CorpusRecord 136495

Board of Education & Budget Information Meeting - February 10, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Syosset Central School District
Date
2025-02-11
Location
Nassau County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
14,341 words · about 80 min
Collected
2026-06-18

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all thank you please take a seat okay the first first agenda item is going to uh be the presentation of the regeneran semifinalists and we are going to have Miss Heather Hall the lead research facilitator for SAS High School to introduce the two semi-finalists good um I'd like to take this opportunity to thank the board the administration teachers and Community for their continued support of our program and for taking the time tonight to recognize our students as our program continues to grow this year we entered over 41 projects into the regeneron science Talent search competition at an average of around 90 pages each that's thousands of pages and hundreds of hours of work by our students and

002our staff it is my honor and privilege to be here tonight to introduce two of our outstanding research students who were recognized by the scient talent search the STS program has been supporting High School research since 1942 the students here tonight were selected among the top 300 High School research students in the country in another year of a record-breaking number of appli to STS as well each student will present a brief summary of their project for you our first student is Michael Ren hello all right all right um hi I'm just trying to get myself adjusted here hi um again my name is Michael Ren I'm a current scasa High School senior and it is an honor to be here in front of the Board of Education and here's a little overview of what I

003did so some a brief background antibiotic resistance is currently a growing issue and it's projected to cause over 39 million deaths by 2050 and it's a huge problem because right now current methods for antibiotic screening are far too slow or costly taking up to 96 hours or nearly $5,000 to complete and this is a huge problem but I I worked into a new technology called multitop Ms which can analyze bacteria in less than 40 minutes for a mere 50 cents but the problem is that it hasn't yet been applied to antia screening so for my regener around SCS project which was in computational biology I added a machine learning we on top of mulito Ms that allowed the mulito MS analyses to be used to predict antibotic resistance and I was able to achieve high

004accuracy metrics up to 97 and this is significant because this means that in the future my technology can be adapted for Rapid cost efficient antibiotic screening thank you and our second student is Winston Z hello my name is Winston Z and uh today it's an honor to tell you a little bit about the machine learning climate science research that I did for my regeneran project so elino Southern oscillation or Eno for short is a weather event that Cycles around every 2 to 7 years with um various impacts on people across the world including tropical storms like hurricanes Milton and hen in the North Atlantic to wildfires like the ongoing ones in California so give given these risks um accurate prediction measures are vital to ensure safety of people worldwide so my study aimed to enhance

005the accuracy of predicting machine learning based Ando forecasts by designing a novel preprocessing technique that number one reduces computational stresses number two improves accuracy in forecasting both Ando phase and strength and number three holding applicability in climate phenomena outside of just Eno so to evaluate my results I compared it to a baseline machine learning model without the pre-processing techniques and you can see tangible improvements in almost all metrics including a 170% increase in hit rate and a 145% increase in success index and compared to the current state-of-the-art forecasting models uh my model achieved a up to an improved 93% correlation a 94% hit rate indicative of state-of-the-art performance and short-term forecasts as well as lot a lot more reliability in real world application thank [Applause] you I would just like to thank the board again

006and invite everyone if you would like to hear more this was our teaser reel um at our research Symposium on May 27th thank you thank you again congratulations to Michael and Winston and to their families as well for such a great project it's definitely a the uh it's it's the uh an honor for our district and then also proves that our our research program um it's doing very very wonderfully thank you okay oh sure so I'd just like to Echo Miss Chang's comments and um also note that the program has grown the number of students who are entering research quality projects has also grown uh the board thank you has invested in the science research facility at the high school and there are some expansions planned as part of the project that was approved by

007the public uh last fall and uh that will make it possible for even more students to do their research on campus uh which I think has led to uh the growth that we've experienced now because we take away some of the challenges of Transportation uh in the program so it just opens up opportunity to even more students so I'd just like to thank the board for its investment and the community for its support of this program thank you again okay and we are going to uh uh continue with our monthly meeting and it's going to be the budget information presentation and you're more than welcome to stay for the presentation uh otherwise this is a perfect time for you to make a graceful exit okay all right so uh we are going to have Dr

008rufel the associate superintendent for business services to present the budget for us quicker thank you thank you so good evening tonight's our first um budget presentation for the 2526 school year and um this will be followed by three subsequent meetings before the annual district election and budget vote on May 20th 25 and tonight we're going to the topics we're going to review are the um budget climate the current climate of the budget the governor released state aid so we'll talk a little bit about that we'll take a look at the pr preliminary tax cap and we'll look at the codes within the capital and administrative components of the budget so starting with the budget climate um over the last couple of years you've known uh we've talked about how health insurance and pension costs have

009have been um considerable and put upwards pressure on the budget and we have had some relief in terms of health insurance and this current year the um actual rates came in um under budget and the pension costs at least TRS have come down a bit but they are certainly still a factor um in the in the budget increase we are still dealing with inflationary pressures um for a school district of that impacts pretty much all of the goods and services um that we buy for our students and in our classrooms as well as our uh facilities and our operations we also um travel costs have skyrocketed and as our students do really well in competitions the costs for um for travel has increased and that just puts a lot of um pressure on the budget

010particularly when we're um subject to the the tax cap we had a fairly substantial increase in Insurance um in this year and that is projected to continue into the next year we also are concerned about Transportation costs as you know um school districts each year have the option of renewing their contracted Transportation at CPI presuming that both the district and the contractor are willing to do so and our contractor has indicated to us that um they cannot Renew at or they will not Renew at at CPI and so the district um has no other choice but to go out for um for an RFP and we have released our RFP and typically um in certain in certain environments and markets an RFP can bring competition and results in in cost savings unfortunately in the world

011of school transportation that's really not um there's not a lot of players and in the market and it is um typical when a school district goes out for a bid or or an RFP that the current provider is the only bidder and I think the situation has even gotten a little more um difficult and Consolidated as for example our current carrier that was a local carrier was um taken over by a national firm so I think there's just even less players um in the market and some of our neighbors um have had some substantial increases in their transportation um proposals when they've gone out for RFP this year and then we've been talking about um our enrollment shifts and how that's put also additional pressure um on the on the budget and again that's not

012something that's occurring in other districts and it does make it difficult um to to meet um all of under all of these other circumstances so our budget goals we need to continue to find efficiencies in order to preserve our existing programs and services for students we are going to continue to support the social and emotional well-being of our students we've made Investments over the last couple of years to increases the increase their supports to our students and we plan to continue that we plan to complement our Capital Bond work with some smaller scale facilities um projects and time our projects so that they work well um and in conjunction with our Capital Bond work and we're going to our goal is to continue to provide fiscal stability we know that having strong reserves and using

013those reserves has helped us manage both the enrollment growth it helped us during the pandemic and it also helps us in our borrowing costs um to investors who purchase our debt it helps keep our borrowing costs low so those are our goals and we'll pursue those goals under the tax cap and it is the six 15th year of the the tax cap and this is the um preliminary tax cap for us um is 2.52% and what you see up there is the office of State controller's um tax cap uh section of their website and while the board all Boards of education do not adopt budgets until April we are required to submit a preliminary number um on March 1st of both our preliminary tax cap and what our proposed Levy will be and um I

014will submit on March 1st for the district and for our proposed Levy I will put us right um at the tax cap and this chart shows our tax cap Trend and over um the years we've always been under the cap and have never EX exhausted our um our full allocation and we've been more than $1 million under the cap back in December um we discussed the recommendations uh recommended changes for foundation Aid um from the Rockefeller report that was released back in December we mentioned uh that the report emphasized the importance of taking a multi-year approach and that we would would need to see what the governor's um budget would would provide in terms of which of those recommendations they uh would be implemented so one of the recommendations that gave us um some concern

015was the move away from the one-year CPI to a more Blended rate which in times of high inflation is not going to um not going to assist districts so we're pleased that the foundation um in the foundation a in the governor's proposal they stuck to the current law CPI we also knew that they were moving the recommendation was to move away from the um free and reduced price lunch and use saip as a different um High needs indicator and that worked out well for the district because our high needs percent went from about 87 a little under eight to um about 134 so that helped us and accounted for the increase in Foundation Aid that we received which was about 4.3% so overall there were no other policy Che uh changes that impacted the expense

016based AIDS besides Foundation aid but because of our wealth factors changed slightly we became relatively more wealthy some of the aid ratios decreased and caused some small decreases in our expense based Aid like Transportation Bose Aid so overall though we're looking at a $700,000 increase in state aid or 2.8% upk we uh in in our state aid run even though it is fully Grant funded they there is a presentation of your upk and it looks like that we will receive a similar funding level at this year 1.6 7 million plus Dr wji had uh acquired a grant for the district that we received this year and it looks like we're going to get that next year so we'll have an allocation for all students um in the district that want to um take advantage of

