001e e is there rules and planning Bor we are live we are recording phone lines are opened go for it very well thank you very much good evening and welcome to the town of East Hampton planning board meeting for December 4th 2024 we have a full plate tonight um we have a public hearing on the Springs General Store application we have four matters on for uh site plan Andor subdivision review then we have a few matters in our regular meeting so uh we'll get started first with well uh uh is Lou on the uh I'm here the zoom okay we have Lou there I don't see him but I hear his and Jen unfortunately is under the weather and not with us tonight so um we're going to start with the uh public hearing uh
002the way this will work is that Lou do you have the public hearing notice Lou yes I do s okay Lou will read uh the public hearing notice into the record then we'll check with Council to see that we jurisdiction and then uh the planning department will give us a very brief overview and after that the anyone who's here in the room will have uh three minutes to uh step up to the podium and speak and then after that anyone who's on the uh Zoom uh on Via LTV will'll have three minutes to speak if after everyone who's in the room and uh on LTV once has had their opportunity to speak we'll give it another round of 3 minutes each after all that the applicant will be given the opportunity to respond uh on
003and the applicant will also be given the opportunity uh if it wants to submit our uh provide its response subsequent to tonight depending upon what the applicant hears we give them that option uh and then after the applicant speaks um the their presumably will be a motion to close the record and uh the public hearing portion will be over uh so with that um and after we do after we do the public hearing then we'll move into the uh work session which we'll uh tonight we we're doing just in case um anyone's here for anything else we're going to do the montalk shores condo sewage treatment plant followed by Glen Valley Associates that's a subdivision review then the Hampton's church and finally 54 Industrial Road waycott Self Storage following that we have a few matters
004on for our regular meeting some uh resolutions and Boards of review so with that Lou if you could kindly read into the record the public hearing notice take notice that a public hearing will be held before the East Hampton Town planning board at Town Hall 159 Pano Road eastampton on Wednesday December 4th 24 at 6:30 p.m. or as soon thereafter as this matter may be heard to consider the application of Springs General Store 2 site plan pursuant to article 6 of chapter 255 of the East Hampton Town code to convert an existing 175 ft storage shed to a wine sales location add an indoor table with four seats to an existing takeout food store maintain three outdoor picnic tables for patrons and abandon the existing kayak rental use the property is currently improved with a
0052 and a half story retail building with a second floor accessory apartment and multiple accessory structures the property contains 56,500 Square ft 12 1. 297 acres and is located on the northeasterly side of oldstone highway Springs and is situate in a neighborhood business Harbor protection overlay District zoning district and springs historic district as shown on the official zoning map of the town of eastampton and is identified on the suffi county tax map as parcel number 3- 8-2-1 subject application is classified as a type two action pursuant to the State Environmental Quality review act Seeker part 617 of the New York code of rules and regulations and chapter 128 Environmental Quality review of the town code a site plan prepared by George walber surveyor PC dated revised April 5th 2024 a site plan prepared by inter
006science dated April 4th 2024 a planning plan prepared by a planning plan prepared by inter science dated April 4 20424 a set of plans prepared by TF engineering pllc dated revised April 2nd 2024 including septic site plan and septic detail sheet a photometric plan prepared practical Arts prepared by practical Arts dated May 24th 2024 and a drainage site plan prepared by TF engineering pllc dated January 29 2024 are available for inspection at the planning board office is 300 Pano Place site 103 eastampton New York the public hearing will be held live and in person by the planning board and will be available electronically by video and teleconferencing and will be televised on local TV LTV channel 22 and available for live stream on the LTV website https www LTV V LTV h.org the public shall
007be permitted to appear in person but may also provide comments on the matter being heard by calling 351 888 6331 any person or party wishing to be heard with respect to the foregoing may do so in person or by agent or by attorney or by Callin to the live stream or by written comment addressed to the planning board 300 Pano Place suet 103 eastampton New York 11937 comments may also be submitted to the planning board by email to planning board at eastampton n.gov all comments must be received by the planning board by the date and time of the public hearing dat dated November 6 202 4 Samuel Kramer chairman thank you Lou and especially appreciate the effort and uh now you don't need to say anything else okay Nancy do we have jurisdiction yes I
008reviewed the affidavit a service in posting and it does appear that there is proper notice and you therefore have jurisdiction very good Tina would you like to give us a brief overview sure um Lou's description really covered the main elements of the site plan it's to convert an existing 170t wine um storage shed to a wine sales location add one table inside maintain existing tables outside and abandon an existing kayak rental use earlier in the application process the application had included the um an SLA liquor license for on-site consumption that element of the proposed action is no longer part of the scope of work um the zba issued a natural resources special permit uh for the proposed action in September of 2024 uh no variances were needed but several of the elements of the scope
009of work were within natural resource permit jurisdiction and several structures that were within um Wetland setback were are to be removed um the action also includes an 11,000 Samad square foot revegetation program with Native species that will help to buffer the site development from adjacent Wetlands associated with aonic Harbor thank you very good thank you okay is there anybody in the uh room tonight who wishes to make a public comment if you're you're here in response to any comments so let's you'll have your CH uh please step up to the podium uh let us have your name and address please spell your last name and I'll be keeping track on this uh device I'll I'll let you know when there's 20 seconds I'll let you know when there's 20 seconds to go so you can
010wrap up okay I my name is Scott Gilbert I live at 12 Shipyard Lane in Springs um I brought some materials which so I'm going to hand them um maybe to the planners okay I'm I'm just going to I'm going to uh stop the clock just for a moment so that you you can do that and let you know that you'll need to submit what you have to the planning depart uh planning board uh office uh electronically is that uh something all right if you can do when might you be able to do that do it tonight I mean I'm here with my wife by the magic of computer sun and also my attorney Martha rker who's given me some advice on this and she's helped me put this together although they are photographs that
011I've taken all right well you don't have to do it right now this moment but by tomorrow uh we'll we we're going to accept these because they are being submitted at the public hearing um and and leave will be given to get it in electronically by tomorrow okay good thank you thank you for the opportunity I'm going to actually I'm going to reset it and please go right ahead thank you Mr chairman um my family and I have lived here in springs for 20 years actually a bit more than that in the same house on Shipyard Lane which is around the corner from the General Store um the H the General Store is a hugely important asset to the community I'm not going to spend a lot of time on that because of the time
012limit but it's of great historic value uh it is the sentimental heart of Springs and it's in a very sensitive Place uh AB buding a nature preserve across the water from uh apolla ker house uh and it it coexists with Residential Properties on Harbor Lane on oldstone highway on School Street and around the corner on Shipyard Lane how it is developed and how it is operated is very important to people in Springs and affects Neighbors in significant ways I'm here to oppose the plan as presented to the board um first the discontinuance of the kayak use in exchange for introducing an organic wine store is a net loss to the community now I recognize that you may not have the authority to prevent that loss but it's not a good thing um it was a
013place where parents and children could go and grab a kayak at a place where they could launch it and have facilities available to them for food and otherwise and now that's gone that's a significant loss and I think the counterveiling benefit of getting organic wine is really not a compensation given that we have two liquor stores within two two uh miles of the place and we're too and this this this wine store is being placed in close proximity to a school and a church it it is nonsensical and in my opinion has been the reason why this whole process has been delayed so much I applaud you for sticking to your guns recognizing the community opposition to the on-site consumption consumption of alcohol and the question is how will that commitment be enforced and I
014think the town should demonstrate how it's going to do that uh I don't think the store is going to have the resources or the incentive to enforce that and I think the town is going to be strapped as well secondly I I think the the parking plan is likely to create uh safety and and congestion problems in the community I was unable to understand the plan the legend indicates 13 places are being provided I could only find 10 on the survey that was part of the uh the materials where are the other three spaces and at any at any rate the they're not enough um the the the regime here would require parallel parking along the edge of the parking lot near the street which is a change from the existing usage 20 seconds and'll
015come back to you if you want i' would like you to come back to me because I've waited two years or so to have a few words on this and I've put some effort I'm going to direct your attention to the photos which I've provided the first one shows the General Store on a Saturday morning in July now that's going to wrap up okay um the plan does not actually address the realities of the parking situation there are about 20 cars in this picture and the other photographs in this show the congestion from the Springs Presbyterian Church that has a food a food um Pantry uh and also the proximity of a children pedestrian Crossing sidewalk to the proposed single exit to the parking lot that's dangerous and you should require a traffic study and
016really think about how this parking plan is going to work because to me it seems like an invitation to chaos and danger for the community okay like I say we're going to go through see if any else has anything to say and then we'll come back to you all right does anybody else in the room wish to speak uh on the application please step up to the podium we'll need your name address and please spell your last name yes uh good evening Mr chairman my name is Martha reer REI cert I'm an attorney with tum leam Shay Kelly d in cordaro I represent Mr Gilbert and his family and to pick up from where Mr Gilbert stopped I think that in reviewing the plans we wanted to really sort of look at the parking plan
017the layout the traffic impacts those are of Paramount concern in terms of this is a you know a heavily trafficked road we have the intersection of school street right at the general store and the parking plan that's been laid out really reduces the number of parking spots that are sort of haphazardly already there in terms of historic use um and I think that aside from the fact that it appears to be missing three spots um the change in the traffic circulation pattern within the parking lot uh and the one-way entrances I think don't speak to the reality of the school drop off line that you see on a daily basis in the morning and the afternoon the Springs food pantry line The Pedestrian crosswalks and so one of the things that we would like the
018board or the applicant to address is really sort of a careful close look at the safety concerns the reality of traffic circulation I understand it's a tight spot but we think that the parking plan could be improved upon and we would like to have that addressed um in terms of of moving forward with the site plan um and that's really the the sum and substance of our comments at this point very well okay thank you okay is there anyone else in the room who wishes to speak uh with respect to the application please step [Music] up hi hello I'm Andrew Burke uh BKE uh I live at 84 Spring close highway right over here okay uh this is my very first time here hello everyone um I'm new I've lived here for two years um
019I'm originally from Wyer Bay just trying to give context and what I kind of want to say here um being here for the two years that I've been here I've made a lot of very gradual efforts to be become a part of your community because I want to be here for a very long time um in this short time of two years I've only met a handful of people um that I've gotten somewhat close to and one of them is Daniel Bennett uh who has kind of let me know about this plan and what has gone on um I beside the technical aspects of worrying about uh parking and everything else I I think these are all valid concerns they sound like they are um I think what I just want to say from a
020a character reference uh for Dan is I think a lot of what we are worried about with this idea is what may end up happening um this guy that is trying to do this is sitting in this room with you is a member of the community I I don't think he's really um I would never consider him an outsider I wouldn't consider him to be malicious in any way with any plans he's trying to move forward um and just as I'm putting my own character reference on the line of the people who I've gotten to know in Ni Hampton over the past two years I trust his word when he says he's going to do what he can to make right by his neighbors and other members of the community um I put my you
021trust in him and everything he's done and personally I would like to see this store open and uh we can do what we can to get it going that's all thank you very much thanks guys is there anybody else who wishes to speak on the application please step right up we'll need your name and address and please spell your last name I am Sam yabc my last name is spelled y a r a b as in boy e k I grew up um in amaganset I'm from here I went to a variety of schools here I lived for many years and Summers um with uh the Coleman who uh are Dan's mom and her partner Jeff in Springs I grew up around Springs I played basketball against Springs etc etc so I've grown up here
022for a long time currently live in Sag Harbor uh 51 Harrison Street just a character reference for Dan again he's my lifelong best friend I grew up you know I've known him since I was about five and this is a man of his word I know that um I don't know the again also don't know the specifics of this plan um forgive me for my nails my nails are painted blue because my niece painted them Thanksgiving really a fashion Choice as much as a Wonder speaking in public not having washed those off just wanted to give a character reverence for Dan he's really a spectacular guy um a man of his word a man of principle and cares about the community always has and certainly again a totally understand parking issues and concerns about what
