CorpusRecord 136239

Suffern CSD BOE Live 12-17-24 Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Suffern CSD BOE Meetings
Date
2024-12-18
Location
Rockland County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
4,549 words · about 26 min
Collected
2026-06-18

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001okay thank you everyone for being here tonight uh we're going to recall to order the regular meeting of the suffer Central School District Board of Education for Tuesday December 17th 2024 May the record reflect that all board members are present and we will now uh rise for the pledge of allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for stand one nation under God indivisible liy and justice for all thank you student report good evening tah one day I'll remember that I go like super like early and like have it ready um one second sorry well I hope everybody's had a good week since I've last been here uh a couple updates from from me and from the girls basketball team we're 3 and0 currently so thank you we play

002again tomorrow against John J at John J so pretty far trip but you know we're super excited and we're excited we're also rig number five in the section as well as of right now so yeah we're doing really good right [Applause] now okay thank you guys um so yeah that's an update from um the girls team but um to continue off of that uh the boys are also undefeated and Mer sports are in full swing with both girls and boys basketball teams winning the bosow tournament last weekend the um Rich bosow Memorial Tournament both teams won so that's really exciting that hasn't happened in a very long time so it's super exciting for everybody um also a number of of clubs have been running activities this month such as uh pause for change had therapy

003dogs come in each day during youa lunch last week and students were interacting with the dogs and could also get a holiday picture with a different dog each day which was super fun I also participated I got a picture with the dog as well um also Operation Smile the club that I'm the treasurer for we had a fundraiser today we sold donuts for $2 today and we sold out in literally 20 minutes it was insane and we made so so much like a lot of profit from it so we're so excited and we're going to continue those fundraisers as well um the national our Honor Society also has been fundraising this week by running a holiday art show in which student made holiday ornaments can be purchased and I actually purchased one for my tree

004as well you know to also support nationaly and because they're super cute um we also have three more days left until break time I think we all for 11 days so while at the high school we have um spirit week going on today was dressed up as their favorite holiday and yesterday was um wear flannel and then tomorrow is wearing winter it's a whole up and then Thursday I think is um ugly sweater and then Friday is dis no Thursday's ugly swe wait Thursday's Disney day and then ugly sweater is Friday there we go got it and yeah so there's a whole lot going on spinter Sports as I said are doing super well you know we had three um we had three students um nominated for athlet the week in their own respective sport

005so yeah there's a lot going on and there's good things going on and I hope everybody enjoys their break while we're away and that's all I have for today thank you [Music] guys thank you so much all right um now we're moving on to 1.08 minutes of the regular meeting of December 3rd 2024 has everyone had an opportunity to review the minutes do I have a motion to approve the minutes thank you Mr Frasier second second Mr karna all in favor signify by saying I I anyone opposed any extenstions okay very good superintendent's comments thank you very much I have a brief brief presentation coming up in just a few moments but before we get to that and before we get to our uh guest performers here this evening I'd like to once again congratulate

006um the girls and boys basketball team on an incredible Bosco tournament uh performance just an incredible job out there per pering um and um and for some of you you may know that on on Friday even Tom Brady came to watch uh the games a little bit so it was really nice to see our girls and boys really showing what suffron Athletics is all about it's great job um a particular significance on Saturday at the Bosco tournament was the induction of uh a new group of folks uh into the suffron athletic Hall of Fame just a wonderful halftime ceremony that I was able to witness um Mr gon was was was welcoming individuals from the past uh and recognizing their great athletic accomplishment something that Sufferin Central should uh and is continually um proud of

007our former athletes and it's really nice to see um how excited folks are to step foot into suffering High School specifically the gym for some of them the first time in 30 years and just to talk about the memories they have and how much suffer Central really has meant to their lives really a beautiful moment um I also had the great pleasure last week of seeing uh two musical performances so we had our sixth grade uh Orchestra String orchestra and band and Jazz Band perform at the middle school an incredible performance uh not only did they do a great job um some of the standouts really was um hearing the sixth graders do Seven Nation Army song you know the one with the big bass cellos in the beginning just they they they rocked it

008it was amazing but we have 90 students in the string orchestra in the sixth grade the the largest class of Orchestra String orchestra playing students in recent memory um just incredible and I think a lot of that is attributed to uh our teachers the great work that they're doing with their students and whether the it's the Alumni Association or folks that have donated instruments as you know we do have a concern that not all of our students are able to afford renting or purchasing instruments and so far we've been supplying students with the instrument so that they can continue to thrive in our music program here just a wonderful concert then of course I also was able to witness uh the high school's first Winter concert again many Juniors and seniors performing in um in