017that um program now we're going to go into the capital section of the budget and the capital codes um account for about 14% of our budget and they include the operations the custodial staff security they also include all of the capital work um that the district performs and before I get into the specific codes I just wanted to clarify the way districts do Capital work and which are included in the budget tonight so some Capital work that is done is part of the maintenance budget they tend to be smaller scale projects then there's transfer to Capital which tend to be larger um scale projects and those those two are within this Capital section then there's the use of the capital reserve and that would be via a proposition or you can do a bond issue

018and the expenses for the bond issue like The Debt Service principal and interest would be part of this as well so in summary the draft Capital codes increased by about $425,000 or 1.3% um the increase is driven primarily by contractual salary adjustments and overtime um as relates to Capital project this increase is partially Offset you can see a little decrease in the Tans um and I want to go over just some of a couple of the variances so the first is the first first code in there is custodial operations and just to go over the format you have the first two years the first columns on the left are the budget the dollar Perc change three years of expenses actual expenditures and then your FTE so the increase in operations and maintenance was about 362

019or 3% and it's again primarily the result of contractual salary increases and an increase in anticip again it's a placeholder an increase in um um in overtime and and that impacts and cap doing Capital work impacts in two ways one we may use our in-house staff where it makes sense and where it's um financially advantageous to have them do some capital projects also when we have contractors in the building we don't leave them unattended and we have our staff um accompany them whenever they're in the building overall if you look at the utility lines um 400 um 420 fuel electric electricity and natural gas are are we're basically flat um we do have a and the we do have an escalation built in that is uh we got it from our utility providers and it's

020about 3% which is consistent with the Department of energy short-term forecasts and it's coming flat because we have a little bit of a surplus this year so when you build in the 3% um It's relatively flat our maintenance budget is up by about um 2 and a half% the maintenance budget has um equipment allocations that are in the left box as well as the contractual services that we do through this budget and they're in the right box and um I do want to emphasize that these are preliminary numbers um because we if there is a need as Staffing um meetings are just underway if there is a um need to make reductions we'll revisit these operational areas um should we need to um make reductions it would probably be likely be in the equipment area

021in contractual services in some of the projects that we have plan similar to how we've done um in previous years where our budget has been very tight breaking up projects over multi- years as a as a way to get them done so our transfer to Capital line is flat and that's the preliminary list of projects hbt tennis courts and the inclusion of two new courts we completed a lot of our classroom bathrooms in phase two and there's an allocation here for staff bathrooms um Renovations for ADA compliance there's a plan for upgrading the Sound and Lighting systems at our secondary auditoriums there's some security upgrades that are planned and then each year we do um districtwide smaller scale projects in Electrical Plumbing HVAC Paving and classroom Renovations and we also have an allocation for renovation

022of the the turf field so tax anticipation notes and Debt Service at the top are our Tans which is showing a decrease of um about 86,000 that's a a result of uh decreasing um interest rates and our bonds are relatively flat slight decrease and then we have the administration section which accounts for about 9 and 1 half 10% of the budget so in addition to costs for school level administrators and a central Administration there's costs in here for it printing mailing Professional Services like attorneys and um and insurance and printing and and mailing and our auditors so overall you see there's an increase of about 4.7% and that's compared to the current year budget and it's primarily attributable to expenses for liability insurance and then shifts in administrative Staffing and increases for increased expenditures for

023technology and software and if we want to look at specifically where those variances are there's actually a negative variance first in district meetings um that represents um this year um the budget had um two votes and next year we have one vote so you see the decrease in the expenditures for that I started to talk about um insurance we H are forecasting an 18% increase we were under budget this year and so we've included um an escalation which was um given to us by our carrier we are planning to do an RFP we're working on it now again this is a market that there are not a lot of players in and um the insurance Market currently is um experiencing higher level of claims and larger settlement of of claims Central data processing increased about

024278,000 or 10% and most of that is due to um purchases that are planned through bosis um a lot of a large component of it is software licensing for AI and and education um as well as um upgrades in our transfinder our uh Transportation routing system and some automated workflow forms are planned as well curriculum and supervision overall the two codes at the bottom increased about 280,000 or 2.78 although there was um uh movement between those those codes the first one 2010 includes expenses for the coordination of curriculum and that decreased by about 425 or 14% as a result in a shift of administrative positions from central office um to to the schools and this decrease was partially offset by again planned um increases in curriculum writing to support um AI Pilots or shifting graduation

025measures and curriculum mapping um and again the middle to high school transition and you can see the offset to some of that decrease is found Below in code 2020 which is supervision which includes the salary of principles assistant principles as well as the office staff in the building so supervision 2020 increased by about 75k or 10% again due to the shift in administrative um positions and that provides more direct supervision and support for curriculum and teaching and again they total 2.78 um in total so so March 10th next our next meeting will focus on the program section of the budget and we'll also take a look at benefits we'll go through um we'll have a better sense of our other revenue streams and our reserves which I uh will be recommending using again to offset

026some of the increases that we're going to see on the benefit side we're going to likely have updates to the codes that we presented tonight and perhaps updates to the tax cap as well okay thank you Dr for the presentation and um are there any questions from the board for Dr rufo okay um Mr greo thank you Dr Ru I feel like I thank you every year at this time because I feel like it's such a difficult year and this year is probably like like no other since I've been sitting up here so thank you um you mentioned when you were talking about the unallocated Insurance line 1910 that that includes all of our Risk insurance across the board the 19 the 1.9 million okay correct and then you also mentioned on your last slide

027updates to the tax cap and I I noticed that six of the seven year last six of seven years we've had tax caps well over 2.5 um is there something you're expecting by way of maybe changes to Pilots or changes to some of the you know that the capital tax levy exclusion that may actually kick that up a little bit in the next month the only item that I would anticipate our Pilots are in so those are unnown quantity and uh and we did have a little bit of an uptick in in Pilots um we have to make a um we have to do an adjustment to building Aid so we have a building aid number that we get from the state and then we're looking at projects and the state isn't aware May close

028by June 30th and making we make adjustments so um in the next month if there's any change and we feel like there's more projects that might close that would get added as an exclusion but that's really the only thing that would likely change thank you are there any more questions Mr asri thanks Dr rufo um the mention of overtime uh increases in the maintenance staff to can to do some of our uh smaller scale projects how much fungibility is there in the sense relative to the bond in other words if we get to a project and we say oh maybe this is better handled as part of the bond contract versus we're budgeting excess to handle some smaller contracts which maybe we initially think can be done more cheaply inhouse how much fungibility how how

029much ability do you have to scale that back the Overton I think that um as we go through there's often changes that we make in for a variety of of factors changes that we make in the um in the the timeline and in the way that we complete projects so there is certainly the possibility of of numbers changing and movement in that area I said couple quick other ones um the transportation software upgrade do we have sort of a sense of um is it that our model is outdated they've come up with a new one we're trying to solve a different problem can you give a sense of what the what the upgrade in the transportation software is designed to accomplish we have been um working with our uh Transportation contractor to um on several

030fronts one is to have um more real-time um GPS data that we have access to so there's some upgrades that need to happen um I'll call them turn by turn a variety of um more detail information that needs to be entered into the routing software to enable us to to provide more realtime um routing information and routing information that is accessible um to us um yeah I mean I'm I'm a proponent of uh trying to get ontime performance for the buses uh certainly as close to the beginning of the school year and quarter was it 250k was the allocation for transport software I think overall that was the allocation it wasn't all Transportation I don't have that specific figure how much they upgrade understood um two other uh quick questions Dr Rogers um I'm I

031was interested that the we ended up more wealthy rather than less wealthy this has to do with the adoption of the say IP or I I thought that we were going the other way it's a good question and St observation so one of the things that happens in New York state roughly a third of the children are in the New York City uh School District a single uh School District so uh a lot of what happens with school district wealth is either driven by what's happening to wealth within the boundaries of the school district District or where you are relative to New York City so with New York City being so large it essentially drives the state average a third of the state average is one school district so what's been happening over the last

032decade is uh we've been seeing uh less measurement of wealth in sosit borders but we are also seeing uh New York City was appearing relatively more wealthy relative to the rest of the state and so that made us appear relatively less wealthy compared to the average the average being driven by New York so the analogy I always use for this is if we're an island the Island's height doesn't change but if the tide goes out the the island looks taller and when the tide comes in the island looks smaller but we're the island so New York City has reversed its trend of looking progressively more wealthy and it started to look progressively less wealthy and so the the trend that benefited us over the last 10 years has reversed itself now in state aid so

033um that's one factor the other factor is this s saip calculation appears to be more favorable in so much as it captures the increase in numbers of students in poverty that we've observed over the last 10 years so um against these um measures of fiscal capacity we are looking more wealthy but that's more driven by the New York City average and in measures of actual student poverty y we are capturing more of that student poverty and just one last question I'm not sure uh where this goes but um the finance committee been having some productive conversations about insurance it may be worth revisiting them to come up with further ideas about um how we can explore other options to keep those insurance premiums from um moving as aggressively as they are against us yeah um