023could come given some of the more boy less than agreeable outcomes of new business in the Hamptons uh this will not be a new surf Lodge this will not be a new um place where people are coming to you know party and whatever uh we don't want that he doesn't want that and I guess that's all I just wanted to say all right thank you very much is there anybody else in the room who wishes to make a public comment please step up thank you hello good evening your name and address Jeff Kazar 984 Springs fireplace Road do you need me to spell that last name if you would yes k u z like zebra a r a thanks very much go right ahead all right well um I've also I think you said you
024were had been here for about 20 years so about right so I also am uh somewhat of a newcomer that is i' I've been here for about 20 years or so um I come from maybe a little bit further away I come from Wyoming from a small uh Mountain Community where we actually have several buildings that are not unlike Springs General Store and uh I also I guess am sort of missing when it was open um uh it really reminded me of home there was something that it felt to me like it knit the community together um but I guess thinking about some of the concerns that I've heard uh I I just am thinking back to I think her name was Christie who was the previous lease holder and uh I think everyone loved
025going there including myself for coffee and a roll on a on a sunny Saturday morning um I I'm trying to think of of course I don't know but I'm trying to think of if there was ever any real problem with I think she sold beer uh she had not very organized parking I guess I just remember feeling very comfortable and at home and grateful for this lovely old building and the services it provided and I think it's kind of a shame that it's sitting there shuttered now for three years and um I can only second everything that I've heard about uh Daniel Bennett I I think his intentions are not too far off of my sentiment so that's what I have to say thank [Music] you is there anyone else in the room who wishes
026to have make a public comment on this application seeing none hearing none Matt do we have anyone in Q you have zero calls on the line thank you okay thank you okay if anyone who's spoken previously wishes to have an additional three minutes you're welcome to that just let us have your name again for the r Scott Gilbert thank you Shipyard Lane I I too have very many fond memories of the operation of the General Store um for all the reasons that the the gentleman pointed out my children grew up on the egg sandwich um they played in the um playhouse on the lawn um and I guess part of the the motivation here is to make sure that the change is good when change brings good things but it also has to be watched
027when it brings things that are either unintended consequences or or otherwise um one of the things that I think I'd like the applicant If he if they would to clarify tonight is you know what is the story with a parking plan I couldn't find 13 spaces on the survey um and I don't think it's enough so I think uh the the the the whole design of the parking plan is going to unleash a bit of Chaos in this area I came here tonight and there were about 35 cars lined up on oldstone Highway for the um for the food bank which is great but um someone has to think about how these uses are going to interact in the neighborhood one other thing I'd like to just get clarity on tonight perhaps the applicant can
028answer this I was shocked by the planning session I think it was November November 6 in which there was an issue about whether a SE the the new Nitro low nitrogen septic system would be installed or not and in the course of this conversation um the board was accused of criminal activity in terms of the way it's handled this matter I I was completely I saw it on YouTube it was a a video trans transcript of the hearing um and so that raises me raises concerns in my mind about the good faith of the applicants and I'd like to get clarity tonight the the natural resource special permit document seems to assume that a low nitrogen septic system would in fact be installed Mr Bennett walked that back at the last session and said it
029was contingent upon a grant and there was some question about whether there would be a grant well having put in one of those low nitrogen systems this year the the grant process worked very very smoothly we got it within a very short period of time the system has been installed and the the grant has been Prov provided so that that conversation was a month ago so in a month it would seem to me that the the natural resource department the other interested parties and the applicant uh must have gotten together and resolved that issue and I'd like to hear what the statuses of the commitment to install low nitrogen system it's an incredibly sensitive part of Springs it's it's where the creek meets the harbor and that really needs to be done thank you for
030the the opportunity to speak again very well thank you okay is there anyone else in the room who wishes to uh add anything to their previous comments okay if not we'll give the applicant the opportunity to respond to the to the comments that were made tonight or if the applicant wants additional time we can keep the record open for the purpose of the applicant giving us their responses it's up to the applicant okay but I would just ask that uh you uh limit your com well there's that but limit your comments to responding to the comments that were made at the me at this public hearing sure Michael shano from inter science research Associates on behalf the applicant uh first regarding the question about parking um Tina can you just uh zoom in uh on
031the area where the leeching structures for the uh uh new septic system are um on the survey each one of the spaces is labeled in a circle it is more clear on the inter science plan however all 13 of them uh are uh specifically labeled um there's four in the front and then there are six in the back um I'll Point yeah you me to bring the other plan up [Music] this is the one you're talking about yes yes um so if you just so that's where the other three probably are because the septic system is is on the plan 8 n and 10 the numbers do not show up very clearly however we have 13 there's the four in the front of the building right in front including the Ada space there's six in
032the back 5 6 7 8 9 and 10 and there's 11 12 and 13 in the front uh where the fence is um the uh originally the last time that this property went came before the planning board when the kayak use was added uh the board requested uh um 12 spaces that was what was on the site plan the approved site plan uh based on what we're proposing here we are adding one additional use based on our read of the code and this is what has been discussed uh so that is um why this number of spaces is specifically identified um the layout of the site was based on uh the Pres submission conference uh or whatever the I I forget what the specific term is that the town of ampton uses but when we
033met with the board um this board had some concerns about how the layout was and how uh on a busy weekend that uh there is no real organization to the parking lot um and so uh the fence that was added in the front the clear entrance and exit um and and the fact that we have delineated spaces showing that we are uh providing the required number of spaces uh is all part of the discussion that uh the applicant had with the board at that time um regarding the iwts um based on what we're proposing to do uh there is no actual increase in the based on our discussions and with the health department and our uh which we have submitted those uh records of those conversations to this board um they have indicated that it
034is not a requirement um however uh we have proposed to do so we have just made it very clear in every one of our submissions and every time that we come before this board and the other boards that it is contingent on us being able to get the grant we're just being very clear about that because it is a lot of money in order to do this it is more expensive than a standard uh residential system especially because there are grease traps that have to be updated and uh there's a very specific um way that this has to be designed uh in order to make sure that it continues to maintain the nitrogen uh reduction so it is more expensive uh so it is important that if we're going to do that that we have
035that Grant um I believe that we will likely need to renew that um uh and uh I have been having conversations with the uh natural resources department about it um and but the next time that we get a chance to really talk about that isn't until uh later this month when it reopens up again um and uh uh so um and uh but we are committed to do it as long as the money is available and I'm sure the money will be available however we still have to say that as part of what our concern is for uh on that matter um and um I just wanted to just point out that all of the uses that are existing on the site and that are proposed on the site are permitted uses um and uh
036uh and so we're not doing anything kind of Unto here um and uh I believe that at the end of the day that this uh all of the improvements that are being proposed will be not just in the in the sake of uh word improvements but it actually be improvements to the site and for the community so uh thank youing very briefly John Bennett for the applicant uh there has been absolutely no change in our position on the I system as Mike said we've always been Crystal Clear uh so Mr Gilbert must not have been listening we've always been crystal clear that it's continued upon on the continued availability of the grant um so and that's very very important the parking has been the parking that has come about as a result of this board's
037very specific comments and the staff's very specific comments we have essentially done exactly not essentially we have done everything that the board has directed us to do including trying to make it so that this isn't one large curb cut by um um putting some Stockade Fence in it but at the same time trying very much not to have any sort of suburban look and the board I has always been very appreciative it's a fine line but I think we've we we've more than uh reached it um and that's important um this is a this is a a permitted retail use um as the board is aware uh there's no special exception involved here there's no variants that are necessary to do this it's a retail use of organic wines absolutely no Spirits none whatsoever in
038a building that is the size essentially of a parking space uh and it's always been as part of the plan um and um the fact that the kayak use uh is leaving has to do with the fact that you can't have more than two uses on this property I know there was some concern about that at the beginning and the board indeed acquiesced over the last couple of years said yes you have to have a community retail Center to have more than two uses so that's that's where we are with that um um so uh these uh complaints of Mr Gilbert are what I can only call generalized local com generalized uh complaints there's there's there there's no science behind it he's not a traffic engineer there's no need for that we have done exactly
039what the board told us to do in terms of parking and I would respectfully request that you uh close the hearing so that the board can come to a determination so we don't lose yet another season I and I thank you all for your for your your your your considered uh study of this application throughout thank you thank you okay with that uh Lou I hate to impose upon you one more time but would you make a motion lell he's there he thereor I was muted Sam sorry I make a motion to close the uh hearing okay is there a second okay all those in favor of closing the public hearing I public hearing is closed thank you all for coming out we appreciate your input okay yes happy holidays to all of you okay
040we're going to now move on to the uh matters on our work session the first is going to be the mon talk Shores condo sewage treatment plant um Ed is going to be on that for the board Dan is going to cover that for the planning department and I believe I see the applicant in the front row so very well okay let's let these folks leave before uh you painted those fingernails again that's that's a story okay looks like we're good go ahead then okay all right well thank you Mr chairman and good evening planning board uh this is a um the rapid review of a Dan can you could you move the mic closer sorry not closer that work now all right um so this is a wrap review of the M talk Shores
041sewage treatment plan site plan application um as this is uh a proposal to constructed on-site Su treatment plant that will proc up to 47,000 gallons per day it will serve all res res residential units and the common facilities of the mon Shores Condominium residential mobile home park containing approximately 199 units community recreation building maintenance building offices two pools and planing courts um most recently this application was before the board for a um a was before the board for a public hearing it was held in person um and electronically by video and teleconferencing televised by LTV on October 23rd 2024 at that meeting no members of the public spoke at the hearing and no written letters have been submitted to the FI to file to date uh therefore the hearing was closed on October 23rd 2024
042so following up on the hearing there was only a um and following up on our past review there's only a few really remaining issues that we've had um were comments that we have at their previous memo most that mostly stem from the review from September 25th 2024 um the memo goes through these pretty full in detail but you know we're going to go go through them briefly tonight um the first of these comments had to do with the construction protocol uh the plan Department generally found that the original ones was developed in a manner consistent with the previous recommendations uh for the project but there were a few minor adits that we requested the applicant has since submitted this and and as requested by the planning department uh and board at the time so we
043generally found this to be acceptable the next comment from there was that there was a request for revised survey showing that the allowed existing U and proposed lot coverage and total loot coverage consistently throughout the plans the applicant has since revised their survey showing them um all three of those calculations as requested and we found this to uh be compliant with the previous requests following suit there was comments last time regarding the lighting plan you know requesting additional clarification to sure was consist with the town code and the board policies have since submitted revised photometric plan um and exterior elevation sheets to address the concerns um of the board last time uh based on our review of the photometric plan and the specifications provided we found to be consistent with the town code and board
044policies uh fixtures were fully shielded dark sky compliant um and color temperatures that met the color temperature guidance um our only comment with this really was about the elevation sheets uh we noted that there were um during the last review we did request that the uh ele the fixtures shown the elevations would be identified because this is something that's Ty required with the ARB but also required by the planning board um for their review now some of those have been identified on the plans but not all of them um as we've reviewed it so again given that this is relatively minor compared to the full side plan review process we recommended that the revised exterior elevation sheet including those names of the fixtures with the specifications as some of the fixtures currently have uh should
