sitting through the entire application to be the one who deliberates and makes the decision I think that that i' I've had I think we've had that David where applicants have asked the chair and and uh if there was an member absent for it depends on

118the the clock the 62-day clock so I would say in the in the um in the situations where you're up against a 62-day clock then the alternative member would take it to the end um because you have there is a time constraint on determinations and that's that's something to consider as well but we should talk about all of that so the first one that we're talking about is should alternate alternate members be required to attend all meetings and these questions are based on the different codes that we saw in New York state for for towns that do have uh alternative members should Al alternate members be required to attend all meetings even when all regular members will be present or should alternate members be required to attend meetings when a regular member will be absent

119or accused from the consider a of an application I have thoughts I do I do too okay um so I think uh for continuity and for um simplification of the process alternate members and I just want to be clear that the code says that uh up to two alternate members can be appointed it doesn't have to be two members so it's an either alternate member or members I I think they should be required to uh attend all meetings um this way they have the full sense of the a board's discussion just as if the board member was sitting at the meeting and if in the case where it's a a quick absence God forbid something happens that process can still continue I think it makes it complicated for folks to decide which meetings they're going

120to attend and which meetings they're not going to attend and that even for the alternate member that SCH eding can mess you up if you don't know that every Tuesday you're going to be in a certain place at a certain time um and make it optional so that's just my thoughts on that board members yeah I I slightly different I understand where you're coming from but just a different perspective would be I'd say that I if an alternate board member is required to step in because another board member is absent for some reason then yes I think they should henceforth be required to tend all further meetings just in case they are required for that final vote but I I think the other the other side to it is is that they can review the

121tape they can re the LTV video of that meeting to get that information so requiring to be at actually all meetings may not be necessary but then you don't get your questions asked right if you're sitting in and the applicant is there and the attorney's there and uh town planning staff are there and you have questions that you want clarified you don't have the ability to do that if you're going going back to look at a tape as opposed to your present I agree I think that goes to point number two and I I think um it it relates to point number two and I I get where you're coming from I I agree with that I think it's how and when they can submit questions I think as an alternative is a is a

122relevant issue so just so folks know I mean when we put together the 2025 budget we assumed that they would be attending every meeting so we budgeted for that so that it's not like it's a a a part-time uh stien it's it's the full stien because we felt that thought at the time that they were going to be uh attending all meetings I mean because we've had situations where you know yes some folks say you know they know that they take their vacation in June so they can give you a heads up that that that they'll be missing those meetings but we've also had situations where folks uh had an illness you know just before they were ready to leave for the you know for their meeting and weren't going to be able to to

123attend so I you know my vote is for they're required to attend all meetings yeah I understand both both sides there for sure and I understand Tom's point but I think if they're being paid as a full member then they should be expected to be at every meeting and be ready to to serve David so one of my greatest privileges of serving this town was being appointed and serving on the zoning Board of appeals uh I remember when I first went on there I had just been broken my hip and to learn all the information uh that was given to me about chapter 255 all all the chapters of zoning and code was tremendous and I think that's what you get from participating in every meeting you NE don't even have to ask a question

124in a meeting but you could just soak it in and learn from uh attorneys on both side of the discussion from planners environmental analysts on both sides of the discussion that is something that I think provides value provides for a stronger uh board member as I enjoyed being being coming but also has more educated uh uh and informed determination on there then too there's also allowances within the town code and that board member can't make it for a certain reason reason that they can actually uh do something remotely also then too for so for those reasons to try to strengthen a a board member and also the strengthen the Rapport of the board as a whole I would say I would also support being present all the time okay so it sounds like we've got

125the consensus is sure what you're trying to edit of course you're not so so the consensus is they would be required to attend all meetings so the next question may an alternate member ask questions and submit input when not appointed to replace an absent member um my thoughts are no um then I think you're expanding the the board de facto you're having you have a board that has uh in our code we have five members of a board and for an alternative member then to come in and join the questioning and and answering if they're not haven't been uh um selected as an alternate member it expands the board I think beyond the scope of what we're intending to do here I yeah I agree with Kate on that I I think that I I

126feel pretty strongly about this one that they should not be able to ask questions or interact or influence the process in any way unless they're actively serving again I'm just going to offer a different perspective on it which is to say that there could be the case where a an existing board member is in the first three meetings and then steps out you know I I think allowing that alternate member to be fully engaged in the process and ask relevant questions is going to deliver a better final outcome so on a zoning board it's not three meetings people aren't coming back it's a public hearing so you prepare for the public ARB they they come back and forth a little bit more um but again we have a code that says we have X amount

127of board members deciding on something and I don't know if that would be consistent with that if alternative members before they're actually asked to sit on the board because somebody's missing wouldn't be a sixth or seventh member I I would need a legal opinion on that yeah I think it would be inconsistent with with if if the I do know that other municipalities in the area do allow um alternate members to opine on applications but especially it it does lead to to questions with when the determination is written um if there's some of the opinions of the alternate member in the decision when they weren't asked to actually be the the voting member that could lead to challenges in in article 78 so I think it's safer to allow only uh sitting members to to

128vote on and participate partip yeah because that goes with the next one too they're kind of together that certainly makes sense to me I think if a question was asked that you know changed the mind of other board members and that can be demonstrated that seems problematic before the supervisor goes you might be the the Bri uh the third vote here I agree with what Tom is saying there that to have engaged uh uh members all parts of the application I think is important then two uh but I understand what Rob is saying as far as uh the legal aspect of it then two I would prefer it this way but I understand legally if it might not be the most prent thing to do yeah I I'm I think that the only the five

129that are tasked with reviewing that application should be asking questions so if the alternate is not engaged because some someone hasn't recused or been out sick or on vacation I don't think that they um should have the ability to ask questions um because part of it too is we live in such a litigious Community when it comes to some of our zoning board applications I think we need to make sure that it's just the five that are uh by code that are should be listening uh DET making the determinations so we're going to answer no to that um next question is May an alternate member be permitted to vote only when a regular member is absent or recused yes because then you have too many votes so if you if you have you again we're

130codified for five members of a zoning board because of the the size of our our community so how do you have six votes which one counts and which one doesn't count that's I think that's just Jo is like like this is a very simplistic question in the sense that if if you're you know if one member has been recused sick or on vacation if that uh alternate is you know the fifth member then that fit you know the alternate votes on the application yeah I I guess the question here would be if you had two alternates uh and they've both been required to you know you're picking one um yeah no I think this is fine I think so just so you know we we only budgeted for one alternate because I I mean I