034we'll certainly entertain any and all suggestions I think part of what's happening in the insurance Market is um more broadly uh more claims experience um from uh acts of nature more claims experienced because of CVA cases uh more claims experienced because uh amounts of uh settlements have been larger so all of that is affecting the insurance Market more generally uh we are going out with an RFP to try and see if we can achieve some more favorable pricing and if other ideas come from the finance committee we'll certainly welcome them and I just wanted to Circle back to your question about the software um in addition to uh getting better real-time GPS data our hope is that the software product that we're acquiring will allow us to have some sort of an app-based uh access

035for parents to have a better sense of how far away their bus is so um and ultimately we want to get to uh situation where we are able to take attendance on buses so we know which so we can account for uh which individual kids are where so all of that is um wrapped up in this conversation about software so I don't uh want to under under sell the capacity of the software but that also is and and this is something that uh Beacon the new Transportation conglomerate that now owns Huntington coach uh has as part of their Suite of tools but uh it I don't want to uh undersell how complicated this process is for us to get underway okay are move Mr Vero thank you again do I know this is your busy

036season you do an excellent job of preparing the budget for us I wanted to kind of piggyback on what Jack had also said which I think I've brought this up so many times and Dr R has just elaborated on um the app um and obviously with having very little options with our transportation provider um eventually at some point do you think it's realistic that we can have that app not only to track our students and parents know where they are and what time the bus is but at some point can we use that app to kind of look at the routes where make the route more efficient so therefore we would need less buses um save fuel cost is that a possibility somewhere down the line I know I ask for this all the time

037but I think the um each year when when the routes are done there's minor in enrollment shifts and our transportation supervisor uses that routing um software to make adjustments and to to try to gain efficiencies um the tradeoff always when when we um are making changes typically they involve um uh making the route potentially longer more students on a bus makes um the route longer and so we're always up against wanting to get our children our students to the buildings on time so certainly we always um Claud is always looking for for efficiencies um in and the routing software helps with that and then the bus company also helps with that in making um suggestions and I guess I wanted to take it to the end which would be where if your child is going

038to go to band or is going to take the late bus is there any way at some point which is my dream to be able to say you know Sienna is not going to be on the bus today or Sienna is going to take this bus because I know that it's just very inefficient the buses are making the loop and the uh Dr Rogers talked about um the attendance feature the swiping on and off the bus and so that's something certainly that we're um we're considering I think what what you're saying what it sounds like what you're saying is sort like a pre uh I don't need the bus kind of thing so don't um and I guess I think that that real time given 7500 students um would be a challenge um for Huntington

039coach yeah I'll put a somewhat sharper point on uh Dr rufo's uh answers so the the trade-off with efficiency is longer routes and earlier pickup times and fewer pickup places so if a bus makes 10 stops on its route each of those stops takes 30 seconds or something it adds up uh if you make kids walk farther to the bus stop and you have fewer stops the bus can go faster um but obviously parents don't uh like having kids further from their house when they're getting picked up so that's a tension that we face and then the longer routes can fill the bus Fuller um and then you need fewer buses when the buses you have carry more students but it means that the routes will be longer so instead of a route of 15

040minutes in duration it might be a route of 25 minutes in duration and again that um that time in the morning in particular particular comes at the expense of student sleep or uh something else so we're constantly trying to um strike the right balance there um and we're certainly rerouting the software every year there is transportation software that does this routing and tries to find efficiencies and then we adjust it based on our own understanding of how traffic Flows at certain times of day here in saset which the software doesn't really doesn't know scos it the way we know scos it um so that's one of the challenges there the challenge when we've had issues where um we're momentarily unsure of where a child is uh BEC it usually comes because there was a change

041in the child's dismissal plan so we call it a dismissal plan even though it just seems like oh my kids riding a bus today but it's a dismissal plan so if someone was picked up or um told one parent that were going to do one thing but didn't tell the other parent the other parent calls us worried and so I think the first problem we're trying to solve is to have a better sense of who exactly is on the buses um I to Dr rufos point I would like to see that run for a while before we started adding a new complication which is dismissal plans that can change almost in real time and have us be accountable for the students because our our most important job is to be accountable for their whereabouts and

042their safety and uh if we make that job more complicated for ourselves even though it's a convenience for parents uh we compromise our safety and that's the one part that we're uh really reluctant to make changes until we're sure that it'll work properly thank you Dr Ruel thank you and uh we are going to um move on with our meeting and the next agenda item is the approval the approval of amend of the January 6 2025 board meeting can I have a motion Please Mr greckle seconded by Miss Levitan are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions and uh Dr ruo again can we have the treasures report and appropriation adjustments please as indicated on the treasures report the cash on hand for the month end December 2024 was 9,416 61544 it shows

043that bank balances for all cash accounts were reconciled to the book balances and were collateralized in accordance with the district's banking policy and investment policy thank you Dr rufel can I have a motion Please Mr Rolo second by Dr Park are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions okay Dr Rogers superintendent report please please sure thank you we've been alluding to this presentation for several months now um as the board is well aware uh the Board of Regents which is the Statewide body that has responsibility for education in New York state has been uh examining revision to the graduation requirements uh dating Back to Before the pandemic so their work on the updated graduation requirements uh took a pause during the pandemic but then I resumed the state is solicited lots of feedback

044uh they established a blue ribbon commission and so we sometimes talk about this as the Blue Ribbon uh commission's report and that blue ribbon commission uh thousands of hours of work and then has uh put out a report with changes in the graduation requirements so we're early days in this conversation because the state's report gives us sort of a highlevel sense of the direction that the state is going with but it's not granular enough that we would be able to have conversations about how many credits of EX and how many credits of why uh will be necessary for graduation and one of the challenges in all of this is you'll see from the presentation is as these graduation requirements are evolving um the good news is that they're moving more towards skill um than necessarily

045content acquisition so it's not just about regurgitating some facts but it's about having some skills the challenge is that skills are harder to assess than content so one of the challenges that we'll all have to work through through as a state as a district is how we assess these skills as students are held accountable for those skills in order to graduate uh but it is uh a change in direction that is similar to some of the work that we've been doing here already and in some ways a lot of our work has anticipated uh where the state is going but to get us into a little bit more detail uh Mr Steinberg will share with us uh some of the uh State Department's work okay thank you Dr Rogers and good evening to the Board

046of Education uh and to my fellow administrators here tonight and teachers and the community so um this is a great opportunity for us to start digging in a little bit to what the plan has uh the state has planned in order what they're saying to transform uh graduation uh uh requirements here in New York and so before we get going just a little bit of a historical context back in 2019 the board of regions um they established the Blue Ribbon commission the commission's basically was charged with coming up with with what these graduation requirements could look like with three basic Focus areas an area on program requirements learning experience and how we're going to measure and assess uh moving forward uh that commission went out did about 19 or 20 or so different Regional meetings

047with all stakeholders took all sorts of feedback in and it was then in 2023 November that the Blue Ribbon commission was able to present uh 12 recommendations uh to the board of education at uh sorry the board of region at the time the board of Regents then asked the state to come up with their plan and what is their Vision to transform now our graduation requirements and it was at the June 10th meeting that that presentation was presented to the Border regions as well and just on a side note these presentations that the um State Ed Department did are linked on this slide for future reference to go deeper into those presentations and most recently in November uh we now were uh we've got to see what the state's timeline is going to look like

048in terms of of what when these things are going to happen how they're going to impact the schools and how they're going to impact certain cohorts of our students so we'll take a a few minutes tonight to sort of go through uh what these uh major Transformations are and then we'll look a little bit how they that might impact us moving forward and as Dr Raj has alluded to how we're sort of already positioned uh for a lot of these changes uh sort of ahead of that game so there are four proposed Transformations by the state uh the first is to adopt a new portrait of a graduate which we'll take a look at shortly the state was going to be moving to one high school diploma currently there are three we'll talk more detail

049about that in a little bit in order to do that they're going to have to S Sunset the current diploma assessments and requirements and finally there's going to be a redefinition of credits and then the actual learning experience what the state is going to expect so we'll jump into right off the bat the porch of The Graduate um it's interesting here because this is what the state has has released they released these seven components of a graduate and when we look at the different components here they do very much align with the conversation we've been having here in scasa for quite some time um these are things that we've been talking about in terms of the horis skills that we're looking to teach our students we want our students to gain um so this should

050this should feel familiar to us um the nice thing for that the state has not yet released any definition of each one of these components they've not released any kind of Assessments to measure these just yet so this is what the state has put out there the opportunity for us though is that we sort of create Within These components and continue to do the work that we're doing moving forward so before we get into what the changes are a quick reminder of what the current model looks like so the current requirements uh from high school there's a credit requirement which requires 22 credits earned through units of study so a unit study is based on a Carnegie unit so one accredited course would be 180 uh uh uh uh excuse me 180 hours uh uh

051uh a week um sorry 108 hours over the course of the Year 180 minutes per week and that would then earn the 22 credits um there are three types of diplomas you have your Region's diploma your local diploma which both require the assessment requirement of at least four regions exams in most cases it's going to be five so there is the option currently where you could take the four and then complete what we what is called a four plus1 pathway there's seven different Pathways in which students can complete that but traditionally especially here in Sasa kids are taking the five regions exams to get that regions or local diploma and then there's the advanced designation on the regions diploma where students would take upwards of eight regions exams the other piece to notice here is