045be required more so as a uh final condition uh final as a condition of final approval um and the plan board should determine whether or not agree on this point as again said this is UL be something that will be required by the ARB upon their formal review of the application um the next from there the next comment we had had to do with the pl themselves during the previous review the planning board uh requested the notation of the plans indicating the approval relates only to the to his treatment plant and not to the overall storm water drainage systems on the property um be shown on the plans and I'll see been here so with the most recent submission uh the applicants have included language to reflect on this point that language is visible here
046and it's identified throughout the memo um we wanted to call the plan board's attention to this note on the surveys as we felt that this is an important item an item important enough that the board themselves should be comfortable with uh during our memo you'll see we suggested a shorter text a short of statement will be more effective and clear in perpetually perpetuity um for the record uh mainly we recommended that it just States the the plan board approval relates only to S treatment plant not to the overall storm water drainage systems on the property uh So the plan board again just discuss whether or not they agree on this point um and if the planning board agrees the plan Department recommends that the submission of a rise survey should be required as a condition
047for final approval um from there there's um a few the last part of this review really had to do with um you know potential conditions of approval for this project again the two the only issues that we're ring at this point where that small exterior elevation sheet um revision and uh comments on the survey here um provided the board agrees with the conditions that we recommended you know we found the applications ready for approval so with respect to the conditions that they're all line You'll see there are 15 outlines uh in the memo um most of these are standard and typical of the uh set plant project but there are a few unique to this project which I'll just go over again now um that goes with item four saying that a revised set of
048survey should be provided with the corrected annotation um as we just indicated about the sewage treatment plant the pro planning board approval relates only to sewage treatment plant and not to the overall storm water drainage on the property um item five a revised set of exterior elevation should be provided with the specific manufacturers label provided for each of the lighting fixtures proposed around the SE treatment plant building uh and again each fixture that be compliant with the planning board fting policy and town code is determined by the planning department um item six the applicant shall maintain the sewer treatment plant system in accordance with the sewer agency agreement which they've already indicated is recorded with sub County as part of their approval um item seven the monthly exercising of the Jor may only be conducted
049during daytime hours as described in the town code um for and finally item eight which saying the permis shall be limited to 199 residential units any attempt to expand Beyond 199 units shall require the comprehensive review and approval of the planning board um that's the remainder of my view and I'm open to any questions very good thank you for that complete report does the applicant wish to add anything yes good evening Mr chairman members of the board Richard whan from whan fer pllc on behalf of the applicant MTO Shores Condominium uh what are you guys doing up there tonight because we have five we have Lou on the um that remote tonight I'm sorry Lou is remote tonight L is remote and Jen is not present had be a little bit confused she's under the
050weather we look okay up here though right you're fine you're fine you're fine it works with five people so um tell everyone you know so uh you have by the way you have a letter you received I think to today from James Green bam date with today's date and I just want to reiterate as Mr Green bam in his letter to you that M sh wants to thank the board for the uh you know for its involvement and its comments and involvement in in making this project which is for the benefit of not only MTO Shores but for the town to go forward so do we we do appreciate the time and effort that the board has spent on this the uh the conditions set forth in uh Daniel's memo are acceptable with one exception
051and the one exception concerns the notation on the survey so the planning board when you discussed this back in uh September uh you wrote a letter to the applicant and one of the conditions of the letter was that the uh the app planning board requires a notation on the plans that indicate that the approval relates only to the sewage treatment plant and not to the overall Stone water drainage systems on the property so we came up with some language we rented by your Council Nancy Marshall and Nancy actually modified what we proposed sent it back to us and we said okay that's agreeable so the language that is discussed in Daniel's memo we that we proposed is based on conversations with your attorney and is acceptable to us and was acceptable to your attorney and
052you didn't specify anything more particular than that the issue that we have with the change that's being proposed tonight is you know in in a sense it seems like the planning department wants to relitigate this issue or at least keep alive this issue of the board's jurisic over the storm water drainage system on the property to be clear you have no jurisdiction over the storm water drainage system on the MTO Shore's property that system is legally pre-existing it's been there for decades it was there in 2015 when there was a consent order uh agreed to with the dec that mainly involved things along the Waterfront but also required that the applicant to design but not Implement a a storm water a storm water control system that would be employed sometime in the future the estimated
053cost of that project just so you know is about $2 million which is why M Shores given the investment that's involved in what's happening uh you know what we're proposing right now uh is not jumping on doing that uh I would hope that someday that that that storm water control system will be upgraded but it's not something we're going to do today and it's not something that the board is jurisdiction over so we have a problem with the removal of the language that states that you don't have jurisdiction over the storm water control system you don't that's clear your own planning department stated in its memo back on September 24th uh couple of the comments that were made at that time in fact they referred to Daniel's memo today this was item six of the
054I think it was the September 24th memo just see the date on that September 25th 2024 among other things the planning department noted that uh it appears the pipes on the property are legally existing they are and the planning department also said after internal review of the matter within the town and with the town engineer it does not appear that the town has authority to regulate the discharges from the pipes or imposed conditions on this site plan associated with the storm water system and the storm water system was also determined and the plany dep department has acknowledged that we do not require a speed permit for a DEC from the discharge that edate from the storm water system so the bottom line is we want it to be clear that you acknowledge that you don't
055have jurisdiction we don't want this issue to come up in the future and there to be ambiguity about it so that's why the language that we proposed which your Council reviewed and actually modified to what it is today is something that we would like you to keep that's our really the only issue that we have with the proposed conditions but we'd like to keep the notation on the map as as we have opposed it thanks very much thank you okay uh thanks Dan for the quick review and thanks uh Rick for your for your comments um and I want to thank you guys for you know being uh so Speedy with making the changes that you did most recently the things that Dan enumerated construction protocol lighting and so on you know we're we're just
056about there I do want to just push back a little bit on what you just said though I mean our reason for what this is my view anyway we'll see what the rest of the board thinks but the the second part of that statement seems to us we we're not looking to relitigate in this case we're not absolutely but it seems to indicate that we're setting up a precedent that we never have jurisdiction over storm water uh systems that's the way it's it feels to me and I think that's that's what we're trying to avoid so one possibility is to say that um the planning board approval relates only to the sewage treatment plan and not to storm water drainage systems on this property on this property because we do have purview in certain circumstances
057right it's not just a blanket thing we don't want to was you know put have that language on something that's then going to be you know come up to bite us later on with a with a different application from someone else so we're not looking to open this up again in this case but we do want to do something that you know creates the sense that this is about this property maybe we can c some other language that we all feel more comfortable with but St yeah no I you know we don't need to do the you know word smithing uh of the document but I agree with Ed's analysis I I'm very concerned with on a set of plans or any that issues from this board setting forth what our jurisdiction is and isn't
058that might be picked up down the road by another applicant and a completely other circumstance I think that by changing the words drainage system on the property to drainage system on this property makes it absolutely clear that we're talking about this property and that the issue is a closed issue and I think that anybody who might and I don't anticipate or understand how it would happen but anyone who might want to relitigate if you will the issue all they need to do is go on look go look at the transcript of this meeting or play the tape of this meeting and they'll see that this board is very specific about this particular issue and and it only relates to this issue but but again and I'm sure you understand that I could suggest there's another
059option for you by the way which is you can say nothing okay we made an application for the sewage Street Plant we have storm water related to the sewage treatment plan building that's as far as it goes the other stuff on the property just predate predates this application and so that's your other option is don't have a notation on there well the approval is what the approval is you I mean you're the ones who want like you it sounded like you're the ones who wanted you know to be the board had requested the notation so we then proposed it if you had no notation and simply approved what we applified for which what you're doing and you you're silent as to the issue of the storm order control system I don't think we have a
060problem with that uh planning I get a little nervous on that just because you know for older sites that are out of compliance right and not yeah consistent with current policies when they come in one of the things we look to do is to understand that and see if the situation can be improved um if if we after all the analysis we did to determine um this issue here if we said nothing I feel like it would that's where that's kind of where I mean we did you know you know as well as we do how much time we spent on this one single issue and I think that putting something on the plans that is um specific and brief and doesn't run the risk of being over and O of overstating the situation I
061think it I think it uh serves everyone's needs so if we you know again and again this this is the kind of thing that you know drives non- lawyers crazy I can certainly understand that Matt udon manager I understand what you're saying and my question is in your approval do I have to make up another 10 copies of this survey with the CH if we were to agree to make a change and then submit the change to all you guys prior to the approval or do can we put the verbiage on at the end of the project when we do our final CFO and it changes it at that point you want to save money is that the idea that's that's no joke I don't to between lawy they just agree us over and now
062all of a sudden it's changing again it's delaying it again is this going to delay the project or are we going forward and you can put it on we can add that one word that you said this property which makes sense I don't see a problem with that and we put it on at the end of the project on condition of the CFO ma can we make it on condition of approval will add the language at the end we could do that I I can do that look I don't want to see the applicant I think what the planning department is actually saying is to make the change and with that change on the survey then you're we we we're entitled to a building permit we've got one question you don't have to in other
063words you won't do another review you're not no no no we are so that you understand we're down to one qu is it one question one question one question and you get it but the one question we thought was answered a month ago when the two lawyers spoke I understand you're going to like the question yeah well presumably they like the answer okay no I I listen I I didn't mean to be GID before I was I'm joking too yeah no no we we we will I think we can without putting another question up agree that that language you can do it the last thing you do all right or easy is that Tina can we so are you are we saying you you let's answer the question first well no Tina but I just
064want to make sure I understand are we saying that we only have to change that to this and we can leave that second Clause no no no second second Clause out second Clause is out and we're changing it this okay well let me let me go across the board is Lou is that good for you I'm not sure I understand what I proposed was that we make a a condition of approval and then add it at the end yeah no we're asking about the end no we're CH we're just changing the we're changing the language of uh appears on the plans here take a look on the screen blow that up just a little we're saying we would remove word property see every word after witch systems in storm water that all goes and and
065it'll just say the planning board approval relates only to the sewage treatment plant and not to overall storm water drainage systems on this property period end of sentence yeah I'm fine with that okay good everybody body else absolutely okay what you need to know Tina okay very good in that case does anyone have any other comments yeah yeah I do go ahead L yeah I just want to say just State for the record that you know in my opinion this is a very bittersweet ending to this uh I think it this storm water treatment plant is an absolute necessity and the community has wanted this for a very long time and I'm glad that it's finally coming to fruition it's very important that this system be built however it's bittersweet because and I think the
066you know the applicant was was uh prompted to build this plant because it gave them a an added benefit of expanding in uh the the site already intensively built site on a small parcel of land on the ocean which now will allow with this with this storm water with this so treatment plant it'll allow 73 units to be expanded which is which is really not something that I'm I'm very happy about uh as far as the storm water drain AG plant system there's no benefit for them to do it and that's why they're not spending the money if there was a benefit in the way that the sewer treatment plant had a benefit for them they would have spent the $2 million but that system is equally as important as the sewer treatment plant they're
067right on the water there's there's been uh a lot of uh complaints about the of affluent that goes into the ocean from that small parcel and this is a this is a storm water drainage system that needs to be built and I you know there's a there's a consent order that was uh issued that called for them to uh draw up a plan for it and implement it and it doesn't sound like they have any any uh plans to do so so that's what I'm very uh upset about so I just wanted to put that in the record all right that is now in that is where this is the board's discussion please okay I just want no no no we we're doing the board's discussion does anyone else have anything they want to add