009the symphony orchestra and the concert band just wonderful performances really sets the tone for the holidays so that being said we thought what better way to go ahead and bring us all into a little bit of the holiday spirit then having some of our standout vocal students in the select choir come and perform a couple of numbers for us here so in order for us to uh to enjoy that we we invited members of the select choir to be here under the direction of Miss Alice biss who is going to welcome our students up here and perform a few holiday numbers for us so thank you so much for being here [Music] that [Music] first we have de the [Music] us [Music] We Wish You a Merry Christmas wish you a Merry Christmas we wish

010you a Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year [Music] Tiding are Tiding Christmas andg good Che we until we get we until we get [Music] and and you happy we wish you a happy and a Happ we're going to take a moment I know this is a busy time of year so we're going to let the uh the student performers uh exit but I just want to thank you again what a wonderful way to set the tone for the holiday season thank you so much for coming here and sharing just the incredible talent that we have at suffron high school thank [Music] you really just an incredible Talent right it just uh seeing the smiles around the room when the students performed and you can see the joy that it brings them just uh sets

011the tone in the select choir has been out throughout our community these last couple of weeks whether it's at Rotary events other government organizations in the community uh tree lighting ceremonies they are in demand they are out there and uh really demonstrating just the incredible talent that they have and uh I thank all the teachers for being involved in their development certainly I'm going to change over to um um on a serious note to talk a little bit about our school survey that was issued probably about two weeks ago uh Miss Mermelstein and I um along with some other administrators put together this survey that we issued through thought exchange to get a sense of how folks are feeling about their child's experience in their school this year and I will be perfectly Frank the

012the main motivating factor for us to push this out there was to get a sense of the feedback from folks after now we went through this Elementary restructuring so we are a little bit over three months into the school year when the survey was issued we wanted to get a sense of how are people feeling about their elementary middle and high school experience so we had um you can see the the cross-section there from everywhere from all the elementary schools uh participating and of course the uh participation percentage as a whole of 100% is smaller for the elementary schools because there are four of them they are smaller of course and you can see the percentage of participation from parents is higher in the middle schools and of course higher at suffer high school because

013we have 1500 students there uh predominantly uh the folks that participated participated in English there were also some folks who participated in uh Spanish and Ukrainian as well one of the first questions we asked was how satisfied are you with your experience at your school so far this year and there was a a ranking of five different categories uh and you can see that we had a a significant uh group of individuals that were um that were selecting that they were satisfied or very satisfied uh you can see the top three categories we had about 90% and again this is overall for the entire district and I'm going to take in a moment and break it down to the elementary and the secondary level so we can so we can talk a little bit more

014about the details there some of the feedback that we received from folks and this is just a wordcloud just to really hone in a little bit on on what people were talking about words that were commonly used when they were asked about how the school year was going um there was some feedback verbal feedback from folks that talked about teachers are the best part of this school in my opinion um folks also talked about curriculum in community and the importance of community and how that helps accelerate uh the learning throughout our curriculum other individuals um talked about how suffering Central is like a big family um teach is playing their role in contributing to the community and they appreciate how the music department art Department are doing a great job for the students throughout the

015entire district and we just witnessed that a few moments ago let's break it down a little bit more into the elementary school survey results um and if you feel like I'm going through this a little bit too quickly this will be posted up on our website so you can dive a little bit more into some of the information that we have here so for the elementary schools um this is for the Four elementary schools you can see our satisfaction satisfaction rating is at approximately 87% the vast majority of folks um are satisfied or very satisfied with what's taking place in their Elementary School experience again a word cloud talking a little bit about some of the the major takeaways that people are experiencing with their child's Elementary School experience um couple folks really talked about

016the leadership and the teachers school is nothing without their people and I think everyone on the board would likely agree that really it's the staff that make up the richness of our schools um folks also talked about how um their children had fantastic teachers uh teachers tend to know their children uh and seem to really Target instruction to help them along we're also pleased that class sizes had stayed consistent as what we had talked about previously and that teachers show that they care for their students another several individuals raved about how the ptas are strong they're larger and that um they really feel supported by their ptas let's dive in a little bit deeper here to some of the the questions that we have so again if you are so inclined and you want to

017spend more time this will be on our website and you can look at each of the individual um questions there but again there's a ranking of uh five there everywhere from very dissatisfied to very satisfied and I'll highlight a couple of the the strongest uh performance Sher for us and also talk about some of the areas where we have a little bit of concern and some admittedly some work to do so um the most um positive feedback that we received on this particular question again for the elementary schools is that folks in general were confident that the school provides a safe and secure environment everything from security guards visitor procedures signin ID checks so on and so forth the board will know that we have placed and continue to place a heavy emphasis on school