052that currently districts can add local requirements to graduation so districts might have different types of requirements some districts could have community service hours as a graduation requirement so a student currently could meet the state requirements the credit requirements the assessment requirements but if they don't meet let's say a Local's requirements like a community service requirement the district has the ability to hold back that diploma okay and what we'll see is that in the transformation what the state's proposing that last piece I was just discussing the states will not the districts will not have that ability once a student completes what the final state requirements then that then the district must confer that diploma to the student okay that's that's something that's very different so that's the one the one diploma that we're going to see

053the other big change here uh we'll notice is that the regions exams will no longer be mandatory for graduation so students will not have to take the region assessments for graduation there will be multiple Pathways for students to show their proficiency and Mastery that yet have been released but this this is where the state is talking about moving in this direction now the regions though it's important to understand that in this model they will remain on the transcript they still remain on the transcript so so in the model right now and the transcripts we have the universities and colleges will see those regions ex those region scores um and the students must take those exams they must take those exams for federal requirements that's the S requirements on the state exam so they're still mandated

054to take those exams and we we need to have them take that exam important to note in scas right now there is a no harm uh in place for our Region's exam so students take them and if the Region's exam doesn't help their final grade it won't get counted in their final grade so that's where we currently stand in this so again that proposed transformation here is the one diploma we Dr we eliminate the region as a mandatory assessment and then the district must confer the one diploma upon a student completing the state's requirement right so what does that look like so again we can add additional seals and endorsements to a diploma but we cannot mandate that so that could look like a locally developed uh endorsement here we've talked in the past about

055the scop plus program we'll bring it up in a little bit again so we can provide that as an additional seal or endorsement or we can provide the kids the skill-based micr credentials which we've talked about before which recognizes students for reaching a certain proficiency of Mastery level in a skill let's say it's Excel it could be uh Google Suites it could be be design thinking um and there's many many more of course currently in the current system there are endorsements that uh then go on to the diploma so it doesn't matter if any of the three diplomas you have whether it's the regions local or the regions with Advanced designation all students can still get the endorsement with honors they can get a Mastery in math a ma Mastery in science and a techn

056technical endorsement in the new proposed model the advanced designation is no longer a diploma type but students can earn it as an endorsement similar to the endorsements that exist right now and then of course the seals that are available for students the Seal of biliteracy and the Seal of of Civic Readiness so looking inward to where are we uh in saset we do have these things and where's the value we would add to the one high school diploma it would be in the seals we just discussed so students could pursue the seal by literacy right now we have uh upwards of about 140 students pursuing that seal uh in this current year uh seal of Civic Readiness was just launched uh this year we have uh upwards around 293 students who are who are uh

057pursuing that um and then we have our sop pathway endorsement program we we've talked in-depth about and we offer four different Pathways for the students the pre-engineering we have the accounting and finance the business management and uh and the most recent one which is the fashion marketing merchandising pathway where our students can pursue those and if you see underneath is are those skill-based micr credentials that students can earn not just by being part of a pathway but those credentials can be included in any course that we offer so when we get to that one diploma phase here these are going to be areas in which students can show their proficiency and Mastery and they're getting recognition for that it's not diploma required it's not a graduation requirement it's just another way a multiple way for

058our students to show uh what they've accomplished and and what they're able to do in addition to that we also have credited programs and internships and we have credited work-based learning programs and those programs now are currently uh uh in effect we probably have somewhere in the range of 30 to 40 students who take advantage of the internship program ranging from medical Fields business Fields um that students are doing that and a similar number of students who take place and participate in accredit accredited work-based learning and that could be anywhere from working at a local restaurant to working within our schools we have students in the work based learning program who work in our libraries our guidance centers our main offices um these are two areas too where there could be a lot of growth

059we have the Acer certificate uh on the PowerPoint to indicate that we have students working in with our it department and they're actually earning aser certification through that work-based learning program again highlighting the skills that they are acquiring and learning as they go through programs like this and this is a way they can earn their credits so just as a quick review again as we get to the new transformed model we have to Sunset out of the region so students no longer have to pass the Regents they do have to sit for the region but they will not be mandatory for graduation okay so that's what this slid just reminding us of so the next transformation is the redefining credit and learning experiences so this is where the state has not been clear as to

060exactly what that means in terms of redefining credit but redefining credit we know will include will include a financial literacy a climate education that will be part of the credits that students will have to earn for New York State graduation so that will be coming we'll see in a little bit in a timeline slide and that's scheduled to come around 2027 and the learn so when Dr Rogers alluded to this shift from sort of this knowledge economy into a skills economy and how do we how do we now assess our students on the skills the standardized testing that we use on the region exam has primarily been a knowledge-based assessment so we're going to have to get creative and leverage the programs that we already have to start shifting more towards a skill-based assessment so

061this gives you an idea of what the state thinks that might look at what what that might look like and that looks very similar to what we already have going on in our schools so this becomes a place you see the state thinks a work Base Service can be a place where this can happen um you will have the approved CTE Pathways and then credentials and seals so it's kind of shows that the work we've been doing we've been ahead of this curve and we have set up our students for Success along this this way so what might this look like so this this picture here if you look at the center of the picture here um this is looking at New York State graduates are effective communicators so effective commun indicators was one of

062our seven uh portrait of The Graduate components and this is intended the state released this to show the student on the left and the student on the right showing Proficiency in the same component but getting there through different Pathways so with the student on the left is earning a seal they're completing a Capstone project and they're completing their English composition course and that assessment showing that this student is an effective communicator on the right hand side the other student took a different Pathway to show their Proficiency in effective communication and being a CTE program passing an uh the English language arts regions and then some sort of Summer internship to get there and that's as much detail as we've gotten from the state in terms of what they might be envisioning uh what this looks

063like there isn't any rubrics yet um there aren't any standards around this yet that's all going to be coming as per the state okay so we're going to be looking out for for all of that um and it's I think it's probably at this point important to note that part of our goal here is to just jog alongside these changes and not to do anything too drastic to change anything too drastic but to ensure that our programs are aligning with the information that we have so that as things evolve and as things change from the state we're at the ready so what is that going to look like so the state has released their phased implementation of the Transformations and if we start from the left-and side in the current school year so we're supposed

064to get a finalized portrait of The Graduate um that's probably most likely going to come more towards the fall in terms of the definitions of the components and then there is this exemption uh in place for diploma assessment requirements for major life effect uh events so that's something that went into play for this current graduating class and as we move through the years we're going to see the details of the new requirements coming in in the next year or so um and then in the 26 27 year that's when we're going to get the rubrics and the guidance on on the on the portrait and then that's when the financial literacy and climate education will be required uh starting in in those years and that's scheduled to uh start in the fall of 2027 so

065we currently let's say at the high school we have a personal finance course that's already running that personal finance course there's probably upwards of 500 students who take that course somewhere in that in that right now in terms of climate education we're not sure exactly what that's going to look like yet yet but we look at our science curriculum we look where things are happening in there we'll look at our Apes course our AP environmental science course where we have uh close to 200 students who take that course and we'll begin to see as we get more information on those standards uh where that that's going to fit in for us uh to make sure our students are meeting those requirements and then it's going to be in the 2728 we'll move to the one

066diploma we'll Sunset that region requirement that we talked about earlier so that no longer becomes a requirement for graduation we'll get some more information about the redefined seals and and endorsements and some more information about rubrics um and and the learning standards and as we move through you can see that we get to a final implementation in the fall of 2029 uh where everything now is in place and that will take place the fall 2029 with the ninth grade class so how does this impact so now we look at all these changes there's a lot here what's happening in the in the years and so when we look at how this impacts current students and F future students so this slide what this will show you on the left hand side is the cohort that's

067going to be impacted by the changes on the right hand side all the way to the right just shows you their graduating year so a cohort is being defined as a grade nine student in that particular year so if we look at the current cohort 2023 in Prior that would have been our ninth grade class last year the 2023 class and everything is is is basically the same for that group as we move through we begin to see how now each of the graduating classes might be affected so if you have a student who is um is going to be a ninth grade student in 20127 for instance so if you look at cohort 2027 that's the class of 2031 the that class will have one diploma we'll know what the redefined seals and endorsements

068are going to to look like the new credit requirements and that's the year that the region mandatory region exams will begin to Sunset so they'll be out so it's in 2027 so we're in 2025 we're two years two and a half years away from that uh happening and then when we get to cohort 2029 we'll be in full implementation and one of the big changes there is the state's going to have a Statewide transcript so there's some standardization of the transcript across um all the districts so that's where where the state is it's a lot so uh I'll I'll stop here and open the floor to questions thank you Mr styberg this is definitely a lot of information to uh to process okay um uh for now um so if there's anything that the Board