068at this point no okay in that case the question is is the application ready for approval Lou yes everybody else yes I yes six nothing the application is ready for approval thank you very much let we're now going to move on to the next matter and you can thank me later not all right the next matter on the plate is Glenn Valery thank you folks for coming out we appreciate it and we appreciate all that you've done on this application the next matter uh up is uh Glenn Valley Associates and this is going to be aa's Premiere woohoo all right and uh we have um Tina you covering or is it Dan covering Dan Dan all right Dan you're on and now I'm sorry the I saw somebody move to the front row you're the
069applicant very well and the folks behind you are with you not with you very well okay that case you're on thank you all right so this is a an application requesting final approval to subdivide an approximately 2475 acre lot uh having Frontage on mford Avenue wood lot Lane and old Northwest Road East hampon into two individual Lots both both of which are approximately 4,425 ft² in size uh a 26945 ft Reserve area is also proposed addition two 5 foot wide Highway easement already present on site uh the site is ownn as a residence and located within the sub County Pine band regions groundwater management zone 5 and the town's water recharge overlight district and the site is considered to be 100% uncleared of natural vegetation per the town records so in terms of issues to
070discussion um at the August 10th 2022 planning board meeting um which is the last time this reviewed the plan board agreed to a negative declaration pursu to secr in chapter 128 of the town code therefore at this time no further the secret review is required in terms of The Proposal itself and I'm just going to pull the plans up quickly so in terms of The Proposal itself there's been a slight slight changes to the um the application between the preliminary subdivision and the final subdivision uh mainly uh per the planning board's previous condition of approval um the abates have revised the subdivision to include a reserve area as we've indicated as opposed to a Scenic easement area as previously proposed um I'll show you here this was the original preliminary plan with the scenic easan
071area and then we'll go back to the current one with the reserve area um in addition to this however there's also been a slight change to um the sizes of the Lots mainly that during the previous review they were slightly unequal with one lot being larger than the other uh during the current review uh both lots are the equivalent in size uh we have indicated the specific square footage of these lots and although it looks significant this really is has to do with the reserve area being proposed as opposed to the C Ean area uh so generally this something that we found to be you know the change be Minimus and generally um acceptable however um there's be this apologies um however there is another indication with this which I'll go talk about a little
072bit further on um so going forward from here there is the preliminary um as part of their preliminary approval back from February 1st 2023 there were several conditions required for conditions of approval for final subdivision approval um I'll go through these quickly but the main point is the applicants have responded to most of these successfully uh these include you know written approval from s County Department of Health Services shall be obtained provided to this board you can see from the map here the sub county has approved this um and it is contained within the files and they have submitted it to for the files um second requirements the map should be revised to illustrate the required 25% open space allotment as reserved area rather than c g and that has already been resolved um Department
073three was that the map should be revised at final subdivision to include the title final Subdivision map of gun Val Associates LTD which has been added accordingly then the U other comment has to do with this was kind of the what was hanging at before is that the was a requirement that this was uh as part of the preliminary approval and the final approval there was a requirement for modification old file map uh technically number 284 um in order to get subdivide the existing parcel into two parcel has presented The Advocate has received Town board approval but that approval was specifically for the preliminary subdivision as previously configured so it included the lots of slightly different sizes um but does still show The Reserve area um however given that the lots have changed slightly um
074you know it's noted that both board's approvals must be consistent and therefore a new approval from the town board is requirement required so at this time this is the one condition that hasn't been met um but besides for that every other condition for the priv approval we found to be met and acceptable um going forward there was some there was a few small other things um in terms of the design of the final subdivision PL um there are specific town code requirement for how this should be designed the town engineer uh consultant engineer um has given review of the map and given several comments that said need to be uh about several revisions that are necessary in order to for filing for the county um and again as we've indicated before the proposed Vision map
075does show 5 foot wide easements uh to be dedicated to the town of East Hampton um and the map indicates the reserve area will also be dedicated town of eastampton um final subdivision approval should um if the plan board Cho it chooses to Grant it will therefore be contingent on easements and Reserve are Deeds respectively being approved as to form by the council to the planning board to record with the sub County Cork and proof of the recording will there will be required um the office of fire prevention reviewed this and found no issues no further reviews required for fire purposes um for the final subdivision um and finally uh we note that based on the town code there is ability for the planning board to wave public hearings for final subdivisions when there's no
076substantial difference between the preliminary and the final as we indicated this the real difference between these two is generally uh we found to be generally minimal um therefore we didn't find it large enough to Warrant a new public hearing um for this application something the app board should agree on and the specific language of this is included in the memo for the review um so ultimately at this time the application is complete prend revisions consistent with the town engineering consultant comments um and also the new town board youat modification um showing the Lots as presented currently for the uh at front of the planning board uh once the application is complete the plan board will need to determine if they will hold additional public hearing on this application um that's it okay thanks again for
077that one and does the applicant wish to be heard on this good evening members of the board Brian locasto with the Adam Miller group attorney for the applicant um I'm in agreement with the memo um I'm aware of the conditions I have to meet I've been back and forth um with staff about the the discrepancy to the UR map um I will offer that this map was submitted but it was pending a long time my original application was for the prior on preliminary layout out so it's um I understand the Chang need to be made and we're working on it so otherwise I appreciate everyone's effort here and look forward to getting this over the Finish Line very good thank you Daniel thank you Brian um I do need to State for the record that
078I do have a family relationship with the Adam Miller group I don't feel that that at all conflicts with uh my um opportunity and you know me being objective to this uh application uh Brian pretty much you restated what I think we're all in agreement with here that the UR application does need to be resubmitted uh for Town board approval to match the you know current current uh Maps here and you know the issues that there the the differences here are pretty discreet um I don't I don't feel that another public hearing is required on the planning board side uh so I will leave it to the fellow board members to voice their opinions on that very well thanks very much does anybody have anything they want to add on this application I agree that
079we don't need another public that be the last question do you have anything you want to add on this no no thank you Sam okay all right so we'll go through the questions and you can wait for the last one ready does the planning board find the proposed changes to the map of for the final subdivision acceptable yes yes thanks does the planning board require the applicant to revise the map consistent with Town engineering consultant comments yes yes okay thought I saw L say yes okay does the planning board agree that conditions of final subdivision approval will be required including the dedicated uh including the dedication I think that means for the highway easement and the transfer of the reserved area deed yes that's yes around and uh finally does the planning board wish to
080have a public hearing when the application is complete or or deferred that decision to that time I think we should defer we just say no say no we can say we we do not well let me I'll break it into two questions there and if we get a no on the first one we don't need to go to the second does the board wish to have a public hearing when the application is complete no no Lou no there you go thanks very much okay all right next item on the agenda is the Hampton church since I'm leave that the Miss Veil is here for the uh the other application that would leave you for that one and Tina you've got that and Ed you've got that yes all right so where's Chris where's the T
081guy he not [Music] feeling yeah so it seems oh all right Dan thanks okay good evening everyone Tina leren from the planning department this is uh Chris steer's application I'm covering it for him Chris is unfortunately not feeling well this evening and we're still going to come and present and I had to ask him to take it umed night off was dedicated about it so that's great um this is the sight plan uh site plan special permit evaluation for 69 Industrial Road in waycott the Hampton's church this site is highlighted on the screen now there's an existing uh structure as well as parking area and some staging and construction areas in the rear of the property the site plan application is submitted to expand the existing Park parking lot legalize an existing maintenance and storage
082area site three storage containers and relocate a playground area The Proposal also includes exterior lighting and a parking lot expansion the application was previously scheduled for Board review on November 6th but the application was adjourned when the applicant wasn't present and we have not changed the evaluation this is just the same evaluation we were going to to provide on that day the subject parcel is zoned commercial industrial and is approximately 1.89 acres and contains an existing Church facility it is within the suffk county Pine barens region the suffk the South Fork special groundwater protection area and groundwater management zone 5 moving on to I'm just going to bring up the site plan so you can see exactly what's proposed and I will start going through the issues in the memo um The Proposal involves oh
083the action is a type two under secra in chapter 128 of the town code that is our suggestion to you and the category we believe it fits in is listed in the memo regarding existing structures and uses that's the first um area of focus of the review this evening the site has an existing semi public facility uh as a which is a church right the church is categorized as a semi-public facility in our code a site visit on October 11th showed that there's an existing maintenance and storage area and other structures on the code that are not on the sites approved uh certificate of occupancy so I'm just going to show some of those so the maintenance of storage area that is proposed to be legalized in the application is shown here there were a
084lot of uh elements kind of present there a construction trailer uh construction materials of various sorts trucks a vehicle parked um in and around the location so we did want to ask the applicant to clarify what the existing use of that site is um and how it relates to the church use we did note that the area did not seem to be present on aerial imagery from 2015 and 2016 um I'm sorry so prior to 2015 so it was constructed during that time which involved the clearing of Woodland and the existing maintenance area is um as you can see I'm just going to skip from the Aerials to the submitted site plan uh to show that the existing um area is larger than what shown as proposed on the plan so we do just want
085to make sure we understand what exactly the applicant is proposing for that area there is also um as you can see sorry to skip around so much but I just want to show the board um the information we have there's roof structure in part of the maintenance storage area existing not clear with the fate of that is going to be and then you can see um an existing play area which is within a the fence kind of surrounded by the construction staging area um so we did have questions just about exactly what's going to um happen with all all of this and if it was shown accurately on these plans um moving on to coverage the building and lot coverage on the calculation on the plan are shown as estimates so we do just want
086to ask the applicant to make sure that all that information is accurate the site is quite close to their um limits of coverage we want to make sure that we have that information correctly um the parking lot is being expanded but at the same time the coverage on the form was proposed to be reduced so we wanted to make sure that that um was very clearly described in narrative form and and backed up with the plans regarding setbacks for the proposed configuration there's two um storage containers proposed and they are located outside the building envelope excuse me the the plan is showing the accessories setback line in a fashion that's not accurate in the CI Zone the accessory setbacks are the same as the principle except as waved by the planning board during site plan
087review um it would it's typically appropriate to find a conforming location for those structures if one is present if one is available so we do want to ask the applicant um to reconsider that regarding parking some of the details on the plan were not consistent with what the code requires and those details are listed in the memo we are um also awaiting comments from the town Consulting engineer who I'm sure will opine on this matter um the submission did note that the um Ada signage was going to be removed from the parking spaces and we did want to make sure the applicant understood that that wasn't um permissible in a scenario like this with the amount of parking that they have on site we did also want to make sure that we had a better
088understanding of the extent of the existing parking area we did not get a existing condition survey for this site and that is one of the things we're asking the applicant to work on for future um submissions so we can see the precise differences between existing conditions and proposed conditions regarding drainage and storm water control um there was small inconsistencies between the drainage calculations and the information shown on the plans and we do need to make sure that the elevations are on the drainage structures so we can ensure that they will function as um appropriate and those comments also need to be addressed um a comprehensive lighting plan that meets all the requirements of the planning board's guidelines needs to be submitted and those are um listed in the memo Architectural Review Board um Architectural Review