018security we've had several uh presentations by uh Mr Pat Breen our individual who's responsible for School Safety and Security running all sorts of training for staff uh and clinical staff as well to identify students who are in need of assistance make sure that we are mitigating all threats and making sure that our students are safe and it's nice to see that from the elementary school perspective parents in general are feeling very positive about this experience one of the areas that on this question that we certainly can use a little bit more work in is that um folks have said that uh with regards to the question I'm satisfied with the extracurricular opportunities available to my student one of the reasons why we wanted to implement this Elementary School restructuring particularly bringing grades three through five

019together was to provide students with some extracurricular opportunities something that was very limited with five different elementary schools as you know we are work working on that we have our we've been working very closely with our ptas to uh roll out um grade three through five musical opportunities for students admittedly um we are learning from that experience um we have two ptas that are really grabbing this and and rolling with it um doing a great job and the board is contributing to that effort but of course as with any first year implementation there are always some things that we need to learn and get better at and we look forward to doing that sharip did you can you refresh the the back screen monitor there for a second if not I'll look on uh on

020my screen I can follow along it's all good sh don't worry about it I'll I'll go ahead and and just follow on my computer here um so we are working on that aspect with regards to uh making sure that um we roll out more curricular opportunities we've also received some feedback from folks saying that they would like some more enrichment opportunities whether that's during the course of the school day or after the school day um as well just need to see here we go okay um another set of questions you know what forgive me I'm going to go to the podium so I can see the presentation that's up there so another set of questions here you can see the first one uh where folks were overwhelmingly positive about uh the support that their student

021receives in the elementary schools for their academic success folks saying that it certainly is effective and you can see some of the other questions that are related to that as well that was one of the more uh positive responses that we received from folks and then here you can see an area where maybe we need a little bit more work on although there is positive feedback um it really came down to communication right so as the board knows we have invested heavily in doing a better job of communicating with parents but we all know that there's no way to ever communicate enough folks want in a different way and some of the feedback that we've been receiving from folks is that hey you know what like why do I have to search to find out

022what the school lunch is on next Tuesday in my school or if I want to find out um something about the code of conduct why can't I go to it immediately I do know that our website provider is working on an AI component which would allow people to just randomly type in questions and get an AI generated feedback so that's something that we're looking forward to but we know that although the response is generally positive for communication we're always looking to see how we can do a more effective job of communicating with folks so here's some of the thoughts from our elementary Community uh I'm not going to spend time and read all these contributions but this is an AI generated um feedback from thought exchange the survey mechanism that calls some of the feedback

023there to really uh provide some quotes that are trending uh if you will so you'll see some folks will say at the beginning I believe all the schools should have stronger anti-bullying programs and preventions uh programs we know that we've been investing also in our well-being program so that is something that we're working on folks have said in the elementary schools that the bilingual program has been great we are also investing in that bilingual program some of you that have children maybe at slosburg have seen a truly unique program that we've rolled out at the kindergarten that two-way dual language program you can see also there's some constructive criticism right we would like to see more Steam and stem enrichment book clubs reading incentives to motivate students um all schools should follow the same policies

024one of the things we talked about with its Elementary School restructuring is to create greater consistencies across the elementary schools and of course in our first year we're not perfect at that so that's one of the areas that we are certainly uh going to need to continue to be working on so let's shift over to some of the secondary school survey results so this will combine middle school and high school together um and we'll dive in a little bit to some of the questions that we had there you can see here uh at the secondary level folks are overwhelmingly satisfied or very satisfied with their experience at either the middle school or the high school with of course there are some people that um see some significant need for improvement here's the word cloud with

025regards to um satisfaction ratings there you can see everything from folks talking about variety of opportunities to music to uh the diversity of the school population the programming and so on and so forth we'll dive into a couple of these questions as well with regards to the satisfaction rating for the secondary schools um one of our most positive areas of feedback there is where folks have um agreed with the statement I'm satisfied with the quality of academic instruction for my students and what they're receiving that's nice to see that we're having that type of feedback um and really in on that particular slide there isn't a a section that really um sticks out as an area that we need to improve Pro on um but we do and we have received feedback from folks that