131think we've never had alternates before so I thought that the thought was we you know we the code allows up to two but at this point we would only looking to appoint one alternate for the ARB and one alternate for the zba yeah I agree with that and I think I think that it's obvious they could only vote if they were you know recused if some another member was accused or absent but I do think there's maybe further discussion to be had about does an absent you know member automatically mean that they're replaced and I think that that'll be debated later I mean if somebody is ill for one day and going to miss one meeting but it's been engaged in an application for a period of time it may not be appropriate to replace

132them I would say only after you know two meetings or in the case of a zoning board if it's a public hearing you need an active member there so that would be different but um if it was something that was drawn out for a long time and a regular member was engag enged and then only missed one meeting for some reason they might not be replaced in that case okay so my feeling is that if someone is absent and just let's think of the record in process for a minute when we talk about this and uh subsequent court cases so what would that look like you'd have one let's talk about uh I'm out let's say that we're the zba okay yeah and I'm out for for the public hearing or I'm out for the

133the ARB discussion and and so my alternate comes up um and Chris waler is my alternate and he comes up and he sits in and he participates in a discussion and he R he gives his he opines on the decision but then I come back because I was only sick that one week and now I have a different set of of conclusions what's what and how do we I I just want to since we're doing this the first time for me to keep it clean and simple as possible um and maybe it's not the same for the ARB as the zba maybe there can be you know a different idea but I'm speaking directly for the zba where it's a public hearing and then there's no expart communication the hearing is either continued and in

134that case I still think the person who sat whoever sat on the public hearing and participated should be that Shepherd that application and make the determination just so the record how would the record look this person participated in the hearing but then this person participated at the work session and a deliberation how do you build a a a clear and direct record that can stand up for that just to clar clarify my comments I agree with you it should be either there's somebody who's subing an alternate or not it should not go back and forth I just mean I can anticipate some cases is say an ARB application where there were several meetings somebody's there for two of them it's nearing the end I don't know if the chair designates an alternate when they serve

135or when they don't but you may wish not to replace them at that point even though they're absent from one meeting I think once the replacement is made the alternative steps in they're in Charlie would you could you comment on that to the scenario that um because since you're the attorney to the a orb uh yeah so repeat that again like what arb's a ARB is very different than zba right yeah I mean and both I'm more familiar with planning where it's it's a more of a long-term process with several meetings often per application I realize ARB and Zoning Board are often fewer meetings so it may be less of an issue but if a a member a regular member has been engaged in an application for you know a meeting or two and just

136happens to miss a meeting because of illness or something but would be back for a vote and I think that would be up to the chair person to decide don't think we should automatically make that replacement I think once you do the alternate is in and you don't go back if that person comes back so I think a decision gets made and you stick with it but I could see it going both ways in different cases yeah I mean ARB practically speaking it probably wouldn't really come up uh because generally I mean if it's something simp like a a sign a business sign it it is one two meetings Max three is like crazy right so and it's usually it's kind of kind of more of a work to get to a point more like

137planning I would say where by the time they're doing an approval it's generally in my experience almost always approved so it's never I mean it depends I I it would be an interesting if there was a full if it was a full building like a full Redevelopment of a property in a overlay for instance or historic district I would probably say if somebody if the member was there and heard the initial and the second and then couldn't make the third it it I I think I don't know I I it would be up to I would leave it up to the chair that's what I would think and then yeah I would say and then every because every application is very different fact specific and some of them it might just be the chair might

138feel like we got three votes anyway so what's the point of delaying it if we can if it's going to pass no matter what or fail no or if it were meeting where a vote was H taking place you might want to have a replacement to make sure you have the full board in that case but if it was you know the meeting before a vote was taking place and somebody had already been a part of the previous two you might want to let them be the voting member when that comes up yeah um yeah I think we've had a couple times since I've been on where we had one person that was one member was uh sick or traveling or one person was traveling and we knew that and then but then someone was

139sick so then you only have three members that's when you're like oh we need someone if you're at four with ARB I'm less concerned about there being an issue like a 2 two split but it it could happen um but generally what happens at ARB is they don't usually vote to deny they usually say you got to come back with some changes come back at a later date and then yeah it would be more I think ARB would be really one where if someone has to recuse we'd have someone step in at the beginning or if somebody is absent that day someone could step in and then I would I think the easiest would be like we discussed would be they just they're in charge the rest of the time the situation that you propose

140when somebody it's in the third meeting and somebody shows up sick I think I would just let the let the chair decide how they want to proceed and I think it's written that way isn't it uh the chair May designate not Shad designate May designate yeah so I think that gives the ARB some leeway there so it's so what we're saying it's really not one size fit all CBA and going have different uh operating procedures for alternates yeah yeah I think an absence doesn't necessitate a replacement the chair decides that but once a replacement is you know for for the ARB yeah I mean that makes sense if somebody if somebody steps in then they're in then they're in right because then if they hear it yeah like I if somebody's like here's the initial

141then fills in for the second one then the first person comes back it's just kind of like just you take over and then yeah that makes sense to me can we talk about recusal for oh go ahead I'm sorry and just like you point out K you know the CBA is up against hard time deadlines to 62 days ARB isn't so I think it makes more sense yeah and I would with ARB too I would probably as a courtesy to the applicant I'd be like what do you want to do this person sign here you can you don't have to come today you can we can postpone it to next week or two weeks down you know if you were prefer to wait for this person to either be back from vacation or you know

142not sick yeah we don't have the 62 hard dead day deadline on ARB it's much more fluid it's more of a and they're not public hearings they're generally not public hearings they're uh it's more of a work session so it's people can come they can discuss airb gives their comments we send in a complete letter they come back with a new application I mean not every time but majority of the time it's usually that's they do what they were asked or you know address the issues that were raised and then um the applicant is then processed and but occasionally does go to three or four but I try to keep that from happening because it takes too long okay y uh then just I just we' talking about absences but uh conflict of interest and

143recusals that's also written into our town code we just had a um training session where those uh the elements of conflict of interest were pretty well spelled out um for our board members and that usually happens before the public hearing that discussion yes okay so that would give plenty of time for the chair to appoint the other the alternate alternate member I think that's chapter 25 of code for ethics yeah all right here so when an alternate member fills in if the if a board member is absent for some reason and the proposed application is presented and reviewed at the meeting it is possible and likely that the vote might not take place until a future meeting should the alternate member be permitted to vote in the situation I think we just we just disced