089board approval of changes to the facade of the building would have been constructed just looking uh would have been required I mean um we looked at some aerial uh imagery and showed a difference of what the facility looks like now as opposed to what it look like in the past and it appears to have changed without approval from the ARB which would be required um other approvals ARB approval would not only be required for the facade change but also for the changes in the overall site plan um and the new structures uh on site with the maintenance and storage area and fencing what also be within their jurisdiction and suffk County Planning Commission review is also going to be required um because it's within the pine Barons and within a mile of the airport regarding
090the necessary elements of a site plan um 2556 50 of the town code um that have have not been addressed with the current proposal current proposal materials I'll go through those quickly um and I will also just show um oh we have elevations we don't really sorry um so I'll go through those these are listed in the memo I'll go through them quickly we are missing um ground elevations for some of the structures because the site's nearly level we don't think we need a lot of the information but we do need it for the drainage um lot area and exact dimensions for the new features of the site need to be provided um and need to be confirmed as as they compare to the existing facility ities the D dimensions of the property need to
091be accurately shown as well as the the setbacks need to be accurately shown um and the plans need to determine if the mobile construction trailers and other features are going to stay or what's going to happen with those um the layout of the proposed parking areas also needs to be clarified dimensions for the um Ada accessible spaces dimensions for the driveway and navigation aisles and important um you know these comments may get altered as we understand better the use of the maintenance and storage area if there's going to be regular vehicle access we're going to make sure that uh adequate turning and drive aisles are provided for those areas um the lighting we've already said that lighting is required um existing sanitary and proposed sanitary systems those were not shown clearly on the plans but
092they should be submitted and also we would note that depending on the use of the um maintenance and storage area that could potentially alter the sanitary calculation if this is a use that is generating Wastewater flow in anyway it's not clear at this time but there was a mobile construction trailer on there it's not clear what the use of that feature is um item J again we need um topography or elevations for the drainage um natural features so we note that wooded areas were cleared from the site um to put in the maintenance and storage area and the lawn we don't really have the extent of what was altered but we would like to see on existing conditions if there is any natural vegetation left that could be preserved um with this new site plan
093in place um and item n elevations will be required for any new proposed structures but it's it's not clear if if there are any aside from the playground structure so in conclusion the applicant is being asked to clarify the project description and provide a narrative that explains the use of the maintenance and storage area including the type of use how the space is utilized materials being stored there and their purpose um the relation to the church should also be clearly understood if any and um they should confirm if it's going to be used for parking right because that really will change how we look at it in terms of of safety and navigation regarding parking and drainage the applicants being asked to clarify the pavement and drainage designs um and specify the existing parking lot
094area as well as how much they're expanding in and just clarify the coverage our calculations and that concludes my comments thanks very much I have a question for you where where is the relocated playground on this planet is that it right there yeah right here okay but isn't it I mean how far from the quote unquote old playground isn't isn't that the same area it does look pretty similar um I'll just go to it's kind of right now in the middle yeah um well actually look at the aerial it's in the middle of the now it's okay right now it's in the middle of kind of two um storage areas this this is it and it's behind def fence okay thank you yeah it's pretty close to okay the applicant like like to be heard
095good evening members of the vard my name is Marco pfel and my last name is p n a f i e l I'm the applicant for the Hampton church project and this project was submitted as a preliminary set between all the back and forth in and my bits to the to the planning department we were trying to uh propose uh the storage area that you are seeing right there and with that we are also trying to propose the driveway expansion and the relocated playground uh from the document we agree in all of the revisions that we have to make the starting from the sorry there's a an existing there's an existing survey that wasn't presented in the in the first submission so we can share that with you so you can see clearly what is
096existing right now and with that all the the proposed calculations are just an average because we just wanted to to know first what is doable and visible here the this is a nonprofit this is our church H Church a nonprofit entity so we're just trying to get the resources and all the professionals that participate in this project are not charging for their their services so we are just trying to coordinate all that uh for the coverage calculations we can uh revise all that make the pertinent uh Corrections uh the playground is just we have just moved uh a couple feet to the to the right the roof storage structure that you see all the way in the in the at the end of the property we can remove all that that was constructed just temporary
097to protect all the the the the construction material you see over there that construction material was donated from from members of the church from construction companies the the trucks that you're seeing over there those are trucks that serve the church then Alla construction as you see on the church that's is a company that H provides services at not charge to the church if the church needs menpower they are there they provide they provide a weekly maintenance to the church as needed so that's why you're going to see the the trucks in their property A Lot H the parking we were just trying to propose an Improvement just trying to expand based on the members that the church have H if that's not doable or feasible we can adjust and just maintain the the actual driveway
098H the actual driveway is not in well conditions that's why we're just trying to improve it for the wellbeing of the property and the members of the church uh the drin the drain drainage and storm water control we can make the revision with the pertinent uh professionals surveyors and Engineers for the lighting we can change the specs of the lighting uh we are we agreed that we have to go to the Architectural Review Board to present the change of the facet the facet because U that was due to a maintenance the the brick that was at the clading at that moment was licking they have to waterproof it that was the easiest and cheapest way to to cover the church and they are just waiting for the resources and donations to continue with the project
099and for the officers and PR prevention comments the ad ad signs and there's missing information we're going to maintain the signs we're going to sign everything as needed uh delighting all that all the all the the the comments and observation that you have we agree on all that we're going to include the contour line we have to coordinate this with a surveyor engineer as I said for most of the most of these H Corrections we H agree on that the church and the parts involved are whing to do all in their in their power just to make all the this compliant uh finally H we're just trying to get an advice from you or some information because this isn't clear it's not a common situation so we're just trying to know if we can keep
100those three containers and at the end at all the way at the end of the of the property H inside the fence we can we have to we know and we want to comply with all the requirements the fence the setbacks we just H those containers are just to storage uh materials and and and just general storage from the church that will be pretty much it thank you very much good thanks Tina and thank you very much for your explanation and I'm glad to to hear that you have taken in the the the things that need to be done to come into compliance um and glad to know that you've got an existing condition survey you understand what we needed in terms so the detail around parking pavement drainage all those kinds of things I
101know that you'll work with the planning department to set those things straight um I guess the question that I have is kind of in regards to what's being stored in that storage area right what what the purpose of that is I mean you've sort of said it's really someone who's in the contracting business who helps out at the church but there's a construction trailer in there there's some heavy equipment in there there's some large trucks um there's a lot of stone that's in there I mean is it being used as a storage area for that contractor is it being used for that purpose yes the construction U the construction trailer that you see in the photos that one contains a lot of landscaping equipment which is used in the church the the the trailer is
102donated temporary by the construction company so when they they are the ones who do the Landscaping snow removal outdoor maintenance all that the church needs so all the the equipment The Outdoor Equipment is in there mostly landc landscape equipment H for the other containers here with me is H Mr B Kelly who H is member of the church he can answer H all all the questions for the containers and their storage and and that will be H pretty much it I mean the the the construction compan is present all the time at the church because they give their services that not charge for them okay but yeah so but is the stone seeing there for examp from yeah if H some members are including vanala construction they donate donate these materials to the church most
103of them have been used inside the church or outside so if if we have to remove them we we can do that we we we don't agree we don't have I mean at least we just have a place or just a certain area and they can have all this material and some of them have to be covered that's what you see the the roof structure so I mean you can maintain and preserve those materials if Jo on uh someone needs them so I mean the difference here is is if it's if it's materials that are going to be used in a construction project on the church property that's one thing if if a contractor is actually using it as his storage area that's another thing no right no to what the the construction company is
104donating the materials that they hav't used in their works so they put it there for the church and the church can dispose from them so they can them the church have specific plans to use the stones that we see there in the building Redevelopment construction of the church itself do those plans exist sorry oh Kelly I'm a board member one of the board members of the church Kelly k l e y um do you need my address or um so here here's kind of what happens that people will donate things uh because you donate to nonprofits there's leftover materials some of that stuff stays uh because we may need it someday some of it goes we don't have any particular um use today for for that particular Stone but the the construction company does donate
105things and again it sort of comes and goes as as needed so I'm sorry I I mean to C area is that it I think the fundamental question here is is the church's facility being used for the construction company to essentially store the materials that the construction company uses in its business understood yeah now the primary use for this area is going to be the uh to to store and to to do the the kind of consistent Renovations there are things that do come and go I mean we're church I'm not going to say that that stone is being used for that building it's not but it is something that somebody donated hey we understand you guys are doing construction hear stuff same thing that happens with like the food pantry people give us stuff
106for the food pantry it's not necessarily stuff we use so it moves in and out what happens if it's not used for the church right so then it it moves on you know the idea the commercial sense of the we'll get it off of the property but I'm saying is what what I'm getting at is is it Warehouse is it stor area I understand the question and again as a as a board member of the church we're we're here to comply with with the town and to do the things we have to I'm certainly not here to obfuscate and and have a secret storage house for a construction company in the back of the church that doesn't do anybody any any good um so realistically no I mean are there things that are back there
107could we be better at maintaining an inventory of what's in there probably um but as we stand here today with the idea is to try to get all of this stuff cleared up with the town get it all cleared up even for the church and then figure out a plan as to how to how to operate going forward so that we're in compliance with the town all right so because to get there you may very well find that the store the uh Construction Company won't be able to keep all that stone and all that heavy equipment and all the other things that are you know hanging around there right now yeah and and some of those things have already moved on I think there was a picture of a car that in that mix that
108that car is out of there uh the storage trailer again I mean this is a project as you might imagine for a nonprofit that has had sort of fits and starts over the years that you know it started and then stopped and started and stopped um Mar had mentioned prior that you know kind of sealing the building and coming up with a with another way to keep uh the outside on the outside of the building so to speak um even that was something that started and fits and start so you know have having that um we'll call it budgetary restrictions along the way uh has kind of uh limited us on how we can do things but I mean ultimately what we'd like to have there is the storage area for the things to maintain
109the church and all the other things when the construction is finished will go on their merry way I I would just say that so I I understand that and but I do think it's really we need to kind of make it clear that if things are kind of coming in and they're not going to be used for the purposes of the the church's construction projects they do need to move along right they do need to move 100% And there are a couple pieces of heavy equipment in there right now construction and a construction trailer and a bunch of things that I think are pretty clearly not part of your plan for renovating this this so the construction trailer um I think in particular is one that I think right now we do have I think
110that is where we're keeping some of the lawn mowers and things you know for for the lawn maintenance but if if people wanted to move on then it'll Move Along okay okay did you have anything else uh no I think that's it so just to be clear one there is one final thing just to be clear about the uh three containers that you that you want to propose is there some reason why they can't be put inside the building envelope yeah we we can sorry we can move them we're just looking for advice that was the accessory I mean as those are I mean it is considered a ro structure but we were just considering as an accessory building so we I mean accessory building has to be between the setbacks of for the principal