026have talked about needing a greater variety especially for students that are looking to go into careers right we've had folks that have said why does my child have to go all the way to bosis if they want to have more of a vocational experience or there are ways that we can provide that uh at the high school as well and then um some other questions that we uh dove in a little bit deeper on some points of Pride here folks that have agreed overwhelmingly with um that the fact that they're confident that the school provides a safe and secure environment that's nice to see that that trend is continuing both at the elementary level and the high school level so it's very nice to see that folks feel that way and then certainly you know

027an area where perhaps we can improve a little bit more on is um having the schools address issues related to Student Wellness effectively specifically mental health uh supports Counseling Services Etc um if you recall early in the year Miss Sarah Kar our director of school well-being presented to the board and talked about the the the struggle that we have with ensuring that all of our students feel like they belong in their school and have that connection that's an area that we continue to work on um and so the survey results here are showing that certainly there are a percentage of folks who believe that we can do a better job of um promoting student well-being thoughts from our secondary community give you a moment to take a look at some of that feedback as well

028one individual is talking about it's very positive to see teachers paying attention to their child and look uh for the best ways for him to understand subjects uh we mentioned the need for more mental health supports folks raving about the music and art programs there we have a ton of variety and opportunities for students and then of course all the way over the right you can see that there are folks that are saying like we need to offer a greater variety of electives particular particularly folks are talking about um a lack of opportunities for students in our business areas uh in our uh engineering Fields um and so on and so forth so for example we've put in that the three-year cyber security Academy people want to see more opportunities like that for students including

029a more formal opportunity for students to go and experience internships or Apprentice ships out in the field as well again bosies is a not as a nice option but it's not the best option for all students and our students could really Thrive by having some of those experiences available to them so really I I just want to to stop right there we are going to go ahead and and I'll take some questions from the board if there are any questions and again we'll have this posted on our website um but we are going to be sending a more comprehensive synopsis to families after the new year after we've been able to um dive into the feedback a little bit more but I wanted to make sure that I took this moment to share with the

030board and share with the community the fact that we have asked for feedback and we wanted to give people a little bit of a glimpse of some of the things that are working really well and also areas in need of improvement I do have to say that um I'm going to be meeting with each individual principal as well in January to talk specifically about their school buildings feedback um we all know that there are things that occur in in different buildings we really want to hone in on what makes a school special what's their point of Pride to see if we can spread that to other school buildings and also take care of some concerns that are out there from um individuals in the schools as well to continually improve those opportunities for students and

031then I hope to monitor this progress uh not only throughout the year but I expect us to send out the same type of survey next year to hopefully see that we are progressing in an even more positive trend for our students so I'm going to take 10 seconds to go back to my seat and if there are board members that have particular questions I'm happy to take those questions or certainly I can take those questions at a later time as well thank you so much um I think um it's really wonderful to demonstrate how seriously we take these surveys when we send them out and that um the respondents and the responses that we get are very valuable to us and it truly is amazing the level of detail that you can look at um

032when you dig deep into what um the survey is telling us about how people feel about the school district so thank you so much for that presentation um are there any board members that have any questions or comments okay very good this conclude superintendent's comments thank you for pointing out that detail thus concludes the superintendence report for December 17th 2024 thank you Miss Dickman okay didn't want to didn't want to step on your feet there okay um then in that case we are going to move on to uh public participation on action items only action items are on our agenda tonight on 2.01 through 2.08 is there anyone who is here to speak on an action item on our agenda okay it looks like not so we are going to close that portion of the

033meeting uh prior to asking for a consent agenda are there any board members who have any items they would like to pull okay 2.01 and did you want to pull a particular subsection or just pull the item if I mean if I can pull this ran numeral five Roman numeral five okay and that's from the professional Personnel report okay um are there any other items from any other board member no okay at this time I would ask for a motion for a consent agenda uh to approve items 2.01 through 2.08 uh with the exception of section five of 2.01 uh do I have a motion no Mr Kern second Mr Shapiro all in favor signify by saying I I I anyone opposed and any extensions okay uh I will now uh ask to call the

034matter of 2.01 section five uh do I have a motion to call that matter thank you Mr Donnelly second uh Mr Frasier all in favor of signify by saying I anyone opposed and any oh I [Music] I think there was is there anything you would like to discuss okay okay uh yeah this is just for a for exstension for a vote uh and uh okay I think I did oppos any abstentions I thank you Mr Kern okay then we are going to move on now to board member comments do any board members have any comments tonight uh if I can I I understand there was the U induction to our former students into the suffering Hall of Fame this weekend um I'd like to congratulate all the recipients well five I believe there were um