144I think we took care of we just took okay actually so then the last one should the applicant have the right or ability no to adjourn basically to request that a certain member either regular or alternate deliberate on its application where both have been present for and participated in the consideration of its application and this is the one where you said that it it may have gotten misconstrued what you're saying is we're we're giving the applicant the ability to to adjourn the decision if the member who sat through the line share of the presentation isn't available on the day that the the determination is to be rendered I'm I'm going to question that um because um in terms of guard rails how do you know there's not you know the alternate member was more in

145favor I got the idea that the alternate member was more in favor of my application so I'm going to ask for that person versus or vice versa right so how do we PR prevent that from happening that's where I think if you on the zba this is different from the ARB if you you were there from the beginning you should stick through to the end or if you came in at a certain point maybe um a situation where a member was there for the public hearing but was absent for the work session and determination that's where it gets a little dicey to me because again we we definitely want to avoid the situation and we don't have predetermined determinations these are discussed in public and then the board comes to consensus in public like we

146do so we don't know it beforehand we want to the biggest thing we want to avoid is that 2 two deadlock that gets sent to court sent back and Wast everybody's money so I don't know how we cover that no I think that's fair a fair point and um you know that's why with with when you're in court you're not allow to Forum shop and try to go to a judge that's going to be more favorable to you um so to me it's a share determination exactly I mean my my only concern would go back to the earlier point about being able to you know alternate members being able to ask questions because you have an alternate member who does come in at some point and they haven't had the opportunity to ask questions does

147that then expose the vote to you know not being compliant because this board members voted without fully having beted all the questions they might have you say that again sure so so my concern would be so say say you have an alternate that comes in you know a or b or CBA say CBA in this case you know I'm more litigious typically um you know they they weren't initi initially in but then they they're in but they've not been allowed to ask a question when it by the time it gets to the vote on the dur during the public hearing they ex exactly but they they are yet now voting on this does that then expose the town to any potential litigious actions I don't think so because I think there's still allowed if they're

148going to be doing the deliberation they're still able to express what the substance of their question would be during the deliberation the the questions are for the zba I mean you you have the town code you have variance applications usually in the public hearings you have the applicant comes in with the best mitigation they it's laid out um there's not a lot of well you know there's questioning of if that's possible if that can you do more mitigation but I don't think it's the same thing as the ARB where you can question colors and and other things but I don't know if I'm making sense yeah no I just I'm thinking if if a if an alternate issue to Denial on an issue but you know and said I'm I'm doing it on this but

149they hadn't actually asked the applicant the question at any point that would be my only concern there you know so it's like you've got to the voting point and you're saying well I'm not approving this you know because this question hasn't been answered my satisfac but you never already answered to the question so usually once you close a hearing now you have a you have those set you don't so when you're on the zoning board you may think oh I should have asked that but that doesn't you still are going by five standards the zoning your determinations are not based on basically only the questions you asked it's based on a set of standards that are codified there's five of them and that's how you your board members should be basing their determination based on

150the Merit of the application the mitigation is possible and adherence to those five standards it's quite clear yeah as opposed to the planning board where you can can angle that a little bit yeah I understand Tom's concerns for sure I think but to Kate's point the record is the record and whether you had been serving or or just now serving you really shouldn't introduce or attorneys would say new reasoning as to why you're doing something or not right so I think that does restrict the alternate a little bit but as Kate said even a regular member might come up with something and so it's not a perfect balance but I feel much more comfortable with only having five members in a given time trying to steer the process I do think and in no case

151should an applicant be able to choose which members sit on there I mean that would be ridiculous I think but I think that there might be something more nuanced which it would be appropriate if they know there's only going to be four board members there and that they could ask for a full board or as close to a full board as the members and alternates allow so if two people are accused they could make sure at least one alternate was sitting on a a voting day I think that that's fair I think that's the whole point of this legislation and so that wouldn't conflict I think what the chair wanted to do but I wouldn't mind explicitly saying that they you know they could adjourn a meeting to to postpone it when there would be

152a more full board the next time and again as long as you're within the 62 days well they're if they're requesting it then it would not the they would have to wave it because otherwise there would be a case here where the chair had to make a decision oh my God we're going to run out the clock but that means we're not going to have a full board because two people aren't available and that would be you know I think legal problem okay other questions comments Rob if it would be possible to have your your office you know synthesize what we agreed to today so we had like standard operating procedure for the zba and for the ARB absolutely so that um because we're you know ideally um I know Kate's got the the legislation

153and just somebody else made a comment about the timing on this uh we did hear it this summer but it only made its way to the planning board in October and we only received their memo in November so that's why we brought it up today and also I'd like toh take full responsibility for the fact that it wasn't posted timely uh that was totally on me I dropped the ball on that one um getting ready for the seven so I there was nothing um nothing unly about that I simply dropped the ball okay so that concludes our topics so we can now go to liazon reports right um so I'll start off with the Aman advisory committee uh obviously we heard a bit today there was some some very um in-depth discussion around the senior

154center um just general voice that they still have major concerns with you know the financials and the design of of the project itself um we also talked a little bit about the lighting update um you know there's a request and I'm going to go back to lkma on this but you know while they've initially said they didn't want the full lighting to extend past Meeting House Lane there's some discussion now as to should there be any kind of lower footpath lighting between that point and the station particularly this time of year the superintendent of the school was saying you have a lot of teachers walking the station at 5:00 it is dark in that area and you know the the the surface is not entirely even so the lighting could potentially be a safety issue

155so I'll be following up with LK on that um we also discussed uh crry Hole uh Bridge so one thing that um some members of the committee have kind of put forward is um would it be possible potentially for it not to be a bridge and for it to be a level crossing and and there's actually some benefits to this which is um as the bridge was in its previous State even when functional um fire trucks couldn't actually go over it nor could ambulances and so you know that potentially impacts safety of a residence in that area whereas a level crossing that they could access that area more easily potentially it's also a cheaper option so it's something that you know I'd like to kind of get feedback from the MTA on whether they see

156that as being a possibility um because the bridge is obviously taking time in itself um I mean but they are in in preliminary engineering and there was an article in Newsday this week about you know the state of actually Long Island railroad MTA Bridges across Long Island yeah and now with the congestion pricing going into effect they're looking they're hoping that there's going to be funding available but is a bridge the right answer for that area or is a level crossing the right answer for that area I think it's the one of the questions so that's something that they're thinking about and I think it's it might be worthwhile reaching out to some of the other community organizations out there to what you know they they see as the the best solution for it um