069needs um clar clarification um U please ask you a question and this is only for a Q&A we are not going to give any directives or nor are we going to be asking the presenter for um his or her opinion um so with that um are there any questions from the board for Mr steinber U Miss valov I first of all I just want to say thank you because I know how hard you guys work to stay proactive and to be on top of everything and it shows in everything that we have um I know we've talked about the pathways before is there in any of the plan you may not know it yet I I think the pathways and the endorsements and the seals have definite benefits but the pathway but the lack of

070ability for the kids to try different things gives me pause that they you know have to decide one area that they want to specialize in and then they're not allowed to or they don't have time to do other things they kind of get pigeon um makes me nervous so in in any of this um are there Pathways or seals that allow them to kind of explore different things so they could they're young so they could kind of figure out different things that they like and I know some of this is you're bound by the state but I think it's a great question and so I'll take the first part about it about Sor so just clarify so students when they're in a pathway they are not declaring a major they're not declaring a concentration that

071at no point do they have to say I want to do this pathway or even do this seal they don't have to do that so what we have built in um in the system is we have a way um uh to disaggregate the students transcripts to see how their course selection their natural core selection without them even choosing a pathway right to tell us oh this is where a student has an interest right so a student can sit with a guidance counsel at the high school and the guidance counsel has the ability to go into the program disaggregate the transcript and it will show how the student's course selection is already potentially meeting a pathway they might already have it so the conversation at that point which typically is not going to happen in a

072ninth grade year that's a conversation typically might happen in in an 11th grade year and where a counselor might say to to the student at that point hey are you aware that your course selection you're showing that you have an interest or a passion right in one of our available Pathways and so just going to make the student aware at this point you have the option if you want to if you want to pursue that you can go and take an additional course and then take this industry exam and then you'll get this endorsement on your diploma so it's never forced on students are not being forced into a pathway the intention of the pathways and the seals is to provide the students with the choice to give them that choice and to help show

073them that some of their choices that they're making in their coursework they're expressing through those choices where their natural interests and passions May lie right so we don't want to lock them in that's the that's the opposite of what we want to do with any of these programs same thing with the seals um this is the first year that we are are able to offer a graduating class endorsements in our Pathways and we have a 39 students we have 39 students who unknowingly completed the coursework for these for these endorsements so we recently just had the guidance councils reach out to these students inform them of that let them know that they can take now the industry exam so they can get that endorsement this year on their diploma and they didn't even know that

074they were eligible to do that so that's more of the philosophy that we're we're going with the program okay go um sorry um are the pathways all specified by New York state or can we make our own Pathways yes great question so early in the presentation when I talked about local endorsements and there was much earlier here so on this slide here we talked about locally developed endorsements so the answer to your question is yes so the current pathways are New York State CT approved Pathways and we have to follow certain criteria in order to get that approval from the state and it's a lengthy process it takes about a year to get those approvals to implement however we do have the ability to create our own local ones so there is conversation happening to

075creating healthc care Pathways health profession Pathways there's conversation about creating education pathways and how do we do that given our current courses and looking how students are choosing their courses so again not saying to a student oh you going to go into a health profession pathway you have to determine that in ninth grade no it's when you're in 11th grade and we're looking at and disaggregating your transcript and saying oh you've shown a natural interest in the Health Professions just by the courses you've taken so when we're developing these Pathways we want to design it from that uh frame so that we're designing them almost around what they kids are doing and recognizing them for the interests that they're pursuing as opposed to forcing them into you know a school you know you you might

076see some of these programs you know in education where students are being asked to say okay you have to pick one of these you know specialized schools that you want to be in that is not what this program is intended to do y uh Miss Fab Miss Abramson um hi I just wanted to to first thank you this is informative um I think there's a lot of really good stuff also I agree with a lot of things Susan said but I just I just want to first I want to see if there are other districts that have started looking at this in the state and have had any any push back on the movement over here because I I have the same concern about the pathways and I see it today in the honor societies

077and the different things and they do decide very young and I think when we implement this it will become part of the culture again to decide your pathway very very young um and that we do want to Foster trying lots of different things like even if it's not in their natural interest and they didn't know it wasn't was an interest like did they take photography do they take uh robotics did they take something different that they never thought they would like and find a passion I just am very concerns about it becoming a new type of culture Where We Are pathway driven instead of and it feels very declaratory of your major it feels like college it doesn't feel like we're exploring all the things that we're supposed to explore before we decide things um

078so that's my concern and the other concern is like a pendulum swinging it's just I don't want it to swing so far away and you lose some of the kids that are very I think it's so beneficial to create a whole child like this and I think there's lots of good in it I think there's a lot of children that will do extraordinarily well in that setting and there are some that will also flounder in that setting so I think we have to pay attention to that both ways yeah and I think it's a great point and I believe that's the point when we go to redefining credits and the learning experiences the the the the point of the the multiple ways of providing students ways in which they can show their proficiency and show

079their Mastery is so that we reach every student so that students in the current system they have to take these region exams and we know there are some students that that's just not you know it's just not how they're going to you know show us that they're successful and what they know so the more variety we can come up with and the more we can create the more opportunity we give our students to express themselves and so we don't limit them we're actually trying to elevate them and Elevate their voice and meet them where they are um and that's going to be our work that's going to be our work as we work through this and not to shift that pendulum as you say all the way to one side there's still plenty of students

080who in the current system are are successful and and that's why the regions aren't going away there's still there's still going to be an option for students who that might be a great way for them to demonstrate to us their proficiency and Mastery and so continue down that road right um but the opportunity before us is to really meet the needs of every single one of our students and give every one of our students an opportunity to show how you know their proficiency mastering multiple in multiple ways so the pathways is not the end all be all it it's not I know we talk a lot about it um but it is not the Endor it's just one of one of the newer programs that happens to be put in place so we happen to

081be talking about it a lot but there is a lot of flexibility in that program okay we're just taking questions so you know anything that you want to clarify on the presentation for now okay are there any other states that have implemented similar programming that we have seen and how they did it and how it's successful and things like that this is like a Statewide like I just it's so if it's so different from other states how does it compare to them when we implement it so when when the Blue Ribbon commission did their work one of the things they did do was look at other state systems in in coming up with their recommendations so that was a lot of the work of the Blue Ribbon commission they did at the state level was

082to go to States and see what other states are doing and and we're one of I think only two states that currently have a a region style assessment tied to a graduation requirement um for our implementation of this what we're doing is we're working I'm in just to give you a sense I'm in a a collegial circle about this work with my co my counterparts mother nasso County districts we're in conversation about this we're all talking about the programs that we currently have we're trying to learn with each other to make sure that we're all staying sort of close on this and that we can create what we believe is not just in you know the best interest of our kids in our individual dist districts but in our County you know here uh together

083so we're kind of everybody's got eyes on this and the conversations are happening to make sure that um we're going to put best practices to this work um once we get to the point where we get a little more clarity from the state so from a process standpoint right now we're really just starting the conversation about what the state's planning on doing before we turn it internal and really start doing our work towards it so it's really this is what we have now this is where the state is and I said it earlier we're just kind of kind of like jog alongside them until we get a little bit more clarity and then we'll move into more in-depth work uh and how we move to this okay are there are there any more questions Mr

084Roo questions only please thanks Dave very good presentation um so just to clarify my understanding that this is going to give our students more options to follow their passions and go into areas where they where they're interested in and will this also um help them kind of find the right path either college or maybe not college for them yes I think that what the state's intention here is to provide multiple ways for students to demonstrate their proficiencies and their masteries right which will Elevate students voice because not every student as we know is going to be successful on a standardized test and that could be very frustrating for a lot of students and I believe from the state's view becomes a barrier to a lot of students being able to graduate and we don't really

085concern graduation rates here we have very high graduation rates so what we want for our students here is to make sure that they feel good about the decisions they're making they feel confident about the decisions they're making and have the ability to Pivot off those decisions should they decide that's not the direction I want to go right and so how does a student then do that over their course of their time here and then how do we assess that and but the more we can offer them to demonstrate their proficiency Mastery the more students were able to reach and I and I believe that's really what we're going after here and and the students will feel better about themselves they and and they'll become better Learners they understand better how they learn who they are

086as Learners so all of that I think is is really what we're headed towards okay Dr Park so um my question is does that mean that our students do not have to spend 180 hours year in school that's a great question we don't have the answer to what the redefinition of credits is going to be right now the state has not um released any information on that so we we know what the the current system is we know the current system is B based on the carneg units of study uh but the state has not released what the red definition of the credits are going to look like it whether they're going to redefine the actual credit hours or they're going to redefine what makes up the 22 credits right now that are necessary for

087graduation so that's some of the information we're still waiting on just comment question question um so I can see that high achieving students will just run wildly with it um I mean regen students will fulfill communication skills in science skill all within that doing that research I can see our students who who are interested in more of work based or service based St they will actually learn to love school because it will be counted but I do have concern about the students in the middle who are less motivated to actually go out will there be um a way that we do not lose a single student who's not as motivated either to Excel or find their passion yeah I don't think we lose I don't think we lose that as our mission in this I