111building so we can move them I mean we can work with the with all the the requirements we can put the wood lines we can put the laan where you want and we can keep the parking as it is we just we're just trying to make it better for all the members if some things have to go be gone the stone the the the the other I mean the other trucks we we can do that we're just looking for advice we have been preparing all these H putting some a lot of effort the engineer myself and a lot of people involv involved in this just trying to to see if where we can get the lights donate light so that's the specs that we get we can change that but it's going to it's taking
112time for us we just want to make it better and make it compliant that's all we want to know if we want to we have to remove something we we're going to do it h we just have to have a space or an area in which we can have those tree containers or at least the trailer so we can the church can save their their lovers maintenance or other materials that sometimes they're going to need inside and for the AR Architectural Review we're going to do the same thing we're going to propose H where where we want to to outside but for now the the church doesn't have I mean the the resources to complete the work all the the the most of the materials there were donated so they are just keep working as
113they have the the resources the people who can work there and mostly As you saw been all construction all the men Powers is from them so if you're going to see their trucks they they they know they they have to move it they'll do it but they just in the they just want to maintain the church at no cost that's that's that's pretty much it well we share that goal okay we want to see you get compliant and we'll all work towards that goal uh does any other any other board members have any other questions or comments that they want to raise I just had a comment about figure three of the roofed storage structure I I went back there recently and I'm not a structural engineer but that looks like it's going to fall
114down so you have a comment on that yeah um for lack of a better term I think this has become a little bit of Frankenstein's monster um and that like it started with one container and then it sort of expanded a little bit so uh I mean we have every intention on getting rid of that the overhang was only there you know as a temporary thing to keep some materials out of the weather but it's clearly it's gotten a little um long in the tooth so probably time also my daughter has donated many Girl Scout cookies to the church back there you know you don't have to refuse yourself it's probably the best use of Girl Scout cookies to donate them Bruce did you have something yeah I just had a question um and that
115the one site in the back corner that back upper corner the maintenance is that what that says maintenance what is what is your what's the goal for that area if what's the church's use for that area I mean it's it's really just a storage area for you know things that that we need for the building so the church doesn't have a shed or other structure currently what they have right now are those threee containers with their storage they're belongings so we're just trying to keep what they have until I mean if there's in a future if they can propose some kind of an accessory building in where they can store a sh their belongings probably that's what they're going to propose in the future but for now all they have is just those three containers
116and that's and you're gonna is that a fenced in area looks like it's fenced in with a it's fenced in currently yeah I mean right now there's no I mean you saw the the pictures there's no playground at all so I mean and all swing head and all that so we're just trying to keep these containers away from from the members from the kid and just try to have a nice long area but that's pretty much just to keep it separated so why do you need such a big area for three containers so a machine can get in and and probably move it when they need it move what move the containers take them out future if they want to do that I mean if if we have to make a compliant we have to
117put ones against each other we can do that I mean we're just looking for advice if we can keep those tree containers if we have to put it together we we we are able to do that we are just trying to to to maintain them if that's possible I think we're using maybe advice when guidance maybe the better word you know we're just looking for some guidance here is going to continue looking like these pictures spenc in is is your intent on still accepting so and putting it there and I think the fence is there just more more to to kind of protect both directions right we don't necessarily want children climbing into construction material and and we don't really necessarily want it walking off either so um I think in the future once the
118construction's done that you know how that would look you know we're certainly up to any so the church is still under construction well it's not necessarily we're getting ready to redo the parking lot and redo the sighting you know that those are kind of the next big things for the for the church the parking lot is in disrepair I mean it's essentially modified gravel you know at this point uh it was paved uh it's less paved than paved I think currently might be the better way to address they caned dispose them better way we're just trying trying to to to look for guidance how we we can keep the the containers where the church is going to clean it up they're going to remove what they have to remove they just want want to make
119it compliant just clean it up once the the the old the renovations and improvements are done meaning the the facade meaning the the parking area meaning the liting so they can actually remove and maybe in the future as I said so so if you look at those pictures right there that the middle one might be the better uh example you know you youd pointed out what the building looked like before it was kind of a beige-ish um color but you know some pointing issues with the brick and the and the block and some of that stuff so uh I think Marco had mentioned earlier that the fastest solution was to paint it uh to kind of seal it that way uh you know as far as the waterproofing goes that's why it went from that
120beish color to Black the intent is not to have air no friendly weight that that's that's not what I wanted to say but the building itself will not be uh black when it's all done it'll it'll probably be clad in that uh that gray material that you can kind of see on the front just seeing kind of how that looks but again ultimately we'll we'll make whatever application when that time comes you know as as appropriate is that it you have anything for now blue do you have anything yeah I mean I I just add you know I guess I'm repeating with a lot of the the board members have said I'm a little perplexed as to what exactly were the church is moving towards I I don't understand if the if the construction company
121is going to remain there what exactly are they going to store I know that right now they're storing the stones for possible Landscaping use on the church but you know long term what is that storage J and I think U you know Bruce started to question the the gentleman about this what exactly are you going to store there what does the church need that space to store once all the work that you're doing will utilize the stone and material that's being stored there now and will a construction company maintain their their trailer there in the long term how do you see this site looking long term and what exactly will you be storing in that large storage area long term well um I I I think long term it's really more of um I would
122Envision that that area would shrink I mean the construction company does do a lot of the common area maintenance for us they do do a lot of plowing of the snow the parking lot they take care of you know mowing the grass doing you know that kind of stuff that that's part of what they um that's part of the what they they donate to the church uh long term though I I don't think it's going to be looking like an industrial storage facility um certainly you know that that's why we're here you know to talk about what what what's acceptable and what's not and we're going to do what's acceptable and we're not going to do what's not but do I'm sorry do they did the construction company plow the driveway and in exchange for
123that work you allow them to park their trucks in the back so no I mean it it there's nothing there's no agreement you know that there's just a sometimes they sometimes they bring trucks there and leave them there sometimes they take them I mean again it's really they come out with the trucks that's how they operate right by truck they're construction company so you can understand where it might appear that there's a quid pro quo there yeah yeah I I understand and and we're not and I'm not trying to I'm not trying to sound evasive either you know at the same time at the end look at the end of the day you know you either have a church or you have a church and a construction company right and it sounds to me like
124you want to have a church and not a church and a construction company corre so whatever is there now at some point down the road won't be there correct and what I would suggest and board members can agree or not that you firm up your final vision and work with the planning department to make sure that you get that final Vision uh done in a way that is as you've used the word compliant with the law yeah so the only other thing I would ask is uh or raise as an issue is the playground am I correct in assuming that it hasn't been used in quite a while no no no the playground actually does get a little bit I mean there's not much much of a playground there at present uh prior prior um
125to that just being what it is now there was a whole swing set in there and there was a jungle gym and a whole running up and down ladders and all that stuff but that that um uh structure was no longer structurally sound so we got rid of that okay maybe in the prior the 2015 version I didn't walk into the playground area because you have the gate there on the fence but it doesn't look like you've got rubber padding down underneath that's no but it does have um like wood chips uh I don't know if there I don't know if that's quite state-of-the-art you know good enough it's good enough for us right a little older you know the world has changed and uh great stickball Court you know I grew up playing on
126a on on an asphalt basketball court that I would never allow when my kids were little I just want to say one final thing which really you know sort of emphasizes what what Sam just said which is that really think about the future state of this right not what do we do with all the stuff that we have temporarily here what do you really want this thing to look like in you know going forward right and that's what we should be planning toward and you should be working with the plan department on right because right now we're all struggling with this you know Stone material and big trucks and all this kind of stuff there and you understand this cannot appear to be a storage area for construction company right well more than not appear
127it just can't be right can't be that's right so I'll interject though I mean they it's a commercial Le Zone site you're allowed to use this well that's well that's to have a storage yard that would be a use that you're adding to the property it would just have to be appropriately configured and very clear how the area would be utilized so we could all plan around those parameters well that's what I meant I think there might been some confusion that's what I meant they were yeah um referencing that this was a preliminary site plan application but it was submitted as a regular site plan application so I I think maybe there was um confusion there was some confusion there We R red like the detail but if it was a preliminary you know so
128I think Sam you're right that we should probably talk to these folks a little bit offline and and help right this out a little bit straight and you know and if you know the Future Vision includes having you know a contractor there then you can have it but like I say it may have sounded a little you know sarcastic it's a church or it's a church on a construction but that really is your choice I mean if you want to have for whatever reason a construction site in this uh parcel you can do it but you got to do it the right way and again that's why we're here we try so and I forg I'm sorry I skipped over this during the review but the lawn area does seem to be proposed for the
129last area of trees that were not cleared on the property so i' really want you to think hard about that and I'm I'm sorry that I skipped that earlier but that's a good point you know um the the woods that were're in the maintenance Storia now we're we're kind of cleared without the benefit of permits and we'd want to prevent further clearing if it was um you know feasible with the plants there are beetles doing a lot of clearing at the moment yeah everywhere welcome to town worth noting that some of the trees that are there yeah know I know are hardly hard being held up by the tree okay all right anybody have anything else on this L do you have anything you want to add oh thank you no okay thanks very much
130save your voice you've got one resolution you know okay all right folks we'll look forward to seeing you again thank you okay finally now across the street across the street at 54 Industrial Road uh the um it's called 54 Industrial Road owners so I guess that's the name of the application right yeah okay again I'm um covering for Gris on the 54 Industrial Road owners um site plan special permit evaluation the site is located on dustrial road literally right across the street um from the site we were just looking at the site plan is submitted to redevelop the subject property by De demolishing the existing building and constructing a twostory self storage building with an office reception area and an unfinished basement um so this is the location I'm going to bring up the plans
131so here is the site plan access is from Industrial Road it would be a um approximately 39,00 square foot um building um in the site the planning department has reviewed this uh as a preliminary site plan application on three separate occasions and the board discussed one of those um the other two were adjourned for various reasons um the floor plans for the proposal that we're going to talk about this evening um are consistent with the ones from the second preliminary application that we reviewed and the board discussed on January um in January 2024 the site is located in the commercial industrial zoning district and is also within the suffa county groundwater protection area groundwater zone 5 and the suffa county Pine Bar um it's surrounded on all sides by CI Zone land and is adjacent
132to the East Hampton Town airport to the north as you saw we have attached some of the preliminary site plan comments that we made to this report um some of the comments that appear as I'll talk through them were made on previous applications and we do ask that when the applicants um responding that they look at not only the comments we're making tonight but those previous ones and ensure that their um next mission is responsive to the comments that have been issued by the department and the board on a few occasions um before I start going through the issues and memo since this is the first time the board has seen this in a while I'm just going to flip through some of the um plans so the board can see what's proposed so this