157whether Bridge or level crossing um Human Services um we have going on this week tomorrow we have a movie at 10: a.m. it's one of my favorites plan Trains and Automobiles highly recommend uh on the 17th uh spring school we be visiting the senior center at 11:00 a.m. for intergenerational games and 11:30 the uh students will be putting on a holiday concert for the seniors so thank you so much to Spring school for doing that uh Monday December 16th the East Hampton Garden Club will be VIs visiting the center and assisting uh 35 senior nutrition program members create holiday center pieces um Adu implementation we have a meeting on December 12th um I will be discussing with committee members as to whether they wish to continue that committee into 2025 um just the reasoning being

158we we've really gone through many elements of the code uh we've come back with recommendations of what they would like to see changed um but beyond that um whether they see a continuing need for that sorry Tom I missed what committee you said this is the ad accessory dwelling yeah accessory dwelling units um moving on to um Fire Chiefs and and Commissioners so just wanted to put a reminder out there to people one of the Town codes we have on there which is 1884 which is posting of numbers um the reason I'm bringing this up is that if there is an emergency response in the middle of the night and you don't have numbers on your property PD and first respondes will not know where to go to get you the help you need and

159that's why this code was likely first introduced so just going to read this um this code out any owner of an improved land parcel in the town for which a street address number has been established pursuant to 1883 she'll Post in display said number in the manner set forth in 1885 for new construction the street address number shall be posted and displayed within 5 days of the US of the building permit no certificate of occy should be issued unless and until the street address number is posted and displayed in accordance with this chapter it unlawful to post or maintain any number on any construction site or completed building other than the street address number designated by the town assessor's office pursu to 1883 so the man of display um just to kind of see what

160the code requires here um style and size of numbers the numbers uh so the numerals letters or script used to display the street address number on the building shall be either painted or made of metal or other durable material the numerals letters or script should be at least 4 in height with a minimum stroke of half an inch and of contrasting color to the background all street address numbers shall be displayed so as to be easily seen from the street both by pedestrians and drivers of vehicles so this is for your safety public I do highly encourage you to hear to that code and it's something that um you know I I will say as a first responder does need reaction time um and we can do a social media post about that great um

161okay moving on uh antibus task force task force will be meeting tomorrow afternoon um disabilities Advisory Board will be meeting on the 19th um and that is everything for my D great thank you Tom David uh a couple updates here second house uh uh house restoration project is fully moving forward we should be able to have that complete very early in the new year now uh and it's looking quite great then too uh Army Corps of engineer projects and mon talk Inlet project then to uh uh myself and uh Town attorneys and Brian frag met with some of the property owners that we were seeking easements over try to make sure we have everything in place before that goes out to uh uh army courp goes out to bid so we're moving that forward too

162long Lane roundabout construction is moving forward rapidly then too uh with the utilities moving all of their uh in needed infrastructure out of the project scope area then too um important pass meetings again I mentioned this uh before Atlantic stri pass management board is meeting on December 6 virtually if we need any more information about that please contact my office I can get that over to you also the 2025 deer Lottery uh for the 2025 uh hunting season uh which opens uh January 5th I think that gets drawn excuse me Carol do you know when that gets drawn I think everything has to be in no later than 28th 2024 on there so please make sure if you're interested in that get that contact information to us um in reference to the uh New York

163state parks um uh response to Southern pine beetle state parks environmental team is on site today they're finishing marking trees for the cut cutting contract they're waiting the dec to issue a wetland permit for the work to begin they had site visits this week with a contractor discussing staging areas and type of equipment to be used the they also are currently meeting as we speak with uh some of the members of the chiefs of the of the Springs Fire Department to discuss uh some of the cutting areas and the turnaround areas uh lastly I know you hear this from me a lot also then too it is a new sports season at bonic high school right now uh girls basketball is playing coached by Sam James boys basketball uh it's being coached by I believe

164Greg no uh sorry Dave conin this year his first year and they have the Kendall Madison tournament um this coming weekend kend the Madison was a stellar athlete fortunately passed way too early Stellar athlete uh East High School and played at Yukon also then too but the wrestling tournament at at uh uh this spr Garner tournament was this past weekend bonic wrestling is doing really really well and then let's take that down a level to uh uh to uh Middle School sports it will be coming home and back out here for the Springs allspray girls basketball girls volleyball green team is playing uh M talk Mustangs so there's a lot of a lot of sport to be seen by some of these kids please go participate and cheer on the teams uh it's fun to

165see everyone out there uh at this time of year uh and please check out uh the athletic schedules on some of our local schools districts websites that's all I have for do that great thank you Kate yes um as you know the zoning code work group I've already mentioned it is preparing a presentation a further discussion on Gross floor area that will be presented on uh next Tuesday December uh 17th in the main meeting room um also I just want to address uh some of the comments that were made today the false comparison of a of a reducing a Max GFA on a house to the senior center and how um how that is an incredibly false uh comparison to make when you're talking about a structure that will uh service a family versus a

166structure that will Service uh Town residents and house an entire town Department um I don't see how that comparison um is valid in any way whatsoever um also researching on um uh Red Cross uh designated Red Cross uh shelters um there uh is quite a lot of documentation that we've researched um on this I Tom I've given you this documentation um also my brother is a part of the nasso county OEM and has been there since Sandy and there's quite a lot of information on why the senior center is could not be considered as a um as a Red Cross uh shelter um although it could be used for a very good purpose uh since it's would be large enough to let emergency responders stay there and rest there when they were in this location

167which does not have all the Des designations of a Red Cross shelter including separate dormitories space for females and males to sleep in separate uh distances from where a kitchen is and no Mechanicals in a basement um enough I we did some research back then when we talked about I think it was here a couple months ago yeah East Hampton High School is designated as an emergency Red Cross American emergency shelter and does anybody want to guess how the size of the e in square feet the East Hampton High School is 75,000 245,000 square feet so that is the appropriate venue to be an emergency shelter for the town also the Red Cross will not put two shelters within such a close distance to each other uh if anyone would bother to do the research

168on County shelters you'll see that they're quite uh spaced out the purpose of the emergency shelter is to shelter in place for a very short time um and it also takes that structure completely out of use for the community so uh medications and uh uh additional uses for the senior center during an emergency distribution of medications meals continue to be cooked there all of those elements would be removed from our abilities to recover after a storm which we take quite seriously um uh Wayne Scott citizens advisory committee met last Saturday it uh they had a lovely breakfast before um there's there's uh it was the last meeting of the uh year for the wcac um they uh during the regular meeting um they spoke again of concerns of uh the what ha what's happening at