088think we need to hold on to that we that's how we approach our work every day right to make sure that every single one of our students right is reaching their potential and we do everything in our power to make sure that we're doing that now I think this will add and help us to do that the opportunity is that this will make it you know maybe easier for us to do that or it will help us to make sure that we're accomplishing that goal but we all show up to work every single day with that in mind that every single one of our students is the most important thing and making sure every single one of them is reaching their potential so I do think we hold on to that we hold on to

089that tight as we go through something like this okay so I know the rubrics aren't developed yet Dr rouer so it's early but as you think about this like the back half of a SWAT the opportunity and the threat here this may not be the right venue or it may be too soon or maybe it's a memo but how do you view the opportunities and the threats that are being created by this new development so um I'll merry your question with Miss aon's question so uh her question was about where has the skepticism been around the Region's approach and uh where are the opportunities um so the skepticism has come from like newday editorial board and others who worry that the um loss of the Regents exam as a graduation requirement uh creates a situation

090where it's harder to compare one District to another one student to another and the worry is that uh the rigor of the program will erode over time without this sort of single uniform Statewide assessment that is a graduation requirement and therefore high stakes and therefore everyone will be invested in taking it so I think uh it's incumbent upon the region to try and identify and I kind of and uh hinted at this at the in my introductory comments the uh devil will be in the details of the assessment process to make sure that even as the assessments evolve that they Inspire confidence in their rigor so how to do that is the opportunity uh because it allows more students to demonstrate their knowledge their Mastery without demonstrating it in such a narrow uh type of

091a a demonstration of success so hopefully that means that students will feel confident in in exploring areas of the curriculum they might not have because they were concerned about the assessment that might be at the end and if that assessment is really um uh responsive to the amount of effort uh that they put in then they'll feel like it's a fair assessment at at the end so I think for us the opportunity is um I like uh Mr Steinberg's metaphor of jogging alongside this uh I see us likely um having many of our courses evolve um so that's exciting it provides us with uh an opportunity to look for gaps and overlaps in curriculum and uh think about how those courses might evolve in light of new technologies and in light of these new graduation

092requirements so in some ways it um it's daunting because of the volume but it's also exciting because those iterations of the courses will make them I think even more relevant to students so uh the opportunity uh is there to help our students become prepared for a world that's going to look very different um and the challenge will be that just the scale of the undertaking because there's just so much there's so many courses so much to do and um this idea of how you would assess this work is still very early days and I think um not as concrete as I would like to see it uh yet okay all right um Mr Steinberg I actually have a question um has the state released any information on the uh resources and funding that's going to

093be allocated for the transition so there there was talk about some funding there's um about $13 million that's being allocated statewide right now um it doesn't feel as if that's going to be uh suffice you know for the transition um so there'll definitely need to be some work done around around that but um I would say that because we're so early on in this it's hard it's difficult probably for the state and it's not in defense of the state but just there's just not enough information to say really how much money is this going to take and it's going to take some time speaking with with the local school districts once we start moving through this a little bit to say okay here's what we're going to need um you know in order to make

094these things happen because there could be Staffing imp implementations um you know as Dr alluding to you know we're going to be looking at our coursework and uh you know we talked earlier um in the year about updating our curriculum guides and that was you know primarily driven you know by our 8 go9 transition but it was also partly the beginning of us beginning to to audit our curriculum descriptions and begin to now get a handle on on those things and and and in the near future we'll be doing some scope and sequencing work around our cours work which will give us the vision to to see where maybe the redundancy are and the opportunities then exist within the curriculum so that we can start shifting those assessments so one of the pieces that now

095I'm going to go back to the porch of their graduate for a minute that the state hasn't released on this are any kind of Standards related to to these components we don't have any standards on the components but there will be a requirement that students show Proficiency in the components and not necessarily a grade in the components but a proficiency so as an effective Communicator that's happening across our curriculum we're not going to have a course in effective communication but we'll but we'll start to look at the courses and what are we doing within our courses to help Elevate those skills that help students become better communicators and that is a big left to to do that work and that's going to take us some time to do that but we can't really dig into

096that till we get some more clarity from the state that Clarity then will come with more understanding of what really the funding the state's going to be able to provide for us thank you Mr v um so so I know you had said we don't want too many questions and we wanted to stay focused so I have a ton of questions on the different Pathways and the different um seals and all that stuff are we going to have an opportunity at a future date to discuss more in depth the pathways and the seals and the different opportunities for the kids cuz I don't want to ask things that you that are off the rails for the conversation you want to have now but I definitely want to preserve my right to have an opportunity to

097discuss more in depth Pathways and seals and and different things we want and opportunities for the kids so I just I want to know when the plan is for us to be able to discuss that we can definitely you know for that uh for future consideration at a board meeting and then uh you know with all the presentations that we have uh thus far and then this will provide the board members a chance to uh look into all the diff information that's already in front of us and then we can definitely have that in future as a discussion item if you want okay so yeah so I would definitely okay so if we could put a note to add that to a discussion item on on what we want to see happen and different things

098that we think are important in regards to this that would be great before it gets too far sure too far into the Future Okay are there any more questions okay all right thank you thanks again Mr sniper for your presentation thank you and I would just make the point that I think we're going to end up because of the scale of this undertaking I think we're going to end up having uh lots of conversations about this so um I see us circling back to this as the state releases more information about what the standards are for a critical thinker or a global Citizen and then thinking about where those things already exist in our curriculum and where uh there are opportunities to embed them elsewhere I could see us talking about as the graduation requirements

099themselves start to shift with each of these successive cohorts will return to okay um because the graduation requirements are going to change almost every year until 2029 we may have to have some interim kinds of plans before we get to the final so uh we may say this is going to be our Bridge plan for how we're going to do this in the short term but we're our goal is to bridge to the 2029 plan so just anticipate this being an ongoing conversation just because of its scale okay uh we are going to uh there's no legislative items and then we're going to do our discussion items um so board members have been busy this past month attending several different events and then the first one that that uh we are going to report to

100the community is the nessel nessle suff scuber association advocacy and mental health ource event uh Mr Roto thanks Mr Chang thank you for the opportunity to discuss a topic of utmost importance to our community which is mental health we are fortunate to be able to attend the Nassau suffk School Board Association all-in advocacy and mental health Wellness resource event where we were able to explore various tools and strategies to support our students Mental Health as we navigate the challenges of our that our students face one critical point that the conference was addressing was the increased funding for mental health which which we had discussed before from New York State specifically through fully funding our foundation Aid this funding is essential for us to provide additional services and enhance our current service offerings to our students

101and families of saset the conference also emphasized the importance of forging Partnerships with local communities and service providers such as our current collaboration with northwell health for mental health services by working together we can create a network of support tailored to meet the unique mental health needs of each student at the conference various um vendors and service providers were available including a particular um resource called counselor which was an app the counselor act which acts as a best friend in your pocket providing a licensed counselor support 24 hours a day additionally we were encouraged to reach out to our state legislators to advocate for funding dedicated specifically to Mental Health Services not just for our school but for also our healthc care providers um the current Cent resources that they've been providing are not sufficient

102the highlight of the evening was a keynote speaker um John Paul Gonzalez which was particularly fitting giving that it was just Super Bowl weekend Mr Gonzalez is a remarkable teacher who actually inspired or was part of inspiring the New York Giants to turn their season around and actually win the Super Bowl Mr Gonzalez was a former professional basketball player and made the courageous decision to leave the NBA to become a ninth grade social studies teacher in New Jersey he is a p passionate advocate for personal growth and Community empowerment and he is best known for his all-in philosophy this philosophy emphasizes commitment resilience Collective effort in achieve achieving success he believes that by fully dedicating ourselves to a cause or a goal we can overcome challenges Inspire those around us his approach encourages us to

103embrace our potential and work collaboratively and support one another on our journey one of the most effective ways to support each child Mr Gonzalez said was simply to be present for them we can all make a difference by volunteering mentoring and demonstrating our community to the wellbeing that's often reflected in our teachers coaches youth ministry which are significant impacts their lives reminding us that truly takes a village to raise a child thank you Mr Vero that was very informative okay and the uh next item is the nas bosis budget presentation um Dr Park you went to the U presentations so before talk about the budget I know you guys the day before the first meeting was the last day for the school district in Nas County to report whether they want to op in out

104of regionalization um out of 56 districts six districts have decided to join and participate in regionalization um so the big picture for both's budget is uh the total budget is $524 million and uh administ rate of charges uh is 34.7 million out of that um the projected cost increase the same the reasons are the same as what we are experiencing however um use of the agences retirement contribution Reserve to fund a portion of the employers employer share of both ERS and TRS will offset approximately $5.5 million um so they will um it will be reduced by $5.5 million um and one unique one thing unique was life uh Long Island High School for Art will be included in the three-year average billing cycle model just like Barry Tech and GC Tech and it will simplify