133is the site plan um there's a you know exterior kind of green spaces that are going to be landscaped or some natural U vegetation will be preserved the building is located um within the appropriate setbacks and there's parking um all around the exterior there is a proposed um it looks like driveway down to the basement and then there are floor plans this is the basement floor plan it's unfinished um the use of the basement's not clear that's one of the things I'll go through as we talk through the um review then the first floor plan has large uh Drive-In units and the second floor plan has smaller um conditioned uh units and here's the elevations just a you know kind of simple facade storage building you can see the slope driveway to the basement um
134so I just wanted to show those and Landscaping plan I'm kind of um some very schematic um renderings have been provided the landscape this is the lighting the landscape plan is the is also here so I will now go through the comments in the memo um we do understand that the site has been issued um violations from code enforcement which is why we do encourage the applicant to move through the site plan process as quickly as possible to um provide a that is compliant the action is unlisted pursuant to secra chapter 128 of the town code once a acceptable eaf is provided by the applicant we suggest that the planning board is the appropriate lead agency we made several comments on the eaf in the memo um regarding some of the discrepancies between lot coverage
135and some other um information on the site setting that wasn't accurately reflected in the form we received so the applicant should revise that and resubmit for our review regarding the uses and project description The Proposal is for a self storage uh a warehouse a self storage warehouse and an accessory office um that would be on the first floor the town code does not have defined use for Self Storage um but other similar proposals have been reviewed as unlisted non- Nuance industry which is provided in our code and so this type of use would be consistent um with past practice of the board in recent history we do want the applicant to provide clarification um just you know what they Envision for the storage units but especially the use of the basement um the um the
136reason I asked this is because the basement is unfinished but there is that driveway uh to the basement such a configuration is very atypical for the town um and brings up a few planning implications that weren't really explored in this submission um there's an external drive aisle that's going to need um to meet appropriate navigation and have drainage um there's also considerations about you know um navigation ventilation Etc within the basement itself so we do want the applicant to explain how they're going to utilize that area and then we can um kind of review it from there um regarding dimensional conformance the building and this is a com that was made previously the building does seem to conform to the CI um Zone dimensional regulations except that there is a height uh restriction based on
137the proximity to the airport it's located somewhere in the rear of the site um they've shown it um unclearly on previous surveys and the height of the building doesn't seem to comply based on what we're piecing together but we are asking for um the text of the easement itself as well as an accurate survey that shows the existing conditions with the location of the easen shown so we can determine whether or not um the building would be compliant but it's important to note like if the building height violates that airport easen what you're looking at may not be feasible in terms of um size and configuration regarding parking um the parking proposed is 30 spaces and because this is a use that's not listed in the code we do not have a parking requirement in
138the code for it referenced other site plans approved for similar use to um review the adequacy of the parking um the most recent one that we looked at was twin forks moving in storage which had 13 spaces for 79,000 square ft so a lot less parking for a lot more storage so what the applicant has proposed is more than um way more than that and seems to be adequate but that really is dependent on clarifications regarding this the use of the site what kind of storage is happen in the basement if any Etc um the dimensions also have to be shown for the parking and um that could be a future site plan clarification the uh navigation aisles have been shown but for the site itself but the driveway down to the uh basement does
139need to be clarified um the Fire Marshall has reviewed the site with respect to Ada requirements and found that it's not compliant and the comments from the far Marshall were attached so those will need to be addressed regarding sanitary systems as I mentioned earlier this is in groundwater zone 5 that has a 300 gallon per day per acre um estimated value like estimated value for um density flow based on the size of the building and the generally industrial use of 0.4 um flow rate for a type of building like this the proposal would exceed the suffet county standard so we would um need the applicant to explain how they're going to handle that with the health department either they would need a variance based or or they would have to have grandfathered flow it's not
140clear if either one of those cases has been examined by them so they should explain regarding um drainage and storm water control um there's a discrepancy in the amount of dry Wells that in indicated that are indicated as required and the ones that are provided so that will need to be settled in future iterations of the application and it's also important to note that this location is uh within the ms4 covered area of the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation uh the planning department recommends that the draft Swip storm water pollution prevention plan is submitted with the next um set of requirements so we can ensure that the drainage systems proposed meet all the requirements that are applicable not just local but the state requirement ments the outdoor lighting plan needs some work as
141outlined um in the in the memo that it exceeds the Kelvin guidelines that should be addressed the Landscaping plan um the necessary elements of a landscaping plan were provided we did just want to ask that there's some clarification about what existing vegetation is going to remain we we did not get an existing condition survey again and do want a um accurate survey to see what drain what areas will remain untouched and what new vegetation will be installed and as always we just if you can preserve native vegetation it's appropriate to do so we already talked about the Fire Marshall regarding necessary elements of site plans um there are several necessary elements that we are um recommending that the board require for this um and they are listed in the memo in detail the ground elevation
142for the proposed building is shown and we do want to make sure that the ground elevations and drainage elevations are all appropriate so this information should be clarified dimensions of property line set backs and dimensions between each building the property line set backs are missing for there's an existing Transformer in the front of the site so we should get that um and the applicant should also demonstrate if there's an approval for that or it needs to be legalized um with this application Transformers right there um it seems that that might be within a ea uh is it I was just going to say if it's within an easement so yep that's fine just making sure um so the location of all easements on the property does need to be shown um including the airport height
143easement um the layout of the existing and proposed parking and loading areas should be clarified in a few ways length withd to the um basement garage curb cuts um the computations for parking uh should be shown I think I'm not sure that they are okay if they are that that's fun and then drainage structures and specifications um are going to be reviewed by the town Consulting engineer so whatever um discrepancies there there may be a longer list of comments to address um there is an existing business sign and it appears to be in the right of way um so that would need to be relocated well approved by RB and then relocated to within the property line of the applicant um so that would be a compliance issue existing fencing isn't shown and um we
144just want to make sure if those are on the existing properties so there is some clarification regarding that that that could be provided in the survey um the lighting plan should be updated with the comments we made about the lighting um the existing sewage Disposal system wasn't shown and as we said we do want want to clarify the issue regarding the sanitary density um the Topography is going to be needed to the extent that we can ensure that the drainage Works uh plans to indicate what trees are going to remain for item n from item o um all of the easen should be shown other agencies to be involved suff County Department of Health Architectural Review Board Fire Marshall and suffa County Planning Commission referrals also can be required for the same reason we said
145earlier because it's the Pine Bar and the East Hampton Town airport to conclude um we'd like the applicant to clarify the proposed uses especially of the proposed basement um to ensure that whether or not it'll be considered GFA and what planning issues may arise associated with the an underground garage which is not common in the town um the applicant should provide a copy of the height restriction easement revisions to the eaf or required and we're asking the applicant to review not only this memo but the past memos to um respond to all the comments that have been made thank you thank you for that thorough report on this very big application well not the biggest but pretty big good evening board members I'm Liz Vale with the law firm of Greenberg TR we're at 2317
146montalk Highway in bridg Hampton and I'm here tonight on behalf of the applicant uh 54 Industrial Road owners LLC for the application of Wayne Scott Self Storage um thank you for your report even though Christopher wasn't here I know I appreciate you covering thank you so we could move forward tonight um as Tina stated this is a a 1.84 acre property it's 880,000 square feet where 40,000 ft of lot area is required in the commercial industrial zoning District so it's important to remember that this is a double the lot area um we are proposing a two-story self- storage building um the proposed building has a 19,826 ft footprint and will be um 39,6 54 ft with 89 storage units for self- storage use um the application complies with zoning entirely no variances are required in
147connection with this application and I am in receipt of the um December 4th memo and I just want to respond to a couple of things we do have some work to do obviously with the planning department before this board and we look forward to that um but first with respect to the basement um you know I think the report mentioned the basement like eight times um with respect to whether it would generate additional trips for traffic whether it would add to the GFA it is on the plan on page a101 sheet number a101 as an unfinished basement that's what it's proposed to be that's the proposed use of the basement um an unfinished basement not it will not be um used as a private garage it will not be used as Self Storage as part
148of the two stories above um it could be used as an unfinished basement would be used for Mechanicals or any storage of the actual property business owner of the Self Storage themselves like I would use my basement maybe but it's not going to be used in connection with the business of Self Storage it's not going to be a private garage it's not going to be um leased out as a separate entity at all so I think a lot of questions about the basement are really speculative and it's certainly well settled law that planning boards are not permitted to speculate um that applicants would break the law or deviate from proposed plans uh it's well settled more than 30 years ago was determined by the New York state court of appeals Basin versus zoning board of
149appeals of the town of Ramapo 40 New York 2 942 um they stated the standard is not the designated or potential use but the actual use because otherwise the effect would be to visit upon the present users and occupiers anticipatory punishment for future wrongdoing um so that's the standard you have to look at the actual proposed use not speculative proposed uses um so the plans do speak for themselves with respect to the basement um with respect to the eaf we are submitting a new a eaf we have the we've done the mapper the eaf mapper so we have that additional information for the planning department um with respect to traffic traffic was brought up a self- storage use is really typically very low level of tra traffic um the number of trips per day is
150typically seven cars per 100 units again we're only proposing 89 so the amount of traffic generated would be really minimal um and we can provide that information to you uh again this is going to be a self storage the building and loot coverage was questioned the subject prod pry is 880,000 sare Ft we're 40,000 s ft is required again it's double the lot area the permitted lot coverage is 75% in the commercial industrial zoning District or 60,000 ft we're proposing a loot coverage of 67.5% or 54,000 square F feet which complies with the code the permitted building coverage on site is 50% or 40,000 square fet we're proposing 19827 Square ft or 24.8% well under the permitted 50% in the code um they did mention in the planning report holding us to a little bit
151of a different standard about what's in the physically Disturbed area that's not in the definitions of building coverage or lot coverage um so I would refer you to that what's in the code in the zoning code um with respect to the flow calculations we do need to update our plans to show you that we comply with the proposed SE County um Department of Health Services flow calculations we have done the calculations um and we believe we do comply based on um there are there's I guess there's a footnote to the um sanitary code s County Health Department standards for approval of plans and construction for sewage Disposal Systems other than single family residences it's table one footnote 9 talks about public storage and the density or design flow that could be reduced if restrictive covenants
152are recorded on the parcel and that's what we're proposing to do so we'll outline that on our plans so it's very clear for the board and for the planners um to review but it's certainly our position that we comply and we will not seeking a variance from the board of appeals um at the health department with respect to the FAA um we have five letters which we put on the plan it's on c17 that there's no Hazard to air navigation from the FAA and those are for the coordinates of the four corners of the building and the actual ultimate height of the building so there's five letters of approval from the FAA for the height of the building however we are aware that on the survey which I'm not sure why I I understood that
153and as um that a survey was submitted and we'll certainly submit a full-size one I don't have that um but there are two lines on the survey which I guess it's on the first it's on the T the title page in a smaller picture yeah I mean which is hard to read so basically information the very north of the property which actually um is closer than further north you go you get closer to the runway right so there's two lines one is a building line for 20 5 ft and the other is a building line uh restriction Building height restriction of 20 ft obviously we are looking for these easements and once we have them we will review them and if we have to comply with the height of this um restriction we certainly will
154but you can see they are to the very north of the property the north corner of the property and we'll submit that for the board's review as well but as far as the FAA is concerned we do have can you I'm sorry the letters of approval you mean these lines right yes so through the property right not to the north okay well yeah but yeah yeah yeah the northern part okay yeah yeah just want to make sure I what you said yeah sure um and so we'll be updating the plans with respect to that if we have to change the height of the building we'll certainly do that um and then that's it Ada you have other things we need to address besides the height issue um we have to correct the number of dry