169the gun club and what will be happening in the future they uh also discussed in length the historic designation of the Osborne property across the street um and had some ideas uh to come back and discuss some of the folks from the Wayne Scott Heritage uh group spoke at the public hearing um uh and they then had their elections um for as far as the ditch Dune project Brian Frank in coordination with the dec is now uh in the process of flagging the wetlands by reinstein Park as part of that will be part of the uh uh permit application when it gets formalized again this is in cooperation with the getting all the elements together with the dec before the formal permit is put in um the do Grant of $600,000 for Coastal resiliency for

170Monto um that meeting with our state contract uh managers got moved to a later date and so I will have an update as soon as we uh speak with them and uh that's all I have thank you Kate uh yes I'm very happy to report that the welcome to Spring signs that have been being constructed are the first one is up on Springs fireplace I want to thank um Steve O'Brien Tony Litman for who is the man who built them and Dave Le L on the department for making it happen um they'll be placed on Springs fireplace three mile Harbor and acabonac uh handmade out of wood and and beautiful signs so very happy to report that uh the property management committee will have a subcommittee meeting on Wednesday uh December 18th to talk about

171the Dodge property um a management plan for that property excited to see that move forward there's some beautiful historic structures there and looking forward to figuring out how we're going to use that and and eventually lead to a a l e um also I'd be remiss not to say that 66 Main Street in Wayne Scott has two historic structures we heard a lot about at the last work session the property management committee is looking forward to figuring out how to best maintain those buildings and and what use they'll be to the town or a lcy um just generally about the property management committee that more and more we are investing in historic structures which I think is great for the the character of our town it's one of the Beautiful Things um but as a

172responsible board I think we need to make sure that we maintain those and are proactive with maintenance and and an eventual plan and so I thank the whole committee for um their work on that and look forward to working with them again next year uh the community housing Advisory Board will also meet Wednesday on December 18th um to go over uh we heard from them last work session with uh recommendations to the rfas that went out this year they'll be recapping sort of this year and looking forward to how to improve their application process and I just want to um say that well a I look forward to working with them on that but I also want to open it up to anybody in the public uh who was an applicant could have been an

173applicant in ways that you think we might want to change that process I know chab has been very open to trying to receive all sorts of applications so we can um you know weigh all the different needs out there and I just want to encourage public involvement to uh to let us know how we can do better uh then just generally I said this during my last Le and report I think Community involvement is is so important and I want to continue to reach out to to more diverse people who might want to serve on different committees or appointed boards um and if you don't want to do that I just want to make sure that people know they don't have to stand up at a work session to talk to us that that every

174I can say that every one of our board members is open to hearing concerns thoughts and um I think the more involved and the more diverse groups of people we have involved the the better we'll be my committees that I'll be appointing coming up uh and I would love to hear people who want to serve on them Springs Park um Springs Park both from the the dog user aspect or others would love to um hear other interests other groups out there who want to or the people who want to serve on that committee uh the a advisory committee um I will be the liaison too and I'm I'm open to anybody who wants to serve on that who has an interest or a relationship to agriculture in the town uh the property management committee that

175is mentioned uh and chap uh so please reach out if anybody's interested in those committees particularly but but any appointed boards or any type of service uh the more involvement we have the better I had preliminary conversations with uh the clerk's office we were approached a couple of times this year about um individuals in public questioning our permit process and how in particular Beach parking permits are issued uh I would just like to look at the language there to uh I mean look this is a a complicated issue in that our parking lots fill up and we want to make sure that we have places for our residents to park I know that there are many people who try to get extra stickers who aren't residents and those take up parking spaces and so I

176want to clarify that language as much as possible to uh help the clerk uh with with very clear rules that are reasonable not the current ones aren't and I'm just saying this out loud so that anybody out there who has thoughts about how we should change that I would like to hear from you and other board members I'm going to open this up to to everybody and any other permits that the town issues I think that refining our language to make sure that the language says exactly what we mean and is fair and I think in the case of Beach parking and so many other permits if you let everybody have them then we you don't have parking for yourself and I've certainly been to beaches I rarely go to beaches but um I've driven

177up to beaches where there wasn't a parking space and and that's a bummer so uh look forward to that conversation I have a few comments on the senior center but it may be most appropriate to just comment on the resolutions as they come up unless we want to have that conversation now that's up to you I'll wait until the resolutions so I'm going to continue Ian's recruitment PSA for Town committees and boards and I'm oned East Hampton Z Harbor cic so if anyone out there is interested in joining that committee please reach out and as you heard we had a discussion today about alternate members for ARB and zba if you would be interested in being an alternate member please reach out to one of the board members and uh provide a resume and we

178will uh consider you for that uh position uh last Wednesday Ian uh Eric shance our housing director and I met with members of the greater East Hampton Chamber of Commerce to discuss affordable housing uh we shared with them the projects that we're working on and other uh housing organizations are working on and we got to hear you know their uh their feedback frustrations and whatnot um and it was a very productive our discussion and what we've decided is it would be really productive if we met quarterly so we're going to pick a topic I'll be working with the uh executive director Suzanne Kelly we'll pick a topic each quarter and um have members of the East Hampton greater e uh eastampton the greater eastampton Chamber of Commerce come to town hall for for that uh

179discussion uh the last thing I wanted to just talk about uh I had sent an email out yesterday you know we're Carol and the rest of us are working on um 2025 for the organizational meeting on January 2nd and 11 a.m. uh one of the resolutions is we set the town board meeting dates for 2025 and you know it's it's critical that we like get this right because warrants depend on and um you know our Thursday night meetings so I just want to if I could just take a um you know a poll of board members um in February we have during the school break which runs the February 17th through the 21st we have two board meetings the work session on the 18th and a Thursday night meeting on the 20 and in years

180past we have cancelled those meetings depending on the composition the board and uh who was going to be away with their family that week so um I just wanted to I know Tom you think you're going to be out I mean we normally do a trip at some point that way I nothing's spooked at this point but yeah normally you know so you're so you're you you I have to consider you out for the 18th and the 20th yes potentially David high probability because I believe in August sorry August April we're into sports seasons and I think this one is in between um and and Ian I know I know Ian you had said on the 20th you were out so 20th I'm likely out the 18th I would I would be here okay all

181right so we've got and that's the only meeting I anticipate so we only have three meet three board members on the 18th and we'd only have um two on the 20th so the 20th would definitely get rescheduled um we'll need to see we may need to cancel the meeting on February 18th then we've got the April break and that um runs uh that's before Easter it goes from April 14th through the 18th and we have two meetings that week the 15th is the work session the 17th is the uh town you know the Thursday night meeting you Tom you yeah I I honestly I just don't know I have to check in with myop on that one so I'll come back to you I listen when you're married to a teacher those breaks no that's