105the billing process for the district and it will reduce um the rate for the school by approximately 10% um they gave $16.5 million refund in 2024 4 to 25 and um they're expecting both's Aid and 2425 to increase from 23 24 by about 99.6% for the nasau county schools and for sasis specifically it's about 7.5% so 4.3 million to 4.7 million um one thing they were very proud to say was uh Rada resident waited uh average daily atten increase is the lowest in 10 years to 0.79% at the billing rate of $26.49 uh one thing that concerned me was that there is a weight list for special ed classes there now and um I hope they resolve the situation and I was wondering whether we have issues using their special ed um Services due to

106their lack La of ability to accommodate everybody who's applying and they have currently 42 active facilities capital projects going on and they have eight new projects for next year that's it okay thank you Dr Park thank you both for attending these events okay uh there's no unfinished business and the board is going to uh entertain uh two uh workout resolutions A1 is the denial of appeal file regarding the imposition of discipline against student known to the board of education and can I have a motion Please Mr GRE second by Miss Levitan are there any questions all in favor opposed any abstentions A2 is the denial of appeal file regarding the imposition of discipline against student known to the bo Board of Education can I have a motion Please Mr Roto second by Dr Park are

107any questions all in favor opposed any extensions okay and we are going to uh move to our uh new business items and that's the uh 12a is the approval of staff changes can I have a motion please M Mr greo secondly by Miss fov are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions 12b is the approval of stiens and hourly rates for 2024 2025 can I have a motion please Dr Mark seconded by Miss kosia are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions 12C is the approval of coaching recommendations can I have a motion please miss leviten seconded by Miss fov are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions 12d is the appointment of individuals to serve as volunteer judges for forensic competitions can I have a motion Please Mr

108Roto second by Miss abson are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions 12E is the approval of settlement agreement can I have a motion Please Mr greckle second by Miss lavitan are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions 13A is the approval of the notice of public hearing budget vote and election of the sayas Central Schools district can I a motion Please Mr Roto seconded by Miss koshia are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions 13B and 13 C can be taken together they are the approval of the com committee on preschool special education and the committee on special education recommendations can I have a motion please miss fov second by m Mr greo are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions 13d is the first reading

109of revised policies 0130 District complaint procedures for Federal programs 1120 School District records 1120 d r 4321 programs for students with disabilities under the idea and New York education law article 89 5150 School admission residency 5150 d r 5150 D e.1 5150 D e.2 8130 school safety plans and teams the second reading of the state policies will be doing the March 10th 2025 for a meeting set policies will be available for inspection on the district website 13 e is the approval of settlement settlement agreement can I have a motion Please Mr greckle second by Miss Levitan are there any questions all in favor opposed any abstentions 14a is the authorization of service contracts can I have a motion Please Mr Roto second by Miss enson are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions

11014b is the author ation for special education and or nursing contracts can I have a motion please miss fov second by Miss Levitan are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions 14 C is the authorization for Health Services can I have a motion Please Mr Rolo seconded by Miss koshia are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions 14d is the authorization for piggybacking Belmore Merck Emerald Island Supply C code Incorporated Incorporated can can I have a motion please um Mr GRE second by Miss Levon are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions 14e is the authorization for picky backing Southampton Union Free School District Library supplies Furnishing and Equipment bid SPS 24-1 first extension can I have a motion Please Mr greo second by Miss Levitan are there any

111questions all in favor oppos any extensions 14f is is the authorization for TI change order g-001 Long Island roofing and Repairs Service Corp can I have a motion Please Mr Roto seconding by Miss abson are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions 14g is the authorization for the change order x-11 inala mechanical Corp can I have a motion Please Mr greel second by Miss Levitan or are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions 14 H is the authorization for tikk change order x-102 inshah mechanical Corp can I have a motion Please Mr Roto seconded by Dr Park are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions 14 I is the rejection of utilization of bid of bid can I have a motion Please Mr greckle seconded by Miss Levitan are

112there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions 14j is the approval of student student Club Charters 2024 2025 can I have a motion Please Mr Roto second by Dr Park are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions 14k is the disposal of broken Sur Surplus and or Absol equipment supplies and box can I have a motion Please Mr Mr greckle seconded by Miss fov uh are there any questions Mr greo thank you Dr Rogers you probably know where I'm going to go with this because I've asked in the past um this list of uh Surplus and obsolete equipment it includes a lot of Chromebooks and Tech and I'm wondering is I know we're very limited for where we can give away our you know we what we're calling obsolete Chromebooks and other

113technology but may be used by others is there anything in the works that we're doing I'm really thinking about the Chromebooks and the other Tech and I know in the past there were ways to use it um or nonprofits that were able to use it uh there are some nonprofits we have uh attempted to auction off some of our uh Surplus equipment so now that you've declared it Surplus it is something that we can try to auction off we've had some success with that um Chromebooks are so inexpensive that uh our out ofd Chromebooks don't present themselves as attractive for those kinds of things there are some Charities that will take these as donations so we've looked into that as well and we've also looked at um recycling uh opportunities because the parts inside have

114minimal but some value as well so uh we do try to get best value for things that you declare obsolete okay all in favor opposed any extensions okay and now we are going to move to audience to the public and uh please just bear with me as I read this the saset board Administration welcomes attend attendance at board meetings the board business meeting will be live streamed and recorded a link to access live stream is available on the district website the board values Community input and provides opportunities to offer that input via email or in person persons who wish to speak during audience to the public must register online to speak in events of the meeting by 5:00 p.m. the day of the board meeting a link to the pre-registration form will be made available

115on the homepage on the district website one week before the meeting persons wishing to address the board in person during the audience to the public must conform to procedures adopted by the board speaker remarks must conform to the following one all speakers and observers are required to conduct themselves in a respectful and civil manner in accordance with rules set by the board speakers must address the board only not members of the audience or audience as a whole speakers must limit their comments to issues concerning the School District Operations School District Affairs or board policy because of the rights protected by state and federal law no speaker may speak about an individual student or staff member nor with a board or Administration entertain questions in public regarding collective bargaining negotiations Personnel matters student matters or legal

116matters no speaker may speak about decisions involving specific Personnel or specific students if a speaker wishes to address the board concerning spefic specific Personnel or specific students the speaker must May write to the board speakers may not use epithets slurs personal personal abuse lwd or absin speech profanity liess speech threats and fighting words or gestures defined as words or gestures which may be uh may may which by their very utterance inflict injury or tend to incite a breach of the piece any person who violates the rules above will immediately forfeit the balance of their time addressing the boore to be recognized to speak person must register with a full full name and address and attest that they will comply with the rules and stated above in addition only residents of the sayas school district are

117permitted to address the board each resident will have four minutes to address the board and could be extended or reduced at the discretion of the chair for good cause the board will not permit polling of the board members by speakers after every resident wishing to speak had had opportunity to do so the board and or Administration May respond to Residents questions or comments no residents will be permitted to address the board more than once per meeting and no one may record Another member of the public in a manner that is disruptive or confrontational okay and I just want to inform the audience that if the these rules are not followed or if the audience hackles any speakers I will first give a warning and if there's a second breach of the rules I will end

118the audience public portion of the meeting okay with that the first speaker will be Tanya get hi good evening word of that um thanks very much for the presentations I'm here tonight to ask a question um about the science curriculum presentation that was held online recently so when my U I should say I had an elder daughter who is a graduate 19 uh 2021 and then I have a son who's a junior and I wondered as I was watching the presentation why honors biology is linked to research one now and research two has to be taken by honors chem students I actually really believe in multiple Pathways for students why I'm at CUNY ever and I think those in the middle can become researchers just as well as those who begin here and I think

119we all need to allow for student growth and student development and my daughter when she was in honors bio did not have to take research one she took it in sophomore year right and she was in social science we really need to be very interdisciplinary and not just focus on the hard Sciences I think we need strong social science researchers and I think we need strong research and many of the humanities as well and when I look across the curriculum where I see research is really only in the science department offered here it's not in human ecology it's not in English except when you're talking about intro to college research and I think getting your feet wet in research at sophomore and junior level can be really good for all students no matter where they

120are coming in I don't think they need to be honor students to be doing that um I had another question which regards to curriculum and this extends past the science curriculum and that is um we have Supa um classes in this district and we have AP but again I feel as if there are other options that the district could look at in terms of dual enrollment besides Supa and that is NASA County Community where we already offer an art class but only art and I wondered why again because we do have such limited options other than the high achieving students in math right now I think the program is very focused on that um why not look at Nasa County Community it is a it can be a Sunni it will translate we have a

121lot of kids who attend Sunni I think and so that is another question I have is why is dual enrollment not also at Nasa County Community which is a close um place and we already have at least one course the art that can be done there so those are my questions for this evening um I did send an email out as a followup to my last question um at the board of Med meeting in January thank you so much for your attention have a great evening okay thank you okay the second speaker is um Ibrahim Kaja uh hello hope everyone's doing well um before I get to my question I just wanted to let you know that I was in forensics back in 2003 with Miss eslinger and we went to debate competitions mostly throughout