155Wells we have to give details about the lighting fixtures for the lighting plan the ADA compliance really all we need to do is give the sizes of the entrance and the bathroom um the parking spaces are listed as 10 by 20 on the plans the fire hydrants are shown on each plan um the Transformer obviously belongs to the electric company there's an easement um which you can see on the survey which we they should have had the benefit for I'm sorry they didn't have the benefit of the survey um and it's not our Transformer it's owned by the electric company and they maintain it um we did submit a Swip plan it's on c105 and the type of septic system will certainly be approved by the S County department of health services is and it's
156going to be a low nitrogen system as well so we have some work to do but we certainly look forward to working with the town and working with the board as we go through this process thank you very much for that you have questions for me presentation we'll discuss and come back okay okay thanks Tina for the summary thanks Liz for the explanation appreciate it um you know I'm glad to hear that you you understand what the challenges are there's still work to do as you pointed out you seem to have could handle on what the issues are Ada drainage lighting um you know all all the things that you just enumerated U making sure that the the building height is appropriate per the FAA those kinds of things um at the risk of sounding
157speculative about your basement um you know this is unusual for E stamp right I mean I I don't know of any other Self Storage that has such a that has a full unfinished basement at all let alone one that you can drive into right have slabs the ones that I know of do but I can't say that I know about all of them but it is it is unusual for sure uh and the drive-in aspect of it is also unusual and the yeah I mean you don't you don't build up 19,000 foot basement uh under a buil a structure like this you know inexpensively right so there's obviously something in mind here and I think we'd like to know a little bit more about the intended use that's a lot of storage right and if
158there's any intention to have vehicles circulate in some way in there that leads to a lot of other planning issues having to do with ventilation and those kinds of things okay but I'm just saying I think we need a little bit more information if the answer is the owner and I I'm speculating here if the answer is the owner of the building wants to use this as storage for their stuff you know that would be an answer right but I think we need to know a little bit more about you know the purpose of this basement particularly since it's Drive in I think it's like I said it's an unusual circumstance well there been a lot of representations that not what it's not going to be so you know my my question would be what
159is it you want to put it in writing yeah CNR if we have to sure so I have a very similar question back to my quiet and ask that well no no I I know it's that's one of the things we ask we're proposing this as an unfinished yeah no I mean to to my my way of thinking if you know if the applicants willing to make a covenant and restriction or whatever Council tells us is the most you know the best way to make that certain going in the future that goes a long way to to uh addressing the concerns that I I have with such a large basically underground facility that is accessible by Vehicles we would be will I'm hesitating to call it an underground garage because I don't want to do
160that but I I you know you can understand that that I think it would be I don't think we have any underground garages in town I don't think so and if you know some res necessary why do we have the driveway then so I'm sorry my question is is is very similar but a little different it why have this in the first place why have a ramp that goes down with a garage door below grade why if you're not going to use if you're going to put a car down there if you're not going to use that space for anything why have that you're not using it in connection with the actual Self Storage business doesn't mean it can't be used by the owner of that business to store their own items right so it
161doesn't their own what their own items like not not for professional yeah not profit but for their own like you would use any unfinished basement space I mean it's it's very typical actually I'm you know well it's a little less typical in a commercial situation right I mean it's I don't know about that I mean I you're building a new building right you want to be be able to use it well the the only point I would make on that is that it probably is the only underground garage underground storage facility of that size certainly of that size and accessible by a car and accessible by a vehicle I think you you have an issue with the access to it butang space and it's not a staircase you know it makes it easier to use
162it for other things but again and you know I don't want to monopolize on this but I think a CNR a covenant restriction could do it could you know just takes takes the issue away yeah there's there's no potential car storage or circulation or anything like that proposed so we' be happy to do that shortcut it yep a lot of the problems or issues okay okay anybody else with any comments at this point I mean look you've got a lot of work cut out and I'm glad to hear the yes we'll do it as much as we're hearing so good but before before we go to our three questions y um but I do want to make one final comment and that is you know I think you know CNR could really be helpful in
163this situation but you know you typically those are about what you're not going to do right and I think I personally would like to have a little bit more of a narrative about what the intention is you know a little bit beyond well you know maybe the owner the building wants to throw stuff down there I'd like a little bit more sure we can do that a narrative L Lou do you have anything you want to add on this one I I have a question so I'm glad to hear what Miss Veil said about the septic system and the capacity of it that in making the application towards the to the uh suff count Health Department uh there's a provision that allows uh a different flow rate for a storage building correct yes it's well
164right so I'm glad right which makes sense because if you have three employees using the bathrooms it's not going to create very much flow right um but my question is this and maybe I'm addressing it to Tina if she knows the answer so if if this company goes out of business or this business is not a viable one and they decide to turn this building into a different type of sorry how would that affect the sanitary the size of the building if they decide to make it an office building let's say what would happen with the with the capacity that they put in that was addressed adere you know it was directed towards a uh storage system how would that change what would happen in that case yeah I mean and and everybody everybody wants
165to answer your question Lou everybody is ready they don't want me to um I mean it's a few different things they would need to get approvals if they're changing to a different use um from the town if it triggered site plan I mean there's possibility that if it didn't trigger site plan they wouldn't need to come to the site plan you know my thinking they would need to get an approval from the suff county department of health services for any Amendment like it would not be appropriate for any other use except for the storage you know the the tell me when I go off the rails on this there is no use as a the town code does not contain Mini Storage self-service storage as a category anywhere and in the six years that I
166have been privileged to be the chairman of this board I think I've had six Mini Storage applications and each time I say the same thing we're building the airplane while we fly it because while we have developed certain I don't want to call them standards or uh uh doctrines But ultimately we you know we we kind of know what we want to do not want to do but what we need to do and usually it involves parking is the is this you know a major issue we we have to we don't have a standard we don't have a town a town uh created uh standard that from the code that we look at in the case of a self storage unit so each time we have to kind of say okay is this right you're
167shaking your head in agreement well my my my position is that you have many standards you have all your site plan standards yeah no no yes we do but we have to Cobble them together every time we get a a self storage or Mini Storage whatever the phrase of the art is and this is one of them and so we have to that's why there's so many issues that have to be addressed because you know we're not just check check check check check we got to check oh okay we can do that check we can do that too so anyway and think Lou the answer to your question is so once we go through that exercise of creating a self storage here or allowing a self storage to be created here for this space to
168be anything else it's going to have to go like Tina said through recite plan all over again if it's not going to be this so that was a very long-winded way of saying don't worry about it um all right so Lou did do you have anything else seriously all King aside no that's it Sam thank you okay anybody else have any comments questions issues all right we we'll do the questions and then we'll uh let you go all right the first one is does the planning board require additional clarification regarding the proposed use specifically of the basement to facilitate a consensus on whether the proposal is appropriate and that yes anyone disagree with that no do not disagree all right does do the planning board agree the planning Department's assessment of additional information that must
169be provided per town code 25-65 uh the necessary Elements which Tina went through yes agree on that yeah Lou yes and finally should the applicant uh respond to comments issued at the last planning board discussion including but not limited to involving reducing the size minim uh the size I think the word of is missing of the building minimizing impervious surfaces and clarifying the uses and I think kind have done that we kind of I think we I think we're beyond that at this point anybody disagree with that assessment size building size Building height height yeah well okay yes well yeah and height is also going to be a function of the FAA uh you know making sure that you comply with a higher authority on that so we haven't talked about impervious surfaces you know
170we have't right we have in previous reviews we didn't repeat every comment um some we did because we wanted to emphasize those but I you know we would just ask because we've reviewed very similar plans at the same times if the applicants go through and make sure they're addressing everything because if they don't now the um they'll probably come up again and when we did talk about this last time we were talking about the mass of the building is you know quite large but again you know to Liz's point it's it's permissible in you know so and it's a large lot it's double large yeah and it doesn't require any variances yeah now we heard you put right right in the lead so they just fine okay is anybody else have anything no okay then
171got your work cut out for you thank you thank you so much board members I hope you have a nice holiday season you do the same thank you okay we're going to move into our uh regular meeting and um a we've got the Silvan realy modification resolution yes um in the matter of the application of silven realy LLC site plan special permit uh sub County tax map number 3000-1 60-49 um I have read the resolution and I make a motion to approve it all in approval I say is there a second yeah I'll second I got a second all those in favor I any opposed pass Six nothing blue you got the last one yeah Rush Meers parking lot resurfacing oh I'm sorry I don't have that one don't have it this is new oh
172hold on came on today no no no no ancient I I have it here if you don't have it l I'll take care of it hold on thank you very much okay in the matter of the uh application of Rush Mar's parking lot Reser ing site plan sou County tax map 300- 27-4 d27 um the extension uh the planning board uh extends the time within which the applicant um must comply with the conditions of the board's resolution retroactively in oneye increments to obtain a c a certificate of occupancy or until May 15 2025 I move for the approval of this extension of time is there a second I'll second all those in favor any opposed past past six nothing uh finally since I just undid my very neat stack here we go we have three
173boards of review the first is uh in the at the request of pis Des desus I apologize for Ming your name I like how close I think uh at 42 Surfside Avenue in mon talk up County tax map 35144 [Applause] um the work to be done is um to install asphalt top course pavement along South Etna Avenue to a width of 20 ft starting at the intersection of montalk Highway and continuing South and West for a distance of 536 linear feet with a minimum of 1 and A2 in New York state type 6f asphalt as directed by the town engineer and uh the bond on that the undertaking as you say on that is $155,000 I've reviewed the board of review and and move for its adoption is there a second all those in favor
174I I thank you any oppos pass Six nothing uh next is a request of Michael Pierce for a building permit at 17 Atwell Street in East Hampton um including portions of Morell Street and uh sou County tax map is 300-1 123 D4 d3.5 the work to be performed on that is prepare stabilize and fine grade the subbase to a width I'm sorry this is along Harbor View Avenue prepare stabilize and fine grade the subbase to a width of 26 ft uh starting at the edge of the existing asphalt Pavement in the vicinity of urban renewal parcel number eight continuing West for a distance of 193 ft as directed by the town's Consulting engineer install asphalt binder course pavement Long Harbor View to a width of 24 ft at the edge of existing asphalt Pavement in
175the vicinity of urban renewal pel 8 and continuing West for a distance of 192 ft within a minimum of 2 and2 in of New York State type 3 asphalt base uh the undertaking on this one is $14,500 I've reviewed the board of review and move for its adoption is there a second second all those in favor thank you six nothing finally the board of review of uh uh the requests of Elena Hunter 33 Hard Review Drive LLC for a building permit at 33 Harborview Drive suff County tax including portions of dado Avenue and portions of Montgomery Avenue um suff County tax map 300- 947 d1.1 work to be done on this is to install top asphalt top Course Long Harbor View Drive to a width of 24 ft uh 20 uh starting at the intersection
176of 3M Harbor Road and continuing East for a distance of 433 ft with a minimum of 1 and2 in of New York State type 6f asphal top as directed by the town's Consulting engineer the undertaking is in the sum of $14,500 I reviewed the boorder of review and move for its adoption is there a second second all those in favor passed six nothing finally I have reviewed the minutes of the board's meeting of November 20th 20124 and they appear to be accurate and I move for their adoption is there a second all those in favor I yes thank you L pass 6 nothing okay our final meeting of the year will be in two weeks and I'm afraid that we will be led by someone other than the incredibly capable and wonderful let me say
177it now because you won't be here at the end of the year thank you Tina for everything you've done under very very uh uh changing circumstances I'm looking for the right adjective so but no but thank you for everything you do you make our job much easier and you more importantly make us look good so thank you very much Tina you have a great holiday uh someone want to make a motion is there a second second gone who's gone turn on