182why I asked that's why asked we had the same thing when Peter was on the board um so you're here that week I I highly probability yes we are okay you know if if not I'll be just taking a kid to go look at colleges or something like that I anticipate being here okay we got another te had a birthday this week got three te you would have to schedule something else in February like the 25th or something for for the Warren if nothing else yeah we'll have to figure something out and then the only other other thing was the week of in November election day is November 4th and Veterans Day is November 11th and town uh offices are closed so what I'm going to propose is that we hold a town board work

183session on Wednesday November 12th okay so that we we at least get two work sessions in in November yeah I'm definitely supportive of that I think just make sure that there's no planning board conflict I don't know the plan well they don't set they they're not going to set their schedule till and um we'd be out of the room by 6:30 yeah I definitely support another another well we can plan to be out the room by 6:30 all right so Carol we'll regroup and and and finalize this so you can get that done all right so that's all I've got so Tom if you could start us off with resolutions you we'll start off with uh 2024 155 this is to Rea retain LK mlan uh this is to construction plans and specifications uh for

184mold remediation at the sanitation Center uh in a sum not to exceed $111,000 second all in favor 1516 is also to retain LK mlan uh this is again for the uh sanitation department this is for maintenance garage drainage project uh this amount is not to exceed $ 59,6 second all in favor I uh we are able to offer resolution 2024 15 17 this is SE bid eh24 055 this is for the Star Island dring to Keith primes Incorporated uh and this would be for the amount of $1,280 second all in favor I I have resolution uh 158 this is the approval of special events for December and January December 24 and January 25 um the resolve that the special events committee is approved uh with the conditions agreed by the reviewing committee the first is

185retroactive for Steve Tuma sound aircraft Services the East Hampton Airport holiday party that was at the airport uh and it was held on Sunday the 8th yesterday from 3 uh p.m. to 8:00 p.m. it was open to the public uh next we have Amber Waves uh deck the farms fundraiser this will take place at Amber Waves Farm uh 367 Main Street amag ganit Friday 12:13 from 4: to 8:00 p.m. there is a rain date on 12:14 for the same hour uh Inlet Seafood holiday boat parade viewing party at Inlet Seafood uh 5:41 East Lake Drive montalk on Saturday uh December 14th from 5:00 p.m. to 8:00 p.m. uh the SAG uh Harbor Community Food Pantry is holding their waycott Polar Bear Plunge Beach Lane on Wednesday January 1st 2025 from 2: to 3: pm. and

186The Monto school district is holding their monok Plunge at Sunset Beach um at uh 469-480 County Road 77 montalk on Sunday um uh January 5th 2025 I uh would like to amend the date uh from 2024 to 2025 from 1 p.m. to 2 p.m. second all in favor five resolution uh 1519 is to approve expenditures for the litter action committee and this is where Christine ganet will be reimbursed in the reimbursed in the amount of $51.98 from the litter action committee's expenses upon proper submission of vouchers second all in favor I I resolution 2024 1520 this is to amend resolution 2023 1287 to authorize acquisition of 82 Bo Orman Road uh East Hampton uh suffet County tax number 300-1 d64 and the final finial impact will be a total cost of the housing fund at

187resale will be $233,000 $233,500 to acquire 100% of the interest in the land second all in favor I resolution 1521 declare lead agency to amend chapter 255 of the town code Article 5 special permit uses to permit a maximum density up to 12 units per acre for non- senior affordable housing second all in favor I resolution 1522 is to re appoint Kevin Warren to the East Hampton Housing Authority for a 5-year term expiring on December 16th 2029 second all in favor I 1523 is a budget modification for the police department we're removing $3,300 from other equipment to M motor vehicle repairs and Supply $1,040 from other equipment to equipment repair and maintenance $4,500 from other equipment to office equipment and $6,000 from office equipment to Building Maintenance and supplies second all in favor I 1524

188is to uh retain gallon marine LLC to provide evaluation inspection of a 2002 young Brothers vessel for establishing an approximate fair market value in an amount not to exceed $1,125 second all in favor I 1525 is to accept bid number eh24 044 treat clearing for 403 Abraham's path green velvet Landscaping the financial impact is $215,000 second all in favor discussion okay um yeah I just wanted the senior you know we first talked about the senior center when I in January I think when I first came on the board a lot of this process took place before my tenure on the board and I'm I I find myself in a little bit of a difficult position in that I respect the work that's gone into it I think that there's been you know very strong opinions

189for the new design against it I respect both sides of that um so I don't want to I don't want to vote against this I'm going to abstain on this and and that's a a strange position for me because I I'm I'm opinionate it's not hard for me to come up with an opinion uh I again I want to respect the work that's gone into it but acknowledge that I wasn't here the design has largely been fleshed out in terms of the the the big picture pieces since before my time and I don't want to get in the way of that I don't think every time a new board member comes on we should start from scratch um but I just wasn't involved in those decisions again uh so I don't want to vote against

190it because I don't want to be you know obstructionist about this I do I do want to say one other thing about the the bats I I'm very confident that the secret process and that the planning Department's attention to following the rules on that has been proper um so the reason I'm abstaining is only because this clearing is a result of the overall design which again I think has been in the work since before I got here I'm happy that um the supervisor and the town board have made some small tweaks that I think make this a better project with solar panels changing the sighting and other things some cost saving measures um so I'm trying to be constructive throughout this process but at the same time recognizing that um decisions were made before I

191got here but also being respectful of the work so I just wanted to explain that position okay Carol I think you need to do a roll call I'm I thank you I I I understand what you're saying and I share it as also as a new board member I I I do have one kind of slight issuance with this which is to make this decision for clearing um for funding it prior to actually reviewing And discussing the Monroe aspect associated with this because you know I I I have I'd like to discuss on that as well when we get to it so is there a way to actually discuss this after the Monro piece or no that's a that's a Rob question this is just accepting a bid this is right for pre-clearing yeah so

192I I don't think you necessarily need to do Monroe first but if if you want to take it out of order I don't see a problem with you doing that either well you want to do it out of order so Carol do I have to do I do I have to change okay we'll come back to it um resolution 2024 1526 is the department head bonus Compensation Program the town board amended chapter 37 of the town code relating to the department head bonus Compensation Program to enumerate the department head titles that are eligible for consideration under the program and now we can do it by board resolution second all in favor I 1527 is a resolution ad adopting a determination that proposed Senior Services Center located at 403 Abrahams path amaganset New York is upon