035uh it's just a great job you're on the board you'll be there for for eternity um all the best to you all and thank you for um what you've done and um I'd also like to wish everybody a great holiday season uh you know it's the best time of the year so uh hug somebody thank you any other comments no okay um well I would like to thank the choir for being here tonight as I've said before um on the board we um have to do very difficult and serious work and it really uh just is so uplifting and just the highlight of our evening when students come and perform and we love having students here even if you're just here to have your paper signed for government class um we're still happy to see

036you and hope that we're you know helping to expand your knowledge of civics and and how things work in the district um also um I had the opportunity to go to one of the Middle School concerts uh last week and it was just great and I agree with Dr Gunderson that the the music department in our district is just wonderful we're so lucky to have it that's not the case Nationwide and it's truly where you know where you're laying the groundwork for professional musicians professional performers professional singers um they get great experience starting here and just in the past few years um as Dr Gunnerson said the alumni contribution the purchased instruments the contribution of um alumni who were no longer using their instruments and gave them to the district um the enthusiasm of the

037teachers the the talent and the dedication of the students and I think we even had an Eagle Scout project last year which uh provided a repair table to the district and all these components really contribute to making these evenings a success so uh thank you so much to our students to our parents uh for bringing your students and for all of our teachers um who helped not only on stage but also wrangling the enthusiastic group of students offstage who were um just clapping and and really excited for their classmates so it was a it was a wonderful wonderful evening uh let's see do I have anything else here [Music] um no I don't think I do okay so that concludes board member comments and now we are going to move on to our second public

038participation section this is on any District related business if you are here to speak uh please keep your remarks to three minutes this is a board policy uh if you need a one minute warning please let us know please give your name and please do not uh speak about any individual District Personnel or any individual students is there anyone who is here to speak [Music] um I will like to take that minute um warning very well sir I'm sitting here before you today because I have been sorry could you just give us your name please before you start yes thank you uh my name is Emmanuel Santos D and I'm the father of a student nichos sofor High School I standing here before you today because have been repeatedly met with resistant deception and outright

039disregard by the superintendent the assistant superintendent for finance and the director of safety of Chess nor Transportation among others in this District I have asked time and time again for physical proof um to back up their claims and for the by the regulations that they keep hiding behind by the way this is a continuation from last time sorry but all I receive is silence and evasion they have no evidence no justification and yet they continue to deny my son the transportation services that is absolutely necessary for his safety let me be Crystal Clear there's a bus entering my son's complex every day to pick up a student with a 504 plan why is that child prioritized over my son why is my son disability being treated as less important what makes my son's safety Expendable

040is it because his race or is it because his religion or is it simply because those empowered whose salaries we fund have decided that teaching a lesson to a concerned father is more important than doing their job I read about the previous superintendent departure his tener was cut short in part because he alleged ually concealed parents complaints from this very board I know for a for a fact that none of you were aware of my son's situation until I F to Vil to make you aware of it now we have a new Superintendent at the same failure and the same negligence I ask you what will this board do to make sure this kind of Injustice doesn't keep happening how many more parents need to suffer because his districts refuse to follow the law sir

041that's one minute remaining and demanding that you allow me to present proof document facts not fa fabricated excuses so you can see for yourself why my son Transportation should never have been an issue in the first place the s school pupil personnel has already deemed this service essential for my son safety yet the superintendent Contin continues to block it for no reason other than stubbornness and negligence I have proposed over Solutions solution that will have resolved this easily but they all been dismissed without a Val explanation not one single solution has been offer in return you can even be even be bothered to offer Alternatives it's because of this if because of this ongoing Transportation issue my S safety is compromised in any way I will hold this board personally responsible you have the power

042to fix this you have the obligation to do so don't you dare let another par ignore another child safety put a risk and I expect you to hold a superintendent to the same standards you held the previous want to it's time to take action please wrap up your remarks it's time to take actions it's time to do what's right happy holidays enjoy your break thank you are there any other speakers this evening okay very well then we will close that portion of the meeting and go to superintendent's closing comments thank you very much I'd simply like to offer up to the board and the entire suffring Central Community just the happiest of holidays hopefully everybody can find some time to relax uh enjoy family and friends and we will be back right after the New

043Year enjoy happy holidays [Music] everyone okay thank you very much uh our next meeting is uh Tuesday January 7th 2025 uh wishing everyone a happy and healthy holiday and uh look forward to seeing everyone back here again next year um do I have a motion to adjourn the meeting thank you Mr Shapiro second thank you Mr Frasier all in favor signify by saying I I okay thank you so much everyone have a great holiday and see you next year

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.