122the Northeast and one of the most difficult things we could do was find judges for the debate competitions um um so reimbursing these people for judging is great because you're going to get a lot more judges um just wanted to put that out there um so I'm here tonight to ask a few questions uh before the upcoming budget vote the programs we utilize here in saset are generally beneficial to the students but sometimes the parents and the faculty and even administrators aren't aware of the organizations that were paying to use that program's curriculum or that organization's curriculum um the peer leadership program uh that we use here in soset is offered by the ADL uh the ADL has been very controversial especially over the last 15 months and I can elaborate on it at a

123later time but for now I'd just like to ask a few questions and if you don't have answers that's fine but if you can please let me know um via email or at the next board meeting it's fine um my first question is how much do we pay the ADL annually uh number two besides the peer leadership program that we use do we pay the ADL for anything else uh number three and I'll go a little slowly so you can write this down um when was the last time we considered an organization besides the ADL for its peer leadership program um from what I understand we've been using it for several years now um lastly it seems like the ADL has been paid on an annual basis for several years um have we paid the

124ADL the same amount or has it gradually been more each successive year uh and if you need me to repeat any of those questions uh I'm more than welcome um more than happy to okay thank you you may take a seat okay okay the next speaker is going to be Peter trette I'm Briant to that my apology Briant to that thank you madam president last week I had the pleasure of attending the PTSA guidance leaon presentation on the peer leadership program at soset high school I want to thank the pdsa uh assistant principal rufini and all the counselors teachers and staff who put together this presentation which was fantastic and very informative peer leadership and peer educators are great programs that we should all be proud of and I would like to see them continue

125and Thrive I have a concern however however about two outside groups at saset High School worked with on these programs one of these groups is the Anti-Defamation leak which was mentioned by the previous speaker the district has an annual service contract with the ADL for peer leadership training which I believe is up for Renewal next month as I have previously outlined to the board the ADL is very controversial right now because of its advocacy work for Israel and I urge the board not to renew this contract during the PTSA presentation I asked Mr muffini about this contract with the ADL and he confirmed that the ADL does have a role in the peer leadership program he said that the ADL is just one of the groups which saset High School works with to enhance the

126program he mentioned another group which Z High School works with to enhance the program I don't remember the exact wording he used and the recording is not available yet but I believe the other group he was referring to is the Holocaust Memorial and tolerance Center of Nassau County now I want to make clear that educating our students about the Nazi Holocaust is very important and it is certainly appropriate to include Holocaust Education in the peer leadership program however recently hmtc has veered from its original Mission which was to educate students and the community about the atrocities of the Holocaust and the importance of Tolerance and respect for all peoples that is a laudable mission it is regrettable that contrary to this Mission HMT hmtc has chosen to insert itself into contemporary geopolitical debates currently on

127the hmtc website there was a series of videos which they produced called MythBusters and a link to a website which somebody else produced called combating modern day modern day anti-Semitism through education in these videos and on this website what is promoted is a very one-sided view of the Israeli Palestinian conflict in which no mention is made of Palestinian rights and in which the entire Palestine solidarity movement including the student protests in our universities is demonized and characterized as anti-semitic with these activities hmtc is expressing a highly contentious point of view and whether or not you agree with this point of view it is not Holocaust Education since since the sasd Central School School District receives Federal funding it is required by title six of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 to make sure that the

128benefits of the peer leadership program are available to all student all students regardless of race color or national origin tensions around the Israeli Palestinian conflict are very high right now I know there are many saset students who sympathize with the Palestinians and I'm concerned that some of them some of these students may not be comfortable participating in the peer leadership program knowing that the ADL and hmtc are involved I know that the ADL and hmtc have historically played an important role in developing these programs in soset but given their recent controversial activities I think it is time for us to part ways with these organizations and carry on our own pure leadership and pure Educators programs without them thank you okay thank you this claes closes the audience to the public I will do my

129best to answer these questions off the top of my head um so first of all Miss gets uh the science curriculum and then onto um uh dual enrollment classes so we have been making some changes to the science curriculum you correctly observe that at saset the science curriculum has really grown I'm sorry the research curriculum has grown out of the science department because it's original function was to prepare students for uh competitions like the regeneron now regeneron competition and things like lysf which is engineering and science so um because of its history the way the program has grown up the research one class and the honors biology class are assumed to be taken together and so there are some areas of curriculum in the two classes uh that support one another so the concern is

130that if we decoupled the two classes there would be aspects of the curriculum that students would not have access to so it doesn't necessarily mean that that's a bad idea but it does mean that if we go through that process we will have to recope and resequence the curriculum to make sure that um we don't leave any gaps in that curriculum we have started moving in this Direction with chem honors so it so there's um kind of there was a bir directional bidirectional relationship between C honors and research 2 which was if you wanted to take cam honors you also had to take research 2 and vice versa if you took research too you also had to take himam honors so we've decoupled that in One Direction so uh now we don't make taking honors

131chem contingent on taking research so if you want honors chem but you're not interested in pursuing research that's fine you can still take honors chem and we've identified that no there's no curricular loss there in doing that we haven't decoupled it in the other direction which is what you're suggesting and again that's because um we see that there are topics in the curriculum that we don't want to lose otherwise the second research program research two we are starting to bifurcate into three strands so uh social science a uh physical sciences Strand and um believe a Technology and Engineering strand thank you Science Tech math and Computing so the idea being to support more research in different kinds of research domains by spreading that out so the question becomes can we do that with research one

132as well right now the curriculum of that class is a physical sciences heavy curriculum so it's not that we don't support the idea of students in Humanities or social sciences pursuing research um quite the opposite and we've had actually some very successful uh projects that have been submitted for competitions that are in the social sciences uh but the curriculum of research that research one research 2 class right now are very focused on more physical sciences than social sciences so even though it may seem like an incremental shift shift the two incremental shifts that we've made are partially decoupling chem honors and research to and now creating three different strands in research to that are more focused so if those prove successful and there is an audience for that kind of strand uh I could see

133us pursuing it further the question will be whether there is enough interest uh in research one to start doing that decoupling so all of that takes place against the backdrop of our earlier conversation about the State's graduation requirements changing so um the one process that's underway right now and that Mr Steinberg and Miss woek are both uh leading at their respective levels is to go through all of the curriculum and do scope and sequence work and a curriculum M mapping project so the product of that effort will be um more public facing curriculum documents so like things like syllabi for honors courses so you know what the um workload is going to look like a better sense of our scope and sequence where there are gaps and overlaps because if we're going to have to

134make major shifts in how we teach what we teach um there may be opportunities in our curriculum through overlaps that we can eliminate and if all of these courses are going to iterate we we should have a better inventory of all the curriculum strands and where they lie so and again I don't we have a lot of people working on it but this is still a mammoth project um but the outcome of it will be we'll have um curriculum mapping software that houses the work that's done more public facing curriculum documents and a sense of how a lot of these courses might shift in order to provide students with uh more flexibility and more individualized opportunities so that's on the first one so I would say we're moving in the direction that you suggest perhaps

135not as fast as you'd like uh but against the backdrop of this other much more profound change that we also have to be attentive to with the resources that we have the second question around dual enrollment I would be enthusiastic about uh exploring further Partnerships with Nassau Community College I've found over time as my colleagues have as well that they are a difficult partner to engage with uh part of their challenge has been uh a lot of leadership turnover and uh they still are in the process of identifying a permanent leader for the college so that has made um some of building some of these longrange Partnerships a little bit more challenging and um my colleagues and I have had the opportunity to meet with uh the last several presidents of the college and at

136every one of those meetings uh we we embrace the college and we tell them we would like to do more with them uh but I will just say that uh there are some Sunni rules that affect how a Sunni institution like the Community College interacts with other Sunni institutions that are in the college's catchment area such as Sunni Farmingdale Sunni Old Westbury and those Sunni system rules also uh complicate the effort to do dual enrollment classes so what we found is they're a complicated partner to work with there are other partners that are super easy to work with and so sort of naturally that's where our attention has gone but I would say um I'm enthusiastic about the idea of partnering with nasau Community College again for all the reasons that you state and if

137um they're able to identify uh permanent leadership and that leadership Embraces the idea of working with us I'd be happy to explore it uh on the subject of our peer leader programs and our partners uh so I would Echo what Mr tet said about uh the Holocaust Memorial in toolerance center and ADL having been good partners with us for a number of years now uh I take your points about uh the concerns that you have uh particularly with respect to the very detailed questions uh Mr quaza that you'd asked what I would do is I would uh treat these like a foil request uh because they'll require us to do some research I don't want to speak off the top of my head and then misspeak so uh we'll we'll do that we'll treat it

138as a foil request we will fulfill the foil request and then you'll have the answer to these very detailed uh questions that you have and then Mr tet I I take your point and uh we heard your suggestion so thank you for that okay thank you Dr Rogers okay so the next board meeting will be Monday March 10th and uh meeting ajed thank you

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.