193application of the Monroe balancing of public interest test exempt from the zoning and land use regulations of the town of eastampton I just have I'm going to just read a few excerpts from the resolution uh I'm sparing you because it's a 133-page resolution the senior center will house the town's Department of Human Services and will provide a modern and spacious environment in which to provide new and expanded Community Services to East Hampton senior citizen population included in the senior center documentation and as stated at the public hearing and public meetings by representatives of the Town board the function or land use involved is governmental and for a public purpose as opposed to a private or proprietary one in that it will provide community services and programs to eastampton Residents the town's Department of Human Services

194is responsible for the Town Senior programs programs for the Aging senior nutrition senior Transportation inh home services and residential repair program the department also provides case management and makes referrals to other agencies that provide social and Medical Services the town board has already received robust Community input that has been incorporated into the concept of the proposed Senior Center nonetheless the town board will elicit additional input on the senior center before it adopts the final site plan the proposed Senior Center represents a substantial capital investment by eastampton and in East Hampton's ability to provide highly essential Community Services the review and approval of such an important Town project is rightly placed in the elected officials who answer directly to East Hampton's residents the public need for a new and expanded seniors Pro senior programs and services

195at a centrally located facility in East hton has been well documented the proposed Senior Center will meet those needs and will improve the quality of life for senior residents of e Hampton at no or minimal charge in addition the proposed Senior Center has been the subject of an extens of secer review by the town board's lead agency and benefits from a determination of nonsignificance I.E negative declaration while the town board acknowledges concerns raised by members of the public they must be viewed in light of the circumstances as stated above the existing Senior Center is ill equipped to handle the current and future needs of the town's aging population and to house the town's Department of Human Services the town board plans to elicit further public comment and particip IP ation in the process before finalizing

196plans to construct the proposed Senior Center especially the town board will seek written comment from the planning board in ARB in a timely manner before the senior center site plan is finalized pursuant to the Monroe balancing of public interest test when taken together upon consideration of the balancing approach the town board hereby finds and declares that the proposed Senior Center and the projects contemplated therein are exempt and immune from the town's local land use and zoning regulations including without limitation all standards requirements and procedures set forth in the town code and shall be required to receive the necessary variance and shall not be required to receive the necessary variances from the zba a special per permit or formal site plan approval from the planning board or approval from the ARB and shall instead proceed to

197the town of eastampton building department and fire Marshall's office subject to the conditions found in the body of the resolution second move for discussion sure so I mean you know I think we' we've gone through and we've discussed mro for many aspects and it's the public interest piece here which I think is you know does it outweigh the need I mean as I had mentioned earlier with regards to kind of the design process Etc you know there's there's aspects that personally I I am uncomfortable with but you know that's not what this is about I would also say that you know from in terms of the need for the town you know with demographics and and the gray wave coming I I do think that we will have definitively an increased need for providing services

198to seniors um with regards to the existing Senior Center um we have put some money into it this year replacing the siding and improving the walking Track there um I think there's a continued need to put more money in there um because you know as people have noted is it is kind of not in the greatest State continued there's leaks in the roof um and other factors that I think we we continue to address but this is more about Monroe itself and whether this is the right decision for the town to take in circumnavigating um the the typical process um for which a project like this would go to um my my concern here is really um around the president this might set not just for us but for also future boards and what that

199may indicate and you know for me I I think that there's there's a risk there um that I I you know personally not supportive so I I'm not going to be supporting this resolution um I think there's still some areas that I would like to see us address I I I think number one and I've bought this up before is is the financial aspect associated with this um you know we we've talked about numbers I you know there was the initial discussion of the 10 million you know I think that was completely unrealistic we're now close to 30 million and you know that number is likely to go up with inflation and other factors as we see this and I think you know giving the public a very clear understanding of how we're going to

200pay for this and what it's actually going to cost a taxpayer is a critical step in this um but going back to Monroe very specifically um yeah as I said I I I think the president is set to take you know decisions like this outside of the typical process is not one I can support okay yeah I I would just add that I was not on the board when the original Monroe hearing took place um I I think it's reasonable for the town board to do this I think there are certain projects that are for a public benefit where the town board should be able to act so um I'm not criticizing that in any way but the specific resolution is written towards this project designed so for the same reason as I said previously

201I'll recuse myself I do want to make one comment about Tom's uh the cost issue I think even if this went before regulatory boards um they would be improper for them to think about the cost to the town I think their role would be PL you know site plan variances setbacks things like that but it wouldn't be I don't think that this by involving them would you know make that cost conversation go any any differently um so that's where I stand so um May I comment sure so for me coming to this decision um uh and uh I just remind everyone that we had standards that we were to go by to make this decision it wasn't um a based on feelings or any there were there were strict standards we walk through them I

202issued my support at that time based on the standards um I wasn't um actually here since this been going on for uh a while to give a um healthy and and uh dignified uh environment for our senior population and also our town Department uh Human Services and if anyone has any doubt about and I am tempted to sit here and uh go through the links of of what services are provided by Human Services not just in the senior center but across town um so therefore uh researching this I went by the standards for the Monroe test it's not the Monroe Doctrine um that's something different uh for the Monroe test and I've already enumerated why I think that this um this this resolution the senior center meets the standards set forth in the Monroe test

203that we are bound to consider and also in doing that further due diligence was to look at other communities um what do they do when they build a community resource because this is not a residence it's not a commercial structure it's a community resource and we seem to be lacking um a definition in a code that all other adjoining municipalities and even further up the chain further up the state use and I hope we address that in the future um and then that would end the fear of setting any type of pres precedence but uh so that was my those are my reasons for voting for this uh resolution and if I could just I'm I'm sorry to say a couple more things I I do think that this meets the standards so again I

204think that it's a it's a very reasonable decision if the board moves forward with this I also just want to explicitly say that the the senior center needs to be redone there's a clear need there and I think that the current plan so much we're talking about who uses the current Senior Center I've said in my liaison report and previously that I think this new structure or whatever the new design would offer you know new things that don't currently exist like housing the the human a human services department I think a different demograph graphic of people who won't use the dilapidate senior center would use something like this and so I I recognize the benefits and I want to be explicit about that it's just that because this is around this particular design is why

205I'm choosing to recuse myself so for me it's not the design it's what's going to happen under that roof that's preced so when you can I ask you when you say the design I mean we are not it's not final the design right so we should have a a work session on the design if you're not comfortable with it because we all need to be comfortable with it moving forward right I mean I know we you would like to see a basement we went through all the reasons why we can't put Mechanicals in the basement that's not FEMA I think it was FEMA it's it's also yeah I mean basement's flood it's the last place you want put mechanic so you know we're open to discussing it's not you know it's it's still a work

206in progress we've made many changes since you became liaison to the uh amans at CAC you know we weren't getting feedback from them because from what I understood the liaison they didn't have a representation for a number of meetings you brought back information lower ceiling the stainless steel you know we've we've Incorporated those changes so we we want to hear from the community but I also have to say some of the comments that came up today to say that only 15 people go there a day is complete misinformation I mean we know we've been there I'm gonna call it a l okay um so but you know as far as the design is concerned we can you know there's time to make changes for sure but um you know the property needs to it's What

207where we're clearing proposing to clear is where you would site any building because there's topography there and it's it's a it's level there and that is the the best site on that property for the for the center but um so anybody else want to weigh in and otherwise we'll take a vote you call it a lie I just call it gaslighting yeah I think well I mean synonymous supervisor I leave that up you whether you want to re-engage I think when when you know Tom and I had spoken about the basement sort of off the cuff previously you know to redo those plans is a really big deal um we I think that the previous boards have been through iterations and made a choice and so at that point I said look I don't want

208to demand to see this just for my own sake so I would understand if you move forward if you want to re-engage that's okay I just know that every time you redo plans like this and look at different options it's a delay it's a process and I guess you've all gone through that so to say redo I don't I I guess I don't know what your what your input is that we could cuz there I'm not suggesting we you know tear up the current plans and start over that's not what I'm suggesting but if there are things that can be made changes that you know that the plans that when you both came into office in January were plans that had been approved by you know David Kate myself uh Peter and Sylvia right because

209they had been working on this with us for the last couple of years I understand now it's you know it's a new board we've got two new members that want to have input on it and you know you that's and we've made changes since you came you know came on board uh in reaction to members of Tom CAC having uh had brought thoughts forward that were definitely worth incorporating so um but that's fine think at this point we'll we'll take a vote on the mro balancing test if you could do call a roll call please Carol so I seconded already right council member flight nay council member lease I council member Rogers I council member called depont recused supervisor Burke Gonzalez I okay so let's keep going and then I think I have the next

210one but I lost and then we'll go back to the 25 to the bid that's David I think you're next right 21 I so 21 page 21 I miss hey check that one out okay uh this is resolution 2024 we are 2024 1528 this is authorized we got to go back to the 1525 oh you want to go back to that one next okay let's do thank you Carol okay so now we're back to just get there okay ex uh resolution 1525 accept bid number eh24 044 tree clearing for 403 Abraham's path goes with to green velvet Landscaping with the financial impact of $215,000 second do we want to we want a roll call oh you want to call for disc roll same no same same discussion okay so R council member flight nay council

211member lease I council member Rogers I council member call to Pont recuse supervisor bur Gonzalez I okay so now we go back to page 21 we are at the moment that uh can offer resolution 2024 uh 1528 this is authorized the release of part of the highway for Hamilton Santa Cola maccor curls and Mitchell the Town East Hampton is the owner of the highway right away at amig and know Bluff Road whereas the owners ofc of properties at 22 Bluff Road 28 Bluff Road AKA 632 MTO Highway 630 MTO Highway um have made a request at the time they release the quick claim to them to Northern most of the 33 ft of the Bluff Road right away adjoining the southern side uh and also with this uh resolution subject to permissive referendum authorized in

212the town board the town board and superintendent highways to release by way of a quick claim deed to the portions of the unopened area the Bluff Road rway amza which is not utilized or necessary for the use of the Town Highway known as The Bluff Road adjacent to 22 Bluff Road 28 Bluff Road and 630 Bluff uh M Highway and uh the record owners there on named Elizabeth Hamilton at uh Charles and April Santa Cola and Lori McCarver and Dennis curls and Frederick and Gail Mitchell all Co call Associated to the recording the quick c da relates the coven is holding the town harmless second all in favor I I I resolution 1529 this is to authorize partial settle stipulation of settlement Dash um 117 BV LLC versus the building department at all index number

21324 and this is a uh a partial uh stipulation of settlement on a property uh located and known as 117 bayw Avenue amaganset suff County tax map number uh 384 block 1 block 3.1 consisting of 0.57 Acres zondo a residence premises uh this premises is uh situated at the Northerly Terminus of bayew Avenue on the west side of bayew Avenue the Northerly portion of the premises fronts along n nap garders Bay and is situated within Coastal erosion overlay Zone 2 Boral Zone CEO z-2 the premises are improved with a single family dwelling and Associated improvements this has been a um this is regarding uh geotextile tubes um that were placed along the property and also across the uh Road ride of the the road bayew Avenue um blocking Public Access this this has a long

214history of litigation Etc and uh this is a a partial stipulation of settlement and it relates to having uh one of the benefits would be to have the geotextile cubes removed uh from the public access area of the road right away uh it's a very long resolution uh the resolved is that the um Town board hereby authorizes the partial settlement of the forgoing manner to the terms above and the execution of a partial stipulation of settlement by the supervisor subject to review and approval of the Town attorney second all in favor I I resolution uh 1530 is to adopt local law amending article 7 of East Hampton Town code section 255 720 Architectural Review Board to appoint alternative alternate members to the Architectural Review Board and again this is the uh the major uh section

215that that is here is C Al alternate members the town board May appoint up to to two additional alternate members to serve or a memb as absent or as a conflict of interest alternate members of the architectural be board shall be appointed by resolution of the town for a term of one year second all in favor I I a resolution 1531 is to adopt local law amending article 7 of the East Hampton Town code 2558-20 terms and duties of members to appoint alternate members to the zoning board of appeals and again uh we had a public hearing as we did for the previous one on Thursday uh June 16th to consider this law and all comments to this law and this also uh gives allows us to appoint the town board to appoint up to

216two additional alternate members to serve or a member is absent or as a conflict of interest on the zoning board of appeals second all in favor and lastly I have resolution 2024 1532 and this is a stipulation of settlement in a Personnel matter second all in favor that's all the business I think we have before the board today and uh this is our last meeting of 20124 here in the monok library but we'll be back we really appreciate how welcoming and you've made it uh for us and do I have a motion to go into exe session yes I'd like to make a motion to go into executive session for cpf personnel advice of council real estate and litigation second all in favor I

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.